Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2017-08-28, recording 1 (started 16:58) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2017-08-28/ [0:00:08] Good evening, I'd like to call to order the Twin Falls City Council meeting from Monday, [0:00:13] August 28th, and confirm that we do have a quorum of the council here. All seven members [0:00:17] are present this evening. The next item is the Pledge of Allegiance. For those of you wishing [0:00:21] to join us, please rise. [0:00:22] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. [0:00:43] Mr. Rothweiler, do we have any amendments to our agenda this evening? [0:00:47] Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, there are no amendments this evening. [0:00:50] Thank you. [0:00:51] We also have no proclamations. [0:00:53] So next on the agenda is an opportunity for general public input. [0:00:57] There's anyone here from the public who wishes to address the council on an item that is not on the agenda this evening. [0:01:02] And now is your opportunity to come forward. [0:01:08] And I would ask if you would please keep your comments to no more than three minutes. [0:01:15] We do have a fairly hefty agenda this evening and if you would just give us your name and whether you're a resident or property owner in the city of Twin Falls [0:01:21] Hi, my name is Ron James. I'm a resident of Twin Falls. Thank you, and I just wanted to thank [0:01:27] the council for recently passing the neighborly city proposal [0:01:34] I was a decent humane gesture on the part of the council to reaffirm [0:01:40] the city's [0:01:42] commitment to [0:01:44] accepting people of diverse geographical and cultural backgrounds. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. James. [0:01:52] Is there anyone else who wishes to address the council? Please come forward. [0:01:55] My name is Melody Lakener and I'm the resident of the impact zone of the city. And [0:02:10] with the recent events in Charlottesville and related events, it occurred to me that we have not [0:02:18] been thanking you enough for passing the neighborly city resolution and I for [0:02:25] one applaud your courage and your timeliness and I want you to know that I'm [0:02:31] happy to live in an area that where all residents are welcome accepted and given [0:02:36] the opportunity to connect with each other without bias so thank you very much [0:02:41] all of you. I appreciate it. Thank you. Anyone else? Yes? [0:02:50] My name is Jason Pearson. I am in residence. When we could go today almost [0:02:57] the hour my son was struck coming home by a vehicle coming home from [0:03:02] South Hills High School or Junior High School. He was going down South [0:03:07] Harrison and Orchard and he was hit right there. Regardless of whether it was the [0:03:12] individual who hit him if it was his fault or not, that's for the police to [0:03:15] determine. I feel that there was other people involved. There was a 50-mile [0:03:22] power speed zone going through that road. There was no crosswalks and there were [0:03:26] no, there's just two stop signs. No far walk, four-way stops, no crosswalks, no [0:03:31] sidewalks. There are weeds that are well over my son's head who is six foot three. [0:03:36] I don't understand how a school could be opened with a speed limit like that in the area. [0:03:47] A mile down on 3,700, there are reduced speeds, there are crosswalks, there are sidewalks. [0:03:56] Twenty feet from where he was hit, that reduces from 50 to 35, where the direction of the individual [0:04:01] was driving, you crest the hill and it goes to 50, you cannot see past the weeds and my [0:04:07] son was struck. [0:04:08] I feel that if Twin Falls County, the city of Twin Falls, [0:04:12] the district, highway district, and school district [0:04:15] would have not dropped the ball and had that fixed [0:04:18] before the school year started. [0:04:21] This could have all been avoided. [0:04:23] I'd just like to get it out there for no one else [0:04:26] will get hurt and maybe something could be done. [0:04:29] I thank you guys for letting me speak. [0:04:33] Thank you for your comments. [0:04:34] I'd like to note as well. [0:04:35] So this certainly isn't the first that we've heard [0:04:38] this incident and our thoughts are certainly with you and your family and hope he's doing [0:04:43] well. So this is certainly an issue that has been, that we're attentive to and we're looking [0:04:50] at options to address the challenges in that area out there. Yes? [0:05:02] I'm Amy Hansen. I live in part of U of States that this just came from where his son was [0:05:07] hit. I'm afraid. I thought it'd be the next one. So I'm here to say, you know, our community [0:05:13] is it's 10 to 15 years old and there's lots of kids and lots of students so I really appreciate [0:05:20] your expedited interest in the matter that this gentleman just spoke about. Thank you. [0:05:26] Thank you. Is there anyone else who wishes to address the council this evening? Mr. Rothweiler. [0:05:40] Mr. Mayor, members of the council may be for the audience especially for the last two individuals [0:05:46] who had spoke regarding the 50-mile-an-hour speed limit. [0:05:51] We have planned to take that issue to the Traffic Safety [0:05:56] Commission later this month. [0:06:01] It'll be the September meeting. [0:06:02] I'm sorry. [0:06:02] We're at the end of this month. [0:06:03] It'll be at the September meeting. [0:06:04] And that certainly does not take away the pain or the accident [0:06:09] that took place. [0:06:09] And we certainly don't want to minimize that. [0:06:12] but know that, and for the others that we have looked at that, [0:06:17] and I think the council had also made a request [0:06:19] at that evening, and so that process is ongoing. [0:06:22] Unfortunately, it wasn't completed in time [0:06:25] to have possibly avoided this. [0:06:29] Thank you, Travis. [0:06:30] Chris, Dr. Travis, just as a follow up concurrent [0:06:34] with that traffic safety meeting, shouldn't we also [0:06:36] be coordinating, though, with school and highway district [0:06:39] and the county to see if they can start their ball rolling [0:06:42] or if they are so that just get into a non-necessarily long drawn out linear process. [0:06:49] Yeah, Jackie has started that process with our partnering agencies. [0:06:52] Okay, good. Thank you. [0:06:56] All right, so seeing no one else from the public who wishes to address the council, [0:07:01] we'll move on the agenda to the consent calendar. [0:07:05] She was first there. We'll go left to right. [0:07:12] Chris Reed. [0:07:13] Move to approve the consent calendar. [0:07:16] Second. [0:07:17] Motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to approve the consent calendar, sorry, any discussion? [0:07:25] Sharon, roll call, please. [0:07:27] Sean Berriger. [0:07:35] Yes. [0:07:36] Dickey Boyd. [0:07:39] Yes. [0:07:40] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:07:41] Yes. [0:07:42] Greg Lanting. [0:07:43] Yes. [0:07:44] Ruth Pierce. [0:07:45] Yes. [0:07:46] Christopher Reed. [0:07:47] Yes. [0:07:48] Chris Tockington. [0:07:49] Yes. [0:07:50] Motion passes 7-0. [0:07:52] Greg Lanting. [0:07:53] Thank you, Greg Lanting. [0:07:55] Sharon, we did never pop up for me to confirm my vote here. [0:08:00] Everybody else did. [0:08:03] What's that? [0:08:04] Everybody else voted. [0:08:06] He didn't pop up for me. [0:08:09] I'll go out and re-render maybe that'll take care of him. [0:08:14] So again, for those of you following along at home, we're dealing with some new technology trying to get our iPads here to follow along with our votes. [0:08:21] Councilman Lanting is talking about. [0:08:23] So that motion passed seven to zero. [0:08:24] So anyone who was here for a special event application [0:08:27] that was on the agenda this evening, [0:08:28] those were all just approved. [0:08:29] So you are welcome to stick around [0:08:32] for the rest of the festivities, [0:08:33] or you can head out. [0:08:35] Her girl's the audience. [0:08:37] And next on the agenda, under items of consideration, [0:08:42] the first is a presentation of the certificate [0:08:44] of Achievement for Excellence in Financial Reporting, [0:08:47] received by the City of Twin Falls [0:08:48] for the comprehensive audited financial report or CAFR [0:08:52] for the year ended October 30, 2016. [0:08:55] And we have Travis Rothweiler, our city manager. [0:08:58] Mr. Mayor, members of council, it'd be probably [0:08:59] appropriate to have members of the finance team [0:09:01] who are here to come up and to be recognized [0:09:05] for this effort all around the finance team. [0:09:17] So Mr. Mayor, members of council tonight, [0:09:18] staff is going to ask you to adopt an ordinance [0:09:23] that will allow for the fiscal year 18 budget [0:09:28] to then take effect on October 1st. [0:09:32] And we often talk about how the budget is a game plan. [0:09:36] It is a plan that we want to lay forward [0:09:38] and we'll talk and we've shared over the course [0:09:40] of the last eight meetings and 11 times this year [0:09:44] of how it's connected to our strategic plan. [0:09:47] And we take great pride in the things that we've been able [0:09:48] to accomplish as a result of thinking [0:09:50] with documents together. [0:09:52] But every year, when we have the audit presentation, [0:09:55] we often share that that's our report card. [0:09:57] And there's a first step, and that [0:10:00] is to make sure that we receive a clean audit from our auditors. [0:10:04] And once again, they came in and they shared [0:10:07] that our audits had met those standards of accounting. [0:10:11] But then there's another layer. [0:10:12] There's a layer of best practices that [0:10:15] exceeds what is minimally required [0:10:18] through the legal standards. [0:10:19] And our team has taken that step, and they have received an award for the Government Finance [0:10:24] Officers Association for their Comprehensive Audit and Financial Report. [0:10:29] And what's important about this isn't the part about winning awards, but it's really [0:10:35] about following best practices. [0:10:37] And the best practices here talk about how we report the financial information in a manner [0:10:43] that allows our citizens the opportunity to review it, [0:10:47] as opposed to be a series of spreadsheets. [0:10:51] Like Gloria likes to say, our budgets have moved [0:10:53] from a series of Excel spreadsheets to words, [0:10:57] pictures, and numbers. [0:11:00] And so tonight, it is my pleasure to recognize this team [0:11:04] for their hard work for receiving the certificate [0:11:07] of achievement for excellence in financial reporting. [0:11:10] The City of Twin Falls is one of just three local government entities in the state of Idaho [0:11:17] to receive both a GFOA award for its budgeting process and then an award for its CAFRA process. [0:11:25] So congratulations to Lori Brandt. [0:11:27] I think you guys have to come shake our heads too though. [0:11:40] Yes. [0:11:41] That works. [0:11:42] That works. [0:11:43] Congratulations. [0:11:44] Thank you guys. [0:11:45] Where are you going? [0:11:46] I do too. [0:11:47] It's always about winning. [0:11:48] Yes. [0:11:49] It's always about winning. [0:11:51] Ruth Pierce. [0:11:57] Being the being counter I am, I really appreciate working with the finance group department and [0:12:06] how excellent they are. I've talked to other cities that have nightmares, and so I just [0:12:14] every day helps us sleep. Thank you. [0:12:18] What she said, nice work. [0:12:20] Yes. [0:12:21] Thanks. [0:12:22] Next on the agenda is a request to adopt an ordinance for the vacation of a 30 foot by [0:12:27] 104 foot undeveloped right of way located along the 100 block of morning-side drive. [0:12:33] I'm Cara Brex Lydell on behalf of Real LLC. [0:12:36] Renee Caraway Johnson. [0:12:40] Good afternoon. As you said, I'm here today to ask for your adoption of an ordinance for a public hearing process that occurred last month and this month. [0:12:51] It is regarding a undeveloped easement that's been on a commercial property for many years. [0:12:58] On July 11th, the Commission held a public hearing on this request. [0:13:03] There was no one that spoke at the public hearing upon conclusion of that presentation and public hearing and deliberation by the commissioners. [0:13:11] Commissioner Gray did make a motion to recommend approval of the request to vacate this easement as presented. [0:13:17] Commissioner Musher seconded the motion and all members voted in favor of that motion. [0:13:23] On August 7th, the Council held a public hearing on the request. [0:13:27] Presentations were given by the applicants, representatives, [0:13:30] and by staff, the public hearing was opened, [0:13:33] and again no one spoke, and the public hearing was closed. [0:13:37] Upon conclusion of that public hearing and council deliberations, [0:13:41] Council Member Talkington made a motion [0:13:43] to vacate the easement as presented. [0:13:45] Council Member Pierce seconded the motion, [0:13:48] and all members voted in favor. [0:13:50] It was a six to zero. [0:13:52] Somebody was absent. [0:13:56] You don't have to be clapped as one. [0:13:59] Upon conclusion, as directed by the Council, [0:14:01] staff has prepared an ordinance for your consideration. [0:14:04] And I would like to ask that you approve this [0:14:07] by third and final reading tonight. [0:14:10] Thank you, Renee. [0:14:11] Sharon, do you have an ordinance number for us, please? [0:14:14] Ordinance number 2017-22. [0:14:20] Council wishes. [0:14:22] Chris talking to move to place ordinance 2017. There's 28 on the third and [0:14:26] final by title under only under suspension rules. [0:14:30] I'll second that. [0:14:32] Motion to place ordinance 2017 was a 22. [0:14:36] Twenty two to excuse me 2017 dash 22 on third and final reading by title only [0:14:41] under suspension of the rules is there any discussion. Sharon roll call vote [0:14:45] please. [0:14:53] Nicky Boyd. Yes. Suzanne Hawkins. Yes. Greg Lanting. Yes. [0:14:59] Ruth Pierce? Yes. Christopher Reed? Yes. Chris Talkington? Yes. Sean Bericher? Yes. Motion passes 7-0. Sharon, would you read the title, please? [0:15:10] Ordinance number 2017-22. And Ordinance of the Mayor and the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho, vacating the real property described below and providing for the besting of title to the property so vacated. [0:15:32] Susanne Hawkins. I move approval of ordinance 2017-22. Second. [0:15:38] Motion by Susanne Hawkins. Second invite Nikki Boyd to approve ordinance 2017-22. [0:15:45] Is there any discussion? I'll call vote please. [0:15:49] Susanne Hawkins. Yes. Greg Lanting. Yes. Ruth Pears. Yes. Christopher Reed. Yes. [0:16:01] Chris Hockington. Yes. Sean Berriger. Yes. Nikki Boyd. Yes. Motion passes 7-0. [0:16:08] Thank you, Renee. Next is request to approve the purchase of real property located adjacent [0:16:15] to the existing public works facility and we have Rob Boling, water superintendent, so [0:16:23] your title. [0:16:24] Yes, good evening Mayor and Council. Welcome, Rob. Robert Boling, water superintendent. And [0:16:27] I'm filling in for John tonight. Practice the sign up for his son itself. Anyway, this [0:16:37] This evening, I come before you, as you guys know, [0:16:41] we're requesting to purchase 0.3 acres adjacent to our public works building and [0:16:48] lot that we have now for expansion of the public's first apartment water, [0:16:54] wastewater, mainly, and probably some days soon down the road, [0:16:59] small water. [0:17:01] Also, so if there's any questions, purchases for $150,000. [0:17:12] If there's any questions on that, we'll answer those. [0:17:18] Suzanne Hopkins. [0:17:20] Since this is an un-budgeted purchase, [0:17:22] can you explain to us where the funds are coming from? [0:17:24] OK, sure. [0:17:25] So when we started looking at it, we [0:17:28] knew that we had a budgeted for it. [0:17:31] So we were trying to decide where [0:17:33] We were going to come up with the money. [0:17:36] Since we haven't been hiring employees in our department, [0:17:40] we were kind of geared up to have equipment for when [0:17:44] we hired employees. [0:17:46] And we haven't been hiring people, so we had equipment [0:17:49] in the budget that we were going to buy, [0:17:51] because if you don't have equipment, [0:17:53] people run, and they're all just standing around. [0:17:56] So you've got to have that. [0:17:57] So when we decided that we weren't going to hire people [0:18:00] for a few years yet, we decided, let's [0:18:03] money that we have been in budget for equipment and use that towards the land. So water department [0:18:10] had 110,000 and wastewater will have money that they can put towards it also because we'll [0:18:18] both use it and they'll have that money from construction projects that they didn't use. [0:18:25] Great, thank you. Any other questions for Rob? Suzanne, how [0:18:36] I move that we approve the request to purchase the real property located next to the existing [0:18:43] Public Works facility for $150,000 and the parcel is 0.83 acres. [0:18:51] I'll second that. [0:18:52] Motion by Suzanne Hocken, seconded by Ruth Pierce to approve the purchase of the real property [0:18:58] as presented. [0:18:59] Any discussion? [0:19:00] Chris talking. [0:19:01] I'll just like pass on the word that I'm sure we've said this before, Rob, how much sense [0:19:06] It makes me get that synergy of what we're doing with the property, the people and the personnel, [0:19:11] and that is also in a very important part of the town that we can serve things. [0:19:17] We look forward to being able to, now that we all go in quite a bit of that corner there, [0:19:23] to be able to do some landscaping and make it look really nice for the people that are coming into the south. [0:19:29] Good, John. [0:19:30] Thank you, Ryan. [0:19:31] Any other discussion? [0:19:32] Sharon, I'll call the vote, please. [0:19:35] Great landing. [0:19:36] Yes. [0:19:37] Ruth Pierce, Christopher Reed, Chris Hockington, Sean Berricher, Nicky Boyd, Suzanne Hawkins. [0:19:46] Yes. [0:19:47] Motion passes 7-0. [0:19:48] Thank you, Rob. [0:19:49] Thank you very much for your time. [0:19:51] Next is a request to adopt a resolution to amend the city's Improvement Reimbursement Resolution. [0:19:56] We have Troy B. Tech Assistant City Engineer. [0:19:59] Welcome, Troy. [0:20:03] Thank you, Council Member. [0:20:05] My name is Troy B. Tech Assistant City Engineer. [0:20:07] engineer and I'm here tonight to discuss the reimbursement resolution and a change to it. [0:20:15] So many years ago we used to have kind of a late-comers agreement, essentially people [0:20:19] would put in infrastructure and people that later came and tagged on to it would pay those [0:20:25] first developers back, eventually took the form of a reimbursement and the council be [0:20:32] elected or started a resolution and ordinance that allowed a reimbursement [0:20:37] commission to be formed and they are currently in place. It shared with the [0:20:43] impact fees so they have to put their way to hats during that meeting. But they [0:20:47] they look at all reimbursements that come before them. So when we originally [0:20:51] took a look at this application we try to look forward to everything that we [0:20:58] thought was possible but being was the first draft we missed a couple of things [0:21:03] And some of these, this change takes care of those. [0:21:07] For instance, we entirely missed that there's going to be large diameter water lines throughout [0:21:13] the city of Twin Falls. [0:21:15] And our standard is 12-inch materials, but we recently did one was 24-inch South of town. [0:21:20] It's a major pipeline and a huge cost of those developers. [0:21:24] And it serves more than just those neighbors. [0:21:26] It serves the whole area. [0:21:28] resolution will allow them to be paid back for more people than are just adjacent to them. [0:21:35] And it really helps share those costs with the people who are benefit from it. [0:21:40] The other one is the canal company. [0:21:42] We took care of our infrastructure. [0:21:44] We sewer water, roadway stuff like that. [0:21:47] But there are canals throughout the city to involve some of them are large and required [0:21:52] to be piped as part of the subdivision process. [0:21:55] So this brings that into being able to be reimbursed. [0:21:59] So it's extending that. [0:22:01] There's also a timeline change. [0:22:03] So originally, there was a date of 20 years set on this. [0:22:07] It was just arbitrarily and picked at that point. [0:22:09] And they're asking for it to be to change to 25 years [0:22:14] before those sunsets. [0:22:16] So if the development, if the utility is installed [0:22:19] after 25 years, that reimbursement would go away. [0:22:24] those people would not be eligible. [0:22:25] So we brought this before the reimbursement commission. [0:22:28] There was some discussion on it. [0:22:29] They all felt it was worthwhile [0:22:31] and they recommended approval. [0:22:32] So we're bringing it to you tonight [0:22:34] to approve an ordinance change. [0:22:39] Thank you, Troy. [0:22:40] Any questions for Troy? [0:22:41] I'm just talking to on the deferred reimbursement [0:22:45] that you're asking to go out to 25 years. [0:22:47] That's at the original amount. [0:22:50] There's no interest at it. [0:22:52] No one. [0:22:53] That is correct. [0:22:53] So there's the true value of the money actually decreases through time to the developer. You think they'd want to get that ASAP [0:23:00] Yeah, as soon as possible. It is tied from the date that the city accepts it 18 months makes for sense to me in the [0:23:07] 25 years [0:23:08] Yeah [0:23:09] As quick as I can't but not everybody develops [0:23:12] Any other questions? [0:23:16] Sharon, do you have a resolution number? [0:23:19] Resolution number 2017-13 [0:23:23] Greg Lanting [0:23:25] Where I move the we approve resolution resolution 2017-13 [0:23:33] Motion by Greg Lanting seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to adopt resolution 2017-13 [0:23:40] Is there any discussion? [0:23:47] Ruth Pierce yes Christopher Reed. Yes [0:23:50] Chris Hockington. Yes, John Barrieger. Yes, Nikki Boyd. Yes, Suzanne Hawkins. Yes, Greg Lanting [0:23:58] Yes. Motion passes 7-0. Next on the agenda is another opportunity for general public input. [0:24:07] If there's anyone here from the public who wishes to address the Council on that, [0:24:10] I'm not on the agenda this evening as your chance to come forward. [0:24:13] We will still have the public hearing on the budget that will be after 6 p.m. [0:24:20] as that's when that was published to occur as well as the other public hearing on the Valencia Park ZDA master development plan. [0:24:29] Seeing no one, council, any items from members of the council? [0:24:40] Mr. Ralph Eiler. [0:24:42] Mr. Mayor, members of council, just a couple of notices. [0:24:45] Number one, City Hall will be closed in observation [0:24:51] of Labor Day next Monday. [0:24:52] Our normal meeting will be then moved to Tuesday. [0:24:58] We are asking and proposing that we maybe start [0:25:03] a little bit early and give you another tour opportunity [0:25:07] of the work that has been done to run [0:25:10] on the public safety complex as well as the city hall [0:25:12] to run concurrent with the report that you'll receive [0:25:15] later that evening from Star Corporation [0:25:18] and our other construction partners. [0:25:20] And so if that works, we'll notice that [0:25:21] as a special meeting for 3.30. [0:25:24] We're hoping the elevator's gonna be working [0:25:26] and that we'll be able to provide, you know, some, so. [0:25:33] we're working on that. We're waiting for an inspection. So maybe there can be a test case. [0:25:43] But also, and more important, the following week, and I want to put this under calendar now, [0:25:52] which would be on Monday, September 11th, there's going to be a memorial in City Park [0:25:58] will make this announcement also next week. But we want to speak of this individual's radar. [0:26:03] there'll be a memorial for the tragic events of 9-11 that took place in our [0:26:09] country and it's going to be led by our public safety team. There'll be a city [0:26:14] park at nine o'clock in the morning and so we want to make sure that people are [0:26:18] able to start making arrangements for that now. Thank you Travis. Well seeing no [0:26:29] other items again both of the public hearings were noticed to occur at 6 p.m. [0:26:34] So at this time we will take a recess and we will come back [0:26:46] You want to do that you have time to do that or we can do it after [0:26:55] If it's the council's desire to do it now we could do that now [0:26:58] So we do have an executive session item for later, so I would entertain a motion to adjourn [0:27:06] To executive session under Idaho code 74 to a six one B [0:27:11] to consider the evaluation, dismissal or disciplining of or to hear complaints or charges [0:27:16] brought against a public officer, employee, staff member, or individual, agent or public school [0:27:21] student. Greg Lanting. I move to remove the executive session under item code 742061B. [0:27:29] Second. Motion by Greg Lanting. Seconded by Ruth Pierce to adjourn to executive session [0:27:35] as stated as there in a discussion. Sharon will call vote please. [0:27:39] Yes. [0:27:43] Christopher Reed. [0:27:44] Yes. [0:27:45] Chris Talkington. [0:27:46] Yes. [0:27:47] Sean Berger. [0:27:48] Yes. [0:27:49] Nicky Boyd. [0:27:50] Yes. [0:27:51] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:27:52] Yes. [0:27:53] Greg Lanting. [0:27:54] Yes. [0:27:55] Ruth Pierce. [0:27:56] Motion passes seven to zero. [0:27:57] So we will adjourn now. [0:27:59] We will not be making any decisions in the executive session. [0:28:03] We will be reconvening the council meeting following the executive session no earlier [0:28:09] and 6 p.m. for the public hearings that are scheduled. [0:28:13] All right. [0:28:34] Yes. [0:28:35] Get a check. [0:28:36] You need that. [0:28:37] We're going to be on our side. [0:28:38] Yeah. [0:28:39] I'm a budget. [0:28:40] That was handy. [0:28:41] Thank you. [0:28:42] Put mirrors on my ears. [0:28:43] She's having a mention. [0:28:44] Maybe doing that. [0:28:45] So. [0:28:46] Okay. [0:28:47] I can do the three minute. [0:28:48] I can participate. [0:31:46] It's time for your Hyundai pop quiz. [0:31:49] Which one of these SUVs do you suppose has a bigger passenger? [0:31:52] The Red Assurance. [1:07:31] So I would like to reconvene the Twin Falls City Council meeting for Monday, August 28th. [1:07:37] It is about eight minutes after six. [1:07:40] We will now move on with the agenda for the public hearings that we had scheduled to start [1:07:45] no earlier than six p.m. [1:07:47] And the first is a request to amend the Valencia Park ZDA Master Development Plan to remove [1:07:56] The landscape within Valencia Street from property located at 2916 through 2930 East 3600 North [1:08:04] is in care of Rex Harding, Rita Cell Engineering on behalf of Dennis Horani and will start off [1:08:15] with Rex with the presentation on behalf of the applicant. [1:08:18] Welcome. [1:08:29] Thank you, Mayor and Council members. [1:08:32] Just a quick background. [1:08:35] This was, ZDA was approved by you last year, recorded, the ordinance was recorded in December. [1:08:45] During that approval of the ZDA, we had actually submitted the preliminary plaque in June of [1:08:51] last year, and the comment that came back on that, which was the first one mentioned, showed [1:09:00] no islands in the public right away, and this was the engineer comment coming back, they didn't [1:09:04] want the islands there. [1:09:05] At that point, you had already approved the ZDA with the islands in place. [1:09:14] Then we resubmitted the Blumory Platte in April this year and we actually had it without the [1:09:22] islands in it to meet their comment. [1:09:25] Within their comment came back, then that's the second we'll mention. [1:09:30] The islands in Blanche are not shown on the latest submittal ZDA requires the islands, [1:09:34] so they must be shown up on Blumory Platte. [1:09:39] And then there were some other comments. [1:09:40] We addressed those comments and then resubmitted the preliminary plaque, which is that one, man, [1:09:48] yes. [1:09:50] But, and comments on this preliminary plaque, which had the island shown in it, the comments [1:09:57] came back. [1:09:58] Also, the street widths, lipogutter, lipogutter, dimensions cannot include the island widths. [1:10:05] You will need to provide 24 feet of asphalt on each side of the island. [1:10:10] So the preliminary plat has total street width from centerline to the lip of gutter of 26 feet [1:10:21] including the island. [1:10:22] So we would have to greatly expand the road in order to get the islands in, well, 4.5 feet [1:10:28] on each side, which means we would have to change the alignment of the road because we're [1:10:33] up against the boundary over here. [1:10:34] It also may affect the setbacks to the buildings as to where they're at. [1:10:38] set back for these buildings is actually from the center line of the road, 63 feet I believe. [1:10:47] And so we're here today to request removing those islands, leaving the street width as was shown on the ZDA development plan. [1:10:58] That being street width is a collector street, which is shown on, it's required to be a collector street because of the street master plan. [1:11:09] The Blensey Street is a collector. [1:11:11] I went out and took a few photos of the streets joining this or coming into this. [1:11:22] The Blensey Street to the north is considered to be a classified collector existing or a [1:11:35] slant to a short term and this is the Blensey Street to the north, which is actually developed [1:11:39] as a residential street, 36 foot face of curb and face of curb. [1:11:44] So once your southwood avenue to the west is also classified in the master plan as a collector [1:11:52] street. [1:11:53] However it's 36 feet regular residential street. [1:11:56] To the east is a residential street. [1:11:59] You see right here that is the gated entrance into the new south hills middle school. [1:12:05] So it only has one lot and then you hit that gated entrance so it's not going through [1:12:09] anymore. [1:12:11] south across 3600 north we run right into the trailer park so it's not going to [1:12:17] extend any further south either so it's just gonna be that one quarter mile but [1:12:20] the plan at this point is to come back take the islands out build the road to [1:12:25] collector street with this is required and then meet the requirements of the city [1:12:31] now as far as removing the islands and why we are looking at doing that just [1:12:46] of education for doing that. [1:12:49] Originally, we were proposed to have a 26-week foot width [1:12:52] for the center line to the Lippen-Gutter with the island [1:12:57] included in that 26-feet. [1:13:00] Institute of Transportation Engineers [1:13:02] defines islands or center island as raised islands located [1:13:06] along the center line of the street that narrow the travel [1:13:08] lanes at that location. [1:13:10] So that was the original plan. [1:13:13] But then the last comment on the preliminary plan review [1:13:18] was no we still need 24 feet of pavement on the outside of the island which doesn't [1:13:24] narrow the street at all actually makes a nice boulevard out of it kind of looks [1:13:28] like Washington Street North with an island out the middle potential impacts [1:13:34] of islands and this is again came from the Institute of Traffic Engineers [1:13:38] it's on their website may reduce parking and driveway access but it's not really [1:13:42] a factor in this this developed because it was laid out such that it wouldn't and [1:13:46] And there's no parking lot in the collector anyway. [1:13:50] Reduces pedestrian crossing width, but if we have to do 24 feet of pavement on each side, [1:13:56] that makes it even a wider street to cross. [1:14:00] May visually enhance the street, which is what we're after in the first place, but we may [1:14:04] also limit visibility of pedestrian crossings. [1:14:08] Not only that, but we also have a number of driveways going into the parking lot, so [1:14:13] So it also could reduce the visibility of vehicles coming out of those parking lots if they're [1:14:19] crossing over for vehicles coming down the street. [1:14:25] This last one doesn't matter. [1:14:26] It's bicepless. [1:14:27] Don't want to be doing it on an arrow or a road to put some into the path of vehicles. [1:14:30] Unless it is striped with four lanes, it's not a problem and there shouldn't be enough [1:14:35] traffic on that road at this point to require four lanes. [1:14:45] In conclusion, the Twin Falls Master Plan classifies the Wenchy Street as a collector since [1:14:50] near the quarter mile line, it's not exactly on it, but it's close to it, and it's the only one left in there to be developed as a collector. [1:14:57] The ZDA development agreement plans, which is what this is, showed, constructed with the 26 feet from the center line to the lipogutter, including the islands, but that does not meet the collector requirement for the city. [1:15:26] That collector requirement of the city requires the 24-foot of asphalt from the center line [1:15:35] to the Lippogutter or total of 48-foot of asphalt, simplest way to get to that solution is to remove [1:15:43] the islands, leave the street to width that was proposed in the first place, meet the requirements [1:15:50] of the city, project can go forward, it's been kind of languishing as we try to get this [1:15:55] Also, in these reviews, City Engineering Department of course, they said they didn't want islands. [1:16:09] The master plan doesn't allow for islands in the master street plan. [1:16:15] It isn't mentioned anyway. [1:16:17] Also, the street department has found that islands are a problem, especially like last winter, when they're trying to plow around them. [1:16:24] the islands themselves were supposed to be maintained by the homeowners [1:16:31] district or homeowners association, they'll previous when we went before the planet [1:16:39] and zoning there was a fellow that stood up in another subdivision and said but [1:16:44] that's not happening where he's at and there's islands and they're burned up and [1:16:48] dry they've been improved I guess since then but there were there was a problem [1:16:53] Also, either those islands have to be separate parcels to be maintained, or it has to be maintained through an agreement with the city. [1:17:03] I had discussed that with Troy. [1:17:06] There is a six foot landscape buffer between the curb and the sidewalk which has to be maintained by the homeowners association anyway, which is part of the right way. [1:17:14] So I think it kind of goes underneath that purvey. [1:17:17] So it still could be done without it being separate parcels. [1:17:22] Questions? [1:17:25] I do not see any questions for you at this time. [1:17:31] Thank you. [1:17:33] Oh, Chris Togenden. [1:17:35] I'd better ask Anal about either from city staff or the applicant. [1:17:40] What was the original concept in the islands? [1:17:43] The original concept was proposed just looking at the master of old planets, [1:17:50] but they just showed the islands in that plan partially as an overall theme for a boulevard type, [1:17:56] having plants in the middle. [1:17:57] It was the applicant's concept. [1:17:59] Yep, that's this is the original that they provided and then gave to us and was approved originally through the [1:18:11] So from the staff's perspective and [1:18:17] June 16 is when they went to the planning and [1:18:20] Zoning commission they forwarded a positive recommendation to the City Council that went to Council in October [1:18:25] over the orons was recorded in December 2016 and then in July they had their preliminary [1:18:31] presentation of the PUNNING and ZONING Commission requesting what we have in front of us now to [1:18:35] remove those islands. [1:18:37] What we have is the original, show the islands, the original showed collector width, city code [1:18:46] requires the pavement as he's talking about on each side. [1:18:49] The ZDA document, the written document itself did not provide for a narrow word road width. [1:18:55] So when it came time to plat, Troy's looking at you need the width per the collector because [1:19:00] the ZDA didn't allow for the smaller or the narrower roadway, and this development plan [1:19:05] showed the islands. [1:19:06] So we were looking at a plat we couldn't approve because it didn't meet the islands [1:19:10] per the ZDA or the collector width. [1:19:12] So what we have in front of us is to, their request to remove the islands to meet the collector [1:19:16] width. [1:19:17] We're planning a zoning commission deliberated at length on July 25th, they held that public [1:19:24] hearing, much discussion, and then there was a motion to recommend to keep the landscape [1:19:30] islands for traffic calming and then allow for the reduction in the required with the [1:19:35] asphalt roadway and there was a second and then one, two, three, four, four, voted in favor [1:19:42] with one voting against, and then staff's conclusion is if the Council approves the recommendation [1:19:52] as presented if you recommend the zoning commission's recommendation there's just [1:19:59] the one subject to site plan amendments as required by building engineering [1:20:01] fire and zoning officials to ensure compliance with applicable city code [1:20:04] requirements and standards that's all we have. Great Lansing. Well how wide will the [1:20:15] asphalt be on each side if the islands are left for six side islands almost 21 feet [1:20:25] That's what it's shown up there, yes. [1:20:44] That's what was yellow. [1:20:53] Right. [1:21:00] That was basically there from the beginning also. [1:21:08] So and who is maintaining that I believe [1:21:15] Wasn't really on this application. So I was really prepared answer who was maintaining that one. Well where where I'm going with this is [1:21:21] Originally we saw it with the islands [1:21:24] And that added aesthetically to the fact that they are stacked [1:21:29] for plexes with lots of parking. I'm assuming a lot of [1:21:34] potentially families. This is good work for really good workforce housing and it's [1:21:40] walking distance. They're going to be able to walk without going on the main [1:21:44] road. They're going to be able to walk to school and the islands do give a [1:21:50] calming effect to the traffic. How big of a collector is a collector but is it [1:21:59] I'm just trying to figure out if it's more important to have it wide open as a [1:22:02] a collector, or the way it was originally presented had a lot of merit, it gave a lot [1:22:10] of nice things to that area where a lot of the neighbors maybe had some concerns, but [1:22:17] with the little park and the landscape, why can't those islands be, if you got a mow and [1:22:25] water that little park, you can mow and water those islands? [1:22:27] Is that in the form of question? [1:22:33] Yeah. [1:22:34] Well, I was just saying. [1:22:36] Where? [1:22:37] I'm silent. [1:22:38] I'm sorry. [1:22:39] Okay. [1:22:40] No, I read all the planning and zoning stuff and it sounds like now the actual developer [1:22:44] is saying to meet city code requirements they'll take the islands out and now if the islands [1:22:53] have to stay they're out. [1:22:57] Is it? [1:22:58] They'd have to ask them if that was their sentiment on it. [1:23:01] They're not going to develop it if that was or so well. [1:23:04] And we'll have a chance to do that once we get to the public hearing part. [1:23:07] So we're kind of on the part here of asking questions of staff. [1:23:10] Right. [1:23:10] I just wanted to make sure that I was correctly up to speed on what I read [1:23:14] and the staff report and everything. [1:23:16] So OK, thank you. [1:23:17] So Kristoff. [1:23:18] And if we left the islands and the reduced asphalt [1:23:25] of the actual traveling areas from 24 to 19, [1:23:29] would the speed still be maintained? [1:23:33] The speed of a collector, which is? [1:23:34] The collector? [1:23:37] Well, Troy, because I'm not an engineer. [1:23:39] So Troy, would you mind coming up and answering that? [1:23:45] It was my feeling that the islands were originally proposed [1:23:49] in place, more for traffic calming, [1:23:51] as well as the little meandering. [1:23:53] That inherently causes people to slow down. [1:23:55] So, while it may technically be signed as a collector or have the speed available, people will naturally want to slow down. [1:24:05] Yeah, we know that effect that the neuro over the road people tend to slow down and speed up as gets wider. [1:24:12] But I'm talking about a little kids potentially on those islands with a collector speed traffic going. [1:24:18] Somebody that isn't feeling like they want to slow down yet, they're still [1:24:23] legally within the law to go at that higher speed or the approved speed anyway. [1:24:29] Is that approved speed 35? Most collectors are on your R site for 35 if they are. [1:24:36] Greg Lanting? Well, we still ask, we can still ask the [1:24:42] I guess the question that Nicky is wanting to ask and I'm wanting to ask is if we allow [1:25:04] the islands with the 19 feet rather than the 24 feet on each side is that still acceptable [1:25:13] to the developer or does he just plain got to get rid of. [1:25:16] I'll let you ask that directly of him. [1:25:18] Right now he would like to really get. [1:25:21] There's a considerable amount of expense on this project, [1:25:25] both the collector arterial on the south end of it, [1:25:31] and moving power lines and different things that make this a [1:25:34] expensive piece of property. [1:25:37] But with the islands and the full 24 feet, [1:25:42] it's not even possible. [1:25:44] not not money-wise is just because the size of things not possible correct or is [1:25:48] it it can be possible to read information but then it can get me really out of here thank you [1:25:55] all right are there any other questions not we will open it up for public input [1:26:05] I don't know if we have a did we have a sign-up shader all right so if there's [1:26:21] anyone who wishes to speak on this item now's your chance to come forward yep [1:26:27] I'm going to please state your name and whether you're a resident or property owner [1:26:32] in the City of Twin Falls. [1:26:33] Yeah, my name is Eric Smallwood and I do live in Twin Falls and I had thoughts on this development [1:26:39] when it first came out and I didn't speak, but my first thought was when they proposed [1:26:44] this that the city should have mandated that they put if they're going to have an island [1:26:48] in a boulevard setting, you should have boulevard trees to provide the spatial enclosure, plus [1:26:53] it does a lot for traffic calming. [1:26:56] You might call it a collector, but with it being a dead-end down there, it's not really [1:26:59] a collector. [1:27:00] Let's just look at it as what it is. [1:27:02] And even if you were to keep the island in a 19-foot travel lane with no parking, in a [1:27:09] setting with all those apartment complexes, do you realize how fast you're asking? [1:27:13] That's going to have a design speed of however fast people want to race their car down. [1:27:17] If you want to have a calm, quiet neighborhood, require them to have a narrower street with [1:27:23] and plant trees alongside them. [1:27:29] Thank you, Eric. [1:27:30] Is there anyone else who wishes to speak on this item? [1:27:34] Mike Shetler, I do live in twin. [1:27:42] I actually live over on off a part view of which everyone is familiar with part view. [1:27:47] They have these islands down the middle of part view. [1:27:50] I've lived there four years, I hate them. [1:27:54] They look like crud, be a nice word. [1:27:59] They finally are just now turning green. [1:28:01] No one's really maintained them. [1:28:02] The trees are dying. [1:28:04] Let's look at Washington. [1:28:06] last winter we had the worst winter we've ever had. Getting down Washington was a pain. [1:28:10] They can't plow the snow to the middle. They can't remove the snow from the middle. It made [1:28:13] it kind of a pain. The same thing on part view. They were grading the snow. They didn't really [1:28:18] grade it away from the center divider. They kind of graded it to the center divider and [1:28:22] couldn't collect the snow. So to me, it made the lanes and I live there every day and they [1:28:27] made the lanes small, like small, because they couldn't get the snow out of there instead of [1:28:31] it is making a quick pass. The kids that are running from part view that I see come out [1:28:36] of the trees. I mean, and you got trees there, which are cool, but all of a sudden here's [1:28:39] these people popping out. And it happens in Washington because it's happened several times. [1:28:43] So I don't like the center dividers. I don't think it calms people. I think on part view [1:28:49] I'm one of them. I think it makes faster traffic there. But it does. It makes people drive faster. [1:28:57] And it makes me drive faster down that street. So it isn't really calming. And then all these [1:29:01] spots you're gonna have all these people pulling out from these you plant [1:29:04] trees on there you know hard it is to see around a tree to see the traffic [1:29:08] coming from the other direction and then you got to try to quickly get around [1:29:10] that island okay I just I don't know I don't I think in certain places maybe [1:29:15] downtown where it's pretty and and in traffic's going eight miles an hour 10 [1:29:20] miles an hour I think they're amazing I think it looks good for the [1:29:22] development something like this now this is a main street coming down you're [1:29:25] gonna have a stoplight down there eventually and you're gonna have turn [1:29:28] lane traffic and you're gonna want to do another turn lane they're gonna want to [1:29:31] white in the streets like that you just how many times they white in Washington so [1:29:34] I don't know I I don't I don't like them I mean I don't think it's a good deal I [1:29:38] think it's a better deal if they don't have them not to be knowing no the [1:29:42] developer I just was here at the other meeting because I was I was the one to [1:29:46] talk that night so and it was just because my own personal preference of what [1:29:49] they are so I think it's a hindrance for the CD to take care of them later on [1:29:53] and I think it'll be worse for traffic so thank you. Hi my name is Dennis [1:30:05] for any important development team, [1:30:07] our application is to remove the islands, [1:30:10] not to find a solution to keep them. [1:30:13] Originally, we wanted to see them in there [1:30:16] for beauty enhancement. [1:30:18] We put the curve in the road for traffic calming. [1:30:24] In our process of development, [1:30:26] we incurred costs to upsize the water. [1:30:31] So that hit our budget that we couldn't, [1:30:33] or didn't anticipate. [1:30:38] The islands now we understand have to be owned privately. [1:30:43] And Council has advised us do not own private property in the middle of a city street. [1:30:48] You're asking for trouble. [1:30:50] If we plant and maintain landscaping on these islands and a child runs to the island and dashes [1:30:58] to the island and then anticipates crossing when it's clear and then isn't seen or misjudges, [1:31:04] we're going to have a, we potentially can have a problem. Our budget doesn't allow for maintaining [1:31:10] it now. The idea of an island in a road, as it was brought up later, does give you the sense [1:31:20] that, okay, I'm on a much larger street, I get to go faster just like on Washington or [1:31:26] when you enter a freeway, the roads are wider. [1:31:29] It's just subliminally, you know you get to go faster. [1:31:33] And this development is designed for young families. [1:31:36] There's likely to be a lot of kids. [1:31:39] And we're just simply asking you to vote, [1:31:44] to remove the islands for all of the reasons [1:31:47] that I've just cited. [1:31:48] Thank you. [1:31:49] Thank you. [1:31:52] Anyone else who wishes to speak? [1:32:03] I'm Dina Steele, I'm a homeowner and I reside here in Twin Falls. [1:32:07] Looking at these islands and the islands that were recently removed from in front of the [1:32:12] Twin Falls High School, we have a business that does maintenance and so forth. [1:32:20] We have a trailer behind our vehicle. [1:32:22] In order to get around these islands, we have to make wide sweeping turns with that trailer [1:32:27] on there. [1:32:28] These islands are a hindrance to there. [1:32:30] You've got 84 units in there. [1:32:33] going to need maintenance. You're going to need people, contractors in there, and [1:32:37] they're going to need to be able to access that street. So it may feel good to [1:32:44] have that in there, but in all practicality, they aren't very practical. [1:32:49] Thank you. Anyone else? Right, with that we will close the public input portion of [1:33:03] the public hearing and we will turn it back to the applicant if you had any [1:33:09] comments or concluding comments okay all right so turn it over to the council [1:33:16] Chris Stockington I'm not sure if the wording is going to be cracked on this but [1:33:26] I would move to proof of the request of amending the ZDA development plan for the [1:33:35] elimination of the center islands within Valencia Street the final design to [1:33:42] are comply with all city standards and requirements. [1:33:49] Second. [1:33:51] Motion by Chris Tockington, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins, [1:33:55] to make it simplest to approve the request to remove the islands from the ZDA requirement. [1:34:07] Is that correct? [1:34:09] Yes, except there is also a subject to the compliance, but that's correct. [1:34:15] City staff discussion. Greg Lanter. Well this is one of those interesting one. I did my [1:34:27] research beforehand. I came in with one thought process and and I've had a couple [1:34:32] since I got here. So I think I'm probably going to be voting in favor of [1:34:40] the motion. I would like to see some sort of common calming but I don't want [1:34:46] to get into the weeds deep enough to see whether we can go to traffic safety [1:34:50] commission and ask them to make it a 25 mile hour speed limit or something [1:34:54] through their sensor as a school right next door I think that's probably [1:34:58] appropriate and I know Jackie want to do her studies and say well the average [1:35:03] speeds of this so we can still make it 25 it's still supposed to be pulled out but [1:35:09] I think that as I read through all the documents I mean we got one side the city [1:35:14] I guess one comment I would make, and this was mentioned by one of the speakers, I do [1:35:30] think if you put the islands yet don't require the road to be widened, well get it away. [1:35:36] If you have 19 feet of travel lane that's never going to be two lanes, I think you invite [1:35:44] higher speeds than you do actually putting the calming in. [1:35:50] And I think you get the same result if you leave the islands in and add four and a half [1:35:54] feet to each side of the street. [1:35:57] So I think the islands themselves as a calming device in this particular case are calming [1:36:02] anything, either way you do it. [1:36:06] I can see the interest in the aesthetics of it at the beginning, but I can also understand [1:36:13] that it has to pencil and we heard from the development group that that wasn't quite [1:36:18] working out in this case. [1:36:20] So again, I think the trying to use the islands as a traffic calming device doesn't seem to [1:36:25] be functioning in my head unless Suzanne Hawkins. [1:36:31] I apologize if I missed this earlier, but the sidewalks on the street are going to be separated [1:36:37] from the road. [1:36:38] They're not along the road, correct? [1:36:39] Thank you. [1:36:40] Chris Stockington. [1:36:41] I'm voting for the request simply because I see a significant children's safety issue [1:36:50] That's driving my whole consideration for aesthetics and the islands that the developers [1:36:56] have met they're not going to take care of and it's going to be a degraded looking situation [1:37:02] but kids are going to be tarding across those things and even at 25 or 35 miles an hour it [1:37:09] could be one of the worst decisions we ever allowed to have happen in the products of [1:37:14] any of the school and multiple family units. [1:37:20] Any other discussion? [1:37:23] Share your roll call, please. [1:37:25] Chris Stockington. [1:37:26] Yes. [1:37:27] Sean Berriger. [1:37:28] Yes. [1:37:29] Nicky Boyd. [1:37:30] Yes. [1:37:31] Suzanne Hawkins. [1:37:32] Yes. [1:37:33] Greg Landing. [1:37:34] Yes. [1:37:35] Ruth Pierce. [1:37:36] Yes. [1:37:37] Christopher Reed. [1:37:38] Yes. [1:37:39] Motion passes 7-0. [1:37:42] Thank you. [1:37:46] Next on the agenda is a request for the adoption of the fiscal year 2017-2018 budget and [1:37:53] the associated annual appropriation ordinance for the City of Twin Falls, [1:37:57] we have our city manager, Travis Raffler, [1:38:00] they don't even let me control the computer around here anymore. [1:38:26] Good evening mayor and council tonight, it is [1:38:35] my opportunity to share [1:38:38] really the work that we've taken part in over the course of the last [1:38:43] months and with the budget kind of moving forward. [1:38:46] As we have shared in all of our other stories, we'd like to tell the ending of this first because most people want to say how is this going to impact me? [1:38:57] And it is a fair point that each individual is going to be, have a different story in a different outcome. [1:39:05] We can't describe what's going to occur to every 17,000 structures within the city of Twin Falls, but we can't take a look at an average, [1:39:15] We can take a look at that average citizen, and we could say if you fall within these averages, [1:39:21] this is what you are likely to see as a result of this budget. [1:39:26] So we know that based upon all of the information that we have with the tax rate for the upcoming [1:39:33] year should decrease by 50 cents per $1,000 of taxable value. [1:39:39] an average home, which according to the U.S. Census, [1:39:42] inside of Twin Falls has a value of $147,200. [1:39:47] That individual would pay $12.87 less in property taxes [1:39:53] under the FY18 budget than they are under the FY17 budget. [1:39:59] And that is based upon implying the tax rate above, [1:40:02] diminishing the homeowner's exemption [1:40:05] to the median or the average value of that home. [1:40:10] below that you'll also notice if that individual uses the averages of 18,000 gallons of water, [1:40:19] which means that they would send us 8,000 gallons of sewer and has curbside recycling. [1:40:26] You'll see that those increases are also illustrated. [1:40:30] And when you take the reduction in the property tax and you take a look at the recommended increases [1:40:36] on the utility, you'll see that the monthly cost to live inside of the city of Twin Falls [1:40:42] based upon the budget that's before you this evening would cost $1.55 more per month to [1:40:49] the average resident. [1:40:52] So why are we here this evening? [1:40:54] Well we started by having this part of the Idaho Code State, the city manager's role [1:41:00] is to prepare a budget for your review and for your consideration. [1:41:04] And as we have shared, this budget meets all of the laws and the requirements that are [1:41:10] spelled within the Idaho Code. [1:41:12] But we want to take an opportunity to illustrate this because tonight is not the first conversation [1:41:19] that we've had about the budget. [1:41:21] In fact, there have been nine other conversations that we've had in which at every single opportunity [1:41:28] the public has been granted and given the opportunity to talk about the budget. [1:41:32] And here is a chronological order of those events. [1:41:36] And our budgeting process really begins very, very early. [1:41:42] In fact, we've already started talking about how we're going [1:41:45] to make some subtle tweaks to the long-term planning team [1:41:49] and anticipation of them convening their group shortly [1:41:53] before Christmas and then rolling so that we are able [1:41:58] to meet these targeted deadlines. [1:42:01] And every time we move forward, it is a rush because we always have [1:42:06] to be evolving as new information is and becomes available. [1:42:11] Tonight, our purpose is to post a public hearing, [1:42:15] which is required by state code. [1:42:19] And then after that public hearing, we have an ordinance [1:42:21] that has been prepared for your adoption. [1:42:26] Should you want to make changes to the ordinance [1:42:30] that has been prepared, that is certainly appropriate? [1:42:34] What we would ask is that we just stand in the brief recess so that staff could then make [1:42:39] the described changes that may occur this evening as a result of the public hearing process. [1:42:45] And then we would then come back and ask for that adoption of that ordinance later this evening. [1:42:52] As we have shared, our budget is driven by the strategic plan. [1:42:56] The strategic plan that we are operating under was first started in 2012 through a citizen-driven [1:43:03] process. [1:43:04] We are in the final stages of providing for the 2017 update and so next steps will be [1:43:11] after the budget is adopted then we will start having conversations about the strategic [1:43:16] plan and that will be a catalyst for driving the FY19 budget and ultimately the decision-making [1:43:23] processes that's used by the long-term planning committee. [1:43:30] When we take a look at the budget, one of the most important numbers we take a look [1:43:34] That is the total taxable value of the city and this illustrates the taxable value of the city grew by 288 million dollars. [1:43:45] That growth is determined by the county assessor's office. [1:43:49] The city of Twin Falls does not assess the property. [1:43:52] That is a role described in Idaho Code and reserved only for the county assessor. [1:43:57] They also provide to us the new construction number, and you'll notice that new construction [1:44:02] number was about $17.9 million lower this year than the prior year, and through those [1:44:08] conversations we shared that it was really a result of when several residential properties, [1:44:14] according to the Cessar's Office, between 60 or 70 actually received occupancy permit, [1:44:19] and when they received that occupancy permit is when they fall onto that tax rule. [1:44:23] And so anything that did not appear or receive an occupancy [1:44:27] permit on December 31st, will fall into the FY19 new construction rule. [1:44:36] This is an illustration of the net taxable value of the city, [1:44:39] and we refer to it as the net taxable value, [1:44:42] because it removes all of the exemptions that are afforded [1:44:46] in the Idaho Code. [1:44:47] It removes the homeowner's exemptions [1:44:48] with nearly equal $800 million. [1:44:52] It also removes all of the urban renewal properties [1:44:55] that are within the city's boundary, [1:44:57] which also are approximately $800 million. [1:45:06] When you're looking at how do you calculate [1:45:08] the property tax rate, this becomes probably [1:45:11] the absolute most important sheet, [1:45:12] and you take the numbers here, [1:45:15] and you can apply that to your individual assessment [1:45:19] to determine what occurs on your property tax [1:45:24] from this year compared to the prior. [1:45:26] And so you can see that the total taxable value is [1:45:30] in a side-by-side comparison, the one for the adopted budget [1:45:33] and then one for the proposed budget. [1:45:36] The net revenues in both budgets are illustrated [1:45:38] and reflected below, and then we have them broke out [1:45:41] into two funds. [1:45:42] One is the tax-supported funds, [1:45:44] the other are the non-tax-supported funds. [1:45:46] Tax-supported funds are all of those funds [1:45:48] in which, as we described, receive some [1:45:50] of their revenue sources from property taxes. [1:45:54] All of the others are non-tax or enterprise funds [1:45:58] are often thought of as a small business. [1:46:02] They collect a fund or a fee for service [1:46:04] and then that is used to operate that fund. [1:46:07] It's a water fund, sewer fund, presentation fund, [1:46:11] all of those fund act like small independent businesses [1:46:14] within the total sit-ins. [1:46:17] When you take a look at total tax collections, [1:46:18] you can see what we're projecting based upon this budget. [1:46:21] And you can see that if you take the tax collections [1:46:24] and you divide that by the total taxable value, [1:46:28] you come up with the tax rate. [1:46:31] And the tax rate is a simple mathematical formula [1:46:34] in Idaho. [1:46:35] Many other states will assess mills. [1:46:38] But we assess a tax rate that is then [1:46:40] leveraged against a homeowner's exemption [1:46:43] if it's a residential property and the owner actually [1:46:47] occupies that property. [1:46:51] This is an illustration of the budgets [1:46:53] over the period of time. [1:46:59] And then this is the corresponding tax rate [1:47:01] for those individual budgets. [1:47:05] It's also important, and I think that we've tried [1:47:08] to illustrate this, but the increase or the decrease [1:47:11] in the tax rate, again, we need to be looking [1:47:14] and focusing at the tax rate as a multiplier. [1:47:17] It is not the total number of mills that are assessed, [1:47:21] and that is why each individual situation is going [1:47:24] to be different, is because that multiplier will be levied [1:47:27] against each individual parcel inside of the city's corporate boundaries. [1:47:33] What's also important when we look at the tax rate, this is just the city's tax rate. [1:47:37] There are many other taxing entities within Twin Falls County, and the city of Twin Falls [1:47:45] only has control over its tax rate because we only control our spending. [1:47:52] All of the other taxing entities are going through this very same process that we are [1:47:57] right now with the exception of the school district, they operate on a different fiscal [1:48:01] year. [1:48:02] And so when you take a look at all the tax rates, it is a product of all of the local governments, [1:48:08] the College of Southern Idaho included in that group as they move forward. [1:48:13] The homeowners' exemption is one of the factors that causes the determinants' tax rate. [1:48:20] And in 2000, up through 2006, it was an amount that was set by the legislature. [1:48:28] And so it went from 50,000 or 50%, whichever is less, to 75,000. [1:48:35] And then after the 2006 legislative session, it was indexed. [1:48:40] So as property values continued to grow, you saw that homeowner exemption increase until [1:48:46] then you see where we had the reception, and then property values declined. [1:48:52] It was still remained indexed up until this year, and this is the first year after a result [1:48:58] of legislative action that they have removed the indexing, and they have then installed [1:49:02] a flat rate, and that flat rate until it is changed by the legislature is $100,000. [1:49:09] So in the state of Idaho, residential properties that are [1:49:14] owner occupied are decreased by 50% with a maximum exemption [1:49:19] of $100,000, and you take the lesser of those two numbers. [1:49:26] This is an illustration, a side-by-side comparison, [1:49:29] of the tax burden based upon local government in our area. [1:49:35] And you can see that there's a tax rate, the median value, [1:49:38] and then the amount of property taxes that they pay, [1:49:42] and you can see that the City of Twin Falls [1:49:44] of these major cities is in about the middle. [1:49:48] When you take a look, you'll notice that Boise [1:49:51] and Meridian are excluded. [1:49:52] We exclude them intentionally, [1:49:55] because all of these cities up here have something in common [1:49:58] that Boise and Meridian do not, [1:50:00] and that is we operate our street department. [1:50:02] Roads that are in public right-of-ways [1:50:05] that are inside of Ada County [1:50:06] are under the jurisdiction of the Aida County Highway District. [1:50:10] It is a separate taxing entity. [1:50:12] They assess their own tax rate. [1:50:14] And so by including them, it is not necessarily [1:50:17] an apples-to-apples comparison. [1:50:19] And so they are intentionally excluded from our graph. [1:50:26] We're going to quickly kind of go through the major components [1:50:29] of our budget. [1:50:30] One is going to be new personnel. [1:50:33] You can see that we're looking at adding bodies [1:50:37] into our members of our team. [1:50:41] We talked about how they're going to actually be absorbed [1:50:45] as a result of taking a look at how we do business. [1:50:48] So we have some private contracts [1:50:50] with some janitorial firms that we've done some analysis. [1:50:53] We determined that it is more efficient for us [1:50:56] to be able to hire one and a half FTE [1:51:00] for that same contracted price that we have [1:51:03] in our city hall and Hanson buildings right now. [1:51:06] And then as we've shared Jackie Wakefield, [1:51:10] who is part of our legal team, which is done by contract, [1:51:14] is going to retire at the conclusion of the next year. [1:51:18] And so we built in some opportunities [1:51:23] to provide some overlap to bring in a paralegal [1:51:25] and a deputy prosecutor to assist with that. [1:51:29] It also includes making sure that we're competitive. [1:51:33] We've talked about the importance of maintaining [1:51:35] competitive salaries, and it was probably five months ago or six months ago that we were [1:51:42] standing in here, and I was asking you to move and do a mid-year adjustment, because the [1:51:48] rate of compensation for critical positions within our organization was not market competitive, [1:51:53] and we were watching many of our teams choose other opportunities of employment. [1:51:58] What I can tell you now is that most of the organization and parts of the organization [1:52:02] carefully staffed as a result of your efforts, and so thank you. [1:52:06] This continues that. [1:52:07] This continues to ensure that we don't continue to fall into those spirals, and so we're asking [1:52:12] for a three and a half percent performance-based increase to ensure that we continue to keep [1:52:17] those good performers on our team. [1:52:19] We're asking for a five percent table measure to ensure that that front end continues to [1:52:25] move to reflect actual market conditions, and then we're also asking to ensure that the [1:52:31] health insurance piece is funded. [1:52:35] The rate of increase as we've shared is 7.9 percent and we know that by the work that we [1:52:40] work with our broker. [1:52:42] What's also important is sometimes when you look at this and you haven't been part of [1:52:47] the conversations of the 3.5 percent increase plus a 5 percent table move does not result [1:52:54] in an 8.5 percent increase for our employees. [1:52:57] It really depends upon how they fall into that spectrum and that scale. [1:53:01] It's really intended to continue to move the scale forward. [1:53:04] One of the things that we had happened to us as an organization is we failed to move our [1:53:08] table for about nine years, and that really started a series of complications that culminated [1:53:13] into last year me coming forward. [1:53:16] We really wanted to do everything that we can to avoid that, and so by working with members [1:53:21] of our management team, we believe that this helps us continue to ensure that we're competitive [1:53:27] especially after having conversations with what some of our peers are doing. [1:53:32] The operation and maintenance budget is up $315,000, which is about 1.88%, the municipal [1:53:38] cost index, which is the measure that we use. [1:53:42] It's very similar to the consumer price index, but it is a greater reflection of the basket [1:53:47] of goods that we have as a community is at 2.05%, so you can see that there have been some efficiencies [1:53:54] gained by members of our team. [1:53:57] And then capital, you can see that the capital for this year is up $2.6 million in comparison [1:54:05] to the prior year we're asking for a total allocation of capital across all funds of $15.78 million. [1:54:14] But one of the really important things, and we talk about the importance of investing in [1:54:19] our infrastructure, the community has invested $131 million in its infrastructure, in the [1:54:27] inside of the City of Twin Falls since 2012, [1:54:30] and I think that just creates a great foundation [1:54:33] for us to ensure that we have opportunities [1:54:37] to take advantage of economic development opportunities [1:54:40] to support a growing and dynamic community, [1:54:42] which are all articulated within our strategic plan. [1:54:46] The $131 million does not include what our partners [1:54:51] have done at the Twin Falls School District. [1:54:54] And so when you take a look at the opportunities [1:54:57] and how we've grown our community, that's awesome. [1:55:02] Someone really doesn't like the budget [1:55:04] by the budget. [1:55:07] So I want to briefly touch upon the enterprise funds. [1:55:11] Again, that's that section of non-tax-supported funds. [1:55:16] We're going to briefly hit. [1:55:17] So the Water Fund asks for a total allocation of $11,893,000. [1:55:23] Again, those are all of the receipts [1:55:25] that are generated from the Water Fund [1:55:28] and then move to support its operations. [1:55:32] We're asking for a 2.5% rate increase, [1:55:36] which results into about $11.46 per year, [1:55:40] or about $96 per month to the average resident [1:55:44] who uses 18,000 gallons in that same time period. [1:55:50] We're looking at a sewer budget of $10,413,000. [1:55:55] we're asking for a 5% adjustment, partially to assist with our minimum debt reserve and [1:56:03] debt coverages that are described in the bond governance, but also to continue to advance [1:56:07] the capital projects that we've looked at. [1:56:10] We're looking at $1.30 per month for that $8,000 gap customer, and one of the projects [1:56:16] that we're going to be looking at as we had shared with you previously is we believe that [1:56:21] 8,000-gallon cap is low. [1:56:25] In the non-irrigation months, we have about 30 percent, I think, Lori, about 30 percent [1:56:32] of our residents exceed the 8,000-gallon cap. [1:56:36] And so we want to make sure that we're honoring our bond covenants that all users are paying [1:56:42] for what they're sending down the drain, and so that's a project that we want to take a [1:56:46] look at and that we will have before you for the next budget cycle. [1:56:56] And then sanitation. [1:56:57] This is really predominantly the contract that we have with PSI for the solid waste and [1:57:03] curbside recycling. [1:57:04] We're looking at an increase of 36 cents per month or roughly 2.13% in the total rate. [1:57:13] So again, back to the conclusion. [1:57:17] This is the impact of the budget that is before you, that is directly connected to the City [1:57:22] Strategic Plan. [1:57:23] If you have any questions, members of the City's team who help construct this budget over the [1:57:30] course of the last several months are here to answer any questions. [1:57:34] And now it is time for the public hearing that is required by COVID. [1:57:43] Thank you, Travis. [1:57:44] Thank you, Travis. [1:57:46] So we will hold our public hearing now. [1:57:48] So I'll open the public hearing and invite anyone who wishes to speak on the budget. [1:57:53] Now is your opportunity to please come forward. [1:57:55] We have some folks signed up there chief. [1:58:00] Okay. [1:58:02] Thank you sir. [1:58:04] That's no no. [1:58:17] So all of these folks have either already spoken. [1:58:20] I think they've all already spoken. [1:58:24] So if there is anyone here wishing to speak on the budget, now is your chance to come [1:58:26] forward and give your public input. [1:58:29] I would ask that you keep your comments brief. [1:58:37] I don't think we have a ton of folks who are up to speak. [1:58:40] Hi. [1:58:41] I'm Randy Steele. [1:58:42] Thank you. [1:58:43] Member of the community and a fine text. [1:58:49] I wonder if you could go over a foregone balance with us. [1:58:56] Yep. [1:58:57] So on the August 14th meeting, I guess Mr. Merritt asked for the privilege to answer the questions [1:59:04] Okay, so the council had the opportunity to take a look at the foregone balance. [1:59:12] It's roughly $2,186,000. [1:59:16] The budget that is before the council does not include any use of the foregone balance. [1:59:21] The council made the decision when they set the tentative budget, which is the maximum [1:59:26] cap at the 14th meeting and then instructed staff to move forward with the public hearing [1:59:31] that the foregone balance would not be included in this budget. [1:59:36] I wonder if you have an estimated value of the finished homes [1:59:41] that will be finished this year of the occupants people [1:59:44] per minute that will be happening at the end of this year. [1:59:46] If you have any idea what that value will be, [1:59:48] it will be added to next year's budget. [1:59:51] At this point, we don't. [1:59:54] Because what happens is that one of the things [1:59:58] that there is a slight disconnect between all [2:00:01] of our building department reporting that we do and when that house actually moves forward [2:00:06] and collects occupancy. [2:00:08] And so while there might be, as the assessor concluded somewhere between 60 to 70 homes [2:00:15] that were not included under the prior role, we have no way of knowing of what homes will [2:00:20] sell when they'll become occupied to determine what that looks like. [2:00:24] When we track our building permit revenues, our revenues appear to be on target as what [2:00:30] but we had projected and were projecting very slight increases [2:00:34] for this upcoming year. [2:00:36] We had seen significant growth coming out of the recession, [2:00:39] but one of the things that we're seeing [2:00:41] is that the number of new housing starts [2:00:45] are really beginning to more flat line, [2:00:48] and that's really probably not an indication [2:00:51] of the demand that's there, [2:00:53] but more of an indication of the availability [2:00:56] of construction workers to be able to fill that void. [2:00:59] We know that Jared Boardy is in our audience and he might have additional information to [2:01:05] add to what I had shared. [2:01:07] Thank you. [2:01:08] Thank you all. [2:01:10] Good questions. [2:01:11] Jared, did you have anything you wanted to add to that? [2:01:19] Thank you. [2:01:21] Anyone else wishing to speak on the budget this evening? [2:01:26] All right. [2:01:27] Seeing no one, we will close the public input portion of the public hearing and we will back [2:01:33] over to Mr. Rothweller. [2:01:39] So Mr. and members of the council were really here to answer any questions that you might [2:01:46] have prior to asking for your adoption of the ordinance. [2:01:56] The ordinance is obviously just a couple of pages and the entire budget is significant. [2:02:03] All of the budgets are online and we would encourage individuals that even after the [2:02:08] action occurs to continue to take a look at that budget. We look at budgeting as an evolving [2:02:15] process. We certainly don't profess to have all of the answers and as I shared we are starting [2:02:21] the kick up of the FY19 budget and so we would want any thoughts to be included earlier on [2:02:29] the front end as opposed to more towards the middle of the way. [2:02:35] Thank you. [2:02:36] Chris Tockington. [2:02:37] I was concerned about this last time and I just like to have a little touchstone the latest [2:02:44] update on our personnel shortages we've had in the past year. [2:02:48] We've made the mid-year adjustments that's benefacking our public safety more than anything [2:02:55] else but are we still receiving indications that the other cities are not just raising [2:03:01] ahead of what we're raising and we're going to have our personnel sucked out of us again [2:03:05] is that even possible to anticipate, I think we're losing a primary in Northwest [2:03:12] cities or have in the past anyway. Predominantly in law enforcement they were [2:03:17] treasure valley cities is where we saw a lot of the loss and I'm gonna go back at [2:03:23] the chief but I believe that we are at 72 of 76 of 77. We received four cops [2:03:38] grants as part of that and they have yet to really add those four into the database. [2:03:46] So we're one down and there were two complicating faculty. [2:03:51] I remember coming before the council and sharing that it wasn't just the total number [2:03:56] of law enforcement that were down but it was also the ten year of the law enforcement that [2:04:01] even though that we had filled those uniform slots they were still in some level of head [2:04:08] had to go to post or had to go to field training and really members of the PD team have done [2:04:14] a great job in not only recruiting with the help of HR but also then moving them very successfully [2:04:22] through post in the field training program so they can be productive law enforcement team [2:04:27] members. [2:04:28] I don't think the public is even aware though that our staffing levels on a per capita basis [2:04:35] reflect the population that we serve daily with a quarter million or so and [2:04:40] sometimes and so we're actually asking our public safety people to be stressed [2:04:45] extremely thin. We've had some very in-app or ten times. [2:04:50] Any other questions? [2:04:57] How about ordinance is a 2017-23? [2:05:04] Yes. Greg Lanting. [2:05:07] Mayor, I move that we place, we suspend the rills in place [2:05:11] or it's 2017-23, one third and final by title O. [2:05:18] It's talking to you. [2:05:19] Second that, and I also like to make a comment. [2:05:21] This is my 26th year of the budgetary process, [2:05:24] and they don't get any simpler or easier, [2:05:27] but you made a pretty good job though, [2:05:28] with the input of our city staff. [2:05:32] I see five main areas I'm very impressed with this year, [2:05:35] though we are addressing our personnel turnover, [2:05:38] especially in public safety. We're repairing and replacing the roads after an historic winter [2:05:45] and it's going to take several years to get through that. We continue to upgrade our city [2:05:49] infrastructure not only looking for the public serving today but in the years ahead. We're [2:05:57] doing all this by maintaining a moderate tax rate and what I'm equally proud of is anything [2:06:04] I've been aware of is, our city has maximum transparency on the budgetary process. [2:06:11] We are lucky if we get two people in here making comments on the budget. [2:06:16] I look at part of that is they know what they can read or see online that that's the factual [2:06:22] data. [2:06:23] They have confidence for making the right decisions and we don't have our hand in their pocket [2:06:28] look unnecessarily. [2:06:30] This is a good solid budget. [2:06:32] a good job. He said seconding that. [2:06:36] Okay. [2:06:37] We do have a motion by Great Lanting, seconded by Chris Tockenton to approve Ordinance 2017-23 [2:06:44] and suspend the rules by title only. Any other comments? Share and roll call both, please. [2:06:54] Sean Berriger. [2:06:55] Yes. [2:06:56] Nicky Boyd. [2:06:57] Yes. [2:06:58] Suzanne Hocken. [2:06:59] Yes. [2:07:00] Greg Lanting. [2:07:01] Yes. [2:07:02] Yes. [2:07:03] Yes, Chris talking yes, Sharon if you would read that. I'm sorry. No, no, no, sorry. I was [2:07:11] trying to read the title, please ordinance number 2017 dash 23 and ordinance of the city [2:07:22] of Twin Falls, Idaho appropriating 66,191,636 dollars for the 2018 fiscal year to defray [2:07:34] all necessary expenses and liabilities of the City of Twin Falls, providing for the objects [2:07:42] and purposes for which such appropriations are made and the amount appropriated for each [2:07:48] object or purpose. [2:07:51] Leving add warm taxes in the amount of $20,253,889 for the 2018 fiscal year, providing that [2:08:04] a copy of this ordinance shall be filed with the county commissioners of Twin Falls County, [2:08:10] Idaho, and with the Secretary of State of the State of Idaho providing for this ordinance to [2:08:17] take effect upon its passage approval and publication according to law. [2:08:25] The rule requiring that an ordinance be read on three separate occasions having been suspended. [2:08:33] Suzanne Hawkins. [2:08:34] Thank you. [2:08:36] I move approval of Ordinance 2017-23. [2:08:39] Second. [2:08:41] Motion by Suzanne Hawkins, seconded by Nicki Boyd [2:08:43] to approve Ordinance 2017-23. [2:08:46] Suzanne. [2:08:47] Thank you. [2:08:48] Not to drag things out, but like Chris this weekend, [2:08:53] I took the time to reread the budget again one month, [2:08:56] probably not one last time, but before tonight, [2:08:58] a final time. [2:09:00] And I would just want to say congratulations [2:09:03] to everybody on the city team. [2:09:05] You make our jobs easy and you make us look good, [2:09:08] and thank you very much for that. [2:09:11] Great, Lansing. [2:09:13] Well, much the same thing. [2:09:14] I've been through, this will be my, [2:09:18] I was doing the math in my 41st public entity budget situation, [2:09:24] 33 of them being in public schools, [2:09:25] which is decidedly different than the city ones. [2:09:30] For one, you just kind of show up at the end [2:09:32] and they tell you what it's going to be, [2:09:34] you vote they vote on it the school board which we have spent as we have for [2:09:38] last many years spent a lot of time on this and city staff have spent a lot of [2:09:42] time on it before we even see it and it's always interesting to go through the [2:09:49] things that you see that got cut before we even got to us because if you went [2:09:55] with just the request this budget would be by 120 million probably I don't know [2:10:00] So maybe not that large, but I really am proud of the city for what we have done to retain [2:10:07] our personnel. [2:10:09] I first got on here in 2005. [2:10:13] It seemed like every week we were hearing about another officer who had been posted away [2:10:17] by Meridian or Boise or CUNO or somebody in the Treasure Valley or even other areas. [2:10:25] And then you start to think about what you just mentioned. [2:10:28] all the things we have to do to even get an officer on the street and then you spend those [2:10:34] thousands of dollars to get that officer on the street and then somebody hires them away [2:10:38] and gets all that training for free. [2:10:40] And so that's the part that I really enjoy or that we have been able to step up and take [2:10:47] care of that issue and save, ultimately, save quite a bit of tax for our money by the fact [2:10:55] we're not training people nonstop. [2:10:57] And then the fact that we now have officers [2:11:00] can make a timely progression through [2:11:02] and we actually have experienced officers [2:11:05] becoming sergeants instead of somebody just becoming [2:11:07] a sergeant because all the sergeants left. [2:11:11] And so I appreciate the efforts that the staff [2:11:14] has made on the total budget, [2:11:16] but on that effort as well, [2:11:18] and I will definitely be voting in favor of this budget. [2:11:21] Thank you. [2:11:26] Any other comments or questions for Travis? [2:11:30] Let that share and we'll call the vote please. [2:11:39] Nikki Boyd? [2:11:40] Yes. [2:11:41] Suzanne Hawkins? [2:11:42] Yes. [2:11:43] Greg Lanting? [2:11:44] Yes. [2:11:44] Ruth Pierce? [2:11:45] Yes. [2:11:46] Christopher Reed? [2:11:47] Yes. [2:11:48] Chris Talkington? [2:11:49] Yes. [2:11:49] Sean Beriker? [2:11:50] Yes. [2:11:52] Motion passes seven to zero. [2:11:53] Thank you, Mr. Mayor, before, and we certainly [2:11:56] as a staff appreciate the comments, [2:11:58] and I think that you're absolutely right. [2:12:01] Well, Mitch, Brian, and I have the opportunity [2:12:06] of really kind of standing here. [2:12:07] It's the team behind us that really puts in [2:12:10] that thoughtful approach. [2:12:11] And this is the last venture for one of our team members. [2:12:19] I'm not going to say he's retiring, [2:12:20] because he's far too young, and if he is, [2:12:22] I'm incredibly jealous. [2:12:26] But Shane Carpenter, if you could stand up for us real quick. [2:12:28] So really, the man who is coordinating all of these, [2:12:35] working tirelessly on these incredibly elaborate spreadsheets, [2:12:40] ensuring that we are literally balanced to the penny. [2:12:45] Shane is certainly an instrumental valuable bar of the team, [2:12:48] and as he concludes this budget, [2:12:51] and he's going to help us get to that GFOA certification again, [2:12:54] we certainly just want to recognize him, [2:12:56] all the members of the team just very, very quickly. [2:12:59] Can we name the budget after him or something? [2:13:07] No, we're still done. [2:13:10] All right. That's the last item on the agenda. [2:13:15] So with that, we are adjourned. [2:13:17] Now we're in 2008.