Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2014-02-10, recording 1 (started 17:00) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2014-02-10/ [0:00:00] To order of Monday, February 10th, 2014, we always start our council meetings off with the Pledge of Allegiance, so those of you wishing to join us, please rise. [0:00:10] I would like to lead you with a few of the bi-I, [0:00:15] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. [0:00:31] Thank you, and welcome to everyone that's here this evening. [0:00:34] I do want to confirm that we have a quorum of the City [0:00:37] Council. [0:00:39] Travis, do we have any amendments to the agenda this evening? [0:00:44] Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, there [0:00:45] are no amendments to tonight's agenda meeting. [0:00:49] Very good, thank you, Mr. Rothweiler. [0:00:52] We are now doing public input at the beginning [0:00:55] and at the end of the council meetings [0:00:57] to give folks in the audience that aren't here to talk about [0:01:02] or make a presentation or comments about something [0:01:05] that's already on the agenda, [0:01:07] to give you a chance to come up at the beginning [0:01:10] so you don't have to wait however long our meetings are. [0:01:14] So if there's anyone in the audience this evening [0:01:17] that would like to come forward and address the council, [0:01:20] this is your time to do so. [0:01:25] And like usual, there's not a mad dash to come to the front. [0:01:28] So the first step, oh, do we have, oh, Kevin, [0:01:31] I didn't see your arm. [0:01:33] That's definitely somebody. [0:01:34] Oh, Chris, Kevin Dane, welcome. [0:01:38] All right, good evening, Mayor, City Council and residents. [0:01:43] This is a reference to the jump surprise, okay. [0:01:45] Kevin, okay. [0:01:46] May I say something we're going to give an opportunity for that item for public input on that item later when it is [0:01:54] Yes, so sorry, no sweat [0:02:02] You actually made my day because you came up [0:02:05] You're the first [0:02:08] So I see no one coming forward, so we're going to move on to the consent calendar and turn that over to council wishes [0:02:13] Second. [0:02:17] We have a motion on the floor to move approval of the consent calendar as written by Jim Mon [0:02:24] seconded by Suzanne Hopkins. [0:02:26] Do we have anything further on that motion council? [0:02:30] Chris talking to. [0:02:31] I'm just wondering the minutes are not included, it's only accounts payable as late as I started [0:02:37] a new procedure with that or is she just kind of bad quality of the minutes from the previous [0:02:42] meeting. [0:02:43] that she's actively working on those and I think that what you'll see is a whole [0:02:47] collection of meeting minutes that will come forward. Our process is that after [0:02:51] she has them in draft form she will submit them to me for my review because [0:02:58] I was out of the office part of last week that process didn't happen. Anything [0:03:05] further on that motion council? Sharon roll call vote please. Suzanne Hawkins. [0:03:09] Yes, Jim Mann. Yes, Sean Berger. Yes, Chris Tockington, Greg Lanting. Yes, Don Hall. Yes, Rebecca [0:03:20] Mills, like that. Yes, Washington passes seven to zero. We're moving on to the items for consideration. [0:03:26] And the first item on the agenda is presentation of the Twin Falls School District Bond levy [0:03:31] election 2014. And I show that our superintendent, Wiley Dobbs. Welcome, Wiley. Thank you, Mayor [0:03:38] Hall, members of the City Council, we appreciate the time this evening. We're going to be brief, [0:03:43] the purpose this evening is to provide our City Council members and of course members of [0:03:47] the audience as well with information about the upcoming Twin Falls School District bond [0:03:52] led the election. We'd stand for any questions you may have regarding that as well. And we're [0:03:58] also hoping for an endorsement by the City Council. Our city and our school district has [0:04:03] worked well together over the years and I know that that has resulted in great things economically. [0:04:10] Our economic development has been outstanding and so we feel like this kind of fits together [0:04:15] in the puzzle toward the promotion of that economic development. [0:04:20] So I'll just dive right in. [0:04:22] Please do feel free to stop me at any point and ask any questions along the way as well. [0:04:28] We began the planning process for the school bond levy election well over a year ago. [0:04:35] We put together a long-range facilities planning committee made up the members that are listed [0:04:39] on board over here to the left were community members that were involved and to the right [0:04:45] to involve school district members that were involved. [0:04:48] We spent eight meetings. [0:04:51] Each of the meetings lasted anywhere from three and a half to four hours. [0:04:55] So we spent well over 30 hours of time. [0:04:57] We looked at the things that are listed on the board over here. [0:05:00] We took a look at the facilities. [0:05:01] We have 13 schools in the Twin Falls School District. [0:05:05] We talked about their condition. [0:05:07] Many of the schools are quite old, but they're well cared for, and we've used our buildings [0:05:11] for long periods of time, I'm sure much to our taxpayers delight. [0:05:16] We looked a great deal at growth. [0:05:19] Last year when the city was working with the wastewater development, we saw those growth [0:05:27] charts and they matched up well with what we had in terms of our school districts growth. [0:05:33] We looked not only at the city population growth and growth but we looked at our Twin [0:05:38] Falls school district enrollment growth that we've experienced over the last few years. [0:05:45] The task of the committee was to present a recommendation to the school board and they [0:05:51] did back in July 25th. [0:05:55] The board really considered this for two and a half months and took a long look at this. [0:06:03] The cost of the bond levy will be $73.8 million over 25 years and would include two new elementary [0:06:10] schools of capacity of 650 students each, a new middle school of capacity of a thousand [0:06:16] students, a continued renovation of Twin Falls High School including air conditioning, fire [0:06:22] protection, roof repair, and new windows, Canyon Ridge High School Phase 2, which would include [0:06:28] a 480 student expansion to that school, and then improved safety measures at all schools. [0:06:36] As I mentioned, there's no secret Twin Falls has been kind of paved as an area where businesses [0:06:43] want to come, and a big part of that has been the educational system that we have in the [0:06:48] Twin Falls School District and with CSI. [0:06:51] It's been a formidable combination of those two. [0:06:55] Also, one of the things I found in working with a lot [0:06:59] of superintendents across the state, [0:07:01] Twin Falls School District enjoys a very good relationship [0:07:04] with the city. [0:07:05] That's not always the case in the places that I talk to, [0:07:08] or people I talk to in the places I visit. [0:07:12] We've heard this Twin Falls Secret Sauce. [0:07:15] We know that just in the last year, [0:07:17] We've attracted 1,200 new jobs to the Magic Valley area and $750 million in capital investment. [0:07:25] We know about the big ones. [0:07:26] They've been highly publicized. [0:07:28] Chibani, Glandbia, Fruitlack over in Rupert, Cliff Bar, but there have been many other smaller [0:07:34] businesses that have also located here. [0:07:36] Again, thanks to the great economic development that has taken place here in Twin Falls. [0:07:43] Our school district growth rate, over the past decade, we've grown every year. [0:07:47] every year of the last 10 we've grown, [0:07:50] anywhere from a percent and a half to 4%. [0:07:52] The last two years in a row has been 4% growth, [0:07:55] actually a little more than 4% growth, [0:07:58] both of the last two years. [0:08:00] This trend is expected to continue, [0:08:03] resulting approximately 3,000 additional students [0:08:06] by the year 2020. [0:08:08] So they're coming. [0:08:10] I'm sorry this doesn't show up as well as I'd hoped, [0:08:12] but in just the last two years, from 2011 to 2013, [0:08:19] we've increased our population. [0:08:21] I mentioned 4% growth each year. [0:08:24] That 4% equates to about 360 students. [0:08:28] So we've grown 721 students in just the last two years. [0:08:32] And I might point out that these numbers [0:08:33] were taken the fourth Friday in September. [0:08:36] We do that every year just so we can continue [0:08:39] to compare each year. [0:08:41] Since this number was taken, 8633 back in September, [0:08:47] we've grown by 50 more students. [0:08:49] So they didn't quit coming [0:08:50] because it was the fourth Friday in September. [0:08:53] They are, and we continue to grow. [0:08:57] The goal of the committee, [0:08:59] the long-range facility planning committee, [0:09:01] was to keep up rather than catch up. [0:09:03] And I've been asked by many, [0:09:05] what would catch up look like? [0:09:07] And I responded this way, [0:09:09] catch up might look like putting modular units down [0:09:12] making our schools bigger. Although I have to tell you that a four classroom [0:09:18] modular unit costs $300,000 to purchase and to put down. It is also about five [0:09:25] times less efficient than classrooms that are attached to a building. So that might [0:09:31] be what it looks like, but to be honest with you, I don't know where we'd get the [0:09:33] funding to put those classroom modular units down anyway. I guess I would also [0:09:40] also said, some people asked me what's Plan B. We've had all hands on deck for Plan A. We [0:09:47] haven't spent much time with Plan B. We know the sun will come up on March 12, the day after [0:09:52] the election. And if a Plan B is required, we'll go to work on that. But right now Plan A is [0:09:57] taking up all of our time. Just a quick review of each of the elements within the bond levy [0:10:04] election, two new elementary schools, 650 student capacity in each. [0:10:10] Each of our elementary schools are at or over capacity right now, and one of the, we would [0:10:15] have enough enrollment to fill up one of the elementary schools the day after it opens. [0:10:21] We'd have some more room to fill in the other one as well and create some capacity in our [0:10:25] other elementary schools that we have as a result, but the students are coming and this [0:10:33] allows us to keep ahead of that. [0:10:37] New middle school, when we passed the last bond [0:10:40] levy back in 2006, we kind of created a bottleneck [0:10:44] at our middle school level. [0:10:45] We moved the sixth graders up to middle school, [0:10:47] ninth graders up to high school. [0:10:49] We still have three grade levels at Robert Stewart and O'Leary. [0:10:53] We also have a full house at our Bridge Academy, [0:10:55] the alternative middle school. [0:10:57] So both of our middle schools will be over capacity [0:11:01] if you're getting next fall, they're at capacity now. [0:11:06] Continuing renovation of Twin Falls High School, [0:11:07] we've done a lot of work at Twin Falls High School. [0:11:10] Most obvious lately has been the entrance area. [0:11:13] We've also been working on the C-wing, C-Haul, I should say. [0:11:19] These were the things that were planned back in 2006 [0:11:22] to a tune of $6.5 million. [0:11:26] We didn't complete all of those. [0:11:28] In fact, we changed our mind on a couple. [0:11:30] The 9th grade wing, we were going to turn B wing or B hall. [0:11:34] If you're familiar with Twin Falls High School into a 9th grade area and a shelter the 9th [0:11:38] graders. [0:11:39] We moved the 9th graders up to Canyon Ridge into Twin Falls High School and lo and behold [0:11:44] they did just fine. [0:11:45] So that was an avoided cost. [0:11:47] The cafeteria we were talking about knocking out five or six classrooms to expand the cafeteria [0:11:53] and we just haven't felt like that was the right approach to knock out the classrooms. [0:11:58] We can't afford to lose those classrooms, so we're looking at a different idea. [0:12:03] But we have done the things that are on the right over here, and when B and Q wings are [0:12:08] finished, we will have spent $7 million. [0:12:11] So the amount of money that was proposed back in 2006 has been spent, and then some. [0:12:17] 2014 bond levy election, you can see those are the price tags for the things that are [0:12:22] planned if the bond levy passes. [0:12:25] The roof and the windows will have a payback as far as efficiency and cost of utilities, [0:12:31] but the amount in the bond levy is 7.5 million. [0:12:35] If the bond levy passes, the money spent on Twin Falls High School since 2006 would be [0:12:40] enough to build a new elementary school. [0:12:42] So a lot of tender, loving care has been paid and will continue to be paid to Twin Falls [0:12:46] High School. [0:12:47] So people have mentioned you just opened Can-E-Ridge. [0:12:51] Why are we adding on to it? [0:12:53] It is part of the plan, back seven years ago, when we created the idea for Canyon Ridge, we [0:13:00] knew that we would reach capacity by about this time, and that an addition would need [0:13:05] to be added on. [0:13:07] We also know that the building was built to be added on to. [0:13:11] It has a core that's much more than the 1200 capacity that it has now. [0:13:16] The 480 student building will bring Canyon Ridge up to the same capacity as Twin Falls High [0:13:22] So both schools will be the same, be allowed to grow at the same rate. [0:13:27] Both schools have about the same amount of enrollment now, will be able to continue to [0:13:31] do that and stay in the same activity classifications. [0:13:41] And then safety measures, we've built into the budget about $100,000 per school. [0:13:47] Within the committee, we talked about camera equipment, special locks. [0:13:51] And I think the main focus that we'll continue to have will be on the four categories that [0:13:56] are listed up here. [0:13:58] I would just mention that Sandy Hook Elementary School, that tragedy happened a little over [0:14:03] a year ago. [0:14:05] That school had a million dollars more in equipment, safety equipment than we have in any one of [0:14:12] our schools and it didn't work. [0:14:14] The things that are working for us are strong relationships with our school resource officers. [0:14:20] We feel like our school administrators, our teachers feel relationships with the kids. [0:14:25] They come and report things to us before they happen so we can get ahead of those things. [0:14:30] And those are the things that we've really emphasized, preparedness, plans and so forth [0:14:36] and partnerships like I said we have with the police department and so forth those have [0:14:40] paid dividends. [0:14:41] We've been asked about the location of the schools. [0:14:46] We have had a committee that worked on that and has presented a recommendation. [0:14:50] If you were to divide our school district up into three triangles, if you will, of course [0:14:56] Canyon Ridge is up at the top in the north, Oregon Trails down in the south, O'Leary's [0:15:02] over in the east and Robert Stewart's in the west. [0:15:07] The recommendation has been to put one of the elementary schools in the east, one of the middle [0:15:12] school in the south and the other elementary school in the northwest. I would say that we [0:15:22] have property, we own property, the school district owns property at each of those triangles. [0:15:29] We have talked about whether those would be safe enough, for instance, we own some property [0:15:35] across the street from the Boy Scouts office. I'm not sure we want kids pretty sure we [0:15:41] We don't want kids crossing Hankins to go to school, so we also have the ability to sell [0:15:46] or trade property for better locations. [0:15:49] Utility hookup, the expense of that is also something we're considering. [0:15:53] But we do own property in each of those three triangles. [0:15:58] Taxes everybody always wants to know about taxes, and we're very mindful of that. [0:16:03] The amount of the tax increase is minimal when you consider the things that we're getting [0:16:09] for it. We're able to layer in some of this over the capacity we have. I also want to mention [0:16:16] something about Jibani just to give you an idea of how the economic growth has really [0:16:20] helped us with this. The amount we've estimated will be $0.66 per $1,000 of taxable value. [0:16:29] So when you eliminate your homeowner's exemption, if you have $150,000 home, the cost to you [0:16:36] would be about $4.13 per month or less than $50 per year. If not for Chobani, just to [0:16:45] give you an example, I'm spreading that tax base out, it would cost over $1 per 1,000. [0:16:53] So Chobani has really made an impact there. [0:16:55] Why? [0:16:56] Well, Wiley and also Greg always tutors me on this. Because of Chobani, are we paying [0:17:01] bonds off early as well? [0:17:03] We will. [0:17:04] And not only that, this is very conservative. [0:17:07] This is not taken into consideration anything new [0:17:10] that might be added on. [0:17:11] And as far as I've heard Cliff Barr's not the last company [0:17:16] that's looking at our community. [0:17:18] So it's quite likely that would actually be lessened, [0:17:23] and would be lessened if we continue [0:17:25] to have the development development we've had. [0:17:28] So with that, just to point out that the election is March 11, [0:17:31] 2014. It does require a two-thirds majority to pass a super majority. And so we're encouraging [0:17:38] people to become informed. You're well-informed. You probably were before I came here. We encouraged [0:17:45] people to be registered, people to vote. And I'd stand for your questions you have. [0:17:50] Thank you, Mr. Dodd. So I'll open up the questions. Suzanne Hopkins. [0:17:54] I'm just curious. What is the capacity of Robert Stewart and O'Leary now? [0:18:00] I think we've got a 975, and Robert Stewart's 900. [0:18:05] So the new middle school would be just staying in the same ballpark? [0:18:09] Same ballpark. [0:18:10] Okay. [0:18:11] And we talked about within the committee, we talked about making mega middle schools, [0:18:14] adding on to the ones we have, or mega elementary schools. [0:18:17] And educationally, that's not very sound. [0:18:19] There's a lot of kids through the cracks. [0:18:21] When you make enormous schools, and that was, we quickly dismissed that within our group. [0:18:27] Right. [0:18:28] You said Bridge Academy is full. [0:18:30] Will any of this help alleviate some of that, [0:18:32] or is that just a whole different project by itself? [0:18:37] It is a whole different project by itself, [0:18:39] but we're always hopeful not to have to have students [0:18:44] go to an alternative school, but we do, [0:18:46] and it serves a great number, well over 100 [0:18:49] of our students are serviced, and not just in our school [0:18:53] district, we have students from other school districts [0:18:55] that are held at Bridge Academy, and also very much [0:18:58] If we were to add to that school, we would have to put down more buildings. [0:19:03] Okay, thank you. [0:19:04] Rebecca Milsock. [0:19:06] Thank you Mayor, thank you Mr. Dobbs. [0:19:08] Just a question about the past, the last one that was passed in 2006, as I said. [0:19:15] I remember that being for maintenance and kind of keep up keep and [0:19:21] to keep up with the budgets as the state budgets were cut. [0:19:23] but you have projects here that were more improvements. [0:19:28] So was it used for maintenance or is it used for remodels? [0:19:33] The bond election in 2006 was for buildings [0:19:38] and for some larger remodel type projects. [0:19:42] We had another, there were a lot of elections and levies, [0:19:47] this is kind of an education finance 101, [0:19:52] but in 2008 we passed the plant facilities levy. [0:19:57] That's for 10 years and that provides the district [0:19:59] with $3.3 million each year for maintenance projects. [0:20:05] So some of the maintenance projects we've done over the last several years [0:20:09] have been out of that fund. [0:20:10] Okay, so that was a separate. [0:20:11] Right, and then the last four years, each of the two years, [0:20:16] leading up to this year, we've passed two supplemental levies. [0:20:20] That's for operations, to help pay for teachers. [0:20:24] And what were those amounts? [0:20:27] The amount of the last supplemental levy is $9 million over two years. [0:20:34] So it was $4.5 million over two years. [0:20:38] Or each of the two years. [0:20:41] Okay. [0:20:42] And you mentioned that the Canyon Ridge growth at this time was part of the plan. [0:20:47] What was the original amount of Canyon Ridge, the Canyon Ridge Bond or Levy and is that still [0:20:54] in place? [0:20:55] Is that still being paid back? [0:20:56] The original amount of the Bond Levy in 2006 was 49.7 million and it is being paid back. [0:21:04] Although we've paid it back to a point where we can layer some of this in to reduce the [0:21:09] amount per year that a person would have to pay. [0:21:12] Thank you. [0:21:13] Thank you. [0:21:14] Chris talking to. [0:21:15] Dr. Dobbs, it was quite a few years ago, [0:21:17] the city took the initiative, cooperate with the school [0:21:20] district to put some of the first school resource [0:21:23] officers in bed to amend the schools of, I think, [0:21:26] in Idaho, I'm not sure. [0:21:29] And I know the council feels very strongly [0:21:32] that public safety is paramount importance. [0:21:36] When your bond issue passes, what [0:21:39] would be the implications so far as the city's [0:21:41] commitment for additional SROs for the three additional schools and do you [0:21:46] see any additional safety measures we should be helping you with on your studies [0:21:53] of schools safety? Very good question and of course we if the bond levy passes we'd [0:21:57] go from seven elementary schools to nine and the nine elementary schools would [0:22:02] feed three middle schools probably three elementary schools would feed one [0:22:08] middle school, the other three second middle school, and the third three, if you will, would [0:22:14] feed the third middle school. We'll need to talk. Of course, we would not be opening these [0:22:21] elementary schools until 2016, would not be opening the middle school until 2017. That's [0:22:27] how long it takes to plan and build these buildings. But in the meantime, we would have [0:22:31] to have discussion with the city council. I would see the need for at least one more resource [0:22:36] officer at the middle school and then we would look at how that serves the [0:22:42] elementary schools. And you are right, Jean. [0:22:47] No, it wasn't Jean, it was Richie. I believe was the first SRO in the state. [0:22:54] He was right here in Twin Falls. And I can't tell you just how much we've [0:23:00] appreciated the work of our school resource officers and I believe they've [0:23:05] You know, it's anecdotal data because you never know how many things they stop, but there [0:23:13] really is quite a few instances on record where they've done some good police work ahead [0:23:19] of time and have curtailed something from happening. [0:23:22] So that has been an outstanding relationship and we would have to grow that program and [0:23:28] discussions would probably begin as immediately as March 12th. [0:23:33] to give us 12 top we'll talk 13. Good question. Here here on the school resource [0:23:39] officer since I used to be one. Yes, you were an outstanding one too. Oh, thank you very much. [0:23:43] Greg Lanney. Well, Dr. Dobbs, I have our time calling today because we went to [0:23:50] the master's program together so more like why I lead to meeting a bit more [0:23:54] company. First I want to let you know that I'm full supportive of your endeavors. [0:24:01] You've kept me informed other people. Brad Wells has kept me informed about some of the different things that were going on. [0:24:08] I want to give the school district kudos. I wasn't ever in this school district. I was in a neighboring school district. [0:24:15] But I had dinner on Saturday night with a couple that have three children in your school system. [0:24:21] They've been all over the schools in the Texas area. [0:24:24] When they first got here, they watched that commercial that says we're 49th in the nation. [0:24:29] nation and they were just scared to death because they just came from what they [0:24:32] considered a really bad school and they had nothing but compliments they said it's [0:24:36] the best schools their kids have ever been in and they've been in districts all [0:24:39] over Texas and supposedly you know Texas with all the kudos that they've been [0:24:45] getting and they said there's no comparison especially the teachers and [0:24:49] the quality of teachers the to and fall school is best I wanted to pass that [0:24:52] who does a lot. [0:24:53] Thank you, Greg. [0:24:54] Appreciate that. [0:24:55] I'll pass that on to our folks in the district too. [0:24:58] Thank you. [0:24:59] Council, I see no further lights, but I know that Dr. Dobbs mentioned maybe some sort of endorsement. [0:25:06] Chris talking. [0:25:07] Well, the economic development of the city is currently witnessing goes hand in hand with [0:25:13] the growth of students, workers coming into this area. [0:25:17] And I don't think that there's a stronger bond between cause and effect of our growth and the impact on the schools. [0:25:26] I'd be very supportive of an endorsement by the council and would so move urging all registered voters to vote on March 11th and to vote a strong yes. [0:25:39] Thank you. [0:25:40] We have a motion on the floor by Chris Tonkin, surprisingly enough, seconded by Greg Lanning. [0:25:46] Rebecca Milsuchka. [0:25:47] This is a question for, I guess our legal counsel. [0:25:51] This item was listed as presentation. [0:25:53] Are we able to take action on it tonight? [0:25:56] It's just an endorsement. [0:25:59] It has no legal implications. [0:26:01] So it's my not. [0:26:02] Okay. [0:26:03] Good question. [0:26:04] Thank you. [0:26:05] But I also would comment on the motion. [0:26:07] You know, I really think this is, you know, it's a personal decision for each taxpayer to [0:26:11] to decide. So I personally wouldn't be comfortable, you know, encouraging them one way or the other. [0:26:16] I would encourage people to vote definitely. And you know, I think with the wastewater bond [0:26:22] that was recently passed, you know, citizens have really taken a lot upon themselves. Obviously, [0:26:27] all of the past bonds and levies that were passed, you know, I think it's something like [0:26:33] 85% of our citizens in Twin Falls are within poverty range or low income. And so I think [0:26:40] It's something that taxes are daily burden, they're yearly burden, and it's up to people [0:26:46] to decide where their priorities lie and what they can afford. [0:26:51] So I wouldn't encourage everyone to vote, though. [0:26:54] Thank you, Rebecca. [0:26:55] Greg Lanny. [0:26:56] Well, I'd like to put another perspective on that. [0:27:00] Our efforts are obviously to bring that poverty level job rate up. [0:27:06] And everybody that we recruit from Chibana to Cliff Bar to other smaller things is we're [0:27:11] We're always looking at jobs that pay considerably better than the pottery level. [0:27:15] We have a cut off of the $14 level or somewhere in that area that we don't recruit jobs unless they pay that much. [0:27:23] And every, I've been very involved in the last two years as mayor with these class two companies as well as with Vice Mayor. [0:27:30] And education is critical to our being able to bring jobs to our community. [0:27:37] Good paying jobs for our community, and it's not only CSI, it's to a full school district, and even our surrounding school district, I will be enthusiastically voting yes to for us to endorse this school bond. [0:27:50] Thank you Greg. [0:27:51] Sean Berter. [0:27:52] Yeah, Wylie, I do want to thank you for your presentation. [0:27:54] I commend the district on the prudent stewardship you've had over the years with the facilities, many of which are how old's vehicle now. [0:28:02] It's going to be pushing 100 years plus, huh? [0:28:04] Well, we can say that the original part of the buildings no longer there burned down in 1933. [0:28:13] But most of the buildings since that's still there was built in about 1935. [0:28:19] So certainly a good use of resources and schools are part of what I kind of refer to as that community infrastructure. [0:28:27] So they're not the sewer lines and water lines. [0:28:30] They're the stuff that Greg just talked about with friends of his who've come here and have kids. [0:28:36] I have kids in the Twin Falls School District and I appreciate what they're able to do for those of us who live here. [0:28:41] Those who are coming here and those who are still to come. [0:28:44] So you definitely have my support and I think that the goals of the school district fit nicely in with the strategic plan of the city [0:28:54] to have a learning community and those opportunities again for those of us who live here and those who are coming. [0:28:59] So I wish you all the best on it. [0:29:02] I'll find out how much the buy-in to the pool is [0:29:05] and see if I win this one. [0:29:06] Yeah. [0:29:07] I'll have to make that. [0:29:09] You know, I just wanted to add Dr. Goss, [0:29:11] thank you for the presentation. [0:29:13] It wasn't very many years ago, actually, [0:29:15] when we first came on council, [0:29:16] that you actually put a committee together [0:29:18] to start looking at potentially closing the school. [0:29:21] And that just shows me that you're flexible, [0:29:23] you understand, you watch the trends, [0:29:25] you try to react and be frugal with our money. [0:29:29] And obviously, since then, we've had an influx of folks. [0:29:33] So I'm going to be in support of this [0:29:36] because of how frugal and a stewardship [0:29:40] that you do have with our children [0:29:42] have had one graduate and two in the school district right now. [0:29:46] And with the economic development as stated before, [0:29:51] we have to have good schools, so I appreciate that. [0:29:54] Councilor C. Nohfler. [0:29:55] I'll say something. [0:29:57] I want to comment on this SRO thing. [0:29:59] First of all, we need the best SRR, no, Dr. Dobbs, I absolutely support this, you know, I like [0:30:05] Sean believe that our school systems are part of the social capital that really help us grow, [0:30:12] and I believe like Greg indicated that to bring better jobs we have to have better educated [0:30:17] people and I just think this is a great investment in our community and southern Idaho, so I will [0:30:23] definitely with enthusiasm support, this endorsement. [0:30:26] Sharon, roll call vote please. [0:30:34] Yes [0:30:37] Sean Berger yes Chris Hockington yes Greg Lanting yes Don Hall yes [0:30:45] Rebecca Melsoica no and Suzanne Hawkins yes [0:30:51] Motion passes six to one and again. Thank you for your presentation and your fine work [0:30:55] We will be moving on to the next item on the agenda with a [0:31:00] presentation on the finances of the City of Twin Falls for the first quarter of fiscal year 2013 [0:31:06] 14 and our own Lori race welcome Lori [0:31:11] Mr. Mayor we're going to be doing a switch out of computers real quick, so you might be 30 seconds [0:31:17] So do you want to entertain us while we're? [0:31:22] No, but I I believe that we might have some in the audience [0:31:25] I don't think we're buying that one. [0:31:35] Ladies and gentlemen, while we are waiting, I know that you might want to make comments [0:32:02] on one of the items later on. [0:32:04] There is a sign up sheet, wow, I must mess that up. [0:32:09] In the back of the room, please, if you put your name on there and which agenda item you [0:32:12] you would like to visit with Council about tonight, [0:32:15] that would be greatly appreciated. [0:32:55] Greg Lanning. [0:32:56] While we're having some technical issues, [0:32:57] I'll bring up one that I was gonna talk about [0:33:00] at the end of the night. [0:33:01] Right before the Council meeting, [0:33:02] I got off a conference call with the AIC. [0:33:06] I'm on the Board of Directors as is Suzanne [0:33:10] of the Association of IITO Cities [0:33:12] and being first Vice President of that group. [0:33:17] I am on what's called the Executive Board [0:33:18] We were having a conference call with the mayor of Caldwell and the legal council if you have [0:33:24] been following it the mayor of the Caldwell and the Pioneer Gayson District have been fighting [0:33:31] for several million dollars on each side ago. [0:33:35] A lawyer's fees over use of the canal system for part of their wastewater drainage which [0:33:42] we are not wastewater, excuse me, are storm water drainage and we of course will be coming [0:33:47] under that provision early. City Caldwell had initiated because they just could not come to [0:33:53] agreement. They went into combination hearing to take over the irrigation district. Actually, [0:33:58] the maintenance of the canals, the speaker of the house is very concerned about that as a lot of [0:34:04] legislature. So the AIC has proposed some compromise legislation that would hopefully not only solve [0:34:12] of that issue but also preserve some of our eminent domain capabilities as a city because [0:34:19] the legislation was definitely threatening that. And so let you know that you should [0:34:23] in the next couple of days you should get some compromised legislation from the AIC that [0:34:28] will hopefully solve the call will issue as well as maintain some of our eminent domain [0:34:35] rights. And it's just a brewing thing up there and it's kind of putting the irrigators [0:34:41] versus the cities and nobody really wants to do it. We have a really good [0:34:44] degree. By the cooperation with our canal company and so I would hate to see [0:34:51] something like this cause a riff for us when it's only those two that are [0:34:58] fighting over it. And like I said each side is well over two million dollars [0:35:02] in attorney's fees to this point. Both the irrigation district the [0:35:05] irrigation district actually had to double their rates this year for their [0:35:11] farmers just to pay their legal fees. So hopefully we can stay out of those [0:35:16] kinds of things. Thank you Greg. I didn't talk long enough I tried. I stumbled quite [0:35:24] a while today. Mr. Mayor members of the Council if I might suggest while they're [0:35:50] working on that maybe we could move to item number three which is Chief Pike's [0:35:55] conversation about IELTS to ensure that the meeting continues to move forward [0:35:59] And I, as can continue to work on the computer to see how it makes sure it gets going and [0:36:05] we'll put Lori into back into the on deck. [0:36:08] We're okay after that. [0:36:09] Actually I was going to make that same suggestion so thank you if, do you need any technical assistance, Chief? [0:36:17] All right, we were going to move to number three on our items for consideration. [0:36:21] And it's a presentation for proposed eyelets fee increases that will reflect in the Twin Falls Police Departments [0:36:29] 2014, 2015 fiscal year budget, and we have our chief police, Brian Pike. [0:36:35] Welcome. [0:36:36] Thank you, Mayor, members of the Council. [0:36:37] I was kind of looking forward to following the financial presentation. [0:36:40] But you'll still be sharp. [0:36:46] This is really just kind of a little informational piece, and that is give you a little history. [0:36:51] First off, what is Islets? [0:36:52] Because, you know, we're a little Akron and having in law enforcement, but it really [0:36:56] really stands for the Idaho Public Safety and Security Information System. [0:37:00] And as I probably included in your packet, I gave a brief history. [0:37:04] This is really a dedicated, secure, reliable, high-speed communication system that enables [0:37:09] law enforcement and criminal justice agencies like the jail to fulfill their mission. [0:37:17] So what it does is it allows every time an officer makes a stop, he stops or comes into [0:37:22] contact with the citizen. [0:37:24] They access this network to get driver's information, vehicle information, criminal history information [0:37:28] back from the national reporting agencies. [0:37:31] It's kind of like our lifeline when our officers are out working in the community. [0:37:36] So it's extremely important to give you a little background on how we got to a point [0:37:40] where we see this increase, which is if you're looking at what was probably in your packet [0:37:44] is a pretty substantial increase as compared to last year. [0:37:49] The IELTS Board has worked with the governor's office and members of AIC to try to find a dedicated [0:37:56] funding source for the IELTS program. [0:37:59] Over the years, basically IELTS has been put together by the state's budget. [0:38:03] They represent the lion's share of the budget and probably about 20 percent of the overall [0:38:07] use of IELTS itself. [0:38:10] But they've carried the burden and they've used grants to kind of piece mill the system [0:38:14] together. [0:38:15] Well, several years ago, what we started to experience is that [0:38:19] the IELTS system would occasionally go down. [0:38:21] And there's no redundancy built into the system. [0:38:23] So when the IELTS system is offline, our officers don't have [0:38:27] that information. [0:38:29] And in this job, if you're dealing with somebody on the [0:38:32] street, that information is critical, whether they have a [0:38:34] warrant, whether there's some kind of caution code with that [0:38:38] individual that you're dealing with. [0:38:39] So the Idaho Chiefs Association and Idaho Sheriffs [0:38:42] Association got together. [0:38:43] They tried to work with a number of legislators [0:38:45] on trying to get a dedicated funding source. [0:38:48] So I came in a little bit late into the game, [0:38:50] but several years ago, they were trying to address [0:38:54] this issue with title fees. [0:38:55] So when a person got a title to a vehicle, [0:38:57] they wanted to assess an extra amount of money [0:39:00] to help cover the expense. [0:39:02] And we were never able to really get that off the ground [0:39:04] and get support of the legislature to make that happen. [0:39:07] So we reached a point, it was actually funny, [0:39:10] I sit on the IELTS board, my first meeting on the IELTS board, [0:39:13] It's an emergency meeting to discuss this historic fee increase. [0:39:18] And the sad part about it is I think that the chief's association [0:39:23] and the sheriff's association recognized that we really need this. [0:39:28] And we need to have redundancy in the system so that it doesn't fail. [0:39:32] We did try to find a way to mitigate the cost to communities, [0:39:36] local communities, but we just weren't able to do that. [0:39:39] It doesn't mean that we won't continue to pursue that. [0:39:41] But at some point we had to kind of draw a line in the sand and simply say, [0:39:44] okay, we have to ensure that the system will be operational. [0:39:49] So last year the governor's office agreed that they, [0:39:52] there's roughly about a $1.4 million shortfall in getting the system up and [0:39:57] having a redundant system. [0:39:58] And the governor's office was willing to meet us halfway. [0:40:01] They'd pay for $700,000 in this budget if the agencies that utilized the system [0:40:08] would cover the additional $700,000. [0:40:11] So the Islet's Board, working with both associations, [0:40:14] came up with a fee structure that I believe [0:40:16] is attached to your packet. [0:40:17] And what you'll notice is that for last year, [0:40:20] and these are going off to 2012 numbers, [0:40:23] and Islets will make that adjustment. [0:40:24] The City of Twin Falls Police Department, [0:40:26] we used roughly 1.7% of the Islets' network. [0:40:31] And we have to pay for a connection fee, which is $5,000, [0:40:34] and then we pay for a usage fee. [0:40:36] So every time we run information through the system, [0:40:39] we get like sending a text, right? [0:40:42] Every time you send a text, there's a charge for that. [0:40:44] And I only say that I don't want to discourage that [0:40:47] because the last thing I want to do is give you the impression [0:40:49] that we could cut back on the numbers of contacts [0:40:53] that were having the information that were running [0:40:54] because I'm not saying that. [0:40:56] I think what we run, we need to run. [0:40:58] It's very important to public safety. [0:41:00] And we paid $11,250 in usage fees for a total of $16,500. [0:41:06] With the new fee increase, our connection fee will be the same, $5,000. [0:41:12] However, our usage fee will go up drastically. [0:41:14] We'll go from $11,250 to $33,750 for total cost of $38,750. [0:41:25] So a little over, well, 120%, 125% increase. [0:41:30] So we're going to budget for that in our next budget year. [0:41:34] And then my promise is that as a member of the Eyelits Board, [0:41:37] we will continue to find ways of looking for dedicated funding [0:41:42] so that maybe this can be reduced. [0:41:45] The other thing we talked about is because we waited so long [0:41:48] as a association, you know, the idea was always find a dedicated [0:41:52] funding source so that we didn't have to push this [0:41:55] out to the local communities. [0:41:56] And the reality was we couldn't get the dedicated funding source [0:42:01] and the longer that we waited, the more of the increase. [0:42:04] So we'll either commit to a dedicated funding source, or we'll probably make adjustments on an annual basis so that we don't have one year where we have these incredible increases. [0:42:14] Chris, talk. [0:42:16] So Chief, I'm trying to do the math. [0:42:19] The difference between this current year and next year is either 22 and a half or 27 and a half thousand dollars increase. [0:42:27] I did not break that out, so we paid $16,500 last year with paying $38,750 in our next budget year. [0:42:35] 22 and a half. [0:42:37] Okay. [0:42:39] Rebecca Milsocka. [0:42:40] Thank you. [0:42:41] We are. [0:42:42] Thank you Chief for your presentation. [0:42:44] Is there a possibility for any sort of cost recovery through a fee? [0:42:49] I know that when you issue a ticket, there's a series of fees that the user has to pay. [0:42:55] And I understand that every stop or every use of the system wouldn't always result in a ticket. [0:43:01] But is that a potential for cost recovery? [0:43:04] It's a potential. [0:43:05] We would have to have legislative support in making that happen and it's a very difficult [0:43:11] conversation because very similar to your concerns over the overall tax rate, just about every [0:43:16] time we approach the legislature on adding a fee either to a title or to the ticket. [0:43:21] They're very sensitive to that and pushing that cost onto the individual has to pay it. [0:43:25] So in a lot of cases, we've really run into just a brick wall on that issue. [0:43:30] But I think it's something that we'll consider. [0:43:34] Yeah, I think in this case it's a little bit unique in that it really is a user fee. [0:43:39] I mean, we all in a sense are users of that system because either I want to be safer because [0:43:46] you're able to access that system and arrest someone who has a warrant out in another county or state or so on. [0:43:52] Or I deserved a ticket and I deserved a pay because you had to background check me essentially. [0:43:58] So I was thinking that maybe that would be an option. [0:44:02] I think both associations as they move forward will be looking for legislative partners to find a dedicated funding source. [0:44:11] Because this is only, obviously we know that test technology increases the cost of this service. [0:44:16] It's probably not going to go down. [0:44:19] Well, I'll defer to my two cop friends on the council, but if I will say it looks to me [0:44:24] like Eilis is absolutely indispensable in a world of interstate crime where the mobility [0:44:30] of the bad guys makes it impossible to get a handle on and unless you use the highest technology [0:44:39] which this represents. [0:44:40] As a councilman, I completely agree without a system like Eilis, our men and women are [0:44:45] working in the dark. [0:44:46] They're dealing with people that have no idea who they are, where they're from, and who knows [0:44:51] what kind of criminal history they may have. [0:44:53] Jim, huh? [0:44:54] Well, yeah, just to briefly give you a scenario that's happened to you and me, when you walk [0:45:01] up on a car at night, you want to have a little bit of information under your belt when you're [0:45:06] walking up to that dark car at night. [0:45:09] And so, you know, this is an insurance investment, really, in the safety of the men and women [0:45:14] of our department. So you know Rebecca it's the first time I've heard a user fee when it came to [0:45:21] tickets and stuff so I just it just kind of it was humorous to me a little bit. I do have a I don't [0:45:28] disagree with it and I'm not making fun of you. It's still esophically sound. It does I love user fees [0:45:34] okay but this is a little different. Chief so if this does take place what will the burden what will [0:45:40] will happen to the state because it sounds like this state only uses about twenty percent [0:45:44] of the highlights and they're paying about fifty percent of it right now so will their [0:45:51] fees go down which i think it should because it should be more user-based really i think [0:45:57] if we could if the two associations could find a dedicated funding source i think that they [0:46:01] would like to provide some relief to the state who's really carried the system for a number [0:46:06] of years i agree i agree thank you this obviously is not a [0:46:10] action item and and there's no other questions. I thank the chief for his presentation. [0:46:17] And we are back to number two on our items for consideration and back to Lori race. [0:46:34] More minutes and we'll be ready to go here. Just let the audience know we do have two public [0:46:46] hearings as well if you're here for that. We say that they will not start any earlier than six [0:46:52] And I can guarantee you that they will not start [0:46:55] any earlier than six tonight, so. [0:47:15] Good evening, Mayor and City Council. [0:47:18] So tonight, I'll be presenting a financial update [0:47:21] for the first quarter of fiscal year 2014. [0:47:25] And as I was visiting with Chris earlier, [0:47:28] I was really hoping that this would follow [0:47:30] the audit presentation. [0:47:32] When you have obsessive compulsive disorder, [0:47:34] you'd like things to go in the right order, [0:47:37] but it's not gonna work out that way. [0:47:39] So we have received a draft copy of our audit. [0:47:43] We got that on January 31st, [0:47:46] but it needs to be reviewed and finalized. [0:47:49] And after that, Scott Hunsaker will be making [0:47:52] a formal presentation to you on his findings, [0:47:55] but it probably won't be for another couple of weeks. [0:47:58] So tonight we're gonna move forward. [0:48:00] I will be sharing budget to actual information [0:48:02] for revenues and expenditures in the tax-supported funds. [0:48:07] and we'll look at how the information compares [0:48:10] with the prior three years. [0:48:12] And we'll also do the same thing [0:48:14] with the three major enterprise funds, [0:48:17] water, sewer, and sanitation. [0:48:21] So I know y'all remember the nine funds [0:48:24] that make up the tax-supported funds, [0:48:26] and you have familiarity with the percentages [0:48:29] that each represents of the total, [0:48:31] but I do wanna share that information [0:48:34] for the folks who may be watching that don't know. [0:48:37] So the tax-supported funds include the general fund, the street and the street light fund, [0:48:43] library fund, airport, capital improvement, and pool, insurance, and fireworks. [0:48:52] The total budget for the tax-supported funds this fiscal year is $32 million. [0:48:58] The largest revenue sources are property taxes representing 54% of the total, [0:49:04] at 5%, state-shared revenues at 10%, highway monies at 7%, and our Interfun Transfers at 7%. [0:49:16] The total of these five revenue sources is $26.6 million, and they make up 83% of all the revenues in the tax-supported funds. [0:49:26] Now we'll just take a look at the actual dollars for these revenue sources and how they've come in for the first three months of 2014. [0:49:38] We've received a little over $1.2 million in property taxes through December, where it's [0:49:44] 7.1% of the budget, which is ahead of our prior three-year average of 6.6%. [0:49:51] When we got our first property tax check, and it was the end of January, I called Deb [0:49:56] Kaufman and just wanted to visit with her about how she was seeing those tax collections come [0:50:02] in. [0:50:05] What Deb shared with me is that this is our highest year since she started keeping stats, [0:50:10] and that was 2001. [0:50:12] And so our collections, or their collections, 56.5% of the total collections. [0:50:21] And so that doesn't mean we'll get more property tax dollars, but it is an indication that people [0:50:26] are paying their taxes timely. [0:50:38] The franchise fees are at 27% of budget, [0:50:42] and the prior three-year average was 19.7%. [0:50:47] Power sales are driving this increase. [0:50:50] The franchise fee from Idaho Power [0:50:52] is showing an increase of almost 32%. [0:50:55] I budgeted 12 and a half. [0:50:58] Their rate adjustments differ for their different users. [0:51:02] And I tried to budget for gas and power franchise fees [0:51:06] very carefully since both are sensitive to temperature and weather conditions. [0:51:11] One thing I'd like to point out that I don't know that we've discussed before is all of [0:51:15] the power franchise fees go to the street and the street life fund. [0:51:23] State shared revenues include sales tax monies received by the state. [0:51:28] We've received $868,000 to date and that's 27% of our budget. [0:51:34] Prior three year average was 27.8%. [0:51:38] If you recall, I really under-budgeted these revenues the last two years, once because I [0:51:45] didn't take into account the increase in population and the second time because of values. [0:51:52] I wasn't aware of how our values compared statewide, but now it looks like we're on target unless [0:52:00] values change dramatically. [0:52:04] The highway user and road and bridge taxes are dedicated street funds. [0:52:08] currently at 19% collected and consistent with past collections. Now that revenue [0:52:15] source has been relatively flat for some time and at the city officials day at the [0:52:20] capital the last week in January, discussions centered around how this [0:52:25] revenue source had not increased since 1996. Different entities expressed their [0:52:33] concern regarding how difficult it was to maintain roads with increasing [0:52:39] costs and no increase to this revenue source. [0:52:43] The different legislators acknowledged that we had a problem, but they really didn't have [0:52:49] any clear direction that it would be addressed at the state level anytime soon, and there's [0:52:56] no graphic for transfers unless there's a story to be told, no story to be told. [0:53:03] So that's a look at our major revenue sources. [0:53:05] Now we'll take a look at the expenditures. [0:53:12] We have four major expenditure categories in these funds. [0:53:16] Personnel, M&O, capital, and transfers. [0:53:23] The personnel budget is 57% of the total, [0:53:26] and we're 23% spent through the first quarter [0:53:29] of our fiscal year. [0:53:31] Now, knowing that our labor distribution [0:53:33] was really reviewed and tightened up this year, [0:53:36] I really wanted to look at that number a little bit more. [0:53:39] So I went through and looked at budget to actual, [0:53:42] And they compared that with our vacant positions. [0:53:46] I had about a $5,000 leeway. [0:53:49] So that just tells me we're very tight. [0:53:54] The plus side is, we're not budgeting [0:53:57] for unnecessary salaries and benefits [0:54:02] or tying up precious resources [0:54:04] that could be used for other projects. [0:54:06] And I will definitely be monitoring this one closely. [0:54:13] The M&O budget is 21% of the total. [0:54:16] And we've spent 23% of the budget [0:54:18] a quarter of the way through the year. [0:54:21] The pool and the insurance funds are the only two funds [0:54:23] that are over that 25% mark, just like last year. [0:54:27] We pay the pool at the beginning of the month. [0:54:30] So there's four months of operation expenses. [0:54:34] And we've paid half of our insurance premiums [0:54:37] in the insurance fund. [0:54:39] Otherwise, everything else is right on track. [0:54:47] The capital improvement budget makes up 19% of the total, [0:54:51] and we're only 8% spent through December. [0:54:54] Three-year average was a little over 21%. [0:54:57] And you'll know that this budget is for one-time projects [0:55:01] or expenditures, and they can be made pretty much [0:55:04] any time throughout the year. [0:55:06] But this is just telling us that our departments [0:55:09] haven't gotten into full swing yet. [0:55:11] Street capital will increase in spring and summer, [0:55:14] and so will equipment purchases. [0:55:16] And our department leaders are really making the decisions about when to pull the trigger on these projects. [0:55:21] Transfers make up almost 3% of total tax-supported funds, and these expenditures are made by adjusting journal entry and they're right on track. [0:55:33] So we've looked at year-to-date revenues, we've received 15% of the budget a quarter of the way through the year, [0:55:40] and the prior three-year average was 13%. [0:55:43] Our property tax collections for January were strong and they were ahead of where the county thought they would be. [0:55:50] Our state-shared revenues are coming in as anticipated and franchise fees from power are higher than expected. [0:55:57] On the revenue side, we're in very good shape. [0:56:00] We've reviewed year to date expenditures. [0:56:03] All four of the expenditure categories are at or below the 25% target. [0:56:09] There won't be a lot of wiggle room on salaries, but that's okay. [0:56:15] There's nothing alarming there right now. [0:56:19] This graph shows the actual revenues and expenditures, three months into each fiscal year, beginning [0:56:24] with 2011 through current. [0:56:27] You'll only notice that 2013 really doesn't follow the trend, but last year we had received [0:56:34] almost $3 million repayment from the wastewater fund and also capital expenditures were higher [0:56:40] them. We continue to maintain adequate cash flows to support activities until revenues [0:56:47] are received. We are on track and we are in strong financial condition in the tax-supported [0:56:52] funds. Now we'll just take a quick look at it, enterprise funds and the budgets for the [0:57:00] three largest are as follows. Water Fund is 9.8 million, waste water fund 9.3 million, [0:57:08] sanitation fund is $2.6 million. We start with the water fund and the revenue picture. [0:57:16] Now, this graph shows water user revenue by month comparing last fiscal year to this one. [0:57:23] And we are up about 4.2% after a 4% rate increase. And this is just what I would expect to see. [0:57:31] It tells me we're on track. I have 10 years of historical information and I can tell you [0:57:36] that on average, we've collected 21.8% three months into the fiscal year, and right now [0:57:43] we're at 21.5% of our budget. Telling months will be spring and summer. [0:57:51] On the expenditure side, personnel costs make up 18% of the total, and those expenditures [0:57:58] are currently at 22% through December. M&O costs make up 26%, and we've only spent 15% [0:58:07] of the budget. We haven't expended much out of utilities yet, and the utilities budget is [0:58:12] about $1 million for power between water supply and pressurized irrigation, and that will definitely [0:58:19] increase later in the year. Capital costs make up 18% of the budget and currently show [0:58:26] where 31% spent, and the majority of this was spent on land for a reservoir. Debt makes [0:58:34] up 28% of the budget in the Water Fund at $2.8 million. [0:58:40] We will make the principal and interest payments in August of 2014. [0:58:44] The ECL $350 expenditure there, it was for the trustee. [0:58:49] It's a fee we have to pay. [0:58:53] Transfers make up 10% of the total budget and they're on track. [0:58:57] And in total, the Water Fund is only 15% spent a quarter of the way through the fiscal year. [0:59:03] We know that this will change when we begin pumping more water during the irrigation season. [0:59:09] As we move forward with our capital projects and when we make our annual debt payment in [0:59:13] August. [0:59:17] In the wastewater fund, there are three major revenue sources that make up 95% of all revenues [0:59:22] in this fund. [0:59:23] Chris, I'll let go back to water for a minute. [0:59:26] There's a question and I'd like to have feedback from you Travis as well. [0:59:32] We're in a terrible drought year at this point. [0:59:35] We're about a third of our moisture normal. [0:59:39] Our budget for the revenue sales shows, even with the 4% bump of what we're budgeting versus [0:59:49] we're projecting, we're going to be down on the actual money collected. [0:59:55] My question is, Lori, not so much for you as policy for the administrator. [1:00:00] If we have a continued drought and the ground sucks up every drop of water it can get, people [1:00:06] put more water on the ground as we encourage conservation even with the 4%. [1:00:12] We're going to have a differential between anticipated revenue and actual consumption. [1:00:20] Just encourage Lori, you and Travis to keep your eye on that figure a lot and continue [1:00:25] to have an aggressive policy, not based on just raising rates, but somehow trimming back [1:00:33] our projected revenues as people get more aware of the water shortage. [1:00:45] So back to wastewater, in 2012, the city implemented an 8% rate adjustment. [1:00:52] And by the first quarter, the revenues for these three sources were coming in at 15% higher. [1:01:00] The increase to residential users was coming in as expected, but both industrial and municipal [1:01:06] user fees were coming in about 26 and 28 percent respectively. [1:01:11] Our residential customers are capped at 8,000 gallons, but our industrials and municipal pay [1:01:16] on flows and loads. [1:01:19] In 2013, we had a 2 percent rate increase. [1:01:23] And this year, after the citizens voted 69 percent to expand our wastewater treatment facility, [1:01:29] increased rates 27% simply to make the debt payment on the $38 million of improvements. [1:01:36] The total increase is coming in around 34%, and it can be specifically attributed to the [1:01:43] industrial's and municipal users. [1:01:47] One thing that we can do with those excess revenues is to sweep them into a rate stabilization [1:01:53] account. [1:01:54] has already been established in this fund, and these excess revenues can then be used [1:01:59] to help mitigate future rate adjustments. [1:02:05] On the expense side, personnel costs make up 6% of the total waste order budget, and [1:02:11] we're at 23% through December. [1:02:15] M&O makes up 39%, and it's showing that on your reports, it's showing that we're 13% [1:02:23] However, this only includes two months of OMI management fees, and the December payment [1:02:29] was made in early January. [1:02:32] So if you include the payment, the actual expenditures are closer to 21%, and that's what's reflected [1:02:38] here. [1:02:40] Capital costs make up roughly 13% of this budget, and according to our reports, we've [1:02:45] expended 160% to date. [1:02:49] This includes $1.3 million that we've already spent for wastewater treatment upgrades, and [1:02:56] they'll be repaid with bond proceeds. [1:02:59] We've also purchased a budgeted skid steer, and we've spent $449,000 on Auger Falls pipeline. [1:03:07] The pipeline will be paid for with grant monies. [1:03:10] If you remove the $1.3 million, we've advanced on the wastewater treatment plant improvement [1:03:16] project, we're at 52% of budget. [1:03:19] And I have no concerns about that being double our 25% benchmark. [1:03:24] Capital expenditures are one time out flows of cash, [1:03:27] and they won't be occurring at the same level [1:03:28] throughout the remainder of the year. [1:03:32] Debt is 35% of this budget at $3.2 million. [1:03:37] That includes an estimate for our new debt. [1:03:40] We have made no debt payments the first three months [1:03:43] of the fiscal year, and we won't until August. [1:03:46] transfers are 7% of the total budget at $672,000, and they currently show we're on track 25%. [1:03:55] In total, the wastewater fund is 18% spent through the first quarter of this fiscal year. [1:04:02] After increasing M&O for the OMI payment and decreasing capital for the $1.3 million we [1:04:08] advanced on the wastewater treatment project, just like in the water fund, we'll have a [1:04:13] large debt payment to make all of one time in August, so our year-to-date percentage of [1:04:19] budget to actual will appear low until that payment is made. [1:04:22] We're going to finish up this discussion with a look at the sanitation fund. [1:04:29] This graph illustrates total revenues from garbage collection, landfill fee, and administrative [1:04:36] fees for the first quarters of fiscal year 2012, 13, and current. [1:04:42] These three sources of revenue make up almost the entire revenue source at 98 percent. [1:04:49] What I want to share with you about the sanitation fund is it's undergone a reorganization. [1:04:55] I know that I've shared with you before that I feel like we should tie our garbage collection [1:05:00] revenue to that expenditure. [1:05:03] We should do the same thing with landfill fees, tie that revenue to that expenditure. [1:05:11] The rest of the fund is for code enforcement activities and administrative costs, like office [1:05:16] supplies and other things necessary to run the department. [1:05:20] Last year, Patty Lehman worked with the code enforcement team to really nail down the portion [1:05:25] of their time that they spent doing sanitation related activities, such as weed violations [1:05:31] and forced mose and reinspections. [1:05:34] We want to make sure that we're charging the appropriate fee for each identified expense. [1:05:41] Prior years make that comparison a little bit difficult because we were subsidizing the recycling program, and then last year we changed the recycling program. [1:05:52] If you'll notice, after our careful review of the budget, it actually decreased about $200,000 from 2013. [1:06:02] We did ask for a small rate increase of 46 cents per customer per month to cover code enforcement activities. [1:06:10] Right now, the total budget is 26%. [1:06:14] Our total revenue is 26% of budget, which tells me that we're getting closer to where we should be in this fund. [1:06:23] On the expenditure side, personnel costs no longer a part of the sanitation fund. [1:06:29] Now, if you look at your report, you'll see an expenditure for about $10,700. [1:06:34] was entered an error and will be adjusted out. [1:06:37] So this graph reflects that correction. [1:06:41] M&O costs are 87% of the budget, and they include PSI [1:06:46] and Twin Falls County Solid Waste Expenditures. [1:06:49] We're showing we're only 11% spent through December, [1:06:52] but when you add in those fillings [1:06:54] that were paid in January, [1:06:57] we're really at 24.9% spent through December. [1:07:03] Now, while there's no capital or debt budget in this fund, [1:07:06] you'll see we have an expenditure of $4,184 [1:07:11] in the capital category. [1:07:13] It was for fencing put up around the Woodways site [1:07:16] on Rose Street, and if necessary, [1:07:18] we'll do a budget amendment to cover that in September. [1:07:21] And finally, transfers make up 14% of the total budget, [1:07:25] and of course, our right-on-track. [1:07:27] The Sanitation Fund is showing 13% spent year to date [1:07:32] when you add in PSI and landfill for the months, [1:07:37] that they were, it was paid in January, [1:07:39] but we add that back to December. [1:07:41] The fund is closer to 25% spent to date, [1:07:44] which is right where I'd expect it to be. [1:07:49] So, that's a look at the revenues and expenditures [1:07:52] for the three major enterprise funds. [1:07:54] As the summary's being displayed, [1:07:56] I'd be happy to answer questions. [1:07:58] Do I have any questions for Lori? [1:08:01] Greg Monning. [1:08:01] Well, this is just a personal knowledge one of the leaders. [1:08:06] You're going through the tax support of funds and the pools and the tax support of funds, [1:08:10] and I know that you didn't cover the enterprise fund, but I know the golf is an enterprise [1:08:14] fund, and yet they seem to be kind of the same thing and why the difference? [1:08:19] So the pool, while it used to be an enterprise fund and paid for with user fees, it was supplemented [1:08:25] with tax dollars, and now it's completely paid for with tax dollars. [1:08:31] And we have a different relationship with the golf course that's handled through contract [1:08:37] and so we're not really collecting user fees to pay for it and we're not subsidizing it [1:08:41] with tax dollars. [1:08:43] Okay. [1:08:45] I'm not sure I got there, but I'm going to do that. [1:08:48] So no tax dollars are going to golf at this time. [1:08:52] They take in all the revenue and they pay all the expenses. [1:08:56] So no user fee there that we're collecting and the pool, long time ago when we used to [1:09:01] to run it and charge user fees. [1:09:04] We still had to supplement it with tax dollars, [1:09:07] so it really wasn't a true enterprise fund. [1:09:09] And now they're no user fees because we're contracting with the why. [1:09:14] And we're paying our portion with tax dollars. [1:09:18] You're welcome. [1:09:19] Do we have any other questions for Lori tonight? [1:09:22] Lori, you must have done such a spectacular job. [1:09:26] Really appreciate your report. [1:09:28] Thank you. [1:09:29] Thanks, Lori. [1:09:31] For the audience, we're now going to be moving to number four, [1:09:34] and I'm assuming that most of you are here to speak on that. [1:09:36] Maybe that's just an assumption on my part. [1:09:39] But if you're interested in making any comments [1:09:42] to the council tonight, if you wouldn't mind making your way [1:09:44] back to the back of the room and signing up [1:09:46] so that we can call you up here in an orderly fashion, [1:09:49] that would be greatly appreciated. [1:09:51] Chris talking. [1:09:52] Laurie, just before you go then, the next step [1:09:54] will be to have a review of the ever-exciting [1:09:57] audit report. [1:09:58] So I have that draft copy and we'll be reviewing it [1:10:02] and then discussing it and finalizing it with the auditors. [1:10:06] And then that's up next, probably in a couple of weeks. [1:10:08] Two weeks, okay, thank you. [1:10:10] We're now moving down to number four under items [1:10:13] for consideration, discussion and possible action [1:10:16] by the City of Twin Falls on the 40th anniversary [1:10:19] of Evil Knievel's attempt to jump the Snake River Canyon. [1:10:23] And Council, we put this on the agenda [1:10:26] so that we could discuss it, [1:10:27] But I think what might be advisable this evening [1:10:32] is if we started with the public input section of this, [1:10:36] if that's the consent of the calendar, [1:10:39] that's the direction I'll move. [1:10:40] Chris talking to? [1:10:41] I would see a lot of friends out there [1:10:42] who have already made some testimony [1:10:44] and I'd be eager to hear what they think [1:10:46] but I would also limit it to a very definite time period. [1:10:49] Very good, Chris. [1:10:50] I think I'll do that. [1:10:51] We generally limit to about two minutes [1:10:54] and we'll try to stay within that. [1:10:56] We won't be taskmasters on that but if you could try to keep your comments as [1:11:00] brief as possible and any other comments from council before we move to that point. [1:11:04] All right we are going to start with calling folks up here and Kevin your [1:11:13] number two on the list so I'm gonna have to go with the number one and it's yeah [1:11:20] she just texted me he's no. Bill Salleo did I say that right Bill if you would [1:11:26] to come forward and make sure you say your name and your address. [1:11:33] Travis, do you have a comment for it while Bill makes his way up here? [1:11:35] Mr. Mayor, members of council, also over the course of the last few days we've received written testimony that we will be flashing up here as part of that as well. [1:11:45] So two minutes Suzanne and Bill, welcome. [1:11:49] Good evening. [1:11:50] One, thank you for the opportunity to address you. [1:11:54] The name is Laley. [1:11:56] I'm sorry. [1:11:57] That's all right. [1:11:58] That's all right. [1:11:59] Which is Nia and Buski. [1:12:01] But hey, I live in 1738, Julie Lane, have been a resident to involve since December 25, [1:12:10] 1979. [1:12:12] I'm up here with regards to, of course, the jump. [1:12:16] I have no real preferences who jumps that can and would not be greatly disappointed [1:12:23] if no one did. [1:12:26] I have a little bit of a problem with the way the whole issue is handled. [1:12:32] I'm privy to a little bit of information that someone brought this proposal to you, [1:12:40] long before it was even made public. [1:12:42] And that person wasn't really given a chance to establish a plan with you. [1:12:51] He now has a current plan with the Jerome County. [1:12:57] I happen to be at that Jerome County meeting, the very first one. [1:13:03] And I saw laid out by Mr. Radio an entire plan of how that was to be done and how it was [1:13:11] going to be accomplished. [1:13:13] From safety to everything, medical services, fire services, police services, he had it documented. [1:13:22] He's now working on, and perhaps by now, as a media company, to back his plan. [1:13:31] And I'm not promoting Scott, okay, I want that to be understood. [1:13:36] I feel that Mr. Beckley, wasn't given an inadequate chance to do what you gentlemen asked him, [1:13:44] ladies and gentlemen, asked him to do. [1:13:48] asked him after that meeting at O'Leary, sometimes after that, and I don't know exactly how long [1:13:56] afterwards, but to present you with a plan. And he began working on that plan. And I've had [1:14:03] no personal contact with Mr. Beckley. I'm surmising a lot of this stuff. But one of [1:14:12] One of the things that seemed to be a stumbling point was that you were unwilling to grant [1:14:19] him at least permission to jump the canyon until he had everything in place. [1:14:28] Now I understand that from the logical standpoint, but I watch the county commissioners in drum [1:14:35] give him permission to do that with the understanding that if he didn't come up with the adequate [1:14:42] plan. They would cancel it. This man put up almost $1 million of his money to do this. [1:14:50] And without your giving at least a signal that yes, we'll allow you to do this if all [1:14:58] this is in place, at least a letter like, and that's what Jerome County did, a letter. [1:15:05] See that letter will allow him to go to the people that were going to front the money, [1:15:10] the TV stations and the supporters of the sponsors of it. [1:15:15] Without any kind of a letter from your gentleman that you were going to allow him provided, [1:15:20] he gave you everything he needed, he was unable to raise money. [1:15:27] Now why should he go forward in his plans with you spending additional money to get [1:15:35] all this accomplished without at least some assurance that if he gets it all done, you [1:15:40] who will allow him to jump the cannon. [1:15:42] Bill, could you wrap it up? [1:15:43] You're almost double the time. [1:15:45] OK. [1:15:46] Well, that's really all I had to say. [1:15:49] I think it was Ms. Hamble. [1:15:51] Thank you, Bill. [1:15:51] Thank you for your testimony. [1:15:54] Kevin Dane? [1:16:01] My name is Kevin Dane. [1:16:02] I live in Twin Falls. [1:16:03] In fact, I live about five blocks from Bill. [1:16:07] Just a statement, no real questions. [1:16:09] It appears that the council has come under a lot of heat, [1:16:11] especially from the times and news [1:16:13] other sources about how the situation has been handled. [1:16:16] And if you read the newspaper yesterday, [1:16:19] I thought that Brent White did a good letter to the editor [1:16:22] and looked at a different perspective on that. [1:16:24] And I thought that was worth reading. [1:16:25] So if you haven't, I'd suggest you read that. [1:16:27] This idea has nothing new. [1:16:29] It's been floating around for the last 40 years off and on. [1:16:33] Initially, I was against this completely. [1:16:36] I was in the Navy back in 1974, but my family was here. [1:16:40] And I was kept in the loop on it. [1:16:42] I can verify that my dad took some heavy financial losses because of basically lack of security [1:16:49] control on it. [1:16:52] Chris talking to was here back in 1974. [1:16:54] He can vouch for a lot of the issues that occurred during that time frame. [1:16:57] Since that time, I've never been in favor of it, but during early 2013 when it was proposed [1:17:02] again, I tried to give it another shot and look at it. [1:17:07] My main issue again is I don't really care one way together if the jump happens. [1:17:11] It would be nice if I did, but if it doesn't, [1:17:13] it's not the end of the world. [1:17:14] But I have an issue with control and security. [1:17:17] And I think that was one of the things [1:17:19] that Chris talking to, Col. Mattock and tonight, [1:17:22] talked about is the problems we have security control [1:17:25] that time. [1:17:28] Right now, the way I calculated between [1:17:31] Councilman Munn, Mayor Hall, Keith Pike, [1:17:37] they've got over 60 years of law enforcement in this area. [1:17:40] In fact, Mr. Munn was the chief of police at one time. [1:17:45] With all that experience, they still do not feel comfortable with the plan or lack of plan presented by Mr. Beckley in his organization. [1:17:52] So I guess in that respect, I'm going to leave it to the experts and leave it that way. [1:17:57] I'd like to hear some other viewpoints, but when we talk about moving 60,000 people to Twin Falls, that's one of the estimates. [1:18:04] To put that in perspective, that's two sold out Boise State football games. [1:18:08] Basically moving in your backyard and they're not going to be all for boys or missionaries [1:18:13] Okay, there's going to be some people who want to have a fun a good time [1:18:16] Which is fine, but I just think that without a viable security plan to protect the citizens and they come first [1:18:21] I think it's a dead issue. Thank you. Thank you, mr. Dang [1:18:25] grand Florence [1:18:34] Welcome mr. Florence. Thank you. I'll make it brief because I have testified in the past first of all just like to say I've [1:18:41] known Kevin Dane for [1:18:43] ever. And we've been friends forever. And it's starting to bother me because I'm [1:18:49] agreeing with what he says more and more every time he speaks. I agree with Kevin. [1:18:59] I also would just like to, I guess, reemphasize that if you go forward with the jump, I just [1:19:05] want to remind or encourage you again to keep in mind the brand of Twin Falls. I listen to [1:19:14] Dr. Bob's talk and I listened to the discussion about the budget items and it's clear that [1:19:21] Twin Falls is on a course that we haven't seen maybe since the very early time of our [1:19:28] history where we have some financial successes and we have some needs that are being addressed [1:19:36] and we have a tremendous amount of positive momentum and it's due in a large part to you [1:19:43] folks up there and it really annoys me when I read things and I hear things that are critical [1:19:50] of your efforts because to a person, I know that your efforts are sincerely and honestly [1:19:58] doing the best job you can do and I think quite frankly you've been doing a terrific job. [1:20:03] And I want you to stay the course, keep working hard, stay with the vision of the brand. [1:20:15] And if you revisit this, please keep that in mind. [1:20:20] Thank you. [1:20:21] Thank you, Mr. Florence. [1:20:23] Jeff Rolick. [1:20:24] Welcome, Mr. Rolick. [1:20:30] Good evening. [1:20:31] Thank you. [1:20:32] Well, as most of you know, I'm an attorney here in town. [1:20:36] I do a lot of real estate work. [1:20:37] I've got a couple of corny old sayings really quickly here. [1:20:40] I'll throw at you. [1:20:41] The first one is haste makes waste. [1:20:44] In my practice, I've found that the client who calls in saying, [1:20:49] I got a million dollar deal, and you've got to do it. [1:20:51] And we're closing on Friday. [1:20:53] This is Tuesday afternoon. [1:20:55] Those are red flags to me. [1:20:57] And I want to just commend you people [1:21:00] for having the gumption to put the brakes on, step back, [1:21:04] and say, wait a minute, let's take a good hard look at this. [1:21:07] And I know you're taking some heat for it, [1:21:09] but I commend you for that. [1:21:12] The other old saw I want to just raise is, [1:21:15] you can't ever go back. [1:21:17] You can't ever go back, regardless [1:21:19] of how romantically people might want to portray evil [1:21:23] canevil and this great event that happened. [1:21:29] A couple of things that I've read that I'll just mention. [1:21:31] One is back when I was in law school, I started in 1974. [1:21:38] I think it was 75, Rolling Stone magazine came out with an article about the evil, [1:21:44] can evil jump. [1:21:45] And if you haven't read it, and if you're not too faint of hearted, I recommend it. [1:21:51] It's a great, very entertaining, hair-raising and ultimately extremely negative article [1:21:58] about that. [1:22:00] The other things that I've read that is probably no coincidence, there are at least two Idaho [1:22:07] Supreme Court cases dealing with riot and mayhem exclusions to property damage insurance [1:22:17] claims. Two cases went to the Idaho Supreme Court trying to figure out, well what's a riot [1:22:23] and what is mayhem because insurance companies never want to pay claims. Well it's not a coincidence [1:22:28] that both of those came out of this event and if you think there aren't going to be problems [1:22:33] this next time your crystal ball isn't as good as mine and I will just close by saying [1:22:40] the same media sources that are bashing you and second guessing you now for stepping back [1:22:47] are going to be the same media sources that are bashing you and second guessing you when [1:22:52] every inevitable negative thing goes down and somehow then that will all be your fault [1:22:58] to. So to me, this deal is bad for the brand. It's bad for property owners, bad for business [1:23:05] owners. It's not a good deal for Twin Falls. [1:23:09] Thank you, Mr. Rood. Jay McBride. Welcome, sir. [1:23:19] Good evening. My name is Jay Jay McBride. I live in 584 IB Prime in Twin Falls. And I'm [1:23:24] a new old citizen of Twin Falls. I was raised here. I recently moved back to pursue my career [1:23:30] and insurance, unfortunately. [1:23:32] After Mr. Rolex conversation, but I just wanted to offer some support to the council's decision. [1:23:39] While I was not alive during the 74 jump, several of my family members were here. [1:23:44] For that, including covering it as part of the media. [1:23:47] And the tales that they were count, not always positive. [1:23:51] But I do believe this could be a positive situation if undertaken properly. [1:23:57] and with due course and slow decision making, excuse me. [1:24:03] So in closing really shortly, I would like to say, [1:24:08] thank you for taking a measured slow approach to this [1:24:10] and I look forward to seeing this occur [1:24:14] at some later date, but maybe not right now. [1:24:16] Thank you. [1:24:17] Thank you, Mr. McBride. [1:24:19] Trevor Tartar. [1:24:26] Welcome Mr. Tartar. [1:24:27] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:24:28] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:24:31] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:24:39] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:24:48] So thank you. [1:24:49] Thank you, Mr. Turner. [1:24:51] Dan Guthrie. [1:24:55] Welcome, Mr. Guthrie. [1:24:55] Thank you. [1:24:57] Basically, I was writing this as the meeting was going, so I'll just read it off. [1:25:02] I feel that as a community, we do need a jump. [1:25:04] It's 40th anniversary. [1:25:05] We don't get a lot of anniversary [1:25:07] of anything around here. [1:25:09] It's pretty dry around here. [1:25:11] It seems to me like the deal is hinging on safety. [1:25:14] We're focusing on the past strategies that we've learned. [1:25:17] We've learned from them, and we can see them coming [1:25:19] in the past we didn't. [1:25:21] A lot of them are worries that are focusing [1:25:23] on bikers that idolized evil, could evil. [1:25:27] And these guys aren't evil, can be evil. [1:25:29] And the people who are showing up to watch them jump [1:25:31] going to be the type of guys that showed up in 1974. [1:25:35] A lot of that guys will encourage to show up back then. [1:25:38] Obviously they're being discouraged from showing up now. [1:25:42] Also, people talk about the bikers. [1:25:44] Many biker groups have evolved in a service-oriented groups. [1:25:48] And surprisingly, I would imagine the community could probably [1:25:51] lean on these guys for a little added level of security [1:25:54] as they please themselves and kind of please the community [1:25:57] as positive eyes around the canyon. [1:26:00] A lot of these motorcycle fans have also evolved into extreme athletes whose clean reputation [1:26:06] and image drive their livelihood through branding and community outreach. [1:26:12] That's kind of what we're looking at right now. [1:26:14] And 1974 was definitely a circus on purpose. [1:26:18] That's how evil can even wanted it if he got exactly what he wanted. [1:26:22] 2014 will be a gathering of purpose, a time to learn about positive adrenaline, teamwork, [1:26:28] and the strength of our community. [1:26:30] And I really think we're going to surprise ourselves if it happens. [1:26:34] Hopefully it does. [1:26:35] So, you know, regardless of who jumps, our city deserves redemption for past events. [1:26:40] We also deserve a big event to look forward to and work together on. [1:26:44] If we miss this anniversary, we'll regret it. [1:26:46] The time is right and we'll just make it happen. [1:26:49] Thank you, Mr. Garthi. [1:26:51] Penny Ploss. [1:26:52] Welcome, Mrs. Ploss. [1:27:00] Thank you. [1:27:01] Thank you for hearing my point of view. [1:27:04] My only concern is I think that the issue now is not that can we handle the jump. [1:27:11] Is that we're going to have to handle it if he does it on private land with no return of revenue. [1:27:17] That's my concern. [1:27:19] Thank you. [1:27:22] Cheryl Wheeler, welcome. [1:27:36] My husband and I are raising our family less than a quarter mile from Evil Kenil's ramp. [1:27:43] I have participated in the selection process. [1:27:46] I was appalled at the council's choice of Ed Beckley because I remained firmly convinced [1:27:52] that he was the weakest and worst of all the candidates. [1:27:56] I applaud your decision to deny his permit. [1:28:00] That said, my husband and I did not oppose the jump. [1:28:04] We opposed merely the Beckley jump. [1:28:08] From the beginning, I felt that the right to jump should be given to a local resident, [1:28:15] no one. Miles Dasher cares about Twin Falls and his team will provide us with an event [1:28:24] that this city can be proud of. Thank you for your time. [1:28:28] Thank you. Mike Jones. Welcome Mr. Jones. [1:28:37] Good evening Mayor and ladies and gentlemen of council. I'd like to remind everybody that [1:28:45] But this is not 1974, this is 2014, and things are different. [1:28:50] People are different times have changed, everything has changed. [1:28:54] I'd like to know how many of you people were here in 1974 and went to the jump. [1:28:59] I was a responsible, mature adult that attended that activity. [1:29:05] There were some things there that were colorful, I'd have to say the least. [1:29:09] I saw what you might call ma'am, but back then, it was in the prank, today it would probably [1:29:18] be a crime. [1:29:21] But there were some things that I didn't see anything that was really much different than [1:29:24] you see at a rodeo or any other big gathering where there's a lot of people and there's alcohol [1:29:28] involved, you're going to have some problems. [1:29:32] I personally was very upset with your decision not to go ahead and at least give Mr. Beckley [1:29:38] the opportunity to come up with what you requested. I'm sure that you all know that in 1974 in [1:29:44] comparison to 2014 today, the county and the city probably have around 20 times more law [1:29:51] enforcement officers on the ground that are prepared right now to deal with something like [1:29:56] this. And that's a huge, huge difference and we're not expecting I don't think any more [1:30:01] people at this one than that one. Maybe not as many. I really don't think it's going to [1:30:05] be a 50 or 100,000 population type thing that are going to show up, I think it's going [1:30:09] to be manageable. I think that there are plenty of law enforcement personnel to take care of [1:30:16] what needs to be done here. I really wish that you would back up and give Mr. Beckley the [1:30:21] opportunity to comply with whatever needs to be complied with. He's put up a tremendous [1:30:26] amount of money and he's definitely the only player involved in this that's capable of [1:30:30] doing it. He has the resources and he has the ability and he has the will. I felt kind [1:30:37] of in awe when I walked up here my attorney, Mr. Rolex, before I did it, and I'm going to [1:30:42] have to visit with about $200 an hour. But anyway, I really wish that you would reconsider [1:30:51] and give this man an opportunity, a fair opportunity. I don't think you've given him a fair opportunity. [1:30:55] I know you've all put a lot of time and effort into this, but I think there's been lobbying [1:30:59] and things that have gone, I don't think the, I really don't think that the Chamber of Commerce [1:31:04] should be lobbying in this group for any kinds of activities like this, and I think that I [1:31:09] see some of that, maybe I'm wrong, but I see it. [1:31:13] Anyway, I appreciate your time and I appreciate you listening to me. [1:31:17] I appreciate everyone that came here tonight and spoke, but I think the man needs a fair [1:31:20] chance. [1:31:21] That's one of the greatest things that ever happened in Southern Idaho. [1:31:23] It's the only thing I can remember of that was really memorable other than family affairs [1:31:28] and things like that. [1:31:29] was an occasion. I don't think it can ever be duplicated, but we can give something that [1:31:33] will last in posterity again. If it's done properly, and if everybody will join in and [1:31:38] just make it work. Thank you for time. [1:31:41] Thank you, Mr. Jones. Tom Ruby. Thank you very much. Sorry. Jacob and I'm having a tough [1:31:56] time. Florence? Oh, welcome, Mr. Florence. [1:32:04] I'm Jacob Florence who live at 478 Pierce, like Mr. McBride. [1:32:08] I moved back about a year ago, pursue my career here in Twin Falls. [1:32:12] I grew up here, loved this town, out of this town. [1:32:16] I want to put my support behind the council's decision. [1:32:19] I think he did the right one. [1:32:22] I have to agree with the gentleman that got up here and spoke [1:32:28] on behalf of Mr. Beckley. [1:32:30] I don't think that riots, I think, times have changed. [1:32:33] I don't think it's a matter of riots and crowd control. [1:32:36] I think times have changed. [1:32:39] But to me, it's a matter of image [1:32:41] and the image that our city wants to portray. [1:32:44] I can't remember what meeting it was at, [1:32:45] but it was probably the presentation at O'Leary, [1:32:49] but Mr. Beckley brought up his team. [1:32:53] And I think it was as crowd control guy [1:32:56] was a bar owner and sturges. [1:33:01] I haven't had the opportunity to go to sturges yet, [1:33:03] I've seen plenty of pictures and stories from lots of people who do. [1:33:07] I've seen that show, I think it's called Full Throttle Saloon. [1:33:11] Anyway, it's Pikers, and it's a party. [1:33:18] It looks like it's fun, but it's definitely not the image that I want our city to portray. [1:33:25] So with that, I just want to thank you for taking your time and making the decision that you did. [1:33:29] I think it was the right one. Thanks. [1:33:31] Mr. Foreign's. [1:33:32] Ladies and gentlemen, that's all I have on the list, [1:33:35] but I certainly will allow others to come up [1:33:37] in a manageable form. [1:33:39] TJ, looks like you wanna come up. [1:33:41] So why don't you make your way up, Travis? [1:33:43] Mr. Mayor and members of council, [1:33:44] if we could have them maybe go down and sign in first [1:33:48] so that we have their names appropriately [1:33:50] for the record as they are approaching the podium. [1:33:52] TJ, why don't you come up and we'll have everyone else do it. [1:33:55] I'll try to write it down as best I can, [1:33:57] your address and everything. [1:34:02] of C.J. Woodhall, owner of Snake Harley-Davidson, 2404, Edison Avenue. [1:34:07] You know, a lot of what's going on with this, you look at Evil Knievel. A lot of people followed [1:34:15] him at that time because of the motor's likely road. We hear about bikers, about what bikers [1:34:20] do and how they act. Well, I'm here to tell you, Don Mayer's a biker. Don Haller, Mayor. [1:34:28] We've got ex-police chief [1:34:31] Is a biker lead of or we've got these people. I'm a biker. I have been all my life [1:34:36] I'm not out pillaging and causing trouble. There's a certain of these people that do [1:34:42] You guys watch too much sons of anarchy on TV. That is not true. That is not how we act. That is not what happens [1:34:49] I've got a list of over 25 groups [1:34:51] motorcycle groups here in Twin Falls Valley in the Magic Valley and they make [1:34:57] the paper a lot. They make articles on the paper. It's for helping kids. It's for [1:35:02] helping homes. It's for helping QRUs. It's for raising money to help people. [1:35:07] It's not the pillaging and the fighting and the riots and I just [1:35:13] watch all think about that. It really it really upsets me when the [1:35:18] The award biker takes a hit because of something they see on TV or the biker community. [1:35:24] I'll tell you what, we've got good family members in our community, they're all bikers. [1:35:29] Okay, very good community. [1:35:31] And it just erks me a little bit when we all get put under some brand of something that's [1:35:36] seen on TV and that's how they think we're all acting and what we're going to do. [1:35:41] Outered to interview at any time, please come down to my dealership. [1:35:44] Look at what we do. [1:35:45] Look how we are. [1:35:46] Okay? [1:35:47] I appreciate that. [1:35:48] Thank you much. [1:35:49] Thanks to the Council, Mayor. [1:35:50] Thank you. [1:35:51] Thank you, Mr. Woodell. [1:35:55] Is there anyone else that would like to come forward? [1:35:58] Signed up? [1:36:05] Come on forward, Woody, and give me your name, address, and we'll just rock and roll. [1:36:13] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:36:14] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:36:25] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:36:30] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:36:35] And like so many who have spoken tonight, you know, if it doesn't happen, it doesn't [1:36:41] particularly bother me. [1:36:43] But I'd like to just point out that our image is sort of merry-to-evil-can-evil, regardless [1:36:50] of what we do going forward. [1:36:52] It's just what we're known for. [1:36:55] We can't really go back and turn that page so I don't know whether not doing it is really [1:37:02] an effect at all. [1:37:04] But my other point to make is really a question. [1:37:09] We're going to be forced with a security problem anyway, aren't we? [1:37:14] And what are we going to do about that? [1:37:18] That's really the only thing that I'd like to make a point about. [1:37:23] So thank you. [1:37:24] Thank you sir, very much. [1:37:27] Is there anyone else in the audience that would like to come testify because if not, [1:37:31] I'm going to turn it over to the council and for deliberations and discussion regarding this issue. [1:37:39] All right, closing the public testimony portion of this and turn it over to council and asking for their direction. [1:37:49] Thoughts? [1:37:52] Suzanne Hopkins. [1:37:55] I just want to address first of all a couple of the comments about bikers in the image. [1:37:59] And from my personal perspective, that has not weighed into my decision. [1:38:04] I agree that bike riders today are a whole different breed of people than they were then. [1:38:10] And that the bikers are very generous and good to our community. [1:38:15] When we started this discussion months ago, as a council, we came up with the end of January for [1:38:20] a deadline to get certain pieces of this puzzle figured out. [1:38:25] and Beckley media did not meet those requirements by January 31st. [1:38:30] I know there's a lot of data about an April 1st date. [1:38:33] That was a general date put out in a draft copy of a lease [1:38:37] that was never agreed upon. [1:38:39] He was never given that date by this council as a whole. [1:38:42] It was talked about, it was discussed. [1:38:44] But the only thing we agreed from the beginning [1:38:47] was by the end of January, there were certain things [1:38:50] that we needed to feel safe with continuing this process. [1:38:54] And in my mind, he did not meet the requirements we set by that date. [1:39:00] And so I just want to clarify that in case people are not understanding what we've been [1:39:04] working on and the project as we've been going through it. [1:39:08] But again, to address the bikers, had nothing to do with my decision, [1:39:12] and the evil, can evil jump really didn't have anything to do. [1:39:16] We had criteria we set out that wasn't met by in a timely matter. [1:39:22] So I just wanted to start to meeting that way [1:39:24] and put that out there. [1:39:25] Thank you, Suzanne. [1:39:26] Sean Berger. [1:39:27] Well, thank you, Mayor, and thank you, Suzanne, [1:39:30] for those comments, because I too would [1:39:32] like to reiterate some of the facts that have been happening [1:39:37] for the last several months. [1:39:39] I appreciate the crowd that's here tonight [1:39:41] to participate in this. [1:39:42] Now, a week after we started this process in September. [1:39:48] So, again, your comments are welcome. [1:39:52] Appreciate your engagement. [1:39:53] But the time to talk about how much you didn't like [1:39:56] this process was September. [1:39:59] Because that's when we started this process. [1:40:01] So I struggle when I pick up the newspaper on a daily basis [1:40:08] and read letters that are full of innuendo [1:40:13] and your opinion about things that then get portrayed [1:40:16] is fact. And it is challenging. That's what we do as a council. I get that. We thicken our [1:40:26] skin and we try to deal with this. But as Suzanne just laid out, we laid out what we needed [1:40:34] months ago and we didn't get it by the date we needed it. So if you want to say that's [1:40:40] screwing Ed Beckley, so be it. But that's not what it is. It's about trying to protect the [1:40:46] citizens of the community with a plan. If this were a developer standing in front of us saying [1:40:52] we're ready to develop this giant subdivision, so go ahead and sign on the dotted line and then [1:40:58] I'll bring you the plan on April 1st. Not one of you in this room would be here saying that's a good [1:41:04] plan. Not one of you. So we didn't get what we needed which was a safety plan to address the [1:41:11] needs of this community. That's why I voted against this. Not because I don't like bikers because TJ [1:41:19] It's not about bikers. It's not about 1974. This is not going to be the same thing it was [1:41:24] 40 years ago, and there may be 15 people who come or there may be 15,000 or there may be 150,000. I don't know [1:41:33] Mr. Beckley couldn't tell us that that's a really good place to start with a plan and it needs to come from mr. Beckley not from us [1:41:42] So that's why I voted the way I did last week not to sign the lease with him [1:41:46] I look forward to the rest of the council's discussion to see where we might go tonight. [1:41:52] But again, this has been a very public process. [1:41:56] Everything is on the city's website. [1:41:58] We have been talking about this for literally months. [1:42:03] Five months ago was when this was first on our agenda to talk about whether we wanted [1:42:06] to entertain this notion, September. [1:42:11] This has not been done in some back room. [1:42:14] It wasn't done in some bar meeting bill, as you alluded to in your letter in the paper this weekend, it's been done right here. [1:42:26] Chris, talking to one of our most important roles as perveyors of the temporary purveyors of the public trust is due diligence on checking out facts that the council is to make a decision on. [1:42:43] It also is really important for us to look back [1:42:46] since September and evaluate ourselves. [1:42:51] We've had some very strong difference of opinion. [1:42:53] We've had a healthy debate. [1:42:55] And the last thing I think we should be [1:42:57] accused of is trying to make decisions [1:43:00] behind closed doors. [1:43:02] We've been exemplary. [1:43:04] One thing I've learned though is that I cannot, [1:43:07] for the life of me, fault our decision-making process [1:43:11] of grabbing the bull by the horns, if you will. [1:43:14] The city being in charge for something that starts [1:43:17] at the Keneville jump site, [1:43:20] of putting a proposed starting point contract [1:43:27] in front of the applicant and driving the issues, [1:43:30] driven primarily by the private, [1:43:33] for the preservation of the public safety. [1:43:37] I think that's been our strongest point [1:43:40] that we can take some solace in that a few of the details may have slipped down but we kept [1:43:47] her eye on the target which is public safety. [1:43:50] I cannot for the life of me imagine sitting around a table with up to 20 different parties [1:43:55] in an agreement like this not having a starting point. [1:43:58] We started I think for the most part where we ended up right now with a need for a demonstration [1:44:05] of a well-managed and publicly safety maintained operation. [1:44:12] We are very clear, as his end point out, by the end of January was the drop dead, no pun [1:44:18] intended, drop dead date for this. [1:44:21] It did not come to our, nor the chief police approval during that time. [1:44:30] We've now moved on. [1:44:32] We'll have other discussion, but I'll tell you where I am right now. We've set the process in motion by [1:44:43] Numerically prioritizing the applicants our first applicant has not met the criterion [1:44:49] We have a second applicant mr. Dasher that I would support to be able to have the same opportunity to meet the negotiation [1:44:59] Resulting in a favorable [1:45:03] outcome for the city, that is public safety. [1:45:06] We've sequenced the applicants. [1:45:10] The first applicant is out. [1:45:12] The second one is Mr. Dasher. [1:45:14] I think we should set a date for Mr. Dasher to finalize a contract with the city, which [1:45:21] includes a safety plan by May 15th. [1:45:25] I think the same terms for Beckley would be applicable to the next applicant, the consideration [1:45:31] for City, including the trail improvements at all. [1:45:36] And the applicant frankly has the burden to see if they can reach an agreement with any [1:45:40] north side private or public property owners. [1:45:44] But my support is to give the next applicant the same opportunity we gave the first. [1:45:51] Thank you, President. [1:45:52] Rebecca Mills-Soyka. [1:45:53] Thank you, Mayor. [1:45:55] I'll probably take a different approach than the others, but I appreciate the conversation. [1:46:01] And similarly, this has been a long process. [1:46:05] A lot of you have been with us this whole entire time. [1:46:08] And so I looked back and looked at the minutes and the notes. [1:46:11] And throughout this process, on December 16th, [1:46:16] we actually set the February 3rd date. [1:46:19] And we did say that it was not a drop-dead date. [1:46:22] We said that if we had indications from staff [1:46:25] that things were moving positively, [1:46:28] we can review the record. [1:46:29] And that was the direction of the council. [1:46:31] and collectively, we said that if things were progressing that we would continue. [1:46:38] We also put in the date of April 1st at that time, that same meeting on December 16th, Travis [1:46:46] Chief of Police came to us and said, you know, physically, we don't have the time to review [1:46:52] a safety plan and have it ready and have a perspective and an opinion on it by your February [1:46:58] third date. [1:46:59] Is it okay if we put a clause in the lease agreement that requires the applicant to have [1:47:07] a safety plan approved by the council at a later date? [1:47:10] At that time, there were two council members that said that would not work for them. [1:47:16] The rest of council said yes, that's how we would move forward. [1:47:20] And that's what we said we would do. [1:47:22] So when last week we made our decision to turn down the lease with Beckley, I was surprised. [1:47:32] We know that Mr. Beckley was surprised, the media was surprised, I think the whole state. [1:47:38] Obviously we made some voicey news, people were surprised, because there was no indication prior to that that there was any issue with Mr. Beckley not presenting a full plan. [1:47:51] because the majority of the council said, okay, we'll wait. [1:47:54] I feel that we had the obligation to let him know [1:47:57] if that was a critical piece of the plan [1:48:02] and it was not going to be approved [1:48:04] by that April 1st deadline that we allowed [1:48:07] to be put in that lease agreement. [1:48:10] There were no discussions a week prior about that. [1:48:13] We should honor what we set forth [1:48:16] and how is Mr. Beckley to know [1:48:19] If we don't let him know ahead of time that this is an issue, [1:48:23] I would like a clarification from the Chief of Police. [1:48:28] There's been some comment even from the public and from the council [1:48:32] that there was doubt on the police department's perspective [1:48:37] that Beckley had a viable plan. [1:48:40] But what I have heard in all of the meetings previous to this one is [1:48:44] that things were progressing in a positive manner [1:48:47] and that at one time it was even said that the plan was further along then we thought it [1:48:55] would be at this time and so you know if that's not the case I would like to know and maybe [1:48:59] I misunderstood some comments from the police department but if the chief could give his perspective [1:49:04] on up until last week how negotiations were progressing on this safety plan. [1:49:10] Chief Pike? [1:49:16] Well this has been quite a process and you know honestly this is not I think it's important [1:49:22] important to state that we have a good working relationship with [1:49:28] Beckley Media. It's not like I'm here to report that things are [1:49:32] a mess and everything is falling apart. But the reality is, [1:49:36] and what I've said all along, is that, let me go back and [1:49:40] probably lay a little foundation here. Because what I've said all along [1:49:43] is that this is something that we've been working on. So when we [1:49:46] first met with Beckley Media, Ed Beckley had the concept of what [1:49:51] wanted to do. And that's pretty much what he said. He was, you know, at Beckley's going [1:49:55] to jump to Canyon. He was going to be mayor. And as we progressed, they sent us a draft, [1:50:00] and that was their safety plan. And I think it's important to understand that when we're [1:50:05] talking about safety plans, I've seen a lot of safety plans, and I've seen a lot of different [1:50:11] plans. And I guess everyone in this room would have a different idea of what that safety plan [1:50:15] would look like. But I haven't seen, it's really rare for us, and we handle a lot of special [1:50:21] events, but it's really rare for us to see a safety plan that a promoter or event organizer [1:50:27] puts together that they present to us that's perfect, that doesn't need to be modified or [1:50:31] changed. [1:50:32] And our approach as a city has always been that we've worked with those individuals. [1:50:36] We work with them, we help them mitigate their concerns because we want them to have the event. [1:50:41] We're not opposed to having the event. [1:50:44] So when we received our first draft plan from Beckley Media, it was just that. [1:50:47] It was a pretty vague plan. [1:50:50] This is what we're going to do, this is how many people we think, and those numbers have [1:50:55] changed. [1:50:56] I think this council realizes that. [1:50:58] We have worked off three sets of numbers, which is kind of a little bit adds to some of [1:51:03] the frustration. [1:51:05] Ed Beckley told this council right here that there'd be 40,000 people at the event. [1:51:10] His event organizer, Rod Woodworth and Wally Walzek said 75 to 100,000 people. [1:51:16] on Ed Deckley's website, he's advertising, [1:51:19] you know, have a great experience in the City of Twin Falls [1:51:22] and joined the hundreds of thousands of people. [1:51:25] So even in their own camp, we've struggled [1:51:27] with the mixed message of how many people were becoming here. [1:51:30] And I think Mayor Hall was right on. [1:51:32] It's impossible to start planning for a event when you have no idea [1:51:35] what those numbers look like. [1:51:37] So the first draft was just that. [1:51:38] It was a draft. [1:51:39] It was their best shot of what this event looked like. [1:51:43] And of course, we met with them. [1:51:45] Actually, we didn't meet with them. [1:51:46] We had a number of phone conversations with the VEGLI media. [1:51:51] And it was at that point that Rod Woodruff and Wally [1:51:55] Walsett came on board. [1:51:57] Captain Barnhart was working with them exclusively. [1:52:00] We had a number of phone conferences. [1:52:01] We finally encouraged them to send Mr. Walsett out here [1:52:05] because it was impossible to put together this public safety [1:52:08] plan using Google Maps and not being familiar with the area. [1:52:12] I mean, there's a lot of dynamics that [1:52:14] are unique about this jump. This isn't similar to probably any other special events in the [1:52:19] state of Idaho. It's unique. We have a canyon. It presents a lot of dangers. There's a lot [1:52:25] of places to view the venue other than buying a ticket and going to a certain location. [1:52:31] You just get to that rim and you're going to see some of the events. And we thought it [1:52:35] was important that Beckley Media would come out that they would have individuals on the [1:52:39] ground because that helped them address some of their issues. [1:52:44] Mr. Walzette came out, we had a really good conversation with him, Captain Barnhart spent [1:52:49] three days burning him around working with some of our partners who were here tonight. [1:52:54] Sheriff Doug McFall and his under sheriff Jack Johnson and Captain Rob Storm from the Idaho [1:52:59] State Police were here tonight to join us. [1:53:02] We were working on that. [1:53:04] That led to what I would consider to be the second draft of the security plan, which is [1:53:09] this document that I have and I'm sure all of you have seen. [1:53:12] And it was, and I said, you know, actually I told the council it was probably a little [1:53:15] better than what I thought it would be for the second round because this is a process that [1:53:20] takes time. [1:53:21] We're going to refine this, we're going to work together. [1:53:24] One of the concerns that I shared with the council is that I thought that this needed to [1:53:27] be a multi-jurisdictional approach. [1:53:29] They were inconsistent messages taking place between what Anthony and I were hearing and what Sheriff McFall and his team were hearing. [1:53:36] And as we met the chiefs and sheriffs and state police, as we met, we thought it would be good to have one comprehensive public safety plan so that we would be very clear. [1:53:48] But even in the second plan, these are all conversations that we've had along the line with Beckley Media. [1:53:55] We responded to their second plan talking about, hey, this is, it's probably further [1:54:02] along than what we anticipated your second draft would be, but these are some things you [1:54:06] need to address. [1:54:07] Remote parking, you can't just simply say we're going to use Canyon Ridge High School [1:54:11] to park it. [1:54:12] You have to have conversations with the school district. [1:54:16] Magic Valley Mall, we encourage them a number of times. [1:54:18] You need to get with the Woodbury Corporation and talk to them. [1:54:21] They're a major player. [1:54:22] They're right at ground zero of this. [1:54:25] have literally thousands of people on their property and we need to have a conversation. [1:54:30] You need to have a conversation with how you're going to mitigate that, what that looks like. [1:54:34] We talked about a traffic control plan which we didn't have. [1:54:39] And there's a big difference and I don't want to mix the two jumps but I think it's important [1:54:44] to understand. [1:54:46] I'm going to be meeting with Scott Rekord on even though we're not part of their jump because [1:54:53] is re-to-sell engineering is devising their traffic plant for them, and he wants to make [1:54:57] sure even though it doesn't directly impact the city that we're comfortable with their [1:55:03] traffic plant. We haven't seen anything like that. I haven't seen it yet, so I don't want [1:55:08] to assume too much, but we work with Beckley Media on that. We need a traffic control [1:55:13] plant and we cannot have gridlock on the bridge. That's a unique dynamic about the Canyon Jump. [1:55:21] You cannot, this event isn't organized correctly. [1:55:24] You can only imagine. [1:55:25] It takes one accident on Blick's Boulevard, [1:55:28] to back traffic up for anyone that's been out there. [1:55:30] One accident and you're through two lights. [1:55:33] So if that bridge, if your traffic flow plan [1:55:36] doesn't work and you're not getting the attendees [1:55:40] into your venue and that flow is not working, [1:55:43] we cannot have gridlock on the bridge [1:55:45] because that's a critical public safety artery. [1:55:50] And with St. Luke's has to be able to provide medical service [1:55:53] beyond that bridge into the residents of our northern [1:55:57] communities that's just essential. [1:55:59] And so we talked about those dynamics, [1:56:00] and we asked for those plans. [1:56:02] We talked about neighborhoods and how neighborhoods would [1:56:04] be impacted. [1:56:05] The one thing that's been consistent in front of this [1:56:07] council is individuals that are close to those neighborhoods. [1:56:10] They want to know, are we going to be safe? [1:56:12] What measures are you going to be taking? [1:56:13] What steps can you ensure us that our properties will be [1:56:17] covered? [1:56:18] Those are things that we talked about, a medical plan. [1:56:20] We did not, we have not seen any medical plan. [1:56:24] How are they going to handle? [1:56:25] What does that look like? [1:56:27] How many, how many, are you working with St. Luke's? [1:56:29] And actually, to be honest with you, [1:56:31] we try to facilitate all of these things for them. [1:56:33] And like I said, we've had a good working relationship [1:56:36] with them. [1:56:37] We know that we're going to have to go out of our way [1:56:39] to make this happen. [1:56:41] And we're okay with that. [1:56:42] It's not like we're drawing a line in the sand saying, [1:56:44] we're not willing to work with you. [1:56:46] we're more than willing to work with them. [1:56:49] And then of course, fire support is not something [1:56:51] that we've even seen. [1:56:52] And we've had a number of discussions here [1:56:54] in front of the council about fire support. [1:56:56] So is the plan ready to go? [1:56:58] It's absolutely not ready to go. [1:56:59] And I shared with you last week when [1:57:01] asked if we had a viable safety plan that I said, [1:57:05] I did not have a plan that we could execute. [1:57:07] We don't have a plan at that point [1:57:09] that we were ready to move forward on. [1:57:11] So but I think that we still, if we were working on this today, [1:57:16] we would still have that level of relationship. [1:57:18] Am I confident that we can put a plan together? [1:57:23] I want to put some of this back on Beckley vid [1:57:26] because it's their plan to put together. [1:57:29] And we'll do everything that we can to assist them [1:57:33] and work with them to make it happen [1:57:34] and mitigate the issues that need to be mitigated [1:57:37] so that we can ensure our community [1:57:39] that we'll have a safe event. [1:57:41] But I think they're going to have to do [1:57:43] the majority of working work on that project. [1:57:45] And that hasn't, that, I'm not saying that they haven't made progress because they have. [1:57:50] But are they at the level that, that I'm comfortable, or are they at the level that the Sheriff Jerome County is comfortable with, that they presented a plan that we're comfortable with, not at this point? [1:58:00] So in your opinion the negotiations were moving forward and Beckley was being responsive and you were progressing without be accurate? [1:58:10] I think that's, I think that's an accurate statement. [1:58:12] You know, we're waiting, we are waiting to, [1:58:15] as I said, I talked about the remote, [1:58:17] the remote parking, Magic Valley Mall, [1:58:18] all those things. [1:58:19] Those are things that, you know, [1:58:21] we sent this information out. [1:58:23] I'm not very sure exactly when we sent it out to him, [1:58:26] but, you know, we haven't seen anything on it. [1:58:28] Right, it was incomplete at the time, [1:58:31] but you were making progress, [1:58:32] and Eglimedia had been responsive to your, [1:58:37] the things that you pointed out for them to improve, [1:58:39] and they were working on them with the acknowledgement [1:58:43] that they thought they had to April 1st. [1:58:45] And I realize you can't speak to that, [1:58:47] but you were working on that. [1:58:49] We were working on the safety plan. [1:58:52] Okay, thank you. [1:58:52] So my last comment, I really thank you Chief. [1:58:59] I really do appreciate all the public input. [1:59:01] And I really see, you know, the media comments, you know, [1:59:05] whether it's deserved or undeserved. [1:59:06] I mean, that's all public input. [1:59:08] And I truly appreciate that. [1:59:11] And I think that Ms. Ploss made a good point. [1:59:14] If the jump happens outside the city limits, [1:59:18] the city still has to deal with the issues. [1:59:22] The public safety will then be paid by the taxpayers, [1:59:25] not by Beckley Media, who he was willing to cover those costs. [1:59:30] So I was surprised by last week's decision. [1:59:35] I also agree with the gentleman that said, [1:59:36] haste makes waste. I think it was hasty. It surprised me. I'm, you know, I'm sure it surprised [1:59:43] Mr. Beckley. And I feel that we didn't give him adequate warning that there was concern [1:59:52] over a safety plan or the strategic plan or anything like that. I felt we really had an [1:59:57] obligation to allow him to address that concern before scrapping the entire project. It seems [2:00:06] like a costly decision to the city and so that that does make me sad. So I I don't [2:00:15] support moving forward with anyone else I can't imagine why any other team when we [2:00:19] said that Beckley team was was the most qualified I can't imagine why someone [2:00:25] else someone else's team would would make a difference but you know I also do want [2:00:31] to comment on the issues of of a brand you know the public input of of our brand [2:00:35] And the city does actually not have a brand statement. [2:00:40] And I appreciate the thoughts, but right now, [2:00:44] everyone has a different concept of brand. [2:00:46] It's subjective. [2:00:47] Everyone's reality is different. [2:00:50] And so I would encourage the city to go through that process. [2:00:53] And it needs to, when we do go through that process, [2:00:56] it needs to involve the public. [2:00:57] And it needs to reflect what the public thinks the city's [2:01:01] brand is and not the brand that they aspire to be. [2:01:05] but maybe what it truly is. [2:01:07] Or if it is an aspiration, it needs [2:01:11] to be what the citizens of Twin Falls aspire to be. [2:01:14] And right now it's just speculative to say this [2:01:17] or that doesn't support the brand of Twin Falls [2:01:19] because Twin Falls doesn't have a brand. [2:01:23] But I appreciate the public input tonight. [2:01:26] Thank you, Rebecca, great mining. [2:01:30] Well, I too was surprised last week that we canceled. [2:01:34] I had the April 1st date at my mine, [2:01:37] I was certainly willing to delay things last week until April 1st because I thought maybe [2:01:45] I was incorrect but I had believed in our minds that we had given you April 1st for a safety [2:01:50] plan. [2:01:51] That's why I really didn't understand the two dates and I think I probably would have [2:01:54] in retrospect I would have had the two dates be the same. [2:01:59] Because I'm, you know, be honest with you, like several other members and people who [2:02:03] contact me. I jump one way or the other. I'm not sure. Matters to me. I do want to address [2:02:10] some of the things that have been letters. I guarantee you there was never anything back [2:02:17] room conversations about any of this. Okay. And the fact that we chose Mr. Beckley, one [2:02:23] had a letter that said, well, if it was a good done deal, it was going to be our EO. If [2:02:27] it was a done deal, it was going to be our EO. Why did we select Beckley? That makes those [2:02:31] sense to me. So I want to come to the the defense of that particular thing and as far [2:02:38] as that we haven't been in cooperation with other agencies, I don't think this is certainly [2:02:46] a fallacy. Our police department has been in cooperation with the other police departments [2:02:50] and 17 other agencies. I mean we didn't convene a grouping of 40 people to try to figure out [2:02:58] to approve a lease because it's our lease, okay, [2:03:01] and so it really doesn't seem to be a reason for that. [2:03:03] It would just put a bug down until we never got it done. [2:03:06] I've been willing to give Mr. Beckley to our April 1st date [2:03:11] to come up with a plan. [2:03:17] I think we shorted him in that particular venue. [2:03:22] I too have the very dramatic concerns as a reason I asked staff [2:03:26] and they've gotten back to me this week. [2:03:28] The property 150 feet to the east of the current jump site is private property, okay? [2:03:36] And I would think with the amount of money that we were expecting from him, he could probably obtain a lease. [2:03:45] I don't know for sure, obviously I don't know those people personally. [2:03:49] He could probably obtain a lease to jump from that 150 feet away from his. [2:03:55] says, all he has to do stay back 50 feet to the canyon, [2:03:57] because that's what we have right to do for the trail. [2:04:02] I would think that that kind of money [2:04:05] with the developments that have been setting there over [2:04:07] sometime and not being completed, not selling lots. [2:04:11] A couple hundred thousand might go a long way [2:04:13] towards the least. [2:04:14] And then again, I bring me back to concerns [2:04:16] that if he can go 150 feet to the east [2:04:20] and be out of the city limits and only be dealing [2:04:22] with the county, I'm assuming there [2:04:25] still we've cooperation with our police department and everyone else on plans but [2:04:30] that concerns me and we would have less control and so I would like to try to [2:04:37] make this happen he's got a million dollars tied up on the other side another [2:04:41] couple hundred thousands of lease and property seems like a a small investment [2:04:45] if you're a poker player sometimes you've got to put you put some money in the [2:04:49] pot because the pot size he's already got a pretty good side-pipe pot that he has [2:04:54] to deal with and so I would like to see us reconsider and give Mr. Beckley to [2:04:59] lay pro first to come up with a suitable safety plan and if at that point [2:05:06] somebody mentioned who chose I chose that group because I thought they had the best [2:05:11] safety people and I'm not sure I'm kind of comfortable with the other groups [2:05:15] safety people if they come to me with different ones I may be safer. [2:05:20] Thank you. But if we have no jump, it's good. I'm not going to be the end of the day. [2:05:24] Thank you, Mayor. Thank you, Greg. I'm going to weigh in probably more than once, but [2:05:32] first of all, I wanted to address something that was brought up before about the City Council [2:05:38] said we were going to have a jump. That's been kind of propagated that we said it's going to be a [2:05:43] jump. I'll direct you back to November 25th council meeting, meetings, minutes where [2:05:50] council person talked and made a motion to allow the Snake River jump concept in [2:05:56] the year of 2014. And that's, and it was voted seven to zero that we would have the [2:06:01] concept that we would start discussing this seriously on the concept of doing [2:06:08] that. So I didn't want to bring that to everyone's attention. As far as the [2:06:13] The biker comment, TJ, you're right, I like to ride bikes and obviously the persona of [2:06:20] a biker today is different than it was in 1974. [2:06:24] Most of us dress up for the weekend, okay? [2:06:27] And it's a different crowd. [2:06:29] When I made the biker comment, it wasn't about bikers, it was about crowds, because I've been [2:06:35] to Sturgis twice and if you've ever been to Sturgis, you know that there's a lot of folks [2:06:39] that show up on their bikes and they dress up for the weekend and have a good time. [2:06:43] And I was more concerned about the crowds and the venue and folks coming here that were [2:06:49] up the biker background and wanted to go for a nice trip and utilize our facility and this [2:06:57] or our city and this event and again it comes back to the crowds and Chief Pike touched on [2:07:03] it about what we heard coming from the Beckley folks where they said it's 40,000 and we're [2:07:09] We're going to house them all on the drone side out there in the weeds and the lava beds [2:07:15] out there. [2:07:16] And then next thing I hear, it's 75,000, next thing I hear, it's over 100,000. [2:07:22] So that started really concerning me, especially when we start talking about numbers. [2:07:26] A lot of folks don't realize the City of Twin Falls population around 50,000. [2:07:32] We have a police force, public safety force that can handle City that size. [2:07:38] that's our tax infrastructure. But most of us know that this community is not 50,000. [2:07:45] That's just folks that sleep here, have their heads hit the bed here and have their residents. [2:07:51] We swell from anywhere from 60 to 80 or more thousand a day because we are the retail hub, [2:07:58] which stretches our public safety folks. And then you put this on top of it and the influx. [2:08:05] that's what really started concerning me and trying to get across town to an [2:08:09] event that police have to be involved in. As far as the location of this, I had [2:08:16] couple concerns. One is the fire danger on the other side of the bridge. I mean [2:08:20] they're on this side as well and in the canyon, but definitely on the other side [2:08:24] if you've ever gone out there and seen the cheatgrass and all those other [2:08:27] dynamics. When you put 40 to 80,000 people on the canyon rim, you're gonna [2:08:32] have some issues with fire. And so I was concerned about that. I was also very concerned, certainly [2:08:43] I appreciate and understand the revenue impact. This can bring revenue to our community and [2:08:48] we all want that. I want folks in our community to make as much money as they can. We live [2:08:53] in a free market society and I want us to enjoy that. But the flip side of that, we heard [2:08:59] testimony regarding the the loss of revenue as well from this impact people [2:09:05] parking and parking lots not being able to go to retail establishments those those [2:09:10] types of places so it's in that really and it comes back to the numbers if this [2:09:17] was a more manageable number that our safe public safety folks said we can [2:09:21] manage with our partners with the idle state police that drone county drone city [2:09:26] Jerome, our Twin Falls County and all the other folks, then that makes sense to me. [2:09:32] Probably one of the outlying things that really affected me on this was [2:09:37] protecting those residences around the jump site itself. [2:09:41] Folks have put their life savings into where they live, and for them to be threatened by this influx [2:09:49] concerned me quite a bit. [2:09:51] So to try to advance this conversation, we've had some of that up here. [2:09:55] here. I'm not going to say we haven't, but I would like to hear from the rest of the council [2:10:00] about what direction we maybe should go. I mean, are we talking about no jump at all? Are we talking [2:10:06] about renegotiating with Beckley? Are we talking about moving to number two? And frankly, if we are [2:10:14] talking anything about moving forward with the jumper, I'm not all that interested in doing it this [2:10:19] here, frankly, because we already have another jump. [2:10:23] And to cloud the water with that other jump, [2:10:26] and I don't think it would be of a good direction for us. [2:10:30] So I'll stop my comments. [2:10:33] Turn it over to Shumberger. [2:10:38] I'll actually answer your question instead [2:10:40] of just spout some more information. [2:10:43] So following our meeting on December 23, [2:10:49] There was a memo sent from Travis's office to the Beckley team, [2:10:54] and there's a paragraph that talks about public safety. [2:10:57] As you know, this is an incredibly important item [2:11:00] for the members of the City Council [2:11:01] and the members of the Twin Falls community. [2:11:03] The members of the City Council reiterated the importance [2:11:06] of including a detailed public safety plan [2:11:09] and transportation plan as part of the overall agreement. [2:11:13] At this point, I do not believe the City Council [2:11:15] will approve any agreement that does not have [2:11:17] detailed public safety plan. As you are aware we have need to present the entire [2:11:21] plan to the council not later than January 27th so they can take action by the [2:11:27] February 3rd deadline. I really believe this item needs to be considered a [2:11:31] critical priority by your team. As Chief Pike, Captain Barnhart and I have [2:11:35] shared we're happy to assist you and the members of your team in this process as [2:11:38] you build a plan that meets the needs of the council and the community. So to me [2:11:43] that said January 27th February 3rd not April 1st. We all received a copy of this. [2:11:51] Let's copy to the council as a courtesy as a communication of them. I think it's [2:11:56] very difficult for us to sit here and say we always thought it was April 1st [2:12:00] because it wasn't. There was an expectation set out from the beginning that [2:12:05] those documents be included as part of the plan. So with that I would agree with [2:12:10] Councilman Talkington's comment that we made took a position also at a meeting to say if [2:12:18] we didn't have the things that we needed by this date, so why we went through the process [2:12:23] of ranking the applicants, I would go along with Chris to move to REO's application who [2:12:32] actually does have an event planning and safety group that has experience doing these exact [2:12:39] kinds of open space activities in downtown Manhattan and the San Francisco Pier and in [2:12:47] all kinds of places where you are not confined to a campground or within an arena, they're [2:12:55] used to this kind of stuff. [2:12:56] And they presented that in the information, they presented to us and it's been a struggle [2:13:01] to talk about qualifications. [2:13:03] So again, the Beckley team didn't meet our expectations and I think if we're going to follow through with what we said we were going to do, I would support that. [2:13:14] Thank you, Sean. [2:13:22] Jim Munn. [2:13:23] Thank you. [2:13:24] I just want to talk a little bit more about the public safety issues. [2:13:28] And Chief, I may summon you up to the front here in a moment. [2:13:35] But a couple of things that really concern me is that let's pretend for a minute that it is April 1st. [2:13:42] Let's talk about that. [2:13:44] Just having worked in this environment for so long, you threw out some red flags to me [2:13:52] as a law enforcement professional that really, really concerned me. [2:13:56] And a couple of those, you might as well come up here, Brian, they really, really concerned [2:14:04] me. [2:14:05] And that was, the first red flag, and I know you and I had some discussions about this because [2:14:12] are just colleagues, but when you, is it a fact that you had to encourage them to, they're [2:14:20] safety team to come out here and actually get on the ground and look around in lieu [2:14:25] of them trying to put together some sort of a safety analysis based on Google Maps? [2:14:33] That's true. [2:14:34] Captain Barnhart had that discussion with the Bechlin Media and this team. [2:14:37] And basically said you got to come out, you can't do this from Google Maps guys, you got [2:14:40] to come out here. [2:14:41] you need to be on the ground, you need to take a look at what, you know, when you're looking [2:14:47] at a map, it's one thing, when you're out staying on the rim, it's another, it's one thing. [2:14:51] It just seems to me, just being a law enforcement officer forever, that's a no brainer. You wouldn't [2:14:56] even consider going on to Google Maps. You would come out here and talk to the police and actually [2:15:00] get on, so it's a red flag for me, anyway. During the course of your discussions, you indicated [2:15:08] that you're getting all sorts of information that is conflicting in regards to the amount [2:15:18] of people who might be in attendance. [2:15:20] You indicated to us that one was $40,000. [2:15:24] There was a website that hundreds of thousands or 75 to 100,000. [2:15:29] This was all documented on websites, correct? [2:15:32] I don't know about the websites. [2:15:33] I know that on Bechley's website you can go to tonight and you'll find that there is [2:15:38] Inviting everyone to join the hundreds of thousands of people. I was also present when he was here in the counseling talked about 40,000 [2:15:44] I've worked with his event planning team when they said 75 to a hundred thousand and I think you're right those numbers [2:15:50] They're vastly different and if you're using any standards set by [2:15:54] FEMA set standards for large crowd gatherings [2:15:57] If they're family events, it's one to a thousand if they're sporting events. It's usually two officers or security personnel per thousand [2:16:03] Those numbers, you know, that would differ from 80 to 400 people depending on the size [2:16:10] of the crowd and what we would need. [2:16:12] And so, you know, the old adage at all roads lead to the Appian Way, don't you need to at [2:16:15] least start with some reasonable anticipated number? [2:16:20] You would think that somebody who was managing major events like this would have some idea [2:16:27] of based on what they were going to do and how they were going to manage the process, [2:16:31] is their plan to have some fairly accurate number of people that they were anticipating [2:16:36] being there. [2:16:37] Is that a good experience statement? [2:16:39] I think it's a fair statement, but I think this event is so dynamic that I think it was [2:16:44] challenging to them too. [2:16:46] Okay. [2:16:47] Because it was an open venue, there's no set number of tickets that they would have for [2:16:52] so. [2:16:53] Let me examine you further. [2:16:56] pretend for a moment that it was a hundred thousand people that would be involved and [2:17:04] Sheriff McFall would have between, you know, and I know just from a fact that we have a [2:17:08] very good working relationship with these guys. [2:17:10] I mean, it's very, very close knit group and we communicate. [2:17:15] Given our influx and I think that Mayor Hall talked a little bit about this, we understand [2:17:19] that we have a community of 45,000, but we did studies many moons ago that indicate during [2:17:24] any business day, particularly on weekends, that we have influx populations during the day, [2:17:28] And maybe even more on weekends of up to 20,000 people. [2:17:32] So you're asked to police a community that you're not funded to. [2:17:35] So you have that influx population you have to police also, every day. [2:17:39] So we're asking you to do that. [2:17:42] Then we're going to throw this on top of you. [2:17:45] What would you do? [2:17:50] You're going to ask me a tough question. [2:17:52] Remember? [2:17:53] No, let me give you a little history on what this would look like for us. [2:17:58] Because I think it's important to understand, do I think that we could have an event like [2:18:02] this. And I thought a lot about it, obviously. And I think that we probably could. But I think [2:18:08] that there's some components that have to take place. We need the time. There has to be [2:18:13] a time. So we're talking probably 12 to 18 months in preparation. There needs to be [2:18:17] memorandum of understandings. There needs to be a multi-jurisdictional approach to it, [2:18:21] because quite frankly, we can't have Western days without help. We don't have the personnel [2:18:29] to even staff our own annual western days parade [2:18:32] without the help of other agencies that come in [2:18:34] and help us block traffic and control traffic flow. [2:18:37] But going back to the staffing and not to bore you, [2:18:40] I know these are things that we've all done. [2:18:41] We need to get this out on the table. [2:18:43] Well, you know, just to give you an idea, [2:18:45] a lot of people don't realize this [2:18:46] because when you think of police officers, [2:18:48] you just think of the cars that you see. [2:18:49] Tonight we have seven people working [2:18:50] in the city of Twin Falls. [2:18:52] Right now there's seven people working. [2:18:53] Two supervisors, five patrol people working [2:18:56] in the city of Twin Falls, providing service [2:18:58] probably well over 60,000 people. We have a very lean department. We don't have [2:19:05] officers sitting around without jobs and assignments. We pride ourselves on that as [2:19:09] a community. We talk about that over the years as value government. We've been very [2:19:14] responsible in how we staff and what we budget for. We only ask for what we need. [2:19:18] And we've had these discussions over the years right here when we talk about [2:19:22] budgeting. So we're staffed for a population of 45,000. And if you look in [2:19:27] Idaho, Idaho generally, so departments serving their communities, staff roughly, in Idaho, [2:19:33] the average is about 1.7 officers per 1,000. And I know that there's lots of different [2:19:38] other ways to measure this, but this is the way that the crime in Idaho, the state of Idaho [2:19:42] measures this force. In Twin Falls, we have 1.6 officers per 1,000 for the 45,000 population. [2:19:50] If we swell to 60,000 in the day with the influx, and we've always used that number because [2:19:54] that's a conservative number. I don't think that anyone here would disagree that [2:19:58] in any given day we have 60,000 people in the city of Twin Falls. Our officer per [2:20:03] 1,000 ratio drops to 1.2 and in order to maintain 1.6 that service level that we [2:20:10] expect we would need 20 additional officers to go from 1.2 to 1.6. So we [2:20:17] deal with the influx population. It's always been part of what we've done and [2:20:21] And, you know, quite frankly, I'm surprised sometimes that we accomplish the things that [2:20:25] we do. [2:20:26] I think it's a real credit to the men and women that work in that department, how hard [2:20:29] they work. [2:20:31] So if we had to add another 100,000, it would simply overwhelm our resources that we have. [2:20:39] We would not be able to have an event like this without our partners, the ones that are [2:20:43] present here tonight. [2:20:44] And honestly, this is probably one of the reasons why we want a multi-jurisdictional approach [2:20:49] to anything like this is that we would have to be trying to go outside of the area and [2:20:53] find resources. [2:20:55] And that's not as easy as it sounds. [2:21:00] Sounds really easy. [2:21:01] We just go get cops from anywhere that you can find them. [2:21:04] But if Pocatello had an event and they called over and they said, chief, we need 10 officers, [2:21:09] can you spare them for the week? [2:21:11] I would be in no position to send 10 of our people over to Pocatello for a week because [2:21:16] we simply don't have that luxury. [2:21:18] 10 people are needed right here to provide safety. And that really goes back to something [2:21:23] that we've talked about over the years is that our primary responsibility, anytime that we start [2:21:28] looking at a public safety plan or any special event in our community, our primary responsibility [2:21:34] is providing public safety to our residents and the members of Twin Falls. I think it would [2:21:40] be somewhat criminal for someone that had a crisis and a need in Twin Falls to pick up [2:21:46] of the phone, dial our police department, [2:21:48] and all of our resources would be tied up somewhere else. [2:21:51] So our first priority, any time that we sit down, [2:21:54] regardless of what the special event is, [2:21:55] our first priority is to make sure [2:21:58] that we're providing the service [2:21:59] that the citizens of Twin Falls expect from us. [2:22:03] And then we build upon that plan. [2:22:07] Also, we have always experienced, [2:22:09] we have for some time a systemic problem [2:22:11] with retention of officers. [2:22:13] And I would like to know, right now as we sit here, [2:22:19] how many police officers down are we? [2:22:22] We could hire right now six police officers. [2:22:25] So during the course of the, so if you were able. [2:22:27] That includes officers that we added in our October budget. [2:22:30] OK, so we're down two right now just out of our order. [2:22:35] So that's not good. [2:22:37] So for you to get them hired and fully prepared [2:22:42] to work the street from today. [2:22:44] How long will that take you to get? [2:22:46] Let's take the four officers out. [2:22:48] You're down too. [2:22:50] How long will it take you if we were able to hire today [2:22:52] to get those two people ready to go on the street? [2:22:56] It takes 26 to 30 weeks to, [2:22:59] depending on the, sometimes we're fortunate enough [2:23:02] to get them out of the CSI law enforcement program [2:23:05] which shaves off 10 weeks. [2:23:07] Sometimes we're not, if they have to go to post, [2:23:09] you're looking at 26 to 30 weeks before they're in the car by themselves providing service [2:23:16] to the community. [2:23:17] Okay, so we're going to be barely meeting that deadline just to get up to fully staffed [2:23:21] at the time this event would take place. [2:23:23] Is that correct? [2:23:24] That's correct. [2:23:25] Okay. [2:23:26] That's a concern to me. [2:23:27] That's a red flag by the way. [2:23:29] I'm just trying to gather my thoughts here. [2:23:36] Mayor, try not to get too much time. [2:23:40] Brian has excreted this kind of discussion before in the past, you're going to be assured. [2:23:49] Oh, yeah, put me on the two minutes for a timer. [2:23:55] So Brian, basically, what we're talking about here is that April 1st, in my opinion, and [2:24:05] I'd like to have your comments on this, even if we could they have put together, this is [2:24:11] asking you to speculate a bit, but could they have really put together a solid plan for you [2:24:15] based on influx population concerns, based on retention of officer concerns, based on [2:24:21] no clear number concerns, by April 1st, given the fact that you were having difficulties [2:24:29] chunking information out of them in the first place? [2:24:32] In all fairness it would be impossible to really answer that. I would have my doubts, you know, overall [2:24:39] Okay, if they could do this and I would too and like I said all along [2:24:43] I think it's important to recognize, you know, we do this on a regular basis. So working with working with Beckley Media [2:24:50] I have like I said, I have a good working relationship with them. I could call them up right now [2:24:55] We could probably start working through some of these issues. I guess the question is [2:24:57] Is that something that you want us to do? [2:25:00] We can put a safety plan together. [2:25:03] But the fact has always been we've put this on the promoter, [2:25:07] on the event organizer, to at least give us something [2:25:10] to start with. [2:25:11] So I have tried to remain optimistic, [2:25:14] and like I said, we have a good working relationship. [2:25:17] Could they come up with a comprehensive plan by April 1st, [2:25:20] they could. [2:25:21] Do I think it would happen? [2:25:23] I have my concerns over that. [2:25:24] And part of that would be adding a multi-jurisdictional approach. [2:25:29] Because I think it's very important if you're Sheriff [2:25:32] McFall, you're certainly going to want the same attention [2:25:35] that we would receive. [2:25:37] And I think we're receiving a little more attention [2:25:40] because of the least document and agreement. [2:25:43] So when we met as a group, we thought [2:25:45] it was really important that Jerome County would privy [2:25:50] to the information that we had, and we'd be privy [2:25:52] their information and we could sit down together as partners with all of our [2:25:57] law enforcement partners and make the best decision that we could for this [2:26:01] community. One last question and I'll yield. Also during the course of this [2:26:07] this window of time which this is going to happen we have the one on the east [2:26:10] side of the bridge we have we what we did have the Ed Beckley we also flung into [2:26:15] the Twin Falls County Fairtime which takes a tremendous amount of resources [2:26:18] from the sheriff. During your discussions with other law enforcement executives, was that [2:26:24] a factor in causing some concern amongst the commanders? [2:26:29] Sure, absolutely was. Sheriff Carter is not here tonight. However, we're all aware of [2:26:37] this. So let's look at the chronology of the Penn State place during this time period. [2:26:42] The Twin Falls County Fair. Following the fair, you would have, well, actually you'd have [2:26:47] the Scott and Scott jump, which I believe the jump is scheduled for the first of September. [2:26:55] And it's a four day, it's a four day festival, so there's a three day build up to the jump. [2:27:02] So you'd have the jump on the first, we'd have a couple days between that. [2:27:06] We would have a special event that would probably be bringing to you, and that's the bridge [2:27:10] festival on the sixth. [2:27:13] I talked to the event organizer today, they would like to have it on the sixth. [2:27:17] willing to move it if necessary, but that's the date they have it. And then, of course, [2:27:21] we would have the build up at the same time to the equity jump and the jump on the seven [2:27:25] time. The things that I worry about during that whole time is that at some point, I will [2:27:31] be meeting with my team, and at some point, the Twin Falls Police Department will be running [2:27:38] all of our personnel 24 hours a day. So we'll put everybody, put all hands on deck like [2:27:43] we do on these types of events, the difference is it's easy to do it for five or six hours [2:27:49] for Western days. It's not so easy to do it over prolonged period of time. And then [2:27:53] we worry about what happens, you know, what kind of contingents you claim. You know, if [2:27:58] we had a critical incident, and it's really like I've always shared, it's not a matter [2:28:03] of if we have a critical incident. It's when we have a critical incident. They're out [2:28:08] there, they will happen. We've dealt with them our entire career. I was talking to Captain [2:28:12] Matt Hicks who runs our tactical team and we were trying to prepare for this because normally [2:28:18] we just go back into a call back situation right. If we have a critical incident we just [2:28:22] call on the other platoon that's not working and we bring him in because we have to we make [2:28:26] a 48 hour plan. So we want to have we want to be able to control the site for 48 hours [2:28:31] we need backup we need all those contingencies but when you're running your entire department [2:28:36] 24-7 there's no one to call that's not fatigued that's not exhausted that hasn't been a work [2:28:41] And we're asking them to make life in death's use of force decision. [2:28:44] So those are things that we worry about. [2:28:45] That's why we simply cannot do this by ourselves. [2:28:48] That's why we need our law enforcement partners. [2:28:51] That's why we need a multi-jurisdictional approach. [2:28:53] We need to bring our partners together to work together on an event like this. [2:28:57] I'm not saying that we can't do an event like this. [2:28:59] And I hope that's not what everyone is hearing here. [2:29:02] I think that we can do an event like this. [2:29:04] But like I said, we need time to put it together correctly. [2:29:07] We need a multi-jurisdictional approach to cover all of our bases. [2:29:11] we're going to need strategic partnerships [2:29:13] to bring in additional resources. [2:29:15] And you indicate that might take 12 to 18 months [2:29:17] to prepare for? [2:29:18] I think that's realistic in an event like this. [2:29:20] If you're preparing the Super Bowl, you're four years out. [2:29:23] And this is like a Super Bowl, to us. [2:29:26] I've always felt, and maybe this is a little bit out of line, [2:29:29] but I always felt that the land auction, which we had no [2:29:32] control over, really started driving a timeline for us. [2:29:36] And because of that, we started this timeline [2:29:38] that I think we all feel a little pressured by. [2:29:41] And so, and maybe that the shortness of time [2:29:44] and the fact that we have deadlines [2:29:46] and we need to have these things done [2:29:48] has put additional pressure on us. [2:29:50] I know it has an law enforcement community [2:29:52] because we're wondering what time [2:29:54] we started establishing MLUs, how many resources? [2:29:57] This is one thing that we've been working on. [2:29:59] How many resources will we need? [2:30:00] How many additional officers will we need to augment [2:30:03] our own team so that we can provide basic security services [2:30:07] because I think that's extremely important. [2:30:11] I think leaving the community out of this so that we can focus our attention on the special [2:30:15] event is not what doesn't represent our mission, doesn't represent our values as an organization. [2:30:22] So that's one thing that we struggle with, how many people will be coming and trying to [2:30:25] get the handle and working with faculty media on what are you proposing so that we can start [2:30:31] making plans. [2:30:32] And I think all of our law enforcement partners feel the same way. [2:30:35] It's the unknown, we have no idea how to prepare for something when we don't know what those numbers look like. [2:30:40] Thank you, I really do appreciate your honesty and professionalism and I think that really gives us a good understanding of what we're facing here. [2:30:46] Thank you, Brian. [2:30:48] I just wanted to weigh in on another thought. [2:30:53] Last Monday, before our council meeting, we took a filter about to see the jump site. [2:30:57] And for me personally, that's the first time I have been out there. [2:31:01] And that's when my mind really started swaying about, are we making a good decision or not? [2:31:07] When I stood up on the jump site and could see the homes right there and realized what [2:31:11] close proximity they were and when I looked at our property, which is long and narrow, [2:31:17] and realized how much work it was going to take just to prepare that part of this jump, [2:31:24] that's when I really started thinking that we're trying to make something happen too [2:31:29] hard we're pushing too fast and we're putting things too far ahead and it just really hit [2:31:37] me hard that if this is something we're going to pursue we need to slow down. We need to do [2:31:43] it right and we need to take our time and make better decisions because again I felt the [2:31:48] pressure of how in the world are we going to ever get all this done by September of this [2:31:51] year and that was my first thought. I know everybody was surprised with our decision. [2:31:57] I had no idea before I went to look at that jump site last week that I didn't realize [2:32:03] all that it entailed. [2:32:05] And so to me that's what started my thinking that we're not doing this properly and we're [2:32:10] not giving it the right justice it should have. [2:32:13] And I don't think it was fair to, this is probably a bad choice of words, but string [2:32:17] Ed Beckley or Beckley Media along, if there really is no safe and good way to do it in [2:32:24] that amount of time. [2:32:25] I do want to remind us that the jump goes forward this year, you know, it's going to be costly to the city regardless and I'm fine with not having a jump, I really, it doesn't matter to me either way and I think the majority of the citizens that testified tonight [2:32:46] having a jump by really it doesn't matter to me either way and I think the majority of [2:32:50] the citizens that testified tonight communicated that they would agree with that. [2:32:56] And so, but the issues that we're talking about tonight, I mean fire issues, multi-jurisdictional [2:33:02] approaches, safety and police staffing levels aren't going to change with a different applicant. [2:33:09] So I wouldn't support moving on to our next ranked applicant because those issues, if that's [2:33:16] that's really what's preventing this from moving forward, [2:33:19] aren't going to change regardless of the applicant. [2:33:24] I still think we were too hasty and we didn't give [2:33:26] Beckley media a chance to address these concerns [2:33:29] that are just not coming out and I do really appreciate [2:33:32] hearing from the Chief of Police. [2:33:33] That is the first time we have heard this concern [2:33:36] and this information and this is after the vote [2:33:39] of last week. [2:33:40] I mean, what I had heard, what we had all heard [2:33:42] in an open meeting and I can't speak to other conversations [2:33:46] have happened, but the only thing that I've heard has been hearing these meetings and that [2:33:49] things are progressing and that things were going forward in a positive manner and that [2:33:55] it was doable and that we were moving forward to our April deadline. [2:34:02] Also moving on to the second applicant, I mean, there's just the real practical issue [2:34:06] of they don't have a landing space. [2:34:09] they have put no financial commitment or backing into any proposal that they've made. [2:34:17] You know, and regarding the potential September 1st other jump, right now it's a hypothetical [2:34:24] jump and we shouldn't be making decisions that affect Mr. Beckley's career and life and [2:34:30] his promises that he's made based on another hypothetical event. [2:34:35] I don't think that's correct and in either way we'll be dealing with with both jumps if they happen. [2:34:41] I mean both jumps are hypothetical at this point in time. [2:34:44] So with that I would move that we allow Beckley until March 1st, the date being a compromise, [2:34:53] moving it up to March 1st, to produce a safety plan to address the issues [2:34:58] that were just now brought up by the council and that we continue negotiating with him in good faith. [2:35:05] We have a motion on the floor by Rebecca Mills-Soyka to move March 1st getting the safety plan from Beckley Media. [2:35:14] Second. [2:35:15] We have a motion on the floor by Rebecca. [2:35:19] Seconded by Greg Lanting. [2:35:21] Any discussion on that motion? [2:35:23] Great planning. [2:35:26] Chief Pike, you come back up please. [2:35:31] This last little bit has been sobering for me. [2:35:39] I may have went into moved into the no-jump category ever, [2:35:44] to be honest with you. [2:35:47] Due to your thoughts, my only concern, [2:35:50] I still have the same concern. [2:35:51] And then maybe you can talk about what your thoughts would be. [2:35:56] Should he obtain a lease to the property, just to the east of us? [2:35:59] What will our plan be then? [2:36:02] And do you feel you have a good enough working relationship [2:36:05] with them that we can still work on some sort of a, [2:36:08] As I, like Rebecca said, I think we've still got two jumps on the table here, [2:36:13] possibly for September, two hypothetical jumps, even if we, even though we've said no, [2:36:18] at this point. [2:36:19] And so what would be your thoughts about what happens if her, [2:36:26] we do not reach a degree of Mr. Beckley, he obtains the least next door. [2:36:30] It's just, we're talking hypotheticals now. [2:36:32] So what would we do then? [2:36:34] What's our plan? [2:36:34] Well, it's a great, I mean, I have not heard anything from [2:36:40] Beckley Media and their team about what they're proposing. [2:36:43] I've heard some talk that Jump will continue. [2:36:46] I have no idea what he may be planning on. [2:36:49] And I've said all along that we've had a good working relationship [2:36:53] and we have made progress. [2:36:55] The concerns I bring up tonight, I mean, these are concerns of, [2:36:58] the council, we've talked about this stuff for a number of years, [2:37:02] the staffing levels and our ability and the service level that we provide, I would say [2:37:09] that we would probably continue to work with Beckling Media and work with the sheriff's [2:37:12] department in the same way that they would be willing to work with us. We still know that [2:37:18] regardless that potential, probably the largest area of impact would be sheriff midfall in [2:37:24] Tron County, because that's where he has the land, that's where probably the majority [2:37:30] of the individuals that he brings in for the event will be there. We'll still have to deal [2:37:34] with issues and we'll still have to mitigate those concerns. [2:37:39] Thank you, Chief. Appreciate tonight, I really do. [2:37:42] Sean Barrier. [2:37:44] So with the motion to extend the deadline for submission of a safety plan, perhaps for [2:37:58] the benefit of both Peclet Media and the rest of us, should we define that on the front [2:38:03] because I don't want to have this debate again on March 1st of what was or wasn't a safety plan. [2:38:11] Are you making an amendment? [2:38:12] No, I'm asking you the question if that's what you meant by a safety plan. [2:38:18] You're asking clarification questions to the maker of the motion? [2:38:21] Okay. [2:38:22] I think that it would be defined by our discussion tonight, everything that Chief of Police said, [2:38:30] including, and even if he didn't mention it, all of his concerns that he considers is incomplete in the safety plan. [2:38:38] We have not seen a safety plan, and so it would be up to the, obviously, the chief of police to decide which aspects of the safety plan need to be presented. [2:38:47] But the motion was for a complete safety plan. [2:38:50] But, you know, I'm open to amendments, I mean, if we need to amend the motion to be more specific, we can do that. [2:39:02] I can't vote for it simply because the chief may submit a plan to as the council has to buy off on it [2:39:09] Take the heat for it. It's our baby [2:39:12] And I've also been kind of concerned hearing the making of the motion by Rebecca who was saying that [2:39:19] This is something that can't be done. We need to step back and take a long-term plan [2:39:24] Approach to the thing and yet now we're telling backly to come back in less than a month. It doesn't make sense [2:39:29] I see no further lights. Sharon Barrieger. No. Chris Hockington. No. Greg Lanting. [2:39:50] Yes. Don Hall. No. Rebecca Mills-Soyka. Yes. Suzanne Hawkins. No. Jim Mann. No. [2:40:05] Motion fails two to five. Jim Mann. Mayor I would move to make a motion to not allow [2:40:15] any special event on the evil can evil jump side for a period of one year [2:40:20] effective February 10th 2014 which time we will again entertain special event [2:40:26] applications pursuant to city code [2:40:30] motion on floor by Greg by Jim on seconded by Greg Lanting anything further on [2:40:36] that motion council Sharon Rokov please Chris Tockington no Greg Lanting yes [2:40:52] Don Hall yes Rebecca Mills like uh, no [2:40:59] Zann Hawkins yes Jim man. Yes [2:41:05] Sean Barrieger no motion passes four to three [2:41:14] I think we're done with this item tonight [2:41:17] Well confused ladies and gentlemen. I know we have a couple public here hearings next if you would be patient with us [2:41:24] Mr. Ruby. I'm sorry [2:41:26] But we will reconvene at 10 to 8. [2:41:31] We aren't on recess. [2:41:39] Good for you, Jim. [2:41:40] Don't agree with it, but at least it's resolved one way or the other. [2:41:45] We tried. [2:41:47] I would like to reconvene a meeting of the Twin Falls City Council. [2:41:54] February 10th, it is about two minutes later than I thought it was going to be, so it's [2:41:59] about eight minutes to eight. [2:42:02] So we're moving on beyond the next item is public input [2:42:06] and or items from city manager, city council. [2:42:08] I'd like to postpone that and go right into the public hearing [2:42:11] section. [2:42:12] And the first public hearing is public hearing for a public [2:42:17] hearing for a zoning district change and zoning map amendment [2:42:21] from R4 to Rb for a single lot located at the northwest corner [2:42:27] of Filer Avenue and Adams Street. [2:42:30] And we will have Jonathan Spemma making the presentation [2:42:33] for the next two items from council. [2:42:38] But we will have Gerald Martins making the presentation [2:42:42] for the applicant. [2:42:44] Welcome, Gerald. [2:42:51] Thank you, well, they're looking for the pointer. [2:42:52] My name is Gerald, for the record, [2:42:54] my name is Gerald Martins. [2:42:55] I'm here this evening representing the owner [2:42:59] and the user of this piece of property. [2:43:06] Okay, this is the intersection of Filer and Washington Street. [2:43:12] A couple of three years ago, I moved my EHM engineers testing laboratory into this building. [2:43:21] For those of you that remember that building sat there and [2:43:23] just repaired from many, many years, I went in and attempted to make some use and [2:43:30] start paying some real taxes on that property. [2:43:32] The owner of that building, and I have entered into an agreement for me to purchase that building, and the two adjacent lots, the most adjacent to it is owned C1, and then this lot is zoned R4. [2:43:52] It's my intent to expand my quality control services by building a 3,500 foot, here again are the lots, the building that sits on this lot, this lot is on C1 and this lot is R4. [2:44:10] It's my intent to build an approximately 3,500 square foot building on the two lots. [2:44:15] I cannot attach it my new building to the existing building because there's a high [2:44:23] voltage power line that runs down what would have been [2:44:26] This line on back behind so I have to I can't attach the buildings because I can't build in the easement [2:44:35] So I would wish to build approximately 3500 square foot building at this location and [2:44:41] And so we're here this evening requesting an RB zoning, [2:44:46] which is compliance with your comprehensive plan [2:44:53] to allow a building that would consist of an expansion, [2:44:58] my testing lab, some additional space that I would attempt [2:45:01] to lease until I needed it. [2:45:05] Most of it would be used for inside parking of vehicles [2:45:08] and testing activities. [2:45:11] All testing activities will occur inside the building. [2:45:16] It's concrete, aggregate soils, [2:45:19] for the various construction projects [2:45:20] that are done in Magic Valley. [2:45:25] We do parker vehicles inside. [2:45:28] The testing equipment is some of it's unwieldy, [2:45:32] but it's very expensive. [2:45:34] We like to park our vehicles inside at night. [2:45:37] They come in late, they go out early, so there will be some grudge spaces, there will be some [2:45:43] testing lab spaces, and then there will be some surplus space at least initially until [2:45:50] I anticipate where there are a few years we'll leave that space for continued expansion of [2:45:54] that services. [2:45:59] We have worked with staff on various alternatives on how we might situate on this lot. [2:46:09] We will continue to do that, but the first step here is moving towards the rezone of that [2:46:16] particular parcel. [2:46:20] We have Adam Street on the east, the father on the south, all access to the development [2:46:26] to the part will be off from [2:46:31] Filer. There will be a one [2:46:34] driveway into a parking area [2:46:37] off from Adam Street. We will [2:46:39] landscape both streets. We [2:46:44] will install lights in a matter [2:46:47] so that no lights spreads over [2:46:49] onto the residential areas to [2:46:51] the north and to the east. We [2:46:54] think what we're doing is [2:46:55] very compatible with what's [2:46:56] there, what's in the area. We have agreed and we'll follow the criteria that it will [2:47:03] be residential and character. It will have a pitched rough and so it'll feel like a 3,500 [2:47:10] square foot residence. We'll have porches and gables on it to give it a residential character. [2:47:16] For that, I'll be glad to answer any questions. [2:47:19] I think, Gerald, we have a couple of lights if you want to hang loose, hang on just for a minute. [2:47:25] We'll back to middle-cycle. [2:47:26] Thank you, Mayor. Thank you, Mr. Martins. [2:47:28] I have a question. In the testimony at the P&Z hearing, there were some concern over the noise of the testing facility, [2:47:35] and so your plan is to put that building. [2:47:39] It will probably be closest to that 525 Adams residential, and I don't know if that was the neighbor. [2:47:44] One of the neighbors asked, you know, will the noise increase? [2:47:47] of becoming closer to my house. [2:47:50] So I was just wondering if you could tell us your thoughts [2:47:53] on that and maybe you talk about ways you might mitigate [2:47:55] the any noises or issues. [2:47:57] Okay, well, after that hearing, I met with the party that brought [2:48:04] that issue up and what we found out the noise was, was we had a [2:48:12] container outside the building and our testing personnel, [2:48:15] when they walked out the door with a broken concrete cylinder, [2:48:18] They threw it in the steel bin and it made a lot of noise and [2:48:22] That's all chamber [2:48:23] so [2:48:25] The good news is in that response to that the testing lab will be at this end of the building [2:48:30] They'll be further building here with certain walls all the activities will stay inside [2:48:36] the the [2:48:37] Refused bin will be inside and it will be then [2:48:41] Carted out, so it should be quieter [2:48:43] better. The noise source will be moving slightly closer to the residents, but there will be [2:48:50] building walls between the activity and the neighbors. [2:48:57] Any noise canceling insulation or that sort of thing or just a regular building? [2:49:02] Just a regular building insulated walls. Right now it's outside, thrown in a metal [2:49:06] of the officer, we'll assure that that doesn't happen and right now that activity and in [2:49:17] the future that activity will continue to occur on property that zone C1. It's not that which [2:49:24] is the area adjacent to the building but that's not the point. The point is we're sensitive [2:49:29] to the noise and I do believe she did say in the last meeting that she went over and talked [2:49:35] to our people once and the noise was discontinued. [2:49:38] But that was the first I'd heard of it [2:49:41] and I will be responsive to her concerns [2:49:44] and the other neighbors' concerns. [2:49:46] Good, well thank you, I appreciate that. [2:49:48] One other quick question you mentioned [2:49:50] that you'll lease some retail space, [2:49:53] you know, and in the CB zone, it allows that light retail. [2:49:56] We're currently updating our parking codes [2:49:59] because we're realizing that we're somewhat under parked [2:50:02] in those areas, you know, kind of a coffee shop [2:50:04] or a yogurt shop, that sort of a thing, higher traffic, [2:50:07] but it's a smaller building. [2:50:09] Do you envision any on-street parking [2:50:11] that might disrupt the neighbors around there? [2:50:14] We intend to provide more than adequate off-street parking [2:50:17] for the project. [2:50:18] In fact, we will meet all of the codes for off-street parking. [2:50:22] And definitely would preclude and work [2:50:28] with the city on pre-cluting any on-street parking [2:50:31] on Adams Street. [2:50:33] Thank you. [2:50:35] Thank you, Mayor. [2:50:38] Gerald, we usually have some sort of requirements [2:50:41] and Mitch can probably answer this as well, [2:50:43] but what kind of fencing plans do you have [2:50:45] to easily require some sort of fencing [2:50:48] between commercial and residential? [2:50:50] Yeah, we intend to put in screening fence [2:50:53] along the common line. [2:50:55] Appreciate that. [2:50:56] That was my question. Thank you. [2:50:58] Gerald, I don't see any other questions right now. [2:51:00] They might come back up, so I will turn over to staff report. [2:51:03] report, Jonathan Spinnlow. Welcome, Jonathan. [2:51:05] Mayor Hall and council members. [2:51:07] First off, the reason why we're not seeing a lot [2:51:09] of this other stuff you're asking about, [2:51:10] the rezone is what we're talking about today. [2:51:13] As far as any of the site improvements, [2:51:15] all that kind of stuff will come up with the building permit. [2:51:18] It will have to follow current city code [2:51:20] as far as the RV residential business, [2:51:23] which is what they're asking for. [2:51:25] That's why you're not seeing any of these drawings, [2:51:26] any of the elevations or any type of that kind of stuff. [2:51:30] Tonight's just about the zoning [2:51:32] and whether or not it complies with the comprehensive plan. [2:51:35] First off, the history, short and sweet in a way. [2:51:39] We don't know of any building that's been built [2:51:41] on this particular lot. [2:51:43] It has been rezoned from R4 to C1 back to R4. [2:51:47] There was a special use permit that was put on it in 99. [2:51:50] I believe it was for a used car lot that never happened. [2:51:55] After that didn't happen, we switched it back from C1 to R4. [2:51:58] So we down zoned it. [2:52:00] The comprehensive plan update happened in 2009 and then that included the residential business [2:52:07] in the comprehensive plan, the map here. [2:52:15] January 3rd of 2011, Council adopted a residential business zoning district, so it is an official [2:52:20] zoning district of the city. [2:52:23] That's what Gerald is asking to have this re-zone for. [2:52:26] As you can see, the lot is completely, and this is taken from the comprehensive plan and [2:52:30] in that residential business zoning district. [2:52:35] The testing laboratory, give a little more information. [2:52:37] The city actually runs a testing laboratory, [2:52:40] almost exactly simmered what Gerald has, [2:52:42] and it's housed right over here in this building. [2:52:44] So the activities that we do right over here, [2:52:47] similar to what Gerald is going to be doing in this building. [2:52:49] So those uses are pretty much the same. [2:52:53] Parks was undeveloped, I'm going to read a little bit [2:52:56] of a section of our residential business district. [2:52:59] It was adopted to allow low-scale, low-intensity commercial and business operations to be developed as part of infill projects. [2:53:07] Comprehensive plan and future land use plan. [2:53:10] Map, designate this particular area as appropriate for residential business development. [2:53:14] It fronts on Adams and Filer, as he said. [2:53:16] Filer being a more major, thoroughfare, not as big as Washington. [2:53:20] Deathland, Jordan Adams, with a lot of traffic on it. [2:53:23] So a small-scale commercial business would fit okay in this neighborhood. [2:53:28] We've got a couple of residences, there's one across the street, one to the north. [2:53:32] This is an empty lot, the service is the church over here, and everything to the west is Gerald's [2:53:39] lab as well as I think it's another commercial staffing job service. [2:53:45] So as far as a fit in the neighborhood, the project will comply with city code, and we [2:53:51] feel like it could be a good fit depending on what Gerald has, but it will follow the code [2:53:55] as it's written when he applies for the billing permit. [2:53:59] The Planning and Zoning Commission, when their review, [2:54:03] they are tasked with determining two things, [2:54:08] determine whether the request is in conformance [2:54:10] with the comprehensive plan to evaluate the request [2:54:13] to determine the extent and nature of the amendment requested. [2:54:16] On January 14th, 2014, the Planning and Zoning Commission [2:54:20] evaluated the request as presented and unanimously determined [2:54:23] the extent and nature of the amendment being requested [2:54:25] was in conformance with comprehensive plan. [2:54:28] The commission unanimously recommended the city council [2:54:30] grant this request as presented. [2:54:33] Thank you. [2:54:34] Jonathan, are there any special recommendations, [2:54:42] amendments, anything from? [2:54:44] They did not, they're pretty much recommending [2:54:46] exactly what the comprehensive plan says [2:54:48] is allowed or should be allowed in that area. [2:54:51] I'm not asking for any different zoning district. [2:54:53] There was no special recommendations. [2:54:55] The other question I was gonna have, [2:54:56] because you mentioned it that we run a lot [2:54:58] very similar to this, actually it's in this building, right? [2:55:00] Yes, it's right. [2:55:01] Right behind this. [2:55:02] Two doors right there. [2:55:03] And are you aware of any neighborhood complaints because of noise being produced within our [2:55:07] lab? [2:55:08] Anything like that? [2:55:09] I'm not aware. [2:55:10] Mitch, maybe you're aware? [2:55:12] But I'm not aware of it. [2:55:14] I'm seeing heads shake now. [2:55:17] Very good. [2:55:18] Chris talking. [2:55:19] So for tonight we would just either yay or nay on the zoning change and then an ordinance [2:55:25] comes back to us later. [2:55:26] Great. [2:55:27] Okay. [2:55:30] questions. I'll open it up to public comment. We'll open it up for public input. If there's [2:55:40] anyone wishing to testify on this item, please come forward. I don't see anyone on this sheet. [2:55:47] If you could state your name and your address, sir, and then we're going to give you about [2:55:50] two minutes. No problem. [2:55:52] Dr. Schienfeld, 181-filer, Mr. Markle's on his project. I don't have a complaint over [2:55:58] his project. His project has so stated, I just have a complaint with the way this is [2:56:03] someone here to begin with. I think you see one thing you go to R4, commercial [2:56:07] needs residential. I think that's a, when the city comprehensively rezoned this, I'm [2:56:12] from Denver. This would never fly there. And we have Enfield, Law Enfield, urban [2:56:17] projects. But anyway, I have nothing to use his project. I'm just saying that C1, [2:56:22] the H-R4 is ludicrous. That's too high a density. There's too much density in [2:56:26] and here now we have part of our [2:56:28] through this area, which I think is wrong. [2:56:30] That's all I had to say. Thank you. [2:56:32] Sir, could you repeat your last name one more time for me? [2:56:34] Shane film, SHAN, FELT, 181-Finer. [2:56:37] Thank you very much. [2:56:40] Is there anyone else from the public that would like to testify to see me on this item? [2:56:44] Seeing none, I will close the public testimony and turn it over to Council for deliberations. [2:56:51] Chris, talk you. [2:56:52] I would move to authorize the zoning district change and the zoning amendment from R4 [2:56:57] R.B. on a single lot located at the northwest corner of Filer Avenue and Adams Street. [2:57:04] Second. [2:57:05] We have a motion on floor, and Chris Dognitz, seconded by Sean Barrigar. [2:57:10] I see a light on Rebecca Milsoy. [2:57:12] Thank you, Mayor. [2:57:16] Just a comment, I appreciate the public input. [2:57:18] I think that that was my only concern. [2:57:20] As you can see when you're looking at the zoning vicinity map, can you put that up there? [2:57:32] You can see that the subject property is actually surrounded by R4 and that C1 really does start [2:57:38] to encroach on the R4 and I appreciate the Planner Spendlove's comments on what we are [2:57:43] addressing tonight but the Land Use Planning Act actually asks us to consider the impact [2:57:49] on neighborhoods and to not zone when it encroaches on residential, or residential when business [2:57:58] is encroaching upon residential. [2:58:02] So we must determine that and it seems that since the neighbors have no objection to this [2:58:08] particular plan, I think I can go ahead and support the rezoning although I would like [2:58:15] to acknowledge that it does appear to start to encroach and I think that's also in the [2:58:20] report from P&Z that is a concern. [2:58:25] But I appreciate that this is an infill project and [2:58:29] as long as things are developed as they have been presented tonight, I think we won't have a problem. [2:58:36] Greg Lanning, I will be supporting this change. [2:58:43] Especially since the blot in question was actually C1 at one point and I'd revert it back to R4 because the use in question did not happen. [2:58:51] I'm glad to see that it's residential business, Gerald. [2:58:54] I think that puts the proper limit on it, [2:58:56] and I'm almost wishing that the other two lots [2:58:59] that you control were being [2:59:01] rezoned to residential business as well, [2:59:03] but I will still be in support of this [2:59:05] because I think that it is a good use [2:59:08] because you're basically on a corner [2:59:10] of two of our major arterials. [2:59:11] And if you look up and down filer in that area, [2:59:15] there's already some other commercial. [2:59:18] So you see one type activities that are going on [2:59:21] or used to go on or used to be an auto shop [2:59:23] and a few things like that along there. [2:59:25] So this will be a good infill project [2:59:29] on a long neglected lot. [2:59:31] That's true. [2:59:32] Thank you, Greg. [2:59:33] Chris talking to you. [2:59:34] I actually think, sir, the reason I vote for it [2:59:37] is I actually think this provides a transitional buffer [2:59:40] that will be more protective of the residents in that area [2:59:44] including yourself, had the request been for a rezone to a C1. [2:59:48] I wouldn't be supportive. [2:59:50] I think this is, Craig said, a good infill. [2:59:53] It's going to provide some improvements to your area [2:59:56] that I think will be beneficial. [3:00:00] And it's just perfect so far as a transition zone. [3:00:04] I don't think if I read the background, [3:00:06] now Jonathan and we have much experience with the RB, do we? [3:00:09] of actual utilization of that for building. [3:00:14] This is the first time anything's been rezoned to our meeting. [3:00:16] Yeah, I'm not used to it. [3:00:20] I just wanted to state I'm in support of this motion as well. [3:00:22] Gerald, I appreciate what you did with that old neglected [3:00:25] building that was there for years and years. [3:00:27] And moving into this area with this application [3:00:33] makes sense to me. [3:00:34] So with that, Sharon, roll call vote, please. [3:00:41] Yes. [3:00:45] Don Hall. [3:00:45] Yes, Rebecca Mills-Soyka. [3:00:48] Yes. [3:00:49] Suzanne Hawkins. [3:00:50] Yes. [3:00:51] Jim Mann. [3:00:52] Yes. [3:00:53] Sean Beriker. [3:00:54] Yes. [3:00:55] Chris Tarkin. [3:00:56] Yes. [3:00:57] Motion passes 7-0. [3:00:58] Thank you, Gerald. [3:00:59] Moving on to the next item, another public hearing [3:01:02] for a zoning district change and zoning map amendment [3:01:05] from R4 to R4 Pro for property located at 840 Addison [3:01:11] Avenue. [3:01:12] And I believe Tom Ruby is the applicant [3:01:15] and he'll be making the first presentation. [3:01:19] 15 minutes, Tom, so welcome. [3:01:24] I bet it's not. [3:01:26] I think we've spent enough time already. [3:01:28] Good evening, Mayor and Council, thank you for your time. [3:01:32] I presume all of you are familiar with the location [3:01:35] and question, it's somewhat of a landmark building [3:01:39] just off of Blue Lakes on Addison Avenue. [3:01:43] We bought this property last fall as a commercial property [3:01:48] represented and listed as a commercial property [3:01:50] by the seller and seller's agent. [3:01:53] By no means that it's intended to be applied upon them. [3:01:56] They were as ignorant of this issue as everybody else was. [3:02:01] The issue really never cropped up until I went to get a [3:02:05] commercial building permit and planning and zoning discovered [3:02:09] that in spite of operation as a commercial structure for over 40 years, it is zoned residential. [3:02:16] It is a little island of R4, kind of surrounded by R4-PRO. [3:02:23] I would like to ask that the council accept the proposal to change the zoning to R4-PRO. [3:02:33] is in harmony with the comprehensive plan and it is in harmony with surrounding properties. [3:02:39] Thank you, sir. Do we have any questions? Doesn't look like it. We'll move to a staff report. [3:02:47] Jonathan, welcome again. Thank you, Mayor and Council members. So in the history section, [3:02:53] there's a lot of history in there. I'll summarize a little bit like go over it if you guys need me [3:02:57] to. Basically what happened was during multiple times, this lot was put on different applications [3:03:02] to be changed from R4, R4 PRO when different people around them went from R4 with the professional [3:03:11] office overlay. [3:03:12] For one reason or the other, it was always pulled off of those applications. [3:03:16] It was withdrawn by the property owner, so they requested not to have the professional [3:03:21] office overlay. [3:03:22] It was allowed to commence, sorry to continue, as a retail business under a legal not conforming [3:03:30] for about 40 years. [3:03:31] I can try it on that one. [3:03:32] It was super times village. [3:03:33] I believe it would have called. [3:03:35] So it was allowed to continue to operate [3:03:37] since it had been there prior to zoning designations. [3:03:40] So my guess is they felt like they didn't need to redo it. [3:03:43] At this time when he came in for the building permit, [3:03:46] we did notice that it did not have [3:03:48] the professional office overlay. [3:03:50] There was an option to either go through [3:03:52] the special use permit process to have it continue [3:03:55] to be illegal nonconforming or to go through [3:03:57] the rezoning process to just change it, [3:03:59] of the property, BR4, PRO from now on, [3:04:03] and to be able to operate under that. [3:04:05] So that's the history in a nutshell. [3:04:08] There's various dates on there, most of them in 2000. [3:04:11] And then recently with Mr. Ruby coming in [3:04:15] for this application as well as this building permit. [3:04:17] Again, this is for a re-zone, [3:04:20] not for looking at what the property is, [3:04:22] it's just to establish whether or not they want to do it [3:04:24] as a professional office overlay. [3:04:26] It's located, primary residential area, except for things along Addison Avenue. [3:04:33] Northern part is red, shaded area is the area of the Stoker agreement, which allows for [3:04:39] residential business type things along Addison Avenue with certain development criteria. [3:04:44] Hard to tell, but there's dotted line somewhere in here for the professional office overlay. [3:04:50] At one time it did come over to Addison Street, but then the next step doesn't come over there [3:04:54] as far anymore. [3:04:55] There's also thought of this operating for 40 years as a business. [3:05:03] We feel that the way it's going to be operated and he's asking for a professional office for [3:05:07] a head therapy clinic. [3:05:09] We feel that that's a pretty good fit for the area and there's other offices, lawyers, [3:05:15] hair salons, things like that that rehabilitate old residences use those as their office. [3:05:23] It's in compliance with the Twin Falls Comprehensive Plan. [3:05:26] It's approved as R4PRO, a special use permit, [3:05:29] and building permit will be required [3:05:31] for change of use to operate professional office. [3:05:35] Development criteria such as landscaping, [3:05:37] parking, trash, and closures, all those things. [3:05:40] They'll be reviewed during the building permit process. [3:05:43] In reviewing a request for zoning discharge [3:05:47] and map amendment, the commission had two main tasks, [3:05:50] one to determine whether the request is in conformance [3:05:52] with the comprehensive plan, and two, [3:05:54] to evaluate the request to determine the extent [3:05:56] and nature of the amendment requested, conclusion, [3:06:00] January 14th, planning and zoning commission, [3:06:02] how the public hearing and evaluated the request [3:06:04] as presented, the commission unanimously determined [3:06:07] the extent and nature of the amendment being requested [3:06:09] was in conformance with the comprehensive plan. [3:06:12] The commission recommended to the city council [3:06:15] that this request be granted as presented [3:06:19] with the condition, number one, [3:06:21] subject to amendments as required by building engineering, [3:06:23] fire zoning officials to ensure compliance with all [3:06:25] applicable city code requirements and standards. [3:06:29] Thank you, that's all. [3:06:30] Great lining. [3:06:31] Jonathan, looking at the application here, [3:06:35] the property that's, you know, [3:06:38] whatever direction it is, probably southeast or Lee [3:06:41] from the street property, [3:06:42] that's a straight out office building that is zoned R4. [3:06:48] We were talking about the same thing [3:06:49] in a long time, [3:06:51] on confirming use. I'm just wishing that we would have cleaned it up at the same time here and did the same thing on this one because it's obviously not a residential use. [3:07:01] I think at a later time they came through and rezoned this to a pro so we had taken it off at one point they came back. City usually doesn't in the past we proactively went after and rezoned properties. I believe this one was taken off put back on in the meantime this property was always left off. [3:07:18] Okay, but so that is our for a pro now. I believe it is. I believe there's a line right there. Okay, because our our notes say that it is residential offers on a day's rate to the surrounding land. [3:07:32] Who says that are for on the map to. I believe it is. There is what they're talking about. Because that's a straight out office, but there's no talking about the law right here. Different law. Nothing's built on it. Oh, okay. All right. I see. There's a lot in between. [3:07:50] I can see the little dotted line there now, I think. [3:07:55] Okay. All right. Thank you. [3:07:56] That's where the lot they're talking. [3:07:57] It's a separate lot. [3:07:58] Okay. Separate what? That's why. All right. [3:08:00] It's a parking lot. [3:08:01] You can see it now. Yeah. [3:08:02] Kind of a green dotted line. Yeah. [3:08:04] That's it right there. Yeah. [3:08:05] So that's a lot that's referred to. [3:08:07] The other one's probably an R4 Pro. [3:08:09] This is R4 Pro and I think R4 Pro goes along to Shown Street, [3:08:12] which is put on. [3:08:13] All right. Thank you. [3:08:14] That was the confusion. [3:08:16] No question. Okay. [3:08:19] Okay. [3:08:20] Just look like we have any other questions, so I'll open it up to public input on this [3:08:26] item. [3:08:27] Anyone from the public wishing to come forward and give input? [3:08:33] Testimony on this item? [3:08:34] Shaking. [3:08:37] Shaking. [3:08:38] He said no. [3:08:39] So if you'll stop. [3:08:40] I'll close the public testimony portion of this item and turn it over to council deliberations. [3:08:46] Great planning. [3:08:47] I move approval of a zoning district change and zoning map amendment from R4 to R4 [3:08:52] property located at 840 Addison Avenue to [3:08:56] and to involve that as well as the amendments as noted. [3:09:04] Second. [3:09:05] Go ahead. [3:09:06] We have a motion on the floor by Greg 19 seconded by Suzanne Hawkins. [3:09:12] Anything on that motion council? [3:09:14] I see no lights. [3:09:16] Sharon will call vote please. [3:09:18] Don Hall. [3:09:19] Yes. [3:09:20] Rebecca Melsoica. [3:09:22] Yes. [3:09:23] Suzanne Hawkins. [3:09:24] Yes. [3:09:25] Jim Mann. [3:09:26] Yes. [3:09:27] Von Veriker. [3:09:28] Yes. [3:09:29] Chris talking. [3:09:30] Yes. [3:09:31] Greg Lanting. [3:09:32] Motion passes seven to zero. [3:09:35] We're going to back up and go to public input and or items from city manager, city council. [3:09:41] Is there anyone from the public that would wish to come to the council and talk about [3:09:47] something that we have not talked about tonight please? [3:09:51] I see no one coming forward, anything from our city manager. [3:09:55] Mr. Mayor, members of the council, just three quick items for you this evening. [3:10:00] First, in observation of President's Day, we will be closed next Monday. [3:10:06] Therefore, our regularly scheduled council meeting will occur on a Tuesday. [3:10:10] So it will begin Tuesday the 18th, and we did publish it that way. [3:10:15] So it is not technically a special meeting, but just so the people who are aware that we usually meet on Mondays. [3:10:20] will be meeting on Tuesday. [3:10:23] Second, on this Wednesday, we will [3:10:25] be selling our wastewater treatment plant bonds [3:10:28] through the Idaho Bond Bank through a competitive sale. [3:10:31] That should occur. [3:10:34] The sale should be completed sometime around 10 AM on Wednesday, [3:10:38] and so I will send out a report based upon the winning bid [3:10:41] and through the competitive sale process. [3:10:44] Through that competitive sale process, [3:10:47] a brokerage firm will acquire all of the bonds available, [3:10:54] and then they will go out and market and package them [3:10:57] through that process. [3:10:59] It is very similar to opening up a sealed bid, [3:11:02] like we would do for capital infrastructure. [3:11:05] The last item I had, and Leila asked me to cover this [3:11:09] in her absence, we have the Chamber of Commerce dinner, [3:11:12] typically the members of the City Council will go [3:11:15] I've been asked to get a head count so if you could share with me if you're planning on going [3:11:21] it is a week from this Friday which is the 21st of February. [3:11:26] So I'm in here going so do you need some time to get back to look at your calendar? [3:11:40] If you could send me an email and let me know so that we can make sure that we can do it. [3:11:43] And also whether we need one or two tickets and we'll obviously pay for the spouse or make [3:11:48] Yep, that's great. All right. That was all three items. [3:11:55] Okay, very good. Greg Lining. A couple of quick items again from the AC. [3:12:02] Talking about it and that's really urban real today. The urban real board did [3:12:07] approve the pocket park. The bids came in considerably under the [3:12:12] engineer's estimates need. So they went ahead and accepted both of the [3:12:16] alternates which one of the first one was to move back to pavers and the third [3:12:21] the second one was to accept their bid they're very much lower bid toward [3:12:25] maintenance for the park for the remainder of 2000 and do you remember [3:12:29] who that was? I don't skates was the winner okay other bid the so that that [3:12:37] process went for also was reported at the Urban and No Meeting today that there is [3:12:41] an urban renewal bill that was probably was introduced this afternoon for they [3:12:50] changed the urban renewal law that would allow that would if you're if you're [3:12:54] going to use any you know this is something we don't do until it falls but [3:12:58] any if you were going to use urban renewal money for a public building and [3:13:02] everyone knows going to provide more than 51% 50% or more of the structure [3:13:09] cost, then you have to go to a simple majority vote for that thing. [3:13:15] And if I have it wrong, Travis, I think he's going to upgrade me here, so I'm great, you [3:13:19] have my work. [3:13:20] It informed me how I was wrong, how's that? [3:13:24] Travis, do you plan? [3:13:25] There are some exemptions to the code as written. [3:13:30] Courthouses are allowed, I believe, public safety buildings would also continue to be allowed, [3:13:35] however, items like a city hall in which 51% of the building, [3:13:42] as a councilman landing described, would have to go to a vote. [3:13:46] But it also has a million dollar threshold. [3:13:48] So if the urban renewal agency is going to allocate more than a million dollars to [3:13:54] the project, it would require a vote of the citizens in the community. [3:13:58] Or if the cost of the project, urban renewal shares greater than 51%, [3:14:02] that would also trigger that second vote. [3:14:05] Thank you, Travis. [3:14:06] Thank you. [3:14:07] I don't know. [3:14:08] Chris, talking to. [3:14:09] I have three items too, and I'll try to make them sure. [3:14:12] First of all, I didn't quite understand on our bonds going out. [3:14:17] Do the bond houses a bit on them, did you say? [3:14:21] OK. [3:14:21] So that'll be a sealed process. [3:14:24] And would you let us know just how to carry out a city who [3:14:27] be picking up the whole package? [3:14:29] Yes, so what happens is that they buy the entire offering by the Idaho Bond Bank, [3:14:34] you'll be a single brokerage house that wins or or brokerage houses that partner. [3:14:39] So it will be a single group and we will provide the tabulated results to the members of the council once they're available. [3:14:48] I'd be curious to know who that or what that partnership is. [3:14:51] Second of all, speaking of urban renewal, we have a city downtown mall area and urban renewal [3:15:01] monies potentially targeted up to 10 million for renovation, rebuilding the water sewer lines [3:15:07] and everything. [3:15:08] We're waiting for some ballpark figures on concept costs. [3:15:14] I asked Melinda the other day if she knew the status and she didn't. [3:15:20] a little inquiry from some people. I'd sure like to have an update on that. [3:15:24] I've asked the city engineer and I've instructed her and shared with her that this is a priority [3:15:30] and she is going to make it as such. [3:15:34] Thank you. And the last item is after four and a half months of falling and jumping over [3:15:39] the canyon and promoting the thing. I think time for the council will know that we've [3:15:44] got to realize that we've got a hell of a big agenda with everything we've set out and [3:15:50] and we're behind and I was thinking, [3:15:53] Jay, this is gonna be nice and down time and quiet, [3:15:55] but we may be more busy or than ever, [3:15:59] but we've got a lot of catch-up to do. [3:16:01] We've got a lot going on. [3:16:03] I see no further lights, so Rebecca, you have radio. [3:16:08] And a couple things I just wanted to let Council know. [3:16:11] We are up for our every two-year picture. [3:16:16] We're going to go to the forts on Addison. [3:16:18] Addison, yes. [3:16:21] What's changed except we're older. [3:16:23] Older, we want to continue the photographs every two years. [3:16:28] And then the mayor's dinner is also, [3:16:30] we're trying to plan that as well. [3:16:32] So I'll keep you informed. [3:16:34] With that, are you going to be 30? [3:16:37] You said that. [3:16:38] You said that on, see, Rebecca Milsoyka just said that. [3:16:43] Close the meeting.