Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2017-08-14, recording 1 (started 17:00) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2017-08-14/ [0:03:15] Good evening. I'd like to call to order the meeting of the Twin Paul City Council for Monday, August 14th. [0:03:20] We do have a quorum of the council here. Six of the seven members are present this evening. [0:03:25] Councilwoman Nicky Boyd is excused. Next on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. [0:03:30] For those of you wishing to join us, please rise. [0:03:32] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. [0:03:48] Mr. Rothweiler, do we have any amendments to the agenda this evening? [0:03:55] Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, there are no amendments. [0:03:58] Thank you. We have no proclamations this evening, so next is an opportunity for general public [0:04:03] input. This is a chance for members of the public to address the Council on items that [0:04:07] are not on the agenda this evening. If you would like to address the Council, please come [0:04:12] forward. Seeing no one, we will move to the consent calendar and I would ask that item 6F, [0:04:24] removed from the consent calendar it's a special event application for an event [0:04:28] that chamber is putting on so that I can abstain from voting on that. [0:04:33] Susanne Hawkins. I have a question on the consent calendar as well. So items C and D [0:04:40] are both scheduled at the City Park for the same day and the same time and I'm [0:04:45] just wondering how that's going to work and if when we get these special use [0:04:50] applications, how do we go about conflicts like that? [0:04:56] Sergeant Diamond is with us and Sergeant Diamond oversees, he's part of the team of sergeants [0:05:00] that oversees our special event process and so I'll turn that over to him. [0:05:04] Thank you. [0:05:07] We did notice, we didn't originally realize that these were scheduled on the same day when [0:05:11] we did find that they were, we actually contacted both the organizers and found that the two [0:05:17] events are not going to be in conflict with one another and the organizers have spoken to [0:05:21] each other as well and said that they can facilitate having both at the same time. [0:05:26] So we went ahead and put those on the consent calendar. [0:05:28] Thank you very much. [0:05:31] Chris Reed. [0:05:32] I move that we approve the consent calendar and exclude F right now. [0:05:36] Second. [0:05:39] Motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Ruth Pierce to approve the consent calendar minus item 6F, [0:05:45] Chris talking to. [0:05:46] First a comment and then a question, one of the comments that be noticed in the payables, [0:05:51] paid out a half million dollars to star corporation for a city holiday and I don't [0:05:57] know if that's a pro-rata figure on his completion or if it's a normal step it's [0:06:02] not really important but my real question is under payables for sanitation I [0:06:07] think we had a hundred and fifty thousand pay-off for PSI that seems a [0:06:11] little high as there's some extraordinary payment for that yeah so two questions [0:06:19] there in terms of the star contract that is for the work that was completed in the month [0:06:26] of July and what happens is they submit that accounts payable that rolls through our architectural [0:06:33] team they approve that and then that is reviewed by Mitch Humble once it makes through all that [0:06:39] process and it's submitted to the council for its review and then the PSI contract is the [0:06:44] the standard monthly amount. [0:06:46] The 150. [0:06:47] It is. [0:06:48] I guess gotten too used to the 150. [0:06:50] It was more like 103 or something. [0:06:53] Thank you. [0:06:55] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:06:56] Oh, I'm sorry. [0:06:57] I forgot to knock my light. [0:06:58] That's right. [0:06:59] Any other comments or questions on the consent calendar minus item 6f? [0:07:03] Seeing none, Sharon, I'll call both of these. [0:07:09] Sean Berriger. [0:07:10] Yes. [0:07:11] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:07:12] Yes. [0:07:13] Greg Lanting. [0:07:14] Yes. [0:07:15] Ruth Pierce. [0:07:16] Yes. [0:07:17] Yes, motion passes six to zero [0:07:22] Chris read I [0:07:24] Got too many things in front of my no, you're good. I was just going to move to approve consent calendar [0:07:30] 6f second [0:07:33] Motion by Christopher Reed second advice Suzanne Hawkins to approve item 6f on the consent calendar for the chambers [0:07:40] Minimasters golf tournament [0:07:42] Any discussion? [0:07:44] Sharon Ralco vote, please [0:07:46] Suzanne Hopkins, yes, Greg Lanting, yes, Ruth Pierce, yes, Christopher Reed, yes, Chris [0:07:57] Tockington, yes, motion passes five to zero with one abstention. So if you were [0:08:08] here for any of these special events that were on the agenda tonight, all of [0:08:11] those were just approved. So you are welcome to stick around for the rest of [0:08:14] the meeting or you are welcome to take off. Next, under items of consideration, the [0:08:22] first is an update of the Twin Falls Urban Renewal Agency main avenue [0:08:26] redevelopment project. We have Karen Robinson with CH2M. Welcome. Hi, good evening. Thank you. [0:08:34] Mayor and Council, happy to be here to give an update. I do have a few photographs to flash up on the [0:08:42] screen. So construction continues to go well out there. A lot of progress has been made in this last [0:09:01] month. A couple of photographs, many of you have been down main avenue and have seen some of these [0:09:07] sites, but just wanted to make sure that we were taking a look at all the good [0:09:11] progress that's been made. This is a shot, as you can see, from Shoshone to [0:09:14] Gooding, and just highlighting the sidewalk eating and dining that's happening, [0:09:22] and is now taking place on Main Avenue in this block, so it's open and being used [0:09:27] by the merchants in Public Gooding to Fairfield. This section has also been [0:09:37] opened up back up into public and traffic. [0:09:40] And actually since this photograph from last week, [0:09:42] landscaping has gone in. [0:09:43] So it even looks slightly different today [0:09:45] than it did last week when these photographs were taken. [0:09:47] So this block is looking very, very good as well. [0:09:51] Few finishing touches on both of these blocks [0:09:53] with some furnishings, some bike racks, street lighting, [0:09:59] some things, but progressing very well. [0:10:02] And she's shown it to Hanson very much under construction. [0:10:12] So this block utility work has been going on, [0:10:19] doing some waterproofing on some of the basements there. [0:10:21] That work is progressing nicely and just prepping. [0:10:24] So this will remain under construction [0:10:27] for several more weeks, [0:10:28] but it's moving along according to schedule. [0:10:34] Hanson to Idaho, last week, [0:10:36] that block was closed down, demolition work began, [0:10:40] and fast majority of that demo work has been completed [0:10:43] and moving in the next stage's construction. [0:10:45] So two blocks, substantially complete. [0:10:50] Two blocks, very much under construction. [0:10:58] Here is one other one I'd like to flash up. [0:11:00] And also a little piece of Hanson Street [0:11:02] is under construction to put in utilities. [0:11:04] So you'll see that work underway. [0:11:06] But this was something I saw last week. [0:11:08] I believe it was actually maybe in the newspaper or something. [0:11:10] But anyway, I thought this was awesome [0:11:13] when I was walking down Main Avenue [0:11:14] and saw Design 125 put the same board out there, [0:11:17] thanking the contractors. [0:11:18] So just hopefully a testimony to the good work [0:11:20] the GuHo has been doing out there, [0:11:23] progress through making and just the revitalization [0:11:25] that this project is doing. [0:11:29] They're doing a great job. [0:11:30] Things are progressing really well, [0:11:31] and hopefully everyone has seen the benefits of this. [0:11:35] We have a couple of comments or questions, Ruth Beers. [0:11:38] So my building is just off Fairfield and Maine, [0:11:43] and I noticed when we had our ribbon cutting [0:11:45] around the trees as particle board is second [0:11:48] and it changed out to something else. [0:11:50] That will change. [0:11:51] Yes. [0:11:52] That's some of those final pieces that remain to be done. [0:11:54] Okay. [0:11:55] That'll be some tree grading that's put around. [0:11:56] Okay. [0:11:57] Great. [0:11:58] Great. [0:11:59] Thank you. [0:12:00] Yes. [0:12:01] Chris talking to. [0:12:02] John, just to comment the building which is talking about the good quality of work, I super [0:12:05] want to supervise sidewalk, supervise several times a week, so I keep track of what's going [0:12:09] on. [0:12:10] I know it's at least one of the existing buildings I think she's shown to Hanson is actually [0:12:14] starting to upgrade their exterior for salt on Main Street. [0:12:19] So there's a media pride that's coming through and showing [0:12:22] and that's wonderful. [0:12:25] It's a real synergy. [0:12:27] Yes, it's great to see the transformation. [0:12:29] And there was a ribbon cutting ceremony last week. [0:12:32] And I'm hearing that it was well attended. [0:12:35] Good event. [0:12:36] Those ribbon cutting ceremonies will be continuing on [0:12:38] as each of these blocks are finished. [0:12:40] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:12:42] Thank you. [0:12:43] us some comments on Facebook actually pictures people have been taking of cars [0:12:48] that are parking in the she's shown to good in block but going too far up [0:12:52] because of the festival street are we getting that under control do we have a [0:12:56] way to help that problem we are working on that so that has been [0:13:02] recognized and so a couple things one thing that will be implemented is [0:13:06] additional striping put on the front or the the end of the stall to really [0:13:11] delineate and we have bicycle racks that are going in, some [0:13:14] bollars that are going in to further delineate the end of [0:13:18] parking and transition into the pedestrian area. So a couple [0:13:21] of things, and there's also we're discussing maybe implementing [0:13:24] some curb stops, some wheel stops. So those are some of the [0:13:28] things because the asset has been a bit of an issue. We want to [0:13:31] protect those trees, protect the protected pedestrian area, [0:13:36] things of that. So we'll put an eye on it and continue to use [0:13:38] to improve that. [0:13:40] Thank you. [0:13:44] That's it. [0:13:45] OK. [0:13:45] Up here. [0:13:46] Excellent. [0:13:46] Well, and one quick item just related to CH2M. [0:13:50] It has been in the news and announced, [0:13:52] but just to make sure everyone is where we were being acquired. [0:13:54] So in a few months, we may be our name [0:13:57] will likely be changing from CH2M and being known as Jacob's. [0:14:01] So being viewed as a good thing, and Jacob's does not [0:14:04] have a presence here in Idaho. [0:14:07] We will continue to do the same thing, [0:14:09] to provide the same service, but I just want to make that a little comment as well in case [0:14:12] you see that in the news. [0:14:13] Okay. [0:14:15] If there are no further questions, I will take some. [0:14:17] Any other questions? [0:14:18] Uh-huh. [0:14:19] Perin, thank you. [0:14:20] Yes, Dr. [0:14:40] there, and labor is tight, but Guho is doing a good job working with their subs, coordinating, [0:14:45] and staging the construction accordingly, so they are keeping up, and things seem to be [0:14:51] going pretty well. [0:14:52] I know the electrical sub, their crews are tight as an example, but again, Guho working [0:14:58] with their subcontractors to advance construction in a fashion that allows the subs to be on-site [0:15:06] main avenue when needed and and then they can disperse and then come back so they [0:15:11] they're working really well. Yeah back on track. Thank you very much. Thank you. [0:15:18] Next on the agenda is the citizen survey feedback and this is a presentation by [0:15:25] John Caten our public works director and Wendy Davis our parks and recreation [0:15:29] director. So Mr. Mayor, members of council as both John and Wendy are coming up we [0:15:36] kind of wanted to set what has been going on and we had shared with you [0:15:42] that when we got our citizen survey results, [0:15:45] there were a couple of areas that we really wanted [0:15:47] to understand the why. [0:15:50] And in those two areas, it really fell into streets [0:15:55] and street construction road maintenance as well [0:15:57] as parks, recreation, and public facilities. [0:16:00] And so John and Wendy have spent a considerable time trying [0:16:05] to understand the why those responses were provided. [0:16:09] When you look at the citizen survey, [0:16:11] It provides the response, it provides the answer, [0:16:14] and what this team has been doing is really [0:16:15] trying to understand the background behind that. [0:16:18] And so we wanted to kind of set that table [0:16:20] as they kind of go into the presentation tonight. [0:16:26] Welcome. [0:16:27] Thank you. [0:16:29] So usually what we do is not talk about why we did this, [0:16:32] so that we can get unbiased answers for the game [0:16:36] you're going to play here in a couple of minutes. [0:16:37] But I'm addressing the audience as well, [0:16:40] because we want everybody to participate if you can. [0:16:45] So as you know, the Citizen Survey is conducted every two years [0:16:49] by the City of Twin Falls and the results are taken. [0:16:53] We put a lot of emphasis on the results we get from that survey. [0:16:57] And when things fall below a certain percentage, [0:17:01] then we really want to try to understand why. [0:17:03] And so those kinds of responses also [0:17:07] are built into the strategic plan. [0:17:09] And so before I go any further in our conversation [0:17:11] about what this is all about, we're [0:17:14] going to play a little game. [0:17:17] And anybody in the audience that would like to join us, [0:17:19] please do. [0:17:20] Am I kidding? [0:17:21] That's right. [0:17:35] OK, so you need to go to Kahoot.it. [0:17:40] And then when you get there, it's a website. [0:17:44] Then you'll type in that game pin number of 85557. [0:17:50] I have to select that they mean, really clever. [0:18:18] You can just hit number, Greg. [0:18:21] It doesn't matter. [0:18:42] So while people are still logging in, [0:18:43] this goes fairly quickly. [0:18:45] It'll flash the question on, and then there [0:18:49] are four symbols that you can select. [0:18:51] So the first one will take a look at the symbol, [0:18:53] and then just pay attention as we go through. [0:18:55] And I can read the question as well, too. [0:18:59] And then you just need to select your answer on your device. [0:19:05] Looks like we're about there. [0:19:07] Oh, a few more. [0:19:31] OK, I'm going to go ahead and get it started. [0:19:33] And if you're not quite there yet, you can catch up to us. [0:19:36] Are we grading on a curve? [0:19:38] Yeah. [0:19:39] With age, weight, or suit, by the way. [0:19:43] OK, so please rate the quality of street repair [0:19:46] for the city of Twin Falls. [0:19:48] And the people are having trouble, but red is excellent. [0:19:52] And then you've got good, fair, and poor. [0:19:54] You can't even shut the music off, [0:20:03] so you don't have to listen to me. [0:20:07] OK. [0:20:12] Please rate the quality of street cleaning [0:20:15] for the City of Twin Falls. [0:20:32] Okay, please rate the quality of snow removal [0:20:34] for the City of Twin Falls. [0:20:35] Tough winter. [0:20:36] I know you have to go back to 2016 in your head. [0:20:40] Please rate the overall quality of parks [0:20:55] in the City of Twin Falls. [0:21:12] Okay, please rate the quality of recreation programs [0:21:14] and classes in the City of Twin Falls. [0:21:25] And finally, please rate the quality of recreation centers [0:21:30] centers and facilities in the City of Twin Falls. [0:22:01] So as you can see, those answers don't give us [0:22:04] a lot of information as to what people are thinking. [0:22:07] And so what we tried to do, and what we would do this evening, [0:22:13] except that I think we're going to try to expedite this [0:22:15] a little bit and share with you guys, particularly the results. [0:22:18] So what we're going to do here in a few minutes is pull up [0:22:20] the results from this survey that everybody just joined us in [0:22:24] and look at kind of what we got through the different [0:22:28] groups that we presented to. So we visited three or four civic groups in the community [0:22:34] and had them take the survey. And then afterwards we went through each question and we asked them, [0:22:39] okay, you guys rated this poor, why did you answer it that way? And then that's how we [0:22:47] got some of the feedback for us to try to respond to the information that we had because [0:22:53] just looking at a poor rating for the recreation centers, [0:22:59] you know, we don't know what people were thinking [0:23:01] when they answered that question. [0:23:02] And so assuming it was a statistically significant survey, [0:23:07] these answers would give us a fairly similar response. [0:23:10] So at this point, we'll pull the results [0:23:14] and then John's gonna share with you [0:23:18] the responses from this survey [0:23:19] as they compared to the general responses. [0:23:21] Then we'll talk a little bit about the things that we learned. [0:23:24] And then at the end, if anybody has any questions or comments, we'll do that. [0:23:34] Can you just blow it up with that? [0:23:38] Okay. [0:23:39] Okay. [0:23:48] So how about, I'll do the first three then. [0:23:50] Is that what you said? [0:23:52] So rate the quality of street repair for the City of Twin Falls. [0:23:55] So we visited three different citizens groups and you can see here, this would be the fourth [0:24:02] and one person rated it excellent, 13 good, three fair and two poor. [0:24:11] And so I would say generally, they were, this group was more generous than the other groups. [0:24:23] And I would say the other three groups were more closely aligned with the feedback that [0:24:28] we got in the Citizen Survey. [0:24:30] For example, blue-eight-stroidery, 8% of them said that we had excellent. [0:24:36] 23% were good, 31% fair, and 38% poor. [0:24:42] mostly, I believe they truly thought they were poor. [0:24:47] Same thing with Magic Valley leadership, 38% was fair, [0:24:50] 35% poor, and the hospitality group, [0:24:55] 44% said good, and 56% said fair. [0:25:00] It was an interesting conversation. [0:25:02] A lot of people had a difficult time thinking [0:25:04] about the prior season as opposed to what they're living in [0:25:08] now, so obviously it's kind of the context [0:25:12] the situation. Any question on this one so far? Nope, she is. Okay, so the second question, [0:25:25] the quality is street cleaning. Again, I think this is fairly generous compared to the other [0:25:33] groups. Actually, no, I take that back. This one's probably the most in line. The highest score was [0:25:39] in good for all three groups. 80% of hospitality, 67% magic value leadership, and 44% for blue [0:25:46] So generally speaking, that followed the same trend. [0:25:55] Question number three, the quality of snow removal, especially is difficult to keep in [0:26:02] context. [0:26:03] This group, this group was definitely generous to us. [0:26:09] The Blue H. Rodey rotary 50% thought we did poorly, magic value of leadership was 48% poorly, [0:26:18] the hospitality group had 0% or 40% fair. [0:26:25] Any questions on that? [0:26:32] Sure, but I can talk about that. [0:26:34] That would be absolutely worth it, honestly. [0:26:39] So we had comments from each of the groups [0:26:41] and I'll just share it quickly. [0:26:42] Some, I'm just gonna read through them quickly. [0:26:44] Street repair, is there a preferred method [0:26:46] for reporting potholes and road rate problems? [0:26:49] So it's a question. [0:26:50] We think you shouldn't allow trucks [0:26:52] to travel on certain roads. [0:26:54] Who lakes was mentioned as a poor option? [0:26:57] advertise and increase awareness, make it fun, [0:27:00] the street repair, make it fun. [0:27:02] On even repairs, big bombs at transitions. [0:27:06] What was that, Blue Eggs Rotary? [0:27:09] Magic Valley Leadership Street Repair, [0:27:10] pothole repair seems to be temporary, [0:27:12] and it took a lot of time for something [0:27:13] that they will have to go back and fix. [0:27:15] Side streets are neglected. [0:27:19] Chip ceiling, they're peeling up after one year [0:27:21] in Canyon Trails. [0:27:23] Why does the city do partial street patch repairs? [0:27:26] That was a general feedback we got on street repairs. [0:27:28] And of course we enter into a dialogue and try our best not to defend ourselves. [0:27:32] We are there to collect information. [0:27:35] So on street cleaning, not frequent enough, sidewalks are dirty. [0:27:39] Who has maintenance for the sidewalks? [0:27:41] There was a real lack of understanding on who has lack of sidewalks. [0:27:44] The very next follow up question was, why doesn't the city enforce sidewalk maintenance? [0:27:48] And I said, you mean go into the private property owner and make them fix it? [0:27:52] Yes, why don't you do that? [0:27:58] Street cleaning generally do a great job. [0:28:00] Lots of sand and growles from the snow [0:28:02] wasn't cleaned as quickly as it should have. [0:28:04] Wendell Repair Guy said that he normally doesn't see [0:28:07] a lot of cracked windshields from what rocks, [0:28:08] but he's got a lot this year. [0:28:10] Again, this year is kind of a anomaly. [0:28:13] Street cleaning is improving coming from a motorcycle rider. [0:28:16] Sweeping is regular. [0:28:18] Snow removal. [0:28:19] Said he does a good job of snow removal. [0:28:22] Don't plow to the center. [0:28:23] Don't plow to the sidewalk. [0:28:25] Although airport access is in the county's jurisdiction it would be nice if it were a higher priority and we do try to coordinate that and collaborate on that. [0:28:38] That was a good comment. Didn't get ahead of the snow removal this year. Neighborhood streets were really bad. Lack of adequate snow removal contributed to the street repair issues. [0:28:47] So these questions are the ones that we felt was a greater than 10% a change of greater [0:29:19] than 10 lower than previously. [0:29:22] And so that's why we kind of focused on these six questions. [0:29:26] So on question number four, that's kind of how it came across, and I don't remember what [0:29:35] the Citizen Survey was, is that the 2016 number? [0:29:39] So quality of parks was at 49% good, which I think we're landing, that's your highest number [0:29:51] too. [0:29:52] So when we asked what the, why would you rate them down, what's the concern? [0:30:00] It was a lot of times had a lot of feedback about certain areas that they thought was sketch. [0:30:06] People didn't like Harman Park, people don't like Rock Creek Park. [0:30:10] There was some comments about signage, better signage for social and falls, not in a picnic [0:30:19] tables, general lack of trees, some safety concerns. [0:30:24] I heard safety quite a few times, but really, in general, [0:30:30] talking about the distribution of parks being pretty good, [0:30:34] but that there's some areas that it feels like it's a little, [0:30:39] especially if you think about from falls to poline, [0:30:43] eastland to blue lakes, there's really no park in there. [0:30:46] And that came up a couple of times [0:30:48] that some of the neighborhood park opportunities [0:30:52] have gotten away from us. [0:30:53] So that was kind of the response to that. [0:30:57] The next one is the quality of recreation programs. [0:31:05] So again, that one, the rating was 48% good. [0:31:11] And it looks like I would say that your answers came pretty [0:31:16] close to that. [0:31:17] And so there was some talk about where programs ought to be. [0:31:22] Maybe the flag football should be under the city [0:31:24] instead of the why, and how come there's no aqua zoom classes [0:31:29] at the pool, and some of those kinds of things, [0:31:31] but certainly the fact that a lot of the programs [0:31:35] are really centered on youth and adult sports, [0:31:38] and that the breadth of the offerings [0:31:41] are kind of limited to that, [0:31:43] and that we are not reaching as big a cross-section [0:31:45] of the community as we could or should be. [0:31:48] And so that's kind of what I expected to hear, [0:31:50] and that's where that was kind of coming from. [0:31:53] So then the last one, which was the one I was particularly [0:32:00] interested in, because the rec center question I, what were [0:32:07] people thinking when they're answering that question? [0:32:09] So when you're telling me you're a whole lot less satisfied [0:32:12] with it in 2016 than you were in 2014, what are you unhappy [0:32:17] about? [0:32:18] And the biggest thing that I found is that when people see [0:32:22] that question, they're thinking it's a building. [0:32:24] They're thinking that it's a recreation center [0:32:27] that has four walls and recreation opportunities in it [0:32:32] and we're not happy because we don't have one. [0:32:36] I, you know, the way it's worded, [0:32:38] you could probably think that maybe you're talking [0:32:41] about Sunway since it's a place where people recreate [0:32:43] and it's a center, but really the idea is, [0:32:46] and from all of those groups, it was pretty consistent [0:32:49] that they believe that we were talking about a building [0:32:52] and we don't have one. [0:32:53] So that was kind of the feedback that we got on those three. [0:32:59] Do you have any comments, questions, thoughts on that? [0:33:06] So we have shared the results that we got with Phil Kuchlin, [0:33:10] and as he is going through the strategic plan update, [0:33:14] he's looking at these responses to help see if there's a way [0:33:19] to incorporate some of what we've learned [0:33:22] into the strategic plan. [0:33:24] There's some things that we need to do to help increase our service delivery in these areas [0:33:31] through the strategic plan. [0:33:32] So that's kind of what we expect to do with this information unless there's anything else [0:33:37] that you guys need to share. [0:33:39] Thanks for playing. [0:33:43] Thank you. [0:33:44] Thank you. [0:33:45] Any other questions for Wendy or John? [0:33:48] Chris Stockington. [0:33:50] I remember in surveys past and I'm not sure Travis if you were city manager when this was happening or not, but [0:33:58] It seems like we always take a real dip on quality of snow removal after a bad winter [0:34:03] I think that's a [0:34:05] Give and take on the thing you'd expect and [0:34:08] You know one time there was a citizen that showed up for some feedback and they said, you know [0:34:13] I think the citizens or the snow removal for the city has been really marginal this year [0:34:20] but I also realize if you purchased enough snow removal equipment [0:34:25] for the one bad year out of 10, then I would be back here [0:34:28] griping about the tax money that you spent for a minority issue. [0:34:32] And so I think that that is a good perspective for some [0:34:35] of the people answering some of these questions. [0:34:39] And I give them a lot of credit for knowing the limitations we have. [0:34:44] We can't, if we went without snow for the next five or 10 years, [0:34:49] we probably would still get half the people say we do a poor job. [0:34:53] But I would rather take a slap on the face once every few years [0:35:00] and look at the overall snow removal and even quality of the streets [0:35:04] after a hard winter like this. [0:35:06] Just a little perspective. [0:35:09] Thank you. [0:35:14] Well, next on the agenda, staying on that right training note is the 2017 [0:35:22] In winter road repair $4.4 million update from John Cade and our public works director. [0:35:27] Thank you, Larry, counsel. [0:35:29] So tonight, I'm just here to talk to you about the projects, provide you a budget update, [0:35:34] and also at the end, just talk to you about potential projects that we could be doing. [0:35:40] So first of all, in April I came before you and asked to have access to street fund reserves [0:35:50] to repair the winter road damage as you remember I had a list of projects in about $4.4 million [0:35:55] or are identified in projects with the backlog of far and more. We just identified what we [0:36:01] thought we could afford at the time. Since then, we've contracted, and I got the emphasize [0:36:10] week because it's definitely been a team effort. Engineering has been pulling the bulk of the [0:36:15] here, contracting all the work out, supervising the work with the support of engineering, but [0:36:22] with the support of Public Works. But engineering has been leading the charge here. So there's, [0:36:27] right now there's 2.1 million dollars contracted. And that's from the list of projects. The [0:36:36] projects that we have not contracted yet are part of Eastlands Repair and Front Tier, [0:36:45] which we did identify. [0:36:47] If I add those projects, which we haven't spent yet, [0:36:52] it'll be about $4.3 million that we've allocated as projects. [0:37:01] There's other opportunity, and we can't spend more than the $4.4, [0:37:04] and I understand that. [0:37:05] We also, as you're aware, we've applied for grant funds [0:37:08] from the state, and we've received a tentative notice of award [0:37:13] for a little over $4 million in projects. [0:37:18] I have not received the award package yet, [0:37:20] and I'm working closely every week with the grant writer [0:37:25] to make sure that we get it. [0:37:27] So because of the order and sequence of things, [0:37:33] we can't spend more than the $4.4 unless we have the grant [0:37:36] money in the bank. [0:37:37] So I'm not asking to spend more money than we have, [0:37:40] or than we currently have, and we have what I'd like to do. [0:37:43] is talked about the projects that you did authorize [0:37:45] and the amount that we do have available. [0:37:48] There's two projects, or excuse me, one project, [0:37:50] Frontier, which is a sizable project [0:37:52] that I estimated about a million dollars [0:37:54] that we're not gonna get to this year. [0:37:56] We're gonna defer it and do it next year. [0:37:59] We gotta design it over the winter. [0:38:00] So that frees up about a million dollars this year [0:38:05] to do something. [0:38:06] We've identified about $380,000 more projects [0:38:11] project that we could do this year. [0:38:14] We believe we can still get it on the contract and we can get it done and they are, it's additional [0:38:20] projects above and beyond what I identified in the list. [0:38:24] And they are, I would provide you another list but really the ultimate question, I'll ask [0:38:30] in a minute, the biggest project would be Locust, which is an overlay, Locust from False to Biler, [0:38:37] which is in front of the swimming pool. [0:38:39] It's in rough shape. [0:38:41] The timing of that would be difficult. [0:38:43] We got filer blown up and school will start here soon. [0:38:46] So we got to work on the timing there. [0:38:47] But right now we're thinking about we could get that done this year. [0:38:52] There's a piece of brand new from Cheney pulling the other [0:38:55] sides of the whole edition that we could look at. [0:38:58] And then the streets department has several, eight or nine smaller [0:39:03] millenentally projects that are going to be maintenance problems [0:39:05] throughout the winter if we don't get an opportunity to do that. [0:39:09] So I guess what I'm asking of council is, [0:39:14] as projects and opportunities present themselves, [0:39:17] and we can repair some winter damage, [0:39:20] I'd like the flexibility to be able to jump on it [0:39:22] and do it and take advantage of the time [0:39:26] without having to come back to council [0:39:28] for every single project and add a project to this. [0:39:31] With the understanding that I can't spend more [0:39:33] than 4.4 million, and I obviously wouldn't [0:39:36] and then I'll be getting more than, [0:39:38] or I'm not gonna make any assumptions on the grass. [0:39:42] So I'd like to maybe ask that question now [0:39:44] and then also provide an update [0:39:46] how we're ordering like there. [0:39:50] So the first question is can you put additional projects [0:39:55] in the list to choose from that you can get to [0:39:58] not to exceed 4.4 million dollars? [0:40:00] And it probably is simpler where to put it [0:40:02] as projects have come in a little bit less, [0:40:04] and I can add to the list, I'd like to add to the list. [0:40:07] particularly knowing you that one project that you're not going to get to the [0:40:10] shouldn't over any. [0:40:11] Yeah. [0:40:12] So I think there's general head nodding there. [0:40:15] Do you need an action on that? [0:40:17] Okay. [0:40:18] Thank you. [0:40:19] Appreciate that. [0:40:20] Chris Reed. [0:40:21] So you just mentioned the projected $4 million coming in. [0:40:25] Have they told you about when do you have an estimation when that's going to be coming [0:40:30] in? [0:40:31] I can tell you. [0:40:32] Let's see here. [0:40:34] So it's about all 10 projects that I brought before council. [0:40:38] I submitted the state so that estimate was right around 4.3 [0:40:42] ish. [0:40:42] And what I've been told is that we qualified, meaning we're [0:40:49] eligible for funding. [0:40:51] And right now, they're evaluating not whether or not [0:40:55] we have enough points for money, but what the source of funding [0:40:59] is, FEMA, FHWA is still involved. [0:41:03] And so they're trying to just figure out which bucket we're [0:41:07] going to come out of. [0:41:09] I'll be shocked if we aren't awarded something. [0:41:12] And I have a feeling that we'll probably be awarded the state [0:41:15] and not federal funds. [0:41:17] And I'm saying that because of the conversations I've had [0:41:19] with the state based on the date and time frame of our damage. [0:41:23] Anything prior to February is a state, [0:41:26] would be a state funded project which all kind of ours were. [0:41:30] So, when, I don't know, but I come on about every week and the good news is it's a reimbursable project [0:41:37] so we can move forward and complete the projects and ask for reimbursement after the fact. [0:41:41] Good. And there's no local match on those grants? [0:41:44] Sir, there is. There's a 10% local match. [0:41:46] And does that come from your existing? [0:41:49] We would take it out of the 4.0. [0:41:51] Okay. Okay. As far as the budget update, I think we have, I touched on all that. [0:42:17] like I said, we're on budget and as far as the projects go, I'm sure you've seen all the ADA ramps [0:42:26] and we're beginning to get pavement down. We're going to see project, we're going to see a lot of [0:42:33] paving in the first week of September. Right now we are concerned about the project manager and [0:42:40] and I are both concerned. [0:42:41] Josh Barrett with school starting, [0:42:44] and Filerby and Pretty Taurep, [0:42:46] we're not gonna get done for school, obviously. [0:42:49] But he has been in direct contact with the school [0:42:52] and will be in getting ahold of the buses [0:42:55] and do the best we can to get through it. [0:43:00] And then I was gonna talk about Grand Dollar. [0:43:02] I think I covered that. [0:43:02] So I'm gonna give you another question. [0:43:08] Chris Stockington. [0:43:09] And celerative, that's the projects we have [0:43:11] for the ADA ramp, sidewalk ramps, [0:43:15] and the number of streets we're tearing up. [0:43:18] We're not doing patch back for the feathering of the asphalt. [0:43:23] We do those all at one time for economy to scale. [0:43:27] That's right. [0:43:27] I try to explain that to citizens a gripe about it [0:43:29] and said look, it's just not efficient to stick around [0:43:33] and do that if you can do six or seven at one time. [0:43:36] Yeah, not only is it efficiency, [0:43:38] the sequence of constructing it is better. [0:43:40] For example, if we pave and repair the road and then come back and put in a ramp, we have [0:43:46] to cut a piece of the pavement and then you have an extra joint right where the water sits [0:43:51] almost all the time. [0:43:52] So you're almost, you know, you are accelerating the value there. [0:43:56] So ideally you build the ramp. [0:43:58] I also also mentioned, I saw this just today, a few of those ramps were being removed because [0:44:05] because they didn't meet our spec. [0:44:08] The ADA ramps have a really tight spec [0:44:11] and several of them will be in the loop today. [0:44:14] It won't slow our paving schedule because the curve can stay. [0:44:18] But I saw that and I'm sure folks will be wondering. [0:44:29] Thank you, John. [0:44:29] Thank you. [0:44:30] Good luck with the grant award. [0:44:33] Thank you. [0:44:33] Can you work the engineering department 24-7? [0:44:36] Those are illegal. [0:44:43] Next on the agenda is a consideration [0:44:44] of a request for approval of a reciprocal transfer agreement of AIP funding with Boise [0:44:49] Airport for $428,658.00, authorizing the mayor to sign the reciprocal agreement. [0:44:56] Bill Carberry, airport manager, welcome, Bill. [0:44:59] Thank you, Mr. Mayor, if it's OK, I'd like to talk to these three action items collectively, [0:45:04] and then we could sort of go down the list as far as their actions. [0:45:13] So just for everybody's reference, I'll go ahead and read the next two so people know [0:45:16] what we're talking about. We also have a consideration of a request to pre-approve FAA [0:45:20] grant offer AIP-40, amount to be determined for a new airport fire truck and construction [0:45:25] of a taxi lane, as well as consideration of a request to award a bid to item construction [0:45:31] materials for reconstruction of taxiway A. Construct a new taxi lane adjustment field [0:45:36] in the amount of $3,557,613.50 contingent upon FAA funding. [0:45:44] So to try to untangle this a little bit for you this evening, I'd like to point out the [0:45:50] projects a little bit and then go over a cost-funding model that really sorts the sort out what these [0:45:54] actions are about. [0:45:56] So last week, I visited with Council and we took approximately $3.4 million grant for rehabilitation [0:46:04] of taxiway alpha. [0:46:05] This section will be reconstructed here. [0:46:07] This will be a mill in an overlay here. [0:46:10] So that's the money for that project. [0:46:12] Today we'll talk a little bit about this taxi lane connector that will connect right [0:46:16] through here and connect Alpha taxiway through this just grass area next to the helipad and [0:46:22] it will allow access back to the FedEx and the growing area in the northeast. [0:46:27] So we bid this project at Home Materials which is our last item tonight as a contract award [0:46:33] that we'll talk about for Alpha as well as this taxi lane connector. [0:46:44] This is the other project that we'll be looking to talk about here and execute this year. [0:46:50] And that's a new fire truck. [0:46:51] This is a look for a picture today. [0:46:53] This was a couple of years ago. [0:46:55] This is our 1996 Oshkosh fire truck. [0:46:59] It was visiting an aircraft. [0:47:00] I think this was about a year or two ago that departed the runway for some unknown reason [0:47:05] out into the safety area, but this was resolved, thankfully without incident. [0:47:09] But as you can see, it's a very sophisticated piece. [0:47:12] Many of you have been out to the airport and have seen that 1,500 gallons of water and [0:47:17] creates foam. [0:47:19] So those projects as well as this fire truck we'll be talking about tonight and we're bidding [0:47:24] this fire truck we'll be opening that on Wednesday of this week. [0:47:38] So this is my attempt to sort of try to align the project costs and the funding and what [0:47:43] we're doing here tonight. [0:47:45] So the taxi lane as an add alternate to the taxiway alpha project came in at 428,658. [0:47:51] And this is the federal share costs that are illustrated. [0:47:55] The fire truck, $781,856 for total costs on these projects of about $1,210,514. [0:48:04] On the funding side, we'll talk first off tonight about a FAA fund transfer from Boise. [0:48:09] And one would ask, why are you having Boise transfer as funds this year? [0:48:15] And really, the reason was the contract was mobilized in to do taxiway off, and it made [0:48:20] made sense from an economy of scale and efficiency since they were mobilized in to have them build [0:48:25] that taxi lane at the same time rather than did it and have them come back out on a separate [0:48:29] project. [0:48:30] So what Boise, they had some entitlement funding that they were just rolling over here allowed [0:48:34] to keep those funds for about three or four years. [0:48:38] So getting with the FAA, David Beter and the folks at the airport did sign off at Fund [0:48:43] Transfer for us, it's just simply taking some out of the account with the FAA so it's just [0:48:48] an internal accounting type of activity. [0:48:51] So they were kind enough to do that for us, [0:48:53] and tonight we'll talk about reciprocating next year. [0:48:56] So we're sort of borrowing forward on this funding here. [0:48:59] Our entitlement funding here should match up closely [0:49:02] with what we anticipate the fire truck to come in at. [0:49:06] So we've got pretty even match on our cost and our funding, [0:49:10] and this is the pending grant. [0:49:11] Once we have a cost on the fire truck, [0:49:13] we'll funnel that over to the FAA on Wednesday, [0:49:16] and we'll see a grant coming shortly. [0:49:19] So I'll talk about why I'm asking for a pre-approval [0:49:23] on that as well. [0:49:25] So that's the big mix of things. [0:49:29] Any questions at this point? [0:49:35] Greg Lanting. [0:49:36] Well, I'm interested in the fire trucks, [0:49:38] because I've been out there on a couple of demonstrations [0:49:42] to see that it's a one-man operation that can actually [0:49:45] operate that truck and do the different things. [0:49:48] Is there only one company that makes [0:49:51] those there, will it be a competitive bidding or? [0:49:54] I'm thinking we'll get probably at least two bids. [0:49:57] Oshkosh is one of the leading manufacturer. [0:49:59] Rosenbauer is another one that has shown interest in our bid [0:50:03] proposal. [0:50:06] There's a few companies that do it. [0:50:08] I think there's another, the name escapes me now, [0:50:10] but there is some competition there. [0:50:12] If the bids come in high, is there a chance to piggyback [0:50:16] on somebody else's like we've done in the past with other [0:50:18] equipment out there? [0:50:20] I think the one thing to know about our estimates on the fire truck cost is that is padded with [0:50:24] some contingency and there's some precedent through history of other airports recently [0:50:29] that have bid these trucks. [0:50:31] So I think our estimates are good. [0:50:32] If they do come in high, I think the next action would be to go the FAA and ask for some [0:50:37] flexibility for them to maybe add a little bit to the grant. [0:50:41] They have some 10 or 15% flexibility when it comes to maybe increasing a grant or rebidding [0:50:47] or maybe looking next year for a piggyback or something like that. [0:50:51] I don't know of any others in the state [0:50:53] that have awarded one of these fire trucks [0:50:55] that'll last the year. [0:50:56] It seemed like on our latest big piece of equipment, [0:51:00] well, the piece of equipment for cleaning the runway [0:51:03] and things seemed like we piggybacked on Sun Valley, [0:51:06] as I recall. [0:51:07] Yeah, on the room, the big runway room that we have. [0:51:11] So we haven't done that. [0:51:12] All right. [0:51:12] Thank you. [0:51:13] Thank you. [0:51:14] Chris, talking to you, Bill, can you [0:51:15] point us a little bit with the longevity of a fire truck of this magnificent price and what [0:51:21] are we doing with our existing one that fill up the center of that? [0:51:25] Well our current truck is about 21 years old and the FAA inspectors started to ride me a [0:51:29] little bit when it was 15 years old about replacing it and I said well I think it's got [0:51:33] a lot of light left into it so I've been able to get to about this 2021 year lifespan and [0:51:41] I think that's adequate, the FAA certainly supports the purchase of one of these at this [0:51:46] time. [0:51:47] I think in the future, they're still looking really, some have said 10 to 15 years, so I [0:51:52] hear different things, but 20 years is certainly a good lifespan for one and really probably [0:51:58] the place you need to draw the line, and what we'd like to do with the current truck is [0:52:02] keep it as a good able bodied, ready, reserved, so if things really do get out of hand, we've [0:52:09] that little extra horsepower out there. [0:52:16] And I'd like to thank the fire personnel, obviously. [0:52:19] They've been very close, Fred McDonald, [0:52:21] as well as the battalion chiefs, helping me [0:52:24] spec this with JUB. [0:52:25] So they're on board with our equipment. [0:52:30] Any other questions for Bill? [0:52:33] So Bill, you need three actions, if I read this correctly. [0:52:38] That's correct. [0:52:39] So Council wishes. [0:52:42] Greg Lanting. [0:52:43] Mayor, I move that we approve the request for approval [0:52:47] of the reciprocal transfer agreement from AIP funding [0:52:51] with the Boise airport for 428,658, [0:52:55] not the rise of Mayor to sign the reciprocal agreement [0:52:58] and thank the Mayor Dave Bieder and Boise [0:53:02] for helping us out, you bet. [0:53:04] I'll second that. [0:53:06] We have a motion by Great Landing, [0:53:07] seconded by Ruth Pierce to approve the request [0:53:11] of the reciprocal transfer agreement [0:53:13] AIP funding as presented. [0:53:15] Any discussion? [0:53:18] Chair and roll call vote, please. [0:53:23] Greg Lanting? [0:53:24] Yes. [0:53:26] Ruth Pierce? [0:53:27] Yes. [0:53:28] Christopher Reed? [0:53:29] Yes. [0:53:30] Chris Talkington? [0:53:31] Yes. [0:53:33] Sean Beriger? [0:53:34] Yes. [0:53:35] Suzanne Hawkins? [0:53:36] Yes. [0:53:39] Motion passes 6-0. [0:53:42] Suzanne Hawkins? [0:53:44] I move that we approve the request for the pre-approved FAA [0:53:49] grant offer on AIP-40 with the amount to be determined for a new airport fire truck and [0:53:56] construction of a taxi lane and authorize the mayor to sign the pending grant. [0:54:01] Second. [0:54:02] Motion by Suzanne Hock and seconded by Christopher Reed and to pre-approve the FAA grant offer [0:54:12] for a new airport fire truck and construction of a taxi lane. [0:54:15] Is there any discussion? [0:54:18] So Bill, just a question on that, if the bids do come in higher than what the funds are there, [0:54:25] is that something that you'll bring back to the Council or identify a solution for it? [0:54:30] We'll have to find a different solution. [0:54:34] Thank you. [0:54:36] Seeing no further questions, Sharon, we'll call the vote. [0:54:38] Rick Pierce? [0:54:39] Yes. [0:54:40] Christopher Reed? [0:54:41] Yes. [0:54:42] Chris Tockington? [0:54:43] Yes. [0:54:44] Sean Bericher? [0:54:45] Yes. [0:54:46] Suzanne Hawkins? [0:54:47] Yes. [0:54:48] Greg Lanthie? [0:54:50] Move through motion passes six to zero. [0:54:53] Good. [0:54:54] The last motion passes six to zero. [0:54:55] Chris Stockington. [0:54:57] Move to approve the request to ID construction bed [0:55:02] and materials for reconstruction at taxi YA, [0:55:05] and to construct a new taxi lane at Johnson Field [0:55:08] in the amount of exactly $3,557,613.50, [0:55:15] contingent upon FAA funding. [0:55:18] Secretary? [0:55:20] motion by Chris Tockington, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to award the bid to Idaho [0:55:24] construction and materials as presented. Any discussion? Sharon, I'll [0:55:32] vote please. Christopher Reed. Yes. Chris Tockington. Yes. Sean Barrieger. Yes. Suzanne [0:55:40] Hawkins. Yes. Greg Lanting. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 60-0. Thank you. Thank you Bill. [0:55:47] Yeah, good job, Bill. Good luck with your bid opening. Next on the agenda is a presentation of the city managers recommended budget for fiscal year 2018 Travis Rothweiler. You have like Kathy Dure magic again. That worked so well last week. [0:56:08] So I spoke too soon in terms of Kathy and her magic. [0:57:21] So tonight we're here to talk about the budget and the process, but actually [0:57:31] tonight one of the things that you have to do is you at the end of this meeting [0:57:35] actually need to take your first formal action on this budget. So over the course [0:57:41] of the last ten weeks or so when you include the conversations that we had [0:57:48] with the long-term planning committee, the conversations that we had prior to [0:57:52] presenting the preliminary budget, and then the conversations that we've had since the [0:57:56] first weekend of July. [0:57:59] We've gone through this in a fairly methodical process, and so we're going to today go back [0:58:06] almost to a similar first presentation, but slightly abbreviated, and not necessarily [0:58:12] focus on the specific focus areas, but talk more about the budget as a collective piece, [0:58:18] at the end of tonight, we're going to ask you to adopt the preliminary budget. [0:58:23] The preliminary budget sets the absolute maximum cap that you can expand. [0:58:27] It does not mean that that is what you will expend. [0:58:30] Idaho Code provides you the opportunity to continue to move that number downward, but [0:58:36] it also creates a ceiling. [0:58:38] And so in that ceiling, it's not a place that you can exceed. [0:58:43] At one more clarification, yes, may you move amounts within the budget as long as you're [0:58:48] they don't exceed the cap, departments or projects, maybe. [0:58:59] Because you can't move funds from the water fund [0:59:01] into the general fund. [0:59:02] And that's why I say, might not understand. [0:59:05] Yep, so we're allowable by law, you could switch monies. [0:59:09] Within the general fund, you guys can move [0:59:11] those general fund projects in categories and projects. [0:59:15] You can shift funds in the tech supported funds generally [0:59:19] unless they are specifically earmarked. [0:59:21] So for example, monies that we receive from the state for the purposes from the gas tax [0:59:29] cannot go into the general operating fund of the city, they must be dedicated to the street [0:59:34] fund. [0:59:35] And so any monies there, they already have a command. [0:59:38] General property tax dollars that we're going to collect, the council does have the priority [0:59:42] to move those and chip those based upon you believe the priorities. [0:59:47] We've set forward a recommendation, but that doesn't mean that that is the end-all be-all. [0:59:53] Water fund, sewer fund, sanitation fund, fees that we have charged to access the parking lots [0:59:59] at Durk-Inchishone Falls. [1:00:01] Those are going to be the enterprise type funds. [1:00:04] We run those like independent small businesses, and those funds where they collect those fees [1:00:09] must remain. [1:00:10] In those funds, we can do some transfers, but we have to justify that transfer amount we refer [1:00:16] So that is a rent. [1:00:19] So just as we've always done, we have the conversation about the end of the novel first [1:00:25] and the end of the novel has not changed from the last week. [1:00:30] We're still projecting that the average individual's home, which we have valued at $147,200, which [1:00:37] comes from the US Census Bureau, will see a property tax decrease of $12.87 annually. [1:00:45] The property tax value is up from $142 now granted when we talk about scenarios. [1:00:53] It's not a case for all scenarios because what we're seeing is obviously how the tax rates [1:00:59] apply to an individual property sets that individual's property tax burden. [1:01:06] So we can't say that all property taxes are going to experience a $12.87 tax rate, but [1:01:12] We also can't say that all property taxes are going to go up as a result of the reassessment [1:01:17] that occurred within our community. [1:01:20] We also provide what the averages are on the water of the sewer and the sanitation. [1:01:26] The average resident inside of the City of Twin Falls uses about 18,000 gallons a month [1:01:32] and this person would see an increase in their monthly water bill at 96 cents. [1:01:38] We have a sewer cap at 8,000 gallons. [1:01:41] We spent time in the initial conversation about the sewer cap, about how that's artificially [1:01:47] low and we're going to be spending time over the course of this next fiscal year looking [1:01:51] at that. [1:01:52] The closer consumption rate of sewer during non-irrigation seasons appears to be between [1:01:59] the 10 and the 12,000 gallons per month. [1:02:02] And so we'll be coming back and taking a look at that. [1:02:06] We're estimating about a third of our residents in the non-irrigation seasons send us more [1:02:10] than the 8,000 gallon cap. [1:02:13] And then the sanitation, the recycling, [1:02:16] now that's up about 36 cents, [1:02:18] and that is completely associated with the PSI contract, [1:02:23] and we'll spend some time talking about that. [1:02:28] So the city manager's budget is put before you, [1:02:32] and according to Idaho Code 50-811, [1:02:35] which says the city manager shall keep the council fully [1:02:37] comprised of financial conditions of the city [1:02:39] and its future needs, [1:02:41] and prepare and submit a budget, [1:02:43] tend to budget for the Council's consideration [1:02:46] deliberation for the next year. [1:02:48] Over the course of time, [1:02:49] we have fulfilled the statutory requirement [1:02:51] by submitting this budget for your review. [1:02:53] And at no time have we ever said [1:02:55] that this is the only plan? [1:02:56] We've always said that this is a good starting place [1:02:59] in the foundation, which again, [1:03:01] started with the long-term planning committee. [1:03:03] They're working February and matriculated [1:03:05] through a conversation with the Council. [1:03:07] We went through a significant balancing exercise [1:03:10] this year and then we publish the budget that is before you for deliberation and consideration. [1:03:18] This is really your task tonight in testifying by Idaho Code 50-10-02 and you are going to [1:03:27] adopt a preliminary or tentative budget that you will estimate the revenues and expenses. [1:03:34] You will charge staff with publishing that in the paper and setting a public hearing [1:03:39] date and that public hearing date is already set through the conversations that we had with [1:03:46] the, I believe it's with the assessor's office and they publish that on individuals property [1:03:53] tax notices. [1:03:55] Ours is for 6 p.m. on the evening of August 28th. [1:04:05] We've shared along the way how this budget and the strategic plan is or is connected to [1:04:10] of the various aspects of the strategic plan, [1:04:12] and we have spent time going through each one [1:04:15] of those focus areas in detail, [1:04:17] talking about the outcomes that we hope to achieve, [1:04:20] the acquisitions that we hope to make, [1:04:22] as a part of this budget. [1:04:24] Tonight we're going to talk about the budget again [1:04:26] in its entirety. [1:04:28] It's based upon a total taxable value of the city [1:04:31] at $2,648,794,000. [1:04:36] $94,000. That total value is the net value of the city. It's important to remember that [1:04:44] that money excludes more than $700,000 associated with homeowners exemption. It also excludes [1:04:51] a $700 million and it also excludes nearly $800 million associated with a little bit of [1:04:58] a little value. You can see that the new construction number for this year, as given to us by the [1:05:03] the assessor's office is about $17.9 million less than the one in the past year and that [1:05:10] is a reflection of when most of those structures receive their occupancy permits and as we shared [1:05:17] it falls on to those tax rolls in subsequent years and so we will see that next year moving [1:05:24] forward. [1:05:25] Chris talking to you know Travis also I think it's worth mentioning the taxable value of the [1:05:29] The city does not include a non-prophet. [1:05:33] That's accepted. [1:05:34] That's accepted. [1:05:35] The churches. [1:05:36] Yep, it does include non-profits. [1:05:37] It doesn't include all properties associated with the hospital. [1:05:41] I mean, there are many, many properties that are also excluded from taxation in general, [1:05:47] but when you take a look at these are just the exemptions and the exclusions from which we [1:05:53] build our budgets. [1:05:58] This is a graphical representation of how the city's taxable value has increased and decreased [1:06:05] over the years and you can see that in 2013 we had recorded the lowest tax rate or total [1:06:13] taxable value and that's a result of the devaluation of property associated with the Census. [1:06:19] One of the things that we see is that this increase. [1:06:23] We know that a lot of the increase is largely a result of the construction market that we're [1:06:29] seeing and in the conversations that we're having, it's really becomes down to is supplying [1:06:34] demand. [1:06:35] And when you look at the number of homes that are being constructed in comparison to the [1:06:38] number of the demand that is out there, the demand is outpacing the supply. [1:06:44] And one of the conversations that Councilman Tockington often asks our partners skilled [1:06:49] construction labor. [1:06:50] I think it's important to recognize, and it's not necessarily part of this budget, but that's [1:06:54] a piece of our local economy that's impacting our growth and our ability to expand. [1:07:01] Right now we're doing about 250 homes a year, and we'll continue to do that. [1:07:07] It's about the third year that we're projecting to be about that 250 homes. [1:07:13] We don't believe that's indicative of the demand that we're seeing, but that's really [1:07:17] the ability of the supply to be delivered by the local construction firms doing business. [1:07:23] One of the things that we have done is, as you know, we partnered with the development [1:07:27] community on the property towards the south by working on our share of the Boot Wheels [1:07:33] Looser Station, making improvements to a significant water distribution line that really does [1:07:38] open up considerable lots and conversations that we've had with our planning and zoning [1:07:42] team. [1:07:43] and plants that are resurrected from the early 2000s, [1:07:46] becoming to come back for light. [1:07:48] And so you'll start seeing those move forward. [1:07:50] Those create additional construction opportunities [1:07:52] for our community to grow. [1:07:54] But again, you need to be able to have the skilled workers [1:07:56] to be able to do the work necessary [1:07:59] to be able to create those housing opportunities [1:08:01] for talent, attraction, and workforce. [1:08:05] Great landing. [1:08:06] Well, just to leave that one up there, [1:08:09] just to get a little perspective on this. [1:08:12] the city and another city in our state is almost identical in population being [1:08:16] Caldwell their net assessed evaluation is somewhere south of a million and we're [1:08:22] at two point six billion but considerable difference in the value of our properties [1:08:27] as compared to Caldwell's we have more McDonald's you know one of the things [1:08:34] that is important and I think you bring up a good point is that the recovery has [1:08:40] has not been equal to all. [1:08:42] And one of the benefits that we've had is we have recovered [1:08:46] at a much quicker plane than many of our peer cities, [1:08:49] not only within the state of Idaho, [1:08:50] but also around the country. [1:08:52] You take a look at our unemployment rate, [1:08:54] I think is indicative of the number of individuals [1:08:56] that are working within our communities. [1:09:00] And so again, it comes down to that talent attraction, [1:09:02] that workforce model so we can continue [1:09:05] to propel the local economy. [1:09:07] So, here is probably the sheet that creeps the numbers, if you will. [1:09:15] So, this is where all the mathematical formulas are created, and as you will fall, the normal [1:09:20] taxable value number, the denominator is the number that is given to us by the County Assessor's [1:09:25] Office. [1:09:26] They go out and they appraise all the property in accordance to the state code. [1:09:31] They have parameters in which they need to do those evaluations and they perform those [1:09:34] evaluations. [1:09:37] From that point, the City of Twin Falls takes a look at its needs in the tax-supported, [1:09:43] which are those funds that are funded by property taxes and the non-tax-supported funds, those [1:09:48] funds that are treated like small and independent businesses that we have operating, we refer [1:09:53] to those as enterprise funds. [1:09:55] You'll notice that our total tax collections this year are anticipated to be $20,253,000. [1:10:04] That is the numerator and you take the numerator divided by the denominator, you create the tax [1:10:12] rate of $7.53, which is about $0.50 less than the property, the tax rate that is applied to [1:10:22] the other. [1:10:23] This is the best information that we have. [1:10:26] We just have this number completely refined to us and provided to us by the county and so [1:10:31] that we are not expecting any significant changes [1:10:34] in any of these numbers from the county at this point. [1:10:39] The council has complete control over its collections. [1:10:43] And the property tax collection is the piece [1:10:46] that would determine by the amount of monies [1:10:49] that you would collect to offer goods and services. [1:10:52] Changing water rates, changing sewer rates [1:10:54] does not impact the tax rate. [1:10:57] Chris talking to you. [1:10:58] Could you give us a real brief overview [1:11:01] if you will, of when the urban renewal projects sunset [1:11:05] and all this start impacting our tax base. [1:11:10] So the first one that we know that we'll close for sure [1:11:13] is Area 4-1. [1:11:14] It's the downtown project area. [1:11:17] It is the largest urban renewal area that we have. [1:11:21] It's also the oldest urban renewal area that we have. [1:11:24] It has a matching statutory life that [1:11:28] will expire on in 2023 and no urban renewal can expire as long as it has any debt and so based [1:11:38] upon current revenues and expenditures and project lists we believe that that will go to 2023. [1:11:47] The cliff bar piece appears to be right on its 20 year time horizon that it will collect the [1:11:53] increment needed to pay off and satisfy the debts that were made for the public improvement and so [1:11:58] So we're looking at a total of a 20-year piece, I believe, [1:12:02] that has about 19 years left. [1:12:04] So that is one that just moved in. [1:12:07] So the Cliff Bar piece, which only includes the Cliff Bar [1:12:11] property, has about 18, 19 years left. [1:12:18] The great unknown is the Chibani piece. [1:12:21] And the Chibani piece has the opportunity [1:12:24] to have a 20-year life in accordance to the Idaho Code. [1:12:29] It collects on an annual basis roughly, [1:12:33] I think it's about $6.6 to $6.8 million [1:12:37] based upon its current value. [1:12:40] $2.6 of that is needed to fund the annual debt service [1:12:44] amount. [1:12:45] $4 million goes to cover Chivani for the additional improvements [1:12:50] that they have made to advance the public infrastructure that [1:12:52] could not be covered by the bond. [1:12:54] There on the bond aid, there's about $28 million. [1:12:58] And when you take a look at the annual debt service payment, [1:13:01] if only that amount were to be applied, [1:13:04] it would last out its entire 20-year life, [1:13:09] which is started in 2012, which means that it would end in 2032. [1:13:14] However, right now, it's collecting [1:13:18] after it makes its investment back to Chibani, [1:13:20] about $4 million, and that additional $4 million, [1:13:24] if there's not a public purpose, [1:13:26] could be provided to the bond, [1:13:29] and it could be an early payoff provision [1:13:31] associated with that bond. [1:13:33] And if without an increase in value, [1:13:36] the earliest possible date could be 2023 as well. [1:13:40] And really that is a conversation [1:13:42] that we've been engaging with Giovanni to say, [1:13:44] is there additional public purpose projects [1:13:47] that could be used for the increment? [1:13:48] if there's not, then we'll continue [1:13:50] to move those conversations forward. [1:13:53] Great landing. [1:13:54] So, I just wanted to try to say, I think I understand, [1:13:57] but I want to make sure, let's say, [1:13:59] Giovanni, they've got a lot of extra acreage out there [1:14:02] that they've purchased. [1:14:04] If they, this is all in there, I mean, no agency area. [1:14:07] If they were to decide to say we're going to do this, [1:14:11] we're going to expand in this manner [1:14:12] or build this other building, [1:14:14] and it needs some additional services [1:14:16] that would be covered in an urban, you know, [1:14:18] Would that delay the bond, most likely, or the payoff I should take? [1:14:22] Well, so not necessarily. [1:14:25] Because if they're going to make an additional expansion [1:14:28] and an additional investment, that means that the increment is also [1:14:31] going to rise. [1:14:32] And so if the increment rises greater than the debt [1:14:35] service, you're not. [1:14:37] But what's important is they all have a maximum life. [1:14:40] And according to the debt of code, and in no time can they [1:14:42] exceed 20 years. [1:14:44] And the jabani piece right now is the one [1:14:47] that is the great unknown, because its increments spin off [1:14:50] is far greater than what we had originally anticipated. [1:14:56] And just a reminder that one [1:14:58] on all these urban noise, the school district [1:15:00] still reflects their full bond payments [1:15:03] and everything they're not included in the text apparel. [1:15:06] That's exactly right. [1:15:07] So the urban renewal agencies [1:15:09] so receive the net amount, [1:15:12] and that net amount is you first exclude [1:15:16] All of the levies and bonds that are assessed by the school district, that school gets that [1:15:23] share and if you take a look at the amount of money that defers the bonding, that helps [1:15:30] all properties experience inside of the city of Twin Falls. [1:15:34] So you tune to us council people about the year 2023 you might see a real significant [1:15:40] of the tax base. [1:15:42] So yeah, something of a small beer around, [1:15:44] but you don't have a whole problem. [1:15:46] So yeah, whoever is here in 2023, [1:15:49] and let's say both of those were to close simultaneously, [1:15:55] the way the current Idaho code is written [1:15:57] is that would be classified as a new construction [1:16:00] because it's new coming onto the taxiles. [1:16:09] So when we take a look at the $20,253,000 [1:16:13] that is proposed to be collected [1:16:15] associated with this budget, [1:16:17] no part of the $2,186,000 for gun balances [1:16:22] incorporated into the city manager's recommended budget. [1:16:26] This is a graphical illustration of the budgets over time. [1:16:32] And we talked about the dark blue being the enterprise funds [1:16:37] and the light blue being associated [1:16:42] with the tech support of those. [1:16:46] This is also an illustration of the property tax rate, [1:16:49] and you can see how the property tax rate assessed [1:16:53] by the city. [1:16:54] There are many other tax rates that are assessed [1:16:56] by other entities. [1:16:57] We only have control over the tax rate that we assessed, [1:17:00] and you can see that our tax rate has gone up and down [1:17:05] in accordance to what has occurred by a combination [1:17:08] of our local spending, as well as the total taxable value [1:17:12] that is provided to us by the assessor. [1:17:17] One of the components in that model is the Homeowners' [1:17:20] Exemption, and you can see how that has changed over time. [1:17:26] Prior to 2006, it was an amount set by the legislature [1:17:30] in the 2006 legislative session. [1:17:33] Following into 2007, the Idaho legislature [1:17:36] decided to index that based upon the global property [1:17:39] values of the state. [1:17:40] That followed in indexing up until this year in 2017, [1:17:45] where the legislature in 16 removed us off of the indexing [1:17:49] and then provided a flat amount. [1:17:50] So it's a flat homeowner's exemption of 100,000, [1:17:55] a maximum of $100,000, and it's determined by 50% [1:17:59] of the total tax will value with a maximum gap of 100,000. [1:18:06] This is an illustration of our total property tax collections [1:18:11] last year in comparison to other property. [1:18:14] We're the green bar, and so you can see that we're [1:18:16] about middle of the pack. [1:18:18] Cortilane, Napa Caldwell, have a slightly less tax rate, [1:18:26] or a tax burden and not tax rate, that is assessed. [1:18:29] And you can see that Idaho Falls, Pocatello, and Lewis [1:18:31] don't have a slightly larger. [1:18:34] Boise and Meridian are excluded from this list simply [1:18:40] because they have the Ada County Highway District. [1:18:43] That is an independent taxing entity. [1:18:45] They do the street funds associated with the city. [1:18:47] We shared that Boise's tax rate does not include [1:18:51] what they do for roads and road maintenance, [1:18:53] where in which ours and all of these other cities [1:18:56] highlight it do. [1:18:57] And so we intentionally exclude them [1:18:59] because it's not an apples to apples comparison. [1:19:01] If you were to take the Ada County Highway District [1:19:04] levy and you were to add that to the Boise levy [1:19:07] or the Meridian levy, they would be higher [1:19:09] than the city of football's levy. [1:19:14] We've had a conversation, several conversations [1:19:16] about the number of employees that work for the City of Twin Falls, we spent time talking [1:19:21] about how really the delivery of quality public goods and services start with the frontline [1:19:27] employees that we have in our organization. [1:19:30] We have 299.13 FTE recommended in this budget, and that growth is pretty small and the new [1:19:40] positions are really covered by looking at how we funded operations such as janitorial [1:19:45] contracts and services, making allowances for changes in how attorney services are going [1:19:52] to be offered by the city. [1:19:53] It also includes a 3.5 percent performance adjustment for all of our employees who meet [1:19:58] the minimum standards, a 5 percent table movement. [1:20:03] And what's important is that 5 percent table movement and a 3.5 percent adjustment does [1:20:08] not mean our employees are getting an 8.5 percent raise. [1:20:12] salary tables more complicated than that. He talks about the starting at the end and most [1:20:18] of the employees in our organization will see about a three and a half percent adjustment. [1:20:23] We also have what's called a compression ratio adjustment so some employees will also [1:20:27] see a little bit more and that is to help our employees move through the table to make sure [1:20:33] that our model remains competitive. One of the things that we've really worked hard [1:20:37] as an organization is to ensure that our model is very competitive. [1:20:42] I think that we've made great strides as an organization in the last several years, and [1:20:46] I think that can be completely illustrated by how we are fully staffed or near fully staffed [1:20:54] in many of our departments and the quality of applicants that we're seeing are continuing [1:21:01] to remain very strong and we're not seeing the exodus that we had seen in the past. [1:21:08] This also provides for covering the 7.9 percent health insurance. [1:21:14] One of the questions that we were asked last week was how do you know that's the right number. [1:21:18] We work with our insurance brokers very early on in the process and we know what it is to [1:21:23] renew our rate for existing coverage and at 7.9 percent that is shared with the employees. [1:21:34] maintenance and operations, you can see that that has gone up slightly. It's gone up $315,000, [1:21:41] which is about 1.88%, which is important as the municipal cost index, which is similar [1:21:46] to the consumer price index, but it's more heavily focused on goods that are procured [1:21:52] by local government. For this fiscal year is 2.05%, and so the cost of inflation associated [1:21:59] with us is less than what you would see by the municipal cost index. [1:22:04] Capital has gone up this year from $13.12 million to $15.8 million. [1:22:12] $2.6 million total increase for an increase of about $20.4 million. [1:22:19] What's pretty, I think, important about this slide is it illustrates [1:22:25] that the City of Twin Falls has spent $131 million [1:22:31] on capital improvements since 2012. [1:22:35] I mean, just let that sink in for a minute. [1:22:37] Remember our total budget this year is $66 million. [1:22:41] And when you take a look at the bonds [1:22:43] that the citizens have supported, [1:22:46] that helps move this forward. [1:22:47] The additional grants that we've gotten to sit and move forward, [1:22:51] that advances our local community. [1:22:54] It helps build the basic foundation in which we're building our economy and we're going [1:22:59] to continue to do what we can to make those investments. [1:23:04] You'll see that it's probably far more than what we typically realize the amount that we're [1:23:10] spending when it comes to durable goods. [1:23:13] Spend a little bit of time talking about the enterprise funds. [1:23:18] Again, those enterprise funds are the small business funds. [1:23:22] We spent time talking about that but the total water fund in this budget is about $11.9 million. [1:23:27] The total sewer fund in this budget is $10.4 million. [1:23:31] We've talked about how the rate increases are not only to assist with bond covenants standards, [1:23:37] but it's also to assist with covering those capital lists, those initiatives, and those [1:23:41] overall projects moving forward. [1:23:45] The sanitation contract is $3,076,000, you'll see that it's about $36 per month increase [1:23:51] or 2.13%, which is right in line with that municipal cost index number that we had shared [1:23:57] with you earlier. [1:24:00] We spent a lot of time over the course of the last several weeks talking about the foregone [1:24:04] balance. [1:24:05] And this is the illustration that we shared that should you elect to incorporate monies [1:24:13] into this budget. [1:24:16] There are some additional steps that you will need to take this evening and if there's a [1:24:20] desire to do that, we can help the council walk through that. If there's no [1:24:24] desire to do that this evening, then we can bypass those additional steps, because [1:24:31] it does require by Idaho Code to declare publicly that you intend to have a [1:24:36] conversation, incorporate foregone balance, and then we have a separate and [1:24:40] additional public hearing as a part of that process, and we would host both of [1:24:45] of those hearings on the 28th of August. [1:24:53] And this is really an illustration of where we stand. [1:24:55] So tonight, it is your opportunity [1:24:58] to set the preliminary budget and the public hearing date. [1:25:07] There's one slight air on this right here, [1:25:09] and that's that we're not meeting on the 21st, [1:25:12] we're going to be meeting on the 23rd, [1:25:15] and for the purposes of having one last look at the budget [1:25:19] before we ask for you to take that full consideration. [1:25:23] So with that, all the members of the city's executive [1:25:26] leadership team, I believe, are in the audience [1:25:28] with the exception of our CFO who had other items [1:25:32] she needed to take care of this evening. [1:25:35] But Shane Carpenter, who is a master of this budget [1:25:38] and probably knows it probably more inside and out [1:25:40] than the rest of us is ready to answer those tough questions. [1:25:46] Travis, can you clarify for me what the total budget number is, is it the 66-209-908? [1:25:59] And this is not the form of an ordinance tonight, this is simply a motion that said the maximum [1:26:05] of 66-191-636-72, I've found two different numbers, yeah, there's another one out there. [1:26:20] And the foregone amount is $2,186,253. [1:26:25] So if there were a desire to potentially include the foregone in that discussion, it would be [1:26:33] the sum of those two numbers, would be the maximum amounts at this evening, not saying [1:26:39] that that is what would have to be adopted at the end of that. [1:26:43] And if you did that, then we, Shane and Laurie, have put together very specific language that [1:26:50] we will put on the overhead projector that you will need to read and becomes from the [1:26:55] Idaho Code as part of that motion. [1:26:57] Chris, talk to me. [1:26:59] But I would hope that we could include this in two separate voting motions as opposed [1:27:05] to one summary amount. [1:27:07] So I would say if that's the case, we'd want to have a discussion about whether we think [1:27:11] we want to take the foregone and if there is some discussion that there may be some interest [1:27:16] and that maximum number is one number. [1:27:20] One motion. [1:27:21] There have been different considerations on the [1:27:23] amount of the four donder take. [1:27:26] What I'm saying is tonight we should, if there is any [1:27:29] interest in taking any of the four going, the number [1:27:33] should not be 66, 191, 636 that we set tonight. [1:27:37] That is correct. [1:27:39] What we need at the end of the evening is a final [1:27:47] number for us to be able to put in the publications that Shane will have to get so [1:27:55] that we can meet the two times within a seven-day requirement. [1:28:01] So are there any questions? Suzanne Hawkins. Not really a question. I just want to say thank [1:28:11] you Travis to you and your team. I think the budget's been well thought out. I [1:28:14] think we're taking on about as many projects as we can humanly get done over [1:28:20] next year and so I think that to me that that sets the page for not taking the [1:28:27] foregone balance because even if we take the money I don't know how we can find [1:28:30] the man hours to do any more than what we're fighting off on this budget but I'm [1:28:37] very comfortable with the budget you've presented and I don't see anything in the [1:28:43] actual proposal that I would change. [1:28:48] I likewise will only support that $66 million $191,636 figure. [1:28:56] We have come 53% more money into a street budget this year. [1:29:03] We're still trying to figure out how to spend all of the $4. [1:29:06] million we have applied in our that indicative of receiving [1:29:13] almost $4.2 million or $3 million in state grants [1:29:17] by our own John Catons admission, the engineering department is working about as much as they [1:29:24] can. I don't find a justification to take, especially since we would be doing a split [1:29:30] pot. I don't see that there's evidence we could wisely use the money this year with everything [1:29:36] that's on our table and already some millions of dollars already expanded toward the repair [1:29:45] of the streets down to the individual residential lanes. [1:29:51] So I just don't think that this taking any of the money as well served in the taxpayers [1:29:58] point where we're going to be boosting their relative tax rate. [1:30:03] I really think that this in my mind has always been emergency need money, we're going to have [1:30:10] to go back if we do approve it expenditure some of this 2.18 6 million and decide how [1:30:16] to spend it after we decide to first of all to spend it. So I would only be in [1:30:21] decorative for supportive of the 66,191,636 for fiscal 2018 budget and I'll put that in [1:30:33] the form of a motion. [1:30:34] So before we have a motion we have offered that the citizens would have an [1:30:38] opportunity to speak at each of these budget hearings and I would like to give them that [1:30:42] opportunity if we may before we do a formal motion. Ruth Bearson. [1:30:48] So I personally don't, I'm not interested in taking the foregone balance. I would really [1:30:57] entertain more citizen feedback. I really had one person reach out to me and tell me that [1:31:05] they thought we shouldn't but, and nobody said we should but I really do think that if [1:31:10] If we could get more feedback whether we form a citizens advisory committee or I don't know [1:31:16] how to do it. [1:31:17] I mean, we don't need more committee meetings but somehow get some feedback on what their [1:31:24] take is. [1:31:26] Understanding that if we don't decide to do it this year, we have to wait for another [1:31:30] full year. [1:31:32] It's not necessarily an emergency. [1:31:34] Oh my gosh, you know, we've got to have it. [1:31:37] So we have an emergency meeting. [1:31:39] We absolutely have to make that decision at budget time. [1:31:49] So with that, I'll turn the opportunity over to the residents who may be here this evening [1:31:54] to give us any input that you may have on the budget. [1:31:58] Again, the action we're taking tonight is setting the maximum possible amount that the [1:32:03] budget will be. [1:32:04] We'll set a formal public hearing that will be open for citizen input and then adopt the [1:32:12] budget at a later date. [1:32:13] So there's anyone here who wishes to give us some input, now is your chance to come forward. [1:32:19] Mr. Edwards. [1:32:40] Good evening, Mayor and Councilman. [1:32:44] I would like to ask if anybody knows what that is. [1:32:50] It's the organizational chart for the city. [1:32:54] And what is it? [1:32:55] It's a line and staff chart. [1:32:58] It shows who answers to who. [1:33:01] It's the authority who gives to whom the organization and rightly places the citizens [1:33:06] the Twin Falls as a supreme authority in the organization, not the City Council, not the [1:33:11] Mayor. 255 page budget proposal, hours of justification during City Council meetings, and 3 to 5 minutes [1:33:23] of public allowed to speak. You're going to allow me more than 3 minutes, I would hope. Is [1:33:29] that correct? Yeah, if you'd like to speak to the budget, that would be fantastic. That's [1:33:33] exactly what I'm speaking to. By the way, all these numbers that I have come directly [1:33:38] from that budget that's been presented, I would like to have a conversation with a [1:33:43] council. Quoting from the budget proposal, the role of local government is [1:33:49] to protect the citizens' health and provide for their safety. This budget goes [1:33:54] far beyond that. Claim a health and safety concern and your city council can [1:34:00] spend tax money on anything and that remotely falls in the categories of a [1:34:05] strategic plan which is really nothing more than a wish list with predetermined [1:34:10] outcomes. The Twin Falls budget process should start with an annual budget [1:34:16] citizens meeting to update and prioritize the goals for the coming year long [1:34:21] before the public proposed budget meetings and before the city manager [1:34:26] departments committees and other special interest groups develop their wish list. [1:34:31] Again, I'm quoting from the budget, while the budget does not fund all capital initiatives [1:34:38] and projects in the entire organization, it does meet the city council's priorities and [1:34:43] the citizen's service level expectations. [1:34:47] I would like to ask what specifically are those. [1:34:52] Quoting from the budget again, it the budget demonstrates restraint in areas of taxation [1:35:00] and rate adjustments. [1:35:02] The combined expenditures and transfers total $71,350,260, [1:35:11] which is $6,125,592, [1:35:16] dollar increase compared to the current year budget of $65,224,264,668. [1:35:28] Does that sound like a restraint? [1:35:31] Government fund type expenditures increase 3,817,744, [1:35:39] a 9.4% increase. [1:35:42] Enterprise fund budget increase of $2,307,848, [1:35:49] or an 8.12% increase. [1:35:53] Does that sound like a restraint? [1:35:56] The budget proposes to limit tax collections and rate increases. [1:36:01] How much more does the city services, [1:36:04] how much more will city services cost? [1:36:07] It recommends, the budget recommends, [1:36:09] and requires a 3.0% revenue increase plus growth. [1:36:16] The city manager's physically 218 recommendation [1:36:19] estimates a 2.5 increase in water rates, [1:36:23] 5% increase in sewer rates, [1:36:25] and 2.4% increase in sanitation fees. [1:36:29] Is that restraint? [1:36:31] It provides an across the board increase of 3.5% for 294 [1:36:36] employees who meet the job performance standard. [1:36:40] Also provides funding to adjust the city's salary table by 5% [1:36:45] and provides for a 7.9 increase in funding for health insurance [1:36:49] benefits. [1:36:50] Budget increases total capital funding and street fund [1:36:54] for $300 or $3,313,975 to $5,777,770, which represents $1,763 or $1,763, 795 or an increase [1:37:19] of 53.22% budget increase of a total capital funding in the water fund from $1,299,500 [1:37:32] to $2,829. [1:37:36] Excuse me, dyslexic care. [1:37:40] $2,829,095, which represents a $1,529,595 or 117.71% increase. [1:37:57] Budget increases total capital funding in the wastewater fund [1:38:01] from 685,600 to 983,625, which represents an increase of $298,025 or 43.47% increase. [1:38:20] Suer Fund's system expenditures in the amount of $11,893,191, an increase of $1,709,202 or [1:38:33] 16.8% and recommends the city increase the water rates by 2.5%. [1:38:42] fund expenditures totaling 10,413,664. This represents an increase of $1,114,233 and recommends [1:38:56] the city increase water rates by 5%. Sanitation funds an increase of 2.4%. Do all those sound [1:39:06] like restraint. Don't be fooled by comparison to other Idaho cities. All cities are unique [1:39:14] in Idaho and it would be like comparing apples and oranges. When comparisons are made using [1:39:20] average home values and tax rates per thousand of assessed value, remember it's based on owner [1:39:27] occupied properties. Nearly half of Twin Falls residents are not owner occupied. They don't [1:39:35] get any benefit from homeowners exemption and so what appears to be a [1:39:43] five hundred and fifty five thousand seventy one cent annual tax rate is [1:39:49] really more like a hundred and eleven dollars and forty two cent annual tax [1:39:55] rate for those without homeowners exemptions businesses will pay more does [1:40:02] Does that sound like restraint? [1:40:06] And regarding the foregone balance, [1:40:07] foregone balance is just another way [1:40:10] for the city council to get into your pocket. [1:40:14] When a full 3% revenue increase plus increases [1:40:18] from new construction and annexation is not enough, [1:40:21] the budget proposal wants to go back in time [1:40:26] and use money that they didn't tax you for in previous years. [1:40:31] This is the only area Councilman talking to and I agree on. [1:40:37] Using foregone balance is not a good idea and if it's used, it will be used at your own [1:40:43] peril. [1:40:44] Remember, if you give them all they ask for, they will seek more next year. [1:40:49] When is enough enough? [1:40:51] We see how the sausage was made. [1:40:55] Where are strategic plan goals that reduce city government spending and waste? [1:41:00] I didn't see any. [1:41:03] This budget proposal is not to protect the citizens' health and provide further safety [1:41:08] at all. [1:41:09] It is a tax and spend big government bloated budget. [1:41:13] It is a local version of the United Nations Agenda 2030. [1:41:18] Thank you for your time. [1:41:19] Thank you, Mr. Edwards. [1:41:20] Is there anyone else who wishes to address the Council on the budget this evening? [1:41:32] Thank you, Mayor and City Council members. [1:41:35] Welcome. [1:41:36] I'm Max Dune. [1:41:37] I'm Seventh Avenue. [1:41:38] Avenue. I'm opposed to a foregone group. I noticed one little arithmetic mistake or [1:41:47] air that says the waterway was going to go up $36 per month. It didn't tell me the [1:41:52] year. And so all the other years, 36 years, I'm all fine. I can sell $100. I almost had [1:42:06] I got an hour attack because I get so many small. [1:42:09] And you got to do that actually. [1:42:18] 36 cents. [1:42:19] I sit down. [1:42:20] Thank you very much. [1:42:21] Thank you, Max. [1:42:22] So that does not add up in our 55 month, 96 and 3. [1:42:38] Yeah? [1:42:40] So crack the other part. [1:42:42] Oh, yeah. [1:42:43] I'm always looking for small conditions. [1:42:45] So anyone else who wishes to address the council this evening on the budget? [1:42:53] Seeing no one, we will move forward with council direction for the evening. [1:42:59] Greg Lanting. [1:43:00] I had a motion on the floor. [1:43:02] We'll move over here in a second. [1:43:04] Well we can go back to a motion from the Chris, that would be just fine. [1:43:08] I would like to give just a little bit of input before we do that. [1:43:11] So speaking of the foregone balance, I do believe there are needs. [1:43:18] needs to help us meet the needs of the citizens that the foregone balance could be used for. [1:43:25] But I also understand that taking it to have a pot to then identify and create projects [1:43:32] to meet those funds is completely backwards of the process that we go through so diligently [1:43:39] in this budget process. [1:43:40] So what I would recommend is not taking the foregone this year. [1:43:45] that through the significant months of work that go into budget planning from the strategic [1:43:55] plan update that we will get this fall through the long-term planning committees work through [1:44:01] the initial conversations that we have in April with the opportunity for citizen input that [1:44:06] we begin to look at specific projects that perhaps fit outside of the scope and scale of [1:44:13] the traditional budget and see if there are ways to look at that into the future. [1:44:18] So there's my two cents on the foregone and with that I'll call on Chris Stockington. [1:44:25] Well, we've obviously, I pay attention, I go around and I talk to people and I would say [1:44:33] that the, I will concur with what Mayor just talked about, there is some concern that I [1:44:42] reach out to my citizens. That's what I do on most major subjects, and certainly a major subject, [1:44:50] that maybe this isn't the year to take it before gone, and we should come up with specific things [1:44:59] to take it for. I did not have much positive feedback on the three pots as much as I did. [1:45:08] other maybe here with here's a project here what we're going to take for which is [1:45:12] what we did last time when we took it previously we had this specific plan in [1:45:20] mind we were going to use it for and we and then it's still being used for that [1:45:24] exact same thing consider on street street departments and I look at it a [1:45:31] little differently than maybe I would heard tonight is it when that's but we've [1:45:35] been saving people that money by not taking into the past we've actually [1:45:39] save those people that money every year as you put it down to your thing it's not [1:45:44] two-point million dollars it's more like 13 million dollars that we could have [1:45:48] taken that we have chosen not to take and so I will be supporting Chris's [1:45:56] motion when he gets ready to make it here again and if I'm fast enough I'll [1:46:01] even do the second. [1:46:04] I just wanted to throw my two cents in also in talking with people that there are some issues [1:46:11] there's some infrastructure concerns that people have and and I think the biggest thing that I heard back is [1:46:18] Specifically what is that money gonna be spent for and right now going into a pot that was a concern for them? [1:46:23] And so going back to what the council has kind of said [1:46:26] Nobody likes to raise taxes nobody likes to hear that and I understand that I'm one of the people that pays those taxes [1:46:34] But specifically, what is it going for? [1:46:37] And so I think a planning session sooner in the process of saying, okay, this is a foregone [1:46:44] balance. [1:46:45] What specific things would this money go towards would be very beneficial for next year? [1:46:52] So I'm in favor of Chris's budget proposal or dollar amount. [1:46:58] Chris, talking. [1:46:59] Okay, so I would move setting the fiscal 8 2018 preliminary budget a total of 66,191,636 [1:47:11] dollars. [1:47:12] Motion by Chris Stockton, seconded by Greg Lanting to set the maximum budget at $66,191,636 [1:47:24] also to set the date of the public hearing right for August 28th at 6 p.m. [1:47:32] At 6 p.m. Is there any discussion? I'm sure I'm not going to get back locked on here. [1:47:40] We've been off here for a while. [1:47:44] Shannell, call vote please. [1:47:48] Chris Tockington. Yes. [1:47:52] Sean Barriker. Yes. [1:47:54] Suzanne Hawkins. Yes. [1:47:56] Greg Lanting. Yes. [1:47:57] Ruth Pierce. Yes. [1:47:59] Christopher Reed. Yes. [1:48:01] Motion passes six to zero. Thank you Travis [1:48:05] Greg Lansing well, I guess I would have the question we've already moved next week's meeting from the 21st of the 23rd and [1:48:16] I'm quite honest. I feel pretty versed in this budget at this point and I would like to ask Travis what he plans to [1:48:25] Present to us that would be different [1:48:29] So we kept that date [1:48:34] Because there was still some question as to whether or not there would be [1:48:37] increases in the budget that we had sent to your review. If you wanted to have [1:48:45] additional conversations, we wanted to reserve that date. If you don't see any [1:48:51] significant deviations or changes as demonstrated here tonight in terms of [1:48:57] going up, then really it's the opportunity of the council to have a [1:49:01] question whether or not you want to host the meeting. It is the only item that we [1:49:05] have on the agenda that evening simply because we do know that members of the [1:49:10] council have conflicts later that evening and so we we kept that agenda to only a [1:49:16] brief overview of the budget which would be very similar to what you've heard this [1:49:21] this past year has been a real struggle for us to keep our law [1:49:27] enforcement fully staffed shape are we still it's full staffing or is there [1:49:33] anything has changed? We are one down. And how did we lose that person? Was it for a better [1:49:41] opportunity? The individual resigned. Thank you. Okay. It's not because of our compensation [1:49:48] right? I don't believe so. Okay. So if that's the only item on the agenda for next week, [1:49:57] and it sounds as if we've all had our opportunities to converse about the budget and we will still [1:50:03] have another opportunity for public input is everyone in agreement we should cancel next [1:50:08] week's meeting. [1:50:09] Yeah. [1:50:12] I'm seeing a lot of head nodding there. [1:50:14] Okay. [1:50:15] Well, I tell you we're going to get criticism of if we cancel up, if anything comes up at [1:50:24] last minutes meeting, I would rather hold it and have no one show up for additional input. [1:50:30] I'm more concerned about using all the city, publication, PR, [1:50:35] advanced techniques possible to get the message out and pack [1:50:41] this place with citizen input. [1:50:43] I'd love to see it be such a surprise. [1:50:45] I know your really public hearing is scheduled [1:50:47] for the following week, which we'd still have [1:50:49] that opportunity for that. [1:50:51] Doesn't mean they couldn't show up next week [1:50:52] and give us the two minutes. [1:50:53] No, it doesn't. [1:50:56] I just want to go bend over backwards [1:50:58] to keep the doors open, if you will, [1:51:03] and we don't have to have a long meeting. [1:51:05] We don't have to have much of anything to do, [1:51:08] if no one shows up. [1:51:09] I'd like to be pleasantly surprised that as Terry [1:51:13] and Max showed us, there were two people [1:51:15] that took the time to go some input. [1:51:17] There are going to be one or two more out there [1:51:19] in the town of 47,000. [1:51:23] All right, great landing. [1:51:25] Well, my only thought process on that [1:51:28] that people contact me directly. [1:51:30] I mean, I don't think everybody feels they have the need [1:51:33] to come to a council meeting in order to reach out [1:51:36] to their council members. [1:51:38] And I certainly have partially because I've been seeking input [1:51:44] of this last, this budget this time, [1:51:48] maybe a little more than I have in others. [1:51:51] But I've received some information from people in that, [1:51:55] that avenue. [1:51:57] I mean, I can certainly show up here after I have us regales with things again and then [1:52:04] go home, but I'm just not sure that's the purpose. [1:52:07] I think there's a chance I won't be here either way, so I'll be honest with you. [1:52:11] I don't think I can, I have a conflict that I would have to change because of the fact [1:52:17] we typically make our agendas for things we're going to do based on Monday nights. [1:52:23] keep those open. I didn't keep this winds the open because my prior [1:52:28] agreement was made prior to us changing the meeting. So I probably won't be [1:52:34] ready. Well maybe we can reach from middle ground. Let's encourage everybody [1:52:37] that's listening or watching out there to call us at home, a business. Sure. Yeah. [1:52:42] And give us their input that we get some more feedback. Yeah. I agree. Chris [1:52:48] I will actually be out of town that day, so I will not be able to attend on Wednesday. [1:52:54] Suzanne? [1:52:55] My concern is Wednesday nights is traditionally a Wednesday night church service for people who attend denominations that have midweek service. [1:53:03] And so putting a Wednesday night council meeting, I just, I don't see a lot of people attending on that night of the week who have regular schedule events, like you said. [1:53:14] They're not attending tonight either. [1:53:16] Again, I think the purpose of keeping that meeting available was should we have decided [1:53:22] we wanted to have a debate about foregone balance items. [1:53:26] To be perfectly honest, we've had nine straight weeks of these meetings on the budget and [1:53:30] allowed public input and we've had input back in April when we had the long-term planning [1:53:35] committee. [1:53:38] I'm confident that people who cleared their calendar to come next Wednesday can clear their [1:53:43] calendar to come the following Monday to give us that input or give us a call. [1:53:46] So I, personally I think we'd be fine canceling the meeting. [1:53:50] I am as well. [1:53:51] I like Chris's idea. [1:53:52] If you're out there listening and you want to contact me contact, you know, go to my email, [1:53:59] send me an email and I guarantee you I'll answer it. [1:54:02] That can be a good way to test the public that we don't see in contact. [1:54:08] No. [1:54:09] Alright, so Claire's not there. [1:54:12] That's pretty clearly, we're not meeting next Wednesday. [1:54:16] That's my mud. [1:54:17] So we do have another opportunity for general public input. [1:54:22] Anybody who wishes to address the council on that item that wasn't on the agenda this evening, [1:54:25] has your chance to come forward. [1:54:28] Seeing no one, do we have any advisory board reports from council members or announcements? [1:54:34] Suzanne Hopkins. [1:54:36] I just have a quick update from the library. [1:54:38] This year, their capital improvement item was replacing the roof or sections of it that [1:54:44] were very old and needed, and that has been completed on budget and passed off inspection [1:54:50] for a full insurance policy from the company who did it, and everything's looking good [1:54:55] at our library. [1:54:58] Chris, read. [1:54:59] So, the Magic Valley Transportation Committee met this last week, and we had an individual [1:55:06] come in and talk to us, and they're putting together a group that would like to light [1:55:11] the Perrine Bridge. It's popular out east, a little bit on the west coast. [1:55:18] Could you explain what you mean by light? [1:55:21] Put light on the bridge. [1:55:23] Not just lights like there are now, but down. [1:55:25] No, underneath so you can see the bridge. It's very popular where the river's really close [1:55:29] to it, so that reflection's really pretty. But they were thinking about really lighting [1:55:34] the canyon wall and really making that the prime bridge kind of stand out and so [1:55:40] that that's a group that is forming right now it's in its very early stages but [1:55:44] that is something that they're looking at. That's really going on in courage base [1:55:49] jumping at night. Well we'll see if it does that but it will be beautiful it'll [1:55:53] be absolutely gorgeous I think. Great landing although I'm not going to be in [1:56:00] town for the north for the eclipse. Somebody had said the library is planning an event where [1:56:08] they're going to close the street. Does anybody have details on that that people might want to? [1:56:11] A little bit. So the library put in for a grant and they were given, I don't remember, [1:56:17] how many thousands of glasses for viewing the eclipse. So for people who are staying local, [1:56:22] they have a program that if you attend the program, you get the glasses for free and they are going [1:56:28] going to close the street between City Park and the library for safety with the darkness [1:56:32] and things happening and they will have all kinds of events happening with stories and [1:56:40] everything related around the eclipse and they're hoping for a large turnout. [1:56:44] Anything else from the manager? [1:56:54] The only announcement that we had was just a reminder that you would be meeting next [1:56:57] week on the 23rd but it appears that that announcement is old so we have nothing else. [1:57:02] All right. We have no public hearings so let that the meeting is adjourned. [1:57:08] Do the nouset 756 or 656? [1:57:14] 645 is mine. [1:57:16] Yeah, you were pretty cool.