Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2015-02-02, recording 1 (started 17:00) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2015-02-02/ [0:05:59] I'd like to call the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council to order. [0:06:02] It's February 2nd, 2015, Monday, and the first thing on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. [0:06:07] And we have a young scout that would like to come forward and lead us. [0:06:11] So those of you wishing to, please rise and join us. [0:06:15] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. [0:06:32] Thank you and welcome everyone and Jaden, Jaden right? Just pull that down and we have [0:06:40] a few questions to ask you. What's your name? Jaden Jensen. Very good. Where do you meet? [0:06:46] At the church. Fifth Ward. Fifth Ward? Yeah. Okay. Very good. Where's that located at? [0:06:55] Jaden do you know? It's right on the Eastland right by the temple. Very good. And what are [0:07:01] you working on tonight? My communication's barebitch and what [0:07:06] trooper you with? 60. 60 and is there anything else you'd like to [0:07:10] share with all of us? No. I didn't think so. Thank you for your [0:07:14] service to our community. Thank you. We do have a form of the City Council this [0:07:20] evening. All seven members are here. Travis Rothwily, do we have any amendments [0:07:25] to our agenda? There are no amendments to the agenda but just for a correction on [0:07:31] On item number six that will not be presented by me, they'll be presented, I believe, by you. [0:07:36] By me. [0:07:39] Yeah. [0:07:43] We have no amendments to the agenda and no proclamations. [0:07:46] Next item on our agenda is public input. [0:07:48] Is there anyone that would like to come forward and address the City Council this evening? [0:07:56] I always give you an opportunity to be able to do that. [0:07:59] I see no one coming forward, but I do see a light. [0:08:01] Rebecca Mills, sir. [0:08:03] Thank you, Mayor. [0:08:03] I'd just like to pull item number two on the consent calendar for discussion. [0:08:08] Pull it off for discussion, please. [0:08:10] Very good, remind me, we don't need a motion for that. [0:08:13] We can just approve the agenda and then, okay, very good. [0:08:16] So item number two will be pulled for discussion [0:08:20] and added later potentially. [0:08:22] So I will move down to consent calendar [0:08:24] and there's only one item on there [0:08:25] and look for direction from council, Greg Lanning. [0:08:28] Move approval as consent calendar [0:08:30] minus item number two. [0:08:32] Second. [0:08:33] Have motion on the floor by Greg Lanning, [0:08:35] The second is by Rebecca Mills-Soyka. [0:08:38] Anything further on that motion council? [0:08:41] The aye of the real couple, please. [0:08:43] Suzanne Hawkins? [0:08:45] Yes. [0:08:45] Jim Young? [0:08:46] Yes. [0:08:47] Sean Berriger? [0:08:48] Yes. [0:08:49] Chris Talkington? [0:08:50] Yes. [0:08:50] Greg Lantham? [0:08:51] Yes. [0:08:52] Rebecca Mills-Soyka? [0:08:53] Yes. [0:08:54] Motion passes seven to zero. [0:08:55] The floor is yours, Rebecca. [0:08:57] Thank you. [0:08:58] I'd just like to discuss the request [0:09:01] to pay fees in lieu of park land at morning sun number eight. [0:09:05] We have almost an acre of park land that would be dedicated and just in light of the [0:09:12] strategic plan, a lot of the public input we got there was the value of open space, green [0:09:19] space. [0:09:20] So I'm wondering if the land itself is actually not more valuable to us than the money because [0:09:28] I don't want to find ourselves kind of in a place we are now where we're looking to buy [0:09:31] land for, you know, larger parks and more green open space and then we have to wonder [0:09:38] do we have enough impact fees to pay for it? [0:09:42] I think it's just harder to acquire in the future. [0:09:46] So I would actually be in support of accepting the land donation and I think it gives us [0:09:52] an opportunity to expand and to diversify our park system. [0:09:58] It doesn't have to be a traditional park. [0:10:00] I know there's a park near Morning Sun and it's kind of the traditional play toys, needs [0:10:06] a restroom, needs a shelter, but I'd like to see more of the Dennis Boyer Parks actually, [0:10:12] just have happened to have that great name downtown that just is a place where you can [0:10:18] enjoy nature, a place where you can sit and enjoy some company. [0:10:22] I think it would just give us an opportunity to have that green open space. [0:10:26] Dennis, if you could address this and maybe even tell us what the philosophy has been with [0:10:33] the size of the parks and just give us a brief overview. [0:10:37] What with the whole park ordinance talks about trying to provide neighborhood parks [0:10:41] to our community. [0:10:43] So when we look at development, similar to this one, we look at how much park land that [0:10:47] would donate to us, be 0.91, almost 1 acres, so we look at where are existing parks we have [0:10:53] now. [0:10:54] and what are there maybe some open spaces. [0:10:57] As Rebecca was talking about, [0:11:00] we do have Morningsong Park [0:11:01] directly south of this proposed development. [0:11:04] It's right here, it's a four acre park. [0:11:06] Currently, mostly it's open space. [0:11:09] We do have playground equipment there. [0:11:10] We do not have a restroom or a shelter there. [0:11:14] That is our long-term plan is to complete [0:11:16] this park to add those two amenities. [0:11:19] And my thoughts were with some of these funds [0:11:22] from this input of what helped us budget for this [0:11:25] in the future year. [0:11:27] I can't remember, I'm not part of the five-year plan, [0:11:29] but I know it's part of the five-year plan [0:11:32] of putting a bathroom and a shelter here, [0:11:34] so I can't tell you exactly what year it is. [0:11:36] I just don't remember what year it is, [0:11:38] but I would say it's pretty soon. [0:11:40] And also I look at other areas of Parkland [0:11:43] or soon-to-be Parkland, you know, [0:11:45] directly west up here on Stadium is Jason's Park. [0:11:49] This is large three-to-park. [0:11:50] It's mostly really a retention area, [0:11:51] how that design, you know, most of the time it does function as a neighborhood park or at least open green space for the neighborhoods. [0:11:58] And also, you know, even though we don't consider elementary schools as parks, they do have a lot of open space. [0:12:06] They do have elementary schools, do have playground equipment, and even though it's on another, you would have to cross a mile. [0:12:12] But over here where the future elementary school is going to go there, there will be another large open, you might call it, play space. [0:12:19] So kind of looking at all these here is staff, I really believe that taking the in-loop is a better option than looking at a smaller park in this area. [0:12:30] So that was just my opinion. [0:12:32] Very good. [0:12:33] We have a couple lights on, Suzanne Hawkins. [0:12:35] Thank you. [0:12:36] Dennis, roughly, what is the cost annually of maintaining a battle one acre park for the city? [0:12:43] I don't have that on top of my head, I'm sorry. [0:12:46] That's okay. [0:12:47] So, when you look at our budget now, if you kind of looked at other parks, you know, by [0:12:54] time you put manpower out there for mowing and weeding and watering and taking care of [0:12:59] it, you have just, I guess, maybe? [0:13:03] You know, sometimes a smaller ones can be more costly than larger ones, you know, especially [0:13:09] but I'm talking about some of those real small triangles you have around town. [0:13:13] us are paying because you got to take you longer to unload your mower and load [0:13:18] the mower back up to do more. Actually you do mower. You know, one acre part, you [0:13:22] know, just kind of depends on amenities and there is the maintenance of it. [0:13:25] If it's just pure grass, that's pretty easy to mow. But, you know, we already [0:13:30] have a park and I think Miss Mills was talking about something a little more [0:13:33] different than just an open-spat space area, you know, where you would have more [0:13:38] landscaping and sometimes some of those, you know, like I still hate to say that [0:13:43] in a sporty place, you know, so it's really rare to be to say that we're typing in there. [0:13:49] But sometimes they can take a little more maintenance just because the type of plant [0:13:52] life in there, like the Courtney Conservation Park, you know, that takes a little bit more [0:13:57] maintenance because there's just a higher degree of maintenance over there compared to some of [0:14:02] our neighborhood parks. [0:14:03] So hopefully that can answer your question. [0:14:05] Yeah, and as you're staffed right now, are you, you know, if we start picking up some [0:14:09] smaller one acre parks. What what is that going to do to your staffing needs are you [0:14:14] gonna be stretched today we just hired a brand new employee doesn't replace anybody [0:14:19] but it's just brand new part of our budget so we do have one more person on [0:14:23] staff and kind of what we have used in a ratios and pass it's roughly every 18 to [0:14:29] 19 manicured acres of grass we have we have to have another full-time employee and [0:14:34] roughly 16 acres of manicured grass we didn't need another part-time seasonal [0:14:40] employee so every time we do add some manicured grass areas it does add on to [0:14:44] you know our budget and I know it's the other side of town but the new park over [0:14:49] at Sunway that's gonna add to your time needs as well right yes okay thank you [0:14:54] Chris talking when we talk about park locations remind us again of we we [0:15:03] I didn't want to have kids having to cross visit arterials and feeders or collectors. [0:15:09] The In-Lua funds right now are our code reads has to be used within that square mile, the arterial. [0:15:16] So in this square mile, we have morning sun and we have Jason's Park. [0:15:24] That's the only two parks we have in that square mile. [0:15:28] So these funds would potentially be used for restroom and cover the land direct itself. [0:15:35] But still a real valid point that Becker brought up. [0:15:39] Greg, you minding? [0:15:41] Well, I usually agree on the additional parks and things on this one. [0:15:45] But in this particular case, I don't believe I do agree because we do have a right across [0:15:51] the street. [0:15:52] We have a park that we have not fully finished out and we can utilize these funds to finish [0:15:56] out. [0:15:57] remember a statement in our senior manager made at one point, we need to start building [0:16:01] parks complete, not just piecemeal them and get them done. So I would be in favor of using [0:16:08] the blue to go ahead and finish off either morning's energizing so that we can get those [0:16:12] parks complete. And then we move on to undeveloped breath. If that morning's own park wasn't [0:16:21] right across the street, I would have before agreement on this, but not in this case. This [0:16:24] is to me it's like we're putting an extra one in just put an extra with it I see [0:16:31] no further light so I'll all way in question for you as far as restrooms [0:16:35] concern when we put a park out Dennis is it kind of the expectation more public [0:16:39] we end up putting the restroom in it eventually especially if I look at this [0:16:43] neighborhood park and I really strongly believe that the three basic amenities [0:16:48] for neighborhood park is playground equipment shelter and a bathroom you have [0:16:52] to make that really a bathroom. If you have young kids taking your kids to a park, you [0:17:00] know, they're not there much longer than an hour. Right? So a bathroom can extend that [0:17:05] visit. So I really believe this, you know, neighborhood park, we need those three [0:17:09] amenities in the neighborhood. Some of the real small areas you may not need it. [0:17:13] Well, I just kind of look at if you go to a park, you go to a park and that the [0:17:18] biological needs will still be there, regardless of what size the park is. So [0:17:23] So that would be one concern about building a lot of small parts. [0:17:27] To me, then we would be spending more money on restroom facilities and things like that. [0:17:32] I certainly appreciate what Rebecca is saying about trying to capture the land. [0:17:37] And I guess maybe that's my next question. [0:17:39] Have we done a market analysis? [0:17:41] Is it still valid, this amount of money for this much land? [0:17:44] And because if we end up having to take that money and purchase more land eventually for [0:17:50] the park will it be apples to apples we have not updated our formula in the [0:17:58] code for I don't know if it ever has been updated yet but if you want to we can [0:18:04] look at that I need to do that I'm wondering if that might be a good idea [0:18:08] because if we're if we're taking money in lieu of land then I mean it could go [0:18:14] certainly towards equipment but it could also go towards lying land and if [0:18:19] if it's not equitable, it doesn't make sense to me. [0:18:23] Which reminded me, the one part that our code, [0:18:26] we talked about, I think it's 31,700, [0:18:28] that's our cost of developing cost per acre. [0:18:32] Each property, when we get an in-lua, [0:18:35] it just depends on what the purchase value [0:18:38] or the appraised value of that property, [0:18:40] and that can change from each subdivision. [0:18:44] So in looking at this, my own personal feeling [0:18:47] is that the park meeting is so close proximity, makes sense, [0:18:51] and I'm okay with the Rebecca Mills circuit. [0:18:55] Thank you. [0:18:56] Appreciate all of your input, Dennis. [0:18:58] I did just want to say that it's an opportunity [0:19:00] for the future, and so we may not develop it right away, [0:19:04] but it's nice to have, because it's when you need it [0:19:07] in the future and all the land around it, it's developed, [0:19:10] it's, you know, open space is just really a rare amenity. [0:19:14] And so I'm still in favor of accepting the land, [0:19:19] but I also wanted to mention that we have an opportunity [0:19:22] to zero-scape. [0:19:23] I mean, we can choose our landscape [0:19:27] to be beautiful and enjoyable, but also low-maintenance. [0:19:30] And I think we've experimented in that direction. [0:19:34] And so I think just for the future land to me, [0:19:37] and from what I've heard from the strategic plan input, [0:19:41] I think it's very valuable to our citizens. [0:19:44] I see no further lights, so I'm looking for direction on item number two and [0:19:47] present calendar, great landing. [0:19:49] Move the approval of item number two of the consent calendar. [0:19:53] Second. [0:19:54] Motion on the floor by great landing. [0:19:56] Seconded by Jim on to approve item number two. [0:19:59] Anything further on the motion council? [0:20:02] The item, can we have a roll call vote, please? [0:20:04] Jim on? [0:20:05] Yes. [0:20:06] Sean Bericher? [0:20:07] Yes. [0:20:07] Chris talking to? [0:20:08] Yes. [0:20:09] Greg Lanting? [0:20:10] Yes. [0:20:10] Don Hall? [0:20:11] Yes. [0:20:11] Rebecca Melsoica? [0:20:12] No. [0:20:13] Suzanne Hawkins? [0:20:14] Yes. [0:20:15] Motion passes 6-1 moving to items for consideration the first item on the list is consideration of requests to adopt an ordinance for a rezone [0:20:26] property located south of [0:20:29] 900 to 1100 blocks of Cheney Drive West [0:20:32] undeveloped and east of the 1350 to 1450 blocks of field streamway for Will's ink and [0:20:40] And if we choose to do this this evening council the ordinance number will be 3087 [0:20:46] 3087 so with that I will turn it over to Renee caraway welcome [0:20:51] Good evening, Mayor Hall City Council. Well, I'm back [0:20:55] If you remember last week, I was here [0:20:58] I'm asking for adoption of an ordinance for vacation of a portion of the Field Stone subdivision [0:21:04] This is the next step in the process, which is what I had [0:21:08] explain to you then just to refresh your memory on where the location of this [0:21:19] property is that we're talking about this evening. This is a portion of Field [0:21:24] Stone Subdivision. This entire portion of Field Stone Subdivision was platted back in [0:21:39] 2004. There was a request to rezone this portion of Field Stone Subdivision under a [0:21:48] a zoning designation from R2 to R4 and R4 Pro, PUD. [0:22:07] This is the approved master development plan of that PUD, [0:22:12] and the first portion of the request this evening [0:22:15] is to ask for adoption of the ordinance [0:22:18] that does codify the zoning of this property. [0:22:21] On January 23rd, 2012, the council, [0:22:26] this body did approve the rezone of this property from R2 to R4 and R4PUD by a vote of 6 to 1. [0:22:37] There were five conditions on that approval. [0:22:40] It's in your packet. [0:22:41] I would be happy to read them to you. [0:22:43] But unless you have them in your packet and you're okay with them. [0:22:46] Okay. [0:22:47] I think we're okay at this point. [0:22:49] Okay. [0:22:50] So my request this evening on this portion is for adoption of this ordinance to allow this project to move forward. [0:22:55] project to move forward. The second item that we'll talk about is the actual PUD agreement. [0:23:00] Which is next. Which is next. So I'll sit down and. [0:23:05] Well you might stand there. There might be some questions for you. [0:23:07] Okay. Do we have any questions for Renee? [0:23:12] Yeah, direction from Council on Chris talking to. [0:23:15] I would move to place 3087 on third and final by title only under suspension of the rules. [0:23:21] Second. [0:23:22] Motion on the board by Chris Tockington. [0:23:24] Seconded by Suzanne Hawkins as stated. [0:23:28] Do you think further on that motion council? [0:23:31] Well, I guess does the motion include the five conditions, [0:23:36] attached conditions? [0:23:37] That would be part of the rezoning of the property, yes sir. [0:23:40] All right. [0:23:40] Is that what your intention is? [0:23:42] That is the intent. [0:23:43] Second, is that your intention as well? [0:23:44] OK, very good. [0:23:46] Anything further on that motion council? [0:23:49] Lea, the roll call vote, please. [0:23:51] Sean Berger, Chris Talkington, Greg Lanting, Don Hall, Rebecca Milsica, Suzanne Hawkins, Jim Munn. [0:24:00] Yes, motion passes seven to zero if you could read the title. [0:24:05] In ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho, rezoning real property [0:24:09] below described, providing the zoning classification therefore, and ordering the necessary area of [0:24:15] impact in zoning district's map amendment. [0:24:18] stand for a motion council, Greg Lanning. [0:24:22] Move approval of ordinance 3087. [0:24:27] Second. [0:24:27] Motion on floor by Greg Lanning, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins [0:24:31] to approve ordinance 3087. [0:24:34] Rebecca Milsoic. [0:24:36] Thank you, Mayor. [0:24:37] Well, as you guys recall back in 2011 and 12, [0:24:39] we did have quite the turnout for these public hearings. [0:24:44] And I think Chris mentioned it last week that these folks [0:24:48] by their homes and invested in them in an R2, what was platted, which, you know, plats are supposed to be forever. [0:24:58] And so I did vote against the vacation and the changing of increasing the density, [0:25:05] making it professional, taking it from residential to partially commercial, [0:25:10] because that is part of the Idaho Code, the Land Use Planning Act, to not let commercial [0:25:16] in close-on or in close-on residential and so I'm gonna maintain that position on [0:25:23] this ordinance and you know in our packet the Planning and Zoning Commission did [0:25:29] recommend denial and the other rezoning was approved so I'm gonna maintain my [0:25:35] position that it really isn't fair for the residents who bought into this their [0:25:41] original homes thank you Rebecca anything further on the motion council the [0:25:47] honor or call vote please yes Greg Lansing yes Don Hall yes Rebecca [0:25:54] milseica no Suzanne Hawkins yes Jim on yes Sean Berger yes motion passes 6 to 1 [0:26:03] next item on the agenda is consideration of requests to approve the [0:26:07] field stone professional PUD, R4 and R4 PRO plan unit development agreement between the [0:26:15] City of Twin Falls and Wells, Inc. Renee, you're up again, Ms. Blaufait. [0:26:19] Yes, sir, I am. This is the same project that we just talked about. The PUD agreement [0:26:26] is actually codifying the specific land uses and development requirements that are unique [0:26:34] to this project. [0:26:35] Again, the master development plan is shown up on the screen. [0:26:40] I believe that the PUD agreement that is in your packet [0:26:44] complies with what your motion was and your approval [0:26:47] of the project. [0:26:48] And we need a motion this evening by simple majority [0:26:52] to approve this PUD agreement. [0:26:55] Make a renegan. [0:26:56] Do we have any questions for any? [0:26:59] Sam for direction from council. [0:27:03] Greg Lanning. [0:27:04] Who have approval of the fieldstone number two? [0:27:07] or whatever the number of the PUD anyway. [0:27:11] What's the number on it? [0:27:12] Just the field cell PUD. [0:27:14] All right. [0:27:16] Second. [0:27:17] I have a motion on four by Greg Lanting, [0:27:19] seconded by Sean Barreger to approve the field stone [0:27:23] professional PUD R4 and R4 Pro planned unit development [0:27:27] agreement between the city of Twin Falls and Will's Inc. [0:27:31] Anything further on that motion council? [0:27:32] Rebecca Milsoy. [0:27:34] Thank you Mayor. [0:27:35] I think his beauty looks like a good transition from zone to zone. [0:27:41] One concern I would have is that the hours of operation says they should be 7 AM to 9 PM unless extended hours are permitted by special use permit. [0:27:51] Which I was, my one concern with that would be is with the homes that are contiguous to the R4 Pro. [0:28:00] I'm not sure, even under special use permit, I'm not sure hours extended beyond 9 PM would [0:28:07] be compatible as the commercial activities would be happening essentially in their backyard. [0:28:15] Any thoughts on that? [0:28:16] That was a condition that came through, I know there was a lot of discussion about it. [0:28:21] The special use permit will allow the opportunity of the commission to review that specific land [0:28:26] use and make their decision based on that. [0:28:29] If it's ultimately appealed, it will come to you on appeal. [0:28:33] Thank you. [0:28:36] Anything further on this motion council? [0:28:39] Lee Island, roll call vote, please. [0:28:41] Greg Lansing. [0:28:42] Yes. [0:28:43] Don Hall. [0:28:43] Yes. [0:28:44] Rebecca Milsmeicke. [0:28:45] No. [0:28:47] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:28:47] Yes. [0:28:48] Jim Munn. [0:28:49] Yes. [0:28:50] Sean Berriger. [0:28:51] Yes. [0:28:52] Yes. [0:28:53] Motion passes six to one. [0:28:55] Moving to item number three, consideration of request [0:28:57] adopt an ordinance to amend Title 10 by adding a definition for governmental open storage yard. [0:29:04] And to allow that use by special use permit in the C1 commercial slash retail zone. [0:29:11] If Council chooses to approve this or move forward with this, the ordinance number will be 3088. [0:29:18] Renee. [0:29:19] Thank you Mayor Hall and City Council. [0:29:22] You have presented before you in your packet a background on the approval process of this request. [0:29:29] This came before the Planning and Zoning Commission. [0:29:32] This request came before the Planning and Zoning Commission to amend Title 10 on a definition [0:29:40] of a storage yard. [0:29:43] And then by allowing a special, you're requiring a special use permit for an outside storage [0:29:49] in concurrence with a governmental facility office building. [0:29:55] Again, it went through public hearings [0:29:57] before the Planning and Zoning Commission. [0:29:58] On December 9th, the Planning and Zoning Commission [0:30:01] unanimous, we recommended approval of this code amendment. [0:30:06] On January 5th, it came to the City Council, [0:30:08] whereby this body did vote five to zero [0:30:12] on this to go forward. [0:30:14] So this tonight is a finalization of that process, [0:30:17] asking for your approval of an ordinance to allow [0:30:20] codification of the code, does require third and final, [0:30:24] which would be by super majority and then simple majority [0:30:28] if that's proved to go forward. [0:30:33] And do we have any questions? [0:30:39] This only applies to the C1 zone, correct? [0:30:42] That is correct. [0:30:43] So a question like the CB zone, the central business [0:30:49] district downtown. [0:30:51] So could you see that there would be perhaps an interest in bringing forward something like [0:30:56] this in that zone and would it make sense to discuss that zone as well now or wait until [0:31:03] that were to come before us? [0:31:06] As this ordinance came through public hearing presented in this way, if you choose not to [0:31:11] go forward it would go back through the process. [0:31:13] But in answer to your question, the CV zone, I believe a governmental office building would [0:31:17] be very appropriate, but perhaps not an outside storage yard. [0:31:21] Right. [0:31:22] I was just thinking of like by the courthouse, the sheriff's office area, parking lots, those [0:31:27] types of things, but I get your point that we don't want to go back and mess with it since [0:31:31] it's come through in a different way. [0:31:33] But something maybe to keep in mind in the future is we're looking at possible areas where [0:31:38] that may occur. [0:31:39] Thanks, Sean. [0:31:41] Anything? [0:31:42] Any further questions, Council? [0:31:43] I'll stand in our direction. [0:31:50] Chris talking to. [0:31:51] Move passage of 30-0, 8-8, [0:31:54] under which is French Revolution by title only. [0:31:57] Third and final. [0:31:59] Second. [0:32:00] Motion on the floor by Chris talking to. [0:32:02] Seconded by Suzanne Hawkins as stated. [0:32:05] Do you think further on the motion council? [0:32:07] The aye la roll call vote please. [0:32:09] Don Hall? [0:32:10] Yes. [0:32:11] Rebecca Milseica? [0:32:12] Yes. [0:32:13] Suzanne Hawkins? [0:32:14] Yes. [0:32:15] Jim Munn? [0:32:15] Yes. [0:32:16] Sean Berriger? [0:32:17] Yes. [0:32:17] Chris talking to them. [0:32:19] Greg Lanthine? [0:32:19] Yes. [0:32:21] Motion passes 7-0 to repeat the complete title. [0:32:24] In ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho, [0:32:27] amending Twin Falls City Code Section 1021 by adding a definition for government [0:32:33] open storage yard and amending Section 1048.2b3 by adding government open [0:32:40] storage yard as a special use in the C1 zoning district. [0:32:45] Stand for motion, good council. [0:32:48] Great, Matt. [0:32:48] Move approval, award, and it's 3088. [0:32:52] Second. [0:32:53] Motion on the floor by Greg 19, [0:32:54] seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to approve Ordinance 3088. [0:32:59] You think further on that motion council? [0:33:03] The aye of the roll call vote, please. [0:33:05] Rebecca Melsoica? [0:33:06] Yes. [0:33:08] Suzanne Hawkins? [0:33:09] Yes. [0:33:09] Jim Mudd? [0:33:10] Yes. [0:33:11] Sean Berger? [0:33:12] Yes. [0:33:13] Chris Tockington? [0:33:14] Yes. [0:33:15] Greg Lansing? [0:33:15] Yes. [0:33:16] Don Hall? [0:33:17] Yes. [0:33:18] Motion passes seven to zero. [0:33:19] I think you're done, Renee. [0:33:21] Thank you. [0:33:22] Thank you for your service tonight. [0:33:24] Next time on the agenda is consideration of the request [0:33:26] to reaffirm consideration of a modified street section [0:33:31] on the Morning Sun subdivision number eight preliminary plat. [0:33:35] We had Gerald Martins with EHM engineers. [0:33:38] Welcome Gerald. [0:33:39] Thank you for the record. [0:33:41] My name is Gerald Martins. [0:33:43] I'm here this evening to ask you to reaffirm something you did [0:33:48] or some of you did back in 2010. [0:33:53] And we're moving forward with the development of this property. [0:33:57] We call morning cent eight, but most of you probably better remember it as a Boy Scout property. [0:34:03] It's a property that is bounded by Falls, Hankins, [0:34:11] Stadium and Meadowview. [0:34:14] It is approximately 30 acres after the streets and [0:34:19] and the Boy Scout meeting hall is taken out. [0:34:23] Back in 2010, we came to you with a preliminary plait concept [0:34:29] that used a modified street section. [0:34:32] Within this project, there are the streets are all looped [0:34:36] and enclosed in just very much neighborhood streets. [0:34:40] They're not a bypass to anywhere. [0:34:42] They're in totally internal streets. [0:34:43] There's only two entrances in and out of this development. [0:34:47] And we proposed a street section that had a narrower pavement section with a streetscape [0:34:54] on both sides behind the curbs and then the sidewalk. [0:34:58] So if you drive down the street, the first street, then five foot to eight foot of landscaping [0:35:05] and then a sidewalk. [0:35:07] The result is a 28 foot street versus a 36 foot street in the residential area. [0:35:13] streets serve a small number of lots. It's less street to maintain, but I think it makes [0:35:21] a much nicer residential environment. The streets are not long, they're very short. You [0:35:27] know, three, four hundred feet maximum before a curve. We would require restricted parking [0:35:36] on one side. Of course, require three car garages and off street parking on all of the homes. [0:35:49] The, I think it's an opportunity to demonstrate something that we've talked about many times [0:35:56] about reducing the amount of asphalt in subdivisions, especially when the streets can never be extended. [0:36:03] never be extended. They don't go anywhere where more homes could be built. They're closed [0:36:08] on themselves or loops. We made this presentation some five years ago. We were moving forward. [0:36:16] The economy slowed down or stopped. But we now are ready to move forward. As I noted [0:36:24] in the cover letter that I believe you have in your packet, it is a closed subdivision. [0:36:30] these bounded by arterials. These are definitely residential streets and I think [0:36:34] it's an appropriate use. It's not, it's not in any way an attempt to, right away [0:36:43] is the same. So the yacht, we're not getting more lots by doing this. We're [0:36:48] not saving money. I think it's going to be a more friendly residential [0:36:53] neighborhood. It's going to encourage pedestrians by separating them from the [0:36:58] the car traffic throughout this subdivision. [0:37:01] They hit by the landscape strip on each side. [0:37:07] The city's concern that they've always had [0:37:10] and always expressed about people with rolled dirt, [0:37:14] but people driving up on the sidewalk [0:37:16] and parking on the sidewalk. [0:37:17] This totally eliminates that. [0:37:20] They're gonna have to knock down a tree to do it. [0:37:24] As part of the development, [0:37:25] The developer will install all the trees and create a streetscape as the development is built. [0:37:32] So the trees will all be similar in type, spacing, and size. [0:37:40] And I think it's just going to make for a very nice residential project. [0:37:43] But that will be glad to answer any questions. [0:37:45] We will have a staff presentation afterwards, but for now, we have any questions for Gerald. [0:37:52] Looks like we have two lights. [0:37:54] Chris Talkington. [0:37:55] The general city could answer this, but going from a 36 to a 28, no way. [0:38:00] Pearl would have us accessed by fire equipment. [0:38:05] No, we. [0:38:06] Now what did you say about parking on the narrow streets? [0:38:10] Is it allowed on both sides? [0:38:12] On one side. [0:38:13] It will be signed then. [0:38:14] Okay, thank you. [0:38:16] Thank you. [0:38:17] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:38:19] Sorry, Gerald. [0:38:20] Who will be required to maintain the landscaping strips? [0:38:24] homeowners well just to back up a bit even today if you have landscaping in [0:38:32] front of your home part of it's in the public right away and you're required to [0:38:37] maintain it this will be no difference a lot over will maintain it the only thing [0:38:41] different here is that the there will be a the landscaping specifically the [0:38:48] trees in the streetscape section will be installed by the developer up front to [0:38:54] make sure that they're uniform and type and size. [0:38:57] So then the watering system will be also installed by the developer and then connected to each individual home for their own slaughter bill? [0:39:05] Okay. [0:39:06] As a homes, we won't install the trees too far ahead of the building operation because they probably wouldn't survive the contractors coming and going. [0:39:18] So, we would install them and tie it into the individual home sprinkler systems, which are all tied to the pressurized canal company water system. [0:39:28] Thank you. [0:39:29] I have a question for you, sir. [0:39:30] You say that it's going to be restricted to one side of the street for parking. [0:39:34] How is that going to be enforced, homeowners kind of a- [0:39:38] Well, in the morning sun homeowners association, and this will become part of that association, [0:39:46] we preclude through the association and monitor and enforce no on-street parking for an extended [0:39:55] period of time anyway. [0:39:57] And so we will continue that through this project. [0:40:04] Certainly guest parking always occurs on this, but the homeowners are not allowed now in the [0:40:10] association to park on the street. [0:40:13] The reason we provide in the morning sensory car, [0:40:17] three car garages and then the parking in front of it. [0:40:20] There's plenty of parking for the homeowners. [0:40:22] And we do enforce it out there, legislate. [0:40:26] Or maybe not religiously, but actively. [0:40:28] Actively. [0:40:30] Next question, as far as the types of trees [0:40:32] you're going to be planting, you're in control of that [0:40:35] as the developer. [0:40:36] And you've researched which ones work best. [0:40:38] They don't buckle roadways and sidewalks later on, [0:40:41] those kind of things. [0:40:42] We will certainly victories that are on the cities list [0:40:46] of approved trees for installation adjacent to roadways. [0:40:51] We will want to generate some color [0:40:54] and so that some flowering opportunities [0:40:58] but to create a character for the neighborhood. [0:41:02] But we will work with the city on selecting the trees. [0:41:05] Very good, thank you, Gerald. [0:41:06] Doesn't look like any other lights, [0:41:08] So I, who is it you, Mitch, or Jackie is going to me? [0:41:13] Making the staff presentation. [0:41:15] Jackie Fields, our city engineer? [0:41:31] So this is the general neighborhood. [0:41:35] Falls to the north and Hankens on the east [0:41:38] and two collector streets. [0:41:40] And based on a question I received prior to the meeting, [0:41:43] I thought that I should, Renee gracefully, [0:41:45] brought the plan along. [0:41:51] has a significant amount of other lines that are really important to me, and you don't care [0:41:58] so much about them. [0:41:59] It's important about what's happening here, even though it's a little bit hard to follow, [0:42:04] is that there are two outlets, one onto each collector, right? [0:42:07] One right here. [0:42:09] So all the rest of the streets are internal. [0:42:14] So the layout meets the requirements for our department access. [0:42:19] It also puts this neighborhood in the spot where it's isolated, but right next to main [0:42:28] roads where people get out. [0:42:30] So this provided us an opportunity to at least consider the alternative that was being [0:42:34] requested several years ago. [0:42:43] So what you're looking at here is half of a street and on the right side there's a little [0:42:52] mark that shows you the center line of the road. So, what you're going to see is what you're [0:43:04] going to see on the other side. So, what I have on the top part of the hand drum numbering [0:43:13] is to talk to you about what exists currently. And our current transportation master plan, [0:43:19] the road right away is 50 feet wide and it is occupied by 18 feet of pavement to the back [0:43:26] of the curb from the center line to the back of the curb. [0:43:29] And then the sidewalk is right on top of the curb line and you have about seven feet per [0:43:34] sidewalk and utilities behind that before you hit the edge of the right way. [0:43:40] The proposal was to do what you see here where you have 14 feet and 14 and a half feet including [0:43:48] the world curb, a landscaping strip, a sidewalk. [0:43:52] And then there's a small piece of ground left to squeeze into boxes and things like that. [0:44:02] But the right-of-way like is still the same. [0:44:05] So the concern I had was, what happens if this road section doesn't work out and we [0:44:13] need to make a change? [0:44:14] So the right-of-way with stays the same to provide an opportunity for making a change [0:44:19] if it's ever in the day. [0:44:21] The Gerald brought forth the idea that we were concerned about people driving on sidewalks. [0:44:26] If you have a narrow street, there are some of us that consider road curve to be an opportunity [0:44:31] to pass and that type of thing needs to be somewhat addressed. [0:44:37] You know, on your sale day when you have people blocking both sides of the road, it can be aggravating [0:44:44] in that type of situation. [0:44:45] So there comes the landscape strip. [0:44:50] The parking on one side helps address making it around some of these corners. [0:44:57] And we have some corners in here that the knuckles actually help with making it around those little [0:45:06] non-cola sack bulb things are called by some people. [0:45:12] So we felt that with the parking restriction on one side of the road, we haven't confirmed [0:45:19] which side of the road that is that we'd be able to accommodate parking for friends and the [0:45:26] fire truck would still be able to get through and if they needed to be there they'd also be [0:45:30] able to set up so the challenge isn't getting the truck through the neighborhood it's getting [0:45:35] the truck able to find a spot so they can set up and fight the fire so that kind of addressed [0:45:39] that issue. We gave consideration to things like school buses and whether they're going [0:45:46] to come in the neighborhood and they're going to be able to make it where they need to go [0:45:49] And also what would happen with the fire trucks. [0:45:54] And we think that we'll think that this plan could be really viable and work really well. [0:46:02] We have something similar to it with high back curve in the portion of the President's Street between Habergan Addison. [0:46:09] That has parking on both sides of the street. [0:46:12] So our tail day isn't quite as pleasant as it could be. [0:46:17] But this plan is going to be a little bit different that way. [0:46:24] The difference, the big difference here is that there is no collector trying to come [0:46:27] through the neighborhood. There's a honey of suitable major roadways. [0:46:30] So when you hear me talking endlessly about the need for arterials and collectors, [0:46:35] it's so that people can be channeled out of their neighborhood [0:46:38] onto streets that are developed for that purpose and move onward. [0:46:42] And this neighborhood is one of probably several, but in my mind a few, that has the facilities [0:46:50] available to the people who live there so they can easily, you know, their slow time is [0:46:55] right in the neighborhood. [0:46:57] And then, but quickly, they're out onto some larger scale roadways to go on their merry [0:47:01] way. [0:47:03] So there's no immediate financial impact to the city's budget. [0:47:11] Students activities like seal coat and you know, [0:47:15] 20 some years from now or 40 some years from now [0:47:18] when we go to overlay, there's less pavement to overlay. [0:47:24] Let's see, if we did decide for some reason, [0:47:29] that we as a community wanted to change our mind [0:47:32] and build that street wider. [0:47:35] There still is not necessarily a cost to the city [0:47:37] if the city chooses to allow that action [0:47:39] to occur via LID. [0:47:43] Let's see. [0:47:45] And the last thing I'm here to ask you to do is to, let's see, [0:47:50] the proposal needs a vote, a simple majority vote, [0:47:55] to go forward as it stands. [0:47:56] So I'm asking you to do that, to allow this alternative section [0:48:02] to go forward into preliminary planning. [0:48:06] Thank you. [0:48:08] Rebecca Melsuka. [0:48:09] Thank you, Mayor. [0:48:11] So Jackie, if someone, even though there's [0:48:14] going to be some possible self-enforcements and self-regulation, [0:48:18] If someone ignores the no parking sign and parks there, [0:48:22] and there's a fire, is the fire truck going to be able [0:48:26] to get in and set up if people ignore the no parking signs? [0:48:33] So the fire department should be able to get in. [0:48:41] So this won't be different from other streets that way. [0:48:45] If somebody, if you have two people that park their campers, [0:48:49] not really even next to the curb, [0:48:52] And then they can create a gap on our regular residential streets that makes it difficult [0:48:56] for a vehicle with mirrors and so on to make it through. [0:49:00] So I think that the fire trucks can get in and around in all circumstances. [0:49:05] The setup of the down rigors and things like that may or may not be able to occur directly [0:49:14] at the most preferred location and somebody can move over a little bit and deal with it. [0:49:19] But you know, people, when that, if parking becomes an issue, [0:49:24] there is, it'll be posted, so I'm going to take it. [0:49:29] And the neighborhood really probably will regulate itself. [0:49:35] I think Gerald wanted to weigh, did you [0:49:37] want to weigh in on that question as well? [0:49:39] Mr. Martins? [0:49:40] I would like to weigh in only, because I think it's [0:49:44] important to point out that I'll bring the plot up again, [0:49:48] Please, none of these are dead ends. [0:49:51] And so if for some reason somebody had a road blocked [0:49:57] with a moving van, unloading furniture or something, [0:50:00] you can get to every lot from two different directions. [0:50:04] And I think that adds additional safety. [0:50:08] If one of these roads were dead end cul-de-sacs [0:50:11] or something, it could be an issue [0:50:13] that we would need to address. [0:50:18] Thank you. [0:50:19] That would be my only concern, [0:50:20] but I appreciate the response. [0:50:23] Do we have any further questions, Council? [0:50:27] Stand for direction, Council? [0:50:31] Got to ask you if you're still gonna name [0:50:33] one of those streets, Tender Futt, [0:50:34] and the other one, Cub Scout, [0:50:37] ask you to personally reconsider that. [0:50:39] Well, I was kind of leaning towards web-lows [0:50:42] or something like that. [0:50:43] As far as I went, so, what we blows, [0:50:50] I did go to a Jamboree when I was a kid, so. [0:50:55] Those are the tentative street names. [0:50:58] I think Chris was trying to adjust that a little bit. [0:51:03] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:51:04] I would like to move that we approve the request to reaffirm the consideration of the modified [0:51:10] street section for morning side subdivision number eight. [0:51:15] And Jackie, did we need to say and move towards the preliminary plan or what was your terminology [0:51:21] that you said earlier? [0:51:22] Is that all we need? [0:51:28] Yeah, that kind of appears to be fine. [0:51:31] Okay. [0:51:32] I'm glad I'm fine. [0:51:33] And then we have a motion on the floor by Suzanne Hocken, seconded by Jim. [0:51:38] We have anything further on that motion to counsel. [0:51:41] I do. [0:51:42] Well, just as long as the modified terminology refers to very specific conditions, threats [0:51:48] this is clear enough, legally then. [0:51:51] Okay. [0:51:52] Suzanne Hockens. [0:51:53] I just want to say thank you to Gerald. [0:51:55] I'm excited. [0:51:56] I know during strategic planning times and stuff we've talked about having the sidewalk split [0:52:00] off with the landscaping between the road and the sidewalk for safety reasons and I think [0:52:05] this is a great place to do it and I hope we see more of this honestly in the future. [0:52:10] We're back on the outside. [0:52:12] Thank you Mayor. [0:52:13] I just want to say I'm okay with the street names. [0:52:15] I had a question about the LID. [0:52:18] I like that concept of in the future if there's a change that's needed. [0:52:22] Something comes up, I like the concept of it not costing the general taxpayers. [0:52:27] So is there a way to, is that something we would add now to, in the future if these streets [0:52:34] seem to be widened, that it be through an LID or how would that progress? [0:52:43] Chris Wonderlick, our city attorney. [0:52:44] That would be difficult because you wouldn't have any additional, I guess it should be reconstructing [0:52:53] the whole section. [0:52:54] Is it right away to frame this regular section? [0:52:58] Right, it would just be the reconstruction of the street. [0:53:02] It wouldn't have to be done now. [0:53:03] I mean, we'll take a vote to establish an MLID. [0:53:06] There's a procedure that you have to follow. [0:53:08] So I don't think he really is put a condition on this right now. [0:53:13] OK, so there's no way to put direction in the future [0:53:16] if there is a cost to the city. [0:53:18] Yeah, that would be up to the future council. [0:53:21] But we don't have to purchase it right away. [0:53:24] Sure, but you have to control the street. [0:53:29] Well, we have a site conversation. [0:53:31] State that again for folks to hear right away. [0:53:34] Sorry, Chris and I were talking about, we do have the right away. [0:53:36] It would just be the cost to reconstruct the street. [0:53:40] I just confirmed that the amount of right away is the same in any subject. [0:53:43] Right. [0:53:44] It's just configured differently. [0:53:46] Right. [0:53:46] And so the cost that would be borne by the city should a change be needed. [0:53:52] Shouldn't be needed, yes. [0:53:54] Yeah. [0:53:54] So the establishment, again, the establishment of an LID would be up to a future council [0:53:59] and whatever procedures are in effect at that time. [0:54:02] Okay. Thank you. So if I, I'll just comment on the main motion then, it's actually an [0:54:10] old concept and we can see it on the number of streets. And I think it is, it's a good [0:54:15] concept for creating friendly or neighborhoods, helping them interact. There's actually a new [0:54:22] movement kind of going in this direction with going back to the front porches. It actually [0:54:26] builds the social fabric of your neighborhood. So I think it's a good idea. In general, I, [0:54:32] I'd prefer not to make exceptions, so I think if it's an acceptable alternative to the city, [0:54:38] then we should change our code, and we should have this as an acceptable neighborhood alternative. [0:54:43] And so, I do support this concept, but I would prefer that if we do approve of it, [0:54:52] to just kind of make it more available to all of our developments. [0:54:57] Thank you. I just wanted to comment and maybe pick it back on what Suzanne said. I know that I think it was [0:55:05] Councilman Johnson that brought it to my attention years ago that maybe it's time for us to actually look at the widths of roads [0:55:12] that we have in our neighborhoods and and it's going to be [0:55:17] incumbent upon the city to to [0:55:19] to rebuild, refurbish, maintain those roads, [0:55:23] and the more square feet of road, the more expensive it is. [0:55:27] So I think this is a modified street that makes sense, [0:55:31] especially the layout, an internal road like this. [0:55:35] It makes perfect sense to me, [0:55:37] and I'm kind of excited about this project, [0:55:39] and I do like the concept of the front porch [0:55:42] and people a little more available [0:55:44] to each other neighborhood boys. [0:55:46] Great planning. [0:55:51] Well, I can agree with it. I'm certainly in favor of this particular proposal, and I'm [0:55:55] here to this particular proposal because we do have a very strong homeowners organization [0:56:00] that can control the street parking. On my way here, I drive down Elm Street north, or [0:56:07] excuse me, south of Addison, and there was a person on a bicycle and a car behind them [0:56:13] and because of cars parked on the street on an older narrow street of the old standard, [0:56:19] We had to do a lot of stopping and waiting for everybody to get by because you have to [0:56:22] weave in and out of the car. [0:56:24] So I don't believe it works everywhere, but I believe in a closed neighborhood like this [0:56:30] one that it does work. [0:56:32] And it is probably a desirable thing to do. [0:56:34] But so that's why I hesitate to put it in. [0:56:38] I like the exception that we get a chance to look at each one of these, that part. [0:56:43] But I don't believe it's remaining to the whole city. [0:56:47] When I do like your time, less cost, [0:56:50] but if I had to just driven that way, [0:56:53] I'm gonna wait to the council tonight [0:56:55] and then had to basically stop dead in the street [0:56:58] with cars back to behind me, [0:56:59] so a bicycle would get through [0:57:00] so we could all get around. [0:57:03] But again, that's not a closed road either. [0:57:05] That's connected to an arterial and everything else. [0:57:09] So I will be voting for it, [0:57:10] but I'm not sure it's a, [0:57:11] I'm looking at a cart blank here either. [0:57:14] You're good, Kristoff? [0:57:14] and I just had one point I've learned from our traffic people [0:57:17] through the years of the width of a road directly affects [0:57:22] the effective speed of the vehicles [0:57:24] and the narrower road will tender reduce that. [0:57:27] Are you there? [0:57:27] Enhancing safety, perhaps. [0:57:28] Good voice call. [0:57:29] Traffic call. [0:57:30] Good voice call. [0:57:31] Good point. [0:57:32] Very good point. [0:57:33] That's the street. [0:57:34] I think there are no further lights. [0:57:35] We have a motion on the floor. [0:57:37] So, Leanna, roll call, please. [0:57:39] Suzanne Hawkins? [0:57:40] Yes. [0:57:41] Jim Lund? [0:57:41] Yes. [0:57:42] Sean Berriger? [0:57:43] Yes. [0:57:44] Yes. [0:57:45] Great glancing. [0:57:46] Yes. [0:57:47] Don Hall. [0:57:48] Yes. [0:57:49] But back in milsica. [0:57:50] Yes. [0:57:51] The motion passes seven to zero. [0:57:52] Moving to the next item on the agenda is a presentation of an update on the waste water [0:57:56] treatment plant project. [0:57:58] And we have Troy Vitek from our engineering department with a very gray beard. [0:58:04] Oh, real nice beard. [0:58:07] That's the first time I've seen your gray beard. [0:58:11] This is the first time I made you smile. [0:58:13] He was in my target next. [0:58:21] Alrighty. [0:58:22] I'm here tonight to just give you the council an update on how things are going down there. [0:58:27] So I am going to start with pictures because I always think those are pretty cool. [0:58:30] The first one, this is the admin building in the background here. [0:58:37] And this is the north side of the new iFAST structure. [0:58:40] They got the south side, the rebar started here and they're starting at this corner. [0:58:45] They're sequencing this because once you build these basins, get people in and out of them, it's difficult, so you don't have to climb out of the next one or the next one. [0:58:54] So, they're doing a pretty amazing job down there and you can see it and what they have to deal with with the snow and I think they're going on. [0:59:04] So, that was a pretty rough day there. This is another one. [0:59:10] different angle here with the aeration basins in the background. [0:59:13] You can see they're still continuing with the walls. [0:59:15] The shoring here that keeps the aeration basins in check until they can construct this. [0:59:20] That'll be back-field. [0:59:22] As it progresses on the north side, this used to look like that. [0:59:28] But this is the walls here. [0:59:31] North side of the IFS basin. [0:59:34] And this here is actually scheduled for the IFS basin blower. [0:59:38] So a portion of the IFS has no blowers in it. [0:59:41] in it, no piping, and the second portion does because of certain processes that go on in [0:59:47] each of those individual basins. [0:59:49] So in order to do that, they have a building going in here and it's the blower building [0:59:54] and these are turbo blower and we're talking with Idaho Power to see if there's additional [1:00:00] rebates because they'll be using more efficient blower system and possibly take off the aeration [1:00:05] portion, at least throttle them down so we can have savings there and put it to the more [1:00:10] efficient ones. As they started at the secondary clarifier, the report shows that they hit some [1:00:19] rock and it's some rock, it's not all rock, but it really slowed them down there. They had [1:00:25] to drill these piles in on the north on the east side of the project here. The golf course [1:00:29] is in the background, there's a roadway right there, and there's a water line, a gas line [1:00:33] that come down behind there that they had to protect us by the pileings in there. When they [1:00:37] drilling these piles in the equipment broke and that took a well from the fix. [1:00:43] So the rock is not extraordinarily, we do have a rock number in there, it's expected, they're [1:00:48] within the budget right now, in fact they're under budget, there's a small difference [1:00:54] whether or not the piles in rock are part of the piles are part of the soil so that the [1:00:58] change order for that, if there was to be a change order being like $2,500 so it's well [1:01:03] than more than covering what we had reserved for contingency there, which I think is right [1:01:09] now currently in 1.5 million in contingency. [1:01:12] Of course we haven't used all that. [1:01:15] Now that gets me to my next portion here. [1:01:21] The original contract price, package one is closed out. [1:01:24] That was the digging of the whole, getting ready to meet the best schedule. [1:01:29] Package two, RCI. [1:01:30] This was the original contract price. [1:01:33] This is a change order to date. [1:01:34] And if you look down here, you can see the reasons for the change orders. [1:01:37] One was some permit fees, and then they fixed the blowout when the rain event occurred. [1:01:42] And then there's some, some mercilessly mixer upgrades. [1:01:46] So the mixers that were going to go into the aeration basins were specked out, and they were [1:01:55] submitted on, and there was a part submitted on. [1:01:58] And we can to find out that those didn't quite meet what the CH2PIL would really like to [1:02:06] have in place. [1:02:07] So we negotiated with the contractor, and this is the price for that. [1:02:13] They feel that's well within reason, and it's within our change order amount there. [1:02:19] So the total current change orders to date is 141,000 given the contract value of 18 million. [1:02:26] We spent 2.6 million, and so we have quite a bit more to do. [1:02:32] Currently, we've issued a couple of work change directives. [1:02:35] This tells the contractor on site what we would like instead of saying, [1:02:39] you know, just saying them, we actually write it down and say, [1:02:41] we want to do this as a reason why that's what these work change directives are. [1:02:45] And one of them was for some additional survey information, [1:02:49] because there's piping, lots of underground piping. [1:02:52] When we had exposed, we thought we probably ought to go measure it [1:02:55] Because I'm probably digging another hole, it's best to, so it's very easy to put that [1:03:01] change order in, or work change directive, and the other one was because of transformer. [1:03:05] It was originally going to be on the generator, and the generator sits outside, it's a huge [1:03:11] generator, and then they moved it into the building, so small change there. Current schedule, [1:03:19] they are on schedule a little bit, so they have a construction management schedule that [1:03:28] that they have to give to us at the beginning and we closely look at that. [1:03:34] The CH2 in Hail looks at that a lot and what they show is in the beginning, [1:03:39] they started out with these large pores and really gave some time. [1:03:42] But with the snow delays and some equipment delays, they're right on schedule. [1:03:47] Right now, one of the milestones is for July 4th, [1:03:52] and their schedule shows July 3rd. [1:03:55] So we call that one day of flow. [1:03:58] There's one day in there, but we really think it's really competitive and they're gonna have to work hard [1:04:04] We don't foresee additional time [1:04:06] But for those unforeseen things that come up will keep Travis and you guys inform if something major comes along that changes that [1:04:12] I don't know if I could ask a question if we had unscheduled weather cause a problem [1:04:17] What happens if we what have a wet windy spring? [1:04:19] if they have a wet windy spring they have to unless it's unreasonable and so [1:04:25] So if all weather goes our way between now and July, the project is new to complete July [1:04:36] 3rd. [1:04:37] If there's rain, they have to meet the schedule still. [1:04:41] This is Idaho. [1:04:42] Yeah. [1:04:43] So I believe, well, they show zero flute, but I think they'll truly work through it, or [1:04:50] I've tried to say that it is an event, [1:04:54] it's out of their control, which I think rain, [1:04:58] everybody understands the rains that I know, [1:04:59] so they should have looked at that [1:05:02] as far as they're scoping, and they're tiny. [1:05:05] But if we have a event like we had not long ago, [1:05:08] that could change, I mean, that's outside the normal. [1:05:11] Yeah, that was extraordinary. [1:05:14] Bless you. [1:05:18] As far as the 30-day look ahead, [1:05:20] they're going to continue to work on their own fast and dig the hole from the [1:05:25] clarifier and proceed in that. Some of the future change order, 317,000 to 18. This is [1:05:35] for while they've been working out there. At the very first before we set out this [1:05:40] bid, we wanted to make sure we made your budget because we're really nervous [1:05:46] about that and it came in under budget, quite a bit under budget. So in order to [1:05:51] that budget to be conservative in that we limited the paving operations and some [1:05:58] piping operations to just the project. Now that we saw that are under budget we [1:06:03] have change order reserves. I think the plan is to expand that asphalt a little [1:06:08] bit so like the area around the admin building there's trailers there there's [1:06:12] large equipment there and it's been pretty well tore up well this change order [1:06:16] would say let's repave it when we're done. Let's not stop at the project limits [1:06:20] that's due to the rest of that. [1:06:22] There's some irrigation piping associated with that [1:06:25] that would, so a portion of the project fixed the piping, [1:06:30] but it's stopped right at the project limit boundaries. [1:06:32] We take that up and fix that as well, [1:06:35] so that a future project won't have to deal with it. [1:06:38] That's what that 317, that is not executed yet, [1:06:42] but we would like to proceed with the execution. [1:06:45] I just want to bring in, this graph is somewhat hard [1:06:53] for me to read, but I think I finally got under control. [1:06:55] So these are requests for information. [1:06:57] So everything that the contractor wants to know about, [1:07:00] he writes down and says, how do we perform this work [1:07:02] that you've elegantly lined up for us? [1:07:05] And so they submit what they call our request [1:07:09] for information, RFI. [1:07:10] And so they get so many per month in total. [1:07:14] If you read this bar graph, so if you're looking [1:07:16] at these bars, read this side of it, the bar side. [1:07:19] If you're looking at the line as the total [1:07:21] three blind side of it. So you can see, so there's 44, five this much with 44 overall, [1:07:27] but then they have some middles. And this is amazing to me, 242 total submittals. Every [1:07:37] part they have to submit on the saves. This is the right bold. This is the right rebars. [1:07:42] This is the right concrete. And there's an engineer that looks at every single one of [1:07:45] those. And 11-8 turnaround is excellent. So I want to congratulate each term here while [1:07:51] I think they're doing a fantastic job at CI as well. [1:07:55] We're working with them. [1:07:57] And I think it really is a good project so far. [1:08:01] As part of that, not knowing who we're going to get, [1:08:04] we originally anticipated putting in a DRB board. [1:08:08] And it's a design review board, essentially [1:08:10] as a member of three people on this board. [1:08:15] The city and the contractor both put in half the money [1:08:19] for these three members. [1:08:20] And what it is is kind of often called a quasi-judicial [1:08:24] or whatever, but as three members, you go to them. [1:08:27] If you have a problem, you go to this person, [1:08:29] and they're like a mediator, and they say, [1:08:31] you feel this is reasonable, and you need to go this way [1:08:33] or that way, but they're really active. [1:08:35] They're on the project, and they're fixing stuff [1:08:37] as it goes on. [1:08:39] We've been so impressed by the contractor so far [1:08:43] that we have the board set up, we have the member, [1:08:46] and we feel that the schedules are going good, [1:08:49] and so far there's minimal resolutions needed for that. [1:08:54] So they're there in place in case a major catastrophe or something comes in because it is such a large project, but we hope we don't have to use them. [1:09:05] And then we've hired some other people. I'm not sure if this is legit or not, but we had this person out there operating machinery and I'm really certain of it. [1:09:19] I think that's when the insurance rates went up. [1:09:31] With that, I guess really the next part of the process down there is, [1:09:40] once the IFAS is built, we'll be at a certain flow rate. [1:09:44] You can see the resulting flow that we'll be allowed down at there. [1:09:57] The very next one that really comes up as a head works at Phase 3. [1:10:01] So we'll be, Phase 2 is what we're doing now. [1:10:03] Phase 3 is what we'd have to do in the future. [1:10:05] I fast, this is additional media. [1:10:08] This is somebody buying media that's just important. [1:10:11] We feel like we can put that on a major industry [1:10:14] if they came in or something like that. [1:10:16] If you want additional capacity, [1:10:18] you can purchase it, type thing. [1:10:20] But the headworks is a large one. [1:10:23] It's a very large number. [1:10:25] Currently, it has made us $6.5 million. [1:10:29] I guess I would like to come back to the council [1:10:31] because we haven't expanded the $34 million [1:10:36] allocated for this and recommend a hired CH2 deal to do a design of the [1:10:44] headwork so we can at least know how much is that six and a half exact and we have [1:10:49] a contractor outside on this past legal whether or not we can negotiate with [1:10:54] the existing contractor on a change order and put that in what kind of things [1:11:00] that is and then how we proceed here but I would actually like permission to [1:11:05] to bring staff report before you guys [1:11:09] in the future that recommends design of the headworks. [1:11:14] I think Chris might have a question, [1:11:16] might even be referenced. [1:11:18] I doubt it. [1:11:20] I'm just trying to put it all together [1:11:22] at the culmination of a successful phase three. [1:11:26] We will be able to increase our gallonage to 18 million. [1:11:32] Currently, once this project is complete, [1:11:35] will be in these numbers. [1:11:36] We would have to update the headworks and add media [1:11:40] and then we would be at these numbers. [1:11:42] And is that that July date that we're aiming at? [1:11:44] No, this is, this would be another phase out beyond. [1:11:51] When can we tell the public then that we will be at the next [1:11:57] stage of capacity increase? [1:12:01] Not by phases but approximately when, [1:12:04] Everything goes perfect. [1:12:06] Everything goes perfect. [1:12:08] July 4th is 13 million gallons and December 27th is 16 million gallons. [1:12:15] Is that noon or one o'clock? [1:12:18] Really? [1:12:19] Okay. [1:12:20] 13 million on, you said. [1:12:22] And 16. [1:12:23] And 16. [1:12:24] Yes. [1:12:25] Thank you. [1:12:26] So try, you were asking the question. [1:12:28] If it's asking permission from council to bring this staff report forward to us regarding [1:12:33] starting being proactive and looking at some design issues? [1:12:38] I guess I'm going to try to bring a staff report before you guys and recommend going ahead [1:12:43] with the design of the headworks and at that point, if you allow it, then I can take it back [1:12:50] to C and Stremel and they can tell me exactly what it is. [1:12:54] To construct currently, we'd have to make sure there's budget and numbers before we go before [1:13:00] but we haven't expended the full value of it. [1:13:05] Okay, so I think that Travis Wonder way. [1:13:07] Yes. [1:13:08] So if you look at the entire project, Troy is right, [1:13:11] that right now that we are realizing [1:13:13] some real savings associated with the project, [1:13:15] and that is outside of the money [1:13:17] that we've reserved for the collection system. [1:13:19] So know that the $6 million that we've placed off [1:13:22] to the site for collections is still intact [1:13:25] and we still fully intend to expand on collections [1:13:28] recommended by the citizen committee. [1:13:32] What Troy is talking about is the opportunity to spend the additional proceeds that have [1:13:37] already been bonded for. [1:13:38] So as you know, this project was bonded for in advance because of the size of it, we were [1:13:44] not able to cash flow this project moving forward. [1:13:48] And so we were able to take advantage of favorable interest rates and we sold the bond and now [1:13:53] we're using bond proceeds to pay for the project. [1:13:55] And it is our desire to advance the project and to expend as all of the bond proceeds that [1:14:04] we can, that we have available, to continue to expand the capacity of the treatment facility. [1:14:11] Right now, we're kind of on that bubble, that brink, right, of how much bond proceeds are [1:14:18] we going to have available by comparison to what is the early engineered estimated cost [1:14:25] of improving the Head Works facility. [1:14:28] And what Troy is asking is, or sharing, [1:14:31] is that we are going to start a process to negotiate, [1:14:35] unless there is extreme reservation from the council, [1:14:38] with CH for an additional project, [1:14:42] which is the Head Works facility, [1:14:44] to start understanding the scope. [1:14:46] And from that design, we are going to be able to understand [1:14:49] costs to see if now is the time that we can proceed [1:14:52] with the project. [1:14:53] If it's not, we still have been able to expand bond proceeds [1:14:57] on advanced design work, and that design's not going to go bad. [1:15:02] We'll be able to then take that off of the shelf [1:15:04] when the funding is available, and then to be able [1:15:07] to advance the construction at that point after we go [1:15:10] through some DEQ review approvals that is required, [1:15:14] and it's probably some additional cost modification associated [1:15:17] with the project, depending upon the duration, [1:15:19] it sits on the shelf should it have to do that. [1:15:23] So right now we're just you're just asking we're just sharing that it's coming right [1:15:28] yeah right okay and there's no additional monies being expanded it's just you would [1:15:33] like to yeah yeah we're good yeah that's right Chris talking I'm not so welcome back [1:15:40] I'm sorry to excuse me it was Rebecca's turn first I know it either way thank you [1:15:46] Mayor so if you do realize savings and there is additional bond money unspent what [1:15:52] What would happen to that money if it's not used? [1:15:57] We would definitely use it, hopefully at the waste rock tree go by. [1:16:01] We could use it at the collection lines. [1:16:07] Travis, did you want to weigh in on the question? [1:16:09] The reason Troy says that we will use it so enthusiastically was because there is no [1:16:15] other real legal alternative. [1:16:19] When we sold the bonds, we made a commitment that we would not do any early calls, [1:16:26] and so we can't take on used bond proceeds, we can't make advance payments, [1:16:30] we can't buy down the debt because we're under restricted bond covenants that we wouldn't do that. [1:16:37] Depending upon where arbitrage rules fall into play, there's a specific window of time in which bond proceeds must be sold. [1:16:44] I don't think that we're looking at any negative arbitrage, looking at Fritz. [1:16:49] Yeah, which is a really bad place to be. [1:16:53] So what we want to do is we want to be able to apply the bond proceeds appropriately. [1:16:58] And one of the things that we did when we asked the citizens to consider the project is [1:17:03] we asked for an expanded list outside of just phase two in the event that this would happen, [1:17:09] that we would have projects that we would be able to utilize the funding for moving forward. [1:17:16] If we reach a place that it is not enough money to cover the Head Works facility, then [1:17:23] we always have the opportunity to buy additional I pass media as shared by Troy. [1:17:28] Or we also have the opportunity to place more funding into the collections side of the equation. [1:17:36] And there's probably, as Jackie would share, probably more than $6 million worth the collection [1:17:42] work that could be done in our community to utilize those bond proceeds. [1:17:48] Okay. [1:17:49] Well, that helps. [1:17:50] So the conversation is not, if you're going to use the money, it's what you will use the [1:17:54] money on. [1:17:55] Okay. [1:17:56] Then I think that would be great if you could bring us a closer look at the options and then [1:18:01] we can decide collectively what's the most important to our citizens or to the waste of [1:18:08] our treatment plan. [1:18:09] Yeah. [1:18:10] We're just talking about. [1:18:12] Looking at the big picture now, our residential construction permits, like guess through February [1:18:20] was it, or through January, were 63 versus 40-some up the pretty significant amount. [1:18:29] Are these currently being given the will serves through new capacity, through existing capacity? [1:18:36] So we're still soaking up the old plant existing plant, but at such time in July 3rd, I mean, [1:18:45] we have new capacity for residential and or commercial. [1:18:50] That is correct. [1:18:52] But how much capacity do we have under the existing for a will serves? [1:18:59] Because that figure that comes to mind at all either residential. [1:19:03] So typically at the wastewater treatment plant on any given day, we have about 7 and 7.75 million gallons that are flowing into the plant daily. [1:19:14] Then we, the plant is rated to handle about 10 million gallons per day after the Chibani improvement. [1:19:20] Is that right, Sean? [1:19:22] 10-ish? [1:19:23] And that difference has been committed. [1:19:28] And so when we issue commercial building permits, residential building permits, [1:19:33] They are eating into that committed place and so we have we were truly over-committed at our waste water treatment plant at one point in time [1:19:42] prior to the passage of the bond, but that's the commitment that's not the actual flowing and [1:19:49] This allows us to continue to honor those commitments [1:19:52] We will be able to engage and and continue to work with developers as we move forward on issuing new commitments to [1:19:58] Utilize the capacity that's been created associated with this project and then not [1:20:03] Just one more little after thought Chibani's new pretreat, but we'll reduce the loading of provide a little more capacity or a little more breathing room [1:20:15] So the Chibani's [1:20:18] Improvement the Chibani improvements are more associated on the water side [1:20:23] So their RO system will utilize their RO system and they'll also utilize and [1:20:28] and improve their WAVE facility. [1:20:31] It does not do anything on their discharge side. [1:20:34] If I had to believe, if I had to bet, [1:20:36] Chibani will maximize their permit on a daily basis [1:20:39] because that is the production of yogurt. [1:20:42] Well, that issue I brought up to you about [1:20:43] though on Hankins Road and the odor problem, [1:20:46] I thought that was related to pretreatment of the waste stream. [1:20:50] It is utilization of the UASB. [1:20:53] The odor issue is different [1:20:57] than the flowing capacity. [1:20:59] Thank you. [1:21:00] Great, my name. [1:21:02] Well, I would hope that we would go forth [1:21:03] and get the what it was gonna cost over the headworks [1:21:07] and also I had to hope that we could, [1:21:09] we could go ahead and build the headworks [1:21:11] as I'm sure building it. [1:21:12] And now it's gonna be cheaper than it would be 35, [1:21:14] whatever the time spent down the road. [1:21:17] I know when during the committee meetings [1:21:21] to help us to decide what to build and things. [1:21:24] They wanted to set six million in size for collections, [1:21:28] but they also recognized that things make cost more, [1:21:31] so that's why we didn't go ahead [1:21:33] and aren't doing the collection things right now, [1:21:35] but they also understood if we could say [1:21:38] we didn't end up under at some point, [1:21:40] then there might be more for collections, [1:21:43] so it was a two-way street there, [1:21:45] as far as what we were planning, [1:21:47] but I would really like to see the headworks put in, [1:21:49] and if you could get us the numbers of what that's gonna cost [1:21:52] and whether we can build it under the bomb, [1:21:54] I would be appreciate that very much. [1:21:56] Thank you. [1:21:59] I don't see anyone arguing that point, [1:22:00] so there you go. [1:22:01] Thank you. [1:22:02] Appreciate it. [1:22:03] Mm-hmm. [1:22:07] Was it gray before all this, [1:22:09] or did this cause part of that? [1:22:12] Our questions. [1:22:14] Thank you very much, Trev, worthwhile. [1:22:17] Do we have any questions for Troy, [1:22:19] or do we have Sean in the audience, or? [1:22:23] Great report, so thank you. [1:22:25] Next item on the agenda is a discussion [1:22:28] and possible action on an agreement [1:22:29] between the city of Twin Falls and the city manager. [1:22:34] I'll start this conversation off [1:22:36] and ask a council to weigh in on the contract issue. [1:22:41] I was, as part of my professional development, [1:22:47] I had the opportunity of having a great leader in my life. [1:22:50] That taught me, he said one thing that stuck with me [1:22:53] and stuck with me my whole career actually, [1:22:55] is that you're not only responsible for what you do in life, but what you know. [1:23:01] And this really does kind of point towards what we're about to talk about, [1:23:07] about the having an agreement with our city manager. [1:23:10] And if you'll indulge me, I'll just read the first couple lines of the background [1:23:15] on this subject in our staff report here. [1:23:21] and the International State, the International City County Management Association's recruitment [1:23:27] guidelines for selecting a local government administrator's states. [1:23:32] It is in the interest of both the community and the chief administrator to have a working [1:23:37] summary of terms and conditions of employment to which both parties have agreed. [1:23:43] So we have been blessed, I guess, well, absolutely blessed in that we had a city manager in our [1:23:54] former government. [1:23:55] We had a city manager that spent 30 years with us. [1:24:00] And recently, fairly recently, we had the opportunity, when he retired, to hire another [1:24:08] city manager and we actually stole that city manager from a local community that came right [1:24:15] back and stole our assistant city manager so they got us back. [1:24:19] But as part of our strategic plan, we have eight different bullet points in our strategic [1:24:27] plan, our focus areas. [1:24:29] And one of the last is our internal organization, which means our staff. [1:24:34] So it's imperative that we, our professional, take care of our staff, [1:24:40] pay them appropriately, treat them appropriately, give them the tools necessary for [1:24:46] them to be able to do their jobs. [1:24:48] Because after all, what a city does is provide services. [1:24:54] And we provide our services through our human resources and that is our city staff. [1:25:00] And the person that is leading that city staff is our city manager. [1:25:06] And so as we found that it is best practice to have a contract with your city administrator or city manager. [1:25:16] And we started doing our research regarding this subject and [1:25:19] found that all the area city administrators and in Idaho there's only three city managers. [1:25:25] But they all have contracts. [1:25:28] And we did our due diligence looking at those contracts, and [1:25:32] melding them into a contract that is for us this evening. [1:25:38] We've had it vetted not only from us as a city council, but from our city of turning. [1:25:45] And also, I crimp attorneys to ensure that this made sense, that it was appropriate. [1:25:51] And so I personally am ready to move forward. [1:25:55] I think the last thing that I'll say, and why this is so important to me, is again, I found that we should have a management contract with our city administrator. [1:26:08] Once I found that out, I shared that with you. [1:26:13] I think it does two things. [1:26:16] It helps us retain our city manager. [1:26:22] And it also in the future, after he spends his 30 years with us like Tom did, it will [1:26:28] help us recruit a city manager. [1:26:30] So I'll turn it over for council discussion. [1:26:33] Chris, talk. [1:26:34] Well, Twin Falls is a $58 million business and we have a CEO that we call a city manager. [1:26:42] The workload upon the city manager has reached a point where we have required to reorganize [1:26:48] the city to provide some risk management from the internal operations and we're still [1:26:57] waiting and are very hopeful that's going to show fruit within the next couple of years. [1:27:02] However, let's get back to the business that we're involved with. [1:27:07] We have in the last several years $150 million, I think, capital projects that have run through [1:27:14] and are running through the city. [1:27:16] This is a great deal of responsibility of all the department heads, but it comes to rest [1:27:21] upon the City Council's shoulders. [1:27:23] That's if you look at our work description, fiscal control is a primary one. [1:27:33] When Don began showing the leadership for providing a contract for a City Manager, I looked at [1:27:39] reflecting on my business days that this is really a risk management and a very large [1:27:44] corporation. It just happens to be a non-profit business. With this 300 employees and $150 [1:27:54] million in projects, we have to treat our business operations competently, responsibly, and with [1:28:03] determination that the Council has to maintain a good work in relationship with the CEO. [1:28:11] And I think the proposed contract that's been worked on both legally and within the council [1:28:18] takes an important step to realize the professional nature of city management in Twin Falls for [1:28:26] us not to have some protection to retain our city manager, I think is irresponsible from [1:28:33] the taxpayer's point of view. [1:28:35] and totally supportive of the present proposed contract, [1:28:39] is good risk management. [1:28:41] Thank you, Chris. [1:28:42] Greg Mann. [1:28:43] Hi, Tom in favor of the contract that has been worked out. [1:28:48] I was recently, as in many of you know, [1:28:50] Suzanne and I are both on the board of directors of the AIC, [1:28:54] and we were there and to show the respect [1:28:57] throughout the state of Travis, [1:28:59] we started working on the possibility of adding a committee [1:29:03] to the AIC one for economic development. [1:29:06] The first name mentioned to be on that community [1:29:09] was Travis Wathler. [1:29:10] The very first name, no administrators, [1:29:13] other administrators, no mayors, no anybody. [1:29:16] The first name to come out of the mouth of anyone's mouth [1:29:18] was Travis and I think if this could help us [1:29:20] to keep Travis for a longer period of time, [1:29:23] then I am 100% in favor. [1:29:25] Thank you, Greg. [1:29:27] Suzanne Hawkins. [1:29:30] Without taking a lot of time, [1:29:31] I agree with everything that's been said here. [1:29:33] I think this is the right choice and I think this is the right time to do it and I support it. [1:29:37] Thank you, Suzanne. [1:29:39] Jim. [1:29:40] Thank you very much. [1:29:41] It's going to take just a moment, Mayor. [1:29:44] But what I want to reiterate is something Chris said here. [1:29:47] And this is kind of going on a political limb, but strong mayor governments are always at risk for things to go bad because it's a lay person in a position of a CEO. [1:30:00] It's like taking somebody in the community [1:30:03] who's popular and making the CEO of a 58 million dollar company. It's probably not a good idea and [1:30:12] We I worked with Travis both from a staff perspective and in a position on the council and we are blessed to have a [1:30:21] well-educated professional person managing our corporation and [1:30:27] I've had time to reflect on this [1:30:30] I believe it is absolutely fair and provides him, I think, a good solid insurance. [1:30:39] So we have to remember that this is a corporation and we have to hire educated, trained people [1:30:46] to manage the corporation and I'm very comfortable with this and I'm very comfortable in your [1:30:52] work. [1:30:53] Thank you, Jim. [1:30:57] I think I'll just end by saying that we do have a very competent city manager. [1:31:06] I think that this contract protects not only our city manager, but it also holds us as a [1:31:14] city council accountable that there's due process in how we treat our staff and how we [1:31:23] respect them. [1:31:25] And there's even built in benchmarks of us having to go back and [1:31:31] review this contract in every five years to ensure that it is still meeting best practices. [1:31:37] And meeting the needs of not only the city, but also our professional manager that is running the day to day operations of our city. [1:31:46] Chris, talking to you. [1:31:47] I'd like to move to approve the agreement as proposed between the city of Twin Falls and [1:31:53] Can I have us boss? [1:31:54] Roth father is setting manager. [1:31:55] Okay. [1:31:56] We have a motion on the floor by Kristin seconded by great glanting to approve the contract as printed in front of us this evening. [1:32:07] Do we have anything further on this motion council? [1:32:12] The aye will roll call vote please. [1:32:14] Jim Munn. [1:32:15] Yes. [1:32:15] Sean Berreger. [1:32:16] Yes. [1:32:17] Chris Tocantan. [1:32:17] Yes. [1:32:18] Greg Lanthi. [1:32:19] Yes. [1:32:19] Don Hall. [1:32:20] Yes. [1:32:21] Rebecca Masleka. [1:32:22] Yes. [1:32:23] Suzanne Honkens. [1:32:23] Yes. [1:32:24] motion passes seven to zero, and council, we're just, we're growing up to be kind of a city. [1:32:31] I'm very, very proud of us. [1:32:34] Next item on the agenda. [1:32:36] Oh, I'm sorry, Chris talking to them. [1:32:37] But Don, as the contract indicates, we're going to have to review this annually to make updates. [1:32:44] So there is responsibility in our part. [1:32:46] Well, I think annually if we choose to we will but we are forced actually in the contract [1:32:52] We have to review it every five years. Well, but section three salary reflects only current salary [1:32:59] And so that they'll have to have some attention or amending [1:33:03] Well, I think in the contract Chris it actually states that it will keep up with what the salaries [1:33:10] Across the board in the city [1:33:12] If there's a raise then this one. So that's just a baseline that we're saying [1:33:17] up to five years we don't have to [1:33:21] Make any adjustments for amendments then yes to the contract, but automatically salary changes will take place. Yes very good. Thank you for bringing that up next item on the agenda is [1:33:34] Discussion and possible action about considering any Snake River Canyon jump activity in 2015 [1:33:40] And we have our city manager, Travis Rother, who's a little red right now. [1:33:44] Well, first, thank you for the generous comments and it's a pleasure working with you to complete [1:33:53] the city's business. [1:33:55] I firmly agree that the success that we've had as an organization is a result of the partnership [1:34:01] but also a result of the team that I have working directly with me. [1:34:06] I am blessed every day to work with some of the best people in local government. [1:34:10] And it's the work that we do collectively that allows us to accomplish the public good. [1:34:15] So thank you for that opportunity. [1:34:19] And now to jumping to Kenya. [1:34:24] So a year ago, maybe to kind of set the stage as you'll recall, we've spent significant [1:34:31] amount of time at the staff level and at the council level every single meeting going through [1:34:36] in having a series of conversations about jumps and jump activities and jump opportunities. [1:34:45] And the Council felt a year ago that the situation was just not maturing and perfecting itself [1:34:52] in a manner that allowed for us to meet all the requirements that we had set forward very [1:34:58] early on. [1:34:59] And at that time the City Council elected not to consider any jump activity to occur within [1:35:06] the city's corporate boundary for a period of one year. [1:35:11] Time flies. [1:35:13] That one year time has now expired. [1:35:17] And so that we don't go through the same processes that we've gone through last year. [1:35:23] And so that we have an opportunity to be better positioned to respond to inquiries should they [1:35:29] be made. [1:35:31] We wanted to have this conversation with you tonight to kind of seek direction. [1:35:35] But to see if there was any circumstance that you would consider entertaining requests that [1:35:46] may come in, I will say for the record we have not been contacted directly by any of [1:35:53] the firms that we had been engaged with previously. [1:35:59] However, I do know that both there are at least two groups [1:36:03] that are still actively pursuing their ambitions [1:36:07] and their goals to consider to jump the Snake River Canyon. [1:36:12] And so that we can provide them and also the members [1:36:15] of our community with good information moving forward. [1:36:18] We want to have this dialogue and conversation [1:36:21] with the Council. [1:36:22] So that kind of sets that stage this evening and we'll be happy [1:36:27] as a staff to respond to any questions that you may have as you deliberate through this process. [1:36:33] Turn it on to council for questions and or deliberation. Chris talking. [1:36:38] Show me your safety plan. That's what I'll say. And I think that we kept asking, we never got a response. [1:36:45] And beyond that, I don't have a lot of problem with if two or 20 come in. [1:36:52] in, but if they do not provide a sufficient scaled out safety plan upfront within a reasonable [1:36:59] period of time, forget it. [1:37:01] And if they do, God bless them and pack your parachute. [1:37:05] Chris Schonberger. [1:37:06] You have to say my opinion has not changed on this issue from a year ago and my opinion [1:37:13] at that time was come to us with a plan that helps to protect the community image and allows [1:37:21] you to put on an event and an activity that serves your needs and doesn't disrupt or put [1:37:29] undue burden on the taxpayers and tie that all up with a bow and sit it in front of me [1:37:33] and I'll let you know what I think about it. [1:37:35] But to go through an ongoing negotiation of what is or isn't in the best interest of the [1:37:42] community or the event promoter and trying to spend an inordinate amount of time figuring [1:37:48] that out. If you don't, if you're not sharp enough on the front-hand to know what that means, [1:37:54] don't even come knocking until you have that all ready to go. [1:37:58] Sean, Greg Manning. Well, I'm pretty close to what I'm kind of the same as both of the previous [1:38:07] two speakers. I mean, I am not inverse to a jump. First thing I'll make that clear. [1:38:13] One, I don't think it's going to be nearly as large of gathering of people as we once thought [1:38:18] it might be based on the previous time because as I've used this analogy before at this point [1:38:25] the technology is as fast as such the point that you could strap a person underneath the [1:38:29] drone at the Twin Falls airport and I haven't landed the drone airport nobody even though [1:38:34] it occurred and so I don't technologically I think that's probably why they're having [1:38:38] so much trouble with the TV contract. [1:38:43] Having it happen is certainly different than it was 40 years ago or the ability to do so. [1:38:48] But I'm like the other two basically said the same thing. [1:38:53] I think that was our mistake in the way we did it last time. [1:38:55] I think we should have been evaluating a complete plan for everything presented to us, like [1:39:02] Sean said, with a bow on it. [1:39:04] And if we should have been selecting who jumped based on that, not on just having present [1:39:11] an idea of what they're going to have happen and select from that. [1:39:14] If we'd been selecting from a complete plan, it may have been somebody different. [1:39:17] It might have been the same people. [1:39:19] We just would have had a complete plan [1:39:21] and be ready to go. [1:39:22] I'm willing to look at that, but I don't like the others. [1:39:26] If it's not something that I feel comfortable with, [1:39:29] I reserve the right to say no to all parties. [1:39:32] If it's not a complete plan, [1:39:34] they're ready for us to just implement it. [1:39:37] And including their remuneration to the city [1:39:40] and everything else, everything being [1:39:41] tied up in one package. [1:39:44] Thank you, Greg, Jim. [1:39:46] Thank you, Mayor. [1:39:48] I also agree with both everyone here. [1:39:50] I do think there is validity in what Greg said in that, [1:39:54] jumping the canyon with a rocket in 2015 [1:39:57] has less appeal than it did in 1970, whatever it was for. [1:40:04] And I just don't think it's like Woodstock. [1:40:08] It was okay in 69, but in 2015, [1:40:10] you know, it's just not that cool anymore. [1:40:12] I believe, my idea was to put just a permanent moratorium [1:40:17] one jumping from the city limits involved. [1:40:20] But I think being, trying to be a bit more reasonable, [1:40:24] I agree with Sean, bring us a completed staff work [1:40:29] with an entire plan that we can deliberate on, [1:40:33] and I would look at it. [1:40:37] So, Suzanne Hopkins. [1:40:38] Thank you. [1:40:40] I would have to think looking down the road, [1:40:42] you know, the 45th anniversary, [1:40:43] the 50th anniversary were probably gonna go down [1:40:46] the same road again. [1:40:47] I would think somebody's going to be really pushing for it. [1:40:51] Not to tie the hands of future councils [1:40:53] who would be here during that time. [1:40:55] But I think maybe if we could come up [1:40:56] with some kind of an application packet that tells [1:40:59] specifically what we want, the safety plan, the cost, [1:41:04] more of the, how are you going to keep this from burdening us [1:41:08] up front so that the people that are putting ideas together [1:41:12] don't bring us half baked plans like they did last time, [1:41:15] because we gave them no specifics. [1:41:17] And I don't think it's fair just to say, [1:41:18] bring us your plan again. [1:41:20] So I think maybe if we just had a small packet [1:41:22] of information that says, you know, [1:41:23] if you really want to consider this, [1:41:25] this is the information you need to have organized [1:41:28] and put together before you bring it to the council, [1:41:31] before you waste staff time on helping you find your answers, [1:41:36] then I think it's something we, [1:41:38] I don't think we should just say no, [1:41:39] we're never going to do this again. [1:41:40] I think we're big enough to handle it [1:41:42] and I think we could do it right. [1:41:45] Thank you, Suzanne. [1:41:47] I just want to weigh in. [1:41:48] I'm kind of leaning more towards, as I was listening to my [1:41:51] fellow council persons up here, that I agreed with what they [1:41:56] said, bring us your plan. [1:41:59] But the whole time they were saying that, I was thinking, [1:42:02] what is that plan? [1:42:03] What are the specifics? [1:42:05] So I agree with you. [1:42:05] We need to give some guidance to draft some sort of an [1:42:11] application where we talk about kind of the same things we [1:42:14] did before, cheap bike, then cheap bike, you know, traffic flow issues, emergency services, [1:42:25] yeah, accessibility, any kind of security operations around, and I don't truly have my [1:42:35] hands around what that actually looks like other than I know that we do need to have [1:42:40] some bullet points. They need to address these items before we will entertain an application. [1:42:47] So maybe I'll just ask you, Travis, do you have any thoughts or are you Deputy City Manager? [1:42:54] Pike, do you have any thoughts when it comes to specifics that we can start talking about? [1:42:59] So I think the first thing, we do have a special event permit that we can use as a base template. [1:43:04] that, and we can modify that specific to this event to help provide some level of guidance. [1:43:10] I think we also recognize, and I think that we was illustrated last time, that any event [1:43:16] of this magnitude is going to draw on resources outside of just the City of Twin Falls' corporate [1:43:22] boundaries. [1:43:23] And so what we will want to do is when we're asking for a construction of a safety plan and [1:43:27] elements to be included, that we also gather the thoughts and concepts from the other local [1:43:32] law enforcement partners that we have in the areas that could be largely impacted and [1:43:38] also from those other public safety entities, fire, EMS and the like. [1:43:44] And maybe we could have a quick conversation with them about what are these items that [1:43:48] need to be included for a safety plan from a dress standpoint, like how are you going [1:43:55] to ensure that travel across the bridge is maintained? [1:43:59] How are you going to be able to ensure that onlookers are going to be safe inside the community? [1:44:06] What is your availability to provide the 100% full cost of security as it may be needed for [1:44:15] staging and for events? [1:44:16] We can put that stuff together as providing for an outline, but I would just ask the council [1:44:25] And those applicants who may be listening in or may come back [1:44:29] and review this, that we are probably not going to be able [1:44:33] to develop that all-inclusive thing. [1:44:35] That as those plans are developed, there may be that one [1:44:38] glaring area that we inadvertently left out of the [1:44:43] conversation that would need to be covered. [1:44:46] And it's not any active malice that we would disclose that. [1:44:51] It would just be active knowledge as we kind of progress [1:44:53] through this process. [1:44:55] The last thing I would say is that we did spend a lot of time developing an agreement. [1:45:00] And I think that that agreement can serve as the base foundation with some modifications from the staff perspective to be able to move it forward. [1:45:09] Travis, I would also make this suggestion. [1:45:12] I think you're absolutely right. [1:45:13] We need to reach out with our other partners, the county, the state, all these other folks, [1:45:20] specifically the county because we have county within the city that could be [1:45:27] utilized for a jump that will directly affect us. So as we're developing this [1:45:33] and we're working with them as partners, if we could share that same kind of [1:45:37] application plan that maybe they might want to also institute because it [1:45:42] directly affects us because we're attached, you know, the county city are [1:45:47] together. [1:45:48] We're all going to be too. [1:45:49] We're all going to be too. [1:45:50] We're all going to be too. [1:45:51] Good point, Chris. [1:45:52] We need to work together on these issues, these big plans, but they're, all it is an imaginary [1:45:58] line. [1:45:59] It's going to affect both of us. [1:46:00] These lines between City limits and County, they're just imaginary. [1:46:06] People walk across them, drive across them all the time. [1:46:09] So let's reach out and get their engagement and maybe hopefully I would like to see them [1:46:16] to incorporate what we're talking about here. [1:46:20] Like Travis said though, we have that agreement [1:46:22] that we spent untold hundreds of hours on, [1:46:24] that's right in front of us. [1:46:26] I agree, that's a starting template. [1:46:29] Yeah, I agree with that, Chris. [1:46:32] Sean Barr? [1:46:34] So going back to the process from before, [1:46:36] truthfully I think taking the general parameters [1:46:40] that we outlined in the initial request for qualifications, [1:46:44] perhaps coupling that with some of the concepts [1:46:47] the agreement but to Travis's point we can't sit first of all it's not our event [1:46:53] this is the argument we had a year ago this is not our event this is somebody [1:46:57] else's event coming to us we can't lay out every detail of every impact of an [1:47:03] event that isn't even ours in the first place and when you miss the one thing [1:47:08] now you're the bad guy because you didn't tell them about this one thing so I [1:47:11] I think keeping a generalized concept and an openness to entertain a proposal, but a proposal [1:47:20] isn't, I got to have an idea, let's jump the canyon. [1:47:24] That is not a proposal. [1:47:26] And that's all we heard for eight months last year. [1:47:31] So I think directing staff to spend any time developing anything beyond what we already [1:47:38] have in anticipation of someone might ask us, is heading us down the path of wasting a whole [1:47:45] bunch of energy and time on something that I'm not confident is going to happen. [1:47:50] I don't believe that we would have to spend a significant amount of staff time based upon [1:47:55] the time that we've already spent to get to this place of some of the other tools, but [1:47:59] I would agree we have to have some idea and knowledge of what the event is going to look [1:48:03] like and location is everything where the location occurs is going to largely [1:48:09] determine the type of safety plan that's going to be needed and the other issues of consideration so we will we will certainly throw that in. [1:48:16] What I've heard is don't bring Travis maybe I'll stop you there because we have [1:48:22] okay last council member wants to weigh in and I want to make sure that Hurley [1:48:26] get incorporated? Oh, no, I I was just gonna weigh in. Something you said Travis, I do [1:48:34] understand where Sean's going with, you know, not getting weighed down again in the process, [1:48:39] but I agree with the how questions. I think one of the mistakes we made in the past was [1:48:44] not requesting specific enough criteria or not knowing what we were looking for. And so I [1:48:53] I like those how questions because I think they're open-ended and general enough to provide [1:48:59] the applicant direction and of course it will be up to interpretation and subjective according [1:49:06] to staffing council if their answers have addressed those questions but I think we do [1:49:11] need to ask a series of questions on some sort of application so that they know what they're [1:49:17] looking to construct and so also that we can understand better what we're looking for should [1:49:26] a safety plan be proposed to us and I would just weigh in that from what I've heard there [1:49:32] are still those two ongoing jumps and so to me not too much has changed from a year ago [1:49:40] because we're still facing the possibility of these two jumps and I know something that [1:49:45] that was said last year was we don't have the officers, we don't have the safety staff, [1:49:53] and so I think we need to be prepared for whatever role we are going to play should these [1:50:00] jumps take place because I'm not sure what has changed about our staffing levels or what [1:50:05] has changed about our preparedness. [1:50:10] What I agree with Suzanne, I think we are large enough and are capable of handling whatever [1:50:16] comes our way, whether it's a neighboring event in the county or whether it happens to [1:50:21] be surrounded by city, you know, wherever that takes place, but I think we need to be prepared. [1:50:31] So we will take the thoughts and we will begin that process. [1:50:37] What I've heard, and I just want to state it to make sure that I heard this right, is [1:50:42] The council does not want to see any plans that the staff do not believe have been perfected. [1:50:49] I'll show you that again now. [1:50:54] The city council does not want to see any proposals or jumps by any proposals that we [1:51:01] do not believe have not been perfected. [1:51:06] Covering safety plans, covering offsetting costs, covering protection of images. [1:51:14] So simply what I'm saying is, or what I'm hearing is you don't want to see it until [1:51:20] it's at a certain place. [1:51:23] So there needs to be a judge in that process. [1:51:27] And I'm asking is if you feel it's appropriate that city staff, mainly our leadership team, [1:51:34] be the first guardian at the gate, if you will, of any plan moving forward. [1:51:41] of that we're not going to have any guidance on what to put on the agenda and when to put [1:51:45] it on. [1:51:46] So if a group comes tomorrow and says we're ready to go with a safety plan and here's our [1:51:52] safety plan but we don't believe that safety plan meets the safety needs of the community [1:51:57] that we as a staff can say you're not ready we're not placing that on the agenda for council [1:52:02] consideration. [1:52:03] Rebecca Milsock. [1:52:05] Thank you. [1:52:06] I don't know if I would personally say that because I know the last applicant did submit [1:52:12] a safety plan and I know staff felt that it was inadequate, but I wouldn't preclude anyone [1:52:17] from coming to council. I mean, it's the right of the public to really, we've said anyone, [1:52:24] can be on the agenda and place themselves on the agenda. I think if they do come unprepared, [1:52:28] it will certainly hear that from the council and will certainly respect staff's recommendation. [1:52:36] But I wouldn't say no to anyone that wants to be heard, [1:52:41] but granted they'll have to understand [1:52:44] that the answer from the council will probably be no. [1:52:49] Shambara. [1:52:50] I was gonna say perfected may be a strong word, [1:52:53] but complete might be a good word. [1:52:58] That if someone were to come to staff [1:53:02] with a half-baked idea, which we heard a lot of last year, [1:53:06] That isn't worth anybody's time to bring forward. [1:53:09] But if they say, here's my safety plan, here's my event's going to be this weekend, [1:53:14] and I think this many people are going to be here, and here's where I want to do it. [1:53:17] Even if it's not perfected, that is certainly more complete, [1:53:23] or at least addresses maybe those criteria that you might lay out, [1:53:27] because I don't want to necessarily put the burden on staff either to assess [1:53:32] what is or isn't perfect. [1:53:35] I mean, you all have a pretty good sense of what the seven of us expect out of this, but [1:53:42] as Rebecca said, the final no or yes comes from here. [1:53:48] And if they come into it with something that is not complete, the answer is going to be [1:53:54] no. [1:53:55] If they come with something that, okay, you've addressed all the areas, we have concerns [1:53:58] with how this is happening, this is happening, that's a negotiation and that's a discussion. [1:54:03] Chris, talking? [1:54:04] I think I'm agreeing with the past speakers. [1:54:07] I think we're the guardians of the gate, [1:54:09] and any and all comers come here in mouth off, [1:54:13] provide golden suggestions or worthless ones, [1:54:16] and then we could keep you from being the lightning rod [1:54:20] and having to offend with them. [1:54:22] So I would prefer, frankly, they come to us, [1:54:25] first of all, we can shake them out. [1:54:31] Remember last time we gave preference [1:54:33] to the high bidder of the state land, [1:54:36] and that drove our entire decision. [1:54:41] I guess I'm a little confused. [1:54:44] I like the, I agree with Sean, [1:54:46] I didn't like the word perfected [1:54:49] because in the eye of the beholder's perfection, right? [1:54:53] But complete or at least at a stage [1:54:57] that staff can look at this application process [1:54:59] and say, you know, this looks like it's something [1:55:03] that with our judgment of doing special event permits [1:55:08] on a regular basis that meets this criteria, [1:55:11] let's bring this to staff, to council. [1:55:14] I'm comfortable with that. [1:55:16] I don't want them all coming to us anytime they want. [1:55:19] I mean, certainly we have an open floor here [1:55:24] with some modification and regulated here, [1:55:29] but I'd rather go through the process [1:55:32] of this application process. [1:55:34] It gets to a point where it looks like it's [1:55:36] might work with your judgment and then bring that to us. [1:55:41] That's where I'm at, in my sense. [1:55:43] Well, I was going to agree with that. [1:55:45] First of all, the seven of us are not professionals. [1:55:47] We're not professionals. [1:55:51] They are. I think that this is one of those situations where we need to trust our staff, [1:55:57] in public safety, city administration, [1:56:00] in making initial determinations on whether this thing can go forward. [1:56:03] Because I mean, you know, we're like it whether we want to be or not. This is not our [1:56:12] It's not our forte and certainly we'll make the last decision based on the staff recommendation [1:56:17] But we got to keep in perspective here. They're the ones who make the [1:56:22] Determination and whether safe dual will so forth not seven citizens [1:56:27] Is that in Hawkins? [1:56:29] I guess I would look at it as any special events permit. Staff goes through it first and make sure that it's complete and you wouldn't bring us a half [1:56:38] completed application on any special event. So I would say if you know you consider this a special event and weigh it with the same [1:56:46] that you do any other special use of and it should all fall in the same category, correct? [1:56:51] Well, I think, so the reason I asked the question was because not that I have any particular [1:56:57] care of being the guardian of the gate, in fact I would, that was, I thought the response. [1:57:04] But I didn't want to have, starting next week or some subsequent week, this reappearing [1:57:10] and us going back through that same process and the council saying, we had this conversation, [1:57:16] We set out these guidelines, why are these items continually coming onto the Council's [1:57:22] agenda for debate and consideration? [1:57:26] So from my perspective, just looking for guidance, and if it is to use the typical special events [1:57:35] process as kind of a guide, if we feel it's a complete application, it's an effort that [1:57:41] was done in earnest, we can share that with the Council at that particular point. [1:57:49] I just don't want to be in a position where it appears that the City staff is in bar going [1:57:55] items from appearing to go on to the agenda and without some understanding from the Council [1:58:01] that in understanding of what that process looks like for both of us moving forward in [1:58:06] you this. We're happy to do it any way you want us to do it. [1:58:14] Yeah, here's what I here's what I'm going to say utilize the special event [1:58:21] application process modified because we can modify that from what we learned from [1:58:26] the past utilize that bring us a completed special event modify application when [1:58:32] you're comfortable and be totally honest with you with us about and I know you will [1:58:41] about whether you think this is doable or not because sometimes it got you know [1:58:45] I mean it got a little bit like it and I think and that's my charge is that [1:58:49] you're the professional and your team of professionals can really guide us in [1:58:54] down this road so just be totally upfront regardless of the political [1:58:58] implications. You sound good counsel do you feel good about your [1:59:04] direction. I think we do. Okay. Very good. Thanks. Thank you, Mr. City Manager. Next item on the agenda is public input and our items from City Manager City Council will start with the public. Is there anyone here from the public that would like to come forward and address the Council? Now is your [1:59:22] opportunities one more time. [1:59:24] I didn't want to make eye contact. [1:59:26] He didn't want to make eye contact. [1:59:28] Teasing about it. [1:59:30] So I see no one coming forward. [1:59:34] City manager. [1:59:35] Just a quick report on Thursday's [1:59:38] opportunity to gather with the members of our [1:59:40] local legislative delegation. [1:59:42] I thought it was a wonderful opportunity in [1:59:45] exchange. [1:59:46] There are probably two significant issues that I [1:59:50] think that we need to continue to keep and work [1:59:53] the pulse of the first is any modifications or changes to urban renewal statutes as we shared [1:59:59] Melinda and I both have been selected or asked by the speaker to serve on this committee [2:00:04] to help work through those issues and it's good so far. We'll hopefully continue to be [2:00:11] able to advance some of the thoughts to provide constructive changes. [2:00:15] The second is our water issues and as many have probably seen and as it's been reported [2:00:23] The rank and call is in a state of state for a few more days. [2:00:29] And we believe that every indication is that the rank and call requirements will be met. [2:00:36] It affects 14 cities in the Magic Valley and about 150,000 acres. [2:00:40] The city of Twin Falls is not directly included in that water call. [2:00:45] Had we been, we would have been obviously sharing this much well before you. [2:00:48] But now, but obviously, there's a huge potential [2:00:51] indirect implication to our local economy, [2:00:55] and to many processors. [2:00:57] And so, as water issues continue to move forward, [2:01:00] I've asked that the City of Flint falls be invited [2:01:03] to participate, and I've offered our assistance [2:01:05] any way that would be appropriate, [2:01:08] recognizing that we're a user of the system, [2:01:11] and that we may not be welcome because of our seniority [2:01:15] that we have in our water rights, in all conversations. [2:01:18] Thank you Travis, anything from City Council? [2:01:22] Rebecca Millsong? [2:01:23] Thank you, Mayor. [2:01:25] Well, unfortunately this past week, [2:01:26] we had an incident with a vicious animal. [2:01:29] And so I just wanted to touch on that. [2:01:33] And hopefully, well, first to say, [2:01:36] great job to the animal control, [2:01:38] who quickly resolved the issue. [2:01:40] And also to maybe set up for a future agenda, [2:01:45] discussion about our leash laws and our code, not only for the education of the community, [2:01:54] but also to get some feedback from animal control. [2:01:57] You know, unfortunately I had an incident last fall with some vicious dogs and lost a pet. [2:02:04] And you know, most of us pets our family and so, you know, it's important to all of us, [2:02:10] especially if it involves lives, children. [2:02:14] So I became aware, a lot of people reached out to me after that incident that in some [2:02:20] neighborhoods it's been described as an epidemic, you know, a lot of people don't take the leash [2:02:27] loss seriously and it's a great danger to our community. [2:02:31] But I also learned the sheer volume and immensity of the issue in our community which I think [2:02:37] I previously taken for granted the safety and the situation that I had been enjoying in my [2:02:44] own neighborhood with not having the issue of vicious dogs at large, really very common. [2:02:54] But I know that lots of other areas and neighborhoods actually have this problem, and so I just wanted [2:03:00] to bring it up and it will be a good chance for the council to review our current code. [2:03:07] And a lot of cities do it differently, there are a lot of other communities inside the state and [2:03:11] outside the state that have either more broad or more free, or also more regulated codes. [2:03:21] So I think it's a good time, I think this incident with one of our citizens really brought [2:03:28] it back to me, the importance of safety in our community. [2:03:32] And so I would like to ask the council if they'd be open to that and staff if they wouldn't mind just preparing a small report. [2:03:41] So we can get an idea, all of us get an idea of really what you deal with on a city-wide basis. [2:03:49] So that we can have an understanding of how we can best ensure the safety of our neighborhoods when it comes to dogs at large and vicious animals. [2:03:59] All of our Rebecca was talking, I was trying to take a head not poll from the council. [2:04:06] And I think most of us are interested in this. [2:04:08] Maybe we could have some stats, like you say, what our current ordinances are. [2:04:14] Get some input from our animal control officers, as well as other public safety officials, [2:04:19] not just police, but our folks that go out and read meters and everything else. [2:04:24] They come in contact with the animals. [2:04:26] Is our ordinance and our codes adequate for where we are today? [2:04:32] So maybe a report in that respect and some personal opinion? [2:04:36] Could we get that provided to us? [2:04:39] Absolutely. [2:04:40] What we'll do is we'll look on the upcoming agenda and we'll make sure it's calendar within the next month. [2:04:45] I believe that we have everyone's schedules of when they're going to be in attendance. [2:04:50] And so we'll utilize that to make sure that we have everyone available to have a conversation about the topic. [2:04:56] Thank you very much. [2:04:57] Chris. [2:04:58] Yeah. [2:04:59] We brought up this issue early on. [2:05:00] I think the council needs to direct planning and zoning or impact fee or somebody to review [2:05:06] the park and luthy structure that has not been reviewed for some time. [2:05:12] Not even sure how to get a handle on it, but to make sure that our costs are legitimate and [2:05:20] pay for themselves. [2:05:22] I think that's a good idea as well. [2:05:24] But I took another head nod. [2:05:27] We'll do that. [2:05:28] A lot of head nodding going on. [2:05:30] Yeah, a lot of head nodding going on. [2:05:31] So anything else from Council? [2:05:35] I wanted to bring to your attention. [2:05:37] I went to coffee with the new radio host at clicks [2:05:41] a few weeks ago. [2:05:42] I shared that with you. [2:05:44] But between then and now, the radio management [2:05:47] has contacted me again. [2:05:49] And they are extremely interested in zooming in some way [2:05:54] our radio appearances on their radio station. [2:05:58] They assured me that all members of the council are welcome, [2:06:02] and that it will stay that way. [2:06:07] They assured me that they would like to work with us on [2:06:12] the actual agenda of us going out there and having some talking points for, [2:06:17] we get out there that we would have some kind of idea of what we'd be talking about. [2:06:24] Of course, when people call in, you take the calls, of course, [2:06:27] and I think we're all okay with that. [2:06:30] But I just wanted to ask Council what their thought [2:06:34] and interest is to resume this in some manifestation [2:06:38] or another. [2:06:39] I did share with them that maybe there should be [2:06:42] a government day that go ahead and maybe folks [2:06:45] from the county and other cities in our region [2:06:49] might be invited as well, and they were open to that. [2:06:53] So, Rebecca Milsoyka. [2:06:56] Thank you, Mayor. [2:06:57] Well, I think the radio is a really important way [2:07:01] to communicate with our citizens. [2:07:02] I think I'm glad that they want to bring it back, [2:07:05] and I would be happy to participate, [2:07:07] because I felt like that was a great opportunity for us, [2:07:10] as elected officials, to communicate directly [2:07:13] with the public and be available for their questions [2:07:17] and their thoughts and collecting their input. [2:07:19] So I would be happy to see us resume our participation because I feel that that's important for us as elected officials to be out there and available. [2:07:29] And of course, as it was before it's voluntary, there are some events that some of us participate in and some not. [2:07:37] So it doesn't have to be a mandatory thing, but I find it an essential part of my job as a council member and I think it's important to be there. [2:07:47] Suzanne Hawkins did you contact other radio stations to see if anyone else was interested as well instead of [2:07:55] Tying down to just one I have not contacted other radio stations. They contacted me. Okay, so and I did not contact them asking [2:08:02] Okay, I'm good with [2:08:05] However, I have no problem doing the radio, but I would also like to see us maybe looking at other media outlets because I think there's a [2:08:14] the listenership there that's very dedicated, but I'm not sure how far out into the community [2:08:19] it actually reaches. [2:08:20] I got another head nod, Paul, from our PIO, he's going to check on that. [2:08:26] Thank you. [2:08:27] Can't be teed on. [2:08:28] And did you not it as well? [2:08:30] Can't be teed it. [2:08:31] Great landing. [2:08:32] Yeah, I'm willing to go ahead and re-enter the market that we were in before. [2:08:40] I really do like your idea though is that maybe getting County Commissioners spaced out [2:08:45] through the program or the order of things and then, you know, every once a month, maybe [2:08:54] they have, we could include Filer, Kimberly, Wendell, or not, I mean, well, even the North [2:09:02] Side kind of community, so that matter, Jerome, because they're all in leadership on the same [2:09:06] radio station and I'm not sure why we would want to monopolize it so it might [2:09:11] cut it down so we're only there once every 10 weeks or something I mean even [2:09:15] less of a problem but I'm going to go back. Very good. I think I have enough [2:09:21] information I will contact the management and share our thoughts with [2:09:25] them and see if we can develop some sort of a plan. All right if there's nothing [2:09:29] else we are going to go to our last agenda item and it is an executive [2:09:34] of session 672345, one C to conduct deliberations concerning labor negotiations [2:09:41] or to acquire an interest in real property which is not owned by a public agency. [2:09:46] I'll stand for motion council, Sean Berger. [2:09:49] So moved. [2:09:50] Second. [2:09:51] We have motion on the floor by Sean Berger, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to move [2:09:55] into executive session as stated anything further on that motion council. [2:10:00] Leila, roll call vote. [2:10:02] Sean Berger. [2:10:03] Yes. [2:10:03] is talking to yes Greg Lanci yes Don Hall yes Rebecca [2:10:08] Melsoika yes Suzanne Hawkins yes Jim yes we will be moving into [2:10:13] executive session we will not be reconvening out and making any [2:10:17] more decisions to see but that we are adjourned into executive [2:10:21] session [2:10:35] You are a role. [2:10:36] I'm going to break the door. [2:10:37] I'm going to break the door. [2:10:38] Thank you. [2:10:39] I'm going to break the door. [2:10:42] I'm going to break the door. [2:10:43] I'm going to break the door. [2:10:44] I'm going to break the door. [2:10:45] I'm going to break the door. [2:10:46] I'm going to break the door. [2:10:47] I'm going to break the door. [2:10:48] I'm going to break the door. [2:10:50] I'm going to break the door. [2:10:51] I'm going to break the door. [2:10:52] I'm going to break the door. [2:10:53] I'm going to break the door. [2:10:54] I'm going to break the door. [2:10:55] I'm going to break the door. [2:10:56] I'm going to break the door. [2:10:57] I'm going to break the door. [2:10:58] I'm going to break the door. [2:10:59] I'm going to break the door. [2:11:00] I'm going to break the door.