Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2013-12-02, recording 1 (started 17:00) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2013-12-02/ [0:01:04] I'd like to call the December 2nd, 2013 meeting and Twin Falls City Council to order. [0:01:17] Our first item is the pledge. [0:01:18] If you'd like to join us, please rise. [0:01:23] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. [0:01:46] We do have a quorum, all seven members are present. [0:01:51] Introduction of staff, at least a partial introduction of staff, [0:01:54] of C. Manager Travis Rothweiler, City Attorney of First Wonderland. [0:01:59] Community Development Director Mitchell Humboldt, and Deputy City Clerk, [0:02:02] Recurricular, Ellis Sanchez, and we'll talk about radio afterwards. [0:02:12] Travis, do we have any amendments to the agenda? [0:02:15] There are no amendments tonight. [0:02:16] All right. [0:02:17] We don't have any proclamation, so moving on to the consent calendar, Council wishes. [0:02:24] Susanne Hockens. [0:02:25] I move approval. [0:02:26] Second. [0:02:27] We move by Susanne Hockens and seconded by Don Hall as we approve the consent calendar [0:02:32] as printed. [0:02:33] Seeing no lights for the other roll call vote. [0:02:37] Yes. [0:02:39] Don Hall. [0:02:40] Yes. [0:02:41] Susanne Hockens. [0:02:42] Yes. [0:02:43] Greg Lansing. [0:02:44] Yes. [0:02:45] Jim Munn. [0:02:46] Yes. [0:02:47] Rebecca Melsweka. [0:02:48] Yes. [0:02:49] Chris Tockington. [0:02:50] motion passes seven to zero. [0:02:55] Going on, moving on items for, I'm sorry. [0:02:58] Mr. Mayor, members of the council, [0:02:59] before you start your items of consideration, [0:03:01] we'd like to do a new staff introduction really quick. [0:03:03] If that's okay, take just a couple of minutes, okay. [0:03:06] Michael Williams is going to introduce [0:03:07] Mandy Thompson, the city's new grant writer. [0:03:10] She, her first day is today. [0:03:16] You need to come up on the twos, Mandy, [0:03:17] don't be questions, so. [0:03:19] Thanks, Travis. [0:03:20] I don't know if I need to add anything to the hails here. [0:03:24] As you know, we counsel approved a landing position [0:03:28] for a grand writer for fiscal year 2014. [0:03:32] I'm pleased to introduce Mandy Thompson. [0:03:36] Well, I see a couple of them say a few words really excited [0:03:37] about having her on board, and she'll do a great job for us. [0:03:41] As well as deals were sitting up here, [0:03:43] there was a new face in the audience, [0:03:44] and there was one or two that was. [0:03:47] Mandy, tell us about yourself. [0:03:48] I'm pleased to be here. [0:03:49] I'm really excited. [0:03:50] I had a very big first day, I met about 75 people, [0:03:53] and I might remember two or three names, [0:03:55] but Mike did a great job of taking me around [0:03:58] to all the different departments [0:03:59] and giving me introductions to the various employees [0:04:03] and what their positions entail. [0:04:04] So I have a good idea of where to start this job. [0:04:07] But just a little bit about myself. [0:04:10] I'm a native Idahoan. [0:04:11] I grew up in Idaho Falls. [0:04:12] I attended the University of Idaho where I met my husband. [0:04:15] You're a native host. [0:04:16] Yeah, no family. [0:04:17] You don't find a lot of those. [0:04:19] After graduating, I worked for the State Department of Agriculture for five years. [0:04:28] During that time, my husband and I moved to Twin Falls, and we've been here for 11 years. [0:04:32] We have three sons, ages nine, seven, and three. [0:04:38] After leaving the Department of Agriculture to raise my family, I sort of stumbled on [0:04:43] grant writing and it became quite a busy little consulting job for me and I was able [0:04:50] to learn a tremendous amount about the grant writing process. I mostly worked for private [0:04:55] companies. So the grant funding available for those types of businesses is not a lot. [0:05:03] So it's really quite refreshing to work for a municipality that has a lot of options and [0:05:08] a lot of opportunities so I have a grant already do on Friday so I hit the [0:05:14] ground running. Thank you Benny we do have a couple of lights done all. First of [0:05:19] all I just wanted to welcome you aboard flying city of Twin Falls. I've been [0:05:23] affiliated with the city for a little over 20 years and been on city council [0:05:27] for eight of those years and at least the last eight we've been talking about this [0:05:31] position and I'm sure we have before that we usually just divvied it out. So we [0:05:36] We really welcome you aboard. [0:05:39] I understand grounds that I've had rid them [0:05:41] as well as maintain them and the other. [0:05:44] So I have a little bit of a concept [0:05:46] and I know that nothing's instantaneous [0:05:48] but really are anticipating your work with the city. [0:05:54] So thank you for coming aboard. [0:05:55] Thank you. [0:05:56] You're welcome. [0:05:57] Yeah, hi, welcome Eddie. [0:05:59] Following on Don's comments about how long he's worked [0:06:02] with the city, I couldn't agree at a very short time, [0:06:05] that he's learning. [0:06:07] With the sequencer and federal monies [0:06:10] and the trickle down the state, [0:06:11] that's presenting a real challenge [0:06:14] to all of the grant applicants at County State [0:06:17] and certainly City. [0:06:19] What, I know you're recognizing that challenge. [0:06:22] Do you have a strategy in mind yet [0:06:23] or do you see opportunities that you might share with us? [0:06:28] Well, I think there's actually a lot of opportunities [0:06:30] in the private sector. [0:06:31] There are a lot of companies that are willing [0:06:34] and do grant programs available to cities, [0:06:39] different types of emergency EMS, fire, police. [0:06:44] So I actually stumbled upon and was looking at one today [0:06:48] that's available through Panasonic. [0:06:51] There's a couple of, there are more on the IT side of things, [0:06:54] but I mean you just have to broaden your line of thinking [0:06:57] and you can't necessarily just rely on federal funds anymore. [0:07:01] So looking- [0:07:02] be looking for that same grant. [0:07:03] You are very correct. [0:07:05] So it's just a matter of doing the best job of putting together the best applications [0:07:11] we can and definitely honing in on what the goals of the city are and making sure that [0:07:16] whatever grants that we are going for, we send a very good chance of getting them and [0:07:21] making sure that we prioritize each of the departments and what they truly need and I [0:07:28] guess going from there. [0:07:29] I know that Travis and the city staff and survey that Council have high expectations that you're hiring means we can get the road running that you have minimal training and learning on the job you do. [0:07:40] So we have high expectations for you. [0:07:43] Thank you. [0:07:45] No pressure. [0:07:46] No, no, no. [0:07:48] Well, welcome, Mandy. [0:07:49] And I don't think we did meet you very uncomfortable. [0:07:52] That's usually our job on this workplace. [0:07:54] You were very articulate and certainly gave me confident things. [0:07:58] going to go well and Travis might have something else to add. [0:08:00] You know, just maybe a little bit about the process, which is maybe something that Mike, [0:08:03] I was hoping that Mike would have touched on, but it was something that we went forward. [0:08:07] We did a full-scale recruitment, as we typically do. [0:08:10] We received a series of qualified applicants. [0:08:14] We reviewed those. [0:08:16] The applicant pool that we received for this position was not necessarily a large applicant [0:08:21] pool, like 50, 60 applicants, but what we did was have a tremendous amount of quality. [0:08:27] And we, from that process, I believe we interviewed six individuals for the position, and it was [0:08:34] a cross-departmental functional interview process because Mandy is going to be interacting [0:08:40] with every single department that we have. [0:08:43] We wanted to make sure that we included other departments, police department, was involved [0:08:47] in that process. [0:08:48] And so we came forward, and then we went forward, we offered the position with Mandy, we completed [0:08:53] a background check, and she's here today. [0:08:56] I do have one more light don holes. [0:08:58] I was going to make a comment about Chris and I'd be primed, [0:09:02] but I'll pass and do that later. [0:09:04] Where's your office? I know there's not much room in the end left, [0:09:07] so I was just here to figure it off. [0:09:07] Apparently I got the very last free office space. [0:09:10] Is it upstairs? [0:09:11] No, I'm downstairs next to the break room. [0:09:13] Normally the mail room, [0:09:14] but it's been converted to an office. [0:09:17] Cool. Thank you for that. [0:09:19] So find us a grant to build a new city hall. [0:09:20] That would be a very good one. [0:09:22] I've had a couple of people suggest that. [0:09:24] All right, thank you, Mandy. [0:09:26] Welcome. [0:09:27] Moving on to item number one, there's an consideration, consideration of a request to use parking, reserve funds for the purchase of a code enforcement tracking and ticketing software. [0:09:38] Mitch Humble. [0:09:41] I'm going to do probably a lot of the talking up front, but I also have Sean here. [0:09:46] And we have some folks from IT who might be able to help answer some questions. [0:09:50] sometime overshot a little bit later during the presentation so we can talk about the way [0:09:55] the program has changed in the last couple years and really get at the impact that we hope [0:09:59] we're making out there, which also drives the need for the requests of the software. [0:10:05] So I guess I'll start by saying that when we go back to our citizen server that we did [0:10:13] in 18 or so months ago, one of those areas that we were identified as not really performing [0:10:19] very well and was going to meet in code enforcement and we only had a 38% response that said we [0:10:25] were doing really well or even good really in code enforcement and to us that I didn't [0:10:31] find a real opportunity for improvement and since then we've made some significant changes [0:10:36] to the program the way we're operating and I think it's we're seeing some payoff for that [0:10:42] and changes have led to some improved performance there. [0:10:49] We used to do code enforcement by kind of committee, [0:10:53] and some departments would be responsible [0:10:56] for some things and others would be responsible [0:10:58] for other things, and depending on what department you're in, [0:11:01] it might affect the priority level [0:11:04] that code enforcement had in your workflow, [0:11:07] and I think that was a big thing. [0:11:10] So one department would be a bit more proactive [0:11:14] and a bit more responsive. [0:11:16] And other departments had a lot of other things [0:11:18] on their plate, too. [0:11:19] And anyway, so one of our first changes [0:11:21] to bring it all together in Pleasant and One Department. [0:11:23] And that's now in the Planning Department. [0:11:25] It's the Division of Planning and Department [0:11:27] of Code Enforcement under Renee's direction. [0:11:29] We created the position that Sean now holds [0:11:31] with the Code Enforcement Coordinator. [0:11:33] And we've empowered Sean to kind of take that role [0:11:38] and really make the program successful. [0:11:43] And given him the authority to do those things [0:11:46] that are needed to be done to really get there. [0:11:49] And I think that's been a huge step [0:11:51] in consolidating the authority, I guess, [0:11:54] for code enforcement. [0:11:55] With that means that Sean is now doing a lot more [0:11:59] than he used to do with regards to code enforcement. [0:12:02] There's a lot of weeds and a lot of junk in the yard. [0:12:05] And now there's a bit more like signage and zoning [0:12:08] and some other things that he didn't really do a lot of before. [0:12:11] And so that's been a bit of a learning curve, [0:12:13] but I think we're making some real progress there. [0:12:17] Another thing we've done, we've given him a little bit of staff [0:12:19] to help him work through these problems [0:12:21] and with Woody transferring over from economic development [0:12:24] and taking some of those parking responsibilities with him [0:12:27] has allowed the division to really do more [0:12:30] with the people that we have and I think that Woody's a real talent [0:12:36] that was underutilized as parking enforcement only [0:12:40] and so he's able to get out there and do some more of the stuff that [0:12:43] he's really well suited for in addition to taking care of the downtown parking [0:12:48] and then we have Carolyn is down the department as well she transferred over [0:12:52] from the water department we used to have three [0:12:54] meter readers that would spend you know the bulk of their time reading meters but [0:12:59] within a couple hours a day they work on code enforcement activities and we've [0:13:03] kind of consolidated that so the meter readers are meter readers and and Carolyn's [0:13:07] code enforcement she's been out there and she really gives us the opportunity to [0:13:10] be a bit more proactive on some of the more common everyday type violations like [0:13:15] weeds and we're going to use her in a lot and water you know conservation [0:13:19] enforcement and we're able to be a bit more proactive now than we were before [0:13:23] where we were truly responding to complaints and Carolyn does respond to [0:13:28] complaints a lot as well but she's out in the field and able to catch things as [0:13:32] they're occurring and educate people and that's I think another key change is the [0:13:37] focus of code enforcement is really in education first to kind of focus. We aren't [0:13:42] driving a lot of revenue into the city with code enforcement. We're not citing [0:13:46] people and measuring tickets. We're out educating people and what the code is and [0:13:50] what I think we're doing is improving compliance rather than you know bringing [0:13:57] and the money from citations. [0:13:58] And I think that's where we want to go, in my opinion. [0:14:01] Code enforcement really needs to be about compliance [0:14:05] and this education enforcement tally, [0:14:07] I think is getting us there. [0:14:10] I attached in the staff report a series of like [0:14:14] little reports and tables and charts and things like that. [0:14:17] I'm gonna let Sean talk about those later, [0:14:19] but he really understands those way better than I do, [0:14:22] but they kind of illustrate the increase in volume [0:14:26] of activities that's been going on, which then leads [0:14:30] to the need for this tracking software. [0:14:33] Again, going back a few years, we had Lisa [0:14:37] in the planning department who was kind of given this little [0:14:41] side task of why don't you help code enforcement get [0:14:43] a handle on things. [0:14:44] And because there was nothing else around, [0:14:46] she kind of created this info path sort of tracking [0:14:50] database or a glorified spreadsheet [0:14:54] so that we can at least keep track of what we were doing. [0:14:57] It's not a great work management tool. [0:15:00] It is really a tracking tool. [0:15:02] What have you done? [0:15:04] Not what do we need to still do. [0:15:06] And we've exhausted the limits of that program [0:15:11] and its abilities for us. [0:15:13] And I would say, in fact, with the workload [0:15:15] that we've got going on now, we are spending probably [0:15:19] as much time and Sean can talk to this as well. [0:15:22] In the office reporting on what we've done, [0:15:24] as we are in the field, [0:15:26] actually doing the work that we need to be doing. [0:15:29] I think we can be a lot more efficient [0:15:31] if we're able to be in the field doing the work [0:15:34] and having the software really just kind of being a tool [0:15:36] for us to do the work and allowing us to stay in the field [0:15:39] rather than coming back in, [0:15:40] spending half of our day, [0:15:42] entering numbers and all this stuff that we've done. [0:15:45] And then having the software also remind us [0:15:47] that, hey, tomorrow you need to go back [0:15:49] and re-inspect that property, or next week, or that, right? [0:15:53] And so the increase in workload has really gotten us [0:15:55] to the point where we're not terribly efficient anymore, [0:15:59] because we're busy tracking all the stuff that we've done. [0:16:02] And I think we can get more done if we have better tracking [0:16:06] and management software. [0:16:08] And that's really, I think, a driving need for this. [0:16:13] The other thing that makes it more of an immediate need [0:16:16] is the parking side of it. [0:16:19] I kind of went into this a little bit, [0:16:21] and Sean, you'll probably remember some of this. [0:16:22] But when parking used to be at the BID, [0:16:26] the BID folks went and bought some parking stuff. [0:16:29] They had a little machine that spins out tickets, [0:16:31] and they had a computer that they loaded that software on. [0:16:35] And that computer found its way to the Chamber of Commerce [0:16:38] when the chamber took it over. [0:16:39] And then when the city took it over from the chamber, [0:16:42] that computer found its way to Woody's desk. [0:16:44] And there's no software, disks, or whatever, attached to this anywhere. [0:16:49] And so we've been nursing this computer along for 10 or so years, [0:16:54] and in computer years, that's like 90, you know? [0:16:57] And it's like dog ears, but worse. [0:17:00] That thing finally gave up the ghost this summer. [0:17:03] And we couldn't limp along with it anymore. [0:17:05] And it is just completely crashed, taking with it our parking [0:17:11] enforcement tool. [0:17:12] And so now we've had no parking enforcement tool. [0:17:15] And the stuff that the police department uses, [0:17:18] it kind of works, but it doesn't really work [0:17:20] because they're different violations. [0:17:21] And so we use those forms that we're scratching out, [0:17:24] all the stuff that doesn't really apply. [0:17:26] And we're handwriting in the stuff that does apply. [0:17:28] It's time consuming and it's not very professional. [0:17:31] But we've been just given parking enforcement [0:17:33] kind of as superficial for the last few months. [0:17:37] And it's past time to really do something better [0:17:41] for parking enforcement. [0:17:43] We need to get those tools back into the hands of these guys [0:17:45] for using them. [0:17:48] So what we got after looking for, what Sean was tasked with, [0:17:53] was go find something that'll work for your code enforcement [0:17:57] stuff, but it will also work for your parking enforcement stuff. [0:18:01] And let's get the right tool in the hands [0:18:04] of these people who are using it, Sean and his team. [0:18:08] We researched several different outfits, [0:18:11] several different companies, and most of them [0:18:13] were parking enforcement that claimed they could also [0:18:18] do code enforcement. [0:18:20] When it comes down to it, a lot of them [0:18:22] had trouble backing up the claims. [0:18:25] This one that we found here called G-Techna Officer, [0:18:28] I think is the name of it, is really kind of the other way [0:18:32] around. [0:18:33] It's a code enforcement workflow software that also [0:18:37] has a parking enforcement attachment to it, or component to it. [0:18:41] And it really seems to be, I was going to say the best one out [0:18:46] there, but maybe the only one out there that'll do both. [0:18:50] And so we've, after I think an exhaustive effort looked [0:18:54] around, we found these guys. [0:18:59] I got a kind of email from Chris with a couple of questions [0:19:01] been working a couple of those answers here. [0:19:03] These guys have been around in this business. [0:19:06] She tech has been around for 92 or so, but in this code enforcement around they've been [0:19:13] having this software on the market since 98. [0:19:16] It's not a brand new kind of a thing. [0:19:18] It's been around 15, 19, what, 58, 98, 15 years or so. [0:19:23] They gave us a list of several other cities who are using it and some big cities, Washington, [0:19:28] D.C., and some other cities. [0:19:30] We've called up five or six of those and everybody we've talked to has had glowing [0:19:35] reviews of this software. Sean will talk to you a little bit more about his conversation [0:19:40] with Washington DC and their level of, you know, happiness with what they've got. So [0:19:49] it appears to be the right product for us. It works from us on an IT standpoint because [0:19:55] kind of we own the data. One of those things that we struggled with was this idea about [0:19:59] controlling the data. A lot of these guys want to use the cloud and put that out there [0:20:04] And maybe there's some benefits to that, but maybe there's also some struggles with that, [0:20:08] and we're not quite sure if we're ready to take that step into the cloud realm yet. [0:20:13] This doesn't use the cloud. [0:20:14] This uses our own database, our own servers for the ownership of that data. [0:20:23] So we're generally pretty comfortable with it. [0:20:26] We think it's, like I said, it's the only one out there that really will do both. [0:20:33] It's kind of pricey, it's about $67,000 for the first year. [0:20:37] We got to buy some kind of paper that's not included in that $67,000 that's more of an [0:20:43] operational kind of expense. [0:20:44] But this $67,000 is the purchase of the software, it's the first year of like the initial programming. [0:20:53] It's also the hardware that we're going to get three outfits, so one for each of these [0:20:57] guys. [0:20:58] Yeah, they can take with them in their trucks. [0:21:02] And but we didn't have any money in the budget for this year for it, right? [0:21:05] So that's I guess the gist of this request tonight is to kind of explain the need, how [0:21:10] we got there. [0:21:11] And then the idea about funding for this is in that we're going to propose that we go [0:21:16] to a couple of different sources. [0:21:19] First I think the biggest portion of this is that over those years where we did manage [0:21:23] parking, we did have a bit of a reserve from the built up. [0:21:30] It's about $57,000 in the Parking Reserve Fund right now. [0:21:33] And that's kind of sitting there waiting for some parking [0:21:35] related expenses to spend it on. [0:21:39] In this year's budget, and actually last year's budget, [0:21:41] and anticipated budgets moving forward, [0:21:44] we're spending all the money we're collecting back [0:21:47] in the program, back in operation of the parking program. [0:21:49] We don't anticipate building parking reserve funds anymore. [0:21:54] And in fact, we moved the funding for code enforcement [0:21:57] into the general fund is not even in a parking fund anymore, [0:22:00] like it was when it was an individual program. [0:22:03] So we got this parking fund, reserve fund money, [0:22:06] kind of hanging out there, waiting for an expense. [0:22:08] We've spent it on signage and some things like that [0:22:11] to help the parking program with all the bumper blocks [0:22:13] that we put in a little while ago. [0:22:14] We spent that money on those. [0:22:15] So we've made some physical improvements [0:22:17] with some of that money, but again, [0:22:18] there's still $57,000 left. [0:22:22] It's not dedicated to anything. [0:22:24] It's in this reserve fund for parking related expenses. [0:22:27] where we have a parking enforcement need, [0:22:30] the proposal is to grab that money [0:22:32] and bring it over here. [0:22:34] In addition to that, we did anticipate actually [0:22:37] buying the software in last year's budget. [0:22:39] And so in this current budget, we did put a little money [0:22:42] in the budget for the annual maintenance of it. [0:22:45] And at the time, we had a different software in mind [0:22:48] and it had a very different price structure. [0:22:49] And so we threw $3,500 in the code enforcement division [0:22:54] budget for annual maintenance. [0:22:56] We want to throw that in this as well. [0:22:57] And then the final little chunk of it [0:22:59] is in the planning department, we did have some money [0:23:03] in our professional services, operational budget, [0:23:06] for some software work with city works, [0:23:10] is what we're going to do. [0:23:11] Have them come in and do some programming for us [0:23:12] to get that all up to speed. [0:23:15] We've been, I think, more successful than we thought [0:23:18] we were going to be. [0:23:20] We're getting more from city works [0:23:21] than we thought we were going to with last year's expenses. [0:23:23] And so the idea is that about in September, [0:23:28] we talked with the folks from City Works [0:23:29] and they told us that when we're all done with this, [0:23:32] we'll have a handful of people who are now programmed [0:23:35] or trained to do the programming ourselves [0:23:37] so we can continue to work with City Works [0:23:40] with our own staff rather than continuing to pay them [0:23:44] to come in. [0:23:45] So that money that we had set aside the 20,000 [0:23:47] in the planning department budget [0:23:48] isn't looking like we're gonna need to spend [0:23:49] that for City Works. [0:23:50] And it was in the planning department budget [0:23:53] for professional services for software. [0:23:56] So we'd like to spend that money to kind of balance out [0:24:00] our need for the $67,000 purchase. [0:24:04] So that kind of gets up the nuts and bolts [0:24:07] of what I wanted to share. [0:24:09] So I'll leave it up to you guys if you want to ask me questions [0:24:11] on this stuff now, or I can turn it over to Sun [0:24:13] and let him talk about the program. [0:24:15] And he does want to talk a bit about what they've been doing. [0:24:19] So I do have a like Chris talking. Yeah, thank you for following up on it. So [0:24:24] longevity is a successful program. Any municipalities in our area that use it? [0:24:34] They were all out of state. The ones that they told us, we'd be the first one tonight to know that [0:24:38] that are and to the municipalities you've found they use it. Is this the current release or update [0:24:43] or is it one of the originals? I'm apprehensive of something with this price tag that is not a [0:24:48] a software program and has to be upgraded and updated very expensively and very often. [0:24:56] So I want to have hand-holding confidence that it works from the get-go. [0:25:07] Do I understand that part of the yearly cost, that is included. [0:25:13] So if we have changed to a city code, anything of that nature, that's included in the maintenance [0:25:18] fee. [0:25:22] And there's nothing unique about our way of siting or anything that you do that makes [0:25:29] it an unusable system. [0:25:30] I mean at Square Peg and Square Hole so far as the project or what we need to have done. [0:25:37] And you will guarantee to be able to spend more time out in the field and in the office [0:25:43] does that make you feel better too? [0:25:45] This was the only system that we found that actually allowed us to have [0:25:51] reinspection dates or give extensions if somebody's trying to resolve a situation. [0:25:59] This is the only one we found that actually allowed that. [0:26:04] Thanks, Sean. [0:26:08] One peculiarity I would say with our system that maybe these other cities [0:26:13] that they gave us is workload volume, basically. [0:26:16] We appear to be a very small volume compared to Washington DC, [0:26:21] for example. [0:26:23] But in the end, that's just how much we're going to use it. [0:26:34] The other thing I was going to suggest, [0:26:35] I want to make sure that the annual fee also [0:26:37] includes the most recent update on the software. [0:26:41] OK, so these other cities that are paying their annual fees [0:26:44] are getting the recent updates as well. [0:26:46] So when we're talking to them, they're using what is currently available. [0:26:50] We'll get what is currently available in the next year when they come out of version 7.2 or whatever, right? [0:26:56] We'll get that update as well. [0:27:00] I would recommend selecting. [0:27:02] Thank you, Mayor. [0:27:03] I just have a question about the parking reserves. [0:27:06] We moved all the other money into the general fund, but kind of left these parking reserves. [0:27:11] But during the budget, we raised, we increased the code enforcement fee, [0:27:16] in increased sanitation fee for code enforcement, [0:27:20] why didn't we use any of these reserves [0:27:22] to offset the costs of code enforcement? [0:27:24] The increase that we went through for the budget process [0:27:28] was, again, we moved everything, [0:27:31] all the revenues came into the general fund, [0:27:33] as well as the expenses came into the general fund. [0:27:35] And so we had an operational increase [0:27:38] that resulted in a need for more revenue, basically. [0:27:42] A one-time reserve fund would be gone in less than a year's time, [0:27:47] I think, or probably about a year's time. [0:27:50] And they needed to be an ongoing increase in revenue stream. [0:27:54] And one-time reserve funds don't really work well [0:27:57] for ongoing operational expenses. [0:27:59] So we kind of held those back for those one-time capital [0:28:02] type improvements that we needed to make. [0:28:04] So like I said, we bought those bumper blocks in the parking [0:28:07] lot, so we put some signs up. [0:28:08] And those things are going to be those one-time expenses. [0:28:11] And we have just a little bit left on that. [0:28:13] That 57,000 is what's left there. [0:28:16] Right, but it could have covered for one year about? [0:28:18] It certainly could have been moved in and covered [0:28:21] and delayed the increase for a little while. [0:28:23] But in the end, we would have increased as well [0:28:26] to cover the additional operating expense. [0:28:28] Thank you. [0:28:28] My other question is about parking enforcement. [0:28:32] I know when we're talking about removing parking meters, [0:28:35] the intention of the council was to really have a more relaxed [0:28:39] parking enforcement program downtown. [0:28:42] I haven't had any complaints about it. [0:28:45] You mentioned that you've had more violations or something, [0:28:50] but have you gotten many complaints about downtown parking? [0:28:54] And how many? [0:28:56] Yeah, I'm going to let Sean really get at it, [0:28:58] because he's the guy that hears it more than I do. [0:29:01] But we have, I would say, had a more kinder, gentler approach [0:29:05] to parking enforcement. [0:29:06] There's, honestly, there's less to enforce [0:29:08] than there used to be to with the meters gone and those kind of things. There's still is a need for enforcement. [0:29:13] And then after this, unless there's more questions, obviously. [0:29:20] Yeah, I have a couple more, maybe delay that question until Sean, is that all right, Rebecca? [0:29:25] I think most of the compliance from good, from a party, are the people that actually have purchased passes, [0:29:31] and they notice people that are parking in spots where they shouldn't be. [0:29:36] So that's most of the complaints we do get. [0:29:39] And then right now, you know, our software is gone, [0:29:44] and we're to the point where it's stated, [0:29:46] we're having to scratch out times. [0:29:49] I mean, we can't even set the device to daylight savings time. [0:29:53] So if we're enforcing a time zone, it's very difficult to, [0:29:59] and it's not very professional to scratch that out and change the time. [0:30:03] So we have had a lot of complaints on that. [0:30:08] that you write in the times? [0:30:09] Yeah. [0:30:10] That's where we're at with the software we have right now. [0:30:15] Okay. [0:30:16] It doesn't seem like an issue to me, but I'll accept that. [0:30:24] And we couldn't print up tickets that suit our purposes, that have the correct information [0:30:31] you could check. [0:30:33] We could. [0:30:34] And then the police department does have those citations, but you know, there's 15 to [0:30:41] 20 citations on that. [0:30:43] So we're having to scratch out the ones we don't use. [0:30:48] OK. [0:30:50] This is in Hoggins. [0:30:54] Working with software, I understand this is a large amount [0:30:57] of money, but I know what companies pay for software, [0:31:00] so it isn't sticker shock to me per se. [0:31:03] But my question is on the training. [0:31:05] Is that training with them sending people here to train you, [0:31:08] or does that mean you're going to need to go somewhere else [0:31:10] to be trained in the software? [0:31:12] I believe that we are going to do it on a webinar. [0:31:17] Yeah, that's how we cut cost. [0:31:19] Okay. [0:31:20] We're able to go to IS and do a webinar. [0:31:23] Thank you for that. [0:31:24] Yeah, three days. [0:31:26] Okay, and then I see that they're charging for installation [0:31:28] is that them sending someone here, Lori, [0:31:31] maybe this is more for Lori, [0:31:32] or are we doing our own install in the IT department? [0:31:35] Or, okay, thank you. [0:31:40] Don't know. [0:31:42] Hi, Sean. [0:31:43] So it's a 67K for the initial cost for the software. [0:31:47] And then did I read it right? [0:31:48] It's 11K a year for maintenance. [0:31:50] That's correct. [0:31:51] Is that seems like a lot of money for maintenance to me. [0:31:55] And do we have to get the updates every year? [0:31:58] Can we wait two or three years and then get an update? [0:32:01] Two or three years, get an update? [0:32:03] Because I know folks, I'm just really tight. [0:32:06] And I think that I know folks do that with certain software [0:32:09] or will that be detrimental to the process? [0:32:12] Yeah. [0:32:13] The changes or support, we wouldn't have it. [0:32:20] So if they could need it in their code, we'd be stuck. [0:32:23] I mean, you really did it to keep the car soft. [0:32:25] OK. [0:32:26] So you think that's just a fact. [0:32:28] Yeah, and then 1,100 is to pay for the tickets. [0:32:31] OK, OK. [0:32:33] And then one last question, probably more for a match. [0:32:37] You mentioned the overall parking. [0:32:40] We get fines. [0:32:41] We also get fees for being able to park. [0:32:45] And you anticipate not building that fund up in the future. [0:32:49] just gonna self. So our parking revenue source right now is primarily in the sale [0:32:56] of the parking passes. Right. That's the bulk of the revenue. We get a little tiny [0:33:00] bit in fines, but that never has been much and it still isn't very much. And [0:33:04] we haven't made a concerted effort to really increase fine revenue. Right. So [0:33:11] so back in the priors we also used to add the meter revenue to that and we [0:33:18] really cut parking revenues almost in half when we change the program up last [0:33:23] last November or October right. We don't think that this software is [0:33:30] necessarily going to help us be increasing revenue right and that isn't my [0:33:35] intent here I don't think we're gonna increase our revenue you know I think [0:33:41] the maintenance part of that 11,000 was 9500 the rest of it's like ticket paper [0:33:45] I don't think we're going to increase our revenue $9,500 a year with this software. [0:33:52] Again, because it's our focus on enforcement is about compliance first and education, and [0:33:59] that rather than citations. [0:34:03] And so in my mind, this is a tool that allows us to be more efficient and gain better compliance [0:34:10] with our codes. [0:34:12] In that sense, that's the driving need for it. [0:34:18] And this isn't going to be, I don't think we're going to see additional revenue to offset that. [0:34:23] I guess really what I was trying to drill down on is there's not going to be any buildup of revenue [0:34:31] throughout the system because it sounds like to me what I had always hoped is [0:34:36] through the parking, some through fines. [0:34:38] I'm not a big fine guy either, but that we could build that up to be able to help the maintenance [0:34:45] of those parking lots themselves because that's an expense to the city. [0:34:50] And I would hope that it would be able to sustain itself financially or at least take a bite [0:34:56] out of that from the rest of the citizens in the city paying for parking lots downtown. [0:35:01] And so with the if this year's funding structure continues into the foreseeable [0:35:09] future which I think that's probably a fair statement. We're not adding anything to [0:35:15] our parking reserve fund well that's going away right but I don't think we're [0:35:19] adding anything to any reserve fund with with our code enforcement slash parking [0:35:24] enforcement program anymore where we used to do that under the old program when [0:35:29] we had more revenue coming in. [0:35:32] So once we spend that parking reserve fund down, [0:35:34] I think it goes away and it probably stays away, [0:35:37] which is also the need for the increase to the sanitation [0:35:41] fee, which Rebecca mentioned a minute ago, [0:35:45] because there was an operational increase that's [0:35:47] going to be a continuing operational increase. [0:35:49] What I think we could potentially see [0:35:51] is if we continue to see more interest in downtown [0:35:55] and more storefronts being full and more customers coming down town. [0:36:01] Potentially we'll sell more parking passes and because we have more parking lots to [0:36:06] fill. I mean, right now we have a few lots that are pretty full. Most of the time we [0:36:10] also have a few that are pretty empty and have a lot of room for growth in sales [0:36:15] of parking passes. I think that's where we'll see an increase in revenue. And I [0:36:20] think that that relies on a bit more than whatever we're going to do in the [0:36:25] enforcement division, I'll click the revise on. [0:36:28] So right now it's kind of flat with the general fund [0:36:33] picking up the maintenance of the lot. [0:36:35] But hopefully someday, if we see continued growth, [0:36:39] selling more parking passes, [0:36:40] that maybe it can start sustaining itself [0:36:42] for the maintenance of those lots. [0:36:44] Right. [0:36:45] And even though the, even worse sustain yourselves now, [0:36:47] if you think about that sanitation fee [0:36:50] is really a code enforcement fee. [0:36:52] So, the program is being funded by parking revenues and code enforcement revenues. [0:36:58] And that's still going to be the case. [0:37:01] We had to increase that code enforcement revenue a little bit this year. [0:37:05] And maybe we won't have to do that if we can sell more passes in coming years. [0:37:12] Thank you. [0:37:13] Rebecca, I'm going to slow you. [0:37:14] Thank you, Mayor. [0:37:17] I guess a follow up question with the annual maintenance. [0:37:21] How are you going to work that into your budget? [0:37:23] What will the effect be on rates? [0:37:26] Yeah, future budgets. [0:37:27] Will there be rate increases? [0:37:29] How are you going to pay for this annually? [0:37:31] That's actually, I can't take credit for this [0:37:35] because this really came from Lori Race, [0:37:37] who really knows the stuff we better not do. [0:37:40] But part of our using the money we had in the budget [0:37:43] this year for the planning department, [0:37:49] gosh, at least that my city works. [0:37:53] That money is in our operational budget now and assuming all things equal, right, [0:37:58] in coming years, it'll be operational money that'll continue to be somewhere in [0:38:03] the future and it can just transfer over to this next year. [0:38:07] That 20,000 will be 20,000 for software maintenance and another 11 for something else. [0:38:15] Okay, and will you be able to do the same amount of work in CityWorks as you [0:38:21] anticipated or will city works kind of have to be affected. [0:38:25] And the reason why we're not spending the 20, I guess I want to go into that a little bit [0:38:29] more detail. [0:38:31] With the money we spent last year for city works and we spent that out of the building [0:38:34] department fund, what we got from that that I didn't really understand is a level of training [0:38:44] of city staff to where we can essentially be city works programmers. [0:38:50] And so I've got five of us, or four of us, that are going to go through that level of [0:38:54] training, and then I'm included in that, where we can actually sit down and do the programming [0:39:01] ourselves rather than paying city works to come in and do additional programming for us. [0:39:07] And that wasn't entirely clear to me until about September. [0:39:12] And that's why we included the 20,000 in the operational side so that we could pay city [0:39:16] to come in and do more programming, [0:39:18] but upon this kind of working out, [0:39:21] I don't think we'll need to do that [0:39:22] because we'll be doing the programming ourselves. [0:39:24] And we'll have that ability into the future, right? [0:39:29] So as more permits become available [0:39:31] or the next whatever process we're gonna come up with [0:39:34] for whatever that we're gonna do, the tracking city works, [0:39:37] we'll have the ability to write that workflow ourselves [0:39:40] and kind of work it into the system [0:39:42] without calling them up to come do that for us. [0:39:46] But we'll still have our annual maintenance with city works, [0:39:48] and they'll still provide the technical support [0:39:51] and the updates to software and all that kind of stuff [0:39:53] that we're gonna continue to get from them. [0:39:55] We just won't pay additional to have them [0:39:57] come in and do programming for us. [0:39:58] Okay, and what is our annual payment to city works for? [0:40:02] Software? [0:40:04] 17,000, 17,000, sorry. [0:40:06] 17,000, just for comparison. [0:40:07] Yep. [0:40:09] Thank you. [0:40:14] All right, did you wanna have Sean? [0:40:16] Welcome, Sean. [0:40:18] Thank you. [0:40:19] I just wanted to make a couple of points [0:40:20] three years ago, this list, well, I only had about a third of those on the code enforcement list, so it's grown pretty rapidly in the last three years. [0:40:37] I understand next week you might have discussion on mobile food vendors, and then I'm sure I know what list that will go on as well, so I just wanted to show you how that list has grown in the last three years. [0:40:51] It also goes with, so I want to make the point that 4,286, [0:41:02] that's not total cases, okay? [0:41:05] We might go to one specific property six or seven times [0:41:10] in the summer if we extend it out, if for some reason we do have [0:41:14] to write a fine or force more property, [0:41:19] we have to go back and take those photos. [0:41:21] So we don't have 4,286 specific cases out there. [0:41:29] And there might be more than one code violation per property also. [0:41:33] So that number is a little bit deceiving. [0:41:38] I also do want to make the point that we, [0:41:42] right now we are spending about 50 to 60% of our time [0:41:46] in the office and code enforcement does much better [0:41:50] when we're out in the field. [0:41:52] when we're out educating people on our codes [0:41:57] and when they put a face with code enforcement, [0:42:00] it helps them and it helps us. [0:42:03] So hopefully with this software, [0:42:06] we can spend a lot more time out in the field. [0:42:11] Alright, good on all. [0:42:12] So Sean the 4286, that included the education visits as well. [0:42:17] visits as well. I was a participant in that this summer. My trees grew a little too long. I didn't realize it. And I got a little note to say, go out and trim them. And when I went out and looked, I said, I need to trim these. I didn't realize. But so that's the education part as well. [0:42:38] is that. Okay, good back. Well, just a technical question. So do you I've seen a few vehicles out [0:42:45] there that have a computer in their truck and it's a white with the city logo. Is that code enforcement? [0:42:52] You guys currently have computers in your truck? Yes, we have two vehicles. Woody and myself do have [0:42:58] those. Okay, so are you're going back to the office for are you not able to enter data in your [0:43:06] computer in your truck? [0:43:07] Not very well, no. [0:43:09] Sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't. [0:43:13] We can't receive complaints when we're out in the field via email [0:43:18] on those computers, but when we have to submit a letter, [0:43:21] we do have to go in to the office. [0:43:23] Oh, I am. [0:43:25] Will the new software allow you to do some of that stuff [0:43:28] from your truck or not? [0:43:29] Yes, it's real time. [0:43:33] So just an example, if I'm at a property at 10 o'clock [0:43:36] in the morning, I get a complaint. [0:43:38] I go to the property, I leave a notification with them. [0:43:41] Woody or Carolyn can go on and see that I've already been there. [0:43:46] So maybe we're not building up on the notifications. [0:43:49] Right now that's kind of hard to do. [0:43:52] Well, Chris, and with your buildup in total violations, [0:43:58] the only thing I've queried about is that 287, those are pending. [0:44:03] I guess they could still move to the closed or resolved position. [0:44:07] Yeah, at the time we printed this, that was the old. [0:44:12] But in the same time period, the previous two years [0:44:14] there weren't any open. [0:44:15] So I guess it's just a function of your volume [0:44:18] that you're dealing with as much as anything. [0:44:20] Right. [0:44:21] Now, I also do want to state that this graph does not include [0:44:25] water conservation board party. [0:44:28] Those are total separate spread sheet that we have to track. [0:44:33] But the new software will do it all. [0:44:37] I want to go on record minds in the resolve category. [0:44:40] Okay, just, I'm saying. [0:44:42] And John, I did have an opportunity, [0:44:44] had somebody complained to me and I asked them to go through [0:44:48] the system because I knew where that lot was and I could kind of see how quickly [0:44:52] things were resolved. It was actually a house was built but they were allowed [0:44:56] and they hadn't put a lawn in and the weeds were growing and it was resolved [0:45:00] rather quickly. I was impressed with the speed which you guys get out [0:45:04] and it didn't come from me because I wanted to see it go through the system [0:45:08] And whereas the citizen submitted the complaint and I appreciate that. [0:45:17] As far as the parking, I think the only complaints I've had to meet personally were exactly what [0:45:21] Mitch said, were the people that have a parking pass. [0:45:24] They paid for a parking pass and they see others parking in them that don't have a parking [0:45:29] pass and they wonder why am I buying a parking pass. [0:45:31] So I think that's probably the parking enforcement that we see complaints about making sure that [0:45:37] we're getting out and patrolling those areas [0:45:40] and making sure that if you have parking pass, [0:45:44] you're getting some value from it rather than [0:45:47] just not buying it and parking in the same spots. [0:45:50] Jimma. [0:45:51] Oh, thank you, Mayor. [0:45:52] One of the, maybe Mitch, you answered this question. [0:45:53] Why wasn't this, well, I think it's in your memorandum [0:45:56] in regards to why this wasn't putting the budget [0:45:58] because research took too long? [0:46:02] We'd intended to buy the parking. [0:46:06] We knew the computer was on its last legs, right? [0:46:08] And so we knew the parking management was going to be something we had to do. [0:46:12] We had some money in the budget for this year's budget early in the year, like around April [0:46:18] May timeframe. [0:46:19] When we were going through our internal staff process and we were meeting as department heads [0:46:24] and kind of pulling out things, and that meeting I said, I'm going to pull that out and instead [0:46:32] I want to use this parking reserve fund to buy that software now, now being last summer. [0:46:38] And so it doesn't have to go in this coming year's budget request, and we'll just go ahead and do this whole thing [0:46:45] Back in July or June [0:46:47] And when it came down to it [0:46:49] That's when we started actually really delving into the software and finding that this one wasn't gonna work for us [0:46:56] And so we'll set that aside [0:46:57] And then we spend some time researching the next one and that one doesn't work [0:47:00] So the next one and it just took us to the to now go get to this point [0:47:04] We had intended to purchase it before October 1 [0:47:08] And that's why I didn't make its way in what would happen. What would be the downside of us waiting to include this and let this [0:47:14] Play out in the vetting process for next year's budget [0:47:20] I think we would need to do some sort of a temporary stop cap [0:47:24] I mean Rebecca asked a minute ago couldn't you print new forms? [0:47:27] We would have to do something like that because the parking thing just isn't it's not working the way it is right now [0:47:33] We'll have to find some way to get us from where we were to where we're going. [0:47:38] And we could probably continue to limp along like that. [0:47:41] You know, the budget is a resource-allocating device that I think works really, really well. [0:47:44] Particularly we're going to have a $11,000 operating expenditure in perpetuity after this. [0:47:52] So I'm going to probably vote no on this Mitch respectfully and would really encourage you [0:47:57] to include this in next year's budget and we proceed that way. [0:48:01] but I just want to go on record saying that. [0:48:02] I wanted to make one more point. [0:48:06] Sean talked about the 4,300 cases there, [0:48:09] not being an actual case count, [0:48:11] but rather more like a visit count. [0:48:13] So when Don's not responsive and they have to go back the next time [0:48:17] and then the next time that's going to count as three, not one. [0:48:20] Okay. Two things. [0:48:21] One, yeah, we need to correct that [0:48:23] because that's not a very good, accurate reflection of what they're doing. [0:48:26] But two, it also shows the current limits of the software. [0:48:30] I mean, this is all we can get out of what we've got is [0:48:33] total number visits, not total cases. [0:48:35] So, anyway, there's that. [0:48:38] And then one other thing, with us looking into the software, [0:48:42] and some of you know that we do all this at senior staff [0:48:46] before we do it here. [0:48:48] And doing this at senior staff caused the chief of police [0:48:52] to go, I wonder if that could be something we could use [0:48:54] for our CSOs, and now they're looking into, [0:48:57] if we go ahead and go down this path [0:48:59] buying a few more pieces of equipment, a few more licenses [0:49:03] to maybe get in the hands of the CSOs [0:49:05] if there's something that they can take advantage of as well. [0:49:09] That's not included in this request. [0:49:11] That'll be additional equipment. [0:49:14] And then Chris, your question, I forgot to mention, [0:49:17] in the email that you asked earlier [0:49:18] was the $2,600 for printers. [0:49:21] It's for three printers for $26. [0:49:23] That equals this would be a little less than $900 each, [0:49:25] which it's generally in that kind of acceptable. [0:49:29] And arranged with what we compared to so with that I think I said I like [0:49:38] Exox our questions [0:49:40] Council issues [0:49:41] We need a motion [0:49:43] We're gonna do an upper down vote. I don't we need most to do so Chris talking [0:49:46] Well, I just want to make a comment pertinent to Jim's [0:49:48] I'm prone to vote against the gym, but [0:49:51] Seeing Sean and crew set spending 50 to 60 percent of their time in the office isn't a good use of valuable city staff [0:49:58] I'm really torn which way to vote, frankly, on the thing. [0:50:01] I also think that the city staff has to be disciplined to do their want listing [0:50:06] within the city budget time period. [0:50:08] But, guys, this is a real efficient use, increased efficiency usage of our personnel. [0:50:16] And I, my conscience doesn't know which way to go. [0:50:21] So I'll just wait to see which way the votes go. [0:50:23] I'll go in way in as far as it says. I like your Jim's comment about the budget [0:50:28] But this is $57,000 that nobody else has access to anyway [0:50:33] It's not like we're gonna be betting that to find the whole amount [0:50:37] 57,000s in this [0:50:39] This other fund that's designed for this and so I'm gonna be in favor of the motion [0:50:48] Do we have a motion? [0:50:50] If there is a motion, I guess, John Mayer. [0:50:55] Mayor, I would move to use the parking reserve funds [0:51:00] as outlined for the purchase of code enforcement, [0:51:02] tracking and ticketing software. [0:51:06] Then I'm getting to the number and the amount of something, [0:51:14] $67,032. [0:51:17] Is that the right number? [0:51:19] That comes up about $10,000 short, though. [0:51:21] Did you want to include the other options [0:51:23] of the, uh, I want and the ongoing annual cost as presented. [0:51:29] Yeah. [0:51:29] Total upfront cost is a 67. [0:51:31] Oh, three, two, 57 of that comes from parking reserve and the rest of it is [0:51:37] outlined in the other two swaps. [0:51:40] Okay. [0:51:44] I second that motion. [0:51:46] So moved by Sean Burger and second by Don Hall that we basically grant the [0:51:50] request as presented. [0:51:52] Um, uh, your life's long. [0:51:56] Yeah, so I agree that the budget is a very important item that we need to try to adhere to to meet the [0:52:04] strategic goals of the city. I also believe it is somewhat of a road map because it is a predictor [0:52:12] 12 months down the road with not complete data on the front end trying to guesstimate where our [0:52:19] revenues and expenses are going to be down the road. [0:52:22] So sometimes things come up and I look at this software as a tool to improve the efficiency [0:52:31] of a critical city department we have, the same as it would be buying lawnmowers for the [0:52:38] parks department or shovels for the street department or whatever, they're important tools. [0:52:47] And I know people get uncomfortable with great big numbers for computer technology, but it [0:52:54] is the world that we live in today, and that's what this stuff costs. [0:52:57] So I think that the staff should be commended for the work they've done in trying to identify [0:53:06] the valuable tools that can be used more broadly than just parking because had we made a purchase [0:53:12] in July of outdated parking software that met one need, [0:53:19] we'd all be complaining about how we wasted money [0:53:21] on something that we can't use for something else, [0:53:23] so I'll be supportive of this request. [0:53:26] Don't know. [0:53:27] Question regarding the 11,000 plus maintenance costs, [0:53:31] that's not going to come into play until next year. [0:53:35] So that can be put in next year's budget? [0:53:37] Part of that needs to happen up front. [0:53:42] The 11.5, I think it was, [0:53:46] is the annual maintenance plus the printer paper. [0:53:51] So what's the printer paper that you need? [0:53:53] We need to purchase printer paper right now as well. [0:53:57] That would be an addition to the 67, [0:53:59] but we'll find that in some other. [0:54:01] Yes, apply stuff. The 95 and then [0:54:05] future year's printer papers is the 11 and that will come up in subsequent years. [0:54:10] I just want to go on record to say that I'm torn on this as well. [0:54:15] I think Jim's argument trying to stay within the budget is solid one. [0:54:21] It makes sense as the parameters that were placed under, [0:54:26] but to listen to some of the other debate, [0:54:28] my own thoughts that we need to be reasonable about our decisions [0:54:35] in being flexible enough to say that it's going [0:54:40] to be more productive, more efficient for our staff [0:54:44] to be able to utilize this. [0:54:45] And it did take some time to research this, like Sean said, [0:54:50] and get the right software instead of trying to rush it [0:54:54] into the budget process. [0:54:55] So I'm torn, but I'm leaning more towards voting in favor. [0:55:00] I'd like to miss all you. [0:55:02] Thank you, Mayor. [0:55:04] You know, I'm going to have to agree with Councilman Munn. [0:55:08] This really would be a good project [0:55:11] to be vetted through the budget process. [0:55:14] But I completely support updating technology [0:55:17] and getting the technology that you need. [0:55:19] And so I can see how this is helpful. [0:55:22] But my one concern would be on the downtown parking side. [0:55:26] I mean, the complaints and really the public outcry [0:55:29] that we got regarding that was that they wanted [0:55:31] to shop downtown, be downtown, and not walk out and have a hundred dollar ticket on their [0:55:36] window, which is now the current cost of a ticket, and so I kind of thought the direction [0:55:43] that we were going, is that not the cost of a ticket in the second violation of the hundred? [0:55:50] It's always thirty-five. [0:55:51] I believe we just updated that. [0:55:54] It used to have an escalating thing. [0:55:56] It went from a like a required warning to a five to a, you know, and it escalated up. [0:56:01] Every violation is a $35 violation, so the first violation went up pretty good. [0:56:07] And if it's not paid within a certain time frame, I want to say it's three business days and it goes to 50. [0:56:11] Okay, 50. [0:56:13] Still a significant fine when you're not expecting it. [0:56:17] And I do agree that we need to have some sort of enforcement so that everyone participates according to the rules down there. [0:56:24] But that would be my concern because that's really the negative input that we heard from the community. [0:56:31] And so I felt that the direction that the council was going was to maybe be a little [0:56:35] more relaxed and friendly about downtown parking enforcement, and that is just my perspective [0:56:45] on it. [0:56:46] But as far as this request right now, I think I would rather see those reserves going to [0:56:54] offset rate increases, or going into actual infrastructure in the downtown parking lots. [0:57:01] That's what it was for, was to improve those parking lots. [0:57:08] But I do support, I do want to go on our career to saying, [0:57:11] I support updating the technology, getting you the technology that you need to be effective and efficient. [0:57:17] But I think that if we print some new tickets or we hand-write tickets and check boxes, [0:57:23] I'm sorry if people feel that's inadequate, but I feel like you know that should be an adequate [0:57:29] warning for people to just have a printed ticket. [0:57:32] I really can't see the downside of that for another few months. [0:57:36] So you know additional lights? [0:57:41] We have a roll call vote. [0:57:43] Don Hall? [0:57:44] Yes. [0:57:45] Susan Hulkin? [0:57:46] Yes. [0:57:47] Greg Lanci? [0:57:48] Yes. [0:57:49] Jim Munn? [0:57:50] No. [0:57:51] Rebecca Malsoico? [0:57:52] No. [0:57:53] Chris Tockington? [0:57:54] Yes. [0:57:55] motion passes five to two thank you for your input moving on to just like I want [0:58:03] to reemphasize I debate on this and everybody had valid points but that [0:58:07] having our staff spend half of the time sitting the office figuring out what [0:58:12] they're going to do just doesn't make sense thank you Chris item number two [0:58:17] consideration of request to approve a resolution declaring a policy of [0:58:20] transparency in city government. Don Hall and Jim. Thank you, Mayor. I'll start this evening. [0:58:27] Surprise, surprise. We're back talking about this again. It's it's been a robust [0:58:32] debate, obviously. It is, I believe, a welcomed conversation that we've had with [0:58:40] our community and with each other regarding transparency and the attached [0:58:45] resolution really does, in my opinion, contain, as the staff reports, as a variety [0:58:52] of measures intended to provide additional transparency in city government [0:58:57] over and above what the state requirements are. So if I could, my [0:59:03] presentation this evening is going to be somewhat brief, I think, hopefully good [0:59:07] debate and questions, and of course I'm going to turn it over to Councilman [0:59:11] Munn for his comments. But the first thing that I'd like to bring to your [0:59:14] attention is we did do some switching around a little bit for clarification and [0:59:19] moving around but it's very similar to the resolution that you saw last week but [0:59:26] one of the areas that we did change and move over into the whereas category and [0:59:31] you'll see it up on the overhead right now it's the one two three four five [0:59:36] sixth whereas I'm discussing ad hoc volunteer groups being put together can [0:59:43] new hero caser being put together by other than city council. [0:59:52] They really does address that. [0:59:56] But probably the crux the biggest portion and what we debated the most about last time [1:00:04] was section three. [1:00:05] And if I could go to section three, could we put that up, Mitch? [1:00:12] This is really a clarification after listening to councils debate and inquiries and conversation [1:00:19] last week and also listening to the community. [1:00:22] This I believe is an area that further clarifies what we're trying to get after in this resolution [1:00:29] regarding transparency. [1:00:31] And if you will indulge me, I'll read it to you. [1:00:34] Section 3, the Idaho Open Meeting Law applies only to meetings of governing board of a public [1:00:40] agency or sub-agency, which is created by statute, ordinance, or other legislative acts with the [1:00:46] authority to make decisions for or recommendations to a public agency regarding any matter. [1:00:53] The Idaho Attorney General and the Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual states that the open meeting [1:00:59] law does not apply to voluntary internal staff meetings if the group is not created by or [1:01:07] pursuant to statute, ordinance, or other legislative acts, even though the discussion [1:01:13] may lead to recommendations to the governing body. A subcommittee is a creation of and is [1:01:19] responsible to the agency that created it. Second paragraph under section 3. In order [1:01:28] to provide more transparency in city government, neither the Twin Falls City Council nor any [1:01:35] of its commissions will permit the formation of ad hoc volunteer groups intended to report [1:01:41] back to the City Council or Commission unless that group is formed as a committee or commission [1:01:48] created by a vote of the City Council or Commission. The City Council and its committees and commissions [1:01:55] shall always comply with all requirements of the Idaho Open Meeting Law. [1:02:01] I'll turn it over to Jim. [1:02:04] Well, I think Don, you've said it very well, and I think that we've at least in my perspective we've discussed this thing, you know, thoroughly. [1:02:13] And I think we're presenting this final resolution, at least when I'm going to present, to the Council for discussion, debate and adoption. [1:02:25] So that's kind of where we're at right now, and I'm very comfortable with it. [1:02:29] Chris, I have a question for you. [1:02:34] Yep, this or a similar resolution were to pass. [1:02:38] What's the consequence of a council violating its own resolutions of this nature? [1:02:44] There isn't a consequence other than somebody calling you on it. [1:02:48] Moral authority then. [1:02:51] That's right. [1:02:52] That's right. [1:02:53] Okay, well I want to make sure the council agrees that we are only doing a feel good [1:02:58] that the spirit of open meetings lies within the individual. [1:03:02] And it doesn't mean that if we do pass this tonight, [1:03:06] it's going to take the burden of proof upon all of us [1:03:09] to be more transparent in the future [1:03:12] than we have been in the past. [1:03:15] I'm a little bit iffy about this. [1:03:17] I think Rebecca is to be committed by starting the debate, [1:03:22] getting with the Attorney General's open meeting law. [1:03:26] It, at first to me, looked like redundancy for us to fail her resolution and move into [1:03:33] our own. [1:03:34] But then upon closer review, it does provide very specific local requirements or recommendations, [1:03:42] I should say, that's only going to be good as this current council that's hot on the subject [1:03:47] now can make it. [1:03:49] Future councils, I would guess, will probably ignore some parts of this. [1:03:53] But I can support it with the inclusion of one amendment. [1:03:57] And I'll be happy to wait until after the debate, and then make my amendment motion or suggestion. [1:04:06] Rebecca, we'll see you. [1:04:08] Thank you, Mayor. [1:04:10] I'm not sure who this question is for, perhaps, Fritz, perhaps the council, but in that section [1:04:17] three second paragraph, the ad hoc volunteer groups intended to report back to the City [1:04:23] Council or commission. [1:04:26] Does that mean that committee groups will not be formed unless they are intended to make [1:04:34] a recommendation? [1:04:36] If not, if there are committees that have some other purpose to discuss issues or so on, I [1:04:43] I guess my question is, will those still be happening being formed and should a commission [1:04:51] or the council create a committee? [1:04:54] Of course if the council creates the committee it will be open to the public and follow open [1:04:57] meeting laws. [1:04:59] But when the commissions create a committee, will those be posted and open to the public? [1:05:06] Yeah, any committee created by a commission planning and zoning commission, historic preservation, [1:05:13] If they committed, create a committee, they're bound by the open meeting law. [1:05:19] Okay. [1:05:20] Let me back up a little bit because Travis came over here after I made the first answer to [1:05:24] Chris and let me make another answer. [1:05:26] So what this resolution is intended to do is, for example, someone reports to the council [1:05:35] we have an opening, let's say historic preservation commission. [1:05:40] like some members of the council to sit in on interviews. So at that point if [1:05:46] Greg says that's a good idea could we have the liaison and ask somebody else [1:05:52] could you guys work on that okay and that's how it's happened in the past with [1:05:57] these I hesitate to call them committees because you never take a vote on them. [1:06:04] Under this resolution, somebody on the council would say, wait a minute, this takes a vote of the council to form the committee. [1:06:18] That's right. [1:06:19] Under this resolution, Greg can't do that. [1:06:23] And if any other member of the council says, hey, I have an idea and I'd like to do this and I'd like another somebody to help me with it. [1:06:31] like to report back to the council, someone else on the council says, wait a minute, that's [1:06:35] in violation of our resolution. We need to have a vote on this. And we need to decide what [1:06:43] authority to give this committee. Once those committees are formed, they are subject to the [1:06:50] open meeting law, and there are definitely violations that are, they're prosecutable, the [1:06:56] violations of the open meeting law. So, Chris, when I'm answering you, there is not recourse. [1:07:02] If you all sit up there and let it happen, under this resolution, you're violating your [1:07:08] resolution because each one of you will be allowed it to happen. [1:07:11] So it's not like you're going to get prosecuted, you're violated your own resolution. [1:07:15] But once you form the committee, every committee that is formed is liable as anybody else is [1:07:22] under the Open Meeting Law. [1:07:25] Let me just point out a couple of other things because we talked about a number of scenarios [1:07:29] with Jim and Dawn. This will not cover if Chief Pike calls up Jim and Dawn and says [1:07:38] we need some help with our use of force policy. Could you come over, you know, you're attached [1:07:46] to the CSILon enforcement program. Can you come over and help us out? This will not cover [1:07:51] that. Because the Council has nothing to do with it. It's not the creation of the Council. [1:07:57] It's an issue between the chief of police and these two council members to help them out. [1:08:02] On the other hand, we had a group of runners I never can think of their name. [1:08:09] The what? [1:08:10] The Magic Valley Trail and the instrument community. [1:08:13] So if they have made presentations to you and if one of you says, hey, would you guys [1:08:20] mind getting together, coming back with some specific recommendations to us, under this, [1:08:27] the rest of you should call foul on that. [1:08:29] You should say, wait a minute, we need to vote on this. [1:08:33] And even though none of them is on the council, you're trying to create a committee that would [1:08:39] belong to you and would report back to you. [1:08:43] So you would require a vote in that case. [1:08:45] So those are two sort of opposite scenarios. [1:08:49] scenarios, but I know there's a bunch of lights, but to clarify that however [1:08:53] They can certainly go out and meet and call one of us to ask some questions [1:08:57] Absolutely, and and and as long as we're not creating it or or saying we should you should bring us back recommendations [1:09:04] That's it that's a volunteer group that can come back and give us recommendations. That's right. That's right [1:09:10] Which is anybody? [1:09:12] Basically any system [1:09:15] Anyway, it's only when it appears to the public [1:09:18] You guys are sitting up here and you're sort of, but not voting on it, but sort of a committee [1:09:25] is being created, then under this resolution, it's a responsibility of every one of you to [1:09:32] say, wait a minute, we need to have a vote on this. [1:09:36] Schomburg. [1:09:37] A little follow up to the consequences of violating this, so if something happens and none of us [1:09:47] call ourselves out on it. Does this resolution though throw it into the open meeting law, [1:09:53] Bailey Wick, that a citizen or a complaint could be filed about some action that took [1:09:58] place that it would be prosecutable? It's a resolution without penalties. And using the [1:10:12] Magic Valley Trail Enhancement Committee example again, suppose they never came to a [1:10:16] a counsel person, they went to Dennis Boyer. [1:10:20] They're not your committee and brought any recommendations. [1:10:23] Not covered, not covered. [1:10:25] OK. [1:10:26] What if Dennis called me as the liaison to the counsel [1:10:30] after they called him and said, hey, this group wants [1:10:33] to get together and come up with some information [1:10:35] to bring back to the counsel, what do you think? [1:10:38] It's not covered, because it's not [1:10:40] a creation of the counsel. [1:10:42] OK. [1:10:51] Who's that on? [1:10:53] following that train of thought, the Magic Valley Air Show Committee. [1:10:57] I've worked and served on their board and helped them with decisions, and they do come [1:11:02] back and make recommendations here or bring information on the air shows since it's our [1:11:06] airport. [1:11:08] How does that fit into this? [1:11:12] I think they are, I think they're 501C3 now. [1:11:17] They're working on it. [1:11:18] They aren't at this point in time yet. [1:11:22] As far as I know, they're a volunteer group that are a volunteer even without you guys. [1:11:28] Maybe I'm wrong about that, but I think they're doing their own thing. [1:11:31] And the fact that it involves our airport and they may come to you and make presentations [1:11:37] about what they want to do, they're not your committee. [1:11:40] But they have city funds in their account? [1:11:45] I don't know if they do or they don't know. [1:11:48] Travis, I don't believe they do at this point in order. [1:11:49] I had a surplus from the last air show, [1:11:52] it's my understanding, they have some amount of money. [1:11:56] They have funds that are theirs, [1:12:00] that we're holding in trust for them, [1:12:04] until they can complete the paperwork of the 501C3 [1:12:09] and then it is our intention to provide that to them. [1:12:13] If we have not already, [1:12:15] one of the conversations that Lori and Grace [1:12:17] than I recently had was because they have a person overseeing their finances. [1:12:25] I asked, and we had the conversation, [1:12:28] doesn't make any sense for us to retain the possession or the funds of another entity [1:12:34] that is not one of the cities. [1:12:38] Even though they utilize our airport for their, for the event, [1:12:45] It's really in a sense similar to Western days and the effect that you have the Western [1:12:50] days committee that utilizes our park or their event. [1:12:56] I think where the confusion is is that we have forwarded money or fronted them money in [1:13:01] the past, but they reimbursed it. [1:13:03] But we, they should have the seed money from this point on. [1:13:07] I, is their goal. [1:13:09] Yes. [1:13:10] Okay. [1:13:11] No conflict with me working with that board and being on city council. [1:13:15] Yeah, okay Suzanne, I want to explain this. [1:13:19] This has nothing to do with you as an individual councilman. [1:13:23] It has to do with this group. [1:13:25] Okay. [1:13:26] And if it looks like they're creating. [1:13:27] So your example, if they haven't created this committee, you're just sitting on a committee, [1:13:33] not a committee of the council. [1:13:35] Even if they come to the council to make a recommendation to do something at the airport [1:13:38] for us. [1:13:39] They do that unless this council appoints them and authorizes them to come back with recommendations. [1:13:46] Otherwise, they're doing their own thing, they want to make a recommendation. [1:13:50] I think they want more than a recommendation, probably they want permission and other things, but yeah. [1:13:57] And in your opinion, what we have been doing still meets the letter of the law for Idaho Open Meetings, [1:14:05] and what we're doing now is going above and beyond what most other cities and entities do [1:14:11] to be even more open and transparent than what's required of us. [1:14:16] I can't tell you what others do. I can tell you that what you've done in the past [1:14:22] is in compliance with the open meeting law. [1:14:27] What this will do is above and beyond the open meeting law. [1:14:31] And in your opinion, we are not [1:14:34] Going so far above and beyond that we're going to limit ourselves and our ability to do the job. We've been elected to do [1:14:49] Okay [1:14:51] I had my name [1:14:54] Next up I want to I want to revisit the [1:14:58] because most of the committees that were in question were the ones where we're [1:15:05] pointing to the you know the our litany of our array of commissions and boards [1:15:14] that we appoint people to I guess I want to be sure you know obviously there [1:15:22] aren't gonna be anymore and then because we typically change mayors every two [1:15:27] years that there won't be any more that I'll be naming, but I'd certainly like to know what [1:15:33] the information is for whoever is the next mayor. We had been, we think it's been outlined [1:15:41] very well in the past, it's been the mayor and the liaison, the chairman of that committee [1:15:46] and the staff member who's conducted the interview. This particular resolution, would they still [1:16:00] will be need, let's say, let's throw examples, that's what we've been doing, so let's throw [1:16:04] out the example. Since it's the mayor's, under Idaho, lots of mayor's job to appoint these [1:16:11] people with confirmation by the council, full council. First example, if I just decide [1:16:19] to interview them by myself and remember with maybe a staff member and then bring an appointment [1:16:27] to the council, would that be covered in needing to be posted and open? [1:16:32] No, because the council had nothing to do with the creation of that group. That was simply you. Okay second example [1:16:39] if I decide to have the chairman of the [1:16:43] Committee and a staff member does that change it at all? No, the focus always has to be on the council [1:16:51] If the council if you talk about it in council meeting, we're gonna do this [1:16:55] Everyone kind of sits there and they don't object or whatever. It sort of looks like [1:16:59] like you're creating a committee. [1:17:02] If you never talk about it to the council, [1:17:05] they can't make any claim toward that committee. [1:17:07] Okay. [1:17:09] Thank you. [1:17:10] We're very well selected. [1:17:11] Thank you, Mayor. [1:17:12] I still have the question of whether this resolution [1:17:16] prohibits whoever the mayor is the mayor [1:17:20] to create a committee and appoint citizens [1:17:23] or invite certain citizens and certain individuals [1:17:27] to discuss public business if they're not going to make a formal recommendation to the council. [1:17:33] It does not prohibit the mayor or any one of you for that matter from having a group of whoever, whether or not. [1:17:41] Even if you do plan to make a recommendation because the rest of the council members have to know about it and it has to appear that the council is creating it not you personally. [1:17:51] Yeah. Thank you for clarifying that. That is a concern of mine because my original intent [1:17:58] was to not really abolish committees because I think they're a great tool but to open up [1:18:03] that discussion and deliberation of public business to the public, you know, and just [1:18:09] have it posted and noticed. So I'm not sure that this resolution accomplishes the same [1:18:15] thing, but perhaps it's a step in the right direction, but I'm just not sure, I mean, [1:18:22] if it's not prohibiting these groups from happening, a real concern of mine is that staff can [1:18:29] then invite or include certain council members without the knowledge of the full council [1:18:36] on discussion groups or so on and so forth, and I am just not sure how that will work, [1:18:42] And maybe my final question will be, if this resolution passes, how does that affect, say, [1:18:48] the Committee on Economic Development that has certain community members invited and sitting [1:18:54] on a committee and certain council members of that group going to remain unchanged by [1:18:59] this resolution? [1:19:00] So, let me kind of maybe go back because I think it's important to understand how the [1:19:09] the committee came or the group came to be, and then give you my recommendation of what [1:19:15] it should look like in moving forward. [1:19:19] So when we went forward with the, after the Chibani project, because of how the city had [1:19:27] been engaged in economic development, it was one of those things that was placed into my [1:19:31] review. [1:19:32] And I believe it was about 2011-ish, I think it was 2011 review. [1:19:38] That's correct. [1:19:39] Because the Chibani signing occurred on November 3rd of 2011, I want to say it was in the 2011 [1:19:45] review, where one of the goals that the Council said for me was the creation of an economic [1:19:49] development ready team. [1:19:51] That would be there to guide and to assist in bringing economic development partners to [1:19:59] the same table. [1:20:00] Because one of the things that we found through that entire process is that there were many [1:20:05] different people who had many different ideas about economic development that had not been [1:20:10] working in concert together for some time. And so the idea was, upon reflection of the [1:20:17] Chabani project, to find a way to maybe make that smoother. And so I created a group and [1:20:25] that group has advised me and the things that we've had conversations about really have [1:20:32] never came to the council. In fact, when we talk about economic development deals, like [1:20:38] the deal sheet, the important pieces, it was often a report back to them after we've had [1:20:43] the conversation and the engagement from the councils. In the Cliff Bar project, this was [1:20:48] a group that did a lot of homework assignments. We had a RF request for information, an RFI [1:20:57] But at the end of the day, I think it wanted to expand probably beyond 110, 112 pages and [1:21:03] it covered every single aspect of our community. [1:21:05] And so it required different field expertise to be able to come in and put that information [1:21:11] into a single document moving forward. [1:21:15] And I think that it's worked well and I think it's worked effectively. [1:21:18] But I also believe that it's time for something that was born in a review of the city manager [1:21:26] to grow and become something of the Council. [1:21:31] I really believe that as we look at [1:21:35] economic development as we move forward, [1:21:37] it is one of probably the most critical things [1:21:40] that we've identified, and we've talked about that [1:21:42] in our strategic planning process. [1:21:44] It is one of the seven external drivers of our community [1:21:48] when it comes to economic development. [1:21:51] It is also one of those things. [1:21:52] It is probably without question one of the things that impacts our community the most. [1:22:02] And impacts are probably really based upon your perceptions or your feelings or your [1:22:09] experiences. [1:22:10] And so they can be both positive and admittedly negative for some. [1:22:15] So kind of the next phase with the hopes that a resolution tonight does pass. [1:22:22] The next piece of, of, during my council report was to recommend to the council looking at [1:22:30] a series of different work groups that we've had and going through a formalized process. [1:22:35] And I have a list and, and we can't talk about them tonight and we can't make any official [1:22:41] declarations tonight because it wasn't agendized. [1:22:47] But we want, I wanted to prime the pump this evening, if you will, to say these are the [1:22:52] groups and these are the things that we need to be thinking about and I think that one [1:22:55] of those things is the economic development ready team and that team I think is ready to [1:23:00] become a full-blown officially recognized committee of the City Council and I think it makes sense [1:23:14] with the strategic planning objectives that we have in moving forward. Obviously with something [1:23:18] that I created, so I have, hopefully, I can maybe participate in what that formation looks [1:23:24] like because it really works well with partners, and I believe that what we talk about, people [1:23:31] will be, I don't want to say bored, but I don't think that it's going to be as interesting [1:23:40] as some would believe. [1:23:42] Now, what I will say is there will be times [1:23:47] where this group will need to, like all groups, [1:23:51] will need to go into an executive session style approach [1:23:54] when they're having actual conversations [1:23:57] about actual potential economic development deals, [1:24:01] and that is permitted under Idaho Code. [1:24:03] We signed confidentiality agreements [1:24:05] that state that we will not talk about projects publicly, [1:24:10] The result of talking about projects publicly can result in the possibility of losing out [1:24:17] on being considered moving forward as was discussed very clearly by the individual who [1:24:23] led the Cliff Bar case and project. [1:24:26] So there may be times when we get a lead from the state or we're talking about what the Council's [1:24:33] recommendation in terms of an economic development incentive package may look like or other partners. [1:24:41] It will be important that we recognize that there is still a retained right to have those [1:24:47] conversations when needed and when appropriate and in accordance with the executive session [1:24:54] statutes of 67, 235, subsection 1. [1:24:59] I think it's A through H. [1:25:01] He is the specific one that deals with academic development. [1:25:07] So a follow-up question to that, Fritz, does a volunteer committee like that have the ability [1:25:13] to go into an executive session or would that be following making it a formal committee? [1:25:19] Following, if they're not a committee, then they don't need to do anything. [1:25:23] If you make them a committee, then they have to comply with the open meetings law. [1:25:27] if they're dealing with a economic development situation where we're competing with entities [1:25:34] and other states or nations, then they can do an executive session, yes. [1:25:39] Okay. [1:25:40] And to follow up with that, I think that generally the input from the community on our economic [1:25:46] development model is very positive, but I have to say that the only negative input that I've [1:25:50] have gotten from citizens is that they wanted to be more involved and have their concerns [1:25:58] considered on the front end. [1:25:59] I mean, the way it happens for the public is we issue a 24-hour notice that we're having [1:26:05] a meeting. [1:26:06] We come to the meeting. [1:26:07] There's very little discussion. [1:26:08] We approve it. [1:26:09] It's a done deal. [1:26:10] And I recognize the importance of keeping those things confidential, and we do have the executive [1:26:16] session provision, and I hope in meeting law. [1:26:20] But I think that it would be a good idea, I agree, to make that a more formalized process [1:26:25] so that citizens might have an avenue for their concerns or thoughts that they would want to [1:26:34] have input on what direction we're going as far as our economic development. [1:26:40] And a concern that I have is that the citizens currently as a system is, the citizens that [1:26:45] are chosen to be a part of this committee do have some insider knowledge. [1:26:51] They have knowledge that the public doesn't have and sometimes those citizens are the ones [1:26:58] that are involved in the land sales and the representation of these very lucrative land [1:27:04] purchase deals. [1:27:06] And so I would hope that we would rotate those members and get more input rather than just [1:27:12] have a select few on this committee. I think that we need to definitely rotate the membership [1:27:18] of that committee. [1:27:19] Well, it does rotate to a certain degree because we have the tier two, which I'm going to suggest [1:27:25] that we formalize as well or not, and though I have to look at it, but we're obviously going [1:27:32] to be opening it anyway so it doesn't matter. The ready team is actually drawn from members [1:27:39] of that group to get their expertise. It's not exactly the same ready team people every [1:27:44] week, but maybe go ahead and probably leave them down the wrong path. You should go ahead [1:27:48] Travis. [1:27:49] No, so I think that if you formalize the economic development ready team anytime they meet, they [1:27:55] must meet in accordance with this. So by virtue of formalizing one, your actual form, actually [1:28:02] formalizing everything that we do in the area that we've been doing in the area of economic [1:28:08] development, which is, you know, and I believe that's probably a really good appropriate step. [1:28:14] You know, like I said, this is a committee that has been for the sole purpose of advising [1:28:19] me in the area of economic development because of what we've done, and the members of that [1:28:26] represent all of those partners that had to learn how to collaborate as we were learning [1:28:32] how to work through the Chibani project. [1:28:37] I'm going to change directions for a minute, see in Melinda sitting out there and thinking [1:28:42] that the URA and the library are kind of under the city umbrella but not under the city council. [1:28:50] Does this affect anything that they do, their organization, their meetings or how does this [1:28:56] play down to the two of them? [1:28:58] Urban Renewal Agency, although associated directly with the city as an independent agency, [1:29:05] So in order for them to follow this, they would have to adopt a similar resolution. [1:29:12] Library Board, I'll have to think about that one. [1:29:16] I don't know if they're the same or different. [1:29:17] That's the question. [1:29:21] Yeah, that's the one confusing that most people want to think that it's a two and [1:29:26] fours room, you know, but it's, it's, it's, they are a separate entity with their own [1:29:31] board. [1:29:32] We do appoint their members, but they, they operate under their own specific things. [1:29:37] we can certainly urge them to look at a similar. [1:29:40] I would argue much stronger than is attached. [1:29:42] When you get a chance, can you maybe follow up on the library? [1:29:46] All those stiffer rules. [1:29:47] That would be my interpretation as a non-lawyer. [1:29:51] Yeah, but that's the problem. [1:29:52] As a non-lawyer, I think that they are a separate entity. [1:29:55] And so I don't know the reason. [1:29:56] And they wouldn't exist without the ability [1:29:58] to utilize the Twin Falls Municipal Tax direction. [1:30:02] It's not only that it's actually [1:30:03] the Twin Falls County tax structure. [1:30:06] Ditto, whatever, city and or county. [1:30:10] And he's actually just a county. [1:30:13] Where do you, you're going to go ahead Travis. [1:30:18] The Twin Falls Public Library's tax rate is included [1:30:25] in the city of Twin Falls's global tax rate. [1:30:28] And we will supply them with a drawdown [1:30:32] of their appropriation request. [1:30:35] their library budget is created by their library board and works closely [1:30:42] with Susan Ash and the members of the library's team in the creation of that budget. [1:30:48] They do generally share what they're looking at. [1:30:53] We don't, as a staff, go through a intensive review of the library budget [1:30:59] because of, you know, the really, Susan does not report to me. [1:31:07] She reports to her library board. [1:31:11] Her library board is appointed by the council. [1:31:15] So their review of that budget, their creation of that budget really comes through us. [1:31:22] And we provide a proportionate share of the tax rate and any increases to them and they live within their structured means just as any other city department would. [1:31:37] But if they form their own subcommittee to research a new project would they have to, would that fall under this resolution anyway for open meeting laws? [1:31:49] Can they do their own thing or are we affecting them with this? [1:31:52] So I think those are two different points. [1:31:56] If they create a committee to report back to them, [1:32:01] they're under the open meeting law. [1:32:05] But the different question is, is if the board trustee says, [1:32:09] hey, I have an idea about whatever would somebody serve on that? [1:32:14] I mean, then the question is, does this resolution, [1:32:19] I mean, off the top of my head, I'm going to say probably [1:32:21] It doesn't think that they're independent of the city in that sense, just like the Urban [1:32:26] Renewal Agency is, but certainly the Council can recommend to those entities that they follow [1:32:34] this or adopt their own like this. [1:32:36] And as they lay us into the library, I can tell you the operating word for that group is [1:32:41] independent. [1:32:43] They have not heated my direction at all. [1:32:47] Perhaps to their betterment. [1:32:48] I'm sure. [1:32:49] You know, I just wanted to add the URA library, I've never thought about the library, that's [1:32:56] a great question, Suzanne, but the URA is an independent body, certainly closely affiliated [1:33:03] with the city. [1:33:04] I would ask the council to allow them to work through this issue. [1:33:08] I know that they're watching us closely, what we're doing here, give them the opportunity [1:33:13] to not start telling them what we think they should do, let them work through this issue [1:33:18] and see what comes out of it. I think just like us, this has been an evolution, if you will. [1:33:23] This has been a learning process. This has been a great conversation. [1:33:27] Although sometimes it got a little difficult. [1:33:31] But it's been a great conversation and I think it's led us to a good place. [1:33:36] That's my personal theme. Allow these other entities to do the same thing without [1:33:42] Big Brother trying to tell them what to do. [1:33:45] Well, this is all about big brother. [1:33:46] It hasn't been present when he's needed. [1:33:50] According to the Senate of the Council, [1:33:52] and I don't feel comfortable letting urban renewal [1:33:54] do their own thing any more than I do library. [1:33:57] Well, we don't have any authority over on Chris. [1:33:59] So we can, why don't we allow them, [1:34:03] I guess if we're disappointed after a few months [1:34:06] or whatever time period, then let's weigh in, [1:34:09] but let's give them the opportunity, [1:34:10] because I think they're monitoring [1:34:12] what we're doing right now. [1:34:14] So, let's give them the opportunity to look into this themselves. [1:34:18] Thank you. [1:34:18] There's more of an opportunity if we tell them to do something [1:34:21] that they're going to do this, if they get to it on their own. [1:34:24] The state law says that they're an independent non-partisan board. [1:34:27] Right. [1:34:29] Okay, for library. [1:34:31] Okay, subject to open meeting laws, though. [1:34:34] Okay. [1:34:35] That's interesting. [1:34:36] All over and you know, and library board meetings are posted, [1:34:39] open and posted, correct? [1:34:41] Okay. [1:34:42] All right. [1:34:43] So I'd actually like to ask a question of Rebecca, if I may. [1:34:50] So with the last two versions of the new versions of this, do you feel that these meet what you [1:34:57] were after in your resolution? [1:35:00] Because I do think that it will be challenging if we don't have some unanimous support of whatever [1:35:08] or we go after tonight, and I would hate to continue to have [1:35:12] grappling over details that we might not agree on. [1:35:17] So do you feel that it accomplishes what you were after? [1:35:21] Thanks for asking that question, actually. [1:35:24] That's where I'm still trying to decide. [1:35:26] The comments that I've made, I'm not [1:35:30] sure it's addressing the issue that I was trying to address [1:35:34] as far as making committees more open and accessible [1:35:38] to the public bringing the deliberation out in the open. [1:35:42] I think this is a good step in the right direction, [1:35:46] but the things that I would change, [1:35:48] I think the details that I would change are, [1:35:53] this resolution does not prohibit the mayor [1:35:57] from appointing committees. [1:35:58] I mean it will be up to, according to Fritz tonight, [1:36:02] it will be up to the council to call him or her on that. [1:36:05] Is that what you said? [1:36:06] Because I asked the question, does it prohibit the appointment, [1:36:10] pointing of committees? [1:36:12] Let's talk about two ways that could happen. [1:36:14] One is Greg knows that there's a vacancy. [1:36:18] And he appoints with the consent of the council [1:36:22] to those appointments, right? [1:36:24] And that's 30 counts from state code, Greg. [1:36:26] That's right. [1:36:26] So Greg, unknown to the entirety of the council, [1:36:31] gets together with whoever they get together, [1:36:35] they do the interviews, okay? [1:36:38] So it's a group of people, I get troubled [1:36:43] when we throw around this term committee [1:36:45] because a committee seems to imply that somebody [1:36:49] created it and it belongs to somebody, [1:36:52] somebody has authority and it has somebody [1:36:54] to respond back to. [1:36:56] Greg is not an agency. [1:36:59] So anything- [1:37:00] What would you call them just so we can use the same term? [1:37:02] What's that? [1:37:03] Well, instead of committee, what language would you like [1:37:05] So we can be on the same curve. [1:37:07] So I would use the term committee if the council votes to create it and gives them authority [1:37:14] to do something. [1:37:15] I would call it a group of people that Greg wants to help him interview if the council [1:37:21] has no input on what he is doing. [1:37:26] So it could happen two ways. [1:37:28] Greg just does it. [1:37:29] The other way Greg says I'm going to do this and I'm going to have somebody else here on [1:37:34] the council sit with me and so and so it implies that that's being done right here [1:37:40] and at that point under this resolution the council would say wait a minute if [1:37:44] you're going to have a committee let's vote on whether you can have this committee [1:37:48] or not and what they're going to do but if he just does it by himself just as it [1:37:53] if any of you do it by yourself it's not it's not a committee it's a group right [1:37:57] and how would the full council have that knowledge if it would be just right so [1:38:01] So I don't think it's accomplishing the same thing that my resolution wasn't intended to accomplish in that it [1:38:08] Be opening up and making public this deliberation [1:38:12] But I think those are the two concerns one that it could be a staff appointed committee where they invite a couple of council members [1:38:21] Just because of our form of government and I'm not saying you would do that Travis [1:38:25] But in our form of government [1:38:27] government we are one body and we don't have a strong mayor and so I think that's what my [1:38:34] original resolution wasn't intended to address and I'm not sure how this resolution accomplishes [1:38:41] that other than you know it might even do the opposite of making these committees or work [1:38:46] groups that someone gets together making those you know even less in the public eye and even [1:38:56] the council and the public being less aware of it and I really don't think [1:39:00] that's the same goal that I was trying to accomplish. Well I think I'll go ahead [1:39:04] and answer that because it's dealing with the mayoral appointments. Okay and [1:39:12] other mayors may have a different opinion on that. I still have the strong [1:39:16] opinion and that I can do a better job of interviewing those potential [1:39:24] candidates without press their TV camera trained on them or radio broadcast [1:39:31] possibly even doing it live I mean those are all possibilities I can do a [1:39:37] better job of interviewing without that okay and so that's why if I were doing [1:39:44] it in the future and myself out there I guess I would be honest with it to make [1:39:50] sure there are no concerns that there's any spirit of any law being broken or [1:39:57] anything I would just follow the exact Idaho code which every other city in the [1:40:02] Magic Valley does go talk to anybody nobody has these committees or work [1:40:07] groups because they're not really committee and I would probably to make [1:40:12] sure that no one is worries that this any spirit is being broken I would [1:40:17] probably interviewed them myself because but that's my personal opinion as the [1:40:21] mayor then I can do a better job interviewing them now the next mayor may [1:40:26] have a totally different opinion to decide that each one each committee be [1:40:29] formed by the council but I think we have to go back to Idaho code on this and to [1:40:37] be honest with the Idaho code is very specific separate from from the open [1:40:44] meeting law that says that the mayor appoints and the council confirms. Now, if the council [1:40:50] doesn't confirm, you go back and you start over. I still bring the example of where one [1:40:58] of these that came into jeopardy in the concern was whenever we appointed Suzanne, okay, and [1:41:04] we interviewed her separately. And it wasn't two months later that, and I won't say that [1:41:11] And I won't say that it was a city, but one of our nearby cities had an opening on Tuesday, [1:41:18] and two weeks later on Tuesday, the mayor showed up with an appointment, and the council confirmed [1:41:25] there was no interview process. [1:41:26] They just picked one of these buddies and named them. [1:41:29] And I don't think that's right. [1:41:30] I think interviews should be conducted and applications taken and all of those particular [1:41:36] things. [1:41:37] I would never skip that portion of it, but I'm, again, back to personal opinion. [1:41:43] I feel I can choose a better candidate by interviewing those individuals without the [1:41:49] player of the press. [1:41:50] But that's again my personal opinion. [1:41:52] The next mayor may have a different opinion. [1:41:56] So I would be following Idaho Code to the letter to the spirit to everything because that's [1:42:03] what Idaho Code says about appointments. [1:42:07] Don Hall's lights next. [1:42:08] So Fritz, I know we were talking about the mayor making these committees or they're not [1:42:15] committees or work groups or whatever so this is going to prohibit that but it [1:42:18] also prohibits any because he has no more power if you will than any of the [1:42:24] council members so so if I get up here and if I say something like I think we [1:42:28] need a committee to look into this and and Jim and I are going to go do it and [1:42:32] that's when the council says wait that's right you need to formalize that and [1:42:37] that's what this is really accomplishing and that's what my goal is so it's the [1:42:41] transparency, it's the openness, it's the making sure the community knows, and it kind of keeps [1:42:46] us in check. [1:42:47] And I like that. [1:42:48] It gets back to the point that if you have a committee, a committee is responsible to someone [1:42:56] and that someone has to be somebody that's subject to the open meeting law. [1:43:01] So it's the council, any of our statutory commissions that we have are subject to that. [1:43:09] The example, Greg, that you gave of interviewing just individually, because you're the one that's [1:43:17] going to make the appointment, if you ask someone to sit with you, is it suddenly a committee? [1:43:25] And if it is, why? [1:43:26] That's a trouble, Rebecca. [1:43:28] I understand what you're getting at. [1:43:29] I have no idea how to write that, because there are so many ways you can think. [1:43:35] It's a little bit. [1:43:36] It's the eye of the beholder. [1:43:38] You know and it's like I think I think this looks like something that ought to be open to the public [1:43:44] But I can't write a rule that applies to all these others to which is this particular one sort of looks that way [1:43:51] Therefore it ought to be open to the public so [1:43:56] You know if you guys come up with more ideas, I'm willing to work on it [1:44:00] This is the best and talking to Jim and Don the best we've been able to come up with so far [1:44:05] which is talking about a committee being responsive to and reporting back to whoever created them. [1:44:14] Rebecca, you make the point that Mitch, for example, asks Chris, hey, Chris, can you come over and sit with me [1:44:23] and a couple of other people were going to talk about some zoning things. [1:44:29] Unbeknownst to you, it's certainly not a council. They won't be reporting back to you. [1:44:35] It doesn't look like open meeting stuff, it doesn't look like that to me. [1:44:39] But I think to you, it looks like maybe the public got to know about this and we had to post this and stuff. [1:44:46] And so I don't know where you draw the line. [1:44:48] I don't know how to define it, other than has been defined here in saying that it's public business if it's a public agency. [1:45:01] Council's a public agency, Planning and Zoning Commission's public agency, and anything that [1:45:05] they create, and when I say create, I mean, vote for and authorize to do something, is a [1:45:11] sub-agency. But when you get beyond that, I don't know how to define it. I don't know [1:45:16] how to say which ones are and which ones aren't. It's like senior staff meetings. I'm going [1:45:26] to tell you, we have meetings with the police department that they absolutely are not going [1:45:31] let anybody into and there's no exception under the open meeting law if we called it a committee [1:45:38] we call their senior staff a committee there's no exception under the open meeting law. [1:45:43] But it wouldn't be a committee if it were an organization headed by a single individual [1:45:49] who's just doing an internal staff meeting. [1:45:53] Correct? [1:45:54] No, I don't understand how you say that. [1:45:57] So Travis is not, he's exempt from open meeting laws, the governor's exempt from open meeting [1:46:03] laws because he's a single head of an organization. [1:46:06] He's not an agency, Greg's not an agency. [1:46:08] Right, so that's how a police staff meeting would not be open to the public and I wouldn't [1:46:14] suggest that it would be open to the public. [1:46:16] But if Jim Mun comes and sits on it, is it open meeting then? [1:46:20] No, that's not what I'm suggesting. [1:46:24] I'm pretty sure at a prior meeting you didn't want Jim and Don to sit in with the use of [1:46:29] force committee. [1:46:30] Well, I'm saying if there is, my issue is more with deliberation of an issue that will in [1:46:36] the future come before the council. [1:46:39] And if you're deliberating on public business that will say you're making a policy change [1:46:46] and you're deliberating on a policy change that will come before the council, I think [1:46:51] that's the connection. [1:46:52] those groups that he works with that come to you and make recommendations that contain [1:46:57] no council members, it's all staff, but the recommendations are coming to you. [1:47:02] Right, and my resolution dealt with committees that the council is involved in. [1:47:07] It's not a staff committee that I'm concerned about. [1:47:10] It's the council. [1:47:11] And I think this does exactly that because the council is involved in it because the council [1:47:17] knows about it and the council either says, yes, we're going to have this committee or no, [1:47:22] we're not going to have this committee. [1:47:23] But if the council may or may not know about it, [1:47:26] depending on which individual creates it. [1:47:29] Yeah, if the council doesn't know about it, [1:47:31] it obviously can't be their creation. [1:47:33] Yeah, so Don and Jim's sitting on use of force group. [1:47:41] I know you had a problem with that, [1:47:42] like a meeting or two meetings ago, [1:47:44] and I don't know how that fits into what that was. [1:47:46] And I was just using, Jim actually came up to me afterwards, [1:47:49] I was just using that as his example, [1:47:51] you know use of force if it has some type of you know coverage in executive [1:48:00] session or private information or things that that can't be shared with the [1:48:03] public then it would have an exemption but I I just use that example because that [1:48:08] was Jim's example not not because I have an issue with a use of force [1:48:12] committee yeah but but like I said before I don't know I don't know I understand [1:48:17] what you're saying it looks like it ought to be open I don't know how to write [1:48:20] the rules for that. I mean, this is as far as we've been able to get, as clear as we've [1:48:28] been able to get, and beyond that, it's like the I have to be holder, and that's where we [1:48:33] are right now with these committees that we're never voted on. We're in the I have to be holder. [1:48:43] Rebecca, your light was next. You've covered it? [1:48:46] No, actually, I think that was for it's input. But I have a question of the council, then [1:48:51] and kind of along the lines of Councilman Verigars question, [1:48:56] you know, what could we all agree on? [1:48:58] What if, you know, I honestly think the original resolution [1:49:01] of posting these work groups that deliberate [1:49:06] on public business in taking minutes and so on and so forth, [1:49:11] you know, if that resolution were to be amended to say [1:49:16] that the mayor can close interviews [1:49:21] that his discretion, his or her discretion, [1:49:24] and that really the bottom line would be [1:49:27] that no work groups would be formed [1:49:29] for deliberating public business. [1:49:31] I mean, is that something we agree on now, [1:49:33] or are we still back to not agreeing [1:49:36] on when public business should be open to the public? [1:49:41] I guess I would say I'm comfortable with the new resolution, [1:49:45] and I don't need to go back to it, hold them to amend it, [1:49:47] but if I'm comfortable with this one, please. [1:49:50] I see Sean's light on, but you're asking this question. [1:49:54] I don't understand your question. [1:49:56] Sorry. [1:49:58] Okay. [1:50:00] Suzanne, you were starting to talk, I'll catch you off. [1:50:08] Well, the two issues with the original resolution, why I ask that because, and Sean is rightfully [1:50:15] asking, you know, what can we all agree on? [1:50:19] Because I'm uncertain of this resolution, of that it really accomplishes more transparency [1:50:26] instead of less transparency. And half of it is, you know, sections six through nine are [1:50:33] things that are just stating what we already do, which is good, but we already do that, so [1:50:39] I don't feel like we need a resolution for it. My question is, what does this change about [1:50:43] our process? What does this resolution change about the way things are done? And I'm not [1:50:48] really seeing exactly how that works. And so my question is about, you know, the two issues [1:50:55] that the council disagreed with the original resolution was one, they needed to protect [1:51:02] interviews for appointments. And the second was, you know, it was too much work or too [1:51:11] much burden on staff and too expensive. So I think we've taken care of that aspect, but [1:51:17] I'm not sure that, you know, so the only reservation would be on the original resolution would be [1:51:28] that the mayor could close these interviews at his discretion, his or her discretion. [1:51:35] I'm just, you know, I also am unclear what this resolution accomplishes, so I was just [1:51:42] trying to find some sort of unity, as Sean suggested, but perhaps I'm looking at it differently. [1:51:51] I'm going to go down to that one, so that one is a good question, Rebecca. [1:51:56] I think what this does is it clarifies, and I think it's just an evolution, starting with [1:52:01] your resolution, moving to the second one, moving to the third one, after listening to [1:52:07] Council debate and input from staff and Frits and others. [1:52:13] I think what it truly does is it tells the mayor [1:52:20] or the council that any time that we are up here, [1:52:24] or any of our commissions or committees, [1:52:26] any time that we say we're going to put together [1:52:29] a committee to review something, [1:52:32] then we need to stop and actually formalize that committee [1:52:36] so that it is attached to the open meeting law, [1:52:39] it's noticed, there are minutes of some form taken, [1:52:45] whether that's recording or handwritten notes. [1:52:49] Trying to get to the spirit of I think your resolution, [1:52:52] I think this is just because of the evolution process [1:52:55] and the discussion. [1:52:56] I think this is a clearer resolution. [1:52:59] And I'm more in support of this than trying to go back [1:53:02] to two resolutions ago and try to clarify it out. [1:53:06] one. The more I listen to the debate tonight, the more I'm clear about this resolution and [1:53:14] I think it's getting to where you're trying to get. Maybe it's not completely there yet. [1:53:20] And maybe there's some work we can do in the future on these issues, but I think it's a good [1:53:25] step forward as you accept. [1:53:27] I can't believe I'm going to say this out loud, but I honestly, I am I feel like the longer [1:53:39] we debate this issue, the further away from the state of goal of what we're trying to do. [1:53:46] If our goal and our practice is full transparency and all that we do, I think after the discussion [1:53:54] with Fritz, that the perception that one of us is seen some place with a group of people [1:54:02] having a discussion about something that someone decides is city business. [1:54:07] The perception is you went out and created a committee and didn't tell your fellow buddies [1:54:12] up on the council, DS, because you didn't want to get busted by late in the city, the [1:54:17] open meeting law, which I don't say that is the intent of any of us, but if we're talking [1:54:23] about perception, which is what a lot of this resolution talks about. [1:54:26] I think we create more opportunity for perception problems than we do in the rules. [1:54:34] I actually would argue that what we're talking about is not so much about transparency. [1:54:39] It's about do we have too many groups working on stuff. [1:54:43] And if it's important enough to have a group go work on it, maybe it's important enough [1:54:47] that we just do it. [1:54:49] If it's important enough to have a group then let's follow the law and make it a formal committee [1:54:55] Which we already have laws for and don't need a resolution for because I really feel like the longer we [1:55:02] Think through what might happen. It creates more perception or reality that we're circumventing our own rules when we don't intend to [1:55:18] Trying to answer your question as specific as as I understood it [1:55:22] I think that this is an improvement over the original resolution, Rebecca, because it's [1:55:27] much more specific to municipal operations. [1:55:31] You ask that it doesn't offer any guidance. [1:55:35] Section 2 refers to physical posting and hyperlinking the calendar's section 5, list 15 specific [1:55:44] areas the city will commit to providing full accountability to. [1:55:51] I think it's a much more specific address of the need for public disclosure than the somewhat [1:55:59] hazy resolution that doesn't address ad hoc committees. [1:56:04] But I must warn that even with the passing of this, we have had in the past and we will [1:56:09] in the future not currently have people not committed to public access of municipal government [1:56:18] and they will twist and turn and misuse this, it gets back to the intent of the individual. [1:56:25] This provides some clarifications hopefully with my amendment that will make it much stronger [1:56:31] tool to show what should not and must be done, should not be done and must be done. [1:56:38] Hey, we can't have an amendment until we have a main motion. [1:56:42] I'm aware of that. [1:56:43] Yeah. [1:56:44] So, we've got to make sure that we have one another. [1:56:46] I was laving up to you guys to make a motion. I just want to amend it. All right [1:56:51] I've seen Jim on well, let's get a motion going. Shall we sure I would move approval of what's the resolution number [1:57:00] Resolution number numero. What is it again? Really? [1:57:04] 1912 resolution number 1912 was written second [1:57:09] It's been moved by Jim on and seconded by Don Hall that we [1:57:13] the approved resolution 1912 as presented. [1:57:18] Chris, I would move to amend the resolution 1912 [1:57:23] to include in the section three new paragraph three, [1:57:28] the statement, no more than two elected city council [1:57:32] persons may serve on any committee, [1:57:35] including ad hoc groups and subcommittees [1:57:38] created by statute, ordinance or legislative act. [1:57:44] second. [1:57:46] Did you say that we're better? [1:57:48] I did. [1:57:49] I did. [1:57:50] Very good for sure. [1:57:51] Don't know. [1:57:52] Okay. [1:57:53] Chris, so I'm just trying to understand your motion. [1:57:54] I think I have it. [1:57:59] The paragraph would add that if it's created by a legislative act or could you walk through [1:58:06] that one more time for me, please? [1:58:08] No more than two elected city council persons may serve on any committee, including ad [1:58:14] hot groups on subcommittees created by statute, ordinance, or legislative act. [1:58:20] Thank you. [1:58:21] In defense of the amendment, Mayor, three in my consideration has been an unholy alliance [1:58:31] of counsel and creates a de facto decision-making group. [1:58:35] This puts a limit on that. [1:58:37] I agree with the except for the unholy. [1:58:41] I don't think anybody will ever put one together. [1:58:46] never put one together thinking about that. It was just that was the number that was less than full [1:58:51] council. I just agree I'm terrible. I think so. We have a chumber. So I'd like to actually ask [1:59:00] for Rebecca a question again. So again I think it's important that we have unanimous support for [1:59:09] this because we will continue to debate this for the rest of our y'all eternity. Are there items [1:59:17] I appreciate your concerns that you expressed earlier about sort of mayoral [1:59:22] appointments formally or informally. Do you feel that this resolution still [1:59:30] meets what you were after with your resolution? I don't. My answer is the [1:59:36] same. I don't feel like it meets and I actually agree with a lot of your [1:59:39] comments about, you know, if we, that really my perspective is that no work group should [1:59:50] be formed except for by the body of the council. [1:59:54] And if it's an important issue, then we should do it ourselves or we should formally make [1:59:57] a committee. [1:59:58] This resolution doesn't prohibit that. [2:00:01] It definitely encourages us not to do it, but it certainly doesn't prohibit it. [2:00:07] And it doesn't, what I was trying to accomplish is to open the debates and the deliberation [2:00:13] portion of the decision to the public. [2:00:16] And this resolution doesn't address opening it to the public unless it's formed by the council, [2:00:22] which is already the state law. [2:00:24] It's already the law that if a committee is formed by the council, it shall adhere to open [2:00:30] meeting laws, which is why, I mean, it's a good resolution in that it's very descriptive [2:00:35] of what we already do, it says in section one that the City of Twin Falls will abide [2:00:40] by open meeting law and section two goes on to say what we already do [2:00:46] in posting our meetings online on the calendar. [2:00:50] And then sections really five through nine are ready to describe what we do, [2:00:57] which is good, but my concern is the change. [2:01:02] And I guess where Fritz and I disagree is I don't believe [2:01:05] that we have to go down an unending philosophical debate [2:01:10] about what is or isn't a committee. [2:01:12] I think that we can decide whether a group is being formed [2:01:16] that involves staff, few council members, few citizens, [2:01:20] and that they're deliberating on public business. [2:01:23] That should be open to the public. [2:01:24] I really think it's a very basic concept. [2:01:28] If you're asking me, you're concerned about my final vote. [2:01:32] If that's what you're concerned with. [2:01:34] I don't know what to tell you. [2:01:36] What I'm trying to do is bait you then to make some amendments to this that might make it more [2:01:40] comfortable for all of us because I agree with many of your comments as well. [2:01:44] I agree and actually I have a few amendments I've been planning but I've been waiting for [2:01:48] my turn. I'll wait for Chris for these amendments and [2:01:52] perhaps people will agree or not. But like I said and it's difficult [2:01:56] to work with this framework of a resolution that is very different than where I perceive [2:02:02] the intent of the original resolution is going. [2:02:06] And so I will certainly do my best and I certainly hope for unanimous verdict so to speak, but [2:02:12] I really can't speak to that right now with respect to you. [2:02:16] All right, we do have an amendment on the floor and I've seen the lights pause. [2:02:20] We're going to come from last week. [2:02:22] No lights. [2:02:23] The aye or roll call vote on the amendment to limit any committees to two city councilmen. [2:02:30] No more than two. [2:02:31] No more than two. [2:02:34] Yes. [2:02:35] Yes. [2:02:36] Yes. [2:02:37] Yes. [2:02:38] Yes. [2:02:39] Yes. [2:02:40] Yes. [2:02:41] Yes. [2:02:42] Yes. [2:02:43] Yes. [2:02:44] Yes. [2:02:45] Yes. [2:02:46] Yes. [2:02:47] Okay. [2:02:48] The main motion has been amended to include a paragraph in section three. [2:02:54] that would allow that no more than two city council members [2:02:58] would serve on any committee [2:03:00] separate of the Holy Alliance coming. [2:03:04] We're back. [2:03:08] Yes. [2:03:11] All right. [2:03:12] It has been two hours. [2:03:13] That's a good point. [2:03:14] Thank you. [2:03:15] Well, we were just asked for five minutes. [2:03:20] 708. [2:03:21] I'm going to turn you in. [2:03:23] All right. [2:09:59] I reconvene the December 2nd, 2013 meeting of the Twin Falls [2:10:07] Council. I believe that Rebecca has the floor for a possible [2:10:11] amendment. Thank you, Mayor. I have two small amendments. One, I would move to [2:10:20] delete in section three, paragraph two, the first sentence, delete the [2:10:26] words intended to report back to the City Council or commission. The reason for [2:10:32] second paragraph, second paragraph, [2:10:37] section three, first sentence. [2:10:39] So would you underline it for us? [2:10:43] I'm not sure I see what she's saying. [2:10:46] I'm not finding it either. [2:10:48] Do you have a different resolution? [2:10:52] The reason why I should have prefaced the amendment with this is that I'm really not sure [2:11:03] I'm really not sure how we decide if a group is intended to report back to the City Councilor [2:11:09] Commission and I feel like that part's probably irrelevant if there's a group discussing city [2:11:14] business whether they bring a formal recommendation to the City Council or not. So I think it would [2:11:21] just be cleaner to delete from intended to report back to the City Councilor Commission. [2:11:26] So you're just getting rid of the word intended? [2:11:31] to report back to the City Council or Commission, [2:11:34] so that the sentence would read, [2:11:36] in order to provide more transparency in city government, [2:11:39] neither the Twin Falls City Council nor any of its commissions [2:11:41] will permit the formation of ad hoc volunteer groups, [2:11:44] unless that group is formed as a committee or commission [2:11:48] created by a vote of the City Council or commission. [2:11:52] Second. [2:11:57] Can we ask Fritz to weigh in on that [2:11:59] and tell us how that affects it? [2:12:02] Because I'm not sure. [2:12:06] First you have a, can you give us your thoughts? [2:12:26] I don't understand what the consequences are. [2:12:33] So I think your intention is, I just, I have to keep using [2:12:45] hypotheticals so I can think about how it works. [2:12:53] The mayor says I have an idea. [2:12:57] I'd like to have, I'd like to get some people together [2:13:05] to do garbage pickup on the in the city parks or the city trails, along the city trails. [2:13:16] And I'd like to have somebody else join me and then we'll get some other citizens to [2:13:20] go along with that. [2:13:24] The council would have to say stop, you cannot do that because it requires a vote of the council. [2:13:34] My intent would be for committees that are discussing public business not doing okay, so this doesn't do that [2:13:40] So you need you need to you need another you need to revise that so that it talks about [2:13:48] Discussing public business without regard to whether they report back okay, okay, and then to discuss public business [2:13:59] Shumber so maybe I'll ask the authors of the original sense there [2:14:05] again speaking in a hypothetical so this is a a group shows up there on the agenda [2:14:11] for a council meeting and they say hey we're an ad hoc volunteer group and we'd [2:14:16] like to go do thus and such public business and report back to you that [2:14:23] would need to be formed by my boss so what this is saying is if that were to [2:14:27] occur with the intent to report back since they stated that they can't do that [2:14:35] that unless we make them official, the question mark. [2:14:39] That was my part, yeah. [2:14:42] So that same group comes and does the same thing [2:14:47] without the sentence intended to report back [2:14:49] to the city council. [2:14:52] We're gonna go talk about some public business [2:14:54] and we may or may not come back to you. [2:14:58] Yeah, and that's my question is what does it matter [2:15:02] if they're bringing back, [2:15:04] because if they're just going to discuss, [2:15:06] Well, my question, I guess, to the original authors, like Sean, [2:15:10] what's the purpose of a group if they're not [2:15:12] bringing a recommendation to the council? [2:15:14] What is, you know, but that's my question. [2:15:16] Is there apparently our groups that have discussion, [2:15:21] and this isn't prohibiting that? [2:15:24] So. [2:15:25] And I think maybe to get back to your resolution [2:15:27] from a couple of weeks ago, this deals [2:15:29] with the making a recommendation part of the code, [2:15:35] but not the deliberation part. [2:15:37] So they may come and say, hey, we're [2:15:40] going to go talk about all these great things. [2:15:42] And that is one piece of what that makes that a quote. [2:15:47] And it's part of deliberation. [2:15:49] And I guess the real qualifier, as Fritz was saying, [2:15:55] to clarify, if staff is involved, I [2:15:59] think that's the only place that it would matter. [2:16:02] if it's a committee unrelated to the city, [2:16:05] unrelated to staff, then it wouldn't matter. [2:16:08] But I think that's what we're talking. [2:16:11] We're talking about work groups that bring together citizens, [2:16:14] staff members, and council members [2:16:19] to deliberate on public business. [2:16:23] So all amended, Fritz, is that your recommendation? [2:16:26] I'll amend my amendment to your wording. [2:16:30] Since you've helped form this resolution, [2:16:32] What would your wording, what would your recommendation [2:16:34] of wording be? [2:16:36] Yeah, I'm just trying to think about the possibilities. [2:16:40] I was just pointing out that this had no limits on it, [2:16:43] so it's like Greg's cleanup committee could not form. [2:16:46] He could not have a cleanup committee [2:16:47] if he talked about it here unless you voted for it. [2:16:50] Right, so what wording could we would you recommend [2:16:52] to change that? [2:16:53] And so your idea of getting back to public policy, [2:16:55] but it's like I'm just trying to imagine how this council would [2:17:02] talk about something unless they expected something back from that group, I mean, and [2:17:07] if it's not, if the council never talks about it, so I think you're getting, you're [2:17:12] still concerned about the ones, like, let's say Travis has, I don't know what kind of a [2:17:17] work group he puts together, and he has two council members to sit on it with him, okay? [2:17:23] Are you wanting to, that one, are you wanting Travis's group to be open to the public, they're [2:17:29] going to talk about public business? [2:17:31] It is public business not covered by executive session. Yes. Okay, so that's totally getting away from that [2:17:37] It's not your committee. You don't have anything you have nothing to say about it because it's it's not yours [2:17:42] But but yet members of the body are on it. Yeah, even though it's not theirs. I mean, that's a minor detail. Yes [2:17:49] So where are we on this amendment? Well, we're we have a second. We're still discussing it. We have a motion and a second and I [2:17:59] I don't think I'm, I'm, I see no lights, so I guess maybe a tunnel. [2:18:07] Okay, I guess I'm confused by it. [2:18:10] If your intention is to say that any group, the Kiwanas, the optimists, the dog park folks, [2:18:22] the anybody that wants to put together a group to talk about city issues, and that could [2:18:29] be anything could be trails could be dog park could be anything and they invite [2:18:34] one of us to come and give input and and and and then so that we can actually [2:18:39] come back to the council and discuss to the council in a public forum what this [2:18:45] committee discussed you're trying to make that an open meeting law issue no no well [2:18:54] that's where that's where it seems like to me Rebecca so I'm okay so I'll clarify [2:18:58] I'll clarify. [2:18:59] If you don't understand after this, that's okay, your own comprehension is your responsibility. [2:19:06] So, after this, the sentence reads in order to provide more transparency in city government. [2:19:15] Neither the Twin Falls City Council nor any of its commissions will permit the formation [2:19:19] of ad hoc volunteer groups unless that group is formed as a committee or commission created [2:19:26] by the vote of the city council or commission. [2:19:28] So maybe to incorporate Fritzes, I see Fritzes' input here, so maybe to incorporate, will [2:19:35] permit the formation of ad hoc volunteer groups that deliberate or discuss public business [2:19:44] that is not covered by executive session or any other part of the open meeting laws. [2:19:54] So if my second agrees with it, Fritz does that add the clarification that you're looking [2:20:03] for so that it's not a volunteer cleanup committee? [2:20:06] Yes, so let me get back to the original purpose of this. [2:20:10] It's really looking to who creates it, who it belongs to. [2:20:16] So Travis's committee, he's got some department heads, some department heads, a couple council [2:20:24] members a couple of citizens that committee is not covered by your amendment because [2:20:30] right this is of the council yes you did not create it okay [2:20:35] it's just changing the wording off into another topic that wasn't this issue [2:20:41] yeah okay yeah so so what will the passage of this amendment do to clarify or [2:20:52] re-directly the section three. [2:20:56] Well, because you could create a committee that isn't intended to report back to the City Councilor [2:21:03] Commission. [2:21:04] Why would you do that? [2:21:05] Exactly. [2:21:06] That's my question. [2:21:07] That's why I don't understand the caveat of intended to report back to the City Council [2:21:12] or commission. [2:21:13] But doesn't that further clarify that it has to be something related to reporting back to the council and such city business? [2:21:21] It seems like it's a strengthening argument for it rather than confusing or deluding. [2:21:35] Maybe I'm reading it different. [2:21:37] Let me go ahead. [2:21:39] Shawnee. [2:21:40] Well, I think what let me let me ask Rebecca. [2:21:43] This is what she's what she's saying. [2:21:45] Taking out intended to report back to the twin to the city council or commissions is a redundant statement. [2:21:52] There's no there's nothing in it. [2:21:54] There's really nothing in it that has any substance because in order to provide more [2:22:01] transparency in city government comma, neither the city council nor any of its commissions [2:22:05] will permit the formation of ad hoc volunteer groups unless that group is formed as a committee [2:22:11] or commission. [2:22:13] What you're saying is anything that we form is going to report back to us or have that [2:22:19] that could manifest in that way. [2:22:24] Is that what you're saying? [2:22:25] Is that what you're saying? [2:22:26] Okay. [2:22:27] that's well I'm the way you're describing it I believe we're saying the same thing [2:22:31] right and said what Chris is saying is I get it but that statement of intended to [2:22:39] report back to the City Council or Commission strengthens that assertion [2:22:44] right and I understand his perspective right [2:22:47] Nancy likes the way I the roko vote on the amendment and that's to delete the [2:22:58] underlying sense and the change wording with Fritz's input of to discuss public [2:23:04] business. I didn't agree with that. [2:23:09] Hey, the other roll call vote. Greg Lan to no. No. Yes. [2:23:21] talking to. No. Sean Berger. Yes. Don Hall. No. Suzanne Hawkins. No. The amendment [2:23:33] fails two to five. Did you have another? Don Hall's next. I just want to clarify [2:23:41] the reason I voted against it is after the discussion I got my head around a [2:23:46] little bit more. I agree with Chris that the actual sentence that's in there [2:23:51] further clarifies it that's why I like it in there and and that's why I vote I [2:23:57] think it's actually more transparent because of that sentence question on the [2:24:10] project you know for the lights they have a roll call vote on the main motion as [2:24:14] amended [2:24:20] Chris's amendment tend to the paragraph with no more than two council members [2:24:24] Okay, so that's where you're going to vote on that amendment now. [2:24:28] No, no, no. [2:24:29] Main motion with that attached. [2:24:31] Main motion. [2:24:32] Correct. [2:24:33] The amended resolution. [2:24:34] The amended resolution. [2:24:35] I'm with you. [2:24:36] Resolution 1912 as amended by Chris's amendment. [2:24:40] Leanna. [2:24:41] Jim Mun. [2:24:42] Yes. [2:24:44] Rebecca Nelsweka. [2:24:45] No. [2:24:46] Let's talk again. [2:24:47] Yes. [2:24:49] Sean Berger. [2:24:50] Yes. [2:24:52] Don Hall. [2:24:54] Yes. [2:24:55] Cezanne Hawkins. [2:24:56] Yes. [2:24:57] Greg Lantham. [2:24:58] Yes. [2:24:59] Motion passes six to one, moving on to item number three, which is public in, but [2:25:11] the public has something that was not discussed tonight that they would like to bring before the council. [2:25:16] We have a hand in the back. [2:25:31] And I had an issue last week with dogs, and it wasn't your dog catcher's fault. [2:25:40] It was 3-1-1's fault and 9-1-1's issue. [2:25:47] I was outside, I was moving some lawn furniture, I got pinned, I have a fence here, my lawn furniture [2:25:56] was here, I have a pick up here, a car here, and a fence here. [2:26:00] I had a dog come up between the car and the pickup, and another dog come between the car [2:26:07] and the fence, and they had me pinned in the corner. [2:26:12] Okay, I called 311. [2:26:14] Hello? [2:26:15] Please hold. [2:26:16] Two and a half minutes later, I hung up, trying to decide if these dogs were going to [2:26:23] eat me or not, and called 911, and was informed very rudely that my problem was not an emergency [2:26:37] emergency and she'd get somebody over there when she could. Well, an hour later there was [2:26:47] a dog catcher over in the area and I stopped and asked him if he found the dogs and he went, [2:26:53] um, didn't get a call for dogs over here. So I was telling him about the situation and [2:27:03] he said, hmm, okay, he got another call. He went on the other call and as he was on the [2:27:10] they're called, he got the call for the dogs at my place, which were probably [2:27:14] home having coffee by then. The gal at 9-1-1 informed me that there was one [2:27:23] 3-11 call operator and one 9-1-1 call operator and I'm thinking if you know [2:27:33] maybe since apparently got a little money in our budget maybe we could find [2:27:39] some money, something to hire some more operators, because I stood in my front yard, trapped by [2:27:49] dogs way too long, scared the live-and-but-Jesus out of me, and you know, and then have to go [2:27:59] through that with her, she was very rude, and she really let me know that that wasn't an emergency. [2:28:07] She was the only 911 caller and she hung up from a real emergency to take my call. [2:28:14] So, I'm just kind of wondering. [2:28:18] One thing I can guarantee you is we tape every call. [2:28:21] So this will be fully investigated to make sure that we see what resolution we come up with. [2:28:28] As far as additional officers, I'm going to have to resort to staff on that one. [2:28:34] But Travis wants to say something and we have a couple of lights. [2:28:38] So Tammy, let me first apologize that you had that experience with us. [2:28:42] Can you share with me the date so as a Mayor Atlantic and indicated, we record every single. [2:28:51] Okay. [2:28:52] And can you give me an approximate time so we can look and I mean. [2:28:58] Roughly one o'clock. [2:28:59] Okay. [2:29:00] So mid-afternoon. [2:29:01] So. [2:29:02] Did you give me your address? [2:29:03] Well, that'll help him narrow it down as well. [2:29:05] Yeah, maybe off. [2:29:06] Off. [2:29:07] You can go tell him afterwards. [2:29:09] So that's what I meant to say, I apologize. [2:29:10] I did meet for you to broadcast the live over the air. [2:29:13] Okay, all right, and that way we can investigate. [2:29:16] I do have a couple of lights of people that would like, [2:29:18] and again, I apologize as well. [2:29:20] We will work through this to our best of our abilities. [2:29:25] Don Hall. [2:29:26] I just want to reiterate that the police department [2:29:27] does have a formalized process where they investigate [2:29:31] these issues. [2:29:31] They go back and they listen to the recording. [2:29:34] They look at all those dynamics and situations around it, [2:29:39] and then they will re-contact you, [2:29:41] and that's the information that our city manager's getting [2:29:44] from you so that he can begin that process. [2:29:46] And they take it extremely seriously, [2:29:49] and they don't, no rock is not overturned. [2:29:54] Thank you, right? [2:29:55] Truly appreciate that. [2:29:56] Jim, what is really important for you to know [2:30:00] after this is all done is what the disposition [2:30:02] of your complaint is. [2:30:03] Because a lot of these complaints, you know, [2:30:05] there's a perception that they kind of go into the ether. [2:30:08] And so we're guaranteeing you that the conclusion [2:30:12] of this investigation, you will be thoroughly advised [2:30:15] of what the results of that investigation. [2:30:17] And if anything, any disciplinary matter issues are imposed, [2:30:24] you'll be informed of that disposition also. [2:30:27] Oh, she'll know whether, if an office, she will know [2:30:29] in the letter if an officer or somebody made a mistake, [2:30:32] but she will not know who the name of the officers were. [2:30:34] And that's, I appreciate that immensely. [2:30:38] I just would like, if we need more help there, [2:30:41] you know, if they're that over words. [2:30:45] Right. [2:30:46] I guarantee you that Travis and his troops will be on top of this. [2:30:50] He'll be reporting to us as well as to you, man. [2:30:53] Could I ask a question, the size of the dogs [2:30:57] and were they known to you? [2:30:58] They just have to. [2:30:59] No, I have no idea. [2:31:00] I've never seen the dogs before. [2:31:02] And do you want the realistic size of dogs [2:31:06] or do you want what they look like at the moment? [2:31:09] At the moment they were like this big [2:31:11] and had teeth this long, but realistically [2:31:14] they were probably like a golden retriever, maybe, [2:31:18] type dog, and the other one was black, but. [2:31:23] Okay, thank you for your patience. [2:31:25] Okay, thank you, Tammy, for letting us know. [2:31:26] Thank you. [2:31:27] Okay, anyone else out there, we obviously don't [2:31:31] always have to come here. [2:31:31] we will certainly investigate these situations. [2:31:35] Good evening. [2:31:36] My friends and I apologize, I didn't get here [2:31:39] in time to sign before the meeting, [2:31:41] so I know I'm violating the rules of order, [2:31:43] but if you'll permit me, I'll speak for an entertainer. [2:31:45] Sure. [2:31:46] I've watched with interest the activities [2:31:48] of the council and I, and I've been impressed, [2:31:51] more so than the last time I watched you. [2:31:55] But I don't think that what you've done tonight [2:31:57] has gone nearly far enough. [2:31:59] I think you're headed in the right direction. [2:32:01] I think that a lot of you have got your heart in it and some of you in particular, Mr. Lanting, [2:32:06] I don't think you do have your heart in openness. [2:32:09] I think transparency is the basis for all government and the more transparent a government [2:32:15] is, the better it works, the more confidence you have in the populace, the voters, everything [2:32:21] works much smoother. [2:32:24] Transparency, even though you are abiding by the letter of the law, even the state of [2:32:28] The White House Attorney General has said that you're not abiding by the spirit of [2:32:34] law. [2:32:35] The letter of the law is not always the best way to go, gentlemen and ladies. [2:32:39] Sometimes we have to open up even on the letter of the law and go into transparency. [2:32:44] We're normally, we don't have to. [2:32:46] I think you're headed in the right direction. [2:32:48] I think we need more transparency not only in this group. [2:32:51] We need it in the URA. [2:32:54] We need it in a lot of these areas that you've got. [2:32:57] We need this transparency. [2:32:58] So people have confidence in their government. [2:33:01] You spend tens and hundreds of millions of dollars of the taxpayer's money in this city. [2:33:08] And people hold you responsible for that. [2:33:10] And when you drop bombs on them, they're not happy about it. [2:33:14] I'm not, I know lots of other people that aren't. [2:33:17] I might mention in particular the last one with the alerted counsel. [2:33:22] And I agree that he's a alerted counsel. [2:33:25] There's no question about it. [2:33:26] He's showed expertise here tonight. [2:33:28] I know he knows what he's doing, and I know that you folks are paying him probably what [2:33:33] you consider to be a fair salary, but to increase it that much in one jump in secret session, [2:33:40] I think was improper and I don't think it was right. [2:33:43] And really, you've made a lot of enemies in the city of Twin Falls for doing that, even [2:33:47] though he is more than probably worth the money. [2:33:51] The proper way to have done it would have been to brought it out publicly, let the people [2:33:55] know that this gentleman is not getting the money that he deserved for his firm and that [2:34:00] heirs had been made and this had gone into arrears and that you were going to rectify [2:34:04] it and let people put some input in. [2:34:07] Everybody would have understood what you were doing and they would have lauded you for picking [2:34:11] up on this and making things right, but you didn't. [2:34:15] You did it in secret and you dropped a bomb. [2:34:17] I would hope in the future that you folks will increase your transparency much more than [2:34:23] Even what you've passed here tonight, you have more work to do. [2:34:27] But our law journey efforts, and I know that you all put a lot of time and effort out. [2:34:31] And I appreciate what you do. [2:34:33] Thank you. [2:34:34] Thank you. [2:34:36] Anyone else? [2:34:41] Seeing none, I'll go to the city manager then with new council. [2:34:45] I know the travel is supposed to give us an update, I don't know what you think. [2:34:48] Well, I have a list. [2:34:53] So with this resolution, now what's important to do is go forward and [2:34:57] make sure that it is accomplishing what you want it to do. [2:35:02] And we want to make very clear and have a really good understanding of, well, to go forward and [2:35:15] to create these work groups and transform them into committees. [2:35:21] And so I'm going to give you a list of them that I am generally aware of where Council people [2:35:27] may be working in concert on projects or areas or whatever that looks like by no [2:35:33] means am I claiming that my list is exhaustive and this list isn't going to [2:35:38] be unfamiliar to anyone this is the same list that has been vetted and discussed [2:35:43] and talked about since the beginning of this process. So we had a [2:35:48] conversation about the ready team and obviously that is one that I think that [2:35:52] like I talked about earlier should be transformed into a a full council [2:35:56] Committee. Typically, what has been done there is that we have individuals that [2:36:03] serve on that. It has typically been the mayor and the vice mayor serving on that [2:36:08] committee, community members that have a direct affiliation with the areas of [2:36:15] economic development. And so I will email you the list of who that is in the [2:36:21] the past and so that you can kind of take a look at that and consider transforming that [2:36:27] into something maybe similar or different than what it is. [2:36:33] The Zowat Committee is one that has also been discussed through this process. [2:36:40] That has two members of the City Council, two members of the community, I believe, and [2:36:46] two members of the Planning and Zoning Committee, if my member, if my knowledge serves me. [2:36:51] And I think that that would be another one of the ones that was on there was was the conversation [2:36:59] that we've had that about the extension of the wastewater treatment contract that committee [2:37:09] has not met for a while it had a general conversation with with the folks from CH about what that [2:37:16] looks like, but I would say that really hitting the reset button on that is pretty easy. [2:37:22] I think that in following with the gentleman, obviously we're looking, we have a contract [2:37:29] with CH2M Hill that is set to expire. [2:37:32] The Council has asked staff to negotiate and have a conversation about an extension [2:37:39] up to 10 years in moving forward. [2:37:43] And this could be one done one of two ways. [2:37:45] This can be done by continued inclusion of the council [2:37:50] in that process, or you can simply instruct me [2:37:53] to go negotiate a contract in good faith on behalf [2:37:56] of the city and make that presentation. [2:37:58] Either way, however that looks, in your opinion, [2:38:02] we will certainly go forward with. [2:38:05] The city has three members, I believe, [2:38:10] that have been invited by the Urban Renewal Agency [2:38:13] to have a conversation about downtown improvements [2:38:15] and those types of things. [2:38:17] I would say that even though it's not a committee [2:38:20] of yours, I think my recommendation, [2:38:22] even though it's maybe is above and beyond [2:38:25] what is here, it's not your committee, right? [2:38:27] But I still think that you should maybe [2:38:31] appoint or recognize three members of this group [2:38:34] to operate on behalf of the city council [2:38:39] for that project as they work with members [2:38:41] of the Urban Renewal Agency in building a downtown project. [2:38:51] And the last thing is, [2:38:55] we've obviously had conversations about, [2:38:57] and we've come to a negotiating position. [2:39:01] I would describe it with the individuals [2:39:04] of the Canyon Jump Process. [2:39:07] My recommendation on that is that that doesn't, [2:39:12] that shouldn't have a committee. [2:39:14] In my opinion, and this is going to be the way I see it is it's going to be maybe local [2:39:28] government at its finest where I think that all of you, because of this process, really [2:39:32] need to be involved and included and actively participating in that discussion moving forward. [2:39:41] Reports and I can have the negotiations with the individuals and moving forward and making, because of the timeline, [2:39:53] not my recommendation is almost weekly reports in terms of what that looks like. [2:39:57] So those would be the committees or work groups that I would call to your attention. [2:40:05] I would ask for you to start thinking about that. [2:40:07] We will have a place on the agenda on the 9th of December where what we will be looking [2:40:13] for are the number of individuals that you would like to serve on that. [2:40:23] The purpose of what that, so a stated purpose or goal of that group and you can only have [2:40:35] have two or up to two. It doesn't mean you have to have two. It means that you can have [2:40:43] more than up to two. So that I think is important as we go forward. [2:40:52] The second thing, so we'll send up that email in terms of what they are. I just want to [2:40:58] do so that you're thinking and get that heads up. We were going to be, and also the other [2:41:06] The other thing that we have done is we've intentionally not had these committees move [2:41:11] forward as the Council was deliberating their process. [2:41:14] So, for example, ZOAC had a meeting that they were contemplating and scheduling for this [2:41:21] Thursday. [2:41:22] That meeting is suspended until, or that work group, if you will, is suspended until the [2:41:31] Council moves forward just as everything else. [2:41:33] Same with the Ready Team. [2:41:34] The Ready Team hasn't met in a while, for lack of a better looking at my calendar, same [2:41:42] with wastewater and these others, just to make sure that when we did go forward we had [2:41:48] clear paths. [2:41:52] So over the course of the last week since the council's decision to prioritize the list [2:42:00] of prospects that want to jump over the canyon and to utilize the city's property as a jump [2:42:09] site. [2:42:10] We've had some developments that I want to pass along. [2:42:13] We are going to on the agenda from this point forward on through the completion as there will [2:42:19] be a report from Fritz and I that talks about what this looks like. [2:42:28] But what I will say is that I would say we've had some good initial conversations. [2:42:33] We've provided them lists of individuals that they need to get in contact with. [2:42:39] They are very supportive of that. [2:42:44] We've shared with them that we've reached out to iCrimp, who is our liability carrier. [2:42:48] And we've asked them to put together a list of things that we need to consider to ensure [2:42:54] that it is that liability cannot be transferred [2:42:57] to the city associated with this event. [2:42:59] That is one of the things that we've actively talked about. [2:43:02] So we've asked them also to provide a list [2:43:06] of possible recommendations of bonds and other types [2:43:12] of related issues to be considered in the development [2:43:16] and of an overall agreement. [2:43:18] We did not want to build that in a vacuum. [2:43:21] We wanted to make sure that our insurance carrier [2:43:23] was providing us good advice and we have not received that yet. [2:43:27] As soon as we will receive that, it's our intent as we committed to Mr. Beckley to provide [2:43:35] that to him, to his council who also submit that to the city council and be included in [2:43:40] a packet as we move forward. [2:43:44] We've had individuals from our community reach out to me. [2:43:50] I don't know if any of it have reached out to you, [2:43:52] but I think it's probably a safe bet that, [2:43:54] you know, through this process, [2:43:55] I think that there's lots of individuals [2:43:58] in our community who would like to be involved [2:44:00] in this process. [2:44:02] They would like the opportunity to comment. [2:44:04] And as you're thinking about next steps, [2:44:08] I really, and my recommendation would be [2:44:11] that this be a council-driven process. [2:44:13] I think that you need to drive that process [2:44:17] through the spirit of inclusion, [2:44:18] where you have citizens provided the opportunity [2:44:25] to contribute to participate to whatever that looks like. [2:44:29] And you may have to move into a workshop style setting [2:44:33] so that it's less formal. [2:44:36] And maybe the conversation is but still done in here, [2:44:39] still more of a free flowing conversation, [2:44:42] something that will continue to be utilizing Channel 17, [2:44:47] continued to be streamed, so on and so forth. [2:44:52] I've had a conversation with Ryan Lay, [2:44:54] and I've invited him to Ryan Lay is the regional manager [2:44:58] for the Idaho Department of Lands. [2:45:00] I've talked to him about the flexibility of their terms [2:45:03] and the term May, and he said that it was put in there [2:45:06] with the intent to be flexible within reason. [2:45:09] And he's going to continue to, we've continued [2:45:13] to make a commitment to communicate with one another [2:45:16] about this process. I've invited him to be a part of our process as we move forward because [2:45:21] I think that the more groups that we have coming together, I think that would be good. Internally, [2:45:29] one of the steps that we've taken is we have designated Captain Anthony Barnhart to lead [2:45:35] our internal process that as it comes to public safety. Captain Barnhart oversees the patrol [2:45:42] division and is probably in conversation with Chief Pike this morning that it is probably [2:45:49] the single group that is going to have maybe potentially the greatest impact. [2:45:55] One of the questions that has been supplied by Mr. Blackbekley and through his legal [2:46:00] counsel and conversations is that the question was asked how big does the city want this event [2:46:09] to be. And what I shared with them was that that really was not in, I didn't feel like [2:46:19] that was something that maybe necessarily I could answer, but I would submit that question [2:46:26] to you for your thought. Mr. Beckley and Mr. Simmons are going to be here at our December [2:46:34] 9th meeting and we're going to provide a telephone opportunity for the gentleman who [2:46:43] has the buffalo chip because he is not able to travel but he is leading their public safety [2:46:48] effort. [2:46:49] I think the biggest takeaway is, I guess, think about the process. [2:46:53] They've asked us to think about how big this could be because they believe that they have [2:46:58] some means or vehicles to control that, which may be a really good conversation piece next [2:47:05] week when they're here. [2:47:07] And then think about the process in terms of what this looks like, how this rules out, [2:47:12] recognizing we have tight timelines, there are expectations of inclusion. [2:47:18] And I know that we prioritize the list of individuals, but I didn't feel like we really [2:47:25] walked away with, we got the what, but we never got the how. [2:47:30] And I think that I think we kind of need to work through that process. [2:47:36] Any questions on that? [2:47:37] I really said I have a list, I was. [2:47:40] For a guy who usually doesn't give a staff report, here you go, right? [2:47:45] Just a reminder on the sixth is the Association of Idaho City's Workshop. [2:47:51] And if you're interested in attending, please let us know. [2:47:54] It is the opportunity to understand legislative issues that may be contemplated by the association [2:48:01] as they're coming in. [2:48:02] I also believe it is where the elected leaders will formulate decisions, but they'll create [2:48:11] policy recommendations in terms of legislation moving forward. [2:48:15] And then also the festival of lights is that evening, and I've been asked to have you at [2:48:20] Station 1 at 5.30 so you can hop aboard your chariot and participate in the parade if you [2:48:27] are interested. [2:48:29] And then on December 19th at, I believe it's either 3 or 3.30, I'll check the time for [2:48:36] sharing, get that, but it's 3.30 is our conversation that we have with our local legislative delegation. [2:48:45] We're trying to set that up in a round table conversation in here. [2:48:49] And the idea of this format is staff will actually be making presentations based upon some of the key ideas that we think, [2:48:58] and the ideas just have more of a conversation about upcoming legislative issues that we see that we're hearing that we might be aware of [2:49:07] and share our thoughts and sentiments and then ask them in terms of what they see are some of the emerging trends and issues [2:49:15] may or may not impact us as local government. [2:49:22] Hey, Councilor Imput. [2:49:25] Wow. [2:49:26] Good report. [2:49:28] It sounds like a pretty big homework assignment to me that he just gave us. [2:49:32] Yeah. [2:49:34] So you know other Council input or advisory board or whatever else we're going on? [2:49:44] We're Jen. [2:49:45] I'm sorry. [2:49:46] I'm sorry. [2:49:47] I'm sorry. [2:49:48] I'm sorry. [2:49:49] I'm sorry. [2:49:50] I'm sorry. [2:49:51] I'm sorry. [2:49:52] I'm sorry. [2:49:53] I'm sorry. [2:49:54] I'm sorry. [2:49:55] I'm sorry. [2:49:56] I'm sorry. [2:49:57] I'm sorry. [2:49:58] I'm sorry. [2:49:59] I'm sorry. [2:50:00] I'm sorry. [2:50:01] I'm sorry. [2:50:02] I'm sorry. [2:50:03] I'm sorry. [2:50:04] I'm sorry. [2:50:05] I'm sorry. [2:50:06] I'm sorry. [2:50:07] I'm sorry. [2:50:08] I'm sorry. [2:50:09] I'm sorry. [2:50:10] I'm sorry. [2:50:11] I'm sorry. [2:50:12] I'm sorry. [2:50:13] I'm sorry.