WEBVTT

00:00:07.340 --> 00:00:42.210
I'd like to call the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council to order.

00:00:42.210 --> 00:00:44.890
It is September 2nd, 2014.

00:00:44.890 --> 00:00:49.250
Welcome to everyone and before we do some of the formalities that we have, there's two

00:00:49.250 --> 00:00:52.370
reasons why we have this many people in the audience.

00:00:52.370 --> 00:00:56.210
One is we're raising fees and people are mad at us.

00:00:56.210 --> 00:00:59.570
Or number two, someone's getting sworn in and we just happen to have a couple getting sworn

00:00:59.570 --> 00:01:00.570
in tonight.

00:01:00.570 --> 00:01:03.850
We always start our meeting off with the Pledge of Allegiance, so those of you wishing to join

00:01:03.850 --> 00:01:04.850
us please rise.

00:01:04.850 --> 00:01:23.660
I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

00:01:23.660 --> 00:01:28.220
Well, welcome to everyone to come to the City Council meeting this evening.

00:01:28.220 --> 00:01:33.720
We do have a quorum of our city council, all seven members are here this evening.

00:01:33.720 --> 00:01:36.400
Mr. Rothwether, do we have any amendments to our agenda?

00:01:36.400 --> 00:01:38.040
There are no amendments this evening.

00:01:38.040 --> 00:01:39.160
Very good, sir.

00:01:39.160 --> 00:01:44.040
We have no proclamations and what we do is we start off every meeting with the ability

00:01:44.040 --> 00:01:51.080
for folks in the community to come forward and talk to the City Council, express some concerns

00:01:51.080 --> 00:01:53.520
or just want to visit with the City Council.

00:01:53.520 --> 00:01:57.920
We generally do that when it's not something on the agenda itself because there will be

00:01:57.920 --> 00:01:59.440
time for that later.

00:01:59.440 --> 00:02:03.760
And I know that there is at least one person here that would like to come forward and that's

00:02:03.760 --> 00:02:07.760
one of our previous mayor serving in the 19th room.

00:02:07.760 --> 00:02:09.260
Not going to do that to you, Paul.

00:02:09.260 --> 00:02:10.300
Mr. Austin.

00:02:10.300 --> 00:02:17.820
Mr. Austin, would you like to come forward?

00:02:17.820 --> 00:02:19.520
Welcome, Mr. Mayor.

00:02:19.520 --> 00:02:20.420
Thank you, sir.

00:02:20.420 --> 00:02:25.340
I didn't realize that you were going to have to bring in the whole police

00:02:25.340 --> 00:02:28.300
force down because I was not bigger than you.

00:02:28.300 --> 00:02:29.500
Chris told me you were coming.

00:02:29.500 --> 00:02:31.830
So that's it.

00:02:31.830 --> 00:02:34.110
Honorable Mayor, you respected council member.

00:02:34.110 --> 00:02:35.350
My name is Paul Austin.

00:02:35.350 --> 00:02:39.610
I'm a resident of the city of Twin Falls.

00:02:39.610 --> 00:02:43.170
I'd like to make a few comments about our dog park.

00:02:43.170 --> 00:02:48.450
If I may, first of all, boy, it's great.

00:02:48.450 --> 00:02:50.370
It's tremendous.

00:02:50.370 --> 00:02:59.050
I am so proud of our city to consider our little four-legged

00:02:59.050 --> 00:03:10.580
friends and create a dog park that just does my hard good.

00:03:10.580 --> 00:03:14.320
I've been out there every day since it opened,

00:03:14.320 --> 00:03:16.640
and just for your information,

00:03:16.640 --> 00:03:21.640
there have been no less than a dozen dogs and people

00:03:22.000 --> 00:03:25.720
in that park every time I've been out there.

00:03:25.720 --> 00:03:30.720
So it is getting used, and it will continue to be used.

00:03:30.960 --> 00:03:33.120
Now, having said all of that,

00:03:34.520 --> 00:03:39.000
I'd like to give you some food for thought, if I may.

00:03:39.000 --> 00:03:46.000
some things to think about down the line as we go along.

00:03:47.080 --> 00:03:50.240
I'm not an expert on dog park.

00:03:50.240 --> 00:03:54.250
For one thing, I'm not 50 miles from home.

00:03:54.250 --> 00:03:59.600
But I consider myself knowledgeable on dog park.

00:04:01.000 --> 00:04:06.000
Joyce and I have driven to almost in every stage

00:04:06.560 --> 00:04:10.280
in the United States during the past few years.

00:04:10.280 --> 00:04:16.040
by automobile. And when we have, we have always taken our pet switches, at least our

00:04:16.040 --> 00:04:24.970
dog, and so we have made use of dog parts all over the United States. I'd like to give you

00:04:24.970 --> 00:04:34.960
an idea or two that as we go along, take them for what they're worth, okay? Probably nothing.

00:04:34.960 --> 00:04:40.000
First of all, I think we need to create a little dog run along that inner fence.

00:04:40.000 --> 00:04:45.380
Now, you say, well, what do you need a dog run for?

00:04:45.380 --> 00:04:53.620
Well, dogs, believe it or not, would prefer to run on something solid rather than gas.

00:04:53.620 --> 00:05:02.220
And a dog run is usually covered with four or five feet wide and is usually covered with

00:05:02.220 --> 00:05:10.980
with little chips, sand, something like they use, like we'll use here in Twin Falls, on

00:05:10.980 --> 00:05:23.520
the warning tracks in baseball fields. I think we need to divide the entry pin, and that can

00:05:23.520 --> 00:05:29.920
be done very, very easily, and with hardly any expense, just put a fence down the middle

00:05:29.920 --> 00:05:34.720
and add one more dog, eight to the other side.

00:05:34.720 --> 00:05:37.680
And then that totally separates the large dog

00:05:37.680 --> 00:05:39.680
and the little dogs.

00:05:39.680 --> 00:05:44.680
I have only seen one little incident between the dogs

00:05:44.760 --> 00:05:47.360
and the days that we've been open.

00:05:47.360 --> 00:05:48.760
And you don't see many of them,

00:05:48.760 --> 00:05:52.520
but the larger dogs have a tendency

00:05:52.520 --> 00:05:57.510
to be a little bit more aggressive than do the little dogs.

00:05:57.510 --> 00:05:59.870
Another thing, and the next thing that I've got down

00:05:59.870 --> 00:06:08.340
is that the grass is awfully tall. Now, I realize that it's probably tall because it's new

00:06:08.340 --> 00:06:16.760
seating and it's just been planted and the Parks and Recreation Department have done a great

00:06:16.760 --> 00:06:25.270
job. They've been tremendous. They put a lot of work into that park and I'm proud that

00:06:25.270 --> 00:06:31.710
Mr. Boyer and his crew have taken it hard to do something with it.

00:06:31.710 --> 00:06:37.470
But I think that the grass should probably be mowed lower.

00:06:37.470 --> 00:06:40.630
Now let me tell you why.

00:06:40.630 --> 00:06:49.430
It has a tendency, the tall grass has a tendency to conceal the dark poop.

00:06:49.430 --> 00:06:53.730
And people are very good about going by and cleaning, and I've noticed our people here

00:06:53.730 --> 00:06:58.730
and Twin Falls have been extremely good about following their dogs and picking up.

00:06:58.730 --> 00:07:01.730
But the tall grass has a tendency to cover it up.

00:07:01.730 --> 00:07:06.110
Now, it is going to hurt anything today, not today, tomorrow.

00:07:06.110 --> 00:07:12.110
But unless we use, and we don't use as far as I know, a suction mower,

00:07:12.110 --> 00:07:15.110
which draws that up out of the grass,

00:07:15.110 --> 00:07:21.110
it will have a tendency to sink down and it could cause a fly

00:07:21.110 --> 00:07:26.230
and an odor problem in the future.

00:07:26.230 --> 00:07:30.230
Big thing which is to be a little cost for us to move on

00:07:30.230 --> 00:07:34.230
and we need to keep encouraging people to contribute

00:07:34.230 --> 00:07:38.230
is we need a covered shelter

00:07:38.230 --> 00:07:42.810
out in the park for the adults,

00:07:42.810 --> 00:07:47.220
believe it or not. You will find

00:07:47.220 --> 00:07:51.220
if you observe it becomes a great gathering

00:07:51.220 --> 00:07:57.950
place for people and the people gather and they visit while the dogs run. And

00:07:57.950 --> 00:08:03.630
especially the seniors and us old duffers that don't have anything else to do.

00:08:03.630 --> 00:08:10.790
But the good dog parts that I've seen has had a little sheller. It doesn't take

00:08:10.790 --> 00:08:16.750
much just a little cover over the top and a couple of benches on around the

00:08:16.750 --> 00:08:22.430
side and leave it open so the dogs can run in and out and around it but the

00:08:22.430 --> 00:08:29.110
people can go over and sit on it. Most of them that I have observed have a

00:08:29.110 --> 00:08:37.840
sidewalk of cement leading out to them which makes them a little nicer. The next

00:08:37.840 --> 00:08:46.970
thing is we need some plastic chairs at the park. Now you say well the park isn't

00:08:46.970 --> 00:08:53.290
for people. Yeah, but it is. It really is. Because the people bring the dog. And a lot

00:08:53.290 --> 00:08:59.170
of the parks I've seen have big hooks on the fence. And then they bought these plastic

00:08:59.170 --> 00:09:05.690
chairs, whether good, snow, rain doesn't bother. And they can hook those, I mean they just hook

00:09:05.690 --> 00:09:13.570
those chairs on those fences. And people can go over and take a chair down from the fence.

00:09:13.570 --> 00:09:21.290
And then most of them will take the chairs back and hang them back up when they get through.

00:09:21.290 --> 00:09:28.290
The last thing, and I'm sure that Mr. Boyle will be on top of this one, but the sprinklers

00:09:28.290 --> 00:09:33.050
need to be adjusted so that they don't come on during the day.

00:09:33.050 --> 00:09:41.890
Twice this weekend in prime time, so to speak, the sprinklers came on and kind of raised

00:09:41.890 --> 00:09:49.990
And anyway, it's a great job, you've done a great job, but I appreciate the effort of the council

00:09:49.990 --> 00:09:58.010
and in getting this dog park and I'm sure that as we go along you'll find more and more people

00:09:58.010 --> 00:09:59.010
use it.

00:09:59.010 --> 00:10:00.410
Thank you for your time.

00:10:00.410 --> 00:10:01.410
Thank you, Mr. Austin.

00:10:01.410 --> 00:10:02.730
I appreciate you bringing that to our attention.

00:10:02.730 --> 00:10:08.330
I know that our Parks and Recreation Director is here and he heard everything and we'll take

00:10:08.330 --> 00:10:09.330
those under consideration.

00:10:09.330 --> 00:10:16.290
I know this guy from the fact that time when he was almost as small as that little bit.

00:10:16.290 --> 00:10:20.610
I don't think Dennis was ever that small.

00:10:20.610 --> 00:10:21.610
Thank you again, sir.

00:10:21.610 --> 00:10:24.410
Is there anyone else from the public that would like to address the council?

00:10:24.410 --> 00:10:27.290
If you'd come up and state your name, sir, and your address?

00:10:27.290 --> 00:10:28.290
My name is Jim Barrett.

00:10:28.290 --> 00:10:30.770
I'm a new resident a year and a half ago.

00:10:30.770 --> 00:10:33.090
I came for the same reason.

00:10:33.090 --> 00:10:34.090
Thank you.

00:10:34.090 --> 00:10:36.530
That great dog park.

00:10:36.530 --> 00:10:39.010
I've been to the one in San Fernando, California,

00:10:39.010 --> 00:10:41.010
it's right on the San Francisco Bay.

00:10:41.010 --> 00:10:43.010
This one has green grass.

00:10:43.010 --> 00:10:44.850
So it's really cool.

00:10:44.850 --> 00:10:45.650
It's awesome.

00:10:45.650 --> 00:10:48.770
My dog, Bosco, won the argument.

00:10:48.770 --> 00:10:51.010
I thought I should come down and argue for the pool,

00:10:51.010 --> 00:10:54.090
because I think the pool's the best thing about Twin Falls.

00:10:54.090 --> 00:10:55.890
But Bosco says that's a bull.

00:10:55.890 --> 00:10:59.170
The dog part is the best thing about Twin Falls.

00:10:59.170 --> 00:11:01.170
So thank you very much.

00:11:01.170 --> 00:11:01.670
It has.

00:11:01.650 --> 00:11:02.170
It's awesome.

00:11:02.170 --> 00:11:02.930
You got the water.

00:11:02.930 --> 00:11:03.650
You got the grass.

00:11:03.650 --> 00:11:04.490
You got the fences.

00:11:04.490 --> 00:11:05.370
You got the parking.

00:11:05.370 --> 00:11:06.450
It's an awesome part.

00:11:06.450 --> 00:11:10.250
period. And sure, of course, we'd like to have, you know,

00:11:10.250 --> 00:11:14.450
son of a baz and free lunch and everything else, but it's a great dog bark.

00:11:14.850 --> 00:11:19.350
And I am a member of the YMCA and I pay 45 a month.

00:11:19.650 --> 00:11:24.050
I don't care what it costs. It's a great YMCA. I'm very happy. Thank you.

00:11:24.450 --> 00:11:26.250
Could you give us your address, sir, just real quick?

00:11:26.650 --> 00:11:29.850
Yeah, I'm in 1932. Addison Avenue East.

00:11:30.850 --> 00:11:33.450
So thank you for sharing this evening. Appreciate that.

00:11:33.850 --> 00:11:35.450
I like what people come and say good things.

00:11:36.450 --> 00:11:40.820
Is there anyone else that would like to come forward and address the council this evening?

00:11:40.820 --> 00:11:44.420
Again, we really do appreciate when people come and share that either their concerns

00:11:44.420 --> 00:11:46.900
or if we're doing something good too.

00:11:46.900 --> 00:11:51.260
It makes a difference to us, make sure that we understand what we should be doing as a

00:11:51.260 --> 00:11:53.900
council, as a staff, and as a city, so thank you.

00:11:53.900 --> 00:11:56.020
Next item on the agenda is the consent calendar.

00:11:56.020 --> 00:11:59.230
I'll turn that over to the council wishes.

00:11:59.230 --> 00:12:00.230
Great landing.

00:12:00.230 --> 00:12:01.710
Move approval.

00:12:01.710 --> 00:12:02.710
Second.

00:12:02.710 --> 00:12:09.870
The motion on the floor by Greg Lanning, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to approve the consent calendar as presented.

00:12:09.870 --> 00:12:13.300
Anything further on that motion, council?

00:12:13.300 --> 00:12:19.210
Le Gallop, could you do a roll call vote please?

00:12:19.210 --> 00:12:20.230
Suzanne Hawkins?

00:12:20.230 --> 00:12:20.950
Yes.

00:12:20.950 --> 00:12:21.900
Yes.

00:12:21.900 --> 00:12:23.580
John Bericher?

00:12:23.580 --> 00:12:24.400
Yes.

00:12:24.400 --> 00:12:25.060
Chris Tocquentes?

00:12:25.060 --> 00:12:26.060
Yes.

00:12:26.060 --> 00:12:26.860
Greg Lanning?

00:12:26.860 --> 00:12:27.660
Yes.

00:12:27.660 --> 00:12:28.320
Don Hall?

00:12:28.320 --> 00:12:28.980
Yes.

00:12:28.980 --> 00:12:30.060
Rebecca Milsoic.

00:12:30.060 --> 00:12:31.420
Yes.

00:12:31.420 --> 00:12:33.100
Motion passes, 7-0.

00:12:33.100 --> 00:12:38.380
Moving to the second portion of our agenda, which is items for consideration.

00:12:38.380 --> 00:12:45.420
The first item is the swearing in ceremony for two new Twin Falls Police officers.

00:12:45.420 --> 00:12:50.980
And Mayor Don Hall to administer the oath of office to officers Kyle Scuza and Jacob Olson.

00:12:50.980 --> 00:12:54.740
I will turn it over to our illustrious chief, Pike.

00:12:54.740 --> 00:12:55.700
Welcome Chief.

00:12:55.700 --> 00:12:57.060
Thank you, Mayor and members of the Council.

00:12:57.060 --> 00:13:01.820
It's always, like I said in the past, it's always a pleasure to share the ever changing

00:13:01.820 --> 00:13:05.420
constant to evolving a department with you, but tonight we have the honor of

00:13:05.420 --> 00:13:09.540
swearing in two of our newest officers, and I'd like to ask them to come forward, Kyle

00:13:09.540 --> 00:13:17.000
Scuza and Jacob Olson. No Kyle and Jacob, the police profession is a challenging and

00:13:17.000 --> 00:13:20.680
rewarding career. It requires the discipline to handle difficult and

00:13:20.680 --> 00:13:25.880
dynamic situations, the courage to face adversity, sometimes the sympathy and

00:13:25.880 --> 00:13:30.360
compassion you have to display as you help families and individuals through

00:13:30.360 --> 00:13:35.160
some of their most difficult and challenging circumstances, the clarity of thought that's

00:13:35.160 --> 00:13:40.000
associated with a life and death decision, and although those moments may be few and far

00:13:40.000 --> 00:13:46.840
in between, that same thought process is carried out in a daily basis, right, in the application

00:13:46.840 --> 00:13:50.240
of force, judgment, and discernment.

00:13:50.240 --> 00:13:53.000
For you tonight, the expectation is no different.

00:13:53.000 --> 00:13:58.040
We believe that you have the background, the temperament, the education, and the life experience

00:13:58.040 --> 00:14:01.500
to serve our community in the role of police officer.

00:14:01.500 --> 00:14:04.860
Council let me introduce you to our newest officers.

00:14:04.860 --> 00:14:07.780
Kyle was hired as a full-time police officer in August 11th,

00:14:07.780 --> 00:14:09.340
2014.

00:14:09.340 --> 00:14:11.060
He was born and raised in Twin Falls.

00:14:11.060 --> 00:14:15.060
He graduated from Twin Falls High School in 2005.

00:14:15.060 --> 00:14:16.940
Kyle attended the College of Southern Idaho's

00:14:16.940 --> 00:14:21.020
law enforcement program and graduated in July of 2011.

00:14:21.020 --> 00:14:22.940
Prior to his employment with our agency, Kyle

00:14:22.940 --> 00:14:26.340
worked for the city of Bellevue, Idaho's at Deputy Marshall.

00:14:26.340 --> 00:14:32.280
I'll receive this post basic certificate in July of 2012.

00:14:32.280 --> 00:14:38.160
Jacob was hired as a full-time police officer, also on August 11, 2014.

00:14:38.160 --> 00:14:40.240
Jacob was born in Bay City, Texas.

00:14:40.240 --> 00:14:42.920
He is the seventh of 11 children.

00:14:42.920 --> 00:14:46.220
It's like a super middle child.

00:14:46.220 --> 00:14:50.160
He graduated from Bay City High School, and he received his Eagle Scout Award.

00:14:50.160 --> 00:14:55.280
In 2001, Jacob moved to southeast Idaho to attend Brigham Young University, Idaho,

00:14:55.280 --> 00:15:01.240
and later served an LDS mission in Honduras from 2002 to 2004.

00:15:01.240 --> 00:15:05.600
In October of 2004, Jacob joined the Army National Guard,

00:15:05.600 --> 00:15:08.880
and has been deployed twice to Iraq in support

00:15:08.880 --> 00:15:11.780
of Operation Iraqi Freedom.

00:15:11.780 --> 00:15:14.580
Jacob was briefly employed by the Madison County Sheriff's

00:15:14.580 --> 00:15:17.700
Office as a detention officer before furthering his college

00:15:17.700 --> 00:15:20.420
education at Idaho State University.

00:15:20.420 --> 00:15:25.500
In May of 2014, Jacob graduated with a bachelor's degree

00:15:25.500 --> 00:15:29.180
of Arts after successfully completing the Army ROTC

00:15:29.180 --> 00:15:31.980
commissioning program and received his commission

00:15:31.980 --> 00:15:36.220
as a second lieutenant in the Idaho Army National Guard.

00:15:36.220 --> 00:15:41.470
Jacob will be attending post in September 14, 2014.

00:15:41.470 --> 00:15:44.590
So tonight really the ceremony consists of two parts.

00:15:44.590 --> 00:15:46.390
It's the pinning of the police badge

00:15:46.390 --> 00:15:49.990
and the oath of office that will be administered by Mayor Hall.

00:15:49.990 --> 00:15:52.470
Kyle and Jacob, the oath that you're about to take tonight

00:15:52.470 --> 00:15:55.030
represents the heart of everything that we do

00:15:55.030 --> 00:15:57.330
and stand for in law enforcement.

00:15:57.330 --> 00:16:00.370
These are more than words repeated in a paper signed.

00:16:00.370 --> 00:16:01.730
The badge that you received tonight

00:16:01.730 --> 00:16:03.690
represents this commitment.

00:16:03.690 --> 00:16:06.010
It's the symbol of your office and the trust

00:16:06.010 --> 00:16:09.370
the community has given you in the performance of your job.

00:16:09.370 --> 00:16:11.370
By raising your hand and affirming your commitment

00:16:11.370 --> 00:16:13.410
to provide public safety to our community,

00:16:13.410 --> 00:16:16.910
you'll be empowered to perform the functions of your job.

00:16:16.910 --> 00:16:19.450
My charge to you is to be always mindful

00:16:19.450 --> 00:16:24.150
of the community's trust and ever diligent in your duties.

00:16:24.150 --> 00:17:21.920
We're hoping you join me.

00:17:52.520 --> 00:17:57.360
the city of Twin Falls and the rules and regulations and the rules and regulations

00:17:57.360 --> 00:18:02.360
of the Twin Falls Police Department of the Twin Falls Police Department and that I will

00:18:02.360 --> 00:18:11.600
and that I will well and faithfully discharge the duties of the office of police officer

00:18:11.600 --> 00:18:15.120
of the office of the police officer Twin Falls Police Department

00:18:15.120 --> 00:18:51.670
to which I have been appointed according to law and according to law and to the best of my ability, congratulations.

00:18:51.670 --> 00:19:23.170
This is really an important day and I was just sharing with some of your family members how impressed I am with how we do these swearing in processes.

00:19:23.170 --> 00:19:28.210
And I believe it was actually under Chief Mundt that we kind of switched around and brought

00:19:28.210 --> 00:19:32.770
them in front of the council and I think it really cements it.

00:19:32.770 --> 00:19:38.890
And I like hearing the oath, but also the message that our chief brings to you about

00:19:38.890 --> 00:19:42.010
how important your job is for our community.

00:19:42.010 --> 00:19:47.930
And we as a council just want to thank you for serving our community and coming out and

00:19:47.930 --> 00:19:50.690
being part of the City of Twin Falls.

00:19:50.690 --> 00:19:53.310
Thank you.

00:19:53.310 --> 00:20:01.510
At this time we generally just kind of, I guess for no better word chill out until most of the folks leave.

00:20:01.510 --> 00:20:04.810
Thank you family and friends for coming out and supporting your loved ones.

00:20:04.810 --> 00:20:06.950
Chief, I do have a question for you.

00:20:06.950 --> 00:20:12.310
What's our vacancy status in the police department now?

00:20:12.310 --> 00:20:14.630
We have three more openings.

00:20:14.630 --> 00:20:16.510
Any applicants to look good?

00:20:16.510 --> 00:20:18.870
We have a number of applicants that look really well.

00:20:18.870 --> 00:20:19.710
Thank you.

00:20:19.710 --> 00:20:24.910
We'll just state that the College of Southern Idaho is doing our best to fill those vacancies for you.

00:20:24.910 --> 00:20:33.270
Well, over the weeks when you listen these swearings in a large number of our applicants are coming out of the College of Southern Items program.

00:20:33.270 --> 00:20:36.830
We'll continue to work on that one, Mr. Martin.

00:20:36.830 --> 00:20:53.920
Thank you, folks.

00:20:53.920 --> 00:20:57.000
Oh, it's very hot.

00:20:57.000 --> 00:20:59.800
There's no air circulation going on.

00:20:59.800 --> 00:21:02.880
Travis, head air conditioning isn't working.

00:21:02.880 --> 00:21:04.640
Can we maybe crank it a little bit?

00:21:04.640 --> 00:21:06.040
It's really hot up here.

00:21:06.040 --> 00:21:13.430
Even get a fan override, anything.

00:21:13.430 --> 00:21:14.710
Chief Munson, he's going to go home.

00:21:14.710 --> 00:21:15.910
We don't adjust it.

00:21:15.910 --> 00:21:16.910
That's just responsible.

00:21:16.910 --> 00:21:19.830
They ain't working.

00:21:19.830 --> 00:21:20.330
That's it.

00:21:20.270 --> 00:21:21.190
It's not warm enough.

00:21:21.190 --> 00:21:22.670
That's it.

00:21:22.670 --> 00:21:24.150
All right, ladies and gentlemen, we're

00:21:24.150 --> 00:21:26.310
going to move on to item number two

00:21:26.310 --> 00:21:27.630
under items of consideration.

00:21:27.630 --> 00:21:31.230
That's a presentation of a certificate of appreciation

00:21:31.230 --> 00:21:35.270
to Gemo Donald for serving on the airport advisory

00:21:35.270 --> 00:21:39.590
Commission and we have our airport manager, Bill Carver, welcome Bill.

00:21:39.590 --> 00:21:40.590
Thank you, Mary.

00:21:40.590 --> 00:21:44.070
Good evening members of the council.

00:21:44.070 --> 00:21:48.190
It's going to be different around the airport advisory meetings in the future without Jim

00:21:48.190 --> 00:21:51.190
O'Donnell being on the board.

00:21:51.190 --> 00:21:52.830
Jim was appointed about eight years ago.

00:21:52.830 --> 00:21:58.110
He filled a vacancy that was a partial term and then he was renewed for two additional

00:21:58.110 --> 00:21:59.110
terms.

00:21:59.110 --> 00:22:03.030
So I've worked with Jim for those eight years and really for years before that.

00:22:03.030 --> 00:22:10.190
So I can't speak more highly about someone who's giving, they're involved with all sorts

00:22:10.190 --> 00:22:11.190
of things.

00:22:11.190 --> 00:22:17.430
The things that stand out about Jim's tenure on the board is his ability to get people to

00:22:17.430 --> 00:22:18.430
come together.

00:22:18.430 --> 00:22:20.390
And I'll give you one example.

00:22:20.390 --> 00:22:24.230
We're required every three years to do an emergency drill at the airport.

00:22:24.230 --> 00:22:29.670
Come up with a scenario, sort of exercise our drills so that we're ready for any future

00:22:29.670 --> 00:22:31.430
incidents that might happen.

00:22:31.430 --> 00:22:36.070
talking to other airport managers, colleagues in the industry, they can't believe how much

00:22:36.070 --> 00:22:40.670
cooperation we get with our first responders. They come together, they take it very seriously.

00:22:40.670 --> 00:22:45.690
And it's really one example of Jim's ability to bring people together. So we're very fortunate

00:22:45.690 --> 00:22:49.470
that he has that ability. As you all know, he's been involved with the air show since

00:22:49.470 --> 00:22:55.590
the mid-1990s. It started as an Eagle Scout merit badge or a Boy Scout merit badge, the

00:22:55.590 --> 00:23:00.790
Aviation merit badge. And it progressed through a static show right into an air show and it's

00:23:00.790 --> 00:23:06.230
been going on ever since. So with that, I won't go on and on, but I'd ask that the

00:23:06.230 --> 00:23:12.230
Mayor present Jim with a certificate in recognizing his efforts.

00:23:12.230 --> 00:23:18.790
I would also ask if Chris Tockington, or in liaison, could sit down with me. And as Jim

00:23:18.790 --> 00:23:23.270
makes his way up, I also want to mention to the audience that is actually Jim's birthday

00:23:23.270 --> 00:23:26.870
today. And both Chris and I have pledged not to

00:23:26.870 --> 00:23:29.270
to seeing you happy birthday out of respect to you, sir.

00:23:29.270 --> 00:23:31.450
So come up for it.

00:23:31.450 --> 00:23:37.210
Chris, we're allowed to form on B.J. Day.

00:23:37.210 --> 00:23:40.370
They've signed the end of World War II.

00:23:40.370 --> 00:23:44.900
My wife disagrees with the peace part, but I would just

00:23:44.900 --> 00:23:52.860
like to read that the fact that I do hereby

00:23:52.860 --> 00:23:56.630
award this as a jimmel Dom, the recognition

00:23:56.630 --> 00:24:07.960
of his eight years of service to the sincere gratitude

00:24:07.960 --> 00:24:11.400
of our sincere gratitude and honor him

00:24:11.400 --> 00:24:21.650
for getting frustrated by and doing reminiscent of that.

00:24:21.650 --> 00:24:24.050
If you need an old one here, I won't read that to you,

00:24:24.050 --> 00:24:34.340
but Jim, I just want to say thank you.

00:24:34.340 --> 00:24:38.530
I'll bring you the festival, what's the aviation background,

00:24:38.530 --> 00:24:40.590
and the outcome of people first.

00:24:40.590 --> 00:24:42.110
And you said, tell me what you're all,

00:24:42.110 --> 00:24:45.830
any good businessman could sell these drives

00:24:45.830 --> 00:24:48.430
just like slaves on the earth or the floor.

00:24:48.430 --> 00:24:52.320
And whenever all the time, bring out some infrastructure.

00:24:52.320 --> 00:24:54.080
Jim, if you come over here, we're going to get a picture

00:24:54.080 --> 00:24:58.520
I want to be a felony part of this as well.

00:24:58.520 --> 00:24:59.520
Thank you.

00:24:59.520 --> 00:25:06.220
What's so close?

00:25:06.220 --> 00:25:12.980
Tuck out of the way here.

00:25:12.980 --> 00:25:14.780
So it's about having these two seats.

00:25:14.780 --> 00:25:17.970
We get almost all the pictures.

00:25:17.970 --> 00:25:20.970
Photo bomb and mall.

00:25:20.970 --> 00:25:33.020
You're not going anywhere, Jim.

00:25:33.020 --> 00:25:35.460
Number three, request from Jim O'Donnell

00:25:35.460 --> 00:25:37.740
on behalf of the Magic Valley Air Show

00:25:37.740 --> 00:25:41.340
to waive public safety fee, police and fire charged

00:25:41.340 --> 00:25:43.500
by the City of Twin Falls.

00:25:43.500 --> 00:25:46.280
We have Jim O'Donnell come out making a presentation.

00:25:46.280 --> 00:25:47.120
Are you starting?

00:25:47.120 --> 00:25:47.960
Trustee.

00:25:47.960 --> 00:25:48.800
Okay, very good.

00:25:48.800 --> 00:25:50.200
Trustee Rufweiler, our city manager.

00:25:50.200 --> 00:25:52.360
Mr. Mayor, members of the council, good evening.

00:25:52.360 --> 00:25:54.080
You'll notice a request in here

00:25:54.080 --> 00:25:56.040
from the Magic Valley Air Show Committee

00:25:56.040 --> 00:26:00.040
to waive the costs associated with the police

00:26:00.040 --> 00:26:04.960
and the fire services time at this year's air show.

00:26:04.960 --> 00:26:07.840
Historically, we've always waived the cost of that.

00:26:09.120 --> 00:26:11.520
The cost of our services towards those events.

00:26:11.520 --> 00:26:18.040
And we've looked at those events as being a part of our contribution to that type of community

00:26:18.040 --> 00:26:21.180
events bringing people into our community.

00:26:21.180 --> 00:26:25.640
In the past, that was recognized at the beginning of the air show process.

00:26:25.640 --> 00:26:32.960
So for example, in 2012, at the July 16th meeting, we made that declaration and we stated

00:26:32.960 --> 00:26:38.800
that that would be a part of our local contribution and that the seed money would be fully repaid

00:26:38.800 --> 00:26:40.940
and it was.

00:26:40.940 --> 00:26:46.660
This year, however, we didn't make that at the beginning of the process when Mr. O'Donnell

00:26:46.660 --> 00:26:52.860
on behalf of the Magic Valley Air Show Committee moved forward with this year's air show.

00:26:52.860 --> 00:26:59.380
There was also a second change, and that second change is in the past really the city oversaw

00:26:59.380 --> 00:27:02.940
the books, and we did the accounting and we moved forward.

00:27:02.940 --> 00:27:09.060
Since the 2012 air show, Jim and through Jim's leadership, and maybe another example of his

00:27:09.060 --> 00:27:14.060
took the air show Magic Valley into a 501c3 status,

00:27:15.100 --> 00:27:17.540
where it became a standalone entity,

00:27:17.540 --> 00:27:21.460
and that entity was no longer under the jurisdiction

00:27:21.460 --> 00:27:24.380
of the city, and so since this is a separate entity,

00:27:24.380 --> 00:27:27.020
we felt from a staff perspective that the request

00:27:27.020 --> 00:27:30.700
was appropriate for the council to consider this evening.

00:27:30.700 --> 00:27:33.900
With that, Mr. O'Donnell's here to answer any questions,

00:27:33.900 --> 00:27:35.500
and we'll be happy to do so.

00:27:35.500 --> 00:27:36.940
Very good.

00:27:36.940 --> 00:27:38.320
Jim, would you like to say a few words,

00:27:38.320 --> 00:27:45.060
Sir, welcome back, sir.

00:27:45.060 --> 00:27:51.420
Basically, from the very beginning, the air show has been a three-legged stool city county

00:27:51.420 --> 00:27:55.240
and the reader flying service without those three together, it's not happening, and we

00:27:55.240 --> 00:28:01.060
do need that support and it would be appreciated very much for us to be able to continue to operate

00:28:01.060 --> 00:28:02.060
a very special event.

00:28:02.060 --> 00:28:06.980
I'm going to brag for a minute if you don't mind.

00:28:06.980 --> 00:28:10.780
One of the things that our air show has done, we're one of the small-tier shows in the country,

00:28:10.780 --> 00:28:13.780
And yet, our air show has set some national standards.

00:28:13.780 --> 00:28:18.620
At our air show this summer, the Twin Falls Fire Department, getting them credit, because

00:28:18.620 --> 00:28:22.500
they want to get this, did something that's not been done before.

00:28:22.500 --> 00:28:25.660
That is the emergency response vehicles put in the show line.

00:28:25.660 --> 00:28:30.860
The reason for that is prior shows this year, there have been three fatal crashes to other

00:28:30.860 --> 00:28:31.860
air shows.

00:28:31.860 --> 00:28:33.500
So they posted it there.

00:28:33.500 --> 00:28:37.260
The thing is that all the performers noticed that.

00:28:37.260 --> 00:28:41.580
emotionally impacted hat on them for that immediate response. They begin posting on

00:28:41.580 --> 00:28:45.980
the Facebook page and they then in turn request other air shows to do what Twin

00:28:45.980 --> 00:28:51.660
Falls Idaho does. And so that says a lot about our community, the support we have

00:28:51.660 --> 00:28:56.660
from the city, the county, and of course all other aspects of it. And so your

00:28:56.660 --> 00:29:01.020
support would be very much appreciated and hopefully continue to have a very

00:29:01.020 --> 00:29:07.020
successful event, one that our community should be very proud of. Thank you Jim. Do

00:29:07.020 --> 00:29:12.010
have any questions. Rebecca Mills, thank you, Mayor. Thank you, Jim, for your

00:29:12.010 --> 00:29:16.250
presentation. I was just wondering more information about the financials of this

00:29:16.250 --> 00:29:20.230
air show. How much did you guys make this year? We actually wouldn't hold this

00:29:20.230 --> 00:29:25.630
year. Okay. The reason is that our attendance was down significantly. We planned that, but

00:29:25.630 --> 00:29:32.030
it's even less more expected. Okay, and what do those numbers look like? Well, we're

00:29:32.030 --> 00:29:35.030
not, we're still trying to collect sponsorship funds. We have four

00:29:35.030 --> 00:29:48.940
not pay their their mouth yet and so it's going to be close we'll be handling it that's one of the reason why this change that way the city does not have that responsibility and or accountability so.

00:29:48.940 --> 00:30:05.660
Right and when it first came through I mean since the loss in 2008 we had an agreement with the council and and the air show that the taxpayers wouldn't have to be responsible for any losses you know because this is a separate entity at the separate event.

00:30:05.660 --> 00:30:08.360
And that provides that protection.

00:30:08.360 --> 00:30:09.360
Right, right.

00:30:09.360 --> 00:30:12.560
So, but on the front end, when the event came through,

00:30:12.560 --> 00:30:17.960
we did have an agreement that the air show would be responsible

00:30:17.960 --> 00:30:22.660
for paying their own safety and fire costs.

00:30:22.660 --> 00:30:26.860
So, were these just a quick question about the $3,000?

00:30:26.860 --> 00:30:30.860
Is that from the Twin Falls Police Department?

00:30:30.860 --> 00:30:33.060
Is that who provided the services?

00:30:33.060 --> 00:30:38.260
And then we also had a majority of paramedics, as well as twin falls can sheriff's department.

00:30:38.260 --> 00:30:38.780
Okay.

00:30:38.780 --> 00:30:41.420
Who also have carried those those committees.

00:30:41.420 --> 00:30:45.780
Okay, and so the sheriff's department provided theirs as well.

00:30:45.780 --> 00:30:47.300
As I have historically.

00:30:47.300 --> 00:30:47.800
Okay.

00:30:47.740 --> 00:30:49.460
Would you want to weigh in?

00:30:49.460 --> 00:30:54.980
Yeah, so of the $3,000, $800 is associated with law enforcement.

00:30:54.980 --> 00:30:59.780
And then the balance is associated with the fire response.

00:30:59.780 --> 00:31:11.580
And that's the fire response that Jim was talking about in terms of the line and the level of support that was noticed by the participants in the airshow.

00:31:11.580 --> 00:31:28.580
My understanding is that in addition to ours, just for the record individuals from the sheriff's department, EMS also participated in providing a service for the airshow.

00:31:28.580 --> 00:31:30.160
That's great.

00:31:30.160 --> 00:31:33.320
And did they waive their fees prior to the air show or after?

00:31:33.320 --> 00:31:38.310
All I know is they told me they would take care of it and the procedures they used I don't know.

00:31:38.310 --> 00:31:41.070
Okay.

00:31:41.070 --> 00:31:42.510
Suzanne Hawkins.

00:31:42.510 --> 00:31:51.590
I would like to make a motion that we approve the request from the Magic Valley Air Show to waive the public safety fees for both police and fire.

00:31:51.590 --> 00:31:52.510
Second.

00:31:52.510 --> 00:31:54.550
Motion on the floor by Suzanne Hawkins.

00:31:54.550 --> 00:32:02.140
Seconded by Greg Lanting to waive the fees associated with the both police and fire for the Magic Valley Air Show.

00:32:02.140 --> 00:32:07.580
anything further on that motion council. Jim, let me jump in on this for a minute. One

00:32:07.580 --> 00:32:17.740
of the questions, the new air show is a non-profit company, correct? Okay. And I think, and correct

00:32:17.740 --> 00:32:24.100
me if I'm wrong here, but I think the council has set precedent in the past for waiving overtime

00:32:24.100 --> 00:32:30.700
fees for certain non-profit events such as the Christmas and the nighttime skies, Twin Falls

00:32:30.700 --> 00:32:39.220
high school parades. There's several non-profits where we do provide overtime for. Is that correct,

00:32:39.220 --> 00:32:46.490
Travis? Is Brian here? I mean, we're so-

00:32:46.490 --> 00:32:48.050
Staff Sergeant Polin this year.

00:32:48.050 --> 00:32:54.570
Oh, yeah. Well, and one of the things I wanted to do is maybe just not all of them because

00:32:54.570 --> 00:32:55.570
they're kind of-

00:32:55.570 --> 00:32:56.570
You're absolutely correct.

00:32:56.570 --> 00:32:59.210
Okay. So this is not unusual for us to provide this kind of-

00:32:59.210 --> 00:33:06.570
It's not in some cases we've actually for like Western days for the homecoming parade.

00:33:06.570 --> 00:33:09.970
We've built that into our overtime budgets as part of what we do.

00:33:09.970 --> 00:33:11.090
Okay, it's okay.

00:33:11.090 --> 00:33:13.380
Very good. Thank you.

00:33:13.380 --> 00:33:14.700
Chris talking to me.

00:33:14.700 --> 00:33:18.540
Just a little bit of background kind of building what Jim says.

00:33:18.540 --> 00:33:23.300
The air show that we're all familiar with that made money through the 501c3.

00:33:23.300 --> 00:33:25.660
We had the blue angels.

00:33:25.660 --> 00:33:27.380
They've kind of been sequestered.

00:33:27.380 --> 00:33:32.460
they're potentially coming back, but I think we were writing awfully high on the success of

00:33:32.460 --> 00:33:39.260
that show a couple years ago. As Jim pointed out, the attendance was down this time that

00:33:39.260 --> 00:33:46.220
Jim's experience with running the budget, starting with controlling costs two years ago,

00:33:46.220 --> 00:33:52.860
made the difference then, and I'm totally convinced without his leadership this year that the

00:33:52.860 --> 00:33:57.100
expense side would have balloon significantly more.

00:33:57.100 --> 00:34:01.620
So given that it has not been uncommon for these fees

00:34:01.620 --> 00:34:04.580
to be waived in other nonprofit situations,

00:34:04.580 --> 00:34:09.660
the fact that Jim, I think, ran it with a real good sharp pencil.

00:34:09.660 --> 00:34:13.100
And we're already planning the next air show

00:34:13.100 --> 00:34:16.060
where I think we can learn even more

00:34:16.060 --> 00:34:18.820
than what we have the last couple of years.

00:34:18.820 --> 00:34:22.100
This looks like a very feasible request.

00:34:22.100 --> 00:34:23.100
Thank you, Chris.

00:34:23.100 --> 00:34:24.100
Rebecca, no second.

00:34:24.100 --> 00:34:25.100
Thank you, Mayor.

00:34:25.100 --> 00:34:29.380
I have a follow-up question to Councilman Munn's question to the police department or

00:34:29.380 --> 00:34:30.380
whoever decides.

00:34:30.380 --> 00:34:35.540
I know that there are non-profit events that take place in City Park or on city facilities

00:34:35.540 --> 00:34:39.940
that we do charge safety fees for and all the overtime.

00:34:39.940 --> 00:34:41.620
How is that determined?

00:34:41.620 --> 00:34:47.340
I know that some things are public events, so they're free, you know, a parade or of

00:34:47.340 --> 00:34:48.340
that nature.

00:34:48.340 --> 00:34:54.620
you determine whether the city pays for the overtime or the rotary or non-profit group

00:34:54.620 --> 00:35:06.220
pays for the overtime?

00:35:06.220 --> 00:35:13.380
You know, my memory, as I look back at it, it's just something that I think at some point

00:35:13.380 --> 00:35:17.340
the council had made a decision and this is going back several years.

00:35:17.340 --> 00:35:21.860
I mean, we've, as far as like Western days, it's something that the city has always just

00:35:21.860 --> 00:35:24.060
absorbed into their budget.

00:35:24.060 --> 00:35:30.700
The other request, other than the ones that we've mentioned go through a different process.

00:35:30.700 --> 00:35:36.420
I think that was really established and I don't know when that was established, but years

00:35:36.420 --> 00:35:42.320
ago it was something that the council agreed that they would fund.

00:35:42.320 --> 00:35:48.080
So you just take an event that's historically been paid for and continually paid for it?

00:35:48.080 --> 00:35:49.480
So what if there's a new event?

00:35:49.480 --> 00:35:50.480
How do you decide?

00:35:50.480 --> 00:36:00.800
There's a lot of events, the concerts at the fountain, they're required to pay for their own security, western days, over the three days, they're required to pay for their own security.

00:36:00.800 --> 00:36:06.360
I was just wondering how we determine which groups we pay for and which we don't.

00:36:06.360 --> 00:36:11.400
All groups, other than the ones that we've mentioned, pay for the security they would need.

00:36:11.400 --> 00:36:14.880
Depending on whether they need security or not, there's a special events process.

00:36:14.880 --> 00:36:21.200
So there's a group, a committee of city employees that meet from a number of departments to evaluate

00:36:21.200 --> 00:36:23.000
the impact of that event on the city.

00:36:23.000 --> 00:36:29.240
So it's not just a police issue, it's a fire issue, it's a building issue, it's there a number

00:36:29.240 --> 00:36:35.160
of considerations that are made to each event and how it impacts not only the city but the

00:36:35.160 --> 00:36:37.920
neighborhood that it's proposed for.

00:36:37.920 --> 00:36:43.960
A minute of security is required and there are even options there.

00:36:43.960 --> 00:36:48.760
Sometimes they find another resource through using the Sheriff's Reserve Program to help

00:36:48.760 --> 00:36:50.160
take care of that.

00:36:50.160 --> 00:36:55.880
Sometimes they use Twin Falls Police Officers, it just depends on the event.

00:36:55.880 --> 00:37:00.480
And really based on a lot of the decisions that we make are based on the past history

00:37:00.480 --> 00:37:01.480
of the event.

00:37:01.480 --> 00:37:06.120
The number of calls that we received the year before, so I can think of several situations

00:37:06.120 --> 00:37:11.320
where five years ago we might have required three officers where a year ago we acquired

00:37:11.320 --> 00:37:15.000
one because we just haven't had the problems.

00:37:15.000 --> 00:37:18.160
Seems like our groups are getting better at policing themselves and taking the steps

00:37:18.160 --> 00:37:27.740
that they need to make sure they have a safe and a funny bit.

00:37:27.740 --> 00:37:31.230
Sean Berger.

00:37:31.230 --> 00:37:34.990
So I think the Chief did an excellent job of outlining some of my memory as well with

00:37:34.990 --> 00:37:41.470
those events, having been on the other end of many of those events here requesting waivers

00:37:41.470 --> 00:37:47.230
of security needs or those types of things but I think with the air show what I see with it is

00:37:47.230 --> 00:37:55.950
it's it's very much a community-wide function it's hosted at a facility that we share with the county

00:37:55.950 --> 00:38:02.180
the service that was provided by police and fire or services that would be required whether that was

00:38:03.380 --> 00:38:07.700
whoever was hosting that event I mean you're not going to have an air show and not have fire service

00:38:07.700 --> 00:38:13.980
on standby. So while I do agree that in the future it would be nice to settle this up on

00:38:13.980 --> 00:38:18.820
the front end so that we're all understanding it going into it instead of trying to dissect

00:38:18.820 --> 00:38:25.860
it a couple of months later. I think these are services that we should have provided. It's

00:38:25.860 --> 00:38:34.260
a relatively small amount of resources that were committed to it and I would support paying

00:38:34.260 --> 00:38:35.930
it.

00:38:35.930 --> 00:38:41.810
Thank you, Mayor. You know, I do support the air show. I think it's great for our community.

00:38:41.810 --> 00:38:49.290
But I am a bit concerned about using tax dollars to to support an event that is losing money.

00:38:49.290 --> 00:38:54.090
You know, and it's not open to the public. It's based on a ticket admission. And so if

00:38:54.090 --> 00:39:01.570
the public is not supporting that event with their dollars in admission, I just have a reservation

00:39:01.570 --> 00:39:04.650
about using tax dollars to then support it.

00:39:04.650 --> 00:39:09.650
And I agree with Council Member Berger, I think this would have been a straightforward request

00:39:09.650 --> 00:39:13.530
on the front end and I definitely would support it on the front end.

00:39:13.530 --> 00:39:20.050
But I'm just concerned because of the losses in 2008 were between 40,000 and 60,000.

00:39:20.050 --> 00:39:24.210
And Jim O'Donnell has done a great job of reducing that loss.

00:39:24.210 --> 00:39:27.090
But we don't even have the financials for this past air show.

00:39:27.090 --> 00:39:29.550
We don't know how the money was spent.

00:39:29.550 --> 00:39:34.890
I can't account for that as a council member if I'm going to say I'm going to waive these fees.

00:39:34.890 --> 00:39:39.410
We don't even know what money came in and what money went out.

00:39:39.410 --> 00:39:44.490
And I trust that the Magic Valley Air Show is doing a great job.

00:39:45.850 --> 00:39:50.290
But I'm just not comfortable because we charge other, this is a separate entity.

00:39:50.290 --> 00:39:56.010
This Air Magic Valley is its own organization separate from the city.

00:39:56.010 --> 00:40:03.370
I don't feel it's the city's place to come in and take on a portion of those losses.

00:40:03.370 --> 00:40:10.770
Our agreement was that they would cover their fire and safety costs and that's the agreement

00:40:10.770 --> 00:40:11.770
we had.

00:40:11.770 --> 00:40:18.010
They also, after the taxpayers actually took on that loss of 2008, we forgave that.

00:40:18.010 --> 00:40:20.490
We had the seed money for 2012.

00:40:20.490 --> 00:40:21.770
That was a great show.

00:40:21.770 --> 00:40:22.770
They made $45,000.

00:40:22.770 --> 00:40:27.330
And instead of paying back those losses, we said, no, keep that seed money.

00:40:27.330 --> 00:40:30.450
And so again, we're back at a loss.

00:40:30.450 --> 00:40:33.730
And so I support the air show.

00:40:33.730 --> 00:40:37.650
I just don't know that I can support this request.

00:40:37.650 --> 00:40:44.010
Greg, my only question that I have on those comments by councilman,

00:40:44.010 --> 00:40:48.690
I was like it was that I've never seen the financials of the Western days.

00:40:48.690 --> 00:40:52.130
Nor do I probably want to see the financials of the Western days.

00:40:52.130 --> 00:40:57.550
And so I will be supporting the motion.

00:40:57.550 --> 00:40:58.470
Suzanne Hawkins.

00:41:00.300 --> 00:41:02.200
I think as far as waving the fees,

00:41:02.200 --> 00:41:03.620
that's our job as council members.

00:41:03.620 --> 00:41:05.740
We take all of these requests one on one

00:41:05.740 --> 00:41:07.700
at their face value when they come in,

00:41:07.700 --> 00:41:09.380
and that's what we're elected to do.

00:41:09.380 --> 00:41:14.220
Look at these things, and it's not always a fun job

00:41:14.220 --> 00:41:16.700
to look and say, yes, we can help this group.

00:41:16.700 --> 00:41:18.660
And sometimes, you know, we don't feel like

00:41:18.660 --> 00:41:20.940
another group we can help at that time.

00:41:20.940 --> 00:41:23.300
But I think the air show is a big part of our community.

00:41:23.300 --> 00:41:28.860
It's our airport and our airport board that's heavily involved in that and it has shown a

00:41:28.860 --> 00:41:31.700
lot of support from the community.

00:41:31.700 --> 00:41:34.900
We don't know what their final numbers are going to turn out to be.

00:41:34.900 --> 00:41:35.900
It might be okay.

00:41:35.900 --> 00:41:36.900
There might not be a loss.

00:41:36.900 --> 00:41:38.500
We really don't know at this point.

00:41:38.500 --> 00:41:42.300
So I think since we're all in agreement that if we would have been asked at the front end,

00:41:42.300 --> 00:41:47.420
we would have done it without hesitating, that we should just go ahead and wave the fees

00:41:47.420 --> 00:41:48.700
this year.

00:41:48.700 --> 00:41:53.100
And then two years from now when the air show comes back, we can readdress it then if Council

00:41:53.100 --> 00:42:00.770
feels differently. Anything further on this motion council? I was just hesitating

00:42:00.770 --> 00:42:06.260
whether I should weigh in. I think it's all been said so I don't need to. Jim

00:42:06.260 --> 00:42:18.590
on. You know my I'm I'm really struggling with this one too. I am I'm just down in

00:42:18.590 --> 00:42:23.510
my heart I'm struggling on this one because whereas I understand in the past

00:42:23.510 --> 00:42:33.300
You know, we've paid these fees and we need to get a handle on what we're going to pay

00:42:33.300 --> 00:42:35.700
and what we're not going to pay in the future.

00:42:35.700 --> 00:42:41.420
We really need to do that because it's arbitrary and capricious about how we do this.

00:42:41.420 --> 00:42:49.740
And I'm going to support this this time, but we got to hear this stuff on the front end

00:42:49.740 --> 00:42:56.160
in the future because this is just not passing the smell test for me very well.

00:42:56.160 --> 00:43:00.360
So I think maybe what I'm hearing Travis is in the future,

00:43:00.360 --> 00:43:03.720
if we could have maybe a work session

00:43:03.720 --> 00:43:06.600
or something to take a look at what we do pay for,

00:43:06.600 --> 00:43:09.120
what we don't, what the dynamics are,

00:43:09.120 --> 00:43:12.000
so that we can have a plan on the front end.

00:43:12.000 --> 00:43:15.600
I think that makes sense to me to see what we are paying for,

00:43:15.600 --> 00:43:17.160
what we are not.

00:43:17.160 --> 00:43:19.040
I was part of committees before too,

00:43:19.040 --> 00:43:23.800
that had to pay their fees for security,

00:43:23.800 --> 00:43:26.000
and it was a community event like this.

00:43:26.000 --> 00:43:27.120
And some do, some don't.

00:43:27.120 --> 00:43:29.920
So maybe if we could have a report on that,

00:43:29.920 --> 00:43:33.080
and then Council can weigh in and give guidance

00:43:33.080 --> 00:43:35.760
on the front, and I think would be worthwhile.

00:43:35.760 --> 00:43:37.280
Rebecca Milsoyka.

00:43:37.280 --> 00:43:38.200
Thank you, Mayor.

00:43:38.200 --> 00:43:40.760
Just a final comment on this.

00:43:40.760 --> 00:43:42.200
The reason that I'm struggling with it

00:43:42.200 --> 00:43:45.600
is if another organization comes to us and says,

00:43:45.600 --> 00:43:46.960
our event didn't make a lot of money,

00:43:46.960 --> 00:43:51.160
could you please forgive our safety and security fees?

00:43:51.160 --> 00:43:52.000
What would we say?

00:43:52.000 --> 00:43:53.280
I mean, that's what we have to ask ourselves.

00:43:53.280 --> 00:43:54.600
What would we say?

00:43:54.600 --> 00:43:55.680
Would we grant that request?

00:43:55.680 --> 00:44:01.280
And we were adamant about any Snake River jump that it not cost the taxpayers.

00:44:01.280 --> 00:44:06.620
We were adamant that that event would pay for itself and similarly, there was going to be

00:44:06.620 --> 00:44:11.020
a ticket fee, there was going to be cost to the community.

00:44:11.020 --> 00:44:17.380
So I agree, you know, we need to decide when we're going to provide security and when we're

00:44:17.380 --> 00:44:18.380
not.

00:44:18.380 --> 00:44:23.500
I mean, I just can't see the difference between some of these organizations and I agree that

00:44:23.500 --> 00:44:26.140
It's our airport and we support the airport.

00:44:26.140 --> 00:44:29.930
But this is a private separate event.

00:44:29.930 --> 00:44:31.570
I see no further lights.

00:44:31.570 --> 00:44:33.170
The island will call the police.

00:44:33.170 --> 00:44:34.330
Jim on.

00:44:34.330 --> 00:44:35.170
Yes.

00:44:35.170 --> 00:44:35.970
Schonberger.

00:44:35.970 --> 00:44:36.770
Yes.

00:44:36.770 --> 00:44:37.970
Chris Chalkington.

00:44:37.970 --> 00:44:38.470
Yes.

00:44:38.470 --> 00:44:39.250
Greg Lansing.

00:44:39.250 --> 00:44:39.890
Yes.

00:44:39.890 --> 00:44:40.490
Don Hall.

00:44:40.490 --> 00:44:41.250
Yes.

00:44:41.250 --> 00:44:42.210
Rebecca Milsoika.

00:44:42.210 --> 00:44:43.600
No.

00:44:43.600 --> 00:44:44.560
Suzanne Hawkins.

00:44:44.560 --> 00:44:45.360
Yes.

00:44:45.360 --> 00:44:46.560
Motion passes.

00:44:46.560 --> 00:44:47.960
Six to one.

00:44:47.960 --> 00:44:49.600
Moving to the next item on the agenda,

00:44:49.600 --> 00:44:54.640
it's a request to approve an FAA grant offer

00:44:54.640 --> 00:45:04.280
for AIP36 architectural services for the terminal modification project in the amount of $380,174.

00:45:04.280 --> 00:45:08.840
And we have Bill Carberry back.

00:45:08.840 --> 00:45:09.840
Welcome back, Bill.

00:45:09.840 --> 00:45:12.460
Thank you very much, Mayor.

00:45:12.460 --> 00:45:16.100
I was just conferring with our attorney whether we should do the contract first or the grant,

00:45:16.100 --> 00:45:19.940
but I told let's do the grant first, so we're in the right place.

00:45:19.940 --> 00:45:20.940
Thank you.

00:45:20.940 --> 00:45:25.940
Yeah, I've got an agenda item in each hand here this evening that are sort of pendant to

00:45:25.940 --> 00:45:27.500
hip.

00:45:27.500 --> 00:45:33.300
Last time we went over the feasibility study for the terminal building and its expansion

00:45:33.300 --> 00:45:39.540
for the future project, we started by looking back at history and what's happened, particularly

00:45:39.540 --> 00:45:47.740
since 9-11, the incorporation of TSA into our system, their equipment, their processes.

00:45:47.740 --> 00:45:53.180
So our master plan in 2012 identified the need for some terminal improvements.

00:45:53.180 --> 00:45:57.940
The goals from the master plan that we moved through the feasibility study with were to

00:45:57.940 --> 00:46:03.500
get that check bagged function behind a wall and out of the lobby to improve capacity in

00:46:03.500 --> 00:46:08.500
the whole room which is very constrained there that we have more of a whole experience and

00:46:08.500 --> 00:46:12.620
also to provide some restrooms in the whole room for passenger comfort.

00:46:12.620 --> 00:46:15.740
So the feasibility took a hard look at that.

00:46:15.740 --> 00:46:20.540
We presented different concepts to our advisory board, to our stakeholders.

00:46:20.540 --> 00:46:25.460
We moved through a very deliberate process and we looked at a cost estimating and we presented

00:46:25.460 --> 00:46:29.180
that to both the city and the county bodies for their consideration.

00:46:29.180 --> 00:46:35.940
So the direction from both the city and county was to move forward with a contract and to

00:46:35.940 --> 00:46:42.220
apply for the grant offer to cover that contract for CSHQAs, design services, bidding services

00:46:42.220 --> 00:46:44.580
and construction management services.

00:46:44.580 --> 00:46:51.580
So first off tonight we've got a grant from the FAA to cover the contract and I broke it

00:46:51.580 --> 00:46:53.740
down in your staff report the numbers there.

00:46:53.740 --> 00:46:55.980
A little bit different with this project.

00:46:55.980 --> 00:47:00.060
Most airport improvement projects are 100% eligible.

00:47:00.060 --> 00:47:04.820
The terminal building as we discussed last time we met had some ineligible areas, the revenue

00:47:04.820 --> 00:47:10.780
producing areas of the airline terminal offices and some of the counter areas that were ineligible.

00:47:10.780 --> 00:47:14.600
So by and large, everything was eligible for that AIP program.

00:47:14.600 --> 00:47:19.740
So we took that same percentage towards this contract and applied the FAA eligibility towards

00:47:19.740 --> 00:47:21.340
this contract.

00:47:21.340 --> 00:47:28.900
So the contract for the architect services is $386,886.

00:47:28.900 --> 00:47:40.210
The grant here this evening breaks down to $380,000, $174, 380,174.

00:47:40.210 --> 00:47:42.010
So I'd be happy to answer any questions.

00:47:42.010 --> 00:47:50.320
I do recommend the council consider and authorize the Chairman to sign the grant offer.

00:47:50.320 --> 00:47:51.320
Chris talking to?

00:47:51.320 --> 00:47:56.840
Bill, in your budget this year we have our local match at six and a quarter percent.

00:47:56.840 --> 00:47:58.400
That's covered there.

00:47:58.400 --> 00:47:59.400
That's correct.

00:47:59.400 --> 00:48:03.970
We do have the matching dollars in our budget for the grant.

00:48:03.970 --> 00:48:10.050
Mayor, I'd like to make a motion that council approve consideration of the FAA grant offer

00:48:10.050 --> 00:48:20.500
for AIP 36 grant a IP 36 the amount of 380,174 dollars second motion on

00:48:20.500 --> 00:48:26.040
for by Chris Stockton seconded by Rebecca Mills so I got as stated anything

00:48:26.040 --> 00:48:37.070
further on that motion council the island roll call vote please yes yes yes

00:48:37.070 --> 00:48:38.070
Yes.

00:48:38.070 --> 00:48:39.070
Yes.

00:48:39.070 --> 00:48:40.070
Yes.

00:48:40.070 --> 00:48:41.070
Yes.

00:48:41.070 --> 00:48:42.070
Yes.

00:48:42.070 --> 00:48:43.070
Motion passes.

00:48:43.070 --> 00:48:44.070
Seven to zero.

00:48:44.070 --> 00:48:49.470
Next item on the agenda is a request to approve an agreement for design bidding and construction

00:48:49.470 --> 00:48:57.150
services with CSHQA Architects for the FAA terminal modification project.

00:48:57.150 --> 00:48:58.150
Bill Carberry.

00:48:58.150 --> 00:48:59.150
Thank you, Mayor.

00:48:59.150 --> 00:49:04.350
And I just would like to point out Mark Hill, the principal architect from CSHQA is with

00:49:04.350 --> 00:49:06.550
with us this evening and he's available for questions

00:49:06.550 --> 00:49:09.110
should you have any.

00:49:09.110 --> 00:49:11.870
When I left after the feasibility study,

00:49:11.870 --> 00:49:14.830
Mark and I started to scope out the contract,

00:49:14.830 --> 00:49:18.110
try to get all of our eyes dotted and teas crossed

00:49:18.110 --> 00:49:19.630
for the scope of work.

00:49:19.630 --> 00:49:22.710
And with the FAA, they're a little particular

00:49:22.710 --> 00:49:24.310
with their grants and their design

00:49:24.310 --> 00:49:26.390
kind of professional services contracts.

00:49:26.390 --> 00:49:28.990
What they require the sponsor or the airport to do

00:49:28.990 --> 00:49:32.510
when you anticipate entering a contract more

00:49:32.510 --> 00:49:39.010
than $100,000 for professional services, is to use an independent fee estimate mechanism.

00:49:39.010 --> 00:49:45.630
So I engage Meat and Hunt, which is one of the leading architectural firms in the country

00:49:45.630 --> 00:49:50.550
they deal with airports, and enlisted their services, provided them an apples to apples

00:49:50.550 --> 00:49:56.450
scope of work, and did a comparison, a man-hour comparison, looked at what they would charge

00:49:56.450 --> 00:49:57.950
for such a project.

00:49:57.950 --> 00:50:05.110
So I was very pleased that their estimate came in within about 9% of CSHQA.

00:50:05.110 --> 00:50:10.950
CSHQA's contract total was $386,886.

00:50:10.950 --> 00:50:16.350
The independent fee estimate for meeting hunt was $421,931.

00:50:16.350 --> 00:50:21.170
So the FA project manager I work with was pleased typically when you're within 10 or

00:50:21.170 --> 00:50:24.870
15%, you figure that people are seeing eye to eye on a project.

00:50:24.870 --> 00:50:33.860
So it's a way for me to sort of gauge if we're in the right place with CSHQA.

00:50:33.860 --> 00:50:36.460
So with that, I'd just like to review the schedule for the project.

00:50:36.460 --> 00:50:43.220
We're hoping to design this out through the end of 2014, bid it late-14 or early-15, hopefully

00:50:43.220 --> 00:50:48.180
award the bid for construction and we'll be back once we receive those bids in the spring,

00:50:48.180 --> 00:50:52.460
hopefully great ground and complete the project in late 2015.

00:50:52.460 --> 00:50:58.280
So it's a fairly aggressive schedule, but I think one that's reasonable.

00:50:58.280 --> 00:51:03.120
So with that, I'd stand for any questions, but I do recommend that Council approve the agreement

00:51:03.120 --> 00:51:12.980
for architectural and engineering services with CSHQA and the amount of 386, $386, contingent

00:51:12.980 --> 00:51:15.540
upon FAA concurrence and available funding.

00:51:15.540 --> 00:51:19.540
That's sort of my catch-all phrase with these contracts, but with the grant, in my other

00:51:19.540 --> 00:51:22.940
hand, we have received the concurrence and their funding.

00:51:22.940 --> 00:51:29.940
much as it again exactly. The contract amount is $386,886.75.

00:51:29.940 --> 00:51:36.290
That would be best for you. Okay, can't forget that 75 cents, Bill.

00:51:36.290 --> 00:51:41.730
Councilman, talking. And Bill, you might just take just a second to remind the

00:51:41.730 --> 00:51:46.070
Council that in the press and the public that much of what we're doing is

00:51:46.070 --> 00:51:53.130
911 TSA driven and we're also being planful for attracting further service.

00:51:53.130 --> 00:51:54.730
Could you take just a moment?

00:51:54.730 --> 00:51:56.490
Thank you, Chris, for the question.

00:51:56.490 --> 00:51:58.730
Yeah, I've been trying to get out in the community

00:51:58.730 --> 00:52:00.890
to the morning rotaries in the Kiwanis Club

00:52:00.890 --> 00:52:03.490
and try to discuss the project with the community.

00:52:03.490 --> 00:52:06.250
And just to clear up, if there's any confusion,

00:52:06.250 --> 00:52:08.730
this is something we've been looking at for several years.

00:52:08.730 --> 00:52:10.810
We've moved into a master plan with our sites

00:52:10.810 --> 00:52:12.530
on this type of a thing.

00:52:12.530 --> 00:52:14.410
It's not something we've come up recently,

00:52:14.410 --> 00:52:16.530
but it's something, I'd like to say,

00:52:16.530 --> 00:52:18.370
it cures some of our current deficiencies,

00:52:18.370 --> 00:52:19.930
and I've discussed the deficiencies.

00:52:19.930 --> 00:52:22.130
We've got queuing out into the lobby.

00:52:22.130 --> 00:52:25.310
We've got people pulling, rifling through bags and doing check

00:52:25.310 --> 00:52:26.810
baggage in the lobby.

00:52:26.810 --> 00:52:28.010
We need to cure those things.

00:52:28.010 --> 00:52:30.290
We need to get restrooms, make people more comfortable on

00:52:30.290 --> 00:52:32.490
the whole side in the sterile area.

00:52:32.490 --> 00:52:36.290
And really, we're hoping to build a project that has the

00:52:36.290 --> 00:52:39.650
ability for future opportunities, if we were ever to get

00:52:39.650 --> 00:52:43.650
larger aircraft, some day, ski churs, whatever it might be.

00:52:43.650 --> 00:52:44.770
We won't have a showstopper.

00:52:44.770 --> 00:52:47.010
We'll have a facility that can accommodate any kind of

00:52:47.010 --> 00:52:48.090
future growth.

00:52:48.090 --> 00:52:51.450
So really, it's twofold in the reason we're doing that,

00:52:51.450 --> 00:52:55.190
this project so i appreciate the question it's it's not something that's

00:52:55.190 --> 00:52:57.330
just been a reaction recently

00:52:57.330 --> 00:52:59.370
bill thank you chris

00:52:59.370 --> 00:53:02.410
any further questions council

00:53:02.410 --> 00:53:06.460
stanford motion

00:53:06.460 --> 00:53:10.200
restocking well i'll take the uh... the pleasure of the end of uh...

00:53:10.200 --> 00:53:12.840
moving council authorize uh...

00:53:12.840 --> 00:53:16.880
the uh... agreement for design betting construction services with c h

00:53:16.880 --> 00:53:18.500
uh... q a

00:53:18.500 --> 00:53:21.880
in the amount of three hundred eighty six thousand eight eighty six point seven

00:53:21.880 --> 00:53:24.480
five

00:53:24.480 --> 00:53:31.120
motion on board by Chris talking seconded by Greg Lanting as stated further on that motion council

00:53:31.120 --> 00:53:46.830
the island will call vote yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes motion passes

00:53:46.830 --> 00:53:50.990
zero bill thank you and I don't know if there's anything more worthy than to

00:53:50.990 --> 00:53:53.270
to try to get the terminal fixed.

00:53:53.270 --> 00:53:55.230
It needs some work.

00:53:55.230 --> 00:53:56.230
Thank you.

00:53:56.230 --> 00:53:57.230
Thank you.

00:53:57.230 --> 00:53:58.230
Thank you.

00:53:58.230 --> 00:54:02.550
Next item on the agenda is a request from Nate Stinson to waive the nonconforming building

00:54:02.550 --> 00:54:10.990
expansion permit process for a home located at 311 Falls Avenue West and we have Mitch

00:54:10.990 --> 00:54:12.950
Humboldt making a presentation.

00:54:12.950 --> 00:54:13.950
Welcome Mitch.

00:54:13.950 --> 00:54:14.950
Hey.

00:54:14.950 --> 00:54:24.050
I think it was on or not.

00:54:24.050 --> 00:54:30.610
I have some pictures to show, so I'm going to, well, that warms up.

00:54:30.610 --> 00:54:36.630
So this is a request for non-conforming building expansion permit waiver.

00:54:36.630 --> 00:54:41.390
Sometimes we have buildings built, or not really built in town, but sometimes they're built before

00:54:41.390 --> 00:54:44.470
the rules change or when they're out of the city limits, they may annex them.

00:54:44.470 --> 00:54:49.130
So, for some reason or other, they're a non-conforming building, and occasionally those folks that

00:54:49.130 --> 00:54:53.670
own those buildings want to add on to them or remodel them in some fashion.

00:54:53.670 --> 00:54:56.110
So that's basically what brings us to tonight.

00:54:56.110 --> 00:55:01.110
We have a non-conforming home along Falls Avenue,

00:55:01.790 --> 00:55:03.790
and 311 Falls Avenue West,

00:55:03.790 --> 00:55:06.270
and it's up here on the picture now.

00:55:06.270 --> 00:55:08.670
And the reason it's non-conforming is Falls Avenue

00:55:08.670 --> 00:55:13.670
is a arterial, and so it has a centerline building setback

00:55:13.950 --> 00:55:15.110
where most of our other streets

00:55:15.110 --> 00:55:16.670
just have like a property line setback,

00:55:16.670 --> 00:55:19.030
and it's a little bigger of a centerline setback

00:55:19.030 --> 00:55:20.510
because of it's an arterial.

00:55:20.510 --> 00:55:26.190
And so the yellow line here represents the front yard set back for the buildings along

00:55:26.190 --> 00:55:27.190
falls.

00:55:27.190 --> 00:55:31.990
You can see if you project this at several of the homes on either side of them for some ways

00:55:31.990 --> 00:55:36.430
or also going to be nonconforming for the same reason.

00:55:36.430 --> 00:55:38.670
So it's nonconforming building.

00:55:38.670 --> 00:55:43.510
They're proposing to add a second bathroom to the home back here behind the building line.

00:55:43.510 --> 00:55:47.670
And when that kind of thing comes along, you can do this one of two ways.

00:55:47.670 --> 00:55:50.390
you can go through a public hearing process that takes

00:55:50.390 --> 00:55:52.670
sometimes six or so weeks to get through

00:55:54.390 --> 00:55:56.990
to decide whether we should expand this non-conform billing

00:55:56.990 --> 00:55:59.390
or because it's a home, they can come straight

00:55:59.390 --> 00:56:01.830
to the council and ask for that process to be waived.

00:56:01.830 --> 00:56:04.830
And that's what they're asking for tonight.

00:56:04.830 --> 00:56:07.910
When we had a way of this process of a long drawn out

00:56:07.910 --> 00:56:09.470
public hearing kind of thing.

00:56:09.470 --> 00:56:11.430
And so we bring these types of requests

00:56:11.430 --> 00:56:13.390
to the council every now and then they don't happen a lot,

00:56:13.390 --> 00:56:15.030
but maybe two, three times a year.

00:56:15.030 --> 00:56:21.420
And we basically throw it on the council for a decision there.

00:56:21.420 --> 00:56:24.780
So that's where we're at tonight.

00:56:24.780 --> 00:56:27.220
The proposed expansion will not further

00:56:27.220 --> 00:56:28.900
encroach into the front yard.

00:56:28.900 --> 00:56:32.560
In fact, the proposed expansion meets every bit of our code

00:56:32.560 --> 00:56:33.660
in terms of a setback.

00:56:33.660 --> 00:56:36.140
And so these types of situations we typically

00:56:36.140 --> 00:56:39.100
have seen them come through and they're typically approved.

00:56:39.100 --> 00:56:41.060
So with that, I'll just turn it over to you guys.

00:56:41.060 --> 00:56:43.740
I have a question before I answer them for you.

00:56:43.740 --> 00:56:45.780
Is Mr. Stinson here in case we have questions.

00:56:45.780 --> 00:56:46.780
I think so, yes.

00:56:46.780 --> 00:56:48.780
Oh, there you go.

00:56:48.780 --> 00:56:49.780
Sorry, yeah.

00:56:49.780 --> 00:56:52.100
He can answer your questions, too, or I can give a shot.

00:56:52.100 --> 00:56:53.100
Very good.

00:56:53.100 --> 00:56:54.100
Thank you.

00:56:54.100 --> 00:56:55.100
Chris talking to us.

00:56:55.100 --> 00:56:59.900
Mitch, how about the side guard setback, but the proposal, proposed construction, are

00:56:59.900 --> 00:57:01.900
we still within R4?

00:57:01.900 --> 00:57:06.420
Yeah, so funny you should ask, right?

00:57:06.420 --> 00:57:15.950
Here this actually, I think it's that.

00:57:15.950 --> 00:57:22.070
This number right here says that that is an 8-foot setback from the property line, which

00:57:22.070 --> 00:57:28.470
exceeds our side yard setback, with 5-foot side yard setback in the R4 zone.

00:57:28.470 --> 00:57:29.470
Greg Lanning.

00:57:29.470 --> 00:57:33.750
Well, as somebody else says further questions, I'll go ahead with the motion.

00:57:33.750 --> 00:57:35.310
Any further questions?

00:57:35.310 --> 00:57:37.070
I'll leave the motion for you, Greg.

00:57:37.070 --> 00:57:38.630
Rebecca, may I second?

00:57:38.630 --> 00:57:39.630
Thank you, Mayor.

00:57:39.630 --> 00:57:45.750
Just one question for the applicant since if this is approved, there won't be a public hearing

00:57:45.750 --> 00:57:48.110
to inform your neighbors of your expansion.

00:57:48.110 --> 00:57:50.790
I'm just, it looks like the only neighbor that might be affected

00:57:50.790 --> 00:57:53.150
by maybe the noise or the construction would be the neighbor

00:57:53.150 --> 00:57:54.270
to the west of you.

00:57:54.270 --> 00:57:57.630
I was wondering if you had informed them.

00:57:57.630 --> 00:57:58.470
Yeah.

00:57:58.470 --> 00:58:01.140
Mr. Stenson, if you could come forward.

00:58:01.140 --> 00:58:03.500
The reason we ask is because it's televised

00:58:03.500 --> 00:58:06.720
and the mics so people can hear.

00:58:06.720 --> 00:58:08.240
Yeah, he knows about it.

00:58:08.240 --> 00:58:10.880
Okay, and he's comfortable with that.

00:58:10.880 --> 00:58:11.720
Yeah, he's still be fine with that.

00:58:11.720 --> 00:58:13.440
Okay, thank you.

00:58:13.440 --> 00:58:15.000
Thank you, Mr. Stenson.

00:58:15.000 --> 00:58:16.080
Appreciate it.

00:58:16.080 --> 00:58:17.540
I don't think we have any further questions.

00:58:17.540 --> 00:58:18.540
Greg Lanning.

00:58:18.540 --> 00:58:26.560
Mayor, I'd like to move that we approve the request by Nate Stinson to waive the non-conforming

00:58:26.560 --> 00:58:33.200
building expense and permit process for his home located at 311 Falls Avenue West for him

00:58:33.200 --> 00:58:36.840
to add 144 foot second bathroom.

00:58:36.840 --> 00:58:37.840
Square foot.

00:58:37.840 --> 00:58:38.840
Square foot.

00:58:38.840 --> 00:58:39.840
Very good.

00:58:39.840 --> 00:58:40.840
Second.

00:58:40.840 --> 00:58:42.840
I have a motion on the floor by Greg Lanning.

00:58:42.840 --> 00:58:45.900
by Sean Berger.

00:58:45.900 --> 00:58:49.440
Anything further on the motion council?

00:58:49.440 --> 00:58:50.920
Leila please.

00:58:50.920 --> 00:58:51.760
Greg Lanting.

00:58:51.760 --> 00:58:52.600
Yes.

00:58:52.600 --> 00:58:53.440
Don Hall.

00:58:53.440 --> 00:58:54.440
Yes.

00:58:54.440 --> 00:58:55.440
Rebecca Misoica.

00:58:55.440 --> 00:58:56.440
Yes.

00:58:56.440 --> 00:58:57.440
Suzanne Hawkins.

00:58:57.440 --> 00:58:58.440
Yes.

00:58:58.440 --> 00:58:59.440
Jim Munn.

00:58:59.440 --> 00:59:00.440
Yes.

00:59:00.440 --> 00:59:01.440
Sean Berger.

00:59:01.440 --> 00:59:02.440
Yes.

00:59:02.440 --> 00:59:03.440
Yes.

00:59:03.440 --> 00:59:04.440
Motion passes.

00:59:04.440 --> 00:59:05.440
Seven to zero.

00:59:05.440 --> 00:59:06.440
Congratulations Mr. Stinson.

00:59:06.440 --> 00:59:10.840
Next item on the agenda is request to adopt an ordinance for a zoning district change and zoning

00:59:10.840 --> 00:59:19.360
map amendment to rezone 6.927 acres from R1 variable to sui for property located west

00:59:19.360 --> 00:59:26.700
of 3236 avenue avenue west east. I can't talk tonight.

00:59:26.700 --> 00:59:28.720
Mitchell Hump.

00:59:28.720 --> 00:59:34.980
So tonight we have an ordinance for your adoption. If you'll recall back in April that we had

00:59:34.980 --> 00:59:40.550
a public hearing to rezone some property on Madison east for the core family. I don't

00:59:40.550 --> 00:59:58.550
We have the hearing there in late July for the county commissioners, they approve the request, and so here we have the ordinance ready for adoption to make that make that change official.

00:59:58.550 --> 01:00:01.550
I don't know the number that we're on that.

01:00:01.550 --> 01:00:08.990
ordinance number if we choose 3079 thank you so if you choose to adopt it

01:00:08.990 --> 01:00:14.190
tonight we can do that if we leave the rules and the procedures there for

01:00:14.190 --> 01:00:20.110
third and final if we want to we can come back more times and talk about thank

01:00:20.110 --> 01:00:23.870
you Mitch Rebecca Mills so I thank you mayor just a quick question on the

01:00:23.870 --> 01:00:29.440
property Mitch we just recently had a public hearing where they talked about

01:00:29.440 --> 01:00:35.880
when City Code requires you to connect to City, Water, and Sewer.

01:00:35.880 --> 01:00:42.800
So can you remind us when people have to connect and if this property will have to connect or

01:00:42.800 --> 01:00:44.360
not?

01:00:44.360 --> 01:00:47.600
This property is actually currently outside the water service boundary.

01:00:47.600 --> 01:00:51.760
So I don't think we would allow them to connect.

01:00:51.760 --> 01:00:54.400
Not just we wouldn't require them to connect.

01:00:54.400 --> 01:00:56.320
We wouldn't even allow it because they're outside the boundary.

01:00:56.320 --> 01:01:05.460
So if you have a water line, I was thinking it's 1000 feet, so if you have a property

01:01:05.460 --> 01:01:11.500
within 1000 feet of a water or sewer system and you have like a sewer, a septic system

01:01:11.500 --> 01:01:15.500
and it fails, you can't get a permit to put in a new septic system, you got to run and

01:01:15.500 --> 01:01:17.340
connect it to the sewer line.

01:01:17.340 --> 01:01:20.620
But where this is outside the boundary, we wouldn't do that here.

01:01:20.620 --> 01:01:25.780
Okay, and so how does that apply to the new school, then that is outside the water boundary

01:01:25.780 --> 01:01:26.780
as well?

01:01:26.780 --> 01:01:27.780
Right.

01:01:27.780 --> 01:01:35.380
So they wouldn't offer them services unless there's a change to the water

01:01:35.380 --> 01:01:36.380
boundary.

01:01:36.380 --> 01:01:38.310
Okay.

01:01:38.310 --> 01:01:39.310
Thank you.

01:01:39.310 --> 01:01:40.310
Chris talking.

01:01:40.310 --> 01:01:45.670
However, I do remember one discussion about the rezoning of the property related to access

01:01:45.670 --> 01:01:55.920
on fall season of not having four or five, six individual entrance exits but more controlled

01:01:55.920 --> 01:02:00.260
by the rezoning from the R1 variable to SUI,

01:02:00.260 --> 01:02:05.400
the study does not lose its ability to control that

01:02:05.400 --> 01:02:08.200
upon the plating and the approval process

01:02:08.200 --> 01:02:11.200
for controlling access to Addison.

01:02:11.200 --> 01:02:14.800
Right, so when they come time for this property

01:02:14.800 --> 01:02:16.740
to develop, they'll have to come through a plat process

01:02:16.740 --> 01:02:19.560
to do so because of the area impact

01:02:19.560 --> 01:02:20.760
and agreement we have in County,

01:02:20.760 --> 01:02:23.320
they're gonna come through the city to do that.

01:02:23.320 --> 01:02:24.920
Eventually that plat is approved

01:02:24.920 --> 01:02:28.320
by the county commissioners, and we make a recommendation to them for that.

01:02:28.320 --> 01:02:33.040
We'll have to comply with the city codes and standards and yes,

01:02:33.040 --> 01:02:40.200
so we have an opportunity to weigh in on the access of those types of issues at the time of planning.

01:02:42.420 --> 01:02:44.240
Anything further council?

01:02:44.240 --> 01:02:45.100
Greg Lanning.

01:02:45.100 --> 01:02:53.520
Mayor Hall, I move that we suspend the rules and place orders 30-79 on third and final by title only.

01:02:53.520 --> 01:02:54.360
Second.

01:02:54.360 --> 01:02:55.760
A motion on the floor by Greg Lanning,

01:02:55.760 --> 01:02:58.680
seconded by Jim Mon to suspend the rolls

01:02:58.680 --> 01:03:03.680
and place ordinance 3079 on third and final title.

01:03:04.720 --> 01:03:07.990
Anything further on that motion council?

01:03:07.990 --> 01:03:09.670
May I have a roll call vote please?

01:03:09.670 --> 01:03:10.510
Don Hall.

01:03:10.510 --> 01:03:11.350
Yes.

01:03:11.350 --> 01:03:12.190
Rebecca Milsoica.

01:03:12.190 --> 01:03:13.030
Yes.

01:03:13.030 --> 01:03:13.870
Suzanne Hawkins.

01:03:13.870 --> 01:03:14.690
Yes.

01:03:14.690 --> 01:03:15.530
Jim Mon.

01:03:15.530 --> 01:03:16.350
Yes.

01:03:16.350 --> 01:03:17.190
Sean Berger.

01:03:17.190 --> 01:03:18.030
Yes.

01:03:18.030 --> 01:03:19.110
Chris talking to Greg Lanthi.

01:03:19.110 --> 01:03:19.950
Yes.

01:03:19.950 --> 01:03:21.750
Motion passes, seven to zero.

01:03:21.750 --> 01:03:24.350
Could you read the last title please?

01:03:24.350 --> 01:03:29.780
In ordinance of the city council of the city of Twin Falls, Idaho, we zoning

01:03:29.780 --> 01:03:34.700
real property below describe providing the zoning classification therefore and

01:03:34.700 --> 01:03:42.240
ordering the necessary area of impact in zoning districts met by council wishes on

01:03:42.240 --> 01:03:49.510
that ordinance Suzanne Hawkins I move approval of ordinance 30 79 second

01:03:49.510 --> 01:03:53.550
motion on the floor by Suzanne Hawkins seconded by Greg Lanting to approve

01:03:53.550 --> 01:04:00.830
ordinance 3079. Bless you. Anything further on that motion council?

01:04:00.830 --> 01:04:07.070
Leila Ro, call vote please. Rebecca Milsoyka. Yes. Suzanne Hawkins. Yes. Jim

01:04:07.070 --> 01:04:13.990
Munn. Yes. Sean Berriger. Yes. Chris Tockington. Yes. Greg Lanthien. Yes. Don Hall. Yes. Motion passes

01:04:13.990 --> 01:04:21.710
7-0. Thank you, Mitch. Excited on the agenda. Request to award a bid to construct the

01:04:21.710 --> 01:04:24.150
pillar falls and the and the

01:04:24.150 --> 01:04:29.070
ten evil sections of the Snake River Canyon rim trail to Idaho Sand and

01:04:29.070 --> 01:04:34.590
gravel our parks and recreation director yes lawyer thank you mayor just to

01:04:34.590 --> 01:04:38.090
clarify Paul Austin has not known me since I was this big only about this

01:04:38.090 --> 01:04:42.790
baby you were tiny like that baby I started as two foot tall anyway yeah I

01:04:42.790 --> 01:04:47.550
don't live you ever that small but yes Paul has known me for over 40 years and

01:04:47.550 --> 01:04:50.110
It's often a pleasure to know Paul and work without him,

01:04:50.110 --> 01:04:51.310
or by the head.

01:04:51.310 --> 01:04:54.190
Tonight I'm here to talk about a couple more pieces

01:04:54.190 --> 01:04:54.950
of the puzzle.

01:04:54.950 --> 01:04:57.470
And I've been calling our Kenium Trelles just pieces

01:04:57.470 --> 01:04:58.110
of the puzzle.

01:04:58.110 --> 01:05:00.790
And we have two more that we're going to find, hopefully,

01:05:00.790 --> 01:05:02.150
after your consideration tonight.

01:05:02.150 --> 01:05:04.430
Get built this year.

01:05:04.430 --> 01:05:06.550
Tonight I'm asking the council to award the bid

01:05:06.550 --> 01:05:09.750
to Idos and Engravel for the Pillar Falls section

01:05:09.750 --> 01:05:11.550
and the Kineville section of building those two

01:05:11.550 --> 01:05:12.870
Kenium and Trelles.

01:05:12.870 --> 01:05:16.150
And let me quickly just show you on the screen here,

01:05:16.150 --> 01:05:22.200
those two sections I'm talking about.

01:05:22.200 --> 01:05:24.340
Okay, maybe a little harder to sell.

01:05:24.340 --> 01:05:26.700
Here's a prime bridge here.

01:05:26.700 --> 01:05:28.580
Then our current trail from the bridge

01:05:28.580 --> 01:05:30.500
runs along East Lawn Canyon Rim.

01:05:31.380 --> 01:05:33.300
And then it stops at this residence

01:05:33.300 --> 01:05:35.800
and comes straight down south to Poline.

01:05:35.800 --> 01:05:37.680
This section of the trail, as I call it,

01:05:37.680 --> 01:05:41.180
the pillar fall section will wrap around this residence house

01:05:41.180 --> 01:05:43.180
right here, come along the rim,

01:05:43.180 --> 01:05:46.160
and then shoot straight south again to Poline Road.

01:05:46.160 --> 01:05:47.540
So that's the pillar fall section,

01:05:47.540 --> 01:05:49.960
approximately about 2,100 men near feet.

01:05:49.960 --> 01:05:51.780
And the Keneville section, I've been calling it,

01:05:51.780 --> 01:05:53.880
have you ever been walked up the Centennial Trail

01:05:53.880 --> 01:05:56.900
all the way to the end of it?

01:05:56.900 --> 01:05:58.720
That's a mile and a half out of Shilshon Falls,

01:05:58.720 --> 01:05:59.560
so let's let you know.

01:05:59.560 --> 01:06:01.120
It's a good hike, too.

01:06:01.120 --> 01:06:05.200
That our Keneville section will just continue on

01:06:05.200 --> 01:06:07.120
where it stops right now, the Centennial Trail,

01:06:07.120 --> 01:06:10.640
and just head west approximately about 650 feet.

01:06:10.640 --> 01:06:13.240
So it just goes right in front of the jump site.

01:06:13.240 --> 01:06:16.320
I'll give you also kind of a little bit more information

01:06:16.320 --> 01:06:19.240
is that I've been having Bruce Stevens,

01:06:19.240 --> 01:06:21.280
he's a retired street superintendent,

01:06:21.280 --> 01:06:23.920
he's been working part-time for us the last couple of years.

01:06:23.920 --> 01:06:25.600
What's really nice about having him,

01:06:25.600 --> 01:06:29.440
he can operate any piece of street equipment that we have,

01:06:29.440 --> 01:06:32.200
and we sometimes take advantage of that situation.

01:06:32.200 --> 01:06:34.600
And what we have this year is,

01:06:34.600 --> 01:06:36.160
if you ever been out to right now,

01:06:36.160 --> 01:06:39.360
the subdivision out at Hankins Road, part of it's paved,

01:06:39.360 --> 01:06:41.720
and then you can actually go on that pavement,

01:06:41.720 --> 01:06:44.200
and if you know the correct dirt road you would take,

01:06:44.200 --> 01:06:48.680
you wander off and you can drive all the way to the base of the kiniable site.

01:06:48.680 --> 01:06:51.960
So you're driving on private property, but then driving on city property.

01:06:51.960 --> 01:06:58.100
Well what we have had so far is someday hopefully we'll have a road from Hankins out to the jump

01:06:58.100 --> 01:06:59.100
site.

01:06:59.100 --> 01:07:04.200
But in the meantime, we've had Bruce that if you directly south of the jump site, approximately

01:07:04.200 --> 01:07:08.880
1200 feet, it's pretty well kind of a dirt road that's been there for ever and ever.

01:07:08.880 --> 01:07:13.120
But once you get about this point here, on a hard property because we have that 50 foot

01:07:13.120 --> 01:07:17.560
white path is, it's just been, you know, the land out there.

01:07:17.560 --> 01:07:20.620
Well, we've had Bruce out there kind of with a greater

01:07:20.620 --> 01:07:22.440
and then he dropped off some re-grind

01:07:22.440 --> 01:07:24.720
that he's kind of made a little trail for us

01:07:24.720 --> 01:07:28.600
that we'll be able to, in next year's budget,

01:07:28.600 --> 01:07:30.280
be able to fence off property off

01:07:30.280 --> 01:07:31.720
and people will be able to park there

01:07:31.720 --> 01:07:33.880
and actually walk all the way to the jump site.

01:07:33.880 --> 01:07:35.360
And even though it won't be paved yet,

01:07:35.360 --> 01:07:37.560
but at least we'll finally get a little connection loop

01:07:37.560 --> 01:07:38.400
on there.

01:07:38.400 --> 01:07:39.960
So I thought it just informed the council of that.

01:07:39.960 --> 01:07:42.240
So some of the advantages that we've been having,

01:07:42.240 --> 01:07:44.960
and have been Bruce been working for the last 12 years.

01:07:44.960 --> 01:07:46.280
Rebecca had some questions, Dennis?

01:07:46.280 --> 01:07:46.780
Yes.

01:07:46.780 --> 01:07:47.440
Thank you, Dennis.

01:07:47.440 --> 01:07:48.560
That's great news.

01:07:48.560 --> 01:07:49.320
Quick question.

01:07:49.320 --> 01:07:53.400
Remind us what, is there development there,

01:07:53.400 --> 01:07:56.400
why the trail is back away from the canyon rim?

01:07:56.400 --> 01:07:58.120
Are there already houses and things there?

01:07:58.120 --> 01:07:59.120
I mean, along here.

01:07:59.120 --> 01:08:00.240
Yes, along this property.

01:08:00.240 --> 01:08:01.240
And who owns it?

01:08:01.240 --> 01:08:03.440
OK, this is just the proposed route.

01:08:03.440 --> 01:08:06.040
When we hopefully can work with this developer here,

01:08:06.040 --> 01:08:09.400
there is houses all along here until about right here.

01:08:09.400 --> 01:08:11.240
So there's these houses that we will not

01:08:11.240 --> 01:08:13.400
be able to access to have Canyon Rim Trail.

01:08:13.400 --> 01:08:17.240
And this is just, you know, this is not a defined route.

01:08:17.240 --> 01:08:18.960
This is the route that we kind of show

01:08:18.960 --> 01:08:20.480
that's gonna go through that development.

01:08:20.480 --> 01:08:22.640
We don't know exactly how that route will work.

01:08:22.640 --> 01:08:24.760
Whenever that developer starts to developing,

01:08:24.760 --> 01:08:26.680
we'll sit down with him or her

01:08:26.680 --> 01:08:29.400
and figure that out.

01:08:29.400 --> 01:08:30.920
Perfect, but wherever we can,

01:08:30.920 --> 01:08:34.680
we'll get as close to that Canyon Rim as we can.

01:08:34.680 --> 01:08:36.520
Yes. Okay, perfect.

01:08:36.520 --> 01:08:37.960
Thank you.

01:08:37.960 --> 01:08:40.360
All right, so kind of back to what I'm here tonight

01:08:40.360 --> 01:08:43.200
is asking the council to consider to award this bid

01:08:43.200 --> 01:08:45.680
to idle standing gravel.

01:08:45.680 --> 01:08:47.080
These two sections I've talked about,

01:08:47.080 --> 01:08:49.160
and also that first section with pillar follows

01:08:49.160 --> 01:08:51.720
is the one that our grant writer, Manny Thompson,

01:08:51.720 --> 01:08:52.800
myself, were done and granted.

01:08:52.800 --> 01:08:55.560
We was awarded a little bit of over $44,000

01:08:55.560 --> 01:08:59.800
from the state of I-02 goal for this project here.

01:08:59.800 --> 01:09:01.840
Also, staff has hired EHM engineers

01:09:01.840 --> 01:09:04.880
for their professional service to design the trail,

01:09:04.880 --> 01:09:07.840
do the bidding, and do the overseas construction.

01:09:07.840 --> 01:09:11.400
And with the EHM, they estimated these two sections

01:09:11.400 --> 01:09:14.280
were under $100,000 so by state code

01:09:14.280 --> 01:09:15.940
that we were just required to get

01:09:15.940 --> 01:09:18.200
the least three estimates from companies.

01:09:18.200 --> 01:09:20.760
And EHM went out there and asked for four estimates

01:09:20.760 --> 01:09:22.160
and only got back two.

01:09:22.160 --> 01:09:24.160
One was from my understanding, and gravel,

01:09:24.160 --> 01:09:27.240
and then the other one from Fauffer concrete, or ink,

01:09:27.240 --> 01:09:28.080
excuse me.

01:09:28.080 --> 01:09:30.000
And you kind of seen your packet, the two beds,

01:09:30.000 --> 01:09:34.320
Eido standing gravel had a total of $88,973,

01:09:34.320 --> 01:09:38.600
and Klawfer had a total of $155,066.

01:09:38.600 --> 01:09:41.040
I do have Tim Bosser in the audience from EHMs,

01:09:41.040 --> 01:09:44.440
so if you have any questions for him, he's available also.

01:09:46.200 --> 01:09:49.560
This bid is only for the construction of those two trails.

01:09:49.560 --> 01:09:51.960
We do have fence costs for that.

01:09:51.960 --> 01:09:53.720
I estimated on the pillar falls,

01:09:53.720 --> 01:09:56.080
we'll have approximately about 1,000 feet of fencing

01:09:56.080 --> 01:09:59.720
because of that trail is really hugs to the rim quite a bit.

01:09:59.720 --> 01:10:01.160
And also the Keneville section,

01:10:01.160 --> 01:10:02.800
it's about on the rim the whole way,

01:10:02.800 --> 01:10:05.320
So I estimated about all 600 linear feet.

01:10:05.320 --> 01:10:09.240
So those two will be a separate contract

01:10:09.240 --> 01:10:11.000
with a fencing company to award that.

01:10:11.000 --> 01:10:13.000
But tonight I'm just here to consider the award

01:10:13.000 --> 01:10:14.400
to have to counsel consider the award

01:10:14.400 --> 01:10:18.200
for the two section of the trails.

01:10:18.200 --> 01:10:22.640
Budget wise that right now we have over $200,000 set aside

01:10:22.640 --> 01:10:25.480
for Canyon Rim Trails.

01:10:25.480 --> 01:10:28.120
What's nice about this is really has been a community effort.

01:10:28.120 --> 01:10:29.680
The Twin Falls Community Foundation

01:10:29.680 --> 01:10:33.280
has committed $10,000 for this section of the trail,

01:10:33.280 --> 01:10:35.920
and also the Magic Valley Trail Enhancement Committee,

01:10:35.920 --> 01:10:38.160
they've been that fun run group you might call them,

01:10:38.160 --> 01:10:40.440
they've been out there raising funds for all their fund runs

01:10:40.440 --> 01:10:43.720
in the past several years, and they have committed $7,500

01:10:43.720 --> 01:10:44.560
for this project.

01:10:44.560 --> 01:10:47.080
So just doing these two sections of the trails,

01:10:47.080 --> 01:10:49.200
not including the fence, is only gonna cost the city

01:10:49.200 --> 01:10:53.680
about $27,000, and with the fence about another 30,000.

01:10:53.680 --> 01:10:56.120
So we can complete these two sections of trail

01:10:56.120 --> 01:10:57.840
that are only gonna be costing our tax dollars

01:10:57.840 --> 01:11:01.720
of the $57,000 with the grant we received

01:11:01.720 --> 01:11:03.280
and the other two donations.

01:11:03.280 --> 01:11:06.640
So if you have any questions, I'm available.

01:11:06.640 --> 01:11:08.100
Or if Tim, if you have any questions,

01:11:08.100 --> 01:11:10.280
Tim Bosser, I'm available.

01:11:10.280 --> 01:11:11.920
Looks like a Christmas tree up here.

01:11:11.920 --> 01:11:13.680
Okay, Suzanne Hopkins.

01:11:13.680 --> 01:11:14.780
I'm gonna stray a little bit.

01:11:14.780 --> 01:11:17.680
I think this is really good news on the cost on this part.

01:11:17.680 --> 01:11:20.160
But have we had a chance to go back over by Canyon Crest

01:11:20.160 --> 01:11:22.160
and get estimates on repairing that part

01:11:22.160 --> 01:11:23.560
of the Canyon Room Trail?

01:11:23.560 --> 01:11:24.920
We are working on that right now.

01:11:24.920 --> 01:11:27.800
Actually, we've been working with EH and we met

01:11:27.800 --> 01:11:29.900
last week and they are getting some estimates

01:11:29.900 --> 01:11:32.200
and kind of designs and our engineering staff

01:11:32.200 --> 01:11:33.440
was out there with them too.

01:11:33.440 --> 01:11:37.340
So hopefully we'll have that available.

01:11:37.340 --> 01:11:39.280
Anytime, Tim, for that.

01:11:39.280 --> 01:11:40.980
All right, I'll leave you with me.

01:11:40.980 --> 01:11:41.620
OK.

01:11:41.620 --> 01:11:42.120
Great.

01:11:41.940 --> 01:11:42.980
Thank you.

01:11:42.980 --> 01:11:45.380
I had the same question today from some citizens.

01:11:45.380 --> 01:11:48.980
So once we get a design or an idea of what we're going to do,

01:11:48.980 --> 01:11:51.340
are we going to be able to open that up this year?

01:11:51.340 --> 01:11:54.500
We might be able to.

01:11:54.500 --> 01:11:56.420
That's my hope, is try to get it open

01:11:56.420 --> 01:11:58.700
before the weather system.

01:11:58.700 --> 01:11:59.540
Thank you.

01:11:59.540 --> 01:12:00.860
Chris Doughton.

01:12:00.860 --> 01:12:04.740
So Dennis, I'm confused now the low debt of 88,

01:12:04.740 --> 01:12:08.780
low bit under 89,000 does not include the fencing,

01:12:08.780 --> 01:12:11.020
which would be 30.

01:12:11.020 --> 01:12:14.700
So did you figure that 30 end up come up with the 27,

01:12:14.700 --> 01:12:16.380
the city needs or is?

01:12:16.380 --> 01:12:19.860
No, that's separate, the 30 would be on top of it.

01:12:19.860 --> 01:12:22.700
It's 27, it's just the estimate of what it would cost

01:12:22.700 --> 01:12:23.540
to the city for those.

01:12:23.540 --> 01:12:25.420
And I'm used to having bids a lot closer

01:12:25.420 --> 01:12:28.620
than the two that were received.

01:12:28.620 --> 01:12:33.120
There was 74% spread between the two of those.

01:12:33.120 --> 01:12:34.680
That's why I brought Tim along.

01:12:34.680 --> 01:12:36.400
Oh, okay.

01:12:36.400 --> 01:12:40.560
But the city's bid was right dead center in the metals.

01:12:40.560 --> 01:12:44.100
I had seen the engineer's estimate was a little bit

01:12:44.100 --> 01:12:47.200
under 900 pounds.

01:12:47.200 --> 01:12:50.880
The engineer's estimate was about $1,000 under the low bid.

01:12:52.770 --> 01:12:55.010
I can't second guess contractors any better

01:12:55.010 --> 01:12:56.530
than you can anymore.

01:12:56.530 --> 01:13:00.630
I typically see, and I know you see some large spreads,

01:13:00.630 --> 01:13:02.730
especially in larger projects,

01:13:02.730 --> 01:13:06.470
which has brought one to you the other day with lateral 33.

01:13:06.470 --> 01:13:08.930
Most of the bids on that were from people

01:13:08.930 --> 01:13:10.470
who were further away.

01:13:12.050 --> 01:13:15.850
We did have one gentleman who didn't get his bid in

01:13:15.850 --> 01:13:19.570
on time that told us that, here's a, of course,

01:13:19.570 --> 01:13:22.410
but he said he was around 114,

01:13:22.410 --> 01:13:25.050
and he was from 90 miles away.

01:13:25.050 --> 01:13:27.690
So why the local beds were so far apart?

01:13:27.690 --> 01:13:28.730
I really can't type.

01:13:28.730 --> 01:13:31.650
I think I don't sense is really close

01:13:31.650 --> 01:13:33.010
where it should be adequate.

01:13:33.010 --> 01:13:36.010
And it could just be due to people's workload

01:13:36.010 --> 01:13:37.530
at this time of year.

01:13:37.530 --> 01:13:38.370
Yeah.

01:13:38.370 --> 01:13:41.530
I guess what we should look at is the estimate

01:13:41.530 --> 01:13:43.890
and the low bed were pretty tight.

01:13:43.890 --> 01:13:44.730
Yes.

01:13:44.730 --> 01:13:45.450
Yeah, thanks.

01:13:45.450 --> 01:13:47.290
Appreciate it too.

01:13:47.290 --> 01:13:48.930
Great timing.

01:13:48.930 --> 01:13:50.970
Dennis, I'm going to use this as an opportunity

01:13:50.970 --> 01:13:54.290
since we have our trail where the people are walking down

01:13:54.290 --> 01:13:58.730
in the candy spring grade and we have about to have a lot of concrete trucks and things

01:13:58.730 --> 01:13:59.730
going down there.

01:13:59.730 --> 01:14:04.810
This is a much safer trail for them to utilize and get the same amount of exercise.

01:14:04.810 --> 01:14:09.330
They just have to drive a couple of miles of park it should show them falls, even up above

01:14:09.330 --> 01:14:10.330
show them falls.

01:14:10.330 --> 01:14:15.290
And I have walked that grade many, many times and this is an excellent trail and it's an

01:14:15.290 --> 01:14:18.830
excellent workout just like the other one is it's actually even a little steeper in

01:14:18.830 --> 01:14:21.650
a couple spots but then a little flatter and other stuff.

01:14:21.650 --> 01:14:22.490
Oh, I disagree.

01:14:22.490 --> 01:14:23.690
Nothing is steeped.

01:14:23.690 --> 01:14:28.490
I'm giving a plug in that people utilize this craft.

01:14:28.490 --> 01:14:29.890
They would like to be a little safer

01:14:29.890 --> 01:14:33.970
during this construction season of our wastewater treatment

01:14:33.970 --> 01:14:36.530
plant that this one is a park and show to them

01:14:36.530 --> 01:14:40.690
falls and walk up is also an excellent exercise.

01:14:40.690 --> 01:14:42.810
And I will guarantee you, there are a couple spots

01:14:42.810 --> 01:14:44.450
on this one are steeper than the other.

01:14:44.450 --> 01:14:47.800
And then the can't screen crate, so.

01:14:47.800 --> 01:14:49.520
All I can say is good luck moving those folks.

01:14:49.520 --> 01:14:51.320
Yeah, I love it.

01:14:51.320 --> 01:14:56.980
And if you would like to say for alternative, this is a safer alternative, even it is still an actual workout.

01:14:56.980 --> 01:14:59.480
I'm not arguing with him, just saying good luck with that.

01:14:59.480 --> 01:15:00.920
Rebecca Milsuk it.

01:15:00.920 --> 01:15:02.440
Thank you, Mayor.

01:15:02.440 --> 01:15:07.720
I have a question about what happens to the rest of that $200,000.

01:15:07.720 --> 01:15:11.120
Great news on the community partners and thank you to all of the community partners.

01:15:11.120 --> 01:15:12.440
We certainly appreciate that.

01:15:13.720 --> 01:15:19.680
Will those reserves be sent back into general park reserves or will it be held specifically for

01:15:19.680 --> 01:15:23.200
in your M-Trail improvements.

01:15:23.200 --> 01:15:28.080
All of the funds that are not associated with grants or donations.

01:15:28.080 --> 01:15:35.080
So funds that do not have restrictions will revert back into the capital fund, cash reserves

01:15:35.080 --> 01:15:37.920
at the conclusion of this fiscal year.

01:15:37.920 --> 01:15:45.200
If Dennis has not encumbered funds or has not had basically contracts in place that allow

01:15:45.200 --> 01:15:47.640
us to spend those funds.

01:15:47.640 --> 01:15:54.720
City code says any unspent funds or any funds that are not committed on September 30th.

01:15:54.720 --> 01:15:58.680
We'll revert back into the City's cash reserve amounts.

01:15:58.680 --> 01:16:03.440
We have the ability as projects come up to approach the council and use cash reserves

01:16:03.440 --> 01:16:05.480
to spend on worthy projects.

01:16:05.480 --> 01:16:10.760
We've done that in the past and should a worthy project come up whether it be associated

01:16:10.760 --> 01:16:14.920
with these trails or other types of projects we will certainly make those presentations

01:16:14.920 --> 01:16:15.920
to the council.

01:16:15.920 --> 01:16:16.920
Thank you.

01:16:16.920 --> 01:16:17.920
Yeah.

01:16:17.920 --> 01:16:22.440
The Magic Valley Trail Enhancement Committee came and I know we made that appropriation in

01:16:22.440 --> 01:16:27.960
response to their request and so if we could in the future just remember that amount and

01:16:27.960 --> 01:16:34.280
maybe keep that in mind for the trail so that that money still gets dedicated to the trails

01:16:34.280 --> 01:16:35.280
if needed.

01:16:35.280 --> 01:16:42.160
And also depending on the scope of the work or the rebuild of the trail by Ken Kress we might

01:16:42.160 --> 01:16:45.320
to be able to do a change order on our existing contract,

01:16:45.320 --> 01:16:47.120
if you work the contract, I don't stand in gravel

01:16:47.120 --> 01:16:50.600
where the money balance that that could be used to pay

01:16:50.600 --> 01:16:52.520
for the repairs of that trail section.

01:16:52.520 --> 01:16:53.420
That's a great idea.

01:16:53.420 --> 01:16:55.940
Thank you, Dennis.

01:16:55.940 --> 01:16:59.910
Sean Verner, I think we're ready for motion.

01:16:59.910 --> 01:17:03.590
So I would move to award the bid to construct the pillar falls

01:17:03.590 --> 01:17:06.110
and the caneval sections of the Snake River Canyon Rim Trail

01:17:06.110 --> 01:17:12.550
to hide out the sand and gravel in the amount of $88,973.

01:17:12.550 --> 01:17:13.710
Second.

01:17:13.710 --> 01:17:17.070
Motion on the floor by Sean Berger, seconded by Rebecca

01:17:17.070 --> 01:17:21.090
Mills-Soyka to approve as presented.

01:17:21.090 --> 01:17:24.370
Anything further on that motion council?

01:17:24.370 --> 01:17:26.230
The ailer will call vote please.

01:17:26.230 --> 01:17:27.230
Suzanne Hawkins.

01:17:27.230 --> 01:17:28.070
Yes.

01:17:28.070 --> 01:17:28.890
Jim Munn.

01:17:28.890 --> 01:17:29.890
Yes.

01:17:29.890 --> 01:17:30.890
Sean Berger.

01:17:30.890 --> 01:17:31.890
Yes.

01:17:31.890 --> 01:17:32.890
Chris Tarkington.

01:17:32.890 --> 01:17:33.890
Greg Lansing.

01:17:33.890 --> 01:17:34.890
Yes.

01:17:34.890 --> 01:17:35.890
Don Hall.

01:17:35.890 --> 01:17:36.890
Yes.

01:17:36.890 --> 01:17:37.890
Rebecca Mills-Soyka.

01:17:37.890 --> 01:17:38.890
Yes.

01:17:38.890 --> 01:17:39.890
Motion passes seven to zero.

01:17:39.890 --> 01:17:40.890
Congratulations on your other puzzle piece.

01:17:40.890 --> 01:17:41.890
Very good.

01:17:41.890 --> 01:17:57.380
We have three public hearings that are slated to not start before six o'clock and as I say quite often we've been very successful not doing it before six o'clock.

01:17:57.380 --> 01:18:06.380
We still have a couple or three more items on the items for consideration and a potential quick break for the council and then we'll jump on those.

01:18:06.380 --> 01:18:12.020
If you are interested in providing any kind of testimony or comment to the council,

01:18:12.020 --> 01:18:15.420
make sure that you go in the back of the room and sign up so that we can bring you up here.

01:18:15.420 --> 01:18:19.080
And what item that you're interested out of the three, or all three if you'd like.

01:18:19.080 --> 01:18:20.520
So, make sure you sign up.

01:18:20.520 --> 01:18:25.720
Next item on the agenda is discussion on the current city sanitation process.

01:18:25.720 --> 01:18:27.520
Lori Race, welcome, Lori.

01:18:27.520 --> 01:18:29.800
Thank you.

01:18:29.800 --> 01:18:32.520
Good evening, Mayor and City Council.

01:18:32.520 --> 01:18:39.320
So, during the budget process, we were asked to investigate the pros and cons of moving away

01:18:39.320 --> 01:18:44.550
from an unlimited trash pickup for one price fee.

01:18:44.550 --> 01:18:49.950
Would there be cost reductions for the city and ultimately the folks generating less garbage?

01:18:49.950 --> 01:18:56.310
So, we contacted PSI to just brainstorm some options.

01:18:56.310 --> 01:19:01.390
And I really thought that we'd sit down with Kevin and Les from PSI that give us several

01:19:01.390 --> 01:19:06.310
options, we'd put some dollars in cost to those, and that's what we would be presenting

01:19:06.310 --> 01:19:15.240
to you tonight. We did sit down with them, and Kevin Malone from PSI started out the meeting

01:19:15.240 --> 01:19:21.040
discussing a route audit or survey that they had done in June. And I'd like Kevin to talk

01:19:21.040 --> 01:19:23.200
about that a little bit more.

01:19:23.200 --> 01:19:29.010
Welcome, Kevin. What was your last name again, sir?

01:19:29.010 --> 01:19:30.010
Malone.

01:19:30.010 --> 01:19:31.010
Malone?

01:19:31.010 --> 01:19:32.010
Yes.

01:19:32.010 --> 01:19:33.010
Welcome, sir.

01:19:33.010 --> 01:19:35.570
Mr. Mayor, members of the council.

01:19:35.570 --> 01:19:39.440
So we looked at three days,

01:19:39.440 --> 01:19:42.580
and we looked at three of the hardest routes we had,

01:19:42.580 --> 01:19:44.440
because we had a free demo truck

01:19:44.440 --> 01:19:47.720
that a company wants to sell at our company.

01:19:47.720 --> 01:19:49.760
So we said, let's put it in the hardest places,

01:19:49.760 --> 01:19:52.920
and so we had a truck going around

01:19:52.920 --> 01:19:55.360
and a guy behind it, right now, what he was doing.

01:19:55.360 --> 01:19:59.080
And so he recorded the number of times you get out for extras.

01:19:59.080 --> 01:20:01.880
So that, we did that in June.

01:20:01.880 --> 01:20:10.850
And you'd see the worst example is 34 times and a 674 ohms.

01:20:10.850 --> 01:20:15.950
So it was a shocker to me because I've done the routes.

01:20:15.950 --> 01:20:19.090
But I wouldn't say necessarily a shocker

01:20:19.090 --> 01:20:22.730
because I've done the almost all of them.

01:20:22.730 --> 01:20:26.290
It sure feels a lot more when you're doing it.

01:20:26.290 --> 01:20:27.690
We've got to lift every bag, right?

01:20:27.690 --> 01:20:30.370
But the truth is when you stand back

01:20:30.370 --> 01:20:32.330
and you look at the street on collection day,

01:20:32.330 --> 01:20:35.450
You'll be down the street and three blocks won't have anything and one guy will have maybe

01:20:35.450 --> 01:20:36.890
ten bags.

01:20:36.890 --> 01:20:42.650
And that's the guy that you focus on and this objective way of looking at it, we did it again

01:20:42.650 --> 01:20:47.800
last week and you can see that it's consistent.

01:20:47.800 --> 01:20:49.800
It's just not as bad as it sounds.

01:20:49.800 --> 01:20:52.360
Why don't you walk us with those figures?

01:20:52.360 --> 01:20:58.120
So the out of truck numbers 34, 14, 6, there is the number of times the guy had to get out

01:20:58.120 --> 01:21:00.720
of the truck to pick stuff.

01:21:00.720 --> 01:21:11.240
And then the homes or stops is the 674, 602, 337, and then that represents 5%, 2.3%, 1.8%.

01:21:11.240 --> 01:21:17.290
And then last week we were looking at it less volunteer to drive around looking.

01:21:17.290 --> 01:21:24.330
And so he also added the number of extra carts that we provide extra cart service for $2.06 a month.

01:21:24.330 --> 01:21:28.250
And so those folks, actually that's the number of extra carts.

01:21:28.250 --> 01:21:35.200
So we don't have to get out for those, because so.

01:21:35.200 --> 01:21:36.760
Travis, did you want to weigh in?

01:21:36.760 --> 01:21:39.680
So what's important is I think that we need to take a minute

01:21:39.680 --> 01:21:42.480
to define out of truck and what that looks like.

01:21:42.480 --> 01:21:45.640
And that is every single time they

01:21:45.640 --> 01:21:50.520
have to get out whether it is a bag that is placed on

01:21:50.520 --> 01:21:54.480
to the curb, or whether it is their own garbage can

01:21:54.480 --> 01:21:57.800
that they choose to use that does not fit within our automated

01:21:57.800 --> 01:21:58.840
system.

01:21:58.840 --> 01:22:06.360
So that means that on June 10th, there were 34 incidents in which they placed a bag outside

01:22:06.360 --> 01:22:15.320
of the blue bin or another receptacle in addition to the blue bin, but it wasn't any

01:22:15.320 --> 01:22:17.800
more than that.

01:22:17.800 --> 01:22:21.680
So one of the things that when we started to look at this, and I think that Laurie started

01:22:21.680 --> 01:22:29.520
to say it in the beginning is we came in with a whole series of assumptions and part of those

01:22:29.520 --> 01:22:35.280
assumptions that we were making was there were a lot more people taking advantage of the

01:22:35.280 --> 01:22:44.240
unlimited garbage system that was out there and when you start looking at that it and

01:22:44.240 --> 01:22:48.680
And your assumptions then quickly get taken away.

01:22:48.680 --> 01:22:54.360
You really get left with a fewer choices and I think that this is where Lori is going to

01:22:54.360 --> 01:23:00.920
be able to talk about based upon these new information and these blown assumptions, what

01:23:00.920 --> 01:23:01.920
that may look like.

01:23:01.920 --> 01:23:06.840
If you don't mind, Kevin, could you stay close in case there's questions?

01:23:06.840 --> 01:23:07.840
You guys have a seat.

01:23:07.840 --> 01:23:10.220
Welcome, Lori.

01:23:10.220 --> 01:23:15.220
So we talked to them, one of the things that Kevin and his team talked about was going to

01:23:15.220 --> 01:23:17.900
this 65-gallon cart.

01:23:17.900 --> 01:23:23.860
And basically, by reducing from the 96-gallon cart to the 65-gallon cart, there were really

01:23:23.860 --> 01:23:30.020
no changes in their route costs, that being labor and fuel costs.

01:23:30.020 --> 01:23:34.860
So PSI's contract would remain basically the same to the city.

01:23:34.860 --> 01:23:39.660
With the exception of the purchase of new 65-gallon carts, and they would amortize those

01:23:39.660 --> 01:23:48.580
over 10 years. So we end up basically reallocating the fee. The folks using a 65 gallon cart would

01:23:48.580 --> 01:23:57.560
pay less than. And so when I was going through and looking, I took the $10.14 that we pay

01:23:57.560 --> 01:24:06.220
PSI and the $3.75 that we charge our customers for landfill. And I added those together because

01:24:06.220 --> 01:24:10.700
The street sweeping remains the same and our admin costs remain the same.

01:24:10.700 --> 01:24:18.780
So you add that $10.14, we paid a PSI in $375 for the landfill and for these options I'm

01:24:18.780 --> 01:24:21.900
coming up with $13.89.

01:24:21.900 --> 01:24:25.020
So basically we just end up reallocating that.

01:24:25.020 --> 01:24:31.020
The folks using the $65 gallon cart would pay less than the current charge of $13.89.

01:24:31.020 --> 01:24:35.820
And folks using the $96 gallon cart would be making up the difference in paying more than

01:24:35.820 --> 01:24:41.940
the current charge. So basically I just went through some different options just to share

01:24:41.940 --> 01:24:50.820
with you. So right now we have 14,039 customers and they pay 1389, the total amount that we

01:24:50.820 --> 01:25:03.100
pay PSI, well PSI and solid waste is 195,000 to bex a month. So if half of our customers

01:25:03.100 --> 01:25:06.460
got the 65-gallon cart, and half of our customers

01:25:06.460 --> 01:25:09.620
remained with the 96-gallon cart.

01:25:09.620 --> 01:25:11.820
Based on the assumption that they're

01:25:11.820 --> 01:25:16.430
going to fill those carts with garbage,

01:25:16.430 --> 01:25:22.390
the 96-gallon group represents about 60% of the total cost,

01:25:22.390 --> 01:25:25.310
and the others represent about 40%.

01:25:25.310 --> 01:25:28.030
And so I just messed around with the fees a little bit,

01:25:28.030 --> 01:25:31.470
just to give you an idea of what that would mean.

01:25:31.470 --> 01:25:39.150
And then if we had just a small group of folks go with a 65-gallon card, that second example

01:25:39.150 --> 01:25:48.310
is 90% with those big cards, they're going to be generating 90% of our trash, and the smaller

01:25:48.310 --> 01:25:52.850
group would be representing 10% of the cost.

01:25:52.850 --> 01:26:00.930
Likewise that last example, the bigger group is 20% of trash generation, and the 65-gallon

01:26:00.930 --> 01:26:07.730
example is 80%. So what happens if everybody wants to save some money and go to the 65 gallon

01:26:07.730 --> 01:26:14.370
cart, then they're going to be paying the same thing they are now, but not have unlimited service.

01:26:16.370 --> 01:26:22.450
Travis, with one exception that all of those fees you have to increase the cost because we now have

01:26:22.450 --> 01:26:30.130
to cover the cost of the new cart over a period of time and the long obviously the longer you spread

01:26:30.130 --> 01:26:37.810
that out, the lower monthly cost that is, but to spread that out longer than, say, four

01:26:37.810 --> 01:26:42.650
more years, which I think is the length of our current agreement, that would require an

01:26:42.650 --> 01:26:48.490
extension to the existing contract that we have with PSI.

01:26:48.490 --> 01:26:53.810
So we have four more years left on our contract, I believe, and if you were to amortize that

01:26:53.810 --> 01:26:58.930
just over the remaining balance of that time, then that's what it would be available if you

01:26:58.930 --> 01:27:04.830
You talked about something like 10 years, which is I believe where you find about a break-even

01:27:04.830 --> 01:27:12.980
point in speaking with Kevin that would require a six-year extension to the existing contract.

01:27:12.980 --> 01:27:18.420
So another concern that was pointed out during our discussion was that if folks that want

01:27:18.420 --> 01:27:24.580
that 65-gallon cart to save money, regardless of the amount of trash they generate, then

01:27:24.580 --> 01:27:29.940
the potential for a legal dumping in empty lots when their cart becomes full is a real

01:27:29.940 --> 01:27:34.980
possibility and that would be an increased demand on our code enforcement

01:27:34.980 --> 01:27:40.140
department. So if that occurs our overall cost could actually increase to cover the

01:27:40.140 --> 01:27:45.700
additional expenditures of Sean Stanley and his team. So it really turned out to

01:27:45.700 --> 01:27:49.940
be quite different than what I thought it would be. That that information is

01:27:49.940 --> 01:27:54.220
very different than what I thought we'd be telling you tonight and Travis, Kevin,

01:27:54.220 --> 01:27:58.020
Jared, Les and I are here and happy to answer any questions you might have.

01:27:58.020 --> 01:28:04.240
Any questions Council Chris talking to I'm really impressed with what you all have done so far

01:28:05.220 --> 01:28:10.820
The people I've had contact with that are interested in small ink smaller containers at smaller

01:28:11.340 --> 01:28:14.080
Cost of course or single people seniors

01:28:16.300 --> 01:28:20.780
Does not take into account some people during this summer are going to dramatically include

01:28:21.460 --> 01:28:23.460
increase their yard waste

01:28:23.460 --> 01:28:30.660
deposits, but I would suspect that middle arrangement you're looking at with the 12,000

01:28:30.660 --> 01:28:38.540
and the 2,000 numbers there. If you were to increase that to say 4,000 on the 65 gallon

01:28:38.540 --> 01:28:45.660
and 10,000 on the other, you might have a closer representation of the people that I'm guessing.

01:28:45.660 --> 01:28:52.220
I'm saying only guessing might potentially, over several years time, partially because

01:28:52.220 --> 01:28:58.020
recycling and partially because they're just loving them along to don't have that much.

01:28:58.020 --> 01:29:03.220
I think that that in my mind would be something that we could try over a couple of years.

01:29:03.220 --> 01:29:08.500
It doesn't have to be an absolute formula since we're going to be finding out the answer

01:29:08.500 --> 01:29:09.500
through time.

01:29:09.500 --> 01:29:16.900
But I'm really impressed with what you found that you could, even if over the 12,000 and

01:29:16.900 --> 01:29:25.540
the 2000 spread, you could still save a person with that smaller container, $500 a year.

01:29:25.540 --> 01:29:27.730
So good work.

01:29:27.730 --> 01:29:28.730
Great.

01:29:28.730 --> 01:29:29.730
Excuse me.

01:29:29.730 --> 01:29:30.730
Shambair.

01:29:30.730 --> 01:29:31.730
So refreshment.

01:29:31.730 --> 01:29:32.730
Excuse me.

01:29:32.730 --> 01:29:36.090
Let's take a decimal off that $50 a year.

01:29:36.090 --> 01:29:42.730
Don't we have some folks who are grandfathered in on something from the last go around with

01:29:42.730 --> 01:29:43.730
smaller cans?

01:29:43.730 --> 01:29:44.730
And it's like 50.

01:29:44.730 --> 01:29:51.730
It's 73, maybe. It's in the resolution that their grandfather did into a one can rate.

01:29:51.730 --> 01:29:56.730
And so that was based upon, hey, I don't create much trash. I come post or I do all the stuff at home.

01:29:56.730 --> 01:29:59.730
And they were grandfather did. So that's that small piece.

01:29:59.730 --> 01:30:10.150
So I would argue a bit against Councilman Tockington, that in an effort to save 4,000 customers a couple bucks a month,

01:30:10.150 --> 01:30:18.370
month, we just raised 12,000 customers or 10,000 customers two bucks a month to

01:30:18.370 --> 01:30:23.030
provide the same service. So I'll give an example. I have the 95 gallon cart at my

01:30:23.030 --> 01:30:29.390
house now. I do the recycling. I rarely fill my 96 gallon cart. But in the

01:30:29.390 --> 01:30:34.030
summer, I don't have to leave two bags a long waste sitting next to the can for

01:30:34.030 --> 01:30:39.270
you to pick up because it now fits in the can. So if I'm going to be able to save

01:30:39.270 --> 01:30:46.010
two or three bucks a month, I might call you and say give me a 65 gallon card and now I'm

01:30:46.010 --> 01:30:52.770
going to have three bags of yard waste sitting next to my can and your 35 out of truck stops

01:30:52.770 --> 01:30:58.090
are now 105 out of truck stops and I would guess that that's going to increase the cost

01:30:58.090 --> 01:30:59.770
of the service provided.

01:30:59.770 --> 01:31:03.770
I don't disagree that we should be looking at a way to reduce the cost.

01:31:03.770 --> 01:31:09.570
I don't think cost shifting it to 10,000 customers is the way to get to it.

01:31:09.570 --> 01:31:13.570
If there's really no way to save the cost of providing the service,

01:31:13.570 --> 01:31:17.570
there's really no way to save the cost of providing the service.

01:31:17.570 --> 01:31:19.570
Travis, did you want to weigh in on that?

01:31:19.570 --> 01:31:31.340
To prevent that scenario, we believe that it would be important to make sure that you're looking at the system in its entirety.

01:31:31.340 --> 01:31:38.660
And so if you were to offer a smaller can, you're probably going to want to get rid of

01:31:38.660 --> 01:31:46.060
the unlimited pickup proportion to ensure that everything is fitting in those cans and that

01:31:46.060 --> 01:31:53.380
individuals are getting the appropriate number and the appropriate size of cans to support

01:31:53.380 --> 01:32:00.340
for the level of service that they're looking at because that scenario could also happen.

01:32:00.340 --> 01:32:05.540
Another thing that we learned and I think is important to pass on is additional recycling

01:32:05.540 --> 01:32:13.940
cans are also available through PSI for the same $2 per month, 206.

01:32:13.940 --> 01:32:20.020
And oftentimes we hear that there are individuals who are requesting additional recycling

01:32:20.020 --> 01:32:27.900
plant receptacles, those are also available for that additional can cost right now as

01:32:27.900 --> 01:32:29.890
well.

01:32:29.890 --> 01:32:31.490
Greek mining.

01:32:31.490 --> 01:32:35.690
That's probably a question for Kevin or less.

01:32:35.690 --> 01:32:43.000
And it goes to the concern that people will go to the 65,

01:32:43.000 --> 01:32:47.720
and then if it's not unlimited, like Sean was saying,

01:32:47.720 --> 01:32:50.560
that they would be probably taking, especially one way

01:32:50.560 --> 01:32:53.840
stop to the vacant lot, because that's just easier.

01:32:53.840 --> 01:32:56.000
With your private customers, and I know you have private

01:32:56.000 --> 01:33:01.100
customers as well as the city, is that what

01:33:01.100 --> 01:33:04.720
you suspect if they go if they're they're they're limited on what they can take or

01:33:04.720 --> 01:33:07.980
what what is your experience without I guess is what I'm asking. Well the private

01:33:07.980 --> 01:33:11.910
customers typically have more land so they can dump it somewhere they don't

01:33:11.910 --> 01:33:15.230
see it if it's grass clippings because typically the majority of the material

01:33:15.230 --> 01:33:20.270
is fast but things that's the excess and tree trimmings are such like that so

01:33:20.270 --> 01:33:23.510
they can dump that on their property somewhere or burn it or whatever they

01:33:23.510 --> 01:33:27.550
do in those rural areas but in those rural areas what we do is we charge five

01:33:27.550 --> 01:33:33.180
dollars a bag and so a lot of people who don't want it piled up are glad to pay

01:33:33.180 --> 01:33:36.960
it because it just worked very good time.

01:33:36.960 --> 01:33:46.800
Alright, thanks you have an accent a comment too. Go ahead. I at one point have no

01:33:46.800 --> 01:33:52.420
longer have it but I had a house in Arizona as well as a house here and by

01:33:52.420 --> 01:33:58.560
the way that $13.89 is such a bargain compared to what I paid down there.

01:33:58.560 --> 01:34:01.960
I think I was paying $36 a month down there, but it's twice a week

01:34:01.960 --> 01:34:09.340
But still $36 a month and the rules that that one as far as the unlimited goes the rules there is not only

01:34:09.340 --> 01:34:15.360
What did the you have to have it in your can the lid had to fit down on the can and that was probably a city ordinance

01:34:15.360 --> 01:34:19.360
So because they didn't want the smell and we'll hotter country and and things and so I

01:34:19.880 --> 01:34:22.600
You know I can see the unlimited. I am with Sean though

01:34:22.600 --> 01:34:25.640
I I really struggle with raising the rate for

01:34:25.640 --> 01:34:29.920
or 10,000 people to lower it for three and 4,000 people.

01:34:29.920 --> 01:34:32.840
That's a cost shift, that's not a cost savings.

01:34:32.840 --> 01:34:37.240
And so I will be struggling unless I see a different proposal

01:34:37.240 --> 01:34:40.960
that fits my thoughts better to be pointing to change.

01:34:42.080 --> 01:34:42.920
Chris talking.

01:34:42.920 --> 01:34:45.920
I can make an equal argument that the rate was set up wrong

01:34:45.920 --> 01:34:50.920
and you were charging the less volumetric users

01:34:51.720 --> 01:34:55.200
to begin with and they've been overcharged all this time.

01:34:55.200 --> 01:34:59.920
I would also make a stronger event that are recycling,

01:34:59.920 --> 01:35:02.360
as long as it's strongly supported by the city,

01:35:02.360 --> 01:35:05.040
advertised, has had a significant impact

01:35:05.040 --> 01:35:06.520
on reducing yard fill.

01:35:07.940 --> 01:35:09.700
And I would, or landfill.

01:35:09.700 --> 01:35:12.540
And the third point I would make is I'm just amazed

01:35:12.540 --> 01:35:17.540
that we would think that unlimited use is okay

01:35:18.900 --> 01:35:21.460
and if we are to cut down on that,

01:35:21.460 --> 01:35:25.060
that we are authorizing and legitimizing people

01:35:25.060 --> 01:35:28.300
to dump yard waste on their neighbors' property

01:35:28.300 --> 01:35:33.620
and legal trespassing to justify keeping the rates higher

01:35:33.620 --> 01:35:36.420
than they should be for the less frequent

01:35:36.420 --> 01:35:40.710
and the less volumetric users.

01:35:40.710 --> 01:35:41.910
Sean Berger.

01:35:41.910 --> 01:35:43.430
I guess I don't understand the argument

01:35:43.430 --> 01:35:45.230
that the rates are higher than they should be

01:35:45.230 --> 01:35:46.790
because the math works out too.

01:35:46.790 --> 01:35:48.710
It's what it costs us.

01:35:48.710 --> 01:35:51.670
It's what it costs us for the service from PSI.

01:35:51.670 --> 01:35:54.710
It's what it costs us for the dumping at the landfill.

01:35:54.710 --> 01:35:57.830
you take the total amount of garbage divided by the

01:35:57.830 --> 01:36:01.630
number of users that is an average cost as hard as

01:36:01.630 --> 01:36:05.470
so i think the only way to do that fairly is to go away everybody's trash can

01:36:05.470 --> 01:36:06.470
every day

01:36:06.470 --> 01:36:07.830
now that's that's ridiculous

01:36:07.830 --> 01:36:11.350
nobody's saying that i think i can argue folks well

01:36:11.350 --> 01:36:14.590
i'm not arguing but i am going to make a point here that i appreciate it will

01:36:14.590 --> 01:36:16.270
just make a point one of the time

01:36:16.270 --> 01:36:19.390
i don't believe that you can

01:36:19.390 --> 01:36:23.750
take someone on their word that they're only going to put trash in their can

01:36:23.750 --> 01:36:31.710
that's smaller than everybody else's can on a regular basis for a lower fee and not increase

01:36:31.710 --> 01:36:36.710
the workload of our trash collection service to figure out who's following the rules and

01:36:36.710 --> 01:36:43.480
who's not. So if I want to get a 25 gallon cart because I don't make any trash but then

01:36:43.480 --> 01:36:48.620
I go clean my yard up that day and leave four bags of trash out there or we're going to take

01:36:48.620 --> 01:36:52.900
away the service which we actually provide which is unlimited trash service which I think

01:36:52.900 --> 01:36:58.020
is a really good service that we provide because last people that keep their yard cleaned up

01:36:58.020 --> 01:37:06.780
and keep their place tidy, I just, I really feel like we're jumping over dollars to save

01:37:06.780 --> 01:37:12.180
pennies here and I don't see how we're going to get there in a fair fashion unless we see

01:37:12.180 --> 01:37:18.140
a significant reduction in BSI's contract or in the fees of the landfill, both things

01:37:18.140 --> 01:37:23.540
that we don't have a lot of control over, we're not going to get to a point where we can shave

01:37:23.540 --> 01:37:25.630
these dollars off.

01:37:25.630 --> 01:37:26.630
Chris Fockin.

01:37:26.630 --> 01:37:33.100
My only rebuttal is that people use the service law should pay less.

01:37:33.100 --> 01:37:34.420
Travis?

01:37:34.420 --> 01:37:40.300
Yeah, Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, we also have an update on the yard waste question

01:37:40.300 --> 01:37:44.780
that we've been working with PSI on and maybe it would be a good time for.

01:37:44.780 --> 01:37:46.740
I'd like to weigh in just real quick.

01:37:46.740 --> 01:37:53.960
I want to say that I applaud Chris for bringing the subject up because his intention was folks have contacted him that

01:37:54.480 --> 01:38:00.340
Don't put as much garbage out and they're looking and there's a lot of folks in our community fix incomes and

01:38:01.140 --> 01:38:07.220
And situations that he was trying to bring to our attention to see if there's some way that we could help

01:38:08.100 --> 01:38:12.740
Shave some costs off of these citizens, but after reviewing this meat personally

01:38:12.740 --> 01:38:17.180
I just doesn't make sense to do anything other than what we are doing,

01:38:17.180 --> 01:38:24.020
especially in light of, I mean, pretty cheap and efficient service that we have

01:38:24.020 --> 01:38:27.000
overall within the city of Twin Falls.

01:38:27.000 --> 01:38:31.580
But again, I applaud at least the effort of trying to shape some of those fees

01:38:31.580 --> 01:38:34.100
off for our fixed income folks.

01:38:34.100 --> 01:38:36.100
Suzanne Hopkins.

01:38:36.100 --> 01:38:39.740
I'm sure you guys have thought of all the options, but what if instead of going

01:38:39.740 --> 01:38:43.740
to a smaller can because of the cost of the cans and everything.

01:38:43.740 --> 01:38:49.420
What if we offered weekly service for those who want it and maybe monthly for those who don't use as much?

01:38:49.420 --> 01:38:53.540
I know it'll get stinky, but if they have a big can and they're not filling it up,

01:38:53.540 --> 01:38:57.220
is that a way to save money or are we still running the same route so we still have the same cost?

01:38:57.220 --> 01:39:00.460
I would assume the same route, same cost, fixed cost.

01:39:00.460 --> 01:39:01.860
You just drive fast.

01:39:01.860 --> 01:39:02.860
Yeah.

01:39:02.860 --> 01:39:06.750
Kevin, could you come forward so?

01:39:06.750 --> 01:39:08.750
Just for the mic and it's also no different.

01:39:08.750 --> 01:39:14.410
Like on those days that we're all trying to rush out of the house and we forget to place our garbage to the curb.

01:39:15.610 --> 01:39:19.890
The truck still goes by my house as though it were still placed there.

01:39:19.890 --> 01:39:25.210
So from a cost saving perspective, it's not any-

01:39:25.210 --> 01:39:25.970
Signition.

01:39:25.970 --> 01:39:26.970
No.

01:39:26.970 --> 01:39:28.890
Kevin, did you want to weigh in on that sort of?

01:39:28.890 --> 01:39:29.570
Okay, very good.

01:39:30.610 --> 01:39:31.730
All right, I see no further lights.

01:39:31.730 --> 01:39:33.850
Do you want to weigh in on the other issue?

01:39:33.850 --> 01:39:38.010
So another thing that we've been working on and as part of our strategic plan was trying

01:39:38.010 --> 01:39:41.730
to find a solution to the yard waste that we have right now.

01:39:41.730 --> 01:39:48.990
We recognize that yard waste flows constitute an increase to 30 to 40 percent of our total

01:39:48.990 --> 01:39:55.100
tonnage that we deposit during the summer months or those months in which we have that.

01:39:55.100 --> 01:39:58.820
So Kevin I think has some information that you'd like to share with the council and the

01:39:58.820 --> 01:40:04.520
steps that we've taken to start finding a alternative solution to yard waste.

01:40:04.520 --> 01:40:10.820
I think that it's certainly very much in its infancy, but I think it demonstrates where

01:40:10.820 --> 01:40:12.580
kind of the direction that we're going.

01:40:12.580 --> 01:40:14.060
Chairman?

01:40:14.060 --> 01:40:18.860
So staff, we're meeting with staff and we discuss the problem of yard waste.

01:40:18.860 --> 01:40:21.660
And it does spike up, as everybody knows that we talked about.

01:40:21.660 --> 01:40:25.060
It's really the driver of a lot of the bulky situation that we're dealing with with getting

01:40:25.060 --> 01:40:27.740
out in these summer months.

01:40:27.740 --> 01:40:30.580
And it's also just like your disposal bill.

01:40:30.580 --> 01:40:40.360
So I've been in this business for 16 years, and so I've seen it in a lot of places, you

01:40:40.360 --> 01:40:43.660
know, from California to Oregon to Washington.

01:40:43.660 --> 01:40:50.080
And so I'm, California's not going to do anything, but if you want to spend a lot of money and

01:40:50.080 --> 01:40:53.840
do a lot of things that make people feel good, they do that.

01:40:53.840 --> 01:40:55.920
But I've learned a lot from watching that.

01:40:55.920 --> 01:41:02.720
So we have a lot of resources within our parent company that do that in those places.

01:41:02.720 --> 01:41:08.800
So I was able to, you know, with that experience, and then we've been working with Josh Bartle,

01:41:08.800 --> 01:41:13.400
maybe who's the director of the Southern Idaho Solid Waste, which handles the landfill and

01:41:13.400 --> 01:41:14.600
transfer station.

01:41:14.600 --> 01:41:20.200
So, yard waste is an easy target because it's so heavy.

01:41:20.200 --> 01:41:24.440
So if you can get that out of your waste room and do something with it, that's usually a good thing.

01:41:24.440 --> 01:41:27.120
So, however, again, from my experience

01:41:27.120 --> 01:41:30.120
and from what Josh is telling me, the good news, bad news

01:41:30.120 --> 01:41:35.640
is that whatever they do with it will cost as least as much

01:41:35.640 --> 01:41:38.280
as it does to throw it away, which, again,

01:41:38.280 --> 01:41:41.240
is our experience, because we have facilities in our company

01:41:41.240 --> 01:41:42.520
that do this in other states.

01:41:42.520 --> 01:41:44.880
And that's because you're handling stuff.

01:41:44.880 --> 01:41:47.040
Whenever you handle anything, it's

01:41:47.040 --> 01:41:48.840
going to add costs, because you've got to pay somebody

01:41:48.840 --> 01:41:50.680
to do something, you've got to buy equipment to do it,

01:41:50.680 --> 01:41:52.520
you have to have a place to do it in.

01:41:52.520 --> 01:41:59.680
And so now around in this area, the most efficient place to do that would be the landfill, because

01:41:59.680 --> 01:42:04.320
they've got the land, they've got equipment, they're all rehandling some bulk material,

01:42:04.320 --> 01:42:06.920
like tree tranines and such.

01:42:06.920 --> 01:42:14.600
So the place that could most do that efficiently would be Josh and his organization.

01:42:14.600 --> 01:42:20.840
So in talking with those folks, so he said he definitely would not, that was the one thing,

01:42:20.840 --> 01:42:24.580
It definitely wouldn't cost any less than throwing it away for handling.

01:42:24.580 --> 01:42:28.020
So there would, you'd save disposal on one end, but then you'd pay a green waste processing

01:42:28.020 --> 01:42:31.520
fee that's roughly or more of this one.

01:42:31.520 --> 01:42:34.480
He's looking at doing something incredibly unique here.

01:42:34.480 --> 01:42:37.440
In this state, it doesn't exist in Idaho.

01:42:37.440 --> 01:42:45.960
It's taken basically sewage for it, that they're treating already, and they could take the green

01:42:45.960 --> 01:42:50.800
waste as part of that process to make something that could be spread on fields.

01:42:50.800 --> 01:42:52.940
So, and I think it can only be, from what I understand,

01:42:52.940 --> 01:42:56.080
it can only be spread on the seed crop, unless you do,

01:42:57.040 --> 01:42:58.880
it's a lot of smart people,

01:42:58.880 --> 01:43:00.400
then smarter than me do it.

01:43:00.400 --> 01:43:03.200
I'm just the trash man that gives them the stuff.

01:43:03.200 --> 01:43:05.080
So, but it's really cool,

01:43:05.080 --> 01:43:07.000
and lots of big cool equipment,

01:43:07.000 --> 01:43:08.560
I understand that part.

01:43:08.560 --> 01:43:12.560
But the process they're developing has to be permitted,

01:43:12.560 --> 01:43:14.960
and it could take about a year and a half to do that.

01:43:14.960 --> 01:43:18.240
So, considerations in that process are,

01:43:18.240 --> 01:43:21.480
If we can transloted at the transfer station,

01:43:21.480 --> 01:43:23.880
so basically we drop here at Twin

01:43:23.880 --> 01:43:26.160
instead of having to go all the way to the landfill.

01:43:26.160 --> 01:43:29.500
Well, if we did that, we could offer,

01:43:29.500 --> 01:43:32.960
you know, a greenway service separate, a separate cart.

01:43:32.960 --> 01:43:37.320
Now again, the carts cost money, you know, so it's money.

01:43:37.320 --> 01:43:41.200
And we'd have to add at least one truck.

01:43:41.200 --> 01:43:42.360
If we could transloted here,

01:43:42.360 --> 01:43:45.640
we'd probably be able to add one truck, just one truck.

01:43:45.640 --> 01:43:49.160
But the truck we bought last year was $320,000

01:43:49.160 --> 01:43:51.120
the truck's really expensive.

01:43:51.120 --> 01:43:55.960
So it's not a cheap solution.

01:43:55.960 --> 01:43:58.640
But if that's the direction that you want to go,

01:43:58.640 --> 01:44:01.880
we can certainly, just because it costs money

01:44:01.880 --> 01:44:04.400
doesn't mean it doesn't have value.

01:44:04.400 --> 01:44:07.160
If that's what you want to do, we know how to do it.

01:44:07.160 --> 01:44:09.120
And there's a lot of stuff in place

01:44:09.120 --> 01:44:11.320
that we're looking at to try to see the most efficient way

01:44:11.320 --> 01:44:12.600
we can do it.

01:44:12.600 --> 01:44:15.080
But right now, that's what we know.

01:44:15.080 --> 01:44:18.880
And we're still looking into it as we get closer to watching it.

01:44:18.880 --> 01:44:21.920
But really just want to keep getting formed with, you know,

01:44:21.920 --> 01:44:24.320
some people think that, well, it's got to have value at the end

01:44:24.320 --> 01:44:25.680
because you can sell this thing at the end.

01:44:25.680 --> 01:44:29.880
Well, you've got to handle it for, you know, all these people.

01:44:29.880 --> 01:44:31.320
And they all want to get paid.

01:44:31.320 --> 01:44:33.440
So it's not cheap.

01:44:33.440 --> 01:44:36.120
So when we're talking about just so I clarify for everyone,

01:44:36.120 --> 01:44:37.120
we'll talk about yard waste.

01:44:37.120 --> 01:44:40.520
We're mainly talking about grass clippings, those kind of things.

01:44:40.520 --> 01:44:42.800
Grass clippings, tree trimmings, leaves.

01:44:42.800 --> 01:44:43.880
OK.

01:44:43.880 --> 01:44:54.880
I'll just throw it, not food waste, the only thing I would just add and I've said this before, I've been launching my lawn for years and it works really well, there's really a reduction.

01:44:54.880 --> 01:45:03.880
The only thing that I can't change is when a wind comes through town and blows my trees down and then I still have to put that in the pile out there.

01:45:03.880 --> 01:45:04.880
Greg Lanning.

01:45:04.880 --> 01:45:12.880
Kevin, do you know what the commercial, because there seems to be more and more and more commercial lawn operators,

01:45:12.880 --> 01:45:16.560
You know people are mowing the lawn and they seem to take it with them for the most part

01:45:16.880 --> 01:45:20.960
Where are they going? I know at one point some of them were going out to a local feedlot

01:45:20.960 --> 01:45:25.240
And I can't imagine that being a good idea because I know the things that I've seen put on lawns

01:45:25.240 --> 01:45:27.120
And it's like a little scary to go to a feedlot

01:45:27.120 --> 01:45:31.240
But are that's where they're going or are they going to the landfill or how are they handling it a lot?

01:45:31.240 --> 01:45:35.240
I see a lot of the myth the landfill and the transfer station and on there, okay

01:45:37.000 --> 01:45:42.000
So they're just making it a portion of their cost to do that direction rather than

01:45:42.000 --> 01:45:45.160
And you would be able to control obviously

01:45:45.160 --> 01:45:47.180
that nobody's doing it,

01:45:47.180 --> 01:45:50.040
and bags out and does it that way, so.

01:45:50.040 --> 01:45:52.880
And the grass clippings are going in the trash right now.

01:45:52.880 --> 01:45:55.780
They're taking both up tree trimmings,

01:45:55.780 --> 01:45:58.320
and the transportation can take that and separate it,

01:45:58.320 --> 01:46:00.520
because they grind that and use it on their roads.

01:46:00.520 --> 01:46:03.680
But the grass clippings are a whole separate.

01:46:03.680 --> 01:46:05.240
Okay, and most of the commercial ones

01:46:05.240 --> 01:46:07.460
aren't going to the transportation.

01:46:07.460 --> 01:46:09.220
All right, thank you.

01:46:09.220 --> 01:46:10.380
We're back in the second.

01:46:10.380 --> 01:46:11.660
Thank you, Mayor.

01:46:11.660 --> 01:46:15.900
Well, I appreciate all this information, Mr. Malone, it's been very helpful.

01:46:15.900 --> 01:46:21.020
As far as the green waste goes, I'd have to maybe see some more statistics on the benefits of it.

01:46:21.020 --> 01:46:26.660
If it's going to be a costly system, I think we need to weigh whether we want those benefits for

01:46:26.660 --> 01:46:31.780
that cost and whether the citizens want that benefit for the cost.

01:46:31.780 --> 01:46:39.940
And we do have to remember that no matter what, the landfill is a fixed cost system largely among eight counties.

01:46:39.940 --> 01:46:45.380
And we are one of the largest, if not the largest user in Twin Falls County.

01:46:45.380 --> 01:46:51.740
And so no matter what, if we do find savings, those fixed costs will still be

01:46:51.740 --> 01:46:55.420
reallocated back to us and we saw that happen.

01:46:55.420 --> 01:47:00.300
Where we thought we would see a reduction and we did see a reduction in general and

01:47:00.300 --> 01:47:02.340
fees with the recycling.

01:47:02.340 --> 01:47:04.940
And it is the right thing to do to recycle.

01:47:04.940 --> 01:47:12.620
But then the tipping fees went up because that's just how a fixed system works exactly.

01:47:12.620 --> 01:47:25.700
And we know that because we have our wastewater treatment plant, and when rates go up, they go up because it costs that same amount of money to run that system no matter how many users participate.

01:47:25.700 --> 01:47:28.940
So we do understand that, but I appreciate you going through these options and

01:47:28.940 --> 01:47:34.000
appreciate the staff and in looking at all of these options and would be eager to listen

01:47:34.000 --> 01:47:37.920
to citizens if that's something that they desire in the future.

01:47:37.920 --> 01:47:38.920
Chris talking it.

01:47:38.920 --> 01:47:44.840
Well, we must be looking at different figures, Rebecca, because my recollection, the significant

01:47:44.840 --> 01:47:51.560
decrease in the garbage to the landfill has not resulted in cheaper rates for Twin Falls

01:47:51.560 --> 01:47:52.560
County.

01:47:52.560 --> 01:48:00.480
They have not, there has been a fixed cost basis and it doesn't matter whether you put

01:48:00.480 --> 01:48:05.680
in half or twice as much of the waste to cost to the same as part of the disagreement.

01:48:05.680 --> 01:48:10.920
I had with south, south, south for a while, waste for some time and that has not been

01:48:10.920 --> 01:48:11.920
resolved.

01:48:11.920 --> 01:48:20.120
Nonetheless, Don's absolutely right, there is a solution to the seasonal up-tech and our

01:48:20.120 --> 01:48:28.310
waste with the yards I've been mulching for 11 years. Probably put an extra couple bags

01:48:28.310 --> 01:48:34.590
out a couple times a year. If more people would recycle, we wouldn't even be having this issue

01:48:34.590 --> 01:48:41.030
to discuss. I don't think too much. But I'm really firm believer and I'll still float a

01:48:41.030 --> 01:48:46.830
motion even though it's not going to get much of a back in the council that those people

01:48:46.830 --> 01:48:52.550
that use Garvey to us should pay less, because we have a skewed system right now.

01:48:52.550 --> 01:49:01.410
And I would so move that we approve on a one-year trial basis, the, I'll call it option

01:49:01.410 --> 01:49:12.680
two of yours of the 12,000 and the 2000 gallon or customers, Lori, the 12,000 customers and

01:49:12.680 --> 01:49:15.480
the 2000 at the respecting costs.

01:49:15.480 --> 01:49:17.240
Could we put that back up, Lori?

01:49:17.240 --> 01:49:27.330
Yeah, I think that'd be helpful.

01:49:27.330 --> 01:49:28.410
I'm out of doing what was it,

01:49:28.410 --> 01:49:31.230
about five bucks a month difference.

01:49:31.230 --> 01:49:33.760
Not 500 a year.

01:49:33.760 --> 01:49:35.960
60, so what do you see, what do you see, what do you see?

01:49:35.960 --> 01:49:38.220
Yeah, the option too, I'll call it,

01:49:39.560 --> 01:49:43.840
where the 65 gallon containers would be charged,

01:49:43.840 --> 01:49:47.040
$9.87 a month.

01:49:47.040 --> 01:49:51.680
And the 96 gallon cards would be $14.57 a month.

01:49:51.680 --> 01:49:53.540
That'd be the 90-10.

01:49:53.540 --> 01:49:54.840
So we have a motion on the floor?

01:49:54.840 --> 01:50:01.840
for the second option which is the 90% would have the 96 gallon cart and 10% would have

01:50:02.680 --> 01:50:07.020
the 65 gallon cart. Do we have a second on that motion? I'll second for discussion with

01:50:07.020 --> 01:50:08.020
you.

01:50:08.020 --> 01:50:14.020
And I'd also like to just add to the motion that that was 2039 potential customers that

01:50:14.020 --> 01:50:20.020
have to be on their first come for a serve application. Second okay with that adjustment.

01:50:20.020 --> 01:50:24.400
So motion on the floor, anything further?

01:50:24.400 --> 01:50:25.240
Greg Lining.

01:50:25.240 --> 01:50:27.900
Well, a couple of concerns I have with the motion,

01:50:27.900 --> 01:50:30.940
although I seconded it, well, I might just overall general,

01:50:30.940 --> 01:50:33.740
but just I'm not sure we can do that as easily

01:50:33.740 --> 01:50:35.820
as we might think here, because we've got to pay

01:50:35.820 --> 01:50:40.100
for the 2039-65 buy-out yelling things

01:50:40.100 --> 01:50:41.580
and I think we've got a calculator

01:50:41.580 --> 01:50:42.780
running right down here right now,

01:50:42.780 --> 01:50:44.340
trying to figure out, we would have,

01:50:44.340 --> 01:50:46.700
that fund has to come forward and let us know

01:50:46.700 --> 01:50:47.780
how much that would be.

01:50:47.780 --> 01:50:49.780
55 dollars each.

01:50:49.780 --> 01:50:50.780
That's our phrase.

01:50:50.780 --> 01:50:52.780
I don't know if I can say that publicly.

01:50:52.780 --> 01:50:53.780
No.

01:50:53.780 --> 01:50:54.780
Well, you have.

01:50:54.780 --> 01:50:55.780
I just get it.

01:50:55.780 --> 01:50:56.780
There we go.

01:50:56.780 --> 01:50:58.780
I'm using my iPhone.

01:50:58.780 --> 01:51:02.390
I'm not putting it this way.

01:51:02.390 --> 01:51:05.600
$2,000.

01:51:05.600 --> 01:51:06.920
$12,000.

01:51:06.920 --> 01:51:07.920
How much?

01:51:07.920 --> 01:51:08.920
$112,000.

01:51:08.920 --> 01:51:09.920
Divided by the $2,000.

01:51:09.920 --> 01:51:10.920
Yeah.

01:51:10.920 --> 01:51:11.920
But I'd have to pay for that.

01:51:11.920 --> 01:51:12.920
55 times $12,000.

01:51:12.920 --> 01:51:18.480
Rebecca Meelesonika.

01:51:18.480 --> 01:51:20.480
Thank you, Mayor.

01:51:20.480 --> 01:51:22.480
I'd also like to win, you know,

01:51:22.480 --> 01:51:26.280
You know, kind of along the lines that Councilman Verger was speaking about,

01:51:26.280 --> 01:51:31.480
you know, knowing human behavior, I think a lot of people would want to rush to

01:51:31.480 --> 01:51:37.480
jump into the lower rate bin, whether, you know, they needed it or not.

01:51:37.480 --> 01:51:44.680
Like Councilman Talkington, I would want the reduced rate to go to the single person,

01:51:44.680 --> 01:51:47.280
the fixed rate income, the elderly.

01:51:47.280 --> 01:51:52.280
I would want that, but I think figuring that out and enforcing that would be a bureaucratic nightmare.

01:51:52.280 --> 01:51:55.280
And I don't think it would be feasible.

01:51:55.280 --> 01:52:00.480
I really support the idea behind the motion, and I support the concept, but I don't think

01:52:00.480 --> 01:52:05.160
that the facts or figures match up, and I don't think it's going to be possible.

01:52:05.160 --> 01:52:09.480
Anything further on that motion council?

01:52:09.480 --> 01:52:15.600
I just want to go on record to say I appreciate the motion and the direction, but the fixed

01:52:15.600 --> 01:52:21.720
costs of buying the bins and the other dynamics make it so that I just can't support the motion.

01:52:21.720 --> 01:52:24.960
but I do appreciate the sentiment behind it.

01:52:24.960 --> 01:52:27.160
I've never had so much support for a motion

01:52:27.160 --> 01:52:28.600
that won't have more than a second.

01:52:28.600 --> 01:52:30.200
I appreciate it.

01:52:30.200 --> 01:52:31.800
Well, you know, I just want to say,

01:52:31.800 --> 01:52:33.400
I understand what you're trying to do, Chris.

01:52:33.400 --> 01:52:36.120
You're trying to help folks that need help.

01:52:36.120 --> 01:52:37.960
And I know there are other ways we can do it

01:52:37.960 --> 01:52:39.360
if we were serious about it.

01:52:39.360 --> 01:52:41.560
Yeah, I agree with the sentiment.

01:52:41.560 --> 01:52:44.000
So I see no further lights.

01:52:44.000 --> 01:52:45.600
The ailer roll call vote.

01:52:45.600 --> 01:52:46.440
Jim?

01:52:46.440 --> 01:52:47.530
No.

01:52:47.530 --> 01:52:48.370
Sean Burger.

01:52:48.370 --> 01:52:49.210
No.

01:52:49.210 --> 01:52:50.030
This talking time?

01:52:50.030 --> 01:52:50.870
Yes.

01:52:50.870 --> 01:52:51.870
Greg Lonti.

01:52:51.870 --> 01:52:52.870
No.

01:52:52.870 --> 01:52:53.870
Don Hall.

01:52:53.870 --> 01:52:54.870
No.

01:52:54.870 --> 01:52:55.870
Rebecca Mils like that?

01:52:55.870 --> 01:52:56.870
No.

01:52:56.870 --> 01:52:57.870
Susan Hopper.

01:52:57.870 --> 01:52:58.870
No.

01:52:58.870 --> 01:52:59.870
Motion fails.

01:52:59.870 --> 01:53:00.870
One to six to one.

01:53:00.870 --> 01:53:01.870
One to six.

01:53:01.870 --> 01:53:02.870
That's how we say it, right?

01:53:02.870 --> 01:53:03.870
Yeah.

01:53:03.870 --> 01:53:04.870
Thanks for your research, Laura.

01:53:04.870 --> 01:53:05.870
Appreciate it.

01:53:05.870 --> 01:53:06.870
Yeah, absolutely.

01:53:06.870 --> 01:53:07.870
And Kevin too.

01:53:07.870 --> 01:53:08.870
Appreciate it.

01:53:08.870 --> 01:53:12.800
Thank you for coming tonight and going through.

01:53:12.800 --> 01:53:14.800
Rebecca Mils like it.

01:53:14.800 --> 01:53:15.800
Mayor, thank you.

01:53:15.800 --> 01:53:19.800
I just noticed all these people sitting here and they're probably hungry and wanting to go home to their families.

01:53:19.800 --> 01:53:23.900
I was wondering if we couldn't talk about item 10 later

01:53:23.900 --> 01:53:25.520
and move on to the public hearings.

01:53:25.520 --> 01:53:27.160
Yeah, I think that would be appropriate.

01:53:27.160 --> 01:53:29.640
Other than, is there someone here

01:53:29.640 --> 01:53:33.200
that wants to engage the council

01:53:33.200 --> 01:53:35.360
that's not one of the public hearings?

01:53:35.360 --> 01:53:37.880
We could certainly move to that first,

01:53:37.880 --> 01:53:40.840
and then my suggestion is we take a short break.

01:53:40.840 --> 01:53:43.000
Folks, I'm sorry, but we've been up here for two hours,

01:53:43.000 --> 01:53:45.000
and you want us to have good attention

01:53:45.000 --> 01:53:46.720
to your public hearing.

01:53:46.720 --> 01:53:47.880
Is there anyone from the public

01:53:47.880 --> 01:53:54.300
I'd like to address the council this evening that's not one of the public hearings.

01:53:54.300 --> 01:54:00.980
I see no one, so any items from city manager?

01:54:00.980 --> 01:54:03.620
There's a fireman's ball coming up, do we have to date with that?

01:54:03.620 --> 01:54:10.960
Mr. Mayor, members of council, there's a fireman's ball and I believe that is the 13th of September.

01:54:10.960 --> 01:54:12.400
13th of September?

01:54:12.400 --> 01:54:12.900
Yeah.

01:54:12.720 --> 01:54:14.080
6.30 PM.

01:54:14.080 --> 01:54:15.600
6.30 PM.

01:54:15.600 --> 01:54:22.320
Would it be appropriate now to share a quick report or would the council like for that to occur after?

01:54:22.320 --> 01:54:26.520
I will say there may be some benefit to the citizens.

01:54:26.520 --> 01:54:29.320
It has to do with property taxes.

01:54:29.320 --> 01:54:31.700
How long's the report?

01:54:31.700 --> 01:54:33.900
My piece might be just two minutes.

01:54:33.900 --> 01:54:37.260
Okay, but you can't control our piece of it.

01:54:37.260 --> 01:54:38.980
I was careful to say my piece.

01:54:38.980 --> 01:54:40.340
Well, I'm okay with saying it.

01:54:40.340 --> 01:54:41.940
I'm guilty as anyone.

01:54:41.940 --> 01:54:49.920
So why don't you go ahead and share that quickly.

01:54:49.920 --> 01:54:54.240
So Mr. Mayor, members of the council, as I shared in a email to you, but I also want to

01:54:54.240 --> 01:55:00.520
share with the public is, as we've talked about the budget every week over the course

01:55:00.520 --> 01:55:06.400
of the last few weeks, we've shared what the potential impacts to our citizens would be.

01:55:06.400 --> 01:55:12.160
And we're hoping that this gets as much attention as the others, because this is pretty important.

01:55:12.160 --> 01:55:16.400
One of the things, and that we were always having this internal conversation about was

01:55:16.400 --> 01:55:27.000
How would there be an accounting for the $302,000 of funding that equates to the personal property tax relief,

01:55:27.000 --> 01:55:29.400
those proposed by the item of a legislature?

01:55:29.400 --> 01:55:32.200
They went through a series of rulemaking changes.

01:55:32.200 --> 01:55:38.200
And one of the things that we found is that it was taken off of the topic at the very beginning.

01:55:38.200 --> 01:55:41.960
And so the entire time in which we were having the conversation,

01:55:41.960 --> 01:55:46.600
we were in a sense double counting the $302,000

01:55:46.600 --> 01:55:48.760
that was going to be coming in.

01:55:48.760 --> 01:55:51.720
As a result of that, our citizens are going to see

01:55:51.720 --> 01:55:55.080
reduction in their property taxes in the upcoming year,

01:55:55.080 --> 01:56:04.280
because the tax rate is going to decrease from $7 and 86

01:56:04.280 --> 01:56:07.520
cents to $7.79.

01:56:07.520 --> 01:56:15.760
That's a true actual reduction in the tax rate, which translates to a reduction in the property

01:56:15.760 --> 01:56:18.880
tax rate, which is multiplied by the properties.

01:56:18.880 --> 01:56:22.280
And also it's important to recognize that there was also an increase in the homeowners

01:56:22.280 --> 01:56:23.280
exemption.

01:56:23.280 --> 01:56:26.200
Because if you recall, we kept on having the conversation.

01:56:26.200 --> 01:56:33.920
We don't understand how the total new construction value of the community could grow by $31 billion,

01:56:33.920 --> 01:56:37.120
but we are only getting credit for the 28.

01:56:37.120 --> 01:56:42.000
And that is because they took that other monies off of the top.

01:56:42.000 --> 01:56:47.120
And then we created tax rates and levies differently.

01:56:47.120 --> 01:56:50.720
So this is the table, because we had to share how much is it going to cost to live in to

01:56:50.720 --> 01:56:52.800
involves this share compared to next.

01:56:52.800 --> 01:56:57.240
And the answer is 80 cents per month, or $9.57.

01:56:57.240 --> 01:57:03.690
And this is just the city's tax rate, water rate, sewer bill, sanitation bills all combined.

01:57:03.690 --> 01:57:06.530
Tax rate decreases, all the other rates remain the same.

01:57:06.530 --> 01:57:08.650
We thought that was important to reflect.

01:57:08.650 --> 01:57:11.230
Josh Palmer will be sending out a press release

01:57:11.230 --> 01:57:12.990
illustrating that.

01:57:12.990 --> 01:57:15.690
Thank you, Travis, Chris, talking to him.

01:57:15.690 --> 01:57:17.210
Oh, I didn't know it was still on.

01:57:17.210 --> 01:57:19.010
But the property tax actually went down

01:57:19.010 --> 01:57:20.450
by about four bucks a decade.

01:57:20.450 --> 01:57:24.850
The average resident, we'll see, in this example,

01:57:24.850 --> 01:57:29.690
we'll see a decrease of $4.71 in property taxes.

01:57:29.690 --> 01:57:32.130
An average, the tax rate will decrease $7

01:57:32.130 --> 01:57:35.030
per $1,000 of taxable value for all properties

01:57:35.030 --> 01:57:38.440
inside the city of Twin Falls.

01:57:38.440 --> 01:57:40.480
I think Travis, anything further on his report.

01:57:40.480 --> 01:57:42.440
Good news, thank you sir.

01:57:42.440 --> 01:57:44.760
We will take, and when we return,

01:57:44.760 --> 01:57:48.200
we're going to go straight into the public hearings.

01:57:48.200 --> 01:57:52.240
If you're interested in engaging the council

01:57:52.240 --> 01:57:54.960
or testifying, make sure you put your name on the back.

01:57:54.960 --> 01:57:58.280
But for now, we are going to take a seven minute break.

01:57:58.280 --> 01:58:01.360
Can I say that we have a real important public hearing

01:58:01.360 --> 01:58:03.240
tomorrow at six o'clock here?

01:58:03.240 --> 01:58:04.080
Yes, absolutely.

01:58:04.080 --> 01:58:08.400
Concerning the downtown ODAC renovation.

01:58:08.400 --> 01:58:11.800
and for the people that are here and in the TV audience.

01:58:11.800 --> 01:58:13.360
I think it's here, isn't it Travis?

01:58:13.360 --> 01:58:15.040
The six o'clock.

01:58:15.040 --> 01:58:17.120
Six o'clock tomorrow evening, thank you.

01:58:17.120 --> 01:58:18.880
We will take a seven minute break,

01:58:18.880 --> 02:05:38.720
being back here at five after seven.

02:05:38.720 --> 02:05:40.520
Ready, Leila?

02:05:40.520 --> 02:05:43.120
I'd like to reconvene a meeting of the City of Twin Falls

02:05:43.120 --> 02:05:44.480
City Council.

02:05:44.480 --> 02:05:49.170
We are moving, we are moving into the public hearing,

02:05:49.170 --> 02:05:50.730
portion of tonight's meeting.

02:05:50.730 --> 02:05:52.770
We will go back to item number 10

02:05:52.770 --> 02:05:56.490
and some more on item number 11 of the items

02:05:56.490 --> 02:05:58.930
for consideration after the public hearings.

02:06:00.450 --> 02:06:03.610
The first item, well first I just wanted to remind folks,

02:06:03.610 --> 02:06:06.330
the presenter generally will have about 15 minutes

02:06:06.330 --> 02:06:07.850
to make their presentation followed up

02:06:07.850 --> 02:06:10.410
many times by a staff portion,

02:06:10.410 --> 02:06:14.250
or the staff might start depending on the situation.

02:06:14.250 --> 02:06:16.050
And when we do turn it over to the public,

02:06:16.050 --> 02:06:18.210
you have two minutes to make your presentation.

02:06:18.210 --> 02:06:19.210
We will time it.

02:06:19.210 --> 02:06:25.890
Suzanne Hawkins, to my right, will have a 30-second sign to give you kind of an indication that

02:06:25.890 --> 02:06:31.250
you're coming close to your time. If the buzzer beeps, don't go running off like, you know,

02:06:31.250 --> 02:06:37.170
it's an emergency, we'll just kind of gently remind you just so that we can try to monitor

02:06:37.170 --> 02:06:42.170
the time. The first time on the agenda for public hearing is a request from the YMCA

02:06:42.170 --> 02:06:49.210
increase rates at the City YMCA swimming pool and we have John Pauly the

02:06:49.210 --> 02:06:53.610
Aquatics Director is that your title John welcome and come forward sir.

02:06:53.610 --> 02:07:00.760
Thank you Mayor and Council. So I'm going to start off with a letter I wrote to the

02:07:00.760 --> 02:07:06.600
City Council if we can go from there. So in October 2013 we made the decision to

02:07:06.600 --> 02:07:10.400
have a minimum of two lifeguards on duty at all times being two guards always

02:07:10.400 --> 02:07:14.360
watching the pool whenever there's people in the water. The reason for this

02:07:14.360 --> 02:07:17.440
This decision was because we wanted to create a safer aquatic environment.

02:07:17.440 --> 02:07:22.160
The Y-City pool is a 50 meter, 8 lane, about 60 feet wide on Olympic-sized swimming pool.

02:07:22.160 --> 02:07:26.520
It is my opinion that the size of the pool is too big for one lifeguard to handle safely.

02:07:26.520 --> 02:07:30.380
By adding a second lifeguard, we split the pool into two pools using the bulkhead which

02:07:30.380 --> 02:07:33.020
is the bridge that goes across the middle.

02:07:33.020 --> 02:07:37.020
This allows our guards to scan and concentrate on a smaller portion of water, making it safer

02:07:37.020 --> 02:07:38.940
for all of our swimmers.

02:07:38.940 --> 02:07:43.140
Having two guards also has other safety benefits besides having an additional person on surveillance

02:07:43.140 --> 02:07:50.140
These benefits include having backup coverage in case one guard has to enter the water for a save or provide first aid.

02:07:50.140 --> 02:07:58.140
Make incidents slash saves easier to handle because not one guard is doing all the work and adds an additional response link in our emergency action plan.

02:07:58.140 --> 02:08:08.680
Since going to the two lifeguard system in October 2013, we have seen an increase of $20,569.10 in staffing costs.

02:08:08.680 --> 02:08:18.760
staffing costs. From September 2012 to June 2013 we spent $58,879.39 on life guard wages

02:08:18.760 --> 02:08:27.560
and from September 2013 through June 2014 we spent $71,448.49 on life guard wages. This

02:08:27.560 --> 02:08:32.520
is a 28% increase in what we are spending on life guard wages. July and August are not

02:08:32.520 --> 02:08:35.680
included on this report because we did not have those numbers available at the time of

02:08:35.680 --> 02:08:40.840
creating the report. I wanted to give you guys the best numbers I could give you.

02:08:40.840 --> 02:08:45.040
That's why we went through June and those were more of our concrete numbers. So

02:08:45.040 --> 02:08:48.800
what we are proposing is a 50 cent increase for all three of our daily

02:08:48.800 --> 02:08:53.240
admission categories. This is our three and unders which would go to 250. Our four

02:08:53.240 --> 02:08:58.000
to 17s which should go to 350 and our adults 18 and older which could go to 450.

02:08:58.000 --> 02:09:03.240
We're also proposing our membership increases as well. Currently an adult

02:09:03.240 --> 02:09:07.920
automatic deduction which automatically deducts out of a person's account every

02:09:07.920 --> 02:09:16.020
month is at $22.50 we're proposing that goes to $23.99 plus tax as well as our

02:09:16.020 --> 02:09:23.780
annual rate going from $1.8991 or sorry $1.84.91 to a flat $200 plus tax how

02:09:23.780 --> 02:09:28.260
that $1.84.91 got there I couldn't tell you but we definitely want to get that

02:09:28.260 --> 02:09:30.760
that more rounded up as well.

02:09:30.760 --> 02:09:33.760
Family, we're looking at going from 27.50 a month

02:09:33.760 --> 02:09:36.540
to 29.99 a month plus tax.

02:09:36.540 --> 02:09:40.300
And then our annual family, we'd be looking at $250 a year

02:09:40.300 --> 02:09:43.300
to $275 a year plus tax.

02:09:43.300 --> 02:09:46.020
With the family, we're also seeking an increase

02:09:46.020 --> 02:09:50.380
in our joiners fee of $10 from $25 to $35.

02:09:50.380 --> 02:09:52.500
We're not seeking any joiners fee increases

02:09:52.500 --> 02:09:54.020
for the adults or the youth.

02:09:54.020 --> 02:09:55.700
And matter of fact, our youth membership

02:09:55.700 --> 02:09:59.600
we're not even requesting any type of increase.

02:09:59.600 --> 02:10:03.600
In fact, our YMCA full membership is actually cheaper

02:10:03.600 --> 02:10:05.460
than our YMCA pool membership.

02:10:05.460 --> 02:10:09.480
So we don't offer a YMCA pool month to month membership anymore

02:10:09.480 --> 02:10:11.540
because our YMCA membership is cheaper

02:10:11.540 --> 02:10:13.780
than that YMCA pool membership

02:10:13.780 --> 02:10:17.160
because we made that decision to lower our full YMCA membership

02:10:17.160 --> 02:10:22.000
down to $20 instead of where the Y youth membership per month

02:10:22.000 --> 02:10:23.700
was about $21.50.

02:10:23.700 --> 02:10:25.580
I don't remember off the top of my head.

02:10:25.580 --> 02:10:30.580
So we offer that because we did some research and found our youth membership was a tad high on that end.

02:10:30.580 --> 02:10:32.220
So we lowered that down to $20.

02:10:32.220 --> 02:10:36.740
So that's what we do for our youth when it comes to month to month.

02:10:36.740 --> 02:10:42.510
We do offer the Y City pools an annual option though because that is cheaper than a YMCA membership.

02:10:42.510 --> 02:10:45.230
So that's all I have for now.

02:10:45.230 --> 02:10:48.390
Any questions for Mr. Pollock?

02:10:48.390 --> 02:10:49.940
Suzanne Hawkins.

02:10:49.940 --> 02:10:52.140
Hi, I have a couple quick questions.

02:10:52.140 --> 02:10:59.020
So, in the two time periods that you quoted us the increase the September 2012 through June,

02:10:59.020 --> 02:11:05.180
how many lifeguards were employed during that time period versus the increase time from September

02:11:05.180 --> 02:11:07.500
2013 to June 2014?

02:11:07.500 --> 02:11:10.140
What that was was a one additional lifeguard during that.

02:11:10.140 --> 02:11:15.540
There was, I'm sorry, there was one fewer from 2012 to 13 and then from 13 to 14.

02:11:15.540 --> 02:11:16.540
So we added one during that period.

02:11:16.540 --> 02:11:17.540
So you added one?

02:11:17.540 --> 02:11:22.100
Where are any pay wage increases given to the lifeguards during those two different time periods?

02:11:22.100 --> 02:11:26.580
There's some annual reviews, but in the whole sheen the things most were around the same because it is a

02:11:27.300 --> 02:11:31.460
Higher turnover right position a lot of our kids work for a year

02:11:31.460 --> 02:11:34.020
So maybe two and then they go off to college, which is just great

02:11:34.020 --> 02:11:41.660
I want them to move on but raises wise probably not a lot and do you know an average annual wage for a lifeguard?

02:11:41.660 --> 02:11:45.780
I can't give you an average annual wage, but I can't give you their hourly rate

02:11:45.780 --> 02:11:51.940
It ranges from about seven seventy five an hour to eight fifty an hour depending on experience and time and all that

02:11:52.100 --> 02:11:53.100
Okay, thank you.

02:11:53.100 --> 02:11:54.100
You're welcome.

02:11:54.100 --> 02:11:55.100
Chris, talking to him.

02:11:55.100 --> 02:12:02.800
So I can freeze for the action.

02:12:02.800 --> 02:12:03.800
Yes, sir.

02:12:03.800 --> 02:12:10.420
Largely pays for the second light guard that you've had on staff since sometime, which is

02:12:10.420 --> 02:12:15.820
in pre-spirit expenses where up late, $20,000 or about 28%.

02:12:15.820 --> 02:12:16.820
Yes, sir.

02:12:16.820 --> 02:12:19.700
And that's the first increase since 2011?

02:12:19.700 --> 02:12:21.540
The daily admissions, yes.

02:12:21.540 --> 02:12:28.540
The daily admissions haven't gone up since the last contract ended in August 31st, 2011,

02:12:28.540 --> 02:12:33.180
We had 25 cents to work with that year, so we did go up 25 cents.

02:12:33.180 --> 02:12:37.380
I believe it, I couldn't give you the exact date, but it was before the new contract.

02:12:37.380 --> 02:12:42.340
And then since the new contract is September 1st, 2011, we have not gone up in any of the

02:12:42.340 --> 02:12:45.420
categories.

02:12:45.420 --> 02:12:56.650
That second white part wasn't mandated by any national Y rules or OSHA or best practices.

02:12:56.650 --> 02:13:01.490
How did you come up determining that we were under safety

02:13:01.490 --> 02:13:02.310
protective?

02:13:02.310 --> 02:13:03.890
That a fair question.

02:13:03.890 --> 02:13:06.330
The aquatic industry nationwide in pools

02:13:06.330 --> 02:13:09.610
is under regulated by a lot, to be honest with you.

02:13:09.610 --> 02:13:11.890
There is, it's all recommendation when

02:13:11.890 --> 02:13:14.290
it comes with the Red Cross, YMCA, state of Idaho.

02:13:14.290 --> 02:13:16.810
There's no, it hasn't been until recently

02:13:16.810 --> 02:13:19.890
since the federal government has started to regulate pools.

02:13:19.890 --> 02:13:22.890
And all they've really elated is mechanical equipment,

02:13:22.890 --> 02:13:25.050
nothing life guardwise.

02:13:25.050 --> 02:13:28.190
So we, it falls upon us to police ourselves.

02:13:28.190 --> 02:13:30.650
So when we look at it, every so often we need to look

02:13:30.650 --> 02:13:33.410
at ourselves and find out what should we be doing

02:13:33.410 --> 02:13:35.490
to provide a safer environment,

02:13:35.490 --> 02:13:37.210
this is the conclusion I came up with,

02:13:37.210 --> 02:13:40.210
with that big of a pool, two lifeguards is the minimum

02:13:40.210 --> 02:13:42.170
for that safe of an environment.

02:13:42.170 --> 02:13:44.850
Even when there's maybe five people on one side

02:13:44.850 --> 02:13:45.970
and two people on the other,

02:13:45.970 --> 02:13:49.200
it's just too much water for one lifeguard.

02:13:49.200 --> 02:13:50.680
Rebecca Milsoyka.

02:13:50.680 --> 02:13:51.520
Thank you, Mayor.

02:13:51.520 --> 02:13:53.480
Thank you for your report, Mr. Polly.

02:13:53.480 --> 02:14:05.360
Um, how many incidents have you had drowning or otherwise on, um, I guess in the past year or on average, uh, are your lifeguards in the pool?

02:14:05.360 --> 02:14:08.680
You know what I mean? I, it, not, not deaths or injuries or anything.

02:14:08.680 --> 02:14:13.560
Just, just the lifeguard needing to go in the water and, uh, recover someone.

02:14:13.560 --> 02:14:21.800
Most of the time they happen during the busiest times when we've already had these lifeguards here anyways, so summer months or spring break or Christmas break.

02:14:21.800 --> 02:14:26.680
We get Saturday Sundays. We have more than two lifeguards on during those times. We

02:14:26.680 --> 02:14:31.840
have, you know, four or five lifeguards watching the water. So those are our most

02:14:31.840 --> 02:14:36.960
at-risk times when it comes to drowning. So you know, we will have less than 20

02:14:36.960 --> 02:14:39.880
in a year normally when you go in and help somebody. Normally it's a child

02:14:39.880 --> 02:14:44.920
getting out too far from the rope and you have to go in and assist them. My

02:14:44.920 --> 02:14:51.120
concern comes in is the morning times and when the kids aren't there there are a

02:14:51.120 --> 02:14:56.960
There are a lot of folks who have some medical conditions that swim or older population.

02:14:56.960 --> 02:14:57.960
I'm not worried about drowning.

02:14:57.960 --> 02:14:58.960
I'm worried about heart attacks.

02:14:58.960 --> 02:14:59.960
I'm worried about strokes.

02:14:59.960 --> 02:15:01.880
I'm worried about things like that.

02:15:01.880 --> 02:15:07.040
That type of stuff where time is essence and you have to get there and respond because

02:15:07.040 --> 02:15:09.560
it's a game of seconds, not a game of minutes.

02:15:09.560 --> 02:15:16.120
I think I've had two groups of guards doing mini-in-services tonight practicing CPR.

02:15:16.120 --> 02:15:20.800
Red Cross never makes changes to us in the middle of a lifeguard certification cycle.

02:15:20.800 --> 02:15:22.600
They changed their book every five years.

02:15:22.600 --> 02:15:23.960
They did that this year.

02:15:23.960 --> 02:15:25.500
And that's something so important.

02:15:25.500 --> 02:15:27.560
We're really ingrained into our staff.

02:15:27.560 --> 02:15:30.120
The thought process now is speed, speed, speed.

02:15:30.120 --> 02:15:32.400
And that's where the second life guard comes in,

02:15:32.400 --> 02:15:34.860
especially during these times when there might not be

02:15:34.860 --> 02:15:35.960
as many people in the pool,

02:15:35.960 --> 02:15:37.560
but you could have that heart attack

02:15:37.560 --> 02:15:39.080
or you could have that stroke.

02:15:39.080 --> 02:15:43.490
And one guard just isn't gonna cut it.

02:15:43.490 --> 02:15:47.450
Travis, do we have a staff report going along with this at all?

02:15:47.450 --> 02:15:53.510
Dennis, or is it?

02:15:53.510 --> 02:15:54.790
Mr. Mayor, members of the council,

02:15:54.790 --> 02:15:58.030
We were not planning on preparing a staff report.

02:15:58.030 --> 02:16:05.630
The YMCA operates the pool on its own behalf, and it is coming before the council requesting

02:16:05.630 --> 02:16:09.070
this to support its operations.

02:16:09.070 --> 02:16:19.350
It has been noted that the Parks and Rec Advisory Commission that we have has asked and supported

02:16:19.350 --> 02:16:23.750
the proposal that has been submitted by the YMCA.

02:16:23.750 --> 02:16:28.230
But really this is a request of the YMCA and the request is coming to the council as a part

02:16:28.230 --> 02:16:32.790
of the agreement that we have, whereas it says that the City Council reserves the right

02:16:32.790 --> 02:16:39.110
to set the fees for those entering into the public facility.

02:16:39.110 --> 02:16:42.270
I just was curious because many times we have a staff report.

02:16:42.270 --> 02:16:47.150
We do have a staff report in but I didn't know if Dennis or you want to make some comments.

02:16:47.150 --> 02:16:49.830
I appreciate the comments that you did make though.

02:16:49.830 --> 02:16:57.310
further counsel before I turn this over to the public for their testimony. You can have

02:16:57.310 --> 02:17:02.070
a seat. I'm going to turn it over to the public. If someone could go back and get the list,

02:17:02.070 --> 02:17:06.030
we are now opening the public testimony portion of the public hearing.

02:17:06.030 --> 02:17:09.790
Mr. Mayor, as I walked back, we did receive one piece of Britain correspondence we'll put

02:17:09.790 --> 02:17:11.790
on the overhead. Very good.

02:17:11.790 --> 02:17:18.750
And that's it as far as, is there anyone here that wanted to testify regarding the city,

02:17:18.750 --> 02:17:23.750
by pull increases in membership and or fees.

02:17:34.540 --> 02:17:37.380
We are looking at the sheet and it does not appear

02:17:37.380 --> 02:17:41.260
that there's any for public hearing item number one,

02:17:41.260 --> 02:17:42.900
but I wanted to ensure,

02:17:42.900 --> 02:17:48.890
because this is your time to engage the council.

02:17:48.890 --> 02:17:51.290
I see no one running for the podium.

02:17:51.290 --> 02:17:53.730
We will close the public testimony portion,

02:17:53.730 --> 02:17:55.650
keeping the public hearing open

02:17:55.650 --> 02:17:59.290
so that we can ask further questions if council has it.

02:17:59.290 --> 02:18:02.930
And then at a point where we want to deliberate,

02:18:02.930 --> 02:18:06.890
I will close all public comments

02:18:06.890 --> 02:18:10.370
other than to our city attorney for legal issues.

02:18:10.370 --> 02:18:13.650
So at this point, council have any further questions.

02:18:13.650 --> 02:18:15.370
I'd ask John if you had any rebuttal

02:18:15.370 --> 02:18:17.450
to what the public said, but the public didn't say anything.

02:18:17.450 --> 02:18:23.620
So, well, you certainly can.

02:18:23.620 --> 02:18:27.380
I received this written testimony today

02:18:27.380 --> 02:18:29.780
from a citizen and I forwarded it on

02:18:29.780 --> 02:18:31.140
to all the council members.

02:18:31.140 --> 02:18:33.140
Did you have a chance to look at council?

02:18:33.140 --> 02:18:34.140
Okay.

02:18:34.140 --> 02:18:43.900
It's up on the overhead now and then we've been asked to put it on the board this evening.

02:18:43.900 --> 02:18:53.660
And John, did you want to make any, if you'd come forward and address the written comment?

02:18:53.660 --> 02:19:01.260
This experience is coming from a summer perspective and in that during the day, a lot of our members

02:19:01.260 --> 02:19:06.100
in our general public want us to stay open so if it is a slower day let's say

02:19:06.100 --> 02:19:11.100
it's a summer day you don't normally want to go below three lifeguards because

02:19:11.100 --> 02:19:15.620
it was longer shifts and you need to rotate out that happened very rarely this

02:19:15.620 --> 02:19:19.940
summer it was more of a well I shouldn't say that when we did the weather heard

02:19:19.940 --> 02:19:24.900
us bad this summer it did not it didn't help any matters explain that is it

02:19:24.900 --> 02:19:30.580
because of the cooler weather or the cool well I mean I mean we were hot we were

02:19:30.580 --> 02:19:34.220
busy right but the cooler weather the rain we lost two weeks of some lessons in

02:19:34.220 --> 02:19:41.420
June because of this weather so I'm gonna say with the weather you know even if

02:19:41.420 --> 02:19:44.420
it's slow and it's a cooler day I'll give you it last week as an example I

02:19:44.420 --> 02:19:48.660
mean we've there wasn't no two weeks ago school was still not in session yet but

02:19:48.660 --> 02:19:51.980
we had a minimum of three or four guards there because you never know if

02:19:51.980 --> 02:19:55.140
it's gonna get busy or not you got to be prepared you can't have enough you

02:19:55.140 --> 02:19:59.700
can't not have enough lifeguards there so yes there are times when there might

02:19:59.700 --> 02:20:04.180
not be a guard or two up like normal, but in that case you're finding stuff for them

02:20:04.180 --> 02:20:08.580
to do. You know, you got to do some deeper cleaning in the city pool. You've got to do

02:20:08.580 --> 02:20:13.980
deck cleaning. I mean, there are tasks that you have to do. We work our hardest to make

02:20:13.980 --> 02:20:17.980
sure the lifeguards aren't standing around. Our head lifeguards do a pretty good job of

02:20:17.980 --> 02:20:22.340
keeping them on that. If there isn't something for them to do, we send them home.

02:20:22.340 --> 02:20:28.500
I think the gist of the letter really was, have you explored every option to do that?

02:20:28.500 --> 02:20:35.380
For cost savings rather than increase the revenue. Okay, that's really I think that just of the letters

02:20:35.380 --> 02:20:38.840
I see what you're saying now. I kind of I got that too at the end. So I wasn't ever sensor. I apologize

02:20:40.040 --> 02:20:45.060
Yes, what we're doing is we are keeping our numbers down as low as possible

02:20:45.060 --> 02:20:48.220
I said we send home guards and we don't need them we I

02:20:49.020 --> 02:20:53.380
Get a little preemptive meaning I'll send home guards before they even come in they don't like it

02:20:53.380 --> 02:20:57.700
They lose hours on it, but I can't just have people sitting around doing nothing now

02:20:57.700 --> 02:21:00.020
Sometimes there are some extra projects that come up.

02:21:00.020 --> 02:21:02.700
You know, for example, we're painting the pool office right now.

02:21:02.700 --> 02:21:05.700
That's coming out of a more, not our life-guarding fund.

02:21:05.700 --> 02:21:08.980
That's more of a general Y fund for improvement of facilities

02:21:08.980 --> 02:21:10.220
to make them look nicer.

02:21:10.220 --> 02:21:12.500
If you have time, I would definitely recommend checking out.

02:21:12.500 --> 02:21:13.140
It's pretty cool.

02:21:13.140 --> 02:21:14.140
I don't recommend seeing it yet.

02:21:14.140 --> 02:21:18.180
But we've sent our guards home when we don't need them.

02:21:18.180 --> 02:21:20.660
We close if the weather's going to be nasty or cold

02:21:20.660 --> 02:21:21.580
or anything like that.

02:21:21.580 --> 02:21:23.780
We're coming up a lot of that right now until we get the bubble

02:21:23.780 --> 02:21:24.280
up.

02:21:23.940 --> 02:21:24.780
I hate closing.

02:21:24.780 --> 02:21:26.700
But you know, if there's a lot of lightning and thunder,

02:21:26.700 --> 02:21:33.300
you have to. But we are sending them home when we can. And what you see is, you know, during

02:21:33.300 --> 02:21:37.820
the open sometimes at night, for example, you don't really want to go below three because

02:21:37.820 --> 02:21:40.640
you got to do your tarts at the end of the night where you're going to need at least three

02:21:40.640 --> 02:21:46.180
lifeguards to get them on to the pool. Sometimes you can't get them on because of the wins and

02:21:46.180 --> 02:21:49.740
all that stuff. But we are doing everything we can to keep our costs down. Yes.

02:21:49.740 --> 02:21:54.620
I think that's really a good question. No problem. Rebecca Milsoka.

02:21:54.620 --> 02:21:55.620
Thank you, Mayor.

02:21:55.620 --> 02:21:58.580
I think you answered most of the question, but that was kind of you mentioned sometimes

02:21:58.580 --> 02:22:00.540
when it's busy, you need three or four lifeguards.

02:22:00.540 --> 02:22:05.020
I was just wondering what that minimum is and it sounds like the minimum lifeguards that you

02:22:05.020 --> 02:22:08.540
need at all times would be three throughout the day.

02:22:08.540 --> 02:22:10.900
Well, it just kind of depends on the season.

02:22:10.900 --> 02:22:12.860
I mean, I would say two.

02:22:12.860 --> 02:22:20.020
For example, let's use summer for example from 5 a.m. until 1 p.m. we do two in the summer.

02:22:20.020 --> 02:22:25.020
One, two, five, we'd have five, six, seven, four, five, six, or seven.

02:22:25.020 --> 02:22:31.300
It fluctuates on hot busy days when you need seven because you need six eyes on the water,

02:22:31.300 --> 02:22:32.980
one of them doing swim tests.

02:22:32.980 --> 02:22:36.180
That's another thing we've learned from our experiences is that, and I've seen this at

02:22:36.180 --> 02:22:40.820
every pool, is when you have a life grid doing swim tests, it's a major distraction from surveillance

02:22:40.820 --> 02:22:41.820
duty.

02:22:41.820 --> 02:22:44.420
So we've dedicated a position to doing the swim test.

02:22:44.420 --> 02:22:48.260
You know, as the day goes on, we'll probably send one guard home because there's not as

02:22:48.260 --> 02:22:51.340
as many swim tests that you don't need that position as much anymore.

02:22:51.340 --> 02:22:54.580
So we'd have the guard who's on break come out and take care of that.

02:22:54.580 --> 02:22:57.020
And then at night in the summer before five.

02:22:57.020 --> 02:22:57.860
Thank you.

02:22:57.860 --> 02:23:04.340
Yes, and I appreciate the input from this member of the public because anecdotally I use the pool every once in a while.

02:23:04.340 --> 02:23:09.420
And there have been times when I go in and there are five or six people standing at the front desk.

02:23:09.420 --> 02:23:15.820
And as a tax-bearing as a user, you want to make sure that the resources are being used responsibly.

02:23:15.820 --> 02:23:21.900
So maybe just be aware of that, and maybe in the future, just find ways where you, we

02:23:21.900 --> 02:23:27.140
don't want you to be so lean that you can't function safely as a pool, but definitely keep

02:23:27.140 --> 02:23:36.460
in mind that, you know, users want to know that their resources are being spared, I guess,

02:23:36.460 --> 02:23:37.460
are used sparingly.

02:23:37.460 --> 02:23:38.460
Can I comment to that?

02:23:38.460 --> 02:23:39.460
Yes, please.

02:23:39.460 --> 02:23:40.460
Yes, yes, please.

02:23:40.460 --> 02:23:44.620
You normally, most of the time you would come in the four to six timeframe, right?

02:23:44.620 --> 02:23:49.340
30 about for a class. Those weren't lifeguards, those were film instructors. So that's coming

02:23:49.340 --> 02:23:53.380
out of the complete different... Okay, thank you for that information. They were the same

02:23:53.380 --> 02:23:57.100
uniforms, generally, so it's hard to tell. Yes, same tool, but I do want to make that, you

02:23:57.100 --> 02:24:01.980
know, death's in preparation. The swim instruction section is a lot different than how we run

02:24:01.980 --> 02:24:06.100
the lifeguard section because there is some downtime in between classes. So for the swim

02:24:06.100 --> 02:24:13.140
instruction is that those fees are covered by the users or do you, does the YMCA or the pool

02:24:13.140 --> 02:24:18.940
subsidize the swim lessons at all. We do. We sure do. We have a financial assistance program for those who can't afford it.

02:24:18.940 --> 02:24:24.940
We had a good number of people who use that this summer. Never do away with that program. So in that subsidizing, does that come from the

02:24:24.940 --> 02:24:32.580
why funds or does that come from the city pool? The YMCA scholarship fund. Okay. Well, appreciate the information. That's actually good for the public to know as well.

02:24:32.580 --> 02:24:39.370
No problem. Council, do we have any other questions before we turn it over to the liberation? Can we do we have a resolution number?

02:24:39.370 --> 02:24:52.730
Thank you. I'll take it. I'll take it. I take it too. 1931. I'm sorry I missed that

02:24:52.730 --> 02:24:59.410
Leah. 1931. 1931. Fine year. Very good. Anything further? Any questions? Council

02:24:59.410 --> 02:25:05.670
before we turn it over to deliberations? You can have a seat jump. We are now closed

02:25:05.670 --> 02:25:11.450
the public hearing and it's up to council for deliberation and or a motion.

02:25:11.450 --> 02:25:29.450
I'll put the motion on floor to accept the request as recommended by Parks and Rec to increase the rates of the city-wide swimming pool as promoted advertised under resolution in 1931.

02:25:29.450 --> 02:25:31.450
Yeah, under 1931.

02:25:31.450 --> 02:25:32.450
I'll second that.

02:25:32.450 --> 02:25:34.450
We have a motion on the floor by Kristallen.

02:25:34.450 --> 02:25:42.250
seconded by Jim Mon to approve resolution 1931 as presented this evening.

02:25:42.250 --> 02:25:43.530
Anything further on that motion?

02:25:43.530 --> 02:25:45.730
Council, Rebecca Milsoy.

02:25:45.730 --> 02:25:46.490
Thank you, Mayor.

02:25:46.490 --> 02:25:53.140
I do want to comment, especially when we're increasing rates, because I hate to do that,

02:25:53.140 --> 02:25:58.100
especially on families and things, but it's important to pay for the service that you're getting.

02:25:58.100 --> 02:26:01.940
Otherwise, people who aren't using the service are going to be subsidizing the pool.

02:26:01.940 --> 02:26:07.100
And tax payers already do subsidize the pool, but it's a benefit to the community.

02:26:07.100 --> 02:26:11.660
And so I will be in favor of increasing these rates.

02:26:11.660 --> 02:26:18.780
But with the caveat of requesting, please always be reviewing your different standards and

02:26:18.780 --> 02:26:24.460
your processes so that you can provide the best service for the least amount of cost.

02:26:24.460 --> 02:26:30.500
But in meeting with Mr. Polly and the YMCA separately,

02:26:30.500 --> 02:26:37.460
demonstrate that they have consistent use of energy really they have a handle on the ups and

02:26:37.460 --> 02:26:44.740
downs of the pool which is very costly you know to heat that pool in the winter and keep it going

02:26:44.740 --> 02:26:50.940
all year round. So I appreciate the information on that and appreciate your management of the pool

02:26:50.940 --> 02:26:55.500
because we do get a lot of positive comments, positive reviews for your management.

02:26:55.500 --> 02:27:01.640
I just want to say, John, that I certainly appreciate what you're doing there.

02:27:01.640 --> 02:27:09.640
I understand that we don't want to pay for a service unless we really need it.

02:27:09.640 --> 02:27:11.040
We need lifeguards.

02:27:11.040 --> 02:27:13.360
And when you need one, you need a lifeguard.

02:27:13.360 --> 02:27:18.680
And I appreciate that you reviewed how large that pool is and the site distances and all

02:27:18.680 --> 02:27:25.960
those things, being able to react quickly to folks when they need us and bring this request.

02:27:25.960 --> 02:27:31.680
The only thing that I would just say is to, you know, it's a 25% increase.

02:27:31.680 --> 02:27:34.520
That's quite a bit on at least one of these categories.

02:27:34.520 --> 02:27:39.840
Maybe we could look at this a little more often, so it's not quite such a jump in the future.

02:27:39.840 --> 02:27:42.160
Just a thought, I will be in support of this.

02:27:42.160 --> 02:27:48.520
And I know from hearing from you and listening to others that you are trying to do those cost-saving measures.

02:27:48.520 --> 02:27:52.600
And I would appreciate you continuing to do that, although I know that you will.

02:27:52.600 --> 02:27:54.960
So, no, we, no more testimony.

02:27:54.960 --> 02:27:58.640
Just anything further on this motion council

02:27:59.570 --> 02:28:02.630
We had a roll call vote for resolution 1931

02:28:04.090 --> 02:28:06.090
Yes

02:28:13.010 --> 02:28:17.130
Yes, motion passes seven to zero moving to the next item. Thank you John

02:28:18.690 --> 02:28:25.250
Request for the city council's recommendation on the vacation of two plated ditch and utility easily

02:28:25.410 --> 02:28:32.410
on property located at 2733 Skyline Drive in the area of impact.

02:28:32.410 --> 02:28:37.410
And folks that will be making this presentation are Jenna and Blake Johnson.

02:28:37.410 --> 02:28:43.410
And I believe that they will be making a presentation followed by potentially a staff presentation.

02:28:43.410 --> 02:28:45.410
So you must be Jenna Johnson.

02:28:45.410 --> 02:28:46.410
I am, thank you.

02:28:46.410 --> 02:28:48.020
Welcome, Jenna.

02:28:48.020 --> 02:28:53.600
I'm hoping, I guess, do you have pictures or do you have stuff?

02:28:53.600 --> 02:28:55.200
[Muted for privacy: home address]

02:28:55.200 --> 02:29:00.200
[Muted for privacy: home address]

02:29:00.200 --> 02:29:06.200
[Muted for privacy: home address]

02:29:06.200 --> 02:29:09.200
[Muted for privacy: home address]

02:29:09.200 --> 02:29:18.130
We rebuilt the home over the existing foundation and did an addition.

02:29:18.130 --> 02:29:25.130
You can see on the far left corner the existing garage splash shop area.

02:29:25.130 --> 02:29:38.130
We requested in May to remodel that building and it unbeknownst to us was built on two utility easements.

02:29:38.130 --> 02:29:41.130
As you can see of the blue line.

02:29:41.130 --> 02:29:47.130
I believe that that building has existed for 42 years.

02:29:47.130 --> 02:29:52.010
You can see just a little in the corner of that building.

02:29:52.010 --> 02:29:53.450
There is some greenery.

02:29:53.450 --> 02:29:57.170
That is a utility pole.

02:29:58.450 --> 02:29:59.850
We have the look.

02:29:59.850 --> 02:30:00.690
Could you point that out maybe?

02:30:00.690 --> 02:30:12.710
Could you give her the very good?

02:30:12.710 --> 02:30:14.110
It also runs.

02:30:14.110 --> 02:30:16.550
There's lines that run back to this corner of it.

02:30:16.550 --> 02:30:18.030
Okay, now I'm gonna really confuse you.

02:30:18.030 --> 02:30:18.990
You gotta get by the mic.

02:30:18.990 --> 02:30:20.870
And speaking of which, real quick, Council,

02:30:20.870 --> 02:30:24.150
we've had some folks say from the public

02:30:24.150 --> 02:30:25.110
that they can't hear us.

02:30:25.110 --> 02:30:29.270
So we need to probably try to talk into the mics a little bit better at home, so probably

02:30:29.270 --> 02:30:30.270
me included.

02:30:30.270 --> 02:30:34.750
So this is a power pole.

02:30:34.750 --> 02:30:37.950
It runs, there's a small line right back here.

02:30:37.950 --> 02:30:43.630
And also on this side of my neighbor's property is some other wiring that go across her property

02:30:43.630 --> 02:30:47.190
to another pole.

02:30:47.190 --> 02:30:52.070
This property is being remodeled and nothing, I mean this is an availability to access also.

02:30:52.070 --> 02:30:55.670
There's still this driveway that can access this pole.

02:30:55.670 --> 02:31:04.750
The utility companies and or the canal company have sent letters saying that they did vacate

02:31:04.750 --> 02:31:12.750
the West easement and after that was vacated the building department notified us that the

02:31:12.750 --> 02:31:18.950
South easement is also impinging on this nonconforming building.

02:31:18.950 --> 02:31:28.910
We have asked to extend on the north end of this building approximately 15 feet from what

02:31:28.910 --> 02:31:36.510
it is already existing to do covering for hay and also horse stalls.

02:31:36.510 --> 02:31:42.430
We had no intentions of touching the south end of this building.

02:31:42.430 --> 02:31:47.790
There's a small greenhouse in a small shop area that's the greenhouse is about six feet

02:31:47.790 --> 02:31:50.150
wide, 16 feet long.

02:31:50.150 --> 02:31:57.820
The shop area is about a 12 by 12, which is attached to the existing two car garage.

02:31:57.820 --> 02:32:02.780
The garage door of that existing garage is about six feet tall.

02:32:02.780 --> 02:32:04.820
It has the way it was built.

02:32:04.820 --> 02:32:08.540
It was built with supporting beams inside the garage.

02:32:08.540 --> 02:32:16.700
So our desire was to make the garage itself more functional, to pull vehicles in.

02:32:16.700 --> 02:32:22.620
The shop and the greenhouse are the most functional part of that building.

02:32:22.620 --> 02:32:28.740
So I would feel bad tearing that down, that was not our intentions.

02:32:28.740 --> 02:32:39.190
Our intentions were to take this area and make it a third car garage and extend this out

02:32:39.190 --> 02:32:43.990
for some covering for the horses.

02:32:43.990 --> 02:32:46.750
But yes, it sits on an easement.

02:32:46.750 --> 02:32:47.670
I have a letter.

02:32:47.670 --> 02:32:49.590
I don't know if you guys have received the letter

02:32:49.590 --> 02:32:50.710
from Utah Power.

02:32:50.710 --> 02:32:53.470
That's the only company we're waiting for.

02:32:53.470 --> 02:32:54.750
I had a whole power, I think.

02:32:54.750 --> 02:32:57.750
I mean, Idaho Power, sorry.

02:32:57.750 --> 02:33:03.140
Right here, it was requested that we've asked them

02:33:03.140 --> 02:33:05.180
to vacate that easement.

02:33:05.180 --> 02:33:09.700
But they cannot vacate that easement because of this poll.

02:33:09.700 --> 02:33:12.820
It's a contradiction.

02:33:12.820 --> 02:33:20.240
So we are now, they have agreed that we will now have a

02:33:20.240 --> 02:33:24.560
resurveyed and that they will vacate the easement from this

02:33:24.560 --> 02:33:30.770
over to the building and that we will give them the easement

02:33:30.770 --> 02:33:33.970
that is existing up into that pole.

02:33:33.970 --> 02:33:39.690
But they would vacate this spot right here.

02:33:39.690 --> 02:33:42.410
And we're just waiting for the surveyor to come out

02:33:42.410 --> 02:33:44.010
and rewrite that.

02:33:44.010 --> 02:33:45.810
But everyone else has agreed.

02:33:45.810 --> 02:33:49.810
I think, Jonathan, you have the letters.

02:33:49.810 --> 02:33:52.170
So do you have any questions?

02:33:52.170 --> 02:33:55.370
Any questions or we could maybe go on to the staff report

02:33:55.370 --> 02:33:57.810
and then we might have some questions for you.

02:33:57.810 --> 02:33:58.650
This is Johnson.

02:33:58.650 --> 02:34:01.250
If you want to have a seat, I'd stay close.

02:34:01.250 --> 02:34:03.610
We have Jonathan Spinnlud, given the staff report.

02:34:03.610 --> 02:34:05.850
Thank you, Mr. Mayor, members of the council.

02:34:05.850 --> 02:34:08.450
The history we've got was a lot was created

02:34:08.450 --> 02:34:15.640
with the Skyline Acres Platt, and that was done in 1963.

02:34:15.640 --> 02:34:17.360
The single family home was believed to be built

02:34:17.360 --> 02:34:22.440
in around 1972 with the accessory building sometime thereafter,

02:34:22.440 --> 02:34:25.640
prior to us actually having building permits for them.

02:34:25.640 --> 02:34:31.440
The accessory building was constructed on a platted easement.

02:34:31.440 --> 02:34:34.280
It's very small and old, but the platted easement runs

02:34:34.280 --> 02:34:36.000
on the south boundary line.

02:34:36.000 --> 02:34:39.560
This easement also runs with the next properties down

02:34:39.560 --> 02:34:41.040
and comes across here.

02:34:41.040 --> 02:34:45.580
And that is for a ditch and utility easement that'll power,

02:34:45.580 --> 02:34:48.400
and I believe a foam company both use that easement.

02:34:48.400 --> 02:34:51.120
There is no ditch in the area, so that's where

02:34:51.120 --> 02:34:53.480
vacating is for those two things.

02:34:53.480 --> 02:34:56.200
In early 2003, the Johnson's extensively remodeled

02:34:56.200 --> 02:34:58.120
the existing single-family dwelling,

02:34:58.120 --> 02:35:00.880
and it now stands the way it is today.

02:35:00.880 --> 02:35:03.840
The accessory building was not part of that permit

02:35:03.840 --> 02:35:07.360
and was not evaluated for compliance at that time.

02:35:07.360 --> 02:35:09.960
In June of 2014, you received a building permit

02:35:09.960 --> 02:35:13.080
to remodel the accessory structure during the permit review

02:35:13.080 --> 02:35:14.840
was revealed that the existing structure was built

02:35:14.840 --> 02:35:16.400
on the platted easements.

02:35:16.400 --> 02:35:18.040
Staff has since worked with the owners

02:35:18.040 --> 02:35:21.910
offer solutions in direction to rectified situation.

02:35:21.910 --> 02:35:26.910
The request is to vacate a 15 by 465 approximately foot.

02:35:27.310 --> 02:35:35.870
easement on the west property boundary,

02:35:35.870 --> 02:35:38.810
that'll be this one on the west property boundary,

02:35:38.810 --> 02:35:43.810
and a 15 by 265 foot easement on the south property boundary.

02:35:43.970 --> 02:35:45.410
These easements are stated on the plaque

02:35:45.410 --> 02:35:49.090
to be for ditch and utility, the intent is to vacate both of those and bring the existing

02:35:49.090 --> 02:35:53.930
garage into compliance due to currently being located over a portion of the easements.

02:35:53.930 --> 02:35:57.250
The extent of the accroachment on the easements are unknown at this time.

02:35:57.250 --> 02:35:59.250
That's why the survey may need to be done.

02:35:59.250 --> 02:36:03.210
The applicant applied for a special use permit in conjunction with the vacation in order to

02:36:03.210 --> 02:36:05.690
add on to the garage as she stated.

02:36:05.690 --> 02:36:10.090
On August 12, 2014, the Planning and Zoning Commission granted the special use permit

02:36:10.090 --> 02:36:12.330
subject to the following conditions.

02:36:12.330 --> 02:36:16.250
I won't read them but they are there and they are on the special use permit that was granted.

02:36:16.250 --> 02:36:22.210
One of those was subject to approval of recordation of the easement vacation and its associated conditions

02:36:22.210 --> 02:36:25.010
prior to issuing a building permit.

02:36:25.010 --> 02:36:29.010
Basically that states that any utility company requires certain conditions to be met.

02:36:29.010 --> 02:36:33.250
They would need to meet those conditions prior to us releasing the permit so we can have the

02:36:33.250 --> 02:36:35.530
vacation accomplished.

02:36:35.530 --> 02:36:40.770
We cannot as a city in our definitions approve a building permit over an easement.

02:36:40.770 --> 02:36:48.470
It is not permitted for us to do so. So if there's any easement remaining we still cannot approve it permit over that easement

02:36:48.870 --> 02:36:55.350
The applicant has stated that no utility exists on the west easement and there are multiple utilities existing in the south easement including

02:36:55.350 --> 02:36:57.350
I don't power a phone line

02:36:57.550 --> 02:37:02.550
Vacation of a plan of these requires approval by each of the applicable utility companies as of today

02:37:02.830 --> 02:37:07.910
The city has received a letter from Idaho power company and the rest of the applicable utilities

02:37:07.910 --> 02:37:12.350
with the auto power company states they agreed to the vacation of the public

02:37:12.350 --> 02:37:16.210
utility easement on the western boundary subject to retaining their Idaho power

02:37:16.210 --> 02:37:20.910
easement on the south. There was no mention of the southern utility easement

02:37:20.910 --> 02:37:24.150
previously. We have not received any other utility

02:37:24.150 --> 02:37:27.350
letters from the applicable utility companies stating their approval. We are

02:37:27.350 --> 02:37:39.730
told that they are coming. We received this letter I believe it stated on August

02:37:39.730 --> 02:37:47.290
29th from Idaho Power. This letter states that there are two separate utilities. One is the

02:37:47.290 --> 02:37:57.330
platted utility. And another one is instrument number 641723 recorded October 27th, 1972. In

02:37:57.330 --> 02:38:05.560
the letter it states that this easement would not be released by Idaho Power. Where this easement

02:38:05.560 --> 02:38:09.880
technically is I'm not certain. It needs to be surveyed as the up kind of stated.

02:38:09.880 --> 02:38:15.720
However, Idaho Power is in support of vacating the public utility easement, although they're

02:38:15.720 --> 02:38:23.720
not in support of vacating their private personal easement, which means we need both of those

02:38:23.720 --> 02:38:30.800
to actually have the billing permit released. So in conclusion, on August 12, 2014, the

02:38:30.800 --> 02:38:33.160
the Planning and Zoning Commission unanimously

02:38:33.160 --> 02:38:36.160
recommended approval of the vacation

02:38:36.160 --> 02:38:38.680
as presented subject to the following conditions.

02:38:38.680 --> 02:38:40.880
One subject to the site plan amendments as required

02:38:40.880 --> 02:38:43.000
by building engineering, fire and zoning officials

02:38:43.000 --> 02:38:46.040
to ensure compliance with applicable city code requirements

02:38:46.040 --> 02:38:48.200
and standards and two subject to letters

02:38:48.200 --> 02:38:50.520
from each of the utility companies granting approval

02:38:50.520 --> 02:38:53.040
of the easements and including in requirements.

02:38:54.810 --> 02:38:56.290
Each may require being submitted

02:38:56.290 --> 02:39:00.410
to the city prior to recordation of the vacation ordinance.

02:39:00.410 --> 02:39:03.610
Should the council recommend approval of this request as presented?

02:39:03.610 --> 02:39:07.650
Staff recommends approval be subject to the recommended conditions from the commission.

02:39:07.650 --> 02:39:12.810
This is a recommendation to the county board of commissioners since this is in the area of impact.

02:39:12.810 --> 02:39:15.830
Thank you, Jonathan.

02:39:15.830 --> 02:39:22.270
Any questions for either the applicant or Suzanne Hawkins?

02:39:22.270 --> 02:39:23.430
Okay, sorry.

02:39:23.430 --> 02:39:27.430
I might be a little slow tonight, but I'm going to ask.

02:39:27.430 --> 02:39:30.950
So there was mention of a letter from the Canal Company

02:39:30.950 --> 02:39:35.740
that we have not seen in our packet yet.

02:39:35.740 --> 02:39:36.700
We haven't got that.

02:39:36.700 --> 02:39:39.340
And then do we know which telephone company

02:39:39.340 --> 02:39:40.900
and have we heard from them?

02:39:40.900 --> 02:39:42.540
I believe it's CenturyLink.

02:39:42.540 --> 02:39:43.040
OK.

02:39:42.980 --> 02:39:44.500
I haven't seen the letters myself.

02:39:44.500 --> 02:39:47.000
I think they are.

02:39:47.000 --> 02:39:47.760
OK.

02:39:47.760 --> 02:39:51.120
With those two pieces of the puzzle missing,

02:39:51.120 --> 02:39:55.320
and now the possibility of needing a survey in Idaho Power,

02:39:55.320 --> 02:39:58.200
kind of going backwards on one, I almost

02:39:58.200 --> 02:40:06.360
But like we're addressing this prematurely that we're not really in a place to grant this until we have all that information.

02:40:06.360 --> 02:40:14.610
Mr. Mayor, members of the council, you would be able to grant it subject to conditions.

02:40:14.610 --> 02:40:24.730
And so it would be conditions and those approvals would be upon acceptance by the different utility companies to continue the process to be able to move forward.

02:40:24.730 --> 02:40:25.730
Thank you.

02:40:25.730 --> 02:40:33.030
If we did do that, would it move on to the county commission prior to those letters?

02:40:33.030 --> 02:40:39.390
Because I don't feel really good about sending something to the commission that they're going to have to wonder about too.

02:40:41.260 --> 02:40:45.720
You could make that as part of your motion is that you could recommend

02:40:45.720 --> 02:40:51.540
to approval to the county commissioners upon receipt of the required documentation.

02:40:51.540 --> 02:41:01.840
Personally, I would feel better about that, because I don't want to send something to the county where they have the same questions that we do.

02:41:01.840 --> 02:41:03.480
Sean Berger.

02:41:03.480 --> 02:41:12.240
So this letter here is talking about, I know power saying yes, the public utilities were fine.

02:41:12.240 --> 02:41:21.080
So you mentioned, are they talking about sort of modifying this private easement that they have that would, okay.

02:41:21.080 --> 02:41:23.640
Ma'am, could you go to the microphone?

02:41:23.640 --> 02:41:26.320
And the only reason we ask you to do that, folks are listening at home.

02:41:26.320 --> 02:41:32.140
It took us about a week to find the property pens that were under old fence posts located

02:41:32.140 --> 02:41:37.520
and so those were just finished up yesterday and so now we're just waiting for the survey

02:41:37.520 --> 02:41:45.400
or to come out and then resubmit to Idaho Power that that would be the easement but we have

02:41:45.400 --> 02:41:52.380
to have the exact property pens and so that's it's just been a long process and I think

02:41:52.380 --> 02:41:56.300
because what they agree to is that that would be

02:41:56.300 --> 02:42:01.300
resurveyed and then we would resubmit for the easement.

02:42:01.540 --> 02:42:03.820
There's no physical possible way for them

02:42:03.820 --> 02:42:05.980
to vacate the South easement.

02:42:05.980 --> 02:42:07.700
They have utilities there.

02:42:07.700 --> 02:42:10.060
I mean, I know planning and zoning

02:42:10.060 --> 02:42:13.660
or the building department requested that,

02:42:13.660 --> 02:42:17.140
but we can't really, they're not going to vacate that.

02:42:17.140 --> 02:42:19.460
So we just need to modify the easement.

02:42:19.460 --> 02:42:36.460
We would like to redo this, I'd hate to tear down a functional building instead of just adding to it, you know, I think it's been there for 42 years and no one's ever, ever come to service that telephone pole in the 11 years I've been there.

02:42:36.460 --> 02:42:47.460
They have access to the telephone pole through gravel and a driveway and I have, we would want them to service that utility pole because it services our home.

02:42:47.460 --> 02:42:49.880
So we would like to work with them on that

02:42:51.680 --> 02:42:55.500
Like I said, I'd hate to tear it down spend there for 42 years and

02:42:56.640 --> 02:43:00.200
Hasn't seemed to bother anyone. I don't know about the easements

02:43:01.420 --> 02:43:04.880
We were very innocent and understanding that it was built on that

02:43:04.880 --> 02:43:09.800
so it is dilapidated in the front and the roof needs to be redone and

02:43:10.760 --> 02:43:14.620
It needs modification just because it is 42 years old

02:43:15.200 --> 02:43:17.040
So thank you

02:43:17.040 --> 02:43:23.840
We're talking to ma'am. I would like to follow up with the question. You've been the property about 11 years correct

02:43:24.240 --> 02:43:31.520
Wasn't that noted upon the title search when you purchased the property? There was nothing attached to that

02:43:32.400 --> 02:43:34.400
It was not huh?

02:43:34.400 --> 02:43:40.420
In fact, these applications were turned into May. I'm not exactly sure exactly

02:43:41.160 --> 02:43:42.840
the date in May

02:43:42.840 --> 02:43:44.800
but we

02:43:44.800 --> 02:43:52.720
Going through the building department, I went back three separate times to get the cracked application for them and

02:43:53.640 --> 02:43:55.560
talking to

02:43:55.560 --> 02:44:01.320
Renee my understanding is this is a unique case and I think I can clarify with Jonathan that

02:44:02.120 --> 02:44:07.160
Everyone was quite confused. I literally filled out three separate applications

02:44:07.360 --> 02:44:14.440
It was three weeks later that I was notified it was on an easement and then it was at least a month later

02:44:14.800 --> 02:44:18.200
that we were notified the South House so had an easement.

02:44:18.200 --> 02:44:21.100
So I'd have a question of you.

02:44:21.100 --> 02:44:23.340
How would that show up on the city's records

02:44:23.340 --> 02:44:29.500
and not a title search?

02:44:29.500 --> 02:44:32.900
Title search would just show whether there were any clouds

02:44:32.900 --> 02:44:36.100
or any impediments on the title itself.

02:44:36.100 --> 02:44:38.700
They would have had to have had a survey

02:44:38.700 --> 02:44:41.780
overlaid over the top of it to show where the easements were

02:44:41.780 --> 02:44:43.740
in relation to the buildings for them

02:44:43.740 --> 02:44:45.980
to have known that when they purchased the property.

02:44:45.980 --> 02:44:50.260
The second part of your question was, oh,

02:44:50.260 --> 02:44:58.260
when this goes to planning and zoning, they immediately go to their GIS and they see the Eastman's like right over the top of it.

02:44:58.260 --> 02:45:04.830
That's fun to do to know. Anything, any further questions Council?

02:45:04.830 --> 02:45:12.620
I think this is time to open up a public hearing for item number two and I'm not sure,

02:45:12.620 --> 02:45:17.620
it says property line. I'm going to go with it. I think it's other issues.

02:45:17.620 --> 02:45:21.620
Jordan Baird, are you here for this item?

02:45:21.620 --> 02:45:25.910
Yes, and same with Nate Stinson.

02:45:25.910 --> 02:45:29.910
I want to make sure I ask because it says property line.

02:45:29.910 --> 02:45:36.700
Is there anyone here to testify regarding this item?

02:45:36.700 --> 02:45:40.700
I will close the public hearing portion of this

02:45:40.700 --> 02:45:44.700
and turn it over to council for any further questions.

02:45:44.700 --> 02:45:48.700
There was no vuddle because there was no

02:45:48.700 --> 02:45:51.220
And before we go to any kind of emotion,

02:45:51.220 --> 02:45:55.480
I'll go ahead and close the full public hearing.

02:45:55.480 --> 02:45:56.960
Did you want to make another comment?

02:45:56.960 --> 02:45:59.360
You certainly can, ma'am.

02:45:59.360 --> 02:46:01.720
I just wanted to say to the city council,

02:46:01.720 --> 02:46:03.200
I appreciate your time,

02:46:03.200 --> 02:46:06.320
and I really appreciate Jonathan or Renee's help and support

02:46:06.320 --> 02:46:10.240
because it's been untangling a horrible mess.

02:46:10.240 --> 02:46:11.080
Renee said today,

02:46:11.080 --> 02:46:15.000
it's one of the most difficult things she's ever come across.

02:46:15.000 --> 02:46:16.480
I want to thank them for their time,

02:46:16.480 --> 02:46:21.480
but I wanted to bring up that just for the city council,

02:46:22.560 --> 02:46:25.200
I don't know, I don't think it was that long ago

02:46:25.200 --> 02:46:28.020
that we were added to the area of impact.

02:46:28.020 --> 02:46:31.000
I think it's since I purchased this property.

02:46:31.000 --> 02:46:34.920
And there are times we are an island

02:46:34.920 --> 02:46:39.000
in the middle of a higher density population.

02:46:39.000 --> 02:46:41.880
And this area that he showed on the map

02:46:41.880 --> 02:46:51.820
has all kinds of animals, livestock, I have 1,000 head of cattle right behind my property

02:46:51.820 --> 02:46:59.780
line on the west and on the other side. And just knowing I'm in the area of impact, sometimes

02:46:59.780 --> 02:47:04.180
I feel like complicate some of the things we're doing, whether the garage or the barn needs

02:47:04.180 --> 02:47:10.220
to be bigger. We have tractors and plows and things like that that we need to take care

02:47:10.220 --> 02:47:18.980
of our land and we do not always fit within the recommendations of the city because we are

02:47:18.980 --> 02:47:20.900
in acreages.

02:47:20.900 --> 02:47:24.540
And so I would just, I know the law is the law.

02:47:24.540 --> 02:47:28.740
I can't change that it was there for 42 years.

02:47:28.740 --> 02:47:31.580
The man who built it has passed away.

02:47:31.580 --> 02:47:33.740
But I do appreciate you doing it.

02:47:33.740 --> 02:47:39.300
I do know I'm the law abiding citizen and we're, Idaho power, we've been working with

02:47:39.300 --> 02:47:43.840
them for over three months to even get this first letter.

02:47:43.840 --> 02:47:52.880
We've had to pay over $2,000 in the process of this and hoping we can speed it up.

02:47:52.880 --> 02:47:54.040
The letters are coming.

02:47:54.040 --> 02:47:57.160
I thought you did have the canal company.

02:47:57.160 --> 02:48:00.680
We have all of them except Idaho Power.

02:48:00.680 --> 02:48:01.680
Okay.

02:48:01.680 --> 02:48:06.200
I got the, I had the feeling that all letters were received except for Idaho Power, which

02:48:06.200 --> 02:48:07.760
we are waiting for this survey.

02:48:07.760 --> 02:48:09.720
So that's all I had to say.

02:48:09.720 --> 02:48:13.620
clarification for it's good you tell it when was do you know when this error was

02:48:13.620 --> 02:48:21.700
put in the area of impact and the issues that we're dealing with tonight on this

02:48:21.700 --> 02:48:25.380
have nothing to do with the area of impact it's just all utility easements and

02:48:25.380 --> 02:48:28.340
those kind of things certainly appreciate what you're saying that can

02:48:28.340 --> 02:48:33.540
complicate it being on the that area Travis did you want to weigh in I was

02:48:33.540 --> 02:48:38.300
just going to clarify for it to chair with me that was 1981 when that was

02:48:38.300 --> 02:48:40.100
to incorporate into the area of impact.

02:48:40.100 --> 02:48:43.060
Okay, very good, 81.

02:48:43.060 --> 02:48:43.900
Greg Lanning?

02:48:43.900 --> 02:48:44.900
Well, I was gonna write a motion.

02:48:44.900 --> 02:48:48.260
Okay, we will close all public testimony and questions

02:48:48.260 --> 02:48:50.140
and turn it over to council for deliberation

02:48:50.140 --> 02:48:50.980
on a motion.

02:48:50.980 --> 02:48:51.820
Greg Lanning?

02:48:51.820 --> 02:48:56.820
I would like to move that we vacate the two plated ditch

02:48:56.900 --> 02:49:02.480
and utility easements on the 15 by 465.3

02:49:03.240 --> 02:49:08.720
and the 15 by 265.3 with the,

02:49:08.720 --> 02:49:15.720
the conditions placed by the Planning and Zoning Commission and also that the resolution

02:49:15.720 --> 02:49:22.720
is reached without a power concerning the power pole on their private vacation.

02:49:22.720 --> 02:49:26.720
Private easement and Fritz is going to tell me that this did some long zones.

02:49:26.720 --> 02:49:28.720
You just need to remember this is in the area of impact.

02:49:28.720 --> 02:49:31.720
The county has the final say so this is a recommendation.

02:49:31.720 --> 02:49:33.720
Recommendation, correct. Thank you Fritz.

02:49:33.720 --> 02:49:34.720
Second that.

02:49:34.720 --> 02:49:38.260
Have most on for by Greg lying seconded by Chris talking 10 as

02:49:39.160 --> 02:49:41.160
Stated I'm like I try to repeat that

02:49:41.640 --> 02:49:48.320
The only concern that I have is I don't really want this going to the county Commission with a recommendation and tell those items are

02:49:49.200 --> 02:49:52.820
addressed and I would I would add that to my motion and we would not that

02:49:53.400 --> 02:49:59.920
Recordation will not be forward on the county although. I think we may have found the two letters. They're here. Okay. Well, let's

02:49:59.920 --> 02:50:05.580
We have letters from CenturyLink, Twin Falls Company, and Netlide Ho Power.

02:50:05.580 --> 02:50:07.660
We're missing Intermountain Gas, K1.

02:50:07.660 --> 02:50:08.580
So we still have some.

02:50:08.580 --> 02:50:16.100
Okay, all vacation letters, for all utilities have submitted letters with their approvals.

02:50:16.100 --> 02:50:18.300
Second, agree with that?

02:50:18.300 --> 02:50:23.160
Yes, we have a motion on the floor by Chris, excuse me, Greg Lanning, seconded by Chris

02:50:23.160 --> 02:50:24.160
Tottenham.

02:50:24.160 --> 02:50:27.380
Do we have anything further on that motion council?

02:50:27.380 --> 02:50:30.240
Leanna, roll call vote please.

02:50:30.240 --> 02:50:31.240
Yes.

02:50:31.240 --> 02:50:32.240
Great.

02:50:32.240 --> 02:50:33.240
Yes.

02:50:33.240 --> 02:50:34.240
Don Hall.

02:50:34.240 --> 02:50:35.240
Yes.

02:50:35.240 --> 02:50:36.240
Rebecca Milsoyka.

02:50:36.240 --> 02:50:37.240
Yes.

02:50:37.240 --> 02:50:38.780
Suzanne.

02:50:38.780 --> 02:50:40.040
Yes.

02:50:40.040 --> 02:50:41.040
Hawkins.

02:50:41.040 --> 02:50:42.040
Jim.

02:50:42.040 --> 02:50:43.040
Yes.

02:50:43.040 --> 02:50:44.040
Yes.

02:50:44.040 --> 02:50:45.040
Yes.

02:50:45.040 --> 02:50:47.040
Motion passes seven to zero.

02:50:47.040 --> 02:50:49.040
I think it's getting late.

02:50:49.040 --> 02:50:52.040
Next item on the agenda is another public hearing.

02:50:52.040 --> 02:50:55.040
It's a request for an amendment to the Twin Falls Vision 2030.

02:50:55.040 --> 02:51:09.040
at comprehensive plan to expand and clarify the depth of the commercial slash retail corridor along the north side of the portion of a portion of Kimberly Road and to amend the water service boundary area to include

02:51:09.040 --> 02:51:17.040
that portion of Kimberly Road being proposed with this amendment for property within the city's area of impact.

02:51:17.040 --> 02:51:22.040
We had Brad Wills as the applicant and welcome, Brad.

02:51:22.640 --> 02:51:23.800
Thank you, Brad Wills.

02:51:23.800 --> 02:51:27.000
Two, two, two, two, show and street where Twin Falls

02:51:27.000 --> 02:51:36.370
told my wife we'd be home by seven, so.

02:51:36.370 --> 02:51:38.610
I'm sorry no better than that, don't I?

02:51:38.610 --> 02:51:41.210
I don't know if I tell our wives that every week.

02:51:41.210 --> 02:51:42.770
I quit saying that years ago.

02:51:44.580 --> 02:51:49.230
So, if you'll remember back last summer,

02:51:49.230 --> 02:51:51.070
about a year ago this time,

02:51:51.070 --> 02:51:53.270
a group of us got together named ourselves

02:51:53.270 --> 02:52:00.860
Twin Falls futures to look at where Twin Falls is going to grow, help the city look at their

02:52:00.860 --> 02:52:07.260
long-term plans and see as a community if we can help in any way. So that's what we did. And so

02:52:07.260 --> 02:52:14.620
we looked at different areas of Twin and I did a presentation of the City of Twin. So one of the

02:52:14.620 --> 02:52:42.150
areas that we looked at, so the area that we looked at was this area around here which this is

02:52:42.150 --> 02:52:47.750
Chibani right here in Cliff bars, and so this is the line between the city of

02:52:47.750 --> 02:52:55.260
Kimberly's area of impact and Twin Falls area of impact. So we we looked at

02:52:55.260 --> 02:52:59.680
long-term plan we think to and eventually grow to the west but in the

02:52:59.680 --> 02:53:05.560
time being we need to look at what lands available. So in the same way that we

02:53:05.560 --> 02:53:26.720
had an area here. St. Luke's is right here and so when we developed in 2003-2004

02:53:26.720 --> 02:53:33.480
Fieldstone Subdivision St. Luke's was not on the map. So at that time all the

02:53:33.480 --> 02:53:38.480
comp plans and everything were designed based on this area becoming a residential

02:53:38.480 --> 02:53:42.920
area where St. Luke's today was probably going to be residential but

02:53:42.920 --> 02:53:48.120
things change, and that's why I'm here today is that things have been changing.

02:53:48.120 --> 02:53:56.010
So we're looking at the 2009 Complan, and when that was done, Chabani was not even on the

02:53:56.010 --> 02:53:57.010
map.

02:53:57.010 --> 02:54:00.250
It was not on the radar anywhere.

02:54:00.250 --> 02:54:11.690
So the reason I'm here today is because we had another large event happen in Twin that

02:54:11.690 --> 02:54:15.090
affected what plans were made five years ago.

02:54:15.090 --> 02:54:18.610
So this is the Chabani complex.

02:54:18.610 --> 02:54:22.890
This is where the Jacob Center, which has been there for 20 years, that, I mean, that

02:54:22.890 --> 02:54:25.530
land's been there 20 years.

02:54:25.530 --> 02:54:29.810
So this is the area that we're talking about, and the area I'm talking about is this area

02:54:29.810 --> 02:54:32.670
right here.

02:54:32.670 --> 02:54:34.390
That's to the north.

02:54:34.390 --> 02:54:49.840
So it's to the north, I'm sorry.

02:54:49.840 --> 02:54:56.080
This is the first exhibit that I did, just to show that we have an overhead of this is

02:54:56.080 --> 02:55:01.120
Google Maps showing that this is the existing Complan C1 commercial zone.

02:55:01.120 --> 02:55:04.600
So this 66 acres is the area in question.

02:55:04.600 --> 02:55:21.980
This area already is zoned to R2 on the Complan and they're the stop line for the Chibanias right here.

02:55:21.980 --> 02:55:31.100
So again this is the same area and what we're doing is because when they do the Complan they don't put dimensions on it.

02:55:31.100 --> 02:55:36.020
If you scale looking at this being 1320 feet approximately,

02:55:36.020 --> 02:55:38.300
this is 660 feet.

02:55:38.300 --> 02:55:42.860
So what we're proposing right now is to expand this commercial

02:55:42.860 --> 02:55:48.780
corridor that's planned here to make this C1 on both sides.

02:55:48.780 --> 02:55:57.290
Sorry, make the depth the same on both sides.

02:55:57.290 --> 02:56:00.930
Right now the zoning map shows this blue lines

02:56:00.930 --> 02:56:04.330
and overlay of what is now C1 on the zoning plan,

02:56:04.330 --> 02:56:08.570
where the comp plan is the plan that basically trumps it,

02:56:08.570 --> 02:56:11.210
but if they match, then great,

02:56:11.210 --> 02:56:15.370
but if the zoning doesn't match the comp plan,

02:56:15.370 --> 02:56:17.530
then that's why I'm here today.

02:56:17.530 --> 02:56:19.170
And the other part of this,

02:56:19.170 --> 02:56:22.380
I'll explain a little bit later, is the water boundary.

02:56:22.380 --> 02:56:25.420
So you can see that right now on the zoning map,

02:56:25.420 --> 02:56:27.220
the C1 actually went up here.

02:56:27.220 --> 02:56:35.550
This is where twin stops is.

02:56:35.550 --> 02:56:37.950
And the other part of this is the water boundary.

02:56:37.950 --> 02:56:40.030
Right now the water boundary goes here,

02:56:40.030 --> 02:56:43.470
And we're asking to expand that water boundary.

02:56:43.470 --> 02:56:46.950
And looking back, that's something that really hasn't been

02:56:46.950 --> 02:56:47.450
done.

02:56:47.250 --> 02:56:52.770
If you look at the Complan in 2009, the language in there says

02:56:52.770 --> 02:56:57.430
we prohibit going outside this water boundary line is a

02:56:57.430 --> 02:57:06.410
recommendation.

02:57:06.410 --> 02:57:09.690
So this currently is the water boundary line.

02:57:09.690 --> 02:57:13.090
And if you look, this is the area that we're talking about.

02:57:13.090 --> 02:57:20.640
And you have a lot of area that we thought by this time when we were looking at 2009,

02:57:20.640 --> 02:57:22.560
we were really growing south of town.

02:57:22.560 --> 02:57:29.680
We thought we would be into this area, but right now we have a lot of water boundary,

02:57:29.680 --> 02:57:32.400
and this is where the growth is happening now.

02:57:32.400 --> 02:57:36.520
The school district is expanding here.

02:57:36.520 --> 02:57:47.570
Chabani came in, so that affected the water boundary.

02:57:47.570 --> 02:57:52.370
I think the best thing that I have now is that I didn't have this when I went to

02:57:52.370 --> 02:58:00.290
Plantian Zoning on the water boundary but on August 18th when the city did the

02:58:00.290 --> 02:58:09.390
water tank presentation that says the water storage tank will also provide water

02:58:09.390 --> 02:58:14.710
for the additional growth on the southeast side of town. To me that that

02:58:14.710 --> 02:58:21.000
That gives me hope that you will now consider expanding that water boundary both for this

02:58:21.000 --> 02:58:26.680
and I'll be back again asking on the school district too that now we've kind of broken

02:58:26.680 --> 02:58:28.720
past the Hankins line.

02:58:28.720 --> 02:58:35.240
We're a little premature, the water's not there yet, but there'll be a lot more steps

02:58:35.240 --> 02:58:48.250
to come before we would ever actually be asking for water service.

02:58:48.250 --> 02:58:54.750
So what I'm asking tonight is that we look at this area and allow the

02:58:54.750 --> 02:59:00.450
plan to change to a C-1 and also to expand the water boundary to this point here.

02:59:00.450 --> 02:59:03.710
I think this is where Twin's growing.

02:59:03.710 --> 02:59:04.870
Our group looked at it.

02:59:04.870 --> 02:59:09.550
This is our recommendation to you as a city council looking at further growth.

02:59:09.550 --> 02:59:13.350
It's not uncommon to have C-1 up against future residential.

02:59:13.350 --> 02:59:17.140
I have my Philstone subdivision.

02:59:17.140 --> 02:59:21.980
And I had that after St. Luke's game there, then we ended up getting C1 to the north of

02:59:21.980 --> 02:59:28.340
us in different areas that it's not uncommon to have C1 in R2 or whatever it is next to

02:59:28.340 --> 02:59:29.340
each other.

02:59:29.340 --> 02:59:31.700
So that's not how the ordinary to ask.

02:59:31.700 --> 02:59:34.820
So I think tonight that's a reasonable request.

02:59:34.820 --> 02:59:42.100
I think that this planning zoning unfortunately didn't grasp the bigger picture here and I'm

02:59:42.100 --> 02:59:44.340
going to ask you guys to grasp it.

02:59:44.340 --> 02:59:46.690
I'll be available for any questions.

02:59:46.690 --> 02:59:52.110
Thank you, Brad. It looks like we have at least one question. We will have a staff report as well for Council's

02:59:52.990 --> 03:00:00.390
Edification, so just talking. Oh, that's the city as well Brad, but if we did the manned or that changed that

03:00:00.830 --> 03:00:04.470
water service area that you're understanding that would be

03:00:05.510 --> 03:00:09.390
Gravity flow from the new water tank or would that have to be pumped?

03:00:10.110 --> 03:00:12.110
Is that uphill in other words?

03:00:12.110 --> 03:00:21.560
Correct me if I'm wrong, but this is where the new water tower is, approximate water tank.

03:00:21.560 --> 03:00:31.570
Sewer-wise in this area, the Chabani line goes down right here.

03:00:31.570 --> 03:00:41.240
Kim release comes down this line, but most likely if this area, when it does develop, most likely would connect somewhere in there.

03:00:41.240 --> 03:00:44.240
We'd be my guess, but that's way down the road.

03:00:44.240 --> 03:00:48.940
I'm not talking about wastewater, I'm talking about potable water.

03:00:48.940 --> 03:00:51.780
I'm sorry, the water tank is going in right here.

03:00:51.780 --> 03:00:54.200
The water line, I believe, goes here,

03:00:54.200 --> 03:00:55.740
so there would have to be a water line

03:00:55.740 --> 03:00:57.300
brought into this area.

03:00:57.300 --> 03:00:59.900
I'm asking though, that's a pump situation.

03:00:59.900 --> 03:01:02.500
It's not a gravity flow water.

03:01:02.500 --> 03:01:06.050
Travis, do you want to weigh in?

03:01:06.050 --> 03:01:09.330
So the water line would be pressure fed

03:01:09.330 --> 03:01:12.130
as opposed to a gravity fed system.

03:01:12.130 --> 03:01:17.130
What's important is when we've looked at putting in the tank

03:01:17.130 --> 03:01:24.490
tank at the new hank and site and the agenda item that Mr.

03:01:24.490 --> 03:01:26.810
Wells had presented.

03:01:26.810 --> 03:01:33.210
It did not include any booster, any pump station, but it's also important that I, and

03:01:33.210 --> 03:01:38.610
I just talked with Mitch, we haven't looked at extending services outside of the water

03:01:38.610 --> 03:01:41.010
service boundary either.

03:01:41.010 --> 03:01:45.610
So I can't tell you, and I don't believe that we have a member of our engineering staff

03:01:45.610 --> 03:01:54.500
available this evening with us to say if and what physical infrastructure requirements

03:01:54.500 --> 03:02:00.660
would be needed if any in addition to the tank to be able to service the area that is

03:02:00.660 --> 03:02:01.740
outlined in blue.

03:02:01.740 --> 03:02:04.710
We just as a staff can't answer that.

03:02:04.710 --> 03:02:11.350
Well it would appear to be logical for us to have that answer before we decided to extend

03:02:11.350 --> 03:02:12.350
our water boundary.

03:02:12.350 --> 03:02:18.660
if only not so much if we could or could not service because it looks like we

03:02:18.660 --> 03:02:29.200
could through hump system but to have a handle on the cost. I don't know how many

03:02:29.200 --> 03:02:35.160
acres we're talking about Brad on this. So we have this area of Twin Falls that

03:02:35.160 --> 03:02:41.880
currently cannot be serviced with your water and we have been looking for eight

03:02:41.880 --> 03:02:49.890
years to solve that problem, but that's a problem on development. I think it's going

03:02:49.890 --> 03:02:55.410
to change and maybe you're going to help along the way, but to service this area we need a

03:02:55.410 --> 03:03:03.010
million dollar line down 3600 in Harrison to service that area. That's on development.

03:03:03.010 --> 03:03:09.530
So this area is in the area of the water boundary, but development usually picks that

03:03:09.530 --> 03:03:14.990
cost up so if there was a pump required to service this area it would not be the

03:03:14.990 --> 03:03:22.050
city's responsibility would be the developers response that would be correct

03:03:22.050 --> 03:03:30.070
anything further Chris no do we have any further questions before we turn to the

03:03:30.070 --> 03:03:39.360
staff of their report stand close by Brad one more statement okay I forgot so

03:03:39.360 --> 03:03:44.680
we are affecting the neighborhood a little bit this is the residents of

03:03:44.680 --> 03:03:50.500
Dr. Cat and Raghetti and I did contact them before I went to planning zoning and

03:03:50.500 --> 03:03:54.780
visit and set up a meeting and went to them and explained what we were doing so

03:03:54.780 --> 03:04:02.260
that rather than just relying on the public notice so but that is the closest

03:04:02.260 --> 03:04:07.460
residents and we have some homes here and we have homes here so what were their

03:04:07.460 --> 03:04:09.860
response. Are they here?

03:04:09.860 --> 03:04:11.860
They're getting ready.

03:04:11.860 --> 03:04:13.860
We're getting ready?

03:04:13.860 --> 03:04:15.860
No, no.

03:04:15.860 --> 03:04:20.530
There's a lot of people here that are affected.

03:04:20.530 --> 03:04:21.530
Sure.

03:04:21.530 --> 03:04:23.530
I assume that because you're still here.

03:04:23.530 --> 03:04:27.370
I'm really hoping they're going for the other one.

03:04:27.370 --> 03:04:33.580
Go ahead and that's the secret and we'll turn it over to Jonathan.

03:04:33.580 --> 03:04:38.940
Thank you, Mr. Mayor, members of the Council on History, the current Twin Falls comprehensive

03:04:38.940 --> 03:04:41.620
The plan was adopted in February 2009.

03:04:41.620 --> 03:04:45.380
That was an entire redraft of the previous plan done in 1994.

03:04:45.380 --> 03:04:47.300
This request is two parts.

03:04:47.300 --> 03:04:49.140
I'm not going to read the entire staff report.

03:04:49.140 --> 03:04:51.940
I'm just going to explain the map a little bit.

03:04:51.940 --> 03:04:52.440
Two parts.

03:04:52.440 --> 03:04:55.500
One is to change this highlighted area.

03:04:55.500 --> 03:05:02.880
The Brad's already described, which is here.

03:05:02.880 --> 03:05:06.400
This area currently has an agricultural designation

03:05:06.400 --> 03:05:07.760
in the comprehensive plan map.

03:05:07.760 --> 03:05:08.720
That's what this map is.

03:05:08.720 --> 03:05:11.640
It's the future land use map from that plan.

03:05:11.640 --> 03:05:15.440
He wants to change that to a commercial retail designation

03:05:15.440 --> 03:05:19.520
identical somewhat to what's south of Kimberly Road,

03:05:19.520 --> 03:05:21.960
as far as the depth and the distance.

03:05:21.960 --> 03:05:23.600
So that's what he's looking at doing,

03:05:23.600 --> 03:05:28.140
is extending this boundary north, some feet, 700,

03:05:28.140 --> 03:05:32.580
some feet to equal 1,320 feet total from Kimberly Road

03:05:32.580 --> 03:05:35.220
to the north, which would be identical or somewhat similar

03:05:35.220 --> 03:05:38.380
to what's to the south, where Chobani is located.

03:05:38.380 --> 03:05:41.500
These are the future land use map designations

03:05:41.500 --> 03:05:42.860
for the surrounding areas.

03:05:42.860 --> 03:05:46.100
There's a small neighborhood which is rural residential.

03:05:46.100 --> 03:05:48.980
The medium density residential is up here

03:05:48.980 --> 03:05:50.460
to the northwest.

03:05:50.460 --> 03:05:53.260
Agricultural is immediately to the north,

03:05:53.260 --> 03:05:56.500
and this boundary line here is actually outside

03:05:56.500 --> 03:05:58.740
Twin Falls City Area of Impact.

03:05:58.740 --> 03:06:01.700
This is Champlain Road, so east side of Champlain Road

03:06:01.700 --> 03:06:04.100
up to, there's no address right here,

03:06:04.100 --> 03:06:06.180
but it kind of jogs over at this point.

03:06:06.180 --> 03:06:08.500
So there's a small subdivision outside

03:06:08.500 --> 03:06:10.260
of the Twin Falls area of impact,

03:06:10.260 --> 03:06:12.880
which is technically, I believe, in the Kimberley's area of impact.

03:06:12.880 --> 03:06:15.840
So those people are probably here as well.

03:06:15.840 --> 03:06:19.360
That's what the comprehensive plan, Landy's Map shows.

03:06:19.360 --> 03:06:28.760
Those are the changes that Brad is asking for.

03:06:28.760 --> 03:06:30.680
How it relates to current zoning.

03:06:30.680 --> 03:06:36.040
Now, this is what is actually zoned and determines the uses of the property today.

03:06:36.040 --> 03:06:40.680
Right now, the zones in this area, this is where the twin sub is, so that's C1.

03:06:40.680 --> 03:06:44.560
The rest of these properties all the way to Kimberley Road are currently R2 right here

03:06:44.560 --> 03:06:49.560
in this area, R1VAR in this area, that's the purple pink.

03:06:49.600 --> 03:06:51.920
R2 continues up into this area.

03:06:51.920 --> 03:06:55.240
Currently we have the M2 zone down here where Chobani is.

03:06:55.240 --> 03:06:56.800
So those are the current zoning areas,

03:06:56.800 --> 03:06:59.480
which means that these areas would then,

03:06:59.480 --> 03:07:02.800
if Brad's proposal goes through to change the comp plan,

03:07:02.800 --> 03:07:06.440
these areas would still have to be re-zoned

03:07:06.440 --> 03:07:11.040
to something else to have any sort of commercial

03:07:11.040 --> 03:07:12.040
development in them.

03:07:12.040 --> 03:07:17.320
right now they can only be residential or ag farmland because of their size or various

03:07:17.320 --> 03:07:18.320
things.

03:07:18.320 --> 03:07:23.940
So we're looking at a long term thing with a rezone that would have to be done for any

03:07:23.940 --> 03:07:25.580
type of development to occur.

03:07:25.580 --> 03:07:31.110
So I've explained most of the staff report.

03:07:31.110 --> 03:07:35.890
The point I want to make is a request to change from agricultural to retail commercial will

03:07:35.890 --> 03:07:40.990
be a dramatic shift in potential development for this area as I previously explained current

03:07:40.990 --> 03:07:41.990
zoning.

03:07:41.990 --> 03:07:48.930
The comprehensive plan has very different descriptive paragraphs for agricultural and commercial retail designations.

03:07:48.930 --> 03:07:51.590
Copies of these designations are in your packet.

03:07:51.590 --> 03:07:58.310
In brief, the agricultural designation was designed to preserve farm ground and direct development inward towards the corporate city limits.

03:07:58.310 --> 03:08:06.990
In this particular area, it was designed to direct development toward the major arterial roadway Highway 30 or Kimberly Road to the south.

03:08:06.990 --> 03:08:11.530
Commercial designation is designed to allow large-scale commercial retail, light industrial,

03:08:11.530 --> 03:08:13.510
office, park, and similar uses.

03:08:13.510 --> 03:08:17.410
This particular commercial retail designation area was placed along Kimberly Road with the

03:08:17.410 --> 03:08:21.370
attention to a loud development along that corridor to continue, as it has for a number

03:08:21.370 --> 03:08:22.370
of years.

03:08:22.370 --> 03:08:26.170
With the recent additions of Chabani and the future addition of Cliff Bar, this historically

03:08:26.170 --> 03:08:29.850
major thoroughfare will continue to develop as a major corridor for commercial industrial

03:08:29.850 --> 03:08:30.850
traffic.

03:08:30.850 --> 03:08:35.210
We believe that this corridor will continue into Kimberly's or even impact as we've seen

03:08:35.210 --> 03:08:40.470
other businesses crop up there. It is known that large tracts of available commercial property

03:08:40.470 --> 03:08:46.070
in these locations are limited due to recent major industrial projects attempting to conclusively

03:08:46.070 --> 03:08:50.590
predict the impact of changing the comprehensive plan and future land use map in this area from

03:08:50.590 --> 03:08:56.190
agricultural to commercial retail designations and expanding the water service boundary is very

03:08:56.190 --> 03:09:00.730
difficult task. It is safe to assume that the general area has become increasingly commercial

03:09:00.730 --> 03:09:05.050
nature along the corridor and that these changes will have ancillary effects in the form of

03:09:05.050 --> 03:09:11.170
secondary businesses associated with these new industrial users. In no way does changing

03:09:11.170 --> 03:09:15.930
the water service boundary guarantee the city services for these properties. That is not part

03:09:15.930 --> 03:09:19.930
of the service boundary. We do not guarantee services until plating and other development

03:09:19.930 --> 03:09:26.020
occurs. In conclusion on July 22, 2014 the Commission planning the zoning commission held a public

03:09:26.020 --> 03:09:29.280
hearing on the request. Three people spoke against the request stating

03:09:29.280 --> 03:09:33.000
commercial encroachment was not appropriate adjacent to existing farm

03:09:33.000 --> 03:09:37.900
ground. One person stated there is already a plan to have a public review of

03:09:37.900 --> 03:09:41.900
the comprehensive plan in the current proposed budget and it may be appropriate

03:09:41.900 --> 03:09:46.160
to review this item at that time. Upon conclusion of the public portion of

03:09:46.160 --> 03:09:49.240
the hearing and after deliberations, Commissioner Daracott made a motion to

03:09:49.240 --> 03:09:53.700
recommend approval of the request as presented to the City Council, Commissioner

03:09:53.700 --> 03:09:55.300
Wood seconded in the motion.

03:09:55.300 --> 03:09:57.480
Commissioners Wood's gray, Boyd, Reid, Higgly,

03:09:57.480 --> 03:09:58.880
and Tatum voted against the motion

03:09:58.880 --> 03:10:02.080
and commissioner Darrick have voted in favor of the motion.

03:10:02.080 --> 03:10:04.600
The motion is recommended for denial 6 to 1

03:10:04.600 --> 03:10:06.780
to the city council as presented.

03:10:06.780 --> 03:10:08.880
The council may recommend approval of this request,

03:10:08.880 --> 03:10:10.240
recommend changes to the request,

03:10:10.240 --> 03:10:12.720
or recommend denial of this request.

03:10:12.720 --> 03:10:15.760
As this property is in the area of impact,

03:10:15.760 --> 03:10:17.040
the recommendation of the council

03:10:17.040 --> 03:10:18.880
will then be forwarded to the Board of County Commissioners

03:10:18.880 --> 03:10:20.280
for a decision.

03:10:20.280 --> 03:10:22.000
That is all.

03:10:22.000 --> 03:10:24.620
Any questions for staff or the applicant again,

03:10:24.620 --> 03:10:29.310
before I turn it over to public input?

03:10:29.310 --> 03:10:30.310
Great landing.

03:10:30.310 --> 03:10:31.750
Just a quick question.

03:10:31.750 --> 03:10:38.140
Jonathan, property taxes, that land is changed.

03:10:38.140 --> 03:10:40.700
The designation is changed on a complaint.

03:10:40.700 --> 03:10:43.780
Probably doesn't change property taxes until at some point,

03:10:43.780 --> 03:10:46.540
whether it is rezoned or re-platted.

03:10:46.540 --> 03:10:51.740
It's actually the assessed use of the property

03:10:51.740 --> 03:10:54.140
is typically the yardstick and measure

03:10:54.140 --> 03:11:00.260
for moving forward. We have residential areas right now that are active and

03:11:00.260 --> 03:11:04.220
productive farm grant that receive agricultural exemptions and they're allowed

03:11:04.220 --> 03:11:13.500
to operate as such. And then my second one would be Mayor Hall, would be since we

03:11:13.500 --> 03:11:20.220
would be now including what is already a residential area into our water

03:11:20.220 --> 03:11:26.350
potentially into our water service area, would that mean once we get our tank and

03:11:26.350 --> 03:11:30.470
we're already to go that they could potentially add on to our system if they

03:11:30.470 --> 03:11:35.750
chose or would that have how does that work? That wouldn't be determined at the

03:11:35.750 --> 03:11:39.190
time of development. I believe the plating process would still have to take place.

03:11:39.190 --> 03:11:43.440
Well I'm talking about the existing one that's already there. Right there yeah.

03:11:43.440 --> 03:11:56.180
It's already planted the whole thing. We'd have to annex them probably too right before

03:11:56.180 --> 03:11:57.980
or they'll be able to eligible.

03:11:57.980 --> 03:11:59.180
Mitch is going to handle that one.

03:11:59.180 --> 03:12:02.350
All right.

03:12:02.350 --> 03:12:03.870
So yeah, if it's in the service plan,

03:12:03.870 --> 03:12:06.750
we could then talk to them about adding city services

03:12:06.750 --> 03:12:07.950
to that area.

03:12:07.950 --> 03:12:11.830
We would annex the property to get them inside the city limits.

03:12:11.830 --> 03:12:15.550
And they would need to put in the infrastructure

03:12:15.550 --> 03:12:17.270
to get the water in there.

03:12:17.270 --> 03:12:19.230
But yeah, we could certainly start those conversations

03:12:19.230 --> 03:12:20.750
with those residential properties.

03:12:20.750 --> 03:12:21.270
All right.

03:12:21.270 --> 03:12:22.390
Thank you.

03:12:22.390 --> 03:12:26.150
Any other questions for staff or staff?

03:12:26.150 --> 03:12:32.710
I'm going to turn over or open up the public testimony portion up to this evening's hearing.

03:12:32.710 --> 03:12:43.170
And it would appear to me the first person is Mike Thompson is Mike here.

03:12:43.170 --> 03:12:46.170
You didn't know you were going to be the first out of the shoot did you Mike?

03:12:46.170 --> 03:12:51.130
Welcome sir, and when you come up to the podium, if you state your name again and your address,

03:12:51.130 --> 03:12:52.850
just for the record that'd be great.

03:12:52.850 --> 03:12:58.840
You have two minutes and you will see the 32nd marks sir.

03:12:58.840 --> 03:13:04.440
Mike Thompson, thank you, Mayor and Council.

03:13:04.440 --> 03:13:06.360
I live in the Prairie Ridge subdivision

03:13:06.360 --> 03:13:08.640
just across the line.

03:13:08.640 --> 03:13:13.640
Question I have is, is the property that is being proposed,

03:13:13.640 --> 03:13:17.200
do we already have purchasers for that property

03:13:17.200 --> 03:13:22.640
to have the light industrial or the commercial properties come in

03:13:22.640 --> 03:13:29.420
and come in and do their businesses there?

03:13:29.420 --> 03:13:35.210
And if we do, what impact is I can have on us?

03:13:35.210 --> 03:13:37.530
What we generally do, folks, if you do have questions,

03:13:37.530 --> 03:13:40.410
we'll take all the questions and I'd ask staff to help me

03:13:40.410 --> 03:13:42.370
make sure that I keep track of those

03:13:42.370 --> 03:13:44.810
and then we'll answer the question afterwards.

03:13:44.810 --> 03:13:52.650
Thank you, sir.

03:13:52.650 --> 03:13:55.410
Next person on the list that I have is,

03:13:55.410 --> 03:14:00.960
I believe it's Paul, Vena, Vetus.

03:14:00.960 --> 03:14:02.760
Welcome, Paul.

03:14:02.760 --> 03:14:06.040
Hello, I kind of come a little unprepared, I think,

03:14:06.040 --> 03:14:11.450
because we were notified of this, just this morning.

03:14:12.410 --> 03:14:13.250
But.

03:14:13.250 --> 03:14:14.570
[Muted for privacy: home address]

03:14:14.570 --> 03:14:17.330
[Muted for privacy: home address]

03:14:17.330 --> 03:14:20.930
[Muted for privacy: home address]

03:14:20.930 --> 03:14:22.650
[Muted for privacy: home address]

03:14:22.650 --> 03:14:24.970
Could you show us where Prairie Ridge is real quick

03:14:24.970 --> 03:14:26.890
so that we have a concept of that?

03:14:26.890 --> 03:14:28.250
Okay, over in that area.

03:14:28.250 --> 03:14:29.570
Thank you, sir.

03:14:29.570 --> 03:14:32.650
And I guess my only concern,

03:14:32.650 --> 03:14:35.250
or one of my concerns would be the traffic.

03:14:35.250 --> 03:14:40.330
We've noticed with Chibani's over there, right now, the 3300

03:14:40.330 --> 03:14:46.690
growth seems to be a fair highway right through there

03:14:46.690 --> 03:14:52.650
with all the trucks and with the additional zoning

03:14:52.650 --> 03:14:55.410
that's proposed there, I would be a little concerned

03:14:55.410 --> 03:14:57.490
with the traffic through there.

03:14:57.490 --> 03:15:01.770
So again, I apologize because I'm a little unprepared

03:15:01.770 --> 03:15:06.770
in terms of, you know, had I known a little bit more about this,

03:15:06.770 --> 03:15:08.970
I would have probably been a little bit more prepared today.

03:15:08.970 --> 03:15:11.490
So that's all I have to say.

03:15:11.490 --> 03:15:13.290
Well, your testimony is important, Paul.

03:15:13.290 --> 03:15:15.860
Thank you for bringing it to us.

03:15:15.860 --> 03:15:18.720
Next person is Climes.

03:15:18.720 --> 03:15:21.100
I can't.

03:15:21.100 --> 03:15:21.940
Did they?

03:15:21.940 --> 03:15:22.940
Did they?

03:15:22.940 --> 03:15:24.930
Welcome.

03:15:24.930 --> 03:15:29.850
Mr. Mayor, Council people, thank you for hearing us today.

03:15:29.850 --> 03:15:34.130
I too, I'm at 3307 Prairie Ridge Lane.

03:15:34.650 --> 03:15:42.290
in the Prairie Bridge subdivision that is to the east of the subject property and I

03:15:42.850 --> 03:15:44.850
guess my

03:15:45.450 --> 03:15:47.450
My request of the council would be

03:15:47.930 --> 03:15:53.050
Not to extend the boundary. We already have 600 feet

03:15:54.950 --> 03:15:56.950
That you know could be

03:15:57.930 --> 03:15:59.930
the light industrial

03:16:00.330 --> 03:16:02.330
Retail etc

03:16:02.330 --> 03:16:10.930
I'm very for, you know, expansion and business and growth in the community, but I don't want

03:16:10.930 --> 03:16:13.390
it to all be in my backyard.

03:16:13.390 --> 03:16:21.110
So, you know, we have Chibani, and Chibani has, in my opinion, been a pretty good neighbor.

03:16:21.110 --> 03:16:26.750
It's not real pretty to look at, which is what I look at on my back door, but they are

03:16:26.750 --> 03:16:34.670
not noisy or you know but I would be concerned that we would be so lucky going

03:16:34.670 --> 03:16:43.110
forward and I think that the 600 feet that is currently platted or zoned that

03:16:43.110 --> 03:16:58.140
way is close enough. Thank you. Thank you. Jessica Randall. Welcome Jessica.

03:16:58.140 --> 03:17:08.240
But yeah, I am 33% asked when to circle, which is just north of where they are.

03:17:08.240 --> 03:17:10.240
And yeah, we were also just notified today.

03:17:10.240 --> 03:17:12.240
I don't know if we were supposed to receive a letter.

03:17:12.240 --> 03:17:18.240
I don't know if we fall within that 300 feet or what, but yeah, we were just notified.

03:17:18.240 --> 03:17:21.240
Of course, we're all concerned about our property values.

03:17:21.240 --> 03:17:28.240
When we chose that neighborhood, it's partly because of the property value, but also because it was just, you know, when we chose to build our dream home there.

03:17:28.240 --> 03:17:34.280
there was because we had a dream kind of living out towards the country, you know.

03:17:34.280 --> 03:17:37.800
And we of course know that that's not guaranteed that nothing's going to change.

03:17:37.800 --> 03:17:46.680
But of course, I have an opinion that it should be the way it was originally attended.

03:17:46.680 --> 03:17:47.680
Thank you.

03:17:47.680 --> 03:17:53.360
Real quick question, Mitch, for our staff member, are these properties should they have been

03:17:53.360 --> 03:17:56.280
notified on this, Travis?

03:17:56.280 --> 03:18:04.480
We were just asking the same question, and it's our understanding that the 300-foot rule that governs this

03:18:04.480 --> 03:18:12.280
would touch the southeast property boundary, according to what John had been saying.

03:18:12.280 --> 03:18:16.040
So it would be right there.

03:18:16.040 --> 03:18:24.720
It would be basically 300-foot circumference around the proposed zoning change is what I understand the rule to be.

03:18:24.720 --> 03:18:29.550
side note we're in the middle of the public hearing but I thought we were going to

03:18:29.550 --> 03:18:36.030
try to extend that on these big projects to make sure that we try to cover more

03:18:36.030 --> 03:18:42.150
folks that need to know I thought we were going to do this this is pretty big

03:18:42.150 --> 03:18:47.190
deal so and can I add to that sure sure at the last planning and zoning work

03:18:47.190 --> 03:18:51.390
session they actually requested staff to start working on that because I agree

03:18:51.390 --> 03:18:54.850
out it was actually kind of a result of the first public hearing and planning and

03:18:54.850 --> 03:18:59.850
zoning where this is a huge impact to a lot of neighbors, even neighbors in another city.

03:18:59.850 --> 03:19:03.850
So I believe staff is working on that now, but it's a good point.

03:19:03.850 --> 03:19:05.850
I agree. Thank you for sharing that.

03:19:05.850 --> 03:19:08.850
Probably complicated. It's actually a different area of impact.

03:19:08.850 --> 03:19:13.850
Different city even. Right. It does complicate things.

03:19:13.850 --> 03:19:17.490
You had your shot.

03:19:17.490 --> 03:19:27.600
Jason Stevens, if it's truly not covered, let me know at the end.

03:19:27.600 --> 03:19:33.040
a little option because you didn't take your full two minutes. Okay. Sir. Mr. Mayor, Council

03:19:33.040 --> 03:19:39.080
members, thanks for letting me speak. My name is Jason Stevens. I'm on 3303 Prairie Ridge.

03:19:39.080 --> 03:19:46.000
I'm right next to Denae that just spoke. I think Mike, one of my neighbors had kind

03:19:46.000 --> 03:19:51.080
of already answered one of the questions that I had, but I probably wouldn't sleep tonight

03:19:51.080 --> 03:19:58.800
if I didn't speak. One of my biggest concerns is we lived in Twin Falls in the city for

03:19:58.800 --> 03:20:03.500
13 years moved to the country while we consider the country out there. So we're very excited

03:20:03.500 --> 03:20:14.320
for kind of the, you know, just the farmland around us and we live right on 3300. And so

03:20:14.320 --> 03:20:19.920
the busyness of the road like Paul had spoke is it's becoming more aggressive, you know,

03:20:19.920 --> 03:20:23.200
and it's fast and it's becoming more used.

03:20:23.200 --> 03:20:27.360
So I think I would ask that you decline

03:20:27.360 --> 03:20:29.880
this BRAT's proposal in extension.

03:20:29.880 --> 03:20:33.240
And in the business I'm in, growing is great.

03:20:33.240 --> 03:20:36.360
And I love to see things grow and businesses grow.

03:20:36.360 --> 03:20:38.160
And I hope ours does.

03:20:38.160 --> 03:20:40.080
And I hope the community grows.

03:20:40.080 --> 03:20:44.400
And I hope BRAT benefits from that also.

03:20:44.400 --> 03:20:47.520
But I believe that the, and I'm probably wrong

03:20:47.520 --> 03:20:50.400
when I say the 620 foot mark, whatever it was,

03:20:50.400 --> 03:20:56.920
I believe is plenty when you're approaching on families and kids and safety and noise.

03:20:56.920 --> 03:21:03.920
And, you know, I would feel like it's plenty.

03:21:03.920 --> 03:21:05.760
So, thank you.

03:21:05.760 --> 03:21:07.200
Thank you, sir.

03:21:07.200 --> 03:21:10.680
Eli Surl.

03:21:10.680 --> 03:21:14.200
A familiar name to some of us.

03:21:14.200 --> 03:21:16.680
Welcome, Eli.

03:21:16.680 --> 03:21:18.720
Thank you, Mr. Mayor and council members.

03:21:18.720 --> 03:21:20.320
[Muted for privacy: home address]

03:21:20.320 --> 03:21:26.020
[Muted for privacy: home address]

03:21:26.020 --> 03:21:27.500
[Muted for privacy: home address]

03:21:27.500 --> 03:21:30.780
[Muted for privacy: home address]

03:21:30.780 --> 03:21:33.460
and we were saving up for our home

03:21:33.460 --> 03:21:35.940
when our daughter was born premature,

03:21:35.940 --> 03:21:37.460
and unfortunately at the time,

03:21:37.460 --> 03:21:42.100
the doctors there at the NICU didn't take,

03:21:42.100 --> 03:21:44.060
didn't accept the city insurance at the time,

03:21:44.060 --> 03:21:46.540
and so what we had for a little nest egg

03:21:46.540 --> 03:21:50.180
for our future home was devastated

03:21:50.180 --> 03:21:52.340
in a matter of a few weeks.

03:21:52.340 --> 03:21:56.540
So we employed the Rural Development Loan,

03:21:56.540 --> 03:22:01.940
And this property here falls under the USDA Rural Development.

03:22:01.940 --> 03:22:06.260
And so we were able to finally get a home for our growing family.

03:22:06.260 --> 03:22:09.780
As you can see, they're all here because we just found about this a few hours ago.

03:22:09.780 --> 03:22:14.980
So we didn't have time to get a babysitter because we weren't notified

03:22:14.980 --> 03:22:19.240
other than the signs out in the property.

03:22:19.240 --> 03:22:23.310
And we also have the same concerns.

03:22:23.310 --> 03:22:26.190
We're actually probably home the most out of all the neighbors there.

03:22:26.190 --> 03:22:29.350
And Chibani has been a really good neighbor,

03:22:29.350 --> 03:22:31.430
although we do hear things at night.

03:22:31.430 --> 03:22:34.790
With the windows closed, the TV on, the door closed.

03:22:34.790 --> 03:22:38.150
We hear loud bangs at night sometimes.

03:22:38.150 --> 03:22:41.750
And so our concern is Chibani is that far away,

03:22:41.750 --> 03:22:43.550
how much more noisy.

03:22:43.550 --> 03:22:45.230
And Chibani is light and industrial.

03:22:45.230 --> 03:22:47.270
One of the light and industrial is going to become closer

03:22:47.270 --> 03:22:47.770
to us.

03:22:47.770 --> 03:22:50.430
It's going to be the traffic and the noise for our family.

03:22:50.430 --> 03:22:53.750
This was originally intended for us as rural development.

03:22:53.750 --> 03:23:02.310
And so, and especially in light of the budget item to review this and we've asked that you

03:23:02.310 --> 03:23:08.380
considered to either delaying this or denying this to really take a look at where this is

03:23:08.380 --> 03:23:13.580
going to impact, because I also know that this property back here, this field, is also currently

03:23:13.580 --> 03:23:16.540
platted for at least a hundred one acre homes.

03:23:16.540 --> 03:23:22.710
And so that is a future subdivision that will be possibly impacted by this.

03:23:22.710 --> 03:23:23.710
Thank you.

03:23:23.710 --> 03:23:24.710
Thank you.

03:23:24.710 --> 03:23:27.370
Thank you, Mr. Cyril.

03:23:27.370 --> 03:23:28.370
Dan Randall.

03:23:28.370 --> 03:23:29.370
Now we're freezing out.

03:23:29.370 --> 03:23:30.370
Welcome, Mr. Randall.

03:23:30.370 --> 03:23:31.370
Thank you, Mr. Mayor and Council members.

03:23:31.370 --> 03:23:34.930
[Muted for privacy: home address]

03:23:34.930 --> 03:23:43.310
[Muted for privacy: home address]

03:23:43.310 --> 03:23:46.310
[Muted for privacy: home address]

03:23:46.310 --> 03:24:00.830
[Muted for privacy: home address]

03:24:00.830 --> 03:24:11.830
And, you know, even though we try hard, a little girl was almost ran over with someone driving just to work, her home from work.

03:24:11.830 --> 03:24:23.800
And so I'm just concerned with all the kids in the neighborhood growing this business even farther and closer.

03:24:23.800 --> 03:24:29.800
I know just to the right is four kids that live on 3,300.

03:24:29.800 --> 03:24:33.860
They don't even live in the circles. They're right on the street.

03:24:33.860 --> 03:24:36.700
So, I'd say please vote against it.

03:24:36.700 --> 03:24:37.700
Thanks.

03:24:37.700 --> 03:24:46.190
Thank you, Mr. Randall.

03:24:46.190 --> 03:24:47.190
Yes, Ken.

03:24:47.190 --> 03:24:48.190
Is it Ken Stokes?

03:24:48.190 --> 03:24:49.190
That's Bill?

03:24:49.190 --> 03:24:55.630
So, you're going to have to help us with your name.

03:24:55.630 --> 03:24:59.350
I am notorious for slaughtering names, so I apologize up front.

03:24:59.350 --> 03:25:07.230
[Muted for privacy: home address]

03:25:07.230 --> 03:25:13.070
[Muted for privacy: home address]

03:25:13.070 --> 03:25:23.630
[Muted for privacy: home address]

03:25:23.630 --> 03:25:30.590
[Muted for privacy: home address]

03:25:30.590 --> 03:25:37.950
Prairie Ridge Street that if you approve it, I'm afraid it could become devastating at some

03:25:37.950 --> 03:25:44.970
point and that you know when you figure that Paul and today they live only a half

03:25:44.970 --> 03:25:50.770
a temp of a mile if you draw a straight line across the back of that and I think

03:25:50.770 --> 03:25:56.440
that it's just really much too close to residential thank you. Thank you sir.

03:25:56.440 --> 03:26:09.840
Jerry Lazarda. Thank you Mayor City Council. My wife and I stepped on Jerry

03:26:09.840 --> 03:26:14.520
Lazarda 3311 Aspen Ridge and we just live in the next development just over

03:26:14.520 --> 03:26:20.460
from Prairie Ridge, Prairie next door neighbors, just at the top of Prairie Ridge.

03:26:20.460 --> 03:26:21.980
So to the north of Prairie Ridge?

03:26:21.980 --> 03:26:22.980
Yeah.

03:26:22.980 --> 03:26:23.980
Very good.

03:26:23.980 --> 03:26:24.980
Thank you.

03:26:24.980 --> 03:26:25.980
Okay.

03:26:25.980 --> 03:26:27.620
My wife and I moved here two months ago.

03:26:27.620 --> 03:26:30.540
We're in Newcomers to your area.

03:26:30.540 --> 03:26:36.460
We lived in a metropolitan area, the busyness, and waited 65 years to get up to this beautiful

03:26:36.460 --> 03:26:40.180
environment of yours with the open ag land and so forth.

03:26:40.180 --> 03:26:44.140
And we're kind of disheartened to see that things are closing in around us at this time

03:26:44.140 --> 03:26:52.020
in the summer, and we, too, just learned about this going on today, and I was a little disheartened

03:26:52.020 --> 03:26:56.620
when I saw the actual posting for this meeting, and it was about a thousand feet from our

03:26:56.620 --> 03:27:01.180
houses across the street from Chibani. So virtually none of us could really see that

03:27:01.180 --> 03:27:04.380
there was a meeting today. I don't know what your requirements are, but you said there's

03:27:04.380 --> 03:27:11.940
a problem with that, but, regardless, I just felt a little sting of subterfusion, something

03:27:11.940 --> 03:27:14.220
like that going on here that we weren't notified.

03:27:14.220 --> 03:27:16.940
This is greatly going to impact all of us

03:27:16.940 --> 03:27:17.780
this future development.

03:27:17.780 --> 03:27:20.100
Now, we all understand the ramifications

03:27:20.100 --> 03:27:23.260
of development and taxes for the city and so forth,

03:27:23.260 --> 03:27:24.900
and we have empathy for that.

03:27:24.900 --> 03:27:27.580
But like all of the other neighbors have said,

03:27:27.580 --> 03:27:30.980
this is really going to change our future.

03:27:30.980 --> 03:27:33.700
This really is allowed to develop the full extent

03:27:33.700 --> 03:27:36.820
across the street, virtually across the street from us.

03:27:36.820 --> 03:27:38.300
And we know nothing stays still,

03:27:38.300 --> 03:27:41.780
but a lot of us live there for the Ag land views,

03:27:41.780 --> 03:27:45.240
and the safety that the country provides us.

03:27:45.240 --> 03:27:47.400
So why don't you just ask me that you denied this?

03:27:47.400 --> 03:27:48.400
Thank you, sir.

03:27:48.400 --> 03:27:49.240
Okay, thank you.

03:27:49.240 --> 03:27:50.080
Thank you.

03:27:50.080 --> 03:27:55.500
Christy Ferenger, who is a close.

03:27:55.500 --> 03:27:59.710
[Muted for privacy: home address]

03:27:59.710 --> 03:28:03.210
[Muted for privacy: home address]

03:28:03.210 --> 03:28:09.050
[Muted for privacy: home address]

03:28:09.050 --> 03:28:11.970
[Muted for privacy: home address]

03:28:11.970 --> 03:28:22.150
But also I have a problem with just basically moving a boundary line to create an area that

03:28:22.150 --> 03:28:24.470
is more marketable.

03:28:24.470 --> 03:28:31.650
You know it ends up just being all about the money and that's kind of what I think it's

03:28:31.650 --> 03:28:37.470
about creating an area that's more marketable.

03:28:37.470 --> 03:28:43.950
So I just request that you deny this request from Brett.

03:28:43.950 --> 03:28:44.950
Thank you.

03:28:44.950 --> 03:28:46.560
Thank you.

03:28:46.560 --> 03:28:51.490
Stacey Serrel.

03:28:51.490 --> 03:28:52.490
Eli's holding the baby.

03:28:52.490 --> 03:28:53.490
Yes.

03:28:53.490 --> 03:28:54.490
Hi, I'm Stacey Serrel.

03:28:54.490 --> 03:28:55.490
Eli's wife.

03:28:55.490 --> 03:29:00.290
And we have our five kids here because we have babysitter tonight.

03:29:00.290 --> 03:29:03.650
And I've been holding them off on gum and lifesavers.

03:29:03.650 --> 03:29:05.130
So this is important to me.

03:29:05.130 --> 03:29:10.930
I'd also like to mention that this road, 3300, first of all, is a 51 hour road, okay?

03:29:10.930 --> 03:29:15.090
So we already have that traffic, second of all, there's five bus stops just for Kimberly

03:29:15.090 --> 03:29:17.530
School District on that road.

03:29:17.530 --> 03:29:21.850
And they already have police officers writing buses because there's so many cars that pass

03:29:21.850 --> 03:29:24.490
the buses when there's a stop sign out.

03:29:24.490 --> 03:29:32.450
Furthermore, when we moved in in 2009, the district team did not encompass this plan.

03:29:32.450 --> 03:29:37.330
And I know that the city, they make plans in foresight.

03:29:37.330 --> 03:29:39.770
Well, we're only what, six years out?

03:29:39.770 --> 03:29:44.610
And they're saying, sorry, we didn't see this coming.

03:29:44.610 --> 03:29:52.340
Well, we planned here to build here knowing that it was agriculture and residential.

03:29:52.340 --> 03:29:55.140
I don't think it's quite fair for somebody to come in and do this.

03:29:55.140 --> 03:29:57.820
I know it brings in revenue and it grows.

03:29:57.820 --> 03:29:59.980
Yes, change has to include growth.

03:29:59.980 --> 03:30:03.820
However, it will probably affect our property value as well.

03:30:03.820 --> 03:30:09.300
Our safety, our property value, and I almost feel like it's ethically not okay.

03:30:09.300 --> 03:30:11.700
I just feel like this is almost dishonest.

03:30:11.700 --> 03:30:16.940
Hey, build your houses, build your nice homes, and then oh wait, we're building a factory here.

03:30:16.940 --> 03:30:19.700
So I'd just like you to consider that.

03:30:19.700 --> 03:30:27.100
Would you want to build your home and then have a factory build right there and with your

03:30:27.100 --> 03:30:31.680
children or maybe in a place that you want to retire?

03:30:31.680 --> 03:30:36.260
I just think planning is important, but I think that we can't just cross it off anytime

03:30:36.260 --> 03:30:37.700
that we feel like.

03:30:37.700 --> 03:30:44.320
So I'd like to just ask that you not accept this.

03:30:44.320 --> 03:30:45.560
Thank you, Stacey.

03:30:45.560 --> 03:30:49.160
I have an apology, and I didn't do it on purpose, Jill,

03:30:49.160 --> 03:30:51.320
because I'm even on the radio with you tomorrow.

03:30:51.320 --> 03:30:53.320
And if I did it on purpose, you would hammer me.

03:30:53.320 --> 03:30:58.120
Jill, you were way up the line, and I apologize for that.

03:30:58.120 --> 03:31:00.400
Jill, Jill, scheme.

03:31:00.400 --> 03:31:01.800
You're next, ma'am.

03:31:01.800 --> 03:31:03.240
And again, that's my fault.

03:31:03.240 --> 03:31:05.640
I bypassed you, but it wasn't intentional.

03:31:08.330 --> 03:31:10.270
Thank you, Mayor and the Council people.

03:31:10.870 --> 03:31:17.730
I'm here because I live on 3,300, but I was also a member of the 2009 Com plan.

03:31:17.730 --> 03:31:20.950
I feel like we met for months.

03:31:20.950 --> 03:31:25.230
We had a cross section of individuals that came up with this Com plan.

03:31:25.230 --> 03:31:30.910
Part of it was to have an ag buffer between commercial and residential.

03:31:30.910 --> 03:31:36.870
And I feel like since the city is about to embark on their new committee, I believe it's

03:31:36.870 --> 03:31:43.110
$100,000 on a comp plan committee that they're going to start October 1st to have a developer

03:31:43.110 --> 03:31:49.510
come in here and change it at Whim, what's the point of a comp committee or a comp plan?

03:31:49.510 --> 03:31:54.750
And I feel like these, I know these people live in Kimberly, they weren't notified and

03:31:54.750 --> 03:31:59.830
I talked to some of my Kimberly City Council members, they weren't notified about the comp

03:31:59.830 --> 03:32:02.630
plan and how it would align with theirs.

03:32:02.630 --> 03:32:04.750
We live on the other end of 3,300.

03:32:04.750 --> 03:32:07.790
We know how factories affect our lives.

03:32:07.790 --> 03:32:13.790
And to extend this, 600 feet, I'm sure still the people

03:32:13.790 --> 03:32:16.270
have to deal with that, but to do it all the way in a butt

03:32:16.270 --> 03:32:21.030
up against residential and have no regard for, really,

03:32:21.030 --> 03:32:22.710
the people across the way.

03:32:22.710 --> 03:32:25.630
What Twin Falls does affects the people that live in Kimberly,

03:32:25.630 --> 03:32:27.190
whether you like it or not.

03:32:27.190 --> 03:32:28.710
And they're right across the street.

03:32:28.710 --> 03:32:32.350
No notice, no notification.

03:32:32.350 --> 03:32:34.990
And I really feel like you should vote this down

03:32:34.990 --> 03:32:36.930
if you want to wait for the new committee

03:32:36.930 --> 03:32:39.750
to see how they want to change the comp plan for twin.

03:32:39.750 --> 03:32:41.030
I think that would be appropriate,

03:32:41.030 --> 03:32:43.590
but I really think that to have someone come in

03:32:43.590 --> 03:32:45.870
and just change it who's going to benefit from it personally,

03:32:45.870 --> 03:32:47.830
financially, just isn't right.

03:32:47.830 --> 03:32:49.230
So that's why I'm here tonight.

03:32:49.230 --> 03:32:52.910
And I really hope that you vote this down.

03:32:52.910 --> 03:32:53.750
Thank you.

03:32:53.750 --> 03:32:55.220
Thank you, Jill.

03:32:55.220 --> 03:33:04.330
Rod, CAC.

03:33:04.330 --> 03:33:05.410
[Muted for privacy: home address]

03:33:05.410 --> 03:33:09.970
[Muted for privacy: home address]

03:33:09.970 --> 03:33:14.770
[Muted for privacy: home address]

03:33:14.770 --> 03:33:19.890
[Muted for privacy: home address]

03:33:19.890 --> 03:33:21.770
but can't get a library card.

03:33:21.770 --> 03:33:25.570
So that's something we can talk about on another day.

03:33:25.570 --> 03:33:32.770
If you turn to your exhibit A, if you can put that back up on the screen, you got it down

03:33:32.770 --> 03:33:33.770
here.

03:33:33.770 --> 03:33:39.370
And while we're talking, while we're waiting for this, just to add a curiosity, just a couple

03:33:39.370 --> 03:33:44.930
The reason P and Z didn't get this, quote unquote, according to Mr. Will's, who I appreciate

03:33:44.930 --> 03:33:50.210
making his presentation, was that he was proposing something completely different.

03:33:50.210 --> 03:33:57.210
He was proposing a new zoning designation for this area that was going to turn into a low

03:33:57.210 --> 03:34:00.290
impact commercial district.

03:34:00.290 --> 03:34:05.410
We have to understand that he's representing a group of commercial developers, although his

03:34:05.410 --> 03:34:06.810
name is on this.

03:34:06.810 --> 03:34:09.530
he was going to extend that throughout Twin Falls.

03:34:09.530 --> 03:34:11.650
Apparently, he has withdrawn that.

03:34:11.650 --> 03:34:13.970
That makes it a lot more apparent what they're doing.

03:34:13.970 --> 03:34:16.050
They just want to be able to use this for commercial

03:34:16.050 --> 03:34:18.730
without regard to the people around this.

03:34:18.730 --> 03:34:20.050
This is not exhibit A.

03:34:20.050 --> 03:34:31.020
Exhibit A was in the, yeah.

03:34:31.020 --> 03:34:33.900
So if you're looking at this, if you have any question

03:34:33.900 --> 03:34:37.020
about how this impacts me, you'll see that the upper right

03:34:37.020 --> 03:34:39.660
end corner of the yellow line to the north

03:34:39.660 --> 03:34:43.180
is actually running across my south pasture.

03:34:43.180 --> 03:34:44.580
So that's my property.

03:34:44.580 --> 03:34:52.180
mind is the one that directly abuts this new subject area.

03:34:52.180 --> 03:34:56.140
As far as notification or concern, yes, Mr. Will's talked to us.

03:34:56.140 --> 03:35:01.780
He called us one week before the P&C meeting and said that there was going to be a P&C meeting

03:35:01.780 --> 03:35:03.700
and met with us the same day.

03:35:03.700 --> 03:35:07.360
We never got a notice of the mail.

03:35:07.360 --> 03:35:10.880
The problem isn't what happens when these areas get rezoned.

03:35:10.880 --> 03:35:13.080
The problem is what comes after that.

03:35:13.080 --> 03:35:15.360
And what I mean is we saw this with Chibani.

03:35:15.360 --> 03:35:18.880
Chivani had an exemption after exemption after exemption.

03:35:18.880 --> 03:35:24.880
One-third of my entire southern view, which was a rural ag, is now a Chivani factory.

03:35:24.880 --> 03:35:27.880
It has a profound visual impact on the neighborhood.

03:35:27.880 --> 03:35:32.800
It changes the whole character of the rural residential area, and according to Mr.

03:35:32.800 --> 03:35:36.640
Wills at our last meeting, it did devalue the property.

03:35:36.640 --> 03:35:41.720
Any impact that runs up to my property will further devalue my land.

03:35:41.720 --> 03:35:43.480
I'm there for rural residential.

03:35:43.480 --> 03:35:45.040
I enjoy this.

03:35:45.040 --> 03:35:47.910
That's why we moved there over a decade ago.

03:35:47.910 --> 03:35:55.940
The current area of development along Kimberly Road is all within the 660-foot corridor.

03:35:55.940 --> 03:36:02.100
So to expand this is well beyond what's currently along Kimberly Road, except if you want to

03:36:02.100 --> 03:36:04.900
put in another jibani plant, okay?

03:36:04.900 --> 03:36:10.540
So I would strongly urge you not to approve this.

03:36:10.540 --> 03:36:12.560
It is amending the general plan.

03:36:12.560 --> 03:36:14.300
We have that process coming up.

03:36:14.300 --> 03:36:18.100
I think we should respect what's currently in the works.

03:36:18.100 --> 03:36:18.940
Thank you very much.

03:36:18.940 --> 03:36:21.100
Thank you, Dr. Cathen.

03:36:21.100 --> 03:36:31.730
Stephanie Lazardo.

03:36:31.730 --> 03:36:32.930
Hi, I'm Stephanie Lazardo.

03:36:32.930 --> 03:36:35.170
I also live on Aspen Ridge Circle.

03:36:35.170 --> 03:36:37.810
My husband just spoke a little while ago.

03:36:37.810 --> 03:36:40.710
All my neighbors have banded together tonight

03:36:40.710 --> 03:36:44.310
and have expressed so eloquently their fears

03:36:44.310 --> 03:36:47.210
of what could happen if this Sony goes through.

03:36:47.210 --> 03:36:48.930
And I don't have anything more to add to that.

03:36:48.930 --> 03:36:51.210
I just want to say that my husband and I moved here

03:36:51.210 --> 03:36:54.950
for our retirement about 800 miles away from home,

03:36:54.950 --> 03:36:58.490
specifically for the agricultural community,

03:36:58.490 --> 03:37:02.260
and the farmland, I'm sorry.

03:37:02.260 --> 03:37:04.220
My husband and I actually sit down the backyard

03:37:04.220 --> 03:37:06.140
and watch his sprinklers and watch the farmland

03:37:06.140 --> 03:37:09.610
that might, that's how strongly we feel about it.

03:37:09.610 --> 03:37:12.690
And I do feel like it's a bait and switch almost,

03:37:12.690 --> 03:37:15.330
you know, moving, we just moved here two months ago

03:37:15.330 --> 03:37:18.850
and now we're finding this out that this could be happening.

03:37:18.850 --> 03:37:21.250
And I just want you to really, really reconsider

03:37:21.250 --> 03:37:27.250
[Muted for privacy: home address]

03:37:27.250 --> 03:37:42.010
[Muted for privacy: home address]

03:37:42.010 --> 03:37:47.010
[Muted for privacy: home address]

03:37:47.010 --> 03:37:57.830
[Muted for privacy: home address]

03:37:57.830 --> 03:38:00.670
for what they believe in and what is right and wrong.

03:38:00.670 --> 03:38:03.110
And I believe that this choice would not benefit us.

03:38:03.110 --> 03:38:07.790
I strongly urge you to not approve this plan.

03:38:07.790 --> 03:38:08.630
Thank you.

03:38:08.630 --> 03:38:10.300
Thank you.

03:38:10.300 --> 03:38:13.180
I have no one else on the list.

03:38:13.180 --> 03:38:14.500
Denae, did we cover it?

03:38:14.500 --> 03:38:17.500
Or do you want to have a few more seconds?

03:38:17.500 --> 03:38:18.420
A few more seconds.

03:38:18.420 --> 03:38:20.300
Do you want me to state my name and address again?

03:38:20.300 --> 03:38:21.140
No, we got it.

03:38:21.140 --> 03:38:21.640
OK.

03:38:21.480 --> 03:38:23.180
So I did receive a notice.

03:38:23.180 --> 03:38:26.460
And I don't know if it's because my home or I own

03:38:26.460 --> 03:38:34.300
actually two properties. I own the property at 38, 30, nor 3300 East as a rental. And so

03:38:34.300 --> 03:38:41.660
it is a house and then three acres of pasture. So I don't know if we got the notice because

03:38:41.660 --> 03:38:48.220
of that property or our place where we live, which is adjacent to that property, but it

03:38:48.220 --> 03:38:52.150
It was very confusing, I guess.

03:38:52.150 --> 03:38:58.150
I didn't really know what was happening, and it's busy,

03:38:58.150 --> 03:39:00.230
and it's first day of school, and I haven't even been home

03:39:00.230 --> 03:39:02.230
to see if my kids had a good first day of school,

03:39:02.230 --> 03:39:04.070
because I've been here.

03:39:04.070 --> 03:39:07.150
So it's one of those things that it could be clearer

03:39:07.150 --> 03:39:12.390
as to really what's going on when you get those notices.

03:39:12.390 --> 03:39:15.470
And it sounds like maybe I was the only one in my subdivision

03:39:15.470 --> 03:39:17.510
who actually did get to notice.

03:39:17.510 --> 03:39:19.270
So that's all I had.

03:39:19.270 --> 03:39:20.910
Thank you.

03:39:20.910 --> 03:39:22.990
That's all the names I have on the list.

03:39:22.990 --> 03:39:25.790
Is there anyone else that wanted to testify regarding

03:39:25.790 --> 03:39:29.940
this item this evening?

03:39:29.940 --> 03:39:31.100
Some clarifications.

03:39:31.100 --> 03:39:35.420
I know we had a question regarding, well, at this time,

03:39:35.420 --> 03:39:37.620
I'm going to go ahead and close the public testimony

03:39:37.620 --> 03:39:38.900
portion of the hearing.

03:39:38.900 --> 03:39:41.740
And we're going to try to address some of the questions.

03:39:41.740 --> 03:39:46.820
First thing I want to say is that it sounds like we legally

03:39:46.820 --> 03:39:52.420
handled the noticing, we just didn't go as far as what we were hoping we would on these

03:39:52.420 --> 03:39:59.020
real high impact areas. And Rebecca stated what planning zoning is looking at doing in

03:39:59.020 --> 03:40:04.980
the future and looking at this because we need to do a better job of notifying people, in

03:40:04.980 --> 03:40:05.980
my opinion.

03:40:05.980 --> 03:40:12.340
Mr. Mayor, I think that you're absolutely right. I think that, yes, there is a 300 foot

03:40:12.340 --> 03:40:18.500
rule, but I think that also we have to have the ability to look at the greater impact

03:40:18.500 --> 03:40:24.180
of this surrounding area and just following a blanket 300 foot rule approach every single

03:40:24.180 --> 03:40:26.260
time is not acceptable.

03:40:26.260 --> 03:40:30.180
And staff will be looking at this starting tomorrow for sure.

03:40:30.180 --> 03:40:37.120
We'll look at not only that, but we'll also look at the exact notice in the process.

03:40:37.120 --> 03:40:43.640
We believe that it is important to ensure that individuals have the opportunity to participate.

03:40:43.640 --> 03:40:50.920
It's one of the things that we value and to have individuals find out about this because

03:40:50.920 --> 03:40:58.750
of not receiving a good and proper notice is not acceptable in my opinion.

03:40:58.750 --> 03:41:01.750
did very well and personal polity

03:41:01.750 --> 03:41:03.750
folks regarding that will do a better job in the future.

03:41:03.750 --> 03:41:08.950
Chris talking to him.

03:41:08.950 --> 03:41:09.950
I'm going to give Chris.

03:41:09.950 --> 03:41:12.950
I'd like to have a question to an answer.

03:41:12.950 --> 03:41:15.950
Should the council amend the

03:41:15.950 --> 03:41:18.950
two thousand thirty comp plan

03:41:18.950 --> 03:41:20.950
per the request?

03:41:20.950 --> 03:41:23.950
This would be identified

03:41:23.950 --> 03:41:27.200
then as commercial retail

03:41:27.200 --> 03:41:33.600
as an intended zone.

03:41:33.600 --> 03:41:42.840
In on the future land use map if approved also by the county commissioners and if that were the case and we have a proposal come in

03:41:43.320 --> 03:41:45.320
That was residential

03:41:46.840 --> 03:41:49.640
For some portion of that proposed area

03:41:50.120 --> 03:41:52.120
would we be in violation of the

03:41:53.280 --> 03:41:57.160
Compliant if we did not follow the commercial retail

03:41:57.160 --> 03:42:13.760
If you did change it or if you didn't change it.

03:42:13.760 --> 03:42:18.080
Are we obligated to zone this as commercial retail?

03:42:18.080 --> 03:42:19.080
No.

03:42:19.080 --> 03:42:26.480
If a property exchange took place and a planning for a large subdivision or a several smaller

03:42:26.480 --> 03:42:38.400
residential, not commercial, not retail, that would not violate our ability.

03:42:38.400 --> 03:42:42.880
Well, any requested zoning would have to be in performance

03:42:42.880 --> 03:42:45.560
with the comprehensive plan.

03:42:45.560 --> 03:42:48.560
So we would be limited to the commercial retail

03:42:48.560 --> 03:42:50.840
intent of the comp plan.

03:42:50.840 --> 03:42:54.120
Well, so I don't know what the comp plan says

03:42:54.120 --> 03:43:01.580
about commercial retail, whether it anticipates

03:43:01.580 --> 03:43:02.100
reasonable requirements.

03:43:02.100 --> 03:43:03.220
Well, but I think we're amending that.

03:43:03.220 --> 03:43:05.820
Isn't that the request tonight?

03:43:05.820 --> 03:43:08.780
that a request is to potentially allow a rezone

03:43:08.780 --> 03:43:10.820
to a commercial.

03:43:10.820 --> 03:43:13.180
Allow or obligate.

03:43:13.180 --> 03:43:17.480
Allow.

03:43:17.480 --> 03:43:19.120
I think we're parsing here in here.

03:43:19.120 --> 03:43:21.840
Yes, well, so I will tell you that the fact,

03:43:21.840 --> 03:43:28.640
even though property is planned under the comp plan,

03:43:28.640 --> 03:43:32.000
you are not, you are never obligated to zone to,

03:43:32.000 --> 03:43:35.120
to grant a zoning request in conformance with that,

03:43:35.120 --> 03:43:37.800
because the property may not be ready to be developed

03:43:37.800 --> 03:43:38.800
in that way.

03:43:38.800 --> 03:43:42.170
Thank you.

03:43:42.170 --> 03:43:43.170
I guess.

03:43:43.170 --> 03:43:44.730
Appreciate that.

03:43:44.730 --> 03:43:49.760
We have some lights on and I just want to state to this council that we still have the

03:43:49.760 --> 03:43:55.400
ability to have Brad come up again to rebut if you will some of the comments.

03:43:55.400 --> 03:43:57.160
That's part of our process.

03:43:57.160 --> 03:43:58.160
Jim Munn.

03:43:58.160 --> 03:43:59.160
Thank you, Mayor.

03:43:59.160 --> 03:44:00.160
Okay.

03:44:00.160 --> 03:44:06.200
So I want to go back a little bit to this whole notification issue and we notified everybody

03:44:06.200 --> 03:44:09.740
we were obliged to notify by the law.

03:44:09.740 --> 03:44:15.300
we have made it determined that just as a matter of local government integrity we want

03:44:15.300 --> 03:44:23.390
to expand that in the future. My question is are there people out there right now that

03:44:23.390 --> 03:44:32.700
we should, who are outside that 300 feet thing that we should notify for this issue and allow

03:44:32.700 --> 03:44:37.660
another opportunity for them to speak? I mean maybe we should have a discussion about that

03:44:37.660 --> 03:44:42.050
amongst ourselves here. Because if these people, well, if these people, huh,

03:44:42.050 --> 03:44:48.210
it depends on what the outcome of our vote is. Yeah, it does, but I want to talk

03:44:48.210 --> 03:44:51.810
about this a little bit. So there may be other people, these people were notified

03:44:51.810 --> 03:44:57.480
this morning where they found out about it. I want to hear from everybody who's

03:44:57.480 --> 03:45:02.080
living in this area, we're talking about here before I make a decision on

03:45:02.080 --> 03:45:05.840
this. And I guess I'm trying to figure out what are the mechanics of making

03:45:05.840 --> 03:45:10.460
that happen. We send out more letters and bring it back.

03:45:10.460 --> 03:45:13.020
Well, the decision needs to be how far do we go out?

03:45:13.020 --> 03:45:19.580
That 1,000 feet, 1,500 feet, all those dynamics. Part of the conversation in the ZOAC meetings

03:45:19.580 --> 03:45:24.580
where we were, I think it was in ZOAC, wasn't Chris, where we tried to tackle this as far

03:45:24.580 --> 03:45:32.260
as on some of these big projects that are going to be so demonstrative to the neighborhood.

03:45:32.260 --> 03:45:36.900
How far should we go out? We went around and around in the ZOAC committee to where we finally

03:45:36.900 --> 03:45:48.060
And he said, you know, it's hard for us to come up with a distance, staff, would you please on these big issues get out further on a reasonable basis.

03:45:48.060 --> 03:45:51.780
And obviously that did not take place in this situation.

03:45:51.780 --> 03:45:56.020
And that's really personally what I'm disappointed in.

03:45:56.020 --> 03:45:58.740
And I think we've heard that from our city manager as well.

03:45:58.740 --> 03:46:03.340
We really wanted to make sure, we appreciate public input.

03:46:03.340 --> 03:46:08.340
want you here. It makes a difference on how we make our decisions. So we appreciate that

03:46:08.340 --> 03:46:12.700
very much. Got all kinds of lights on. Keep in mind Brad still has the ability to come

03:46:12.700 --> 03:46:17.500
up and converse with us. So I think Rebecca was next.

03:46:17.500 --> 03:46:21.700
Thank you, Mayor. And I just wanted to respond to Councilman Munn's question. I think that's

03:46:21.700 --> 03:46:27.740
a good question. Personally, I feel like a good way to include all of the public and notify

03:46:27.740 --> 03:46:31.620
why people properly would be to address this in the Comp Plan update.

03:46:31.620 --> 03:46:35.340
And as the public testified, they're right.

03:46:35.340 --> 03:46:40.540
We've budgeted $100,000 for a process that engages the public,

03:46:40.540 --> 03:46:42.340
that includes the public.

03:46:42.340 --> 03:46:49.980
And so it doesn't make sense to me, and obviously not to them, to have a couple of people rewrite a portion of the Comp Plan.

03:46:49.980 --> 03:46:54.940
When it's a very holistic plan, it's a very holistic experience, and as we've heard,

03:46:54.940 --> 03:47:00.780
This goes before the county commissioners and it does so because our comp plan butts up against

03:47:00.780 --> 03:47:02.340
Kimberly's comp plan.

03:47:02.340 --> 03:47:09.180
So we need to coordinate those plans and if we change it right now, we don't include everyone affected.

03:47:09.180 --> 03:47:11.620
We don't notify everyone properly.

03:47:11.620 --> 03:47:14.900
So my recommendation, and I think that's a good question, Jim.

03:47:14.900 --> 03:47:24.260
My recommendation is to spend the $100,000 that we put in our budget to address the comp plan and not try to rush this.

03:47:24.940 --> 03:47:27.040
Yeah, I think we're in the middle of a debate

03:47:27.040 --> 03:47:28.940
about the actual issue.

03:47:28.940 --> 03:47:31.720
What I would like to do now with the permission,

03:47:31.720 --> 03:47:34.580
I'd like to have Brad have a chance to come up and

03:47:34.580 --> 03:47:38.760
clarify some issues with the public.

03:47:38.760 --> 03:47:41.620
One thing that one of the questions, Brad, just

03:47:41.620 --> 03:47:45.060
that I heard and clarify if this is wrong,

03:47:45.060 --> 03:47:47.260
is this property already purchased,

03:47:47.260 --> 03:47:49.060
is there already developmental plans,

03:47:49.060 --> 03:47:50.980
those kind of things, that's one of the questions

03:47:50.980 --> 03:48:07.220
that I heard, sir.

03:48:07.220 --> 03:48:12.220
Okay, so in answer to that first question that was asked,

03:48:12.740 --> 03:48:16.940
there are no buyers, there are no plans.

03:48:16.940 --> 03:48:18.780
So let me back up.

03:48:18.780 --> 03:48:23.100
So the futures group, none of those developers

03:48:23.100 --> 03:48:26.460
have anything to do with this land at all.

03:48:26.460 --> 03:48:30.340
This is other, these are other land stakeholders

03:48:30.340 --> 03:48:35.980
that we requested that we would create

03:48:35.980 --> 03:48:38.880
some long-term planning for their land.

03:48:38.880 --> 03:48:41.880
There's probably seven public hearings that will happen

03:48:41.880 --> 03:48:44.220
before something would ever happen on this land.

03:48:44.220 --> 03:48:46.760
But the first thing that you have to do,

03:48:46.760 --> 03:48:48.820
the con plan gets changed.

03:48:48.820 --> 03:48:51.360
It's a five-year-old document.

03:48:51.360 --> 03:48:54.460
It gets changed because it's five years old.

03:48:54.460 --> 03:48:59.270
And you can't just lock it in.

03:48:59.270 --> 03:49:03.760
Kimberly Road, that's a commercial corridor.

03:49:03.760 --> 03:49:06.140
That's been there forever.

03:49:06.140 --> 03:49:10.900
So that will end up being some type of commercial zone,

03:49:10.900 --> 03:49:14.180
whether it's 300 feet, 660.

03:49:14.180 --> 03:49:23.570
So we did do, right now this is where the Com Plan shows,

03:49:23.570 --> 03:49:25.650
and that may be where it stays.

03:49:25.650 --> 03:49:28.970
If you guys decide not to, it is what it is.

03:49:28.970 --> 03:49:33.130
And this will stay here, and these people that on this land

03:49:33.130 --> 03:49:35.650
may look at putting some future uses.

03:49:35.650 --> 03:49:39.390
but C1 is not industrial, C1 is not manufacturing.

03:49:39.390 --> 03:49:43.250
So that's been thrown out that this is another manufacturing,

03:49:43.250 --> 03:49:46.610
and this is C1, which is what Pull Line Road is,

03:49:46.610 --> 03:49:49.130
this is what Blue Lakes is, this is, you know,

03:49:49.130 --> 03:49:51.820
those kind of roads, so.

03:49:51.820 --> 03:49:56.710
So the idea here was you give yourself a little more opportunity

03:49:56.710 --> 03:50:01.630
for these land owners if that is a deeper than the 660.

03:50:01.630 --> 03:50:04.710
And you see that as you go down in different places.

03:50:04.710 --> 03:50:10.350
So state law is what we've, and I think I can only think

03:50:10.350 --> 03:50:15.030
of one place that Jonathan, we've actually gone beyond 300.

03:50:15.030 --> 03:50:19.070
And that was our property over by St. Luke's.

03:50:19.070 --> 03:50:22.470
That was the WSND PUD we incorporated more properties.

03:50:22.470 --> 03:50:24.990
Yeah, that was the one that we've done.

03:50:24.990 --> 03:50:26.150
You heard that?

03:50:26.150 --> 03:50:27.670
Probably the 10 years ago.

03:50:27.670 --> 03:50:30.190
That's the only time we've done that.

03:50:30.190 --> 03:50:32.830
But I agree with you, the properties we visited.

03:50:32.830 --> 03:50:33.950
I looked at my list.

03:50:33.950 --> 03:50:38.630
there were 24 people notified there were two with prairie ridge addresses so they

03:50:38.630 --> 03:50:47.330
must have been within that 200. 300 feet. I mean at 300 feet so you know when we

03:50:47.330 --> 03:50:55.730
did the project over by the St. Luke's you know we went we went beyond that and

03:50:55.730 --> 03:51:03.260
they actually looked at a map rather than figure a footage thing so really the

03:51:03.260 --> 03:51:06.660
The only question I thought is, there are no plans.

03:51:06.660 --> 03:51:13.100
The idea is to get the zoning changed in the comp plan so that then you go back and you

03:51:13.100 --> 03:51:20.370
have to rezone the R2 and the R1 variable.

03:51:20.370 --> 03:51:25.170
Then you would maybe have a subdivision of some type, some plan unit development.

03:51:25.170 --> 03:51:30.370
But those are steps and this could be five years, ten years down the road or somebody could

03:51:30.370 --> 03:51:31.370
knock on the door.

03:51:31.370 --> 03:51:37.970
was the whole point of this is to look at what lands out there and do some long-term planning.

03:51:37.970 --> 03:51:38.970
That was what this was.

03:51:38.970 --> 03:51:42.130
So there's nothing personal in for us.

03:51:42.130 --> 03:51:43.930
We're not getting paid for this.

03:51:43.930 --> 03:51:48.260
We just think it was good planning for the community.

03:51:48.260 --> 03:51:54.110
So I don't really have any other answers to any other questions.

03:51:54.110 --> 03:51:55.110
Thank you, Brad.

03:51:55.110 --> 03:51:56.110
Okay.

03:51:56.110 --> 03:52:01.950
Remind the council here in a moment after we've asked all of our questions of staff, our folks

03:52:01.950 --> 03:52:06.270
to testify and Mr. Wills will close the public hearing

03:52:06.270 --> 03:52:08.350
and turn it over to deliberations.

03:52:08.350 --> 03:52:09.790
If we do make a motion tonight,

03:52:09.790 --> 03:52:11.630
let's make sure we do that in affirmative,

03:52:11.630 --> 03:52:13.910
even if it's whatever way it goes.

03:52:13.910 --> 03:52:16.150
So, Suzanne Hawkins.

03:52:16.150 --> 03:52:17.790
Brad, don't go away.

03:52:17.790 --> 03:52:18.630
Sorry.

03:52:21.120 --> 03:52:24.160
First of all, I appreciate all the effort and energy

03:52:24.160 --> 03:52:26.800
you spend in our community working with development

03:52:26.800 --> 03:52:28.520
and helping us plan for the future.

03:52:28.520 --> 03:52:31.280
And I know you put a lot of effort into it.

03:52:31.280 --> 03:52:34.740
My question is, knowing that we're getting ready to readdress the

03:52:34.740 --> 03:52:40.660
comp plan shortly, what's the hurry, why now, why not wait and do it in a more

03:52:40.660 --> 03:52:48.050
uniform manner instead of jumping ahead of that review?

03:52:48.050 --> 03:52:51.330
So we've been working on this a year.

03:52:51.330 --> 03:53:00.450
And so if the comp plan gets going, you know, that's another year, probably.

03:53:00.450 --> 03:53:01.650
We don't have any hurry.

03:53:01.650 --> 03:53:03.890
We just think it needs to be done.

03:53:03.890 --> 03:53:11.670
And that's why we brought it forward rather than waiting for the city and we will continue to do that if we see other needs

03:53:11.990 --> 03:53:13.990
We'll come forward and bring them to you

03:53:14.750 --> 03:53:20.570
You may end up like this thinking well, this is probably good, but let's give it the chance

03:53:20.570 --> 03:53:22.810
You know to go through the community, right?

03:53:22.810 --> 03:53:25.170
You know if you look at the zoning map in the

03:53:25.810 --> 03:53:30.770
Compliant there's a lot of conflicts in those I agree. Yeah, I agree

03:53:30.770 --> 03:53:38.530
I was just curious for your thought on why now when we're getting ready to address this and just from the comments

03:53:38.530 --> 03:53:46.010
we've gotten tonight with the lack of notification, I would have to think there's more people in the community that are interested in this development

03:53:46.010 --> 03:53:50.770
besides just the people that live there, especially after the comments back on, you know,

03:53:51.370 --> 03:53:57.970
possibly moving water lines for the new elementary school. I feel like we really maybe need to slow down and

03:53:57.970 --> 03:54:00.970
and look at the whole area.

03:54:00.970 --> 03:54:04.450
You know, if that's how you decide to go forward.

03:54:04.450 --> 03:54:08.610
Our goal here is just to help.

03:54:08.610 --> 03:54:09.410
Push us forward.

03:54:09.410 --> 03:54:10.310
Push us forward.

03:54:10.310 --> 03:54:12.110
That's kind of what we're wanting to do here.

03:54:12.110 --> 03:54:13.590
Thank you.

03:54:13.590 --> 03:54:14.750
Thank you, Brad.

03:54:14.750 --> 03:54:17.910
Do we have any further questions for staff or Brad

03:54:17.910 --> 03:54:24.060
or any of our citizens in the came out and testified?

03:54:24.060 --> 03:54:26.380
I will close the public hearing portion of this,

03:54:26.380 --> 03:54:28.500
turn it over to staff for deliberation

03:54:28.500 --> 03:54:31.580
or to counsel for deliberations,

03:54:31.580 --> 03:54:33.020
and maybe if we got a motion on the floor,

03:54:33.020 --> 03:54:35.140
we get to deliberate that.

03:54:35.140 --> 03:54:35.980
Greg Lanny.

03:54:38.540 --> 03:54:40.380
We can discuss this more effectively.

03:54:40.380 --> 03:54:43.340
If I can tell me what the motion needs to be, I do it.

03:54:43.340 --> 03:54:44.980
There we go, thank you.

03:54:44.980 --> 03:54:46.660
Okay, before you do that,

03:54:47.820 --> 03:54:48.660
I'm sorry.

03:54:48.660 --> 03:54:50.660
I have to reopen the public hearing.

03:54:50.660 --> 03:54:51.500
Can you do that?

03:54:51.500 --> 03:54:53.700
I am reopening the public hearing

03:54:53.700 --> 03:54:56.540
so that we can ask a question for that.

03:54:56.540 --> 03:54:58.380
So this question would actually be for Fritz.

03:54:58.380 --> 03:55:03.380
So if just by the way, you can ask our legal staff,

03:55:05.780 --> 03:55:08.340
even when the public hearing is closed, so future.

03:55:08.340 --> 03:55:10.300
So the question would be,

03:55:10.300 --> 03:55:15.300
if we wanted to delay this to be part

03:55:15.500 --> 03:55:20.040
of the broader comprehensive plan discussion,

03:55:20.040 --> 03:55:25.460
if there's a motion and it's denied tonight,

03:55:25.460 --> 03:55:36.940
Does that muddy that water for having this so so in my head, I'm thinking can we table this and be part of that discussion should we deny it?

03:55:38.880 --> 03:55:41.040
What are what are some options there?

03:55:43.140 --> 03:55:49.630
Yeah, the complicating thing is that this your action here is not the final action.

03:55:49.630 --> 03:55:53.190
It goes on to the goes on to the county commissioners.

03:55:53.190 --> 03:55:58.420
So my concern is, shot down by planning and zoning,

03:55:58.420 --> 03:56:01.820
shot down by us, shot down by county commissioners,

03:56:01.820 --> 03:56:04.560
why don't you bring it back in six months?

03:56:04.560 --> 03:56:08.560
My question is, can we slow this down

03:56:08.560 --> 03:56:10.520
and have it be part of that broader discussion

03:56:10.520 --> 03:56:12.440
and how might we go about doing that?

03:56:12.440 --> 03:56:14.840
So yeah, so let me just take a look.

03:56:14.840 --> 03:56:16.960
I know there's nothing in the state law,

03:56:16.960 --> 03:56:18.240
but let me take a look in our code

03:56:18.240 --> 03:56:20.920
to make sure there's not some minimum period

03:56:20.920 --> 03:56:23.240
that you have to have responded within.

03:56:23.240 --> 03:56:27.810
While he's doing that, Kristi, you have a question of staff?

03:56:27.810 --> 03:56:31.810
No, it's just a deliberation point.

03:56:31.810 --> 03:56:35.810
So I think that we can go ahead and close the public hearing again

03:56:35.810 --> 03:56:41.810
because this is a question to our legal staff and I'll turn it over to Chris for a deliberation.

03:56:41.810 --> 03:56:45.810
Yeah, and I don't have a motion, but I'm really in a quandary on this.

03:56:45.810 --> 03:56:49.810
I have to respectfully disagree with Brad.

03:56:49.810 --> 03:56:56.530
I all my time on public service mixing commercial and residential when you have the option or

03:56:56.530 --> 03:56:59.890
whether to do it or not is a big mistake.

03:56:59.890 --> 03:57:04.790
There's some advantage if you bring an area in adjacent to a residential or a commercial

03:57:04.790 --> 03:57:11.530
and can make a buffer transition zone, but I would never purposely put commercial next

03:57:11.530 --> 03:57:12.530
to residential.

03:57:12.530 --> 03:57:21.310
As for the question, though, of opening up the water boundary to go eastward to the area

03:57:21.310 --> 03:57:28.350
of impact terminus with Kimberly, that's got to happen.

03:57:28.350 --> 03:57:31.110
This land will not stay agricultural forever.

03:57:31.110 --> 03:57:38.470
I think it's highest and best used beyond that 600 or so feet off of Kimberly Road is

03:57:38.470 --> 03:57:45.670
residential in some form as opposed to commercial. So I'm really in a quandary of making any

03:57:45.670 --> 03:57:49.830
motion right now where I'd have to say if we bring it in it's going to have a commercial

03:57:49.830 --> 03:57:55.110
retail corridor there. I wouldn't be in favor of that, but I am in favor of extending the

03:57:55.110 --> 03:58:00.200
water boundary. Rebecca Milsocka.

03:58:00.200 --> 03:58:04.200
Thank you, Mayor. Well, we're waiting for Fritz's answer. I just wanted to add, you know,

03:58:04.200 --> 03:58:09.440
tabling it also might complicate the situation we've been talking about notification-wise,

03:58:09.440 --> 03:58:13.240
If it starts over at the beginning at a new public hearing and

03:58:13.240 --> 03:58:17.540
we've updated our codes to be sufficient to notify people sufficiently,

03:58:18.920 --> 03:58:23.480
tabling it might complicate that, it might be best to start over and that's just my recommendation.

03:58:23.480 --> 03:58:24.520
Thank you Rebecca.

03:58:24.520 --> 03:58:26.920
We're going to have our city attorney come forward.

03:58:26.920 --> 03:58:32.880
So there is no statement in the city code at all on

03:58:32.880 --> 03:58:38.800
amending the complaint and the state code there is no time limit within which you have that.

03:58:38.800 --> 03:58:43.160
We just have a go away.

03:58:43.160 --> 03:58:44.080
Great line.

03:58:44.080 --> 03:58:45.200
Thank you, Chris.

03:58:45.200 --> 03:58:47.800
Like Chris said, there's some quandary items

03:58:47.800 --> 03:58:48.640
for me on this, too.

03:58:48.640 --> 03:58:50.680
One, I agree with him.

03:58:50.680 --> 03:58:55.400
We're going to, at some point, 3,300 will be our water boundary.

03:58:55.400 --> 03:58:57.920
I don't know that it's this year, next year, or 10 years

03:58:57.920 --> 03:59:00.840
from now, but some point, 3,300 will all be our water

03:59:00.840 --> 03:59:01.680
boundary.

03:59:01.680 --> 03:59:04.960
It'd probably be farther than if we had been a little more

03:59:04.960 --> 03:59:08.720
insightful and had our, well, not insightful.

03:59:08.720 --> 03:59:11.760
If it had come about that our area of impact

03:59:11.760 --> 03:59:13.560
with Father Turch Kimberly that does,

03:59:13.560 --> 03:59:15.940
because I think we're gonna be developing

03:59:15.940 --> 03:59:18.360
Father against our line way before Kimberly

03:59:18.360 --> 03:59:21.660
will be developing against their line.

03:59:21.660 --> 03:59:23.540
This is hard, okay, and I understand,

03:59:23.540 --> 03:59:27.720
because I definitely respect residential zones,

03:59:27.720 --> 03:59:31.500
but the argument that about the farm ground,

03:59:31.500 --> 03:59:34.540
you folks took up farm ground when you built your house.

03:59:34.540 --> 03:59:37.260
And so that's kind of a quandary issue

03:59:37.260 --> 03:59:41.420
because you've made a residential area in the country,

03:59:41.420 --> 03:59:43.260
and I understand your desire to do that,

03:59:43.260 --> 03:59:47.340
but it has the same problems that the person there,

03:59:47.340 --> 03:59:50.550
and then I also always have a problem with,

03:59:50.550 --> 03:59:54.510
how much can I tell somebody what they can do with their land?

03:59:54.510 --> 03:59:58.750
I don't own that land, I don't have any interest in that land,

03:59:58.750 --> 04:00:03.030
but I'm telling somebody potentially down the road here

04:00:03.030 --> 04:00:05.990
that they can't use their land for the best highest use,

04:00:05.990 --> 04:00:07.970
and I start with that.

04:00:07.970 --> 04:00:09.830
I'm not gonna be willing to vote for this tonight

04:00:09.830 --> 04:00:10.670
and be honest with you,

04:00:10.670 --> 04:00:12.230
I hope we don't do even do a motion.

04:00:12.230 --> 04:00:13.430
We just let it drop for now

04:00:13.430 --> 04:00:14.950
and we'll go ahead and take care of it

04:00:14.950 --> 04:00:19.430
during the compound review that is coming up.

04:00:24.310 --> 04:00:28.660
I know how fast we have to move

04:00:28.660 --> 04:00:31.380
to provide quality jobs to our community.

04:00:31.380 --> 04:00:33.300
And that's the other part that overrides this.

04:00:33.300 --> 04:00:38.300
So we have to find land in the case of Jibani 187 acres

04:00:38.300 --> 04:00:43.300
in the point of Cliff Bar, 80 acres or 83 acres, whatever it was.

04:00:44.560 --> 04:00:46.920
We don't have time to go through a Complan review.

04:00:46.920 --> 04:00:49.040
We don't have time to go through all these different things.

04:00:49.040 --> 04:00:50.200
So some of that, thanks.

04:00:50.200 --> 04:00:55.080
I know Brad has pointed out that C1 does not mean industrial,

04:00:55.080 --> 04:00:58.800
but I understand the neighbors concerned that it does bring it up.

04:00:58.800 --> 04:01:02.560
If we want to continue to grow as a city and have quality jobs,

04:01:02.560 --> 04:01:04.680
we have to find additional industrial land.

04:01:04.680 --> 04:01:07.560
And this may not be the place for it, I understand that.

04:01:07.560 --> 04:01:10.520
but we have to find additional industrial land.

04:01:10.520 --> 04:01:13.600
And we've wrestled with this all along.

04:01:13.600 --> 04:01:16.920
And I understand that you don't want it in your backyard

04:01:16.920 --> 04:01:18.360
and I wouldn't want it in my backyard,

04:01:18.360 --> 04:01:20.560
but my backyard has houses all the way around me.

04:01:20.560 --> 04:01:23.200
So my backyard is, you know,

04:01:23.200 --> 04:01:24.880
I build inside the city on purpose

04:01:24.880 --> 04:01:26.560
because I wanted to be on city services,

04:01:26.560 --> 04:01:29.360
I wanted to be involved in those things

04:01:29.360 --> 04:01:31.640
you're building for your purposes.

04:01:31.640 --> 04:01:35.000
But it all gets muddled in here at one of the point

04:01:35.000 --> 04:01:37.080
I'm just saying I hope this goes away

04:01:37.080 --> 04:01:39.860
until we can address it during the comprehensive plan.

04:01:39.860 --> 04:01:43.300
And it may be the under the comprehensive plan

04:01:43.300 --> 04:01:47.980
that this gets re-designated for something different.

04:01:47.980 --> 04:01:51.220
You already got 660 feet, I don't know.

04:01:51.220 --> 04:01:53.940
First I have a question for you.

04:01:53.940 --> 04:01:57.100
So if we take no action tonight,

04:01:57.100 --> 04:02:00.460
it's essentially we're agreeing, if you will,

04:02:00.460 --> 04:02:04.340
with P&Z's denial, it's been denied by P&Z.

04:02:04.340 --> 04:02:05.340
and deny by me.

04:02:05.340 --> 04:02:10.340
The agency recommended that you not make the change.

04:02:10.340 --> 04:02:14.860
I know this is all a little bit messy, and Jonathan and I were just talking about it.

04:02:14.860 --> 04:02:23.260
You have to realize that it's your comp plan, but the county has adopted your comp plan for

04:02:23.260 --> 04:02:25.300
use within the area of impact.

04:02:25.300 --> 04:02:29.220
So it's a little bit of an odd situation.

04:02:29.220 --> 04:02:34.060
The reality is you have to approve it, and the county has to approve it for the comp plan

04:02:34.060 --> 04:02:36.180
to get change within the area of impact.

04:02:36.180 --> 04:02:40.180
For it to go to the county, we have to approve it.

04:02:40.180 --> 04:02:42.220
If we don't approve it tonight, it doesn't even

04:02:42.220 --> 04:02:43.300
make it to the county.

04:02:43.300 --> 04:02:46.700
So that's the question on this.

04:02:46.700 --> 04:02:47.200
Yeah.

04:02:47.200 --> 04:02:49.740
So again, it's your complex.

04:02:49.740 --> 04:02:54.020
It is absolutely your comp plan that the county has adopted

04:02:54.020 --> 04:02:56.300
for application within the area of impact.

04:02:56.300 --> 04:02:58.260
If you don't change your comp plan,

04:02:58.260 --> 04:03:00.660
it doesn't change no matter what the county does.

04:03:00.660 --> 04:03:02.580
OK.

04:03:02.580 --> 04:03:03.620
That's clear as much.

04:03:03.620 --> 04:03:04.940
Thank you.

04:03:04.940 --> 04:03:05.940
I think I've got it.

04:03:05.940 --> 04:03:08.020
Okay, here's where I stand on it, folks.

04:03:08.020 --> 04:03:10.520
Brad, I am a pro-development guy.

04:03:10.520 --> 04:03:13.120
I understand what jobs do for our community.

04:03:13.120 --> 04:03:16.280
I'm been involved in a lot of different

04:03:16.280 --> 04:03:18.660
economic development pieces of our city.

04:03:18.660 --> 04:03:20.540
Been proud to be part of those.

04:03:20.540 --> 04:03:22.980
Chobanis and the clip bars and the like,

04:03:22.980 --> 04:03:24.680
because I know what it does for the community.

04:03:24.680 --> 04:03:27.300
I know what it does for people.

04:03:27.300 --> 04:03:30.100
A good, well-paying, well-benefited job

04:03:30.100 --> 04:03:32.020
does wonders for our community.

04:03:32.020 --> 04:03:38.100
but on this one I just can't if it did come to us I'm not going to support it I

04:03:38.100 --> 04:03:42.340
think we need to wait for that compound review and look at it a little more

04:03:42.340 --> 04:03:46.180
holistically I don't use that word very often Jill you got to be proud of me okay

04:03:46.180 --> 04:03:51.460
that's that's big step for me saying that work I just I just think we need to

04:03:51.460 --> 04:03:56.940
step back there's no big rush let the system let it play out and let's get that

04:03:56.940 --> 04:04:00.340
committee together and start looking at our confluent.

04:04:00.340 --> 04:04:01.820
So that's where I stand.

04:04:01.820 --> 04:04:03.530
Rebecca.

04:04:03.530 --> 04:04:04.370
Thank you, Mayor.

04:04:04.370 --> 04:04:06.210
I couldn't agree more.

04:04:06.210 --> 04:04:07.330
But I think we should vote on it.

04:04:07.330 --> 04:04:10.090
I think that we should, I think these people

04:04:10.090 --> 04:04:13.610
deserve after four hours, they deserve a vote.

04:04:13.610 --> 04:04:15.530
And they deserve a conclusion.

04:04:15.530 --> 04:04:18.010
And we can go through the confluent process afterwards.

04:04:18.010 --> 04:04:22.210
So I'll make a motion to approve in the affirmative.

04:04:22.210 --> 04:04:24.290
The amendment to the Twin Falls Vision 2030,

04:04:24.290 --> 04:04:26.250
a comprehensive plan to expand and clarify

04:04:26.250 --> 04:04:27.970
at the depth of the commercial retail corridor

04:04:27.970 --> 04:04:30.410
along the north side of a portion of Kimberly Road

04:04:30.410 --> 04:04:32.090
and to amend the water service boundary area

04:04:32.090 --> 04:04:34.410
to include that portion of Kimberly Road

04:04:34.410 --> 04:04:37.250
being proposed with this amendment for property

04:04:37.250 --> 04:04:39.130
within the city area of impact.

04:04:39.130 --> 04:04:42.370
And this is a motion for recommendation

04:04:42.370 --> 04:04:44.450
to the Board of County Commissioners.

04:04:44.450 --> 04:04:45.290
Thank you, Rebecca.

04:04:45.290 --> 04:04:46.130
Do we have a second?

04:04:46.130 --> 04:04:47.770
I'll second to get it on the table.

04:04:47.770 --> 04:04:49.770
We have a motion on the floor by Rebecca Melsoica,

04:04:49.770 --> 04:04:52.670
seconded by Chris Tawkin and as stated,

04:04:52.670 --> 04:04:58.630
Do we have any further deliberations regarding this motion council Rebecca Mill so I can.

04:04:58.630 --> 04:04:59.630
Thank you Mayor.

04:04:59.630 --> 04:05:00.630
I do want to say a little bit about the process.

04:05:00.630 --> 04:05:06.130
I do want to say thank you to everyone, the applicant who has also been with us these hours.

04:05:06.130 --> 04:05:12.170
Everyone who came to provide input because obviously this means a lot to you to skip your

04:05:12.170 --> 04:05:16.910
dinners and bring your children and kind of go through this hectic process.

04:05:16.910 --> 04:05:18.610
So I appreciate that.

04:05:18.610 --> 04:05:26.610
One thing I just want to state on the state law is clear, that any rezone needs to comply

04:05:26.610 --> 04:05:30.050
with the comp plan and that's why we do the comp plan.

04:05:30.050 --> 04:05:35.250
So that changing the comp plan would actually, it wouldn't require, as Councilman Talkington

04:05:35.250 --> 04:05:40.690
said, that a zoning change be made, but it opens the door for zoning change to be made.

04:05:40.690 --> 04:05:46.670
And so I understand that the majority of you testified against having that opportunity,

04:05:46.670 --> 04:05:50.210
you do not want that opportunity to be available.

04:05:50.210 --> 04:05:54.510
And I think that that's reasonable because I think that our planning documents are con

04:05:54.510 --> 04:06:00.390
plan and the Land Use Planning Act also is very clear that commercial development shall

04:06:00.390 --> 04:06:03.870
not infringe upon residential.

04:06:03.870 --> 04:06:08.390
And during the Planning and Zoning Commission hearing, they understood that very well and

04:06:08.390 --> 04:06:15.430
they were very clear about it, and that was part of their reasoning behind denying or

04:06:15.430 --> 04:06:20.470
having a negative recommendation for this change.

04:06:20.470 --> 04:06:26.750
As far as changing the water boundary line, I think we need to assess the cost to the general

04:06:26.750 --> 04:06:27.750
public.

04:06:27.750 --> 04:06:32.590
The cost to the city, I mean right now we're working on odor reduction facilities that will

04:06:32.590 --> 04:06:38.750
be paid for by the general users along that Northeast sewer line and it brought great things.

04:06:38.750 --> 04:06:40.790
It brought Chobani, it brought jobs.

04:06:40.790 --> 04:06:46.710
But there's been some negative impacts that we have to mitigate, but at the cost of everyone.

04:06:46.710 --> 04:06:51.590
And so I think we need to take the comp plan, even though it was created in 2009, we need

04:06:51.590 --> 04:06:53.590
to take it seriously.

04:06:53.590 --> 04:06:56.790
And citizens should be able to trust the current comp plan.

04:06:56.790 --> 04:07:03.530
should be able to have faith in the documents that are on file and they're required by state

04:07:03.530 --> 04:07:07.830
law. We have to have a complement. We have to update our complement every five years,

04:07:07.830 --> 04:07:12.870
and that's the purpose in it. And it's supposed to be a community-wide project. It's supposed

04:07:12.870 --> 04:07:19.670
to be holistic and all-inclusive. I use those words all the time, Don, so I'm used to that.

04:07:19.670 --> 04:07:25.790
But it's a good idea. You know, it's not a good idea to piecemeal it, and that's specifically

04:07:25.790 --> 04:07:30.670
the words that the Planning and Zoning Commission used collectively, that this was piece milling

04:07:30.670 --> 04:07:35.390
the comp plan and that's a bad idea because when you piece mill comp plan it's not really

04:07:35.390 --> 04:07:36.390
a plan.

04:07:36.390 --> 04:07:43.200
I just want to go on record two real quick.

04:07:43.200 --> 04:07:48.400
I do want to see Twin Falls continue to grow and I'm very supportive of our development community

04:07:48.400 --> 04:07:52.640
and I do believe we need to watch what our comp plan has but the document's also been

04:07:52.640 --> 04:07:57.240
created to be amended and there are sections in there for how to amend it and so it is

04:07:57.240 --> 04:08:02.160
proper and it is okay to look at these things and not wait five years to make changes to

04:08:02.160 --> 04:08:04.800
a document of this nature.

04:08:04.800 --> 04:08:09.200
And it isn't a document that we look at changing on a regular basis.

04:08:09.200 --> 04:08:13.960
It's something we do take serious and that's why we devoted so much time to it tonight.

04:08:13.960 --> 04:08:19.200
And it is okay for citizens to come forth when they see an issue and ask us to look at this

04:08:19.200 --> 04:08:21.800
document and make changes to it.

04:08:21.800 --> 04:08:24.360
And so I am not opposed to amending the CompPailan.

04:08:24.360 --> 04:08:30.020
However, I don't feel like tonight and this idea is the right one for amending it.

04:08:30.020 --> 04:08:36.400
I do want to see us look at the water boundary lines and I'm excited to update it this year and see where it goes.

04:08:36.400 --> 04:08:46.620
But I think as a council, we need to remember it is a document to guide us, but it is supposed to be a living document that when an issue comes up we can change and amend.

04:08:46.620 --> 04:08:54.120
And so even though when you bought your houses five years ago, the comp plan said this is what we look at.

04:08:54.120 --> 04:08:59.120
You have to understand too that like everything else in life, it is a changing moving piece.

04:08:59.120 --> 04:09:04.620
It's just because a comp plan said this is agricultural at this time does not mean that's forever.

04:09:04.620 --> 04:09:07.620
So you do have to weigh both sides of that.

04:09:07.620 --> 04:09:11.420
Anything further on this motion, Council?

04:09:11.420 --> 04:09:19.780
I actually just want to say that I'm disappointed that we even have a motion to vote on, because

04:09:19.780 --> 04:09:25.920
I think we've made it clear tonight that we maybe have a better process that's ahead

04:09:25.920 --> 04:09:33.320
of us to go through this, and I think that by having a motion and a second is forcing

04:09:33.320 --> 04:09:39.040
us to all make a decision tonight on without quite all the information we need.

04:09:39.040 --> 04:09:44.000
So I will say that I am going to vote, but actually I have a question for legal counsel.

04:09:44.000 --> 04:09:45.000
Is it too?

04:09:45.000 --> 04:09:47.360
Is a motion to table debatable?

04:09:47.360 --> 04:09:55.350
You have not adopted Robert's rules, so is your own rules to decide whether you want a

04:09:55.350 --> 04:09:59.010
debate, a motion to table or not?

04:09:59.010 --> 04:10:04.310
I do want to point out, if I didn't make it clear, if you vote no on this, it does not

04:10:04.310 --> 04:10:05.410
go to the county.

04:10:05.410 --> 04:10:07.780
Right.

04:10:07.780 --> 04:10:15.580
I just feel like we, in the testimony we heard comments from everything from, I don't want

04:10:15.580 --> 04:10:19.940
it in my backyard too, there's a whole process coming up and maybe you want to use that process

04:10:19.940 --> 04:10:27.260
to look at this and we're putting a position now to make a decision that I just think is,

04:10:27.260 --> 04:10:31.340
I think it's unfair to us and I actually think it's unfair to the people who came here because

04:10:31.340 --> 04:10:37.940
Because if this fails tonight, the feeling is going to be, hooray, this is never going

04:10:37.940 --> 04:10:42.580
to happen, and then we're going to move down a process to look at it again.

04:10:42.580 --> 04:10:48.220
So I just wanted to express that I'm disappointed that we even have to have a vote on this, and

04:10:48.220 --> 04:10:53.380
I'm voting against it not because I don't think that there is opportunity for development

04:10:53.380 --> 04:10:57.860
in that area, but because I don't think we have any other choice tonight.

04:10:57.860 --> 04:10:59.580
That's a good point, sir.

04:10:59.580 --> 04:11:00.580
We're stalking it.

04:11:00.580 --> 04:11:01.580
Move to table.

04:11:01.580 --> 04:11:08.800
Second we have a motion on floor by Chris talking in to table seconded by Greg Lanting

04:11:11.250 --> 04:11:13.250
Anything further on that motion

04:11:17.690 --> 04:11:19.690
Order

04:11:22.410 --> 04:11:27.930
Anything further on that motion council motion to table zolle yes, it is a motions table

04:11:27.930 --> 04:11:31.310
Which if we do we don't need to vote on the set on the first motion obviously

04:11:31.310 --> 04:11:34.310
I think it's clear that there's already a motion on the floor.

04:11:34.310 --> 04:11:36.310
I think that it actually needs closure.

04:11:36.310 --> 04:11:41.310
And I think that it actually provides a better answer for everyone who provided input.

04:11:41.310 --> 04:11:47.310
To me, either motion, I know how I'm going to vote and what the outcome is going to be.

04:11:47.310 --> 04:11:52.310
So, I think that the motion is going to be a little bit more clear.

04:11:52.310 --> 04:11:58.010
So, I think that the motion is going to be a little bit more clear.

04:11:58.010 --> 04:12:06.800
I know how I'm going to vote and what the outcome is going to be so I'm comfortable with the motion so because I know how I'm going to vote.

04:12:06.800 --> 04:12:12.220
The motion on the floor is to table this issue to this evening.

04:12:12.220 --> 04:12:15.220
Leila Roll call vote please.

04:12:15.220 --> 04:12:16.220
Big Latine.

04:12:16.220 --> 04:12:17.220
Yes.

04:12:17.220 --> 04:12:18.220
Don Hall.

04:12:18.220 --> 04:12:19.220
Yes.

04:12:19.220 --> 04:12:20.220
Rebecca Masoica.

04:12:20.220 --> 04:12:22.050
No.

04:12:22.050 --> 04:12:23.050
Suzanne Hawkins.

04:12:23.050 --> 04:12:24.050
Yes.

04:12:24.050 --> 04:12:25.050
Jim Mann.

04:12:25.050 --> 04:12:26.050
Yes.

04:12:26.050 --> 04:12:27.050
Sean Berger.

04:12:27.050 --> 04:12:28.050
Yes.

04:12:28.050 --> 04:12:29.050
Chris Tacham.

04:12:29.050 --> 04:12:30.050
Yes.

04:12:30.050 --> 04:12:33.150
Passes six to one. It's tabled and

04:12:34.950 --> 04:12:37.390
Thank you folks for all coming this evening

04:12:38.190 --> 04:12:42.010
Really appreciate your testimony and your patience. It's been a late

04:12:43.710 --> 04:12:46.550
Moving on to the item number 10

04:12:47.630 --> 04:12:49.630
under items for consideration

04:12:50.550 --> 04:12:56.830
Formation of a City Council meet committee to complete the annual performance evaluation of the City Manager and

04:12:57.670 --> 04:12:59.350
City Attorney

04:12:59.350 --> 04:13:01.350
This is a

04:13:01.710 --> 04:13:08.370
Formation of the City Council Committee that I would like to put together as the mayor, but anytime that we do that as per our

04:13:10.190 --> 04:13:12.190
Transparency transparency. Thank you

04:13:14.470 --> 04:13:18.510
Resolution needs to come in front of the Council, so I would like to ask first of all

04:13:19.630 --> 04:13:26.470
The Council to allow me to put together a committee to begin the performance annual performance evaluation

04:13:26.470 --> 04:13:33.030
for our city manager and that committee would be myself, Suzanne Hawkins and Chris

04:13:33.030 --> 04:13:38.230
Tockington. Obviously that's just a committee looking at it, working on it, we

04:13:38.230 --> 04:13:43.030
will bring that back to the full council in executive session because it is a

04:13:43.030 --> 04:13:49.960
personnel issue. That's my first piece of business on number 10.

04:13:49.960 --> 04:13:53.760
Council wishes. I need a motion. Sean Berger.

04:13:53.760 --> 04:13:59.760
I would move to allow the mayor to form the City Council Committee to complete the annual

04:13:59.760 --> 04:14:03.760
performance evaluation of the City Manager and City Attorney as presented.

04:14:03.760 --> 04:14:04.760
Second.

04:14:04.760 --> 04:14:10.180
Motion on the floor by Sean Berger, seconded by Greg Lanning.

04:14:10.180 --> 04:14:12.180
Anything further on that motion council?

04:14:12.180 --> 04:14:14.980
Leyla Rokelbo?

04:14:14.980 --> 04:14:15.980
Don't add?

04:14:15.980 --> 04:14:16.980
Yes.

04:14:16.980 --> 04:14:17.980
Rebecca Masmica?

04:14:17.980 --> 04:14:18.980
Yes.

04:14:18.980 --> 04:14:19.980
Suzanne Hawkins?

04:14:19.980 --> 04:14:20.980
Yes.

04:14:20.980 --> 04:14:21.980
Jim Mann?

04:14:21.980 --> 04:14:22.980
Yes.

04:14:22.980 --> 04:14:23.980
Sean Berger?

04:14:23.980 --> 04:14:40.980
Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Great lens. Yes. Motion passes seven to zero. Last item on the agenda is public input. Is there anyone else from the public wishing to have any input to the city council? Excuse me. Did you want to address the city attorney?

04:14:40.980 --> 04:14:49.980
Well, he put it in the motion of the city attorney. Oh, I guess we'll address that. We'll kind of walk through it. I was just reading it off the agenda.

04:14:49.980 --> 04:14:55.560
Right, well you put it in the motion so I allowed it to stand and that's okay we'll

04:14:55.560 --> 04:15:01.100
review both and bring it back to the council. I have some real, just let you

04:15:01.100 --> 04:15:04.080
know I have some real strong feelings on the city attorney side of things and

04:15:04.080 --> 04:15:08.140
we'll debate that and bring it to full council. Plenty of time to be able to do

04:15:08.140 --> 04:15:12.790
that one. It's a positive thing Chris.

04:15:12.790 --> 04:15:14.790
That did sound kind of ominous, didn't it?

04:15:17.790 --> 04:15:19.790
I'll clarify later.

04:15:21.110 --> 04:15:23.110
Anything further on that council?

04:15:23.110 --> 04:15:26.110
Okay, public input? No one here from the public?

04:15:26.110 --> 04:15:30.110
Any other items from City Manager? I know we have an executive session this evening.

04:15:35.570 --> 04:15:36.570
They'll be brief.

04:15:36.570 --> 04:15:38.570
They'll be brief. Very good.

04:15:38.570 --> 04:15:41.570
Just real quick, Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, just one quick thing.

04:15:41.570 --> 04:15:46.570
If you would like to attend the Entrepreneurs Forum that's going to be on September 16th,

04:15:46.570 --> 04:15:51.570
please let us know the I-LIS making the reservations.

04:15:51.570 --> 04:16:02.570
It is going to be held at the CSI Fine Arts Auditorium, and the keynote address is the founder and CEO of Chibani Hameday Ulukaya.

04:16:02.570 --> 04:16:04.570
You already have me.

04:16:04.570 --> 04:16:08.510
We have Don.

04:16:08.510 --> 04:16:09.510
Yep, and Sean.

04:16:09.510 --> 04:16:10.510
And Sean.

04:16:10.510 --> 04:16:11.510
Very good.

04:16:11.510 --> 04:16:14.020
If we all go together, we can't sit together.

04:16:14.020 --> 04:16:24.770
it together. Anything further from City Manager? Anything further from City Council? At this

04:16:24.770 --> 04:16:34.820
time, Jim Ma. Oh, I'm sorry, Mayor. Last item on the is a German anti-executive session,

04:16:34.820 --> 04:16:42.380
672345-1C to conduct deliberations concerning labor negotiations or to acquire an interest

04:16:42.380 --> 04:16:45.780
in real property which is not owned by a public agency, Jim Munn.

04:16:45.780 --> 04:16:46.620
So moved.

04:16:46.620 --> 04:16:47.460
Second.

04:16:47.460 --> 04:16:50.740
A motion on form by Jim Munn, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins,

04:16:50.740 --> 04:16:52.300
to go into executive session.

04:16:52.300 --> 04:16:54.340
Anything further on that motion council?

04:16:54.340 --> 04:16:56.020
Will you add a roll call, vote please.

04:16:56.020 --> 04:16:57.180
Your question must wake up?

04:16:57.180 --> 04:16:58.020
Yes.

04:16:58.020 --> 04:16:58.860
Suzanne Hawkins?

04:16:58.860 --> 04:17:00.180
Yes.

04:17:00.180 --> 04:17:00.980
Jim Munn?

04:17:00.980 --> 04:17:01.820
Yes.

04:17:01.820 --> 04:17:02.660
John Berger?

04:17:02.660 --> 04:17:03.500
Yes.

04:17:03.500 --> 04:17:04.340
Chris Faucienten?

04:17:04.340 --> 04:17:05.180
Yes.

04:17:05.180 --> 04:17:06.020
Greg Lanci?

04:17:06.020 --> 04:17:06.860
Yes.

04:17:06.860 --> 04:17:07.700
Don Hock.

04:17:07.700 --> 04:17:08.700
Yes.

04:17:08.700 --> 04:17:10.500
Motion passes, seven to zero.

04:17:10.500 --> 04:17:14.460
we are moving into the executive session and journeying into the executive session.

04:17:14.460 --> 04:17:20.140
We will not be making any decisions in there, nor will we be coming back out and reconvening

04:17:20.140 --> 04:17:20.700
this evening.
