Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2025-04-07, recording 1 (started 16:29)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2025-04-07/

[0:01:46] Good afternoon, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the July, it's sorry, April 7th, it's at 7, April 7, 2025 City Council meeting, want to confirm we have a quorum, we have all seven members present in chambers.
[0:02:04] First item on the agenda is an executive session.
[0:02:07] A request to adjourn to Executive Session pursuant to IDO code section 74-206-C to acquire
[0:02:17] interest in real property not owned by a public agency.
[0:02:20] F to communicate with legal counsel for the public agency to discuss the legal ramifications
[0:02:26] of and legal options for any litigation or controversies not yet being litigated but
[0:02:33] Imminently likely to be litigated the mere presence of legal counsel at a executive session does not satisfy this requirement
[0:02:41] Take a motion so moved. Thank you second second
[0:02:48] Thank you motion by Chris Reed second by Jason Brown to
[0:02:52] adjourn to executive session pursuant to Idaho code 74 206 1c and
[0:02:58] F Amy roll call vote please
[0:03:03] Yes.
[0:03:05] Chris Reed.
[0:03:06] Yes.
[0:03:07] Ray Cawkins.
[0:03:08] Yes.
[0:03:09] Jason Brown.
[0:03:10] Yes.
[0:03:11] Spencer Cutler.
[0:03:12] Yes.
[0:03:13] Grayson Stone.
[0:03:14] Yes.
[0:03:15] Thank you.
[0:03:16] Motion passes seven to zero.
[0:03:17] We'll be an executive session till approximately five o'clock and then we'll be back.
[0:03:43] Good evening ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the April 7, 2025 City Council meeting.
[0:03:49] I want to confirm we have a quorum.
[0:03:51] We have all seven members present in chambers.
[0:03:56] We met at 4.30 and had an executive session that took a little bit longer, so I appreciate
[0:04:01] your patience.
[0:04:03] Next on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance.
[0:04:05] If you wish to join me, please rise.
[0:04:28] Thank you.
[0:04:29] Before we get on to our meeting tonight, I do have a proclamation, and it is a proclamation
[0:04:36] for the month of the military child, April 2025.
[0:04:41] Whereas April is the month of the military child, an opportunity to recognize military
[0:04:46] children for the resilient spirits, personal sacrifices, strong character, and courage.
[0:04:52] And whereas military children are part of the strength of our nation, as they support and
[0:04:58] encourage their service members with a fierce patriotic spirit.
[0:05:02] And whereas these children are a source of pride for the great state of Idaho and to
[0:05:07] us all and it is only fitting that we take time to recognize their contributions and whereas
[0:05:14] military children continue to make the significant contributions to family, community and their
[0:05:20] nation as they endure prolonged and repeated absences of one or both parents.
[0:05:27] Therefore, I, Ruth Pierce, Mayor of the City of Twin Falls do hereby proclaim the month
[0:05:32] the April as month of the military child. So I, do we have anybody here to accept this?
[0:05:38] Until do you want to accept it? Oh, not really. Okay. All right. Moving along. Next on the agenda, we have our consent calendar.
[0:05:54] Council wishes. Move to approve the consent calendar as published. Thank you. Do I have a second?
[0:06:01] Not a mayoral second. Thank you. Motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Grace and Stone to approve the
[0:06:07] consent calendar as written. Amy Roll call vote please.
[0:06:11] Chris Reed, Greg Hawkins, Jason Brown, Spencer Cutler, Grayson Stone, Barry Bölmer, and
[0:06:21] Ruth Pierce. Thank you, motion passes 70-0. Okay, moving on under items of
[0:06:28] consideration, our first item is a presentation, a presentation to recognize
[0:06:34] Twin Falls Fire Department's newest firefighters, Ashley Palmer, Daniel Hamilton, and Porter
[0:06:41] Lorna, for their completion of Twin Falls Fire Department's Fire Recruit Academy. Take
[0:06:48] their firefighter oath and the pinning of their badges. And we have our chief fire chief,
[0:06:54] Mitchell Brooks. Welcome, Mitchell. Well, thank you, Mayor. Good evening to all of you.
[0:06:58] I just look at this crowd and think there's a lot more here today than there was last week. Would you agree?
[0:07:07] I didn't want to say anything, but I just want to recognize that. They have a lot of support. That's awesome.
[0:07:13] If I could have Ashley, Daniel, and Porter come down and join me before I get started, please.
[0:07:19] A little awkward. They have their backs to their families, but not for long.
[0:07:36] So anyway, I just want to I want to thank you guys for allowing us to have a little bit of time to celebrate this
[0:07:42] This is kind of cool. This is my first presentation as chief and what an honor it is to bring on new individuals, especially at this caliber. So
[0:07:52] These three have recently well first, let's let's do this. Here's what I'd like to do
[0:07:57] Could you guys introduce your families first? I think that's the most appropriate. So Daniel will start with you
[0:08:07] I'm a dad Dave, I'm a staff mom, Allison, along with some very good friends, brothers and sisters.
[0:09:09] They did a lot better job than I did when I introduced all my families.
[0:09:12] Anyway, these three individuals have completed an eight-week high-intensity fire academy that
[0:09:18] was taught by many of our line staff and our fire marshal.
[0:09:22] Some of them are in the crowd, and they're top-notch instructors, and there's a lot of work that goes into this.
[0:09:28] I appreciate their efforts.
[0:09:30] Over the course of the eight weeks, they learned basic firefighting skills, physical
[0:09:34] fitness requirements, and most importantly, about themselves.
[0:09:38] The bond that was created over the eight weeks period between them has been pretty fun to watch.
[0:09:43] These guys, when they started off kind of clunky just to put it nicely, and then at the
[0:09:48] end, it was really cool to see them gel together and kind of work as a team, so very proud of
[0:09:54] them.
[0:09:55] So I'll start with Ashley.
[0:09:56] She's an Idaho native.
[0:09:58] She was born in the metropolitan area of Oakley, Idaho.
[0:10:03] She attended the fire science program in CSI in 2023.
[0:10:07] She volunteered at Rock Creek Fire Department
[0:10:10] to get some experience, because she
[0:10:11] knew she wanted to be into firefighting.
[0:10:14] One of her cool projects that she worked over there
[0:10:16] was a peer fitness, peer support group
[0:10:19] that they didn't have before she arrived.
[0:10:23] Ashley is also a top-notch dedicated crossfitter,
[0:10:26] like many in the crowd, so that helps with the physicalities side of the fire
[0:10:32] department and today Ashley will be pinned, her badge will be pinned by her
[0:10:37] wife Ashley Finch, so we'll bring her up here in just a little bit. So Daniel, he had
[0:10:43] a pretty good career going with the BLM, he graduated from Lighthouse High School,
[0:10:49] worked for the BLM, he got to fly around and helicopters and look really good for
[0:10:54] many years, right? Got the radio voice. We'll hear it hopefully here in a little bit.
[0:10:59] He's getting ready to be married in October of this year, to his fiancee.
[0:11:07] Though he's eager to grow as a firefighter and serve the community, he considers home.
[0:11:12] Pining Daniels Badge will be his fiancee in Veronica.
[0:11:15] And then Porter, he from another large city in Idaho, Carey.
[0:11:21] He pursued kind of a welding path as a career early on.
[0:11:26] He went to CSI, got his degree in welding,
[0:11:28] and then he's quite the entrepreneur.
[0:11:30] He started his own business building trailers.
[0:11:33] And luckily, he found us as we had an opening,
[0:11:37] and we picked him up as a firefighter,
[0:11:39] so we're very thankful for that.
[0:11:42] Porter is passionate about serving Twin Falls
[0:11:44] and cherishes his role with our department.
[0:11:47] Pining his badge will be his girlfriend, Rian.
[0:11:51] So all three of these individuals are enthusiastic and committed to making a significant positive impact in our community.
[0:11:57] And I can't thank them enough for joining our team.
[0:12:01] So, Madam Mayor, I'd ask you, if you'd like to come down, give them the oath.
[0:12:05] I'm going to take a page out of Chief Kingsbury's book.
[0:12:08] We're going to do, we're going to sign two of them per person.
[0:12:12] And then in a year, when they, they complete their first year, I'll present that to them as a completion into the permanent status of the fire department.
[0:12:21] So I'll let you guys want to turn towards the mayor.
[0:14:28] So thanks, mayor.
[0:14:29] I appreciate that.
[0:14:31] Kind of a cool, fun fact in the fire department.
[0:14:35] With our current structure, they have six opportunities
[0:14:38] in their career to take the oath.
[0:14:41] I had the honor of taking my sixth one last week,
[0:14:44] which was super cool.
[0:14:45] So this is one of potentially six for you three,
[0:14:48] and I'm excited for you.
[0:14:50] So Ashley, if you could ask your wife to come down,
[0:14:53] we'll pin your badge first.
[0:15:34] you want to ask Veronica to come down and Porter, would you like
[0:16:26] Reanda come down and pin your badge? So Madam Mayor, if you
[0:17:10] guys would like to Council come down and congratulate them that
[0:17:13] will follow it with City Administration and then the
[0:17:17] firefighter family. Let's give them another round of applause.
[0:19:58] And just to kind of finalize us, did you guys want to say
[0:20:00] anything to the audience? Any speeches or anything? Okay. So
[0:20:05] I thought so again, Mayor, thank you for this opportunity
[0:20:09] Council, can we have a few minutes just to exit out of here?
[0:20:14] Yeah.
[0:20:15] OK.
[0:20:15] Thank you.
[0:20:15] I know everybody wants to stay, but anybody that does want to leave
[0:20:20] will take a couple of minutes.
[0:20:21] So thank you.
[0:20:23] OK.
[0:20:23] Congratulations.
[0:21:54] Quiet.
[0:21:55] OK.
[0:21:56] So next under items of consideration is an action item.
[0:22:00] A request to approve resolution 2025-004, declaring equipment
[0:22:07] number 96 20 surplus and authorized the sale to the City of Goody and in the
[0:22:12] amount of 30,000 we have our wastewater superintendent Gonzalez welcome Doug.
[0:22:17] Good evening Marin Council. How do you follow that? I don't know. Nice to get
[0:22:24] new team members. It's awesome to see. Yeah, but this one's pretty cool too. I
[0:22:28] think I'm really excited for the City of Goody to get this equipment. I know how
[0:22:34] much it helps our our municipality out I think this is going to be a great ad for
[0:22:39] for their fleet as well. So under the city of Twin Falls asset disposal policy
[0:22:45] disposal of or sale of surplus or outdated equipment is prioritized to
[0:22:51] ensure maximum benefit and utility within the community. This supports
[0:22:57] resource optimization and fosters broader community partnerships. Recently
[0:23:04] the wastewater collection and fleet maintenance departments assess the need for equipment
[0:23:09] 96-20, a Ford F-450 camera van originally purchased in 2003 for approximately $88,000.
[0:23:19] With the acquisition and delivery of new equipment, that was budgeted in this current fiscal year,
[0:23:26] the older model can now be deemed surplus.
[0:23:30] I contacted various municipalities to determine if there was any interest in purchasing the
[0:23:37] used equipment.
[0:23:39] The city of Gooding quickly responded.
[0:23:42] Being a small entity that has historically lacked the resources for infrastructure inspections
[0:23:47] without resorting to expensive external contracts.
[0:23:54] Gooding's Public Work Director Larry Biby believes our significant advantage is to adding
[0:23:59] the camera band to their operations. He highlighted how it would allow them to enhance their maintenance
[0:24:05] routines and effectively plan for future projects involving their wastewater and stormwater systems.
[0:24:12] For the City of Gooding, acquiring this van would mean a leap forward in operational capacity,
[0:24:18] enabling them to manage and maintain critical infrastructure more proficiently without excessive
[0:24:24] expenditures. Our recommendation to sell the van to the City of Gooding aligned with our
[0:24:30] asset disposal policy goals ensures that this sell results in intangible benefits.
[0:24:38] The city's readiness to sell the van at the price reflecting both its depreciation
[0:24:45] excuse me both its depreciation of M Gooding's budget constraints exemplifies our commitment to
[0:24:52] to fostering collaboration and our dedication
[0:24:55] to supporting the infrastructure needs
[0:24:57] of our neighboring cities.
[0:25:01] A majority vote of the council present tonight
[0:25:04] isn't needed to prove the request.
[0:25:07] The budget impact, the revenue collected from the sale
[0:25:10] of the property will be deposited
[0:25:12] into the wastewater reserve fund.
[0:25:16] There is no regulatory impact of this request.
[0:25:21] So in conclusion, the staff recommends
[0:25:23] Council declare equipment number 96 20 surplus and authorize the sale of the
[0:25:28] equipment to the City of Gooding IDO in the amount of $30,000. And I'll stand for
[0:25:35] any questions you may have for me. Any questions for Doug? Sherry Vomer. I will
[0:25:45] call for the motion. I was I moved to approve resolution 2025-004 declaring
[0:25:53] equipment number 96 20 surplus and authorize the sale to the City of Gooding in the
[0:25:59] amount of 30,000. Thank you Jason Brown. Second. Thank you motion by Sherry
[0:26:03] Vomer seconded by Jason Brown to approve resolution 2025-004 declaring
[0:26:10] equipment number 96 20 surplus and authorizing the sale to the City of Gooding
[0:26:16] in the amount of $30,000.
[0:26:20] Any further discussion?
[0:26:22] Amy Roll call vote please.
[0:26:25] Craig Hawkins.
[0:26:26] Yes.
[0:26:27] Jason Brown.
[0:26:28] Yes.
[0:26:29] Spencer Cutler.
[0:26:30] Yes.
[0:26:31] Grayson Stone.
[0:26:32] Yes.
[0:26:33] Barry Bomer.
[0:26:34] Yes.
[0:26:35] Bruce Pierce.
[0:26:36] Yes.
[0:26:37] And Chris Reed.
[0:26:38] Yes.
[0:26:39] Thank you.
[0:26:40] Motion passes seven to zero.
[0:26:41] Okay.
[0:26:42] So we have a public hearing tonight, but before we get to that, now is the time for general
[0:26:46] public input. If there's anybody in the audience that wishes to speak on items
[0:26:52] not on today's agenda or items not personnel related they can come down to
[0:26:58] the podium state your name and you have two minutes. My name is Maria Hernandez
[0:27:26] it's been a minute since I've been here and I'm a proud follower of the Chief
[0:27:30] Standing Bear from Ponca in Detroit a proud follower Mark Luther King and the
[0:27:35] Democrat John Lewis. I'm also a proud follower of the line of the tribe of Judah.
[0:27:39] I'm a proud follower of Chief Kingsbury of Twin Falls Police Department and I'm
[0:27:45] also a proud follower of you, Mayor Ruth Peac-Ruth Pierce. I'm here tonight. I was
[0:27:52] really pleased that you asked if anybody wished to pay a pledge of allegiance because
[0:28:01] that gave us a choice. But also tonight, it was beautiful to see the support of the firemen
[0:28:08] that were grafted in, but also to the support of the family. And that brings me in conclusion
[0:28:16] to what I want to project here. And I've been very affected by the teacher in Meridian with
[0:28:25] a church I have here, it's called Everyone is Welcome Here. I've acknowledged and I've
[0:28:33] gotten more signatures, but I'm getting more signatures to present to her. I was affected
[0:28:39] because it made national news. So Idaho was put on the map for something big, and I know
[0:28:47] this is controversial, but it affected me because why? He's an educator, and I've had
[0:28:53] so many educators and teachers in my life that have affected me so much and because she stood
[0:29:01] up, I'm going to stand up for what she did because I believe it was the right thing and
[0:29:09] so next week I will be presenting this shirt to her in an in-class case and should anybody
[0:29:15] want to sign this shirt, I'm going to present it to her and thank her for standing up for
[0:29:20] me because as far as I'm concerned, I'm Maria Alma Hernandez say to this situation.
[0:29:28] Sarah Aname, my beautiful brown eyes, brown hands and brown feet acknowledge you as a patriot.
[0:29:35] And yes, not all heroes wear capes.
[0:29:38] I say to you, Sarah Aname, stand up and be strong.
[0:29:42] You have my support as well as many others.
[0:29:46] Thank you for your time.
[0:29:47] Thank you.
[0:29:54] There anybody else in the audience that wishes to address City Council on anything, not on today's agenda?
[0:30:04] Okay. Advisory Board reports. Anything to report from boards? Anything from the City Manager's Office?
[0:30:17] I'm not the student.
[0:30:18] Thank you. Okay, so next is the public hearing. Does you guys need a break or we could?
[0:30:25] Okay, hang on, let me start the agenda item.
[0:30:40] So the public hearing is an action item, a request for a comprehensive plan amendment
[0:30:45] to modify the future land use map to expand the utility service boundary and change future
[0:30:52] land use categories for properties generally located in the 1100 to 2400 Locks of Sunway
[0:30:59] drive north a.k.a.a. 2700 e.c.a.m. engineering's ink on behalf of South Canyon Farms LLC and
[0:31:11] we have our PNC director Jonathan Spennlove but Grayson did you.
[0:31:17] Yeah thank you Madam Mayor. I've got a direct conflict of interest on this property as I'm
[0:31:21] in a past consultant on this property and actively consulting with the landowners that
[0:31:25] be directly impacted by this so I will be recusing myself and stepping up the
[0:31:29] diocese. Okay, thank you. So I'm going to read the rules related to the public
[0:31:34] hearing. The Council will follow these steps for each request on the public
[0:31:40] hearing portion of the agenda. City staff will present the request and analysis.
[0:31:45] The applicant will then present their request. The Council will then ask
[0:31:50] questions of the applicant or staff after questions have been answered the
[0:31:55] public hearing will then be opened during that time anybody in attendance
[0:31:59] is given the opportunity to comment or ask questions about the request being
[0:32:04] considered when giving testimony please step up to the podium state your name
[0:32:10] and address and present your comments or concerns after giving testimony please
[0:32:16] sign the public sign-in sheet that should be located in the lobby with your
[0:32:21] name and address for the record. After public comments are concluded the
[0:32:26] applicant will be invited to answer any questions and make a closing statement.
[0:32:31] Staff will then answer or clarify any questions or any comments as needed and
[0:32:37] after the closing statements the public hearing will be closed. No further
[0:32:41] testimony or comments from the applicant or audience will be allowed and then the
[0:32:46] council will have open discussion and take action. Thank you Johnathan you're up.
[0:32:52] Okay when we get this we could work this. Tonight is the request for a comprehensive
[0:33:05] plan amendment. The comprehensive plan is the document that guides all land use
[0:33:10] decisions by the City Council and the Planning and Zoning Commission. It
[0:33:14] It encompasses all of the city limits as well as the area of impact as designated by the
[0:33:19] City Council and the County Commissioners.
[0:33:22] The area we are talking about and what specifically we're talking about is the utility service
[0:33:28] boundary which is identified within the comprehensive plan.
[0:33:31] It's on the future land use map.
[0:33:33] I'm going to use some terms.
[0:33:34] I'll explain some of those later.
[0:33:36] But in general, we're talking about the Northwest area of town, particularly near the Sunway
[0:33:42] Soccer Complex, which is on the south side, and then you have the large farm acreages on
[0:33:49] the north side, which would be west of Grandview, north of Pole Line, and then Sunway as the
[0:33:56] name changes when it goes out of city limits to the north. It encompasses both sides of
[0:34:00] that road. Looking at the map, it's most of what we're looking at here, and it comes
[0:34:07] down further south. Bring up this map because you can kind of orient yourself with Walmart,
[0:34:12] line is all on there. The maps specifically are this. The areas outlined in black that's
[0:34:20] on the map on the left are the properties which showed some support for changing the boundary.
[0:34:28] The boundary is on the map on the right and is that blue dotted line or as I trace it with
[0:34:35] the mouse. It comes down, follows sort of in the middle of the farm area, down to pole
[0:34:42] meets pole line, meets pole line, goes towards the northwest, and then hits
[0:34:45] Sunway and is the road, comes down Sunway to what would be falls.
[0:34:51] Utility boundary, although that it's on this map, is more specific than the
[0:34:57] comprehensive plan map usually are. And the utility boundary is the city planning
[0:35:01] for water and sewer service. We use that boundary to have more firm areas that
[0:35:07] we expand into so we can have a more adequate sewer and water model so we
[0:35:10] know what areas to expect to grow.
[0:35:14] This future land use map, and in general the comprehensive plan was viewed and created in
[0:35:20] 2014 to 2016.
[0:35:22] We're coming up on 10 years of that information.
[0:35:26] It is natural and usual for future land use maps to last around 10 years.
[0:35:30] So we are due for an update in the next few years.
[0:35:33] So having an application to expand it is not unheard of and is quite expected from a planning
[0:35:38] standpoint.
[0:35:39] We've also highlighted the properties on this map to kind of identify where they are.
[0:35:45] Currently, some go back to the one on the left, the zoning map is the current entitlement on the property is what is currently permitted to be constructed.
[0:35:52] This green and hash mark means it's outside city limits and it is SUI suburban urban interface that is one acre or larger lots with wells and septics.
[0:36:03] And we move this boundary.
[0:36:05] Everything within the utility boundary
[0:36:08] should have a more dense fabric for development,
[0:36:13] which is more of a two to 10 units per acre.
[0:36:16] And that's what we call town neighborhood.
[0:36:18] When you have Pull Line Road,
[0:36:19] we generally have a commercial corridor along our arterials,
[0:36:22] particularly Pull Line Road, the state highway and bypass.
[0:36:26] Having commercial along it is also expected
[0:36:30] and also planned for in the current plan.
[0:36:32] So when that boundary, if it's moved,
[0:36:35] these laws or these areas would then need to have
[0:36:38] a city, future land use designation.
[0:36:41] We just have one, it's called town neighborhood,
[0:36:43] encompasses all of our residential.
[0:36:45] We also have that commercial.
[0:36:47] The applicant is seeking to have this be the designation
[0:36:52] in the boundaries, the yellowish or orange,
[0:36:55] whatever color is up there, would be the town neighborhood.
[0:36:59] The red would be that commercial designation.
[0:37:01] This is their proposal for all of the properties that are being sought.
[0:37:05] In essence, this blue line would then come up and encompass all of these properties towards
[0:37:10] what would be the Northwest, South boundary here, and then meet back up to where it's currently
[0:37:14] out here on Sunway.
[0:37:15] You give a moment to pause, just to view that map.
[0:37:21] It does not extend into any currently platted one acre lots that are outside city limits,
[0:37:28] is the Stone Ridge subdivision and for some reason this area is escaping me but
[0:37:32] it's also planted on the north side of Pull Line and other roads, Creek Mesa Drive,
[0:37:38] but I can't remember the name of the subdivision. Anyway, those are one acre or
[0:37:40] larger lots. Though this comprehensive plan does not contemplate any of those
[0:37:45] areas that would remain a SUI and outside any potential city annexation. Put
[0:37:56] side-by-side. This is their future map. This is our current one and if we married
[0:38:02] those we would propose having them be close but not exactly for a staff
[0:38:09] recommendation to have one I'll get to in a second. During the state code at 67-65-09
[0:38:17] you have to have two public hearings for comprehensive plan amendment one of them
[0:38:21] with the Planning and Zoning Commission to get a recommendation. This next one is
[0:38:24] has only have tonight.
[0:38:25] Planning and zoning commission recommended
[0:38:28] with the staff recommendation,
[0:38:29] which is to have the commercial corridor
[0:38:31] be approximately 1350 feet.
[0:38:35] I think it's supposed to be close to a quarter mile.
[0:38:38] But on the map it's 1350,
[0:38:40] and that would be split along Pauline.
[0:38:42] So either side has an equal commercial corridor.
[0:38:46] These maps are not lot specific.
[0:38:48] They're not meant to be.
[0:38:50] What we're talking about tonight is changing the plan.
[0:38:53] If any of these properties in the future wanted to become part of the city limits, they would
[0:38:57] have to then go through annexation.
[0:39:00] The annexation processes further hearings with P&Z and you in the final decision to be annexed
[0:39:05] for us with the city council and at that point is when you decide what zoning designation to
[0:39:10] have.
[0:39:11] This plan is merely asking the question for the person to be able to ask a question to
[0:39:16] be annexed.
[0:39:17] So it's like the pre-question.
[0:39:18] This is what you're deciding tonight.
[0:39:21] actually goes into effect until a resolution is passed, whichever decision you come up
[0:39:25] with, we would bring a resolution back to reflect that decision.
[0:39:29] I believe I've covered everything unless you have questions for me and the applicant will
[0:39:36] come up here and explain their side as well as they represent a group of people.
[0:39:41] Any questions for Jonathan on his information?
[0:39:53] Thank you, Mayor, members of the Council.
[0:39:54] My name is David Tebow with EHM Engineers representing South Canyon Farms, LLC and there
[0:39:59] request this evening for a comprehensive plan amendment and an amendment to the Water and
[0:40:06] Sewer Service Boundary Areas. So our firm has engaged in land development and in consultation
[0:40:13] with the property owners in the area, we have been able to successfully identify a route
[0:40:17] to provide sanitary sewer service through a neighboring piece of property. As a result
[0:40:21] of that success, we were able to then identify, okay, what is that going to provide for service
[0:40:27] area in the future, as we have many landowners and stakeholders in the vicinity talking to
[0:40:33] us regularly about potential development of their property.
[0:40:37] So in your packet you'll see there's letters from the Detweiler family, the Sibala family,
[0:40:42] and many others.
[0:40:43] I'll let you peruse those at your leisure, but we ultimately came up with a map that made
[0:40:49] sense to how far could this sewer and water, water is less of a concern because it's not
[0:40:54] tied to a gravity elevation.
[0:40:56] It's a pressurized utility, but how far can it service and then what's the appropriate
[0:41:02] use there?
[0:41:03] As Jonathan said, along Pole Line and the state highway, we expect a commercial corridor
[0:41:07] to continue to be established, very similar from 2700 or Sunway back to, let's say, Washington
[0:41:13] Street or even North College, or not North Village, Fillmore, something with commercial
[0:41:19] frontage along the front of it, and that is consistent with your current future land
[0:41:24] use map, only that it just stopped at your boundary, so we would extend it
[0:41:28] westerly as we extend the boundary westerly. And then from there, ranging north,
[0:41:34] primarily the Deaf Weiler and the Requa family properties, we believe the
[0:41:39] residential development is going to be occurring in the northwest side of
[0:41:42] Twin Falls. As water and sewer service becomes closer to each of these properties,
[0:41:46] we expect them to engage in some type of residential development and similar
[0:41:51] to the south. Once you get outside of that, 1,320 or 660 on each side of
[0:41:57] whole line. We expect that residential neighborhoods would be very compatible
[0:42:02] with the one acre, single family planted residential lots that above the rock
[0:42:06] creek. In order for us to proceed with development and proper planning, this is
[0:42:12] the first step to modify our future land use map. As Jonathan said, the areas
[0:42:17] designated town neighborhood with an anticipated density between two units per acre. All of
[0:42:24] these zones which we proposed are consistent with that and we do think and believe that
[0:42:30] the water and sewer service has the capacity and capability to serve the area. That is
[0:42:34] evidenced by the letters that should be in your packet from GUB for water modeling.
[0:42:41] Should we be successful in our petition, I would anticipate that annexation requests will
[0:42:45] follow and then probably subdivision plating will follow that step. So with
[0:42:50] that I would stand for any questions that you might have. Thank you Dave. Any
[0:42:55] questions for Dave at this time? Thank you. Everybody good? Thank you. Okay so with
[0:43:12] that being said I will open up the public hearing. When you want to come
[0:43:18] down please state your name and address and present your comments for
[0:43:25] questions. We will be timing. You have three minutes to speak. And once your three minutes
[0:43:32] is up, please hand your presentation. So I'm opening up the public hearing. Does anybody
[0:43:39] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[0:44:00] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[0:44:06] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[0:44:17] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[0:44:24] As proud as our family is of the farm that my great-grandparents homesteaded at the turn of the last century,
[0:44:32] We want to see our land develop to its highest and best use as a functioning component of a future neighborhood.
[0:44:38] We believe that to achieve the highest and best use of our property and be in synergy with the future plans of neighboring carceral owners.
[0:44:45] A commercial designation is awarded for our property.
[0:44:48] Polline Road to the East is developing into a commercial corridor and this high volume and
[0:44:53] high speed state highway best lends itself to use as a development corridor that's typical
[0:45:00] of this type of use and best practice.
[0:45:05] Sometimes existing neighbors have concerns about traffic and safety, but these concerns
[0:45:08] can be addressed with careful planning and future applications for annexations and for
[0:45:13] or the particular individual developments
[0:45:16] that would then have opportunities
[0:45:18] to incorporate their best practices into the development.
[0:45:22] What is important to consider tonight
[0:45:24] is that a commercial designation is warranted
[0:45:26] in terms of future land use along this highway.
[0:45:29] And I register this not just as the current owner
[0:45:31] of the agricultural land, but as my professional opinion
[0:45:34] is someone who has been in this business
[0:45:36] for two and a half decades and has seen
[0:45:38] many successful projects blossom into thriving neighborhoods.
[0:45:42] We have Shuler Ranch, very much appreciate your consideration
[0:45:46] in passing the amendment in the form.
[0:45:53] Thank you, Mark.
[0:45:55] Is there anybody else in the audience that wishes
[0:45:58] to comment on during the public hearing?
[0:46:09] Everybody a minute to think, okay?
[0:46:21] Anything you want to say?
[0:46:24] Dave?
[0:46:25] Thank you, Madam Mayor and members of the council.
[0:46:25] The only thing I'd point out is in your packet,
[0:46:28] You have a alpha numeric identified map.
[0:46:33] Mr. Schubert, or Ms. McAlster's properties identified as H.
[0:46:38] It's at the Southwest Quadrant of the intersection
[0:46:40] of 2700 in Poline Road.
[0:46:42] And as I said, I think you two have a letter from him
[0:46:46] where we talk to him in advance.
[0:46:47] I failed to mention too that we work with your staff,
[0:46:49] as we come up with these applications on a one-by-one basis.
[0:46:53] We really appreciate the direction of staff.
[0:46:55] They said, hey, rather than come in one at a time
[0:46:58] and then six months later or four months later come in with another one.
[0:47:00] Let's look at a greater area and try to get everybody around the table that might have
[0:47:04] an interest.
[0:47:05] So we made that effort and we're pleased with that effort and the package that you have
[0:47:08] before you.
[0:47:09] So thank you for your consideration.
[0:47:10] Thank you.
[0:47:12] Anything you want to add, Jonathan?
[0:47:15] I have nothing less.
[0:47:16] You have any questions for us on anything.
[0:47:20] Any other questions or on this before we start discussion?
[0:47:24] Okay.
[0:47:26] I will close the public hearing.
[0:47:28] more comments from the audience or the applicant. So Council wishes any discussion? Questions?
[0:47:36] Jason Brown. I'll just jump in and these are decisions as Jonathan had mentioned. Good
[0:47:51] planning. We got to come back and make sure that we're looking at what changes have occurred
[0:47:57] last 10 years, dynamics in the community, changes, things like that, but also demands for public
[0:48:05] service and looking at how to put the best use for that property, I'd be in support of
[0:48:14] making those boundary changes.
[0:48:16] Thank you. Any other comments? Hey, Chris Reed.
[0:48:23] I'll just comment as well. I mean, it's a bittersweet to see farmland change.
[0:48:31] I know that there's a lot of people who have grown up in Twin Falls.
[0:48:35] I know several of these families and change is sometimes very challenging.
[0:48:41] But also my end in structure growth is very important for a community understanding that we are growing.
[0:48:48] So I do appreciate those families coming together.
[0:48:51] It does make everybody's life a little bit easier when they come together and do something like this.
[0:48:55] So we do appreciate it, understanding that this is just a boundary change.
[0:48:58] There's still a lot of discussion as to what goes in these areas.
[0:49:03] And so we would ask the community to continue to participate in this process
[0:49:07] because this is not done, but I am in favor of this as well.
[0:49:13] Thank you.
[0:49:15] So any other comments or I would entertain a motion?
[0:49:19] I'll make a motion.
[0:49:19] Thank you.
[0:49:20] Thank you, Jason.
[0:49:22] Move to approve the comprehensive plan amendment to modify the future land use map
[0:49:27] to extend the utility service boundary and change future land use categories for the properties
[0:49:31] generally located in the 1100 to 2400 blocks of Sunway Drive, also known as 2700 East, and
[0:49:42] along with the recommendations given by the planning and zoning.
[0:49:45] Thank you, Sherry Vomer.
[0:49:47] I'll second.
[0:49:48] Thank you, motion by Jason Brown, second by Sherry Vomer to approve the comprehensive
[0:49:54] plan amendment to modify the future land use map to expand the utility service
[0:49:59] boundary and change future land use categories for properties generally
[0:50:04] located in the 1100 to 2400 blocks of Sunway Drive North also known as 2700
[0:50:11] East incorporating the recommendations from planning and zoning any further
[0:50:17] discussion or comments Amy Rokavo please
[0:50:21] Jason Brown? Yes.
[0:50:27] Spencer Kettler? Yes.
[0:50:29] Jerry Volmer? Yes. Ruth Pierce? Yes.
[0:50:31] Chris Reed? Yes.
[0:50:32] And Craig Hawkins? Yes.
[0:50:34] Thank you. Motion passes.
[0:50:37] Six with one abstention.
[0:50:40] Six. Yes, one abstention.
[0:50:42] Okay. So are we going to have the rest of our executive session?
[0:50:48] Okay. So we didn't quite finish our executive session.
[0:50:53] So, request to adjourn to Executive Session Pursuant to IDO code 74-2061C to acquire interest
[0:51:05] in real property not owned by a public agency or F to communicate with legal counsel for
[0:51:11] the public agency to discuss the legal ramifications of and legal opinions for pending litigation
[0:51:18] are controversies not yet being litigated but imminently likely to be litigated. The mere
[0:51:23] presence of legal counsel in executive session does not satisfy this requirement. Chris Reed.
[0:51:29] So moved. Thank you. Do you have a second? Second. Motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Jason
[0:51:35] Brown to move into executive session pursuant to Code Section 74206. One C and F. Amy Roll
[0:51:45] Provost Covo please.
[0:51:48] Spencer Cutler.
[0:51:49] Yes.
[0:51:50] Grace and Stone.
[0:51:51] Yes.
[0:51:52] Gary Vomer.
[0:51:53] Yes.
[0:51:54] Bruce Pierce.
[0:51:55] Yes.
[0:51:56] Chris Reed.
[0:51:57] Yes.
[0:51:58] Hawkins.
[0:51:59] Yes.
[0:52:00] And Jason Brown.
[0:52:01] Yes.
[0:52:02] Thank you.
[0:52:03] Motion passes 7-0.
[0:52:04] Thank you everybody.
[0:52:05] We will not be back.
[0:52:06] So meeting is adjourned.
[0:52:07] Thank you.
