Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2013-08-19, recording 1 (started 17:00) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2013-08-19/ [0:01:51] I'd like to call the Twin Falls City Council meeting for August 19, 2013, to order. [0:02:03] First item is the Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. [0:02:21] for all. [0:02:22] Welcome, everyone. [0:02:29] We do have a quorum also and members are here. [0:02:32] Brief introduction staff have a lot more here than I recognize, but we do have City Manager, [0:02:37] Travis Roth, Euler, City Attorney, Fritz Winterlich, and City Clerk, Dick, reporting [0:02:42] secretary of the aisle of the Sanchez. [0:02:44] Travis, do we have any amendments to the agenda? [0:02:50] Mr. Mayor and members of the council, we do have some amendments to the agenda for consideration [0:02:55] by the council. [0:02:57] The first is in addition to the consent calendar. [0:03:00] It has been included that information is at your individual places. [0:03:05] It is now called license application for San Angel, [0:03:16] Angel, Mexican restaurant located at 164 Main Avenue North. [0:03:23] Again, that is to the consent calendar. [0:03:25] The second would be to add two executive sessions to the City Council. [0:03:30] The first is under 67, 2, 3, 4, 5, subsection 1A, [0:03:37] which is to consider the hiring of a public officer, employee, staff member, or individual agent wherein the respective qualities of the individual are to be evaluated in order to fill a particular need or vacancy. [0:03:49] And also under 1B to consider the evaluation dismissal or disciplining of or to hear complaints or charges brought against a public officer. [0:03:58] So that is one item of an executive session that we'd like to add. [0:04:03] That item just came up over the course of the last hour and is to engage the council at the request of the council in a employee related matter. [0:04:14] The second is an executive session under 6723451E which is to consider preliminary negotiations involving matters of trade or commerce in which the governing body is in competition with governing bodies in other states or nations. [0:04:29] The city is currently actively working on a significant economic development opportunity and we would like to provide additional information at the request of the council as to the status of that opportunity. [0:04:41] to show them in the agenda. [0:04:43] Second. [0:04:44] Moved by Cruz Tacking and seconded by Don Hall [0:04:47] to amend the agenda as detailed by Travis Rothweiler, City [0:04:53] Major, seeing the lights of the Isle of Wokal vote. [0:04:57] Sean Berger. [0:04:58] Yes. [0:04:59] Don Hall. [0:04:59] Yes. [0:05:00] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:05:01] Yes. [0:05:01] Greg Lanzine. [0:05:02] Yes. [0:05:03] Jim Munn. [0:05:03] Yes. [0:05:04] Rebecca Milsoica. [0:05:05] Yes. [0:05:06] Chris Tonkin. [0:05:07] Yes. [0:05:08] Motion passes 7-0. [0:05:10] Next time, oops, we do have a. [0:05:15] We have a proclamation for the United Way of South Central Idaho kickoff. [0:05:20] Off the mayor's city of Twin Falls Idaho Proclamation, the United Way of South Central [0:05:23] Idaho kickoff day, whereas the city of Twin Falls and its elected officials recognize the [0:05:28] efforts of the United Way of South Central Idaho and its hundreds of volunteers. [0:05:33] And whereas the people of Twin Falls are the benefactors of the 32 human services agency [0:05:39] programs and meals on meals for seniors funded by the United Way of South Central Idaho [0:05:43] in 2013, and whereas the 2013 official United Way of South Central Idaho campaign drive [0:05:50] will kick off on Friday, August 23rd, and whereas United Way of South Central Idaho recognizes [0:05:56] and appreciates the many contributions of volunteer hours and dollars in making our area [0:06:01] a better place to live and work, and whereas United Way of South Central Idaho's mission [0:06:05] is uniting people and resources for a stronger community. [0:06:10] Now therefore be a result that I Greg Lane, Mayor of Twin Falls, Idaho, do hereby, do hereby [0:06:16] proclaim Friday, August 23rd, 2013 as United Way of South Central Idaho kick-off date in [0:06:23] Twin Falls and their adult citizens to support activities and efforts of United Way of South [0:06:27] Central Idaho signed by myself and Leah Sanchez as a City Clerk August 19th, 2013. [0:06:35] Do we have somebody from United Way here to represent this? [0:06:38] I think they're all probably out manning their whole closest to the whole programs that they have going on right now [0:06:43] I will make sure the mister the bill gets this from the United Way and [0:06:48] I'd like to thank them for their efforts in our community [0:06:53] Moving on to the consent calendar or council wishes [0:06:58] Don't move approval. We've been down hall and seconded by [0:07:03] Second Susanne Hawkins that we remove the consent calendar as amended [0:07:11] Seeing no lines of the other roll call vote. [0:07:13] Don Hall. [0:07:14] Yes. [0:07:15] Suzanne Hopkins. [0:07:16] Yes. [0:07:17] Greg Lantine. [0:07:18] Yes. [0:07:19] Jim Munn. [0:07:20] Yes. [0:07:21] Rebecca Milsoyka. [0:07:22] Yes. [0:07:23] Chris Tocantan. [0:07:24] Yes. [0:07:26] Sean Berriger. [0:07:27] Yes. [0:07:28] Motion passes 7-0. [0:07:30] Please bring us to the items of consideration. [0:07:32] Item number one, a presentation of funds from the YMCA and the Magic Valley Canine Social [0:07:37] come for development of Baxter's Park by Eric Gury editor Steve Vosser and Leah [0:07:44] scripture presentation Dennis Boyer is the name on the identification there's [0:07:51] gonna start this for us anyway yes I will start thank you mayor and council [0:07:54] yes it is a pleasure pleasure tonight to be here give you a low background you [0:07:58] know the Magic Valley King High Social Club has been out raising funds and so [0:08:02] far through the Twin Falls Community Foundation they have raised over $60,000 [0:08:06] of the dog park, so we have started preparing the ground, [0:08:09] actually we're starting to, we haven't installed the [0:08:11] sprinkler system, but we've done a lot of prep work [0:08:13] out of this side of Lake Street, North and Shoebab, [0:08:16] and West, but also the Canine Soldier Club, [0:08:19] they're looking at fundraisers, and the YMC contacted us [0:08:22] to see if somehow they could offer their help [0:08:24] and their expertise on fundraising. [0:08:26] So of course the Canine Show Club jumped on board of it, [0:08:29] and as you know, June 29th, we had the Fast and Furious [0:08:34] fund run for dogs and humans, raise the money, and then we had a big event at City Park. [0:08:41] We had a dog agility contest. We had a lookalikes pet contest. Also, we had Dr. Medt, Marty Becker [0:08:49] came down from up north and came down and did some book signing to raise some additional [0:08:54] funds for the dog park. I would like to introduce Gary Edger from the YMCA. We have Leah here [0:09:00] from the K9 Social Club and I think I know the check will be made out to the [0:09:04] Twin Falls Community Foundation. I know Terry McCurdy is in the audience too so I'm [0:09:08] pretty sure he won't be able to take care of that check for. So Gary and Leah, please? [0:09:12] Well, good evening everybody. As Dennis mentioned on June 29th, the Y partnered [0:09:28] with K9 Social Club to do a dog fundraiser for Baxter's Park, we weren't [0:09:33] sure how we were going to do in that. We had put on three 5k raises in the past year [0:09:37] but never a 5k race with dogs running as well and this is the first one in my [0:09:42] 30 years with the why that we've tried to do that so we did our best. We had 53 [0:09:49] people and their pets run in the event and it was a very hot day. The fee was $20 [0:09:54] per individual or we had a nice family of price $50 for the whole family and [0:10:00] included a free t-shirt for all the humans. No charge for the dogs. [0:10:06] And it's funny, Donna Cleveland, who's a marketing director, [0:10:10] was really the driving force behind us, [0:10:12] and she even put down the race results, [0:10:13] because I know you're on the edge of your seats. [0:10:15] I know who won this thing. [0:10:17] So in first place was a German short hair [0:10:20] named Flying Phoebe, okay? [0:10:23] In second place was a little short [0:10:26] legged Dachshund named Turner. [0:10:28] And then I'm not sure I want to read this, [0:10:30] but in one dog ahead, heat stroke, [0:10:32] but it's doing much better now. [0:10:33] As Dennis mentioned, also, there were a lot of other fun activities in the park that day, [0:10:40] including pet photography of people in a pet look-alike contest. [0:10:45] I didn't really like that one because somebody kept bringing up a pug and saying, Gary, look, [0:10:48] we found the one that's just like you. [0:10:50] So that was great for money to go. [0:10:52] Dr. Marty Becker flew in. [0:10:54] He sold copies of his book and he also donated an extra $300, which was very nice for this [0:10:59] effort. [0:11:00] On behalf of the wide board of directors and staff, [0:11:02] I'm very, very pleased to present a check to you. [0:11:04] We were hoping to do a little more, [0:11:06] but this is made up to the Twin Falls Community Foundation [0:11:10] from the Y-Run, and it's for $1,700. [0:11:13] So hopefully that'll be put to good use, [0:11:14] and we're really delighted to leave that here. [0:11:18] Thank you. [0:11:19] Leah, did you want to say something as well [0:11:20] from the Canine Social Forum? [0:11:22] Only that we've got the splash planned for [0:11:24] Durkeys Lake on the 14th of September, from 10 to 2. [0:11:27] All right. [0:11:28] Thank you. [0:11:29] Thank you. [0:11:31] And I'll turn around, and I'll turn around and have it to turn and y'all said so. [0:11:42] As I was actually doing a little work on that today, as I was going around lining up beds [0:11:55] up, I had chosen to donate the sign for the dog park and going around and getting beds [0:12:01] on that because I had one person all lined up and all of a sudden they were no longer [0:12:04] in town, so it was a little tough tip. [0:12:06] They were cheaper than everybody, but we will have a sign, I'll guarantee you by the time [0:12:11] it opens. [0:12:12] Thank you very much for your efforts. [0:12:16] Item number two, consideration of request [0:12:19] to adopt ordinance 3054 a vacation of proc pretty low date [0:12:23] located between lot one and lot 14, [0:12:28] lot 14 of the Canyon Trail subdivision number five, [0:12:31] Mitch Humble, our community development director. [0:12:39] Okay, I'll recall that on make six, [0:12:41] we had public hearing to discuss this vacation. [0:12:44] This is a vacation on the commercial side of the subdivision [0:12:47] that was for basically a nonvehicular access [0:12:50] into the residential side of the subdivision to the north. [0:12:53] The deal was that they were going to shift that a little bit [0:12:56] to the west, and there were some easements and tracks [0:13:01] that needed to move along with it. [0:13:02] So that was a proof back on May 6. [0:13:07] We had some conditions that they had to meet, [0:13:09] and they've done that, and now we've got the adoption ready. [0:13:11] or the ordinance ready for your adoption tonight. [0:13:15] It's ordinance number 3054. [0:13:17] It's been prepared in accordance [0:13:19] with the approval from May 6th and it's ready to adopt. [0:13:22] We do need to, if you wanna adopt it tonight, [0:13:24] place it on 30 final and all that good business. [0:13:27] So if you have any questions I'll try to answer. [0:13:30] It's one's is not what you like on the other one. [0:13:34] It appears that they are at least, [0:13:38] because it's clear at the very, [0:13:39] clear down a federation road at Parkview Drive is where the property is correct [0:13:43] where they're actually where they're actually building the new facility or [0:13:48] whatever they're putting in there. That's where the ground is being disturbed anyway. [0:13:54] So the location of the easement is where you can see the yellow right right in [0:14:03] there. Federation is going to be up a little bit further to the north and east [0:14:09] a little. So we're talking about down here, closer to pole line. Okay. Just to the west [0:14:17] of Parkview Drive. I'm assuming that, so we're, where is, hmm. Fright, fright, fright, [0:14:25] okay. I guess I was just confused because they're doing prep work, clear down by Federation. [0:14:32] And it appears that they may be getting ready to do finish off Parkview Drive all the way [0:14:40] to do polling from polling to federation that only goes part way now. Do you know anything [0:14:44] about that or? Because I know that was one of the questions. I remember knocking on, oh [0:14:49] Tim can come up and tell us maybe. If I remember knocking on doors there four years ago, the [0:14:53] people were very interested that when they're not, when polling or when the part you was going [0:15:01] to get done, I was hoping they knock on the same door as this campaign that they'd be able [0:15:05] that I'd be able to say and. [0:15:08] Tim, if you could help us out, I'd appreciate it. [0:15:10] Yes, Mary. [0:15:11] Good evening. [0:15:12] Kim Vosser with the CHM engineers. [0:15:14] Part of your consent calendar was the approval [0:15:17] of the development agreement for Kenning Trails number six. [0:15:22] And with the sale of this pending sale of this property [0:15:25] to prospective developer within the commercial portion, [0:15:30] Gary feels like he has an impending possibility to finish out part view at this time Gary [0:15:37] Nelson the developer. [0:15:39] Along with that there's a retention basin going in along Federation and part view and [0:15:45] he'll have about 11 lots along with that basin there for the subdivision. [0:15:52] So hopefully if this set goes through and it should as soon as this ordinance is recorded [0:15:58] then you'll see all of that street you want to do it's full [0:16:01] feature with. [0:16:01] OK, so when I knock on those doors this campaign, [0:16:04] though, I can say, and they're putting that through it. [0:16:06] I don't know why I took four years from when you asked me [0:16:08] last time, but I better keep going because we're cutting. [0:16:12] All right, OK. [0:16:13] All right. [0:16:14] Thank you, Tim. [0:16:14] I appreciate the information. [0:16:16] Do we have any other questions for Mitch or Mr. [0:16:20] Voster from the team engineers? [0:16:24] Seeing none, do we need to do a third and final on this? [0:16:29] Chris, I would move a suspension of the rules from place ordinance three thousand fifty four on third and final by title only [0:16:37] Second [0:16:38] He's been moved by Chris talking in a second by Rebecca mil soikha to place ordinance 3054 and third and final [0:16:46] My title and spending rules models good thing. So see no lights. We have a roll call vote [0:16:54] Suzanne Hawkins. Yes [0:16:56] Greg 19. Yes Jim on yes [0:16:59] Rebecca mil soikha. Yes [0:17:01] Yes, John Berriger. Yes, Don Hall. Yes. Motion passes seven to zero and entertain the motion for the adoption. Oh, sorry. Let's have Lee on the read at first. Thank you and ordinance of the mayor and the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho, [0:17:18] Thank you. [0:17:19] Thank you. [0:17:20] Thank you. [0:17:21] Thank you. [0:17:22] Thank you. [0:17:23] Thank you. [0:17:24] Thank you. [0:17:26] Thank you. [0:17:27] Thank you. [0:17:28] Thank you. [0:17:29] Thank you. [0:17:30] Thank you. [0:17:31] Thank you. [0:17:32] Thank you. [0:17:33] Thank you. [0:17:34] Thank you. [0:17:35] Thank you. [0:17:36] Thank you. [0:17:37] Thank you. [0:17:38] Thank you. [0:17:39] Thank you. [0:17:40] Thank you. [0:17:41] Thank you. [0:17:42] Thank you. [0:17:43] Thank you. [0:17:44] Thank you. [0:17:45] Thank you. [0:17:46] Thank you. [0:17:47] Thank you. [0:17:48] Motion passes 7-0. [0:17:51] Thank you. [0:17:52] Thanks, Mr. Nelson, the investment in community as well. [0:17:58] Okay, we appreciate those things moving forward. [0:18:01] Hey, next item is number three. [0:18:03] Consideration of request to adopt the utility rate resolution 1907 [0:18:08] for fiscal year 2013-14. [0:18:11] Lori, race. [0:18:14] Good evening, mayor and the city council. [0:18:16] Two weeks ago, on Monday, August 5th, we held a public hearing [0:18:20] increase sewer rates 27% and that 27% increase was needed to cover a new debt service payment [0:18:30] in association with a bond, a $38 million bond that was passed by the citizens in May. [0:18:37] And we have included that debt service payment in the budget as well as the anticipated revenues. [0:18:45] Now in addition to that 27% rate increase, our rate resolution also includes 4% for water [0:18:54] and 2.79% for sanitation. [0:18:57] The 4% in water, three of that is to help offset Idaho power costs and in sanitation, [0:19:06] it's the 2.79% that amounts to $0.46 per month for our customers, 13 cents of that's [0:19:14] for PSI for since of that is for landfill and 29 cents is for admin fee. And I would be happy [0:19:23] to answer any questions you may have. [0:19:29] I guess I'm confused. I might have misunderstood you. I thought this is just for passing the [0:19:37] sanitation, not inclusive of solid waste. Is that what your report was for all of that? [0:19:44] So two weeks ago we held the public hearing and we had to do it for sewer because it was over 5% [0:19:51] but I wanted to make sure you understood that the utility rate resolution included 4% for water and 2.79 for sanitation. [0:19:59] I would just have a wavelength behind you. I'm caught up now. Thank you. [0:20:03] I didn't go with the script tonight and I forgot to tell you that we're also reducing the arsenic compliance fee by 40 cents per month. [0:20:15] That's part of the same ordinance. [0:20:17] Yes. [0:20:18] Okay. [0:20:19] I'm sure that's what I meant to ask. [0:20:20] Yeah. [0:20:21] Yeah. [0:20:23] Um, we're back. [0:20:24] I'll say. [0:20:25] Thank you, Mayor. [0:20:26] Um, so on page six of the resolution under garbage and rubbish collection fees, is that [0:20:33] uh, 1699 per month does that include the twenty nine cent increase for code enforcement? [0:20:39] Yes. [0:20:40] Okay. [0:20:41] Thank you. [0:20:42] Seeing no additional likes, John Berger. [0:20:50] Here, for a motion to amend. [0:20:53] I would move approval of resolution number 1907. [0:20:57] Second. [0:20:59] It's been moved by Sean Berger and seconded by Jim Mundt, [0:21:02] for the approval of utility rate realized resolution 1907. [0:21:07] Rebecca Misleker. [0:21:09] Thank you, Mayor. [0:21:11] I'm still having trouble with the code enforcement portion [0:21:15] of the sanitation increase, you know, we said that we would be sensitive to rate increases, [0:21:21] and so I just, I'm just not convinced that, you know, this is something that we need or [0:21:27] that the community wants. So, I would just make an amendment to the motion to decrease [0:21:34] the sanitation fee by 29 cents per month. [0:21:37] Does that motion feel, Chris, I'll second it, just because I don't understand the rest [0:21:48] now and I'd like to put it on the floor. [0:21:49] Maybe we could discuss it. [0:21:51] Would you explain it again now what you're concerning? [0:21:53] I've been moved by Rebecca so I can say by Chris talking. [0:21:57] Now I'll have to move forward the discussion. [0:22:00] Sure. [0:22:01] Chris asks you questions. [0:22:02] You go ahead, Rebecca. [0:22:03] Thank you, Mayor. [0:22:05] My rationale is just to not increase the rate as much [0:22:09] as we can, basically, if we don't have to increase that portion [0:22:12] for $0.29 per user per month to not do it. [0:22:18] Again, while I'm certainly sensitive of rate decreases and I voted against many of them over the years, I [0:22:31] Guess my disagree would be that I believe that [0:22:35] Many people in our city do want code enforcement. They don't want we to eat lots. They don't want [0:22:41] Things that that all that encompasses I mean even to the point of all even bring up an economic development [0:22:50] prospect of it [0:22:52] One of the things when we bring companies the quality companies this town [0:22:55] They've always talked about the level of our that the cleanliness of our town and we have to have that code enforcement to maintain that [0:23:06] Cleanliness and I know that we've had [0:23:13] Some of maybe complained because they were having to read and they've had they've gotten the ticket from code enforcement or things on that line [0:23:19] But like I said when I was talking the same thing when they were complaining about Parkview Drive not be completed [0:23:24] I certainly got an earful a lot of times as I knocked on doors four years ago about [0:23:29] why is that lot being allowed to be weedy over there and who do I call and I always had [0:23:33] a number of prepared of who they call because that was something that was important to them. [0:23:40] They felt it lowered their property values, they felt it was a concern for their neighborhood [0:23:45] to keep their neighborhood looking good and that just goes all across the city, including [0:23:49] commercial development that have been built yet, that have been taken out of farmland [0:23:53] And that thing, so I will be voting against this [0:23:58] and just for that reason. [0:24:00] I believe it was Chris Docking and Jim Ed. [0:24:03] Go ahead, Jim. [0:24:04] Well, thank you, Chris. [0:24:06] Yes, I will support this amendment either. [0:24:09] Part of the criminal justice, one of the main components [0:24:12] of a criminal justice system is a broken windows theory [0:24:14] in which communities, when they see the degradation [0:24:17] of neighborhoods in different areas, [0:24:19] it's like a cancer and it continues. [0:24:22] And I think that communities have an obligation to work closely [0:24:28] to ensure that those things don't happen in crime rates. [0:24:31] And other socioeconomic issues will start degrading. [0:24:36] It's ironic, I forwarded two code enforcement issues [0:24:39] to the city manager this week from citizens in the community [0:24:42] who fed up with weeds that are encroaching on the property [0:24:45] and another one with a tree in a property that was actually [0:24:49] causing a public safety issue with a stop sign. [0:24:51] So I can't support this and I do believe that the community [0:24:54] doesn't, in fact, want code enforcement [0:24:56] and they're willing to pay for it. [0:24:58] Just talking to them. [0:24:59] Yeah, I wish I could, I could side with you, [0:25:02] but I guess I'm voting in the majority, [0:25:05] apparently at this time, Rebecca. [0:25:07] Coming to council today, I counted 34 homes [0:25:11] that had stopped watering their lawns [0:25:13] and on probably a third of them, [0:25:14] we had a fire and sanitation hazard. [0:25:17] I don't think we're enforcing enough [0:25:20] And I can say when I left the council before and I was part of the problem, we had virtually [0:25:25] no weed enforcement just to take that as a simple topic. [0:25:30] And I think this is somewhat of a citizen backlash that we've gone too far one way, [0:25:35] happy to do some pick up. [0:25:37] The other thing is related that it's real easy to put off these little two-bed increases [0:25:44] and then lump them together in one big one every five years. [0:25:48] And that's when you really get the citizenry up in arms. [0:25:51] I think that's better to do it just incrementally a year for years. [0:25:54] So I respectfully have to not support your motion. [0:25:59] Rebecca, may I say yes? [0:26:00] Thank you, Mayor. [0:26:01] Well, I appreciate the Council's input. [0:26:02] I still believe that it's not really needed or wanted. [0:26:06] But also, I want to note that we have increased code enforcement [0:26:10] over the past year. [0:26:11] So with our parking attendant that became part time code enforcement, [0:26:17] We also added our own animal control enforcement and to my knowledge they do part time code enforcement. [0:26:25] So I believe that we have added quick code enforcement so I'll be supporting it. [0:26:32] Do you see no little lights? [0:26:33] Do you have a roll call vote on the amendment? [0:26:36] Jim one. [0:26:38] No. [0:26:39] Rebecca Milsoica. [0:26:40] Yes. [0:26:41] Chris Talkington. [0:26:42] No. [0:26:43] Sean Beroger. [0:26:44] No. [0:26:45] Don Hall. [0:26:46] No. [0:26:47] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:26:48] No. [0:26:48] Greg Lansing. [0:26:49] No, the amendment fails one to six. [0:26:53] Moving back to the main motion. [0:26:56] Seeing no additional lights. [0:26:57] We have a roll call vote on the main motion. [0:26:59] Rebecca Melzukka, no. [0:27:02] Chris Talkington, Sean Baraker, Don Hall, Suzanne Hawkins, [0:27:08] yes, Greg Lanting, Jim Munn, motion passes six to one. [0:27:15] Thank you, Lori. [0:27:17] Moving on to item number four. [0:27:31] Any discussion on the budget for the upcoming [0:27:34] physical year at Travis Rothwiler? [0:27:37] So Mr. Mayor, members of the council, [0:27:40] we can't lawfully go forward until six o'clock. [0:27:45] And at six o'clock is when we'll go forward [0:27:47] with the presentation for anyone who wants to come. [0:27:50] We reserve this time in the event that the council [0:27:54] had additional questions of the budget before [0:27:56] later this evening. [0:27:57] we ask you to suspend the rules and adopt it. [0:28:00] If there are no additional questions by the council [0:28:04] and recognizing that we can't do anything before six o'clock, [0:28:07] you did add a series of executive sessions [0:28:10] that you could use for the balance of the time. [0:28:12] So we really, this time is more reserved for you [0:28:16] and any questions in the budget that you might have. [0:28:18] The staff and the team is here [0:28:20] and we are ready to answer questions [0:28:24] in terms of what that looks like in moving forward. [0:28:27] You do have one like, Chris, talk to us? [0:28:29] It's actually a little bit of an update for the council, [0:28:33] but I'd like to proceed that with a question to Travis, [0:28:35] if I might, the impact fees that we collect [0:28:41] for streets, fire, police, and parks and rec [0:28:45] are escrowed and dedicated funds. [0:28:49] If the council, and there's only one dedicated project, [0:28:54] think and that was a signal light and we've changed that. If the council chooses to [0:28:59] utilize some funds in one of those designated areas during the year, can we [0:29:06] do that without opening the budget if there's no budgetary implication that [0:29:11] would spill over into the general area? Yes, so that's a great question and the [0:29:16] answer is yes. What we've done in the past is we've had opportunities that [0:29:21] we've taken advantage of over the course of the year. [0:29:24] And then what we will do is we will come to the council [0:29:27] because it's an unappropriated expense. [0:29:29] We will seek your authorization to make that expenditure. [0:29:34] Lori and her team throughout the entire year [0:29:36] will track those additions and deletions to the budget [0:29:41] as something being unanticipated. [0:29:44] One of the best unanticipated examples [0:29:47] is when we receive a grant. [0:29:48] We don't necessarily include grant dollars [0:29:51] in our budgets and so at the end of the year, [0:29:53] prior to the audit and like we will also do this year [0:29:56] is we will ask you to adopt an ordinance [0:30:00] amending the budget for fiscal year 2013. [0:30:05] And we will typically do that only one time a year. [0:30:07] We could do it every time you chose to add [0:30:09] or move those and anticipated funds [0:30:12] but we found it better from a bookkeeping perspective [0:30:14] to capture them all over the course of the year [0:30:16] and do it at one time. [0:30:18] Thank you. [0:30:19] And then Mayor, if I might just have a quick update [0:30:22] on an important meeting held this last week [0:30:24] between the library board and the foundation [0:30:27] just being appropriate time. [0:30:29] I think you were aware that the two bodies [0:30:33] have been kind of arm's length discussing the prospect [0:30:37] of a joint building project on the back lot of the library [0:30:42] that City purchased when a house was raised. [0:30:45] And there's never been an exact usage for that lot. [0:30:48] right now it's collecting grass and using city water. [0:30:52] There's been a proposal presented this last week [0:30:56] by the foundation to the library board [0:30:59] to have a joint funding project in this next year [0:31:06] that would provide foundation with a permanent home. [0:31:10] As you recall, the foundation provides [0:31:13] somewhere $40,000, $50,000 a year in support [0:31:16] to the library that saves taxpayers money for books and [0:31:21] ancillary uses. [0:31:23] The foundation has not had success in securing a site [0:31:26] for their collection of donated materials. [0:31:30] The library itself has an approved capital expenditure [0:31:35] project to house the mobile book facility, the mobile book [0:31:41] bus. [0:31:43] And the idea is that either co-terminus with that [0:31:47] or in the same general area, [0:31:49] there may be a utility for a joint use building [0:31:55] that the IT section of the library could use [0:31:59] or have for future expansion without having to go [0:32:01] through a bond issue, which is doubtful if it would pass. [0:32:09] The city manager has informed us [0:32:10] that there is an addition to $950,000 in the library reserves, [0:32:17] or at library, I guess it be reserves, but it not. [0:32:21] That could be utilized within the confines of the budget [0:32:27] that we may or may not pass. [0:32:29] That would be contingent upon the foundation [0:32:32] of the library agreeing and the library board approving [0:32:36] and sending their request to the council [0:32:39] for ultimate approval. [0:32:41] I have no idea whether it's going to pass or not. [0:32:44] I think there are people on both sides of foundation and library board saying if we're ever going [0:32:49] to do a project now is the time where the land is available, money is available, and the foundation [0:32:55] would be able to and would be willing to provide some financial support. [0:32:59] How much I couldn't tell you on that. [0:33:02] Thank you, Chris, Don Hall. [0:33:04] Chris, I just had a question just so I understand exactly the direction here. [0:33:08] So they would utilize this land and build some sort of a structure for housing donated [0:33:14] items so they can go through those on site as well as a place for the mobile book bus [0:33:22] to be housed out of the weather. [0:33:24] Well I think the mobile bus shelter is a separate one and whether they're actually going to [0:33:29] be a separate facility or joined I don't know. [0:33:32] I think that they're envisioning several thousand feet of new construction. [0:33:38] I don't know whether the library has need for immediate use. [0:33:42] I do know that their IT is down in a little cramped hole in the basement. [0:33:47] The foundation though sometimes has quite a quantity of books that they need to keep dry [0:33:54] and would be a place for people to come in one central location when they have the book sales. [0:34:00] I don't know much particular beyond that. [0:34:03] I don't know if the library board is going [0:34:05] to even agree to the concept. [0:34:07] My personal thought is liaison to the library is this is a unique opportunity [0:34:13] and I certainly hope that they're looking forward to the needs of the city [0:34:17] of Twin Falls and do agree to it. [0:34:21] Thank you. [0:34:22] So you know either Travis, I'm assuming we'll finish with the agenda [0:34:27] which is a public input and things and then we'll probably go [0:34:30] into the executive session if that's the move to the council [0:34:32] and take part of it, we'll make, [0:34:34] let's try to make sure we come back out right at six, [0:34:37] even though if we're not done, [0:34:38] make sure we get to what we're carrying started on time, [0:34:41] I think. [0:34:42] So any other members of the council has input [0:34:46] that they would like to break forth for tonight, [0:34:48] that's not an agenda? [0:34:50] Rebecca, no further. [0:34:52] Thank you, Mayor. [0:34:53] Just an update on the fill the boot campaign last Saturday. [0:34:58] They had a goal of $12,000 and they have met that goal. [0:35:02] So just wanted to share that good news with the council. [0:35:04] And that tomorrow night in the overflow room is council office hours from six to seven. [0:35:09] If you'd like to meet with the council member. [0:35:12] Thank you, I'm the other council. [0:35:17] Mr. Rothweiler, do you have any items? [0:35:21] Mr. Mayor, members of the council, Bill Carberry, our airport manager sent me an email this afternoon, [0:35:29] with an opportunity that might be something that you all want to observe. [0:35:33] They're going to be going through an airport emergency drill on Wednesday, September 18th. [0:35:41] And the drill is scheduled to start at 9 a.m. and it is scheduled to wrap up by 11 a.m. [0:35:51] And Bill asks that I pass that invitation to all members of the council. [0:35:57] What we will do is we also have, we either send out a reminder, we'll get a head count [0:36:01] and we will post it in the event that we have more than four that choose to attend. [0:36:07] All right. [0:36:08] Thank you, Travis. [0:36:09] You want to publicly have something they wanted to share with us tonight that wasn't [0:36:12] on the agenda and it's not part of the public hearing that's coming up. [0:36:17] Seeing none, I would entertain a motion to go into executive session 6723451A and E and was [0:36:27] Are there a third one travels? [0:36:31] He's being in. [0:36:32] All right. [0:36:33] So moved. [0:36:35] Second. [0:36:36] And moved by Sean Berger and seconded by Don Hall for us to move into executive session. [0:36:43] For those items as listed. [0:36:46] We have a real help up. [0:36:48] Chris Tocquinton. [0:36:49] Yes. [0:36:50] Sean Berriger. [0:36:51] Yes. [0:36:53] Don Hall. [0:36:54] Yes. [0:36:55] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:36:56] Yes. [0:36:57] Greg Lanting. [0:36:58] Yes. [0:36:59] Jim Mun. [0:37:00] Rebecca Mille Swenka. [0:37:01] for those in the eyes we will come back out at 6 o'clock so we can begin the [0:37:07] public hearing on time and so we're adjourned or whatever we're to second [0:37:13] session always look at the best of the worst can happen with your opposition [0:37:32] what we've given on the best shot [0:37:42] I don't even know if we don't really have too many particulars. [0:37:50] Thank you. [0:37:51] This goes with my other 39 for the budget. [0:37:55] How many trees gave their all for us? [0:38:08] I'd like to reconvene the Twin Falls City Council meeting. [0:38:49] We did not finish all of the items on the executive session, so after the public hearing, we will be finishing those executive session. [0:39:00] But we would like to move forward on a timely matter with the public hearing for [0:39:05] the adoption of the physical year 2014 budget and Travis Wathwa there if you'll lead us through that. [0:39:12] Mr. Mayor, members of the council. [0:39:14] So tonight is the end of the first part of our journey. [0:39:19] The journey that we started on the 29th of April this year when we first sat down with you and [0:39:26] had a conversation about the budget and then we've engaged in a series of conversations about the budget. [0:39:30] almost each and every week since after the 4th of July. [0:39:35] And today is a [0:39:40] opportunity to take those conversations and later tonight we are going [0:39:44] to ask you to host a public hearing to allow the citizens [0:39:48] to submit their thoughts and their inputs into this budget [0:39:52] and then we are going to ask you as required by Idaho Code to adopt [0:39:56] an ordinance. We'll ask you to suspend the rules and then we'll ask you to adopt [0:40:00] adopt that ordinance and that ordinance will set the appropriations measure for the City [0:40:05] of Twin Falls for fiscal year 2014 which is scheduled to begin on October 1st. [0:40:14] So as we shared in every single part of our conversation that everything that we do in [0:40:21] the City of Twin Falls should be and needs to be linked to our mission statement. [0:40:27] Our mission statement describes who we are, describes that we are the stewards of the public [0:40:33] trust that it is our duty to present and prepare to you as staff and then to have you [0:40:41] to debate and vet what is the best option not only for our community to date but also [0:40:49] in the future that we obviously want to ensure that we're doing so with the highest degree [0:40:54] of transparency and that we're soliciting public input in that process. [0:40:59] And it's done so in a manner that is respectful of the quality of life that we enjoy in Twin Falls. [0:41:05] Because Twin Falls is a very special and unique place, and it deserves our utmost care and attention. [0:41:13] When we started that conversation on the 29th of April, after a series of three meetings, [0:41:20] we created a series of templates or foundational portions of that budget. [0:41:27] And what we said was we wanted to make sure that we limited tax collections to the statutory [0:41:34] allowance. [0:41:35] And we wanted to keep the entire city's foregone balance intact in this budget. [0:41:41] The city's foregone, again, is not used. [0:41:43] That city's foregone balance will remain at $1,478,577. [0:41:52] We said that we wanted to continue with Phase 2 of our compensation strategy that we recognize [0:41:58] is the value that our employees bring and the importance of having a good, high-quality [0:42:04] market-based compensation model. We felt that this is the year to continue that. This year [0:42:10] we have a 3.5% adjustment in this budget for our employees. We are also proposing moving [0:42:16] the table 2%. We also said that we wanted to make sure that we were continuing to do what [0:42:24] we can for our infrastructure systems, including finding additional redundancies and strengthening [0:42:30] the backbone of our community, which is our water system, and like always, we wanted to [0:42:34] make sure that we were pursuing innovative strategies and efficient outcomes, and that [0:42:39] is going to be determined with our performance management system, which is something that [0:42:44] you will begin to see on the veil and unrolled over the course of the next fiscal year. [0:42:50] So this budget is a balanced, sandable course of action. [0:42:54] We like to share that because everything that we're doing is looking out not only beyond [0:42:59] this fiscal year, but those that may be impacted by our decisions, that it is truly linked to [0:43:06] our strategic plan that we spent over a year creating. [0:43:10] And as you go through the narratives, we talk about the individual strategic planning objectives [0:43:15] that we intend and hope to accomplish over the course of this year, out and over the course [0:43:20] of several years. [0:43:22] That it allocates money to do the things that cities must do, and that's protect our public [0:43:27] health, protect our safety, and do what we can to encourage and enhance the quality of [0:43:32] life that merits our attention as our community continues to grow. [0:43:37] And on the 5th of August, it sets that maximum spending limit that you set at $52,937,917. [0:43:48] At no point in our process and according to the Idaho Code, can we now exceed that total [0:43:55] budget for this process? [0:43:58] We were asked along the way about what does a different percent look like and what we wanted [0:44:04] to do is we wanted to make sure that you have that information available as we presented it. [0:44:09] So the statutory increase is at 3% creates $498,028. [0:44:19] We illustrate here what the tax rate would be for each one of those 1% adjustments. [0:44:26] In the very first column, you'll notice what the tax rate is for this current fiscal year, [0:44:31] which is $7.71. [0:44:33] And at a 1%, the tax rate would decrease to $7.26, and it would be a savings of $7, or [0:44:43] the taxes would be $7.26 per $1,000 in taxable value. [0:44:48] For 2%, the tax rate would be $7.33, and as we presented in the recommended budget, that [0:44:56] tax rate would be $7.40. We illustrated what those individual tax impacts would be on a median [0:45:03] house value in our community. And you'll notice that in all of those cases, the tax rate on [0:45:10] that median home example and the individual taxes paid on that example are less than the [0:45:16] taxes that are paid by the citizens this year. And that's because our community has grown. [0:45:24] the numbers below illustrate the numbers that would be collected, the revenues that [0:45:29] would be collected. [0:45:30] So in this budget, you'll notice that we've scheduled to collect property tax dollars and [0:45:36] they amount to $498,028. [0:45:41] With a 1% adjustment, that number is decreased by $332,000 and the total new property tax collections [0:45:49] would be $166,009. [0:45:55] And then we did some comparisons of what that means, and you can see that the difference [0:45:59] of taking 1% this year as opposed to 3% this year is $10 per month for the resident, or 84 [0:46:08] cents per month. [0:46:09] So this gives you an idea of those different impacts of what that looks like. [0:46:14] We believe based upon the spending plan that we put forward that the 3% allocations we discussed [0:46:22] in the beginning allows us to move forward organizationally [0:46:25] to accomplish the strategic planning objectives [0:46:28] that we have set forward. [0:46:32] This is a side-by-side comparison of the fiscal year budget [0:46:35] that we are in now, and it illustrates the budget [0:46:39] that we have proposed for your adoption this evening. [0:46:43] It illustrates the taxable value of the city [0:46:46] has grown by nearly $183 million. [0:46:49] What is important to note is that does not include Jibani, [0:46:53] that does not include Glandia. [0:46:55] Those girls in our economy are outside of the 183 million. [0:47:00] There is no question in my mind that there [0:47:02] is an indirect relationship to the growth that we've enjoyed [0:47:05] and the significant economic development success [0:47:09] that we've had. [0:47:11] But their taxable values are in revenue allocation areas [0:47:15] used to support the public infrastructure [0:47:17] that they needed to move forward. [0:47:20] The tax supported portion of the budget [0:47:21] for this year's $31,416,000. [0:47:25] The non-tax supported fund, those enterprise funds, [0:47:27] which is attached to the utility rate resolution, [0:47:30] is $21,521,498. [0:47:35] You'll notice that the total tax collections here [0:47:38] would be $17,286,685,000 total new taxable dollars. [0:47:46] Again, from the previous slide, [0:47:49] 187,820 from new construction, [0:47:52] 498,000 from the statutory 3%. [0:47:57] I would do, I would like Chris talking. [0:47:59] I just want to make sure I understand, [0:48:01] Travis, on that 685, [0:48:03] if you flip forward there again. [0:48:05] 685 and change represents [0:48:08] property tax increase only. [0:48:11] None of the enterprise fund that [0:48:13] is correct increases. [0:48:14] Okay. It's correct. [0:48:16] It's also meant to illustrate that of [0:48:19] the nearly $1.8 million of additional money in the tax-supported funds, roughly one-third [0:48:28] of that is coming from additional property tax collections. [0:48:31] The other two-thirds is coming from other sources. [0:48:35] Increased building permit revenues, as a result of increased building activity, increased revenues [0:48:39] from state-shared revenues because of our growth and the increase in our taxable value [0:48:44] and other sources. [0:48:47] The tax rate for this budget is estimated to be $7.40 per $1,000 of taxable value. [0:48:55] The tax rate for the current budget is $7.71. [0:49:00] We are estimating again that the tax rate in this budget will decrease by 31 cents per $1,000 of taxable value. [0:49:11] This is a side by side comparison of the budgets that we've passed since 2008. [0:49:18] The blue represents the tax-supported funds, the red represents those enterprise funds [0:49:23] of those enterprise fee-based funds. [0:49:28] This is a graphical illustration of the tax rate of the community. [0:49:31] Again, you can see a $0.31 per $1,000 decrease in this projected tax rate as a proposed to [0:49:38] one that we issued for fiscal year 2013. [0:49:42] And it is continuing to move down as what we would expect as a result of the strengthening. [0:49:51] The property tax collection since 2008 are illustrated and you can see that again in 2013 [0:49:58] we collected $16.6 million dollars and this year we're projected to collect nearly $17.3. [0:50:04] One of the questions that we're often asked is how does my tax rate stack up to other communities? [0:50:15] And we have to take a look back a year because all other cities right now are still in the [0:50:21] process of finalizing what their tax rate is going to be by adopting a spending plan that [0:50:28] would begin on October 1st. So we look backwards. And what this illustrates are the major cities [0:50:35] in Idaho with the total tax rate multiplied against the median household income or excuse [0:50:43] me median household value. And then the city of Twin Falls it's $142,300 with the tax rate [0:50:49] last year of $7.71. [0:50:52] And so the tax is paid on the median house in Twin Falls [0:50:55] would be $548. [0:50:57] And that is the same calculation that we did for all of those [0:51:00] cities here with the exception of Boise [0:51:03] and the exception of Meridian. [0:51:06] And we did not include them in our assessment [0:51:08] because they utilized the services of the Ada County Highway [0:51:11] District. [0:51:12] And because of that, the streets present almost 17% [0:51:18] of our budget, it was not a fair apples-to-apples comparison. [0:51:22] I also wasn't certain that I could just add the Ada County Highway District portion to the [0:51:29] other portion, so in an effort to be consistent and we left that out. [0:51:37] This is just a graphical representation of what that looks like. [0:51:42] One of the things that we do know that as the City of Twin Falls has grown by $183 million, [0:51:50] very, very few communities have enjoyed the same level of growth and so we look at this [0:51:55] difference only increasing over the course of the next fiscal year. [0:52:03] This again talks about the utility rate resolution that was adopted a little bit earlier this [0:52:09] evening where the functional net increase in water is 2.2 percent and we get the functional [0:52:15] net adjustment by taking a 4 percent adjustment in operations and then decreasing the arsenic [0:52:21] great by 40 cents per month per resident. The most that an individual pay is 4%. However, [0:52:30] water users of less than 18,000 gallons will be defined in average user will pay less. So [0:52:37] someone who uses 5,000 gallons of water, their net adjustment is roughly 8 tenths of [0:52:44] a percent. We originally talked about in the budget where 29% in the recommended budget [0:52:51] would be needed, but then as we went forward, [0:52:54] we were able to find some additional efficiencies, [0:52:56] and the only increase in the sewer fund [0:52:58] is that of the voter approved debt. [0:53:01] That is a 27% adjustment of $5.21, [0:53:05] and then the sanitation, 2.8% or 46 cents per month, [0:53:10] 13 cents of that is attributed to CSI or PSI [0:53:17] in our contract provider. [0:53:21] So when we add up, how much is it going to cost us [0:53:23] in Twin Falls this year over compared to the last. [0:53:26] This is a side-by-side comparison. [0:53:28] It's the assessment of property taxes. [0:53:30] It is the assessment of water, sewer, and sanitation. [0:53:34] And you'll notice that difference is $4.85 a month. [0:53:38] The debt service for the sewer fund is $5.21. [0:53:43] All other funds in Twin Falls, it's actually less per capita [0:53:50] than the debt service in the sewer fund [0:53:52] that we've asked, and those approved by 70% of our citizens. [0:54:00] And with that, Mayor and Council, by Idaho Code, [0:54:05] it is required to open up a public hearing [0:54:10] to solicit and capture public comment. [0:54:13] And then this budget is still very much alive [0:54:17] and open for conversation, debate, and spending. [0:54:21] The staff is prepared and assembled [0:54:23] to answer any questions that you may have [0:54:26] before we anticipate it adoption later this evening. [0:54:29] I'd like to look forward past this budget just [0:54:33] real short time frame. [0:54:34] The next year or two trend-wise, if the economy, which [0:54:40] has appearances have bottomed and coming up now, [0:54:45] property values by and large seem to be on the uptick. [0:54:53] Repos may have finally passed its apex, [0:54:58] or nature, whichever way you look at it, and we're successful and continuing to grow the [0:55:05] economy and the job base of the town. [0:55:08] Give us a two to three year prognostication at those variables by and large come true, [0:55:16] and the city did not expand in any significant white budget wise the impact on the property [0:55:24] tax rate per thousand. [0:55:28] So the Idaho, as I understand it, so obviously the more you grow, and the larger that your [0:55:33] total taxable value is, we could see that decrease as designed by the Idaho tax system in the [0:55:41] individual tax rates that are paid by our residents. [0:55:47] The tax rate is a mathematical formula. [0:55:49] It is governed by total government spending divided by the total taxable value, and if the [0:55:56] The taxable value of the community significantly outpaces our 3% that we can take on an annual [0:56:02] basis for inflation and to cover increased costs associated with doing business, then [0:56:08] that tax rate goes down. [0:56:10] And that tax rate goes down really does send signs of an improving economy. [0:56:19] Now what I will caution is the tax rate is a multiplier. [0:56:23] The tax rate going down does not necessarily mean that individual taxes are going to go [0:56:28] down. [0:56:29] In fact, last year we illustrated that even though the tax rate went up, that individual [0:56:36] taxes were made the same functionally or went down. [0:56:42] So we can say with some level of certainty that if the current path continues, the tax [0:56:48] rate will go down. [0:56:51] And if the state's homeowner exemption continues to show a expanded taxable amount, the impact [0:57:00] would be what? [0:57:01] We believe that actually the homeowners exemption at 80, so as we've shared that tax rate, homeowners [0:57:08] exemption decreased this year from $83,295 to 81,000. [0:57:14] It had a 3% decrease, which broadens the taxable amount on those homes. [0:57:20] That's right. [0:57:21] We believe that in our conversations that that has shown signs of repair and that we [0:57:25] will see that homeowners exemption once again moving upward and having more being left [0:57:34] or having more being allowed to be exempted based upon the 50% rule. [0:57:40] The question ultimately, and it's really tough to answer, it comes down to what an individual's [0:57:46] house value grows by comparison to the percentage of growth of its multiplier. [0:57:56] If we do a illustration of the median household value of our community and we illustrate the [0:58:05] impact of that tax rate, I think that it illustrates that all things being equal, we can anticipate [0:58:12] that the individual tax burden should drive downward, but that is not to say or should [0:58:17] and ever be confused that everyone in the community [0:58:20] is going to receive lower property taxes. [0:58:24] Thank you. [0:58:26] John Burr. [0:58:28] Travis, I wanted to follow up on the information [0:58:30] you sent out to us almost two weeks ago [0:58:33] about the health insurance cost. [0:58:35] So it sounds like Susan did an outstanding job [0:58:40] of working on getting those anticipated increases [0:58:45] to not be increases on the health insurance [0:58:47] for employees this year. [0:58:48] So I just wanted to reaffirm that that savings is still anticipated. [0:58:55] And as we discussed tonight that those funds may be available for [0:58:58] reallocation to other types of activities. [0:59:03] Yes, so obviously great credit goes to Sue and [0:59:10] Gretchen and the HR team for really working their magic again this year. [0:59:15] And I don't know exactly what they do, but [0:59:19] It always tends to work out in our favor and we're very appreciative of their efforts. [0:59:24] So as you'll recall, we budgeted for a 12% increase in this year's budget and that's where [0:59:29] we started. [0:59:30] And then once we received our notice, it was about a 12 and a half percent adjustment. [0:59:36] And from that point, Sue and her team immediately went to work. [0:59:41] And over a course of dialogues and really being the beneficiary of good and competition [0:59:48] because we started shopping our plan. [0:59:51] Sue was able to get a proposal from both firms that basically [0:59:56] illustrates a 0% increase with no significant change [1:00:00] in our benefit package for this year moving forward. [1:00:05] And so going from a budgeted 12% adjustment [1:00:10] to a 0% adjustment has a total savings [1:00:14] in the budget of $284,828. [1:00:21] Because most of our employees are housed in the general fund, [1:00:28] most of that savings is in the general fund [1:00:31] or the tax-supported funds. [1:00:33] And so there's $238,164 that is not or could be reallocated. [1:00:47] There are several opportunities before the council. [1:00:54] One of the options is to do nothing. [1:00:59] One of the things that staff would recommend [1:01:01] and is that we take $30,000 of that, [1:01:06] and it would be applied from the appropriate funds, [1:01:09] and we would move that into a wellness line item [1:01:12] so that we could enhance our wellness and proactivity, [1:01:16] prone activeness and create activities that encourage employee wellness. [1:01:22] One of the things that we have learned is that employee wellness is going to be the [1:01:27] key to long-term success in managing future health care costs. [1:01:32] If we have good, solid, strong employee cores, we can have a better experience rate. [1:01:40] The experience rate is one of the largest determining factors in the overall future [1:01:45] health care adjustment. [1:01:46] we believe that we would request that 30,000 of that [1:01:49] remain intact and that we would move forward. [1:01:53] You could keep the other part intact as well, [1:01:56] and you could elect to do nothing by creating a health [1:01:58] insurance reserve account. [1:02:01] We started this year in looking at developing and seeing [1:02:07] if we made sense for us organizationally to become [1:02:10] partially self-insured. [1:02:12] And one of the things we wanted to do was to look back [1:02:15] to see if that would have made sense. [1:02:17] And what we found is it would actually [1:02:19] would have cost us about a half a million dollars more. [1:02:23] And so that was a quick look that said, [1:02:26] that's probably not a right or appropriate path for us [1:02:29] at this time based upon our experience ratios. [1:02:33] But at some point in time, should that be a path [1:02:36] or an option, we need about $800,000 of cash reserves [1:02:39] to be able to go that direction. [1:02:42] Additionally, that funding could be used [1:02:43] to buffer future rate adjustments, [1:02:45] and so the impact isn't experienced by our employees. [1:02:50] The other is obviously, so from the do nothing option, [1:02:54] you have the remove it all option, [1:02:57] which is obviously to the council's discretion. [1:03:05] The other is that you could move a portion of that [1:03:07] to cover capital costs. [1:03:09] What's important to recognize is that when internally [1:03:13] we started this process, [1:03:14] we had $3.1 million of capital projects. [1:03:19] And we vetted those through our processes, [1:03:22] and we removed them. [1:03:24] And it's down to about $1.8 million in tax in general fund [1:03:28] tax-aborted projects. [1:03:30] So you can see that there's a significant collection [1:03:32] of projects that was not. [1:03:35] I would be remissed if I didn't see my fellow running [1:03:38] companions behind me. [1:03:42] And they actually did come, in fact, [1:03:45] I think for the record, they were the only group that did come and approach the council [1:03:50] about trails publicly. [1:03:52] We've had comments, I had comments, and certainly you could take those monies and place them [1:03:58] into one-time capital projects for the expansion of trail systems or to cover any other capital [1:04:05] project that we did not include in this process. [1:04:10] And finally, you could do any combination of the three. [1:04:14] I would do have a question, Don Hall. [1:04:17] Not to get a sidetrack, but could you maybe drill down a little bit deeper and tell us why [1:04:21] we thought it was going to be 12% and it ended up being 12 something, but of course, to find [1:04:26] work with a HR, we're able to negotiate that down to zero, but how do we come up with 12% [1:04:33] in the first place? [1:04:36] So one of the things we do to determine costs is we look backwards. [1:04:39] last year when we started our budgeting process, we came up with about an 8% adjustment, I believe. [1:04:48] And we received incredible sticker shock when our renewal notice was 24.9%. [1:04:55] And then we were able to work that down to, I believe, 16%, is that right, for this year? [1:05:02] And so we were able to work that down to 16% and that's what was provided in this fiscal year budget. [1:05:11] And really at the 12% was, are we having conversations [1:05:16] about different things? [1:05:17] What can we afford organizationally to ensure sustainability? [1:05:21] It's important for us that we have a benefit package [1:05:24] that not only is competitive, but is something [1:05:26] that we can continue to support and sustain going long term. [1:05:30] We never want to be on the benefits rollercoaster [1:05:33] with our employees. [1:05:34] We're one year because of a good windfall like this one. [1:05:37] we decide to do something significant that enhances. [1:05:41] We're only next year because everything is predicated upon our experience ratio and the [1:05:48] uncertainty of the affordability health care act. [1:05:52] We never know what's going to happen. [1:05:55] We got a zero percent because of a new competitor in the area and they offered a zero percent [1:06:00] adjustment to us and then we approached our current carrier and after. [1:06:05] This is where Sue and her team really did a good job. [1:06:08] She was able to get an equal proposal, [1:06:11] or nearly equal proposal, from our current carrier of 0%. [1:06:17] So I hope that answers. [1:06:19] Well, 12%, but last year it was 24%. [1:06:22] You know, girl, she did it down to 16%. [1:06:24] What brought you to 12% for this year? [1:06:26] Just out of curiosity. [1:06:27] That's what we could afford. [1:06:29] OK. [1:06:29] What we could afford, and that's the target. [1:06:31] It was within a reason that we felt [1:06:33] What are we going to experience and what can we for it to allow us to continue to be sustained? [1:06:37] Thank you. [1:06:38] Thank you. [1:06:39] We'll be back in a second. [1:06:40] Thank you, Mayor. [1:06:41] I have a question about the wellness item, I don't know if Susan or yourself if you would [1:06:46] like to answer. [1:06:49] I think it's a great idea. [1:06:50] I think the wellness programs that I've seen in other companies have worked well. [1:06:54] What would that amount allow you to do? [1:06:57] I've heard of different programs where per month, they reimburse races or physical activities, [1:07:06] entrance fees and into certain races. [1:07:09] There's a portion that they help buy down fees to help clubs. [1:07:15] Do you know why did you choose that $30,000 and what would it allow us to do? [1:07:21] Honestly, the $30,000 was a dart at a dart board and it said this is a good start and [1:07:27] an opportunity for us to maybe start doing something. [1:07:30] Because this is relatively new information, [1:07:32] we have not pounded out what could that wellness program look [1:07:37] like, but you're absolutely right. [1:07:38] There are lots of good examples that we could copy and bring [1:07:43] into our organization, whether that be offsetting the cost [1:07:47] of a gym membership, paying for entrance fees, [1:07:53] as you mentioned, as well as there's [1:07:55] a mental health wellness portion as well, [1:07:58] that maybe people want to take a finance class, [1:08:00] maybe individuals. [1:08:01] So it's not just physical wellness, [1:08:03] but also I think it's important to recognize [1:08:06] the mental wellness and the stress piece [1:08:08] that could also be just almost equally as debilitating. [1:08:13] And so it's important that what we thought [1:08:15] is if there is a financial allocation, [1:08:17] it would give us the opportunity to create something new [1:08:20] that could enhance the employee wellness, [1:08:22] and there's lots of models out there [1:08:24] that I'm confident that Sue and her team could use [1:08:28] and really create probably a far superior program [1:08:31] than what may even exist out with some other organizations now. [1:08:35] Thank you. [1:08:36] Yeah, I would be interested in seeing some of those numbers [1:08:39] and seeing what you might need. [1:08:41] I mean, if it's more than that or what it might encompass, [1:08:45] especially that's a group point about mental health [1:08:49] and mental wellness, I know some programs provide a certain number [1:08:52] of free counseling sessions, which are critical to mental health. [1:08:57] So I would be open to seeing those amounts and be open to entertaining even greater amount [1:09:04] for employee wellness, and I think that's a great idea. [1:09:07] Thank you. [1:09:09] Can you comment on some of the lights I have at this time? [1:09:13] Does that mean it's time for us to open the public hearing? [1:09:15] Let the public give us comment on what they think of our budget and how we're utilizing [1:09:22] the budget. [1:09:24] I'm sure I have an idea how some of them are going to feel. [1:09:28] Some suggestions that they might give us. [1:09:30] So do we have a list back there, Travis? [1:09:33] Or Josh is going to look for it. [1:09:38] Did everyone who would like to speak sign up on the list [1:09:42] did appear so? [1:09:47] Well, I see more people than I have names here for us. [1:09:51] Well, first I need to open with them. [1:09:55] I'm going to open the public hearing. [1:09:56] We're going to allow, since we don't have it, [1:09:58] I only have two names here. [1:09:59] I'm going to allow four minutes tonight, [1:10:00] which is double normal. [1:10:01] But yeah, we really do want to hear what people have to say [1:10:04] about the budget. [1:10:05] So four minutes, I don't want to, I don't want to, [1:10:08] mostly when you went. [1:10:09] So first name on Don Hall will be giving you [1:10:12] two minutes left and a 30 seconds left. [1:10:14] I'm the time police. [1:10:15] These people have been here before. [1:10:18] I thought maybe they do the process, [1:10:19] but good thing that we remind them. [1:10:21] So the public hearing has opened the first name [1:10:23] on the list is Mark Alexander. [1:10:26] Mark if you'd come forth and speak to us [1:10:28] and give us your address in your full name [1:10:31] for, because we do record the meetings. [1:10:33] Okay, my name is Mark Alexander, [1:10:35] and I represent, oh, you need my address. [1:10:38] It's 1152, Sal Stevens, and Father Idaho. [1:10:42] Okay. [1:10:43] And I'm a member of the Magic Ballet Trail Enhancement Committee, [1:10:49] and since I've been kind of out of the loop [1:10:52] on a couple of our recent meetings, [1:10:54] I'd like to turn my time over to Jamie T. [1:10:57] Give if I could please. [1:10:58] Certainly, she's the next one on the list, [1:11:00] you can each have four minutes you want or she can have eight. So, don't give her eight. [1:11:05] She's better prepared than I am. Jamie, if you'd come for give your name and address, [1:11:10] we recognize that you're speaking for a larger group. They're here with their [1:11:15] shirts on light. I just know you're speaking for a larger group. My name is Jamie Tigg and I'm a 23 [1:11:22] grace drive. What are you doing? Okay, just go ahead and whatever you would like to share with us. [1:11:31] Okay, and as you can see, yes, I'm here on behalf of the [1:11:35] trail enhancement committee, and this is literally the eighth [1:11:41] of what the committee really is composed of, so Monday evenings [1:11:46] I think are difficult for people to attend, but I just want to [1:11:52] say that this is probably one of the best advisory committees [1:11:59] that we have for community support and of course our mission is for the [1:12:06] trails so as you recognize that we were here last time that was our main objective [1:12:13] and we are here again just so you don't forget us and we would love to be included [1:12:21] in your budget and is it Travis? Travis I think I should just pay you afterwards [1:12:28] because that sounds good and to what I am here for I was thrilled to hear that [1:12:38] you have and I don't want to say extra because money is not extra even in my [1:12:44] own personal income it's like when it's extra it's gone I'm sure you have lots [1:12:50] of things that you can put towards but to have a little less than 285,000 I [1:12:56] I think is what I heard to play with, is exciting for us [1:13:04] because our mission is to complete the trail system here [1:13:08] in Twin Falls, and mainly our focus right now [1:13:12] is to finish from what you guys can probably vision is [1:13:17] behind Sportsman's warehouse, ish. [1:13:20] That trail out to Shoshone Falls where evil can evil site [1:13:26] ends, and that is our mission is to get that completed. Rather, it would be not a paved [1:13:35] trail at this time, just something that can be put down for people to meander upon and [1:13:41] save, of course, to be able to run, walk. Hopefully, cycle, but some road, I guess, gravel [1:13:51] isn't as feasible to cycle, but hopefully we can make that happen, depending on the [1:13:56] cost of it. I know now tonight that you have in your strategic goals that your mission is [1:14:04] wellness. What better way to have more trails and complete trails and safe places for people [1:14:12] to recreate. And of course our Canyon, how beautiful is that for people to continue from [1:14:22] Clear from the Perrine Bridge Visitor Center, [1:14:25] I go all the way out to Shoshone Falls, [1:14:28] the whole thing complete and back again. [1:14:31] That would be so cool. [1:14:33] So that is kind of what we're hoping. [1:14:37] We have fundraised from this race here, [1:14:41] completely four years, right? [1:14:44] Oh my gosh, I've spent four years [1:14:46] that I've led that race. [1:14:48] All the funds have gone into the Twin Falls Community [1:14:51] foundation to host that funds for us and we're willing to give what we've [1:14:59] raised plus we're willing to continue to fund raise and we look at this we can [1:15:09] put in some sweat equity into it to help the city make this happen we're [1:15:16] willing to go meet with those homeowners that are being a little bit [1:15:23] That we're willing to give him a little sweet talk, if we need to, to help make this happen. [1:15:31] Am I still good on time? [1:15:33] He gave you eight minutes, you've only done four, so you've got time. [1:15:37] Okay, I just hope that you guys consider how important this can be. [1:15:44] I'm passionate. [1:15:47] I work at CSI, when you talk about wellness, I work on wellness, so if you want to partner, [1:15:53] I can do that because I'm on the wellness team and it is such a passion of mine and CSI does have the most amazing wellness program [1:16:02] and that you might be interested in learning more about because we just partnered with St. Luke's. [1:16:07] So it is my passion, but it's not only mine, but it's the whole group. [1:16:11] They said they're runners. [1:16:14] We just want a place that's also safe for people. [1:16:18] I'm going to be able if it's off the roads, you have to probably see cyclists and runners [1:16:24] on the road all the time and you can be unsafe. [1:16:28] Plus chores, people coming into town, I hear this all the time, where do I go, how do I do, [1:16:36] what can't, where's the trails, what's it like, well you can go here and stop, you have to go [1:16:41] back, great to say, gosh you can go four miles plus and I think that would be fantastic for [1:16:48] people to bring people back to this area. I think it's a huge plus. And again, it's wellness. [1:16:57] It's all about being healthy and your insurance rates will go down. Right? Because you're all [1:17:03] healthy because you're out there being active. So that's important too. Do you have any questions? [1:17:10] How much does it cost, how much, what is the estimate to, I guess, complete the trail [1:17:21] between, um, where it ends there by Todd Blass's house over to, where it hooks in by [1:17:27] Evil Knievel. [1:17:28] S me, and this is, this is paved. [1:17:33] Okay. [1:17:34] Yeah. [1:17:35] Let's see. [1:17:36] Are you talking about the best travel ever? [1:17:37] Yeah. [1:17:38] Ever. [1:17:39] I just realized, Jim, I really can't. [1:17:40] I can ask questions. [1:17:41] I can ask her questions. [1:17:42] I can ask her questions. [1:17:44] Well, we'll allow them because we only have one. [1:17:48] Let's let the bureaucracy take over here. [1:17:50] I can't see what's going to be what I've done. [1:17:54] Let me retract that question right now. [1:17:56] I'm going to retract it, staff. [1:17:58] Okay. [1:17:59] All right. [1:18:00] Thank you. [1:18:01] We really probably shouldn't wait until after the public hearing. [1:18:04] You're going to ask certain questions. [1:18:07] You're getting trouble. [1:18:08] Yeah. [1:18:11] Well, thank you, Jimmy. [1:18:14] And there will probably be some questions after the public hearing. [1:18:17] That would be great. [1:18:18] Please, at any time we're here again, we are so excited and getting it done this year [1:18:27] would be a dream come true. [1:18:29] Thank you so much. [1:18:30] Thank you, Dean. [1:18:31] If you're keeping track, you use seven minutes. [1:18:33] You're still good. [1:18:34] Thank you. [1:18:35] Can I ask staff a question during the public hearing? [1:18:37] No, I'm about to close it, I have a feeling also. [1:18:41] Do anyone else that would like to speak on the physical year 2014 budget? [1:18:46] Seeing no one, I'm going to close the public hearing. [1:18:51] And now it's time for questions. [1:18:53] Why don't you ask a question? [1:18:55] Travis, I think he's going to... [1:18:57] What information do you have, Travis, that you would like to share with us? [1:19:01] This is already what we've just brought up. [1:19:03] How much is it going to cost to build a trail between Todd Blass' house and Gille Knievel? [1:19:09] The best case here. [1:19:10] $650,000 is our best guess fully built out and paid. [1:19:16] Does that include the entire trail system? [1:19:20] So the entire trail system, it's broke down here by not only the linear foot, but then [1:19:29] also the cost. [1:19:32] We have about 4.1 miles of trail that could be completed as a part of our overall project, [1:19:42] which has a total estimated price tag of about $1,618,000. [1:19:49] The piece that you're talking about in particular [1:19:52] is about $650,000, and that's a rough estimate, okay? [1:19:58] That's what she was talking about, [1:20:00] was that that's the dream, right, that part. [1:20:05] The end, I got several lights on top, [1:20:09] but I wasn't next, so Don Hall's light was next. [1:20:12] Travis, do we have that land already locked up to be able to go through Scary Stores property, [1:20:20] right? [1:20:21] It hasn't been developed yet. [1:20:26] The way trails are put in place is generally on the developers' dime. [1:20:31] We have standards, they have to put it in, but we don't have the particular route. [1:20:36] So on parts of it we do. [1:20:38] So through the pillar falls development, that property is there and it is, in fact, it's [1:20:45] also partially trapped. [1:20:47] Okay. [1:20:48] And so the linear cost we believe is going to be less than what is illustrated here [1:20:53] through that development. [1:20:56] We also have, through the Gary Store property, we have a, I want to scribe as a temporary [1:21:04] easement. [1:21:05] Is that the best way to say that? [1:21:07] I've got Mitch come up. [1:21:08] We've done some research since the last visit. [1:21:11] We recognize that there might be some obstacles in terms of land owners and Mitch did some [1:21:17] research and I'm going to present that with the council. [1:21:21] Then I have a little follow-up too. [1:21:26] So it's the one that's labeled here the Preserve. [1:21:29] We have a PUD in place that I guess I'll call it an opportunity to negotiate with the [1:21:36] property owner for a temporary alignment of a trail with a temporary surface. And then [1:21:43] the PUD requires the developer of the property to build the permanent trail in a more fitting [1:21:50] location as the streets and everything kind of coming with that development. So we know [1:21:56] the, by that PUD, we know where the temporary alignment of the trail will be and basically [1:22:02] just as far north as you can possibly get, but it probably isn't a permanent surface. [1:22:07] It's probably just kind of a temporary level, maybe with some fencing to keep separation from [1:22:16] the rest of the use of that property in this current state. [1:22:19] There's some cattle use going on out there. [1:22:23] So we have basically the opportunity to negotiate for that. [1:22:28] We've made some very early volleys, [1:22:31] and I'm not quite sure how it's all going to pan out yet, [1:22:33] but there's a possibility. [1:22:35] Pillar Falls, we can get across to the Nevel, [1:22:38] and we can get across. [1:22:39] So that would basically connect the gap from Todd's house [1:22:42] to just past the genocide. [1:22:45] You know, I think that's incredibly important. [1:22:47] I'm glad that you brought it up, [1:22:48] but there's also that funky little piece behind Costco as well. [1:22:52] I rode my mountain bike there the other day, [1:22:54] and it's not all paved. [1:22:56] It's kind of a couple different directions you can go and you've got to go over a lot of [1:23:02] thorns and so there that's it and that would truly that I mean Sean and I talked about this [1:23:08] the other day that would truly from is it Federation Point Washington Federation Point [1:23:12] all the way down to the falls would be awesome. [1:23:15] Right Sean Burger. [1:23:22] So these estimates are based on building out our full standard. [1:23:28] So do we have any ballpark idea on how to estimate a cost for something less? [1:23:38] I don't want to call it primitive, but I think it's like a re-grind compacted trail or something [1:23:45] like that. [1:23:47] And if we don't, you can just tell me no. [1:23:53] So then my other question totally escaped me. [1:23:59] We have another thing about it. [1:24:01] The light went off. [1:24:02] No, they're still, they're still. [1:24:04] I'm assuming. [1:24:06] Like someone's praying. [1:24:07] Someone's praying. [1:24:08] It's not a praying on your first meeting. [1:24:09] Okay. [1:24:10] Okay. [1:24:11] We know where the, up there, you know, it says Quo-Bridge. [1:24:15] That is from our property up on top by Quo-Bridge, heading west. [1:24:19] Okay. [1:24:20] But last year we did pay that section that goes from the Quo-Bridge. [1:24:23] It states down into Derpies Lake. [1:24:26] We pay for the paving, but the developer did pay for the preliminary work. [1:24:30] work, actually, when Ken Stetsman and his company kind of Jack [1:24:35] Hamburg, part of the canyon wall to get down there. [1:24:37] And they did put a road base on that trail. [1:24:41] And if I remember the case, the trail you see was about [1:24:43] low at almost 1,300 linear feet. [1:24:45] And I just don't have those numbers in front of me what it [1:24:48] was prepped with the pace. [1:24:51] It was already too key at paid. [1:24:53] And I think that you kind of remember those prices, $30, $3,000 [1:24:58] for a little bit less than 1,200, [1:25:01] I mean a little less than 1,300 linear feet. [1:25:04] Just to let you know, I did meet with the representative [1:25:06] from Setman Construction to give us an estimate [1:25:09] on the, excuse me, the pillar falls. [1:25:12] Sir, if you've been out there, they have really prepped [1:25:15] a lot of work on that development. [1:25:16] They have kind of hauled dirt in, and they have, [1:25:19] they're ready to put a base and pave on it, [1:25:21] just about pave on it. [1:25:22] So there is some cost savings. [1:25:24] All these estimates were based on a $75 per linear foot [1:25:28] but dark from construction. [1:25:31] Also, I did put in there every canyon rim trail [1:25:34] we built, we had fencing, and it's like every trail, [1:25:37] every five feet, we have another foot of fencing, [1:25:39] so there's some cost of fencing. [1:25:41] If we especially look on pillar falls, [1:25:44] there's gonna be quite a bit of fencing [1:25:45] because that trail really hugs the canyon rim out there. [1:25:49] So, pillar falls is, it's not my turn, [1:25:51] but I don't wanna be clear. [1:25:52] To have a pillar falls is the part from Todd Blass's house [1:25:56] to the corner of Eastland in Poland. [1:25:59] All right, because I noticed what I was going on that corner [1:26:01] the other day, I noticed, well, it looks like it's ready [1:26:04] to be paved or kind of in that direction anyway, [1:26:06] and I didn't realize that it was that close. [1:26:08] Kind of really the trail would get in right at the pole line, [1:26:12] you might say, then there is a section up [1:26:14] that you have to do something sidewalk or temperature [1:26:16] trail to get to Gary Stewart's property, okay. [1:26:22] Thank you. [1:26:23] Chris, do I have to follow up kind of on Sean's question. [1:26:26] I had the same query with your figures, Dennis. [1:26:29] If I had the information correct, 1,300 lineal feet at 75, [1:26:36] we could do a temporary project for between 100 and 130,000. [1:26:41] Is that feasible? [1:26:42] And that's what Mr. [1:26:43] And would that require eventual realignment, [1:26:45] or would we be throwing good money after bad by not being able to? [1:26:49] You're talking about the temporary trail on the PILR return. [1:26:53] but on the permanent location of the meets and bounds. [1:26:57] Yes, they do. [1:26:59] I don't know if I call it the pre-base of the trail [1:27:02] is there. [1:27:03] You probably would have to do something about it. [1:27:04] My question is relating to Mitch's comment that one time [1:27:08] that the permanent trail location may not [1:27:12] be where this current location is. [1:27:16] And I don't think the council would want to throw 100,000 [1:27:18] away if we can't count on that being [1:27:21] the permanent trail and you're talking about the preserved Gary storage property. [1:27:28] The 1300 linear feet were but that is I think that's on the preserve. [1:27:32] No, the preserve is about 7,000 feet that surely goes from the corner of Eastland Pole [1:27:37] line to the area. [1:27:38] Well, where was the 1300 that you were referring to? [1:27:40] That's the part between Todd Blass and the corner of Pole line and Eastland. [1:27:45] That is the permanent location. [1:27:46] Yeah, and originally you can see I kind of chickened and scratched my hand right in there. [1:27:51] I don't know where I got the estimate of $1255 by RGIS, that trail is approximately 2,100 in your feet. [1:27:57] So if you would contract that out completely, my estimate at 75 bucks a linear foot would be 157. [1:28:04] But I just mentioned a lot of that trail does have the dirt base there. [1:28:08] So it's ready to put a base to put the gravel underneath and [1:28:12] paid it if you need to be. [1:28:14] Okay, thank you. [1:28:16] Rebecca Masley. [1:28:17] Thank you, Mayor. [1:28:19] Thank you, Dennis. [1:28:19] I don't have a question just more of a comment, I appreciate you guys coming down for the public hearing and I think that right now kind of one of the comments that Jamie made is really probably part of our first step is getting access to that property and [1:28:34] if you'd like to reach out, I'm sure we can help reach out to that property owner and just ask for a temporary easement for the trail. [1:28:44] But I do think that the money we have appropriated in this year's budget is $20,000 for proper [1:28:52] signage and connection and really trail identification systems, whether it's painting the street, [1:28:59] lines on a street or whether it's posting a sign, but it's also for getting a written [1:29:04] map of brochure out for citizens and for tourists so that they know how to connect the [1:29:10] infrastructure that we do have right now. [1:29:12] So I think that's a good step. [1:29:13] I think that's a good part of the budget [1:29:15] that you actually did have an effect on [1:29:17] because that's why we put it in there for this year. [1:29:21] But I also think we need to look at in the future [1:29:24] the possibility I know we've talked with Fritz [1:29:26] a little bit on whether there's an area for impact fees [1:29:31] to apply to parks and recreation trails [1:29:34] and move forward on that. [1:29:35] Definitely get those projects on that list [1:29:38] so that we can appropriate those funds [1:29:40] to the trail projects because we certainly want to use whatever money is available for [1:29:46] that project. [1:29:47] And I think certainly it's possible in that part as far as using impact fees might take [1:29:52] a little bit of time, but certainly I think within the next one or two years you'll definitely [1:29:58] see progress. [1:29:59] But thank you for bringing that to our attention because I know it's definitely on the hearts [1:30:03] and minds of most of the community and we do need to press forward and focus on it. [1:30:08] So I remember my other question so um so with the [1:30:15] color falls property in particular so the city retained the easement for that when we vacated the [1:30:23] plant that was on it and so we could go build the trail for X number of dollars. Is there a process [1:30:32] says that we could use so that when that does develop, [1:30:38] that we can exact that expense back. [1:30:43] So right now, if I were to develop naturally, [1:30:45] the developer would build the trail and give it to us. [1:30:49] Is there some mechanism that we could get reimbursed, [1:30:53] the cost of that, once that property were to develop? [1:30:57] Getting it back is really difficult. [1:31:00] It's easy when it's a development requirement when they want to do something, but saying, [1:31:05] okay, now you'll have to pay a certain amount of dollars to put in this development. [1:31:10] We don't have a mechanism for that. [1:31:11] Is that something you could research for us, Fritz? [1:31:16] Because I knew exactly where he was going once he got started, and I'm thinking, you [1:31:20] know, some of these other developers are probably going to be just a little bit. [1:31:24] You know, we could, the only thing you could do is make an agreement with the developer [1:31:28] that we would record the agreement, that they would bind any future owners, and I think somebody [1:31:34] just bought it. They would agree that if we do this now, that's an expense they would have [1:31:42] had to pay for their development, and they'll agree that they'll reimburse. [1:31:48] And I'm thinking more so of the pieces that might be built to full pay standards. I'm not [1:31:58] thinking that's so much for the regrind compacted whatever that might get moved [1:32:04] someday or that's on our own properties because a couple of those pieces of the [1:32:09] cities but I was just I was trying to think through if there was some mechanism [1:32:13] for that because again it's sort of turning the process backwards that the [1:32:18] trail is the more critical part let's get it finished and connected and figure [1:32:23] instead of waiting 25 years for the development to occur out there yeah so [1:32:28] So if you could resources, because I have the same feeling and more of a fairness issue, [1:32:35] I think we require every other developer a longer to build the trail, then we go build [1:32:40] it for somebody else. [1:32:41] I don't think if I was one of those developers, I feel very good about it, so that's one of [1:32:48] the thought process. [1:32:49] At least explore what our options might be, and if it's only to get an agreement with [1:32:53] them, build it at a days cost that they're going to be five years down the road, we're [1:32:58] It's probably saving our money in the long run. [1:33:00] It's going to be an interest-free loan to get it done now, [1:33:04] plus the community, you know, good feeling [1:33:07] that they've helped the community going into the situation. [1:33:11] I've probably asked all of what you were going to say. [1:33:13] Well, that's exactly what I was going to say. [1:33:15] I would hope there's some kind of mechanism [1:33:16] to be reimbursed somehow. [1:33:18] But it can only help the developer, [1:33:21] because being built today with the costs of today, [1:33:26] things aren't getting any cheaper. [1:33:27] I've noticed. [1:33:29] And so what it's going to cost today in lieu of five to 10 [1:33:32] years down the road, and also it makes that piece of property [1:33:35] more marketable, in my opinion, as well. [1:33:39] So I'm going to hit on what I was going to say. [1:33:42] So just a final comment I would make. [1:33:47] We've heard a lot about the trails this last year [1:33:50] through our strategic planning process, [1:33:52] through land use issues that we've [1:33:56] dealt with about how much people appreciate the value that those trails give our community. [1:34:04] I think that for a couple hundred thousand dollar investment that we might leave set aside in [1:34:11] the budget to then partner with this group and others I think with in kind like we saw [1:34:19] saw done when the Centennial Trail was built, I think we could actually get the miles of these [1:34:27] trails connected in some fashion that would be safe and beneficial for the community. [1:34:33] And I don't know what the appropriate mechanism is for that, but what I would love to see, [1:34:41] I support the wellness program and leaving some funds in for that. [1:34:45] But really if we could sort of commit the balance of those funds, [1:34:49] which is about the $208,000 toward trail enhancement projects, [1:34:54] in partnership with whoever else we can find, [1:34:58] but to actually complete something instead of piecemeal it, [1:35:03] I think it's what our citizens have been asking us for [1:35:06] through this entire strategic planning process. [1:35:09] And it's a benefit to the health initiative that we have [1:35:13] in our strategic plan. [1:35:15] And to be perfectly honest, it's one of the few groups that actually came and spoke to us [1:35:20] through this lengthy, lengthy budget process. [1:35:26] Susanne Hawkins, then Rebecca Masley. [1:35:28] Thank you. [1:35:29] I love the idea of working on the trails and I support working on that, [1:35:33] but I do have another thought for a small slice of that pie, I guess, for lack of a better word. [1:35:41] Working with the Youth Council, one of the areas we've been really struggling with is recruiting [1:35:47] and maintaining membership with the Youth Council and looking at the other clubs that [1:35:54] we're competing against for the youth's time, it looks to me like the one thing we're missing [1:35:58] with our group is a chance for a scholarship when they complete our program. One of our [1:36:04] other focus areas is on a learning community and we've talked in depth about helping encourage [1:36:12] our youth to go on past high school, to get a college education. [1:36:16] And I know that with the CSI scholarship foundation, this might be a chance for us to start a base [1:36:22] program so every year we can award a scholarship to one of our graduating seniors who meets certain [1:36:28] criteria. [1:36:29] I don't think it has to be a large scholarship, but I think offering that would be rewarding [1:36:36] to our students, it would be encouraging them continuing on with their education, but it [1:36:42] It also could be used as a recruiting tool to maybe interest other kids into joining our [1:36:46] youth council. [1:36:47] And so I'd just like to throw that out for the council to think about too. [1:36:50] Okay. [1:36:51] Thank you, Suzanne. [1:36:52] Rebecca Massega. [1:36:53] Thank you, Mayor. [1:36:54] I just wanted to comment on Councilman Berger's idea, you know, I support it and just I would [1:37:01] add to it that we try to take the steps necessary to use impact fees. [1:37:09] I mean, these are fees that developers are already paying, [1:37:12] have already paid, and they do expire, [1:37:14] and so if we don't use them, we can't use them. [1:37:17] So, you know, I mean, I understand there's a process [1:37:21] for getting those projects added, [1:37:22] and it may take some time, but I would hope [1:37:25] that we would first try to do that [1:37:26] and try to utilize some funds from there as well. [1:37:31] So, the question I always have is I think I'm getting [1:37:35] a fairly good consensus that the group would like to leave [1:37:39] that those funds in the budget and so is our what do you think our best [1:37:47] course forward is rather than try to slice them up now but is there a way just [1:37:52] just to leave it way it is and just put it in and then we can cite later or what [1:37:56] do we have to do alright I think it needs to have a label on it otherwise it's [1:38:06] gonna be further away ten ways not a lot of we choose to make sure we [1:38:12] I'll just want to say it's put a label on it. [1:38:14] I believe on it now. [1:38:35] I love the body language. [1:38:37] Laurie was juckling over there. [1:38:39] Shuffling. [1:38:40] Shuffling. [1:38:41] So what we would ask is clear and define direction from the council in terms of exactly how you [1:38:51] want to see those monies shifted. [1:38:55] It's really, so if you say, if you elect to keep the $30,000 that staff is asking and put [1:39:07] that into a wellness fund, that would be one motion. [1:39:11] We have a wellness line item set up in HR already. [1:39:15] The balance would be $208,000 and that you could take that $208,000 and you could shift [1:39:25] that some to a scholarship. [1:39:27] You could shift that to trails. [1:39:29] You could shift that to a topic that you haven't talked about. [1:39:33] The movement to the scholarship is just moving it [1:39:38] from a collection of line items in the general fund [1:39:43] under a, we've probably put it under contract and services [1:39:47] for the youth scholarship. [1:39:50] The rest would be a shift into the capital improvement fund. [1:39:56] And my recommendation is we're ready for you to move forward. [1:40:01] We will make all of the notes. [1:40:03] Lori and her team can go back and modify this document. [1:40:09] We could recess and go into our second portion [1:40:14] of the executive session that you've [1:40:16] talked about doing. [1:40:17] Upon completion of that executive session, [1:40:20] you could reconvene and have a good ordinance that is ready to go. [1:40:28] We think that it takes a little bit more time, [1:40:31] but we think that is the absolute cleanest process. [1:40:34] And then we can take that ordinance that you have seen, [1:40:38] that you voted on, and we can take that and submit our L2 [1:40:41] form, and we could publish it in the paper [1:40:43] in accordance with law so that everybody is clear in terms [1:40:46] of what that looks like. [1:40:49] This is the reason why we want to do this, [1:40:53] as opposed to waiting until the 11th, midnight hours. [1:40:55] We're going to ask you for a little bit more time now, [1:40:58] but it still gives us the opportunity [1:41:00] to make sure that what we do tonight, we got right. [1:41:03] And if we happen to have an error, [1:41:05] we can always come back and say, [1:41:07] we need you to reconsider whatever that is the following week, [1:41:11] where at some point in time, it's too late. [1:41:15] So in other words, we need to make a little sausage right now. [1:41:17] We would like you to make the sausage. [1:41:18] John Berger, Chris, John, they were in rapid order, [1:41:22] but I think he got John and then Chris and then Rebecca. [1:41:25] So I think for the sake of maybe trying [1:41:27] to make this as least confusing as possible, [1:41:30] let's take them one piece of time. [1:41:33] So I would make a motion that we allocate $30,000 [1:41:40] to the employee homeless program. [1:41:42] Second. [1:41:44] I'm going to find something for some of us here. [1:41:47] Yeah, I've been moved by Sean Berger and seconded by Don Hall that we moved $30,000 into the [1:41:53] employee wellness section wherever that may be. In HR. In HR. In HR, okay. And we have any [1:42:02] discussion on that particular thing? Chris talking? Not on that. Okay. All right. I see no other [1:42:08] lights. So that I assume we're ready for a real call vote. Sean Berger. Yes. Don Hall. Yes. [1:42:15] Susan Hawkins yes Greg Lansing yes Jim on yes Rebecca Mills like a yes Chris [1:42:21] talking yes yes [1:42:22] passes seven to zero did you want to do the second one or at least what so these [1:42:26] other lights I'd like to go for it Chris was like was next I would move to [1:42:33] utilize the remaining approximately two hundred and eight thousand dollars in a [1:42:38] dedicated Twin Falls Canyon Rim Trail system project for 2014 application. [1:42:46] Second. [1:42:47] Okay. [1:42:48] So moved by Chris Teigen, seconded by Sean Berger to move the remaining 208,000 into a dedicated [1:42:57] trail improvement fund that... [1:42:59] A Canyon Rim. [1:43:00] Canyon Rim. [1:43:01] Canyon Rim. [1:43:02] We're good at the trail improvement fund. [1:43:05] My only question then, I'll give you the discussion, I guess, and then Susanne's lights [1:43:08] on, so it's done. That doesn't leave me for a scholarship. So I assume for the maker, the [1:43:17] motion maker that he's not planning on any money for a scholarship. No, that wasn't my [1:43:22] motion. Okay. Suzanne Hawkins. I guess I'd just like to discuss it further. I think that, [1:43:29] you know, we have a fair amount of money there and I do want to see the trails worked on, but [1:43:34] I don't want to leave our youth out of this. I think they're a big portion of our future. [1:43:38] We've discussed too much the need to encourage kids to continue their education. [1:43:43] We have a great system here with the college to work with them on this and I think it would [1:43:47] be a great tool to use and it would show our youth that we do believe in them as well. [1:43:53] I believe we have the lawyer wants the way our attorneys use me. [1:43:57] My question was can we even do that? [1:44:03] When you think of a scholarship in a traditional sense it looks like a gift to a private person [1:44:07] which we can do. So unless we can think of another way to do it, I mean a scholarship [1:44:17] does not work. So we would have to do it in a different way. Well, I mean when Travis [1:44:23] mentioned contracted services but I don't, there would be some sort of service but then [1:44:28] there wouldn't be, we don't want to get into employee issues. So I'm not, I guess we need [1:44:35] some time to think about how that might work and I know we're making sausage here but I think [1:44:39] we're going a little fast. Okay. All right. And the one suggestion that we do have reserves [1:44:46] that we may be able to do a small thing if a plan forward isn't come up with I think we [1:44:51] do those reserves we possibly have as well at some point this year. I'm not saying we would [1:44:58] but I think there's money there we don't have to take a skim a thousand here or whatever [1:45:03] to make that work. [1:45:04] I don't know. [1:45:05] You know, that's the exact question I was going to ask, is if we can even do that because [1:45:10] you're giving money to an individual and it's not like under a MPOG where we give money [1:45:17] to organizations that do like services and all those kind of dynamics. [1:45:22] So I was really concerned and what I was going to say is I think we just need a little more [1:45:26] time to vet that out. [1:45:27] I'm in full support of trying to figure out something to do for our youth and some kind [1:45:31] scholarship, but I don't know if this is the best mechanism for you. [1:45:34] You're right. [1:45:35] But in POG, the way you really need to think about that, they perform a service for us that [1:45:39] we might perform ourselves. [1:45:40] We might do. [1:45:41] So we need to figure out a way to think about the youth council in that way. [1:45:44] Right. [1:45:45] Right. [1:45:46] And maybe there's some kind of opportunity for some private funding to do something like [1:45:50] that, Suzanne. [1:45:51] I just wanted to give it a little more time and thought because this is the first I've heard [1:45:54] of it tonight. [1:45:58] Okay. [1:45:59] The motion on the floor is to dedicate the other $208,000 towards a Kenya. [1:46:03] the Canyon Rim Trail system so you know why oh Travis did you have a comment just [1:46:15] for clarification as we modify this the motion would take the two hundred eight [1:46:22] thousand dollars and it would place it into the capital improvement fund for [1:46:27] this year with a line item for Canyon Rim Trail improvements and development and [1:46:34] I think that's the, I think that's the, uh, wish of the, what I heard you made, Donald. [1:46:41] I just wanted to add that I, I'm going to be in support of this motion, but, uh, in no way [1:46:47] do I support that we just now can go spend it all. [1:46:50] I think that we need to do it wisely. [1:46:52] We might not end up spending all of it. [1:46:54] I, I love the opportunity of working in partnership with other funders and, and sweat equity [1:46:59] and all that stuff. [1:47:00] I mean, that's, that's private, public funds coming together, which is what we should [1:47:04] be doing more of so again I don't want to send the message to the public that we [1:47:08] now we have two hundred eight thousand dollars we're going to dedicate it right [1:47:10] to the the trail that's there if the opportunity and it makes sense to us to [1:47:16] to do that. I'm reminded of the big hands in our strategic plan that talk [1:47:24] about the partners that we need for this and I think this is a excellent trial [1:47:29] run at a partnership program to try to stretch those dollars as far as we [1:47:35] possibly can and preferably leave some of them there when we're done, but complete the [1:47:40] trail in a fashion that serves a means of community. So while that doesn't need to be laid [1:47:46] out in the ordinance, that is the spirit, certainly what I'm talking about. I think we can get there. [1:47:52] Well, I just like to say in defense of my embattled motion that the intent is not to be [1:47:59] a spend-through up to be a person who's using their money wisely. I don't think anybody [1:48:04] this council is going to say we have to spend it all and I don't think we should be [1:48:08] filled with like we're trapped in a corner where we have to make a move. This is a [1:48:13] one-time a unique opportunity for us perhaps to get some link up of some [1:48:18] component parts and make it more of an integrated hole. I have asking whether [1:48:24] 208 is going to do the problem, solve the problem in that area that we're [1:48:28] looking at but I'm most concerned about frittering this money away in the six [1:48:33] different directions in a year from now not being able to recall how we invested any of it for the [1:48:39] public. So let's try to make this really count. And I think with all these sharp lines on the council, [1:48:44] we can do it. I have no additional lights. Lee, I have a roll call though. Don Hall. Yes. Suzanne Hawkins. Yes. Greg [1:48:56] Yes. Jim Mun. Yes. Rebecca Mills-Suega. Yes. Chris [1:49:00] Talkington. Yes. Sean Burger. Yes. Seven zero zero. See it does it does work to come to council. [1:49:06] We talked to this one. We haven't spent a [1:49:09] setup again. You know. All right. The other any other additional questions and [1:49:18] or thoughts about the the total budget we're we're we're gonna send them off to [1:49:25] to come back with an ordinance that we need, that we need the best any saucy, the other [1:49:29] saucy that needs to be made, needs to be made now though because they're going to go do the [1:49:33] ordinance. So we're making those like it. [1:49:35] Thank you, Mayor. I would like to discuss part of the budget message was about some of [1:49:41] our most significant increases in operations were due to increases in professional contract [1:49:47] services. So I have really considered the fact that the municipal cost index and the consumer [1:49:54] price index have been 1.9%. So really if we aren't getting a new service or an enhanced [1:50:01] service, I really don't see why we would have or allow any increase above 1.9%. So I'm just [1:50:10] going to throw out their emotion to restrict professional service contract increases to [1:50:16] a maximum of 1.9%, which is the MCI and CPI for 2013. [1:50:22] I'll second that. I believe motion should have their fair day and chance for a discussion [1:50:30] of the council. So that's the second any further discussion seen them. They don't roll [1:50:44] vote on the amendment. Susan Hawkins. No. They're glancing. No. Jim. No. Rebecca Mills-Reidkah. [1:50:53] Yes. Chris talking to. No. Sean Burger. No. Don Hoch. No. Motion passes. There fails [1:51:02] to six. Any other comments or thoughts on the budget? See, we're going to reconvene into [1:51:13] executive session and allow our financial staff to time to prepare the ordinance. And so we're [1:51:21] adjourned to executive session. [1:51:22] We need to do some kind of a trail across those sleeping stands and pavements. Do we have [1:51:38] access? Well, Lane Rancis down there, though. We'll be in between the two, so they can jump [1:51:47] the highway there. This race. I'm sorry I got out kind of confused and turned things on. [1:51:59] I got to turn my, I was turning left. Does Travis have the ordinance? You open in [1:52:06] this back. Oh, good idea. Re convene the August 19th, 2013 Twin Falls City Council meeting. [1:52:17] That was brought by them. [1:52:23] Do we have an ordinance number? [1:52:24] So moved. [1:52:27] 3055. [1:52:32] This will be need to be a third and final [1:52:34] and all those good things. [1:52:44] We just do it. [1:52:45] Mr. Mayor, members, council, do you want us to walk through [1:52:47] for a comparative purposes of the changes that we made? [1:52:50] Sure. [1:52:51] For the record. [1:52:52] Real quick. [1:52:53] We'll see what the different changes are. [1:52:55] At least in a generalized fashion. [1:52:56] Generalized fashion. [1:52:57] I think we know what they are. [1:52:58] So if you take a look at the ordinance that was included, [1:53:02] and then you take a look at the ordinance [1:53:04] that has been presented, you can see some of the differences. [1:53:08] There are going to be those that are the tax-supported funds, [1:53:11] which are going to be the general fund, the street fund, [1:53:13] the streetlight fund, library fund, airport fund, [1:53:16] and capital improvement fund. [1:53:18] And you'll see what we've done as we've shifted the $208,000 [1:53:24] from those collective funds for health care insurance, [1:53:27] and we've lumped that into the capital improvement fund. [1:53:30] The $30,000 remained in HR, and it's just been shifted, so we took health care savings [1:53:40] also, and we shifted that into a single line. [1:53:43] That constitutes the two changes that were made on the work. [1:53:46] Bottom line is still the same. [1:53:48] Yes, sir. [1:53:50] D'Nertane, the motion is done, all. [1:53:51] Mayor, I would move that we place Ordinance 3055, right? [1:53:55] Right. [1:53:56] on third and final by title only and suspend the rules. [1:54:01] Second. [1:54:02] Been moved by Don Call and seconded by Chris Tockington [1:54:06] that we place Ordinance 3055 on third and final. [1:54:09] By title only, he's spending the rules. [1:54:11] It's got a further long title, so when we get to that point, [1:54:13] well, I'll get to read a little bit today. [1:54:16] All right, I have no light for discussion, [1:54:19] so the ailer won't call vote on the third and final motion. [1:54:23] Greg Lanthane? [1:54:23] Yes. [1:54:24] Jim Mon? [1:54:25] Rebecca Mills-Weica. Yes. Chris talking to Sean Baraker. Yes. Don Hall. Yes. Suzanne [1:54:32] Hawkins. Yes. Busch past seven to zero. Lila. Lila. Lila. Lila. Lila. Lila. Lila. Lila. [1:54:40] Would you read the title of the ordinance? In the ordinance of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho, [1:54:45] appropriating $52,937,917 for the 2014 fiscal year, did defray all necessary expenses and [1:54:58] liabilities of the City of Twin Falls, providing for the objects and purposes for which such [1:55:03] appropriations are made, and the amount appropriated for each object or purpose. [1:55:09] adding for LORUM taxes and the amount of $17,286,791 for the 2014 fiscal year. [1:55:20] Providing that a copy of this ordinance shall be filed within the county commissioners of Twin Falls County, Idaho, and [1:55:26] with the Secretary of State at the State of Idaho. [1:55:29] Providing forward this ordinance to take effect upon its passage approval and publication according to law. [1:55:35] The rule requiring that an ordinance be read on three separate occasions have been having [1:55:40] been suspended. [1:55:41] Thank you. [1:55:43] I live in the next order of business with the emotion. [1:55:46] John. [1:55:47] Move approval of ordinance 3055 second it been moved by Sean Berger and seconded by Susan [1:55:54] Hawkins that we just one second here I need to do my book work here first right. [1:56:04] Rebecca. [1:56:05] Thank you. [1:56:06] I just want to make some comments on the budget. [1:56:08] I've appreciated the conversations that we've had for the past several months. [1:56:13] And I think that there's a lot in this budget that I really can support the increase funding [1:56:19] for roads, the water redundancy, and the quality of life things like the trails and [1:56:25] the dog park and the community garden. [1:56:28] But we've also had conversations about things that I'm a little bit concerned about. [1:56:35] And we've talked about the significant increases in the city manager budget, [1:56:40] especially just the $46,000 for personnel training, which I certainly support personnel training. [1:56:47] But at that amount, there's got to be an outcome that the citizens are getting for that investment. [1:56:53] And I have to ask myself will the outcome be different or [1:56:57] would it be different if we put it towards something else? [1:57:02] I'm still a little bit concerned about that. [1:57:06] Also the three patrol positions, I appreciate the police department and [1:57:11] what they do. [1:57:12] They're doing a fabulous job because the crime rate is down, the calls for service are down. [1:57:17] But without data, any sort of data to support that appropriation, it's difficult to support. [1:57:26] And I know it's dependent on the COPS grant, but even so, [1:57:30] we're paying three-fourths of the cost. [1:57:35] There's the vehicles that we're spending $18,000 more on [1:57:42] that we don't have to, and on top of that, [1:57:44] the fuel savings that we could get. [1:57:47] I'm sure you all noticed the fuel bill this month [1:57:49] was $31,000, and we're just gonna have to take [1:57:55] purposeful measured steps towards, [1:57:57] you know, towards managing that because towards the future the cost of fuel is not [1:58:05] going down and we'll definitely need to find waste to find savings and then of [1:58:12] course there's the the code enforcement fee in sanitation the sanitation fee [1:58:18] increase and the contract increases so so I'm a little bit conflicted but I [1:58:25] I think overall this is a good budget but as we've had our discussions and I respect that [1:58:31] it's not the majority will of the council but I still feel very strongly about having a [1:58:36] conservative budget and there's just those areas where I really feel like we're not being [1:58:42] as conservative and saving as much as we could. [1:58:46] Mr. Steiden. [1:58:47] Well that's about the 21st or 22nd time I forget that I've gone through a city budgeting [1:58:51] process and I am of the further firm conviction this time of any year I've witnessed that city [1:59:01] government works unlike state and national government. [1:59:06] We work directly for the people and this document shows with our 2030 strategic plan ready to [1:59:13] be implemented by the adoption of this budget that we're working in the taxpayers best interest. [1:59:20] We are one of the most frugal cities in the state on a per capita, per employee basis, on [1:59:25] a property tax per 1,000 of assessed valuation. [1:59:31] And I'm immensely happy that we have planned now for the next 25 years with expansion of [1:59:40] the wastewater plant with an astounding 68 percent voter approval. [1:59:46] With respect to my colleague to the left and there are always savings we can make. [1:59:51] This is a damn good business plan that we put into effect that I think we're providing [1:59:57] pretty good value for the money and I'm glad to be a part of this. [2:00:02] And although there are always ways we could spend more money, I'm not sure cutting edges [2:00:07] around some of these projects are going to give us the bang for the buck that we're going [2:00:12] to see in the next couple years. [2:00:14] This is a big budget, $53 million, but we're also a town that's 45 going on $70,000. [2:00:22] We owe it to the taxpayers to think ahead. [2:00:24] That's what they pay us the big bucks for. [2:00:26] Thank you, Chris. [2:00:30] I would like to thank the staff and all of them have chosen to go home and I appreciate [2:00:35] that. [2:00:36] We had them here every night for most of this budget process and they certainly answered [2:00:42] any email that I sent because I usually haven't. [2:00:44] I didn't ask most of my questions in open, I asked them in private and to find out information [2:00:51] about a particular item and if I was satisfied, I would satisfy it. [2:00:56] But I'd like to thank everyone on the staff who worked diligently on this budget, I'd [2:01:01] like to echo what Chris said, this is my eighth budget and my confidence in this budget is the [2:01:08] the highest of those eight without a doubt. [2:01:11] That we have spent the money wisely [2:01:14] and that we have provided a blueprint for the future [2:01:18] for the city of Twin Falls and the Lake Chris said, [2:01:21] that's our job. [2:01:22] It's not to cut pennies now, [2:01:23] but to look to the future and make sure we have. [2:01:26] And if I could find the money, [2:01:28] I'd add 10 more officers. [2:01:29] Cause I think that's one of the places [2:01:31] we're still dramatically short, [2:01:33] is on our number of police officers. [2:01:36] And so that's something that I'm, you know, [2:01:38] it's gonna be working forward. [2:01:40] And I think I would have the support of the community [2:01:42] that they wanna feel safe, [2:01:45] and that's one of the places we can help me feel safe. [2:01:47] So I'm proud of this one, [2:01:48] and I will definitely be voting yes on it. [2:01:52] Anyone else? [2:01:54] Seeing none, the other roll call vote. [2:01:57] Jim Munn. [2:01:58] Yes. [2:01:59] Rebecca Masleka. [2:02:00] No. [2:02:01] Chris Tocquentin. [2:02:02] Yes. [2:02:04] Sean Baraker. [2:02:05] Yes. [2:02:06] Don Hall. [2:02:07] enthusiastically yes Suzanne Hawkins yes Greg Lansing yes motion passes six to [2:02:15] one and we'll start on this again about next March right so yeah so I we are as [2:02:25] far as I know we have covered all of their business for tonight oh Chris [2:02:29] talking I'm sorry Sean has radio and [2:02:37] Suzanne and TV Mexico we have to seal the pilots [2:02:41] only the budgets [2:02:45] so that the state tax commission and the treasure all know what [2:02:49] we're doing we don't do others that way [2:02:57] I assume that the treasure I didn't know oh yeah the [2:03:01] L2 alright we're adjourned [2:03:08] I think we've got the chamber 115.