Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2025-04-28, recording 1 (started 16:55)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2025-04-28/

[0:03:12] Good evening ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the April 28th 2025 City Council meeting
[0:03:18] I want to confirm we have a quorum we have all members
[0:03:23] present in chambers
[0:03:25] First item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance if you wish to join me please rise
[0:03:29] So before we get to the big event today, I do have a couple of proclamations.
[0:03:57] The first one is for Idaho gives week.
[0:04:01] Idaho gives week April 28th through May 1st 2025, whereas nonprofit organizations help
[0:04:09] build and sustain healthy communities in our state and enhance the quality of life for
[0:04:15] Idahoans and for others throughout the country and the world and whereas over 7,000 charitable
[0:04:22] non-profit organizations based in Idaho contribute significantly to our economy by providing services
[0:04:29] to our communities, employing over 79,000 Idahoans and producing total revenue of over $10 million
[0:04:38] dollars, excuse me, and whereas Idaho non-profit leaders often are entrepreneurs, create new
[0:04:44] solutions to problems, and fill previously unmet needs in the area of health, recreation,
[0:04:51] education, research, arts, social services, and more, and whereas Idaho gives weeks, services
[0:04:57] at time for Idahoans to join together with one voice on one day to contribute and amplify
[0:05:04] by the efforts of idle nonprofits,
[0:05:07] and whereas the nonprofit sector acts
[0:05:10] as a responsible steward of charitable dollars
[0:05:14] to achieve a diverse range of missions and goals,
[0:05:17] and whereas nonprofit organizations often fulfill
[0:05:20] their missions by advocating on behalf of those
[0:05:24] who cannot advocate for themselves.
[0:05:26] Therefore, I, Ruth Pierce, mayor of the city of Twin Falls,
[0:05:30] to proclaim the week of April 28th through May 1st, 2025,
[0:05:35] as the Idaho gives week in the city of Twin Falls
[0:05:38] and encourage all residents to continue to recognize
[0:05:42] and support the many nonprofit organizations
[0:05:45] in our community.
[0:05:46] And we have to accept, Daryl Foth is from,
[0:05:50] I said that wrong, didn't I,
[0:05:51] after you tried to correct me, I like four times.
[0:05:54] From the Idaho gives board here to accept the proclamation.
[0:06:44] I know that's not going to be the case on this next one.
[0:06:48] Okay, the next proclamation is for public service
[0:06:52] recognition week, the week of May 4th through 10th, 2025,
[0:06:57] where Americans are served every single day by public servants at the federal
[0:07:01] state, county, and city levels, and these unsung heroes do the work that keeps our
[0:07:07] nation working. Whereas many public servants, including
[0:07:11] military personnel, police officers, firefighters, and others risk their lives each day in service
[0:07:19] to the people of the United States and around the world.
[0:07:23] Whereas public servants include planners, public works crews, first responders, librarians,
[0:07:29] parks, and recreation staff, IT specialists, engineers, human resource specialists, building
[0:07:36] inspectors, finance officers, prosecutors, and countless other occupations, they provide
[0:07:42] the diverse services demanded by the American people of their government with efficiency and
[0:07:47] integrity.
[0:07:49] Whereas without these public servants at every level, continuity would be impossible
[0:07:54] in a democracy that regularly changes its leaders and elected officials.
[0:08:00] Therefore, I, Ruth Pierce, may have the City of Twin Falls do hereby proclaim the week
[0:08:05] of May 4-10 as Public Service Recognition Week. All citizens are encouraged to recognize the
[0:08:12] accomplishments and contributions of government employees at all levels, federal, state, county,
[0:08:19] and city. We have Ancina from the city accepting.
[0:08:55] Madam Mayor and City Council members, on behalf of us at the City of Twin Falls, thank you
[0:09:02] for proclaiming the first week of May as Public Service Recognition Week.
[0:09:08] Every day, public servants across our city dedicate themselves to serving our citizens.
[0:09:15] These unsung heroes perform the work that keeps our community running,
[0:09:20] often in ways that we don't even realize.
[0:09:24] In celebration, we invite you to join us next week
[0:09:27] for department tours and social wellness activities that we,
[0:09:32] as we come together to recognize and appreciate one another.
[0:09:37] Along with the police department, we also invite you to attend the Bracken
[0:09:41] Memorial Service on Thursday, May 8th as we honor the memory of the officer
[0:09:46] who made the ultimate sacrifice for our community.
[0:09:50] Following the service, the police department will unveil a new archival
[0:09:54] case displaying the uniform worn on the night of officer
[0:09:58] Bracken's death, preserving a powerful piece of our history.
[0:10:04] Finally, we thank you Mayor Pierce, City Council members, and City Manager Team for your leadership
[0:10:12] and service.
[0:10:13] We recognize that our City approaches public service differently.
[0:10:19] With our Council, Manager's Forum of Government, and we are stronger and better because of it.
[0:10:26] Thank you.
[0:10:28] Thank you. Okay. Next on the agenda is the consent calendar. Council wishes move to approve the consent calendar. Thank you. Do I have a second?
[0:10:44] Not a mural second. Thank you motion by Chris Reed second by Grayson Stone to approve the consent calendar as written. Amy Roll call vote please.
[0:10:54] Ruth Pierce. Yes. Ruth Reed. Yes. Great. Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. Spencer Cutler. Yes. Grayson Stone. Yes.
[0:11:03] and Sherry Wilmer.
[0:11:04] Yes.
[0:11:05] Perfect, thank you.
[0:11:06] Motion passes seven to zero.
[0:11:09] Okay, next under items of consideration,
[0:11:13] our first item is an action item.
[0:11:15] A request to confirm the city manager's appointment
[0:11:18] of Matthew Hicks to the position of police chief
[0:11:21] for the city of Twin Falls.
[0:11:23] Upon confirmation, the mayor will administer the oath
[0:11:26] of office.
[0:11:27] We have our city manager, Travis Rothweiler.
[0:11:30] Welcome, Travis.
[0:11:31] Thank you, Madam Mayor, members of the council.
[0:11:34] It is my pleasure to stand before you
[0:11:37] and to recommend Matthew Hicks to the position of chief
[0:11:42] of police for the city of Twin Falls.
[0:11:45] Idaho Code 5811 says it shall be the responsibility
[0:11:49] of the city manager to recommend the appointment
[0:11:52] of all department heads to the governing board
[0:11:55] for their consideration.
[0:11:58] Twin Falls municipal code says that city council members
[0:12:01] and members shall deal with administrative services only through the City Manager.
[0:12:07] And the City Manager shall have the opportunity to recommend names for the appointment of the
[0:12:11] position of department head, which the Chief of Police is.
[0:12:16] And so it's with great pleasure that I bring forward to you, Matthew Hicks.
[0:12:21] And Matt in our organization is probably one of the longest-serving members that we have today.
[0:12:27] a 31-year career and 100% of his career in law enforcement has been with us. He has served
[0:12:38] in every single position that we've had in our organization and he has had the opportunity
[0:12:43] to serve our community as captain since the year 2005. He has grown in each one of those
[0:12:54] years, and I could go through his entirety of his resume that's available. He has a
[0:13:01] master's degree in Human Resource and Training from Idaho State University. He has graduated
[0:13:07] from the prestigious FBI National Academy, session number 228. He has continued his academic
[0:13:15] pursuits as he is a graduate of the senior executive institute at the University of Virginia.
[0:13:22] He has ingrained himself in our organizational culture.
[0:13:27] He has been a teacher and a leader.
[0:13:31] He is considered a mentor and a friend by many.
[0:13:35] And all you have to do is look at the crowd tonight.
[0:13:38] It is not only filled with members of our current TFPD team,
[0:13:46] but there are several retirees that have come
[0:13:49] to watch this occasion.
[0:13:52] There are members of other departments, there are members of the city's executive leadership
[0:13:56] team, and I think that's a testament to the character of the person that I'm bringing forward
[0:14:02] to you this evening.
[0:14:05] This is not the first time that Matt has put his name into the ring to be the chief, and
[0:14:13] what I would describe is Matt is not only loyal to the organization, but he is tenacious,
[0:14:21] he is courageous, and he's also humble.
[0:14:27] He is a person that I trust fully.
[0:14:31] I've watched him grow in my time inside of the organization.
[0:14:36] I've watched him develop into the leader that is before you
[0:14:41] today.
[0:14:43] And I believe it is through true reflection
[0:14:45] that we have the opportunity to grow.
[0:14:48] And I believe that he is more than ready and demonstrated
[0:14:52] the skill sets to leave the Twin Falls Police Department
[0:14:55] into the future.
[0:14:58] Last Thursday, we had the opportunity to celebrate the 35-year career nine years up with the City
[0:15:06] of Flint Falls in Chief Kingsbury.
[0:15:10] And sometimes there's a learning curve, and I'm not saying that there's not a learning
[0:15:13] curve because whenever you step up, but I believe that Matt has done everything that
[0:15:20] he can to take the organization and build upon the leadership legacy that has been left
[0:15:26] by Craig, that he is not only going to hit the ground,
[0:15:30] but he is going to hit the ground running,
[0:15:33] and he is going to be able to continue
[0:15:36] to lead our organization and the police department
[0:15:40] moving forward.
[0:15:42] As a member of the executive leadership team,
[0:15:48] Matt has the respect of all of those members.
[0:15:51] He has had the opportunity to serve as a facilitator
[0:15:54] of our executive leadership team sessions.
[0:15:57] And now he's going to serve as a member of that team
[0:16:01] with your confirmation.
[0:16:02] And so it is my pleasure and honor
[0:16:05] to bring for you Matthew X to the position of chief of police.
[0:16:10] I'm happy to stand for any questions.
[0:16:13] I'd also invite him to come forward
[0:16:16] to answer any questions that you might have as well.
[0:16:19] Thank you, Travis.
[0:16:20] Any questions for Travis or Matthew?
[0:16:26] I don't have any questions, but if the council is ready, I'll make a motion.
[0:16:31] Okay. Mayor, I move that we approve the city manager's recommendation of Matthew Hicks,
[0:16:38] the position of police chief for the city of Twin Falls and upon that, on the confirmation,
[0:16:44] ask the mayor to administer the oath of office.
[0:16:47] Thank you, Jason Brown.
[0:16:48] I'll second that.
[0:16:50] Thank you.
[0:16:51] Motion by Chris Reed.
[0:16:52] by Jason Brown to approve or confirm the appointment of Matthew Hicks to the position
[0:16:59] of the City of Twin Falls. Upon confirmation, the Mayor will administer the oath of office.
[0:17:08] Any further discussion? Amy Roll call vote please.
[0:17:12] Chris Reed. Yes.
[0:17:14] Craig Hawkins. Yes.
[0:17:15] Jason Brown. Yes.
[0:17:17] Spencer Cutler, Bracen Stone, Jerry Volmer, and Bruce Pierce.
[0:17:23] Yes. Thank you, Mel, she passes 7-0.
[0:17:28] So, Madam Mayor, one of the things that is true about all leadership roles, especially with the City of Twin Falls, is we embrace a family first culture.
[0:17:39] and to help celebrate this chief Hicks,
[0:17:45] as asked that his family be a part of the ceremony
[0:17:48] and so I would invite Chief Hicks and Madison and Brady
[0:17:52] to come forward as part of the process they're going to remove his captain's bars.
[0:18:23] His wife, Jamie, is going to pin the chief badge,
[0:19:09] and his father is going to take a minute to pin the symbol of the chief of police
[0:19:14] on his daughter Kylie, who also pinned the other side.
[0:21:09] I would invite the council, the command staff,
[0:21:12] members of the city's executive leadership team,
[0:21:15] and all those who have come to support
[0:21:19] chief Hicks in this journey to congratulate him
[0:21:22] on this moment.
[0:26:10] So Madam Mayor, members of council,
[0:26:11] I know that chief Hicks has a few words
[0:26:15] that he would like to share with you and the community,
[0:26:18] But prior to that, we would ask that he officially introduce his family, friends, and guests that
[0:26:25] have come to celebrate with him in this occasion.
[0:26:27] Madam Mayor, remember the council, thank you for indulging all of that.
[0:26:37] I appreciate the patience for that.
[0:26:39] I want to introduce a few people here that are very meaningful to me.
[0:26:44] First of all, I would not be here without my wife, Jamie.
[0:26:48] Next, I want to introduce my father, Michael Hicks, who drove all the way down from Boise
[0:26:52] here today, be here.
[0:26:54] My father-in-law Ron, my daughter Madison, my daughter Kylie, my sister Ronnie, sorry
[0:27:05] he just got choked up Ron.
[0:27:07] My mother-in-law Patty, her son Freddie, my son Brady, his girlfriend Layla, my friend's
[0:27:15] Heather, the Stott's family that I know you're very familiar with.
[0:27:21] John, nice to see you sir.
[0:27:22] And my friend Pat Kennedy, we went to college together, Pat works for the Vancouver Police
[0:27:26] Department.
[0:27:27] We've been lifelong friends and have,
[0:27:30] far enough to make it the drive all the way down here.
[0:27:33] There's a number of people left in the room
[0:27:34] that are meaningful to me,
[0:27:35] that there's one person in particular,
[0:27:39] legendary police chief, Lee Devore,
[0:27:41] and his wife, Barbara, here.
[0:27:43] Lee has been a lifelong mentor for me,
[0:27:46] and obviously one of the people that I worked for
[0:27:49] in the past.
[0:27:51] But for all of you that are here,
[0:27:52] that I didn't get a chance to introduce,
[0:27:54] just know how meaningful your presence here is to me.
[0:27:57] I would not be anywhere in life without your friendship and support, and I cannot thank you
[0:28:03] enough for sharing this moment with me.
[0:28:04] Thank you all for being here.
[0:28:14] I specifically want to thank Madam Mayor U and the other members of the Council.
[0:28:21] You continue to lead this community with vision and integrity, and I'm humbled by the trust
[0:28:26] that you placed in me.
[0:28:28] I want to say the same thing to you that I told the members of the TFD two weeks ago
[0:28:32] at a department meeting.
[0:28:34] I really want to do a good job for you.
[0:28:36] So please know that.
[0:28:38] I want to thank Travis, Gretchen, and Mitch
[0:28:40] for your faith in me and for your countless hours
[0:28:43] you've spent invested in mentoring, teaching,
[0:28:45] and listening to me.
[0:28:48] You three exemplified the best of the one city mindset.
[0:28:52] And I'm deeply honored that you want me to serve in this role.
[0:28:55] I recognize that I will not only be the police chief,
[0:28:58] but a critical leader within the City of Twin Falls
[0:29:00] organization and therefore an extension of you.
[0:29:04] I want you to know that I am all in
[0:29:06] and I will not let you down.
[0:29:09] I cannot thank everybody enough for attending tonight
[0:29:12] and supporting me for over the years.
[0:29:14] I wanna thank you all for your advice, your counsel,
[0:29:16] and at times, your brutally honest feedback.
[0:29:20] You've made me a better man,
[0:29:22] and while I know that I have your support,
[0:29:24] I absolutely feel the magnitude of your expectations.
[0:29:28] For those of you representing our key partners here tonight,
[0:29:31] our community is so much better off
[0:29:33] because you are here in those roles,
[0:29:35] and because you choose to see
[0:29:37] your organizations with honor, thank you for being here.
[0:29:41] I want to thank all the members of the police department
[0:29:44] for being the guardians of Twin Falls.
[0:29:48] And let me say how truly humbled and honored
[0:29:50] I am to be your new police chief.
[0:29:53] This department has a 118 year tradition
[0:29:56] of providing professionalism, respect, integrity,
[0:30:00] dignity and excellence.
[0:30:02] And I am committed to building that legacy
[0:30:04] with each and every one of them.
[0:30:06] Their devotion and perseverance in their resolve
[0:30:09] continue to inspire me every day,
[0:30:11] and the people of the TFD are simply
[0:30:14] some of the best people I've ever met in my life.
[0:30:17] I believe the strength of our department lies in its people.
[0:30:20] Their hard work and sacrifices every day
[0:30:23] make us very strong, and as your chief,
[0:30:25] I will always support you, listen to your concerns,
[0:30:28] and advocate for the tools and the environment
[0:30:31] they need to succeed.
[0:30:33] And finally, again, I want to thank my close family
[0:30:35] friends, especially my children, and I'm sorry, I forgot to introduce somebody,
[0:30:41] or I grant some Benjamin sitting on my wife's lap. I will continue to try to
[0:30:50] live up to your aspirations for me. I would be nothing without all of you, and
[0:30:54] you all give me a sense of purpose and determination to try to be a better
[0:30:57] husband, father, grandfather, and friend that you all deserve. I've had the
[0:31:05] opportunity over the last 31 years to work for seven different police chiefs, and
[0:31:08] have learned valuable lessons from all of them.
[0:31:12] Our vision in the Police Department is simple.
[0:31:14] They will continue to focus on aggressively pursuing criminals,
[0:31:18] becoming victims centered in our approach
[0:31:20] to resolving community problems, and being deeply connected
[0:31:24] to our community to resolve their issues.
[0:31:27] In my opinion, the public trust is the key
[0:31:30] of effective policing.
[0:31:32] Police legitimacy is predicated on that public trust
[0:31:36] and requires a robust collaboration
[0:31:39] of the law enforcement and the community they serve.
[0:31:42] My commitment is to lead with transparency, integrity,
[0:31:44] and focus on strengthening those partnerships
[0:31:47] and the people we serve.
[0:31:49] I cannot thank you enough,
[0:31:51] members of the council for your trust
[0:31:53] and stand for any questions
[0:31:56] or let you move on with your meeting.
[0:31:58] Thank you.
[0:31:59] I don't think we have any questions.
[0:32:01] Thank you, congratulations.
[0:32:02] We'll put you on the hot seat next week, how's it at?
[0:32:15] So I don't know if we could take a few minutes
[0:32:19] if we want to clear out the auditorium for anybody
[0:32:23] who is not going to stay for this riveting meeting
[0:32:26] that we're about to have.
[0:32:29] It's hard to top, yeah.
[0:32:32] Hard to top what we just did.
[0:34:09] Okay, so we're going to move on to item B
[0:34:13] under items in consideration.
[0:34:17] This is an action item.
[0:34:18] It's a request to confirm the mayor's appointment of Thomas Bixler to serve on the Parks and Recreation Commission.
[0:34:25] And we have Mitch Humboldt standing in for Wendy.
[0:34:30] Right. We have another appointment. Almost as important as the last one in Parks and Recreation Commissioner.
[0:34:36] I was not involved in this, but Wendy said at conference today.
[0:34:39] And so I told her I would pitch it for.
[0:34:42] So we had an opening on the Parks and Recreation Commission.
[0:34:46] And as we usually do, we'd notify that opening and had nine applications, which is really excellent, actually, to have nine for one position.
[0:34:55] Sherry and Wendy interviewed the nine, so Sherry, correct me if I'm just speaking in here, but I understand it was all nine were really excellent applicants.
[0:35:04] And it was a tough choice.
[0:35:06] The interviewing committee recommends Tom Bixler, who has some experience with golf, some experience with youth coaching.
[0:35:15] with youth coaching. Let's see what else. There's one more thing I'm missing here.
[0:35:22] And a lot of community relationships that they felt would be important. So they
[0:35:27] recommended Tom Bixler's name to Ruth Pierce. And I think Mary, you were gonna
[0:35:32] recommend that this appointment be confirmed by the council. So with that, I
[0:35:38] think Tom is here, right? Yep. And so he's ready for your tough questions if you
[0:35:45] have one I guess. Any questions for Mitch or Tom?
[0:35:50] Jay Volmer. I should have thought of some really tough questions. I think this is equally
[0:35:59] as important as to the one that we just had. Well, maybe.
[0:36:03] Appointment that we had, but I'm excited to have Tom on here. He also brings
[0:36:09] He brings a lot of outside knowledge as well.
[0:36:14] He's been all over the state,
[0:36:16] and so not just bringing in parks suggestions
[0:36:22] or parks, you know, do's and don'ts from other states.
[0:36:26] It's actually from within our state, which is great.
[0:36:29] And he's excited to get on and see how we run
[0:36:34] and what we can do, and so we're excited to have him on.
[0:36:37] So with that, I would like to go ahead and make the motion.
[0:36:42] Does anybody have questions?
[0:36:44] I think we're good.
[0:36:45] OK.
[0:36:46] I would like to move that we confirm the mayor's appointment
[0:36:50] of Thomas Bixler to serve as the Parks and Recreation
[0:36:54] Commission.
[0:36:55] Thank you, Grace and Stone.
[0:36:56] Thank you, Madam Mayor.
[0:36:57] I will second.
[0:36:58] Thank you, motion by Sherry Vollmer, seconded by Grace
[0:37:01] and Stone to approve to confirm the mayor's appointment
[0:37:04] of Thomas Bixler to serve on the Parks and Recreation
[0:37:08] Commission any discussion Amy roll call vote please
[0:37:14] Pray cockens Jason Brown. Yes, that's our cutler. Yes, Jason Stone. Yes, Jerry Volmer. Yes
[0:37:21] Ruth Pierce. Yes, and Chris Reed. Yes. Thank you motion passes seven to zero
[0:37:26] I don't know Tom if you want to come down and say something you're not forced to okay
[0:37:34] Man a few words. We like that. Thank you. Congratulations
[0:37:38] Okay. Thank you, Tom. Okay, next on the agenda is a presentation. Presentation to Council
[0:37:53] on the results of the 2024 National Citizen Survey, and we have Mandy Thompson, Assistant
[0:37:59] to the City Manager. Welcome, Mandy.
[0:38:03] Good evening, Madam Mayor and Council. Well, good evening. Thank you for allowing me some
[0:38:52] time to give you an update on the Citizen Survey. So we've been doing this for a few
[0:39:02] years now. The Citizen Survey is conducted by the National Research Center which was acquired
[0:39:09] by a company called Colco about three years ago, but the research center still exists
[0:39:15] within that larger parent company. And it was developed in order to provide communities
[0:39:20] some level of accurate and affordable means by which to assess not only the work that they
[0:39:26] were doing but their citizens interpretation of the work and the services that they're providing.
[0:39:32] So prior to 2022, we had been doing this every other year. So what we do kind of backing up,
[0:39:40] what we do is we divide the city into four quadrants along Blue Lakes and Addison and then we
[0:39:48] we send out 3,000 random surveys to recipients.
[0:39:53] Those individuals are selected at random, although we have had a few instances this year where
[0:39:58] because we tend to over sample and multi-family units, so apartment buildings, where there's
[0:40:03] just larger density, we have had a couple of different individuals reach out to the city
[0:40:08] concerned that they were being targeted because they had received the Citizen Survey three
[0:40:12] years in a row.
[0:40:13] So I've had some conversations with POCO about making some adjustments to make sure that
[0:40:18] individuals are not receiving them multiple years in a row, because what we want to do
[0:40:22] is we want to ensure that our citizens believe that these are anonymous surveys, and so I
[0:40:27] think it's hard to not feel so much like that if you do start getting those every year.
[0:40:32] So, but again, the citizens are selected at random and they're contacted three times throughout
[0:40:39] the process to make sure that they know that they were selected.
[0:40:42] So this is just a representation of the survey and you can kind of see based on the color
[0:40:47] how we break up the community and those are where obviously not necessarily who answered,
[0:40:53] but who received a notification that they were selected to participate in the survey.
[0:41:00] So this year, 2,888 households received the survey.
[0:41:06] That's based upon, we keep any of the postcards that we receive back so that we know that not
[0:41:12] every household that was sent to survey received at a lot of times those are based on vacancies
[0:41:18] in homes and apartments.
[0:41:21] Four hundred and eighty two individuals completed the survey which is about a 17% response rate.
[0:41:27] We've slowly been declining in the response rate that we have that we've been receiving
[0:41:36] over the last several years.
[0:41:37] Initially I felt like it was maybe due to the fact that we more than almost doubled the number
[0:41:42] of surveys that we send out.
[0:41:44] When I first took over this project,
[0:41:46] we were only sending out about the first time
[0:41:48] I was 1,200 and then 1,500.
[0:41:51] So when we've really always kind of stayed
[0:41:54] around that same number of individuals returning the results
[0:41:59] or the surveys, excuse me, regardless of the number
[0:42:01] that we send out.
[0:42:03] However, there's not any difference in costs from POCO
[0:42:05] to send it to 1,500 or 3,000.
[0:42:07] So we try to over sample again,
[0:42:09] just so that we can make sure
[0:42:10] and we get a decent response way.
[0:42:12] Great, and additionally, the results are weighted
[0:42:16] to reflect the demographics of the population,
[0:42:19] and those would be the demographics that are reported
[0:42:20] in the Census in 2020, and then if there are any
[0:42:24] significant changes in the 2022 America,
[0:42:27] or the community survey that is released
[0:42:29] by the Census Bureau every two years.
[0:42:32] The purpose of the waiting is to make sure
[0:42:34] that the responses are reflective of the larger population,
[0:42:37] because obviously not everyone has an opportunity
[0:42:40] to take the survey, but one of the things that we've noticed
[0:42:46] the last couple of years is it creates some challenging challenges
[0:42:49] with muting some voices while elevating others.
[0:42:53] So this is just a page out of the survey itself,
[0:42:59] and it just gives you an idea of who's taking percentage wise,
[0:43:02] who's taking the survey.
[0:43:03] And you can see that the unweighted is just truly the flat percentage
[0:43:07] of individuals taking the survey.
[0:43:09] So our largest response rate is our from citizens over 55.
[0:43:14] More women.
[0:43:16] The lowest response rate rate is for citizens 18 to 34 males.
[0:43:22] We have more homeowners responding than non-home owners.
[0:43:24] And we have more non-mistem Hispanic or Caucasians
[0:43:29] responding over Hispanic.
[0:43:31] So we had, it took a little while to bring these results to
[0:43:35] because we had to talk and we had to have several conversations
[0:43:38] about how we wanted to address that,
[0:43:40] because I was able to get a hold of the raw data from POCO
[0:43:44] to have an idea of what were these responses.
[0:43:49] They weren't so wildly different
[0:43:51] that it really vastly changed the results.
[0:43:55] But you can see here where 34% of respondents
[0:43:59] were women, 55 and older, but with the weighted system,
[0:44:06] They were only accounted for 18%.
[0:44:09] So it definitely muted that.
[0:44:11] And if you go to the very top line,
[0:44:13] you'll see almost the complete inverse of that,
[0:44:15] which was only 18 to 34 year old, excuse me,
[0:44:19] 12% of 18 to 34 year olds that received the survey responded.
[0:44:23] But they were able to,
[0:44:24] their weighted response was at 35%.
[0:44:28] So when you're looking at that age demographics.
[0:44:31] So it definitely elevates and meets those voices.
[0:44:34] And so it's interesting to look at the unweighted data
[0:44:39] to see if there were any major shifts.
[0:44:42] There were a few, but in order to kind of keep things
[0:44:45] a little less complicated, I'm reporting
[0:44:49] on the weighted results tonight, and there
[0:44:52] are a few places where I'll tell you
[0:44:53] where there was a real change between the nonweighted
[0:44:57] and the weighted results.
[0:45:00] So the survey looks at various different facets
[0:45:05] of livability, our natural environment, our utilities,
[0:45:08] parks and rec, the citizens feel safe,
[0:45:10] our health and wellness, and so forth.
[0:45:12] And so this is the first time that the graphic has looked
[0:45:18] like this, and I think it's the most easy
[0:45:20] that they've ever made it to understand.
[0:45:22] Because remember that when you look at those percentages,
[0:45:25] remember that we're looking for the people
[0:45:28] who have rated whatever question they're being asked
[0:45:32] as either excellent or good.
[0:45:36] And so they're asked kind of two lines,
[0:45:40] the quality of the services, and if they're important.
[0:45:43] And so I think it's really interesting to see
[0:45:45] that in some of these areas, like for instance,
[0:45:46] our natural environment, the respondents,
[0:45:48] we're rated 70%, 4%, in general,
[0:45:52] of the natural environment of Twin Falls
[0:45:54] is being either excellent or good,
[0:45:56] and they also are saying it's also very important
[0:45:58] that we have, you know,
[0:45:59] that the natural environment is cared for.
[0:46:02] 66% of respondents rated essentially that the safety
[0:46:08] in Twin Falls is excellent or good,
[0:46:10] and obviously 91% of those taking the survey felt
[0:46:14] that it was very important to live in a safe environment.
[0:46:16] So you can kind of just see where,
[0:46:19] you can see how we fair, you know,
[0:46:23] how we're doing versus the importance
[0:46:25] of the services that we're providing.
[0:46:27] And I think one that's very interesting,
[0:46:30] and one we're finally making some in-roads in,
[0:46:33] is on mobility, specifically public transportation.
[0:46:37] We look at that overall mobility score is 23% is excellent
[0:46:42] or good, and what our citizens are saying
[0:46:45] is it's really important that we have,
[0:46:46] that mobility is taken into consideration.
[0:46:49] And just know that that's not just public transportation,
[0:46:51] that's always also the conditions of our streets,
[0:46:53] our sidewalks, is our community walkable,
[0:46:56] is it bikable, so it's important to our citizens
[0:46:59] that they're able to navigate the community
[0:47:02] and they're saying that we, in that instance,
[0:47:04] they are, but they believe we could do a little bit better job.
[0:47:08] So I think I did things a little bit different this year
[0:47:11] and I just went and spent some time looking over the report
[0:47:18] to just give you an idea of kind of those key findings.
[0:47:22] And truly, residents, they share an overall feeling of safety,
[0:47:26] 66% believe that it's the overall feeling of safety.
[0:47:30] It's twin falls, it's excellent, are good.
[0:47:32] That little down arrow just says that it's down
[0:47:35] from last year, that it was down from 69% last year.
[0:47:45] But in their own neighborhoods,
[0:47:47] in the downtown commercial area during the day,
[0:47:49] they feel very safe.
[0:47:51] And also, they feel safe from property crime and violent crime.
[0:47:57] So I would say in general, this is a nod to the work that the police department is doing
[0:48:02] to ensure that our citizens live in a community where they have an overall feeling of safety.
[0:48:09] And then again, remember that then we always also look at it's important to feel safe, but
[0:48:14] also the quality of the services that we provide.
[0:48:17] Our police services remained fairly neutral at 72%.
[0:48:23] Animal control increased from 63%.
[0:48:28] Fire services was up from 91%.
[0:48:31] They finally recovered from their dip during COVID.
[0:48:36] We always say everybody loves the firefighters,
[0:48:38] but, and then EMS as well, fairly neutral.
[0:48:41] They, I think, are only declined by 1%.
[0:48:44] So of those individuals that took the survey,
[0:48:47] I would say kind of an overall, you know, theme is that they do,
[0:48:50] or said that those individuals do feel safe.
[0:48:53] And again, I'd like to remind everyone that this is,
[0:48:56] it's a moment in time, you know,
[0:48:57] who knows what was influencing those individuals
[0:48:59] as they were answering those questions,
[0:49:01] but I would say in overall, they do have a feeling of,
[0:49:05] an overall feeling of safety in the community.
[0:49:07] And then this is just a graphic of either excellence or good,
[0:49:12] all the way down from fair to fair and for.
[0:49:14] Another area that actually was, the largest increases this year is just our overall confidence
[0:49:24] in the quality of the infrastructure that we have in Twin Falls.
[0:49:29] That was 10% from last year and those all in general are water, sewer services, storm
[0:49:37] water management, utility building, sanitation, so garbage collection was also the only one
[0:49:42] that continues to decline is recycling,
[0:49:45] but I think that is given considering the amount
[0:49:47] of that we've pulled back from our recycling program.
[0:49:50] But I would say that the citizens are recognizing
[0:49:55] the work that we've been putting in over the years
[0:49:58] to shore up the infrastructure of Twin Falls.
[0:50:02] That's just another graphic representation of that.
[0:50:07] Mobility continues to be a challenge.
[0:50:09] So if you were to look at previous survey results,
[0:50:15] we are definitely doing better than we were,
[0:50:18] which we should, because up until only,
[0:50:21] not quite two years ago, we weren't even operating
[0:50:23] a public transportation system in Twin Falls.
[0:50:26] And what we did have was,
[0:50:28] had to continue to shrink year by year.
[0:50:31] So it really was not serving the vast population,
[0:50:34] majority of citizens in Twin Falls.
[0:50:36] So the quality of public transportation is seen fairly low,
[0:50:39] 22%, that's fairly stagnant from where it was last year.
[0:50:43] But I will say that the ease of travel by public transportation says 14 percent, my
[0:50:49] Euro is missing, but that's up from 8 percent last year.
[0:50:52] So citizens are, excuse me, ease of public transportation is 15 percent, and that's really
[0:50:58] totally stagnant.
[0:50:59] But travel by public transportation, last year people were taking the survey, only 8 percent
[0:51:03] had even used right TFT.
[0:51:05] So at least we are seeing an increase there as well.
[0:51:08] We're going to have to have some patients as we see some how those individuals that are
[0:51:14] taking the survey see public transportation.
[0:51:18] But I would also, if you were to go back to that page on the demographics of the individuals
[0:51:22] taking the survey, I'm not entirely certain that the individuals that are taking the survey
[0:51:26] are the individuals that are using the system either.
[0:51:28] So that's a little bit of a hard metric to measure.
[0:51:32] the overall quality of the transportation system continues to remain relatively low.
[0:51:39] Street repair was relatively stagnant and it only decreased by 2%.
[0:51:46] Street cleaning was up, lighting was up as well, snow removal continues to be a challenge.
[0:51:51] I believe that is down from 39%.
[0:51:59] So not a lot, but again, that is something that we know is a challenge for our citizens
[0:52:04] regardless of, you know, I mean if we were to take it this, do it this year with a relatively
[0:52:09] small, you know, number of snow events, we would probably still have citizens that felt
[0:52:15] that we did not perform as well as we could have.
[0:52:18] So I think again, sometimes that is the challenge of, which I'll touch on at the end of my
[0:52:23] presentation on telling our story and educating the public on why we do some of the things
[0:52:28] we do, the way we do them.
[0:52:30] of walking was down, which I thought was interesting because sidewalk repair and maintenance is
[0:52:35] up. So I think citizens are recognizing that we're putting money, as I know the Council's
[0:52:40] been committed over the last several years to improving sidewalks, especially those around
[0:52:45] public facilities. So definitely I think people are starting to recognize that we are trying
[0:52:50] to enhance the walking experience. And then this gives you an idea of what people think
[0:52:56] of the overall transportation system.
[0:53:02] This is interesting.
[0:53:03] This one was interesting to me.
[0:53:04] This was an area that also saw a lot of the most decline.
[0:53:09] And I believe is part of a larger story that we're seeing
[0:53:15] in our community, in our community, but our state,
[0:53:18] and our country.
[0:53:19] And that is just kind of a declining sense of community.
[0:53:24] Having looked at the results and understanding
[0:53:28] that in action and engagement, which is that one that's 41%, that's down from 11 points
[0:53:36] from 52% last year.
[0:53:39] So, I mean, I think we can all kind of sit here and have our own opinions about why perhaps
[0:53:45] that is, but I would say that in general individuals that are not really feeling engaged with our own
[0:53:51] community, the number of people attending public meetings are in the single digits.
[0:53:56] The number of people that are reaching out to city staff, as well as council members, is
[0:54:03] in like the low, like 10 to 12 percent.
[0:54:06] So not only are they not feeling engaged, but they're not reaching out and they're not seeking
[0:54:11] information.
[0:54:12] That's really challenging when you try to tell a story about why we don't allow residential
[0:54:16] streets during this snowstorm.
[0:54:19] And I think it's a constant challenge as to how to engage our community, get them excited
[0:54:24] about the things that we're doing when they're positive,
[0:54:27] and not only have to hear from citizens when, you know,
[0:54:30] there's a perception that we've done something wrong.
[0:54:33] And I know that last one is just value
[0:54:36] and respecting residents of a diverse background.
[0:54:38] That's down from the year before almost 10% as well.
[0:54:43] But it's interesting because in that same facet,
[0:54:48] people say that Twin Falls is a good place to live.
[0:54:51] The overall quality of life remains pretty steady.
[0:54:55] And there's just a small decrease in the overall image
[0:54:57] or reputation of the city of Flint Falls.
[0:54:59] So sometimes these are hard to interpret
[0:55:02] because they don't always make a lot of sense
[0:55:04] when you look at them overall.
[0:55:06] But I think it does still support an overall, I think,
[0:55:10] what we're seeing on a larger scale in the country right now.
[0:55:14] And these are just a couple of those representations
[0:55:17] of just connection within the community
[0:55:20] and the quality of life.
[0:55:21] So overall, I would say people believe
[0:55:23] that their quality of life is good here,
[0:55:26] but they don't feel engaged, not connected
[0:55:28] within their community.
[0:55:33] Citizens are continuing to demand quality parks
[0:55:35] and recreation amenities.
[0:55:37] Overall quality of our city parks is increasing,
[0:55:39] which is great to see.
[0:55:41] 69% believe that they're either good or excellent.
[0:55:44] And again, same with the availability
[0:55:46] of our paths and walking trails.
[0:55:50] And I think with the improvements
[0:55:52] that we've made down at Shoshan Falls,
[0:55:53] with the building out of VISTA meeting a park out by the new fire station that I'm hopeful
[0:55:58] that we'll continue to see some of these numbers increase.
[0:56:01] Again, it's always hard to know, you know, what parks they've visited.
[0:56:05] Remember the year that we did this right after we opened First Federal Park out at Sunway?
[0:56:10] And it was one of the worst reviews that the parks department had gotten in years.
[0:56:13] So, you know, you think, okay, well, whoever was answering those questions had not had
[0:56:18] an opportunity to visit that amazing park.
[0:56:19] But I think we're also building parks that aren't just
[0:56:25] serving a specific population.
[0:56:27] And so as we continue to build out those parks,
[0:56:29] hopefully that these will continue to increase.
[0:56:33] Recreational opportunities, specifically
[0:56:36] our recreational programs and our rec center and facilities,
[0:56:40] have seen a decline this year.
[0:56:42] Again, nothing major, but recreation programs
[0:56:47] is only down a couple percent.
[0:56:48] And then I think individuals still want to see a recreation facility in Twin Falls.
[0:56:52] I think as we all know the challenge is how we pay for it.
[0:56:59] And then the last that I just focus in on was how the economy is impacting our citizen.
[0:57:05] And I think this is very telling.
[0:57:07] It's a little bit dreary looking and I was, I met with Sean Berger to talk about some
[0:57:12] of the responses that he saw in, that we saw in the Citizen Survey and how they relate
[0:57:17] to the work that he does in economic development.
[0:57:20] And it's challenging because there's a lot of these things that are on this page that we
[0:57:24] as the City of Twin Falls we can't necessarily impact.
[0:57:27] But we ask the question and so I think it's worth reporting out that the overall economic
[0:57:34] health of the community is on the decline and our citizens are really feeling like we have
[0:57:40] less employment opportunities.
[0:57:42] They do not believe that Twin Falls is as good of a place to work as it was before.
[0:57:46] The vibrant downtown and commercial areas interesting especially after everything that
[0:57:50] we've invested in downtown.
[0:57:51] But I think it also comes on the hills
[0:57:53] of quite a few businesses closing downtown.
[0:57:56] Now, they're tending, I mean,
[0:57:57] we don't have very many vacant forest storefronts,
[0:57:59] so there are new businesses that are coming in,
[0:58:01] but I just think that's a cycle that people have noted.
[0:58:05] And so, that's something definitely that Sean
[0:58:09] and I spoke about that is something
[0:58:11] that he can pay attention to moving forward.
[0:58:15] And then, I think how the economy
[0:58:18] will impact your family income in the next six months, only 16% so that it would be good
[0:58:22] or excellent.
[0:58:23] So the majority of the individuals asking that, answering that question truly are living
[0:58:28] in a sense that the economy, the economic health of not initially just Twin Falls, but
[0:58:36] how a general economy impacts their family is definitely declining.
[0:58:42] And then obviously the affordability piece, which is a big reason and I think fees those
[0:58:47] answers to those questions, which is just, it is more expensive to live in to
[0:58:51] involve them. It has ever been. We've access to quality and healthy foods,
[0:58:58] childcare in preschool, quality mental health care. I think these are all things
[0:59:02] that's more expensive. The grocery store, you know, childcare is incredibly expensive,
[0:59:06] and then just looking at like that mental health piece I brought in there
[0:59:11] just because overall health care is not nearly as low as mental health care, so again, nothing
[0:59:18] that we can impact at the city, but recognizing that our citizens recognize that we have, you
[0:59:26] know, which I think a lot of people in this room know is we have a shortage of mental
[0:59:31] health providers in the community.
[0:59:35] Confidence in government, again, sorry to end on the downnotes,
[0:59:41] but, you know, it's down for the confidence of Twin Falls
[0:59:47] government, 40% down from 42%.
[0:59:51] Quality of services for taxes paid is only down
[0:59:53] a couple of percentages as well,
[0:59:55] but I think one of those I didn't put up there,
[1:00:00] ahead of my notes is the quality of services provided
[1:00:03] the federal government is like at 24%.
[1:00:05] So again, I think sometimes we sort of get the,
[1:00:11] you know, the residuals scores of how people
[1:00:14] are seeing things going on on a larger scale.
[1:00:17] And again, part of being able to tell our story
[1:00:20] is helping citizens understand the difference
[1:00:23] between what the federal government offers
[1:00:25] is versus what we, the city offer
[1:00:28] and how truly they're impacted on a daily basis
[1:00:33] much more so by what we're doing here.
[1:00:37] But overall, the quality of service
[1:00:38] has remained fairly stable, as well as the overall direction
[1:00:41] of the city, and we're not in any jeopardy in any way,
[1:00:46] in any jeopardy of that going to a ride.
[1:00:51] And it is, I think, definitely something
[1:00:58] to consider moving forward that we
[1:01:00] have to not only tell our story, but make sure
[1:01:02] that we counteract the impact that,
[1:01:06] what is going on around us,
[1:01:08] what the impact that that has on the perception
[1:01:10] that our citizens have of what we're doing here,
[1:01:13] that graphic of that.
[1:01:18] So I was going through and reading over,
[1:01:20] actually I saw this the other day,
[1:01:23] and I scribbled it down, I think I got it right,
[1:01:25] but the importance of telling our story,
[1:01:27] I would like to think can impact to some degree citizens,
[1:01:32] You know, maybe it won't be seen in the citizen survey, but the importance of telling our story
[1:01:39] and what we're doing and how we're doing it, because stories can change lives, communities
[1:01:43] and systems by understanding issues, creating relationships and connecting problems with
[1:01:47] solutions.
[1:01:48] So just to kind of tie in what we're doing and how we're trying to weave this all together,
[1:01:55] we get these results now.
[1:01:56] We've committed to doing this every year.
[1:01:58] since 2022. We ask our citizens these questions every year. As you know, we're going through
[1:02:06] a strategic planning update. And so the concept of if you look at those livability, those facets
[1:02:12] of livability, they all align almost perfectly with our focus groups within the strategic
[1:02:18] plan. So taking into consideration what we see in the citizen survey that has to be a
[1:02:26] piece of what's considered in the strategic plan moving forward and making sure that we
[1:02:32] are, we're asking the question and we're doing something with the results that we get.
[1:02:38] Part of A's budgeting has been a, it has been a slow role but we are making, we are getting
[1:02:45] momentum and this is where we're telling our story will be huge because today we started
[1:02:50] our budget hearings today and being able to tell individuals how much we're spending
[1:02:56] on a particular program, how much we're spending on a particular type of a program in comparison
[1:03:02] to other cities, you know, benchmark cities of a similar size. And really when, you know,
[1:03:07] when someone says you don't put enough money into snow plowing and we can say, well, actually,
[1:03:13] based upon the personal, you know, the personal power, the capital costs, the operation and
[1:03:18] And we can tell you that this is what we spend.
[1:03:21] And if we really, truly were to double the amount of snow
[1:03:25] plowing, that's what it would look like.
[1:03:29] We know that's the impact it would have to our budget,
[1:03:33] not just the line item of a new plow or additional maintenance
[1:03:38] or fuel, but also the manpower that
[1:03:40] is required to operate that machinery.
[1:03:42] So my hope is we continue moving forward.
[1:03:45] And as we have conversations, difficult conversations
[1:03:48] during the budgeting process about what needs to be cut,
[1:03:51] this gives not only staff an opportunity
[1:03:54] to tell their story about why it's important,
[1:03:56] but then we can educate the community and our citizens
[1:04:00] about how much we are investing in control
[1:04:04] in directed patrol versus undirected patrol,
[1:04:07] and what we are doing to help them feel safe.
[1:04:09] And then lastly, this is hopefully on the horizon
[1:04:13] for this next coming fiscal year,
[1:04:15] is really starting to move towards those performance measures.
[1:04:18] So, okay, so our citizens say they feel safe,
[1:04:21] but let's understand what it is about being inside
[1:04:24] of the City of Twin Falls, that what makes them feel safe.
[1:04:28] You know, and you look at a whole lot of data points
[1:04:30] about crime rate and the number of arrests made
[1:04:32] and the number of tickets issued,
[1:04:34] but really trying to understand like,
[1:04:36] one of those big metrics will be what we see
[1:04:39] in the Citizen Survey, which is that overall filling of safety.
[1:04:43] And if our citizens are telling us
[1:04:45] they don't feel safe, what can we do specifically
[1:04:48] to impact those feelings for them?
[1:04:50] What are the things that we know that we can do
[1:04:53] that have a positive impact on the overall feelings
[1:04:56] of safety for the community?
[1:04:58] So that is my end of my formal presentation.
[1:05:02] I did have, Rachel sends you guys a copy of the report
[1:05:05] and was in your team's inbox.
[1:05:09] So if you have any other questions about that
[1:05:12] or anything about what I presented to you tonight,
[1:05:14] I would be happy to stand for questions.
[1:05:16] Thank you, Mandy.
[1:05:16] Any questions on this survey?
[1:05:20] Teri?
[1:05:23] How do you determine how many surveys go out?
[1:05:26] That's a POCO or the National Research Center.
[1:05:29] That's, I believe they do a based population.
[1:05:33] Well, it's just a percentage of populations.
[1:05:35] I believe so, yes.
[1:05:36] That'll like five percent four.
[1:05:41] No, now that I want to stand up here and do math in my head.
[1:05:44] Oh, right.
[1:05:44] Sure.
[1:05:45] It's OK.
[1:05:46] It's close to about five percent.
[1:05:48] Yeah, thank you.
[1:05:51] In a couple of points, one of the things that Mandy had shared, and I think that some of you,
[1:05:55] so when the survey was issued I think is important. It was issued prior to the November election.
[1:06:01] So when you put things into context, one of the things that Mandy had shared was this is a particular sentiment at a point in time.
[1:06:11] in time, and I think if you look at the economy piece of it,
[1:06:14] and for those of you that attended the ATI conference,
[1:06:18] you'll appreciate that Jonathan Spendlove,
[1:06:20] who's probably one of the best economists
[1:06:22] in the state of Idaho, he had shared a graph
[1:06:26] that on one, depending upon your political affiliation,
[1:06:31] was how you viewed the economy,
[1:06:33] and one week prior to the election,
[1:06:36] if you tended to vote more Republican,
[1:06:39] You had a very dismal view of the economy.
[1:06:43] If you tended to vote more democratic,
[1:06:45] you had a very positive view of the economy.
[1:06:47] And what was absolutely amazing is they did that survey
[1:06:51] four days after the election.
[1:06:53] And it was inverse, where those who
[1:06:56] tended to vote more Republican had a much greater view
[1:07:00] of the economy and its trajectory moving forward.
[1:07:03] And those who devoted democratic actually
[1:07:06] had now a lesser view.
[1:07:09] So timing does matter.
[1:07:10] So that's one of the things I wanted to share is,
[1:07:13] Mandy did share, it did take us a while to get to it
[1:07:14] because the weighted stuff did have considerable debate
[1:07:18] inside of our organization where if you think
[1:07:21] about our household, so my family got a survey.
[1:07:26] And Amy wouldn't let me complete it.
[1:07:27] She said that I was biased.
[1:07:30] So, and maybe rightfully so, right?
[1:07:32] So she completed it, but if you think about the number
[1:07:35] of individuals who are in our community
[1:07:39] who may be, you know, not working or retired or the first person to get the mail is the one
[1:07:48] to complete the survey.
[1:07:50] And so, lessening their voices in comparison to amplifying how there's, I think, is one
[1:07:54] of the challenges that we had.
[1:07:56] And the other thing is that it's not perfect, right?
[1:08:00] There's a standard deviation with all of these things, and so when Mandy's talking about it,
[1:08:04] one or two points, plus it is within that standard deviation
[1:08:08] that's within the report.
[1:08:10] So it certainly shows areas that we can improve.
[1:08:13] I think it shows areas that we can continue to share our story.
[1:08:17] And thanks to Mandy for waiting through it.
[1:08:20] The results will be published online after tonight.
[1:08:24] It's voluminous.
[1:08:26] As you guys saw, it's rich with lots of information.
[1:08:30] And thanks to Mandy for participating, a nice concise
[1:08:36] report of several dozen pages of information.
[1:08:44] Keep track of this.
[1:08:44] Chris Reed.
[1:08:46] Mandy, just want to thank you.
[1:08:48] It's always fascinating to see this year over year
[1:08:50] and see the results that come back.
[1:08:53] You mentioned, when the first slides there, the breakdown,
[1:09:00] Is this only offered for those that take the survey in English or their office?
[1:09:04] No, you can also, you get the option in both English and Spanish.
[1:09:07] And one thing I felt to say is that you have the option now of online or a mail.
[1:09:11] So your first initial contact is a postcard with a code, with a website and a code.
[1:09:17] And if you choose to use do it online, you do it online and you're done.
[1:09:22] And you can choose English or Spanish online and then you get both English and Spanish version
[1:09:29] of the printed survey as well, so.
[1:09:36] Thank you, thank you, Mandy.
[1:09:38] I think that's it.
[1:09:40] He shaded.
[1:09:41] Thank you.
[1:09:47] Okay, next on the agenda is an action item.
[1:09:50] It's a rock creek sewer crossing on track,
[1:09:53] and we have Troy Vitek, our city engineer.
[1:09:57] Welcome, Troy.
[1:10:05] Thank you, Mayor and Council.
[1:10:07] I think this is a story I've told many times before,
[1:10:10] just for a refresher and for our audience.
[1:10:12] I came before you a long time ago. There is a sewer line crossing Rock Creek just south of the Addison Field there.
[1:10:19] It was kind of brought to our attention recently that is probably our responsibility on how easements were written.
[1:10:26] It hasn't been maintained at forever. So I came before you.
[1:10:30] That's the Alakay reserves towards the project and at that time we set aside $550,000
[1:10:38] anticipating the cost of this. I went out for a bit as the state code requires. We didn't receive
[1:10:45] any bidders at a lab and then I came back before you as to go and negotiate on the open market and
[1:10:52] our good social engineer did that on our behalf on the audience tonight. You have any questions
[1:10:58] technical questions you can answer them but he went work with PMF Inc and we defined his scope
[1:11:04] for the project and I think we can get it done for $362,168 and that's for the
[1:11:12] construction portion of it and then there's the landowner that's down there
[1:11:15] and he has some horses and some hay and some needs that need to be associated
[1:11:18] with that project in order for us to acquire an easement with him so we're
[1:11:23] in negotiations I think we've come to conclusion in exchange for an easement
[1:11:28] We're going to provide some AFERS, his horses and animals until such a time as we complete
[1:11:36] the project and we're replanting and working with the place down there so that he can have
[1:11:42] a reasonable expectation that one is done and looks like we never touched it again.
[1:11:47] So anyway, that looks like for the $362,000 contract with PMF, I also reserve some for
[1:11:55] a total of $450,000 so they intend us not to use all that or even for scene stuff or whatever,
[1:12:01] and then we still have the contract negotiated with them. So before you tonight to ask, allow
[1:12:09] me to sign this contract with the contractor and go forward with the construction project.
[1:12:13] Do you have any questions? I'd be happy. Thank you, Troy Spencer. This is a public meeting.
[1:12:20] This is recorded, so I say this positively. I think the contractor would get it. If there's
[1:12:26] There's ever a contractor that's just a cowboy that can get things done.
[1:12:29] This would be it, and this project is far from typical, so I'm glad we found a local
[1:12:35] contractor that's excited to get after it.
[1:12:38] I am too, and it seems like he has a relationship with the owner, so I think that works to our
[1:12:44] benefit as well.
[1:12:45] Oh, that's great.
[1:12:46] Jason Brown.
[1:12:47] Troy, so what the approval will be up to the $450,000?
[1:12:50] Yes, it would be.
[1:12:51] Yeah, it's looking for.
[1:12:52] that was the yeah looking for authorizing me to use city funds wastewater reserves up
[1:12:59] to four hundred fifty thousand contract release for three hundred six I was
[1:13:02] struggle with this part because we kind of get into the numbers here but I want
[1:13:06] to sign the contract and keep a low contingency for any unforeseen I'm ready
[1:13:12] to make a motion if if we're ready to go I'd move to approve the Rock Creek sewer
[1:13:18] We're crossing contract and authorized the city to sign the contract using sewer reserves
[1:13:26] up to $450,000.
[1:13:30] Thank you.
[1:13:31] Do you have a second?
[1:13:32] I'll second.
[1:13:33] Thank you.
[1:13:34] Motion by Jason Brown.
[1:13:35] Second by Sherry Volmer to approve the contract with PMF in the amount of $362,168 and reserve
[1:13:45] a total of $450,000 out of sewer reserve funds.
[1:13:49] Any further discussion?
[1:13:54] Amy Roll-Covall, please.
[1:13:57] Jason Brown.
[1:13:58] Yes.
[1:13:59] Spencer Cutler.
[1:13:59] Yes.
[1:14:00] Grayson Stone.
[1:14:01] Yes.
[1:14:02] Jerry Volmer.
[1:14:03] Yes.
[1:14:04] Ruth Pierce.
[1:14:05] Yes.
[1:14:06] Chris Reed.
[1:14:07] Yes.
[1:14:08] And Craig Hawkins.
[1:14:09] Yes.
[1:14:10] Thank you.
[1:14:12] Motion passes 7-0.
[1:14:13] Thank you, Troy.
[1:14:14] Thank you.
[1:14:15] Okay.
[1:14:16] Next item on the agenda is an action item.
[1:14:17] Consider a request for $90,000 in contingency funds to remove and replace the Senior Center
[1:14:23] roof and we have deputy city manager Gretchen Scott welcome. Good evening so
[1:14:28] I'm here before you tonight to ask for authorization for contingency funds for
[1:14:34] the senior center roof. In your agenda packets was included some photographs
[1:14:39] from one of the vendors that went up and did an inspection. On that roof you saw
[1:14:46] degraded flashing around different pieces on the roof missing shingles,
[1:14:51] torn areas, some staining of water damage to the roof. Inside the facility,
[1:14:59] right now the only leak that they are experiencing is it's following some of
[1:15:03] the HVAC mechanical stuff. It's not serious. However, the condition of the
[1:15:08] roof is giving us a really good indication that additional wind storms
[1:15:13] more rain, heavier snowfall that sat on the roof for a long time may have more
[1:15:19] significant interior damage. Our part of responsibility for the senior center is
[1:15:24] that we provide the facility and we're responsible for major repairs and maintenance.
[1:15:29] The ongoing maintenance, daily maintenance, those things are the responsibility of the
[1:15:34] the Leaser, VC, and then we take care of the major expenses. We were putting this
[1:15:42] into the budget for fiscal year 26 with funding for after October 1, but after
[1:15:47] seeing the results we realize that we probably need to accelerate this. So I'm
[1:15:52] here to ask for up to 90,000 we'll solicit informal bids, we'll get those
[1:15:58] responses, we'll take the low bidder and we'll go from there. So it looks like
[1:16:05] you've gotten a couple quotes that is just for potential where we think it's
[1:16:11] going to be they're not actually bids. Right I was soliciting that for the
[1:16:16] budget process so that we knew what to include. The only information that I had
[1:16:20] was 10 years prior to that and when they had done some repair work at that time
[1:16:25] it was $30,000. So that's your basis for the ask? Yes. Okay. Chris Reed. I'll make the
[1:16:36] motion unless there's other questions. Any questions? Okay go ahead Chris. I move
[1:16:41] that we approve up to 90,000 and contingency funds to remove and replace
[1:16:46] the senior center roof. Craig Hawkins. Seconded. Thank you motion by Chris Reed
[1:16:52] seconded by Craig Hawkins to approve the request of her 90,000 in contingency
[1:16:57] funds to remove and replace the senior center roof. Amy Roquevo please.
[1:17:03] That's for color. Yes. Grayson Stone. Yes. Jerry Bulmer. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes.
[1:17:10] Chris Reed. Yes. Craig Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 7 to 0.
[1:17:16] Thank you very much.
[1:17:17] Thank you Gretchen.
[1:17:18] Okay, that's it for items of consideration next on the agenda is the time for public
[1:17:25] input.
[1:17:26] There's anybody from the public that wishes to address City Council, please come down
[1:17:31] the podium, state your name and whether you're a resident of Twin Falls and remember you
[1:17:37] have two minutes.
[1:17:38] Welcome Maria.
[1:17:39] I don't think your mic's on, dear.
[1:17:47] Our proud follower of the Chief Standing Bear, Panka Indian Tribe,
[1:17:51] proud follower of John Lewis, Martin Luther King,
[1:17:55] proud follower of the Lion of the Tribe of Judah,
[1:17:57] proud follower of Chief Kingsbury,
[1:17:58] Twin Falls Police Department now,
[1:18:00] giving away the Chief Hicks,
[1:18:02] proud follower of Mayor Ruth Pierce, telling her story,
[1:18:06] her presentation was excellent.
[1:18:08] I enjoyed that information,
[1:18:10] even though it was kind of sad at times,
[1:18:13] but it's the world and the times we live in.
[1:18:15] So, the stories that can change lives, communities and systems
[1:18:19] by understanding issues connecting problems with solutions.
[1:18:23] So, I first would like to thank Christopher Reed and Spencer Cutler
[1:18:26] for attending the Human Dignity and Immigration Policy Forum on Tuesday, April 15th.
[1:18:31] I realize you were here on a Monday and then on a Tuesday you went over there
[1:18:36] and that's two long days back to back.
[1:18:38] You didn't have to do that which tells me you're showing a concern
[1:18:41] and you're telling your story.
[1:18:43] And so thank you for your actions on on behalf of the Latino community of Twin Falls.
[1:18:50] I was asked by journalist Sean Dolan if I felt a Latino panelist should have been there to
[1:18:55] represent the community.
[1:18:56] I responded they should have been for two reasons.
[1:18:59] One of the questions was was there how longs to take to become a legal alien to become legal.
[1:19:05] They couldn't answer it because of course there are occasion.
[1:19:08] So then there was a whole forum was white and then have you felt any racism or bigotry they
[1:19:13] they couldn't answer that as well.
[1:19:15] And so I was asked by the Times News a question,
[1:19:18] and so I just would like to say that,
[1:19:22] be like if you're having a Black Lives Matter forum
[1:19:25] with whites only, so I'm just gonna follow up on this,
[1:19:28] but I wanted to make a public, you know,
[1:19:30] I had to be open because I was open before the public,
[1:19:34] and I wanna represent my people.
[1:19:37] I plan to follow up in another way,
[1:19:38] but I made a public statement, so as I said,
[1:19:41] And also, I'd just like to say that add to the National Day
[1:19:46] of Prayer on Thursday night at City Park at 6 p.m.
[1:19:49] Thank you for your time.
[1:19:50] Thank you for being a follow-up with that.
[1:19:51] Thank you.
[1:19:53] Hey, anybody else in the audience that wishes
[1:19:55] to address City Council, please state your name
[1:20:03] and whether you're a resident of Twin Falls.
[1:20:05] Hello.
[1:20:06] I'm Steve McMaw and I am a resident of Twin Falls.
[1:20:08] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[1:20:11] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[1:20:16] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[1:20:20] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[1:20:24] it seemed like there's a lot of people that are coming against you guys,
[1:20:27] and I just wanted to say thank you for what you do, and Madam Mayor,
[1:20:32] and city manager.
[1:20:35] I just wanted to say thank you for what you have done,
[1:20:37] and I don't know your meetings are not riveting, so I've been.
[1:20:42] But anyway, the reason I'm up here is because of last week there was a couple of people that
[1:20:54] got up here and kind of put you guys down for the invocation that you introduced.
[1:21:04] So I just wanted to say thank you for introducing that, introducing that, and then I pray for
[1:21:11] voting for it. But these gentlemen, I don't know them, but in the process they quoted the
[1:21:19] state constitution and they basically said that the state constitution didn't condone the
[1:21:26] prayer. And so I looked at the constitution and there's a preamble to the constitution.
[1:21:32] I thought I'd bring it up here and read it. It says, we the people of the state of Idaho
[1:21:37] grateful to Almighty God for our freedom to secure its blessings and to promote our common
[1:21:44] welfare to establish this Constitution.
[1:21:47] So I thank you for putting this invocation into place.
[1:21:54] And so one of the reasons that I come here is I come here to pray for you individually
[1:22:01] name by name.
[1:22:02] So that's the only reason I'm here so thank you very much.
[1:22:06] Thank you, sir.
[1:22:09] Okay.
[1:22:10] Is there anybody else in the audience that wishes to address City Council?
[1:22:13] Okay.
[1:22:16] See no one advisory board reports anything from Council?
[1:22:20] Chris feet.
[1:22:21] We have the airport advisory committee this Tuesday over at the airport.
[1:22:27] Perfect.
[1:22:28] Thank you, Madam Mayor.
[1:22:31] So Twin Falls area Chamber of Commerce of their business days.
[1:22:35] It was really well attended.
[1:22:37] The breakfast was great.
[1:22:38] I think they had 38 vendors throughout the day.
[1:22:42] I didn't have a chance to spend much time there,
[1:22:43] but I walked through it was extremely well attended
[1:22:46] and seemed like it was a great event.
[1:22:48] So thank you.
[1:22:49] Perfect.
[1:22:50] Anybody else?
[1:22:51] It's great.
[1:22:52] I took the opportunity after Chief Kingsbury's retirement,
[1:22:57] as I'm only going to the library and view the display
[1:23:00] there, the revolutionary.
[1:23:02] And Grayson, again, I was not born during the revolution.
[1:23:07] But it was a great display.
[1:23:08] but I thought that was fun to see, so.
[1:23:11] Thank you.
[1:23:13] Diddy Manager's Office.
[1:23:15] Nothing, mm-hmm.
[1:23:17] Okay, so next is Executive Session, an action item,
[1:23:22] a request to adjourn to Executive Session Pursuant
[1:23:25] to Code, Idaho Code Section 74-206-1-C-F
[1:23:31] to acquire an interest in real property,
[1:23:33] not owned by a public agency to communicate
[1:23:37] with legal counsel or the public agency
[1:23:40] to discuss the legal ramifications of and legal opinions
[1:23:45] for ending litigation or controversies not yet being
[1:23:50] litigated but imminently likely to be litigated
[1:23:53] the mere presence of legal counsel at an executive session
[1:23:58] does not satisfy this requirement.
[1:24:00] I believe that's section 740061C and F,
[1:24:07] whoever's making the motion.
[1:24:08] So moved.
[1:24:10] Thank you to have a second.
[1:24:11] Second.
[1:24:12] Motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Craig Hawkins,
[1:24:15] to adjourn to executive session,
[1:24:18] pursuant to Idaho Code's sections,
[1:24:20] 74-2061-C and F.
[1:24:25] Amy Roll-Covell, please.
[1:24:28] Grace and Stone.
[1:24:29] Yes.
[1:24:30] Barry Vollmer.
[1:24:31] Yes.
[1:24:32] Ruth Pierce.
[1:24:33] Yes.
[1:24:34] Chris Reed.
[1:24:35] Yes.
[1:24:35] Craig Hawkins.
[1:24:36] Yes.
[1:24:37] Jason Brown.
[1:24:38] Yes.
[1:24:39] Yes.
[1:24:40] motion passes seven to zero just to let everybody know we will not be returning
[1:24:45] to chambers so most or meetings adjourned thank you
