Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2013-11-18, recording 1 (started 17:00) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2013-11-18/ [0:01:56] I thought I had it on the schedule. [0:02:23] No, we have, did we trade? [0:02:28] No, actually, I've not to my knowledge. [0:02:32] Either way. [0:02:35] I'm real busy now, I know. [0:02:39] I have a question for Mr. Mayor and members of the Council staff would ask for you to consider [0:02:58] two amendments. [0:03:00] The first would be consideration of initiating and hearing at a future council meeting to [0:03:06] to revoke an alcohol permit for the Pioneer Club, [0:03:08] located at 1519 Kimberly Road East. [0:03:14] That item would be placed below the other items. [0:03:18] Should you approve it on items of consideration? [0:03:22] The next is an amended city council meeting minutes [0:03:25] for November 4th, 2013. [0:03:27] There was a correction and should you choose [0:03:30] that would be attached and done in replace up [0:03:35] meeting minutes as indicated on the consent calendar for this evening's agenda. [0:03:40] It will mean just like move to amend the agenda with the aforementioned two items. [0:03:46] It's been moved by first-second and then affected by long hold. [0:03:51] It will be amended as outlined by CDN, due to that five-hour one to be twice-minute minutes. [0:03:58] And then you can take down it. [0:04:00] And then item number six is the possible. [0:04:04] So do you know the hearing of the room? [0:04:06] I just had a question on that first item for a hearing to revoke the alcohol license for [0:04:21] Pioneer Club was the owner able to make it tonight I know that we invited him or her [0:04:28] I don't know who it is last minute okay okay I just wanted to make sure I didn't want [0:04:33] to add it without. I know it was kind of last minute. He is not here right now. Okay. He will be here. But he was invited. He has [0:04:45] been notified of the. Yeah. Yeah. And I think I heard Dwayne say that he said he was coming. Okay. Okay. Okay, because I would just feel a little bit bad if we gave him less than 24 hours notice and he wasn't able to make it. And honestly, I haven't had time. We just received the [0:05:04] the agenda report and I haven't had time to go through that so I'm a little hesitant to add the item. [0:05:12] We're not doing it tonight, we're going to be setting a future correct for a hearing. [0:05:19] Let's do it. [0:05:22] All right. [0:05:23] All right. [0:05:24] Is that a little homo? [0:05:25] Yes. [0:05:26] Sean Darger. [0:05:27] Yes. [0:05:28] Don Hall. [0:05:29] Yes. [0:05:30] Greg Lanti. [0:05:31] Yes. [0:05:32] Jim. [0:05:33] Yes. [0:05:34] and we have one for small business energy, as shown as the president's CEO of the local [0:05:44] chain group, the whole chain work comes, I thought it would be appropriate that you read it. [0:05:49] Thank you Mayor. Office of the Mayor, City of Twin Falls Proclamation, small business [0:05:54] Saturday, whereas the City of Twin Falls celebrates our local small businesses and the contribution [0:05:59] they make to our local economy and community. [0:06:01] falls, celebrates our local small businesses, and the contribution they make to our local [0:06:05] economy and community. [0:06:07] According to the United States Small Business Administration, there are currently 28 million [0:06:10] small businesses in the United States. [0:06:13] They represent more than 99 percent of American companies, create two-thirds of the net new jobs, [0:06:18] and generate half of private, gross domestic product, and whereas small businesses employ [0:06:23] one half of the employees in the private sector in the United States, and whereas 89 percent [0:06:28] of consumers in the United States agree that small businesses contribute positively to the [0:06:33] local community by supplying jobs and generating tax revenue, and whereas 86% of consumers in [0:06:40] the United States have small businesses in their community that the consumers would miss [0:06:44] if the small businesses closed, and whereas 93% of the consumers in the United States agree [0:06:50] that it is important for people to support the small businesses that they value in their [0:06:54] community, whereas 90 percent of consumers in the United States are willing to pledge support [0:06:59] for a by-local movement, and whereas City of Twin Falls, Idaho supports our local businesses [0:07:04] that create jobs, boost our local economy, and preserve our neighborhoods, and whereas [0:07:09] advocacy groups and public and private organizations across the country have endorsed the Saturday [0:07:15] after Thanksgiving as small business Saturday, now therefore Gregory L. Lanting Mayor of the [0:07:20] City of Twin Falls does hereby proclaim November 30th, 2013, has small business [0:07:26] Saturday and urge the residents of our community and communities across the [0:07:30] country to support small businesses and merchants on small business Saturday and [0:07:34] throughout the year. [0:07:36] Thank you, Sean. I believe I was going to present it to you. [0:07:40] Well, thank you. [0:07:41] I appreciate that. [0:07:43] That is an important thing to remember that some of the things they talked about in the [0:07:48] proclamation but that those as somebody pointed out to me one time it's when was [0:07:54] the last time Amazon sponsored a little league team and some of those kinds of [0:07:59] things so well this is our very important part to the community as a whole so we will [0:08:04] proudly display that at the Chamber office and we too are encouraging folks to shop [0:08:09] locally throughout the holiday shopping season in partnership with some of our [0:08:12] media partners. Thank you. Thank you. [0:08:15] Me too. I bet. Moving on to the consent calendar. Council wishes. Move approval. [0:08:32] Second. And moved by Don Hall and seconded by Jim Mundt that we approve the consent [0:08:38] the calendar as amended, so you know lights, [0:08:41] the other roll call vote. [0:08:43] Sean Verigert. [0:08:43] Yes. [0:08:44] Don Hall. [0:08:45] Yes. [0:08:46] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:08:47] Yes. [0:08:47] Greg Lanting. [0:08:48] Yes. [0:08:49] Jim Mann. [0:08:49] Yes. [0:08:50] Rebecca Mills-Weicher. [0:08:51] Yes. [0:08:52] Just talking. [0:08:53] Yes. [0:08:54] Motion passes 7-0. [0:08:57] Moving down to items for consideration. [0:09:00] Situations of requests to approve the airport grant offer [0:09:03] from ITV Division of Aeronautics, [0:09:05] the amount of $25,000. [0:09:08] Bill Carveray, our air part manager, welcome Bill. [0:09:11] Thank you very, good evening council members. [0:09:13] A little good news to start things off here [0:09:15] for your consideration tonight. [0:09:17] Recently we got the grant offer from ITD Division [0:09:21] of Aeronautics for $25,000 for the airport. [0:09:24] This is through their airport aid program, [0:09:27] which you're in and you're out struggling, [0:09:29] so it was a pleasant surprise to get this grant [0:09:33] offered this year. [0:09:34] Although it's an offer to the city [0:09:38] which one falls equally to the county and would be included in the airport budget, which is [0:09:43] shared equally by the city and county. [0:09:46] Our eligibility is based on the airport spending at least $50,000 for match monies on airport [0:09:53] capital programs which we do through the FAA. [0:09:55] So that would be the eligibility. [0:09:57] And these dollars would go into our airport capital fund to help us with future capital [0:10:02] improvements at the airport. [0:10:05] There's a grand agreement as well as a city resolution that would need to be processed here this evening, Mary. [0:10:11] So with that, I'd be happy to answer any questions and recommend approval and acceptance of the grant. [0:10:17] Chris, so it can be rolled forward into a future project as yet and determined, then there's no use that or lose it. [0:10:24] That's correct. [0:10:26] That's real good. [0:10:26] At this point, we are eligible for proceeding now. [0:10:33] Okay, action that's needed, Bill, you mentioned we need a resolution. [0:10:37] Well, I don't know if you need to take this separately or not, there's a city resolution which Leila I think would number. [0:10:43] 1910. [0:10:44] And you could work that through and then the grand agreement as well. [0:10:48] All right. [0:10:49] And what would the wording of the resolution be? [0:10:52] Leila, could you take us through that, please? [0:11:09] I think if you read the first paragraph there. [0:11:13] Okay, resolution 1910, the city of Twin Falls, Idaho. [0:11:17] Accepting the grant offer to state up Idaho Transportation Department, Division of Aeronautics, the maximum amount of $25,000 to be used under the Idaho Airport 8 program. [0:11:29] Program number LNS8 TWF, Project Number TWF 2013, AIT-033, the development of the Jawsland Field, Magic Valley, ACF, Airport. [0:11:46] and be it resolved by the mayor and the city council [0:11:49] at the city of Twin Falls here and here and that's it. [0:11:53] And then the resolution would be following that. [0:11:56] That would be the initial ground offering [0:11:58] and there's a resolution that I'm not sure [0:12:00] if you have to read as well. [0:12:01] So there's a fair graph on that and I'm doing it. [0:12:04] Chris, do you think we can improve these? [0:12:07] I apologize, I just got it, okay thanks. [0:12:09] Do we need to approve these separately [0:12:11] or can we do them and tan them? [0:12:14] Could you try to do this? [0:12:15] Okay, so what are we doing first? Yeah, cuz we got one one was ran into resolution numbers a separate one so [0:12:24] She did read the resolution. I was okay. All right, so we'll do the resolution first Jim. Yes. I'd move to approve [0:12:32] Resolution number 1910 [0:12:35] Second yeah [0:12:37] Hey, I've been moved by Jim. Oh second records talking to we improve resolution 1910 [0:12:43] Jim do you still be lying on? No? [0:12:46] We had a roll call vote on the resolution. [0:12:49] Don Hall? [0:12:50] Yes. [0:12:51] Suzanne Hopkins? [0:12:52] Yes. [0:12:53] Greg Lantin? [0:12:54] Yes. [0:12:55] Jim Mundt? [0:12:56] Yes. [0:12:57] Rebecca Masueka? [0:12:58] Yes. [0:12:59] Sean Beriger? [0:13:00] Yes. [0:13:01] The motion passes 7-0. [0:13:02] Now we need the motion to accept the $25,000 grant. [0:13:07] I'll try to sign it. [0:13:09] I'll have to sign it. [0:13:10] I'll put my light on that. [0:13:12] I'd like to make a motion that we accept the grant from the state of Idaho for $25,000 [0:13:17] to be used at the airport later in whatever project it [0:13:21] steamed reasonable. [0:13:22] And authorized me to sign. [0:13:24] And authorized you to sign the grant. [0:13:27] Second. [0:13:29] Been moved by Suzanne Hawkins and seconded by Don Hall, [0:13:32] but we accept the $25,000 grant from the ATD Division of Aeronautics [0:13:38] and authorized the mayor to sign such grant. [0:13:43] Seeing no likes of the other roll call vote. [0:13:45] Susan Hawkins. [0:13:46] Yes. [0:13:47] Greg Lansing. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. [0:14:17] earlier on there, but only Steve was moving forward. [0:14:20] Welcome, our PGA professional and course manager, [0:14:23] Steve Meyer. [0:14:25] Good evening. [0:14:26] I'm here to ask the little money for the next few years. [0:14:30] I'm asking for a $20 increase on all adult yearly dues, $20. [0:14:36] So for a couple or a dollar senior, $20 increase. [0:14:43] I started working at the club June 1st in 2011. [0:14:48] Since that time, there's been no increase [0:14:50] in any due, so it's been at least three years [0:14:53] since that happened. [0:14:55] So I feel at this time the small increase [0:15:01] would be helpful at this time. [0:15:05] Then it's mentioned in 2012, just a little sheet here, [0:15:08] that we had a green fee increase. [0:15:11] And we kind of did, what we did at that time, [0:15:13] we had about nine different green fee prices. [0:15:16] What we did is we made it easier for everybody. [0:15:20] And we had, for example, we had a weekend rate of 23, [0:15:25] week to reach up 21, we made it one rate of 22. [0:15:28] So we made all of our rates just each of the understand [0:15:31] by the customers, by myself. [0:15:33] So it wasn't really an increase at that time, [0:15:35] it was just kind of a restructuring, I should say. [0:15:38] So there has not been a really increase [0:15:39] in green fee prices or yearly rates [0:15:43] from last at least three years that I'm aware of. [0:15:47] I did do some research as far as other golf courses. [0:15:52] I don't follow this area. [0:15:55] Magic Valley, Boise Valley, Napa Valley. [0:15:59] And we were, for an 18-hole golf course, [0:16:01] we are the cheapest, yearly raise of eight [0:16:04] in the course I spoke with. [0:16:05] I spoke, I think, about 70 to 18 golf courses. [0:16:08] So we are very competitive right now. [0:16:10] And that's where we want to be. [0:16:13] I don't want to change that. [0:16:16] We're at risk for $20 for the year, [0:16:18] and also for $1 for a green fee increase. [0:16:22] So $22 to $23 for an 18-year-old green fee. [0:16:25] All these increases are less than 4.5% or 4.6%. [0:16:30] So somewhere at 2 and 1-1% or 4 and 1-1%. [0:16:33] So there's not a lot of increase. [0:16:37] For example, $20 is less than one green fee. [0:16:40] So it's not that big a increase at all [0:16:43] in my opinion. My idea is over the next two or three years to make you have a small increase [0:16:48] again about three years again. Rather than waiting for a long period of time having a large increase, [0:16:52] you know, we just keep up with the economy and the cost of living increases as we go and just make [0:16:59] a here and there a small love beach or the large increase over half dozen years. So that's what [0:17:05] we're asking for a small increase just to keep up with the cost of living increases. And I guess [0:17:10] has been at least three years as we did that. [0:17:13] And it has been approved by the advisory board already. [0:17:17] So now I guess we need your approval as well. [0:17:21] Don't know, Steve. [0:17:23] Steve, any feedback from the golfers themselves? [0:17:25] Yeah, we've talked to our legacy association, [0:17:27] our men's association, and they're all understanding [0:17:30] that it's probably time it's been in a while. [0:17:32] Okay, thank you, Jim. [0:17:37] Oh, thank you. [0:17:38] Hi, Steve. [0:17:39] One of the things I think that the community [0:17:41] is gonna wanna know, [0:17:42] And I'm sure that the Gulf Commission knows, [0:17:45] and maybe some golfers, is why are we increasing this, [0:17:48] precisely? [0:17:49] What will that increase in revenue, [0:17:52] what will you do with that money? [0:17:54] Nothing. [0:17:55] Reason being, over the last three years, Jim, [0:17:58] my cost for fertilizer, for chemicals, for gas, [0:18:02] for insurance, for food, every product I have [0:18:05] has increased more than 3%. [0:18:07] So I'm not really going to have an extra money [0:18:08] to do extra things with. [0:18:09] This is kind of just to stay even more recurrently out, [0:18:12] not not to fall behind where we have to do a bigger jump later. [0:18:15] Roger. Thank you. [0:18:17] Rebecca, no second. [0:18:18] Thank you, Mayor. [0:18:19] Thanks for your presentation, Steve. [0:18:21] You mentioned talking about the price of golf in other areas, [0:18:26] specifically Twin Falls, because I'm not a golfer. [0:18:30] Can you give us an idea? [0:18:31] Sure. [0:18:31] Give me an idea of what the costs are at the Twin Falls Golf [0:18:36] Club versus private golf courses just here in this area. [0:18:40] Yeah, private golf courses, for example, [0:18:43] like Jerome Country Club and Clearly Country Club. [0:18:47] Those are about $12 a year to play golf those places. [0:18:51] Blue Lakes is probably twice at about $24 a place. [0:18:53] Those are places. [0:18:56] Ranch 93, which is more kind of like we are, [0:18:57] just a 18-hole course owned privately in Canyon Springs. [0:19:01] They're about $200 more than we are. [0:19:04] East and Idaho is not bad, actually. [0:19:07] They're about 650 for their yearly rates. [0:19:11] The Boise Valley, you're almost all over $1,000 [0:19:13] for the rates for a year. [0:19:15] So our area in East Idaho is very competitive. [0:19:18] As you go west, it's not so much. [0:19:21] It's getting pretty expensive to play golf in those areas. [0:19:23] The only place I know is less than a jack-back bat. [0:19:27] So I've all of that. [0:19:30] And how do you think they increase or do you [0:19:32] think they increase will affect your numbers of play [0:19:36] at the golf course? [0:19:37] I think the small, you know, my idea was if you do it when we need it every few years, a small amount, it won't hurt us at all. [0:19:44] If you waited, you know, three, four years, did a large jump, might run people off. [0:19:48] That's the last thing we want to do is have it by not playing a big jump in fees. [0:19:53] Thank you. [0:19:54] Susan, I'm not right. [0:19:55] I just want to say thank you to Steve in the last 18 months getting the chance to work with you and see how you manage the golf course [0:20:02] and how the golfers and everybody respond to you. [0:20:04] been such a positive experience and I think you've done a great job with all of your upgrades [0:20:08] and all the effort you guys have put into the golf course out there and I appreciate it. [0:20:12] Appreciate it. [0:20:13] Thank you. [0:20:15] Just taking. [0:20:16] Well since the recommendations have come from the Golf Advisory Commission I think that [0:20:21] they would not do anything that would decrease the usage of the course. [0:20:25] It sounds like we're highly competitive anyway and also as a non-gauper I would like to recommend [0:20:33] that puts that resolution 1911, that's what we're talking about, [0:20:37] that we adopt resolution 1911, [0:20:39] calling for the passes and play fees, [0:20:46] not to exceed 5% as described in the golf pros schedule. [0:20:54] Second. [0:20:55] Then moved by Chris Tocking and second by Sean Berger [0:20:57] that we approve our resolution 1911, [0:21:00] which is outlined for us by the Steve Meyerhofer. [0:21:05] I see no additional lights. [0:21:08] We have a roll call vote. [0:21:09] Greg Lante. [0:21:10] Yes. [0:21:11] Jim Mann. [0:21:12] Yes. [0:21:13] Rebecca Mills-Weicher. [0:21:14] Yes. [0:21:15] Miss Tocke. [0:21:16] Yes. [0:21:17] Sean Berger. [0:21:18] Yes. [0:21:19] Don Hall. [0:21:20] Yes. [0:21:21] Susan Hawkins. [0:21:22] Yes. [0:21:23] Motion passes 7-0. [0:21:24] I do have one additional question and maybe Dennis can help on this one. [0:21:27] The Friends of Meany tournament and how much was raised and what are the plans? [0:21:31] We raised about $9,000. [0:21:32] And so the audience that made, I know the golfer kind of golf courses are used extensively [0:21:37] to raise money for every organization you can imagine. [0:21:41] And the golfers that, when follows the golf club basically have chosen to voluntarily raise [0:21:48] their own dues by about 50 bucks or go find a sponsor and raise funds to make improvements [0:21:54] at the course that maybe we as the city have been unable to do, but would increase the playability [0:21:59] and also the more people playing the course and Steve didn't want to interrupt you, [0:22:04] but I want to get that out. [0:22:05] So it is televised and maybe not everybody knows what their friends are meeting tournament is. [0:22:09] We raised about $9,000 this year. [0:22:12] We've spent a little more than half of that. [0:22:14] We will have some carrier over this year because our last item was maybe some [0:22:20] cement cart pass that our golf course, there's a little more spending than we guessed. [0:22:24] So right now we are redoing a tee box on number 11. [0:22:27] Number 11, once that's done, we'll have [0:22:28] a little care over for next year for new projects. [0:22:31] Maybe that time, as the cement cart passed, [0:22:33] we can afford to do that. [0:22:35] Okay, thank you, Steve. [0:22:36] Those of you who don't really, [0:22:38] don't play golf, typically. [0:22:40] T-box, we're out for the one of a better term. [0:22:44] They get uneven because of the play [0:22:47] of people taking divots and different things like that, [0:22:49] and then just settling over time, [0:22:51] until you have to rebuild them on occasion, [0:22:53] just to keep them looking good at level, [0:22:55] and especially one right where you're coming into the golf course. [0:22:58] I happen to drive by there today and notice that they were out there working on it. [0:23:02] And that's probably the, I'm glad the golf advisory had picked that one [0:23:08] because that was probably had the most need right now on the course. [0:23:12] So thank you, Steve. [0:23:14] Appreciate your efforts. [0:23:15] Thank you, Council. [0:23:15] Thank you. [0:23:17] See you in three years. [0:23:18] All right, item number three, [0:23:22] consideration of request from the Twin Falls River no agency to accept the proposed [0:23:26] pocket park to be built on 4th Avenue South upon completion of construction [0:23:31] Cindy Bond and his lawyers and names on here as well. As you recall the last [0:23:43] time that I was here I asked that you that the city accept ownership of the new [0:23:48] pocket park with the knowing that the new agency would pay to maintain that park [0:23:56] through 2022 and you would ask that some additional research we've done about the actual care of [0:24:03] the park and so I think Dennis has quite a bit to say. [0:24:07] I couldn't get away with not talking on this report. [0:24:26] Okay, thank you Council. [0:24:29] Thank you Mayor. [0:24:30] Yeah, at last Council meeting when we discussed this pocket park, the Council really kind of [0:24:35] and this is what will it really cost me to make this park? [0:24:40] And also, because I remember last time, [0:24:42] I kind of really talked about this is really [0:24:44] a different type of park than a lot of our neighborhood parks. [0:24:47] Part of my staff report, the last 20 years, [0:24:49] our department has really streamlined our maintenance [0:24:52] in our parks, that we are gaining more parks, [0:24:54] and we just need to be more efficient at it. [0:24:57] This type of park, as I mentioned also, [0:24:59] Courtney's Park, and if we get the main avenue, [0:25:02] Fountain Plaza, that group brings funds, [0:25:04] that ever gets done. Those three parts I kind of see, these are going to be all the same [0:25:08] type of parts. They're beautiful, what they're designed for, but they do take more time to [0:25:13] maintain it, which is not bad thing at all. But it's just kind of a different design. So [0:25:20] I have met with staff looked at what we could, what kind of cost estimates like that. We figured [0:25:26] you know typically it's 26 weeks of mowing we have out there. And we figured you know it's [0:25:30] going to be about three and a half hours per week, mowing it, we're going to be [0:25:33] weeding. Does any time you have flowers in these flower beds, even though you have [0:25:37] the weed mat underneath it, weed seed blows in. Just the common fact, blows in, [0:25:42] we're going to have to do some weeding in their spraying of the weeds, and we [0:25:46] can have a seasonal employee do that, so save some money on that. Then we'll have [0:25:52] always, you know, clean up, and we're just thinking, you know, someone going [0:25:58] down there, emptying trash cans may have a little backpack blower, blow off the dust [0:26:02] or whatever off the concrete around there. [0:26:06] We figure that's only 20 minutes a day that we're going to be down there and that's seven [0:26:10] days a week. [0:26:12] Especially during the summer we could see this area getting used all seven days. [0:26:17] And then basically when we shut down for the winter when we blow out the systems, we're [0:26:22] still going to figure we're going to send somebody out there twice a week just to check [0:26:27] on the trash out there, make sure everything's fine. [0:26:30] That's still only going to be, hopefully, only 20 minutes a day. [0:26:32] And then when I did talk about, you know, [0:26:34] we do have to blow out the system irrigation system [0:26:37] and energize it every year. [0:26:38] You know, of course, we'll have full-time employees to that. [0:26:42] And we estimate those four duties that just really labor-wise, [0:26:46] it's about a little bit over $4,100 per year. [0:26:50] And then we do have, you know, if we cost our equipment, [0:26:53] we have out there driving a vehicle there, [0:26:55] driving vehicle with on more in the trailer there there's some equipment costs [0:26:58] we figure that's about $1,200 you know we will have power there we have some of [0:27:03] those decorative street lights in there we are just estimating $300 you know [0:27:08] yearly on that I don't know we don't know exactly where that power bill is [0:27:12] gonna be assigned to can we push it off to Dean in the streets department or can [0:27:16] we have it in my department I don't know that hasn't been decided on and of [0:27:21] Of course, we'll have some costs for chemicals for the killing the weeds and then we figure [0:27:26] some fuel costs. [0:27:27] So we estimate, you know, it was a total of about a little bit over $6,000 if we did [0:27:33] that internally to maintain this park. [0:27:36] As I mentioned, the last staff report, you know, all season, they did have an estimate [0:27:40] on this design, you know, they figured somewhere between $5,000 and $6,000. [0:27:44] So we can internally do this ourselves, as I think Melinda Anderson said, that urban [0:27:52] renewal agency will reimburse, will pay for the maintenance for the next seven years, till [0:27:58] 2022. [0:28:00] We can do that ourselves, or we could, time-wise, we could contract that out to some business [0:28:07] like all season. [0:28:09] We could ask for bids to maintain this or some of the other companies that do this time [0:28:13] work. [0:28:14] As I mentioned earlier, you know, this type of park, [0:28:17] it's just a different design of our neighborhood parks. [0:28:20] You know, it's not going to be something we can just get in, [0:28:22] get out real fast, especially with the flowers and stuff, [0:28:25] like especially in Courtney's Park. [0:28:26] We're going to spend more time out there than we do [0:28:28] with typical neighborhood or community park. [0:28:31] But as I mentioned, I think that's okay. [0:28:34] So, kind of a conclusion, our staff really embraces this design [0:28:39] of this park so we think it's going to be unique [0:28:41] and set a great example for downtown. [0:28:44] So I'm available for questions. [0:28:47] Thank you for any questions. [0:28:50] Rebecca Bill's like it. [0:28:52] Thank you, Mayor. [0:28:53] Thank you, Dennis. [0:28:54] When you talk about the $1,200 for equipment, [0:28:57] is that each year or is that the initial start [0:29:02] of the equipment for the first year? [0:29:03] That is each year. [0:29:04] Because each piece of equipment has a value to it, [0:29:06] it's, you know, pickup truck is, don't quote me on this. [0:29:11] It's like 15, 16 bucks an hour. [0:29:12] That's what you prorated out the life of the pickup. [0:29:15] Lawn mowers, it depends how expensive the lawn mower, [0:29:17] it's X amount of dollars. [0:29:19] So that's what we figured. [0:29:20] The hours that's being used, being driven, whatever, [0:29:23] that's our estimated cost of the equipment. [0:29:27] Okay, so that's $6,000 is an annual amount. [0:29:30] Yes, total of $6,000. [0:29:31] Okay, thank you. [0:29:32] Thank you. [0:29:33] Just a hand. [0:29:34] And to follow up on that, Cindy or Dennis, [0:29:36] than when the allocation area 411 terminates in 2020 or 2022, nine years in change. [0:29:45] The agreement would say you'll do it until then. [0:29:49] We pick it up at that time, fully owned and all the responsibilities there in, right? [0:29:57] It sounds like, excuse me, the district in the city of that area. [0:30:05] Yeah. [0:30:10] So there's a question that kind of jumped into my mind. [0:30:13] We said that Cindy, that the revenue does return to us, what are we anticipating as a city [0:30:19] to receive in taxes from the revenue allocation area? [0:30:26] Do we have an estimate on that? [0:30:27] Melinda Anderson? [0:30:28] Melinda, you can score that one as a pretty large area. [0:30:35] And Travis may want to weigh in as well on this question, but I'll give you a quick and [0:30:38] dirty answer quickly. [0:30:40] So currently, the Urban Renewal Agency collects approximately $2 million per year from revenue [0:30:47] allocation for Dash 1, which is a big geographic area, it includes now part of downtown and [0:30:52] old town, but it's a bigger area than just that. [0:30:55] So that's about, there's about a little over a million dollars each year from that $2 million [0:31:00] that the agency pays debt on, whether it's a bond or other debt that it has out there. [0:31:09] So the city gets, we estimate it on one of them. [0:31:13] The city probably would get about half of the, whatever the taxable income will be in 20, starting in 2023. [0:31:23] So right now the city is the biggest beneficiary of the tax income that's going to be coming to all the taxing districts once 2022. [0:31:35] Excuse me, what's for Dash 1 expires in 2022? [0:31:39] Thanks. [0:31:40] But of course, we've been, much of that, of course, [0:31:44] will be looking to be used for fire, please, [0:31:46] all the different things. [0:31:47] Whatever, the aviation, the city, yes. [0:31:49] Right, yes. [0:31:51] That was, did you want to weigh in as well? [0:31:54] No. [0:31:55] All right. [0:31:57] Just Don's lighting, and then Sean, but next. [0:32:01] Dennis, it sounds like times are changing a little bit [0:32:03] with the design of parks. [0:32:05] And they're just a little different now. [0:32:06] They tend to be a little more expensive, [0:32:11] but I think it's really a positive. [0:32:13] I think I had a citizen tell me once [0:32:15] that we're getting beyond the old stage of throwing [0:32:19] a bunch of railroad ties down, [0:32:21] throwing some grass seed out there [0:32:22] that we're actually building in different parks. [0:32:24] Is that? [0:32:25] And these three parks I mentioned are just examples of that. [0:32:29] Yes. [0:32:30] And also I know that we put some significant investment downtown, [0:32:34] I.e. we've also we're watering flower flowers on the street lights and the [0:32:42] like. So I was going to make a motion the motion but it looks like a couple of [0:32:47] other like questions or just comments. All right. So what we have a little [0:32:51] questions for the motion. All right. Sean Berger. Thank you for the [0:32:57] presentation Cindy and for having a little more detail for us this time [0:33:00] It talks in here that the construction plans are completed and the agency is going to schedule a public bid process. [0:33:07] When that's awarded, will there be, is there some city oversight of that construction process? [0:33:13] Like, I mean, it's not a building, but does the building department inspect it or engineering to make sure that it's being built to standards that we will want to accept when it's completed? [0:33:26] Yeah. [0:33:28] I just want to make sure Melinda wasn't coming up here. [0:33:31] Yeah, we do have in there about the plans, about a lot of oversight part of it is with [0:33:35] or maybe somewhere with their engine new prime, but also with the Parks and Recreation [0:33:39] Department. [0:33:40] Okay. [0:33:41] We'll provide some oversight on those. [0:33:42] Great. [0:33:43] Thank you. [0:33:44] All right, Mel. [0:33:45] So, did you have a question? [0:33:46] Just a comment. [0:33:47] Okay. [0:33:48] Well, if we want to go ahead and do a motion and then just make it this part of the discussion. [0:33:50] Thank you. [0:33:51] There's others want to comment as well. [0:33:52] So, Donald. [0:33:53] Mayor, I would move that we accept the request from the Twin Falls Urban Renewal Agency to accept the proposed pocket park to be built on 4th Avenue South upon completion of the construction in revenue allocation area 4 and 1. [0:34:10] Yeah, we can put the in revenue allocation area 4-1. [0:34:16] And Rebecca, did I hear you a second? [0:34:18] Okay, thank you. [0:34:19] All right, it's been moved by Don Hall saying [0:34:21] by Rebecca Mills-Sleka. [0:34:22] Are we doing this from my time to Rebecca Mills-Sleka? [0:34:24] Thank you, Mayor. [0:34:26] Thank you, Cindy, for your presentation [0:34:27] and Dennis for your numbers. [0:34:30] It's good to hear that the Parks and Rec Department [0:34:32] is embracing this diversification, [0:34:36] so to speak, of our parks. [0:34:37] And I think it is a good idea as well. [0:34:39] I think it's a good location for that. [0:34:42] My only comment would be to keep an eye on, [0:34:45] And if you do decide to contract the workout, keep an eye on the cost, and if ever it's more reasonable or efficient to have the city do it in-house than to just keep an eye on that contract. [0:34:59] But I too can embrace this new type of park. [0:35:04] And I think it's much needed for our community to have a place where adults can gather and enjoy lunch and enjoy the beauty of the surroundings, so thank you. [0:35:16] Thank you. [0:35:17] Dennis and Cindy, thank you to everyone. [0:35:19] And Melinda, thank you to the everyone in the agency for building this park for us. [0:35:24] That's one thing. [0:35:25] We do appreciate that and we accept it. [0:35:30] I'm hoping that it spurs additional growth down there in that area and maybe some additional [0:35:35] office buildings or different things in there because it does beautify the area quite a [0:35:40] bit. [0:35:41] If you drove by there like two days ago, you know, that big old blank. [0:35:45] Piece of dirt really doesn't seem very attractive, but whereas I couldn't visualize what the park's going to be and I think that it definitely will [0:35:53] Enhance the area and hopefully bring even more investment private investment [0:35:58] Chris I I forget by this comeatic is show is that night lit? [0:36:04] Yes, there were two like a couple of those decorative street lights that were similar on social and street will be in there [0:36:10] Can I remember? [0:36:11] Two? [0:36:12] Two. [0:36:13] Two. [0:36:14] Now there will be lights in there. [0:36:15] Well for my juvenile administration days I'm really hesitant to have parks without well [0:36:19] lit areas for a night time and I'm not sure that that's going to be adequate lighting [0:36:25] so we may have to boost that. [0:36:27] Okay. [0:36:28] Well I don't expect you to do it tonight. [0:36:30] No. [0:36:31] No. [0:36:32] There's a couple of lights now proposed as I would put on there. [0:36:36] Yes. [0:36:37] similar to our lights along social street. [0:36:39] But nothing in the alley proximity then. [0:36:43] There are more, let me get the drawing out again. [0:36:47] It looks like it could be an appropriate meeting place [0:36:49] for sometimes a higher crime area, at least in the past, [0:36:54] if we want to start off on the right foot. [0:36:57] Comment on that. [0:36:58] I know that there were some crime prevention philosophies [0:37:01] through the design of this tennis. [0:37:05] Just to give you a clue, [0:37:06] the lights are planned to be here and here. [0:37:10] This would be Fourth Avenue South there. [0:37:15] And as you know, glad to be able to put some street lights [0:37:19] out on Fourth Avenue there, it's on their side [0:37:21] where we have lights and I could not tell you [0:37:23] what the lighting is over in the alley. [0:37:26] I cannot remember, I call it the Helper parking lot. [0:37:29] I do not remember if they have lighting [0:37:31] in that parking lot or not. [0:37:34] I would suggest we at least re-evaluate to make sure that the [0:37:37] the adequate lumination in those tuck-the-way corners. [0:37:41] I would just add that during the design of this, [0:37:46] that was part of the request of the design of the park itself, [0:37:49] the vegetation, how it's lower, and the site distances. [0:37:53] Crime prevention was a element of the design of the park. [0:37:57] Chris. [0:37:59] All right, so you know additional lights. [0:38:01] We have a roll call vote. [0:38:04] Jim, I. [0:38:05] Yes. [0:38:06] Rebecca Mills like that. [0:38:07] Yes. [0:38:08] Best talking. [0:38:08] Yes. [0:38:09] Sean Baragurd. [0:38:10] Yes. [0:38:11] Don Hall. [0:38:12] Yes. [0:38:13] Suzanne Hopkins. [0:38:13] Yes. [0:38:14] Greg Maxine. [0:38:15] Yes. [0:38:16] Motion passes seven to zero. [0:38:17] Thank you, Senator Dennis and Melinda. [0:38:20] I'll be burning in about the year 2022. [0:38:23] All right. [0:38:27] Moving on by number four, consideration [0:38:29] of adoption of an ordinance for the annexation [0:38:31] of property consisting of 412.49 acres [0:38:35] with a zoning designation of open space located approximately 10,900 feet along the boundary [0:38:42] of the stank river canyon between Hankins Road North, 3,200 east extended, and the eastern [0:38:48] boundary of Deerkeys Lake, including the Evil Connegal Jump Site, Centeno Trail, Twin Falls [0:38:52] City Gun Range, Shosho and Falls Park, and Durkeys Lake. [0:38:56] Mitchell of that. [0:38:58] Thank you for the development director. [0:39:01] But I don't have to. [0:39:04] Two weeks ago we had the public hearing for this annexation that was approved for 412 acres [0:39:11] of annexation. [0:39:12] The item tonight is simply the adoption of the ordinance that makes it happen. [0:39:15] So we've gone and prepared the real description of the ordinance in accordance with the approval [0:39:19] from two weeks ago and we recommend that you adopt it as presented. [0:39:24] It is an ordinance. [0:39:25] So if we go ahead and adopt it, I would need to do the third and final business and wait [0:39:29] of the rules and all that. Do we have an ordinance number? 3058. [0:39:35] 3058, alright. Did you have any other comments? Just to answer your questions if you've got them. [0:39:43] Chris talking. Is it appropriate to make a motion? I think so. I didn't see other [0:39:49] lights. I would move to suspend the rules and place ordinance 3058 on third and [0:39:55] final by title only. Second. Moved by Chris talking in the second by Suzanne [0:40:01] Hawkins that we place ordinance 3058 and third and final by title only and suspend [0:40:06] the rules to do so. [0:40:07] Leanna Rokalvo. [0:40:09] Rebecca Nelsweica. [0:40:10] Yes. [0:40:11] Chris Talkington. [0:40:12] Yes. [0:40:13] Sean Berriger. [0:40:14] Yes. [0:40:15] Don Hall. [0:40:16] Yes. [0:40:17] Suzanne Hunken. [0:40:18] Yes. [0:40:19] Greg Lentine. [0:40:20] Yes. [0:40:21] Jim Munn. [0:40:22] Yes. [0:40:23] Motion passes 7-0. [0:40:24] I would now entertain a motion to pass. [0:40:26] I'm sorry. [0:40:27] Leanna Rokalvo. [0:40:28] Would you please read the title? [0:40:31] The ordinance of the city council [0:40:32] of the city of Twin Falls, Idaho, [0:40:34] annexing certain rail property below described, [0:40:37] providing the zoning classification therefore, [0:40:40] and ordering the necessary area they have packed [0:40:42] in zoning districts, map them in here. [0:40:45] Thank you. [0:40:48] Council wishes on ordinance 3058, Don Hall. [0:40:51] So moved. [0:40:54] Second. [0:40:56] And then moved by Don Hall and seconded by Suzanne Hawkins [0:40:58] that we accept ordinance 3058. [0:41:00] See no lights for discussion. [0:41:03] We have a real cover. [0:41:05] Chris talking. [0:41:05] Yes. [0:41:06] Sean Berger. [0:41:07] Yes. [0:41:08] Don Hall. [0:41:09] Yes. [0:41:10] Suzanne Hunken. [0:41:11] Yes. [0:41:12] Greg Lanthine. [0:41:12] Yes. [0:41:13] Jim Mine. [0:41:14] Yes. [0:41:15] Rebecca Nelswechka. [0:41:16] Yes. [0:41:17] Motion passes. [0:41:18] How about you? [0:41:19] That was a wonderful. [0:41:20] Item number five. [0:41:23] General, general outline of the upcoming special meeting [0:41:26] be held on Thursday November 21st for the possible Canyon jumping. [0:41:31] That's what that looks like. [0:41:32] Oh, it's listed here. [0:41:33] I don't think I'll have a grammar or a correct book. [0:41:35] All right. Good evening, Mayor and Council. [0:41:37] Mike Williams, our assistant to the City major. [0:41:39] Thank you. [0:41:40] As you know, we're having a public forum on Thursday at four o'clock at [0:41:46] O'Leary Middle School to hear some proposals from or a proposed jump [0:41:51] across the state of opinion. [0:41:54] We've discussed this before in Council and kind of had a general idea of what the meeting [0:41:59] would look like. [0:42:00] We wanted to bring this before you tonight to give a general outline of what the meeting [0:42:05] could look like to set expectations and give you an opportunity to comment on it. [0:42:12] This is live tonight, so I want to take the opportunity as well to take care of meeting [0:42:15] some housekeeping items. [0:42:16] We'll be sending out a PSA with some of this information as well. [0:42:19] We will start the meeting at 4 o'clock. [0:42:21] We would ask anyone who is going to attend that meeting to not show up until 3.30 p.m. [0:42:28] There is school in session that day and generally the buses will be gone by 3.30. [0:42:33] We probably don't want a whole bunch of folks wandering around on a leery campus either at [0:42:38] 2.30 or 3. [0:42:41] Might make some folks something easy. [0:42:42] So show up at 3.30, the room will be set up and we'll be ready to go. [0:42:48] We are proposing a 15-minute presentation from each one [0:42:52] of the applicants followed by a break. [0:42:55] We will be feeding the City Council. [0:42:58] We think this meeting will go for quite a long time. [0:43:03] The idea is to have the public comment portion similar [0:43:07] to our public hearing process where we'll have a timer [0:43:09] and give folks two minutes to comment. [0:43:12] We'd like to point out if you are not able [0:43:14] and you're listening tonight we'll be advertising this as well. [0:43:17] If you are not able to make the meeting, [0:43:19] we have set up an email address. [0:43:21] It is jump at tfid.org. [0:43:24] And you can send your comments to us. [0:43:26] We will have them prepared. [0:43:27] We will forward them to the council [0:43:30] and have them at the meeting as well, [0:43:32] from those interested in seeing those comments [0:43:34] from folks who would like to attend the meeting. [0:43:36] But the idea is to have the Q&A from the city council [0:43:41] after the public comment period. [0:43:43] The reason behind that is we'd like to level the play [0:43:46] field as much as possible. For example, those who are presenting first, you know, can hear [0:43:52] the questions from the council and have those that are waiting to present and have the opportunity [0:43:56] to get a pulse of the council and hear those questions and modify their presentations accordingly. [0:44:01] So that's the idea behind waiting for questions until the presentations have been heard and [0:44:06] the public's had an opportunity to comment. This final step or final part of the agenda [0:44:15] is something that maybe you all want to discuss tonight, [0:44:18] to maybe start deliberated and have an idea [0:44:21] of what the next steps are going to be. [0:44:23] The applicants definitely in the community [0:44:25] will probably want to know that. [0:44:27] We probably want to talk about setting up a time [0:44:29] to discuss the proposals and what information [0:44:32] that you all gathered at that meeting, [0:44:35] and maybe discuss a rating system [0:44:38] or how we're going to narrow this down [0:44:40] If it's something that we will be doing to have that ready to go. [0:44:49] Certain questions about the proposed. [0:44:51] We have a couple of lights. [0:44:52] One quick one. [0:44:54] We have been contacted by the media [0:44:56] that they will be broadcasting the presentation portion [0:44:59] of it live. [0:45:00] Is that on KMT, is it on the Fox affiliate, [0:45:03] or the CW, or what's it on, or all of them, or? [0:45:05] I believe a KMT will be broadcasting that live on 14. [0:45:11] I don't know what station there. They will be there. They will be broadcasting live, but I'm not aware of which station that will be on. [0:45:18] My understanding is following that evening, we do know that they're going to tape it, and that later in the evening, the balance of the presentation will be viewed or shown on Fox. [0:45:35] They're prime time ends at nine, so they're a thought process. [0:45:39] I know that in discussion with them and we'll have to have discussions, they were a little [0:45:44] concerned with the live broadcast of the actual comments that way they don't have any [0:45:47] control over what someone may say that would be in violation of their FCC license. [0:45:53] And so they wanted to be sure that's the reason they're going to tape that portion and actually [0:45:58] show it later because that way they can have a chance to edit it should something be said [0:46:02] that they can't broadcast. [0:46:04] So that's the current plan on that one. [0:46:08] Would you have some questions? [0:46:09] Chris, I can assure you, as an old broadcaster, [0:46:11] there are very few rules and regulations [0:46:13] you can't violate under today's FCC standards. [0:46:16] So I suspect that's not the real reason, [0:46:19] but we're quite certain it's live airing, [0:46:23] as opposed to taping. [0:46:25] My understanding, you know, Travis and Josh [0:46:27] met with KMT, my understanding it's alive [0:46:29] with a five to 10 second delay, is that? [0:46:32] No delay at all, it's straight out live. [0:46:34] I wasn't supposed to do a film clip and there was a tan sort of a thing though. [0:46:39] The media wanted to broadcast it live. [0:46:44] We did not believe that this was their call and their decision is not something that we [0:46:48] advocated for and we didn't believe that we were in a position to tell them no. [0:46:53] And Josh, I would suspect you are already in contact with them because they will have [0:46:56] of requirements for mics and setting up and running their cables and lighting and who [0:47:04] knows what else. [0:47:05] Yeah. [0:47:11] Josh Palmer. [0:47:12] I should use my own technology, right? [0:47:15] Yeah, we've been in touch with KMT. [0:47:17] Their crews have gone out and looked at it. [0:47:20] We're actually going to be going back out tomorrow to make sure all those connections [0:47:22] work. [0:47:23] KTVV is also expressed interest in doing its broadcast this evening. [0:47:27] broadcast, doing a live, basically would be like a three to five minute shoot. [0:47:31] Yeah, that's right. [0:47:33] Okay. [0:47:34] The next question is, this is not a regular meeting for its no decisions really can be made by [0:47:41] the Council, can they? [0:47:45] This actually will be an open meeting we're noticing that posting the agenda, we don't [0:47:49] expect you'll make a decision. [0:47:51] Yeah. [0:47:52] And if the Council decides to not limit participation per the event to only one, it's [0:47:59] What might we set a surety bond level at that meeting to say this is a range we would expect [0:48:07] and it can be applied in more than one case if we let everybody say they want to participate? [0:48:13] Okay, is it a two million dollar protection bond? [0:48:16] Yeah, what we've talked about this internally is that first you would choose your preferences [0:48:23] And then we would do it like we do request [0:48:26] for qualifications for engineers, for example, [0:48:29] and you tell us which one is your first priority, [0:48:31] we would start negotiating with them, [0:48:33] but we would take to them whatever requirements [0:48:36] that the council sets for bonding. [0:48:40] Well, but if they are to use access to public land, [0:48:45] meaning the city's public land, [0:48:47] then we'd be well advised to set any sort of bonding [0:48:51] the same for any user. [0:48:54] It probably will be the same for any user, [0:48:56] but I'm going to tell you, you're going to hear [0:48:58] some different types of proposals, [0:49:01] so it might depend on what they might want to do. [0:49:03] But Chris, I'm going to tell, I'll say to this, [0:49:06] the whole council. [0:49:07] You don't need to worry about any of the conditions, [0:49:10] because before you approve this, [0:49:12] you will have all the requirements [0:49:14] that make you comfortable to do this. [0:49:17] Well, I'm speaking only for one council person, [0:49:19] But I want to scare away the people that are under-capwise and don't have a full idea of the public protection I plan to hopefully enact, and that means a very big surely bond. [0:49:32] And that's why I'd say, you know, in the range of, are you prepared to get that? [0:49:37] Travis, thank you. [0:49:38] So I think it's fair for you to ask any of those questions that you want to get that comfort level. [0:49:48] I would ask the council not to set a floor on a bond amount yet because my fear is that you may set a floor that you think is [0:50:00] Good and appropriate only to come to find out that it may be too low after we spend some time working with iCrimpton going through risk [0:50:08] Some of the risk analysis pieces of that [0:50:10] That's a good advance. [0:50:12] Rebecca, I'd like to say. [0:50:14] Thank you, Mayor. [0:50:16] Just a question about the starting time. [0:50:19] I know I've already gotten some feedback about the meeting, the presentation starting at 4pm, which might [0:50:25] prevent a lot of our citizens from coming. [0:50:30] And I know that the comment period is after that, perhaps starting at six or later, but [0:50:35] how do you comment on something if you miss the presentation? [0:50:39] So I'm just wondering, did we think about how that might affect participation and what [0:50:46] can we do to maybe have it at a time that's convenient for the public and not just us. [0:50:52] And I know that it might go late, but we can always have further conversations down the [0:50:57] road. [0:50:58] I just would ask us to consider that. [0:51:01] And in my second comment is that perhaps we might move the question and answer from the [0:51:09] city council to before the public comment because a lot of the comments might be addressed [0:51:15] in that question and answer period. [0:51:19] That just might, might input on the order. [0:51:22] So this is the time that we have proposed as a start. [0:51:29] If there's a time that the council wants to change that too, we are happy to work with [0:51:34] a literary school and move that to any time that you may feel that may be appropriate. [0:51:41] I think what's important here is what we've done is just provide a starting place for a [0:51:47] conversation. [0:51:49] The second place, and we originally, when we were having our conversation, having the [0:51:54] council have the ability to ask questions and then go into a public comment and then go [0:51:59] go into another series of questions. We thought that number one, we did not believe that because [0:52:07] of maybe the sensitive nature of this, that it would be appropriate for a direct one-on-one [0:52:12] discussion between applicant and citizen. And so we're trying to have the council serve [0:52:16] as that buffer. And so that you would actually ask questions on citizens' behalf. So whether [0:52:21] they came in by email or if they were asked during that presentation, just as we do in [0:52:28] a normal standard land use public hearing if those were questions that you felt were important, [0:52:33] those are ones that could also be asked. [0:52:36] And then I think my kid on another very important point is if you are number six, and I'm sure [0:52:43] that you're going to have a collection of standard questions that are going to be important [0:52:48] in this process, and then there might be some questions that are very specific to the individual. [0:52:54] If you're number six, you've heard the question, and you've heard responses, and rather than [0:52:58] answering that question, you might retort on why one, two, three, four, and five don't, [0:53:07] their solutions don't work and why yours do or does instead of really spending time on [0:53:12] that. [0:53:13] And so we didn't want, one of the things that we're going to do is we're actually going [0:53:16] to have you draw the names out of the hat this evening to determine the rank and the [0:53:20] starting order. And we did not, we're trying to create an apples to apples and fairness [0:53:25] place and we didn't want one applicant to have an unfair competitive advantage by being [0:53:30] able to sit back, hear everything and maybe come across as a better applicant than maybe [0:53:39] what they truly are. [0:53:42] Jim Martin, then we'll back to Rebecca. [0:53:47] Mike, I only have one and it's kind of just a Jim Mun personal problem here, but at six [0:53:52] a clock I have to teach college. So I'm only going to be able to be there from four to probably [0:53:59] five thirty quarters six and I guess I'm pleading to the council that if you make is there any [0:54:06] way that we could do at a subsequent meeting make our ranking and so forth. I would want [0:54:13] to participate and I just can't get out and teach it. [0:54:16] And I think bounce with you. I think my plan would be in my mind that we would go to a we'd have a chance that I [0:54:23] to [0:54:25] Digest the information that we heard and then come back in a later date to actually rank the proposals [0:54:31] Okay, because I'll do my homework after I leave I will listen to the public comment [0:54:36] I will listen to council questions, and then I'd like to get back and [0:54:39] Amongst us and so we have a discussion, so I'm sorry. I can't participate in the whole thing [0:54:43] I would just ask the council to consider a time that would be most convenient for our citizens, and also sorry to Councilman Munn, who obviously would be more [0:54:59] for him to be earlier, but I really don't think we should start before 5 PM, but that is up [0:55:05] to the council, so that is just my request. [0:55:09] The 4 o'clock I think we often hold, start meetings during the budget process at 4, and [0:55:16] so to me that the 4 o'clock time is the same for me as that we do during the budget process, [0:55:22] that doesn't mean that time is wrong. [0:55:24] I'm just saying we already have started at four o'clock. [0:55:28] I would like to have Jim there for all of the presentations [0:55:32] and I believe we can have all the presentations done by six o'clock. [0:55:36] If we can. [0:55:37] Yeah, I'm Mr. What's up? [0:55:39] Well, the presentations by six. [0:55:42] The other time, I'm not sure when they may end, [0:55:44] but the public comment and the question and answer portion. [0:55:48] I don't know if this is helpful or not. [0:55:49] All the proposals are currently on our website. [0:55:52] so all the information that we gathered. [0:55:55] So anyone wants you to jump on it or knows it can't be [0:55:58] there earlier, it might be helpful to go on our website [0:56:01] and check those out. [0:56:02] I'm also asking that all the presentations are given [0:56:04] to us by Wednesday, so we have an opportunity [0:56:07] to make sure they work. [0:56:09] They're on our laptop and I can be composed [0:56:11] of those on mine as well. [0:56:13] John, John Burger? [0:56:15] Yeah, I appreciate Rebecca's comments of starting later, [0:56:20] but I would also point out we have a number [0:56:22] of other commissions and such that meet during the week at all times of the day. [0:56:28] We have noon meetings, we have afternoon meetings, and honestly I think we're never going to [0:56:34] find a time that works for absolutely everyone, and I think in the spirit of not having a bunch [0:56:42] of citizens have to sit there until one o'clock in the morning while we're still hearing comments. [0:56:47] I think if we can start at four, I think it's reasonable. [0:56:51] the presentations as proposals as Mike's that are online now, [0:56:55] people can make comment in advance by email. [0:57:00] I just think that we're never gonna find the right time [0:57:03] for everyone and I think a four o'clock time works well. [0:57:12] This is going to be replayed on the air [0:57:15] and will it also be on our website as well? [0:57:18] We recording it anyway that people can go back [0:57:20] and access the presentations. [0:57:23] We aren't recording. [0:57:26] We are not. [0:57:27] We use the city, I'm not recording. [0:57:28] I don't believe we have the equipment to do that. [0:57:30] I don't know if the answer is if we can hear this or stream it through KMBT. [0:57:35] I don't know. [0:57:36] It sounds like KMBT is going to play it later. [0:57:38] Is that what you said? [0:57:40] That is our understanding. [0:57:41] Is there any way that we could get that somehow and then we stream it as well so that citizens [0:57:48] that aren't even able to make it, because some have already, we have some folks going [0:57:54] south because it's wintertime, and they might be affected by this because they might live [0:58:00] out there. [0:58:01] And I'd like for them to be able to see it. [0:58:02] And then are we going to receive comments later, too, that we can digest as well through [0:58:09] this process? [0:58:12] Does that make sense? [0:58:13] So the first part, we can work with K&BT and maybe, [0:58:20] I don't know if Benito's going to be there [0:58:23] recording the whole thing, are you? [0:58:25] I don't know about the little thing. [0:58:26] Okay, but we'll have several media partners [0:58:30] that we might be able to record it [0:58:32] and if we can't necessarily put it on our website, [0:58:36] we might be able to have a link to their websites [0:58:39] that allow for them to host and click it [0:58:42] to be able to get that information. [0:58:44] The second piece is, so maybe so a little bit of why did we move? [0:58:50] Let me stop you there. [0:58:52] I would really appreciate if there's some way we could do that because again, we have some [0:58:57] citizens that can't even be there, there are snowbirds, things like that, and this is going [0:59:02] to affect them. [0:59:04] And I'd like for them to be able to see the presentation, what this is all about, and then [0:59:07] I would like to receive those comments as well for a period of time. [0:59:11] And then the second piece is that website or the email address that we set up will be [0:59:17] up for a period of time to be determined by the council. [0:59:22] And really it becomes where you stop your deliberation process is where we will cut off [0:59:27] that. [0:59:28] And so that window of time however long you want that will be up and running. [0:59:32] And the reason that we set that up is we didn't want those emails to get lost in other [0:59:37] active email accounts. [0:59:41] So we wanted to set up one that was just for this. [0:59:44] Well, I think that that might solve some of the issues [0:59:47] with what we're back as saying, [0:59:49] because, and I agree with Sean, there is no perfect time. [0:59:52] Sometimes in the middle afternoon, [0:59:54] that works for some people in the evening, doesn't, [0:59:55] because people have, they might go to graveyards [0:59:58] or swing shifts or whatever. [0:59:59] So go to bed at night. [1:00:01] Or go to bed at night. [1:00:02] But I think it's imperative that we could keep that out there, [1:00:05] because this is such a big deal in our community [1:00:08] has so much potential on all different sides of public safety and income as well for some [1:00:17] of our businesses. [1:00:18] So there's so many dynamics here. [1:00:20] I'd like to have the citizens have as much opportunity to make comments back after looking [1:00:24] at the proposals as possible. [1:00:27] Jim, just to make it clear here because I do have to do my homework later and read and [1:00:34] listen to everybody because I'm not going to have an opportunity there. [1:00:37] It's going to be live on KMBT. [1:00:40] I'm looking at Josh. [1:00:41] So, you know, okay, but this whole [1:00:46] possibly eight hour debacle will not be alive on TV. [1:00:51] They're going to live broadcast. [1:00:52] Their plan is to live broadcast the first part [1:00:55] up until the public comment period. [1:00:57] After that point, they will record it [1:01:00] and then they'll play it at a later time. [1:01:02] They're going to start playing on the fuck, Jim. [1:01:04] And there's another network that will be there. [1:01:07] I'm just trying to figure out some way to get the information so I can't be there where [1:01:15] I can do it and we're not going to record it. [1:01:18] We're going to try. [1:01:19] Okay. [1:01:20] But it's going to be an hour and a half just for them to get through the app. [1:01:23] Yeah, and I'll be able to see those. [1:01:25] I'll be there for those. [1:01:26] But then the public comment which is extraordinarily important to me and the question and answers [1:01:31] from the council is really important to me also and so where do I get that? [1:01:35] From what the information I was up to me, but we will they have told us that the Fox channel [1:01:40] Which is channel over with you [1:01:42] What will be on at nine o'clock so you can set your DBR for whatever program it shows [1:01:47] There's probably gonna show something else and you can record that for several hours [1:01:56] To throw me off a little bit they should be able to [1:01:59] Recorded and watch it there and thus we're gonna try to set up links or whatever else we can do so everybody can watch it at a different time [1:02:05] should they want? [1:02:06] Well, I'll work with Josh so I can get that. [1:02:08] Right. [1:02:09] So, yeah, we hadn't talked about just developing a partnership with KMT where maybe we can even [1:02:13] post it to Channel 17. [1:02:15] We're also recording the audio. [1:02:16] Audio sometimes is a bit of a problem with a lot of faces, but we'll provide an avenue [1:02:23] where people can view that entire meeting later. [1:02:25] Okay. [1:02:26] Thanks. [1:02:27] All right, Mike. [1:02:28] I should mention to you that ABC has mentioned that they're going to be there with cameras. [1:02:31] There's going to be a lot of cameras there. [1:02:33] All right, so get your powder on or whatever you need to do, [1:02:35] dress nicely. [1:02:37] ABC wants to do some sort of documentation as well, [1:02:41] so they'll have a camera crew there. [1:02:42] Right, and as I look at it, we're talking about this, [1:02:45] and I'm getting the mood of the council [1:02:47] that we probably want them to weigh the ranking [1:02:49] to a different date. [1:02:51] I actually think we have three questions here, [1:02:53] that we will be, as a council, need to answer. [1:02:56] One will be that yes, we're gonna allow this jump [1:02:59] and we're gonna work with somebody. [1:03:01] two is no we're not going to allow this jump and we're not going to rank it we're just [1:03:05] going to say no and number three is that maybe we're going to say if the right proposal [1:03:11] of this first person or this second person really wows us we may decide that yes we can [1:03:16] make this going to safely be done and so I think there's actually those choices are [1:03:21] still up there I think that at least some of the jumpers think just because they got [1:03:26] at least on the other side, I mean it was yes on our side. [1:03:29] And I don't know if that's the case. [1:03:31] I wouldn't at this time to say we're only going to do one yes [1:03:34] and the rest now we've understood your question correctly. [1:03:37] Well I'm saying yes or no to ever even doing it. [1:03:41] The no but that's a fundamental question that I'm not. [1:03:46] The purpose of the ranking would be just like we do [1:03:48] with engineers, that's the reason we ask for a request [1:03:51] for qualifications. [1:03:52] We can come back and rank them, we can rank them one through six [1:03:55] And we start negotiating with group number one. [1:03:58] And if we can't reach a suitable deal with group number one, [1:04:01] we move on to group number two. [1:04:02] Fine but you have to have the questions to know [1:04:04] to reach an agreement. [1:04:05] I don't think we're at that point yet. [1:04:07] Part of where we're going to have to get to. [1:04:10] To make sure that this is something [1:04:11] that's right for the community and we can do safely. [1:04:15] Sean. [1:04:17] So I'd like to make a suggestion having dealt with this issue [1:04:21] for nine years in some fashion or another [1:04:23] in either my day job or this job. [1:04:28] Every time we try to figure out what the next step is, [1:04:31] we appeal about 14 layers off the onion. [1:04:34] And I would suggest that we focus on, [1:04:37] does this format work well for Thursday [1:04:41] to gather information? [1:04:44] We certainly can have some discussion [1:04:46] at the end of that meeting to talk about the next step. [1:04:49] I would actually say to determine [1:04:53] that we're going to rank proposals tonight? [1:04:57] No. [1:04:57] Is the wrong phrasing. [1:04:58] I think what we're going to do is we're going to review [1:05:01] the information that we got. [1:05:03] And that's probably the most likely next step. [1:05:06] Do either do that Thursday after we've listened to all [1:05:08] of this input, or to decide Thursday night when we're [1:05:12] going to schedule that time to sit down and sort of talk [1:05:15] through what did we hear? [1:05:18] Where are our questions? [1:05:19] Do we still have some? [1:05:21] Is everyone crazy or are these the best things ever [1:05:24] and how are we gonna move forward? [1:05:25] I had to try to figure that out before you hear anything. [1:05:28] I mean, it's just, it's a struggle [1:05:30] and I think it's exhausting us [1:05:32] and it tends to drift us around from just trying to go [1:05:35] through the process of staying focused [1:05:36] on what we're trying to protect. [1:05:37] So I would recommend that we, this is a good format [1:05:41] and at the end of the meeting on Thursday, [1:05:44] we talk about when we get back together [1:05:46] to review what we learned. [1:05:47] I'm sure the gym too, they allow him to just depend on what you would like. [1:05:55] Mike, do you have anything else? [1:05:57] No, if there's nothing else, if you'd like to designate someone from the council. [1:06:01] We have one more question for Suzanne Hawkins. You're lighted, I keep changing my mind, but I'm going to ask. [1:06:07] I'm afraid I know the answer. Do you have any kind of schematic or chart or points that we should be looking for as far as positives or negatives? [1:06:16] how are we, I mean, we're gonna have seven different opinions. [1:06:21] And so is there some, [1:06:24] you know, I would, [1:06:25] I would send out a question for qualification. [1:06:28] Right. [1:06:28] And then I would have a copy of that [1:06:29] and then ask for a seven rank different bullets [1:06:31] that range from, you know, what do you wanna, [1:06:34] what are you trying to do here? [1:06:36] How are you to address public safety traffic? [1:06:39] You know, who are your references? [1:06:42] Maybe I'd start with that. [1:06:43] That's really the information we've asked for. [1:06:46] I think that would be a place to start to begin to get a good feel for the different proposals. [1:06:55] We do not have a tabulation cheap worked out if that's what you're asking. [1:07:01] That's what I'm asking. [1:07:02] We do not have one and that is by design. [1:07:05] Really this is a council process. [1:07:08] And the purpose of the group that met was to get the information in a position that could be presented to the Council by the applicants. [1:07:18] And we felt the working group that did that has completed their job. [1:07:23] It wasn't to go out and to create, and this is how to score it, because the value set on how you score it actually might be determined through this process. [1:07:33] So, I think that Mike's guidance is sound, where if you take the questions that were asked [1:07:42] and you use that as part of the value set to judge that, then you build upon that as the [1:07:49] foundation. [1:07:50] I think that you may come up with something remarkably similar. [1:07:54] Okay. [1:07:55] I'm actually quite impressed with the effort you put together, the schematic of everything [1:08:01] Mike. [1:08:02] most of the right questions and Sean's comments are appropriate about taking some time to [1:08:07] digest this and get back for decision making. [1:08:10] Susan, I thought about your question too, and I would suggest that the Council look at [1:08:17] the experience that the applicants come to us with prior publicly staged events. [1:08:24] Some of the successes they had, one of the attributes themselves has been perfect. [1:08:29] we may want to check up on. [1:08:31] But I believe a novice is going to be [1:08:34] looked at a little differently than somebody [1:08:35] that's had some miles under the belt, so to speak. [1:08:39] So I think that'll be one ingredient that I will look for. [1:08:44] All right. [1:08:45] I'll go ahead, John. [1:08:46] One other question. [1:08:47] On the advanced input that you get on the email and such, [1:08:51] can you provide us either electronically or copies [1:08:55] of those prior to the meeting so that it's not [1:08:58] just to throw them up on the overhead to put them in the public record because I think [1:09:02] that might be good information for us to have. [1:09:04] I'd anticipate too that you all may be contacted directly through your own emails or phone calls. [1:09:09] That might be helpful to pass along to each other too if you do get those. [1:09:13] Okay. So how did you want to do that? I don't actually have a hat with some names in it. [1:09:18] We have six, we have seven applicants and then we have six that are going to be at the meeting. [1:09:23] We told them we'd do a random drawing to determine order that's important to all of them. [1:09:27] So if he doesn't make somebody to let's adjust you start at one end or the other and everyone [1:09:31] We start well if that was the last person gets to draw name up [1:09:35] There's one one name, but I will skip out and well there's six [1:09:38] So just start on Suzanne's in and work your way across that seat one through seven so [1:09:44] First presentation is being drawn out by seat number one [1:09:50] REO development group [1:10:00] American Broadcasting Corporation [1:10:03] Incon productions. Just skip over me. [1:10:12] We're going to keep you blamed. [1:10:18] The Prine Cooley reenactment Jim Monchum. [1:10:23] I didn't know that was in there. [1:10:26] Adrenaline Nation. [1:10:33] That clean media LLC. [1:10:35] Should we number these two? [1:10:37] Travis is right. [1:10:38] We'll make a point productions. [1:10:40] All right. [1:10:42] That's the order and you will notify them. [1:10:45] Do you want this look back? [1:10:46] We wrote the numbers on. [1:10:48] Yeah, that's good. [1:10:49] One, two, three, four, five, and this was recorded to, [1:10:52] I think we figured it out. [1:10:55] All right, thank you, Mike. [1:10:57] Good job. [1:10:57] Okay, moving on to item the new number item, number six, [1:11:01] which is a request to consider initiating a hearing [1:11:05] and a future council meeting to revoke the alcohol license [1:11:08] for the Pioneer Club located at 1519 Kimberly Road. [1:11:13] I do not see a representation from them [1:11:17] in the audience, but we, since we are setting it, [1:11:20] my theory is we're setting a hearing for a later date, [1:11:24] and we, if that maybe makes me want to set it [1:11:26] a little bit later. [1:11:27] Excuse me, Mayor. [1:11:28] Yes. [1:11:29] I need to recuse myself. [1:11:30] As Pioneer Club is one of my customers. [1:11:32] All right, thank you, Suzanne. [1:11:33] That's always the dangers of small business people [1:11:36] and council, they do have customers. [1:11:38] Okay, thank you, Suzanne. [1:11:41] If we decide to proceed, what the things [1:11:43] that we're required to do is to hand a liver or a nail [1:11:46] the notice of hearing date anyway, so. [1:11:49] Okay, so if I had to do your presentation [1:11:51] and we can decide what that hearing date [1:11:53] or if we're gonna set one tonight, [1:11:54] I thought that will be the council's resume. [1:11:57] I'll be the spokesman for a week about other folks [1:12:00] who are involved in this. [1:12:01] You probably noticed our building and fire staff back there [1:12:05] and Fritz is here to pipe in when he's needed to. [1:12:10] We have, we've been looking at a building permit [1:12:14] for some time now for the addition [1:12:16] that was made to the Pioneer Club. [1:12:18] The building permit came in for basically [1:12:21] to add on a storage room in the back, [1:12:26] and the plans were reviewed in that vein [1:12:28] and issued the permit in that vein, [1:12:31] and then so on and so forth, [1:12:33] all the way through the process, [1:12:34] through the final occupancy, [1:12:37] or the final inspection that was done on the first of this month. [1:12:40] So, the difference between a storage unit or a storage unit for the storage area and the [1:12:51] building code as classified as an S1 storage area versus a bar which is the rest of the [1:12:57] building there is classified as an A3 as the herb. [1:13:01] A3, A3 assembly which is people coming together to congregate in the place and the difference [1:13:09] from a building code regulation standpoint is significant. [1:13:12] And again, as we go through this process [1:13:19] with a storage occupancy group, [1:13:23] it carries with a certain building requirements [1:13:27] that have to be met. [1:13:28] Had that been submitted as a assembly group, [1:13:31] we would have a very different set of rules in place. [1:13:34] And primarily about the safety [1:13:36] and the life safety issues of the occupants of that space. [1:13:40] So, we go in on the first of November, we do the final inspection on the first, and then [1:13:50] as it turns out, just like two days before that, Captain Lauda with our fire department went through [1:13:56] to do the annual business inspection that they do every year for every business, and he went [1:14:02] in there on the 28th, I think it was, and noted a couple of minor violations and talked [1:14:08] to the guys and said, I'll be back and double check on these two violations when he came back [1:14:13] on the 12th, so 11 days after our final inspection for the storage. That it passed and on the fifth, [1:14:19] we prepared a certificate of occupancy that was never picked up and we still have it in [1:14:25] our possession at the office. On the 12th, he went into the inspection again and noted [1:14:30] that the room that had been closed in for a storage was now opened up and part of the bar [1:14:39] and asked about it and was told to have and they were in fact expanding the bar area which [1:14:46] caused some concern as it was through the whole process of the storage area. One of those key [1:14:53] requirements is fire sprinklers and you know there's some other things that may or may not [1:14:57] come into play with exiting issues and parking space in the bathroom and all those kind of things [1:15:05] that happen when you add assembly space versus storage space. No permit was requested for the [1:15:12] conversion from storage to assembly. They were told through the process that this is being issued [1:15:18] as a storage permit or sealing this as a storage, you know, certificate of occupancy and should you [1:15:26] need to come and convert that, you'll need to come back and get a building permit. [1:15:32] So it's basically been opened up into an assembly area, a much larger assembly area than was originally [1:15:41] planned. [1:15:42] The occupancy rating now is 175 occupants where it used to be 110. [1:15:47] The increase adds a requirement for fire sprinklers, we know that much, and it may require some [1:15:53] other things as well. [1:15:56] The added occupancy in the room without the fire sprinklers causes some significant concerns [1:16:01] about the safety of the building to be used as a bar. [1:16:07] In addition to that, the wall that was tore out happened to be the former perimeter wall [1:16:13] of the building is a load bearing wall. [1:16:16] Also a concern since we haven't seen any plans or structural analysis or anything like [1:16:21] at the building, you know, can really stand to have that all removed. [1:16:25] So we've got some significant safety concerns with the building, the way it is now. [1:16:29] Earlier today, the building department, and not, again, [1:16:33] polished for the shortness, just starting next year. [1:16:37] For you all, there's a short notice. It's all kind of coming together in the last few days, [1:16:43] and we're kind of putting all these things together. So earlier today, the building part went out, [1:16:47] issued a stop work order, basically a red tag, is what you might have heard [1:16:51] work that was being done without the permit and so that happened. We also have some photographs [1:16:56] that were taken today, probably as good as any photograph of the storage area that was [1:17:10] final on November 1st. All of this was the storage area, everything that we can see here. [1:17:16] Okay. So again, we have some significant safety concerns with the building, so we did a stop [1:17:24] work order. We also plan tomorrow to have the building official to go out and probably [1:17:29] Or yeah, I think he's going to put up a do not occupy placard on the building. [1:17:34] We don't want people in an occupancy like an assembly to go into the building where we have [1:17:38] significant store or safety concerns to go in and have an unfortunate situation occurs. [1:17:46] So we're going to try and keep on that and get on that right away. [1:17:51] But let's get into the end of the report, I guess. [1:17:55] City Code 3912 is the Code 39, as the section deals with the City Issuing Alcohol Licenses [1:18:05] Businesses. [1:18:07] 3912 is the City Code that gives the Council authority to review those licenses. [1:18:13] And if the licensee is not in compliance with state and city laws, [1:18:21] that the Council has the right to consider a revocation [1:18:27] of the license, the call license, [1:18:28] and we think that's an appropriate step here as well. [1:18:32] We can't do that tonight. [1:18:33] Tonight, like I said, is just the opportunity [1:18:36] for the Council to say, yeah, let's have [1:18:37] that conversation later. [1:18:40] So, that's, I guess, down to the end of it. [1:18:43] We're recommending that we set a date for a hearing [1:18:48] to have the conversation about a revocation. [1:18:51] And with that, we'll turn it over. [1:18:54] Like I said, there's lots of us here [1:18:55] to help answer questions. [1:18:56] So. [1:18:59] I do have Rebecca, Bill Slickard. [1:19:01] Thank you, Mark. [1:19:03] Just a quick question on alcohol license. [1:19:06] We usually see them come through on the consent calendar. [1:19:10] And I think the information that I've had in the past [1:19:13] is it's mostly regulated by the state. [1:19:17] So are we checking on building permits [1:19:20] and making sure people are abiding by the building codes [1:19:24] for our other alcohol licenses, [1:19:28] or is this a special situation? [1:19:29] Can you just give me an idea of how the city usually proceeds? [1:19:47] So I know we check for zoning compliance [1:19:49] before we'll even bring them to you. [1:19:51] And then also, if they've got a certificate of occupancy, [1:19:54] then we're gonna assume that they're in compliance there. [1:19:57] And they do get the yearly inspections, [1:20:00] just like Mr. Fireman Lotta. [1:20:02] Well, the fire inspection happens to all businesses, [1:20:06] whether or not there's alcohol involved. [1:20:16] Thank you, Mayor. [1:20:17] I'm reading the memoranda you've sent forward here, [1:20:19] the memoranda I'm dated today. [1:20:22] On the second page, [1:20:25] I'm going to third to last paragraph in your background, [1:20:30] beginning the, this is the third to, [1:20:33] that would be the second paragraph on the second page, [1:20:35] it says, the Pioneer Club Building is not safe to occupy. [1:20:42] I mean, that is alarming. [1:20:45] And so the question I have is if staff is indicating [1:20:51] that this building is currently not safe to occupy, [1:20:55] then you would, I'm trying to figure out the process here. [1:21:02] If staff has determined that, [1:21:03] then you close the building, correct? [1:21:06] You close the building, okay, let me just walk through my mind that I want you to jump in and help me here. [1:21:11] So you would close the building, no further business to be conducted in the building. [1:21:17] And then we would have a subsequent hearing to allow Mr. [1:21:21] Pierce to give evidence in his defense and for us to proceed that way. [1:21:27] Two separate issues. [1:21:28] Okay, help me out. [1:21:29] I'm sorry. [1:21:29] I could have been more clear. [1:21:31] The building code issue, again, we do close the building, right? [1:21:35] building official has the authority to issue a do not occupy and that's what [1:21:40] they're going to be proceeding with right and what he's doing that that's not [1:21:43] what the council is being asked tonight okay so he's doing that and then [1:21:48] following that the work with the napkin designers and contractors to help them [1:21:53] get to a place where the building is able to read where that thing can be [1:21:56] removed okay and occupancy can be can be permitted okay separate from that [1:22:02] process we have another process that is the alcohol license and that is the [1:22:07] license that the council issues and that the council can can have a hearing to [1:22:12] revoke and that is the opportunity where we'll set the hearing date open it up [1:22:17] have the conversations about should or should not the alcohol license be [1:22:21] discussed okay except for from building issues but tied to the building issues [1:22:27] because it's the building issues that we're saying they're not complying if [1:22:29] If Mr. Pierce and the Building Department tomorrow come to some resolution and the businesses [1:22:35] allowed to proceed, we would then probably, so the building issue is resolved, correct? [1:22:46] Then it becomes somewhat moot in regards to the alcohol license, correct? [1:22:49] Then we could come back all that night of the hearing or just cancels all together because [1:22:54] there is no violations anymore. [1:22:55] Okay, I got it. [1:22:56] Right. [1:22:57] Thanks. [1:22:58] and then Rebecca is the next one. [1:23:01] I mean, I'm not certain looking at the picture there. [1:23:05] I mean, other than somehow between down tomorrow morning [1:23:10] that sprinklers are put in and proper exits [1:23:14] or whatever the building department feels they need, [1:23:16] I'm not sure how they come to resolution tomorrow. [1:23:20] That's my... [1:23:21] Well, can I respond to that? [1:23:23] Sure. Oh, thank you, Mayor. [1:23:25] The only thing I would figure is that the building department [1:23:28] would close that section of the building, which is the addition, correct? [1:23:32] And then the building could stay open, something to that. [1:23:35] Potentially, and perhaps the better person answer that is doing more so than me. [1:23:40] Okay, okay. [1:23:41] The concerns about the load bearing wall may or may not prevent the whole thing from. [1:23:47] But I would say if we're working toward a resolution actively, [1:23:52] then maybe there's a different feel come, you know, two weeks or [1:23:57] weeks from now and maybe there is a resolution in three weeks time. [1:24:01] Gotcha. [1:24:02] Thanks. [1:24:03] Rebecca Milster. [1:24:04] Thank you. [1:24:05] My question is similar to Councilman Munn in that it seems like we're moving quickly and [1:24:10] we haven't tried to or has the city tried to resolve the issue with the building permit [1:24:16] and kind of work through the options for the owner. [1:24:22] they've been presented with, as he's been presented with what he's in violation of and [1:24:28] his options for resolving it, because I would hate for us to set a hearing and not really [1:24:34] need to do that if the city can just work with the applicant. [1:24:38] But if maybe you could address anything that's been done up into this point. [1:24:43] So I guess I would start with the initial application for the billing permit was applied for as [1:24:49] a storage condition for storage with the very first review letter that's also [1:24:56] attached in the package. They're from the fire marshal comments right from the start [1:25:00] saying in addition to the A3 area the assembly area will require fire [1:25:08] sprinklers when it's over a hundred occupancy. The occupancy at the time was [1:25:12] already over a hundred and ten to start with so really any increase is going to [1:25:17] require Park Sprinklers so it's been fairly that particular point has been [1:25:23] fairly consistently and early on identified and as we go through the [1:25:27] process there's other places where the storage issue versus assembly issue is [1:25:32] noted again and again and then the plans there's notes on the plans that [1:25:36] say this is for storage and the permit was very clearly marked for a storage [1:25:40] building this is the dog and see that was prepared was for a storage you know [1:25:44] area. And then should that occupancy be changed, we need to come back in for [1:25:52] permit to change the occupancy from storage S1 to assembly A3. And those were [1:25:58] all comments passed along throughout the process. Then the final inspection [1:26:04] happens on November 1st and within a week work is being done to convert the [1:26:10] space without a permit. So I think there's been times when the message has been delivered [1:26:18] to the designer and the contractor and those kinds of things all throughout the process. [1:26:23] And then earlier today when they had the conversation, they were saying we're stopping [1:26:27] work and we're going to have this conversation tonight. [1:26:30] So. [1:26:31] Okay, thank you. [1:26:33] I have a procedural question for us if I could. [1:26:40] For us I'm assuming because this is a hearing that the council will be potentially quasi judicial that we should not take any public comments or are any kind of information from the applicant or anyone else in between now and then. [1:26:57] That's correct. [1:26:58] that we all understood that. [1:27:00] Chris Daniels. [1:27:01] And this is somewhat an unusual event because, at least as I understand it, the fire marshal [1:27:07] has the prerogative to declare a building unfit for occupancy and the no occupants here and [1:27:15] no usage sign goes up tomorrow morning. [1:27:18] The building official actually. [1:27:19] The building official. [1:27:20] The building official. [1:27:21] Not the fire marshal. [1:27:22] The building official can place the placard that do not occupy the placard. [1:27:27] Are we allowed under a quasi judicial to hear from the applicant at this time, Fritz? [1:27:39] He's the one that has an interest. [1:27:41] So, unlike some of the zoning issues here, where the public also has an interest. [1:27:46] So, I would say you can hear from him. [1:27:49] Okay. [1:27:50] And the last point is I hope that we inconvenience ourselves to hold a hearing as soon as possible. [1:27:56] We're not scheduled to have a meeting next Monday, but I think that we can publish for one. [1:28:00] That's the least we can do is to get it on the agenda as soon as possible [1:28:06] Jim well, I'm trying let me see if I can move through this thing very quickly [1:28:11] So our our our purpose is to set a hearing date [1:28:16] for the for the purposes of hearing a request or evoked in alcohol license and [1:28:22] We're not meeting on the 21st or 25th, correct? [1:28:26] So the next regular schedule council meeting would be December 2nd [1:28:29] And so we are going to, we would set a hearing for the purposes of that. [1:28:36] Prior to that, Mr. Pierce and our building officials are going to be working together to resolve [1:28:40] this matter. [1:28:41] So this may become a mood issue, correct? [1:28:43] Okay. [1:28:44] Then I would move to set a hearing on our, go ahead. [1:28:52] You can meet on the 25th, if, I mean, there's, we don't have a meeting that's scheduled. [1:28:58] But if there's going to be a quorum of the council and you believe that this issue is [1:29:02] there, we've been telling you that this meeting was going to be canceled. [1:29:05] So you guys might have made plans already not to be, but know that when we place a do not, [1:29:13] the important pieces, when we place a do not occupy into the building, that means no business [1:29:19] will be conducted for a period of time until this issue is resolved. [1:29:23] That has nothing to do with what we're doing now. [1:29:27] We're sitting here. [1:29:28] That is going to be proceeding down a track with the building department. [1:29:31] That is correct. [1:29:32] So, okay, then, if everybody's in town, I'll set this thing for, I'll make a motion to set [1:29:36] this for November 25th, but I'm looking for a consensus here. [1:29:39] I'm just wondering if it should be earlier than that. [1:29:42] Okay. [1:29:43] Okay. [1:29:44] Well, I just want to start with the clarification from Frister. [1:29:48] We don't have the power, or at least I hope we don't have the power to over-road's building [1:29:52] department, correct? [1:29:53] This is about the liquor. [1:29:54] This is just about the liquor license. [1:29:55] I'm going to set a hearing date. [1:29:57] Okay. [1:29:58] And I'm hopefully. [1:29:59] I agree. [1:30:00] We can't unoverroll the bullet. [1:30:01] Yeah. [1:30:02] So I, it's my hope that the building official and Mr. Pierce are going to work together and [1:30:07] resolve this prior to the hearing. [1:30:09] Okay. [1:30:10] So, right. [1:30:11] So, I mean, so I'm okay with setting it for the 25th. [1:30:15] Okay. [1:30:17] So, so I would move to, I would move to have a hearing set for the purposes of reviewing a [1:30:24] a request to revoke the alcohol license for the Pioneer Club located at 1519 [1:30:28] Kimberly Road at a City Council meeting scheduled for five o'clock on [1:30:33] November 25th. [1:30:38] Okay before we vote on it I think Chris quoted up I think we should have Mr. [1:30:45] Pierce have an opportunity to state his side of this this it won't change the [1:30:52] I mean, right now he's the dealings with the building department. [1:30:55] We can't overrule the building department. [1:30:57] They have life, fire, and safety codes that they're charged with upholding. [1:31:04] And if we were able to overrule those, that would be probably a pretty sad day in most cities. [1:31:09] The Marvin Pierce, the proprietor. [1:31:13] Thank you. [1:31:14] First of all, I was notified that about this, about 330. [1:31:17] I didn't hear a word he said, actually. [1:31:20] All I heard was closed and revocation. [1:31:21] It's ridiculous and I wouldn't tell you this straight out, it's ridiculous. [1:31:27] Let me go down. [1:31:28] I have about three pages here I wrote a while ago when I bought the Pioneer Club. [1:31:34] Pioneer Club had about two hundred square feet of rock and floor people could fall through. [1:31:40] I fixed them. [1:31:42] They were draining a draft box into the basement for seven years. [1:31:48] I hauled out the dirt out of the dirt there, [1:31:51] get the dairy disinfected through the whole building, [1:31:54] sprayed the whole building, [1:31:57] put in a handicap ramp on my own, no city after that. [1:32:02] I poured the sidewalk 137 feet. [1:32:05] The city didn't want to do it. [1:32:07] I poured it, my own money, no problem there. [1:32:12] I put $11,000 in a parking lot [1:32:15] that I wasn't required to do. [1:32:17] I sensed the pioneer law, which had something out there, [1:32:21] I don't know what it was. [1:32:22] Everybody talks about this permit I got [1:32:26] to build this storage unit. [1:32:28] I put up a fence. [1:32:30] There never was nothing there. [1:32:32] The fence wasn't a property for me, [1:32:35] would protect me from the Pioneer Trender Park [1:32:37] and that house next door, which is pure crap. [1:32:41] I put it back behind the Pioneer Club [1:32:46] where this beautiful building and very, very safe [1:32:50] can contrary to what these people say, was dirt and a dump yard. [1:32:56] They've been dumping trash there. [1:32:58] I treated out, hauled it out in a dump truck in a backhoe. [1:33:03] That was years ago. [1:33:04] Dead sewer lines in cinder block walls. [1:33:08] I pulled out, hauled with a trash. [1:33:10] Three cinder block walls that were [1:33:12] practice falling, I jacked up, put three beans in the plant, free AGM, we're drawn up for. [1:33:21] Nobody's trying to get by with anything here. [1:33:23] I'll get to that in just a minute. [1:33:26] Everything in there is new electrical, by electrical in here, not marpiers. [1:33:31] I don't plumb things in electricity. [1:33:35] New doors, new doors everywhere. [1:33:38] code signed off on this permit, two fire doors, three fire doors, changed the locks, everything. [1:33:49] Firewalls, there's about seven to eight items in this building I wasn't notified with until [1:33:55] about a week before this storage unit was opened by the city, by the engineers, by the [1:34:05] fire department, by whoever else is involved. I don't like that chip on my shoulder thing. [1:34:11] I'm a black and white guy. [1:34:14] You tell me what you want, I'll do it. [1:34:16] Don't be around the woods with me. [1:34:19] Parking blocks, put parking blocks in. [1:34:22] Police in the area. [1:34:24] I police Howard O'Carol's trailer park. [1:34:29] Terries, trailer park, or Terries Heedy. [1:34:32] The house next door, my own trailer park, [1:34:34] four times a week, I pay for it. [1:34:42] Replaced a broken underground gas lines. [1:34:47] that I didn't even know were underground, that weren't even supposed to be there. I replaced [1:34:50] them. I replaced broken sewer lines that nobody knew were broken. I replaced them. And I didn't [1:34:57] get permitted. I didn't get permitted. I replaced them. Fairbanks construction done a lot of it. [1:35:02] Once all sewer and water are, sewer and water are especially done the rest. Now I already [1:35:09] went over the fencing, all that. That fence was the looks of my surroundings, not the Pioneer [1:35:18] trailer park. It looks like crap. You know, in the storage unit I did change my [1:35:27] mind about three-fourths of the way through about what was there. I had all this [1:35:32] burning thing and everything. The cost overrun on this job was ridiculous. From [1:35:38] about 41,000 to about 63,000 bucks, I changed seven to eight plans. The [1:35:45] The wank can justify it, or it can know that, so can the city, so can the P&Z. [1:35:51] I changed floor beams to 12 inch beams, put TGI's in the ceiling, put a pony wall that [1:35:58] made sure concrete, not pillars, the engineer I had was an idiot. [1:36:04] I'm going to tell you straight out. [1:36:05] I'd say the common sense went away from it. [1:36:07] The common sense is going away right now. [1:36:11] The pioneer is the safest bar in Twin Falls Idaho. [1:36:14] It's not only the number one liquor count in this whole valley, it's the number one beer [1:36:19] count now. [1:36:21] You get less calls to the pioneer, the police department, than anywhere else in this town. [1:36:26] I have two vouchers, sometimes three vouchers, card. [1:36:30] Every person that comes through the door, don't have any of those goofy mishaps. [1:36:34] We either call the police, we take care of it. [1:36:37] I put up half the bill for taxes or pay for the taxes myself so people get home safely. [1:36:44] I don't take any bull off of anybody. [1:36:47] I don't give it any to anybody either. [1:36:51] I don't like this pitley stuff. [1:36:55] And that's what's going on here, pitley stuff. [1:36:58] I don't like it at all. [1:37:00] The city has somewhat of a complaint I wrote down here, [1:37:03] but it's not for the bad building, okay, [1:37:07] or taking up parking. [1:37:08] I didn't take up any parking spots. [1:37:10] None. [1:37:12] I did not mess up the fire codes. [1:37:20] There's nothing there. [1:37:21] I was failed and told that it might have to have [1:37:25] a sprinkler system that's 5,000 square feet. [1:37:28] I would not measure the building myself. [1:37:31] 63, 8 by 63, 12, 4,221 square feet, [1:37:37] nowhere close to 5,000 square feet, nowhere close. [1:37:42] All fire doors, all proper locks, [1:37:44] all everything is proper, all everything is expensive, [1:37:47] and all everything is done right. [1:37:49] It wasn't like yesterday year when we'd done things, [1:37:52] just put them in. [1:37:54] And it doesn't count the seven to eight people [1:37:56] that I can write down on this piece of paper [1:37:58] that do the same thing, which I won't do, [1:38:01] because that's not my character, [1:38:03] that do things in their place. [1:38:04] You do a certain amount of things in your places [1:38:06] to survive. [1:38:09] The other thing is the occupancy, [1:38:15] The Pioneer Trailers are the Pioneer occupancy is 175 before this. [1:38:23] You know what we see here are now? [1:38:25] 162. [1:38:26] That floor there, you can put Dumbo in his entourage here. [1:38:34] That's on 12, 2 by 12s. [1:38:38] With a concrete wall that runs that direction clear through it, I took out the engineered [1:38:43] pillars. [1:38:44] It's the stupidest thing I ever heard. [1:38:47] There's a feed room through the top up there, and these people can verify it, that it's [1:38:53] strong as hell. [1:38:54] I switched the roof from asphalt to steel. [1:38:57] It has a steel roof on it. [1:39:00] I did these on my own to make it good and make it safe. [1:39:03] These little cinder block walls are talking about, do I say, falling down? [1:39:08] Oh, there's only one bearing wall in the place that would affect this. [1:39:16] I put those in years ago. [1:39:18] That's five 2x8s studded by three 2x8s to hold five cinder-bock torches, which is zero [1:39:28] ground in the whole building. [1:39:30] They didn't do it in 1947. [1:39:33] There's no way to speak of, just like these little hallways I put in, 8 foot, 10 foot, [1:39:39] 12 foot. [1:39:40] No weight there. [1:39:41] One wall didn't have anything, it was ended, knocked out, put the beams in anyway. [1:39:52] the roof route to grade, brought the floor up to grade, the pony wall, the traffic flow. [1:40:02] The traffic flow in this place right here is unbelievable. [1:40:05] Can you imagine putting 175 people, grandfather, in and 2,800 square feet drinking alcohol? [1:40:17] It's crazy. [1:40:18] I've been associated with crazy this place for 14 years. [1:40:22] This place flows so well, it's so easy, so nice to take care of, it's unbelievable. [1:40:29] You have to see it. [1:40:31] You can't sit here from here and say, oh, this is horrible. [1:40:36] It's not true. [1:40:37] It's great. [1:40:38] That's what it is. [1:40:39] It's absolutely great. [1:40:42] And the materials used in this building, 100% new. [1:40:48] Nothing I scraped up at the landfill, nothing I scraped up at my house, there are 100% new [1:40:53] There's a bunch of things I would have written down here on the city department. [1:41:04] I'm going to forego those for a minute, if we can get passes. [1:41:08] Pioneer Club is an asset to this community. [1:41:13] You know why? Because I own it. And because I don't take any shit from anybody, [1:41:19] I don't allow people to be hurt. I don't want to allow people to do things [1:41:23] that are against what we do and what we believe in this business. [1:41:27] Not only because I have a liquor license and city licenses, I don't allow it. [1:41:32] And people that know me, and a lot of you do know me, know that's true. [1:41:36] I don't lie to you, I don't need to, I won't have to. [1:41:40] This is a good community, not only a good business, I don't need a lot of money to charity funds, money donations for the needy. [1:41:51] I do three times a year at least have a free Easter dinner, free Thanksgiving, and free Christmas dinner. [1:41:58] So, I'm not taking the money the pioneer just regulates the tax revenue when I bought the place they had two people work for [1:42:05] I have eight to ten a week [1:42:08] Very good people very nice people very decent people. No derelex none of that cool earthy. I don't know what else to say to you [1:42:17] I'd say this to you right now [1:42:20] I will not take this lying down and I said I was gonna say that to me and I won't take it lying down [1:42:26] Because I think this is a trash deal. I did change my mind [1:42:31] This permit was issued on a storage at four storage units about three cords way through [1:42:37] I see the money I had in this thing and I figured out other ways to do it and I did convert this over out of school [1:42:43] Without a load of fighting anybody, but there were no [1:42:48] corners [1:42:49] cut none of that stuff and [1:42:51] and I'm a legit guy and honest guy and it's not a storage unit, it is part of the bar and I made that comment to four guys last week or eight, nine days ago. [1:43:05] It probably wasn't a beat. Probably something like that. I had a bunch of tables, a bunch of stuff, downstairs, a bunch of pictures all over. [1:43:12] I changed all the outside, all the inside to drive it. [1:43:16] from cedar I have three thousand bucks in driving so it's not there's nothing [1:43:27] cheap about this place there's nothing cheap done I don't like cheap things I [1:43:31] spent too much time too much money there and I'm sorry if I steal a little [1:43:36] I'm coming across a little strong that's what I believe and it's a good place [1:43:45] it's very good place and it'll always be a good place thank you [1:43:51] Well, Mr. Pierce, I had a couple of questions tomorrow. [1:43:55] Can you stand there? [1:43:57] Well, I'm just trying to make sure I heard what you said. [1:44:00] One, you said it was permitted as a storage, [1:44:03] but about two thirds is the way you changed your mind. [1:44:06] Were you aware that by changing your mind, [1:44:08] there was different codes that would come into play? [1:44:12] I absolutely was not aware of that, [1:44:13] because everything from the ground up was primo to the ground up. [1:44:21] I guess my question on the whole thing, if this is going to be a storage unit, what difference [1:44:26] did it make if all the sudden a sprinkler system comes up at 5,000 square feet? [1:44:31] So does that mean that the storage unit is burning than the rest of the building does [1:44:36] it burn? [1:44:37] Whether it's in a place where people hang out, it doesn't make any difference? [1:44:41] I think it's just the opposite. [1:44:42] I think they're saying because you're having people in it, it needs a sprinkler if it was [1:44:47] a storage it would not need one. [1:44:49] No. [1:44:50] It's still doesn't happen to me. [1:44:52] Still doesn't have to be a sprinkler. [1:44:55] Can I have a chance for Mr. [1:44:59] for our building department to maybe talk about some of the things that the reason that they're [1:45:03] they're going to be there's a question. [1:45:06] We have some questions first. Hang on, Dwayne. We have some questions first. [1:45:09] I think Rebecca's life was actually done. [1:45:11] Oh, Donald, sorry. [1:45:13] I have a question for Dwayne. [1:45:14] In fact, yes. [1:45:16] For Dwayne. [1:45:17] For Dwayne, yeah. [1:45:18] Okay, you're all right. [1:45:20] My question to you, Duane, is, you know, in the report it says the Pioneer Club building [1:45:26] is not safe to occupy. [1:45:28] So if it's not safe to occupy, why are we waiting till tomorrow? [1:45:32] I'm assuming he's got customers in there now. [1:45:36] And if the building department thinks that it's unsafe to occupy, why would we let them [1:45:41] occupy today? [1:45:42] That's a good question. [1:45:44] That's why it prompted this to bring this forward tonight. [1:45:49] There's a matter of going through the right kind of process. [1:45:56] We looked at the addition as a storage unit, and that's what we looked at. [1:46:02] I'm just a minimum code guy. [1:46:04] So we looked at the minimum codes for a storage unit, which when the storage unit again, had [1:46:11] And Mark can agree with me that we had to put in a two-hour wall between the storage [1:46:18] unit and your bar area, which required fire dealers, fire dealers, two hall separators. [1:46:27] These are the five-inch fire rock. [1:46:29] You rock hockey. [1:46:31] And looking at that there, that was one of the things I don't think that you're aware [1:46:38] of Marv is, is it, it's not just a square footage that constitutes putting in a sprinkler [1:46:45] system, that's also the octopus. [1:46:47] The octopus, see, I am, that's just what I said, 175 people in 2,800, now that I have [1:46:53] 2,200? [1:46:54] I know. [1:46:55] I heard what you said, Marv. [1:46:56] I understand what you said. [1:46:57] And I believe you're totally wrong. [1:47:00] Okay, well, we can, we can go through that a later day. [1:47:05] But one of the other items, I know you mentioned door hardware. [1:47:08] You said that the door hardware was all okay. [1:47:11] Well, I cannot require to put in panic doors or a panic emergency [1:47:17] doors in a storage building. [1:47:19] I can't do that. [1:47:20] But I can do it for an assembly. [1:47:23] You know, several times we've approached you and say, [1:47:26] if you want to do that, let us help you. [1:47:27] Let us decide what you know, on the fun part of that. [1:47:31] Because there's so many, there's such a vast separation [1:47:35] difference between having this in the leak and having a storage. [1:47:39] So I guess my question right now and for everybody is, if I need a panic bar, [1:47:45] Mark will get a panic bar. I have $64,000 in a unit that started out at $41. [1:47:51] You don't think that's been $300 for a panic bar? [1:47:54] I use that. I referenced that the panic, the emergency bar, [1:47:59] has just as an example of items. We need to look at the whole thing. [1:48:04] Do I think honestly, this is probably your conversation with Marro tomorrow, but my question goes back to again, [1:48:13] if it's if it's not safe to occupy if that's what the building department said [1:48:18] Why are we allowing it to occupy tonight? That's that's my only question [1:48:29] This is something that I have never been pushed this far before [1:48:34] Did I have a small one? [1:48:38] Prior to taking any action, we wanted to do exactly what we're doing right now. [1:48:42] We wanted to have the opportunity for the council to hear the issue and understand the [1:48:46] issue because we felt that once that issue is taken, you're going to have questions, right? [1:48:51] And so this is really that opportunity. [1:48:53] The other opportunity is to make sure that Marv had noticed and had the opportunity to [1:48:57] come and have that conversation and go forward. [1:49:01] I think that in terms of that the building is unsafe, I think one of the things to maybe [1:49:06] rephrase that is we want to make sure that the building is safe. [1:49:09] So it's not, the report is. [1:49:14] It does need a sprinkler system as part of this system. [1:49:20] As a part of the change from a storage unit to an A3 assembly, as I understand the issue, [1:49:27] a sprinkler system is needed to pass building code [1:49:32] and fire code inspection [1:49:35] i'm kind of a simple guy though [1:49:37] to me if you're telling me in your work [1:49:40] that is unsafe for occupancy [1:49:43] why are we allowing occupancy [1:49:49] you're absolutely right [1:49:50] is a report on the report [1:49:55] i've never run anybody out of the book [1:49:57] Right, right. And I appreciate you bringing it to council and allowing Marv to have the process here. [1:50:03] But I guess my my concern is if we're saying it's unsafe, why are we allowing people in it? [1:50:10] I'm going to bring this up one more time. I am giving 175 seat occupancy in 2800. [1:50:21] Now I have forty two hundred now almost seven for me to carry [1:50:26] 162 seats is what I have now automatically. I want to burn to the ground with all the retardants all the sheet rock [1:50:33] But all everything else is done most ridiculous thing I've ever heard so Fritz I would ask you to [1:50:39] put an answer that [1:50:41] Marv is stating stating on the occupancy portion [1:50:44] that he is [1:50:46] as a grandfather at hundred seventy-five and that's the so that would be our question [1:50:52] to you whether or not. [1:50:53] Could you have Fred's problem getting there? [1:50:54] Marb, would you mind letting Fred's here? [1:50:56] Thank you. [1:50:57] I'm going to defer to Dwayne on the occupancy issue but I think Dwayne's trying to explain [1:51:04] that Marvin is looking at it at a different direction than our building department is looking [1:51:09] at it. [1:51:10] He thinks he's okay and our building official thinks he is not. [1:51:13] He was grandfathered in at a smaller amount, but now he's got a much bigger amount. [1:51:18] He's not grandfathered anymore. [1:51:22] So as soon as you add on, then your grandfather goes away. [1:51:24] Is that what you're saying? [1:51:25] He lost his grandfather. [1:51:26] Yeah. [1:51:27] Good. [1:51:28] So, I mean, we follow the building code, we follow the fire code, because the state says [1:51:35] that's what we need for minimum safe requirements. [1:51:39] He has an un-sprinkled, oversized occupancy area now. [1:51:46] He's got a bearing wall that we have no idea whether it's safe or unsafe because it was [1:51:52] done without any permits. [1:51:54] We don't know what other issues are out there because he did all of this from November 1. [1:52:00] After we did the inspection, he's done all this without a permit. [1:52:04] He tore down the wall without a permit, and he turned it in to occupied space without a [1:52:11] permit. [1:52:12] So we don't know what other issues are there. [1:52:14] Dwayne just mentioned panic hardware as one example, but they have no idea until they get [1:52:20] in there and review it as not a storage area which they've approved already but as occupied [1:52:27] space. [1:52:30] We just want to let you make them a second. [1:52:32] Thank you, Mayor. [1:52:37] I think that one of the reasons that I voted against amending the agenda tonight was that it wasn't enough time. [1:52:46] It wasn't proper notice for the applicant to come here tonight. [1:52:49] I think I can see the difference between what the applicant's addressing and what the building department is addressing. [1:52:55] And I think that they have some true concerns about meeting the code. [1:53:00] And I understand that having this space as a place for the assembly of patrons requires [1:53:09] different requirements than if it were just a storage area. [1:53:13] And I think that's really the discussion that you're going to have. [1:53:17] So my question for us tonight in voting on this hearing is, I guess, addressed to Duane. [1:53:26] Is it a realistic amount of time from now until, if we set this hearing at November 25th, [1:53:35] is that a realistic amount of time for you and your team to address and verify and work [1:53:41] through these code requirements with the applicant? [1:53:45] I want to address them as soon as possible. [1:53:47] I'd like to get them addressed as soon as possible. [1:53:49] I really would, Rebecca. [1:53:51] The problem I have here is that if it's not done properly now, [1:53:57] if it wasn't done, wasn't built properly, [1:53:59] then you know, Mars problem would include me [1:54:04] if there were to be a hazard. [1:54:06] If it weren't burned down tonight, [1:54:07] you'd see my name in the paper as well. [1:54:10] There's some litigation here issues, [1:54:12] there's also some, I'd say, [1:54:13] how in the world could I live with that, [1:54:15] knowing that it was built on? [1:54:18] I think my question is- [1:54:19] I understand your responsibility in it, but my question is, is this enough time for you [1:54:26] to address these issues and have, is this enough time for the applicant to address these [1:54:32] issues before we have the hearing of the revocation of his alcohol license? [1:54:37] Well, we're going to address the issues right away. [1:54:41] I would suggest that we make tomorrow our end. [1:54:44] Correct. [1:54:45] But as far as getting everything that is needed, I don't know how to answer that because it [1:54:52] actually, that's why we depend on what we call a design professional, to take a look at what's [1:55:03] a lot of design professionals job is. [1:55:05] It's actually required by state statute, but that's what their job is to meet with their [1:55:14] customer and relate to us what their customer needs are and meet the minimum code standards. [1:55:20] So when I go to answer questions like that, it's like I've got a codebook that thick. [1:55:28] And there's several things I could say, yeah, this is possible and this is possible. [1:55:33] And maybe this is possible, but it kind of depends on what the wants and the needs are [1:55:39] of the owner, the business owner. [1:55:41] So that's why we rely on the, on a design professional. [1:55:45] In the meantime, we have an issue at hand here. [1:55:48] You know, we have a storage building that's been illegally turned into an assembly area. [1:55:54] We have to our firewall separation, the storage building that from the assembly area that no [1:56:00] longer exists. [1:56:01] We've got some big open holes right now. [1:56:03] Yes, I understand there are some code issues to address. [1:56:06] I think what I'm saying is that, you know, I understand the applicant's frustration in [1:56:10] being called to a council meeting a few hours before and as a council member I [1:56:15] haven't really had the proper time to review this information. I think the better [1:56:20] option would have been to meet with him first and make him aware of these issues. [1:56:25] I think that maybe would have helped him accept the information a little better [1:56:30] rather than this public arena and so I understand his frustration. I don't [1:56:35] think he was properly notified prior or had the conversation where he could ask [1:56:40] questions and you could both be on the same page because I do understand the need to address [1:56:45] the codes here, the code issues here. [1:56:49] But my question is for my information on this vote to set a hearing, I need to know [1:56:54] is this enough time for this to be addressed? [1:56:57] Because what we're hearing from staff is that the fact that you're going to close the [1:57:02] building and it will remain closed is a separate discussion from the council revoking alcohol [1:57:08] So I want to make sure that we give proper time for you and the applicant to, you know, [1:57:14] get together and review the code violations if any, address them and implement the changes [1:57:20] before we go to the extent of setting a hearing to revoke the alcohol license. [1:57:26] Does that make sense? [1:57:28] I'm all in the water suggestions you have for me to handle the issue of the story. [1:57:38] The call to the question please, let's get this resolved. [1:57:41] This is without having to. [1:57:43] I think we're still in the middle of the discussion. [1:57:45] Well, I'll tell you this right now. [1:57:47] I'll do anything in case. [1:57:49] My problem was in my list of city things that came up, that I didn't know about some [1:57:54] of the little things, small things, kind of like this deal here. [1:57:57] All of a sudden, this sprinkler system garbage won't happen. [1:58:02] Sprinkler system will not happen in the Pioneer Club [1:58:06] because it makes absolutely no sense to me [1:58:09] or anybody else other than the city coast. [1:58:12] And I don't want a bunch of money keep throwing at me [1:58:16] when the reasons aren't there. [1:58:18] And I am prepared, in fact, I've already started to prepare. [1:58:21] If our talks and our things don't get together, [1:58:25] we'll be important. [1:58:27] and I am not going to do this sort of thing. [1:58:31] I don't do anything it takes to make this building safe [1:58:34] and have over-safe, in fact. [1:58:37] And now they're telling me that they don't believe [1:58:39] that I told them about the way walls are short up and stuff [1:58:43] are true, why would I lie about 250 bucks? [1:58:50] Didn't happen, it won't happen, and never will happen. [1:58:55] But for them, all of a sudden, spring this on me, [1:58:57] and then they fall back on another part, I don't like. [1:59:01] And I won't say yes when I believe it's known. [1:59:06] Well, and get off this occupancy thing. [1:59:09] It's something I don't get at all. [1:59:14] Now it's that we're back-crafted. [1:59:16] I would, Marvin, my suggestion is you [1:59:18] since you've already invoked the possibility of a suit [1:59:21] that kind of puts an end to our proceedings. [1:59:23] I suggest that your attorney contact [1:59:26] attorney first thing tomorrow and start process that process so you will [1:59:30] understand because when I've been friends a long time and I believe in [1:59:35] waiting I trust to wait we can come together in the morning and I'll look at [1:59:40] things okay but I want other people I want another opinion on that needing a [1:59:46] fire system but I can't believe that needs that I understand your concerns [1:59:52] And I hope that you guys at 8 a.m. tomorrow, we're setting out and trying to work things out, that'd be our purpose. [1:59:59] Yeah, absolutely. I'll do whatever it takes. [2:00:02] Travis, do you want to make a comment? I have a couple of lights as well. [2:00:05] In terms of the hearing date, we recognize, and so the 25th may not be enough time for this. [2:00:11] Maybe in that there could be some flexibility placed into the motion where you set that as the 29th, [2:00:19] the 25th and then if we are noticing progress we can notify you and then you could suspend [2:00:27] that until a delayed date may be until December 2nd. [2:00:32] The idea I think of the accelerated date is just to make sure that we're working swiftly [2:00:37] through this process out of respect for MARF. [2:00:40] But we certainly want to make sure that the council has the information that they need [2:00:44] also to process a significant decision. [2:00:47] So, okay. [2:00:49] Well, there is a motion on the floor [2:00:51] and there's a second, correct? [2:00:53] And it is set for, the motion on the floor [2:00:55] is for November 25th at our five o'clock city council meeting [2:00:58] with seconded. [2:01:01] So I'm okay with that. [2:01:03] That's gonna give, that has nothing to do [2:01:06] with what you two are doing, but get it fixed. [2:01:10] So that's kind of where we're at, right? [2:01:12] Christa, Chris has been on even before your job, I mean. [2:01:14] We couldn't continue the hearing if we're not able to resolve it by the 25th, but I'm getting very uncomfortable now that lawyer-esque language is coming out. [2:01:22] So we need to get the same. [2:01:23] Maybe if you could just set up for the 25th, give us the flexibility to work with Mr. Pierce, and if we're moving forward and he would like more time, is that okay with you guys? [2:01:35] Yes. [2:01:36] I think, can I amend my motion to- [2:01:39] As long as you're seconding the- [2:01:40] I want them to work together and with what our attorney said, [2:01:45] as long as they're making progress and so forth, [2:01:48] that things can be a bit flexible. [2:01:51] How do you define progress? [2:01:53] In other words, the staff will- [2:01:54] Staff will- [2:01:55] Staff will- They need to continue it or not. [2:01:56] I'll go for that. [2:01:57] Right, so we've been- [2:01:58] Yeah. [2:01:59] Multiple- [2:02:00] Do you understand the motion? [2:02:01] Staff? [2:02:02] I want to make sure- Okay, Great. [2:02:03] All right, Rebecca? [2:02:07] Yes, I was just asking if maybe we shouldn't set it for December 2nd [2:02:12] But it or my question is of the motion that does it encompass either the 25th or the second? [2:02:17] I guess now I'm confused about the motion. It does it right now. It only it's the 25th with the caveat that if progress is being made that we could [2:02:28] Push it out. Okay. Thank you. All right [2:02:37] Yes, Don Hall. Yes [2:02:42] She's your fusion herself [2:02:46] Yes [2:02:48] Yes [2:02:53] Yes [2:02:56] Well look forward to hearing you're at your conversations and what you guys can work out that's our that's our plan to our [2:03:03] Thank you, it wasn't my intent to offend anybody. [2:03:08] And thank you very much, sorry I was sorry, but I'm sorry. [2:03:11] John, John, I just have to ask, Marvin, I think we have one more comment. [2:03:18] Well, it's not so much that I'd like for you to listen to. [2:03:21] But I just have one more question. [2:03:23] I just haven't felt good about my question being answered. [2:03:27] We said in a report that is not safe to occupy. [2:03:31] They're occupying it tonight. [2:03:33] So is the report maybe skewed a little bit, [2:03:37] and it's okay for them to occupy it? [2:03:39] I'm just, I just need that question answered. [2:03:46] Very good on the mic. [2:03:49] I didn't notice any movement of the building. [2:03:51] I didn't, you know, even though there had been some walls removed. [2:03:57] I'm just visiting here with Travis about that. [2:04:00] But go back to your question, Don. [2:04:02] You know if something's going to happen there tonight, I can't say that there isn't because there's Murphy law involved here and if it's going to happen, it'll happen to me. [2:04:12] So yeah, I mean that's a valid question. [2:04:17] You know, anytime we put a building as unsafe or put that on the building, that is very serious. [2:04:25] I think they need to be done immediately. I agree with that. [2:04:28] Could a caveat be to ask more, not have anyone in that section? [2:04:32] That section? [2:04:33] Yes, thank you. [2:04:34] Thank you. [2:04:35] Is that what you were thinking Travis? [2:04:37] So the place that is unsafe according to the fire marshal and the fire chief who where [2:04:43] this is all about sprinkler systems right is that room. [2:04:48] It is not the chief clerk is not a it's not the we want to make sure that there's a distinction [2:04:56] between as we believe it the entire structure and that room is what is what [2:05:01] the fire chief is is nodding. Yeah, Mark, can we exclude people from being in that [2:05:06] room tonight? Just keep your business open. Thank you. Thank you, [2:05:10] mama. Thank you. All right, moving on. Thank you. Any public input? Somebody like [2:05:18] this? We're gonna get Max two weeks in a row. All right. Max, no, no. [2:05:31] I've got more active. I'm on your web page. I've got the [2:05:36] notice from meetings. I've got the all 31 pages of your packet. And I've got the [2:05:42] request for [2:05:45] qualifications. And in the bottom of it, it says acceptance [2:05:54] of responses. The RFQ is a binary agreement to [2:05:58] have to post-event to accept proposals for any of the applicants. [2:06:02] Responses to the RFQ will be accessed in light of the qualification review criteria. [2:06:08] I would like to know if you will have that review criteria available before the quorum or after the quorum, [2:06:17] so we'll know kind of what you're going to be judging on. [2:06:20] I have a little conversation, and the main thing is to be the brand of Twin Falls and public safety [2:06:27] and money so that the John Q said it was not [2:06:32] funding the money. If there's going to be any more than that [2:06:35] I'd like to know about it. I'm just satisfied [2:06:39] that the public will know how you're going to [2:06:42] evaluate the six [2:06:46] cloth people that have turned in their permit and subject themselves to the 15 [2:06:51] minutes, [2:06:52] 13 points and 15 minutes or deal. [2:06:55] So, thank you very much. [2:06:57] Thank you, Max. [2:06:58] I promised to do you want to answer that as far as you can. [2:07:01] Yes, so, you know, and as I shared with Maxal earlier today, really that is going to be [2:07:07] up to the process. [2:07:08] And so I think what's important to remember is you're still in that information gathering [2:07:13] phase and you're going to continue to gather information throughout this phase and who [2:07:17] knows what that looks like. [2:07:19] There may be subsequent interviews that you may want to do. [2:07:22] there may be subsequent processes that you may want to do. [2:07:26] This is really, I would not look at this as a final conversation, I would look at this [2:07:30] as a continuance of the conversation. [2:07:33] And I think that the Council, this is a significant potential event that may occur in our community, [2:07:41] and I think that the Council needs to take the time that they need to process the event. [2:07:48] We never said that this was going to be the only public opportunity to the public, it may [2:07:55] be, it may not be. [2:07:57] What we're doing is we're trying to make sure that there is a process created so that the [2:08:03] Council and the public can come to a reasonable conclusion that protects health and safety, [2:08:13] ensures, you know, our reputation or our brand is maintained, and to ensure that it's a safe [2:08:20] event for spectators, the jumpers, and any other criteria throughout this call it a journey, [2:08:28] the council sets. [2:08:31] So again, this is, I wouldn't, and I would encourage people who are listening and going [2:08:36] to watch that there may not be a clear answer that comes out. [2:08:39] Really that's up to the seven of you after Thursday night. [2:08:43] You may make that determination to say there is more information that we need before we can [2:08:48] make that decision, and I think that's entirely appropriate. [2:08:51] I wouldn't, I would encourage you not to rush to judgment on this issue. [2:08:58] David, thank you, perhaps. [2:09:01] Any other public who would like to speak to the council? [2:09:04] Seeing none, City Manager, anything in addition? [2:09:09] Just come for an enjoyable evening on the 21st, and we will keep you notified of the [2:09:15] potential of the meeting on the 25th. [2:09:17] Okay. [2:09:18] City Council? [2:09:19] Donald? [2:09:20] Just wanted to say I had a delightful cup of coffee with Max the other day. [2:09:26] He's a citizen that's getting involved. [2:09:28] He contacted several of us regarding our latest controversy as far as public noticing [2:09:36] and the like. [2:09:37] And it was a pleasure to sit down and talk. [2:09:39] And I would encourage, I know this is live, all citizens to contact their City Council [2:09:44] and ask these questions and get clarification, [2:09:47] because sometimes maybe it's not being reported [2:09:52] as accurately as maybe it should, [2:09:54] and or sometimes you don't hear it here, [2:09:56] get a hold of us, that's what we're elected to meet with folks. [2:10:00] So again, thank you Max for being involved. [2:10:02] Just talking to. [2:10:03] I have two items. [2:10:05] First, I put on everyone's desk, [2:10:07] a little wrap sheet in the library. [2:10:10] I think the council needs to be aware of an invaluable [2:10:13] growing service the library provides to the taxpayers. Just the three or four facts I'll [2:10:18] pull out of the center. This last year of 2013, we've seen 244,000 people visit the library. [2:10:28] That's over 800 a day. Our library patrons now are in excess of 29,000. Let's see, patrons [2:10:38] to use her computers on average of 167 sessions a day and yearly total is well over 50,000. [2:10:48] Staff has answered 15,000 plus questions during the year, not all the same questions I can [2:10:53] guarantee. [2:10:54] And this is an adjunct to the education system. [2:10:59] The library has provided close to 10,000 kids with programming special specific to their [2:11:07] You can see the nice picture of the bookmobile inside. [2:11:11] So study your library. [2:11:13] It's an incredible civic resource. [2:11:17] My second item has to do with something the City Manager has put [2:11:21] out dealing with our various funds that I thought have some reason [2:11:31] for comment. [2:11:32] First of all, attributing to you, Travis, [2:11:34] of the City of Twin Falls remains incredibly financially healthy and he provided a few highlights [2:11:41] for the year, September of last year at October of this year I think is the period. I'll get [2:11:47] to my question and point but and these are not property tax, these are enterprise funds [2:11:52] then. These are the waters and the well-seaved streets, excuse me I take that back, there's [2:11:58] sewer in the water out of the enterprise fund. But it's a mixture of five funds I want to [2:12:04] to bring attention to. The general fund has almost $7 million in unrestricted [2:12:13] surpluses. The straight fund, $1.3 million. We have a healthy capital [2:12:20] improvement fund. In the water fund, $5.9 million in unrestricted and close to a [2:12:27] million dollars in the sewer fund unrestricted. If you total up all of the [2:12:32] unrestricted monies and those accounts you have in addition are in excess of $15 million. [2:12:40] Our property tax and enterprise supported budget for this year is your call over $50 million [2:12:46] for the first time. [2:12:47] This represents nearly a third of our total operating budget in the way of surpluses. [2:12:54] Several of us on the council attempted to have a reduction in expense lines and a resultant [2:13:00] lower city budget. We were unsuccessful. The majority of the council felt that we had a [2:13:06] healthy and operating and necessary budget. I'm bringing these points up tonight because [2:13:11] frankly I'm very uncomfortable with these apparently historically high and I'm not sure [2:13:21] how reasonable all of the unrestricted monies are. Now there's some areas, Travis, I know [2:13:28] that I'm on real thin ground on. I don't know what our [2:13:32] unrestricted percentages in these various funds have been. [2:13:37] But historically I know that they have been lower and higher at [2:13:42] various times. The question is, do we and should we have [2:13:47] room to provide crediting back to various enterprise funds when [2:13:52] we have unrestricted surpluses of this magnitude in some of [2:13:57] So let me give a really good example, like in the water fund, for example. [2:14:03] So right now, those are a report that ran through October, and it illustrated that there [2:14:07] was 5.96. [2:14:10] That's right. [2:14:12] So remember, as part of the Cliff Part deal, we're going to take $3.5 million of that, and [2:14:17] we're going to remove that from there, and we're going to reduce that balance, and we're [2:14:21] going to contribute to the point. [2:14:22] What we call it, unrestricted, then, I was dedicated already. [2:14:26] Because it had not been dedicated at the issuance of the report. [2:14:28] So one of the things about the report is the report is rear looking. [2:14:33] It is not a forward looking approach. [2:14:36] And so when you look at the October report, that's going to come out. [2:14:40] You'll notice that the cliff bar, the city's portion of the cliff bar water tank will then [2:14:46] be a restricted account moving forward because what we do is we say all of those actions up [2:14:51] until September 30th, this is what that looks like. [2:14:55] We made that action on October 17th, I believe, was when we had the cliff bar deal that was [2:15:02] agreed to. [2:15:03] So we will take that three and a half million dollars and we will place it into that restricted [2:15:07] ability. [2:15:08] So it'll be 5.9 minus three and a half. [2:15:10] And then minus another hundred thousand for the acquisition of the land. [2:15:17] As you recall, we had budgeted $350,000 for the acquisition of the land and the site. [2:15:22] And the price came in at about $450,000, and so you'll start seeing those really go down. [2:15:31] And that in terms of the level of unrestricted cash reserves, I would say that they're about [2:15:38] where we've been historically. [2:15:39] They kind of have been flow. [2:15:41] I wouldn't say that they're significantly larger than where they've been in the past, [2:15:45] especially when you take a look at the general fund. [2:15:48] In the past. [2:15:49] It's almost 7 million. [2:15:50] In the past, we used proceeds from street fund and general fund to make improvements on Eastland drive. [2:15:58] And so what we do is we take those monies and we invest them into one-time capital projects that couldn't normally be absorbed in any operating year budget. [2:16:08] When we go through a budgeting process, we want to make sure that the anticipated revenues are covering the anticipated expenditures. [2:16:15] I appreciate that and we will always have a surplus of projects that we can't or haven't funded. [2:16:21] So to make a flip or comment that we have all these projects that need to be done, you tell that to the taxpayers some of the people who are wondering if the monies are reasonable. [2:16:32] So the main enterprise fund, the Water Fund, that's down to a couple million bucks now, two and a half million. [2:16:42] If you were to do a real live report on that, you're going to see us take about $3.6 million [2:16:48] away from that $100,000 for the tank and $3.5 million for the actual acquisition of the tank. [2:16:55] And we'll dedicate that. [2:16:57] We made a commitment as part of the process that we would take that $3.5 million and we'd apply that to the tank. [2:17:04] We have a million 369 unrestricted in streets. [2:17:08] So you're entering, envisioning using more out of the general fund, [2:17:13] transfer industry fund for capital projects? [2:17:16] No, not at this time. [2:17:18] But you can do that at any time. [2:17:20] The council has done that in the past when they did the work on the Eastland Street project. [2:17:26] We took cash from the general fund because the general fund had the financial capacities to absorb those improvements. [2:17:33] And we made a commitment of general fund dollars to offset improvements on each one. [2:17:38] And we have 4.28 million in capital improvement that is unobligated. [2:17:44] In which fund? [2:17:45] Pardon. [2:17:46] In which fund? [2:17:47] Capital. [2:17:48] I think the unobligated portion is, I'd have to look at the report. [2:17:54] But it didn't show anything about unrestricted there, it just says 4.28 million capital. [2:17:58] I think that's the total balance. [2:17:59] I think that was the total balance. [2:18:01] I'd like to understand this a little more because I feel very uncomfortable that these [2:18:05] are all within historic bounds and I'll be the first to buy a cup of coffee if I'm wrong [2:18:09] on that, but some of them seem excessive. [2:18:12] Okay. [2:18:13] Would the staff would be glad to sit down and work through that with you? [2:18:16] One of the things I would come in, I've sat through enough of my 33 years of education [2:18:21] where I sat through the general practices by our accounting firms and one-third is not [2:18:30] excessive to them without a doubt. It makes the excessive and some of the individual funds, [2:18:35] but every one-third of your balance in reserves is, to general accounting practices, is not out [2:18:41] of line. [2:18:42] Well, when you're dealing with property taxes, 25% is necessary because we don't get property [2:18:48] taxes for that three-month period, but not in enterprise funds. [2:18:51] Well, and I know on the street department on our time, my time on the council, we're [2:18:57] going to use that to save up to do a major project because sometimes the major [2:19:00] projects may be two to three million dollars to do them. We want to do a full [2:19:05] length of each of these things. Well we have a lot of philosophical difference [2:19:07] just because the money is there. I don't think we should spend it all necessarily [2:19:11] especially if we haven't budgeted it in the specific program. The one I would say [2:19:15] is though traditionally on our surveys and other things we talked about the [2:19:20] streets always come out very high as something people feel that we need to be [2:19:24] making sure we're thinking taking care of maintenance and rebuilding roads were [2:19:29] necessary and I was out on South Eastland just the other day and let's be honest [2:19:35] but we're gonna have to take that is gonna go the same way as that mid portion [2:19:39] of Eastland did very very soon and I would like to have the funds to fix that [2:19:42] when we feel like we just have to fix it. Anything else from City Council? We do [2:19:53] We have executive sessions on the agenda. [2:19:57] It's actually exception 67235B to consider [2:20:00] the evaluation, dismissal, or discipline of, [2:20:03] or to hear complaints or charges brought up against. [2:20:06] The public officer, employee, staff member, [2:20:07] or individual agent. [2:20:09] We also have 67235C to inject deliberations [2:20:14] on this particular case to acquire an interest [2:20:17] in real property which is not known by a public agency. [2:20:20] So moved. [2:20:22] Second. [2:20:22] Then moved by Don Hall and seconded by Jim Len [2:20:24] and we move into executive session for those two items, [2:20:27] those two items only. [2:20:30] Seeing the lights, will there be a roll call vote? [2:20:32] Don Hall. [2:20:33] Yes. [2:20:34] Do you think I'm talking? [2:20:35] Yes. [2:20:36] Do you think I'm talking? [2:20:37] Yes. [2:20:38] Jim Len. [2:20:39] Do you think I'm else like that? [2:20:39] Yes. [2:20:40] Yes. [2:20:41] Councillor. [2:20:42] Yes. [2:20:43] Motion passes seven to zero. [2:20:46] And we will not be coming out and making [2:20:47] any decisions after this meeting. [2:20:50] without me making decisions straight. We're adjourned.