Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2025-05-19, recording 1 (started 16:59)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2025-05-19/

[0:00:50] Good evening ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the May 19th 2025 City Council meeting
[0:00:55] I want to confirm we have a quorum. We have six members present in chambers and councilman
[0:01:02] Cutler is excused tonight
[0:01:04] First item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance if you wish to join me, please rise
[0:01:10] Thank you. We have no proclamations tonight
[0:01:31] So next on the agenda is the consent calendar council wishes
[0:01:35] May I would like to make a motion that we approve the consent calendar?
[0:01:40] Thank you.
[0:01:41] Do I have a second?
[0:01:42] Madam Mayor, I'll second.
[0:01:43] Thank you.
[0:01:44] Motion by Craig Hawkins, seconded by Grayson Stone to approve the consent calendar as written.
[0:01:50] Rachel, roll call vote, please.
[0:01:53] Ruth, Paris.
[0:01:54] Yes.
[0:01:55] Yes.
[0:01:56] Yes.
[0:01:57] Yes.
[0:01:58] Yes.
[0:01:59] Yes.
[0:02:00] Yes.
[0:02:01] Yes.
[0:02:02] Thank you.
[0:02:03] Motion passes six to zero.
[0:02:05] So, if you were here for the La Perona Festival, the Twin Falls Tonight, the Facts and Findings
[0:02:14] for Black Ops Subdivision, and the Special Permit for the annual St. Edward's event, those
[0:02:21] all have been approved.
[0:02:22] So, we have nothing under items of consideration tonight.
[0:02:27] We do have a public hearing, which we'll get to shortly.
[0:02:32] Next, actually on the agenda is the time for general public input.
[0:02:36] So if there's anybody in the public that wishes to address City Council on an item not
[0:02:42] on today's agenda, please come forward.
[0:02:49] He no one, advisory board reports, anything?
[0:02:54] Yeah, so the Metropolitan Planning Organization, we were supposed to meet, but didn't have
[0:03:02] enough for a quorum this this go around but there are a couple of items there
[0:03:06] that I think are of interest as we gather together and that's the third
[0:03:12] bridge crossing study should be some of that information should be coming out
[0:03:18] here hopefully within the next few weeks I know that's been one of those statements
[0:03:22] that has been going on for the last year or so but we are getting closer for for
[0:03:28] some of that environmental impact study should be getting on its way here pretty soon.
[0:03:36] So the Greater Twin Falls area transportation also met not a whole lot there to cover other
[0:03:45] than the topics at the third bridge and some of the other things.
[0:03:49] And I did hear that they were trying to have a public meeting on the third bridge by the
[0:03:54] end of June.
[0:03:55] Yep.
[0:03:56] Yep.
[0:03:57] report reports, meeting manager's office.
[0:04:00] I just a reminder that we will not be meeting next Monday,
[0:04:03] but we'll be meeting the Tuesday following.
[0:04:07] We're closed in honor and remembrance of Memorial Day.
[0:04:12] Thank you.
[0:04:15] OK, so next we'll go on to our public hearing.
[0:04:19] That is, I guess, OK, it's an action item.
[0:04:33] It's request for a zoning title amendment
[0:04:35] to repeal and replace Title 10.
[0:04:38] items to include our regulations pertaining to subdivisions,
[0:04:42] care of the city of Twin Falls, PZ24-0121.
[0:04:47] We have Jonathan Spinn-Love and William Clayver.
[0:04:50] Before we do that, I need to read these.
[0:04:54] The P&C public hearing, excuse me,
[0:04:57] the public hearing procedures for council
[0:05:00] will include these steps.
[0:05:02] City staff will present the request and analysis.
[0:05:05] The applicant typically would present their request.
[0:05:08] We are it, so the council will then ask questions of staff.
[0:05:14] After questions have been answered,
[0:05:16] ask and answered the public hearing will be opened.
[0:05:19] During that time, anyone in attendance
[0:05:21] is given the opportunity to comment
[0:05:24] or ask questions about the request being considered.
[0:05:28] When giving testimony, please step up
[0:05:30] to the podium, state your name and address.
[0:05:32] Present your comments and concerns
[0:05:34] and you are limited to three minutes.
[0:05:37] And if you do speak, there's a sign in,
[0:05:39] sheet located upstairs on the table
[0:05:42] that you need to sign before you leave.
[0:05:45] After public comments are completed,
[0:05:46] the applicant will be invited to answer any questions.
[0:05:50] The applicant, meaning the staff,
[0:05:52] will answer, clarify any comments as needed.
[0:05:55] After those statements, the public hearing will be closed.
[0:05:58] No further testimony or comments
[0:06:00] from the audience will be allowed.
[0:06:03] and then Council will have open discussion and take action.
[0:06:07] Welcome, Jonathan.
[0:06:09] Thank you, Mayor, members of the Council.
[0:06:10] I'm going to stick into a script essentially
[0:06:14] at the staff report.
[0:06:15] I'm just kind of highlighting basically this section here.
[0:06:18] And then I'll dig into the current code
[0:06:20] and the proposed code,
[0:06:21] but we're gonna highlight just these four items.
[0:06:24] We have updated this chapter.
[0:06:26] It has gone through a group review
[0:06:30] with the developers group and their representative.
[0:06:33] We met with them on April 10th.
[0:06:34] we went through a bunch of items.
[0:06:36] What you're seeing today in the proposed is
[0:06:38] including their changes that they requested.
[0:06:42] With that, the four major items,
[0:06:45] I'm gonna say there's five major items.
[0:06:46] We're keeping preliminary plats as we propose
[0:06:48] to go through the Planning and Zoning Commission.
[0:06:51] That was in the sentence up here.
[0:06:52] Final plats per state code have to go to the city council.
[0:06:55] So you always have to approve final plats.
[0:06:58] That can't be delegated.
[0:07:00] Preliminary plats could, but the commission does a lot
[0:07:02] of that work, so that's a good way for them
[0:07:04] to have that. We've added a new thing that's a provision for a short
[0:07:12] plat. It's five or fewer lots and less than five acres geared towards infill
[0:07:17] projects, requires to follow city standards and allows for an administrative
[0:07:21] review and then a final plat with the council. So the short plat concept would
[0:07:26] be an administrative which is staff level. It's designating the city engineer or a
[0:07:31] staff engineer as the person that's like a, almost like a hearing examiner that basically
[0:07:36] looks at the code to make sure that the application meets the code. It does that, which is the preliminary
[0:07:42] plat process. It would then be delivered to the city council for a final plat review. Our hope is
[0:07:49] to make that process shorter as it's not a public meeting advertised for short plots because it's a
[0:07:57] smaller area and so they can receive comments but there wouldn't be a public hearing meeting.
[0:08:03] They could still, a neighbor could still write a letter. We're going to get to that in a second.
[0:08:09] The short process is a new thing. The second item was to change the notification requirement.
[0:08:18] We have had a few instances and in the past 10 years have been here. There's a discrepancy
[0:08:25] I've seen the code on what the preliminary plat process is
[0:08:29] and whether it's a public hearing, public meeting,
[0:08:33] and whether or not people have the right,
[0:08:36] and I'm saying in the right to speak,
[0:08:38] not that they are given the time to speak,
[0:08:41] when it's a public hearing per state statute,
[0:08:44] we read the rules like we did tonight.
[0:08:46] There's a process we follow for public hearings.
[0:08:49] Preliminary plats do not follow public hearing requirements.
[0:08:54] they're not required to by state law. Cities can make them go through that process if they wish.
[0:09:01] When you do that, it makes the preliminary plan a time frame pretty long because you have to publish
[0:09:07] in the newspaper post the signs a certain time frame forward. You have the hearing here and the
[0:09:13] people that are in the audience have that two minutes to speak regardless. Current code does
[0:09:20] not require public hearing. It just says there will be a meeting and there's a decision on a preliminary
[0:09:24] and you're welcome to attend the meeting. However, a lot of times, and those that have been on
[0:09:31] Planning and Zoning Commission have known people speak. They want to have that input. Sometimes it's
[0:09:41] really good. Sometimes they bring up items that are not necessarily associated with the plan, which
[0:09:45] is difficult to get through during the public hearing process because it's not in the purview of
[0:09:50] the commission to deal with. So there's pluses and minuses there's things to take into account from
[0:09:55] from the commission's standpoint and the council standpoint
[0:09:58] and what we wanna do.
[0:10:01] That's gonna be one of the sources
[0:10:02] I'm gonna get to that section here in a minute.
[0:10:05] Be thinking about how you would like that interaction to go.
[0:10:08] I've written it to be,
[0:10:10] public comments should be written
[0:10:13] and received basically a week before the meeting.
[0:10:18] You'd still notify the property,
[0:10:21] basically the five acres or the 10 acres
[0:10:24] that has a subdivision would still have a sign on it.
[0:10:27] One of the inputs from the Planning and Zoning Commission
[0:10:29] was to have that sign be a different type
[0:10:31] because our signs all look the same.
[0:10:33] So our public hearings all look like the same sign
[0:10:35] and so a plat could have a different color or size
[0:10:38] or something to identify it as a subdivision.
[0:10:42] And the letter would be specific
[0:10:44] that it's a submit your comments in writing
[0:10:46] before the meeting.
[0:10:49] So that's separate.
[0:10:52] The other two things are, they're big changes,
[0:10:55] but they're minor in terms of their number of letters
[0:10:58] are changed. The expiration of plats, approvals, modified to include a grace period at the end,
[0:11:04] as well as the maximum time we shortened it down from, like I said, years went to months with a 30
[0:11:12] day grace period. The last changes we removed a lot of language out of it that was really in design.
[0:11:17] Basically, this section had design on straight back curb that we never, we don't follow anymore.
[0:11:22] and we reference everything over to the standards for public works
[0:11:29] construction or the Idaho standards ISPWC with the city of Twin Falls modifications.
[0:11:35] Those fourish items are the things that were changed. I'm going to move to this is
[0:11:41] the current code. You can see the layout and the number of items within it. I'm
[0:11:49] not going to spend a lot of time on it other than this page to show where what
[0:11:52] looked like and this is the newer proposed section. I don't have a index yet. We haven't
[0:12:02] made that yet until we change them. I'm going to go very briefly through most of it. The
[0:12:07] purpose, jurisdiction, interpretation, administration all stayed the same. Maybe some grammar that's
[0:12:13] changed. Approval, this is the procedure for subdivision approval and this outlines when
[0:12:22] When you go through the process, how big are you?
[0:12:29] You go through these four things.
[0:12:32] You have a vacant farm ground, you're going to start with number one, and then you could
[0:12:36] go to number two, it's a short platter preliminary whichever's applicable, then you get a public
[0:12:40] infrastructure plan, and then you get the final platter.
[0:12:43] Those are the steps we take.
[0:12:47] This is similar to what we have currently in code, we just made it a little bit easier
[0:12:50] to understand, because it wasn't actually written very clearly, it was just, you had
[0:12:53] to go through these steps, but they weren't enumerated.
[0:12:57] subject to concept review wasn't called the same thing but the idea is you just
[0:13:00] give us kind of an idea what it is you're gonna do and we write back to say
[0:13:05] here's the code you're gonna have to follow and go ahead and get your preliminary
[0:13:09] plat a plat for it short plat this is all brand-new these are the items we're
[0:13:20] looking to do and one of those changes on the short plat would would be you cannot
[0:13:30] have a widening of the road, meaning new dedication and construction. If you needed
[0:13:39] to do that it kicks it out of this process. It's a little bit more complicated, not
[0:13:45] the widening is existing, you can't have a new street dedication. If you already
[0:13:47] dedicated it, but you just need to widen it until I could drop play and that's okay.
[0:13:53] The street dedication is what makes it more difficult. This is where the process
[0:14:03] goes through city engineer as a designated, it's almost like a hearing
[0:14:11] examiner as a designee. So Jonathan as I was looking at that short
[0:14:26] plan line 77 78. I think those lines has helped as well by the way. So it says it
[0:14:35] shall not involve a total acre exceeding five acres and then shall not create
[0:14:39] more than five lots. So if we have five acres we'd only be able to create five
[0:14:45] existing homes is that what it basically is saying we're not from a
[0:14:50] density standpoint if it's inside the city limits would we or what was the
[0:14:56] a little bit of the thought behind that wouldn't necessarily be tied to density
[0:15:08] would really it's about the review time okay the complexity of it okay and I'm
[0:15:15] trying as I'm going through this my mind's going really fast and maybe Will has
[0:15:19] something as he's not the one in the hot seat remembering something no and I
[0:15:23] And I didn't mean I just look at it just from a from an acreage standpoint
[0:15:27] You have five acres with five lots which then would create a an acre lot inside of the city not saying that that's a bad thing
[0:15:35] but
[0:15:36] Yeah, most of the time we're looking for just smaller infill that doesn't it's I think you need both a lot number and an acreage
[0:15:45] Sure, but it doesn't assume you'd only be single family homes
[0:15:51] Okay, this is where I'm at this is the way it's written this could be some smaller commercial projects as well
[0:15:56] could get into that and that would still be allowed to have five lots but
[0:16:03] they could have different items on it they could have a commercial project or
[0:16:11] apartment on it there would be more than five homes I guess as far as I'm
[0:16:15] getting hung up on the number of houses okay and I don't know if that's a
[0:16:22] something we should correct the direction that's a different direction
[0:16:25] want to go I mean I'm just looking at it and you know when having you explain
[0:16:33] I just, I don't know how many areas inside the city this would really affect.
[0:16:41] How many, you know, are we looking at smaller acreage, one, two acres kind of thing?
[0:16:46] How many five acre non-developed areas do we really have?
[0:16:51] I guess that was just, it was some math on my side of it.
[0:16:55] We're not sure it's a lot.
[0:16:58] We think that there are some where you have like an existing home on an acre and they just
[0:17:03] want to take it to one to two or three houses and that happens more in downtown
[0:17:08] I'd say down to older parts of town and we've had some of them that it just
[0:17:13] precluded them from actually subdividing to create those additional lots that are
[0:17:17] possible. I like that I like the short-plat process I was just looking at it again
[0:17:22] just I was thinking maybe thinking out loud a little bit too. I have the same
[0:17:26] like more houses but we don't think it's a bad thing necessarily we're trying to
[0:17:30] get that to be a little bit easier to do.
[0:17:33] How often do you have one of these, is it?
[0:17:38] We've had a couple, one of them was on Jackson.
[0:17:41] Will doesn't, we'll zoom in on one of them.
[0:18:10] And this one right here.
[0:18:11] But this was the access through here to these.
[0:18:14] There were two lots, they ended up putting two lots in three or four units because it was
[0:18:19] printed back here.
[0:18:20] They did a fourplex on each lot.
[0:18:22] And they needed to separate it out to have two lots.
[0:18:27] And they went through the entire preliminary and final plan process.
[0:18:31] And then the one just to the north was, I want to say, four lots, somewhere around there.
[0:18:38] And it would have been, it would have qualified for this type of regulation.
[0:18:44] And when I sit and talk with developers, they're wanting a full subdivision process.
[0:18:51] So it starts to become cost prohibitive on the smaller infill ones.
[0:18:57] Sure.
[0:18:58] My question is, like, does that happen once a month?
[0:19:02] Why is it a year?
[0:19:03] I think it could happen.
[0:19:04] It happens right now, maybe once or twice a year.
[0:19:06] But it could happen more if it were available.
[0:19:09] Because it could be a little bit cheaper, we hope.
[0:19:12] Sure.
[0:19:12] OK.
[0:19:13] Thank you.
[0:19:16] That's the short plot.
[0:19:20] Yeah, hearing examiner.
[0:19:22] This is basically how they work it.
[0:19:25] This is the process that they would take,
[0:19:27] the render decision, they follow the statute,
[0:19:29] they're basically making sure that it is all okay.
[0:19:33] Again, with any like a hearing exam where you can appeal,
[0:19:38] you can make that appeal of the decision
[0:19:39] and then you have the city council make the preliminary
[0:19:48] plat process is the same.
[0:19:50] We didn't change a lot on here
[0:19:53] and some of the wording got moved around.
[0:19:55] We required certain modeling and stuff before
[0:19:58] that we didn't have at that time when they applied,
[0:20:00] but now we were gonna get that.
[0:20:02] And then, in the end, the commissions, what they're looking for is all the same.
[0:20:08] They're looking to make sure that it complies with the standards of the title, subdivision,
[0:20:14] with the comprehensive plan, services, and then anything else that's brought to their attention.
[0:20:19] That's what was basically out of the statute or what we currently have.
[0:20:23] They're not, the commission does not have that, they don't go outside of their box, the code
[0:20:32] makes you, if you give us a subdivision that meets the code, there's very few things that
[0:20:37] the commission can add or take away or deny for.
[0:20:40] And that's where the notification for public for the preliminary class comes into play.
[0:20:47] That's where we changed it.
[0:20:51] Change now reads, in addition to posting the property, we're going to get written notice
[0:20:56] to owners within 300 feet.
[0:20:58] And then they have this.
[0:21:00] Notice the notice shall have repose drawing.
[0:21:05] We don't currently actually require the drawing to go to them.
[0:21:08] The neighbors general information and the time frame of no less than 10 days for submitting
[0:21:13] written comments from the day to the mailing.
[0:21:18] And then down here the consideration by the commission it says they're going to review
[0:21:23] the preliminary prat, the plat, the written comments from concerned persons and agencies,
[0:21:29] report from us and we explicitly say a public hearing is not required to consider a preliminary
[0:21:34] plan.
[0:21:37] Can you have a question, Grayson?
[0:21:38] Yeah, thank you Madam Mayor.
[0:21:39] So on the water modeling and then like even on the drawings, that's still on the plate
[0:21:45] of the developer, correct?
[0:21:47] Make sure that was clear.
[0:21:48] Yeah, they would provide that with their application.
[0:21:50] Correct.
[0:21:51] Cool.
[0:21:52] Thank you.
[0:21:53] Can we just use that drawing and send it to people in terms of this plan?
[0:21:56] So I'm going to pause here.
[0:21:58] This was the biggest discussion at the commission was this item right here is how much
[0:22:02] notification and what should it be. Their response back to us was if we're going to go this route,
[0:22:10] the sign should be different so that the people know it's not a public hearing. It looks different
[0:22:14] than the rest of our public hearing signs. When we agree with that, it should be different.
[0:22:20] We would work with, I say we'd work at a local sign company that is the one that usually rents
[0:22:26] these out to figure out what that design could look like, to be efficient in what we need to convey.
[0:22:32] one that they might be able to produce to rent to people to do it. Not that
[0:22:37] people have to rent them. We also provide them with the drawing of what it looks
[0:22:40] like and if you can meet it the other way you can make your own. There you go.
[0:22:46] Well you mentioned in your staff report that you've spoken to the developers, what
[0:22:52] did they think about this section? Were they? The only comment and I'm gonna try
[0:22:58] and go back on my memory with Dave Tebow was they didn't see an issue on their
[0:23:04] side of it, we believe it will be helpful to have the written comments because oftentimes
[0:23:11] the comments made during the meeting either are not part of the issue or we can't address
[0:23:18] in the meeting.
[0:23:19] And so we're end up trying to make a condition on it that might apply to apply, may not apply.
[0:23:24] We could hopefully address them and then the developer, the applicant could have those things
[0:23:30] beforehand.
[0:23:31] So they know what the issues are before any type of decisions made by the Commission.
[0:23:37] They felt it would be helpful, although trying to balance what would be like the transparency of it.
[0:23:46] It's just difficult in that conveying to the public and the people that come to these meetings.
[0:23:52] This item in particular is one that's pretty strict when it comes to what you can change.
[0:23:59] you can't diminish somebody's density if they're just following the basis
[0:24:05] zoning code. So that's always a difficult balance if we don't want that many homes
[0:24:10] and the staff report and what they provided is meets the code. If they're
[0:24:16] trying to do more than the code allows, that usually took place during like a
[0:24:19] zoning development agreement which is a separate process. And so if they're
[0:24:22] following the code, minimum things that you can change. The list is pretty small
[0:24:29] and it usually ends up doing with timing.
[0:24:31] Like when are you building it?
[0:24:32] Which area of the subdivision you're building first,
[0:24:35] or second, or third?
[0:24:37] I mean, you can say I want all the sidewalks
[0:24:38] on the arterials done in the first phase.
[0:24:40] Like that's something that can be done
[0:24:42] and put us a condition.
[0:24:45] But just saying that we don't want the development
[0:24:47] to happen or there's too many homes
[0:24:49] is not something because the code permits it.
[0:24:51] So having the comments to kind of sift through
[0:24:55] to know we could address them all during the meeting
[0:24:58] and say these are not applicable.
[0:24:59] these are the ones that are and then the commission could sift through that with
[0:25:02] the developer where they could say yeah we're going to do that anyway but it's
[0:25:07] really about it's a transparency type of thing it's you're in the meeting you
[0:25:13] want to be able to affect change from a public standpoint during before the
[0:25:18] decision the commission and the council need that time to actually affect the
[0:25:23] change if it can happen so we came up with the idea of a different sign the
[0:25:28] letter will be different be very explicit in what it will
[0:25:31] statement when you would write in and when your comments would be applicable or not.
[0:25:36] So what's the timing when you send out letters to surrounding people?
[0:25:44] How long before the meeting do you send out those letters?
[0:25:51] Yeah, for a hearing on Landy's decision, it's 14 days.
[0:25:55] So they in theory have four days to make a comment in writing?
[0:26:00] No, in this case, we would push that out and say we need the day.
[0:26:05] We need the letters back before a certain date and give them that 10 days.
[0:26:11] Okay.
[0:26:13] Thank you.
[0:26:16] Any other questions?
[0:26:17] I'm going to move down.
[0:26:24] Final plat, we didn't change.
[0:26:26] Well, I don't believe we changed much.
[0:26:30] We tightened up some of the external agency timeframes and your actions are the similar
[0:26:38] regulations, reasons, and then this final documents we cleaned up, it used to be like four or
[0:26:49] five different paragraphs.
[0:26:53] This approval period is in months instead of the years, and you can grant two extensions
[0:27:00] of 12 months each.
[0:27:02] This was a change.
[0:27:03] This whole extension time frame is a change.
[0:27:07] Every extension that would be granted if they needed one could bring up the option for
[0:27:14] the council to have conditions for the extension.
[0:27:17] We do not have that currently.
[0:27:19] One of those issues is when we have,
[0:27:23] let's say a new technology comes out
[0:27:26] for a new type of road paving,
[0:27:29] and we haven't got it into our standards,
[0:27:31] and if we approved it five years ago,
[0:27:35] and they're still working on the old standard,
[0:27:37] we have a new one.
[0:27:38] If they need an extension,
[0:27:39] we can make them come with a new standard
[0:27:41] the engineering's come up with.
[0:27:43] Another one is like a sewer manhole, like a new type of technology or item or a thing.
[0:27:49] That extension can allow a condition to come up to the current standard if they needed
[0:27:53] it.
[0:27:54] We do not have that ability right now, and with that we wrote in this last bit that six
[0:27:59] years from a preliminary plat approval, any subsequent final, follows the standards, the
[0:28:05] date of the final plat submittal, instead of the old preliminary plat standards.
[0:28:14] Those are the major changes.
[0:28:16] The rest of this we just moved places and we took out a lot of the requirements so the
[0:28:22] total number of pages is a little bit less.
[0:28:25] These are all still the standards that point to our ISPWC items and some items we still
[0:28:32] need to be in code otherwise we kept everything the same.
[0:28:40] One thing to note is we did remove the conveyance plot, that conveyance plot essentially but
[0:28:49] off the house of a farmland and left no development right for the they'd have to
[0:28:54] come back and go through the planning process nobody was using this even had
[0:28:59] engineers say we tell people not to go through that process so we removed that
[0:29:06] and the process we had was the short plywood replace conveyance process we kept
[0:29:15] everything all the special subdivisions the same changing zones but everything
[0:29:19] else. That is all I have. Any other questions for Jonathan or Will at this
[0:29:33] point in time? Okay so moving to the public hearing do you have anything else to add Jonathan?
[0:29:48] Okay I'm gonna open up the public hearing if there's anybody in the audience that
[0:29:53] wishes to give testimony on this particular item please come up to the
[0:30:00] podium, state your name, present your comments, and you have three minutes.
[0:30:06] Okay, see no one, anything to add, Jonathan, I'll just close the public hearing.
[0:30:19] Yeah, you can close the information and I'm looking for particularly that preliminary
[0:30:25] plat is the one question I think we have the rest of it.
[0:30:28] I don't have any, either more direction or some specifics or we're in a good path.
[0:30:34] That's all.
[0:30:35] So you're specific.
[0:30:36] Okay, so the public hearing is closed.
[0:30:39] So you're specifically asking about the written comment
[0:30:43] only and the change in the signed.
[0:30:47] Yeah, and whether or not, basically saying
[0:30:50] it's not a public hearing, we need to do written comments
[0:30:52] before the meeting.
[0:30:54] And the sign changes what the commission said
[0:30:56] if we go those routes we need to do.
[0:30:59] Oh, let's see here.
[0:31:02] Grayson.
[0:31:04] Thank you, Madam Mayor.
[0:31:05] I would offer that I appreciate your hand like your guys' efforts in this.
[0:31:13] I like the direction.
[0:31:15] I think I like the sign change versus a zone change personally, but I'd be open to feedback.
[0:31:22] But I think what you have is great for a step for sure.
[0:31:29] Any other comments?
[0:31:30] I just might mention that this takes a lot of work, a lot of wonderful reading and studying
[0:31:40] to come up with it. I know it's been a big burden on your shoulders and we would appreciate
[0:31:44] it. It sounds good to me. Jason. Yeah, I think, you know, adding the preliminary
[0:31:52] plat, the short plat and some of that helps us work through issues that we have. The question
[0:32:01] I have is maybe from my daytime job, oftentimes we get a comment on those, those plats with the
[0:32:10] the short plat affect anything with that aspect of it, would that be part of the
[0:32:17] public comment period? The short plat will still require external agencies to get
[0:32:23] letters, still those. But I like what you've done, I think it helps do some of that
[0:32:33] infield, do some things that... Curiosity is kind of killing the cat here,
[0:32:39] director's been there, why did you switch from years to months? At least we could
[0:32:46] have the 30 day and it was just like the developers are saying the years they're
[0:32:50] losing it and if they have a month ring it was just got it one of those I don't
[0:32:55] did anybody else I'll share I do think that this cleans it up it allows for a lot
[0:33:08] of flexibility which I think is really good I think the design change is good I
[0:33:12] think it's a in theory it works really well we do work with people there's always
[0:33:20] going to be somebody that is an exception to the rule though understanding we do
[0:33:24] We live in a small community, all know people that go through these processes, so a 10-day
[0:33:32] submit, we mean we're going to get people that it's going to be all over the place.
[0:33:37] No, there's concern there, where we say, understanding that the reasons behind it we
[0:33:48] want to be able to bring information to it, we want to be able to fix it, we want to be
[0:33:52] able to answer, we've always allowed for open dialogue, that's just a little concerning.
[0:34:01] Wouldn't they still be able to provide comment though during the public hearing you know they could well
[0:34:08] No, it wouldn't there's no public meeting not a public hearing and I want to be on the agenda
[0:34:19] In general public input so it would have to be that's the concern
[0:34:24] Is not having
[0:34:27] Opening a four-public comment at the day of the meeting for the preliminary plan
[0:34:31] who's what we're talking about. If I'm understanding, right, they they have to
[0:34:37] submit that 10 days prior so they couldn't submit it noon that the day of
[0:34:41] the meeting. Yeah, we can't. The way this rights is like we the government wouldn't
[0:34:46] give them less than 10 days. We can we can open it for working base again and put
[0:34:51] the letter here's how this would work. I send the letter out to the neighbors. We
[0:34:55] put it in the sign that says your written comments shall be submitted to the
[0:34:58] city by date and we can't give less than the 10-day time frame for them to do
[0:35:05] that from the mailing like they will give them a date certain to give it to us
[0:35:08] and it has to be at least 10 days we can't give them less than 10 days time of
[0:35:13] notice to give us the letter they could give you a letter the day of the hearing
[0:35:18] soon as the sign goes up they can email me and it will be included yeah they could
[0:35:22] So when's the cut off? I think that's the confusion. When's the cut off for
[0:35:30] public letters for a public meeting? We're trying to get it so that we have it
[0:35:36] before the weekend. So it'd be like the Thursday before a Tuesday or a Wednesday
[0:35:40] before a Monday. The councilman reads point though. So let's do this.
[0:35:48] I can get you on the thing here, so you're next, Grayson, if you want.
[0:35:56] Oh, thank you, Madam Mayor.
[0:35:57] So, the Councilman Reed's point.
[0:35:58] So, that's on the preliminary plat, the 10 days before, but then the final plat, they could still...
[0:36:05] No, your final plat's trying to consent calendar.
[0:36:08] That's correct.
[0:36:09] Okay.
[0:36:10] Just wanted to make sure.
[0:36:11] Chris, we...
[0:36:12] I mean, if we're looking for Thursday, the agenda isn't even published until Thursday.
[0:36:18] So we're getting notification on Thursday that this is coming, who's weak?
[0:36:26] I'm trying to counsel, counsel.
[0:36:28] So we get an email that packets published, we can go in and start reviewing it.
[0:36:34] They at that point in time, that's when we would cut it off.
[0:36:37] We want to have you get the letters before you get your packet.
[0:36:40] Yeah.
[0:36:42] At the same time.
[0:36:43] At the same time, we need it.
[0:36:45] Understanding this is preliminary, there will be a final.
[0:36:48] We're trying to say you because there's times we get 50 letters or 10 or 20
[0:36:55] before noon on the same day that's not ample time for y'all or the commission to
[0:37:02] review everything that comes in we're trying to this is an attempt to get those
[0:37:07] beforehand Jason Jonathan on the preliminary
[0:37:17] plait process. Do you get do you get more letters pre-liminary plait or final
[0:37:25] plait? Which one would you say you get more comments in response to? Or is it equal?
[0:37:29] We don't get hardly anything for final. Okay. Because they're on consent,
[0:37:34] preliminaries we're getting most of those. So we're not we're not taking the
[0:37:40] ability for people to come in on pre-liminary plait because I guess the
[0:37:44] My thing is a preliminary plat is just a concept to me, right?
[0:37:48] The final plat is where the meat and the potatoes come in to some extent.
[0:37:52] I'm going to say swap die. The final plat is where the city council gives the final authority to develop.
[0:37:58] The preliminary has all of the development information on it.
[0:38:02] Okay, but they don't have a right to change the land until final plat.
[0:38:07] Sure, but there's things that come in on the preliminary that change.
[0:38:13] And I'm trying to so so we're not cutting the ability of people to comment on the preliminary
[0:38:24] plan and say hey I don't see this I don't see that or that doesn't make sense to me.
[0:38:29] Yeah.
[0:38:30] Sorry.
[0:38:31] No.
[0:38:32] And so that I guess that's my concern is we're not we're giving people enough time to make
[0:38:37] the comments and they need to is is ultimately what we're spearheading here.
[0:38:43] Yes, two things. Comment during the public meeting would not happen. Sure. They would all have been writing. This is our way of advertising that when we send a letter, which is generally 15 days before the meeting, we are saying we can give them less than 10 days from that mailing to give us comments.
[0:39:04] So I'm kind of saying that's four days before the hearing or the meeting is when the cutoff
[0:39:10] will.
[0:39:11] We're just, we're committing to seeing, we're giving you this minimum amount of time to send
[0:39:17] me a letter or an email from the date of the mailing.
[0:39:22] I have to create a timeline to do that.
[0:39:25] So that makes sense.
[0:39:26] So it's all in the communication in the letter basically is, and maybe some public announcements
[0:39:34] There's some public discussion, press release or whatever about the change, notifying maybe
[0:39:41] developers in writing that this is a change, and then I think it can work personally.
[0:39:48] In the end, from a practical standpoint, we're going to be sending out the letters because
[0:39:53] we should currently do that anyway.
[0:39:55] The letters for all of our zoning actions are going to be sent 15, 14, 15 days before the
[0:40:01] meeting.
[0:40:02] And that is then accomplishing this 10-day window, and we'll have a date on the letter
[0:40:08] says you shall submit written comments by this day or we won't accept them in order for
[0:40:14] the Commission to counsel to have enough time to review all of the comments received.
[0:40:20] That's the ultimate goal.
[0:40:22] As we felt the 50 letters that day of the hearing is nobody has enough time within that hour
[0:40:29] basically to get them.
[0:40:30] We have our time getting them to you and the Commission.
[0:40:33] And that's all over for that matter.
[0:40:35] Yeah, no, oftentimes they don't get them until they're in the meeting, looking at them the first time.
[0:40:39] Right.
[0:40:40] And they don't have enough time to answer some of the questions.
[0:40:45] It's kind of all around.
[0:40:47] Or be able to address the concerns exactly.
[0:40:51] Okay.
[0:40:52] Anybody else want to comment, Chris?
[0:40:54] You're still on?
[0:40:55] Yeah, just a quick question.
[0:40:57] Jason brought this up in public hearings.
[0:41:00] so understanding written when could somebody come in actually address what's happening.
[0:41:08] When it comes to a subdivision, there won't be in that sense.
[0:41:14] The hearing happens when you change the zoning.
[0:41:17] Her state statute subdivisions is the one where I have a subdivision,
[0:41:21] and I have, let's just say, I have five acres.
[0:41:26] Let's make it 10, so we skip the short part.
[0:41:28] ten acres. I have zoned it where it's already zoned, R2 currently. I have a right to develop it
[0:41:36] per the R2 zone. I'm giving you the plan on following the R2 zone and the subdivision ordinance
[0:41:42] that you have written as a city. Here's my plan, I'm following all of these laws and we go
[0:41:50] great, that's what you're required to do by the law and that's really all the statutes as you
[0:41:55] should do in the plat. It's just a subdivision ordinance is applicable
[0:41:59] everybody equally and if they follow the rules
[0:42:03] there's very few things you should condition at night so I was giving it a timing
[0:42:07] thing. I'm remembering the presentation and yeah I guess I have
[0:42:11] some heartburn on that. That's where... I'm gonna be honest most
[0:42:17] places and I don't do like we just kind of go oh I don't really like that
[0:42:21] and that's just kind of the statute. I missed Thursday now all of a sudden
[0:42:25] I don't get to speak on this and it could be next door to us, or it doesn't get in email, whatever it is, I'll be on, I don't like that.
[0:42:39] Man, understanding why?
[0:42:41] Yes.
[0:42:42] I don't have a button.
[0:42:43] Yeah, no, you don't. Yes, sir.
[0:42:46] So one of the important things to remember is all ZDA's and PUDs and all those types of things will still go through this process.
[0:42:57] that this does not change any of that.
[0:43:02] The way to think about this, and I understand it's a stretch,
[0:43:08] but you're giving permission to do something
[0:43:12] by following the ordinance, by creating the ordinance,
[0:43:17] by assigning the zone.
[0:43:20] But you want them to come back and ask permission again
[0:43:24] to be able to utilize and develop the property.
[0:43:28] where some cities can run into an obstacle on land use is when they have
[0:43:34] followed all of your steps and you don't like it and you say no in which they
[0:43:42] have completely followed all of the steps that are outlined and then we find
[0:43:48] ourselves in a litigious situation because our preferences are overwriting
[0:43:56] the laws that you created. So this is one way to look at this is you're helping us to avoid
[0:44:06] potential litigious situations by removing the politics. And it does require us to be more
[0:44:14] thoughtful when we're assigning the zone and going through the comprehensive plan. That
[0:44:21] is when the true community design process is occurring. Because like Jonathan said, if
[0:44:27] If you are going to then develop 10 acres and they have met all of your standards, they
[0:44:34] say here are the rules, we say great.
[0:44:37] They want to do something different through his EDA.
[0:44:41] They come to you because they want a different collection of rules or circumstances than what
[0:44:47] he has already carved out and that is when you have discretion.
[0:44:56] Jason here, just to honor you.
[0:44:59] So Travis said it way better than I was, but that my comment was then the zoning process
[0:45:06] becomes far more critical to have public input and as Chris was talking and Travis, I think
[0:45:14] the general public needs to understand that that becomes the critical aspect of this whole
[0:45:18] thing is historically we may have worked around some different things, but this change really
[0:45:27] looks at is if it comes in as R2 or R4 and they follow the rules, they're approved.
[0:45:34] And it's typically always been that way, correct?
[0:45:38] Yeah.
[0:45:39] We've allowed them to give input when really there's nothing we can do to change R2 rules.
[0:45:46] And I think that's been some of those hard decision factors that we've worked through.
[0:45:52] But yeah, like I said, Travis said it, but that was my thought is really the emphasis becomes on the zoning
[0:45:58] Alice you really eliminate the frustrated citizen coming in and saying, but you didn't even listen to us
[0:46:07] when when your hands are tied by
[0:46:11] Actions that this council or past councils might have been the ones that have taken
[0:46:16] So they're the ones that have signed the zone
[0:46:19] they're the ones that are going to be operating under the
[0:46:22] Zoning and subdivision requirements that you've created they come in and say yeah
[0:46:30] but our hands are tied there's something that's where that confusion occurs I
[0:46:34] thought this was a hearing how come you listen to us and all reality it's
[0:46:40] unfortunate that that process is set up because there's not much hearing in
[0:46:47] In finger quotes, right? Yeah, but that we're really truly able to do right? That makes sense
[0:46:53] No, and now that you've you've said that and stated it we've been in multiple situations where
[0:46:59] Jonathan's point people have come up and I'm frustrated with this and not in my backyard
[0:47:04] Yeah, I totally get it, but that has nothing to do with this
[0:47:08] No, thank you
[0:47:11] Okay
[0:47:12] Any other questions?
[0:47:15] If not, I think I would entertain a motion.
[0:47:19] Chris Reed.
[0:47:20] All right, I move that we approve the zoning title amendment
[0:47:25] to repeal and replace title 10 items to include
[0:47:30] our regulations pertaining to the subdivision area
[0:47:34] as presented tonight.
[0:47:36] Thank you, Sherry Vomer.
[0:47:38] I will second.
[0:47:39] Thank you, motion by Chris Reed, second by Sherry Vomer
[0:47:43] to approve the zoning title amendment to repeal and replace title 10 items are
[0:47:50] included items to include our regulations pertaining to subdivisions as
[0:47:55] discussed tonight. Any further discussion? Rachel Rokalvo please.
[0:48:03] Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Thank you motion passes 6 to 0.
[0:48:13] Okay, next on the agenda, we have an executive session.
[0:48:18] It's an action item, request to adjourn to executive session pursuant to Idaho Code Section 742061B
[0:48:27] to consider the evaluation dismissal or discipline of or to hear complaints or charges brought against a public officer,
[0:48:35] employees, staff member or individual agent or public school student, Chris Reed.
[0:48:40] So moved.
[0:48:41] Thank you to have a second motion by Chris Reed seconded by Jason Brown to move
[0:48:47] into executive session under Idaho Code Section 74-2061b. Okay thank you
[0:48:55] everybody we are adjourned.
[0:49:02] Maybe it depends if I'm in the mood I will see is it a yes or no or abstain.
[0:49:08] Rachel Rolclavoe please. Jerry Volmer. Yeah. Grayson Stone. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes.
[0:49:16] Chris Reed. Yes. Greg Hawkins. And Jason Broke. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 6 to 0 now.
[0:49:22] We're adjourned. Thank you everyone.
