Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2025-08-25, recording 1 (started 16:14)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2025-08-25/

[0:03:35] Good evening ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the August 25th 2025 City Council meeting. I want to confirm
[0:03:43] We have a quorum. We currently have four members in chambers
[0:03:48] Sherry molars on the phone and Spencer color will be here shortly
[0:03:52] So first item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance if you wish to join me, please rise
[0:04:11] Thank you, okay, we have no proclamations tonight
[0:04:20] So next on the agenda is the consent calendar. Council wishes. Move to approve. I'll second. Thank you
[0:04:29] motion by Jason Brown second by Chris Reed to approve the consent calendar as written
[0:04:37] Amy Rokalvo please Ruth Pierce. Sorry Rachel. Yes
[0:04:43] Yes, yes Jason Brown. Yes, and Sherry Lohmer. Harry. Can you hear?
[0:05:00] Chair, are you good?
[0:05:30] Okay, motion passes four to zero.
[0:05:35] Okay, next, under items of consideration,
[0:05:40] our first item is a presentation,
[0:05:43] an update on the development of the Rock Creek Restoration
[0:05:47] Master Plan and public engagement by Jacob's Engineering
[0:05:50] and Gee Glow, and we have Mandy Thompson,
[0:05:53] Assistant to the City Manager.
[0:05:55] Welcome, Mandy.
[0:05:56] Thank you, Mayor Parrish and Council.
[0:05:58] I'll be brief.
[0:05:59] I just wanted to come up here and tee it off.
[0:06:01] We have a presentation tonight by representatives from Jacobs
[0:06:07] on some of the work that we've been doing
[0:06:09] towards the master plan and then also Josiah Brown
[0:06:13] and Mark Sandell from GGLO.
[0:06:15] We'll talk about the public engagement
[0:06:19] that we've been doing over the summer
[0:06:20] to interact with our citizens and get input
[0:06:23] from the community on the direction of the master plan.
[0:06:26] So any of you can, or Rachel can be perfect, okay?
[0:06:31] And I think we're gonna start with Aaron Cox from Jacobs.
[0:06:36] Hello everybody, it's great to see you again as a honor.
[0:06:40] Thank you.
[0:06:41] We're here to provide an update on the progress
[0:06:43] on the Watershed Restoration Master Plan.
[0:06:46] We were here a few months ago, you might remember,
[0:06:49] and we're excited to share what we've done today.
[0:06:52] We're gonna do a brief overview of the project
[0:06:55] just to remind everybody what it is.
[0:06:56] We're going to discuss some of the very interesting outreach and engagement opportunities that
[0:07:02] we have been undertaking.
[0:07:04] We're going to talk about one of our tasks, what was to assess the watershed and do a catchment
[0:07:09] prioritization.
[0:07:11] And then we're going to talk about the projects that we started to identify and then what we're
[0:07:14] going to be up to next before the completion of the project.
[0:07:18] Just to remind those who may be new to this project, we are looking at developing a master
[0:07:24] plan to develop a list of projects to help improve Brock Creek. As we know, it's listed
[0:07:32] as impaired for total phosphorus, total suspended solids, TSS, E. coli and flow alterations.
[0:07:39] The city was awarded a grant to develop this master plan and we are underway working collaboratively
[0:07:45] with the Twin Falls Canal Company and other regional partners to help restore the water
[0:07:50] quality for a more positive future. This is very wordy. Those of you who are interested
[0:07:55] can read it when you forgot a little more time, but really the last sentence pulls it all together.
[0:08:00] The improvements that we make today to Rock Creek will leave a legacy and ensure the environmental
[0:08:04] health, connectivity, and livability of Twin Falls for generations to come. We know that
[0:08:09] this river is important to the community and our outreach events and our survey have really
[0:08:14] confirmed that. Here's a brief timeline of what we have done and what we're going to be
[0:08:20] doing in the future. We have had an amazing opportunity to do some chartering, develop that
[0:08:25] vision statement. We have assessed the watershed, we've done a series of water quality sampling
[0:08:30] events, and we've developed a restoration toolbox. Now we're going to be supporting the
[0:08:37] prioritization of projects. I'll share a little bit more about that. We're going to be pulling
[0:08:41] together the master plan, and we'll be sharing the final master plan with you early in the
[0:08:46] year 2026. Before we go into some more of the technical results, we're going to have GGLO talk
[0:08:53] about the stakeholder and outreach engagement. Hello, I'm Josiah Brown, an urban designer with GGLO,
[0:09:01] and we've been working with Jacobs to engage the public throughout this process. So our outreach plan
[0:09:12] is divided into three phases that follow along the project. We've already completed the discovery
[0:09:17] phase where we cast the vision for the project. Now we have wrapped up the draft plan phase
[0:09:24] of engagement that happened over the summer where we were gaining local intel, providing
[0:09:29] progress updates to the community and helping identify some of the priorities for the projects
[0:09:35] that we'll talk about in a minute here. So during this draft plan engagement we had
[0:09:41] three different venues where we were able to hear from the community. First we had community
[0:09:47] leaders workshop where we had representatives from the community with expertise and knowledge
[0:09:52] about the watershed. We had a public workshop open to anyone and this was at Rock Creek Park.
[0:09:59] We had about 50 attendees and we also had an online survey that kind of ran concurrently
[0:10:05] with all of these outreach efforts. We got 136 responses so we're really pleased with
[0:10:11] the participation and what we were able to gather from that.
[0:10:16] So, here's the highlights of what we heard.
[0:10:21] Rock Creek is very important to the community.
[0:10:24] There's a lot of support for this project and its vision.
[0:10:28] Nearly 85% of the residents consider the creek polluted or dirty and nearly 80% of the respondents
[0:10:36] support using public funds to improve water quality.
[0:10:39] So that's great news for this project.
[0:10:44] Diving in a little deeper,
[0:10:46] here are some of the questions from the public survey.
[0:10:49] So number one was on a scale of one to five,
[0:10:52] how important is Rock Creek to your enjoyment
[0:10:54] of the Twin Falls area?
[0:10:56] You can see half of respondents said extremely important
[0:11:00] and another 33% said it's very important.
[0:11:04] So we know that Rock Creek means a lot to the community
[0:11:07] and we also know that people feel
[0:11:10] that it is degraded on a scale of one to four,
[0:11:12] how would you rate the water quality?
[0:11:14] 50% say somewhat dirty and about 40 say very dirty.
[0:11:21] Oops, sorry.
[0:11:27] Okay, so number three,
[0:11:30] which of the following would increase your use of rock creek?
[0:11:32] We had the highest response for cleaner water quality.
[0:11:36] And then two other answers that we're highlighting here
[0:11:40] are things that will be directly addressed
[0:11:42] by this project, more navigable sections of the creek
[0:11:45] and more fish and wildlife.
[0:11:48] And then finally, would you support using public funding
[0:11:51] to improve rock creek?
[0:11:52] More good news, 80% nearly say yes, only 2% say no,
[0:11:58] and about 20, say maybe.
[0:12:02] During the open house, we had two questions
[0:12:05] with quantitative data, do you support the project vision?
[0:12:09] All yeses, and then what projects should we prioritize
[0:12:13] And we had the top three responses
[0:12:16] where livestock exclusion fencing instructed wetlands
[0:12:19] and riparian shading.
[0:12:21] So that'll help as we're prioritizing projects
[0:12:25] and what we'll talk about here in a minute.
[0:12:28] So we also had an interactive map
[0:12:30] that people could use online or at the workshop.
[0:12:33] We had a physical version and we were gathering intel
[0:12:36] from the community where they've seen problem areas
[0:12:39] and where there's opportunities for projects
[0:12:43] to be implemented.
[0:12:44] And so through that, we got 46 responses,
[0:12:48] a lot of great information that we'll be folding
[0:12:51] into the master plan.
[0:12:53] So with that, I will pass it over to Shannon.
[0:13:01] Thank you.
[0:13:02] I'm Shannon Crohn's.
[0:13:03] I'm a civil engineer at Jacobs Engineering,
[0:13:06] and I'll be providing an update on the watershed assessment
[0:13:09] and catchment prioritization.
[0:13:13] So in summary, we started off this project
[0:13:15] doing a watershed delineation of the Rock Creek watershed.
[0:13:18] We delineated 16 different sub watersheds
[0:13:20] that all train into Rock Creek.
[0:13:22] We've also conducted water quality sampling
[0:13:25] over the past two years.
[0:13:27] We did a deep dive in the historical data analysis
[0:13:30] from USGS and IDEQ.
[0:13:33] What we're finding is the trends that we are currently
[0:13:36] sampling are very similar to the historical data.
[0:13:40] And then all of the historical data
[0:13:42] is showing that the water quality is still poor,
[0:13:45] but it is better than during the 1970s.
[0:13:48] and some of the early sampling events.
[0:13:50] Lastly, we're working on a sub-catchment prioritization
[0:13:54] to help identify the most impaired areas that need improvement.
[0:14:00] The map here is showing the 16 different sub-water sheds
[0:14:03] within the Rock Creek watershed.
[0:14:05] So the total watershed area is just over 300 square miles
[0:14:09] starting in the South Hills
[0:14:10] and flowing all the way to the Snake River.
[0:14:12] Just over half of the watershed is publicly owned
[0:14:15] and under that is privately owned.
[0:14:18] then we have all of the 16 difference of watersheds color-coded.
[0:14:25] There's various sources of pollutants in Rock Creek.
[0:14:28] Just to name a few here, we have sediment or erosion,
[0:14:32] temperature from the urban runoff and ag-return flows,
[0:14:35] nutrients from agricultural return,
[0:14:38] septic, urban runoff, and bacteria.
[0:14:44] So far, we've completed five different sampling events,
[0:14:47] and we have one more upcoming sampling event.
[0:14:49] So over the past two years,
[0:14:52] We're planning to collect six different rounds of sampling
[0:14:55] during the three different flow regimes in Rock Creek.
[0:14:58] So we've been taking samples during the spring runoff
[0:15:00] when there's a peak inflows, high sediment and phosphorus.
[0:15:04] We've also been sampling during irrigation season
[0:15:07] when there's some agricultural returns in Rock Creek
[0:15:10] and then lastly during low flow in late October, early November.
[0:15:19] So the key water quality takeaways
[0:15:22] show that the spring runoff samples were above the TMDL targets for TSS and total phosphorus,
[0:15:29] and this indicates a high level of sediment bound phosphorus. Also, there is dissolved phosphorus
[0:15:34] as well. E. coli levels were high during the summer, which corresponds with the higher
[0:15:39] temperature and more bacterial growth. Microbial data, we did microbial tracing, indicated a
[0:15:46] high level of ruminant or cow bacteria in the watershed. And then lastly as I
[0:15:52] mentioned the Jacobs collected water quality data follows similar trends to
[0:15:56] historical water quality data. And then the map here on the right shows the number
[0:16:01] of TMDL exceedances from the Jacobs collected water quality data. So green is
[0:16:07] a low number of exceedances and then red is a high number of exceedances. And with
[0:16:15] that, I'll turn it over to Erin to talk about the project identification and toolbox.
[0:16:20] Thank you, Shannon. So now you know where we've been, what we've been doing. And the
[0:16:26] next phase is that we have identified that the projects are falling into three categories.
[0:16:32] And the reason we're doing this is multiple. One of the things is when we are looking at
[0:16:36] projects and how they might be funded, urban projects might come from different funding
[0:16:40] sources than agricultural. So urban stormwater projects have been identified. And those are
[0:16:46] things like detention basins, street sweeping, bioswales, agricultural projects, we've got
[0:16:52] a suite of opportunities, including the ones listed here as well as constructed wetlands,
[0:16:58] and then river corridor projects. We identified areas of a lot of erosion where we know sediment
[0:17:03] is being washed into the river at high flow events. So we know there are a lot of opportunities
[0:17:08] to restore that riparian habitat and floodplain. All of these identified projects are
[0:17:14] going to be culminated together and prioritized in a very actionable
[0:17:18] master plan. Shannon worked really hard with the city and got a tremendous amount
[0:17:25] of data. We delineated the major stormwater basins, which is going to be useful for the
[0:17:29] future for the city. And what we've identified is a number of locations for
[0:17:34] potential stormwater projects. And when we looked at stormwater projects, we looked
[0:17:39] for all of the typical projects that can be implemented. And to help us
[0:17:44] prioritize, we're looking at those that have the most green dots, those that we know are
[0:17:50] effective and can provide significant reduction in pollutions.
[0:17:53] So this list here shows the types of projects that we were looking to locate around the city.
[0:18:00] We started by identifying 16 projects that would really help improve water quality.
[0:18:05] And then in a workshop with the city's engineering team, we narrowed that down to six based on
[0:18:10] some what we're calling exclusionary criteria making sure that these are
[0:18:14] implementable and that the city would be happy to have them in their system. So
[0:18:21] that is one of the big things with stormwater projects we want to make sure
[0:18:24] that they're not too difficult to maintain. We're doing the same thing in the
[0:18:29] agricultural area. We had to really understand the Twin Falls Canal
[0:18:34] Company and the agricultural infrastructure. That has been very helpful for us
[0:18:38] because we're able to identify locations where projects would be most beneficial.
[0:18:44] One of the things that we did is a model that helps identify the most susceptible areas for
[0:18:50] sediment erosion and phosphorus-bound sediment impacts.
[0:18:54] That's been really helpful for us because not only is the area that is like you can see the
[0:19:01] areas in red, we know that projects that could mitigate phosphorus in those areas would be
[0:19:06] extra impactful.
[0:19:07] So we're using a lot of different technical tools to try to identify and prioritize projects.
[0:19:14] We're also looking at things as broad as programs, things that we could partner with the soil
[0:19:20] and water conservation districts and the NRCS to implement.
[0:19:24] Best management practices, things like exclusion fencing.
[0:19:27] That was one of the items that came up in the public engagement too.
[0:19:30] People support that.
[0:19:32] And so we're looking at not only the types of things that can be done on a small scale,
[0:19:37] but we're actually, we're also looking at bigger projects
[0:19:40] like some sediment ponds, there are some great sediment ponds
[0:19:43] in place, but we could expand them,
[0:19:44] we could add more at the locations where they'll create
[0:19:47] the biggest positive impact,
[0:19:48] and then we're doing a lot of research
[0:19:52] to find the best location for constructed wetlands.
[0:19:55] We are doing some really interesting work throughout the state
[0:19:58] on some constructed wetland locations
[0:20:01] that can help improve water quality.
[0:20:02] They're very effective at water quality improvement.
[0:20:06] And then in the riparian corridor,
[0:20:09] we used a lot of different models and technical data
[0:20:13] to really hone in on the places that were experiencing
[0:20:17] the greatest amount of erosion.
[0:20:18] So you look at the longitudinal connectivity,
[0:20:22] we use things like the channel profiles,
[0:20:25] rodent diversion GIS data, for lateral connectivity,
[0:20:29] we looked at aerial imagery,
[0:20:31] and then for vertical connectivity,
[0:20:33] That's like, you know, if a channel bank,
[0:20:36] it's not supposed to be straight up and down,
[0:20:37] unless it's, you know, like a canyon.
[0:20:39] Usually that indicates that there is erosion.
[0:20:41] So if we look at like the relative elevation model,
[0:20:45] we can tell if it's very steep, that it's likely eroded.
[0:20:47] We can use that data.
[0:20:49] So we obviously can't go and look at every single foot
[0:20:53] of the stream riparian, well, it'd be awesome.
[0:20:56] We could float it, but this is a way to do it
[0:20:59] from the office and prioritize areas.
[0:21:01] And then also that map that Josiah called.
[0:21:04] He showed you that is another way that we've been collecting information on where there are
[0:21:09] areas that might be impaired.
[0:21:11] So again, like the previous urban area, we're looking at the types of projects that we know
[0:21:18] from literature can create the biggest plute removal and benefit.
[0:21:22] And so everything that we're doing, we're wanting to make sure that we're going to get
[0:21:26] the biggest bang for the buck.
[0:21:29] In the riparian corridor area, we identified 25 potential projects, so 25 areas where we
[0:21:34] knew that there is erosion and it has been impacted.
[0:21:39] And then what we decided to do is take the entire corridor and rank it low, medium, or high level
[0:21:44] of impairment.
[0:21:45] That helped us prioritize areas that we wanted to look at more closely.
[0:21:49] So those areas that based on our modeling efforts were shown to be high.
[0:21:53] We were able to look at them more closely and then prioritize projects based on where we
[0:21:58] we know there's gonna be a positive impact.
[0:22:01] Again, then we looked at that prioritization
[0:22:04] of water quality data, and we're starting
[0:22:06] to marry it all together.
[0:22:09] So what's next?
[0:22:11] So I talked about this, we've got the urban stormwater projects,
[0:22:14] those riparian corridor projects, the ag projects.
[0:22:17] We're developing that list of projects, very comprehensive.
[0:22:22] We've already narrowed it down to some degree
[0:22:23] using exclusionary criteria, because you could do endless projects.
[0:22:27] We're now really honing in on those specific projects
[0:22:31] that we then bring into this very robust decision analysis tool
[0:22:36] that we call MODA.
[0:22:37] It's very scientifically based, and we can rank and wait
[0:22:41] projects to make sure that our final projects are going
[0:22:45] to be the ones that are going to be most effective again.
[0:22:49] So just a little bit more about that.
[0:22:51] One of the biggest things that we're doing
[0:22:53] is we're developing criteria.
[0:22:56] How do we want to evaluate all of these projects that we've identified?
[0:23:00] And once we do that, we can also wait, develop scales.
[0:23:05] So if we decide, you know, pollutant removal is a number one criteria, you can wait that.
[0:23:10] Or cost is another one that we oftentimes wait because obviously, you know, we don't have endless
[0:23:15] sources of funding.
[0:23:16] So we use this criteria, we wait it, then we do, we're going to work with the city on
[0:23:21] the criteria and the waiting, and then we score the projects.
[0:23:25] So you're basically going to, at the end of this, have a prioritized list of projects and
[0:23:30] those three separate buckets that then we can start looking at how to pay for these projects
[0:23:34] and develop a funding strategy.
[0:23:37] And once we have this list of projects, we'll be able to bring it back to you and get everybody's
[0:23:42] feedback again through some public engagement.
[0:23:45] And then we're going to have our marching orders.
[0:23:48] If we could accomplish all the projects on that list, I truly believe we can make a big
[0:23:53] impact on improving water quality and that we're going to have two different things that
[0:23:57] we deliver.
[0:23:58] We're going to have a more technical like typical report that you'd expect from an engineering
[0:24:02] firm.
[0:24:03] It's going to be very thorough and talk about all of our methods and how we've done everything.
[0:24:07] That will be something that you know you can keep and refer back to but that really great
[0:24:12] thing we're excited to prepare for you is a ArcGIS story map that will be available to
[0:24:17] the public.
[0:24:18] We can show all the project locations.
[0:24:20] You can click on the locations and learn more about each project.
[0:24:24] And so that's just a way to keep this board of like a living master plan that everybody
[0:24:28] can be fully bought into.
[0:24:34] You have any questions?
[0:24:35] Well, that's a lot.
[0:24:39] Anybody have any questions?
[0:24:41] Isn't that way more exciting than numbers?
[0:24:43] The budget.
[0:24:44] I don't know.
[0:24:45] Yeah, it's very exciting.
[0:24:46] A lot of work went into that, I could tell.
[0:24:49] Anybody have any questions?
[0:24:51] Jason, you're probably the only one that's qualified.
[0:24:54] Okay. Thank you very much. Thank you for the opportunity.
[0:24:58] Okay. Next on the agenda is an action item, a request to use water reserve funds not to
[0:25:09] exceed $150,000 to procure professional services to investigate the Canyon Springs pump station
[0:25:16] and adjacent water supply corridor. Josh Baird, our public works director, welcome, Josh.
[0:25:24] Thanks, Marion City Council. I was thinking I was a little later, so I wasn't hopping
[0:25:29] up as quick as I probably should have. So typically on a request I just kind of
[0:25:39] read the the request kind of go through it but this is a different type of
[0:25:45] request so I'm going to actually share a presentation with you as well as Travis
[0:25:50] is going to help towards the end. So I want to talk a little bit about some of
[0:25:55] the recent large-scale projects we've been working on in the city. One that
[0:26:00] you're familiar with that was in the past completed the Hankins pressure zone and I
[0:26:04] I list the cost down there.
[0:26:07] These are approximate costs.
[0:26:08] I didn't go through any real detailed analysis,
[0:26:09] but about $5 million to that one,
[0:26:12] some other large scale ongoing projects.
[0:26:16] Everybody's familiar with the Kimberly Road
[0:26:18] and the Easton Drive projects right now.
[0:26:20] Easton Drive is mostly a street project,
[0:26:24] but it has some water components.
[0:26:25] So the cost here is just the water portion
[0:26:27] and then upcoming and not yet started construction
[0:26:32] is South Hall number five.
[0:26:33] So it looks like we need total all of those together.
[0:26:36] You're looking at maybe $12ish million,
[0:26:38] kind of keep that number in the back of your mind.
[0:26:43] So a couple of projects we have not yet tackled,
[0:26:47] Harrison Tank, I show a picture there,
[0:26:49] the existing Harrison Tank on the left
[0:26:51] and the Canyon Springs Pump Station project.
[0:26:55] And so we're gonna kind of discuss those
[0:26:56] a little bit more now.
[0:27:00] So when you go back and look into little history
[0:27:03] and kind of look at our master plans.
[0:27:06] Starting as early as 2009,
[0:27:09] there is discussion of a proposed five million gallon storage
[0:27:14] tank that says likely or near the existing source tank
[0:27:18] of the Harrison booster station.
[0:27:20] So that's over 15 years ago.
[0:27:23] And then in 2015, you look at master plan.
[0:27:26] That need is still there, an additional five million gallon
[0:27:28] Harrison tank.
[0:27:29] And then in the 2022 version, the recommendation's
[0:27:32] gone from 5 million gallons to 10 million to counting.
[0:27:35] So the need has not gone away.
[0:27:38] You haven't seen it.
[0:27:39] It's not constructed.
[0:27:40] But that's a future project that we feel is needed.
[0:27:46] The other major project is a Canyon Springs pump station.
[0:27:51] Again, back in 2009, we were aware of it.
[0:27:53] I think we've been aware of it for longer than that.
[0:27:55] But it's specifically mentioned then,
[0:27:57] talks about it's not being equipped with variable frequency
[0:27:59] drive or back at power source.
[0:28:02] And then the last two master plans in 15 and 22
[0:28:04] just said that requires improvements
[0:28:06] to the condition and capacity restrictions.
[0:28:11] So I'm gonna show you a little video here.
[0:28:13] This was a recent tank inspection.
[0:28:16] So what you're gonna see is it looks like
[0:28:18] almost a vacuum and that's kind of what it is.
[0:28:22] We have tank inspections about every five years.
[0:28:26] This is kind of the newest technology.
[0:28:29] It's powered by people that are outside the tank.
[0:28:33] They disinfect this, looks like a kind of a drone meets a vacuum and it's concerning for
[0:28:40] the first part.
[0:28:41] We've actually started seeing a concern with not just the capacity, but the conditions.
[0:28:46] So I'll let you guys watch it.
[0:28:50] It's from just about a year ago and there you can see this, this device is on the floor
[0:28:58] of the tank inside and it's picking up debris and those are, those little roches here actually
[0:29:05] chunks of concrete, and they're coming from the roof, and you can see here there's gonna
[0:29:10] be a spot where I'm in a positive, but there's that white spot. It's kind of hard to see,
[0:29:17] but that's where you can see the difference between where the chugs have fallen and what
[0:29:21] they haven't fallen. So, this is the first time that we become aware of it becoming a
[0:29:27] condition issue. All of a sudden, there's a concern because this is kind of a heartbeat
[0:29:32] of our city in terms of water supply.
[0:29:37] So you may ask yourself if this has occurred,
[0:29:39] if you've been aware of these plans since 2009,
[0:29:41] why haven't you tackled the projects yet?
[0:29:43] And as you can imagine, the biggest issue is cost.
[0:29:47] So the Harrison, if we build a brand new tank,
[0:29:51] the preliminary estimate from this year 2025 was about $17.7
[0:29:55] million and then connect that new 10 million gallon tank
[0:29:59] to the old tank, another $2.3 million.
[0:30:02] So $20ish million there, Canyon Springs Pump Station,
[0:30:07] the preliminary cost just to work on the upgrade
[0:30:11] of the station itself, $13.9 million.
[0:30:15] So you're looking at $30 plus million for two large scale
[0:30:21] projects.
[0:30:22] And like I said, that's not any station upgrades.
[0:30:25] So the new Harrison tank is a significantly more straight
[0:30:30] forward project.
[0:30:31] Here's an aerial view right here.
[0:30:34] You can see on the north side, on the top of the screen,
[0:30:38] that East West Road is Falls Avenue,
[0:30:41] and that other street that you see that goes up and down
[0:30:43] vertically is Harrison, and on the white circle
[0:30:48] you see is the existing top of the Harrison tank.
[0:30:52] And so several years ago, we were able to at least
[0:30:55] acquire property adjacent to it so we can build a new tank on it.
[0:30:59] So we have the property, we have a kind of a plan,
[0:31:04] we can have the cost, and it's a pretty well-known,
[0:31:07] mostly clear plan.
[0:31:09] And so that's, I guess I feel significantly more comfortable
[0:31:11] about that cost.
[0:31:15] When we look at the Canyon Springs Pump Station project,
[0:31:21] like I said, we were just looking at upgrading
[0:31:26] the station itself, but in my mind's eye,
[0:31:28] it makes sense for us to do maybe a little bit larger study.
[0:31:32] We have four wells, you can see in that top left picture, and that's where we receive our water.
[0:31:39] It actually runs to the canyon on the north side in Jerome County. It eventually crosses the Snake River over a bridge,
[0:31:47] and you can see that bridge and those two pipelines that we have in the top right picture.
[0:31:52] And then it goes to our Canyon Springs pump station, which is that left bottom picture,
[0:31:58] which is where we have a ton of pumping power and we are pumping it all the way
[0:32:03] up the canyon rim wall. Eventually making it to the Harrison station so it has to
[0:32:10] go then a couple miles south and east to make it at that location. There's a
[0:32:17] single pipe from that pump station taking it to the Harrison station so there's
[0:32:23] this entire corridor we haven't really done any big large investigative look
[0:32:31] into this corridor. So if we're going through the effort of big changes and
[0:32:36] upgraded that pump station, I think we should look at the entire corridor, which
[0:32:39] is really the request tonight. So the Canyon Springs corridor, we would request
[0:32:44] $150,000 pulling money from reserves to develop a better cost
[0:32:50] system specifically for that entire Canyon Springs project. And then at some
[0:32:54] point in time, getting that number and adding it to the Harrison Tank project
[0:33:01] And at that point in time, it's likely that we cannot afford out of our budget, so we'll
[0:33:05] be looking at a bond.
[0:33:06] And so Travis is going to talk about what a potential bond might look like for these two
[0:33:11] specific projects.
[0:33:12] Thank you, Josh.
[0:33:19] So I think Josh did a really good job in kind of identifying some of the needs that have
[0:33:26] been described for a long period of time.
[0:33:30] And as we kind of go through this process, I want to share starting at a high level as
[0:33:37] the concept of maybe looking at a water bond in the future as being a possible solution for
[0:33:42] us in moving forward with some of these projects.
[0:33:45] A lot of those projects you've seen come through our normal budgeting process, and you're aware
[0:33:52] of the many times that we've had to remove well number five from the budgeting process
[0:33:59] and we've had to insert another project because there was something that became more pressing.
[0:34:06] What's important to recognize is all of those projects were funded by a combination of revenues
[0:34:11] and cash reserves and today, just recently, maybe not even yet, looking at that in Brianna,
[0:34:21] but maybe not even yet, but the conclusion of this fiscal year,
[0:34:25] we will have paid off the last of the remaining water debt
[0:34:29] that we have in our system.
[0:34:31] And so we've been able to make the critical improvements
[0:34:36] that have come through, and we're part of our plan,
[0:34:40] but in addition to that, we're now at a space
[0:34:43] where we have no water debt, and we can take a look
[0:34:45] at what are some of those opportunities in moving.
[0:34:50] So let's first talk about bonds and water debt and how local governments go into debt because
[0:34:59] it is not something that we do on a regular basis.
[0:35:04] In fact, most of the members on the city council today, I'm looking, I don't think any of the
[0:35:12] members here were on the city council when we issued the debt.
[0:35:17] I know that there were people on the council that assisted in getting the bonds through
[0:35:23] the process, but really that beginning of that debt starts with understanding the Idaho
[0:35:31] Constitution, which states that you cannot go into any state of indebtedness beyond the
[0:35:37] limitations of a single fiscal year without the consent of the voter.
[0:35:42] So whether you have the resources or the money or not,
[0:35:46] we have to go and ask permission of the voters
[0:35:50] to have them say, yes, the city of Twin Falls
[0:35:54] can go into a state of indebtedness
[0:35:56] beyond the limitations of a single fiscal year.
[0:36:00] And those thresholds become very different.
[0:36:04] So with a revenue bond,
[0:36:07] a revenue bond is where we are going to use
[0:36:10] the enterprise funds or those business units that we have.
[0:36:14] We've talked about that throughout the entire budgeting process that receives a fee for
[0:36:19] its operational service to cover its operational costs and doesn't use any portion of tax dollars
[0:36:25] to fund its operations.
[0:36:27] So the water fund, the sewer fund, sanitation funds are the ones that we often highlight.
[0:36:33] So with this being a revenue bond,
[0:36:36] it would require a simple majority for approval.
[0:36:42] Unlike the Geo bonds, when we went forward
[0:36:44] and asked for a fire station,
[0:36:46] it required that super majority of two thirds,
[0:36:49] nearly 67% approval of the voters who go to the polls that day.
[0:36:55] In addition to that, part of that mechanical process
[0:36:58] is 45 days prior to the election,
[0:37:03] you have to adopt an ordinance.
[0:37:06] It has to be published and it has to describe
[0:37:10] with specificity what you intend to do with those dollars.
[0:37:15] So part of the reason that Josh needs to have the resources
[0:37:18] is because we need to help answer the question
[0:37:21] on the specificity of what exactly are we going
[0:37:24] to be completing with these dollars.
[0:37:27] And then there are only certain dates
[0:37:30] in which we're able to ask the citizens
[0:37:33] these questions through bonding.
[0:37:34] So the Idaho legislature changed those times.
[0:37:37] And so I put up three possible dates.
[0:37:40] Obviously, there's some strategy that goes into it,
[0:37:43] but there's also a tremendous amount of front and leg work
[0:37:46] that also has to be a part of that process.
[0:37:48] And not knowing exactly what that timeline looks like,
[0:37:51] here would be the next three available election dates
[0:37:55] in which we could go ask the citizens
[0:37:58] for their approval of a water bond in moving forward.
[0:38:03] And then what we would do is we would pledge those systems moving forward and what's important is we're going to pledge those systems
[0:38:10] So how are we gonna pay for it right that gets to be?
[0:38:17] the million or the
[0:38:20] hell
[0:38:21] Maybe 40 million dollar question that is passed
[0:38:26] We're gonna take you back
[0:38:31] just a few years and
[0:38:34] the City Council
[0:38:36] authorized the staff to make a structural change
[0:38:43] into our budgeting process.
[0:38:45] For many of us will remember the arsenic debt,
[0:38:51] that flat arsenic debt that we placed on to each individual bill,
[0:38:57] and we had that debt until we were able to pay off that debt
[0:39:01] Once we paid off that debt, we came to the council and we said we would like to take those same dollars and put them and apply them towards capital projects moving forward.
[0:39:17] And then as we've paid off other debts, we've added money into the capital.
[0:39:24] capital. And what we've been able to do is balance our capital acquisitions with our rates.
[0:39:33] And so over the course of the last several years, we've come to the council and said,
[0:39:39] we don't need a rate increase in water. Because we're able to have a water fund that is able
[0:39:46] to not only pay its operational costs, who is able to pay its debt service costs, but
[0:39:50] also pay for its capital projects moving forward.
[0:39:55] And so over the course of an annual basis, we now collect $5.5 million a year that we
[0:40:03] can apply the capital projects.
[0:40:06] And in a 20-year window, we are able to take nearly $60 million and apply that to capital
[0:40:16] projects as well as debt and then the other $50 million continues of mainline replacement
[0:40:23] and other projects at a cost of about $2.5 million a year, excuse me, $3 million a year.
[0:40:31] So $3 million a year for existing capital and this is what the debt service would look
[0:40:36] like.
[0:40:37] look at a debt service, you can see nearly $60 million where we pay $17 million in interest
[0:40:48] on a total note of about $42.5 million. What's important is I've also asked Josh to explore
[0:40:59] what the cost of refurbishing the Harrison tank would be. But while we're talking about
[0:41:05] constructing a new tank, they may be entirely cost-effective to refurbish and make improvements
[0:41:14] in that tank once it has been drained so that it can have another 50 years of life.
[0:41:21] And so if we can make that improvement, we're going to go from having a structure that supports
[0:41:28] five million gallons that as Josh shared, it's beginning to show its age to a place that we have
[0:41:36] 15 million gallons of storage that can promote economic growth development, fire protection,
[0:41:45] water safety for the next 40 to 50 years. And so really the request is
[0:41:53] is in capturing the information so that we would be able to move forward to understand
[0:41:59] what this project is.
[0:42:01] Is 42.5 million dollars enough?
[0:42:03] We don't know.
[0:42:04] It's a stab that we took, but as we reflect here, we can make other concessions and changes
[0:42:12] as we move forward.
[0:42:14] But right now, if this were to stay at a 42 million dollar price tag, we would not anticipate
[0:42:21] a water rate increase associated with this bond based upon the existing revenues that we have
[0:42:30] and that doesn't assume any growth in water sales and it doesn't assume any growth in customers.
[0:42:42] Could that wrap a day and see any questions that you have? Any questions for Travis or
[0:42:48] Josh, Jason, are you around it? No, I don't have any questions. I'm ready to
[0:43:00] I'll just feed back, I know that this is something that we've talked about for years.
[0:43:04] I mean, this is not the first time that we've had a presentation.
[0:43:07] I was new on the council when we purchased that property, knowing that this was going
[0:43:11] to be coming.
[0:43:14] We all know that that pump station is aging, and we talked about that just a few months
[0:43:19] ago.
[0:43:20] So all of this is coming.
[0:43:21] I think that, well, we are just looking at 150,000 right now, anticipating that in the
[0:43:29] the next couple of months is wise.
[0:43:33] Thank you.
[0:43:35] Okay, thank you.
[0:43:37] We need a motion to.
[0:43:40] Oh, yeah, sorry.
[0:43:43] I'll make that if.
[0:43:45] Please, Jason.
[0:43:45] But move to approve the use of water reserves funds,
[0:43:49] not to exceed 150,000 to procure professional services
[0:43:52] to investigate the pump station and adjacent water corridor.
[0:43:57] Thank you, Chris Reed.
[0:43:59] I'll second.
[0:44:00] Thank you, motion by Jason Brown,
[0:44:01] seconded by Chris Reed to approve the use of water reserve funds not to exceed $150,000
[0:44:09] to procure professional services to investigate the Canyon Springs pump station and adjacent
[0:44:15] water supply corridor. Any further discussion? Rachel Rojo, please.
[0:44:22] Ray Cawkins. Jason Brown. Ruth Pierce. Chris Reed. Yes.
[0:44:27] Sherry Bulmer yes thank you motion passes 5 to 0 thank you hey next on the agenda is
[0:44:40] an action item a request to adopt ordinance 2025-015 for annexation on property located
[0:44:49] at the 500 block of South Hills Road and we have Jonathan's been love our honey and
[0:44:56] Sony director welcome Jonathan thank you mayor members of the council this item is before
[0:45:01] you as directed from the meetings on June 10th of the planning and zoning commission in the
[0:45:06] council with July 28th. This is annexing the portion of essentially there's a little spot
[0:45:13] near a subdivision on the south side of that road. We provided you the ordinance and if
[0:45:18] you wish to pass it, it would be third and final. The language is within the staff report
[0:45:24] and I have the ordinance if you need the ordinance title as well. I'll stand for any questions.
[0:45:29] I'm ready to make a motion we've we've discussed this okay perfect I move that we
[0:45:43] dispense with the reading rules and put ordinance 2025 dash 015 on third and
[0:45:49] final reading by title only thank you Jason Brown second thank you motion by
[0:45:54] Chris Reed seconded by Jason Brown to dispense with the reading of the rules
[0:45:58] and putting up put ordinance number 2025 dash 015 and third on third and final
[0:46:05] reading by title only. Any discussion? Rachel Roquavo, please. Ruth Pierce. Yes.
[0:46:13] Yes. Chris Reed. Yes. Greg Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. And Sherry Wilmer. Yes.
[0:46:21] Thank you. Motion passes five to zero. Okay. Ordinance number 2025 dash 015.
[0:46:29] Nordance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho. Annexing
[0:46:34] certain real property below described, providing the zoning classification, therefore, and
[0:46:40] ordering the necessary area of impact in zoning district map amendment.
[0:46:45] Craig Hawkins.
[0:46:46] Mayor, I'd like to make a motion that we adopt Ordinance 02025-15 for annexation on property
[0:46:56] located at the 500 block of South Hills Road.
[0:47:00] Thank you, Chris Reed.
[0:47:01] I'll second.
[0:47:02] Thank you motion by Craig Hawkins seconded by Chris Reed to approve the ordinance number 2025 dash
[0:47:09] 015 annexation on property located at the 500 block of south ills road
[0:47:15] Any further discussion?
[0:47:18] Rachel row call vote please
[0:47:21] Brown yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, and Sherry Volmer
[0:47:30] Thank you motion passes five to zero
[0:47:32] Okay, next item on the agenda is an action item, a request to adopt Ordinance 2025-016
[0:47:43] for annexation on property located at the 1400 block of Sunway North, the Sunway Drive
[0:47:49] North, aka 2700 East, we have Jonathan back.
[0:47:55] Same process, this one's on the south side of Pulline, it's the church property, we got
[0:47:59] quite a few at that same time was in July so there's like five or six. Same process
[0:48:04] if you wish. Hey, what do you want to make a motion? Chris, Chris Reed, again
[0:48:13] something that we've already discussed so I'll make that motion and move that we
[0:48:16] dispense with the reading rules in place of Ordinance 2025-016 on third and final
[0:48:22] reading by title only. Thank you Jason Brown. Thank you. Motion by Chris Reed
[0:48:27] seconder by Jason Brown to dispense with the reading of the rules and put
[0:48:32] ordinance number 2025-016 on third and final reading by title only any
[0:48:39] discussion Rachel Roquevo please yes yes Jason Brown yes yes yes and
[0:48:49] and Chair Filmer.
[0:48:50] Oh, yes.
[0:48:53] Motion passes 5 to 0.
[0:49:00] Okay.
[0:49:01] Ordinance number 25.016.
[0:49:02] And ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho, annexing certain rail
[0:49:15] property below, describing providing the zoning classification, therefore, and ordering the
[0:49:20] the necessary area of impact and zoning district map amendments.
[0:49:25] Chris Reed.
[0:49:26] Move to adopt ordinance 2025-016 as presented.
[0:49:31] Thank you, Craig Hawkins.
[0:49:32] Just second death.
[0:49:33] Thank you, motion by Chris Reed.
[0:49:35] Second by Craig Hawkins to adopt ordinance 2025-016
[0:49:40] for annexation on property located
[0:49:42] at the 1400 block of Sunway Drive North.
[0:49:46] Any further discussion?
[0:49:49] Rachel Rocha, vote please.
[0:49:51] Ruth Pierce.
[0:49:52] Yes.
[0:49:53] Chris Reed.
[0:49:54] Yes.
[0:49:55] Great Hawkins.
[0:49:56] Yes.
[0:49:57] Jason Brown.
[0:50:05] Yes.
[0:50:06] And Sherry Vollmer.
[0:50:07] Yes.
[0:50:08] Thank you.
[0:50:09] Motion passes five to zero.
[0:50:11] Thank you, Jonathan.
[0:50:12] Okay.
[0:50:13] Next, on the agenda, we have an action item.
[0:50:15] We have a request to approve the guaranteed maximum price of $2,239,615 for the remodel in addition
[0:50:26] to the city pool and we have deputy city manager Mitch Humboldt, welcome Mitch.
[0:50:31] I feel like he just said everything I was going to ask you to do.
[0:50:35] Okay.
[0:50:36] No questions.
[0:50:37] No, I'm just kidding.
[0:50:39] We hired core construction to do the pool project a few months back.
[0:50:43] We signed the CMGC contract with them and then went through the bidding process and they prepared the attached GMP guaranteed maximum price.
[0:50:53] That price is $2,239,615.
[0:50:58] We have in the 2025 fiscal year budget,
[0:51:03] we included $1.2 million for this project,
[0:51:06] and then a few months back,
[0:51:08] we realized the estimates were going to come in a little bit higher,
[0:51:11] and that's when we came and authorized an additional use of $1.1 million
[0:51:15] from cast reserves for a total of $2.3 million.
[0:51:19] And so this project coming in at 2.2 is a little bit less than the 2.3 we had set aside
[0:51:25] for it.
[0:51:26] There's one thing that's not included in the GMP and I confirmed it late this afternoon,
[0:51:29] didn't get it into the staff report for you.
[0:51:32] And the door access and like data cabling stuff wasn't provided by the architect to the
[0:51:40] contractor in time to make the bids.
[0:51:43] And so that's not included in the GMP.
[0:51:45] That's $60,000 that we have left over will be more than enough to cover that once we
[0:51:49] to get that final adder put in here.
[0:51:51] So with that, I would just recommend council
[0:51:55] to approve the G&P and we will work.
[0:51:59] If we do approve it, I don't know if you noticed
[0:52:01] the schedule in here, start work on September 8th
[0:52:04] or 9th, I think was the day was, so.
[0:52:07] Coming right up.
[0:52:08] Excellent.
[0:52:09] Any questions for Mitch?
[0:52:11] Happy to answer questions.
[0:52:12] Yep.
[0:52:13] On this.
[0:52:15] Jason Brown.
[0:52:16] I don't have any, but I'll make a motion if we're ready.
[0:52:17] Good.
[0:52:18] Yes.
[0:52:19] the guaranteed maximum price of $2,239,615 for the remodel in addition to City Pool.
[0:52:28] Thank you, Craig Hawkins.
[0:52:30] Second.
[0:52:31] Thank you.
[0:52:32] Motion by Jason Brown, second by Craig Hawkins to approve the guaranteed maximum price of
[0:52:37] $2,239,2,239 for the remodel in addition to the City Pool.
[0:52:48] further discussion. Rachel Rokow please. Chris Reed. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes.
[0:52:58] And Sherry Volmer. Yeah. Thank you. Motion passes five to zero. Thank you Mitch. You. Okay.
[0:53:09] You're up for this one too. Action item a request to approve a letter of intent from wireless
[0:53:14] edge consultants LLC to purchase the former fire station number three property from the
[0:53:20] city for seven hundred thirty thousand. Mitch Humboldt. Okay so this is a project that we've
[0:53:26] been working on for several months now as we've we've sold properties before and it's
[0:53:33] a lengthy process. I have to go through with the state when the when the cities want to
[0:53:37] dispose of property. We've we went through that whole process we have the appraisal done
[0:53:42] back in March. We went through the resolutions that you have to adopt. We declared it access
[0:53:47] to our needs. We went all the way through and did an auction and then got no responsive
[0:53:52] bids to our request for bids. And so we brought that to the council a month or so ago. And
[0:54:02] we did get a couple of bids, but they weren't responsive. They didn't meet this as a criteria
[0:54:07] we put out there. So we rejected the bids and then the council asked that we go and negotiate
[0:54:11] with that high bidder.
[0:54:14] In the meantime, we also have an antenna, a cell tower,
[0:54:17] on the property.
[0:54:18] We have the tower, we lease space on the tower for an antenna.
[0:54:22] And in the meantime, we started negotiations with the antenna
[0:54:26] provider, our leaseholder, to relocate them
[0:54:29] to another location, because one of the things
[0:54:31] that the bidder wanted was the tower removed from the property.
[0:54:36] And so we need to move the antenna first,
[0:54:38] because we have an obligation for at least a couple
[0:54:40] more years on that. And then, so we're having these two parallel conversations. I'm working
[0:54:46] with our consultant Steep Steel on the antenna relocation, and then I've been working directly
[0:54:53] with the potential buyer of the property. In those conversations for the antenna relocation,
[0:54:59] when you get some of these names wrong, this is more complicated than I thought it was.
[0:55:05] So we have the antenna provider that we have a lease with,
[0:55:18] works with a partner of theirs on several locations around.
[0:55:22] And wireless edge consultants, LLC,
[0:55:24] is this partner to the antenna provider.
[0:55:30] Those guys and those negotiations in a counter offer
[0:55:35] to a relocation conversation, they just said,
[0:55:41] we just want to buy the property from you, including the tower.
[0:55:45] And then we will continue that lease with the antenna provider
[0:55:49] on their behalf.
[0:55:51] We weren't looking to sell it to them.
[0:55:53] Again, I was having those negotiations with somebody else,
[0:55:55] but they offered that back in exchange.
[0:55:58] Their offer was for $730,000.
[0:56:01] And if you'll recall, the high bid that we got that was not
[0:56:06] responsive was for $680,000.
[0:56:10] but it also had some things in there that we needed to do,
[0:56:12] relook, or remove the tower, and then do a level one
[0:56:15] environmental analysis.
[0:56:16] Those things would have cost us some money,
[0:56:18] so our net from that sale with that potential bidder
[0:56:22] might have been $50,000 less than that.
[0:56:24] We don't have any hard numbers for that,
[0:56:25] it's just a guessment at this point.
[0:56:28] So this offer for $730,000 might be as much as $100,000
[0:56:32] more than that offer would have been.
[0:56:35] At that dollar amount, we felt it would be irresponsible
[0:56:38] us not to share that with the council. We were negotiating with somebody else, these guys
[0:56:45] kind of came in unexpectedly from the outside, not in alignment with the direction you'd
[0:56:51] be given us. So we're back here to say, we've got this quandary. I think the offer that we
[0:56:59] got is a good one. It doesn't require us to do anything. We don't have to remove the tower.
[0:57:04] We don't have to do the level of environment analysis.
[0:57:07] We do need to go through a process to renegotiate an extension of the lease that then the buyer
[0:57:15] would take over.
[0:57:17] And that's it.
[0:57:19] Other offer, those guys are still out there.
[0:57:22] They still would like to buy the property.
[0:57:23] They still would like us to remove the tower.
[0:57:27] They would like us to do the level of environmental.
[0:57:30] And they have plans to then remarket it to whoever they can get to.
[0:57:36] I did send the council an email today that I got over the weekend, and that was an email
[0:57:41] from those buyers saying, here's what our plan is.
[0:57:45] And it basically didn't change the offer at all, just said, hey, we have this user that
[0:57:49] wants to go there, and it could be potentially good for the community and that part of town.
[0:57:56] So, that's kind of where we're at, I'm looking for some direction where you want me to go with this.
[0:58:02] We can accept the letter of intent from Wilder's Edge, or I can just tell them no thanks.
[0:58:10] We're going to keep working with our other bidder, and we'll go from there.
[0:58:16] So, I guess this is the part where I would answer questions, take your feedback,
[0:58:22] in whichever direction you want to go.
[0:58:24] I think the hundred thousand dollars personally makes a little sense.
[0:58:28] So I would say if I was asked for a recommendation, I would lean toward that.
[0:58:36] With that.
[0:58:37] Jason, answer the question.
[0:58:38] Yeah, I think it, you know, Mitch, as we talked about this last time, looking at it,
[0:58:44] I think, you know, the previous bidder was a non or the previous bidders were non-responsive,
[0:58:50] which then allowed us to go out and do have some negotiation with people.
[0:58:55] And so, I mean, in this scenario and situation, I would look at us, you know, going with edgewireless or the consultant there, looking at that property, if we don't have to put any more effort into disposing of this property, knowing that we followed the law, we did what we needed to do, and having non-responsive bids allows us to go through this process.
[0:59:23] And I should clarify to that point, we did follow all of our state required processes exhausted those and now we are just free to negotiate on the open market. So, anything we do here is, is fair game.
[0:59:36] And then the other thing I should say is that the appraisal we did back in March valued the property for $450,000. So these bids are both over that.
[0:59:46] Good it's both of them, but the one is certainly more than yet. Thank you any other comments or questions
[0:59:55] Jason do you want to make a motion
[0:59:57] I'd move
[1:00:01] To approve the letter of intent from wireless edge consultant L. They'll see to purchase the former fire station number three property for the from the
[1:00:09] For the amount of seven hundred and thirty thousand dollars. Thank you. Do I have a second?
[1:00:13] Thank you.
[1:00:14] Motion by Jason Brown, seconded by Craig Hawkins to approve a letter of intent from wireless
[1:00:21] edge consultant LLC to purchase the former fire station number three property from the
[1:00:27] city for $730,000.
[1:00:30] Any further discussion?
[1:00:34] Rachel Rolkelvo, please.
[1:00:36] Ruth Pierce.
[1:00:37] Yes.
[1:00:38] Chris Reed.
[1:00:39] Yes.
[1:00:40] Craig Hawkins.
[1:00:41] Yes.
[1:00:42] Jason Brown.
[1:00:43] Yes.
[1:00:45] motion passes five to zero. Okay. She said the lag time is really bad. Wait time. Okay.
[1:00:57] So that is it for our items of consideration. Before we move into our public hearings, we
[1:01:06] have three public hearings tonight. One on community block development block grants and
[1:01:12] to on budgets. If there's anybody in the audience that wishes to address City Council
[1:01:18] on something that is not on our agenda tonight, you're welcome to come up and you have two
[1:01:28] minutes. Please state your name and whether you're a resident of Twin Falls. Welcome. You're
[1:01:35] giving that to Travis. Okay. My name is Maria Hernandez. I am a, I live here in Twin Falls
[1:01:49] and I'm a proud follower of the Chief Standing Bear, the pocket Indian tribe, proud follower
[1:01:54] of the Imagine Dragons, proud father of the tribe of Judah.
[1:01:58] I'm here today because I wanted to present to Travis Rottweiler.
[1:02:01] I wanted to present to you this plaque an honor of Native American Indians.
[1:02:10] I just know that my ancestors are connected to you in some way.
[1:02:14] Just take my word for it.
[1:02:19] So the Yihan Noha on the top of that means prosperity and happiness.
[1:02:27] And so it's a song, a Navajo song, and it means something really rich as far as breaking
[1:02:38] into the atmosphere, prosperity and happiness to the one city of Twin Falls, Idaho.
[1:02:44] And I felt a need to release it.
[1:02:46] There's 129 days left at the end of this year, and you know what?
[1:02:51] You're doing the budget and everything, and I just want to believe I'm going to sing a
[1:02:55] little bit of this native song.
[1:02:58] Oh, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey
[1:03:47] Can you turn that off, Marie? Sorry. Thank you. Okay. Anybody else? Okay. Please state your
[1:04:02] name and whether you're a resident of Twin Falls and you have two minutes.
[1:04:07] My name is Amanda Leita and I am a resident of Twin Falls and I am coming as a representative
[1:04:12] of people that live in the Stonehengeen Field of Dream subdivision about the Eastland Drive
[1:04:18] roadway project. We are glad that Eastlands being widened, but we just want to make sure
[1:04:23] that some of the things that have happened right along our neighborhood are going to be
[1:04:27] resolved when the project is complete. There's a couple of items that now that the slope has
[1:04:32] been taken away. We want to make sure that that area is going to be retained so that our
[1:04:36] backyards don't fall into Eastlands. So there is no longer a one to three vertical
[1:04:41] horizon for the slope there. So we just want to make sure that that's done so that our adjacent
[1:04:47] properties are protected. Because of the proximity of the roadway and that being taken away, now
[1:04:54] that sidewalk that runs along our subdivision is sloping towards Eastland now and that's
[1:05:00] kind of a danger. We want to make sure that the panels they're replaced, that now that
[1:05:05] it's doing that, so that's something we wanted to address. We also wanted to address that now
[1:05:11] that the landscape strip is gone. There is no protection there if some child trips or falls.
[1:05:17] they're going to go right into traffic,
[1:05:19] and it's going to be hard for them to get out of traffic.
[1:05:22] So because that sidewalk is right,
[1:05:24] there used to be a six foot or four foot strip of grass
[1:05:27] that kind of protected if someone fell down that slope,
[1:05:30] but now it's gone.
[1:05:31] It's the scotter is right there,
[1:05:34] so a little kid could ride off the sidewalk
[1:05:36] or someone could trip and fall and go right into Eastland,
[1:05:38] and it's gonna be hard for them to go up.
[1:05:40] So there's also at the very end of the subdivision
[1:05:43] where our overflow for the water is,
[1:05:45] that area now has been cut off.
[1:05:48] So I have a letter to provide you
[1:05:49] that kind of has all those specifics,
[1:05:51] but I know that a lot of this is being addressed,
[1:05:53] but we just wanna make sure as a neighborhood
[1:05:55] that our concerns for the finalization of the project
[1:05:58] are gonna be completed in the satisfactory manner,
[1:06:00] so that there's not danger for pedestrians or flooding
[1:06:04] or our backyard being, you know,
[1:06:07] a roading because the slope is no longer there.
[1:06:10] And you've shared these concerns with our staff already?
[1:06:13] I think so, yes, and I have a letter as well that I'll leave.
[1:06:16] Travis, did you have something?
[1:06:18] Okay.
[1:06:21] Thank you.
[1:06:24] Hey, is there anybody else in the audience
[1:06:26] that wishes to address City Council?
[1:06:31] Please come up, sir.
[1:06:36] I'm a proud resident of Twin Falls.
[1:06:40] I'd travel up and down from Lowe's to my house,
[1:06:44] and lately I'm very concerned about the amount of graffiti
[1:06:49] that is out there on the boxes.
[1:06:51] I don't know if the council has addressed that
[1:06:53] or we got our police enforcement addressing this,
[1:06:56] but really sad to see our city get this graffiti
[1:07:01] and it seems like it's spreading.
[1:07:03] I would be happy to, I guess,
[1:07:09] find out what the rules are
[1:07:11] or what is going to be done to address this issue.
[1:07:16] Thank you.
[1:07:16] I know our code enforcement has been out
[1:07:18] and actually notified property owners
[1:07:22] of graffiti on their property.
[1:07:24] And I just noticed them the other day,
[1:07:27] so I did also reach out.
[1:07:29] So they are aware of it.
[1:07:31] If you have something specific,
[1:07:33] you can call code enforcement
[1:07:36] and they would get out there
[1:07:38] and at least notify the property owner.
[1:07:41] Okay, appreciate it.
[1:07:42] Thank you.
[1:07:43] Thank you very much.
[1:07:47] Maybe our police chief since code enforcement isn't here,
[1:07:49] is that what you're doing, Matt?
[1:07:51] Okay, perfect.
[1:07:53] Anybody else in the audience that wishes
[1:07:55] to address City Council on something,
[1:07:57] not on today's agenda?
[1:08:00] Okay, scene no one, advisory board reports.
[1:08:08] Anything?
[1:08:12] Okay, no meeting next week.
[1:08:15] It's Monday is Labor Day, Tuesday.
[1:08:18] We are not having a meeting.
[1:08:20] Josh wanted me to remind everybody
[1:08:22] that we will be having a large 9-11 ceremony again
[1:08:27] at the Visitor Center with all the bells and whistles,
[1:08:30] the big flag, law enforcement, fire department,
[1:08:34] a bunch of city staff, so it's a great event,
[1:08:38] so we hope to see you there.
[1:08:42] Oh, and Wednesday morning is the state of the city.
[1:08:44] If you haven't bought your tickets,
[1:08:46] you can do that through the chamber.
[1:08:48] You want breakfast, a ticket,
[1:08:50] if you don't want breakfast, it will be free.
[1:08:52] Starts at 7 a.m., anything else?
[1:08:58] Anything from the city manager's office?
[1:08:59] Well, if you keep going, you can do my full report.
[1:09:01] Okay.
[1:09:02] You've done amazing.
[1:09:03] Welcome.
[1:09:04] Yeah.
[1:09:05] You've got to be Vanna up there.
[1:09:07] I like it.
[1:09:09] The last thing that we have is on September 4th, it was on your consent calendar, but the
[1:09:15] Employee Recognition Committee is going to be recognizing employees for their time.
[1:09:20] That's going to start at noon.
[1:09:21] It's going to be in the city ban shell and then as you had shared mayor, we will not be
[1:09:27] meeting on Labor Day, so our next scheduled meeting after this evening will be on September
[1:09:33] at a regular start time.
[1:09:34] Perfect.
[1:09:35] Thank you.
[1:09:37] Okay.
[1:09:38] So we're going to move on to our public hearings.
[1:09:39] Do you guys want to take a quick break or five minutes?
[1:09:46] Okay.
[1:09:47] Yeah.
[1:10:17] The question is, are you?
[1:10:18] Yeah.
[1:10:19] Okay.
[1:10:20] Thank you.
[1:10:21] We're reconvening our meeting and we're moving into the public hearings.
[1:10:25] So our first public hearing is, I should read the rules first, so what's going to happen?
[1:10:32] These are not land use hearings, so we won't have an applicant.
[1:10:36] So city staff will present, make their presentation, and then we'll ask any questions, and once
[1:10:42] we ask some questions, public hearing will be opened, that means anybody from the audience
[1:10:47] who wishes to address that particular item can come up to the podium, state your name, and
[1:10:54] whether you're resident of Twin Falls,
[1:10:56] and then you have two minutes to comment.
[1:10:59] Once all the public comments are concluded,
[1:11:01] staff can answer or clarify any comments.
[1:11:05] Once that's done, no further testimony or comments
[1:11:10] from the audience will be allowed,
[1:11:12] and then council will have open discussion
[1:11:14] and take action.
[1:11:16] So our first item is an action item,
[1:11:18] a request for approval of the fiscal year 2025
[1:11:22] Community Development Block Grant or CDBG Annual Action Plan and the 25-29 Consolidated Plan
[1:11:31] and we have our P&C Director Jonathan Stemlove.
[1:11:34] Welcome.
[1:11:35] Thank you, Mayor, members of the Council.
[1:11:39] This item I recognize is 199 pages.
[1:11:42] You should have just added one to get to 200 but I'm not going to go through it page by
[1:11:46] page obviously.
[1:11:47] Now what you have in front of you are two different items so it can be in one motion though.
[1:11:52] The 25 to 29 consolidated plan has a lot of,
[1:11:57] both of them actually have a lot of federal requirements
[1:12:01] to report on.
[1:12:03] They go through a lot of analysis of essentially
[1:12:05] information weak glean from our federal partners,
[1:12:09] basically the census and some state data
[1:12:12] as well as some local data.
[1:12:14] Some of that's not available to our specific area,
[1:12:17] so we end up getting lumped into region, the region.
[1:12:20] So we include like Lane County, Twin Falls,
[1:12:23] there's like six counties or seven counties.
[1:12:25] One we're dealing with some of that data.
[1:12:27] So if you're going through that entire report,
[1:12:29] paying attention to where other information was gleaned from,
[1:12:32] essentially it's the ACS American Community Survey,
[1:12:36] which is always like four years looking backwards.
[1:12:39] So they kind of go from 16 to 20
[1:12:41] because the 24 year is not quite released,
[1:12:43] it actually comes out in December.
[1:12:44] So we're always a little bit behind
[1:12:46] on some of those numbers.
[1:12:47] And then some of the other numbers we get,
[1:12:49] we're in with that Southern Idaho area.
[1:12:52] So it's not specific to Twin Falls,
[1:12:53] but it also includes Blaine County,
[1:12:55] which has some Valley, Ketchum, Hayley, all of that.
[1:12:59] So as you're going through it, if you're reading it,
[1:13:01] I'm hoping you don't select a certain page test questions
[1:13:03] on it because I only read it once,
[1:13:05] so I don't have it memorized,
[1:13:06] and it was a pretty quick read.
[1:13:08] But really what we're going after,
[1:13:10] I'll just give a brief overview of it,
[1:13:13] is we're focusing our efforts on continuing our efforts
[1:13:16] on our downtown low income and low and moderate income
[1:13:21] census track for our block, which is our downtown core.
[1:13:25] It has residential areas.
[1:13:28] It has a lot of our services.
[1:13:30] City Hall, the library, which many people utilize
[1:13:35] as the location to get services or to get information.
[1:13:39] So we have been, ever since we went through the amendment
[1:13:44] back in 2022 we focused our CDBG efforts in that area and to that we have generated the current
[1:13:54] project which I failed to actually put in like a cool looking good looking map and so I just have
[1:14:01] the pictures from the event if you want to go to page 148 that I wrote down I believe in the packet
[1:14:10] of the plan itself.
[1:14:12] Yeah, the plan itself of like actually of the whole packet,
[1:14:15] I think, is I got the PDF.
[1:14:17] And it would look like it would say 146 at the bottom, right?
[1:14:21] If you can swap it over yet.
[1:14:23] So this is this actually is taken from our event
[1:14:26] at the library, we received comments on it.
[1:14:27] This is what we're calling the City Park Library Plaza.
[1:14:32] It is a reconstruction one of the bathroom,
[1:14:34] which is currently underway.
[1:14:36] We have an idea to create an outdoor learning space
[1:14:39] for the library, they end up using a lot of the park,
[1:14:42] and we also have a lot of patrons that utilize going
[1:14:45] to the park and the library at the same time.
[1:14:48] So the idea is to create an outdoor learning space here
[1:14:51] within the street, reconstructing the playground
[1:14:56] to an all access playground for all abilities and ages,
[1:15:02] and then a few other elements around the park.
[1:15:04] This is the concept that we have submitted
[1:15:06] to the federal to essentially HUD as well as our state partners
[1:15:10] with SHPO, the State Historic Preservation Office,
[1:15:13] because we all come under some very specifics, part 24,
[1:15:17] CFR, the federal government.
[1:15:19] I'm just going to name it off.
[1:15:20] That's the one.
[1:15:20] And then they kind of say, you have to follow
[1:15:22] all these other guidelines.
[1:15:24] We actually get a lot of approval from the different levels.
[1:15:27] This is the park plaza concept that we're going after,
[1:15:30] that we're going to be open to continue to do.
[1:15:32] And that's what we've identified.
[1:15:34] in the 25 to 29 five-year plan, as well as going through this area of town and identifying
[1:15:44] needed sidewalk replacement.
[1:15:47] Any areas that were on this map or downtown area, this is where the park is here and then
[1:15:52] the library would be here.
[1:15:54] So anywhere in that five, six-block area, then we have City Hall, it's closer down here,
[1:16:00] actually that building.
[1:16:04] We can help facilitate people to get to the services they need from a public standpoint.
[1:16:10] So those are the two main projects we've identified in this plan is public infrastructure that we
[1:16:15] can construct and then facilitate a good transition for people to get there.
[1:16:21] In a nutshell, that's what the program is about.
[1:16:24] Within it, there's a whole lot of other information about the cost and the budget.
[1:16:28] We receive around 350,000 on average a year.
[1:16:32] actually going down because of the way the federal government calculates it by
[1:16:35] population and the number of cities. We're actually receiving less money every
[1:16:39] year, just a little bit. Trying to think of any other items I'm missing. We went
[1:16:47] through the, we did two actual events. One of the library in the plaza or in their
[1:16:53] entrance area and then we did another at City Park for people that were using the
[1:16:58] park during one of their events and others that were there to gain input on
[1:17:02] on both of these project ideas.
[1:17:05] All of that input is within the packet.
[1:17:08] We also received some letters from citizens
[1:17:11] on their concerns about the plaza
[1:17:13] and the plaza being closing Hanson Street
[1:17:16] to basically to car traffic,
[1:17:20] having it be primarily a,
[1:17:22] essentially like a festival type street
[1:17:24] that you see down main street
[1:17:25] so that it can be used for that outdoor learning space
[1:17:27] for the library and the park events.
[1:17:30] So we received comments on both of those
[1:17:31] because that was what we're contemplating is just reconstructing slash changing that road
[1:17:36] to being more of a pedestrian plaza instead of a roadway.
[1:17:39] We have previously done some work with the engineering department to understand how many
[1:17:43] vehicles are driving up in on Hanson.
[1:17:46] At the time it was around 300.
[1:17:48] In talking with our engineering department it's probably less than 500.
[1:17:51] That's a daily count, average daily count.
[1:17:53] Most of those being the destination of the library.
[1:17:56] So we would still facilitate that destination.
[1:17:59] we would actually still maintain all of our public utilities within the roadway as well.
[1:18:05] So that's kind of the idea of the projects, what we've included and the dollars that have
[1:18:10] gone through it for the next five years to be utilized for those two things.
[1:18:17] So just to be clear, if we approve this action plan, then the vacation of Hanson Street is
[1:18:28] a done deal or there's a more process to go through.
[1:18:32] They'll see more process actually, so there's gonna be a couple more processes as we look
[1:18:38] to find the design of what the plaza exactly will look like. That's a future thing that would
[1:18:42] come to you to approve a contract to look at it, to have what it looks like as well as any
[1:18:47] construction plans for you. Closing the street but maintaining the ownership by the city can
[1:18:54] be done in certain circumstances by the city engineer. Obviously we're not closing a public
[1:18:59] like that without having a conversation with you on what we're going to put in
[1:19:02] there. Right. This is us saying this is our goal. We're gonna work towards that goal
[1:19:06] of the foreseeable future, basically meeting with you as certain points. Wonder
[1:19:13] the contract to what it looks like to actually implement the plan. You'd have
[1:19:18] two other opportunities to talk about what that would look like. Okay. Any
[1:19:23] questions other questions for Jonathan? We have an estimation if there'd be a
[1:19:29] a loss of parking space or is that going to be a factor?
[1:19:35] Yeah.
[1:19:36] So when we're talking parking along Hanson Street there, it's parallel parking.
[1:19:41] We've judged around between 13 and 15 or as many as 17, depending on where the closure
[1:19:47] happens of the parallel parking spaces that are right there.
[1:19:52] One of the, and a few of the comments we have is those parking spaces are actually right next
[1:19:56] for the playgrounds going to be.
[1:19:57] So it actually is not a bad idea to have parking not next to where the playground is because
[1:20:02] of the kids.
[1:20:03] So yeah, there are 17 spaces that could be removed or basically gone from our estimation
[1:20:11] as we've actually walked that park for the last four months checking out the bathroom.
[1:20:17] Utilization is probably about 50%.
[1:20:18] So when we're looking at it morning or afternoon, we have about eight, nine cars.
[1:20:26] however I have is they're street parking on the other sides of Hanson or not on Hanson on
[1:20:31] them sixth and fifth or that is far less than 50 percent. I know the schools now in at St.
[1:20:40] Eds and they use it a little bit more. We don't have a parking number problem. What we do end
[1:20:46] up having a lot of times in Twin Falls is parking right in front of the door where you
[1:20:50] want to go. We have that downtown. We recognize that that is something. We have parking around
[1:20:56] that can handle and that can utilize those 17 spaces nearby, but yet it won't be
[1:21:01] just at the library. And some of those patrons that are parking there oftentimes
[1:21:06] are sitting in their cars using the Wi-Fi or doing something, not necessarily always
[1:21:10] going to the library, although that does certainly happen. So moving that parking
[1:21:15] from the playground area we think is a safe bet as well as we have parking
[1:21:21] around that can accommodate understanding there are 17 spaces that might go away.
[1:21:26] I would like to acknowledge that.
[1:21:28] With larger events at the park,
[1:21:31] sometimes that is more of an issue than like a normal day.
[1:21:36] It could be and that's the comment I'm hearing.
[1:21:39] Yeah, it could be and that sometimes that road is closed for those events occasionally
[1:21:43] because they have a dumpster or something else in the way it's not parking anywhere.
[1:21:47] Yep, 17 parking spaces is something we've acknowledged.
[1:21:52] We feel like there's enough around.
[1:21:54] certainly point towards other areas where we can put parking or build it if you wish at
[1:21:59] as my conversations with people's 12,000 bucks of space is what you end up paying for
[1:22:03] a surface parking. Okay, perfect. Okay, any other questions or comments? Okay, I would...
[1:22:10] So what you're looking at is a motion that takes care of both the grant action plan and
[1:22:16] the consolidated. Correct. Okay, perfect. So anybody want to make that motion? We're gonna
[1:22:22] have the public hearing. Oh, yes. Sorry. You know, snap, snap. Okay. So, um, since we have
[1:22:31] no other questions for Jonathan, I will open up the public hearing. If there's anybody in
[1:22:36] the audience that was just to address City Council on the community development block
[1:22:42] grad action plan or the 25 to 29 consolidated plan, please come up to the podium. Okay, seeing
[1:22:55] No one. Nothing else you want to add?
[1:23:00] Okay. I'm going to close the public hearing.
[1:23:03] Now council discussion.
[1:23:07] Chris Reed.
[1:23:08] I'll make a motion if we're ready.
[1:23:10] Move that we approve the 2025 Community Development Block
[1:23:13] Grant annual action plan and the 2025 to 2029
[1:23:19] consolidated plan as presented.
[1:23:21] Thank you, Craig Hawkins.
[1:23:22] Second.
[1:23:23] Thank you motion by Chris Reed,
[1:23:25] second by Craig Hawkins to approve the fiscal year 2025
[1:23:29] Community Block Development Community Development Block Grant Annual Action Plan in the 2025-2029
[1:23:38] Consolidated Plan.
[1:23:40] Any further discussion?
[1:23:42] Rachel Roquevo, please.
[1:23:44] Ruth Pierce.
[1:23:45] Yes.
[1:23:46] Chris Reed.
[1:23:47] Yes.
[1:23:48] Craig Hawkins.
[1:23:49] Yes.
[1:23:50] Jason Brown.
[1:23:52] Yes.
[1:23:53] And Sherry Bulmer.
[1:23:54] Thank you.
[1:23:55] Motion passes 5-0.
[1:23:56] Our next public hearing is a public hearing on the use of $24,980 a foregone revenue in
[1:24:07] the 2025-2026 fiscal year to cover ongoing operation and maintenance costs beginning on
[1:24:14] October 1, 2025, ending on September 30, 2026, and we have our city manager Travis
[1:24:22] Thank you members of the council.
[1:24:25] Tonight is the beginning of the end of the fiscal year 26 budgeting process.
[1:24:34] And now just as you've had the conversations and you receive presentations,
[1:24:38] most of the time there were not any actions that you had to take.
[1:24:43] Tonight you'll take two actions as prescribed by Idaho code and we'll do them in
[1:24:51] the proper sequence. The first is the public hearing as described by the mayor on the use of the foregone balance of
[1:24:58] $324,980 to cover ongoing operational expenses and just by way of little history. As you know, the legislature has often
[1:25:11] had conversations about the appropriateness and the use of foregone balances by cities. And the foregone balance is very
[1:25:20] simply, monies that could have been collected in the past by taking the statutory maximums,
[1:25:27] but where the city opted not to.
[1:25:30] The Idaho Tax Commission creates this fictitious bank of count of monies that could be available
[1:25:36] for you to incorporate into your budgets for very specific purposes.
[1:25:41] Prior to 2021, you could, as a city, go and capture that entire sum in a single year.
[1:25:50] And after some cities did that and their sums collected were significant and the property
[1:25:56] tax rate grew significantly, the legislature came back in and made that change in which
[1:26:05] they said that 1% can be used, 1% equivalent revenue is how we come up with that can be used
[1:26:12] to cover ongoing operational costs or the city can collect 3% to cover capital costs.
[1:26:18] The difference is 1% is built into our annual operating budgets moving forward.
[1:26:23] The 3% goes away once you've collected and paid off the capital acquisition costs.
[1:26:31] So what the city has been doing as we've watched the legislature is we've been clawing back
[1:26:35] some portion of that money that we could have taxed in the past but elected not to.
[1:26:40] And so inside of our process now, you are required to do two things.
[1:26:45] First, you are required to have a public hearing, which was also part of the 2021 legislative process,
[1:26:53] and you'll have a resolution which is actually part of the 2016 process. So the resolution was
[1:26:59] handed out to you. You have that resolution to move forward after the public hearing.
[1:27:07] Thank you. Any questions for Travis before he
[1:27:09] the public hearing.
[1:27:15] Yes or not?
[1:27:16] Okay.
[1:27:17] So I'm going to be opening up the public hearing discussing specifically the use of $324,980
[1:27:25] of the foregone balance.
[1:27:28] So I'll open up the public hearing.
[1:27:31] Is there anybody in the audience who wishes to address the city council?
[1:27:35] Please come down.
[1:27:37] Welcome, Francis.
[1:27:38] for us ourselves with a resident of Twin Falls.
[1:27:42] From what I understand on this 300 and some thousand,
[1:27:46] I really wish it would be used.
[1:27:48] It's part of it since it's not always in the budget
[1:27:51] from what I understand.
[1:27:52] For lights at the pickleball court
[1:27:54] that didn't get approved a few weeks back,
[1:27:58] they were short about 100,000 and it would should be nice
[1:28:00] if we could have lights on the pickleball courts
[1:28:03] at the restory, so that's, thank you, okay?
[1:28:09] anybody else in the audience that wishes to address City Council on the foregone balance.
[1:28:15] Okay, seeing no one, Travis, do you have any response to that? Anything you want to add?
[1:28:25] So again, while I wish that we could use these funds in a manner that our organizations off
[1:28:33] it, the Idaho legislature has said it must go specifically towards operation and maintenance
[1:28:38] costs as a result of the limitation of 3%. So as we've seen the municipal cost index grow larger
[1:28:46] since COVID than that 3% threshold. A lot of these things will go into cover operational costs.
[1:28:56] Things like increase oil costs associated with shift ceiling as you saw that grow quite more
[1:29:00] than a million dollars over the last few years. There are other options that the city has for
[1:29:04] for lighting at pickleball courts and the other items
[1:29:08] that were included on the capitalists are not funded
[1:29:12] and will work towards those ends.
[1:29:15] Thank you.
[1:29:16] Hey, so I am gonna close the public hearing.
[1:29:19] Come on down Spencer, so timely.
[1:29:23] Thank you.
[1:29:25] I'd rather that I was here than doing what you were doing,
[1:29:29] so I appreciate that too.
[1:29:31] Okay, so we are on the second public hearing,
[1:29:34] Just so you know.
[1:29:35] Okay.
[1:29:36] So the item is, I close the public hearing.
[1:29:41] So the action item we're asked to do
[1:29:44] is an adoption of the resolution 2025-014.
[1:29:50] And I can read that.
[1:29:52] It's a resolution of the city council,
[1:29:55] the city of Twin Falls declaring the intent to levy
[1:29:58] and he's $324,980 of foregone property tax funds.
[1:30:04] in fiscal year 2526 and declaring the purpose for which the foregone funds are budgeted.
[1:30:10] So I would need a motion to that effect to adopt that resolution.
[1:30:15] Chris Reed.
[1:30:17] I move that we adopt resolution 2025-014 as presented this evening.
[1:30:23] Thank you.
[1:30:24] We have a second.
[1:30:25] Jason Brown.
[1:30:26] Second.
[1:30:27] Thank you.
[1:30:28] Motion by Chris Reed.
[1:30:29] Second by Jason Brown to adopt resolution 2024-014.
[1:30:33] for declaring the intent to levy and use $324,980 of Fordham property tax funds. Any further
[1:30:44] discussion? Rachel, roll call vote, please.
[1:30:47] Ray Cockens? Yes. Jason Brown? Yes. Chris Reed? Yes. Ruth Pierce? Yes. Spencer Cutler? Yes.
[1:30:54] and Sherry Volmer.
[1:30:58] Yeah.
[1:30:58] Thank you.
[1:30:59] Motion passes six to zero.
[1:31:02] Thank you.
[1:31:05] OK, so next public hearing, I've got a lot of papers up here.
[1:31:13] OK, action item, it's a public hearing
[1:31:16] on the fiscal year 2526 budget for the city of Twin Falls, Idaho.
[1:31:21] And again, we have our city manager, Travis, welcome.
[1:31:25] Thank you.
[1:31:25] So this is the last official and formal step that you will take
[1:31:30] associated with the development of the fiscal year 2526 budget.
[1:31:41] Our fiscal year, as you know, will begin on October 1st,
[1:31:45] and of 2025, and it will conclude on September 30th of 2026.
[1:31:52] Our calendar aligns with the federal calendar,
[1:31:55] but it does not align with the state
[1:31:57] where the state's fiscal year begins on the 1st of July
[1:32:01] and will go tell June 30th.
[1:32:04] Our budget is regulated by the Idaho Code
[1:32:10] and here are the relevant, relevant code sections
[1:32:13] that need to be thought of when we're going forward
[1:32:17] and creating the budget.
[1:32:17] And I can share with you that it is compliant
[1:32:20] with all sections of the Idaho Code.
[1:32:22] And as we move forward, I'm gonna go relatively
[1:32:27] quickly. Because while some may be joining us for the first time in this conversation, I
[1:32:33] appreciate that this is your 14th conversation this year on the budget. And that is far more
[1:32:42] than what most organizations will go through. But really what we did was we started by saying,
[1:32:49] let's make sure that we're all looking at Twin Falls through the same collection of lenses.
[1:32:54] And this is the statistical data that we used.
[1:32:57] And we updated this data as we went through the process
[1:33:00] because the home values are going to change.
[1:33:02] The unemployment rates are going to change.
[1:33:04] But a couple of the things that I think are really important,
[1:33:09] always to keep a top of mind is while the city of Twin Falls
[1:33:13] has a heads and beds population of just under 57,000 people.
[1:33:20] Our community grows and swells to nearly 116,000 people
[1:33:25] every single day.
[1:33:27] We know that by tracking the number of people
[1:33:30] that cross the bridge or access the city of Tuan Falls
[1:33:33] through any of the other points.
[1:33:35] And I-T-D has some amazing traffic counters
[1:33:37] that we're able to dial into.
[1:33:39] And so when you start looking at the total number of cars
[1:33:42] that are coming into our community,
[1:33:44] it is easy for us to see how we more than double in size.
[1:33:49] We also can take a look at our per capita sales
[1:33:52] and retail sales in comparison to our per capita income
[1:33:54] because it is impossible to have per capita retail sales
[1:33:58] $7,000 more than you have of your per capita income.
[1:34:03] And I saw my friend Coach Ben Benoit in the audience
[1:34:10] wearing a really ugly hat, but we'll forgive him.
[1:34:14] But you know, most of those folks are going to Costco, right?
[1:34:17] And they're going to other places inside of our community.
[1:34:20] And that sales tax is being generated
[1:34:23] and that generation is going back to the state
[1:34:26] because inside of the city of Twin Falls,
[1:34:28] where we may generate more than $100 million in sales tax
[1:34:32] that goes to the state of Idaho.
[1:34:35] It is not held by the city.
[1:34:38] In fact, we get about $5.5 million returned.
[1:34:42] So we build a budget that is designed for a community
[1:34:48] of 116,000 people.
[1:34:51] And it is largely funded through user rates,
[1:34:55] such as water and sewer, as well as property tax dollars.
[1:35:00] And if those are the three pillars
[1:35:01] that we have to fund local government,
[1:35:04] and those three pillars are only paid for by residents,
[1:35:08] every second person that comes into the city
[1:35:10] if to in falls gets services for free.
[1:35:13] And this is where I will share that it is important
[1:35:16] for the legislature to really look at local option sales tax
[1:35:19] for communities like Twin Falls,
[1:35:21] so that as we continue to grow and we provide services,
[1:35:25] it is not based upon the backs
[1:35:27] of just the citizens who live here.
[1:35:31] We use economic indicators.
[1:35:32] We talked about housing and housing costs
[1:35:34] and the difficulty to acquire housing in comparison
[1:35:38] to how our median wage is growing.
[1:35:41] We talk about where Twin Falls stands
[1:35:43] and housing costs in comparison to other places in state of Idaho,
[1:35:47] we talk about the type labor market,
[1:35:49] where there is still one opening out of every four
[1:35:54] available jobs.
[1:35:56] And that Idaho and Twin Falls are at full employment.
[1:35:59] And the ability to attract quality employees
[1:36:03] is more and more difficult.
[1:36:04] And so that's why our best attraction tool
[1:36:07] is not to lose folks.
[1:36:09] That we want to retain the talent that we have.
[1:36:12] we want to be the employer of choice,
[1:36:14] and that's why we've unapologetically said,
[1:36:17] we're going to take care of our employees as we move forward.
[1:36:20] Which falls into line with the different overarching budget
[1:36:23] strategies that we put forth, where you can see,
[1:36:25] we want to be the employer of choice.
[1:36:28] But we're not just spending money for the sake of spending money,
[1:36:30] it is directly tied to a strategic plan,
[1:36:34] where that strategic plan built in concert
[1:36:36] with our community in 2012,
[1:36:38] updated in 2017, 2018, and going through another revision right now to make sure that
[1:36:46] it aligns with the community that we all want to live in.
[1:36:50] And then we want to make sure that it's nimble, it's stable, it has the ability to adapt to
[1:36:54] an ever-changing environment, and it's something that our citizens can afford.
[1:36:58] And so we take a look at what is the tax rate going to be.
[1:37:01] We want to make sure that we're minimizing utility rate increases.
[1:37:04] earlier, we had the opportunity to present a forward thoughtful thinking that we planned
[1:37:09] out several years ago by taking dollars and shifting them from debt service into capital
[1:37:15] funds so we can continue to build upon the capital expenditures and have resources to
[1:37:22] build water facilities and water plants.
[1:37:25] So the total taxable value of the city is going to grow by slightly more than $200 million.
[1:37:31] When you include the Urban Renewal Agency into this, the City of Twin Falls crested over
[1:37:36] $7 billion of total taxable value for the first time this year.
[1:37:40] You can see that our total net expenses are down by about $7 million, largely in the
[1:37:47] tax-supported funds, and that is a result of lots of one-time dollar capital projects
[1:37:53] being completed, whether it has through the state and revolving fund that we received from
[1:38:01] the federal government, or it was from the $8.3 million Eastland project that right now
[1:38:06] our community is questioning why we accepted that.
[1:38:09] I promise to come November will be a better place.
[1:38:13] And then also you'll notice in the non-tech supported funds, those enterprise funds that
[1:38:17] receive a user rate to cover their cost, we're going to be the largest increase
[1:38:22] associated with that is over time we've collected impact fees and there's a
[1:38:27] significant road project that's funded with impact fees as is the end of this
[1:38:31] upcoming budget. So as we share during the bond presentation again a 0% increase
[1:38:37] for water, a 5% increase in sewer, a 2.5% increase for sanitation and recycling,
[1:38:43] And you can see the different taxes that we look to collect.
[1:38:49] Here's how the City of Twin Falls has grown over a period of time.
[1:38:55] And then you can see that our tax rate has leveled out since about 2023 through 2026.
[1:39:04] It's been relatively flat and it had gone downward significantly since 2020.
[1:39:11] In fact, I think in the late 20 teens, we had a tax rate right around 8 or 4 per thousand.
[1:39:22] So we've done the work to be able to make sure that we are capturing the resources needed
[1:39:30] to be able to support local government functions and driving the tax rate down as not only do
[1:39:38] we find more efficient returns but also trying to make sure that we're creating an environment
[1:39:44] that is still a place that's affordable to live.
[1:39:50] We like to compare ourselves on apologetically to other places.
[1:39:57] We're competitive by nature and we want to see how does our tax rate compare to others
[1:40:02] and so we provide this information.
[1:40:05] What I like about the information that we provide is that we can verify that source.
[1:40:09] We can show you exactly how we came up with the data.
[1:40:12] You can see that on a median valued home inside the City of Twin Falls, that median valued
[1:40:18] home pays less in property taxes for municipal services than the cities of Caldwell, Pocatello,
[1:40:24] Jerome, Lewiston, and Idaho Falls.
[1:40:27] We exclude Boise, Meridian, and Nampa, intentionally, because those cities are not considered to
[1:40:35] to be full services by the classical definition.
[1:40:39] Highways are maintained by the Ada County Highway Department.
[1:40:43] So the city is a Boise and Meridian no longer
[1:40:46] have to cover the road costs.
[1:40:48] And then recently the city of Napa gave up its fire department
[1:40:52] and it turned into a larger fire district.
[1:40:55] So the city of Napa no longer offers fire services
[1:40:58] to their community.
[1:40:59] It is done by and through a fire district.
[1:41:02] So we compared just the city taxes.
[1:41:04] Now this doesn't include all taxes, it doesn't include the county or the ambulance district
[1:41:10] or the weed abatement district or the college southern Idaho or the Twin Falls school district.
[1:41:15] We don't have control over what they levy.
[1:41:17] We have control over what we do and that's why we focus on our spending alone.
[1:41:23] So again, I said everything is connected to the city strategic plan.
[1:41:28] Here are the eight focus areas, seven on the outside going to the internal organization
[1:41:34] Because we at our heart, you've heard us share that we're a service organization and
[1:41:39] that we provide services directly to our citizens through the talented men and women that are
[1:41:46] part of our team.
[1:41:48] And it's because of their efforts and their work.
[1:41:51] Our community is one of the most local places in Idaho.
[1:41:58] And with that, you can see that our largest cost is associated with personnel.
[1:42:04] When you're a human organization delivering services through human hands, it makes sense
[1:42:09] that that's going to be your largest cost.
[1:42:11] Our second largest cost is going to be in capital, providing our employees with the tools
[1:42:15] and the resources that they need, and also making sure that we're updating our infrastructure,
[1:42:21] our very platform in which we can continue to grow and expand our local economy, create
[1:42:25] better jobs, and retain kids, as mine just went to wherever they went, right?
[1:42:34] other eye, lots of corn. Operation, the maintenance, transfers, and debt services make up the other
[1:42:40] expenditures that are part of our total budget. So we break it into two pieces. We break it
[1:42:45] into the tax-supported funds, and then we break it into the enterprise funds. And so
[1:42:50] inside of the tax-supported funds, you can see that it goes into the General Fund Street
[1:42:54] Fund, Capital Fund, the Airport Fund, and then a whole series of, you know, non-major tax-supported
[1:43:02] funds. There's several categories and inside of your ordinance you have that detail list.
[1:43:08] Of that you can see the sources where property tax is the largest source that funds the tax
[1:43:16] supported funds. It's about 55.1% of the tax supported funds, but of the total budget it's
[1:43:22] less than a third. So the rest of the fees are associated with transfers, franchise fees,
[1:43:30] and other sources of revenue, if you've ever had a chance to look at Matt and Brianna's
[1:43:37] detailed revenues, I've lost track, I think it was like something like 342 different revenue
[1:43:44] sources across the organization, it's fairly significant, and they do a great job in the
[1:43:51] enterprise funds are those, again, that receive a fee and it operates like its own small business.
[1:44:01] So we have the larger ones broke out.
[1:44:05] You can see the non-major enterprise funds
[1:44:07] only equal to about 2.1%.
[1:44:09] So we don't break it down that granular,
[1:44:12] but you can see water constitutes about 46% wastewater,
[1:44:18] 37% sanitation, 13% of the enterprise
[1:44:23] or business like funds.
[1:44:25] The council went through its process
[1:44:27] And it allocated its council directed capital projects
[1:44:31] that equaled one too many fours.
[1:44:35] Oops.
[1:44:37] So it was $1,212,460.
[1:44:42] There were, you maintained and you
[1:44:44] preserved the MPOG allocation of $50,000
[1:44:48] to be described later.
[1:44:51] And the city has a contingency fund of about $240,000.
[1:44:55] So at the end of the day, this total
[1:44:57] If you have that median house with median water and median sewer, we estimate that your maximum expense is going to be about $9.05 per month.
[1:45:11] And with that, I'm happy to answer any questions that you have about the budget that has been presented to you.
[1:45:20] Any questions for Travis before I open up the public hearing?
[1:45:25] Did you say week what, 18?
[1:45:30] 18, 14 times?
[1:45:32] Okay. No questions. Thank you.
[1:45:36] Okay. I will open up the public hearing if there's anybody in
[1:45:39] the audience that wishes to address City Council specifically
[1:45:44] on the fiscal year 2526 budget.
[1:45:47] Please come down to the podium.
[1:45:49] Okay, see, no one.
[1:45:59] Lows the public hearing.
[1:46:01] So we have an ordinance to pass and I understand it needs to go on third and final.
[1:46:07] Yes, you'll need to suspend the rules this evening and then you will ask that you approve it thereafter.
[1:46:13] Should the rules be suspended to adopt the ordinance for individuals who want more detail.
[1:46:21] the budget is online and has been online and it is available for inspection and if
[1:46:28] anybody has questions even after it's adoption we're happy to sit down and and
[1:46:32] share the logic that went into creating the document. Okay Chris Reed. Two things
[1:46:42] before. Yes. To all city staff. I know that we've been hearing about it for 14
[1:46:49] weeks and we may have seen this the seasons change is getting a little bit
[1:46:54] colder but you guys started January February so thank you thank you thank you
[1:47:00] I know this is a very heavy list and we just got to sit here and it was
[1:47:04] presented to us but that he staff really they're the ones that we should be
[1:47:10] thinking for for all of this number two what is the ordinance number 2020 for 5
[1:47:16] five dash zero one four. It's right here on the okay. I'll make a motion if we're
[1:47:25] ready. Thank you. I move that we dispense with the reading rules and put
[1:47:28] ordinance 2025 dash zero one four on third and final reading by title only.
[1:47:34] Thank you Jason Brown. Second. Thank you motion by Chris Reed second by Jason Brown
[1:47:39] to move that we dispense with the reading of the rules and put ordinance
[1:47:44] December 2025-014 on third and final reading by title only. Any discussion?
[1:47:52] Rachel Roquavo please. Reg Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. Spencer Cutler. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes.
[1:48:01] Chris Reed. Yes. And Sherry Volmer. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 6 to 0. Okay. I'm
[1:48:11] I'll read the ordinance number 2025-014,
[1:48:15] an ordinance of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho
[1:48:17] appropriating $95,476,336 for the 26 fiscal year
[1:48:26] to defray all necessary expenses and liabilities
[1:48:29] of the City of Twin Falls,
[1:48:31] providing for the objects and purposes
[1:48:33] for which such appropriations are made
[1:48:36] and the amount appropriated for each object or purpose.
[1:48:40] loving at Valoram taxes in the amount of $32,896,123
[1:48:48] for the 2026 fiscal year,
[1:48:50] providing that a copy of this ordinance
[1:48:52] shall be filed with the county commissioners
[1:48:55] of Twin Falls County, Idaho,
[1:48:57] providing for this ordinance to take effect
[1:49:00] upon its passage approval and publication,
[1:49:03] according to law, the rule required that an ordinance
[1:49:06] be read on three separate occasions,
[1:49:09] having been suspended.
[1:49:11] Chris Reed.
[1:49:13] Move to approve Ordinance 2025-014.
[1:49:16] Thank you, Jason Brown.
[1:49:18] Second.
[1:49:19] Thank you, motion by Chris Reed, second by Jason Brown
[1:49:22] to approve Ordinance number 2025-014,
[1:49:27] which is approving the fiscal year 2025-2026 budget
[1:49:32] for the city of Twin Falls, Idaho.
[1:49:34] Any additional discussion?
[1:49:37] Mayor, I'd like to suggest that we should really refer
[1:49:41] to this one big beautiful budget.
[1:49:43] Hahaha.
[1:49:44] Thank you, Craig.
[1:49:48] Any other discussions?
[1:49:50] Rachel Rokal, please.
[1:49:52] Ruth Pierce.
[1:49:53] Yes.
[1:49:54] Chris Reed.
[1:49:55] Yes.
[1:49:56] Greg Hawkins.
[1:49:57] Jason Brown.
[1:49:58] Yes.
[1:49:59] Bensur Cutler.
[1:50:01] Yes.
[1:50:02] And Sherry Bomer.
[1:50:03] Thank you.
[1:50:04] Motion passes six to zero.
[1:50:05] And I would like to add thank you everybody
[1:50:07] for all your hard work, it's been fun, it's been the last little while.
[1:50:12] Well, for me, I heard on the radio this morning that I sit up and you sit up when they start
[1:50:20] talking budget, we got called out.
[1:50:23] Okay, the only other thing I'd like to add is I would like to see us focus on how we're
[1:50:32] going to try to get this dog park taken care of and the lights at yep so it looks like
[1:50:42] we may have some extra funds is coming here with the sale of the fire station and I would
[1:50:47] personally I don't know how everybody else feels if we could have staff maybe come back
[1:50:52] and give us some thoughts.
[1:50:55] We will do that.
[1:50:56] Thank you.
[1:50:58] Yes.
[1:51:00] I'd like to look at it a little bit as well as we move into the next, I know we've just
[1:51:04] concluded one budget year, Travis and City staff. Something as I've gone, the last couple of weeks
[1:51:11] that I've been really thinking about, trying to figure out with a lot of the park and recs and a
[1:51:16] lot of the projects that we have done, you know, there's a lot of things going on in the parks and
[1:51:22] rec, I would ask that we start looking at potentially doing something very similar to the engineering
[1:51:28] department as we've done with the water, you know, hiring an engineer specifically
[1:51:33] for the water projects, wastewater projects. I'd like to potentially look at
[1:51:39] hiring a project manager, what those qualifications are we may have to look at
[1:51:45] for helping the parks run some of their projects. There's a lot of money going
[1:51:51] through the parks department specifically and I know Wendy and her staff
[1:51:55] have other things on their plate to run the recreation side and the park side but
[1:52:01] having a staff member look specifically for project management. Thank you. Any
[1:52:07] other comments before Greg? No? Good. Okay so next on the agenda is an
[1:52:15] executive session. I promise it won't be long. It's an action item a request
[1:52:21] switch or into executive session pursuant to auto code section 74206 1a to consider hiring
[1:52:28] a public officer employee. Staff member or individual agent wherein the respective qualities
[1:52:34] of individuals are to be evaluated in order to fill a particular vacancy or need. This
[1:52:39] paragraph does not apply to filling a vacancy of an elective office or deliberations about
[1:52:45] Staffing needs in general Jason Brown
[1:52:50] Chris Reed second
[1:52:52] Thank you motion by Jason Brown seconder by
[1:52:55] Chris Reed to adjourn to executive session under Idaho code section
[1:53:00] 742061 a Rachel Rolle call vote, please
[1:53:07] Jason Brown yes, and sir cutler yes, yes Chris Reed. Yes and Sherry Volmer. I
[1:53:14] I think she said yes, did she?
[1:53:21] Motion passes six to zero, just let her eliminate.
[1:53:24] No, will not be reconvening, so have a good night.
[1:53:27] Thank you.
