Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2014-03-31, recording 1 (started 17:00) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2014-03-31/ [0:03:52] I'd like to call the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council to order for March 31st [0:03:56] And it is 3 p.m. About 1 after 3 for the purpose. We were meeting today for the purpose of [0:04:03] taking a tour of [0:04:04] various buildings that belong to the city [0:04:08] City Hall police station and Hanson building so at this time do I adjourn? [0:04:16] We'll stand and recess for the tour. Thank you Travis [0:11:29] The Pledge of Allegiance, so for all of those wishing to join us, please do so. [0:11:50] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. [0:12:06] Thank you and welcome to everyone this evening. [0:12:09] I do want to confirm that we do have a quorum of the council here this evening. [0:12:12] All seven members are here. [0:12:14] And I'll now ask our city manager, do we have any amendments to our agenda tonight, Travis? [0:12:20] Mr. Mayor and members of the council, we have two amendments for your consideration. [0:12:26] The first one is to take item number three that is listed on the consent calendar and [0:12:31] to request that it be moved to the items of consideration. [0:12:35] And have that item appear to be as number two. [0:12:40] and then from number two on being renumbered. [0:12:45] The second item for amendment consideration this evening [0:12:48] is an executive session under 6723451E as an elephant. [0:12:58] It is to consider matters of trade or commerce [0:13:01] in which the city of Twin Falls is [0:13:02] competing against other states or foreign nations. [0:13:08] So moved. [0:13:09] Second. [0:13:10] Motion on four by Greg Lanting, [0:13:13] seconded by Chris Tockington to amend the agenda. [0:13:18] Anything further on that motion council? [0:13:21] I see no lights. [0:13:22] We have the roll call vote, please. [0:13:24] See Dan Hawkins? [0:13:25] Yes. [0:13:26] Jima. [0:13:27] Yes. [0:13:28] Burger. [0:13:29] Chris Tockington. [0:13:30] Yes. [0:13:31] Yes. [0:13:32] Greg Lanting? [0:13:33] Yes. [0:13:35] Yes. [0:13:35] Rebecca Mills, like that. [0:13:36] Yes. [0:13:37] Motion passes to seven to zero. [0:13:39] We will move down to general public input. [0:13:42] If you're here this evening and would like to address [0:13:44] the council on something that's not on the agenda [0:13:47] this evening, we have some public hearings, [0:13:49] we have some other public comments later. [0:13:52] But if it's not on the agenda and you're here [0:13:54] and you'd like to address the council, [0:13:55] this is the time to do so. [0:13:56] So I'll give you just a minute to come forward [0:13:59] and address council. [0:14:02] If you would state your name and your address [0:14:04] [Muted for privacy: home address] [0:14:06] [Muted for privacy: home address] [0:14:08] [Muted for privacy: home address] [0:14:13] [Muted for privacy: home address] [0:14:19] the park. [0:14:20] I've talked with Parks and Rec and secured the facilities already, but I guess that we can't [0:14:26] broadcast music until 1215 on that day. [0:14:29] And I was told that if we could or I needed to come here to see if we could broadcast starting [0:14:34] at 10 o'clock instead of 1215. [0:14:37] And it's just praise and worship music, nothing like rock, heavy stuff, it'll just be mellow [0:14:43] stuff. [0:14:44] And then we have some other stuff, barbecue and stuff like that afterwards, after church, [0:14:48] Easter egg hunt for kids, it's a community event, we'll have it on KMBT and stuff like that. [0:14:53] But I just need to see if we can get time changed from 12, 15 to 10 o'clock. [0:14:57] We're good. [0:14:58] And your Josh, Josh Tucker, Mr. Tucker, who are you with again? [0:15:02] With the church? [0:15:04] Our church is called the church. [0:15:05] The church. [0:15:06] It's a branch off from the River Christian Fellowship. [0:15:10] We split, and so we meet at the Red Lion right now, [0:15:13] and we're looking at doing a community Easter day [0:15:16] at the park, so that's what we're here for. [0:15:18] Very good. [0:15:19] I think Travis had some comments. [0:15:20] Yeah, Mr. Mayor, members of the council, [0:15:22] typically what you would see is this item [0:15:24] would be first presented to the Parks and Recreation Board [0:15:28] for a recommendation, and that recommendation [0:15:30] would be carried forward onto the City Council. [0:15:33] Because of the timing of the event, [0:15:35] the fact that the Parks and Recreation Board will not meet again in time then for adequate [0:15:41] preparation for the church to be able to do their advertising. We thought it would be appropriate [0:15:46] to bring this item just directly to the Council for consideration. Also Dennis Boyer, our Parks [0:15:51] and Recreation Director is in the audience. He'll wave his hand so you could be. But Dennis [0:15:59] is here and is available to answer any questions that you might have. [0:16:04] Very good. [0:16:05] Dennis, could you come forward? [0:16:06] Chris talking. [0:16:07] No. [0:16:08] Oh, my comment. [0:16:10] So, Dennis, you're aware of this in any thoughts? [0:16:14] Well, when we implemented these rules and regulations at the City Park, I believe they [0:16:19] were implemented for the 2001 season. [0:16:23] What we did when we met with the churches on that area, they asked us to consider that [0:16:27] as the request from them, because they do have their church services typically from 11 [0:16:32] in the 12, 11 to 12, 15, do not have any amplified sound or music out of the band shell to 12, 15 [0:16:38] on Sunday. So we have been using that policy ever since 2001. [0:16:44] Okay. [0:16:45] Chris Scott. [0:16:46] Well, I still think that there is some degree of flexibility by amplification and the type [0:16:53] of music. Josh, I'm supposing you know you want to be good neighbors and if this is to [0:16:58] be repeated, we have to recognize that other churches are in that same time zone using facilities. [0:17:05] I would have no trouble making a moment, a motion to amend this to allow the Easter Sunday [0:17:14] 10 a.m. music amplification by the church subject to decibel limitations established by the [0:17:24] police. [0:17:27] So that's both a comment and a motion. Okay. It's a motion. So I need in a second before we make comments second [0:17:32] We have motion on for by Chris talking then seconded by Greg and Lanting Greg [0:17:36] I haven't like that Dennis Paul and a question good since Dennis typically handles [0:17:41] These types of things [0:17:45] Do you feel that Dennis identify yourself first staff sergeant Dennis pulling [0:17:52] it's sergeant we [0:17:54] You would deal with decibels probably more than anyone else does and so did you would you have an idea of what would be acceptable? [0:18:01] Because those churches are you know a couple 300 feet away in each direction [0:18:06] I would be afraid to say to give it a specific decibel level seems like a lot of them are in the 70 [0:18:12] Zone of a range if you can hear beyond that. I think what we'd be looking at is [0:18:17] if the churches [0:18:19] It doesn't really matter what the desk 11 that that desk 11 level is [0:18:24] It just depends on if people can hear it and if it disturbs their piece rather than the homes or if they're holding a church service [0:18:30] If their music in the park is loud enough. It's going to [0:18:34] Go inside the church. They're gonna be able to hear that. It's gonna disturb them [0:18:38] That would be my only concern [0:18:40] I'm possibly the neighbors as well. That's why they have to just really focus on keeping the noise level down [0:18:46] I don't know if they do hold the event there. [0:18:49] I would be afraid to set a specific decibel level. [0:18:53] Thank you, Dibs. [0:18:54] Rebecca Mill so I can. [0:18:56] Thank you, Mayor. [0:18:57] Dennis, could you stay for a minute? [0:18:59] Sorry. [0:18:59] Yeah, you might have a few. [0:19:02] You know, this sounds like a similar request [0:19:03] to what from another church that was now [0:19:06] moved to our items of consideration. [0:19:08] So would it be fair to apply kind of a similar conclusion [0:19:14] where it says the Twin Falls Police Department recommends [0:19:18] the on-duty patrol supervisor be given the authority [0:19:21] to order the event's organizers to mitigate sound [0:19:23] of amplified noise. [0:19:24] There are continued noise complaints to services [0:19:27] by those participating in the event [0:19:28] and non-compliance, the on-duty patrol supervisor [0:19:31] shall terminate the event. [0:19:33] Yes, I think that would be a good idea. [0:19:35] Okay, I think I would support it [0:19:36] with similar applications. [0:19:39] Similar language in the motion. [0:19:42] Chris talking. [0:19:44] The decibels are measured from their source and also the directionality and from the perceived [0:19:49] or the reception and so it's a variable but if the place in the street or the perimeter [0:19:56] between the park and let's say the Catholic Church, they're going to know that exceeds [0:20:02] normal bounds. [0:20:04] Otherwise you have to get into DB meters but I think that Rebecca's suggestion would give [0:20:09] us a working application for this. [0:20:13] Is that right? [0:20:14] Are you Josh? [0:20:15] Yes. [0:20:16] Okay. [0:20:17] That how many people do you expect? [0:20:18] Right around 150 to 200. [0:20:21] No more church service. [0:20:23] We have about 125 to 130 somewhere around there. [0:20:27] So they can stay fairly close to the banjo. [0:20:29] We can set speakers down on the concrete so the body of people will absorb that sound [0:20:36] as much as possible. [0:20:37] We have a decibel meter reader. [0:20:39] So I can go to the street right there by the way the Catholic Church is and make sure, you know, I mean if we're, I mean if we're at 75 decibels at the street there we're definitely way too loud. [0:20:51] Have you had a chance to contact the other churches and just let them know what you're planning so that they're aware? [0:20:56] I have and if that's something that I need to do I will do that. [0:20:59] So and I, and I, it's like I said we're going to put it on K&BT as a community outreach. [0:21:04] We're going to have Easter account for kids and stuff. [0:21:06] So if it can go to 10, a lot of the times other churches [0:21:10] are doing their same worship service at like 10 to 10.30, [0:21:13] which ours will fall in that too. [0:21:15] And so I mean, it's kind of the same time [0:21:19] as they're doing theirs and stuff, so. [0:21:21] Well, my philosophy is if everybody can just work together, [0:21:23] we all have the same goal on Easter Sunday, I think. [0:21:26] And I would think we're all big enough to make that happen, [0:21:28] but I was just curious about how much to come. [0:21:30] Oh, yeah, I can contact him. [0:21:31] I didn't even think about that. [0:21:32] So that's an awesome idea that contact him. [0:21:35] and coordinate with them, let them know what we're doing. [0:21:38] Maybe for parking as well. [0:21:39] Okay, yeah. [0:21:41] Okay, thank you. [0:21:42] Great learning. [0:21:43] Well, my question is, I'm not sure what the closest church [0:21:47] obviously is the Catholic church, [0:21:49] and I'm not even sure when their service is [0:21:51] that time of day. [0:21:52] We, Gretchen, dude, you, eight, 10, 30, and noon. [0:21:59] So probably gonna be during that time, okay. [0:22:01] Obviously the Christian church would be the next one, [0:22:04] would be the closest, and then the Methodist church [0:22:06] is behind it. I don't know that they're going to catch very much at all. It's going to be [0:22:11] busy. Everything's going to be facing away from them. So, and those two, both on 11, or [0:22:15] that neighborhood anyway. So, all right. I would support, and I don't know whether Rebecca [0:22:20] since you're the one that read it, or whether you would like to make the amendment. I'd [0:22:23] like to see an amendment that covers what you talked about. [0:22:26] Oh, if the maker of the motion and the second are okay with inclusion, maybe we could just [0:22:32] That's where I was going to go. [0:22:33] Is that correct? [0:22:34] So you're okay with just including more language about that on the supervisor. [0:22:37] Right. [0:22:38] I'll add them as well. [0:22:39] Okay. [0:22:40] Rebecca Mills-Soyka. [0:22:41] Thank you. [0:22:42] Anything further on this motion Council? [0:22:44] The aye. [0:22:45] Roll call vote? [0:22:46] Jim? [0:22:47] Yes. [0:22:48] Sean Bericher? [0:22:49] Yes. [0:22:50] Chris Chalkington? [0:22:51] Yes. [0:22:52] Greg Lanting? [0:22:53] Yes. [0:22:54] Don Hall? [0:22:55] Yes. [0:22:56] Rebecca Mills-Soyka? [0:22:57] Yes. [0:22:58] Suzanne Hopkins? [0:22:59] Yes. [0:23:00] Motion passes. [0:23:01] You have your events, sir. [0:23:02] All right. [0:23:03] Thank you. [0:23:04] Greg Lanny. [0:23:05] And Josh, just as Councilman Hawkins talked about, your Councilman person, Hawkins, excuse [0:23:10] me. [0:23:12] If you could make sure to contact those churches and also work with them, in other words, if [0:23:16] they think you're being too loud, be cognizant of that, at least until they get their services [0:23:21] done. [0:23:22] Yeah, definitely. [0:23:23] All right. [0:23:24] Thank you. [0:23:25] Thank you, sir. [0:23:26] Next item on the agenda is the consent calendar subtracted by number three items. [0:23:30] So I'll leave that to council's wishes. [0:23:33] Greg Lanning. [0:23:34] Move approval of the consent calendar as changed. [0:23:37] Second. [0:23:39] We have a motion on the floor. [0:23:40] Greg Lanning seconded by Suzanne Hawkins. [0:23:43] Rebecca Milsuk. [0:23:45] Thank you, Mayor. [0:23:46] Consent calendar is hefty today, so I apologize. [0:23:49] But I do have a quick question on four and five. [0:23:53] And then I would like to remove six and seven [0:23:56] for discussion. [0:24:00] We'll remove six and seven for discussion and you have some questions for four and five. [0:24:08] Yes, would you like me to ask those quick questions before we vote? [0:24:11] Please. [0:24:12] Okay. [0:24:20] So on number four, this item is on budgeted expenditure for a door for a safety concern, [0:24:28] which I don't have an issue with. [0:24:30] And at the risk of simplifying the issue, maybe too much, I was wondering what other alternatives [0:24:38] were looked at, such as technology, I know that, you know, like there are sound monitors [0:24:46] that you can hear in another room, even some with video. Maybe could you talk about some [0:24:54] of the alternatives that you considered? [0:24:56] Good evening, John Caten, Public Works Director. [0:24:59] Welcome, John. [0:25:01] Thank you. [0:25:03] We really didn't consider doing any sort of remote monitoring. [0:25:07] The proposal really was that the shop supervisor's office actually sits between these two base [0:25:17] spaces. [0:25:18] The one base space has a complete firewall with no access. [0:25:21] So with somebody working on that side without immediate supervision, there are some safety [0:25:28] concerns that the person could be injured. [0:25:31] So we really didn't consider a camera or sound monitor as much as you just add in the door. [0:25:40] Is there direct access? [0:25:42] So if there were some sort of monitor and you could hear into that room, can the supervisor [0:25:50] quickly access that base base or is it an issue of not being able to access? [0:25:54] You would need that. [0:25:56] You'd have to go through the shop and then outside and back in. [0:26:00] Okay. [0:26:01] there's another hallway just as you exit, but yeah, it would not be as fast. [0:26:06] Okay, so the issue is also access. [0:26:07] Yeah. [0:26:08] Okay, I appreciate that. [0:26:10] Okay. [0:26:11] I think the next question is for you as well. [0:26:15] Just quickly, I noticed in the report that, you know, this is to consider an unbudgeted [0:26:21] 8,950-elect expenditure from the general fund, but the structural analysis was done back in [0:26:28] 2009. [0:26:29] wondering why is there an immediate need for this now or why it wasn't budgeted or done [0:26:36] before now? [0:26:37] I did anticipate this question. [0:26:40] So fair question. [0:26:41] You know, this year we anticipated, we just hadn't gotten to dealing with the issue. [0:26:47] And what we were going to do is this year is the street department was going to demolish [0:26:51] it with their own forces. [0:26:54] But after we started to pull it from that, we realized that there's asbestos in light [0:26:58] of some things that have happened here recently with some other contractors in asbestos. [0:27:05] We decided to investigate the requirements. [0:27:08] There's the state requires a week-long course and annual training. [0:27:13] It's fairly in-depth. [0:27:14] So we decided that we had better step back from that. [0:27:18] Now as far as waiting and budgeting for it, we can do that. [0:27:22] There's not a huge hurry on this. [0:27:24] I like to, I always take adding things after the fact seriously. [0:27:30] The thing that Dean and I talked about is it's, people are starting to notice that it's vacant [0:27:36] now and windows are starting to get broken out, pages are starting to show up and we're [0:27:41] just waiting for that day where maybe someone goes in there. [0:27:44] Okay. [0:27:45] Yeah, I don't have any objection to the expense. [0:27:48] I just kind of wondered just after reading the letter and the analysis happening in 2009. [0:27:53] And I just wondered if there was a particular reason that it was coming out now, but just [0:27:58] curious. [0:27:59] Thank you. [0:28:00] I appreciate it. [0:28:01] Travis, how's it coming? [0:28:02] Yes. [0:28:03] So what's important about these two items is, especially on the asbestos one, is the intended [0:28:09] use is contingency funds. [0:28:11] And on an annual basis in the capital fund, the city council allocates about $200,000 for [0:28:17] the opportunity to use contingency. [0:28:19] And what maybe we haven't done in the past as well as we'd like to do is communicate [0:28:23] when those funds are being used. [0:28:25] And so part of this process is to enhance our communication [0:28:28] with the council when we are using those contingency funds. [0:28:31] Those contingency funds are for opportunities [0:28:33] that we can't necessarily foresee. [0:28:36] Things that come up and on an annual basis, [0:28:38] we budget that as part of the contingency. [0:28:40] And so they're not specifically budgeted for, [0:28:42] but they could be at some point in time [0:28:45] the use of contingency could be for both of them [0:28:48] if there was not funds available [0:28:50] in the respective funds to move forward. [0:28:53] Thank you. [0:28:54] Were you wanting to make a motion to take the two off that? [0:28:57] Oh, no. [0:28:58] Yeah, that's why I just had the question. [0:29:00] Well, 6-7, you can just ask them, OK? [0:29:03] Yeah. [0:29:03] So they're off. [0:29:04] Do you need a motion to remove those? [0:29:05] Well, we did for the three. [0:29:06] So let's go ahead and make a motion for 6-7. [0:29:09] I move that we remove 6-7, item 6-7 [0:29:12] from the consent calendar for discussion. [0:29:17] Section. [0:29:18] Motion on the floor by Rebecca Mills, [0:29:22] I guess seconded by Sean Barrett to remove those items and move them down to under items consideration [0:29:29] Lea the real call vote, please. Sean Barrett vote. Yes. Chris Tockington. Yes. Great glancing. Yes. Don Hall. Yes. Rebecca Masueka. Yes. Suzanne Hawkins. Yes. Jim Mine. Yes. [0:29:42] Yes. [0:29:44] I move those items down to our motion passes, I've moved those items down after, well, I'll [0:29:50] just tell you when they come along, we're moving three to two and six and seven to three [0:29:56] and four. [0:29:58] There's no way you're going to keep up on that, but I'll keep you informed. [0:30:02] So we need a motion for the consent calendar still, minus all those others that we already [0:30:07] have. [0:30:08] I think we have. [0:30:09] Okay. [0:30:10] Thank you. [0:30:11] All the listed changes. [0:30:14] The island roll call roll, please. [0:30:18] Chris Talkington. [0:30:19] Yes. [0:30:20] Greg Lanting. [0:30:21] Yes. [0:30:22] Don Hall. [0:30:23] Yes. [0:30:24] Rebecca Milsoica. [0:30:25] Yes. [0:30:25] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:30:26] Yes. [0:30:27] Jim Mone. [0:30:28] Yes. [0:30:29] Sean Berriger. [0:30:30] Yes. [0:30:31] Motion passes seven to zero. [0:30:32] We're moving to item number one. [0:30:34] There's two items under number one. [0:30:36] We're going to start with the presentation [0:30:38] of a post-advanced certificate for Officer Justin [0:30:42] Hendrickson and then we're going to follow that up with the swearing in ceremony for Twin Falls Police Department's newest police officer [0:30:49] Matt Faronado [0:30:51] and [0:30:52] We're going to start with Captain Anthony Barnhart and then Chief Brown pipe [0:30:59] Thank you, Mr. Mayor and members of the Council [0:31:01] For giving us this opportunity tonight to recognize and honor the achievements of our employees [0:31:07] It is vitally important to us that we have a well-trained professional police department capable of providing the best [0:31:13] possible public service to our community and I think that everyone would agree [0:31:17] with that. Tonight we will be recognizing Officer Justin Henderson with his advanced [0:31:22] certificate. It takes hundreds of training hours, college credit, and time and service [0:31:28] to achieve this particular certificate. I would ask that Justin please come forward [0:31:33] now and also Mayor Hall and Chief Pike to present the certificate. Justin Henderson [0:31:43] was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department on January 2nd, 2003 as a full-time police officer. [0:31:51] Justin was born in Twin Falls. He graduated from Kimberly High School and attended the College of Southern Idaho. [0:31:58] Prior to his employment with our department, Justin worked as a transportation technician with the Idaho Transportation Department. [0:32:06] During his employment with the Twin Falls Police Department, Justin has served as an narcotics detective, [0:32:11] has been a member of the SWAT team for eight years and is currently assigned to the traffic unit and is a field training officer. [0:32:18] Justin was awarded his basic certificate from the Post Academy on December 29, 2003, and his intermediate certificate on February 27, 2009. [0:32:31] It is with great pleasure that we present Justin with the Advanced Certificate from the State of Idaho Peace Officer Standards and Training Council. [0:32:40] Thank you, Mayor, and members of the Council. [0:33:16] Tonight, once again, I have an honor of swearing in one of our newest members, Matt Ferranado. [0:33:22] The police profession is a challenging and rewarding career, and I've heard this many times from [0:33:26] Chief Mundt, and several times from Chief DeVore. [0:33:29] They told us law enforcement is a noble and honorable profession, and I believe that it [0:33:33] is. [0:33:34] It requires the discipline to handle difficult and dynamic situations, the courage to face [0:33:39] adversity to go to the fight, to stand in the gap, sympathy and compassion as you help [0:33:45] individuals and families through their most difficult struggles, the clarity of thought [0:33:50] associated with the life and death decision. [0:33:53] Now though those moments are few and far in between, the same thought process is carried [0:33:57] out daily in the application of force, judgment, and discernment, Matt, the expectation for [0:34:03] you will be no different. [0:34:05] We believe you have the background, the temperament, the education, and the life experience to serve our community in this role. [0:34:13] Council, let me introduce you to our newest officer. [0:34:16] Matt Ferrinato was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department on March 24, 2014 as a full time police officer. [0:34:23] Matt was born in San Bernardino, California. [0:34:26] He and his family moved to Boise, Idaho when he was five years old. [0:34:29] Matt graduated from Eagle High School in 2009 and then moved to Twin Falls to further his education [0:34:34] College of Southern Idaho. Matt graduated from CSI's law enforcement program in May [0:34:39] of 2011. While attending CSI he worked as a security officer for the college. Matt [0:34:45] participated in the Twin Falls Police Department's Explorer program from [0:34:48] January 2010 to April 2011. After graduating from CSI in May of 2011 he obtained [0:34:55] employment with the Blaine County Sheriff's Office and then just after a short [0:34:59] six months I believe in the detention centers where Matt started he went to work [0:35:03] for the Haley Police Department. That was awarded as basic certification from the Post Academy [0:35:08] in May of 2012. Matt, tonight the ceremony really consists of two parts, the painting of the police [0:35:15] badge and the oath of office administered by Mayor Hall. The oath that you're about to take [0:35:19] tonight represents the heart of everything that we stand for in law enforcement. These are [0:35:23] more than words repeated and a paper signed. The badge that you'll receive tonight represents [0:35:29] this commitment. It's the symbol of your office and the trust that the community has given you [0:35:34] in performing your job. [0:35:36] By raising your hand and affirming your commitment [0:35:37] to provide public safety to our community, [0:35:39] you'll be empowered to perform the functions of your job. [0:35:42] My charge to you is to be always mindful [0:35:45] of the community's trust and every diligent in your duties. [0:36:10] Please raise your feet after me. [0:36:13] I am the Dean. [0:36:15] I am not fair enough to solve this work, [0:36:18] to solve this work that I will support [0:36:20] the Constitution of the United States of America, [0:36:22] that I will support the Constitution and the Constitution [0:36:26] in laws of the state of Iowa, in a constitution, [0:36:29] in laws of the state of Iowa, [0:36:30] and the laws of ordinances of the city of Twin Falls, [0:36:33] and the laws of ordinances of the city of Twin Falls. [0:36:36] In the rules and regulations, [0:36:38] and the rules and regulations of the Twin Falls, [0:36:41] please partner with the law's place of crime. [0:36:43] And then I will, let I will, well and faithfully discharge. [0:36:48] Well, it basically just, the duties of the office [0:36:52] of the police officer, the duties of office [0:36:55] I guess I just want to say, again, congratulations to Justin. [0:38:00] I suck my gut up when I was up there with Justin because he, we, we do presume you should [0:38:05] suit together, and he routinely beats me up every Tuesday night, so I was trying to put [0:38:10] my best foot forward. [0:38:11] I've known Matt for a while, I've graduated from the CSI law enforcement program, congratulations, [0:38:18] and you're going to have a great career here. [0:38:21] Friends and family, if you want to leave, you certainly can, because that's what always happens [0:38:25] out here. [0:38:26] So we'll give you just a little bit of a break so you can leave. [0:38:28] Thank you for coming this evening. [0:38:48] Dennis. [0:38:49] Okay. [0:38:51] Now comes the confusing part. [0:38:53] We will move to item number three under consent calendar, which is now our new item number two. [0:39:00] Consideration of a request to grant additional time for the use of amplified noise for [0:39:05] the Lighthouse Church on Easter Sunday, April 20, 2014. [0:39:09] Densepolar. [0:39:11] Thank you, Mayor Hall, City Council. [0:39:14] We received a request through a special event application. [0:39:18] It's been three or four weeks ago from the Lighthouse Church located at 960 Eastland Drive. [0:39:23] requesting to hold their church service on Easter Sunday on April 20th, [0:39:27] requesting to hold their service on their football if they're not familiar with that, [0:39:31] which in itself is not an issue. However, [0:39:35] their PUD that the city has approved in the past [0:39:39] states that they can have amplified [0:39:43] noise or the use of their PA system from 10 a.m. in the morning until [0:39:47] 10 p.m. in the evening. The request for this event [0:39:51] start their service, actually not start their service at nine o'clock, but to start warming [0:39:55] up and playing soft music at nine o'clock in the morning. However, by doing so, it does [0:40:01] change the hours and the time frame for that event. After discussing this with all several [0:40:07] city staff members from different city entities and speaking with planning and zoning department [0:40:15] on this, we have approved on our end of this application. [0:40:20] We have advised the staff from the church [0:40:23] that, as we talked earlier regarding the other issue, [0:40:27] we need to keep the noise level down. [0:40:30] They assure me it's just gonna be soft music, [0:40:32] and at some point, they will have a live band out there [0:40:35] starting at 10 o'clock, so they will be doing some sound checks [0:40:38] with their instruments before the 10 o'clock original [0:40:43] time frame allows for the music to be in. You know Dennis when I first saw this item, I the [0:40:49] question that came to my mind is do the neighbors know that you're going to drop it down to nine [0:40:54] o'clock and it seems like you've taken mitigated measures here to have the on-duty supervisor [0:41:01] to be able to go in and ask them to turn it off if there's a problem. But I think it's [0:41:06] just really important for us to let the neighbors know that we are concerned with their quality [0:41:12] of life issues to nine o'clock on a Sunday morning [0:41:15] for some people, that's pretty early. [0:41:17] Yes, and I agree with that, and I'm not sure [0:41:20] if we had a representative show up or not from the church. [0:41:24] Apparently not, I did leave a couple of messages today [0:41:26] and advised them a week ago, we were coming, [0:41:30] but we can certainly, with your wishes include that, [0:41:34] we can pass that on to them if you go forward with them. [0:41:39] Council wishes on this agenda item. [0:41:42] Greg Lanning. [0:41:43] Move, approval. [0:41:44] Second. [0:41:45] We have a motion on the floor by Greg Lanning, seconded by Rebecca Milsoyka to approve the [0:41:52] motion. [0:41:53] Anything further on the motion council? [0:41:55] Will you add the roll call vote please? [0:41:59] Greg Lanning? [0:42:00] Yes. [0:42:01] Don Hall? [0:42:02] Yes. [0:42:03] Rebecca Milsoyka? [0:42:05] Yes. [0:42:06] Suzanne Hawkins? [0:42:07] Yes. [0:42:08] Jim Munn? [0:42:09] Yes. [0:42:10] Sean Berriger? [0:42:11] Yes. [0:42:12] His talking. [0:42:13] Yes. [0:42:14] Motion passes 7-0. [0:42:15] Thank you, Dennis. [0:42:16] I'm sure they're going to be good neighbors just as we spoke about, but, you know, nine [0:42:23] o'clock's early. [0:42:25] Thank you. [0:42:26] Next item is we're going back up to item number six under the consent calendar. [0:42:30] Consideration of a request to approve the final plat of the Riverhawk Commercial Subdivision, [0:42:35] a PUD, located at the southwest corner of Washington Street North and Chaney Drive West. [0:42:42] Mitch Humboldt. [0:42:44] I can ask my question so much doesn't have to guess what I'm wondering about. [0:42:55] And this may be a legal question for Fritz as well. [0:42:59] I noticed in the reports, and this is on, they kind of go together the final plat and the [0:43:06] PUD. [0:43:07] But in the reports, on December 13, 2011, the commission approved a final two-year extension, [0:43:15] which expire January 12th of 2014. [0:43:18] Oh, sorry, it approved a final two-year extension of the preliminary plat subject to the four [0:43:25] conditions, but my question is, when a preliminary plat expires, what is the process? [0:43:35] Does it need to go back through the process, and so in that case, we wouldn't be able to [0:43:40] approve it tonight since it was last seen. [0:43:43] I think it had two extensions according to this report, so the last public hearing took [0:43:49] place in January of 2010. [0:43:52] We just need the final plat to be submitted prior to the expiration of the preliminary [0:43:58] plat. [0:43:59] And the preliminary plat, what you guys are considering tonight is the final plat, and [0:44:04] so it's application. [0:44:12] So the application for the final plat came in before the preliminary plat expired, therefore [0:44:16] the final plan is a valid application and we can continue to move on it. [0:44:22] Okay, so it just has to be submitted not approved? [0:44:25] Right. Make application for before the expiration of the preliminary plan and that was done. [0:44:33] Okay, and that's your conclusion as well for it. [0:44:36] Okay, just needed to ask about that. [0:44:39] My other question is that one of those four conditions, number three, subject to a cross-use [0:44:44] agreement for parking, drainage, ingress and egress, etcetera, along Chaney Drive, right [0:44:52] next to where this final plat will be, there's heavy flooding when it rains. So there doesn't [0:44:59] seem that there's sufficient drainage or stormwater function there. I'm not sure maybe Jackie [0:45:09] can inform us of what's going on there, but in just looking at one of the agreements, I [0:45:14] I just don't know how they're going to continue with the, or maybe my question is, what does [0:45:23] a cross-use agreement look like for parking and drainage, whereas they're having flooding [0:45:30] problems now and it's also significantly under-parked when there is a large event. [0:45:44] Okay, so the cross-use agreement between is for the lots within this plait. [0:45:51] there's four or five lots on this plat. [0:45:55] The cross-use agreement allows them to kind of park [0:45:57] on one another's lots to drain together [0:46:00] into a common drainage area, those kinds of things [0:46:03] that'll come along with the development [0:46:04] of that five acre property. [0:46:08] All that stuff is independent of what's going on [0:46:10] in the roadway, and it's not. [0:46:12] Okay, so that's not related to the development. [0:46:15] Just for the property included in the plat, [0:46:18] and it's just so they can kind of all develop together. [0:46:20] And if one lot needs a few extra parking spaces [0:46:23] and this one can provide, they can kind of work together [0:46:25] to provide those and they can all go [0:46:27] to a common retention pond and those kinds of things. [0:46:30] This five acres will have to provide retention [0:46:33] to meet code when it develops. [0:46:35] And that allows that to happen in a single retention pond [0:46:40] for the five acres that's developing here. [0:46:43] Okay, thank you for clarifying that. [0:46:44] And is there an opportunity here [0:46:47] to address the flooding on Sheenie Drive? [0:46:49] is that a separate issue? [0:46:51] I've had several comments on it just every time it rains. [0:46:54] That floods right in front of Walmart [0:46:56] and across from Canyon Ridge. [0:46:58] And so, of course, one of the subject conditions [0:47:04] to these plats and these developments [0:47:05] is to build according to city standards. [0:47:08] But yet we have this flooding on Cheney is, [0:47:11] do you know what that's related to [0:47:12] or what people can expect in possibly alleviating [0:47:15] that flooding there? [0:47:19] development of this particular parcel should not add to that flooding. [0:47:25] So, in fact, because it's not dirt anymore, there's some management that's going on with [0:47:32] the water that's created on the surface. [0:47:36] At some point in time in the recent past, we did some improvements to the river zone, a drainage [0:47:45] connection that was not made, and you couldn't see it because it was subsurface, and we believe [0:47:50] we corrected that and so most of the every time it rains flooding should be minimized. [0:47:58] We shouldn't have the sea of water out there that we've had in the past. [0:48:02] We'll have it again when we have 100 gear storms, things that exceed our design parameters, [0:48:08] but we believe that it's become much more controlled with the efforts that we've put into [0:48:15] the making the fix currently. [0:48:19] Okay, and what was the date of that fix was that just recently? [0:48:23] Well, it wasn't in the last three months, and quite honestly, it's like within a year. [0:48:31] Was it the day before yesterday? Yeah, it was within the last three years. [0:48:35] I think it was during the last summer. [0:48:38] So it's been a little bit, and as soon as the fix was constructed, [0:48:46] we were watching it, you know, you wait for the rain and somebody runs out there and takes [0:48:50] a look to see what's happening, try to see if we need to do more. [0:48:54] Okay. [0:48:57] Thank you for that information. [0:48:58] Kristoff. [0:48:59] I'm not sure this is the appropriate time for us. [0:49:02] I need an interpretation of the, I know we're going for final plat approval and the PUD and [0:49:10] the C1 zone. [0:49:12] I'm concerned about the proximity to the school that this proposed development. [0:49:19] A list of allowed uses are provided, but I am concerned that the proximity to school that we should make the extraordinary effort of not allowing a bar for lack of a better word. [0:49:34] Open alcohol to be served within that close proximity to school. [0:49:37] convenience stores and sporting goods stores sell beer and wine and bulk [0:49:45] packaging but I'm very concerned that we need to be a specific enough and do not [0:49:50] allow the the C1 siding of a bar or an open container facility so is this the [0:49:56] appropriate time? Renee is whispering to me that and I'm looking for it and the [0:50:05] permitted use as a bar is not one of the listed permitted uses. Well we listed the [0:50:09] permitted uses and I didn't see that there I could have overlooked it Renee. [0:50:13] I'm looking on page 61 and it shows permitted but not non permitted. So we're [0:50:28] saying if it's not a permitted use it's a not permitted use. That's clear in [0:50:32] government ease. There's no way that can become a wiggle factor and all the ones we [0:50:37] start having open beer served. They could ask for an amendment to the PD but they [0:50:44] We still have a problem with state statute on a location within 250 feet, I think that's the number. [0:50:52] Travis, did you want to make comment? [0:51:05] Travis? [0:51:12] Rebecca Milsorgen. [0:51:13] Thank you Mayor. [0:51:14] Just one final comment. [0:51:16] I realize this has already been rezoned and when the preliminary plot was passed, one of [0:51:23] the conditions according to the state statute is that it be in conformance with the comprehensive [0:51:29] plan. [0:51:30] And on the report, it says the comprehensive plan is medium density residential. [0:51:37] Is that accurate? [0:51:44] It's on the first page of the report. [0:52:17] Renee Caraway. [0:52:20] The answer that quicker than he can find it. [0:52:22] You're correct. [0:52:23] I'm Renee Caraway, zoning and development manager. [0:52:27] The zoning of the process did occur five, six years ago. [0:52:32] It was determined at that time that you're correct on a comprehensive plan, [0:52:37] their land use designations across the street of this was commercial and it was determined [0:52:43] by the council at that time that this was consistent enough with the development in that [0:52:48] corridor. This was the school property and they were the ones that were the applicant and [0:52:53] were in full support of that development taking place. [0:52:58] Okay. Does that answer your question? [0:53:01] Yes, it does answer it. That brings up a legal question for Fritz. Does that create some problems if it's not, if the zoning, I mean obviously it's already happened, but in approving this final plat, it's not in accordance with the comprehensive plan. [0:53:23] Does that bring up any issues? [0:53:25] I'm sorry, I was not going to travel. [0:53:27] Oh, I apologize. [0:53:29] So I apologize. [0:53:30] I'll repeat. [0:53:31] So the comprehensive plan actually [0:53:32] designates this area as medium density residential. [0:53:37] It was rezoned to C1. [0:53:38] So it is now commercial. [0:53:40] But in approving the final plat, it's actually not. [0:53:44] So the rights are established at the time of application. [0:53:49] And so this started a long time ago for them. [0:53:52] So the fact that the comp plan now designates it [0:53:55] as medium density residential that wouldn't change in it. [0:53:59] Did the comp plan designate it as medium residential [0:54:03] at the time of freezing? [0:54:04] I assume it designated it in a way it could be used. [0:54:14] I assume that it was. [0:54:15] I don't know. [0:54:19] OK, thank you. [0:54:27] Great landing. [0:54:28] Well, I'm looking at it and I can see Rebecca's point, [0:54:31] but obviously that is not going to develop [0:54:35] was medium density residential at this point where you've got Walmart across the [0:54:40] street and likely to have commercial entities across the other direction [0:54:45] from it so council at that time must have chosen to even if it was medium [0:54:52] density residential I believe we still have the ability to zone things if we [0:54:58] entered if sometimes the compound does not keep up with the growth as it occurs [0:55:02] So I would be you know if we need to go in and change the complement to some matches [0:55:06] I wouldn't have any problem with that [0:55:11] As far as the drainage and things like that [0:55:14] Then there are a few times of the rain and I agreed that there sometimes this is a problem of the street [0:55:18] But some of that's actually coming off these lots. I mean even though they're dirt. They still do manage to [0:55:23] Drain a little bit that way. So this I think this will actually alleviate the problem [0:55:28] somewhat by the fact that it will be [0:55:30] developed in a common draining jury will will come into play and the same thing on [0:55:37] that R1 PUD one more additional thought the applicant owns the land and they're [0:55:42] the most they're the closest neighbor and so they would be the most affected if [0:55:45] they agree what do we care just getting back to Rebecca this was initially [0:55:54] approved in 2008 the complaint was approved in 2009 okay so it may or may not [0:56:01] I don't have to assume it was in compliance at the time they applied for it or would not have gone forward or they would have asked for a change at that time. [0:56:13] Okay. Thank you. [0:56:15] Sean Berger. [0:56:16] Hey, I was just going to comment on the zoning map that's in the packet actually shows that the property where Canyon Ridge High School is is actually zoned R2. [0:56:25] And this is a small strip of C1PUD, so I would guess that that was probably R2, that strip [0:56:34] when they brought it through the initial application process since it appears it would [0:56:40] have been carved out of that larger piece of property. [0:56:43] Travis, did you have a comment? [0:56:47] Yeah, so I think it's important to recognize that in 2007 when the application went through, [0:56:52] I think it's what it says, right, Mitch? [0:56:54] That in order for, it was obviously pre the 2008 [0:56:59] Comp Plan. [0:57:00] In order for the Council at that time in the Planning and Zoning [0:57:02] Commission to find this a qualified use, [0:57:06] they had to have found it to be in compliance with the comprehensive [0:57:09] plan at that time, is what Mitch is sharing with me. [0:57:13] So at that point in time, we have to believe [0:57:16] that those who were sitting here found it to be in compliance [0:57:20] with that plan at that time. [0:57:27] Rebecca, your lights don't. [0:57:30] Did that answer your question for item number seven as well? [0:57:33] Did you have questions regarding item number seven? [0:57:37] I think that that answers my question. [0:57:39] I think it's a pretty complex issue, especially considering [0:57:45] that it's been quite a few years since the last public hearing. [0:57:48] That does concern me a bit. [0:57:49] And even though it's within, you know, [0:57:54] And it was submitted before it expired. [0:57:57] That still concerns me a little bit, but it does answer my question, thank you. [0:58:04] Thank you, Jim. [0:58:05] Thank you, Mayor. [0:58:06] Well, I'm trying to understand exactly what the concern is from Rebecca. [0:58:12] Can you help me understand? [0:58:15] Yes, the concern is that it's not in compliance with the comprehensive plan as reported. [0:58:21] So we have to believe that it was. [0:58:23] Okay, so the concern is maybe the council or city staff made a mistake back in 2006 or 2007 or 2008? [0:58:32] No, I'm not concerned with what was done in the past. I'm just concerned with my approval of something that I don't mean. [0:58:38] Okay, well, I'm just trying to understand because if there's an assertion that something may have gone wrong or the city council or city staff didn't do a proper analysis in 2008 [0:58:51] And a subsequent approval now may throw us into some sort of legal entanglement. [0:58:55] Is that kind of what you were thinking about? [0:58:57] No, I have not commented on any value judgment on what was done in the past. [0:59:04] I'm just trying to understand how we got here today and whether I believe it should be approved. [0:59:10] Okay, I just want to clarify my questions. [0:59:12] Yeah, just with your line of questioning, I was concerned if are we missing something here we need to be looking at. [0:59:17] and apparently we're not. [0:59:21] Okay, thank you. [0:59:23] Chris, talking. [0:59:24] Well, I think the missing ingredient is our awareness [0:59:27] at about that time. [0:59:28] I think I went off the council on five or six, [0:59:31] and about that time, Washington was being designated [0:59:35] as a truck route, an alternative alternate bypass. [0:59:40] Development started getting serious, [0:59:41] the state was coming in thinking about rebuilding, [0:59:45] and that became a real growth corridor, [0:59:47] And there's just no doubt that there isn't a place along [0:59:51] Washington now, North is now seated for residential. [0:59:55] The highest and best used, my favorite realtor's terms, [1:00:00] is probably commercial in this area. [1:00:02] You might make an argument in treating on Chaney [1:00:07] to the West, you might get in the marginal area, [1:00:10] but that gets back to Greg's point [1:00:11] that the property most affected is the school district. [1:00:14] And if they're applying for it, [1:00:16] and they should have no problem with this. [1:00:19] I don't think there's anything more than the fact [1:00:22] that growth's got ahead of the comp plan. [1:00:25] I'm gonna repeat these two items. [1:00:26] There's six and seven under consent calendar [1:00:28] that we move down to items for consideration. [1:00:31] Consideration of a request to approve the final plot [1:00:34] of the Riverhawk Commercial Subdivision APUD [1:00:37] located at the southwest corner of Washington Street, [1:00:39] North and Cheney drive west, [1:00:41] as well as consideration of a request [1:00:44] to approve the Riverhawk commercial. [1:00:46] So you won the U.D. agreement between the city of Twin Falls [1:00:50] and the Twin Falls school district number 411. [1:00:53] For instance, can we take both of those in the same motion [1:00:55] since they were both on this consent calendar, [1:00:57] cleaner due to two motions? [1:00:59] Very good. [1:01:00] We have a motion on number six, Schonberger. [1:01:04] As I would move to approve the final plat [1:01:08] of the Riverhawk Commercial Subdivision PUD [1:01:12] consisting of 4.2 plus or minus acres [1:01:15] and five commercial lots as presented subject [1:01:18] to the conditions outlined. [1:01:22] Second. [1:01:22] We have a motion on four by Sean Berger, [1:01:25] seconded by Rebecca Melsoica. [1:01:27] Rebecca Melsoica. [1:01:28] Thank you, Mayor. [1:01:29] I seconded it to move the item forward. [1:01:31] And I agree that the C1 zoning does seem to be appropriate [1:01:36] for all the other criteria that you establish [1:01:40] for a final plat. [1:01:42] And I agree that it should be C1, [1:01:44] But the only problem I'm having is that I think maybe [1:01:46] for a correct process we probably needed to update [1:01:51] the comp plan so it would be in conformance [1:01:53] because the plan needs to be in conformance [1:01:57] with the comprehensive plan. [1:02:00] And right now it's not so. [1:02:03] Anything further around that motion council? [1:02:05] We had a roll call vote please. [1:02:09] Yes. [1:02:12] No. [1:02:15] Yes. [1:02:16] Yes. [1:02:19] Yes. [1:02:21] Yes. [1:02:23] Yes, motion passes six to one Greg landing move approval of consideration of where we're hop commercial C1 [1:02:30] PUD agreement between the city to unfals and the turnfalls go district for 11 including the three conditions as [1:02:38] outlined in the [1:02:41] Plan second motion on floor by Greg landing seconded by Suzanne Hawk and say anything further on the motion council [1:02:48] We're back in that second. [1:02:50] Thank you, Mayor. [1:02:51] Just one question on the PUD under C on page two. [1:02:55] The hours of operation, there's no restriction of hours of operation for non-retail uses. [1:03:01] What would be an example of a non-retail use? [1:03:04] You get an office building? [1:03:07] Okay, so no restriction of hours. [1:03:09] And that's consistent with our code. [1:03:11] Okay, thank you. [1:03:12] I see no further lies. [1:03:15] Leila, roll call vote, please. [1:03:20] Yes. [1:03:23] Yes. [1:03:24] Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 7 to 0. Just let folks know we do have public hearings that state that they will start no sooner than six o'clock. City staff that are here for long term planning. I'm probably going to move you after the public hearings. We have three public hearings this evening. Just want to give you fair warning and you're fair warning to the rest of the audience out there that we're barely off the consent calendar. It's almost six. [1:03:56] So we're going to forge ahead. [1:03:59] Next item on the agenda is consideration of a request [1:04:02] to recommend to the county commissioners that Ryan Higley [1:04:06] be appointed as an area of impact member of that planning [1:04:10] and zoning commission. [1:04:12] Just wanted to report to the council that we had [1:04:16] advertised for planning and zoning members for our commission [1:04:21] on two different occasions. [1:04:23] We had to reopen it a couple of times to give a sufficient amount of folks interested [1:04:28] in those positions and specifically that the position this evening is going to be for the [1:04:35] area of impact. [1:04:36] And I'm not sure is Ryan here? [1:04:38] Ryan, are you here? [1:04:40] Excellent. [1:04:41] Probably call you up in just a minute, Ryan. [1:04:43] I had the opportunity to interview Ryan. [1:04:45] He was the only applicant from the area of impact, found that his credentials in appraisal [1:04:52] And his experience, we believe, will be a attribute [1:04:57] to the Planning and Zoning Commission. [1:04:59] And he has passed through our extensive background process. [1:05:06] And I am making the recommendation to the Council [1:05:09] this evening to recommend to the County Commissioners [1:05:12] that he be our area of impact Planning and Zoning Commission. [1:05:17] Chris, talking. [1:05:18] Well, it's sad that we only have one application, [1:05:20] I'm sure Ryan is qualified, but I have a procedural problem, Mayor. [1:05:26] Why is not the P and Z liaison interviewing on this? [1:05:30] Well, with our transparency regulations and guidelines now, if I start bringing in more [1:05:39] folks on that commission or on that committee, it becomes a committee of the council. [1:05:45] Then we have to open that up to the [1:05:48] Media and the public to come in on the interviews, and it is my intention my intention was never to open up the interview processes [1:05:57] to anyone so that we could have a [1:06:01] better [1:06:03] Ability to sit down with folks and get to know them in the interview process [1:06:06] So it's your intent to hold all the interviews for [1:06:10] Ladies and positions in the future without the input of the council [1:06:14] Well, your input is now. [1:06:16] Now, bring these to you. [1:06:18] No, I was not at the interview step. [1:06:21] I have to oppose that dramatically. [1:06:24] Absolutely not democratic. [1:06:26] And I don't think having two council people [1:06:29] violates the transparency unless I'm misinterpreting it. [1:06:32] Well, and why would we have a liaison from the council [1:06:35] if they don't interview an applicant [1:06:38] to serve on that commission? [1:06:40] Rebecca Milsica. [1:06:42] Thank you, Mayor. [1:06:43] I was going to ask that same question as the liaison to planning and zoning and just as a [1:06:49] recommendation to the process. [1:06:51] I really appreciate that we opened up to the public. [1:06:53] I think that was a great improvement on the process. [1:06:56] And I recognize that the code gives the mayor the opportunity to appoint two members here. [1:07:00] She wishes and that is true. [1:07:03] I think the check and balance in the system is that the council is asked to approve. [1:07:07] And so I agree with Chris. [1:07:09] I would feel better. [1:07:10] I wouldn't violate our transparency resolution to have the liaison and the mayor do interviews. [1:07:17] And I think it just would help me in approving because you have more information. [1:07:22] You have the same information that you've had in the interview, which is helpful. [1:07:27] I think it can only help the process. [1:07:29] And my request would be to include the liaison on the interviews, but do respect your choices, [1:07:36] mayor. [1:07:37] But it will be difficult in the future. [1:07:39] Of course tonight is not difficult at all because we're all very grateful for this volunteer that stepped forward. [1:07:46] And I'm sure he will be an asset to the Planning and Zoning Commission. [1:07:49] I also want to say thank you to Lee Devore who served for several years, I think a total of six. [1:07:55] I think his has allowed years and really did great service for the Planning and Zoning Commission and appreciate that. [1:08:03] And I am sure that Mr. Higley will do a great job as well and appreciate his desire to volunteer in the community. [1:08:10] Thank you, Rebecca. [1:08:12] Jim? [1:08:13] Thank you, Mayor. [1:08:14] I guess this does now fall to an legal analysis as to whether or not the Mayor's process and [1:08:22] appointing people to commissions does in fact violate the transparency. [1:08:25] So I would call the city attorney to the stand if he would come up here. [1:08:28] And I would ask you, the assertions by Council [1:08:34] persons Rebecca Milsoyka and Chris Talkington, [1:08:37] is that accurate? [1:08:40] Is it accurate in that it doesn't violate the transparency [1:08:45] provisions to allow these liaisons to participate? [1:08:49] What the resolution says is no more than two elected city [1:08:52] council persons may serve on any committee, [1:08:55] including ad hoc groups and subcommittees [1:08:58] created by statute ordinance or other legislative act. [1:09:02] So I would say it's not in violation [1:09:04] of the transparency resolution. [1:09:07] I would caution you, however, the committees [1:09:10] that you had before that did this interviewing also [1:09:13] were not in violation of any law, [1:09:15] and you got in trouble for it, so. [1:09:18] Well, you got in the line of media. [1:09:21] I.E. from the media, which whatever, [1:09:24] not that I'm being disrespectful of the media, [1:09:26] But who cares, the second quote is who cares. [1:09:33] So if the mayor would in fact appoint a public or excuse me a planning and zoning liaison to his selection committee, [1:09:46] it wouldn't violate the transparency code or the transparency ordinance. [1:09:51] It would not. [1:09:55] Okay. I mean, that's where we need to know that. [1:09:57] But I'm just going to caution you have any time you start talking about the mayor appointing people [1:10:02] and having committees, the media is going to think you've got things that should be open to the public [1:10:08] and you're going to get in trouble for not providing public notice and inviting the media to those meetings. [1:10:14] Right. Even though it's not in violation of the transparency resolution. [1:10:18] Right. And that and that to add to the to the mayor's, I'm not speaking for the mayor, [1:10:24] but it would seem to me that people are probably not going to be, well, people who apply for [1:10:31] these positions were having problems anyway, are not going to probably want to sit through [1:10:36] an interview with the Times News and K&VT cameras in the room. [1:10:42] I would suspect that's not going to be very much fun. [1:10:45] So I understand that. [1:10:47] I guess we aren't a bit of a dilemma here. [1:10:51] So before I call on, it certainly sounds like I could invite, as long as I don't do it up [1:10:57] here and make a committee, invite the liaison and I'd be more than willing to do that. [1:11:02] But I just want to be cautious about having the appearance that we, as you said, got in [1:11:08] trouble for before. [1:11:09] Okay, so I just want to give you a little history. [1:11:12] Before this council did not create any of those committees that you got in trouble for. [1:11:18] They were not legal committees. [1:11:20] were not subject to the open meeting law, but you got in trouble for them just the same. [1:11:26] So I'm telling you, Mayor, if you start appointing groups to do interviews, it's going to look [1:11:32] like, to the public, it's going to look like you're doing the public business in private. [1:11:38] That's what I was trying to forgo. [1:11:41] Greg Lanning. [1:11:43] Well, this seems like our conversation is during that time redoxed, and I have since I'm [1:11:49] the most immediate past mayor and I could see this exact problem coming forth when we started [1:11:56] discussing it and I was of the same opinion that Don is that I was not going to open up [1:12:03] interviews for somebody wanting to be on one of our commissions to the public because like [1:12:09] we said Ryan I apologize to this because I look at your resume I think you're a great [1:12:15] candidate and that says nothing to do with you. I want you to realize that. Nothing at all. [1:12:23] If I had been mayor for another two years, I probably would have followed the same plan just [1:12:28] for the fact that I didn't want to run afoul of a resolution or the spirit of our [1:12:36] relatives for the one of their word. We've been through that word around before and how do you [1:12:40] decide what the spirit of something is? That's in everybody's heart is the spirit. So if I will [1:12:46] come down as I did that. If Don wants to have someone else there, I enter my thought process. [1:12:52] He can, if he wants to have a liaison's there, I'm fine with that. And I would not recommend [1:12:57] he open them up. And we'll just let the flak lands where it lands. And if he chooses to [1:13:02] do it individually, and I believe those candidates are solid, this is my opportunity. The code says [1:13:08] the mare points, the council confirms. It doesn't talk about liaison's interviewing and any [1:13:14] putting in our things of the other sides of it that way and I believe those candidates [1:13:19] are strong and need to be appointed. I will be voting yes. [1:13:22] Suzanne Hawkins. [1:13:25] Greg took some of what I wanted to say. Having one other council member in the interview [1:13:30] process to me is not giving the other five of us any more information than what we have [1:13:34] tonight anyway. So I think it is our chance tonight if we have questions of the candidate [1:13:39] to ask those questions tonight if we have something we're not comfortable with. But I feel like [1:13:44] you bringing the candidates before us and keeping all six of us on an even playing field is [1:13:49] fair to the group as a whole. Thank you, Chris Stockington. If you're like, I'm opposing [1:13:56] motherhood and apple pie up here. But tell you what, we're going the opposite way of transparency. [1:14:03] The mayor and this form of government is the parliamentarian. He signs payrolls or paychecks [1:14:08] or proclamations, he does not rubber stamp or provide a rubber stamping for the council. [1:14:15] I cannot see how this interpretation will mean less, anything except less visibility [1:14:22] for the public and certainly the council by accepting your edicts. [1:14:28] That's just not the type of government that is serving the public well. [1:14:34] And I'm not going to vote against a well qualified person like you, but I have to tell you that I think the power has gone to your head. [1:14:43] Well, Chris, the power has not gone to my head. I'm trying to do the right thing for folks that are applying for positions within our city and trying to make the process as less cumbersome and comfortable as possible. [1:15:00] possible. It's already a difficult enough process just to put your name out there and to be put [1:15:06] in the public forum. I think all seven of us could talk about that all night. But my job, [1:15:15] two things that I want to do as the mayor. One is when people come up here to testify, [1:15:20] I want to make it as comfortable as possible. It's not going to be comfortable because you're [1:15:24] coming up here. You've got a mic stuck in your face. There's cameras looking at you. You're [1:15:28] on the web and there are seven people up here staring down at you and people behind you. [1:15:33] But I'm trying to make it as comfortable as possible because it's already nerve wracking [1:15:37] and this is a process that I think is the right way of doing it and you can see the power [1:15:42] is going to my head and that I'm doing edicts, I'm doing what the Idaho Code says that I can [1:15:47] do and I'm going to continue doing it. [1:15:50] Rebecca, I'll sort you out. [1:15:51] Thank you, Mayor. [1:15:52] Yeah, I think I have a little bit of a different perspective. [1:15:55] I actually, you know, I would disagree that anyone got in trouble, you know, I think we [1:16:00] had good conversation about a better way to do things. [1:16:04] And I think it's all been very positive. [1:16:06] I appreciate all the different committees that are now posted and the public is invited to, [1:16:11] the URA Downtown Committee is a great example. [1:16:16] I personally am not opposed to posting, you know, if we do need to post an interview. [1:16:23] It doesn't really mean that people will show up with cameras and maybe the media doesn't [1:16:30] even show up. [1:16:31] But I'm not opposed to that because the volunteers on these boards and commissions have to sit [1:16:37] up here and do business. [1:16:39] They have to sit up here and do it in the public eye and in front of many people in front of [1:16:45] the camera. [1:16:46] We record every meeting. [1:16:47] So it's really no different than the job that they're being asked to do should they need [1:16:52] to answer questions or speak in public. [1:16:55] So I'm not opposed to that. [1:16:57] I agree with the mayor. [1:16:58] It's his process and I respect that. [1:17:01] I respectfully request that the liaisons be involved. [1:17:05] I think it could only be helpful but respect his decision. [1:17:10] But I don't think that the transparency resolution makes an issue. [1:17:15] We also have some options. [1:17:16] If we want to make an amendment to that resolution to say, [1:17:20] you know, the council decides to exclude [1:17:23] interviews of potential volunteers. [1:17:26] I think that's a reasonable move if we want to do that. [1:17:29] I think there are some options, [1:17:31] but I appreciate the fact that this, [1:17:34] the input was taken to post these positions [1:17:37] that they were open to the public. [1:17:38] I think that's a great improvement on the process. [1:17:41] You know, I'm wondering if we're going to continue [1:17:43] the conversation about this. [1:17:44] I think it's appropriate to continue it, [1:17:46] but I'm wondering if we can get Ryan out of here today. [1:17:49] I'm making that motion right now. [1:17:51] Make motion. [1:17:52] I'm not in my life's name. [1:17:53] I move that we recommend that the county commissioners [1:17:56] that Ryan Higgly be appointed to area of impact member [1:17:59] of the Twin Falls City Planning and Zoning Commission. [1:18:02] Second. [1:18:04] We have motion on the floor by Greg Lanting. [1:18:08] Seconded by Suzanne Hawkins. [1:18:10] Anything further on the motion? [1:18:15] The aye the roll call vote please. [1:18:17] Suzanne Hawkins? [1:18:18] Yes. [1:18:19] Jim Bani? [1:18:20] Yes. [1:18:21] Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes [1:18:51] We have planning zoning is one of our most active [1:18:54] and really carries a line share of a lot of work for us. [1:18:59] So we appreciate that you would step forward [1:19:01] and take that position, sir. [1:19:03] Thank you very much. [1:19:05] Rebecca Mill, sorry. [1:19:06] Thank you, Mayor. [1:19:07] I just wanted to invite Mr. Hickley. [1:19:08] We do have a training this Wednesday at noon, [1:19:10] so if you can jump right in, [1:19:12] that would be great right here in this building. [1:19:15] Thank you, Rebecca. [1:19:15] Jim, I. [1:19:16] Thank you, Mayor. [1:19:17] Well, I guess we're kind of a bit of a crossroads here. [1:19:20] We have several council people who do not believe in the current process. [1:19:23] In fact, one council person believes that this is a power trip on your part. [1:19:32] So I guess what we need to do is we need to decide as a council how we're going to proceed [1:19:38] here. [1:19:39] I recommend that we bring to a vote how this process is going to unfold. [1:19:45] And let's, I know we have some council people here who agree wholeheartedly in the way you [1:19:51] are conducting these appointments and we have council people who disagree. [1:19:56] So I think in an effort to move this process along, we bring this to a motion and to a conclusion. [1:20:03] We're within, as long as we're acting within that resolution, I think that this is a procedural issue we need to vote on. [1:20:11] Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, I was going to say, if it would help staff, we can [1:20:15] add this to a future agenda. [1:20:17] We can be in a position where we could include this in a resolution, and so that you have [1:20:24] that to be able to move forward and to continue this conversation. [1:20:31] One of the things that we want to make sure is that the agenda is reflective of the actions [1:20:35] that you're going to take, so the public wants to have engagement in that opportunity [1:20:40] that there's every opportunity to create that forewarning. [1:20:45] We know that this is an issue that was developed as a result of an appointment, and I think it [1:20:50] was a good and spirited conversation staff. [1:20:53] My recommendation would be that we would include this on the April 7th agenda for your [1:21:00] review and consideration, and at that point we will also provide a copy of the current [1:21:05] transparency resolution that will be something that all of you can have in front of you, so [1:21:10] So if you're looking to make those amendments, we can do so clean. [1:21:13] I think that's a good recommendation. [1:21:15] Thank you. [1:21:16] Travis, Suzanne Hawkins. [1:21:17] I'm fine with continuing on with the conversation. [1:21:20] However, I do believe this is the mayor's decision. [1:21:23] More than the council's. [1:21:24] It is his prerogative to appoint how he feels fit. [1:21:27] And so I'm not trying to put you on the spot, but I don't know that you need our input on [1:21:33] it. [1:21:34] I think you know where the council feels. [1:21:35] I think if you're comfortable making that decision, I would support that. [1:21:39] Thank you, Susanne, Chris Docking. [1:21:42] Yep, we are going to put it on the council. [1:21:44] I wonder the agenda of threats, [1:21:46] if you could provide a range of options [1:21:48] for the consideration of the council, ABC, whatever, [1:21:53] D-E-F-G-H, or maybe there's only one, I don't know, [1:21:56] but anything that helped us get a better grasp [1:21:59] of the magnitude of this. [1:22:02] So I'm better. [1:22:03] Yeah, I'd also ask that in addition [1:22:05] to the transparency resolution that we also bring the code [1:22:09] that refers to the process for appointments, [1:22:12] which is mayoral appointment and council confirmation, [1:22:15] and truthfully the fact that the process [1:22:17] in between is an in-code. [1:22:21] Thank you. [1:22:23] Moving on to the next item for consideration [1:22:25] is a consideration of a request to award a contract [1:22:29] to Golden Harvest Inc. of Burlington, Washington [1:22:32] in the amount of $345,821 for procurement package D [1:22:37] package D of the wastewater treatment plant upgrades. Troy, did I miss one? Oh, I did miss [1:22:48] one. I'm sorry. Yeah, let me go back to three. I'm sorry, Troy. Got y'all excited to get [1:22:52] you out again. I've got writing all over this, so I apologize. Number three is consideration [1:22:58] of a request or award the bid to install curb, gutter, sidewalk and construction of a parking [1:23:04] law for Baxter's Park to Idaho Sand and we have our Parks and Recreation Director [1:23:10] Dennis Boyer. Thank you mayor and council yeah I was starting to get up and [1:23:14] Alton I heard that's not my item but I got a long time to even know about it. [1:23:19] Okay I am kind of really excited about this you know we'll finally we'll open [1:23:25] our first permanent dog park in Smith Falls in 2014 so I'm excited about that [1:23:30] and this is just one of the processes of developing this dog park. The city [1:23:34] hired EHM engineers who designed the curb gutter inside walk in the parking lot and managed [1:23:40] the bidding process. This project is only a long chute avenue. [1:23:45] I'll get back to where it was. [1:24:13] Anyway, but I'll just go ahead. This is for the curb gutter inside walk and a parking [1:24:21] on chute avenue. [1:24:23] Originally the EHM engineers, they kind of came up with an estimate about $80,000 for [1:24:28] this project. [1:24:29] So staff, we recommended EHM to kind of split this up and have an alternate bid because we [1:24:34] really didn't know if we had enough funds between what the city funds were and what [1:24:37] the Magic Valley K9 Social Club has raised so far. [1:24:40] So I had the parking lot as an alternate on this, just to make sure we can cover at least [1:24:46] the curb gunner slide walk in there. [1:24:48] So bids were advertised in the paper and EHM also contacted five contractors to invite [1:24:54] them to bid on this project. [1:24:56] The bids were due on Tuesday, March 18th and we had four bids come into on time and EHM [1:25:03] reviewed all the bids and determined that Irao Sand has submitted the low bid in the [1:25:09] amount of $55,169. [1:25:10] I'm going back to here. [1:25:13] So here's the dog park here. [1:25:14] This is Shoop Avenue, Blake Street. [1:25:17] So this will continue on with a curb and gutter along here, [1:25:20] then it will kind of wind around here, [1:25:21] come back and back on Chub Avenue. [1:25:24] This is, if you're familiar with Cascade Park [1:25:26] and the parking lot over there, [1:25:28] where this is kind of you pull in here, [1:25:29] do a diagonal parking and exit here. [1:25:31] There is some curbing that will be along this street here, [1:25:34] so people can't just exit in and back up [1:25:37] along the road anytime. [1:25:40] And I'd like to know the restroom [1:25:42] that we have money in the budget. [1:25:43] Yes. [1:25:44] I'm sorry, Greg Lanning. [1:25:45] Just so everybody knows what you're talking about, [1:25:46] or else calls it, candy cane park, so. [1:25:49] Sorry, okay, yeah. [1:25:50] Cascades the official name, candy cane's the unofficial. [1:25:53] Yeah, or now I've heard it's dinosaur park too. [1:25:55] Okay, right, Nandy? [1:25:57] Yeah. [1:25:58] Anyway, sorry about that. [1:26:00] It's on, it's stadium boulevard anyway, [1:26:01] just down from south to elementary school. [1:26:04] So this is a project here consisting of the curb, [1:26:07] gutter sidewalk here, and then also the parking lot here. [1:26:10] I'd like to know we will be installing a small restroom [1:26:14] similar to what we did at the jury park in this location. [1:26:18] So and also I have attached the bid showing the engineering estimates and the four bids [1:26:31] that we received and like I said I do have Tim Vosser with the HM engineers here if you [1:26:36] have any questions for the bidding process he is here. [1:26:40] Now we'll kind of go over the budget impact. [1:26:43] We have approximately about $105,000 in the city funds for this dog park. [1:26:48] $8,000 is earmarked for the small restroom we have in there. [1:26:52] We still have about $7,000 work of PI irrigation system over there. [1:26:56] We have a little bit of utilities cost of getting our power and sewer and water there. [1:27:02] And also we have 21,000 for engineering fees for EHM on this project here. [1:27:07] That leaves approximately about 34,000 in city funds. [1:27:10] The Magic Valley Canine Social Club, we have to have approximately about 35,000 left in their funds. [1:27:17] So between what our city funds are and with the K9 Social Club, the funds they have through [1:27:22] the community foundation, we have between these two sources, we have around $69,000 for this [1:27:27] project. [1:27:29] So with the amount of money that we have between the two funds, between the city funds and through [1:27:36] the Magic Valley K9 Social Club, we have approximately $69,000 in their bid here, just a little bit [1:27:41] over $55,000. [1:27:43] So kind of the recommendation from the staff is for the council to award the bid for Baxter's [1:27:48] park for the curb gutter sidewalk and parking lot to idle sand in the amount of $55,169 available [1:27:56] for questions now. [1:27:57] Chris, talking to you. [1:27:59] Dennis, I'm really confused about the numbers from around. [1:28:02] I don't know. [1:28:03] Is the project cost $105 or is it $80 or $69? [1:28:08] Okay, the project cost the the bid that the low bid was fifty five thousand one hundred and sixty. That's the bed [1:28:15] That's the big price. Yeah, and I had I we have approximately a hundred five thousand in city funds for [1:28:25] doctors Park this year total of the total project [1:28:29] With all the embedded costs and the bidding [1:28:33] What is the engineering amount? [1:28:36] The engineering amount with EHM is $21,000. [1:28:41] We hired them to do this. [1:28:42] So we're saying that on a project of $69,000, $21,000 is spent for engineering services. [1:28:50] That's why I'm confused. [1:28:51] I figure I'm off base because that's a third of the project for engineering. [1:28:56] So I figure I'm misconstruing somewhere. [1:29:04] That's just even for engineering fees. [1:29:08] That doesn't make sense. [1:29:10] Do we want to emposser? [1:29:14] I must be a misunderstanding. [1:29:15] Good evening. [1:29:16] No, sir. [1:29:18] The basic design does not include just that portion [1:29:22] of the parking lot. [1:29:23] It also includes future improvements on Blake Street, [1:29:27] which involves surveying, testing, full development [1:29:29] plans for both phases. [1:29:32] In addition, we're doing contract administration, [1:29:34] construction testing and inspection, which will be testing the asphalt concrete, all the [1:29:40] services that could normally put into a set of bed specs as a requirement for the contractor. [1:29:47] We're providing for that cost. [1:29:51] And so it's Blake N. Shoop improvement. [1:29:54] The full design was the surrounding area of the entire dog park, as opposed to the forest. [1:30:01] It still sounds like an incredibly embedded [1:30:03] engineering amount though. [1:30:07] I'm sorry sir, I gave this the most competitive cost [1:30:11] that I've given. [1:30:12] That's far a figure I'm not understanding of that [1:30:14] because it seems like in the neighborhood of 10, 15% [1:30:18] what I've been used to before. [1:30:21] And that's very relative to a project [1:30:25] that would include both phases of construction. [1:30:29] But the full design plans have to be developed [1:30:32] for future as well as the current site that's being bid. [1:30:38] Okay, well, thank you. [1:30:40] Sean, Mayor? [1:30:41] I think what Tim's saying is that the engineering costs [1:30:44] are for a much broader scope of project, [1:30:48] and this is one piece of that broader scope of project. [1:30:52] So I don't disagree with you, Chris. [1:30:54] $21,000 in a $55,000 project sounds like a lot of engineering, [1:30:59] But it's $21,000 in a who knows what final cost if you were to build out all the stuff [1:31:07] that it's engineering. [1:31:08] It just happens to be the front end cost of all that engineering. [1:31:11] I'm not sure that you should have Dennis in your department have to absorb that full [1:31:15] amount for a non-recoration or park-related activity. [1:31:19] I mean, it's more related to the Blake Street, as I understand, and the full build out. [1:31:24] I'm just saying that cost should be attributed more than just to the dog part for this fully-developed [1:31:33] concept. [1:31:34] I'm giving it just a second because Rebecca Millsoikum. [1:31:46] I just have two quick questions and a comment. [1:31:49] The first question I received from some of the volunteers that were out building the area, [1:31:56] they kind of wanted a better idea of what it's going to look like. [1:31:59] And their question was, is the grassy area, it's quite large, is it going to have any type [1:32:04] of hills that dogs can run on or people can sit on as they let their dogs run? [1:32:11] Right now we do not have any plans for kind of having berms or hills in that area, but [1:32:15] that's something we can look at. [1:32:17] If there's really a need for it, if there's a request for it, I have not heard of that [1:32:21] kind of comment yet of having kind of hills or berms out there. [1:32:25] Okay, well that came from the canine social club who I'd like to note is donating slightly [1:32:31] more money to this project than the city, but it just goes to show really their passion [1:32:35] and they were the ones out there volunteering and really so their contribution has been countless [1:32:41] more dollars and they've really done a great job doing that, but I'll have them contact [1:32:47] you and I don't have a dog but I think Burm or Hills would actually be interesting and [1:32:51] fun. So that's that's my two cents there. My other question is when we talked [1:32:58] about you know Pave and City parking lots we were kind of considering the the [1:33:02] lower cost of the re grind. So is this parking lot fully paved or is it a type [1:33:08] of re grind project? It's fully paved. Okay. That's wonderful. Thank you. Great [1:33:15] Well, Dennis, Maury Days, right? [1:33:20] It's been probably about three years since the first $10,000 was donated by Marcia Laney. [1:33:25] You're going to get the ball rolling. [1:33:27] And we certainly appreciate your efforts to keep that ball rolling. [1:33:32] And also, certainly to the Madge Valley K9 Club for their efforts. [1:33:40] I mean, they've had numerous fundraisers at different places [1:33:44] and dog swims and they've really went at their portion [1:33:48] from a very grassroots direction. [1:33:50] And of course we had some, the original 10,000 [1:33:52] from RC as well as a couple of donations [1:33:54] from the Becker's don't want to forget them as well [1:33:57] in the state of Mavidji Becker [1:33:59] and also Marty Becker and his wife have donated funds. [1:34:02] And I believe we're going to be naming the two sides [1:34:05] for them as I recall the. [1:34:07] Yes, that is the plan right now. [1:34:09] I know the Community Foundation has not received the second, [1:34:11] you know, I might say donation from the Becker family, [1:34:16] they received one of them, [1:34:17] but the idea was to name, you know, [1:34:19] what the large dog area, you know, [1:34:21] could be Dr. Marty and Theresa Becker, [1:34:23] and the other one could be, [1:34:25] the small dog could be Virginia Becker. [1:34:27] That's kind of the idea was, [1:34:28] and they are all, those two parties were comfortable with this, [1:34:31] and our original donor of Marcia Lanting [1:34:33] was also okay with that idea, [1:34:35] because you can, in our naming policy, [1:34:37] you can name certain areas inside a full park facility, [1:34:41] different name anyway. [1:34:43] So we're going to be Baxter's Park, [1:34:45] and then the large dog area could be one of the Beckers, [1:34:48] and the small dog area could be named after the Beckers also. [1:34:51] And we do have the stone is already there, [1:34:54] the large rock that is for the park [1:34:58] has already been selected, hitched on, and paid for. [1:35:02] And so hopefully that when we have a grand opening, [1:35:06] or sooner because I think vital signs must get rid of it because they've had it for a while. [1:35:10] But we can have a nice ceremony at some point for a ribbon cutting for that because it's [1:35:17] been a long time coming and I remember over two years ago I made it as one of my points [1:35:24] as I want to become mayor. [1:35:25] It was one of the things that we would hopefully get accomplished during that soon and I really [1:35:31] believe once people get to using this the ball will be rolling and it will get more and more [1:35:35] support to have a second one somewhere on another area of town and I haven't been [1:35:41] to one has berms and things but that's not a bad idea to me I mean give it a [1:35:45] little more variety a little harder to keep the grass alive on the berms I know [1:35:49] but it's certainly you know I've been to probably 10 at this point in my life [1:35:55] only about 10-8 and you know I haven't seen berms but certainly we are still [1:36:01] planning on some sort of a walking path on the inside for people to do a little [1:36:05] exercising while their dogs are playing? [1:36:07] Well, we kind of had a little change of kind of a thought [1:36:10] on that process, because one is thing is you actually build [1:36:15] past after people wear out an area. [1:36:18] We're looking at that, see if they really get a worn area. [1:36:21] We think believe, I really believe, [1:36:23] maybe between the large dog area and the small dog area, [1:36:26] we might get a bit of a worn path where the dogs are kind [1:36:29] of running, barking, chasing after each other. [1:36:32] We really want to see how that handles. [1:36:34] maybe we don't need that, you know, because that is an extra at a cost, but if we do need [1:36:38] it, we definitely can't take care of it after the fact, after we get the whole part of it. [1:36:42] That's certainly something with senders or regrind or something that would certainly need [1:36:45] to be paid. [1:36:46] I'll kind of give you a quick timeline. [1:36:47] What we're looking at, you know, of course this project, if you do award it, we'll start, [1:36:51] you know, soon have the construction, you know, in April, we plan on having our restroom kind [1:36:56] of installed over there, some April, May time frame. [1:37:00] irrigation once we have to wait because it will be water by canal water so we have to [1:37:05] wait until the canal waters in so we're like that probably late April to get this seated [1:37:10] and then just how well that grass grows out there that we don't have to you know we'll [1:37:14] probably touch up some more receding but I really hopefully by the end of July latest [1:37:19] the first part of August we'll have our as I want to call it the ribbon cutting tail wagging [1:37:24] day out there so. [1:37:25] Thank you, Deuce. [1:37:26] We're back in Mill Soika. [1:37:28] Thank you. [1:37:29] Well done, Dennis. [1:37:30] I really appreciate it to all the volunteers. [1:37:33] I also want to quickly mention Lane Taylor of Taylor Made Fence. [1:37:36] That was a huge donation in tools and labor. [1:37:42] I mean in the town, $10,000 or whatever, it's quite a donation. [1:37:46] I appreciate that. [1:37:47] Thank you for all your hard work. [1:37:49] I'll move toward the bid for Baxter's Park to Idos and the amount of $55,169. [1:37:56] Second. [1:37:57] motion on board by Rebecca Milsoka seconded by Greg Lanten Greg Lanten well and I [1:38:01] want to my apologies we certainly need to mention your father kind of [1:38:05] commissioner Leon Smith who made the efforts the omels mill see that they're [1:38:12] boldly of the Leon Mills excuse me for his efforts on this as well we do [1:38:16] appreciate that thank you for reminding me of that [1:38:19] We'll call it vote. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 7-0. Council, I'm going to take a [1:38:40] A seven minute break will be back at 6.35. [1:48:28] Troy, Troy, come in. [1:48:30] Yeah, I'll check now. [1:48:32] One of the holidays. [1:48:33] I'll move this. [1:48:49] He's cursing me inside, but at least on the outside. [1:48:52] Please come inside. [1:48:54] The end. [1:48:56] I'd like to reconvene the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council. [1:49:00] March 31st, it is about 22 till the hour of seven o'clock at night. [1:49:07] For the public that are here or potential public that are here for the three public hearings, [1:49:13] I'm going to go ahead and move our agenda and move us into the public hearing section. [1:49:18] And so I'm going to start that right out with the first one is a request to vacate a portion of 23 feet plus or minus platted utility drainage access and irrigation easement on property located at [1:49:34] 1662 Park View Drive for Castle Twin Falls, LLC. [1:49:41] And it looks like Jonathan Spenlove will be the city staff [1:49:46] making the report on all three of these items, [1:49:48] but we always start off with the applicant. [1:49:51] And I have Gerald Martins, [1:49:52] but I'm thinking maybe it's welcome back. [1:49:56] Yes, from Mayor. [1:49:57] Thank you, my name is Tim Vosser [1:49:59] with the HM Engineers representing the applicant. [1:50:02] in lieu of Gerald tonight, who's out of town. [1:50:05] I'm taking his place and I think this is a relatively easy thing to do. [1:50:17] I is more of an administrative thing, [1:50:19] but I will give you some background. [1:50:21] This slot was sold to Castle's Corner to build a immediate store and service station. [1:50:30] The blue area you see highlighted on the north boundary was a blanket easement prepared [1:50:36] in the plating process. [1:50:38] Excuse me, I kind of ran back here so I'm going to go out and grab. [1:50:43] Anyway, the utility companies have been contacted to my knowledge, the canal company which has [1:50:50] no facilities in the area is yet to respond as well as possibly in our mountain gas which [1:50:56] I also know they're in joint trench with that old power. [1:50:59] So the easement itself still complies with city ordinance. [1:51:03] As far as the minimum width does not get below the 15 feet required by code. [1:51:09] There's nothing in the easement at this point. [1:51:12] The vacation in itself is to allow underground storage tanks for the gas islands. [1:51:20] There's storage for them to have just a little bit more encroachment within the area that was set aside originally as a blanket easement. [1:51:28] As I said, I don't believe there's anything in this, and we believe it's totally appropriate [1:51:35] to agree with staff recommendations that all the utility companies and canal company letters [1:51:41] be approved and that it be contingent upon that. [1:51:45] If you have any questions? [1:51:47] Are there any questions? [1:51:48] We do have a staff report after this. [1:51:50] I see no lights if you want to sit down, Tim, and we'll turn it over to Mr. Spindlow. [1:51:56] Thank you, Mr. Mayor. [1:51:57] Council. A little bit of history, this particular PUD and development has been going on since 2005, [1:52:05] was until recently, the plot was finished in 2009, so there was a four-year period between [1:52:10] those two as well, and then a special use permit was approved by the Commission on December 10, [1:52:15] 2013 for the construction and operation of a convenience store slash gas station that would [1:52:20] be open 24 hours a day, seven days a week. The SCP was for the hours operation only. [1:52:26] The convenience store wasn't allowed to use per the PUD, [1:52:28] so it was just for the hours of operation. [1:52:31] The easement is to vacate six feet of a 23 by 187 section. [1:52:41] It's basically that section of traffic coming up. [1:52:43] It's that section area highlighted in blue [1:52:45] as it's just for reference. [1:52:47] The tanks were put underneath this easement [1:52:51] during the building permit process, [1:52:52] became a carter across it while we were reviewing it. [1:52:55] We notified EHM as far as the site constraints [1:53:00] basically came down to, we needed to vacate the easement in order to get that approved and finalized. [1:53:05] And this is the final step. [1:53:08] The existing easement is 22.97 feet, the request is to vacate six feet. [1:53:13] It does. It will be 16.97 feet. The standard is 15 feet. [1:53:18] So we're not going to be lowering the standard for city code by accepting this vacation of the easement. [1:53:24] And the applicant has stated in their narrative that all utilities for the North Haven subdivision are in place. [1:53:29] The city of Twin Falls has a sanitary sewer line located in the easement east of the proposed vacation, so it's actually off. [1:53:35] This map would be over here as where the sanitary sewer is, so it's not going to come into play. [1:53:41] The vacation of a planted easement requires approval by each of the applicable utility companies. [1:53:46] As of today, the city has not received any of the required letters from the applicable utility company stating their approval of the vacation of the easement. [1:53:52] Staff recommends a condition be placed on this proposed vacation prior to adoption of an ordinance letters. [1:53:59] There's approval and any requirements as determined to be necessary from the applicable utility company shall be submitted to the city. [1:54:05] On February 25th, 2014, the Commission unanimously recommended approval to vacate a portion of the utility drainage access and irrigation easement as presented and subject to the following conditions. [1:54:17] Subject number one to site plan amendments as required by building, engineering, fire, and zoning officials to ensure compliance with all applicable city code requirements and standards. [1:54:26] Number two, subject any requirements recommended [1:54:28] by applicable utility companies and staff [1:54:31] concurs with the commission's recommendation [1:54:33] and we would ask to add a third, [1:54:35] which is a condition that a letter from each [1:54:37] of the applicable utility companies [1:54:38] authorizing the vacation as presented, [1:54:41] be submitted prior to adoption of the ordinance. [1:54:44] That is all. [1:54:46] Thank you, Jonathan. [1:54:47] Council have any questions for either the applicant [1:54:50] or our city staff? [1:54:53] I see no lights. [1:54:54] So at this point, I'm going to open up [1:54:56] the public testimony portion of the hearing [1:54:58] And we have no, no. [1:55:03] Mr. Mayor, members of the council, there was no one that is signed on in any of the three public hearings that you have this evening. [1:55:09] Is there anyone that's been inspired to come forward since I've opened up the public testimony portion of the hearing? [1:55:16] I see no one running for the podium, so I will close the public testimony, [1:55:21] turned over to staff or for council for any questions that they might have staff or motion. [1:55:28] and I went and stand for a motion as well. [1:55:31] Thank you Mayor. [1:55:32] First I just want to comment great job to staff for finding this. [1:55:36] Obviously upon your review and your inspection it was located so I think this is a great solution. [1:55:41] Questions were asked at P&Z when this came before them and all of the answers are in the minutes and it was clarified and I think it's, I agree it's a good move. [1:55:51] So I'll move to vacate a portion of a 23-foot plus or minus platted utility drainage access and irrigation easement on property located at 1662 Parkview Drive for Castle Twin Falls, LLC, as presented tonight with the three staff conditions. [1:56:10] Second. [1:56:11] We have a motion on floor by Rebecca Melsoyka, seconded by Chris Tawkington to approve the [1:56:17] request as listed. [1:56:19] He added it. [1:56:20] I'm just making sure the motion was solid. [1:56:25] I know you had some discussion down there. [1:56:30] Any questions regarding or comments from the council regarding the motion? [1:56:36] The other will call vote please. [1:56:38] Yes. [1:56:40] Yes. [1:56:41] Yes. [1:56:42] Yes. [1:56:43] Yes. [1:56:45] Yes. Yes. Motion passes 7-0. Moving to the second public hearing is a [1:56:53] request for a zoning district change and zoning map amendment for 0.5 plus or [1:57:00] minus acres from R6 Pro to C1 for property located at 580 Addison Avenue West for [1:57:09] a pro west engineering and I show a Dan Teal, Teal, [1:57:17] is Dan Teal here. [1:57:26] We don't believe that Mr. Teal is here this evening [1:57:29] as the applicant. [1:57:31] So I guess I turn it over to city staff. [1:57:34] Welcome again, Jonathan. [1:57:36] Thank you, Mr. Mayor and members of the council. [1:57:40] This will be a brief history. [1:57:42] The story that's in the report basically we have is [1:57:45] the building in this area. [1:57:47] We had a special use permit come through for this building to replace a nonconforming use with another nonconforming use. [1:57:55] That was due to the fact that the northern portion of this property was zoned R6 on the official zoning map. [1:58:02] And it's shown that the building was bisected on the official zoning map. [1:58:05] And this is basically a cleanup item that we're trying to adjust that line so [1:58:10] we can coincides with the property line to the north. [1:58:13] That's the items for. [1:58:15] especially used permit passed with conditions. [1:58:18] This came before, I'll get the exact date, [1:58:23] came before the Planning and Zoning Commission on February 25th, [1:58:27] in talking about these different things. [1:58:29] There was discussion about the uses to the north, [1:58:32] the east to the south, and the east and the surrounding, [1:58:34] and what kind of impacts that would be. [1:58:36] To the north, we have the apartment complex up here. [1:58:38] That use is not going to change. [1:58:41] The rezoning of this is not going to change the boundary [1:58:44] between the two owners are consented with each other [1:58:48] on various items. [1:58:49] So what we have here is the comprehensive plan [1:58:51] and future land use map designate the particular area [1:58:55] you wish to be rezoned as commercial slash retail. [1:58:58] The area immediately to the east, south and west [1:59:00] are currently C1 and have commercial [1:59:01] and government uses established. [1:59:03] The area to the north is zoned R6 Pro [1:59:05] and is currently a multifamily housing project. [1:59:08] This proposed rezone would be compatible [1:59:09] with the adjacent land uses in the area [1:59:11] and does follow the future land use map [1:59:13] goals of the comprehensive plan. [1:59:15] In reviewing requests for zoning district change and zoning map amendment, the commission had [1:59:21] two main tasks. [1:59:22] One, to determine whether the request is in conformance with the comprehensive plan and [1:59:25] two, to evaluate their request to determine the extent and nature of the amendment requested. [1:59:31] In conclusion, on February 25, 2014, the Planning and Zoning Commission evaluated the request [1:59:35] as presented and unanimously determined the extent and nature of the amendment being requested [1:59:40] was in conformance with the comprehensive plan. [1:59:42] commission unanimously unanimously [1:59:44] recommended the city council grant [1:59:46] this request as presented. [1:59:49] Thank you, Jonathan. [1:59:51] Chris, talk to you. [1:59:53] A little question then. [1:59:54] Is that the lot with the split [1:59:58] USR6C1 with the building north [2:00:00] south orientation? [2:00:03] Where's the property line? [2:00:05] I mean, how did that building get [2:00:07] in two zones? [2:00:09] You said it was rather an arbitrary [2:00:11] line that was drawn for the I can't I know that the zoning happened in the past I [2:00:15] don't know the exact date of it but I know the current zoning map the official [2:00:19] zoning map shows an outline of a building and shows the property line to the north [2:00:24] of where the R6 line was that that is one building with no separation of aid or [2:00:29] anything of that nature correct and so it would be considered to be a one-use [2:00:34] building compatible with C1. [2:00:38] Correct. [2:00:39] Okay. [2:00:40] Do we have any other questions of staff? [2:00:43] All right. [2:00:46] At this point, I'll go ahead and open up the public testimony portion of this hearing again. [2:00:51] And if we look again, no one went back there. [2:00:55] Could you look for it? [2:00:56] Okay. [2:00:57] Someone snuffed back there. [2:00:58] See mostly city staff here. [2:01:03] But it shows no one wanting to testify on this item as well. [2:01:23] as well, so I'll close the public testimony portion of this hearing, turn it over to council [2:01:27] for their wishes. [2:01:28] Chris Dockey. [2:01:31] I still have one question. [2:01:34] Is that building actually encompassing a half under an acre? [2:01:38] Are we saying a half an acre plus or minus? [2:01:41] Just to give us a little fudge factor. [2:01:43] I believe the area in blue that you see there highlighted encompasses the half acre. [2:01:47] So they're just changing that portion, they're not going to change the zone to the north. [2:01:51] They're going to be changing just that area to C1. [2:01:54] Okay. [2:01:55] Sean Verger. [2:01:56] I'm ready for a motion if you are. [2:02:02] I'm ready. [2:02:03] I would move to approve the zoning district change and zoning map amendments for half an [2:02:09] acre plus or minus from R6 Pro to C1 for the property located at 580 Addison Avenue West [2:02:17] subject to the conditions from the lower conditions, right? [2:02:26] No conditions. [2:02:27] No conditions. [2:02:28] Never mind. [2:02:29] Subject theory. [2:02:30] Second. [2:02:31] We have a motion on floor by Sean Berger, seconded by Rebecca Mills-Soyka. [2:02:34] Anything further on that motion council? [2:02:37] Be aye that will call vote please. [2:02:41] Yes. [2:02:43] Yes. [2:02:45] Yes. [2:02:46] Rebecca and Soyka. [2:02:47] Yes. [2:02:48] Suzanne Hopkins. [2:02:49] Yes. [2:02:50] Yes. [2:02:51] Yes. [2:02:52] Yes. [2:02:53] Motion passes. [2:02:54] passes 7-0 moving to the third public hearing is a request for zoning district [2:02:59] change and zoning map amendment from R4 to R4 Pro for the property located at 708 [2:03:06] Washington Street South and I show a Judith Rayborn as the applicant. Welcome, [2:03:14] Judith. Hi, my name is Judy Rayborn, dial in the property at 708 South Washington and [2:03:26] And we purchased the property about 20 years ago, it's just an investment in a rental. [2:03:31] And that's what it has been for the past 20 years. [2:03:36] The law itself is quite unique because I assume you have a packet on it. [2:03:41] It's 67 feet wide and it's 200 and 31 feet deep. [2:03:47] And it borders on Austro-low. [2:03:50] So it has access to Austro-low. [2:03:53] And at the time, you know, it's a nice rental. [2:03:57] You don't use the back half of it because it's so large. [2:04:01] But Washington Street North and South have changed so much [2:04:07] with the improvements, the widening of it. [2:04:12] The speed limit there is 45 miles an hour, [2:04:17] so it's really not conducive for a residential. [2:04:21] for everybody would like to have them here on single family, 2.2 children that's going to stay a couple of years. [2:04:28] But on a 45 mile an hour street in front of you, it's really too fast. [2:04:33] It's perfect for a little small at home business or an office, a beauty salon. [2:04:40] I've had a few people ask me about it. [2:04:43] I think the lot is unique because it's the only one that really does have access that's not on South Washington. [2:04:50] South Washington. So you could utilize the whole frontage a lot without disturbing any [2:04:55] of the neighbors or having to egress and on to South Washington, my back, you go on to [2:05:02] it because you have the osterlo, the whole length of the property. So I was, and all of [2:05:09] the property around us is either M1, you know, across the street is the old Jacob building, [2:05:17] And then on the other side to the north is the Gould, you know, all the Gould property, [2:05:23] which has been, you know, the Cat House and the, you know, probation, parole, all of that. [2:05:30] So this just hasn't quite hit our block or that area yet. [2:05:35] But we think it would be a good addition to South Washington. [2:05:39] South Washington could use a little shot in the arm. [2:05:42] It did wonders for Addison Avenue when they started just using the homes for small home [2:05:50] offices or small business-dawn retail and that's what I would like to do with that one. [2:05:58] Anybody have any questions or any questions for Mrs. Rayburn at this point? I see them, [2:06:04] but there might be for you just a bit. [2:06:07] I'll turn it over to the staff. [2:06:09] Okay, yes, if you're finished. [2:06:11] Yes, yes. [2:06:12] Okay. [2:06:13] more comfortable for you. [2:06:15] Thank you, Gamas, Mayor and members of the Council of History. [2:06:21] The farmstead platt was recorded in 1937, and we do not have any history on the building, [2:06:26] so it was built prior to us keeping records or outside of our city limits. [2:06:31] In 81, we adopted the current Title X Outlay in our outline, and there amended the area [2:06:37] of impact and zoning district maps. [2:06:40] She outlined the request very well there. [2:06:44] We're looking at this one lot. [2:06:45] The one lot would then be rezoned R4, PRO, PRO stands for Professional Office Overlay. [2:06:49] I know this makes sense with PR, but it would be the first lot in this area to have the Professional [2:06:56] Office Overlay designation. [2:06:58] To the north is zoned M1. [2:07:00] It's currently used as a residence with agricultural. [2:07:03] To the rear, northeast of that is the old Jacob plant and there are current manufacturing [2:07:08] commercial uses in that building. [2:07:10] To the east immediately across Washington we have rows of homes. [2:07:14] are R2, all residential currently, and to the south, we also have more residential as you [2:07:21] go down to Washington. We don't have any commercial buildings in the immediate area in that area [2:07:26] as well. 2009, the comprehensive plan in future land use map designates this portion of Washington [2:07:32] Street, South Corridor as appropriate for urban village and urban infill development. That's [2:07:40] what this map designates. So we have urban village on the south, just north across the [2:07:45] In this area we have an industrial designation which goes in and out of city limits. [2:07:51] So we have city limits and an area of impact immediately to the west on the north side. [2:07:56] Urban village and urban infill uses and this is directly from our comp plan. [2:08:00] They are proposed within the existing city limits on sites that are surrounded by built up areas which are generally smaller than land located on the outskirts of the community. [2:08:08] Instead of being developed with single family homes or similar homogenous uses, [2:08:11] mixed-use profiles envisioned, incorporating a range of residential uses and densities. [2:08:16] In addition to commercial and community uses which support urban lifestyles, mixed uses would be both vertical and horizontal, [2:08:22] depending on the design quality of each specific project. [2:08:26] Since the adoption of the comprehensive plan in 2009, this land has, this land use designation of urban village, [2:08:32] urban infill has not been adopted in Title X as a zoning district. [2:08:36] The intent of the UV zone is to allow for infill development of light commercial slash professional uses in established areas, specifically along major arterials, such as Washington Street South. [2:08:48] Under staff review, we determined a professional office overly may accomplish the intent of the UV, UV description of utilizing this lot other than as a single family residence. [2:08:59] A home occupation could still be operated by SCP at this site under the current zone of R4. [2:09:04] could have an home occupation there without changing the zoning district at all. [2:09:09] If the request is approved by the City Council, development of the site would require a special [2:09:12] use permit and development of site improvements, which may include paving, landscaping, storm [2:09:17] water retention, curb gutter sidewalk, development of Austro Avenue West, compliance with building [2:09:22] codes to change the use from a residence to a professional office and review for compliance [2:09:26] of engineering and fire codes. [2:09:28] So it can be multiple things that this applicant is going to need to do in order to make it a [2:09:32] professional office, the improvements as well as converting the home to a commercial building. [2:09:38] The building codes are very different from those two uses. [2:09:42] If approved, this would be the first zoning amendment to allow a use other than residential [2:09:45] along this section of Washington Street South for property currently zoned slash developed [2:09:50] slash used as residential. [2:09:52] In reviewing a request for zoning district change and zoning map amendment, there are two main tasks [2:09:57] that the Planning and Zoning Commission has to determine. [2:10:00] to determine whether the request is in conformance with the comprehensive plan, and two, to evaluate [2:10:05] the request to determine the extent and nature of the amendment requested. In conclusion, [2:10:09] on February 25, 2014, the Planning and Zoning Commission evaluated the request as presented [2:10:13] and unanimously determined the extent and nature of the amendment being requested was [2:10:17] in conformance with the comprehensive plan. The Commission unanimously recommended the [2:10:21] City Council grant this request as presented. That's all. [2:10:25] Do we have any questions of the staff or the applicant this evening? [2:10:32] I will open up the public testimony portion of this hearing. [2:10:35] I see no one on the list. [2:10:36] Is there anyone that would like to come forward to make any testimony regarding this matter? [2:10:43] I see no one coming forward, so I'll close the public testimony and turn it over to Council for their direction. [2:10:49] Rebecca Mills, sorry. [2:10:51] Thank you, Mayor. [2:10:53] This request is compatible with the comprehensive plan. [2:10:57] Also, it's compatible with the zoning to the north, even though it's stated it would be the first rezoning to a business type retail establishment in this area. [2:11:11] But since there was no comment from neighbors and no disruption to the neighborhood, then I move that we approve the request for [2:11:21] zoning district change and zoning map amendment from R4 to R4 Pro for property located at 708 [2:11:27] Washington Street South. Second. We have a motion on the floor by Rebecca's Mill, so I [2:11:35] can second it by Suzanne Hawkins to approve the motion. The request in front of us. I have [2:11:41] a couple lights. Chris talking to them. Yeah, I have a question you mentioned, a special [2:11:46] use permit that that's not germane to this that's just part of the [2:11:51] in the p or a professional overlay so the professional overlay allows uses but [2:11:56] those uses all require special use permit if there's an office and it's [2:11:59] still come back to the fair especially I see no further lights roll call vote [2:12:08] please break 19 yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes [2:12:19] Yes. Yes. Motion passes 7-0. We will move back. Thank you for coming this evening. We will [2:12:27] move back to items of consideration and Troy Vitek is very happy because now we're on [2:12:33] to his three items. So the first one being consideration of the request to award a contract [2:12:38] to Golden Harvest Inc. of Burlington, Washington in the amount of $345,821 for the procurement [2:12:48] package D of the wastewater treatment plant upgrades. [2:12:52] You're on, Troy. [2:12:56] Evening council members. [2:12:57] For the record, my name is Troy Vitek, [2:12:59] the Assistant City Engineer. [2:13:01] I'm coming before you tonight for several presentations [2:13:05] on the wastewater treatment plant, how it's going. [2:13:08] So the first one tonight is work package D. [2:13:11] This one here is in order to meet the schedule, [2:13:14] the timely schedule. [2:13:15] We've had to break up this project [2:13:17] into multiple procurement packages. [2:13:20] And this is one of those. [2:13:21] This is actually for the gates. [2:13:22] The gates are a sufficient size and it's hard just to go buy them off the shelf. [2:13:26] You have to actually have them constructed. [2:13:29] So we sent it out for bid. [2:13:30] We had two bidders return information to us. [2:13:34] Bitter number one, Golden Harvest. [2:13:36] As you can see it's slightly larger than number two, Rodney Hunt Fontaine. [2:13:41] The reason being is Rodney Hunt Fontaine qualified their bid. [2:13:46] They said we don't agree with the schedule and we don't agree with the LDs. [2:13:50] do in that they essentially remove themselves from the bidding process so [2:13:53] a state statute requires us to go with the next lowest bidder which is only [2:13:57] other bidder in this case so tonight I'd like to request that the council [2:14:02] approve need to enter into negotiation with this contractor and award the [2:14:08] contract for three hundred forty five thousand eight hundred and twenty one [2:14:11] dollars for this procurement package and stop there and discuss the next one. [2:14:17] Greg Lanning. [2:14:18] Yes, Troy, could you tell me just a little bit more of the two conditions they put on [2:14:24] them? [2:14:25] I've heard LD and something like that. [2:14:27] So LDs are associated with liquid data damages because this project is so fast-paced, we say [2:14:33] to the contractors that you have to have it done by this time or there's a consequence [2:14:38] for that. [2:14:39] Usually that's financial. [2:14:40] They have to pay so much per day because we're at a loss, we're holding up our contractors, [2:14:47] We're having to pay for more overhead for our people to witness it and inspect and stuff [2:14:53] like that. [2:14:54] So we pass that on to them. [2:14:59] Greg Lanning. [2:15:00] I move that we can refer to request the reward, a contract to Golden Harvest Incorporated of [2:15:05] Burlington, Washington in the amount of $345,821 for the procurement package D of the wastewater [2:15:13] treatment plant upgrades. [2:15:15] Second. [2:15:17] motion on floor by Greg Lanning, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins. [2:15:21] Rebecca Milsoy. [2:15:23] Thank you, Mayor. [2:15:24] Councilman Lanning's question brought up a question for me. [2:15:28] In the past, when we've had contracts with the liquidated [2:15:31] damages, do they get to count days for bad weather [2:15:37] and that sort of thing? [2:15:38] And if that's part of a delay, how does that work, [2:15:43] as far as our timetable and our schedule, [2:15:45] how would that be factored in? [2:15:48] So usually at the end of the project, [2:15:50] as a project goes on, if there was a rain day like yesterday [2:15:53] or something like that, they couldn't actually do work. [2:15:55] And it's not a critical path item. [2:15:58] Say they were working on something else [2:15:59] that they couldn't do at any time. [2:16:02] We look at those and we either awarded it at that time or not. [2:16:05] And that does affect the LDs. [2:16:07] Essentially, it pushes them out a day, [2:16:09] extends the contract time. [2:16:11] And that's pretty common. [2:16:13] and there is some time planned for that, but not much. [2:16:17] Okay, thank you. [2:16:19] Sean Veriger. [2:16:20] Try and notice on this particular item, [2:16:22] there was no engineers estimate for the work. [2:16:28] This item, the engineer did not give me it on this one, [2:16:32] but I do have what their 60% said, [2:16:34] and I believe it was 289,000. [2:16:36] Okay. [2:16:37] At 60%, they haven't quite dotted all the eyes [2:16:40] across all the T's. [2:16:41] I think as we move forward with the pieces of this, it would be nice to have those comparisons [2:16:48] when they come. [2:16:49] Okay. [2:16:50] I totally understand. [2:16:52] So thanks. [2:16:53] I see no further lights. [2:16:54] We have a roll call vote. [2:16:56] Please. [2:16:57] Yes. [2:16:58] Yes. [2:16:59] Yes. [2:17:00] Yes. [2:17:01] Yes. [2:17:02] Yes. [2:17:03] Yes. [2:17:04] Yes. [2:17:05] Yes. [2:17:06] Yes. [2:17:07] Motion passes seven zero moving to the next item. [2:17:10] All right that last one is procurement this is actually one of the [2:17:15] questions I need to read it first. I just for the record I know you're [2:17:21] excited to get out of here. Consideration of a request or award a contract to [2:17:27] performance system Inc. in the amount of two million 93,189 dollar I don't get to [2:17:35] say that very often so I want to say it. For construction package one of the [2:17:39] waste water treatment upgrades. Troy B. Tech. [2:17:44] This package is one of the two construction packages on this project. This one is to start [2:17:48] the earthwork creating the big hole for the second guy to come in and actually put in [2:17:55] the equipment. This one we received two bidders on this. We do have the engineers estimate on [2:17:59] it. It was estimated 2,218,000. The low bidder actually came in, 6% under the engineers estimate. [2:18:07] if the latch were really good. [2:18:10] Both of them were qualified, the bids were perfect. [2:18:14] We just would like to request that you award it [2:18:16] to the lowest bidder at this time. [2:18:20] Any questions for Troy? [2:18:23] Council direction? [2:18:25] Chris Stockton. [2:18:26] Move to award the contract bid to perform at the systems [2:18:29] in the amount of $2,193,189 for construction package 1 [2:18:35] of the WTP upgrade. [2:18:38] Second. [2:18:39] We have a motion on the floor by Chris Tarrington, [2:18:41] seconded by Sean Berrigger. [2:18:43] Anything further on that motion council? [2:18:45] The aye of the roll call vote please. [2:18:47] Rebecca Mills-Suecka? [2:18:48] Yes. [2:18:50] Suzanne Hawkins? [2:18:51] Yes. [2:18:52] Jim Bunn? [2:18:52] Yes. [2:18:53] Sean Berrigger? [2:18:54] Yes. [2:18:55] Yes. [2:18:56] Greg Lantine? [2:18:57] Yes. [2:18:58] Don Hall? [2:18:59] Yes. [2:19:00] Motion passes. [2:19:01] Seven to zero. [2:19:03] The next item is consideration of a request [2:19:07] to reserve $1 million of the wastewater treatment plant bond [2:19:11] proceeds for reconstruction of the Canyon Springs [2:19:14] grade due to impacts from the wastewater treatment plant [2:19:21] expansion project, Troy Vitek again. [2:19:24] For the Rec and Troy Vitek assistant city engineer. [2:19:27] So several weeks ago, [2:19:28] I started actually several months ago. [2:19:30] I came before you and asked what would the council like [2:19:33] to see on this Canyon Springs upgrade. [2:19:35] We felt that the road would be impacted due to the wastewater treatment plant construction. [2:19:40] It would essentially break up the road. [2:19:42] In that, multiple conversations ensued. [2:19:45] We started looking at safety and other opportunities here. [2:19:49] When we did that, I generated an estimate, an engineer's estimate, roughly $3.5 million [2:19:56] to a real high level estimate there. [2:19:58] That was actually based on what is standard practice of 700,000 per lane mile of construction. [2:20:05] I also included in that some engineering, some contingency costs, and some rock fall mitigation. [2:20:16] When I did that, then I came to the council and the council said, you know, we would really [2:20:20] like to see what we can do here, but kind of need more of a firm estimate on that. [2:20:25] So we hired Strata, who happened to do some, they went out and looked at the rock fall and [2:20:33] what was associated in the area and see what the dangers were and how was possible to do [2:20:38] to meet these obligations. [2:20:39] So we asked them to look at improving the pedestrian access [2:20:44] and safety, providing rock, fall protection, [2:20:48] and improving roadway hoards on alignment where possible. [2:20:51] And they came back with what I felt [2:20:53] was a really good plan, kind of describing here. [2:21:02] So in the upper portion of the Canyon Springs grade [2:21:05] before you get so far along, the roadways here, [2:21:10] Most places, the upper Kingdom Rim is here, sometimes it's right adjacent to the roadway [2:21:14] here. [2:21:15] What they recommended was to construct a four-foot wide roadway, a little shoulder here with a [2:21:21] concrete jersey, and then actually blast in a separated pathway for pedestrians. [2:21:27] You would do that for the majority of the upper section, as you got down to the lower [2:21:31] region. [2:21:36] As you went around the first hairpin turn, you would actually create a retaining wall here [2:21:41] and build a separated pathway out here in this area. [2:21:46] And that would put the pedestrian separator [2:21:48] from the vehicle traffic. [2:21:50] I'll show you where those two areas. [2:21:52] So in this area, you'd actually blast [2:21:57] to create an area for pedestrian traffic. [2:22:00] We felt that this was probably the best idea, [2:22:02] because one, you're not blasting the JSON [2:22:04] to the residences at the top. [2:22:07] You're actually down from the roadway going down. [2:22:11] So you give a place for the rock to go, less blasting impact pressure for those houses up on top and less impact for that trail weight and those associated properties. [2:22:20] As you go down here the trail would kind of enter the talus slope, make the hairpin and right in this area. [2:22:26] They proposed a pedestrian traffic crossing and then you would be in this area where you construct a retaining wall and separate them. [2:22:36] So they went through the numbers and the gyrations and formerly laid an opinion there, and then they actually gave us some costs [2:22:42] for two alternatives. One was to create this pathway. [2:22:47] Pretty much fall on the slope of the roadway. 10% slope, which is roughly what the roadway is now. [2:22:51] Creating an all-vast fault so everybody can walk it. It'd be kind of like a bike path. [2:22:56] Although it's not geometrically sound enough for a bike path, but the bikers, they stand in a single file line [2:23:04] line, and they usually observe the roadway, and they go down quite fast, come up a little [2:23:10] slower, but they don't sit two or three breaths, so they would follow the same roadway standards, [2:23:16] but the pedestrians would be out here. This is an eight foot wide asphalt path in a 12 [2:23:22] foot swath, and so they gave two alternates. One, the pathway generally falls the roadway, [2:23:28] 10% grade, it's half-fall. [2:23:30] And that came in at an estimated cost of $5,327,000. [2:23:36] The second one turned on was essentially the same, [2:23:38] although it would generally fall the nature [2:23:41] of the canyon a little bit more, [2:23:43] and it would be essentially more of a trail. [2:23:46] There wouldn't be no asphalt on it. [2:23:49] That has pluses of minuses. [2:23:50] It feels like a trail, but hiking on dirt [2:23:53] is a little more difficult, sweeping in the winter, [2:23:56] cleaning snow, stuff like that. [2:23:57] makes a different, I guess. [2:24:01] And that came in an estimate of $4,827,000. [2:24:06] So after I surprised Travis with this, [2:24:10] he said, how do you pay for it? [2:24:12] And knowing the budget process, that [2:24:15] is probably the most difficult part of this whole project. [2:24:17] And we all have ambitions that we'd really like to see this [2:24:20] improved, but we don't know how to pay for it. [2:24:24] So after him educating me about not having that opportunity, [2:24:32] what I would like to actually recommend [2:24:34] is we go through an effort to reconstruct the roadway, [2:24:37] get back to the real basis of this. [2:24:38] We do feel that the corners and probably a good portion [2:24:43] of the roadway will be affected with the wastewater treatment [2:24:45] plant. [2:24:46] The wastewater treatment plant bond [2:24:48] allows us to reconstruct what we damage, [2:24:50] but it doesn't allow us to improve. [2:24:52] So to put the bike path on it, that isn't an opportunity there. [2:24:56] So the money would have to come from some other fund, [2:25:00] either a street fund, and you'd have to do that by pushing [2:25:03] out all those steep street projects for a substantial amount [2:25:07] of time, or defer something else, or go into reserve, [2:25:12] something like that. [2:25:13] So what I came before you tonight is actually to recommend [2:25:17] that we reserve about $1 million of the wastewater treatment [2:25:20] plant barn phones to use to reconstruct this roadway as we see necessary to address any [2:25:27] concerns on the roadway. [2:25:30] With that, there's also an estimated $75,000 associated with rock fault protection. [2:25:38] What it is, is an anchor-and-nail system, you're driving into the face of it, and then they [2:25:42] put a mesh screen over that. [2:25:44] It's called an active system. [2:25:45] It's really tension. [2:25:46] It doesn't let the rocks fall out and kind of drop to the bottom. [2:25:50] pretty much holds them in place and it doesn't eliminate all the danger or all the rock falls, but it really mitigates it [2:25:57] So you don't have as much impact [2:26:00] I know we have a property owner that Katie is here tonight, and she could probably talk about [2:26:07] how that impacts her property and and if it would be a [2:26:11] allowable, I guess, because there would be some access issues. [2:26:17] We probably have to work with a recent property owners in that. [2:26:20] But so tonight I just come before the council and ask them to recommend [2:26:27] reserving a million dollars out of the waste money treatment plant bond for [2:26:30] reconstruction of the roadway and then the rock fall and future bike path we can [2:26:37] discuss at a later time. [2:26:39] Question from council [2:26:45] Thank you mayor just a clarification question your estimates on alternative two and three [2:26:51] Do they include that one million dollars for the repaving of the street or is that separate? [2:26:57] From the rock fall and pedestrian improvements [2:27:00] So the one million thirty seven is just the roadway reconstruction the [2:27:05] the 705,000 is the rock fall and the other 3.5 million would be to put in the pathway. [2:27:17] Thank you. [2:27:20] Chris Stocky, that's what we're really doing is just kind of getting a first step of a longer [2:27:25] term solution with price tags attached to it. [2:27:30] Yeah, that's absolutely correct. [2:27:34] And so the strategy that we had was to come back as we had committed and present to you [2:27:39] a probable cost for the opportunity that was discussed by the council at the prior meeting. [2:27:48] And looking at that as a possible, if the alternative is light and preferred, then it's what we [2:27:57] would do as the next step is begin to look at process to try to find a way to pay for it. [2:28:03] Look at those solutions and bring that back. [2:28:05] But more immediately what we're looking at doing is making sure that when we complete [2:28:11] the construction of the roadway, that we have a usable road surface and that is the million [2:28:18] dollars. [2:28:19] And then in addition to that, looking at using upwards of $700,000 out of street fund or other [2:28:27] cash reserves, Jackie and I will debate that, but find that $700,000 on securing that rock [2:28:37] wall. [2:28:42] So Travis, let me answer this question. [2:28:45] The million dollars obviously is for the roadway reconstruction, that's $700,000, we can't use [2:28:53] bond money for the idea of the rock way. [2:28:57] Even if the trucks utilizing that loosen up some of the rocks next start falling. [2:29:05] I think it would be difficult to prove. [2:29:07] That there's a cause and effect relationship associated with the rocks. [2:29:13] Especially in recognizing that there were past issues. [2:29:17] I think it's important that we use the bond funds in a manner that allows us to easily justify moving forward. [2:29:25] I think it's a clear justification that if we tear up the roadway going down because of [2:29:32] the number of trucks as we've communicated with the public that are going to be there, [2:29:36] then it's appropriate to restore that road back to a usable condition. [2:29:43] We will continue to work on the stabilization of that rock wall solution and bring back [2:29:49] a series of possible options for Council review. [2:29:55] So if we do this tonight, we're going to reserve the million dollars for just the roadway and [2:29:59] then we'll look at the two projects if we end up approving both of them won't be done [2:30:05] simultaneously, the roadway first and then the rock falls second or is there... [2:30:10] That's fair to say or we plan on doing this at the end of the construction. [2:30:14] We may have all the answers on the rock fall data and approval at the same time so we couldn't [2:30:19] make it one contractor making a bigger package but we'd like to break it into two. [2:30:24] at least reserve this for now. [2:30:26] Yes. [2:30:26] Perfect. [2:30:27] Sean Berger. [2:30:29] Troy, I want to thank you and everybody else you worked with [2:30:32] on bringing us some real numbers for us [2:30:35] to wrap our minds around. [2:30:37] Was better than throwing a dart at the dart board [2:30:39] and seeing what's there. [2:30:42] And while it is a tremendous amount of money, [2:30:44] I will say I was pleasantly surprised it [2:30:46] wasn't a bigger number. [2:30:48] So that's good. [2:30:50] I'm totally supportive of allocating the million dollars [2:30:54] to the bond funds toward the tearing up [2:30:58] that will be directly related to that. [2:31:01] But I really do think we should seriously consider [2:31:04] our funding options to move forward [2:31:06] with the separation of the pedestrian path down there. [2:31:09] I just think the continued use of that trail, [2:31:14] and it's a tremendous asset for the community [2:31:16] that I think has just kind of happened over time [2:31:19] with very little effort on anybody's part promoting it. [2:31:22] And we continue to see recreational development down there, and it's only going to continue to get used more. [2:31:30] So I think if we can find a way to separate that, I thought this was a, I'm sure, clever is an engineering word that you all use much, [2:31:38] but it was a clever solution, I thought, that really helped solve the problem. [2:31:43] So that would be my two cents is I'm all for the million dollars in the bond funds, [2:31:50] I think we need to definitely see if there's a way to have this included in the budget process this year. [2:31:57] At least look for options. [2:32:02] Great learning. [2:32:03] Well my thoughts are close to Sean's. [2:32:05] I'm worried that the million dollars after Dean's assessment of the road a couple weeks ago about how it was built. [2:32:13] Then it really wasn't built as a road before I worried that we're going to end up rebuilding the whole thing. [2:32:18] because of the weight of the concrete trucks and maybe a million won't be enough, but at [2:32:23] least start looking at that. I agree with Sean. I mean, I think we have to look at something [2:32:30] on that trail. I mean, half-heartedly, or facetiously said, you know, ban pedestrians [2:32:39] on that, boy, did I get the mean mills on that one. [2:32:45] I would, for somebody to make it safer and I, you know, I would even say we even expand [2:32:50] our thought processes to, it would be better just to build a whole new trail starting at [2:32:56] the terminus of Washington Street, you know, down from that area or, instead of making [2:33:01] the corner with the road, the trail keeps going like, you know, down kind of the way [2:33:06] our sewer line goes, down the other direction, continues heading west, and look at all options [2:33:11] to make it safe and economical so that we can afford to do it and keep our people safe. [2:33:20] So I will too be a favor of setting aside a million dollars and just hoping it's enough [2:33:24] and as I look at Dean Dean, I hope it's enough too. [2:33:28] So thank you. [2:33:29] This is Ann Hawkins. [2:33:32] Okay. [2:33:34] So I am very supportive of taking care of the road and fixing it. [2:33:38] The problem I'm having is we went to our citizens and asked for a large amount of money to upgrade [2:33:46] our wastewater system and we gave them numbers that we needed to do that job. [2:33:53] And now how do we explain or justify that we could have done it with a million dollars [2:34:00] less because now we're going to take a million dollars for the road that we didn't consider [2:34:04] at that time. [2:34:07] So the project right now is looking at being about $38 million and I think when you saw the estimates, we appear to be tracking on that. [2:34:19] Later we're going to have, I think it's later this week, even we're going to have a 90% review, which we're going to even continue to further refine those costs. [2:34:27] So going back as presented by Lori Race, our CFO, because of the strength of the city's financial assets and portfolio, [2:34:35] we were able to get a premium, which allowed us to capture additional dollars from that [2:34:40] bond transaction larger than what was anticipated. [2:34:44] In addition to that, we have reserves in the sewer fund in the form of capacity fees [2:34:50] that have been collected over a period of time that can also be allocated to this project. [2:34:55] And so it may not necessarily come out of the bond funds, but it's coming out of the [2:34:59] project funds that we've earmarked, whether that be the actual bond proceeds or the capital. [2:35:05] Excuse me, the capacity fees or the other premium dollars that we were able to capture [2:35:12] above the initial $38 million bond issuance. [2:35:16] Okay, thank you. [2:35:19] Sure, Greg. [2:35:20] Well, I had the privilege of attending all of the group working on the bond fund. [2:35:26] And it was not central to anybody's thoughts, but it was at least brought up by one of the [2:35:31] people in the group with the concerns about that road, and so there was at least on people [2:35:36] I would really think that the citizens would feel that they'd rather have it come out of the wardens. [2:35:49] What caused the damage rather than have it come out of their property hack taxes, [2:35:53] because that's our alternative, is it comes out property taxes to fix that road, [2:35:56] because it gets torn up, we have to fix it. [2:35:59] I think it was on people's minds at least, but, Billy. [2:36:03] We're back in the mail so I can? [2:36:04] Thank you, Mayor. [2:36:06] You know, I agree with, you know, what Councilman Berger stated, that this is important, you [2:36:12] know, it's important to our community. [2:36:14] It's not going away anytime soon or in the future, so I believe we should move forward even with [2:36:20] the extensive costs with either option or alternative two or three. [2:36:26] I would like to, if we could, get some funding option ideas from staff, maybe have those presented [2:36:34] to us as far as what reserves are available either in general reserves or in street fund [2:36:42] reserves and I know it may be difficult or maybe this needs to be a two-year budget process. [2:36:49] But I would also like to hear from the public on these alternatives. [2:36:52] I think this is, like Mr. Barger said, this is very popular with the public, with our community. [2:37:01] It's almost a sacred exercise place at this grade and people really do feel that it's their grade and it is and if it's important to them [2:37:10] I feel like if we hear from the public and they say yes, you know, this is what we would prefer [2:37:16] I think that's important for us to prioritize [2:37:19] So I would like maybe we can reach out through our public information officer through our media partners [2:37:25] To hear from people on what their preference is if they have a preference [2:37:30] on creating that separated walkway, [2:37:34] I think it would be good for safety [2:37:36] and for convenience of everyone, pedestrians and drivers. [2:37:43] Also, I think we should look for partners. [2:37:45] I know in the past that the county owns the park down there, [2:37:50] so they utilize the road. [2:37:52] In the past, they've expressed a desire to be a partner. [2:37:55] So I think we should at least reach out, [2:37:57] And obviously in government, people may not be willing, [2:38:01] but we can at least ask, see if we can partner [2:38:04] with all of the other groups that utilize that roadway. [2:38:10] Mostly what I'm thinking of it is the county, [2:38:14] since they use that as an access to their park. [2:38:20] So I would support moving forward [2:38:22] with looking for funding for alternative two or three. [2:38:28] I try one of your options, we spoke of a 42-inch pedestrian walkway, right? [2:38:35] One of the options? [2:38:39] 42-inch wide. [2:38:40] No, it was eight feet wide in the 12-foot. [2:38:42] Well, it was 12-foot. [2:38:43] Maybe I saw something wrong up there. [2:38:46] You know, as a user of that facility, I can tell you that people will not be boxed in [2:38:50] and they will use the road unless it's easy for them going downhill and uphill. [2:38:56] uphill and that includes the bikers too so we felt we felt they needed sufficient [2:39:01] area now the pathway the 42 inches of pedestrian railing there the pathways 12 [2:39:06] foot with an eight foot pass fault area good I also think even though we're only [2:39:12] requesting the million dollars tonight we should certainly hear from the private [2:39:16] property owners about this plan to hook a big net and series of anchors into [2:39:22] of their property. [2:39:23] Ducky wanted me to ask about the other, the third option I guess, was lighting a signal. [2:39:32] I know there's a cost there by $550,000 I think is what it was. [2:39:39] So while we're talking about a $3.5 million pedestrian path, it's probably prudent for [2:39:45] us to bring back a prior option which was to make that a one-way road with a signal which [2:39:50] which had an additional cost of 400,000. [2:39:53] And perhaps in the process of finding the funding [2:39:56] and addressing all of our values and needs, [2:39:59] we decide we'll take the inconvenience of a one-way road. [2:40:02] That's 20 feet wide versus the eight-foot-wide, [2:40:09] three and a half million dollar separated pathway. [2:40:12] Maybe not. [2:40:14] I just think that we should at least look at it. [2:40:19] I'd like to ask a question about that if we do that if you really looked at how [2:40:23] far people will be backed up onto the on the grade because that road gets I walked [2:40:30] it the other day and I couldn't believe how many vehicles are on that road in the [2:40:35] evenings even. It would be measurable. Interesting. [2:40:42] Jim. Thank you Mayor. I'm just going to take this just from a little bit different [2:40:47] angle. And I certainly, I believe that is very, very wise and prudent of staff or the local [2:40:53] government to place that million dollars into an area to proceed in that direction. I think [2:40:58] that's very, very wise. But I think the bigger issue here, we're dealing with what I think [2:41:03] has been clearly established as a health and safety issue. I think that there is, regardless [2:41:09] of the convenience for pedestrians to have the opportunity to walk in a narrowly, in a walk [2:41:15] way and so far they think that's good and I think we need to proceed that way. [2:41:20] But I think we've clearly established over the last several years, we've had significant [2:41:24] rockfalls in fact I think you gave testimony to that sometime back, was it you? [2:41:30] Dean did? [2:41:31] It was a big deal. [2:41:34] So you know one of the, I mean the primary charge of local governments to ensure that they [2:41:39] keep, we were created for the purposes of keeping our communities safe, through we have safe drinking [2:41:44] water safe sewer systems and so forth, whereas this is an early focused little area in our [2:41:49] community, there is a significant potential for somebody to be gravely injured on that [2:41:55] roadway and I think that that is true. [2:42:00] So I don't think we can hide from this anymore. [2:42:05] We are going to have to buck up, I guess, as politicians and really think seriously about [2:42:13] and working closely with staff on finding a way to fund this, [2:42:18] and get this done somehow within the parameters you've established here. [2:42:24] Because I personally don't want to be in a position where if next week rocks fall, [2:42:33] and somebody's really hurt bad, to sit and debate this thing. [2:42:37] I mean, I understand it's a narrow piece of our community, [2:42:40] but this is a health and safety issue. [2:42:43] It has to be fixed as soon as possible. [2:42:46] And we can't mess around with it much longer. [2:42:48] Thank you. [2:42:49] I think at this point in light of both councilmen talk, [2:42:52] again, and councilman Mums comments, [2:42:56] I'd like to have Katie come up and maybe address her thoughts. [2:43:02] Or Rob. [2:43:03] Generally, it's Katie. [2:43:04] But Rob can come up too. [2:43:08] Maybe talk about the concept of netting it [2:43:11] and those kind of ideas, because obviously you're impacted. [2:43:16] Katie Wreckenridge and Rob Struthers, [2:43:19] and we both are here because we do have, as you know, [2:43:23] real deep concerns. [2:43:26] Both of us as we were waiting to talk to you, [2:43:30] looked at this book that we have that is that thick, [2:43:33] and we started in 2008 talking to you [2:43:36] about our concerns on the road. [2:43:38] So, we're going to give you some general thoughts, and then, so you understand who he is. [2:43:48] Rob has worked with planning and zoning, written ordinances, is a broker, understands land values, [2:43:58] is a farmer, is a rancher, is a key person in agriculture and water and land and development, [2:44:06] so that when you talk a lingo, this is all very familiar. [2:44:10] to him and it's very unfamiliar to me, but that's the team and we work very closely together [2:44:16] with it. So that's why I asked tonight that Rob Wock up here because sometimes I don't [2:44:23] say the right things and then we have a discussion about it on the way home. [2:44:28] So we want- [2:44:30] It's usually the other way around, okay, to my family. [2:44:33] Yeah, it is. Well, I want you to have the discussion with me on this. [2:44:36] It works both ways. [2:44:38] So having said that, the very first and most important thing we've said to you is we couldn't [2:44:43] agree more wholeheartedly than what Jim Munge has said. [2:44:48] And we are here to be a part of an extremely dangerous situation. [2:44:53] And we believe that. [2:44:56] I've lived on the rim on my life and I do not have an engineering degree, but I watched [2:45:03] as portions of that wall fell off when I played along the edge where the lemming says [2:45:08] were. [2:45:09] If you look where John Breckenridge, who lived on the rim his entire life, we're looking [2:45:15] at 100 years of history and he backed his home clear away from the edge of the rim by [2:45:21] that wall because it kept sloughing. [2:45:25] And then when you created and widened the road, you went underneath the road to do it. [2:45:32] So now you have the rock wall foundation, it comes down, and then it goes like that. [2:45:38] If you look at the springs that flow underneath that road, you now are, pardon me, underneath [2:45:44] that wall, you now have rocks coming out like this, a spring here that runs year round so [2:45:50] it's not affected by irrigation, and then it comes like that and goes underneath it. [2:45:55] So now you have all this rock hanging over the edge. [2:45:59] That is our biggest concern and as you know when you walked out there on the property [2:46:03] you saw these huge sink holes that had appeared in the last two to five years. [2:46:09] So the wall is changing and it's changing constantly. [2:46:15] So we do have a different approach. [2:46:18] We look at number one. [2:46:20] And if you look at number one, can we have that picture, the overall, the head part, [2:46:28] the picture of the wall, yeah, okay. [2:46:32] So looking at number one, alternative, the, oh God, I have to put my grubby little finger [2:46:39] up there again, that portion of the wall is pretty straight up and down and fairly secure. [2:46:52] it starts to become unsecured and that's us when it goes over there and that's you, okay? [2:47:08] So we feel that you could do the, on the first portion where it's just the homes, you could [2:47:17] probably do that thing where you drill it in and you could do rock netting there. [2:47:26] But then when you move into the portion that is us, there is no, there are no homes there [2:47:32] And there is no bike path there. [2:47:34] And that portion, there's a lot of it that needs to just be sawed off. [2:47:39] And that's what I call it, cut off. [2:47:42] Because there's so much jaggedness along there that I don't understand how you're going [2:47:47] to be able to do that thing in and then put the mesh across. [2:47:51] How are you going to follow a contour of a very rugged wall? [2:47:55] And then you move down to the portion of what you own, [2:47:59] where there is an existing bike path, but I think it would be a small price to pay to [2:48:04] remove that bike path and again, shear off the wall so that you have a solid portion all [2:48:11] the way along. [2:48:13] And that's why we think you should consider option number one and not just throw it out. [2:48:20] And we think you should really, deeply consider that. [2:48:23] In addition to that, I don't know if Troy, you've ever been able to look at the top of [2:48:27] the wall from our perspective, but we would really encourage you or anyone who needs who [2:48:34] is making this decision to come out and walk that rim because what you're going to see [2:48:39] right along our property, if you will remember, there was the flat part and then it went down [2:48:46] and then it was a lot of, well that's the portion that you might want to consider cutting [2:48:51] all the way off. [2:48:52] So those are our basic ideas. [2:48:56] We also know that the City of Twin Falls has a 25 foot maintenance easement along that portion. [2:49:06] But what is maintenance is making it, when you start cutting off our property, [2:49:10] that becomes an issue with us too. [2:49:13] Not a big issue, but it becomes an issue of removing our property. [2:49:18] and then where financially do we stand. [2:49:23] So those aren't our issues, those are our thoughts. [2:49:28] But again, we feel very, very strongly [2:49:31] that it is extremely dangerous. [2:49:34] And if you don't do something about it, [2:49:36] it's gonna be on all of our heads [2:49:39] when that bus goes by and the rocks fall and kill [2:49:42] all the kids or when there's a little baby down there [2:49:44] and a stroller and they get killed [2:49:46] or I can go on and on, but it's not if it's when. [2:49:51] And I feel on Rob Fields. [2:49:53] And thank God I think my name is Jim Munfield, [2:49:56] but it's not a safe scenario. [2:49:58] So those are our thoughts. [2:50:00] And anyway that we can work it through with you. [2:50:04] And I also think that Rob could be a major part [2:50:08] of this discussion and give you a lot of good ideas too. [2:50:12] And we enjoy working with Troy and Jackie [2:50:16] And I mean, the whole, I had to call them staff, [2:50:19] it makes them sound like they got an infection or something. [2:50:22] But these are good folks, okay? [2:50:27] And I think that over a period of time, [2:50:30] we have developed a very good rapport with them [2:50:33] and we would really like to work with you. [2:50:35] And Rebecca, you bring up the issue of access? [2:50:39] Well, yeah, you gotta come on us. [2:50:40] Yeah, you gotta drive along. [2:50:42] Yeah, you gotta destroy land. [2:50:43] Yeah, you gotta do all of that. [2:50:44] And yeah, we know all of that. [2:50:46] And we're here to work with you to get it done. [2:50:50] Rob, did you want to weigh in? [2:50:53] No, not at this time, but I just think before you started [2:50:59] drilling the, I guess I do, before you start drilling [2:51:05] where the loose rock is, a lot of that's going to have to be [2:51:08] cleaved off to get a clean surface, good solid surface. [2:51:12] And I don't know how much that is, but it's going to be [2:51:17] There'll be a lot of rock that'll have to come off to get a good solid service to drill [2:51:24] into if that nanny's going to work and I guess we got to start somewhere so I'm glad we're [2:51:39] doing it. [2:51:40] So I think it's fair to say that you're ready to stand with us and work with us on this as [2:51:45] we move forward. [2:51:46] That's what I'm hearing. [2:51:48] We want to be part of the solution. [2:51:50] Excellent. [2:51:51] Thank you both, thank you, thank you, Greg Lanning. [2:51:58] I'm Ms. Rebecca, your comments a little while ago [2:52:03] actually made me think of a possible other funding source. [2:52:06] I'm not sure that we have fully explored at this point [2:52:10] because we haven't had great success with getting funds out of them in the past. [2:52:15] Let's be the Twin Falls Highway District. [2:52:17] Since doesn't that that road kind of go in and add a city ownership [2:52:23] I'm gonna look at it look at the Fritz or somebody on that one that is doesn't it get end up in the county at some point [2:52:29] And then back into the city and those things so you need to remember that that Canyon Springs Road is not a [2:52:35] It's not a public roadway. It's not a dedicated right away. It's city owned property all the way down [2:52:42] Yeah, I don't want to dedicate it at some point, but [2:52:45] All right so I'm just look I'm like everyone here I think we're looking at [2:52:50] funding sources yeah the highway district although they as they do seem to have [2:52:55] have a new attitude just to use a term about sharing on projects their [2:53:01] problem would be it doesn't connect any part of their system there okay but that [2:53:06] half of the their income that comes from the residents the city to and falls [2:53:11] maybe they'd be willing to at least look at it as a project that benefits everyone. [2:53:16] And I would actually very much suggest that you work with with with [2:53:22] Katie and Robin get out there and look at that top because there's one little [2:53:25] section there that Robin is very definite is gonna have to be cleaved off [2:53:29] and probably should be cleaved off soon. There's a gap like that on [2:53:34] some about eight feet of rock there's a big gap between it. You know what was [2:53:40] Because that's 10,000 years, I don't know, but it's going to come down sometime. [2:53:43] The strategy report did say there would be some cleaving, I guess, of rocks needed to [2:53:49] make it more solid. [2:53:50] The hard part is this raw wall here is 100 feet high. [2:53:53] I mean, for you to blast that wall, you're going to put it right on top of that roadway. [2:53:57] It takes a long time to move that much rock, and then you're impacting those businesses [2:54:01] down there, and again, the wastewater treatment plant. [2:54:04] So it really has to be thought about. [2:54:05] That's why the nanny, and I don't want to give you guys a false impression that the nanny [2:54:09] eliminates all risk. It doesn't. I don't know really what does or blasting. Yeah, it you can make [2:54:17] another face, but the face behind it could be just as bad as this one. You get a little bit more room, [2:54:22] again, moving the pedestrians away is an opportunity to make them a little safer, but it doesn't eliminate [2:54:28] at all. So I think it's fair to say we can't dedicate that road to the highway district tomorrow. [2:54:34] I don't know. [2:54:35] This is Jackie. [2:54:37] Sean, or excuse me, Rebecca, Mel, soika. [2:54:40] Thank you, Mayor. [2:54:41] I think you might have just touched on the answer to my question, but I appreciate the [2:54:46] comments from Mr. Struthers and Ms. Breckenridge and their input. [2:54:52] So my question is, did Strata consider in these estimates the need to, I think your [2:55:01] which is cleaving off the edge or as Katie put it taking off the edge. [2:55:05] So that was part of the estimate, what they felt was a necessary expense. [2:55:12] Okay. [2:55:13] Thank you. [2:55:13] Sean Barrier. [2:55:16] I'd like to make a motion if we're ready for that. [2:55:19] Please. [2:55:20] So I would move that we approve the request to reserve $1 million of the wastewater treatment plant bond proceeds. [2:55:28] reconstruction of Kane's things grade due to impacts from the wastewater treatment plan expansion project [2:55:34] So I can have a motion on the floor by Sean Barregger seconded by Chris talking to [2:55:40] Any further on that motion council? [2:55:43] Do you have the roll call vote please? [2:55:45] Suzanne Hawkins? [2:55:46] Yes [2:55:48] Jima? [2:55:48] Yes [2:55:49] Sean Barregger? [2:55:50] Yes [2:55:51] Chris Talkins? [2:55:52] Yes [2:55:53] Brad Lanting? [2:55:54] Yes [2:55:54] Uh-huh [2:55:55] Yes [2:55:56] Rebecca Miss Linda? [2:55:57] Yes [2:55:58] Motion passes seven to zero and I look forward to the options that we will find in the future [2:56:05] Actually this Wednesday [2:56:07] We are having an open house and it is really just talk about the construction traffic how it impacts the can't reach great [2:56:13] for [2:56:14] You know the general public to come out past questions [2:56:17] And if you have me to talk to our PIO about experiment a little bit. [2:56:23] The other part of this is there was discussions about a groundbreaking. [2:56:29] And since we've awarded the package one here pretty soon, I don't know if you guys are interested [2:56:34] in having something like that. [2:56:35] It's such a large project. [2:56:37] And do you have any ideas and schedules? [2:56:40] We did have to go pretty quick here, unfortunately. [2:56:43] I don't know if there's something you want us to recommend that a future data or if you [2:56:51] guys have an idea in mind? [2:56:56] Council thoughts? [2:57:00] I think it's certainly a significant project, a very significant project and probably worthy [2:57:06] of some celebration of it kicking off. [2:57:10] Okay. [2:57:11] I don't think it's too difficult to try to throw our schedules together and stick some shovels in the dirt. [2:57:20] Come up with the time and make a recommendation. Thank you. [2:57:25] As I have a great landing, I'm thinking of that as if I'm in Boise this weekend and the other email from Mayor Tammy Dewear from Brady [2:57:36] and then they're throwing dirt because they're starting to work on the interchange. [2:57:39] We need to consider that with our interchange act here. [2:57:41] So I would think, yeah, we can throw some dirt on this. [2:57:46] Council in light of the next presentation that [2:57:49] says it's an hour long, I think I'm [2:57:51] going to recess us for three minutes. [2:57:53] Be back here at 10-0. [2:57:55] Back to the break back. [2:57:57] Keep my room. [3:03:11] I'd like to reconvene the meeting of the Twin Falls City [3:03:18] Council on 31st. [3:03:20] It's about eight minutes till the hour of 8 o'clock. [3:03:24] Next item on the agenda is presentation by the long term planning committee on personnel, [3:03:29] capital needs and maintenance and operations needed to accomplish identified goals and [3:03:34] objectives of the City of Twin Falls Community Strategic Plan 2030. [3:03:40] So it looks like we have our finance director, Lori Race. [3:03:44] Welcome, Lori. [3:03:45] Thank you, Mayor and City Council. [3:03:47] The very first thing I'd like to do is just do a quick introduction of this team. [3:03:52] So we have John Spendlove with the Planning and Zoning Department, Chuck Garner, Police Department, [3:04:00] Matt Barnes Airport, Gretchen Scott, HR, Tammy Lotta, IS, Jerry Aten, Wastewater, [3:04:11] Mandy Thompson, City Manager, good, City Manager Department, Todd Anderson's, Todd Anderson's. [3:04:22] Todd Anderson, Parks, Jack Barnes, Fire, Rob Owens, [3:04:27] Inspections, Dean Littler, Streets, Stacey McClintock, [3:04:33] Recreation, Norm Hatkey, Shop, Patty Lehman, Finance, [3:04:38] Rob Bowling, Water, and Jackie Fields. [3:04:51] Oh, Terry Thousen, who couldn't be here tonight? [3:04:54] So that's our team. [3:05:01] So our team first meant January 7th, and we were charged with coming up with a realistic multi-year fiscal planning tool. [3:05:11] And it was to be able to begin addressing the goals and objectives of the strategic plan. [3:05:19] Now you'll remember the items in the strategic plan that are marked with the one are items that we're supposed to be able to accomplish within a five-year window. [3:05:28] So that really worked perfectly with this plan. [3:05:31] So our plan needed to be the things that we needed to meet the goals and objectives, and [3:05:40] yet we still needed to be able to provide services to the citizens that we serve. [3:05:47] Now this tool does not take the place of budgeting nor is it meant to produce any kind of a balanced [3:05:52] document. [3:05:54] You know that that's what we do during the budget process. [3:05:56] Rather, this is a tool to just start addressing the implementation of our strategic plan, goals [3:06:03] and objectives that will be incorporated into the budget process. [3:06:08] It's kind of a kick off to our budget process. [3:06:12] So our new members spend a day learning about what the other departments did. [3:06:17] They toured one another's facilities and they learned about the services that each provided. [3:06:25] We then began the process, and each team member brought their five-year estimated needs to [3:06:31] the table. [3:06:32] Those needs had to include personnel and capital equipment to meet the objectives of our strategic [3:06:40] plan and also the same types of needs that we would have for our ongoing levels of service. [3:06:49] Due to time constraints, we really focused on the tax-supported funds, although personnel [3:06:55] and equipment needs were brought forward by the enterprise funds. [3:06:59] And we also really focused on 2015, even though it's a five-year plan, knowing full well that [3:07:06] some of the items that we didn't recommend for 2015 could become higher priorities in [3:07:12] the outline years. [3:07:14] The items we identified were space and facility needs, new personnel needs while recognizing [3:07:22] the need to treat our current employees fairly. [3:07:25] We included a 3% pay adjustment in each of the five years knowing full well it could be [3:07:31] more or less in each of those years. [3:07:34] We included a 7% health insurance increase for 2015 and a 10% increase past that time. [3:07:44] Based on historical information, we included a 4% multiplier for M&O expenses for each of [3:07:50] the five years and we identified capital projects and equipment needs. [3:07:56] Now we prioritized each item with a one, two, or three, [3:07:59] number one's were our highest priority. [3:08:02] And we wanted to be able to easily identify what if scenarios? [3:08:07] What if we stripped out all the twos and threes? [3:08:10] And what if we had enough resources [3:08:12] we could start putting some of the items back in? [3:08:16] So we had quite a list of needs. [3:08:18] And it seemed appropriate to introduce [3:08:21] what I call a dose of reality. [3:08:23] We looked at five years of resource projections [3:08:29] because we did need this plan to be realistic. [3:08:32] Now this graph is used only to illustrate the gap [3:08:36] between needs and resources to pay for those needs. [3:08:40] The red line indicates the needs [3:08:42] and the blue line the resources. [3:08:45] We use the best information available at the time. [3:08:50] Property taxes, we use the 3% increase [3:08:53] with estimated growth, no use of foregone amount. [3:08:57] And it became pretty apparent to our team [3:09:01] that there simply were not enough resources to fund the needs. [3:09:06] Now remember our goal is not to balance anything. [3:09:09] This occurs during the budget process. [3:09:12] But we did want to provide a realistic view [3:09:15] of our needs and affordability. [3:09:19] We then had to discuss and reevaluate each position [3:09:24] and each capital project. [3:09:26] We didn't have consensus, we would vote, [3:09:29] and we had lots of heated discussions. [3:09:32] Each member of this committee realizes [3:09:35] that our recommendations may not be the final product [3:09:38] or the final budget document for the next five years. [3:09:41] We realize priorities change. [3:09:44] We have identified future needs [3:09:46] and identified a pathway to start meeting [3:09:49] the goals and objectives of our strategic plan. [3:09:52] In the rest of our presentation, [3:09:54] we'll be discussing facility needs, [3:09:56] personnel needs, and capital needs in more detail. [3:10:00] Next up is John Spindlove. [3:10:07] Mayor, members of the council, [3:10:08] I know you first for me quite a bit today. [3:10:11] Some of you were able to come on the tour. [3:10:13] That's, I've included also Jim and Rebecca, [3:10:15] giving you copies of what the other council members have. [3:10:18] And the details, different facilities, [3:10:20] we identified that we may have issues with space. [3:10:23] Later, you're gonna be hearing about the personnel request [3:10:26] we will be needing with the growth in the city and positions we're going to need. [3:10:31] Those people need a place to work. [3:10:34] There are specific locations that we talk about and we toured today, Police Department, [3:10:39] City Hall, Fire Departments and the Hanson Building. [3:10:42] Those ones were identified specifically as needing space for these additional people. [3:10:50] Also in this whole process, the space needs were identified very early. [3:10:56] We also know that those space needs the dollar amount to fix and to address those space needs [3:11:03] are a lot. [3:11:04] With this process we pulled that space needs out and said we know this dollar amount and [3:11:10] whatever it's going to cost is going to be more than what this group is going to be able [3:11:14] to identify and solve in a short amount of time we had to put together the strategic plan. [3:11:21] So those were taken out and we focused on personnel and capital, even though the space [3:11:27] needs as most of you saw today are great as far as what we look towards in the next 5 years. [3:11:34] So this is the summary piece that we have that goes with the slides you guys already saw today. [3:11:40] We have a report done in 2005 by the Evergreen Studio. [3:11:46] There's a comprehensive report done by in conjunction with the department heads as far as looking to the next 10 years [3:11:52] Ten years from 2005 is this year. They identified this year as one that [3:11:59] We would have space needs [3:12:01] There were a couple options [3:12:03] They proposed one of those and we talked about this earlier was adding on to City Hall between the fire department that would give us extra space [3:12:10] That addition would have gotten us to this year and we'd be in the same position. We are today [3:12:14] What happened was we acquired the Hanson Building in 2007, which was a fix and or a solution to getting more space from this report. [3:12:23] And that wasn't in the report, but that's something we thought was physically responsible at the time. [3:12:28] It was a lot less expensive to acquire the Hanson Building, get that square footage and have places for the engineering building and planning and zoning or community development to all be in a space together. [3:12:40] alleviating the space needs we had a city all the time. [3:12:43] We also relocated the engineering lab to this building, [3:12:47] and we also relocated the Parks and Rec Department [3:12:50] to their new office. [3:12:52] So we kind of did what was in this report. [3:12:55] Despite all of that, they said, and this report detailed, [3:12:59] that in 2015 we would need to consider other options [3:13:02] because we would be running out of space. [3:13:05] So that's what this report talks about, [3:13:07] is what we did, what we accomplished, [3:13:09] And now we are at where we are today. [3:13:14] So in conclusion, the group felt that the current facilities [3:13:18] that we have and are using are insufficient for our future [3:13:21] growth. [3:13:22] The future growth of key public safety and customer service [3:13:25] departments have or shortly will exceed the available space, [3:13:28] specifically the police department, City Hall, [3:13:31] the Hanson Building, which deals with all of the building [3:13:33] permits, the inspections, and the engineering department [3:13:37] that offers those customer service-oriented groups. [3:13:39] those spaces have or will shortly be used up with very few space to put individuals and [3:13:47] or storage of things we need to as you saw in our tour with the space for building permits [3:13:55] storage in the basement of the Hanson building that's not fireproofed or have sprinklers in [3:14:00] it and also has ADA issues. [3:14:03] City Hall relocation consolidation was something that this group came up with. [3:14:07] There was something to say about a disconnect between the Hanson Building and City Hall. [3:14:11] Those two groups, they contact each other every day. [3:14:15] Travis being at City Hall, Mitch and Jackie, senior staff level individuals in a different [3:14:20] building. [3:14:21] Sometimes there are issues that need answers quickly. [3:14:24] The disconnect in a different location does create a delay. [3:14:28] It can create some issues between inter-departmental communication. [3:14:32] So this group considered creating a central location for all customer service oriented [3:14:37] departments and plan for future growth needs. That would include consolidating City Hall [3:14:43] with the Hanson building, all those individuals under one roof, and it would also as a by-product [3:14:48] and in conjunction with create a public safety campus for future police and fire needs while [3:14:53] remaining in the downtown area. We've been told that the fire department and the police [3:14:57] department would like to stay in the downtown area as the fire department specifically [3:15:02] is a response time the police department has been in one central location. If City Hall [3:15:07] were vacated that would then be turned over to the police department for a potential public [3:15:13] safety campus. It would also allow for the parking lot to potentially become a secure parking [3:15:18] lot area for the police vehicles, storage areas. And in talking about this consolidation [3:15:25] we talked about locations. The strategic plan talks about three specific goals. And I have [3:15:32] I've noted them in my notes, it's PC1, PC2, and PC3. [3:15:37] They're all goals that deal with downtown redevelopment. [3:15:41] Talk about dollars downtown, paying attention to downtown, [3:15:46] reinvigorating downtown. [3:15:48] So there are a total of approximately five, [3:15:51] there's an A and a B on a couple of those. [3:15:55] And it also says something to the fact [3:15:57] that downtown area has been a place [3:16:00] where redevelopment has occurred with private dollars. [3:16:03] There's a list of businesses I put together just roughly. [3:16:06] Larger ones with Glamia St. Luke's, [3:16:08] Will's, Toyota, First Federal. [3:16:10] Those ones have put large dollars in private capital [3:16:13] into reinvigorating the downtown, improving it. [3:16:17] The smaller businesses in comparison. [3:16:20] The sandwich company, the cookie basket, [3:16:22] the ground round, the ballroom, the Stone House, [3:16:24] which is over by 4th Avenue South or East, I believe, [3:16:29] owned by Adair Johnson. [3:16:31] The old muggers building, which was redone, [3:16:33] the entire building done by Eddy Sabia, [3:16:34] the old Pomerail Studio, [3:16:35] which is gonna be turned into apartment buildings. [3:16:39] And the URA is also invested in numerous dollars. [3:16:42] If this is an option or is something [3:16:44] that we look forward to doing or possibly doing, [3:16:47] we would suggest the downtown area [3:16:49] as a very strong option to put this location, [3:16:54] co-location or consolidation of City Hall [3:16:58] the Hanson Building under one roof. There is the study talks about square footages, briefly [3:17:04] I mentioned it earlier. We have about 11,000 square feet of City Hall and 11,000 square [3:17:09] feet at the Hanson Building. This study said that in 2015 we would outgrow a 55,000 square [3:17:17] foot building. Those square footages have changed, but today we're operating at a 26,000 square [3:17:25] square footage for those two offices and it's proposed that we have a lot more than that. [3:17:30] I think we can do more with less. We always have in Twin Falls. We will always give the best customer service that we can [3:17:37] to the individuals that come to us and that's what we do, people serving people. [3:17:42] And we think we can do better if we have a consolidated campus with the synergy between the different departments and the different facilities. [3:17:50] facilities. You're not going to hear from Chuck Garner talking about the personnel requests [3:17:54] that we put in. He'll talk about those in specifics. [3:17:57] Mayor Hall, members of the Council, thank you for giving us this opportunity. This process [3:18:07] was, I've worked here a long time, but this was my first exposure to how other city departments [3:18:13] work and it was quite an education. And what we're going into now, our personnel request, [3:18:19] is probably the most emotional and heated of our discussions. [3:18:24] Everyone is very passionate about their mission [3:18:26] and the resources they have to complete that. [3:18:31] And it was a real struggle for our committee [3:18:34] to reach the proposals we're going to show you tonight. [3:18:38] I'd like to start by showing you what the city's long-term [3:18:42] operations plan projects as Twin Falls' population growth [3:18:47] to the year 2020. This plan says that within six years, our city is going to grow to 57,000 [3:18:55] people, almost a 25% increase from where we are right now. One of the things we struggled [3:19:02] with was how do we, given our available resources, not improve our services, but just meet the [3:19:11] services we are currently delivering with this anticipated growth. I'd also like to point [3:19:18] out that we use the term influx population a lot or service population. I've heard conservative [3:19:28] estimates that 60,000 people a day are in our city, two estimates of 70 to 75,000 people. [3:19:35] That's our service population. Our personnel request and our current staff and levels do [3:19:40] not address that. So the proposals we're going to show you were reached by using these [3:19:54] weights and measures. What are the city strategic plan goals? How can we maintain current service [3:20:01] levels? How can we improve our services and increase efficiency? What can we do to respond [3:20:07] to projected growth? And we also identify personnel that are needed, but we just can't [3:20:15] support this time as a priority warrant given our resources. [3:20:21] And one thing the community identified that we'd like to point out to the Council and [3:20:26] all the city staff members that are here is that maybe some elements of our strategic plan [3:20:33] are too ambitious. [3:20:35] There's a lot of priority wants which I'm sure the Council recalls our objectives we want [3:20:41] to have met within five years. [3:20:43] And we encourage that the council, senior staff revisit that and see maybe if we took [3:20:52] off just a little bit more than we can shoot with some of them. [3:20:55] Can we move some of the priority ones to priority twos, priority twos to priority threes. [3:21:03] Our recommendations we envision will improve our professional technical development in [3:21:09] the city's communication system. [3:21:13] We hope the city can continue to serve as a focal point for economic development efforts [3:21:20] in that the city will continue to provide public services and facilities that support economic [3:21:25] development. All of these, of course, tie into the city strategic plan objectives. We want [3:21:33] to continue to support environmental stewardship. Dean Littler talks about Phase 2 storm water [3:21:41] that's a mandate that's coming up. We're going to have to increase personnel to meet [3:21:46] that. We want to maintain a high level of interactive communication with the city citizens on our [3:21:54] our police services. We want to support the [3:21:58] information of DEDACs there that stands for [3:22:02] data-driven, accident, crime and traffic safety. [3:22:09] How can the police deploy to respond to these [3:22:13] spots, hot spots are identified by the data we collect? [3:22:18] And how can the police maintain police response to [3:22:21] drug and alcohol problems? [3:22:27] So these are the recommendations we have that [3:22:30] we think will maintain our service levels, [3:22:33] not increase maintained. [3:22:38] And I get confused on this. [3:22:40] Wastewater has a position that they fund, [3:22:44] but that person now works in the streets department. [3:22:48] So we would like to have that funding [3:22:54] put under the proper department now. [3:22:59] And then as I get far along my presentation, [3:23:01] we hope to backfill that position as a safety measure [3:23:05] their crew. The police, these numbers with patrol officers respectively, we're just [3:23:17] trying to maintain a staffing level of 1.6 per 1,000 people, which is the Idaho average. [3:23:27] If we don't add personnel, we're going to continue following behind if these population [3:23:34] bear out. And with more patrol officers, you need more [3:23:39] dispatchers. This has already been approved, but it's [3:23:46] something that we've acted into. Our discussions is the new [3:23:53] Deputy Prosecutor's Attorney that's going to work in City [3:23:55] Manager's office. IS, or a real eye opener for me, I had no [3:24:02] idea that the workload that our Information Services [3:24:06] Department have. They are in dire need of another [3:24:10] These two electrician positions will fall under different departments, but be managed by IS, and if any council members have a question on that, I will defer to them departments there, because it's very technical stuff in this way above my head. [3:24:35] Chief Pike has had a vision of transforming the management structure of the police department and [3:24:42] The supervisor reposition upgrade from a staff sergeant position to a lieutenant position is not a new body. It is simply [3:24:50] Removing one one staff sergeant and create changing that position into a lieutenant [3:24:56] We need a staff engineer badly [3:25:01] Jackie made impassioned [3:25:03] presentations on why we need that. [3:25:09] The Council's well aware of all of the economic growth [3:25:12] and all the pressures that puts on her department. [3:25:16] And wastewater collection operator, it's a safety issue. [3:25:20] They need a crew of three for trenching [3:25:25] and to stand by while the guy's in the trench. [3:25:29] I'm sure the Council may recall the unfortunate incident [3:25:34] in window last winter when one of their city employees [3:25:37] at a fatal accident while working in a trench, [3:25:41] we want to avoid that. [3:25:46] These projections, we hope, will respond to the growth [3:25:51] that we are projecting to come to the city. [3:25:54] The staff engineer to keep up with the new economic development [3:25:58] projects, a water supply operator, because as the city grows, [3:26:03] the water supply system grows. [3:26:10] Probably the most heated and emotional part [3:26:15] of our meetings where our requested personnel that we can't support given our resources. [3:26:24] And everyone understands that, but these positions, everyone on the committee feels [3:26:32] are absolute needs. [3:26:34] We just can't prioritize it as one given our other needs. [3:26:38] But we wanted to make the council aware that our building department, they are slammed. [3:26:49] Parks, probably the most impassioned presentation was from a parks department. [3:26:55] Hundreds of acres that these people have to maintain. [3:26:58] But when you balance other needs, public safety and whatnot, we could not make that a one. [3:27:08] Engineering, a GIS technician. [3:27:11] One of the police departments hope to implement the DDAC's policing model is we rely on heat [3:27:20] mapping and Jackie's GIS technician may as well be one of our employees, we use her so [3:27:27] much and Jackie needs some help there. [3:27:33] And we would like to continue if possible to add more than just two police officers a [3:27:40] year just to maintain, we would like to stay ahead a little. [3:27:48] With that, I turn over to Matt Barnes from the airport [3:27:52] to talk about our capital request. [3:28:00] Good evening, Mayor, Council members of Matt Barnes [3:28:03] from the airport department. [3:28:05] And I'll be talking about the capital needs [3:28:08] of this committee identified while working together. [3:28:12] Again, we use the same kind of model [3:28:14] that when we identified all the personnel needs, [3:28:17] And that we looked at the specific strategic plan goals [3:28:21] that these capital needs will help us solve. [3:28:26] Also, how these needs will maintain [3:28:29] current service levels, how they might help us improve [3:28:33] our service levels, and also to try [3:28:37] to respond to the projected growth that we're [3:28:40] experiencing in Twin Falls. [3:28:42] Also, I'd like to talk about all those priority [3:28:46] to capital needs that were identified and just to kind of help make sure everybody understands [3:28:54] how they are still very important to us that, you know, again, because of limited resources, [3:29:00] they became priority twos instead of ones. [3:29:06] So first, I'd like to hit on the strategic plan goals that these different capital needs [3:29:12] that I'll talk about soon are going to help us with. [3:29:17] There are things like maintain and improve the airport facilities, maintain and improve [3:29:24] water and wastewater utility systems, maintain the street department network within the [3:29:31] City of Twin Falls, ensure the safety of our facilities, ensure that our facilities stay [3:29:39] safe and active during emergencies, and also provide for facilities and programs that the [3:29:46] City of Twin Falls citizens want as part of a healthy lifestyle. [3:29:54] So this first section of needs and departments have to do with maintaining current service [3:30:00] levels. [3:30:01] First is the airport is proposing a terminal lighting upgrade in order to continue to provide [3:30:08] safe lighting at the airport. [3:30:12] Also the pool is proposing the same kind of upgrade in order to again provide safe environment [3:30:20] at the pool. [3:30:23] Next the street department is a very important equipment replacement program that they have. [3:30:30] They like to continue to replace equipment on a timely basis just because they're using [3:30:37] it every day and of course it wears out with continued use. [3:30:41] Now they're very aware that sometimes equipment lasts longer than expected, so they're very [3:30:48] careful on picking which pieces are going to actually need replacement on these timely [3:30:53] bases. [3:30:55] Also we've identified the need for just regular street maintenance. [3:31:03] The police department identified the need for a new SWAT vehicle. [3:31:07] The current vehicle is extremely antiquated and frankly unsafe. [3:31:11] It's been identified by the shop supervisor that it's extremely unreliable and it's one [3:31:19] of those vehicles that maybe isn't needed very often, but when it is needed it's very important [3:31:25] that we get the SWAT team to a location in a timely and safe manner. [3:31:30] So they would like to upgrade to a new vehicle that would be specifically designed for that [3:31:35] role. [3:31:37] Along, just like Street Department, they also have a fleet replacement program because of [3:31:42] the daily use of their vehicles. [3:31:45] They also would like to start doing a taser replacement program. [3:31:48] They found that over the years that these tasers have a limited shelf life and through use and [3:31:55] And just becoming older, they're experiencing what's called brownouts with these tasers, [3:32:01] where they're not performing as needed, and it could become a public safety issue or even [3:32:08] an officer safety issue. [3:32:13] The Parks Department again has a fleet replacement program completely based on if the particular [3:32:22] vehicle is wearing out and is in need of replacement so they can do their day-to-day activities. [3:32:29] Along with that, the tennis courts kind of fall under that same kind of idea is that over [3:32:35] time and use they become worn and need regular maintenance. [3:32:40] The City Hall building is in need of a roof repair. [3:32:45] They've experienced leak here recently and they would like to fix that before it gets [3:32:49] any worse. And then a really important one for all of us is, you know, here again, there's [3:32:55] IS. They support us in everything that we do. Without them doing this network and server [3:33:02] replacement, it makes it very difficult for us to do our jobs if we cannot rely on, you [3:33:07] know, the speed and the access to that network. Lastly, I have there that the Fire Department [3:33:16] is trying to procure a new tower truck, along with a breathing apparatus replacement. [3:33:24] Now both of these are proposed to be grant funded. [3:33:28] So if the grants aren't awarded to the fire department, they're not going to purchase [3:33:32] these pieces of equipment, and they will be able to maintain their current service levels [3:33:37] with the equipment they have now, they would just like to take advantage of purchasing [3:33:43] new equipment because the tower truck is quite old. [3:33:47] You know, down in Keith Barnes could tell you exactly how old it is, but it's definitely [3:33:53] yeah, thank you. [3:33:56] It's definitely getting up there. [3:33:57] So they saw that it was an opportunity to maybe get a brand new one and then put the [3:34:01] current one into reserve. [3:34:03] They'd like to continue to keep it and maintain it because it is in good shape. [3:34:08] The BA replacement isn't necessary right now in order for them to do their jobs in case [3:34:13] they're called on. If this grant doesn't go through to replace the entire breathing apparatus [3:34:21] equipment that they have right now, they've got a plan to slowly replace that as those systems [3:34:26] become too old and are no longer used. So next we were able to identify some capital needs that [3:34:36] would actually improve services and increase efficiency within the City of Twin Falls. [3:34:40] The lighting upgrades I've listed here for airport and pool are actually the same lighting upgrades that I mentioned before. [3:34:48] I feel that it's important to mention that when doing these upgrades, the pool and the airport have looked into the possibility and the realism that we can use new technology when we're making these upgrades. [3:35:03] And by doing that, we can save the city a significant amount of money by using less energy. [3:35:11] Also, it would provide better lighting and a safer environment, again. [3:35:17] The street department would like to make some changes to their equipment storage facilities [3:35:24] and upgrade them so that they're heated. [3:35:26] And by doing that, they can maintain the quality of their equipment for a longer time [3:35:31] And just make it easier to use the equipment and make sure that they can rely on that equipment when they need it. [3:35:38] Next, the Police Department is proposing smartphones for their Criminal Investigation Division and their supervisors. [3:35:49] Now, these small tools could be used to help the officers share information in a much quicker and more timely fashion. [3:35:58] One example that was mentioned was being able to very quickly email photos to all the officers that are out in the field just really quickly so that missing persons or whatever else can be identified quickly. [3:36:13] Next, the parks was proposing improvements to auger falls, the city park and legion field. [3:36:22] Now most of these improvements have to do with new restrooms or rebuilding old restrooms. [3:36:29] Could I stop you just real quick? [3:36:30] I object wholeheartedly. [3:36:33] I have everyone in here. [3:36:37] I'm sorry, but I just couldn't help it. [3:36:46] Go ahead, sir. [3:36:47] I'm sorry. [3:36:48] That's okay. [3:36:49] For a minute there, I thought I did something wrong, you're attempting to meet. [3:36:55] Oh, the parks. [3:36:57] So the parks department is talking, you know, they'd like to make improvements to agar falls, [3:37:02] the city park in Legion Field. [3:37:04] Now most of these have to do with, like I said, drinking fountains, trails, restroom areas. [3:37:11] Specifically, at the city park it was identified that the ban shell is an aging structure that [3:37:16] has a lot of use still. [3:37:18] A lot of people like to use that building and it's, you know, unfortunately hasn't been [3:37:22] upgraded in many years. [3:37:24] So that was one of the things they would like to try to tackle is improving that facility, [3:37:29] making it more modern and making it easier to maintain and easier to use. [3:37:33] One of the things identified with that structure in particular was the electrical system. [3:37:39] John Leisure, our overworked electrician, is constantly half in the go on service calls [3:37:45] during events to fix issues that they have. [3:37:52] In the recreation, oh, excuse me, that Legion field, along with all the other proposed upgrades [3:37:58] to parks, they would like to mitigate a safety risk that's been identified with the netting [3:38:07] above the backstop. They've already got a plan in place to make sure that that's not [3:38:11] going to be an issue for this upcoming ball season, but they would like to spend some additional [3:38:17] dollars in the next fiscal year to make sure that it's not a recurring issue, and then we [3:38:21] have a more permanent fix for capturing foul balls that might go behind the dugout. [3:38:27] On top of that, they would actually like to rebuild the score box, the score booth. [3:38:33] Moving on to recreation, they would like to start looking into a program to slowly update [3:38:40] all the scoreboards at different fields. [3:38:43] The idea behind, one of the big ideas behind this is to try to make them all the same. [3:38:48] That way you have similar parts, similar systems, and it will just make it easier to maintain [3:38:54] and service these scoreboards in the future. [3:38:58] Here again, I asked, you know, [3:38:59] there's a department that supports the rest of us [3:39:02] in what we do, and they're proposing a computer replacement [3:39:06] to make sure that we can, you know, [3:39:07] all do our jobs in a timely matter [3:39:09] and rely on the technology that we come to use [3:39:12] and be used to. [3:39:14] On top of that, they'd like to connect station, [3:39:17] Fire Station 1 and 2, corrections, [3:39:20] Fire Station 2 and 3 to fiber optic. [3:39:24] They're still using old wireless internet systems, [3:39:29] and it's proven to be unreliable in the past. [3:39:33] And there was talk of plans with using the street department [3:39:37] personnel and possibly even water department personnel [3:39:41] to do some of the labor involved with these connectivity [3:39:45] issues and reduce the cost by a lot. [3:39:49] That's something that we can go into more detail [3:39:52] you guys wish. On top of all that they're also proposing some procurement of [3:39:59] additional GPS units. Chuck kind of mentioned before that it's really [3:40:04] important to the police department for all this GPS stuff. Well some of the other [3:40:08] with the rolling out of city works it's become very important for the rest of [3:40:14] the departments to start being able to go out in the field and gather GPS data. [3:40:19] data. [3:40:20] And it's been identified that we're maybe a little bit short on those tools that the rest [3:40:25] of the departments need in order to gather that data. [3:40:30] Building inspections is planning an equipment upgrade so they can begin e-planning submittal [3:40:37] and review. [3:40:38] Now, this will hopefully speed up the process and make it much easier for building department [3:40:46] to do review planning and then obviously go out and do inspections. [3:40:52] This is kind of a big deal because the committee felt that it would ultimately end up in a lot [3:40:57] better customer support because of the growth that we're experiencing here in Twin Falls now. [3:41:04] And finally, the engineering department would like to update their lab equipment just for [3:41:08] quality control purposes during all these projects that are going on. [3:41:12] The current equipment doesn't allow them to do all the different quality control that [3:41:16] they'd like to do, and they could feel that they could do a better job with more current [3:41:20] and modern equipment. [3:41:29] So this next bit of capital needs that were identified, all have to do with the response [3:41:36] to projected growth. [3:41:40] A lot of it has to do with new personnel requests that were made, and obviously every time we [3:41:45] hire a police officer, we also need a vehicle for each pair of police officers that we hire. [3:41:52] Along with that, the Parks Department was proposing using some impact fees to increase their indoor storage for their equipment. [3:42:00] And, you know, therefore making that equipment last longer. [3:42:04] The weather is just really hard on things like mowers and tractors and that kind of stuff. [3:42:10] IS would need new office equipment for all those new personnel that we're requesting that IS get. [3:42:17] And at the same time, engineering would also need office equipment for the new personnel, [3:42:24] along with some upgrades to the top floor of the Hanson building, to house those personnel. [3:42:31] So finally, I'd like to talk about those, you know, again, very heated conversations about [3:42:44] capital needs that, unfortunately, became priority twos. [3:42:49] I know that I'm starting to repeat what other presenters have already told you guys, but [3:42:54] I'd like to make it clear that just because we gave it a priority to doesn't mean it wasn't important. [3:43:00] It's just that we wanted to present a realistic presentation to the council about and try to match up with what resources really are. [3:43:11] And so these departments experienced some needs that they felt were priority ones, but [3:43:18] unfortunately got downgraded to priority two. [3:43:22] Those are the police department, building inspection, engineering, and parks. [3:43:27] And like I said before, all of these priority two needs do tie directly to the personnel needs [3:43:35] that were also downgraded to priority two. [3:43:40] And with that, I'd like to invite Lori Raceback up. [3:43:48] So we've shared our needs, and those needs include some serious space and facilities issues. [3:43:56] Those needs include new personnel and capital projects to meet identified goals and objectives [3:44:02] of our strategic plan while at the same time maintaining current levels of service. [3:44:08] We've considered current city employees, including dollars for pay and health insurance adjustments. [3:44:15] And we've looked at historical M&O costs and applied an increase for ongoing expenditures. [3:44:22] We know the difficult job of trying to allocate very limited resources to an unending list of [3:44:29] needs. [3:44:30] And this group has learned the necessity of prioritizing those needs. [3:44:36] This group has also learned the challenges that are faced during the budget process. [3:44:41] We need to ensure that our priorities align with our citizen expectations. [3:44:47] Are we being realistic about what we can truly fund in our strategic plan? [3:44:53] Are our goals realistic in the timeframes we've set? [3:44:57] We recognize that this plan is a compilation of our best efforts to begin addressing identified [3:45:03] goals and objectives in our strategic plan. [3:45:06] But we also know that those priorities could change and they may look very different as we move forward. [3:45:13] At the end of the day, we are a service organization and [3:45:16] we will continue to provide quality, affordable services to our citizens. [3:45:22] And that is our presentation and our entire team. [3:45:25] We'd be happy to answer any questions you might have. [3:45:29] Well, I know that there's going to be some lights come on. [3:45:31] I guess I just want to say, first of all, thank you for hanging in there this evening with us. [3:45:35] a long evening. And personally I just want to say thank you for all the work because I can just [3:45:42] imagine those groups meeting and talking about these priorities and we all have our own agendas [3:45:47] and what we think are priorities. And then you had to come out probably with a few scars but you [3:45:54] had to come out with a consensus and so appreciate all that work that you've done. So thank you. [3:45:59] I'd like to second that approval and nod to the committee on the old dinosaur on the crew, [3:46:09] but it gives me the long side, not the foresight for God's sakes, the long side to look back [3:46:15] how the City of Twin Falls was in the 70s and 80s, and there is no comparison to the professional [3:46:22] level that you're exhibiting today and not only meeting the service needs of the population, [3:46:30] but the planfulness that you're looking at the next 10, 15 years. [3:46:35] I think that's why I like to say that local government works and most especially Twin Falls, [3:46:42] the professional collaboration that you've shown in the guidance for us all fit within [3:46:47] the template of the strategic plan, I'll put us up against most businesses for being efficient [3:46:54] with our resources. Thank you. That's the easy part though, how we fund everything. I guess [3:46:59] we're all in this together. Good job though. Suzanne Hawkins. [3:47:03] Yes, again, thank you. It was very educational starting with the tour today and then continuing [3:47:08] on with tonight. Everything was really first class. Is it possible to get your presentation [3:47:13] dropped in our e-box so we can read through it and kind of mull over some of it in the [3:47:17] next couple weeks. I would appreciate that. Thank you. [3:47:20] You know, I guess one thing that I'm most impressed with with your presentation tonight [3:47:26] is how well you know each other now and your operations. I mean, you were talking about things [3:47:32] that aren't in your department like it's in your department. So that was really impressive. [3:47:37] And I guess that's part of this process of growing and learning together and check what [3:47:42] you said about getting with other folks and didn't realize really what they had to deal [3:47:47] deal with every day is powerful. Yeah. Well, that's part of it, I'm sure. [3:47:58] So to some of your customers. So thank you too for the work that you all did. So Chuck, [3:48:10] you mentioned a comment that you were hopeful that maybe the council and senior management [3:48:14] would take another look at those number one priorities in the strategic plan. [3:48:21] It rang in my head because I think I've made that same comment back when we were adopting [3:48:26] the strategic plan. [3:48:28] As you all went through this process, so I'm looking at the attachment that came with our [3:48:32] packets. [3:48:33] It's got different initiatives in the strategic plan listed out and we heard these priorities. [3:48:41] In your process, did you identify number one strategic plan priorities that are currently [3:48:48] number ones that maybe you might make recommendations? [3:48:52] Shouldn't be number ones or are there ones that didn't have resources attached to them? [3:48:58] Chuck, if you're going to answer kids, you can just vote for those folks that are wrong. [3:49:01] And I didn't mean to put you on the spot, but you're the one who said it. [3:49:06] Just so the council knows, there is a hobo spider that has been bringing it back and forth [3:49:11] up there and it is currently under the dies so I don't know are you trying to [3:49:17] get us out of here my conscious cannot allow I have to tell you that's a good [3:49:22] way to clear the room thank you there in mass presentation I was thinking of a [3:49:27] I was looking for a moment to come up again right there [3:49:36] It's keep your feet down underneath it. [3:49:42] Councilman Verger, we did. [3:49:44] If I remember right, the Police Department has 21 strategic goals. [3:49:52] And almost all of them are priority ones. [3:49:55] If I had it in front of me, I could look at it right now and tell you which ones I think. [3:50:01] I don't know as a committee if we went through that process. [3:50:06] I think each person from their own work knows what them are. [3:50:11] Okay. [3:50:12] And if we can definitely get that to you, if the council reports. [3:50:18] I think maybe the follow-up question to that would be for Travis is through this process [3:50:23] as we continue to move forward into the budgeting. [3:50:25] I mean, that's sort of the goal of this right is to maybe help do some prioritizing through [3:50:33] that process too. [3:50:36] So, absolutely. So, this really does begin to create the foundation of... [3:50:44] It's going to say that you lost Jim about four minutes ago. [3:50:49] We got the spider, so we're coming back. [3:50:52] Just meeting Matt. [3:50:54] I'm sorry, Lisa wasn't here to kill it for you, Jim. [3:51:01] So, this really does begin the formation of that budgeting process. [3:51:05] What we've done in the past is we've often had members of the city's management team [3:51:12] and department heads come in and talk about needs of the organization and what that looks [3:51:17] like. [3:51:18] With this new approach, it's really a collaborative effort of multiple groups of different employees [3:51:24] which is a really good cross-section of the entire organization. [3:51:29] And oftentimes you're going to find that their experience is on the front lines of providing [3:51:35] customer service is going to provide an expertise that maybe some of us might miss. [3:51:40] So we take that information and then we use that as part of that budgeting process. [3:51:45] I've had the opportunity to also share in a conversation with many of you about what the [3:51:50] strategic planning priorities for this upcoming year and budget are. [3:51:54] And with that, we take this list, we take your list, and we begin to create the funding [3:52:01] strategies and the funding opportunities. [3:52:03] We begin to look at making modifications to the prioritization of that strategic planning [3:52:09] list during this budget and subsequent budgeting processes. [3:52:14] Because there may be items that are number ones that we say the need may not be as pressing [3:52:20] today as what we thought it was a year ago and we committed that to be a flexible, fluid [3:52:25] and representative document of the current needs of the community. [3:52:29] And likewise, there might be some twos that we say this need has now been elevated and [3:52:34] we need to dedicate time, talent and resources to it faster than what was anticipated. [3:52:40] So as we roll through our budgeting process, you have a week really to digest this because [3:52:46] on the 14th, I guess it's about two weeks, on the 14th of April we will come back in [3:52:53] And we will begin hearing about conversations from you about how you would like to see move [3:52:58] forward with the budgeting process, as well as it's an opportunity for our citizens to [3:53:04] enter and early engage in that process. [3:53:08] So, by the 21st of April, you will have an entire palette of possible options to move [3:53:16] forward with the budgeting. [3:53:18] And that's where we'll set those overall arching priorities for the budgeting strategy. [3:53:22] We'll roll into a series of department meetings where we've heard your strategies, [3:53:27] the long-term planning piece, the citizens, and then we will begin that process of [3:53:33] painting a balanced yet thoughtful budgeting approach that accomplishes [3:53:39] hopefully most of the needs and desires of those who provide that input. [3:53:44] And thank you, Chuck, for the hope of the phone. [3:53:49] I don't think you killed it. [3:53:55] Anything else from the council? [3:53:57] regarding this agenda item. [3:54:01] Again, I think that you could see our true appreciation. [3:54:05] It really was a good job. [3:54:09] Yeah, Mr. Mayor, if I could, I'd just [3:54:10] like to really publicly comment and thank all of them [3:54:13] for their efforts. [3:54:15] This is really the team that built the documents [3:54:18] and have the conversations that is right there. [3:54:20] And if they're not on that side, [3:54:22] they weren't necessarily involved in those conversations. [3:54:25] And really, every single one of these members [3:54:29] stretched from a capacity place to really look beyond their own individual operating areas, [3:54:35] and they're all to be congratulated with a very, very thoughtful plan that will help us [3:54:39] to move forward. [3:54:41] What we will be doing different in subsequent years is not only do I present the budget to [3:54:47] you, but I feel obligated that I will also present the budget to the long-term planning [3:54:51] group for their comment and for their input. [3:54:55] We're trying to really get away from everything operates within a hierarchy and trying to create [3:55:00] a series of working groups designed around knowledge and expertise. [3:55:07] The other thing is they're going to begin their work in October. [3:55:10] So after the adoption of the budget, they're going to begin round two. [3:55:15] And this is going to be incorporated in our annual process where we do budgeting in a [3:55:20] planning continuum. [3:55:25] Thank you again. [3:55:26] Appreciate it. [3:55:29] to our second to our last item. [3:55:32] You can go ahead and take that down if you want, Lori, that's fine. [3:55:36] Is public input and or items from city manager and city council? [3:55:40] So first of all, is there anyone that's lasted this long from the public that would like to address us? [3:55:45] That's not bringing us coffee. [3:55:46] It's a nice thing, no one. [3:55:50] So I will turn it over to City, is there some? [3:55:53] No, no. [3:55:56] City manager. [3:55:57] Mr. Mayor members of the council just a quick reminder not this week, but next week is the state of the city [3:56:05] Conversation and and so that is going to be whole held I believe on the 8th [3:56:11] Beginning at noon at the Stone House [3:56:14] actually what I have is on the 8th at 11 30 and lunches served it lunch. I believe it served at noon is that correct and [3:56:21] and it's going to be and and tickets are available by contacting the [3:56:28] chamber. Leila have you sent out an appointment to all the council members for [3:56:33] their anything else I'm sorry the second item is beginning to think about dates [3:56:43] that will work in your calendar as Troy had shared with the groundbreaking [3:56:47] ceremony we want to make sure that we get that and so that it is well [3:56:52] attended and maybe it's something that we can coordinate with Sean to move [3:56:55] forward with you know what works best for me on how the rest council is is we [3:56:59] were given a couple three choices so that we can send her in on because I can't [3:57:03] tell you what my challenge it changes every day all right anything else sir [3:57:08] all right Greg MacLanley I'd like to slip out the door but I'd like to invite [3:57:14] and welcome Kimberly back from the thing from the state of Ada where she [3:57:19] was covering the legislature I enjoyed listening to you're reading your your [3:57:24] post and welcome back. You were sequestered up there right? This is real [3:57:30] government here. All right anybody else on City Council? I'm back in [3:57:37] Melsoy. Oh could you just remind us I think Troy mentioned that there will be an [3:57:42] open house regarding some impacts of the the Kenyans brings great and I think he [3:57:48] said it was Wednesday but just to remind the public of the time and location. [3:57:52] Wednesday, 530 to 730 here. [3:57:58] Second, 530 to 730 here. [3:58:00] Thank you, John. [3:58:01] We'll be talking about backflow. [3:58:03] Also, we're going to have like a little display for people, [3:58:06] so we'll catch them on the way out. [3:58:11] I see no further lights. [3:58:13] Couple things. [3:58:14] We've been in contact with folks at Rise and Shine to start [3:58:18] scheduling that again, but I think there's been some changes [3:58:21] in personnel there, so we're going to kind of wait on them [3:58:24] getting back. [3:58:25] I also wanted to report to the council that I had the opportunity and privilege to go out with the home-delivered meals, folks, a week or so ago, they're not meals on wheels, that's a whole separate deal. [3:58:39] They do the same kind of things, but home-delivered meals, and it was eye-opening, it was inspirational, and they have some wonderful volunteers that do God's work with our community. [3:58:51] So I just wanted to state that and if you get a chance to go out with them, please do so because it was it was [3:58:58] Yes, please well, I know Rebecca when I was one out last year [3:59:02] I believe but Rebecca did last year on this particular program and [3:59:06] It is obvious that one it is the only [3:59:11] Contact some of these people get [3:59:13] Every day that's the only person they get a chance to talk with as you you have to be prepared to talk to [3:59:18] because they had a few things, those few stories they'd like to tell, especially if you're the mayor. [3:59:23] Speaking of which, I need to talk to you about some canal issues over off of Harmon Park. [3:59:28] So thank you for that reminder because a gentleman wanted me to, yeah, I know it's really not ours, but he shared it with me and we need to address some things. [3:59:37] They're not afraid to share their opinions with you, so that was good as well. [3:59:43] Also, April 7th at 3.30 at the PD classroom, [3:59:48] economic ready team again. [3:59:52] And if there's gonna be more than three of us [3:59:54] show up again, we've gotta notice that. [3:59:56] So if you would let the island know so that we can do that, [4:00:01] that would be great. [4:00:02] Anything else council? [4:00:04] All right, we will be moving to our last item, [4:00:06] which is an executive session. [4:00:08] Two items, two sections here. [4:00:10] to adjourn into executive session 6723.45.1c to conduct deliberations concerning labor negotiations or [4:00:20] to acquire an interest in real property which is not owned by a public agency and e to consider preliminary [4:00:27] negotiations involving matters of trade or commerce in which the governing body is in competition with [4:00:33] governing bodies in other states or nations. So I will stand for motion. [4:00:38] We have a motion by Chris Talkington, seconded by Greg Lanting. [4:00:44] The other roll call vote, please. [4:00:50] Yes. [4:00:51] Yes. [4:00:52] Yes. [4:00:54] Yes. [4:00:55] Yes. [4:00:56] Yes. [4:00:58] Yes. [4:00:59] I'd like to state that we will be moving into executive session, [4:01:01] because we had a 7-0 vote to do so. [4:01:04] We will not be making any decisions, [4:01:07] nor will we be coming back out and reconvening. [4:01:11] So at this time, we're adjourning to executive session. [4:01:14] Okay. [4:01:15] Okay. [4:01:16] Okay. [4:01:17] Okay. [4:01:18] Okay. [4:01:19] Okay. [4:01:20] Okay. [4:01:21] Okay. [4:01:22] Okay. [4:01:23] Okay. [4:01:24] Okay. [4:01:25] Okay. [4:01:26] Okay. [4:01:27] Okay. [4:01:28] Okay. [4:01:29] Okay. [4:01:30] Okay. [4:01:31] Okay. [4:01:32] Okay. [4:01:33] Okay. [4:01:34] Okay. [4:01:35] Okay. [4:01:36] Okay. [4:01:37] Okay. [4:01:38] Okay. [4:01:39] Okay. [4:01:40] Okay. [4:01:41] Okay. [4:01:42] Okay.