Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2024-09-30, recording 1 (started 16:58)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2024-09-30/

[0:02:34] Good evening, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the September 30th, 2024 City Council meeting. I want to confirm
[0:02:41] We have a quorum. We have six members present in chambers, and I believe
[0:02:48] Grayson's on the phone
[0:02:50] So first item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance if you wish to join me, please rise
[0:02:56] Thank you. We have no proclamations tonight. So next is the consent calendar council wishes
[0:03:20] Move to approve.
[0:03:21] Move to approve.
[0:03:22] Can you do I have a second?
[0:03:24] Second.
[0:03:25] Thank you.
[0:03:26] Motion by Chris Reed.
[0:03:27] Seconded by Craig Hawkins to approve the consent calendar as written.
[0:03:32] Amy Rolkelvo, please.
[0:03:37] Ruth Pierce?
[0:03:38] Yes.
[0:03:39] Chris Reed?
[0:03:40] Yes.
[0:03:41] Craig Hawkins?
[0:03:42] Yes.
[0:03:43] Jason Brown?
[0:03:44] Yes.
[0:03:45] Spencer Cutler?
[0:03:46] Yes.
[0:03:56] Barry Bolmer?
[0:03:57] Yes.
[0:03:58] And Grayson Stone.
[0:04:00] But he's not able to communicate back. He was texting me here. Okay. You said yes
[0:04:07] Is that legal work?
[0:04:10] Okay motion passes seven to zero just check him
[0:04:15] Okay
[0:04:16] What's the matter? He did he texts?
[0:04:23] Okay, I can screenshot it. Thank you. Okay motion passes seven to zero
[0:04:29] Next, under items of consideration is an action item, a request approval of the collective
[0:04:38] bargaining agreement between the city and Twin Falls Firefighters Local 1556 and we
[0:04:46] have our HR Director Kristin Kontopf, welcome, Kristin.
[0:04:52] Good afternoon, thank you for having me here tonight.
[0:04:56] I'm here to ask for the approval of the collective bargaining agreement, as Mayor Pierce stated.
[0:05:02] Last year, we approved a one-year contract with an agreement to open for specific issues
[0:05:09] that we wanted to address in this current year.
[0:05:12] Over the past five months, City Admin and the executive board have had several meetings
[0:05:19] and worked together covering some important topics like health insurance, staffing, physical
[0:05:24] fitness standards and wages. This was my first time going through the negotiations and I
[0:05:31] truly appreciated the collaboration and getting to know the e-board better. It was just really
[0:05:37] fun to get to know those members on a different level. So tonight I wanted to provide you with
[0:05:43] a quick overview of some of the key changes that we agreed on. Under that we updated both
[0:05:50] the medical leave section and the bereavement leave section to align with our employee hand
[0:05:55] book language. In section 16, the medical expense retirement plan, or MERP section, we
[0:06:04] clarified benefits for employees that transition outside of the union. So, for members currently
[0:06:10] enrolled in the MERP, they will carry their existing benefit if they promote out of the
[0:06:15] bargaining unit, but they will not be eligible for both the MERP and the city's HRA Viva.
[0:06:21] So, just some clarifying language there.
[0:06:25] Another change that we made was to section 24, Manning of Companies.
[0:06:30] We made some revisions to incorporate a previous memorandum of understanding or MOU related
[0:06:36] to shift assignments and staffing.
[0:06:40] We updated language to better align with the additional operational opportunities made
[0:06:46] possible by the new fire stations.
[0:06:49] The language also limits splitting engine companies on a long-term basis, so splitting
[0:06:55] a staffing, which will help with the safety and efficiency of our operations going forward.
[0:07:03] In Section 34, Health and Wellness and Physical Fitness Section, there is some revised language
[0:07:10] regarding the annual physical and mental wellness checks that we do partnered with Dr. Hilvers
[0:07:16] out of Boise.
[0:07:17] If you guys remember last year, we started engaging and partnering with Dr. Hilvers last
[0:07:22] fall to provide those services, and I'm pleased to share that at this time, all of our frontline
[0:07:29] employees have met with Dr. Hilvers or his staff for their annual check.
[0:07:34] The feedback has been great, and our employees feel that the experience is more individualized
[0:07:39] and efficient.
[0:07:41] And lastly, I wanted to talk about the 6% wage increase included in the agreement.
[0:07:49] It aligns with our competitive market adjustments that we've provided while being mindful of
[0:07:53] the effects of inflation and labor shortages in our area.
[0:07:58] So in conclusion, the relationship between the city and the local has been extremely
[0:08:04] positive and informative for me this year.
[0:08:07] teams have thoroughly reviewed the agreement and I'm here to ask the council
[0:08:11] to formally adopt the collective bargaining agreement.
[0:08:14] With that I'll stand for any questions.
[0:08:16] Thank you, President. Any questions on the agreement? Jason Brown.
[0:08:23] I don't have any questions but I'm willing to make a motion.
[0:08:26] Okay, go ahead.
[0:08:28] I'd move to approve the collecting bargaining agreement between the city of Twin Falls
[0:08:33] and the Twin Falls firefighters local 1556.
[0:08:38] Thank you, Sherry Vomer.
[0:08:39] I'll second.
[0:08:40] Thank you.
[0:08:41] Motion by Jason Brown.
[0:08:42] Seconded by Sherry Vollmer to approve the collection bargaining agreement between the
[0:08:47] city of Twin Falls and the city, excuse me, Twin Falls firefighters, Local 1556.
[0:08:55] Any further discussion?
[0:08:57] Amy Rolcovo, please.
[0:08:59] Chris Reed.
[0:09:00] Yes.
[0:09:01] Greg Hawkins.
[0:09:02] Yes.
[0:09:03] Jason Brown.
[0:09:04] Yes.
[0:09:05] Spencer Cutler.
[0:09:06] Yes.
[0:09:07] Sherry Vollmer.
[0:09:22] Go ahead.
[0:09:23] And Ruth Piers.
[0:09:25] Yes.
[0:09:27] Thank you.
[0:09:28] Motion passes six to zero.
[0:09:31] Thank you, Kristen.
[0:09:36] There are a better way to do that.
[0:09:38] Can he email or is he just not responding?
[0:09:41] No, he responded.
[0:09:42] He just, it was time to leave.
[0:09:44] Okay.
[0:09:45] Okay.
[0:09:46] All right.
[0:09:47] So that's actually seven to zero.
[0:09:50] Okay.
[0:09:51] Okay.
[0:09:52] Next is an action item.
[0:09:53] Consider a recommendation from the Public Arts Commission
[0:09:57] to approve the selected artwork,
[0:09:59] artists and placement of art for the downtown
[0:10:02] Commons Mural Project, and we have
[0:10:04] Parks and Rec Director, Wendy Davis.
[0:10:14] Good evening, Mayor and Council.
[0:10:15] And actually, I was kind of kidding,
[0:10:18] as I was walking out the door,
[0:10:19] and I said, Eloise, are you ready to present at Council?
[0:10:21] And she said, sure, if you want me to.
[0:10:23] So, I'm gonna call her up and let her make this request.
[0:10:28] Perfect, thank you.
[0:10:31] Welcome, Eloise.
[0:10:33] Thank you, Mayor.
[0:10:34] Thank you, City Council.
[0:10:35] Thanks for the opportunity to speak to you folks today.
[0:10:38] So I'm coming to you with a request
[0:10:40] to consider a recommendation from the Public Art Commission
[0:10:43] to approve the selected artwork, artists, and placement
[0:10:46] for art for the Downtown Commons mural project.
[0:10:49] Back in June of this year, City Council allocated the funds
[0:10:53] of up to $15,000 from Public Art Reserve funds
[0:10:57] to support this project.
[0:10:59] After that, the commission sent out a culture artist.
[0:11:02] We received 12 artists with a total of 30 submissions
[0:11:06] and upon a series of public meetings,
[0:11:10] the commission selected six pieces of art
[0:11:13] to be placed in the commons mural frames
[0:11:16] that are right outside our building here.
[0:11:20] So I would like to go through the artwork.
[0:11:25] And again, this is in consideration of the artwork itself,
[0:11:29] as well as the placement that Council will be considering today.
[0:11:35] Our first artist is Emily Midell,
[0:11:45] and these are the two pieces that she has submitted
[0:11:48] that were selected.
[0:11:51] We have Monica D'Angelo and her two pieces,
[0:12:05] Rod S.X., and this piece was selected from his submissions.
[0:12:15] Rick Cune, this was the piece selected from his submissions.
[0:12:23] The overlay that we were able to impose
[0:12:26] the artwork onto the frames in the downtown commons for just sort of a mockup to see what
[0:12:32] this would look like.
[0:12:33] And this is sort of the intention of the pieces and the placement.
[0:12:38] I'm coming to you today to ask if you folks would like to approve the placement and the
[0:12:46] artwork along with these selected artists.
[0:12:51] Any questions for Eloise Piss Reed?
[0:12:54] As far as the material being used, how long are we expecting these to last?
[0:12:58] I know, the last round we had some issues with some of the material that this was originally
[0:13:04] printed on, but what about this?
[0:13:06] So the intention for this artwork is that it's going to be something that will open up in
[0:13:11] coming years for a rotating piece, so we're hoping to get a little bit more lifespan out
[0:13:16] of these pieces.
[0:13:17] I believe the estimate was about three to five years.
[0:13:21] Perfect.
[0:13:22] Thank you.
[0:13:23] Spencer, I like the way you've arranged them on the mockup.
[0:13:29] want to give artists the liberty of changing if you wanted but I just I like
[0:13:33] the way you did it and I appreciate the work. Thank you Jason Brown. Yeah really
[0:13:39] yeah I think the art pieces look great did they they give any explanation of the
[0:13:45] the art itself like why they did it or I know oftentimes artists will will provide
[0:13:51] just a little synopsis of of that art I guess I look at it from a from a
[0:13:56] perspective of history that if we keep these in in storage at some point then the art
[0:14:02] then we have some at least some history associated with why the artists drew what they did.
[0:14:09] So if approved we will go into an agreement with the artists and part of that agreement
[0:14:14] states that we require a little synopsis or biography that would encapsulate that.
[0:14:19] Well thank you. I think Greg Hawkins. Hello I just want to thank you for
[0:14:24] for the effort you guys have put into this.
[0:14:32] This was not just looking and throwing it up on the wall, but we had to work with sizes
[0:14:38] and lengths and dimensions to fit it all in.
[0:14:42] It was pretty interesting to hear all the information that went into it, but they did
[0:14:46] a good job, I think.
[0:14:47] Thank you.
[0:14:48] Thank you.
[0:14:49] Definitely a team left with the Public Art Commission as well.
[0:14:53] Thank you.
[0:14:54] Anybody else?
[0:14:55] I'll go ahead and make a motion then, if that's okay.
[0:15:00] That'd be great.
[0:15:01] I'd like to move that we approve a recommendation of the
[0:15:07] Public Arts Commission to approve the selected art work,
[0:15:10] artists and placement of the art for the downtown commons,
[0:15:13] your project.
[0:15:15] Thank you, Sherry Vomer.
[0:15:17] I'll second.
[0:15:18] Thank you, motion by Craig Hawkins, seconded by Sherry Vomer
[0:15:21] to approve the recommendation from the Public Arts Commission
[0:15:25] for the selected artwork, artists and placement of art for the downtown commons mural project.
[0:15:31] Any further comments or discussions? Amy Rolke, I'll vote please.
[0:15:37] Craig Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes.
[0:15:40] Spencer Cutler. Yes.
[0:15:41] Grayson Stone. He is text yes.
[0:15:45] Cherry Vomer. Yes. And Ruth Pierce. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes seven to zero.
[0:15:51] I'll say yes to yeah Chris read it's all right yeah I like them okay now motion
[0:15:59] passes seven to zero thank you somebody's always the last to know all right okay
[0:16:06] thank you Louise next is an action item request to enter into negotiations
[0:16:12] with Wright brothers construction for CMGC services associated with the
[0:16:18] Canyon Trail Junction and Chirani Wellness Park project. We have Wendy Davis Parks and
[0:16:26] Rec Director. Good evening and on the way out the door I can't find anybody to do
[0:16:33] with this one so. These are stuck with me. So if you may recall in June the
[0:16:40] Parks Department went through a formal bid process for the construction of that
[0:16:46] project at the corner of Poland and Eastland that we have named the Canyon Trail Junction.
[0:16:52] The bid came in high, we got one bid and we rejected it in a meeting due to insufficient
[0:17:00] funds and indicated that I was looking at options and would come back with a recommendation.
[0:17:07] So we visited with the plan holders and the bidder, talked to other city departments and
[0:17:19] considering the fact that a CMGC process has been successful for the city in the past and
[0:17:27] based on the information I was getting from the plan holders that required a little more
[0:17:30] information, this route made more sense than to go back and redo the bid packets.
[0:17:35] So we opened the project for request for qualifications in August, and received six proposals.
[0:17:49] And so we had a lot of qualified applicants to select from.
[0:17:52] We ranked those, invited four back for interviews, ranked based on the interviews that I'm here
[0:17:58] this evening to request that we begin negotiation with what Wright Brothers' construction.
[0:18:05] I included the ranking on here for you if we are unsuccessful with right brothers,
[0:18:11] then we would move on to number two, number three, number four, depending on what we need to do there.
[0:18:16] So I guess if at this point that's our recommendation and that's my request,
[0:18:24] is that I can open that discussion and I believe, I wasn't sure, do I have to come back with a contract
[0:18:31] for these guys. Okay, so yeah, once we're able to settle on a suitable contract, then I'll
[0:18:40] be back with that for you.
[0:18:42] Thank you, Wendy. Where are Wright brothers located, you know?
[0:18:47] So Wright brothers are based out of Rupert.
[0:18:49] Okay.
[0:18:50] However, I think now their main offices are in Boise.
[0:18:53] Okay, thank you. Anybody else have any questions? Nice to be moving this along.
[0:19:02] Yes.
[0:19:04] I'll make the motion.
[0:19:07] I move that we approve the, that we enter into negotiations with Wright brothers construction
[0:19:12] for CMGC services associated with the Canyon Trail Junction and Chobani Wellness Center,
[0:19:20] Wellness Program Project.
[0:19:22] Thank you.
[0:19:23] Jason Brown?
[0:19:24] Second.
[0:19:25] Thank you.
[0:19:26] Motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Jason Brown to approve entering into negotiations with
[0:19:32] with Wright Brother Construction for CMGC services
[0:19:36] associated with Canyon Trail Junction
[0:19:40] and Jibani Wellness Park Project.
[0:19:42] Any further discussion?
[0:19:45] Amy Roll call vote please.
[0:19:49] Jason Brown.
[0:19:49] Yes.
[0:19:50] Venter Cutler.
[0:19:51] Yes.
[0:19:52] Grayson Stone.
[0:19:53] He says yes.
[0:19:54] Jerry Volmer.
[0:19:54] Yes.
[0:19:55] Ruth Pierce.
[0:19:56] Yes.
[0:19:57] Chris Reed.
[0:19:58] Yes.
[0:19:59] And Craig Hawkins.
[0:19:59] Yes.
[0:20:00] Thank you.
[0:20:01] Motion passes 70-0.
[0:20:02] Thank you. I hope to back soon.
[0:20:04] Okay. Next on the agenda is an action item, a consideration of an independent contractor agreement with Bruce Castleton of Castleton Law PLCC for city services defined as defined in the HIDO Code Section 50-208A.
[0:20:23] We have Travis Rothweiler, our city manager.
[0:20:27] Mayor, members of the council, tonight I bring before you an extension of the agreement with
[0:20:32] Bruce Kastleton to serve as our city attorney, as defined by Idaho Code. The agreement is
[0:20:40] very similar to last year with some slight increases and associated with the hourly wages,
[0:20:46] not only for Mr. Kastleton, but also for his legal assistant. And then you'll also note that
[0:20:54] should he bring on an assistant and that assistant do additional work for us.
[0:20:59] There is a price that has already been negotiated and we'll come back and we'll
[0:21:02] modify that agreement. Mr. Castleton will continue to represent the city on city
[0:21:10] matters and represent the city on civil related issues. We have a great
[0:21:14] prosecutorial staff that will continue to be working through the courts in that
[0:21:19] court system and will continue to make sure that they're working in concert with
[0:21:25] Bruce as he continues to coach and mentor them. The members of our
[0:21:31] prosecutorial team really want to be involved in more of the civil and city
[0:21:37] attorney related items and so we're going to continue to provide those
[0:21:40] opportunities. The agreement that you have is for a one calendar year and it is
[0:21:47] before you for consideration, Mr. Castleton is in the audience if you have any really hard
[0:21:55] questions for him, but I'll stand for any questions that you may have.
[0:21:59] Thank you. Any questions for Travis on this? Or Bruce for that matter?
[0:22:07] I don't know. Travis just wants to go over maybe the exceptions because there's two areas
[0:22:12] of exceptions in the contract just for the general public to hear. Do you want to...
[0:22:18] I just threw you on there and there's an entire agreement here the two exceptions water disputes and then urban renewal matters
[0:22:25] Yeah, so we do have legal counsel for those two matters number one the urban renewal agency is a independent entity
[0:22:32] It's often viewed as an extension of the city
[0:22:36] They do and have hired their own legal counsel in the past
[0:22:41] The city attorney's office was representing the agency that switch was made
[0:22:46] probably about four years ago and that will continue down that path and then
[0:22:51] obviously water law is becoming much more complex and will continue to utilize
[0:22:56] Martin law for for those types of services. Thank you. Good good call. Any other
[0:23:03] comments or questions? I would just like to publicly say that I've been
[0:23:07] really pleased with the relationship the advice that
[0:23:12] The law has given us the relationship that we've had and hopefully moving forward.
[0:23:18] So I'm excited for this.
[0:23:20] Yep, I agree.
[0:23:23] Okay.
[0:23:24] I'll make the motion.
[0:23:25] Go ahead, Chris.
[0:23:26] I move that we approve the independent contractor agreement with Bruce Castleton of Castleton Law
[0:23:32] PLCC for city attorney services as defined in Idaho Code Section 50-208A.
[0:23:42] Thank you, Jason Brown.
[0:23:43] I'll second that.
[0:23:44] Thank you.
[0:23:45] Motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Jason Brown
[0:23:48] to approve the independent contractor agreement
[0:23:51] with Bruce Castleton of Castleton Law,
[0:23:53] PLCC for City Attorney Services defined
[0:23:57] in Idaho Code Section 50-208A.
[0:24:01] Any further discussion?
[0:24:03] Amy Roll-Covall, please.
[0:24:06] Vince or Cutler?
[0:24:07] Yes.
[0:24:09] Jerry Volmer?
[0:24:10] Yes.
[0:24:11] Grayson Stone?
[0:24:12] Yes.
[0:24:12] Ruth Pierce, Chris Reed, Craig Hawkins, and Jason Brown.
[0:24:17] Yes.
[0:24:18] Thank you.
[0:24:19] Motion passes 7-0.
[0:24:20] Thank you, Travis, and thank you, Bruce.
[0:24:24] Okay.
[0:24:25] That is all the items under items of consideration.
[0:24:29] Next on the agenda is the time for public input.
[0:24:33] There's anybody in the public that wishes to address City Council.
[0:24:39] Now's your time.
[0:24:41] come down to the podium and state your name and whether you're a resident of
[0:24:45] Twin Falls. Everybody looks at their feet. Okay, um, seeing no one, uh, advisory board
[0:24:53] reports. There's an airport meeting tomorrow at 11 o'clock for those that
[0:24:59] would like to join. Thank you. Anybody? We had a great policeman's award banquet
[0:25:06] on let's see Thursday wasn't very nice it was fun, Chris, Craig. I just want to
[0:25:14] report that ending the citizens police mechanics been really a blast so far
[0:25:20] really was pretty exciting driving the police car and trying to go through an
[0:25:26] obstacle course so it's a really neat program I'd really recommend it to anybody
[0:25:32] to take it. So thank you. Anything from the city manager's office? No? Okay, next on the
[0:25:42] agenda is executive session, executive session under code section 74-2061c to acquire an interest
[0:25:50] in real property which is not owned by a public agency and 74-2061f to communicate with legal
[0:25:59] Council for the public agency to discuss the legal ramifications, excuse me, of and legal
[0:26:07] options for pending litigation or controversies not yet being litigated, but imminently likely
[0:26:14] to be litigated. The mere presence of legal counsel and executive session does not satisfy
[0:26:19] this requirement. So moved. Thank you. Do I have a second?
[0:26:25] Second.
[0:26:26] Motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Spencer Cutler to move into Executive Session under
[0:26:33] 742061C and F. Amy Rolkow, please.
[0:26:44] Grace and Stone?
[0:26:45] Yes.
[0:26:49] Terry Vollner?
[0:26:50] Yes.
[0:26:51] Ruth Pierce?
[0:26:52] Yes.
[0:26:53] Chris Reed?
[0:26:54] Yes.
[0:26:55] Craig Hawkins?
[0:26:56] Yes.
[0:26:57] Jason Brown?
[0:26:58] Yes.
[0:26:59] Spencer Cutler?
[0:27:00] Yes.
[0:27:01] Thank you.
[0:27:02] We will adjourn out of executive session and will not be coming back to chambers tonight.
[0:27:08] Thank you.
