Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2017-03-27, recording 1 (started 17:00) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2017-03-27/ [0:08:26] Welcome to the Twin Falls City Council meeting of March 27th. [0:08:31] At this time we are going to start with the Pledge of Allegiance. [0:08:33] If you would like to join us, please rise. [0:08:35] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. [0:08:59] Thank you and with that we will officially call the meeting to order and we have a confirmation [0:09:03] that we do have a quorum tonight. [0:09:04] We have six of the seven council members here. [0:09:07] At this time we're gonna ask our city manager [0:09:10] if we have any amendments to our agenda tonight. [0:09:13] Madam Vice Mayor, there are no amendments this evening. [0:09:16] Thank you very much. [0:09:18] We do have two proclamations tonight. [0:09:21] So we are gonna go ahead and get started with that. [0:09:25] Too many papers here. [0:09:28] Thank you, Greg. [0:09:35] Our first proclamation is for the Year of the Lions. [0:09:40] Where as Lions Club International was founded in 1917 and is celebrating their 100th anniversary [0:09:48] and where as the Lions Club is the world's largest service organization with over 1.4 million [0:09:54] numbers in 215 countries. [0:09:58] Where as Lions Club empower volunteers to serve communities, meet humanitarian needs, encourage [0:10:05] peace and promote international understanding through participation in club activities, [0:10:11] and whereas the Lions Club in Idaho have distributed over 62,000 pairs of glasses throughout the [0:10:17] world and provided vision screening for over 30,000 students, and whereas Helen Keller [0:10:24] called the Lions Club in 1925, nights of the blind in crusade against darkness, and whereas [0:10:31] the City of Twin Falls holds the greatest admiration and the utmost support for all of [0:10:37] its Lion Club members, especially in the local club. Therefore, I, Suzanne Hawkins, vice mayor [0:10:43] of the City of Twin Falls, do hereby proclaim the year of 2017 as year of the Lions and encourage [0:10:50] all citizens of Twin Falls to show their appreciation by supporting the Lions Club in all their activities. [0:10:57] I have the stated and signed and at this time I'd like to invite Dennis Burks from Mountain [0:11:02] Home up to receive the proclamation. [0:11:04] Madam Vice Mayor, ladies and gentlemen of the City Council, thank you so very much. [0:11:34] The lines and twin falls, the lines of Southern Idaho and the lines international, we appreciate [0:11:39] this very much. [0:11:40] This means a lot to us. [0:11:41] A hundred years ago this June and that we started Lions Club in Chicago, Illinois, Melvin [0:11:48] Jones was a businessman and he had a vision. [0:11:51] And he says, let's get together and help the people in our communities. [0:11:55] And then it turned into the world three years later. [0:11:58] It's an awesome organization. [0:12:00] We enjoy serving our communities. [0:12:03] And one of the things that we enjoy doing the most is our vision screening with the kids. [0:12:07] To be able to walk into a classroom and see some of these kids and to get down there [0:12:11] because I'm six foot five and get out on my knees and set there and talk to them. [0:12:15] And then three or four days later you see them again and they say, oh my gosh, [0:12:18] he checked my eyeballs. [0:12:20] That's what means a lot to us. [0:12:22] It means a lot whenever we go to somebody's house [0:12:25] and we build a ramp for them because they're handicapped. [0:12:30] So we build a ramp for them and then to come out there [0:12:32] and see the smile on their face and the tears running down [0:12:34] their cheeks because we love serving our communities. [0:12:37] We thank you very much for this proclamation. [0:12:40] We will treasure it and we'll pass it around to everybody. [0:12:43] Thank you again. [0:12:49] At this time we're gonna invite the Lions Club forward [0:12:51] so we can take a group shot and ask the council [0:12:53] to stand up here behind them for the picture. [0:13:00] You guys can just group up here in front of us. [0:13:02] Yeah, definitely. [0:13:04] We're good. [0:13:05] We're good. [0:13:06] We're good. [0:13:07] We're good. [0:13:08] We probably need a double room. [0:13:14] At least. [0:13:15] You want to go down there? [0:13:19] Yeah. [0:13:20] Thank you guys. [0:13:59] Thank you. [0:14:01] Good job. [0:14:02] Thank you so much. [0:14:03] You know, come on in. [0:14:04] It's been known to sit down for a cup of coffee together. [0:14:07] I didn't tell him that we were quanning up here yet. [0:14:11] Thank you very much. [0:14:12] Thank you. [0:14:13] Thank you. [0:14:14] Appreciate it. [0:14:18] Thank you. [0:14:19] Uh-huh. [0:14:20] Yeah. [0:14:24] Oh, bye. [0:14:27] Can't beat that. [0:14:29] Okay, we're going to continue on with the second proclamation as the Lions make their way [0:15:12] out the back. [0:15:14] Our second proclamation is for Fair Housing Month, whereas April of 2017 marks the 49th [0:15:21] anniversary of the passage of Title VIII of the Civil Rights Act of 1968, commonly known [0:15:27] as the Federal Fair Housing Act, and whereas the Idaho Human Rights Commission Act has prohibited [0:15:34] discrimination in housing since 1969, and whereas equal opportunity for all, regardless [0:15:42] of race, color, religion, sex, disability, familial status, or national origin is a fundamental [0:15:51] goal of our nation, state, and city, and whereas equal access to housing is an important component [0:15:57] of this goal, as fundamental as the right to equal education and employment, and whereas [0:16:04] housing is a critical component of family and community health and stability, and whereas [0:16:09] housing choice impacts our children's access to education, our ability to seek and retain [0:16:15] employment options, the cultural benefits we enjoy, the extent of our exposure to crime [0:16:22] and drugs, and the quality of healthcare we receive in emergencies, and whereas the laws [0:16:27] of this nation and our state seek to ensure such equality of choice for all transactions [0:16:33] involving housing, and whereas ongoing education, outreach, and monitoring are key to raising [0:16:40] awareness of fair housing principles, practices, rights, and responsibilities, and whereas only [0:16:47] through continued cooperation, commitment, and support of all Idahoans can barriers to [0:16:53] fair housing be removed. [0:16:55] Now therefore, I, Suzanne Hawkins, vice mayor of the City of Twin Falls, do hereby proclaim [0:17:00] April 2017 to be Fair Housing Month in the City of Twin Falls in the state of Idaho. [0:17:07] that I would like to present this proclamation to Mitch Humble. [0:17:23] Just real briefly, fair housing practices are important in our community. [0:17:27] They're critical for our family and family development and growth of the community. [0:17:35] But we do this every year also to help us with our CDBG grant monies and complaints with all [0:17:45] of those. [0:17:46] Every time the federal government gives us money, it comes with a bunch of strings attached to [0:17:49] And this is one of those strings, but apart from that, it's still critical that we enforce [0:17:55] and try to encourage fair housing practices throughout the community. [0:17:58] So we appreciate this. [0:18:00] So I am this off to the appropriate folks. [0:18:03] Thanks. [0:18:04] Mitch, before you sit down, Nikki has a comment for you. [0:18:08] Thank you for doing this every year on behalf of all the realtors in Magic Valley. [0:18:14] It is very important. [0:18:16] And we appreciate that. [0:18:17] And it's you guys who are on the front lines of that really, realtors and mortgage companies [0:18:22] and all those folks that are really making sure this happens. [0:18:26] How about consumers too? [0:18:28] And buyers, right? [0:18:29] Let's keep buying houses. [0:18:32] Thank you very much. [0:18:35] At this time we're going to move forward with general public input. [0:18:38] Is there anybody in the chambers tonight who would like to address the council on an issue [0:18:42] that is not on our agenda? [0:18:48] Please step forward. [0:18:50] yourself and we ask you to keep your comments to between two to three minutes, please. [0:18:54] Okay. Thank you. [0:18:55] I apologize. I'm not really prepared. I just found out a few minutes ago I could actually [0:19:00] say this. So I'm Aaron Regal so I own fashion 15 below down on Main Street. And so I just [0:19:08] wanted to, I guess, address this or throw this out there to Madam Mayor and the City Council [0:19:15] that with the current construction that is going on in Main Street, so we are huge advocates [0:19:24] of that where that was a deciding factor actually and why we chose to put our business downtown. [0:19:29] So we're super excited for what's happening downtown and we fully support that. [0:19:34] But over the last several weeks, we have had a lot of complaints from our customers about [0:19:41] the parking situation. We receive almost daily deliveries from UPS. We've had on probably [0:19:49] four or five separate occasions where the UPS driver has been told by construction workers [0:19:55] that he's not allowed to deliver at the back of our building. He's also been told that he [0:20:01] can't deliver to us on Maine and so we've had delays on some of our shipments. But more [0:20:08] Or so we've just had a difficult time with the parking situation for our customers. [0:20:13] We've had to, we've had women call us from their cars and we've had to run out and grab [0:20:18] their credit card on Main Street and they just want to buy gift cards and there's nowhere [0:20:23] to park. [0:20:25] I've been answering a lot of that on social media and just getting a lot of that from [0:20:29] our customers. [0:20:30] And so I know that that probably can't be entirely fixed but I've spoken to a few different [0:20:37] people with the city and some of the project managers with the different construction companies. [0:20:42] They were very accommodating for us for our anniversary sale that we had about a month ago. [0:20:47] We had several hundred women that showed up for that and so we appreciated that. [0:20:51] But I am just concerned at the amount of time that this is going to take over the year and [0:20:56] to see if there is some type of solution or relief that we can have a little bit for the, [0:21:05] Especially the rear parking lot, I guess. [0:21:08] I knew that these things were going to be taking place [0:21:11] on Main Street, so we've tried really hard the last year [0:21:13] that we've been in business to educate our customers [0:21:16] on the additional rear parking and parking entrance [0:21:20] in the back, and that has been not a very good situation, [0:21:25] I guess for us. [0:21:27] So. [0:21:28] Thank you very much for making us aware [0:21:29] of what's going on, and Councilman Talkington [0:21:31] would like to weigh in. [0:21:32] This is exactly the type of end product, [0:21:34] time we need it to see the little tweaking we need. We can't build any more parking lots. [0:21:40] If people refuse to use the parking lots on the back and want to park the front of your [0:21:45] store, there's not much we can do. But it sounds like you're educating the people as [0:21:48] much as possible to go around back. But as I understand that the delivery truck [0:21:53] prohibitions, that's a major problem for you. Yes, and it's actually the rear parking is [0:22:00] what there is no rear parking that's available. My girls have actually had to [0:22:05] park a couple blocks of way, a way to walk in to work because there is no. And [0:22:11] where did they park before? In the rear parking lot. But what is happening is [0:22:17] because of the and I don't know if it's because there's multiple construction [0:22:20] companies or but by the time that we open at 10 and we usually get there at [0:22:26] at about 9.30 every single parking spot is taken [0:22:29] by a construction vehicle or and I recognize [0:22:36] that the city offices are a couple doors down from us [0:22:38] so we know that there's city employees [0:22:40] that are parking in the rear parking [0:22:42] but it's taken by every, I mean, [0:22:44] just about every single spot is taken [0:22:46] by the time we even open by construction workers, vehicles. [0:22:53] Thank you. [0:22:54] Yes. [0:22:55] So I had that same issue with the tree removal. [0:22:59] They decided they were parking in front of my office. [0:23:01] They were supposed to be parking in the lot behind me. [0:23:05] And so it's tax season, and there's not one place [0:23:08] for my customers to park. [0:23:10] And of course, by the time I found somebody to [0:23:13] bridge to it about if they were gone. [0:23:16] But I wonder if they can't base themselves out of that [0:23:19] Gould parking lot and walk a little bit, even if one [0:23:23] vehicle picked up everybody who parked in that parking lot and went to work. It just seems [0:23:30] that there needs to be, because it is, and we're encouraging everybody to play up the fact [0:23:38] that you're going to use your back door and that type of thing. And I just think we need [0:23:42] to address it now. They don't have to park right there as far as I'm considering. [0:23:50] Chris Reed. [0:23:51] So maybe you're going to answer the question. [0:23:54] So what agreements do we have in place with the construction workers? [0:23:58] Do they just have free rein over that parking lot or is there a certain area where they're [0:24:02] supposed to park? [0:24:05] So I think that it's important there are several construction activities that are occurring [0:24:09] in that very small geographic area. [0:24:11] You have the construction of the city hall piece which is overseen by star and most of [0:24:16] those construction individuals are parking at a different location than the alleyways that [0:24:22] we're talking right now. A lot of this work is probably being done by the trench work that [0:24:28] has been occurring. And so what we can do is we can reach out and have a conversation. So [0:24:33] that's not only going to impact the alleyway delivery because the alleyways really shouldn't [0:24:39] be used because they are a construction zone. And not only do you have the dry utilities, [0:24:45] But as the council will call you recently approved to get the what utilities moving down into the alleyway. [0:24:52] We can have a conversation with that construction company to see if there are other locations that they can park to open up that parking. [0:25:02] On the other side, and we know that this is also part of an education, [0:25:06] is on the other side of Main Street on the other seconds there is usually lots of parking. [0:25:12] And so I know that folks that are in the temporary city hall parking or building in other locations, [0:25:19] we have kind of dispersed and gone into those areas. [0:25:22] And so there are other areas, but that tends to be right now the ground zero of construction [0:25:29] and will continue to work with those construction companies to see if there's an alternative that [0:25:36] they'd be willing to work with us on. [0:25:37] Thank you. [0:25:39] And you let us know if you see an improvement. [0:25:41] Okay, we feel your pain. [0:25:43] I'm not trying to complain. [0:25:46] I just understand. [0:25:47] Because we are excited about what's going on. [0:25:50] So I do, I guess, want to make sure then, is it fine for UPS to deliver on Main Street? [0:25:57] Because that's what we've been told is that he can't deliver on Main Street. [0:26:00] And that is why he delivers that. [0:26:03] Do you know who told you that? [0:26:05] Are UPS. [0:26:06] Your UPS driver told you he's not allowed to? [0:26:08] Do you know who told him that? [0:26:10] Okay. Well, we'll do some research on that and see what we can find out. [0:26:15] It wouldn't have been a city group that would have shared that there's a prohibition of parking on Main Street temporarily. [0:26:25] I mean, we have tractor trailers that park in the middle is just showing and stopping block traffic. [0:26:32] So, and they make deliveries. [0:26:35] So, that might be something to have a conversation with their individual delivery companies with. [0:26:42] The company might have a prohibition about parking in an active [0:26:48] street way and blocking traffic. [0:26:51] And if that's an internal company regulation, that's not something that the city has oversight over. [0:26:56] Thank you. [0:26:56] We'll see what we can find out for you. [0:26:58] Okay. All right. [0:26:59] Thank you. [0:27:00] Have a good evening. [0:27:02] Is there anyone else who would like to address the council tonight? [0:27:08] And we are going to recess for 10 minutes when we, oh, sorry. [0:27:12] We have reports. [0:27:14] Ah, yes we do. I apologize. Okay. [0:27:17] Yeah. Oh, okay. Sorry guys. [0:27:21] Take a week off and you know everything goes ahead. Okay. [0:27:24] Let's go ahead. We'll move on to the consent calendar. [0:27:27] Ruth Pierce. [0:27:28] I move that we approve the consent calendar. [0:27:31] Second. [0:27:34] Chris, did you have a comment on that? [0:27:36] Yeah. [0:27:37] The motion on the floor by Ruth Pierce, seconded by Nikki Boyd, and before we go to a vote, [0:27:45] Chris Stockington. [0:27:47] On the capital expenditures, this period travels on page two. [0:27:55] Let's see, it's an expenditure out late at Star Corp for $490,000. [0:28:02] And what struck me is this is application seven, and I don't know if that's the seventh payment. [0:28:07] or some sort of tracking that we're doing. [0:28:10] My question is, even though we're on a fixed bid contract [0:28:15] with them, I hope that it's not all or nothing [0:28:20] and that these various stages, the application 7 here, [0:28:23] represent some sort of a step, a threshold, [0:28:27] and a check-off listing. [0:28:29] Could you kind of just give us a little assurance [0:28:31] that it's not a blind trust? [0:28:33] Yeah, absolutely. [0:28:34] In fact, what I'm going to do is I'm actually [0:28:35] turn the mic over to Mitch Humble. Mitch Humble is overseeing the construction [0:28:41] tracking of the project and he can kind of talk about the steps the staff goes [0:28:46] through to ensure that the work is being completed in that manner. So we [0:28:57] actually split the project up so Brian's got the police side of things and I'm [0:29:00] taking the city hall side of things so the contractor will submit their [0:29:06] request for payment. Very detailed pages and pages of stuff that's been happening [0:29:11] since the last one. Those are go first to the architect. You remember Hummel's [0:29:16] architect is working for us on this project. They go through every one of those [0:29:19] things line by line, make sure they're all appropriate. And then Hummel sends the [0:29:23] pay request with their, if they got questions they'll deal with those [0:29:28] before that comes to us even. And then we do basically the same thing Brian or I [0:29:32] will go down depending on which one of the projects is for. We'll go on each one [0:29:35] of those things and line by line and project or for the project and make sure that they're [0:29:42] all legitimate expenses and that's where we're at. [0:29:44] We have regular construction meetings with StarCorp and Hummels and those regular construction [0:29:49] meetings as well so we're aware of the status. [0:29:52] I'm walking through the projects pretty regularly. [0:29:55] I was there a half hour ago today, spending some time on city hall building so I'm pretty [0:30:02] much familiar with where they're at and what their request and payment for and so [0:30:05] they go through all kinds of checks and balances. I could do just a full of them. [0:30:08] I'm glad to hear that. That's what I suspect a lot of the public may not be [0:30:12] aware of that. I won't say check and balance, but $400,000 check is a big one. [0:30:18] You kind of got to go wait. To this point up to this point of our outlays to star [0:30:24] Heather Benany put you in terms of surprises. He had labor or material that [0:30:32] So we've found a few things that caused the [0:30:37] cause of the nature too, yeah. So the biggest one I can think of would be on the [0:30:41] City Hall project would be the asbestos stuff that they found on the skin of [0:30:46] that building that we didn't expect to be there and that causes us to have like [0:30:49] a, I want to say it was about a $60,000 increase in asbestos removal, but apart [0:30:55] from finding things that are just weird like that, they've been pretty well, pretty [0:31:01] well in line with what we've expected. [0:31:04] But we also have a contingency line item in the GMP that covers some of that stuff. [0:31:10] And there was a structural steel component of what we're doing right now, and where they're [0:31:17] putting those steel plates on the outside of the concrete, and they're drilling through [0:31:21] the concrete and bolting it on both sides so the steel is kind of beefing up the structure [0:31:26] of the building. [0:31:27] That's been another one that we found recently, [0:31:30] but when they're drilling those holes through, [0:31:33] sometimes they're hitting like steel rebar in the concrete [0:31:36] and they're having to come back [0:31:37] and it's taking a little bit more work than they expected. [0:31:39] That should have been predictable. [0:31:41] I knew that was real. [0:31:42] But where they drill the holes in the steel [0:31:45] versus where it lies up against the concrete [0:31:47] has been a little tricky for them at a few times. [0:31:51] That's caused a little bit of contingency use [0:31:52] on the City Hall project, [0:31:53] but for the most part, the City Hall Proctite [0:31:56] is right kind of right online where we want it to be, [0:31:59] where we expect it to be. [0:32:02] Any other comments or questions? [0:32:05] Sharon roll call vote. [0:32:10] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:32:11] Yes. [0:32:12] Nicky Boyd. [0:32:13] Yes. [0:32:14] Chris Talkington. [0:32:15] Yes. [0:32:16] Greg Lanting. [0:32:17] Yes. [0:32:18] Christopher Reed. [0:32:19] Yes. [0:32:19] Ruth Pierce. [0:32:20] Yes. [0:32:21] Motion passes six to zero. [0:32:25] Okay. [0:32:27] At this time then we'll turn it over for public input again. [0:32:30] if there's anybody who came in since we've started, [0:32:34] see a no one city manager's office. [0:32:39] Both Mitch and I do have a couple of items [0:32:41] that we want to not only share with the council, [0:32:45] but then also kind of use this opportunity [0:32:49] to share with the community as well. [0:32:52] The first one is, and it was on the consent calendar [0:32:59] on number five, but I wanna just take a minute [0:33:02] to talk about that on Tuesday, the 11th of April, [0:33:07] we are going to have a dual state of the city [0:33:13] that's going to begin at 11.30, [0:33:15] and that's going to take place inside of the Orpheum. [0:33:20] And then after the state of the city, [0:33:22] my understanding is the chamber is going to be providing [0:33:26] vouchers for different restaurants in the long downtown, [0:33:31] And that will be followed by 1230. [0:33:33] There's going to be a ground breaking [0:33:36] for the downtown urban renewal project [0:33:40] and that we will kick that project off. [0:33:43] I had an opportunity to talk to Nathan Murray [0:33:45] about the bids and as they're coming in [0:33:48] and we're really excited about where they're looking. [0:33:51] The bids at this point in time as they're kind of working [0:33:54] through their due diligence appeared to be under budget. [0:33:58] And we also believe that there are several local companies [0:34:04] who receive the opportunity to participate in the project [0:34:08] by having good and favorable low bids. [0:34:11] So we will have more information as this week goes. [0:34:16] I'll detail that in my weekly report to you with the hope [0:34:20] that on April 3 at a special urban renewal board meeting, [0:34:23] they will approve the GMP, they will move that forward. [0:34:27] And so then on the 11th, we'll have an official ground breaking ceremony. [0:34:31] And that really will be the kickoff to that project before you start, Mitch, Chris, [0:34:42] talking to Jan your projects and approved it was on the consent calendar. [0:34:47] Thank you. [0:34:54] Sorry about the glare on that. [0:34:57] I'm starting on the 1st of April. [0:35:01] So just occurred to me that that's April flu. [0:35:03] I hope this isn't a big joke. [0:35:04] But anyway, starting on the 1st of April, the National Recreation and Parks Association [0:35:12] is working in conjunction with Disney and all of their affiliates to do this meet me [0:35:17] at the park campaign. [0:35:19] And it's a nationwide campaign to kind of help people get out and, you know, recreate [0:35:25] and play, visit your city parks. [0:35:29] But the real reason why I wanted to share this with you is because there's also potential [0:35:34] for some money, some cash rewards. [0:35:37] So Disney and the National NRPA are handing out, [0:35:41] there's several of these $20,000 grants. [0:35:43] I want to say there's something 18 or 20 of them. [0:35:46] So residents can go take a selfie at these parks [0:35:51] at their favorite park. [0:35:52] They can hashtag post these things with the hashtag [0:35:54] meet me at the park or hashtag parky. [0:35:58] And you can post those things with where you're at [0:36:01] and the community that tends to be the most, you know, [0:36:04] those communities that have the most participation, [0:36:07] have the potential to win a grant of $20,000 [0:36:10] for park improvements at one of those city's parks. [0:36:13] And so we're kind of jumping in [0:36:15] and trying to get behind this project here. [0:36:17] Josh has got a big press release. [0:36:18] He's gonna release tomorrow in April. [0:36:21] He'll be following that up with social media attention [0:36:26] and trying to get the word out. [0:36:27] This, what I put up here is a little call a sticker, [0:36:32] kind of a page size sign sticker thing. [0:36:34] We're going to put up various parks around the city, [0:36:37] but kind of, you know, when you're out there using, [0:36:40] it's just showing Falls Park or walking at agar falls. [0:36:43] You can look at this and go take yourself at agar falls [0:36:48] and post it to Hashtag Parky. [0:36:51] And hopefully we can, at the very least, [0:36:54] get a lot of public press and excitement [0:36:57] about our city parks and maybe even get some money out of it. [0:37:03] Travis, can I let Chris talk to you first? [0:37:06] Okay, hi, Chris. [0:37:07] Great idea. [0:37:07] And so are you, but related to this, [0:37:11] is there a reason we don't collect money? [0:37:12] It's just shown falls on the weekend. [0:37:14] Is that some prohibition? [0:37:17] We have had people lined up a quarter mile [0:37:20] toward off the top of the rim to get down. [0:37:22] And we're missing a great deal of revenue. [0:37:25] So we have been collecting. [0:37:27] We started collecting, there was the first weekend, [0:37:32] what we did not, and then right after that, [0:37:36] probably the Monday or Tuesday, [0:37:39] after that first weekend, we began moving forward [0:37:42] and we've been collecting fees. [0:37:44] It has been, manned and operated the same typical times [0:37:47] that we would during the normal season, [0:37:50] and so that has been there. [0:37:53] And maybe, but we have been collecting the fees and certainly have it open. [0:38:03] Thank you. [0:38:04] This is a great destination with this high water and it's nationally known. [0:38:07] Yeah, and it's been spotlighted on the weather channel and many, many other places throughout [0:38:14] the entire country. [0:38:15] seeing lots of support and patrons coming down and just really taking a look at amazing water [0:38:27] here. One of the things that we will share is in our conversations and I passed this [0:38:32] along to the council, they are looking at removing nearly a million acre feet of water [0:38:38] out of the system to prepare for the snow melt. And a million acre feet is massive amount [0:38:45] of water, and so know that this is going to be going on for a long period of time. [0:38:51] They're looking at trying to drain that million through the end of April in anticipation of [0:38:57] the snow melt, and so we do have potentially several more beautiful weeks of falls and for [0:39:07] citizens to be able to take a look at. [0:39:09] Not only that, but I'd also say there's a great opportunity to take advantage of what's [0:39:14] at Auger Falls. [0:39:16] It does require a bit of a walk in, but Auger Falls right now is roaring probably as high [0:39:25] as it ever has, just like the Falls is, which is really cool. [0:39:31] Great, Lanting. [0:39:32] Well, just for information, we did start collecting early, typically in the past, but [0:39:38] collected until April 1st. We also, we have some need down there, some of the [0:39:46] pictures I've seen. I was going to get down there just morning. It was a little too [0:39:49] windy. Up the trail there has been some damage to the trail. It obviously we can [0:39:54] use these funds to make repairs and things along that line. And then on a [0:39:59] personal night, a couple weeks ago, even before it was really big, I mean it's [0:40:03] Now I drove down to, it depends on what it's called. [0:40:08] It's official name is Calderon Land, [0:40:10] a lot of people call Star Falls over by Murtaugh, [0:40:13] and that again requires a bit of a walk [0:40:16] to get from the parking area down to the actual falls, [0:40:20] but it's well named. [0:40:22] It looks like a roaring, boiling Calderon [0:40:26] where that water all comes together there, [0:40:28] and that's putting on a pretty good show, too. [0:40:30] I plan on, I haven't been down to social and falls yet, [0:40:32] I'm picking a morning, I get in or without the big crowds, [0:40:36] but also I understand it was single falls, [0:40:42] where it used to be good falls, [0:40:43] is also putting it on a pretty good show as well. [0:40:45] That's just a few miles to the east of Shoe's homefalls. [0:40:50] Thank you, Greg. [0:40:52] Travis? [0:40:53] So Mitch took a moment, [0:40:54] so Mitch did the good guy part about our parks, [0:40:58] and now I have to do the bad guy part about our parks. [0:41:01] And so our parks are probably some of the most amazing assets that we have in our community. [0:41:08] It's a great place to gather. [0:41:10] It's a great place for people to congregate. [0:41:14] And what we would ask is that as you have animals, we would ask that you would be respectful [0:41:21] of our parks and be respectful to all of those others who want to use them and just take a [0:41:27] minute and be prepared and if you're going to bring your animal please do two [0:41:31] things make sure they're always on a leash we do have leash laws and even [0:41:37] in our falls we think it's important that those animals are on leashes because [0:41:41] there are lots of mountain bikers and lots of people who are running and [0:41:46] utilizing those trails that you know a dog and a bike moving at a high rate of [0:41:52] speed are not a good combination for either and then the second is we would [0:41:56] ass that you clean up after your animal. There is unfortunately a large amount of dog [0:42:04] feces in our parks right now. We're going to spend quite a bit of time cleaning that up. [0:42:09] Our citizens can really help us out by just taking that few extra steps by carrying a garbage [0:42:15] bag with them and we supply them at several of our parks and just take that few extra [0:42:20] seconds and clean up after your dog and so that our assets truly do remain to the benefit [0:42:25] of the entire community. [0:42:26] Thank you. [0:42:27] Mickey Boyd. [0:42:28] Thank you, Travis. [0:42:29] I didn't know how I was going to bring this up in this particular meeting, but now I can. [0:42:37] Everybody can help. [0:42:39] All the parks have containers where you can stuff your grocery bags, your vegetable bags, [0:42:44] you know, the ones that don't recycle. [0:42:47] They can be reused. [0:42:48] In the back of the room, there's a blue canvas box, and if you open it up, you can shove all [0:42:54] the bags in there you want, and then I'll take them over to Parks and Rec and make sure that [0:43:00] they can get distributed, but those things don't need to go to the landfill and we could [0:43:04] really use them and they'll help keep our parks clean, so thank you very much for helping. [0:43:09] Thank you, Nikki. [0:43:11] I would, oh Mitch, I'm sorry. [0:43:14] I had one more, but you can come back to me if you wanted to hear us first. [0:43:18] This is on the doggies in the park again. [0:43:21] I know that we've talked about it before but again last week I was at First Federal Park [0:43:27] and there were big black labs out on the turf with the kids and one of them went after one [0:43:32] of my three year old grandchildren and I don't know what we can do with that park but that [0:43:36] is not a park for animals and I just I don't want to be offensive to anybody but when you [0:43:42] have kids with special needs out there and large dogs running around it is not a mix and I [0:43:48] I just really think it's something we need to get a handle on before a child is injured. [0:43:53] So I don't know if, Nikki, if you want to take that back to Parks and React, but that park [0:43:59] especially just has too many little ones. [0:44:01] So I'll get off my soapbox. [0:44:03] And that's one of the parks that needs to be cleaned up a little bit too, particularly. [0:44:11] So the other item I have for you, if you will all remember back in December, we talked about [0:44:18] the automatic increase for impact fees. [0:44:21] And at the time, well, let me be reminded a little bit [0:44:24] because a couple of you may not be totally familiar [0:44:25] with this, maybe Chris. [0:44:28] In our impact fee program, we have a clause in the program [0:44:31] where we automatically increase the cost of our impact fee [0:44:34] projects by an amount equal to the municipal cost index [0:44:38] every year on January 1st. [0:44:41] American City and counties who publishes the MCI [0:44:44] is usually a few months behind. [0:44:46] And so in December, when we came and talked to you about, [0:44:49] should we allow that increase to occur, [0:44:52] best knowledge we had at the time was about a .8, .86, [0:44:56] if I want to be, I'm trying to remember that exactly, [0:44:59] about a .8% increase. [0:45:01] And at the time, we said, well, that's, yeah, [0:45:03] let's go ahead and let that go. [0:45:05] This week, we actually learned the January 1st MCI [0:45:08] was 3.46. [0:45:10] So there was a significant increase [0:45:12] between August and December in the MCI. [0:45:15] And so my question is, is there something that the council [0:45:18] would like us to do? [0:45:19] Do we want to come back and have that conversation again? [0:45:22] Or do we want to go ahead and implement the new costs [0:45:25] with the 0.3.46% cost increase? [0:45:29] I don't know if that would have made a difference [0:45:30] in our conversation in December or not. [0:45:33] I can tell you that the MCI is a reflection [0:45:35] of the cost of construction. [0:45:39] And so our costs are going up. [0:45:41] And so it makes some sense to it. [0:45:43] I mean, that's the whole justification [0:45:44] for the automatic increase anyway. [0:45:46] But if you would like us to, we can come back [0:45:48] and we can talk about that again [0:45:49] in a future meeting, schedule a conversation [0:45:51] and a decision where we can have folks involved. [0:45:55] Well, I'll just say, oh yeah, I just wanna take one second [0:45:59] so that people listening can understand [0:46:02] what the municipal cost index is. [0:46:04] So most people might be very familiar [0:46:05] with the consumer price index [0:46:07] and the consumer price index is going to be a measure [0:46:11] inflation. How much buying power does your dollar have on certain goods from one point [0:46:18] in time to another point in time? The municipal cost index is the exact same thing but it's [0:46:23] used by cities because it looks at our bushel of goods that we will typically buy and applies [0:46:29] a multiplier to those. And so it's going to be heavy on diesel fuel, it's going to be [0:46:34] heavy on asphalt, it's going to be heavy on all of those things that we are typically large [0:46:40] consumers of, and so when you're looking at concrete pricing, you're looking at labor, [0:46:45] you're looking at the price of asphalt, the price of pipe, those are going to be included [0:46:50] in our cost indexes that are going to help determine what that looks like moving forward. [0:46:56] So just so that individuals understand what is a municipal cost index and why do we use [0:47:02] it? [0:47:03] Thank you. [0:47:04] Chris? [0:47:05] will be absorbing more cost because of the MCI. [0:47:09] But as the LA is in the MPAC fee committee, [0:47:13] I would like to recommend a lesser amount for this reason. [0:47:17] We've been at 1% or less now for two or three years, [0:47:22] multiple anyway, yeah. [0:47:24] I just think that I think the city [0:47:28] can absorb a little bit of that cost this year. [0:47:30] I think it's a little bit unconscionable, [0:47:32] I'm not doubting the figures at all to pass on a tripling plus of the rate, and I would [0:47:39] like to suggest that we double it from 1% to 2% this year. [0:47:44] And I'd open it up for any questions, but I'd put that in the form of the motion. [0:47:49] I think we need to have it on an agenda item before we do that. [0:47:53] Yes, so the purpose of Mitch's request tonight was to say, if you're good with the 3.6%, [0:47:59] 3.46% increase, there's no action that the Council needs to take because the resolution [0:48:05] says you will do this. [0:48:08] Anything different is kind of backwards. [0:48:11] Anything different would require the Council to include that. [0:48:13] We would bring a resolution forward that would have the Council intentionally say that we [0:48:19] choose to do a cost adjustment this year of blank percent. [0:48:25] And so if that is of interest to the Council, we can prepare that resolution and then we [0:48:29] we can bring that forward for your review. [0:48:34] Just to help you understand what 3.46% actually means, [0:48:40] the cost of an impact fee on a new home is right now, [0:48:44] is 1994, $1,994, 3.46% increase, [0:48:50] brings that to $2,062,63, so it's essentially [0:48:55] So it's essentially a $69 increase to the cost of an impact fee for a single family home. [0:49:03] So again, what Travis said is accurate, if we're okay with that increase, we're moving [0:49:08] on, we're increasing. [0:49:09] If you want us to do something different, we'll schedule a meaning where we can actually [0:49:14] have a resolution prepared and something to act on. [0:49:20] So has anyone been charged the new fee yet or when does it go into effect? [0:49:25] We wait until we get the new MCI figure, which is about now, and then typically in the past, [0:49:31] last year there was no increase because the MCI was negative. [0:49:34] The year before that, we was like 1.1, 1.4%, and it was about this time of year. [0:49:39] We just kicked in the new fees, and I kind of held off on that this time. [0:49:44] Thank you. [0:49:45] Ruth Pierce? [0:49:46] So my concern, if we don't take the full increase, I mean, again, we're talking 70 bucks, is what [0:49:54] What are we going to do next year? [0:49:56] Because I don't think, given what's going on, that we're going to see a decrease or slow [0:50:01] down. [0:50:02] And so if we just take 2% and we're behind almost another 2% and then it's 3.5% again [0:50:09] next year, then we're behind 5.5%. [0:50:13] I think we need to keep up with the costs personally. [0:50:17] Chris Reed? [0:50:20] I would echo what Ruth said. [0:50:23] I think that when you tie it to an index, you follow the index, whether it's up or down, and right now it's up significantly, but we stick with it. [0:50:33] There's a lot of industries that do that, the banking industry does that, and we stick with that rate. [0:50:38] So I say we stick with it. [0:50:41] Thank you, Mickey Boyd. [0:50:42] And those are originally paid, those impact fees are originally paid by the builders. [0:50:50] And then, ultimately, it's passed on to the consumer. [0:50:55] Sure. [0:50:56] So that's $69 a house. [0:50:59] OK. [0:51:01] And how do you feel about that? [0:51:03] Do you want him to bring it back? [0:51:03] Are you OK with letting it ride? [0:51:05] I think we follow the index. [0:51:09] We agreed. [0:51:10] I would say the majority has spoken, [0:51:12] and they would like to just let it ride. [0:51:14] Still like that, am I? [0:51:15] Go ahead. [0:51:16] OK, Chris. [0:51:17] The MCI is a national figure, is it not? [0:51:21] Has there been any breakdown on a regional basis [0:51:25] to know how we compare to other parts of the country? [0:51:29] No, unfortunately, where you look [0:51:31] at the Western version of the consumer price index, [0:51:37] the MCI has just a standard version. [0:51:40] It doesn't offer multiple variations [0:51:43] based upon a geographic location. [0:51:46] So we can make an assumption that could be higher [0:51:48] than lower than the average? [0:51:51] either. Yes, it might be 10 or [0:51:53] about me to. I'll go on record as [0:51:56] supporting the resolution to bring [0:51:58] it before the council for a lesser [0:52:00] amount. Did you get that Sharon? [0:52:03] Thank you. Any other comments from [0:52:05] the council? Is there anything else [0:52:09] from your office Travis? Anything [0:52:12] from the City Council on reports [0:52:15] from committee meetings? I see no [0:52:20] one weighing in. So we will go ahead [0:52:22] ahead and move on to our public hearings. [0:52:25] I'm going to flip pages here. [0:52:38] Our first public hearing tonight is by an applicant, [0:52:41] Lydine Dane, to request a zoning district change [0:52:46] and zoning map amendment from R2 to Rb for property located [0:52:50] at 838 Filer Avenue. [0:52:54] And is Lydine here? [0:52:57] Jonathan, you're going to help us out? [0:53:00] The Dean's out of the country, so she sent somebody in her place to do a quick overview of that. [0:53:03] Okay, thank you. If you wouldn't mind introducing yourself for the council. [0:53:07] My name is Katie Kaufman. The Dean is my mother and she's currently out of the country, so I told her I [0:53:13] would come and speak to the council. We are looking to have her current home re-zoned from, [0:53:20] you'll have to forgive me, from the R2 to the RB, for the property that's located at 838 Filer [0:53:26] Avenue. For those of you that aren't familiar with the location of the property, it's set [0:53:32] three doors off of Blue Lakes Boulevard, just Kitty Corner from the Starbucks and that [0:53:39] Shucksville Riley that's on the corner there on Blue Lakes and Filer Avenue. Everything [0:53:47] currently surrounding that area is either rentals or small business accountants, a lawyer's office, and things like that, she is looking to sell the house and is hoping to go through the rezoning process just to open up some extra options for selling for somebody that might want to come in and start a smaller business in that location. [0:54:14] Thank you very much. We'll go ahead and have Jonathan come present the city's [0:54:24] portion of that application now. Vice mayor and members of the Council on the [0:54:29] history on the property briefly it's the westernmost portion of the lot 20 of the [0:54:35] Garden Home subdivision that was recorded in June of 1919. It's a very old [0:54:40] subdivision not the original but pretty old. The house originally came in the [0:54:45] Pope directories in 1957, and the county parcels have it as it dates back to 1960s [0:54:51] when the house was approximately built. The owners had it since at least 1994. [0:54:56] The map up on the screen is the current zoning map. Her lot is adjacent to what is [0:55:04] a business where like an office to the east, and then the O'Reilly is the one on [0:55:09] the corner of Blue Lakes and Filer. It's one of the few remaining homes in the area [0:55:15] that the face is filer that close to bootlegs. Most of them don't face, they face Lincoln or they face [0:55:20] inwards these present streets. So there's others on filer that we anticipate will come through the [0:55:25] same process for some similar. This might be one of those first ones. The request to zone it to Rb [0:55:32] from R2 will change it to more of a business type. Rb stands for residential business. Rb also has [0:55:39] a lot of protections for neighboring landowners as far as keeping the residential character. [0:55:44] And we encourage the reuse of the building, not a demolition of it, but a reuse into something [0:55:49] else. [0:55:51] Most likely it will either remain as kind of a residential home as somebody will buy in the [0:55:55] future or it could be purchased with other properties and put together onto a larger project. [0:56:01] The part is kind of small for an RB, but an office could work with some minimal parking requirements. [0:56:09] So that's kind of what we're going to. [0:56:12] comprehensive plan the newly adopted one shows the future land use map here [0:56:21] it's kind of difficult the corridor along blue lakes is listed as mixed use the [0:56:29] neighborhood commercial kind of follows filer Avenue and then the remaining [0:56:34] oranges what we're calling town neighborhood the future land use map [0:56:38] although there are lines up there I'm not meant to be a lot specific so this [0:56:43] This could be a multitude of types. [0:56:46] RB seems to fit the mixed use, [0:56:48] neighborhood, commercial, where neighborhoods [0:56:51] butt up against those businesses or possible businesses. [0:56:54] It's a good transition from houses [0:56:57] that people still live into a commercial [0:56:59] or an office type use. [0:57:02] In reviewing the request for zoning district change [0:57:04] and zoning map amendment, two main tasks. [0:57:07] One is to determine whether the request [0:57:10] is in conformance with the comprehensive plan [0:57:12] the future land use map. Number two is to evaluate the request to determine the [0:57:16] extent nature of the amendment requested. Both those things are met according to [0:57:21] staff's view of it. Also on February 28th 2017 the Planning and Zoning Commission [0:57:28] held a public hearing. Upon conclusion of the public hearing and discussion there's [0:57:32] a motion to recommend approval of the request as presented with staff [0:57:35] recommendations. It was seconded in all members vote. All members present voted [0:57:39] in favor of the motion and staff concurs with the commission's recommendation. [0:57:44] That's all. [0:57:45] Thank you. [0:57:46] Is there any questions for the applicant or Jonathan at this time? [0:57:51] We'll go ahead and open up the public hearing on this item. [0:57:55] If there's anyone in the audience who would like to speak to this issue, now is your opportunity? [0:58:04] See no one. [0:58:05] We will go ahead and close the public hearing and turn it over to the Council for discussion [0:58:10] or wishes. [0:58:11] Nikki Boyd. [0:58:12] Well, I love that this is a perfect example of what I think that we want there. [0:58:19] We're using our future land use map. [0:58:21] I think it's a really good thing. [0:58:25] The property is really well situated for such a thing like this and I would be very much [0:58:30] in favor. [0:58:31] Do you want to make a motion? [0:58:32] Yeah, you didn't have a question or anything? [0:58:35] No. [0:58:36] Okay. [0:58:37] Make a motion. [0:58:41] And I move that we grant the request for a zoning district change and zoning map amendment [0:58:47] from R2 to Rb for property located at 838 Filer Avenue application 2838. [0:58:55] Second. [0:58:59] We have a motion from Nikki Boyd, seconded by Ruth Pierce to accept the request for the [0:59:04] zoning district change and map amendment. [0:59:06] Is there any discussion by the council? [0:59:09] Seeing none, Sharon, roll call vote please. [0:59:13] Nikki Boyd? [0:59:14] Yes, Chris talking to yes, Greg Lanting. Yes, Christopher Reed. Yes, yes, yes, Suzanne Hopkins. Yes, motion passes six to zero. [0:59:24] Tell your mom we wish her luck on selling her property. [0:59:27] Okay, public hearing number two. [0:59:33] We have a request for a zoning district change and zoning map amendment from our four to our four pro for a lot 22 block four of the golden rule subdivision on property located. [0:59:45] property located at 415 Addison Avenue. And I show Lynn Dunlap as the applicant tonight. [0:59:56] Welcome in. Please go ahead and introduce yourself and... [1:00:01] My name is Lynn Dunlap. I own the property involved. My understanding of the property is I purchased it about 20 years ago. [1:00:12] But at any rate, the property was built up. My understanding is originally there were three [1:00:16] lots, two facing Addison and one on the backside Jackson. [1:00:25] The original builder before Savernath, he built the two lots on the Addison side, which [1:00:33] is the current white L-shaped building in the parking lot in front. [1:00:38] He also owned the lot behind. [1:00:40] As the owner of the lot behind, he waved the requirement of a fence regarding a commercial [1:00:47] outlet. [1:00:48] And then ultimately he leveled the house there and put in a parking lot. [1:00:55] Talking with Royce, he advised me that he was certain that he had requested a zoning change [1:00:59] at that time. [1:01:00] The city was well aware that apparently the house is set on the empty lot. [1:01:07] The city went in, dug down, and put a permanent cap on the sewer line to that residence. [1:01:13] The city advised him what grade he had to have from the alley all the way out to Jackson. [1:01:19] The city also advised him he had to put a small gutter handy little culvert under the sidewalk. [1:01:25] And his statement was, the city's somebody knew he was doing it, he has no idea why his [1:01:30] only change was not done at the time. [1:01:33] The, which was one had been, I wish he had been. [1:01:37] The bottom line to it is while we're trying to do it this stage is simply bring the land [1:01:41] and conform us with your map. [1:01:45] Thank you very much. [1:01:46] Are there any questions for the applicant? [1:01:47] Seeing none, we will go ahead and let Jonathan update us on the city side. [1:01:53] Okay. [1:01:54] So the history on this one, it's part of the Golden Rule Subdivisions Record in 1909. [1:02:01] Zoning designation of our four were set in 1981. [1:02:04] record to show the appraisal in 1960 and also between 1588 the residences took [1:02:11] place and the businesses kind of transitioned. Really what we're doing and [1:02:16] Mr. Dunlap summarized it very well. We have a land use of a parking lot [1:02:21] accessory to an office that's within the residential zoning district. It's been [1:02:26] that way for quite some time we can tell that point but we don't have a record of [1:02:30] it actually being zoned for professional office. So we're simply adding the [1:02:34] professional office overlaid to this one lot to the north basically bringing the [1:02:38] parking lot into compliance with the accessory use of that office. So the two [1:02:44] things to make a positive recommendation the Commission looked at to request and [1:02:48] conformance of the comprehensive plan. Also the extent to nature of changing the [1:02:52] zoning of this property Dar 4 Pro would allow land development that would be [1:02:56] compatible with and not to track from surrounding area. The major land use map [1:03:05] place neighborhood commercial along Addison Avenue. Again, it's not a defined line. [1:03:12] Case by case basis is it compatible with what's north of it, so everything along [1:03:17] Addison has that neighborhood commercial. Everything south of it is [1:03:20] downtown or a high-density residential commercial type mix. So it is [1:03:25] conformance with the comprehensive plan if this body deems it so, as well as the [1:03:32] nature of the business being compatible. [1:03:35] On February 28th, the commission held a public hearing [1:03:38] upon conclusion. [1:03:41] On the presentations, the commission had no further questions [1:03:43] or clarifications. [1:03:44] There was no public comment. [1:03:46] There was a motion and a second. [1:03:48] And everybody, all members present voted in favor of a motion. [1:03:52] And staff concurs with the commission's recommendation. [1:03:55] Thank you. [1:03:56] Are there any questions for Jonathan at this time? [1:03:59] I don't see any. [1:04:00] At this time we will open the public carrying [1:04:03] on this zoning map amendment. [1:04:05] Is there anyone in the audience [1:04:07] that would like to speak to this request tonight? [1:04:11] See no one, we will close the public carrying [1:04:13] and turn it over to the council for discussion. [1:04:16] Chris talking to. [1:04:17] I would move to approve the zoning district change [1:04:20] and map amendment from R4 to R4 Pro. [1:04:23] Block 22, Block 4, the Golden Rule subdivision [1:04:26] located north and east of the intersection of Addison Avenue [1:04:29] and Jackson Street. [1:04:30] also known as 415 Jackson Street. [1:04:34] 415 Addison Avenue. [1:04:37] Correct? [1:04:40] Second. [1:04:44] We have a motion from Chris Talking did seconded by Ruth Pierce [1:04:48] to accept the request for the zoning district change and zoning [1:04:51] map amendment from R4 to R4 Pro, Greg Lanting. [1:04:56] Well, one of the nice things about being on council [1:04:58] is you learned something every week. [1:04:59] I learned that that whole subdivision is called Golden Rule. [1:05:02] I didn't know that. [1:05:04] I had a unique game. [1:05:08] Any other discussion or questions from the council? [1:05:11] Sharon Roll call vote please. [1:05:13] Chris Stockington. [1:05:14] Yes. [1:05:15] Greg Lanthine. [1:05:16] Yes. [1:05:17] Christopher Reed. [1:05:17] Yes. [1:05:18] Ruth Pierce. [1:05:19] Yes. [1:05:19] Suzanne Hawkins. [1:05:20] Yes. [1:05:21] Nikki Boyd. [1:05:22] Yes. [1:05:22] Motion passes six to zero. [1:05:26] Thank you very much. [1:05:28] OK. [1:05:30] And public hearing number three. [1:05:36] We have a, oh, I'm sorry, Chris. [1:05:38] I need to recuse myself from this public hearing [1:05:40] to my relationship with some of the applicants. [1:05:43] Thank you very much. [1:05:49] At this time we will hear the request for an annexation with the zoning district change [1:05:53] and zoning map amendment from R4 CRO AOL to M1 CRO ZDA for approximately 7.5 acres to [1:06:05] allow a storage unit rental facility, truck rentals, truck rental display pads and designated [1:06:12] outdoor storage yards for automobiles, pickups, and RVs for property located at 403 Grand [1:06:18] View Drive and I show Greg Olson. So if you would like to go ahead and introduce yourself [1:06:25] and take it, we'll let you go from there. [1:06:27] Vice Mayor, thank you. Council members, my name is Scott Allen and I work at JUB engineers. [1:06:32] I'll be speaking on behalf of Greg. Mr. Olson is in the audience. So if you have questions, [1:06:37] well you can direct them to me or Greg. [1:06:40] Greg is one of the members that [1:06:43] own the Meany Storage Building which is... [1:06:52] There. [1:06:53] This is the point of that. [1:06:55] So the property in question is this dash property right now. [1:07:13] This is the property you'll grant you [1:07:15] drive in the year, which unfortunately times have changed [1:07:19] and those items are going out. [1:07:22] Mr. Olson and his partners own the Muni storage facility and when the grant you came available to purchase, they went ahead and purchased it. [1:07:31] So tonight we're asking under a recommendation from planning and zoning to go ahead and annex this property and from the current zoning to an M1, [1:07:43] We have supplied a ZDA for this or a ZDA agreement and draft form for your review. [1:07:53] City staff has reviewed that and Jonathan can speak on that here in a second. [1:07:58] The surrounding uses, we have a pasture to the west. [1:08:02] We have an existing trailer part to the northwest. [1:08:05] Jubilee house sits here and this is a religious facility. [1:08:09] Of course, we have the Muni storage commercial buildings in this area, and then we have the [1:08:14] open space rocker Canyon, and then the municipal golf course to the east. [1:08:20] This isn't compliance and conformance to the recently adopted comprehensive plan. [1:08:28] We have concurred in the ZDA and all the documentation that we've supplied that these buildings will [1:08:34] be very similar to the Muni storage. [1:08:36] will be just an expansion of that. They will be utilized for RV storage, the [1:08:42] buildings along Grandview. They will actually be utilized in a similar fashion [1:08:46] to the concrete tilt up buildings here. These will also be concrete tilt up so [1:08:51] it'll be very consistent in not only visual but also the use. As we move back [1:08:55] into the center of the property, then we get into the enclosed or open [1:09:00] building for RV storage. There was some questions of P&Z along the far east side. If there's [1:09:06] any buildings there, the answer to that is no. That will be just outdoor storage facilities. [1:09:11] We have supplied a site map. We have supplied a site map that shows just this area right [1:09:21] here will be utilized for outdoor vehicle storage. Two weeks ago I was golfing at Munion. One [1:09:28] One thing you can see is the screen right now, about half of the screen height you can see [1:09:33] from over there, but other than that, because of the foliage alone, rock, creek, and this [1:09:37] lateral that runs through here, most of it is very well screened just by the natural [1:09:42] foliage. [1:09:43] And there are gregs probably. [1:09:44] I don't know if you call them that way. [1:09:47] No more than four times. [1:09:49] But if you're out there, you can actually see it. [1:09:53] So this is a use that is, like I say, it's just an expansion that exists in use there. [1:10:00] By matching up the architectural features from the existing storage facility, this one [1:10:05] is going to be very consistent. [1:10:08] There is a lack of water or irrigation water in this area. [1:10:12] So we have proposed extra scape, or zero scape along the front versus the lawn scape, [1:10:17] like the original Meanie story chads. [1:10:19] We have supplied a completed landscape plan. [1:10:24] We will be using the bottom water until set time that PI [1:10:27] water is available. [1:10:29] And that's the same as the beauty storage that you're using [1:10:31] right now. [1:10:32] If that system does have enough capacity at present time [1:10:35] with the existing beauty storage, we'll just tie into it, [1:10:37] use it for this, because it's a lobby of dream system. [1:10:41] I think I'll stop at that point, let Jonathan add to [1:10:44] anything we'll be here to answer any questions we have. [1:10:47] Thank you very much. [1:10:54] I think Vice Mayor and the members of the council, [1:10:57] this one's gonna be a little longer [1:10:58] than the last few reports, [1:10:59] as we have to talk about more items. [1:11:01] Grandview Theater, 1952 to 2013 is when it operated, [1:11:05] from what we can understand. [1:11:08] Zoning was in place in 1981, [1:11:11] and the mini storage came in 2007, [1:11:14] and the owner recently purchased the other, [1:11:17] the Grandview Theater in about 2016. [1:11:20] Since this is a ZBA, there's a few things [1:11:23] They have to provide, has to conform to all sections of Title 10, unless it's specifically [1:11:29] addressed within the written zoning development agreement, meaning it has to meet the code sections [1:11:34] that are in our currently written code, if they want to vary from that code, they write [1:11:38] it in a document. [1:11:40] So whatever you see in the document would be a variation from our base zoning code. [1:11:44] I'm going to go through those one at a time, kind of explain a couple of them what they're [1:11:49] going to be doing. [1:11:52] the M-1, like manufacturing district, that's the base zoning code they want to put on the [1:11:59] property. It allows through a special use permit automobile and recreational vehicle storage [1:12:04] rental. The applicant has requested storage of automobiles and recreational vehicles to [1:12:09] be outright permitted, as well as 24-hour operation of the facility with an office, which is [1:12:15] kind of a secondary use. So the base code doesn't outright permit the storage of those [1:12:20] things so they're asking that to be a permitted use outright. So that would be a [1:12:24] variation from our base code from the M1 zone. The canyon rim overlay along Rock [1:12:30] Creek is a 200 feet from the canyon rim. The building setbacks 100 feet from the [1:12:34] designated canyon rim. The base code does not permit storage in a rental facility [1:12:39] or automobile RV storage areas. Again they're requesting that those uses or [1:12:44] land use is permitted within that zone for that area. 1079, the filling of [1:12:51] canyons. The filling of canyons is prohibited and the special use permit [1:12:55] required for filling with thin 100 feet of the canyon rims. They're asking for the [1:12:59] special use permit requirement to be waived for this project, essentially [1:13:02] reviewing it here tonight. Specifically, they are showing plans to fill an area in [1:13:07] order to gain some flat surface for vehicle and RV storage. They're also [1:13:11] looking to use fill to design a stormwater facility with an 100 feet of the canyon rim. [1:13:21] This area in here that designated the 100 foot mark as comes to here. [1:13:26] So anything in this area that would be filling parts of and this is where it gets tricky [1:13:33] as far as if it's designated canyon rim or not. [1:13:38] Scott alluded to a lateral. [1:13:39] There's a irrigation lateral that comes down here. [1:13:43] What point does that lateral become rot-creed canyon as it flows into rot-creed canyon? [1:13:49] We believe it's somewhere in this vicinity, not a specific point, but there's somewhere [1:13:55] in this vicinity that it changes into the canyon rim, whether or not it's a lateral [1:14:02] canyon or setback. [1:14:03] That's one of the discussions. [1:14:05] We don't feel like filling in that area is actual filling of rot-creed canyon, or at [1:14:11] least it's not a large portion of it. [1:14:13] So a minor field to get a flat surface is not something we are intensely worried about. [1:14:19] So just a little bit of background on the filling the canyon. [1:14:22] But we put it in there to be safe. [1:14:24] They want to basically wave that special use permit process. [1:14:30] As part of this, they are going to be. [1:14:32] Jonathan, I'm going to interrupt you real quick. [1:14:34] Chris talking to you. [1:14:35] He may answer this all the way in a minute. [1:14:36] Okay. [1:14:37] I was moving on to annexation so. [1:14:40] Go ahead. [1:14:41] P and Z though didn't choose to attach conditions [1:14:44] allowed under the ZDA. [1:14:46] That's correct. [1:14:47] They did not specifically target that item. [1:14:49] Thank you. [1:14:51] This is outside city limits. [1:14:53] So part of this is an annexation as well. [1:14:55] So we're reviewing the zoning request [1:14:57] in conjunction with that annexation. [1:15:00] Zoning is basically the ZDA. [1:15:02] As part of the annexation, the role [1:15:05] is to make a recommendation to the city council [1:15:08] on the proposed zoning designation [1:15:10] and the master development plan. [1:15:13] Upon receipt of the commission's recommendation and the development plan the city council holds the public hearing what you're doing tonight [1:15:18] And then the master development plan has presented and subject to any recommended conditions [1:15:24] The newly adopted comprehensive plan identifies this area as industrial [1:15:30] employment slash flex and [1:15:32] Natural area the proposed rezone of the property complies with the 2016 future landies map in terms of [1:15:39] of the general area being flexed. [1:15:41] The actual line, again, is not specific to lot lines. [1:15:45] It is determined by this body where those lines officially [1:15:49] land when they come in for a reason. [1:15:53] However, that 2016 plan also has a concern [1:15:57] throughout the document several times [1:15:59] that need to protect the canyon rim. [1:16:02] And what appears to be a possible conflict [1:16:04] with the plan the applicant is showing [1:16:05] a future stormwater facility [1:16:07] in the automobile recreation vehicle store charge [1:16:10] constructed within the feet of what could be considered part [1:16:14] of the canyon rim if we take that lateral into consideration [1:16:17] to something we just identified as a possible issue. [1:16:20] There's no city code prohibiting the construction [1:16:23] of the stormwater facility near the rim [1:16:27] and the plan is not a directly enforceable document [1:16:30] talking about the comprehensive plan. [1:16:33] It's just saying we want to protect our rims [1:16:35] and the lateral is near the rim. [1:16:37] When reviewing the applications is best, [1:16:40] practice to examine the surrounding area [1:16:42] to ensure good transition between among different land uses. [1:16:45] The area to the south is currently [1:16:47] undenoperated by the applicant. [1:16:50] This request is an expansion of that facility. [1:16:52] In the end, it will look like one large facility. [1:16:55] It would be appropriate to place some conditions [1:16:57] on that make the transition between the property seamless. [1:17:00] Land-skipping along ground view can and should [1:17:03] be of similar depth and quality to be consistent [1:17:06] along this entire frontage. [1:17:08] The applicant currently has fencing on the south property [1:17:10] that includes some screening material. [1:17:11] It may be appropriate to have this new area match [1:17:13] that same screening fence. [1:17:16] There's a few other items within the document that pertain [1:17:19] to and depart from city development requirements. [1:17:22] And they're enumerated A, we'll start with B. [1:17:26] That's because it's under written commitment section number two. [1:17:29] I think actually was answered with the P and Z. [1:17:33] It says a vehicle storage structure shall be permitted [1:17:35] to be fully enclosed or constructed with only a roof. [1:17:39] Staff's not concerned about that. [1:17:40] What they're really talking about was constructing these [1:17:43] as three-sided buildings so you could pull underneath them. [1:17:47] Our worry is they were gonna construct one here. [1:17:49] That was clarified on the PNC item. [1:17:51] They won't be building anything. [1:17:53] No building will be built in this area. [1:17:56] B talked about that DU is your escape landscape [1:17:59] being shall be permitted. [1:18:01] We concur with the use of zero escaping. [1:18:04] staff consistently encourages Euroscape landscaping, [1:18:07] drop tolerant ground covering trees. [1:18:10] It is consistent with cover requirements, [1:18:11] and you can agree the depth of landscaping [1:18:14] should be or would be consistent with this property [1:18:16] to the south. [1:18:17] The verbiage has been added to this ZDA, [1:18:20] so you'd see that addition that was different [1:18:22] from the Planning and Zoning Commission. [1:18:24] And a master landscape plan is required for the ZDA. [1:18:29] F was an irrigation for water, [1:18:31] irrigation water for plants shall be provided [1:18:34] the city of the water system. The engineering department does not support bypassing current [1:18:39] city code requirements for irrigation water and the development process involved with the [1:18:43] building permit approval. We believe the applicant shall proceed through the process for irrigation [1:18:48] water as required within the city code. We have a process if irrigation water is absolutely [1:18:53] not obtainable and we wish they go through that process already currently set up. We [1:18:57] don't want to create a new one. So we've agreed to that point with them on going through whatever [1:19:02] that process looks like with the engineering department at the time of building permits [1:19:06] in middle. [1:19:08] Chris, I might be a little confused on this, but if I understood, is going to be zero escaping [1:19:13] until the non-potable water is provided? [1:19:18] Well, so even with zero escaping, you need a little bit of water to start some of that [1:19:21] plants and some of them even take some water. [1:19:24] What we're saying is if there's currently there's no irrigation system permitted or in the area, [1:19:32] You have no, like, PI in the area. [1:19:35] They were putting in the document that they were going to use city's potable water and [1:19:38] that that should be allowable within the ZDA document. [1:19:42] We, staff said, you don't like that condition or putting that condition upon ourselves that [1:19:47] we have to give you potable water. [1:19:49] There's another system or a process by which you go through if PI is not permitted or isn't [1:19:55] in the area. [1:19:56] Thank you. [1:19:57] The security fencing without view obscuring slats, some of the requests to rezone this [1:20:06] does require side obscuring fence per 10, 11, 3 between any residential use and the trade [1:20:12] or manufacturing use with the Jubilee house to the north. [1:20:19] It's a residential district. [1:20:20] So there's going to be a requirement for screening. [1:20:22] We believe that should still exist between those two properties, not between the two [1:20:26] of themselves, their properties, but in other location we believe that should still exist. [1:20:32] On February 28th, the Commission held a public hearing. [1:20:34] There were two citizens who spoke on this request. [1:20:36] They both expressed concerns with the current use of the property and used as vehicle RV [1:20:40] and semi-storage of the property prior to approval. [1:20:43] They also expressed concerns with the proposed industrial use impacting the development, the [1:20:48] developed and undeveloped residential neighborhoods. [1:20:53] Part of the applicant's response stated that the city had given permission for the storage, [1:20:59] which is true as far as building the remaining portion of their property they needed some place [1:21:04] to put vehicles that they were currently storing to create the space to build the building they [1:21:10] have. [1:21:11] So we, since he owned this property, this is basically a staging area for the construction [1:21:16] happening on this other portion of their property. [1:21:19] So there are vehicles out there, they need somewhere to put them since they own the property. [1:21:24] We allow them to put them there on a temporary basis as a part of the construction plan. [1:21:31] Upon conclusion of the public hearing and deliberations, there was a motion and a second [1:21:35] and all members present voted in favor of the motion and there are eight conditions. [1:21:41] Subject number one, subject to site plan amendments as required by building engineering, fire, [1:21:44] and zoning officials to comply with applicable city codes and standards. [1:21:50] Number two, subject to right-of-way dedication for that portion of Grandview, fronting this [1:21:53] project, occurring prior to issuance of any building permit and the width of the right-of-way [1:21:57] to be determined by the city engineer. [1:22:00] Number three, subject to no building, recovered area being constructed within the outdoor storage [1:22:03] area, identify the master development plan. [1:22:05] That would be this eastern portion over here. [1:22:09] Number four, subject to removal of section two dash F, irrigation water by a pondable water [1:22:14] system from the ZDA document. [1:22:16] Number five, subject to replacement of Section 2H, [1:22:19] replacement of fill with appropriate language asking for [1:22:21] concession to City Code 1079. [1:22:24] Said language to be determined by staff. [1:22:26] The current document doesn't address it properly, [1:22:29] so we're gonna address it within the code section [1:22:31] there needs to be. [1:22:33] Number six is subject to a master landscape plan [1:22:35] consistent with the uni-storage PUD. [1:22:38] And as per the master development plan submitted [1:22:40] and approved by staff prior to a recordation of the DDA. [1:22:43] Number seven, subject to a master lighting plan. [1:22:46] approved by staff, a number eight subject to a master sign plan, submitted and approved [1:22:50] by staff. [1:22:52] I believe that concludes the report. [1:22:54] Is there any questions for Jonathan at this time? [1:22:58] Nicky Boyd. [1:23:00] Those eight, are those part of a motion that would be made with those recommendations still [1:23:08] as we go forward? [1:23:09] Yeah, if you wanted to propose a motion to include those eight with staff recommendations [1:23:14] would cover those eight. [1:23:15] Okay, thank you. [1:23:18] Any other questions from the council? [1:23:22] I think we're good at this time Jonathan, thank you. [1:23:26] At this time we're going to open up the public hearing [1:23:28] on this item if there's anyone in the audience [1:23:31] that would like to address the council on this request. [1:23:34] Now is your opportunity. [1:23:38] Seeing no one, we will close the public hearing [1:23:40] and I will turn it over to the council. [1:23:42] Great landing. [1:23:43] I actually have a question for one of the applicants. [1:23:47] Scott or Greg, you the one. [1:23:51] At some point, I mean, I understand we have to provide, [1:23:53] you have to have some weight, [1:23:55] we're going to require you to have landscaping, [1:23:56] so we have to provide you with the way to get the water, [1:23:59] so I understand we will need to work that out. [1:24:01] My question would be, would there be a plan [1:24:04] to change the existing community storage [1:24:07] to zero-scape as well, or is that you've thought about that? [1:24:11] Come on up, Greg, and if you'd talk, please. [1:24:14] You just thought we were going to let you sit down. [1:24:16] Yeah, you know, Greg Olson 485, Grandpa, no, never thought about it. [1:24:20] That's a great question. [1:24:22] I don't think I'm going to change anything. [1:24:24] OK, I'd like to tear those trees out because the water table is really high. [1:24:27] The rock level is really high. [1:24:29] And they are not growing. [1:24:30] I mean, those trees should be 15 feet taller. [1:24:33] But planning zoning recommended I put those in about eight years ago. [1:24:38] And they're terrible trees. [1:24:40] I'd like to redo the whole thing at some point. [1:24:42] So maybe, yeah. [1:24:43] I guess the other question was, because there was so much pounding of rock that was not going [1:24:49] to happen again. [1:24:50] I guarantee you. [1:24:51] You can't afford it. [1:24:52] You couldn't even put on tent. [1:24:53] No. [1:24:54] I know. [1:24:55] Really terrible. [1:24:56] I'm sorry. [1:24:57] Advanced. [1:24:58] And I'm not going to do it again. [1:24:59] I promise. [1:25:00] I'm going to bring in so much bill. [1:25:01] It's going to be. [1:25:02] All right. [1:25:03] Thank you. [1:25:05] Thank you. [1:25:06] Are there any other questions from the council? [1:25:09] I'm open to a motion if somebody's ready to go there. [1:25:11] I'll have to get my shoes for the news. [1:25:17] Okay, I'll move for approval or request for an annexation with the Dunning District Change and Zoning Map Amendment from R4CROL to M1CRO ZDA for approximately seven and a half acres to allow storage unit rental facility truck rentals, U-Haul truck rental display pads and designated outdoor storage yards for automobiles, pickup, surveys, all this on property located at 403 Grand Vue Drive. [1:25:45] second before we have a second do you want to attach the eight conditions with [1:25:49] the eight attached pins eight conditions thank you second any other questions [1:25:57] from the council we have a motion from chris talkington seconded by roof [1:26:01] pierce to accept the request for annexation and to attach the eight [1:26:05] conditions that were read to us earlier great landing so I'm gonna be voting a [1:26:10] My favorite is I think it's probably since it does comply with the new plan, comprehensive [1:26:18] plan. [1:26:19] Also, it could be nice to see something on that property since it's been no longer been [1:26:25] the theater. [1:26:26] It's kind of just kind of a big bear piece of gravel that really doesn't look very good. [1:26:31] And so some sort of use will make it look like it deserves to be in the city. [1:26:37] Thank you. [1:26:38] I'd like to second Greg's concern about the demise of the grand view has [1:26:43] brought up from it a vote in favor of this but I don't think outdoor theaters [1:26:46] are coming back and as such gladly accept this as a an appropriate use for the [1:26:53] appropriate area. Sharon Roll call vote. [1:26:58] Chris Tarkington. Yes. [1:27:00] Greg Lanting. Yes. Christopher. [1:27:03] Stainford Pierce yes Suzanne Hawkins yes Nicky boy yes motion passes 5 to 0 [1:27:12] thank you for your time this evening with that I believe we have concluded [1:27:18] everything on our agenda so we will adjourn