WEBVTT

00:03:19.020 --> 00:03:24.780
Yeah, be there are my bills bills my toes and I bet we'll talk about mr.

00:03:24.780 --> 00:03:25.740
Backway

00:03:25.740 --> 00:03:51.040
I like to call the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council Order. It's August 11th 2014

00:03:51.040 --> 00:03:55.760
We are meeting at four o'clock for the purposes of going into an executive session

00:03:56.240 --> 00:04:00.880
So I'll go ahead and read that code and then ask for Council's direction

00:04:01.440 --> 00:04:06.720
67 23 45 1 F to communicate with legal counsel for the public

00:04:06.720 --> 00:04:13.600
agency to discuss the legal ramifications of the legal options for pending litigation,

00:04:13.600 --> 00:04:19.640
or controversies not yet being litigated, but eminently likely to be litigated.

00:04:19.640 --> 00:04:26.200
The mere presence of legal counsel at an executive session does not satisfy this requirement, Council wishes.

00:04:26.200 --> 00:04:27.360
So moved.

00:04:27.360 --> 00:04:34.120
We have a motion on the floor by Chris Tognedon, seconded by Sean Berriger to go into executive session.

00:04:34.120 --> 00:04:37.580
Anything further on that motion, Council?

00:04:37.580 --> 00:04:39.220
the ailer, real call vote please.

00:04:39.220 --> 00:04:40.300
Suzanne Hawkins?

00:04:40.300 --> 00:04:41.140
Yes.

00:04:41.140 --> 00:04:41.900
Jim Munk?

00:04:41.900 --> 00:04:42.740
Yes.

00:04:42.740 --> 00:04:43.580
Sean Baraker?

00:04:43.580 --> 00:04:44.420
Yes.

00:04:44.420 --> 00:04:45.260
Ms. Talkington?

00:04:45.260 --> 00:04:46.100
Yes.

00:04:46.100 --> 00:04:47.340
Greg Lanting?

00:04:47.340 --> 00:04:48.420
Not here.

00:04:48.420 --> 00:04:49.340
Don Hall?

00:04:49.340 --> 00:04:50.620
Yes.

00:04:50.620 --> 00:04:52.180
Motion passes 5-0.

00:04:52.180 --> 00:04:55.980
I'll mention that both Rebecca and Greg Lanting

00:04:55.980 --> 00:04:57.900
weren't able to make it to the council meeting tonight.

00:04:57.900 --> 01:03:51.460
So at this time, we were going into executive session.

01:03:51.460 --> 01:03:53.700
I'd like to reconvene the meeting of the Twin Falls City

01:03:53.700 --> 01:03:54.700
Council.

01:03:54.700 --> 01:03:56.660
It is August 11, 2014.

01:03:56.660 --> 01:04:01.720
We're just returning from an executive session and I just want to report to everyone we made

01:04:01.720 --> 01:04:06.260
no decisions in our executive session with just more conversation.

01:04:06.260 --> 01:04:10.740
The first item on our agenda, as always, first of all, welcome to everyone that's here, is

01:04:10.740 --> 01:04:17.920
our Pledge of Allegiance, so please rise if you wish to join us.

01:04:17.920 --> 01:04:24.520
I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for

01:04:24.520 --> 01:04:29.160
which is perhaps one nation under God, indivisible,

01:04:29.160 --> 01:04:32.570
with liberty and justice for all.

01:04:32.570 --> 01:04:35.250
Again, thank you all for joining us this evening.

01:04:35.250 --> 01:04:37.010
We do have a quorum of the city council.

01:04:37.010 --> 01:04:40.570
Five members are here, both Greg and Rebecca

01:04:40.570 --> 01:04:41.530
had prior commitments.

01:04:41.530 --> 01:04:43.450
We're not able to be here this evening.

01:04:45.290 --> 01:04:48.290
We have no proclamations, Travis.

01:04:48.290 --> 01:04:51.130
Do we have any amendments to our agenda this evening?

01:04:51.130 --> 01:04:52.250
There are no amendments.

01:04:52.250 --> 01:04:53.090
Thank you.

01:04:53.090 --> 01:05:01.170
First item that we now typically do is we open up the mic for anyone in the audience that

01:05:01.170 --> 01:05:07.250
would like to address the City Council about any issue that's not on the agenda this evening,

01:05:07.250 --> 01:05:10.690
and if you could keep it brief, because we have a full agenda this evening, that'd be

01:05:10.690 --> 01:05:11.690
appreciated.

01:05:11.690 --> 01:05:19.540
So this time I'll open it up to folks in the audience, and no one's running for the mic

01:05:19.540 --> 01:05:20.540
again.

01:05:20.540 --> 01:05:25.420
So we'll move on to the consent calendar, and before we approve the consent calendar, I do

01:05:25.420 --> 01:05:31.220
I do want to mention that the second item in the consent calendar is the

01:05:31.220 --> 01:05:40.940
Prine Bridge Festival, it's called Kids Bridge to Success, and it's going to be held Saturday, September 6, 2014, just because we are televised.

01:05:40.940 --> 01:05:42.660
I wanted to make sure folks knew about that.

01:05:42.660 --> 01:05:47.660
So at this time I'll turn to the council for their wishes with the consent calendar.

01:05:47.660 --> 01:05:48.660
Suzanne Hawkins.

01:05:48.660 --> 01:05:50.300
And move approval.

01:05:50.300 --> 01:05:51.300
Second.

01:05:51.300 --> 01:05:53.140
Motion on the floor by Suzanne Hawkins,

01:05:53.140 --> 01:05:56.380
seconded by Sean Berriger to approve the consent calendar.

01:05:56.380 --> 01:06:00.060
Anything further on that motion council?

01:06:00.060 --> 01:06:01.700
The a la roll call vote, please.

01:06:01.700 --> 01:06:02.540
Jim Mundt.

01:06:02.540 --> 01:06:03.380
Yes.

01:06:03.380 --> 01:06:04.220
Sean Berriger.

01:06:04.220 --> 01:06:05.060
Yes.

01:06:05.060 --> 01:06:05.900
Chris Talkington.

01:06:05.900 --> 01:06:06.740
Yeah.

01:06:06.740 --> 01:06:07.580
Don Hall.

01:06:07.580 --> 01:06:08.420
Yes.

01:06:08.420 --> 01:06:09.260
Suzanne Hawkins.

01:06:09.260 --> 01:06:10.260
Yes.

01:06:10.260 --> 01:06:11.900
Motion passes five to zero.

01:06:11.900 --> 01:06:16.100
Moving down to items for consideration.

01:06:16.100 --> 01:06:19.380
You must have been here for the consent calendar item.

01:06:19.380 --> 01:06:20.620
Item for consideration.

01:06:20.620 --> 01:06:27.540
The first item is a request to present and adopt the 2014 Americans with Disability Transition

01:06:27.540 --> 01:06:30.940
Plan and we have Josh Baird here to make the presentation.

01:06:30.940 --> 01:06:31.940
Welcome Josh.

01:06:31.940 --> 01:06:32.940
Thank you.

01:06:32.940 --> 01:06:40.140
I was here back in, I believe May and I presented the draft transition plan at that time and

01:06:40.140 --> 01:06:46.060
said that we were going to go forward with a public open house as well as getting a kind

01:06:46.060 --> 01:06:48.180
of a stakeholders meeting together.

01:06:48.180 --> 01:06:53.380
We went ahead and did that, we had a State Colors meeting and a pipe a leave June.

01:06:53.380 --> 01:06:57.220
We had quite a few people attend, I'd say about a dozen or so from different agencies

01:06:57.220 --> 01:06:59.460
that represented those who were disabled.

01:06:59.460 --> 01:07:05.340
And then later in July, we had an open house where we had six people attend that weren't

01:07:05.340 --> 01:07:09.900
city staff and we didn't have any pertinent comments to the plan.

01:07:09.900 --> 01:07:14.860
So the draft plan that you already received back in May is virtually the same plan that

01:07:14.860 --> 01:07:22.710
we have now with a few minor grammatical changes that occurred. So I guess that's my report.

01:07:22.710 --> 01:07:30.900
Do we, first of all, if we want to go at this evening and pass this, we'll need a resolution

01:07:30.900 --> 01:07:36.260
numbers. Is that correct? Do you have a resolution number for us?

01:07:36.260 --> 01:07:47.270
1929. 1929. So I'll open it up to council for questions. Josh, any questions? I see no

01:07:47.270 --> 01:07:50.270
So I'll now turn it over for a motion.

01:07:50.270 --> 01:07:51.270
Chris, talk.

01:07:51.270 --> 01:07:56.270
Well, I'd like to compliment you, Josh, on a very difficult project on that sort of way,

01:07:56.270 --> 01:07:59.270
the whole tug on town site, practically.

01:07:59.270 --> 01:08:05.270
I would still like to have some affirmation from the city manager of the passage of a

01:08:05.270 --> 01:08:13.780
resolution and a long-term financial consequences to the city to involve.

01:08:13.780 --> 01:08:16.780
You know, I'm also going to have Josh help me with this because he's been involved in

01:08:16.780 --> 01:08:22.980
But really what you're creating is a transition plan, a plan that basically states that these

01:08:22.980 --> 01:08:29.120
are the conditions of some of those roadways and areas and intersections, curves, gutters

01:08:29.120 --> 01:08:36.180
and sidewalks, and how are we going to ensure that they become ADA compliant in the future.

01:08:36.180 --> 01:08:41.020
And what we want to do as an organization is to remember a couple of things.

01:08:41.020 --> 01:08:46.660
There is not a defined timeline in which all of these things need to be completed.

01:08:46.660 --> 01:08:54.520
It's important to recognize that as we do road jobs and different projects in other areas that we are following that transition plan.

01:08:54.520 --> 01:08:59.360
And that we are making those improvements in a very incremental and systematic manner.

01:08:59.360 --> 01:09:05.520
And also whether or not we're making those improvements, but also that we're encouraging those improvements to be constructed.

01:09:05.520 --> 01:09:14.200
Whether they be from the call of deferrals, the replacements of curb scutters and sidewalks in other areas and through partnerships.

01:09:14.200 --> 01:09:16.880
Really, this creates a plan and creates a standard.

01:09:16.880 --> 01:09:21.000
It doesn't necessarily create a timeline, and a timeline, I think, would be the place that

01:09:21.000 --> 01:09:24.840
has the financial consequences to it.

01:09:24.840 --> 01:09:27.480
Our goal and our commitment is to complete this as expeditiously-

01:09:27.480 --> 01:09:33.720
So we can demonstrate progress to our normal upgrading, new bill, LID process, whatever

01:09:33.720 --> 01:09:36.320
that that should be sufficient?

01:09:36.320 --> 01:09:40.880
There is an implementation schedule stated in the plan.

01:09:40.880 --> 01:09:44.880
If you have the plan in front of you, it's on page E-4.

01:09:44.880 --> 01:09:47.120
And I'll just read it short.

01:09:47.120 --> 01:09:49.080
It says implementation of the curb ramp program

01:09:49.080 --> 01:09:52.880
is dependent upon funding allocated towards the program

01:09:52.880 --> 01:09:55.560
by the City Council of the City Twin Falls.

01:09:55.560 --> 01:09:57.080
While this is variable from year to year,

01:09:57.080 --> 01:10:00.000
it is suggested that upon completion

01:10:00.000 --> 01:10:02.920
of the detailed evaluation, a number or percentage

01:10:02.920 --> 01:10:05.760
of deficient curb ramps be targeted to be retrofitted

01:10:05.760 --> 01:10:09.600
or replaced each year to bring them into ADA compliance.

01:10:09.600 --> 01:10:11.440
So it's a fairly loose schedule,

01:10:11.440 --> 01:10:14.140
and it's dependent upon the city council's approval

01:10:14.140 --> 01:10:16.100
for the funding.

01:10:16.100 --> 01:10:17.580
Okay.

01:10:17.580 --> 01:10:22.330
I would move passage of 1929 then.

01:10:22.330 --> 01:10:23.170
Second.

01:10:23.170 --> 01:10:26.330
Motion on floor by Kristall Heathen.

01:10:26.330 --> 01:10:31.330
Seconded by Sean Berriver to pass resolution 1929.

01:10:32.940 --> 01:10:35.690
Anything further on this motion council.

01:10:35.690 --> 01:10:38.670
So basically Josh what you're saying in the implementation

01:10:38.670 --> 01:10:42.370
is it doesn't have a whole lot of teeth to it.

01:10:42.370 --> 01:10:45.370
just says in the future we're going to decide what we're going to do in the future.

01:10:45.370 --> 01:10:46.690
Okay.

01:10:46.690 --> 01:10:51.690
So I try to make as loose as possible for the City Council, but I also wanted to, you know,

01:10:51.690 --> 01:10:55.690
we're required to have a plan and we're trying to have a schedule as part of the plan.

01:10:55.690 --> 01:11:04.360
So do you foresee us coming together later and actually doing something with more teeth, more, more plan?

01:11:04.360 --> 01:11:08.360
We're going to do 10% a year or 4% a year.

01:11:08.360 --> 01:11:10.360
Do you foresee anything like that?

01:11:10.360 --> 01:11:19.360
I would imagine that occurring but I would think it would occur in street department budget meetings where they just, you know, because I think it's going to go to the

01:11:19.360 --> 01:11:25.360
poll works department that will be in charge of implementation and as such then they'll have to find a way to make it work.

01:11:25.360 --> 01:11:31.360
But it's still about 10 years out before we have a detailed plan even in place to know exactly what we're up against.

01:11:31.360 --> 01:11:32.360
So, okay.

01:11:32.360 --> 01:11:33.360
Perfect.

01:11:33.360 --> 01:11:34.360
Travis?

01:11:34.360 --> 01:11:38.400
Very good starting place, maybe during our strategic planning update, where during that

01:11:38.400 --> 01:11:44.720
process the city council can establish a set percentage that we can move forward with.

01:11:44.720 --> 01:11:51.320
I think it's important to recognize that when you create those goals and those standards,

01:11:51.320 --> 01:11:54.720
that gives us something to drive those budget conversations from.

01:11:54.720 --> 01:11:59.360
And so during that strategic planning process, it would be a good time to talk about what

01:11:59.360 --> 01:12:03.200
percent and what as we go through zone maintenance and those other activities

01:12:03.200 --> 01:12:09.240
of a various to replace. Again because in our strategic plan the accessibility piece

01:12:09.240 --> 01:12:15.680
is one of the goals that we have and obviously this is getting us there it's

01:12:15.680 --> 01:12:20.080
just taking a small city that's moving into a medium-sized city and

01:12:20.080 --> 01:12:25.680
trying to transition us to do the right thing in these respects. So great work

01:12:25.680 --> 01:12:30.060
I appreciate all that you've done and I see no further light so the other roll call vote, please

01:12:30.060 --> 01:12:34.700
Sean Burger. Yes, Chris talking to yes Don Hall. Yes

01:12:35.500 --> 01:12:40.440
Suzanne Hawkins. Yes Jim. Yes motion passes five zero. Thank you, sir

01:12:41.000 --> 01:12:49.100
Next time on the agenda is request award the bid for a dump slash sander truck to rush truck centers for an amount

01:12:49.200 --> 01:12:54.840
Not to exceed 144,000. We have John Kate and welcome John. Thank you, ma'am. Good evening

01:12:55.680 --> 01:13:00.560
I do have the streets superintendent Dean Littler's here tonight and if you have specific questions

01:13:00.560 --> 01:13:05.520
about the piece of equipment, he can be easily more suited for that than I am.

01:13:05.520 --> 01:13:08.240
We did advertise this as a formal bid.

01:13:08.240 --> 01:13:12.720
It went into the newspaper like we do all of our formal equipment bids and we received

01:13:12.720 --> 01:13:17.720
one bid for our rush equipment for $144,000.

01:13:17.720 --> 01:13:24.550
It is about a budgeted expenditure and I'd recommend approval of the country.

01:13:24.550 --> 01:13:32.550
Any questions for John or Dean stand for a motion if there's no questions

01:13:33.030 --> 01:13:40.430
Jim I'd move to award the bid for a dumpster standard truck truck centers for the amount not to exceed

01:13:41.530 --> 01:13:46.700
$144,000

01:13:46.700 --> 01:13:49.800
Motion on for by Jim on seconded by Suzanne Hawkins

01:13:50.580 --> 01:13:53.180
As stated anything further on motion council

01:13:53.620 --> 01:13:56.610
Lee Island roll call vote, please

01:13:56.610 --> 01:13:57.610
Yes.

01:13:57.610 --> 01:13:58.610
Don Hall.

01:13:58.610 --> 01:13:59.610
Yes.

01:13:59.610 --> 01:14:00.610
Suzanne Hawkins.

01:14:00.610 --> 01:14:01.610
Yes.

01:14:01.610 --> 01:14:02.610
Jim Munn.

01:14:02.610 --> 01:14:03.610
Yes.

01:14:03.610 --> 01:14:04.610
Some Barricas.

01:14:04.610 --> 01:14:05.610
Yes.

01:14:05.610 --> 01:14:06.610
Motion passes.

01:14:06.610 --> 01:14:07.610
Five to zero.

01:14:07.610 --> 01:14:08.610
Thank you, John.

01:14:08.610 --> 01:14:15.810
Next item on the agenda is a request from the FAA to transfer $200,000 to the Twin Falls

01:14:15.810 --> 01:14:24.100
Fiscal Year 2014 FAA funding to Idaho Falls Airport to be transferred back to the Twin

01:14:24.100 --> 01:14:31.460
falls in fiscal year 2015. We have our airport manager, Bill Carberry. Welcome, Bill.

01:14:31.460 --> 01:14:36.140
Thank you, Mayor. Good evening, Council. In your packet, there's an email request there

01:14:36.140 --> 01:14:42.320
from the FAA project manager that we work with that helps us with our capital improvement

01:14:42.320 --> 01:14:47.060
plan, with our grant program. He also works with other airports, Idaho Falls, amongst

01:14:47.060 --> 01:14:52.980
them. So it's sort of a good neighbor request that they've put before us. They're asking

01:14:52.980 --> 01:14:57.300
for us to take the unused funding from our current year.

01:14:57.300 --> 01:14:59.300
And when we don't use entitlement funding,

01:14:59.300 --> 01:15:01.300
we carry that over to the next year.

01:15:01.300 --> 01:15:03.500
And in this case, we're looking to utilize those

01:15:03.500 --> 01:15:05.860
for the airport terminal job.

01:15:05.860 --> 01:15:08.180
So with that, he's simply asking us

01:15:08.180 --> 01:15:12.940
to authorize a transfer of $200,000 of this year's funding

01:15:12.940 --> 01:15:16.460
that we would carry over, transfer that to Idaho Falls

01:15:16.460 --> 01:15:18.860
so that that will enable one of their projects

01:15:18.860 --> 01:15:22.740
that they need an additional $200,000 they're borrowing ahead

01:15:22.740 --> 01:15:28.780
to complete, and then they'll intern, sign a transfer agreement in fiscal year 15 to return

01:15:28.780 --> 01:15:34.180
that to us, fiscal 15 being October 1st for the federal government.

01:15:34.180 --> 01:15:38.420
So with that, I'd be happy to answer any questions I did discuss this with the airport

01:15:38.420 --> 01:15:39.420
board.

01:15:39.420 --> 01:15:45.020
They have no objections and would recommend the council authorize the mayor to sign the

01:15:45.020 --> 01:15:46.700
agreement.

01:15:46.700 --> 01:15:47.700
They're talking to me.

01:15:47.700 --> 01:15:51.620
It might buy us a little bit of goodwill, possibly too, Bill, with that, very good.

01:15:51.620 --> 01:15:55.300
The shoe could be on the other foot someday, so certainly.

01:15:55.300 --> 01:16:03.620
I would so move, unless there are any questions Council has to authorize transfer of $200,000

01:16:03.620 --> 01:16:12.340
FAA funds, Twin Falls fiscal 2014 funding, Idaho Falls airport, that money to be transferred

01:16:12.340 --> 01:16:16.180
back to Twin Falls fiscal year 2015.

01:16:16.180 --> 01:16:18.520
Second.

01:16:18.520 --> 01:16:22.720
We have motion on floor by Chris talking and seconded by Jim.

01:16:22.720 --> 01:16:25.280
My question, oh, Sean Barrier, go ahead.

01:16:25.280 --> 01:16:26.280
I'm sorry.

01:16:26.280 --> 01:16:28.440
So my question.

01:16:28.440 --> 01:16:31.560
So the funds that get transferred back to us next year,

01:16:31.560 --> 01:16:34.040
those are FAA funds that then go to Idaho Falls

01:16:34.040 --> 01:16:36.760
and they get transferred to us next year.

01:16:36.760 --> 01:16:40.200
So is this an issue that the, you mean the federal government

01:16:40.200 --> 01:16:42.240
doesn't have any money that they can't front the 200

01:16:42.240 --> 01:16:43.040
for Idaho Falls?

01:16:43.040 --> 01:16:44.640
Well, I think it's buckets.

01:16:44.640 --> 01:16:45.520
They have their bucket.

01:16:45.520 --> 01:16:46.720
We have ours.

01:16:46.720 --> 01:16:51.760
So can we transfer some money out of our entitlement funding?

01:16:51.760 --> 01:16:54.000
We typically get a million dollars this year.

01:16:54.000 --> 01:17:00.620
We only anticipate taking a grant for the architect's contract, which you'll be seeing shortly,

01:17:00.620 --> 01:17:01.620
to pay for that.

01:17:01.620 --> 01:17:06.020
And then we'll be carrying it over, designing the project, and when we go to construct, we'll

01:17:06.020 --> 01:17:07.860
be using these carryover funds.

01:17:07.860 --> 01:17:13.440
So the thinking is, let's move it from R about get to theirs, and then back to R. So I

01:17:13.440 --> 01:17:15.200
think that's how they probably work.

01:17:15.200 --> 01:17:20.360
And I'm all supportive for the Goodwill, and it just seemed like an odd request to me

01:17:20.360 --> 01:17:25.340
of transferring money around over the course of the next four months, but yeah, I think

01:17:25.340 --> 01:17:27.700
they have to account for those funds.

01:17:27.700 --> 01:17:28.700
Thank you.

01:17:28.700 --> 01:17:32.980
My question is a little bit different, and I know that you don't have a crystal ball,

01:17:32.980 --> 01:17:34.540
but what's the risk?

01:17:34.540 --> 01:17:40.450
I mean, could there be a chance that it won't be returned?

01:17:40.450 --> 01:17:44.610
Well, that's a good question and one that we articulate a little bit in the email in

01:17:44.610 --> 01:17:50.370
your packet, and I think it's a larger issue, that was my first question, what's the risk,

01:17:50.370 --> 01:17:55.650
And really, the larger issue is always with FAA funding is timing.

01:17:55.650 --> 01:17:58.050
The government seems to use continuing resolutions.

01:17:58.050 --> 01:18:01.650
They, authorization for funding sometimes gets delayed.

01:18:01.650 --> 01:18:04.370
Last year, I'm happy to say that it was a normal year.

01:18:04.370 --> 01:18:09.010
It's been many years since we've had a normal year with a full funding authorization.

01:18:09.010 --> 01:18:16.330
So we'll see if timing changes, but the ability to lose that 200,000 is probably not the issue.

01:18:16.330 --> 01:18:22.560
It's more when will those grant funds be authorized on a larger scale?

01:18:22.560 --> 01:18:24.880
There's always risk, right?

01:18:24.880 --> 01:18:28.880
Yeah, but from what I can tell here, that $200,000 will be returned.

01:18:28.880 --> 01:18:32.440
Idaho Falls and their city council, I think, are meeting on Thursday,

01:18:32.440 --> 01:18:37.120
and they will be executing their transfer agreement as well this week.

01:18:37.120 --> 01:18:39.220
That was your question, Mr. Grant.

01:18:39.220 --> 01:18:42.020
Any other questions?

01:18:42.020 --> 01:18:44.380
We have a roll call vote, please.

01:18:44.380 --> 01:18:46.310
Yes?

01:18:46.310 --> 01:18:47.550
Yes.

01:18:47.550 --> 01:18:49.140
Yes.

01:18:49.140 --> 01:18:53.700
Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Thank you Bill.

01:18:53.700 --> 01:18:54.700
Thank you Mayor.

01:18:54.700 --> 01:18:57.740
Next item on the agenda is request to adopt an ordinance

01:18:57.740 --> 01:19:00.580
for the Twin Falls school district and the city of Twin Falls

01:19:00.580 --> 01:19:05.580
for the annexation of 53.6 acres currently zoned R1 variable

01:19:06.180 --> 01:19:10.260
located on the east side of the 500, 600 and 700 block

01:19:10.260 --> 01:19:14.500
of Hankins Road North, also known as 3,200 east road.

01:19:14.500 --> 01:19:17.060
And we have Renee Caraway, welcome Renee.

01:19:17.060 --> 01:19:18.940
Good evening Mayor and Council.

01:19:18.940 --> 01:19:23.940
I was going to read that for you, so you didn't have to go through that, but now that you did...

01:19:23.940 --> 01:19:25.940
I took all your time, I'm sorry.

01:19:25.940 --> 01:19:29.940
Two more to do, so you can decide then.

01:19:29.940 --> 01:19:35.940
This is the final process to annex a piece of property into the city limits.

01:19:35.940 --> 01:19:45.940
Just a little background on July 8th of 2014, the commission did hold the public hearing to hear this request for annexation of this property.

01:19:45.940 --> 01:19:48.860
There was one person who did speak at the public hearing.

01:19:48.860 --> 01:19:50.780
This person stated that his property

01:19:50.780 --> 01:19:52.780
bordered the southern boundary of the property

01:19:52.780 --> 01:19:55.940
proposed for annexation, which is High Long Drive.

01:19:55.940 --> 01:19:58.180
His concern was whether he would be required

01:19:58.180 --> 01:20:02.780
to connect to city services if his well or subject system failed.

01:20:02.780 --> 01:20:06.420
Troy B. Tech, the city engineer, did respond to that question

01:20:06.420 --> 01:20:08.940
and indicate that if the property is annexed

01:20:08.940 --> 01:20:12.580
and his property is within 150 feet and his systems fail,

01:20:12.580 --> 01:20:16.180
he would in fact have to annex an internet.

01:20:16.180 --> 01:20:19.420
Upon conclusion of the public hearing, Commissioner Higgly

01:20:19.420 --> 01:20:22.700
made a motion to recommend the current zoning of R1 variable

01:20:22.700 --> 01:20:25.300
as an appropriate zoning designation.

01:20:25.300 --> 01:20:27.140
Commissioner Boyd seconded the motion,

01:20:27.140 --> 01:20:30.740
and all members present voted in favor of the zoning

01:20:30.740 --> 01:20:32.830
staying the same.

01:20:32.830 --> 01:20:37.950
On August 4, 2014, the City Council held a public hearing

01:20:37.950 --> 01:20:38.750
on the request.

01:20:38.750 --> 01:20:40.990
There was one person who had some questions

01:20:40.990 --> 01:20:44.630
about the future development of the school site.

01:20:44.630 --> 01:20:47.070
Brad Wills stated it was a premature

01:20:47.070 --> 01:20:48.790
to know the answer to those questions,

01:20:48.790 --> 01:20:50.330
but he would work on them

01:20:50.330 --> 01:20:53.470
as they were going through the design process.

01:20:53.470 --> 01:20:56.510
Upon conclusion of the public hearing and deliberation,

01:20:56.510 --> 01:20:58.790
Councilman Talkington made the motion

01:20:58.790 --> 01:21:01.110
to approve the request as presented,

01:21:01.110 --> 01:21:03.870
Councilman Berger seconded the motion

01:21:03.870 --> 01:21:06.630
and by a vote of six, four and one against.

01:21:06.630 --> 01:21:10.350
This Council voted to approve the request as presented.

01:21:10.350 --> 01:21:13.550
as directed by the council, staff has prepared an ordinance

01:21:13.550 --> 01:21:15.190
for your consideration this evening,

01:21:15.190 --> 01:21:17.590
that ordinance is in your packet,

01:21:17.590 --> 01:21:20.750
and staff does recommend that the council adopt the ordinance

01:21:20.750 --> 01:21:22.550
so it can be published and codified

01:21:22.550 --> 01:21:26.100
and the property be annexed into the city limits.

01:21:26.100 --> 01:21:26.940
Thank you, Renee.

01:21:26.940 --> 01:21:28.860
Do we have an ordinance number?

01:21:28.860 --> 01:21:30.220
3075.

01:21:30.220 --> 01:21:33.820
3075, and this will need to go to third and final on all three

01:21:33.820 --> 01:21:36.220
of these if we choose to adopt those this evening.

01:21:36.220 --> 01:21:39.780
Is that correct, Renee?

01:21:39.780 --> 01:21:41.100
Excuse me? Is that correct?

01:21:41.100 --> 01:22:11.060
I know that we held a couple of public hearings on this and we've asked for public comment, but since we made our decision last week, I've had a lot of feedback to the negative.

01:22:11.060 --> 01:22:18.630
for annexing this land and I'm just curious if I don't know how to make the

01:22:18.630 --> 01:22:23.870
public more informed in a timely matter so that they can have their opinion heard

01:22:23.870 --> 01:22:31.430
or what we can do to possibly I don't know I just I feel frustrated for the

01:22:31.430 --> 01:22:35.750
general person out there who doesn't understand our system and now they're

01:22:35.750 --> 01:22:39.430
feeling like we've made this decision without giving them a chance to speak

01:22:39.430 --> 01:22:44.430
which I've made it very clear that they had opportunity, but they felt like they weren't

01:22:44.430 --> 01:22:48.430
aware of those opportunities. And I guess I'm not really sure what I'm asking Renee. I just

01:22:48.430 --> 01:22:54.430
don't know. I feel really bad that there's been so much negative feedback on this issue.

01:22:54.430 --> 01:23:02.430
Two comments. One that we were asked to take a look at our notification process again,

01:23:02.430 --> 01:23:14.790
perhaps have signs bigger, perhaps out longer, maybe a little bit broader range of notification,

01:23:14.790 --> 01:23:19.910
make it easier for people to contact us if we can, and we are looking at that so that

01:23:19.910 --> 01:23:20.990
could help.

01:23:20.990 --> 01:23:29.960
I think the other issue with this specific annexation is there is a lot of public media

01:23:29.960 --> 01:23:36.480
on these properties that are coming through the process and people want to know development

01:23:36.480 --> 01:23:42.120
details and those aren't ready yet and that does make you a little bit anxious when you,

01:23:42.120 --> 01:23:44.040
especially when you live nearby.

01:23:44.040 --> 01:23:48.520
I think as time goes on and we go through the rest of the public process with the actual

01:23:48.520 --> 01:23:54.400
development of the site, for example, it will relieve concerns.

01:23:54.400 --> 01:23:55.720
Thank you.

01:23:55.720 --> 01:24:00.000
Before we go on to the next slide, just for my own edification, you say a lot of negative

01:24:00.000 --> 01:24:04.960
feedback or just so I understand and what was the negativity?

01:24:04.960 --> 01:24:06.320
Urban scroll.

01:24:06.320 --> 01:24:09.760
They don't think we should be moving to school that far out and they don't think we should

01:24:09.760 --> 01:24:13.360
be allowing the residential development around the school.

01:24:13.360 --> 01:24:14.760
And that's the comments I've been getting.

01:24:14.760 --> 01:24:20.800
I got a call on the radio last week and then I've had some emails.

01:24:20.800 --> 01:24:25.520
I don't know that a lot's the right word, but I have not heard anything positive.

01:24:25.520 --> 01:24:27.000
Everything I've heard has been negative.

01:24:27.000 --> 01:24:28.000
Thank you.

01:24:28.000 --> 01:24:29.000
Thank you for sharing that.

01:24:29.000 --> 01:24:33.000
Thank you, Mayor. I'd just like to maybe examine just a little bit closer.

01:24:33.000 --> 01:24:37.000
When we talk about notifying people of a public hearing,

01:24:37.000 --> 01:24:41.350
people, residents who are directly impacted by this

01:24:41.350 --> 01:24:45.350
annexation request, were notified, correct?

01:24:45.350 --> 01:24:49.350
People within 300 seat of the public hearing.

01:24:49.350 --> 01:24:53.350
They were given a letter in the mail. So people within 300 feet of this

01:24:53.350 --> 01:24:59.050
this developed with this idea were notified via the letter.

01:24:59.050 --> 01:25:00.450
It's standard letter.

01:25:00.450 --> 01:25:00.950
Standard letter.

01:25:00.850 --> 01:25:01.850
Right.

01:25:01.850 --> 01:25:06.450
So I would submit that the people who were directly impacted were notified properly.

01:25:06.450 --> 01:25:07.850
It had an opportunity to come forward.

01:25:07.850 --> 01:25:10.350
We had one come forward, right?

01:25:10.350 --> 01:25:13.550
I had some calls on the radio and we had, you know,

01:25:13.550 --> 01:25:17.250
there was one person that came forward at the commission hearing and one that came

01:25:17.250 --> 01:25:22.450
forward at the council, different people from North and South.

01:25:22.450 --> 01:25:28.090
Right now and like you indicated in as we progress I think it's really important to

01:25:28.090 --> 01:25:32.630
understand that annexation doesn't mean that we have a lot of things where the public

01:25:32.630 --> 01:25:38.370
could have an opportunity to chime in before the urban sprawl issues and residences closest

01:25:38.370 --> 01:25:40.370
to the school.

01:25:40.370 --> 01:25:45.610
We haven't had a lot of calls but we have had a couple with questions.

01:25:45.610 --> 01:25:51.450
We're not at liberty to disclose any types of site development plans at this point but we

01:25:51.450 --> 01:25:55.190
we have encouraged people to please come to the meetings,

01:25:55.190 --> 01:25:57.010
there is going to be a few coming up.

01:25:57.010 --> 01:25:58.530
And so.

01:25:58.530 --> 01:26:01.210
This will be completely vetted in a public process.

01:26:01.210 --> 01:26:02.210
Correct.

01:26:02.210 --> 01:26:05.200
Absolutely.

01:26:05.200 --> 01:26:07.960
Yeah, Mayor, I would just like to respond to Councilman.

01:26:07.960 --> 01:26:10.600
I think the problem in this one is not the neighbors

01:26:10.600 --> 01:26:13.320
that are impacted by it, but the general citizens who

01:26:13.320 --> 01:26:16.180
were not notified that they feel like because we're annexing

01:26:16.180 --> 01:26:18.880
land, it does affect them even though they're not

01:26:18.880 --> 01:26:21.680
in that neighborhood because the city is growing.

01:26:21.680 --> 01:26:25.160
And so this one was unique, and we haven't done a lot of annexation.

01:26:25.160 --> 01:26:28.520
And so I think that was the concern on this, not the neighborhood or where it was,

01:26:28.520 --> 01:26:32.480
but the fact that we are growing the city limits.

01:26:32.480 --> 01:26:35.920
I will just share with you, we haven't done a lot of annexation recently.

01:26:35.920 --> 01:26:38.920
A few years ago, we were doing hundreds of acres at a time.

01:26:38.920 --> 01:26:42.840
There's a lot of gray under this belong because of this time.

01:26:42.840 --> 01:26:44.960
So Jim, did you want to respond to that, Chris?

01:26:44.960 --> 01:26:46.000
No, no, I'm sorry.

01:26:46.000 --> 01:26:48.320
I was just going to make a motion.

01:26:48.320 --> 01:26:50.400
I've not had any negative response.

01:26:50.400 --> 01:26:56.240
I appreciate people's concern about annexation. The fact is, annexation hasn't paid for municipalities

01:26:56.240 --> 01:27:04.560
to do for a long time. And we don't willy-nilly annex. This is more in line with preparing for

01:27:04.560 --> 01:27:11.040
the continued growth of the city through new schools. There is a solution we can offer, though,

01:27:11.040 --> 01:27:16.800
for if there's enough swelling of questions. We simply don't put it on third and final

01:27:16.800 --> 01:27:21.560
of night, we could carry it through for the second hearing or the third hearing and sometimes

01:27:21.560 --> 01:27:22.560
the future.

01:27:22.560 --> 01:27:27.160
Probably could be notified if they want to show up, but we'd be happy to hear them.

01:27:27.160 --> 01:27:29.430
Point, thank you, Chris.

01:27:29.430 --> 01:27:30.430
Jim Munn.

01:27:30.430 --> 01:27:31.430
I thank you, Mayor.

01:27:31.430 --> 01:27:37.790
I'd like to suspend the rules and place Ordinance number 3075 on third and final reading by title

01:27:37.790 --> 01:27:39.490
only.

01:27:39.490 --> 01:27:40.490
Second.

01:27:40.490 --> 01:27:44.970
Have a motion on the floor by Jim Munn, seconded by Sean Berager as stated.

01:27:44.970 --> 01:27:47.330
Anything further on that motion council?

01:27:47.330 --> 01:27:58.260
I'll vote against it simply because I think I'd like to take another week to have another public hearing to have this public input that we've been hearing on that.

01:27:58.260 --> 01:28:00.260
I'm sorry Travis.

01:28:00.260 --> 01:28:10.260
I believe in order, because this is a land use question, the only way that you can do another public hearing is to go through the complete notification process.

01:28:10.260 --> 01:28:11.260
Okay.

01:28:11.260 --> 01:28:12.260
Well, forget about that.

01:28:12.260 --> 01:28:17.100
Because remember, this started with a public hearing, and I would imagine, since the Mayor

01:28:17.100 --> 01:28:21.780
closed the public hearing, and then staff was instructed to develop an ordinance, if you

01:28:21.780 --> 01:28:27.980
wanted to infuse additional public comment into this issue, we should probably and rightfully

01:28:27.980 --> 01:28:35.420
go through the entire public hearing process, which would mean the notifications, the postage

01:28:35.420 --> 01:28:42.780
of the signage, the submission of a advertisement for the legal to be able to move forward.

01:28:42.780 --> 01:28:46.380
We could, we could deliberate for additional hearings, but you're saying no additional

01:28:46.380 --> 01:28:47.380
public input.

01:28:47.380 --> 01:28:49.920
That is correct.

01:28:49.920 --> 01:28:52.720
Yes.

01:28:52.720 --> 01:28:53.720
Suzanne Hawkins.

01:28:53.720 --> 01:28:56.280
I just wanted to clarify, that wasn't the suggestion I was making.

01:28:56.280 --> 01:29:01.040
I just wanted to kind of talk about the process and since we're live and get the information

01:29:01.040 --> 01:29:04.000
aired for people, I think people did have a chance on this.

01:29:04.000 --> 01:29:10.660
I think it was posted on our agendas, and that you've called for public input multiple times.

01:29:10.660 --> 01:29:14.740
They've had two public hearings, so I'm not suggesting we need to do that.

01:29:14.740 --> 01:29:18.780
I was just wanting to make sure that the public knew that it is a two-way street and

01:29:18.780 --> 01:29:26.100
they need to be paying attention if they're really interested in what we're doing and when their chance to talk comes up that they're here.

01:29:26.100 --> 01:29:27.740
Very good, thank you, Susan.

01:29:27.740 --> 01:29:30.660
Anything further on the motion, Council?

01:29:30.660 --> 01:29:32.400
Lee, I love the roll call vote, please.

01:29:32.400 --> 01:29:33.440
Susan Hawkins?

01:29:33.440 --> 01:29:34.100
Yes.

01:29:34.100 --> 01:29:39.500
Jim Munn, Sean Berger, Chris Talkington, Don Hall.

01:29:39.500 --> 01:29:42.060
Yes, Motion passes five to zero.

01:29:42.060 --> 01:29:44.480
And Renee, I'm going to allow you to read the next one.

01:29:44.480 --> 01:29:46.580
I said she wanted to last time.

01:29:46.580 --> 01:29:49.220
I'm sorry, we have to, I'm sorry.

01:29:49.220 --> 01:29:50.740
You have to read the ordinance and then.

01:29:53.740 --> 01:29:59.700
An ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho, annexing a certain real property below described.

01:29:59.700 --> 01:30:07.820
providing the zoning classification, therefore, and ordering the necessary area of the impact of zoning district's amendment.

01:30:07.820 --> 01:30:09.140
Stand for a motion council.

01:30:09.140 --> 01:30:11.810
Move pass date to 37, aye.

01:30:11.810 --> 01:30:13.050
Second.

01:30:13.050 --> 01:30:17.010
We have a motion on the floor by Chris Togenden and seconded.

01:30:17.010 --> 01:30:18.370
Barely by Sean Berrick.

01:30:18.370 --> 01:30:20.330
Barely because I'm closer to you.

01:30:20.330 --> 01:30:21.610
Yeah, I got to my ear faster.

01:30:21.610 --> 01:30:25.780
Anything further on that motion council?

01:30:25.780 --> 01:30:26.420
Sean Berricker.

01:30:26.420 --> 01:30:33.420
One other comment I'll make in general, and I stated this last week when we had the public hearing,

01:30:33.420 --> 01:30:38.420
there are going to be a lot more pieces of this process as the school district moves forward,

01:30:38.420 --> 01:30:42.420
not only with this particular school, but the others that they're working on.

01:30:42.420 --> 01:30:49.420
And I would encourage the public to not only engage with what's happening at the city council and the planning and zoning level, but also with the school district.

01:30:49.420 --> 01:30:55.420
So for example, the school district is actually having an open house tomorrow night to talk about their schools

01:30:55.420 --> 01:31:00.580
those processes and if people have concerns I would encourage them to get involved in those.

01:31:00.580 --> 01:31:08.700
This is really one small step in a process for the new schools and it does address the

01:31:08.700 --> 01:31:14.460
broader issue of the community's growth and I appreciate that but I do think that we need

01:31:14.460 --> 01:31:20.180
to try to keep progress moving as the citizens are the ones who pass the bond to move forward

01:31:20.180 --> 01:31:24.220
with these schools we need to not stay in the way of that.

01:31:24.220 --> 01:31:31.920
I just want to chime in on this that a lot of folks have been looking at different directions

01:31:31.920 --> 01:31:35.600
of how the city should grow and where it's growing actually.

01:31:35.600 --> 01:31:42.800
And I would assume that the school district has really mapped out where those populations

01:31:42.800 --> 01:31:50.000
are going to be as they're looking at future sites for schools and they're wise in obtaining

01:31:50.000 --> 01:31:55.280
property in the right areas for future growth and this is just one of those situations where

01:31:55.280 --> 01:32:01.280
it's growing that direction and it kind of makes sense to me but again as stated many times this

01:32:01.280 --> 01:32:07.120
evening there's going to be plenty of more public input as this process goes on. Anything further

01:32:07.120 --> 01:32:14.080
on the motion council? Lee I have a real call vote on the ordinance. Jim Mann? Yes. Sean Baraker? Yes.

01:32:14.080 --> 01:32:26.480
Yes, Don Hall. Yes, Suzanne Hopkins. Yes, motion passes five to zero. Renee, I'll allow you to you want to read it for so I'll allow you to read the the next one.

01:32:27.200 --> 01:32:43.550
Thank you, Mayor Hall. This is a request for the Council to consider adoption of the ordinance on July 8th, 2014, the Commission held a public hearing for a zoning title amendment to delete Title 10 chapter 10.

01:32:43.550 --> 01:32:51.430
Off street parking and loading and replaced with the new title 10 chapter 10 off street parking and loading care of the City of Twin Falls

01:32:52.550 --> 01:33:01.090
At that public hearing there was no one who came to speak for or against this zoning title amendment and upon conclusion of the public hearing and

01:33:01.670 --> 01:33:07.710
Commission deliberations commission a gray made a motion to recommend approval to the City Council for request

01:33:07.710 --> 01:33:14.070
Commissioner, on August 4th, the City Council held a public hearing on this request whereby

01:33:14.070 --> 01:33:20.470
there was a unanimous vote that was granting approval of this zoning title amendment as presented

01:33:20.470 --> 01:33:22.750
as directed by the Council.

01:33:22.750 --> 01:33:25.710
Staff has prepared an ordinance for your consideration this evening.

01:33:25.710 --> 01:33:30.510
It is in your packet and staff has recommended the Council adopt the ordinance so it can be

01:33:30.510 --> 01:33:32.950
published and codified in code.

01:33:32.950 --> 01:33:33.950
Thank you.

01:33:33.950 --> 01:33:34.950
Thank you.

01:33:34.950 --> 01:33:36.950
Ordinance number, the other?

01:33:36.950 --> 01:33:37.950
3076.

01:33:37.950 --> 01:33:38.950
3076.

01:33:38.950 --> 01:33:49.170
I'll turn it over to council for questions and or a motion.

01:33:49.170 --> 01:33:50.170
Sean Berger.

01:33:50.170 --> 01:33:56.900
Mayor, I would move to suspend the rules in place ordinance 3076 on 3rd and final reading

01:33:56.900 --> 01:33:57.900
by title only.

01:33:57.900 --> 01:34:00.850
Second.

01:34:00.850 --> 01:34:03.580
We're a little hesitant tonight.

01:34:03.580 --> 01:34:10.900
We have a motion on the floor by Sean Berger, seconded by Jim Nein to, as stated, anything

01:34:10.900 --> 01:34:18.880
further on that motion council, Schomburger. Anything further on that motion council?

01:34:18.880 --> 01:34:20.640
Leila Rolkopo please.

01:34:20.640 --> 01:34:21.640
Schomburger?

01:34:21.640 --> 01:34:22.640
Yes.

01:34:22.640 --> 01:34:23.640
Chris Talkington?

01:34:23.640 --> 01:34:24.640
Yes.

01:34:24.640 --> 01:34:25.640
Don Hall?

01:34:25.640 --> 01:34:26.640
Yes.

01:34:26.640 --> 01:34:27.640
Suzanne Hopkins?

01:34:27.640 --> 01:34:28.640
Yes.

01:34:28.640 --> 01:34:29.640
Jim Munn.

01:34:29.640 --> 01:34:30.640
Yes.

01:34:30.640 --> 01:34:31.640
Motion passes 5-0.

01:34:31.640 --> 01:34:33.000
Could you read the ordinance or the title?

01:34:33.000 --> 01:34:34.000
Leila please.

01:34:34.000 --> 01:34:39.160
An ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho be peeling chapter 10 of

01:34:39.160 --> 01:34:45.580
The title 10 of the Twin Falls City Code, and in acting in a new chapter 10 of Title 10,

01:34:45.580 --> 01:34:50.010
the Twin Falls City Code, regulating off-street parking and loading.

01:34:50.010 --> 01:34:51.530
Thank you, Leila.

01:34:51.530 --> 01:34:52.690
Suzanne Hawkins.

01:34:52.690 --> 01:34:56.490
I move that we pass Ordinance 3076.

01:34:56.490 --> 01:34:58.530
Has read.

01:34:58.530 --> 01:34:59.490
Second.

01:34:59.490 --> 01:35:06.330
Motion on the floor by Suzanne Hawkins, seconded by Sean Berger to pass Ordinance 3076.

01:35:06.330 --> 01:35:06.930
Chris talking.

01:35:06.930 --> 01:35:08.450
I have a question, Renee.

01:35:08.450 --> 01:35:15.450
Is this upgrade our off street parking so far as the so-called semi problem that we had around Wal-Mart?

01:35:15.450 --> 01:35:17.450
That's in a different code section.

01:35:17.450 --> 01:35:19.450
That is a different code section.

01:35:19.450 --> 01:35:24.450
We are planning to bring you an update in September on how that new code amendments have started.

01:35:24.450 --> 01:35:28.450
I'd like to speak to that after this just a second, but thank you.

01:35:28.450 --> 01:35:29.450
You bet Chris.

01:35:29.450 --> 01:35:31.450
Anything further on the motion council?

01:35:31.450 --> 01:35:33.450
Lee aye of the roll call vote please?

01:35:33.450 --> 01:35:34.450
Chris Tocquenten?

01:35:34.450 --> 01:35:35.450
Yes.

01:35:35.450 --> 01:35:36.450
Don Hall?

01:35:36.450 --> 01:35:37.450
Yes.

01:35:37.450 --> 01:35:43.990
and Hawkins. Yes, Jim Munn. Yes, Sean Berger. Yes, motion passes five to zero. Chris talking

01:35:43.990 --> 01:35:50.290
to you. Driving around actually had our 50th class reunion this weekend. We were driving

01:35:50.290 --> 01:35:57.470
somewhere out there around Canyon, Crest, and I noticed a love meeting of a bunch of

01:35:57.470 --> 01:36:03.990
semis that were parking similar to the situation we had on Walmart some months ago. I think

01:36:03.990 --> 01:36:07.390
that they are relocating and refining places to park.

01:36:07.390 --> 01:36:09.070
And these are ones with the curtains up,

01:36:09.070 --> 01:36:10.550
and they're there for a while.

01:36:10.550 --> 01:36:13.830
So, the problem has not gone away, it's only moved.

01:36:13.830 --> 01:36:17.110
I will tell you, I just met with Sean this morning

01:36:17.110 --> 01:36:21.590
to discuss this issue, getting ready for our update to you.

01:36:21.590 --> 01:36:23.750
And he indicated he hasn't had any problems,

01:36:23.750 --> 01:36:25.430
there's been no complaints.

01:36:25.430 --> 01:36:31.350
And we often wonder when we prohibit an area for some place

01:36:31.350 --> 01:36:35.790
to something to occur and where are they going to go?

01:36:35.790 --> 01:36:38.070
So perhaps we'll kind of watch that.

01:36:38.070 --> 01:36:39.390
There may not be any complaints

01:36:39.390 --> 01:36:40.910
because it wasn't a developed area,

01:36:40.910 --> 01:36:43.190
but nonetheless it was on the public road.

01:36:43.190 --> 01:36:44.270
We'll go take a look.

01:36:44.270 --> 01:36:45.670
I'll send them up there.

01:36:45.670 --> 01:36:47.370
Renee, could you also,

01:36:47.370 --> 01:36:49.430
how do other communities handle this issue

01:36:49.430 --> 01:36:52.710
when we start tightening these issues down?

01:36:54.110 --> 01:36:56.390
I don't know if you could do some research or find out.

01:36:56.390 --> 01:36:58.030
Is there something we can do

01:36:58.030 --> 01:37:00.910
because these truckers need to stay somewhere?

01:37:00.910 --> 01:37:03.910
I can bring you some information.

01:37:03.910 --> 01:37:05.910
Sean actually has quite a bit of that.

01:37:05.910 --> 01:37:13.910
He did quite a bit of research, worked with Mitch pretty closely before we brought some of the proposals to you, some of the questions.

01:37:13.910 --> 01:37:18.910
So he'll have it in our presentation to you in September, for sure.

01:37:18.910 --> 01:37:19.910
Very good, because you know.

01:37:19.910 --> 01:37:21.910
Unless you want it earlier and we come next.

01:37:21.910 --> 01:37:23.910
I think I'm okay with that, as long as Council is.

01:37:23.910 --> 01:37:28.910
I just know that sometimes we think we're fixed with the problem, we can just displace it and put it somewhere else.

01:37:28.910 --> 01:37:30.160
I'm sorry.

01:37:30.160 --> 01:37:31.160
Sometimes.

01:37:31.160 --> 01:37:32.160
Very good.

01:37:32.160 --> 01:37:33.160
Thank you.

01:37:33.160 --> 01:37:35.400
Next time I'm on the agenda, I'll go ahead and read this one.

01:37:35.400 --> 01:37:40.320
There's a request to adopt an ordinance for the City of Twin Falls for the zoning title

01:37:40.320 --> 01:37:48.760
amendment City Code sections 10-4-8.3C regarding maximum building heights in the C1 District

01:37:48.760 --> 01:37:58.620
10-4-8.3D1 regarding site and rear setbacks in the C1 District 10-4-13.

01:37:58.620 --> 01:38:09.300
14.3C regarding requests for additional building height in the OT district and 10-7-3 regarding

01:38:09.300 --> 01:38:13.700
the approval process for request for additional building height.

01:38:13.700 --> 01:38:15.620
I should have had you do that, Renee.

01:38:15.620 --> 01:38:19.030
I'm glad you didn't.

01:38:19.030 --> 01:38:26.630
Again, this is the last process before zoning title amendment is adopted and codified.

01:38:26.630 --> 01:38:32.350
been through the public hearing process and is ready for an ordinance. On July 8th, the

01:38:32.350 --> 01:38:38.350
commission did hold a public hearing to amend the city code that would allow additional building

01:38:38.350 --> 01:38:46.990
height with some limiting restrictions. As presented, the commission did not have anybody that spoke

01:38:46.990 --> 01:38:53.230
for or against this amendment. Commissioner Gray did make a motion to approve, recommend

01:38:53.230 --> 01:38:56.510
to the council to approve this amendment as presented

01:38:56.510 --> 01:38:58.730
and Commissioner Munoz seconded.

01:38:58.730 --> 01:39:01.510
All members voted in support of forwarding this to you

01:39:01.510 --> 01:39:03.190
with a positive recommendation.

01:39:04.190 --> 01:39:07.270
August 4th, the city council held a public hearing

01:39:07.270 --> 01:39:08.830
on this request.

01:39:08.830 --> 01:39:12.350
There was no public comment and by a vote of five, four

01:39:12.350 --> 01:39:14.970
and one against the council granted approval

01:39:14.970 --> 01:39:16.770
of this amendment as presented.

01:39:17.990 --> 01:39:20.670
As directed by council staff has prepared an ordinance

01:39:20.670 --> 01:39:24.510
that is in your packet for you to have reviewed.

01:39:24.510 --> 01:39:28.550
And we're asking that the council adopt the ordinance tonight

01:39:28.550 --> 01:39:31.830
so that it can be codified and placed in code.

01:39:31.830 --> 01:39:32.670
Thank you, Renee.

01:39:32.670 --> 01:39:35.990
And I'm assuming 3077, ordinance 3077,

01:39:35.990 --> 01:39:41.600
turn it over to council for questions and or motion.

01:39:41.600 --> 01:39:44.080
Move to suspend the rules from place 37 to seven

01:39:44.080 --> 01:39:47.570
on third and final by title only.

01:39:47.570 --> 01:39:49.010
Second.

01:39:49.010 --> 01:39:50.850
We have a motion on the floor by Chris talking

01:39:50.850 --> 01:39:53.930
and seconded by Suzanne Hawkins as stated.

01:39:53.930 --> 01:39:57.020
Anything further on that motion council?

01:39:57.020 --> 01:39:58.740
Lee Eilah, roll call please.

01:39:58.740 --> 01:39:59.580
Don Hall?

01:39:59.580 --> 01:40:00.400
Yes.

01:40:00.400 --> 01:40:01.380
Suzanne Hawkins?

01:40:01.380 --> 01:40:02.220
Yes.

01:40:02.220 --> 01:40:03.060
Jim Munn?

01:40:03.060 --> 01:40:03.880
Yes.

01:40:03.880 --> 01:40:04.720
Sean Berriger?

01:40:04.720 --> 01:40:05.560
Yes.

01:40:05.560 --> 01:40:06.380
Chris Talking?

01:40:06.380 --> 01:40:07.220
Yes.

01:40:07.220 --> 01:40:08.260
Motion passes five to zero.

01:40:08.260 --> 01:40:11.130
Could you please read the title?

01:40:11.130 --> 01:40:13.050
In the ordinance of the city council of the city

01:40:13.050 --> 01:40:16.050
of Twin Falls, Idaho, amending Twin Falls city code

01:40:16.050 --> 01:40:32.130
sections 10, 4, 10-4-8.3, 10-4-13.3, and 10-7-3, permitting additional height in the C1 and OT zoning districts.

01:40:32.130 --> 01:40:35.130
Stand for a motion council.

01:40:35.130 --> 01:40:36.130
So moved.

01:40:36.130 --> 01:40:37.700
Second.

01:40:37.700 --> 01:40:42.700
I have a motion on the floor by Jim Mon, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins.

01:40:42.700 --> 01:40:44.700
Pass, ordinance 3077.

01:40:44.700 --> 01:40:47.730
I see no further lights.

01:40:47.730 --> 01:40:49.730
Lee, I have the roll call vote please.

01:40:49.730 --> 01:40:50.730
Suzanne Hawkins.

01:40:50.730 --> 01:40:51.730
Yes.

01:40:51.730 --> 01:40:52.730
Jim Mon.

01:40:52.730 --> 01:40:53.730
Yes.

01:40:53.730 --> 01:40:54.730
Schonberger.

01:40:54.730 --> 01:40:55.730
Yes.

01:40:55.730 --> 01:40:56.730
Chris Tockington.

01:40:56.730 --> 01:40:57.730
Yes.

01:40:57.730 --> 01:40:58.730
Don Hall.

01:40:58.730 --> 01:40:59.730
Yes.

01:40:59.730 --> 01:41:00.730
Motion passes five to zero.

01:41:00.730 --> 01:41:01.730
Thank you council.

01:41:01.730 --> 01:41:02.730
Thank you Renee.

01:41:02.730 --> 01:41:07.690
Next item on the agenda is discussion of the city of Twin Falls budget for the year

01:41:08.690 --> 01:41:09.890
2015

01:41:09.890 --> 01:41:17.090
The fiscal year 2015 and we have a traverse white brother our city manager as well as looks like Lori race

01:41:17.410 --> 01:41:19.410
Going to be presenting

01:41:20.250 --> 01:41:24.820
Or or or our other city manager he might come up as well

01:41:24.820 --> 01:41:25.820
This is all tonight.

01:41:25.820 --> 01:41:26.820
He is here tonight.

01:41:26.820 --> 01:41:27.820
Yes, sir.

01:41:27.820 --> 01:41:33.990
Mr. Mayor, members of the council, thank you for the opportunity to once again have a

01:41:33.990 --> 01:41:40.110
conversation about our budget that we have proposed for you for the upcoming year.

01:41:40.110 --> 01:41:44.910
We recognize that at the end of the last meeting, there were some questions about travel and

01:41:44.910 --> 01:41:50.470
training and we do have a series of responses towards travel and training.

01:41:50.470 --> 01:41:54.830
But what we want to do right now is we kind of want to just again touch upon the budget.

01:41:54.830 --> 01:41:59.150
There have been no deviations and no changes from the budgets that we presented to you last

01:41:59.150 --> 01:42:00.150
week.

01:42:00.150 --> 01:42:04.070
There are no changes in the valuations, and so everything that was presented to you last

01:42:04.070 --> 01:42:07.950
week remains true today.

01:42:07.950 --> 01:42:11.430
So one of the things that we want to take a look at is we want to really highlight and

01:42:11.430 --> 01:42:17.110
illustrate probably one of the most important questions that all citizens ask on the very

01:42:17.110 --> 01:42:18.110
front end.

01:42:18.110 --> 01:42:21.230
But how much is that going to cost?

01:42:21.230 --> 01:42:23.150
And that amount is illustrated here.

01:42:23.150 --> 01:42:28.990
And what's important is this is what we would often describe as a fully burdened cost for

01:42:28.990 --> 01:42:34.430
that average citizen within our community, an individual who has a home that is owner-occupied

01:42:34.430 --> 01:42:43.070
of $144,300, an individual who consumes about 18,000 gallons of water monthly and reaches

01:42:43.070 --> 01:42:49.870
the maximum cap of 8,000 gallons of sewer on a month and then is obviously part of our

01:42:49.870 --> 01:42:53.260
sanitation process.

01:42:53.260 --> 01:42:58.100
Those total costs are reflected below and you can see that that average resident in our

01:42:58.100 --> 01:43:05.580
community for the city portion is $19.36 or $1.62 per month.

01:43:05.580 --> 01:43:10.100
What's important to remember is as that number has ebbed in flowed,

01:43:10.100 --> 01:43:13.020
our spending piece has remained constant.

01:43:13.020 --> 01:43:20.580
The cause of the deviation or the variations is largely in response to our total community taxable value.

01:43:20.580 --> 01:43:26.420
Remember, that is a number that we can expect to continue to have some slight changes, and

01:43:26.420 --> 01:43:29.100
we illustrated what that was in the past.

01:43:29.100 --> 01:43:35.580
We get that final valuation number in December after we've completed that budget process, and

01:43:35.580 --> 01:43:44.260
after the county assessor has had his opportunity to complete his tasks.

01:43:44.260 --> 01:43:50.860
By illustration, you can see the total taxable value of this year compared to last year.

01:43:50.860 --> 01:43:54.180
And one of the things that's really interesting, and I don't think that we've taken a lot of

01:43:54.180 --> 01:44:00.040
time to point this out, but when you look at the total taxable value for fiscal year 2005,

01:44:00.040 --> 01:44:05.500
you see it as $2,228 million.

01:44:05.500 --> 01:44:14.420
The total new construction for the city of Twin Falls this year was $31 million.

01:44:14.420 --> 01:44:23.600
So if you add 31 to the $2,200,000,000, you can see without the new construction, there

01:44:23.600 --> 01:44:28.740
appears to be a net loss in total taxable value.

01:44:28.740 --> 01:44:31.180
And so there are a couple of explanations for that.

01:44:31.180 --> 01:44:35.940
Number one, the homeowners exemption has increased this year, which would account for

01:44:35.940 --> 01:44:37.300
some of that.

01:44:37.300 --> 01:44:42.380
The other is there is this sub-roll piece that we believe that might be understated.

01:44:42.380 --> 01:44:50.580
Remember, we spent some time in the past talking about a sub-roll and that number really is our best gas based upon historical trends.

01:44:50.580 --> 01:45:02.180
We've illustrated in the past how that sub-roll has grown the city's total taxable value by 32 million and it has also caused the city's taxable value to decrease in the past by 1.5.

01:45:02.180 --> 01:45:11.180
That is the range, and so any increases in the city's total taxable value is going to cause the tax rate to decline and

01:45:11.180 --> 01:45:18.020
declines in the total taxable value of the city would obviously cause it to increase.

01:45:18.020 --> 01:45:24.300
Based upon the best information that we know, that the tax rate illustrated here would be

01:45:24.300 --> 01:45:30.640
$7.93 per $1,000 of taxable value, and that is assuming that all of the numbers that remain

01:45:30.640 --> 01:45:31.800
unchanged.

01:45:31.800 --> 01:45:39.760
The only piece that we really have any influence directly over is the total government spending

01:45:39.760 --> 01:45:48.560
in the area of property tax dollars, that is the $17,662,302.

01:45:48.560 --> 01:45:52.240
It is important to recognize that the City of Twin Falls is not taking.

01:45:52.240 --> 01:45:55.840
It's 3%, like other communities and other entities do.

01:45:55.840 --> 01:46:04.640
We're taking roughly 0.8 of 1%, which is going to cause an increase to our foregone balance.

01:46:04.640 --> 01:46:07.960
We're anticipating our foregone balance at the conclusion of this fiscal year.

01:46:07.960 --> 01:46:11.080
will be approaching $1.8 million.

01:46:11.080 --> 01:46:12.760
One of the things that we're often asked

01:46:12.760 --> 01:46:17.160
is how does our total tax rate or tax burden compare

01:46:17.160 --> 01:46:20.440
in the city of Twin Falls based upon other communities?

01:46:20.440 --> 01:46:24.040
And this illustrates using the best information that we have.

01:46:24.040 --> 01:46:27.360
We take that total median value of those communities.

01:46:27.360 --> 01:46:30.080
We multiply it by the published tax rate.

01:46:30.080 --> 01:46:34.320
We receive that from the associated taxpayers of Idaho's

01:46:34.320 --> 01:46:35.360
website.

01:46:35.360 --> 01:46:37.640
And that is going to then multiply those two togethers

01:46:37.640 --> 01:46:41.160
produces what that total tax burden is.

01:46:41.160 --> 01:46:44.820
For fiscal year 2014, what we've done is we've applied what

01:46:44.820 --> 01:46:47.600
we believe to be in the anticipated tax rate.

01:46:47.600 --> 01:46:50.400
And you can see that the tax rate on the average home in Twin

01:46:50.400 --> 01:46:54.000
Falls is significantly lower than the average.

01:46:54.000 --> 01:46:58.200
As we've pointed out in the past, we don't illustrate Boise,

01:46:58.200 --> 01:47:02.000
nor do we illustrate Meridian because of their relationship

01:47:02.000 --> 01:47:04.560
with the AD County Highway District.

01:47:04.560 --> 01:47:10.720
We are responsible for all street maintenance activities since about 14% of our total budget.

01:47:10.720 --> 01:47:16.770
If you were to include them, they would be closer to the top of that list.

01:47:16.770 --> 01:47:24.490
What's important also is to take a look at our total budget by spending.

01:47:24.490 --> 01:47:32.730
And you can see that this budget has a total price tag of $57,082,189.

01:47:32.730 --> 01:47:38.370
We illustrated that in the past, a lot of that is coming from different sources.

01:47:38.370 --> 01:47:40.610
It's coming from increases in investment income.

01:47:40.610 --> 01:47:43.690
It's coming from increases in shared revenue.

01:47:43.690 --> 01:47:48.660
It's coming from increases in additional housing starts.

01:47:48.660 --> 01:47:51.180
We've also illustrated what's in grants.

01:47:51.180 --> 01:47:54.220
We've also illustrated what some of those expenditures equal.

01:47:54.220 --> 01:47:56.500
The blue represents those tax-supported funds.

01:47:56.500 --> 01:48:01.340
The red represents the enterprise funds or those utility-driven funds.

01:48:01.340 --> 01:48:05.780
We spent time talking about each of the major funds that impact our citizens.

01:48:05.780 --> 01:48:09.980
And we've illustrated that the water fund is balanced with a 2% rate adjustment or

01:48:09.980 --> 01:48:13.540
75 cents per month to our average resident.

01:48:13.540 --> 01:48:17.900
1% rate adjustment or 25 cents per month in the sewer.

01:48:17.900 --> 01:48:26.380
And also 19 cents per month or 1.11% increase associated with the sanitation fund.

01:48:26.380 --> 01:48:30.980
Which leads us to where we started, which is an illustration to the cost.

01:48:31.980 --> 01:48:33.980
Just to highlight and illustrate

01:48:35.380 --> 01:48:43.320
What our next steps are so tonight is really our last conversation before we have the public hearing the public hearing is scheduled for

01:48:43.700 --> 01:48:46.300
Next Monday night at six o'clock p.m

01:48:47.260 --> 01:48:53.020
Citizens will have the opportunity to come and have and share their thoughts about the budget

01:48:53.540 --> 01:48:56.860
Not only at that meeting, but we've also afforded that same opportunity

01:48:56.860 --> 01:49:02.440
opportunity the Council has by opening up the mic every single time we've had this conversation

01:49:02.440 --> 01:49:09.600
since the beginning of our process and our process started in March. So our citizens have

01:49:09.600 --> 01:49:13.800
had the opportunity to really come and I think that's something that we can celebrate

01:49:13.800 --> 01:49:20.360
and be proud of is our process has certainly been done in the full light of the community

01:49:20.360 --> 01:49:25.780
viewing process. Last week there were some questions regarding travel and training and

01:49:25.780 --> 01:49:29.620
If there are no questions specifically on the budget or other questions,

01:49:29.620 --> 01:49:34.880
we'd like to dive right into the information that we've prepared regarding

01:49:34.880 --> 01:49:37.140
travel and training in this year's budget.

01:49:37.140 --> 01:49:40.300
Does Council have any questions before we move into that section?

01:49:40.300 --> 01:49:42.980
I see no light, sir.

01:49:42.980 --> 01:49:52.930
Okay. I believe if you turn into your budget books approximately page 197.

01:49:52.930 --> 01:50:01.190
I want you to go.

01:50:01.190 --> 01:50:14.560
So what's really valuable about looking at pages 197 and forward is that it not only

01:50:14.560 --> 01:50:19.560
illustrates what is recommended in the budget on the far right, but it illustrates the budget

01:50:19.560 --> 01:50:27.560
of 2014 and then it also illustrates the actual expenditures made by the city in fiscal

01:50:27.560 --> 01:50:30.560
years 13, 12, and 11.

01:50:30.560 --> 01:50:35.560
And I think that history detail provides a lot of really good information because if you're

01:50:35.560 --> 01:50:40.000
that just year over year of budget, it may not tell the entire story.

01:50:40.000 --> 01:50:46.320
So we want to look in some cases in that section as we make this presentation tonight.

01:50:46.320 --> 01:50:52.840
In particular for the conversation, we're looking at line items that end in 447 and 449.

01:50:52.840 --> 01:50:57.080
And so those are going to be the areas specifically towards travel and training.

01:50:57.080 --> 01:51:00.760
And when you look at travel training and meetings, I think it's important to have a conversation

01:51:00.760 --> 01:51:04.320
about what is included in those items.

01:51:04.320 --> 01:51:08.520
So the first under travel is that is, well, that's what it is.

01:51:08.520 --> 01:51:10.560
It's the cost to get there.

01:51:10.560 --> 01:51:17.080
But it also includes the cost of transportation and lodging per DM.

01:51:17.080 --> 01:51:23.640
Any ground fair or ground transportation that is needed.

01:51:23.640 --> 01:51:27.240
And Lori's going to show you all of these, which is going to be good.

01:51:27.240 --> 01:51:32.040
This is a capture of all of that information starting on page 197.

01:51:32.040 --> 01:51:38.170
condensed it so that you can just look at those two line items in particular.

01:51:38.170 --> 01:51:47.330
Training describes just the cost of the tuition or the cost of the registration of that class.

01:51:47.330 --> 01:51:50.250
Meetings is a very wide catch term.

01:51:50.250 --> 01:51:53.650
The meeting may be something that we have locally in the community.

01:51:53.650 --> 01:51:58.130
It may be something that we go up to Boise and meet with our bond bank advisors.

01:51:58.130 --> 01:52:04.450
It may be something that we meet with legislative dignitaries, working through economic development

01:52:04.450 --> 01:52:12.190
deals, public-private partnerships, really that is the catch-all for when we have meetings.

01:52:12.190 --> 01:52:14.130
Community meetings also.

01:52:14.130 --> 01:52:16.890
And those are all of the open houses that we may have.

01:52:16.890 --> 01:52:21.650
And so, or the community sponsor, so when we are moving forward with a citizen's wastewater

01:52:21.650 --> 01:52:26.650
committee, one of the things that we do to try to make sure that they're coming on their

01:52:26.650 --> 01:52:34.010
lunch hours to at least buy them a sack lunch. And so part of that is also the meals. Under

01:52:34.010 --> 01:52:39.610
the meetings is where we also pay for all of the meals associated with all of the different

01:52:39.610 --> 01:52:45.490
advisory groups, committees, committee work groups. When we have an open house in the evening

01:52:45.490 --> 01:52:53.000
and we buy punch in cookies, it comes out of those same line items.

01:52:53.000 --> 01:52:58.000
To give you an idea, in fiscal year 2013, we spent approximately $13,000.

01:52:58.000 --> 01:53:00.000
May I stop you there just real quick?

01:53:00.000 --> 01:53:06.000
I think it's important for folks to realize that we have several advisory committees and

01:53:06.000 --> 01:53:15.000
commissions, and that these are all volunteer positions, and we treasure the input we get

01:53:15.000 --> 01:53:18.000
from these committees, because they're our citizens.

01:53:18.000 --> 01:53:20.760
And for us to, I'm just going to say how I feel about it.

01:53:20.760 --> 01:53:26.120
For us to buy them a sack lunch, for them to volunteer the hours that they do for us,

01:53:26.120 --> 01:53:29.520
I think is a small payment towards that.

01:53:29.520 --> 01:53:35.840
We certainly come out far ahead for the information and the work that we get in return.

01:53:35.840 --> 01:53:40.800
And the community engagement of what we're trying to accomplish with these commissions.

01:53:40.800 --> 01:53:46.040
So when you take a look at the total general fund in fiscal year 2014, and you compare

01:53:46.040 --> 01:53:51.200
that the fiscal year 2015 that is proposed in this budget you'll see that

01:53:51.200 --> 01:53:57.400
there's a $51,055 increase in the tax-supported funds and a 60 in a total

01:53:57.400 --> 01:54:00.420
increase of $66,125.

01:54:00.420 --> 01:54:02.880
And where is that all funds?

01:54:02.880 --> 01:54:16.280
Information that we might have.

01:54:16.280 --> 01:54:20.280
So at the very very bottom you're going to see all funds right there and you're

01:54:20.280 --> 01:54:26.080
going to see that that is the total increase of fiscal year 15 over fiscal

01:54:26.080 --> 01:54:30.080
year 2014, $66,125.

01:54:30.080 --> 01:54:31.850
Proposed.

01:54:31.850 --> 01:54:32.850
Proposed.

01:54:32.850 --> 01:54:33.850
That's right.

01:54:33.850 --> 01:54:38.200
Because this budget has yet to be adopted.

01:54:38.200 --> 01:54:41.200
So this is what we're proposing right now.

01:54:41.200 --> 01:54:44.200
Is that level of increase?

01:54:44.200 --> 01:54:50.200
So Travis Mann, this is proposed this year versus proposed last year.

01:54:50.200 --> 01:54:51.200
That's right.

01:54:51.200 --> 01:54:52.200
Not actual.

01:54:52.200 --> 01:54:53.200
Not actual.

01:54:53.200 --> 01:54:58.920
And so one of the reasons that you're asking is why are you proposing a larger increase

01:54:58.920 --> 01:55:04.880
and what we want to do through that first introductory is kind of set the stage by telling you there's

01:55:04.880 --> 01:55:07.350
not one reason.

01:55:07.350 --> 01:55:12.390
There are at least five reasons that the members of the city's leadership team and they're all

01:55:12.390 --> 01:55:16.470
in the audience and they're here specifically to answer specific questions that you may have

01:55:16.470 --> 01:55:19.390
about their specific training line items.

01:55:19.390 --> 01:55:22.830
We'll also have individuals specifically come up as some of the areas that have been mentioned

01:55:22.830 --> 01:55:27.150
in the past to talk about what is causing some of those increases.

01:55:27.150 --> 01:55:37.710
So if Lori could go back to the very first one, which is going to be the City Council,

01:55:37.710 --> 01:55:43.110
one, there are five reasons that we really wanted to point out that is driving the overall

01:55:43.110 --> 01:55:44.110
cost.

01:55:44.110 --> 01:55:50.910
Number one is making sure that the actual expenditures are reflected inside of the budget.

01:55:50.910 --> 01:55:55.750
We felt that it is important that when you look at year over year and if you have history

01:55:55.750 --> 01:56:01.670
telling you that you have not been containing your spending within the authorized amounts,

01:56:01.670 --> 01:56:04.390
we probably should reflect reality.

01:56:04.390 --> 01:56:07.590
Number two, we're adding new employees into the organization.

01:56:07.590 --> 01:56:11.910
We believe it's important to provide them training and also maintain training for the

01:56:11.910 --> 01:56:17.990
third group which is certifications and recertifications of our employees.

01:56:17.990 --> 01:56:23.230
We also are meeting and having more public involvement and we are also changing our meeting time

01:56:23.230 --> 01:56:30.410
which is influencing the number of meals and the number of opportunities that we're trying

01:56:30.410 --> 01:56:31.930
to engage the community.

01:56:31.930 --> 01:56:36.110
And so we're seeing a little bit larger expenditure there.

01:56:36.110 --> 01:56:40.810
And then the fifth is there are still some areas that we're trying to restore in terms

01:56:40.810 --> 01:56:45.190
of training budgets comparison to where we were in the past.

01:56:45.190 --> 01:56:52.280
Tonight, we're going to have a series of individuals talk about their particular areas

01:56:52.280 --> 01:56:57.620
and ones that stood out to us, because each one of them really present a different piece

01:56:57.620 --> 01:57:01.780
of that story. I'm going to talk about two of them really, really quick, and then I'm

01:57:01.780 --> 01:57:07.500
going to turn it over to Lori, who's going to talk to Susan, and then John, and then Brian,

01:57:07.500 --> 01:57:11.490
and they're all going to go forward and have the conversation.

01:57:11.490 --> 01:57:15.890
So in looking at the top, you look at the actual expenditures, you can see that in the

01:57:15.890 --> 01:57:23.450
past and in the actuals, it is important to recognize and to capture that the spending

01:57:23.450 --> 01:57:25.750
reflect the amount that is budgeted.

01:57:25.750 --> 01:57:32.830
And so if you were only to look at the adopted budget in comparison to the proposed budget,

01:57:32.830 --> 01:57:37.050
it does not necessarily reflect what was going on in reality.

01:57:37.050 --> 01:57:39.330
We think it is important to reflect that.

01:57:39.330 --> 01:57:43.130
So that covers that first one, making sure that the actual expenditures that are being

01:57:43.130 --> 01:57:48.970
made reflect the amounts that we're budgeting and largely that's because this

01:57:48.970 --> 01:57:54.370
council is very engaged in the Association of Idaho Cities it is engaged

01:57:54.370 --> 01:57:59.250
in other activities associated with our community and because of that engagement

01:57:59.250 --> 01:58:04.770
we've seen an increase that engagement really began in 2012 and it carries

01:58:04.770 --> 01:58:10.570
forward today that engagement is reflected in the proposed budget for

01:58:10.570 --> 01:58:17.580
fiscal year 2015. The next one is to look at the city manager's budget and under the city

01:58:17.580 --> 01:58:22.460
manager's budget if you were to roll back the clock and you were to say what was the city

01:58:22.460 --> 01:58:29.660
manager's budget in 2006 and what is it today and why has it grown so much it falls under

01:58:29.660 --> 01:58:34.820
the next category and that is the number of different employees that we've added under

01:58:34.820 --> 01:58:40.260
the city manager's umbrella over that period of time. In that period of time we've added

01:58:40.260 --> 01:58:46.980
a public information officer. We've added a grant writer. You've added at one time an

01:58:46.980 --> 01:58:51.380
assistant city manager, an assistant too, and we're having conversations and we've always

01:58:51.380 --> 01:58:56.620
had conversations about continuing to move forward with refilling that position after we

01:58:56.620 --> 01:59:02.900
complete our look at our organizational structure to determine what makes sense. The increase

01:59:02.900 --> 01:59:07.420
associated in this budget, especially in travel and trainings, is largely because when

01:59:07.420 --> 01:59:11.920
that we brought on, we also have a new one, too, Shane,

01:59:11.920 --> 01:59:14.940
who's now our deputy city prosecutor,

01:59:14.940 --> 01:59:18.180
falls under the city manager's umbrella as well.

01:59:18.180 --> 01:59:19.740
And one of the things that we wanted to do

01:59:19.740 --> 01:59:21.960
is we wanted to make sure that we're providing

01:59:21.960 --> 01:59:24.100
appropriate training and training opportunities.

01:59:24.100 --> 01:59:29.100
And so you will see a $1,500 increase for travel in meetings,

01:59:30.260 --> 01:59:33.340
excuse me, a $3,500 increase in travel in meetings

01:59:33.340 --> 01:59:36.460
for Josh and for Mandy and for other types of training

01:59:36.460 --> 01:59:38.380
because we're adding new employees,

01:59:38.380 --> 01:59:41.580
and you will see that throughout our organization,

01:59:41.580 --> 01:59:44.260
that based upon adding employees,

01:59:44.260 --> 01:59:48.780
we wanna continue to make sure that we require them

01:59:48.780 --> 01:59:51.420
to come with us with a collection of tools.

01:59:51.420 --> 01:59:54.700
We wanna make sure that they're maintaining those tools,

01:59:54.700 --> 01:59:57.700
because one of the main driving forces of this budget

01:59:57.700 --> 02:00:00.780
was, again, to ensure that we continue the pursuit

02:00:00.780 --> 02:00:03.860
of innovative strategies and to find more efficient

02:00:03.860 --> 02:00:05.340
and more effective outcomes.

02:00:05.340 --> 02:00:11.460
we believe that occurs through travel and training of our employees.

02:00:11.460 --> 02:00:15.860
To cover some of the other areas and then to provide a quick wrap up, I'm going to turn

02:00:15.860 --> 02:00:21.100
it over to Lori and she's going to start and then we'll just kind of go through that process

02:00:21.100 --> 02:00:22.700
unless there are other questions.

02:00:22.700 --> 02:00:25.460
Just a real quick question and maybe it's going to be covered by the other individuals

02:00:25.460 --> 02:00:26.460
coming up.

02:00:26.460 --> 02:00:33.980
But some of the questions have been from Council, Council is the training itself and maybe we can

02:00:33.980 --> 02:00:39.420
address is can it be done more locally instead of you're going to talk about that.

02:00:39.420 --> 02:00:40.420
Thank you.

02:00:40.420 --> 02:00:43.240
Welcome, Lori.

02:00:43.240 --> 02:00:44.240
Thank you.

02:00:44.240 --> 02:00:50.900
So what is an explanation from your CFO without a chart or a graph?

02:00:50.900 --> 02:00:56.940
So I just wanted to visit with you about the history of travel and training and finance

02:00:56.940 --> 02:01:01.040
about our new personnel and about the benefits of the training.

02:01:01.040 --> 02:01:08.160
So this is actual travel and training dollars spent, beginning with 2007, and I would just

02:01:08.160 --> 02:01:14.400
like to point out that the dollars in 7, 8, and 9 were really for just one individual.

02:01:14.400 --> 02:01:16.800
It was travel and training for one individual.

02:01:16.800 --> 02:01:22.760
Now that also included a day trip to the Associated Taxpayers' Vitahole.

02:01:22.760 --> 02:01:29.880
And it also included a trip to Portland for our finance software conference.

02:01:29.880 --> 02:01:36.040
pretty much the substantive training was for one individual. In 2010 you'll see a

02:01:36.040 --> 02:01:40.840
pretty big decrease there. Well in December of that fiscal year I was appointed to

02:01:40.840 --> 02:01:44.960
the position of CFO and it's not that I didn't think training was important I

02:01:44.960 --> 02:01:50.940
just had other things going on. So in 11 now you've got a new CFO you've got a

02:01:50.940 --> 02:01:55.660
new assistant finance director and a new budget coordinator. Within a couple

02:01:55.660 --> 02:02:02.460
years time, I had a new budget coordinator and then a brand new account specialist.

02:02:02.460 --> 02:02:11.170
So an individual that really he had good financial skills but no background in governmental accounting.

02:02:11.170 --> 02:02:16.900
So we've got a history of not a lot of training and finance.

02:02:16.900 --> 02:02:21.460
I've got a lot of new bodies in there and I want to share with you the benefits that

02:02:21.460 --> 02:02:24.020
I've seen from the training.

02:02:24.020 --> 02:02:30.940
So because of the training, we now have written formalized financial policies.

02:02:30.940 --> 02:02:33.140
We did not have those before.

02:02:33.140 --> 02:02:37.760
We approach bonding much differently than we have in the past.

02:02:37.760 --> 02:02:43.720
We now opt for a competitive sale where appropriate as opposed to a negotiated sale, and that is

02:02:43.720 --> 02:02:49.530
a best practice and assures us we'll be getting the best interest rates possible.

02:02:49.530 --> 02:02:56.130
I've attended training on building a CAFRA, which is a comprehensive annual financial report,

02:02:56.130 --> 02:03:00.930
public funds investing, and economic development for finance directors.

02:03:00.930 --> 02:03:07.810
And my team has attended budget analysis, building a better budget document, intermediate governmental

02:03:07.810 --> 02:03:08.810
accounting.

02:03:08.810 --> 02:03:15.050
And this year we had folks going to the National GFOA Conference in Minnesota.

02:03:15.050 --> 02:03:19.170
We got scholarships to do that because we were first time attendees.

02:03:19.170 --> 02:03:24.860
So we received three scholarships that amounted to almost $500 a piece.

02:03:24.860 --> 02:03:31.300
So this GFOA training, it's very specific to governmental entities.

02:03:31.300 --> 02:03:37.580
And it really goes hand in hand with Travis's ICMA training and best practices.

02:03:37.580 --> 02:03:43.140
So we try to take online training and we try to be more localized.

02:03:43.140 --> 02:03:47.980
We've gone to Seattle, Portland, and Salt Lake City.

02:03:47.980 --> 02:03:55.780
And I know that we're on an upward binge, it looks like, but I really believe that with

02:03:55.780 --> 02:04:02.380
what we have left in fiscal year 2014, we'll be almost to the $11,000 we're asking for

02:04:02.380 --> 02:04:03.820
next year.

02:04:03.820 --> 02:04:10.940
And I don't want to let seven people not continue to receive training.

02:04:10.940 --> 02:04:16.540
I see huge benefit for the city and the things that we've learned and we're trying to implement.

02:04:16.540 --> 02:04:20.140
So I would be happy to answer any questions you might have.

02:04:20.140 --> 02:04:24.640
Do we have any questions for Lori?

02:04:24.640 --> 02:04:26.640
Your graphs must have just dazzled us.

02:04:26.640 --> 02:04:27.640
I'm right.

02:04:27.640 --> 02:04:28.640
Good job.

02:04:28.640 --> 02:04:33.330
I think I'm tag teaming to Susan now.

02:04:33.330 --> 02:04:34.730
Well, you're a person now.

02:04:34.730 --> 02:04:35.730
I'm not an accountant.

02:04:35.730 --> 02:04:36.730
Well, Susan.

02:04:36.730 --> 02:04:37.730
Thank you.

02:04:37.730 --> 02:04:39.330
Good evening, Marin Council.

02:04:39.330 --> 02:04:44.570
Thank you for the opportunity to respond to any questions that you may have regarding

02:04:44.570 --> 02:04:47.770
the travel and training budget in the HR department.

02:04:47.770 --> 02:04:54.690
It was noted last week that that line item shows an increase for next year of 100%.

02:04:54.690 --> 02:04:55.690
That's true.

02:04:55.690 --> 02:05:03.770
I requested an additional $2,000, which would bring the total for the line item to $4,000.

02:05:03.770 --> 02:05:09.490
As I was preparing the request for the budget, several factors were taken into consideration

02:05:09.490 --> 02:05:11.250
for that increase.

02:05:11.250 --> 02:05:20.330
First, HR staff is either frequently, either directly or indirectly involved in programs

02:05:20.330 --> 02:05:27.870
regarding regulations or programs that affect the entire organization.

02:05:27.870 --> 02:05:31.870
A good example of this is the Affordable Care Act.

02:05:31.870 --> 02:05:42.050
The Affordable Care Act came out with in excess of 2,400 pages of regulations.

02:05:42.050 --> 02:05:50.130
It is imperative that we know what we need to do in order to comply to avoid penalties

02:05:50.130 --> 02:05:53.250
for noncompliance.

02:05:53.250 --> 02:06:00.010
Number two, it's not uncommon for the HR department to assist other departments in their training.

02:06:00.010 --> 02:06:05.890
The other line item that we have is the personnel training and I have $5,000.

02:06:05.890 --> 02:06:14.450
If you look back historically that line item actually decreased 100% several years ago and

02:06:14.450 --> 02:06:21.530
we use funds in that account to augment other departments who have an unexpected training

02:06:21.530 --> 02:06:22.930
opportunity.

02:06:22.930 --> 02:06:29.970
We use funds in that account to bring training programs to the organization for everyone.

02:06:29.970 --> 02:06:34.210
In May of this year, we actually used funds in that account

02:06:34.210 --> 02:06:37.010
to send 37 people.

02:06:37.010 --> 02:06:41.330
There was a nationally, a national leadership conference

02:06:41.330 --> 02:06:49.980
held in Atlanta, because it was magically a simulcast

02:06:49.980 --> 02:06:52.420
here in Twin Falls via satellite.

02:06:52.420 --> 02:06:58.980
We were able to send 37 people to that national conference.

02:06:58.980 --> 02:07:05.980
webinars and internet training are used whenever possible. You may recall that the

02:07:05.980 --> 02:07:12.980
iCrimp discount training program, we've participated the last two years. We will do so in the future

02:07:12.980 --> 02:07:19.980
by our employees, our supervisors and council members participating in that online training

02:07:19.980 --> 02:07:27.980
program. The city's actually saved $37,423 on our insurance liability premiums.

02:07:27.980 --> 02:07:36.780
The third, the additional $2,000 requests for next year's training and travel is primarily

02:07:36.780 --> 02:07:40.900
driven by one training opportunity that I support.

02:07:40.900 --> 02:07:46.420
Each year the Society for Human Resource Professionals, you may hear it referred to as

02:07:46.420 --> 02:07:49.700
SHIRM, holds an annual conference.

02:07:49.700 --> 02:07:56.690
In June of 2015, that conference will be held in Las Vegas, Nevada, so as not to think it's

02:07:56.690 --> 02:08:03.470
just another conference in another fun city, no one from the HR department has ever attended

02:08:03.470 --> 02:08:10.870
a national conference. So why now you may ask, professional certification in HR requires

02:08:10.870 --> 02:08:21.150
60 CEUs in a three-year period. Only 20 of those CEUs can be obtained by webinars by

02:08:21.150 --> 02:08:28.470
By attending one three day conference in Las Vegas, we can obtain 25 CEUs towards that

02:08:28.470 --> 02:08:31.720
professional certification.

02:08:31.720 --> 02:08:39.720
As a note, the Sherm conference that was held in the fall in Twin Falls was not accredited

02:08:39.720 --> 02:08:46.160
so while there was attendance by staff, there were no CEUs obtained.

02:08:46.160 --> 02:08:52.240
In conclusion, I've prepared the city's HR budget for 20 plus years and have always taken

02:08:52.240 --> 02:08:58.080
a fiscal conservative approach in doing so. Never losing sight of the fact that we are

02:08:58.080 --> 02:09:06.910
spending taxpayers money. Looking back, you'll see that the HR budget has increased and it's

02:09:06.910 --> 02:09:15.800
decreased based on the needs of the department and financial constraints. The requested HR

02:09:15.800 --> 02:09:22.800
budget for fiscal year 2014-15, including this travel and training line item is no exception.

02:09:22.800 --> 02:09:24.630
Any questions?

02:09:24.630 --> 02:09:27.630
Do we have any questions for Susan?

02:09:27.630 --> 02:09:31.910
Susan, I have a question for you.

02:09:31.910 --> 02:09:36.910
You stated that you've never gone to the national conference.

02:09:36.910 --> 02:09:39.910
Your team, you, why?

02:09:39.910 --> 02:09:46.910
The year that I was slated to go to the conference was the year that the economy went bad.

02:09:46.910 --> 02:09:52.350
bad, and travel and training was cut, and I think justifiably so.

02:09:52.350 --> 02:09:53.350
Sure.

02:09:53.350 --> 02:10:03.130
But all the other subsequent years before and recently, is it possible that we were all

02:10:03.130 --> 02:10:08.810
raised under a gentleman that actually has a park named after him as a conservation park?

02:10:08.810 --> 02:10:11.570
And we're just conservative and we try to-

02:10:11.570 --> 02:10:18.980
I think we are conservative, I think we were, and I think we continue to be so.

02:10:18.980 --> 02:10:25.980
we can get things online. We have training manuals. I just never went to a conference.

02:10:25.980 --> 02:10:32.980
I've obviously attended some other conferences. I've just never attended the National Conference.

02:10:32.980 --> 02:10:40.300
Well, I just want to say personally, thank you for your frugal nature, but you need training.

02:10:40.300 --> 02:10:44.300
So I appreciate that you put it in this year. Thank you.

02:10:44.300 --> 02:10:57.100
Mr. Keaton welcome sir. Thank you. I'll be speaking to obviously public works and engineering

02:10:57.100 --> 02:11:02.140
tonight. There's a few other I think are fairly straightforward but if you have questions

02:11:02.140 --> 02:11:07.840
please. So there's new personnel in the engineering department this year there'll be two more

02:11:07.840 --> 02:11:18.400
engineers which require professional development hours and engineering did increase a little.

02:11:18.400 --> 02:11:24.340
Biggest increase in public works is wastewater collection, thank you.

02:11:24.340 --> 02:11:33.970
And I believe it was right around 300%.

02:11:33.970 --> 02:11:40.850
Okay, 200, oh my God, water.

02:11:40.850 --> 02:11:49.850
The biggest change increases here for wastewater is due to a single training event that I'd like

02:11:49.850 --> 02:11:50.850
us to do this year.

02:11:50.850 --> 02:11:58.090
And it's a sewer condition assessment and basically we go out and we TV sewer all over

02:11:58.090 --> 02:12:05.050
the city, you know, that we do, it's, the purpose is to do preventative maintenance.

02:12:05.050 --> 02:12:09.570
For years and years we've done this and when we have a project specific to a pipe, we can

02:12:09.570 --> 02:12:13.970
pull that video and we know where people's services are and we know the condition.

02:12:13.970 --> 02:12:16.290
We can decide the best way to fix it.

02:12:16.290 --> 02:12:22.170
For example, we've talked about that, that CIPP pipe that you inflate and you can use

02:12:22.170 --> 02:12:26.970
that video to help you decide the best and most appropriate repair.

02:12:26.970 --> 02:12:31.970
We've done that for years and it's been great, but we haven't been able to do and has been

02:12:31.970 --> 02:12:39.050
implemented since 1998 as an international assessment system and it was developed in the

02:12:39.050 --> 02:12:45.370
United Kingdom and it's significant because it's standardized how people look at PIPE and

02:12:45.370 --> 02:12:50.450
how they describe a crack so we can have some consistency and the reason that's important

02:12:50.450 --> 02:12:53.770
is because of all the automation and software that comes out.

02:12:53.770 --> 02:12:56.330
We can now score PIPES.

02:12:56.330 --> 02:13:01.490
Now when we look at the whole city, we can start to develop scores for pipes, a scoring

02:13:01.490 --> 02:13:04.970
system, rating, and we can start to prioritize our work.

02:13:04.970 --> 02:13:10.150
It's all part of the asset management tool.

02:13:10.150 --> 02:13:13.990
So again, not to diminish what we've done in the past.

02:13:13.990 --> 02:13:18.150
It's served its useful purpose and continues to do so, but we need to get it to the next

02:13:18.150 --> 02:13:20.350
level so we can optimize our dollars.

02:13:20.350 --> 02:13:26.710
So the waste water collection training event is an event that I think Mr. Mayor, you were

02:13:26.710 --> 02:13:31.310
asking about bringing local training, I'm trying to do that.

02:13:31.310 --> 02:13:33.790
That single event depends on where it is.

02:13:33.790 --> 02:13:39.310
There's only 11 trainers in the United States, so the training is all over the U.S. The next

02:13:39.310 --> 02:13:45.590
training event that I'm more of that's in our region is in Las Vegas.

02:13:45.590 --> 02:13:52.510
It's $900 per person, not including travel, so it's probably $1,500 when all is said and

02:13:52.510 --> 02:13:53.510
done.

02:13:53.510 --> 02:13:59.740
And we should probably train at least three people, me being one of them.

02:13:59.740 --> 02:14:03.600
I've contacted the trainer, it was a master trainer in our region.

02:14:03.600 --> 02:14:07.640
I asked her if she could investigate what it would take to get a class here.

02:14:07.640 --> 02:14:13.920
She explained that it just takes five participants for a certified class and she would advertise

02:14:13.920 --> 02:14:15.480
to see if we can get the class locally.

02:14:15.480 --> 02:14:18.960
So that'll help, but it's not certain if we're going to get it.

02:14:18.960 --> 02:14:24.060
So I think we need to budget for travel, just in case.

02:14:24.060 --> 02:14:28.450
So I probably spend enough time on wastewater collection.

02:14:28.450 --> 02:14:32.630
Is there any other questions in public works?

02:14:32.630 --> 02:14:39.510
Well, I just, there's certain certifications in the like that some of your team have to

02:14:39.510 --> 02:14:44.870
have, and they have to have training, so much training, can you enlighten us on that?

02:14:44.870 --> 02:14:45.870
Yes, thank you.

02:14:45.870 --> 02:14:54.110
So just like engineers, there's required training for certified operators, .6 CEUs per year,

02:14:54.110 --> 02:14:56.710
which is six hours of training a year.

02:14:56.710 --> 02:15:02.370
And some of the training is free, but there's travel with it sometimes.

02:15:02.370 --> 02:15:06.170
And sometimes it's local, but the class isn't free.

02:15:06.170 --> 02:15:09.690
We also like to, so we try to get as much free training as we can.

02:15:09.690 --> 02:15:13.250
And every about two, three years, probably about we're on a three-year rotation, we like

02:15:13.250 --> 02:15:21.760
to send a person to an actual convention, not a convention, but a conference. Thank you.

02:15:21.760 --> 02:15:25.760
And that allows for that.

02:15:25.760 --> 02:15:31.370
Some of these positions have to be certified, though. Is that, is there some?

02:15:31.370 --> 02:15:37.370
Yes, all by state code, water operators have to have a certification, a license.

02:15:37.370 --> 02:15:40.370
And wastewater operators also have to have a license.

02:15:40.370 --> 02:15:44.770
don't have folks in those positions with those certifications is their fine fines

02:15:44.770 --> 02:15:52.290
that are attributed. There is the DEQ they have I'm trying to remember

02:15:52.290 --> 02:15:56.230
specifically what it says but they have tools that they can use to enforce

02:15:56.230 --> 02:16:00.950
licensure. Okay lots of different options. Thank you. Chris talking in that question.

02:16:00.950 --> 02:16:05.950
And you have investigated all potential for webinars and anything and

02:16:05.950 --> 02:16:11.670
everything online. The reason I asked this, you can practically do a complete automotive

02:16:11.670 --> 02:16:18.670
strip down and build up, including the engine, online now. And so much of the technical side

02:16:18.670 --> 02:16:25.550
of everything up to what I know of in the city is available. And I'm surprised that

02:16:25.550 --> 02:16:36.580
municipal government does not have a more technological life advancing and doing some

02:16:36.580 --> 02:16:42.980
of these seminars because a lot of your on hand to hand things may involve a piece of

02:16:42.980 --> 02:16:49.870
equipment, but it's just very surprising that there is not that availability.

02:16:49.870 --> 02:16:56.670
We do have some available on and we do have the AWA offers some webinar training and it's

02:16:56.670 --> 02:17:00.110
not very expensive and the beauty is there's no travel.

02:17:00.110 --> 02:17:02.470
So we try to take advantage of that as much as we can.

02:17:02.470 --> 02:17:07.470
Idaho Rural Water Association also has those opportunities.

02:17:07.470 --> 02:17:10.710
But the certification that your people were facing, John,

02:17:10.710 --> 02:17:14.110
it'd be the same thing all across America they're facing.

02:17:14.110 --> 02:17:17.630
And if you don't have very many trainers or training sites,

02:17:17.630 --> 02:17:27.960
then something isn't meeting the market need, he said.

02:17:27.960 --> 02:17:32.610
I know Suzanne Hawkins.

02:17:32.610 --> 02:17:34.210
I'm going to change directions real quick.

02:17:34.210 --> 02:17:37.010
I just want to publicly say thank you to your and your team.

02:17:37.010 --> 02:17:41.730
I know you guys had a very stressful week last week, and you guys pulled together and did a wonderful job.

02:17:41.730 --> 02:17:42.730
Thank you.

02:17:42.730 --> 02:17:47.440
Thank you.

02:17:47.440 --> 02:17:49.000
I see no further questions regarding public works.

02:17:49.000 --> 02:17:51.920
Were you going to move to engineering, is that what you said?

02:17:51.920 --> 02:17:57.680
I'm really, it's the fact that there is going to be two more engineers on staff.

02:17:57.680 --> 02:18:02.000
But if there's further questions, I can be happy to try and answer.

02:18:02.000 --> 02:18:04.000
Okay.

02:18:04.000 --> 02:18:05.400
Any further questions for John?

02:18:05.400 --> 02:18:06.900
I'm from Missouri.

02:18:06.900 --> 02:18:07.900
I see no lights, sir.

02:18:07.900 --> 02:18:13.730
Thank you for your presentation.

02:18:13.730 --> 02:18:18.730
I believe we have our Chief of Police and one of his captains.

02:18:19.450 --> 02:18:20.650
Welcome, Chief.

02:18:20.650 --> 02:18:22.530
Thank you, Mayor, members of the council.

02:18:22.530 --> 02:18:23.850
I brought everyone along.

02:18:23.850 --> 02:18:24.690
I see that.

02:18:25.770 --> 02:18:27.410
Doesn't hurt at all.

02:18:27.410 --> 02:18:30.010
I was wondering how I would present this to you.

02:18:30.010 --> 02:18:33.130
And I think Travis did a great job in laying it out.

02:18:33.130 --> 02:18:35.250
So I'm just gonna follow the format that he provided.

02:18:35.250 --> 02:18:36.850
And I wanna start a little bit with just talking

02:18:36.850 --> 02:18:39.370
about some of our actual expenditures.

02:18:39.370 --> 02:18:40.690
But I think it's probably important.

02:18:40.690 --> 02:18:42.090
When you look at these numbers,

02:18:42.090 --> 02:18:43.410
these numbers always look high.

02:18:43.410 --> 02:18:46.450
And you look at, you know, we're asking for $35,000,

02:18:46.450 --> 02:18:49.330
and this is just our travel and meeting line item.

02:18:49.330 --> 02:18:52.330
I know it looks substantial, but you also need to understand

02:18:52.330 --> 02:18:54.890
that represents 93 employees in our organization.

02:18:54.890 --> 02:18:58.480
So, like always take that in mind.

02:18:58.480 --> 02:19:01.240
And we also have a state agency that's dedicated

02:19:01.240 --> 02:19:03.520
to training and certification standards.

02:19:03.520 --> 02:19:05.800
So there's a lot tied into this.

02:19:05.800 --> 02:19:09.160
But if you look back at our actual expenditures,

02:19:09.160 --> 02:19:11.720
we went back to 2004 to give you an idea.

02:19:11.720 --> 02:19:19.320
In 2004, we were actually spending 39% more in this area than we're spending today.

02:19:19.320 --> 02:19:22.320
And you can see that as we move along, there's some ebb and flow to it.

02:19:22.320 --> 02:19:29.360
And as you can see after 2008, we really put the clamp down on our training dollars.

02:19:29.360 --> 02:19:33.960
And what's amazing about this is even going into 2010, what we started to hear when we

02:19:33.960 --> 02:19:40.240
were out at state meetings, the best practice was actually not what we were doing.

02:19:40.240 --> 02:19:47.800
We were hearing from members of the ICOPA that in times similar to 2008, when you had

02:19:47.800 --> 02:19:51.720
lean staffs and you had to make deep cuts, those were the times that you probably needed

02:19:51.720 --> 02:19:55.600
to make the greatest investment in training to make sure that your personnel were ready

02:19:55.600 --> 02:19:56.600
to go.

02:19:56.600 --> 02:20:00.320
So you can see that in 2013, our actual was 33,000.

02:20:00.320 --> 02:20:04.160
I'm not for sure where we're at right now, and I meant to bring that so that you would have

02:20:04.160 --> 02:20:11.320
that number, but I think that our proposed 2015 request at 35,000 will probably be in

02:20:11.320 --> 02:20:13.800
line with what we're actually spending.

02:20:13.800 --> 02:20:20.960
I also want you to understand that as a department, since October 1st, 2011, we brought in 38 new

02:20:20.960 --> 02:20:24.600
employees, 22 of those employees being in patrol.

02:20:24.600 --> 02:20:29.320
So every time that we have movement or shifting, and I'll talk a little bit about our core training

02:20:29.320 --> 02:20:33.320
curriculum in just a minute, but every time that we bring on a new employee, we have that

02:20:33.320 --> 02:20:37.000
an additional training burden to get them up to standards and certification.

02:20:37.000 --> 02:20:41.780
And if we lose someone, let's say out of detectives, then we have to put somebody,

02:20:41.780 --> 02:20:45.960
move someone from patrol in the detectives and then make sure that they're ready and

02:20:45.960 --> 02:20:53.430
well trained to assume the responsibilities of their new role.

02:20:53.430 --> 02:20:58.430
Under, obviously we're mandated for certification and recertification.

02:20:58.430 --> 02:21:02.830
The state requires that our officers have 40 hours of training every two years.

02:21:02.830 --> 02:21:07.890
We can do this in a number of ways and we do utilize in-house training through our block

02:21:07.890 --> 02:21:08.890
training.

02:21:08.890 --> 02:21:12.390
We utilize training sponsored by the colleges of Idaho.

02:21:12.390 --> 02:21:19.170
We use some online training through post, any webinar or trainings that we can find that

02:21:19.170 --> 02:21:21.670
will relate and we try to take advantage of this.

02:21:21.670 --> 02:21:27.010
A lot of that training is hands-on training and it has to be done in the classroom setting.

02:21:27.010 --> 02:21:31.650
We also use, and I don't have this number and I probably should have it for you tonight,

02:21:31.650 --> 02:21:35.050
is that a lot of our training is reimbursed through grants.

02:21:35.050 --> 02:21:38.170
It's not necessarily reflected in the actuals.

02:21:38.170 --> 02:21:40.930
So sometimes it looks like we've got $33,000.

02:21:40.930 --> 02:21:44.450
We might have been able to recover $5,000 to $10,000

02:21:44.450 --> 02:21:46.450
of that money through grants.

02:21:46.450 --> 02:21:49.130
And we continue to look for grants in finding ways

02:21:49.130 --> 02:21:56.500
to save the citizens of Twin Falls in any way that we can.

02:21:56.500 --> 02:22:00.060
Under employee development, this is a work in progress

02:22:00.060 --> 02:22:01.740
and certainly something new to us.

02:22:01.740 --> 02:22:06.320
And I think that Chief Mon and Mayor Hawley will remember

02:22:06.320 --> 02:22:09.080
the times when we used to go into our annual,

02:22:09.080 --> 02:22:11.920
we get ready for budget and we try to list every possible

02:22:11.920 --> 02:22:14.820
class that we may need for the next year.

02:22:14.820 --> 02:22:16.680
And what we really found is it was impossible

02:22:16.680 --> 02:22:18.480
because a lot of times we would list classes

02:22:18.480 --> 02:22:21.320
that weren't available or classes would become available

02:22:21.320 --> 02:22:23.920
later on in the year that we didn't know

02:22:23.920 --> 02:22:25.320
that would be available.

02:22:25.320 --> 02:22:27.360
And so what we did is we moved away and started

02:22:27.360 --> 02:22:29.720
to develop a core training curriculum

02:22:29.720 --> 02:22:31.360
for all levels of our department.

02:22:31.360 --> 02:22:33.800
And this is just a sample of what that looks like.

02:22:33.800 --> 02:22:36.280
So we're making a trying to make a commitment to our police

02:22:36.280 --> 02:22:38.840
officers at certain points in their careers

02:22:38.840 --> 02:22:40.760
to provide them with what we believe

02:22:40.760 --> 02:22:42.920
is the training, necessary training.

02:22:42.920 --> 02:22:44.880
Like NIMM's training is obviously something

02:22:44.880 --> 02:22:46.440
it's all done online.

02:22:46.440 --> 02:22:48.400
And you'll see that we start making investments

02:22:48.400 --> 02:22:50.800
in our officers for training,

02:22:50.800 --> 02:22:54.400
offsite training, usually at the three to six year mark,

02:22:54.400 --> 02:22:56.200
giving them more advanced training.

02:22:56.200 --> 02:22:57.440
But certainly in those early years,

02:22:57.440 --> 02:23:05.020
taking advantage of anything that we can online to limit our investment.

02:23:05.020 --> 02:23:08.260
And I also think that there's a fact I'd like to consider.

02:23:08.260 --> 02:23:11.860
I would like to thank Captain Barnhart for putting this together for you.

02:23:11.860 --> 02:23:13.860
But that's the cost of not training.

02:23:13.860 --> 02:23:17.460
And unfortunately, in our business, it doesn't take you long.

02:23:17.460 --> 02:23:21.820
If you look through the paper, you're going to find some officer that made a mistake,

02:23:21.820 --> 02:23:28.720
did something wrong, and it's very expensive, expensive to our agency,

02:23:28.720 --> 02:23:33.720
to our morale, to our image and at times to the city.

02:23:33.720 --> 02:23:36.600
So we always try to keep that in mind as we move forward

02:23:36.600 --> 02:23:39.200
to make sure that we are developing our people

02:23:39.200 --> 02:23:40.720
and we're making the investment

02:23:40.720 --> 02:23:45.310
makes it more efficient, more effective.

02:23:45.310 --> 02:23:49.110
That's kind of like a shotgun approach to our training

02:23:49.110 --> 02:23:49.950
for the next year.

02:23:49.950 --> 02:23:52.190
Are there any questions specifically about this?

02:23:52.190 --> 02:23:54.510
Do we have any questions for our chief?

02:23:54.510 --> 02:23:56.190
Or one of his many captains?

02:23:56.190 --> 02:23:57.030
You guys are.

02:23:57.030 --> 02:23:58.190
We're all ready to go.

02:23:58.190 --> 02:24:00.910
you say 93 employees in the cop shop?

02:24:00.910 --> 02:24:02.630
That's 93 employees now.

02:24:02.630 --> 02:24:06.790
The dispatch communications actually has their own training budget.

02:24:06.790 --> 02:24:16.150
So we have the out of the employees that 447 under our normal training and meeting line item,

02:24:16.150 --> 02:24:20.150
it's 93 employees that that provides training to.

02:24:20.150 --> 02:24:25.710
Now our registration, the 449, we didn't increase that.

02:24:25.710 --> 02:24:29.670
And a lot of the increases that you're seeing in travel and meeting is just that.

02:24:29.670 --> 02:24:32.990
It's related to the expense of travel.

02:24:32.990 --> 02:24:36.910
Airfare is higher and when we have to utilize it, it's more expensive.

02:24:36.910 --> 02:24:41.470
It's more expensive to drive and it's more expensive to lodge our employees when they do

02:24:41.470 --> 02:24:42.470
go.

02:24:42.470 --> 02:24:46.630
And so what we found is that our actual was getting close to the 35,000.

02:24:46.630 --> 02:24:47.630
Right.

02:24:47.630 --> 02:24:49.340
So.

02:24:49.340 --> 02:24:53.980
Brian, I think a couple of things that really struck me here is two areas, really.

02:24:53.980 --> 02:24:58.980
the supervision training when we start talking about the West

02:24:58.980 --> 02:25:01.980
Staff and Command, 400 hours and those kind of things.

02:25:01.980 --> 02:25:06.980
Really, we're up there, but you have to have that training to

02:25:06.980 --> 02:25:09.980
I've always said the supervision's easy if we didn't deal with people.

02:25:09.980 --> 02:25:14.980
Once you put the element of people in, you've got to have some background

02:25:14.980 --> 02:25:16.980
and some training to be able to do it.

02:25:16.980 --> 02:25:20.980
The other thing is this Canine Academy, 420 hours.

02:25:20.980 --> 02:25:27.980
So these training events that you have your staff go to, they're pretty extensive.

02:25:27.980 --> 02:25:30.980
They're extensive training sessions.

02:25:30.980 --> 02:25:33.980
They're very expensive now for canine in particular.

02:25:33.980 --> 02:25:35.980
We use asset forfeiture funds.

02:25:35.980 --> 02:25:40.980
So this is money that basically is awarded back through the court system to us on drug seizures.

02:25:40.980 --> 02:25:42.980
And we use that money to pay for that.

02:25:42.980 --> 02:25:47.980
But it's still an investment of time into these individuals.

02:25:47.980 --> 02:25:50.980
That's really a substantial one.

02:25:50.980 --> 02:25:51.980
Suzanne Hopkins.

02:25:51.980 --> 02:25:52.980
Thank you.

02:25:52.980 --> 02:25:54.980
I'm going to go off subject again real quick.

02:25:54.980 --> 02:26:00.230
Early in the budget meetings, you talked about possibly adding three officers.

02:26:00.230 --> 02:26:04.230
And through our course of discussion, we decided not to fill those positions.

02:26:04.230 --> 02:26:09.230
And I know there were some questions last week in the media and stuff about why we decided that.

02:26:09.230 --> 02:26:12.230
Can you just give us a quick recap on how we got to that point?

02:26:12.230 --> 02:26:13.230
I can.

02:26:13.230 --> 02:26:18.750
Actually, this is a series of conversations that Travis and I had referenced our staffing.

02:26:18.750 --> 02:26:22.910
And it's not that these positions are fully vetted, and I think we can demonstrate a need

02:26:22.910 --> 02:26:23.910
for them.

02:26:23.910 --> 02:26:27.910
The reality of where we're at, you know, and Travis asked me, you know, a tough question.

02:26:27.910 --> 02:26:29.670
I hate those tough questions.

02:26:29.670 --> 02:26:32.550
But he wanted to know if we could staff the positions.

02:26:32.550 --> 02:26:36.270
If we budgeted the positions, could we actually get to a point where we hired these individuals

02:26:36.270 --> 02:26:37.710
in the next calendar year?

02:26:37.710 --> 02:26:40.950
And I could not make that promise to him.

02:26:40.950 --> 02:26:45.270
So we're moving forward, we recognize that we need to add the personnel.

02:26:45.270 --> 02:26:48.030
We also have the ability to over hire by two.

02:26:48.030 --> 02:26:52.270
So even though we're not getting the two individuals in this budget,

02:26:52.270 --> 02:26:54.270
we have the ability to over hire.

02:26:54.270 --> 02:27:00.790
If we do reach that point, right, fortunately we will, then we could over hire by two.

02:27:00.790 --> 02:27:04.390
So I think it's a realistic approach to where we're at.

02:27:04.390 --> 02:27:07.750
And really, like I said, the positions are fully vetted.

02:27:07.750 --> 02:27:13.270
I feel good that they're needed, but it's just a matter of reality.

02:27:13.270 --> 02:27:16.470
Can we staff those positions in this budget here?

02:27:16.470 --> 02:27:17.510
Thank you.

02:27:17.510 --> 02:27:18.310
Chris talking to.

02:27:18.310 --> 02:27:28.740
Laurie, when we have city staff receive some sort of a reimbursement,

02:27:28.740 --> 02:27:32.220
however you might term it for training, does that go back against that?

02:27:32.220 --> 02:27:34.900
Is that receded against Schonner's credit?

02:27:34.900 --> 02:27:39.180
So it's not Chris because the expenditure is real.

02:27:39.180 --> 02:27:46.180
It's what we're incurring and we show that reimbursement from grants as a revenue source.

02:27:46.180 --> 02:27:48.060
But not in that department.

02:27:48.060 --> 02:27:54.460
Well, in the general fund it's going to go under grant revenue, but we don't reduce the

02:27:54.460 --> 02:27:57.660
expenditure just because we are reimbursed.

02:27:57.660 --> 02:28:03.140
And there's no way you can do that and stay in compliance with auditing to have a reflection.

02:28:03.140 --> 02:28:07.140
I mean, we can say, Chief, I think is really informative to know this.

02:28:07.140 --> 02:28:14.140
Sometimes we get a, I don't know, stipend or we can reward back on that, but it'd be nice

02:28:14.140 --> 02:28:19.340
for us to know in a specific department that there is enough emphasis and priority on this

02:28:19.340 --> 02:28:24.740
type of training that there is some outside resource being applied back to it.

02:28:24.740 --> 02:28:26.700
Right now we don't have any way of knowing.

02:28:26.700 --> 02:28:34.260
Chris, we could certainly go through our grant income and see what was specifically for reimbursement

02:28:34.260 --> 02:28:37.060
for travel and training and provide that information.

02:28:37.060 --> 02:28:43.030
I actually should have had that, I apologize for not having that, I think it would have been

02:28:43.030 --> 02:28:46.770
very informative.

02:28:46.770 --> 02:28:49.470
Any further questions for Chief?

02:28:49.470 --> 02:28:50.470
Your app the hopes, sir.

02:28:50.470 --> 02:28:51.470
Thank you.

02:28:51.470 --> 02:28:54.360
Thank you.

02:28:54.360 --> 02:28:55.360
Welcome back Travis.

02:28:55.360 --> 02:28:56.360
Thank you.

02:28:56.360 --> 02:29:00.720
So I just want to provide a quick recap and I'm also going to take a minute to also reflect

02:29:00.720 --> 02:29:17.700
upon my own travel and training budget, because mine is big, and really kind of like Susan,

02:29:17.700 --> 02:29:22.300
there's a large portion of my budget that is used for other opportunities and other

02:29:22.300 --> 02:29:26.000
services, and I really want to talk about that.

02:29:26.000 --> 02:29:28.700
But so I'll talk about that now.

02:29:28.700 --> 02:29:35.820
So last year, you recall, I came in and I said, I really want to develop a new internal

02:29:35.820 --> 02:29:43.020
philosophy that encourages greater collaboration, greater opportunity, and I want to send people

02:29:43.020 --> 02:29:48.060
to be able to capture this thought of what I've been talking about.

02:29:48.060 --> 02:29:54.980
And over the course of this year, we've been sending people back to attend LEED and the

02:29:54.980 --> 02:29:57.300
senior executive institute.

02:29:57.300 --> 02:30:02.720
there are several in the audience that could probably talk about the benefit of that training.

02:30:02.720 --> 02:30:07.720
We want to continue that training, but also because of the number of individuals that we

02:30:07.720 --> 02:30:12.640
have been able to send back there, we are also now going to be able to bring that training

02:30:12.640 --> 02:30:19.640
to us. And it's going to be able to us to allow to have upwards between 40 to 80 individuals

02:30:19.640 --> 02:30:25.720
across section of our organization to really spend time in this new operating philosophy

02:30:25.720 --> 02:30:29.520
that we're trying to work forward and move forward.

02:30:29.520 --> 02:30:32.640
That collaboration is important.

02:30:32.640 --> 02:30:35.320
We are trying to ensure that we are not operating

02:30:35.320 --> 02:30:37.600
within defined silos as department,

02:30:37.600 --> 02:30:41.680
that we are working collectively to ask how one's actions

02:30:41.680 --> 02:30:45.160
may impact another individual department's workloads,

02:30:45.160 --> 02:30:48.480
and that might sound really simple.

02:30:48.480 --> 02:30:50.720
But when you start at the ground level,

02:30:50.720 --> 02:30:53.640
and we've talked, we've developed some key phrases, right,

02:30:53.640 --> 02:30:56.890
driving decisions downward.

02:30:56.890 --> 02:30:59.730
In order for us to be able to drive decisions downward,

02:30:59.730 --> 02:31:02.690
we have to equip our employees with the knowledge,

02:31:02.690 --> 02:31:06.090
skills, and abilities of the situation

02:31:06.090 --> 02:31:09.970
so that they feel good about making command decisions,

02:31:09.970 --> 02:31:12.610
that they feel empowered and they feel like they have

02:31:12.610 --> 02:31:13.770
the opportunity to do that.

02:31:13.770 --> 02:31:16.410
So that is, part of that is included in there.

02:31:18.570 --> 02:31:20.850
And in the whole spirit of full disclosure,

02:31:20.850 --> 02:31:24.290
I wanted you to be aware that that is once again in there.

02:31:24.370 --> 02:31:28.190
We're also needing to continue to send people back.

02:31:28.190 --> 02:31:33.070
And as we have transitions in our department head group, we want to make sure that the

02:31:33.070 --> 02:31:38.550
management and leadership philosophy that we're trying to, that place into our organization,

02:31:38.550 --> 02:31:46.220
is understood and that they have the opportunity to really experience that first hand.

02:31:46.220 --> 02:31:50.500
We've talked a lot about trying to keep it close to home.

02:31:50.500 --> 02:31:53.980
And that is something that is very, very important.

02:31:53.980 --> 02:31:58.660
We have individuals come in in the engineering department to talk about how to do the new

02:31:58.660 --> 02:32:04.420
AutoCAD training programs and we will take and lock the engineering department into a room

02:32:04.420 --> 02:32:07.700
and they will talk about AutoCAD for hours.

02:32:07.700 --> 02:32:10.140
Now that sounds painful.

02:32:10.140 --> 02:32:14.940
But they will tell you that it is incredibly great training.

02:32:14.940 --> 02:32:19.780
Technology does provide some low cost alternatives and we certainly try to take advantage of those

02:32:19.780 --> 02:32:22.290
when they are there.

02:32:22.290 --> 02:32:27.610
But a web-based seminar is sometimes very tough for some of us.

02:32:27.610 --> 02:32:33.330
So for me in particular, if I can't leave my office, I guarantee you I won't be able

02:32:33.330 --> 02:32:38.570
to get whatever training opportunities may be there.

02:32:38.570 --> 02:32:41.690
And I'm not that only one.

02:32:41.690 --> 02:32:46.330
It's not as easy as just closing my door and saying please don't disturb me, because there

02:32:46.330 --> 02:32:51.330
are times in which people really do need to get a hold of us.

02:32:51.330 --> 02:32:55.210
It also eliminates that human element.

02:32:55.210 --> 02:33:00.950
There's a lot of synergy that occurs from conversation and networking.

02:33:00.950 --> 02:33:06.190
Conversations that you can go and have a one-on-one conversation with a structure, instructor, or

02:33:06.190 --> 02:33:11.770
lecturer about a particular issue, and they may be able to appoint you into a direction

02:33:11.770 --> 02:33:13.010
of resources.

02:33:13.010 --> 02:33:19.010
Or maybe someone across the room is experiencing a deal with an issue that you are now trying

02:33:19.010 --> 02:33:21.530
to fix and solve yourself.

02:33:21.530 --> 02:33:25.850
We think that is one of those unspoken, valuable assets

02:33:25.850 --> 02:33:30.290
and parts of training, that opportunity to network with peers

02:33:30.290 --> 02:33:32.290
to find best practices.

02:33:32.290 --> 02:33:34.730
We've talked about training the trainer programs,

02:33:34.730 --> 02:33:38.330
where we sent individuals away to hone their skill sets

02:33:38.330 --> 02:33:40.330
and their tools and their expertise,

02:33:40.330 --> 02:33:43.010
and then bring those back and share and part those

02:33:43.010 --> 02:33:44.770
with their folks.

02:33:44.770 --> 02:33:46.610
We've also talked about how some of those

02:33:46.610 --> 02:33:48.850
are reimbursed expenditures.

02:33:48.850 --> 02:33:53.200
Because again, right here, we are reflecting only,

02:33:53.200 --> 02:33:55.060
only on the expenditure piece,

02:33:55.060 --> 02:33:58.500
we are not reflecting on the net cost piece.

02:33:58.500 --> 02:34:01.380
And some of these, as Chief Pike shared,

02:34:01.380 --> 02:34:05.620
are reimbursed through our process.

02:34:05.620 --> 02:34:10.620
We believe that also keeping it local makes sense.

02:34:12.540 --> 02:34:16.300
But keeping it local doesn't always provide you

02:34:16.300 --> 02:34:18.780
with a lower cost alternative.

02:34:18.780 --> 02:34:22.780
National conferences are held in major metro settings.

02:34:22.780 --> 02:34:25.780
That's just where they're at.

02:34:25.780 --> 02:34:28.780
And sometimes you can choose not to attend those conferences,

02:34:28.780 --> 02:34:31.780
and obviously the organization has made those choices,

02:34:31.780 --> 02:34:34.780
and we've heard from people tonight who have made those choices

02:34:34.780 --> 02:34:38.780
and maybe made that choice for an entire career.

02:34:38.780 --> 02:34:42.780
It's not any cheaper, for me to fly to Charlotte

02:34:42.780 --> 02:34:45.780
to go to the International City Manager's meeting this year

02:34:45.780 --> 02:34:52.780
and have my conference and be a part of that as it will be for me to go to Seattle the following year.

02:34:52.780 --> 02:34:58.040
In fact, I will be surprised if Seattle is just not a little bit more expensive.

02:34:58.040 --> 02:35:05.040
In fact, I've been told that all training places to avoid it's San Francisco.

02:35:05.040 --> 02:35:14.040
That San Francisco is, although closer, will be the place that will cost you by far the most when it comes to training dollars.

02:35:14.040 --> 02:35:18.780
We think that this is an appropriate question.

02:35:18.780 --> 02:35:23.930
The idea tonight was to hopefully illustrate

02:35:23.930 --> 02:35:28.930
and say there's not one reason why this is going out.

02:35:28.930 --> 02:35:33.930
We wanted to showcase and share multiple reasons because it's not

02:35:33.930 --> 02:35:38.930
an easy answer to a fairly important question.

02:35:38.930 --> 02:35:42.930
And so we hope that we've answered your questions in those areas.

02:35:42.930 --> 02:35:50.650
areas. Also know that all of the members of the team are also behind me that have are supposed

02:35:50.650 --> 02:35:55.530
to, you can call them and see if they did their homework assignment, are supposed to be in

02:35:55.530 --> 02:36:00.250
a position to respond to the specific increases in their particular training line items, but

02:36:00.250 --> 02:36:04.290
we wanted to point out some of the larger ones and more obvious to the student. And with

02:36:04.290 --> 02:36:08.850
that, we'll stand for any additional questions on this or any other aspect of the budget and

02:36:08.850 --> 02:36:13.460
recognition that next week, we're going to ask you to adopt it.

02:36:13.460 --> 02:36:16.180
I want to make sure that I open it up to the public as well.

02:36:16.180 --> 02:36:20.780
I'm not seeing the public here, but we always want to make sure that we do that.

02:36:20.780 --> 02:36:27.340
I think what might be interesting to me, Travis, is maybe a report from a couple folks that

02:36:27.340 --> 02:36:29.700
have gone back to that training.

02:36:29.700 --> 02:36:34.740
Not tonight necessarily, but in the future so that we can see really what they're gaining

02:36:34.740 --> 02:36:40.500
and because it's a substantial investment on the city side and we want to, I think that

02:36:40.500 --> 02:36:45.060
would be interesting for not only the council but for folks at home to see where their tax

02:36:45.060 --> 02:36:48.920
dollars are going. We'll do that. Chris, talking to?

02:36:48.920 --> 02:36:54.360
Well, since I was one of the people that asked to look this up and had the information, I

02:36:54.360 --> 02:36:59.000
appreciate it. I'd like to have had a chance to have that sheet a little bit ahead of time

02:36:59.000 --> 02:37:06.000
to study it, nonetheless I felt like I'm questioning motherhood apple pie and canoe safety to get

02:37:06.000 --> 02:37:12.700
into questioning travel. But I'm doing it anyway. I think it's a useful civic function because

02:37:12.700 --> 02:37:18.540
the public too often gets the idea that the city staff, the county staff, the state, the

02:37:18.540 --> 02:37:24.280
fed bureaucrats don't have accountability for their training. I think this has been useful

02:37:24.280 --> 02:37:30.760
tonight because it shows the department heads take the training responsibilities seriously,

02:37:30.760 --> 02:37:39.480
expect something out of them, and try to make them localized or applicable or useful.

02:37:39.480 --> 02:37:46.760
Nonetheless a $66,000 increase in travel in one year representing 21% of the travel budget

02:37:46.760 --> 02:37:50.180
is something that sticks in the public's mind.

02:37:50.180 --> 02:37:55.220
experience for many years of doing budgeting for people, two things I always look for and

02:37:55.220 --> 02:37:56.980
my superiors did.

02:37:56.980 --> 02:38:04.120
We're number one, disproportionate increases in one year, which we've had this year, possibly

02:38:04.120 --> 02:38:08.740
reflective of our decrease back in 2007 and 2008.

02:38:08.740 --> 02:38:14.460
And the other item I always look for was crowding travel and training in the last couple months

02:38:14.460 --> 02:38:18.540
or months or week, use it or lose its syndrome.

02:38:18.540 --> 02:38:24.980
And I would trust that the city staff is not nor you would allow that because that is the

02:38:24.980 --> 02:38:28.060
least consumable way to spend the travel money.

02:38:28.060 --> 02:38:29.060
It's been a good exercise.

02:38:29.060 --> 02:38:30.860
I've picked my battles carefully.

02:38:30.860 --> 02:38:33.260
I'm not going to vote against the budget because of this.

02:38:33.260 --> 02:38:40.500
I think it's still an awfully steep increase for one year, but I appreciate the department

02:38:40.500 --> 02:38:46.860
had sharing with that and with me in educating and hopefully the public learns something from

02:38:46.860 --> 02:38:53.340
process as well. Thank you, Chris. Anyone else from council have questions regarding

02:38:53.340 --> 02:39:00.750
the subject matter this evening? All right, at this time I'd like to open it up for

02:39:00.750 --> 02:39:07.320
anyone in the public that has any questions regarding the budget, keeping

02:39:07.320 --> 02:39:14.220
in mind next week, it's time to vote to adopt it, right? So again, I'm not seeing

02:39:14.220 --> 02:39:17.740
members of the public, although you're all members of the public I guess, but your

02:39:17.740 --> 02:39:22.140
City staff here to make any input.

02:39:22.140 --> 02:39:28.790
So we will move to our last agenda item, which is public input.

02:39:28.790 --> 02:39:30.790
I don't think I need to do that again.

02:39:30.790 --> 02:39:35.270
And our items from City Manager or City Council, do you have anything further, Mr.

02:39:35.270 --> 02:39:36.270
Rothwider?

02:39:36.270 --> 02:39:37.270
I do.

02:39:37.270 --> 02:39:38.270
I have two quick items.

02:39:38.270 --> 02:39:44.750
Number one, as a result of the rain storm event, we had a series of cancellations.

02:39:44.750 --> 02:39:47.830
One of the cancellations was the National Night Out.

02:39:47.830 --> 02:39:53.310
That will be celebrated tomorrow evening, beginning at 5 o'clock in City Park.

02:39:53.310 --> 02:39:56.310
If Staff Sergeant Pullen were here, he would say please come.

02:39:58.070 --> 02:40:00.590
I think it's a very worthwhile opportunity.

02:40:00.590 --> 02:40:06.510
It's an opportunity not only to get to have some great interaction with the Twin Falls Police Department,

02:40:06.510 --> 02:40:10.230
but the other law enforcement agencies from around the valley.

02:40:10.230 --> 02:40:16.950
The second is, as you know, that we try to structure and schedule agenda meetings going out into the future.

02:40:16.950 --> 02:40:22.630
We try to budget times for individual items over the course of about a month.

02:40:22.630 --> 02:40:33.030
At this point in time, we would just announce that unless there is a significant change in the business schedule, as we've anticipated,

02:40:33.030 --> 02:40:36.710
there would be no need to have a council meeting on August 25th.

02:40:37.990 --> 02:40:44.230
We have looked at maybe canceling the meeting on the second after the Labor Day holiday.

02:40:44.230 --> 02:40:46.990
We have public hearings that have already been scheduled

02:40:46.990 --> 02:40:48.510
for those times.

02:40:48.510 --> 02:40:51.310
There is no business to be conducted

02:40:51.310 --> 02:40:53.870
on the evening of the 25th at this time.

02:40:54.950 --> 02:40:55.790
Thank you, Travis.

02:40:55.790 --> 02:40:57.590
Anything from city council?

02:40:57.590 --> 02:40:59.030
Chris Dockington.

02:40:59.030 --> 02:41:00.910
Brought this up a week or two ago

02:41:00.910 --> 02:41:03.550
and without her two missing council people,

02:41:03.550 --> 02:41:05.510
I wouldn't like to have any action on,

02:41:05.510 --> 02:41:07.910
but I hope the council would still give consideration

02:41:07.910 --> 02:41:12.910
to requesting city staff initiate discussions with PSI

02:41:12.910 --> 02:41:19.710
about reviewing our solid waste sanitation standards and look at the

02:41:19.710 --> 02:41:27.430
pros and cons of no longer continuing the unlimited at one price fee and moving

02:41:27.430 --> 02:41:32.390
towards some cost reductions on those with the extremely limited use of the

02:41:32.390 --> 02:41:37.830
big blues every week. Maybe a smaller can. What some of the options that I think

02:41:37.830 --> 02:41:42.830
would talk about. I hope the Council would always hear that information.

02:41:42.830 --> 02:41:49.310
I think maybe if we could put that on a future agenda to bring to the Council's attention.

02:41:49.310 --> 02:41:55.310
When it's a full Council, I agree with Chris. It's better to have all of us here with me.

02:41:55.310 --> 02:42:00.310
Those discussions. I appreciate you bringing that up, Chris. Sean Berger.

02:42:00.310 --> 02:42:07.310
Just shameless plug here. Thursday night at six o'clock is the annual Sabre Sudden Idaho event.

02:42:07.310 --> 02:42:10.790
This is co-hosted by Sotomayor tourism in the chamber.

02:42:10.790 --> 02:42:15.910
It's a chance to sample local foods and beverages prepared

02:42:15.910 --> 02:42:18.310
with local food products by local chefs.

02:42:18.310 --> 02:42:22.630
And it is a fundraiser for the tourism promotion in the region.

02:42:22.630 --> 02:42:25.550
So tickets are available at the chamber office.

02:42:25.550 --> 02:42:27.110
Give me how much?

02:42:27.110 --> 02:42:31.150
$25 a piece or $40 a couple.

02:42:31.150 --> 02:42:33.150
All you can eat?

02:42:33.150 --> 02:42:36.070
All you can eat till the food's gone.

02:42:36.070 --> 02:42:39.000
Food and beverages actually.

02:42:39.000 --> 02:42:39.520
Thank you, Sean.

02:42:39.520 --> 02:42:42.520
Anything else from council?

02:42:42.520 --> 02:42:43.520
Travis Rothwiler.

02:42:43.520 --> 02:42:46.840
Just real quick, we will schedule that conversation

02:42:46.840 --> 02:42:49.480
regarding the city's solid waste contract

02:42:49.480 --> 02:42:52.680
for the evening of September 2nd.

02:42:52.680 --> 02:42:55.520
Is there a way that we could have some information from PSI

02:42:55.520 --> 02:42:57.400
if there's that, is there opportunity

02:42:57.400 --> 02:43:00.200
to have smaller size cans or whatever?

02:43:00.200 --> 02:43:04.680
We'll start and we'll engage in a conversation with less.

02:43:04.680 --> 02:43:07.200
Thank you, thank you, Travis.

02:43:07.200 --> 02:43:09.800
If there's nothing further, we are adjourned.
