Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2017-03-06, recording 1 (started 17:00) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2017-03-06/ [0:02:07] I'd like to call the order, the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council, for Monday, March 6th. [0:02:12] Before we begin with the agenda, I'd like to indulge everyone for just a moment to help in remembering the life of Kent Just. [0:02:20] I can't pass away this weekend. He served as the Executive Director of the Twin Falls Chamber for about 16 years. [0:02:27] Had a long and strong partnership with the city, serving on a number of our various commissions, including the Centennial Commission that worked on the [0:02:36] worked on the community centennial. [0:02:40] For those of you who knew Kent, his over-the-top personality, and Jill Beale's spirit could [0:02:47] light up a room whenever he walked in, so he certainly will be missed, and I would ask [0:02:52] that you please join me in a moment of silence. [0:03:06] Thank you. [0:03:07] And now, for those of you wishing to join us, please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance. [0:03:11] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. [0:03:31] We do have a quorum of the council. [0:03:33] All seven members are here this evening. [0:03:35] Mr. Rothweiler, do we have any amendments to our agenda? [0:03:37] There are no amendments this evening. [0:03:39] Thank you. [0:03:40] We do have a couple of proclamations this evening. [0:03:43] The first is, it's not that one. [0:03:46] The first is this one. [0:03:48] The first is a proclamation for March for Meals Month. [0:03:52] Whereas on March 22, 1972, President Richard Nixon [0:03:55] signed into law a measure that amended the Older Americans [0:03:59] Act of 1965 and established a national nutrition program [0:04:03] for seniors 60 years and older. [0:04:06] And whereas Meals on Wheels America [0:04:08] established the March for Meals campaign in March 2002 [0:04:12] to recognize the historic month, the importance [0:04:14] of the Older Americans Act nutrition programs, [0:04:17] both congregate and home delivered, [0:04:19] and raise awareness about the escalating problem [0:04:22] of senior hunger in America. [0:04:24] And whereas the 2017 observance of March for Meals [0:04:27] provides an opportunity to support Meals on Wheels programs [0:04:31] that deliver vital and critical services [0:04:33] by donating, volunteering, and raising awareness [0:04:36] about senior hunger and isolation. [0:04:39] And whereas Older Americans act, [0:04:41] and whereas the Older Americans Act nutrition programs [0:04:44] both congregate and home delivered in Idaho have served our communities admirably for more [0:04:50] than 40 years, and whereas volunteers for Twin Falls Senior Center, Meals on Wheels [0:04:55] program in Twin Falls, Idaho are the backbone of the program, and they not only deliver [0:05:00] nutritious meals to seniors and individuals with disabilities who are at significant risk [0:05:04] of hunger and isolation, but also carrying concern and attention to their welfare. [0:05:10] And whereas Meals on Wheels programs in Idaho provide nutritious meals to seniors throughout [0:05:13] the state and help them maintain their health and independence, thereby preventing unnecessary [0:05:18] falls, hospitalizations, and or premature institutionalization. [0:05:25] And whereas Meals on Wheels programs in Idaho provide a powerful socialization opportunity [0:05:30] for thousands of seniors to help combat loneliness and isolation. [0:05:35] And whereas Meals on Wheels programs in Idaho deserve recognition for the contributions they [0:05:39] have made and will continue to make to local communities, our state and our nation. [0:05:44] Now therefore, I, Sean Berriger, Mayor of the City of Twin Falls, do hereby proclaim March [0:05:49] 2017 as March for Meals Month and urge every citizen to take this month to honor our Meals [0:05:55] on Wheels programs, the seniors they serve, and the volunteers who care for them. [0:06:00] Our recognition of the Twin Falls Senior Center Meals on Wheels program and involvement in the [0:06:05] National 2017 March for Meals can enrich our entire community and help combat senior [0:06:11] hunger and isolation in America. We have Jeanette Rowe from the Senior Center here. [0:06:16] I would like to thank the Mayor and the City Council in doing this proclamation. It is also [0:06:36] National Nutrition Month as well in recognizing what a great service is for our community [0:06:41] as well as the entire nation. Before I came in tonight, or when I came in tonight, I also [0:06:47] provided you with the yearly statistics. Starting in basically first of March, I started my six [0:06:55] year as being the director at the Twin Falls Senior Center. And so I went back four years [0:06:59] to show how it has grown by leaps and bounds. And a lot of that has to do not just on the [0:07:05] services that we provide. It has to do with the number of people needing to have the services. [0:07:10] And down at the bottom it shows that some statistics that one in six seniors in Idaho is food [0:07:16] and secure, 85,917 seniors are living in or near poverty, [0:07:22] and the number of seniors will double from the number [0:07:25] of 57 million in 2010 to double that by 2050. [0:07:31] There's over 12,000 seniors or individuals [0:07:34] who turn 60 every single day in the United States. [0:07:38] And one day in the hospital or equals six days [0:07:41] in nursing home, or you can pay for an entire year [0:07:43] meals for somebody to have meals through the Meals and Wheels program. [0:07:48] Every dollar that we spend on our program saves $50 worth of Medicaid spending and this [0:07:54] is only going to become the number of food insecure seniors that are protected to increase [0:07:58] by 50% as the baby boom generation continues to turn 60 until 2025. [0:08:05] So this problem is not going to go away any time in the future. [0:08:09] My main purpose is just making sure that the community understands what the senior center [0:08:13] does. [0:08:14] I think that's the biggest obstacles that I have is they do not understand what exactly [0:08:17] we do at the center. [0:08:19] But it provides 92% of the seniors who get a home delivered meal say they are able to [0:08:24] stay in their home as long as possible and 83% say it helps improve their health and they [0:08:29] seem to be happier and live longer while getting meals through our program. [0:08:34] And as you can see on the statistics, especially for the home delivered meals, we used to only [0:08:38] average about 2,400 meals a month for home delivered meals and we do almost 4,500 meals [0:08:45] per month for home meal delivery and last year we talked our all-time record at [0:08:50] 72,399 meals both at the center and hometown and it is just mind-boggling [0:08:59] it days to think that we do that many of them but thank you so much. Thank you [0:09:04] And that's on a wonderful job back when I was early in my city council I was [0:09:11] a liaison to the senior center when they're down from the cross-meal Sears [0:09:15] building and actually before that they were on rock creek but I can remember [0:09:22] how happy we're one of those years when I went through 10,000 meals and now we're [0:09:28] up to 72,000 just in the four years you've been involved, that's 71% increase. [0:09:36] And it's an essential service that you're providing. [0:09:39] I don't have to tell you what, staff you mentioned here are about food insecure one and sex and [0:09:45] the number of people at home and sometimes that's the only contact that people have is [0:09:49] that meal on the wheel. [0:09:51] So if it were up to me, you'd be appointed to life in this job, and you're doing it in [0:09:58] a sense. [0:09:59] Some things that seem like I've been there all over the place. [0:10:02] I'm appointed in that sentence. [0:10:04] But basically what happens, I want people to understand is the City of Twin Falls is [0:10:10] really unique in this process. [0:10:12] We have a lot of people who come to this community and they are older. [0:10:16] So I think 21% of the population growth, 15% of that is people over the age of 60. [0:10:21] So that's huge. [0:10:22] We also feel that by 2020, the census data will probably come back saying that approximately [0:10:28] 35 to 40 percent of the population will be over 60, which is huge. [0:10:33] But that's because a lot of people like this community and they want to retire here or they [0:10:38] have other services or they come off of the farms and decided to be here instead of into [0:10:42] a bigger city city. [0:10:44] So like I said, there's a lot of things that are coming up and like I said, I think it's [0:10:47] really important that we recognize that this is going to be a long time thing that we [0:10:51] we need to make sure we provide for. [0:10:53] And a lot of times people may get disgruntled [0:10:55] or say something about the senior center [0:10:57] and go, well, that's not a good service [0:10:59] or maybe there's something going on there. [0:11:01] But think about it this way. [0:11:02] What happens if we aren't there? [0:11:05] Who is gonna pick up that big, huge gap? [0:11:07] And that's been always been my mission [0:11:09] of what's happening at the senior center [0:11:11] is we have to make sure that we take care of the whole ground. [0:11:15] Thank you, Jen. [0:11:28] The next proclamation is for groundwater awareness week. [0:11:31] Whereas groundwater is a limited resource in the City of Twin Falls, and whereas clean abundant groundwater is an essential resource of our citizens, [0:11:39] and whereas groundwater supplies approximately 95% of residents with water they use to meet their drinking water needs, [0:11:45] and whereas the agricultural community, private industry, and businesses and communities rely on large quantities of high quality groundwater for economic prosperity. [0:11:55] And whereas groundwater can be vulnerable to contamination and degradation. [0:12:00] And whereas groundwater and surface water can be interconnected and therefore degraded or reduced, [0:12:05] groundwater supplies can adversely impact surface water users, [0:12:09] including drinking water, recreation, irrigation, and power generation. [0:12:13] And whereas groundwater is one of our most precious natural resources, [0:12:17] it is appropriate to set aside a special time to call upon everyone young and old [0:12:21] young and old to learn about the importance of groundwater in their lives and to learn [0:12:26] how they can protect and conserve our precious groundwater resource. [0:12:30] Now therefore, I, Sean Barrigar, mayor of the City of Twin Falls do hereby proclaim the [0:12:34] week of March 5th through March 11th, 2017 to be groundwater awareness week in the City [0:12:39] of Twin Falls, State of Idaho. [0:12:42] Should also mention too, the County Commissioners also passed a similar proclamation so throughout [0:12:46] West Wind Falls County is recognition of groundwater awareness week and we have our [0:12:51] own Rob Bowling here to accept this this evening. [0:13:07] Evening Mayor and Council, we'd just like to say thank you for bringing this to the recognition [0:13:14] of the city and the citizens of the city of Twig Falls. [0:13:18] We all know that we're pretty lucky here with the sources of groundwater that we have and [0:13:25] although it may seem this winter like we've got lots of water and abundance of water. [0:13:30] We need to keep in mind that our water all comes from groundwater sources and they have [0:13:36] been declining for the last 60 years and just one year of winter weather. [0:13:43] Doesn't always fix our problem. [0:13:47] So we are glad that everybody's recognizing that groundwater is important. [0:13:52] We all know that without it here, [0:13:54] twin wouldn't be what it is for citizens, [0:13:58] industrial, commercial, and most kind of uses. [0:14:02] So we appreciate that. [0:14:03] We'd also like to invite anyone since groundwater awareness [0:14:08] week, we're partnering with the county, Idaho Department [0:14:12] of Water Resources, DEQ, and a few other entities. [0:14:18] And we'll have the groundwater awareness fair [0:14:21] at County West Building on Wednesday from 3 to 6 p.m. [0:14:26] In the four-year there. [0:14:28] And if anybody's worried about having contamination [0:14:31] to their private wells or nitrates in your well water, [0:14:36] if you're on private well water, [0:14:38] if you live outside of the city limits, [0:14:41] come by there, there'll be, I think, Magic Valley Lab [0:14:45] is going to be there at Department of Water Resources. [0:14:48] And DQ will have test trips that they can test your water [0:14:52] right there for nitrates also. [0:14:55] So we'd invite anybody with those concerns to come out [0:14:58] and we'll have some little poster boards and stuff set up [0:15:02] on our wells and the declines and stuff. [0:15:05] And those also are straight nitrates and some other things. [0:15:09] So anybody who wants to come out, we'd appreciate it. [0:15:13] And thank you again. [0:15:14] Thank you, Rob. [0:15:15] Great landing. [0:15:16] with the current thing that's been in the news [0:15:19] with the problems over in Lincoln County, [0:15:22] since we have our wells and both places, [0:15:25] how often do we test for like nitrates [0:15:27] and that kind of thing? [0:15:28] And we sample monthly or quarterly, [0:15:31] depending on what the stipulations of DEQ, [0:15:34] the rules that we have to follow. [0:15:36] But yeah, for nitrates, [0:15:39] and E. coli and those kind of things, [0:15:41] we sample monthly, so. [0:15:43] Correct. [0:15:44] Thank you very much. [0:15:45] Thanks Rob. [0:15:46] Okay. [0:15:47] Thank you. [0:15:48] Appreciate it. [0:15:49] Thank you. [0:15:50] What? [0:15:52] Next is an opportunity for general public input if there's anyone here from the public who wishes [0:15:56] to address the council on any issues that aren't on the agenda this evening. [0:16:00] Now is your opportunity to come forward. [0:16:06] Yes. [0:16:11] So if you could please state your name and address for us. [0:16:15] My name is Heather Tufts. [0:16:17] 2552 Poline Road East. [0:16:20] Welcome. [0:16:21] Thank you. [0:16:24] Thank you. I am here to talk about the Snake River Trails Enhancement Project. Our property [0:16:38] is adjacent to that trail that I believe has been approved to go in this month or start. [0:16:49] Basically, we just have a lot of concerns regarding that trail and our property. We just [0:16:56] wanted to address those at this time. I have, I don't know if you are familiar with the layout out there. [0:17:08] So it's the north end of Gary Stor's property that will be the path. We are on the south side of [0:17:14] Poline, so we're, like I said, right next to it. Our property, as I understand it, is the most [0:17:23] affected by the trail because we are a peninsula into his field. So we're surrounded completely [0:17:31] by the path. It's very invasive to our privacy, security, and we didn't know if you were aware [0:17:42] of those things. I have some photos if you'd like to see them of our property and the situation, [0:17:51] And I guess it's visible from every window in our house. [0:17:56] Like I said, it completely encompasses the fourth side is our driveway, which is literally [0:18:01] the width of the driveway. [0:18:04] So we are surrounded. [0:18:06] There's some very large old trees out there. [0:18:12] They're not healthy. [0:18:13] Every time we get a big windstorm, which happens pretty frequently, limbs fall out. [0:18:19] that poses a concern that if we, you know, [0:18:22] there's a difference between empty field [0:18:23] with the occasional cow, [0:18:25] and you have the general public marching through there, [0:18:28] is that my liability, that if the limb falls out of the tree, [0:18:33] that it would hurt someone or cause damage to the path. [0:18:39] Also, as far as our privacy, [0:18:43] like it's from every window in my house, [0:18:45] we would see the path. [0:18:47] It's very close to my driveway. [0:18:50] We purchased this house in 2015 for the fact [0:18:54] of where it's located. [0:18:56] It's kind of isolated. [0:18:59] I have three children. [0:19:00] It's a great place that my kids could be outside to play [0:19:03] without the fear of the general public interfering [0:19:07] with their activities. [0:19:09] But when this path goes in, from me to there is the path. [0:19:15] There is a barbed wire funds that separates our property [0:19:20] from Gary Storrs' property, but I've been informed [0:19:23] that that fence is being removed [0:19:25] because it's Gary Storrs claiming it's his fence. [0:19:30] Which, that fence, obviously it's just the barbed wire funds [0:19:33] does not provide any security or privacy in any way. [0:19:40] I have animals pets that I can't really explain. [0:19:45] there's going to be people walking by now, you can't approach them. [0:19:48] I'm also concerned that people will have their pets on the walking trail, on their walks and [0:19:55] rides, and that they will trespass on to our property and interfere with my kids, my pets, [0:20:02] I have plans of getting chickens. [0:20:04] It's just very invasive, I guess. [0:20:09] So I don't know if you want to see these photos, if there's a process there. [0:20:15] Do you mind if we showed it over here? [0:20:17] I don't at all. [0:20:17] Yeah, you can put it right there on the overhead. [0:20:36] The trail will be to the right and to the left, [0:20:39] and I'll remember that. [0:20:44] You can see the right there, where the path will be west of. [0:21:03] This is the east of the Grand [0:21:29] and we'll be driving apart. [0:21:35] That is out the back of my house [0:21:39] and you see the fence home to the right there. [0:21:44] We have to be this day from my porch on my front door. [0:21:57] So again, for those fence close to our, [0:22:00] we draw the path to the picture there. [0:22:12] This is off to the other side of the house, [0:22:14] the west side, the trees, [0:22:35] was referring to earlier than our, [0:22:38] not in the best cheese. [0:22:53] Our fire pit area, [0:22:56] again, you said the bench hooks in the back, [0:22:58] it's the boundary line, [0:23:03] it's in the corner there, [0:23:04] so it's supposed to be at home, [0:23:10] taking out in that condition. [0:23:14] These are the trees, seven on our property, [0:23:21] and they understand they're all under their shoulder, [0:23:23] so they are hollow on the inside, [0:23:28] they're just so old. [0:23:29] So again, whatever they blow, [0:23:31] they're just crashing down. [0:23:40] I just went in the back of that, obviously. [0:23:51] I do have some. [0:23:56] These are from the inside of my house. [0:24:12] This family living room and trail by the roughly the king view. [0:24:38] And then I have just pictures. [0:24:41] I'd walk the property line and I guess the point of view [0:24:49] from if you were on the trail, what you would see. [0:24:53] And I kind of just went from west to east. [0:25:06] And our law is not square. [0:25:08] It's weird kind of angled sheets. [0:25:11] So it's not in some places, like here's probably [0:25:14] where it gets the closest to the actual house. [0:25:21] And you know, long, ever before everyone knows. [0:25:26] It's the furthest point, by the way. [0:26:23] I like pictures, but I just kind of wanted to get a point, [0:26:25] you know, across that how it's all the way around us. [0:26:29] We're not escaping it, so I guess we just wanted to come [0:26:35] and let you guys know that, see what we can do [0:26:39] to remedy that situation. [0:26:43] There was talk of putting up a fence. [0:26:45] I know Gary Storr part of that deal [0:26:47] is that the cows on the south side of the fence [0:26:53] or the south side of the path, [0:26:55] there will be a fence to keep the cows in. [0:26:59] Tree, remedying, I guess, as far as removing [0:27:06] the dead trees, planting new trees, that kind of thing. [0:27:12] Okay, so we have a couple of comments, Craig, Lanting. [0:27:15] Well, thank you for coming in and sharing the pictures with us. [0:27:19] Thanks. [0:27:20] The question I had since you bought this in 2015, did the realtor let you know a trail [0:27:25] was coming or if there was a preliminary plat for that property behind you for supervision? [0:27:30] No. [0:27:31] There's actually a road right away, goes right through there. [0:27:36] Well, I've had conversations unofficially with Wendy Davis from Twin Falls Parks and Rec. [0:27:41] We've been speaking for about a year. [0:27:44] I had a conversation with Mitch Humble the other day, [0:27:48] and he suggested that we come here to let you know [0:27:52] kind of what was going on. [0:27:53] It was not, no, it was never, there's a path going here [0:28:02] in a year, because we bought in October 2015. [0:28:06] So there was not ever, there was gonna be, [0:28:08] there was mentioned that there was some day [0:28:10] when the property was developed, there would be a path, [0:28:13] but not that it was moving forward in this fashion. [0:28:22] And what about the, we had looked at several maps [0:28:26] as we were doing, there's actually a road right away [0:28:28] that goes, kind of catches most of that property [0:28:32] along with their actual loss, that most people weren't aware [0:28:38] of what they disclosed that to you, [0:28:39] that you actually had a right-of-way [0:28:41] that's in your property? [0:28:43] no. Chris Stockington. Just to follow up on a couple of your observations, ma'am, the [0:28:51] trees you talked about are all on your property. All those that you see there [0:28:57] are in are on my property. There's seven. There's actually more out there that are [0:29:01] just on the other side of the fence. Well, whose property is that? Well, I'm not [0:29:07] sure the one would fall probably half in Gary stores and half in the trail area. [0:29:15] Okay well certainly if it's the city's property we have responsibility of [0:29:21] jurisdiction inside your property line very little we can do. [0:29:26] Well I guess it was kind of explained to me that I'm thinking on a liability in the [0:29:31] fact that if that tree were to fall with the path that the path I have no [0:29:36] control over sure so that there was a suggestion made that maybe as the city [0:29:41] that you would want to remove those trees as a benefit to both of us in that I'm [0:29:48] not taking on the liability of a tree falling on someone. I'm sure we'll look [0:29:53] at all those possibilities to minimize risk and liability for both the city and [0:29:58] yourself. The question of the proximity of the path to your property is not in [0:30:04] all fairness there's a fairly good distance that looks like 150 200 feet. [0:30:09] On this section, yes, but on the side near, it's my bedroom window, it's from from the house, it's about 20 feet. [0:30:21] The observation is that in most of the areas that I think we're building a trail, have built a trail, we pretty much always have a fence, a three-poster fence up like that. [0:30:33] And if, in your circumstance, there's an extra close proximity to your personal part of your [0:30:41] house, there may be something more of the city would entertain doing. [0:30:47] And you came to the right place and Mitch there, who helped you with the photos, will [0:30:52] be kind of the middleman on that. [0:30:53] But we want to make it as comfortable as possible for you, given that you only have control [0:30:59] up to your property line. [0:31:00] We want to be good neighbors. [0:31:01] So I'm sure we'll work with you what we're asking for so I have a question for you, so are you attending the [0:31:11] Community meeting tomorrow evening. Yes, that's being hosted about the trail, so I believe it's that [0:31:19] meeting they'll have [0:31:21] Perhaps some more solid drawings of where the trail is anticipated [0:31:25] I've seen the drawings I've been dealing with this since February [0:31:29] I had a conversation with Wendy Davis because I heard rumors about this trail. [0:31:35] I was told it was not going in. I had nothing to worry about. [0:31:39] It was just kind of talk that throughout this process I feel I've been lied to. [0:31:50] Because like I said, I've had this conversation since February of last year. [0:31:55] that up until January, that, and even with Gary's store, [0:32:02] my real estate agent called Gary's store in October [0:32:06] to try and get a different perspective [0:32:08] and he said it wasn't happening. [0:32:10] So until January, there was an article published [0:32:13] in the Messenger newspaper that they were raising funds [0:32:19] and they had been raising funds. [0:32:20] That part was always known, but the likelihood [0:32:24] of reaching that goal was very unlikely. [0:32:27] I was told that the entire time. [0:32:29] Until January, Wendy Davis came to my house [0:32:33] under the guy, well, not guys, [0:32:34] but they wanted to cut the path instead of going around us. [0:32:38] They wanted to cut towards the front of our property, [0:32:41] but that basically put the path in our front lawn. [0:32:47] It did avoid the going around, [0:32:50] but then it broke our property up into, [0:32:52] So then there would be house, path, a little sliver, the water, and then we have property [0:32:59] on the other side of it. [0:33:00] So it made it really inconvenient and basically unusable. [0:33:05] And we were not agreeable to that situation. [0:33:09] But that's why she came over to ask. [0:33:11] We did appreciate that, that she was trying to make the best out of a bad situation I guess. [0:33:18] that's when I was informed that they were going to bring it to you guys for [0:33:24] official moving forward in March. Apparently at the end of January mid [0:33:32] February they came to you and the final decision was made. So all the [0:33:39] information that I've been given is always seems like a step behind what's [0:33:45] actually happening. So if I had known that, because like I said, she said in March, you [0:33:51] can come to City Council and plead your case before it's a done deal. But then two weeks [0:33:56] after I talked to her, it was a done deal. So it's not, it's not a spur of the moment [0:34:01] surprise kind of thing. I've known about it. I just, I don't feel that I've been given [0:34:07] all the correct current information regarding the path. And as I understand the, there wasn't [0:34:14] a public hearing regarding the path and it's [0:34:19] so that so the path was actually approved many many years ago as part of [0:34:26] the development plaque for that property right so so there were public hearings [0:34:32] and all kinds of public input at that time about the placement of the trail [0:34:36] which was in 2005 ish so where there's new property owners I guess [0:34:46] So again, that applies to that property, not to the neighboring properties, it was about the development of that property. [0:34:53] And then as far as the pursuit of potentially developing the trail prior to development of that property, [0:35:00] that conversation began well over a year ago with the Council on our public meetings, on our public agendas, [0:35:07] to enter into an agreement that should the funds be raised, [0:35:12] and the city would agree to take ownership of that [0:35:16] and move forward with development. [0:35:17] So that was included in our budget discussions last year [0:35:21] and in that. [0:35:22] So I can't speak to what you were, [0:35:25] weren't told when you had conversations with people [0:35:28] because it wasn't there. [0:35:30] But I would say that there has been a lot of public discussion [0:35:34] about this trail development in these meetings [0:35:38] and in media coverage much earlier than January of this year. [0:35:44] Yes, and I agree with that, and I saw in the news. [0:35:48] That's why my phone call was made, so when did you do this? [0:35:51] So, I mean, you bring valid concerns here, [0:35:55] and I think as this moves forward with finalizing [0:35:58] the development and the plan there to Councilman [0:36:02] Tockington's point, staff will work with the neighboring [0:36:06] property owners to do what we can to minimize impacts of it. [0:36:10] Understanding the overall goal of the benefit of the trail is what we're trying to pursue [0:36:16] with minimizing that impact on the neighbors. [0:36:18] Okay. [0:36:19] All right. [0:36:20] So thank you very much. [0:36:26] So and Mitch, I assume you have contact information and okay. [0:36:31] Thank you for coming this evening and sharing that information. [0:36:40] Is there anyone else from the public who wishes to address the council on any issues that are not on the agenda this evening? [0:36:49] Seeing none, we will move on with the agenda, the consent calendar, council wishes. [0:36:55] I move that we accept the consent calendar. [0:36:58] Second. [0:37:00] Motion by Nikki Boyd, seconded by Ruth Pierce to approve the consent calendar as presented. [0:37:05] Is there any discussion? [0:37:08] Seeing none, Sharon Rolkel, vote please. [0:37:10] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:37:11] Yes. [0:37:12] Nikki Boyd. [0:37:13] Yes. [0:37:13] John Berricker, Chris Hockington, Greg Lanting, Christopher Reed, Ruth Pierce. [0:37:20] Yes. [0:37:21] Motion passes 7-0. [0:37:22] If there are any of you who are here for any of the approval of the special events, those [0:37:28] were just approved on the consent calendar, so you're welcome to stick around or take [0:37:34] off. [0:37:35] Please stick around. [0:37:40] And next we have a presentation of certificates of appreciation to Jodi Tatum and Christopher [0:37:44] Reed in recognition of their service on the Planning and Zoning Commission. [0:37:48] We have Renee Caraway-Johnson. [0:37:50] Welcome Renee. [0:37:51] Good evening. [0:37:52] Starting to be a regular thing, I can keep it up. [0:37:58] First off I would like to appreciate, I would like to tell you I appreciate the opportunity [0:38:02] to publicly thank Christopher Reed and Jodi Tatum for serving on the commission. [0:38:08] It is, as you're well aware, public service does take a lot of time and commitment, and [0:38:14] both of you served with your full hearts. [0:38:19] Jody served on the commission for three years and nine months. [0:38:24] She was appointed to fill out the term of a vacated position in May of 2013. [0:38:29] She was later reappointed in March of 2014 to serve a full three year term. [0:38:35] the end of February she had served her maximum time. [0:38:40] Chris, Christopher, served on the commission for two years and 10 months. [0:38:48] He was appointed in March of 2014 to serve a three-year term and in 2016 elected to our [0:38:54] city council which were very glad and not glad both. [0:39:02] Harris's last official planning and zoning commission meeting was in December of 2016. [0:39:07] In January he took office. [0:39:09] So at this time I would like Jody to come up and Chris and it's the mayor would come down [0:39:15] and present the plaques. [0:39:16] I would appreciate it. [0:39:17] It is. [0:39:24] Thank you. [0:39:25] Thank you. [0:39:28] Thank you. [0:40:16] Thank you. [0:40:17] Well I'd like to congratulate them both for and thank them for serving on planning zoning. [0:40:24] I'm pretty sure I pointed to Jody when I was mayor. [0:40:27] I think I tried to appoint Chris, but he didn't [0:40:29] might meet all the qualifications at times. [0:40:31] I think Don appointed you, but I appreciate your service. [0:40:36] And I cut my teeth on seven years on planning zoning. [0:40:40] And I really understand how important that committee is, [0:40:45] or that commission, whichever it is, [0:40:48] to helping us to move forward, especially [0:40:51] with development issues and SUPs and all those things. [0:40:55] Certainly, lightens our loan. [0:40:56] I'll guarantee you so appreciate your service. Thank you. Chris Reed. I just want to tell Renee [0:41:03] thank you. I really enjoyed the time that I was able to serve there. Jonathan [0:41:07] Spendlove also, he's not here but he really helped me out also and if it's [0:41:12] alright my family came also and I wanted to introduce them. I didn't do that when I [0:41:16] was appointed and I feel like a horrible husband and father so I need to do that [0:41:21] now. So my wife is here Anne and then my seven children Isabelle Elizabeth Eli [0:41:27] Hi, Isaac, Mark, you've heard him yell mom several times, [0:41:33] Reyna and then Sarah James. [0:41:34] So thank you for coming and supporting me. [0:41:42] Nikki Boyd. [0:41:43] I was lucky enough to serve on planning and zoning [0:41:45] with both Christopher and Jody. [0:41:47] And I just wanted to tell you guys both thanks. [0:41:51] I learned a lot from both of you. [0:41:53] And thank you for your service to our community. [0:41:56] Thank you, Nikki. [0:41:59] So next on the agenda, we have a presentation [0:42:02] of the service plaque to Leah, [0:42:03] by in a recognition of her service on the Parks and Recreation Commission. Unfortunately, Leah [0:42:08] is not able to be here right now, so I think what we'll do is we'll hold this in case she [0:42:13] shows tonight, Wendy, if that'll work, and if not, we will reschedule that on a future [0:42:18] agenda to present that to her. But we will move to the next item, which is the appointment [0:42:24] request to appoint ZJ Martinez and Sherry Murray to the Parks and Recreation Commission. And [0:42:31] That's me on the agenda. [0:42:33] So I'll go to that page. [0:42:38] We, the commission had two openings due to two members [0:42:43] who served their full six-year terms on the commission. [0:42:46] So we had six applications for the openings that we received. [0:42:50] The interview committee consisted of myself, [0:42:53] Parks and Recreation Commission liaison, [0:42:54] Councilwoman Nikki Boyd, and Parks and Recreation Director [0:42:57] Wendy Davis. [0:42:59] On Monday, February 13th, we interviewed [0:43:02] five of the applicants, the interview committee, [0:43:05] as we reviewed those, selected ZJ Martinez [0:43:09] and Sherry Murray to serve on the Parks and Recreation Commission [0:43:13] or recommended that. [0:43:15] Both candidates have successfully passed a background check. [0:43:19] So as the city code states, [0:43:21] the commissioners are appointed by the mayor [0:43:24] and confirmed by the members of the council. [0:43:27] And I would entertain a motion to approve [0:43:32] my recommended appointment of ZJ Martinez and Sherry Murray. [0:43:38] Mayor. [0:43:39] Nicky Boyd. [0:43:40] I recommend that we accept both of your recommendations [0:43:44] for ZJ Martinez and Sherry Murray to the Parks and Recreation [0:43:47] question. [0:43:48] Second, a motion by Nicky Boyd. [0:43:52] Seconded by Christopher Reed to approve those two appointments. [0:43:56] Is there any discussion? [0:44:01] Seeing none, Chair and roll call vote, please. [0:44:04] Nicky Boyd? [0:44:05] Yes. [0:44:06] John Barricar, Chris Talkington, Greg Lanting, Christopher Reed, Ruth Pierce, Suzanne Hawkins. [0:44:14] Yes. Motion passes 7 to 0. Unfortunately, neither of these folks were able to make it [0:44:21] this evening either, but trust us, they were great applicants and they are very enthusiastic [0:44:27] about their opportunity to serve on the Parks and Recreation Commission. [0:44:33] This is a request to appoint Richard Brown to serve a five-year term in the capacity of [0:44:38] resident commissioner for the Twin Falls Housing Authority Board. [0:44:41] And we have Leanne Trappen with the Twin Falls Housing Authority and Mr. Brown. [0:44:47] Welcome, Leanne. [0:44:49] Thank you for having us here this evening. [0:44:53] Richard has agreed to complete a vacated term as resident commissioner for the Twin Falls [0:45:00] Housing Authority Board. [0:45:02] And so he will complete that term and then hopefully serve another five after that. [0:45:11] I was very fortunate to have Rick and have him agree to participate because this is not [0:45:18] always an easy recruitment. [0:45:21] And we really look forward to having him represent the tenants there on our board so that we can [0:45:28] continue to make sure that we are making wise decisions, [0:45:31] providing clean, safe, affordable housing [0:45:34] for our seniors, disabled, and families. [0:45:38] So this is very proud. [0:45:42] Welcome, Mr. Brown. [0:45:43] Thank you for your willingness to serve. [0:45:46] Thank you for your willingness to serve. [0:45:47] We appreciate your engagement as a resident commissioner. [0:45:52] And we have a background in the end [0:45:54] of the property management and working [0:45:58] in the houses and supervising the maintenance on home to their team. [0:46:04] Yeah, I'm looking really over to it, for sure. [0:46:08] Good, well, we appreciate that. [0:46:09] So, and Leanne, thanks for your presentation. [0:46:12] So with that, I would entertain a motion. [0:46:14] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:46:17] Sorry, I move that we appoint Richard Brown [0:46:19] to serve the remainder of the five-year term [0:46:23] in the vacancy on the board for the Twin Falls Housing Authority. [0:46:27] Second. [0:46:28] motion by Suzanne Hopkins seconded by Ruth Pierce to approve Mr. Brown's appointment is [0:46:33] there any discussion? Seeing none Sharon roll call vote please. Sean Periker yes [0:46:39] Chris Tockington yes Greg Lanting yes Christopher Reed yes Ruth Pierce yes [0:46:45] Suzanne Hawkins yes Nikki Boyd yes. Motion passes seven to zero you're [0:46:51] official thank you very much appreciate your time thank you and next is a [0:46:59] The presentation on the successes of Southern Idaho tourism and plans on the upcoming tourist [0:47:05] season. [0:47:06] We have Melissa Berry, the Executive Director of Southern Idaho tourism. [0:47:09] Welcome, Melissa. [0:47:10] Thank you, Mayor. [0:47:11] Thank you, Council, for taking the time to let me speak tonight. [0:47:14] I do appreciate it. [0:47:15] For those of you that don't know me, my name is Melissa Berry and I'm with Southern Idaho [0:47:18] tourism. [0:47:19] So I just wanted to kind of give you an update on what things we've been working on as well [0:47:23] as kind of the plans we have for the upcoming tourism season since we're getting to that [0:47:27] point where hopefully warmer weather is on the horizon although the snow flurries [0:47:31] again today were a little disappointing so as the region 4 portion of our area we [0:47:39] are the fifth largest industry in our region so it's a big piece of the pie [0:47:44] when it comes to economic development we have seen a 17.4% increase which is the [0:47:50] largest increase in the entire state so we're doing very very well the closest to [0:47:54] is region six, which they're setting at a 15.1% increase, followed by region three and region [0:48:00] seven, which are setting about 13 and 14% increases. [0:48:04] So, I think the tactics that we've been able to put out to the different areas that we target [0:48:09] are really working and we're seeing some good responses to that. [0:48:13] So we're very excited about that. [0:48:16] We see about 60, a little bit over 60 million of wages generated from tourism industry as [0:48:22] as well as 11.5% of our non-farm-working workforce [0:48:27] comes from the tourism industry. [0:48:28] So it's a very viable industry, [0:48:30] and I think something that as council members, [0:48:34] you should be aware of the things that we're doing, [0:48:36] so that way you can speak to these successes as well. [0:48:39] Or the Twin Falls County, we collect almost 27 million [0:48:43] in lodging sales. [0:48:45] The city of Twin Falls obviously has the majority [0:48:47] of those hotels and properties. [0:48:50] The U.L. does have a few and some of our outlying communities do as well. [0:48:54] RV parks are also considered into those collection numbers, but really the crux of what's going [0:48:59] on is happening here in the city limits of Twin Falls, so we're very excited about those [0:49:04] numbers as well as the two new extended stay hotels that are going to be developed. [0:49:08] So both of those are going to be probably coming up here in the next upcoming season [0:49:12] if not maybe into the next season as well. [0:49:15] So that will provide kind of a service that we right now don't have and will hopefully [0:49:20] increase the hotel lodging tax even further. [0:49:25] One of the things that I really wanted to focus on when I came into the position was [0:49:29] to make sure that we worked on the shoulder season and so a lot of what we've done this [0:49:34] winter is to really look at some areas of opportunities. [0:49:37] So things that happen up in the South Hills as far as skiing, snowmobiling, snowshoeing, [0:49:42] cross-country skiing has been a really big one. [0:49:44] The Nordic area ski group takes really good care of the trails that are up in the South [0:49:49] Hills. [0:49:50] And so my purpose is just to make sure that people are aware of that. [0:49:53] We did some native advertising that included these activities that are part of like a top [0:49:58] 10 which people really enjoy that kind of content because it allows them to search through [0:50:02] what they're looking for and gather exactly what they want. [0:50:05] And we were able to gather almost 6,000 qualified leads off of that campaign in the last 60 [0:50:10] days. [0:50:11] Unfortunately, the weather has not cooperated, and so we've really seen kind of while we've [0:50:16] gotten the leads and we've been able to get the interest, they haven't been able to actually [0:50:20] convert into sales. [0:50:21] And so as of January, and I'm going to expect that February will be low as well, but we probably [0:50:27] won't see the kind of numbers that the campaigns are leading us to believe that we're going [0:50:31] to. [0:50:32] So unfortunately, that hasn't been great, but I think looking at next year, you know, that [0:50:36] shoulder season campaign again will be successful as long as the weather behaves. [0:50:41] Looking forward, the spring and summer campaigns, the one positive of having so much snow while [0:50:47] we weren't able to always open up our ski lifts and whatnot is that we will have really [0:50:51] good water year this year. [0:50:53] So the runoff will be very high. [0:50:55] Shosham Falls has already seen great flows. [0:50:57] People are eating that stuff up. [0:50:59] Social media has just been running rampant with images of Shosham Falls, thousands of [0:51:03] springs, different areas that are around here that people are excited about coming and visiting. [0:51:08] Unfortunately, sometimes the road was closed for a little while, so we weren't able to [0:51:12] get everyone down there. [0:51:14] But I think looking at what we're going to do for the upcoming season, we're really going [0:51:18] to try and focus specifically on that high water. [0:51:20] So not only for a viewer's standpoint, but also kayaking, fishing, whitewater rafting. [0:51:27] It's all going to promote within that segment. [0:51:30] So it's very exciting on that end. [0:51:31] I'm going to partner with Wendy and get some passes to give away. [0:51:35] So we're going to run out two ways to see the falls, we'll give away those hundred passes, [0:51:39] and then do a discount with AWOL to get people excited about kind of what to be able to see [0:51:44] while they're here. [0:51:45] Additionally, National Parks are a huge deal. [0:51:48] We have four of the six National Parks in the state of Idaho. [0:51:52] A lot of what the Centennial Campaign that they did for the National Parks Service last [0:51:57] year will still see a lot of that kind of fall over into this year for people who weren't [0:52:01] may be able to make it, plus the National Park Service is still putting in lots of advertising [0:52:05] dollars for that purpose. [0:52:07] So what our plan is to hopefully get people that are not only headed towards Yellowstone [0:52:11] but also the ones that are looking to visit all these different National Parks and make [0:52:15] that kind of part of their vacation plans. [0:52:18] So with such a huge, not huge, but such a good cluster of National Parks here locally, [0:52:24] it's something that I see as a very big potential and hopefully we'll be able to spread that [0:52:28] message and let people know that we have such a good variety of places for them to come visit. [0:52:34] Additionally, we have a billboard campaign, so I think it's fairly obvious, but ID4 represents [0:52:40] a lot of our traffic, and so to be able to hit our travelers along those lines will hopefully [0:52:46] get a lot more people to our area and be able to let them know that to get off the interstate, [0:52:52] it's not always what you see. [0:52:53] You have to drive a little bit further and come into town, and then you can view the [0:52:57] the visitor center, the bridge, the falls, all the things that there are to do in our area. [0:53:01] And so I think those billboards are really help capture that vision of what there is to [0:53:05] do. [0:53:06] Additionally, the eclipse is coming up. [0:53:09] I don't know if you guys are aware, but that's going to be a pretty large event. [0:53:13] So it's going to happen August 21, but they're expecting it to be more like a week long celebration. [0:53:19] People have been getting excited about that. [0:53:21] A lot of people are going to be coming from Europe and out of the country, as well as [0:53:25] neighboring states, so we're going to see some good visitor counts from that as well. [0:53:30] They're expecting 20,000 to 30,000 people per community along that line of totality, so it's [0:53:36] definitely going to be a big deal, and we're hoping to help pull some of those people that are kind of [0:53:41] along. Those lines where, you know, many of those little towns are very small, so hopefully we can [0:53:47] get some of the hotel states here. We're going to be partnering with the Chamber to do a guided tour [0:53:53] and get people from our specific hotels here up to the blind of totality and take advantage of that as well. [0:53:59] And then the last piece that I will speak to is kind of our plans for the fiscal year 17 grant. [0:54:04] So we are in the process of planning that at the moment. [0:54:07] Our board will meet actually next week. [0:54:10] And some of the big things that we're working on are regional trail system and map. [0:54:14] So the hope is to have a GIS platform that has not only our hiking, biking, walking trails, [0:54:19] tracking trails, but water, historical, all different kinds of things layered into a map. [0:54:24] So that way, not only can a visitor really see what there is to do, but they can pick [0:54:28] what they want to see, and then we'll have pinpoints and be able to upload photos, and [0:54:33] hopefully we're still working through some of the details, but we'll be able to do crowdsourcing [0:54:38] information and get groups to insert information, whether they have details that pertain to rules [0:54:45] of the trail or something along those lines, so that way they can kind of talk with each [0:54:48] other too. [0:54:50] With that, we're going to be working with Wendy from Parks and Rec to update her collateral [0:54:55] material for the Canyon Rim Trail, obviously the connection piece is very important, as [0:54:59] well as making sure that our tourist understands how to get there, what to expect, and you know, [0:55:04] the history behind it as well. [0:55:06] So we're excited about that. [0:55:07] And then the last piece is a local social media manager. [0:55:10] Currently, we have a manager that lives up in Boise area. [0:55:14] So it's a little bit behind sometimes when we're thinking about, oh, hey, we need to [0:55:17] go post this, we need to go post that. [0:55:19] My hope is in the vision is that these content pieces that they're going to create will actually [0:55:25] be shareable either directly if the city chooses to do so. [0:55:30] Two cities, cities and counties, social media feeds, but also available for the local public [0:55:37] to understand exactly what's going on and see our town as a recreational hotspot as [0:55:42] many people here do, but there are still lots of community members that don't necessarily [0:55:47] know all the things that we have to offer. [0:55:49] So, that is kind of our plans for the upcoming season, and I will open myself up for questions. [0:55:56] Thank you, Melissa. [0:55:57] Great landing. [0:55:58] Well, I'm glad you brought up the total eclipse, because everywhere I was, last week I was on [0:56:04] the Oregon coast, and I was in Central Oregon, and everywhere along there is in that path. [0:56:09] I mean, even Depo Bay is like the first place [0:56:13] it hits landfall, which is, I guess, [0:56:14] is supposed to be special. [0:56:16] And then Central Oregon even had one of my relatives [0:56:19] that's already has rented out her entire pasture area [0:56:23] to people camping. [0:56:25] And they've already, you know, have their gym there. [0:56:28] And also here in Twin Falls, my house already [0:56:31] have people out of Arizona coming to stay with me [0:56:33] that time span. [0:56:34] So I know our hotels are gonna be filled [0:56:36] because everything up in that path is wake-filled for a long ago. [0:56:41] So I'm sure our hotels probably are already full now, I would bet, just so that people, [0:56:46] whereas I don't fall as well, it's actually in it, a little different. [0:56:49] But I think we're probably going to see quite a bit of what a few people are going to get [0:56:54] up that morning and drive up to be a part of the eclipse. [0:56:57] Yeah, so the hoteliers right now have seen really good filling rates. [0:57:01] So what they've done is in the hopes of extending the stay, [0:57:05] They're looking for multiple night stays versus just the single night stays. [0:57:09] So that's where their strategy is at the moment, but we are seeing some really heavy reservation rates, [0:57:14] which is great because that's a couple of months out and really it's already a busy time, [0:57:19] because it's the end of the season. People are already going on their vacation, [0:57:22] so this is just going to boost and extend that, which is fantastic. [0:57:26] Thank you. Chris, talk. [0:57:28] Yeah, I think it's worthwhile to remember that there are two parts of the eclipse. [0:57:34] So the Penumbra and the Umbra, the Inner and the Outer, and the Inner, which you're [0:57:40] talked about, the Path of Totality is 70 to 90 miles wide. [0:57:44] That's placed in the state of Idaho. [0:57:46] The sea is the top of Mount Bora, but I don't think there'll be many people up there. [0:57:50] You never know. [0:57:51] These people are. [0:57:52] But from the Craters of the Moon up on Idaho Falls, that's going to be jam-packed. [0:57:57] I'd really like to compliment you for this wonderful overview of the impact of tourism [0:58:02] and in our region as you stated as our fifth largest industry and throws in 27 million into [0:58:09] the Tills Twin Falls area directly related to tourism. [0:58:15] This brings to mind the issue of public lands because so many of the people come from areas [0:58:21] that have little if any public lands. [0:58:25] Do you have any or do you plan on doing any sort of survey work for the people that [0:58:31] you and the businesses come in contact with that would relate [0:58:36] wider coming here is it for these open areas is it fishing [0:58:41] hunting. I think you could do some follow on work on that and [0:58:45] really nail how important our public lands are, especially [0:58:49] to southern Idaho. [0:58:51] Yes, sir. We have plans actually for this season to do four [0:58:55] sets of survey results. So we're going to go to not only the [0:58:58] visitor centers but private areas where hospitality is important and then I [0:59:03] think you know depending on how tourism goes we'll probably wait and see maybe [0:59:07] we'll do one-inch-of-show and just kind of pinpoint where we think people will be [0:59:11] but that's part of that conversation is to figure out how 62% public plans so [0:59:17] we're making good advantages of job well done. Any other questions or comments [0:59:23] Thank you so much. [0:59:24] I get to see her every day down the halls. [0:59:29] Thanks, Melissa. [0:59:34] Next on the agenda is a request by people for pets for a change in the timing of their annual [0:59:40] audit. [0:59:41] We have Sarah Harris and Debbie Blackwood from Sarah Harris from People for Pets. [0:59:48] Thank you for being here this evening. [0:59:50] Thank you guys very much for having us again. [0:59:52] I'm Sarah Harris. [0:59:53] President of the Board of Directors for the Animal Shelter, and Debbie is our Executive Director. [1:00:00] People for Pets hires Debbie to run the Animal Shelter, but we, People for Pets, are the entity [1:00:06] that actually enters into a contract with the city to operate the Animal Shelter. [1:00:13] In December, we met with you, except for Christopher, you weren't here, and I want you to know that [1:00:18] my name is also Sarah Jane. [1:00:20] Okay, we came in December to meet in the middle so that we could get that contract signed, [1:00:29] and part of the contract involved an annual audit for the next five years, I guess, since [1:00:35] we're going to be entering into a contract that will last five years. [1:00:39] And at that meeting, it was decided that that audit would be completed by March. [1:00:47] It was, I think that we were a little bit taken aback because in October when we submitted [1:00:54] our budget to the city, our budget request to the city, we didn't think to put in a line [1:01:03] item for an audit or think to or have any way of asking our donors to maybe help with [1:01:11] than audit, not only that, but we asked for about $289,000 [1:01:20] from the city and received only $282,000, which was $7,000 [1:01:26] less than we had originally asked. [1:01:28] At the meeting in December, it was brought out primarily [1:01:32] because Don Hall was sitting at the dyes at that time, [1:01:36] and also pointed out by Brian that the county is not [1:01:41] holding their end of the deal up very well. [1:01:45] And we do, again, we've already gone to the county, [1:01:50] and we've received money for them for this fiscal year, [1:01:54] so it's not like we can go to them right now [1:01:56] and ask for additional money. [1:01:59] So anyway, we don't have a pile of money sitting around, [1:02:02] and we, so we were a little bit, a little bit sad. [1:02:08] And anyway, we did have a meeting with Brian and Travis, [1:02:17] and talked a little bit about how to proceed with the audit [1:02:24] process. [1:02:25] They were very, very helpful. [1:02:27] We went down after we talked to them [1:02:30] and talked with Brent, Hyatt, and Lori [1:02:32] race who are also incredibly helpful and Brent actually drew up a letter, a request for proposal [1:02:41] letter which we then sent out to 11 accounting firms in Twin Falls. Brent suggested that we [1:02:52] ask for three probabilities, I guess. [1:02:59] Number one is that we ask for a review of finances [1:03:02] rather than a full audit for our first year. [1:03:04] He felt that that might be a good way to get started, [1:03:07] that it would be less expensive. [1:03:10] He said that maybe what we should do is ask for [1:03:14] the price of an audit to be done in March [1:03:17] and the price of an audit to be done after tax season. [1:03:21] So we put all those into our request for proposal, [1:03:25] send it out to 11 accounting firms. [1:03:27] We've heard from three accounting firms. [1:03:31] Evans, Polson, Catmall, Deagle, Ames and Company, [1:03:35] and Dennis Brown. [1:03:38] And of those, [1:03:43] two of them said that they could finish an audit in March. [1:03:47] the price for an audit from Deagle and Ames in March, [1:03:52] six to $7,000 from Dennis Brown, 42 to $47,000. [1:04:00] I'm sorry, 4,200 to 4,700. [1:04:03] You knew that. [1:04:06] Anyway, a review of our books is considerably less. [1:04:13] Evans, Polson, and Catmull said they [1:04:16] could do a review of our books for $2,000, but not until after April 15th. [1:04:22] Deagle and Ames said they could do a review in March for between 4.5 and 5,000, and in [1:04:31] July for 3.5 and 4,000, so less a thousand. [1:04:38] Dennis Brown, he's a heck of a deal here in Twin Falls, said that he could do a review, [1:04:45] I guess any time for 900 to $1,100. [1:04:51] All three accounting firms raise their price by at least $1,000, [1:05:01] excuse me, lower their price by at least $1,000 [1:05:05] if we delay until after tax season and have, I guess, [1:05:10] a due date. [1:05:12] Deagle said that he couldn't do it until July. [1:05:15] So the other two said in June. [1:05:18] I don't know if that's the beginning of June or the end of June. [1:05:20] But anyway, for $1,000 less than to have it done at this moment in time. [1:05:32] So we're asking for an extension. [1:05:34] We feel not only will that give us a price break on the audit, [1:05:39] but it will hopefully help us to be able to maybe pull some money [1:05:44] from some sources, I don't know. [1:05:47] I got to say our donors are most of their, well, [1:05:53] I would say 100% of their donations [1:05:55] go to care for the animals and not for things like audits [1:06:01] and advertising and that kind of stuff. [1:06:05] So we don't really feel comfortable [1:06:07] about asking our donors to pay for this. [1:06:11] So, again, an extension would give us some time to figure out where that money, [1:06:16] or to get that money in line, and then also lower the price of the audit. [1:06:21] So, there you go. [1:06:23] Any questions? [1:06:24] Nikki Boyd. [1:06:26] How often does your board meet? [1:06:29] Well, we are required, or it's in our bylaws, that we meet every quarter. [1:06:37] But we meet, we have been meeting much more than every quarter. [1:06:42] Our last meeting was our open board meeting, which was in January. [1:06:48] So that was right after that December council meeting. [1:06:51] So I understand very much that the donors are interested in the animals. [1:06:57] But you are also running a business. [1:06:59] And you came before us in December. [1:07:03] How soon were you able to get the letters out? [1:07:07] We had the letter out with a requirement for them to reply by February 1st. [1:07:13] Okay. [1:07:16] Thank you. [1:07:19] In that time, we put on two planning, put on and put together two major fundraising events. [1:07:29] One was whiskers in Wonderland and the next one was our furball fundraiser. [1:07:35] So we had two huge, not to mention our annual meeting, but we had two huge events to put [1:07:42] together and orchestrate. [1:07:44] I was just making sure since you knew in December, did you properly plan ahead and try [1:07:50] to get this all done to meet the deadline? [1:07:54] I have to say that we had a deer in the headlights look for quite a while and that we did not [1:08:03] really get going until after we talked with Travis and Brian and Brent. [1:08:11] So you know we probably were not as proactive as we should have been. [1:08:20] Additionally too could be substantiated by Brian and Travis is that horrendous weather [1:08:27] we had delayed our first meeting with them was July, January 3rd, but it was delayed until [1:08:36] the 17th where we us four could all get together again. So it was very much, it seems a little [1:08:43] bit long, but it was actually fairly compact. Okay, thank you very much. [1:08:48] Chris talking to me. I'm ready to make a motion, but it looks like there's a couple of comments [1:08:53] here. Let's go. [1:08:54] I think my questions are more at city staff first of all. [1:08:59] So what is the difference between a financial review and an audit? [1:09:03] So I can't tell you because I'm not an accountant, but Brian and I both heard the review of the books conversation. [1:09:17] We felt that that was outside of the council's direction. [1:09:22] And I think that part of this conversation tonight is still going forward with the full audit piece. [1:09:29] But the question is more, is there the ability to delay [1:09:35] from a March during tax season approach and incorporate [1:09:41] that more into a June deadline? [1:09:46] My second question is, what happens if we deny the request? [1:09:54] If you deny the request, then people for pets [1:09:57] will have to complete the audit as originally requested by the council to be able to continue [1:10:05] to move forward. [1:10:08] So we will not have an animal shelter if we don't deny their request? [1:10:13] I mean, I don't understand what the consequences are because I feel like they asked for the [1:10:18] June when they were here in December and we said no. [1:10:21] And there were good reasons why we said no. [1:10:23] So I kind of feel like this is the second go around where we've already made a decision [1:10:27] and we're taking a step back. [1:10:30] So if we say no tonight, I mean what happens? [1:10:33] What do we? [1:10:37] Can I step in here real fast? [1:10:39] First of all, we didn't ask for a June back in December. [1:10:43] And I don't know if the minutes, if there's availability [1:10:46] of minutes, we did not ask for June. [1:10:48] We asked actually at that time if we could start [1:10:51] with the next fiscal year so I could put it in the budget. [1:10:55] So, we never asked for, we didn't ask for June back in December 5th. [1:11:02] We asked to put it off until the fiscal 16, no. [1:11:09] 17, 18, so I was allowed to put it, we were allowed to put it in our budget, [1:11:17] we would present to you in May, this coming May. [1:11:22] So I was just asking for a budgetary, a chance to put in the budget and formulate the financial part. [1:11:28] So that's, it is, it's not the same thing. [1:11:32] It was, we're asking for a full year now, we're just asking for a couple months. [1:11:37] In our industry, with no additional funding available at this time, $1,000 makes a world of difference, [1:11:46] $1,000 to $2,000. [1:11:48] It's a huge amount and back then, I think, when we discussed on December 5th, like I said, [1:11:57] this new, it was a surprise to us that we didn't hear at contract times that we were required [1:12:06] to do an audit until December, and lost my train of thought here, but that was a difficult [1:12:17] thing. [1:12:18] saying okay we didn't think that we didn't think about March being tax season for these [1:12:25] accountants and it was brought up in many discussions or at least between the board and [1:12:31] even with us the city personnel that perhaps being that's tax season or that we could actually [1:12:38] ask for a little bit of a break or get some better bits which we have if we didn't have [1:12:44] to do it in March, so if that's verified that for you, so. [1:12:48] That helps with that part, but still, I don't understand, [1:12:51] do we really have a choice? [1:12:53] I mean. [1:12:57] Well, I haven't heard people for pets say [1:13:00] that they're going to walk away from the animal shelter. [1:13:02] I mean, I haven't heard that. [1:13:04] So right now, we're working on a month to month [1:13:06] because we haven't signed the contract because of the audit, [1:13:08] or where I'm really trying to. [1:13:11] That's right. [1:13:12] So that would continue? [1:13:14] I think that that's at the discretion of the council. [1:13:16] the Council feels that the original contract that you've set forward is the relationship [1:13:25] that you want to have with people for pets, then the answer is to deny their request and [1:13:32] have them complete that within their time frame. [1:13:35] The idea was that they presented was to find a way to find flexibility in the date to be [1:13:43] be able to save them resources to be able to complete the audit. [1:13:48] We spent time with them in our meeting, sharing why the audit was important, [1:13:54] and why the city had to go forward with its fiduciary responsibility. [1:13:58] These are taxpayer dollars, and when we issue taxpayer dollars, [1:14:02] we want to make sure that those dollars are being committed to a purpose that we had described. [1:14:07] And that not performing an audit was not [1:14:12] They answered that we believe the Council of Support, and it certainly wasn't a solution [1:14:16] that the staff would support. [1:14:18] So the next place was how do you find an opportunity to lessen that cost if you follow the supply [1:14:25] and demand of availability of accountants? [1:14:27] We all know that this is not the best time to be procuring additional service from accountants. [1:14:33] So we said is there a possibility that you could extend that most of the accountants [1:14:38] that I know of, tend to like to take a vacation after April 15th for a period of time, and so [1:14:45] we are trying to say, is there a way that you could get out of taxis and have them back in the [1:14:51] office and then have this maybe do by a June 1st deadline to be able to submit? So that really is [1:14:58] the proposal before you tonight. But this was in the contract in October, so it should not have [1:15:03] have come in a surprise of December, is that correct? [1:15:07] So the contract was originally proposed in October? [1:15:12] No. [1:15:13] We really didn't finalize it until I know we had conversations, [1:15:18] probably at some point in November, [1:15:19] but finalized in December. [1:15:21] And the other thing I think is important to understand here, [1:15:24] too, is that moving the time frame of the audit this year [1:15:27] would not impact subsequent years. [1:15:30] So in other words, the proposal that I'm [1:15:32] saying from Dennis Brown here, if this [1:15:33] is the one that they decide to go with, shows a price for a June audit, and then it shows [1:15:39] in year two and three an audit that would take place in December. So moving forward, they [1:15:44] would fall right in line with the contract language of supplying the city an audit within [1:15:48] six months of the closing of their fiscal year. [1:15:51] Thank you. That makes me feel much better. [1:15:53] Any other comments or questions from anyone? If not, Chris Dockington. [1:16:00] Well, I think it's important to realize we also didn't have an audit from the YMCA. So [1:16:04] This is not the only organization that does business on a non-profit basis with the city. [1:16:11] We're trying to bring people for pets organization online with a legitimate request, any kind [1:16:20] of public money is involved. [1:16:22] I think we need to help people for pets. [1:16:26] It's a great deal. [1:16:27] Public safety is involved with maintaining animal control. [1:16:31] we look at as friendly furry animals, but there's also the public health that we can't underestimate [1:16:37] as a vital service for us. I would be very supportive of agreeing to extend the time frame [1:16:45] for the this year's annual audit until July of 2017 and the city to supply $1,000 toward [1:16:54] that audit. [1:16:55] I think that's a motion [1:16:58] Motion by Chris Togginton seconded by a great landing to approve an extension [1:17:03] To july 2017 for the audit this year and to commit a thousand dollars from city funds to assist with the funding for that [1:17:12] Are you talking July 1 or July 30 days? [1:17:18] We have very one days [1:17:20] is there do you have a [1:17:22] a proposed date on the bid that you suspect you may be going with? [1:17:27] June, July. We didn't specify. [1:17:30] Oh, man, that to July 31st. [1:17:34] Nikki Boyd. [1:17:40] You ready for discussion? Yes. [1:17:45] It appears that they can get it done at a discount by June 1st. [1:17:52] And I believe I would like, I already asked my questions. [1:17:57] And so I'm disappointed that we couldn't get it going [1:18:00] and have it happen by March, because that's what we wanted. [1:18:03] But it's a, I love pets, you know, [1:18:07] but we have to have an audit. [1:18:10] As Chris said, everybody that we're partners with, [1:18:13] we have to know exactly where our citizens money go. [1:18:17] And so the June, I would be willing to extend it to June 1st. [1:18:24] Nikki, the one, and I appreciate all that you're all saying. [1:18:29] We're on board the best we can, believe me. [1:18:33] But Dennis Brown is a firm that I think is much less expensive. [1:18:39] And he says in here, and he's planning, and I can provide you with a copy. [1:18:45] We plan to conduct our audit at the corporate financials during June for the first year. [1:18:52] and start the audit during the first week of December in subsequent years. [1:18:59] So I think if you want Dennis Brown to do that and his prices are much less expensive, [1:19:08] it sounds to me by his proposal, [1:19:11] his statement that he would need the month of June. [1:19:15] Okay, Susan, that happens. [1:19:20] Thank you. I will be voting against this motion not because I don't want to give you the extension, but I don't think we are should be obligated for $1,000 towards that. [1:19:30] So I just want you to understand why I'm voting the way I am before it comes to you. [1:19:37] Chris Reed, I don't have a problem with the extension moving it out to be able to get that done, especially at a discounted price. [1:19:44] It's the $1,000 throwing that in there. So with the current motion, the way it is, I'll be voting no. [1:19:50] further discussion. So the motion on the table by Chris [1:20:03] Stockington and seconded by Greg Lanting is to approve the [1:20:06] request to extend the deadline for the audit to July 31st, 2017, and [1:20:13] to provide $1,000 toward funding that audit. So with that [1:20:22] chair and roll call vote please. [1:20:31] Chris Hockington? [1:20:32] Yes. [1:20:33] Greg Lanting? [1:20:34] Yes. [1:20:35] Christopher Reed? [1:20:36] No. [1:20:37] Ruth Pierce? [1:20:37] No. [1:20:38] Susanne Hawkins, no, Nikki Boyd, no, Sean Bericher. [1:20:44] Yes, motion fails, three to four, Greg Lanting. [1:20:52] I move that we extend the deadline to July 31st. [1:20:56] Second. [1:20:58] Motion by Greg Lanting, second by Susanne Hawkins [1:21:00] to approve the request to extend the deadline for the audit [1:21:04] to July 31st, 2017. [1:21:06] Is there any discussion? [1:21:09] Sharon will call please Greg Lanting. Yes, Christopher Reed. Yes with peers. Yes, Suzanne Hawkins. Yes, Nikki Boyd. Yes, Sean Baraker. Yes, Chris Hockington. Yes. Excuse me. I know who's here. I think you're pushing passes seven zero. Thank you for your presentation tonight and [1:21:33] Thank you. [1:21:35] You can look forward to, I guess, great things in July. [1:21:41] Next on the agenda again is another opportunity for public input. [1:21:50] If there's anyone here from the public who wishes to address the council on any issues, [1:21:53] now's your opportunity. [1:21:55] Seeing no one, items from the city manager, Mr. Rothwein. [1:22:03] Mr. Mayor, members of the council, as it has been reported, the city of Twin Falls and [1:22:09] The YMCA have taken steps at the request of the Y to dissolve our relationship and at the [1:22:20] request of the Y for the city to then take back over the operations of the pool. [1:22:25] We wanted the record to reflect that, although it's been widely reported, the last conversation [1:22:30] that we left for our record was that the city staff was going to begin negotiations with the [1:22:38] why on possible changes of terms, those conversations now have shifted to more of a transition of [1:22:49] operations and we will continue to keep you informed as we have those but again we just [1:22:54] wanted the record to reflect that there has been an evolution in that conversation. [1:23:00] The next thing is that right now we are anticipating that there will not be a meeting the week [1:23:08] of spring break, which would be the meeting [1:23:12] on the evening of the 20th. [1:23:16] We will know for certain next week, [1:23:19] but right now that meeting is completely clear [1:23:22] and we're not, and at this point in time, [1:23:24] we're not anticipating any issues [1:23:25] that we need to be taken care of [1:23:27] or could not be taken the week before or the week after. [1:23:31] And also this week, we have several of our employees [1:23:34] once again going through our One City training, [1:23:37] The one city training this year is being hosted at First Federal. [1:23:42] If you have a few moments between now and close a business on Wednesday, [1:23:48] probably Wednesday, noon, swing by, say hi. [1:23:52] There are 49, 40, there are 40 individuals that are going through that team building exercise again this year. [1:24:03] Thank you, Travis. [1:24:07] Can I thank you from the council? [1:24:09] Suzanne Hawkins. [1:24:10] Thank you. [1:24:11] Well, it's that time of year again. [1:24:12] I got my email from Paint Magic requesting that the city provide another paint team this [1:24:18] year, so I'm bringing it up to the council to see if there's anybody who's opposed to [1:24:23] us doing so. [1:24:24] I'm not opposed and I'm a terrible painter. [1:24:29] Well, if anybody would like to talk to Captain with me this year, I've done two years now, [1:24:34] So I'd be willing to share the opportunity with anyone who's willing. [1:24:39] So anyway, if everybody's good, we'll commit then. [1:24:44] I see no strong objections. [1:24:47] Thank you. [1:24:48] As long as it's understood, we're not sponsoring or underwriting the event. [1:24:53] Just have a team because of personal liability on property. [1:24:58] Strictly volunteer. [1:25:00] Greg Lansing. [1:25:03] Since the, probably got more phone calls in the last few weeks [1:25:11] than I have had in my entire council career concern, [1:25:14] worried, not really complaining, [1:25:16] but worried about the condition [1:25:17] that the winner has caused upon our roads. [1:25:20] Is there a chance that we could have public works, [1:25:21] maybe at some future meeting, [1:25:24] I'm not talking anywhere quick, [1:25:26] but what their plan is and what kind of funds [1:25:29] we may be training to come up with to do this? [1:25:33] I live on Elm and from Addison to Linwood Shopping Center, the road is going away and I just [1:25:42] can't imagine how much I know other areas of the city are doing the same thing and we've [1:25:47] had an estimate given to us of dying million and things like that. [1:25:50] I just wanted to see if we could get it up to eight somewhere along the line in the next [1:25:55] few weeks to what the plan is and what kind of funds we need to be looking at to get [1:26:02] We've done what we need to get done. [1:26:03] Yes, certainly. [1:26:04] Last week we had shared that when the Council proposed the question, there's a series of [1:26:10] different steps that we're going to take that are ranging from we will patch the pothole [1:26:15] and then we'll do a chip seal over the top of it to there are sections that just merely [1:26:19] patching the pothole won't work because the base isn't of strength or the alligatoring and [1:26:27] the cracking that's occurring is going to cause us to use our zipper and then to do like a [1:26:31] a million overlay type scenario. [1:26:36] As we shared last week, resources that we have are limited in terms of what we have to be able [1:26:45] to fix the problems. [1:26:47] I think that we'll have a lot better idea, so since the last conversation that we've had, [1:26:52] there appears to be some movement at the legislative level. [1:26:58] There's about anywhere between 56 and I've heard as high as $100 million that could be [1:27:06] appropriated to local governments across the state in a one time infusion of cash to assist [1:27:14] with the roads and the infrastructure. [1:27:18] There's also some conversation about increases in gas tax temporarily and lots of other steps. [1:27:27] The more dollars that we have from an outside source allows us to really carry the fixed [1:27:35] amount of resources that we have moving forward. [1:27:40] As that kind of matures and the legislative session adjourns, we'll have a much better [1:27:46] idea of the resources that we have and the resources that we're going to be able to commit. [1:27:54] One of the things that's important to remember is that when we started this fiscal year we [1:27:58] didn't anticipate this winter and I'm not aware of a single entity that did. [1:28:03] So it would require us to use cash reserves in the street fund to be able to advance projects [1:28:12] that are outside of the course of the budget. [1:28:15] While we do have healthy reserves in the street fund, I think it would be incredibly difficult [1:28:22] to pull off $9 million and still carry on the maintenance activities moving forward. [1:28:29] John and his team will be able to come in and so maybe what we can do is tentatively [1:28:34] schedule that for like the first or second meeting in April. [1:28:38] Now that we have the understanding that the legislative session should adjourn closer to [1:28:44] the end of March of this year. [1:28:46] appreciate it. I just, as what you were saying, I obviously the north end of Elmer's gonna need a zipper and the whole line. [1:28:55] You're sure it's, it's gone. At least, at least the northbound lane is. And so, appreciate it. Thanks, Deb. [1:29:02] Anything better in your back? Yeah, well, it's just, I figured it, it seems to be, as I was going down, [1:29:09] Bull likes today thinking, what are we gonna do about traffic on Bull likes? I think Elmer's becoming some of those outside [1:29:15] streets are starting to become a surrogate for bull eggs and so they're [1:29:24] getting a lot more traffic than they've ever had before so even though they're [1:29:28] a residential street they're not being treated like one right now so well it's [1:29:32] definitely a top-of-mind issue when I read Dr. Seuss's book to 2nd graders [1:29:37] last week at Morningside Elementary one of these 2nd graders asked me if I was [1:29:41] going to be out fixing the pothole. [1:29:43] We'll get down. [1:29:47] Get right on there. [1:29:49] Down the hood. [1:29:51] Anything else from the council? [1:29:55] All right, meeting adjourned.