Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2025-03-17, recording 1 (started 16:29)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2025-03-17/

[0:00:03] Thank you, ladies and gentlemen, I'd like to call the meeting back to order.
[0:01:01] We were had an executive session, so we're running a little bit late.
[0:01:06] First item on the agenda, I want to confirm we have a quorum, we have six members present
[0:01:11] in chambers and Councilman Brown is excused tonight.
[0:01:16] First item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance.
[0:01:18] If you wish to join me, please rise.
[0:01:29] Or which is stands, nation, every possible way
[0:01:33] to deliver to you, Justice for all.
[0:01:40] OK, we have a proclamation tonight.
[0:01:45] It is the recognition of Transit Driver Appreciation Day
[0:01:48] and its March 18, 2025, which is tomorrow.
[0:01:52] Whereas the City of Twin Falls operates the right TFT
[0:01:55] public transit system in accordance with its goals
[0:01:59] for an accessible community.
[0:02:00] And whereas March 18 has historically been observed
[0:02:04] National Transit Employee Appreciation Day by the American Public Transportation Association
[0:02:10] and Transit Agencies nationwide to recognize the efforts of transit drivers and staff for
[0:02:16] their positive impact on their communities.
[0:02:21] Ride TFT drivers have demonstrated customer service, patience, empathy and understanding
[0:02:28] all to create a welcoming and inclusive environment for community members and visitors while meeting
[0:02:33] and high demand for transit services.
[0:02:36] Therefore, I, Ruth Pierce, Mayor of the City of Twin Falls
[0:02:40] do hereby proclaim March 18, 2025
[0:02:44] to be Transit Employee Appreciation Day.
[0:02:48] And Maxine, do you want to come down?
[0:02:51] I never remember to do that.
[0:03:54] Madam Mayor, Members of Council, thank you for having us this evening.
[0:03:57] I just wanted to really quickly say thank you for this proclamation.
[0:04:01] Our drivers for ride TFT work really hard to represent the city and offer the service that they do.
[0:04:07] And so I just I wanted to make sure that we gave them a day to recognize that.
[0:04:11] Thank them for that and let the community know March 18th.
[0:04:15] It's a national day kind of get on the bandwagon and just, you know, a great excuse to acknowledge them and thank them for the work that they do every day.
[0:04:22] So again, just thank you very much. Really appreciate this.
[0:04:25] Thank you.
[0:04:26] Okay.
[0:04:31] All right.
[0:04:33] Next on the agenda is the consent calendar.
[0:04:37] Council wishes.
[0:04:38] Madam Mayor, I will make a motion to accept the consent calendar as written.
[0:04:44] Thank you.
[0:04:45] Do I have a second?
[0:04:46] Thank you.
[0:04:47] Motion by Grayson Stone.
[0:04:48] Second by Craig Hawkins to approve the consent calendar as written.
[0:04:53] Rachel Rolkow, please.
[0:04:57] Yes.
[0:04:58] Great.
[0:04:59] Cawkins.
[0:05:00] Yes.
[0:05:01] Yes.
[0:05:02] Praise and Stone.
[0:05:03] Yes.
[0:05:04] And Ruth Pierce.
[0:05:05] Yes.
[0:05:06] Thank you.
[0:05:07] Motion passes six to zero.
[0:05:08] Okay.
[0:05:09] Under items of consideration, our first item is a presentation.
[0:05:12] A presentation of the City of Twin Falls 2024 Audited Financial Statement.
[0:05:17] The presentation will be made by Scott Hunsaker of Mulkey Hunsaker and Company and we have
[0:05:23] our Assistance Finance Director Parker Sheer.
[0:05:26] Welcome, Parker.
[0:05:27] Good afternoon, evening.
[0:05:30] Good evening, Council. My name is Parker Sheer. I am the new assistant finance director following
[0:05:37] Brent's retirement this past year. Before Scott comes up, I just want to discuss the audit and
[0:05:43] more to discuss the audit in more detail. I wanted to note that the city has received an
[0:05:48] unqualified opinion. While that may sound bad, it is actually means that the city passed their
[0:05:53] audit. Overall, it's been a good year working with Scott and his team and with that, I'll turn it over to Scott.
[0:05:59] Thank you, Parker. Welcome, Scott. Well, thank you. Well, it's good to be with you this
[0:06:39] evening and appreciate the opportunity to come and share findings of the audit.
[0:06:45] We've met with Travis and the Finance Department, Brianna and Parker last week
[0:06:52] and talked about the audit and so it's good to be here and present what we found
[0:06:59] and kind of discuss what the audit is. You've all been delivered the audit and it's
[0:07:06] 140 pages or so long. We won't get into much detail at all. We want to talk more
[0:07:12] about the audit, not necessarily a lot of the numbers. You have finance reports
[0:07:16] regularly and so we won't get into that detail. We'd really want to talk more
[0:07:21] about what our role is as independent auditors for the city. And so this
[0:07:27] presentation is is very similar to the last year just knowing that this is a
[0:07:35] very technical document and so we want to kind of give you an overview of what
[0:07:39] you're looking at and maybe some some guidance as to what to look for as you
[0:07:44] review the audit and your role in the audit so first who are we we've worked
[0:07:55] with the city for a number of years.
[0:07:58] Mulcan Taker and Company is a firm here in Twin Falls.
[0:08:01] We've been here for many years
[0:08:04] and appreciate the opportunity to work with the city
[0:08:07] and perform this audit.
[0:08:10] Using a local firm has been great
[0:08:11] and we appreciate that chance that we've had.
[0:08:15] To do this type of work and audits,
[0:08:17] especially governmental audits,
[0:08:19] our firm is required to have some standards
[0:08:23] And we have to be peer reviewed.
[0:08:26] And that means that we have another firm come,
[0:08:28] another accounting firm come every three years
[0:08:31] and they review our audits, the opinions that we've issued
[0:08:35] financial statements that we've issued
[0:08:37] and make sure that we're in compliance.
[0:08:39] And in fact, we just had that happen about two months ago.
[0:08:44] And that's a stressful time, but we passed
[0:08:47] and we're glad that we can continue to do this,
[0:08:49] but that's important and significant part
[0:08:51] of what we do.
[0:08:53] We perform audits of a lot of many local governments and counties and nonprofits as well as commercial
[0:09:01] entities as well.
[0:09:04] Significant accounting or education is required for this, especially governmental audit.
[0:09:09] You'd think, well, it's accounting, it's debits and credits, what's the difference, what's
[0:09:13] the big deal?
[0:09:14] But governmental accounting is quite different and learning that and presenting that's quite
[0:09:20] a different thing.
[0:09:21] So there's some requirements on those that are involved in this type of business.
[0:09:28] So what is a governmental audit?
[0:09:31] First, there's the most people focus on the financial statements.
[0:09:36] We issue an opinion on those financial statements.
[0:09:38] Make sure that they're materially correct, that there's no material misstatements.
[0:09:43] That's the main part of your package that you have.
[0:09:46] But also part of the audit that we do is we look at your internal controls and we issue
[0:09:51] an opinion on those internal controls.
[0:09:54] And we also, since you are expenditures of federal funds, exceed a threshold, we perform
[0:10:02] a single audit and we'll talk a little bit about that as well.
[0:10:05] So there's different kind of things that we do during the audit.
[0:10:10] It's not just all financial, it's a lot of other things that we look at as well.
[0:10:15] This is the most important thing, and Parker alluded to it and talked about the Unqualified
[0:10:20] Opinion.
[0:10:21] This is a page from the audit report, and that's pretty small, but it summarized the most important
[0:10:28] sentence.
[0:10:29] It just says, in our opinion, the financial statements refer to present fairly in all
[0:10:34] material respects, respect of financial position of the city to and falls in accordance with
[0:10:40] the Counting Principles General accepted in the United States of America.
[0:10:43] That's the unqualified opinion, and that's what you want, because like Parker said, it sounds
[0:10:48] like a bad thing, but it's a very good thing.
[0:10:50] So nothing rose to the level where we had to qualify our opinion.
[0:10:55] So if we issue that opinion, how did we get there?
[0:11:00] With all the things that the city does, how do we approach this?
[0:11:04] We spend quite a bit of time planning and looking and figuring out where the transactions are,
[0:11:09] are the risks associated with these transactions, and then we assess risks
[0:11:15] according to complexity or likelihood of fraud and those types of things and
[0:11:20] those types of balances would get more attention than others. We also refer back
[0:11:27] to independent sources, bank confirmations or tying out loans to bank
[0:11:32] balances. Those are an integral part of an audit as well. Internal controls we
[0:11:40] talked about that being part of our audit and we do issue an opinion on that but
[0:11:45] internal controls is kind of a word that account issues a lot that maybe most
[0:11:51] people don't understand and this is a good definition internal controls are
[0:11:55] mechanisms rules and procedures implemented by an entity to ensure the
[0:11:59] integrity of the financial and accounting information promote accountability
[0:12:03] and prevent fraud so as I said as part of our audit we test the internal controls
[0:12:08] that the city has established, we run through checks and deposits and make sure
[0:12:15] that the controls are being utilized. Those controls can change from time to time
[0:12:20] if the city, finance department or other departments think they need to adjust and
[0:12:26] change, that's fine. We will just test those and make sure that they comply and
[0:12:30] will work and will prevent misstatements is the whole purpose. So every governmental
[0:12:37] audit issues and opinion on the internal controls and that's an unqualified opinion
[0:12:42] as well in the back of the of your document there.
[0:12:47] And then we talked a little bit about this single audit, which is a strange term, but
[0:12:51] it's it has to do with federal funds.
[0:12:55] And the threshold is is if you spend $750,000 of federal money is going up to a million here
[0:13:02] very soon then you're subject to this single audit requirement and what that
[0:13:07] means is we tested those expenditures according to the granting agencies
[0:13:12] requirements and so they they have what's called a compliance supplement that we
[0:13:17] look at and make sure that those rules are being followed and then we submit that
[0:13:22] to the OMB as part of this reporting package and so it's a it's another layer
[0:13:29] of auditing that you're subject to because you use federal funds. Like I said, this is
[0:13:37] a significant document that you have and there's all these different reports of
[0:13:43] the audit report. The one thing I would draw your attention to is the
[0:13:46] management's discussion and analysis, the second section. This is written by the
[0:13:53] finance department, the rule of state that we can't, as auditors we can't write
[0:13:58] that. It's written by the finance department and it's intentionally written in plain English
[0:14:05] so that people can read it and understand kind of a summary as to the city's financial
[0:14:10] health, what's happened in the past, where you're going, those types of things. And so
[0:14:16] if I were sitting in your chair, that would be the first thing I would read and study
[0:14:21] would be that the MD&A is important and kind of gives you a summary of this whole thing.
[0:14:28] All these other documents are fairly complex, but that kind of boils it down to understandable
[0:14:36] good way to understand or kind of swallow what this whole thing is.
[0:14:41] So this lists everything that's on your, it's in the table of contents for you.
[0:14:47] This is significant and the last several years I've drawn the attention to the council to this.
[0:14:53] This is this award given by the GFOA, which is kind of the governing board of the government
[0:15:01] accounting.
[0:15:02] And they give this award not to everyone that has financial statements, but this is saying
[0:15:10] that you've qualified, it's been reviewed, and they give this award to very few.
[0:15:18] This is a voluntary thing that the city has chosen to be a part of, submit your financial
[0:15:25] statements.
[0:15:26] And it says the purpose of this award is to encourage and assist the state and local
[0:15:30] governments to go beyond the minimum requirements of generally accounted, generally accepted accounting
[0:15:36] principles to prepare annual comprehensive financial reports that evidence of transparency
[0:15:42] and full disclosure and then to recognize the individual governments that succeed in
[0:15:46] achieving that goal. Those get submitted to GFOA, GFOA contracts with
[0:15:52] accounting firms to review those very, very closely. And like I said in these
[0:15:58] bullet points, only six cities. I looked again today to see how many six cities in
[0:16:03] Idaho have received this award and the City of Twin Falls is one of those and
[0:16:08] has been for the last I think six years. And that says a lot about your accounting
[0:16:12] department and just promoting transparency.
[0:16:16] That's, you can't really overstate that.
[0:16:19] That's significant.
[0:16:22] Just a few financial highlights I told you I wouldn't get
[0:16:25] into it too much, but the city is in very strong financial
[0:16:29] position.
[0:16:31] This is kind of a balance sheet there on the left, showing
[0:16:35] your assets have increased liabilities have increased some,
[0:16:39] but not as much as your assets.
[0:16:42] And so your net assets, if you were in a business, that would be your equity.
[0:16:46] I've increased about 10 million.
[0:16:49] On the right, you'll see your revenues and expenditures.
[0:16:54] And revenues and expenditures for a city are kind of interesting.
[0:16:56] Your government, you know, you're not here for profit or whatever.
[0:17:00] And so this can fluctuate a lot depending on projects or grants or all those types
[0:17:05] of things.
[0:17:06] So, you know, it just happened this year that with control, and most of the things your
[0:17:13] revenues are listed there.
[0:17:16] And the excess, that would be revenues over expenditures on 9.7 million this last year.
[0:17:27] The accounting literature talks about your role.
[0:17:30] They say those charged with governance is what they consider you, and that we're required
[0:17:37] to report directly to you anything that is significant enough that you need to take action.
[0:17:43] And fortunately, there's nothing we have to report that would be to that level.
[0:17:48] We didn't have any disagreements about accounting or anything like that.
[0:17:52] Everything went well.
[0:17:54] There's no unusual or strange things that we discovered.
[0:17:57] So that's very good.
[0:18:01] Just overall just wanted to kind of in closing to say the auto went really very well.
[0:18:07] You have qualified accounting staff that are educated and are doing a very good job.
[0:18:14] We were a little bit nervous going into this without brand being here as we've been here
[0:18:19] for so long and had a lot of institutional knowledge.
[0:18:22] But I have to say Parker has stepped up and educated himself.
[0:18:27] himself, we talked a little bit about accounting for governments being different, but he's stepped
[0:18:33] up and taken the initiative to learn and grow and has become a real key asset to the city,
[0:18:40] so we're glad for that.
[0:18:42] Financially, like I said, city has significant reserves doing very well.
[0:18:47] This emphasizes to you your role in the audit.
[0:18:50] Your role is oversight and representing the citizens of the community, so inquiring and reviewing
[0:18:57] those financial reports that you see plays an integral part of those internal controls
[0:19:03] that we've talked about.
[0:19:04] And so your role mitigates some risk as you review those financial statements.
[0:19:10] So again, appreciate the opportunity to present what we found and take any questions you may
[0:19:16] have or not or whatever you'd like.
[0:19:19] Thank you.
[0:19:20] Any questions?
[0:19:21] Chris Scott, there always always.
[0:19:26] Thank you.
[0:19:27] Thank you.
[0:19:28] Thank you and thank you parker and team. Okay next item on the agenda is an action item
[0:19:41] a request for the mayor to sign a contract with coal architects for the first phase of the design
[0:19:47] and engineering of a police evidence storage facility and we don't have Mandy but we have
[0:19:53] Mitch our W.D. City manager welcome Mitch. Thank you I'll be playing the part of Mandy tonight.
[0:20:01] she couldn't be here but I'm expecting to lean so take this over as you'll recall a few meetings
[0:20:06] ago we ranked we presented a ranked order for architects for the police evidence storage building
[0:20:12] and coal architects was the top ranked firm they've gone and negotiated a contract with coal and
[0:20:18] what you have before you is the is the phase one architectural contract if you'll recall coal
[0:20:25] is also our architect for the city pool and we did a multi-phase contract with them on that
[0:20:30] project as well as something that they kind of like to do and it works well for us too.
[0:20:35] We have a budget in this year's or we have a money in this year's budget for $175,000
[0:20:39] for design.
[0:20:40] This first phase is only $36,235 of that and so a successful negotiation.
[0:20:47] We have the contract in front of you and we recommend that you approve it and the mayor
[0:20:53] to sign it.
[0:20:55] Right answer questions if you have any.
[0:20:57] Thank you, Madam Mayor. I think it's pretty straightforward.
[0:21:01] If there's no discussion, I'll be prepared to make a motion.
[0:21:04] Anybody have any questions? Go ahead, Grayson.
[0:21:07] Thank you, Madam Mayor. I'll make a motion for the mayor to sign a contract with coal architects for the first phase of the design and engineering of a police evidence storage facility.
[0:21:16] Thank you to have a second. Thank you. Motion by Grayson Stone, seconded by Craig Hawkins to
[0:21:22] approve the request for the mayor to sign a contract with Cole Architects for
[0:21:28] the first phase of the design and engineering of the police evidence
[0:21:31] storage facility. Any further discussion? Rachel Rokow please.
[0:21:37] Spencer Cutler. Yes. Jerry Volmer. Yes. Grayson Stone. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes.
[0:21:42] Chris Reed. Yes. And Craig Hawkins. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 6-0. Thank you
[0:21:48] Okay, next item on the agenda is an action item authorized city staff to enter negotiations
[0:21:59] with Hazen and Sawyer regarding the scope of work for the Canning Rim Drop Line project
[0:22:05] and we have our environmental manager Nathan Erickson.
[0:22:08] Welcome Nathan.
[0:22:09] Thank you Mayor.
[0:22:10] Council appreciate your time tonight.
[0:22:12] You might remember a couple months ago I was here and we got authorization to purchase a
[0:22:18] a piece of property just south of the treatment plant that was the slope below the canyon
[0:22:23] rim. And this has to do with that area. The canyon or the canyon and drop line project
[0:22:32] is has to do with the grand view trunk line that comes off right at that slope. And that
[0:22:41] carries about half of the city's sewer flow, about four to five million gallons per day.
[0:22:46] we have encountered is that that line is getting to the point where it needs some maintenance.
[0:22:53] Unfortunately, due to the complexity of that area, there's no way to turn it off or to bypass
[0:22:58] pump very easily. And so the recommendation has been that we put in a redundant sewer line.
[0:23:04] And so the city has put out a request for qualifications to find an engineering firm that
[0:23:13] qualified to be able to help us get through putting in a redundant line. We
[0:23:19] received back seven statements of qualifications from different firms and
[0:23:24] I will say that many of them were very well qualified. It was very close and we
[0:23:30] after going through the scoring process, Hazen and Sawyer, which is a national
[0:23:36] engineering firm, but they have a office here locally and I guess close to one is
[0:23:40] and Boise scored the highest.
[0:23:43] And so at this point we're asking for permission to be able
[0:23:45] to go in the negotiations with them on a scope of work.
[0:23:49] Thank you.
[0:23:51] Any questions for Nathan?
[0:23:53] Okay.
[0:23:56] I'd entertain a motion then.
[0:23:57] Sherry Volmer.
[0:23:58] I will move to authorize city staff to enter into negotiations
[0:24:04] with Hazen and Sawyer regarding the scope of work
[0:24:07] for the Canyon Rim Drop Line project.
[0:24:10] Thank you.
[0:24:11] Do I have a second?
[0:24:13] Sorry the name is blocked because we have this new annotation thing going on. Thank you
[0:24:19] Motion by Sherry Vomer seconded by Craig Hawkins to authorized city staff to enter in negotiations
[0:24:26] With Hazen and Sawyer regarding the scope of work for the Canyon Rim drop line project
[0:24:33] any further discussion
[0:24:36] Rachel Rokovo, please
[0:24:43] Yes.
[0:24:44] Yes.
[0:24:45] Yes.
[0:24:46] Thank you.
[0:24:47] Motion passes six to zero.
[0:24:49] Thank you.
[0:24:50] Nathan, next on the agenda is an action item.
[0:24:53] A request to utilize up to a million, 600,000 of water and wastewater reserves for the public
[0:25:01] work site improvement project and authorize the public works director to sign the CMCCG
[0:25:07] contract with suburban construction management.
[0:25:11] We have Aaron Steele, our Assistant Public Works Director.
[0:25:14] Welcome Aaron.
[0:25:15] Thank you very much.
[0:25:16] Good evening, Mayor and Council.
[0:25:17] I'm here tonight.
[0:25:18] Hopefully wrap up our Public Works Site Improvement Project.
[0:25:23] As you recall, I've been here a couple of times to talk about what that project entails.
[0:25:27] So I'll give a real brief background if you have questions I'm happy to answer.
[0:25:31] But the long and short of the story is, Public Works is required to install curb gutters,
[0:25:37] sidewalk along Washington Street, along the frontage of our property, as
[0:25:42] required by planning and zoning code. In 2023 staff went through a long-term
[0:25:49] planning process and budgeted $1.2 million for this project. The original
[0:25:53] project was bid back in that same time frame and the bid came back at
[0:25:59] nearly $2.2 million. So it was too much and so staff
[0:26:03] committed to come back with a way to offset some of those costs. And so what we
[0:26:07] we did is we chose to go through the construction management general contracting project delivery
[0:26:13] method which is something that we've seen common in the last six, eight months that you've seen
[0:26:18] quite a few contracts come before you. And so we went to a general request for qualifications
[0:26:25] as per state code and came up with a couple of individuals that qualified to do the project.
[0:26:32] After scoring as staff, we came up with Suburban Construction Management as the group that
[0:26:37] we wanted to work with for the CMGC process.
[0:26:40] We came to council at that point, recommended going in and working through the negotiation
[0:26:45] to come up with a guaranteed maximum price.
[0:26:48] So I'm here tonight to share that price with you.
[0:26:51] So Suburban went through, they bid all their individual packages and came up with a guaranteed
[0:26:58] maximum price of $1,500,800,800,800,57 for the total.
[0:27:06] So we're here tonight to ask for an even $1,600,000 to deal with any contingencies or change orders
[0:27:12] that would be unexpected.
[0:27:14] The one that comes to the top of mind is there's a foam pole that we're going to have to move.
[0:27:19] And in my experience, what I've realized is it's never about the one pole that we have
[0:27:24] to move.
[0:27:25] It's about the other three that come along with it.
[0:27:27] So hence the reason for the contingency along with that.
[0:27:29] I just want to make sure I've got everything covered here.
[0:27:34] In that 1.5 million is suburban construction's general contracting fee.
[0:27:41] It's a 7% fee, which falls right in line with what we've seen in the past over the last
[0:27:47] couple of weeks and what you've heard.
[0:27:49] So I'm here to request to authorize the Public Works Director to sign the contract and allow
[0:27:55] staff to proceed with the project, and then to utilize $1.6 million, the $1.2
[0:28:02] of which was already previously budget rolled into reserves, there's $400,000
[0:28:06] that we're asking for that we split between water and wastewater reserves at
[0:28:10] that point, so $200,000 each to fund the entirety of the project. I will stand for
[0:28:15] any questions if you have any. Thank you Aaron. Chris Reed, Aaron, would you be able
[0:28:21] to bring up a map and show us the location of where this is at and we came
[0:28:31] prepared tonight so the Public Works site is this building here down through
[0:28:38] there that's it so we have to when we're doing the improvements we don't just get
[0:28:43] to do that we have to do all of this front of the Long Washington Street
[0:28:46] all through here so this will be curved better sidewalk all the way down to
[0:28:49] here along the frontage as well parking in here for staff Republic Works as well
[0:28:56] as visitor parking up front, the buildings will remain the same right now.
[0:29:00] This is kind of a dirt gravel stuff for lack of a better term, right?
[0:29:06] And so we're going to come in and put asphalt, sea man to ride all through here.
[0:29:13] Bring the site up to code, which would normally be standard for any construction
[0:29:17] place across the city of San Falls.
[0:29:21] Good answer your question.
[0:29:22] It did.
[0:29:22] Thank you.
[0:29:23] Thank you.
[0:29:23] Grayson Stone.
[0:29:24] Oh, thank you, Madam Mayor and Director Steele.
[0:29:27] So given what's going on in the world right now, do you think 6% is enough on the contingency side?
[0:29:34] I do. That's where the guaranteed maximum price comes in, right?
[0:29:38] So really I'm just using that. That 6% is really a buffer to make sure we're good.
[0:29:44] I've recently done a project on Filer Avenue in Hankins where we had to move four holes and it was only 45,000.
[0:29:52] think we're okay. Yeah that GMP is a pretty good little one to the back of the chair. Okay thank you.
[0:29:59] Okay any other questions for Erin? If not I'd entertain a motion. I move that we
[0:30:13] approvalize up to 1.6 million of water and wastewater reserves for the public works site
[0:30:20] improvement project and authorize the public works director to sign the CM CGC contract
[0:30:28] With suburban construction management. Thank you. Do I have a second?
[0:30:32] Thank you motion by Sherry Vohmer second by Craig Hawkins to approve the request to utilize up to
[0:30:40] $1.6 million of water and wastewater reserves for the public works side improvement
[0:30:46] Project and authorized the public works director to sign the CMGC contract with suburban construction management
[0:30:54] any further discussion
[0:30:57] Rachel Rocha. Oh, please
[0:30:59] Yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes
[0:31:30] have our deputy city manager Mitch Humboldt. Welcome back. Thanks. This is a weird one that
[0:31:37] we haven't done a lot of in like 20 years and so we thought we'd bring it to the council,
[0:31:42] we'll have a conversation about it, see all know what's happening. Back in like 2000, the city entered
[0:31:48] in one of these seven different lease property leases with tell cell tower providers and various
[0:31:56] city owned properties around the city and at the time we did that we were looking to
[0:32:02] improve our own radio communications and things like that and cell tower companies were wanting
[0:32:07] to improve the cell services and city and it come together really nicely so we did a bunch of these
[0:32:12] leases where we're both the cell tower provider and the city were benefiting from the construction
[0:32:19] of the towers. All of those leases are coming up and expiring in the next and all their extensions
[0:32:25] are all expiring in the next year or two. And so we're getting to the point where we need to start
[0:32:29] renegotiating these leases. And since then, we kind of changed our delivery method of the city
[0:32:37] services and we don't really have much of a benefit from these towers anymore. These are truly just
[0:32:43] market rate leases and we're not really familiar with the idea of market releases for cell towers.
[0:32:50] There's a company out there, Steepsteal, that does this kind of thing for a living and Kathy
[0:32:54] and I have been talking with these guys at steep steel and we really feel like they can
[0:32:58] do a good job of helping us renegotiate these leases to a market rate lease and we feel
[0:33:07] like that would be a much better benefit for the city.
[0:33:10] They do a great job.
[0:33:11] We actually called, I say we, I didn't do it, Kathy did it, reached out to four or five
[0:33:17] different other communities that have used them before and we got glowing reports and
[0:33:22] And so we're going to recommend that we enter into this contract with Steve Stil to do this
[0:33:29] negotiation for us.
[0:33:31] And the contract is before you, it's got Travis's name for a second here, so if you are okay
[0:33:35] with the idea, approve the contract, we'll have Travis execute the contract and I'm going
[0:33:40] to answer any questions if you have any, Kathy's also here if they're hard questions.
[0:33:47] So the cost of this.
[0:33:49] Oh, I should have talked about that.
[0:33:52] Yeah.
[0:33:53] Actually, this is a good point.
[0:33:54] This is actually, I think, a really innovative kind of an
[0:33:57] approach to this deal.
[0:33:58] So we have these seven current leases, and the theory is
[0:34:02] they're going to negotiate an increase in our lease rate,
[0:34:05] because we have really low lease rates right now.
[0:34:08] So we will pay Steve Steel for their work based on the
[0:34:12] increase in the rate that they get for us.
[0:34:14] And so for an example, it's a graduated scale.
[0:34:17] There's four different steps in the scale.
[0:34:18] If they increase the fee for us up to 10%, we pay them one
[0:34:21] months worth of the new rate. And so we don't pay them anything unless they get
[0:34:26] us more money. And then we're not putting any money in the budget for this but we
[0:34:30] also haven't budgeted the increased revenue. And so the idea being if they get
[0:34:34] us more money we'll pay them for the more money they get us out of the money that
[0:34:37] they get for us. And so it's kind of a cool structure. We're kind of looking
[0:34:41] forward to it and we feel like we can do pretty well. Excellent. Any questions for
[0:34:47] on this topic. Chris Reed. I'll make a motion if we're ready. I move that we approve the
[0:34:57] request for a professional service agreement with Steve Steel LLC to provide the city with
[0:35:02] cellular tower lease negotiation services and authorize the city manager to sign the agreement.
[0:35:09] Thank you. Do I have a second? I'll second. Thank you. Motion by Chris Reed. Second by
[0:35:13] Sherry Bomer to approve the request for professional services agreement with Steve Steel LLC
[0:35:20] to provide the city with cellular tower lease negotiations and services and authorized the city manager to sign any further discussion
[0:35:32] Rachel roll call vote please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes seven to zero. Thank you Mitch.
[0:35:46] Okay, next item on the agenda is Mitch Back.
[0:35:52] A request to approve a contract with core construction to service the city construction manager, general contractor GM's, GC, CMGC for the remodel in addition to the city pool.
[0:36:08] Just a second ago Aaron told you that we're doing a lot of these CMGC projects. This is one of those
[0:36:15] I want to do I want to do two things with you tonight
[0:36:18] Again a few meetings ago. We brought the rankings for the the CMGC
[0:36:23] contracts and and core
[0:36:26] I gotta get these right core construction. The architect is coal. This is core
[0:36:34] Core construction with the top ranked firm there
[0:36:36] So, we have since then negotiated the contract and we're, I think, ready to have that sign and see pre-construction services came in at $12,764 and then the CMGC fee is 5%.
[0:36:55] This is an excellent team GC fee for this one.
[0:36:59] As you've heard lately, we've been seeing seven upwards as much as nine, and so for
[0:37:06] them to come in at five, this is really excellent.
[0:37:09] Core construction is sort of newish in Idaho.
[0:37:13] They certainly are new to the Magic Valley.
[0:37:15] They have an interest in working in the Magic Valley and they're trying hard to get business,
[0:37:21] and so we're really pleased with this contract.
[0:37:25] And so, first thing is, yes, we're ready to go with this contract.
[0:37:28] We think it's a great contract.
[0:37:31] If you're OK with it, we would recommend that you approve it.
[0:37:34] And then I'll execute the contract with Core.
[0:37:36] The second thing I want to talk to you about and get a little bit
[0:37:39] of feedback from you is schedule.
[0:37:41] The schedule for the project is not in the contract.
[0:37:44] We'll get to the schedule a little later when we come back with the GMP.
[0:37:47] But it's one of those things that we want to negotiate with them.
[0:37:50] And I would like some City Council feedback on that negotiation
[0:37:54] because they've given us a few different things to consider.
[0:37:58] We're going to be tearing down or remodeling the pool building,
[0:38:04] not the pool itself, but rather the restrooms in the building.
[0:38:07] And we're going to be removing amenities, right?
[0:38:11] Restaurants and locker rooms and things like that
[0:38:13] and reducing capacity of the pool.
[0:38:16] And because of that, we can do a couple of different things.
[0:38:19] One of the things that they suggest
[0:38:20] is we can completely close down the pool for six months.
[0:38:25] That's the fastest way to get it done and probably the cheapest way to get it done and then reopen and and get to work
[0:38:34] There's problems with that, right?
[0:38:36] It might be fast and cheap, but also we have a handful of
[0:38:42] Employees that are part-time employees that probably will go find other work
[0:38:45] I have a couple full-time employees that we need to find something to do with
[0:38:49] There's also programs and services that we offer over the winter time
[0:38:52] time. There's the Marlin's swim team, there's the water polo team, all those things that
[0:38:59] would not be able to happen in that case. So that was option one. Option two would be
[0:39:05] a complete closure for like four months, and then a partial reopening at a reduced capacity
[0:39:11] for two more months. This is probably the next closest in terms of, or the next cheapest
[0:39:16] in terms of cost, but still a closure and all those same issues that would still happen.
[0:39:22] And then the third option would be try to remain open through the construction.
[0:39:26] It adds a couple of months to the process.
[0:39:28] I don't believe that equates to a third more money because we're not talking about the total
[0:39:33] cost, but we are talking about general conditions extending for a couple of months.
[0:39:37] It would be a little bit more expensive.
[0:39:39] And it would reduce the capacity throughout the winter time, which isn't terribly a big
[0:39:45] problem because we have reduced use in the winter anyway.
[0:39:50] And so those are generally the three kind of options.
[0:39:53] I'm curious to see the Council's appetite for complete closure or partial closure or
[0:40:01] try to stay up in the whole time.
[0:40:03] Wendy and John are back here and also can help us talk about this if you have comments or
[0:40:09] questions.
[0:40:10] So first of all, questions about the contract.
[0:40:12] Second of all, let's have a chat about schedule really quick.
[0:40:15] Any question on the specific contract?
[0:40:18] Yeah, Mayor, a question on the contract.
[0:40:21] Yeah.
[0:40:22] This is a different template than it's normally used.
[0:40:24] I'm just curious if it's been reviewed by our attorney.
[0:40:27] This, um, core is a big outfit and this is their own template that they've created.
[0:40:34] Yes, Bruce has reviewed it.
[0:40:35] He's comfortable with this contract.
[0:40:37] Actually, we tweaked it a little bit because of Bruce's input.
[0:40:40] But the way it is right now, yeah, he's been given his blessing.
[0:40:45] I actually am skeptical of those firms that have been in multiple states and they offer their own contracts, but I trust Bruce. So thank you
[0:40:53] Anything else on the contract itself?
[0:40:56] Great, Grayson. Did you have a question? Oh, thank you. Thank you, Madam Mayor
[0:41:01] You did a great segue into my question and I saw a director Davis back there
[0:41:06] And I'd be really inclined if you wouldn't mind
[0:41:09] When do you come in down and kind of giving your feedback on what you think the schedules would be like and kind of the impacts of it?
[0:41:14] Don't mean to put you on the spot, but
[0:41:18] John has some thoughts too and where he's like kind of right there in the pulpit.
[0:41:23] He might be good to talk to you.
[0:41:25] All of you.
[0:41:26] Yeah, please.
[0:41:33] What's up?
[0:41:34] Don't be mean.
[0:41:35] Not going to be walking down there.
[0:41:37] No, we've talked about this and I think John has thoughts on this as well and I'll kind of summarize it and then if we need to go a little deeper.
[0:41:45] A six-month closure, we're concerned more than anything about staff, especially the seasonal staff,
[0:41:55] and if we close up over six months, John has serious concerns about losing all of them and having to
[0:42:01] start over with a full new staff in May. So there's some concerns about maybe doing it that way, and
[0:42:09] the four-month closure with a two-month window feels more manageable and maybe less impactful
[0:42:19] than a full six-month closure. The eight-month open, I don't, I can't really wrap my head around
[0:42:27] what I think that's going to look like and what the impacts would be as far as what are limited
[0:42:35] capacity to be open is, I mean, there's always impacts to the users of the pool, and there's
[0:42:41] impacts to the staff. And as far as eight months of limited open, I don't really know quite yet what
[0:42:51] that might look like. So is there more to that that you guys want to hear, or does that give you kind
[0:42:57] of the over? I think if we closed for six months solid, we would be opening in May about the same
[0:43:06] time we'd want to open for the summer with maybe no staff. Or if we'd be doing
[0:43:12] stuff like we used to back where you have to hire and train them and get open in a
[0:43:18] couple of weeks. I have a concern that there's not much difference between four
[0:43:23] months and six months when it comes to staff. I'd be more inclined if the cost
[0:43:28] wasn't that much more to try to cobble through being open. It's kind of like
[0:43:34] Do we close Eastland for a month or do we leave it partially open and people are in
[0:43:41] convenience?
[0:43:42] Forever.
[0:43:43] Yeah.
[0:43:44] I just can't see, and I don't even have kids swimming, but I just can't see a closure
[0:43:50] being anything but negative personally.
[0:43:54] And I think the only advantage that John can see in the four versus six months is that
[0:44:00] The opening time would be before summer,
[0:44:05] which would give him a little bit of time
[0:44:07] to start rebuilding the staff and getting them trained
[0:44:10] by summer versus closure right up until time
[0:44:14] to open for the summer season,
[0:44:16] which is when we make our most revenue
[0:44:20] and have the greatest use through the summer, obviously.
[0:44:24] Basically, either way, you're seeing,
[0:44:26] you'd be looking for new staff with a closure.
[0:44:29] That what you think, John?
[0:44:30] I think we may keep some with the four month
[0:44:36] because we've had similar closes like that before,
[0:44:38] but it was difficult.
[0:44:40] I don't think it's gonna be a great result, honestly.
[0:44:43] I also worry about certain user groups' access
[0:44:45] to the pool as well, and I'm not talking about
[0:44:47] like some teams in water pool,
[0:44:48] we've already advocated for them,
[0:44:50] but senior special needs people
[0:44:52] who definitely need that type of facility,
[0:44:54] that one is a high concern for me.
[0:44:57] Sure, kind of answered some of my stuff.
[0:45:03] Questions?
[0:45:06] Have you talked to staff at all or had discussions with them?
[0:45:09] Or are we just kind of thinking?
[0:45:12] This all is very recent within last week,
[0:45:14] so it really hasn't even been enough time to talk about it.
[0:45:17] But with based off our past trends,
[0:45:19] whether it be COVID shutdown or redoing the surface,
[0:45:24] we're very similar in how things went about.
[0:45:28] So what programs on the longest time
[0:45:31] that you shut down, what programs
[0:45:32] are going to suffer from that?
[0:45:33] And not just like you said, the swim team and what,
[0:45:35] because that is important as well, but as you were saying, you know, some of the things
[0:45:40] that we don't, that maybe the general public doesn't think about like the special needs
[0:45:44] that go in and use those.
[0:45:46] So mainly it's the, it's the type of people that come in that, so like we have two or three
[0:45:50] different senior water fitness groups that come in multiple times a week, they do their
[0:45:54] own thing, they're big groups, I mean they're getting up there in big sizes.
[0:45:58] This is their activity, this is their socialization, I can name you, I know a couple, one or two,
[0:46:04] some of them are for sure who definitely needs the pool and to keep doing their
[0:46:10] things so with our programs we can rebuild we won't have the experience if
[0:46:16] we have to start all over that's gonna take time to rebuild again and it'll be
[0:46:19] hard we'll do it but it's gonna take time but our internal programs such as
[0:46:24] our some lessons and hurricanes will hurt long-term because we'll lose that
[0:46:28] experience so that that's where I kind of look in that I don't know that the
[0:46:34] cost outweighs staying open and I don't have those numbers so I'm just kind of
[0:46:40] guessing based on what you're saying but it would be great and it would be nice
[0:46:44] to be able to just like you know shut whatever we need down and let it go you
[0:46:49] know get it fixed and get it done but is it does it outweigh the cost outweigh the
[0:46:54] benefit. We talked a little bit today about cost as far as you know if you shut
[0:47:01] it down, there's still going to be cost. It'll be not unlike when we had it, when the but
[0:47:12] when we didn't have the bubble on it. So, you know, having the pool open but not having
[0:47:16] people come in or trying to maintain the space, there's some costs associated with that as
[0:47:22] well, even if people aren't there. John has a plan for that that kind of makes sense to
[0:47:26] me that we would drain the pool and do some work and do some cleaning and leave it drained
[0:47:30] over the wind during the closure which would certainly minimize the need for
[0:47:34] chemicals and keeping the bubble area warm and some of those kinds of things as
[0:47:39] far as that goes. It seems to me that you're going to have an impact to revenue no
[0:47:45] matter what during construction. There's probably no way that we'll be able to
[0:47:49] operate at full capacity no matter what. But to really analyze those numbers I
[0:47:55] I think maybe the question today is a little bit more of what's the appetite for closing
[0:48:01] it, and as we get closer we can look a little bit more and really dive in to what the impacts
[0:48:10] would be and try to make a recommendation that makes the most sense.
[0:48:13] I have some pains of closing up for six months, okay.
[0:48:19] I would echo I have some some concerns closing at that that period of time
[0:48:26] much rather do a phased approach on
[0:48:29] Building it understanding that the pool itself isn't going to be affected. It's the building
[0:48:35] But also financially need to see where those numbers come in as well
[0:48:39] But my appetite is to keep it open and move it in phases
[0:48:43] right
[0:48:45] John I was wondering how feasible is it to relieving partially open?
[0:48:50] construction. I mean, are the changing rooms that they're going, aren't they?
[0:48:57] So from what they presented to us last week on that, a phase would go where
[0:49:02] they would do some, they would start building the new portion and getting that
[0:49:07] already and then once that's done we would get into that section and then they
[0:49:11] would shut off the locker rooms to us and while they did that part that's what
[0:49:16] would allow us to phase to use the different sections of the building. That's
[0:49:21] That's where the capacity drop would occur, but the capacity drop in the non-summer months
[0:49:27] is much more achievable than in the summer months.
[0:49:31] And if there is some addition closer into the summer, like if they're still continuing it,
[0:49:36] you can always bring in some porta-potties too and things like that to help with that.
[0:49:41] Okay, a couple more comments and then we need to vote on this contract.
[0:49:47] Grayson?
[0:49:48] Thank you Madam Mayor.
[0:49:49] I'm actually in a shock that I'm going this way a little bit in my own head, but I'm
[0:49:53] actually in favor of closing down for six months and just ripping the bandit off. I
[0:50:00] think operationally it could be really clunky. For sanitary conditions I'd
[0:50:07] be interested to see a plan for showers. I mean we had to close it for that
[0:50:10] whatever that was. I saw the email come out. How important is to make sure you're
[0:50:15] taking a shower before and everything else. I think my preference would be we
[0:50:19] We just ripped the bandit off on this one, but.
[0:50:23] Sherry Volmer again.
[0:50:25] Just real quick, and I don't want to make it a big long
[0:50:28] conversation, but are there options for just to have
[0:50:35] temporary facilities?
[0:50:37] And not, they don't have to be super nice ones,
[0:50:40] but are there options for temporary changing room?
[0:50:45] There are options that are feasible.
[0:50:48] The plan that they presented to us
[0:50:49] was face construction, so you wouldn't
[0:50:51] need the temporary ones. But because it's a public pool, there's requirements for facilities
[0:50:56] to serve the pool. We would reduce the number of people that could use the pool hearing that
[0:51:02] reduced capacity. It would never shut down entirely. If we needed to, we could also bring
[0:51:08] in temporary ones. That just adds to the cost of those rental facilities. And again, we
[0:51:13] don't know what the cost will be for the eight months versus the six months versus the four,
[0:51:19] this conversation kind of informs how we move forward with that pricing and negotiations.
[0:51:26] For the final vote for that.
[0:51:28] Which we will give you back.
[0:51:30] Yeah, we bring back a change.
[0:51:32] This is just an ed nod.
[0:51:33] This is just kind of helping us shape how that G&P is going to look when we bring it back to you.
[0:51:38] Thank you.
[0:51:40] Mr. Reid.
[0:51:41] I'll make a motion if we're ready.
[0:51:42] Thank you.
[0:51:43] I move that we approve a contract with core construction to serve as the city's construction manager slash general contractor.
[0:51:50] CMGC for the remodel in addition to the city pool.
[0:51:55] Thank you, Sherry Vomer.
[0:51:56] I'll second.
[0:51:57] Thank you.
[0:51:58] Motion by Chris Reed.
[0:51:59] Second by Sherry Vomer to approve the request to approve a contract with core construction.
[0:52:10] To service the city's general construction manager, general contractor, CMGC for the remodel
[0:52:17] in addition to the city pool.
[0:52:22] No, you can't. I'm sorry.
[0:52:26] So not on this particular topic.
[0:52:30] You're welcome to speak at public comment section only on items not on today's agenda.
[0:52:37] If you wish to send me an email, send us an email on comments you have today.
[0:52:45] On this particular item, you can do that.
[0:52:49] Okay.
[0:52:53] We had a motion and a second.
[0:52:57] Rachel Rolkow, please.
[0:53:00] Ruth Pierce.
[0:53:01] Yes.
[0:53:02] Chris Reed.
[0:53:03] Yes.
[0:53:04] Greg Hawkins.
[0:53:05] Yes.
[0:53:06] Spencer Cutler.
[0:53:07] Yes.
[0:53:08] Sherry Fulmer.
[0:53:09] Yes.
[0:53:10] And Grayson Stone.
[0:53:12] Yes.
[0:53:13] Thank you.
[0:53:14] Motion passes six to zero.
[0:53:15] Okay.
[0:53:16] Next on the agenda is an action item.
[0:53:17] A request to approve the reallocation of $25,615 from budgeted full time salaries to
[0:53:24] to purchase the Human Resource Module from BS&A Software,
[0:53:28] and we have our HR Director, Kristen Kontop.
[0:53:33] Welcome, Kristen.
[0:53:34] Thank you.
[0:53:35] Good evening, Madam Mayor and Council.
[0:53:37] As stated, I'm here to request approval
[0:53:40] for reallocation of funds to purchase that HR module
[0:53:43] from BS&A Software.
[0:53:46] This would be our first true HRIS or HR information system.
[0:53:52] Historically, we've utilized paper, Excel,
[0:53:56] and kind of a variety of forms through our laser fish
[0:53:59] process.
[0:54:01] This purchase would allow us to offer seamless integration
[0:54:04] with our existing payroll system and enhance efficiency
[0:54:08] across various things, including managing job postings,
[0:54:12] handling job applications, and streamlining
[0:54:15] our hiring process, as well as overall employee file
[0:54:19] management.
[0:54:20] As stated, it would also allow us to centralize our data
[0:54:25] into a more effective system that would allow us
[0:54:29] to manage things such as trainings, certifications,
[0:54:32] and licenses for all of our employees.
[0:54:35] Plus, it also has a smart budgeting ability
[0:54:38] that I believe will be very beneficial in the future
[0:54:41] for forecasting capabilities.
[0:54:45] Why is this important, do you ask?
[0:54:47] So, fun fact in calendar year 2024, the HR department was responsible for maintaining roughly 362 full-time employee files and 194 seasonal employee files.
[0:55:02] So, by centralizing all of that information will be more efficient.
[0:55:08] So, financially, the HR department has realized significant savings this year due to vacancies totaling roughly $89,000.
[0:55:17] $89,000, which includes salary and insurance savings.
[0:55:23] This positions us well to fund this request
[0:55:25] without adversely affecting our overall budget.
[0:55:29] It is important to note that there is an ongoing annual,
[0:55:32] cloud-based hosting fee of $13,675.
[0:55:38] But I believe that this reallocation
[0:55:40] will lead to long-term savings and more efficient use
[0:55:43] of the department's time and operations.
[0:55:47] So in conclusion, with approval to reallocate these funds,
[0:55:50] we can begin the acquisition of this process.
[0:55:54] And the HR team looks forward to long-term savings
[0:55:57] and all the benefits provided by the HRBSNA module.
[0:56:02] Stand for any questions.
[0:56:04] Thank you.
[0:56:05] Any questions for Kristen?
[0:56:07] Ms. Wiet.
[0:56:08] A quick question for you, understanding
[0:56:09] that this will be housing personnel information.
[0:56:13] Have you looked with the IT, has the IT department looked
[0:56:17] over it for all security and safety with this service.
[0:56:22] Yes, we had an initial demonstration from BS&A roughly 9
[0:56:27] to 12 months ago regarding the software,
[0:56:29] and we have another one scheduled in two weeks to review and see
[0:56:33] any changes that have come about in that time frame.
[0:56:37] Perfect.
[0:56:38] Thank you.
[0:56:38] Any other questions for Kristin?
[0:56:42] OK, I'd entertain a while.
[0:56:43] Thank you.
[0:56:44] Thank you.
[0:56:45] Motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Grayson Stone to approve the reallocation of $25,615
[0:56:50] from budgeted full-time salaries to purchase the human resource module from BSNA software.
[0:56:57] Thank you.
[0:56:58] Do we have a second?
[0:56:59] Grayson Stone?
[0:57:00] Thank you.
[0:57:02] Thank you.
[0:57:03] Thank you.
[0:57:04] Motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Grayson Stone to approve the reallocation of $25,615 from
[0:57:12] budgeted full-time salaries to purchase the Human Resource Module from BS&A software. Any further
[0:57:19] discussion? Rachel Roquevo, please? Ray Hopkins? Yes.
[0:57:24] Senator Cutler? Yes. Jerry Volmer? Yes.
[0:57:27] Grayson Stone? Yes. Ruth Pierce? Yes.
[0:57:29] Tincris Reed? Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 6-0. Thank you, Kristen. Hey,
[0:57:36] The next item on the agenda is an action item, a presentation of the 2024 annual report, uh-oh.
[0:57:44] Did I skip one?
[0:57:46] I did, I'm so sorry.
[0:57:48] Come on up.
[0:57:49] A request to approve a contract with suburban CM to service the city's construction manager, general contractor, CMGC, for the demo and reconstruction of the city park restroom project.
[0:58:06] project. We have Will Clayver, our senior planner. Welcome Will.
[0:58:10] Thank you. Sorry about that. Not a problem. I understand best for last and that's usually the plan zoning.
[0:58:17] We have another request to approve a city manager, general contractor request before you today. We've gone through a couple of these today, so I won't go into too much detail on that process.
[0:58:34] This is specifically for the demolition and the reconstruction of the City Park bathroom.
[0:58:39] And last month in February, we brought this the rankings of our RFQ before you.
[0:58:50] The highest ranking was for suburban construction management for suburban CM.
[0:58:55] What this contract negotiations ensued, Suburban is proposing a 7% CMGC fee with a $3,500 for
[0:59:09] pre-construction cost. This contract does not contain the guaranteed max price for
[0:59:18] GMP, we'll bring that forward, should this contractor go forward and after more negotiations or discussions
[0:59:26] since who?
[0:59:29] So if should you approve the contract as presented to you today, this will authorize
[0:59:36] staff to execute the agreement.
[0:59:43] And just a note, the contract that was in your packets had Chance Munn's signing for
[0:59:51] it.
[0:59:52] I have since updated that to authorize Mitch Humbler, WCMA, to sign, but that will stand
[1:00:00] for any questions.
[1:00:01] Thank you.
[1:00:03] Well, what's the time frame on this project?
[1:00:06] Yeah.
[1:00:07] timeline, the anticipated timeline is April, May through September, have a deadline to finish
[1:00:17] by October 31st. That is what we've talked about so far. We have talked with our Parks
[1:00:24] Department because we know this is a major park, especially for our events, and only a portion
[1:00:30] of the park will be closed, will minimize the closure of it and still be able to work
[1:00:36] through our projects and the vendors that the park is used to host.
[1:00:44] Thank you. Any other questions, Grayson?
[1:00:48] Thank you, Madam Mayor. I don't have a question. It's another straightforward deal.
[1:00:51] So I'm prepared to make motion. That'd be great.
[1:00:54] Madam Mayor, I move to approve a contract with suburban CM to service the city's construction manager slash general contractor CMGC
[1:01:02] for the demo and reconstruction of the City Park restroom
[1:01:06] and authorized Mitch Humboldt to sign the contract accordingly.
[1:01:09] Thank you.
[1:01:10] Do I have a second?
[1:01:11] Second.
[1:01:12] Thank you.
[1:01:13] Motion by Grace and Stone.
[1:01:15] Second by Spencer Cutler to approve a contract with suburban construction management
[1:01:20] to serve six cities, construction manager, general contactor,
[1:01:24] to see MGC for the demo and reconstruction of the City Park restroom
[1:01:29] and authorized Mitch Humboldt to sign.
[1:01:32] Any further discussion? Rachel Rolkow, please.
[1:01:36] Sherry Wilmer. Yes.
[1:01:37] Brace and Stone. Yes.
[1:01:39] Ruth Pierce. Yes.
[1:01:40] Chris Reed. Yes.
[1:01:41] Ray Calkins. Yes. Yes. Spencer Cutler. Yes.
[1:01:44] Thank you. Motion passes six to zero. Thank you, Will.
[1:01:49] Hey, now Sean. Next on the agenda is the presentation of the 2024 annual report of the Urban Renewal Agency of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho.
[1:02:00] and we offer you our executive director, Sean Berrigert.
[1:02:03] Welcome, Sean.
[1:02:05] Good evening, Mayor and Council.
[1:02:07] So Idaho Code requires that urban renewal agencies
[1:02:11] operating in Idaho present an annual report
[1:02:14] regarding activities from the preceding calendar year,
[1:02:17] which gets super complicated since we don't operate
[1:02:19] on a calendar year, fiscal year.
[1:02:24] It's required by law.
[1:02:26] So today at the Urban Renewal Meeting at noon,
[1:02:30] the Urban Renewal Agency Board did accept this annual report.
[1:02:37] This is my delivery to you that the city have a copy of this.
[1:02:41] We will also place notice in the general public note
[1:02:44] that the report has been filed for the year
[1:02:47] and is available for inspection.
[1:02:49] So understanding that I'm what's standing between you
[1:02:52] and the last couple of short items on the agenda
[1:02:55] and dinner. I will hit the high points are 2024 annual report basically identifying who
[1:03:03] the Board of Commissioners are and again this operates on a slightly wonkier year than what
[1:03:09] we actually operate in the key activities in the past year. First our old town two revenue
[1:03:16] allocation area so that's the large blue map on the screen there the broader downtown
[1:03:23] area really starting some of the implementation of the downtown master plan
[1:03:27] that has been presented to you in the past looking for opportunities to identify
[1:03:33] properties for redevelopment opportunities, scheduling some one-on-one
[1:03:37] presentations with potential developers who have expressed interest in development
[1:03:41] in the core area of downtown and the agency board has directed me over the
[1:03:47] coming weeks to develop some specific requests for proposals for some of the
[1:03:52] agency owned properties in downtown. Just as I highlight these red parcels on the map are
[1:04:00] properties that are currently owned by the urban agency. Some of those are vacant properties. Some
[1:04:06] are parking lots as part of the downtown parking system. Some are buildings that actually have tenants
[1:04:12] in them. We'll be looking at the most opportune ways to advance private development in some of those
[1:04:19] in the coming year.
[1:04:21] Also, there were two specific funding projects that the agency did in the old town two area
[1:04:28] last year.
[1:04:29] The first was in support of the gas lamp LLC, it's a new event center space that opened
[1:04:35] in downtown.
[1:04:36] I'm assisting with some impact fees for that as well as funding to do a budget study to
[1:04:45] to determine preliminary cost estimates for a redo of Hanson's Street, so something along
[1:04:54] the lines of Main Avenue, though probably not that extensive that we're done a few years
[1:04:59] ago, but in alignment with the downtown master plan, talking about creating a corridor since
[1:05:07] down Hanson Street, so that was completed as well.
[1:05:11] Orchard Drive used revenue allocation area, so this is the location of the Gemini Business
[1:05:15] Park just south of Clipbar, really one of the more active activities of the
[1:05:20] agency last year driven by the private developer there certainly. Three new
[1:05:26] buildings were constructed in 2024, another is under construction currently.
[1:05:33] To date they've completed more than two million dollars in public improvements
[1:05:39] out there with roadway construction, water and sewer expansion, a power
[1:05:45] extensions as part of that urban renewal area. So excited to see a lot of good
[1:05:50] activity out there and and tenants signing on to utilize those facilities. The last
[1:05:57] two items really are kind of tied together. The first is the termination of
[1:06:00] the Washington Street South Revenue Allocation Area. This is the smaller
[1:06:06] property that's near that included Glambya and the property just south of
[1:06:09] that, in anticipation of the creation of the new Southwest Revenue Allocation Area,
[1:06:16] that property couldn't exist in two areas at once. So the Washington Street South Area
[1:06:22] was terminated. In the Southwest Revenue Allocation Area was created, creating the opportunity
[1:06:27] for industrial development on about 350 acres adjacent to the kind of the core industrial
[1:06:35] part of Twin Falls. So those were the high points also included in the annual report. You will see
[1:06:41] copies of both the 2023 and 2024 audits. We too got a clean bill of health as that audit was conducted
[1:06:54] in conjunction with the city's audit and then I would just note we do have some bond obligations
[1:07:00] related to the Chobani and Cliffbar projects. The average length of time on those currently is
[1:07:06] nine years and the average interest rate on all those bond obligations is 6.6%. But that
[1:07:14] I would certainly stand for any questions you have on the highlights of 2024.
[1:07:19] Thank you Sean. Any questions for Sean on his report?
[1:07:25] That's more rising. Thank you. I heard it at lunch so.
[1:07:31] And last month as well. Yes. Thank you. Thank you.
[1:07:35] Okay, that's it for items of consideration.
[1:07:40] The next item on the agenda is the time for public input.
[1:07:44] There's anybody in the public that wishes to address City Council on an issue not on
[1:07:49] today's agenda or not any personnel issue.
[1:07:55] Please come down to the podium and state your name and whether you're a citizen of Twin
[1:08:00] Falls and then you have two minutes.
[1:08:02] My name is Ashley Besser, yes I'm a resident of Twin Falls.
[1:08:20] I am a school teacher, I'm also a tennis coach for Twin Falls High School and a tennis instructor.
[1:08:27] I'm here today to bring light of a situation I have encountered the last few years.
[1:08:32] When you go to the Parks and Recs department to fill out an application,
[1:08:37] to reserve and pay for tennis courts, which I have done multiple times.
[1:08:42] At the time I reserve the courts, the department tells me if they are open and whether or not I'm allowed to reserve them.
[1:08:49] I am then, I am then, and able to pay and sign a contract.
[1:08:55] However, at any time after I have done that, the Parks and Rec Department can bump me from the time that I have paid for of those courts for their own usage.
[1:09:10] they then refund me. I personally just feel as though if money has been exchanged
[1:09:17] and a contract has been signed and accepted they should honor that and the
[1:09:23] Parks and Rec Department can use other city courts instead of bump me from the
[1:09:28] courts I have already purchased. Thank you. Okay anybody else that wishes to
[1:09:41] to address City Council on issues not on today's agenda.
[1:09:48] Okay, seeing no one, advisory board reports, right?
[1:09:54] I just want to mention that we had the honor
[1:09:58] of seeing our chief of fire department,
[1:10:02] tirement celebration today,
[1:10:04] and it was really outstanding, a fantastic crowd.
[1:10:07] I think we got to have a bigger parking lot Travis, so.
[1:10:12] Oh, parking lots, okay.
[1:10:15] fewer retirements. Yeah, right. Okay, any other advisory board reports? City
[1:10:22] manager's office. So, just with that, you know, the celebration of Chief Ken Worthy
[1:10:27] was was great and it's my obligation to then find and work with members of our
[1:10:35] team to secure the next fire chief and it's my pleasure to announce again that
[1:10:41] I'll be appointing Mitchell Brooks or asking the council to confirm the
[1:10:44] appointment in Mitchell Brooks to the position of Fire Chief at our next meeting, which is scheduled for the 31st of March.
[1:10:51] We will not be meeting on the 24th. I guess an observation of spring break, which is still a new phenomenon to me.
[1:11:00] So we won't be meeting next week so everybody can enjoy spring break whether you have children or not in the school system, but we'll be meeting again on the 31st.
[1:11:10] Okay, that means that we are adjourned. Thank you.
