Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2015-02-17, recording 1 (started 17:00) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2015-02-17/ [0:09:19] I'd like to call the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council to order. It's February 17, 2015 those of you wishing to join us [0:09:25] Please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance [0:09:45] Welcome everyone to our meeting we have several items on the agenda tonight [0:09:50] but I think we'll be able to work right through them. [0:09:52] First item is to make sure that we confirm [0:09:55] that we do have a quorum of the City Council. [0:09:57] All seven members are here this evening, [0:09:59] and now I'll turn it over to our City Manager [0:10:01] for if there are any amendments to the agenda this evening. [0:10:06] Mr. Mayor and members of the Council, [0:10:07] there are no amendments to tonight's agenda. [0:10:09] Thank you. [0:10:10] We have no proclamations. [0:10:11] Next item in order is public input. [0:10:15] If there's anyone here that would like to address the Council [0:10:18] on an issue that's not on the agenda already. [0:10:21] If you would like to come forward now, [0:10:23] this is your time to do so. [0:10:24] So we'll give you just a minute [0:10:25] if there's anyone in the audience. [0:10:30] No one's rushing for the podium again this evening, [0:10:33] so we'll then turn it over to Council [0:10:35] for their consideration of the consent calendar. [0:10:41] Greg Lanning. [0:10:41] You have approval of the consent calendar as published. [0:10:46] Second. [0:10:48] We have a motion on the floor by Greg Lanning, [0:10:49] seconded by Chris Cawkington to approve the consent calendar. [0:10:53] the consent calendar as published. [0:10:56] Anything further on that motion council? [0:10:59] We are the roll call vote please. [0:11:01] Suzanne Hawkins, yes. [0:11:02] Jim Munn, yes. [0:11:03] Sean Berriger, yes. [0:11:05] Chris Tawkins, yes. [0:11:06] Greg Lantee, yes. [0:11:07] Don Hall, yes. [0:11:08] Rebecca Milsoic, yes. [0:11:10] Motion passes seven to zero. [0:11:11] We'll move now to items for consideration. [0:11:14] The first item under this is presentation announced [0:11:18] in the Twin Falls Police Department [0:11:19] has met the accreditation standards [0:11:21] of the Idaho Chiefs of Police Association. [0:11:25] And our presenters first in order will be our chief, [0:11:29] Brian Prayer, followed by retired chief, [0:11:31] Dave Moore from the Blackfoot Police Department. [0:11:34] Chief, welcome. [0:11:38] Thank you, Mayor and Council. [0:11:40] So this evening, we've asked first of time [0:11:43] to recognize our entire organization [0:11:46] for really a tremendous amount of work [0:11:49] that this journey started several years ago [0:11:52] on the Chief Brian Pike, and Brian wanted our organization [0:12:01] to go through the accreditation process [0:12:03] to the Idaho Chief of Police Association. [0:12:06] And, you know, first look of an accreditation process, [0:12:15] I can tell you I wasn't sure how lengthy [0:12:17] or time consuming this was going to be. [0:12:19] And this process under the Idaho Chief [0:12:23] Police Association really formalizes what we have believed in for so long, that we do have [0:12:34] a professional organization, that we have outstanding people working not only in our organization [0:12:40] but for the city of Twin Falls. [0:12:43] And it really just reaffirms with all of us that we have everything in place that the [0:12:49] the chiefs of police in the state of Idaho recommend that every agency has in place for [0:12:54] your policies and your procedures so that you do maintain that professional standard. [0:12:59] Retired Chief Dave Moore, who is on the accreditation standards team for [0:13:05] the out of chiefs of police association, was the lead accreditor for this process. [0:13:13] And he brought with him Captain Frank Wyatt from Caldwell Police Department and [0:13:18] Lieutenant Scott Colliani from Meridian Police Department. [0:13:21] Now these three gentlemen travel throughout the state [0:13:24] and assess many, many agencies. [0:13:28] And I've asked Chief Moore to come here tonight [0:13:33] to talk a little bit about the accreditation process, [0:13:37] the purpose of the process, and then to formalize [0:13:41] the awarding of that to our organization, the CB. [0:13:45] Thank you, Chief. [0:13:48] last chief more to come forward and welcome you to sunny southern South [0:13:54] Central Idaho sir could be worse good snowed last I was here all right let me [0:14:02] I'm gonna go through a letter here first I prepared for the council and then I'll [0:14:06] give you a couple of words of input on the accreditation itself that was done [0:14:09] for the Twin Falls Police Department. [0:14:11] Audible Mayor council members and city manager it's my pleasure to inform you [0:14:16] The Twin Falls Police Department has successfully completed the [0:14:19] I don't Chief of Police Association accreditation process. [0:14:22] During onsite inspection by members of the I don't Chief [0:14:24] of Police Association accreditation team on January 21st and 22nd, [0:14:29] your police department was found to be in compliance with all [0:14:32] accreditation standards set forth by the I don't Chief of Police Association. [0:14:36] This milestone achievement was accomplished after hundreds of hours [0:14:39] of preparation by Twin Falls Police Department personnel. [0:14:42] Our special thanks go out to Chief Brian Creer and his staff [0:14:46] taking this opportunity and putting forth their efforts in meeting the [0:14:49] accreditation standards set forth by the chiefs of police association. This is an [0:14:53] accomplishment that you and the citizens of Twin Falls can be proud of as it [0:14:57] demonstrates your dedication to maintaining a progressive professional [0:15:02] police department for your community. Once again on behalf of the [0:15:05] police association we congratulate you and your city on this outstanding [0:15:10] achievement. Now Mayor, I don't even know why I do this and I'm retired. I retired [0:15:20] two years ago from the Blackfoot Police Department, I was Chief of Police there [0:15:23] for 16 years after 36 years of law enforcement and I've been doing the [0:15:28] accreditation for the Attachis Police Association since 1997 and as much as I'd [0:15:34] like to say that we have all the agencies that we want to have accredited in the [0:15:38] state, we don't. And that was a project that was taken on after I retired two years ago, [0:15:43] the Chiefs of Police Association came to me and asked me if I would stay on and continue [0:15:47] the accreditation program so that we can continue to move forward. We have accredited four agencies [0:15:53] in the last two years that put us above what we had originally for the United Chiefs of [0:15:57] Police Association. So I've had the opportunity to go out and work with the agencies just a [0:16:01] little bit more than we had before to help do that one-on-one training with them and to [0:16:05] get the standards of speed. [0:16:07] Now, Twin Falls put a lot of hard work into this. [0:16:09] They ran into one glitch. [0:16:11] Cheap Ryan Pike got a hold of me. [0:16:12] Two years ago, I asked if we could get this going, [0:16:15] but they changed policies. [0:16:17] And when they changed their policy manual, [0:16:20] that takes a lot of work just to get caught back up [0:16:23] from where they were before. [0:16:25] So it was a choice that Chief Pike made [0:16:27] to have the entire accreditation done again. [0:16:29] The accreditation for Twin Falls [0:16:30] had been done originally back in 19. [0:16:33] Jim, one might help me, I think it was 99, [0:16:36] somewhere in that area, 2000. [0:16:38] And that accreditation had the lapse [0:16:40] because the change over in the policy manual. [0:16:42] So we came back and did another accreditation [0:16:45] from the ground up. [0:16:46] And I have to tell you, between working with Chief Creer [0:16:50] and Captain Hicks and Captain Bernard and all your staff, [0:16:55] I can't tell you how impressed I am with your agency. [0:16:58] And I have to tell you, and I'm not getting paid for this. [0:17:03] I've done inspections and accreditations of all the agencies in state of Idaho that currently [0:17:08] have accreditation. [0:17:09] So I've had my opportunity to see all the policies, all the procedures statewide. [0:17:15] And I have to tell you that the City of Twin Falls Police Department was the easiest accreditation [0:17:22] that we have done. [0:17:23] Your agency was so prepared. [0:17:26] We have never left early from doing accreditation. [0:17:29] We have never left without findings and asking to have things corrected that we would come [0:17:33] back of a cat leaguer. So I'll tell you what, you want to be [0:17:37] proud of your police department. I am. So on that note, we would [0:17:43] like to present to them, Fund Falls Police Department, I [0:17:47] don't choose to place association, recognize the Fund Falls [0:17:51] Police Department as a fully accredited police agency, a [0:17:54] set forth by the Standards of its Association, January 2015. [0:17:58] We have technology issues. We generally do. We're ready to go. [0:18:25] It was a privilege, it was a real learning experience for us, for me to bring other members [0:18:41] of other agencies across the state to see how other agencies do their work. [0:18:44] You know, an accreditation doesn't mean that one agency is any better than another, it [0:18:48] just means that your one step above the professionalism has been set by the standards being set by [0:18:53] the Chief of Police Association. [0:18:54] Good job. [0:18:55] Well, thank you, Chief. [0:18:57] If you both wouldn't mind staying just for a minute, I know that we're going to have some [0:19:00] comments and questions. [0:19:01] Mr. Stocking. [0:19:02] Chief, thank you for your help in enabling our group to hear. [0:19:08] I know they never put much time in until they have to study for the test, but they somehow [0:19:13] squeak through. [0:19:14] I say that with tongue in cheek. [0:19:16] We're awfully proud of our police department. [0:19:18] I'd like your perspective, if you would, for a minute with the various departments around [0:19:22] the state. [0:19:24] In the last few years with the emergence of hate groups, cults, [0:19:29] lone-loath shootings, if this is affecting law enforcement [0:19:34] procedurally and operationally, and what we might tell [0:19:39] our citizenry that might be listening. [0:19:43] Councilman Talkington, one thing I wanted to avoid tonight [0:19:47] was all the negativity in law enforcement right now, [0:19:50] only because of what a positive milestone [0:19:52] this was for your police agency. [0:19:55] But I'll tell you, of all the years that I've been law enforcement, I have never seen what we're facing right now with law enforcement. [0:20:01] One of the biggest problems we have is I don't think we've given on enough credibility to how these police officers do their job, what they're facing, what it takes to get the job done. [0:20:11] And how easy it is to criticize when they make one mistake or two mistakes. [0:20:15] Our problems that we have right now are being run by a minority of people who are disgruntled with police agencies. [0:20:21] I just wish we could get more of the majority of people [0:20:24] that support the police agencies to come see what I saw [0:20:27] when I went through everything in your agency [0:20:30] from the ground up all the way from the hiring, [0:20:32] from the promotion to how everything is done in this agency [0:20:36] for professionalism. [0:20:37] I wish everybody could see that. [0:20:41] Chief Moore, I just wanted to say first of all, [0:20:43] thank you to you and your team for coming here. [0:20:45] Thank you for your continued professionalism. [0:20:48] Again, you're supposed to be retired, [0:20:49] but can't let it go, can ya? [0:20:52] But I think you just reaffirmed what we already knew, [0:20:56] that we have a professional team that really cares [0:20:59] about this community and is willing to take the time [0:21:04] to be as professionals they are. [0:21:06] From our predecessors, Chief Devore and Chief Mon, [0:21:12] Chief Pike, Chief Preer, they've all done an outstanding job [0:21:15] to bring us to this point. [0:21:16] So thank you very much. [0:21:17] Thank you, Mayor Hall, and I have to tell you, [0:21:18] but it's easy to look at a piece of paper [0:21:21] and have a piece of paper to tell you the trade and see looks good but we take the [0:21:24] next step for the we want to ride with your officers [0:21:27] and your officers don't know what we're going to ask them [0:21:30] and so we throw a series of questions on them to find out do they really know [0:21:34] what's in their policy manuals and what do they really think about the city of [0:21:37] Twin Falls [0:21:38] I have to tell you that when we get done we critique that all the assessor get [0:21:42] together [0:21:43] and I told the gentleman that I rode with [0:21:45] I said you know when I was chief of place for the city of blackfoot why wouldn't [0:21:47] give to have ten of you [0:21:49] I was so impressed with that individual I rode with, and I heard that from other sessions [0:21:53] I rode with, you know, I'm not just spillin' this, just to tell you, you have an excellent [0:21:58] police department here. [0:21:59] You really do. [0:22:01] With that I think we should give them one more hand. [0:22:04] Thank you Chief, thank you Chief, gentlemen, I'm assuming most of you will be leaving now, [0:22:15] so we'll give you just a moment, half our audience is gone, and at this time I see that [0:22:24] We have some boy scouts here. [0:22:27] Sir, could you bring them up forward to the podium? [0:22:29] I have a few questions I'd like to ask them. [0:22:36] Gentlemen, we will make this as painless as possible. [0:22:39] So one at a time, if you'd go to the podium, [0:22:41] I have three questions or a couple questions I want to ask you. [0:22:44] Could you tell me what troop you're, [0:22:46] well tell me your name first, [0:22:47] what troop you're with, [0:22:49] what you're working on today tonight, [0:22:51] what badge you're working on and where you meet. [0:22:55] My name is Aiden Humboldt and we're in troop 180, [0:22:59] Where we're working on a citizenship in the community near a bench. [0:23:02] Where do you meet, sir? [0:23:03] At the... [0:23:09] That one building. [0:23:11] North College. [0:23:14] North College. [0:23:17] Very good. [0:23:18] Thank you. [0:23:25] Same question. [0:23:26] Well, just your name. [0:23:27] And if you're working on something different. [0:23:30] My name is Daniel Ashby and it's pretty much everything. [0:23:37] The same. [0:23:39] Thank you. [0:23:40] Thank you, Daniel. [0:23:41] Yeah, the same thing. I'm James Doerth, and I'm working on the citizenship in the community, [0:23:47] Merit Badge, and I'm in troop 180. [0:23:50] Very good. Well, welcome to all three of you, and Mitch is one of these somewhat affiliated [0:23:55] with you. [0:23:57] Well, again, welcome, gentlemen, and if you have any questions tonight, please let us [0:24:06] know. [0:24:08] Next item on the agenda is consideration of a request [0:24:15] to confirm the reappointments of Steve Woods, Tom Frank's, [0:24:18] Kevin Gray to the Planning and Zoning Commission [0:24:21] to serve a three year term starting from this February [0:24:27] through February 2018. [0:24:29] So this is my report and basically in the nutshell council, [0:24:33] all three of these gentlemen have served [0:24:36] with distinction and with involvement. [0:24:41] We got nothing but praise from the folks [0:24:44] that they work with and their attendance [0:24:46] and their participation within the commission. [0:24:51] And so it comes to me to either put these positions back out [0:24:57] or to re-point these individuals and bring that [0:25:00] to your attention. [0:25:02] During this, my research of these three individuals, [0:25:07] I did get with our council liaison, Rebecca Milsoica, [0:25:12] and asked her her opinion, [0:25:14] and she confirmed the same thing that we knew, [0:25:16] that all three of you are positive members [0:25:19] of our planning and zoning. [0:25:21] And as we know, our planning and zoning commission [0:25:24] is the commission that really does a lot [0:25:26] of the heavy lifting for the council. [0:25:28] You put a lot of time and effort in, [0:25:30] and we really appreciate you. [0:25:31] So I believe that with Tom, Frank, and Kevin Gray [0:25:36] are both city representatives on P&Z. [0:25:40] So we're going to be reaffirming your or reappointing you. [0:25:44] And then of course Steve Woods is actually our area of impact. [0:25:48] So he has already gone in front of the county commission. [0:25:51] They've reappointed him and then we are confirming [0:25:54] that appointment. [0:25:55] So with that, I'll turn over to council for their comments [0:25:57] or questions or direction. [0:26:02] Rebecca Melsoika. [0:26:03] Thank you, Mayor. [0:26:05] I would say that I would concur with all of your comments. [0:26:09] In general, I like to post vacancies, but I think you just cannot deny the quality of [0:26:14] volunteers that we have these three. [0:26:17] The fact that they're all three here tonight, I want to thank them for showing up. [0:26:21] From left to right is Tom Frank, Kevin Gray, and Steve Woods, and they've all put an incredible [0:26:26] amount of time into their volunteer work. [0:26:30] They take it seriously, they're great representatives for the community, they're great listeners. [0:26:37] They also ask good questions and so I would certainly recommend their reappointment and [0:26:44] we may have some questions but just to put the motion on the floor I would move that we confirm the reappointments of Steve Woods, Tom Frank and Kevin Gray to the Planning and Zoning Commission for the three year term described by the mayor. [0:27:00] second. [0:27:01] Have motion on floor by Rebecca Milsorica, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins. [0:27:05] Anything on that motion council? [0:27:08] I would mind if you came up forward after we make the vote and just again introduce yourself [0:27:14] so that we can, sometimes we don't get a chance to see the face with the name and for [0:27:20] us to give another chance to say thank you to you. [0:27:22] So I see no lights on, could we have a roll call vote please? [0:27:28] Jim Mine? [0:27:29] Yes. [0:27:30] Sean Berriger? [0:27:31] Yes. [0:27:32] Greg Lansing. Yes, Don Hall. Yes, Rebecca Melsweicke. Yes, Suzanne Hawkins. Yes motion passes seven to zero [0:27:40] Gentlemen one at time just if you have a couple words really wanted to say thank you to you mayor and council on Tom Frank [0:27:47] Again, thank you for your support. You know, this is kind of a labor love for me [0:27:53] be involved with our community at this level and I'm very appreciative of what you folks have done to [0:28:00] to reappoint me and to our cubscot, I don't know if they're still here, I first kind of [0:28:05] got aware of social things like this when I was a cubscot. And I think this could be the [0:28:11] start of something good for some of these young men. They can keep going, stuff like that, [0:28:16] and grow that love for their community as they go through life. So I'm supportive of them. [0:28:21] But thank you very much for your support. [0:28:23] Thank you. Tom, appreciate it. Kevin? [0:28:28] Kevin Gray. I also thank you very much. I have enjoyed the three years that have served [0:28:33] and I'm looking forward to another three years with Troop P&Z. [0:28:37] What merit badge are you working on? [0:28:41] And just as Tom said, I think that more community involvement [0:28:45] and at a younger age is very important. I really hope that we see more of it. [0:28:49] We've had Boy Scouts visit our meetings and [0:28:54] a couple of times we've run them out before them, but at least they are showing up [0:28:58] taking in hopefully an interest. [0:29:01] So, thank you. [0:29:02] Thank you, Kevin. [0:29:03] Mr. Woods. [0:29:05] My name is Steve Woods. [0:29:09] I'm the area of impact representative trying to make ends meet between the city and the county [0:29:16] responsibilities and managing growth of our wonderful area. [0:29:20] And since we have the scouts here, I spent about an hour with about 20 scouts early late [0:29:29] last week at the Hankins LDS facility talking about managing growth as it pertained to the [0:29:40] new school area and the subdivision right around the school, they had a lot of questions and [0:29:47] they're going to make some great citizens. [0:29:49] Thank you. [0:29:50] I just again want to say thank you to all three of you for being willing to serve in these [0:29:54] positions because I know how much time it takes and how much involvement. [0:29:57] So thank you again. [0:29:58] Moving to the next agenda item. [0:30:01] Mr. Mayor. [0:30:02] Would it be possible to take a quick five minute technology break recess? [0:30:08] We either need to reboot our computer. [0:30:11] We certainly can. [0:30:12] So at this point we're going to go ahead and take about a five minute break. [0:30:16] Thank you. [0:30:17] I'd like to bring the council meeting back to order after a short technology break. [0:35:59] We will now be moving on to item number three under items for consideration. [0:36:03] and it is recognition of John Locke's appointment to the NFPA's Building Code Development Committee. [0:36:12] This committee consists of 13 members from around the United States. [0:36:16] So with that, we will turn it over to Mitch Humble first and let you take over Mitch. [0:36:22] So, Jared and I are going to tag team this a little bit. [0:36:25] I'll let Jerry come up and talk about the more technical aspects of it. [0:36:28] Um, first thing I want to say is I sit here like every night, every Monday night for weeks and weeks and weeks and months and months and I see the police departments stand up here and everybody claps for the police department. [0:36:40] They have a great police department. I clap right along with them. [0:36:45] We need to find some other people to clap for them. [0:36:48] It's the police department. So I've been looking around and we've been paying attention to stuff and we found this thing come across my desk recently. [0:36:56] And I said, Jared, we need to go to the council with this. [0:36:58] And he agreed, so we're here. [0:37:05] And John agreed to come, too. [0:37:06] So John, back here, too. [0:37:07] We want to talk about John a little bit tight. [0:37:11] So it's not that often that we get [0:37:14] to recognize the achievements of our building department. [0:37:18] Too often, maybe all we hear about them [0:37:20] is, how come I'm staying so long to be in my permit, [0:37:23] or how come I didn't pass my inspection? [0:37:25] And they do a lot of good work. [0:37:30] Let me tell you a little bit about John. [0:37:31] We hired John in April of 2012. [0:37:33] He's been working with us here, but as a building inspector, [0:37:35] I've planned with him ever since then. [0:37:38] He was born in St. Anthony. [0:37:39] I know he was raised in Ashton, graduated from Fremont High [0:37:42] School, went to University of Idaho, [0:37:45] and got a BS degree in wildlife resources. [0:37:48] And you can see he's putting that to work. [0:37:55] He's building communities a bit wild at times. [0:37:58] So yeah, after graduating, he married his wife, [0:38:01] led of the half-four kids living in Kimberly. [0:38:07] Now we're happy to have him. [0:38:10] He's been in the inspection field since 98. [0:38:13] How did a job as an inspector for Fremont County? [0:38:18] And I think he moved to the building official in that same [0:38:20] position. [0:38:21] We brought him here in 12. [0:38:23] And he's been working with us doing great things ever since then. [0:38:29] He has served as the secretary of treasure [0:38:33] in the president of the Snake River chapter of the ICC. [0:38:36] He was appointed by the governor to the Heating [0:38:38] and Ventilation Air Condition Board. [0:38:42] And all this is in the past that we forgot to bring him here [0:38:44] to talk about to you, because this is good stuff too. [0:38:48] So he's currently, I want to say, vice president of the Idaho [0:38:52] Association of Building Officials. [0:38:54] And so we've got a very accomplished guy that's [0:38:56] working with our department right now. [0:38:59] And the NFPA thing is, takes it to that next step. [0:39:03] And I'm gonna let Jared talk to you about what the NFPA is [0:39:06] and what this position really means for John, [0:39:09] for the city to have that kind of recognition [0:39:11] to have a guy, one of our guys out in that committee. [0:39:14] And then we'll bring John up here so we can hear from him too. [0:39:19] Very good, thank you, Mitch. [0:39:20] Welcome, Jared. [0:39:21] Good, Council. [0:39:24] So what does NFPA mean? [0:39:26] It's kind of an acronym you probably don't know anything about, [0:39:28] but I just got a little bit of notes here I wanted to read off to you and open up for [0:39:31] you any questions. So National Fire Protection Association is an international [0:39:36] nonprofit organization established in 1896. NFPA is the rules leading advocate of [0:39:42] fire prevention and an authoritative source on public safety. NFPA publishes [0:39:48] 300 codes of standards. Many of these are referenced in the I codes we have [0:39:51] adopted. Two of the major codes we've adopted that are without Idaho is NFPA 13 [0:39:57] which is the Fire Sprinkler Suppression System and NMPA 70, [0:40:01] which is our electrical code. [0:40:03] And it's going to be nice to have someone on the board [0:40:06] on the inside because these standards are really technical [0:40:08] standards and have someone on the board [0:40:11] that can help articulate some of the standards [0:40:13] and maybe have some insight and knowledge of how to worsen [0:40:16] the stuff can be extremely helpful. [0:40:19] Also with John's appointment, he was given free digital access [0:40:23] to all the codes, which is a $1,400 value for free. [0:40:26] Also, I thought that was pretty exciting. [0:40:29] And since John's gonna be on the floor, [0:40:31] I thought I'd come up here and you can put him on the spot [0:40:33] and get him used to that position. [0:40:35] So. [0:40:37] Well, John, come on forward, sir. [0:40:39] Welcome. [0:40:40] Good evening, Mayor and Councilman. [0:40:42] People. [0:40:43] Good evening, Councilman. [0:40:44] Good evening, Councilman. [0:40:45] You're an animal. [0:40:46] You know, I'm proud to be one. [0:40:50] Go Vandals. [0:40:52] Anything that you'd like to share with us regarding [0:40:55] this background and this honor, actually. [0:40:57] Well, I was notified just by email, [0:41:00] a guy who's the liaison to the Board's health contact [0:41:04] community in the half state. [0:41:05] We've seen what you've done. [0:41:07] We'd like to ask you to sit on this board. [0:41:09] And if I was able to, so I sent it up to Jared and said, [0:41:12] hey, this is a neat opportunity to be allowed to do this. [0:41:16] And we went through just what is all involved [0:41:20] and what it is is two times a year in the spring [0:41:24] in the fall, they meet face-to-face somewhere around the country. [0:41:27] I missed the last October one, which would have been in Boston, which would have been, [0:41:31] would need to see. [0:41:32] But I recently attended a webinar. [0:41:35] They kind of went over all the different how things go operate. [0:41:39] I have been able to attend numerous, well, two, code hearings, which I see puts on every year. [0:41:46] And it's very similar to what they do is they bring up any changes, people vote on it, [0:41:51] stuff that passes, gets put into codes, taken out of codes, and so I was familiar with kind [0:41:58] of how the operation goes along. And so it's not new to me in regards to how it plays out, [0:42:05] but I was able to sit through this webinar and they kind of went through how NPA does it, [0:42:11] and we are starting with the 2015 NPA 5000, which is basically kind of mimics the IBC in [0:42:19] in similarities and things, but is there, [0:42:21] the annotate codes will be reviewing, [0:42:23] and each one of us on the committee has to kind of be [0:42:27] assigned to different sections, which we go through, [0:42:29] we view, see if there's anything that needs to be changed, [0:42:31] or, you know, spelling, whatever it is, you know, [0:42:34] bringing things to attention to the board, [0:42:36] and then moving up for printing, so. [0:42:40] Quite the honor, really. [0:42:42] Very good, I know that we're gonna have some comments [0:42:44] from the council, and maybe questions, [0:42:47] but we cannot move on without, [0:42:51] because Mitch has already set you up for this, [0:42:53] without giving you a hand. [0:42:54] So thank you. [0:42:55] Thank you. [0:42:56] We might even do that twice to make Mitch feel better [0:43:03] about that, please. [0:43:04] Well, it's an honor. [0:43:05] Chris talking. [0:43:06] Congratulations, John. [0:43:09] Because you well know by now we're in an unprecedented growth [0:43:12] spurge in Twin Falls. [0:43:13] Don't know how long it'll last a few years probably. [0:43:16] But what kind of particular problems [0:43:19] with getting in and doing the checking verification and approval for the Chobanis and the Clif bars [0:43:26] and the Glamvias. How's one person even do that? [0:43:31] Well, it's not one person. It's an entire team. We have a great team that's assembled here at the city [0:43:36] and I'm really proud of being a part of that. But we work together, open team and meetings where we [0:43:43] discuss different items that we see have questions on, obviously contacting our protection engineers, [0:43:49] everybody else involved in it and we work together to do our best, you know, and yes, [0:43:53] things will be missed on the land, things will be missed in the field, but we try to [0:43:57] minimize those if possible. We love the challenge or the challenge of the big things. [0:44:02] What do you work off of laptops and notebooks for your codes and your [0:44:09] tech specs? Actually, I personally have been getting my some of my code books [0:44:15] electronically. Some of the other inspectors like to have them the hard [0:44:18] I'm a digital freak, so I enjoy that and having access to it because I can copy and paste and [0:44:24] email stuff to our protection engineers, project managers, eventually we will get to the digital [0:44:30] more of the plans. [0:44:31] I do have a couple of the projects I work on, personally I have got the digital plans sent [0:44:36] to myself which I keep on the iPad that I have, to where I can review them and look into [0:44:41] detail on the different things. [0:44:43] I mean that some of those projects are as large as they are carrying around a set of plans that's been approved [0:44:49] It's not the easiest thing to do so you can print off or keep digital small form and you're able to review before you step out on project [0:44:57] Thank you Sean Verger [0:44:59] So I have to say I would agree with Mitch. I think that the folks in the building department are [0:45:05] underappreciated and [0:45:06] Just kind of they're doing your job [0:45:08] But as we've been building the new visitor center [0:45:11] I've got a chance to see many, many, many of you, many, many, many times, but you all do [0:45:17] a great job. [0:45:18] You're super professional. [0:45:19] I've heard no complaints from the contractors and subs that we've been working with. [0:45:24] So John, congratulations to you. [0:45:25] This is quite an honor and I think demonstrates the commitment of not only your, you to the [0:45:32] city, but also the entire department. [0:45:34] So congratulations. [0:45:35] Thank you. [0:45:36] So is that Hawkins? [0:45:37] Thank you. [0:45:38] Congratulations, first of all, and excuse my lack of knowledge in everything that you guys [0:45:45] deal with, but a board member 13 across the United States is a very select group. [0:45:53] How did they find you? [0:45:54] How does that process work? [0:45:56] Well, I believe what it was, I was a part of the local chapter as a president of the [0:46:04] as a chapter of building officials here in the area. [0:46:10] I was a representative on what's called a region two. [0:46:13] Region two is an area of Idaho as a Idaho, [0:46:18] which they're supposed to be, not an H. [0:46:21] And what is, it's an association of all the building [0:46:24] officials who choose to be a part of it through the ICC. [0:46:27] And then it's a larger entity that we all fall under. [0:46:32] So, and I was a part of that in the gentleman on the board that I just have been appointed to. [0:46:38] I must have said my name up to the gentleman and just said, hey, check this gentleman out in the night, [0:46:43] receive an email, ask him if I'd be interested in sitting on it. [0:46:47] It's very incredible. [0:46:48] I'm very impressed. [0:46:49] Thank you for all you do. [0:46:52] You know, John, I guess I'll close with saying this. [0:46:54] I know that when we take these committees on, it's certainly an honor, [0:46:59] but it also means an additional amount of work. [0:47:03] So we appreciate that you would do that, first of all, [0:47:06] because we're all busy. [0:47:07] I know that your department's busy, [0:47:09] but this obviously is over and above, [0:47:11] and we just want to express our appreciation [0:47:14] for what you do for us. [0:47:15] So one more time, let's give him a hand. [0:47:17] Thank you. [0:47:18] Thank you, John. [0:47:22] Thank you, gentlemen. [0:47:23] Thank you, gentlemen. [0:47:24] Moving on to the next item for consideration, [0:47:27] is consideration of request to approve the recommendations [0:47:29] from Planning and Zoning Commission to negotiate a contract [0:47:32] with Logan Simpson Design Inc. [0:47:35] to develop a comprehensive plan update. [0:47:38] And we have Renee Caraway-Johnson. [0:47:40] Welcome Renee. [0:47:41] Good afternoon, Mayor Holland Council. [0:47:43] It's a pleasure to be back up here again. [0:47:46] He's a hard act to follow. [0:47:47] He's so. [0:47:50] Just a little bit of background on why I'm here this evening. [0:47:54] It is time for a comprehensive plan update. [0:47:56] I brought that RFQ to you guys to look at [0:47:59] several months ago, and late last year we did solicit the RFQ [0:48:05] that you approved for qualified consulting firms [0:48:10] to provide professional services to the city [0:48:12] for a comprehensive plan update. [0:48:15] Proposals were due on Thursday, December 18th of 2014, [0:48:19] and we did receive seven submittals to that RFQ request. [0:48:25] On January 6th of 2015, a committee compiled [0:48:29] of Tom Frank, which is our Planning and Zoning Chairman, [0:48:33] Councilwoman Rebecca Mills-Soyka, [0:48:35] which is our Planning and Zoning Liaison, [0:48:37] Brad Wills, which is a local developer, [0:48:40] Kevin Mailer, a local business owner and resident, [0:48:44] Kevin Dane, who is the Parks and Rec Commission Chairman [0:48:48] and myself, reviewed those seven submittals. [0:48:53] This group narrowed the seven down to two. [0:48:56] Those two firms made a presentation to the Planning and Zoning Commission on Wednesday, February 4th. [0:49:03] Those two firms were Logan Simpson Design Inc. and CRSA. [0:49:09] The two firms were given 15 minutes to make a presentation and 15 minutes to answer questions from the Commission. [0:49:16] Excuse me. [0:49:18] After the presentations and some discussion by the Commission, each Commission are voted for their top-ranked firm. [0:49:24] Based on qualifications, the Commission gave five first place votes to Logan Simpson Design Inc. [0:49:30] and two first place votes to CRSA making Logan Simpson design the top rate firm. [0:49:37] The Commission's comments about why Logan Simpson Design Inc. seem to stand out above the other group are very interesting. [0:49:44] All the Commissioners felt that both firms were very technically qualified to perform the work for the day, for the city. [0:49:51] However, those commissioners that voted for Logan Simpson design did so for two primary [0:49:57] reasons. [0:49:58] First, they presented a much more thorough public engagement plan, not only with a thorough [0:50:05] but also more diverse. [0:50:07] And secondly, their approach to the project seemed individualized and tailored to Twin [0:50:11] Falls, where the CRSAs approach was more of a one-size-fits-all approach. [0:50:19] He was quite apparent that the Logan Simpson design team had spent a lot of time in Twin [0:50:24] Falls preparing for this presentation. [0:50:27] They talked to not only city staff members before this presentation on February 4th, but [0:50:32] to various citizens and citizen groups around the community. [0:50:37] They followed up with that after that meeting also. [0:50:41] If the commission's recommendation is approved this evening, staff will begin negotiations [0:50:46] with Logan Simpson design aid. [0:50:48] So those negotiations fail, staff would then begin negotiations with the number two ranked [0:50:53] firm, CRSA. [0:50:55] Staff is confident that the negotiations with Logan Simpson design will be successful. [0:51:01] So upon conclusion, the Planning and Zoning Commission recommends that the City Council [0:51:06] direct staff to begin negotiations with Logan Simpson designing to develop a contract and [0:51:11] bring that contract back to you for approval. [0:51:14] Thank you. [0:51:15] Very good. So tonight again, just to reiterate, we are just [0:51:20] potentially going to approve an association and on the contract. That'll be brought to us at a different time. [0:51:26] Correct. We can come to an agreement. Very good. Thank you. Kristin? [0:51:29] I was so moved that we [0:51:32] authorized planning and zoning to begin negotiations [0:51:36] fulfill negotiation contract by Logan Simpson design for updated comprehensive plan. [0:51:42] I would second. [0:51:43] A motion on board by Chris Donning and seconded by Rebecca Mills-Soyka. [0:51:47] Rebecca Mills-Soyka. [0:51:48] Thank you, Mayor. [0:51:50] I don't have a lot to add. [0:51:52] The zoning and development manager Renee Caraway did a great job of outlining the commission's [0:51:57] thoughts and it was a pretty good majority that recommended Logan Simpson. [0:52:02] They're a firm out of Colorado and their approach was very unique and they really had some [0:52:09] concrete concepts for reaching out to minority groups in the community and reaching out in [0:52:16] nontraditional ways. [0:52:19] One aspect of their presentation that the Commission liked is that they would have a standardized [0:52:25] questionnaire so that the information that they gather can be uniform and can be specifically [0:52:32] geared towards questions that they're trying to answer. [0:52:35] So all of that information will be very quantitative and measurable, and [0:52:43] will give us a good representation of how the community feels about this comp plan update. [0:52:50] So I would concur with the report. [0:52:53] Very good, thank you Rebecca. [0:52:55] Anything further on the motion made by Chris Dotton, seconded by Rebecca Mills, Leila, Rokalvo? [0:53:03] Chris Talkington? [0:53:03] Yes. [0:53:04] Greg Lanthine? [0:53:05] Yes. [0:53:05] Don Hall? [0:53:06] Yes. [0:53:06] Rebecca Missoika, Suzanne Hawkins, Jim Mann, Sean Berriger. [0:53:13] Motion passes 7-0, thank you for your presentation. [0:53:17] Thank you, look forward to working on this for you. [0:53:20] Absolutely, thank you Rene. [0:53:22] Next item on the agenda is a consideration of a request to approve expenditures to install a recirculation system for the splash part to be constructed as part of the first federal bank part. [0:53:34] And we have dentists here, but I see that we have a light on first and that's Jim. [0:53:39] Thank you, Mayor. [0:53:40] Whereas I've discussed this with the city attorney and the city manager and there is not a conflict of interest for me to vote and deliberate in this next agenda item. [0:53:53] There may be a perception from the community that there would be because my daughter is an employee of First Federal. [0:53:58] So, I'm going to recuse myself and not participate in these discussions or nor vote, okay? [0:54:07] Very good. [0:54:08] Thank you, Jim. [0:54:09] We respect your decision on that. [0:54:11] Dennis Boyer, welcome. [0:54:12] Welcome. [0:54:13] Thank you, Mayor and Council. [0:54:14] It's a pleasure to be here tonight. [0:54:15] Kind of when we started working on this whole project with First Federal, you know, I don't [0:54:22] care about him a month ago, we started working on this project. [0:54:25] One of the issues was, what are we going to do with the water after it's been used in the [0:54:30] park? [0:54:31] I kind of called around the state and talked to a lot of the communities and what they've [0:54:35] done, especially from Meridian because they do have a splash park at one of their facilities, [0:54:40] Settlers Park, and they just have a new one also at Julius's kind of park. [0:54:44] In both of those splash parks what they do, they reuse that water, they put it back into [0:54:49] the irrigation system and use that water for irrigation in their parks out there. [0:54:53] So at that time, we believe that was the way that we was going to go out at this facility [0:55:00] out here, out at the Sunway Soccer Complex. [0:55:04] But later on, when we did some further investigations and we found out with DEQ, the rules have changed [0:55:09] a little bit about, you still can put that water back into your irrigation pond, but there [0:55:15] now there's a lot longer process, permit process to get that done, and that permit process could [0:55:22] to take any word of four to six months. [0:55:24] So kind of city staff got together. [0:55:25] There's myself, Mitch Humboldt Travis, Jackie, [0:55:31] a couple other ones from engineering. [0:55:33] We had Mandy work with us too about, [0:55:35] you know, let's look at the ways [0:55:39] of how we could best use this park [0:55:42] and what's the best way to reuse this water [0:55:44] if we want to reuse it. [0:55:45] So really, there's kind of three ways you can [0:55:49] with a splash park. [0:55:50] One is a recirculation, similar to what our city pool is. [0:55:53] It's recirculate, goes through a sand filter, [0:55:56] goes through UV light, it's chemicals, [0:55:58] and you just reuse the water. [0:56:00] Okay, that's one recommendation, not recommendation, [0:56:04] but that's one way we can do that. [0:56:06] And it's really a cost effective [0:56:08] because we are not really using water continuously. [0:56:15] Excuse me, it really, really conserves [0:56:17] are really our most precious commodity that we have here is our water so that's our kind [0:56:23] of our it is our focus on tonight is our recommendation of that but like I said I talked about it [0:56:30] before water features you know we have a you know kind of a storage sink underneath and [0:56:35] that just gets ready when it gets low it will get filled up again but we just reuse [0:56:40] that water during the time of the splash park is on you know one added cost to it is a UV [0:56:46] light similar to what we have at our swimming pool and that UV light is about $50,000 but [0:56:51] that really kills the stuff that chlorine doesn't kill. Chlorine, I'm talking to Kevin [0:56:58] Skeleton, is one of our certified pull operators that we have on staff that maintains the pool [0:57:02] that he says chlorine a lot of times is going to kill 99% of the bugs, I might say, and the [0:57:08] UV light kills that other basically 1% in there and that's what we're really looking at is [0:57:14] to killing everything that we use in the water. [0:57:20] I was going to just mention there, you know, we added that UV light to the pool system back in 2009 [0:57:25] and we worked with the OMI part of their contract with the whole waste treatment plant, [0:57:30] is they do the checking on our UV light and maintain that UV light as a pool, [0:57:35] and we're hoping that we can use that same type of contract to help us with, [0:57:39] with if this is the direction we're going to go, is to use a UV light at the splash park. [0:57:47] So one of the options is the treatment of recirculation, like I said, that's staff's recommendation, [0:57:54] but I'll go through the other two options too, what we have. [0:57:59] Option, let me jump in ahead of myself a little bit, and kind of go back to the option number [0:58:05] one of recirculation and treatment of the water. [0:58:08] The cost of the recirculation and treatment of water included in UV light and the estimated [0:58:13] cost of installing in that system is approximately about $148,000. [0:58:19] And that does not include the maintenance of the system, replacement of the UV bulbs or [0:58:24] the cost of the chemicals or also we know that we will have some labor of a sitting employee [0:58:28] out there checking the water out there. [0:58:32] We don't know exactly how many times a day but we're looking at it could be three to [0:58:35] four times a day out there testing the balance of the water anyway. [0:58:40] Option number two is really you reuse the water for the irrigation out there and that's [0:58:45] where potable water will have to be delivered out to these fish park and we know that it [0:58:49] will take a six inch water line. [0:58:51] To do that currently we have a three inch water line going to the restroom right now so [0:58:55] that would not be enough if we want to reuse the water in this for irrigation and we know [0:59:01] that somewhere, you know, we would have to pipe that water out there because currently [0:59:06] there's the main water junctions, if you think of the corner of North College, [0:59:11] kind of just south of Xavier School out there on North College, that's where we [0:59:17] get our water from initially, that we would have to have some pond out there [0:59:23] to pump the water into and pump the water out to get to the airgate the [0:59:29] land out there. You know, we know that the extra piping is anywhere, you know, could [0:59:34] be 800 to 1,000 feet of piping and engineering kind of really worked on all [0:59:42] the preliminary cost estimates of doing all this, the extra pond that we would [0:59:46] have to build in the extra piping and it, you know, roughly it's like $388,000 to do [0:59:53] that, you know, and, you know, Jackie, could probably explain a little bit more [0:59:57] all the details of that, but that was her working with her staff and her team to figure [1:00:02] out what would cost, and that would be if we would contract it all out, of course. [1:00:06] But that's her cost estimates of doing that. [1:00:10] As I mentioned earlier that we found out that we could not use that waiver from the DEQ [1:00:16] about just getting the quick waiver on that. [1:00:19] It's a new process. [1:00:21] As you would call it Jackie, kind of the test with beta side of this, they have not [1:00:27] not issued a permit like this since they have modified the rule. So we would be kind [1:00:32] of a beta site for that where we would have to do a lot of testing in that. And we may [1:00:36] we really thought that this minor permit would take four to six months to process. And you [1:00:43] know, and at that time we'd like to have this flash park open sometime in May and we'd think [1:00:47] you know, we probably won't hit that deadline at that time. So and the third option is [1:00:54] really is just discharging the water that is run through the splash part back [1:00:57] into our sewer system and going down to the sewer line. We know that system would [1:01:03] take a lot of potable water and are we willing to use that potable water for [1:01:08] this system here. You know you can modify, there's 19 spray features at this [1:01:13] splash part and they run anywhere between two gallons per minute to 35 [1:01:18] gallons per minute and this program on this you can program as many as you [1:01:23] want to come on at one time, run as long, shut off, and then you can have a system where [1:01:28] you have different ones come on at all the different times. [1:01:31] So you can program this water feature anywhere you could run it at 50 gallons from in a minute [1:01:37] or 230 gallons from it. [1:01:38] And 230 gallons per minute, that is the full, if you have all 19 features on at one time, [1:01:44] that's how many gallons per minute you would use. [1:01:46] And we did some simple math looking at what range you could have, the splash part how many [1:01:54] features you have on there, and we looked at, you could easily run from 60 to 70 gallons [1:01:59] per minute, you're running 70 hours a day, have it on for 50 minutes every hour where [1:02:05] you have it on for 10 minutes, off for 2 on 10 off to that system. [1:02:09] And you could easily, for that 100 day window we're looking at Memorial Day to Labor Day, [1:02:14] We're looking at 1.8 to 2.5 million gallons per year on that. [1:02:21] And we know that's really wasn't a long-term viable kind of solution for that. [1:02:27] We thought maybe that's just a one-year fix until we got a recirculation. [1:02:32] But internally, staff really talked about what's the best way for the city to handle this. [1:02:41] And we really believe that doing the recirculation system is our best option. [1:02:47] It's something that we do not have the budget of funds for, but [1:02:51] we really believe it's the best option. [1:02:53] And kind of talking about the budget, I went back to the recirculation, [1:02:57] would cost an additional $148,000 to purchase the equipment and to install it. [1:03:06] I did talk to Ms. Lori raised our Chief Financial Officer today. [1:03:11] Currently we have 150,000 in contingency, and she said we have not spent any of that at this time. [1:03:18] And that's one option for the council is to, if they wish to, expend this money to take it all out of contingency. [1:03:27] One of the other options I had was we do have some capital improvements in the Parks and Recreation Department that we could maybe delay for [1:03:34] year or kind of readjust a little bit. One was looked at it like a bull toll that Down [1:03:40] and Dogger Falls. Right now we have a porta potted down there year round. It's functional, [1:03:46] not the best of what everybody likes, but it is functional and we could need to wait [1:03:50] another year for that. I tell the story about after Sunway restroom was built, you know, [1:03:59] people wish we would have built it earlier, but now I ask people when did we build it? [1:04:03] They don't remember, you know, so sometimes one year difference is not that big, you know, [1:04:08] at that time it is, but years down the road is not that big. [1:04:10] So I looked at, you know, maybe we can just delay that building, that bull toilet for one [1:04:15] year, and also down in Augur Falls, I have $50,000 for trail development. [1:04:20] And I'll have to tell you that, you know, we've been fortunate that working with the Southern [1:04:24] Idaho Mountain Micro Association, they have built over 20 miles of trails down at Augur [1:04:28] Falls for us. [1:04:29] And besides just started out as mountain bike trails, [1:04:33] but every time I go down there, [1:04:36] I see people walking on it or jogging on it. [1:04:38] So that really is a multi-use trail [1:04:41] that it didn't cost us a dime to do that. [1:04:45] I have talked to a few of the members [1:04:47] of the Southern Idaho Mountain Bike Association. [1:04:50] They said if I could get them with some materials, [1:04:52] there's some areas that the trails need to be sure [1:04:55] up and need some extra material, [1:04:57] kind of more like not right gravel, [1:04:59] but kind of crush granted or something like that [1:05:01] to help build because some of the trails got really dusty [1:05:04] during the summertime. [1:05:05] So I really believe that I wouldn't need that whole $50,000 [1:05:08] for the trail development. [1:05:09] That auger falls, I could just kind of cut that in half [1:05:12] and still have plenty of money to help further develop [1:05:17] our trails down at auger falls, but also maybe use [1:05:20] some of that money for this project here. [1:05:23] So option two is really savings. [1:05:25] I'm approximately $65,000 out of our Parks Capital [1:05:28] improvement fund and combine that with would be approximately 83,000 out of [1:05:33] contingency would pay for the $148,000 if the council was to pursue this [1:05:38] recirculation system for the splash part. And I'll ask my team, because I was [1:05:43] reminded I do have a team behind me that did I miss anything. [1:05:47] One thing I would like for you to do if you wouldn't mind either you or Travis, [1:05:50] could you introduce our partners from first bed that are here? Yes, even [1:05:54] we do have questions for them. [1:05:56] We have Ashley Terry and Jeff Chardine from the first federal bank there. [1:06:01] They, we worked with them quite extensively. [1:06:04] It was, I don't know how many months we have, it's April of last year like that. [1:06:10] We started with them so, you know, the two of our great partners that we have. [1:06:15] Absolutely great partner, so welcome. [1:06:17] And if we have any questions for them, I'm sure you'd be happy to come forward. [1:06:21] So Travis. [1:06:25] So I think Dennis did a really good job in his report. [1:06:27] There's a couple of points that I wanted to highlight. [1:06:32] Number one, one of the things we wanted to make sure we were looking at was what was [1:06:37] the indirect costs of whatever solution we were looking at. [1:06:41] And one of those costs was the water consumption. [1:06:44] And with the recirculation, we recognize that that is going to be the single piece [1:06:48] that really allowed us to minimize the use of water moving forward. [1:06:54] We've long said and long held as an organization that water is the most [1:06:58] present precious resource that we have and it's probably going to be the most [1:07:02] defining resource that we have as we continue to move forward in the community. [1:07:07] The recirculation pump allows us to maximize that water and it allows us to [1:07:11] essentially have a tank that can be filled up, it goes through its process and [1:07:16] then it continues to achieve certain levels and there's some evaporative loss [1:07:21] but certainly significantly and far less than what you see in the others. [1:07:26] The second point that I think is pretty important when you looked at the cost of using irrigation [1:07:31] for the park. [1:07:33] We also felt that it was important that we, as have been directed by the Council, follow [1:07:38] our own rules and policies, and one of the rules and policies that we have is that we [1:07:43] will not apply potable water and use that for irrigation purposes on new subdivisions. [1:07:50] Right now, this is not a subdivision, but it is going to go through the subdivision process [1:07:55] because Sunway Soccer Complex is going to be split from the farm that is directly to the [1:08:00] north of it, and that is going to be gifted to the city from the school district for our [1:08:05] agreement. [1:08:06] Right now, that is not a separate partial, so it will go through that subdivision process [1:08:10] and that is a subdivision that you will see, and if we were to apply that, then we would have [1:08:16] to make a conscious decision that we're going to create a rule that we wouldn't be having [1:08:20] others follow as well. And then discharge to the city's waste [1:08:24] water treatment plant. We have went through this process to [1:08:28] convince the voters to really expand the waste water treatment [1:08:33] plant for growth and growth opportunities that make sense [1:08:37] in a growing economy. What's important about these numbers [1:08:41] that Dennis shared is that when you allocate space in a waste [1:08:46] water treatment capacity, it's not done on a seasonal basis. [1:08:50] You have to be able to ensure that you receive those flows all of the time. [1:08:56] And you have the capacity to receive those flows all of the time. [1:09:00] And you're going to take away a significant amount of capacity, daily capacity, [1:09:07] in our wastewater treatment facility that could be otherwise used for something else. [1:09:12] Dennis shared the options and the opportunities here. [1:09:16] here. There was a fourth option that we talked about briefly, and that fourth option was wait [1:09:25] until the next budget year. The challenge that we had with that is we have the opportunity [1:09:32] to get in, fix the system, build it, development all in once, get in and get out. Dennis shared [1:09:39] that we had about $150,000 of contingencies that we have not used. I think it's also important [1:09:44] to recognize that for whatever reason over the course of the year, we will also have unused [1:09:50] allocated dollars, monies that we've allocated for specific projects that may not get spent [1:09:57] for one reason or another or that we will have savings over those projects for one reason [1:10:01] or another. [1:10:04] The other side is we also have cash reserves. [1:10:07] And we have cash reserves that specifically in the capital fund that we could also use [1:10:13] for this project in moving forward. [1:10:17] And so we wanted to really bring these options before the council tonight and to see what [1:10:22] your pleasure was as we look to move forward with this really exciting project with First [1:10:27] Federal. [1:10:29] On another note, I think that as a staff we learned a really good lesson, I think we learned [1:10:33] the value of internal communication, really communicating with one another and making sure [1:10:40] that all of our partners and all of our resources inside of the organization have the ability [1:10:45] to contribute to an even better process. [1:10:49] Thank you, Travis. [1:10:50] Thank you, Dennis. [1:10:51] We have a couple of lights on. [1:10:52] Rebecca, Mel, sorry. [1:10:53] Thank you, Mayor. [1:10:54] Thank you, Dennis, for outlining those options for us. [1:10:58] I support getting the part going this year, and I hope we can do that. [1:11:02] I do have two questions real quickly, and then maybe a comment regarding the budgeting [1:11:10] question that you're asking us, but my one question is, what is the difference, do we [1:11:15] know the difference between the annual maintenance on options number one and two? [1:11:22] Because I certainly understand the concern of utilizing the water, you know, and I think [1:11:29] that's why you're kind of staring away from option number two. It seems like maybe it has [1:11:35] a little bit larger investment on the front end, but as far as annual maintenance, it seems [1:11:40] a little bit less complex whereas you're doing monthly testing and a yearly [1:11:46] report as opposed to having an employee test three or four times a day. Plus, like [1:11:52] you said, the UV bulbs, the chemicals, I mean from our experience with the pool, we [1:11:55] know that it's a good recirculation system but it does get really costly. So do we [1:12:02] have any idea on the cost difference for annual maintenance between the preferred [1:12:08] option number one and then the number two reuse for irrigation. [1:12:13] You know, I can tell Lisa on option number one, you know, I have not looked in detail [1:12:18] of the approximate cost of maintenance because we're thinking about, you know, [1:12:23] do we need someone out there every hour that the splash park is on? [1:12:28] You know, right now we believe we don't need someone out there, but we need someone out there [1:12:32] testing more often than, because, you know, it's something that's a little different [1:12:37] a little different at the pool, you know, even when we manage it or the why manage it, they [1:12:41] have someone there all the time. They're, you know, life-guarding or you have a pool manager, [1:12:45] so it's easy for them to test it. Typically, at a park, we don't have someone there. We have [1:12:50] people that, okay, that's your park. This is, you know, have several parks, but they're [1:12:54] not at that park every single hour that they're working. So, you know, like I said, we haven't [1:13:00] figured out the exact cost estimates of having someone there on staff. You know, we can probably [1:13:05] have once we review the system more and more, we'd probably [1:13:10] going to have a good idea of the chemical cost, because we [1:13:13] have a good idea of what the pool costs, what it costs to [1:13:16] for the supplies of the chemicals. [1:13:18] We can kind of break that down. [1:13:22] I know Jackie would know more about the reuse system, [1:13:25] about maybe the maintenance on Mac. [1:13:27] Because I know I think she's talked about there's some [1:13:29] testing to do. [1:13:30] I don't know if you can't remember how often was it [1:13:32] once a month testing? [1:13:34] Would you like to come forward, Jackie? [1:13:39] By the way, we have had a comment, [1:13:41] and I'm gonna try to be better at this. [1:13:43] When folks come to the podium, [1:13:45] we need to make sure that we say their names, [1:13:46] because folks at home sometimes can't. [1:13:48] They don't know who it is. [1:13:49] So Jackie Fields, our city engineer. [1:13:52] Thanks for introducing me. [1:13:54] So, the land application option has several costs [1:14:00] that are different from the recirculation. [1:14:02] And we did not estimate them out entire. [1:14:07] If we're choosing to do the land app, then we need to add the waterline cost. [1:14:14] We'll need to address the chlorine residual, so we make sure we have some there, which is in a larger quantity, a different amount of chemical. [1:14:24] There's probably not a big difference on the distribution pumping. [1:14:29] We need to put in a pump so that we can move that water to a place where it can be reused. [1:14:36] And there is a small pump and electrical cost associated with that. [1:14:41] The irrigation system has some kind of pumping cost to get it back into the system and maintenance on those pumps. [1:14:48] Those types of functions are conducted by either a dentist's group for parks or water supply for pressurized irrigation stations. [1:14:58] The land application permit would hopefully be substantially easier than the one that we [1:15:07] have down at Otter Falls. [1:15:09] Otter Falls has a significant reporting responsibility that occupies some staff time and some very [1:15:17] regular testing by OMI. [1:15:20] So we can only assume, based on the indicators of having a new and easier land app permit, that [1:15:34] we would only have to test maybe a couple of times a month, but we'd have to report that [1:15:42] testing. [1:15:43] And I don't know what else I can offer you on that. [1:15:48] So. [1:15:49] No, that leads perfectly into the second clarification question. [1:15:52] The water line that you're talking about in the report, it says that it would be needed [1:15:56] for options two and three. [1:15:58] Does that mean it would not be needed for option one? [1:16:01] So would that be a savings? [1:16:02] You would put that money into the creation of the UV filtration system? [1:16:07] Or are you going to still temporarily build that water line? [1:16:11] So it's accurate to say that we wouldn't build the water line because we don't have [1:16:15] a clear use for it. [1:16:17] When you build a long dead end line, there are some consequences there that are better to be avoided as far as water stagnating. [1:16:26] So, if we pursue option number one in recirculation, we have, as I mentioned earlier, we have a three-inch water line going to the restroom. [1:16:36] We can use that water line to fill up our tank for this recirculation. [1:16:39] Then there is a small line discharge that would go into our sewer line that eventually goes down to the sewer plant. [1:16:45] but recirculation we wouldn't have a lot of water going down into the sewer line because [1:16:51] we kept on recirculating the water so we don't really there's just a couple of small [1:16:56] new lines you would have to put in there so you wouldn't have to put one of these longer lines that [1:17:01] we talked about earlier. Okay thank you um so just lastly I think it would be helpful for me [1:17:07] before making a choice here to know exactly the cost that we're taking on just for our knowledge [1:17:14] I think there's good points made about the conservation of water and that sort of thing. [1:17:20] So it sounds like the city really should go with option one, but I would just like to [1:17:25] know more about the annual maintenance costs. [1:17:28] Thank you Rebecca. [1:17:30] Greg Lanning. [1:17:31] Well, one of the things that this gives us a good little preview to there are no agencies [1:17:38] thoughts in the plans in the new plaza area across from the new city hall to put it in [1:17:42] splice market there. Obviously anything we do here is going to help us learn for that one, I'm sure, and also help us to learn about potential costs of that, if we were asked to take that over, which I assume we would be and things. [1:17:56] So I think it's a little hard for me to understand as a farm kid growing up swimming into canal, to think about needing to purify the water each time before it comes back through use and all those things. [1:18:10] is kind of like, what were we drinking out of the canals? [1:18:13] We just did it out there, over and over and over again [1:18:16] off the makeshift diving board we built [1:18:18] and all those kinds of things. [1:18:20] So, and then also I think about where does the water, [1:18:24] how does the fountain work that's downtown now, [1:18:26] which is serving as a de facto water park [1:18:30] in the summer times and then the Hanson Street park work. [1:18:34] The kids just, it gets hot in the evenings, [1:18:36] families show up there with their chairs [1:18:38] and the kids playing in the water. [1:18:41] So where does that water go to? [1:18:43] Is it recirculated? [1:18:44] Those are not recirculatory systems [1:18:46] and they're also old systems. [1:18:48] So they absolutely predate the addition of our sewer use [1:18:53] to organize that, that type of discharge. [1:18:56] So in their in their in-situ state, they're a grandfather. [1:19:01] That's it. [1:19:03] So that's actually going down the sewer for now? [1:19:05] Well, yes. [1:19:06] That would be accurate. [1:19:07] And then it's probably important for you to understand [1:19:10] that estimating the cost of the testing [1:19:14] for this altered land at permit is going to look a lot like the [1:19:18] guess. [1:19:19] So there's going to be some huge level of uncertainty [1:19:23] associated with it. [1:19:26] Because we haven't sized a pump, so it's [1:19:28] going to be difficult to estimate pumping costs. [1:19:30] Without doing a substantial amount of design, [1:19:33] getting you a number that seems real, is going to be difficult. [1:19:47] Travis Rothweiler, our city manager. [1:19:49] So I think it's also important to remember is that we would develop the program and [1:19:53] the protocols associated with testing as we move forward. [1:19:56] And so at this point in time, although we believe that it may be a couple of times [1:20:01] a month, it could be more or it could be less, largely dependent upon. [1:20:06] The way our permit ends up. [1:20:09] Really. [1:20:10] That's a great deal. [1:20:13] Thank you for that clarification. [1:20:15] Since this is a broadcasted meeting and we have young, impressionable mines in the back [1:20:22] of the room, Mr. Lanning is not recommending that you drink now. [1:20:26] We'll swim in the canals. [1:20:29] I'm just making comparison to his youth and that's probably not a good idea. [1:20:34] So I just want to make sure I clarified that. [1:20:36] Suzanne Hawkins. [1:20:37] Thank you. [1:20:38] Maybe since we can't drill down too deep, [1:20:40] you can at least give us an idea. [1:20:41] What does the UV light cost? [1:20:43] And how often do you estimate you're [1:20:46] going to have to replace that? [1:20:47] Or how does that work? [1:20:49] All right. [1:20:49] The UV light costs approximately $50,000. [1:20:54] And we have, like I said, we have a maintenance agreement. [1:20:56] Part of our contract with OMI, they come up [1:21:00] and do the maintenance on it. [1:21:02] And I believe the pool UV light was installed in 2009, [1:21:08] so it's five, almost come on month, six years. [1:21:11] If I think, if I remember, we have replaced the bulbs, [1:21:15] at least once in there, maybe twice. [1:21:18] Those bulbs in there. [1:21:19] But part of our contract with- [1:21:22] Since what date, Dennis? [1:21:23] 2009, thank you. [1:21:25] So we're talking about just a little less than six years. [1:21:28] I know we replaced them once, [1:21:30] And those bulbs are 50,000 or the whole stretch. [1:21:35] Okay, I'm sorry. [1:21:36] How much are the light bulbs when you replace them? [1:21:38] Do you have that? [1:21:39] I have to. [1:21:40] Maybe I don't know if Jackie would know, but our agreement with OMI, that's part of our [1:21:45] whole contract with OMI and taking care of those. [1:21:48] So they do it. [1:21:49] They are pretty expensive though. [1:21:51] They are pretty expensive. [1:21:54] We have an audience member that's here every night. [1:21:57] I believe engineering background might be able to give us a yes. My name is Dave Moore and I'm a Twin Falls resident retired [1:22:04] Chief engineer at AmeriPride where we used UV lighting to pre-treat our wastewater [1:22:09] Those bulbs run around a hundred and fifty dollars a piece. They do have a two to three-year life expectancy in my experience [1:22:17] Thank you. That helps. Thank you for sharing. That's a lot better than 50,000 [1:22:21] That's the whole UV system, that's okay, sorry. [1:22:26] Chris, talking about the water testing in general, [1:22:30] but the narrative here on option one [1:22:35] which looks to be the preferable one, [1:22:37] mentions multiple times per day testing the PH. [1:22:42] If we're extending that to having a person [1:22:45] partially dedicated just for water testing there [1:22:48] plus the new splash park downtown. [1:22:51] I mean, we're talking about a significant labor component. [1:22:55] This cannot be automated, I guess, huh? [1:22:58] No, the testing you have to manually test. [1:23:01] Yeah, put a strip in. [1:23:03] And one thing we know with high-use parks, [1:23:06] like we know that this park will have a lot of visitors. [1:23:09] We expect a lot of visitors out there. [1:23:11] That means that our restrooms, [1:23:13] because during the summertime our restrooms at Sunway, [1:23:16] don't get a lot of action, you might say. [1:23:18] You know, you have a few soccer, you know, practices. [1:23:21] We have some youth baseball softball games out there. [1:23:23] But now, I really believe that we'll have someone else out there more often besides. [1:23:29] You know, we hope and we can train this person besides just cleaning the bathrooms [1:23:33] out there doing our testing. [1:23:34] So we're not sending someone specifically just to go out there testing. [1:23:38] So while we're doing some of our regular maintenance, our basic maintenance [1:23:42] out there have this person do the testing of the water also. [1:23:45] So we're looking at trying to combine a couple of functions we have out at that park just to have that person [1:23:52] Add another function to it. Thank you. Dennis if I could ask you we had an audience member say that it could be automated [1:24:00] It's good. Can you are you sure it can't be automated? [1:24:03] Did have we done some research have we done some research to make sure it can't be automated or maybe it's cost-prohibitive? [1:24:10] What do you know about that? [1:24:12] The system, the chlorine system automatic pumps in chlorine when it meets it, but you still [1:24:19] have to. [1:24:20] I know at the pool, okay, I wish I had Kevin Skelton right here because he explained that [1:24:25] to you in details very well, but we do test that water at the pool when it's during the [1:24:30] summertime, three or four times manually. [1:24:33] Do we have to do that though, is there some sort of automation? [1:24:38] maybe Jackie knows. [1:24:39] That question was brought up and I think we need to clarify that. [1:24:46] You bet. [1:24:47] And our industrial users have continuous pH monitoring and so that unit is available. [1:24:55] There is a capital cost to it and there is some kind of support that goes on for people [1:25:01] to either communicate with it through skater, radio or something and to watch the results [1:25:08] and then respond accordingly. [1:25:10] So having the unit test the PH does not [1:25:14] relieve you necessarily, [1:25:18] relieve the city of having an employee do something about it. [1:25:22] There's another piece of equipment [1:25:25] that can also be purchased that'll drip in PH, [1:25:30] because the industries do that. [1:25:32] And we do that as a part of our particular facilities [1:25:36] with some regularity. [1:25:38] Are they cost prohibitive? [1:25:40] What do you have? [1:25:41] They are there yet another cost on this job. [1:25:44] So we didn't estimate them. [1:25:47] OK. [1:25:48] We didn't estimate those costs. [1:25:49] And probably as we proceed down a path, [1:25:52] we can certainly look at that in terms of personnel [1:25:56] and ONM dollars versus the capital cost. [1:26:00] I suspect that in the short term at least, [1:26:04] the capital cost will be a little bit prohibitive compared [1:26:07] of what we think will spend in manpower, [1:26:11] but we can certainly validate that. [1:26:12] So certainly we could start with the manpower piece, [1:26:16] and then if it made sense later on, [1:26:18] it was really cost prohibitive for the manpower, [1:26:21] the man hours out there, [1:26:23] that we could proceed to a more automation, potentially. [1:26:26] We can, and we may decide we wanna do that sooner [1:26:30] rather than later. [1:26:31] I'd rather start with the automation. [1:26:36] Well, we'll have some more debate about that. [1:26:38] Rebecca Milsoyka. [1:26:40] Thank you, Mayor. [1:26:41] So I just wanted to make a final comment. [1:26:43] You're asking us on how to fund this. [1:26:47] I would prefer not to reduce improvements at agar falls [1:26:52] if we can help it. [1:26:53] And so I just personally would prefer [1:26:56] to either use general reserves or contingency. [1:26:59] And that way we're not delaying or reducing improvements [1:27:03] at other parks to get this one up and running. [1:27:06] you know, since we do have the general reserves and the contingency [1:27:09] of the oil membership. [1:27:11] Thank you. [1:27:14] Here's where I am with it. [1:27:15] I think you're option one for recirculation makes perfect sense to me. [1:27:19] I was always concerned when we were talking about this to make sure that we explored. [1:27:26] Water is such a precious resource. [1:27:28] All you have to do is pick up the Times News about once a week, [1:27:32] and there's some sort of issue out there with water calls or the need for us [1:27:37] to be conservative with our water. [1:27:39] And for me, recirculating, even though there's some upfront costs, obviously, [1:27:46] fairly substantial upfront costs, it makes sense to me. [1:27:49] And I would rather go that direction to be able to recirculate it. [1:27:54] As far as the funding piece, I was probably leaning more towards a combination like you [1:27:59] gave us. [1:28:00] But Rebecca makes some good points about, I hate to delay some of these projects. [1:28:05] We just had a meeting with a gentleman where we talked about [1:28:07] delaying a restroom. [1:28:10] And these are amenities that the community really want. [1:28:14] And I know that you've gone through painstaking exploration [1:28:18] and research and presentations to make these amenities [1:28:25] come into line with budgets for all these different years. [1:28:28] So I'd hate to see that delayed as well. [1:28:30] So I think that's point well taken. [1:28:32] Suzanne Hopkins. [1:28:34] Thank you. I'm looking at the funding option, you know, I would hate to see us put off doing [1:28:40] the restrooms down there, but I think the 25,000 savings on the trail is reasonable since [1:28:44] you really don't need that money this year. And that would, that still leaves us 27,000 [1:28:49] in contingency instead of 2,000 and I'm much more comfortable with that. So I'd like to [1:28:53] see it go down the middle personally. [1:28:56] Very good. Sean Berger. [1:28:58] So at the end of the year, if there are savings and there's money left that didn't get spent, [1:29:03] It goes to reserves, correct? [1:29:05] That is correct. [1:29:06] So I would recommend that we use reserves and at the end of the year, if these other things [1:29:11] aren't spent, that money goes back to reserves to replenish reserves. [1:29:15] Or you're making a question, Mark. [1:29:21] Travis, Travis, why don't you? [1:29:26] I believe an appropriate motion would be to, if you wanted to move forward with option one, [1:29:33] would be to fund option one, and if you wanted to do a deduct for one of the projects, you [1:29:40] would include that. But then the end of the motion, which is probably the most critical, [1:29:44] from a staff perspective, is where you would say to use contingency or cash reserves, whichever [1:29:49] is appropriate at the end of the fiscal year, and to be included in the budget amendment. [1:29:53] I think that's a great suggestion. Anyone like to take that on? [1:29:58] I would move that we authorize or approve. [1:30:04] Option one, the research system for the proposed splash pad to present to the Council as soon [1:30:15] as possible all known labor costs and a PH automation system and to begin to look at funding [1:30:24] the project using a combination of contingencies and reserves. And with Auger Falls being the [1:30:34] least optimal option for deferring. [1:30:39] I'll second that. [1:30:41] Motion on floor by Chris talking and second by Rebecca Mills Suica. Anything on the motion [1:30:46] council? [1:30:47] Sean Barrier. [1:30:48] So that didn't quite incorporate what Travis suggested we should put on the end of the [1:30:53] motion about allocating that to either cash reserves or contingency at the end of the year [1:31:00] and providing for a budget and including in the budget amendment. [1:31:05] I left it open. [1:31:06] I did mention reserves and contingency. [1:31:09] I don't think that we have to dictate down to the dollar on where the split has to come [1:31:15] from, especially since the reserves are reimbursed. [1:31:19] And I did mention I thought the Dogger Falls Project should not be tampered with, except [1:31:23] as a last potential. [1:31:25] I'm comfortable, personally, [1:31:27] I'm just giving them the flexibility to come to us [1:31:30] with recommendations on how to finance it. [1:31:32] Well, let me ask our city manager. [1:31:34] Did that, the motion as made, [1:31:37] did that meet what you were shooting for, essentially, [1:31:41] giving you that flexibility to take it out [1:31:43] of whatever is most appropriate? [1:31:48] The part that I didn't quite track with [1:31:53] was whether or not the Council was authorizing staff [1:31:57] to go forward and acquire today, [1:32:00] or if you were looking for additional research, [1:32:03] which included a staff time calculation [1:32:08] by comparison to an automated system. [1:32:13] What may be helpful is if just so that we understand [1:32:17] what the motion is, that maybe take them in pieces, [1:32:21] and if there's additional things [1:32:22] that you would like to see such as an allocation of staff time [1:32:27] in comparison to automation that be included [1:32:29] and we can certainly make that report on that. [1:32:33] The idea of this project and the timing of this project [1:32:36] is to ensure that it is being constructed at a time [1:32:40] in which the other parts and pieces of the splash pad [1:32:43] and the University of Accessible Park are being constructed. [1:32:46] So there's a window in there that we're trying to really, [1:32:50] to try to really work through, and I don't know if that was impressed upon in [1:32:55] Dennis's report or not, but that's that that window is something that we're [1:32:58] trying to work through as well. Well, I can withdraw my motion to try it again or [1:33:03] if somebody else has the perfect motion, they can do it. Probably be cleaner to [1:33:09] withdraw the motion at this time and then you're right, right, I'm just going to [1:33:16] ensure that. So, Rebecca, would you be fine with? Sure, I'll withdraw. Can I follow it [1:33:22] with a question. [1:33:23] Yeah, absolutely. [1:33:24] You're next. [1:33:25] Appreciate that. [1:33:27] Do we have time? [1:33:28] So you're speaking of that time frame that we want to get this. [1:33:31] Do we have time to provide additional information to the council? [1:33:37] I mean, how long would that take and if it would delay the project, then I suppose it's [1:33:44] I guess not that important, but do we have time to have some additional information? [1:33:49] So I think, I always want to say yes, there's time for the additional information. [1:33:54] I think it's a plan to plan how complex the information is and what we're going to be asked to look at. [1:34:00] There are again, representatives with first federal here, or maybe Dennis, they can talk about the construction timeline and [1:34:06] when they hope to begin moving forward and the time in which we need to acquire the pieces before going to go forward with option one this year. [1:34:15] Okay, I know, you know, First Federal has been working with the Sun Tag Recreation and [1:34:20] Jeremiah Webb is one of the representatives, and I just spoke with him today in fact, and [1:34:25] he told me the kind of the lead time on ordering this recirculation system this 12 weeks. [1:34:32] So he said that, you know, the sooner or the better, because I told him tonight that we're [1:34:36] making a presentation of the council and hopefully looking for direction. [1:34:39] And they said that's good because it's a 12-week lead time on once you order it and getting that [1:34:45] recirculation system here and our goal is [1:34:48] Was middle of May try to middle made to try to get this up and running which you know 12 [1:34:55] About we're there [1:34:58] Schumburger [1:35:00] Well, I'll give an attempt to the had a motion so I would move approval of the [1:35:07] I would move approval of the expenditures to install a recirculation system as presented [1:35:17] in Option 1. [1:35:20] For the funds to come from a $25,000 reduction to the agar falls trails and the balance from [1:35:34] cash reserves or contingency, whichever is more appropriate, and to have the Budget Amendment [1:35:41] reflect that at the conclusion of the year. [1:35:45] Secretary? [1:35:46] I have a motion on the floor by Sean Berger, seconded by Suzanne Hopkins. [1:35:50] Chris talking. [1:35:52] I would also move to amend the motion to include a presentation to the Council that would not [1:35:59] and the votes off the record wouldn't impact ordering the equipment now, but I think we [1:36:05] need to look for automating that system and if we could get that added to us as an amendment [1:36:10] to the motion so we could see at the time it begins to be installed whether we can automate [1:36:16] it right away. [1:36:18] So the point is to amend it to include to the council the cost of automating the PH another [1:36:26] appropriate safety water standards within 30 days. [1:36:31] I'll second. [1:36:34] Have a motion on the floor by Chris talking and then seconded by Rebecca Mills, Suica. [1:36:39] And again, this is not going to affect the actual main motion in the sense of order of [1:36:45] funding. [1:36:46] It's just, we need to just, we'd like to have a report back within 30 days so that we can [1:36:49] look at some options. [1:36:50] Is that fair? [1:36:51] Very good. [1:36:52] Anything on that amendment or the main motion council? [1:36:57] We will start with the amendment. [1:37:00] Yeah, roll call vote, please. [1:37:01] Greg Lanting. [1:37:02] John Lewis. [1:37:03] Yes. [1:37:04] Don Hall. [1:37:05] Yes. [1:37:06] Rebecca Milsoyka. [1:37:07] Yes. [1:37:08] Suzanne Hawkins. [1:37:09] Yes. [1:37:10] Jim Munn. [1:37:11] Refused. [1:37:12] Sean Barakar. [1:37:15] Yes. [1:37:16] Chris Tocken. [1:37:17] Yes. [1:37:18] Motion passes 6-0. [1:37:19] We have a light. [1:37:20] Rebecca Milsoyka. [1:37:21] Thank you, Mayor. [1:37:22] I do want to float in another amendment. [1:37:27] I really, I just feel strongly about not reducing any funding for Augur Falls. [1:37:32] And I know we have some groups that are so passionate and they put in a lot of time and effort. [1:37:36] And I really believe that money should be available to them since it was budgeted. [1:37:40] So I would amend it to not take the $25,000 from Augur Falls funding. [1:37:50] But take that from either reserves or contingency, whatever staff sees fit. [1:37:56] We have a motion on floor. [1:37:57] Second. [1:37:58] We have a motion on floor by Rebecca Milsorca, [1:38:00] seconded by Sean Berig. [1:38:02] Chris Talkington. [1:38:03] Dennis, didn't you indicate that that 25 [1:38:05] that's available as a result of a reduction from 50 to 25 [1:38:10] because of some of the volunteer? [1:38:12] What happened to current budget is $50,000 for trail development. [1:38:16] And originally, you know, give you a little more background [1:38:19] about agrofals, you know, I envision maybe some, you know, [1:38:22] like miles of paved trail, but I found out in really the beauty [1:38:25] It's not having it developed, you know, and with the mountain bike association, they have built those 16 to 20 miles of trails where, you know, a lot of stuff I thought we're going to be doing a lot of construction down there about building these trails and they [1:38:40] Mount bike association has built those trails. [1:38:43] Like I said, no really no charge to the city. [1:38:46] need some funds to get some materials to shore up some of their trails and I [1:38:51] believe that I thought cutting reducing the 50,000 down the 25,000 would still be [1:38:56] enough to help them to enhance our trails down there. So it's still needed? [1:39:04] It's still, yes, part of it is still needed. Yes. Not the 50,000, 25,000. Yes, [1:39:11] so again in your opinion the 25,000 could be appropriate for this year. [1:39:16] Yes, very good reduction of anything further on the amendment [1:39:22] Council the recent amendment here's where I I stand on I certainly don't want to see us reduce the amenities down there [1:39:30] However, this makes sense to me [1:39:32] We're pulling from from an area that we could save and I think government needs to do that more often instead of spend spend spend maybe we could [1:39:40] cut back and reallocate and that's kind of what we're looking here at here and I [1:39:46] think it's appropriate to reduce it by 25 so that's my perspective again this is [1:39:52] the amendment that Rebecca Milsoyka made seconded by John Barreger to put the [1:39:57] 25,000 back in to the other Falls trail enhancement the real call vote [1:40:05] Don Hall? No. Rebecca Milsoyka? Yes. Suzanne Hawkins? No. Sean Berriger? No. Chris [1:40:17] Tocquent? Yes. Greg Lanting? No. Motion passes 3-2. [1:40:26] Well, fails. 3-3, is it? No. 4-2. 2-4. 2-4. [1:40:32] Let me look. Yeah? Motion fails. I was thinking the other way around. 2-4. [1:40:38] So we are now moving to the main motion council, anything further on the main motion. [1:40:44] Leila roll call vote, please. [1:40:46] Rebecca Milsoica? [1:40:47] Yes. [1:40:49] Suzanne Hawkins? [1:40:50] Yes. [1:40:52] Sean Berger? [1:40:52] Yes. [1:40:53] Chris Tocquentine? [1:40:54] Yes. [1:40:55] Greg Lanthine? [1:40:56] Yes. [1:40:57] Don Hall? [1:40:58] Yes. [1:40:58] Motion passes 6-0. [1:41:00] Thank you, Dennis. [1:41:01] Thank you very much. [1:41:03] Go forward. [1:41:04] You understand what we agreed upon? [1:41:05] Yeah, I was right now, no, it's over. [1:41:08] Take port back in 30 minutes. [1:41:09] Well, yeah, I want to have the items. [1:41:11] I'll just do it. [1:41:13] All right, Council, we have a couple more items on the agenda. [1:41:17] It is 632. [1:41:19] Do you wish to take a short recess, [1:41:22] or do you want to forge ahead? [1:41:23] Looks like we have a lot of people here waiting. [1:41:26] Well, we always have people waiting. [1:41:28] I wish, go ahead. [1:41:28] Should everybody OK with forging ahead? [1:41:31] All right, we will now move to the next item. [1:41:33] is consideration of a request to approve [1:41:35] and adopt a new updated application packet [1:41:38] to be required for all special events [1:41:40] and or parades held within the city of Twin Falls. [1:41:43] And we have Staff Sergeant Denz-Pulham [1:41:45] from the award-winning Twin Falls Police Department. [1:41:48] Yes, yes, thank you. [1:41:50] Mayor Paul, City Council, I appreciate you taking the time [1:41:53] to hear me out on this. [1:41:55] As a lot of you know, I frequent a lot of the council meetings [1:41:59] with special events have over the last several years. [1:42:04] Throughout my time doing that, I've learned a few things and picked up a few ideas from [1:42:10] working within the city as well as from the people, our event organizers, which I'd also [1:42:15] like to thank. [1:42:16] We have some people here that do a lot of annual events, and so I appreciate all of them [1:42:21] coming out tonight as well. [1:42:24] Several years ago, when I was put into a traffic type position, one of my responsibilities [1:42:30] was to oversee the special event process. [1:42:33] staff started doing that. Our main concern was to make sure all of these events were done [1:42:39] safely. There were no security type issues. Everything would flow a long way. After about [1:42:47] a year or so of doing that, we started realizing the police, let me back up a little. The police [1:42:53] department has always brought as long as I can remember kind of overseeing this process. [1:42:59] forward again to this time period, we started realizing just on the police side of it, we [1:43:04] were approving applications allowing people to possibly violate city ordinances simply [1:43:08] because we didn't know that they were doing so. [1:43:11] So we started getting together with several employees from different entities within the [1:43:16] city such as the Parks Department, Fire Department, Planning and Zoning Building Department, several [1:43:23] different entities within our department to make sure that everybody was meeting the [1:43:27] criteria in order to have a safe event and not to violate any city ordinances. [1:43:34] While doing this we started tracking all the events that we were conducting, come to realize [1:43:39] we were doing well over 100 events a year that we were reviewing. [1:43:43] Currently we're averaging, kind of goes back and forth a little bit, but right out of 100 [1:43:48] events still that we review doesn't necessarily mean we bring all those to you, a lot of those [1:43:52] we can handle on our own without getting Council approval. [1:43:59] So, one of the other things that I want to point out with the history of these events, [1:44:07] especially in the last probably two years, we've noticed a huge increase in running type [1:44:12] of events and cycling, running walking, races, cycling events, a lot of these events is because [1:44:19] that is becoming more popular in this area as well as we have a lot of seniors in the [1:44:23] high schools that tackle these type of projects for their senior project and we've seen a [1:44:27] huge increase in that. [1:44:28] So that's kind of bringing our numbers up as far as what would follow into parade categories as well as we want to kind of keep that in mind. [1:44:36] Some of the things that I've kind of picked up on and learned over the past six, seven years, I'm not sure how long it's been. [1:44:44] One of the things is that we have the requirements and we need to get those requirements into a special event application as something that we haven't had in the past. [1:44:54] We've formed a better relationship, at least I feel that we've formed a better relationship [1:44:58] working with the citizens of the community because we're constantly talking to them, even [1:45:03] those that do an annual event every year, we have a pretty good rapport with them. [1:45:10] One of the things that I've picked up on is that we currently have two separate applications. [1:45:23] This is our special event application, and you've seen these come through and they've [1:45:27] probably been filled out. [1:45:28] But if you notice the first page, it's basically asked for the date, the location of the event, [1:45:33] and it has a couple of questions regarding alcohol use and public streets, and that's pretty much it. [1:45:38] The second page, the second page, it's simply asked for a brief description of the event, [1:45:46] and the whole rest of the page is where we meet and either approve or make recommendations [1:45:51] so we can get this approved. [1:45:53] This is one of the issues that we run into. [1:45:55] This application does not ask for any specific detail, [1:45:58] or does it explain any of the information, [1:46:01] or why we need that information. [1:46:08] This would be our current parade application. [1:46:11] It's pretty much the same way. [1:46:13] Notice you have three lines, about a third of the way down, [1:46:17] for you to describe the entire parade. [1:46:19] That doesn't go into a lot of detail [1:46:20] about the information we need, [1:46:22] requirements such as insurance, things along that line. [1:46:25] And this is just a one page application. [1:46:32] One of the things I don't know if you caught it on there, [1:46:35] that we've picked up on. [1:46:37] I don't know when it was started, but several years ago, [1:46:40] there was a $25 administrative fee attached [1:46:42] to all parade applications. [1:46:45] There is no fee attached to the special event applications [1:46:48] that always struck me odd. [1:46:50] I didn't know why we had that in place, [1:46:52] what little research I was able to do [1:46:55] with our finance people, asking around why we had that, [1:46:59] I was advised it's simply an administrative fee [1:47:02] that that money would go towards licensing [1:47:04] permits for whatever else they would use it for. One of the issues that we have, we [1:47:13] have two different time restrictions on these events. The parade application [1:47:17] asked for, there's several events floating around within the city. I don't [1:47:22] know how that started. I didn't know it. Some of them say you have two days to ten [1:47:29] days to notify the police department that you want to hold a parade. Others say it's [1:47:32] It's a 20-day time limit, others say it's a 45-day time limit. [1:47:36] So there's some discrepancies we've had there. [1:47:39] The current special event application we have, at this time, requires 45 days advance notice [1:47:45] to us so we can get the process going. [1:47:48] I will say that with what I've done in the past of 45 days of notification, if somebody [1:47:54] calls me and they're asking about what they need to do, I consider that their starting [1:47:58] point. [1:47:59] I don't wait until they actually hand the paper to us. [1:48:01] That helps them out because sometimes it takes several phone calls to get them lined [1:48:05] out, so we're pretty flexible with that. [1:48:08] I'll try to make this quick. [1:48:11] I know you guys have been here in a long time. [1:48:14] And as I said a while ago, the current applications we have, they don't provide the required information, [1:48:20] so with this new proposed application that I put in place, I think that will help us streamline [1:48:26] things a little. [1:48:27] I believe you all have a copy or was able to look at this special event application. [1:48:32] I want to show you these other two because they're very short, sweet, especially for the [1:48:35] people that are filling them out. [1:48:37] But it is an absolute nightmare for us on the city side of this. [1:48:43] I don't want to say I created an event application packet because I kind of stole it from other [1:48:48] cities. [1:48:49] I did contact several other cities throughout the state that are similar to Twin Falls [1:48:54] to kind of get idea what they were doing. [1:48:56] They all graciously sent me all of their information. [1:48:59] I started going through that. [1:49:00] kind of use the format of one using some of their information as well as putting most [1:49:06] of the information that we need into that packet as well. [1:49:11] One of the things that we do when we get these applications, all the city entities we will [1:49:16] meet, if we don't have a set schedule when we meet, we will set up a date when we get [1:49:22] three or four, six or eight, this is a busy time here, we should start receiving a lot [1:49:26] of applications. [1:49:27] We will sit down and go over these again, somebody for me or most city entities will discuss [1:49:33] if there's anything that needs to be done or if there's any special restrictions that [1:49:36] are required. [1:49:37] The new application, part of the link to that is explanations as to why we do that and for [1:49:43] each specific issue that comes up. [1:49:47] So we put this application together, it's 22 pages long. [1:49:50] I counted the pages correctly. [1:49:53] about 15 pages that are checklist or you have to provide brief narratives the rest of it [1:49:59] is simply instruction. [1:50:00] So when you look at this special event application, I mean it's pretty intimidating because it's [1:50:06] pretty thick and it's not two pages. [1:50:08] I did take the time yesterday, as you know I, last few years have done the National Night [1:50:13] Out event. [1:50:14] We have to do a special event application for that. [1:50:16] We're not exempt from that. [1:50:18] I filled this out yesterday. [1:50:19] Now, granted, I knew I didn't have to read the direction, [1:50:22] but it took me about right at 30 minutes to fill it out. [1:50:26] So it does take a little bit longer. [1:50:31] What we did to prepare for this, it's [1:50:33] been about a month or so ago, which we track and keep record [1:50:37] of the special events that we've done from year to year. [1:50:40] We contacted via mail all the annual event organizers, [1:50:48] which somewhere here today, and invited them [1:50:51] to a meeting that we held here in the council chambers [1:50:53] to go over this special event application packet. [1:50:57] That turned out pretty good because they pointed out [1:50:59] a couple things that I missed or that we needed [1:51:00] to correct and we made those corrections. [1:51:03] Again, for this meeting tonight, [1:51:05] we sent them letters again as well as we've notified [1:51:09] downtown business owners through a contact I have [1:51:12] she does one of the business owners. [1:51:14] She has a system set up to notify them [1:51:16] to invite them to the meeting as well tonight. [1:51:18] We've also put it on our, yes, she left, [1:51:22] and then he put it on our city website [1:51:24] that we're holding this meeting as well, [1:51:25] and also out through the media [1:51:27] so we can try to get more involvement [1:51:28] in the community with this. [1:51:31] So this new application packet, what it'll do, [1:51:34] it asks for more descriptions for site plans. [1:51:37] One thing that is new is we're asking [1:51:40] with your approval, the packet that people, [1:51:43] if it's a large gathering, we'll have a lost child booth. [1:51:45] That's something we've picked up on in the past, [1:51:48] but it's always an issue. [1:51:50] It will allow us to have better contact with the event organizers. [1:51:54] This packet also requires an emergency plan. [1:51:57] The emergency plan is based on, if they're required to have that, it's based on our decision [1:52:01] when we meet. [1:52:02] Or when I see this, if it's a large enough event, such as the City Park, they have a huge [1:52:07] event there. [1:52:08] We would have to have a plan for this. [1:52:11] Talks about catering permits. [1:52:12] A lot of people confuse the catering permits with food. [1:52:15] It has nothing to do with food. [1:52:16] It's alcohol related. [1:52:17] But it explains this. [1:52:19] about liability insurance. [1:52:21] One thing that's not really a change, but it's not written. [1:52:24] One of the things we've added in here is designated parade routes. [1:52:29] You know, all of our parades go down Main Street except for western days parade, [1:52:33] and I think we've got western days, community people here. [1:52:36] So we're asking to kind of finalize this, [1:52:40] that all parades will be on Main Street from Muerta Street to [1:52:46] get our passport, yeah, somewhere down there on that end. [1:52:50] And that's pretty much what we have on the outside for western days, western days of pool [1:52:55] It shows and there as well [1:52:56] It'll be held on blue lakes [1:52:58] We also have the ability if we have somebody that wants to do a parade elsewhere [1:53:02] We can meet discuss that and we can make those arrangements if necessary [1:53:05] We would like to try to focus all of them there as well as parades [1:53:09] I'm a lot of people aren't in or unaware [1:53:12] Rob walking events running events cycling events those fall under a parade application [1:53:16] location. We were asking that all walking and running events be held on the city walking [1:53:22] trails for safety reasons, mainly safety from traffic related issues or private property [1:53:28] with written permission. The first thing that pops in my mind, a lot of people will use a [1:53:32] CSI walking trail or parks if that may be the case. [1:53:37] That's likely to be an event, obviously. I would not work. We asked for a trash plan to [1:53:43] we put in here against something else that we always ask for, clean up plans, medical [1:53:48] staging area, that's not something we've asked for at a lot of events. Again, depending [1:53:52] on the size of the event, that's something we're going to have as an area for ed-ed paramedics [1:53:57] to be on site. We hope to, speaking with our media, people with the city, once this is approved, [1:54:08] We're going to have this on our website so people can access it there, I've been advised [1:54:15] we can do that as well as they can fill it out and return it back through email or they [1:54:20] can print it off whatever the case may be. [1:54:22] My recommendation to them would be to do something where they can save it and use it [1:54:27] from year to year and that's how I get through all my agendas for council meetings. [1:54:30] They don't take me long anymore to do them so that's changed the dates and the names. [1:54:36] But that would be an option for them as well as I can come down and pick one up in the police department. [1:54:44] Let's see what else do we have on here. [1:54:47] The one thing that I want to point out, reference the fees. [1:54:53] I've prepared, I've gone over the city ordinances, there'll be some changes for [1:54:57] all the special events, they're not major changes, they're very minor, but this would create a couple of changes. [1:55:03] One of the things we have in there in this application is a $50 fee. [1:55:09] I know that can be controversial. [1:55:12] I want to point out it does not matter to me what we do if we have a fee or [1:55:16] way the fee or if we reduce it to the $25 or if we increase that. [1:55:22] I believe that's a decision that the council would need to make. [1:55:27] With that being said, I guess I'm open for questions if you have any questions. [1:55:33] questions. We have several lights on. I also see Travis is raising his hand. So I'll go to him next. However, I do want to say that [1:55:41] there's members of the public here that I'm going to give an opportunity to come forward if they would like to say a few words. Keep it kind of brief. [1:55:48] Just a quick reminder on the Idaho code when it comes to raising fees because any fee that would occur tonight, if you followed the [1:55:56] recommendation of Staff Sergeant Poland, that would require a public hearing because it's [1:56:01] greater than 5% or if you were to create a fee for the parades or the parade-like things [1:56:05] that do not, as Dennis had described earlier, that would also require a public hearing moving [1:56:10] forward. [1:56:11] Great clarification. [1:56:12] Thank you, Travis. [1:56:13] Chris Dutton. [1:56:14] Really good job on killing trees and making this much longer but also more thorough. [1:56:20] So that is much needed. [1:56:22] On page 17, getting with the insurance and demdification and the hold harmless for the city, I'm only [1:56:29] a little bit concerned about the half million dollar single limit insurance policy. [1:56:37] Let me say that I'm familiar with a number of non-profit charities that run like crop walk [1:56:44] and muscular dystrophy, but they also be required to post this half million dollar bond or insurance. [1:56:52] We, that's a really good question, as I spoke earlier, when we first started this, we kind [1:56:57] of had a gray area where we would make the decision if somebody had to pay the fee and [1:57:05] or if they had to provide the insurance, we realized that gray area was causing problems [1:57:09] because it was difficult for us to make the decision saying you got to pay but you don't [1:57:15] have to pay. [1:57:16] That time we started I believe for the city's certificate of liability insurance for the last several years. We have required that [1:57:24] It's a five hundred thousand dollar policy and [1:57:29] Please don't hold me to this I've checked on this a couple of times for events that I've been involved in [1:57:35] And maybe some of our guests here tonight can answer that a [1:57:39] $500,000 policy is like a hundred and fifty to two hundred dollars [1:57:44] It kind of depends on the event and what's taking place there of foods being served and things along that line [1:57:50] I think we need to have that just for the city's protection [1:57:53] I and I believe we might also be required to have that [1:57:55] I'm not sure I don't think we would have an option for the insurance well [1:57:59] I I'd like to address just the nonprofit piece [1:58:01] We routinely at the Boys and Girls Club when I ran the fence we had that in in place [1:58:06] We just went out and got the insurance because it's necessary Travis. Did you want to weigh in? Yeah, mr. [1:58:11] If you take a look at agenda packet item number four that was included, [1:58:17] it has the series of code citations and references that are included in the code. [1:58:22] It's on page three and city code three dash six dash four permit applications fees, insurance, and indemnification. [1:58:29] Subsection E states that all applicants shall submit with application and [1:58:34] maintain at least until the conclusion of the special event a comprehensive general liability policy in the amount of $500,000 [1:58:41] of the City of Twin Falls, of Twin Falls County, Highway District or both depending upon the location of the special event named as the certificate holder and so forth. [1:58:51] That part of the code was amended by Ordinance number 2986 in June of 2010. [1:59:03] Well, I guess I would have to say if I understood you, Sergeant, you said you wanted to have the internal flexibility whether to require that half million. [1:59:12] I'm sorry not on the insurance. Okay on the fee that permit fee. Yeah, the fee charge [1:59:19] That's fine with me, but I wouldn't want to put that responsibility on you to decide yes on this and on the other and if it's only [1:59:26] 150 that's affordable [1:59:29] And it doesn't sound like a bad choice what it was a couple years ago [1:59:32] I have no idea what it is now, so and it depends on your organization how often you get the I mean [1:59:36] There's a lot of one thing we've found to a lot of these businesses that spawns for events [1:59:41] that they use their business policy and so it's already there. [1:59:44] Yeah. [1:59:45] Thank you. [1:59:46] Rebecca Melsoit. [1:59:47] Thank you, Mayor. [1:59:48] Well, I want to commend you, Staff Sergeant Pullen, for doing all this work and writing this [1:59:54] all out because it opens our eyes to the amount of effort and staff time that goes into approving [2:00:01] each of these special event applications. [2:00:04] And I actually believe that the additional paperwork will save you some staff time and it [2:00:09] will actually help the applicants know what information needs to be presented up front, [2:00:16] which I find helpful when I'm applying for something, so that way you don't send them [2:00:20] back to get additional information over and over. [2:00:23] So I think this is a significant improvement over our current process, and it really just [2:00:29] puts into writing all the work that you all do. [2:00:33] I do have a concern about a standard flat fee, because as we were referencing, you know, [2:00:40] most of our events, what it seems like most of our events are local events that either fundraise [2:00:47] or raise awareness, and I certainly wouldn't want to unnecessarily burden those local events and possibly, [2:00:56] you know, prohibit them from happening. I know that there are a couple of events in the park [2:01:02] that raise money for schools, that raise money for, you know, special Olympics and so on and so forth. [2:01:07] I think it would be helpful to distinguish between events of a commercial nature versus events that are fundraisers or non-profit. [2:01:18] I don't use the non-profit in the technical definition of whether you're a nonprofit or not, [2:01:23] but just whether you're fundraising or doing an event for awareness. [2:01:27] I think somewhere along that line, we need to make a determination between those two types [2:01:35] of events. [2:01:37] I also think that each event is unique in its scale and its size, and so a $50 fee for one [2:01:45] event really may not be adequate for the amount of time and effort that's going into, staff [2:01:50] time and effort that's going into monitoring and processing that event. [2:01:56] I don't know what kind of scale you might recommend for us to use, [2:02:03] but I'm just feeling that a one-size-fits-all fee might not be the best approach here. [2:02:09] And we should determine between commercial events and non-commercial events. [2:02:15] Thank you, Rebecca. [2:02:17] Sean Berger. [2:02:21] I too was not super excited about the tree. [2:02:26] But I do think, as was said before, the fact that all the information and instructions [2:02:33] are here, it really isn't any more information than was being provided previously. [2:02:38] It's just more easy to follow and understand process. [2:02:42] So a couple of observations I have. [2:02:44] I notice in the introduction, it never talks about special events having to come to the [2:02:51] City Council for approval. [2:02:53] as per process. [2:02:54] And so I thought that that might be something to include. [2:02:57] It talks about permits having to be approved and submitted two weeks prior to the event, [2:03:02] but it doesn't explain that there's a council component to that. [2:03:05] And I know that has created some challenges previously with last-minute stuff trying [2:03:10] to get in, and it doesn't make the agenda. [2:03:12] So just a suggestion that maybe that should be included in the process. [2:03:16] And the other observation I have, and I'll pose it as a question. [2:03:21] So on page five it talks about running and walking events being held on City of Twin Falls walking trails are on private property only [2:03:32] So I appreciate the encouragement to use the trails and the desire to keep [2:03:38] Those events off of streets, but I don't know how practical that is [2:03:42] So the example I'll use is actually an event that we hosted at the chamber last year at the color dash [2:03:47] So a majority of it was on the trail system [2:03:51] But we did have to get onto the street a couple of times. [2:03:55] Correct. [2:03:56] And I just think, and so in the western days half marathon has held on streets. [2:04:05] I just don't know how feasible it is to try to get 5k and 10k events exclusively on the trail system. [2:04:14] I think we could encourage people to do that. [2:04:17] But requiring it is challenging for me. [2:04:20] That's kind of what we're trying to do here, is encourage people to do that. [2:04:26] You're right when we have larger events, but what they have to realize is those are taking [2:04:29] city resources. [2:04:30] When we have to send police officers out there to direct traffic, and everybody's been pretty [2:04:35] good to deal with over the last couple of years on this one, this we've seen this large [2:04:39] increase. [2:04:40] They have to understand that it's not something we budget for. [2:04:43] More often than not, it's going to be an over time issue for the police department, so [2:04:47] because we're going to have to call somebody in to just simply be out there to make sure [2:04:50] that they're safe. [2:04:54] My intent was to do just, as you said, we want people to use the walking trails. [2:04:58] I know a lot of times out in the chamber area, there's only one street they have to cross. [2:05:04] And if that's the case, we don't have to be there, as long as we know who's going to [2:05:09] be there to provide the traffic control, we kind of talk to that person, you know, and [2:05:13] tell them how to do it, what to watch for, so when people are crossing the street, they're [2:05:17] We're not going to run over a lot of times we see people that are running or cycling. [2:05:21] They're going to go through that stop center across the road and the traffic just needs to stop forming. [2:05:26] That's not always what happens. [2:05:27] So we got to let the flaggers know, so we kind of train them, we try to tell the people in the event. [2:05:32] That's what we try to encourage them to do at private property or these other areas just for that reason. [2:05:38] It's better for them cost wise. [2:05:42] We have looked at using some private traffic control companies in the area. [2:05:47] Sometimes that works, sometimes it creates more work for us. [2:05:50] So that's kind of up and down in that area. [2:05:52] So we'll explore those options. [2:05:54] That's kind of our main focus. [2:05:55] We want it to be safe. [2:05:56] We're trying to keep people off the visitor streets. [2:05:58] And then I think too, with the component that talks about, [2:06:01] you know, extraordinary resources and those types of things. [2:06:04] I mean, if someone's going to do a 10K race and it's on busy streets, [2:06:08] then they have to understand that if there are city resources committed to that, [2:06:11] there's a cost associated. [2:06:13] So, I just, I know that it felt like it was saying that's the only place you can have one. [2:06:18] So, if the intent is to encourage that, then I think that's fantastic. [2:06:23] What does it say, Sean? [2:06:25] Just real quick, does it say, shall and? [2:06:26] It says all running walking events will be held on the City of Twin Falls walking trails [2:06:30] around private property with approved written consent from the owner of the private property. [2:06:34] I think it does talk about in here, though, that you can submit maps for events and that [2:06:40] will be approved by the committee and so forth. [2:06:42] Yes, we still have, I know there's a section in there of special praise and that we can still approve and be held elsewhere. [2:06:48] And then just one last comment and then I'll be quiet. [2:06:51] In reference a little bit to Rebecca's comments about the permit fee. [2:06:55] Truthfully, I don't have an issue with the application fee because in my mind what that's covering is the application process. [2:07:02] It's not covering the impact of the actual event later. [2:07:06] That's being taken care of by, so for example, the scope and scale of western days [2:07:11] as opposed to the scope and scale of the crop walk. [2:07:14] The paperwork is probably still in the same neighborhood, [2:07:18] but the events are two different things [2:07:21] and that's allocated for appropriately. [2:07:23] So, I mean, $50 maybe a little steep. [2:07:26] Maybe there is a threshold of, you know, [2:07:27] if you're gonna have, well, actually, you know, [2:07:30] if you're gonna have 100 people show up for the crop walk [2:07:33] and it's all in private property, [2:07:34] you're gonna have to do one of these. [2:07:36] Correct. [2:07:37] So maybe some of those events actually [2:07:39] We will get taken care of that way, so just an observation. [2:07:42] Suzanne Hawkins. [2:07:44] Thank you. [2:07:44] Two questions. [2:07:45] First one's for Travis. [2:07:46] The fees we collect on these, does it just [2:07:48] go into the general budget? [2:07:50] So that's how it's absorbed. [2:07:52] And I'm just curious, how did you come up with the $50 fee? [2:07:56] Was there any logic behind that? [2:07:58] Absolutely none. [2:08:00] Sounded like a good enough time. [2:08:01] I just wanted to bring the two of them together. [2:08:03] I knew the $25 fee had been in place [2:08:06] since about the time I started working here. [2:08:09] I just made an assumption, and maybe I should now. [2:08:13] I regretted it after I put it in. [2:08:15] No, just on average, and I know it's hard [2:08:18] about how many man hours go into processing [2:08:20] one of these applications. [2:08:22] Well, I think it'd be easily, or be safe to say that [2:08:27] when we meet with all of our people, [2:08:30] and I can give you a breakdown of which groups are, [2:08:32] if you like, there's generally, if we're all there, [2:08:34] there's A know us. [2:08:36] And like I said, we'll wait until we have [2:08:37] two or three applications. [2:08:40] Sometimes if we just have one, [2:08:41] I'll just drive it around wherever we have to go to [2:08:44] because it's quicker that way. [2:08:46] And it doesn't pull everybody else out of their office. [2:08:48] Eight people figure at least an hour. [2:08:51] That's just for us to look at this [2:08:52] to see if there's anything we gotta do to fix it. [2:08:54] In the past, sometimes I'll spend 10 minutes [2:08:58] contacting people to get all this same information [2:09:01] that we have to have. [2:09:02] Sometimes, I might make two or three calls a day [2:09:06] for several days have to meet with them, depending on the skill of the event. [2:09:10] Western days will work really well with them. [2:09:12] We will actually go to a couple of their meetings with their people, so [2:09:16] they vary greatly, so it would be hard to put an exact time frame. [2:09:20] But I would say a minimum of take count each person's time and minimum of eight [2:09:25] hours for the meeting, then whatever it takes us on the police side of it to get it through. [2:09:30] Thank you. [2:09:31] Couple comments that I have is, first of all, I'd like to see us move towards [2:09:36] Automation of this application that somebody can go online and just fill it out and hit send [2:09:42] Certainly, I know that I'm working at Tammy [2:09:45] That that's a possibility depending on the you know the folks that be put that together [2:09:51] But I think in today's age I mean we do that with everything [2:09:55] So I think that would be very very convenient with folks number two is the amount for the application for you [2:10:01] I'm I like the idea of having an application fee because it shows skin in the game if you will [2:10:06] people that are going to put on an event, I think 50 bucks is a little bit steep for me, my comfort level, I like the idea of maybe 25. [2:10:14] But it sounds like no matter what we do with that, it's going to have to be a public hearing because the 25 is just for parades. [2:10:21] We've never had an application fee for the other events, so we'd have to go through the process of doing public hearing, changing ordinance, all that kind of stuff anyway. [2:10:33] stuff anyway, but that's where I'm at. 25 is a little more in line for our community for [2:10:42] me. And then I think Sean's right, if it's a big event, all those other costs, police services [2:10:49] and all those things will be taken consideration and folks will have to pony up for those events [2:10:54] or private security, whatever you deem necessary. There's one more point that I wanted to make, [2:11:02] It just escaped me must been all that canal water. I drank [2:11:17] Well, I would move would that we approve the new application less a discussion on the fee [2:11:23] I would have to do that later anyway. [2:11:28] So my motion would be to approve the new special events application. [2:11:33] Second. [2:11:34] And motion on floor by Jim Munn, seconded by Sean Berger to approve the new application [2:11:40] packet. [2:11:41] You know, I would like to ask permission from the motion makers to the oversight of our [2:11:51] part. [2:11:52] Well, that's my fault too. [2:11:53] I should have stopped you. [2:11:54] reminding me of that. If it's okay with the motion maker as well as the second, we'll go ahead and [2:12:01] set down the motion and ask anyone from the public if they'd like to come forward and [2:12:08] give us some input about this application process. After all of that, one of you have to come forward, [2:12:15] at least very good Diane. [2:12:19] Steve was at your beck and call. [2:12:26] The discussion about will use windfalls, bike paths and walking paths. [2:12:34] I thought about the rim to rim race and the complications that that would provide there. [2:12:41] As far as chopping down trees for the paper, for those of us who deal with paper rather than electronics, just printed on both sides of the paper, and then the electronics for those of us who are caught in between, the electronics makes perfect sense. [2:12:57] Very good. Thank you, Ms. Woodson. Anyone else would like to come forward? When you come forward, if you just state your name, that would be great. [2:13:06] I'm Twilight Knudson and I represent the classic cruiser car club. [2:13:14] I don't, I haven't seen this. [2:13:16] I was out of town on the last meeting and I agree we probably should have more than, you [2:13:23] know, those two pages were kind of, but I do like filling them out bigger than 30 minutes. [2:13:31] But I guess, I don't know if it's on the application or not, what's really been a problem with us [2:13:37] is we have to get on the state schedule for our car shows. [2:13:42] So we have to have that in by December that I come to you [2:13:48] and you only approve it the month before. [2:13:52] Well, in the meantime, I've got 120 applications. [2:13:55] The car is coming to my car show. [2:13:58] Is there any way we can deal with that? [2:14:01] Because like Dennis said, he said, well, [2:14:04] Some applications he brings to you and somebody just to prove. [2:14:09] That's been my biggest worry every year [2:14:12] when I come into your meeting and I'm sitting here thinking, [2:14:16] what if they say no? [2:14:18] I will clarify, correct me if I'm wrong, Dennis or Travis, [2:14:21] that if it's an ongoing event where we haven't had issues [2:14:25] with that just goes more on the consent calendar. [2:14:28] If it's a new event, alcohol serve, maybe we've had some challenges [2:14:33] with that event in the past, that actually comes to the council for a presentation. [2:14:36] Is that correct? [2:14:37] Yes. [2:14:38] Okay. [2:14:39] Travis. [2:14:40] I think it also in terms of the timing, I think it's important to recognize that events [2:14:44] can be approved a year out, no more than a year out and no sooner than 45 days to the event. [2:14:50] So we could place that on the calendar with a completed packet much sooner than just the [2:14:57] one month before to accommodate those events that need those longer time planning horizons. [2:15:04] How does that sound, Twilight? [2:15:06] That sounds wonderful because that's always been my biggest fear. [2:15:09] You know, I come in here and I know you're going to prove it because we don't really, you know. [2:15:15] You guys are pretty radical. [2:15:17] I know, especially they're all our age group. [2:15:20] But, you know, we do not encourage the burnouts. [2:15:24] In fact, last year, there were a couple down on Main Street, [2:15:29] and I had their cell phone numbers, and I called them up, [2:15:32] and I said, bring a car back in Parkett. [2:15:35] Well, I was called a few choice names, [2:15:38] but we have little kids there, we have older people, [2:15:42] we have some of those cars, if they hit one of those cars. [2:15:46] You know, I mean, not only the damage, they also did. [2:15:50] You know, because the owner would. [2:15:52] But, you know, that's always just been my biggest fears to come in here and, you know, worry about. [2:16:02] Sounds like we have that alleviated now. [2:16:04] Great. [2:16:05] Thank you very much for your input tonight. [2:16:07] Is there anyone else that would like to come forward? [2:16:12] From the floodgeeks. [2:16:14] Hi there. [2:16:17] My name is Diane Jellovich and I'm with the CSI Harvesting Festival. [2:16:20] And I want to just say that putting this electronically would be just marvelous because we do our [2:16:26] event this year, 37th year, and just to go in and change the date, submit would be just [2:16:33] wonderful. [2:16:34] So, and I appreciate the police department inviting us to come to this as well in the [2:16:39] communication. [2:16:40] So, thank you very much. [2:16:41] Thank you, Diane. [2:16:42] Anyone else? [2:16:43] Chief Horry, did you? [2:16:46] Oh, not the citizen. [2:16:47] and then the general white chair. [2:16:49] Okay. [2:16:50] Hi, my name is Barb Barnes. [2:16:52] I'm chairman of the Twin Falls Western Days Parade, [2:16:55] and I'd really like to thank you for all your help with us, [2:16:57] and we couldn't do it without all the police support. [2:17:02] Of course, you know that it's huge. [2:17:05] I did want to make one thing. [2:17:07] We've had a little issue with the half-K run [2:17:11] that you mentioned. [2:17:12] It really isn't associated with Western Days, [2:17:14] And there's been a some disc hern, [2:17:19] disc hern over that. [2:17:20] I go through a lot of process to get that route [2:17:23] with the state of Idaho. [2:17:25] And it's my understanding that they don't, [2:17:27] but they use our route. [2:17:30] And I've been worried, [2:17:31] because I know someone got hurt during that event [2:17:34] a couple of years ago quite seriously. [2:17:37] So this is a really good idea. [2:17:38] Thank you. [2:17:39] I'm sorry, Mr. Meeting, but appreciate it. [2:17:42] Thank you, ma'am. [2:17:50] I'm Sherry Wright, and on behalf of Christmas and the nighttime sky, one of the things that [2:17:58] we've always been grateful for is coming before the council and getting their approval for [2:18:04] the event. [2:18:05] This will be our 25th annual, and it is a nonprofit. [2:18:08] So we would like to, for all the nonprofits out there, just keep that into consideration [2:18:16] Because other than the money for the fireworks, [2:18:20] everything else is volunteers all the way down to Santa Claus. [2:18:26] And I've looked through the 22 pages [2:18:28] and I was a bit overwhelmed. [2:18:32] And I just wondered if everybody was going to be held [2:18:34] to the same standards, like probably depending [2:18:37] on the amount of people, like say for instance the lost child [2:18:42] booth. [2:18:45] Somebody's in our office at all times anyway, [2:18:47] answering the phones for people that are concerned, what time does the event start? [2:18:52] So that's not an issue for us. [2:18:56] One of the things that was on there was about having vests or something for specially marked [2:19:02] volunteers for security. [2:19:06] So I didn't know if we were all supposed to. [2:19:09] Everybody that was a volunteer needed to have safety vests or something or shirts that said [2:19:14] volunteers? [2:19:15] I don't think that's the intent, but as Chief Mundt says, [2:19:19] that probably if you're in a safety position like in the street, [2:19:22] doing some guidance, those kind of things, [2:19:23] that's probably a great idea just for their safety. [2:19:26] But I think that's something you can work out [2:19:27] with Staff Sergeant Pullen through the process. [2:19:31] Okay. [2:19:33] He's been wonderful to work with. [2:19:34] Very good. [2:19:36] Thank you. [2:19:36] Thank you. [2:19:37] Sure, appreciate it. [2:19:39] Anyone else? [2:19:40] Cheap prayer, look like you wanted to say a couple words. [2:19:43] Thank you, Mayor. [2:19:44] I just wanted to get some clarification. [2:19:45] before you actually move on to motion. [2:19:49] Pinch five, summary of events. [2:19:51] There was some discussion, even some concern, [2:19:54] on the language for all running and walking events [2:19:57] will be held. [2:19:58] And I just want to offer that if the council [2:20:04] is grants authorization, we will work on that language [2:20:09] to reflect. [2:20:11] We encourage, but we'll also work with event organizers [2:20:15] understanding that maybe not all the events like the Playa Cader on Western [2:20:18] days can't be held on a walking trail. [2:20:20] Thank you, Chief. I think probably some language like we strongly encourage might be [2:20:26] in my motion. Who's my second? [2:20:28] Sean Berger, or was it okay with that? [2:20:30] I would say we changed that to more permissive language. [2:20:34] So if you actually read this sentence right after that, it talks about all [2:20:38] cycling events requiring a detailed mapping and approval by the Special Events [2:20:42] coordination team, I would suggest the same kind of language that we encourage you to use the trail system, but if you're not, you need a detailed map and approval by the committee. [2:20:55] Actually, on a cycling event with the traffic, we would require that for safety reasons. [2:21:00] For the running event. [2:21:04] But I think requiring them to say here's the map and here's where I want to go and submitting [2:21:09] that then you can say that's fine you're running on you know can and crash drive at seven o'clock [2:21:15] in the morning when no one's there so that's fine. [2:21:20] I would think that we would need a map otherwise we're going back to the current status right [2:21:24] now I'm going to be on the phone calling them trying to fit maybe I'm misunderstanding your [2:21:28] career. [2:21:29] So what I'm saying is when you're talking about the walking and running events the language [2:21:33] could say you're encouraged to use the trail system but if you're not, a detailed map and [2:21:39] approval by the committee is required the same as the cycling units. [2:21:43] Okay, gotcha. [2:21:45] So that language could be incorporated in both directions and the maker of the motion, is [2:21:49] that your intent to put that in? [2:21:51] Yes, Mayor. [2:21:52] Very good. [2:21:53] Second, are you good with that? [2:21:54] Yes, please. [2:21:55] Anything further on the motion that we have in front of us? [2:21:57] Be it a roll call, please. [2:22:00] Suzanne Hawkins? [2:22:01] Yes. [2:22:02] Jim Munn? [2:22:03] Yes. [2:22:04] talking to Greg Lansing. Yes, Don Hall. Yes, for Beckman. Yes, [2:22:09] motion passes seven to zero. Thank you, Dennis. And thank you, [2:22:12] chief. Moving on to the next item. This shouldn't take very long. I [2:22:16] hope is a discussion on the state of the city. Basically, in a [2:22:20] nutshell, Travis and I've been visiting about this. Obviously, [2:22:23] every year we do a state of the city, this goes back a few years [2:22:26] that we started this. And we would like to engage the the [2:22:31] Council, if this will work. We were thinking about maybe Travis and I, tag teaming the [2:22:38] actual presentation of the state of the city and then towards or having some place in there [2:22:44] for Q&A and then engaging the council members during that time, unless you want to see it [2:22:49] go a different direction. [2:22:51] Just a public format you're talking about? [2:22:54] Public format, remember how we do the state city every year? We're probably going to be [2:22:57] be at the Stone House again and that work for our council. [2:23:03] Yes. [2:23:04] Rebecca Milsuk. [2:23:05] I think that works great. [2:23:06] I think the ones in the past that have had more public interaction and more public involvement, [2:23:12] I think have been more successful. [2:23:13] So if we could keep our speeches and our presentations to maybe a third of the time and then leave [2:23:19] majority of the time for the citizens. [2:23:21] And I think in the past what they've done is going to have someone to emcee it and have [2:23:25] pre-written questions in case there aren't any from the audience, but I really find the time that we have [2:23:31] answering questions with the community is more valuable than our great speeches. [2:23:36] I think it's just going to be a challenge because you have a city manager and a mayor talking, but I think we can [2:23:41] tremor down about a third of it and make that work. But your point's well taken and I think that public input is [2:23:48] really important and to have some sort of moderator, whether that's one of us, to field the questions and maybe have them go towards a [2:23:55] particular council member, but we have time to answer what we have time to answer. [2:24:00] Anything further on that? Sounds like it's a deal. [2:24:05] The next item on the agenda is public input and or items for city manager, city council. [2:24:09] So we'll start with the public again. Is there anyone from the public that would like to address the council? [2:24:15] City manager, anything further? [2:24:17] Mr. Mayor, members of the council, just two things. [2:24:20] Remember, this week is the Chamber of Commerce Banquet that is often attended. [2:24:26] If you'd like to attend, please get that information to Leila ASAP if there is still room. [2:24:35] And so typically the event gets pretty full, so we want to make sure that you get that RSVP in. [2:24:42] Second is we, as you know, we kind of construct agendas about a month to a month and a half out. [2:24:49] And we're looking to see whether or not we'll have a quorum at the March 23 meeting that is the first Monday of spring break. [2:25:00] And so as we're kind of setting that legislative agenda, we want to see if we would have a quorum of the council. [2:25:07] And if we still had a quorum, if there was a desire to meet, typically what happens for those larger pending issues. [2:25:15] We recognize that members of the council are going to be gone. [2:25:17] We'll hold those and place those on a subsequent meeting. [2:25:21] I guess we'll just pull the council. [2:25:22] Anyone going to be gone or not able to attend that meeting [2:25:26] Monday night, first spring break? [2:25:28] One out. [2:25:30] One out. [2:25:31] One out. [2:25:32] One out. [2:25:33] Two out. [2:25:37] We have five members, so it looks like we would be able [2:25:39] to hold a meeting, but you're exactly right. [2:25:42] So maybe some of the larger items we put to a different. [2:25:46] Yeah, and we've already made a commitment not to hold public hearings on that evening, [2:25:49] but we will also be looking back at a more of a scaled back meeting depending upon the issues that emerge. [2:25:56] Mary Goode, thank you, Travis. Anything further from me? [2:25:59] City Council, Chris Stockton? [2:26:01] Well, this weekend I took an opportunity to review the three proposed for approved building school sites in Twin Falls. [2:26:08] And I just wonder where you get to write my impression. [2:26:11] I think most of you have looked at the one on Federation Road or drive. [2:26:15] but that's a safety issue. [2:26:18] And I think the council really needs to ensure [2:26:20] that we're on the leading edge of the curve [2:26:23] with the city that they, or with the school district, excuse me, [2:26:28] that they fulfill not only their good intentions, [2:26:34] but evidence to the city that access to that school is provided. [2:26:40] As you may or may not be aware of the North South Road [2:26:43] grand view and it connects between pole line and what I call the gun club road. I'm not [2:26:49] sure what it is, but Federation is several hundred feet from punching through to grand [2:26:55] view. I know we've spoken about it in general terms, but I would like to really suggest that [2:27:01] we insist that this school district tell us as soon as possible or by an unspecified deadline [2:27:08] what they're doing to provide access for all the traffic that is going to really I think [2:27:15] flow down that street as much as anything. Thank you Chris I think Greg wants weigh in on that. [2:27:20] Yes I also went out and took a look at it just to and it does appear that the road is being [2:27:27] constructed to the west edge of northern passage number two which is a section that wasn't there [2:27:34] It only comes that street and it goes there. [2:27:37] And with Mr. Nielsen's commitment to taking even further on his side, [2:27:44] at least his half, and Sean actually had a good idea that maybe we could have him [2:27:47] complete the middle and then he won't work. [2:27:52] All right, so that leaves us about, as I measured it with Jonathan Spindlove [2:27:59] from our planning department. [2:28:02] I think the leaves is about 800 feet, that is not there. [2:28:06] And I do believe that just for economies of scale, [2:28:08] I think that Mr. Nielsen was going to contact the owners [2:28:12] on the north side just to see whether, [2:28:14] because if they were doing it together, [2:28:17] they could probably get a better deal out of the construction [2:28:19] than leaving it there, because they will have to, [2:28:21] we're about 800 feet apart, but that's still 800 feet. [2:28:24] And that we're going to have to figure out [2:28:27] what we'll do, we'll put it in the requirement, [2:28:31] I see us putting in a plan on the requirement for the temporary trail and that but that doesn't take care of the traffic [2:28:38] So we'll just have to kind of watch that fluid and then like I said keep the lead on it and see whether our planning department can [2:28:44] Cokes [2:28:46] Maybe I was to put the road in center then they may have anticipated. Yeah, I'd say [2:28:52] Shower and the will instead of me [2:28:54] Well, we have a little trouble making the school district build a road that's not on their property [2:28:58] I'm sorry it's a safety issue though for access of hospital, police and fire and I think we have very [2:29:04] I'm willing to coax the developers who were gonna have to build sooner or later [2:29:07] But I'm not willing to cause this cool district pay a couple million hours [2:29:11] Maybe we'll turn it over to Travis for a moment. He has maybe some ideas [2:29:15] This is rough weather [2:29:17] so as we shared at the last meeting making it is a condition of the SUP is a very appropriate place and [2:29:23] if the SUP is not [2:29:25] If all the elements of the SUP are not fulfilled, then the occupancy permit is not provided. [2:29:35] So staff has heard and we will work and we also know there are a couple members of the [2:29:41] Planning and Zoning Commission here still that will probably also be able to carry that [2:29:46] message since the SUP will land at the Planning and Zoning Commission and will only come [2:29:52] to the City Council should there be an appeal. [2:29:56] And the City Council has the ability to appeal that decision and have a hearing moving forward. [2:30:01] Thank you Travis. [2:30:02] I think that gives us some clarification. [2:30:03] I think it's a point while talking. [2:30:05] Thank you Chris. [2:30:06] Greg Lanning. [2:30:07] I would like to ask, this is what I've seen here in a few of the council with frets on [2:30:13] this whether or not, I think whether we even have legally the ability to force the school [2:30:20] district to put the road through this number one. [2:30:22] And I'm not saying that I'd be willing to vote for that, [2:30:24] but I'm not sure we have the legal ability to do that, [2:30:27] but I figured they could give us that information. [2:30:33] Travis, do you want to answer that, [2:30:34] or do you want to give us a further? [2:30:35] I think you have the answer. [2:30:38] So we'll consult our legal counsel. [2:30:40] Okay, very good. [2:30:42] And then get back to us. [2:30:43] I appreciate it. [2:30:44] Good place to lay that. [2:30:45] Anyone from anyone else from the city council? [2:30:49] All right, the next item on the agenda, [2:30:50] obviously is in juris into executive session. [2:30:53] If you choose to do so counsel, it's Executive Session 67-23-45-1B to consider the evaluation [2:31:00] dismiss or disciplining up or to hear complaints or charges brought against a public officer, [2:31:06] employee, staff member or individual agent or public school student. [2:31:13] I'll stand for motion on there. [2:31:17] I move that we, I'm sorry. [2:31:18] No, you got it. [2:31:19] Suzanne Hawkins. [2:31:21] A move we adjourn into executive session under the conditions you just read. [2:31:27] So we have a motion on the floor by Suzanne Hawkins, seconded by Greg Lanting to move into executive session. [2:31:32] I want to mention that before we do this, that we will not be coming back out and meeting again this evening. [2:31:40] So just let you know that. [2:31:43] We have a roll call vote, please. [2:31:45] Jim Munn. [2:31:46] Yes. [2:31:48] Sean Berriger. [2:31:48] Yes. [2:31:49] Chris Chocking. [2:31:50] Yes. [2:31:50] Greg Lanting. [2:31:51] Yes. [2:31:51] Don Hall. [2:31:52] Yes. [2:31:53] Yes, Suzanne Hunter, yes, motion passes seven to zero. [2:31:58] We will be moving into executive session.