Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2013-07-01, recording 1 (started 17:00) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2013-07-01/ [0:00:16] I don't know what you wanted to do with those. [0:00:30] Two day hot to get excited about anything. [0:00:33] One of my horrible mistakes, almost before. [0:00:37] Yeah, I got it. [0:00:39] I just forgot. [0:00:40] I'm not going to tell you what. [0:00:42] Oh, you should. [0:00:43] I think. [0:00:52] Good. [0:01:11] You see anything pertinent? [0:01:27] I see business at 1138 zoning bill. [0:01:30] They told us, you know, [0:01:32] Which says we're okay. [0:01:34] Okay. [0:01:36] Okay. [0:01:38] Okay. [0:01:55] Jim Smallwood, seniors building. [0:01:57] Yes. [0:02:05] I need to buy first. [0:02:07] Meeting of the Twin Falls City Council. [0:02:09] Our first item of business as usual is the pledge. [0:02:12] If you'd like to go, please stand. [0:02:17] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. [0:02:32] Confirm that we do have a full form, all seven members are here, introduction of staff. [0:02:40] City Manager, Travis Roth, Hunter City Attorney, Fritz Wunderlich, Deputy City Clerk, [0:02:45] recording Secretary, Leila Sanchez, and we do have several other members of staff here to help us on some of the items. [0:02:52] It appears that the radio is using this week to honor this. [0:02:57] It is reminded me on July 11th. [0:02:59] I have rising change and I think I'm going to have to look at my calendar. [0:03:05] All right, next time it's considerations of amendments, Travis, do you have one? [0:03:12] I have one, do you have any? [0:03:14] I have the one that you asked me to put on there, but if you want to cover it, Mr. Boyad, [0:03:18] you can, members of the Council, the Mayor would like to ask the Council to convene into [0:03:24] to an executive session under 67, two, three, four, five, [0:03:29] the subsection B as in boy, [0:03:32] which is the evaluation dismissal or to hear [0:03:37] issues or complaints section of the executive court. [0:03:42] I've got the whole list here, but this, [0:03:44] we have the work. [0:03:47] Council wishes on the amendment. [0:03:50] Move to. [0:03:51] Good. [0:03:52] Good. [0:03:53] Get on. [0:03:55] Chris is moved, we have a second to ask. [0:03:57] We'll move by Chris and then second by Sean that we add the executive session to our agenda. [0:04:06] See no lights. [0:04:07] I have a roll call vote. [0:04:09] Sean Berriger. [0:04:10] Yes. [0:04:11] Don Hall. [0:04:12] Yes. [0:04:13] Susan Hawkins. [0:04:14] Yes. [0:04:15] Greg Lantine. [0:04:16] Yes. [0:04:17] Jim Munn. [0:04:18] Yes. [0:04:19] Rebecca Nelsweka. [0:04:20] Yes. [0:04:21] Yes. [0:04:22] Yes. [0:04:23] We'll place that time for many non-the-on-eight there if we don't have time we'll have to come back [0:04:25] afterwards. [0:04:26] public hearing to do that okay um no proclamation tonight moving on to the council wishes on the consent calendar [0:04:38] second then moved by jim mudd and seconded by don hall to approve the consent that are [0:04:44] as published uh see no lights the other row cover don hall yes sees that hawkins yes great [0:04:51] Yes, Jim. Yes, Rebecca. Yes, yes, yes, John Berger. Yes, [0:04:57] passes seven to zero. [0:05:00] Moving on to item number one on the items, consideration, [0:05:05] consideration over request by Melinda Anderson, the economic [0:05:08] development director to approve the grand opening event. [0:05:14] Yes. [0:05:17] Look at my face. [0:05:18] I don't have to be either of it. [0:05:20] All right, item number one, [0:05:23] consideration of request to appoint Sarah Taylor [0:05:25] to a three year term beginning July 1st, 2013, [0:05:29] and as part of June 30th, 2016 to the City of Twin Falls, [0:05:34] Berber and Renewal Agency Board [0:05:36] were the option of renewing for a second three year term. [0:05:39] Wouldn't it? [0:05:40] The other one started out right, [0:05:41] to have the right person that just didn't provide them. [0:05:44] Thank you, Mayor and Council. [0:05:48] As you all probably know, Gary Garnand term, two full terms, actually plus a little extra [0:05:56] seven-year term ended yesterday, officially. [0:05:59] So back in April, the city began the process of advertising for folks who were interested [0:06:07] in serving on the Urban Renewal Board for a three-year term with an option to have a [0:06:13] second three-year term. We ran several PSAs and got the word out to a lot of [0:06:20] different groups and we received two letters of interest. The interview panel [0:06:27] which consisted of the mayor, the vice mayor who was also the liaison to Urban [0:06:34] Hill Don Hall as well as Vice Urban Hill Vice Chairman Cindy Bond and [0:06:39] and myself interviewed the two candidates. [0:06:42] And the panel made a recommendation [0:06:46] for the mayor to appoint with your approval, [0:06:49] Sarah Taylor to the Urban Renewal Board [0:06:52] for that three year term. [0:06:56] I, and I'll certainly let, [0:06:58] would suggest that the mayor, Vice Mayor, [0:07:00] make any comments if they're interested, [0:07:01] but Sarah has been a long time resident [0:07:06] of the city, she lives in the city of Twin Falls. [0:07:08] She's very engaged in, especially in downtown. [0:07:12] She and her family have run the Cirque Ballroom [0:07:14] for a number of years and continue to do so. [0:07:18] Basically, we're asking that the interview panel [0:07:22] recommends that the Council approve Sarah [0:07:25] be appointed to the city. [0:07:26] A Quinn Falls or Greenville Agency Board, [0:07:28] and if you were interested in talking with Sarah, [0:07:30] she is in here tonight. [0:07:32] Dave, her back is like you, my first man, Don Hall. [0:07:36] Thank you, Mayor. [0:07:37] I was just curious, Melinda, who was your other applicant? [0:07:39] Joe and then Gabe Austin. [0:07:41] All right, thank you. [0:07:43] Don't know. [0:07:44] No, I was just going to say about Sarah. [0:07:46] I don't know if I've been to an open house [0:07:48] or something that the city has put on, [0:07:52] asking for public input where Sarah and others haven't been [0:07:58] there. [0:07:58] And she always brings a fresh perspective. [0:08:02] I like to be around people that make me think differently, [0:08:06] get myself out of my box a little bit and she certainly does that and so I'm [0:08:10] very very excited about her coming on the urban renewal agency. She interviewed [0:08:15] well and I think she's the right choice. [0:08:17] I provide us with a little youth as well to you know as us some of us what do you think? [0:08:23] What do you think? [0:08:24] Sneaking or 60s here. [0:08:26] Sometimes I get a different like Don said a fresh perspective and she [0:08:30] certainly provided that in like he said great interview. [0:08:35] I think so. I got a polar light, Chris, document? [0:08:37] Well, though I know, Sarah, I would like to ask her a question or two if she could come up. [0:08:45] This is known as the Christot King Grilling. [0:08:48] So, be ready. [0:08:50] I'm thinking as I got here, I'm just happy to be here for a reason instead of just for fun and curiosity. [0:08:56] Fine, then you won't mind these 45 questions. [0:09:00] I do concur, I think, for once the mayor and vice mayor got their act together and got their right person. [0:09:07] Sarah, the number of sudden, probably the majority of us on the council are intensely not only [0:09:14] interested in but almost to the point of demanding that urban renewal proceed yesterday with the [0:09:21] renovation of downtown, specifically in the wet renovation of the water lines, streets, [0:09:30] sidewalks. [0:09:32] is kind of underway, but there have been a few obstacles unforeseen show up in their way, [0:09:38] but I want to ensure before I gave you my one of seven votes that that is also your highest priority. [0:09:45] Absolutely. I don't know if I can give you one word answer, but yes. [0:09:50] Can you ask some tough questions, though, like why we haven't proceeded up to this point, [0:09:55] or what's next in the action line? I think that you have to be a leader in the urban renewal [0:10:01] and direct and focus and drive beyond just getting together once a month and meeting. [0:10:07] Yeah, I think that's why I'm excited to step into this role because I've been trying to [0:10:14] do my part from the citizen side of things, you know, being involved and asking the questions [0:10:19] and responding to inquiries and surveys and doing everything that I can to be part of the [0:10:25] discussion, you know, the strategic planning, you know, adding my two cents to that, you [0:10:29] just doing what I can on the community side, so now being able to step into the board member [0:10:36] side of things with the board that may potentially have the ability to make some changes and maybe [0:10:43] have some funding available to make some changes, I would love to be on that side of things [0:10:49] to add my thoughts and feedback. [0:10:51] So if there's not progress made on the renovation at downtown Twin Falls, the old site in the [0:10:57] three years I probably won't vote for your renewal okay is that a fair deal [0:11:01] absolutely and likewise you'll have my one of seven votes [0:11:05] I was just gonna add I think Chris's thoughts here are right on track that I [0:11:17] think that the urban renewal board has really made an emphasis downtown as you [0:11:22] can see some of the businesses moving down there but Chris is right some of the [0:11:25] renovation, some of the infrastructure which we're trying to address. [0:11:30] This is a good time for you to come in and give your input because we are moving that direction [0:11:35] and we do have some funding for us to be able to do that so Mayor and expect, yeah we need [0:11:41] to expand that area so that we can utilize those funds in that area. [0:11:45] That's what kind of helps back a little bit. [0:11:47] So Mayor if there are no other lights, I would like to make the motion. [0:11:51] I would move approval of Sarah Taylor to be appointed to a three-year term July 1st 2013 [0:11:58] and expiring June 30th 2016 to this city of Twin Falls Urban Renewal Agency Board with the [0:12:05] option of renewing for a second third year or three-year term. [0:12:09] Rebecca's like did you come up for the second or two? [0:12:12] Okay, so it's been moved by Don Hall and seconded by Rebecca Mill-Slica to approve Sarah for [0:12:18] of the three year term, seeing no additional likes. [0:12:21] Lay other roll call vote. [0:12:23] Susan Hawkins. [0:12:24] Yes. [0:12:24] Greg Lansing. [0:12:25] Yes. [0:12:25] Jim Munn. [0:12:26] Yes. [0:12:26] Rebecca Milsica. [0:12:27] Yes. [0:12:29] Chris Talkington. [0:12:29] Yes. [0:12:30] Sean Berriger. [0:12:31] Yes. [0:12:31] Don Hall. [0:12:32] Yes. [0:12:33] 7-0. [0:12:34] Welcome, Sarah. [0:12:37] Moving on to item number two, a consideration of a request [0:12:40] to a reappoint Randall Watson to the Twin Falls City [0:12:43] Historic Preservation Commission to serve a three year term [0:12:46] beginning July 1st, 2013, [0:12:49] expiring June 30th, 2016. [0:12:52] Mitch Humble has listed on this. [0:12:54] Oh, there he is. [0:12:55] I didn't see Mitch. [0:12:56] Okay. [0:12:56] Rand Randall is in the audience for questions. [0:12:59] Another board appointment we have here tonight. [0:13:01] This is a reappointment. [0:13:02] Randall's been on the sort preservation commission [0:13:05] for three years now. [0:13:06] For the last year that he's been the chairman [0:13:08] of the commission. [0:13:09] He does a great job. [0:13:10] He comes to the meeting to participate. [0:13:12] He even comes to the Saturday, you know, [0:13:14] walk-a-thons that we have downtown and stuff like that. [0:13:16] So Mayor Hall, I'm sorry, Mayor Lanting, former Mayor Hall, [0:13:23] the liaison to the HBC, and I have discussed the reappointment. [0:13:28] And we are all recommending that Rand will be reappointed [0:13:30] for a three-year term beginning today, [0:13:32] and for three years until June 30th of 2016. [0:13:37] So I don't, on the HBC, we actually [0:13:39] had two other terms expired at the end of the month, [0:13:43] and one designation that happened in June as well. [0:13:46] or have three vacant seats that we need to fill. [0:13:48] And we've put the word out in a few places, [0:13:51] and we're getting a little sluggish [0:13:52] getting responses there. [0:13:53] So we have a board meeting, I want to say, [0:14:01] very soon, a week or two on a Monday, right? [0:14:04] And if we're going to try to put a quorum together. [0:14:08] So we need to get this re-apointment done at the very [0:14:11] least so we can have a, you know, a four-member quorum [0:14:15] show up to the meeting. [0:14:16] And then we have three vacant seats, [0:14:17] trying to feel as if you know people who might be interested in the historic preservation, [0:14:21] get the word out, and we're looking for interest there. [0:14:26] And I will add to that, I'm sure, Don as well. [0:14:28] This is one of our boards that actually has some decision-making power. [0:14:32] There are some things in downtown that are in the old town, especially in some of those [0:14:37] historic districts. [0:14:38] They actually have some decision-making power. [0:14:40] So if anyone out there were on the web as well as on Channel 17, if you have interest, [0:14:46] to get a hold of Mr. Humble, you want to give him your phone number, your office? [0:14:49] Yeah, 735-7267. [0:14:51] All right. [0:14:52] 735-7267. [0:14:53] Or email at mhumbletfid.org. [0:14:55] Right. [0:14:56] Okay. [0:14:57] And we would like some interested members. [0:15:02] We truly would. [0:15:03] And I think we'll just use this avenue to get the word out a little better or a little [0:15:07] more that we have these openings and it's an important thing. [0:15:13] And yeah, that's what I was laying on this. [0:15:15] One of the funnier ones to be laying on to you. [0:15:17] I mean, they do some interesting things. [0:15:19] It's kind of fun. [0:15:20] So I think you people would enjoy being on it. [0:15:22] And the four people that we have left there [0:15:24] have a lot of passion for this. [0:15:25] And those that were expiring also, [0:15:28] whose terms are expiring also had a lot of passion. [0:15:30] This is a group that really cares about [0:15:32] historic preservation and good group to work with. [0:15:35] All right. [0:15:36] So, I think we should be hitting the all the history teachers [0:15:39] at both high schools and schools. [0:15:41] I was just going to echo what both of you and Mitch said, this is a very important committee [0:15:52] that gives us advice about possibly adding some areas that we can work on in the future [0:16:00] to maintain the historic value of our community. [0:16:03] And some of the events that these folks have had, putting together some of these walking [0:16:07] towards that Mitch has alluded to have been incredibly well attended and informative and [0:16:13] just plain fun. [0:16:15] We've learned a lot about our community and the rich history and I would encourage anyone [0:16:20] that is interested in our community and maintaining that history to come along for a ride because [0:16:27] it is very, very enjoyable committee. [0:16:31] So with that, Mary, I would make another emotion unless there's another light. [0:16:36] I just also wanted to, we talked about the committee, [0:16:39] not so much about you, Randall. [0:16:40] Randall, you've been really an attribute to that committee [0:16:44] and obviously serving as a chairman [0:16:46] and your attendance has been fantastic [0:16:48] and you've been involved in every aspect of it. [0:16:50] So without hesitation, I would make the motion [0:16:55] to real point, Randall Watson, [0:16:57] to the Twin Falls City Historic Preservation Committee [0:16:59] to serve a three-year term beginning July 2013 [0:17:03] and expiring the end of June 2016. [0:17:06] Second. [0:17:07] Second. [0:17:08] Okay. [0:17:09] So that speech by just a second, everybody. [0:17:11] Okay. [0:17:12] Okay. [0:17:13] It's been moved by Don Hall and seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to a real point, Randall Watson, [0:17:20] seeing the lights, Lea, the robo, Greg Lantane, Jim Mon, Rebecca Milsica, Chris Tockington, [0:17:27] Sean Berger, Don Hall, Suzanne Hawkins, yes. [0:17:31] Motion passes 7-0. [0:17:33] Thank you for wanting to serve another three years, [0:17:36] Randall, we appreciate it. [0:17:37] And thank you for your stepping up and being chairman as well. [0:17:41] That's always important. [0:17:43] Okay, moving on. [0:17:44] Item number three, consideration of request [0:17:46] to approve the first community yard sale event [0:17:48] to be held in the city park on Saturday, August 17, 2013. [0:17:54] Staff Sergeant Pollan. [0:17:56] Thank you, Marlin, and council members. [0:17:58] We received a request here a while back [0:18:00] I'm Susan Nickel on behalf of Town Square Media at the Holy Yark [0:18:04] Sell at the Twin Falls City Park on August 17th this year. [0:18:10] The event will run from 6 a.m. in the morning when they start setting up and [0:18:14] go until 5 p.m. that afternoon. [0:18:17] I do know from speaking with Susan and I'd like to mention I work with her on several events [0:18:22] over the last few years and they've always gone very smoothly so I have no concerns about [0:18:26] this whatsoever. [0:18:27] I believe this is the third time they're going to hold a yard select this, be the first time [0:18:33] during Twin Falls, but they've done this before and they've been quite successful in other [0:18:37] communities. [0:18:38] There will be no security required for this, there's no fight in the way, there's no alcohol [0:18:42] or anything like that. [0:18:43] They've estimated about 500 people to attend this event, obviously we have no idea how many [0:18:50] people will attend throughout the entire day, probably more than that, I would imagine. [0:18:55] of our relevant city staff members have met and we've approved this. We don't [0:19:01] see any issues with it whatsoever. [0:19:03] Rebecca, we'll see you. [0:19:06] Thank you there. I just have a question. Is it going to be in a certain section of the park or is it [0:19:12] going to be the entire park? Do you know? [0:19:16] I don't know that. Susan's here if you'd like to ask her. [0:19:20] Yeah, if you wouldn't mind, Susan. [0:19:24] Go ahead. Do you just take your name before? [0:19:26] My name is Susan Nickel. [0:19:27] I'm the life of Vince Manager for Town Square Media and Mayor and Council, thank you for the opportunity to present this event. [0:19:32] In answer to your question, we have, for example, just come off of one in June, we did in Kimberly City Park. [0:19:41] And no, we did not take up the entire park. It is predicated on how many people choose to participate. [0:19:47] I did have 38 garages cleaned out in Kimberly on my last event. [0:19:55] So I would only imagine there would be more than that here in Twin Falls. [0:20:00] However, I get out there with a yardstick and loosely mark out ten by tens so that everybody [0:20:07] has an equal amount of space. [0:20:09] So no, I don't anticipate taking the whole park. [0:20:12] Okay. [0:20:13] Thank you. [0:20:14] I was just curious if it was going to be confined to one area or where you might be setting up. [0:20:17] We'll start with the grassy parts to the east and work our way back toward the bench, I [0:20:23] would imagine. [0:20:25] There are only one or two of the vendors that we're talking to that would like to have electricity. [0:20:31] Most people don't need it at all, they're just showing their lawnmowers and their baby clothes. [0:20:35] But I have a food vendor that needs 110 and I've already kind of scoped out the electrical [0:20:41] situation. [0:20:42] Okay. [0:20:43] Thank you. [0:20:44] Thanks. [0:20:45] Hi. [0:20:46] Hi. [0:20:47] So is this a fundraiser for something? [0:20:49] Do you charge people to set up their tables and do this or what is the scope? [0:20:54] Yes. [0:20:55] Okay. [0:20:56] I can equate this, if I could, too, for example, a couple of weeks ago, I think it was, [0:21:02] Canvieti, the television station did a health and wellness fair in the park. [0:21:06] It's pretty much the same kind of thing. [0:21:08] I charged a very minimal fee for residents to come out and take their booths face, because [0:21:14] I have to cover my costs. [0:21:15] I charge my food vendors and a couple of commercial vendors, obviously, more, because [0:21:21] they're in it to make money. [0:21:23] And whatever I make over my costs goes to my bottom line. [0:21:28] So it is not a non-profit event. [0:21:30] It is very much a for-profit, but I can guarantee you there's not a lot. [0:21:34] Okay. [0:21:35] Thank you. [0:21:36] Mr. Stockton. [0:21:37] You mentioned, Sarah, that, or Susan, that you have a clean-up plan. [0:21:45] We think it's only fair sense, especially you're doing this for a profit, that doesn't [0:21:49] I mean, everything has to be speck and span, but I'm concerned that some of those people may want to leave their unsold garage materials and walk away. [0:21:57] Not an issue. [0:21:58] I'm a slave drive. [0:21:59] They take away things and most of the garbage picked up off the grass, we will hope. [0:22:04] I would say 99.9% of the garbage. [0:22:07] I walk around hourly during my events, no matter where the venue is, with garbage back. [0:22:12] Great. [0:22:13] And I have very good relationships with the people that I work with, even if they're just cleaning out their garage. [0:22:18] happy to be there, they're having a good time, and I have yet to have an issue. [0:22:24] The event is over at three. [0:22:26] I don't leave until we turn out the lights and pick up the last gum wrapper. [0:22:30] Thank you. [0:22:32] Thank you. [0:22:33] I think that looks like all the questions. [0:22:34] Okay. [0:22:35] Thanks. [0:22:36] Council wishes. [0:22:38] I would move to authorize the request of Susan Nichols on behalf of Town Square Media for [0:22:44] the community yard sale in Twin Falls City Park on the Saturday August 17th subject to [0:22:50] of the conditions laid out in the application. [0:22:54] Second. [0:22:55] It's been moved by Chris Stockington [0:22:56] and seconded by Sean Berger to approve the curate sale [0:23:01] as described to us and with the staff recommendations. [0:23:06] Seeing no additional lights, Leanna Rokovov. [0:23:09] Jim Munn. [0:23:10] Yes. [0:23:11] Rebecca Minsuica. [0:23:12] Yes, Chris Tockington. [0:23:13] Yes. [0:23:14] Sean Berger. [0:23:14] Yes. [0:23:15] Don Hall. [0:23:16] Yes. [0:23:17] Suzanne Hopkins. [0:23:18] Yes. [0:23:19] Motion passes seven to zero and number five consideration are quest to waive the admission fees that show shown falls for the American Legion writers [0:23:37] It's interesting to prove the Latin [0:23:41] ecstasy car show event to be held on Saturday June 20 July 27 2013 [0:23:46] May 8th, a.m. to 9 p.m. this will help. That will be held from fall city park. [0:23:55] That's it. There we go. All right. Sergeant Dennis Pullen. Staff Sergeant. I don't want to know. [0:24:01] Thank you. Again we have another event to be held at the Twin Falls City Park on July 27th. [0:24:08] They do requests that this started at eight o'clock in the morning. [0:24:11] We've indicated that we'll go until nine o'clock in the evening. This is for the car show. [0:24:16] However, they do plan on ending the show quite a bit earlier than that, and they want to [0:24:20] remain on site too, make sure that it's cleaned up and hope to have everything picked up and [0:24:24] organized back to normal by nine o'clock. [0:24:28] Chris Vargas is the one that provided this information to me, he's in the audience as [0:24:33] well. [0:24:34] We've been working for several months on getting this thing going. [0:24:38] They don't know how many cars they will have for sure because this is their first event. [0:24:43] They're hoping to have a large turnout. [0:24:46] They do plan on having a couple of food vendors in place. [0:24:51] They will be having some live music, [0:24:54] like amplified music through speakers, to start out with. [0:24:57] And then they will have a couple hours [0:24:59] where they will have a live band playing. [0:25:01] However, all the music will conclude [0:25:03] around four o'clock in the afternoon. [0:25:08] There will not be alcohol served at this event. [0:25:12] So therefore, we do not require security. [0:25:15] We feel that the music that's going to be played with no alcohol. [0:25:19] I mean, the first time for the event, [0:25:20] we don't see any issues rising out of this car show. [0:25:26] They are going to have a food drive for the Salvation Army [0:25:31] as part of the promotion for this. [0:25:33] And they have asked St. Jude's to be present, [0:25:36] to receive donations. [0:25:38] However, last I spoke with them, I don't know if they've heard [0:25:40] back from them or not. [0:25:44] Jima. [0:25:44] Thank you, Mayor. [0:25:45] Whereas in history, an experience [0:25:48] could tell me that whereas no alcohol is going to be served, [0:25:52] are we going to prohibit people bringing alcohol [0:25:54] into the park that day? [0:25:56] If I understand the city ordinance correctly, [0:25:58] if alcohol is being served and nobody can bring alcohol in, [0:26:01] but if it's not being served, I think they can. [0:26:07] So they would be allowed to, anybody could bring in a keg, [0:26:09] not a keg. [0:26:10] They could bring in cases or whatever to drink during the event. [0:26:13] An on bottle. [0:26:14] Yeah, it can't be glass. [0:26:15] So alcohol could be consumed, but they're not going to have a beer vendor there. [0:26:23] Correct. [0:26:24] That makes me nervous, a little bit, particularly with amplified music. [0:26:33] So I'll see where the discussion goes. [0:26:35] We can talk a little bit more. [0:26:39] Francis had a lot. [0:26:40] Fritz is looking at the exact site in our code, but Mitch and I conferred, and we do [0:26:44] do not believe that there is any prohibition at any point unless as Staff Sergeant Poland [0:26:51] had shared that since alcohol is not being served as part of the event and there's not [0:26:56] a regulated beer garden that individuals can't bring alcoholic beverages in a non-glass [0:27:04] bottle. [0:27:05] So that is part of the rules and regulations that we have I think on the books now. [0:27:15] Just like the yard sale. [0:27:18] We just. [0:27:19] My only concern is amplified music. [0:27:21] That would be my only concern there. [0:27:24] Okay. [0:27:25] So I guess. [0:27:26] What time is the music ending? [0:27:27] Four. [0:27:28] Four. [0:27:29] So it's going to be amplified from 10 till four. [0:27:34] Ten. [0:27:35] The music is on. [0:27:36] Then the band comes on at two and it plays for two hours. [0:27:38] And then it closes at four. [0:27:40] Okay. [0:27:41] And then we can monitor it. [0:27:42] If we would have any difficulties and next year you could step it up. [0:27:45] As well as if we do have any disturbances or complaints on doing [0:27:48] control supervisor will have to already. [0:27:50] Okay, thank you. [0:27:52] Let me what's going on. [0:27:53] Thanks, Dennis. [0:27:54] I don't know. [0:27:55] Could I visit with the representative? [0:28:09] You'll need to just say your name and... [0:28:12] Mark, Mark, we're going to ask the president for the Latinxist Car Club chapter here in [0:28:15] Twin Falls. [0:28:16] In our event, yes, we're not promoting alcohol at all. [0:28:18] We don't want to issue with it. [0:28:20] Our music is not going to be set up for a big concert. [0:28:24] It's just going to be a couple of these speakers so that when we announce the trophies, we can [0:28:28] actually get above the crowd. So our on-premise music will be just a couple hours because we [0:28:33] have some live performers, local performers that want to just show their music, their talents [0:28:37] out there for us. And we're trying to help out a little bit more here in our community, [0:28:41] trying to get something going for some of the youth. [0:28:45] So Marco, are you going to be using the band shell for some of your performers? [0:28:50] Yes, we want to use that stage just so that we can be just a little bit of both ground so [0:28:54] we will be level to all the spectators that we hope show up. [0:28:58] That's where we would want a couple of our performers to be at. [0:29:02] And I'm assuming you're going to want this to be an annual event? [0:29:06] If we can, yes, we would really want to look forward to a future. [0:29:10] Try to set this for a little bit different than what we have in the past. [0:29:15] Since we have little different thoughts and creativity and we're just trying to bring something new into the area. [0:29:21] You know, it sounds like you're trying to do the right thing. [0:29:24] You're trying to get back to the community, all those things. [0:29:26] I would just, a little bit of advice, just really be on it this year, make sure that there's [0:29:32] no, you know, try to mitigate any kind of disturbances or anything like that. [0:29:35] Because the way we look at it is we always look at past years to what security measures [0:29:41] or other things that we might put in place. [0:29:43] So just do your best job, which I'm sure you will, but just some word of advice. [0:29:47] Yes, we would look forward into our group. [0:29:51] We're not new here in the area. [0:29:53] We've been living here. [0:29:54] I've been off and on here for 12 years. [0:29:56] The rest of my guys have been here, born here, raised here. [0:29:59] And our car club has actually been together for 15 years. [0:30:01] But this is our New York chapter. [0:30:03] So we're just trying to get it going a little bit more. [0:30:06] We're out here every once in a while cruising. [0:30:08] But we're never causing problems. [0:30:10] We're not speeding or just doing reckless things. [0:30:12] So we've had a pretty good name up with the city and everything. [0:30:15] So hopefully we can keep it up like that. [0:30:17] Thank you. [0:30:18] Suzanne, I think Suzanne's next. [0:30:20] Can I, I'm sorry. [0:30:22] Well, we've got you in your being broadcast. [0:30:25] You said you were going to give awards. [0:30:26] What kind of categories, what kind of things should people [0:30:29] be expecting or looking for? [0:30:31] We have categories depending on your vehicle. [0:30:33] If you want to put it under maker model or certain years, [0:30:35] we have 50s custom, 50s street, all the way up to present. [0:30:40] We're doing best ofs, you know, [0:30:41] to see who brings out the best cars out there. [0:30:43] So we have, we've been able to do about, [0:30:46] I think we have close to 25 categories. [0:30:49] We're trying to get a little bit of variety [0:30:50] and everything on rocks. [0:30:51] We have muscle cars, four by fours, motorcycles. [0:30:54] So we're bringing it in for everybody around the valley. [0:30:57] Okay, thank you. [0:30:58] Sure, stock it up. [0:30:59] Actually, this question for Dennis, [0:31:01] since this is your first show, [0:31:03] you might already know this, [0:31:05] but is there guidance on putting cars on grass? [0:31:09] I know we've had other car shows there in the park. [0:31:12] Are they prohibited from anything? [0:31:14] Is that the asphalt or what? [0:31:16] We always ask them to put cardboard or something like a pan underneath their oil pans just in case that some of these cars do lick oil so we don't have a problem with them killing the grass. [0:31:24] I have not personally sat down with these gentlemen yet to go over that. [0:31:28] Usually two or three weeks in front of the event, I try to sit down with these band organizers, especially the car shows. [0:31:35] Some of this, especially this group is their first one. Some of the other ones like the classic cruisers they've been around forever. [0:31:42] maybe a relevant issue if we water the lawn the night before and have soft grass so that [0:31:47] may require some coordination. If I had to shut off the water for every [0:31:50] Ben and City park whenever you water. So some events they know it's going to be a little wet [0:31:57] but we try to especially on the big events when they have vehicles coming in we try to make sure [0:32:02] we don't water that night. Thanks. [0:32:06] Dan, just real quick I was going to save this until the end but since you're up here it is a [0:32:12] Amazing how many how often we use that city park and your your staff do a phenomenal job of keeping I don't know how grass grows on it [0:32:20] There's so many people and events on there, so you guys do a superior job [0:32:37] I'm always amazed in this the [0:32:39] We talked about parking in different parts of town and trying to get parking down south, [0:32:44] like those of huge events there and there's virtually no parking there. [0:32:48] So that they seem to still be able to find a spot and walk their way in. [0:32:52] It's important enough they'll find a way to get there. [0:32:56] Jim, I would make a motion. [0:32:58] Certainly. [0:32:59] I would move approval of the Latin ecstasy car show pursuant to the conditions outlined by [0:33:06] Staff Sergeant Pulling in his memorandum dated 1 July 2013. [0:33:11] Second. [0:33:13] Been moved by Jim on and seconded by Don Hall [0:33:16] to approve the event as proposed. [0:33:20] Seeing no additional lights, will I have a roll call vote? [0:33:23] Rebecca Milsica. [0:33:24] Yes. [0:33:25] Chris Tocketer. [0:33:25] Yes. [0:33:26] Sean Bericher. [0:33:27] Yes. [0:33:27] Don Hall. [0:33:28] Yes. [0:33:28] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:33:29] Yes. [0:33:30] Greg Lanthine. [0:33:31] Yes. [0:33:32] Jim on. [0:33:32] Yes. [0:33:33] Motion passes 7-0. [0:33:35] I hope your event turns out well. [0:33:36] Thank you, David. [0:33:39] Moving on to item number five. [0:33:42] Consideration of request to waive the admission fees [0:33:44] at Shoshone Falls for the American Legion Writers [0:33:48] on Saturday, July 20th, 2013. [0:33:52] Dennis Boyer. [0:33:55] Thank you, Mayor and Council. [0:33:57] Yes, tonight the American Legion Writers [0:34:01] are requesting to waive the fees at Shoshone Falls [0:34:04] park on Saturday, July 20th. [0:34:07] They're doing a ride, which they're approximately, I think, [0:34:11] they're riding about 300 miles that day. [0:34:13] They're doing a few other rides throughout the week anyway. [0:34:16] Richard Sowcock, representing the American region [0:34:18] lighter riders, is in the audience. [0:34:20] And I hope you have any questions for him. [0:34:22] He approached the staff last week about the wave and the fees. [0:34:25] And generally, when large groups looking at wave fees, [0:34:29] I said, I can't wave all of your fees. [0:34:31] It's just too large of a group. [0:34:33] Typically, we have offered half off on these large groups. [0:34:37] Because typically, they'll ride in. [0:34:40] It could be car shows. [0:34:41] A lot of times, car shows what can happen going in there. [0:34:44] They just pull in, drive around, and drive back out. [0:34:47] I understand that. [0:34:48] I just talked to Richard before the meeting [0:34:50] started that they're looking at having a barbecue [0:34:52] at Durkys Lake later on that day once they get down there. [0:34:55] So they may not just do the drive through. [0:34:58] With these large car band, you might say, of cars, [0:35:01] or motorcycles go down there. [0:35:03] we do not want to stop every single person at the gate [0:35:07] and collect our $3 from them. [0:35:08] Usually that's why we offer that half price. [0:35:11] So we can kind of make arrangements. [0:35:12] If they estimate 200 vehicles are going down, [0:35:15] normally that'd be $600. [0:35:17] We have for half price, we get $300 in advance. [0:35:19] Then we start counting. [0:35:21] We actually keep tracking the number of vehicles [0:35:22] go down their motorcycles. [0:35:23] And then after the event, we kind of even up, [0:35:29] figure out if we owe them money back or they owe us money [0:35:31] and we send them invoice. [0:35:33] So that's typically what we've done on these other large events [0:35:36] we look at, how many cars are going down there. [0:35:40] We don't want to stop them at each gate [0:35:41] if they're going to stay there or they're just [0:35:43] going to drive down to the falls, take a quick peek, [0:35:46] and drive back out. [0:35:48] Typically, I would have my Parks and Recreation Commission [0:35:50] review this, but he just spoke to us last week. [0:35:53] I told him about the process. [0:35:55] July 9th, it's not until it's my next Parks and Recreation [0:35:58] Commission meeting. [0:35:59] Their recommendation would come to the council till the 15th, [0:36:02] and he really would like to have an answer before that. [0:36:04] So that's why I was kind of put on the agenda [0:36:06] at the last moment anyway. [0:36:09] So with that, if you have any questions for myself [0:36:11] or Mr. Silkock, he is available in the audience [0:36:14] if you have any questions. [0:36:17] I have a Rebecca Melstika. [0:36:19] Thank you, Mayor. [0:36:20] I do have a question for the applicant [0:36:22] if he would come forward. [0:36:30] Thank you. [0:36:31] So in reading your email, this is a fundraiser [0:36:35] for a children have veterans. [0:36:38] It's for children, veterans that have been killed since 9-11, and this legacy fund provides funding [0:36:47] for their college until they graduate as long as they maintain a sea average. [0:36:53] Okay. [0:36:54] Great. [0:36:55] Thank you. [0:36:56] I just want clarity on the money that was being raised is what caused that's going to. [0:37:01] They have an annual legacy run from National Headquarters in Indianapolis to where the convention [0:37:08] is every summer. This year there's a big ride from Indianapolis to Houston, Texas and it's [0:37:14] a fundraiser. A lot of people out west and back east for various reasons can't make it. [0:37:25] So we started this romp west or western romp. Romp meaning ride on military pride and they [0:37:33] will also have an eastern rock probably in northern New York state. [0:37:39] Okay. [0:37:41] Thank you. [0:37:42] And where does this begin? [0:37:43] Is this a group of local writers or does this be in somewhere else? [0:37:45] We will have mostly people from west of the Mississippi River. [0:37:49] We do know there's one writer coming from Michigan. [0:37:53] I know there's a lot of writers coming up from Texas and California. [0:37:57] They will be coming in from all over and they pick Pocatello because they're two interstates [0:38:03] intersecting so they get more people in there because it is also a family affair and there [0:38:12] will be family members coming in cars or RVs or whatever. [0:38:18] Thank you. [0:38:19] Hi, Chris. [0:38:20] And Richard, I know that it starts in Indianapolis, which is a headquarters for the American Legion. [0:38:26] I also see the logo. [0:38:28] So you are directly affiliated with the Legion. [0:38:31] You're all veterans. [0:38:32] Yes. [0:38:33] happen to be the adjutant for the local post-seven? [0:38:36] Well, here's to you, Bernard. [0:38:39] That's great. [0:38:40] I would like to move for consideration [0:38:43] of waiving the admission fee for the Saturday, July 20th, [0:38:49] to show them the falls fee for the romp activity. [0:38:53] That would be between the hours of 10 to 1, [0:38:56] is what you're saying. [0:38:57] So it would be a fairly confined space. [0:39:00] I'll second. [0:39:01] Okay. [0:39:02] Chris, I am saying by Rebecca Miller, it's like we do have one additional light that Suzanne [0:39:07] Hawkins, you can certainly still ask your questions. [0:39:09] Okay. [0:39:10] Thank you. [0:39:11] My question is for Dennis, actually. [0:39:12] So, have we ever waived anybody else's fees completely? [0:39:16] Because you said you normally do half price and if we do waive, I mean, do we have anything [0:39:21] besides our, I mean, is there any kind of structure for making that decision or? [0:39:26] I would say we have waived fees. [0:39:28] I can't right now think of a specific one, you know, [0:39:30] they may have been smaller ones, [0:39:32] but I think it has been kind of related. [0:39:35] I just taught my head, I just can't think of one, [0:39:38] you know, I've, you know, wave a few here and there, [0:39:42] like that, but for large groups, I know we have to wave [0:39:44] something, but I just taught my head, I can't think of it. [0:39:47] Probably released a few several years ago. [0:39:49] And besides the wear and tear, then, is there a cost to us [0:39:53] as the city for having them down there for the day? [0:39:56] I mean, you know, your employees or anything extra or not. [0:40:00] Really just that they're looking at having a barbecue at [0:40:02] Durkis like I'm going to be talking with that because on weekends in July, [0:40:07] we have a thousand people down at Durkis without any reservations. [0:40:12] And do you have room down there for that many motorcycles to park comfortably? [0:40:16] People like, I know last week and people were, if you take, you know, [0:40:19] you go through the admission booth and then turn off the Durkis by late afternoon [0:40:23] cars were backed up on both parking on both sides of the roads on there at [0:40:27] Durkis. We just it is as you get to overcrowded in Durkis on weekends on [0:40:32] especially this hot weather like that. We have a I do hire a security company [0:40:37] firm that handles my security down there and parking and you know they had [0:40:41] to bring someone else in that weekend to help with a parking situation just [0:40:44] because of the everybody wants to get a dirty is a cheap entertainment at $3 [0:40:48] So is it possible for this group, I know their thing is writing motorcycles to work with [0:40:55] transfer and maybe park up on top of the canyon and have busing down to save the parking for [0:41:00] the local citizens who once in. [0:41:01] I mean, is anything like that doable? [0:41:03] Have we ever done that? [0:41:04] We've done something like some of the larger events I think you know Sean with the chamber [0:41:07] has done. [0:41:08] I think on this boat we've got to have that and also when we did blessings of the water [0:41:13] I think in 2004, busing in the water in the city of Centennial, we did that and also when [0:41:18] we had really big flows, we did set up some busing ourselves for people to park up on top. [0:41:25] We have used the church at the corner and also used part of Open Field at Wild Roads Subdivision [0:41:33] before, so we have worked with that. [0:41:35] I just found out tonight that we're looking at doing a barbecue at Turkey, so what we're [0:41:40] I'll be talking tomorrow to try to hopefully reset something up anyway. [0:41:43] Just to help the, you know, the situation. [0:41:47] Okay, thank you. [0:41:48] Okay, thank you. [0:41:49] I was really honored that you went off with that movie like that. [0:41:52] Maybe you finally burned out. [0:41:55] No, it's still cool. [0:41:56] Not at all. [0:41:58] I would just like to say that I'm in full support of what you're doing. [0:42:02] I do have some concerns about the congestion down there and good luck with that. [0:42:07] But I certainly appreciate what the American Legion does, [0:42:11] and this is obviously an important scholarship, [0:42:16] and I appreciate what you're doing for our community. [0:42:19] Thank you. [0:42:21] All right, seeing no other lights, [0:42:23] we do have a motion on the floor. [0:42:25] Yeah, a roll call vote. [0:42:26] Chris Talkington. [0:42:27] Yes. [0:42:28] Sean Berriger. [0:42:29] Yes. [0:42:30] Don Hall. [0:42:31] Yes. [0:42:32] Suzanne Hopkins. [0:42:32] Yes. [0:42:33] Greg Lanting. [0:42:34] Jim Munn. [0:42:35] Yes. [0:42:36] Rebecca Millslika. [0:42:37] Yes. [0:42:38] Item number six, Mitch, I'm a general discussion on a strategy for the downtown Old Town Parky. [0:42:52] So we have a newly adopted strategic plan, includes an objective in the goal for revitalizing [0:42:59] downtown. One of the objectives in there was to do a parking analysis and strategy for downtown, [0:43:07] It was a number one ranking, so in the first few years, [0:43:11] we had to get that done. [0:43:13] When we were proposing preliminary discussions [0:43:19] on the budget, Travis had asked Council-free priorities, [0:43:22] and that particular project came up from a couple of people, [0:43:24] saying, yeah, that's something we ought to get working on. [0:43:27] We've been looking at what's coming to you guys next week [0:43:31] on the budget, but you won't find that project being funded [0:43:34] next year. [0:43:35] One of the things we wanted to talk to you about was, [0:43:38] In the current fiscal year budget, we have two professional services contracts funded [0:43:44] that are not going to move forward. [0:43:46] And one of those is in the planning department. [0:43:47] If you guys were to recall, we put $30,000 in planning department professional services [0:43:52] to do an update of our growth projections for the comp plan. [0:43:57] And then as we went through the strategic plan process, [0:43:59] that particular consultant provided a lot of good information that really solidified what we already said [0:44:06] in our completeness of the need to update wasn't quite there anymore. [0:44:10] So we've kind of set that project aside, so there's some money there [0:44:14] that isn't going to get spent in the economic development department budget. [0:44:18] There was some money that was set aside for a target market analysis. [0:44:23] And we have our economic development group that meets every other week or so, [0:44:29] talked about that particular project. [0:44:31] And really the end result of that project is a list of folks [0:44:37] who you should go out and target and say you're looking [0:44:41] to expand, we have a spot for you. [0:44:43] It's a very time sensitive list that you get at the end [0:44:46] of that project and where we had some unknown future issues [0:44:51] with utility provisions and things like that, [0:44:54] we decided at the group not to proceed with that project, [0:44:56] either there's $25,000 there. [0:44:58] So I have a total of about $55,000 in professional services [0:45:03] for these two projects that aren't going to move forward [0:45:05] this year, and we would like to take that money in instead [0:45:08] of doing those projects, put it into this newly recommended [0:45:12] strategic plan project of a downtown strategy, [0:45:15] parking strategy. [0:45:17] And so when Travis I discussed, we thought let's bring it [0:45:21] to the council, see if you've got some feedback for us. [0:45:25] If you're OK with that, then we can go negotiate contracts [0:45:28] with somebody that can really take a look at what kind [0:45:33] of a parking need we have for downtown, look at who's there, [0:45:36] who's not there, what isn't vacant, kind of count up square footage [0:45:41] and count up necessary parking spaces that might be a result [0:45:47] of that occupancy rates. [0:45:50] And then look into the future and really lay out a good plan [0:45:54] for us on how to provide public parking, [0:45:57] as well as, you know, maybe recommendations coming out of that say we don't want to be in [0:46:01] the public parking business and somebody else needs to do it. Whatever that strategy comes [0:46:05] out, you know, a moron street parking should be acquire lots. We've looked at acquiring additional [0:46:11] parking lots for the city and we struggle with where that needs to be. This could help us [0:46:17] decide those kinds of things. And that's why the project's in the strategic plan. We'd [0:46:22] like to go ahead and move forward with it right now. And we think we have a funding source [0:46:26] to do that. So with that, we'll flip it over to you guys for some comments. [0:46:31] Do you like to add before we go to the questions? [0:46:35] Mr. Mayor, Mr. Council really quickly would. So the other thing that we're looking at doing [0:46:38] is taking a look at traffic flow and traffic patterns. And so this is not only just a look [0:46:45] at parking and parking lots in use, but it would also be looking at the flow of traffic. [0:46:51] One of the things that Mitch talked about was making sure that we're making maximum use [0:46:55] of on-street parking. [0:46:57] So it may involve the use of transforming some of our two [0:47:00] way streets into a collection of one way streets. [0:47:04] And so it then becomes a much more involved study [0:47:08] from an engineering perspective, because you're looking at the [0:47:10] flows of traffic than you are having us as a staff, [0:47:15] hiring a temporary employer, whatever it may be, going out [0:47:18] and counting empty parking spaces, which would be part of that. [0:47:22] So I wanted to make sure that that point was also [0:47:25] emphasize that it becomes really not only a parking plan, [0:47:29] but also a downtown traffic flow plan [0:47:32] that will help us in moving forward. [0:47:33] One of the things that we talked about [0:47:35] during the first federal project [0:47:37] was having a much more robust plan [0:47:39] than a two block stretch of road. [0:47:41] And so we wanted to incorporate that same thought [0:47:44] into this project as well. [0:47:46] To kind of fall on that hot. [0:47:49] In my mind, I didn't really go into that much detailer, [0:47:51] but in my mind, [0:47:53] and I've told you all this before, [0:47:55] So this shouldn't go as far as, but I think I believe that the city has [0:47:58] responsibility to participate in public parking for downtown, because of some of [0:48:01] the decisions we've made in the past have got us to the point we are. [0:48:04] I don't think that's a bad thing. [0:48:06] I think that the development pattern we have down there is a good thing for [0:48:10] downtown. [0:48:11] That's what we see across the country. [0:48:12] For downtown, it's, but parking is also part of the solution across the country [0:48:17] for downtown, and an easy way for us, potentially, to provide large amounts of [0:48:23] public parking is to maximize what we already have in the right-of-way and making [0:48:28] one way allows you to potentially maximize parking on street parking with [0:48:32] angled instead of parallel like we have in so many places now. So for me the traffic [0:48:38] flow issue is a way that potentially easily and maybe cheaply helps us provide [0:48:43] a good amount of on-street parking and a good amount of public parking throughout [0:48:47] the downtown commercial areas particularly. So I think that's absolutely [0:48:51] part of the plan and so Travis's point can we fit parking angled parking you [0:49:00] know there's needs to be a design perspective there and on the right of it [0:49:03] we have a through lane into trail of parking lanes is there enough right away [0:49:08] to accommodate that with the sidewalks and some of those things that an engineer [0:49:11] who designs roads and streets and will have kind of a you know a specialty for [0:49:17] And we should be able to find somebody like that. [0:49:19] You can move us down that project pretty rapidly. [0:49:22] That was because you have some addition. [0:49:24] Just really quickly on in terms of why we're here tonight [0:49:29] and what that looks like. [0:49:31] So the council in the budgeting process voted to award funding [0:49:37] to two very specific projects. [0:49:39] And those two projects, as Mitch shared, [0:49:42] are not going to go forward this year. [0:49:43] And as such, one of the things that we like to do as staff [0:49:46] is before we just take that money and shift it or slide it to another project or focus area that the council gives the blessing of moving that forward just as you would during the budgeting process. [0:49:57] Should the council say that yes, we believe that it's appropriate to move forward with those projects and we will go out and we will begin the process of negotiating a contract to move forward to meet the objectives that Mitch and I kind of take, [0:50:14] team and shared upon tonight. When this originally came out, we had a contract in there and we [0:50:19] thought that we might be putting one, the cart before the horse, but number two, we also wanted [0:50:24] to make sure that after this conversation we had an opportunity to fully vet the contract [0:50:29] a little bit more with the engineering firm. So that is the reason why this agenda is before [0:50:35] you this evening is just to make sure that number one, that the council is good in moving [0:50:40] forward. If the council elects not to, those funds would just revert into a cash reserve [0:50:45] position at the conclusion of the fiscal year for being unused on, on, on expanded funds [0:50:52] that have been appropriate for a specific purpose or project. [0:50:55] All right. You have a Christmas tree up here, so there's lots of questions in for comments. [0:51:01] I think I have an order, I wrote years down, Donny, I know your lights are off, but I [0:51:05] I'm going to, yes. [0:51:07] Okay. [0:51:08] All right, Chris Stockton. [0:51:11] Supporting with the concept, but it would appear to me that we're overlooking the major [0:51:15] player in this, the one ways I'm supposing we're saying the seconds is I.T.D. [0:51:21] and that's the U.S. 30, as I recall. [0:51:24] And without their playing, we don't get to first base. [0:51:29] And, as I recall, they put a lot of money into expanding the roads to their current right [0:51:35] away situation and they're probably going to be, of the mind to say, what are you offering [0:51:42] in the trade-off back to us? [0:51:45] Second of all, I'm sure you've already thought that, through, but ITD has to be a player in [0:51:49] this, which means it's going to take longer, be slower, and more red tape. [0:51:54] The other thing, if we can negotiate a contract, [0:51:58] I would only be supportive of this, [0:52:02] a planner, not a realtor with a conflict of interest. [0:52:06] Hopefully somebody that has no ties in locally [0:52:10] and can be somewhat objective. [0:52:12] That can't be anybody that is taking out of one pocket [0:52:16] and putting into another. [0:52:18] I would agree with Councilman Talkington's concerns. [0:52:25] I would even support having a firm outside of Twin Falls just so that there's no conflicts [0:52:32] of interest because even identifying certain pieces of land, all of a sudden makes them more [0:52:37] valuable if they know that the city or the URA through taxpayer funds are needing to acquire [0:52:44] it. [0:52:46] And so my question is just a technical question in the report that says the EHM is one of [0:52:52] of the firms that are approved. [0:52:56] Is it possible to also get a cost estimate [0:52:59] from any of the other firms that have been approved? [0:53:03] We, for this type of a service, [0:53:05] we have to make a selection on qualifications.on costs. [0:53:08] So we have to be careful about going out [0:53:10] and getting costs from pre or four different ones [0:53:13] and picking the one that's the cheapest. [0:53:15] Rather, we make a selection-based decision [0:53:20] and then negotiate a contract with them. [0:53:22] So when I mentioned that the engineering department [0:53:26] went through a process about a year and a half ago [0:53:29] to create kind of a list of pre-selected, [0:53:33] qualified consultants for a variety of projects. [0:53:36] And they were a firm that is on that list. [0:53:38] They've already been pre-selected [0:53:40] as qualified to do work like this. [0:53:44] So we wouldn't have to go through a standalone RFQ process [0:53:47] to select someone for this specific project, [0:53:50] but we still have to base the decision on who [0:53:53] as a qualification-based decision, [0:53:55] not a price-based position. [0:53:58] Right. [0:53:59] This is different than building [0:53:59] like a construction project in that sense. [0:54:01] Right, but there are, so how did you choose this from? [0:54:04] I mean, there are other firms on that list [0:54:05] that are qualified for. [0:54:07] There are others, there are several that could do it. [0:54:10] The conversation that we had with regards [0:54:14] to this conversation was that those guys [0:54:16] have been in the area quite a bit lately. [0:54:19] They've been designing parking lots. [0:54:20] They've been designing street projects for downtown, [0:54:23] have a lot of the knowledge already collected [0:54:26] for good portions of the property. [0:54:28] And we felt like they would be able to jump on it quickly [0:54:30] and have a good response in a good timely fashion. [0:54:35] And that was it. [0:54:36] So we didn't even ask anybody else for a bid or for a quote [0:54:41] for that reason. [0:54:42] We didn't want to make it about price. [0:54:44] I would like to see other costs just to make sure that it's not an inflated cost or, you [0:54:51] know, and obviously when you negotiate the contract we'll see specifics about the specific costs [0:54:58] involved. [0:54:59] Is that correct? [0:55:00] Yeah, that's one of the things we wanted to kind of pull back on is get like a more [0:55:05] of an item kind of a thing, one we got was kind of a lump sum, lump sum kind of a deal. [0:55:13] So it is, as a city, we can't negotiate cost until we've made a selection of a firm. [0:55:23] So we actually, by Idaho Code, have to go through a qualifications process which basically says [0:55:31] you will rank the firms based upon what you believe to be either expertise or skill sets [0:55:39] or additional knowledge that they bring to that process. [0:55:43] And then you rank those, and after you rank those, then you begin the process of negotiating [0:55:47] the price with the number one company. [0:55:50] If you are unable to reach a agreed upon price for service, then you move to number two. [0:55:58] So it is not possible for us under the Idaho Code to get different costs, because I understand [0:56:07] it for the work, because we have to actually select a company first before we can begin [0:56:15] the process of negotiating with them. [0:56:20] And we have to reject that company, the number one company, before we can move down to the [0:56:26] perceived number two on that list. [0:56:28] And that's just the stipulations of any time that we hire architects, land surveyors, engineers [0:56:35] or any firm of the like, you have to do with this process [0:56:39] as opposed to the other. [0:56:40] Right, so the city ranks as the ranking? [0:56:45] The city does the ranking, and from that ranking, [0:56:50] then we negotiate with the highest rank firm. [0:56:53] And then, like Mitch said, we felt that EHM, [0:56:55] because of their two downtown projects that they're doing, [0:56:58] as well as the other parking lot works [0:57:00] that they've done in particular for the Urban [0:57:02] a new agency that they probably brought the most relevant information to the table at the [0:57:07] time. [0:57:08] Okay. [0:57:09] Thank you. [0:57:10] And I don't disagree with, you know, going through with this contract. [0:57:15] I do think that a lot of the parking strategy, a good portion of it can be done in house as [0:57:21] far as on Tuesday, this past Tuesday, you know, as you know, I'm one of the liaisons [0:57:27] to planning and zoning in this past Tuesday. [0:57:29] we actually dealt with an issue regarding parking. [0:57:33] And with the different overlay districts downtown, [0:57:38] I think a review of that in the needs, [0:57:41] obviously some districts don't even require parking. [0:57:44] And I think you talked about this in your report, [0:57:47] down to some that only say require 30% or more. [0:57:52] But this issue came before P and Z, [0:57:56] And staff's recommendation was actually [0:57:59] that to do away with that requirement of parking. [0:58:05] And so I just want to make sure that whenever we recommend [0:58:10] removing that parking requirement, [0:58:12] that it falls in line with the city's philosophy on parking, [0:58:16] because here we're saying we created a problem in the past. [0:58:20] I just hope we don't continue to go through with that philosophy, [0:58:25] even though we know we've created a problem, [0:58:28] we're going to have to change kind of our perspective [0:58:31] in the way that we do things. [0:58:33] This particular site actually has an undeveloped piece of land [0:58:37] that could be used for parking. [0:58:40] And I don't know if it's right or wrong [0:58:46] that you remove that requirement. [0:58:48] But even in the staff report at the end, [0:58:50] it said, but in the future, if we [0:58:52] we don't have enough public parking, we'll have to reevaluate. [0:58:56] And I would just recommend that our policies be consistent all the way into the future. [0:59:01] I mean, any exception that we make needs to be able to be consistently applied. [0:59:07] And if we give one applicant credit for public parking spaces, then in the future you'd have to obviously allow other people to use public parking. [0:59:16] then it starts to create that problem again of not having enough public parking, and then [0:59:21] it shifts the cost and the responsibility of parking to the public, to the taxpayers, and [0:59:27] I think that we just need to be careful about finding new—and I think that's how I interpreted [0:59:34] this aspect of the strategic plan is to find new, even internal strategies to kind of deal [0:59:42] with whether that's a partnership, and I think that's a great idea. [0:59:45] you know, if say someone has a lot, they don't actually have room for parking, you know, what [0:59:51] would be their contribution, you know, towards the city's provision of parking, you know, [0:59:56] just kind of thinking along broad, innovative ways to address the parking issue within [1:00:04] our code. [1:00:05] So I would encourage that as well as the, you know, technical traffic flow changes. [1:00:11] I think it's a great idea to go ahead and get the study and I like the idea of using somebody [1:00:23] who's been involved in what's going on and knows what's happening and what our strengths [1:00:27] and weaknesses are. [1:00:29] My concern is in the past we have paid for a number of studies and then they get pretty [1:00:34] pictures and nice binders and they go on a shelf and that's the end. [1:00:39] And my caution is I don't want to waste taxpayer money to do a study that leads to another dead [1:00:45] stand. So if we go ahead with the study, are we ready to make the implementations, are we [1:00:53] ready to make the changes, are we going to follow through with it, or are we just gathering [1:00:57] information that is going to sit there and be null and void again? [1:01:05] in the council, but we are sorry. [1:01:07] That's us. [1:01:08] That's us. [1:01:09] So. [1:01:10] So. [1:01:11] So. [1:01:12] So. [1:01:13] The look on the mirror to that. [1:01:15] I just, I'm nervous about spending that much money and having no results come from that. [1:01:26] I think we have some potential actionable items that come from this though that we [1:01:33] could then bring to the council for further action and some of those might be code amendments [1:01:37] And some of those might be an actual change to our traffic flows [1:01:43] to allow more one-way streets and then striping. [1:01:46] We have some things that might come out of this [1:01:48] that might be easy and quick implementation steps. [1:01:53] But if we do it now, we really don't [1:01:55] have time to address that in the 2014 budget. [1:01:58] So we're looking at a whole year out [1:02:00] before we can implement any of it. [1:02:02] I think some of this is going to take some time anyway [1:02:05] to get through this process. [1:02:06] And then the next steps might take a little time to develop [1:02:10] and actually request for maybe next spring, [1:02:12] we actually have some good solid, you know, [1:02:15] what's gonna cost us to go re-sign [1:02:19] and re-stripe all of our roads, or some of them anyway, right? [1:02:22] So, it'll take a little time to get there anyway. [1:02:27] So what we are going to study now, [1:02:29] we probably won't address in our budget [1:02:30] until 2015 realistically. [1:02:32] You certainly won't see it in next Monday's [1:02:34] preliminary budget presentation. [1:02:35] Well, I understand that. [1:02:37] Great. [1:02:40] So when we go through the budgeting process [1:02:42] and we look in particular at the Street Fund, [1:02:44] we allocate $684,200 a year towards miscellaneous street [1:02:50] projects. [1:02:51] And they're generally to accomplish [1:02:53] those projects that come up after the time [1:02:56] in which we've adopted the budget as we kind of go through. [1:02:58] So some of that includes ADE ramps, some of that [1:03:00] includes striping, some of that includes additional signage. [1:03:04] So, we always try to make sure that there is, [1:03:08] we don't develop a budget or a budgetary process [1:03:11] that does not allow us to take advantage of opportunities [1:03:14] as they present themselves. [1:03:17] We also have the ability to use cash reserves [1:03:19] for land acquisition. [1:03:21] We've got a cash reserves that we've set aside [1:03:24] that we've actually from the sale of other properties [1:03:27] that we said that we intend to use at some point in time [1:03:30] for the acquisition of additional properties [1:03:31] so those funds would also be available. [1:03:33] So, even though you may not see funds directly in the budget associated with implementation [1:03:38] of a plan, we do have resources that are indirectly marked in the budget and also access to other [1:03:44] cash. [1:03:45] The other side is it may come up with a series of recommendations that, from a policy perspective, [1:03:50] make a lot of sense, but from a political perspective, are challenging. [1:03:55] And so I don't want to sit here and say that all plans will be implemented because there [1:04:02] there has to be a recognition of the sensitivity of what may be presented. [1:04:06] All right, Jim, I'm okay so. [1:04:16] I want him to go for Sean's first. [1:04:22] He was next. [1:04:23] I got ahead of myself. [1:04:24] Sean, start. [1:04:25] So I do want to echo Suzanne's concerns because if the result of this study is there [1:04:34] needs to be public parking downtown. I am not supportive of spending $10, let alone $55,000 [1:04:41] on that because I'm pretty sure that I have about four studies on my shelf at my office [1:04:47] that say that already. So a couple of things that I would like to see addressed in this is [1:04:55] to take the stuff that we've already studied and look at what we haven't done with that [1:05:03] and see if it's still applicable, and that should not be a 15-month strategy. [1:05:10] That's a grab the plan and read it and see what it says about it and how do we do that. [1:05:15] The other part that I like about this is the opportunity to address multiple goals, not [1:05:22] just parking, but things like traffic flow and how that may tie to the truck route improvement [1:05:30] project that we've discussed, how it deals with pedestrian access throughout the community. [1:05:37] Certainly, the streets issues, and I really would like to see actionable items from it, [1:05:46] because, again, if it's just a study that says downtown has challenges with parking [1:05:51] and you ought to do something with that, I will be very upset if that is what we end up. [1:05:59] The other part, too, that I think is important to think about is the future planning that [1:06:05] you mentioned, Mitch. [1:06:06] This isn't about what's there today and how many parking spaces those businesses need. [1:06:12] It's about where we realistically think downtown is going, and I think we have some of that [1:06:18] sense already with some activity that's happening down there, and I would encourage some discussion [1:06:24] with folks who have investments down there about what they're trying to do, because, again, [1:06:30] if we create parking strategies that address the 1970s needs of downtown, we're not going [1:06:37] to get there. [1:06:39] The other piece, too, that I do want to point out, and Greg made the comments somewhat tongue [1:06:42] in cheek earlier, but when we have a thousand person event at City Park, I never get phone [1:06:49] calls from people talking about how terrible the parking is downtown. [1:06:53] And we have a thousand people at Twin Falls tonight last week. [1:06:56] I never get phone calls from people complaining about how there's no parking down town. [1:07:00] So I think we need to paint a realistic picture of what the parking challenges truly are. [1:07:08] Not what we perceive them to be. [1:07:11] Even since the parking meters have been yanked, all I hear from people is, isn't it wonderful [1:07:16] that sometimes it's difficult to find a parking place on main because there's stuff going on. [1:07:21] So I think that's an important perspective to have too and I'm certainly going to leave [1:07:27] this election process to the process that exists but I do think folks with local roots can be [1:07:35] more helpful in that than perhaps others. [1:07:38] Jim, I want to talk a little bit about there have been, I know probably four, three or four [1:07:46] studies that have been completed in regards to downtown from different disciplines over [1:07:52] over the years. [1:07:54] I won't support another study downtown [1:07:58] or funding of a study downtown until there's [1:08:00] a careful analysis of the studies that we have already [1:08:03] completed and to determine if any of that information [1:08:08] would be useful in determining both traffic flow, parking, [1:08:13] and other areas downtown. [1:08:18] The community has spent way too much money [1:08:20] place those has been indicated on the shelf without any sort of action. [1:08:27] So I guess my recommendation is we carefully analyze what we already have in place, see [1:08:35] if it can be used because I believe that studies go south for one particular reason. [1:08:41] Nobody on the council, nobody in the community, and most generally nobody in staff are stakeholders [1:08:47] in those studies. [1:08:48] They're just not. [1:08:50] brought in from people outside the organization, it's easy to have those things placed on the [1:08:55] shelf and your money spent. So I won't support this mission. [1:09:04] John Hall. [1:09:05] You know, the first thing I want to say is that government gets a bad rep for when we're [1:09:11] save some money because we're not going to spend it, we automatically figure out how [1:09:15] to spend it somewhere else. And I'm critical of us doing that government as a whole. But [1:09:22] I support what we're doing here because this was already something that's in our strategic [1:09:27] plan, something that we need to do. We understand that it's been called out by the citizens and [1:09:33] so I'm certainly in support of that. And I look at this strategy much like I look at [1:09:39] the, and certainly I understand that there's all these plans on the shelf. But I look at [1:09:43] this strategy is very similar to what I look at our master land scaving plan that we have [1:09:48] for downtown and that was a plan that was put together not too many years ago and we utilize [1:09:52] it every time there's a development downtown and this is what I hope will come out of this. [1:09:59] We certainly aren't going to come up with this strategy and this plan and implement it [1:10:04] the next week because we don't have the resources, the ability to do that but I would hope that [1:10:09] that we come out with a plan that has a good solid strategy [1:10:13] that as the opportunity to implement it takes place, [1:10:17] that we're strong enough, [1:10:18] and we remember that there's this plan up there, [1:10:20] and we'll open it up and make sure that we do it. [1:10:22] And I'm so glad that you mentioned [1:10:24] about the traffic patterns and flow [1:10:26] and possible one ways in the future. [1:10:29] And because we already talked about that around First Fed, [1:10:32] where we were going to make that one section a one way, [1:10:36] made kind of sense for there, [1:10:37] But the council rightfully said, well, where's the plan? [1:10:41] I mean, we're just going to do this for this one block, [1:10:43] or these two blocks. [1:10:44] Where's the ultimate plan? [1:10:45] And this gives us that opportunity to have that ultimate [1:10:48] plan when we have opportunities for development [1:10:51] and to utilize the streets in a wiser way for parking [1:10:55] and flow and all those things that it can take place. [1:10:58] Thank you. [1:10:59] Just talking. [1:11:00] A final thought on ITD is a role in this. [1:11:04] As a rep for the joint, [1:11:06] larger Chamber Commerce Transportation Group, [1:11:10] every time we meet I.T.D.'s reps are there. [1:11:14] And I think I need to reacquaint the Council with how they operate. [1:11:18] Unless you're on a list and move up on a list, nothing happens. [1:11:23] This U.S. 30 to 2 second avenues is not even approaching the list. [1:11:30] The only area within the municipality that I'm aware of that has any [1:11:35] at I.T.D. dollars remotely attached is the southeast corridor for study at East [1:11:42] five points. I do know that the I.T.D. rep consistently says the way you get [1:11:50] something to move up on the list is to have local impetus or urging for something [1:11:57] to be done in the case of this downtown area, I can think of no other group or groups other [1:12:04] than the individual businesses, urban renewal in the city, urging something. [1:12:09] But this is something that even if we suddenly got a groundswell of support until they implemented [1:12:15] on their budget, it will be multiple years. [1:12:19] That said, if we're serious about taking the one ways off the second, then this is something [1:12:25] that we need to or should have put into our strategic plan as guidance for me to urge [1:12:33] the group to do something, and they're going to say, well, where's your support for doing [1:12:38] this? [1:12:39] Or is this just because you have a study that you've funded? [1:12:43] So this is a much longer range proposition and problem than just the results of a study [1:12:51] that may or may not make it onto a shelf. [1:12:55] And on the less, I still support it because I think Don spoke very well of the need for it. [1:13:01] And if it should be an approved project, and I guess the first thing that study group should have would be access to all that material has background information. [1:13:11] So you know additional lights, Council wishes? [1:13:19] You need a motion to say that we will utilize those funds? [1:13:24] Is or yeah, is this do yeah, thank you Sean or is this directional so I believe that there was a majority of the council [1:13:31] Who was in favor of moving those funds again? [1:13:34] We have we've earmarked $55,000 that we do not intend to use we do not believe that the cost of this will approach that [1:13:41] We'll do everything that we can to ensure those costs are kept well below that. Yeah, make sure you don't tell them what money we have [1:13:48] on the field. [1:13:49] This is broadcast on the internet. [1:13:51] Why, any kind of RFI or anything. [1:13:55] Yeah, we're just funding the big game in it. [1:14:00] Jim, let's take it to a formal vote so there's a record of who voted yes or no. [1:14:05] Then I would suggest that you make a vote. [1:14:07] I would move to approve the, I guess, the reallocation of money in a, in white items that are not [1:14:17] to be used for an economic study and for what was the other one? [1:14:21] The growth reduction study and convert that over, that would be about $55,000, convert [1:14:29] that over to allow staff to use for a what? [1:14:35] Parking and traffic flow analysis, right. [1:14:38] Second. [1:14:39] I can move by Jim Mann and second by Don Hall to allow staff to utilize the savings from two [1:14:47] other studies to to fund a study for traffic traffic flow and parking in downtown [1:14:53] to and fall. Well that wasn't stated we're talking about downtown area downtown [1:14:58] town okay all right see no additional lights on the other roll call vote [1:15:03] some burger yes John Hall yes season Hawkins yes Greg Lansing yes Jim I know [1:15:13] Rebecca Mills like that yes yes motion passes 61 [1:15:21] Rebecca Mills like thank you mayor sorry didn't turn my light on in time that's a quick vote [1:15:27] but as a caveat to my vote I do want to [1:15:30] reiterate that I think a lot of this can be done in-house and the stuff that we [1:15:34] can [1:15:35] ascertain for ourselves that we do that and only the parts that need to be done professionally [1:15:40] because the only reason I say that is at this P&C meeting a question was asked by the commission [1:15:47] and staff said well we don't have that information assembled, we do have that information, it's [1:15:52] not assembled and we're going to do this study. So I just want to make sure that the things [1:15:59] that we can do in house we do that. [1:16:02] Moving on to item seven which is public input, the audience, we will be going ahead and having [1:16:08] the public hearing before the executive session since there is a time before 6 o'clock. [1:16:14] Those executive sessions in the public know that. Anyone have public input for items that [1:16:20] we're not on tonight's agenda? Same major? Council? Thoughts on things? I want to do a quick report. [1:16:29] I was in Washington DC last week, uh, stumping for a better word with our congressman and senators [1:16:38] for the Land and Water Conservation Fund, [1:16:41] which is a fund that we have utilized in the past [1:16:44] for a building of parks and the City of Twin Falls. [1:16:46] The County has utilized them as well. [1:16:48] I think the largest one grant we ever received [1:16:51] was $275,000 for Frontier Field for the ones we've utilized. [1:16:57] And hopefully, they've come up, [1:17:00] Congressman Simpson has come up with a plan [1:17:03] to marry that to the PELT and rural schools [1:17:06] to provide that the more secure funding. [1:17:08] And also, through Senator Rish's office, [1:17:12] I think I found some ways that we can be more successful [1:17:16] as the term I would use. [1:17:18] And so, I don't feel like that we were successful. [1:17:23] Plus, may as well as contacts with the chiefs of staff [1:17:26] of each of the congressmen and senators back there. [1:17:29] And yes, it is hot and humid in Washington DC. [1:17:34] Certainly wasn't a pleasurable truth. [1:17:36] I was just going to make mention, remind our citizens again that 4th of July is coming up. [1:17:42] We are going to step up our enforcement of our laws regarding illegal fireworks. [1:17:47] I think there's no better illustration of how dangerous it can be than what just happened [1:17:52] in Arizona with 19 of our firefighters losing their life fighting wildland fires. [1:17:59] And I spent several years of my youth, I guess, doing that same thing. [1:18:04] I certainly understand the dangers there, but my thoughts and prayers go out to them. [1:18:09] But again, please be careful with fireworks and we don't need any tragedies like that around [1:18:15] here. [1:18:16] It's extremely dry out there. [1:18:17] Obviously, I can't. [1:18:18] I don't need to tell everyone it's extremely hot right now. [1:18:21] So please be careful. [1:18:22] Chris, I didn't have a thought after a thought. [1:18:26] I've been used to send carberry here all the time. [1:18:30] not that have you had word of hold back because of sequestration for BLM operations at our [1:18:38] airport? Travis? I have not heard that that was one of the areas that would be held back [1:18:43] but we can check and confirm. I think the council needs to be aware of that [1:18:47] if in fact there's going to be a change in activity because this is going to be one hot [1:18:52] sucker dangerous this year and I sure hope that those crazy politicians back there continue [1:19:00] fund B01 and the point and for service and for service John Berg well backing up [1:19:08] to speaking of the 4th of July I want to remind everyone as well that there is a [1:19:11] wonderful community celebration going on on Thursday 4th there is a breakfast at [1:19:17] City Park I'm not gonna recall what time it starts but early and that is a [1:19:24] fundraiser to help support the fireworks fund I would encourage people to go [1:19:28] participate in that and certainly contributions are still being accepted to the Fireworks Fund [1:19:34] and it's one of those things that we all expect and hope happens every year but it takes resources [1:19:40] so I would encourage people to pony up and be a part of that. [1:19:44] I think we have one of the participants that helps the breakfast be a successful endeavor [1:19:49] in our audience and Mr. Kyle McDonald's helps that be profitable. [1:19:54] So you know other lights, I'm going to skip over it and move on to the public hearing, unless [1:20:01] we have a need for a break, alright, everybody feels good to go forth. [1:20:06] Alright, next item is the public hearing to hear a request for an amendment to the Beauty [1:20:11] Storage Facility C1PUD agreement, 6.4 acres, to allow U-Haul track rental business and to [1:20:18] to approve a paving deferral to continue the use [1:20:20] of an undeveloped internal vehicle traffic travel areas [1:20:25] and continue the operation of an outside boat RV [1:20:29] and storage vehicle storage business on undeveloped property [1:20:32] in conjunction with the operation of storage unit facility [1:20:35] business, I'm properly located at 485 Grand View Drive, [1:20:40] 485 Grand View Drive. [1:20:42] I simply forgot where I'm going, but maybe not. [1:20:45] Mitch, what's our, we're gonna have the applicant go first. [1:20:48] All right, Mr. Olson, are you starting this out for us? [1:20:54] All right, we typically allow 15 minutes [1:20:58] for the applicant to present their side of things [1:21:02] before we move on to the public hearing [1:21:04] or the staff thoughts and also the public hearing portion. [1:21:09] So go ahead, Greg Olson. [1:21:11] Greg, I will be giving you a five and a two and a 30 second [1:21:14] you get to that point. Okay, thanks. Great, Olson 45, Grand View [1:21:20] draft. This is obviously a reconsideration, and I appreciate you allowing us to do this. [1:21:30] We basically, I have to look at it from the very first meeting, I added up that there [1:21:37] was more people that were in support of it than there wasn't, but with the confusion [1:21:41] of the votes or the confusion of the motions through all that, I think that I think it makes [1:21:47] a lot of sense to do it. I think it makes a lot of sense for a deferral and a revisit [1:21:51] at a later date. And we're a locally owned member of the Chamber of Commerce, an extremely [1:21:58] community minded and a common sense says that putting asphalt down where you're going [1:22:07] to put buildings at a later date for another phase is not real feasible. [1:22:14] We're not trying to get around any of the rules, but O9 obviously was a little bit of [1:22:18] a tough year or the start of the crash and business wasn't very great. [1:22:25] It's been kind of a rough road for a couple of years. [1:22:30] To put us out for $25,000 or $30,000, it's going to be painful. [1:22:36] I also had a conversation with our neighbor. [1:22:40] The guy that was here before is not a property owner. [1:22:43] From our last, the very first meeting, [1:22:45] he's actually a tenant of Brent Trappen's. [1:22:48] Brent Trappen owns Argo Company. [1:22:50] And I visited with Brent Trappen and kind of wanted [1:22:52] to get his thoughts and slats in the fence. [1:22:55] And if anything, you know, dust has been a problem, [1:22:57] or any of that. [1:22:58] And he said absolutely not. [1:22:59] He is just, he's absolutely in support of whatever we think [1:23:03] is reasonable and just, and he is not at a problem in three years, and I haven't heard [1:23:11] a complaint. [1:23:12] I mean, the guy shows up, but I haven't heard anything over three years during the process. [1:23:19] So when the rubber meets the road, that's when he came down. [1:23:27] And then I did grow around a little bit and looked at the tractor place for the deferral [1:23:31] that you got for the destroy their asphalt or whatever. [1:23:34] And actually, that looks pretty good. [1:23:36] I mean, I bet that was a reasonable request [1:23:40] and a reasonable approval. [1:23:43] And then also the Oregon Trail softball complex [1:23:46] or baseball complex where the kids play. [1:23:49] Same thing there, so let's see. [1:23:53] And that's about it. [1:23:55] And the adjacent property around us [1:23:57] is very similar to kind of the operational, what [1:24:00] we're doing with gravel areas. [1:24:02] I guess they're not grandfathered in somehow, so it's about it, thanks. [1:24:09] Thank you, Greg. [1:24:10] We'll reserve, you'll have some time at the end, and if you need, after the public hearing [1:24:15] portion, usually the answer questions and things, people will, you'll obviously save some of [1:24:19] your time, or if you'll choose to enforce and speak, you can as well, since he's one of [1:24:25] the owners. [1:24:26] Ms. Humble, or whoever from the staff is conducting this. [1:24:31] I had this hearing on May 20th, and we spent a good amount of time talking about the whole, [1:24:45] I guess the whole totality of the request. [1:24:49] Tonight was the reconsideration, and Greg explained what he was exactly after, and I didn't plan [1:24:57] to talk about the full request again, but rather just kind of focus on the point of the reconsideration. [1:25:03] And so we all remember that it was a PUD amendment [1:25:07] and all those kinds of things. [1:25:08] And this is a notified public hearing. [1:25:12] We need to have a public hearing at one point tonight. [1:25:14] At the end of that, we'll make a decision. [1:25:16] And if the motion is in whatever the motion is, [1:25:20] we'll go ahead and prepare a PUD agreement and bring that back [1:25:25] for your final execution at a later meeting. [1:25:29] All those kinds of things. [1:25:30] So again, the point of, I guess, tonight was on May 20th, we approved the case as outlined [1:25:37] and then recommended by the Planning and Zoning Commission, basically was, yep, you've got your [1:25:41] amendment, you can do the uses you want to do with the conditions that are in there and [1:25:45] the conditions basically said, pave the parts that you're going to use. [1:25:51] And it was defined as a few special parts, you know, one under the future building and then [1:25:55] along this property line along that property line, you know, where they're storing the vehicles [1:25:59] There was a bunch of discussion about the paving requirements and ultimately there is still on [1:26:15] the books a recommendation from the Planning and Zoning Commission for approval with the [1:26:19] four conditions that are listed here and the traffic has got them up on the screen there. [1:26:24] That is the Official Reclamation Planning and Zoning Commission that hasn't changed. [1:26:28] We didn't have this reconsideration at the planning of zoning commission, so they haven't [1:26:33] had a chance to talk about it again, so their recommendation stands. [1:26:39] Greg felt like, again, counting votes or whatever, there might have been a favorable motion that [1:26:46] could have been drafted, how do we spend a little bit more time to do that, and I think [1:26:50] that's what he's asking for. [1:26:52] And if that's where we want to go with it, we can certainly try to help come up with [1:26:56] that wording for you. We do have, we do we do deferrals for development [1:27:06] requirements at times. Our city code allows hardship development deferrals so [1:27:12] if you've got significant cost that represents greater than a certain [1:27:19] percentage of the total project then you can defer that over a three-year span as [1:27:22] long as you're making progress in the three years to get that done. I think this [1:27:27] This is a little different. [1:27:28] I don't think it prizes to the level of hardship or the total project, so I mean that's a little [1:27:33] bit out. [1:27:34] Building the different line to the PUD is probably the way to go, so anyway, I guess I, I mean, [1:27:43] try to answer questions if you have, I'll try to help you craft language if you, if you [1:27:47] want to go down that path, it's just, I didn't want to spend a lot of time dealing with that [1:27:53] sometimes with the request because nothing's really changed there. [1:27:55] You do have the full report from last time as well as the minutes from last time [1:28:00] So the May 20th hearing from this council those minutes are attached as well, so [1:28:05] I said we do need to open above a king and then we'll work our way through this I guess so [1:28:14] So I have a question and I'm guessing it's for Troy so [1:28:20] At the last time we discussed this I [1:28:23] I have asked that someone from engineering be here to answer a couple of questions that I have. [1:28:29] So in reading through the minutes of the Planning and Zoning Commission, it talks about the engineering [1:28:34] department having reviewed the application and not recommending allowing any undeveloped [1:28:41] area to be used for outside storage unless it is paved and then it discusses accepting an [1:28:46] alternate surface which would need to be 2-inch re-cried with chips seal over the top. [1:28:51] So I have a couple of questions. [1:28:53] One, can you explain to me the rationale and purpose [1:28:58] of having hard surfaced parking areas in city development [1:29:03] and what the consequences of not having that are? [1:29:06] And then my second question would be, [1:29:08] do you have an idea what the cost differential [1:29:12] between a traditional full-on pave [1:29:17] and this alternative option might be? [1:29:20] if you don't that's okay that's just my second question. [1:29:23] Okay. [1:29:24] Sorry VTech, the city engineering department. [1:29:29] The reason for the paving of the areas is we are approaching 50,000 as a city in the size [1:29:36] of 50,000 which will start to bring on additional storm water requirements for us. [1:29:43] So a long time ago part of the city code was developed to say that any areas that you're [1:29:49] maneuvering or using as part of a new film have to be paved a hard surface and [1:29:53] their standards in our engineering documentation as to how to do that. Our [1:30:00] effort to do that is in the future as these additional EPA requirements come [1:30:05] on the city we'll have to clean up our roadways a lot more. So it's either a [1:30:11] cost we bear to go out and do these areas so they don't track dirt and [1:30:17] gravels and stuff on our roadways. I'm sure there will be some sweeping. I'm sure there will be some storm drainage requirements. [1:30:23] Different sediment bases will have to be developed as part of that. So it will be a huge effort on our part. [1:30:28] And so I'm guessing the code when it was originally written was to ask the developers to do their portion of that [1:30:36] so that they don't drag those materials out onto our city streets and were responsible for maintaining that. [1:30:44] I believe that's why it was originally developed and that's why the heart surfacing. [1:30:49] In discussions with Jackie, the city engineer, we've allowed some of these projects, not [1:30:55] city roads, because those are stuff we'll always maintain, but in parking areas, private [1:31:02] developments. [1:31:03] There's a few options as to why acceptable heart surfaces and she recommended doing what [1:31:11] to call like a re-grind with an oil copy that's similar to what we did at the soccer fields. [1:31:16] And it seems to be performing. [1:31:18] And so that's, there is a cost differential there. [1:31:21] I can't actually tell you what it is, the difference in it. [1:31:25] But that was another option that was out there. [1:31:27] Otherwise we're usually an asphalt concrete or concrete. [1:31:31] Chris Titan. [1:31:38] This is actually for Mitch. [1:31:40] I'm a little bit confused again by this, [1:31:45] this because the application speaks for the reconsideration for adding the U-Haul and allowing [1:31:53] a paving deferral. [1:31:56] How does that interface with the four conditions? [1:32:02] Are there some subtractions and a paving deferral, does that infer the regrinder just the existing [1:32:10] surface? [1:32:11] Right. [1:32:12] The request is specifically, we'd like to add this use of U-Haul to our project. [1:32:19] That's part of the request. [1:32:20] The second part of the request is, and we also are requesting to have a defer of the [1:32:23] paving requirement. [1:32:24] So City Coats is parking, maneuvering house, or parking, or moving area, so it's a statement [1:32:30] in the City Coats. [1:32:31] So there's a requirement for paving, so they're asking for two things with this request. [1:32:36] One, can we add the use? [1:32:37] And two, can we defer on the paving requirement? [1:32:40] So that's the request and when we say this is the request, it's going to include their [1:32:47] entirety of their request. [1:32:49] The conditions as I've written say yes we're going to approve your request with a couple [1:32:54] of changes and some of those changes talk about you have to pay. [1:32:57] So basically your request was to have the use and waive the paving. [1:33:02] We're going to approve your request and add the use but not waive the paving. [1:33:07] So they're talking about specifically, you shall pay in these areas. [1:33:11] And then one, I guess, middle ground would be the reduced standard of the paving, [1:33:20] the regrind will allow you to do that instead of a full-on waiver. [1:33:26] So this is a request to add a use to further paving. [1:33:30] Yes, PNC recommends adding the use. [1:33:33] No, they don't recommend reducing the paving to nothing but rather to a lesser standard of the regrain [1:33:43] So to see you see one PUD [1:33:46] Amendment would allow all of this to happen if if we prove the crest as [1:33:52] recommended by planning and zoning Commission [1:33:55] The four or five conditions that are there then they would have to pave they would not get the deferral [1:34:00] But they would be allowed to pay with that reduced [1:34:02] standard of paving. If there's a desire to go ahead and allow a full defer, then we [1:34:10] can park through that in three years from today, five years, one year, whatever [1:34:16] we want to do, we can work through those. So the C1PUD amendment would not [1:34:25] speak to the regraining at all, it would be it has his basis then, that would [1:34:31] override a portion of those four. Okay, so to ask your question again, I want to make sure [1:34:40] I understand if we approve the amendment on the hearing tonight for the adding the [1:34:48] U-Haul rental and allowing a paving deferral that paving deferral removes a [1:34:55] requirement for a regrinding or any other modification to the parking surface. [1:35:00] Right, so I would look at the conditions being recommended by the Planning and Zoning Commission [1:35:09] are one through four up here. [1:35:10] The fifth one is one that the Council added and got approved on May 20th, okay, so that's [1:35:15] a Council added one. [1:35:17] But condition number two talks about paving the hard surface concrete or asphalt. [1:35:26] We could change that one or basically delete that one and replace it with whatever new one [1:35:31] comes in. [1:35:36] Condition number three is also talks about hard surface paving and then condition number [1:35:44] four is allowing the reduced regrine standard. [1:35:51] So really if you were inclined to grant a waiver for a time or whatever, 2, 3, and 4 should probably [1:35:59] all be examined and either thrown out or amended or just strike them, you know, approve it with [1:36:06] 1 and 5 because they're new, 6 or however we get there. [1:36:12] But 2, 3, and 4 from the PNC, I'll get at their paving recommendations. [1:36:17] Thank you. [1:36:18] This is part of the confusion I think we got to at that meeting. [1:36:22] Okay, so I'm going to try to simplify this. [1:36:26] The use is something that the council has gone forward and said the use sounds like it would be appropriate. [1:36:31] So number one in consultation with Fritzes, one of those things that is not necessarily up for consideration right now. [1:36:39] It's more of a conversation of what issues are you going to place upon the allowance to [1:36:47] do the U-Haul there. [1:36:50] And so if you look at what's listed up here, items number two, three, four, and five would [1:36:57] be subject to council review or an amendment. [1:37:00] So like Mitch shared, these are items that you can move forward as they are and say we [1:37:05] believe on that evening we were right. [1:37:07] You can strike them all, and you can say we believe on that evening we were wrong. [1:37:11] You could do some combination thereof. [1:37:13] And just a very quick consultation with Mr. Olson. [1:37:16] He is looking for basically the paving requirements in two and three to be deferred for a five-year [1:37:26] period of time. [1:37:27] I'm looking at Greg to make sure I get this right. [1:37:30] That the number four would go away in its entirety. [1:37:35] that number five would go away in its entirety based upon consultation that he had with the [1:37:42] owner of the property, not the presentation by the tenant. [1:37:47] And so Mr. Olsen to request is again a five year deferral for items number two and three, [1:37:56] and the removal of items four and five that appear up here. [1:38:02] I have a couple of questions, Troy. [1:38:08] What typically triggers a paving requirement? [1:38:17] I mean, I'm casting a mach on us. [1:38:20] We just recently built restrooms at Oregon Trail, but we didn't pay the part of it. [1:38:26] What is the purpose of the paving? [1:38:28] You've talked about the gravel and the grit and the whole things on the street. [1:38:32] What typically would trigger a paving requirement to wipe up the grapes that grab from the [1:38:40] closets or whatever it is? [1:38:41] I'm about that. [1:38:42] I go by there four or five days a week and he has cracked his neighbors to the east, [1:38:48] have gravel areas with trailers parked on them and all kinds of things along that line [1:38:52] and have all kinds of variety of uses on that property and you're overall looking at fairness. [1:39:03] So Troy, what would typically trigger the, [1:39:06] is that what it's dogging there? [1:39:09] Yeah, number B there, essentially, [1:39:11] since how it's supposed to be surfaced. [1:39:13] In most cases, and in this case, it's because it's a PUD, [1:39:16] and major building remodels, stuff like that, [1:39:19] anything that comes forward with a special use program, [1:39:22] it comes before planning the zoning. [1:39:24] And we see it as an opportunity to bring the code [1:39:27] into place and update everybody as possible. [1:39:32] Oregon Trail I know we've discussed that I believe that is city run facility and [1:39:40] our street crews are responsible for sweeping the roadways and so we're kind [1:39:44] of engine harming ourselves in that case so we have to go out there and sweep our own [1:39:49] roads and clean up our own mess. I think in the future we'll try to address that but that's [1:39:54] the budget and trapezine to talk about that. And is this requirement different for [1:40:00] different zones or some like again looking looking around just in the [1:40:04] general area that we're talking about you know it's in the town or that side of [1:40:08] town I noticed that like the Glamby parking lot they have a strip paved but [1:40:13] then you always see trucks parked out in the the gravel area or dirt area for that [1:40:19] matter is that requirement the same on M1 and the M2 that they're obviously [1:40:23] actually the manufacturing zones have a different [1:40:26] Okay, that's just part of the zoning. [1:40:31] All right. [1:40:32] This one happens to be C1 and PD. [1:40:35] So that's why it's. [1:40:36] Okay. Well, that was the question I had today. [1:40:38] Obviously you can see trucked park there in, in my, yes, the gravel areas. [1:40:43] I just wondered what, what, whether there was a difference. Okay. All right. [1:40:47] Well, we, we, you'll get some redialical time after the public hearing, right? [1:40:53] Or unless somebody asked you a question, Susan Hawkins. [1:40:56] Okay. [1:40:57] I just want to make sure, just because I wasn't the original planning and zoning meeting, the whole reason this issue came up is because Greg did not know that he could not have a U-Haul business and he was parking U-Hauls out there and the City Compliance Officer found it. [1:41:13] And that's how it got brought to our attention and that's what kind of makes him unique from his neighbors because of his PUD and because he stepped outside at what, you know, not knowingly, that's how it became an issue for him that it might not be with his neighbor at this point. [1:41:27] point and any time anybody goes forward to make a change and it comes before planning [1:41:32] and zoning, these same requirements will be handed down to those people at that time. [1:41:37] So that's what brought this one to the forefront of attention at this time. [1:41:43] Along with that, I had another train of thought here, I'm sorry. [1:41:51] I think if the PUD had originally been signed and turned in when it was supposed to, a lot [1:41:56] of this would have been made known to Greg at that time as well. So some of this has kind [1:42:00] of been a snowballing effect over the period of years of things that haven't happened on [1:42:05] both the city side and Greg side that should have happened. But the reason this is here [1:42:08] now is strictly because Sean diving by saw you hauls where they shouldn't have been. And [1:42:14] so that's how we got to this point tonight. And I just thought I'd clarify that because [1:42:17] Rebecca and I did have that knowledge. [1:42:19] Okay. Sean Berg has a great question. [1:42:22] Oh, I'm sorry, Don Hall. [1:42:24] Don's next. I apologize. I'm lying to Matt. I didn't call on it. [1:42:27] Okay. So one of my questions was what, how long of a deferral? So you've answered that. I appreciate that. [1:42:35] The other one, if you could throw it back up there. Number four, subject to undeveloped [1:42:39] and unpaid barriers having a substantial barrier to discourage use of the property per the engineering department require. [1:42:45] Tell me what that means again. [1:42:50] We didn't feel that this shouldn't go forward and he can park on all the hard surfaces, but the areas that were gravel or dirt or whatever [1:43:00] We felt if it wasn't buried off they would be used parked on [1:43:10] So that would be optimized for his his storage, so we were gonna bury her somehow so it couldn't be [1:43:16] Utilized, so what do you mean by barrier? Give me an example of how you would do that [1:43:21] I would say a small fence, parking blocks, anything that's not easily just taken down and removed [1:43:26] so people could cross it. [1:43:28] And he would be responsible for doing that in this recommendation? [1:43:31] Yeah, number four, either pave the area so nobody can, you know, some gentleman off the [1:43:37] street can't just pull in there and, you know, mine's people drive over all the time so something [1:43:43] a little bit more promising by Matt. [1:43:45] So we are, what we're saying is that we're going to not allow you to do it and we're going [1:43:50] going to make sure you don't do it. [1:43:52] Well, if he paid everything. [1:43:53] Basically, right? [1:43:54] I mean, if he doesn't pay, but OK. [1:43:57] If he wouldn't pay, but OK. [1:44:03] Thank you. [1:44:05] Summer. [1:44:06] Great to have a question for you. [1:44:10] Do you know the cost difference between full-on paving [1:44:13] and use of the regrind and the oil? [1:44:15] Ballpark. [1:44:16] Regrind is going to be between 25,000 and mass faults [1:44:20] between $45,000 and $50,000. [1:44:22] That's about 45% less for regrind. [1:44:27] to cover the entirety of what you're requesting to be [1:44:30] deferred. [1:44:31] Thank you. [1:44:32] Jim, thank you, Mayor. [1:44:35] I'm just looking at my Google map here. [1:44:38] And I see the Grand New Theater course, its gravel. [1:44:42] And didn't we remodel our golf course maintenance shed [1:44:49] and do all these upgrades to it? [1:44:50] We still have all that gravel parking [1:44:52] that we leave there next to the driving range? [1:44:54] gravels being been giving it better than the depth. [1:44:59] So it's just not fair that we're having our own buildings [1:45:03] where we worked. [1:45:04] We leave it gravel for parking, and then we're going to have [1:45:06] this guy cough up 50 grand to pave it. [1:45:14] Well, are we gravel, or we fix this parking lot here? [1:45:18] Let me get a public comment. [1:45:19] Are we still in the question? [1:45:20] Yeah, I'll start with you. [1:45:22] I guess I'm pontificating here, but I just want to talk about [1:45:25] fairness a little bit. [1:45:26] Well, we probably should wait to our discussions. [1:45:29] Okay, we need that. [1:45:31] We need to call additional lights for questions. [1:45:34] And I'll be asked by the name of the name of the hammer. [1:45:36] What was that? [1:45:37] I'm sure Rebecca Bels like us. [1:45:40] Thank you, Mayor. [1:45:41] I have a question for staff. [1:45:44] How does the city enforce, you know, [1:45:46] if you give someone a deferral, say, [1:45:50] give them three years to pave? [1:45:52] If the pavement doesn't done, I mean, what happens? [1:45:55] I mean, we don't shut people's businesses down, we don't. [1:45:58] I mean, can you really, if you give a deferral, [1:46:00] can you really take it away, can it really, [1:46:02] is it really a time limit? [1:46:05] I mean, sorry if that's theoretical, [1:46:07] but in a practical sense, how would the city, [1:46:12] yeah, maybe this is a question for Fritz. [1:46:13] Where's the teeth? [1:46:14] How does the city enforce their deferral? [1:46:17] So I can't tell you about tracking, [1:46:20] maybe Mitch needs to talk about that, [1:46:22] But when we're aware of it, and you may have been to some [1:46:26] of the P&Z meetings where somebody's not doing what they're [1:46:30] supposed to do, they bring them back before planning and zoning, [1:46:34] commission planning and zoning commission can act to revoke [1:46:37] any approvals that they've given for non-compliance. [1:46:41] And then if they don't comply then, we take them to court [1:46:45] because they're acting illegally. [1:46:47] OK, so it's done in the judicial system. [1:46:50] And so that's not just for a special use permit, [1:46:53] because I knew that you could revoke a special use permit, [1:46:54] but you can revoke any decision for new complaints. [1:46:57] You can't revoke any decision, but this [1:46:59] is a conditional approval. [1:47:01] So read for five years. [1:47:05] You're allowed to have a U-Haul business. [1:47:08] So he doesn't follow his condition [1:47:12] that he loses out on the approval of the U-Haul business. [1:47:18] And then if he continues, if he continues the use [1:47:20] exacting illegally and go to the courts for that, [1:47:24] if they don't comply. [1:47:25] And what's the punishment for that? [1:47:27] Is that just a fine? [1:47:29] Well, it's a general misdemeanor. [1:47:31] So maximum year in jail, a year in jail, $1,000 fine. [1:47:35] So it's a threat. [1:47:38] Thank you. [1:47:41] All right, so you know, additional lights, [1:47:43] we do need to open the public hearing to allow anyone [1:47:46] in the audience that came to speak on this particular issue. [1:47:49] And so I'll do that now. Do we have a list back there of any opening the public hearing [1:47:55] Someone might see if there's a list of those who chose to speak tonight. Thank you [1:48:12] Bill cop bill if you just the format of this is if you could just give your name and address [1:48:24] and then we'll give you two minutes and and [1:48:28] Don't be afraid of the 30 seconds. Don't have 30 seconds when I help that out. Yeah [1:48:32] We don't don't seem to have a lot of names on the nature. So we're probably gonna cut you off exactly it too [1:48:37] We might give a little bit. [1:48:39] Well, first of all, I just want to thank the Council for taking [1:48:41] the time to revisit the situation. [1:48:46] After the last session, Greg and I talked about it, [1:48:48] and it just seemed like it was utter confusion. [1:48:50] Nobody understood the motions, the andor, the amendments [1:48:53] to the motions, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. [1:48:55] So again, thank you for giving us your time again. [1:48:59] I just want to make a couple of comments. [1:49:02] With regard to storm water retention [1:49:04] that was mentioned by the City Engineer, [1:49:06] We spent many tens of thousands of dollars to generate our own storm retention up to and [1:49:13] including the hundred year potential storm scenario. [1:49:16] So I don't think that that's an issue. [1:49:18] With regard to the public roadways getting quote dirty because we don't have pavement back [1:49:23] in that rear storage area, again that's a non-concern because there are no public right [1:49:28] of ways close to that particular area. [1:49:31] There are no public roads right there. [1:49:33] We were backed up against private property, and that's owned by Argo. [1:49:38] Argo is all gravel and dirt, as is someone mentioned earlier. [1:49:43] I think it was Jim with regard to the golf course. [1:49:47] Dirt and gravel improvements, similar improvements have been made. [1:49:51] We're not asking for something that hasn't been done by others, [1:49:55] where these kinds of exceptions have been granted. [1:50:01] again to the point that Greg touched on earlier. [1:50:04] We built that facility in 07 and 08. [1:50:09] As you all know, that was the peak of the construction costs [1:50:13] ever. [1:50:14] And so our investment was extremely heavy. [1:50:17] And as a result, we saw the U-Haul as a potential [1:50:21] to generate some additional income. [1:50:23] At that point in time, we didn't know [1:50:25] that it was against the rules. [1:50:27] We put it in, hoping to generate a little additional income. [1:50:30] It's an alligator that we have to feed each and every month. [1:50:35] We have not yet made dollar profit number one [1:50:38] in that facility. [1:50:39] So when you folks come out as with something out of the blue [1:50:42] or what was appeared to be out of the blue [1:50:44] that we didn't know about, [1:50:46] and now we're asked to spend another $40,000 or $50,000 [1:50:49] to pave an area that basically is rather insignificant [1:50:54] in the overall scheme of things there. [1:50:57] It just seems like an extreme amount of money when we're not making any money on that whole [1:51:03] project at this point in time. [1:51:04] That's where asking for the deferral. [1:51:06] We're not saying a total exemption. [1:51:08] Give us an opportunity to take a look at this thing in three or five years, preferably [1:51:13] five years, and see just how things have come along and whether or not we've been able to [1:51:19] advance the operation. [1:51:20] It is slowly growing. [1:51:21] It is slowly growing. [1:51:22] I'll give you that. [1:51:23] hopefully within three to five years we'll be in a position where we can do that and not [1:51:28] really be in a hardship situation. So that's the nature of why we're here, folks. Again, [1:51:35] the deferral, non-exemption. Okay. Thank you very much for your time. [1:51:39] Typically, we wait for questions for those until everyone's at 10th speak. Alright, Chris. [1:51:45] Fine. Alright. I'll put you down to ask questions first. Okay, Darren Kyle, or Darryl, Kyle, excuse [1:51:52] It looks like two L's there, but it's actually a NANF. [1:51:57] My handwriting hasn't always been my special time, sorry. [1:52:00] Daring mile, but false. [1:52:02] Most of everything they said I had on my list as well. [1:52:07] We are just trying to make this a viable business as much as we can. [1:52:11] I think probably in the first meeting, Greg had mentioned that it was our intention and we have buildings and storage waiting to be erected on the site. [1:52:20] But when we got to that point in that late 2008 timeframe and cost-resulating and economy [1:52:30] was declining, we decided to put some of those on the back burner and table some of those back [1:52:35] buildings just because we knew this was going to be rough road in the next few years and it [1:52:42] has as Bill mentioned. [1:52:44] So Greg, to his credit, has done everything to try to make this a more violent business [1:52:49] We thought that U-Haul was a natural addition. [1:52:52] By no means thought it would create, [1:52:55] what the uproar that it did in being in violation of this PUD, [1:53:02] but we apologize. [1:53:05] Again, everything that is on our property that is not of a hard-surface nature is not on, [1:53:13] you know, the public really, truly public thoroughfares. [1:53:17] It's in the back of the section adjacent to those other businesses and they're really the only ones that see that [1:53:24] We did discuss a little bit about the the grid and the gravel that might travel on to the roads [1:53:29] I know that I understand that from Troy from the engineering perspective and makes perfect sense, but [1:53:34] We only have one exit there. You have to travel through our hard surface [1:53:39] After the gravel and the grid so it's going to dump it all mostly back on our own property before you exit the profit exit back [1:53:46] on to the roadway. So I just I appreciate your listening to this and the help you can provide [1:53:53] it for us to make this business venture a little more viable near term. Thank you. Thank you, [1:53:59] Darrell. Darren. I'll just plug you down here. It looks like Darrell won't be my chief here. [1:54:05] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:54:22] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:54:27] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:54:35] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:54:41] and my contention was that nobody would want to have a business across the road from R4 [1:54:49] as an actual property, and in all of this agreement and so forth that went to get this [1:54:57] approved, these items were part of them that that would be paved. I was not of the understanding [1:55:05] that even the storage of the fifth wheels, the motorhomes, the travel trailers, the votes, [1:55:12] the pickups, and all of that in the back were even a part of that was to be, it was [1:55:16] we paid, and no other business of any kind was to be there except just the storage buildings. [1:55:25] And so now the U-Haul comes in, and that's my contention. It won't stop there. I contended [1:55:35] that from before, and a very similar thing happened to me on the subdivision that went [1:55:42] and the developer wouldn't wait for idle power to move the poles, put the main water lines [1:55:50] over on my property on my half of the wealth line, and that has been a mess. [1:55:58] Anyway, so that's why I have posed this. [1:56:05] My contention would be to have him comply with what he agreed to do. [1:56:12] Thank you, Mr. Miller. [1:56:15] That's all I have on the list. [1:56:17] We have a few other people in the audience [1:56:19] that have the opportunity to speak, they would like. [1:56:22] Some of our regulars here, apparently, [1:56:25] don't want to speak on this either. [1:56:27] But we'll close the public hearing portion. [1:56:29] Chris, talking, I believe, had a question for one of those. [1:56:32] Yeah, it was for Bill, actually. [1:56:34] You made an dissertation that the city [1:56:38] is making demands out of the blue bill. [1:56:41] What do you refer to in that? [1:56:45] I guess I should have chosen my words a little more closely, Chris. [1:56:50] We were not aware that a U-Haul rental operation would require a special PUD permit in addition [1:57:03] to what we already have. [1:57:05] We just assumed that it was something that we could do without infringing upon anyone on [1:57:13] our property or an existing business. [1:57:16] So from my perspective, I said out of the blue because it was a surprise to us when the [1:57:23] Code Enforcement Officer for the City advised Greg that we couldn't have a rental unit there, [1:57:29] a U-Haul rental unit there. [1:57:31] And that was some, what, Greg, three or four months after we actually started renting units, [1:57:39] two or three months after the fact. [1:57:46] And only then were we surprised that we were not in compliance. [1:57:52] So that's why that was my... [1:57:54] So where was that of the blue? [1:57:56] Well, it was out of the blue us. [1:57:58] It may not have been out of the blue to the city staff, but we didn't know. [1:58:04] We had no idea that there was a special use permit required to put in a U-Haul facility. [1:58:11] We assumed, I assumed, and I guess maybe I shouldn't speak for Greg, but I assumed [1:58:17] that we were totally in compliance with everything that we were doing in that facility right [1:58:23] up until the day that the compliance officer notified us here a few months back that we [1:58:28] weren't. [1:58:29] So that was my terminology, Chris, I apologize for using the wrong word, but that's the nature [1:58:37] of it. [1:58:39] Rebecca, no second. [1:58:41] Thank you, Mayor, just as a follow-up question, more to staff, because in reading the history [1:58:47] of the property, you know, and I think we heard testimony on how it was a contentious [1:58:52] issue to taking our floor and turning into C1. But wasn't it that the PUD was specifically [1:58:59] for one commercial enterprise because, was it because of the issue? It has here in the [1:59:09] history that in 2008 originally when it came before the planning commission that it was [1:59:16] a recommended denial to even change the land use map to allow for commercial. And the city [1:59:27] council then later approved it. And so when it came through as a PUD was it stated at that [1:59:33] time. Do you know? [1:59:37] Yeah, the PUD that was approved in 2008 was a very, very specific PUD and allowed one [1:59:46] use of a storage warehouse place. And that was the only use permitted. And it's very uncommon. [1:59:53] We don't typically do that type of a thing with the PUD. But as that process went through [1:59:58] the, and a rather long process too, because it had a compliment amendment that had to have [2:00:03] first and it was contentious and the end result was a PUD that was very specific at a site plan [2:00:11] with some buildings and it said this is what can happen there and that's it and so yeah typically [2:00:18] we wouldn't do that with the PUD. Even if this was a straight C1 request that allowed everything [2:00:25] that's allowed in the C1 though a truck rental yard still requires an SUP but you know that's kind of [2:00:33] of a hypothetical scenario in this specific situation. [2:00:38] The PUD specifically allows one use [2:00:40] and that is currently the mini warehouse storage use [2:00:44] and that's it. [2:00:45] Okay, and so just maybe the applicant wasn't aware of it [2:00:48] but it was specifically for one use. [2:00:51] Okay. [2:00:53] That brings me to a question then. [2:00:57] That particular one, there seems to be a few of them [2:01:01] have popped up around town and do we have an SUP [2:01:04] for all those, I certainly haven't seen them come before us. [2:01:07] For the truck rentals? [2:01:08] Yeah. [2:01:09] They require an SUP when they go in. [2:01:11] Do they only come to? [2:01:13] SUPs are approved, or especially they're approved [2:01:16] by the Planning and Zoning Commission. [2:01:17] They come to the Council on appeal if there's an appeal. [2:01:19] I'm going to say, I haven't seen any. [2:01:21] They don't often make it to the Council. [2:01:23] All right, makes sense. [2:01:24] All right, Rebecca, we'll see you. [2:01:25] Thank you, Mayor. [2:01:26] And just as a quick response, I have seen a couple [2:01:28] of those U-Halls and they actually were identified [2:01:31] by the Code Enforcer. [2:01:32] I know the one over on Fillmore, next to Pullline. [2:01:37] They are actually prohibited from using the unpaid portion, [2:01:40] and they've complied with that. [2:01:42] And then there's one on Addison that we've also seen. [2:01:45] So I have to say. [2:01:46] All right. [2:01:47] Good. [2:01:48] I just say, but I forgot that we don't always see it. [2:01:49] It's a good question, yeah. [2:01:51] All right. [2:01:54] Any other questions for staff or the applicants? [2:01:59] Seeing none, Greg, if you've got some additional time, [2:02:02] if you would like to say anything else? [2:02:06] Oh yeah. [2:02:07] OK. [2:02:08] I got to miss Harkins on the signing of the PUD. [2:02:12] I specifically, if I would have gotten it, [2:02:16] I don't remember getting it. [2:02:18] I was, I did a cartwheel out front [2:02:20] when I got approved the last time. [2:02:23] And so if it was sent to me, there [2:02:25] would be no reason for me not saying that. [2:02:27] I'd like to say I would be irresponsible and take [2:02:30] responsibility for not signing it. [2:02:32] And I know it's a burr in your saddle, [2:02:34] but I really don't remember ever receiving it. [2:02:38] Or I would have signed it, because I mean, [2:02:39] I went through it in my head quite a few times [2:02:42] and thought, why wouldn't I sign it? [2:02:45] And I had absolutely no reason not to sign it. [2:02:47] So I don't know if that helped you out, [2:02:49] but certainly there's absolutely no reason [2:02:52] why I wouldn't have signed it. [2:02:54] As far as you all goes, it's contained [2:02:56] within the fenced area. [2:02:57] So we were required to do some sort of a stucco brick rock, [2:03:05] some sort of a face. [2:03:07] And what we did, we ended up doing a stamp [2:03:09] tilt up concrete on the front. [2:03:11] And then the fence, which faces the golf course, which is south. [2:03:18] To the south, so that's where we put the slats in, [2:03:24] because it faces us the city roadway. [2:03:26] Goes all the way to the end. [2:03:27] That's why they're not in the back. [2:03:29] And I read the code and it said, if it's facing a city roadway, [2:03:34] it needs to have some, the fencing needs to have some sort of a slat install. [2:03:38] And I think what Rebecca's question to Mitch, essentially, what City Council didn't want me [2:03:48] to do was rezone it to C1 and then go put a gas station on it. [2:03:51] I don't think that the spirit of the agreement was, okay, you can do a storage facility, [2:03:57] But you can't do anything else, you can't sell any boxes. [2:03:59] You can't rent you walls, you can't do. [2:04:01] I think the spirit of the agreement was, [2:04:03] you have to build a storage facility, [2:04:05] and anything contained within those walls [2:04:07] needs to be storage related. [2:04:09] And I think that was more of the spirit of the agreement [2:04:11] than you can't do anything else. [2:04:14] I mean, it wasn't, I think it was based on [2:04:17] don't build a gas station, build a convenience store, [2:04:19] but you know, those kind of things, [2:04:20] once you get a rezone and get what you want. [2:04:23] I mean, my intention was to build a storage facility [2:04:25] and to do businesses associated with that. [2:04:34] With the driving from the asphalt or from the gravel [2:04:37] to the paving, they have to go at least 300 feet [2:04:41] to get it to your city street. [2:04:43] So where Troy has to, Oregon Trail, [2:04:46] they have to sweep their own streets at your own cost. [2:04:52] 95% would be, I guess, of any material that was stuck to a tire. [2:04:59] come off in that 300 feet by the time they got to Grandview Drive. So, that's it. Thanks. [2:05:09] Thanks again. Great. We're still in the question portion. I'll leave public [2:05:15] hiring open for a short amount of time. Oh, I'm sorry. You're certainly within the time [2:05:22] since you're part of the ownership. He didn't use all of his time without a doubt. [2:05:26] I appreciate it. I'll just take a moment. I just wanted to reiterate the fact that the [2:05:30] The area that again is under discussion is the area toward the rear of our facility. [2:05:35] That's the lowest portion of our property. [2:05:38] And it is a considerable distance away from any public street. [2:05:45] The thing that I wanted to also say is folks, that's not a mud hole. [2:05:50] We have packed gravel in there. [2:05:53] It's been packed solid. [2:05:55] It's not hard top. [2:05:57] It's not black top, but it is hard surface. [2:06:00] So we're not tracking mud out of there every time a vehicle goes through that place. [2:06:04] And I just wanted to get that on the record, okay? [2:06:07] It's a pretty darn clean facility as it is. [2:06:12] Black top might make it just a tad bit more so, but it's not a problem the way it is. [2:06:16] And to the points made earlier, nothing is going to track out onto the, out onto Grandview [2:06:21] once they've had to go through all of our facility on the paved surface. [2:06:25] The other thing that I would like to just piggyback on to something that Greg said and [2:06:30] that was with regard to the slat of fence in item number five that the city council you [2:06:36] folks added last time. [2:06:39] According to the code that's not a requirement and according to the adjacent property owner, [2:06:46] our goal company, they do not necessarily ask for that and want it. [2:06:52] More cost on that, according to estimates that Greg has received, is approximately $2,000 [2:06:58] to do that, to buy the slats and then to install them. [2:07:01] Just the slats alone are roughly $1,500 plus tax, and then we have to install them. [2:07:08] Our bid is right at $2,000, but that's $2,000, quite frankly, we don't have in the bank right [2:07:13] now. [2:07:14] And then as much as it's not a requirement of the code, it's not a requirement of the [2:07:20] Jason property owner it is not a facing a public right away I would ask that you [2:07:26] please remove that from any consideration when you when you discuss the issue in [2:07:33] hand okay thank you very much I you refresh our memory I if you I remember [2:07:38] you talking about last time and you mentioned it briefly about the the [2:07:42] drainage what did you install to for the hundred-year flood thing I remember you [2:07:47] talk about a filter but I'm not sure I can remember exactly what you did. If I [2:07:50] may Greg I'd like to defer that. Sure. He is much more knowledgeable about that [2:07:56] than I because he was the one that signed all the contracts to get that all [2:08:00] thought I just got right in the checks to pay for it. Thanks Bill. Go ahead Greg. [2:08:04] There's two right here from there to there. There's two 200 foot 8 foot by 8 foot [2:08:15] in diameter, CMP pipes, corrugated metal pipe. [2:08:21] The end caps on the 50-year storm [2:08:25] are about four foot, they're right in the center [2:08:28] of the pipe, and then I think the 100 years at six foot, [2:08:31] both of those drain into sandal separator, [2:08:35] which is across the street. [2:08:38] Right there, we bought that property from the millers, [2:08:41] and then I got approval from the city, [2:08:43] from the canal company, and we actually [2:08:45] Discharge that water after it goes through the sandal separator into the Cooley [2:08:50] Instead of into the ground because it recharges and the farmers could use it rather than [2:08:56] Putting it back in the ground and it dissipates. Okay. Thank you. Great. I I couldn't remember what I've never you said [2:09:02] You had a filters [2:09:08] Mitch just so I know we hit we're still in the question answer time. I just wanted to [2:09:13] When we get ready, when we get out, [2:09:16] after we have our debate, and we make a motion possibly, [2:09:20] the motion, if a guy wanted to make a motion [2:09:24] to remove some items and do a deferral, [2:09:28] what does that look like for what we have? [2:09:31] Fritz, you can help me with that. [2:09:33] So it would be a motion to approve the request [2:09:36] with whatever conditions you think you need to attach. [2:09:40] Thank you. [2:09:44] All right, so you know they're like for quit. Oh, Chris. You're quite right. I'm all right. Oh, bitch [2:09:49] I just want I mean bill said something is last bit that I just wanted to kind of verify so you [2:09:55] You have it from two sources. I guess [2:09:58] Screening is not required between two adjacent commercial uses in the in the city code [2:10:03] So that's why there were no slats put there in the first place [2:10:06] even if screening were required in the city code the [2:10:10] The code also allows the adjacent property owner [2:10:15] to opt out of the screening. [2:10:17] So we provide for that scenario. [2:10:20] So if the adjacent property doesn't care about screening, [2:10:22] they can write a letter says no, I don't care about screening. [2:10:25] So Bill mentioned that and I just thought [2:10:28] I'd throw that out there. [2:10:29] Yeah, he's right. [2:10:30] We don't require screening of this scenario normally, [2:10:34] even if we did the adjacent property owner [2:10:37] could opt out of that. [2:10:39] All right, Suzanne Hockett. [2:10:42] Before Chris makes the motion, I just [2:10:44] want to throw something out. [2:10:45] Or is the public hearing still? [2:10:46] Public hearing isn't closed yet. [2:10:48] OK. [2:10:48] We're not going to discuss you. [2:10:50] We're still questioning. [2:10:51] OK, I just heard Chris that he was ready to make a motion. [2:10:53] So I just wanted to make sure we were. [2:10:55] Right, if we're making a motion, you can still discuss afterwards. [2:10:58] But you can't ask questions. [2:10:59] Right, but I just want to make a, before he makes a motion, [2:11:02] I have something on with a wrap. [2:11:03] That's all. [2:11:03] OK, is it a question? [2:11:04] Or, OK, well, not quite the process, [2:11:07] but we'll see where it's Rebecca. [2:11:10] Thank you. [2:11:12] I do have a question. [2:11:13] I guess more of a comment. [2:11:16] If my memory serves me right, I think that was added based [2:11:20] on the public testimony. [2:11:22] I believe that the applicant, maybe this is my question. [2:11:24] I believe that. [2:11:24] It said that I think the only reason it was passed [2:11:27] is that they said they'd be glad to do some screening, [2:11:30] to be a good neighbor. [2:11:32] But I understand. [2:11:33] And I think that's really the only reason it was added. [2:11:37] But if, do we have, I saw another question, [2:11:42] do we have any testimony or written or verbal [2:11:46] of the property owner? [2:11:48] I mean, we had a public hearing, but no one came. [2:11:50] Well, I mean, some people came, but no one of this testimony [2:11:54] came, so I just don't know what to think of that. [2:11:59] Because the last decision that we had made was. [2:12:03] We had a tennis, a previous one, of the property [2:12:07] next door but not the owner. We have not received any official correspondence for [2:12:14] tonight's public hearing. Okay thank you. The minutes from the last meeting [2:12:18] reflect the adjacent the tenant. His name was Mike Jones who talked about the [2:12:24] ISO or you know those kinds of comments that he made and and that was as I recall [2:12:28] here. I have the same recollection he did. Right. That that condition came as a [2:12:32] result of that tenants comments at the public hearing. I just wanted to remind [2:12:38] you that tonight you've received additional evidence and testimony but you [2:12:43] have all the other testimony and evidence you received at the first [2:12:48] area. All right. Suzanne did you want to make the comment or well what's close [2:12:58] what's going on post-public hearing and turn it over to council for our [2:13:03] our deliberations, it's actually more appropriate for the motion to be made in them to discuss [2:13:11] and I realize we don't do that always. Your light was on first so I will give you a shot [2:13:15] here and then. I guess it was just more of a general discussion with the council. I just [2:13:22] wanted to throw out that I have been opposed to this because I feel like the applicant [2:13:27] has already had a deferral since his PUD was signed five years ago and the paving hasn't [2:13:32] been completed in that time. [2:13:34] But if you guys are interested, I would be [2:13:36] willing to compromise on a smaller deferral like one or two [2:13:39] years rather than three or five, because I feel like they've [2:13:42] already had a number of years to work through some of this. [2:13:45] And as a small business owner, I understand the ups and downs [2:13:48] and the heads and flows and the hardship. [2:13:49] And I don't want to create a hardship where it doesn't need [2:13:52] to be. [2:13:53] But I don't think that that extended of a period is fair either. [2:13:57] And I just wanted to throw that up before emotion was made, [2:13:59] in case a motion maker wanted to consider that. [2:14:01] Okay, Chris, Dr. Hearing that and trying to not disassemble as much as we did last time, [2:14:09] I'll propose a motion to approve an amendment to the mini storage facility C1 PUD agreement, [2:14:17] 6.4 acres, approximately located at 485 Grand View Drive, Cara Greg Olsen, Mojo LLC, [2:14:26] to include adding a U-Haul rental business and allowing a three year paving deferral and utilizing in the interim a what is described as a regrined oil surfacing and also in that amendment to the PUD to delete items four and five of the [2:14:55] the planning and zoning's earlier recommendations. [2:15:01] I'll second. [2:15:03] OK, so I'm going to get that clear in my mind. [2:15:06] So whenever I'm trying to explain it at the end, I can't. [2:15:10] So if I were to read your motion correctly, Chris, [2:15:14] as you are allowing for the storage, [2:15:18] you're deferring pavement for three years, [2:15:21] but you're still requiring the regret. [2:15:25] a substitute non-permanent surfacing that is correct, [2:15:29] and deleting items four and five. [2:15:31] Okay, but so the only, [2:15:34] I'm not sure that changes anything from West, I do. [2:15:37] It's a motion that can be amended. [2:15:39] It can be dealt with, hasn't received this. [2:15:41] Oh, it did receive this. [2:15:42] Yeah, a second. [2:15:43] All right. [2:15:44] Chamber. [2:15:46] So on discussion on that motion, [2:15:48] I would actually agree with your assessment, Mayor. [2:15:51] I think that is exactly what we approved last time, [2:15:53] except that we struck four and five, [2:15:55] because the motion that we approved last time talks [2:16:00] about it talked about it references the engineering, [2:16:10] is that our motion right there? [2:16:15] OK, it doesn't. [2:16:18] Is the recommendation of planning the zoning commission [2:16:20] actually took into account the re-grant? [2:16:22] Because it referenced the engineering department's [2:16:28] alternative from the staff report. [2:16:32] And I get the feeling that that is exactly what the applicant does not want to do, because [2:16:38] that's a $25,000 to $30,000 cost. [2:16:43] Donald? [2:16:44] I'm just going to tell you where I'm at with this, and I'm not going to be in support of [2:16:47] this motion because it takes us right back to where we are right now. [2:16:51] I'm in support of deleting both four and five with the additional testimony and information [2:16:56] we have tonight. [2:16:58] And I was leaning towards a five-year deferral, but I think probably, well, I'd be happy with [2:17:04] either a three or five-year deferral. [2:17:06] I just understand the economics of this. [2:17:12] We've been in a downturn. [2:17:13] We're starting to come out of that downturn, and I want to give a business, a fighter's [2:17:18] chance to start making some money. [2:17:20] That's why we're in business. [2:17:22] So I would be in support of that into three or five year deferral along with extricating [2:17:30] four and five. [2:17:31] We're back in this second. [2:17:35] Thank you, Eric. [2:17:36] I seconded the motion for discussion and I do support it. [2:17:41] And only for the fact that I think there just needs to be a consistency and I think the [2:17:46] regrind is an option to everyone and I certainly understand economic times, certainly sympathize [2:17:53] economically, but honestly, you would have to then change city policy, which I am for. [2:18:00] If we need to change the city code, I think that's what we need to do instead of make [2:18:05] these exceptions and deferrals, because currently we have two other U-haul businesses that we've [2:18:11] said, no, you can't utilize your unpaid portion of your property. [2:18:16] And I think that needs to be consistent, or there needs to be extenuating circumstances, [2:18:20] physical circumstances where you cannot or need not pave. [2:18:28] I wasn't here for the tractor deferral. [2:18:30] I know that it was made because it was stated [2:18:32] that tractors naturally tear up pavement. [2:18:36] And so that was the physical necessity of the deferral. [2:18:41] I think the city does need to address their own compliance [2:18:45] with the code and I think that we should do that. [2:18:48] but until we change the city code, [2:18:51] I think every business could probably say, [2:18:57] this is a financial hardship, it just is, [2:18:58] and it's a part of the code that is a financial hardship, [2:19:02] and so I just struggle not for lack of wanting to defer it, [2:19:08] but I think that the regrind is something [2:19:09] that the city has approved for the county [2:19:12] and all of the deferrals that I've been a part of, [2:19:15] the regrind has been a more affordable option, [2:19:18] So that's why I support the motion. [2:19:21] Hello, I have a question that I had [2:19:23] and one of the other council members had the same question. [2:19:25] This is questions of Fritz. [2:19:27] We can still ask legal questions, I believe. [2:19:33] If we choose not to amend this motion [2:19:35] and just to vote on it and say it goes down, [2:19:38] can we go ahead and have another motion after the fact? [2:19:41] Yeah, but it's, and that's what I'm watching here [2:19:44] and I'm seeing a train wreck. [2:19:46] So I wish, if some of you, [2:19:49] And I think I see some support of it. [2:19:50] Think that there ought to be just a straight out deferral. [2:19:53] If you just make the motion to amend [2:19:54] and see if it would fly or not, I wish you'd do it. [2:19:57] Because otherwise, we've got to vote. [2:19:59] And I think a bunch of you aren't going to like it, [2:20:02] and you're going to vote no. [2:20:03] And then it's hard to know where we are. [2:20:06] Makes sense. [2:20:07] All right. [2:20:07] Let's go ahead and go with the lights in order here. [2:20:10] Suzanne Pockis and Jim Munn, and then Donald. [2:20:14] I agree with Rebecca that we need to stick by our codes [2:20:16] and enforce our laws. [2:20:18] The difference between this U-Haul and the other ones that we are not allowing to use their spaces. [2:20:22] The other ones are not planning on building on that land in the near future. [2:20:26] So I think as reasonable adults we have to remember that- [2:20:30] We don't know their plans. [2:20:31] They didn't come and ask for that for that reason and this is a specific case where they have. [2:20:37] And so I want to see them compliant, I want to see them get it done. [2:20:42] That's why I'm not comfortable and I can't support a five year deferral. [2:20:45] I think that is just too long. [2:20:46] I think they're asking for too much. [2:20:48] And I think a shorter deferral to give them the chance [2:20:51] to get their finances in place and either build [2:20:54] or they're not going to do their business on that land. [2:20:58] I can understand that as a business owner [2:21:01] and I think we have to take each situation [2:21:03] as it comes to us and not all situations are the same. [2:21:06] And it's hard not to put everything into the same category. [2:21:10] So again, I would like to see this business [2:21:13] have a chance to succeed, but I cannot justify five years [2:21:17] my mind. The motion was three years. Yes, but you also wanted to have to put in a [2:21:21] regrind and what they're saying is we're gonna build there so to have to put in [2:21:29] that expense and then rip it out is a huge expense to a small business owner. I [2:21:32] understand that going through the the reconstruction of Blue Lakes as a small [2:21:38] business owner. I know that how those things that you don't plan for can sneak [2:21:42] up on you and you have to survive where you have to survive and I'd like to see [2:21:47] the business succeed but again they've already had five years and I don't think [2:21:51] another five years is reasonable. [2:21:53] Jim, thank you Mayor. So the motion right now is an item number two to make the [2:22:00] deferral for three years and require the reground after that period of time. [2:22:04] No, right away. Right away. Okay. I would I would move for an amendment, okay, and [2:22:11] And the amendment is this, work with me. [2:22:14] On item number two, I would amend that requirement to just simply defer the hard servicing for [2:22:24] three years. [2:22:26] On item number three, I would amend that motion to simply defer the hard service for three [2:22:38] years. [2:22:40] All the other items would remain the same, remove number four and not require number five. [2:22:46] Second. [2:22:47] I'm not sure which one got the good in there, but Sean's on my good here, so he's going [2:22:53] to get it. [2:22:54] You always get a bonus be on the set. [2:22:57] Yeah. [2:22:58] All right. [2:22:59] So that we have amendment to the main motion that would change the main motion to granted [2:23:05] deferral for a hard surf scene for a period of three years and everything else [2:23:12] remained the same. Is it clear that that's what the amendment is? Four or five go [2:23:16] away three years. Three years on two and three in one stage because we really [2:23:21] can't mess with one. So you know what it's like is that address the potential [2:23:28] train wrecking? Yeah don't hear the train coming. So this is where we now voting [2:23:34] on the amendment, which is as just stated, Rebecca Milsek, it has a comment first. [2:23:41] Thank you, Mayor. [2:23:43] Well with this amendment, the motion is exactly as I understood the original motion that was [2:23:49] voted down. [2:23:50] So I guess I would vote for it for three years, you know, granted, is there a revisiting or how [2:23:57] do you enforce after the three years? [2:24:01] So it's a three-year deferral. [2:24:03] So he has to do it three years, unless he comes back to you and says, [2:24:07] give us whatever reason, and he needs another deferral. [2:24:10] So it's basically a time limit, and when that day comes. [2:24:14] He has to do it unless you guys change it. [2:24:17] Okay. [2:24:21] So you know additional rights to that, a roll call vote on the amendment. [2:24:24] Yes. [2:24:26] Yes. [2:24:28] Yes. [2:24:30] Yes. [2:24:31] Yes. [2:24:32] Yes. [2:24:34] Yes. [2:24:35] Yes. [2:24:36] Yes. [2:24:37] The amendment passes seven to zero that brings us back to the main motion as amended at this point [2:24:45] Doesn't change much from the amendment which still one is one is still in place four and five of those [2:24:51] Recommendations last I are gone two and three have been changed to three years [2:24:57] deferral for any kind of hard surfacing at this point [2:25:01] Okay, is everyone turn that does that make sense to you gentlemen? I think I'm trying to make sure it makes sense to everybody [2:25:08] Yeah, it's kind of about a worker business motion was a deferral for asphalt, but put in right yes regrind and that's been amended so that [2:25:24] No [2:25:27] Standby I just want to make sure everybody in the room understands where we're at love how we equate it to John Verger [2:25:33] I just want to clarify here, so I am going to be supportive of this motion, but I want [2:25:40] to make a couple of comments related to the commentary, both from the public hearing perspective [2:25:46] and the comments we keep venturing around. [2:25:48] If this is a fairness issue and it's all about whether or not we have the Oregon Trail baseball [2:25:54] park in lot paid, we are going to come and we're going to have very astute applicants [2:26:03] come before us, and we are going to continue to debate amongst ourselves that how can we [2:26:08] enforce this upon the poor business people of Twin Falls when we don't even do it ourselves. [2:26:14] So are you speaking as a chamber member or a council person now? [2:26:20] No, Chris, what I'm trying to tell you is if the argument is always going to boil down to [2:26:27] well you're not paving your street, your parking lot city, so therefore I'm having a hardship, [2:26:33] We need to either pay for our parking lots or get rid of this piece of code because, honestly, [2:26:39] this is how this debate is going to be every time and I appreciate hardships, but I also [2:26:47] appreciate that we have a code for a reason which we heard from our assistant city engineer [2:26:51] tonight. [2:26:53] So I just think that we need to take a good hard look at this particular requirement, because [2:27:01] because it's going to keep coming back to us and keep coming back to us. [2:27:04] And tell you what, if I were an applicant standing out there and it cost me $10 to pay [2:27:08] for my parking lot, I would probably tell you it's a terrible hardship on me. [2:27:13] And by the way, you haven't paved your baseball park park and let either city. [2:27:17] So I just think if the philosophy of this keeps coming back to the same points, [2:27:22] we're going to keep debating this and keep coming back to this fairness issue [2:27:27] that I think people have a valid point on. [2:27:29] I think that this is a reasonable accommodation regarding businesses. [2:27:43] We're not at that 50,000 yet, but we need to move that direction. [2:27:47] I get, we need to start paving things and move that direction so that we can be in compliance [2:27:53] and show good faith. [2:27:55] I think that, again, this is reasonable, and I think it's reasonable also for the city, [2:28:01] I always like to tell people, by the way, we are all the city, it's not this entity, it's you. [2:28:06] If you live in the city, you're the city. [2:28:08] We need to be moving towards these regulations as well. [2:28:12] We've given ourselves to furls, and we need to start working on those parking lots and [2:28:18] those issues as well, and I think that we're going to be doing that, and I would hope that [2:28:23] city staff takes a note that we will continue to move down that direction. [2:28:28] reasonable because we are all city members here and it's reasonable for businesses I will [2:28:35] be in support of this motion tonight. Jim. Thank you, Mayor. I was the one pontificating [2:28:41] probably out of order in regards to the fairness issue. If we as a city government don't get [2:28:48] our ducks in order and start complying with the code, it's comparable to allowing the constable [2:28:56] to drive down the street speeding but it's not okay for you to do it. I really [2:29:02] believe that and I think there's a tendency for us to lose faith in our [2:29:06] local government when we allow those things to happen. That's why I think this [2:29:10] is so important for us to get our ducks in order. So I will support this [2:29:14] amendment and I think along with that we need to move forward as a city [2:29:19] government so you have faith in us to do the right thing and get our golf course [2:29:24] parking lot in order, and these other deferrals in order, or we people lose state this. [2:29:32] I think in the year and a half this current council has been together, I believe this has [2:29:36] come up three times now, so that's probably the only thing we're agreeing to tonight. [2:29:42] Rather than, and nobody can dispute the fairness standard when the city does not have some of [2:29:47] its own operations, meaning the standards that we expect the businesses to comply with. [2:29:55] I think the council needs to look at the bigger issue though, because I don't see any impetus [2:30:00] to change but to cut slack for some businesses based upon economic hardship, when in fact this [2:30:06] is an issue that's going to be driven by federal and state runoff and pollution permit [2:30:11] standards. [2:30:12] And we're going to find ourselves in a highly untenable situation if we don't conduct some [2:30:18] better and more permanent and universal resolution of these paving standards. [2:30:25] I can't understand why we cannot, first of all, on all these deferral permits have the [2:30:34] city send out the registered letter return receipt required and keep the tickle files [2:30:40] so there's no confusion. [2:30:43] I don't understand why. [2:30:44] You cannot have perhaps a little less strenuous standard on paving that isn't as difficult [2:30:50] to comply with than a four-inch concrete pad or an asphalt mat. [2:30:56] I'd like to explore more of this regrining as more of a permanent solution. [2:31:02] But I would guess the only thing else that I'd guarantee is by the end of year we'll [2:31:07] probably have other applicants coming in claiming hardships and how are we going to do with that. [2:31:13] What are we going to do with that? [2:31:14] when that may not be addressing the longer term pollution permit [2:31:18] that we're going to have you around the city shoulders here. [2:31:22] It can allow the blue in virtually any time. [2:31:25] And it gets down to does the applicant take that [2:31:30] out of their own pocket or is that put on the public tax [2:31:33] rules to comply with mitigating? [2:31:40] I'm not sure on the big game, I'm assuming [2:31:42] laws were issuing deferrals that would never [2:31:44] be our time to pay somebody else's parking lot. [2:31:48] We're out right, so you know you don't have to do it, [2:31:51] then yeah, we may be in that category. [2:31:53] All right, so you know additional lights, [2:31:56] the animal call vote. [2:31:59] Yes. [2:32:01] Right line please. [2:32:02] Yes. [2:32:03] Yes. [2:32:06] Yes. [2:32:07] Yes. [2:32:09] Yes. [2:32:11] Yes. [2:32:13] Most pass seven to zero. [2:32:16] I never think you'd jump in one of the things [2:32:18] that's for my step in the right direction. [2:32:19] May I make a comment about Greg's shoes and socks? [2:32:22] Could you let us know when you're going to wear those so I can wear my sunglasses? [2:32:30] All right, we are moving, Rebecca feels like. [2:32:36] I do have a comment based on our conversation. I would like staff and ask for Council's permission to have staff review this requirement. [2:32:45] And if at the end of the review, maybe if regrind is an option, let's put that in the code. [2:32:52] address issues in the code so that we don't have to keep coming back and wondering [2:32:57] when should we give an exception, when should we not, and if at the end it is [2:33:01] engineering's recommendation that, you know, maybe we just need to add the [2:33:06] regrinder. Whatever you think needs to be adjusted, I think it should be [2:33:11] reviewed. [2:33:13] And do that to our own parking lots? Yes, exactly, and comply. [2:33:19] So we don't speed anymore [2:33:23] All right, I remember eight moving back to it is a the German to exacting session [2:33:29] 67 to three four five one [2:33:32] Be [2:33:36] Second by John Hall [2:33:40] Seeing the lights [2:33:43] Yes [2:33:45] Yes [2:33:48] Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 7-0. We will not be coming out and making any [2:33:57] decisions. So the press can confidently leave and know they're not going to miss anything.