Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2016-10-10, recording 1 (started 17:00) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2016-10-10/ [0:05:35] It is. I'd like to call to order the Twin Falls City Council meeting for Monday, October 3rd. [0:05:47] Those of you wishing to join me please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance. [0:05:51] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. [0:06:11] We do have a quorum of the council this evening. [0:06:15] Six members are here this evening. [0:06:17] Councilwoman Nikki Boyd is running a little late and she will join us soon. [0:06:21] Mr. Rothweiler, are there any amendments to the agenda this evening? [0:06:24] Mr. Mayor, members of the council, there are no amendments this evening. [0:06:27] Thank you, sir. [0:06:28] We do have a couple of proclamations this evening. [0:06:31] I'll start off with proclamation for Xavier Charter Schools Day. [0:06:36] Whereas Xavier Charter Schools was granted Idaho Charter School status [0:06:40] on December 15th, 2006, as the first independent charter serving Twin Falls and surrounding [0:06:47] Magic Valley communities, and whereas Xavier Charter Schools has provided a classical education [0:06:53] model based on the Trivium to students in the Magic Valley for the last 10 years, and whereas [0:07:00] Xavier Charter Schools primary mission has been to nurture its students in virtue, thus [0:07:05] preparing them for every duty of life through recognition of the good, the beautiful, and [0:07:09] true, and whereas Xavier Charter Schools has committed to carrying forth the founding fathers [0:07:15] hope that American schools teach students how to preserve a constitutional republic, and [0:07:20] whereas Xavier Charter Schools has participated in community service that reflects responsible [0:07:26] citizenship in a democratic society, and whereas Xavier Charter Schools began with 267 students, [0:07:33] Today has 683 students enrolled and has graduated 83 students since 2008, and whereas other charter [0:07:41] schools in Idaho have struggled financially to stay open due to inequities of facility funding, [0:07:47] Xavier Charter Schools has attained financial stability with plans for expansion, and whereas [0:07:52] Xavier Charter School students have tested in the top 15% on the SAT, now therefore be [0:07:59] he had resolved that I, Mayor Sean Barrager, [0:08:01] to hereby proclaim December 15th, 2016, [0:08:04] as Xavier Charter Schools Day, [0:08:06] and call upon the citizens of the City of Twin Falls [0:08:09] to honor Xavier Charter Schools for its success [0:08:12] and service to the people of Twin Falls [0:08:14] for the last 10 years. [0:08:15] In here to accept this this evening is John Capularis. [0:08:47] Mayor and Council, I'm John Capularis. [0:08:50] And when I first heard about Xavier Charter School, [0:08:52] I was living outside of the DC area in Waldorf, Maryland. [0:08:56] It was 2011. [0:08:59] At the turn of the decade, the Classical Charter School had struggled and faced closure. [0:09:04] Luckily, I am able to tell you this story as the chairperson of the Board of Directors [0:09:09] in 2016. [0:09:12] The 15th of December, 2006, was when our charter was granted. [0:09:17] We've come a long way since then when Xavier was a small school located on North College [0:09:22] where the Plasma Center currently stands. [0:09:26] This story is not yet finished. [0:09:29] We have much work ahead of us. [0:09:32] Xavier Charter School is an important asset to the Magic Valley. [0:09:35] I would like to point out two ways in which we are an important asset. [0:09:40] First, we are one of the very few classical schools in the state and in the western United [0:09:45] States. [0:09:46] We provide a true alternative choice to parents and educators. [0:09:50] Second, we help alleviate the overcrowding of the Twin Falls School District, [0:09:54] providing a lighter tax burden on the local property owners. [0:09:59] Xavier Charter Schools provides the travium, or the three ways. [0:10:04] This method of education was spelled out most clearly by quintillion during the first century AD. [0:10:10] The three ways are grammar, logic, and rhetoric, [0:10:14] and corresponding directly to our grammar school, logic school, and rhetoric school. [0:10:20] It culminates ultimately in civic virtue. [0:10:23] In our philosophy statement, we say, no nobler training exists but that which cherishes the [0:10:27] good, the beautiful, and the true, thus producing disciples of knowledge and lovers of wisdom. [0:10:34] Contract popular belief, charter schools in Idaho do not get the same amount of money [0:10:39] for facility funding as traditional public schools. [0:10:42] Idaho charter schools receive similar amounts of money from the state but cannot partake [0:10:47] and local levies, which provide so much in the way of facility funding. [0:10:53] Charters must take what they get and not throw a fit. [0:10:57] Many charters have closed due to this fiscal environment. [0:11:00] Some must fundraise every year simply to pay for operating expenses. [0:11:05] At Xavier Charter School, we have such great demand for students to come to our school, [0:11:09] we must expand. [0:11:12] Though we have been good stewards of our finances, we need to expand and eventually replicate [0:11:19] in order to meet the need. [0:11:21] Enrollment is up and we are busting at the seams and have a waiting list large enough [0:11:25] to start another school. [0:11:28] In order to expand and replicate, we must begin a capital campaign because we cannot [0:11:34] raise a levy like the Twin Falls School District Camp. [0:11:38] I am sure this move will prove difficult, but these are good problems to have. [0:11:45] If we are successful, it will provide parents with a viable choice and ease the burden on [0:11:51] the Twin Falls school districts overcrowding and therefore ease the burden on the property [0:11:55] owners who will have to fund any new levies, thus meeting the Twin Falls City strategic [0:12:02] plan of being an education community. [0:12:05] Thank you for supporting and proclaiming our decennial. [0:12:09] We hope to do this again in another 10 years. [0:12:12] Thank you, John. [0:12:19] And then we have another proclamation, Baby Safe Haven Awareness Day. [0:12:24] Whereas the goal of National Baby Safe Haven Awareness Day is to prevent the deaths of newborn [0:12:29] infants and to provide parents with a responsible safe mechanism to relinquish a newborn. [0:12:35] And whereas parents who relinquish their infants can now leave them in the care of hospitals, [0:12:39] Physician offices, clinics, medical personnel responding to 911 calls, nurses and physician [0:12:45] assistants without facing prosecution if the child is dropped off within 30 days of birth. [0:12:51] And whereas the Infant Abandonment Act was signed into law on July 1st, 2001 in the state of [0:12:56] Idaho, and whereas Safe Haven programs have been started in all 50 states and the District [0:13:01] of Columbia to promote awareness and to ensure that all birth mothers are given all their [0:13:06] options, and whereas many local safe haven programs have combined efforts with the National [0:13:11] Safe Haven Alliance in further efforts to prevent infanticide and unsafe newborn abandonment through [0:13:17] safe haven relinquishments. [0:13:20] Now therefore, I, Sean Barrigher, Mayor of Twin Falls, Idaho, do hereby proclaim the day Monday, [0:13:25] October 3, 2016, to be Baby Safe Haven Awareness Day in the City of Twin Falls, Idaho, and I [0:13:32] I call upon the residents of the city to join with me to encourage all citizens to work together [0:13:36] to promote an increased awareness and understanding of this important initiative. [0:13:42] Do we have someone from the CSI paramedic? [0:13:44] There you are. [0:13:45] This is Mckenzie. [0:14:07] We are your second semester paramedic students at the College of Southern Idaho. [0:14:11] During the first semester we required to do a community outreach project. [0:14:15] We noticed that since Angel Rose was found there had been no safe haven awareness in our [0:14:21] community or even in our state for a long time. So we decided to do a safe haven PSA. [0:14:26] We got a lot of support from some new agencies to help us put a video together. [0:14:31] We thought we were just going to put this little video together and put it on [0:14:34] Facebook and that's all it was going to be and it turned out even bigger than we can imagine. [0:14:39] We did an awareness day and we got support from the entire community, [0:14:44] fire, law enforcement, Twin Falls City, Twin Falls County, the hospital, [0:14:49] hospital, match value paramedics, there was so many people there. [0:14:53] Then we received a phone call from Timothy Jacquard, who is the founder of Safe Haven. [0:15:01] And he called us congratulating us on what we did and has supported us through the entire [0:15:06] situation. [0:15:09] So with getting recognition from Timothy Jacquard, he has actually donated signs to [0:15:17] be placed on fire departments, paramedics, stations, hospitals, [0:15:22] basically anywhere that you can actually hand your baby over [0:15:26] and have a safe haven place. [0:15:28] So what we're showing you guys today [0:15:30] is that these will be the signs set out [0:15:33] in front of the buildings that I have named. [0:15:39] Just explaining that there are safe haven place, [0:15:42] that we recommend that if nobody is there, [0:15:45] that it has a phone number to be given stating [0:15:49] what the actual act is in English and in Spanish as well. [0:15:54] For our community, so not only are we giving this awareness [0:15:58] out to people, but it doesn't stop there. [0:16:01] The signs are going to be put on the buildings [0:16:03] to forever be stand there. [0:16:05] So with that, in mind, we thank you guys for all your support. [0:16:09] Great. [0:16:10] Thank you very much. [0:16:11] Present these signs from both of these. [0:16:43] I'm sure it's going to be a council meeting. [0:16:44] You bet. [0:16:50] Thank you very much. [0:17:16] Moving on to the agenda, next is general public input. [0:17:19] If I could get somebody from staff to check the sign up sheet for me, please. [0:17:45] So signed up to address the council. [0:17:47] We have Lee Strandahan. [0:17:50] Welcome, Lee. [0:17:53] If you could please state your name and address and if you would please limit your comments [0:17:57] to three minutes. [0:17:58] We'd appreciate it. [0:17:59] Sure. [0:18:00] My name is Lee Strandahan. [0:18:01] I live in Twin Falls. [0:18:02] and good afternoon, Mr. Mayor, members of City Council. [0:18:05] Last week I talked about downtown development a little bit, [0:18:09] and I'd like to continue on that theme. [0:18:12] Last week I mentioned the importance, I think, [0:18:14] of getting some sort of sense of what anchor businesses, [0:18:18] businesses that would draw people to the downtown area, [0:18:23] should be considered. [0:18:25] What I'd like to talk about this week [0:18:26] and urge you to strongly consider [0:18:30] I've looked into the issue of downtown development a little bit, and I'm not telling you anything [0:18:35] you don't know here probably. [0:18:37] There are a number of different interests at work here. [0:18:41] For instance, there's the people who are downtown currently, the business owners. [0:18:45] There's the property owners, a number of whom are absentee owners. [0:18:48] A lot of the buildings downtown are owned by people who are not in Twin Falls currently. [0:18:53] You've got the historical society, you've got the downtown redevelopment project, you've [0:18:57] We've got other businesses in the area at the development meeting that Sir Watweiler [0:19:04] did a presentation at a couple of weeks ago, some of the business owners who aren't in [0:19:09] downtown express some concerns about the area. [0:19:13] So here's what I'm suggesting practically. [0:19:15] I think what's needed at this point, and this has been suggested by other people, but I [0:19:21] just want to lay out a couple of parameters I think are important, is you need to sort [0:19:25] of come to Jesus meeting where, you know, I'm using it not literally, but you know, you [0:19:31] need a meeting where everybody gets together and people can express their concerns. [0:19:36] And I think getting public input on this is also important. [0:19:40] Some people at a historical society meeting, this came up a couple of weeks ago, they were [0:19:44] saying, well, we don't know if we want input from these people. [0:19:46] I think what you need initially is something where everybody can come in and in an honest [0:19:51] atmosphere and not trying to solve every problem at that one meeting. [0:19:55] But people can say, this is what I'm concerned about, this is what I'm concerned about, and [0:19:59] at least we can lay those out on the table at first. [0:20:02] I think that's a good first step to starting to solve it because there are practical problems [0:20:08] that definitely involve certain things, the city council and the city manager, have to [0:20:12] deal with, for instance, zoning concerns, issues about building code that are keeping [0:20:17] certain development from happening down there without getting into the weeds. [0:20:20] the kind of general stuff I'm talking about. And I think that it's about time to, especially [0:20:26] with the investment, and the reason I'm suggesting this now is because you've obviously, you're [0:20:32] into this already, right? The project is well underway. So I think it's a good time to start [0:20:37] to talk about what comes next after the city hall is up, after the work on Maine is done, [0:20:45] that's going to happen and everything. And so that's one thing I would just like you [0:20:48] to consider is it about time to start laying out [0:20:51] what the situation is bringing everybody together [0:20:54] and then moving forward together to try to get some solutions [0:20:57] for the problems that come up there. [0:20:59] Thanks very much for your time. [0:21:00] Appreciate it. [0:21:01] Thank you, Mr. Shanahan. [0:21:03] Great landing. [0:21:04] Lee. [0:21:08] This is, and I'm not saying that your ideas [0:21:11] are an excellent one and we probably should do [0:21:12] especially after we get the new city hall and things there. [0:21:16] But I probably personally myself, [0:21:18] of a 10 similar meetings over the last 15 years [0:21:23] about downtown or we brought in all the stakeholders [0:21:26] brought in the public, met right here in this room, [0:21:30] had good crowds at times too. [0:21:32] And so it's not something that has been not been occurring [0:21:35] but I do agree with you after the new city hall [0:21:38] it's possible that another one would be a good idea. [0:21:41] I just wanted to didn't want you to think [0:21:43] that they hadn't been occurring because they have been. [0:21:45] I appreciate clarifying, just so you know, I am aware of that. [0:21:48] And I'm also aware that it's obviously a complex issue, [0:21:51] and that's like I say that I'm aware that there's been stuff in the past. [0:21:56] And what I'm suggesting is you're probably going to need a series of meetings, one or two, [0:22:03] because it's a tangle, right? [0:22:04] There's a lot of conflicting interest in everybody's got an opinion. [0:22:07] And so you're probably going to need one or two meetings just to get on the record for everybody [0:22:13] what the actual problems are, and then solving them is going to be, you know, that's going to go in ten different directions. [0:22:20] But I agree with you, what's the schedule in the city hall? I forget what the specific schedule in the city hall being up to. [0:22:26] Yeah, so we will go out to bid in November of 16, and we estimate that there'll be somewhere between a 10 to 12 month construction, [0:22:35] and so at the latest we'll be in in November of 2017. [0:22:40] The only thing I would say just to respond to your point and appreciate you making it, [0:22:46] is that because of some of the other work that's going on now, there might be, and again, [0:22:53] I'm not a meeting person. [0:22:55] I'm not an endless meeting person. [0:22:58] So I think your concern is for not having too many meetings is well-founded, but with [0:23:04] the work that I know is going to be going on there soon, for instance, are about to [0:23:08] to start ripping up Maine to put to do work on sewage [0:23:11] and other stuff in there, great. [0:23:13] I think it's a good time, but I think sooner or better [0:23:16] to at least lay out some of the concerns. [0:23:17] So I appreciate you saying that, but that's my suggestion. [0:23:22] All right, anything else? [0:23:24] I appreciate it, Mr. Lanting. [0:23:26] Thanks. [0:23:28] Thank you, Mr. Schoonan. [0:23:31] So that's the only person who had signed up, [0:23:33] so anyone else who wishes to address the council [0:23:35] on any item this evening? [0:23:39] Seeing no one, we will move on with the balance of our agenda. [0:23:43] First up is the consent calendar, council wishes. [0:23:46] Move to approve. [0:23:49] Second. [0:23:50] Motion by Chris Tockington, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins [0:23:53] to approve the consent calendar. [0:23:55] Is there any discussion? [0:23:58] Seeing none, Sharon, roll call vote please. [0:24:01] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:24:02] Yes. [0:24:04] Sean Berriger. [0:24:05] Yes. [0:24:06] Chris Tockington. [0:24:07] Yes. [0:24:07] Greg Lanthine. [0:24:08] Yes. [0:24:09] Don Hall. [0:24:10] Yes. [0:24:11] Ruth Pierce. [0:24:12] Yes. [0:24:12] Motion passes six to zero. [0:24:15] Under items for consideration, the first [0:24:17] is the Twin Falls Fire Department. [0:24:19] We'd like to recognize the achievements [0:24:20] of firefighter Jared Sauer, who has completed his firefighter [0:24:23] at level one certification, and we have Ron Aguirre. [0:24:27] Welcome, Ron. [0:24:30] Thank you, Mr. Mayor. [0:24:32] Good evening, Mr. Mayor, City Council. [0:24:34] My name is Ron Aguirre, and on behalf of the Twin Falls Fire [0:24:37] Department, I would like to thank you for your support [0:24:40] in recognizing firefighter Jared Sauer [0:24:42] for his recent accomplishment of achieving [0:24:45] his firefighter level one. [0:24:46] Jared Sauer was born and raised in Jerome Heidehope. [0:24:59] He graduated from Jerome High School and attended CSI for two years. [0:25:04] In 2008, he was hired by the US Forest Service and worked as a wildland firefighter until the spring of 2015. [0:25:11] Jared is happily married to his wife, Sarah, and they have two boys, Weston and Brody. [0:25:16] Jared joined the Twin Falls City Fire Department on August 3, 2015, [0:25:21] and recently completed his firefighter level one program. [0:25:24] Firefighter 1 consists of classes and practical exercises that include the incident command [0:25:29] system, hazardous materials awareness, extrication awareness, and CPR. [0:25:35] In total, Jared has completed over 360 hours of fire service training and an additional [0:25:41] 155 hours of special operations training. [0:25:46] Once all the coursework and practical exercises are completed, a recruit is given a final, [0:25:52] practical and written exam in which the recruit must score an 80 percent or higher. [0:25:58] I'm happy to announce that Jared has performed extremely well over the past year and has demonstrated [0:26:03] the skill and ability to receive his Twin Falls Fire Department firefighter one certification. [0:26:09] Jared, congratulations on this accomplishment. [0:26:12] You are no longer a recruit firefighter. [0:26:14] Today, we are proud to call you a professional Twin Falls firefighter. [0:26:19] On behalf of the Fire Department Administration, we would also like to thank the members of [0:26:24] the department that helped Jared over the past year, including members of the training office [0:26:28] and team members on his engine company. [0:26:31] At this time, I would invite Mayor Baradour to present Jared with his Firefighter One certificate [0:26:38] and his new helmet shield. [0:26:51] Jared, congratulations and thank you to all of our firefighters for their professionalism [0:27:19] and service in the community. [0:27:22] on the agenda as a request to adopt the collective bargaining agreement between the [0:27:25] City of Twin Falls and Twin Falls Firefighters Local 1556 and we have Susan Harris, our Human [0:27:31] Resources Director. Welcome, Susan. [0:27:33] Thank you. Good evening, Mayor and Council. And before we get on to our agenda item, I'll [0:27:39] apologize because it was me who took the sign-up sheet last week inadvertently, so sharing [0:27:45] and apologize, was in with some enrollment materials and it just got picked up and I didn't catch [0:27:51] it until after your meeting. So I apologize for that. But I am pleased to be here this [0:27:58] evening to present to you the draft copy of the collective bargaining agreement. This agreement [0:28:05] is between the City of Twin Falls and the Twin Falls Firefighters Local 1556. As my staff [0:28:12] report indicated, members of the executive team with a local who consist of Dave Owens, [0:28:22] Gerald Dilman and Jesse Bowman met with City Administration and we've been meeting the last [0:28:29] few months to go over just information, share information about salary and benefits that [0:28:36] were coming into play beginning October 1st, as well as go over some items that they had [0:28:43] wanted to discuss. [0:28:45] At the conclusion of these meetings, we have primarily just three changes to bring forward [0:28:50] in the draft. [0:28:52] The first one is changing the contract from a two-year, as it's been in past years, to [0:28:59] a one-year agreement. [0:29:01] This allows the new chief to come into an organization, gives him a time to become familiar [0:29:06] with the department, and it allows the firefighters to open up the negotiations again at the conclusion [0:29:14] of that year. [0:29:16] The second change can be found on page 10. [0:29:20] It is in reference to Section 22, which is Manning of Companies. [0:29:26] The expanded language that you'll see in the contract just clearly identifies kind of the [0:29:32] make-up of the shift that is recommended. [0:29:36] It also allows for a four-hour period of time so that the Manning can drop below the Manning [0:29:43] requirements in the event of an emergency situation, gives flexibility to the command staff of [0:29:50] the fire department as well as to individuals who may have an unforeseen emergency and they [0:29:57] need to leave. So that language is in there to help both parties. [0:30:04] The last change is just some language that's been added to the appeal process under discipline. [0:30:11] It's in appendix B of the draft. And it just provides an opportunity for both parties to [0:30:18] come together to have a discussion of the issue at hand prior to requiring mediation and binding [0:30:25] arbitration. So both parties were in agreement with this when it was put together and Dave, [0:30:34] do you want to come up and say something now? Dave Owens, President of the 12th Firefighters [0:30:47] Local 1556, I just wanted to stand up here and publicly thank Travis and Brian and Susan [0:30:54] for working with us during the collective bargaining agreement. [0:30:59] This is my first time actually working with the city [0:31:01] and going through all the negotiations, and it was incredible. [0:31:06] They did a great job working with us, [0:31:08] keeping the communication open. [0:31:10] I just want to public you to say thank you. [0:31:11] So that's it. [0:31:12] Thank you, thanks. [0:31:15] Donald. [0:31:17] Susan, under the Manning of Companies, it looks like, [0:31:20] maybe I just missed it in your presentation, [0:31:23] that there's really no change because it was 11 before, excluding the battalion chief, now it's 12, including the, so it's just a language change. [0:31:35] It's just, I think, kind of a more detailed explanation of how it will work. [0:31:41] Okay. [0:31:42] So the numbers haven't really changed, just kind of an explanation of the positions. [0:31:48] Thank you. [0:31:49] Chris talking. I just like to relate during my experience with the city that our meaning management relationship with the [0:31:58] firefighter union members and management staff has been most exemplary. I would put [0:32:05] Twin Falls relationship with this fire crew up against any that I'm aware of certainly an Idaho and [0:32:12] probably far beyond its boundaries and I think that [0:32:15] is because of several [0:32:17] There's been a lot of trust engendered going both ways. [0:32:22] We have a flat organization, and we know what our mission is. [0:32:27] Sometimes we perhaps work a little bit too hard in one area [0:32:32] and forget about some other areas. [0:32:35] But we come back and keep our eye on the mission. [0:32:38] I'm really proud of our relationship we have with the Fire Department. [0:32:42] Thank you all. [0:32:43] And let's keep that trust at the level that it has maintained for years. [0:32:48] Rick Pierce. [0:32:53] Are you ready for a motion, Sean? [0:32:55] I am. [0:32:56] I would make a motion that he adopt the collective bargaining agreement for the period October [0:33:02] 1, 2016 to September 30, 2017. [0:33:07] The agreement is between the City of Twin Falls and the Twin Falls Firefighters Local 1556. [0:33:13] Second. [0:33:14] Motion by Rick Pierce. [0:33:15] motion by Ruth Pierce, seconded by Don Hall to adopt the collective bargaining agreement [0:33:20] as presented. [0:33:21] Is there any further discussion? [0:33:25] Seeing none, Sharon, roll call vote, please. [0:33:27] Sean Barriker? [0:33:28] Yes. [0:33:29] Chris Talkington? [0:33:30] Yes. [0:33:31] Greg Lanting? [0:33:32] Yes. [0:33:33] Don Hall? [0:33:34] Yes. [0:33:35] Ruth Pierce? [0:33:36] Yes. [0:33:37] Suzanne Hawkins? [0:33:38] Yes. [0:33:39] Motion passes 6 to 0. [0:33:40] Thank you, Susan. [0:33:41] Thank you very much. [0:33:42] Travis? [0:33:43] Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, just say a couple of quick things. [0:33:45] I think that we would echo Dave's comments in terms of the overall partnership. [0:33:51] The relationship that we have with 1556 is probably second to none and [0:33:56] something that we always appreciate. [0:33:59] There are, I guess, to kind of put it for a council awareness, [0:34:02] there are two issues that are not resolved. [0:34:06] And we agreed to bring the agreement forward and [0:34:09] the main reason the two issues aren't resolved right now, because we're waiting for [0:34:12] our new chief to come. [0:34:13] And we really wanted his input. [0:34:15] One of them, you'll see shortly, I believe, [0:34:17] is going to be a memorandum of understanding [0:34:20] between the city and the local to adjust hours of work. [0:34:25] So right now, they're on a 24-48 schedule, [0:34:29] and lots of companies are moving to a 48-96 schedule. [0:34:33] But before we included that in here [0:34:35] and made a whole bunch of changes to SOPs, [0:34:39] we wanted to get the new chief involved, [0:34:41] and so we wanted to let you know [0:34:42] that we continue to work on that, as well as other areas, [0:34:45] especially in the areas of compensation and making sure [0:34:47] that those remain equitable and fair across the board. [0:34:51] And our commitment to the fire local is no different [0:34:54] than we have in any other part of our organization. [0:34:58] Thanks, Travis. [0:35:02] Next item, the agenda is a request to approve an agreement [0:35:04] for design, bidding, and construction engineering services [0:35:07] with JUB engineers for the 2017 FAA taxiway construction [0:35:12] and fire truck acquisition projects. [0:35:16] Bill Carberry, our airport manager. [0:35:19] Thank you, Mayor. [0:35:19] Welcome, Bill. [0:35:23] The evil clown. [0:35:24] Sit there. [0:35:28] Let me see what's up with your shots. [0:35:33] Yeah? [0:35:34] Yes. [0:35:48] I have this. [0:35:51] Good evening. [0:35:52] Thank you, Mr. Mayor. [0:35:53] Good evening, Council. [0:35:55] Three projects to talk about tonight and two contracts. [0:36:00] The first one here tonight is the Tax-A-Way Alpha [0:36:03] reconstruction and rehabilitation and the bidding and acquisition of a fire truck. [0:36:10] Taxiway Alpha from the midpoint of the airfield here at connector Alpha 3 down. [0:36:16] This is Alpha 2 and then here's Alpha 1. [0:36:19] This section is due to be rehabilitated. [0:36:22] It's been since I think the early 80s we've done some crack seal and seal coat maintenance [0:36:27] but we're looking here to rehabilitate that and couple that with another high priority [0:36:33] project, which is the acquisition of a replacement fire truck for the 1996 model that we have. [0:36:42] When engineering contracts are in excess of $100,000 and this contract is $621,000, and [0:36:51] soon as I get to it here, I'll fill in the other numbers, but it's well over $100,000. [0:36:56] We're required to do an independent fee estimate with another engineering firm that has familiarity [0:37:01] with these types of projects, and that's an FAA requirement, [0:37:04] all of the projects tonight are FAA projects. [0:37:07] So we enlisted for a small fee, the services of CH2M, [0:37:11] Hills Aviation Division, to look at the scope of work, [0:37:16] go over man hours, cost, expenses, [0:37:19] those types of things, consultants, [0:37:20] to come up with an independent fee estimate. [0:37:24] JUB contract came up at $621,537, [0:37:30] And the CH2M engineers contract was 631, 798. [0:37:36] So they were extremely close. [0:37:37] They were about 2%. [0:37:38] JUB was slightly under the CH2M. [0:37:41] And that's really, in all my years, [0:37:42] that's the first time something's come in so close. [0:37:44] So perhaps it was complemented with a well-written scope. [0:37:48] The FAA considers anything within 10 or 15% [0:37:51] of each other to be fairly close in your negotiation. [0:37:56] Construction costs for the project [0:37:58] are estimated at about $2.7 million for the taxiway rehabilitation, and the fire truck [0:38:03] could be upwards of $750,000 roughly for that. [0:38:08] You've been working with the FAA for several years. [0:38:11] When you couple two high priority projects together like this, you improve your chances [0:38:16] of receiving what they call discretionary funding. [0:38:19] So with this, we're looking at a substantial discretionary funding from the FAA in the amount [0:38:24] of approximately $2.9 million in addition to our $1 million annual entitlement to cover [0:38:31] these projects. [0:38:34] So we're looking to have the Taxaway Project bid in the spring, so JOB will be very busy [0:38:38] through the fall and winter of shaping up this bid packet to get an April bid opening. [0:38:44] Bid awards are presented when we have open bids, the grants are based on open bids, and [0:38:52] we're hoping to do that this spring. [0:38:53] The local match of 6.25% of cost is in our budget, and we'll be covering that through our PFC funds that we collect through the airlines, so we'll be providing the match that way. [0:39:06] So with that, I'll stand for any questions and recommend the City Council approve the agreement for engineering services with JV Engineering in the amount of 621,000, 537, and 56 cents, contingent upon FAA concurrence and funding. [0:39:23] You build Chris talking to one of the one that counts with the fact I think not the first item [0:39:29] But the second the fire truck Travis is then they'll because I'm not paid with impact fees for a local share [0:39:37] That would be FAA eligible if that piece of safety equipment. Yeah, so no impact. Okay. Thank you [0:39:45] Greg Lanting again on the fire truck bill is there a chance we can pick you back on some other city or [0:39:53] or airport in our area or our state [0:39:56] that has recently replaced a fire truck. [0:39:59] We've done that with a snow plow, [0:40:02] with the FAA project manager I'm looking at right now, [0:40:05] he tends to like competitive bidding processes. [0:40:08] But we'll explore that with him if it's a like for like, [0:40:11] if we could piggyback, [0:40:12] and if there are others within Idaho, [0:40:14] that could be a possibility. [0:40:15] Guess what, you know, he's gone for bid [0:40:16] and then reject him and do the piggyback if it's better. [0:40:22] Chris Stockington. [0:40:23] move city approve the engineering service for JUD in the amount of six twenty one six hundred twenty [0:40:29] one thousand five hundred thirty seven dollars fifty six cents content upon FAA concurrence and [0:40:35] funding second motion by Krista augington seconded by Ruth Pierce to approve the agreement for design [0:40:44] bidding and construction engineering services as presented is there any discussion seen then [0:40:52] Chair on roll call vote please. [0:40:54] Sean Beriker. [0:40:55] Yes. [0:40:56] Chris Tockington. [0:40:57] Yes. [0:40:58] Greg Lanting. [0:40:59] Yes. [0:41:00] Don Hall. [0:41:01] Yes. [0:41:02] Ruth Pierce. [0:41:03] Yes. [0:41:04] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:41:05] Yes. [0:41:06] Nikki Boy. [0:41:07] Now present and yes. [0:41:08] Motion passes 7-0. [0:41:09] Excuse me. [0:41:10] Next on the agenda we have a request to approve the Northeast Taxi Lane Preliminary Design Contract [0:41:18] with JUB engineers in the amount of $89,829.16 and again, Bill Carberry, airport manager. [0:41:26] Thank you, Sean. [0:41:27] When I was here in, gosh, it must have been March when we looked at the FedEx project and [0:41:32] this Google Earth image shows really the foundation being laid there for the FedEx facility. [0:41:39] We talked about having a future project to try to define how we would bring a new taxi [0:41:46] and what it's configuration would look like with types of impacts and opportunities that may present. [0:41:53] So we've been working with the FAA, and we've included this preliminary design project in the airport budget for 2017. [0:42:01] And we'd like to kick that off soon. [0:42:03] To start to give us an idea, as we really fits together with this rehabilitation of this taxiway, [0:42:09] we'll start to look at grades of where we can tie in and come down. [0:42:14] And there are some pretty good gray down the hill here, but then tie in here, and will it be here, will it be here, what will it look like. [0:42:21] So there's certainly a lot of interest from tenants on the airport that they like to be part of this process, [0:42:28] the pre-design project that we have here tonight will include public involvement, the board will have open meetings, [0:42:34] there'll be a series of meetings, much like any planning project where we'll sort of throw it all on the table first [0:42:40] First and then come back with a few alternatives and the board will select a preferred alternative to recommend to the city and the county [0:42:48] As we move forward so we look to see this project span from the fall into the spring time period [0:42:54] To try to come up with a preferred alternative [0:42:57] To recommend to the city and county to move forward on that and then look for forward fund for funding in the near future from the FAA to build that [0:43:04] So through this pre-design, it's really important that, you know, one of the key parameters is that it's a fundable project, a constructable project that the FAA will support. [0:43:16] So they are in support of us looking at this, doing this pre-design exercise that will fold right into design and then ultimately construction. [0:43:24] The contract is for below 100,000. [0:43:27] It's 89,829.16. [0:43:32] We'll be reimbursed from the FA in the 2018 fiscal cycle. [0:43:36] So we forward funded this into 17 with the anticipating [0:43:40] grant reimbursement in 2018. [0:43:43] So with that, I'd like to stand for any questions, [0:43:46] but I'd recommend the council approve the agreement [0:43:48] for the Northeast Prominary Design with JUB [0:43:50] for the amount of $89,829 and $0.16, [0:43:55] contention upon FAA concurrence and funding. [0:44:00] Thank you, boy. [0:44:01] Bill, have you had people reaching out to tenants [0:44:05] that are already out there and they understand [0:44:08] that they're gonna be involved [0:44:10] and I just wanna make sure there's really good dialogue [0:44:13] out there. [0:44:14] Yeah, we've communicated that to the tenants out there. [0:44:17] They know that they'll be part of this process. [0:44:19] They'll be get personal invitations to come to these. [0:44:21] will let them know well in advance so they can prepare to be there and participate. [0:44:27] Fantastic, thank you. [0:44:28] Suzanne, are you ready for a motion? [0:44:32] I am ready for a motion. [0:44:33] I would move that we approve the Northeast taxi lane preliminary design contract with JUB engineers. [0:44:41] In the amount of $89,829 and 16 cents. [0:44:48] Contingent. [0:44:51] Yeah, contingent upon FAA. [0:44:53] Contingent funding. [0:44:54] Okay, motion by Suzanne Hawkins, seconded by Greg Lanting [0:44:59] to approve the preliminary design contract as presented. [0:45:04] There for the discussion. [0:45:07] Seeing none, Sharon, roll call vote please. [0:45:11] Chris Tockington. [0:45:12] Yes. [0:45:13] Greg Lanting. [0:45:14] Yes. [0:45:15] Don Hall. [0:45:15] Yes. [0:45:16] Ruth Pears. [0:45:17] Yes. [0:45:18] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:45:19] Yes. [0:45:20] Nikki Boyd. [0:45:20] Yes. [0:45:21] Sean Barriker. [0:45:22] Yes. [0:45:23] Motion passes seven to zero. [0:45:24] Thank you. [0:45:25] Thank you. [0:45:27] a request to award a GSA contract to purchase a sewer jet truck. I have John [0:45:34] Caten, Public Works Director. Welcome John. Good evening Mayor and Council. Thank you. [0:45:42] Yes tonight I have a GSA contract to procure a sewer jet and if you recall a [0:45:56] couple weeks ago we rejected bids. We were going to go out to bid. I was able to [0:46:01] to find a GSA contract that we can pay you back. [0:46:05] So that's what you have before you. [0:46:06] If there's any questions? [0:46:15] Great landing. [0:46:16] I have approval of the request of awarded GSA contractors [0:46:19] to purchase a sewer jet truck. [0:46:23] Second. [0:46:25] Motion by great landing. [0:46:27] Seconded by Don Hall to award the GSA contract [0:46:32] as presented, Chris Talkington. [0:46:34] No, we need to make a mention of the vendor in the motion [0:46:38] and the amount. [0:46:39] Maryland Industrial Trucking. [0:46:42] Let's do that, Merritt Wood Festival Trucking. [0:46:44] What's the amount? [0:46:46] One seven. [0:46:47] We're asking you. [0:46:48] One hundred and seventy eight thousand two hundred fifty six and twenty nine cents. [0:46:52] Or seventy thousand two fifty six and twenty nine cents. [0:46:57] Twenty nine cents. [0:46:58] Be included in my motion with the permission of my second. [0:47:02] I think that would be appropriate. [0:47:04] So the motion is to award the GSA contract to purchase a sewer jet truck from Maryland [0:47:15] industrial trucking incorporated in the amount of $178,256.29. [0:47:21] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:47:22] Thank you. [0:47:23] John, I'm sorry if I'm slow, but can you remind me what is GSA? [0:47:27] It's a general services administration and it's an independent agency at the federal [0:47:32] government level name. They procure goods and services for government agencies. [0:47:37] Thank you. Any further discussion? Sharon will call vote please. [0:47:45] Greg Lanting. Yes. Don Hall. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes. Suzanne Hawkins. Yes. Nicki Boyd. Yes. [0:47:54] Sean Beriker. Yes. Chris Hawking. Yes. Motion passes 7-0. Next is a request to [0:48:03] to approve using $300,000 from Street Preserves to fund a mill and inlay and ADA ramps on Falls [0:48:11] Avenue. [0:48:12] I'm Kate. [0:48:13] Thank you. [0:48:30] So I just wanted to talk about pavement prices right now. [0:48:35] Today, Josh Baird was able, and engineering was able to put together some information for [0:48:40] this presentation just to illustrate the good advantage we're getting due to oil prices being [0:48:47] where they're at. [0:48:49] You can see this chart here, I have in front of you, [0:48:52] goes back to 2010. [0:48:55] I don't have a lot of data in 2010, 11, and 12. [0:48:58] You see in 13, there's several data points. [0:49:01] And those prices are price per ton in place. [0:49:06] So for example, you see in 2013, the anomaly [0:49:10] of a real high number, $142, almost $143 per ton. [0:49:17] That one's high, there's a couple things going on here. [0:49:20] Also, that was a real small quantity job. [0:49:22] So you don't get quite the price advantage [0:49:24] when you get the small quantity. [0:49:26] That's why you see such a spread from 93 all the way up [0:49:29] to 142 in 2013. [0:49:34] Jumping ahead to 2015, it's $102 and $108. [0:49:42] And the difference between last year and this year alone [0:49:46] is 25%. [0:49:47] So right now, we have projects that we've bid that are at $81.25 per ton in place. [0:49:55] If you look left, it's the lowest price we can see in the last five, six years. [0:50:02] It's a good price. [0:50:04] And so last week we started talking about this good price, [0:50:07] and we started talking about what the upcoming zone maintenance projects are going to be. [0:50:11] And Falls Avenue is the one I wanted to talk about tonight. [0:50:17] And in our zone maintenance program and long-term planning, [0:50:22] we wanted to mill an overlay, falls [0:50:25] Avenue from Washington to Blue Lakes, a whole mile. [0:50:29] Two lanes on the south side. [0:50:32] And that's too much money and one in a single year to do that. [0:50:35] So we wanted to do half of it this year and half of it [0:50:39] next year. [0:50:41] But what I'd like to propose is that because of this pricing [0:50:46] is to accelerate the project and use reserves to milling over the north half now and then [0:50:56] next summer we use our budget to mill the south half. [0:50:59] And just to point out, part of the reason I'm not asking for all of it right now is because [0:51:05] I have some water line work to do. [0:51:14] So I would be asking for to mill and do the whole thing because I think the price is so [0:51:18] good. [0:51:19] This is falls. There's frontier right here. Just did the ADA ramps there. If you remember [0:51:27] in front of Subaru, we have several waterline failures right along here and some patches. [0:51:33] I simply can't get out there and do the underground in time before the weather turns [0:51:37] off and we can't get it paved. We need to hold off on this southern side of falls for [0:51:44] next year. So, can I ask a question then John whether with the difference of the [0:51:54] mill overlay just on the north side well that representing sort of a driver's [0:52:00] problem is there going to be a physical variation in the asphalt height [0:52:06] constructed to constitute a danger? No, we'll match the existing centerline [0:52:13] crown. In fact, a lot of the center lane, in my opinion, is in good enough condition to [0:52:20] leave as is, so we'll leave it. There's some turning lines and there's some intersections [0:52:24] that it's not, so we'll just be, we'll match existing though. [0:52:27] Okay, Greg Leantone. John, was that one? I went through Falls today and it looked like [0:52:36] quite a few of our guys were out there trying to get run over trying to mark things. Is that [0:52:39] what they were doing? Yeah, they probably were located in utilities. [0:52:48] And actually, the Northside has some gate valves in it, and when you bring a melon and you're [0:52:54] rotating up pavement, you've got to move those lids, so they might be doing that. [0:52:59] They were marking. [0:53:02] They were marking. [0:53:04] Okay, so we asked Idaho Materials Construction, we put a bit of a mill and LA project and that [0:53:14] was the $81 per ton. [0:53:16] We asked if they'd be willing to piggyback that price and they are, and that's the bid [0:53:20] that you have in your package for $232,811. [0:53:33] On top of that, any time, is there any questions, you know, any time we do a milling in late, [0:53:45] we're required by the federal government to improve the ADA ramps. [0:53:49] And on the north side, we have, you can see, about 10 different ramps that we need to improve [0:53:58] And the price on the north side alone is $65,000. [0:54:04] So before I get into what I'm asking, I guess I'd [0:54:11] like to point out what the South Side ADA ramps look like [0:54:15] for next year. [0:54:18] And there's a lot more on the South Side. [0:54:21] So keep in mind, if we got the same price next year [0:54:26] to mill the South Side, let's say it's 235,000, [0:54:29] It's going to cost us more to do the ADA ramps than it is the whole south side. [0:54:34] So, anyway, that's an issue for another day. [0:54:37] I just wanted to point out the cost of the ADA ramps. [0:54:41] Suzanne Hopkins. [0:54:42] Sorry, I know it's not relevant, but I'm just curious. [0:54:44] What's the difference between the type 1 and type 3 ADA ramps? [0:54:49] I TD has standard types. [0:54:51] I don't have them all memorized in my head. [0:54:53] I'm glad. [0:54:54] It depends on the configuration of what you're looking at, [0:54:56] whether it's like a double ramp or a single, I don't remember. [0:55:00] That's OK. [0:55:01] I was just curious. [0:55:02] Thank you. [0:55:05] OK. [0:55:07] So I guess in closing, staff would like to request about $300,000 [0:55:13] from Street Reserves to fund the Milan-N-Lite and the ADA [0:55:16] project for the north side of Falls, from Blue Lakes, to Washington. [0:55:22] Chris Stockington. [0:55:23] Anytime we can save $66,000 by taking advantage of our lower costs, [0:55:29] I think we'd be irresponsible not to take advantage of it. [0:55:33] That's being said, I would move to use $300,000 from Street [0:55:37] Reserves to fund the mill in light, and ADA ramps on Falls Avenue. [0:55:44] Second. [0:55:46] Motion by Chris Stockington, seconded by Nikki Boyd to approve the use of $300,000 [0:55:50] from Street Preserves for the Millon Inland ADA Ramp Project [0:55:54] as presented. [0:55:55] Nikki did you have another comment to make her? [0:55:57] I do not. [0:55:58] OK. [0:55:59] Is there any discussion from Council? [0:56:03] Seeing none, Sharon, we'll call the vote, please. [0:56:05] Don Hall? [0:56:06] Yes. [0:56:07] Ray Pierce? [0:56:07] Yes. [0:56:08] Suzanne Hawkins? [0:56:09] Yes. [0:56:10] Nikki Boyd? [0:56:11] Yes. [0:56:12] Sean Beriker? [0:56:13] Yes. [0:56:14] Chris Hockington? [0:56:14] Yes. [0:56:15] Greg Lanthine? [0:56:16] Yes. [0:56:18] Motion passes. [0:56:18] It's 7-0. [0:56:19] Thank you. [0:56:20] Thank you, John. [0:56:21] What's the timeline on that? [0:56:24] They're marking stuff today. [0:56:25] Yes. [0:56:26] You know, I first of all. [0:56:28] Completion. [0:56:29] Yeah. [0:56:29] First of all, I need to sign a contract with them [0:56:31] and communicate with Idaho materials. [0:56:34] It's my understanding that they're [0:56:35] going to close their hot plant towards the end of November. [0:56:38] So it's going to happen between now and then. [0:56:41] OK, this year then. [0:56:42] Yes. [0:56:45] But even if for some reason cold weather, bad weather, [0:56:49] closed in before then, we'd still [0:56:50] have that contract at that price. [0:56:52] that would have to be honored. [0:56:54] You know, I'm not sure how long that I could get him [0:56:56] to honor the contract, but I can, that's why. [0:56:59] I'd make sure it's as long as possible. [0:57:03] 2020. [0:57:04] At least until next year, I'll wait for the other half. [0:57:07] The weather looks like we'll be able to make it. [0:57:09] Shouldn't be an issue. [0:57:11] Travis, did you have something there? [0:57:13] Yeah, so the reason we're coming to you [0:57:14] and asking for cash reserves is because on Saturday [0:57:19] was the beginning of the new fiscal year. [0:57:20] and John and I had a conversation about looking and really trying to project forward and moving [0:57:26] forward. The amount of money that you're spending on the project is less than the amount of money [0:57:32] that we'll be placing into the street fund cash reserves this year. And so John and his [0:57:37] team are going to start doing some forward looking about July and August because if we [0:57:42] have monies appropriated and then we can take advantage of the situations like this, we want [0:57:47] I want to try to do so within the confines of that fiscal year. [0:57:50] So I just wanted to explain to the council and also to the public why are we using reserves. [0:57:55] And really it's a timing issue right now on the fiscal year. [0:58:00] We will present to you a budget amendment in September of 2017 that will incorporate these funds if it's needed. [0:58:11] If we find ourselves into the same place that we were this year, this amendment wouldn't be included because we would have to do that. [0:58:17] have the cash to be able to carry it forward, but this just gives us the [0:58:20] authorization in the event that we're able to utilize the funds allocated that [0:58:25] you've given us permission to use cash reserves in upcoming years. [0:58:30] Thank you, Travis. Thank you, John. Next on the agenda is another opportunity for [0:58:35] public input. Is there anyone here from the public who would like to address the [0:58:38] council? Seeing none, Mr. Rothweiler. So I'm gonna be gone for a couple of days [0:58:47] and Mr. Pike is going to be serving as the acting city manager in my absence. [0:58:55] Good luck to you and your competition. Any items from the city council? [0:59:03] I just wanted to remind the council that our good mayor has accepted the mayor's [0:59:11] challenge, walking challenge, and so if you see him wandering around aimlessly [0:59:16] throughout the City of Twin Falls. [0:59:18] It's not English, it's actually doing it for a good cause. [0:59:22] As well, maybe Shawn, you could tell us a little bit [0:59:25] about the fundraising aspect of what you're trying to do. [0:59:27] Yeah, so it's the Mayor's School Walking Challenge [0:59:31] that kicked off on Saturday. [0:59:32] Actually the official kickoff in Twin Falls [0:59:34] is tomorrow afternoon at one o'clock [0:59:36] at Sawtooth Elementary. [0:59:38] And the goal is to raise awareness and activity [0:59:41] in young children and those of us terrible role models [0:59:45] to get out there and change our ways so that we can be better role models. [0:59:49] Fitness is not one of my greatest strengths, so this is going to be a bit of a challenge, [0:59:53] but so the opportunity is there is between $1,000 and $6,000 available. [0:59:59] Should I be the mayor of the 25 mayors who walks the most steps in October to go toward school [1:00:06] and parks projects? [1:00:08] Because I don't like to lose, I added rules. [1:00:11] So what I did is I have challenged members of the community [1:00:16] to make a pledge per mile that I walk in October [1:00:19] and make a commitment to donate those funds [1:00:21] through the community foundation [1:00:22] to our Magic Valley Trail Enhancement Committee [1:00:26] so that even if I come up short on the funds [1:00:29] from this project, maybe we can get a few funds together [1:00:32] for the trail. [1:00:33] So I will be out and about. [1:00:35] I have a Facebook page that's set up [1:00:36] telling you where I'll be walking [1:00:38] and inviting you to come join me. [1:00:39] And today I decided I'm going to hit the treadmill [1:00:42] because I'm afraid if I went walking [1:00:44] I would end up in Burley in about three steps. [1:00:49] Don last year did an outstanding job representing [1:00:52] our community and I'm not confident I will come close [1:00:55] to what he did but we'll have a good time doing it. [1:00:58] So thank you. [1:01:01] Anything else from the council? [1:01:05] We are not quite to six o'clock yet. [1:01:06] We have a public hearing scheduled at six [1:01:09] So we will take a short recess and reconvene at six o'clock. [1:01:25] Have a good chair. [1:01:29] All right, we will bring back to order [1:01:33] the city council meeting for our public hearing. [1:01:35] It is 6.02 and our public hearing this evening [1:01:39] is a request for a special use permit [1:01:41] to establish an open parking lot [1:01:43] on property located at 229 Second Avenue North. [1:01:47] Lots six through 14 block 85 Twin Falls town site [1:01:50] for the city of Twin Falls urban renewal agency. [1:01:53] We have Nathan Murray, our economic development director. [1:01:56] Thank you. [1:01:57] It's a pleasure to be here. [1:01:59] So this property, as you can see, [1:02:00] the intersection of Gooding and Second Avenue North [1:02:03] was purchased by the URA with the intention [1:02:05] of creating a parking lot, a use that is customary [1:02:09] for your downtown, and an area that's adjacent [1:02:11] to another city lot that at times [1:02:14] exceeds capacity during events, particularly. [1:02:18] We're asking the council to approve two things. [1:02:20] Right now, we want to approve the special use permit [1:02:24] to allow this to be a parking lot, [1:02:26] and second, to defer the permanent improvements [1:02:29] which are required as part of the development [1:02:32] of the property. [1:02:34] We're asking that deferral as we're in the middle [1:02:36] of our main street project and subsequent alleyway improvements, [1:02:40] rather than have to install those now, [1:02:43] tear them up at a later date, and then recover again. [1:02:46] And I have to do that twice. [1:02:47] we just prefer to defer if we could. [1:02:51] So do you have any questions regarding these requests? [1:02:54] Ruth Pierce. [1:02:55] So Nate, that parking lot as it is right now, [1:02:58] or excuse me, that piece of property is right now, [1:03:01] that would be left, the. [1:03:04] Yeah, so it's been graded and underground utilities [1:03:09] have been in place. [1:03:10] We would put these millings over the top [1:03:14] to give it some sort of, just keep dust down [1:03:17] and a little more appropriate for parking [1:03:19] rather than just the base that's there. [1:03:22] Okay, thank you, Travis. [1:03:25] So we're going to do that same process [1:03:29] that we've done in all of the other parks [1:03:31] where we take the Millen, LA, [1:03:32] and then we put that over the top. [1:03:35] It acts like a really nice compact surface [1:03:38] for a period of time, and then like Nate said, [1:03:40] 2019, we'll go back through, remove the temporary seal, and the urban renewal agency will turn [1:03:49] it into, they'll use the hot mix and turn it into a full parking lot. [1:03:57] Greg Lanting. [1:04:03] Yes, and landscape and lighting. [1:04:06] Okay. [1:04:07] And then can we go back to the very first picture for that? [1:04:12] And I'm just thinking for the future here, maybe for the URA, [1:04:16] if something that would, if the money was available and had a willing seller. [1:04:21] Do we really know who that building right there, its viability? [1:04:26] Because it would be an excellent pass through to Main Street, [1:04:29] like we have in some other places in our downtown [1:04:33] that make those parking lots much more usable. [1:04:36] Especially I'm thinking for the event center, we have right there [1:04:39] It has a lot of activity, especially on Friday nights for key scenarios if I'm saying that, correct? [1:04:45] So, [1:04:46] So one of the strategies that the Urban Renewal Agency is looking at is trying to find those connectors from the parking lots. [1:04:55] And as you're aware, most of our parking lots are on either side of the seconds. [1:04:59] And so that has actually been a property and other places have also been identified as trying to create [1:05:05] opportunities to access from the parking lot directly onto main avenue as opposed to having to walk. [1:05:12] around. And so that is a strategy the agency is currently looking at. [1:05:15] So I would think it would make that particular block a lot more viable if that had that ability [1:05:21] to, I don't think I'm thinking that, what is that, the northeast side, I guess, of Maine. [1:05:27] So, and also there's some buildings on the opposite side that are not being fiddly utilized either. [1:05:33] So, I mean, thank you. [1:05:35] Chris talked. [1:05:36] Nathan, perhaps you know the answer to this, this temporary mill levy. [1:05:40] As such time, it'll be replaced with the permanent overlay that can be recycled and the cost-free cover on that is that correct? [1:05:49] So we're not doing a one-way throwaway process. Yes. I'm a tree hugger. Okay. He's a mama and asphalt hugger [1:05:59] Any other questions for Nate seeing them? We will have the staff report from Jonathan's in love [1:06:08] Welcome Jonathan. Thank you mayor Baerger and council members the history of it [1:06:12] It's been zoned CB for at least since the 1980s when that zoning district was established. [1:06:18] Various business, United Automotive, United Engine, United Electronics, Muffler Warehouse, [1:06:23] and Mandic Valley Archery was the last business in there. [1:06:26] The URA purchased the property demolish the two buildings, they put the fill material. [1:06:31] We are dealing with the CB zoning district, which lists open parking lots as special [1:06:35] use permits, so typically that would go to the Planning and Zoning Commission. [1:06:39] The reason it's coming to the City Council is the city will be operating that parking lot. [1:06:43] We'll be enforcing the hours. [1:06:45] So when the city owns or maintains or operates a land use that's different from what it was [1:06:51] before it comes to the City Council for that establishment because we are basically the operators [1:06:56] of it as a city. [1:06:58] So that's why it's before you. [1:07:00] The 10-7-19 is the code section that allows that to come to you. [1:07:06] The requirements, 10, 11, title 10, chapter 11, and sections 1 through 8. [1:07:16] And when there's a change of use of the building structure or parcel of land that's had a building, [1:07:20] now it's going to go to a parking lot, two different land uses. [1:07:23] Certain improvements to the property are required, most notably, hard surface parking areas, parking [1:07:27] lot landscaping, lighting, and stormwater management. [1:07:31] The area is expressed that they've got the main street and the alleyway projects. [1:07:35] They'll be tearing up portions of the property and or utilizing part of it. [1:07:39] This is the inter-in layout that they have, how it will be striped after they do the mill [1:07:46] and inlay, and then like a sealer, they'll be putting in landscaping eventually in these [1:07:53] cross-hatched areas in the future. [1:07:56] So the parking lot landscaping is a required improvement that they have to do. [1:08:01] That would be done at the permanent stage of it. [1:08:03] Interim, it would just be striped. [1:08:05] Additionally, there'll be parking lot lighting, [1:08:07] the security lighting for the parking lot. [1:08:10] That will then be deferred as well [1:08:11] until the permanent portions of the project are done, [1:08:15] as well as the resurfacing with either Portland concrete [1:08:19] or New Asphalt or concrete. [1:08:21] So those are the items they're asking to defer. [1:08:25] The storm water would also have to be done at the later time [1:08:28] and they're looking at incorporating the landscaped areas [1:08:31] to take the storm water. [1:08:33] similar to what you see in some other locations. [1:08:35] So that's something we've been working with the engineering [1:08:37] department on figuring out how to do that. [1:08:39] Those items we take care of at the permanent phase. [1:08:42] So should the council grant us a request, [1:08:45] as presented staff recommends approval be subject [1:08:47] to the following conditions. [1:08:49] One subject to the site plan members as required [1:08:51] by building engineering, fire and zoning officials [1:08:53] to ensure compliance with applicable city code [1:08:55] requirements standards. [1:08:56] Number two, subject all applicable required improvements, [1:08:59] such as asphalt, paved parking, maneuvering, [1:09:01] landscaping, lighting, stormwater management, [1:09:03] being installed in conjunction with the completion of the downtown main street slash alley project is projected for 2019. [1:09:10] That's all. [1:09:11] Thank you, Jonathan. [1:09:13] Suzanne Hawkins. [1:09:14] Jonathan, I don't know if these questions are for you, but we'll start there, okay? [1:09:18] So will these all be the three-hour parking or will some of them be available as other options in our other lots or how will it be configured? [1:09:26] The actual locations haven't been decided. I'm guessing that'll be between the [1:09:30] RA and the city. And what I can tell you is there's two options. You have three [1:09:34] hour free and parking paths. If they deviate from either of those options we [1:09:39] either have to amend the code or something else because those are the two [1:09:42] that recognize that we have the code for the parking options. But we're not sure [1:09:46] how it's going to be yet. I don't believe a layout has been determined as to [1:09:50] which ones would be parking paths and which one would be three hour. If I'm [1:09:54] looking at the other lots. Most of them have a pretty good mix of parking [1:09:57] paths in three hour, especially the ones that you orange a lot, which is [1:10:01] behind the or if you have a lot of three hour, not as much parking paths as the [1:10:05] others do. Okay and my next question is I'm just a little concerned about deferring [1:10:10] the lighting for three years. We've had a lot of comments from citizens who feel [1:10:15] unsafe walking because of the darkness and it's been a huge concern at every [1:10:20] public meeting we've had. And so is there no way to get some kind of temporary lighting [1:10:25] just to help alleviate that? I mean, three years seems like a long time to go without lighting [1:10:30] to me. [1:10:31] I think that's a very good question. We could put these things were brought up in our discussion, [1:10:37] but we could definitely take a look at if it's motion by the council to have, make sure that [1:10:42] temporary lighting source to make sure that the security lighting is acceptable in the [1:10:46] parking lot, figure out some way to do that. [1:10:49] Thank you Greg Lanten. [1:10:53] I'm going to use my laser about a year. [1:10:56] So we only made it through the first few seconds. [1:11:00] The question I would have is the church parking lot that is adjacent to it. [1:11:06] Has there been any other key shot to it? [1:11:10] Has there been any cross-use agreement conversations about possibly when they're not in use [1:11:17] the city could use it and then because obviously they're going to spill over [1:11:20] in ours when they have church of us. I mean, is that any conversation? Probably [1:11:24] that's really that's question for Nathan. I know it's been mentioned to me as far [1:11:28] as the depth of those conversations. I don't know what that is, but I know [1:11:32] those come some conversation took place. Part of it was to look at seeing if we [1:11:36] could have a cohesive layout that incorporated that area. I do know that it [1:11:41] didn't go so far as to include it in our layout and approval. [1:11:45] Okay, so if there's any more information [1:11:49] There's not any further all right any other questions for or Jonathan [1:11:58] See then we will move on to the public input portion of the public hearing [1:12:04] We'll open that for anyone who wishes to speak on this issue [1:12:08] Please come forward if you'd please take your name and address for the record [1:12:23] Please my name is bear borton 2670 east 4256 north [1:12:27] in and I'm the pastor at Bench Valley Bible Church. [1:12:30] Just to just your last comment, Mr. Landon, [1:12:33] I haven't seen anything come across our desk [1:12:36] as far as with the city wanting to maybe partner [1:12:39] with that space shoes, we would be open to that. [1:12:42] Yeah, we want to be good friend, good neighbor. [1:12:46] I'll have to say if you wanted to come and talk [1:12:49] and try to figure out what's the best use of that, [1:12:51] we'd love to do that, so it's just that input. [1:12:54] Thank you. [1:12:55] Is there anyone else who wishes to speak on this issue before us? [1:13:06] Seeing none, we will close the public input portion of the hearing and turn it over to [1:13:10] the council for deliberation. [1:13:15] Chris talking to me. [1:13:16] I would move that we authorize the issuance of a special use permit for an open parking [1:13:21] lot at the property described at 229 Second Avenue North, law 614, block 85, and false [1:13:28] 10-site, subject to the two attached conditions, [1:13:33] and the add a third to explore and fund temporary lighting [1:13:41] on the permit later, the temporarily deferred project [1:13:48] completion parking lot. [1:13:52] Second. [1:13:54] Motion by Chris Toggington, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins [1:13:57] to approve the special use permit [1:13:59] has presented with the two conditions, [1:14:03] plus a third condition that would require [1:14:07] the exploration and potential installation [1:14:11] of security lighting in advance of the- [1:14:15] I might need to remember- [1:14:16] I might need to remember- [1:14:17] Would that not be a URA funding, [1:14:20] or would that be a city? [1:14:21] Correct. [1:14:22] The request is from the urban renewal agency [1:14:23] now from the city. [1:14:24] Yeah, from the agency. [1:14:27] I'm a pedestrian as much as anybody, [1:14:29] and there's a way we can install it without having to go back [1:14:32] and change a lot of the underground utilities [1:14:34] in an additional cost that we should do it [1:14:36] if we're gonna do it anyway. [1:14:39] So I'll talk to our board about that and see what's available. [1:14:43] Okay, do you need a discussion with the council, Don Hall? [1:14:49] So should we have that in the motion [1:14:51] if it's not under our authority to? [1:14:54] So it's under your authority to create certain conditions [1:14:58] for those to do that? [1:14:59] Yeah, we've been sitting side barring determining. [1:15:04] One of the questions we don't know is [1:15:08] if the Urban Renewal Agency makes an investment [1:15:11] in temporary power, would they be able to utilize [1:15:15] that investment on the permanent solution? [1:15:19] And that's just something that we don't know [1:15:21] based upon the configuration and the layout. [1:15:24] And I think what Nate was talking about [1:15:28] is determining whether or not the funds going forward would have a future cost and if the [1:15:37] agency can do it now it's probably something that we would recommend if they could be incorporated [1:15:43] into the permanent solution but if it can't be the agency would be spending money that [1:15:50] would ultimately be pulled out of the ground. [1:15:59] I guess my question is, should it be in the motion? [1:16:02] Should it be more about, [1:16:04] the motion is a condition? [1:16:07] That's the intent. [1:16:09] That's true. [1:16:10] That's an overriding city condition for public safety [1:16:14] that we're imposing upon the URA. [1:16:16] On the URA, how they do, I'll go up to that. [1:16:23] Suzanne Hawkins. [1:16:24] Thank you. [1:16:25] I'd just like to thank Pastor Bear for coming forward tonight [1:16:28] and encourage city staff and URA [1:16:31] to continue negotiations there because working with good partners is something [1:16:36] we'd like to strive for. [1:16:43] Further discussion from the council? [1:16:47] So just to clarify that the motion is to approve the special use permit subject [1:16:51] to the conditions of, to the conside plan amendments is required by building engineering [1:17:02] fire and zoning officials and then to defer required improvements with the exception [1:17:13] exception of lighting until the completion of the downtown main street alley project projected for 2019 and that the lighting will be explored for installation now close enough Greg Lanting I know we're in the discussion but can I get the mayor's approval for one last question. [1:17:36] possibly the Maduche Valley church person or is that not allowed sure good you come [1:17:47] back up sir I didn't catch your name I apologize [1:17:50] yeah so I'll reopen the public public input position of the hearing I haven't been [1:18:00] by there so I don't know or the sensibility has gone on the billboards gone or no [1:18:05] the billboards are still there, Lamar actually owns them, but we've read the [1:18:10] space where the posts go in the ground. So they give us a rental check for that [1:18:14] little portion to put their signs up. I guess I was going to plan a seed that [1:18:19] since those are still there and obviously there's electricity already there for [1:18:23] those because they believe they're lighted, aren't they? They are lighted. That [1:18:27] maybe part of the temporary could be that would be later [1:18:32] per permanent would be placed on your property through your agreement that [1:18:36] would actually provide some lighting for both sides in the meantime until that [1:18:41] way I'm not I'm not envisioning in my mind was with Mr. talking this portion of [1:18:46] the motion that there's gonna be a full lighting like we would see on a [1:18:50] purple cold parking lot we're talking temporary here to at least give some [1:18:54] security as my thought but I'm just planning a seat for maybe further [1:19:00] conversation. Just put some insight on that. Lamar owns, they have their own [1:19:05] designated power box there for their signs, so they would have to get into [1:19:09] discussion with electricity. I'm assuming there's a the idle part has a source of [1:19:16] power to their to their meter that they can either somebody else can tap into [1:19:20] besides them. Okay. Thank you. [1:19:27] There are questions for anybody? [1:19:28] I don't vote late, so hopefully we'll close that up again [1:19:33] for the public input. [1:19:35] And if there's no further discussion on the motion, [1:19:38] Sharon, we'll call vote, please. [1:19:44] Ruth Pears? [1:19:45] Yes. [1:19:46] Suzanne Hawkins? [1:19:47] Yes. [1:19:48] Nikki Boyd? [1:19:49] Yes. [1:19:50] Sean Beriker? [1:19:51] Yes. [1:19:52] Chris Hockington? [1:19:53] Yes. [1:19:54] Greg Lanting? [1:19:54] Yes. [1:19:55] Don Haute? [1:19:57] Yes. [1:20:00] Motion passes 7 to 0. [1:20:07] Thank you, Nate. [1:20:10] Next on the agenda is request to adjourn into executive session. [1:20:16] Idaho Code 742061B to consider the evaluation, dismissal, or [1:20:21] disciplining of or to hear complaints or charges brought against a public officer, [1:20:25] employee, staff member, or individual agent or public school student. [1:20:30] Council wishes. [1:20:33] Suzanne Hoxett. [1:20:34] approve approval of Executive Session 74-2061B. [1:20:39] Second. [1:20:40] Motion by Suzanne Hopkins, seconded by Don Hall to adjourn into the Executive Session as [1:20:45] stated. [1:20:46] Any discussion? [1:20:47] Seeing none, Sharon roll call vote, please. [1:20:53] Yes. [1:20:55] Nikki Boyd? [1:20:56] Yes. [1:20:57] John Berriger? [1:20:59] Yes. [1:21:00] Chris Hockington? [1:21:01] Yes. [1:21:02] Greg Lanting? [1:21:03] Yes. [1:21:04] Don Hall? [1:21:05] Yes. [1:21:06] Ruth Pierce? [1:21:07] Yes. [1:21:08] So just to remind everyone, we will not be making any decisions while in executive session, [1:21:12] nor will we be reconvening while in the executive session with that. [1:21:16] We are adjourned.