Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2016-01-19, recording 1 (started 17:00) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2016-01-19/ [0:00:00] Get your my group [0:00:03] I'd like to call the order the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council for Monday January 11th [0:00:10] To start off. I don't see any boy scouts or girl scouts, but if you would please if you choose join us for the Pledge of Allegiance [0:00:34] I would confirm that we do have a quorum of the City Council. [0:00:45] All seven members are here this evening. [0:00:49] Mr. Rothweiler, do we have any amendments to the agenda this evening? [0:00:52] Mr. Mayor, members of the council, there are no amendments this evening. [0:00:55] All right, thank you. [0:00:57] Next on the agenda is proclamations and the council will see that there are no proclamations. [0:01:01] However, I'm including a proclamation type item. [0:01:06] have a plaque to present to Don Hall recognition of his service as mayor of the [0:01:13] City of Twin Falls from January 2014 to December 2015 awarded to him and includes [0:01:20] the Athenian Oath and this is something that we give this plaque to people for [0:01:24] their service in various areas of the city and we give them this oath at the [0:01:29] end of their service but I'd like to read this oath tonight as a reminder to [0:01:33] all of us of why we serve in public service. [0:01:37] The font is terribly small, so I'm gonna do my best here. [0:01:42] The Athenian oath. [0:01:45] We will never bring disgrace to this our city [0:01:48] by any act of dishonesty or cowardice [0:01:51] or ever desert our suffering comrades in the ranks. [0:01:54] We will fight for the ideals and sacred things of the city, [0:01:57] both alone and with many. [0:01:59] We will revere and obey this city's laws [0:02:02] and do our best to incite to a like respect and reverence [0:02:06] those who are prone to annul or set them at naught. [0:02:10] We will strive unceasingly to quicken the public sense [0:02:13] of public duty, that this in all these ways, [0:02:17] we will transmit this city not only not less, [0:02:21] but greater, better, and more beautiful [0:02:24] than it was transmitted to us. [0:02:26] So, Mr. Hall, in recognition of your service. [0:02:28] I would also like to recognize our youth council for handing out the agendas this evening, but [0:03:02] they did their duty and then took on. [0:03:05] Is there anyone from the general public [0:03:07] that would like to give any input this evening [0:03:09] on an item that is not on the agenda? [0:03:12] Seeing no one clamoring for the podium there, [0:03:16] we'll move to our agenda, the first item, [0:03:18] the consent calendar. [0:03:23] Great landing. [0:03:23] I move approval as printed. [0:03:26] Check it. [0:03:27] We have a motion by Greg Lanting, [0:03:29] seconded by Chris Tockington to approve [0:03:31] the consent calendar as printed. [0:03:33] Any discussion? [0:03:38] Chair and roll call vote please. [0:03:40] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:03:41] Yes. [0:03:42] Nikki Boyd. [0:03:43] Yes. [0:03:44] Sean Bericher. [0:03:45] Yes. [0:03:45] Chris Hockington. [0:03:46] Yes. [0:03:47] Greg Lanting. [0:03:48] Yes. [0:03:49] Don Hall. [0:03:49] Yes. [0:03:50] Ruth Pierce. [0:03:51] Yes. [0:03:52] Motion passes 7 to 0. [0:03:55] Under items for consideration. [0:03:57] The first item is a consideration of a request [0:04:00] to confirm the appointments of James Ray, Jay Reese, [0:04:03] and Scott Stanley to the Building Advisory Committee. [0:04:07] And while this has my name on it, [0:04:10] I will ask Jared if you would like to come up [0:04:12] and do you want me to just read this? [0:04:14] You can come up and help him. [0:04:16] Okay. [0:04:19] Well, it's appointment by the mayor, [0:04:21] so I'm the mayor right now. [0:04:23] Okay. [0:04:25] Well, Sean's actually the ex-officio member liaison [0:04:30] to the board, so he's got some familiarity with it, [0:04:32] but it's a nine member board, [0:04:35] and down. We bring stuff to them like fee structures. They also serve as an appeal board. So if there's [0:04:42] ever an appeal to the building official decision, they can go to this board for that too. So, [0:04:47] and these three guys have sat on it and they've had good attendance, really good participation, [0:04:52] good members of the community and done a really good job. [0:04:56] So as you mentioned, so this commission requires members to be under certain categories for their [0:05:02] involvement in the building industry as well as at large. And James Ray, Jay [0:05:08] Reese and Scott Stanley, Mr. Ray served as the residential construction member, Mr. Reese as the [0:05:13] plumbing contractor and Mr. Stanley as the at-large member. Yeah. Chris, were there other names, applicants [0:05:21] for this? Three small positions. No, we all supplied these guys were sitting on the board and they reapplied [0:05:27] and showed interest to serve again, but we had no other applications. No, no. Okay, thank you. [0:05:30] Thank you. [0:05:34] Great. [0:05:35] Lanting. [0:05:36] I would move that we reconfirm the appointments of James Ray J. Reese and Scott Sandler, the [0:05:40] Building Advisory Committee, and I'm assuming for a three-year term. [0:05:44] Second. [0:05:45] Of a motion by Greg Lanting. [0:05:48] Seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to reappoint these gentlemen as presented. [0:05:52] Any further discussion? [0:05:56] Chair-in-roll call vote, please. [0:05:58] Nikki Boyd. [0:05:59] Yes. [0:06:00] Sean Berger. [0:06:01] Yes. [0:06:02] Chris Talkington. [0:06:03] Yes. [0:06:04] Don Hall, Ruth Pierce, Suzanne Hopkins. [0:06:08] Yes. Motion passes 7-0. Thank you for your help, Jared. [0:06:14] The next item on the agenda is consideration of a request to adopt an ordinance authorizing the transfer of 1.32 plus or minus acres of city-owned property [0:06:23] located at the southeast corner of Victory Avenue and Oak Street to the Urban Renewal Agency. [0:06:28] We have Deputy City Manager Mitchell Humpel. [0:06:31] Thanks. [0:06:32] On December 21st, there was a public hearing about this item, that's what I've told, because [0:06:38] I wasn't actually there, even though I got it all ready to go, and then I took off. [0:06:43] Anyway, my understanding from that meeting is that the public hearing was held in the direction [0:06:48] from the Council to prepare the ordinance to make the transfer. [0:06:51] So that's what we have for tonight, it's prepared in accordance with that direction. [0:06:56] If this will transfer the property from the city to the agency, urban renewal agency, [0:07:01] as discussed in the public hearing. [0:07:04] If you'd like to adopt this ordinance tonight, [0:07:06] we need to put it on the third and final labor [0:07:08] of the rules and all that good stuff. [0:07:11] And if we wanna go through the readings, [0:07:12] we can do that too. [0:07:14] So it's there, it's ready to be adopted tonight, [0:07:16] if you choose to do so. [0:07:18] And we can answer your questions if you have any. [0:07:20] And Sharon, what is the ordinance number? [0:07:24] 31-11. [0:07:26] 31-11, thank you. [0:07:28] Chris talking. [0:07:29] And Mitch, if you could just read, [0:07:31] point us all again, and since the discussion came up and the action the Council has taken [0:07:36] or in between that time and now with this ordinance has the beneficiary at all expressed [0:07:41] any pro-con discussion or their thoughts to you that we should be aware of. [0:07:48] Even he said, beneficiary, do you mean the renewal agency or the ultimate goal of getting [0:07:53] this into the hands of Con-Agra, I guess? [0:07:59] We've, we, so no, there's nothing that would have changed the direction we're going on. [0:08:03] We're still going down that path of both of those entities. [0:08:07] And this ordinance, I will authorize the transfer, the actual transfer will come when the mayor comes inside some deeds and stuff like that. [0:08:14] So, but no, there's no change in plans that nothing has happened that would affect this to the contrary. [0:08:20] Any other questions from the council? [0:08:27] Great. [0:08:27] Thank you. [0:08:27] I'm Mayor Baker. [0:08:29] I would move that we suspend the rules of place ordinance [0:08:32] 3111 on third and final by title only. [0:08:36] Second. [0:08:38] We have a motion by Greg Lanting, seconded by Ruth Pierce, [0:08:43] two place ordinance. [0:08:44] To suspend the rules and place ordinance 3111 on third and final [0:08:48] reading by title only. [0:08:50] Any discussion with that motion? [0:08:54] Seeing that, Sharon Roll call vote please. [0:08:56] Sean Baraker. [0:08:57] Yes. [0:08:58] Chris Tockington. [0:08:59] Yes. [0:09:00] Greg Lanting. [0:09:01] Yes. [0:09:01] Don Hall. [0:09:02] Yes. [0:09:02] Ruth Pierce. [0:09:03] Yes. [0:09:04] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:09:05] Yes. [0:09:06] Nikki Boyd. [0:09:06] Yes. [0:09:08] Motion passes 7-0. [0:09:10] Sharon, if you could read the title please. [0:09:13] Ordinance number 31-11. [0:09:15] An ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, [0:09:19] Idaho authorizing the transfer or conveyance [0:09:23] of real property owned by the city to a tax-supported governmental unit, as provided by Idaho Code 50-1403-4. [0:09:36] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:09:40] I would like to move that we adopt Ordinance 31-11. [0:09:45] Second. [0:09:46] Motion by Suzanne Hawkins, seconded by Don Tall to approve Ordinance 31-11. [0:09:56] Discussion on the motion? [0:09:59] Sharon roll call vote, please [0:10:02] Chris Tockington. Yes, Greg Lanting. Yes, Don Hall. Yes, Ruth Pierce. Yes, Suzanne Hawkins. Yes, Nikki Boyd. Yes, Sean Barriker. Yes [0:10:15] Motion passes 7 to 0 [0:10:17] The next item on the agenda [0:10:20] Discussion on the city's economic development director and the Twin Falls urban renewal executive director role and position [0:10:27] I'm our city manager, Travis Rothweiler. [0:10:30] Good evening, Mr. Mayor, members of the council. [0:10:34] Tonight is really our opportunity to talk about what economic development and the phase [0:10:38] of economic development looks like inside the city of Twin Falls over the course of the [0:10:43] next few years. [0:10:47] Maybe to kind of go back a little bit and kind of share how this conversation came to be [0:10:54] and why it's before us this evening, to kind of set the table and then I'll also be in [0:10:59] a position to share some of the thoughts that were shared by the members of the Urban Renewal [0:11:06] Agency today as they look at that piece of the executive director function of this role. [0:11:14] So one of the things that Melinda and I started having a conversation with or about, say, [0:11:20] summer of last year was the opportunity to do some succession planning. Some planning [0:11:27] that allowed us to line up resources with the budget to determine exactly what we felt that [0:11:32] we needed to do to ensure that the prosperous community section of our strategic plan, those [0:11:37] objectives were being realized and met. And we started to engage in that conversation [0:11:44] and plan to do it this year so that we had a recommendation that we could include in the [0:11:50] long-term plan. And then in that long-term planning [0:11:53] document, it could then become part of a budgetary [0:11:56] resource project or process and to be able to advance that [0:11:59] moving forward. Belinda took an opportunity into [0:12:04] Wallatin. And that really has kind of accelerated this [0:12:08] conversation. But I also believe it's an important [0:12:11] conversation for us to have. And it's really a good [0:12:15] opportunity for us to evaluate how the city has [0:12:18] performed in the areas of economic development and the things that we think that we need to [0:12:23] do, preserve, continue to move forward as we look and begin a search for the position [0:12:30] to fill. And there are a series of questions that I think that we need to answer and part [0:12:36] of those questions really begins to be what are the essential tenants and duties of this [0:12:43] as we move forward so that we can be successful in completing our [0:12:48] prosperous community strategic planning objectives. [0:12:54] By contract, the City of Twin Falls has the responsible charge of supplying an economic [0:13:00] development director to the agency. [0:13:04] The Urban Renewal Agency provides financial cash for the city on an annual basis [0:13:11] services for a myriad of services. Part of that is to assist with the executive director [0:13:16] salary. Part of it is to assist with time that I would normally spend on the role or in the [0:13:24] roles as city manager assisting the urban renewal agency execute their roles as well as other [0:13:30] members of the team including finance, legal, and they pay and engineering and they pay a [0:13:37] lump fee on an annual basis. [0:13:43] And so the city has the responsible charge to ensure that we are staffing those appropriately. [0:13:50] Moving forward, I think it's important to ask the question, how do we staff that moving [0:13:55] forward? [0:13:57] And so one of the things that I thought that worked really, really well in Mr. Merritt, ask [0:14:06] maybe a similar process occur today, is that the agency just took an opportunity to kind [0:14:12] of share their perspectives in the beginning of that conversation, which then allowed us [0:14:19] to kind of build and move forward and go forward with the process. [0:14:24] I could, and I thought about this a couple of different ways. [0:14:27] One of the things I thought that I could do is I could stand up here and share exactly [0:14:30] what I felt that I wanted to do. [0:14:34] But I felt that that might be a bit short-sighted for me just to stand and present that direction. [0:14:42] Because I recognize that the Council has become increasingly involved in the area of economic [0:14:47] development over the course of the last few years. [0:14:50] And this Council has been very passionate about the role of economic development. [0:14:54] And I think that those thoughts and characteristics that you would like to share are very, very [0:15:01] valuable to this process just as they were from the urban renewal board members today. [0:15:06] And I also plan on having the same conversation with the members of the ready team. [0:15:11] Because as partners, they need to also kind of be engaged. [0:15:15] I want to take all of that information and then make a complete recommendation to you [0:15:21] probably in the next 30 days and make sure that everybody is on board and that we'll [0:15:29] will begin those searches or search depending upon what that outcome looks like. [0:15:34] Well, with that would anyone like to chime in with some thoughts on Travis's question? [0:15:41] Well, are you going to make a presentation of sales job to the council or just want our [0:15:46] input then what's your thought on that? [0:15:49] I would like your input and then maybe we can do it as a response and I can. [0:15:54] Well, I'm the liaison for the urban renewal, [0:15:58] at least the city hall part of it, [0:16:01] I mean, Greg's overall liaison for urban renewal, [0:16:04] but I was at the meeting today. [0:16:06] It was interesting, the urban renewal's perspective, [0:16:10] I won't lay out how they went so far as keeping the position [0:16:17] the way it is or expanding, [0:16:19] but I'd like to give my perspective, [0:16:22] since I think I've been through some of the growth [0:16:24] and up and down cycles at Twin Falls. [0:16:27] I think right now we are in a risk position [0:16:31] of straight line projection. [0:16:34] We are in a vertical of a growth curve [0:16:37] as the city has ever been. [0:16:39] And I think some people, perhaps on the urban renewal, [0:16:43] think that's going to continue. [0:16:45] But I like to put in a perspective [0:16:47] that several of our last major new employers [0:16:52] or the expanding employers who are here because of the abundance of cheap pure water, cheap [0:17:00] power, cheap labor, and a hell of a lot of dairy cows. [0:17:06] Right now most of that free, cheap, pure water is spoken for. [0:17:12] We have a labor shortage, we're below full employment, and we know that there are not [0:17:17] many unknown dairy cows within 100 miles or a couple hundred. [0:17:25] So if we're going to have growth, I think it's going to come from different sources than mega [0:17:29] businesses coming in for the foreseeable future. [0:17:32] Now, I'd be wrong on that, but I also went through the Dell computer bursting bubble, [0:17:41] if you will. [0:17:42] We had a lot of expectations that ended up with a lot of disappointed people. [0:17:49] I really think that our future, near to term future, is going to make the growth that we [0:17:55] have right now come to fruition, get the the hirings up and raise the wage scale above the [0:18:06] bottom of the nation where we stand now. [0:18:09] And I think most of our new growth is going to come from helping existing businesses as [0:18:16] well as businesses that are going to come here only and if we have land available to move in [0:18:22] and start building on. [0:18:24] We have a shortage of that category right now. [0:18:28] As such, I see this urban renewal and economic development position as not the same animal [0:18:36] as when Melinda left, but one that's going to have a little bit of a changing role through [0:18:43] time as some of the projects come online that we're familiar with under urban renewal. [0:18:50] I personally favor that we keep the urban renewal position and the economic development is kind [0:19:01] of one position, but with more help in that, you are a position. [0:19:06] I think there's no doubt that Melinda was overwhelmed. [0:19:10] I'm not sure what the kind of expertise it might take, but for us to create two separate [0:19:17] positions, I would not be able to support, at least of all, to have an economic development [0:19:22] directory that thinks their job might be to go to conventions. [0:19:25] That was not the way I think we're going to move ahead. [0:19:29] So I guess I'm coming back full circle on this saying [0:19:33] that I would like to keep the position [0:19:35] as Melinda left up with more help within her office. [0:19:40] Thank you. [0:19:41] Thank you. [0:19:42] Don Hall. [0:19:43] You know, I've been on city council not as long [0:19:46] as Chris has his tenure, but for the last 10 years, [0:19:49] but I also was involved with the city for many years [0:19:51] before that as an employee and on different committees [0:19:55] and the like. [0:19:56] And Chris is right, the last few years [0:19:58] We've seen tremendous growth in our economic outlook the last six years, especially with [0:20:09] some real successes. [0:20:14] I look at economic development and the URA, those positions, I'm going to take a different [0:20:19] stance than Chris is. [0:20:20] I think they need to be absolutely two separate positions. [0:20:24] The URA, it's very difficult to serve two masters. [0:20:29] And we have to remember that the Urban Renewal Agency is a separate organization in the city. [0:20:34] And I think we blur the lines when we have the same person as the director of the URA that's [0:20:41] also our economic development director. [0:20:44] I do agree with Chris on the stance that I think that we have some real opportunities [0:20:49] in the future to help existing businesses. [0:20:53] And I see our economic development director heavily involved in that. [0:20:58] I know that we've had a block of resources, human resources, at times when we've worked [0:21:03] with different businesses or retention and those kind of things. [0:21:07] And I think honestly that having that separated, that would be very, very beneficial so that [0:21:13] they could allocate their times correctly for those endeavors. [0:21:20] I've said this before. [0:21:21] I think one of the best things that you can be involved in as a human being on this earth [0:21:25] is to try to help with economic development, [0:21:28] because it is absolutely to the core of people's ability [0:21:34] to have a quality life and a quality place to work and live. [0:21:40] And so I think our city is at the point now [0:21:45] that we need to separate and have two different entities. [0:21:51] Thank you. [0:21:51] Greg Lanting. [0:21:54] Well, one of his first proposed that we might split it up. [0:21:58] I was very hesitant, to be honest with you. [0:22:00] I was, my biggest fear on separating them is that we'll end [0:22:07] up with situations like Boise or some of the other ones where [0:22:10] they kind of seem to have a competing role. [0:22:13] And they're not cooperating as well as ours. [0:22:17] If there were the city and the economic development or the urban renewal agency [0:22:23] agency have cooperated so well. [0:22:26] And so that's why when somebody mentioned it today [0:22:28] at the meeting, one of the directors [0:22:30] about the possibility of one position that shared with both, [0:22:34] but then maybe have a deputy so that that person [0:22:38] could delegate more and then be a little more help. [0:22:42] And I don't know that that's a whole lot different [0:22:44] than having two separate people, but at least I still [0:22:48] have that concern about whether or not [0:22:50] we can make sure that we're cooperating with them. [0:22:52] And maybe I'm wrong on how the city of Boise, [0:22:56] and maybe it is working together better than I realize it is, [0:22:59] but they really do feel like a completely separate organization. [0:23:03] It's over here doing their thing, [0:23:04] and the city's over here doing their things, [0:23:06] and sometimes they come together. [0:23:08] We've always been one organization working together, [0:23:11] and I would hate to lose that. [0:23:13] I think that's what helps us to be the poster child, [0:23:18] probably not a very good word, [0:23:19] but the example that the legislators like to throw out [0:23:23] of how to use an urban renewal agency, [0:23:26] because we haven't tried to paint outside the lines [0:23:30] like some of the others have. [0:23:31] But I think that comes from our cooperation together [0:23:35] and the fact that the city council has a little more [0:23:38] direct influence upon the urban renewal than they do in, [0:23:41] say, I'll get to use the example of Boise [0:23:44] where the capital city, which was kind of interesting. [0:23:48] I remember the interim committee, they were wanting [0:23:50] to make sure that all of them had their urban renewal [0:23:52] their name. I thought that was a little, I don't want to get that one out, but I know [0:23:56] what that is, but maybe not our mail stubs. But that's my feelings. I could [0:23:59] probably live with either way, but just I want to make sure we stay cooperative if [0:24:04] we're, and how are we doing this? Thank you. Suzanne Hawkins. Thank you. So I guess [0:24:11] from my perspective, it's hard to know how many hours a week Melinda was [0:24:17] splitting towards each position, which makes it harder to make a decision. So I [0:24:21] I can help with that, so that's a great point. [0:24:26] I will tell you that if Melinda were here right now, [0:24:28] she would tell you that she spent well over probably 80 [0:24:33] ish percent of her time serving as the city's economic [0:24:38] development director in overseeing some of those projects [0:24:42] and shepherding those projects. [0:24:44] The balance of her time would probably [0:24:46] be the other roles and responsibilities [0:24:48] that she would have as a member of the city's departmental [0:24:51] leadership teams, and so on and so forth. [0:24:56] One of the things that probably that we did not do in the [0:25:00] areas of economic development, that you typically think of [0:25:03] in the areas of economic development well, is we don't [0:25:08] do any marketing of our own community. [0:25:10] And we don't do any direct attraction of companies to come [0:25:17] in. [0:25:17] We often wait. [0:25:19] We often wait to have those leads come into our organization whether it comes in through [0:25:24] the state or whether it comes in through the Southern Idaho Economic Development Organization, [0:25:28] which are two very, very good resources and partnerships. [0:25:31] But we don't go out and target companies that we believe will help further our strategic planning [0:25:38] objectives that would fit well within our community. [0:25:43] We don't and we didn't, Melinda was here, she would probably also share that we didn't [0:25:49] spend any time in the areas of business retention. [0:25:54] We had some levels of conversation but one of the biggest Achilles heel that we have in [0:25:59] the area of economic development is retention. [0:26:03] Retention is a big term for preserving relationships and we probably do not do that really well [0:26:13] with all of our business partners. [0:26:16] And that's a pretty important piece of economic development [0:26:19] because most of the statistics will tell you [0:26:22] that 70% of your new job growth comes [0:26:25] from existing businesses within your community expanding. [0:26:29] And if we are not working with them on grants [0:26:32] and resources and opportunities [0:26:34] and building those connections, [0:26:36] then they may not take and expand [0:26:38] and create those opportunities in our community. [0:26:41] But most importantly, if they're struggling, [0:26:45] we don't know that either. [0:26:47] And the last thing, in fact, I can remember [0:26:51] there were conversations with Dell as a really good example. [0:26:55] Dell had made a series of decisions [0:26:57] and had a series of conversations. [0:26:59] And we were the first time, I believe, [0:27:02] that the 11th hour able to come in [0:27:04] and salvage that relationship with Dell. [0:27:07] The second time, they had made the business decision [0:27:11] to pull out of our market. [0:27:15] But we were caught by surprise. [0:27:18] We were caught by surprise because those communication [0:27:21] channels weren't necessarily at a spot where they may have [0:27:25] been able to share a little bit more. [0:27:28] And we had great relationships with them. [0:27:31] In the past, we've tried to do business retention [0:27:33] through a series of outside groups and through a series [0:27:37] of partnerships. [0:27:38] And it was grant-based, and it was funded. [0:27:40] And the problem with that is when the grants went away, [0:27:43] the program went away. [0:27:45] And no one took responsibility for the project. [0:27:48] And so I really believe that if you're going to have [0:27:51] a true business retention program, it needs to be led [0:27:54] by the city, and it needs to be city focused and city based. [0:27:57] So that was something that we probably weren't doing [0:28:00] as well as we could have. [0:28:02] And it really, because it was hit on. [0:28:05] A lot of those times were spent on typical [0:28:09] urban renewal type works, and so we would go out and we would have a conversation with [0:28:16] a company, and after the deal sheet is coming together and it's brokered and you signed [0:28:22] the agreement, there is this incredibly long effort that occurs on that back end, and it's [0:28:32] really a project management component where we are financially working with the companies [0:28:39] on tax increment financing, allocation of resources, selling of bonds, creating long-term debt, [0:28:46] overseeing a litany of companion engineering projects that are absolutely critically important [0:28:55] to meet deadlines and development agreements, but causes us to get sucked out of doing economic [0:29:02] development. [0:29:03] And this model is the model that we've always had, as far as I can see. [0:29:09] The city and the urban renewal agency director was one position prior to Melinda, and that [0:29:15] person was Dave McLenden, and they've served in that role for several years as well, and [0:29:22] he served in both capacities. [0:29:25] What is different is the city of Twin Falls has become much, the council and the community [0:29:31] had become much more aggressive in our economic development strategies than maybe what we [0:29:37] were in the past. [0:29:39] In the past, the Urban Renewal Agency was really the economic development engine and we as [0:29:45] a city weren't necessarily as engaged as we have been since the Chibony Project. [0:29:50] And we've become much more engaged and we continue to be engaged because I think that [0:29:55] there is real value if you do it right. [0:29:57] It's that job growth. [0:29:58] It's the creation. [0:29:59] And it's the place making that's all occurring as a part of that larger process. [0:30:08] But Melinda would probably also tell you that there are two very, very different skillsets [0:30:14] that are needed in recruitment, brand protection, and marketing, finance, project management, [0:30:27] deal making, bond selling. [0:30:31] And we've been lucky to have individuals who've been able to wear both hats from a competency standpoint, [0:30:41] but not from an availability of hours and a day to do both goals successfully. [0:30:47] So then do you have other input? [0:30:48] Yeah, I'm going to finish up with where I was going. [0:30:51] Back during the budget talks this last fall, I was pushing pretty hard to get a position [0:30:58] added to our economic development team for business retention and expansion, which didn't [0:31:03] materialize and maybe now in hindsight it's a good thing since we're having a chance to [0:31:08] address those issues. [0:31:10] I think that personally with everything that we're facing with the downtown, redevelopment, [0:31:16] finishing up Chobani, bringing Cliff far online and everything we have going, I see splitting [0:31:22] the positions as a positive. [0:31:24] Not only that, but we've seen the last couple years how hard the URA's come under attack [0:31:28] from the state level, and we don't know what the future of the URA's going to look like. [0:31:33] The interim committee's meeting now to discuss possible changes to that, and so that could [0:31:39] affect that position, and I don't know that we want to tie one person into both of those [0:31:43] jobs if the URA is changed from the state level in what they're allowed and not allowed [0:31:49] to do. [0:31:50] So I can see a lot of benefit to splitting it and really hitting the business retention [0:31:56] harder, especially if that includes a person who's looking at a minor league baseball team [0:32:01] moving to town. [0:32:04] I want that job. [0:32:07] Any other input in the game or Bruce? [0:32:12] So I would just add perhaps to echo kind of the comments you were wrapping up with their [0:32:17] Travis, the ability of a single person [0:32:21] to drive an overarching economic development strategy [0:32:27] while at the same time managing whatever heap of tasks [0:32:31] and projects happen to land on that plate [0:32:34] can be challenging. [0:32:38] Does it mean two people? [0:32:39] I don't know. [0:32:41] But I think that it's a pendulum that swings. [0:32:45] It's when nobody's building or growing or expanding. [0:32:49] you have all kinds of time to market and promote and protect [0:32:53] the brand of the community. [0:32:55] But when two enormous companies are building and hiring [0:32:59] hundreds of people and you're building sewer lines and water [0:33:02] lines and roads and all those things, [0:33:05] you've sort of run out of time to deliver the big message [0:33:07] about what are we doing strategically [0:33:10] and you're kind of caught in weeds. [0:33:13] So again, I don't know that that necessarily means two [0:33:16] It means a different strategy for delegating projects. [0:33:21] It means carving out pieces of those things to other people [0:33:25] and city staff or some sort of a deputy position. [0:33:28] But I think that's where we run into the real challenges. [0:33:32] We feel like we have a very cohesive and aggressive [0:33:35] economic development strategy. [0:33:37] But at times we're just getting by because we're [0:33:40] juggling all the balls. [0:33:44] Thank you, Boyd [0:33:48] So when it comes to there's two things there's recruitment and retention and it in my experience [0:33:57] Most of most everybody thinks like recruitment is going out and finding them and getting them here [0:34:02] And then retention is something that happens later [0:34:06] And in reality retention starts the day after the recruitment took place [0:34:11] So if we're missing some little things in there, it sounds like perhaps a policy review or something that says, this is how we do it so that we don't miss, because the easiest thing to do is to get super busy with all the things that recruitment brought on, and then from what I hear, that there's a little weak link there. [0:34:39] And so maybe that's one reason why having it as two separate jobs is important because [0:34:45] the recruitment and the retention could be part of, it could be brought more together, [0:34:53] have better written policy on how we do it and have somebody's job to be to actually [0:34:59] monitor that rather than, oh, we need a little PR here and a little PR there. [0:35:07] Maybe way too simplistic. [0:35:08] Thank you Ruth Pearson. [0:35:12] So I just want to echo most of what's been said, I think because I've worked in the economic [0:35:18] development area with Melinda for several years and she was overwhelmed. [0:35:23] The business retention portion was not being taken care of and she just didn't have time. [0:35:30] I think also with what you said, I think the two positions require different skill sets [0:35:38] And there's, the marketing is really important [0:35:43] because we really haven't done that. [0:35:44] So I would concur with splitting the two positions. [0:35:51] Thank you, Don Hall. [0:35:52] Last thing I'm gonna say about this tonight. [0:35:54] I do share what Grace said about when you do separate, [0:35:57] there is that chance of drifting apart. [0:36:00] And I think that's gonna be incumbent upon us, [0:36:03] upon the URA to ensure that doesn't happen. [0:36:07] But I look at the example of what we've been able [0:36:09] achieve with CIDG. CIDG is an organization that encompasses the whole region and we've [0:36:17] been very successful with that and maintaining that relationship. And I see this no differently, [0:36:23] but it will take maintenance. [0:36:25] And one of the things that I think is really important in how that relationship is imperative [0:36:34] that were working collaboratively, is how I understand how solo cup, now dart came to [0:36:40] our community. So my understanding is that they had landed and selected a particular company [0:36:47] that was not Twin Falls. And there was a urban renewal like entity that was working with [0:36:54] them. And they had made a series of commitments. And when the city was approached to honor [0:37:03] the commitments that this other entity had made, they said, no, we can't do that. And [0:37:13] so they reactivated their search, and to our benefit, they chose to win false. So if there's [0:37:21] a lesson that we can learn from another entity of the importance of working collaboratively [0:37:28] with partners, we could look at the example that we actually benefited from another community [0:37:33] not working together. I think it's important that we do everything that we can to ensure [0:37:41] that all of the parties are working collaboratively and that they have the ability to do so absent [0:37:49] of personalities. And so I don't know if that means a structural look, but I really believe [0:37:56] that what is important is that we have the ability to continue to be successful like we've [0:38:04] been in the past, and that has been more of a put the ego at the door, and we all kind [0:38:10] of walk in for the betterment of our community, which is truly the reason when people ask us [0:38:16] what is our secret sauce, it's our ability to work together where other entities would [0:38:22] rather compete and fight over the very turf that they're trying to represent. [0:38:28] are you aware of the cities in the state that have a URA projects, how many of those have [0:38:39] separate economic development directors? [0:38:42] I mean, it's a small fiber none of them. [0:38:46] It's a mixed bag. [0:38:48] There are models like ours. [0:38:51] There are models that have a separate entity and a separate director that go to that same [0:38:57] level of extreme that Boise does. There are others that are there. There are also others [0:39:02] in which they carry a similar relationship like we have. And I don't think that one is [0:39:09] more, the model hasn't created any more success or less success. I think it's the partnerships [0:39:15] and the relationships that have created this success. [0:39:18] Good point. Any further input for Travis on this topic? [0:39:27] So next steps, just so you're aware, we have our first economic development ready team of [0:39:31] the year on the first, Monday and February. [0:39:37] I intend to ask them, and that's really kind of my last question. [0:39:40] And so the second meeting in February, I intend to come back to the Council and with a full [0:39:46] on presentation of what the role, the duties, the responsibilities, the structure, what that [0:39:55] looks like and then engage in a conversation of how we would go about filling those roles [0:40:00] and if there are any differences in funding how we would fund those roles. [0:40:05] We are working on right now and I will say we are covering the basis but we are doing [0:40:10] a multiple team member approach to do so. [0:40:15] I can understand how Melinda became overwhelmed because of the number of projects that I am [0:40:21] Assisting with right now whether it be the downtown project [0:40:26] Going through the cliff bar financing piece and responding to other types of leads [0:40:31] It's it is definitely more than a one-person role [0:40:36] I [0:40:37] But I want to really continue to get that input to really define what that structure looks like [0:40:43] So I really the input from the council has been very valuable. I really appreciate that and [0:40:47] And I look forward to incorporating that. [0:40:51] The other thing, because we are tele-advising, [0:40:54] and if there is anyone listening, [0:40:55] and if there's someone that has other thoughts [0:40:58] and comments that they would like to share directly, [0:41:01] I would encourage them to email the members of the council, [0:41:03] and also encourage them to get a hold of staff directly [0:41:06] if they have any significant words of wisdom [0:41:08] in the areas of economic development [0:41:10] that they'd like to share. [0:41:12] All right, thank you Mr. Rothweiler. [0:41:16] The next item in the agenda is public input or items from the city manager and city council. [0:41:25] What are these going? [0:41:26] I just realized I've never paid attention. [0:41:29] What are we going to do? [0:41:30] You're in charge. [0:41:32] I was asked for public input on the city manager and then the public input first if there's anyone from the public that has any item they'd like to bring up that was not on the agenda. [0:41:42] That was a easy one. [0:41:44] City manager. [0:41:46] Mr. Mayor, members of council, just a quick note that we will be closed on Monday in observation [0:41:51] of Martin Luther King, Idaho Human Rights Day, next Monday. [0:41:59] As a result, our normal meeting will be shifted to Tuesday and it will be at 5 o'clock p.m. [0:42:03] Thank you, Travis. [0:42:08] Don Hall. [0:42:09] Just want to say, I recognize that you're still trying to make our new chief of police [0:42:13] feel welcome by keeping your hair shaved off. [0:42:17] I think that's an incredible leadership trade of yours. [0:42:22] Mr. Mayor, may I respond? [0:42:24] Which would you like to? [0:42:29] You may. [0:42:30] So I tried to grow it out, and I looked like a chia pet. [0:42:33] So this is a look that you're going to be seeing for a while. [0:42:37] So you take some time off and go away. [0:42:43] The other announcements from members of the council. [0:42:48] All right. [0:42:48] Well, with that, there are no further items on the agenda. [0:42:51] So the meeting is adjourned.