WEBVTT

00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:02.000
I'm trying to meet them so can we?

00:00:02.000 --> 00:00:04.000
Don't you have a memorize?

00:00:04.000 --> 00:00:07.000
Give them a little thing here. I can open this up and look at it.

00:00:07.000 --> 00:00:11.640
62, 3, 4, 5, 1, save.

00:00:11.640 --> 00:00:13.640
Subsection L.

00:00:13.640 --> 00:00:21.080
It's 1C.

00:00:21.080 --> 00:00:26.930
I was reading this in the middle of reading it.

00:00:26.930 --> 00:00:28.930
The last one apparently.

00:00:28.930 --> 00:00:38.180
I was just going to try to find it, but I was at the end of the document.

00:00:38.180 --> 00:00:40.860
Do you have a book for me today?

00:00:40.860 --> 00:00:43.860
All right, that's all right, we just do this.

00:00:43.860 --> 00:00:44.860
Yeah.

00:00:44.860 --> 00:00:46.860
You're right, right?

00:00:46.860 --> 00:00:47.860
Hit it.

00:00:47.860 --> 00:00:48.860
Hit it better.

00:00:48.860 --> 00:00:54.780
I can call the, to order the Monday for me.

00:00:54.780 --> 00:00:59.780
Twin Falls City Council meeting for Monday, May 6, 2013.

00:00:59.780 --> 00:01:02.780
This is a special beginning for our meeting.

00:01:02.780 --> 00:01:05.780
We're going to go ahead and do an executive session.

00:01:05.780 --> 00:01:10.780
If the council so desires exactly seven, sixty seven, two, three, four, five, one,

00:01:10.780 --> 00:01:13.940
to conduct deliberations concerning labor negotiations

00:01:13.940 --> 00:01:15.940
or to acquire an interest in real property,

00:01:15.940 --> 00:01:19.060
which is not owned by a public agency.

00:01:19.060 --> 00:01:20.580
And Council wishes.

00:01:20.580 --> 00:01:21.420
So moved.

00:01:21.420 --> 00:01:22.260
Second.

00:01:22.260 --> 00:01:24.620
It's been moved by Don Hall and then seconded by Chris

00:01:24.620 --> 00:01:27.420
talking that we move into the executive session.

00:01:27.420 --> 00:01:30.420
And we do have, and I didn't talk about the form,

00:01:30.420 --> 00:01:33.060
we do have six of seven here.

00:01:33.060 --> 00:01:34.860
Leyla Rojovok.

00:01:34.860 --> 00:01:35.700
Don Hall?

00:01:35.700 --> 00:01:36.540
Yes.

00:01:36.540 --> 00:01:37.460
Susan Hawkins?

00:01:37.460 --> 00:01:38.300
Yes.

00:01:38.300 --> 00:01:39.100
Greg Lansing.

00:01:39.100 --> 00:01:42.040
Yes.

00:01:42.040 --> 00:01:50.500
Great. Jim on yes. Rebecca Mills like that. Yes. Yes. Motion passes six to zero. We will come

00:01:50.500 --> 00:02:01.140
me come back into regular session at five o'clock for our normal agenda items and with that we're

00:02:01.140 --> 00:02:03.140
We recess into executive session

00:02:21.000 --> 00:02:23.410
I can do radio

00:02:37.730 --> 00:02:38.730
Yeah.

00:02:38.730 --> 00:02:39.730
Yeah.

00:02:39.730 --> 00:02:40.730
Yeah.

00:02:40.730 --> 00:02:41.730
Yeah.

00:02:41.730 --> 00:02:42.730
Yeah.

00:02:42.730 --> 00:02:43.730
Yeah.

00:02:43.730 --> 00:02:44.730
Yeah.

00:02:44.730 --> 00:02:45.730
Yeah.

00:02:45.730 --> 00:02:46.730
Yeah.

00:02:46.730 --> 00:02:47.730
Yeah.

00:02:47.730 --> 00:02:48.730
Yeah.

00:02:48.730 --> 00:02:49.730
Yeah.

00:02:49.730 --> 00:02:50.730
Yeah.

00:02:50.730 --> 00:02:51.730
Yeah.

00:02:51.730 --> 00:02:52.730
Yeah.

00:02:52.730 --> 00:02:56.640
Yeah.

00:02:56.640 --> 00:02:57.640
Yeah.

00:02:57.640 --> 00:02:58.640
Yeah.

00:02:58.640 --> 00:02:59.640
Yeah.

00:02:59.640 --> 00:03:00.640
Yeah.

00:03:00.640 --> 00:03:01.640
Yeah.

00:03:01.640 --> 00:03:02.640
Yeah.

00:03:02.640 --> 00:03:03.640
Yeah.

00:03:03.640 --> 00:03:04.640
Yeah.

00:03:04.640 --> 00:03:05.640
Yeah.

00:03:05.640 --> 00:03:06.640
Yeah.

00:03:06.640 --> 00:03:07.640
Yeah.

00:03:07.640 --> 00:03:08.640
Yeah.

00:03:08.640 --> 00:03:09.640
Yeah.

00:03:09.640 --> 00:03:14.010
I know you're making a water.

00:03:14.010 --> 00:03:16.010
Anybody want a water?

00:03:16.010 --> 00:03:18.010
Yes, I want a water.

00:03:18.010 --> 00:03:20.490
Where are we headed?

00:03:20.490 --> 00:03:23.870
Yes, you're right.

00:03:23.870 --> 00:03:25.870
Now you can't do that.

00:03:25.870 --> 00:03:28.860
I'm going to get a new mansion.

00:03:28.860 --> 00:03:30.860
Are you a rock and a car?

00:03:30.860 --> 00:03:32.860
Did they take my mics in here?

00:03:32.860 --> 00:03:35.500
On your head.

00:03:35.500 --> 01:10:52.120
Oh, that's okay.

01:10:52.120 --> 01:10:58.510
We need to find him.

01:10:58.510 --> 01:11:10.330
Hey, baby.

01:11:10.330 --> 01:11:12.330
Thirty minutes.

01:11:12.330 --> 01:11:35.770
stuff out. I'm so you got to think about what you're doing and where you're going

01:11:35.770 --> 01:11:51.670
and what all your handling and standing and like oh absolutely I look at Southwest

01:11:51.670 --> 01:11:55.790
who let you check to for free and they're more expensive even going with others

01:11:55.790 --> 01:12:08.770
and checking you know you have to compare no matter what you're doing and

01:12:08.770 --> 01:12:20.800
and each and every time absolutely awesome and I'm very please know I am very

01:12:20.800 --> 01:15:16.680
Yeah.

01:15:16.680 --> 01:16:15.280
Yeah.

01:16:15.280 --> 01:16:16.890
Yes.

01:16:16.890 --> 01:16:57.930
Should I do it again?

01:16:57.930 --> 01:17:31.760
So.

01:17:31.760 --> 01:21:01.670
Let's just say no.

01:21:01.670 --> 01:21:03.670
It has a different meaning here.

01:21:03.670 --> 01:21:07.240
You don't have school.

01:21:07.240 --> 01:21:08.240
Right.

01:21:08.240 --> 01:25:30.740
Okay.

01:25:30.740 --> 01:25:31.740
I'm going to send you an email.

01:25:31.740 --> 01:30:13.160
I just want to say where we got the money.

01:30:13.160 --> 01:31:03.150
I'd like to reconvene the Twin Falls City Council meeting for May 6th to the regular 5 o'clock meeting.

01:31:03.150 --> 01:31:06.150
I do have a voice count that is agreed to come up and lead us in the pledge.

01:31:06.150 --> 01:31:10.150
So if you come forward now, that's always our first item of business is the pledge.

01:31:10.150 --> 01:31:15.160
We'll take you home.

01:31:15.160 --> 01:31:16.160
All right, that's fine.

01:31:16.160 --> 01:31:17.160
All right, go ahead.

01:31:17.160 --> 01:31:22.410
I'd like to introduce to the flag of the United States of America

01:31:22.410 --> 01:31:25.410
and to the Republic for which it stands,

01:31:25.410 --> 01:31:31.250
One nation under God, individual with liberty and justice for all.

01:31:31.250 --> 01:31:33.410
And you can go down to the mic and

01:31:33.410 --> 01:31:35.610
there are a few questions for you.

01:31:35.610 --> 01:31:37.810
He's a person you need to tell me about.

01:31:37.810 --> 01:31:41.210
And that was the first for somebody to come all the way up here, but that's-

01:31:41.210 --> 01:31:43.010
I like it actually, yeah.

01:31:43.010 --> 01:31:45.110
Alright, if you go ahead and tell us your name.

01:31:45.110 --> 01:31:47.110
My name is Logan Barfis.

01:31:47.110 --> 01:31:48.810
Okay, and what's your troop number?

01:31:48.810 --> 01:31:50.010
161.

01:31:50.010 --> 01:31:51.310
And where do you meet at?

01:31:51.310 --> 01:31:53.610
Me at the LDS Caswell Building.

01:31:53.610 --> 01:31:54.210
Okay.

01:31:54.210 --> 01:31:58.770
and what mayor battery working on I'm working on citizenship in the community all right well thank

01:31:58.770 --> 01:32:05.760
you very much for leading us in the place very we do have quorum all seven members are here

01:32:06.800 --> 01:32:13.990
uh introduction of staff city manager Travis Rothweiler city attorney Fritz Wonderlick

01:32:13.990 --> 01:32:19.910
chief financial officer Lori race staff sergeant Ryan Howe and there's several others out there as

01:32:19.910 --> 01:32:23.990
well and i'd get mixed up if i tried to do them all but uh we also have deputy city clerk for

01:32:23.990 --> 01:32:26.030
for 36 to be liable, Sanchez.

01:32:28.160 --> 01:32:30.800
Perhaps we have an immense to the agenda.

01:32:30.800 --> 01:32:32.360
Mr. Mayor, members of the council staff

01:32:32.360 --> 01:32:34.880
would like for you to consider adding an item

01:32:34.880 --> 01:32:37.930
to the consent calendar.

01:32:37.930 --> 01:32:39.930
You would appear as item number five.

01:32:39.930 --> 01:32:42.810
Should you accept our request?

01:32:42.810 --> 01:32:47.650
The item is in consideration of request by Rosa Paez

01:32:47.650 --> 01:32:50.490
to approve the 28th annual Mother's Day

01:32:50.490 --> 01:32:54.290
and Latin Fiesta to be held in City Park.

01:32:57.000 --> 01:33:03.320
Second move by Chris talking then and second by Don Hall that we add the mother's day

01:33:05.040 --> 01:33:09.720
Ain't no mother's day and Leat and Latin fiesta at City Park to our consent calendar

01:33:10.320 --> 01:33:12.560
See no lights Leila Rofel vote

01:33:12.760 --> 01:33:20.520
Sunperger yes Don Hall yes Suzanne Hawkins. Yes, Greg Lansing. Yes Jim on. Yes Rebecca Mills like a yes

01:33:21.400 --> 01:33:23.400
Yes, that item will be amended

01:33:23.400 --> 01:33:27.740
and the consent calendar when we get to the consent calendar.

01:33:27.740 --> 01:33:31.360
Next up are a couple of proclamations,

01:33:31.360 --> 01:33:33.920
and I did more than Vice Mayor Hall,

01:33:33.920 --> 01:33:36.080
but I'd like him to read the American Auxiliary One,

01:33:36.080 --> 01:33:38.510
if you would.

01:33:38.510 --> 01:33:40.090
I'd be honored.

01:33:40.090 --> 01:33:42.590
Off to the mayor city of Twin Falls Proclamation,

01:33:42.590 --> 01:33:45.710
whereas the American Legion Auxiliary of Twin Falls,

01:33:45.710 --> 01:33:50.150
Idaho, will conduct its annual poppy day donations

01:33:50.150 --> 01:33:52.510
from May 24th through May 27th,

01:33:52.510 --> 01:33:57.550
And whereas the poppy has been the memorial to the war dead

01:33:57.550 --> 01:34:03.390
since adopted in 1919 by the American Legion and its auxiliary.

01:34:03.390 --> 01:34:08.430
And whereas these poppies are made by hospitalized veterans

01:34:08.430 --> 01:34:10.830
in veterans hospitals throughout the nation.

01:34:10.830 --> 01:34:16.150
And whereas Americans have always given generous support

01:34:16.150 --> 01:34:19.510
to the poppy day program conducted by the American Legion

01:34:19.510 --> 01:34:26.710
Auxiliary, and this year's observance provides a timely opportunity for reaffirming our heartfelt

01:34:26.710 --> 01:34:33.310
appreciation for sacrifices made by our armed forces in the defense of America's freedom.

01:34:33.310 --> 01:34:40.430
Now therefore, our mayor, great-lanting in the City of Twin Falls does hereby proclaim

01:34:40.430 --> 01:34:48.590
May 24th through the 27th as American Legion Auxiliary Poppy Days.

01:34:48.590 --> 01:34:56.350
In the city of Twin Falls and urge participation in this program by all citizens as we together

01:34:56.350 --> 01:35:02.910
pause to remember the heroic sacrifices of our gallant fighting men and women signed by

01:35:02.910 --> 01:35:06.510
both our mayor and deputy city clerk, Leyla Sanchez.

01:35:06.510 --> 01:35:11.070
All right, so if somebody from the market needs you here to accept the award, thank you.

01:35:11.070 --> 01:35:12.070
Would you come forward?

01:35:12.070 --> 01:35:13.070
I'd appreciate it.

01:35:13.070 --> 01:35:51.510
Last year when I was here I read something and I said it was good to be under two minutes

01:35:51.510 --> 01:35:54.670
And I had someone from up here and also a couple of people

01:35:54.670 --> 01:35:57.830
on the audience say thank you for reading it

01:35:57.830 --> 01:36:01.630
because it completely kind of explained what the poppy is.

01:36:01.630 --> 01:36:03.230
So I can read pretty fast.

01:36:03.230 --> 01:36:04.830
So I'm just going to read this to you

01:36:04.830 --> 01:36:07.470
because most people won't know this.

01:36:07.470 --> 01:36:11.230
It's that how did the poppy become a symbol of remembrance?

01:36:11.230 --> 01:36:12.790
And it's called the Flanders Poppy

01:36:12.790 --> 01:36:15.150
because it's in the Flanders Division over there

01:36:15.150 --> 01:36:17.470
in Belgium and France.

01:36:17.470 --> 01:36:20.950
Flanders is the name of the whole western part of Belgium.

01:36:20.950 --> 01:36:23.710
It saw some of the most concentrated and bloodiest

01:36:23.710 --> 01:36:26.190
fights of the First World War.

01:36:26.190 --> 01:36:28.190
It was complete devastation.

01:36:28.190 --> 01:36:32.230
Building road, trees, and natural lives simply disappeared.

01:36:32.230 --> 01:36:34.030
For once, there were homes and farms.

01:36:34.030 --> 01:36:37.310
There was now a sea of mud at grave for the dead.

01:36:37.310 --> 01:36:41.230
Only one other living thing survived, and that's the poppy,

01:36:41.230 --> 01:36:44.830
flowering each year with the coming of the warm weather.

01:36:44.830 --> 01:36:47.950
The poppy brought light, hope, color, reassurance

01:36:47.950 --> 01:36:49.950
to those still fighting.

01:36:49.950 --> 01:36:53.830
Poppy seeds can be in the ground for years without germinating,

01:36:53.830 --> 01:36:58.630
and it only grows after the ground has been disturbed.

01:36:58.630 --> 01:37:00.390
The point states, in Flandersville,

01:37:00.390 --> 01:37:03.910
the poppies blow between the crosses row on row,

01:37:03.910 --> 01:37:06.030
that mark our place and in the sky,

01:37:06.030 --> 01:37:08.310
the larks still bravely singing by,

01:37:08.310 --> 01:37:11.270
scarcely heard amid the guns below,

01:37:11.270 --> 01:37:13.750
we are the dead short days ago,

01:37:13.750 --> 01:37:17.430
we lived, fought, saw sunset glow,

01:37:17.430 --> 01:37:21.350
Love and for love, and now we lie, in Flanders Field.

01:37:21.350 --> 01:37:23.270
Take up your quarrel with the foe,

01:37:23.270 --> 01:37:25.270
to you from falling hands we throw,

01:37:25.270 --> 01:37:27.630
the torch be yours to hold on high,

01:37:27.630 --> 01:37:30.470
the e-break faith with us who die.

01:37:30.470 --> 01:37:34.350
We shall not sleep, the poppies grow in Flanders Field.

01:37:34.350 --> 01:37:37.150
The most recent and current tradition of World War I,

01:37:37.150 --> 01:37:40.590
when John McCrae wrote the poem, just as I read.

01:37:40.590 --> 01:37:43.710
McCrae was a Canadian who enlisted to help the Allies

01:37:43.710 --> 01:37:45.150
in the war.

01:37:45.150 --> 01:37:48.050
He was made medical officer upon landing in Europe.

01:37:48.050 --> 01:37:50.690
During a lull in the battle with a nub of a pencil,

01:37:50.690 --> 01:37:54.090
he scratched on a page in his dispatch book.

01:37:54.090 --> 01:37:58.010
The porn thought its way to the pages of punch magazine.

01:37:58.010 --> 01:38:00.110
By 1918, the coin was well known

01:38:00.110 --> 01:38:02.130
throughout the Allied world.

01:38:02.130 --> 01:38:04.410
Mionna Michael, a American woman,

01:38:04.410 --> 01:38:06.210
wrote to these lines in reply.

01:38:06.210 --> 01:38:08.930
We cherish to the poppy red that grows in fields

01:38:08.930 --> 01:38:10.350
where valor led.

01:38:10.350 --> 01:38:12.370
It seems to signal to the skies

01:38:12.370 --> 01:38:15.450
that blood of heroes never die.

01:38:15.450 --> 01:38:18.050
She then adopted the custom of wearing a red poppy

01:38:18.050 --> 01:38:19.890
in memory of the sacrifices of war

01:38:19.890 --> 01:38:22.850
and also as a symbol of keeping the faith.

01:38:22.850 --> 01:38:26.290
A French woman, Madam, here in,

01:38:26.290 --> 01:38:27.890
visiting the United States,

01:38:27.890 --> 01:38:31.130
learned of the custom and took it one step further.

01:38:31.130 --> 01:38:32.450
When she returned to France,

01:38:32.450 --> 01:38:34.810
she decided to hand make the red poppies

01:38:34.810 --> 01:38:36.290
and sell them to raise money

01:38:36.290 --> 01:38:37.650
for the benefit of the orphaned

01:38:37.650 --> 01:38:39.810
and destitute women and children

01:38:39.810 --> 01:38:42.810
in war-torn areas of France.

01:38:42.810 --> 01:38:46.610
This tradition spread to the United Kingdom, Canada,

01:38:46.610 --> 01:38:50.650
the United States, and Australia, and it still follows today.

01:38:50.650 --> 01:38:52.570
The money collected from the sale of poppies

01:38:52.570 --> 01:38:55.250
goes to fund various better programs.

01:38:55.250 --> 01:39:01.330
Poppies are now not sold, but given up freely.

01:39:01.330 --> 01:39:03.650
Donations are accepted as given.

01:39:03.650 --> 01:39:06.610
If anybody ever says, we will get in more trouble

01:39:06.610 --> 01:39:10.370
if we ever use the word sell.

01:39:10.370 --> 01:39:12.930
So that's the little story of the poppy.

01:39:12.930 --> 01:39:17.930
Oh, FYI, the American Legion has something called O-C-W,

01:39:19.210 --> 01:39:23.780
my Santa Barbara Operation Comfort Warrior.

01:39:23.780 --> 01:39:26.940
We help the veterans that are in the hospitals.

01:39:26.940 --> 01:39:29.860
We don't have a six-figure CEO running it.

01:39:29.860 --> 01:39:32.780
Our CEO has a salary of zero.

01:39:32.780 --> 01:39:34.140
They don't have a car.

01:39:34.140 --> 01:39:36.700
They don't have anybody to help them.

01:39:36.700 --> 01:39:40.180
But all of the men and women that work to help our warriors

01:39:40.180 --> 01:39:41.420
It's paid nothing.

01:39:41.420 --> 01:39:42.620
It's all volunteers.

01:39:42.620 --> 01:39:45.820
So if you ever want to give a little extra and say on there,

01:39:45.820 --> 01:39:49.320
oh, Sita, we will be more than happy to afford that money to you.

01:39:49.320 --> 01:39:52.420
We don't have TB ads either.

01:39:52.420 --> 01:39:53.460
Thank you very much.

01:39:53.460 --> 01:39:54.460
Doris.

01:39:54.460 --> 01:39:55.460
Doris?

01:39:55.460 --> 01:39:56.460
Doris.

01:39:56.460 --> 01:39:57.460
We have a question.

01:39:57.460 --> 01:39:58.700
Do you please accept a donation here?

01:39:58.700 --> 01:40:01.180
We have for the city.

01:40:01.180 --> 01:40:03.510
Not the Holston.

01:40:03.510 --> 01:40:04.510
Just a donation.

01:40:04.510 --> 01:40:05.510
Thank you.

01:40:05.510 --> 01:40:09.520
Thank you.

01:40:09.520 --> 01:40:12.960
The next proclamation is for the National Police Week Peace

01:40:12.960 --> 01:40:18.950
Officers Memorial Day to the Office of the Mayor of City of Twin Falls, a proclamation

01:40:18.950 --> 01:40:23.270
by the Mayor of the City of Twin Falls declaring Sunday May 12th through Saturday, May 18th

01:40:23.270 --> 01:40:28.590
as National Police Week and May 15th as Peace Officers Memorial Day.

01:40:28.590 --> 01:40:31.830
Whereas the Congress and the President of the United States have designated this week in

01:40:31.830 --> 01:40:37.670
which May 15th falls as a National Police Week and whereas the members of the law enforcement

01:40:37.670 --> 01:40:42.310
agency of the City of Twin Falls plays an essential role in safeguarding the rights and

01:40:42.310 --> 01:40:45.270
freedoms of the residents of the City of Twin Falls.

01:40:45.270 --> 01:40:48.190
And whereas it is important that all citizens know and

01:40:48.190 --> 01:40:51.670
understand the duties, responsibility, hazards, and

01:40:51.670 --> 01:40:56.350
sacrifices of their law enforcement agency, and that members of our law enforcement

01:40:56.350 --> 01:41:01.670
agency recognize their duty to serve the people by safeguarding life and property,

01:41:01.670 --> 01:41:06.350
by protecting them against violence and disorder, and by protecting the innocent

01:41:06.350 --> 01:41:10.990
against deception and the weak against oppression.

01:41:10.990 --> 01:41:16.570
And whereas the men and women of the law enforcement agency of the City of Twin Falls, and seasonally,

01:41:16.570 --> 01:41:21.610
and CCG, provide a vital public service now there for I, Gregory,

01:41:21.610 --> 01:41:26.210
and Mayor of the City of Twin Falls call upon all citizens of the City of Twin Falls,

01:41:26.210 --> 01:41:33.850
and upon all patriotic civics and educational organizations to observe the week of May 12th through May 18th, 2013,

01:41:33.850 --> 01:41:39.250
as police week with appropriate ceremonies and observance in which all of our people

01:41:39.250 --> 01:41:42.850
may join in commemorating law enforcement officers

01:41:42.850 --> 01:41:46.370
past and present, who by their faithful and loyal devotion

01:41:46.370 --> 01:41:49.850
to the responsibilities have rendered a dedicated service

01:41:49.850 --> 01:41:52.690
to their communities, and in doing so have established

01:41:52.690 --> 01:41:57.210
themselves as an enviable and enduring reputation

01:41:57.210 --> 01:42:00.450
of preserving the rights and security of all citizens.

01:42:00.450 --> 01:42:02.490
Furthermore, I call upon all citizens city

01:42:02.490 --> 01:42:07.290
to involves observe May 15, 2013 as peace officers Memorial Day

01:42:07.290 --> 01:42:11.170
in honor of those law enforcement officers who,

01:42:11.170 --> 01:42:14.690
through their courageous deeds, have made the ultimate sacrifice

01:42:14.690 --> 01:42:18.410
in service to their communities, or have become disabled

01:42:18.410 --> 01:42:21.250
in the performance of duty, and let us recognize

01:42:21.250 --> 01:42:25.370
and pay respect to the survivors of our fallen heroes.

01:42:25.370 --> 01:42:31.010
Signed by me and my Leidl Sanchez, the deputy city clerk,

01:42:31.010 --> 01:42:35.490
and F Chief Pike, or would you come forth and accept this,

01:42:35.490 --> 01:42:40.420
unless there's someone else at the audience that's here to do that.

01:42:40.420 --> 01:42:42.500
Appreciate it, thank you.

01:42:42.500 --> 01:42:44.220
I will accept this on their behalf.

01:42:44.220 --> 01:42:48.980
All right, thank you, sir.

01:42:48.980 --> 01:42:53.540
Moving on to the consent calendar as amended, Sean Berger.

01:42:53.540 --> 01:42:56.100
I'd like to, I have a couple of questions

01:42:56.100 --> 01:43:01.540
on the Western Days event and the marathon, so have a marathon.

01:43:01.540 --> 01:43:02.660
So I'd like to remove both of them.

01:43:02.660 --> 01:43:05.140
I think Suzanne's light was coming on for the Western Days

01:43:05.140 --> 01:43:07.700
as well, so we'll remove those two items.

01:43:07.700 --> 01:43:12.700
Do I have a motion on the rest of the consent calendar

01:43:13.540 --> 01:43:16.940
as amended with the exception of item number three

01:43:16.940 --> 01:43:19.800
and item number four?

01:43:19.800 --> 01:43:22.640
Some of, it's been moved by Sean Berger.

01:43:22.640 --> 01:43:23.560
Second.

01:43:23.560 --> 01:43:25.000
Seconded by Suzanne Hawkins,

01:43:25.000 --> 01:43:28.140
I would accept the remainder of the consent calendar.

01:43:29.440 --> 01:43:30.720
See no lights.

01:43:30.720 --> 01:43:32.240
The aye let it roll call vote.

01:43:32.240 --> 01:43:33.080
Don Hall.

01:43:33.080 --> 01:43:33.920
Yes.

01:43:33.920 --> 01:43:34.760
Suzanne Hawkins.

01:43:34.760 --> 01:43:35.580
Yes.

01:43:35.580 --> 01:43:36.400
Greg Lanting.

01:43:36.400 --> 01:43:37.240
Yes.

01:43:37.240 --> 01:43:38.240
Yes.

01:43:38.240 --> 01:43:39.240
Rebecca Mills-Suega.

01:43:39.240 --> 01:43:40.240
Yes.

01:43:40.240 --> 01:43:41.240
Chris Talkington.

01:43:41.240 --> 01:43:42.240
Yes.

01:43:42.240 --> 01:43:43.240
Sean Berriger.

01:43:43.240 --> 01:43:44.240
Yes.

01:43:44.240 --> 01:43:45.240
All right.

01:43:45.240 --> 01:43:48.240
That portion of the consent calendar has been approved.

01:43:48.240 --> 01:43:53.240
John, you want to talk about item number three and Suzanne, I believe that questions as well.

01:43:53.240 --> 01:43:54.240
Yes.

01:43:54.240 --> 01:43:55.240
On the western days.

01:43:55.240 --> 01:43:57.240
Sergeant Howe, if you come forward.

01:43:57.240 --> 01:44:03.040
The exam request, it talks about, it goes through the detail of the total overtime hours

01:44:03.040 --> 01:44:09.640
expected and that the Western Days Committee has been advised every year since 2007 that

01:44:09.640 --> 01:44:13.980
they'll be responsible for those. My question was have those costs been consistently paid

01:44:13.980 --> 01:44:18.880
since that time every year? Yes, they have. They have been late a few years, but do we

01:44:18.880 --> 01:44:23.680
have a new chairman this year? So I'm anticipating that being paid on time. Okay. Thank you. That

01:44:23.680 --> 01:44:28.400
was the only question. Suzanne, your question? I'm reading through the notes. There was a

01:44:28.400 --> 01:44:32.080
lot of details of what's going on and in two different places it's mentioned that there

01:44:32.080 --> 01:44:36.240
would like to be street closures for the three on three basketball tournament, but nowhere

01:44:36.240 --> 01:44:38.400
did I find what streets those are.

01:44:38.400 --> 01:44:39.400
That is correct.

01:44:39.400 --> 01:44:44.440
I actually looked at that today and had to look up and actually call the chairperson.

01:44:44.440 --> 01:44:50.640
What we are looking at doing is closing down 4th Avenue East from Shoshone to Hanson Street

01:44:50.640 --> 01:44:54.120
and Hanson Street from 4th Avenue to 5th Avenue.

01:44:54.120 --> 01:44:56.520
So it would be right in front of the library.

01:44:56.520 --> 01:44:58.440
Okay, so it won't go all the way down to 6th?

01:44:58.440 --> 01:45:01.300
It will not, that we would need to allow the access

01:45:01.300 --> 01:45:03.480
into the park and that's why we would not close it

01:45:03.480 --> 01:45:05.520
from beyond fifth.

01:45:05.520 --> 01:45:08.200
The Western Days Committee actually has signatures

01:45:08.200 --> 01:45:10.760
of all the businesses that are around that area.

01:45:10.760 --> 01:45:12.920
I have a copy of those that they agree

01:45:12.920 --> 01:45:14.280
that this would be a street closure

01:45:14.280 --> 01:45:17.400
that they would accept and they would agree to.

01:45:17.400 --> 01:45:19.080
Thank you very much.

01:45:19.080 --> 01:45:21.760
All right, Rebecca, we'll second.

01:45:21.760 --> 01:45:22.600
Thank you, Mayor.

01:45:22.600 --> 01:45:24.560
I have a question about half marathon.

01:45:25.800 --> 01:45:28.400
The Western Days stated how much the overtime

01:45:28.400 --> 01:45:32.000
cost and that it would be paid by the committee.

01:45:32.000 --> 01:45:38.740
But the notes on the half marathon is that the total overtime cost will be $264.

01:45:38.740 --> 01:45:42.800
And this event has not been approved in the Twin Falls Police Department's overtime budget.

01:45:42.800 --> 01:45:45.880
So I was just wondering who will be paying those costs?

01:45:45.880 --> 01:45:55.960
Normally what the city does is the police department has in the past absorbed that as part of the overtime budget of the city of Twin River,

01:45:55.960 --> 01:46:02.880
of the police department, it coincides well with the western days because some of the work

01:46:02.880 --> 01:46:08.160
that needs to be done for the parade route, we actually have officers that are able to

01:46:08.160 --> 01:46:14.600
work double duty and swing over and assist with the marathon at the same time to have

01:46:14.600 --> 01:46:15.600
marathon.

01:46:15.600 --> 01:46:20.080
So at this time it has been approved as part of the city's overtime.

01:46:20.080 --> 01:46:22.280
It is not actually approved.

01:46:22.280 --> 01:46:25.120
We don't have that in our part of the budget.

01:46:25.120 --> 01:46:27.560
And again, part of that becomes absorbed

01:46:27.560 --> 01:46:29.480
through the Western days.

01:46:29.480 --> 01:46:32.320
Does that make sense?

01:46:32.320 --> 01:46:34.300
It's not really clear, but I think I understand what you're

01:46:34.300 --> 01:46:35.300
saying.

01:46:35.300 --> 01:46:35.800
Yes.

01:46:35.800 --> 01:46:37.360
That's the point that you can't.

01:46:37.360 --> 01:46:42.040
Well, maybe just a point of clarification.

01:46:42.040 --> 01:46:43.600
The amount that we end up charging the West

01:46:43.600 --> 01:46:46.880
Base Committee is for providing security at the park.

01:46:46.880 --> 01:46:49.320
The parade, the cost for the parade

01:46:49.320 --> 01:46:51.160
and putting the parade on is completely absorbed

01:46:51.160 --> 01:46:52.920
by the city and the police department.

01:46:52.920 --> 01:46:55.400
So there's really, there's a little bit of a breakout.

01:46:55.400 --> 01:46:57.840
So what Sergeant Hal is saying is that we'll already

01:46:57.840 --> 01:47:00.720
be in place, we're already making that contribution.

01:47:00.720 --> 01:47:02.680
As part of the normal parade route,

01:47:02.680 --> 01:47:05.200
we'll just let them take advantage of the fact

01:47:05.200 --> 01:47:07.640
that we're already there without charging them any money.

01:47:07.640 --> 01:47:08.840
Because we're not charging in the West

01:47:08.840 --> 01:47:10.320
or days committee for the parade route

01:47:10.320 --> 01:47:13.280
and the closures that's involved there.

01:47:13.280 --> 01:47:16.040
Right, so it's going, yeah, so it's gonna be included

01:47:16.040 --> 01:47:21.320
just as the parade would be.

01:47:21.320 --> 01:47:24.560
I mean, we don't charge any, if anyone puts in their request

01:47:24.560 --> 01:47:28.340
for a parade, we have not traditionally charged them

01:47:28.340 --> 01:47:29.180
for the parade.

01:47:29.180 --> 01:47:31.360
We usually have to absorb it with either on duty personnel

01:47:31.360 --> 01:47:34.440
or in the traffic team tries to pick up that duty.

01:47:34.440 --> 01:47:35.840
Okay, thank you.

01:47:35.840 --> 01:47:38.040
Sean Berger, I believe also had a question on that.

01:47:38.040 --> 01:47:39.600
That was his question, right?

01:47:39.600 --> 01:47:41.800
So, she is much more eloquent than I did.

01:47:41.800 --> 01:47:43.360
It's like that much better.

01:47:43.360 --> 01:47:44.800
All right, Chris talking to him.

01:47:44.800 --> 01:47:46.920
I would move it happens to the two

01:47:46.920 --> 01:47:48.880
separately discussed consent items.

01:47:48.880 --> 01:47:52.750
Then moved by Chris Dockington and seconded by Don Hall.

01:47:52.750 --> 01:47:55.050
Subject to the conditions as explained.

01:47:55.050 --> 01:47:56.050
Right.

01:47:56.050 --> 01:48:00.690
To accept items three and four of the consent calendar as explained.

01:48:00.690 --> 01:48:03.690
So you know, lights of the other roll call vote.

01:48:03.690 --> 01:48:04.810
Susan Hawkins.

01:48:04.810 --> 01:48:05.490
Yes.

01:48:05.490 --> 01:48:06.130
Greg Lanting.

01:48:06.130 --> 01:48:06.890
Yes.

01:48:06.890 --> 01:48:07.570
Jim Munn.

01:48:07.570 --> 01:48:08.130
Yes.

01:48:08.130 --> 01:48:09.210
Rebecca Melsoica.

01:48:09.210 --> 01:48:09.890
Yes.

01:48:09.890 --> 01:48:10.650
Chris Talkington.

01:48:10.650 --> 01:48:11.250
Yes.

01:48:11.250 --> 01:48:12.010
Sean Berriger.

01:48:12.010 --> 01:48:12.610
Yes.

01:48:12.610 --> 01:48:13.330
Don Hall.

01:48:13.330 --> 01:48:14.770
Yes.

01:48:14.770 --> 01:48:16.930
Motion passes seven to zero.

01:48:16.930 --> 01:48:19.930
Thank you, Sergeant Hal, for your contributions.

01:48:19.930 --> 01:48:21.930
of the most deep pipe.

01:48:21.930 --> 01:48:23.930
Moving on to item number one.

01:48:23.930 --> 01:48:28.930
Another item for consideration is the presentation of the finances of the City of Twin Falls for

01:48:28.930 --> 01:48:32.930
the first six months of fiscal year 2012-2013.

01:48:32.930 --> 01:48:36.930
This presentation will be an overview of the tax-supported funds, the three major enterprise funds,

01:48:36.930 --> 01:48:44.930
water, wastewater and sanitation, those on the Quatshinesan live on 17 or on the web.

01:48:44.930 --> 01:48:50.930
Why we six months in is the fact that we were our budget year starts October 1st each year.

01:48:50.930 --> 01:48:53.930
So the future is in confusion there.

01:48:53.930 --> 01:48:56.930
Lori race, CFO.

01:48:56.930 --> 01:49:09.980
Travis, do we need to talk?

01:49:24.100 --> 01:49:30.740
We come forward yet, Tammy.

01:49:30.740 --> 01:49:50.720
All the passwords.

01:49:50.720 --> 01:49:55.190
It doesn't work.

01:49:55.190 --> 01:50:00.710
It worked earlier.

01:50:00.710 --> 01:50:06.710
So, Mr. Mayor, members of the Council in order to keep the meeting kind of moving forward,

01:50:06.710 --> 01:50:08.750
what we can do is I also have a quick presentation.

01:50:08.750 --> 01:50:10.190
I can do mine.

01:50:10.190 --> 01:50:12.110
Mine is relatively quick.

01:50:12.110 --> 01:50:17.430
And maybe in that meantime, I ask you to figure out what's going on and can get Mrs.

01:50:17.430 --> 01:50:19.430
Race's moving forward.

01:50:19.430 --> 01:50:20.880
All right.

01:50:20.880 --> 01:50:23.880
Travis, why don't you go ahead with item one.

01:50:23.880 --> 01:50:25.880
We'll move on to item number two briefly then.

01:50:25.880 --> 01:50:44.120
I'm going to try one more time.

01:50:44.120 --> 01:50:47.010
She's praying.

01:50:47.010 --> 01:50:48.010
She's ready.

01:50:48.010 --> 01:50:56.980
Talk.

01:50:56.980 --> 01:50:58.980
We will be back to item one.

01:50:58.980 --> 01:51:06.240
Good evening, Mayor and City Council.

01:51:06.240 --> 01:51:11.240
It is time for our second financial update for the current fiscal year.

01:51:11.240 --> 01:51:24.760
Tonight we will review the tax-supported funds for the first six months of this fiscal year along with the three major enterprise funds, just like we typically do.

01:51:24.760 --> 01:51:31.600
Now, for a quick review, we have the nine funds that receive tax revenues for operations.

01:51:31.600 --> 01:51:36.440
And I apologize for the size of this graph, but I show it to you quite a bit, so I'm going

01:51:36.440 --> 01:51:40.440
to read those categories to you.

01:51:40.440 --> 01:51:48.280
Those nine funds are the general fund, street fund, street light fund, library, airport, capital

01:51:48.280 --> 01:51:54.130
improvement, pool, insurance fund, and the Fourth of July fund.

01:51:54.130 --> 01:51:59.690
And the total budget for the tax-supported funds is $30.1 million, and that includes these

01:51:59.690 --> 01:52:01.290
reserves.

01:52:01.290 --> 01:52:08.810
The largest contributing resources, revenue sources, are property taxes, franchise fees,

01:52:08.810 --> 01:52:14.140
state-shared revenues, highway monies, and inter-fund transfers.

01:52:14.140 --> 01:52:21.000
The total of these five revenue sources is $25.3 million, and they make up 84% of the total

01:52:21.000 --> 01:52:24.120
revenues in the tax-supported funds.

01:52:24.120 --> 01:52:28.520
Now, we're going to look at these in a little more detail, but we're also going to review

01:52:28.520 --> 01:52:32.400
a couple of revenues that aren't in the big five category.

01:52:32.400 --> 01:52:36.920
I promise you, my team and I do not overlook the smaller revenue sources that make up the

01:52:36.920 --> 01:52:38.440
other 16%.

01:52:38.440 --> 01:52:46.510
Tonight, we're going to take a look at building permit revenue and interest income.

01:52:46.510 --> 01:52:52.330
As reported last time, current property tax collections are up.

01:52:52.330 --> 01:52:56.650
We really don't have much to talk about in this category until we receive our next large

01:52:56.650 --> 01:52:57.850
installment in July.

01:52:57.850 --> 01:53:04.530
We're at 59% of budget with a prior three-year average a little over 58%.

01:53:04.530 --> 01:53:08.810
For property taxes, we're not going to get any more money than what we levied for.

01:53:08.810 --> 01:53:12.090
It's simply a matter of when we receive those dollars.

01:53:12.090 --> 01:53:16.130
And it's a good sign for our local economy that people are able to pay their taxes more

01:53:16.130 --> 01:53:17.130
timely.

01:53:17.130 --> 01:53:26.180
So, franchise fees are at 41% of budget, but the prior three-year average was 51%.

01:53:26.180 --> 01:53:31.260
Now this raised red flag and we needed to investigate a little further.

01:53:31.260 --> 01:53:36.560
So the first thing I discovered is that we had not received our annual payment from Intermount

01:53:36.560 --> 01:53:38.720
Gas.

01:53:38.720 --> 01:53:42.840
We received that in April so it's not included in the total.

01:53:42.840 --> 01:53:48.600
So I noticed that that payment was down almost 19% compared to last year.

01:53:48.600 --> 01:53:55.120
So I contacted Jim Capps of Intermountain Gas and he indicated that the temperatures were

01:53:55.120 --> 01:53:59.080
about 15% warmer last year.

01:53:59.080 --> 01:54:02.120
And they look at the year from January to December.

01:54:02.120 --> 01:54:06.740
So this would have been January 12th through December of 12th.

01:54:06.740 --> 01:54:10.600
And obviously that affects their revenue stream.

01:54:10.600 --> 01:54:15.400
Idaho Power continues to track ahead of the prior year.

01:54:15.400 --> 01:54:19.480
When I put the budget together, I projected a two and a half percent increase.

01:54:19.480 --> 01:54:23.360
But what we're really seeing is more like a 16 percent increase.

01:54:23.360 --> 01:54:28.040
We do know that Idaho Power had a significant rate adjustment last year, and we're actually

01:54:28.040 --> 01:54:33.160
looking at another large increase this year as we start building our budgets.

01:54:33.160 --> 01:54:39.720
I'm anticipating we'll receive somewhere between 100,000 and 110,000 more in this category

01:54:39.720 --> 01:54:49.140
that was budgeted. State shared revenues are currently at 54 and a half percent of budget.

01:54:49.140 --> 01:54:56.140
Our prior three-year average was 52 percent. So there are two formulas that make up that amount.

01:54:56.140 --> 01:55:01.140
County distribution share is tracking just to take over budget, but the big story continues

01:55:01.140 --> 01:55:07.140
to be state shared revenue. You'll recall we're receiving a bigger piece of that pie because

01:55:07.140 --> 01:55:12.140
our property values actually decreased less than other entities.

01:55:12.140 --> 01:55:18.560
I'm estimating an additional revenue generated from this category will be somewhere between

01:55:18.560 --> 01:55:25.700
100,000 and 115,000 and this will be added to our revenue estimates prior to rejecting

01:55:25.700 --> 01:55:27.540
for 13, 14.

01:55:27.540 --> 01:55:32.090
So that's a good thing for us.

01:55:32.090 --> 01:55:37.090
Highway user and road and bridge taxes are about 56% of budget.

01:55:37.090 --> 01:55:45.540
The prior three-year average was 55%, we're running just a bit ahead of budget in this category.

01:55:45.540 --> 01:55:52.180
For transfers, I typically remind you we're at 50% of the budget and move on.

01:55:52.180 --> 01:55:58.460
Well, this time, I want to remind you that we're looking quite a bit out of line due to

01:55:58.460 --> 01:56:02.620
the $2.9 million repayment from the wastewater fund.

01:56:02.620 --> 01:56:08.500
If you remove that amount from the year-to-date actuals, we're at 50% of that budget.

01:56:08.500 --> 01:56:15.700
In case you happen to notice, this 54.9% spent in 10 and 11, well, I will share with you

01:56:15.700 --> 01:56:21.300
that that's from an unbudgeted transfer, from the Capital Improvement Fund, to the Library

01:56:21.300 --> 01:56:26.660
Fund. So they were all approved expenditures. We just budgeted it in our Capital Improvement

01:56:26.660 --> 01:56:32.730
Fund, moved it to the Library Fund. So that's a look at the major revenue sources in the

01:56:32.730 --> 01:56:37.890
tax-supported funds. Before we move to the expenditures, I wanted to show you a bit of

01:56:37.890 --> 01:56:46.020
history on building permit revenue and interest income. Building permit and inspection revenues

01:56:46.020 --> 01:56:50.460
account for not quite 2% of the total tax-supported fund revenues.

01:56:50.460 --> 01:56:54.900
That's about $546,000.

01:56:54.900 --> 01:57:00.260
The graph is a 10-year history of building permanent revenues, and it represents six months of

01:57:00.260 --> 01:57:03.500
receipts for each of the fiscal years.

01:57:03.500 --> 01:57:11.340
Prior to 2007, we were not providing inspections for plumbing, electrical, and mechanical jobs.

01:57:11.340 --> 01:57:18.310
Those services were provided by the state and we received 10% of what they were receiving.

01:57:18.310 --> 01:57:25.070
In 2007, we started performing those inspections and receiving the related income.

01:57:25.070 --> 01:57:30.100
2008 was a record year, six months into the fiscal year.

01:57:30.100 --> 01:57:34.940
Then you can see what happened to this revenue source as the housing market took a downturn

01:57:34.940 --> 01:57:37.940
and the decline continued on into 2011.

01:57:37.940 --> 01:57:44.350
Well, it appears that we are slowly turning around and heading back in the right direction.

01:57:44.350 --> 01:57:49.510
We're not quite where we were in 2005, even with the inspection revenue, but it's definitely

01:57:49.510 --> 01:57:53.660
looking better.

01:57:53.660 --> 01:57:59.260
Next we'll take a look at total investment income for the city, not just in the tax-supported

01:57:59.260 --> 01:58:00.940
funds.

01:58:00.940 --> 01:58:06.100
This revenue source accounts for only 1% of the total of our $49 million budget.

01:58:06.100 --> 01:58:11.900
I'm not going to even try to break it down by investment category or any other variables

01:58:11.900 --> 01:58:13.400
that are out there.

01:58:13.400 --> 01:58:18.760
We're just going to make the assumption that all idle monies were earning a rate of return.

01:58:18.760 --> 01:58:23.660
So the city's investment policy states that we have three objectives and they are prioritized

01:58:23.660 --> 01:58:25.180
as follows.

01:58:25.180 --> 01:58:27.940
Number one is safety.

01:58:27.940 --> 01:58:32.540
Safety of principle is the foremost objective of our investment program.

01:58:32.540 --> 01:58:34.820
Number two is liquidity.

01:58:34.820 --> 01:58:40.580
The investment portfolios shall remain sufficiently liquid to meet all operating requirements that

01:58:40.580 --> 01:58:43.780
may be reasonably anticipated.

01:58:43.780 --> 01:58:46.740
And number three is yield.

01:58:46.740 --> 01:58:53.590
Return on investment as of secondary importance when compared to safety and liquidity.

01:58:53.590 --> 01:58:58.270
So when I first looked at this information, this really feeling a little bit sensitive about

01:58:58.270 --> 01:58:59.270
it.

01:58:59.270 --> 01:59:03.110
I was appointed to my current position in December of 2009.

01:59:03.110 --> 01:59:07.870
And here's what happens, 9 to 10.

01:59:07.870 --> 01:59:10.790
Now I'd like to tell you it was all crummy rates of return,

01:59:10.790 --> 01:59:13.110
and that's the reason for this drop.

01:59:13.110 --> 01:59:15.430
But honestly, we were trying to decide

01:59:15.430 --> 01:59:18.350
whether to contract out our investment portfolio

01:59:18.350 --> 01:59:20.310
or keep it in-house.

01:59:20.310 --> 01:59:22.750
We left the funds in the state investment pool,

01:59:22.750 --> 01:59:25.270
and as you can see, there's a cost

01:59:25.270 --> 01:59:28.430
to not proactively look for better opportunities.

01:59:29.470 --> 01:59:31.870
Granted, the returns have been pretty low,

01:59:31.870 --> 01:59:37.350
It's pretty sad when 57 basis points on a half million dollars seems attractive.

01:59:37.350 --> 01:59:42.910
But working with Greg Sammons of Piper Jaffrey, a trusted investment advisor of the cities,

01:59:42.910 --> 01:59:47.990
we're following our three major objectives in our investment policy and those yields are

01:59:47.990 --> 01:59:50.130
picking up.

01:59:50.130 --> 01:59:55.490
So that is a look at the revenues we typically review plus permits and investment income.

01:59:55.490 --> 01:59:56.490
Can I ask a question?

01:59:56.490 --> 01:59:57.490
Of course.

01:59:57.490 --> 02:00:01.170
Do we do a daily sweep of vital cash or how is that done?

02:00:01.170 --> 02:00:06.690
We used to do that, Chris, because the rates were such that it was to our benefit to do

02:00:06.690 --> 02:00:07.690
it.

02:00:07.690 --> 02:00:08.690
We don't do it anymore.

02:00:08.690 --> 02:00:09.690
Okay.

02:00:09.690 --> 02:00:16.210
Because we get less, we have cheaper rates, cheaper banking fees by not doing that now.

02:00:16.210 --> 02:00:18.810
So it's not cost effective to do that.

02:00:18.810 --> 02:00:21.810
So I try to keep a minimum amount in our checking account.

02:00:21.810 --> 02:00:24.210
Sean Burger, also a question.

02:00:24.210 --> 02:00:25.210
Okay.

02:00:25.210 --> 02:00:26.210
You hit two of them.

02:00:26.210 --> 02:00:27.210
So good job.

02:00:27.210 --> 02:00:30.530
I have a few other questions that were from what was provided in the packet.

02:00:30.530 --> 02:00:32.970
So it's not related to the presentation.

02:00:32.970 --> 02:00:39.010
So court revenues seem to be tracking well behind where

02:00:39.010 --> 02:00:42.250
they have historically, for this point of the year,

02:00:42.250 --> 02:00:47.300
at 32.4% of budget.

02:00:47.300 --> 02:00:48.980
So you're right.

02:00:48.980 --> 02:00:51.620
And I visited with Anthony Barnhart about that,

02:00:51.620 --> 02:00:53.260
because that's been a trend.

02:00:53.260 --> 02:00:58.220
Last year, we were actually hitting,

02:00:58.220 --> 02:00:59.140
that's what I'm looking for.

02:00:59.140 --> 02:01:01.840
we were actually hitting record ties.

02:01:03.680 --> 02:01:05.920
Anthony was trying to review that information

02:01:05.920 --> 02:01:06.920
and got back with me.

02:01:06.920 --> 02:01:10.720
He's not seeing a big change in the number of our citations.

02:01:10.720 --> 02:01:13.280
So if you would allow me to,

02:01:13.280 --> 02:01:15.280
I'll come back and look through that information

02:01:15.280 --> 02:01:18.200
and send out an email to the entire city council.

02:01:18.200 --> 02:01:19.640
That would be great, Kate.

02:01:19.640 --> 02:01:23.080
And I have just a few more items in the expenditures there.

02:01:23.080 --> 02:01:27.160
The contributions, the $1425,

02:01:27.160 --> 02:01:31.480
Is that like for dog park or fireworks or?

02:01:31.480 --> 02:01:34.840
I apologize, Sean, because I didn't look at that.

02:01:34.840 --> 02:01:37.480
And this is accumulation of all nine funds.

02:01:37.480 --> 02:01:39.560
So it's probably a little bit of all that.

02:01:39.560 --> 02:01:40.480
I would look at these.

02:01:40.480 --> 02:01:43.120
It could be fireworks.

02:01:43.120 --> 02:01:45.000
So I will take a look at that one as well

02:01:45.000 --> 02:01:46.480
and get back with the entire council.

02:01:46.480 --> 02:01:48.760
Well, wasn't there a fairly substantial donation

02:01:48.760 --> 02:01:51.640
to the library as well?

02:01:51.640 --> 02:01:53.240
That might have been after the sixth month.

02:01:53.240 --> 02:01:55.040
Yeah, it might have been because this

02:01:55.040 --> 02:01:59.630
is only $1,425.

02:01:59.630 --> 02:02:06.220
What makes up miscellaneous revenue?

02:02:06.220 --> 02:02:10.340
So we actually have a miscellaneous category.

02:02:10.340 --> 02:02:11.620
These are great questions.

02:02:11.620 --> 02:02:12.620
I'm not cleaving.

02:02:12.620 --> 02:02:14.100
I am so ill-prepared.

02:02:14.100 --> 02:02:15.660
No, it's OK.

02:02:15.660 --> 02:02:17.060
And if you don't have the answers for them,

02:02:17.060 --> 02:02:18.340
you can get them back to me.

02:02:18.340 --> 02:02:21.060
There's going to be a long list of categories,

02:02:21.060 --> 02:02:23.460
because it's not just in the general fund.

02:02:23.460 --> 02:02:25.620
And it's going to be all of those items that

02:02:25.620 --> 02:02:28.420
are a few thousand dollars here and a few thousand dollars

02:02:28.420 --> 02:02:31.140
there all across all nine funds.

02:02:31.140 --> 02:02:33.660
But I can get you the exact

02:02:33.660 --> 02:02:34.660
categories that we have.

02:02:34.660 --> 02:02:36.460
Because it actually adds up to a fair amount of money.

02:02:36.460 --> 02:02:40.780
I mean, it's $325,000, so, okay, I'm getting close.

02:02:40.780 --> 02:02:41.980
All right.

02:02:41.980 --> 02:02:45.900
Airport revenues seem to be tracking well ahead of pace.

02:02:45.900 --> 02:02:47.540
Do you think that that's going to continue

02:02:47.540 --> 02:02:48.780
or is that a timing?

02:02:48.780 --> 02:02:51.580
It's a timing deal because we did quite a bit

02:02:51.580 --> 02:02:55.340
of our hangar rental income at the first of the fiscal year.

02:02:55.340 --> 02:02:58.380
So it's not like that's going to continue to come in.

02:02:58.380 --> 02:03:00.060
And on the other end of the spectrum,

02:03:00.060 --> 02:03:04.180
the fire district revenue seems to be lagging

02:03:04.180 --> 02:03:07.500
compared to the years past at this point.

02:03:07.500 --> 02:03:10.020
I have a great story about that.

02:03:10.020 --> 02:03:13.500
So the fire district revenue, we typically

02:03:13.500 --> 02:03:17.420
receive a payment in February and then again in August.

02:03:17.420 --> 02:03:25.860
And we actually haven't received our February payment yet.

02:03:25.860 --> 02:03:30.740
And this $157,000 is from last year.

02:03:30.740 --> 02:03:33.100
So there's a big timing difference there.

02:03:33.100 --> 02:03:37.660
And so when I noticed that we weren't receiving that, I got in touch with Chief Clark, and

02:03:37.660 --> 02:03:41.500
he contacted the fire district, and we got our money right away.

02:03:41.500 --> 02:03:43.460
So it'll show up on the next update.

02:03:43.460 --> 02:03:47.180
And then it's going to look out of whack because we have that tiring issue from last

02:03:47.180 --> 02:03:49.010
year.

02:03:49.010 --> 02:03:50.010
I'm all done now.

02:03:50.010 --> 02:03:51.010
All right.

02:03:51.010 --> 02:03:52.010
Thank you.

02:03:52.010 --> 02:03:53.010
You're welcome.

02:03:53.010 --> 02:03:54.010
All right.

02:03:54.010 --> 02:03:55.010
That's all the lights I have.

02:03:55.010 --> 02:03:56.010
All right.

02:03:56.010 --> 02:04:06.630
So that's a look at the revenues we typically look at and now we can switch over to the expenditure side.

02:04:06.630 --> 02:04:08.630
So this is all review for you guys.

02:04:08.630 --> 02:04:13.630
We have the four major expenditure categories in these funds we'll be reviewing,

02:04:13.630 --> 02:04:22.560
and their personnel, M&O, capital, and transfers.

02:04:22.560 --> 02:04:28.560
The personnel budget constitutes 58% of the total budget in the tax-supported funds.

02:04:28.560 --> 02:04:31.560
And we've spent 46% through March.

02:04:31.560 --> 02:04:37.200
Now, this is one category that's fairly consistent from pay period to pay period.

02:04:37.200 --> 02:04:40.020
They can see seasonal salaries over time.

02:04:40.020 --> 02:04:43.800
Those are the types of expenditures that are going to affect that number.

02:04:43.800 --> 02:04:48.720
Now, last quarter, when I stood up here, I told you we were down about five positions.

02:04:48.720 --> 02:04:53.520
And in visiting with HR, we are still down about four positions in these funds.

02:04:53.520 --> 02:04:59.000
They include one police officer position that's been vacant since October.

02:04:59.000 --> 02:05:06.260
If you recall earlier this year, you authorized that we get over higher by two positions and

02:05:06.260 --> 02:05:09.180
we haven't been able to do that yet.

02:05:09.180 --> 02:05:13.980
There's a staff engineer that was hired in February, so that position was vacant for four

02:05:13.980 --> 02:05:15.740
months.

02:05:15.740 --> 02:05:22.610
The environmental engineer should be coming on board in May this month, and the engineering

02:05:22.610 --> 02:05:28.090
tech has been vacant for three out of the last six months.

02:05:28.090 --> 02:05:33.570
So this seems to be one expenditure that always produces savings, if you will.

02:05:33.570 --> 02:05:38.370
We budget as if we have full employment beginning at the start of the fiscal year, and this is

02:05:38.370 --> 02:05:40.410
rarely the case.

02:05:40.410 --> 02:05:47.170
We also budget all new positions as if with full benefits, including family health coverage,

02:05:47.170 --> 02:05:52.650
and we do have a waiting period for our employees, and new employees don't always utilize family

02:05:52.650 --> 02:05:53.650
coverage.

02:05:53.650 --> 02:05:58.330
Patty Lehman, this part of the budget review, is going to be looking at our actual labor

02:05:58.330 --> 02:06:03.130
distribution and comparing that to the budget to see if there are some expenditures that can

02:06:03.130 --> 02:06:04.130
be reduced.

02:06:04.130 --> 02:06:11.710
The M&O budget makes up 20% of the total.

02:06:11.710 --> 02:06:16.310
We've only spent about 40% halfway through the year.

02:06:16.310 --> 02:06:20.270
Now there are some major expenditures in this category that we'll be picking up during the

02:06:20.270 --> 02:06:27.230
summer months and some examples would be like Dean Littler's materials, line item.

02:06:27.230 --> 02:06:34.120
It's a fairly large line item and he does a lot of road repairs and maintenance in the

02:06:34.120 --> 02:06:42.420
summertime and also fuel budgets for parks and recreation. The capital improvement

02:06:42.420 --> 02:06:47.680
budget makes up 19% of the total and we're a little over 40% spent through

02:06:47.680 --> 02:06:52.650
March and that's in line with our three-year average. Capital expenditures have

02:06:52.650 --> 02:06:56.770
all been approved by you folks during the budget process.

02:06:56.770 --> 02:07:01.870
When we start the new fiscal year and before any actual purchases are made, requests are

02:07:01.870 --> 02:07:04.410
discussed again at senior staff.

02:07:04.410 --> 02:07:09.410
When the economy started its downturn, each capital project was discussed at length.

02:07:09.410 --> 02:07:14.050
We wanted to know the consequences of waiting 90 days, and many purchases were deferred until

02:07:14.050 --> 02:07:15.850
early spring.

02:07:15.850 --> 02:07:20.810
We continue to ensure revenues are tracking with budget before spending capital dollars,

02:07:20.810 --> 02:07:28.610
And department leaders have had good justification for moving forward with these items.

02:07:28.610 --> 02:07:34.520
Transfers make up about 3% of the tax-supported fund budgets.

02:07:34.520 --> 02:07:39.360
These expenditures are made by adjusting journal injury consistently throughout the year.

02:07:39.360 --> 02:07:45.000
And if you had a chance to review the information, obviously you have attached to the agenda item,

02:07:45.000 --> 02:07:51.200
you'll notice that the 2012 transfer expenditure in the tax-supported fund was at 6.1%.

02:07:51.200 --> 02:07:57.280
And I'm always telling you, it should be the percentage of the year we've just gone through.

02:07:57.280 --> 02:08:00.680
Well that's because we had large budget amendments last year.

02:08:00.680 --> 02:08:05.480
And funds were transferred out of the general fund to the sewer fund for the Northeast Sewer

02:08:05.480 --> 02:08:10.280
Project and also cash flows for the Rock Creek lift station and other improvements at the

02:08:10.280 --> 02:08:11.280
treatment plant.

02:08:11.280 --> 02:08:14.280
And that was all done prior to bonding.

02:08:14.280 --> 02:08:20.040
So those amounts were added to our budget after the budget hearing, but actual transfers

02:08:20.040 --> 02:08:27.170
were made later in the year after March, so it looks out of WAC right now. Likewise,

02:08:27.170 --> 02:08:34.010
you may have noticed the 60.7 amount in 2011. That's the other part of that library transfer

02:08:34.010 --> 02:08:39.970
we talked about just a little bit ago on the revenue side.

02:08:39.970 --> 02:08:45.130
So in the tax-supported funds, we've reviewed the major revenues and how they've come in

02:08:45.130 --> 02:08:52.450
year to date. We've received 64% of our total tax-supported fund revenues if you include

02:08:52.450 --> 02:08:59.650
that $2.9 million repayment from the wastewater fund. 55% without that. The prior through your

02:08:59.650 --> 02:09:07.120
average was 51%. We talked about current property tax collections in January. We're strong and

02:09:07.120 --> 02:09:12.280
ahead of where the county expected them to be. State shared revenues are coming in higher

02:09:12.280 --> 02:09:17.160
than anticipated, along with franchise fees and investment income.

02:09:17.160 --> 02:09:20.660
On the revenue side, we're in very good shape.

02:09:20.660 --> 02:09:23.980
We've reviewed year to date expenditures.

02:09:23.980 --> 02:09:29.500
Personnel, M&O, and transfers are all at or below the 50% target level.

02:09:29.500 --> 02:09:33.580
On the expenditure side, we're at 44% spent year to date.

02:09:33.580 --> 02:09:37.420
We know we'll have increased expenditures in certain departments as we head into the summer

02:09:37.420 --> 02:09:39.310
months.

02:09:39.310 --> 02:09:44.550
The graph shows the actual revenues and expenditures six months into the fiscal year, beginning

02:09:44.550 --> 02:09:47.110
with 2010 through current.

02:09:47.110 --> 02:09:54.190
Now you can see that current revenues on the far right side are higher than normal, and

02:09:54.190 --> 02:10:01.350
if you remove the 2.9 repayment from the wastewater fund, we're much more in line with prior years.

02:10:01.350 --> 02:10:06.110
We continue to have adequate cash flows, several revenue categories are coming in more than

02:10:06.110 --> 02:10:11.150
budget, and we continue to be in strong financial condition in the tax-supported funds.

02:10:11.150 --> 02:10:17.300
Do you have any questions about that before we move into the enterprise funds?

02:10:17.300 --> 02:10:19.660
You hit them all.

02:10:19.660 --> 02:10:20.660
All right.

02:10:20.660 --> 02:10:24.300
We're going to switch our focus to the enterprise funds.

02:10:24.300 --> 02:10:28.540
And as a review, the budgets for the three largest funds are as follows.

02:10:28.540 --> 02:10:37.860
Water is 9.1 million, wastewater 7.3, and sanitation 2.8 million.

02:10:37.860 --> 02:10:46.460
In the Water Fund, we'll compare user revenue by month for fiscal years 2011, 12, and current.

02:10:46.460 --> 02:10:52.920
User fees are only one source of revenue in this fund, but it accounts for 66% of the total.

02:10:52.920 --> 02:10:59.760
The first six months of fiscal year 2012 showed that we had received about a 7% increase over

02:10:59.760 --> 02:11:00.760
2011.

02:11:00.760 --> 02:11:03.960
That was after a 5% rate adjustment.

02:11:03.960 --> 02:11:08.960
For 2013, these revenues are up, but only 0.3%,

02:11:10.240 --> 02:11:13.400
and that's after a 3% rate adjustment.

02:11:13.400 --> 02:11:16.760
When we budget user revenues for the next fiscal year,

02:11:16.760 --> 02:11:20.600
we base that on what actual revenues that we're seeing.

02:11:20.600 --> 02:11:24.520
When I look at historical user revenues the past eight years

02:11:24.520 --> 02:11:26.800
from 2005 through current,

02:11:27.680 --> 02:11:30.680
and I look at six months into the fiscal year,

02:11:30.680 --> 02:11:33.800
I can see on average that we have collected

02:11:33.800 --> 02:11:37.260
38% of what we're going to collect.

02:11:37.260 --> 02:11:39.940
So if that holds true, we should collect

02:11:39.940 --> 02:11:43.980
an additional $3.7 million over the next six months.

02:11:43.980 --> 02:11:47.840
And that will put us within a half a percent margin of error

02:11:47.840 --> 02:11:49.700
to our budgeted figure.

02:11:49.700 --> 02:11:52.580
Obviously, if we have a cool wet spring and summer,

02:11:52.580 --> 02:11:54.380
that will affect that projection.

02:11:54.380 --> 02:11:57.940
And likewise, a hot, dry spring and summer

02:11:57.940 --> 02:11:59.300
will do the same.

02:11:59.300 --> 02:12:02.020
I will definitely keep Travis posted

02:12:02.020 --> 02:12:07.560
as those revenues come in.

02:12:07.560 --> 02:12:09.680
On the expenditure side in the Water Fund,

02:12:09.680 --> 02:12:13.080
personal costs make up 19% of the total budget,

02:12:13.080 --> 02:12:16.480
and we're currently at 42.5% through March.

02:12:16.480 --> 02:12:19.040
And that's a bit under what I would expect to see,

02:12:19.040 --> 02:12:21.200
and this is part of the Labor Distribution Review,

02:12:21.200 --> 02:12:25.780
Patty will be undertaking during 1314 budget prep.

02:12:25.780 --> 02:12:29.220
M&O costs make up 24% of the Water Fund,

02:12:29.220 --> 02:12:32.820
and are a little over 35% of budget.

02:12:32.820 --> 02:12:35.260
We haven't expended much out of utilities yet,

02:12:35.260 --> 02:12:37.140
and power costs will definitely pick up

02:12:37.140 --> 02:12:41.440
as the demand during the summer months picks up.

02:12:41.440 --> 02:12:44.480
Capital costs make up 14% of the budget

02:12:44.480 --> 02:12:47.720
and currently show we've spent about 24%.

02:12:47.720 --> 02:12:51.280
Year to date, we spent money on the facility plan upgrade,

02:12:51.280 --> 02:12:54.160
booster upgrades, PLC booster upgrades,

02:12:54.160 --> 02:12:58.480
and excavator, flatbed trailer, and a vehicle.

02:12:58.480 --> 02:13:01.160
These projects and other budgeted capital projects

02:13:01.160 --> 02:13:04.360
will pick up during the summer months.

02:13:04.360 --> 02:13:07.920
Debt makes up one-third of this budget at $3 million.

02:13:07.920 --> 02:13:10.880
And we're showing that 144% spent year to date,

02:13:10.880 --> 02:13:13.920
but it's the old we paid off the debt early story.

02:13:13.920 --> 02:13:15.900
While our budget will show it's out of line,

02:13:15.900 --> 02:13:19.640
refinancing that debt and paying off that 4% DEQ loan,

02:13:19.640 --> 02:13:22.160
save the city in the rate payers hundreds of thousands

02:13:22.160 --> 02:13:23.640
of dollars.

02:13:23.640 --> 02:13:25.520
Now this anomaly will continue to show up

02:13:25.520 --> 02:13:28.360
on the financial updates for the remainder of the year.

02:13:28.360 --> 02:13:30.640
But if you remove the payoff, this category

02:13:30.640 --> 02:13:32.800
is only at 15% of budget.

02:13:32.800 --> 02:13:36.640
as we've only made interest payments on our 2009 bond series.

02:13:38.000 --> 02:13:40.120
Transfers make up 10% of the budget,

02:13:40.120 --> 02:13:42.740
and of course we're at 50%.

02:13:42.740 --> 02:13:47.420
And in total, the water fund is showing 73% spent,

02:13:47.420 --> 02:13:49.940
50% through our fiscal year.

02:13:49.940 --> 02:13:52.980
If you remove the debt payoff from expenditures,

02:13:52.980 --> 02:13:55.940
this fund is only about 30% spent a year to date.

02:14:00.100 --> 02:14:01.100
In the wastewater fund,

02:14:01.100 --> 02:14:03.860
there are three major revenue sources we're gonna review,

02:14:03.860 --> 02:14:07.210
residential industrial municipal.

02:14:07.210 --> 02:14:10.650
These account for 95% of the total revenues in this fund.

02:14:10.650 --> 02:14:13.290
And we'll start with a look at residential user fees

02:14:13.290 --> 02:14:15.770
from 2010 through current.

02:14:15.770 --> 02:14:19.130
For the first six months of 2013,

02:14:19.130 --> 02:14:23.770
this revenue is coming in at about 3.7% higher than 2012

02:14:23.770 --> 02:14:26.660
after our 2% rate adjustment.

02:14:26.660 --> 02:14:30.860
Industrial user revenues are pretty difficult to predict.

02:14:30.860 --> 02:14:34.860
We find out about changes in usage after the fact.

02:14:34.860 --> 02:14:37.140
Industries don't want to share that information,

02:14:37.140 --> 02:14:39.620
whether they're ramping up or slowing down production,

02:14:39.620 --> 02:14:41.940
even when we ask them directly.

02:14:41.940 --> 02:14:44.820
So this revenue was up from 2012,

02:14:44.820 --> 02:14:46.940
but it's because we have a new user,

02:14:46.940 --> 02:14:49.620
not to the levels that we had anticipated.

02:14:49.620 --> 02:14:52.260
Also, expenditures related to this new user

02:14:52.260 --> 02:14:55.580
are not to the levels anticipated either.

02:14:55.580 --> 02:14:58.540
Municipal user fees for 2013 are showing

02:14:58.540 --> 02:15:02.260
just a slight decline over 2012.

02:15:02.260 --> 02:15:05.940
Overall, we're up about 6% from the same time last year

02:15:05.940 --> 02:15:11.060
with these three revenue sources.

02:15:11.060 --> 02:15:13.160
On the expenditure side,

02:15:13.160 --> 02:15:15.840
personnel costs are 7% of the total,

02:15:15.840 --> 02:15:19.080
and we're showing 52% spent through March,

02:15:19.080 --> 02:15:21.200
and this too will be part of the labor distribution

02:15:21.200 --> 02:15:23.770
reviewed by Patty.

02:15:23.770 --> 02:15:26.370
MNO costs are 50% of the total,

02:15:26.370 --> 02:15:29.330
and are showing 49% spent.

02:15:29.330 --> 02:15:33.010
If you remove $600,000 of Chobani activity

02:15:33.010 --> 02:15:35.370
that the city will be reimbursed for,

02:15:35.370 --> 02:15:37.790
and add in a March payment for OMI,

02:15:37.790 --> 02:15:41.360
these costs are at 39% of budget.

02:15:41.360 --> 02:15:44.200
Capital costs are roughly 18%,

02:15:44.200 --> 02:15:48.600
and according to our reports, we've expended 66%.

02:15:48.600 --> 02:15:51.600
And this includes some of those projects,

02:15:51.600 --> 02:15:54.760
Rock Creek Lift Station, improvements to the treatment plant

02:15:54.760 --> 02:15:56.560
that we were going to bond for.

02:15:56.560 --> 02:15:59.600
So we will include those in a budget amendment.

02:15:59.600 --> 02:16:01.720
When you strip out those items,

02:16:01.720 --> 02:16:12.700
year-to-day capital costs are more at like $290,000 or 22% of budget, debt 17% at 1.2 million.

02:16:12.700 --> 02:16:19.580
And of course we paid 462% because we did the payoff. Bond proceeds covered this and it will

02:16:19.580 --> 02:16:25.220
be part of the budget amendment. We also paid off our certificates of participation and that

02:16:25.220 --> 02:16:31.020
resulted in about a $10,000 savings to the city and to the rate payers. So if you strip

02:16:31.020 --> 02:16:35.400
about the early debt payoff, we've really spent about $163,000

02:16:35.400 --> 02:16:38.980
in our 13% of this budget.

02:16:38.980 --> 02:16:43.540
Transfers make up 8% of the total that $576,000,

02:16:43.540 --> 02:16:47.380
and they currently show 554% spent.

02:16:47.380 --> 02:16:49.580
It's just the $2.9 million that we

02:16:49.580 --> 02:16:51.780
repaid to the general fund.

02:16:51.780 --> 02:16:53.980
So in total, the wastewater fund appears

02:16:53.980 --> 02:16:57.940
to be 161% spent halfway through the fiscal year.

02:16:57.940 --> 02:16:59.900
But if you subtract out the expenditures that

02:16:59.900 --> 02:17:01.900
will be included in the budget amendment,

02:17:01.900 --> 02:17:06.220
We're about 30% of budget and our expenditure graph looks more like this.

02:17:06.220 --> 02:17:13.790
So we're going to finish up our discussion with a look at the sanitation fund.

02:17:13.790 --> 02:17:18.910
This chart shows the budget and year-to-date actuals for the three major revenue categories

02:17:18.910 --> 02:17:22.680
and I've included recycling revenue as well.

02:17:22.680 --> 02:17:27.060
So we're really changing how we account for some of the revenue in this fund.

02:17:27.060 --> 02:17:33.140
In the past, the admin fee was included in garbage collections and I would like garbage

02:17:33.140 --> 02:17:38.000
collections to reflect only what we're receiving for that service. We've started

02:17:38.000 --> 02:17:42.160
breaking the admin fee out separately on the billing and also in our financial

02:17:42.160 --> 02:17:46.720
records. However due to a miscommunication this didn't begin until

02:17:46.720 --> 02:17:52.880
February. Also the revenue budget for the admin it's the second second little

02:17:52.880 --> 02:17:59.280
piece over it's showing we budgeted over $400,000. I believe that's way too

02:17:59.280 --> 02:18:04.320
high. I believe we calculated that early in the budget process and didn't adjust it down

02:18:04.320 --> 02:18:09.000
when we made some changes. So my goal this year is to ensure that we're collecting enough

02:18:09.000 --> 02:18:15.300
fees to cover our expenses. We'll be working to correctly state revenues and the 2013-14

02:18:15.300 --> 02:18:21.420
budget should be more in line with what's actually happening.

02:18:21.420 --> 02:18:28.600
On the expenditure side, personnel costs are 7% of sanitation's budget and we're at 52%

02:18:28.600 --> 02:18:36.420
M&O costs are 87% of the budget and include PSI and Twin Falls County solid waste.

02:18:36.420 --> 02:18:43.400
We're only showing 37% spent but there are some March fillings for PSI

02:18:43.400 --> 02:18:48.320
and the landfill that weren't paid until the 1st of April. So if you add those

02:18:48.320 --> 02:18:54.440
expenditures to the appropriate period, M&O budgets really 44% spent through

02:18:54.440 --> 02:19:00.880
March. There's no capital and there's no debt. It's simply an operations fund and

02:19:00.880 --> 02:19:05.380
that fact allowed you folks to use some unneeded reserves to help offset rate

02:19:05.380 --> 02:19:12.360
increases for several years. Finally transfers are 6% of the total and right

02:19:12.360 --> 02:19:18.960
on track. The sanitation fund is showing that we're 39% spent year to date. When

02:19:18.960 --> 02:19:23.360
you add in the additional expense for PSI in solid waste for March the fund is

02:19:23.360 --> 02:19:31.840
closer to 45% spent to date. So that is look at revenues and expenditures for our three major

02:19:31.840 --> 02:19:38.000
enterprise funds. That concludes what I prepared for you for this six month financial update

02:19:38.000 --> 02:19:43.160
and as the summary of revenues and expenditures for the enterprise funds is displaying. Happy

02:19:43.160 --> 02:19:48.720
to answer any other questions you might have. First laid on, Mr. Kristine. Lori, Travis,

02:19:48.720 --> 02:19:51.240
you may have to help on this.

02:19:51.240 --> 02:19:57.080
Our May 21st wastewater bond election, should that pass?

02:19:57.080 --> 02:20:00.280
I haven't heard a table, or at least I don't reacal act

02:20:00.280 --> 02:20:03.240
of when rates might be adjusted.

02:20:03.240 --> 02:20:07.400
This is a multi-year project for its completion.

02:20:07.400 --> 02:20:10.000
So I wouldn't envision it waiting until it's completely done

02:20:10.000 --> 02:20:14.000
or put it in the first month of construction.

02:20:14.000 --> 02:20:15.240
You know, that's a really good question.

02:20:15.240 --> 02:20:21.240
And we've had the conversations internally, and at this point in time, we're still really

02:20:21.240 --> 02:20:22.520
trying to work through that.

02:20:22.520 --> 02:20:29.160
We want to make sure that we are assessing the rate right around the time in which we need

02:20:29.160 --> 02:20:30.720
it.

02:20:30.720 --> 02:20:36.160
So we're probably looking at assessing a rate adjustment for our citizens no sooner than

02:20:36.160 --> 02:20:40.040
the beginning of the next fiscal year, but timing is everything, and so we want to make

02:20:40.040 --> 02:20:46.280
sure that we are collecting the appropriate resources to pay the debt.

02:20:46.280 --> 02:20:51.240
We believe internally that being in the strong financial position we are, we're going to

02:20:51.240 --> 02:20:56.160
be able to cash flow for a period of time which is going to delay the time that we have

02:20:56.160 --> 02:20:57.760
to move forward.

02:20:57.760 --> 02:21:03.280
But in working with CH and working with what that schedule looks like from an engineering

02:21:03.280 --> 02:21:10.000
perspective and then acquisition, more than likely we'll do one issuance, more than likely

02:21:10.000 --> 02:21:17.720
that one issue into probably occur at some time in late fall, early winter, and you will

02:21:17.720 --> 02:21:25.160
probably see us recommend an adjustment probably beginning of the fiscal year to be safe.

02:21:25.160 --> 02:21:26.450
Thank you.

02:21:26.450 --> 02:21:34.490
Laurie, as always, you explained everything in terms of weak and understand.

02:21:34.490 --> 02:21:38.670
I guess I should, I should, I should, I should, I should.

02:21:38.670 --> 02:21:42.830
That I can understand, but others that there aren't any lights on,

02:21:42.830 --> 02:21:47.150
so we appreciate your timely, oh, we do have light, Chris talked.

02:21:47.150 --> 02:21:52.430
I can't let you off, but without restating this, what the county wide

02:21:52.430 --> 02:21:58.670
across the board, reduction and assessed valuations, not residential property,

02:21:58.670 --> 02:22:03.170
that provides less property tax revenue to us, no.

02:22:03.170 --> 02:22:14.280
changes the rate. So remember in Idaho the tax rate is just a simple mathematical formula

02:22:14.280 --> 02:22:19.840
that on an annual basis you as a local government unit could collect three percent more revenue

02:22:19.840 --> 02:22:24.620
than you did the prior year and so you will always be able to collect those revenues until

02:22:24.620 --> 02:22:31.040
your tax rate hit a ceiling. So the challenges that we have is as the tax as the taxable

02:22:31.040 --> 02:22:37.800
value of the community decreases that tax rate may go up but the tax rate is not an indication

02:22:37.800 --> 02:22:42.300
the taxes are going up because the tax rate again is just a multiplier that is

02:22:42.300 --> 02:22:47.560
a tax that is multiplied against the value of the property and if the value of

02:22:47.560 --> 02:22:53.000
the community is going down then the value of the properties are going down and so

02:22:53.000 --> 02:22:59.200
it really depends upon is that the depreciation of the property greater than

02:22:59.200 --> 02:23:04.480
or less than the increase in the tax rate. So it becomes just more of a

02:23:04.480 --> 02:23:07.500
mathematical formula.

02:23:07.500 --> 02:23:14.280
John Hall, Lori, if you stated this, just forgive me.

02:23:14.280 --> 02:23:19.200
But I saw the other night that Idaho Power is going forward

02:23:19.200 --> 02:23:21.480
with asking for a hike adjustment.

02:23:21.480 --> 02:23:23.920
Have you been looking at that, tracking that, seeing when

02:23:23.920 --> 02:23:27.040
that possibly will take place, and how will that affect us?

02:23:27.040 --> 02:23:31.200
So they had a pretty large increase last year.

02:23:31.200 --> 02:23:34.640
And that's the additional 100,000 that I'm projecting will

02:23:34.640 --> 02:23:36.600
will receive from Idaho Power.

02:23:36.600 --> 02:23:39.200
So we'll be including a portion of that,

02:23:39.200 --> 02:23:41.960
but they're also looking at another rate increase.

02:23:41.960 --> 02:23:46.120
So that could affect increase our revenue projections.

02:23:46.120 --> 02:23:48.120
That's not a given though, correct.

02:23:48.120 --> 02:23:50.040
They have to go through PUC.

02:23:50.040 --> 02:23:51.480
Will it be approved?

02:23:51.480 --> 02:23:54.120
I don't know if I've ever seen them not be.

02:23:54.120 --> 02:23:57.720
There's been a few times when they question their method

02:23:57.720 --> 02:24:00.400
of figuring the rate and they wanted

02:24:00.400 --> 02:24:02.720
to use a different average for the amount of water coming

02:24:02.720 --> 02:24:03.920
on the river and things like that.

02:24:03.920 --> 02:24:07.440
So they have been adjusted all the time.

02:24:07.440 --> 02:24:08.440
Good, that's good to hear.

02:24:08.440 --> 02:24:14.380
Thank you, Laura.

02:24:14.380 --> 02:24:17.140
Next up is a continued discussion

02:24:17.140 --> 02:24:24.590
of the upcoming budget and travel to Roth

02:24:24.590 --> 02:24:32.250
and City Manager has the floor, but he's still doing something.

02:24:32.250 --> 02:24:36.650
So there's a silent communication going up to him.

02:24:36.650 --> 02:25:04.090
I'm trying to fill space there.

02:25:04.090 --> 02:25:08.220
We're interested in taking a quick break, yes sir.

02:25:08.220 --> 02:25:09.980
We have a technical difficult,

02:25:09.980 --> 02:25:11.940
we're probably gonna take one after this anyway

02:25:11.940 --> 02:25:13.420
before the public hearing.

02:25:13.420 --> 02:25:14.860
Those of you who came for the public hearings,

02:25:14.860 --> 02:25:18.460
we never start them before six o'clock,

02:25:18.460 --> 02:25:21.420
but we certainly do often as our other agenda runs long,

02:25:21.420 --> 02:25:22.940
we start them after six o'clock,

02:25:22.940 --> 02:25:25.220
so let's go ahead and take our 10 minute break now,

02:25:25.220 --> 02:25:26.860
we'll do Travis, then we'll go right into

02:25:26.860 --> 02:25:31.910
the public hearing, it's a warrior, this is a business.

02:25:31.910 --> 02:26:01.130
Recents, this is the term, what can I do with that term?

02:26:01.130 --> 02:26:06.630
I think that the work that she is doing and the work that the finance department team is doing

02:26:06.630 --> 02:26:11.470
really makes our jobs a lot easier.

02:26:11.470 --> 02:26:15.710
And what Laurie communicated with me and we went through a presentation earlier was relax

02:26:15.710 --> 02:26:22.170
were fine and I'll show you how and we really, you know, with her team and going through

02:26:22.170 --> 02:26:28.710
all of the information, I think the city of Twin Falls stands in a really good financial

02:26:28.710 --> 02:26:35.190
position compared to most. And the reason we are there is because of these types of processes,

02:26:35.190 --> 02:26:40.870
not only communicating openly about our finances but having our financial dashboard online and

02:26:40.870 --> 02:26:47.520
probably starting our budget process far earlier than anyone else dreams of. While other organizations

02:26:47.520 --> 02:26:53.160
may be having those conversations internally, we are the only ones that I know that start

02:26:53.160 --> 02:26:54.160
in April.

02:26:54.160 --> 02:26:57.540
And I think that's really good for that process.

02:26:57.540 --> 02:27:00.020
So this is the second installment.

02:27:00.020 --> 02:27:06.420
This is really quick because after this, this is designed to provide a recap of the conversation

02:27:06.420 --> 02:27:12.460
from last week, but really then to kind of get you back engaged in how you would like

02:27:12.460 --> 02:27:20.460
to see and what you would like to see included in the upcoming fiscal year 2014 budget.

02:27:20.460 --> 02:27:25.340
Again, everything that we do in the city of Twin Falls, our strategic plan, our budget,

02:27:25.340 --> 02:27:30.340
performance measurement system, the levels of services, the types of services, the different

02:27:30.340 --> 02:27:35.200
services that we're engaged in should all be based upon the mission of the City of Twin

02:27:35.200 --> 02:27:36.200
Falls.

02:27:36.200 --> 02:27:39.620
It is our job to meet the current and the future needs.

02:27:39.620 --> 02:27:45.540
The budgeting process helps us communicate current as well as future needs because some

02:27:45.540 --> 02:27:49.620
of these things take many, many years to go forward with.

02:27:49.620 --> 02:27:56.840
It is our job to promote public safety, to encourage citizen input, to preserve our heritage,

02:27:56.840 --> 02:28:00.620
and really develop a sense of well-being for our community.

02:28:00.620 --> 02:28:06.140
At the end of the day by living up to our mission, we do allow for the City of Twin Falls

02:28:06.140 --> 02:28:10.380
to continue to exist as it has in the past.

02:28:10.380 --> 02:28:13.100
The budgeting process is a part of that.

02:28:13.100 --> 02:28:15.220
So what did we talk about last time?

02:28:15.220 --> 02:28:17.660
We talked about why we budgeted.

02:28:17.660 --> 02:28:23.880
We talked about how it is important for us to keep our citizens safe, to engage in economic

02:28:23.880 --> 02:28:28.100
development, to continue to promote our community forward, to realize the objectives that are

02:28:28.100 --> 02:28:32.470
contained in the City Strategic Plan.

02:28:32.470 --> 02:28:36.790
Also, and we often don't talk about this because maybe we think it's assumed, but we

02:28:36.790 --> 02:28:40.670
are required by law to have a balanced budget.

02:28:40.670 --> 02:28:45.910
And so when we go forward with this process, we have to make sure that every revenue is

02:28:45.910 --> 02:28:50.310
equal to every expenditure, and if we are going to go into a state of indebtedness, it

02:28:50.310 --> 02:28:54.400
is only at the consent of our citizens to do so.

02:28:54.400 --> 02:29:00.200
And then also, we talked about how there is a relationship between levels of services

02:29:00.200 --> 02:29:07.480
and the types of services, the types of projects that we can offer in our community.

02:29:07.480 --> 02:29:15.360
We reviewed the key budget drivers from the last time we had this type of conversation.

02:29:15.360 --> 02:29:21.080
We went forward and we took a look at the differences between the fiscal year 2012 budget

02:29:21.080 --> 02:29:27.080
and the fiscal year 2013 budget to really provide an illustration and you can see that

02:29:27.080 --> 02:29:33.420
that taxable value which is listed on top and then you take a look at government spending

02:29:33.420 --> 02:29:39.120
does create and produce the tax rate which is showing at the bottom and that user rates

02:29:39.120 --> 02:29:44.680
those are those enterprise funds are based upon the usage that our citizens for our water

02:29:44.680 --> 02:29:48.660
for our sewer, it's also for those who are members

02:29:48.660 --> 02:29:51.640
and use our sanitation system, which is namely all residential

02:29:51.640 --> 02:29:53.680
members of our community.

02:29:53.680 --> 02:29:55.940
It illustrates the difference in the tax rate.

02:29:55.940 --> 02:29:58.800
And although you look at that for the residential property owner,

02:29:58.800 --> 02:30:02.840
as we shared last time, the residential property owner

02:30:02.840 --> 02:30:06.400
saw a decrease in the dollars of or per capita taxes

02:30:06.400 --> 02:30:07.440
that they paid.

02:30:07.440 --> 02:30:10.240
Well, on the other side, because our commercial and industrial

02:30:10.240 --> 02:30:12.960
properties remained flat or even slightly increased,

02:30:12.960 --> 02:30:20.160
They did see a tax increase in the school year 13 compared to fiscal year 12.

02:30:20.160 --> 02:30:23.600
We illustrated what the budgets look like over the course of time.

02:30:23.600 --> 02:30:28.800
We pointed out that the highest budget that we still have is in 2009, and that our budgets

02:30:28.800 --> 02:30:35.600
have responded with the economy, and the budget that we issued in 2013 in totality was still

02:30:35.600 --> 02:30:39.520
less than the budget that was issued in 2009.

02:30:39.520 --> 02:30:43.280
The blue represents those government funds that Lori went through.

02:30:43.280 --> 02:30:48.110
the Reddit represents the enterprise funds.

02:30:48.110 --> 02:30:51.270
We illustrated what we, the steps that we took.

02:30:51.270 --> 02:30:53.950
And last year, the council elected to take the 3%

02:30:53.950 --> 02:30:55.910
plus the new growth formula, which

02:30:55.910 --> 02:31:02.910
caused a tax rate of $7.71.

02:31:02.910 --> 02:31:05.070
At our last meeting, we had a conversation

02:31:05.070 --> 02:31:08.230
about the upcoming tax options and what that looked like.

02:31:08.230 --> 02:31:10.470
And the direction that we took from the conversation,

02:31:10.470 --> 02:31:13.590
it looked like the council would be at least at this time

02:31:13.590 --> 02:31:17.390
in favor of looking at the 3% and the growth

02:31:17.390 --> 02:31:23.150
and leaving before gone balance of $1,479,000 on the table

02:31:23.150 --> 02:31:31.440
at this point, not to be considered.

02:31:31.440 --> 02:31:35.950
And this kind of recaps what some of those are.

02:31:35.950 --> 02:31:38.310
We also spent some time really reflecting

02:31:38.310 --> 02:31:39.990
about the cost of doing business

02:31:39.990 --> 02:31:43.470
and what that cost of doing business looks like.

02:31:43.470 --> 02:31:46.670
And we compare ourselves to the municipal cost index

02:31:46.670 --> 02:31:49.950
and if all things were to remain the same

02:31:49.950 --> 02:31:53.390
and we were to keep up with inflation as it's in quotes,

02:31:53.390 --> 02:31:58.390
You'll notice that we need about $936,000 of new money

02:31:58.390 --> 02:32:01.050
across all of the funds to be able to support

02:32:01.050 --> 02:32:03.050
and supply the same levels of service

02:32:03.050 --> 02:32:07.610
and to fund capital at similar levels that we did last year.

02:32:07.610 --> 02:32:11.970
And we broke that down, which translates to $561,000

02:32:11.970 --> 02:32:16.970
of tax-supported revenue based upon the budget of $29,054,000.

02:32:17.450 --> 02:32:19.690
You might remember a slight difference from Lori's

02:32:19.690 --> 02:32:22.010
and that's because the transfers have been taken out

02:32:22.010 --> 02:32:24.170
For budgeting purposes, we look at the net.

02:32:24.170 --> 02:32:27.130
We look at those total net, not the dollars that are transferred

02:32:27.130 --> 02:32:31.500
from the water fund or the sewer fund and into the general fund.

02:32:31.500 --> 02:32:38.140
And then in the enterprise funds, you're looking at about $375,000.

02:32:38.140 --> 02:32:48.840
So if you refer back to this slide, the $671,000 of new taxable revenue,

02:32:48.840 --> 02:32:53.600
a significant portion of that will be used to maintain and go forward

02:32:53.600 --> 02:32:56.040
with the current levels of service that we have.

02:32:56.040 --> 02:32:59.720
The $561,000 is just an estimate.

02:32:59.720 --> 02:33:03.320
It is only an estimate because we are just at the very infancy

02:33:03.320 --> 02:33:07.480
of our budgeting process, but it's a good place to start

02:33:07.480 --> 02:33:09.320
from an informational perspective.

02:33:09.320 --> 02:33:14.240
This does not, the $561,000 if that were real, does not include

02:33:14.240 --> 02:33:17.800
any additional costs associated with compensation adjustments

02:33:17.800 --> 02:33:21.880
or any changes or modifications associated

02:33:21.880 --> 02:33:26.480
with health insurance or other types of benefits.

02:33:26.480 --> 02:33:29.600
We spent some time talking about how the homeowners exemption

02:33:29.600 --> 02:33:33.120
is indexed and what that means and why that's important.

02:33:33.120 --> 02:33:38.760
And you can see that over the course of time since 2005,

02:33:38.760 --> 02:33:40.920
there has been significant, what I would describe,

02:33:40.920 --> 02:33:44.100
fluctuations in the homeowners exemption

02:33:44.100 --> 02:33:46.400
that is provided starting out at 50,000

02:33:46.400 --> 02:33:48.400
and then moving to 75.

02:33:48.400 --> 02:33:52.000
And you can see that in 2000, and I believe that's 9,

02:33:52.000 --> 02:33:58.480
it crested at $104,471, and that's about the time

02:33:58.480 --> 02:34:01.840
in which the property values for tax purposes began

02:34:01.840 --> 02:34:04.720
to see the effects of the recession.

02:34:04.720 --> 02:34:07.720
And we began to see that downward decline

02:34:07.720 --> 02:34:12.270
and depreciation of properties to where it is today.

02:34:12.270 --> 02:34:15.190
And you can see it's more of a flattening out.

02:34:15.190 --> 02:34:19.030
For this upcoming tax year, the homeowner's exemption

02:34:19.030 --> 02:34:21.750
will be $81,000.

02:34:21.750 --> 02:34:25.830
Based upon our conversations, that does make sense.

02:34:25.830 --> 02:34:28.330
When we have the conversations with the county assessors,

02:34:28.330 --> 02:34:30.070
they've shared with us that they believe

02:34:30.070 --> 02:34:33.510
that residential property values should decrease again

02:34:33.510 --> 02:34:37.510
this fiscal year for our tax purposes for about 3%

02:34:39.470 --> 02:34:42.350
which is about in line with the homeowner's exemption

02:34:42.350 --> 02:34:44.630
decrease of about 3.5%.

02:34:44.630 --> 02:34:47.790
So we are reflecting of what is also being seen

02:34:47.790 --> 02:34:49.950
statewide in the Idaho market.

02:34:49.950 --> 02:34:53.110
So that 81,000 is a statewide number, not as to to

02:34:53.110 --> 02:34:54.110
default.

02:34:54.110 --> 02:34:55.110
It is.

02:34:55.110 --> 02:34:56.310
It is a statewide number that is provided by the

02:34:56.310 --> 02:34:57.310
IDO Tax Commission.

02:34:57.310 --> 02:35:00.270
We usually get that number in late fall, and so what is

02:35:00.270 --> 02:35:03.550
going to be really interesting is to be able to, and it

02:35:03.550 --> 02:35:06.270
applies for then the following June, and we'll be able to take a

02:35:06.270 --> 02:35:09.590
look at that to see if that goes up, if that homeowner's

02:35:09.590 --> 02:35:12.870
exemption increases because it's indexed, that's a good

02:35:12.870 --> 02:35:16.830
indication that property values have began to recover, and we're

02:35:16.830 --> 02:35:19.870
hearing right now in just in the market that property values

02:35:19.870 --> 02:35:25.390
are beginning to appreciate we're seeing that in national publications. We're also hearing

02:35:25.390 --> 02:35:32.800
that locally from several of our builders, developers and members of the visitor community.

02:35:32.800 --> 02:35:37.480
Building activity. We illustrated what building activity was for single family permits and

02:35:37.480 --> 02:35:43.360
we illustrated that permits from the standpoint for this year are looking really good. Here's

02:35:43.360 --> 02:35:51.960
an update. For April, we issued 25 single family permits. That was the report that I sent out

02:35:51.960 --> 02:35:53.960
to the Council on Friday.

02:35:53.960 --> 02:35:57.040
The prior year, we only issued 12.

02:35:57.040 --> 02:36:00.700
There were four building permits that had not been issued,

02:36:00.700 --> 02:36:02.000
and so they were not included.

02:36:02.000 --> 02:36:05.200
So on the first week of May, we started automatically

02:36:05.200 --> 02:36:07.120
with four moving forward.

02:36:07.120 --> 02:36:09.080
We are starting to see significant return

02:36:09.080 --> 02:36:11.320
around in the number of building permits.

02:36:11.320 --> 02:36:14.280
We began, we started hearing early from buildings

02:36:14.280 --> 02:36:16.920
that they would be building more homes this year.

02:36:16.920 --> 02:36:18.480
And now we're starting to see that.

02:36:18.480 --> 02:36:20.520
Commercial properties and commercial investments

02:36:20.520 --> 02:36:23.420
are also up and continuing to move forward.

02:36:23.420 --> 02:36:25.240
We're aware of several commercial properties

02:36:25.240 --> 02:36:27.080
that are not reflective on the list

02:36:27.080 --> 02:36:29.820
that intend on pulling building permits

02:36:29.820 --> 02:36:31.200
within the next 60 days.

02:36:31.200 --> 02:36:33.360
And you'll start really seeing a rise

02:36:33.360 --> 02:36:36.080
in the number of commercial building permits as well.

02:36:36.080 --> 02:36:38.640
When you look here, though, it's still a significant increase.

02:36:38.640 --> 02:36:43.600
It's about 125% over where we were in the prior year.

02:36:43.600 --> 02:36:49.340
And on the April report, that has done nothing but improve.

02:36:49.340 --> 02:36:51.860
So the building permit and the valuations

02:36:51.860 --> 02:36:58.900
translates into future years, expansion of our tax base, and the new construction roll through the

02:36:58.900 --> 02:37:04.260
growth formula. We also want to make sure that we're taking a look at that number from a revenue

02:37:04.260 --> 02:37:11.860
perspective. So when we issue those building permits that we assign a revenue amount and that those

02:37:11.860 --> 02:37:16.740
revenue amounts are coming in and I think that Lori did a really good job in during her report

02:37:16.740 --> 02:37:21.780
reflecting that building permit revenues are at least on base up where we anticipated

02:37:21.780 --> 02:37:28.050
and with April's numbers should be much more robust.

02:37:28.050 --> 02:37:31.210
Another really good indicator that we take a look at is on employment.

02:37:31.210 --> 02:37:36.930
We illustrated the impacts of the improved economy from several of our employers.

02:37:36.930 --> 02:37:42.250
Chibani also having a significant role in the number of jobs that have been provided.

02:37:42.250 --> 02:37:49.740
You can see that our unemployment has significantly decreased from where it was a year ago, and

02:37:49.740 --> 02:37:56.060
we have every anticipation that that will continue as additional factories, additional

02:37:56.060 --> 02:37:59.820
factories create those additional workforce opportunities.

02:37:59.820 --> 02:38:05.980
And then at the tail end, I presented what I believe to be some of those really important

02:38:05.980 --> 02:38:08.950
items in moving forward.

02:38:08.950 --> 02:38:14.150
the phase two of the compensation strategy, we made great headway last year, but we're

02:38:14.150 --> 02:38:19.650
not at a place where I believe that we can rest. Attracting quality employees into our

02:38:19.650 --> 02:38:25.330
organization for vacancies, maintaining the quality workforce that we have is paramount

02:38:25.330 --> 02:38:34.330
to our success. We are a public service organization, and it's done with people. It's done with us

02:38:34.330 --> 02:38:38.990
having the ability to attract the best and the brightest to come to work with us.

02:38:38.990 --> 02:38:46.330
As that economy begins to improve, and those firms in the private sector that we compete

02:38:46.330 --> 02:38:53.490
with come into our house to begin to lure folks away, it is also important that we make sure

02:38:53.490 --> 02:39:01.690
that all aspects of our organization are competitively paid, not only with those public sector comparisons,

02:39:01.690 --> 02:39:08.450
also in those private sector comparisons where there is a relevant and important match.

02:39:08.450 --> 02:39:12.490
Finding the resources to implement the new strategic plan, part of that conversation tonight

02:39:12.490 --> 02:39:17.170
is to talk about the strategic planning objectives that you want to move forward with at our last

02:39:17.170 --> 02:39:18.170
meeting.

02:39:18.170 --> 02:39:23.730
Rebecca shared that as an example, the dog park was something that as a starting place she

02:39:23.730 --> 02:39:29.490
would like to see included in the parks and recreation capital projects moving forward.

02:39:29.490 --> 02:39:34.290
The purpose of tonight is really to define those strategic planning objectives that you

02:39:34.290 --> 02:39:40.010
would like to see move forward so that as we go into our budget hearings the week of the

02:39:40.010 --> 02:39:46.290
20th we are incorporating your thoughts early on into that budget process which is the main

02:39:46.290 --> 02:39:49.800
purpose for these conversations now.

02:39:49.800 --> 02:39:53.200
Continuing to make those capital investments in our infrastructure and facilities so that

02:39:53.200 --> 02:39:58.440
we are keeping pace, we are moving forward and that we are fixing some of the deferred maintenance

02:39:58.440 --> 02:40:02.560
that we have in our community, strengthening and collaborating

02:40:02.560 --> 02:40:04.880
through better public-private partnerships.

02:40:04.880 --> 02:40:07.320
Our strategic plan is based upon that.

02:40:07.320 --> 02:40:09.960
And then, as Councilman Hall shared, and we included this

02:40:09.960 --> 02:40:13.360
in the list, continuing to seek to strive to find greater

02:40:13.360 --> 02:40:17.400
efficiencies and more effective outcomes with the people's money

02:40:17.400 --> 02:40:21.210
that they trust with us to deliver public services.

02:40:21.210 --> 02:40:23.650
So with that, we turn it over to you.

02:40:23.650 --> 02:40:38.650
I don't know, Travis have we heard or do we have any indication of where we're going to be with where we're going to be with health insurance costs any preliminary information coming our way.

02:40:38.650 --> 02:40:44.890
So I'm going to look back at Sue, excuse me.

02:40:44.890 --> 02:40:52.890
We're looking at a series of different health options, but at this point in time because our renewal process is still ways out.

02:40:52.890 --> 02:40:57.390
has not been able to get a quote yet, but we're also looking at the possibility of

02:40:57.390 --> 02:41:01.090
becoming partially self-insured. We'll ask for a quote with that. We'll go through

02:41:01.090 --> 02:41:04.890
the proper paperwork. So we are taking the steps that we need to make sure that

02:41:04.890 --> 02:41:11.010
healthcare in the future is long-term and viable. But at this point, we don't. They're

02:41:11.010 --> 02:41:15.170
really all from what you hear from people. They're really all across the board.

02:41:15.170 --> 02:41:21.920
Yeah, thank you. They, you know, solve connections with a few different

02:41:21.920 --> 02:41:24.560
of the public entities and things, and they were talking

02:41:24.560 --> 02:41:26.780
of some fairly low rates, but I think they were also

02:41:26.780 --> 02:41:28.660
messing with the benefits at the same time.

02:41:28.660 --> 02:41:30.520
The benefits were getting less,

02:41:30.520 --> 02:41:32.040
but the rate wasn't going up much,

02:41:32.040 --> 02:41:35.140
and that seemed to be, select health seemed to be

02:41:35.140 --> 02:41:37.240
causing that a little bit, because some of the major

02:41:37.240 --> 02:41:40.680
employers are looking at, at least going to select health.

02:41:40.680 --> 02:41:42.680
I know CSI is going there.

02:41:42.680 --> 02:41:45.780
CSI is looking, I think there's Prince Foods is looking

02:41:45.780 --> 02:41:48.320
and things, which is the new player.

02:41:48.320 --> 02:41:49.840
Those are not sure what select health is,

02:41:49.840 --> 02:41:53.840
It's a new player that's in partnership with St. Luke's.

02:41:53.840 --> 02:42:00.340
I know Susan and the members of the HR team were really able to successfully negotiate

02:42:00.340 --> 02:42:07.440
from the starting point of where our original adjustment came in and they worked significantly

02:42:07.440 --> 02:42:09.240
to decrease that.

02:42:09.240 --> 02:42:14.840
It did cause us though to have to increase the deductible amount and one of the things

02:42:14.840 --> 02:42:19.520
we want to make sure when we look at compensation that we look at the total cost of

02:42:19.520 --> 02:42:24.800
compensation. It's not just salary, but it's also full compensation by looking at benefits

02:42:24.800 --> 02:42:31.560
as well and how we compare to those that we're competing against in a full compensation model.

02:42:31.560 --> 02:42:40.040
Chris Dininga? Along that same line, thanks for bringing it up on. I think your office, Travis,

02:42:40.040 --> 02:42:48.400
has to be planful enough to be looking ahead to implementation of Obamacare or the state.

02:42:48.400 --> 02:42:51.000
with a call to state of smart exchange or whatever it is.

02:42:51.000 --> 02:42:52.280
This is health insurance exchange.

02:42:52.280 --> 02:42:55.200
That has to have some impact on us and a lot of it

02:42:55.200 --> 02:42:56.000
is not known.

02:42:56.000 --> 02:43:01.240
But I think we need to really have our feeders out, if you will,

02:43:01.240 --> 02:43:03.640
what other municipalities are hearing

02:43:03.640 --> 02:43:07.840
and to clue the council in as soon as possible on the potential

02:43:07.840 --> 02:43:11.280
of long-term impacts to the budget as well as coverage,

02:43:11.280 --> 02:43:11.920
of course.

02:43:11.920 --> 02:43:13.280
Absolutely.

02:43:13.280 --> 02:43:15.560
Thank you, Chris.

02:43:15.560 --> 02:43:17.760
Travis, I'm not seeing any other lights.

02:43:17.760 --> 02:43:22.980
So when are we next scheduled to talk about this June June.

02:43:22.980 --> 02:43:25.040
So we're hoping for a little bit more direction.

02:43:25.040 --> 02:43:27.980
I will shut that but a few that got a few lights on.

02:43:27.980 --> 02:43:29.980
Sean Berger.

02:43:29.980 --> 02:43:31.980
So Travis, I agree with your assessment

02:43:31.980 --> 02:43:33.980
of sort of the priorities that you laid out

02:43:33.980 --> 02:43:38.140
in those broad broad strokes.

02:43:38.140 --> 02:43:40.620
You know, a few areas of focus that I

02:43:40.620 --> 02:43:45.640
would like to see streets really addressing

02:43:45.640 --> 02:43:48.560
some of our street construction needs, road construction

02:43:48.560 --> 02:43:54.640
needs. And again, I don't know the answers to all of those, but that's a critical issue

02:43:54.640 --> 02:43:59.320
that I think we tend to get behind and then we sort of get ahead and then we get behind

02:43:59.320 --> 02:44:06.570
and I'd like to see some consistency there. And then from the Parks and Rec perspective,

02:44:06.570 --> 02:44:12.460
I like the way we've approached things this year to put a reasonable amount of funds into

02:44:12.460 --> 02:44:16.860
actually accomplishing something of substance as opposed to piecemealing money all around

02:44:16.860 --> 02:44:19.700
and trying to get bits and pieces of things.

02:44:19.700 --> 02:44:23.300
So I would hope that the Parks and Rec Department

02:44:23.300 --> 02:44:24.900
will continue to look at that.

02:44:24.900 --> 02:44:27.300
I'm looking at Dennis behind you.

02:44:27.300 --> 02:44:30.100
But find some priority projects there.

02:44:30.100 --> 02:44:34.300
And that could be Dog Park, Community Garden,

02:44:34.300 --> 02:44:36.740
significant enhancements to parks that

02:44:36.740 --> 02:44:39.020
don't have a lot of amenities.

02:44:39.020 --> 02:44:41.660
But I also think that is a great segue

02:44:41.660 --> 02:44:45.060
to your strengthening collaborative public-private partnerships.

02:44:45.060 --> 02:44:47.140
I don't know that that needs to be the city's nickel

02:44:47.140 --> 02:44:48.620
for all of those things.

02:44:48.620 --> 02:44:51.220
We have some good examples with the Blue Lakes Rotary Club,

02:44:51.220 --> 02:44:56.220
for example, with the Canine Social Club

02:44:56.220 --> 02:44:58.820
and their efforts with the dog park.

02:44:58.820 --> 02:45:05.170
And so one of the things I've thought of is,

02:45:05.170 --> 02:45:09.490
does it take another body, another employee,

02:45:09.490 --> 02:45:14.410
to champion collaborative public-private partnerships?

02:45:14.410 --> 02:45:17.930
Does it make sense to have a like you would have a grant

02:45:17.930 --> 02:45:19.490
writer who's out pursuing grants?

02:45:19.490 --> 02:45:21.450
Do you need a person whose job it is

02:45:21.450 --> 02:45:25.410
to go build these partnerships and create those functions?

02:45:25.410 --> 02:45:27.130
I throw it out as something to think about.

02:45:27.130 --> 02:45:30.170
I don't know if other communities have it.

02:45:30.170 --> 02:45:33.650
But I think as I look through all of these strategic initiatives

02:45:33.650 --> 02:45:39.870
that we have, few if any of these are us on our own.

02:45:39.870 --> 02:45:46.870
And I know the staff is already lean and busy doing the things that they do.

02:45:46.870 --> 02:45:53.870
It might be something to think about if a position really could return dollars and cents to the bottom line.

02:45:53.870 --> 02:45:56.870
It might make sense to look at something like that across the board.

02:45:56.870 --> 02:45:58.870
So those are just a few items that I'll throw out.

02:45:58.870 --> 02:45:59.870
Thank you.

02:45:59.870 --> 02:46:01.870
Uh, right in the second.

02:46:01.870 --> 02:46:03.870
Thank you, Rare.

02:46:03.870 --> 02:46:08.870
I did mention a few last time, so I wanted to wait and give other people an opportunity.

02:46:08.870 --> 02:46:14.670
I think a few of the objectives that we should put forward first are the ones that include planning.

02:46:14.670 --> 02:46:26.410
And a lot of the objectives, for example, you know, there's HC-1, well, I just had it, HC-1.1b.

02:46:26.410 --> 02:46:32.410
And that says that we'll require bike and walking past intrels as part of our development,

02:46:32.410 --> 02:46:39.410
and then EC-2.1 adopt a master plan with funding mechanisms and development standards for parks,

02:46:39.410 --> 02:46:41.870
parks, recreation, trails, and natural features.

02:46:41.870 --> 02:46:47.530
I know a couple other objectives include a street's master plan or updating other master

02:46:47.530 --> 02:46:48.530
plans.

02:46:48.530 --> 02:46:53.410
I think those are ones that we should put forward first because as we move forward about the

02:46:53.410 --> 02:46:58.950
business of the city, we're going to need those planning documents to help us do it correctly

02:46:58.950 --> 02:47:03.190
and to have a holistic perspective.

02:47:03.190 --> 02:47:07.730
So I would like to move forward with those and there are many of them.

02:47:07.730 --> 02:47:11.890
I'm sure you and your staff can identify which ones.

02:47:11.890 --> 02:47:13.730
There's a master plan of transportation

02:47:13.730 --> 02:47:18.730
for all modes of transportation, I believe that's SC4.1E.

02:47:20.850 --> 02:47:25.850
So along with definitely supporting

02:47:26.850 --> 02:47:29.530
like Councilman Berger was saying,

02:47:29.530 --> 02:47:31.650
the critical infrastructure of the streets

02:47:31.650 --> 02:47:36.650
and not deferring needed maintenance in all of our systems.

02:47:36.650 --> 02:47:44.770
systems. I know one of the objectives is about the redundancy for our water system. I think

02:47:44.770 --> 02:47:50.890
that has to be number one. You know, we want to protect ourselves and move forward in funding

02:47:50.890 --> 02:47:56.550
what we need to fund and fund that plan that we just spent a quarter of a million dollars

02:47:56.550 --> 02:48:02.650
building. You know, we want to follow up and not just have that, but fund as much as we

02:48:02.650 --> 02:48:10.650
we can, while being sensitive to rate increases, but if we're deferring maintenance in our

02:48:10.650 --> 02:48:18.730
water system or wastewater system, we need to have those rates equal to what is wise as

02:48:18.730 --> 02:48:24.330
far as putting the correct amount of infrastructure in place.

02:48:24.330 --> 02:48:30.330
So I know that we have the parks and rec things that we want to do, and we definitely should

02:48:30.330 --> 02:48:38.170
always prioritize quality of life items, but certainly I know in the past we have had some

02:48:38.170 --> 02:48:42.370
problems with deferred maintenance and we definitely don't want to continue that. So

02:48:42.370 --> 02:48:48.090
what's left, you know, sometimes it might require cuts, you know, in things that we

02:48:48.090 --> 02:48:53.370
might want. And I know you guys always have a list of things that didn't quite make it,

02:48:53.370 --> 02:48:58.950
and so I recognize that that's going to happen. But definitely, I would like to move forward

02:48:58.950 --> 02:49:02.390
on those objectives that set out plans.

02:49:02.390 --> 02:49:07.150
Another one just to mention is downtown parking.

02:49:07.150 --> 02:49:12.950
You know, we get many requests for buying this piece of property or that piece of property

02:49:12.950 --> 02:49:16.290
and developing it into a parking lot here and a parking lot there.

02:49:16.290 --> 02:49:23.390
I would like to move forward on the objective that makes a well-reasoned and logical plan

02:49:23.390 --> 02:49:29.070
for downtown parking that encourages growth and you know helps bring all of the partners

02:49:29.070 --> 02:49:39.610
together. The businesses downtown, the URA, you know, economic development, but to have

02:49:39.610 --> 02:49:44.370
kind of a holistic view of parking and not just because it's difficult when we get those

02:49:44.370 --> 02:49:49.170
requests to just build a parking lot here, build a parking lot there. I think we need

02:49:49.170 --> 02:49:51.650
to look at it holistically.

02:49:51.650 --> 02:49:53.650
Thank you, Rick.

02:49:53.650 --> 02:49:54.650
Chris, talk of it.

02:49:54.650 --> 02:49:55.650
OK, Senator.

02:49:55.650 --> 02:49:58.650
Here's my wish list.

02:49:58.650 --> 02:50:01.650
Right along the line, I'll just pick up where Rebecca left off.

02:50:01.650 --> 02:50:05.650
I think it's incumbent for this Council and for the City

02:50:05.650 --> 02:50:10.650
Administration to ignite a fire in urban renewal to get their

02:50:10.650 --> 02:50:14.650
plan together where they can tie in some of the tax,

02:50:14.650 --> 02:50:18.650
anticipate or tax sharing areas and get that infrastructure

02:50:18.650 --> 02:50:27.110
infrastructure, actually not all on the drawing board, but actually changing out the sidewalks,

02:50:27.110 --> 02:50:33.910
the planings of water lines. We're way overdue to have revitalization of a bin structure and

02:50:33.910 --> 02:50:40.150
I know there are things that will follow until we do some internal investing. We are not

02:50:40.150 --> 02:50:45.050
going to be able to attract a substantial growth in downtown areas. So it's not going to be

02:50:45.050 --> 02:50:49.750
just on your shoulders beyond the council's shoulders to make sure urban renewal doesn't

02:50:49.750 --> 02:50:55.670
pontificate this thing for another year without action. As the council's liaison for the greater

02:50:55.670 --> 02:51:00.130
area chamber, no, it's not the chamber, is it?

02:51:00.130 --> 02:51:01.130
Transportation.

02:51:01.130 --> 02:51:02.130
Transportation.

02:51:02.130 --> 02:51:03.130
We need that.

02:51:03.130 --> 02:51:13.570
We're working on another thing with the chamber, but I think that, Jack, we need to put pressure

02:51:13.570 --> 02:51:19.730
on I.T.D. to give us some measurable feedback on the study that they're doing at these five

02:51:19.730 --> 02:51:26.090
points for the relocation of the truck lane. What do they call that project, by the way?

02:51:26.090 --> 02:51:34.890
It's the, yeah, that's what it is. You know, it's going to take jiggling on our end at

02:51:34.890 --> 02:51:40.130
this level for them to do much of anything, but there is money there. And the last thing

02:51:40.130 --> 02:51:48.120
deals with the chamber is to get that realignment of potential of the second avenues. I'm not

02:51:48.120 --> 02:51:53.720
sure ITD is going to give up the second avenues after all the money they spend in developing

02:51:53.720 --> 02:51:58.960
and widening them, but it should be a pursuit. And last but not least, since we talked about

02:51:58.960 --> 02:52:04.080
dog parks, I'll give you my last wish list so we could actually get a community garden

02:52:04.080 --> 02:52:07.080
somehow implemented this next year.

02:52:07.080 --> 02:52:08.800
Thank you.

02:52:08.800 --> 02:52:09.880
Don Hall.

02:52:09.880 --> 02:52:14.000
Chris, I just wanted to let you know that the URA is planning

02:52:14.000 --> 02:52:15.560
on doing a strategic plan.

02:52:15.560 --> 02:52:17.200
Again, updating their strategic plan.

02:52:17.200 --> 02:52:20.640
They were waiting for us to complete ours so they can make

02:52:20.640 --> 02:52:23.080
sure that it was in line as much as possible.

02:52:23.080 --> 02:52:23.960
That would make sense.

02:52:23.960 --> 02:52:26.480
So I'll make sure I share your views with them.

02:52:26.480 --> 02:52:29.320
I think they're appropriate.

02:52:29.320 --> 02:52:32.880
My, I guess I'm going to piggyback on a couple things,

02:52:32.880 --> 02:52:38.960
water infrastructure. We've had a few scares in the past about water infrastructure and I'm not

02:52:38.960 --> 02:52:43.920
just talking about lines, I'm talking about capacity, possible generators so that the pumps

02:52:43.920 --> 02:52:48.320
will still run, those kind of things. So that's kind of a personal priority of mine because

02:52:49.360 --> 02:52:56.800
we need water. We need water not only for water in our lawns or drinking but we need it for fire

02:52:56.800 --> 02:53:04.480
flows and all those other life health safety issues so please let's keep that on the front

02:53:04.480 --> 02:53:10.880
burner water infrastructure and I guess the last thing well yeah the last thing I really

02:53:10.880 --> 02:53:17.560
want to talk about I know that we are a service organization and as you eloquently put earlier

02:53:17.560 --> 02:53:26.760
Travis you said the service that we provide is with people and so I'll be somewhat open

02:53:26.760 --> 02:53:34.500
to ideas if we need more personnel in our fire, in our police, in our streets, in our water

02:53:34.500 --> 02:53:39.600
employees, because the town is growing, our infrastructure is growing.

02:53:39.600 --> 02:53:45.120
We have more roads, we have more responsibilities, we have more influx coming into this town.

02:53:45.120 --> 02:53:53.080
Giovanni, by itself, has brought more people driving through our town, which stretches and

02:53:53.080 --> 02:53:58.480
capabilities and really it's the people that we have employed with us that I think

02:53:58.480 --> 02:54:03.780
we run pretty thin and it's time to again can keep that on the front burner as well

02:54:03.780 --> 02:54:08.960
make sure that we have adequate personnel to provide those services and I'm gonna

02:54:08.960 --> 02:54:14.760
say this again would love to see someday the city having a grant writer and maybe

02:54:14.760 --> 02:54:18.500
it can be a dual role with some of the other ideas but I think we're leaving

02:54:18.500 --> 02:54:21.500
money on the table when it comes to grants.

02:54:21.500 --> 02:54:22.500
Thank you.

02:54:22.500 --> 02:54:23.790
Thanks, Don.

02:54:23.790 --> 02:54:24.790
Suzanne Hawkins.

02:54:24.790 --> 02:54:32.200
I think everybody's covered most of the main issues, but my list of priority would be to continue

02:54:32.200 --> 02:54:35.200
moving with the employee's salary packages.

02:54:35.200 --> 02:54:39.200
I would like to make sure that we're addressing those issues.

02:54:39.200 --> 02:54:44.960
I think it's only fair to compensate people according to the work they do.

02:54:44.960 --> 02:54:49.960
And I do know the city staff does a lot of really good things that helps make our jobs

02:54:49.960 --> 02:54:56.080
all much easier. And so I know I appreciate that. The infrastructure, again, the water.

02:54:56.080 --> 02:55:00.480
I'd really like to see us concentrate on that and the roads. But the other thing I would

02:55:00.480 --> 02:55:05.760
like to see is us continue with the forward thinking we've been doing with our IT department

02:55:05.760 --> 02:55:12.520
and our communication and the money we're investing into, the equipment to do what we

02:55:12.520 --> 02:55:19.120
need to do there and make sure that the people that are taking care of our computer and IT

02:55:19.120 --> 02:55:24.000
needs are also getting the training. They need to keep up with the technology because

02:55:24.000 --> 02:55:28.120
as you know it changes daily. So that would be my wish list.

02:55:28.120 --> 02:55:30.480
Thank you, Sam. Jim, man.

02:55:30.480 --> 02:55:35.240
Thank you, Mayor. Everybody's covered everything. I think we've got a pretty good handle on stuff.

02:55:35.240 --> 02:55:41.240
One of the questions I have though is on public buildings, I remember when we, do we have, are

02:55:41.240 --> 02:55:45.800
we going to be seeing some capital requests for public building improvements? For example,

02:55:45.800 --> 02:55:48.000
We have a police department that was built for 45 people.

02:55:48.000 --> 02:55:50.440
We have 105 people working out of the building.

02:55:50.440 --> 02:55:54.840
We have a whole group of women police officers who don't have a locker room.

02:55:54.840 --> 02:55:56.000
They should soon.

02:55:56.000 --> 02:56:00.520
Good. That's good. Are we okay there?

02:56:00.520 --> 02:56:03.240
I remember several years ago we had swamp coolers on the top of City Hall.

02:56:03.240 --> 02:56:06.960
I know we fixed that, but we're still a bit antiquated over there.

02:56:06.960 --> 02:56:08.760
We have to invest in our facilities.

02:56:08.760 --> 02:56:10.160
Yes, without question.

02:56:10.160 --> 02:56:11.840
Because that's part of the people equation.

02:56:11.840 --> 02:56:13.200
You're absolutely right.

02:56:13.200 --> 02:56:17.440
And I think that we've started to take those steps.

02:56:17.440 --> 02:56:22.600
We have funding in this year's budget to assist in the police department.

02:56:22.600 --> 02:56:25.680
We've made improvements in the library just a few years ago.

02:56:25.680 --> 02:56:26.520
Right.

02:56:26.520 --> 02:56:32.680
The public works water shop was acquired and it's under a remodel.

02:56:32.680 --> 02:56:36.240
And we've vacated a condemned building that will one day come down, right?

02:56:36.240 --> 02:56:36.760
Yep.

02:56:36.760 --> 02:56:40.120
So we're beginning to make these strides and beginning to move forward.

02:56:40.120 --> 02:56:50.540
I believe it's important for us to have facilities that I would describe as dignified.

02:56:50.540 --> 02:56:53.900
That does not mean a brand new city hall in my opinion.

02:56:53.900 --> 02:57:00.460
But it means facilities that allow us to provide quality services to our citizens.

02:57:00.460 --> 02:57:10.240
And at some point in time, we do need to look at possibly bringing back the city hall employees

02:57:10.240 --> 02:57:14.060
and the employees that were moved over to the hands and building

02:57:14.060 --> 02:57:16.680
and put us all back under one roof.

02:57:16.680 --> 02:57:20.080
I believe we lose considerable efficiencies

02:57:20.080 --> 02:57:23.080
and we lose certainly a lot of synergy.

02:57:23.080 --> 02:57:25.560
We have to have, and we have to have

02:57:25.560 --> 02:57:27.760
very intentional effort, right,

02:57:27.760 --> 02:57:29.760
to go over and have a conversation.

02:57:29.760 --> 02:57:32.560
And those synergies really

02:57:32.560 --> 02:57:35.400
have to be almost manufactured as something that occurs

02:57:35.400 --> 02:57:36.360
naturally.

02:57:36.360 --> 02:57:40.100
I will also tell you that if you asked for my list of priorities

02:57:40.100 --> 02:57:43.400
where a city hall would fall, it's probably at the bottom.

02:57:43.400 --> 02:57:46.180
I believe that we need to look at our police facilities,

02:57:46.180 --> 02:57:47.780
we need to look at our fire stations,

02:57:47.780 --> 02:57:52.320
we need to continue to look at our public works facilities.

02:57:52.320 --> 02:57:55.360
Our building works well, and if we're the last one

02:57:55.360 --> 02:57:57.200
to get a building, I'm okay with that.

02:57:57.200 --> 02:57:59.480
But I think it's really making sure

02:57:59.480 --> 02:58:01.600
that all of our folks have the equipment.

02:58:01.600 --> 02:58:05.960
And this is a wonderful, wonderful conversation in dialogue.

02:58:05.960 --> 02:58:10.080
And I'm really not only excited about it,

02:58:10.080 --> 02:58:16.080
Because this is something that I think that this is the purpose of that conversation, right?

02:58:16.080 --> 02:58:22.280
I'm also looking at the amount of money that we may have available and the types of the

02:58:22.280 --> 02:58:25.560
conversations and rules will do our best.

02:58:25.560 --> 02:58:30.480
And that's why in June we'll come back and say, this is what we believe we can fit within

02:58:30.480 --> 02:58:32.800
the revenue projections.

02:58:32.800 --> 02:58:35.800
This is what we've left off the table and why.

02:58:35.800 --> 02:58:40.800
then on June 10th, it's the citizens' conversation.

02:58:40.960 --> 02:58:42.920
They will come in and also share their thoughts,

02:58:42.920 --> 02:58:46.040
which I think is a nice addition to the process.

02:58:46.040 --> 02:58:48.120
And then the second week in July,

02:58:48.120 --> 02:58:51.160
we will hit the ground running again by presenting

02:58:51.160 --> 02:58:55.000
what is included in the draft budget.

02:58:55.000 --> 02:58:56.320
Rebecca Milsuk.

02:58:56.320 --> 02:58:58.040
Thank you, Mayor.

02:58:58.040 --> 02:59:00.880
I'd just like to comment on a couple of the issues

02:59:00.880 --> 02:59:01.960
that have come up.

02:59:03.000 --> 02:59:05.280
According to staffing, I appreciate that,

02:59:05.280 --> 02:59:11.280
We are a government organization or a lean organization, and so it would encourage us to continue that tradition.

02:59:11.280 --> 02:59:19.280
However, adding positions where they're absolutely needed, I could support definitely a grant writer.

02:59:19.280 --> 02:59:26.280
I'm not sure if I could support organizational position as far as bringing partners together.

02:59:26.280 --> 02:59:29.280
I mean, because we, in a sense, all have that responsibility.

02:59:29.280 --> 02:59:35.940
U.S. City Manager, Josh Palmer as public information officer, I think, and us certainly as council.

02:59:35.940 --> 02:59:42.160
That's our job is to bring partners together and we can certainly do that on our levels.

02:59:42.160 --> 02:59:47.680
And then as far as facilities go, if we really in the next 30 years, if you and your staff

02:59:47.680 --> 02:59:56.920
are seeing that we are going to need to come into one single place, I would just encourage

02:59:56.920 --> 03:00:04.580
you to consider a building that is already existing and not try to construct a brand new building

03:00:04.580 --> 03:00:05.580
somewhere else.

03:00:05.580 --> 03:00:12.700
I mean I believe in the importance of the city staying downtown, being downtown and to

03:00:12.700 --> 03:00:19.780
not, I certainly wouldn't support constructing a $30 million city hall or city complex but

03:00:19.780 --> 03:00:25.420
the reality is if we are going to build it in the future, we don't know what that price

03:00:25.420 --> 03:00:31.420
type will be but will certainly be significant. So I would encourage us to, I know there was

03:00:31.420 --> 03:00:36.740
a committee that looked at the clinic and that sort of a thing and I don't have an opinion

03:00:36.740 --> 03:00:44.340
one way or another but I do know that that's a significantly sized building that is available

03:00:44.340 --> 03:00:49.700
that you could invest in and not just that building but there are other buildings downtown

03:00:49.700 --> 03:00:56.700
But I'm just saying I would not encourage us to try to rebuild a brand new city hall.

03:00:56.700 --> 03:01:01.700
I would encourage you if you feel like you're going to need it in the next 20 to 30 years,

03:01:01.700 --> 03:01:06.340
work with something that is already existing in the city.

03:01:06.340 --> 03:01:13.340
So for those listening and for those watching the conversation kind of veered to a city hall conversation,

03:01:13.340 --> 03:01:16.340
I think that's appropriate for facilities, right?

03:01:16.340 --> 03:01:26.340
I think it's important to note that the budget that I'm putting together does not contemplate a new city hall in this fiscal year, more than likely the next.

03:01:26.340 --> 03:01:36.340
If I have to go for a stretch, probably more than likely the next, only because when I line up the priorities that we have as an organization, like I said earlier,

03:01:36.340 --> 03:01:44.540
We're really trying to recover and really trying to move forward with some of the funding

03:01:44.540 --> 03:01:51.220
challenges and issues that face us, water, streets, wastewater, you know, those are really

03:01:51.220 --> 03:01:53.540
the lifebloods of our community.

03:01:53.540 --> 03:02:00.580
And I personally believe that I can offer high quality effective service in that building.

03:02:00.580 --> 03:02:04.180
And I believe our team does and I think that we demonstrate that on a daily basis.

03:02:04.180 --> 03:02:06.380
the thing that we lack is that synergy,

03:02:06.380 --> 03:02:08.340
but I think that there's also ways to overcome

03:02:08.340 --> 03:02:11.840
that don't cost or don't requires to move

03:02:11.840 --> 03:02:15.330
into a new building tomorrow to be effective.

03:02:15.330 --> 03:02:17.650
Oh, I am not advocating, I repeat,

03:02:17.650 --> 03:02:20.410
I am not advocating a new city hall,

03:02:20.410 --> 03:02:22.890
but I want us to be open enough to understand

03:02:22.890 --> 03:02:25.090
that our police department, our fire departments,

03:02:25.090 --> 03:02:27.850
they're growing and they need more space

03:02:27.850 --> 03:02:30.810
and it kind of makes sense to me

03:02:30.810 --> 03:02:32.970
that they've already invaded your space anyway,

03:02:32.970 --> 03:02:34.130
those police officers.

03:02:34.130 --> 03:02:35.970
You got them downstairs in the basement.

03:02:35.970 --> 03:02:38.010
It's not going to be long until they creep up to the top.

03:02:38.010 --> 03:02:39.210
They can come next door.

03:02:39.210 --> 03:02:42.970
They can come right into the wonderful feeling of security.

03:02:42.970 --> 03:02:44.450
Having them in the building.

03:02:44.450 --> 03:02:45.730
I encourage that.

03:02:45.730 --> 03:02:50.410
But my thought is, I think you would be open to, if it made sense.

03:02:50.410 --> 03:02:58.010
I'm not saying build a new city hall, but if we find something that works that we could bring a lot of folks together, have this energy,

03:02:58.010 --> 03:03:03.170
have this space available for these other departments to grow into, or really,

03:03:03.170 --> 03:03:08.330
Some of them would just take over tomorrow because they have those needs that we would be open to that.

03:03:08.330 --> 03:03:14.290
So I don't want to take that off the table and I'm supportive of that depending, obviously, on a lot of variables.

03:03:14.290 --> 03:03:14.930
Absolutely.

03:03:14.930 --> 03:03:15.930
Thank you.

03:03:15.930 --> 03:03:18.290
Thank you, John.

03:03:18.290 --> 03:03:23.210
The only comment I would have in all of them, I was going to make the exact same comment that you made, Travis,

03:03:23.210 --> 03:03:27.450
that we've just talked about $3 million of extra things here and

03:03:27.450 --> 03:03:30.610
you're going to have anywhere near that kind of money to work with.

03:03:30.610 --> 03:03:32.770
and so we understand the juggling match

03:03:32.770 --> 03:03:35.970
of you and your department heads are gonna be doing

03:03:35.970 --> 03:03:39.410
in the next six weeks or so to try to come up

03:03:39.410 --> 03:03:42.770
with something that meets our needs

03:03:42.770 --> 03:03:45.410
and I could have some of the same exact priorities

03:03:45.410 --> 03:03:46.730
as everyone else here.

03:03:46.730 --> 03:03:48.650
And the only thing I would finish with

03:03:48.650 --> 03:03:52.010
is that everything we've talked about is quality of life,

03:03:52.010 --> 03:03:53.850
whether it's just a different way of looking

03:03:53.850 --> 03:03:57.210
at it, the police force feeling safe is quality of life.

03:03:57.210 --> 03:03:59.730
And the fire department knowing that they're gonna be

03:03:59.730 --> 03:04:04.690
to your home with everything his quality of life and I don't envy you and your department

03:04:04.690 --> 03:04:09.890
heads there here next six weeks of wrangling so to speak to say what bring what you're

03:04:09.890 --> 03:04:15.810
going to bring back to this so thank you though Travis for your your input tonight that we

03:04:15.810 --> 03:04:21.010
have anybody else from the public that would like to comment on something tonight time for

03:04:21.010 --> 03:04:27.810
public input here see no one dashing forward to see majoring in the additional mr. Mayor

03:04:27.810 --> 03:04:36.270
members of the council I do just a quick reminder on May 8th and May 16th from 4 to 7 o'clock

03:04:36.270 --> 03:04:43.370
in this room we will be having a series we won't but our citizens committee will be having

03:04:43.370 --> 03:04:50.050
a series of open houses to describe why they made the recommendation to move forward with

03:04:50.050 --> 03:04:55.350
the wastewater treatment plant bond and why they believe now is the optimum time for that

03:04:55.350 --> 03:05:02.430
consideration. So again May 8 May 16 from 4 o'clock to 7 o'clock it's going to be a

03:05:02.430 --> 03:05:07.630
very informal process so if people can't show up at 4 that's fine. We wanted to

03:05:07.630 --> 03:05:11.630
make sure that we were trying to have a long enough time so that as people were

03:05:11.630 --> 03:05:17.710
going home depending upon what time they got off they could swing in here and meet

03:05:17.710 --> 03:05:20.870
members of the committee and engage in conversations with members of the

03:05:20.870 --> 03:05:23.380
committee and the staff.

03:05:23.380 --> 03:05:25.380
Do they have?

03:05:25.380 --> 03:05:30.730
Anyone on a council or something they would like to add tonight.

03:05:30.730 --> 03:05:32.730
Rebecca, we'll switch it.

03:05:32.730 --> 03:05:33.730
Thank you, Mayor.

03:05:33.730 --> 03:05:36.730
Just want to remind the public that tomorrow is council office hours.

03:05:36.730 --> 03:05:42.730
We'll be located right here in this side room of council chambers from 5.30 to 7.

03:05:42.730 --> 03:05:46.730
And there will be myself and councilman Jimman available.

03:05:46.730 --> 03:05:51.730
If you have an issue that you would like help with, you just want to talk to someone.

03:05:51.730 --> 03:05:57.050
or if you want to provide input, this is your time and it's just open, you can drop by any

03:05:57.050 --> 03:06:00.730
time and we'll be ready to speak with you.

03:06:00.730 --> 03:06:03.550
Thank you, Rebecca, Sean Burger.

03:06:03.550 --> 03:06:10.290
I wanted to thank the Council for their support of the Hanging Basket Partnership last week.

03:06:10.290 --> 03:06:16.530
So we shot an email out on Wednesday to the Chamber of Membership, letting everyone know

03:06:16.530 --> 03:06:22.810
that project was coming back, and as of this afternoon, about 4 o'clock, 38 of those baskets

03:06:22.810 --> 03:06:27.610
have been spoken for for a sponsorship, so that was a pretty good return for three days

03:06:27.610 --> 03:06:28.610
of an email.

03:06:28.610 --> 03:06:33.450
And a good number of those actually weren't people who had sponsored in the past, so starting

03:06:33.450 --> 03:06:35.450
those follow-up calls today.

03:06:35.450 --> 03:06:41.050
So I'm relatively confident we'll get to our 50 that we hoped for and hoping to go even

03:06:41.050 --> 03:06:42.050
beyond that.

03:06:42.050 --> 03:06:50.090
Those are available for sponsorship $125 a year and the plan is to get those installed the week of the

03:06:50.510 --> 03:06:56.710
27th after Memorial Day, but before Western days altogether. How many are available Sean? So there are

03:06:58.190 --> 03:07:00.190
There are in theories 72

03:07:02.510 --> 03:07:06.050
Spots to put baskets we're having a little bit of tweaking

03:07:06.050 --> 03:07:13.050
We have a couple of items that we

03:07:13.050 --> 03:07:14.050
have.

03:07:14.050 --> 03:07:17.050
Based on the discussion we have with the downtown folks.

03:07:17.050 --> 03:07:20.050
We may be utilizing a couple of those polls there on

03:07:20.050 --> 03:07:23.050
show shown around Maine for those signs which wouldn't

03:07:23.050 --> 03:07:25.050
accommodate baskets.

03:07:25.050 --> 03:07:29.050
We have some replacement type bracket issues.

03:07:29.050 --> 03:07:32.460
But somewhere in that ballpark.

03:07:32.460 --> 03:07:39.240
a couple of items I'd like to commend our fire department for their efforts in helping

03:07:39.240 --> 03:07:45.340
out the city of Jerome and their time of need last week. I went over there to check in

03:07:45.340 --> 03:07:50.180
with their officers and it was obvious. I'm not sure whether we have better equipment

03:07:50.180 --> 03:07:54.100
or better maintained or better operators. I'm sure what was going on with our fire truck

03:07:54.100 --> 03:07:59.660
was putting a lot more water on the fire than Jerome's was. And I'm not sure what the problem

03:07:59.660 --> 03:08:03.980
was but it was just even the layman's eyes it was very obvious when you have this stream

03:08:03.980 --> 03:08:07.900
about that big around coming down hard on the fire and there's this kind of shooting out like

03:08:07.900 --> 03:08:13.580
you saw on TV. It appeared that they may have been in trouble if we had helped them out and

03:08:13.580 --> 03:08:19.460
I'm glad that we could be able to do that and then as I mentioned to some of the others when

03:08:19.460 --> 03:08:24.980
our second truck got there they were of course fresh and ready to go and so one of the buildings

03:08:24.980 --> 03:08:30.500
It was ready at that moment to be entered and the drone fire chief immediately chose our professional

03:08:30.500 --> 03:08:35.540
well-traded firefighters to be the ones to enter that building and take care of things and they were

03:08:35.540 --> 03:08:40.420
they were quite proficient. It caused me a little concern to see them going in but everything turned

03:08:40.420 --> 03:08:46.740
out fine and as far as nobody was injured and those things like but that they were certainly

03:08:46.740 --> 03:08:51.860
you could tell very easily who the professional firefighters were and it was obvious that

03:08:51.860 --> 03:08:54.700
that they had the training necessary,

03:08:54.700 --> 03:08:56.860
and I thank the chief for getting that training

03:08:56.860 --> 03:08:59.380
to be there so that they're very well prepared.

03:08:59.380 --> 03:09:01.340
And also, I'm the owner of representing

03:09:01.340 --> 03:09:04.310
the city Saturday night.

03:09:04.310 --> 03:09:08.030
In the Stuckel Center at Boise State University,

03:09:08.030 --> 03:09:11.910
if you haven't been in that facility, it's pretty amazing.

03:09:11.910 --> 03:09:13.070
As most of you know, I'm a bandal,

03:09:13.070 --> 03:09:16.030
but that was a pretty nice facility in Boise State.

03:09:16.030 --> 03:09:18.390
It's up actually on top of the west side

03:09:18.390 --> 03:09:20.470
of the stadium there that has,

03:09:20.470 --> 03:09:22.870
I just assumed it was seating up there, but down one end

03:09:22.870 --> 03:09:26.670
they have a very large, almost like a convention area

03:09:26.670 --> 03:09:30.770
that has floor ceiling glass that goes around three sides

03:09:30.770 --> 03:09:36.150
of the building that you can see under the lube of views

03:09:36.150 --> 03:09:39.710
of downtown Boise and the campus and the end zone

03:09:39.710 --> 03:09:40.710
of the stadium anyway.

03:09:40.710 --> 03:09:44.910
But I was representing us at the family medical residency

03:09:44.910 --> 03:09:48.610
of Idaho fundraiser that is put on each year.

03:09:48.610 --> 03:09:52.770
we most of us may not realize that since we don't have a medical school we have to do

03:09:52.770 --> 03:09:58.610
some things to get doctors to find out as a place to come and they come here for their

03:09:58.610 --> 03:10:02.850
family residency a three-year program we have at any one time we have six different doctors

03:10:04.050 --> 03:10:08.690
during this three-year program and I was sitting with one of those Dr. McCluskey was

03:10:08.690 --> 03:10:15.330
also there representing the faculty from this area for this and one of the gentlemen who

03:10:15.330 --> 03:10:19.890
never been to this area before in his life, has chosen to try to establish the practice

03:10:19.890 --> 03:10:21.890
and fuel when he's done.

03:10:21.890 --> 03:10:27.370
And so that's just how that program works to be in this area and the others who are looking

03:10:27.370 --> 03:10:28.370
at Twin Falls.

03:10:28.370 --> 03:10:34.490
So that was an organization I didn't even know existed that raises funds to pay for these

03:10:34.490 --> 03:10:38.530
doctors' residency and their training right here until they stay in Idaho.

03:10:38.530 --> 03:10:43.690
And they get about 60% of them to stay, which I guess is well above the average that they were

03:10:43.690 --> 03:10:44.690
hoping for.

03:10:44.690 --> 03:10:47.170
All right, moving on to the second part of our agenda,

03:10:47.170 --> 03:10:51.640
which is our public hearings.

03:10:51.640 --> 03:10:53.440
We are in the public hearing process.

03:10:53.440 --> 03:10:57.520
We ask if you do want to speak that you sign up in the back.

03:10:57.520 --> 03:10:59.680
Vice Mayor Hall will have the timing

03:10:59.680 --> 03:11:04.360
when we get to that public portion of the agenda.

03:11:04.360 --> 03:11:08.920
First, we will use that we have the applicant present to us,

03:11:08.920 --> 03:11:13.120
and then we move on and have staff give us their thoughts

03:11:13.120 --> 03:11:15.040
and some history.

03:11:15.040 --> 03:11:17.720
And then we have a portion of time for questions,

03:11:17.720 --> 03:11:21.180
and then we'll open it for the public to testify,

03:11:21.180 --> 03:11:23.600
and then we'll close, and the council members

03:11:23.600 --> 03:11:24.640
will deliberate.

03:11:24.640 --> 03:11:28.320
Since these two items are virtually the same thing

03:11:28.320 --> 03:11:30.600
on different spots of the process,

03:11:30.600 --> 03:11:32.400
I believe you have asked,

03:11:32.400 --> 03:11:34.960
Tim have you asked to just present once for both of them,

03:11:34.960 --> 03:11:36.120
or is that not the case?

03:11:36.120 --> 03:11:37.040
We would appreciate it.

03:11:37.040 --> 03:11:42.120
Okay, and I believe not expecting a lot of public comment,

03:11:42.120 --> 03:11:44.840
we will combine the public hearing portion of as well,

03:11:44.840 --> 03:11:49.720
Although we will have to vote on them separately as we get to that point.

03:11:49.720 --> 03:11:55.800
So Tim Vosser from EHM representing Gary Nelson, you have the floor.

03:11:55.800 --> 03:11:58.680
Good evening, Mr. Mayor and member of the council.

03:11:58.680 --> 03:11:59.880
Thank you.

03:11:59.880 --> 03:12:10.000
This is two subdivisions and a request to vacate the easement in Canyon Trail's subdivision number five,

03:12:10.000 --> 03:12:15.000
as well as tracked E in Canyon Trail Subdivision Number 9.

03:12:17.960 --> 03:12:22.260
Park View Drive is located right here.

03:12:22.260 --> 03:12:25.860
The developer has a potential client

03:12:25.860 --> 03:12:28.980
that he's working with that needs more than,

03:12:28.980 --> 03:12:33.020
believe it or not, the acreage that is encompassed

03:12:33.020 --> 03:12:33.860
in that lot.

03:12:33.860 --> 03:12:38.460
He needs about six acres, which means this lot line

03:12:38.460 --> 03:12:44.820
encroached about a hundred feet as to the area that he needs to do his development.

03:12:44.820 --> 03:12:50.740
So having said that, there's a platadiesement along the shared lot line in Canyon Trails number

03:12:50.740 --> 03:12:55.820
five that needs to go through the vacation process in order to make that happen.

03:12:55.820 --> 03:13:02.540
It will be rededicated at the future lot line and submitted as a separate legal to the City

03:13:02.540 --> 03:13:07.540
engineering department as of right now and I'll ask for

03:13:07.540 --> 03:13:14.240
Mitch's help on this. The development plans for the vacation of track D have

03:13:14.240 --> 03:13:18.440
not been reviewed by engineering yet but it's entirely possible that we won't

03:13:18.440 --> 03:13:25.440
need to vacate that if engineering agrees with my routing of utilities and

03:13:25.440 --> 03:13:31.940
the sidewalk there. So I would like to ask that that be vacated contingent on the

03:13:31.940 --> 03:13:39.660
need and if there is such a need then the ordinance could be recorded and we would re-dedicate

03:13:39.660 --> 03:13:43.820
by separate legal and other tract over here on this portion where it would be needed if

03:13:43.820 --> 03:13:46.460
so deemed.

03:13:46.460 --> 03:13:53.460
As I said this is King Trails 9 where the tract has been platted, it's in escrow and

03:13:53.460 --> 03:13:56.000
the development has taken place there.

03:13:56.000 --> 03:14:00.760
and Trails 5 is platted, ready to develop potential user,

03:14:00.760 --> 03:14:07.900
is compliant with the zone, which is C1.

03:14:07.900 --> 03:14:11.820
And it will also help if all of this comes to fruition

03:14:11.820 --> 03:14:15.460
to widen that road adjacent to the Parcelon Park view

03:14:15.460 --> 03:14:18.460
and create better access there.

03:14:18.460 --> 03:14:21.020
I'll stand for questions and I ask for your approval.

03:14:21.020 --> 03:14:24.300
That was going to be my question, because I remember

03:14:24.300 --> 03:14:26.860
when I was last election and I was knocking

03:14:26.860 --> 03:14:30.700
outdoors the longer they were questioning when Parkview was going to be

03:14:30.700 --> 03:14:34.440
whit whitened through more of that section and so if that's going to be

03:14:34.440 --> 03:14:40.460
soon I'll be happy I'm sure it's all money yeah having having a sale agreement

03:14:40.460 --> 03:14:44.380
and having that sale come to fruition would certainly help it's

03:14:44.380 --> 03:14:49.900
be the alright Chris talking to could you tell us the property ownership on

03:14:49.900 --> 03:14:55.290
on the area to the right of the proposed realignment.

03:14:56.170 --> 03:14:58.650
Mr. Nelson owns all the persons.

03:14:58.650 --> 03:14:59.490
All right.

03:14:59.490 --> 03:15:01.330
As well as to the south.

03:15:01.330 --> 03:15:02.410
Exactly, yeah.

03:15:02.410 --> 03:15:03.250
Okay.

03:15:03.250 --> 03:15:04.090
Thank you.

03:15:04.090 --> 03:15:04.930
Thank you.

03:15:04.930 --> 03:15:07.610
I just have a question about the alignment.

03:15:07.610 --> 03:15:12.610
It appears that track D, where it will be moved to,

03:15:12.890 --> 03:15:16.970
and then the second item don't quite line up.

03:15:16.970 --> 03:15:17.810
Why is that?

03:15:17.810 --> 03:15:24.810
The second item is, we're trying to replace the area in kind,

03:15:24.810 --> 03:15:32.180
and so I've had to make a little bit, if required,

03:15:32.180 --> 03:15:37.180
a little bit of a jog here to allow utilities to go through

03:15:37.180 --> 03:15:39.180
with proper separation.

03:15:39.180 --> 03:15:42.180
The tract itself is for utilities in a walk path,

03:15:42.180 --> 03:15:46.180
so a little bit of meander isn't going to help hurt in a walk path,

03:15:46.180 --> 03:15:53.460
but it was certainly needed for straight-lining utilities through.

03:15:53.460 --> 03:15:59.460
Okay. And then the second item, which is the vehicular access easement,

03:15:59.460 --> 03:16:04.460
is about 30 feet wide, correct? Correct. So that's not wide enough

03:16:04.460 --> 03:16:09.460
to ever become a street or an actual access. So what is this access for?

03:16:09.460 --> 03:16:14.460
Both utilities and a private drive to be shared between the two parcels.

03:16:14.460 --> 03:16:21.280
And that's why we're relocating it so that we can keep those utilities and that shared access in place and the majority of the

03:16:21.280 --> 03:16:28.360
Shared access is going to be to provide for fire truck access and turn around and looped roads if needed

03:16:28.840 --> 03:16:33.900
Okay, and will that walking is the walking trail only through

03:16:35.100 --> 03:16:41.340
The smaller section or will the walking trail continue on that down the road that is the vehicular?

03:16:41.340 --> 03:16:46.260
access road and I apologize I should have gone into this as part of the PUD

03:16:46.260 --> 03:16:52.780
agreement recorded quite some time ago there were provisions that were

03:16:52.780 --> 03:16:57.180
negotiated between the city and the developer that there's a certain amount of

03:16:57.180 --> 03:17:02.780
walking connectivity between residential and commercial so while it's

03:17:02.780 --> 03:17:08.540
entirely post while it's only required to provide that connectivity it's entirely

03:17:08.540 --> 03:17:15.280
possible, it could continue on in the form of a sidewalk or some other interior design

03:17:15.280 --> 03:17:18.580
common to the filling permit process.

03:17:18.580 --> 03:17:19.580
Great.

03:17:19.580 --> 03:17:25.380
Yeah, I'm sure you might have seen our strategic plan, which includes a lot of objectives for

03:17:25.380 --> 03:17:31.860
connecting trails and just having trails that don't just suddenly end, and so it would be

03:17:31.860 --> 03:17:42.020
be great if when and however you do plan your subdivision or your lot that it would actually

03:17:42.020 --> 03:17:47.540
kind of end up somewhere either end to a street or end to some sort of path. I think that would

03:17:47.540 --> 03:17:56.740
be helpful just in the design of the area that it would be great. What's great about the

03:17:56.740 --> 03:18:00.340
is that it had that requirement, that there be that access,

03:18:00.340 --> 03:18:05.020
but I certainly would encourage you to have it lead somewhere

03:18:05.020 --> 03:18:08.900
that people could use and especially take into consideration

03:18:08.900 --> 03:18:13.300
ADA accessible so that maybe people who are in wheelchairs

03:18:13.300 --> 03:18:15.640
can still continue on.

03:18:15.640 --> 03:18:16.480
Sure.

03:18:16.480 --> 03:18:18.740
Thank you.

03:18:18.740 --> 03:18:23.420
So you know the questions will give me a chance to talk to us,

03:18:23.420 --> 03:18:25.940
and then we'll at that point we'll open the public hearing

03:18:25.940 --> 03:18:28.380
and then listen for questions during it,

03:18:28.380 --> 03:18:30.740
in case you'll have a lot of, obviously,

03:18:30.740 --> 03:18:33.820
as usual, have time at the end as well, okay.

03:18:33.820 --> 03:18:36.580
Ms. Humble?

03:18:36.580 --> 03:18:39.540
Okay, so, I didn't want to go through

03:18:39.540 --> 03:18:41.660
and read, state, everything that just got said.

03:18:41.660 --> 03:18:43.420
So he did a pretty good job of explaining

03:18:43.420 --> 03:18:44.940
what was going on here.

03:18:44.940 --> 03:18:46.780
I think I'll focus then just mainly

03:18:46.780 --> 03:18:47.860
on process kind of stuff.

03:18:47.860 --> 03:18:50.580
So this is a vacation process.

03:18:50.580 --> 03:18:53.300
We're vacating in one subdivision number nine

03:18:53.300 --> 03:18:54.140
on the north half.

03:18:54.140 --> 03:18:59.070
Let me actually put another exit out there.

03:18:59.070 --> 03:18:59.910
that zoomed in.

03:18:59.910 --> 03:19:02.270
This is the same picture just zoomed in a little bit closer.

03:19:02.270 --> 03:19:05.390
So there's an open space tract right up in here

03:19:05.390 --> 03:19:07.590
that's in the residential part of the subdivision.

03:19:07.590 --> 03:19:11.070
We're vacating that and then rededicating it over here.

03:19:11.070 --> 03:19:14.230
And then the second item is this easement.

03:19:14.230 --> 03:19:16.270
Again, you explain removing it over here.

03:19:16.270 --> 03:19:18.350
So these are the current alignments.

03:19:18.350 --> 03:19:20.050
These are the future alignments.

03:19:21.310 --> 03:19:22.150
There's a process,

03:19:22.150 --> 03:19:23.030
you have to go through public hearing

03:19:23.030 --> 03:19:26.070
at the Planning and Zoning Commission that happened.

03:19:26.070 --> 03:19:26.910
April 9th.

03:19:29.070 --> 03:19:45.070
In both cases, the commission unanimously recommended approval with the three conditions that are listed in the staff report, subject to site plan amendments is required by building engineering, fire and zoning officials to ensure compliance with the applicable city code requirements and standards to subject to new

03:19:45.070 --> 03:19:48.950
being recorded as presented to be utilized as outlined in the

03:19:48.950 --> 03:19:53.290
Canyon Properties PUD, that's the PUD that requires the walking

03:19:53.290 --> 03:19:56.390
connection from the residential part to the commercial part.

03:19:56.390 --> 03:20:00.230
And then number three, subject to a newsman being recorded as

03:20:00.230 --> 03:20:04.150
presented to be utilized as the outlined in the Canyon Properties

03:20:04.150 --> 03:20:10.770
PUD 229. Tim requested another condition be added basically

03:20:10.770 --> 03:20:13.530
saying let's just make the whole thing subject to engineering's

03:20:13.530 --> 03:20:18.970
review of the development plan and that's fine. We can do that too. Following a vacation after

03:20:18.970 --> 03:20:24.050
today's public hearing you'll make a decision if that decision is in the affirmative then

03:20:24.050 --> 03:20:29.010
we'll come back later with an ordinance that makes it all happen and we can just not do

03:20:29.010 --> 03:20:38.410
that part if engineering approves the development plan for the tract in phase nine, right? So

03:20:38.410 --> 03:20:41.490
The easement will still move, but the track may not move.

03:20:41.490 --> 03:20:43.930
So we could do that one on the,

03:20:43.930 --> 03:20:47.330
that would be the first item of the two.

03:20:47.330 --> 03:20:48.730
So public hearing, I remember one,

03:20:48.730 --> 03:20:51.250
if we wanted to add that condition.

03:20:51.250 --> 03:20:54.390
With that staff concurs with the recommendation

03:20:54.390 --> 03:20:56.910
from the Planning and Zoning Commission,

03:20:56.910 --> 03:20:57.910
we'll try to answer your questions.

03:20:57.910 --> 03:21:03.160
If you have any, we do need to open the public hearing.

03:21:03.160 --> 03:21:05.560
Thank you, Mitch.

03:21:05.560 --> 03:21:08.400
Seeing no additional questions at the moment,

03:21:08.400 --> 03:21:11.360
I am going to open the public comment portion

03:21:11.360 --> 03:21:16.400
of the hearing, is anyone in the audience that would like to speak to this issue?

03:21:16.400 --> 03:21:24.060
Well, let's just go back to check, see if we have any names, list no names, all right?

03:21:24.060 --> 03:21:27.140
So I'll see you know on stepping forward to speak on this issue.

03:21:27.140 --> 03:21:30.140
I will close the public comment portion of the hearing.

03:21:30.140 --> 03:21:32.260
Turn it back to the developer.

03:21:32.260 --> 03:21:34.420
We do have one question at the same time.

03:21:34.420 --> 03:21:36.180
Tim, if you stand up, Chris.

03:21:36.180 --> 03:21:37.660
No, I was ready to make a motion.

03:21:37.660 --> 03:21:39.660
All right, well we still have here.

03:21:39.660 --> 03:21:40.620
I'm fine, thank you.

03:21:40.620 --> 03:21:41.260
You're good to go.

03:21:41.260 --> 03:21:45.060
Well, we need to vote on these two separately,

03:21:45.060 --> 03:21:46.940
and the first one needs the one that talks about

03:21:46.940 --> 03:21:50.120
if deemed necessary by the engineering review.

03:21:51.340 --> 03:21:52.300
Okay, Chris, Ryan.

03:21:52.300 --> 03:21:54.640
Okay, so is this an ordinance or a?

03:21:55.660 --> 03:21:58.140
That's just, that's very ordinance is back later.

03:21:58.140 --> 03:22:02.140
Okay, well, I would move the approval of vacation attract

03:22:02.140 --> 03:22:06.460
of Kenyan trail subdivision number nine

03:22:06.460 --> 03:22:10.740
of the described part, I guess that would be

03:22:10.740 --> 03:22:23.140
the eastern parcel of E and the rededication of the described location of track E to the

03:22:23.140 --> 03:22:31.850
west. Again of Kingen's trail subdivision number nine, Kingen properties PUD 229, and that

03:22:31.850 --> 03:22:35.070
be on third and final by title only or just no.

03:22:35.070 --> 03:22:41.330
Okay, that's right the the asked and mitz talked about and also the three conditions as

03:22:42.230 --> 03:22:43.590
outlined by

03:22:43.590 --> 03:22:49.230
Engineering Department and they would all they've also asked if this is deemed necessary by the engineering review

03:22:49.950 --> 03:22:51.950
Did all that

03:22:52.830 --> 03:22:55.470
Second I can don't know if that made any sense

03:22:56.550 --> 03:22:58.550
Did that speak to the?

03:22:59.190 --> 03:23:03.850
Request okay, so the move of Chris talking and then seconded by Sean

03:23:05.070 --> 03:23:12.510
I didn't actually close everything completely, but we do have the other one we might have questions on so we will go ahead and vote on this particular motion.

03:23:12.510 --> 03:23:14.710
I have no lights on the other roll call vote.

03:23:14.710 --> 03:23:16.110
Greg Lansing.

03:23:16.110 --> 03:23:17.110
Yes.

03:23:17.110 --> 03:23:17.610
Jim Munn.

03:23:17.610 --> 03:23:18.110
Yes.

03:23:18.110 --> 03:23:19.110
Rebecca Milsoiga.

03:23:19.110 --> 03:23:20.110
Yes.

03:23:20.110 --> 03:23:21.110
Chris Tonkin.

03:23:21.110 --> 03:23:22.110
Yes.

03:23:22.110 --> 03:23:23.110
John Berriger.

03:23:23.110 --> 03:23:24.110
Yes.

03:23:24.110 --> 03:23:25.110
Don Hall.

03:23:25.110 --> 03:23:26.110
Yes.

03:23:26.110 --> 03:23:27.110
Susan Hawkins.

03:23:27.110 --> 03:23:28.110
Yes.

03:23:28.110 --> 03:23:29.110
Motion passes seven to zero.

03:23:29.110 --> 03:23:30.110
The next item would be.

03:23:30.110 --> 03:23:48.160
We'll make a motion that we approve the request for vacation of a platted utility and vehicular

03:23:48.160 --> 03:23:56.340
accessesment 30 feet 5, 478 feet located between lot 1 and lot 14, block 14 within canyon

03:23:56.340 --> 03:23:58.900
and trails subdivision number five,

03:23:58.900 --> 03:24:03.660
care of Canyon properties, PUD, number 229,

03:24:03.660 --> 03:24:05.180
with staff recommendations.

03:24:07.680 --> 03:24:11.240
By Rebecca Wessocka, second, seconded by Don Hall.

03:24:11.240 --> 03:24:16.010
That we vacate the second portion of this hearing.

03:24:16.010 --> 03:24:19.370
That puts us the planted utility back where it's been,

03:24:19.370 --> 03:24:20.770
as Rebecca described.

03:24:20.770 --> 03:24:23.450
I think it's supposed to also be a rededication.

03:24:23.450 --> 03:24:24.490
It's an rededication.

03:24:24.490 --> 03:24:26.010
It's in the staff recommendations.

03:24:26.010 --> 03:24:29.810
Okay, all right, that's completely the staff recommendations.

03:24:29.810 --> 03:24:31.170
Rebecca, did you want to comment?

03:24:31.170 --> 03:24:32.850
Which, yeah, I'd actually like to comment on that.

03:24:32.850 --> 03:24:35.370
I appreciate the staff recommendations,

03:24:35.370 --> 03:24:38.730
including that the new track be recorded as presented.

03:24:38.730 --> 03:24:42.650
I think that's a lot easier for me to be in favor

03:24:42.650 --> 03:24:45.010
of a vacation when you have presented,

03:24:45.010 --> 03:24:48.090
and no for sure what will take place.

03:24:48.090 --> 03:24:50.250
So I just wanted to commend staff on,

03:24:50.250 --> 03:24:53.970
on including those conditions.

03:24:53.970 --> 03:24:57.420
So you know, dish and lice, they have a Rocco vote.

03:24:57.420 --> 03:24:58.180
Jim Mann.

03:24:58.180 --> 03:24:58.680
Yes.

03:24:58.680 --> 03:24:59.700
Rebecca Mills-Wiecka.

03:24:59.700 --> 03:25:00.440
Yes.

03:25:00.440 --> 03:25:01.200
Miss Tocquenten.

03:25:01.200 --> 03:25:01.700
Yes.

03:25:01.700 --> 03:25:02.600
Sean Berriger.

03:25:02.600 --> 03:25:03.100
Yes.

03:25:03.100 --> 03:25:03.940
Don Hall.

03:25:03.940 --> 03:25:04.500
Yes.

03:25:04.500 --> 03:25:05.460
Suzanne Hawkins.

03:25:05.460 --> 03:25:05.960
Yes.

03:25:05.940 --> 03:25:06.700
Great glancing.

03:25:06.700 --> 03:25:08.300
Yes.

03:25:08.300 --> 03:25:10.300
All right, both of them have been approved.

03:25:10.300 --> 03:25:13.300
We'll be looking for those work notes to come back to us.

03:25:13.300 --> 03:25:16.060
Moving on to our third public hearing of the night.

03:25:16.060 --> 03:25:19.700
Is to consider a question to amend the building permit fees.

03:25:19.700 --> 03:25:23.070
Mitch Humboldt?

03:25:23.070 --> 03:25:26.230
OK, so let me just start by saying,

03:25:26.230 --> 03:25:30.230
This was a really long staff report for me to write.

03:25:30.230 --> 03:25:36.630
I tried to be extremely thorough because I knew what was coming up on tonight's agenda

03:25:36.630 --> 03:25:40.950
and I was wanting to make sure you had all the information but not having me have to tell

03:25:40.950 --> 03:25:42.030
you all the information.

03:25:42.030 --> 03:25:47.790
So my intent and the presentation is not to go over a lot of the stuff but rather just

03:25:47.790 --> 03:25:49.750
talk about the fees and the proposal.

03:25:49.750 --> 03:25:54.590
So if you have questions about that, fire away at me as I'm going through, stop me.

03:25:54.590 --> 03:25:58.550
and I'll try to look up every now and then.

03:25:58.550 --> 03:26:00.830
Anyway, so like I said, I knew what was coming up on this agenda

03:26:00.830 --> 03:26:01.750
and it was gonna be a long one,

03:26:01.750 --> 03:26:04.550
so I wanted to give you all kinds of information.

03:26:04.550 --> 03:26:10.160
So anyway, we've been working for a good amount of time

03:26:10.200 --> 03:26:12.240
to come up with a fee proposal.

03:26:12.240 --> 03:26:14.760
I've got lots of information here that I've got

03:26:14.760 --> 03:26:16.120
for background to answer questions.

03:26:16.120 --> 03:26:19.440
If you need any, I want to also thank a lot

03:26:20.880 --> 03:26:25.200
the work that the building department staff put into this.

03:26:25.200 --> 03:26:28.480
And then we also had a good deal of help from builders,

03:26:28.480 --> 03:26:31.920
and our advisory board was very involved in this process,

03:26:31.920 --> 03:26:33.600
and there's a lot of good work that came out of this.

03:26:33.600 --> 03:26:36.520
So, and set all that.

03:26:36.520 --> 03:26:41.520
We tried with this amendment to accomplish

03:26:41.520 --> 03:26:43.040
a couple of different things.

03:26:43.040 --> 03:26:45.400
The first part of that is that we wanted our fees

03:26:45.400 --> 03:26:48.520
to become more simple, more simple to understand,

03:26:48.520 --> 03:26:51.640
more simple to calculate, more simple to just deal with

03:26:51.640 --> 03:26:53.560
for a lot of reasons.

03:26:53.560 --> 03:26:56.880
One is that we need to be able to understand it and be able

03:26:56.880 --> 03:26:59.800
to present it to people who ask us questions.

03:26:59.800 --> 03:27:02.320
So sometimes they're a bit complicated.

03:27:02.320 --> 03:27:06.600
It makes it easier for my staff to actually help customers

03:27:06.600 --> 03:27:08.880
when it's a more simple fee.

03:27:08.880 --> 03:27:10.800
Also more simple for the customers.

03:27:10.800 --> 03:27:13.560
So when they're bidding jobs, they know what the fee costs

03:27:13.560 --> 03:27:16.440
are going to be so they can accurately reflect that

03:27:16.440 --> 03:27:17.520
in their bids.

03:27:17.520 --> 03:27:20.200
But also more simple for programming.

03:27:20.200 --> 03:27:23.120
So we have a tracking software that's just outdated

03:27:23.120 --> 03:27:25.220
And it needs updated very badly.

03:27:25.220 --> 03:27:26.660
We've ordered some new software.

03:27:26.660 --> 03:27:30.100
We're getting it implemented and programming the new software,

03:27:30.100 --> 03:27:32.100
particularly where the fees are involved,

03:27:32.100 --> 03:27:34.820
is one of those big variables in cost

03:27:34.820 --> 03:27:36.700
with our new software providers.

03:27:36.700 --> 03:27:40.340
So under the current system, a lot of programming effort

03:27:40.340 --> 03:27:43.060
needed to implement our current fee structure.

03:27:43.060 --> 03:27:44.700
With this much more simplified version,

03:27:44.700 --> 03:27:45.540
it cuts that way down.

03:27:45.540 --> 03:27:48.460
We're able to go a lot further with our money

03:27:48.460 --> 03:27:49.540
that we were paying these guys.

03:27:49.540 --> 03:27:54.240
So simplification was a key goal for us.

03:27:54.240 --> 03:28:00.480
Second goal was we want an accurate building valuation.

03:28:00.480 --> 03:28:06.560
So we have in our code, we basically

03:28:06.560 --> 03:28:08.520
use there's a company called the ICC,

03:28:08.520 --> 03:28:10.120
it's the International Code Council.

03:28:10.120 --> 03:28:13.600
They're the group that writes the building code

03:28:13.600 --> 03:28:15.640
that the state has adopted that we enforce.

03:28:15.640 --> 03:28:23.240
They also with that provide basically six months updates to an average construction cost.

03:28:23.240 --> 03:28:25.240
It's their building valuation table.

03:28:25.240 --> 03:28:28.840
They produce it in February and August every year.

03:28:28.840 --> 03:28:36.200
We have adopted the 2005 February table, which is somewhat dated.

03:28:36.200 --> 03:28:41.080
And it's construction values and some national average from February 2005.

03:28:41.080 --> 03:28:43.320
And we apply that to our building permits.

03:28:43.320 --> 03:28:47.760
And then the fee structure is calculated from the valuation.

03:28:47.760 --> 03:28:52.960
We know that we are not right when we calculate our values.

03:28:52.960 --> 03:28:56.440
Why that's important is we use those values frequently.

03:28:56.440 --> 03:29:03.400
We showed you earlier tonight and last week our projected building valuation, those numbers

03:29:03.400 --> 03:29:07.920
are coming from our permit data and we know they're wrong.

03:29:07.920 --> 03:29:12.900
And so we do a lot of planning efforts based on the state and we would like those to be

03:29:12.900 --> 03:29:15.060
update and accurate.

03:29:15.060 --> 03:29:20.540
So goal number two was we want to reflect the accurate evaluation in our building construction

03:29:20.540 --> 03:29:25.620
based on the planning needs that we place on that data.

03:29:25.620 --> 03:29:35.070
So as we started going through this process, a third goal kind of rose and that was basically

03:29:35.070 --> 03:29:36.350
gives back to full staff.

03:29:36.350 --> 03:29:39.550
I mean, so the first two had nothing to do with,

03:29:39.550 --> 03:29:40.830
we just need money, right?

03:29:40.830 --> 03:29:43.350
This one is all about, we just need money.

03:29:43.350 --> 03:29:44.390
So let me explain that a little bit.

03:29:44.390 --> 03:29:47.830
Two years ago, we'll all recall that we ended up laying off

03:29:47.830 --> 03:29:49.590
a couple of people in the building department.

03:29:49.590 --> 03:29:52.550
We did that in response as we looked again at the workload,

03:29:52.550 --> 03:29:54.110
that was kind of coming up and down.

03:29:54.110 --> 03:29:56.790
It dropped way low, ended up laying off

03:29:56.790 --> 03:29:59.030
the building inspector plans examiner.

03:29:59.030 --> 03:30:01.630
Last year, about this time, last year in April,

03:30:01.630 --> 03:30:04.430
we added a position back due to the,

03:30:04.430 --> 03:30:07.670
starting to bottomed out and start to level off and come out.

03:30:07.670 --> 03:30:13.070
We think we're at a point now where we need to have the second one back.

03:30:13.070 --> 03:30:19.570
So what we're looking to do is add a dedicated plans examiner back into the staff.

03:30:19.570 --> 03:30:25.290
The reason we want to go there is that permits are beginning now to take a little bit longer

03:30:25.290 --> 03:30:27.490
to get out than they really should.

03:30:27.490 --> 03:30:30.890
For years we've had to target, this is an example, right?

03:30:30.890 --> 03:30:35.130
For years, we've had a target of maybe five days, four or five days of turnaround on the

03:30:35.130 --> 03:30:38.610
new single family permits.

03:30:38.610 --> 03:30:41.930
Right now we're sitting around two weeks.

03:30:41.930 --> 03:30:51.440
April, no, March numbers, we've talked, we've showed 19 new single family permits had been

03:30:51.440 --> 03:30:52.840
issued in March.

03:30:52.840 --> 03:31:00.040
The first week of April, we had 14 in the queue waiting to be issued.

03:31:00.040 --> 03:31:07.160
Most of all 10 or 12 of those could have been issued probably in March if we'd have the staff to get through on the time

03:31:07.160 --> 03:31:09.160
That we'd normally like to get through those

03:31:09.160 --> 03:31:13.660
It's starting to affect how we're getting through permits people are starting to notice it

03:31:14.080 --> 03:31:19.520
The newspaper did an article about it. It was picked up by a couple other news outfits through four weeks ago

03:31:19.520 --> 03:31:21.520
Hey, maybe a month ago now

03:31:21.960 --> 03:31:28.340
And so yeah, we want to we want to be back to our level of service that we've that we'd like to reach

03:31:28.340 --> 03:31:33.780
you know, a quick home turnaround and a little bit faster on a commercial turnaround.

03:31:33.780 --> 03:31:38.420
Also, in the last several months, primarily due to Chobani, I think, but also for some other

03:31:38.420 --> 03:31:44.460
reasons, we were farming out plan review for a lot of our commercial stuff to other people

03:31:44.460 --> 03:31:47.140
to do for us and we've stopped doing that now.

03:31:47.140 --> 03:31:51.900
We've brought it all back in-house and again, I think we're slowing down, we need to get that

03:31:51.900 --> 03:31:52.900
body back in.

03:31:52.900 --> 03:31:57.340
The problem with what happened when we laid the people off, the funding also went away.

03:31:57.340 --> 03:32:00.180
was kind of the intent was to save the money.

03:32:00.180 --> 03:32:01.020
So the funding went away.

03:32:01.020 --> 03:32:02.640
We need to create a new funding source,

03:32:02.640 --> 03:32:05.740
a dedicated funding source for plan review.

03:32:05.740 --> 03:32:07.780
And so there's a third goal that we tried to meet

03:32:07.780 --> 03:32:12.780
with this program was bring us back to full staff.

03:32:13.420 --> 03:32:14.700
So with those three goals in mind,

03:32:14.700 --> 03:32:15.700
we started this process.

03:32:15.700 --> 03:32:18.180
We involved our building advisory board.

03:32:18.180 --> 03:32:20.060
There's nine guys on that board.

03:32:20.060 --> 03:32:22.940
And eight of those guys are employed

03:32:22.940 --> 03:32:25.860
in the building trades of some sort or another.

03:32:25.860 --> 03:32:28.330
One is in that large appointment.

03:32:28.330 --> 03:32:31.410
And so those guys know it, they work with it every day.

03:32:31.410 --> 03:32:33.250
They're very knowledgeable, they're very helpful.

03:32:33.250 --> 03:32:36.590
We also involved and invited lots of other folks

03:32:36.590 --> 03:32:39.050
from the building community to come help us out,

03:32:39.050 --> 03:32:43.150
the Home Builders Association, other residential contractors,

03:32:44.330 --> 03:32:47.370
commercial or mechanical plumbing electric contractors.

03:32:47.370 --> 03:32:48.970
We got all these guys in the room

03:32:48.970 --> 03:32:51.550
and we put together this proposal

03:32:51.550 --> 03:32:53.010
to try and meet those three goals.

03:32:53.010 --> 03:32:59.010
So, I wanted to kind of show you what we're proposing, and then I'm going to go through

03:32:59.010 --> 03:33:04.010
a series of, you know, if you want me to, I'll go through a series of examples that I include

03:33:04.010 --> 03:33:07.010
in staff for as well, what they actually mean for projects.

03:33:07.010 --> 03:33:13.010
Because it's really difficult to say this change will mean that this much percent increase or

03:33:13.010 --> 03:33:17.010
decrease or whatever, because it's so dependent on the exact project.

03:33:17.010 --> 03:33:22.010
So, rather than do that, I just said, okay, here's some permits that we issued, and this is what they would look

03:33:22.010 --> 03:33:26.470
like today under this proposal.

03:33:26.470 --> 03:33:31.180
So let's see here.

03:33:31.180 --> 03:33:33.540
I'm going to put this up here so everybody can kind of see it

03:33:33.540 --> 03:33:35.860
and I'll kind of walk through it a little bit here.

03:33:35.860 --> 03:33:38.660
But proposed fees, the first change

03:33:38.660 --> 03:33:40.260
we want to make is the first bullet point,

03:33:40.260 --> 03:33:43.790
is a declared project valuation.

03:33:43.790 --> 03:33:51.080
The thought behind this is that, zoom that in a little bit.

03:33:51.080 --> 03:33:52.520
We want accurate values.

03:33:52.520 --> 03:33:54.160
We've stated that as a goal going into it.

03:33:54.160 --> 03:33:56.480
Who knows the value of a project better than the person

03:33:56.480 --> 03:34:00.320
build in that project. I don't know that there's a better person out there to

03:34:00.320 --> 03:34:03.960
understand the value than those guys. They go through their bid process, they

03:34:03.960 --> 03:34:06.920
understand exactly what their bottom line is and what they need to make the

03:34:06.920 --> 03:34:11.480
profit and all those kinds of things are included in this declared value. I can

03:34:11.480 --> 03:34:16.970
tell you that when we assume a national average and we apply a local modifier to

03:34:16.970 --> 03:34:21.210
it, we'll be wrong most every time. We might get lucky now and then get

03:34:21.210 --> 03:34:25.610
something right on evaluation. We ask these guys to declare it, we'll be right

03:34:25.610 --> 03:34:31.930
most every time. It might be some folks that try to fudge a little bit and or that

03:34:31.930 --> 03:34:35.930
might not know exactly but close will still be better off than if we were

03:34:35.930 --> 03:34:42.090
guessing ourselves. We also have been doing this already in our in our mechanical

03:34:42.090 --> 03:34:46.370
electrical plumbing for commercial straight for commercial permits and

03:34:46.370 --> 03:34:51.930
they're declaring those values now hasn't been a problem for us so we think

03:34:51.930 --> 03:34:56.430
people will know these numbers, we think they'll provide them. And so project

03:34:56.430 --> 03:35:00.210
valuation, declared project valuation is the first change. We want to get away from

03:35:00.210 --> 03:35:06.870
this table altogether. There was a very valid concern and this was I think a

03:35:06.870 --> 03:35:13.680
remarkable outcome of the public hearing process that we had at the advisory board

03:35:13.680 --> 03:35:22.690
level. This idea of residential building valuation was discussed at length. In fact

03:35:22.690 --> 03:35:29.690
We probably talked for an hour and a half at that particular meeting on this item, and an hour of that was probably this one issue.

03:35:29.690 --> 03:35:32.690
So this is something that means a lot to these guys.

03:35:32.690 --> 03:35:38.690
Basically, the problem is that there are things in a home that will cause the value to increase,

03:35:38.690 --> 03:35:43.690
that don't necessarily cause the inspectors workload to increase, or the plans of them, or workload to increase.

03:35:43.690 --> 03:35:52.070
For example, a tile floor or wood floor, cost more than a vinyl floor, granite countertops,

03:35:52.070 --> 03:36:01.110
cost more than the laminate countertops, hardwood cupboards, cost more than press board cupboards.

03:36:01.110 --> 03:36:06.610
Those things all add value to the cost, but all of those things we don't inspect.

03:36:06.610 --> 03:36:07.930
We don't care if you have a floor.

03:36:07.930 --> 03:36:10.490
You could have concrete in your house for all we care.

03:36:10.490 --> 03:36:12.490
It's not a code requirement, so we don't inspect it.

03:36:12.490 --> 03:36:14.930
We don't care what your countertops are made out of.

03:36:14.930 --> 03:36:17.490
We don't care that you have countertops, right?

03:36:17.490 --> 03:36:19.930
So there's just some things that we don't bother looking

03:36:19.930 --> 03:36:22.010
at that affect the value of a home.

03:36:22.010 --> 03:36:25.210
And so what the board wanted to do was put some sideboards

03:36:25.210 --> 03:36:26.050
on that.

03:36:26.050 --> 03:36:28.770
Okay, yeah, we get the declared value is important.

03:36:28.770 --> 03:36:31.850
And that value is going up and down also can be,

03:36:31.850 --> 03:36:34.330
it's a 4,000 foot home instead of a 2,000 foot home.

03:36:34.330 --> 03:36:36.850
That does mean more work for us.

03:36:36.850 --> 03:36:38.370
But let's put some sideboards on it.

03:36:38.370 --> 03:36:41.850
Let's say that there's a max and a minimum

03:36:41.850 --> 03:36:43.050
that you need to fall within.

03:36:43.050 --> 03:36:45.170
So we're still going to ask for a declared value,

03:36:45.170 --> 03:36:47.770
but what they suggested was that the declared value

03:36:47.770 --> 03:36:51.690
should be within 20% either side of an average value

03:36:51.690 --> 03:36:53.210
for a single family home.

03:36:53.210 --> 03:36:55.930
And when I say single family, we also mean two families.

03:36:55.930 --> 03:37:01.220
So duplex or a single family both kind of fall into this room.

03:37:01.220 --> 03:37:04.420
We don't have the declared value data right now

03:37:04.420 --> 03:37:08.020
to say what the average single family cost is.

03:37:08.020 --> 03:37:09.740
Because for years we've been using

03:37:09.740 --> 03:37:13.140
in this assumed national average value.

03:37:13.140 --> 03:37:15.300
So what the board said was,

03:37:15.300 --> 03:37:18.020
and with input from a room full of builders,

03:37:18.020 --> 03:37:19.940
was just start at 70 bucks a foot,

03:37:19.940 --> 03:37:22.900
which is actually pretty close a little more

03:37:22.900 --> 03:37:25.220
than a single family home, what we've been valuing,

03:37:25.220 --> 03:37:27.460
and we've been valuing about $67 a foot,

03:37:27.460 --> 03:37:29.100
so it's a slight increase.

03:37:29.100 --> 03:37:34.060
Start at $70 a foot, and then collect data for a while.

03:37:35.980 --> 03:37:38.260
The declared value should be 20% less,

03:37:38.260 --> 03:37:39.780
or 20% more than 70.

03:37:39.780 --> 03:37:42.060
Once we have some data in our system,

03:37:42.060 --> 03:37:44.620
each fiscal year will just update our average.

03:37:44.620 --> 03:37:46.460
And we can do that with the prior years,

03:37:46.460 --> 03:37:48.180
declared values.

03:37:48.180 --> 03:37:50.940
So that's what that second paragraph there talks about

03:37:50.940 --> 03:37:55.380
is it gets at this issue of we don't want too high

03:37:55.380 --> 03:37:58.020
or too low of single family costs.

03:37:58.020 --> 03:38:00.340
So with that one condition, the board

03:38:00.340 --> 03:38:02.860
unanimously recommended this part of the request.

03:38:05.420 --> 03:38:08.000
The second part of that is that our fee structure

03:38:08.000 --> 03:38:15.000
should stay in place. Our fee structure for building permits, this is kind of complicated

03:38:15.000 --> 03:38:24.880
a little bit, but it's basically that. It's a declining fee structure. So as the value of

03:38:24.880 --> 03:38:29.800
your project goes up, your fee will also go up, but it won't go up at the same rate that

03:38:29.800 --> 03:38:37.680
the value is going up. Why that's important to these guys was that the big project is expensive

03:38:37.680 --> 03:38:42.120
Projects won't see these huge enormous building permit fees, right?

03:38:42.120 --> 03:38:44.640
They'll be more than the little guys, but they won't be

03:38:45.520 --> 03:38:49.760
Significantly more and they do require a little bit more work, but they don't require significantly more work

03:38:49.760 --> 03:38:54.240
So we think that the declining fee structure we've been using is is a fair structure

03:38:54.240 --> 03:38:59.320
It's what most cities in Idaho use is a fee structure very similar to this

03:38:59.720 --> 03:39:01.920
Although I will say that these exact numbers

03:39:01.920 --> 03:39:05.040
I think we might be the only ones using these exact numbers, you know

03:39:05.040 --> 03:39:09.280
For example, the 22 bucks for the $100 to $500 permit, right?

03:39:09.280 --> 03:39:12.400
I think we're probably the only ones that are that low.

03:39:12.400 --> 03:39:15.640
We don't feel the need to increase them because increasing

03:39:15.640 --> 03:39:18.720
the building permit fee wasn't one of our goals.

03:39:18.720 --> 03:39:21.880
We aren't in this to raise the revenue for this part of it.

03:39:21.880 --> 03:39:24.520
We're in this to simplify.

03:39:24.520 --> 03:39:28.040
The valuation is the huge simplification here.

03:39:28.040 --> 03:39:31.160
This doesn't need to change the board.

03:39:31.160 --> 03:39:32.040
Believe that was true.

03:39:32.040 --> 03:39:34.000
We're not recommending the change to the fee structure,

03:39:34.000 --> 03:39:35.800
but only to the valuation.

03:39:35.800 --> 03:39:44.080
The commercial plan review fee at 65%, that's what we charge today, there's no change there.

03:39:44.080 --> 03:39:48.680
This is the second new part, the residential plan review fee of 30%.

03:39:48.680 --> 03:39:54.790
That is a new part of this request, that's the second new thing here.

03:39:54.790 --> 03:39:57.910
This is hard to compare to other communities, so some do it and some don't.

03:39:57.910 --> 03:40:01.590
We haven't for years charged it, there are other communities around us that don't charge

03:40:01.590 --> 03:40:02.590
it.

03:40:02.590 --> 03:40:06.750
There are communities that charge us 65% residential plan review fees similar to the commercial

03:40:06.750 --> 03:40:11.430
There are others that charge 25, 35, they're all over the board here.

03:40:11.430 --> 03:40:14.110
We just stuck at 30 for a couple of reasons.

03:40:14.110 --> 03:40:19.350
One, it seemed right in the middle of the road, but also, it actually, when applied to last

03:40:19.350 --> 03:40:25.390
years of fiscal year 2012, I took the 30% and applied it to last year's actual single

03:40:25.390 --> 03:40:31.790
family permits that came in, and it, my estimate, right, got us almost exactly where we need

03:40:31.790 --> 03:40:33.950
to be to hire the body.

03:40:33.950 --> 03:40:37.310
and I'm using the cost that we hired the last guy had.

03:40:37.310 --> 03:40:39.710
So the full cost of employment, 30%

03:40:39.710 --> 03:40:41.270
gets us right there.

03:40:41.270 --> 03:40:43.430
We don't need more than that.

03:40:43.430 --> 03:40:45.550
And so that's where we landed.

03:40:45.550 --> 03:40:46.470
So that's the second part.

03:40:46.470 --> 03:40:49.390
This particular part of the recommendation

03:40:49.390 --> 03:40:51.390
for the board was also unanimous.

03:40:51.390 --> 03:40:53.310
And it was the first thing they got behind.

03:40:53.310 --> 03:40:54.750
They said, yeah, we need it.

03:40:54.750 --> 03:40:57.310
Let's go with it.

03:40:57.310 --> 03:40:59.350
OK, so that's building permit fees.

03:40:59.350 --> 03:41:01.630
I'm about to jump into mechanical electrical planning

03:41:01.630 --> 03:41:04.270
unless there's questions, I can go back over anything.

03:41:04.270 --> 03:41:05.630
That kind of went quick.

03:41:05.630 --> 03:41:06.710
You're back a little slower.

03:41:06.710 --> 03:41:07.630
Thank you, Mary.

03:41:07.630 --> 03:41:10.190
Just for clarification, when you're

03:41:10.190 --> 03:41:13.750
under mechanical electrical and plumbing,

03:41:13.750 --> 03:41:19.110
should 44,000 plus square feet, should that be 4,001?

03:41:19.110 --> 03:41:20.110
One, no.

03:41:20.110 --> 03:41:22.550
Or what is the cost between 4,000 and?

03:41:22.550 --> 03:41:23.910
This should be 4,001.

03:41:23.910 --> 03:41:26.110
That's a typo in the staff report.

03:41:26.110 --> 03:41:26.610
No problem.

03:41:26.470 --> 03:41:28.110
Just for clarification, I wondered what that cost.

03:41:28.110 --> 03:41:29.110
I want to make sure that the resolution doesn't

03:41:29.110 --> 03:41:35.150
the same type of which first got the information for me so you you may have

03:41:35.150 --> 03:41:42.790
that too. It's accurate the resolution right this is just on the staff that should

03:41:42.790 --> 03:41:50.110
be four thousand and one plus okay great and my other question is just under

03:41:50.110 --> 03:41:55.960
non-residential you're we're gonna match the state's commercial fees base rate

03:41:55.960 --> 03:42:00.800
plus a percent of the project value. What's the reason behind the different percentages?

03:42:00.800 --> 03:42:09.040
Up to 10,000 is like a 2 percent and then from 10,000 to 100,000 it goes to 1 percent and

03:42:09.040 --> 03:42:14.520
then over 100,000 it goes to 5 or 0.05 percent.

03:42:14.520 --> 03:42:20.800
So it's basically the same logic behind the declining fee that I talked about on the building

03:42:20.800 --> 03:42:27.080
It's for the big projects to generate a little more value on the permit, but not at a straight

03:42:27.080 --> 03:42:30.400
rate that the value of the project is going up.

03:42:30.400 --> 03:42:36.560
So it's that same kind of fee structure that declines as you get more expensive or more

03:42:36.560 --> 03:42:37.760
value to the project.

03:42:37.760 --> 03:42:42.520
So were those numbers just chosen or is that about what it would cost?

03:42:42.520 --> 03:42:49.280
So our effort on this part of it was basically what should we be doing?

03:42:49.280 --> 03:42:51.520
The thought was, and this is how simple it was,

03:42:51.520 --> 03:42:52.920
we didn't come up with the numbers.

03:42:52.920 --> 03:42:54.960
We just took what the state did and said,

03:42:54.960 --> 03:42:57.960
it makes sense for us to adopt the state's fee structure

03:42:57.960 --> 03:42:59.400
for a couple of reasons.

03:42:59.400 --> 03:43:01.360
But we didn't go back and try to figure out

03:43:01.360 --> 03:43:03.200
why the state adopted their fee structure.

03:43:03.200 --> 03:43:05.440
We just wanted to match their fee structure.

03:43:05.440 --> 03:43:07.440
For that last bullet point there,

03:43:07.440 --> 03:43:09.880
it is exactly the state's fee structure.

03:43:09.880 --> 03:43:10.880
Okay, that's my question.

03:43:10.880 --> 03:43:12.640
I just wondered why the state is very-

03:43:12.640 --> 03:43:13.560
So those numbers they came up with,

03:43:13.560 --> 03:43:17.320
but the logic, again, is that declining valuation

03:43:17.320 --> 03:43:18.480
per fee kind of a thing.

03:43:18.480 --> 03:43:22.480
So, as the bigger projects come in, we need a little bit more money to do the work, but

03:43:22.480 --> 03:43:26.480
we don't need the same rate of increase that the values are increasing.

03:43:26.480 --> 03:43:32.480
Okay. And you say that the 30% will cover the cost of that

03:43:32.480 --> 03:43:37.480
additional staff member. Is that true in the case of, you know,

03:43:37.480 --> 03:43:42.480
you talked about the varying numbers. If we were to go back to a year where there

03:43:42.480 --> 03:43:50.340
or fewer permits say 2011, 2012, would these fees always cover the cost of that position

03:43:50.340 --> 03:43:55.480
or are we going to have a possibility of running into a situation where it wouldn't cover the

03:43:55.480 --> 03:43:56.480
cost?

03:43:56.480 --> 03:44:02.440
So I looked at again, fiscal year 2012 single-family permits.

03:44:02.440 --> 03:44:05.520
Given the same circumstances, it'll cover the cost.

03:44:05.520 --> 03:44:11.960
If the circumstances change, the fee collected will also change.

03:44:11.960 --> 03:44:19.500
So if we have permits that we issued in fiscal year 10, where they were our rock bottom,

03:44:19.500 --> 03:44:20.700
the revenue will reflect that.

03:44:20.700 --> 03:44:21.700
It will also go down.

03:44:21.700 --> 03:44:23.220
We'll collect less revenue.

03:44:23.220 --> 03:44:28.300
If we go back to where we were in 8, where we had, you know, a million, 5 in total department

03:44:28.300 --> 03:44:34.280
revenue, it'll reflect that as well.

03:44:34.280 --> 03:44:38.240
When it comes to the budget, I think it's important to recognize that the building department

03:44:38.240 --> 03:44:47.880
is the only, I believe, tax-supported fund that covers its cost plus.

03:44:47.880 --> 03:44:54.640
And so on this permit review fee and moving forward, it will cover the cost of the body,

03:44:54.640 --> 03:44:58.480
but also all aspects of the building department.

03:44:58.480 --> 03:45:03.720
It is designed to not only cover the building department's cost, but other costs associated

03:45:03.720 --> 03:45:08.600
with the building trade, such as engineering, planning, and zoning.

03:45:08.600 --> 03:45:16.360
So when you look at those costs, it's important to not also to consider one level of service

03:45:16.360 --> 03:45:21.760
that's being provided, but number two that the building department is and always has been

03:45:21.760 --> 03:45:27.560
more of a profit center than any other departments that we have and the revenues that they collect

03:45:27.560 --> 03:45:30.080
support all general fund operations.

03:45:30.080 --> 03:45:36.440
So I don't know if it's necessarily fair to say that if the building department doesn't

03:45:36.440 --> 03:45:41.400
collect all the funds needed for this position, but that's the first place that you look.

03:45:41.400 --> 03:45:45.960
I think that we need to look globally across the organization if we need to pair out bodies

03:45:45.960 --> 03:45:52.960
because we don't know where those holes may lie.

03:45:52.960 --> 03:46:00.720
I will also tell you that this is probably one of the larger mistakes that I have made

03:46:00.720 --> 03:46:09.560
as a manager and that is cutting a department staff so small that it could not remain effective

03:46:09.560 --> 03:46:12.720
or efficient in its job and function.

03:46:12.720 --> 03:46:21.920
And I met with several builders that were very frustrated with that decision because they

03:46:21.920 --> 03:46:28.440
were trying to operate in a very tight market and we compounded the problem because we were

03:46:28.440 --> 03:46:36.040
slowing down, the issuance of permits, we were slowing down, the timeliness of inspections,

03:46:36.040 --> 03:46:41.440
and I had a chance to do it again, I probably would look somewhere else.

03:46:41.440 --> 03:46:42.440
Honestly.

03:46:42.440 --> 03:46:43.440
Thank you.

03:46:43.440 --> 03:46:49.160
So, but my question is, if the circumstances change at what point, my question is just for

03:46:49.160 --> 03:46:52.720
your goal number three, what's to fund this additional staff member.

03:46:52.720 --> 03:46:59.420
So really the question is just at what point, or will there be a point where it doesn't

03:46:59.420 --> 03:47:03.060
cover the funding for the staff member that is merely mentioned?

03:47:03.060 --> 03:47:04.060
There could be.

03:47:04.060 --> 03:47:08.740
And like I said, if permits don't come in the way they came in in 12 and they come in lower,

03:47:08.740 --> 03:47:11.060
we'll have less revenue coming in and it won't.

03:47:11.060 --> 03:47:17.000
I mean, at 30%, it basically exactly covers the full cost of employment of the last guy

03:47:17.000 --> 03:47:20.240
we had in the position.

03:47:20.240 --> 03:47:22.480
And there's not much wiggle room there.

03:47:22.480 --> 03:47:28.200
So if permits come in in in 14 like they did in 11, we're not going to fund the position

03:47:28.200 --> 03:47:31.320
with a 30 percent, we won't do it.

03:47:31.320 --> 03:47:35.200
The difficulty with that, and I'll go back a little bit to what Travis was getting at here

03:47:35.200 --> 03:47:40.640
too, is that we're projecting forward and we're doing that by looking backward, and so

03:47:40.640 --> 03:47:43.900
that sometimes is a struggle.

03:47:43.900 --> 03:47:50.640
Looking forward, when we made the decision to cut these positions, it was July 2nd, I think,

03:47:50.640 --> 03:47:52.040
when we told these guys they're laid off.

03:47:52.040 --> 03:47:56.140
I remember that because the 4th of July was one of the guys last day, right?

03:47:56.140 --> 03:47:59.060
So it was probably July 1st.

03:47:59.060 --> 03:48:03.360
July 13th, a company called Jibani comes and meets with us.

03:48:03.360 --> 03:48:08.540
And it wasn't two months after the plans examiner left,

03:48:08.540 --> 03:48:13.460
then we start having a flood of significant permits coming in to deal with Jibani,

03:48:13.460 --> 03:48:17.260
right after we agreed to do all those for free.

03:48:17.260 --> 03:48:21.820
So who knew that was going to happen when we had no clue?

03:48:21.820 --> 03:48:26.260
right now looking forward, we believe next year is going to be a good year, better than

03:48:26.260 --> 03:48:32.420
this year. We believe that, but my crystal ball sometimes gets fuzzy. My magic ball doesn't

03:48:32.420 --> 03:48:40.100
work always. So we do the best we can, and sometimes we get it right. We try to be conservative.

03:48:40.100 --> 03:48:45.100
So that's kind of where we're at. We may end up losing money again someday. We don't think

03:48:45.100 --> 03:48:55.020
it'll be next year. Any questions on the building? I wasn't going to talk a little bit more about

03:48:55.020 --> 03:49:03.500
mechanical electrical plumbing, but if we want to talk about building. Okay, so the first one up

03:49:03.500 --> 03:49:09.500
there, one fee schedule for all MEP permits, mechanical electrical plumbing, MEP. That, again,

03:49:09.500 --> 03:49:13.900
gets at the simplification goal. We have three different program types, mechanical electrical

03:49:13.900 --> 03:49:17.460
plumbing and each one of those has three different fee types, and each one of those has a different

03:49:17.460 --> 03:49:23.500
calculation currently. We got nine different fee calculations. We're pairing that down to

03:49:23.500 --> 03:49:31.940
three. And so in that move alone, we are significantly simplifying our fee structure. So again, to

03:49:31.940 --> 03:49:37.540
get at that goal, and then how we're doing that is the next few bullet points. Even more

03:49:37.540 --> 03:49:43.140
simplification here too, that first one, a new residential flat fee for the mechanical

03:49:43.140 --> 03:49:46.220
to a plumbing permits.

03:49:46.220 --> 03:49:49.300
This is loosely based on, it's actually not loosely,

03:49:49.300 --> 03:49:52.380
it's pretty much based on our mechanical permits structure

03:49:52.380 --> 03:49:53.100
right here.

03:49:53.100 --> 03:49:55.660
We have five different categories in the current mechanical

03:49:55.660 --> 03:49:57.460
fee based on the size of the home.

03:49:57.460 --> 03:50:02.160
We're pairing that down to three, again, simplification.

03:50:02.160 --> 03:50:03.720
And then we're making it a flat fee,

03:50:03.720 --> 03:50:04.880
so it's easy to calculate.

03:50:04.880 --> 03:50:07.240
Right now, if you come in for a plumbing permit fee

03:50:07.240 --> 03:50:08.400
for a new home, we're going to want

03:50:08.400 --> 03:50:11.920
to know how many drains there are, how many faucets there are,

03:50:11.920 --> 03:50:13.480
how many toilets there are.

03:50:13.480 --> 03:50:15.280
All this kind of stuff we're going to count unit counts.

03:50:15.280 --> 03:50:16.600
We're going to add a little bit.

03:50:16.600 --> 03:50:19.160
Anyway, we're going to end up with this fairly complicated

03:50:19.160 --> 03:50:22.000
fee structure when I could easily just say,

03:50:22.000 --> 03:50:23.480
is it a 2,500-foot home?

03:50:23.480 --> 03:50:24.320
OK.

03:50:24.320 --> 03:50:26.320
Then it's $120.

03:50:26.320 --> 03:50:27.320
And you're out the door.

03:50:27.320 --> 03:50:30.120
So simplification is the goal there.

03:50:30.120 --> 03:50:33.200
Miscellaneous, this is for other types of permits.

03:50:33.200 --> 03:50:37.720
So if you do an addition or remodel in your home

03:50:37.720 --> 03:50:42.040
and you add a dual sink from your single sink that

03:50:42.040 --> 03:50:43.400
was in your master bathroom.

03:50:43.400 --> 03:50:45.120
Yeah, it's just a straight up $50 per month.

03:50:45.120 --> 03:50:46.360
We're not counting fixtures again.

03:50:46.360 --> 03:50:48.640
It's just help the door $50.

03:50:48.640 --> 03:50:51.560
And the same goes for all those types of remodels

03:50:51.560 --> 03:50:52.400
you might have.

03:50:52.400 --> 03:50:54.280
You're adding a bath fan so you don't

03:50:54.280 --> 03:50:55.360
have a mechanical permit.

03:50:55.360 --> 03:50:58.440
You're adding a light switch on that wall where you always

03:50:58.440 --> 03:51:00.720
reach for the light switch and it's not there.

03:51:00.720 --> 03:51:03.000
So you add a light switch there.

03:51:03.000 --> 03:51:05.560
All that stuff is just a flat $50 free.

03:51:05.560 --> 03:51:08.960
There's no more counting circuits and no more counting

03:51:08.960 --> 03:51:11.960
appliances or any of that.

03:51:11.960 --> 03:51:14.900
Again, simplification, the non-residential fee.

03:51:14.900 --> 03:51:17.060
Again, this really is about simplification too.

03:51:17.060 --> 03:51:19.820
We want our guys, and actually this goes back

03:51:19.820 --> 03:51:21.460
to the reason why we adopted it in the first place,

03:51:21.460 --> 03:51:24.340
our fee structure, because it's what the state had in place.

03:51:24.340 --> 03:51:26.100
So now if you pull a permit in Jerome

03:51:26.100 --> 03:51:28.740
or in Twin Falls County, you're gonna have the same fee

03:51:28.740 --> 03:51:32.870
that you, for a non-residential mechanical electrical

03:51:32.870 --> 03:51:34.030
plumbing permit, you have the same fee

03:51:34.030 --> 03:51:36.190
if you pull that permit in the city's Twin Falls.

03:51:36.190 --> 03:51:37.710
Again, it's simplification.

03:51:37.710 --> 03:51:40.590
There's three fee structures there.

03:51:40.590 --> 03:51:46.100
So, that's kind of the gist of it.

03:51:46.100 --> 03:51:49.740
We're not making, oh, let me go down to this small job fee.

03:51:49.740 --> 03:51:52.300
Small job fee, we currently have a small job fee.

03:51:52.300 --> 03:51:55.540
The idea of the small job fee is that we know

03:51:55.540 --> 03:51:57.540
that there was work out there being done

03:51:57.540 --> 03:51:59.620
without coming and getting the permit.

03:51:59.620 --> 03:52:02.060
So we know, and it happens,

03:52:02.060 --> 03:52:05.140
that when somebody went to install a new water heater,

03:52:05.140 --> 03:52:06.380
they just went and did it,

03:52:06.380 --> 03:52:07.700
and they didn't bother coming down

03:52:07.700 --> 03:52:10.180
and paying the $40 fee that it would have cost.

03:52:10.180 --> 03:52:12.860
So, some years ago we adopted this small job fee

03:52:12.860 --> 03:52:14.260
and we saw an immediate increase,

03:52:14.260 --> 03:52:17.820
particularly in plumbing of fees or permits

03:52:17.820 --> 03:52:18.660
that were being issued,

03:52:18.660 --> 03:52:20.740
which was exactly the intent we wanted.

03:52:20.740 --> 03:52:22.420
We wanted people to come in and get these things,

03:52:22.420 --> 03:52:23.460
goes on a water heater,

03:52:23.460 --> 03:52:26.580
those things can be really dangerous if you do it wrong.

03:52:26.580 --> 03:52:28.420
We want our guy to get out there and inspect them.

03:52:28.420 --> 03:52:30.420
It's more about safety than about revenue.

03:52:30.420 --> 03:52:32.900
We want him in the house looking at water heaters.

03:52:32.900 --> 03:52:34.820
So we charge a $10 small job fee.

03:52:35.860 --> 03:52:36.980
We want to keep that the same.

03:52:36.980 --> 03:52:38.020
We want to keep the small job fee.

03:52:38.020 --> 03:52:40.220
There's a good reason for it.

03:52:40.220 --> 03:52:42.140
We just want to make it a little bit more clear about what

03:52:42.140 --> 03:52:43.380
is and isn't a small job.

03:52:43.380 --> 03:52:47.420
Sometimes we had some conflict, right?

03:52:47.420 --> 03:52:48.980
So people say, oh, this is a small job,

03:52:48.980 --> 03:52:50.420
because it's less than $500.

03:52:50.420 --> 03:52:52.260
And we would say, well, but that also

03:52:52.260 --> 03:52:55.340
was called out specifically over here as $40.

03:52:55.340 --> 03:52:57.540
So it's not a small job, it's $40.

03:52:57.540 --> 03:52:59.700
So we say that now, that's what we're proposing here,

03:52:59.700 --> 03:53:02.020
is to just add it, if it's specifically designated

03:53:02.020 --> 03:53:04.820
somewhere else, it's not a small job.

03:53:04.820 --> 03:53:07.140
And then add a sprinkler system back full of prevention.

03:53:07.140 --> 03:53:11.380
that again is about safety and that again is stuff that's getting done right now without

03:53:11.380 --> 03:53:15.260
checking with us because it's a $40 permit right now.

03:53:15.260 --> 03:53:19.660
We don't want our PI water mixing with our potable water so we'll want to get out there

03:53:19.660 --> 03:53:20.860
and look at those.

03:53:20.860 --> 03:53:24.260
So that basically is the fee proposal.

03:53:24.260 --> 03:53:26.420
There's two things that need to happen though.

03:53:26.420 --> 03:53:33.170
Our current city code is what has adopted the building permit fee right now.

03:53:33.170 --> 03:53:37.870
We need to do a code change to strike those references to the building permit fee in the

03:53:37.870 --> 03:53:38.870
city code.

03:53:38.870 --> 03:53:42.870
What we're going to do is propose that those be included in the fee resolution, which is

03:53:42.870 --> 03:53:48.070
the more appropriate place for money types of fee conversations.

03:53:48.070 --> 03:53:51.910
So there's two things that you've got attached to your agenda that you have an ordinance.

03:53:51.910 --> 03:53:57.910
That ordinance simply strikes the references to the building permit fees that are in Title

03:53:57.910 --> 03:54:01.550
4 section 1, I think is what it is.

03:54:01.550 --> 03:54:02.550
So that's the first one.

03:54:02.550 --> 03:54:03.830
That's a separate action.

03:54:03.830 --> 03:54:05.350
We need to put that as an ordinance.

03:54:05.350 --> 03:54:08.590
So if you're ready to proceed with that after the hearing tonight, we can put that on third

03:54:08.590 --> 03:54:11.310
and final and we can adopt it.

03:54:11.310 --> 03:54:15.070
The second attachment is a resolution and it can just be adopted.

03:54:15.070 --> 03:54:19.030
There's no third and final there if, again, if the council is fair, we'll be moving forward

03:54:19.030 --> 03:54:20.550
with this.

03:54:20.550 --> 03:54:23.550
And if you want also, I can go through the samples that we prepared.

03:54:23.550 --> 03:54:26.790
There's nine or ten of them in your packet.

03:54:26.790 --> 03:54:31.030
They are actual permits that we issued sometime in the last year or two, and so they should

03:54:31.030 --> 03:54:37.550
be somewhat familiar. There's four or five homes. This is an actual home permit that we issue.

03:54:37.550 --> 03:54:44.150
We apply what we actually charge as the first one. The second group is what we're proposing

03:54:44.150 --> 03:54:47.550
here tonight and then we compare it to Jerome City and Twin Falls County just for comparison

03:54:47.550 --> 03:54:53.830
sake. But I don't want to go through those unless you all want me to. I can walk you through

03:54:53.830 --> 03:54:54.830
them.

03:54:54.830 --> 03:55:07.390
I hope this experience of re-establishing the permit fees is Senate was a good meaning in

03:55:07.390 --> 03:55:10.110
the minds of private industry and government.

03:55:10.110 --> 03:55:17.790
I'm assuming that we took a lot of input and they saw our perspective but we really

03:55:17.790 --> 03:55:22.790
convinced some people that we were interested in making a more logical, easier to understand

03:55:22.790 --> 03:55:31.430
process was a much negative blowback that were on the wrong track.

03:55:31.430 --> 03:55:35.790
I mean, did you build a consensus in most times and events?

03:55:35.790 --> 03:55:39.150
Right. We really wanted to involve the community in this.

03:55:39.150 --> 03:55:39.710
Yeah.

03:55:39.710 --> 03:55:43.790
So we made painfully efforts to do it,

03:55:43.790 --> 03:55:46.470
to make sure we got everybody involved.

03:55:47.030 --> 03:55:50.070
I would say, generally speaking,

03:55:50.070 --> 03:55:52.310
there were several comments like,

03:55:52.310 --> 03:55:54.610
Why haven't you done this sooner?

03:55:54.610 --> 03:55:56.210
Why aren't we doing this now?

03:55:56.210 --> 03:55:58.490
There was a lot of general support for it.

03:55:58.490 --> 03:56:01.610
Like I said, we went to the committee, the advisory board,

03:56:01.610 --> 03:56:04.350
the building advisory board that you all appointed.

03:56:04.350 --> 03:56:07.610
Their comments were unanimous in every case

03:56:07.610 --> 03:56:11.450
with the one change to the 20% value thing.

03:56:11.450 --> 03:56:12.450
They loved the idea.

03:56:12.450 --> 03:56:15.330
We involved four of those guys in the preparation of it,

03:56:15.330 --> 03:56:18.050
just enough not to be a quorum, right?

03:56:18.050 --> 03:56:20.370
We called specifically other guys

03:56:20.370 --> 03:56:23.070
in to have conversations with it.

03:56:23.070 --> 03:56:26.390
I went out to Builders offices and I sat down with them

03:56:26.390 --> 03:56:27.510
and talked with them and said okay,

03:56:27.510 --> 03:56:28.830
here's what we're trying to do.

03:56:28.830 --> 03:56:32.590
And there were cases where folks came in

03:56:32.590 --> 03:56:37.940
and sat down with me initially, waiting to be opposed to it.

03:56:38.140 --> 03:56:40.220
And then in the end after some questions said okay,

03:56:40.220 --> 03:56:42.220
we're good for this.

03:56:42.220 --> 03:56:45.260
And generally I will say, and I might speak for all those guys,

03:56:45.260 --> 03:56:47.300
but my, from sitting here at the room,

03:56:47.300 --> 03:56:48.580
a lot of people that we had at that.

03:56:48.580 --> 03:56:53.880
I mean, it felt like very good support for it.

03:56:53.880 --> 03:56:54.880
It all sort of reflects.

03:56:54.880 --> 03:56:55.880
There were questions.

03:56:55.880 --> 03:56:56.880
Absolutely were questions.

03:56:56.880 --> 03:57:01.880
And it also reflected more current practices from other jurisdictions.

03:57:01.880 --> 03:57:02.880
Right.

03:57:02.880 --> 03:57:08.680
I think, well, what we found was that we weren't really that far off from other jurisdictions.

03:57:08.680 --> 03:57:09.680
Okay.

03:57:09.680 --> 03:57:14.160
Like for example, we're recommending we keep the same building permit fee structure.

03:57:14.160 --> 03:57:15.360
I wanted to change that.

03:57:15.360 --> 03:57:18.440
I looked at it and I thought, it's complicated.

03:57:18.440 --> 03:57:20.240
I want to make this simpler.

03:57:20.240 --> 03:57:22.520
And we looked around the state and it's what everybody's doing.

03:57:22.520 --> 03:57:25.940
They're using almost the identical fee structure,

03:57:25.940 --> 03:57:28.160
just with some slightly different numbers in there.

03:57:28.160 --> 03:57:31.360
And I wanted to change that and I couldn't get there.

03:57:31.360 --> 03:57:33.600
In fact, when we started me with all the building community,

03:57:33.600 --> 03:57:36.560
we didn't even propose it because it

03:57:36.560 --> 03:57:39.840
was something familiar that everybody else is doing.

03:57:39.840 --> 03:57:40.340
Good job.

03:57:40.340 --> 03:57:41.680
Thanks, Mitch.

03:57:41.680 --> 03:57:42.560
Donald.

03:57:42.560 --> 03:57:43.960
I just have one comment, Mitch.

03:57:43.960 --> 03:57:48.960
I really appreciate that we kept that small work permit at $10.

03:57:48.960 --> 03:57:50.760
I think that's just going to help with compliance.

03:57:50.760 --> 03:57:55.760
I mean, if you raise that up much and somebody's just replacing the water heater,

03:57:55.760 --> 03:57:58.840
you're going to have some compliance issues with that, so I appreciate that.

03:58:00.630 --> 03:58:02.330
Jim, thank you, Mayor.

03:58:02.330 --> 03:58:07.970
Great job on this, Mitch, also in your efforts to continue our partnership with the building community.

03:58:07.970 --> 03:58:12.210
In fact, I'm the liaison on the Building Advisory Committee.

03:58:12.210 --> 03:58:17.810
I got the impression they were the vast majority of them were in support of this.

03:58:17.810 --> 03:58:23.170
Did we hear any pushback from any of the guys out there?

03:58:23.170 --> 03:58:28.850
So I don't want to name names, but when I called the Home Builders Association, I asked

03:58:28.850 --> 03:58:32.490
those guys, will you send some folks to this meeting and I want the schedule?

03:58:32.490 --> 03:58:33.490
They said they would.

03:58:33.490 --> 03:58:34.490
Okay.

03:58:34.490 --> 03:58:37.330
So the representative, and it wasn't the guy who was knocked on the phone, representative

03:58:37.330 --> 03:58:40.490
that came, was just ready to fight.

03:58:40.490 --> 03:58:41.490
Go to war with me.

03:58:41.490 --> 03:58:45.490
fight with me every step of the way and he threw out all kinds of questions well what

03:58:45.490 --> 03:58:49.770
about this what about this in the end and he didn't say it to me he said it to

03:58:49.770 --> 03:58:56.170
Dwayne off to the side he goes I can't say anything bad about that was my my take

03:58:56.170 --> 03:59:01.850
from the from the that community so that was again that was the represent from the

03:59:01.850 --> 03:59:03.930
home business association

03:59:03.930 --> 03:59:10.690
Thank you mayor I agree I think this is a good process and I appreciate that we're

03:59:10.690 --> 03:59:16.250
updating our fees and updating the system to be easier for the users, and also to be

03:59:16.250 --> 03:59:25.570
easier to make things digital and more in real time, which will also better serve our citizens.

03:59:25.570 --> 03:59:31.210
I think that's a great idea, and so I appreciate you being forward thinking and realizing,

03:59:31.210 --> 03:59:36.810
hey, let's use some technology in this building permit system.

03:59:36.810 --> 03:59:42.090
I do have a question in the resolution on other building permit fees.

03:59:42.090 --> 03:59:46.050
Number three is a moving permit of $42.

03:59:46.050 --> 03:59:49.010
What would a moving permit apply to?

03:59:49.010 --> 03:59:53.650
So occasionally, it doesn't happen very much at all, but occasionally you will actually

03:59:53.650 --> 03:59:57.730
pick a building up and move it and plop it down somewhere else.

03:59:57.730 --> 03:59:58.730
That's all we're talking about.

03:59:58.730 --> 04:00:01.210
This isn't for you to move from your house to another house.

04:00:01.210 --> 04:00:05.130
Yeah, I was thinking, wow, we don't really try to regulate that, do we?

04:00:05.130 --> 04:00:10.130
I want to answer a question you didn't ask, but you kind of made me think about it.

04:00:10.130 --> 04:00:11.130
There are a lot of fees.

04:00:11.130 --> 04:00:16.330
This resolution took five, I think, different fee resolutions and combined them all into

04:00:16.330 --> 04:00:17.330
one.

04:00:17.330 --> 04:00:20.850
So a lot of these aren't changing, but they're moving into one resolution.

04:00:20.850 --> 04:00:21.850
That's one.

04:00:21.850 --> 04:00:22.850
Right.

04:00:22.850 --> 04:00:23.850
It stays the same.

04:00:23.850 --> 04:00:24.850
We aren't proposing any change to it.

04:00:24.850 --> 04:00:28.010
But it was in one that we're getting rid of and I wanted to make sure it's still in place.

04:00:28.010 --> 04:00:29.010
Okay.

04:00:29.010 --> 04:00:30.650
If I didn't talk about it, it's not changing.

04:00:30.650 --> 04:00:31.850
No, that's great.

04:00:31.850 --> 04:00:35.410
I just read moving permit and wondered what that actually meant.

04:00:35.410 --> 04:00:38.280
So thank you for clarifying.

04:00:38.280 --> 04:00:39.280
Thank you, Mitch.

04:00:39.280 --> 04:00:41.480
We'll go ahead and we have fun.

04:00:41.480 --> 04:00:45.720
I was going to say, although I can't tell you exactly, again,

04:00:45.720 --> 04:00:50.160
without the specific permit data, we do believe, in fact,

04:00:50.160 --> 04:00:52.480
we know that on a new home permit, for example,

04:00:52.480 --> 04:00:55.840
this 30% fee, we're going to have an increase of more than 5%

04:00:55.840 --> 04:00:56.480
to some people.

04:00:56.480 --> 04:00:58.440
We do need for that reason to have a public hearing.

04:00:58.440 --> 04:01:01.480
So we're just going to lump it all in on the public hearing,

04:01:01.480 --> 04:01:05.800
even though I know all of it isn't going to be a 5% increase, we notified it that way.

04:01:05.800 --> 04:01:12.440
Okay. I will see no other questions. I'm going to open the public comment portion of the hearing.

04:01:12.440 --> 04:01:19.440
Does anyone in the audience would like to speak concerning the proposed amendment to the building permit fees?

04:01:19.440 --> 04:01:27.450
Seeing none, I'm going to close the public comment portion, which you have the other final comments for us.

04:01:27.450 --> 04:01:35.010
Do we have an ordinance number 3049 as the ordinance number on that will be needed

04:01:35.010 --> 04:01:42.490
to be placed on third and final and then the resolution number 1905 1905

04:01:42.490 --> 04:01:46.100
All right, Jim Munlow.

04:01:46.100 --> 04:01:47.900
Did I hit it first?

04:01:47.900 --> 04:01:56.760
No, I would move to place ordinance number 3049 on third and final reading by title only.

04:01:56.760 --> 04:01:57.760
Second.

04:01:57.760 --> 04:01:59.320
Do we want to suspend the rules of the title?

04:01:59.320 --> 04:02:01.120
I'd like to suspend the rules also mayor.

04:02:01.120 --> 04:02:02.840
Thank you for the clarification.

04:02:02.840 --> 04:02:04.960
Then moved by Jim Mann and seconded by Don Hall

04:02:04.960 --> 04:02:08.600
to move ordinance 3049 to third and final.

04:02:08.600 --> 04:02:10.320
To suspend the rules and place ordinance

04:02:10.320 --> 04:02:13.200
3049 on the third and final by title.

04:02:13.200 --> 04:02:15.040
The a la roll call one.

04:02:15.040 --> 04:02:16.320
Rebecca Milsica.

04:02:16.320 --> 04:02:18.960
Yes, because talking to Sean Beroger.

04:02:18.960 --> 04:02:19.800
Yes.

04:02:19.800 --> 04:02:20.640
Don Hall.

04:02:20.640 --> 04:02:21.480
Yes.

04:02:21.480 --> 04:02:22.320
Susan Hawkins.

04:02:22.320 --> 04:02:23.160
Yes.

04:02:23.160 --> 04:02:24.000
Greg Lanci.

04:02:24.000 --> 04:02:24.840
Yes.

04:02:24.840 --> 04:02:25.680
Jim Mann.

04:02:25.680 --> 04:02:26.680
Yes.

04:02:26.680 --> 04:02:28.480
Leila would you read the title?

04:02:28.480 --> 04:02:38.920
In ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho, amending Twin Falls City Code Subsection 411 by deleting outdated building code references.

04:02:38.920 --> 04:02:43.290
Okay, I would entertain a motion for 30-49 V.S.

04:02:43.290 --> 04:02:46.270
Move approval, ordinance 30-49.

04:02:46.270 --> 04:02:47.270
Second.

04:02:47.270 --> 04:02:48.270
Seconded by Chris.

04:02:48.270 --> 04:02:49.270
Seconded by Chris.

04:02:49.270 --> 04:02:50.270
Seconded by Chris.

04:02:50.270 --> 04:02:55.270
Seconded by Chris talking to the approved ordinance 30-49, seeing the lights.

04:02:55.270 --> 04:02:56.270
Leila Rojelvo.

04:02:56.270 --> 04:02:57.270
Chris Talkington.

04:02:57.270 --> 04:02:58.270
Yes.

04:02:58.270 --> 04:02:59.110
Sean Berger.

04:02:59.110 --> 04:03:01.810
Don Hall yes, yes

04:03:01.810 --> 04:03:04.550
Greg Lanching yes Jim on yes

04:03:07.350 --> 04:03:14.150
Pass the seven zero the next item up for businesses resolution 1905 do we have a council issues?

04:03:16.950 --> 04:03:20.510
I should mention this when you ask me about anything else because I do

04:03:21.350 --> 04:03:26.590
I wanted to talk to you guys about implementation a fee resolution typically is is

04:03:26.590 --> 04:03:29.050
is goes into effect upon adoption.

04:03:30.450 --> 04:03:32.650
So if we adopt it tonight, tomorrow way

04:03:32.650 --> 04:03:33.970
we should be charging new fees,

04:03:33.970 --> 04:03:36.970
unless we talk about this and do some kind of delayed

04:03:36.970 --> 04:03:37.810
implementation.

04:03:37.810 --> 04:03:40.890
I think it's appropriate for us to, like,

04:03:40.890 --> 04:03:43.470
send some notice out to folks saying this was adopted

04:03:43.470 --> 04:03:48.470
and in 30 days we're gonna apply these new fees or whatever.

04:03:49.370 --> 04:03:52.370
So I wanted to talk about that with the council.

04:03:52.370 --> 04:03:54.410
Implementation of the fee.

04:03:54.410 --> 04:04:01.650
And then also, as part of that implementation, when we had the hearing at the advisory board

04:04:01.650 --> 04:04:05.610
and with the room full of builders present, we talked about this need for the 30 percent

04:04:05.610 --> 04:04:09.290
plan review fee for a body.

04:04:09.290 --> 04:04:12.730
And I personally made the commitment to those guys that I don't want to charge that fee until

04:04:12.730 --> 04:04:13.730
I have the body.

04:04:13.730 --> 04:04:15.010
And that's the purpose of it.

04:04:15.010 --> 04:04:18.420
So we don't need it ahead of time.

04:04:18.420 --> 04:04:25.380
So implementation of that, if that's a separate kind of a date, then the rest of them.

04:04:25.380 --> 04:04:28.740
Anyway, I did want to have a bit of discussion with the Council about implementation.

04:04:28.740 --> 04:04:33.620
That's a little messy for us to try to legislate though it'd be easier if we just set a date

04:04:33.620 --> 04:04:38.900
in the future, say June 15th or something like that, which would give us a month and a half

04:04:38.900 --> 04:04:43.240
to fill that position, and that's not long enough.

04:04:43.240 --> 04:04:48.160
We more than likely, depending upon the process, would not have the position filled by June

04:04:48.160 --> 04:04:51.500
15th.

04:04:51.500 --> 04:04:58.460
So you may say August 1st, because really, by the time we go find somebody with the skill

04:04:58.460 --> 04:05:03.820
sets in the backgrounds, we would encourage them to provide a notice.

04:05:03.820 --> 04:05:06.500
We'll have to do reference checks and background checks.

04:05:06.500 --> 04:05:13.460
And so, you know, if you set the data to August 1st, we can begin that process of recruitment

04:05:13.460 --> 04:05:14.460
now.

04:05:14.460 --> 04:05:17.220
And then hopefully that will line up.

04:05:17.220 --> 04:05:20.900
If it does not look like that schedule is lined up, we'll come forward and we'll ask

04:05:20.900 --> 04:05:24.420
you to delay the implementation of the ordinance or the resolution excuse me.

04:05:24.420 --> 04:05:26.580
I have a delight, Sean Berner.

04:05:26.580 --> 04:05:33.860
So Mitch is the software set up with this new formula and such and it.

04:05:33.860 --> 04:05:38.140
Right, I haven't got it set up yet, but as soon as I know I can send the new data to

04:05:38.140 --> 04:05:39.980
those guys and they can program it as such.

04:05:39.980 --> 04:05:44.900
I've got probably five months before that's in place and we're using it.

04:05:44.900 --> 04:05:48.620
They know that we're having this discussion, so they haven't got to the part yet where

04:05:48.620 --> 04:05:51.700
their programming fees that'll come later in the process.

04:05:51.700 --> 04:05:56.500
So we can get them time to implement it into our new software,

04:05:56.500 --> 04:05:59.900
our current software, which I'm actually more afraid of this

04:05:59.900 --> 04:06:02.740
than the other thing, is that we'll probably

04:06:02.740 --> 04:06:08.270
have the new fees in place under the current software for us

04:06:08.270 --> 04:06:12.630
sometime, and we can reprogram those as well.

04:06:12.630 --> 04:06:18.450
So I can appreciate the residential plan review, fee,

04:06:18.450 --> 04:06:23.530
delay since it was communicated as tied to a body.

04:06:23.530 --> 04:06:26.330
However, based upon some of the feedback you received,

04:06:26.330 --> 04:06:29.330
which was, I can't believe nobody looked at this before.

04:06:29.330 --> 04:06:30.690
Thank goodness we're doing it.

04:06:30.690 --> 04:06:34.370
I hate to put it off until August or September

04:06:34.370 --> 04:06:36.250
with the whole shooting match.

04:06:36.250 --> 04:06:43.330
So would it be possible to implement this effective June

04:06:43.330 --> 04:06:45.570
first or July first?

04:06:45.570 --> 04:06:55.330
So everything but the plan review fee, and make the plan review fee effective upon firing of the person.

04:06:55.330 --> 04:06:57.370
We're just looking through your direction on that.

04:06:57.370 --> 04:07:00.770
Like I said, if you don't say anything, we'll do it all tomorrow.

04:07:00.770 --> 04:07:06.790
Aren't we creating more confusion again, multiple steps, implementation?

04:07:06.790 --> 04:07:08.230
Well, or just implement it all.

04:07:08.230 --> 04:07:11.110
I mean, it's one thing that you're not going to collect.

04:07:11.110 --> 04:07:12.830
It's one thing out of this whole ordinance.

04:07:12.830 --> 04:07:21.940
You're going to say I approve of this resolution with the exception of the whatever it was in it's lost in

04:07:24.680 --> 04:07:29.240
Special plan review fee until such time as a person is hired in that position

04:07:35.950 --> 04:07:37.950
I'm in favor of

04:07:41.870 --> 04:07:43.870
We're working to hire somebody

04:07:45.350 --> 04:07:47.350
That's not stretching our

04:07:47.350 --> 04:07:50.350
your credibility very much and let's everybody know it's coming and that's

04:07:50.350 --> 04:07:53.790
very much going to give them a firm date that they can start a bit

04:07:53.790 --> 04:08:00.030
practice the people I talk to really like the simplification of the structure for

04:08:00.030 --> 04:08:03.870
them to bid a project a bit of house for somebody because they do exactly what

04:08:03.870 --> 04:08:07.310
their fees are gonna go they just weren't in this guessing mode that they

04:08:07.310 --> 04:08:11.790
typically are and they sometimes guess I and sometimes they guess low they

04:08:11.790 --> 04:08:16.630
they like to some so I would like to just go ahead and set a time at date in the

04:08:16.630 --> 04:08:20.950
future like say July one we know we're working towards they know we're working

04:08:20.950 --> 04:08:24.870
towards an indifference a few days difference one way or the other I don't

04:08:24.870 --> 04:08:29.840
think anybody's gonna feel it or stretch it no Rebecca did you have other

04:08:29.840 --> 04:08:33.800
comments I would agree with those comments but I did have a separate

04:08:33.800 --> 04:08:39.680
comment if I may I know that in the resolution was an opportunity for the

04:08:39.680 --> 04:08:44.720
city staff to verify the declared values and so as far as implementation goes I

04:08:44.720 --> 04:08:47.760
I just would encourage us, since this is our first year,

04:08:47.760 --> 04:08:51.200
to kind of do a random sampling and just kind of stay up

04:08:51.200 --> 04:08:54.240
on auditing, so to speak, those declared values,

04:08:54.240 --> 04:08:57.880
just to make sure they're accurate and current,

04:08:57.880 --> 04:09:00.840
and then looking towards the future,

04:09:00.840 --> 04:09:05.240
if ever we are not covering the costs that we need to cover

04:09:05.240 --> 04:09:06.880
that you would find appropriate,

04:09:06.880 --> 04:09:10.040
that we would look at reviewing the SPE schedule,

04:09:10.040 --> 04:09:12.480
which is from 1994.

04:09:12.480 --> 04:09:15.200
So if we ever do, you know, I understand that,

04:09:15.200 --> 04:09:16.760
and completely agree with the reasoning

04:09:16.760 --> 04:09:18.520
of not changing it right now,

04:09:18.520 --> 04:09:22.240
but if at some point in the future we need to change it,

04:09:22.240 --> 04:09:24.880
then I certainly would encourage that

04:09:24.880 --> 04:09:30.800
since it is almost 20 years old.

04:09:30.800 --> 04:09:35.200
So Council wishes on Resilience 1905,

04:09:35.200 --> 04:09:38.280
and please place an effective date when you,

04:09:38.280 --> 04:09:39.400
like your motion chamber.

04:09:39.400 --> 04:09:41.800
It would move approval of Resolution 1905,

04:09:41.800 --> 04:09:45.260
with an effective date of July 1st, 2013.

04:09:45.260 --> 04:09:46.260
Second.

04:09:46.260 --> 04:09:48.820
It's been moved by Sean Berger and second by Jim Mon

04:09:48.820 --> 04:09:51.860
that we approved resolution 1905 with an effective date

04:09:51.860 --> 04:09:54.300
of July 1st, 2013.

04:09:54.300 --> 04:09:56.340
Seeing no lights, will they add a roll call vote?

04:09:56.340 --> 04:09:57.540
Sean Berger.

04:09:57.540 --> 04:09:58.060
Yes.

04:09:58.060 --> 04:09:58.780
Don Hall.

04:09:58.780 --> 04:09:59.280
Yes.

04:09:59.260 --> 04:10:00.180
Cezanne Hawkins.

04:10:00.180 --> 04:10:00.680
Yes.

04:10:00.660 --> 04:10:01.340
Greg Lansing.

04:10:01.340 --> 04:10:01.840
Yes.

04:10:01.820 --> 04:10:02.420
Jim Mon.

04:10:02.420 --> 04:10:02.980
Yes.

04:10:02.980 --> 04:10:04.060
Rebecca Milsoyka.

04:10:04.060 --> 04:10:04.620
Yes.

04:10:04.620 --> 04:10:05.180
Ms. Chocolate.

04:10:05.180 --> 04:10:06.180
Yes.

04:10:06.180 --> 04:10:08.180
Motion passes 7-0.

04:10:08.180 --> 04:10:11.260
Anyone else have something for the good of the group?

04:10:11.260 --> 04:10:14.900
the other first one to tell you thank you for the battery I can see this well

04:10:14.900 --> 04:10:20.860
I didn't need it this evening number two could you replace my light in up here

04:10:20.860 --> 04:10:28.700
because I'm trying to hypnotize Sean it's not working but if you could replace

04:10:28.700 --> 04:10:34.420
that I'd help you all right see no other business we're adjourned

04:10:34.420 --> 04:10:35.620
Over back, I'm sorry.

04:10:35.620 --> 04:10:36.620
I apologize.

04:10:36.620 --> 04:10:38.220
I thought it was done so clearly.

04:10:38.220 --> 04:10:39.220
I popped back up.

04:10:39.220 --> 04:10:40.220
Folks were going to go back.

04:10:40.220 --> 04:10:41.420
I'm sorry.

04:10:41.420 --> 04:10:42.020
We're adjourned.

04:10:42.020 --> 04:10:42.520
No, really.

04:10:42.520 --> 04:10:44.220
Yes, I got to go.

04:10:44.220 --> 04:10:45.220
No.

04:10:45.220 --> 04:10:47.860
I did forget to mention the beat the heat run.

04:10:47.860 --> 04:10:49.620
And so I'm signed up for it.

04:10:49.620 --> 04:10:52.820
I think we should have certainly our own little council

04:10:52.820 --> 04:10:53.420
contest.

04:10:53.420 --> 04:10:57.220
We should all sign up for the police departments 5k.

04:10:57.220 --> 04:10:59.620
It's just raising money for Special Olympics.

04:10:59.620 --> 04:11:00.620
And so you can walk it.

04:11:00.620 --> 04:11:01.820
You don't have to run it.

04:11:01.820 --> 04:11:03.720
But just wanted to remind the council

04:11:03.720 --> 04:11:07.880
to remind the public and encourage us all to help them raise money for a special

04:11:07.880 --> 04:11:11.440
Olympics. I just wanted to say that I'd love to do that but we have the

04:11:11.440 --> 04:11:17.220
memorial afterwards as well as a historic walking tour just before so I'm not

04:11:17.220 --> 04:11:25.860
gonna be able to participate both physically or yeah.
