WEBVTT

00:02:08.560 --> 00:02:11.200
I'd like to call the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council Order.

00:02:11.200 --> 00:02:13.440
It's July 28th, 2014.

00:02:13.440 --> 00:02:17.760
And the first thing that we always do is we recite the Pledge of Allegiance.

00:02:17.760 --> 00:02:23.040
So everyone rise, please.

00:02:23.040 --> 00:02:23.540
Hi.

00:02:23.400 --> 00:02:37.460
I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

00:02:37.460 --> 00:02:39.140
I'd like to welcome everyone here tonight.

00:02:39.140 --> 00:02:43.100
We do have a full quorum of the City Council.

00:02:43.100 --> 00:02:48.930
Mr. Rothwiler, do we have any amendments to the agenda this evening?

00:02:48.930 --> 00:03:09.070
Mr. Mayor and members of the council, we do not, with the exception that staff would ask that if we are able to move through the items of consideration, and there is five to ten minutes to spare, we would request that we go into executive session if it meets council approval prior to the public hearing should time allow.

00:03:09.070 --> 00:03:11.070
We will do our best to do that. Thank you, Travis.

00:03:11.970 --> 00:03:19.370
Next item on the agenda is a proclamation and I know that Jeanette Row is here and I'll read the proclamation

00:03:19.370 --> 00:03:26.010
hand it off to you Jeanette and then we'll turn the mic over to you. It is Senior Appreciation Month 2014.

00:03:26.770 --> 00:03:31.830
Show your appreciation, open your heart, do your part, volunteer, share, and care.

00:03:32.510 --> 00:03:36.950
Whereas seniors have contributed and and continue to contribute

00:03:36.950 --> 00:03:43.170
immensely to the life and vibrancy of this community, and seniors continue to serve as

00:03:43.170 --> 00:03:51.890
leaders, mentors, historians, volunteers, and most importantly, dynamic members of this community.

00:03:51.890 --> 00:03:58.010
And their contributions past and present warrant appreciation and recognition, and their stories

00:03:58.010 --> 00:04:06.410
deserve to be told, and the health and well-being of seniors is in the interest of all and further

00:04:06.410 --> 00:04:12.970
adds to the health and well-being of the community and the knowledge and experience seniors pass

00:04:12.970 --> 00:04:19.170
on to us continues to benefit us all. Therefore, I, Don Hall, Mayor of Twin Falls, proclaim

00:04:19.170 --> 00:04:25.890
the month of August Senior Appreciation Month in Twin Falls, Idaho, and urge all citizens

00:04:25.890 --> 00:04:32.490
to recognize and celebrate the accomplishments of our seniors. I have had the privilege of

00:04:32.490 --> 00:04:35.850
of signing it along with our Deputy City Clerk,

00:04:35.850 --> 00:04:38.410
Leila Sanchez, so we will ask Jeannette Rowe

00:04:38.410 --> 00:04:40.850
from the Twin Falls Senior Center to come forward,

00:04:40.850 --> 00:04:54.300
and I'll hand this to her.

00:04:54.300 --> 00:04:55.140
No.

00:04:55.140 --> 00:05:03.630
Oh, she wants a picture.

00:05:03.630 --> 00:05:04.910
I had a smile too, Michelle.

00:05:04.910 --> 00:05:05.910
She was a little too.

00:05:05.910 --> 00:05:07.750
You're inside.

00:05:07.750 --> 00:05:09.230
That was a straight line.

00:05:09.230 --> 00:05:12.670
Yes, the main reason why I asked for this proclamation

00:05:12.670 --> 00:05:15.670
is the fact that we are really short of volunteer drivers

00:05:15.670 --> 00:05:17.710
of the Senior Center.

00:05:17.710 --> 00:05:21.550
And I want people to understand how vital it is

00:05:21.550 --> 00:05:27.070
the seniors in our community and I just want people to understand that they need to do something.

00:05:27.070 --> 00:05:31.750
How hard is it to go out and check on your neighbor to make sure that they're adequately

00:05:31.750 --> 00:05:33.590
hydrated, especially during these days.

00:05:33.590 --> 00:05:37.710
We had a gentleman when we delivered meals that had fallen and was laying on the floor.

00:05:37.710 --> 00:05:42.150
We find this on a daily basis, but people need to understand that elderly do not need

00:05:42.150 --> 00:05:46.310
to be out into this heat if they need to have their lawns mowed, maybe they need to have

00:05:46.310 --> 00:05:50.430
help going to the grocery store, maybe it's just picking up their mail, but please do

00:05:50.430 --> 00:05:56.750
do something, don't say it's somebody else's responsibility, take action and help somebody

00:05:56.750 --> 00:06:00.950
because morally that's what we all should be doing. It's just caring a little bit about

00:06:00.950 --> 00:06:06.030
our members of our community. And a lot of times seniors are the last people to think

00:06:06.030 --> 00:06:10.870
about. It's always about the kids, it's about the humane society, it's about the rats, it's

00:06:10.870 --> 00:06:16.150
whatever else that something else is that spikes people's interests. But I want people

00:06:16.150 --> 00:06:20.910
understand that these people, a lot of these stories are going to die. I've got a 96-year-old

00:06:20.910 --> 00:06:26.010
gentleman who's one of the last World War II vets who's still alive here at Twin Falls.

00:06:26.010 --> 00:06:30.690
We need to honor him and recognize the valuable history and the things that he's done for this

00:06:30.690 --> 00:06:35.430
country because in a year or two he may not be here. So those are the things and that was

00:06:35.430 --> 00:06:39.070
the reason for the proclamation. So thank you so very much.

00:06:39.070 --> 00:06:43.710
Well I would just add to that that a community is really judged in my opinion on how we take

00:06:43.710 --> 00:06:49.150
care of our youth and our seniors so you bringing this to us tonight and reminding us and I would

00:06:49.150 --> 00:06:54.070
encourage you to do this every year to remind us and everyone at home that we do need to reach

00:06:54.070 --> 00:06:55.070
out.

00:06:55.070 --> 00:06:56.070
Thank you.

00:06:56.070 --> 00:06:59.590
And we've got a lot of special activities planned at the center for this month and I'm

00:06:59.590 --> 00:07:04.830
trying to do a lot of things to recognize people and we've implemented a brand new website.

00:07:04.830 --> 00:07:08.710
We're still working on but we're going to start featuring seniors and veterans and things

00:07:08.710 --> 00:07:11.070
like that so people can get a little bit of idea.

00:07:11.070 --> 00:07:15.510
But a lot of people say, well, I just thought the senior centers where old people go and

00:07:15.510 --> 00:07:19.270
they don't do anything and it's sort of like the loose lodge, and there's not anything and

00:07:19.270 --> 00:07:23.270
not every outside people can come in, and that's not what it's about, and we don't have

00:07:23.270 --> 00:07:27.670
residents down there who live there, they come and they go and they socialize, but people need

00:07:27.670 --> 00:07:29.070
to see how vibrant it is.

00:07:29.070 --> 00:07:32.390
I had somebody described the other day and they said, I haven't been in here in a long

00:07:32.390 --> 00:07:36.770
long time, and it's really vibrant around here, and people are so excited and it's a happy

00:07:36.770 --> 00:07:37.770
place.

00:07:37.770 --> 00:07:38.770
What do you have going on?

00:07:38.770 --> 00:07:40.870
That's what we do, and that's what we're supposed to do.

00:07:40.870 --> 00:07:45.130
I agree. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you for coming to see

00:07:45.930 --> 00:07:52.370
Next item on the agenda is general public input. This is a time for anyone in the audience that would like to address the council that

00:07:52.370 --> 00:07:54.370
It's not something on the agenda

00:07:55.090 --> 00:07:59.210
That can come forward and address the council so we'll open up the mic for them

00:08:00.450 --> 00:08:03.900
Again, we don't see a mad rush to the mic

00:08:03.900 --> 00:08:08.140
So we will move on to the consent calendar and before we do the consent calendar

00:08:08.140 --> 00:08:09.900
I did want to mention

00:08:09.900 --> 00:08:15.320
One of the items on the consent calendar before we just bypass it or prove it and then move on is

00:08:16.140 --> 00:08:17.300
the

00:08:17.300 --> 00:08:21.200
2014 MDA filled the boot campaign on August 8th

00:08:21.820 --> 00:08:28.020
2014 at the intersection of Addison Avenue East and locus where our firefighters go out and

00:08:28.860 --> 00:08:35.180
For the day and collect money for MDA. So just wanted to make sure that I said that with folks at home watching that and

00:08:36.220 --> 00:08:39.660
I will then turn it over to council for their wishes on the consent calendar

00:08:39.900 --> 00:08:43.840
Greg Lanning. I'd like to be with approval and I think I saw the statistic

00:08:43.840 --> 00:08:49.180
when Burley was doing theirs at the race like $700,000 a year or something, some

00:08:49.180 --> 00:08:56.240
amount. $70,000. Okay, $70,000 for the state I'm talking. State every race like $70,000.

00:08:56.240 --> 00:09:00.340
Yeah, I think it's $70,000. Just with this one-day thing to describe versus I

00:09:00.340 --> 00:09:04.770
move approval to consent calendar. We have motion on the floor by Greg Lanning,

00:09:04.770 --> 00:09:09.250
Lansing, seconded by Jim Mann to approve the consent calendar. Do we have any further

00:09:09.250 --> 00:09:11.860
on that motion council.

00:09:11.860 --> 00:09:13.860
Leanna roll call vote please.

00:09:13.860 --> 00:09:14.860
Suzanne Hawkins.

00:09:14.860 --> 00:09:15.860
Yes.

00:09:15.860 --> 00:09:16.860
Jim Munn.

00:09:16.860 --> 00:09:17.860
Yes.

00:09:17.860 --> 00:09:18.860
Sean Berriger.

00:09:18.860 --> 00:09:19.860
Yes.

00:09:19.860 --> 00:09:20.860
Yes.

00:09:20.860 --> 00:09:21.860
Great 19.

00:09:21.860 --> 00:09:22.860
Yes.

00:09:22.860 --> 00:09:23.860
Don Hall.

00:09:23.860 --> 00:09:24.860
Yes.

00:09:24.860 --> 00:09:25.860
Becca Mills-Sueckett.

00:09:25.860 --> 00:09:26.860
Motion passes.

00:09:26.860 --> 00:09:27.860
Seven to zero.

00:09:27.860 --> 00:09:28.860
Now moving on to items for consideration.

00:09:28.860 --> 00:09:32.740
Before we go into the items for consideration, I'd like to ask our city attorney, First Wonder

00:09:32.740 --> 00:09:33.860
Lick to come forward.

00:09:33.860 --> 00:09:38.860
The first two items on the agenda have an element to the college of southern Idaho.

00:09:38.860 --> 00:09:44.320
attached to them and there's at least two or three members of the council that have

00:09:44.320 --> 00:09:49.360
some sort of affiliation with that fine organization. So for us, could you give us

00:09:49.360 --> 00:09:54.340
your legal opinion whether we can be part of the conversation? And you warned me

00:09:54.340 --> 00:09:59.860
about this and we talked about it earlier. These items all are to the benefit of the

00:09:59.860 --> 00:10:05.820
City of Twin Falls. They're not permits or applications by CSI requesting

00:10:05.820 --> 00:10:10.980
anything special, so my opinion is you do not have a conflict of interest.

00:10:10.980 --> 00:10:14.660
Thank you sir, I appreciate you coming forward and sharing that with us.

00:10:14.660 --> 00:10:19.400
So the first item is consideration of a request to accept the right-of-way for

00:10:19.400 --> 00:10:27.060
Chaney Drive project key 11495 and authorize the mayor to sign the right-of-way certificate.

00:10:27.060 --> 00:10:31.700
We have our city engineer Jackie Fields.

00:10:31.700 --> 00:10:33.020
Welcome Jackie.

00:10:33.020 --> 00:10:41.540
Thanks.

00:10:41.540 --> 00:10:44.440
Okay, so in order to go forward with the construction

00:10:44.440 --> 00:10:47.060
of the Chaney Drive project, we need to have right away

00:10:47.060 --> 00:10:49.020
in the position of the city.

00:10:49.020 --> 00:10:53.140
And so there were five parcels, and I neglected to give you

00:10:53.140 --> 00:10:57.250
two of the warranty deeds, because I needed to have them

00:10:57.250 --> 00:10:59.190
stitched so we could see where they are.

00:10:59.190 --> 00:11:04.280
So they're right here.

00:11:04.280 --> 00:11:06.560
And what those do, they're on the northern side

00:11:06.560 --> 00:11:09.520
of the property line, and that allows the project

00:11:09.520 --> 00:11:12.760
to go ahead and build the pavement to the property line

00:11:12.760 --> 00:11:15.440
and then tie it back in, because the pavement will be.

00:11:15.440 --> 00:11:19.400
You can't just leave it vertically at a property line.

00:11:19.400 --> 00:11:21.320
You have to have some way to tie it back in.

00:11:21.320 --> 00:11:24.640
So those two parcels on the north side of the road

00:11:24.640 --> 00:11:27.920
address the tie-in, and the rest of the parcels

00:11:27.920 --> 00:11:31.960
are from CSI to facilitate the construction of the project

00:11:31.960 --> 00:11:34.240
from Washington, the intersection of Washington Street,

00:11:34.240 --> 00:11:37.800
north of the dead end signal, which you have called it before.

00:11:37.800 --> 00:11:40.720
She was in Northern Trimines on North College

00:11:40.720 --> 00:11:47.530
near the driveway for Expo Center.

00:11:47.530 --> 00:11:51.210
I think that was actually the intersection to know where was the actual term.

00:11:51.210 --> 00:11:53.050
Okay, I stand correct.

00:11:53.050 --> 00:11:55.310
I was just a people is offended by that.

00:11:55.310 --> 00:11:57.490
By the rest of it.

00:11:57.490 --> 00:12:02.010
So the request tonight is that the council accept the right away and

00:12:02.010 --> 00:12:04.770
authorize the marriage sign the right away agreement.

00:12:04.770 --> 00:12:05.970
Thank you Jackie.

00:12:05.970 --> 00:12:08.110
Chris talking to so much.

00:12:08.110 --> 00:12:13.190
Second, we have a motion on floor by Chris talking to seconded by Greg Latting.

00:12:13.190 --> 00:12:17.750
To accept the right away for the genie dry project key one one four nine.

00:12:17.750 --> 00:12:22.310
and authorize the mayor to sign the right-of-way certificate.

00:12:22.310 --> 00:12:24.350
Anything further on that motion, council?

00:12:24.350 --> 00:12:27.660
The aye, the roll call vote, please.

00:12:27.660 --> 00:12:28.660
Jim and?

00:12:28.660 --> 00:12:29.660
Yes.

00:12:29.660 --> 00:12:30.660
Sean Burger.

00:12:30.660 --> 00:12:31.660
Yes.

00:12:31.660 --> 00:12:32.660
Chris Tockney.

00:12:32.660 --> 00:12:33.660
Yes.

00:12:33.660 --> 00:12:34.660
Greg Lenten.

00:12:34.660 --> 00:12:35.660
Yes.

00:12:35.660 --> 00:12:36.660
Don Hall.

00:12:36.660 --> 00:12:37.660
Yes.

00:12:37.660 --> 00:12:38.660
Rebecca Melsoica.

00:12:38.660 --> 00:12:39.660
Yes.

00:12:39.660 --> 00:12:40.660
Suzanne Hunt.

00:12:40.660 --> 00:12:41.660
Yes.

00:12:41.660 --> 00:12:42.660
Motion passes.

00:12:42.660 --> 00:12:43.660
Seven to zero.

00:12:43.660 --> 00:12:44.660
Thank you.

00:12:44.660 --> 00:12:45.660
Thank you, Jackie.

00:12:45.660 --> 00:12:50.860
Other items for considerations, consideration of a request to begin discussions and possible

00:12:50.860 --> 00:12:57.460
negotiations in partnership with the College of Southern Idaho for the possible acquisition

00:12:57.460 --> 00:13:02.060
of real property owned by the Idaho Department of Water Resources.

00:13:02.060 --> 00:13:04.460
And we have our own City Manager, Travis Rethweiler.

00:13:04.460 --> 00:13:05.460
Welcome, Travis.

00:13:05.460 --> 00:13:06.900
Thank you, Mr. Mayor and members of the Council.

00:13:06.900 --> 00:13:09.420
There are also, there'll be a brief presentation.

00:13:09.420 --> 00:13:15.620
I'm going to introduce a common and familiar partner with the city and that's Vince Alberti.

00:13:15.620 --> 00:13:31.500
We probably remember Vince from his many years of stewardship over the surface waters that we have in our canal company specifically, but now in his retirement, he is active on the Idaho Department of Water Resources Board of Directors.

00:13:31.500 --> 00:13:35.180
First, I want to set a couple of stages.

00:13:35.180 --> 00:13:43.000
Oftentimes, cities and other local government entities are allowed to negotiate matters

00:13:43.000 --> 00:13:50.540
of property acquisition and negotiate those matters until they reach a point of brightness

00:13:50.540 --> 00:13:52.100
in executive sessions.

00:13:52.100 --> 00:13:57.740
However, there is a clause in there that states that if, unless you're working with a public

00:13:57.740 --> 00:13:58.740
entity.

00:13:58.740 --> 00:14:03.740
The Idaho Department of Water Resources Board is a public entity, so therefore everything that

00:14:03.740 --> 00:14:13.740
we're doing tonight is really the initial conversations that we may have in a different setting if we're

00:14:13.740 --> 00:14:22.740
dealing with a private entity, which is very legal and very common with all government entities across the state.

00:14:22.740 --> 00:14:31.760
So tonight we present to you really to determine, engage the City Council's interest in negotiating

00:14:31.760 --> 00:14:36.780
for a possible land transaction for properties owned by the Idaho Department of Water Resources

00:14:36.780 --> 00:14:37.780
Board.

00:14:37.780 --> 00:14:47.580
Bryant Patton is going to give a brief presentation on the pristine springs complex which was part

00:14:47.580 --> 00:14:55.180
of the partnership that we used in conjunction with the state and the North Snake and the

00:14:55.180 --> 00:14:59.020
Magic Valley Groundwater Districts to satisfy a water call.

00:14:59.020 --> 00:15:04.700
And from that, we were able to receive the Sunnybrook Springs water right as well as

00:15:04.700 --> 00:15:11.700
have the pristine springs rights subordinated to us so we can maximum pump out of the Blue

00:15:11.700 --> 00:15:13.700
Lakes region.

00:15:13.700 --> 00:15:20.980
I'm going to have Brian come up and share a bit about the property to see if the council

00:15:20.980 --> 00:15:25.060
is really interested in moving forward and that's the point of the conversation.

00:15:25.060 --> 00:15:32.460
To see if this merits spending staff time moving forward to see if a possible agreement

00:15:32.460 --> 00:15:35.420
for acquisition of property makes sense.

00:15:35.420 --> 00:15:42.470
I will say on the front end, we do not have monies set aside for this.

00:15:42.470 --> 00:15:48.710
We do not have an idea at this point in time where monies would come from because we don't

00:15:48.710 --> 00:15:51.510
know how much we're looking at.

00:15:51.510 --> 00:15:57.950
And we have not negotiated any prices, any arrangements and so on and so forth.

00:15:57.950 --> 00:16:03.510
The college is here, not because they're acquiring the property, but the college is

00:16:03.510 --> 00:16:07.150
here because they may be a possible partner as well.

00:16:07.150 --> 00:16:12.830
And also this evening we have Dr. Fox and Mike Mason with the college, and they may be able

00:16:12.830 --> 00:16:19.870
to express what interests the college may or may not have in the acquisition of this parcel

00:16:19.870 --> 00:16:21.830
should that come to be.

00:16:21.830 --> 00:16:26.430
So with that I'm going to introduce Vince Alberti, and you can introduce our next speaker, which

00:16:26.430 --> 00:16:28.430
is Brian Pat.

00:16:28.430 --> 00:16:30.430
Thank you, Travis.

00:16:30.430 --> 00:16:31.430
Thank you, sir.

00:16:31.430 --> 00:16:32.430
Welcome, Vince.

00:16:32.430 --> 00:16:33.690
Thank you, well.

00:16:33.690 --> 00:16:38.330
Mayor Hall and members of the council, it's always good to stand and

00:16:38.330 --> 00:16:42.110
visit with you in regards to something that's very near and dear to my heart.

00:16:42.110 --> 00:16:48.590
First of all, as our city manager, my name is Vince Elbury.

00:16:48.590 --> 00:16:53.670
I'm on my second term as a member of the Idaho Water Resource Board.

00:16:53.670 --> 00:17:00.150
And when I got into this job, I didn't have any idea of all of the parameters and

00:17:00.150 --> 00:17:04.590
all the various things that the Water Resource Board's involved in.

00:17:04.590 --> 00:17:09.750
But one of the things that we're very interested in is, I think most all of us are interested

00:17:09.750 --> 00:17:18.400
in, and that's our gone aquifer out here, and we're trying to help that aquifer all we can

00:17:18.400 --> 00:17:21.280
because the depletions continue.

00:17:21.280 --> 00:17:26.720
So the Water Resource Board has looked at some of the properties that we may do something

00:17:26.720 --> 00:17:33.440
with sell to folks maybe such as yourself, take that money and with that money then build

00:17:33.440 --> 00:17:41.200
some infrastructure. If you remember or happen to keep up with the legislature last year,

00:17:41.200 --> 00:17:49.640
you know that the legislature was very interested and directed us to do more on aquifer recharge.

00:17:49.640 --> 00:17:55.520
So when we look at what we might be able to do, one of the things is the pristine springs

00:17:55.520 --> 00:18:01.160
property that we own. If we were to place that pristine springs property and you were

00:18:01.160 --> 00:18:08.080
interested in it, then that frees our funds up to move those resources and then build

00:18:08.080 --> 00:18:15.180
some infrastructure to get some meaningful offer re-charge done. So we've invited Brian

00:18:15.180 --> 00:18:21.860
Patton. Brian is our chief administrator for both the department and the Water Resource

00:18:21.860 --> 00:18:28.660
Board. He's put a PowerPoint presentation together to kind of introduce you into the project so

00:18:28.660 --> 00:18:34.380
that you know what's there and what the possibilities might be for the city. And so with that, I'd

00:18:34.380 --> 00:18:36.500
like to introduce Brian Patton.

00:18:36.500 --> 00:18:53.610
Thank you, Mr. Alberti. And welcome, Mr. Patton.

00:18:53.610 --> 00:18:59.170
Well, thank you, Mr. Mayor and members of the City Council. As Vince said, my name is Brian

00:18:59.170 --> 00:19:04.730
Patton with the Department of Water Resources. One of my roles at the department is as the

00:19:04.730 --> 00:19:07.570
executive officer for the Idaho Water Resource Board.

00:19:07.570 --> 00:19:11.990
So I basically run around the state, making sure that they do the things that they're

00:19:11.990 --> 00:19:24.650
supposed to do when we get the job done.

00:19:24.650 --> 00:20:26.240
Technology is a wonderful thing when it works.

00:20:26.240 --> 00:20:28.240
It's the same one as this, sir.

00:20:28.240 --> 00:20:29.240
Yes, yes.

00:20:29.240 --> 00:20:30.240
Maybe we can put it on the overhead wall.

00:20:30.240 --> 00:20:45.730
She continues to work that going old school.

00:20:45.730 --> 00:20:46.730
That works for me.

00:20:46.730 --> 00:20:54.790
Well, thank you for allowing me a few minutes this evening to talk about Christine Springs.

00:20:54.790 --> 00:21:01.790
and where the water board is at in moving forward with that project and what its interests

00:21:01.790 --> 00:21:05.250
might be currently forward.

00:21:05.250 --> 00:21:10.050
I think most folks here probably under probably know where pristine springs is.

00:21:10.050 --> 00:21:17.210
It's located down in the canyon, just downstream of the Blue Lakes golf course, or Blue Lakes

00:21:17.210 --> 00:21:23.490
Country Club, excuse me, and is the property that's generally circled in the oval.

00:21:23.490 --> 00:21:31.140
encompasses everything from about this point here down to this bend in the river and everything

00:21:31.140 --> 00:21:45.640
between the river and the canyon rim. So the Idaho Water Resource Board, in cooperation

00:21:45.640 --> 00:21:56.780
with its partners, purchased this facility back in 2008 before the facility was purchased.

00:21:56.780 --> 00:22:00.580
This is a description of the land and water rights that were associated with the facility.

00:22:00.580 --> 00:22:06.100
is approximately 400 acres in size.

00:22:06.100 --> 00:22:27.950
Oh, just no problem, thank you.

00:22:27.950 --> 00:22:29.110
Okay, thank you.

00:22:29.110 --> 00:22:31.370
It's approximately 400 acres in size.

00:22:32.470 --> 00:22:37.470
It had 25 CFS of fresh water from Alfie's Creek.

00:22:38.070 --> 00:22:40.590
Had a water right to reuse all the water

00:22:40.590 --> 00:22:44.590
that is passed down from the Blue Lakes trout farm.

00:22:44.590 --> 00:22:46.710
Has water rights on sunny brook springs,

00:22:46.710 --> 00:22:49.110
water rights from the geothermal aquifer,

00:22:49.110 --> 00:22:53.550
and water rights for storage in the pond and water rights

00:22:53.550 --> 00:22:57.850
for hydropower.

00:22:57.850 --> 00:23:00.930
This is just a description of the fish raceways.

00:23:00.930 --> 00:23:03.250
The primary purpose for that facility

00:23:03.250 --> 00:23:06.770
was as an operational commercial fish farm.

00:23:06.770 --> 00:23:12.210
Had raceways that would take about 175 CFS

00:23:12.210 --> 00:23:15.810
in the upper bank of raceways and about 195 CFS

00:23:15.810 --> 00:23:21.790
in the lower bank of raceways.

00:23:21.790 --> 00:23:26.990
The facility also includes two small hydroelectric power plants.

00:23:26.990 --> 00:23:31.470
The smallest one is 125 kilowatts and actually uses

00:23:31.470 --> 00:23:34.110
artesian pressure from the geothermal aquifer

00:23:34.110 --> 00:23:36.270
to turn the power turbine.

00:23:36.270 --> 00:23:39.510
It produces about 900,000 kilowatt hours

00:23:39.510 --> 00:23:41.190
a year in annual generation.

00:23:41.190 --> 00:23:45.870
Then there is a more traditional low-head small hydro located

00:23:45.870 --> 00:23:48.350
the bottom end of the facility as all the water

00:23:48.350 --> 00:23:53.990
drops back to the Snake River and it produces about 1.4 million kilowatt hours of annual

00:23:53.990 --> 00:24:00.230
generation. There are also farm facilities associated with the property. It's approximately

00:24:00.230 --> 00:24:06.430
200 acres are under irrigation. Some of that is planted throughout the Alpha. The rest of

00:24:06.430 --> 00:24:23.520
it is in irrigated pasture and it's set up primarily as a cattle ranching operation.

00:24:23.520 --> 00:24:28.880
So when the Idaho Water Resource Board purchased this facility back in 2008, it did so with

00:24:28.880 --> 00:24:32.840
the help of three partners, one of which was the City of Twin Falls.

00:24:32.840 --> 00:24:39.440
The City of Twin Falls contributed $10 million toward that purchase in exchange for the first

00:24:39.440 --> 00:24:45.240
right to use water from Sunnybrook Springs and then this is a little difficult to explain

00:24:45.240 --> 00:24:51.680
if you're not a water rights guy, but basically the subordination of the Christine Springs

00:24:51.680 --> 00:24:56.280
water right from Alfeas Creek to the city's existing water rights.

00:24:56.280 --> 00:25:02.600
that move the city's water rights up in priority, allowing the city's rights from Blue Lakes

00:25:02.600 --> 00:25:09.000
to come in line ahead of these water rights, thereby giving the city an additional 15 CFS

00:25:09.000 --> 00:25:14.920
should it need it for future growth and also to assist with the water quality issues.

00:25:14.920 --> 00:25:22.520
The groundwater districts also contributed $11 million toward that purchase for 10 CFS

00:25:22.520 --> 00:25:25.240
from the Alfeas Creek Water Right,

00:25:25.240 --> 00:25:32.200
in order to meet the water delivery call from Blue Lakes.

00:25:32.200 --> 00:25:35.360
So the financing structure that was put in place

00:25:35.360 --> 00:25:38.640
for this purchase consisted of $5 million

00:25:38.640 --> 00:25:40.640
from the Idaho Water Resource Board,

00:25:40.640 --> 00:25:43.400
$11 million to the groundwater districts,

00:25:44.320 --> 00:25:47.280
10 million of which was loaned to the districts

00:25:47.280 --> 00:25:50.400
by the board, so the board carried that note.

00:25:50.400 --> 00:25:52.960
$10 million from the City of Twin Falls,

00:25:52.960 --> 00:25:57.560
So the Water Board carried a short-term note there,

00:25:57.560 --> 00:26:00.240
was paid off within, I believe, six months.

00:26:00.240 --> 00:26:03.240
And then the Water Board retained all of the assets

00:26:03.240 --> 00:26:05.040
that were not sold either to the city

00:26:05.040 --> 00:26:13.150
or the groundwater districts.

00:26:13.150 --> 00:26:15.110
So the two groundwater districts,

00:26:15.110 --> 00:26:16.510
North Snake and Magic Valley,

00:26:16.510 --> 00:26:19.870
have been repain those that $10 million note

00:26:19.870 --> 00:26:21.710
to the Water Resource Board.

00:26:23.600 --> 00:26:28.600
They have 13 more scheduled payments of about $716,000

00:26:28.600 --> 00:26:36.160
years a year and those funds have been turned back around and made available for aquifer

00:26:36.160 --> 00:26:40.960
monitoring measurement and modeling on the eastern snake plane aquifer.

00:26:40.960 --> 00:26:48.970
So we're trying to turn those funds around and maximize the use of those dollars.

00:26:48.970 --> 00:26:57.190
The water board has been receiving some rental and hydropower cash flows or revenues.

00:26:57.190 --> 00:27:03.790
And the property was purchased, it was purchased from CPAC, commercial fish producer here in the

00:27:03.790 --> 00:27:05.290
valley.

00:27:05.290 --> 00:27:08.990
They stayed on as a tenant through 2012.

00:27:08.990 --> 00:27:11.110
They terminated the lease in 2012.

00:27:11.110 --> 00:27:17.200
There has been no fish production in the facility since that point.

00:27:17.200 --> 00:27:22.560
The water board is receiving revenue from hydro power sales to Idaho Power.

00:27:22.560 --> 00:27:26.040
Those current power sales agreements run through next year.

00:27:26.040 --> 00:27:30.960
have actually started the renewal process for those power sales contracts as we don't

00:27:30.960 --> 00:27:36.880
know exactly how long we may be owning this facility. Some of the farm facilities are leased

00:27:36.880 --> 00:27:43.240
out at about $20,000 a year. These funds have gone into a project reserve fund that we actually

00:27:43.240 --> 00:27:48.160
have drawn down for a couple of different things, one of which was to replace the fresh

00:27:48.160 --> 00:28:05.860
water pipeline here shortly, not too long ago.

00:28:05.860 --> 00:28:13.140
So what has changed at the facility since we purchased it, the fresh water diverted

00:28:13.140 --> 00:28:18.780
from Alfeas Creek to the pristine springs property has been reduced as 10 CFS went of

00:28:18.780 --> 00:28:19.780
that.

00:28:19.780 --> 00:28:24.180
10 CFS of that, excuse me, went to the ground water districts who are then turning around

00:28:24.180 --> 00:28:29.980
and delivering it to the Blue Lakes Trout Farm in order to mitigate the water call.

00:28:29.980 --> 00:28:34.460
That does come back to pristine springs as reused water, but for fish production that has

00:28:34.460 --> 00:28:44.100
a lesser value. We did reduce the geothermal water use from 7 CFS to 4.5 CFS. When we purchased

00:28:44.100 --> 00:28:49.500
it there was some discrepancy about whether the actual water right was for 7 or whether

00:28:49.500 --> 00:28:54.500
it was for 4.5 and it was interesting I took it to our attorney and said which is it. He

00:28:54.500 --> 00:29:03.480
said I could argue either one and one. So when we purchased it we looked at that and said

00:29:03.480 --> 00:29:07.140
One of the issues in the Twin Falls area is declining

00:29:07.140 --> 00:29:09.600
Artesian pressures in the geothermal aquifer.

00:29:09.600 --> 00:29:13.720
Is this a way to try and maybe assist with that issue?

00:29:13.720 --> 00:29:16.940
So the board voluntarily throttled back the use to four

00:29:16.940 --> 00:29:19.440
and a half in order to see what would happen.

00:29:19.440 --> 00:29:24.240
And the Artesian pressures in the geothermal aquifer

00:29:24.240 --> 00:29:28.670
rebounded substantially with that reduction of use.

00:29:28.670 --> 00:29:32.030
We do anticipate further reductions in alpheus

00:29:32.030 --> 00:29:39.450
Creek deliveries to pristine springs as the city grows and starts to make use of that 15

00:29:39.450 --> 00:29:45.710
CFS of water that was made available from Blue Lakes as a result of this purchase.

00:29:45.710 --> 00:29:50.830
And then this is a fairly important piece right here, the freshwater pipeline which is

00:29:50.830 --> 00:29:57.390
owned jointly between or it's owned actually by Blue Lakes Trout but the water is delivered

00:29:57.390 --> 00:29:59.950
to pristine springs through it.

00:29:59.950 --> 00:30:05.670
We joined, we replaced that here shortly, or excuse me, recently, in cooperation with Blue

00:30:05.670 --> 00:30:11.150
Lakes Trout and the groundwater districts.

00:30:11.150 --> 00:30:14.010
So what were the outcomes of that purchase?

00:30:14.010 --> 00:30:18.670
The North Snake and Magic Valley groundwater districts gained access to water that they

00:30:18.670 --> 00:30:24.910
needed in order to meet their mitigation obligations under the water delivery call.

00:30:24.910 --> 00:30:31.270
The city gained access to water supplies for future growth resolved depending litigation

00:30:31.270 --> 00:30:38.750
over water quality and TMDL issues in that reach of the river as CPAC was actually in litigation

00:30:38.750 --> 00:30:44.910
with a state or pending litigation with a state, over load allocations.

00:30:44.910 --> 00:30:56.720
And then we reduced the use of that geothermal aquifer, as I mentioned previously.

00:30:56.720 --> 00:31:04.260
So where we are right now is the water board has basically accomplished the goals that it

00:31:04.260 --> 00:31:06.300
set out to achieve with this project.

00:31:06.300 --> 00:31:10.060
We acquired the project, redistribute the water supplies

00:31:10.060 --> 00:31:13.260
to those who may need it in order to resolve water delivery calls,

00:31:13.260 --> 00:31:16.310
provide for future growth in the area.

00:31:16.310 --> 00:31:19.990
The legislature and the Water Board have intended

00:31:19.990 --> 00:31:25.310
that those remaining assets be leveraged or flipped, if you will.

00:31:25.310 --> 00:31:29.510
And those financial resources be made available

00:31:29.510 --> 00:31:33.670
to address other water problems in the area.

00:31:33.670 --> 00:31:37.410
Since that purchase, the board has been realizing a revenue stream,

00:31:37.410 --> 00:31:40.710
started out at about $360,000 a year.

00:31:40.710 --> 00:31:45.510
It is now around $100,000 a year, primarily from hydropower sales.

00:31:45.510 --> 00:31:50.590
We have intentionally not leased out the fish facilities to a tenant

00:31:50.590 --> 00:31:56.070
as we've been going around the area and engaging interest

00:31:56.070 --> 00:32:01.980
that folks may have in the facility.

00:32:01.980 --> 00:32:05.380
So we have been discussing this facility with various parties,

00:32:05.380 --> 00:32:10.720
including CSI, including some commercial fish producers.

00:32:10.720 --> 00:32:14.440
The board, the water board has designated Mr. Alberti

00:32:14.440 --> 00:32:17.680
to be their lead in going out, engaging this interest

00:32:17.680 --> 00:32:22.840
and potentially reaching some proposed agreements.

00:32:22.840 --> 00:32:25.600
And just as an aside, I would say you have a very good

00:32:25.600 --> 00:32:27.360
representative on the water resource board.

00:32:27.360 --> 00:32:30.120
He does a great job.

00:32:30.120 --> 00:32:34.760
We have been discussing with the college

00:32:34.760 --> 00:32:39.720
the possibility of their interest in the geothermal facilities.

00:32:39.720 --> 00:32:41.880
They do appear interested in that.

00:32:41.880 --> 00:32:44.080
And we've had just some very preliminary discussions

00:32:44.080 --> 00:32:47.480
with Travis about the city's interest

00:32:47.480 --> 00:32:50.480
in the remainder of the facilities.

00:32:50.480 --> 00:32:54.840
So I believe that's what I've got for you this morning.

00:32:54.840 --> 00:32:58.040
Mr. Mayor, excuse me, and we'll send Mr. Chairman

00:32:58.040 --> 00:32:59.320
for us a bit.

00:32:59.320 --> 00:33:02.120
Kind of the same thing here, but that's all right.

00:33:02.120 --> 00:33:07.920
And if it's allowed, I'd be happy to answer any questions

00:33:07.920 --> 00:33:11.280
that any members of the council may have.

00:33:11.280 --> 00:33:11.880
Very good, sir.

00:33:11.880 --> 00:33:12.380
Thank you.

00:33:12.380 --> 00:33:13.560
Chris talking to.

00:33:13.560 --> 00:33:19.240
Mr. Patton or Mr. Albert, either of you or both of you.

00:33:19.240 --> 00:33:22.680
This is a non-consumptive water right.

00:33:22.680 --> 00:33:25.800
Twin falls would require a consumptive usage.

00:33:25.800 --> 00:33:31.360
Is that a legal dispute that cannot be resolved?

00:33:31.360 --> 00:33:39.960
Mr. Mayor, Mr. Talkington, that is actually why we had to use the subordination arrangement.

00:33:39.960 --> 00:33:44.540
You can't take a non-consumptive water right and turn it into a consumptive water right,

00:33:44.540 --> 00:33:46.960
such as the city would utilize.

00:33:46.960 --> 00:33:58.200
So when the property was purchased in that partnership arrangement back in 2008, the arrangement

00:33:58.200 --> 00:34:06.740
that was struck was that the state, after it acquired the pristine springs waterite for

00:34:06.740 --> 00:34:13.340
25 CFS, would split 10 CFS of that off, sell that to the ground water districts for their

00:34:13.340 --> 00:34:14.340
needs.

00:34:14.340 --> 00:34:19.280
Then the remainder remaining 15 CFS would then be subordinated or we would voluntarily

00:34:19.280 --> 00:34:26.290
say, the city's waterite is here, the pristine springs waterite was here ahead of it, we're

00:34:26.290 --> 00:34:29.730
We're going to take that and move it back here so the city's water right comes before

00:34:29.730 --> 00:34:31.770
ours.

00:34:31.770 --> 00:34:36.730
So that's the arrangement that was made in order to get around that issue of non-consumptive

00:34:36.730 --> 00:34:38.930
versus consumptive water rights.

00:34:38.930 --> 00:34:45.590
Travis, did you want to add something to that?

00:34:45.590 --> 00:34:49.030
Do we have any more questions?

00:34:49.030 --> 00:34:50.030
Greg Lang?

00:34:50.030 --> 00:34:56.300
Well, I guess it always comes down to when you're talking about what is it you're looking

00:34:56.300 --> 00:35:00.560
to, I guess the big example, what are you looking to sell to the city and what might

00:35:00.560 --> 00:35:09.500
cost. Mr. Mayor, Mr. Lansing, we are at the present, we're gauging interest. We're

00:35:09.500 --> 00:35:13.740
seeing, would the City of Twin Falls have any interest in part or all of this

00:35:13.740 --> 00:35:18.780
facility? We know that the college may have some interest in at least the

00:35:18.780 --> 00:35:24.420
geothermal facilities. Are there arrangements that could be put together

00:35:24.420 --> 00:35:28.420
that maybe provide a win-win-win if you will.

00:35:28.420 --> 00:35:34.420
As far as cost, I think the Water Resource Board

00:35:34.420 --> 00:35:41.820
would be probably looking to get back its investment out of the facility.

00:35:41.820 --> 00:35:45.820
However, there have been a couple of recent appraisals that indicate

00:35:45.820 --> 00:35:50.820
the current value is probably less than the board's $5 million investment.

00:35:50.820 --> 00:35:53.660
Do I have to follow up?

00:35:53.660 --> 00:35:56.810
I have to follow up.

00:35:56.810 --> 00:35:58.810
That threw me on that last one.

00:35:58.810 --> 00:36:05.810
I guess my question is, the following question would be, Travis, and either Vince or you, Mr. Pan.

00:36:05.810 --> 00:36:11.810
If we were to utilize that, the perstrain water for a future use in Flint Falls,

00:36:11.810 --> 00:36:15.810
do we have any place to build a pumping station to do that?

00:36:15.810 --> 00:36:20.250
So I think it's important to recognize that we are not looking at this from a water interest

00:36:20.250 --> 00:36:22.850
standpoint.

00:36:22.850 --> 00:36:29.130
The property went through a process and because the water rights were subordinated to us, there

00:36:29.130 --> 00:36:34.530
is some question like it was being described in terms of is there value to those water rights

00:36:34.530 --> 00:36:36.330
to the city of Twin Falls.

00:36:36.330 --> 00:36:41.770
We're looking at this maybe for a very, very different purpose than what it was originally

00:36:41.770 --> 00:36:43.970
acquired for and that is water.

00:36:43.970 --> 00:36:49.450
When we've looked at this parcel, this may be an opportunity to capture additional open

00:36:49.450 --> 00:36:54.350
space in the canyon right across from Auger Falls.

00:36:54.350 --> 00:36:59.850
And so what we've done is we've outlined where the Auger Falls property is, and we've outlined

00:36:59.850 --> 00:37:03.450
where the pristine springs property is as well.

00:37:03.450 --> 00:37:10.970
Again, that pristine springs property is about 400 acres, and Mr. Patton went through

00:37:10.970 --> 00:37:16.570
and kind of described how that is kind of arranged in terms of its current uses.

00:37:16.570 --> 00:37:23.770
The second piece is we believe and it would take additional exploration, but in our plenary

00:37:23.770 --> 00:37:31.410
search, we believe that the NPDS permit or the discharge permit that was originally connected

00:37:31.410 --> 00:37:37.410
to the fish hatchery may have some value to the city as we look at the possibility of maybe

00:37:37.410 --> 00:37:42.130
lifting that and moving that over to our wastewater treatment plant.

00:37:42.130 --> 00:37:50.010
We don't know if that's entirely feasible, but in very, very early and preliminary conversations,

00:37:50.010 --> 00:37:52.330
we've been told that it's generally possible.

00:37:52.330 --> 00:37:58.120
And to look back to Jackie to make sure I got that wording right.

00:37:58.120 --> 00:38:05.200
So again, this would be more of a recreational opportunity, an open space opportunity.

00:38:05.200 --> 00:38:10.820
he would expand the amount of property that we have in the canyon from approximately a little

00:38:10.820 --> 00:38:21.990
more than 600 acres to almost 1,100 acres, and that we would possibly be able to lift those

00:38:21.990 --> 00:38:25.430
credits and move them over to our waste water treatment.

00:38:25.430 --> 00:38:26.430
Thank you, Travis.

00:38:26.430 --> 00:38:30.390
We have a couple other lights on, but I want to make sure that we are aware and remind us

00:38:30.390 --> 00:38:35.990
that we do have President Fox as well as Vice President Mason here as well from the CSI if

00:38:35.990 --> 00:38:37.370
we have any questions for them.

00:38:37.370 --> 00:38:39.590
And also, through the seat, is joint.

00:38:39.590 --> 00:38:41.030
And Mr. Eaton is here as well.

00:38:41.030 --> 00:38:42.110
Thank you.

00:38:42.110 --> 00:38:43.470
Rebecca Milsoy.

00:38:43.470 --> 00:38:44.750
Thank you, Mayor.

00:38:44.750 --> 00:38:48.790
Just a similar question in regards to evaluating, you know,

00:38:48.790 --> 00:38:51.950
what kind of benefit it would be to the citizens

00:38:51.950 --> 00:38:54.510
for a roughly 5 million investment.

00:38:54.510 --> 00:38:57.270
You know, we've invested the 10 million for the water rights,

00:38:57.270 --> 00:39:01.030
and kind of that's gotten the city where we need to be.

00:39:01.030 --> 00:39:04.830
What would the other benefits be to acquiring this property?

00:39:04.830 --> 00:39:05.830
You know, off the top.

00:39:05.830 --> 00:39:06.830
It's property.

00:39:06.830 --> 00:39:11.750
Yes, so that's where we really need to see if we're interested in moving and exploring

00:39:11.750 --> 00:39:12.750
and going forward.

00:39:12.750 --> 00:39:14.590
We have not done any cost-benefit analysis.

00:39:14.590 --> 00:39:20.630
We haven't really been able to describe the true and total benefit of 400 acres.

00:39:20.630 --> 00:39:23.910
I personally have not been to the property, so I can't.

00:39:23.910 --> 00:39:28.430
I don't have boots on the ground to really describe what that could be.

00:39:28.430 --> 00:39:36.510
If I look at the success of the Augur Falls project and the popularity of Augur Falls and

00:39:36.510 --> 00:39:43.870
say that there may be some value, I'm drawn to open space and recreation.

00:39:43.870 --> 00:39:50.230
Again the water issue is in the water value, the water benefit probably may not exist directly

00:39:50.230 --> 00:40:01.510
to us, and the nutrient value may be able to be expanded to help grow our NPS permit to

00:40:01.510 --> 00:40:04.070
help with our loadings and TMDLs.

00:40:04.070 --> 00:40:09.130
I think you really don't have a lot of specific answers.

00:40:09.130 --> 00:40:16.610
This is, again, to see if there is at least interest in from the Council in kicking the

00:40:16.610 --> 00:40:23.790
to see if this is something that we want to investigate more fully to go forward with.

00:40:23.790 --> 00:40:30.990
I think that, you know, as Mr. Patton shared, the water resource board and the state initially

00:40:30.990 --> 00:40:37.710
invested $5 million, but there have, as I'm aware, there are appraisals that have come

00:40:37.710 --> 00:40:44.460
back and said that the property may be valued less than that, shall we?

00:40:44.460 --> 00:40:58.460
Sure, well with that information it is a little difficult, it is kind of difficult to gauge interest, but you know I think we have a lot of work to do a lot of investment to do at Agar Falls and I think that will probably preoccupy us for some time.

00:40:58.460 --> 00:41:12.460
I guess if there's no other pressing benefit, you know, things like the new city hall and new facilities are to me probably more pressing needs at this time.

00:41:12.460 --> 00:41:20.740
But I'll remain open, but at this time, I'd probably say I can't really see that there's

00:41:20.740 --> 00:41:23.420
a significant benefit to the cost.

00:41:23.420 --> 00:41:24.420
Okay.

00:41:24.420 --> 00:41:25.420
Thank you, Rebecca.

00:41:25.420 --> 00:41:26.420
Chris, talking.

00:41:26.420 --> 00:41:29.380
Yeah, I just had a follow-up question, but first answer your question, Rebecca, I think

00:41:29.380 --> 00:41:37.220
the TMDL litigation is a very significant issue and one that could impact our ability

00:41:37.220 --> 00:41:43.060
to discharge into Snake River with a growing community.

00:41:43.060 --> 00:41:47.780
I think there's a very real value there, but I did have one little follow-up to the question

00:41:47.780 --> 00:41:58.640
on the consumptive use, so the subordination is a legal way for us to raise our first and

00:41:58.640 --> 00:42:06.530
right, first and time first and right, and is that supported by case law in Idaho?

00:42:06.530 --> 00:42:13.890
Mr. Mayor, Mr. Talkington, yes, that has been done with this facility.

00:42:13.890 --> 00:42:20.330
That was what the city paid $10 million to accomplish back in 2008.

00:42:20.330 --> 00:42:23.730
So we wrote our own case law.

00:42:23.730 --> 00:42:27.610
Support nation is actually fairly well recognized, you're not the only ones that have done it.

00:42:27.610 --> 00:42:31.690
It's happened when part of the region agreed to do so.

00:42:31.690 --> 00:42:32.610
Thank you.

00:42:32.610 --> 00:42:35.090
Mr. Pan, I just want to tell you we're a little more informal here.

00:42:35.090 --> 00:42:36.090
This isn't the legislature.

00:42:36.090 --> 00:42:40.250
You don't have to address me first before you address the candidates.

00:42:40.250 --> 00:42:41.450
Thank you, Mr. Mayor, to have it happen.

00:42:41.450 --> 00:42:44.050
I really appreciate it, but it's not necessary.

00:42:44.050 --> 00:42:45.050
Greg Manning.

00:42:45.050 --> 00:42:50.330
I guess I would like to have Dr. Fox or whoever is speaking for the campus to come up and they're

00:42:50.330 --> 00:42:56.610
the colleagues to come up and let us know their level of interest and how much they might

00:42:56.610 --> 00:42:59.770
be willing to partner with us for the geothermal.

00:42:59.770 --> 00:43:04.610
Apparently it's down to 4.5 at this point that what the water resources would be selling.

00:43:04.610 --> 00:43:08.610
Mr. Mayor, members of the council, I'm Mike Mason, Vice President of the administration

00:43:08.610 --> 00:43:13.250
for the College of Southern Idaho. As you may know, all of our buildings on campus, the major

00:43:13.250 --> 00:43:18.790
ones, are heated with geothermal water. We have a heat pump system that we run the geothermal

00:43:18.790 --> 00:43:24.050
water through. And years ago, we had a backup electrical system, but we don't have that now.

00:43:24.050 --> 00:43:30.490
As Mr. Patton said, there is a direct correlation from what comes out of the canyon to our levels

00:43:30.490 --> 00:43:36.290
of geothermal pressure. We do have to pump it, but we are extremely nervous about anybody

00:43:36.290 --> 00:43:40.330
else gaining control of that water. Water resources have been very good to work with. They have

00:43:40.330 --> 00:43:45.550
monitored it closely and they have ensured that our flows are actually stable. But if

00:43:45.550 --> 00:43:50.210
somebody else did get that, it would be a significant concern for us. So we are very interested

00:43:50.210 --> 00:43:55.050
in the geothermal water from that aspect. As far as the rest of the property and college

00:43:55.050 --> 00:44:00.290
use, we don't really see a future use for that at this time. But the geothermal is what

00:44:00.290 --> 00:44:06.490
we covered. And I think we've been discussions with water resources in various entities probably

00:44:06.490 --> 00:44:09.810
over four years on those geothermal water rights.

00:44:09.810 --> 00:44:19.480
Well, I mean, further I'd just like to weigh in, Rebecca, I would at least like to explore

00:44:19.480 --> 00:44:27.040
further what this range might be. The MPDS permit is very interesting because we keep hearing

00:44:27.040 --> 00:44:32.960
that we may be struggling in other areas to meet that or potentially meet it in the

00:44:32.960 --> 00:44:38.120
future, so I think I'm ready to look further, especially if we can partner with CSI, I think

00:44:38.120 --> 00:44:43.400
you're looking to maybe cap it so you keep your levels higher, is that what I'm hearing?

00:44:43.400 --> 00:44:48.120
Mr. Allen, we'd either cap it or we'd continue to use it for agentery and thermal water source.

00:44:48.120 --> 00:44:52.040
There are some educational purposes that we could use it for in starting some of our programs

00:44:52.040 --> 00:44:56.240
and, you know, archaeology and engineering and those type of things, but we would probably

00:44:56.240 --> 00:45:03.440
We have to get it re-permitted to use it solely for a geothermal water generation process,

00:45:03.440 --> 00:45:07.720
which would be able to go down that road.

00:45:07.720 --> 00:45:10.480
We also would really look forward to partnering with the city.

00:45:10.480 --> 00:45:15.520
We would certainly be amicable to taking to our board any kind of agreement we could

00:45:15.520 --> 00:45:18.200
reach or a negotiation that we could go through.

00:45:18.200 --> 00:45:19.550
Okay.

00:45:19.550 --> 00:45:20.550
Thank you, Mr. Mason.

00:45:20.550 --> 00:45:22.510
I have a question for you, Travis.

00:45:22.510 --> 00:45:30.150
So if this came to fruition, what about the power generation and the income from that?

00:45:30.150 --> 00:45:32.230
What does that look like?

00:45:32.230 --> 00:45:38.430
My understanding is, Krik, from wrong, a bulk of the power generation is associated with

00:45:38.430 --> 00:45:48.690
the geothermal 50-50, so there is a portion of that that may go away depending upon how

00:45:48.690 --> 00:45:51.410
that college looks like and how it goes forward.

00:45:51.410 --> 00:45:58.170
The other piece could certainly be a revenue source of some amount, I believe, that Mr.

00:45:58.170 --> 00:46:01.370
Patton illustrated it's about $300,000 a year.

00:46:01.370 --> 00:46:04.200
Over $100,000 a year?

00:46:04.200 --> 00:46:06.960
About $110,000 a year.

00:46:06.960 --> 00:46:14.460
Yeah, so, and then you also have the ranch piece that would generate some additional possible

00:46:14.460 --> 00:46:20.620
revenues if it wasn't applied to open space, so I wouldn't necessarily look at this as

00:46:20.620 --> 00:46:30.460
a significant revenue source, it certainly could be used to repay back funds that the city

00:46:30.460 --> 00:46:33.900
may use to move forward.

00:46:33.900 --> 00:46:38.780
Should the council believe it's appropriate in the first step and should we be able to

00:46:38.780 --> 00:46:42.220
negotiate an agreement with the Idaho Department of Water Resources?

00:46:42.220 --> 00:46:45.180
Well, I think I'm going to weigh in as well.

00:46:45.180 --> 00:46:51.780
First of all, I really appreciate and I really appreciate past councils that have been brave

00:46:51.780 --> 00:46:55.100
enough to explore things like Augra Falls.

00:46:55.100 --> 00:47:00.580
And I know that at that time that was a big chunk that they had to bite off and for future

00:47:00.580 --> 00:47:06.420
generations and now that we go down and look at what we have, we have over 1,300 acres

00:47:06.420 --> 00:47:10.380
of parklands within the city that we have control of.

00:47:10.380 --> 00:47:15.140
And I think that's a huge benefit to our citizens for long term.

00:47:15.140 --> 00:47:20.980
So I think this is no different for us to at least explore the idea of extending some more

00:47:20.980 --> 00:47:25.100
parklands, some more recreational activities.

00:47:25.100 --> 00:47:29.700
I look at this as a partnership with CSI, can never be a bad thing.

00:47:29.700 --> 00:47:37.070
I think that we both have the same endeavors in mind as far as public support and what we

00:47:37.070 --> 00:47:39.270
want to do for our community.

00:47:39.270 --> 00:47:44.350
And I think at least let's put our toe in the water and explore this.

00:47:44.350 --> 00:47:45.350
That's my opinion.

00:47:45.350 --> 00:47:50.600
I agree.

00:47:50.600 --> 00:47:56.240
I think it's something we need to do diligence on and see exactly what our options are and

00:47:56.240 --> 00:47:57.480
where it comes out.

00:47:57.480 --> 00:48:02.720
I think it's in our citizens best interest to at least find out what the possibilities

00:48:02.720 --> 00:48:04.720
are and move forward from there.

00:48:04.720 --> 00:48:12.340
So I would recommend that we continue on the path and see where it leads.

00:48:12.340 --> 00:48:13.340
Jim?

00:48:13.340 --> 00:48:16.780
Well, just very quickly so we can move through this, but I do support us moving forward

00:48:16.780 --> 00:48:18.980
with exploring opportunities.

00:48:18.980 --> 00:48:25.060
So if we're looking for a majority consensus in that regard, I would support that.

00:48:25.060 --> 00:48:26.060
Thank you, Mr. Mayor.

00:48:26.060 --> 00:48:27.060
John Berger.

00:48:27.060 --> 00:48:31.370
Yeah, I would say it's certainly worth looking into.

00:48:31.370 --> 00:48:36.010
It does sound like there are probably maybe some unique opportunities with it, not things

00:48:36.010 --> 00:48:38.690
that jump right out at you like when we were dealing with the water issue.

00:48:38.690 --> 00:48:41.650
There was sort of a problem to solve and it helped solve it.

00:48:41.650 --> 00:48:46.490
So I think spending some time looking at opportunities with the discharge to the river

00:48:46.490 --> 00:48:47.490
and certainly partnerships.

00:48:47.490 --> 00:48:53.730
partnerships, but also be curious if there might be other partners that may be, have some value

00:48:53.730 --> 00:48:56.530
in being involved in it.

00:48:56.530 --> 00:48:57.530
Thanks, Sean.

00:48:57.530 --> 00:49:02.110
Well, I think you've, I've seen no further lights, and I think you've heard at least some

00:49:02.110 --> 00:49:04.550
direction, Travis, from the Council.

00:49:04.550 --> 00:49:08.950
So we will start engaged in a formalized conversation.

00:49:08.950 --> 00:49:14.350
We'll report back to the Council as we are able to go through the process.

00:49:14.350 --> 00:49:19.810
of the first and initial steps may be while it's still nice is maybe to go toward the property.

00:49:19.810 --> 00:49:21.410
I know that I've never been there.

00:49:21.410 --> 00:49:23.570
I don't know if anyone else has ever been there.

00:49:23.570 --> 00:49:27.730
Well, during the first agreement, the Council at that time went down and Donna and I may

00:49:27.730 --> 00:49:30.690
have been the only ones all at that time, but we've heard of it.

00:49:30.690 --> 00:49:31.690
It's certainly interesting.

00:49:31.690 --> 00:49:32.690
I'd go again.

00:49:32.690 --> 00:49:33.690
Yes, I agree.

00:49:33.690 --> 00:49:39.530
So maybe we can work with Mr. Alberta to arrange a tour to take a look at that.

00:49:39.530 --> 00:49:41.930
So we'll look at upcoming agenda meetings.

00:49:41.930 --> 00:49:44.930
We'll take a look at what future schedules may be.

00:49:44.930 --> 00:49:47.570
And also in the meantime, we'll start exploring other possible

00:49:47.570 --> 00:49:53.170
partners that we might be able to also drag along with us on a tour.

00:49:53.170 --> 00:49:57.950
And maybe they should come along with big checkbooks.

00:49:57.950 --> 00:50:01.370
Well, I wanted to say thank you to Mr. Pat and Mr. Alberti,

00:50:01.370 --> 00:50:05.290
President Fox, Vice President Mason, and even Mr. Beaten back there.

00:50:05.290 --> 00:50:11.360
Thank you all for being here tonight and sharing, I appreciate it.

00:50:11.360 --> 00:50:21.650
Moving on to the next item on the agenda.

00:50:21.650 --> 00:50:24.810
And that is a brief recap of the city manager's

00:50:24.810 --> 00:50:28.670
recommended budget for FY 2015.

00:50:28.670 --> 00:50:32.070
And we have both the Travis Rothweiler and our CFO,

00:50:32.070 --> 00:50:33.090
Lori Rice.

00:50:33.090 --> 00:50:37.490
So we're going to continue old school to expedite

00:50:37.490 --> 00:50:39.770
and kind of go through this conversation.

00:50:39.770 --> 00:50:44.210
Really tonight is to provide a recap

00:50:44.210 --> 00:50:47.450
of the conversations that we've had over the course

00:50:47.450 --> 00:50:53.530
of the last really five weeks, and then the three weeks prior

00:50:53.530 --> 00:50:56.490
to that when we are going forward with the long-term planning

00:50:56.490 --> 00:50:58.930
and the initial conversations.

00:50:58.930 --> 00:51:04.410
What we want to do is also share that it's important to coordinate.

00:51:04.410 --> 00:51:09.210
That this continues to be an evolving process.

00:51:09.210 --> 00:51:13.330
And so one of the things, because we start this process so early,

00:51:13.330 --> 00:51:17.010
there are constant changes as we continue to go forward

00:51:17.010 --> 00:51:21.490
as we refine estimates in terms of expenditures

00:51:21.490 --> 00:51:24.770
and refine estimates in terms of revenues,

00:51:24.770 --> 00:51:28.330
those two are going to cause differences

00:51:28.330 --> 00:51:31.490
and possible changes as we move forward.

00:51:31.490 --> 00:51:35.570
So one of the issues about starting early as we do

00:51:35.570 --> 00:51:38.330
is it certainly provides an insight

00:51:38.330 --> 00:51:41.130
of how this is a constant moving process

00:51:41.130 --> 00:51:43.490
because just because we publish a budget

00:51:43.490 --> 00:51:45.930
on, and it's presented initially,

00:51:45.930 --> 00:51:50.450
does not mean that we just stop our review and our process.

00:51:50.450 --> 00:51:53.050
And so through this process, we've been able to continue

00:51:53.050 --> 00:51:54.370
to move forward.

00:51:54.370 --> 00:51:57.650
We've been able to identify where we feel comfortable

00:51:57.650 --> 00:52:00.610
in elevating some of the projected revenues,

00:52:00.610 --> 00:52:03.810
specifically number one, in building permits.

00:52:03.810 --> 00:52:07.290
We see that we can comfortably add $50,000

00:52:07.290 --> 00:52:09.890
to our building permit revenue,

00:52:09.890 --> 00:52:12.290
because of a couple of different things.

00:52:12.290 --> 00:52:19.210
Number one, the current projections that we have for this fiscal year, and then the projections

00:52:19.210 --> 00:52:23.850
that we have in communications with some of our building and development partners in the

00:52:23.850 --> 00:52:29.710
subsequent fiscal years really believes that we might have been at first a little too conservative

00:52:29.710 --> 00:52:31.030
on that number.

00:52:31.030 --> 00:52:34.250
The second is contribution from Urban Renewable.

00:52:34.250 --> 00:52:41.970
We simply did not put in the right amount of $32,000, so Lori in her process has been able

00:52:41.970 --> 00:52:47.490
to identify about $82,000 of additional revenue on the tax-supported funds that we're able

00:52:47.490 --> 00:52:48.970
to incorporate.

00:52:48.970 --> 00:52:56.470
The second is we've been also able to take a look and reduce and remove some expenditures.

00:52:56.470 --> 00:52:59.690
One example is in the police budget.

00:52:59.690 --> 00:53:05.370
A few weeks ago, the council had authorized Chief Pike and his administrative team to go

00:53:05.370 --> 00:53:09.610
through the process of changing out their firearms.

00:53:09.610 --> 00:53:13.170
We had $20,000 in the budget for the firearms.

00:53:13.170 --> 00:53:16.870
We've been able to remove that from this year's budget because it's a project that they're

00:53:16.870 --> 00:53:19.010
moving forward with this.

00:53:19.010 --> 00:53:23.910
And so through those entire processes, we are able to illustrate that the difference

00:53:23.910 --> 00:53:26.790
in property tax is going to go down.

00:53:26.790 --> 00:53:30.730
And as a result, we believe that the tax rate will also change.

00:53:30.730 --> 00:53:37.690
And so as you see here, that the possible property tax rate is right around $4.05 as

00:53:37.690 --> 00:53:45.650
illustrated here. As we continue to look at the water, sewer, and sanitation bills,

00:53:45.650 --> 00:53:49.130
we're going to continue to go through those before we set the maximum

00:53:49.130 --> 00:53:54.570
appropriation, but we really believe that the 1% amounts that are in there are

00:53:54.570 --> 00:53:59.970
appropriate. As I said at the very beginning, we started this conversation

00:53:59.970 --> 00:54:07.210
several, several weeks ago, and in fact actually in early April we set the six

00:54:07.210 --> 00:54:13.770
primary tenants of what the budget looks like and five of them are included in the

00:54:13.770 --> 00:54:18.690
budget. One of them in terms of investing in our structures and facilities was removed

00:54:18.690 --> 00:54:25.750
and we even we shared and talked to the community and the council as to why. So as

00:54:25.750 --> 00:54:30.350
we've described in the past oftentimes local governments are able to take a

00:54:30.350 --> 00:54:35.350
3% increase in their revenues and and I think it's been shared by members of

00:54:35.350 --> 00:54:42.070
the council, that is done historically and often by most taxing entities.

00:54:42.070 --> 00:54:46.750
Every year that you don't take that 3%, you grow what's called your foregone balance,

00:54:46.750 --> 00:54:52.950
and that is those funds that you could have captured but you elected not to.

00:54:52.950 --> 00:54:56.670
This budget does not take a 3% increase in the revenues.

00:54:56.670 --> 00:55:02.430
It relies on .76 increase of the property tax plus the new construction.

00:55:02.430 --> 00:55:10.890
As a result of that, we will grow our city's foregone balance by approximately $387,000.

00:55:10.890 --> 00:55:17.350
That is going to elevate that to roughly about $1.8 million in total foregone balance that

00:55:17.350 --> 00:55:20.350
we have for the city.

00:55:20.350 --> 00:55:24.870
The reason we're able to drop that is because when you take a look at the other revenues

00:55:24.870 --> 00:55:29.610
and we believe that they're going to come in, so the logical place is to decrease the

00:55:29.610 --> 00:55:34.370
property tax collections. And so those property tax collections continue to be

00:55:34.370 --> 00:55:42.450
decreased as we refine the budget. So what we do is we illustrate then what the

00:55:42.450 --> 00:55:47.250
total taxable value of the city will be, the net revenues, so on and so forth. And

00:55:47.250 --> 00:55:52.770
again, we don't define a mill levy. If you were to define a mill levy, we could

00:55:52.770 --> 00:55:57.490
tell you this is what it's going to be because that's what you're going to assess.

00:55:57.490 --> 00:56:01.490
In Idaho, you set your spending.

00:56:01.490 --> 00:56:07.490
Your spending is then divided by the total taxable value of a community which produces a tax rate.

00:56:07.490 --> 00:56:13.490
That tax rate, as we found last year and in subsequent years, continues to evolve over time.

00:56:13.490 --> 00:56:22.490
In fact, you will not get a final tax rate number from the county until long after we've adopted and submitted our budgets.

00:56:22.490 --> 00:56:28.330
our budgets. We have to submit what's called an L2 form to the county and the county will

00:56:28.330 --> 00:56:39.590
submit a final evaluation to us after that.

00:56:39.590 --> 00:56:45.630
Great lining has a question. Travis or Laurie, when do we get our last best estimate from

00:56:45.630 --> 00:56:52.420
the county or have we received that?

00:56:52.420 --> 00:56:58.380
Great. The last best guess comes at the latter part of August and then December is when we

00:56:58.380 --> 00:57:00.820
we really get the true number.

00:57:00.820 --> 00:57:03.140
Well, will we have that before the August 18th?

00:57:03.140 --> 00:57:03.980
Or not?

00:57:03.980 --> 00:57:06.240
The letter last best, yes.

00:57:06.240 --> 00:57:09.860
So that's where we're going to have that leads into my next.

00:57:09.860 --> 00:57:11.570
OK, all right.

00:57:11.570 --> 00:57:17.340
Thank you.

00:57:17.340 --> 00:57:19.060
So Laurie and I debated.

00:57:19.060 --> 00:57:21.660
And then we even asked, is this something

00:57:21.660 --> 00:57:24.980
that is going to make sense, or is this something that's

00:57:24.980 --> 00:57:26.900
just going to be even more confusing when

00:57:26.900 --> 00:57:31.620
we start talking about tax rate and property tax collections

00:57:31.620 --> 00:57:38.390
taxable value and all of those types of things. So I'm going to do my best and if I get it

00:57:38.390 --> 00:57:46.870
wrong I'm going to ask Gary Bowden to correct me. So what we've done is we went back and

00:57:46.870 --> 00:57:52.870
we've explored over the course of the last five years how this process changes and how

00:57:52.870 --> 00:57:59.950
this process evolves to really have the council focus on the amount of money they're collecting

00:57:59.950 --> 00:58:03.950
and property taxes not to be focused on the tax rate.

00:58:03.950 --> 00:58:05.950
And I want to share why.

00:58:05.950 --> 00:58:09.710
I'm not saying that taxes are not important because they are,

00:58:09.710 --> 00:58:12.190
but the only place that you have the opportunity

00:58:12.190 --> 00:58:15.430
to affect that change is in our spending.

00:58:15.430 --> 00:58:19.430
We need to be mindful of our spending first.

00:58:19.430 --> 00:58:23.190
So if you take a look at these, you can see that there was

00:58:23.190 --> 00:58:27.310
a preliminary taxable value that is afforded and provided

00:58:27.310 --> 00:58:28.790
by the city.

00:58:28.790 --> 00:58:33.950
We are very fortunate to have a good relationship with our assessor's office and they do provide

00:58:33.950 --> 00:58:39.650
that information to us much early than they are required so that we can start our process

00:58:39.650 --> 00:58:43.050
to get an understanding of what things look like.

00:58:43.050 --> 00:58:49.970
So that number typically comes in August and we're as we've experienced that kind of ebbs

00:58:49.970 --> 00:58:54.810
and flows as we go forward, then they have what's called the sub-roll.

00:58:54.810 --> 00:59:02.070
And the sub-roll is after the county has provided their initial number, and until the time that

00:59:02.070 --> 00:59:08.270
they have to certify, they recognize there's going to be some level of growth that occurs.

00:59:08.270 --> 00:59:12.790
And so they give us an opportunity to grow number.

00:59:12.790 --> 00:59:17.870
That number generally tends to fluctuate as a sub-roll, and you can see its fluctuations

00:59:17.870 --> 00:59:18.870
there.

00:59:18.870 --> 00:59:21.150
It is provided to all taxable entities.

00:59:21.150 --> 00:59:27.450
For example, ours is $2.8 million this year, I believe the counties and CSIs is about $9.5

00:59:27.450 --> 00:59:29.810
million.

00:59:29.810 --> 00:59:35.470
You take those numbers and you divide it by the total property tax revenue that we anticipate

00:59:35.470 --> 00:59:38.190
and that is what produces the tax rate.

00:59:38.190 --> 00:59:46.070
And so the tax rate is illustrated over there in dollars per thousand of taxable value.

00:59:46.070 --> 00:59:50.080
And we do all of this work in August.

00:59:50.080 --> 00:59:56.800
And then December comes, and December we illustrate some of the possible changes, and

00:59:56.800 --> 01:00:05.640
so you can see that the preliminary number in December of 11 and 12 and 13 and 14 went

01:00:05.640 --> 01:00:08.260
through a refinement.

01:00:08.260 --> 01:00:16.580
And in some cases, those refinements are significant, and in some cases they're very, very close.

01:00:16.580 --> 01:00:22.540
So you can see that the actual sub-roll, the actual values of properties added into the

01:00:22.540 --> 01:00:30.620
city after we received those values range from an increase of $32.2 million to a decline

01:00:30.620 --> 01:00:32.380
of $1.5.

01:00:32.380 --> 01:00:39.380
So you can see that range there and then you can see what the impact is on the tax rate.

01:00:39.380 --> 01:00:45.980
The tax rate is not determined by us because the only constant we have in there is the property

01:00:45.980 --> 01:00:55.800
tax revenue. So if you scroll down, you can see what the variance is. And in some cases,

01:00:55.800 --> 01:01:05.840
the tax rate has fluctuated as much as 11 cent swing in the four-year process. So if

01:01:05.840 --> 01:01:12.070
our goal is to focus on a tax rate, I'm not saying that taxes are not important, I can't

01:01:12.070 --> 01:01:18.670
get you there. And I can't get you there because we don't know what those final numbers are

01:01:18.670 --> 01:01:27.960
going to look like. That said, it is incredibly important and we understand the sensitivity

01:01:27.960 --> 01:01:35.890
of property taxes. So with that, hopefully that doesn't complicate things more than what

01:01:35.890 --> 01:01:42.970
it is. This number, that's a long story to tell you, that number at the bottom at $7.91

01:01:42.970 --> 01:01:47.850
is going to change and it's going to go up and it may go down.

01:01:47.850 --> 01:01:49.970
I have my own suspicions is what it is.

01:01:49.970 --> 01:01:55.810
I provided that to Lori and we'll see if I'm right because I'm really trying to understand

01:01:55.810 --> 01:02:00.930
and unlock the secrets of the system so that we can continue to provide you better information

01:02:00.930 --> 01:02:03.690
as we roll forward in subsequent years.

01:02:03.690 --> 01:02:09.650
So we believe that the total taxable, again, you'll notice that there are some changes here

01:02:09.650 --> 01:02:14.930
And the changes are driving down the property tax collections comparison to the prior week.

01:02:14.930 --> 01:02:24.520
In addition to that, you can see that we're estimating a possible six cent increase in the tax rate.

01:02:24.520 --> 01:02:28.840
So this is an updated chart, and if you take a look, it does not change things.

01:02:28.840 --> 01:02:35.000
If you compare where we're at, because there's only one number that's moving, and that is the red graph.

01:02:35.000 --> 01:02:40.600
This graph is designed to illustrate the median property tax

01:02:40.600 --> 01:02:44.360
values assigned to those various cities.

01:02:44.360 --> 01:02:46.880
Again, as we've shared, we don't include the city's

01:02:46.880 --> 01:02:51.080
a Boise-Oterritian because of their Aida County Highway

01:02:51.080 --> 01:02:56.520
District and servicing their roadways in their community.

01:02:56.520 --> 01:02:59.960
And as a result of that, property taxes in the city

01:02:59.960 --> 01:03:03.920
of Twin Falls constitute just shy of 15% of our total budget

01:03:03.920 --> 01:03:09.660
to support street fund operations.

01:03:09.660 --> 01:03:12.700
We try to break the budget into components,

01:03:12.700 --> 01:03:15.820
but first we want to talk about what it looks like overall.

01:03:15.820 --> 01:03:18.700
We spent some time talking about the five new positions

01:03:18.700 --> 01:03:20.900
that we want to add to the organization.

01:03:20.900 --> 01:03:22.780
Three of them in the tax-supported funds,

01:03:22.780 --> 01:03:26.380
two of them are in the enterprise-supported funds.

01:03:26.380 --> 01:03:29.160
We're talking about a 3% pay adjustment,

01:03:30.420 --> 01:03:32.820
compensating the city's proportion share of healthcare

01:03:32.820 --> 01:03:34.620
at 7.72%,

01:03:34.620 --> 01:03:44.180
making sure that we have a competitive structure in the areas of compression ratio adjustment.

01:03:44.180 --> 01:03:52.320
When we add, if all five bodies are included and approved by the council into the budget,

01:03:52.320 --> 01:03:57.360
that total cost to our organizations is just shy of $300,000.

01:03:57.360 --> 01:04:02.480
And that would bring our employee count to $6.2,000 for $1,000.

01:04:02.480 --> 01:04:09.480
That is the heads and bed numbers based upon census that does not include those people who come to our community on a daily basis.

01:04:09.480 --> 01:04:14.480
We estimate that that number ranges between 60 to 70,000 per day.

01:04:14.480 --> 01:04:20.480
If you divide the number of employees per capita that we serve, that number drops to roughly 3.9.

01:04:20.480 --> 01:04:27.800
Common is anywhere between 8 to 10 employees based upon census population.

01:04:27.800 --> 01:04:30.800
This illustrates the increases in operation and maintenance.

01:04:30.800 --> 01:04:36.080
We're looking at a 1.96% total increase in operation and maintenance.

01:04:36.080 --> 01:04:39.000
And there are two items that predominantly drive that.

01:04:39.000 --> 01:04:44.700
Number one is the new agreement that we reached with Wonderlink and Wakefield for

01:04:44.700 --> 01:04:47.520
the enhanced legal services under professional services.

01:04:47.520 --> 01:04:52.480
And the number two piece of that is the professional services that we've attached

01:04:52.480 --> 01:05:00.500
in community development to assist with the update to our city's complement at $80,000.

01:05:00.500 --> 01:05:08.860
Our capital expenditures for the upcoming year, right around $12,380,000.

01:05:08.860 --> 01:05:16.300
This does not include items such as a $38 million improvement to our city's wastewater treatment facility.

01:05:16.300 --> 01:05:20.100
We will account for that through the auditing process.

01:05:20.100 --> 01:05:29.580
In total, if you include the wastewater treatment facility, the city would have added $150 million of capital investment in our community since 2007.

01:05:29.580 --> 01:05:36.010
Okay, that figure again 150 million

01:05:37.270 --> 01:05:39.270
2007 since 2007

01:05:40.270 --> 01:05:51.820
Nice round figure when we start looking at the impact of the decisions of the budget when it comes to the individual rates

01:05:51.820 --> 01:05:54.980
It's important to recognize what this budget is asking

01:05:55.740 --> 01:05:58.980
It is asking for a 2% increase in the water rate

01:05:59.660 --> 01:06:05.860
Which would increase consum or the cost to those who average consume in our instead 18,000 gallons?

01:06:05.860 --> 01:06:11.420
Upon request of Councilman Tawkington, we went back and looked and we illustrated that the

01:06:11.420 --> 01:06:20.460
18,000 number is slightly high. Most individuals use right around just shy of $17,000, $17,000.

01:06:20.460 --> 01:06:25.500
So this number is larger than what we anticipate. It's important to recognize that we don't

01:06:25.500 --> 01:06:30.380
use the average in driving the cost. We look at total revenues of the system and total expenditures

01:06:30.380 --> 01:06:35.660
of the system. And so when we state that it's going to be 75 cents per month, that is over

01:06:35.660 --> 01:06:41.300
stated to the average resident. We're looking at a 1% increase in sewer, it's a 25 cent

01:06:41.300 --> 01:06:48.020
per month increase. We're also looking at a 19 cent increase in sanitation, which represents

01:06:48.020 --> 01:06:57.020
a 1.11 percent, a significant portion of the increase of about 1.7 of the 1.11 percent,

01:06:57.020 --> 01:07:05.780
if that made any sense whatsoever, is associated with our PSI contract for services. So when

01:07:05.780 --> 01:07:09.180
When we look at the total cost of how much more it's going to cost to live in Twin Falls

01:07:09.180 --> 01:07:15.420
next year based upon this budget, the annual difference is $18.33, the monthly difference

01:07:15.420 --> 01:07:18.020
is $1.53.

01:07:18.020 --> 01:07:25.740
We get to that place by saying tonight is the last night that we have before the council has

01:07:25.740 --> 01:07:28.640
to take a formalized action.

01:07:28.640 --> 01:07:33.800
And that action is something that you will take next week where you set the maximum amount

01:07:33.800 --> 01:07:38.800
that the city is willing to spend in the 2005 fiscal year.

01:07:40.520 --> 01:07:42.820
You can't exceed that amount after next week

01:07:42.820 --> 01:07:43.920
when you set that ceiling,

01:07:43.920 --> 01:07:46.600
but you can certainly continue to work

01:07:46.600 --> 01:07:49.640
and find ways to reduce that expenditure

01:07:49.640 --> 01:07:52.960
should you feel that is appropriate as we move forward.

01:07:54.740 --> 01:07:59.540
All anticipation with hopes to have the city budget

01:07:59.540 --> 01:08:06.860
adopted on the 18th of August after our public hearing on the budget.

01:08:06.860 --> 01:08:11.300
Next week, we'll also have a series of public hearings on possible rate adjustments.

01:08:11.300 --> 01:08:14.700
Those rate adjustments predominantly affect the airport and impact.

01:08:17.230 --> 01:08:17.730
Thank you, Travis.

01:08:17.710 --> 01:08:22.230
I just wanted to let the folks know out in the audience that we do have a public hearing tonight.

01:08:22.230 --> 01:08:28.270
It stated that it will not start before six, and again, we've been very successful because it's not going to start before six.

01:08:28.270 --> 01:08:31.950
We're still in the midst of this conversation,

01:08:31.950 --> 01:08:33.230
then we have some public input,

01:08:33.230 --> 01:08:36.150
and then we'll go right into the public hearing.

01:08:36.150 --> 01:08:38.630
If you're interested in testifying regarding that,

01:08:38.630 --> 01:08:39.870
make sure you sign up in the back

01:08:39.870 --> 01:08:42.230
so we can bring you up here early.

01:08:42.230 --> 01:08:43.950
Any questions for Mr. Rothweiler?

01:08:43.950 --> 01:08:45.110
Chris talking to?

01:08:45.110 --> 01:08:47.950
Last week I had asked City

01:08:47.950 --> 01:08:50.070
with the Council's concurrence to look in

01:08:50.070 --> 01:08:54.710
to reducing the arsenic levy, if you will,

01:08:55.630 --> 01:08:57.030
on our taxpayers.

01:08:57.030 --> 01:09:01.710
And I had a very thorough education by, they ganged up on me actually,

01:09:01.710 --> 01:09:03.590
by Lori and Travis.

01:09:03.590 --> 01:09:08.910
And I just want to tell you what I think or what I have discovered.

01:09:08.910 --> 01:09:13.050
The reduction we took last year, which was 40 cents,

01:09:13.050 --> 01:09:16.670
largely was the population growth factor.

01:09:16.670 --> 01:09:20.190
We have a 10-year cap or a 10-year call

01:09:20.190 --> 01:09:25.410
provides though that does not allow us really to tap into the

01:09:25.410 --> 01:09:32.010
1-to-1-25 ratio amount where we over accrue money for our SNCC.

01:09:32.010 --> 01:09:38.530
The next opportunity we would have to readjust the rate would be in a couple of years based

01:09:38.530 --> 01:09:41.730
upon whatever population growth we have.

01:09:41.730 --> 01:09:47.210
So I spoke without knowing the facts, thinking that we could do this every year.

01:09:47.210 --> 01:09:48.210
We cannot.

01:09:48.210 --> 01:09:52.210
Well, we could, except we'd be taking out of one pocket and putting into another.

01:09:52.210 --> 01:10:00.090
be robbing the one to 125 and taking out of some capital fund I suppose to replenish that.

01:10:00.090 --> 01:10:05.130
So as much as I'd like to get that, owner is unfunded, federal mandate off her back.

01:10:05.130 --> 01:10:12.010
We can't really talk about it for another seven years until that ten year period of the

01:10:12.010 --> 01:10:13.410
past four years.

01:10:13.410 --> 01:10:14.410
Yeah.

01:10:14.410 --> 01:10:16.770
So that was Chris's education.

01:10:16.770 --> 01:10:21.830
However, I do have another point in the budget that I'd like to talk about before we're

01:10:21.830 --> 01:10:23.670
going to a executive session.

01:10:23.670 --> 01:10:30.400
Well, I think it was an education for all of us, Chris, thank you for sharing that.

01:10:30.400 --> 01:10:32.400
Anything further to Mr. Rothweiler?

01:10:32.400 --> 01:10:35.020
Did you want to ask your question?

01:10:35.020 --> 01:10:37.180
Is it related to the budget, Chris?

01:10:37.180 --> 01:10:46.820
Yeah, I'm still concerned that I think there's some property relief that might be warranted,

01:10:46.820 --> 01:10:50.240
And this would be something that is

01:10:50.240 --> 01:10:52.580
remained to our garbage pickup.

01:10:52.580 --> 01:10:56.540
As Travis and I and Lori were talking,

01:10:56.540 --> 01:11:00.780
I would strongly support the, this is not their position,

01:11:00.780 --> 01:11:04.500
this is mine, that after the budget is set,

01:11:04.500 --> 01:11:06.980
it does not have to be concurrent with the start

01:11:06.980 --> 01:11:12.220
of the budget year, that we discuss with PSI

01:11:12.220 --> 01:11:15.740
to readjust our garbage pickup.

01:11:15.740 --> 01:11:22.700
Currently, I think we are the only municipality and PSI's southern Idaho jurisdiction that

01:11:22.700 --> 01:11:25.860
allows an unlimited amount of garbage dump.

01:11:25.860 --> 01:11:33.660
And if you've seen during the summer, garden waste and yard waste just causes an overflow

01:11:33.660 --> 01:11:41.740
of the system, it's not uncommon to see anywhere from five to 15 bags thrown out besides the

01:11:41.740 --> 01:11:43.580
big blues.

01:11:43.580 --> 01:11:48.860
This is at a time when we're quite successful in reducing our garbage to the landfill through

01:11:48.860 --> 01:11:51.540
our recycling program.

01:11:51.540 --> 01:11:59.980
But I think we should work with the PSI to establish a pay-to-dump price that would say

01:11:59.980 --> 01:12:05.420
we will only, PSI will only pick up trash and approve containers.

01:12:05.420 --> 01:12:10.380
So if you have bags, you can meter them in through the next week or two, or you could buy

01:12:10.380 --> 01:12:13.260
another container from PSI.

01:12:13.260 --> 01:12:19.920
at the same time investigate a single small can-user rate.

01:12:19.920 --> 01:12:29.660
We have a fairly substantial amount of seniors, not even dual family, but single seniors, who

01:12:29.660 --> 01:12:34.460
they have literally the amount of garbage that some of us would have in a waste basket

01:12:34.460 --> 01:12:36.060
in a week's time.

01:12:36.060 --> 01:12:41.220
And for them to have to pay for the emptying of a big blue is just imminently unfair.

01:12:41.220 --> 01:12:47.820
And I would sincerely like this to look into that after the budget settles.

01:12:47.820 --> 01:12:56.280
It's time to discourage wanton wasteful dumping without paying for it.

01:12:56.280 --> 01:13:01.120
You know Chris I would support you on that because you know we see folks that put a lot

01:13:01.120 --> 01:13:03.640
of things out of the curve that are picked up.

01:13:03.640 --> 01:13:08.840
And then we have some folks like you mentioned maybe the senior population that hardly even

01:13:08.840 --> 01:13:16.080
fill up a quarter of a big blue dumpster. So to me that's almost like the seniors are

01:13:16.080 --> 01:13:21.680
subsidizing those others. Well they are and they wouldn't mean a property tax shift, not

01:13:21.680 --> 01:13:29.080
a property, a garbage dump shift to large users away from small users. It's a fee based

01:13:29.080 --> 01:13:35.720
at which I'm a very supportive of user fees. So I would be supportive of that Chris. So

01:13:35.720 --> 01:13:37.600
So thank you for bringing that to our attention.

01:13:37.600 --> 01:13:38.720
Greg Lanning.

01:13:38.720 --> 01:13:40.680
Well, I'm certainly in favor of,

01:13:40.680 --> 01:13:42.840
and I remember during the last negotiations,

01:13:42.840 --> 01:13:43.760
as if I recall though,

01:13:43.760 --> 01:13:45.960
the PSI really wanted to get rid of those little ones

01:13:45.960 --> 01:13:47.400
because that was causing them some issues,

01:13:47.400 --> 01:13:51.960
but that aside, the lowering of some sort of fee base,

01:13:51.960 --> 01:13:55.440
but I also know the unintended consequence of that is,

01:13:55.440 --> 01:13:57.320
when you go to communities that have that,

01:13:57.320 --> 01:14:01.080
there are lots, lots are people that are thrown away,

01:14:01.080 --> 01:14:02.440
they just throw it in the backyard

01:14:02.440 --> 01:14:04.280
or they throw it in the side yard.

01:14:04.280 --> 01:14:08.400
or any empty lots in the area, catch all the grass.

01:14:08.400 --> 01:14:13.170
And so that's pretty hard to control.

01:14:13.170 --> 01:14:16.330
And because if people are gonna have to pay

01:14:16.330 --> 01:14:18.330
to have that whole grass all the way,

01:14:18.330 --> 01:14:20.050
they're just gonna take it over to that vacant lot

01:14:20.050 --> 01:14:22.010
and let somebody else haul it away at a later date.

01:14:22.010 --> 01:14:25.970
So we have to think of all of the unintended consequences

01:14:25.970 --> 01:14:29.140
of a move we make.

01:14:29.140 --> 01:14:30.220
Thank you, Greg.

01:14:30.220 --> 01:14:32.620
Anything further, I just wanna mention

01:14:32.620 --> 01:14:34.660
that we did have a couple of concerned citizens

01:14:34.660 --> 01:14:38.660
that sent us an email regarding the budget,

01:14:38.660 --> 01:14:41.220
and we have that displayed prominently at the front.

01:14:41.220 --> 01:14:43.460
We do, and we thank them for writing.

01:14:43.460 --> 01:14:45.220
We would also encourage individuals

01:14:45.220 --> 01:14:48.340
to go directly to the source for the information.

01:14:48.340 --> 01:14:51.780
We have all of the information as we've gone through

01:14:51.780 --> 01:14:54.660
this process placed onto the city's website.

01:14:54.660 --> 01:14:57.940
This publication, again, this will be on there this evening.

01:14:57.940 --> 01:14:59.380
And as we continue to go forward,

01:14:59.380 --> 01:15:01.420
we want to make sure that our public continues

01:15:01.420 --> 01:15:03.060
to be engaged in the conversation,

01:15:03.060 --> 01:15:08.260
but engage with the information that is up to date and accurate.

01:15:08.260 --> 01:15:16.800
They reference June 10th, time in which they received information, and really as we've gone

01:15:16.800 --> 01:15:21.340
through the iterations of this process, this has evolved substantially.

01:15:21.340 --> 01:15:28.140
So we would just encourage individuals to continue to reach out, to share their thoughts.

01:15:28.140 --> 01:15:33.180
Maybe they have some good ideas inside the budget where we can generate more partnerships

01:15:33.180 --> 01:15:39.660
are generating additional efficiencies and certainly this is the thing that involves our

01:15:39.660 --> 01:15:46.300
citizens the most either directly or indirectly. This is where we take services and we pay

01:15:46.300 --> 01:15:50.660
for those services with the property tax dollars and the user fees that we collect from

01:15:50.660 --> 01:15:53.700
them on a periodic basis.

01:15:53.700 --> 01:15:59.820
Thank you Travis. Is there anything further? Travis is regarding the budget this evening.

01:15:59.820 --> 01:16:06.180
I would again remind council and we've all been doing a good job of this I think this year.

01:16:06.180 --> 01:16:10.140
If you do have questions that come up as you're going through the budget and we start looking

01:16:10.140 --> 01:16:16.020
at details, let's engage staff so that they have some time to research those questions

01:16:16.020 --> 01:16:19.540
rather than get them flat-footed here.

01:16:19.540 --> 01:16:23.060
Certainly questions come up as we have these discussions but if we know about them ahead

01:16:23.060 --> 01:16:28.660
of time I think it's just common courtesy to share that with staff.

01:16:28.660 --> 01:16:36.650
All right, I think we will move to the next item on the agenda, which is, yes, thank you.

01:16:36.650 --> 01:16:40.650
We're going to go to public input, so I'll just do both at the same time.

01:16:40.650 --> 01:16:47.650
We always have an opportunity for the public to engage us regarding our budget, and so I'm

01:16:47.650 --> 01:16:49.250
going to open that up.

01:16:49.250 --> 01:16:58.650
At the same time, I'm going to open up public input generally on anything that wasn't on the

01:16:58.650 --> 01:17:03.850
on the agenda other than the budget hopefully that even made sense if you're

01:17:03.850 --> 01:17:10.650
here to talk about the public hearing that's going to be just a few minutes

01:17:10.650 --> 01:17:15.610
later so at this point we'll open it up to any comment regarding the budget from

01:17:15.610 --> 01:17:26.460
the public okay we will now turn it over to the public input regarding

01:17:26.460 --> 01:17:35.010
[Muted for privacy: home address]

01:17:35.010 --> 01:17:42.010
[Muted for privacy: home address]

01:17:42.010 --> 01:17:45.160
[Muted for privacy: home address]

01:17:45.160 --> 01:17:49.720
[Muted for privacy: home address]

01:17:49.720 --> 01:17:53.680
of thought that goes into a lot of things. And so that gives me a great deal of confidence

01:17:53.680 --> 01:17:59.650
that perhaps there may be some solutions for what I like to talk about tonight. What I like

01:17:59.650 --> 01:18:06.870
to talk about is a little bit based upon the previous 110 years of Twin Falls history.

01:18:06.870 --> 01:18:13.990
And with that in mind, the question exists during the next 86 years of this century, does

01:18:13.990 --> 01:18:22.990
this particular council or current staff have any specific plans to install and replace and

01:18:22.990 --> 01:18:28.630
repair perp-duttering sidewalk within the following five areas of Twin Falls.

01:18:28.630 --> 01:18:37.920
The Twin Falls town site, South Park, President Streets, this area which I'll define as east

01:18:37.920 --> 01:18:43.800
of Blue Lakes, west of Locust Street, north of Kimberly Road, and south of 9th Avenue

01:18:43.800 --> 01:18:51.920
East, and the last section which is smaller, east of Locust, west of Madrona, north of Kimberly

01:18:51.920 --> 01:18:57.040
Road, and south of Harman Park.

01:18:57.040 --> 01:19:06.060
If there's an answer, yes, in the affirmative there's an actual plan, I'd like to hear that,

01:19:06.060 --> 01:19:10.060
and that might preclude a little, some of my other comments.

01:19:10.060 --> 01:19:12.780
So the question can I be answered?

01:19:12.780 --> 01:19:13.860
No.

01:19:13.860 --> 01:19:17.020
Mr. Rotherweiler, could you maybe go through the dynamics

01:19:17.020 --> 01:19:21.020
of the curb, gutter, and sidewalk, and where's the responsibility

01:19:21.020 --> 01:19:24.280
live for those?

01:19:24.280 --> 01:19:27.920
So we have Jackie Fields who's here with us.

01:19:27.920 --> 01:19:30.920
I like the delegation.

01:19:30.920 --> 01:19:33.840
You know, really, Jackie can talk about the specific areas.

01:19:33.840 --> 01:19:36.160
But what I'm going to do, and I'll ask Mr. Wonderlick

01:19:36.160 --> 01:19:38.760
to correct me if I get this wrong.

01:19:38.760 --> 01:19:43.680
But generally, the curbs, the gutters, and the sidewalks,

01:19:43.680 --> 01:19:46.200
and people really don't like it when we say this.

01:19:46.200 --> 01:19:48.920
But according to City Code are the responsibility

01:19:48.920 --> 01:19:52.800
of the individual property owners.

01:19:52.800 --> 01:19:55.200
There has been always a conversation

01:19:55.200 --> 01:19:58.720
about how do we advance and how do we cause construction

01:19:58.720 --> 01:20:06.040
to occur when you have upwards of 17,000 individual units

01:20:06.040 --> 01:20:13.040
in a community, and maybe to add a little bit of credence

01:20:13.040 --> 01:20:16.280
to what Mr. Yates is saying as we reflected in the Citizen

01:20:16.280 --> 01:20:20.760
Survey just last week, it is an area of concern in our community

01:20:20.760 --> 01:20:24.040
in terms of the maintenance of the sidewalks and the position

01:20:24.040 --> 01:20:28.280
in which several sidewalks in our community find themselves.

01:20:28.280 --> 01:20:30.810
That's why I replaced mine.

01:20:30.810 --> 01:20:34.600
I was concerned about it and had the funds and I did it.

01:20:34.600 --> 01:20:35.960
Chris, Chris talked a bit like that.

01:20:35.960 --> 01:20:39.860
And also, Ron, I'm sure you're aware that neighbors

01:20:39.860 --> 01:20:44.100
in a specific area, adjacent area to one another,

01:20:44.100 --> 01:20:47.580
can form a local improvement district

01:20:47.580 --> 01:20:51.460
and get an economy of scale of multiple properties,

01:20:51.460 --> 01:20:55.060
doing that at some reduction in price.

01:20:55.060 --> 01:20:59.980
They're not very popular, but an LID is a state

01:20:59.980 --> 01:21:05.490
allowed use of public gathering together to do that.

01:21:05.490 --> 01:21:08.490
and that would be initiated by the neighbors.

01:21:08.490 --> 01:21:12.080
It can be imposed by the city.

01:21:12.080 --> 01:21:14.840
I will add that since I've been on council,

01:21:14.840 --> 01:21:17.840
I've seen opportunities where we,

01:21:17.840 --> 01:21:19.680
as we're making street improvements

01:21:19.680 --> 01:21:20.640
and those kind of things,

01:21:20.640 --> 01:21:24.400
we have been able to invest in some sidewalks and like,

01:21:24.400 --> 01:21:26.400
but I agree with you.

01:21:26.400 --> 01:21:29.720
There's a lot of areas that not only

01:21:29.720 --> 01:21:33.800
the sidewalk, curb, and gutters are deteriorating.

01:21:33.800 --> 01:21:37.280
They don't even exist in some areas.

01:21:37.280 --> 01:21:46.560
I have heard the explanation that the property owner is responsible from essentially the

01:21:46.560 --> 01:21:53.480
center of the alley to the center of the street and improving several properties of a couple

01:21:53.480 --> 01:22:00.880
of the realization that there are a lot of IOU's out vouchers to the building department.

01:22:00.880 --> 01:22:05.240
For example, if a homeowner increases the size of the footprint of their home or as a garage

01:22:05.240 --> 01:22:06.440
or something like that.

01:22:06.440 --> 01:22:08.700
There's a review done to the condition of the sidewalk

01:22:08.700 --> 01:22:10.000
urban gutter.

01:22:10.000 --> 01:22:13.080
And in many cases, it wouldn't be really economically

01:22:13.080 --> 01:22:16.740
convenient to anybody to change the view of the flow of the

01:22:16.740 --> 01:22:20.640
street by changing the dimension of the sidewalk or doing it all.

01:22:20.640 --> 01:22:24.040
So there's a lot of IOUs that could be called in.

01:22:24.040 --> 01:22:27.900
They were issued to the building department in specific

01:22:27.900 --> 01:22:28.720
areas of town.

01:22:28.720 --> 01:22:32.280
And maybe that you find that there's a significant amount

01:22:32.280 --> 01:22:39.280
them on one block and you begin to plan to make the changes.

01:22:39.280 --> 01:22:45.280
It's just that the city lacks a lot of congruency when it comes, I don't know if that's a word,

01:22:45.280 --> 01:22:53.860
incongruent is what I see and it's somewhat of a hopscotch.

01:22:53.860 --> 01:22:56.860
And so a little bit of historical review.

01:22:56.860 --> 01:23:03.100
In 2007, I participated in the steering committee, several meetings which gave input to the current

01:23:03.100 --> 01:23:05.100
comprehensive plan.

01:23:05.100 --> 01:23:11.540
And it was an interesting process and the comprehensive plan has 130 or so pages.

01:23:11.540 --> 01:23:16.780
What's curious to me is how many of the same subjects for improvement in this current comprehensive

01:23:16.780 --> 01:23:20.020
plan were in the former comprehensive plan.

01:23:20.020 --> 01:23:27.500
So with that in mind, when I received that, I sent an email to the Utah-based consulting

01:23:27.500 --> 01:23:32.900
firm who helped compile that all the input.

01:23:32.900 --> 01:23:37.240
With the question, will you direct me to the page that has the to-do list?

01:23:37.240 --> 01:23:39.700
Which of these are going to be accomplished?

01:23:39.700 --> 01:23:44.220
A lot of things mentioned, there wasn't a specific to-do list.

01:23:44.220 --> 01:23:53.780
With that in mind, if you search the PDF form, if you search that document, the comprehensive

01:23:53.780 --> 01:23:57.420
plan using the word sidewalk, it appears many, many times.

01:23:57.420 --> 01:24:04.870
There's a tremendous concern for that, specifically the danger, the property value, et cetera.

01:24:04.870 --> 01:24:08.710
So with that in mind, looking for solutions, I'm not laying blame here.

01:24:08.710 --> 01:24:12.230
It's really something that needs to be solved and planned for.

01:24:12.230 --> 01:24:17.230
The number of questions that I just witnessed, and several of the planning, several of the

01:24:17.230 --> 01:24:24.350
intelligent questions that were presented here tonight, I'm sure it can be resolved that

01:24:24.350 --> 01:24:30.170
some form of plan for these needing areas began to take form.

01:24:30.170 --> 01:24:32.250
I'm suggesting that it take place.

01:24:32.250 --> 01:24:37.650
I did hear from Tom Courtney who went for City Manager Tom Courtney in late 2008 or

01:24:37.650 --> 01:24:38.650
early 2009.

01:24:38.650 --> 01:24:42.250
I'm not sure about the LID, the local improvement district.

01:24:42.250 --> 01:24:47.770
And it was a successful one that had been taking place in South Park at one time.

01:24:47.770 --> 01:24:57.010
And what was required of me, if I wanted to pursue that at this time, was to petition

01:24:57.010 --> 01:25:06.420
approximately 200 property owners in my area of Twin Falls to voluntarily increase the

01:25:06.420 --> 01:25:15.390
property tax to produce that. I could foresee a lot of argument about where the new sidewalks

01:25:15.390 --> 01:25:19.510
are going to go, whose tree is going to have to get cut down, et cetera, things like that.

01:25:19.510 --> 01:25:25.870
I see a lot of apathy as well, tremendous amount of apathy. So looking at what my schedule

01:25:25.870 --> 01:25:31.790
was and the fact that I couldn't afford to purchase steel shutters from our windows if

01:25:31.790 --> 01:25:37.030
the LID was successful. That means I

01:25:37.030 --> 01:25:39.310
shelled the idea. But not before asking

01:25:39.310 --> 01:25:42.590
Jackie Fields to give me an idea of what

01:25:42.590 --> 01:25:46.030
it would cost in dollars to do our

01:25:46.030 --> 01:25:49.130
my area of town anyway. It was approximately

01:25:49.130 --> 01:25:51.910
two million dollars. I don't have that

01:25:51.910 --> 01:25:53.670
in writing at this time. I can't put my

01:25:53.670 --> 01:25:55.190
hand on the document. But it was

01:25:55.190 --> 01:25:57.310
approximately two million, somewhere in

01:25:57.310 --> 01:25:59.750
there, it was in that area. And the

01:25:59.750 --> 01:26:07.430
The response was very rapid and insistent, and I didn't follow up on it because there's

01:26:07.430 --> 01:26:09.430
a lot of work to do on that.

01:26:09.430 --> 01:26:14.870
So I'm looking for solutions to start the planning process.

01:26:14.870 --> 01:26:16.990
I mentioned the IOUs from a lot of property owners.

01:26:16.990 --> 01:26:20.830
They could be researched at the building department with some of the building permits.

01:26:20.830 --> 01:26:25.030
I know I gave one, and I sold a house so that nice person is stuck.

01:26:25.030 --> 01:26:27.030
Yeah, I think they're called deferral.

01:26:27.030 --> 01:26:28.030
Deferals, correct.

01:26:28.030 --> 01:26:29.030
That's right.

01:26:29.030 --> 01:26:34.860
remember it's been a while. That's one possible solution. I say it's possible.

01:26:34.860 --> 01:26:39.060
It's one way to look. The second possible one is to say no to all future

01:26:39.060 --> 01:26:46.140
federal mandates. That's a nice one. I see a smile out front. That's a great idea.

01:26:46.140 --> 01:26:52.180
Yeah, okay. Thank you. Thank you. Well, by myself. Well, Tom Fortany helped. And

01:26:52.180 --> 01:26:56.020
share the experience, make a plan, share the expense with property management or

01:26:56.020 --> 01:27:02.310
property owners where the need exists the most. Okay, share the expense with

01:27:02.310 --> 01:27:09.010
property owners, make a cohesive plan that serves well. And now I see there's a

01:27:09.010 --> 01:27:15.410
tremendous demand for the tax revenue that exists and with growth comes expense. So

01:27:15.410 --> 01:27:20.980
what I'm saying for the next part of this century anyway, let's begin the plan to

01:27:20.980 --> 01:27:28.700
make this happen. A little bit of humor. I also want to thank you for your time and your

01:27:28.700 --> 01:27:34.020
attention. And Ron, I would really ask if you try to wrap it up. I'm done. I just want

01:27:34.020 --> 01:27:39.340
a public hearing and I know that Rebecca was. I don't want to stand on in the way of Renee

01:27:39.340 --> 01:27:44.540
and her hearing. So this is something that was produced 10 years ago. And there's a lot

01:27:44.540 --> 01:27:49.540
of truth in it, not all truth. There was a pump or snicker here where there was a misprudendage.

01:27:49.540 --> 01:27:54.280
you can read that since two thousand four twin falls centennial celebrating

01:27:54.280 --> 01:27:56.760
fifty years of progress

01:27:56.760 --> 01:28:01.620
okay so it was never on a bumper of anybody's automobile into one falls

01:28:01.620 --> 01:28:04.480
because it was pulled before it was actually print or perhaps a little bit

01:28:04.480 --> 01:28:09.970
after it's but what i'm saying is there was a lot of progress in twin falls

01:28:09.970 --> 01:28:12.140
i'll turn this this way

01:28:12.140 --> 01:28:15.460
and so let's make sure that it's

01:28:15.460 --> 01:28:19.820
continues and i will stop talking and i really appreciate those of you that are

01:28:19.820 --> 01:28:25.220
We're working up there because I've sat there too and it's important.

01:28:25.220 --> 01:28:26.860
Thank you to be here.

01:28:26.860 --> 01:28:28.460
Thank you Mr. Yates, come and see me.

01:28:28.460 --> 01:28:29.460
Rebecca?

01:28:29.460 --> 01:28:31.380
Well I just want to say thank you Ron.

01:28:31.380 --> 01:28:33.740
Mr. Yates for bringing this to our attention.

01:28:33.740 --> 01:28:38.500
You're certainly not the first citizen to bring this to our attention.

01:28:38.500 --> 01:28:44.860
And as Travis stated, it's significant, you know, it's significantly reflected in our national

01:28:44.860 --> 01:28:45.860
citizen survey.

01:28:45.860 --> 01:28:52.780
So, I think it is time to maybe do a review of our current code and our current process.

01:28:52.780 --> 01:28:53.780
Something isn't working.

01:28:53.780 --> 01:28:57.940
You know, I mean, it's easy to say, well, in our code, property owners are supposed to

01:28:57.940 --> 01:28:58.940
take care of it.

01:28:58.940 --> 01:29:04.700
But if it's not happening and people who utilize wheelchairs or crutches or other, you

01:29:04.700 --> 01:29:10.220
know, things are even just walkers, citizens who want sidewalks to walk on, maybe we need

01:29:10.220 --> 01:29:16.460
to be a little more proactive in finding a way to review these needed areas.

01:29:16.460 --> 01:29:18.740
Thank you for pointing out those areas.

01:29:18.740 --> 01:29:23.940
You know, much like we do with our street zones, which we didn't have a couple of years ago,

01:29:23.940 --> 01:29:28.300
and now we have zones, and so we make sure that we properly maintenance and pay attention

01:29:28.300 --> 01:29:30.460
to all sections of town.

01:29:30.460 --> 01:29:31.900
We didn't do that before.

01:29:31.900 --> 01:29:37.180
And so maybe it's time to review and to find a way to create partnerships.

01:29:37.180 --> 01:29:44.540
I think it's a good suggestion calling on deferrals, but also reaching out to

01:29:44.540 --> 01:29:51.500
property owners and seeing if they would be willing to participate in a local improvement district.

01:29:51.500 --> 01:29:57.420
Really being more proactive and maybe we can focus the city's resources and staff on finding

01:29:58.620 --> 01:30:01.900
more successful ways to address the sidewalks. So thank you.

01:30:01.900 --> 01:30:06.900
I agree if we could find a way that our staff could do it.

01:30:06.900 --> 01:30:11.350
I think about all the different areas that Mr. Gates outlined,

01:30:11.350 --> 01:30:13.350
and that's a lot of town.

01:30:13.350 --> 01:30:18.350
I walk often on Lincoln Street, and Lincoln Street, many of them,

01:30:18.350 --> 01:30:22.350
they didn't band together to do it, but they're like Mr. Gates.

01:30:22.350 --> 01:30:24.350
I know you're property, and you put in a new sidewalk.

01:30:24.350 --> 01:30:28.350
Much of Lincoln Street is putting in new sidewalks on their own,

01:30:28.350 --> 01:30:30.350
because they're the 100-year-old sidewalks,

01:30:30.350 --> 01:30:37.350
They're replacing them and trying to be a way that we could have staff do that without

01:30:37.350 --> 01:30:38.350
hype.

01:30:38.350 --> 01:30:40.350
I'm not very creative.

01:30:40.350 --> 01:30:47.350
So I'm having struggling with how we can reach out to 17,000 households and see who,

01:30:47.350 --> 01:30:51.350
and what we certainly can't afford to redo them ourselves.

01:30:51.350 --> 01:30:52.350
We understand that.

01:30:52.350 --> 01:30:56.350
I mean, if his neighborhood was too many, what would it be for the whole city?

01:30:56.350 --> 01:30:58.350
I mean, pretty staggering.

01:30:58.350 --> 01:31:04.150
But if we can, if there's some other community has come up with a plan that works, that's

01:31:04.150 --> 01:31:10.670
what I would suggest we review to see if somebody else has come up with a way without burdening

01:31:10.670 --> 01:31:17.710
staff to come up with, to put people together to maybe get some accountability to scale.

01:31:17.710 --> 01:31:18.710
Thank you, Greg.

01:31:18.710 --> 01:31:23.030
Is there anyone else from the public that would like to address Council on another issue?

01:31:23.030 --> 01:31:24.030
Come forward, please.

01:31:24.030 --> 01:31:29.840
[Muted for privacy: street address]

01:31:29.840 --> 01:31:34.240
[Muted for privacy: street address]

01:31:34.240 --> 01:31:41.000
[Muted for privacy: street address]

01:31:41.000 --> 01:31:47.280
The pedestrian crossing warning lights just aren't visible when they're on the side now.

01:31:47.280 --> 01:31:55.040
I just have a tough time seeing them, especially preceding southwest, I guess.

01:31:55.040 --> 01:31:58.600
on Shoshone Street coming up to Maine Avenue.

01:31:58.600 --> 01:32:04.520
That particular pedestrian crossing warning light is almost always blocked by a tree

01:32:04.520 --> 01:32:08.760
or by one of the service trucks for the east roads that are going in.

01:32:08.760 --> 01:32:15.280
So my suggestion, that's my concern and my suggestion is to put it in the middle.

01:32:15.280 --> 01:32:24.280
I think it would be more visible if it's in that center part in between the two lanes.

01:32:24.280 --> 01:32:25.280
That's it.

01:32:25.280 --> 01:32:26.280
That's perfect.

01:32:26.280 --> 01:32:31.280
And I'll ask Jack Fields come forward and maybe could we have someone go look at that.

01:32:31.280 --> 01:32:33.280
What do you think of the suggestion?

01:32:33.280 --> 01:32:34.280
Jackie.

01:32:34.280 --> 01:32:41.230
So we'll look at the suggestion and we'll also look at cutting the trees back or dealing

01:32:41.230 --> 01:32:48.750
with the site distance here because at some point in time you can see it, right?

01:32:48.750 --> 01:32:53.670
I think I know further as well.

01:32:53.670 --> 01:32:57.270
might have some living up to do or we might need to move the signs and the

01:32:57.270 --> 01:33:01.970
center is it necessarily a bad spot it has a few little issues associated with it

01:33:01.970 --> 01:33:07.930
but you know most things can be done with thank you very much well and this

01:33:07.930 --> 01:33:13.130
point is well taken as there's seemingly during the day there's often a truck

01:33:13.130 --> 01:33:17.690
parked there to make deliveries to the different restaurants both sides of

01:33:17.690 --> 01:33:21.590
It's just shown street, and so that does cause for a,

01:33:21.590 --> 01:33:26.330
that sign be blocked often for those deliveries.

01:33:26.330 --> 01:33:29.810
I think they must deliver to the full block on each way.

01:33:29.810 --> 01:33:33.010
Let me see if we can move them to the alley, too.

01:33:33.010 --> 01:33:34.970
So I drive that all the time,

01:33:34.970 --> 01:33:36.890
and I didn't necessarily notice that,

01:33:36.890 --> 01:33:39.210
and that's part of the beauty of having people step up

01:33:39.210 --> 01:33:41.370
and say, yeah, I think this is a problem,

01:33:41.370 --> 01:33:44.490
because it causes us to take another block

01:33:44.490 --> 01:33:46.940
with a different kind of eye.

01:33:46.940 --> 01:33:58.940
I agree, thank you for bringing this to our attention because we might not have seen it, but I think this is a cooperation between yourself and your department, maybe the police department, and now taking a look about some enforcement.

01:33:58.940 --> 01:33:59.940
Awesome.

01:33:59.940 --> 01:34:11.940
Captain Krier is with us this evening, and he is serving as our acting chief for the balance of this week, and I'm sure that he has heard and been thinking about opportunities that he could participate as well.

01:34:11.940 --> 01:34:13.940
I bet he has.

01:34:13.940 --> 01:34:16.980
Thank you, thank you again for bringing that to our attention.

01:34:16.980 --> 01:34:20.470
Anyone else from the public?

01:34:20.470 --> 01:34:22.150
City manager, anything further?

01:34:23.250 --> 01:34:25.390
Mr. Mayor, members of council, just one quick item

01:34:25.390 --> 01:34:28.470
for people to put on their calendars as a date,

01:34:28.470 --> 01:34:30.790
but we don't have a lot of specifics yet.

01:34:30.790 --> 01:34:33.230
On August 23rd, which is a Saturday,

01:34:33.230 --> 01:34:35.310
we're going to be having a ribbon-cutting

01:34:35.310 --> 01:34:38.710
and an opening for Baxter's Park.

01:34:39.590 --> 01:34:41.070
We're working in conjunctions

01:34:41.070 --> 01:34:42.510
with the different service groups

01:34:42.510 --> 01:34:44.350
that have really contributed to the volunteers

01:34:44.350 --> 01:34:45.990
who have labored out there.

01:34:45.990 --> 01:34:49.870
And we also want to make sure that we have a really good

01:34:49.870 --> 01:34:53.070
celebration for the effort that has taken place.

01:34:53.070 --> 01:34:56.310
So the date is set for August 23rd.

01:34:56.310 --> 01:34:59.230
And our Parks and Recreation Director Dennis Boyer

01:34:59.230 --> 01:35:00.990
is still working out all of the details,

01:35:00.990 --> 01:35:04.470
but we'll continue to provide them as they materialize.

01:35:04.470 --> 01:35:09.280
I believe I got an email today, said it was 11 a.m.

01:35:09.280 --> 01:35:11.520
Does that change?

01:35:11.520 --> 01:35:14.400
I have not heard of time, so let's shoot for 11 a.m.

01:35:14.400 --> 01:35:18.400
We have some time and we'll be able to find it.

01:35:18.400 --> 01:35:19.400
Perfect, thank you.

01:35:19.400 --> 01:35:20.400
Anything else, sir?

01:35:20.400 --> 01:35:22.880
City Council, anything else?

01:35:22.880 --> 01:35:26.880
Ladies and gentlemen, we've been here an hour and 35 minutes, so if you would be just patient

01:35:26.880 --> 01:35:30.880
with us, we're going to go ahead and take about a five minute break

01:35:30.880 --> 01:35:32.880
and come back and go into the public here.

01:35:32.880 --> 01:42:05.620
I'd like to reconvene the meeting of the City Council for

01:42:05.620 --> 01:42:08.620
July 28th, 2014.

01:42:08.620 --> 01:42:11.620
It is 20 minutes to the hour of 7 p.m.

01:42:11.620 --> 01:42:15.020
Now, next item on the agenda is the public hearing.

01:42:15.020 --> 01:42:18.900
And just like to advise folks about the public hearing,

01:42:18.900 --> 01:42:20.380
what we'll do is we'll open it up.

01:42:20.380 --> 01:42:24.180
In this case, the appellant will have 15 minutes

01:42:24.180 --> 01:42:26.660
to come up and make a presentation,

01:42:26.660 --> 01:42:29.700
followed by a city staff.

01:42:29.700 --> 01:42:33.860
And there could be some questions from council regarding

01:42:33.860 --> 01:42:36.220
either presentation.

01:42:36.220 --> 01:42:39.660
And then we will open up the public testimony portion

01:42:39.660 --> 01:42:42.340
of the hearing and give folks about two minutes.

01:42:43.700 --> 01:42:46.900
Over to my right is our Vice Mayor Suzanne Hawkins,

01:42:46.900 --> 01:42:48.580
and she will have a,

01:42:49.960 --> 01:42:51.600
for which you wanna straighten me out.

01:42:51.600 --> 01:42:57.640
You should give the respondent 15 minutes as well, you're on.

01:42:57.640 --> 01:42:58.640
Oh, okay, thank you.

01:42:58.640 --> 01:43:01.800
And 15 minutes for the respondent as well.

01:43:01.800 --> 01:43:04.320
So we have an appellate, we have a city,

01:43:04.320 --> 01:43:05.560
and then the responder.

01:43:05.560 --> 01:43:07.680
You were the original applicant for the special use,

01:43:07.680 --> 01:43:09.240
so they should be given 15 minutes.

01:43:09.240 --> 01:43:10.920
First, second, where?

01:43:10.920 --> 01:43:13.240
It doesn't matter, in there somewhere.

01:43:13.240 --> 01:43:18.240
Okay, but Susanne Hawkins will hold up a sign for the appellant

01:43:18.240 --> 01:43:23.640
and the applicant itself, you'll have five minutes,

01:43:23.640 --> 01:43:26.200
two minutes, and then 30 seconds.

01:43:26.200 --> 01:43:29.040
For the two-minute folks, the public that have two minutes

01:43:29.040 --> 01:43:31.040
to speak, you'll have the 32nd.

01:43:32.920 --> 01:43:35.360
It doesn't mean that you have to stop when you see those.

01:43:35.360 --> 01:43:37.280
It just gives you kind of a guideline.

01:43:37.280 --> 01:43:40.680
So that's how we'll run the public hearing tonight.

01:43:40.680 --> 01:44:08.680
So we will start off with consideration of an appeal regarding the planning and zoning commission's decision on June 10, 2014 to approve a special use permit to allow for a 24-hour gasoline service station with a drive-through window on 2.7 give or take acres located at the northeast corner of Meadowview Lane and Kimberly Road.

01:44:08.680 --> 01:44:16.120
So at this time, we'll go ahead and ask the Appellant Gary Asher to come forward.

01:44:16.120 --> 01:44:18.120
Welcome, Mr. Asher.

01:44:18.120 --> 01:44:29.360
Did you get my copy of my neighbors with the science of the petition?

01:44:29.360 --> 01:44:31.360
Yes, sir. We have a petition in front of you.

01:44:31.360 --> 01:44:32.360
Yes, sir.

01:44:32.360 --> 01:44:36.360
Okay. I'm a resident of Twin Falls.

01:44:36.360 --> 01:44:40.360
It's 1979. I like it here. I don't want to stay here.

01:44:40.360 --> 01:44:42.360
Don't plan on going anywhere.

01:44:42.360 --> 01:44:49.960
have an issue and so do my neighbors have an issue with this service station going in on the corner of Metalview and Kimberly Road.

01:44:49.960 --> 01:45:03.960
As it says here, we concerns the location, the hours, the increase, the big, big issue I think is the increased amount of automobiles that will probably come into our community.

01:45:03.960 --> 01:45:10.960
And then the other issue is the access in and off of Kimberly Road to Metal View.

01:45:10.960 --> 01:45:13.960
Okay, there's no stoplight there.

01:45:13.960 --> 01:45:16.350
All there is the stop sign.

01:45:16.350 --> 01:45:22.350
People are trying to make left-hand turns from the service station on the Kimberly Road.

01:45:22.350 --> 01:45:25.350
And that gets pretty congested at times.

01:45:25.350 --> 01:45:31.350
You know, living over there since 2008, I got a pretty good handle on getting pretty congested at times.

01:45:31.350 --> 01:45:37.350
And with this japanee pant going out there, it's even gotten more traffic quite a bit more.

01:45:37.350 --> 01:45:50.110
We would like for you guys to listen to us that there should be someplace else for a service station to go in.

01:45:50.110 --> 01:45:55.110
That would be better suitable than the corner of the metal view in Kimberly Road.

01:45:55.110 --> 01:46:01.840
There's property available down at a four point on Hankins and Kimberly Road.

01:46:01.840 --> 01:46:05.920
I don't know, that would be more suitable, I think,

01:46:05.920 --> 01:46:08.280
and I saw some of my neighbors.

01:46:10.680 --> 01:46:12.680
Some few additional comments or points

01:46:12.680 --> 01:46:16.100
that I'd like to address is this is not to be,

01:46:16.100 --> 01:46:19.000
this is not a use that is outright allowed

01:46:19.000 --> 01:46:20.600
by the commercial zone.

01:46:20.600 --> 01:46:23.240
This is only allowed through special use.

01:46:23.240 --> 01:46:27.440
The use is more intrusive than others allowed uses

01:46:27.440 --> 01:46:29.040
in the C1 zone.

01:46:29.040 --> 01:46:33.520
That is why it went through special use.

01:46:33.520 --> 01:46:34.880
The Planning and Zoning Commission

01:46:34.880 --> 01:46:40.560
seemed to just lump this into the general allowed uses in C1.

01:46:40.560 --> 01:46:46.700
Second point is the apartment should not be viewed as a buffer.

01:46:46.700 --> 01:46:50.500
To residential, they are residential.

01:46:50.500 --> 01:46:55.880
All the more reason to disallow more intrusion uses

01:46:55.880 --> 01:46:59.020
that would outright allow the C-Zone

01:46:59.020 --> 01:47:07.350
unless precipitation that those residents don't count unless they perceive that.

01:47:07.350 --> 01:47:13.550
The applicant is also obviously assuming that the neighbors have no say in the process.

01:47:13.550 --> 01:47:19.390
They put up the huge sign announcing coming soon even though we have appealed the special

01:47:19.390 --> 01:47:21.550
use of the city council.

01:47:21.550 --> 01:47:26.760
Please let them know that the neighbors do matter.

01:47:26.760 --> 01:47:31.120
I don't know if we're allowed to give you any conditions or something if this was to go in.

01:47:31.120 --> 01:47:34.240
a couple of conditions that I've thought about was,

01:47:34.240 --> 01:47:38.120
if this has to go in on our corner,

01:47:38.120 --> 01:47:42.600
I would like to have a red light put at that stop sign.

01:47:42.600 --> 01:47:49.020
With a left hand turn lane from Bellevue on to Kimberly Road,

01:47:49.020 --> 01:47:50.740
I think that would help a whole lot.

01:47:50.740 --> 01:47:56.490
I can just see accidents happening there.

01:47:56.490 --> 01:47:58.050
That's all I got.

01:47:58.050 --> 01:47:58.970
Thank you, Mr. Asher.

01:47:58.970 --> 01:48:00.810
There might be some questions for you, sir.

01:48:00.810 --> 01:48:02.290
OK.

01:48:02.290 --> 01:48:05.250
I think this time we're going to go ahead and let

01:48:05.250 --> 01:48:10.250
the applicant come forward and it's Mr. Jim Lynch.

01:48:11.420 --> 01:48:13.900
Mr. Lynch, you will have 15 minutes as well.

01:48:15.610 --> 01:48:16.890
Mayor said, Council members,

01:48:16.890 --> 01:48:20.250
thank you for giving the opportunity to be here tonight.

01:48:22.190 --> 01:48:24.890
We have been in business for 91 years.

01:48:24.890 --> 01:48:26.530
I'm the third generation,

01:48:26.530 --> 01:48:29.710
my boys who are running this project

01:48:29.710 --> 01:48:32.530
are the fourth generation and the fifth

01:48:32.530 --> 01:48:34.860
has already been born.

01:48:34.860 --> 01:48:38.460
We have not got to this level in many or 91 years

01:48:38.460 --> 01:48:40.660
by not listening to our neighbors.

01:48:40.660 --> 01:48:43.900
Absolutely it's critical to be good neighbors.

01:48:43.900 --> 01:48:44.980
We want these neighbors.

01:48:44.980 --> 01:48:47.980
We don't look at the apartments as a buffer zone.

01:48:47.980 --> 01:48:51.140
But as I said during the planning and zoning process,

01:48:51.140 --> 01:48:53.140
we're gonna put the trees in,

01:48:53.140 --> 01:48:54.940
we're gonna buffer everything.

01:48:54.940 --> 01:48:58.340
We do not want neighbors to be disturbed at night.

01:48:58.340 --> 01:49:00.980
One of the people in the previous meeting said,

01:49:00.980 --> 01:49:04.260
we're gonna, it looks like we're building a mini truck stop.

01:49:04.260 --> 01:49:11.380
We are going to build a truck stop in Jerome, that land we already own at the second exit.

01:49:11.380 --> 01:49:18.020
We are building a gas station convenience store that's going to have an RV facility for people

01:49:18.020 --> 01:49:21.340
who are traveling through our beautiful state with fifth wheel traders.

01:49:21.340 --> 01:49:29.460
It's getting more and more difficult as we, at least I age, to back up better with traders.

01:49:29.460 --> 01:49:36.460
So therefore, we want to get the entrance in so they pull in, they fuel up and move on.

01:49:36.460 --> 01:49:41.460
The drive and window is a six to tenet night.

01:49:41.460 --> 01:49:47.460
Every night of the week is set for Fridays and Saturdays, and then we go to 11th.

01:49:47.460 --> 01:49:49.460
People don't drink coffee all night long.

01:49:49.460 --> 01:49:51.460
We're not going to run that all night long.

01:49:51.460 --> 01:49:57.460
People said they were worried about the diesel engines running all night long.

01:49:57.460 --> 01:50:02.740
We don't accept any deliveries until our manager has to accept deliveries.

01:50:02.740 --> 01:50:06.300
They don't get to work until 6.30 in the morning, so no deliveries are ever delivered

01:50:06.300 --> 01:50:08.060
to the store.

01:50:08.060 --> 01:50:14.200
And I supply diesels to quite a few of the people who deliver product to me, and nobody

01:50:14.200 --> 01:50:19.280
at $4 a gallon allows their trucks to run an idle.

01:50:19.280 --> 01:50:20.280
Nobody.

01:50:20.280 --> 01:50:24.400
Everyone pulls in, shuts them off, and delivers the product.

01:50:24.400 --> 01:50:29.680
they want to get through that day, they hurry on and move out of the way. And I went through

01:50:29.680 --> 01:50:39.920
the neighborhood and I cannot see in any way a person with a tow vehicle pulling up to Nettleby Lane

01:50:39.920 --> 01:50:46.880
and turning to the right. I drove down the road isn't straight, excuse me, it curves around,

01:50:46.880 --> 01:50:52.240
you go quite a distance before you hit the stop sign and you can turn to go to Hankham's road

01:50:52.240 --> 01:50:55.140
or go up there, come out to elementary school.

01:50:55.140 --> 01:50:57.720
That was the first time I'd ever been on it.

01:50:57.720 --> 01:51:03.200
I see people pulling in, and do we have a slide for the

01:51:03.200 --> 01:51:08.300
property that we submitted?

01:51:08.300 --> 01:51:11.500
Pulling in, the RV island is over to the side.

01:51:11.500 --> 01:51:12.780
Can you use the pointer, Jim?

01:51:12.780 --> 01:51:16.070
Can you give him the pointer to?

01:51:16.070 --> 01:51:19.360
Has a little laser on it.

01:51:19.360 --> 01:51:22.160
Okay, so what we're hoping is people are going to pull in

01:51:22.160 --> 01:51:25.840
here, they're going to fuel up here, or if they're driving

01:51:25.840 --> 01:51:31.700
in an automobile that will come in over here, and the natural form is going to exit right

01:51:31.700 --> 01:51:32.700
over here.

01:51:32.700 --> 01:51:36.960
I can't see no reason on Earth why anybody would go down here.

01:51:36.960 --> 01:51:41.160
You've been traveling on a four-lane road, and I'd call that really a five-lane road with

01:51:41.160 --> 01:51:45.320
a turn lane in it, but a four-lane in traffic out here.

01:51:45.320 --> 01:51:49.800
So I just can't see how anybody's going to, if they're pulled in here and don't know the

01:51:49.800 --> 01:51:50.800
area.

01:51:50.800 --> 01:51:55.120
The first thing I do, when I'm traveling, I see when I pull in someplace, I want to know

01:51:55.120 --> 01:51:59.680
how I'm going to get back out if I got a trailer. There's no lamp on it in some place if I can't

01:51:59.680 --> 01:52:06.320
see it and exit out. So these cars back here are lined up for a drive-in window on that side

01:52:06.320 --> 01:52:14.720
of the building and the delivery areas, I mean they sort of just park where they want to,

01:52:14.720 --> 01:52:19.440
you know, and we don't really get to tell the beer guys or the food service vendors where,

01:52:19.440 --> 01:52:25.000
but we envision right through here is be where they're going to park. They'll probably turn

01:52:25.000 --> 01:52:29.880
in here, go this way so that you can get back out and go back towards town.

01:52:29.880 --> 01:52:35.960
And the kind of lighting we use, we use LED lighting at our newest facilities and in Burleigh

01:52:35.960 --> 01:52:41.410
we just built a new canopy to replace an old one and we put LED lights in it.

01:52:41.410 --> 01:52:45.690
And underneath that canopy it's like daylight, you can read your watch.

01:52:45.690 --> 01:52:50.210
Walk 12 feet outside the canopy, you can no longer read your watch.

01:52:50.210 --> 01:52:54.410
We're not going to throw light all over this piece of property.

01:52:54.410 --> 01:52:59.960
And then I brought some numbers for you to look at, I really don't like competitors to

01:52:59.960 --> 01:53:07.320
see these kind of numbers, but this is, at our Blue Lakes location, it takes the first

01:53:07.320 --> 01:53:10.340
27 days of this month.

01:53:10.340 --> 01:53:15.020
This is a clock, midnight one o'clock, morning two o'clock in the morning.

01:53:15.020 --> 01:53:21.660
We average 20 customers, and if you did this, you would see they're normally on your weekends.

01:53:21.660 --> 01:53:32.210
So this tells you that at 2 o'clock of the morning we average 6 customers at 3 to 4,6,10.

01:53:32.210 --> 01:53:36.570
And then here because we're in agricultural state, this time of year people are going

01:53:36.570 --> 01:53:37.970
out into the fields.

01:53:37.970 --> 01:53:42.050
They stop being at ice, sodas, sandwiches, and they head on out.

01:53:42.050 --> 01:53:48.850
But if you look here, the most we have ever is in the evening from 5 to 6.

01:53:48.850 --> 01:53:51.860
We have 62 customers per hour.

01:53:51.860 --> 01:53:54.140
Now most of our people in the city of Twin Falls,

01:53:54.140 --> 01:53:56.620
now this is for our location on Bluemakes.

01:53:56.620 --> 01:54:00.260
I believe that the numbers will be even slower

01:54:00.260 --> 01:54:01.620
at this particular, you know,

01:54:01.620 --> 01:54:05.340
Bluemakes, the high traffic area and everything.

01:54:05.340 --> 01:54:10.020
And at this location, 58% of the people pay at the pump,

01:54:10.020 --> 01:54:12.660
and don't even come in the storm.

01:54:12.660 --> 01:54:15.980
You just pull in with the credit card in and you're gone.

01:54:15.980 --> 01:54:18.780
And I really don't see how we're going to impact

01:54:18.780 --> 01:54:20.300
the neighborhood a lot.

01:54:20.300 --> 01:54:22.060
People shut the cars off by law.

01:54:22.060 --> 01:54:24.900
They're supposed to shut the cars off while they're fueling.

01:54:24.900 --> 01:54:27.420
And I know out of the diesel islands they're going to have to do that.

01:54:27.420 --> 01:54:32.740
So I promised the planning zoning that I would bring this so

01:54:32.740 --> 01:54:37.300
that you guys could see during the winter time it goes down substantially.

01:54:37.300 --> 01:54:39.780
No one's out during the middle of the night or anything.

01:54:39.780 --> 01:54:44.190
Well, so you're saying, well, why don't you guys just close at one?

01:54:44.190 --> 01:54:46.710
Well, we have to have people there to clean up.

01:54:46.710 --> 01:54:49.950
At five o'clock you can see when we start to get a little bit busy with

01:54:49.950 --> 01:54:56.010
15 and then at seven we get busy they want coffee. Well when we're making these great

01:54:56.010 --> 01:55:01.550
big petals like this it's a 30-minute process. We grind the coffee, we make the

01:55:01.550 --> 01:55:07.050
coffee and then it needs to be brewed. And so it takes a period of time. Even at

01:55:07.050 --> 01:55:10.590
Blue Lakes we've wondered well let's don't be open all night long. So my

01:55:10.590 --> 01:55:17.630
manager who's been my manager for 28 years said if you think I'm going to get

01:55:17.630 --> 01:55:24.560
up between 2.30 and 3. Put on makeup. Get my hair fixed so I can be down there and by 4

01:55:24.560 --> 01:55:29.520
o'clock you better find somebody else. So we just thought it's unfair. I mean during

01:55:29.520 --> 01:55:33.520
the minute you don't get somebody up that early. So keep someone there overnight and

01:55:33.520 --> 01:55:38.920
let's clean up the property. Let's wipe down the pumps, empty the garbages, brew the coffee,

01:55:38.920 --> 01:55:44.240
we make our own sandwiches on site, we make pizzas on a daily basis. So we do all this

01:55:44.240 --> 01:55:51.910
prep or get everything done so during the day we can wait on customers and take care of them.

01:55:51.910 --> 01:55:54.950
We've already been contact by Kimberly Nursery.

01:55:54.950 --> 01:55:58.610
They're going to come in and do a site plan that we'll submit to the City of Twin Falls

01:55:58.610 --> 01:56:02.750
to make sure that we're going to do everything absolutely right.

01:56:02.750 --> 01:56:11.140
We're going to make sure that everybody's going to be happy.

01:56:11.140 --> 01:56:16.780
And you know, I just, I maybe disagree a little bit.

01:56:16.780 --> 01:56:19.940
And I think we're zoned in the proper neighborhood,

01:56:19.940 --> 01:56:22.900
C1, what we want to do here is allowed.

01:56:22.900 --> 01:56:26.540
We do new special use permits, but it isn't allowed in that area,

01:56:26.540 --> 01:56:29.060
and it just seems to make sense for us.

01:56:29.060 --> 01:56:32.900
We realize that it's nice to be down at the four corners.

01:56:32.900 --> 01:56:34.460
We look at it.

01:56:34.460 --> 01:56:37.700
The price doesn't make sense for us.

01:56:37.700 --> 01:56:39.500
Now, some companies are much bigger than us,

01:56:39.500 --> 01:56:42.620
have a lot more money, and they can do that.

01:56:42.620 --> 01:56:44.500
But we just couldn't make that work for us,

01:56:44.500 --> 01:56:48.030
we moved down here and bought this property.

01:56:48.030 --> 01:56:50.390
And we're looking, trying to be good neighbors.

01:56:50.390 --> 01:56:55.620
I really believe that everybody who has concerns

01:56:55.620 --> 01:57:00.820
one year after this is built in Oakland,

01:57:00.820 --> 01:57:03.100
they will say we're glad we're there

01:57:03.100 --> 01:57:04.780
and that we are good neighbors.

01:57:04.780 --> 01:57:06.980
Thank you very much for your time.

01:57:06.980 --> 01:57:11.540
Thank you, Mr. Lynch.

01:57:11.540 --> 01:57:13.260
At this time, we'll go ahead and turn it over

01:57:13.260 --> 01:57:14.860
to staff for a staff presentation.

01:57:14.860 --> 01:57:16.300
We have Jonathan Spendlove.

01:57:16.300 --> 01:57:17.380
Welcome, Jonathan.

01:57:17.380 --> 01:57:18.820
Thank you, Mr. Chairman, as the Council,

01:57:18.820 --> 01:57:22.920
And as this is an appeal, I'm going to actually read exactly the presentation we gave the Planning

01:57:22.920 --> 01:57:25.460
and Zoning Commission.

01:57:25.460 --> 01:57:31.540
We also have a copy of the petition that if we need to, we can put it up on the screen

01:57:31.540 --> 01:57:32.540
for everybody in the audience.

01:57:32.540 --> 01:57:36.500
And I know you guys have a copy of that as well.

01:57:36.500 --> 01:57:41.420
So on June 10, 2012, 2014, the Commission granted a special use permit to construct and

01:57:41.420 --> 01:57:46.920
operate a 24-hour gas station slash convenience store with a drive-through window on property

01:57:46.920 --> 01:57:52.320
located at the northeast corner of Meadowby Lane and Kimberly Road subject to four conditions.

01:57:52.320 --> 01:57:55.040
We received an appeal during the appeal period.

01:57:55.040 --> 01:58:01.920
I believe that the appellant has stated his concerns exactly how they were written in the letter

01:58:01.920 --> 01:58:05.920
we received as well as the applicant, they've stated those and I'm going to go over their

01:58:05.920 --> 01:58:07.520
histories again.

01:58:07.520 --> 01:58:14.680
As per City Code 1013.2.2j, upon receipt of an appeal from the action of the Commission,

01:58:14.680 --> 01:58:18.860
Council shall set a hearing date under the same provisions as the Commission hearing to

01:58:18.860 --> 01:58:22.980
consider all information, testimony and the Commission's minutes of the public hearing

01:58:22.980 --> 01:58:28.520
should reach a decision to uphold, conditionally uphold or overrule the decision of the Commission.

01:58:28.520 --> 01:58:34.680
The following is the analysis provided to the Commission at June 10, 2014 public hearing.

01:58:34.680 --> 01:58:39.400
First City Code 1048.2b6a and 10g and 10j.

01:58:39.400 --> 01:58:44.960
I'm a gasoline service station, 24-hour retail operation, and a drive-through are all required

01:58:44.960 --> 01:58:50.060
to obtain a special use permit prior to being established in the C1 Commercial Highway Zoning

01:58:50.060 --> 01:58:51.060
District.

01:58:51.060 --> 01:58:54.080
Per city code 1076, street setbacks.

01:58:54.080 --> 01:58:57.280
Any building located along the stretch of Kimberly Road will need to follow a centerline

01:58:57.280 --> 01:59:00.400
setback, set forth in the code.

01:59:00.400 --> 01:59:03.960
On this section of Kimberly Road, the centerline setback is 93 feet.

01:59:03.960 --> 01:59:07.720
The site plan is submitted by the applicant, which is up on the overhead right now, appears

01:59:07.720 --> 01:59:11.800
to meet this requirement. However, this setback will be officially reviewed at the time of

01:59:11.800 --> 01:59:15.880
building permits submittal. That is not a construction drawing that they gave us, it is merely a site

01:59:15.880 --> 01:59:21.810
plan. Per City Code 10712, gateway arterial landscaping. This stretch of Kimberly Road is a gateway

01:59:21.810 --> 01:59:27.570
arterial. There will be a required 30 foot wide landscape strip along Kimberly Road frontage.

01:59:27.570 --> 01:59:31.890
This landscaping will be required to follow all applicable standards for a number of trees and

01:59:31.890 --> 01:59:37.490
bushes. This requirement will be assessed at the time of building permits submittal. Per City Code 10

01:59:37.490 --> 01:59:41.810
10-10 Austrian parking. The parking requirement for this type of use will be

01:59:41.810 --> 01:59:45.610
assessed at a rate of one parking space for every 300 square feet. The site plan

01:59:45.610 --> 01:59:49.410
provided by the applicant shows the site plan meets or exceeds the amount required.

01:59:49.410 --> 01:59:53.250
The official count and assessment will be performed at the time of building permits

01:59:53.250 --> 01:59:58.650
the middle subject to applicable city codes at that time. First city code 1011-1-8

01:59:58.650 --> 02:00:02.810
required improvements. All improvements required under this code section will

02:00:02.810 --> 02:00:06.050
be reviewed at the time of building permits the middle. The required improvements

02:00:06.050 --> 02:00:11.610
outlined in the City Code include landscaping, screening, parking, streets and utilities.

02:00:11.610 --> 02:00:14.530
Some of these improvements have been addressed on the site plan, others will be reviewed

02:00:14.530 --> 02:00:16.610
at the time of building permit.

02:00:16.610 --> 02:00:20.610
A lot in question was part of a larger parcel that was split sometime in 2008.

02:00:20.610 --> 02:00:25.010
A split was by a previous owner, was done without recognition by the City as a legal

02:00:25.010 --> 02:00:30.210
lot, as a consequence this lot may need to be plotted prior to approval of any development

02:00:30.210 --> 02:00:31.970
occurring on this lot.

02:00:31.970 --> 02:00:35.690
Further review by City staff will determine if it's required.

02:00:35.690 --> 02:00:39.250
possible impacts that line by city staff.

02:00:39.250 --> 02:00:42.850
The impacts of gasoline, service station will generally include an increase in customer

02:00:42.850 --> 02:00:48.150
traffic to the immediate streets in the area, light intrusion on surrounding properties,

02:00:48.150 --> 02:00:52.810
deliveries by larger trucks, a 24-hour operation for the store, and an increase in noise disturbance

02:00:52.810 --> 02:00:54.450
to neighboring properties.

02:00:54.450 --> 02:00:57.450
The increase of traffic to the area should be kept to a minimum given the location of

02:00:57.450 --> 02:01:01.810
the property along Kimberly Road, which is a major arterial in Twin Falls.

02:01:01.810 --> 02:01:05.890
It is safe to assume the majority of traffic will enter and exit onto Kimberly Road, thus

02:01:05.890 --> 02:01:11.630
diminishing the negative impacts of the customer and truck traffic on the surrounding area.

02:01:11.630 --> 02:01:14.970
The possibility of light intrusion on neighboring properties is something that can be a negative

02:01:14.970 --> 02:01:17.010
impact on neighboring properties.

02:01:17.010 --> 02:01:20.530
City code currently requires all lighting to be downward facing in order to help mitigate

02:01:20.530 --> 02:01:22.010
the light intrusion.

02:01:22.010 --> 02:01:26.970
The city always encourages new businesses to be open to neighboring properties, complaints

02:01:26.970 --> 02:01:28.610
about light intrusion.

02:01:28.610 --> 02:01:33.690
If a problem arises, the city has a process to get the situation rectified if needed.

02:01:33.690 --> 02:01:37.290
The drive-through and 24-hour operation could produce an increase in noise for neighboring

02:01:37.290 --> 02:01:38.850
property owners.

02:01:38.850 --> 02:01:42.490
Current city code requires screening between commercial and residential properties.

02:01:42.490 --> 02:01:45.610
This can be accomplished in a variety of ways.

02:01:45.610 --> 02:01:49.410
The minimum standard of screening will be required and reviewed at the time of building permits

02:01:49.410 --> 02:01:50.410
in the middle.

02:01:50.410 --> 02:01:54.290
The commission may require more than the minimum standard outlined in the code if it finds that

02:01:54.290 --> 02:01:57.810
the proposed development will have greater impacts on the neighboring properties than

02:01:57.810 --> 02:01:59.970
and the minimum standard will mitigate.

02:01:59.970 --> 02:02:02.250
The applicant has attempted to address this issue

02:02:02.250 --> 02:02:04.450
by showing a landscape strip on the north side

02:02:04.450 --> 02:02:09.460
of the property that shows multiple trees.

02:02:09.460 --> 02:02:11.620
The following is analysis of the public hearing,

02:02:11.620 --> 02:02:14.300
and a testimony found at that hearing.

02:02:14.300 --> 02:02:16.100
On the PUNN and Commission public hearing,

02:02:16.100 --> 02:02:17.920
there were four people who spoke against the request

02:02:17.920 --> 02:02:20.500
below are the public comments from the public hearing.

02:02:20.500 --> 02:02:23.420
Number one, concerns with late night traffic

02:02:23.420 --> 02:02:25.900
with diesel trucks parked and running at night.

02:02:25.900 --> 02:02:28.780
Number two, this area still has a residential feel,

02:02:28.780 --> 02:02:32.880
this will increase a hazard to the residential area. The 24-hour service will

02:02:32.880 --> 02:02:36.820
provide a disturbance to the neighborhood. He stated a service station will increase

02:02:36.820 --> 02:02:40.600
traffic flow through the neighborhood noise, fumes from the gasoline, people

02:02:40.600 --> 02:02:43.660
loitering, and the glare from lights located on the site will impact the

02:02:43.660 --> 02:02:49.100
neighborhoods also. Number three, while the concept may make sense to have

02:02:49.100 --> 02:02:52.200
these services, the location proposed for this development doesn't make sense.

02:02:52.200 --> 02:02:56.980
Some of the reasons for this are that this is not going to be located at a light

02:02:56.980 --> 02:03:01.860
intersection. The RV vehicles are similar to semi-trucks and maneuvering to get this

02:03:01.860 --> 02:03:06.220
location is going to be difficult without the benefit of the light. The easiest way

02:03:06.220 --> 02:03:09.260
to get back to Hankins Road or Kimberly Road would be to travel through the

02:03:09.260 --> 02:03:13.500
neighborhood and number four the apartments being built with the

02:03:13.500 --> 02:03:16.540
apartments being built traffic has increased through their neighborhood and

02:03:16.540 --> 02:03:20.660
he is opposed to this request. Those are all people that had showed up to the

02:03:20.660 --> 02:03:25.620
hearing to speak against or for the item. Upon conclusion of the public hearing the

02:03:25.620 --> 02:03:31.020
commissioners deliberated and asked for clarifications from staff on many traffic related issues

02:03:31.020 --> 02:03:33.020
and potential impacts.

02:03:33.020 --> 02:03:37.200
Those specifically are in your packet attachment number four.

02:03:37.200 --> 02:03:41.900
At the conclusion of their deliberations, Commissioner Derrikott made a motion to approve

02:03:41.900 --> 02:03:45.920
the request as presented subject to compliance of four conditions.

02:03:45.920 --> 02:03:49.860
Commissioner Reed seconded the motion and the motion was unanimously approved.

02:03:49.860 --> 02:03:53.460
I'm going to read those exact conditions.

02:03:53.460 --> 02:04:02.100
Number one, subject to the site plan amendments as required by building, engineering, fire, and zoning officials to ensure compliance with applicable city code requirements and standards.

02:04:02.100 --> 02:04:07.260
Number two, subject to final determination whether the property requires planning prior to development.

02:04:07.260 --> 02:04:14.340
Number three, subject to access location on adjacent roadways being approved by city staff in the Idaho Transportation Department.

02:04:14.340 --> 02:04:23.170
And number four, number four, if ITD allows Kimberly Road access, the applicant should provide a right turn deceleration lane.

02:04:23.170 --> 02:04:29.430
conclusion, as per City Code 1032.2j, which is the appeal process,

02:04:29.430 --> 02:04:33.690
the motion shall be made in the affirmative and may be subject to specific conditions.

02:04:33.690 --> 02:04:39.430
The council decision shall be to uphold, conditionally uphold, or overruled the decision of the commission.

02:04:39.430 --> 02:04:44.490
The decision shall be by simple majority of vote.

02:04:44.490 --> 02:04:45.990
Thank you, Mr. Spinlop.

02:04:45.990 --> 02:04:52.370
At this time, we're going to probably have council ask questions of, can't ask questions of the

02:04:52.370 --> 02:05:00.690
the applicant or city staff, so Chris talking to Jonathan, a little bit of background, if

02:05:00.690 --> 02:05:06.880
you will. This is a most difficult situation philosophically that I've encountered in

02:05:06.880 --> 02:05:13.720
a while because you don't normally about a commercial next to a medium density. That's

02:05:13.720 --> 02:05:20.920
poor planning. How long has this been stripped zone commercial all along Kimberly Road for

02:05:20.920 --> 02:05:28.760
that depth. So that depth I believe is done at least as far back as the 1970s. The apartments

02:05:28.760 --> 02:05:34.700
were done, they are technically zones C1 as well. Those apartments are. So they're not

02:05:34.700 --> 02:05:42.120
so C1. The apartments are zones C1? Correct. Yeah, I see that but I mean nobody could have

02:05:42.120 --> 02:05:47.680
a commercial operation then an apartment. So that's just. The apartments are in allowed

02:05:47.680 --> 02:05:52.380
use in the C1 zone, anything over five units is allowed in that zone.

02:05:52.380 --> 02:05:56.750
So the apartments encroached upon the commercial building zone.

02:05:56.750 --> 02:05:58.350
I guess it's different.

02:05:58.350 --> 02:06:04.830
They were allowed in a loud use because of the magnitude of the development, because of

02:06:04.830 --> 02:06:06.810
the size.

02:06:06.810 --> 02:06:12.700
At the same time, I don't see anything the applicant could have done except to provide

02:06:12.700 --> 02:06:13.700
for the screening.

02:06:13.700 --> 02:06:20.500
I do have a question in Mr. Lynch that you do not entertain putting in a car wash, an external

02:06:20.500 --> 02:06:24.260
speaker system, anything of that nature?

02:06:24.260 --> 02:06:27.140
Mr. Lynch, if you'd come forward, please.

02:06:27.140 --> 02:06:31.230
This is recorded in for the microphone, sir.

02:06:31.230 --> 02:06:34.350
No car washes envisioned, ever.

02:06:34.350 --> 02:06:39.270
And no external speaker system telling you to come in and pay from pump three or something

02:06:39.270 --> 02:06:40.830
like that?

02:06:40.830 --> 02:06:45.490
We do have communication systems so that if a person presses a button outside they can't

02:06:45.490 --> 02:06:46.490
make the work.

02:06:46.490 --> 02:06:47.490
Okay.

02:06:47.490 --> 02:06:48.490
That's right.

02:06:48.490 --> 02:06:49.490
It can just intercoms.

02:06:49.490 --> 02:06:50.490
It can't be shared.

02:06:50.490 --> 02:06:51.490
It can't be shared.

02:06:51.490 --> 02:06:54.030
And then right now we currently have at our facility here.

02:06:54.030 --> 02:06:59.330
We have pumps that have TVs so that people have something to do for the five or six minutes

02:06:59.330 --> 02:07:01.650
while they're watching them.

02:07:01.650 --> 02:07:03.890
But they shut off at ten o'clock at night.

02:07:03.890 --> 02:07:10.690
And finally, the LED lighting that you mentioned, that's a newer type of lighting, but it's specifically

02:07:10.690 --> 02:07:17.690
shielded to protect against any sort of external bleeding beyond a certain angle past so many

02:07:17.690 --> 02:07:18.690
feet.

02:07:18.690 --> 02:07:22.530
Yeah, it just comes down to the angle and it's not a wide angle, it's a pretty sharp angle

02:07:22.530 --> 02:07:23.530
coming down.

02:07:23.530 --> 02:07:27.970
But that's not your opinion, that's something that the spec will show that there's a shielded

02:07:27.970 --> 02:07:28.970
lighting.

02:07:28.970 --> 02:07:29.970
Yes, thank you.

02:07:29.970 --> 02:07:30.970
Thank you.

02:07:30.970 --> 02:07:31.970
Rebecca Milsoy.

02:07:31.970 --> 02:07:32.970
Thank you, Mayor.

02:07:32.970 --> 02:07:35.050
I also have a question for the applicant.

02:07:35.050 --> 02:07:36.970
If you might want to stay up close.

02:07:36.970 --> 02:07:37.970
Stay close, yeah.

02:07:37.970 --> 02:07:38.970
Thank you.

02:07:38.970 --> 02:07:41.350
And they're relevant too, you might get some questions.

02:07:41.350 --> 02:07:42.610
Yes, thank you.

02:07:42.610 --> 02:07:48.010
You mentioned tonight that you're trying to work with the residents to kind of mitigate any impacts.

02:07:48.010 --> 02:07:51.850
You also mentioned that in the minutes of the Planning and Zoning Commission meeting.

02:07:51.850 --> 02:07:57.690
Have you reached out to them in the form of an open house, or have you met with the concerned

02:07:57.690 --> 02:08:03.450
residents about their concerns and what the specific requests that they have?

02:08:03.450 --> 02:08:06.370
No, ma'am, we haven't.

02:08:06.370 --> 02:08:11.130
Until we had a physical building, we could show this is the most recent building we've

02:08:11.130 --> 02:08:12.530
built in Burley.

02:08:12.530 --> 02:08:17.250
Every time we do something, we modify it, put a different cooler someplace.

02:08:17.250 --> 02:08:22.850
Until we received the blessing, these guys charged by the square foot, we were waiting

02:08:22.850 --> 02:08:28.450
to get a blessing, and then we were going to have an open house so we could explain to

02:08:28.450 --> 02:08:32.330
the neighborhood exactly what's going to go on, where things are going to actually be

02:08:32.330 --> 02:08:37.950
be placed on the property after the Corps is harvested off the property.

02:08:37.950 --> 02:08:38.950
Okay.

02:08:38.950 --> 02:08:43.450
Well, it just has been, it's not uncommon for the developers as they work through the

02:08:43.450 --> 02:08:45.650
process to really reach out to the residents.

02:08:45.650 --> 02:08:50.010
And sometimes that has created a better outcome.

02:08:50.010 --> 02:08:54.050
For example, the development on the corner of Addison in Eastland.

02:08:54.050 --> 02:08:58.330
At one point in time it was a proposed gas station and that didn't work out with the

02:08:58.330 --> 02:08:59.330
residents.

02:08:59.330 --> 02:09:03.490
the current development that's there, they actually went to the residents and said,

02:09:03.490 --> 02:09:07.570
what specifically, you know, what types of trees. So that leads to my other question, you know,

02:09:07.570 --> 02:09:13.010
you mentioned the trees along, landscaping along the north side, which that would be the side

02:09:13.010 --> 02:09:21.410
that abuts the residential use, is correct. But it seems to be the thinnest strip of landscaping

02:09:21.410 --> 02:09:26.130
and there's no specifics on what type of trees those are and how big they are and if there's a

02:09:26.130 --> 02:09:35.130
So, do you have any specifics on how the landscaping will mitigate the lights and the glare and the noise?

02:09:35.130 --> 02:09:42.830
Well, the lights will be here, the lights will be on this side out here.

02:09:42.830 --> 02:09:46.830
And the Kibley nursery is doing that as we speak.

02:09:46.830 --> 02:09:48.830
I'm not a tree or an arborist.

02:09:48.830 --> 02:09:51.830
I have no idea what does the best thing.

02:09:51.830 --> 02:09:55.830
And as I told the plant in zoning, I said, you know, normally when you plant trees,

02:09:55.830 --> 02:09:58.510
It takes a time period for them to grow.

02:09:58.510 --> 02:10:03.470
It's difficult to find 15 or 20 foot trees already.

02:10:03.470 --> 02:10:05.430
And so we're just working on those things.

02:10:05.430 --> 02:10:08.310
He'll have the plants done, I would assume,

02:10:08.310 --> 02:10:10.150
in the next three weeks.

02:10:10.150 --> 02:10:11.610
Okay.

02:10:11.610 --> 02:10:12.810
Jim Munn.

02:10:12.810 --> 02:10:14.010
Thank you, man.

02:10:14.010 --> 02:10:18.890
I guess my questions are gonna be for staff, Jackie Fields.

02:10:18.890 --> 02:10:20.890
First question I have, hopefully you can answer is,

02:10:20.890 --> 02:10:28.400
what is the speed limit in front of this property?

02:10:28.400 --> 02:10:30.440
Jonathan, do you know?

02:10:30.440 --> 02:10:39.160
is it 35 or 45? I can't remember. It's 45 miles per hour. Okay. The second question I

02:10:39.160 --> 02:10:48.520
have is the intersection of Meadowview Lane and Kimberly Road, vehicles who would leave

02:10:48.520 --> 02:10:57.400
the parking lot at this location will presumably turn left out of the parking lot and then

02:10:57.400 --> 02:11:00.240
come up with a stop sign there on the middle of the lane,

02:11:00.240 --> 02:11:03.520
which is only controlled by a stop sign.

02:11:03.520 --> 02:11:04.080
That's accurate.

02:11:04.080 --> 02:11:05.600
OK?

02:11:05.600 --> 02:11:10.910
So vehicles would queue up to either turn right or left there

02:11:10.910 --> 02:11:12.670
into a 45-mile-an-hour zone.

02:11:12.670 --> 02:11:13.670
That's accurate.

02:11:13.670 --> 02:11:14.750
From a stop sign.

02:11:14.750 --> 02:11:16.080
OK.

02:11:16.080 --> 02:11:18.880
From an engineering perspective, is it safe to assume

02:11:18.880 --> 02:11:23.790
that vehicles given that issue, and there's

02:11:23.790 --> 02:11:25.830
already been some testimony that there

02:11:25.830 --> 02:11:28.110
is a lot of traffic, or at least in the written documentation,

02:11:28.110 --> 02:11:31.100
There's a lot of traffic on Kimberly Road there.

02:11:31.100 --> 02:11:35.700
That they may opt to turn right and go down south or north

02:11:35.700 --> 02:11:38.540
on Meadowview Lane, turn right on Fourth Avenue,

02:11:38.540 --> 02:11:40.980
come down Hankins Road to get to a stoplight.

02:11:40.980 --> 02:11:45.980
I mean, in your analysis of traffic behaviors,

02:11:46.700 --> 02:11:50.510
would that be a possibility?

02:11:50.510 --> 02:11:52.070
Should we put that up on the board?

02:11:52.070 --> 02:11:54.000
Go ahead, understand what you're saying.

02:11:54.000 --> 02:11:55.560
I'm starting to find an answer.

02:11:55.560 --> 02:11:59.930
We have not studied people's habits except that we know

02:11:59.930 --> 02:12:04.930
they're generally lazy and singly focused on the direction that they're going to.

02:12:04.930 --> 02:12:11.930
There's a relationship between delay and how far around you have to go to get there.

02:12:11.930 --> 02:12:14.930
So that is a long way around.

02:12:14.930 --> 02:12:19.930
From four down medals used to fourth and around at Hankins because Marie has a long way around.

02:12:19.930 --> 02:12:23.930
And I don't know what the gaps are like on the highway.

02:12:23.930 --> 02:12:27.930
I know that there's a traffic light down the way about a quarter of a mile.

02:12:27.930 --> 02:12:36.600
on Hankins road right okay that's all my questions for now thank you great

02:12:36.600 --> 02:12:39.600
planning

02:12:42.600 --> 02:12:48.100
is the way white up there that we could make it turn lane a left-end turn lane

02:12:48.100 --> 02:12:53.440
as we currently see this bill with a if we've got rid of the parking let's say

02:12:53.440 --> 02:13:00.640
or something. I don't remember that answer for sure. I'm sorry. I didn't look at geometry

02:13:00.640 --> 02:13:05.440
before I came here. Sometimes if we have the room, if we don't allow parking for a certain

02:13:05.440 --> 02:13:10.080
number of feet, then that allows us to widen it. The theory is that it was built as a collector

02:13:10.080 --> 02:13:15.080
and was four lanes wide. But like I said, that's the theory. I actually don't know the

02:13:15.080 --> 02:13:19.160
answer. I don't know the answer. I don't know if you land as a collector. It's a quarter

02:13:19.160 --> 02:13:21.640
mile room or so.

02:13:21.640 --> 02:13:24.280
How you doing?

02:13:24.280 --> 02:13:26.280
Suzanne Hawkins.

02:13:26.280 --> 02:13:28.280
Jackie, this is for you also.

02:13:28.280 --> 02:13:29.830
I'm sorry.

02:13:29.830 --> 02:13:32.830
Further to the east, there's the chevron station.

02:13:32.830 --> 02:13:41.830
It's not on our maps, but there are no stoplights at that one for vehicles turning in and off of Kimberly

02:13:41.830 --> 02:13:42.830
Road.

02:13:42.830 --> 02:13:43.830
Is that correct?

02:13:43.830 --> 02:13:44.830
Or is there a stoplight down there?

02:13:44.830 --> 02:13:45.830
I don't remember.

02:13:45.830 --> 02:13:52.830
Have we had any traffic complaints or problems with vehicles getting in or out of that gas station that you know?

02:13:52.830 --> 02:13:56.190
Well, we haven't had complaints that I know of.

02:13:56.190 --> 02:13:59.910
Okay.

02:13:59.910 --> 02:14:03.740
That's also 45 out there, correct?

02:14:03.740 --> 02:14:10.800
Are there, do you know in that plan, in this plan, are there major differences in the entrances and exits?

02:14:10.800 --> 02:14:14.840
As far as turn lanes coming in off of Kimberly Road or...

02:14:14.840 --> 02:14:23.040
The Chevron or down east of Hanketts has access only from the state highway.

02:14:24.310 --> 02:14:28.970
So they have to, the entirety of their ingressing ingress is from the state highway.

02:14:29.530 --> 02:14:33.250
So this particular site has ingressing ingress for a metaview.

02:14:33.470 --> 02:14:39.050
So at some level, metaview provides like refuge.

02:14:39.450 --> 02:14:43.110
Is it possible to change the plan so they cannot go out on metaview,

02:14:43.110 --> 02:14:45.750
but they have in and out on Kimberly Road only,

02:14:45.750 --> 02:14:48.430
like the Chevron, so that the traffic

02:14:48.430 --> 02:15:10.300
is not being forced on to Meadowview?

02:15:10.300 --> 02:15:17.300
OK, so my dilemma is that I still wear an ITT hat now

02:15:17.300 --> 02:15:20.800
and then, so how do I answer the question

02:15:20.800 --> 02:15:24.440
and provide you information?

02:15:24.440 --> 02:15:28.520
So ITT has not yet issued their permit,

02:15:28.520 --> 02:15:32.840
and they are interested in keeping the state highway

02:15:32.840 --> 02:15:35.120
with a minimum number of approaches.

02:15:35.120 --> 02:15:46.970
So we could, at least for the time being, say that there could be no aggresss and aggresss

02:15:46.970 --> 02:15:51.970
on Metaview, but that could be very challenging for the permitting process.

02:15:51.970 --> 02:15:54.970
And I'm not involved in that permitting process, so.

02:15:54.970 --> 02:16:02.340
But that would help resolve the issue with people going back through the neighborhood to get back

02:16:02.340 --> 02:16:06.340
to Hankins Roadstop, like to get out, if there was no.

02:16:06.340 --> 02:16:12.780
If they actually do that, I would think that if anybody turns right, they either live in

02:16:12.780 --> 02:16:16.960
that neighborhood or they're going to shoot down Elizabeth to go somewhere else along the

02:16:16.960 --> 02:16:17.960
way.

02:16:17.960 --> 02:16:21.720
I sincerely doubt that anybody's going to come back to Hankins to go out to Kimberly.

02:16:21.720 --> 02:16:22.720
Okay.

02:16:22.720 --> 02:16:26.940
That's a long, you know, like I said, I'm not any different than anybody else, I'm pretty

02:16:26.940 --> 02:16:34.160
lazy and I tend to take the direct pass rather than going around in a big old circle.

02:16:34.160 --> 02:16:35.160
Thank you.

02:16:35.160 --> 02:16:40.160
I prefer to not to say it's lazy, we're being efficient with our time.

02:16:40.160 --> 02:16:46.160
And maybe you know respectful of our natural resources, non-renewable natural resources,

02:16:46.160 --> 02:16:47.160
we could go on and on.

02:16:47.160 --> 02:16:48.160
Excellent.

02:16:48.160 --> 02:16:50.160
But you're going to go with lazy.

02:16:50.160 --> 02:16:53.160
I will refrain from using that word for the drink.

02:16:53.160 --> 02:16:58.160
I have a question for you regarding the MetaView intersection.

02:16:58.160 --> 02:17:02.160
Mr. Asher mentioned potentially putting a traffic light there.

02:17:02.160 --> 02:17:07.120
light there. What are the chances of putting a traffic light at that location?

02:17:07.120 --> 02:17:15.800
Okay, so all signals regardless of where they are are supposed to make a warrant. Okay, so

02:17:15.800 --> 02:17:21.640
on the state highway, ITD will require that a warrant be met. So that's a traffic impact

02:17:21.640 --> 02:17:31.600
study. And there needs to be some form of delay or death or some other extraordinary and extremely

02:17:31.600 --> 02:17:38.600
limited school zone problems or something to be able to get a signal in and at this point

02:17:38.600 --> 02:17:47.820
in time the volumes on meadow view the delay on meadow view in my opinion go on to signal

02:17:47.820 --> 02:17:53.020
that's why we didn't have the conversation in the first place.

02:17:53.020 --> 02:17:58.140
Could you put up if you could say could you put up the kind of site plan that Mr. Lynch

02:17:58.140 --> 02:18:08.420
brought to us let me ask you a question about this Jackie.

02:18:08.420 --> 02:18:12.480
We were having a brief discussion on how the Chilani signal was warranted and it was

02:18:12.480 --> 02:18:16.620
a very complex effort even with 500 people working there.

02:18:16.620 --> 02:18:21.220
That was really my point that the chances of getting the signal there, especially when

02:18:21.220 --> 02:18:25.350
it's just a T-intersection, are fairly minimal.

02:18:25.350 --> 02:18:27.710
The North College has some fabulous volume.

02:18:27.710 --> 02:18:31.840
The North College can fill more signal and the worst thing about it is that the delay

02:18:31.840 --> 02:18:32.840
is everywhere.

02:18:32.840 --> 02:18:36.080
So you couldn't just flip the soft signs or fix it.

02:18:36.080 --> 02:18:39.340
It has some commendable volume over there.

02:18:39.340 --> 02:18:42.340
So the question I have for you regarding the layout,

02:18:43.840 --> 02:18:45.840
the entrance coming in off of Kimberly Road

02:18:45.840 --> 02:18:50.840
and potentially going out of Meadowview as illustrated.

02:18:51.040 --> 02:18:54.440
There's nothing that will stop unless I see,

02:18:54.440 --> 02:18:57.840
unless it's an only entrance off of Kimberly Road,

02:18:57.840 --> 02:19:00.440
is it an entrance only off of Kimberly Road?

02:19:00.440 --> 02:19:03.800
So can someone come out of that parking lot

02:19:03.800 --> 02:19:07.800
or that convenience store out that,

02:19:07.800 --> 02:19:09.280
where you show them coming in?

02:19:09.280 --> 02:19:14.250
Maybe that's a question to you, Mr. Lynch.

02:19:14.250 --> 02:19:15.890
We hope to use both.

02:19:15.890 --> 02:19:16.730
OK.

02:19:16.730 --> 02:19:18.370
So it's not a one-way only.

02:19:18.370 --> 02:19:21.090
It's not a one-way, not designed to be a one-way.

02:19:21.090 --> 02:19:24.010
There is a turn lane in front of that property.

02:19:24.010 --> 02:19:24.510
OK.

02:19:24.490 --> 02:19:26.570
And so whether or not the state of Idaho

02:19:26.570 --> 02:19:31.780
would allow a to move the driveway way from the intersection

02:19:31.780 --> 02:19:34.300
into a turn lane, I don't know.

02:19:34.300 --> 02:19:35.580
I can't speak for them.

02:19:35.580 --> 02:19:36.100
Right.

02:19:36.100 --> 02:19:38.980
I'm just making mention the entrance where we show kind

02:19:38.980 --> 02:19:41.340
of the sweeping going out onto a matter of view.

02:19:41.340 --> 02:19:44.580
That's in and out. People can go out that way as well.

02:19:44.580 --> 02:19:50.130
Both ways. Right.

02:19:50.130 --> 02:19:53.650
Okay. That's that was kind of my point. Thank you.

02:19:53.650 --> 02:19:55.970
Rebecca Mills-Sueckett. Thank you, Mayor.

02:19:55.970 --> 02:20:00.410
Jackie, could you talk more about the ITD approval process?

02:20:00.410 --> 02:20:05.850
There was in the minutes of the Planning and Zoning Commission meeting

02:20:05.850 --> 02:20:08.050
page 12 and 13.

02:20:08.050 --> 02:20:15.510
They had quite a discussion about how ITD's approval of ingress and egress off of

02:20:15.510 --> 02:20:20.950
that Kimberly Road would affect the impacts to the neighborhood and whether they could

02:20:20.950 --> 02:20:27.630
assess the actual impacts without having that decision from ITD and then there was a discussion

02:20:27.630 --> 02:20:37.990
about whether if ITD denies that ingress and egress off of Kimberly Road how that would

02:20:37.990 --> 02:20:45.790
impact the configuration of the traffic and whether that would cause the permit, the

02:20:45.790 --> 02:20:49.030
special use permit to fail because it was a condition.

02:20:49.030 --> 02:20:55.370
So I was just wondering if you could clarify for us because I'm not sure that I got a really

02:20:55.370 --> 02:21:00.270
good sense of what the answer was from the minutes.

02:21:00.270 --> 02:21:08.470
If this special use permit is upheld and later I-TD does not provide an access off of Kimberly

02:21:08.470 --> 02:21:16.110
road with that, and this may be a question for planning and zoning, number one, would

02:21:16.110 --> 02:21:21.310
that cause this special use permit to be no longer valid?

02:21:21.310 --> 02:21:32.520
And then two, could you talk to us about that I-T-D process and will we be able to evaluate

02:21:32.520 --> 02:21:39.520
the impacts of the traffic on the neighborhood without having I.G.D.s. conclusion or decision.

02:21:40.720 --> 02:21:47.920
Okay, so let's try to tackle this a little piece at a time.

02:21:47.920 --> 02:21:52.920
Yeah, sorry, that wasn't. It's all right. It was a very complex discussion that they were having.

02:21:52.920 --> 02:21:56.920
There are several different things going on there. So I.T.D. has a permitting process

02:21:56.920 --> 02:22:04.600
for getting that driveway that's on Highway 30, Kimberly Road. And they may or may not

02:22:04.600 --> 02:22:07.140
or may not issue that permit.

02:22:07.140 --> 02:22:10.100
If they choose not to issue the permit

02:22:10.100 --> 02:22:15.100
or they require that the permit is a shared approach

02:22:15.820 --> 02:22:18.120
and Mr. Lynch can't successfully negotiate

02:22:18.120 --> 02:22:24.670
with the neighbor or something else

02:22:24.670 --> 02:22:26.390
that I can't think of right now comes up

02:22:26.390 --> 02:22:28.350
and that permit doesn't actually happen,

02:22:28.350 --> 02:22:32.870
then circulation in and out of the gas station

02:22:32.870 --> 02:22:36.290
will change a little bit.

02:22:36.290 --> 02:22:43.890
So to the tune of 50 cars an hour or less in the shown by 50 to 60 cars an hour or less

02:22:43.890 --> 02:22:48.580
is shown in the document provided by Mr. Legend.

02:22:48.580 --> 02:22:57.940
So to that piece of the permitting question, it's hard for us to estimate what exactly is

02:22:57.940 --> 02:23:02.700
going to happen on Metaview without knowing where the drive was on.

02:23:02.700 --> 02:23:14.270
Then the next piece of the question had to do with whether or not the special use permit

02:23:14.270 --> 02:23:24.160
stands if you can't get an I-T-D permit.

02:23:24.160 --> 02:23:26.360
I don't actually have the answer to that.

02:23:26.360 --> 02:23:36.860
That falls into the planners area.

02:23:36.860 --> 02:23:42.060
Renee's pointing to item number four, basically saying that if I-T-D allows Kimberly Road access

02:23:42.060 --> 02:23:45.500
the applicant shall provide a right turn lane, turn deceleration lane, and number three which

02:23:45.500 --> 02:23:49.100
which is subject to access location on adjacent roadways

02:23:49.100 --> 02:23:50.340
being approved by city staff

02:23:50.340 --> 02:23:53.710
in the Idaho Transportation Department.

02:23:53.710 --> 02:23:56.150
It was the intent and you can read the minutes

02:23:56.150 --> 02:23:59.690
as far as what they determined as far as changing conditions

02:23:59.690 --> 02:24:04.500
or having conditions approved for what they desired.

02:24:04.500 --> 02:24:06.620
Because according to condition three

02:24:06.620 --> 02:24:10.620
is just that the access roadways be approved.

02:24:10.620 --> 02:24:14.340
So would that matter if it's only going to be off

02:24:14.340 --> 02:24:17.230
of Medeville Lane or?

02:24:17.230 --> 02:24:21.470
Well, if there's an and in there, so it's by city staff and ITD.

02:24:21.470 --> 02:24:23.990
ITD doesn't have any jurisdiction on Mediview Road,

02:24:23.990 --> 02:24:26.350
and they won't approve or disapprove a driveway on there.

02:24:26.350 --> 02:24:26.850
Right.

02:24:26.790 --> 02:24:32.970
So the understanding that I have from reading that

02:24:32.970 --> 02:24:37.250
is that their ITD approach needs to be approved in some form.

02:24:37.250 --> 02:24:41.750
As a condition of the permit, is it?

02:24:41.750 --> 02:24:42.750
So we're all together on that.

02:24:42.750 --> 02:24:44.550
And then the third piece of your question,

02:24:44.550 --> 02:24:46.870
I could not retain Rebecca, I'm sorry.

02:24:46.870 --> 02:24:52.830
I think that that was the two major questions is whether the special use permit stands if you don't get that

02:24:53.750 --> 02:24:57.750
Permit, I don't know if you would have the answer to this question, but do you know?

02:24:58.750 --> 02:25:03.510
When that permit might be approved or when we might have that information

02:25:05.830 --> 02:25:10.200
Okay, thank you

02:25:20.200 --> 02:25:26.600
in the 77 feet and have you had any discussions with obviously you're

02:25:26.600 --> 02:25:32.160
purchasing this property from the other the other knee which owns full length of

02:25:32.160 --> 02:25:36.800
that whether the shared access is something that they think was a possibility or

02:25:36.800 --> 02:25:43.000
we are discussing that as a shared he is it's my understanding through a third

02:25:43.000 --> 02:25:47.560
party okay so I have not spoke directly that eventually the corner prop would

02:25:47.560 --> 02:25:52.960
be sold and that will be divided into two or three parcels and the only way to be able

02:25:52.960 --> 02:25:59.640
to reach the inside parcel would be through a community entrance.

02:25:59.640 --> 02:26:08.520
And then on your question, we filed for the permit like eight weeks ago and they just

02:26:08.520 --> 02:26:11.840
cast the check two days ago.

02:26:11.840 --> 02:26:14.040
So we haven't heard anything from them.

02:26:14.040 --> 02:26:17.440
I just called today about the check just to make sure because I thought it could be lost

02:26:17.440 --> 02:26:18.880
the mail and they just cash.

02:26:18.880 --> 02:26:20.440
Thank you.

02:26:20.440 --> 02:26:26.060
Council having further questions before I open up the public testimony portion of tonight's

02:26:26.060 --> 02:26:29.320
hearing.

02:26:29.320 --> 02:26:35.160
At this time I'm opening the public testimony portion of the hearing and I will be calling

02:26:35.160 --> 02:26:36.160
your name.

02:26:36.160 --> 02:26:38.800
Remember we're going to keep it at about two minutes.

02:26:38.800 --> 02:26:43.840
Mr. Yates, you were the previous issue, right?

02:26:43.840 --> 02:26:51.330
I think the first one and I believe she might have left is Mrs. Righetti.

02:26:51.330 --> 02:26:57.620
This road was a little hard to read, so I believe she'd love.

02:26:57.620 --> 02:27:00.540
Bobby Latham is next.

02:27:00.540 --> 02:27:05.300
If you'd come up, introduce yourself, your address, we have about two minutes, sir.

02:27:05.300 --> 02:27:06.500
Thanks for the time.

02:27:06.500 --> 02:27:07.900
[Muted for privacy: home address]

02:27:07.900 --> 02:27:13.300
[Muted for privacy: home address]

02:27:13.300 --> 02:27:22.340
[Muted for privacy: home address]

02:27:22.340 --> 02:27:26.240
[Muted for privacy: home address]

02:27:26.240 --> 02:27:31.860
I would enjoy the convenience of the convenience store being there.

02:27:31.860 --> 02:27:40.340
As far as the concerns about noise from the pellet, I guess, it's hard for me to believe

02:27:40.340 --> 02:27:44.620
that a car sitting in the driveway waiting for a coffee would be any more noisy than a

02:27:44.620 --> 02:27:48.780
semi-18 wheeler going by there at 45 miles an hour.

02:27:48.780 --> 02:27:54.580
Or even the train that I hear at two o'clock in the morning a mile away.

02:27:54.580 --> 02:28:02.420
So, like I said, my bedroom window will face the gas station if they do their part as far

02:28:02.420 --> 02:28:06.780
as lighting in which I've been to other Mr. gas stations in Burleigh and in Twin Falls

02:28:06.780 --> 02:28:12.540
and they do a very good job of the way they build things, keeping other people in mind

02:28:12.540 --> 02:28:13.540
that sort of stuff.

02:28:13.540 --> 02:28:19.020
The very clean facility, so I would definitely approve and support the project.

02:28:20.020 --> 02:28:22.600
Thank you. Thank you, sir.

02:28:22.600 --> 02:28:25.600
Next person I have on the list is Alex Tubbs.

02:28:25.600 --> 02:28:32.910
Welcome, Mr. Tubbs.

02:28:32.910 --> 02:28:36.950
[Muted for privacy: home address]

02:28:36.950 --> 02:28:39.950
[Muted for privacy: home address]

02:28:39.950 --> 02:28:46.950
[Muted for privacy: home address]

02:28:46.950 --> 02:28:53.750
[Muted for privacy: home address]

02:28:53.750 --> 02:28:59.790
And then I'm the last house there before you get to the empty fields where the water tank is.

02:28:59.790 --> 02:29:03.860
And that's where I'm at right there.

02:29:03.860 --> 02:29:14.360
And I have some concerns about the proposed service station, a couple of things really quickly.

02:29:14.360 --> 02:29:22.080
The apartment complex is a 67-unit apartment complex with two and three bedroom apartments.

02:29:22.080 --> 02:29:29.520
There are lots and lots of children in there, so I would estimate that I know quite a few

02:29:29.520 --> 02:29:30.520
people there.

02:29:30.520 --> 02:29:38.640
Of course, there are some single individuals there, but by and large, everybody has children,

02:29:38.640 --> 02:29:43.160
and I would guess there are probably 100 or more kids that live in those apartments.

02:29:43.160 --> 02:29:50.160
And even with the buffer zone, I have those kids in my yard in the empty field next to me,

02:29:50.160 --> 02:29:55.160
having a convenient store with the lights and the sodas and all of that.

02:29:55.160 --> 02:29:58.160
I can see kids running around the corner.

02:29:58.160 --> 02:30:01.160
And I'm concerned about that.

02:30:01.160 --> 02:30:02.160
The street is wider.

02:30:02.160 --> 02:30:10.160
There are men of U lane where we're at the corner, and so I can see people coming in and out of there a lot.

02:30:10.160 --> 02:30:14.040
And kids don't really watch.

02:30:14.040 --> 02:30:18.800
A couple other things is the stoplight issue.

02:30:18.800 --> 02:30:22.480
There was a stoplight put there at Hankins and Kimberly

02:30:22.480 --> 02:30:22.980
Road.

02:30:22.800 --> 02:30:24.720
That was because of accidents.

02:30:24.720 --> 02:30:28.400
Those were people that were turning left to go east on

02:30:28.400 --> 02:30:29.040
Kimberly Road.

02:30:29.040 --> 02:30:30.320
That's why they put that there.

02:30:30.320 --> 02:30:33.200
From my point of view, I can see where that stoplight is, and

02:30:33.200 --> 02:30:37.320
I watched many accidents there before they put that light in.

02:30:37.320 --> 02:30:42.020
people turning left off the metal view lane will have a problem, especially

02:30:42.020 --> 02:30:45.420
certain times of the year when the sun is setting or rising.

02:30:46.620 --> 02:30:50.220
And I think it'll be a problem by myself.

02:30:50.220 --> 02:30:55.320
If I'm turning to go east, I do go down to Fort Avenue and back up and

02:30:55.320 --> 02:30:57.420
around through Hankins so I can use the stoplight.

02:30:58.020 --> 02:31:01.320
And I think people will do that, especially if they have if they

02:31:01.320 --> 02:31:04.820
know the area and they have a big trailer, they're not going to try

02:31:04.820 --> 02:31:06.620
and cross two lanes and then turn.

02:31:07.320 --> 02:31:09.840
I don't think you'll see people doing that.

02:31:09.840 --> 02:31:14.040
I think you'll see people going through the neighborhood and then going up.

02:31:14.040 --> 02:31:15.520
I know they will.

02:31:15.520 --> 02:31:19.840
And a lot of people in the neighborhood do that because of that very reason.

02:31:19.840 --> 02:31:24.440
It's hard to turn east off of the middle of the building.

02:31:24.440 --> 02:31:28.240
So there are other things like the speakers.

02:31:28.240 --> 02:31:30.120
Some of the gas stations have speakers.

02:31:30.120 --> 02:31:31.680
They have music playing all the time.

02:31:31.680 --> 02:31:33.280
I don't know if you will or not.

02:31:33.280 --> 02:31:40.600
I'm not so concerned about the trucks, because I hear the trucks all the time, and I do hear the train as well.

02:31:40.600 --> 02:31:46.600
But I am concerned about the extra traffic. I'm concerned about the kids.

02:31:46.600 --> 02:31:55.600
I'm concerned about, and then maybe this is a little on edge, but I'm concerned about the number of people coming through there with a lot of little kids around

02:31:55.600 --> 02:32:02.330
being able to snap one of those kids and run off pretty quickly, because you can escape very quickly.

02:32:02.330 --> 02:32:05.810
it's a concern. What else?

02:32:05.810 --> 02:32:10.530
Sir, you're about two minutes past your time, so wrap her up and see what it is.

02:32:10.530 --> 02:32:12.730
I'm so excited. Yeah, I can hardly stand.

02:32:12.730 --> 02:32:19.170
Now, a few years ago, the City Council did approve that apartment complex,

02:32:19.170 --> 02:32:23.250
and I think it's really covered on the City Council to protect

02:32:23.250 --> 02:32:25.850
the decision that they made several years ago now.

02:32:25.850 --> 02:32:31.570
And I don't think having a Mr. Gas next to that apartment complex

02:32:31.570 --> 02:32:36.530
and next to the community there is a good choice.

02:32:36.530 --> 02:32:38.530
Thank you, Mr. Tubbs.

02:32:38.530 --> 02:32:42.290
I don't have any other names, but I saw somebody run up there

02:32:42.290 --> 02:32:44.410
and want to sign their name up, I believe.

02:32:44.410 --> 02:32:48.010
So come on forward, sir, and introduce yourself,

02:32:48.010 --> 02:32:51.500
and give me your, well, I know Ron does,

02:32:51.500 --> 02:32:53.700
but this gentleman here, you bet.

02:32:53.700 --> 02:32:55.900
[Muted for privacy: home address]

02:32:55.900 --> 02:32:58.220
[Muted for privacy: home address]

02:32:58.220 --> 02:33:01.820
[Muted for privacy: home address]

02:33:01.820 --> 02:33:05.820
[Muted for privacy: home address]

02:33:05.820 --> 02:33:08.480
we all know what gas stations are

02:33:08.480 --> 02:33:10.910
what they will bring to the community.

02:33:10.910 --> 02:33:12.510
A lot of stupid people

02:33:12.510 --> 02:33:15.430
going forty five miles down that road. We already have that.

02:33:15.430 --> 02:33:18.030
We already have enough people going forty five down that curve

02:33:18.030 --> 02:33:20.270
where it's barely wide enough to put one car.

02:33:20.270 --> 02:33:23.590
You're giving us a tell me that it's going to be good enough for

02:33:23.590 --> 02:33:25.030
an RV trailer.

02:33:25.030 --> 02:33:26.390
I mean you know

02:33:26.390 --> 02:33:29.830
and trucks burn their stuff all night. It happens.

02:33:29.830 --> 02:33:32.690
Mr. and I've said no, they've been in prison for four dollars.

02:33:32.690 --> 02:33:33.770
It doesn't matter.

02:33:33.770 --> 02:33:35.690
They don't pay for the gas to come to us.

02:33:35.690 --> 02:33:37.050
The company has money.

02:33:37.050 --> 02:33:39.050
Money is what talks.

02:33:39.050 --> 02:33:43.890
So the people with money can buy stuff and build stuff.

02:33:43.890 --> 02:33:48.650
Without regard to the little guy, we work to live.

02:33:48.650 --> 02:33:50.010
We don't work for a profit.

02:33:50.010 --> 02:33:52.030
We work to live.

02:33:52.030 --> 02:33:59.440
I moved into this neighborhood in 2009.

02:33:59.440 --> 02:34:00.880
And it's a residential neighborhood.

02:34:00.880 --> 02:34:03.880
It's been a great neighborhood and Mr.

02:34:03.880 --> 02:34:08.610
Whoever's up here last, he said there's lots of kids.

02:34:08.610 --> 02:34:11.850
There are hundreds of kids, everywhere.

02:34:11.850 --> 02:34:18.250
I'm disabled so I stay home and I admit I've become a window warrior.

02:34:18.250 --> 02:34:21.130
I like to sit up there and watch.

02:34:21.130 --> 02:34:27.010
Just how many cars will be for lack of a better word hauling ass by.

02:34:27.010 --> 02:34:30.770
And it's really sad, it's really frustrating.

02:34:30.770 --> 02:34:35.770
And to bring another, a whole other aspect of traffic in,

02:34:35.970 --> 02:34:41.290
people already used that road to go from Elizabeth to Kimberly.

02:34:41.930 --> 02:34:42.770
There you do that.

02:34:42.770 --> 02:34:44.970
Those have got to travel fastest.

02:34:44.970 --> 02:34:49.800
And this, you know, and the delighting situation, come on.

02:34:49.800 --> 02:34:52.330
You know, I've got three kids.

02:34:52.330 --> 02:34:55.210
Our window, their window's having me on the side of the house.

02:34:55.210 --> 02:34:56.970
And he said, well, we're gonna put some trees in.

02:34:56.970 --> 02:35:00.540
Well, there better be some pretty tall frequent trees.

02:35:00.540 --> 02:35:03.480
and pretty thick to block out the light.

02:35:03.480 --> 02:35:05.980
I'm from Burleigh, I know, I worked,

02:35:05.980 --> 02:35:08.500
I worked for Mr. Lynch for a while.

02:35:08.500 --> 02:35:13.420
And not a long time ago, but, you know,

02:35:13.420 --> 02:35:15.980
I know the gas stations, Mr. Gas, gas station

02:35:15.980 --> 02:35:19.260
in Rupert and Burleigh, and you know, they're bright.

02:35:19.260 --> 02:35:24.880
You can see those from a long, long ways ago.

02:35:24.880 --> 02:35:28.550
You know, it's completely and totally opposed to this idea.

02:35:28.550 --> 02:35:32.350
So residential neighborhood, it's not a neighborhood for you.

02:35:32.350 --> 02:35:38.150
I know what nobody else lives there, well, some of the little guys live there, but, you know,

02:35:38.150 --> 02:35:43.830
what if you put a gas station in the middle of your residential, next to your house, you know,

02:35:43.830 --> 02:35:50.340
how would that make you feel? Put yourself in our shoes.

02:35:50.340 --> 02:35:51.700
Thank you, Ms. Wiggins.

02:35:51.700 --> 02:35:53.410
Thank you.

02:35:53.410 --> 02:36:00.250
Mr. Yates, looks like you wanted to come forward. Ron Yates?

02:36:00.250 --> 02:36:07.680
Yes, I'd like to comment, historically, this question might be a little moot about whether

02:36:07.680 --> 02:36:12.640
of the zone this were allowed as if it was zoned in 1970 for commercial purposes.

02:36:12.640 --> 02:36:19.160
So in my opinion, it was zoned many, many years ago, and it's a done deal.

02:36:19.160 --> 02:36:27.240
The other thing is back with this comprehensive plan idea, at this time it was a big idea for

02:36:27.240 --> 02:36:35.840
future developers to encourage, to encourage future developers to include uses like this

02:36:35.840 --> 02:36:39.080
within their subdivisions, so there was a done deal. It was already there. When you

02:36:39.080 --> 02:36:41.980
bought a property and built a home, you know that there was going to be an

02:36:41.980 --> 02:36:45.340
Albertson's within a block. You knew that it was going to be a Mr. Gas

02:36:45.340 --> 02:36:50.080
within a block. So going back to that document, that was an encouraging thing to

02:36:50.080 --> 02:36:54.880
hear for developers to be encouraged to include those within residential areas so

02:36:54.880 --> 02:36:57.800
that they would serve. Because frankly, we're running out of Blue-Ex

02:36:57.800 --> 02:37:05.300
property to construct more gas stations on. When I fill my gas tank,

02:37:05.300 --> 02:37:12.300
It's always difficult because there's so many people there.

02:37:12.300 --> 02:37:17.060
The more we spread this demand out across the city of Twin Falls, the less it's going

02:37:17.060 --> 02:37:20.700
to be dangerous for many of the people in other places.

02:37:20.700 --> 02:37:25.300
There was a huge disturbance when someone wanted to build a gas station on northwest corner

02:37:25.300 --> 02:37:34.300
of Locust and Falls many years ago, and now there's a different development in there.

02:37:34.300 --> 02:37:38.020
We cannot have all of them on Blue Lakes.

02:37:38.020 --> 02:37:39.340
We can't have them all on Addison.

02:37:39.340 --> 02:37:41.720
I support the deal.

02:37:41.720 --> 02:37:48.360
Listening to it here, it's going to be good to distribute

02:37:48.360 --> 02:37:51.360
the business around the country and get the model off

02:37:51.360 --> 02:37:55.720
of Blue Lakes and other places, I can spend I support it.

02:37:55.720 --> 02:37:57.440
Thank you, Mr. Yates.

02:37:57.440 --> 02:37:59.800
Is there anyone else from the public that would like

02:37:59.800 --> 02:38:01.040
to address us?

02:38:01.040 --> 02:38:03.040
Come forward, sir, and if you'd state your name

02:38:03.040 --> 02:38:09.540
and your address.

02:38:09.540 --> 02:38:10.540
Thank you.

02:38:10.540 --> 02:38:11.660
[Muted for privacy: home address]

02:38:11.660 --> 02:38:19.260
[Muted for privacy: home address]

02:38:19.260 --> 02:38:22.850
[Muted for privacy: home address]

02:38:22.850 --> 02:38:24.970
[Muted for privacy: home address]

02:38:24.970 --> 02:38:25.970
Deon?

02:38:25.970 --> 02:38:33.690
Deon.

02:38:33.690 --> 02:38:34.690
Deon.

02:38:34.690 --> 02:38:35.690
A-U-N.

02:38:35.690 --> 02:38:38.330
I'm not sure if that's how you've been.

02:38:38.330 --> 02:38:40.050
That's not part of your time, sir.

02:38:40.050 --> 02:38:47.680
So, anyway, basically my concern is just that road is a pretty busy road as it is.

02:38:47.680 --> 02:38:54.680
people are flying up and down Metal View and Elizabeth, from Elizabeth, Kimberly Road

02:38:54.680 --> 02:38:57.680
and it's become a pretty busy road.

02:38:57.680 --> 02:39:07.130
And I'm just concerned that we had a gas station in there and people are going to go ahead and use that as that connector to get to Elizabeth and cook out.

02:39:07.130 --> 02:39:11.550
I don't think they're going to come across and down and get it to fourth.

02:39:11.550 --> 02:39:14.550
People don't really do that so much.

02:39:14.550 --> 02:39:19.490
And then the other concern that I have is on the opposite side of Meadowview, it's an empty

02:39:19.490 --> 02:39:20.490
lot right now.

02:39:20.490 --> 02:39:24.690
So, what are we going to do there, you know, we're going to put an apartment later on.

02:39:24.690 --> 02:39:30.550
I don't know, you know, who knows what future use is, but just wondering about conflicts

02:39:30.550 --> 02:39:31.550
later on.

02:39:31.550 --> 02:39:32.550
Thank you.

02:39:32.550 --> 02:39:33.550
Thank you.

02:39:33.550 --> 02:39:37.870
Is there anyone else from the public that would like to address the council this evening?

02:39:37.870 --> 02:39:39.570
All right.

02:39:39.570 --> 02:39:45.330
I think it's appropriate to have both the Appellant and the applicant have their five-minute retort

02:39:45.330 --> 02:39:47.330
be well so we'll start with the

02:39:47.330 --> 02:39:51.680
about Mr. Asher welcome again, sir.

02:39:51.680 --> 02:40:00.320
I know there's going to increase the traffic on fourth and on

02:40:00.320 --> 02:40:04.320
Metal View. We got this thing called GPS.

02:40:04.320 --> 02:40:08.800
People are going to find their way around shorter distance or a

02:40:08.800 --> 02:40:13.080
faster distance if they have the necessity to do that.

02:40:13.080 --> 02:40:16.080
I know it's going to increase the traffic on that road and I really

02:40:16.080 --> 02:40:20.690
think that's the bad place for that road to be in to be on.

02:40:20.690 --> 02:40:24.670
Excuse me. That's about all I got to say.

02:40:24.670 --> 02:40:30.850
Thank you, sir. I'll give the same courtesy to the applicant, Mr. Lynch.

02:40:30.850 --> 02:40:39.170
Thank you. In closing, I'd just like to say that, you know, our goal here is to wait on people

02:40:39.170 --> 02:40:44.370
who normally will come down Kimberley Road, need a tank of gas. They're passing through,

02:40:44.370 --> 02:40:49.290
they'll get back out onto Kimberley Road and go, there are some locals. I had never been

02:40:49.290 --> 02:40:54.030
on that road. I'll just be honest with you until we looked at the property. And I

02:40:54.030 --> 02:40:58.050
found it way too slow for me to drive down that road. I was driving the speed

02:40:58.050 --> 02:41:01.990
limit of that neighborhood to go down there and go. I just don't see it as being

02:41:01.990 --> 02:41:05.970
a faster. We're looking at it as a place that people are going to be able to pull

02:41:05.970 --> 02:41:11.570
in normally during daytime hours when children may be in school. And I want to

02:41:11.570 --> 02:41:16.850
be honest though we view that children will come on to our property but we're

02:41:16.850 --> 02:41:20.590
We're going to do everything that we can to make sure they're safe.

02:41:20.590 --> 02:41:22.890
We think of the apartment complex.

02:41:22.890 --> 02:41:25.490
We have several gas stations buying them.

02:41:25.490 --> 02:41:30.690
Moms will run low on a quarter milk, and they'll send the child over to get a quarter milk or

02:41:30.690 --> 02:41:31.690
some cereal.

02:41:31.690 --> 02:41:34.530
And so we're just going to do everything we can.

02:41:34.530 --> 02:41:36.890
We do not want to add additional traffic.

02:41:36.890 --> 02:41:43.730
We're more than willing out our driveway when it's up there that we will put, you know, left

02:41:43.730 --> 02:41:44.730
turn only.

02:41:44.730 --> 02:41:49.050
I believe the road, you can definitely see the road as planned for a four-lane road.

02:41:49.050 --> 02:41:55.570
It is not today, but we could have a turn lane with the stoplight down the road at Hankins.

02:41:55.570 --> 02:41:56.570
There's always a stop.

02:41:56.570 --> 02:41:58.130
There's a gap.

02:41:58.130 --> 02:42:00.650
And then there is a turn lane for them to turn.

02:42:00.650 --> 02:42:05.770
But we believe most people are going to turn right and head into town to work and wherever

02:42:05.770 --> 02:42:09.450
they're going, if they're going on the way down through Nevada.

02:42:09.450 --> 02:42:16.530
We think it's a fair project and we're asking for your permission to have the right to be able to put it

02:42:17.170 --> 02:42:21.570
At that location and we appreciate your consideration. Thank you. Thank you, mr. Lynch

02:42:23.850 --> 02:42:32.400
We counsel you still have the opportunity to ask questions of the appellant the applicant or folks that have testified or staff

02:42:32.820 --> 02:42:39.840
Before I close the public testimony portion where we turn it over to deliberations before we have any other questions

02:42:39.840 --> 02:42:44.280
though, could you straighten us out one more time, Jonathan, about the three options that

02:42:44.280 --> 02:42:50.280
we have here? And I would remind us it's always best to make the motion and the affirmative

02:42:50.280 --> 02:42:54.720
so we can have an up and down vote regarding that. So if you can give us the three options,

02:42:54.720 --> 02:42:56.810
then sir.

02:42:56.810 --> 02:42:59.010
Let me get to it. And I put it right up here.

02:42:59.010 --> 02:43:07.010
It's per city code 1032.2 after you receive the appeal which we've done. From the action

02:43:07.010 --> 02:43:11.610
of the commission, the council shall set a hearing which we're doing to consider all information

02:43:11.610 --> 02:43:16.230
testimony and the commission's minutes to reach a decision to uphold conditionally

02:43:16.230 --> 02:43:21.030
uphold or overrule the decision of the commission. Motion shall be made in the

02:43:21.030 --> 02:43:26.470
affirmative and may be subject to specific conditions. That's perfect.

02:43:26.470 --> 02:43:30.290
Thank you. Now this time any questions for staff or anyone else from council?

02:43:30.290 --> 02:43:38.620
Well we're not at that point yet. Any questions before I close the

02:43:38.620 --> 02:43:44.270
public testimony portion. We are now posed as far as the public testimony and

02:43:44.270 --> 02:43:47.710
Any questions that we will have at this point on,

02:43:47.710 --> 02:43:49.030
even after the motion,

02:43:49.030 --> 02:43:53.110
will be directed to our city attorney.

02:43:53.110 --> 02:43:53.950
Greg Lanning.

02:43:54.790 --> 02:43:56.830
This one's supposed to make these in the affirmative.

02:43:56.830 --> 02:44:00.110
I said I move that we uphold the planning

02:44:00.110 --> 02:44:02.350
and zoning commissions ruling,

02:44:02.350 --> 02:44:07.500
including their conditions.

02:44:07.500 --> 02:44:08.340
Seconded.

02:44:08.340 --> 02:44:10.720
We have a motion on the floor by Greg Lanning,

02:44:10.720 --> 02:44:12.460
seconded by Chris Tawkington.

02:44:13.880 --> 02:44:15.920
Now I'll turn it over to council

02:44:15.920 --> 02:44:20.470
for any other discussion or thoughts.

02:44:20.470 --> 02:44:21.310
Chris, talking to you.

02:44:21.310 --> 02:44:24.550
Well, again, this is not a clean and easy decision.

02:44:24.550 --> 02:44:29.870
Both sides have some issues, I think, that logic backs up.

02:44:29.870 --> 02:44:40.270
But the fact that the applicant has willingly and,

02:44:40.270 --> 02:44:43.630
by his past experience, provided mitigation

02:44:43.630 --> 02:44:48.630
for the property occupied, the apartments occupying

02:44:48.910 --> 02:44:51.630
the North border.

02:44:51.630 --> 02:44:54.150
That's specifically including the birming,

02:44:54.150 --> 02:45:00.830
the tree, shielded lighting.

02:45:00.830 --> 02:45:06.270
And most of the traffic is going to be on,

02:45:06.270 --> 02:45:07.790
Han and Kimberly Road anyway.

02:45:07.790 --> 02:45:09.470
I don't think that there's gonna be

02:45:09.470 --> 02:45:11.030
a lot of additional traffic.

02:45:11.030 --> 02:45:16.030
I just, I'm weighing in favor of the applicant

02:45:16.510 --> 02:45:24.690
But the burden of proof is if it is approved for the applicant to show good will by following

02:45:24.690 --> 02:45:31.030
through and getting substantial trees, not three-foot twigs, but substantial trees, including

02:45:31.030 --> 02:45:34.030
some conifers that provide substantial shielding.

02:45:34.030 --> 02:45:36.580
Thank you, Mr. Stockton.

02:45:36.580 --> 02:45:38.020
Rebecca, may I second?

02:45:38.020 --> 02:45:39.020
Thank you, Mayor.

02:45:39.020 --> 02:45:42.660
Well, thank you to everyone who testified.

02:45:42.660 --> 02:45:52.660
I think the citizens actually have a really good point about the traffic impacts, and that is one of the criteria that we should weigh in considering special use permit.

02:45:52.660 --> 02:46:01.660
And as the Planning and Zoning Commissioners noted, there's actually three items in this application that qualify for special use permit.

02:46:01.660 --> 02:46:09.660
You use permit, it's the 24-hour operation, and it's the drive-through, and it's the service station.

02:46:09.660 --> 02:46:15.980
So, considering those three special uses, those are not outright permitted in commercial,

02:46:15.980 --> 02:46:21.420
and so that it's up to us to decide whether it's a good fit for the neighbors and how it will impact the neighbors.

02:46:22.620 --> 02:46:29.420
I am concerned, as you can see on the schematic, the direction of traffic and

02:46:29.420 --> 02:46:36.980
the headlights that would be coming 24 hours a day would really be in the direction of those apartments and

02:46:36.980 --> 02:46:42.860
houses, the lights would be going directly into their bedroom windows and so on and so forth.

02:46:42.860 --> 02:46:48.460
I think that's a concern for me. Also, I would like to have more information and the commission

02:46:48.460 --> 02:46:53.300
to talk about this in their deliberations. More than one commissioner really felt like they

02:46:53.300 --> 02:46:58.660
needed more information. I personally would like to see a detailed landscape mitigation

02:46:58.660 --> 02:47:05.020
plan because right now we really can't tell, you know, as Councilman talking to said, what

02:47:05.020 --> 02:47:07.540
kind of trees those are, what they look like, what kind of

02:47:07.540 --> 02:47:12.460
burming might be available, and that landscape strip looks a

02:47:12.460 --> 02:47:16.740
little narrow to me to really mitigate the impacts right now.

02:47:16.740 --> 02:47:18.300
And we just don't have a lot of details.

02:47:18.300 --> 02:47:21.740
We also don't have the decision from ITD, and I think that

02:47:21.740 --> 02:47:26.300
that would significantly change the impacts to the

02:47:26.300 --> 02:47:30.100
neighborhood, whether all traffic is directed through

02:47:30.100 --> 02:47:37.100
or not, you know, as staff stated, you know, the special use permit would be void if it is going through

02:47:37.100 --> 02:47:43.100
Meadowview, but I think either way, you're still going to have traffic impacts to residential.

02:47:43.100 --> 02:47:52.150
And, you know, the guidelines that we're given is that commercial does not impose on residential.

02:47:52.150 --> 02:47:59.150
And even though those apartments are zone C1, it matters what the use is.

02:47:59.150 --> 02:48:01.470
currently, they're being used as residential.

02:48:01.470 --> 02:48:04.870
I don't see this use as very compatible with this neighborhood,

02:48:04.870 --> 02:48:08.310
and it reminds me a lot of the hearings

02:48:08.310 --> 02:48:10.990
that we went through regarding service stations

02:48:10.990 --> 02:48:13.550
on the corner of Addison and Eastland.

02:48:13.550 --> 02:48:17.150
And that was a high traffic area, and both of those roads

02:48:17.150 --> 02:48:20.670
were actually better equipped for traffic.

02:48:20.670 --> 02:48:24.830
But based on testimony of the neighbors,

02:48:24.830 --> 02:48:26.470
it wasn't a good fit for them.

02:48:26.470 --> 02:48:33.470
And in the end, they now have a development that is a better fit that went through a more specific process.

02:48:33.470 --> 02:48:37.470
They reached out to the neighbors, had open houses throughout the process,

02:48:37.470 --> 02:48:48.470
and were able to mitigate the issues with specifics, with specific promises and plans that were followed through on.

02:48:48.470 --> 02:48:51.470
And that's my only concern, is we don't have any specifics here.

02:48:51.470 --> 02:49:01.810
So, there's really nothing to hold the applicant to as far as mitigating light or glare, and

02:49:01.810 --> 02:49:06.830
really having commercial impact residential in a negative way.

02:49:06.830 --> 02:49:14.510
For me, it's too negative, but I would like to see us require decision by ITD first before

02:49:14.510 --> 02:49:22.470
or deciding or a more specific landscape planning on that north side that impacts the residential

02:49:22.470 --> 02:49:23.470
right next to it.

02:49:23.470 --> 02:49:24.980
Thank you, Rebecca.

02:49:24.980 --> 02:49:25.980
Sean Bearerger.

02:49:25.980 --> 02:49:35.570
So as I look at this area, I mean, we are always going to run into the point where commercial

02:49:35.570 --> 02:49:37.810
development abuts residential.

02:49:37.810 --> 02:49:40.770
That's just the way it works.

02:49:40.770 --> 02:49:44.410
Otherwise, everything would be on blue lakes and everything else in town would be residential

02:49:44.410 --> 02:49:48.510
subdivisions and that would be what it is.

02:49:48.510 --> 02:49:56.950
So as Councilman Talkington said that this is a little difficult to make those decisions

02:49:56.950 --> 02:49:58.550
when you're running into that.

02:49:58.550 --> 02:50:05.330
However, I think that the fact that this is a highway frontage, it's not just a busy

02:50:05.330 --> 02:50:07.990
road, it's a highway.

02:50:07.990 --> 02:50:13.410
I think it's easier for me to be inclined to support the commercial development there

02:50:13.410 --> 02:50:20.590
because it's not like it was a little tiny street that suddenly became big and now it's

02:50:20.590 --> 02:50:27.110
going to have a gas station. It's always been a highway. I do think that the transition

02:50:27.110 --> 02:50:32.430
from apartments to single family residents does create a buffer and I don't mean that as

02:50:32.430 --> 02:50:36.110
a derogatory thing against the apartments. I think that's the natural progression of

02:50:36.110 --> 02:50:42.190
trying to keep that transition. I also think that some of the items that Mr. Lynch has

02:50:42.190 --> 02:50:51.250
talked about with landscape buffering, with limiting those access points, trying to create

02:50:51.250 --> 02:50:55.530
a natural flow of traffic through there is helping to mitigate some of that.

02:50:55.530 --> 02:51:00.530
And I would certainly encourage you to go above and beyond, as I think you will, after

02:51:00.530 --> 02:51:05.130
your 90 plus years of business here in the valley, to be a good neighbor to make sure

02:51:05.130 --> 02:51:06.130
you do that.

02:51:06.130 --> 02:51:10.250
I think the other thing to keep in mind is that this development will actually make some

02:51:10.250 --> 02:51:17.250
improvements to that roadway that is not currently built out to width to the highway

02:51:17.250 --> 02:51:19.650
as the property developers will develop that.

02:51:19.650 --> 02:51:25.770
So, again, I would just encourage Mr. Lynch and your team to make sure that you're working

02:51:25.770 --> 02:51:31.930
closely with the neighbors and identifying those issues, and I think Rebecca makes a good

02:51:31.930 --> 02:51:34.810
point of reaching out to them sooner than later.

02:51:34.810 --> 02:51:39.750
might be a good option to build that comradery and

02:51:39.750 --> 02:51:41.050
and neighborliness.

02:51:41.050 --> 02:51:43.680
Thank you, Mr. Parrater.

02:51:43.680 --> 02:51:44.680
Greg Len.

02:51:44.680 --> 02:51:50.040
Chris, you said that well, I'm not going to try to repeat

02:51:50.040 --> 02:51:51.840
on how the conflict here.

02:51:51.840 --> 02:51:55.540
If this was, if we were rezoning this to see one,

02:51:55.540 --> 02:51:57.380
my answer would be no.

02:51:57.380 --> 02:51:59.680
It was already see one from the 70s,

02:51:59.680 --> 02:52:04.760
so basically the housing and the houses and the apartments

02:52:04.760 --> 02:52:07.800
actually made the choice to build that distance

02:52:07.800 --> 02:52:14.060
from a C1 piece property, actually the ones on the first street there, the apartments had

02:52:14.060 --> 02:52:18.560
to went in, they had a keymark backed up to them, and probably would have had a special

02:52:18.560 --> 02:52:23.400
easterment because this is C1 property.

02:52:23.400 --> 02:52:27.760
And the difference I will draw from what Rebecca talked about in the corner that we

02:52:27.760 --> 02:52:35.000
voted down, that was the change of use to make it worse.

02:52:35.000 --> 02:52:40.200
went from a residential house to a commercial and that made it make a difference to me. That's

02:52:40.200 --> 02:52:44.600
the reason I backed by it when I would have said the C1. And also I have a little disrespect.

02:52:44.600 --> 02:52:51.770
[Muted for privacy: home address]

02:52:51.770 --> 02:52:58.010
[Muted for privacy: home address]

02:52:58.010 --> 02:53:05.210
[Muted for privacy: home address]

02:53:05.210 --> 02:53:10.930
[Muted for privacy: home address]

02:53:10.930 --> 02:53:16.250
walk to often, the all the different ones that actually enhance my life a

02:53:16.250 --> 02:53:21.410
little bit but yet cause a lot of traffic and I just don't see the cars

02:53:21.410 --> 02:53:27.200
going down that a few. I see that point slightly because when I leave the

02:53:27.200 --> 02:53:30.600
McDonald's property and both likes and filer.

02:53:30.600 --> 02:53:33.440
Sometimes I turn right and go down Lincoln Street,

02:53:33.440 --> 02:53:35.800
which I'm through, lay Iowa and other residents on that,

02:53:35.800 --> 02:53:38.680
but I'm not very happy about, but I sometimes do it.

02:53:38.680 --> 02:53:40.880
But I'm actually gonna be heading that direction.

02:53:40.880 --> 02:53:44.880
So, it's one of those things where I'll go back

02:53:44.880 --> 02:53:46.880
to my original statement, this was,

02:53:46.880 --> 02:53:50.120
we were rezoning this to C1, my answer would be no,

02:53:50.120 --> 02:53:55.120
but it's already C1, and it's been C1 for about 40 years.

02:53:55.120 --> 02:54:02.840
And so I'm going to be voting in favor of upholding the money and vote.

02:54:02.840 --> 02:54:04.800
Thank you, Greg.

02:54:04.800 --> 02:54:11.400
All the way down, I think for me, looking at this development, it makes sense to me.

02:54:11.400 --> 02:54:15.520
It's incumbent upon you, Mr. Lynch, as I've known you for many years, and

02:54:15.520 --> 02:54:21.400
I've known you to be an honorable businessman to mitigate the lighting as you've spoken.

02:54:21.400 --> 02:54:24.840
And as other council members of ARRI said,

02:54:24.840 --> 02:54:27.380
overdo the landscaping if you need to,

02:54:27.380 --> 02:54:29.460
because obviously we need to be sensitive

02:54:29.460 --> 02:54:31.440
next to these residences.

02:54:31.440 --> 02:54:34.740
And I know that you're the type of businessman

02:54:34.740 --> 02:54:35.580
that will do that.

02:54:35.580 --> 02:54:38.140
So I would just further encourage that

02:54:38.140 --> 02:54:40.700
from the dias up here.

02:54:40.700 --> 02:54:43.220
I too will be voting in favor,

02:54:44.220 --> 02:54:47.460
because to me it makes sense that it's a C1 zone.

02:54:47.460 --> 02:54:51.840
And I don't know what to say about Mero view

02:54:51.840 --> 02:54:59.660
And utilizing that as a thoroughfare, it is, as it's a collector.

02:54:59.660 --> 02:55:04.960
That's what people drive through from the residential areas to get to other locations,

02:55:04.960 --> 02:55:06.400
was designed that way.

02:55:06.400 --> 02:55:09.520
So again, I will be voting in favor.

02:55:09.520 --> 02:55:11.590
Suzanne Hawkins.

02:55:11.590 --> 02:55:15.150
I've really struggled with this one, looking at it from both sides of the view.

02:55:17.230 --> 02:55:21.350
You know, I listened intently to the gentleman who talked about the children in

02:55:21.350 --> 02:55:25.030
the apartment complex and that they would be going to that property.

02:55:25.030 --> 02:55:29.350
And I went, thought about that for a minute and I thought, you know, when my grandkids come

02:55:29.350 --> 02:55:33.390
and spend the night with me, they like to walk to the service station and get a treat.

02:55:33.390 --> 02:55:34.990
It's a big deal.

02:55:34.990 --> 02:55:36.870
It's not an inconvenience to them.

02:55:36.870 --> 02:55:38.590
It's not an inconvenience to the business owner.

02:55:38.590 --> 02:55:41.430
It's a good, it's a good relationship.

02:55:41.430 --> 02:55:44.150
So I have a hard time seeing that as a negative.

02:55:44.150 --> 02:55:50.950
I see, again, having the convenience of being able to grab a last minute grocery snack

02:55:52.370 --> 02:55:54.470
without having to get in your car and drive from the neighborhood.

02:55:54.470 --> 02:55:57.950
I would think that would be a good thing, and it isn't necessarily right in your backyard.

02:55:57.950 --> 02:56:02.070
I understand the apartments are, but from the houses you have a street or two to walk.

02:56:03.230 --> 02:56:09.430
Kimberly is a state highway, it's going to have a lot of development, it is a commercial build zone.

02:56:09.430 --> 02:56:13.670
And I think with a good relationship between the business owner and

02:56:13.670 --> 02:56:18.390
the residents working through some of the smaller issues, I think it can work.

02:56:18.390 --> 02:56:24.450
And I would have to say I think of it as more of a positive than a negative to the neighborhood.

02:56:24.450 --> 02:56:25.010
Thank you, Suzanne.

02:56:25.010 --> 02:56:26.610
Rebecca, no second.

02:56:26.610 --> 02:56:28.330
Thank you, Mayor.

02:56:28.330 --> 02:56:30.090
Just one more thought.

02:56:30.090 --> 02:56:34.010
I know that we're talking about commercial, see one makes sense, it does.

02:56:34.010 --> 02:56:35.650
It fits in with the comp plan.

02:56:35.650 --> 02:56:39.010
It should be commercial, but there's lots of different types of commercial.

02:56:39.010 --> 02:56:43.450
What we're talking about here tonight is a special use permit and it is a special use permit so

02:56:43.450 --> 02:56:48.490
that we can have public hearings and get input from the neighbors on how they're going to be impacted.

02:56:48.490 --> 02:56:58.210
And I think I guess my only suggestion for a compromise then would be to not have it operate 24 hours.

02:56:58.210 --> 02:57:04.170
That's one of the items, one of the three special use permit items that are here tonight.

02:57:04.170 --> 02:57:18.410
And so even though there might not be support for it, I would motion that we amend it to be the regular hours of operation for the commercial district and not 24 hours.

02:57:18.410 --> 02:57:19.930
What would those hours be?

02:57:19.930 --> 02:57:23.180
I can put it in motion.

02:57:23.180 --> 02:57:25.820
Regular retail hours are 7 a.m. to 10 p.m.

02:57:25.820 --> 02:57:31.730
We have a motion on floor by Rebecca Mills so I get to amend the main motion to

02:57:32.250 --> 02:57:37.450
Regulate the hours for this location from 7 a.m. To 10 p.m. Yes

02:57:38.250 --> 02:57:40.200
Wait for a second

02:57:40.200 --> 02:57:46.520
I'll second that make a motion we have a motion on the floor by Rebecca Mills so I guess seconded by Chris talking

02:57:46.520 --> 02:57:54.080
Yeah, I'd like to make a comment. I used to be in the sea store or gas business at a 7-11 franchise in North blue lakes

02:57:57.200 --> 02:58:02.200
It was not a very nice place 24 hours a day. I was required to keep it open.

02:58:02.200 --> 02:58:11.200
But my main problem was I had to keep staff on there at the time as Mr. Lynch's survey showed there's virtually no customers.

02:58:11.200 --> 02:58:15.200
I will say during the hunting season it peaked out pretty good.

02:58:15.200 --> 02:58:21.200
But there were about three, four months a year where there would be hours in between customers.

02:58:21.200 --> 02:58:26.200
And the lights are left on off and even when the businesses are closed.

02:58:26.200 --> 02:58:31.200
So 24 hours a day does not necessarily need much of a difference

02:58:31.200 --> 02:58:38.200
than 16 or 18 hours a day if those other mitigating factors are taking place.

02:58:38.200 --> 02:58:43.200
It's very possible if we approve the limitation on hours,

02:58:43.200 --> 02:58:47.200
people will be pulling in there to arrest their RVs,

02:58:47.200 --> 02:58:54.760
The lights will still be on and the people who are night owls would not be able to get that cup of coffee.

02:58:54.760 --> 02:59:01.910
So I'm seconding it, but I will not support the motion for the amendment.

02:59:01.910 --> 02:59:06.310
Anything further from council before we go to a vote on the amendment?

02:59:06.310 --> 02:59:13.350
I see no further light, so again, this is an amendment to amend the hours of the business from 7 a.m.

02:59:13.350 --> 02:59:14.830
To 10 p.m.

02:59:14.830 --> 02:59:16.630
The ayla, roll call vote please.

02:59:16.630 --> 02:59:17.510
We're glanting.

02:59:17.510 --> 02:59:18.960
No.

02:59:18.960 --> 02:59:19.840
Don Hall.

02:59:19.840 --> 02:59:21.040
No.

02:59:21.040 --> 02:59:21.920
Chris Tockington.

02:59:21.920 --> 02:59:23.040
No.

02:59:23.040 --> 02:59:24.080
Rebecca Milsoyka.

02:59:24.080 --> 02:59:25.580
Yes.

02:59:25.580 --> 02:59:26.740
Suzanne Hawkins.

02:59:26.740 --> 02:59:27.820
No.

02:59:27.820 --> 02:59:28.740
Sean Berriger.

02:59:28.740 --> 02:59:29.940
No.

02:59:29.940 --> 02:59:30.700
Jim Mann.

02:59:30.700 --> 02:59:31.860
No.

02:59:31.860 --> 02:59:34.420
Motion fails 1 to 6.

02:59:34.420 --> 02:59:39.840
Now on to the main motion to uphold the planning and zoning

02:59:39.840 --> 02:59:42.580
decision with the conditions that were

02:59:42.580 --> 02:59:45.140
listed within their document.

02:59:45.140 --> 02:59:46.860
the island roll call vote, please.

02:59:48.700 --> 02:59:50.800
Yes.

02:59:50.800 --> 02:59:53.490
Yes.

02:59:53.490 --> 02:59:56.390
No.

02:59:56.390 --> 02:59:58.650
Yes.

02:59:58.650 --> 03:00:00.450
Yes.

03:00:00.450 --> 03:00:02.380
Yes.

03:00:02.380 --> 03:00:03.200
Yes.

03:00:03.200 --> 03:00:04.940
Motion passes.

03:00:04.940 --> 03:00:06.460
Six to one.

03:00:08.070 --> 03:00:10.510
Ladies and gentlemen, this is the way democracy works.

03:00:10.510 --> 03:00:12.670
Appreciate everyone coming out this evening

03:00:12.670 --> 03:00:14.250
and sharing your input.

03:00:16.980 --> 03:00:18.700
Oh, we do have an executive session.

03:00:18.700 --> 03:00:19.540
Thank you.

03:00:19.540 --> 03:00:20.940
Let me read this.

03:00:20.940 --> 03:00:23.540
I was getting ready to get us out of here.

03:00:23.540 --> 03:00:25.240
Thank you, great.

03:00:25.240 --> 03:00:27.080
The next item on the agenda is an adjournment

03:00:27.080 --> 03:00:28.800
into executive session of the council.

03:00:28.800 --> 03:00:33.960
So wishes 67-2345-1C to conduct deliberations

03:00:33.960 --> 03:00:37.440
concerning labor negotiations or to acquire an interest

03:00:37.440 --> 03:00:39.600
in real property, which is not owned

03:00:39.600 --> 03:00:41.360
by a public agency, Greg Lanning.

03:00:41.360 --> 03:00:42.480
So moved.

03:00:42.480 --> 03:00:43.320
Second.

03:00:43.320 --> 03:00:46.320
Motion on 4 by Greg Lanning, seconded by Sean Berger

03:00:46.320 --> 03:00:48.040
to go into executive session.

03:00:48.040 --> 03:00:50.440
Anything further on that motion council?

03:00:50.440 --> 03:00:52.810
We have the roll call vote.

03:00:52.810 --> 03:00:54.850
Yes.

03:00:54.850 --> 03:01:15.420
Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes seven to zero just to inform folks. We will not be making any decisions within our executive session. And we will not be coming back out and reconvening tonight in as a council.

03:01:15.420 --> 03:01:19.030
We are adjourned into executive session.
