Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2026-09-28, recording 1 (started 16:58)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2026-09-28/

[0:00:00] I saw the link because it's going to be so good.
[0:00:03] Oh, yeah.
[0:00:04] Thank you.
[0:00:06] Thank you.
[0:00:07] Jason.
[0:00:26] That's awesome.
[0:00:27] Okay.
[0:00:29] Thank you for the opportunity to recognize driver operator aisles and celebrate the accomplishments
[0:00:42] with him and his family.
[0:00:44] With your permission, we'd like to allow driver operator aisles, his family, friends and others
[0:00:49] to go ahead and exit.
[0:00:50] Take a minute to exit and go outside for more photos and some more congratulations.
[0:00:54] Congratulations, but once again congratulations
[0:00:59] Would you have our newest driver operator maybe introduce the family that he brought the seating so we never mind
[0:01:34] Okay, we'll go ahead and move on to our
[0:01:37] Next agenda item and that is a request
[0:01:40] request for approval of the collective bargaining agreement between the City of Twin Falls
[0:01:45] and Twin Falls Firefighters Local 1556, you know, Kristin.
[0:01:50] Good evening, Mayor and Council.
[0:01:53] Tonight, I'm bringing forward the proposed 2627 Collective Bargaining Agreement or CBA
[0:01:59] between the City of Twin Falls and the Firefighters Local 1556, which was just said.
[0:02:05] So the City Administration and the Executive Board of the Union have been meeting over about
[0:02:10] the last five months. As I say that, I want to recognize the members of the executive board
[0:02:15] who are here with us tonight and thank them for the time that they have put into the process.
[0:02:19] I believe our President Kyle is here and he may have a few words that he would like to
[0:02:23] share at the end. So I'm proud to say that we continue to have a very good working relationship
[0:02:30] with the local 1556 and I truly appreciate the conversations that we've been able to have
[0:02:35] throughout our negotiations. As you can see in the background packet, our discussions covered
[0:02:40] several topics including preventative health screenings, company staffing and work periods,
[0:02:46] wages and longevity pay. I want to start by clarifying that one item from the list that was
[0:02:54] the preventative screening did not reach a final agreement but those conversations are
[0:03:00] continuing and we anticipate that some form of additional preventative screening will be provided
[0:03:06] in the future. Where the agreement before you tonight, agreement was reached on three primary
[0:03:12] changes. The first is an update to section 11, work period. We agreed to remove the alternative
[0:03:20] D and E shift language. The D and E shifts were originally created to help provide coverage
[0:03:25] and balance staffing across our A, B and C shifts. However, the arrangement created some operational
[0:03:32] and personnel challenges. Having one or two firefighters rotate amongst the three shifts
[0:03:38] made it more difficult for those employees to become fully integrated with a single crew
[0:03:43] and also complicated some scheduling such as vacation selections.
[0:03:48] The second change is to appendix A, the pay table. It provides a 3% wage increase effective
[0:03:55] October 1st of this year which is consistent with the wage adjustment being provided to all
[0:03:59] other city employees. And lastly, we updated longevity pay so that it is based on each employee's
[0:04:08] anniversary date. Historically, our longevity pay has been calculated based on an employee's completed
[0:04:14] years of service as of December 31st each year. Employees become eligible beginning with their
[0:04:21] sixth consecutive year of service and calculated at $6 per month for each year. Under the new
[0:04:27] language rather than waiting until the end of the calendar year to recognize
[0:04:31] additional service, longevity pay will be adjusted and based on the employee's
[0:04:36] actual anniversary date. The underlying longevity benefit and calculations not
[0:04:42] changing, it's just the timing of the implementation. This change aligns with
[0:04:48] and was driven by our transition to our new payroll system, BSNA, which you guys
[0:04:52] have heard a lot about. All of the financial implications associated with the changes talked
[0:04:59] about tonight have been included in the city's FY26-27 budget. And with that, I'm happy to
[0:05:08] stand for any questions or if President Kyle Eldridge would like to come down and speak.
[0:05:14] Any questions? Council? Kyle here tonight? Kyle, I'm sure you want to say something? Okay.
[0:05:23] Welcome.
[0:05:24] Mayor, Council, College, President of Local 1556, I've been the President for about six
[0:05:33] years.
[0:05:34] I think I have a pretty good relationship with you guys and City Administration.
[0:05:38] Little background is I also perform roles for the State Union, PFFI, and our International
[0:05:43] Union, the 7th District.
[0:05:44] And so I've done, been fortunate to do union work not only for here in the city but across
[0:05:50] the Pacific Northwest.
[0:05:52] And I can say right now that I think our relationship between labor and management, pretty unprecedented.
[0:05:59] For example today, to have an issue come up and be able to just call city administration,
[0:06:05] schedule a meeting and get it figured out within an eight hour work day is pretty unheard
[0:06:10] of across the country.
[0:06:11] So I'd like to say thank you guys for your support for supporting your firefighters and
[0:06:16] again, the same goes to the city administration.
[0:06:18] Thank you guys.
[0:06:19] Thanks Kyle.
[0:06:20] Thank you.
[0:06:22] any questions? What are councils wishes? I make a motion. Okay. Ruth, I move we approve the
[0:06:31] collective bargaining agreement between the city and Twin Falls firefighters local 1556.
[0:06:36] Chris Reed, I'll second. We have a motion and a second to approve the collective bargaining
[0:06:42] agreement between the city of Twin Falls and Twin Falls firefighters local 1556. Any further
[0:06:49] discussion by the Council. Hey, Amy, roll call vote, please.
[0:06:53] Chris Reed. Yes. Greg Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. Sherri
[0:06:58] Vomer. Yes. Nathan Murray. Yes. Edward Pierce. Yes. Hey, motion
[0:07:02] carries six to zero. As with everything, Kyle, group, appreciate
[0:07:07] all your guys' service with that and all that you do. Thank
[0:07:11] you. Okay, we'll go ahead and move on to the next Council
[0:07:21] item which is the consideration of an
[0:07:26] employing agreement with Bruce
[0:07:27] Castleton of Castleton Law PLLC for the
[0:07:30] City Attorney Services as defined in
[0:07:32] Idaho Code Section 5208A and we have
[0:07:36] Travis Rothweiler. Thank you Mr. Mayor
[0:07:39] members of the Council tonight I'm
[0:07:40] bringing forward to you the annual
[0:07:43] agreement that we have with Bruce
[0:07:45] Castleton to serve as our City Attorney.
[0:07:47] Since October 2023, Bruce Castleton has served as our city attorney, and over that period of time, he had worked as a private contractor for our city, being available for all of our departments, as well as providing a level of mentorship to our prosecutorial staff.
[0:08:11] The city is bound to have a city attorney, and that section of code is found in 50-208A.
[0:08:21] However, how that arrangement looks is really largely at the discretion of the organization in which that council is serving.
[0:08:31] And we started with an outside firm moving and provide after we moved from
[0:08:39] in-house legal counsel services after several years. And while that worked,
[0:08:45] there is an interest by both parties to begin a more permanent and placement as
[0:08:53] the years come forward. And so what's different about this agreement in
[0:08:58] comparison to the past is Mr. Castleton will actually become a city employee and be eligible
[0:09:06] for the benefits of being a full-time city employee.
[0:09:09] And so we restructured that agreement to reflect that and some of the major changes are is that
[0:09:15] Mr. Castleton commits to working an average of about 30 hours per week which is the definition
[0:09:22] of a full-time city of employee to be able to receive the benefits that are associated
[0:09:27] with the position which include access to the city's health insurance programs, as well
[0:09:36] as an opportunity to become vested in Percy.
[0:09:43] In response to that, the city employee, now Mr. Castleton, will receive a salary of $135,000
[0:09:53] payable on the city's current payroll cycle.
[0:09:58] And Mr. Castleton will be, like I said,
[0:10:01] have an opportunity to participate in our health insurance program.
[0:10:04] He will also have regular and routine presence inside of the city of Twin Falls.
[0:10:11] One of the requests was to have him be able to continue to have a Lexus nexus
[0:10:19] or related program so that he can continue to do his legal research.
[0:10:25] At this time, when we are going through this negotiation process as well as part of the
[0:10:30] budgeting process, it was outside of the ceiling that we had put in for the legal department.
[0:10:36] So Mr. Castleton is going to continue to use that as he has other clients that he participates
[0:10:43] with and we don't discourage outside employment opportunity so long as it does not interfere
[0:10:50] with his ability to provide those services
[0:10:54] to the City of Twin Falls.
[0:10:55] And we committed that as future budget years move forward
[0:10:59] that we would look at adding him as a licensure
[0:11:02] or a subscription to a program that we move forward
[0:11:05] with the city.
[0:11:07] In addition to that, he will be afforded vacation
[0:11:10] and sickly like we do all other full-time employees.
[0:11:14] And so with that, Mr. Mayor and members of the council,
[0:11:16] I'm happy to answer any questions that you have
[0:11:19] about this agreement, it is largely the same,
[0:11:22] it is with the same person,
[0:11:24] we're just changing the classification of Mr. Castleton.
[0:11:28] Nathan Murray.
[0:11:30] Yeah, did we, it's not the right question,
[0:11:32] but did we determine the reporting process?
[0:11:35] Did we, this is a camel too?
[0:11:37] Is that us or is this a city manager?
[0:11:40] It is you, and the reason it is you
[0:11:43] is because it is a contractual relationship
[0:11:47] with the organization. However, I do believe that the city council has had some
[0:11:56] conversations that would lead me to believe that the day-to-day and evaluations would be
[0:12:03] largely performed by my office with significant input and direction from the council.
[0:12:09] And I would agree with that.
[0:12:11] Yep.
[0:12:12] Delegate, delegate.
[0:12:15] Yes, I will.
[0:12:16] Yeah.
[0:12:17] The other questions for Travis on.
[0:12:20] Castleton.
[0:12:21] Was contract.
[0:12:23] Chris read.
[0:12:24] I don't.
[0:12:25] I'm ready to make a motion.
[0:12:26] You get it.
[0:12:27] Go ahead, Chris.
[0:12:28] I move that we approve an employee agreement with Bruce.
[0:12:31] Castleton.
[0:12:32] Castleton law.
[0:12:33] PLC.
[0:12:34] But the city attorney services is defined in Idaho code section.
[0:12:38] 50-208 a Ruth Pierce. I'll second that Kevin motion and a second
[0:12:45] We approve an employee agreement with Bruce Castleton of Castleton law P LLC for City Attorney Services as defined in Idaho
[0:12:53] Idaho Code section 50-208 a any further discussion?
[0:12:58] Hey, Amy roll call vote, please
[0:13:01] Craig Hawkins yes Jason Brown yes. Yes. Yes, I think Murray yes Ruth Pierce yes and Chris Reed yes
[0:13:11] Okay, motion carries six to zero.
[0:13:14] Travis, move on to the next item of consideration,
[0:13:20] which is a request for the city council
[0:13:22] to approve the funding agreement with ITD
[0:13:25] for $107,360 and the FY2027 contract
[0:13:30] with downtown via in the amount of $1,759,200.
[0:13:38] And authorize the mayor to sign both agreements
[0:13:40] and we have Travis Rothwiler again.
[0:13:43] Yeah, Mr. Mayor, members of the Council,
[0:13:44] I'm filling in for Mandy Thompson,
[0:13:46] who's unable to be with us today.
[0:13:48] And maybe by just way of a little background,
[0:13:51] the City of Twin Falls started its microtransit program
[0:13:54] in 2023.
[0:13:56] And at that point in time, we had seven vans,
[0:13:59] including of which two were accessible units.
[0:14:04] We thought that that would be a really good launching pad
[0:14:08] for a new program and what we quickly found out is that the demand for that service, as
[0:14:14] we have reported back to you on several times in the past, had initially exceeded our expectations
[0:14:21] and it continues to grow and to evolve.
[0:14:25] And as a result of the demand, we added an additional van in 2020-24 and the seven original
[0:14:36] VANs were refurbished in 2025. In concert with Nathan Jerky and the Twin Falls Metropolitan
[0:14:48] Planning Organization, we were able to access 53-10 funds which is administered by the State of Idaho.
[0:14:57] And those 53-10 funds allow us to add an additional accessible VAN to the route which is going to come.
[0:15:06] It's going to help balance the demand as well as the need for those that need a van that
[0:15:16] is designed to accomplish those that have disabilities.
[0:15:21] The ITD grant is for $107,360 and it does cover the cost of the van as well as the operational
[0:15:32] costs as well.
[0:15:34] What we're asking tonight is that because of the timing and where our fiscal year starts
[0:15:41] and where the contract ends, that you would approve these for the 2027 fiscal year moving
[0:15:49] forward.
[0:15:51] Happy to stand for any questions.
[0:15:53] Any Ruth Pierce?
[0:15:54] So Travis, do you want two different motions or can this be one motion?
[0:15:58] It can be in the same motion.
[0:16:00] Okay.
[0:16:01] Ready to make motion.
[0:16:02] Okay.
[0:16:03] Go ahead, Ruth.
[0:16:04] move we approve the funding agreement with I.T.D. for $107,360 and the FY2027 contract with
[0:16:14] downtown or slash via in the amount of $1,759,203 and authorize the mayor to sign both agreements.
[0:16:23] Sherry Bohmer. I'll second. I have a motion and a second to approve the funding agreement
[0:16:29] with itd for 107,360 dollars and the fy 2027 contract with downtown or slash
[0:16:37] via in the amount of 1,759,203 dollars and authorize the mayor to sign both
[0:16:44] agreements any further discussion by council.
[0:16:48] Okay, Amy roll call vote, please.
[0:16:50] Jason Brown.
[0:16:51] Yes, Mary Wilmer.
[0:16:52] Yes, Nathan Murray.
[0:16:54] Yes, Ruth Pierce.
[0:16:55] Yes, Chris Reed.
[0:16:56] Yes, and Craig Hopkins.
[0:16:57] Yes. Okay. Motion carries six to zero. Thanks Travis. Okay. That brings us to our next item
[0:17:05] and that is the request to adopt ordinance 2026-10 for zoning district changes on property located
[0:17:14] at 451 Russet Street and we have Jonathan Spinlove. Thank you, Mayor, members of the Council. This
[0:17:21] item went to the Planning and Zoning Commission on July 14th was forwarded with the positive
[0:17:25] was a recommendation to the council that heard it on August 17th.
[0:17:29] On that date, it was unanimously approved by those present.
[0:17:32] Tonight, if you wish to pass this ordinance,
[0:17:35] it would be half plus one, which we do have,
[0:17:38] with the math before I walked in.
[0:17:39] So we did, we didn't do a first reading.
[0:17:41] I have the title, the location is actually a property
[0:17:44] just off of Rust the street, north of Rock Creek.
[0:17:46] So it's just behind PIPECO, if you know where that is,
[0:17:48] just west of that.
[0:17:50] There's just a single lot re-zone of a property zone
[0:17:52] to put in a Iplex I believe is a little bit ago and I'll stand for any questions if you need me
[0:17:59] to read the title I can do that for you as well. Okay any questions for Jonathan? Chris read.
[0:18:04] I don't have any questions but I can put it on third and final. Sounds good Chris go ahead.
[0:18:08] I move that we dispense with the reading rules and place ordinance 2026-10 on third and final
[0:18:15] reading by title on me. I'll second that. Can I have a motion and a second to dispense with the rules
[0:18:22] the reading of the rules and put ordinance 2026-10 on third and final reading by title only and I'll
[0:18:30] read that it says in ordinance of the city of the city council of the city of twid and falls
[0:18:35] ido rezoning certain real property below describe providing the zoning classification therefore
[0:18:42] and zoning district map amendment or amendment any further discussion.
[0:18:48] Okay Amy roll call vote please.
[0:18:51] Sherry Volmer.
[0:18:53] Yes.
[0:18:54] I've been married.
[0:18:55] Yes.
[0:18:56] Ruth Pears.
[0:18:57] Yes.
[0:18:58] Chris Reed.
[0:18:59] Yes.
[0:19:00] Yes.
[0:19:01] And Jason Brown.
[0:19:02] Yes.
[0:19:03] That motion carries six to zero.
[0:19:04] Chris.
[0:19:05] Move to approve Ordinance 2026-10 for 10.
[0:19:10] Sherry Volmer.
[0:19:11] A second.
[0:19:12] Can I have a motion to approve Ordinance 2026-10 for the zoning district change on property located
[0:19:19] at 451 Russet Street. Any further discussion by the council?
[0:19:23] Hey, Amy, roll call vote, please.
[0:19:26] Jason Murray? Yes.
[0:19:29] Ruth Fierce? Yes.
[0:19:30] Chris Reed? Yes.
[0:19:31] Craig Hawkins? Yes.
[0:19:32] Jason Brown? Yes.
[0:19:33] Craig Wilmer? Yes.
[0:19:34] Okay, motion carries 6-0. Thank you, Jonathan. Appreciate it.
[0:19:38] Thanks.
[0:19:39] Okay, that brings us to our last item, and that's a presentation on the finances of the City of
[0:19:47] Twin Falls for the third quarter of fiscal year 25 to 26 and Brianna Howard.
[0:19:54] Good evening, Mayor and Council. Here we are again. I've got some smiles. I love this stuff.
[0:20:06] It gets numbers and financial data, national economics surroundings, and where do we sit?
[0:20:12] So right now, as we are all aware and as we watch all of the reports that come through,
[0:20:17] The national atmosphere is unstable, it's volatile, it's moving, but on the city side,
[0:20:24] we're relatively resilient.
[0:20:31] Growth is increasingly on leave-ins.
[0:20:32] We'll start with the national, and I'll go down to the city.
[0:20:36] Manufacturing strengthened in July, but as we've seen, growth is substantially in AI,
[0:20:40] semiconductors, data centers, and defense.
[0:20:43] July non-farm payrolls fell 23,000, and the three-month trend was stalling, but rebounded
[0:20:49] in August.
[0:20:50] to pull quite a few statistics that were just in this quarter that we're doing with a little
[0:20:54] bit of updates.
[0:20:55] And there's one slide I actually updated completely from the packet that you have.
[0:21:00] But so that's why I'm referencing some of this is to remember that we are in the third
[0:21:04] quarter that we're in right now.
[0:21:06] But we rebounded in August and wanted to throw that in there because we did see some increases
[0:21:09] at that point.
[0:21:10] July retail sales fell, giving consumer activity a softer start to quarter three.
[0:21:15] inflation cooled, shifting the balance of risk from inflation towards growth, who were consistently
[0:21:21] seeing an economy at a two-speed level. Investment led manufacturing continues to grow and stay
[0:21:27] strong while jobs and household spending are continuing to lose. This is the change we're
[0:21:32] watching this quarter. The concern has shifted from primarily energy volatility and back again,
[0:21:37] as we are concerned with it right now, towards labor and consumer durability. We do not assume
[0:21:43] Assume the strength in AI and manufacturing and defense translates into local broad growth,
[0:21:48] but we can tell that the slowdown is reaching twin falls through hiring trends and sales
[0:21:52] volatile revenues like our revenue sharing in our permits.
[0:21:57] As far as the labor market goes, job creation has narrowed sharply.
[0:22:02] Non-farm payrolls in July are far below expectations for an 80,000 gain, but before the large uptick
[0:22:08] in August.
[0:22:10] employer employers added 30,000 on the flip side, government declined by 53,000.
[0:22:16] Job gains have been concentrated in healthcare and construction, while several service sectors
[0:22:20] have lost jobs. Annual wage growth has slowed to a new cycle low of 3.2%. Since COVID, we've seen
[0:22:27] that cycle, that increase go exponentially higher, which is why we've consistently tried to give
[0:22:32] higher raises to our employees to keep up. That's actually dropping off, and we're seeing that 3.2%,
[0:22:37] which is relatively close to what we're doing with our employees in this upcoming budget.
[0:22:43] Consumers, this is the Enigma. Consumers spending has outrun income. It's an Enigma because people
[0:22:49] keep spending. Consumption exceeded income growth for the 14th consecutive month in June, but the
[0:22:56] personal savings rates fell to 2.7 percent. The lowest since June of 22 in the weakest since 2008
[0:23:03] thought that was a massive indicator. July retail sales fell for the first time in nine months and
[0:23:08] and posted the largest monthly decline since May of 2025.
[0:23:12] Consumers entered quarter three with less momentum.
[0:23:15] The consumers keep spending longer
[0:23:16] than income growth supported,
[0:23:18] which is pushing that savings rate down.
[0:23:20] July finally showed softer spending momentum.
[0:23:23] This decline was actually concentrated in a few spots.
[0:23:26] It was online and vehicle sales.
[0:23:27] So this is moderation,
[0:23:29] not a complete collapse in the consumers.
[0:23:32] For Twin Falls, household weaknesses can eventually show up
[0:23:35] in sales sensitive revenues,
[0:23:37] recreation activity and utility delinquency, so we watch our actual collections rather than assume the national trend applies broadly to us.
[0:23:45] Confidence, less pessimistic, but yet still not confident.
[0:23:52] Consumer sentiment improved for a second month in July after reaching a record low in May.
[0:23:57] Lower gas prices helped, but sentiment remained historically weak.
[0:24:00] Lower gas prices temporarily, and then they shot back up.
[0:24:04] Confidence weakened in July as present conditions fell to the lowest since February of 2021.
[0:24:09] Consumers remain cautiously optimistic about income,
[0:24:12] but subdued about future business conditions.
[0:24:16] Confidence and sentiment surveys are,
[0:24:18] they conflict somewhat, how much confidence you have
[0:24:20] about the economy and the market,
[0:24:23] and yet how much your sentiment is,
[0:24:25] is how much you want to spend.
[0:24:27] Sentiment improve while confidence weakened,
[0:24:29] but what consumers do matters more than what they say,
[0:24:32] and that's the enigma as well.
[0:24:33] People keep saying they're worried,
[0:24:35] they're cautious about spending,
[0:24:37] but yet people are still spending,
[0:24:38] and we're still seeing that in our sales revenue across the city.
[0:24:42] Consumers are still uneasy about affordability and current condition.
[0:24:46] Between falls, confidence can affect our housing moves
[0:24:49] and discretionary purchases before it appears in revenues.
[0:24:51] So we might see a lag, but our local revenue performance
[0:24:54] is a better signal than National Survey Mood Alum.
[0:24:58] Inflation, energy volatility, cooler underlying trend.
[0:25:03] So headline CPA, that's the broadest measure of CPI
[0:25:06] that does everything in this basket of what consumers.
[0:25:08] that's the CPI index. That fell a little bit in June, but it's the largest monthly decline since
[0:25:14] COVID, so since 2020. Super core inflation excludes food, energy, and housing, and it neared its cycle
[0:25:22] low when it's lowest level since March of 2021. On the flip side, MCI has increased. Remember, MCI
[0:25:29] is municipal cost index. That's what we have to purchase. So it excludes the volatile food and
[0:25:34] energy that government doesn't purchase. This remains higher than CPI at 4.49% in July.
[0:25:41] Energy remains volatile, gasoline prices fell, and then rebounded and are still over that $100
[0:25:46] barrel. So underlying inflation cool this quarter, but energy volatility remains high.
[0:25:51] Oil and diesel matter because they flow through freight, construction, and agriculture in our city.
[0:25:58] We should separate general inflation as we do with the MCI versus the CPI.
[0:26:02] from energy sensitive costs such as fuel utilities, asphalt freight, and contractor
[0:26:07] pricing. Those costs can remain high even when core inflation improves, so we look
[0:26:12] at a different indicator. This is the slide that I swapped because as we know
[0:26:17] last week the Fed's just had their meeting and increased rates. So interest
[0:26:23] rates relief has been delayed. The Fed reserved as we know raised rates by
[0:26:28] 25 basis points, so it's now it's around 3.75% to 4%. The unanimous decision, the key
[0:26:34] indicator there is unanimous, followed the FEDS assessment that inflation remains elevated.
[0:26:40] The FEDS decided a resilient domestic spending, strong productivity and robust capital investment,
[0:26:46] but that leaves the average 30-year fixed rate around 7.03%, which is compared to 6.3%
[0:26:52] one year earlier. If you ever have the opportunity to do a quick amortization schedule, get
[0:26:57] do it in Excel and just do new schedule and drop in a few key factors, those type of differences
[0:27:03] affect us significantly.
[0:27:05] On a home that costs $300,000 or $400,000, the monthly increase is significant.
[0:27:10] The increased reversed expectations of near-term relief and borrowing costs remain high.
[0:27:14] The unanimous action is what shows that controlling inflation currently outweighs pressure to reduce
[0:27:20] interest costs.
[0:27:21] So, big complexion.
[0:27:23] For Twin Falls, higher short-term rates might be cheaper and we might be getting more when
[0:27:28] we invest in city earnings, but elevating and borrowing and mortgage rates can constrain
[0:27:34] development, housing affordability, and capital financing.
[0:27:41] Housing with small improvements, persistent constraints.
[0:27:45] June new home sales, this is national, rose 1.6%, but remained 5.6% below the prior year.
[0:27:52] housing starts jumped 19%, but the gain came from volatile multifamily
[0:27:56] constructions. As we talk about permits, I mentioned that as a city as well, we are
[0:28:00] seeing a lot more multifamilies than we have in the past. Building permits fell
[0:28:04] 3% providing a weaker signal for future construction. Real-home values
[0:28:09] declined from 11th consecutive month through April. Housing improved with
[0:28:13] affordability and forward looking construction indicators remained
[0:28:16] constrained. For Twin Falls National and Western Housing
[0:28:20] weaknesses, you've seen some of those reports that's showing that some of our
[0:28:24] areas is lowering, but this does not automatically describe us. Our own
[0:28:28] permit counts, construction values, and population growth are the indicators
[0:28:32] that matter for us. Improving inventory and builder incentives by third parties
[0:28:37] is what could unlock transactions if mortgage rates ease. Business conditions,
[0:28:43] investments, strength is concentrated, July manufacturing rose to 55.6%, which
[0:28:50] exceeds expectation and signals expansion. Manufacturing is the strongest counterweight
[0:28:55] to weaker labor and consumer data and index above 50 means you're doing well, anything
[0:29:00] below 50 means you're doing, you're not, you're in retraction area. Production reached its highest
[0:29:06] level since November of 2021 and manufacturing employment expanded for the first time in
[0:29:11] 33 months, nearly three years. Demand was strongest in AI, we know that, semiconductors,
[0:29:17] centers, defense, consumer, and industrial markets were softer.
[0:29:22] And on the other side, tariffs, supply constraints,
[0:29:25] longer lead times, geopolitical risks
[0:29:27] continue to complicate planning for businesses.
[0:29:31] For Twin Falls, we could benefit for food processing,
[0:29:33] logistics, construction, and industrial investments
[0:29:36] remain active, but we verify this through local activity
[0:29:39] rather than assume the national manufacturing strength comes
[0:29:42] down to us.
[0:29:44] AI, tools alone are not producing value.
[0:29:47] I'm sure every one of you are realizing this and trying to figure out how to quantify it.
[0:29:52] People continue to use AI, they continue to spout how AI is helping, but nobody can prove
[0:29:56] where AI is gaining efficiency and how much money we're actually saving by the use of AI.
[0:30:01] 71% of employees receive little to no guidance on how to use time free by AI, and that's something
[0:30:06] our executive team at the city is concerned about right now and trying to work through.
[0:30:12] Clear strategy with limited tool access produced more measurable impact than strong tools
[0:30:16] without direction, 80% versus 60%.
[0:30:19] Only about 1% of laid off workers explicitly identified
[0:30:22] as AI or automation as the primary reason for job loss.
[0:30:26] So it's not factoring into the numbers yet.
[0:30:30] The larger benefits need to come from direction, workflow,
[0:30:32] redesign, and clear expectation, not just AI itself.
[0:30:36] So for Twin Falls, our opportunity
[0:30:38] is targeted in process improvement.
[0:30:40] We are continuously using the things that we do have available
[0:30:42] to us now to try to figure out how we can do things better,
[0:30:46] To save time, error reduction through put-in capacity rather than just adopting AI because it's there.
[0:30:53] Health costs, this continues to rise significantly.
[0:30:57] This first stat is pretty staggering.
[0:30:59] Employers expect healthcare costs to raise 11.1% in 2027, which is the largest increase in two decades.
[0:31:07] Researchers anticipate costs could increase by 76% over the 10-year period starting in 2018, which is double the rate of inflation.
[0:31:14] Cancer treatments and broad use of weight loss drugs are what's factoring into some of these costs.
[0:31:20] The bigger hits to the plan, 24% of workers report staying in and want jobs because they want the health insurance benefits.
[0:31:28] You may or may not have seen the article regarding the Idaho School Benefit Trust.
[0:31:33] So quite a few school districts, charters and staff of the Idaho Education Association were in this.
[0:31:40] It exhausted all of their reserves fairly quickly and had a 19.5% renewal increase.
[0:31:47] I mentioned that just for us to watch and to be cautious, this doesn't indicate that we
[0:31:52] have any concern with our health insurance trust at this point.
[0:31:55] Our focus is claims, stop loss recoveries, contribution adequacy and reserves, and this
[0:32:00] is an area where discipline forecasting will help us in the future.
[0:32:05] That's the national side.
[0:32:07] Right now I'm going to stop and talk about the what we're seeing locally, so I'm going
[0:32:11] to break it up into, well, I'll show you the full graph and then break it up into tax-supported
[0:32:16] funds and then enterprise. Our budget structure, 60% of what we receive, is tax-supported funds.
[0:32:22] That's local shared revenue, that's property taxes, that's everything that we get from
[0:32:25] the state to help us. Enterprise funds are 40%. It's important we compare what we are actually,
[0:32:32] it's important that we compare these separately because property tax dollars pay for one thing,
[0:32:37] whereas enterprise funds would pay for their own fund. They operate under different revenue
[0:32:41] models. We're jumping into tax-supported funds. This one is the most directly tied
[0:32:47] to taxes. This is what people talk about. You can see our property taxes are 33
[0:32:53] million, which is 56% of the tax-supported funds, but if you compare it to the
[0:32:58] entire city, it's actually only 32% of the budgeted revenue across the city.
[0:33:03] State shared revenues is about 6.7 million. This is where you're going to
[0:33:08] see some of the volatility if it comes to pass and in the future. That's
[0:33:11] liquor licenses in state revenue. Dedicated Street Fund is 4.9 million. We have
[0:33:17] transfers budgeted of 4.3 million, franchise fees or 2.4, and grants are only
[0:33:22] 1.1 million this year. Reserve serves 700,000. Everything else that's smaller in
[0:33:27] nature is in that other category. There's a few larger ones comparatively. 1.4
[0:33:33] million is building permits. 1.4 million is in the airport. We have 1.2
[0:33:38] million in investment income and then 640,000 in the fire district. This shows
[0:33:46] where our tax-supported funds go. It's not just the general. We act general fund,
[0:33:50] we actually we spend money in our street fund, we have library capital
[0:33:54] improvements, a little bit of our fireworks airport. It goes across the
[0:33:58] entire all the departments. In looking at property tax history for the last four
[0:34:04] years we've budgeted relatively close 33 million as opposed to 27 million the
[0:34:09] last four years. Mostly property taxes come from new construction and the 3%
[0:34:16] increase that we you are allowed to allow to take. Collection timing is not
[0:34:22] pro-red, it's not perfectly even throughout the years. Some people pre-pay
[0:34:25] for their taxes, some people pay towards the end. We've received 64% so far.
[0:34:31] Long-term growth in this revenue depends heavily on expanding the tax base through
[0:34:36] new construction which is why URA is so important. Other major revenue sources are
[0:34:42] highway money. We've got 4.9 million that we budgeted. This is not far as well as
[0:34:46] people drive. State revenue sharing as people are spending money we get a
[0:34:51] portion of that back. We have 6.7 million. We've received 80% 79. And then
[0:34:56] franchise fees about 2.4 million. Franchise fees are made up of
[0:35:02] of in-amount gas, Idaho power, and some cable.
[0:35:05] That is 3% of their gross revenues.
[0:35:08] You can see where they've gone
[0:35:10] throughout the last 10, 20 years.
[0:35:14] Building permit revenue, we have budgeted 1.36 million,
[0:35:19] and we've received 1.34 million,
[0:35:21] so because of some larger expansion,
[0:35:24] the Giovanni expansion, we've received
[0:35:26] most of what we had budgeted.
[0:35:27] It was unanticipated.
[0:35:30] Residential permit counts remain below last year,
[0:35:32] including 23% fewer single-family permits,
[0:35:37] but construction values continue to rise.
[0:35:40] This distinction mattered if fewer permits
[0:35:42] does not mean total less investment
[0:35:44] because larger projects are still moving forward.
[0:35:48] This graph continues to show over the last almost 20 years
[0:35:52] where we have gone.
[0:35:54] Building permits, revenue, and remember
[0:35:56] it's only single-family in this graph.
[0:35:58] Revenue fell after the housing crash,
[0:36:00] recovered gradually, peaked in 2021,
[0:36:03] and then bump from the 2.9 expansion, it continues to moderate.
[0:36:10] On the expenditure side, personnel is the largest part of our budget.
[0:36:13] We have 37.9 million budgeted, only 28 million, three quarters of the year.
[0:36:19] We have 73.9 percent expended.
[0:36:21] We still are not fully staffed, but we budget for fully staffed
[0:36:24] because that's our expectation is that we would fill those seats.
[0:36:28] We have about 17 open positions across the city,
[0:36:32] which is a 4.7 percent vacancy rate.
[0:36:36] MNO is 71% of the 10.7 million that we have budgeted.
[0:36:42] Capital improvements, I will list off just so you have some idea of what's fitting into that because
[0:36:48] there's larger numbers across the city. We have 340,000 patrol vehicles, 400,000
[0:36:54] evidence storage training center design, 1 million in the fire station 2 in apparatus lease payments,
[0:36:59] 600,000 for the water tender, 736,000 for the Harmon state skate park infrastructure,
[0:37:06] West tennis and pickleball course and canyon trail junction, 2.6 millions in seal coating,
[0:37:11] 600,000 in road reconstruction, 380,000 in sweet sweeper and 250,000 library 88 compliant.
[0:37:20] We are more than what we have budgeted because other capital expenditures that are not budgeted
[0:37:25] that were encumbered from last year are received at council authority come from reserves
[0:37:29] and shows it as extra on this, are the pool remodel of $2 million, the SLF, RF, and rock creek projects, the legal and gym.
[0:37:37] Transfers are not pro-rata, if we have any extra money in the capital improvement fund, we shift it over to the general fund to use the future.
[0:37:49] Jumping over to the enterprise funds, and our prize funds are like a business without a profit motive, so we charge fees and we annually watch those fees to see where we come in.
[0:37:58] These are user revenue fees only, we get more, the water fund is quite a bit bigger than the waste water fund, but the only one that I'm showing here to analyze is on the water revenue usage that we see.
[0:38:15] They both have about $10 to $11 million in user revenue fees.
[0:38:19] And the risk here, it goes without saying that there's a local risk, we know that much of our economy is ag based.
[0:38:26] drought, irrigation availability, and higher input costs can ripple through farm, ag, dairy,
[0:38:31] all across our organization or all across our Magic Valley. Sean Berriger shared some data from
[0:38:37] several reporters from CSI, the Magic Valley Land Trust, and U of I regarding the multiplayer and
[0:38:42] economic output of every dollar spent in dairy and or ag manufacturing in the Magic Valley.
[0:38:47] So if it's spent by ag, it's spent again and again, that we can roughly, although we can
[0:38:51] We can say it's more, but we can conservatively say it's at least another dollar that's spent
[0:38:56] in our economy.
[0:38:58] This means that other sectors affected like vets, consultants, transportation, equipment
[0:39:02] and supply, mechanics, et cetera, all across the Magic Valley.
[0:39:06] Wastewater is billed on water usage, and so as we see water increase or decrease, we
[0:39:12] will see wastewater as well.
[0:39:15] Currently we have 11.4 million of water and 7.7 million received.
[0:39:19] We will see that last big jump in the last quarter of a year on wastewater to 11.1 and
[0:39:24] 8.7 million today.
[0:39:31] The expenditure side, so personnel is 67% and at 75% of the year we will pay a bit more
[0:39:42] during the summer months as well, but their MNO is a bit lower and that's typical for
[0:39:46] water when they spend most of theirs throughout the summer months as they're using power to
[0:39:50] pump water.
[0:39:52] is significantly larger than budgeted for a handful of projects.
[0:39:57] So the water capital that we have budgeted first, I'll tell, and then I'll explain it
[0:40:01] in the one that we are encumbered or used later.
[0:40:04] So budgeted was 850,000 in the South pressure zone boundary adjustment, 300,000 with the
[0:40:09] in-sign pump station, 4 million with our main line of meter replacement, and we expended
[0:40:15] 4.1 million on hinkins that was budgeted from reserves because 4.5 million was encumbered
[0:40:20] from last year. That's why you're seeing a significant increase or over budgeted
[0:40:24] amount. It's not that we didn't plan for it. It was planned wastewater personnel is at
[0:40:31] 69.5% so 900 out of 1.3 million. That's not the largest expenditure we contract
[0:40:36] most of our services out. They're just a little over three quarters the way
[0:40:40] year of the way through the year. Overspent power chemicals supplies continue
[0:40:46] to increase with some of the other stuff we've talked about, gasoline, tariffs, et cetera.
[0:40:52] On the capital side, they have budgeted 338,000 jet truck, 650,000 mainline replacement, or
[0:41:00] meant 4 million canyon rev drop line, most of that has not been expended to date, 700,000
[0:41:05] dewatering and aeration system, and we've spent about 1.3 million on the CIPP project.
[0:41:13] is comparatively simple. We contract it out so the income that comes in and the expenses
[0:41:17] come in are budgeted. This will be important as we work through the PSI contract that expires
[0:41:22] the end of this year and then we will see where that one changes. So in summary, manufacturing
[0:41:29] and productivity investment remains solid, but growth is increasingly concentrated. Labor
[0:41:35] creation and consumer momentum weakened, underlying inflation cooled while energy continues to be
[0:41:40] volatile, housing improved at the margin, but permits in single family activity remain constrained.
[0:41:46] Idaho's strong relative position in Twin Falls revenue performance continues to provide offsets.
[0:41:50] Health plan costs are not expected to remain flat in 2028. For our national economy remains
[0:41:56] resilient, but the margin is narrower. Strength is concentrated with labor,
[0:42:00] consumers' housing, energy, and health costs create more uncertainty. Where Twin Falls,
[0:42:05] our local results are providing meaningful offsets, tax-supported revenues, steady and
[0:42:09] in permit revenues near at full-term,
[0:42:11] what we've anticipated.
[0:42:13] The areas that we are going to continue to watch
[0:42:15] with the expenditure timing or consumer
[0:42:17] and labor softness, housing, energy volatility,
[0:42:21] and future health plan costs.
[0:42:24] Any questions?
[0:42:26] Any questions for Brianna?
[0:42:31] It was great, thank you.
[0:42:32] Yep.
[0:42:34] Always good information.
[0:42:35] We've been seeing healthcare costs
[0:42:38] in my daytime job go up about that percentage.
[0:42:42] I mean, it is crazy to see what health care
[0:42:46] gonna do over the next several years.
[0:42:50] I think costing everything have gone up, gas, food.
[0:42:53] Fund to drive down blue lakes and seek gas up over $5.
[0:42:57] Painful.
[0:42:58] And diesel, woo.
[0:43:00] It's crazy.
[0:43:01] Off time.
[0:43:02] Yeah.
[0:43:03] Thank you.
[0:43:04] Thank you.
[0:43:08] Brianna.
[0:43:09] Okay, that brings us to the general public input
[0:43:12] As we have over the last several weeks, months, if you want to address the council, we ask
[0:43:18] now that the sign up sheet is down here now.
[0:43:21] If you, before you address the council, please fill that out.
[0:43:25] And we'll operate it as we have the last couple of weeks.
[0:43:29] Several, or several weeks, I should say, you'll have two minutes, please state your name.
[0:43:33] And we'll start the time when you start speaking.
[0:43:36] Who's our first one tonight?
[0:43:38] Maria?
[0:43:39] Good evening.
[0:43:43] Good evening, my name is Maria Hernandez.
[0:43:46] I was born and raised here in Twin Falls, Idaho.
[0:43:49] I'm a proud, hello, Mr. Brown, Mayor Brown,
[0:43:53] and furious five.
[0:43:56] And a proud champion follower of Chief Standing Bear,
[0:43:58] the Ponca Indian Tribe.
[0:44:00] I would like to thank Lighthouse Church for assisting me
[0:44:02] in financially in the 2026 Mountain West worship conference,
[0:44:06] which incurred September 17th through the 19th.
[0:44:09] These workshops enhanced my creativity,
[0:44:12] which helped my writing skills and song selections,
[0:44:15] which I create weekly.
[0:44:16] Songs 96, one through three,
[0:44:19] says, sing into the Lord a new song.
[0:44:21] So what came forth were new songs.
[0:44:23] I was able to share the new songs I wrote
[0:44:26] with a couple of other students
[0:44:28] and even to a stranger on a sidewalk last week.
[0:44:32] I will address the stranger as Mr. A.
[0:44:35] The outcome was advancing Mr. A
[0:44:38] to a positive elevation of self-awareness of the divine.
[0:44:43] Once again, I would like to thank
[0:44:45] Minister Greg Badness of Lighthouse Christian Church
[0:44:48] for his love and support to his congregation
[0:44:52] and to his musicians everywhere.
[0:44:55] Thanks, Greg.
[0:44:56] And I also would like to add
[0:44:57] that there will be the preventing targeted violence
[0:45:01] community panel discussion.
[0:45:03] September 30th at Kenyon Crest.
[0:45:06] And it's regarding in response to the August 1st,
[0:45:11] 2026 shooting of the in and out burger in Twin Falls.
[0:45:14] This panel brings together expertise
[0:45:16] from behavioral health law enforcement,
[0:45:19] threat assessment, higher education,
[0:45:21] and community based youth prevention.
[0:45:23] It's at Canyon Crest from 6 to 7.30 PM.
[0:45:27] Thank you for your time.
[0:45:29] Thanks Maria.
[0:45:30] Thanks, periods three over there.
[0:45:35] That's all we have it.
[0:45:37] Yep.
[0:45:38] else that would like to address the council if so please fill that out.
[0:45:43] Okay.
[0:45:45] Not seeing anybody running up front here as of yet we'll move on to advisory board reports
[0:45:51] and announcements.
[0:45:52] Anything that we can go ahead, Craig.
[0:45:56] Just want to remind the council that AICs has their district meeting on October 22nd.
[0:46:01] He haven't signed up with Rachel with them do it now and then also on October 6 Tuesday
[0:46:11] The art commission will be is involved with hearts across America
[0:46:14] There'd be a unveiling of the sculpture of the heart there at the visitors center that that's at one o'clock
[0:46:23] Anyone else I got something so I know he laughed by one to think our planning director Jonathan spend love
[0:46:28] of a Herrot Center for Presentation on Housing.
[0:46:34] I'm involved with that group who's like speakers
[0:46:36] and Jonathan came and did a really good job
[0:46:38] about just using some of our data related to building permits,
[0:46:41] some of the things that he's seen since our code improvements
[0:46:44] and just appreciate him doing that.
[0:46:45] I wish there were a bit more people there,
[0:46:47] so I'm about 30, but it was pretty good.
[0:46:50] Thanks, Nathan.
[0:46:51] Anybody else?
[0:46:52] Travis, you're off this nothing tonight.
[0:46:55] Just as a reminder, again, last week,
[0:46:57] we talked about the announcement for the vacancy
[0:47:00] at the city council about application processes open
[0:47:03] at this point, and hopefully we continue to get applicants
[0:47:09] to participate in that process.
[0:47:12] That brings us to our final item of this evening,
[0:47:15] and that's an executive session.
[0:47:17] This is a request to adjourn to executive session
[0:47:20] Pursuant to Idaho Code 74-206-1B to consider the evaluation, dismissal or discipline of
[0:47:28] or to hear complaints or charges brought against a public officer, employee, staff member or
[0:47:33] individual agent, or public school student.
[0:47:37] So moved.
[0:47:38] Second.
[0:47:39] We have a motion and a second to adjourn into executive session pursuant to Idaho Code 74-206-1B.
[0:47:47] Any further discussion?
[0:47:48] Any roll call vote please.
[0:47:51] Ruth Pierce, yes.
[0:47:52] Chris Reed, yes.
[0:47:53] Greg Hawkins, yes.
[0:47:55] Jason Brown, yes.
[0:47:56] Jerry Bomer, yes.
[0:47:57] And Nathan Murray.
[0:47:58] Yes.
[0:47:59] OK.
[0:47:59] Motion carries 6 to 0.
[0:48:01] That is the conclusion of our meeting tonight.
[0:48:04] We will not be returning to the council chambers
[0:48:06] after the executive session.
[0:48:08] Thank you.
