Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2026-08-10, recording 1 (started 16:59)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2026-08-10/

[0:00:47] Okay, we'll go ahead and call the City Council meeting for August 10th, 2026 to order.
[0:00:54] I will confirm that we have a quorum.
[0:00:56] We have six members in person and Councilman Reed is online.
[0:01:02] We'll start out with the Pledge of Allegiance.
[0:01:04] Any of those that would like to follow along and participate, please stand.
[0:01:08] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
[0:01:23] Thank you, we'll as we have over the last several weeks if tonight in our public comment
[0:01:35] opportunity
[0:01:37] Please make sure that you sign up on the the sign-up sheet out front and
[0:01:43] And we'll go through that process as we get to that point in the meeting, but just
[0:01:47] again wanted to remind everybody that if you want to address the Council at night,
[0:01:51] we'll have you sign in.
[0:01:53] We'll move into our items of consideration, what are Council's wishes?
[0:01:57] Move to approve it.
[0:01:58] The consent calendar is written.
[0:02:00] Mr. Mayor, I'll second.
[0:02:02] Appreciate it.
[0:02:03] Had a motion to approve the consent calendar with a second.
[0:02:06] Sorry, I said items consideration, but I meant consent calendar, so thank you.
[0:02:11] further discussion. Rachel roll call vote please. Ruth Pierce, Craig Hawkins, Jason
[0:02:19] Brown, Kerry Bulmer, Grayson Stone, Nathan Murray, Chris Reed. Motion
[0:02:26] carries 7-0. Now we'll move into our consent calendar items. Our first
[0:02:32] presentation tonight is the presentation of Roadmaster certificates.
[0:02:37] Mark, you doing that tonight?
[0:02:40] Okay.
[0:02:42] Good evening, Mayor and Council.
[0:02:45] Thank you for allowing us the time to come for you tonight and recognize Will Fuller for his completion of the Road Scholar and Road Master Program and also Zach Kowsner for his completion of the Road Master Program.
[0:02:58] Tonight we have a representative from the local Highway Technical Assistance Council, Danny Rhodes.
[0:03:09] roads and he will kind of give a brief description of what it takes to complete
[0:03:14] the programs and present Will and Zach with their certificates so I'll turn it
[0:03:21] over to Chaney. Perfect, thanks Mark. Appreciate it. Thank you Mayor and
[0:03:24] and council members. I've been here before, you're new, it was changed a
[0:03:28] little bit and I see that a lot when I travel now. I'm also employees. A lot of
[0:03:34] times I there's everything's changing so much so thank you for allowing us to come
[0:03:38] and presents some awards to some of your employees.
[0:03:42] Road Scholar, for those of you that are not familiar
[0:03:44] with it, 80 hours of training and testing goes along
[0:03:48] with that so that in order for them to get that certificate,
[0:03:51] they have to have a passing grade of 80 or higher.
[0:03:53] So it assures that you guys are getting your dollars work
[0:03:57] and they're actually getting the knowledge
[0:03:59] that you're paying them to go get for you guys.
[0:04:02] Same with the Roadmaster.
[0:04:03] Roadmaster gets a little bit more technical though.
[0:04:06] A couple of our classes are two days long,
[0:04:08] still again, 80% or greater on your exams.
[0:04:12] And I mentioned last time, I think it's been
[0:04:14] a couple of years since I've been here,
[0:04:16] we were doing the leadership program.
[0:04:17] That started really taking off,
[0:04:19] and we've started giving out awards
[0:04:21] for the leadership program.
[0:04:22] Also, there's six classes on that one,
[0:04:24] which is transition to leadership,
[0:04:26] mastering management, leadership communication,
[0:04:29] organization of a local highway,
[0:04:31] leading across generations,
[0:04:33] and then team building and team communications.
[0:04:35] And what I've noticed as we're starting to teach these classes is it's not just your top leaders.
[0:04:41] It's your feet on the ground that are coming to these classes because everybody's so new.
[0:04:46] A lot of these younger feet on the ground are leaders sooner than we've ever seen before.
[0:04:51] And so it's nice to have them in.
[0:04:53] And what I'm seeing too is you get management and the feet on the ground in a time that they can talk
[0:04:59] and kind of figure out why leadership happens the way that it does instead of just assuming
[0:05:05] why they weren't told this happens,
[0:05:06] or why we're going this direction.
[0:05:09] It was nice to see those guys actually communicate
[0:05:12] and find out the why behind your guys' decisions
[0:05:15] and March decisions.
[0:05:17] So pretty cool.
[0:05:18] We've only had three finished the leadership.
[0:05:21] What we've done is in the past,
[0:05:24] we give the Rhodes Scholars get a hat
[0:05:27] and a Leatherman, Roadmasters get a coat.
[0:05:30] And then we were like, what do we do for the leadership?
[0:05:33] And every time I'm in a training, I look around,
[0:05:35] and everybody has their water cups.
[0:05:38] And so Stanley had a deal on cups,
[0:05:41] and we have an engraving company that works with us,
[0:05:44] and we're like, we should get Stanley cups,
[0:05:46] and we made sure that the bottoms of them
[0:05:48] will fit in the truck driver's cups,
[0:05:50] and also our form and structs too.
[0:05:51] So excited about that.
[0:05:54] Hopefully you guys will have some of your employees
[0:05:56] come to that.
[0:05:58] The other thing that I'm excited about
[0:06:00] is we started a WAC training.
[0:06:02] A lot of agencies came to us and said,
[0:06:05] we have our new employees out there working.
[0:06:07] And then when they go to get WAC certified,
[0:06:10] they're having issues.
[0:06:11] And so can you guys put a training together on that?
[0:06:14] So we did do it.
[0:06:15] We put one together, ran one in June.
[0:06:18] Our success rate, the asphalt two testing
[0:06:20] was a 50% failure on the written.
[0:06:23] We're up to 75% just in one training.
[0:06:26] We've got another one in September
[0:06:28] that will September 21st, three days in class,
[0:06:32] one day in the lab and then they'll have access to ACEC
[0:06:35] and go ahead and go to S.
[0:06:37] So pretty excited about that.
[0:06:39] And then as we evolve on that, we'll bring the other
[0:06:42] certifications in to LTCH to instruct that training
[0:06:46] on that end of it as well.
[0:06:47] So if there's no questions for you guys,
[0:06:50] I'll give the awards and any questions.
[0:06:53] And then when I'm done, if I can get a picture.
[0:06:55] Yeah, absolutely.
[0:06:56] Thank you so much.
[0:06:57] So first we have Will Fuller.
[0:07:04] And so I did to give you the part.
[0:07:06] So we'll complete both scholar.
[0:07:08] December 12th, 2020.
[0:07:12] Our rounds, it's so hard sometimes.
[0:07:15] As is me.
[0:07:19] Well, thank you, my man.
[0:07:26] In lieu of time, I'm going to keep him up here.
[0:07:28] First, go ahead and give him his Roadmaster.
[0:07:33] Will you have to wear this the rest of the summer?
[0:07:36] I'm sorry.
[0:07:37] I'm sorry.
[0:07:38] I need you to wait here.
[0:07:42] And then we have Zachary Housner.
[0:07:45] Zachary, same rules for you, man.
[0:07:46] All summer long you got to wear the coat and get a picture real quick again
[0:08:01] Thank you guys for allowing us to take some your time. Thank you want to go down there
[0:09:19] Okay, we'll move into our next item on the agenda
[0:09:28] Which is the swearing-in ceremony and we have chief Hicks. Hi everybody. It's been a while
[0:09:38] Members of council
[0:09:39] Thanks for allowing us to take some of your time tonight to recognize some of our newest
[0:09:43] officers as they start their journey and also to recognize some of our great employees for
[0:09:48] obtaining a career milestone.
[0:09:50] Our ceremony to swear our officers will consist of three parts, a brief introduction, a badge
[0:09:55] painting by a loved one, and then finally the formal oath of office administered by Mayor
[0:10:00] Brown.
[0:10:01] At this point, I would like to invite our three officers, Kyle Boas, Hatred Jones, and
[0:10:08] from the front please.
[0:10:22] Congratulations on graduating from the post academy two weeks ago, becoming a police officer as
[0:10:27] you know now is more than a badge.
[0:10:29] Today each of you is accepting a public trust.
[0:10:32] The trust that is earned every day and the way that you speak to people and the decisions
[0:10:37] that you make under pressure and the integrity you carry while no one is watching.
[0:10:42] You will quickly learn, if you haven't in the last week, that our profession is demanding.
[0:10:47] There will be long nights, difficult calls, and moments that will test your patients, judgment,
[0:10:52] and resilience.
[0:10:53] But there will be also moments when your presence changes someone's life for the better, sometimes
[0:10:58] in ways you may never fully realize.
[0:11:01] Never forget that people often meet you on the worst day of their lives.
[0:11:05] They may not remember every word that you say, but they will remember how you made them feel.
[0:11:11] Whether you treat them as a professionalism, respect, integrity, dignity, and excellence,
[0:11:17] You are now three all guardians of Twin Falls.
[0:11:20] Your training is prepared to enforce the law, but great officers also understand the importance
[0:11:24] of humility, empathy, and restraint.
[0:11:28] Strength in this profession is not measured only in courageous acts and dangerous instances,
[0:11:33] as for measured by character and everyday moments.
[0:11:37] I have a few at pavers to ask of each of you.
[0:11:40] They care of each other.
[0:11:41] The bond that you will build with your fellow officers will carry you through the most difficult
[0:11:45] days.
[0:11:46] Watch out for your partners, ask for help when you need it, and never mistake vulnerability
[0:11:50] for weakness.
[0:11:52] To their family members here today, thank you for sharing your loved ones with us.
[0:11:56] This career asks not only much of these officers, but you as well.
[0:12:01] Your support, your sacrifice and encouragement are part of what makes their service possible.
[0:12:07] As you raise your right hand today, remember this, this badge gives you authority, but your
[0:12:11] conduct earns respect.
[0:12:14] this uniform with pride, serve with honor, and never lose sight of why you chose this profession.
[0:12:19] I want to congratulate each one of you. Stay safe, stay grounded, and serve this community
[0:12:24] well. And Mr. Mayor, let me introduce these three men to you. First, Kyle Boas. He was
[0:12:31] hired by our department on February 23rd of this year. He was born in Redding, California,
[0:12:35] and he was raised in Ben, Oregon. Kyle graduated from Mountain View High School in 2006 and
[0:12:41] and eventually moved to Twin Falls in 2021.
[0:12:44] Kyle Kyle's employment with us,
[0:12:46] he worked for PepsiCo for 15 years,
[0:12:48] becoming part of their management and leadership team.
[0:12:51] Kyle also worked for PSI as a driver and supervisor,
[0:12:54] providing leadership and guidance to a team of 25.
[0:12:58] Kyle is passionate about serving this community
[0:13:00] as a law enforcement officer
[0:13:02] and promoting personal and professional integrity.
[0:13:05] This past life experiences have taught him
[0:13:07] that serving others is where he wants to focus his energy,
[0:13:10] finding fulfillment and making positive differences to the lives of those here in Twin Falls.
[0:13:16] And his girlfriend and I, Casey Graham, will be pinning his batch in just a moment.
[0:13:21] Next, I want to introduce you to Patrick Jones.
[0:13:24] He was hired by our department on March 9th.
[0:13:27] He was born and raised in Tulare, California.
[0:13:29] Prior to his employment, he was enlisted in the Marine Corps for five years.
[0:13:33] Patrick is also passionate about serving his community in this new role.
[0:13:37] Just like the military, he joined the Twin Falls Police Department to help people to the best
[0:13:41] of his ability.
[0:13:43] And his wife, Jersey Jones, will be printing his badge at him in a moment.
[0:13:47] And finally, Marad Selvaroff.
[0:13:50] He was hired by our department also on March 9th.
[0:13:54] He was raised in Twin Falls.
[0:13:55] He's lived here since he was one.
[0:13:57] He graduated from Canyon Ridge High School in 2021.
[0:14:01] Prior to his employment, he worked as a semi-truck dispatcher for his family business.
[0:14:06] reason he chose to become a police officer and work for our department was to build a
[0:14:09] better relationship with the community and be part of something bigger than himself.
[0:14:14] Rod wants to protect those who cannot protect themselves serving his community and making
[0:14:19] a positive impact on those random and pinning his badge on them that will be his sister,
[0:14:24] Louisa.
[0:14:25] So I would ask for all of the family members pinning their badges to please come forward
[0:14:28] at this time.
[0:15:23] I would now like to ask Mayor Brown to come down and please administer their oaths of office.
[0:15:28] Is this way after me I say your name
[0:15:49] Don't we swear?
[0:15:53] That I will support the Constitution
[0:15:57] And the Constitution and laws of the state of Idaho and and the laws and ordinances of the city of Twin Falls
[0:16:13] And the rules and regulations and falls police department that I will
[0:16:24] well and faithfully
[0:16:26] Discharge the duties of office duties of the office of
[0:16:33] I'll go that one again out my back discharge the duties of
[0:16:40] Office of police officer
[0:16:44] Windfall's Police Department
[0:16:47] Which I have and appointed and according to law
[0:16:55] And the best of my ability. Thanks guys
[0:16:59] Okay, that takes us to our next item and we have Chief again, the presentation of post-basic
[0:17:38] emergency communication certificates to Justice Larson, post-basic emergency communication
[0:17:45] certificate to Megan Park-Smith, and post-advanced emergency communication certificate to Emily
[0:17:53] Hill, post-advanced certificate to Martin Becerra, and post-master certificate to Jason Kelly.
[0:18:02] Thank you, Mayor, members of Council.
[0:18:05] Due to the events of last week, we have a couple of apps to assist tonight and due to
[0:18:08] schedules and maintaining the balance for that, a couple of people weren't able to make it
[0:18:11] tonight.
[0:18:12] We'll come to the Mac on a future agenda.
[0:18:14] But at this point, I'd like to ask Justice Larson and Emily Hilder, please come forward.
[0:18:30] Justice Larson was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department on May 5th of 2025 as an
[0:18:35] emergency communication officer. She was born in Twin Falls and graduated from the
[0:18:40] Idaho Virtual Academy in 2021. Justice is very passionate about doing well in her
[0:18:45] job and being a mom of a little boy who just turned one. Before joining TFPD, she
[0:18:50] worked for the mentally with mentally disabled adults for six years and she
[0:18:54] still has as many of her former clients to this day. She was always in
[0:18:58] of serving this community in client care and now as a dispatcher for the Twin Falls Police
[0:19:02] Department. They were honored to be able to award justice, her emergency communication
[0:19:09] officer certificate. I'm sorry, Mayor, I forgot to invite you down if you would like to join
[0:19:13] us also, sir. Am I coming down now? Next, we have Emily Hill, who was hired by the Twin
[0:19:24] Falls Police Department in October of 2013. During her tenure, she obtained a tactical dispatcher
[0:19:29] certificate, communications training certificate, and a basic and intermediate post-certificate.
[0:19:36] She returned from a dispatch conference in San Antonio where she met fellow dispatchers
[0:19:39] and attended many classes, learning tools that she will be sharing with Twin Falls dispatchers.
[0:19:44] Emily is often stated that dispatching is her true calling in life, and this is where
[0:19:48] she's meant to be.
[0:19:49] She thrives on busy times, being an involved fire, or a high-risk traffic stop.
[0:19:55] She takes a men's pride in her career.
[0:19:56] The greatest compliment you can give Emily, aside from how cute her cats are, is to tell
[0:20:03] her that she's doing a good job, or that you have complete trust in her abilities, which
[0:20:07] we do.
[0:20:08] Emily has been married for 17 years and is a proud cat mother.
[0:20:12] In her spare time, she enjoys spending time with family, reading, collecting many stray
[0:20:16] neighborhood cats, and taking solo trips in her white Bronco, named after one of her cats
[0:20:22] to buy overpriced coffee.
[0:20:24] We will be awarding Emily, the post-advanced
[0:20:27] emergency communication officer certificate.
[0:21:26] And finally tonight, I'd like to ask
[0:21:28] Copa Martin Becerra to come forward.
[0:21:36] Martin Becerra was born in California,
[0:21:38] moved to Idaho when he was still in high school.
[0:21:41] Martin attended the College of Southern Idaho
[0:21:43] and graduated from the law enforcement program
[0:21:45] in the summer of 2020, excuse me, 2014.
[0:21:51] Martin was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department
[0:21:53] in October of 2014 and has held various positions
[0:21:55] within this organization including patrol officer,
[0:21:58] Field Training Officer, School Resource Officer,
[0:22:01] and was promoted to the rank of Corporal in 2025.
[0:22:04] In his spare time, Martin is already spending time
[0:22:06] with his family and watching his kids play sports.
[0:22:09] Tonight, we have the privilege of awarding Martin
[0:22:11] the post-advanced certificate.
[0:22:50] Before we go into our next item,
[0:22:52] if family wants to leave or move on, we're okay with that.
[0:22:57] And we'll give you a minute or two.
[0:22:59] I know this is an opportunity to go out in the foyer
[0:23:01] and give congratulations.
[0:23:03] make pictures, big pictures, and all the other fun stuff.
[0:23:10] You're more than welcome to stay.
[0:23:23] This will be a good time and opportunity to, again,
[0:23:27] just remind everybody if they want to address the council
[0:23:29] tonight, please make sure you sign up in the foyer,
[0:23:35] and then we'll go through the process and procedure
[0:23:38] as we get closer to that point in the meeting,
[0:23:40] but again, just wanted to remind everybody
[0:23:43] that if we want to address the council, please sign up.
[0:23:47] Okay, we'll move, we'll move into our next item,
[0:23:50] which is the request to authorize $91,284 and 34 cents
[0:23:56] from Wastewater Reserve Funds for HVAC unit
[0:23:59] at the Wastewater Treatment Plant in E-Watering
[0:24:02] and Head Works Number Two Building,
[0:24:04] and we have Nathan Erickson.
[0:24:07] Thank you, Mayor, Council.
[0:24:08] I appreciate your time tonight.
[0:24:10] And I recognize we are getting towards the end
[0:24:13] of the fiscal year, but we do have some projects
[0:24:15] we want to finish up, and so that's why I'm here today
[0:24:18] To ask for this, the $91,000.
[0:24:21] At the treatment plant, we've been working
[0:24:24] on the dewatering building.
[0:24:26] It was completed in 2015.
[0:24:28] It's a very harsh environment, and I've talked about previously
[0:24:31] about the belt presses that we've been,
[0:24:33] we rebuilt one this year, next year we're
[0:24:34] going to rebuild two others.
[0:24:36] This year we're also hoping to get some work done
[0:24:38] on the HVAC unit on that building.
[0:24:41] And again, it's a very harsh conditions in there.
[0:24:45] It's a lot of humidity, a lot of HUS gases,
[0:24:47] and different things that have eaten away at the current HVAC unit that's not functioning
[0:24:52] completely.
[0:24:53] And so we have in our current budget just over $211,000 left.
[0:25:01] But the after going through informal bidding, the bid came out to $249,000.
[0:25:08] So we're a little short on what's left.
[0:25:10] And then we also just recently had another HVAC unit, a smaller one, luckily, in the head
[0:25:15] work's building that just went out and that's $13,000.
[0:25:19] So with those two additional money we need for the watering
[0:25:26] building HVAC and then the head work's HVAC,
[0:25:28] and then also a contingency just in case something is needed
[0:25:33] before the end of the fiscal year,
[0:25:36] we are requesting that $91,000, $24, and $34.
[0:25:41] And if there's any questions?
[0:25:43] Any questions for Nathan?
[0:25:47] I'm ready to make a motion if we're ready.
[0:25:50] Okay, go ahead.
[0:25:51] I move we approve authorizing $91,284.34
[0:25:57] from wastewater reserve funds for HVAC units at the
[0:26:00] WWTP in the dewatering and headworks number two buildings.
[0:26:05] Great.
[0:26:06] Well, thank you, Mr. Mayor.
[0:26:07] I second.
[0:26:08] I have a motion and a second to authorize the use of $91,284.34
[0:26:15] from wastewater reserve funds for HVAC unit
[0:26:18] at the wastewater treatment plant
[0:26:20] in the dewatering and headworks number two building.
[0:26:22] Is there any further discussion?
[0:26:25] Rachel, roll call, vote please.
[0:26:27] Craig Hawkins.
[0:26:28] Yes.
[0:26:29] Jason Brown.
[0:26:29] Yes.
[0:26:30] Sherry Volmer. Yes.
[0:26:31] Praysen Stone. Yes.
[0:26:32] Nathan Murray. Yes.
[0:26:33] Ruth Pierce. Yes.
[0:26:34] And Chris Reed.
[0:26:36] Yes.
[0:26:37] Motion carries seven to zero.
[0:26:39] Thank you, Nathan.
[0:26:42] That brings us to our last item of consideration
[0:26:46] for the evening, and that is the review of the fiscal year 27
[0:26:51] budget recap with the focus on council capital.
[0:26:54] You have Travis Rothweiler.
[0:26:58] Good evening, mayor and council.
[0:27:02] We're almost done.
[0:27:05] Just a few more meetings to go.
[0:27:06] So after tonight, you'll have two additional meetings,
[0:27:10] and really the purpose of tonight is to share
[0:27:14] with the members of the audience
[0:27:16] who are joining this conversation today
[0:27:22] and who have not had an opportunity
[0:27:23] to be a part of the conversations
[0:27:26] that we've carried for the balance of the summer.
[0:27:29] And then also to ask the members of the city council
[0:27:32] to vet the council capital list that has been developed
[0:27:39] since the first week in July.
[0:27:43] And we will continue through that conversation.
[0:27:47] So that next week, the conversation about the budget
[0:27:50] will be brief.
[0:27:52] It will have been our ninth consecutive meeting
[0:27:55] in which we talked about the budget next week.
[0:27:58] And we really want to provide a recap in anticipation
[0:28:02] and in advance of the public hearing that will occur
[0:28:05] on August 24th.
[0:28:12] As we have shared, we like to make sure
[0:28:15] that everyone is looking at our community
[0:28:17] through the same set of lenses.
[0:28:20] And part of that is to share the economic data
[0:28:26] as well as the state of the community
[0:28:31] when this budget was constructed.
[0:28:33] And so we have gone through and we have shared
[0:28:37] that the city of Flint Falls is a community
[0:28:41] that's much larger than our census population,
[0:28:44] that every single day our community will nearly double.
[0:28:49] And those are on days that there aren't special activities
[0:28:53] or special events that are occurring.
[0:28:56] Twin Falls remains the economic hub for the Magic Valley.
[0:29:00] It's a geographic area that contains about 275 to 280,000
[0:29:06] persons.
[0:29:07] And at some point in time, people either come directly
[0:29:12] to Twin Falls or they pass through Twin Falls and services are provided at their points of need.
[0:29:21] Housing is something that we've spent some time talking about how the median home value of a home
[0:29:28] in Twin Falls has increased by nearly 60% since the year 2020 and that employment continues to be
[0:29:38] something that we focus on, where our employment is at 3.6% in May. When we started the conversation,
[0:29:49] we confirmed that these were going to be the overarching strategies for this budget that
[0:29:56] we can never really anticipate on what is going to happen with the state of the economy,
[0:30:02] what is going to happen with our local economy, what is going to happen that is going to trigger
[0:30:08] or cause some level of unanticipated expenditure or event.
[0:30:15] And so we want to be nimble, and in building that, you see that on display, often on a regular basis as members of our team come forward.
[0:30:25] We want it to be stable.
[0:30:27] We believe that our budget is important to be stable, it is important to be predictable, so that our citizens have an understanding of what they can expect.
[0:30:37] in terms of cost and fees that are assessed by the City of Fundfalls in the
[0:30:44] transmitting of our services. And we want to be sustainable. And we use the City
[0:30:50] Strategic Plan to guide and help us determine the appropriate projects, the
[0:30:58] appropriate service levels, and matching that with what is truly stable, sustainable,
[0:31:08] We've talked about the importance of caring for employees as we strive to be the employer
[0:31:15] of choice.
[0:31:17] We talk about the importance of judiciously collecting rates and services as well as the
[0:31:27] care that we take with property taxes to make sure that those are transmitted, provide
[0:31:32] the full services that we collect.
[0:31:38] We've shared many times that this is only an illustration, but if we could ever find that
[0:31:45] median person, that person who lives in the median home that consumes the median amount
[0:31:53] of water transmits, the median amount of sewer and lives in the city and partakes in city sanitation
[0:32:01] and recycling program, year over year they can expect about a 28 cent decrease in this
[0:32:09] budget. And while that 28 percent increase does not seem significant, it needs to be taken
[0:32:19] in light of how the costs inflation continue to rise. And so the fact that the team can
[0:32:26] come together that can find innovative practices to be able to hold the budget flat, I think,
[0:32:33] is commendable.
[0:32:37] We spent a lot of time going over the economic indicators.
[0:32:40] We've talked about housing, we've talked about costs growing, and we've talked about the importance
[0:32:47] of employment where for every 100 job openings there's only 97 qualified applicants.
[0:32:56] we've talked about how the actual labor market size
[0:33:01] inside the City of Twin Falls has shrunk,
[0:33:04] at least it had in May, in comparison to the prior year.
[0:33:13] This budget is guided by an entire series
[0:33:17] of Idaho code sections.
[0:33:20] As a Dillon Rule State, we receive direct instruction
[0:33:27] from the state legislature through Idaho codes
[0:33:30] on the processes that we need to minimally follow
[0:33:35] as it follows in the budget.
[0:33:37] I will share that this is one of the few entities
[0:33:39] that has the number of public conversations
[0:33:42] that we have regarding the budget.
[0:33:46] And when you get through that process
[0:33:50] from the first conversations that we had in April
[0:33:52] till the end of August,
[0:33:54] we will have had 13 public conversations about the budget.
[0:34:01] We engage our citizens.
[0:34:03] Part of the value of the citizen survey is it is a report card
[0:34:08] at a particular point in time in asking our citizens
[0:34:12] how we are doing, how safe do they feel,
[0:34:15] what are the quality of our roadways,
[0:34:17] what are the quality of our services and our amenities,
[0:34:21] and we use that to help gauge our performance.
[0:34:26] And then we ask ourselves, what can we do to sustain the quality ratings that we have received?
[0:34:34] And what can we be doing different in service delivery to better meet the expectations of
[0:34:40] our community?
[0:34:43] We examine economic indicators, some of those that we shared with you through this process
[0:34:48] and several others that Brianna Howard, our chief financial officer, will share with you
[0:34:54] during her quarterly finance updates.
[0:34:59] We build this budget through a team process.
[0:35:02] That team begins budgeting in December
[0:35:06] where a collection of employees across the organization
[0:35:09] come together and they talk about the highest needs
[0:35:12] and they help form the budget.
[0:35:15] We believe that individuals need to make the decisions
[0:35:18] where the information lies.
[0:35:20] And those who are using the tools,
[0:35:22] using the equipment on a day to day basis and the performance of their duties have far better
[0:35:27] information than I do. And then we create a funding solution through a series of internal
[0:35:34] budget hearings. We balance the budget collectively and then we bind it all together and present
[0:35:41] all 278 glorious pages or whatever it is this year for your full review. And the city has
[0:35:52] been recognized by several professional organizations for our process and our documents.
[0:35:59] And we don't follow the process for the sake of hanging awards on a mantle.
[0:36:07] We do it because it's the best practice.
[0:36:09] We believe that it enhances transparency and that we believe that the citizens shouldn't
[0:36:16] have to read a whole series of complex spreadsheets and be left with more
[0:36:23] questions than when they started. So that's why our budget is a combination of
[0:36:28] words, it's a combination of charts and graphs, and yes, all of the numbers are
[0:36:34] there. And if someone really is into spreadsheets like I know some of you are,
[0:36:39] we can easily provide those for you at a moment's notice. So this is a
[0:36:48] a reflection of the city's budget for this year that's proposed. It is the preliminary
[0:36:55] budget because last week you set the maximum spending cap. It is no longer the recommended
[0:37:02] budget. And based upon that, in comparison to the adopted budget, you can see the changes
[0:37:09] in tax-supported funding, non-tax-supported funding, in particular the enterprise funds,
[0:37:16] as well as the impact to the tax rate.
[0:37:21] To understand how this applies
[0:37:24] or how this budget will impact each individual,
[0:37:28] they can take that tax rate and they can multiply that
[0:37:33] by the assessment that they have already received
[0:37:37] from our county assessor.
[0:37:41] The growth of the city of Twin Falls
[0:37:42] has been nothing short but impressive.
[0:37:45] If you take a look at 21, the city's total taxable value was $3.4 billion.
[0:37:56] And this year, it's nearly double that at $6.78 to $2 billion.
[0:38:04] But what's not included in that is $717 million of value of property that is inside of urban
[0:38:12] renewal agencies for the purpose of continuing to grow our local economy.
[0:38:18] And if you take both of those, the total value of properties inside of the city of Twin Falls
[0:38:23] as corporate boundaries exceed $7.5 billion.
[0:38:31] This is an anticipation of the tax rate and how the tax rate has changed over a period
[0:38:36] of time.
[0:38:38] And then one of the questions as we like to share, how does my city taxes compare to others?
[0:38:46] We are the green bar, while competing and compared to sea to these full-service cities
[0:38:52] are illustrated in blue.
[0:38:55] We have shared that we have intentionally omitted three cities, Boise, Meridian, and
[0:39:02] Nampa, because at some part of their service delivery, they are not full-service.
[0:39:08] Two of them do not do roads, and one of them no longer operates their own fire department.
[0:39:16] I said that we built everything through the City's strategic planning effort.
[0:39:21] These are the eight primary focus areas and we are excited later this fall to show you
[0:39:27] the final version for final draft version for your adoption of the 2040 strategic plan
[0:39:34] that also has a series of performance measures and metrics attached to it to be able to further
[0:39:42] examine our performance in the completion of those goals and tasks that are spelled out.
[0:39:51] So when you take a look at the total budget, there are really two very distinct points.
[0:39:57] One of the government funds or a portion where a portion of their resources is derived from
[0:40:04] property tax dollars.
[0:40:07] Then in the blue are enterprise funds.
[0:40:09] Those are our independent business units like water, sewer, and sanitation.
[0:40:16] Those individual business units assess a fee for service and those funds stay intact for
[0:40:23] the operations of those departments.
[0:40:28] We have shared throughout that the services that we deliver are delivered by quality individuals,
[0:40:36] of our own organization, and in a very large sense, we are a service-driven entity, and so
[0:40:44] it makes sense that 44.5% of our total cost of the budget across all funds would be associated
[0:40:51] with personnel costs.
[0:40:53] Capital and operation maintenance equal 23.3%.
[0:40:57] We have very little debt service.
[0:40:59] The only debt that we have is a note inside of the waste water fund as a result of the 2014
[0:41:08] expansion and then transfers.
[0:41:11] Transfers are simple rents that are paid from the enterprise funds to the tax-supported funds
[0:41:17] for professional support.
[0:41:21] You can see that we collect in the tax-supported funds 55% of that is used to fund tax-supported
[0:41:30] operations and total property tax collections are about 31, 32 percent of the total budget.
[0:41:46] If you were to add up the cost of police, fire, streets, and prosecutorial services, those
[0:41:58] four departments cost more to operate than total property tax collections brought in
[0:42:10] by the city.
[0:42:16] And then when we break down the enterprise funds, you can see that 46% of the enterprise
[0:42:22] funds are supported to support water.
[0:42:25] Nearly 38% are for wastewater and 13% is for sanitation.
[0:42:32] the non-measure enterprise funds include things like Derkey's Lake.
[0:42:39] So this is the part where we have built that list and you'll notice some intentional blanks.
[0:42:47] So we have included all of the items that were shared and we included dollar assignments that
[0:42:56] we had and we have some information, some additional information to share with you.
[0:43:03] like, maybe should have plugged it in, but as we kind of move forward, there's some, some
[0:43:09] information to go. So I guess, yep.
[0:43:14] My recommendation was not improvements to the skate park, but actually the arts commission.
[0:43:20] Yep. So that's incorrect.
[0:43:22] Yep. So yes, you're right. Yes. So Councilwoman Pierce did say for the, for the arts, these
[0:43:29] These are the, and we can make that adjustment.
[0:43:31] These are the four areas that are left.
[0:43:35] A citizen came forward and shared about adding umbrella shades that we're doing at another
[0:43:43] park in both city park and the downtown commons.
[0:43:46] Another citizen came forward for the improvements to the skate park.
[0:43:54] when Pierce did talk about making a allocation to the heart's commission and it says and
[0:44:03] also approached for the meals on wheels program. We've received some additional information.
[0:44:12] I have your seats in front of you, maybe you could case. So over the course and I know Wendy's
[0:44:23] here and I'm going to look at Councilman Hawkins as it comes to Councilwoman's Pierce suggestion
[0:44:30] for additional seed monies that go into and fund
[0:44:34] and support of the Arts Council.
[0:44:38] So just backing up, the amount that is funding used
[0:44:44] to fund arts is directed by a resolution.
[0:44:50] That resolution says it will be 0.05% of the capital fund
[0:45:01] of the tax-supported items, so it excludes any improvements to water, any improvements
[0:45:06] to sewer, and when you go forward with that calculation when we are conferring this morning,
[0:45:13] we believe it's between $2,700 annually that goes into that fund.
[0:45:20] It is reserved for a specific purpose.
[0:45:24] The Arts Council has been having a conversation about how to move and adjust that resolution.
[0:45:31] And in conversations earlier today, part of their move would have increased the allocation
[0:45:40] in the capital fund to nearly $60,000.
[0:45:48] The purpose of how we would move forward with the Council directed capital, the first would
[0:45:55] be to incorporate monies as one time into the Art Council's fund and in subsequent meetings
[0:46:07] prior to the establishment of next year's budget, we will come forward to adjust the resolution
[0:46:15] to be equal or greater or less than at the Council's direction with input from the Arts
[0:46:21] Commission as to what percentage of that ongoing funding would be. I understand that
[0:46:28] the Arts Commission today is working through a series of processes to understand
[0:46:33] what is the true cost of maintaining the city's art collection and the art is
[0:46:40] defined by any piece of art that is in any public place or on any public right
[0:46:46] of way it is owned by the city and we have a duty to maintain.
[0:46:52] Currently I believe that 75% of the money is used for maintenance of the pieces and 25%
[0:47:03] goes to new projects and so you can see that there is a resolution that needs updating
[0:47:09] and seed money would be appropriate again that a request when they were playing with
[0:47:14] the numbers I understand amounted to nearly $60,000 based upon this year's capital budget.
[0:47:25] The next request was for meals on wheels and this one becomes a little bit more complicated
[0:47:39] in that Idaho is a deal and rule state like I shared.
[0:47:46] And the city has the ability to engage in partnerships with other individuals.
[0:47:57] Our city attorney, and when we consulted him,
[0:48:02] chaired that the city cannot simply donate funds to a charity.
[0:48:07] that the city would have to enter into a contractual agreement with very specific conditions and performance metrics spelled out
[0:48:21] prior to
[0:48:24] Making an allocation
[0:48:26] The council does have the ability to reserve funds for that purpose and staff can bring that
[0:48:34] contract out
[0:48:35] the total request from the senior citizen center as I understand it for the balance of this fiscal year and
[0:48:45] all of fiscal year
[0:48:48] 27 is
[0:48:50] 100,000 eight hundred dollars
[0:48:53] that excludes
[0:48:56] 26 thousand dollars in staff
[0:49:00] the
[0:49:15] umbrella shades are
[0:49:17] If that is something that the city council wants to move forward
[0:49:25] My suggestion is that the city staff spends more time
[0:49:32] The request is going to have and need to have some level of engineering associated with it
[0:49:39] The pump system or the fountain is in the basement below the stage of the restrooms
[0:49:50] And the last thing that we want to do is inadvertently get one of those lines with large anchor bolts in that process.
[0:50:02] I also believe that it would be important to have conversations with the regular users of the downtown commons
[0:50:11] so that our design that we move forward with does not hinder or significantly modify any
[0:50:22] of their events or any of the things that they do.
[0:50:30] And so just as the Council has directed from the Dias in past years, you can very easily
[0:50:39] share with us, please include this in fiscal year 28 for consideration, which means that
[0:50:48] at some point at the beginning of fiscal year 27, we will ask for a portion of contingency
[0:50:54] or cash reserves to go through an engineering and design project, or we can have that first
[0:51:01] phase included in 28, but I really do believe that that is a project that really should
[0:51:09] be much more inclusive and we should utilize our community engagement tools to
[0:51:17] order that. I think it's a great suggestion if you've had an opportunity to
[0:51:24] participate in any of those events it is it gets hot. One of the things that we
[0:51:33] want to be cognizant of is the placement needs to provide appropriate balance of
[0:51:39] shade, but we also like to celebrate Christmas with the lighting of a Christmas tree and bringing
[0:51:49] in a tree with a large canopy needs to be something that we consider again so that one
[0:51:58] really good intended project doesn't significantly change other quality events inside of our community.
[0:52:08] then improvements to skate parks.
[0:52:11] I know that Wendy is here,
[0:52:14] and we have outplayed a comprehensive plan to you
[0:52:18] in the past for Harmon Park.
[0:52:22] Part of that appears on your list of projects this year
[0:52:26] to replace the playground and make site improvements
[0:52:29] for 356,000.
[0:52:32] As chance shared with you during our inspection,
[0:52:35] we found significant portions of that play structure
[0:52:38] beyond safe and they've had to be dismantled and so we have included that in
[0:52:43] this upcoming project list for your consideration. Any questions on the
[0:52:56] projects that I went through or any of the other projects that are before I
[0:53:04] jump in with my questions council questions for Travis to Travis maybe you
[0:53:11] or Wendy, are you in a spot to talk about the skate park?
[0:53:16] I know the young gentleman came up to you last week,
[0:53:19] or maybe it was the week before, I'm sorry,
[0:53:22] the weeks are running together a little bit right now.
[0:53:25] Did you have an opportunity to speak with him
[0:53:27] about what they were looking for?
[0:53:29] You might kind of fill in the sand a little bit
[0:53:31] on what that may be.
[0:53:38] Cause I do know we have talked about it.
[0:53:40] I know it's part of the,
[0:53:42] or a little bit bigger plan of what's going on there,
[0:53:44] but just wanted to understand what they were looking for.
[0:53:48] I don't think he was aware of the status of that project.
[0:53:54] And so he had told me he was trying to build something
[0:53:57] in Kimberly, and I was trying to explain to him
[0:54:00] that I had met with the Community Foundation to,
[0:54:06] and they're super excited to talk to the skate community.
[0:54:09] And so I think we're to a place with that project
[0:54:12] that literally we've got, I want to say four projects
[0:54:19] that are fully designed that can be done out there.
[0:54:23] And they can be done in any order.
[0:54:25] We're doing the lights and then there's a parking lot piece
[0:54:28] and then there's a pump track
[0:54:29] and then there's an expansion of the skate park
[0:54:32] and then I think there's an all wheels park.
[0:54:34] And so there's a couple of different pieces
[0:54:36] that would go along with that.
[0:54:37] That could be, we could raise funds for and do it
[0:54:41] any time or we can start chipping away at them.
[0:54:44] I think the total project is about $3 million.
[0:54:47] He, I gave him some focus on, and I've been reaching out
[0:54:54] to the escape community that we have been,
[0:54:59] we just go out there and talk to him.
[0:55:00] And they're not as organized as they have been
[0:55:03] in the past sometimes, but there's factions, right?
[0:55:05] And they all have an interest.
[0:55:07] and I need to find one or two that are ready to step up
[0:55:12] and go meet with the community foundation
[0:55:16] and start talking about what it would look like
[0:55:18] to do some fundraising.
[0:55:20] And I tried to channel him in that direction.
[0:55:24] He wasn't aware of the work we'd done.
[0:55:27] And they invited him to come over.
[0:55:29] I gave him my card.
[0:55:30] I told him to come and talk to me
[0:55:31] and I could show him the designs that we have so far.
[0:55:34] Okay, and that I think that's all I was really looking for
[0:55:37] is making sure that those end roads were met
[0:55:41] and that we could interject some of what they're looking for
[0:55:44] in that particular project.
[0:55:45] But I think-
[0:55:46] Can you tell me you wanted to build a new one?
[0:55:48] Yeah.
[0:55:49] I said, well, no, I don't know if that's the direction
[0:55:51] we're going right now, but we can certainly add on
[0:55:53] and improve the one we've got.
[0:55:54] Sure, and I think for me, a lot of it is just making sure
[0:55:58] they're a part of the process as we look at projects.
[0:56:02] But it sounds like, I guess what I've taken from that
[0:56:04] a little bit is a little bit more communication
[0:56:06] with the skate community and making sure
[0:56:09] that we can get them involved in that process.
[0:56:12] So before we go out and invest in the skate park,
[0:56:15] it's what that part of the community would use.
[0:56:19] It's what I'm kind of picking up from that.
[0:56:21] Well, and we did that.
[0:56:22] So we had multiple meetings on site with them,
[0:56:27] gathered their input and then the designs reflect
[0:56:32] that input that we got from them.
[0:56:34] Okay, thank you, Wendy.
[0:56:35] Appreciate it.
[0:56:38] Sherry Vomer.
[0:56:40] On the shades for the park or for the parks.
[0:56:46] It's really not a question to be answered tonight,
[0:56:48] but just wondering if when it comes time to look at those,
[0:56:53] one, I think the city park, the new plan for the city park
[0:56:57] included some shades.
[0:56:58] It did not, okay, it was trees.
[0:57:00] I think that we're in there or something.
[0:57:03] Go ahead.
[0:57:04] I don't, so what he wants is shade in front of the band shell.
[0:57:11] So there's the big concrete pad where the benches are, that's the hot spot in that park
[0:57:17] and that's where everybody thinks we need to try to put shade.
[0:57:23] The work at City Park may include some structures and things, but they're not in front of the
[0:57:29] a band shell so that if you're on the stage playing to the crowd and the crowds all back
[0:57:33] in the trees or the shade, you've got a big open space in front of you. That's what, right?
[0:57:40] That's what I think he's looking for.
[0:57:42] Okay, well that makes sense on there. And so then I guess if it comes to the point of engaging
[0:57:50] engineering and seeing for the commons or any other place, is there an option for some
[0:57:57] kind of temporary, I mean, you know, a commercial temporary structure on that, and that's probably,
[0:58:04] that's not an answer I need tonight for that, but, but try something like that.
[0:58:08] We tried some temporary at the downtown commons and they weren't secure enough. They would
[0:58:13] blow over, I'm trying to remember, and I'm sorry, I'm not really trying to call you out,
[0:58:18] but I think we also looked at trying to put some bolts on the building and run them somewhere.
[0:58:22] Maybe Nate.
[0:58:23] Yeah.
[0:58:24] Yeah, I run the urban way to see what nobody was doing.
[0:58:34] As a temporary solution, while we were looking into engineering-wise to do some larger canopies,
[0:58:42] we got some temporary shade and the wind was too strong for those things.
[0:58:48] Okay, that makes complete sense.
[0:58:51] but I think I recall it, nothing was,
[0:58:55] anything of quality was not cheap.
[0:58:58] Yeah, I get expensive.
[0:59:01] Where I envisioned some of those shades,
[0:59:05] permanent shades would be probably over
[0:59:07] some of the playground structures,
[0:59:08] maybe at some of the various parks.
[0:59:11] Thank you.
[0:59:12] Nathan, do you have something more to add to that?
[0:59:15] No.
[0:59:17] I was gonna bring up a different subject.
[0:59:19] Ruth, do you have something?
[0:59:21] Okay.
[0:59:22] Those temporary or those shades would definitely not hold snow loads.
[0:59:29] So that's one of the things that you see with some of these permanent structures unless
[0:59:34] they're super permanent.
[0:59:36] And that's very spandy.
[0:59:39] Yeah, one of the things that we would want to make sure is that it is going to be able
[0:59:45] to handle not only snow loads that we really hope that we're going to get, so all of those
[0:59:53] people of faith be praying for a recap of, or, you know, I'll take 2017 again, 2017 again.
[1:00:07] Being in Montana, and I will tell you that's one of the few times I've actually seen it
[1:00:10] It's snow here in Idaho, but it not only needs to be able to handle the weather and have
[1:00:18] it be durable, but the structure also needs to be safe so that individuals can occupy that
[1:00:28] without concern.
[1:00:30] So there are a whole series of standards that we would need to move forward and engineer.
[1:00:33] I think, again, it's a great idea.
[1:00:37] We would need to do some significant engineering work.
[1:00:42] And again, like I shared, you can include that.
[1:00:46] We don't have a number.
[1:00:49] And my recommendation, if that is a project that we can bring forward to you early in fiscal
[1:00:58] year 27 with anticipation of finding the resources or at least presenting the cost of the Council
[1:01:07] for consideration in fiscal year 28 okay Nathan I think we're ready to unless
[1:01:15] anybody else has something on that line just gonna ask about meals on wheels you
[1:01:21] said $100,800 correct that's two years yeah for the meals yeah for the remainder
[1:01:32] of the 2026 and so the remainder of 2026 calendar year for this it's blended
[1:01:39] because it is based upon calendar years or in fiscal years.
[1:01:45] So part of our allocation would go into fiscal year 28.
[1:01:52] Okay. So for the balance of calendar year 26,
[1:01:57] which would bisect fiscal year 26 and 27,
[1:02:02] the request is for $25,920.
[1:02:09] or calendar year 27, which would include both fiscal years 27 and 28, is $74,880.
[1:02:23] And then to return full staffing to the center, or fiscal year, the note, it is for $26,000.
[1:02:34] That's my understanding is the request to not include the staffing by conference with Veterans.
[1:02:41] So it was only for the two items of 25,920, 74,000, 80,000.
[1:02:48] So we cannot gift this to nonprofits such as them.
[1:02:56] According to contracts.
[1:02:58] So I'm trying to think, is there any kind of, I can't think of an exchange for service that we might already do the building.
[1:03:06] And we already own the building and we lease the building for a dollar annually.
[1:03:20] If this is something that the council would like staff to work on outside of the budget
[1:03:26] process, we are happy to explore that.
[1:03:31] I think it's important to recognize that while you have the 800, we budget for the entirety
[1:03:39] of the 880, and the entire piece of that from a staff perspective is we'd like to then categorize
[1:03:49] that and put that in.
[1:03:53] Part of that that is unused could remain under Council Capital simply being unallocated,
[1:04:00] and we could come back with contracts if that's what you would like.
[1:04:07] could also move that into contingency could approach the council to use those contingency
[1:04:16] dollars that are unallocated. So either way, we would come back to the city council.
[1:04:20] But I guess maybe my question is, do we need to exchange something in that contract, or
[1:04:28] is it, we just have a recording.
[1:04:31] According to Bruce, what we would be doing is we would essentially have them become a contractor
[1:04:37] for the city to carry out tasks that the city finds. It has a responsibility to provide to
[1:04:45] the public. And the key to that is the responsibility to provide to the public, because the next
[1:04:55] is to that is Title 50, Chapter 3, that describes the municipal powers and the things that the
[1:05:03] city can conduct business in a way by direction of the state legislature.
[1:05:16] Thank you.
[1:05:18] Ruth?
[1:05:19] Is there a concern that if we were to fund the 25,000 for this fiscal year that we're
[1:05:26] committing future councils to something we can't technically do?
[1:05:36] So when you have a contract for service, that contract for service would carry over.
[1:05:44] This council is still the council that would be intact at the creation of the 28 budget.
[1:05:52] That question gets a little bit more difficult if there were an election in between our two
[1:06:01] fiscal years, but in this case there's not.
[1:06:03] Okay, thank you.
[1:06:05] I saw your name and popped off or do you have a comment on anything?
[1:06:09] Thank you Mr. Mayor.
[1:06:10] No.
[1:06:11] I'm getting my question.
[1:06:12] I got the answer.
[1:06:17] Thank you.
[1:06:18] Okay.
[1:06:19] So Travis, again, would you mind going over the Art Council portion again just so I need
[1:06:28] to write my numbers down again and see what that commitment was?
[1:06:32] Yes.
[1:06:33] So
[1:06:36] Back yeah back
[1:06:40] Before I got here, so we're talking pre 2008
[1:06:48] The city council at that time passed a resolution in which it
[1:06:54] Committed a portion of the general fund capital
[1:07:00] to go to
[1:07:02] public art and
[1:07:04] And at the time the resolution was created, it was 0.05%.
[1:07:11] And when you take a look at the budgets that we approve
[1:07:15] just in that supported or in those line items,
[1:07:20] it's somewhere between $2,700 and $3,000 annually.
[1:07:25] The resolution further spells out that 75% of that
[1:07:29] should be used for the maintenance of existing art,
[1:07:31] 25% can be placed into future projects.
[1:07:38] Windy just passed me a note, and there's about $60,000
[1:07:42] currently in the fund.
[1:07:45] When I had a conversation with Mitch earlier about the
[1:07:49] percentages that they were moving forward with, there
[1:07:54] were that amount increased.
[1:07:56] So let's just run up $3,000 to $60,000.
[1:08:02] And the purpose that what we would do tonight
[1:08:07] is that the amount that you allocate
[1:08:11] would be either a flat amount that we would include
[1:08:15] in a future resolution for the council
[1:08:17] to amend for ongoing subsequent years
[1:08:20] to provide instruction to the staff
[1:08:22] on how much we should set aside.
[1:08:25] Or it could be a percentage.
[1:08:28] Neither of those items need to be decided tonight,
[1:08:31] but my approach to this would be to keep the 880 intact
[1:08:37] for the future.
[1:08:39] We, or 820, we would look at this as a one-time funding
[1:08:48] that we would use as the basis in helping us
[1:08:51] create the resolution moving forward.
[1:08:55] And I know that members of the Arts Commission
[1:08:58] would wanna be active participants in that conversation.
[1:09:01] So to be clear, not come up with a number tonight
[1:09:06] for the seed money that I was proposing.
[1:09:10] You could, absolutely.
[1:09:13] But we don't really know what that is.
[1:09:15] We think it's 60.
[1:09:18] I think it really becomes a discussion of the council
[1:09:22] because even if you were presented with a resolution,
[1:09:25] you would have to make a decision
[1:09:27] if that is the appropriate number.
[1:09:29] I think it is appropriate for the city council
[1:09:31] to say this year we're planning on doing X
[1:09:34] and in subsequent years, we would like to have
[1:09:38] that conversation and look at other things as well.
[1:09:43] So again, is that number 60 or, I'm a little confused
[1:09:48] because we have 60 right now.
[1:09:50] You have 60 right now.
[1:09:51] But it's made up of all the 3,000s
[1:09:53] that have come in for the last little while.
[1:09:55] So it's not seed money, it's maintenance.
[1:09:58] In the bank, in the bank right now,
[1:10:01] and then you have $99,000 that is unallocated
[1:10:06] and some portion of that money could be added
[1:10:09] to the $60,000 that we have in the bank.
[1:10:13] Okay, thank you.
[1:10:17] You can also not make that decision tonight
[1:10:21] and we could come back and approach
[1:10:24] by keeping the 99,000 in tech and you could say
[1:10:27] that list that we have right now is exactly what we want to do.
[1:10:31] we want to retain the balance and use that for future consideration because the entirety
[1:10:37] of the 820 has been budgeted and accounted for in all of the numbers that we've shared
[1:10:44] with you.
[1:10:45] Thank you.
[1:10:46] Okay, Ruth, I still see your name up here.
[1:10:48] Yes, so I'm actually prepared to make a motion unless anybody else has a question.
[1:10:52] Any further discussion?
[1:10:55] Okay, go ahead, Ruth.
[1:10:56] I would move we accept the council directed projects
[1:11:00] for fiscal year 2027 at a total of 721,000
[1:11:06] of the 820,000 allowed and reserve the difference
[1:11:12] for potential future decisions.
[1:11:16] Okay, do I have a second?
[1:11:17] Sherry Gohmer?
[1:11:19] I'll second that one.
[1:11:21] Okay, I had a motion to accept the $721,000 project
[1:11:26] as displayed and then hold the remaining the difference in reserves for future
[1:11:34] conversation is that correct Ruth yes okay motion in a second on that item is
[1:11:40] there any further discussions with the council grace and stone thank you
[1:11:43] Mr. Mayor Travis what's the process to access those funds should we come up the
[1:11:47] project because I perceive somebody coming up with some kind of idea to do a
[1:11:52] a memorial for all the horrific incidents that were here lately?
[1:11:56] Yeah, so the first step is to move forward with the Arts Council.
[1:12:01] They will go through and they will determine the art piece in alignment with the appropriate
[1:12:12] codes that we have, whether it be a zoning code, if it's close to a significant roadway.
[1:12:20] types of impacts that we'll have. We also need to make sure that any monument or piece
[1:12:28] of art that is created fits within the confines of government's speech. And so there is a
[1:12:36] process. It starts with our arts council. They do that lift for the members of the city
[1:12:43] council. And then the city council has the opportunity to weigh in. Councilman Hawkins,
[1:12:49] I believe is the liaison for the Council to the Arts Commission, but it is a very much
[1:12:55] collaborative process with final authority coming to the City Council for proposals.
[1:13:01] I meant specifically for accessing the funds.
[1:13:04] Again, they just make a request.
[1:13:07] They use a metacash reserves very similar to what Nathan did earlier this evening for
[1:13:12] the HVAC system.
[1:13:13] That's what I thought.
[1:13:14] Thank you.
[1:13:15] Any further discussions?
[1:13:16] Again, the motion is to approve the $721,000 of projects that are presented and reserve the
[1:13:26] remaining balance for future projects.
[1:13:32] Rachel Roll call vote on that.
[1:13:38] Ruth Pierce.
[1:13:39] Yes.
[1:13:40] Craig Hawkins.
[1:13:41] Yes.
[1:13:42] Jason Brown.
[1:13:43] Yes.
[1:13:44] Sherry Wilmer.
[1:13:45] Yes.
[1:13:46] Grayson Stone.
[1:13:47] Yes.
[1:13:48] Nathan Murray.
[1:13:49] Yes.
[1:13:50] And Chris Reed.
[1:13:51] Yes.
[1:13:52] also just to carry on the motion, it is my understanding, and this is more of an add-not.
[1:14:03] You would like for staff to work with the Arts Council and to bring forward a possible resolution
[1:14:14] modifying the percentage for your consideration in anticipation of funding to be received in
[1:14:22] fiscal year 27.
[1:14:24] Does it mean it has to be done on October 1st, but it should probably be done earlier in
[1:14:30] that process.
[1:14:31] Okay.
[1:14:32] Second, I believe that there was interest in exploring shade structures and we will move
[1:14:40] forward with using our engineered list to determine who has the appropriate qualifications
[1:14:51] design such structures, we will solicit proposals and then we will bring them back for your consideration.
[1:14:58] As we move forward with those, we will have to come to the council.
[1:15:04] We can access potentially some of those funds or we may be using cash reserves or contingency
[1:15:11] or a combination thereof to move forward with the engineering.
[1:15:17] I understood in fiscal year 27 with possible consideration for funding in fiscal year 28.
[1:15:24] Yes.
[1:15:26] Thank you.
[1:15:33] Just two more weeks.
[1:15:34] Sounds good to me.
[1:15:36] So again, this is an opportunity.
[1:15:38] Now we're in that opportunity for the general public to provide input.
[1:15:42] I will.
[1:15:43] One more time.
[1:15:44] We have the list right down here.
[1:15:46] So if there's anybody else that would like to address the council tonight that has not
[1:15:51] signed up before we go into the general public input process, please come down and put your
[1:15:57] name on the list just so we capture everybody or give them the opportunity.
[1:16:10] Okay, and I'll outline the process as we have the last several weeks.
[1:16:16] Each individual will be allotted two minutes to address the council of the items that
[1:16:23] pertaining to city business, we will at that point ask you to state your name, whether
[1:16:31] you're a resident, and then also we'll limit tonight, we'll limit the public comment period
[1:16:37] to 60 minutes if it goes that long. So Rachel, who is the first individual tonight?
[1:16:46] Maria Hernandez. So again, Maria two minutes and that'll start when you start addressing
[1:16:54] the council. My name is Maria Hernandez. I was born and raised here. I would like to
[1:17:46] thank Chief Hicks and Chief Brooks for standing ten toes down in the face of
[1:17:51] adversity on August 1st. And for the agencies that stepped up, I can't imagine
[1:17:56] how battle fatigue you guys are and your men and women are. Thank you, Chief Hicks
[1:18:03] and Chief Brooks for demonstrating that we are Twin Falls strong. One day at a
[1:18:08] time, Chief's, one day at a time, we are Twin Falls strong. We are Twin Falls strong.
[1:18:29] We are Twin Falls strong. We will overcome brighter days, brighter days. We are Twin
[1:18:41] Falls strong. We are Twin Falls strong. We are Twin Falls strong. We are Twin
[1:18:46] We are strong, we will overcome
[1:18:50] Friday days
[1:18:52] Friday days
[1:18:56] You will overcome
[1:19:00] We will overcome
[1:19:03] We are strong
[1:19:05] We are resilient
[1:19:09] We are together
[1:19:11] We are one
[1:19:13] We are courageous
[1:19:15] We are brave
[1:19:18] We comfort one another
[1:19:21] We rejoice with others
[1:19:23] And we cry with others
[1:19:25] You guys deserve Purple Hearts.
[1:19:27] You deserve Purple Hearts, Purple Hearts, Purple Hearts, and I love you.
[1:19:42] Thank you and I love you.
[1:19:44] Appreciate it.
[1:20:01] Next item there.
[1:20:03] Individual.
[1:20:04] Rachel.
[1:20:05] Candice.
[1:20:06] Miano.
[1:20:07] Candice.
[1:20:28] Candice.
[1:20:29] Is the green light on there?
[1:20:30] Bright, it's right.
[1:20:31] Should you okay perfect?
[1:20:32] It's not working as it.
[1:20:46] Other good, you are.
[1:20:47] Sorry.
[1:20:48] My family has deep roots in the Magic Valley.
[1:20:50] The handsheets came here after World War II and built lives and businesses here.
[1:20:55] Through my blended family, I'm also connected to the Yuri legacy.
[1:20:58] People who helped clear the original Twin Falls town site and build this community from the ground up.
[1:21:03] My grandfather Sergeant William Raymond Carter served 11 years in the United States Marine Corps,
[1:21:09] including a combat tour in Vietnam.
[1:21:12] When he came home, he helped preserve this valley's history
[1:21:15] through the CSI's Herret Museum.
[1:21:18] That service did not end with him.
[1:21:19] Both of my sons have worn the uniform of this country.
[1:21:22] My son served in the United States Army, and my youngest
[1:21:25] is still serving in the Air Force today.
[1:21:28] As a mother, I understand what service,
[1:21:30] that service is not an abstract word, it is a sacrifice.
[1:21:33] It is time away from family, uncertainty, duty,
[1:21:36] and willingness to put something larger
[1:21:38] than yourself first.
[1:21:39] Across this community, generations of mothers and fathers
[1:21:42] have watched their sons and daughters raise their hands and promise to defend this country
[1:21:46] and the freedoms it represents. If we are willing to ask that of them, then surely we have an obligation
[1:21:51] here at home to safeguard those freedoms they are willing to sacrifice for. That responsibility
[1:21:57] belongs to all of us. We are not owners of liberty. We are its temporary custodians.
[1:22:02] We inherited it from those who sacrificed before us and our children will inherit the decisions we
[1:22:07] have now. And that's why it's bigger than the 40-clock cameras we already have. The
[1:22:12] question is not simply what can technology do. The question is what will the free people
[1:22:17] permit their government to do. Previously I said freedom is not lost in one dramatic moment.
[1:22:22] It is lost to compromise at a time. So I ask you to remember the other side of that truth.
[1:22:28] Liberty is preserved one decision at a time. This is that time for those decisions. Please
[1:22:33] Please terminate the block program, preventative renewal and remove those cameras.
[1:22:38] It is our legacy that will be left for our children, so let's protect it.
[1:22:43] I have also given you guys some forms you can go through.
[1:22:46] It is a pretty much budget and all that fun stuff and stuff with the block contract.
[1:22:52] Thank you Candace.
[1:22:53] Rachel, who do we have next?
[1:23:02] Benedict, Niano.
[1:23:12] Good evening Council.
[1:23:13] My name is Ben.
[1:23:14] I live here in Twin Falls.
[1:23:15] have some thoughts on some things that have been said
[1:23:17] about block camera systems.
[1:23:20] It's been said that they're merely automatic license plate
[1:23:24] readers, while this may be true for some cameras.
[1:23:27] Many block cameras are using AI to track people.
[1:23:30] All across the United States and many cities,
[1:23:32] they've been seen going up on a bike and walking paths,
[1:23:35] as well as public parks and playgrounds.
[1:23:37] I don't know how many license plates
[1:23:39] you're going to read on a playground.
[1:23:41] Claims have been made that are data safe.
[1:23:44] And Flock has claimed that have never been hacked.
[1:23:46] And while this may be a partial truth that our data has ever
[1:23:49] been hacked on the AWS server, cameras have been hacked.
[1:23:52] And data, live footage, have been livestreamed on the
[1:23:56] internet.
[1:23:57] Our data is not safe.
[1:23:59] That our data is permanently deleted.
[1:24:01] I don't know.
[1:24:02] Is it?
[1:24:04] That we can turn off the nationwide lookup tool?
[1:24:06] This is the illusion of control.
[1:24:09] all it takes is some legislation to take this out of the hands of local authority and put
[1:24:15] into state or federal. Also, there's many reports coming in that different police organizations
[1:24:22] have turned off their nationwide look up tool only to find out that it wasn't. Also, I think
[1:24:29] it's interesting that the FLOC CEO called the organization DFLOC, a terrorist organization.
[1:24:33] Those are strong words. I would call them patriotic. FLOC is for a private for-profit
[1:24:40] company. They don't care about us. They don't care about the law. They don't care about what's
[1:24:43] right. All they care about is their shareholders. They don't want the rest of my time. I'm going
[1:24:47] to read some new changes to flock contracts in last year. These are from their terms and conditions.
[1:24:52] Flock's previous terms and conditions stated that flock does not own and shall not sell customer
[1:24:57] data. That language is now absent from their terms and conditions. The new license while
[1:25:02] granting formal legal ownership of data to the customer grants the company the exclusive
[1:25:06] right to determine and control the method, timing, format, and medium of access to that
[1:25:10] data.
[1:25:11] Thank you Ben.
[1:25:12] Appreciate it.
[1:25:13] Thank you for your time.
[1:25:14] Thank you.
[1:25:20] Rachel, who else do we have tonight?
[1:25:22] Blake Coomann.
[1:25:23] Said Blake.
[1:25:25] Yeah.
[1:25:26] Yeah, correct.
[1:25:35] Blake.
[1:25:36] Thank you Council members.
[1:25:37] My name is Blake Coleman.
[1:25:38] I've lived here for a little over 10 years now and I'm speaking with you today to pretty
[1:25:44] much be a dead horse.
[1:25:46] I just want to voice some concerns that I had about
[1:25:49] flock systems and related systems.
[1:25:54] I'm sure all of you have heard plenty from other individuals
[1:25:57] and seen online about their facial recognition
[1:26:03] when our police chief has stayed previously
[1:26:06] that they only scan license plates.
[1:26:09] To the best of mine knowledge,
[1:26:10] we've had license plate readers that gauge prior to flock.
[1:26:14] I personally don't understand or see the use of using those and flock when we could use one
[1:26:22] or the other, preferably the stuff we've had prior that's controlled by the city and not
[1:26:27] some third party company who has their cameras.
[1:26:33] As we speak right now, there are several websites where you can log into pretty much any of
[1:26:37] those cameras and watch them live.
[1:26:40] So as Ben was saying previous, they're nowhere near secure as state they are.
[1:26:46] And the just sheer volume of legal cases being conducted against individuals either in the
[1:26:57] police force or flock themselves for misusing and abusing the flock cameras by stalking
[1:27:04] individuals accessing them when they shouldn't need to.
[1:27:09] These are points that there's a need to be addressed if we ever want to use flock in our
[1:27:15] community which I strongly advise against personally.
[1:27:20] Thank you for your time.
[1:27:21] Thank you, Blake.
[1:27:22] Appreciate it.
[1:27:25] Okay, Rachel, who else do we have tonight?
[1:27:27] That's it.
[1:27:28] It is signed up.
[1:27:30] Okay.
[1:27:31] Appreciate it.
[1:27:32] Okay, that brings us to our advisory board reports and announcements.
[1:27:38] Any advisory board reports from the council tonight, Craig?
[1:27:42] I just our council met last week and working in hand in hand trying to figure out what's
[1:27:49] the best way to approach it so we hope that will come to fruition soon so.
[1:27:54] Okay.
[1:27:56] Anybody else?
[1:27:57] City Manager's Office tonight?
[1:28:00] Okay.
[1:28:01] That brings us to our Executive Session portion.
[1:28:07] to adjourn to Executive Session pursuant to Idaho Code 74-206-1B to consider the evaluation,
[1:28:14] dismissal or discipline of or to hear complaints or charges brought against a public officer,
[1:28:21] employee, staff member or individual agent or public school student, and F to communicate
[1:28:28] with legal counsel for the public agency to discuss the legal ramifications of and legal
[1:28:36] options for pending litigation or controversies not yet being litigated but
[1:28:40] imminently likely to be litigated. The mere presence of legal counsel at
[1:28:45] executive session does not satisfy this requirement. What are counsel's wishes?
[1:28:49] I move we adjourn to executive session under Idaho Code Section 742061-B and F.
[1:28:58] Do I have a second? I'll second. Okay I have a first by Council woman Paris in a
[1:29:04] second by Councilwoman Volmer to adjourn into his executive session as presented.
[1:29:09] Any further discussion? Rachel Roll call vote please. Nathan Murray? Yes.
[1:29:16] Grayson Stone? Yes. Sherri Volmer? Yes. Jason Brown? Yes. Greg Hawkins? Yes. Ruth
[1:29:21] Pierce? Yes. And Chris Reed? Yes. Okay motion carries 7-0. That brings us to
[1:29:28] the conclusion of our meeting tonight. We will not be returning the city.
