Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2025-12-15, recording 1 (started 16:57)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2025-12-15/

[0:02:33] Good evening ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the December 15th 2025 City Council meeting
[0:02:39] I want to confirm we have a quorum. We have five members
[0:02:44] present currently Spencer cutlers on his way and
[0:02:47] Councilman stone is excused first item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance if you wish to join me
[0:03:08] Thank you. There are no proclamations tonight. Next is the consent calendar. There is one
[0:03:17] item under items of consideration, action item C that should be under the consent calendar.
[0:03:24] It was put in the wrong place. It's a consideration, consider a recommendation from Parks and
[0:03:30] Rec Commission to accept a tree donation from Twin Falls Parks and Rec Department to be
[0:03:35] We planted at Thompson Park in memory of Jacob Thompson.
[0:03:40] We usually put those on the consent calendars.
[0:03:43] Do we need a motion to move that over there?
[0:03:45] Can we just approve it all together?
[0:03:47] I would say a motion to approve the consent calendar adding for C.
[0:03:51] Okay.
[0:03:52] Go ahead, Chris.
[0:03:53] So that we approve the consent calendar as published, including item of consideration
[0:03:59] item C.
[0:04:00] Thank you.
[0:04:01] Do I have a second?
[0:04:02] Second.
[0:04:03] Thank you.
[0:04:04] by Chris Reed, second by Craig Hawkins to approve the consent calendar items A through D plus
[0:04:12] number four C. Any discussion? Rachel Roquevo, please. Ruth Pierce? Yes. Chris Reed? Yes. Craig
[0:04:24] Hawkins? Yes. Jason Brown? Yes. And Sherry Lohmer? Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 5-0. Okay. Next
[0:04:36] under items of consideration is a presentation. A request is
[0:04:40] where in the sixth newest when false police department police
[0:04:43] officers Malachi Bruni Joshua Gonzalez Luke Haninger
[0:04:51] Colton Michael Lizzie Eric Ryan and Owen Shields and we have
[0:04:56] Luke Allen right Luke come on up. Thank you. Turn on your mic.
[0:05:09] There we go.
[0:05:12] They get it.
[0:05:13] It's my privilege to present to you our six newest officers and present their bios to you
[0:05:20] prior to them being sworn in.
[0:05:22] So at this time, I would like to have Officer Malachi Bruni, Officer Joshua Gonzalez, Officer
[0:05:27] Luke Henniger, Officer Colton Mitchell Lizzie, Officer Eric Ryan, and Officer Owen Shields
[0:05:33] to come forward, please.
[0:05:44] Officer Bruni was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department on July 14, 2025 and graduated CSI
[0:05:50] law enforcement academy on December 10, 2025. Here in an associate's degree in criminal justice
[0:05:56] from Lewis and Clark State College, Officer Bruni looks forward to continuing professional growth
[0:06:01] while serving the community of Twin Falls. Officer Bruni, if you would please introduce
[0:06:05] members of your family and friends in attendance and invite who's going to come and pin your badge
[0:06:10] on down for you. Next we have Officer Joshua Gonzalez. Officer Gonzalez was hired by the
[0:06:47] the Twin Falls Police Department on November 3rd, 2025.
[0:06:50] He earned an associate's degree in liberal arts,
[0:06:52] criminal justice, and law enforcement
[0:06:54] from College of Southern Idaho.
[0:06:56] Prior to joining the Twin Falls Police Department,
[0:06:57] he served as a detention deputy
[0:06:59] with the Twin Falls County Sheriff's Office
[0:07:01] and is a police officer with the Jerome Police Department.
[0:07:04] Officer Gonzales is bilingual
[0:07:06] and committed to community-focused policing.
[0:07:10] Officer Gonzales, if you would please introduce members
[0:07:12] of your family and friends that are in attendance
[0:07:14] and invite who's pinning your badge to come and join you.
[0:07:48] Next, I'd like to present Officer Luke Henniger.
[0:07:51] Officer Henniger was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department
[0:07:53] on July 14th, 2025.
[0:07:56] And graduated the CSI Law Enforcement Training Academy
[0:07:58] on December 10th, 2025.
[0:08:00] Originally from Bozeman, Montana,
[0:08:02] he brings prior experience working in a county jail.
[0:08:05] Officer Henniger is proud to serve the Twin Falls community.
[0:08:08] Officer Henniger, if you would please
[0:08:10] announce, introduce any members of your family
[0:08:12] here in attendance and the Chief will be pinning his badge. Next we have Officer Colton Mizalichy.
[0:08:50] Officer Mizalichy was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department on June 30, 2025 and graduated
[0:08:56] the CSI law enforcement training academy on December 10, 2025. He holds a degree in criminal justice
[0:09:01] from Tarleton State University and brings a strong background rooted in discipline and public
[0:09:07] service. Officer Mizalichy is honored to continue a family tradition of law enforcement. Officer
[0:09:12] Officer Misalichi, if you would please introduce members of your family and friend and attendance
[0:09:16] and invite who is going to pin your badge.
[0:09:57] Next we have Officer Eric Ryan.
[0:09:58] Officer Ryan was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department on July 28, 2025 and graduated
[0:10:03] from the CSI Law Enforcement Training Academy on December 10, 2025.
[0:10:07] He has prior law enforcement experience in California and is served as an EMT with the
[0:10:11] Fire Department.
[0:10:13] Officer Ryan holds degrees in administrative justice, administration of justice, and wildfire
[0:10:18] Science and is committed to serving the community of Twin Falls. Officer Ryan, if
[0:10:23] you would introduce any family and friends that you have in attendance and
[0:10:25] the Chief will also be pinning his badge. And finally we have Officer Owen Shields.
[0:11:05] Officer Shields was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department on May 19th, 2025
[0:11:10] and graduated from the CSI Law Enforcement Training Academy on December 10th, 2025.
[0:11:15] He served six years in the United States Marine Corps and has prior
[0:11:19] experience as a correction officer in Montana. Officer Shields is proud to serve
[0:11:23] the community of Twin Falls.
[0:11:25] Officer Shields, if you would please introduce members
[0:11:27] of your family and friends that are in attendance
[0:11:28] and invite the individual down to pin your badge.
[0:12:00] Thank you, and now the Chief would like to say a few words.
[0:12:10] Thanks, Luke.
[0:12:11] Mayor, before we invite you down to issue
[0:12:13] their oath of office, I just wanted to address these gentlemen.
[0:12:19] And your journey to become a Twin Falls police officer
[0:12:21] is progressing very nicely, and the time and hard work
[0:12:25] that you've put in so far is paying off.
[0:12:27] I can't think enough of you for choosing our team
[0:12:32] and for joining the Twin Falls family.
[0:12:34] We've spent time visiting individually and collectively
[0:12:37] about your expectations of each other,
[0:12:40] and I want to share some of the conversations
[0:12:42] that we've had with each other, with everybody here tonight.
[0:12:46] So I've heard from all of you, when you said during your interviews,
[0:12:49] that you wanted to join our department
[0:12:50] because of its reputation being service oriented,
[0:12:53] and that it takes pride and care of its employees.
[0:12:56] You have my commitment on behalf of the TFPD that we will be ruled by our showered values
[0:13:01] and ethics and that you have found a place to work where you will feel valued and appreciated
[0:13:07] and we will give you the opportunity to grow and become the officers and the men that you
[0:13:10] want to be.
[0:13:12] In return, this community, this organization and I have some expectations of you.
[0:13:18] We are a resilient and forgiving community that places importance on service to one another.
[0:13:23] We know that you've displayed a history of placing needs above others in your collective
[0:13:27] backgrounds and as a guardian of Twin Falls we will ask you to continue to
[0:13:31] place a high value on respecting all of those that you encounter. The badge that
[0:13:35] you are now wearing carries the trust of this community and we do not give it to
[0:13:40] you casually. We are placing tremendous trust in you and we are all here to help
[0:13:45] you. You are not in this alone and together we can make Twin Falls a great
[0:13:50] place to live, work and visit. Now I know you will immediately start contributing
[0:13:55] to our culture and our community.
[0:13:57] And I think I speak for everybody here tonight
[0:13:59] that we cannot wait to see what you accomplish next.
[0:14:01] Welcome to the City of Twin Falls family.
[0:14:31] Last time I lost around.
[0:14:33] I stayed here.
[0:14:41] I found the company.
[0:14:44] I only swear.
[0:14:45] And I will support.
[0:14:48] And I will support the Constitution,
[0:14:52] the United States of America.
[0:14:56] Constitution and laws.
[0:14:58] I have no.
[0:14:59] But the state of Idaho.
[0:15:00] And the laws and the ordinance.
[0:15:02] Laws and the ordinance.
[0:15:03] the city of Twin Falls and the rules and regulations the Twin Falls Police Department that I will well and faithfully discharge
[0:15:19] the city of the office of police officers, the police department which I have been appointed according to law and the best of my ability
[0:15:37] Madam Mayor's, we're waiting for them to sign their oaths.
[0:16:00] I just want to tell everybody that's new tonight,
[0:16:03] that we have a tradition here at the City of Twin Falls.
[0:16:06] Upon completing their first year of service,
[0:16:09] we will actually present all of these officers
[0:16:12] with their oath, their original signed oath,
[0:16:15] and a frame for them to keep as their constant reminder
[0:16:18] of the values that they just attested
[0:16:20] that they will adhere to.
[0:16:23] As they're completing signing this, we have a second part,
[0:16:25] And we will be asking some additional folks to come forward
[0:16:29] to receive some honors that they've earned.
[0:16:30] And at the conclusion of what, we'll have them all come back
[0:16:32] up so you have an opportunity to come in and acknowledge them.
[0:16:35] Thank you.
[0:16:36] So with that, I'd invite Lieutenant Steve Gassard
[0:16:38] to please come forward.
[0:16:40] So I might mention that this is a presentation
[0:16:46] of post-communication certification.
[0:16:48] I better get my glasses here.
[0:16:50] For Jessica Burgess, Hannah Smith, and Logan Wilcox,
[0:16:54] post-intermediate communication certification
[0:16:56] to Jamie Thomas, who now, and post basic Peace Officer certification to Cesar Cervantes, Jr.
[0:17:03] Go ahead, Steve.
[0:17:06] All right.
[0:17:07] Madam Mayor, members of council, I am honored to present the basic Peace Officer certification.
[0:17:13] So if I can ask Cesar Cervantes to please come forward.
[0:17:24] The basic Peace Officer certification is issued after an officer has completed the post academy
[0:17:30] Academy and completed field training program.
[0:17:35] Cesar Cervantes Jr. was hired by the Twin Falls Police
[0:17:38] Department on April 8, 2024.
[0:17:41] He graduated from Canyon Ridge High School in 2019
[0:17:45] and worked several jobs from a retail associate
[0:17:48] to a hospital transporter where he grew a heart for helping
[0:17:51] those in need before pursuing his childhood dream
[0:17:55] of being in law enforcement.
[0:17:57] In his spare time, Cesar enjoys practicing Brazilian
[0:18:00] Jiu Jitsu, wrestling and mixed martial arts.
[0:18:03] He is very honored and humbled to have been selected
[0:18:06] to protect and serve the community
[0:18:08] and that he was born and raised in.
[0:18:10] These are, if you could please introduce the members
[0:18:12] that you have in the audience today.
[0:18:45] Good evening, Madam Mayor and members of the Council.
[0:18:48] Mike a little bit closer, there we go.
[0:18:50] There you go, thank you.
[0:18:51] Good evening.
[0:18:52] I am Deann Taylor and I am the Emergency Communications
[0:18:55] Manager and I get the honor of introducing
[0:19:00] the dispatchers who have earned their post-certificates,
[0:19:05] the basic certificate and the intermediate certificate.
[0:19:08] If I could have Jessica, Hannah, Logan, come down.
[0:19:34] Okay, I'll start with Jessica.
[0:19:35] Jessica Burgess is 22 years old
[0:19:37] and was hired for the Twin Falls Police Department
[0:19:39] as an emergency communications officer in June of 2023.
[0:19:44] Jessica says that it's been an amazing opportunity
[0:19:47] to work in this role, helping people
[0:19:49] and being part of a strategic team that targets her life work
[0:19:53] passion.
[0:19:55] These years will also strengthen her future life work steps
[0:19:58] as she is currently attending CSI for Nursing.
[0:20:01] Her primary goal is to help serve the pediatric population.
[0:20:06] Outside of work in school, Jessica is probably
[0:20:09] stressed studying with her horses or forcing herself not
[0:20:12] to abduct and feed all the stray cats.
[0:20:15] Jessica is very grateful for the opportunity
[0:20:17] she has been given to work in this role
[0:20:20] and grow as a person.
[0:20:22] Jessica has earned her basic post certificate.
[0:20:25] Do you have any family in the audience tonight
[0:20:27] that she would like to introduce?
[0:20:31] And will the and, Mike's birthday today?
[0:20:36] Okay, Hannah Smith was hired
[0:20:38] by the Twin Falls Police Department on October 21st, 2024
[0:20:42] as an emergency communications officer.
[0:20:44] Before working in dispatch, Hannah worked at Marisa's
[0:20:47] as a stylist and assistant manager
[0:20:50] for about a year and a half while she was still in high school.
[0:20:53] She graduated from Jerome High School in May 2023
[0:20:57] with a 4.0 GPA.
[0:21:00] Anna has two cats, Indy May and Pumpkin,
[0:21:03] and they are her whole world and paycheck.
[0:21:06] In her spare time, she loves to read books and bake.
[0:21:09] Anna has always had a passion for helping people,
[0:21:12] and she's thankful to be part of dispatch.
[0:21:15] Have any family members in the audience?
[0:21:29] OK, Logan Wilcox was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department
[0:21:32] on May 20, 2024, and has an emergency communications
[0:21:38] officer.
[0:21:38] In his spare time, he enjoys reading, playing games, card
[0:21:42] games, board games, and video games,
[0:21:44] as well as going on walks or hike.
[0:21:46] Logan lives with his fiance here in Twin Falls,
[0:21:49] along with his two cats.
[0:21:50] He plans to take every opportunity to improve his current skills
[0:21:54] and learn as much as he can from his superiors, his seniors,
[0:21:58] and peers. Logan has earned his post-basic certificate. You have anyone in the audience
[0:22:04] with us tonight? Okay, Jamie Thomas was hired in the communications center in March 2022
[0:22:21] as an emergency communications officer. Jamie was promoted to assistant manager in April
[0:22:26] 2025. Jamie attended ISU and received her bachelor's degree in emergency management.
[0:22:33] Jamie resides in twin falls with her husband and daughter.
[0:22:36] Jamie has earned the post intermediate certification.
[0:23:56] There we go.
[0:24:05] Aaron, Council, thanks for letting us take time to celebrate
[0:24:07] achievement for these folks.
[0:24:08] We'd now invite you to come down if you want to
[0:24:10] congratulate them yourselves.
[0:24:11] Bring your officers too.
[0:24:15] OK.
[0:25:26] Thank you, folks.
[0:25:26] We'll gather in the lobby here in just a second.
[0:25:29] As in closing, Madam Mayor, for the last four years,
[0:25:32] we've had the privilege of watching you swear in all
[0:25:35] of our folks, especially in my case myself, we just want to thank you for the way that you've
[0:25:41] gone about that and for taking the time for us to celebrate this in front of everybody.
[0:25:45] Thank you.
[0:25:47] Okay.
[0:25:57] So we're going to take about a two minute break.
[0:25:59] I know the families are dying to stay, but you're excused if you'd like.
[0:26:06] I won't take it personally.
[0:27:33] Okay, meetings back in order.
[0:27:45] Next item on the agenda is an action item.
[0:27:48] It's the purchase of a new 420-cat backhoe loader budgeted for the fiscal year 2026.
[0:27:54] You know, Rob, CIP Water Fund, and we have Josh here.
[0:28:01] So Rob had time to be here.
[0:28:02] He was not feeling well this morning.
[0:28:04] He called and said, I can still come in.
[0:28:05] I said, don't worry about it.
[0:28:06] Sure.
[0:28:07] I get other people sick.
[0:28:08] So I said, I can take it for you, Rob.
[0:28:12] What you have before you is the purchase of a new backloader loader for us for the water
[0:28:17] department. The water department needs reliable equipment for water main repairs,
[0:28:21] hydrant valve repairs, sewer line work, trenching, utility cuts, those types of
[0:28:26] things. We've already gotten rid of an old backhoe loader that had exceeded its
[0:28:32] useful lifespan. So it was traded in and the city has already looked at this
[0:28:37] new one and it comes with a five-year warranty, a five-year and 1500-hour
[0:28:46] warranty. It was budget in this year's budget for $176,000 and the purchase
[0:28:52] price came in under budget by about $5,000. So this comes not only with the
[0:28:59] loader but also a rock-breaker or hammer on the front of it as well. So that would
[0:29:04] be included in the cost. So city staff recommends the purchase of it and I can
[0:29:10] for any questions you might have.
[0:29:13] Perfect.
[0:29:15] Chris Reed.
[0:29:17] Just a quick question on time.
[0:29:19] Is this something that we would be able to get quickly?
[0:29:21] Or is this something that's gonna take
[0:29:22] a little bit of time to get to our page?
[0:29:24] That is a great question.
[0:29:25] I don't know the answer for sure,
[0:29:26] but I believe it's actually there
[0:29:28] and we can pick it up relatively soon.
[0:29:30] That's my understanding.
[0:29:31] Perfect.
[0:29:32] Thanks.
[0:29:33] Thank you, Spencer.
[0:29:35] Thanks for purchasing the right brand.
[0:29:36] It might be unforgivable if the wrong name were on there,
[0:29:39] but you guys did a good job, some of the things.
[0:29:44] OK, so Jason Brown.
[0:29:47] But I'd move to approve the new purchase of a 420CAD
[0:29:50] back-o-loader budgeted in the fiscal year 26 CIP water fund.
[0:29:55] Thank you, Sherry Vomer.
[0:29:56] I'll second.
[0:29:57] Thank you, motion by Jason Brown, second by Sherry Vomer,
[0:30:00] to approve the purchase of a new 420CAD back-o-loader budgeted
[0:30:04] in the fiscal year 2026 CIP water fund.
[0:30:10] Any further discussion?
[0:30:12] Rachel Rokoff, oh please.
[0:30:14] Craig Hawkins.
[0:30:14] Yes.
[0:30:15] Jason Brown.
[0:30:16] Yes.
[0:30:16] Spencer Cutler.
[0:30:17] Yes.
[0:30:17] Jerry Holmer.
[0:30:18] Yes.
[0:30:19] Ruth Pierce.
[0:30:20] Yes.
[0:30:20] And Chris Reed.
[0:30:21] Yes.
[0:30:22] Thank you.
[0:30:22] Motion passes 6 to 0.
[0:30:25] OK.
[0:30:25] Next item on the agenda is an action item.
[0:30:28] Consider a consideration of a request
[0:30:31] to enter into contract negotiations for the solid waste
[0:30:35] contract, beginning January 1, 2027 to BSI.
[0:30:40] environmental systems, and we have our utility billing manager, Chelsea Ross.
[0:30:44] Welcome, Chelsea.
[0:30:45] Thank you, Madam Mayor and Council.
[0:30:47] So tonight we're requesting Council authorization to enter into contract negotiations for the
[0:30:52] City's followed waste hauling in recycling contract.
[0:30:56] This proposed negotiation would be with PSI environmental systems with a contract start
[0:31:00] date of January 1st, 2027 for a 10-year term.
[0:31:04] The City's current solid waste and recycling contract expires December 31st, 2026.
[0:31:09] And in accordance with the procurement policy, staff issued a request for proposal to secure a new vendor.
[0:31:15] The RFP was issued on October 23rd, 2025 and was closed on November 20th.
[0:31:20] You will see in the staff report, there were proposals were requested for multiple service options.
[0:31:27] The base bid was for unlimited solid waste, no bi-weekly recycling.
[0:31:31] Alternate one, unlimited solid waste with bi-weekly recycling.
[0:31:35] alternate to limited solid waste, no bi-weekly recycling, and alternate three limited solid
[0:31:40] waste with bi-weekly recycling. Our evaluation criteria included pricing, administrative compliance,
[0:31:46] and proper licensing. For the bid results, there were three vendors that submitted bids,
[0:31:51] elevate recycling disposal. We did not accept this bid as they were considered non-responsive.
[0:31:57] They submitted the current pricing after the bid was closed. Republic services also submitted
[0:32:03] bit and PSI environmental systems. PSI was the lowest bidder across all four categories
[0:32:08] in all alternatives as well. I did some cost analysis highlights for you. So the cost difference
[0:32:17] between unlimited and limited solid waste is 24 cents per month. Unlimited does not necessarily
[0:32:23] mean unlimited. It means your can is full and you can have seven to eight bags outside of
[0:32:27] that can that they will pick up on a later date. When it's limited, it is only as full
[0:32:32] your can can go. Right now we do have unlimited with recycling. We picked up 23,244 tons of
[0:32:41] solid waste and 98.9 tons of recycling. And the average solid waste cost was $56.46. The
[0:32:50] average recycling cost per ton was $11,758. These figures were based on the total population
[0:32:57] of 16,747 units.
[0:33:00] So for recycling considerations, that is why I'm here tonight.
[0:33:03] Council may choose whether to continue city-provided recycling services.
[0:33:07] We are not aware of any other entities in our Solid Waste District
[0:33:10] that's participating in recycling at this time.
[0:33:13] If recycling was removed, PSI has proposed for an optional subscription-based recycling
[0:33:20] where customers can opt to work with them outside of the city to have a recycling cart.
[0:33:26] Our next steps, this is not approve our final contract,
[0:33:31] but the next steps would be to enter into negotiations
[0:33:33] with PSI, refine service options, pricing and terms,
[0:33:37] and return to council with finalized contract for approval.
[0:33:39] If we're not able to come to terms with PSI,
[0:33:42] we would go to the second bidder.
[0:33:44] So let's open for any questions for you tonight.
[0:33:48] Thank you, Chelsea.
[0:33:49] Any questions for Chelsea on this?
[0:33:53] So you just need a motion to move forward
[0:33:56] with contract negotiations, not necessarily picking an alternative or do you need us to
[0:34:02] guide you on an alternative?
[0:34:06] Yeah, members of the Council.
[0:34:09] So, right now, we know what those costs are.
[0:34:14] If the Council has a preference in the direction that we go, that would be very helpful in negotiating
[0:34:20] that contract.
[0:34:24] We do have some time because PSI is the current provider and there's not the requirement to
[0:34:37] go through all the capital intensive startups that a second group would have.
[0:34:43] I'll put it a little bit more plainly than what Chelsea did.
[0:34:48] We've gone through and we've analyzed the recycling.
[0:34:53] From a staff perspective, we don't believe that the recycling pencils from an economic
[0:34:59] standpoint, we don't believe that it pencils from a consumer standpoint.
[0:35:10] When I first read the staff report that Chelsea provided me last week or maybe the week before
[0:35:16] when I reviewed it, I challenged her numbers because one of the things you'll see in there
[0:35:22] was $11,000 per ton of recycled material.
[0:35:26] And that is not a typo.
[0:35:30] Based upon the amount of cycling materials
[0:35:35] in comparison to the cost, that is a true cost
[0:35:38] because there were several months in which there was
[0:35:41] zero materials sent to a recycling facility
[0:35:45] for a series of reasons.
[0:35:46] You'll recall the prior recycling center closed
[0:35:51] and there had to be a window of time that we were moving up,
[0:35:55] but that cost was still sent forward to our citizens.
[0:35:59] If the council does not believe at this point in time,
[0:36:04] you're ready to make a decision that recycling is not something
[0:36:08] that we would do, but I understand that PSI is willing
[0:36:11] to do a subscription-based service,
[0:36:15] that is an opportunity for the citizens
[0:36:17] who truly want to be engaged in recycling to move forward.
[0:36:20] Part of that challenge in that recycling is not only market, but also the types of commodities that were able to recycle.
[0:36:30] When we first started single stream recycling, it was loose paper, it was all types of plastic, for the most part.
[0:36:38] It was cardboard, aluminum, tin. It was truly a multiple stream, 96 gallon recycling.
[0:36:48] And today it has been reduced to 10 aluminum and cardboard,
[0:36:56] because that's really where some of that commodity lies.
[0:37:00] The benefit to our citizens in comparison
[0:37:02] to potentially the environmental cost could be debated.
[0:37:07] And from a staff perspective,
[0:37:09] we struggle to find the economics
[0:37:12] of continuing with that program.
[0:37:15] I'll say it about that plainly.
[0:37:17] So two things we've been talking about this for a long time,
[0:37:20] and Chris and I've actually had this conversation over the years,
[0:37:26] the fact that recycling, what is recycling if those?
[0:37:31] Let me start over.
[0:37:33] If that trash was taken to the landfill,
[0:37:39] what does that add in or subtract in life?
[0:37:43] life, it was like a couple months from what I recall. I don't know what the answer is, but it literally
[0:37:50] shortened the life of the landfill very immaterial-y. So, and this is going many, many years back.
[0:37:57] Right. It was like 55 days in which the current cell would be extended. So if you, Chelsea has
[0:38:04] the exact numbers, but I want to say it was like 35,000 tons of sanit-y garbage. Is that what it was?
[0:38:10] Okay, so 23,000 tons of garbage, 92 tons, 99 of recycled materials. So you can see the
[0:38:24] significant disparity in the amount of tons that's truly being recycled inside the city
[0:38:28] of McBalls and comparison to the tonnage that is going forward. We are often asked as an
[0:38:38] entity to look at the products and service lines that we offer very similar to what a
[0:38:45] private business would do and ask does it continue to make sense to offer these product
[0:38:51] lines to our customer from a government perspective or if there's a subscription-based service
[0:38:56] are those interested citizens able to go in that direction.
[0:39:00] Do we want to compete?
[0:39:02] Do we have an IDICPSI here of what your subscription service would cost just for a general idea?
[0:39:10] Just a rough estimate from some behind the back of the napkin.
[0:39:16] You're looking probably $30 to $35 a month for a subscription based.
[0:39:20] A lot of the reason why is because of the quantity of customers that you would have actually signed up for the services.
[0:39:27] And then do you allow drop off?
[0:39:30] We can absolutely look into that option, talk with Travis and Chelsea, and you guys as well.
[0:39:36] I was thinking about, as your business model, would you accept drop-off?
[0:39:42] If the citizen chose not to have a subscription, but wanted to periodically bring things to
[0:39:47] Yeah, so right now we are accepting cardboard drop-off. We are not expanding it out right now into
[0:39:54] other commodities, and depending on where the city chooses to go on the recycling option,
[0:40:00] would be where we go on our drop-off options.
[0:40:03] Okay. Thank you.
[0:40:04] Yep.
[0:40:06] Chris.
[0:40:07] As we kind of discuss this and look at the four options,
[0:40:12] I personally, the base bid that option is the most desirable for me,
[0:40:17] at least when it comes to the city, knowing that other individuals,
[0:40:21] if you want to go outside of it for the recycling, perfectly fine.
[0:40:25] This is bringing flashbacks from many years ago when we talked about recycling.
[0:40:29] the cost associated with it, the drive time, where it would end up going, contamination issues, all of those types of things, even though you're paying for recycling, sometimes it's going straight to the landfill because you put other things in there.
[0:40:44] So I think if we can, as a city, get out of the business of recycling, allow the citizens to go directly if they choose to do that and go with the base bid, that would be my personal opinion.
[0:40:56] also think that currently we're on the unlimited.
[0:41:00] I know unlimited is, there is a limit,
[0:41:03] but it is the term unlimited.
[0:41:05] It is more than just your trash bin.
[0:41:07] Yes, I think if we continue with that service,
[0:41:09] I think that that would be the best thing for our community.
[0:41:11] The rate is minute, the difference.
[0:41:14] Yes.
[0:41:15] Okay, Jason.
[0:41:16] I'm with Councilman Reed with Chris.
[0:41:18] I think the base bid looks good.
[0:41:20] I would prefer to stay with that unlimited.
[0:41:24] I'm probably one of those users that puts extra bags out,
[0:41:27] and I'm also the one that always forgets
[0:41:29] that my recycling week is bi-weekly,
[0:41:31] so my recycle can goes out every week it seems like
[0:41:36] because I always forget.
[0:41:37] So I'm good, I think the base bid is probably the direction.
[0:41:42] I mean, recycling is something that's important,
[0:41:45] but obviously at the expense at a cost, the city
[0:41:48] and the citizens, I think that would be better served
[0:41:51] individually.
[0:41:52] So, this is an action item if somebody would like to make a motion.
[0:41:58] Chris, we'll make a motion.
[0:42:00] I move that we enter into contract negotiations for the solid waste contract beginning January 1st,
[0:42:06] 2027 to PSI environmental systems.
[0:42:11] You want to list the option?
[0:42:14] With the base bid unlimited solid waste services without biweekly recycling.
[0:42:20] Thank you.
[0:42:22] Jason.
[0:42:23] second.
[0:42:24] Thank you.
[0:42:25] Motion by Chris Reed, second by Jason Brown to approve the request to enter into contract
[0:42:31] negotiations for the solid waste contract, beginning January 1, 2027 to PSI environmental
[0:42:37] systems using the unlimited sanitation service without biweekly recycling.
[0:42:45] Any additional discussion?
[0:42:48] Rachel Roquevo, please.
[0:42:50] Ruth Pierce?
[0:42:51] Yes.
[0:42:52] Yes, yes. Yes, Jason Brown. Yes, Spencer Cutler. Yes, and Sherry Vomer. Yes. Thank you. Thank you
[0:43:01] Motion passes six to zero so madam mayor the the process will be that we will
[0:43:05] Negotiate with psi you might be asking we have all the numbers there were some
[0:43:12] Exclusions that they had requested to be a part of the contract if we will negotiate those items and hopefully be able to come to terms with them
[0:43:19] the price of that recycling
[0:43:21] is what would be, or the cost of all the programs, right,
[0:43:25] would be what starts in January 1st of 2027.
[0:43:30] If at some point in time we have those numbers,
[0:43:33] and if the council were to change their mind
[0:43:36] after hearing from the community,
[0:43:37] or whatever that looks like,
[0:43:39] know that we can move forward and include those numbers,
[0:43:44] but again, I would argue just please remember
[0:43:46] the economics of recycling in our area in comparison
[0:43:52] to potentially other areas.
[0:43:53] So, but know that this does not finalize the agreement.
[0:43:58] Like, agreement still needs to come back to the council
[0:44:01] and we will take our time working through that.
[0:44:03] And there still will be recycling through 2026?
[0:44:06] Yes, all of 26.
[0:44:08] Yeah, okay, thank you.
[0:44:11] Okay.
[0:44:11] I had to remember to take my can out of the other week.
[0:44:13] Yeah, yeah.
[0:44:14] circle it on the calendar. Okay.
[0:44:16] You think I'm old? Okay. Next item is an action item or request to adopt ordinance number 2025-028.
[0:44:26] Amending city code related to appeals of staff decisions and we have police Captain Brent.
[0:44:32] Right. Welcome, Brent. Good evening, Madam Mayor. Members council. Yes, tonight I'm here with an
[0:44:39] ordinance that would change city code related to appeals of city staff decisions. During
[0:44:49] a review of some other city codes, we came across several codes that required the appeal
[0:44:55] for those staff decisions to go in front of this group. All in, we identified 22 separate
[0:45:04] code sections that would require modification.
[0:45:10] This change further aligns with our city manager form
[0:45:13] of government and the decision making process.
[0:45:17] I do want to point out that any commission
[0:45:20] or committee decisions as well as anything related
[0:45:24] to alcohol, beer, wine, all of those decisions
[0:45:28] would still stay with the council.
[0:45:31] But with that, I would stand for any questions.
[0:45:34] Thank you. Any questions for Brandt on this? Chris?
[0:45:39] I don't have any questions, but I'm ready. And this will be a third and final.
[0:45:42] Correct. Okay. I move that we dispense with the reading rules and put 2025-028-028 on third
[0:45:52] and final reading by title only. Thank you. Sherry Vomer. I'll second. Thank you. Motion
[0:45:57] by Chris Reed. Second by Sherry Vomer to dispense with the reading of the rules and put ordinance
[0:46:02] number 2025-028 on third and final reading by title only.
[0:46:10] Rachel Roquevo, please.
[0:46:12] Ray Cauquins, Jason Brown, Spencer Cutler, Sheri Palmer, Pierce, and Chris Reed.
[0:46:20] Thank you.
[0:46:21] Motion passes 6-0.
[0:46:22] I'll read the ordinance.
[0:46:25] Ordinance number 2025-028, an ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls,
[0:46:31] providing for the changing of the City Council as the approving or authority for
[0:46:38] various decisions to the City Manager. Chris Reed. Move to approve
[0:46:44] Ordinance 2025-028. Thank you, Sherry Vomer. Second. Thank you. Motion by Chris Reed,
[0:46:51] seconded by Sherry Vomer to adopt Ordinance 2025-028, a demanding city
[0:46:56] code related to appeals of staff decisions. Any discussion? Rachel Rokavo, please? Ruth
[0:47:04] Pierce? Yes. Chris Reed? Yes. Chris Kockens? Yes. Jason Brown? Yes. Spencer Cutler? Yes.
[0:47:10] Yes. And Sherry Bölmer. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 6-0. Thank you. Okay. Next item on
[0:47:18] the agenda is an action item and it was actually we started this last week and couldn't finish
[0:47:25] So and I see that's not will you guys are changing up on me today. It's an action item a request to adopt ordinance number 2025 dash 0 3 0
[0:47:35] For vacation of a portion of a water line easement on property located in a portion of lot 9 10 and 11 a block 2 of
[0:47:44] Sunwest subdivision number 2
[0:47:47] Welcome, Jonathan. Thank you madam mayor for those of you here last week. You were aware of what happened
[0:47:53] We did not have five council members of places on third and final.
[0:47:57] So we read it the first time you wish to read it a second time and then come back for a third.
[0:48:01] We can certainly do that or you can dispense with the rules similarly to the last ordinance.
[0:48:05] This is the water line vacation for the tractor supply building that took place this summer.
[0:48:11] Thank you.
[0:48:12] Chris Reed ready.
[0:48:13] Yep.
[0:48:14] I move that we dispense with the reading rules and put ordinance 2025 dash zero three zero on third and final reading by title on me.
[0:48:21] Thank you Jason Brown.
[0:48:22] Second.
[0:48:23] Thank you motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Jason Brown
[0:48:26] to dispense with the reading of the rules
[0:48:28] and put Ordinance number 2025-030
[0:48:32] on third and final reading by title only.
[0:48:36] Rachel Roelkow, please.
[0:48:37] Chris Reed.
[0:48:38] Yes.
[0:48:39] Fred Cockens.
[0:48:40] Yes.
[0:48:41] Jason Brown.
[0:48:42] Yes.
[0:48:43] Yes.
[0:48:44] Sherry Bomer.
[0:48:45] Yes.
[0:48:46] Yes.
[0:48:47] Thank you.
[0:48:48] Motion passes six to zero.
[0:48:49] I'll read the ordinance number 2025-0300.
[0:48:52] of the Mayor and the City Council of the City of Twin Falls,
[0:48:55] Idaho, vacating a portion of a waterline easement
[0:48:59] described below.
[0:49:00] Chris Reed.
[0:49:01] Move to approve Ordinance 2025-030.
[0:49:05] Thank you, Jason Brown.
[0:49:06] Second.
[0:49:07] Thank you.
[0:49:08] Motion by Chris Reed, second by Jason Brown
[0:49:10] to adopt Ordinance number 2025-030,
[0:49:14] or vacation of a portion of a water easement
[0:49:17] on property located in a portion of Lot 9-10-11,
[0:49:21] to have some west subdivision to Rachel Rocha-Ovo please.
[0:49:26] Sherry Belmer? Yes. Ruth Pierce? Yes.
[0:49:29] Chris Reed? Yes. Greg Hawkins? Yes. Jason Brown? Yes.
[0:49:32] And Spencer Cutler? Yes. Thank you. Motion passes six to zero.
[0:49:37] Okay. Next on the agenda is an action item,
[0:49:44] a authorization to proceed. Okay. You're here.
[0:49:49] You're here. I just want to make sure you're authorization to proceed with the refunding refinancing of the city's two 14 a wastewater revenue bond through the idol bond bank authority and we have our CFO.
[0:50:04] We're on a Howard. Yes, you.
[0:50:08] I was wondering why you were doing back there.
[0:50:10] Okay.
[0:50:11] Okay.
[0:50:12] So I'm here to ask your permission to go forward and look at refunding the 2014 A wastewater revenue
[0:50:24] bond.
[0:50:25] We have about $22.33 million left in these and they've been callable since March 15, 2024.
[0:50:34] We have not seen a benefit up to this point of refunding, but at this point right now looking
[0:50:39] at where interest rates are going, they have recommended that we could go ahead and go through
[0:50:44] the process, go with the bond bank, submit an application for $2,500 and potentially get
[0:50:50] some savings. At this point going forward, we don't actually sign any documents or go forward
[0:50:55] until we know for certain that we will have the savings depending on where interest rates
[0:51:00] lie at that point. So it's like typical any mortgage refinancing. So I had them run a
[0:51:06] few handful of scenarios on what would it be if we refunded and just paid the fees up front
[0:51:13] just to see would that decrease the savings, would it increase the savings in this particular
[0:51:18] case by paying the $250,000 of fees that are scattered throughout the term.
[0:51:25] There's almost inconsequential to no savings at all.
[0:51:29] So the approval I'm looking for tonight is to start this process to get the $2,500 bond
[0:51:35] bank fee and continue forward with with dions to see if we would actually save
[0:51:41] money and we are looking at about a million forty five thousand in savings
[0:51:46] that we would see. So you have any questions? I'm here to stand for any
[0:51:53] questions but it's a basic refunding. Thank you. Anybody have any Spencer?
[0:51:58] Thanks mayor. I think you kind of alluded to this but if this is
[0:52:02] authorized this gives you a time window that you can kind of watch and see and
[0:52:07] understand no one can predict what's going to happen but sometimes it's
[0:52:11] pretty strong indicator so this isn't saying you've got a short time frame you
[0:52:15] have to move you have a pretty long time window that you could look out and see
[0:52:19] if it's worth waiting even a little bit longer before doing the refund refinancing.
[0:52:23] Potentially we have up until the point where we decide to pull the the triggers
[0:52:27] so similar to any refinancing they'll run the scenarios and then at that point in
[0:52:31] time, if we end up doing it, then we will sign the documents and lock in and seal in
[0:52:36] the rate. Right now, we know the Fed's just drop rates by 25 basis points. We're anticipating
[0:52:41] something that actually bodes well for us, having interest rates drop. So, yes, there's
[0:52:46] some time that they have to do all the paperwork beforehand. So, even though it seems like it's
[0:52:51] a long time, it's not necessarily as long as it feels because they have a lot in the
[0:52:55] background that they have to do.
[0:52:56] All right, thanks for clarifying
[0:52:58] Thank you. Any other questions for Brianna on this?
[0:53:02] Hey, I would entertain a motion then
[0:53:10] I'll make one go for it. I move that we authorize city staff to proceed with the refunding of the city's 2014 a waste water
[0:53:18] Revenue bond through the Idaho bond bank authority
[0:53:22] Thank you to have a second second
[0:53:24] Thank you motion by Spencer cutler second and by Chris Reed
[0:53:27] to authorize the staff to proceed with the refunding refinancing of the city's
[0:53:33] 2014-2014 a wastewater revenue bond through the Idaho Bond Bank Authority. Any further
[0:53:42] discussion? Rachel Rolkow-Voh please. Ruth Pierce? Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Jason Brown? Yes. Yes.
[0:53:51] Cutler. Yes. Sure. A Volmer. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes six to zero. Hey, next item on the agenda
[0:54:00] is a presentation. It's a presentation of the finances of the City of Twin Falls for the fourth
[0:54:06] quarter fiscal year 24-25. This presentation will be an overview of the tax-supported funds
[0:54:13] and the three major enterprise funds, water, wastewater, and sanitation.
[0:54:17] Brianna's back. I apologize I thought the resident parks tree thing on the
[0:54:24] agenda. Well we moved it to the consent calendar so all right yeah so that's
[0:54:28] your problem. Okay I swear there was something before me okay thank you.
[0:54:32] Uh-huh. Oh great. Sign in. Next up. Exit. Okay. The multi-factor I don't know where I'm
[0:54:46] feeling. Yeah no kidding. All right good evening mayor and council this is my
[0:54:50] favorite time of year. I thoroughly enjoy bringing the updated numbers. It was great
[0:54:55] to see most of you at ATI last week and so trying to actually seeing some of the
[0:54:59] similar stuff. We're all looking at the same thing so that was a good affirmation.
[0:55:04] So I'm gonna start with a national context, see how everything lays out on
[0:55:08] the federal perspective and tie it into where our budget is, where we're at with
[0:55:13] our tax-supported funds and then our enterprise funds. What you'll find
[0:55:17] interesting or what you'll see or maybe most of you are following is there's still
[0:55:21] a lot of volatility in in the national context but yet the city of Twin Falls
[0:55:26] remains stable and I think that's a permeating factor throughout our
[0:55:30] organization as we are consistent. We're nimble, we're stable in where we are in
[0:55:35] our budget. So the key things that are important here is consumer spending
[0:55:40] remains resilient despite tariffs and low consumer sentiment. Inflation continues
[0:55:45] moderating but still remains a public's number one concern. Housing market shows mixed signals,
[0:55:50] home prices are up, yet affordability is strained. Labor market is cooling with slower payroll growth
[0:55:55] and corporate layoffs. This frames the environment in which local revenues cost pressures and resident
[0:56:00] behavior occur. This is the interesting anomaly that we've all seen. Consumers keep spending.
[0:56:08] But if you look at the data, spending is greater than the rise in income. So year over year,
[0:56:14] Retail sales are up 5%, but the savings rate is down 4.6%, which is indicating a reliance
[0:56:22] on savings for spending. This supports our local consumption driven revenues like our revenue sharing
[0:56:27] for sales tax and possibly for traveling for fuel as well. I just read an article recently about
[0:56:33] Black Friday and Cyber Monday for 2025. It's record-breaking performances. Online sales were up 9.1% while
[0:56:41] global spending reached $79 billion in just those couple of days. We've seen a
[0:56:47] raise in AI traffic to retail websites which was notable with 805% increase as
[0:56:53] we've talked before sales tax online doesn't typically generate or convert
[0:56:58] into sales tax paid to us. Consumers as sentiment this one is a constant we are
[0:57:05] constantly seeing it remaining near historic lows because of volatility.
[0:57:10] Inflation and tariffs are the top concerns with 45% at inflation, 33%
[0:57:16] tariffs and 21% market volatility. I'm sure all of us in this room I myself
[0:57:21] included have these as concerns. To city low confidence may delay large
[0:57:27] purchases like building activities and potential softening in permits and fees.
[0:57:32] Inflation is cooling but it's still elevated.
[0:57:36] CPI is 3% year over year, because PCE, which is core personal consumption expenditure, so
[0:57:42] stripping out some of the other volatile stuff that is not necessarily core, is at 2.9%, but
[0:57:47] what's important to note is energy and services, which is part of super core inflation, still
[0:57:52] remains elevated. Shelter costs are cooling, but high. The city this impacts costs, contracts,
[0:57:59] and materials. Tariffs remain the number two economic concern, despite limited price increase
[0:58:05] passes through so far. Businesses are preparing for volatility. The risk to the city is the
[0:58:11] impacts pricing for capital goods, vehicles, technology, and construction materials.
[0:58:17] On the employment side, payroll growth is down sharply. More people are unemployed,
[0:58:23] participation is weakening, discouragement is rising, rage premiums for job changes is declining,
[0:58:29] internal is low nationally as well as in the city. This is good for recruitment,
[0:58:34] but may increase applications for open roles.
[0:58:37] Our HR department has been seeing this for quite some time now that there are a lot of applicants
[0:58:41] for every position that we post. Major corporate layoffs are hiring phrases that hit the news.
[0:58:49] I don't know if you guys have read the articles about Amazon. They are planning to up to 30,000
[0:58:53] cuts citing AI is driving staff reductions. Meta Goldman Boeing are also trimming the number of
[0:58:59] knowledge workers they employ. More companies are also betting they can grow without hiring.
[0:59:04] This may influence migration and spending locally.
[0:59:07] This reinforces our cautious economic outlook
[0:59:10] for the next fiscal year.
[0:59:12] Housing starts are the lowest since 2020.
[0:59:15] I found this chart and found it interesting.
[0:59:17] This is the rent burdened by state
[0:59:18] where greater than 50% of household income is spent on rent.
[0:59:22] This is actually at the end of 2024,
[0:59:25] so it's a little bit dated,
[0:59:26] but what was surprising to me was how red Idaho is.
[0:59:29] 21.8% falls into this category.
[0:59:34] Price cuts and incentives continue to increase.
[0:59:37] Existing home sales are up but still historically low,
[0:59:41] and Idaho continues to remain unaffordable,
[0:59:44] and we're cited as one of the least affordable states.
[0:59:47] The slower construction affects city permit revenue
[0:59:49] and housing availability.
[0:59:52] Case Shiller home price induces is a monthly report
[0:59:56] that analyzes housing data in major metropolitan areas
[0:59:59] across the U.S.
[1:00:00] Home prices are up only 1.5% year over year.
[1:00:04] month to month declines are emerging. We've seen the Midwest, North, what East being stable
[1:00:09] and the Sun Belt softening. We see similar moderation appearing here locally in the city.
[1:00:17] For health care, we have new health care cost pressures with federal rule changes. Medicare rules
[1:00:22] freeze, freeze provider tax expansions and Medicaid rates capped at Medicare labels levels.
[1:00:28] There's a new report from a Mercer survey saying average cost of employer sponsored health
[1:00:32] insurance increases 6%.
[1:00:35] Chart growth and prescription drugs spending, which rose 9.4% on average,
[1:00:40] higher total health benefit costs increases of 6.7% are expected next year.
[1:00:46] This could raise our city health plan costs and is something that we are
[1:00:49] monitoring and going to continue to watch for trends.
[1:00:57] So in summary, what are we watching? Obviously we're watching inflation,
[1:01:01] we're watching tariffs, they continue to pressure purchasing power.
[1:01:04] Housing affordability affects mobility and permit activity,
[1:01:07] Slower job growth may reduce consumer confidence, health care policy shifts could increase our city
[1:01:13] costs for benefits. But the stabilizing factors are consumers still spending our local economy
[1:01:18] continues to be resilient with national cooling in the housing market and may reduce construction
[1:01:23] cost inflation. Low turnover supports continuity of our city services. Let's talk about budget.
[1:01:30] Where do we end up? Our total budget adopted budget if you remember was $109 million.
[1:01:36] 34% is non-tax supported funds with the remainder,
[1:01:40] 66% on tax supported funds. Fast forward to the amendment,
[1:01:45] we had $132 million after the amendment. Included in that budget
[1:01:49] amendment that Matt brought up just a few months ago was a $1.4 million
[1:01:53] health trust injection, $2.6 million increase in chip seal,
[1:01:58] millen inlay, asphalt truck and street improvements.
[1:02:01] We had $1.2 million in the further fire training facility,
[1:02:05] 690,000 for the Rock Creek Restoration Project.
[1:02:09] Some of these we had offsetting revenues come in, but those are the expenses that we increased for.
[1:02:13] 8.7 million is the WaterHankins Pump Station,
[1:02:16] Kimberley Road, and other miscellaneous projects.
[1:02:19] 1.4 million was the Public Works Site.
[1:02:21] 2.6 million was F.C.L.F.R.F. projects.
[1:02:24] So that makes our city budget 132 million with tax-supported funds at 62% of that now.
[1:02:32] Driving down to tax-supported funds.
[1:02:34] And by the way, I got accused that my budget presentation was the same every single quarter
[1:02:39] since the entire time I've been here. So I'm happy to note that it has changed up. I've got some pretty
[1:02:44] pictures in there and it looks different for your appeal. So our largest contributing revenue sources
[1:02:52] on the tax-supported funds or property taxes. We know that 43% of 31 million dollars just comes
[1:02:58] from our property taxes. Grants make up 10.3 million and then there's others that are about 6 million
[1:03:04] each, just a little bit over state shared revenue. We had budgeted reserves, our transfers, and
[1:03:10] dedicated street funds at 4.4 million, and then franchise fees coming in at 2.4 million.
[1:03:16] Everything else, including permits, permits are in that other category. When we amended
[1:03:20] that budget, you'll see a few changes, grants specifically being increased by $2 million.
[1:03:26] That's from the Rock Creek for 687 for the project there. Fire District Training Center was
[1:03:31] the 1.18 million. Our reserves spending increased by 6 million, if you show in
[1:03:38] fall's grade, was 2.3 million, the health plan trust for just the property tax part
[1:03:43] was 1.1 million, and streets were 2 million for Milan in late and Chippsfield.
[1:03:48] So we're gonna just jump to going forward on the amended stuff. I'm not
[1:03:53] gonna keep going back and forth. That was just a high-level overview of where we're
[1:03:56] at. Now we're just gonna talk about where we are hitting the bar at now. So in
[1:04:02] In tax-supported funds, this is allocated as such.
[1:04:04] You can see in this graph that we have about 50%
[1:04:07] that goes to general fund.
[1:04:09] High on this pie chart this year is streets.
[1:04:11] Obviously, we have some massive projects at 22%
[1:04:14] getting funding and then capital improvements at 18%.
[1:04:19] Property tax history revenue, this is the last four years.
[1:04:22] We've gone from 25 million to the 31 million.
[1:04:26] This is just under the half of the tax-supported fund budget.
[1:04:30] Substantial increases in the last four years
[1:04:32] are because of the growth in our population and the closure of the URA district. Property
[1:04:37] taxes mainly come as an increase for the 3% that you are allowed to accept and pass as well
[1:04:44] as new construction. Other revenue sources are highway money, so we've got 6.1 million
[1:04:51] as where we ended up. State revenue sharing at 6.8 million and franchise fees of the 2.5
[1:04:57] Highway revenue is 137% budget.
[1:05:00] We typically, we consistently budget on a level basis.
[1:05:04] We don't count for fluctuations nor can we.
[1:05:07] We don't know what the state's going to give us.
[1:05:09] We don't know how much people are driving.
[1:05:11] We don't know when that's going to cool down.
[1:05:12] And so we try to budget consistently at a stable number.
[1:05:15] If we budgeted too high or too low,
[1:05:18] then we would end up spending that amount.
[1:05:20] And then we would find ourselves using reserves unnecessarily.
[1:05:24] And then backing up the next year.
[1:05:26] This shows franchise fees, which mainly come from
[1:05:28] Intermountain Gas, Idaho Power and Cable.
[1:05:31] We get 3% of their gross revenues.
[1:05:35] The last four years, Idaho Power has increased 22%
[1:05:40] on a smaller scale, Intermountain Gas has increased 28%.
[1:05:46] Building permits, we continue to watch this
[1:05:47] because permits are an indicator of economic activity,
[1:05:50] and we track them closely.
[1:05:52] Like the national level, we aren't seeing
[1:05:53] the number of permits increase in the residential sector,
[1:05:55] but we are seeing a significant increase
[1:05:57] in the value of homes.
[1:05:59] So just for educational purposes, single family homes,
[1:06:02] we've received 11% less than last year,
[1:06:05] but the value of homes have increased by 15%.
[1:06:09] But even though we're not seeing that
[1:06:11] on the residential side,
[1:06:13] Poon Falls is a thriving and economic hub.
[1:06:16] We are seeing significant industry building.
[1:06:19] The number of permits from the commercial sector
[1:06:20] has increased substantially, 112%,
[1:06:23] And the values there have increased 92%.
[1:06:26] We've received 2.23 million of the budgeted 1.24 million,
[1:06:31] and this is specifically because of the Chobani expansion.
[1:06:35] It's a big piece of it.
[1:06:37] The last almost 20 years, this is what we've gotten
[1:06:39] in building permit revenue.
[1:06:41] You can see the dips from 2010 housing market crash,
[1:06:44] and then after COVID where we increased significantly,
[1:06:48] and then have dropped because of the massive increases.
[1:06:54] Expenditures.
[1:06:56] Almost half of what we budget is in personnel.
[1:06:58] We have 96.9% of personnel is where we ended up for the year,
[1:07:02] almost spent the 10 million at the M&O.
[1:07:05] On personnel side, we have about 17 open positions,
[1:07:08] which is only a 4.8% vacancy rate.
[1:07:11] I thought that was interesting considering some
[1:07:13] of the COVID years when we were at over a 10% vacancy rate.
[1:07:17] This is an indicator along with the national level.
[1:07:21] Inside of capital improvements, because that's a large dollar,
[1:07:24] 27 million of which we've only spent 19 million. Most of it has been encumbered or
[1:07:28] looked into next year. We have all this list off a handful of the bigger projects
[1:07:33] that we have budgeted for your recollection. 4.5 million in seal coding,
[1:07:38] million inlay with a million dollars that was under spent. And that was actually a
[1:07:41] good thing. I don't believe that we're going to end up spending that. That was a
[1:07:44] cost savings that our street department was able to work. 9.2 million was Eastland
[1:07:49] and some other street projects. Two million is under spent by 930. So we're
[1:07:54] We're still going to continue to have some trickle off of what we owe for the rest of
[1:07:58] that.
[1:07:59] Plus, we had 900,000, so almost a million that was transferred to the water department because
[1:08:03] of the sharing of costs after we get information from the builders.
[1:08:07] 2.5 million in auto equipment purchase was materially spent.
[1:08:11] 1.8 million was Fire Station 2 payment and Fire Training Center, which was spent.
[1:08:16] 1 million in parks facility enhancements and Canyon Trail Junction was material spent.
[1:08:21] $1.9 million for Vista Bonita was not spent, but they are anticipating after talking with
[1:08:26] Wendy to have that done by next year, next calendar year.
[1:08:30] $67,000 was the Rock Creek project.
[1:08:33] $1.8 million in the legal offices, $1.1 of that was encumbered into next year.
[1:08:38] $1.2 million is the pool or model, which has been encumbered into next year as well.
[1:08:43] Transfers are more than what we budget because every year, if we have money left over in the
[1:08:47] the general fund, we transfer it to the capital funds so that we can continue to purchase bigger
[1:08:52] items as they come up.
[1:08:54] On the enterprise fund side, this is our revenue, so user fees in both, you can see it's about
[1:09:02] $10 to $11 million in both the water and the wastewater fund, of which we have exceeded budgeted
[1:09:10] expectations.
[1:09:11] This one is really hard to budget.
[1:09:13] It depends on the weather, well, for the water part.
[1:09:15] It depends on the weather.
[1:09:16] It depends on what people are using.
[1:09:18] We've tried to correct and budget more, and then we get less, and so really what's important
[1:09:24] to note is the dollar amount is similar.
[1:09:27] We get about $11 million for water and wastewater for user fee revenue.
[1:09:31] That's not the entire fund.
[1:09:33] That's just the main pieces that we can watch and look at.
[1:09:38] On the expenditure side, personnel is 97.7%.
[1:09:44] Again, we're starting to see that we're getting fully staffed.
[1:09:47] We're starting to see some nicer numbers when it comes to personnel.
[1:09:50] So 3.3 million on the water side and MNO is about 98% to expend it as well.
[1:09:56] Capital, so it's some numbers that are in that 14.7 million, we had 5.37 million of Hankins
[1:10:02] pump station pressure zone of 350,000, which was significantly underspent there, 3.2 million
[1:10:08] with Eastland and only 900,000 was spent.
[1:10:12] That will go on.
[1:10:13] So we're just crossing the years.
[1:10:14] 0.5 million was for the Kimberley Road water line and 700,000 public work site improvements
[1:10:20] is a little less than half spent.
[1:10:22] On the waste water side for capital, the fuel larger projects include 650,000 for mainline
[1:10:29] replacement, which was half expended, 650,000 for the odor project, you still have almost
[1:10:35] the entire amount, 521,000 remaining.
[1:10:38] 300,000 canyon rim drop line was half spent and 300,000 heat exchangers, digesters,
[1:10:44] that was half-expended as well. The $28 million or the debt right there
[1:10:49] indicates or includes that $28 million that we just decided to refund and we will
[1:10:55] go forward with that to spend less in debt and interest payments going forward.
[1:10:59] Sanitation is extremely consistent. We get pretty close to the same amount year by
[1:11:05] year. This is the contract with PSNI. PSI we don't have a lot of we don't have any
[1:11:11] personnel, we just contract it all out so it's just M&O. So, in total, risks and
[1:11:19] stability. Inflation and tariffs continue to be a risk. Federal health care rule
[1:11:24] changes are something we're going to watch. Housing affordability, challenges
[1:11:28] Idaho, challenges the city of Twin Falls. The cooling labor market could reduce
[1:11:31] consumer confidence in local economic momentum. But for stability, we have strong
[1:11:36] reserves. We continuously maintain those reserves and we try to budget
[1:11:40] This provides a financial cushion against volatility.
[1:11:43] We have low employee turnover, which supports consistent service delivery,
[1:11:47] stable revenue performance supported by continued consumer spending,
[1:11:50] and we have cooling national housing market that may reduce future construction
[1:11:54] cost inflation in the future.
[1:11:56] Our key priorities going forward are to maintain conservative spending
[1:12:00] and protect our reserves, to prioritize essential city services,
[1:12:04] which is why we are doing priority-based budgeting across the organization,
[1:12:07] and core community needs.
[1:12:09] Stay competitive and pay and benefits
[1:12:11] to support workforce stability,
[1:12:13] continue monitoring healthcare costs,
[1:12:15] and track housing and construction conditions
[1:12:17] affecting growth.
[1:12:21] And that's all I have, unless you have any questions.
[1:12:25] Anybody have any questions for Rihanna?
[1:12:30] One question is, we've all been hearing
[1:12:34] about the state budget issue.
[1:12:37] What impact does that have in Twin Falls, if any?
[1:12:42] I can differ to Travis at one in just a minute.
[1:12:46] Right now, I would see that as sales tax changes.
[1:12:49] Now, when they talked about it at TI,
[1:12:51] they don't see a change in sales tax,
[1:12:53] I see it in corporate tax.
[1:12:54] Right now, we don't have, there's not an indicator
[1:12:58] that that's going to change or that they will reduce it.
[1:13:01] I just wonder if in the future,
[1:13:03] they decide to change the way they calculated.
[1:13:06] And based off of the rainy day fund conversations
[1:13:09] in the legislature, I wonder if our
[1:13:12] Our position on maintaining and keeping stable reserves might affect us in the future a handful
[1:13:18] of years ago.
[1:13:19] We had quite a few conversations about what are we going to do if they come back?
[1:13:23] How do we spend those reserves by the things that we need because we know that they're
[1:13:26] going to go away in the future?
[1:13:27] So I get concerned personally about if they change those formulas, what does that mean
[1:13:33] to us?
[1:13:34] We do only get for $6 million in shared state shared revenue, that doesn't mean that I can
[1:13:41] shoot that can't change.
[1:13:42] get so much in property tax dollars that doesn't mean it can change. You want to add anything
[1:13:47] Travis? I think Rihanna hit the high points. I think another thing that I would add is our
[1:13:57] street fund has been the beneficiary of the surplacile eliminator. And so when the state
[1:14:04] has more revenue and it has expenditures, the state has agreed to share some of that with
[1:14:12] with local governments to assist with road maintenance.
[1:14:14] And so we've been able to get about a million dollars a year
[1:14:17] over the course of the last few years.
[1:14:18] That money we use to cover the increased costs
[1:14:22] associated with chip ceiling our roadways.
[1:14:25] So if there is no surplus,
[1:14:27] then there's nothing that's going to be shared.
[1:14:29] And so there's a potential impact there as well.
[1:14:32] And Braden is right.
[1:14:34] The state shared revenue formula is statutory,
[1:14:37] which means it can change
[1:14:39] by a couple of legislative votes,
[1:14:42] how cities collect property taxes can be changed
[1:14:45] with a couple of votes.
[1:14:46] And so we believe that this legislative session
[1:14:50] is going to be important,
[1:14:51] not only because of the fiscal place the state finds itself,
[1:14:56] but it's also important to remember
[1:14:57] that only 22 members of the legislature,
[1:15:00] I believe are a part of JFAC.
[1:15:01] There are 105 members of the legislature
[1:15:04] that will be waiting for the budget to get done,
[1:15:06] so I'll give them a lot of free time
[1:15:08] to come up with a lot of creative pieces of legislation
[1:15:14] that sometimes require us to become engaged.
[1:15:21] Unless there are some non-legislators
[1:15:23] that have some great ideas as well.
[1:15:26] Quote, anything else for Briana?
[1:15:34] Thank you.
[1:15:35] That was great.
[1:15:37] OK.
[1:15:38] That's it for under items of consideration.
[1:15:42] It's not now time for general public input.
[1:15:45] There's anybody in the audience that wishes
[1:15:47] to address city council today.
[1:15:50] Now is your time.
[1:15:56] Okay, seeing no one advisory board reports.
[1:16:00] Greg, did you have some?
[1:16:01] Yeah, we still have one position open in the Arts Commission.
[1:16:05] Anybody interested in that?
[1:16:07] We sure appreciate some applications for that.
[1:16:11] Great.
[1:16:12] Anybody else have anything?
[1:16:16] We have an MPO transportation meeting tomorrow.
[1:16:19] No, Thursday.
[1:16:21] And also tomorrow morning, no, sorry,
[1:16:23] Wednesday morning at eight of City Hall or County, geez.
[1:16:30] The new County Courthouse will have a ribbon cutting
[1:16:34] and then tours all day.
[1:16:35] So Don Hall called and said,
[1:16:37] make sure, make that announcement.
[1:16:39] So eight o'clock for the ribbon cutting on Wednesday.
[1:16:43] Hey, anything from the City Manager's office?
[1:16:45] Just a note that we will not be meeting on December 29th,
[1:16:49] and so we'll meet next week,
[1:16:50] and then our next meeting will be January 5th.
[1:16:53] Thank you.
[1:16:55] Anybody else?
[1:16:57] Hey, our meeting's adjourned.
[1:16:58] Thank you, everyone.
