Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2026-10-19, recording 1 (started 14:58)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2026-10-19/

[0:01:40] Okay, I'll go ahead and call the special meeting City Council meeting to order for October 19th, 2026. I will
[0:01:49] Confirm that we have three council members in in attendance. These are the three council members that I have asked
[0:01:57] Vice Mayor Craig Hawkins and Councilwoman Ruth Pierce to help facilitate the City Council
[0:02:05] Vacancy application process
[0:02:07] process. We spoke to the other two council members and in that process and felt that it
[0:02:15] was a decline to this initial onset to be a part of that. And so three of us will go through
[0:02:26] this process and make some recommendations and move some applicants forward to the whole
[0:02:34] body future council meetings coming up soon. We'll turn the time over to Travis
[0:02:45] Rothweiler, our city manager for a few minutes, as we outline some of this process
[0:02:51] and have a conversation. Mr. Mayor, members of the council, my role today, as you said,
[0:02:57] was to more or less walk you through the legal requirements of the process and
[0:03:05] kind of share the work the staff did to get to this point today. So in September Councilman Stone
[0:03:18] elected to resign from his seat that he was duly elected to and that created an opening on the city
[0:03:28] Council. Idaho Code has a series of requirements that we are following as a part of this process.
[0:03:41] The first is Idaho Code 5601 and Idaho Code 5601 says that whenever there is a vacancy
[0:03:53] that occurs in the middle of a term. It is the responsibility of the mayor to nominate a candidate
[0:04:03] or candidates to fill the vacancies for consideration by the council and that the council has
[0:04:14] the opportunity to affirm or not his selection. Idaho Code does not give the
[0:04:26] opportunity to select someone alternative than who the mayor has put
[0:04:32] forward. It simply says yes or no on the candidate or candidates that are
[0:04:38] moving forward. The next piece of Idaho Code that we look at is 5702 and it says
[0:04:47] that a person is eligible to hold a City Council office if the person is a
[0:04:51] qualified elector when the declaration of candidacy or intent is submitted and
[0:04:57] remains a qualified elector for the duration of his or her term. So what is a
[0:05:04] qualified elector in the eyes of Idaho Code? First, they have to be a resident and
[0:05:12] and they have to reside as their primary residency inside of the City of Twin Falls's corporate boundary.
[0:05:21] Second, they must be 18 years of age, and third, they must be a citizen.
[0:05:30] Those are the three requirements that are articulated in Idaho Code as to what are the qualifications for someone to serve.
[0:05:40] As part of the process, we published and we held open a period for almost three weeks,
[0:05:50] an application period for individuals to submit their interest to this selection committee,
[0:06:00] and also which will be made available to the other members of the City Council,
[0:06:06] and they are open to public record.
[0:06:10] Unlike other personnel items that are protected under Idaho Code,
[0:06:15] any time that a person is submitting their names for qualification or they put their names on a ballot,
[0:06:21] there is no records exemption that applies.
[0:06:27] So that's why we're going through this process in a very, very public light,
[0:06:31] because the Idaho Open Meeting Law not only insists,
[0:06:36] but requires on a transparent process.
[0:06:39] because the mayor has elected to include council members
[0:06:44] in the initial review of the applications that are followed.
[0:06:48] We are following all of the Idaho Open Meeting Law
[0:06:53] requirements.
[0:06:54] The public has the opportunity to observe this either now
[0:06:57] or later as we are recording and streaming this
[0:07:01] as a part of our process.
[0:07:06] One last thing is that it says that the Idaho,
[0:07:10] The person that is submitting must have resided
[0:07:12] at their place of residency for at least a period of 30 days.
[0:07:17] So when we put this information out through a series
[0:07:20] of press releases and public announcements,
[0:07:23] we placed the application as well as five questions
[0:07:27] that were developed by the mayor
[0:07:29] onto the city council's page,
[0:07:32] and individuals who were interested
[0:07:34] had to fill out the application,
[0:07:36] and they also responded to those five questions.
[0:07:39] They also had to acknowledge that their submittals
[0:07:43] in their entirety would be a matter of the public record.
[0:07:47] And they also acknowledged that they are a duly qualified
[0:07:49] elector.
[0:07:50] We provided that definition on the application
[0:07:53] and each one of those candidates affirmed that process.
[0:07:58] We went through a secondary validation process
[0:08:02] for all of the 15 candidates that elected to submit
[0:08:05] their names and credentials for your evaluation.
[0:08:09] We worked with the county elections office in Idaho.
[0:08:13] The county elections office is the one who oversees
[0:08:16] all elections in the state of Idaho,
[0:08:19] state, national, local, and municipal.
[0:08:25] And so they are the keepers of all of the voting records
[0:08:28] and you will see that all of the candidates
[0:08:32] that are before you do meet the minimum qualifications
[0:08:36] as articulated in Idaho code.
[0:08:42] Your process is really simple.
[0:08:47] On the evening of the second,
[0:08:49] we've reserved the entirety of the City Council meeting
[0:08:52] for individuals to approach the dais
[0:08:54] and to share why they believe
[0:08:57] they should be a member of the City Council.
[0:09:01] And it will also be an opportunity for the Council
[0:09:04] to ask questions.
[0:09:05] The mayor will take that information and it is anticipated that on November 9th, he will name one or two candidates depending upon the outcome of the upcoming state election in which one of the members of our city council is a candidate for.
[0:09:24] If she were to win and she were to choose to vacate her seat,
[0:09:31] that would create two openings on the City Council,
[0:09:35] and so your process at the end of the second would be to determine,
[0:09:41] in some level of order and advise the mayor on individuals who you believe
[0:09:48] should be a part of the City Council.
[0:09:53] You may elect to bring some number up to the 15 candidates that you have here.
[0:09:59] That is entirely your discretion.
[0:10:02] The length of time that you give to them to present is the discretion of the mayor,
[0:10:08] as he is the facilitator and leader of all council meetings.
[0:10:16] Staff is happy to help you navigate the process,
[0:10:21] but I've hopefully set the table for you in terms of legal responsibilities that you have
[0:10:29] and the process that has been outlined not only previously but also in the weeks to come.
[0:10:37] Happy to stand for any questions.
[0:10:38] Thank you, Travis.
[0:10:40] And I think, and you can affirm this, but as you've said, all the applicants that we've
[0:10:46] received are qualified electors from everything that I've read in the application and so I
[0:10:53] just want that to be on the record that we found that all of the applicants that we'll
[0:10:58] be reviewing tonight or at least looked at. Again, I'll reiterate what you said that it
[0:11:05] closed on the 16th of October and so over the weekend I know that I looked over them.
[0:11:13] I'm assuming that the other council members also looked over them and so I think we've
[0:11:18] come here tonight in anticipating of moving new candidates forward for that November 2nd.
[0:11:27] I would like to reiterate that I appreciate we did have a good pool of applicants.
[0:11:34] There's always it's always great to see the interest now that this is my second time of
[0:11:39] trying to fill a vacation on the City Council, it is nice to see people still
[0:11:46] interested in serving on City Council. So Mr. Mayor, yes I can validate again
[0:11:53] all of the members, all 15 candidates that have been submitted for your
[0:11:59] consideration have affirmed first that they meet the definition of qualified
[0:12:05] Elector and that affirmation was validated by the County Elections Office and our
[0:12:12] team worked closely with them and they were timely in their responses. It did
[0:12:17] close on the 16th and we did not receive any applications after the cutoff time.
[0:12:23] So the entirety of individuals who had submitted for consideration are now
[0:12:30] available to you for your deliberation.
[0:12:34] Perfect. Thank you, Travis. Ruth, Craig, do you want to say anything before we kind of
[0:12:40] jump into looking at this and figuring out how we move forward? I do have a couple of
[0:12:46] summary notes, but wanted to give you a chance.
[0:12:49] Yeah, I'll just weigh in here. I really am pleased with this process.
[0:12:54] I'm very excited to see we had 15 individuals who are citizens of Twin Falls that wish to
[0:13:03] potentially join City Council. It was refreshing to see the group of candidates,
[0:13:09] and I'm very excited to go through this process and hopefully in the long run pick the best candidates
[0:13:16] for that position. Thank you, Ruth. I'd just like to reiterate what Ruth said too that it's impressive
[0:13:23] the number of candidates and also their qualifications, so it's not going to be
[0:13:29] a certain easy process. I never never is and so again as we've as I work through
[0:13:34] this is Mr. Mayor before you begin one one other maybe editorial note. You'll
[0:13:40] notice that on the matrix with the names and the verifications that we provided
[0:13:46] you. There is a number that appears on the left-hand side. That number is merely the order in which
[0:13:56] their timestamp was responded to us. It is not a ranking by staff or preferential treatment of
[0:14:04] any one of the candidates. We place them in numerical order as we receive the applications.
[0:14:09] And the individual submitted first, the last individual submitted last, and the 13 other
[0:14:17] applicants in between submitted in their order.
[0:14:22] Perfect.
[0:14:23] Thank you for the clarification, Travis.
[0:14:26] I appreciate that.
[0:14:27] Again, I think just to talk about the process a little bit more, as I've tried to navigate
[0:14:34] through this and again, learn from previous experience.
[0:14:39] It would be really nice to give everybody an opportunity, but some of this has been treated
[0:14:46] very similar to what we would do job applications or other public agencies that I've been affiliated
[0:14:54] with and move a smaller group of applicants forward to allow them maybe a little bit more
[0:15:01] time to help explain and then allow the council for those questions.
[0:15:07] So again, we're going to try to move the best applicants forward as we've reviewed these
[0:15:14] and looked at them and try to put our city in the best position that we can moving forward
[0:15:21] until the next election in about a year.
[0:15:25] Mr. Mayor, I think that's a fair point.
[0:15:28] So again, part of the Idaho Code says that the individuals that are selected to fill the
[0:15:34] vacancy, their terms would conclude at the time of the next general election. In this
[0:15:42] case, one or potentially both of the candidates' terms would naturally come to a conclusion
[0:15:50] for the November 27 election. Individuals who win that election will be seated at the first
[0:15:56] meeting of January of 2020.
[0:15:58] And that just so again, for the record, that was one of the questions that we wanted to make
[0:16:06] sure is that the individuals that we're applying would be still be interested in pursuing the
[0:16:13] council after the current term is over.
[0:16:17] And so I think that is an important note that I follow the candidates as I review them, said
[0:16:24] that they would be willing, and that is important,
[0:16:26] because I have found value in the cohesiveness
[0:16:32] of the council as we've discussed things
[0:16:34] over the course of time.
[0:16:38] Okay, I think we're to that particular moment,
[0:16:44] and I have no problem going first in talking,
[0:16:49] particularly the candidates that I have felt
[0:16:52] that I would like to move forward,
[0:16:53] but I don't wanna monopolize this because I value
[0:16:58] both of your opinions.
[0:17:00] Would one of you prefer to go first and jump out there
[0:17:04] and we can have a conversation and work through this
[0:17:06] or would you prefer that I go?
[0:17:08] I'm happy to go.
[0:17:09] Okay, go ahead, Ruth.
[0:17:10] So thank you, Mayor.
[0:17:12] What I did is in going through the 15 applications
[0:17:15] is look at several things.
[0:17:18] One was their involvement with the city
[0:17:22] and city meetings, city council meetings,
[0:17:27] attending city events, city commissions.
[0:17:31] I also looked at their community involvement
[0:17:38] and then in addition, looked at their answer
[0:17:45] to the questions related to what the significant issues
[0:17:49] are moving forward with the city.
[0:17:52] So I took all those things into account.
[0:17:55] I came up with five candidates.
[0:17:58] I'm happy to go through those five
[0:18:00] or we can talk about.
[0:18:03] Maybe we'll, yeah, let's maybe let Craig
[0:18:05] kind of outline his thought process before we jump into that.
[0:18:09] And I think that would be appropriate
[0:18:11] that I can outline a very similar my process.
[0:18:14] Yeah, I looked at some of the things about their,
[0:18:18] how connected are they to the community itself, you know?
[0:18:22] Are they showing up to community events and city council meetings?
[0:18:28] They served on any city commissions.
[0:18:32] Those things were really important to me about it.
[0:18:36] And then I guess their background provided a little bit of information
[0:18:42] about some of their experience and stuff other than maybe Twin Falls.
[0:18:47] I think that that was a little bit of a swaying factor too,
[0:18:52] why I chose my five, so.
[0:18:55] Perfect, thanks, Craig, and I'll provide some of my insight,
[0:18:57] very similar to both of you that I felt like,
[0:19:00] you know, the community involvement piece was important,
[0:19:04] is we spend a lot of time here each Monday.
[0:19:07] There's also other commissions or liaison positions
[0:19:12] that we sit in, and there is a tremendous amount
[0:19:16] time commitment as we work through this and so I wanted to make sure that people truly understood
[0:19:22] what the time commitment was. It is interesting that each, you know, the selections that I've had,
[0:19:31] you know, come from different backgrounds, which I felt was important. I felt that that is a huge
[0:19:35] value to the City Council, a great representation as, you know, we have different individuals from
[0:19:43] different backgrounds. And so that also was important for me. I think Craig you'd
[0:19:48] alluded to that a little bit. But community service and really what you were able to
[0:19:55] articulate to some of the nature in which your background brings to the City Council
[0:20:01] was important to me. Also I noted it earlier, you know, are you willing to run?
[0:20:07] Are you willing to do this again and go through and allow the citizens to
[0:20:11] to ultimately vote for you at that next election.
[0:20:17] But again, I'll reiterate,
[0:20:19] I really believe that all the candidates,
[0:20:21] and I too have a couple of candidates
[0:20:24] that I would like to move forward.
[0:20:26] But maybe Ruth at this point,
[0:20:28] maybe we can talk,
[0:20:30] see where we come together and move forward.
[0:20:35] Okay, sure.
[0:20:36] So the five that I selected,
[0:20:38] and I think these are in numerical orders,
[0:20:41] so no particular order other than numerical.
[0:20:45] Neil Christensen, Kelly Hurgassell,
[0:20:52] Dorado Munoz, Todd Ramber, and Lucy Wills.
[0:21:03] Yes, Neil Christensen, Kelly Hurgassell,
[0:21:09] Dorado Munoz Bryant, Todd Ramber, and Lucy Wills,
[0:21:16] Greg, I may ask you at this point, are there any similarities between yours and Ruth's?
[0:21:27] Yes, there are, mostly, I think.
[0:21:30] I've got Lucy Wills.
[0:21:33] Uralro.
[0:21:36] We're with him on P&Z.
[0:21:39] Neil Christensen.
[0:21:41] Kelly.
[0:21:44] Higgers.
[0:21:45] Okay, so I would say that we have three applicants that are similar. I also did Neil,
[0:21:53] Lucy, and Todd would maybe like I had also Donna and I'd like to be able to maybe add
[0:22:18] on it if you're okay with that roof. I'm happy with you know we can do six there's
[0:22:21] no reason we have to do five. I think I think that I think that gives us a good
[0:22:28] body very similar across the board. I have no no qualms as I've looked through
[0:22:36] and you know you always look through these and people present themselves and
[0:22:40] allow themselves to put themselves out there and so it's always a little bit
[0:22:44] risky in that, but it's nice to see that we had at least three very similar candidates,
[0:22:56] and then obviously helps us get for just a little bit if we bring some other folks in.
[0:23:04] For me, personally, it's always hard to communicate over paper.
[0:23:08] I definitely like to give people in-person, I know that that's, I feel better myself if
[0:23:14] I can do that.
[0:23:15] So I agree.
[0:23:17] I think six candidates would be reasonable.
[0:23:20] Travis, did you get the names of those six?
[0:23:22] Mr. Mayor, we did not get your six.
[0:23:24] I got your four.
[0:23:26] So what I have is Lucy Wills.
[0:23:31] I have Neil Christensen.
[0:23:33] I had Todd Ramber.
[0:23:35] I had Dorado, or Tato, is what I know him as.
[0:23:40] Kelly Hurgacil.
[0:23:42] And then I've asked to add Donna Graybill.
[0:23:52] that you got them. Okay. I think it's important to note, and again, these are difficult situations,
[0:24:01] and we have to move forward with the candidates or the individuals that we feel will best serve,
[0:24:07] and I think you could hear an underlying theme, that public service, public involvement,
[0:24:12] and then also bringing some different backgrounds and things, that nature. So,
[0:24:18] So next steps, we'll go ahead Travis.
[0:24:23] Yeah, so after this we will let the individuals know those who are advancing as well as those
[0:24:33] who were not selected to advance.
[0:24:35] We will make sure that those that were selected to advance will be available for the November
[0:24:44] second with the meeting starting at 5 p.m. and again that is the only item on the
[0:24:50] City Council. A couple of things for you to think about as we prepare the six
[0:24:58] individuals to move forward is the amount of time that you are going to
[0:25:02] allocate to each one of the presenters. I think that it would be good to have them
[0:25:09] as you have historically done called them up.
[0:25:13] And if they understood the time constraints
[0:25:16] of their words and remarks, that would be helpful to them.
[0:25:21] And Travis, I think, and maybe if we want to have
[0:25:23] that conversation here now, and we can decide that,
[0:25:27] I think at this point, if we're ready to do so,
[0:25:32] Craig, are you okay with that?
[0:25:34] Maybe I'll start out on this one.
[0:25:36] was I was thinking anywhere the initial filling for me was about five to six
[0:25:42] minutes for them to prepare. I think that that gives gives a few more minutes
[0:25:48] than what we have historically allowed. I think last time we added we did three
[0:25:53] to two to three minutes for each candidate and that seemed part of the
[0:25:59] process to bring it down would be the five to six minutes. I would probably lean
[0:26:03] to the six minute mark myself and then allow two minutes for general questions from the
[0:26:09] council. But those are my initial thoughts as I've thought about this and trying to be clear
[0:26:16] with the candidates.
[0:26:17] So I was thinking seven and ten, but very close. But one of the things that I find very helpful
[0:26:25] as we do interviews when we're interviewing for commissions or even the jobs staff interviews
[0:26:32] that I've been involved in is having some questions that consistently each candidate answers.
[0:26:40] So last time when I was selecting a council person, it was a little bit too random.
[0:26:46] And so somebody thought of a question, fourth person down, and the first three didn't get
[0:26:51] a chance to answer it.
[0:26:53] So some maybe assigned questions or questions we'd come up with ourselves that we would
[0:27:00] like to see asked.
[0:27:01] So we've contemplated that in the past.
[0:27:05] I will share that the reason that we have gone away from that is because if you're first,
[0:27:14] so remember it's a public meeting, unlike our other processes, and individuals that go
[0:27:20] last have the ability to prepare thoughts and remarks where consistency is important.
[0:27:30] One of the things that you might consider is to ask questions based upon their presentations.
[0:27:37] You might have some stock questions, certainly, and we are going to randomize these, and they
[0:27:46] won't necessarily know until the mayor calls them up.
[0:27:51] It is candidate A's time to speak first, and so also making sure that we're trying to level
[0:27:58] the playing field as opposed to the person who goes first, as a person who goes last who
[0:28:03] hears the same questions, can gauge the council's response on the answers that they provide,
[0:28:10] and then maybe tweak what they're going to share, which almost in a sense, gives them
[0:28:14] the test answers in advance of the test in comparison to those who are taking it as they
[0:28:20] walk in.
[0:28:21] Because we can't, as a public meeting, we can't exclude them from observing the process.
[0:28:28] That makes sense.
[0:28:29] Greg, what are your feelings?
[0:28:32] I was thinking a little on the slider side,
[0:28:34] but after hearing what we've discussed,
[0:28:36] I think I'd go from four to six minutes,
[0:28:39] it'd probably be somewhere at neighborhood.
[0:28:43] Yep, I get to make that ultimate decision.
[0:28:46] And again, I've been looking at it.
[0:28:49] I use comments that are good, and so I'd
[0:28:52] be willing to maybe even open it up just a little bit,
[0:28:54] maybe go to seven minutes, eight minutes
[0:28:58] if we've all given speeches or presentations or talks,
[0:29:02] does that seem, you know, like?
[0:29:05] That's plenty.
[0:29:06] Okay.
[0:29:07] It would be nice to have maybe more than two minutes
[0:29:12] for questions, I don't know that.
[0:29:13] So maybe we do this, should we go seven minutes
[0:29:16] and then three minutes of questions?
[0:29:17] That's what I would say.
[0:29:18] And then that would be a total of 10 minutes
[0:29:20] for each candidate, that'd be okay with that.
[0:29:24] That'd be fine, Travis.
[0:29:26] My recommendation would be providing a little bit more flexibility on the Q&A piece of it.
[0:29:32] I think that you can have that hard stop in terms of total time and presentation,
[0:29:39] but I think that if you start a hard clock,
[0:29:44] Council may have lots of questions and someone may not be able to ask the question because of that.
[0:29:49] Okay, that was a good suggestion.
[0:29:52] The second would be typically at the end of the Q&A piece, you might invite them to share
[0:30:01] some closing remarks under a minute. Maybe that's what we do is we do seven minutes
[0:30:09] and then a closing remark of one minute and then that would allow them that would be eight
[0:30:14] minutes total for the candidate minus the question and answer. Yeah so I'm thinking six or seven minutes.
[0:30:23] Let's say six minutes, three minutes for questions, one minute for wrap-up.
[0:30:28] Okay, that's fine with me. I mean, that's with without a hard, I like Travis said, without a hard,
[0:30:36] there may be somebody says something that generates a question, we wouldn't typically ask anybody else.
[0:30:42] You need some flexibility. And I think we can write that in. This says generally three minutes
[0:30:47] with flexibility if it needs to go longer. Yeah, I don't think you need to regulate that piece of
[0:30:52] of it, I think you can share that with the council and then we'll have one minute closing.
[0:30:56] My other suggestion would be that we don't allow for AV materials presentations with cybersecurity
[0:31:05] risks.
[0:31:06] I think it's important that they come and they make their thoughts and their remarks
[0:31:12] without the use of audio visual, audio visual.
[0:31:16] I'm comfortable with that if they come with their own personal notes and presentation that way in the good old fashioned way, I guess.
[0:31:27] And questions only from Council.
[0:31:30] Correct.
[0:31:31] Audience or.
[0:31:33] That is correct.
[0:31:34] Okay, so we we determine six minutes.
[0:31:38] You ever take three minutes and then one minute for a closing remark.
[0:31:43] That's great, guys, good with that, okay.
[0:31:47] I'm with that Travis, and we send out that email and we'll send those out.
[0:31:55] Anything further for this special meeting?
[0:31:59] You good? No, I just appreciate the number of candidates that have applied and just some tough decisions and looking forward to getting to meet some new council members.
[0:32:15] Well, one of the things that in case candidates review this
[0:32:19] that weren't selected,
[0:32:21] I encourage you to get involved in the city,
[0:32:24] whether it's committee start coming to city council meetings,
[0:32:29] attend events that the city sponsors
[0:32:32] and get more involved, that's always good to see.
[0:32:36] And that was gonna be my closing remarks again.
[0:32:39] I don't think it's a good applicants.
[0:32:42] Everybody presented their answers well,
[0:32:47] but I think ultimately this is a pathway
[0:32:50] that you want to pursue out into the future.
[0:32:52] I think it bids to be and bids well to be involved.
[0:32:57] People know who you are and a level of commitment
[0:33:02] to the process that we try to adhere to.
[0:33:05] We're always looking for board or commission spots.
[0:33:08] I know that we're getting ready to open a few more.
[0:33:11] in the coming weeks.
[0:33:14] And again, that is an opportunity to jump in
[0:33:16] and figure out how the city process works.
[0:33:20] Many of the council members currently serving have sat
[0:33:24] or done very similar to that process.
[0:33:27] So anything further, okay, we'll go ahead
[0:33:31] and close and adjourn this special city council meeting
[0:33:35] for October 19th, 2026.
