Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2016-07-18, recording 1 (started 17:00) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2016-07-18/ [0:00:00] Monday July 18th, it is 4 10 p.m., and we are calling the meeting to order here, and [0:00:07] then we are going to go into a recess so that the council can go with city staff to [0:00:13] tour the under construction new city hall for the City of Twin Falls, and then we [0:00:19] will return here for the balance of the agenda. So with that, we will stay in a [0:00:25] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. [0:00:43] We do have a quorum of the City Council here this evening, six of our members are here. [0:00:52] Councilman Lansing was not able to join us. [0:00:55] Mr. Rothweiler, are there any amendments to our agenda? [0:00:58] Mr. Mayor, members of the council staff would ask that you add an item to the consent calendar appearing as item number four. [0:01:04] Should you make this addition, the item would be approval of a beer and wine license transfer. [0:01:11] For the ownership of ownership, for Red Robin, Gourmet Burgers and [0:01:15] Brews doing business at 1-8-2-4 Blue Lakes Boulevard North Twin Falls, Idaho. [0:01:23] We placed a copy of that item before you for your consideration. [0:01:28] Thank you, Travis. [0:01:29] Chris Dockington. [0:01:30] I would move approve of the consent calendar [0:01:32] with the addition of the red, red, red, [0:01:34] and red, red, and red, white, liquor license. [0:01:36] Transfer. [0:01:37] Second. [0:01:38] I have a motion by Chris Dockington, seconded by Don Hall [0:01:41] to approve the amended. [0:01:45] Do we need to actually amend the agenda first, [0:01:47] or can we just add that to the consent calendar? [0:01:50] Fritz? [0:01:53] Sounds like it was combined in a single motion. [0:01:55] That's OK. [0:01:56] All right, thank you. [0:01:58] So motion to approve the consent calendar [0:02:00] with the inclusion of the beer and wine license transfer [0:02:04] as outline varsity manager. [0:02:06] Is there any council discussion? [0:02:09] Seeing none, Sharon, roll call vote please. [0:02:11] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:02:13] Yes. [0:02:13] Nikki Boyd. [0:02:14] Yes. [0:02:15] Sean Bericher. [0:02:16] Yes. [0:02:17] Chris Tockington. [0:02:18] Yes. [0:02:19] Don Hall. [0:02:20] Yes. [0:02:21] Ruth Pierce. [0:02:22] Yes. [0:02:23] The motion passes six to zero. [0:02:24] So we went ahead and jumped down a little bit on the agenda there too. [0:02:26] So I'll rewind us now. [0:02:29] We have no proclamations this evening. [0:02:31] So the next item on the agenda is general public input. [0:02:35] So just to clarify our public input procedures for this evening, and this is printed on the [0:02:42] back of the agenda, individuals wishing to provide public input regarding matters relevant [0:02:47] to the City of Twin Falls shall wait to be recognized by the mayor, approach the microphone [0:02:53] podium, state their name and address and whether they are a resident or property owner [0:02:58] in the City of Twin Falls and proceed with their input. [0:03:03] Our procedures allow that the mayor may limit input to no less than two minutes and that [0:03:08] individuals are not permitted to give their time to other speakers. [0:03:12] So this evening I will be limiting each individual's public input to three minutes. [0:03:19] We'll be timing that and I would invite the public to address the council now. [0:03:29] Please come forward. [0:03:30] Oh, they have assigned a list. [0:03:37] Oh, is there a list back there, officers, that one of you could bring to me, please. [0:03:46] Thank you, Josh. [0:04:00] So I apologize. [0:04:01] We'll go ahead and allow you to speak here and then we'll jump to the list and then we'll [0:04:04] catch anybody else who would like to. [0:04:06] So again, if you would please introduce yourself with your name and address and whether you're [0:04:10] a resident or property owner in the city and then proceed with your input. [0:04:13] I'm Jesse Stroupe. [0:04:14] I'm a 3161 East, 3200 North Twin Falls, Idaho. [0:04:18] I'm a resident, and I actually came tonight to invite the City Council and some of the city staff to an event [0:04:23] that's being hosted in Twin Falls, and I brought you guys some tickets, and I just wanted to [0:04:28] pass those out or leave them here, whichever is better. Do I bring them up or? [0:04:32] You could probably just leave them with Mitch, actually, if that's handier for you, if you had [0:04:35] other comments you wanted to give to us. Okay, and you're welcome to bring those forward and pass them out to us. [0:04:42] Thanks, Jesse. Thank you, Jesse. Yeah, we'll get that to him. [0:04:52] Can we bring a guest with us or it's okay. [0:04:59] Thank you. [0:05:05] All right. [0:05:06] Thank you. [0:05:08] [Muted for privacy: street address] [0:05:18] [Muted for privacy: street address] [0:05:20] [Muted for privacy: street address] [0:05:25] I am speaking this evening in support of our city council and city management. [0:05:31] The council and city employees do incredible work, all in support of each and every citizen. [0:05:36] They do it without malice, issue fair and educated rulings, and yes, they sometimes disagree. [0:05:44] We can all disagree on issues, but civil citizens agree to disagree. [0:05:49] They do not engage in name-calling, threats, bigotry, and hiding behind their so-called [0:05:55] Christian beliefs. [0:05:57] Informed and engaged citizens wishing to speak on a subject, research the appropriate venue [0:06:03] and or governmental agency to air their grievances or present their point of view. [0:06:10] They do not waste the time of those who are not charged with dealing with issues that are [0:06:14] not within their power or realm. [0:06:18] Ignorance wishes to blame everyone and anyone without regard to the steps it takes to protest [0:06:23] intelligently and accomplish their goal. [0:06:27] My support is with our city council and management who have handled a very difficult situation [0:06:33] which remember they are not chartered to deal with with poison grace. [0:06:39] They are citizens who care just as much about our community as we do. [0:06:44] Take these protests to the appropriate agencies and this council is not that place. [0:06:50] I personally thank the council for their hard work and their commitment to our community. [0:06:57] Thank you, Ms. Taylor. [0:07:00] Next we have Lucy Wills. [0:07:10] Good evening. [0:07:10] Welcome. [0:07:11] Mayor, Council. [0:07:13] and women. Thank you for having this form. I appreciate it very much. [0:07:19] Lucy, could you please state your address for the record, please? [0:07:23] Yes. Do I dare? 816 Cherokee Lane, Twin Falls, Idaho, [0:07:28] I am a resident and in Twin Falls, the city of Twin Falls. So I came here tonight to express my thoughts regarding some of what's [0:07:40] been happening in the meetings for the past few weeks, and to try and understand what the [0:07:47] function is and why you were elected. [0:07:52] Now correct me if I'm wrong, but the function of this body is to conduct business to make [0:07:57] sure that we have law and order, that promotes safety to all of us, by having a functional [0:08:05] and well-trained police department, fire department, and water department, and all other departments, [0:08:13] etc., etc. The last few meetings have been somewhat of a circus and have been made and [0:08:20] have made a mockery of what this is, what this body is supposed to mean and represent. And [0:08:30] The people that have come before it, that come before it for actual city business have [0:08:35] been made to wait hours so that a small group, obviously, like to hear themselves speak, [0:08:41] has pretty much manipulated or monopolized that process. [0:08:47] There are some constitutional toting, quoting, and handing out who obviously need a refresher [0:08:53] Corps in Civics 101 to know that this body does not control their agendas, they need [0:09:00] to look elsewhere to accomplish this. [0:09:04] With that being said, I would like to make a pitch for my faith and my Christianity and [0:09:09] ask that when I say I'm a Christian, that I am not lumped into the bunch that has called [0:09:16] for members of this body to take a bullet between the eyes, for example, or to recommend [0:09:23] or suggest that their spouses, daughters, sisters, be raped, please I beg of you to not [0:09:29] consider me one of those Christians. [0:09:32] You are elected by a majority of the people that you serve based on your character, your [0:09:37] integrity and your principles, and although you represent everyone, I don't believe that [0:09:45] the thoughts or actions of a few speak for the many of us, the majority who believe that [0:09:51] in what you do and the time and dedication that you give to our community. [0:09:56] This is no longer a refugee problem or anything of the sort. [0:10:03] It's become a bitter and angry attention-seeking tactic for a few. [0:10:13] Are there Muslims in Twin Falls? [0:10:15] Yes, I believe there are. [0:10:17] Are there radical members in Muslims in Twin Falls? [0:10:21] I'm not sure. Are there Christians in Twin Falls? Most definitely. Are there radical Christians in [0:10:28] Twin Falls? I believe most definitely based on what I've seen for the past few weeks, [0:10:34] stirring up hatred and trying to convince everyone that they are Christians. And such as there is no [0:10:41] room for radical Muslims in Twin Falls, I don't believe there is any room for radical Christians [0:10:48] Thank you so much for the work that you do. [0:10:52] I appreciate you all very much and thank you for giving me this opportunity. [0:10:56] Thank you, Mrs. Wells. [0:11:01] Next on the list is Terry Edwards. [0:11:12] My name is Terry Edwards. [0:11:14] I live in Jerome. [0:11:15] I own property in Twin Falls. [0:11:18] Is that okay? [0:11:19] Thank you. [0:11:20] Thank you. [0:11:22] I just would like to encourage you folks to remember that you're not the victims. [0:11:27] The victim is a little girl. [0:11:31] These folks have to respond to victims in the community. [0:11:35] That's part of the safety and well-being of the community as leaders. [0:11:39] You need to do that. [0:11:41] And I'm sorry if some people have taken upon themselves to make physical or abusive attacks to you, [0:11:48] but what needs to be done is do your job. [0:11:53] You all volunteered for this. [0:11:55] Nobody held a gun or a knife to your throat, made you become a city council person. [0:12:01] I don't believe, but I'll tell you, I remember my dad telling me if you can't stand the heat, [0:12:07] get out of the kitchen. [0:12:09] So if you can't stand the heat, get out of the kitchen. [0:12:12] Thanks. [0:12:16] Thank you, Mr. Edwards. [0:12:18] That's all the folks that I have who signed up to speak this evening. [0:12:21] So if there's anyone else who would wish to, please come forward to the podium. [0:12:32] My name is Glenita Ziderfeld. [0:12:34] I am from Jerome, and I don't own any property and twin, [0:12:38] but I live in the Magic Valley all my life. [0:12:42] I have just come from the apartments of the victim. [0:12:47] I've been helping the victim out and the family out. [0:12:51] And so I'm coming to you. [0:12:54] I know it's probably not your duty as a council, [0:12:57] but coming to you as individuals. [0:12:59] we are looking for a house for them to move into because they are still only a hundred feet apart [0:13:07] and they don't go outside and actually the kids are going to come over my house tonight so they [0:13:13] can actually go outside and play. So I am asking if you guys have any place that they can move to a house [0:13:22] so they can have their own yard. And so this little girl can heal. So I really [0:13:29] just am asking from the bottom of my heart we need to recomse and trade on [0:13:35] this family. I'm sorry you guys are can't attacked or threatened but this little [0:13:40] girl was attacked and she needs to heal and we need a house for her. So if [0:13:46] anybody has any idea they're unlimited money you know they have to have a you [0:13:56] know a certain price range that they can afford but a group of us are coming [0:14:00] together to help them to afford something a little bit more than what they have but [0:14:06] I am just asking you as a council help us find them a house because we've looked [0:14:13] and there's like every house that we've looked at there's like 20 people showing [0:14:17] up for one house so if you guys have any place that would be a safe haven for [0:14:23] them to heal with me. Great. Thank you. Don Hall. [0:14:28] Cleanita. I was trying to figure out how to say your name from your email earlier. So I [0:14:34] believe, wasn't there a GoFundMe account set up? Are they are they receiving some [0:14:39] income there that they can help them? Yes, they are getting the funds, but they [0:14:43] don't want to count on that. Sure. They want to make sure it's within their [0:14:46] budget of what they can afford after things. So it needs to stay within their [0:14:52] budget but they do have money to help for a down for something maybe a little [0:14:57] over their budget right now but because of course it's gonna be more than what [0:15:01] the apartment is that they're in but we would really you know something maybe [0:15:07] 975 less three three bedrooms preferably two could work but something [0:15:14] that is detached has their own yard so that the girl can both of their kids [0:15:20] can go outside and play and not be afraid. [0:15:22] Right. [0:15:23] I know that the Match Valley Realtors Association, I think, they put out a rentals list fairly [0:15:30] often. [0:15:31] We have to try. [0:15:32] We have looked at something. [0:15:33] There is a kitchen not every place we go to. [0:15:35] There's at least 20 people applying for one home, like that kitchen not. [0:15:41] So we have really, really been trying. [0:15:43] So if you guys have any. [0:15:46] We will do what we can to try to identify as some of the resources that are available [0:15:49] And then you can email me. [0:15:50] And try to email you. [0:15:51] I appreciate that. [0:15:52] I appreciate you being a good neighbor and doing what you can to help and for asking respectfully [0:16:01] this evening for our assistance. [0:16:03] Thank you. [0:16:04] Thank you. [0:16:05] Suzanne, should you have a comment? [0:16:06] I was just wondering, Glinita, if you had a chance to contact the Twin Falls Housing [0:16:09] Authority, have they been any resource at all? [0:16:12] No. [0:16:13] No. [0:16:14] Wait, the struggle is real. [0:16:15] I know it is, my children actually had to move out of the area because they could not find a rental house for a family with small children, I understand the struggle. [0:16:24] And they do have pets, they have ferrets to put their under medical, they have like a, through a doctor's note that they have them, and they're very clean people, so, and that. [0:16:37] Okay, we'll definitely get back and touch it on them. [0:16:40] I was just making sure that you had her contact him for okay. [0:16:47] Thank you. [0:16:48] Is there anyone else wishing to address the council this evening? [0:16:55] Seeing no one, thank you for your public input this evening. [0:16:59] We will move on with the agenda. [0:17:03] So we already handled the consent calendar, so the next item under items for consideration [0:17:07] is a request to accept the bid from TASER International Incorporated for the purchase of [0:17:12] wearable body cameras, software and integration and implementation services for $127,510. [0:17:20] We have Captain Anthony Barnhart from the Twin Falls Police Department. [0:17:23] Welcome, Captain. [0:17:24] Good evening, Mr. Mayor and members of the Council and thank you for giving us this opportunity [0:17:29] to bring forward the body camera bid for your approval this evening. [0:17:33] Tonight, I would ask that you approve the bid from Taser International for the purchase [0:17:39] of wearable body cameras, software, integration and implementation services for the total bid [0:17:45] price of $127,510. But before we get into that, I just want to give you guys a brief recap [0:17:54] if I could. So in 2015 as an organization, as one city, we decided that the police department [0:18:03] was going to implement body worn cameras in 2016. [0:18:07] In that same year, we identified a grant [0:18:09] through the Department of Justice [0:18:11] that would help us stand up a body worn camera program. [0:18:14] We applied for that grant, and we were awarded $90,000. [0:18:19] As part of that grant, it's a matching grant, [0:18:20] so we're going to match another $90,000, [0:18:23] and we have an additional $49,000, also budgeted [0:18:28] just to implement the body worn camera program. [0:18:31] for a total of $229,000. [0:18:35] Right around that same time that we were awarded the grant, [0:18:38] we stood up a body-worn camera project team [0:18:41] to help us through implementation. [0:18:44] That team is made up of Mandy Thompson [0:18:46] out of the City Manager's Office, [0:18:48] Mike Plain out of Information Services, [0:18:51] Officer JPO Donald from the Police Department [0:18:53] and Sergeant Brent Wright, also with the Police Department. [0:18:56] And the project team has been working extremely hard [0:18:59] to get through policy development, [0:19:01] which by the way has been accepted by the Department of Justice and approved by our command staff. [0:19:07] That policy will guide us in the programs that we need and it will also direct police officers [0:19:14] on how to use the cameras. [0:19:16] We also have been engaged in community outreach, giving several presentations, talking about [0:19:23] how we're going to use body cameras in the community. [0:19:25] We've given those to our strategic stakeholders. [0:19:27] presented to service organizations and most recently we had an open house on the campus [0:19:33] of the College of Southern Idaho inviting any community member that might be interested [0:19:38] to attend that presentation. [0:19:42] Captain Chris, talking to NASA. [0:19:44] Well I can wait. [0:19:45] I'm wondering about the warranty on the whole package. [0:19:48] We'll hold on and let him get to a good process here. [0:19:51] Just to wrap up, we've also tested and demonstrated a couple of different systems and through all [0:19:57] this way identified well over 30 specifications that we wanted to see in a [0:20:01] body camera system. Coming out of this process we went to open bid on Thursday [0:20:08] June 9th and by the time it closed on June 23rd we had four different bids from [0:20:14] four different vendors. Based upon our review the only conforming bid was from [0:20:19] Taser International based out of Scottsdale Arizona with a bid of $127,510. We [0:20:26] We believe TASER's bid is compliant with the conditions and specifications set forward [0:20:31] in the bid document and we believe the other three bids from VVU, Digital Ally and Centworth [0:20:38] all submitted bids that are nonconforming to the bid document. [0:20:42] With that I'm happy to speak about the nonconforming bids. [0:20:45] If not, I'd be happy to stand for any questions. [0:20:49] Chris Tockington. [0:20:52] And we discussed the eventual purchase of a body cam package and filming for the officers. [0:21:01] We're, I think, collectively the council most concerned that we just agree on the protocols [0:21:09] who is filmed along with keep the records, what is evidentiary, what is personal or private [0:21:17] filming. [0:21:18] Have we moved on that at all? [0:21:19] Absolutely. [0:21:20] and all that is clearly outlined in our policy [0:21:23] that was approved by the Department of Justice [0:21:25] and our command staff. [0:21:27] And it's all based off of best practices [0:21:29] we put a ton of research into the policy. [0:21:31] But we didn't have to invent it ourselves [0:21:33] as the best practices then. [0:21:35] Absolutely, we did not have to invent it ourselves [0:21:37] but I would also mention that we worked in collaboration [0:21:39] with our prosecuting offices, [0:21:41] both the Frits and the Grant Loaves. [0:21:44] Thank you, Kevin. [0:21:46] John Hall. [0:21:46] Mayor, if you're ready for a motion. [0:21:48] Are there any other questions for Captain Barnhart in this? [0:21:54] I do just want to make a comment in interviewing the information. [0:21:56] I think the diligence that you and your team put into making sure that the specifications [0:22:04] were going to meet the needs of the department now and into the future is to be commended. [0:22:11] And then as you went through the reasons that the other bidders were non-conforming, [0:22:15] It was some very specific items like the length of battery [0:22:18] to make sure your officers aren't dealing [0:22:21] with recharging batteries or dying in the middle of shift [0:22:24] and those types of things. [0:22:25] So I think your team did a great job. [0:22:27] And to Councilman Tockington's point too, [0:22:31] these are just the tools, how you use them [0:22:34] and how you implement those to help you do your job [0:22:37] and make sure that we're protecting the safety [0:22:40] of our citizens. [0:22:41] I think you've done a great job with that too. [0:22:43] So, thank you for the detail in this report. [0:22:45] Appreciate that. [0:22:47] And with that, I'll call. [0:22:48] Well, Seth, I would move approval of the request [0:22:51] to accept the bid from Taser in the National Inc. [0:22:54] For the purchase of wearable body cameras, [0:22:56] software and integration and implementation services [0:23:00] at the bid price of $127,510. [0:23:05] I'll second that. [0:23:08] The motion by Don Hal seconded by Ruth Pierce [0:23:10] to approve the accept bid from Taser International [0:23:14] as presented. [0:23:16] Is there any further discussion from the council? [0:23:19] Excuse me. [0:23:20] Seeing none, Sharon, roll call vote please. [0:23:23] Nicky Boyd? [0:23:24] Yes. [0:23:25] Sean Berriger? [0:23:26] Yes. [0:23:26] Chris Hockington? [0:23:27] Yes. [0:23:28] Don Hall? [0:23:29] Yes. [0:23:29] Ruth Pierce? [0:23:30] Yes. [0:23:31] Suzanne Hockton? [0:23:32] Yes. [0:23:33] Motion passes at 6 to 0. [0:23:35] Thank you, Captain. [0:23:39] Next on the agenda, we have a presentation of the City [0:23:41] managers recommended budget for fiscal year 2017 for a strategic plan focus [0:23:46] areas 7 responsible community and focus area 8 internal organization followed by [0:23:53] citizen input welcome Travis. Thank you Mr. Mayor members of the council so [0:23:59] tonight we're going to talk about two areas of our strategic plan one is going [0:24:03] to be a responsible community and the second is going to be our internal [0:24:07] organization, the internal organization that really is the heart of where we're at. [0:24:13] And I would be remissed if we didn't just, if I asked the council, and this might be in [0:24:17] a probe, just to take a few minutes to reflect on the tragic events that have occurred throughout [0:24:22] the country regarding police officers and how police officers are being attacked across [0:24:31] our country. [0:24:32] We have police officers that are very dedicated into our community. [0:24:35] We pray for their safety every night. [0:24:36] But if we could just take a minute to for those around the country, you know, that would be appreciated. [0:24:43] So again, Mr. Mayor, members of the council tonight is focus areas 7 and 8 being a responsible community. [0:24:58] And this really is important to have that conversation that our city's strategic plan really governs the financial and policy decisions that we set forth on an annual basis. [0:25:11] This strategic plan was created in 2012, it was implemented in 2013, and it will go through [0:25:20] its first official review later this fall. [0:25:24] And over the center vision, you will see eight overarching areas, eight areas that we have [0:25:32] created as primary focus areas to realize the vision that was created by our citizens [0:25:38] through a series of outreach processes, which is very similar to the process that we will [0:25:42] use moving forward, all to realize the vision that our community has set forward for 2030. [0:25:50] The vision elements are areas for us to strive, areas for us to try to achieve. [0:25:55] And what we hope is that through concentrated action and diligent pursuit of these objectives, [0:26:02] we will become the community that our citizens want us to become. [0:26:06] Before we begin talking about that, this is obviously we want to get to the end of the [0:26:10] story first. [0:26:11] We want to know how much is this going to cost me in right now as we shared last week and [0:26:17] we will continue to share, we have part of the puzzle answered today. [0:26:22] We have that part of the puzzle answered for those services that we completely control [0:26:27] what those costs are going to be, which are going to be the water utility and sanitation [0:26:33] fees. [0:26:35] And you'll notice that in total we're looking at about $1.19 per month for those three services [0:26:42] for the average user inside of the City of Twin Falls. [0:26:45] That average user is someone who is defined by uses 18,000 gallons of water on a monthly [0:26:51] basis that goes up to the 8,000-gallon sewer cap per month and then has also a residential [0:26:59] dwelling that receives both solid waste and sanitation or solid waste and recycling services. [0:27:06] You'll notice right now that the tax rate piece is listed as unknown. [0:27:13] And the tax rate in Idaho is different than some places because we don't assign mills. [0:27:18] We look at a tax rate and the tax rate is a mathematical formula that takes government spending. [0:27:23] And we know how much we're proposing, but we don't know the total taxable value. [0:27:28] Essentially, we don't know how to divide the pie, so that each property pays its fair share per $1,000 of total tax of a value. [0:27:37] That number is produced by the county assessor, and we will receive that number sometime in August. [0:27:42] And so as we continue to move forward, know that we recognize that this is an important part of that equation. [0:27:48] But at this point in time, it's not a place that we can fully answer. [0:27:52] and we hesitate on guessing, because in past years, as you know, we've guessed and we've [0:27:58] guessed really wrong, and so we've decided to get out of that guessing game and we really [0:28:03] want to be able to focus and provide good concentrated solid information as we have that. [0:28:11] So this is what the vision of focus area number seven is for our community, and it says that [0:28:19] Twin Falls community has retained its human face as it has grown over time. [0:28:24] It talks about how the community is actively engaged. [0:28:29] It talks about how all institutions, public, private, civic, art, religious, [0:28:35] nonprofit are working collectively and collaboratively [0:28:40] for the betterment of our organization. [0:28:43] And this is one of those primary focus areas that really calls the need for partners. [0:28:48] Because when you're looking at community and creating community, the city is a component. [0:28:55] And the city has the ability to lead. [0:28:58] But it does not have the ability to serve in all of those different areas. [0:29:03] And that's where our partners really help us secure the responsible community objective. [0:29:12] Our area is to be inclusive and to ensure that we're involving the community. [0:29:17] There are things that we're going and doing on an annual and routine basis that we are [0:29:22] committed to transparency and we're going to continue to openly operate in a transparent [0:29:27] manner by continuing to engage the community and we're going to dedicate human talent [0:29:32] and resources to city fairs through intentional outreach programs that involve the community [0:29:39] from transportation planning, to land use planning, to other different types of aspects [0:29:47] that we really believe that the community's input adds better and higher value than if [0:29:53] we try to do this alone. [0:29:56] That we're going to continue to build outreach to those groups that maybe are not as connected [0:30:00] to our entity as we would like, but they're incredible, valuable members of our community. [0:30:06] We started our outreach program to the senior citizen center. [0:30:10] We've also started that same outreach to the Latino community and we are going to continue [0:30:15] to dedicate resources towards those ends and we'll continue to do that and find other groups [0:30:21] that we don't necessarily see as being completely represented here to make sure that their voices [0:30:26] and access to our local government is equal to everyone else. [0:30:32] We're also going to go through that process to revise the strategic plan like I shared. [0:30:36] that cardinal document will start in September, and we'll enter that contract in September, [0:30:42] but it will be longer than a single month process that will need time and talent from [0:30:47] the city moving forward into the subsequent fiscal years. [0:30:50] And then we've also have some capital investment. [0:30:53] Capital investment for public art, repairs and maintenance to ensure that our library [0:30:58] remains world-class, fireworks, municipal band, and then obviously the municipal power [0:31:04] outsource grants where we increased that amount this year to reflect the total [0:31:09] allocation of the council awarded this year recognizing as we saw through all [0:31:13] those conversations the need was far greater than what we had and so we [0:31:18] increased that this year so that there's a hundred thousand dollars for the [0:31:23] municipal outsource grants which was the amount that was appropriated and we [0:31:27] have already set aside the money for the band. So with that Mr. Mayor members of [0:31:34] Council that is focus area seven again it's a it's a smaller area because it [0:31:39] requires a lot of the partnerships it's not capital intensive it's resource driven [0:31:44] from the talent that we have already on staff and those are the goals objectives [0:31:49] that we hope to accomplish through this budget. Chris talking to make one [0:31:55] comment I I'm particularly taken with our term responsible community I I applaud [0:32:01] that but I don't unfortunately feel as reflected in our budget all the way for 2017. Again, [0:32:10] I'm going back to the single can sanitation user who uses so little during a month that [0:32:21] they are in effect subsidizing the wasteful user like myself that has a full big blue. [0:32:30] We're only talking about a 1% sanitation hike this coming year, but I'm wondering if the [0:32:36] council can rationalize why we offer different recreation rates for golf and swimming, why [0:32:43] we offer different water rates on a sliding scale the more you use, the more you pay, and [0:32:49] also why you use the sliding scale for the sewer, and yet for the sanitation, that single [0:32:57] person within the Twin Falls confines who is on fixed income and maybe indeed be below [0:33:04] the poverty rate. I think we're overlooking and neglecting in our otherwise responsible [0:33:10] community budget. I didn't expect a response and I'm happy to hear I didn't get one because [0:33:20] it's obviously falling on deaf ears. Ruth Pierce. [0:33:23] Charles, I have a question and maybe it's a question for Bill or somebody in that department. [0:33:29] I noticed that there's the larger blue cans, and then there's the smaller blue cans. [0:33:34] Is there a different fee for the smaller? [0:33:36] There is. [0:33:37] So that could be a for a smaller person, senior fixed income, it would be a less charge than [0:33:44] what I'm paying or Chris's pay. [0:33:47] You could be. [0:33:48] And I think that there are a whole series of options. [0:33:49] And I know members of the team, Lori and Bill are continuing to work with PSI. [0:33:53] We owe you a contract and we heard the council at the last meeting, and we're still working [0:33:57] with PSI to find that optimum solution that has been kind of expressed. [0:34:04] What is important to remember about the sanitation is that most of the costs are fixed. [0:34:13] And what happens is if you assign a fee, whether it's fair or not, to all of the users, you're [0:34:22] going to spread an even fee across all users. [0:34:27] And as you know, if you offset that by the size of the can, the next question is, because [0:34:34] there is so much revenue that you need to be able to bring into the support of the system, [0:34:38] what happens to the cost that you're going to impact to the other users? [0:34:42] And so we're working through that math equation right now, and hopefully we'll build a pitch [0:34:46] some other, maybe some solutions for you to look at. [0:34:50] The largest thing that we're looking at, though, is if you give someone a smaller can, does [0:34:58] that restrict their ability to take advantage of the unlimited trash collection system that [0:35:06] we have? [0:35:07] So is there a way that someone can say, well, I'm only going to pay for this can, but under [0:35:11] our current collection system, we allow you to use that can and then to use the entire [0:35:18] curb that you have left available for pickup. [0:35:23] And so how do you regulate the unlimited connect collection to ensure that the person who is [0:35:31] needing, truly needing the small can is receiving the small can, and then someone who is trying [0:35:36] to take advantage of the system that we've created is held accountable, and that system [0:35:41] doesn't allow that to move forward. [0:35:43] And so we're looking at some of those opportunities to present to you, and I wish I could stand [0:35:49] before you to say that we have found the absolute perfect solution. [0:35:53] While we've searched, we have yet to find it. [0:35:55] We recognize that whatever solution we pitch to you will could fundamentally change that [0:36:02] level of service for some member of our community, maybe both positively and negatively, but [0:36:08] know that we're working on that. [0:36:09] Travis, do you anticipate that that will, [0:36:13] prior to some level of conclusion [0:36:15] prior to the adoption of the budget? [0:36:16] Yes, it will. [0:36:19] Yes, it will. [0:36:21] Thank you. [0:36:22] Yeah. [0:36:24] Any other questions related to Area 7 [0:36:27] before Travis moves on in his presentation? [0:36:32] Okay, so focus area number eight [0:36:33] is the internal organization. [0:36:36] And this is the part that we've spent [0:36:39] the most time talking about. [0:36:42] This is the place that public. [0:36:47] Did you need to jump in on the item seven? [0:36:49] Yeah, I did. [0:36:50] Okay. [0:36:52] Sorry. [0:36:56] I know that we're at the beginning stages of the budget. [0:37:00] I know that we at least hinted around to this, [0:37:05] but involving the community and being a responsible [0:37:10] community number seven, area seven, [0:37:14] One of the things that I think that we absolutely need to do, and I know this is on the plate [0:37:19] at least visiting about, is to get a person to start helping with our victims. [0:37:27] We used to have a victim advocate coordinator with the City of Twin Falls, and then several [0:37:34] years back, I don't even remember when it was, we lost that position. [0:37:38] And I think some of the issues that we've had recently with some folks. [0:37:43] And I think that position could have really helped out to help folks navigate the whole criminal justice system. [0:37:52] Because it's not user friendly sometimes. [0:37:56] And I just think that's so paramount to the service that we can provide. [0:38:00] I know that the sheriff's department's victims coordinator has helped us tremendously. [0:38:05] that's one person for the whole county. [0:38:08] And I really envision maybe if we had one, [0:38:12] and they had one, they could work together and share, [0:38:15] you know, one of them, they have to take vacation, [0:38:18] in person a while. [0:38:19] So it'd be nice to have someone taking over [0:38:21] for the full county and just kind of collaborate [0:38:24] and work together. [0:38:25] Could you maybe give us some kind of indication [0:38:27] what your thought process is about that, Travis? [0:38:30] So, absolutely. [0:38:31] So as we shared last week, we have a amount of money [0:38:35] that has not been appropriated inside of this budget. [0:38:39] As I shared, we had about, we estimated, [0:38:42] this is a good example of how when we look [0:38:44] at the best information we have available, [0:38:47] we sometimes in projecting resources will get it wrong. [0:38:51] So we were projecting, so last year, [0:38:54] we had achieved about a 36 million, [0:38:57] slightly more than $36 million new construction number, [0:39:00] which is the added number of the total taxable value [0:39:04] of the city. [0:39:05] And the way Idaho Code is, is we're able to tax, use new construction growth plus the 3% [0:39:12] and that's called our statutory allowance. [0:39:14] And so that becomes a pretty critical piece of what it looks like for tax revenues coming [0:39:18] in. This year we were projecting that it would be about $40 million and we did receive [0:39:23] that number and as I shared with the council last week it exceeded $68 million. [0:39:29] And so that amount of money plus some of the monies that we had not budgeted as we [0:39:35] We're kind of waiting to see what that total taxable value number is. [0:39:38] Right now we have about $300,000 of funds that are available at the statutory increases, [0:39:48] keeping the entire foregone balance intact and using $300,000 for a series of things. [0:39:57] I believe that a victim witness coordinator with those resources is absolutely one of those things that should be considered. [0:40:05] it for funding. It is not included in my budget because at the point of looking at $40 million, [0:40:13] we were making sure that we were taking care of our employees that we had internal to our [0:40:17] organization first, and about $60,000 represents about a third of an increase across all of the [0:40:25] employees. And so I took caring for the existing staff as a higher priority. While we're talking [0:40:31] about that, the other thing that you won't see in terms of staffing in here, and I was [0:40:35] going to save this for Brian, but Brian, while we're talking about it, I'm going to take [0:40:38] it now. [0:40:40] I've asked Mandy and members of the PD's command team to take a look at securing another [0:40:48] COPS grant to get more police officers, and we have submitted that grant, and you won't [0:40:54] necessarily see that into the budget because there's no necessary allocation needed for [0:41:01] this time front end. But it will be needed as we kind of go forward and the idea is to [0:41:05] continue to find ways to add men and women to the streets in the front line. It's a double [0:41:11] edged sword. So, you know, Sergeant Brent Wright is still here. And he can be my witness that [0:41:22] He is probably one of the strongest advocates in sharing [0:41:27] how important it is to make sure that we are compensating [0:41:32] our police force so that we can retain them. [0:41:36] I mean, it's one thing to have an allocation of 72 or 76 [0:41:41] officers if you get the grant that are sworn that are working [0:41:44] the streets on a daily basis. [0:41:46] But if you can't fail 60 of them, [0:41:48] it doesn't matter what that total allocation is [0:41:51] because they go on field. [0:41:53] And what we need to make sure is not only [0:41:55] are we providing the adequate number of police officers [0:41:58] on the streets, but we need to make sure they're compensated [0:42:02] at a level that the salary considerations [0:42:05] and other communities, including the Treasure Valley, [0:42:08] is not the primary motive for them leaving. [0:42:12] Because all we then become is a revolving door, [0:42:15] and we talk about this concept of one city. [0:42:19] and I'm really getting away ahead in my presentation right now. [0:42:22] But we talk about this concept of One City [0:42:24] and how all departments will work collaboratively [0:42:27] to find better programs and services [0:42:30] across department lines. [0:42:33] One city works when you have strong tenures. [0:42:37] It works when you have people who have been able to build [0:42:40] connections and relationships for a long period of time. [0:42:44] And so here, in a one focus area eight, [0:42:48] The reason that I have put such an emphasis on compensation [0:42:51] this year is because we need to ensure [0:42:55] that we can do everything that we can to not only retain, [0:43:01] but also to attract new men and women into our organization [0:43:04] across all levels, across all departments, [0:43:09] when those vacancies arise and occur. [0:43:13] And so, to answer your question, really, [0:43:16] I was wondering when you come back around to it. [0:43:20] Hopefully you didn't have a follow-up. [0:43:24] So synopsis is that yes, we're going to be looking at that. [0:43:28] We're going to be busy about it. [0:43:29] Funds are available, and if a council believes it, [0:43:31] I've had conversations with the chief. [0:43:34] I've asked the chief, I've shared my ideas [0:43:36] about what a victim witness coordinator should look like. [0:43:39] The chief and I've had conversations [0:43:41] about a victim witness coordinator, [0:43:43] and I think that he would welcome that into the budget. [0:43:46] should the council agree that that would be an appropriate use of that $300,000 that we [0:43:50] have not allocated or maybe it's a plant, something else that we put into the budget. [0:43:56] Well, certainly it wouldn't cost $300,000 to do it, but I would just- [0:44:00] We estimate that it's slightly under $62,000 fully burdened for that position. [0:44:05] I would just reiterate what I said to the council then, that I don't know what's more important [0:44:11] then for us to be able to help victims weave their way through the system because, again, [0:44:17] the system is not the easiest system to get through and I mean we had somebody come forward [0:44:25] tonight that talked about trying to find housing for someone. I mean it could go as far as that, [0:44:30] have resources that they could help folks in their time of trouble. So I just, I advocate [0:44:37] for that. [0:44:43] So on an internal organization, I tried to remember what I was going to say if I kind [0:44:47] of get a little bit repetitive, I apologize, but really I think that we're looking for the [0:44:57] last sentence here. [0:44:58] And that is a high degree of competency is provided by a lean, properly compensated and [0:45:04] respected core staff. [0:45:05] I mean at the end of the day, public services are delivered by the men and women who work [0:45:10] for the City of Twin Falls. [0:45:13] of the human face of our organization. That's the place where I believe that we need to focus [0:45:18] our resources this year and subsequent years being able to move forward. So these are some [0:45:26] of the strategic planning objectives. One is to provide a high effective professional staff [0:45:31] to provide the high quality services and residents to our citizens, our businesses, and our visitors. [0:45:40] I think it's really important to remember that the City of Twin Falls is an urban hub [0:45:46] with a service population that is defined by the Chamber of Commerce and St. Luke's that [0:45:51] contains a geographic population of about 250,000 people. And on any given day inside [0:45:58] of the City of Twin Falls, we grow to about 70 to 75,000 people and the human and the physical [0:46:05] infrastructure that we have needs to be used to accommodate that. And when we start looking [0:46:11] at talent and how we're going to be able to offer higher better services, it's important [0:46:16] to recognize the size of the community that we're looking at. [0:46:21] It's not just our census population that we offer services to. [0:46:24] In fact, last year, the police department through their research was able to illustrate [0:46:30] that nearly half of the citations and half of the misdemeanors that are issued by the [0:46:38] by the Twin Falls Police Department are two citizens that do not have Twin Falls City addresses. [0:46:47] We offer a level of service regardless of address and in order to effectively offer [0:46:53] that service we need to make sure that we're able to do these different types of things. [0:46:57] So the first is that we're giving proper tools and training as one of the objectives [0:47:02] and you'll see that we're going to continue to look at the digitizing of building permits, [0:47:06] We're expanding our code enforcement software to be able to be used by animal control for [0:47:10] one city. [0:47:11] We're going to be upgrading our Granica software, not only for here, but also for additional [0:47:16] live streaming capabilities that will be able to be transferred over to the new city hall. [0:47:21] We're looking at an FfNE budget for not only the new city hall, but also for the public safety [0:47:25] bids. [0:47:26] That is the entire for both. [0:47:28] And then we're going to continue to invest in one city. [0:47:31] That we continue to send people back to the University of Virginia, and we continue to [0:47:35] bring them here because we want to make sure that members of our team are looking at those [0:47:40] opportunities. We have employees today that come up to us and say, I hope I get to go next. [0:47:47] It is really something that we want to continue with. We believe it's making great strides. [0:47:52] We believe that the Council's allowance for us to do the city retreat and then also to [0:47:58] have a one-city planning session for those individuals to go forward is paying dividends [0:48:03] not only in connection and collaboration, but also in the work product that's realized [0:48:07] by our citizens. [0:48:08] Chris, if I could ask a question on that Virginia training. [0:48:16] I have no doubt that there's intangible benefits, but this is an expensive program, there's no [0:48:21] doubt about it. [0:48:23] Do we have any way to measure success on an intangible like employee training? [0:48:30] I don't know if you can do it on retention, reduction in workload, but I think it's only [0:48:37] fair to the citizenry that are paying the bill to say, how do you know it's working? [0:48:42] Yep, I think that's fair. [0:48:43] So maybe what we should do is in the past, we've had individuals who've attended the One [0:48:47] City training. [0:48:48] We did it very early on and they came and talked about what they've seen. [0:48:52] I can share with you what I'm seeing as the benefits, but let us take a minute and we'll [0:48:58] actually have people that have gone to both the one city training as well as the training [0:49:04] here in town and we'll have them come and share how they're applying that in their [0:49:10] day-to-day activities as it helps them serve the customers. I think their testimonials [0:49:16] will be far more impactful than what I might share with you. We'll do that during this [0:49:21] budget session. So treating our employees fairly and under this it talks about making sure [0:49:33] that our compensation strategies are equitable. [0:49:36] And so what we have here is we're looking at a salary table adjustment of about 5% that [0:49:43] basically takes the entire table and it shifts it and has the compression ratios that would [0:49:49] come into play should those triggers be reached and realized. [0:49:53] This is in addition to that 4% mid-year adjustment that you've gone forward with and then across [0:49:58] the board we're looking at a 5% movement based upon performance and those are the total costs. [0:50:06] And that's a lot of money. [0:50:08] That is a considerable amount of money when you start looking at wages and increases. [0:50:14] But I will also say that I have yet to have a citizen say, send me the police officer in [0:50:20] my time and need that you can afford. [0:50:25] For us to be able to ensure that we're offering the high level of services, it takes us securing [0:50:34] the highest level of talent. [0:50:37] And when folks in the Treasure Valley and communities in Eastern Idaho, as I shared during those [0:50:42] studies earlier this year, are compensating their employees significantly more than where [0:50:48] we are, you know that the table movement and the 5% that I'm proposing now doesn't [0:50:56] even cross and create the bridge to get us to where they're at. But it's a step in [0:51:03] the right direction. And the area, the question is, well, can you always be [0:51:08] competing against Boise? Should you be competing against Boise? And I think that [0:51:13] what we need to do is recognize that public service professionals are [0:51:19] scarce resources. And if this is a simple economics equation, scarce resources can [0:51:25] also be considered as luxury goods. And luxury goods in a market have their price. And so [0:51:33] the reason that I am recommending this is because I believe in the men and women of [0:51:38] the City of Twin Falls, I believe in everything that they do, and we owe it to them to be fair. [0:51:47] We're going to develop a wellness program. We've been working over the course of the last [0:51:51] several months with both St. Luke's and Select Health in developing an employee wellness [0:51:56] program because we believe that the best way that we can reduce or to slow down high [0:52:03] cost health insurance increases is to have an well-employed court. [0:52:09] And we think that helping them become informed about healthy choices and healthy opportunities [0:52:14] is something that we should be a part of. [0:52:17] We have a funding to support the 15 percent rate adjustment for health insurance this year [0:52:23] are covered into the budget. [0:52:24] And in order for us to help curb some of that, [0:52:27] we believe that we need to focus on wellness. [0:52:29] Some of the best practices say that that's where we're at. [0:52:32] And then we're going to continue to enhance our recruitment [0:52:35] and retention through the One City concepts. [0:52:38] We want individuals to become fully [0:52:41] and bored with One City as we move forward. [0:52:47] So again, this is kind of where we're at. [0:52:50] We've illustrated what this part of the budget costs [0:52:53] and how we continue to be able to move forward. [0:52:57] That didn't turn out very well, that's my fault. [0:53:00] But this kind of illustrates the budget calendar [0:53:02] if you could read it, so I'll read it for you. [0:53:06] So next week, you'll see that we're going to be focusing [0:53:09] on strategic planning areas one, two, and three. [0:53:15] And I believe Brian has those. [0:53:17] And so Brian is going to be talking [0:53:19] about those three focus areas next week. [0:53:22] Mitch will come back the following week with focus areas four and five. [0:53:27] I will have focus area number six and if all things work on that evening, which might [0:53:34] be the perfect alignment of stars, we might be also able to introduce an economic development [0:53:41] director on that evening. [0:53:45] We will go through, have the public hearings on any necessary rate adjustments that are [0:53:50] needed at this point in time we're not believing that there are any rate adjustments that would [0:53:54] require public hearings. But we would still have to set the maximum spending of the budget. [0:54:01] We would then host the public hearing on the evening of the 29th and then we would ask [0:54:07] the council to consider the budget on Monday, August 29th as we continue to move forward. [0:54:13] Every step along the way, every single area, we would encourage the citizens to share their [0:54:20] thoughts with staff, share their thoughts with council to participate in the public meeting [0:54:25] to help shape this budget, to help us understand the services that they want to see delivered [0:54:31] in this upcoming fiscal year. [0:54:33] And with that, I'm happy to stand for any questions. [0:54:36] Any questions from the council for Travis? [0:54:39] Yeah, would you add a no? [0:54:42] We're just getting started. [0:54:44] I do not see any Travis. [0:54:49] So as we have done in every step of the budget process and we'll continue to do so, we would [0:54:55] give an opportunity for members of the public to give input on the budget, any thoughts related [0:55:01] to the presentation this evening or ongoing spending of those dollars? [0:55:07] Come on forward sir. [0:55:13] Please introduce yourself and state your address with the record. [0:55:16] Absolutely, my name's Paul Thompson. I am a resident of Twin Falls. Just live a couple of blocks from here [0:55:23] If you need my address, I don't mind giving it to you, but I don't like giving it out in public [0:55:27] If that's alright, I [0:55:31] Think we'll be fine with the Twin Falls. Okay. I'll be happy to give it to you come visit me sometime [0:55:40] So mr. Mayor and members of the council, I'm so grateful to live in the city of Twin Falls [0:55:46] For 15 years, I've had the privilege of living here. [0:55:51] And just recently, I've moved my widowed mother, [0:55:54] because I think Twin Falls is a good place to live. [0:55:57] And so I want to just speak to you in relationship to the budget [0:56:01] and make appeal to you to continue doing a good work that you're doing. [0:56:07] And I'm grateful for the partnered work that I have in the city [0:56:11] city as a member of the citizen group number seven. [0:56:18] I didn't know I was a member of citizen group number seven until tonight. [0:56:22] So a member, a reasonable and responsible person, a partner in the community, [0:56:29] a pastor in the community and grateful for everything that the city affords, [0:56:33] the people that I pastor and my own personal household and my family at large. [0:56:39] And so I don't have a question for you. [0:56:42] I have an appeal to you to continue to do your good duty. [0:56:46] And I give you my word that I'll continue to do my duty in relationship to spiritual matters [0:56:51] in our community. [0:56:52] And I'm grateful for the unique and distinct difference that we have. [0:56:57] And I'm grateful again to my Lord and Savior that I live in the city of Twin Falls. [0:57:02] And I know there's a lot of reports about people worried about living in the city. [0:57:07] And I haven't had one sleepless night yet. [0:57:11] I do not say that to diminish the seriousness of all issues that are before us, but I want [0:57:17] to encourage you, do not be moved to adjust your duty to accommodate what would appear [0:57:25] to be fear and misunderstanding around the country about the good city of Twin Falls. [0:57:30] I'm grateful for you. [0:57:33] I will disagree with you, and I've even stood at this podium before to disagree with you, [0:57:38] and I think it's an amazing thing that as a member of the community, a citizen, as a pastor [0:57:44] in a community, that I can do so and not live in fear that I'm going to go home and lose [0:57:49] my house because I've disagreed with you, that I hold a different opinion than you, or [0:57:53] that my church is going to be taxed because of a different opinion that we have. [0:57:58] So I stand before you today, give you my word. [0:58:01] I will continue doing my duty, and I'm grateful for your charge and your duty that you have [0:58:06] and a shared group that we have in area number seven. [0:58:12] So thank you very much. [0:58:14] Thank you for your continued partnership and for your participation in the process. [0:58:18] Nicky Boyd. [0:58:19] Yes, I just want to say thank you very much, very well spoken. [0:58:22] Is there anyone else from the public who'd like to provide input on the budget this evening? [0:58:31] Seeing no one. [0:58:32] We'll move on to the next item on the agenda, which is items from the City Manager or the City Council. [0:58:39] Mr. Rothweiler. [0:58:40] Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, we sent out a PSA. [0:58:43] I sent you out an email, but we're also going to take an opportunity to talk about the Eastland Road Construction Project. [0:58:49] Just for those viewers that we might have this evening that may have missed both. [0:58:55] So, we're started the Eastland Road Construction Rebuild Project that will run until about mid-September [0:59:03] of this year. [0:59:04] It really does fix that critical section from the underpass moving south. [0:59:12] There are detail detours that are established. [0:59:14] We've contacted and worked with the individual businesses out there who are going to be directly [0:59:18] affected, but we would encourage our citizens to recognize that there might be some delays, [0:59:24] And there are certainly some detours in that area from now until later this year. [0:59:29] It's a million dollar project that is being performed by PMF. [0:59:34] It is slightly under budget in comparison to what we came forward with and [0:59:38] we're looking at how we might be able to maybe further that project. [0:59:42] There is still subsequent sections of Eastland. [0:59:45] One of the things that we're doing to secure that is we're moving the asphalt and [0:59:49] we're turning into a concrete road surface so it has much longer life and durability, [0:59:53] especially in those truck areas. [0:59:54] So we wanted to make sure that the citizens were aware, [0:59:57] that you had awareness, and if you had any questions, [0:59:59] that you were able to respond to that. [1:00:02] Donna, do you have a question, Malay? [1:00:04] Not about that, okay. [1:00:07] The next thing I have for you is just a quick reminder. [1:00:12] Chief Ron Clark will be retiring on Friday, [1:00:17] and there's a celebration of his over 40 year career [1:00:21] that will take place on Friday. [1:00:24] we would encourage, it's a Friday afternoon, I believe it starts at three o'clock. [1:00:29] We would encourage you to come, it's in the bay of the fire station, really it's a celebration [1:00:37] of a phenomenal career and as Ron has been on the member of our city's executive leadership [1:00:47] team and we are certainly going to miss the wisdom and the experience that he brings to [1:00:55] the table and so we would invite you to come and celebrate with us. [1:01:00] This is his send-off. [1:01:02] We let our folks determine how they want to have their celebration and this is what he [1:01:09] has chosen. [1:01:10] Thank you, Travis, Susan Hawkins. [1:01:17] Thank you. [1:01:18] So on Friday afternoon, Don Hall and I had the opportunity to attend a ribbon cutting event [1:01:25] for some homes that were built to help fundraise for the Boys and Girls Club of Magic Valley. [1:01:32] Since we're talking about responsible community tonight and partnerships, I see Gerald Martin's [1:01:37] here and it was his leading that brought this project together and was able to bring something [1:01:44] to our community to light that nobody thought was possible. [1:01:48] I think during that meeting there were probably ten minutes where they just read off names [1:01:52] of people in our community that donated, volunteered, or helped to realize this project. [1:01:58] But the homes have been built and now they're being sold and the money is going back to the [1:02:03] Boys and Girls Club to help them in the future. [1:02:06] And with that, I don't know if the council remembers, but at the time we did agree to [1:02:10] waive some of the building fees for them. [1:02:13] And so we were listed on their partners in the project, and they gave us a very nice gift [1:02:19] that I have here to present to the city on behalf of Boys and Girls Club. [1:02:22] I don't know if the camera can see it. [1:02:25] It's a nice clock with our name and the Boys and Girls Club logo on it. [1:02:30] Cool. [1:02:33] Am I the city? [1:02:34] You are right now. [1:02:35] I'm going to give it to you. [1:02:36] I'm going to give it to you. [1:02:37] Thanks. [1:02:38] Thank you. [1:02:39] And thank you to the Boys and Girls Club and all of those partners. [1:02:45] Dunhall. [1:02:46] I'll just reiterate. [1:02:48] was Gerald's leadership in that. You said it quite well, but just one more kudos to Gerald for him [1:02:56] making that whole process and ability for the Boys and Girls Club to realize those funds to [1:03:03] better serve our kids. What I wanted to bring up, you brought up roads and it finally hit me, [1:03:07] and maybe this is for you, Mitch, if you could talk to Jackie. I've had several folks as well as [1:03:11] as myself, notice that the intersection of frontier and falls, [1:03:16] where you're right next to that fire department, [1:03:19] that road is gone. [1:03:21] It's almost on the frontier itself. [1:03:24] It's chipping up and looks really bad, [1:03:28] and I didn't know if that was on the list this year [1:03:31] to be rebuilt. [1:03:32] Seems to me that's not an overlight, that's a rebuild. [1:03:39] We'll check to see if that is truly [1:03:41] part of the public road system it's the north side of falls we'll look into [1:03:50] that it goes by the park though yeah I know but we'll look into see if that is [1:03:55] actually a public thoroughfare okay well look yeah I would assume that the fire [1:04:01] department probably drives that quite often so all right thank you anything [1:04:09] else from the council all right we're gonna go ahead and move into our public [1:04:16] hearing, which was scheduled for no earlier than six o'clock. [1:04:20] So this evening we have a request for a special use permit [1:04:23] to construct and operate a medical dental office [1:04:27] on property located at the southeast corner of Bridge [1:04:29] Ubelevard and Locust Street North. [1:04:32] Gerald Martin's on behalf of Temple View Properties. [1:04:36] Welcome, Mr. Martin's. [1:04:37] Thank you. [1:04:39] For the record, my name is Gerald Martin's. [1:04:41] I'm here representing Temple View Properties, [1:04:43] owner of the property at the intersection of Locust and Bridgeview where the little red [1:04:54] axe is on the exhibit. This is part of East Park commercial subdivision number two and [1:05:05] one of the conditions in this subdivision was that a special use permit be provided by the [1:05:15] City Council, which makes it very unique for any development within this [1:05:19] subdivision. So you've heard me here three times. This is my third time here in [1:05:22] about three meetings. The first one was the surgery center. The next one was [1:05:26] first American title. And this is the third one. And we've got another project [1:05:31] forthcoming. So I'll be back again. Basically, what we're proposing here is a [1:05:37] one story, professional medical office building, basically sitting on the corner, it's really [1:05:51] in kind of a fishbowl, it's open to three frontages in a lot of ways, and so the architecturally [1:06:00] we, I believe, come up with a plan that is quite attractive from any and all directions, [1:06:06] It's quite compatible material-wise and color-wise with the other two buildings that are going adjacent to it. [1:06:12] It is an office building, normal hours are eight to five, five days a week. [1:06:18] We have reviewed the staff recommendations for approval of a permit, and we can occur. [1:06:27] And as with the others, two previous ones, the lighting on this project will be done project-wide, [1:06:35] as part of the master project and operate and maintained, [1:06:39] as will the landscaping by the property owners association. [1:06:42] And so the lighting will be very conscious to make sure [1:06:45] that the lighting is installed in such a way that none [1:06:48] of the light source is seen from off from the property [1:06:51] with special attention to the residential properties [1:06:54] to the south. [1:06:56] That'll be glad to answer any questions. [1:06:59] Chris, Dr. Oleges, you don't have any problem, [1:07:02] and it is feasible in asking both parties [1:07:04] on the pressure right irrigation system. [1:07:08] Yes. [1:07:08] There's a ditch on the other side of it. [1:07:10] Would you want to put up the? [1:07:11] I'll admit, Jonah, but I wasn't sure [1:07:13] if water was accessible on it and that. [1:07:15] No, no, no, let's go into the plot. [1:07:22] This development called East Park Commercial Subdivision [1:07:26] number two, number one, is this just the surgery center? [1:07:30] Two is a tan colored parcel. [1:07:34] There will be six lots in that development. [1:07:37] The Brown parcel is East Park commercial subdivision number three, which will be coming through [1:07:45] the review process. [1:07:46] It's now been submitted. [1:07:49] And this is the irrigation ditch at biceps of property. [1:07:53] All property owners, all three of the developers are collectively working to install a pressurized [1:07:59] irrigation system at this location. [1:08:02] And it will be installed this summer for irrigation before any of these homes are completed and [1:08:08] ready for occupancy. [1:08:09] Excellent. [1:08:10] I should point out, and that is a private pressurized irrigation system, not one that will be maintained [1:08:21] by the city. [1:08:24] All right. [1:08:27] We'll have our staff report from Jonathan Spendlow. [1:08:30] Thank you, Mayor Becker. [1:08:32] So staff report is no different from the last couple really. [1:08:37] looking at just a slightly different location. You've seen this a couple of [1:08:42] different times from March, April, May, June. The plan will be checked. The [1:08:48] building permits are going to be checked through the normal process. Really we have [1:08:51] a PUD that kind of dictates the process. We have not the special use permit. We [1:08:54] reiterated that a couple different times. So the zoning code we're dealing with is [1:08:59] professional office overlay and the R2 zone which requires a special use permit. [1:09:03] They've got parking requirements and other requirements such as landscaping [1:09:07] screening, storm drainage, we'll check all of those on the building permit, the plans they've [1:09:11] given us appear to follow all those requirements. We do the final official review during that [1:09:17] building permit stage. The PUD agreements also got additional development restrictions. For [1:09:25] those looking or listening online that didn't hear the previous ones, I'll read those. All [1:09:30] buildings constructed on this property will be constructed using residential style architecture [1:09:35] and we'll have an architectural finish aesthetically pleasing. [1:09:37] All professional buildings in this area will be limited to single-story construction. [1:09:42] Buildings within 350 feet of Locustreet may have a maximum size of 10,000 square feet. [1:09:48] All other buildings will be limited to 6,000 square feet. [1:09:52] Buildings facing Chaney, which this one is not, parking occur in the north of the building [1:09:56] and landscaping, perimeter landscaping along Locustreet, North Chaney and Bridgeview shall [1:10:01] be installed at a minimum depth of 20 feet from back of curb, or future curb. [1:10:07] The PUD also contains other building standards above and beyond the base zoning code, these [1:10:12] items will be reviewed and enforced at the time of building permits submittal as well. [1:10:15] The site plan and elevation is submitted by the applicant to peer-to-being compliance [1:10:19] with requirements listed above and within the PUD agreement. [1:10:23] This is not an official review, we'll do that during the building permit process. [1:10:26] The impacts as with the others really come down to traffic and light. [1:10:30] The traffic will increase in this area but they are in close proximity to locust, bridge [1:10:35] view, Madrona and Pulline Road. [1:10:37] If you don't think the roads will be deteriorated to a point that they'll be terrible. [1:10:43] There will be more traffic because of businesses that previously was bare ground. [1:10:48] However, none of those access points directly go into neighboring residential homes. [1:10:55] You have to kind of go around only people going through those neighborhoods will be the people living there [1:10:59] Most of them are dead end streets around it [1:11:01] So we don't believe the traffic will have a huge impact the lighting as Gerald said [1:11:05] We've made a point with them to make sure that it's shielded from the neighboring property owners and [1:11:10] In general professional offices make pretty good neighbors [1:11:13] the operating hours [1:11:15] The landscaping usually kept really well and most of the stuff takes place inside [1:11:19] So we believe it's an okay fit for this area and a decent development for this corner [1:11:25] in between the heavy commercial of Home Depot and the other's retail and then the residential [1:11:31] to the south. [1:11:32] So it's a good buffer between the two. [1:11:36] Other pretty much gone through all of that. [1:11:39] So should the council grant this special use permit as presented staff recommends the following [1:11:44] conditions. [1:11:45] One subject to the site plan amendments as required by building engineering, fire and zoning officials [1:11:51] to ensure compliance with applicable city code requirements and standards and compliance [1:11:55] with the East Park PUD agreement number 213. [1:11:58] Number two, subject to a PI system being approved [1:12:01] by the City Engineering Department prior to issuance [1:12:03] of a certificate of occupancy. [1:12:05] And number three, subject all lighting being downward facing [1:12:07] and light source being shielded [1:12:08] from nearby residential properties. [1:12:10] That's all. [1:12:13] Thank you, Jonathan. [1:12:14] Any questions for Jonathan? [1:12:16] Chris talking. [1:12:16] Ready for a motion. [1:12:17] We got to do a public hearing still. [1:12:20] Gotcha. [1:12:22] So any questions for Jonathan? [1:12:26] Seeing none, we will open and now to the general public [1:12:28] to provide testimony on this request. [1:12:31] If there's anyone from the public wishing to testify, [1:12:33] please come forward. [1:12:38] Seeing no one, we will close the public testimony [1:12:41] portion of the hearing. [1:12:43] Mr. Martins, did you have any rebuttal you'd like to give [1:12:46] to the overwhelming testimony there? [1:12:49] Certainly not any rebuttal. [1:12:51] I just wanted to point out which I intended to before [1:12:54] that Cheney Street along the south boundary [1:12:57] of this entire quarter of a mile, which [1:13:01] has been half straight for many years, ever since the residential subdivision was developed, [1:13:06] will be fully developed to full with this part of these three continuous projects that [1:13:11] are being done now. So we will improve some of the traffic facilities in the area. [1:13:19] Thank you, Gerald. Chris Stockington. [1:13:23] I'm a little unfamiliar with how many private PI systems we have in the city and the consequences [1:13:32] of that downstream or the city taking over any of the liability. [1:13:37] Anybody in the city answer any of that for me or Gerald or what your knowledge of it, I [1:13:43] appreciate that. [1:13:44] I can think of five or six that I've been involved in, private systems. [1:13:52] They typically occur in an area like this where it's more of an infill and the watersheds [1:13:59] are still available because the canal goes through the property. [1:14:03] They function relatively well, or well, [1:14:08] especially in a commercial project, [1:14:10] because you have an organization that's active [1:14:14] to operate it and assess the property owners. [1:14:18] Unlike you might have, [1:14:20] if it were in a residential subdivision [1:14:22] where you have sometimes homeowners associations [1:14:26] are relatively inactive or dysfunctional, [1:14:30] but we have a property owners association, [1:14:33] These property owners are building these office buildings, [1:14:36] they're making large investments in this property. [1:14:41] The association not only maintains a pressure irrigation system, [1:14:45] but all of the perimeter landscaping, [1:14:47] all of the interior landscaping, [1:14:49] all of the parking lot maintenance. [1:14:51] So it needs to be active and it will be active [1:14:54] and it's very important to their business [1:14:57] and the success of their businesses [1:14:58] to have a functioning property owners association. [1:15:02] All right, we'll close the public hearing and turn it over to Council for a deliberation. [1:15:10] Chris Stockton. [1:15:11] I'll try it the fourth time. [1:15:13] I will move approval for the special use permit to construct and operate a medical dental office or property of the southeast corner of Gridfield and locus subject to the three attached conditions permit. [1:15:28] I'll second. [1:15:29] I'll second. [1:15:30] Motion by Chris Stockington, seconded by Nikki Boyd to approve the special use permit as [1:15:36] presented and including the staff recommendations. [1:15:39] Is there any further discussion from the council? [1:15:44] Seeing none, Sharon Roll, call vote please. [1:15:47] Sean Bericher? [1:15:48] Yes. [1:15:49] Chris talking to? [1:15:50] Yes. [1:15:51] Don Hall? [1:15:52] Yes. [1:15:53] Ruth Pierce? [1:15:54] Yes. [1:15:55] Suzanne Hawkins? [1:15:56] Yes. [1:15:57] Nikki Boyd? [1:15:58] Yes. [1:15:59] She passes 6-0. [1:16:00] With that, we are ready to move to the last item of the agenda, which is adjournment. [1:16:09] We have a request to move to adjourn into executive session under Idaho Code 742061A to consider hiring a public officer, [1:16:22] employee, staff member, or individual agent. [1:16:25] We're in the respective qualities of individuals are to be evaluated in order to fill a particular vacancy or need. [1:16:31] This paragraph does not apply to filling a vacancy in an elective office or [1:16:35] deliberations about staffing needs in general. [1:16:39] Council wishes. [1:16:40] So moved. [1:16:42] Don Hall. [1:16:44] So moved. [1:16:44] So moved. [1:16:45] Second. [1:16:46] Motion by Don Hall. [1:16:48] Seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to adjourn into executive session as stated. [1:16:53] Any discussion? [1:16:55] Seeing none, Chair and roll call vote please. [1:17:01] Chris Tockington. [1:17:02] Yes. [1:17:03] Don Hall. [1:17:03] Yes. [1:17:04] Ruth Pierce. [1:17:05] Yes. [1:17:05] Is Ann Hawkins? [1:17:06] Yes. [1:17:07] Nicky Boyd? [1:17:08] Yes. [1:17:09] Sean Beriker? [1:17:10] Yes. [1:17:11] Motion passes 6-0. [1:17:12] Just to let everyone know, we will not be making any decisions while we are in executive [1:17:18] session nor will we be reconvening following the executive session. [1:17:23] With that, we are adjourned.