Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2024-03-04, recording 1 (started 17:01)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2024-03-04/

[0:00:47] Thank you. Next item on the agenda is a proclamation. This is Make a Wish Idaho April 2024. Whereas
[0:00:57] on April 29th 1980, Department of Public Safety Officers and members of the community in Phoenix,
[0:01:04] Arizona came together to grant a wish, the wish of Chris Grecius, a seven-year-old boy about a
[0:01:12] leukemia who wished to be a police officer.
[0:01:15] Whereas Chris's wish inspired six of the people involved to form a foundation that would grant
[0:01:21] life-changing wishes for other children with critical illnesses.
[0:01:25] The organization known as Make a Wish has since granted more than 520,000 wishes worldwide
[0:01:32] operating in every community in the US and in nearly 50 countries worldwide.
[0:01:38] Where as maker wish Idaho was founded in 1986 and has granted more than 2,000 wishes
[0:01:44] that deliver hope and joy back into the lives of children with critical illnesses in Idaho,
[0:01:51] whereas research has shown that wishes can improve a child's quality of life and produce
[0:01:57] better health outcomes.
[0:01:59] When a wish is granted, a child replaces fear with the confidence anxiety, with confidence
[0:02:05] anxiety with hope and sadness with joy. Therefore, I, Ruth Pierce, Mayor of the City of Twin Falls,
[0:02:12] do hereby proclaim the month of April 2024 will be celebrated as World Wish Month in recognition
[0:02:22] of the anniversary of Chris's wish that inspired the founding of Make a Wish and subsequently Make
[0:02:29] a wish Idaho and the global wish granting movement and ask our citizens to keep the children battling
[0:02:35] critical illnesses throughout the state close to their hearts. Do you have anybody from make
[0:02:41] a wish here tonight? Okay. Thank you. Okay. Next item on the agenda is the consent calendar.
[0:02:51] Council wishes. Move to approve the consent calendar.
[0:02:55] Thank you. Motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Craig Hawkins to approve the consent
[0:03:01] calendar as written. Amy Roek, I'll vote please.
[0:03:05] Ruth Pierce? Yes. Chris Reed? Yes. Craig Hawkins? Yes. Jason Brown? Yes. Spencer
[0:03:16] Cutler? Yes. Sherry Vomer? Yes. And Grayson Stone. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 7-0.
[0:03:24] Okay, next we move to the under items of consideration.
[0:03:30] The first item is an action item to consider a request to confirm the mayor's reappointment
[0:03:37] of Ashley Squires and Michael Maccalfe and the appointment of Olivia Meyer to serve on
[0:03:42] the Parks and Rec Commission and we have Wendy Davis, our Parks and Rec Director.
[0:03:47] Welcome, Wendy.
[0:03:48] Good evening, ma'am Council.
[0:03:50] It's my pleasure to be here this evening to recommend, I guess, on behalf of the Mayor,
[0:03:58] recommend the reappointment of Ashley Squires and Michael Metcalf and the appointment of Olivia
[0:04:04] Myers to serve on the Parks and Recreation Commission and I believe that they could stand
[0:04:12] up for a fish.
[0:04:16] There you are.
[0:04:17] Look at that.
[0:04:18] Awesome.
[0:04:19] Awesome.
[0:04:21] So we can talk a little bit about the process.
[0:04:23] So Ashley and Michael have served their three-year terms and did a great job on the commission
[0:04:31] and expressed an interest in serving a second three-year term.
[0:04:35] And so we confirmed that with those two and then we had a vacancy, we met, I think we had
[0:04:42] five applications.
[0:04:43] Actually, I think we had six, but we interviewed five.
[0:04:47] Sherry and the Parks and Recreation Commission leaves on and the Parks and Recreation Commission
[0:04:54] chairperson Kirk.
[0:04:55] Melton and I interviewed the five applicants and chose the person we thought would be the
[0:05:02] best fit and presented that to the mayor who I think agreed with that and recommends
[0:05:10] appointment.
[0:05:11] Yes, thank you.
[0:05:12] Sherry Wilmer.
[0:05:13] to confirm the mayor's reappointment of Ashley Squires and an appointment of Olivia Meyer
[0:05:28] to serve as on the Parks and Recreation Commission.
[0:05:31] Thank you, Grace and Stone.
[0:05:33] I'll second.
[0:05:34] Thank you. Motion by Sherry Vomers, seconded by Grace and Stone to approve the reappointment
[0:05:40] of Ashley Squires and Michael Metcalf in the appointment of Olivia Meyer to serve on the
[0:05:46] Parks and Recreation Commission.
[0:05:48] Any discussion?
[0:05:50] Amy Roll call vote please.
[0:05:52] Chris Reed.
[0:05:54] Yes.
[0:05:55] Ray Cawkins.
[0:05:56] Yes.
[0:05:57] Jason Brown.
[0:05:58] Yes.
[0:05:59] Spencer Cutler.
[0:06:00] Yes.
[0:06:01] Grayson Stone.
[0:06:02] Yes.
[0:06:03] Terri Bulmer.
[0:06:04] Yes.
[0:06:05] And Ruth Pierce.
[0:06:06] Yes.
[0:06:07] Thank you.
[0:06:08] Motion passes seven to zero.
[0:06:09] Thank you, Wendy.
[0:06:10] And welcome everyone.
[0:06:12] Thank you.
[0:06:13] Next is also an action item.
[0:06:15] A request to confirm the mayor's appointment of Danielle Titus.
[0:06:19] Kelly Hurgassell, Susan Petrosselli, Tiffany Zimmerman Mills, and the
[0:06:23] re-importment appointment of Courtney Campbell to the Planning and Zoning
[0:06:27] Commission. And we have Jonathan Spendlove, our Planning and Zoning Director.
[0:06:32] Welcome, Jonathan. Thank you, Mayor, members of the Council.
[0:06:35] Very similar process was held for the Planning and Zoning Commission,
[0:06:38] except we don't have a liaison that's basically the mayor
[0:06:42] as liaison to the Planning and Zoning Commission. We've had one recent
[0:06:46] They can see with the craison. We had two others that turned out one had a reassignment for work and was
[0:06:52] there for resign basically during the process as we had a conversation. So we have quite a turnover
[0:06:58] at the planning and zoning commission. There's seven members and there will be four new one reappointment.
[0:07:03] Courtney is finishing her first partial term. It won't go through the bios of everybody but we did
[0:07:08] have around 13 applications. A couple people were not eligible as they didn't live within the boundaries
[0:07:15] that we govern. And we had, I believe, eight or nine interviews with the mayor over the
[0:07:21] course of an entire day, and these are the ones that rose to the top. They showed a willingness
[0:07:26] to advance the comprehensive plan and to balance the private property rights decisions with
[0:07:31] the applications that we get. The committee was the mayor, our current chairperson, Craig
[0:07:37] Kelly, and myself. That group, up with these people, are four people with the...
[0:07:47] questions for Jonathan. I can go through everybody as they are all here. Maybe just read their names
[0:07:54] again and maybe they can stand. So Danielle Titus right here. She's a returning commissioner from a
[0:08:00] few years ago at Kelly Hurdesell who's sitting next to Danielle. Who's in Petruzelli. She's our
[0:08:06] area of impact appointment. We have one on the commission. Tiffany's and Munn Wills which is in
[0:08:11] the back corner right there. And then Courtney Campbell is over here on the right as a re-input.
[0:08:16] Thank you. Well, it was a fun process. A long day, but it was fun. I got Jonathan to
[0:08:22] buy lunch. So I feel pretty good about that. Okay, Grayson Stone. Yes, Madam Mayor, I just
[0:08:29] really want to thank all 13 of the applicants that put in for planning and zoning. Having
[0:08:35] that be my first introduction to city government, I know that that board can be very taxing.
[0:08:40] And I appreciate you and Director Spindlove and Commissioner Kelly going through that process.
[0:08:45] That being said, Madam Mayor, if there's no further discussion, I'd like to make a motion
[0:08:50] to confirm the mayoral appointment of Daniel Titus, I'm going to butcher this last name,
[0:08:55] Kelly Hurdessell, Susan Petrizzelli, Tiffany Zimmerman Mills, and the re-employment of
[0:09:01] Ms. Courtney Campbell of the Planning and Zoning Commission.
[0:09:04] Thank you, Chris Reed.
[0:09:05] I'll second.
[0:09:06] Thank you, motion by Grayson Stone, seconded by Chris Reed to confirm the mayor appointment
[0:09:12] of Daniel Titus, Kelly Hergesell, Susan Patrozzelli, Tiffany Zimmerman-Nils, and the re-employment
[0:09:19] of Courtney Campbell to the Planning and Zoning Commission.
[0:09:23] Any further discussion?
[0:09:26] Amy Roek, I'll vote, please.
[0:09:29] Okay.
[0:09:30] Hawkins?
[0:09:31] Yes.
[0:09:32] Jason Brown?
[0:09:33] Yes.
[0:09:34] Spencer Cutler?
[0:09:35] Yes.
[0:09:36] Grace and Stone?
[0:09:37] Yes.
[0:09:38] Jerry Bulmer?
[0:09:39] Yes.
[0:09:40] Ruth Pierce?
[0:09:41] Yes.
[0:09:42] And Chris Reed?
[0:09:43] All of you, be a fun year.
[0:09:48] Okay, next is a presentation,
[0:09:50] a reimbursement of operational expenses
[0:09:53] at the wastewater treatment plant.
[0:09:55] And I believe, yes, we have Nathan Eric,
[0:09:57] Eric's in our environmental manager.
[0:09:59] Welcome, Nathan.
[0:10:03] Thank you, Mayor, Council.
[0:10:04] Appreciate your time tonight.
[0:10:07] Yes, this year, as in the past years,
[0:10:11] we, the wastewater treatment plant
[0:10:14] is the operation of that plant is contracted out to Jacobs Engineering.
[0:10:19] And each year they propose an operational budget and
[0:10:24] this is the presentation is for the fiscal year 2223.
[0:10:27] And we have present with this, Dan Black is the project manager.
[0:10:33] He's been the project manager for about a year and I'd like to,
[0:10:36] I guess turn the time over to him for the presentation.
[0:10:38] Thank you.
[0:10:39] Council.
[0:10:46] Welcome, Dan.
[0:10:47] There's just be a quick update.
[0:10:50] The end of the year closed out.
[0:10:52] We were $111,685 under budget.
[0:10:57] Though, Jacobs will be cutting a check
[0:11:00] and it should be in the mail.
[0:11:01] You guys should be receiving it very shortly.
[0:11:03] Thank you.
[0:11:04] That's exciting.
[0:11:05] Thank you.
[0:11:08] Okay.
[0:11:11] Next item is an action item.
[0:11:13] A request to reallocate $43,328 of fiscal year 2020.
[0:11:20] 24 budgeted wastewater funds to replace the roof of the electrical building at the wastewater
[0:11:25] treatment plant and we have Nathan back.
[0:11:28] Welcome.
[0:11:29] Thank you.
[0:11:30] Yes, so this is also down at the wastewater treatment plant.
[0:11:34] This is for this fiscal year, fiscal year 24.
[0:11:38] We had a project that in our budgeting, when we went to get bids for it, it came out over
[0:11:45] budget.
[0:11:46] So we haven't been able to do it.
[0:11:47] But now that we're about halfway through the fiscal year,
[0:11:49] we have three projects down the plant
[0:11:52] that we were able to complete and that are under budget.
[0:11:55] And so we have excess money from those projects
[0:11:59] in the total of about $43,000 that we would ask to reallocate.
[0:12:04] So we're not asking for any new money.
[0:12:05] We're just asking to move this money.
[0:12:07] It's not going to be used to be able to finish that electrical
[0:12:10] roof if there's any questions.
[0:12:15] Questions for Nathan, Chris Reed.
[0:12:17] Actually, if I can just jump back one real quick
[0:12:21] and just thank Jacobs for their partnership.
[0:12:24] Oh, I have this.
[0:12:25] No, that's perfectly fine.
[0:12:26] It's just every year we seem to go through this,
[0:12:30] and it's a great thing to go through with the reimbursement.
[0:12:32] So thank you for your partnership,
[0:12:34] being great stewards of the systems
[0:12:38] that you were taking care of.
[0:12:39] Thank you.
[0:12:41] Thank you, Chris.
[0:12:43] Let's speak on this.
[0:12:44] You don't have any questions on this one.
[0:12:48] Questions for Nathan, anybody?
[0:12:51] Hey, I'd entertain a motion.
[0:12:54] Mayor Hawkins.
[0:12:57] Thank you.
[0:12:58] I'll go ahead and make a motion to move, reallocate for that $43,328 of FY24 budget to waste water funds to replace the roof of the electrical building.
[0:13:17] We have a second.
[0:13:18] I'll second.
[0:13:20] Thank you.
[0:13:21] Emotion by Craig Hawkins and seconded by Chris Reed to approve the request to reallocate $43,328 of FY24 budgeted waste water funds.
[0:13:32] budgeted waste water funds to replace the roof of the electrical building at
[0:13:37] the treatment plant. Any further discussion? Amy Roll call vote please.
[0:13:43] Jason Brown. Yeah. Spencer Cutler. Yes. Grayson Stone. Yes. Jerry Bomer. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes. Chris Reed. Yes.
[0:13:53] And Craig Hawkins. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 7-0. Thank you, Nathan. Hey, next item on the
[0:14:01] agenda is an action item, a request to approve a bit award in contract to
[0:14:07] summit construction in the amount of $1,525,537 for the FAA Northwest
[0:14:16] Aircraft Apron Rehab Project and authorize the mayor to sign the contract and we
[0:14:23] have our airport manager Bill Carberry. Thank you mayor, good evening council
[0:14:26] members. Amy, if you could put up this on the screen I'll have a couple of quick
[0:14:31] slides to take us through this. I'd like to identify the area of the project with this
[0:14:37] diagram here, the Northwest. Apron is an aircraft tie-down parking area and it's an area that years
[0:14:45] ago, 21 years ago, we did full depth reconstruction and we're looking at a mill and overlay for
[0:14:52] that area now. We don't need to do a full depth reconstruction. So that's the Northwest
[0:14:57] parking apron there and on my next slide we put this out to bid we received two
[0:15:08] bits very close to the engineers estimates I was very encouraged there
[0:15:12] are tight bits and it looks like they're coming in on budget so Summit
[0:15:17] Construction is that is just shown Idaho with Idaho materials and construction
[0:15:21] here in Twin Falls Idaho so often we only get one bid so it's really good to
[0:15:26] see we've got two for this one and it's a very tight bid. So Kent Dantkin is here if you
[0:15:32] want to have any questions after my recommendation, but I would recommend the Council approve the
[0:15:37] request to award the bid in contract to some construction in the amount of $1,525,537.
[0:15:47] Intention upon FAA funding and authorized the mayor assigned me. Happy to answer any questions
[0:15:53] about this project you might have.
[0:15:55] So this is contingent on FAA funding.
[0:15:57] Yes, as we have a match on this one or is that 100%?
[0:16:01] Yeah, thank you.
[0:16:02] Yeah, for the question.
[0:16:03] Yeah, there is a match of 6.25% the days of 100% grants seem to be behind us.
[0:16:08] So we're back to the 6.25% local match that is evenly divided between city and county.
[0:16:14] And we do have that in the budget to pay that match.
[0:16:17] Thank you.
[0:16:18] Chris Reed.
[0:16:19] Bill, thank you for your presentation.
[0:16:20] What would be the timetable for this project?
[0:16:25] still be pending you want to take this one so the schedule on that is
[0:16:33] tricky because we're waiting we have open bids this summer but we've seen
[0:16:45] those sometimes carry over kind of in some new areas there we'll update the
[0:16:59] user I think the biggest impact is to the user so as those start getting legs
[0:17:03] and the grants come in we'll update the users give me any other questions I'd
[0:17:18] entertain a motion from someone Mr. Street I move that we approve a bid an
[0:17:24] an award and contract to summit construction
[0:17:27] in the amount of $1,525,537 for the FAA Northwest aircraft,
[0:17:34] apron, rehabilitation project, and authorize the mayor
[0:17:38] to sign the contract.
[0:17:40] Thank you, Grace and Stone.
[0:17:41] Madam Mayor, I second.
[0:17:43] Thank you.
[0:17:44] Motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Grace and Stone
[0:17:46] to approve the bid, award, and contract
[0:17:50] to sum a construction in the amount of $1,525,537
[0:17:55] for the FAA Northwest A-aircraft apron rehab project
[0:18:00] and authorized the mayor to sign the contract.
[0:18:03] Any discussion?
[0:18:05] Amy Roll call vote please.
[0:18:07] Spencer Cutler.
[0:18:09] Yes.
[0:18:10] Grayson Stone.
[0:18:10] Yes.
[0:18:11] Jerry Volmer.
[0:18:12] Yes.
[0:18:13] Ruth Pierce.
[0:18:14] Yes.
[0:18:15] Chris Reed.
[0:18:16] Yes.
[0:18:17] Craig Hawkins.
[0:18:18] Yes.
[0:18:19] And Jason Brown.
[0:18:20] Yes.
[0:18:21] 7 to 0. Thank you. Hey action item a request to allocate $12,700 from
[0:18:30] contingency funds to supplement encumbered funds from fiscal year 2023 and budgeted
[0:18:37] fiscal year 2024 funds towards an agreement with flock safety for the
[0:18:42] continued use of 12 automated license plate readers ALPR's flock safety Falcon
[0:18:50] cameras, that's a mouthful. We have a lieutenant check gardener with our police
[0:18:55] department. Welcome, Chuck. Here's your mic on by chance. The green button. Lights on.
[0:19:14] Here's your outside voice. Not really. Go ahead. Any questions for Chuck? I'm not. My
[0:21:49] screen's not. Oh, Grayson, are you up? Yeah, okay. Yeah, if there's no discussion on that.
[0:21:56] I don't think so.
[0:21:59] Madam Mayor, I would make a motion to allocate $12,700 from contingency funds to supplement
[0:22:06] the encumbered funds from fiscal year 2023 and budget fiscal year 2024 funds towards an agreement
[0:22:13] with flock safety for the continued use of 12 automated license plate reader ALPR flock
[0:22:19] safety Falcon cameras.
[0:22:22] Chris Reed.
[0:22:23] Second.
[0:22:24] Thank you. I have a motion by Grayson Stone, seconded by Chris Reed to allocate
[0:22:29] contingency funds of $12,700 to supplement fiscal year 23 and fiscal year 24 funds
[0:22:38] towards an agreement with Flock Safety for the continued use of 12 ALPR Flock Safety Falcon cameras.
[0:22:46] Any further discussion?
[0:22:49] Amy Rolkow, please.
[0:22:51] Grace and Stone?
[0:22:53] Yes.
[0:22:54] Perry Wilmer?
[0:22:55] Yes.
[0:22:56] Ruth Pierce?
[0:22:57] Yes.
[0:22:58] Chris Reed?
[0:22:59] Yes.
[0:23:00] Ray Cawkins?
[0:23:01] Yes.
[0:23:02] Jason Brown?
[0:23:05] Yes.
[0:23:06] Spencer Cutler?
[0:23:07] Yes.
[0:23:08] Thank you.
[0:23:09] Motion passes 7-0.
[0:23:10] Thank you, Chuck.
[0:23:14] Okay.
[0:23:15] That is it for items on the agenda.
[0:23:17] Next on the agenda is a time for general public input.
[0:23:21] This is the time for anybody in the audience who wishes to address City Council on an issue not on today's agenda or not related to personnel or personnel related issues.
[0:23:35] If you do, please come down the microphone state whether you're a resident or property owner in the City of Twin Falls and proceed with your input, you will be limited to two minutes.
[0:23:47] We ask that you please remain respectful to anybody in the audience that wishes to address
[0:23:54] counsel tonight.
[0:23:55] Okay.
[0:23:59] See no one advisory board reports from advisory boards.
[0:24:07] This is a holiday week, kind of last week, I guess.
[0:24:11] Travis, do you have anything from city manager's office?
[0:24:17] We don't, I guess.
[0:24:18] Just quickly we continue to track pieces of legislation kind of moving through the process
[0:24:23] very similar to what the Council has instructed us in the past. We continue to track short-term
[0:24:31] rental legislation members of our team going up to testify this week. Also taking a look
[0:24:40] at urban renewal bills and how those are going to be potentially moving forward and impacting
[0:24:46] how we promote and create economic development opportunities. So a lot of work going on at
[0:24:51] legislature they still believe that they're going to be concluded with their
[0:24:54] business sometime towards the end of March. However, every legislator I talk to has
[0:25:01] never stated the calendar year in which they're going to be completed. Because of
[0:25:06] the amount of work that they have short of a journey and then coming back later
[0:25:11] mid-summer they had better be spending a lot of evenings in the in the state
[0:25:16] Okay, so no public hearings tonight.
[0:25:22] Next, we have an executive session under Code Section 74206F to communicate with legal counsel for the public agency to discuss the legal ramifications of and legal options for pending litigation or controversies not yet being litigated,
[0:25:41] imminently likely to be litigated the mere presence of legal counsel at an
[0:25:47] executive session does not satisfy this requirement. So moved. We have a second
[0:25:54] motion by Chris Reed seconded by Craig Hawkins to move into executive session
[0:26:01] under his co-section 74-206F. Amy Rokalvo please.
[0:26:09] Sherry Bulmer. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes. Chris Reed. Yes. Greg Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yeah.
[0:26:16] Spencer Cutler. Yes. And Grayson Stone. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 7-0. So we
[0:26:24] will not be returning to chambers after our executive session and so our
[0:26:29] meeting is adjourned. Thank you everyone.
