Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2023-08-07, recording 1 (started 16:00)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2023-08-07/

[0:00:00] We have seven members present in council chambers.
[0:00:04] First item on the agenda is executive session
[0:00:07] under action item under code section 742061B
[0:00:13] to consider the evaluation dismissal
[0:00:15] or disciplining of or to hear complaints
[0:00:17] or charges brought against public officer,
[0:00:20] employees, staff member, or individual agent
[0:00:22] or public school student, council wishes.
[0:00:27] Thank you motion by Alex Koval, seconded by Nikki Boyd to approve moving into executive
[0:00:37] session under 742061B.
[0:00:41] Amy Roll call vote please.
[0:00:44] Ruth Pierce.
[0:00:45] Yes.
[0:00:46] Chris Reed.
[0:00:47] Yes.
[0:00:48] Thank you Boyd.
[0:00:49] Yes.
[0:00:50] Great Conkins.
[0:00:51] Yes.
[0:00:52] Jason Smith.
[0:00:53] Yes.
[0:00:54] Yes.
[0:00:55] Wow.
[0:00:56] I changed your name.
[0:00:57] That's okay.
[0:00:58] It's common.
[0:00:59] and Brown. Motion passes seven to zero. Oh you didn't? Okay.
[0:01:08] We're not totally confused. Alex Smith. Go ahead. Spencer Cutler. Yes. And Alex Koval.
[0:01:17] Yes. Thank you. Motion passes seven to zero. So we will be moving into executive session.
[0:01:24] We will be coming back when we are through and moving into regular session.
[0:01:30] We will not make any decisions while we're in there and we will be back when we get back.
[0:01:36] Thank you.
[0:01:37] I know you feel like you're in a good evening ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the August
[0:05:04] 7th, 2023 City Council meeting.
[0:05:07] I want to confirm we have a quorum.
[0:05:08] We have six members present in chambers and Councilwoman Kaval is excused.
[0:05:15] So we met at four o'clock and went into executive session
[0:05:18] and we're just coming back out.
[0:05:20] So we'll move on to the regular agenda.
[0:05:24] First item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance.
[0:05:26] If you wish to join me, please rise.
[0:05:46] Thank you.
[0:05:49] We have no proclamations tonight.
[0:05:51] So next on the agenda is the consent calendar.
[0:05:54] Council wishes.
[0:05:56] Move to approve the consent calendar.
[0:05:58] Thank you, motion by Chris Reed,
[0:06:00] seconded by Craig Hawkins to approve the consent calendar as written. Amy Roll call
[0:06:06] vote please. Yes. Thank you Boyd. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Thank you motion passes six to zero. So if you were here for
[0:06:25] PZ-230028 zoning district for the Hispanic Heritage Festival or donation of a tree and
[0:06:36] plaque at Vista Bonita Park, those have all been approved.
[0:06:40] So moving on to under items of consideration, the first item is action item.
[0:06:49] Consider a request from people for pets to waive vehicle access fees at Shoshone Falls
[0:06:54] Park for the 12th annual pooch splash and we have Mallory Cox from the Twin Falls
[0:07:01] Animal Shelter manager. Come on up Mallory. Sure. I mean you could help her. I
[0:07:17] wanted to thank you all for allowing me to come up and speak in front of you guys.
[0:07:54] First of all, I'm Mallory Cox. I'm the Kennel Manager of the Twin Falls Animal
[0:07:58] Shelter. I've worked there for eight years now so this will be my eighth or
[0:08:03] ninth annual pooch splash that I've attended. I've lost count over the years.
[0:08:06] So, our mission is to take care of these animals and provide them an opportunity for connecting
[0:08:12] with the community and finding safe new homes.
[0:08:16] We know that this requires money, obviously.
[0:08:18] It's not cheap.
[0:08:20] In the month of May, the Twin Falls Animal Prichelter provided temporary housing for 320 cats
[0:08:24] and dogs.
[0:08:26] In the same month, that bill has reached approximately $13,000.
[0:08:30] In the month since, the community has rescued three notable dogs off the street in need
[0:08:37] of immediate care and those bills exceeded the budget per month provided for all the animals
[0:08:42] in our care.
[0:08:43] I say the community rescued because our caring community found these animals that were in need
[0:08:47] and turned to us for support.
[0:08:50] This is what People for Pets does.
[0:08:52] We help the community help the animals.
[0:08:54] Now instead of giving you numbers, I want to talk about some fun stuff.
[0:08:57] The pooch blast is an event where about 100 people and their dogs come to enjoy a day in
[0:09:02] the sun at the beautiful turkeys lake.
[0:09:05] Here we provide a place for the people to come together and bask in the enjoyment of the dog.
[0:09:14] At the event staff provides opportunities to connect with the attendees for the first time
[0:09:19] or the tenth time about what we can do to help them help the animals.
[0:09:24] We provide low-cost microchipping, education about adoption and responsible pet ownership
[0:09:29] and a way for citizens to connect with their community and what we can do together to create
[0:09:33] a safe bridge home for the community's beloved pets.
[0:09:36] What I'm hoping for you today is that the $5 entry fee for vehicles to be waived so that
[0:09:41] the attendees can have the opportunity to put those funds towards our medical fund down at
[0:09:45] the event.
[0:09:46] The fund raising will have about vendors down there, opportunities to purchase food, and
[0:09:53] all that money goes towards the medical fund for caring for about 4,000 animals a year.
[0:09:58] I ask you this because every $5 counts when it comes to helping our animals.
[0:10:02] Thank you.
[0:10:03] Um, do you have any questions? Anybody have any questions for Mallory?
[0:10:10] I do have a question, Mallory.
[0:10:13] Okay. Do you recall how much you raised last year?
[0:10:16] Around $2,000. Okay. Good.
[0:10:18] Good street. This might be a question for Wendy.
[0:10:24] Wendy just walked in. I know I saw her come down the stairs.
[0:10:28] Um, as far as making sure that the individuals who are going to this event,
[0:10:32] If this is approved and it's and it's waived how do we make sure that if I'm just traveling down with my family to see she's shown
[0:10:39] Falls I pay five dollars, but the individuals going this event don't if again if that happens
[0:10:46] So ideally the way I'd like to do it and this is something that we've tried to do before
[0:10:53] But if they've purchased tickets ahead of time and they'll have like their bandanas or they have different things and and we can work it out
[0:11:01] out so that the participants in the pooch splash have something for the ticket
[0:11:06] booth to show that they're getting in, that they're you know we usually just
[0:11:11] tell them to say something but I've been trying to make it a little cleaner so we
[0:11:16] can actually track how many came through and if approved Mallory and I can work
[0:11:22] that out.
[0:11:24] Yeah I guess I'd kind of follow up on what Chris was looking at is looking at
[0:11:29] way that this organization or the toll booth gets the fee so I can so do they
[0:11:40] have to buy a ticket to get down there through through your organization?
[0:11:44] Yes, so we will be having tickets available here in the next couple of weeks
[0:11:48] and those people who purchase their tickets ahead of time will have their
[0:11:52] tickets to be able to present to the booth whoever's manning that to be able to
[0:11:57] Do you have to purchase the ticket before or?
[0:12:00] We don't, but that is something we can work out to get.
[0:12:03] So people who are attended who haven't purchased a ticket
[0:12:06] ahead of time, we can make it so that they have some sort
[0:12:08] of proof that they are attending to the event.
[0:12:11] Yeah, because my concern would be is, hey,
[0:12:13] I'm with this organization I jump in.
[0:12:15] I don't think it's a huge problem.
[0:12:17] It probably won't be a big problem,
[0:12:19] but it is a problem that would exist
[0:12:20] and would have to consider that.
[0:12:23] So if it's something that can get worked out
[0:12:25] that they know, then thanks.
[0:12:31] Yes, Nikki.
[0:12:33] Have you guys ever considered having a sponsor for the parking
[0:12:37] so that I'm just thinking, we charge the city charges
[0:12:45] to get down there, and that's an important asset,
[0:12:48] and those coming through the gate is important money.
[0:12:54] Has any, have you ever had somebody donate to cover all that?
[0:12:58] Or does that get really sticky and confusing?
[0:13:03] Probably not, because historically,
[0:13:07] we've always partnered with this event, the city has.
[0:13:10] Okay.
[0:13:11] So I don't think they've ever been in a position
[0:13:13] where they've had to deal with covering those fees.
[0:13:18] It's not something that couldn't be down in the future.
[0:13:19] You just build it into the ticket price of the event,
[0:13:22] but it's been something that's been, okay, done before.
[0:13:28] Okay, all right, that makes sense.
[0:13:30] Chris, I'll make a motion if we're ready.
[0:13:33] Okay.
[0:13:33] I move that we approve the request from people for pets
[0:13:36] to waive vehicle access fees that should show in Falls Park
[0:13:40] for the 12th annual boot splash.
[0:13:43] I'll second.
[0:13:45] Thank you.
[0:13:46] Most of my Chris reads second by Nicky Boyd
[0:13:48] to approve the request from people for pets
[0:13:51] to waive the vehicle access fees.
[0:13:54] She'll shown to hit my thing for the 12th annual pooch splash.
[0:14:00] Amy Rowe, call vote please.
[0:14:03] Nikki Boyd?
[0:14:04] Yes.
[0:14:05] Greg Hawkins?
[0:14:05] Yes.
[0:14:06] Jason Brown?
[0:14:07] Yes.
[0:14:09] Spencer Cutler?
[0:14:10] Yes.
[0:14:10] Ruth Pierce?
[0:14:11] Yes.
[0:14:11] And Chris Reed?
[0:14:12] Yes.
[0:14:13] Thank you.
[0:14:13] Motion passes 6 to 0.
[0:14:16] Thank you, Mallory.
[0:14:16] Thank you so much.
[0:14:20] OK.
[0:14:22] Next item on the agenda is a presentation, an update to City Council on Ride TFT.
[0:14:29] We have Maxine Duran, our transit coordinator.
[0:14:33] Welcome, Maxine.
[0:14:37] Make sure your mic is on.
[0:14:39] Hello.
[0:14:39] Oh, perfect.
[0:14:41] Out of mayor, members of the City Council, for those who hadn't met me yet, I'm Maxine Duran.
[0:14:47] I'm your new City Transit Coordinator.
[0:14:49] I started on June 20th, just a second here, and I will get this presentation pulled up.
[0:14:54] might have to help me find the play button here. I'm just using Linux. So for those of
[0:15:37] you who are not yet aware, RIDTFT is the name of our new public transit service
[0:15:42] that launched on July 1st. So we wrapped up our first month of operation
[0:15:47] July 31st. So this is just kind of a general overview of our first month of
[0:15:52] operations, some of the feedback that we've had in our numbers, and then of course
[0:15:57] be available for questions at the end. So starting out here, just giving kind of an overview of our
[0:16:06] service, we are a point-to-point on-demand service within Twin Falls City limits. We currently have
[0:16:14] seven vans in operation. We just got our seventh. It's actually being wrapped right now for our
[0:16:18] ride TFT logo. Five of those vans are the standard six-person passenger vans and we have two four
[0:16:26] person ADA wheelchair compliant vans as well.
[0:16:29] It's a $3 standard fare, but we do have a $1 discounted fare for riders with disabilities
[0:16:35] or ages 16 up.
[0:16:37] Children ages 12 and up can ride unaccompanied and then we have service through primarily
[0:16:41] our RIDE TFT app that's available in the Google Play and Apple stores and then we've also
[0:16:46] got our dispatch line which I've included up there.
[0:16:49] For members of the audience, if you'd like to try the QR code listed under the picture
[0:16:53] there, that'll actually take you to our download page,
[0:16:56] shameless plug, please feel free to give it a try.
[0:17:02] Funding for our program came from a $3 million CARES Act grant,
[0:17:07] and then that came through IDO Transportation Department,
[0:17:10] and then we turned around and worked with a company
[0:17:12] called Down Tauner.
[0:17:14] There are paths through our Turnkey service,
[0:17:17] and so they're the ones that operate the day-to-day operations,
[0:17:19] and then my job is to oversee that.
[0:17:23] Downtown has got about 10 years of experience too,
[0:17:25] and so they've partnered with a handful of cities
[0:17:27] around the country.
[0:17:28] So far, I have to say it's a pretty good operating
[0:17:31] relationship, and I think we back the right horse.
[0:17:36] So to give some perspective on our program,
[0:17:39] we have kind of an unofficial sister program
[0:17:42] with Greater Idaho Falls Transit or GIFT.
[0:17:45] They partnered with Downtown as well.
[0:17:48] They started about a year ahead of us.
[0:17:49] They got their funding from the same grant that we did.
[0:17:53] Their first month, they got 2,599 rides, 3,976 passengers.
[0:18:00] This is an apples-to-apples comparison.
[0:18:02] Obviously, Idaho Falls is a little bit bigger than us.
[0:18:05] They advertised very heavily prior to launch of their service.
[0:18:09] Ours, we didn't really do that.
[0:18:11] We kind of went over the word-of-mouth option.
[0:18:14] They have a regional transit authority, one of only two in Idaho.
[0:18:17] They had a public transportation service that was in operation
[0:18:20] and become defunct prior to this.
[0:18:22] And so the population of Idaho Falls generally had a expectation
[0:18:27] of what public transportation should look like
[0:18:28] within the Idaho Falls area.
[0:18:29] So people were ready and waiting.
[0:18:32] And with all that being said, they at the time of their launch
[0:18:36] were the biggest launch month for any of downtown
[0:18:38] or previous projects up to that point.
[0:18:42] So for our launch month, I was on board at June 20th.
[0:18:46] And so I kind of tried to hit the ground running,
[0:18:49] reaching out to different community organizations,
[0:18:52] St. Luke's, Twin Falls County, a handful of different nonprofits in the region, also been
[0:18:58] reaching out to some of the other local transit providers.
[0:19:01] I've had meetings with Mountain Rise, Lincoln County Connections.
[0:19:05] We recently started partnering with Link to be able to accept Link cards that should be
[0:19:08] coming out here in the near future.
[0:19:10] For those of you who don't know, Link is a service that has prepaid cards for riders 60
[0:19:16] and up or with disabilities who are approved through their program.
[0:19:20] And so sometime in the next couple of weeks we should have the ability to accept payment
[0:19:23] through link cards through our happen dispatch lines.
[0:19:27] We have about 30 rides on our first day.
[0:19:30] We expected about 2000 rides for our first month.
[0:19:34] So the real question is how did we do?
[0:19:37] We had 3,251 rides in our first month with a total of 4,338 passengers.
[0:19:43] So we blew our own expectations away and we beat Idaho Falls significantly.
[0:19:49] not a competition, but I think that that shows that if there was a question of whether or
[0:19:54] not demand for public transit existed in Twin Falls, it certainly does, and it's probably
[0:19:58] a lot more than anyone could have expected.
[0:20:01] I think there's a lot of reasons for that that I'm still kind of digging into, and you'll
[0:20:04] probably want to expect an update from me about that in the next few months.
[0:20:09] I would expect Idaho Falls, they're stabilizing around 9,000 rise per month, they'll hit 8,000
[0:20:15] or 9,000 and they'll hit 9,000 for the first time officially this month and they expect
[0:20:20] that that'll most likely be there every month.
[0:20:23] They should rock out around 9,000.
[0:20:26] So we just did almost half of that in our first month and our rate of growth if you look
[0:20:30] at our rise from our first day to our last days, exceptional.
[0:20:36] So I would not be surprised if we hit that 9,000 mark.
[0:20:40] They are doing it about a year in change.
[0:20:42] I would expect we'd probably hit that around 9 or 10 months.
[0:20:46] The next three to six months based on Idaho Falls numbers
[0:20:49] are when we should expect our most significant rates of growth.
[0:20:52] And that's also not accounting for the fact
[0:20:54] that the school year is starting.
[0:20:55] I've been reaching out pretty heavily to college,
[0:20:57] to Southern Idaho and the local school district,
[0:20:59] just to try and make sure that we're getting the word out
[0:21:01] so that people can take our service either to get to class
[0:21:03] or to get to after school programs.
[0:21:05] Right now our average wait time is 12 minutes.
[0:21:08] Though that does spike during certain demand hours, that seventh van that I mentioned we
[0:21:13] got, once that's wrapped and we have a little bit more data coming in from the next, or the
[0:21:18] last couple of weeks, we'll start trying to create shifts for that van that go for those
[0:21:23] demand hours and keep that number around 12 minutes or as low as possible.
[0:21:28] We've had really good feedback from the community.
[0:21:29] Our average score for rider reviews is 4.8 out of 5 stars and our last weekly report that
[0:21:36] I saw was all five star reviews for our drivers and I have to say I've met all the drivers,
[0:21:40] I've actually gotten to drive one of the vans at this point and everyone's very proud both
[0:21:45] from the public and for the drivers.
[0:21:48] The drivers consider it to be a public service, they're happy to be offering it, they're all
[0:21:52] from around here, they all understand what we're trying to do and the demographics that
[0:21:56] we're trying to help the most and I think that they're seeing, you know, as the front
[0:22:00] line of our program they're really seeing who we're helping.
[0:22:07] So I've given you kind of an overview, I'm going to take a minute just to kind of talk
[0:22:11] about the future, what I expect for things going forward.
[0:22:14] I'd have to say estimation conservatively, I'd expect at least 60,000 rides by the end
[0:22:19] of the year, probably about 100,000 at our top, Idaho Falls had 88,000, and I expect
[0:22:25] we'll probably continue to blow their numbers out of the water.
[0:22:28] Now that being the case, we have a two-year pilot program, we have seven vans right now.
[0:22:34] Based on Idaho Falls numbers, we will probably need 14 vans by the end of that two-year pilot
[0:22:39] doubling our fleet in order to keep our wait times as they are and to make sure that we're
[0:22:43] covering the demand as it grows.
[0:22:46] Now, to do this, I have been building partnerships like I mentioned with some different regional
[0:22:50] transit providers.
[0:22:52] I'm trying to build a community pipeline so that the areas around Twin Falls that rely
[0:22:58] on us as the economic core have a means to bring people into the city and then we can take
[0:23:03] it from there.
[0:23:04] But I'm also looking to bring those other groups into the folds so they have the seat
[0:23:07] of the table as we plan, not just for Twin Falls, but for the region going forward.
[0:23:12] Because frankly, I think Twin Falls is the best and only group organization or entity
[0:23:16] that can really make those calls going forward.
[0:23:18] And everyone is looking at us and expecting it.
[0:23:20] So we need to act proactively.
[0:23:24] Another part of my job going forward, we will be finding new funding sources for when our
[0:23:27] CARES grant runs out after two years.
[0:23:29] Now, a good chunk of that will probably come from additional federal funding that will
[0:23:32] be eligible for, going forward, I'm looking to work with business partnerships, setting
[0:23:37] up donation campaigns, et cetera, but realistically, when the time comes, there will be another meeting
[0:23:43] from me coming up to City Council to have that conversation about how we're going to
[0:23:46] pay into this program.
[0:23:48] And again, I think that the numbers back up, that the demand is there, we need to make
[0:23:53] sure that we're acting in a way that plans for the future and not just the numbers that
[0:23:57] I'm showing you today.
[0:23:59] So with that in mind, you should expect probably in the next few months, I'd say by January,
[0:24:05] I will have a more detailed strategic plan that I will bring to you and you'll be able
[0:24:10] to go over that and we can have that conversation.
[0:24:17] Now the last thing that I want to say with that too is as someone who grew up in this region,
[0:24:23] I'm from Richfield, I'm from Lincoln County, I started a college in Southern Idaho and watching
[0:24:30] the need for public transit grow since I was a child, since I was raised here as a teenager,
[0:24:36] as a young adult, watching friends of mine I went to school with who almost got hit by
[0:24:42] cars walking to school every day. I would say the demand has been here for a very long time
[0:24:47] to have this program. And just like we had with our downtown revitalization where we went
[0:24:53] from having a downtown that wasn't necessarily a place that people like to participate to one
[0:24:57] where I can look out the window of City Hall and see every group of person that would represent
[0:25:02] Twin Falls families, teenagers, enjoying the amenities of our downtown and honestly getting
[0:25:07] more foot traffic than the mall. I think it's really important that like we did with the
[0:25:11] downtown project, we keep in mind that public transit is a growing necessity for the City
[0:25:17] of Twin Falls and one that we can't afford to lose. It's one that we can't afford to let
[0:25:23] idle on the line so to speak.
[0:25:26] So I just really want to get that across because I will be coming back and I will have more
[0:25:31] numbers but that's probably going to be the point when I'm asking city council to consider
[0:25:35] additional funding.
[0:25:37] So with that, I'll open it up to questions.
[0:25:41] Any questions for Maxine?
[0:25:46] I just want to say you've done a fabulous job, Maxine, with his program and kudos to you
[0:25:51] and Mandy who it's been her baby for a long time. I've heard nothing but great
[0:25:58] things from the community, great emails, touching stories for people that were
[0:26:03] homebound that can now get out so I really appreciate all your hard work.
[0:26:08] Great numbers, Chris Reed. Yeah, thank you what the mayor said. Just a quick question,
[0:26:14] the $3 standard fare, is that per rider or per ride? So if group of individuals are
[0:26:20] going the three dollars per person or for the trip itself.
[0:26:25] Yeah, so it's three dollars per ride per party.
[0:26:28] So up to a group of six, which is the max we can fit
[0:26:30] in one of our vans, it would be three dollars.
[0:26:32] The other question I get related to that is,
[0:26:35] if I have someone in my party who qualifies
[0:26:37] for the discount and I have people that don't,
[0:26:39] which fare do we get?
[0:26:41] It's based on who calls the ride.
[0:26:43] So if you have someone in your party who qualifies
[0:26:45] for the discount, I would say go ahead
[0:26:46] and just have them call the ride, you'll get it for a dollar.
[0:26:48] Got it.
[0:26:49] Thank you.
[0:26:51] Any other questions for Maxine comments. Hey, thank you very much
[0:26:57] Hey next on the agenda is an action item a
[0:27:05] Request to authorize these reserves to purchase police vehicles in the amount of
[0:27:11] 291
[0:27:12] $264 and 50 cents and we have Gretchen Scott our deputy city manager
[0:27:18] Welcome, thank you mayor and good evening council
[0:27:21] I just wanted to start by acknowledging that this request is unusual and it is entirely
[0:27:29] based on some of the things that we have been talking to you about over the last couple of
[0:27:33] weeks as we've been presenting the budget.
[0:27:38] The operating environment for purchasing vehicles, fleet vehicles, is changed dramatically and
[0:27:46] we're bringing this request for your consideration tonight in order to try to get ahead of what's
[0:27:50] happening and in order to be responsive to the environment we find ourselves in, which
[0:27:55] is very consistent with the budget message we've been sharing, that we need to be able
[0:28:00] to respond to what our current operating environment is, that we're trying to put our team first.
[0:28:06] So let me talk about how we have not been able to accomplish that goal in the last two current,
[0:28:12] the current fiscal year and the fiscal year prior to that.
[0:28:16] So there's been some unique influences to the purchasing environment right now for fleet
[0:28:21] vehicles. Some of those I talked to you about, there have been restrictions in
[0:28:26] manufacturing, labor shortages, cargo ship delays, micro processing chip shortages,
[0:28:32] which seems to be one of the most important factors right now. So the cars
[0:28:36] are built but they can't operate because so much of it is computerized now and
[0:28:40] without those chips they can't send them out for sale. So in the last couple of
[0:28:49] years, you've had a variety of presentations of budget requests come before you. The
[0:28:53] street department has come before you asking to
[0:28:56] purchase things that have been delayed by two years. In January, I believe it was
[0:29:03] January when we came forward with the fire truck purchase and we talked to you
[0:29:06] about the production timeline for that purchase is two years out. There are just
[0:29:11] a lot of delays to the system. So as we try to figure out how we're going to
[0:29:17] approach that. When we entered the current fiscal year we were optimistic
[0:29:21] that we'd be ahead of it and we'd be able to purchase what was budgeted in
[0:29:25] the current fiscal year last October when the purchasing window opened. The
[0:29:31] problem is that it opened about 60 days prior to the start of our fiscal year.
[0:29:37] So everything that we had budgeted for the current fiscal year was opened and up
[0:29:43] for sale and then closed prior to us being allocated the funds.
[0:29:48] So we sat for a year with the opportunity to buy vehicles and not any inventory to purchase
[0:29:55] from.
[0:29:56] The same thing had happened, a similar thing had happened, the prior fiscal year, fiscal
[0:30:01] year 22.
[0:30:03] We had four vehicles total budgeted, two were pickups which we were able to get, two were
[0:30:08] cars.
[0:30:09] The cars we placed the order for in the window because it had opened an appropriate time frame.
[0:30:14] the contracts were canceled.
[0:30:17] So once those contracts were canceled,
[0:30:20] the funds that we had encumbered,
[0:30:22] then now go back into reserves.
[0:30:25] So in short, what we are really trying to do
[0:30:29] is to request authorization essentially to catch up,
[0:30:33] purchase the vehicles that we need
[0:30:35] in order to make sure our fleet rotation schedule
[0:30:37] is operating the way that it should.
[0:30:40] The funds that are budgeted in fiscal year 24
[0:30:42] will be used to buy fiscal, sorry,
[0:30:45] manufacturing year 25 vehicles. So those will still continue to move forward, it'll
[0:30:49] still continue to use the funds appropriately in the way that the budget
[0:30:53] cycles are meant. But what we're trying to do is get ahead of the purchasing window.
[0:30:58] Our fleet manager, Norm, is here tonight. He will help answer any questions that you
[0:31:04] have. I have printed the state bid representatives. The dealership that has
[0:31:14] the state bid and contract. We have his email where he outlines all of the problems and delays
[0:31:20] that he's facing and Norm can also answer those because he's in regular contact with all of
[0:31:26] the major city fleet managers here in Idaho. So essentially, patrol vehicles is where this
[0:31:37] has had the biggest impact for us. As we considered this request, we made sure that we looked
[0:31:43] at the inventory of both public works, medium and large-duty trucks, to make sure that what
[0:31:49] we were bringing forward was what we would need in order to equip our employees through
[0:31:55] conversations, norm believes, that he'll be able to get to the medium and heavy-duty
[0:31:59] trucks that he needs.
[0:32:02] So what we are asking for is for funding for reserves to purchase one-ford interceptor and
[0:32:10] the outfitting costs that will total from fiscal year 22, that will total 64,427 and the
[0:32:17] 50 cents, and then essentially to advance on four for interceptors at the purchase cost
[0:32:26] of $45,000 and one animal control truck, which is an F-250 for $46,837. Those six vehicles
[0:32:37] or what we are asking to purchase from reserves.
[0:32:40] The current fiscal year that we are finishing
[0:32:44] on September 30th, we still have funding for four cars.
[0:32:49] The thing we don't know, it can't guarantee,
[0:32:52] is that all of the cars that we need will be available,
[0:32:55] even if you authorize the money for us.
[0:32:58] But if we don't have the money,
[0:32:59] we know that we can't replace the vehicles
[0:33:02] that are starting to fail.
[0:33:06] The total request then from reserves are $291,264.50.
[0:33:15] I know this is a little interlaced.
[0:33:18] What questions can we answer for you?
[0:33:23] So basically you're saying based up your staff report
[0:33:28] that we're looking at, let me find your report,
[0:33:36] 64,427.50 for the 22 interceptor or interceptors at 45,000 apiece and one animal control vehicle
[0:33:49] and that's where you get the 291,000.
[0:33:51] That's correct.
[0:33:55] Okay.
[0:33:56] Other questions?
[0:33:57] Council questions?
[0:33:59] Chris?
[0:34:00] I don't have a question.
[0:34:01] I was going to make a motion on this, Jason.
[0:34:02] No, go ahead.
[0:34:03] I did.
[0:34:04] My question was pretty much answered.
[0:34:06] Okay.
[0:34:07] Here's a question.
[0:34:08] Go ahead.
[0:34:09] move that we authorize the use of reserves
[0:34:12] to purchase police vehicles,
[0:34:15] sound like there was one pickup truck,
[0:34:17] and I guess, animal controls and police vehicles,
[0:34:19] and the amount of $291,264.50.
[0:34:24] Jason Brown.
[0:34:25] I'll second.
[0:34:26] Thank you.
[0:34:27] Motion by Christopher Reed, second by Jason Brown,
[0:34:30] to approve the, to authorize the use of reserve funds
[0:34:34] to purchase police vehicles in the amount of $291,264.50.
[0:34:41] Any further discussion?
[0:34:43] Amy Roll call vote please.
[0:34:45] Craig Hawkins.
[0:34:47] Yes.
[0:34:48] Jason Brown.
[0:34:49] Yes.
[0:34:50] Senator Cutler.
[0:34:51] Yes.
[0:34:52] Chris Reed.
[0:34:53] Yes.
[0:34:54] Thank you Boyd.
[0:34:56] Yes.
[0:34:57] Motion passes six to zero.
[0:34:58] Thank you.
[0:34:59] Thank you.
[0:35:00] Gretchen.
[0:35:02] Okay.
[0:35:03] Next item on the agenda is an action item, an adoption of our preliminary fiscal year 2324 budget.
[0:35:13] Budget and we have Travis Rothwiler our city manager. Welcome Travis. Thank you, Madam Mayor members of the council, so
[0:35:23] Been quite a process
[0:35:26] And I hope that through this process that we've been able to go through you've been able to
[0:35:32] enjoy it
[0:35:33] the many presentations by
[0:35:36] The members of the team that help create the budget
[0:35:40] And who says budgeting can't be fun, right?
[0:35:43] But what I really, really appreciated was the commitment, the level of enthusiasm, and the
[0:35:50] creativity that individuals brought forward from the very beginning of the process.
[0:35:54] And that process for us starts shortly after the first of the year where we formed the long-term
[0:36:01] planning team, which is one of our committees in the city that spans all levels of our organization.
[0:36:12] it really applies our One City concept where individuals bring knowledge to the table about
[0:36:18] their particular department and their particular need.
[0:36:21] Those are vetted, those are discussed, and throughout an entire process we come together,
[0:36:26] we balance collectively, and then after that we make that presentation.
[0:36:31] And those individuals that help create this budget for the fiscal year, for the ones that
[0:36:36] came and made their presentations, and certainly that's not all that were involved in the process
[0:36:41] but I think that they've done a great job.
[0:36:44] The unfortunate part now is,
[0:36:46] it's like the fun is over and now you get to see me.
[0:36:49] So I'm the guy that's going to be talking
[0:36:52] about the budget over the course of the next three weeks
[0:36:54] and really that is including tonight,
[0:36:57] three more presentations as we move forward.
[0:37:00] So we've shared the overarching budget strategies.
[0:37:04] These are the guide posts that we use
[0:37:08] to create a stable, sustainable,
[0:37:10] and nimble budget that allows us to adapt to a rapidly changing environment.
[0:37:15] I think the last item that was before the City Council reflects that constant level of thought
[0:37:22] and effort going into adopting and adapting new processes to be able to find and do something
[0:37:29] as simple as acquire lease vehicles, where we had to take a look and we had to align up
[0:37:35] are funding to match very, very tight windows, because of a scarce resource, and that is just
[0:37:43] one of the many examples that we have inside of the City of Twin Falls where members of
[0:37:47] our team are being nimble and moving forward. We're obviously wanting to be sensitive to
[0:37:52] our operating environment. We know that housing starts are down. We know that housing costs are
[0:37:57] up. We know that property taxes, interest rates, the price of a home all go into helping define
[0:38:05] affordability. It's a directly tied to the City's strategic plan and as we have
[0:38:12] shared with you that strategic plan will go through a review later this year in
[0:38:18] which in hopes by the creation of fiscal year 25 we're going to be in a space
[0:38:23] that we can be validating the strategic planning goals and objectives. We
[0:38:28] unapologetically want to put our team first. We recognize that the labor market
[0:38:33] is tight, and that acquiring and having good talent around us is incredibly beneficial.
[0:38:41] We want to make sure that we balance available reserves and we maximize utility rates.
[0:38:49] So these are the guiding sections of the Idaho Code.
[0:38:53] In addition to that, we also use best practices recommended by the Government Finance Officers
[0:39:01] Association or GFOA.
[0:39:03] In addition to that, we're going to use a whole series of economic indicators and probably
[0:39:09] one of the most important things that we look at is the rapid level of growth that the city
[0:39:15] of Twin Falls is experiencing over the course of just the last three years.
[0:39:20] We estimate that the city of Twin Falls is now over 56,000 people and that would reflect
[0:39:26] an 8.32% growth rate.
[0:39:28] And what's interesting about our growth rate is we know that the City of Twin Falls is not the only community in the region experiencing rapid growth.
[0:39:38] And what we do know is that many of those individuals come to the City of Twin Falls on a daily basis where they are buying goods, they are buying services, they are engaging in commerce and activities.
[0:39:54] And that is paid for by the property tax payers of the city of Twin Falls.
[0:40:00] In fact, what's interesting if you take a look at the retail sales per capita based upon 2017 numbers at $28,871, the income per capita is less than.
[0:40:15] And when you take a look at per capita retail sales in 2017, Jonathan's been left has done a lot of great work in this area.
[0:40:23] and he can show you that that number is nearly twice as large as the statewide average.
[0:40:29] We totally validates that the city of Twin Falls' population grows on a daily basis,
[0:40:36] and the team has the obligation to provide the services to those.
[0:40:42] We look at the median home as we talked about.
[0:40:44] We also look at unemployment rate, and we know that at 3%, we're still considered to
[0:40:48] be fully employed.
[0:40:51] So we've shared a lot of these things.
[0:40:53] We've talked about the cost of housing and how it's escalated since 2019, really.
[0:40:59] The median home value inside of the City of Twin Falls has almost tripled since 2012.
[0:41:06] We talk about cost and growth and population and all of those things that cause impact
[0:41:14] on how we move forward.
[0:41:17] And we want to be a value-based organization where we're focusing on becoming high-performing
[0:41:22] and we're governed by leadership philosophies and established values created by the organization.
[0:41:29] So all of that in process is rolled into, I think it's 279 pages this year, of a budgetary
[0:41:37] document that really is more than a bunch of Excel spreadsheets, it's words that we want
[0:41:43] to fully describe how we're making expenditures,
[0:41:46] its pictures and graphs, and then obviously the numbers.
[0:41:51] So one of the things that we shared at the state of the city
[0:41:54] and as numbers continue to evolve is
[0:41:57] that we have some updated numbers from the county.
[0:42:00] And one of the things that we have been sharing
[0:42:02] over the course of the last several weeks is we believe
[0:42:06] that that tax rate was going to be flat.
[0:42:09] However, based upon new valuations received
[0:42:12] from the county, we're now projecting that tax rate
[0:42:15] isn't going to be even lower than what it was last year.
[0:42:18] We believe it will decrease by about $0.7 per $1,000
[0:42:22] of taxable value inside of the city of Twin Falls.
[0:42:26] Now, does that mean that everyone's
[0:42:27] going to see property tax relief as a result of our work?
[0:42:30] Maybe not.
[0:42:31] Because the tax rate is a simple multiplier.
[0:42:34] That multiplier is applied to the growth
[0:42:37] and the value of the property less the homeowner's exemption.
[0:42:42] So the answer is maybe.
[0:42:44] But what we do know is that with the work of the Idaho
[0:42:47] legislature and how they are going to use sales tax dollars
[0:42:52] as replacement revenue, we do believe that everybody
[0:42:56] inside of our community will receive
[0:42:58] some form of property tax relief.
[0:43:01] And that the city of Twin Falls will receive that
[0:43:03] in the form of replacement revenue.
[0:43:05] So while we're made whole, the citizens can benefit
[0:43:08] from the growth that has been experienced
[0:43:10] inside of the state property tax, is that tax that nobody loves to pay because we often
[0:43:19] pay it in two big chunks.
[0:43:23] And so we want to be very, very sensitive as to what that looks like.
[0:43:27] And you can see what we're doing, where it's 90% of the new construction, 80% of the urban
[0:43:32] renewal areas, and 1% of the foregone revenue.
[0:43:37] And while we can illustrate that the municipal cost index has rapidly increased over the
[0:43:42] last few years, and we've kept pace, we do need to raise rates in both water and sewer
[0:43:49] this year at two and a half percent.
[0:43:52] And we can show what that impact looks like in just a minute.
[0:43:55] But we are projecting no increase for sanitation.
[0:44:01] So this is the slide.
[0:44:02] This is the last page of the book, the conclusion, the thing that everyone wants to know, and
[0:44:09] how much more is it going to cost me inside of the City of Twin Falls next year, as opposed
[0:44:15] to this year.
[0:44:16] We believe that when you take a look at the totality of a median home and how it is appreciated,
[0:44:22] if you take a look at the median consumer of water and sewer services inside of the community,
[0:44:30] We believe that median customer, if they did exist, would pay about $4.37 more per month
[0:44:39] next year under this budget than what they would in prior years.
[0:44:44] However, what's not reflected here is the property tax relief that is provided through
[0:44:51] the sales tax mechanism that I talked about.
[0:44:54] So the IDO tax commission is still working through that process.
[0:44:58] And right now they are providing some general parameters where they believe that the average
[0:45:04] Idahoan will see property tax relief somewhere between 9 and 13%.
[0:45:09] And it's all going to depend upon tax value, growth of accounting, and all of that process
[0:45:16] is going to be handled by the county officials for the enabling resolution and not by the
[0:45:23] cities.
[0:45:26] Any questions on that?
[0:45:27] Looks like we're good, all right?
[0:45:32] So this is a reflection of how the city's total taxable value has increased over the last
[0:45:40] decade and you can see that the growth of the city of Twin Falls
[0:45:47] over the course of the last two years at
[0:45:51] 2.143 billion is
[0:45:54] almost equal to the total value of our community in
[0:45:58] in 2013. So I mean that's a moment where you have to pause to reflect on the
[0:46:09] rapid appreciation of property values and growth that we've experienced inside
[0:46:13] of the City of Twin Falls. And what is important to note is that it excludes
[0:46:18] five hundred and ten million dollars of value inside of two urban renewal areas,
[0:46:25] is the one supporting Cliff Bar and the one supporting Chubani.
[0:46:31] The property, the urban renewal area that the council
[0:46:34] in partnership with the urban renewal agency
[0:46:37] created for the Orchard Every New East project
[0:46:40] is not reflected as a value and it will be stood up.
[0:46:44] And then also the good work that the agency's doing
[0:46:46] to create the old town district is also not reflected
[0:46:50] in that $510 million value.
[0:46:55] So when you add the two of them together,
[0:46:57] the total value of the city of Twin Falls
[0:47:00] approaches nearly $6.7 billion.
[0:47:06] And that's a B, Mayor.
[0:47:10] It was very cute.
[0:47:13] Thank you.
[0:47:13] For those of you who are at the state of the city,
[0:47:15] that's picked up that.
[0:47:16] Maybe too soon.
[0:47:20] When you take a look at the tax rate
[0:47:21] over a period of time, I think that it reflects the work
[0:47:24] that the city council has done,
[0:47:25] but it also reflects the growth of the community
[0:47:29] While we can't necessarily claim credit entirely for the decline in the property tax rate, we
[0:47:35] do control the spending, which is one of the products associated with that.
[0:47:40] And there's two new construction values here that are both illustrated in green.
[0:47:45] One is the customary growth of the community at $116 million.
[0:47:49] It is the largest new construction inside of our community.
[0:47:55] Then you'll notice the one for $170.7 million
[0:47:58] that is result of the closure of the urban renewal area,
[0:48:02] 4-1 and 4-1 amended.
[0:48:10] One of the questions that we often get asked is,
[0:48:13] well, how does my property tax load compare
[0:48:16] to other communities of similar size?
[0:48:19] And this is probably the best reflection.
[0:48:21] It's not today.
[0:48:23] It's not current.
[0:48:25] Every major city and county,
[0:48:28] well, every county and everybody's going through their budgeting process right now.
[0:48:33] And so what we do is we do a one year look back where we apply the median home value as
[0:48:39] of January of 2022, the tax rate that was applied for the prior fiscal year, which was
[0:48:46] 23.
[0:48:47] And then you take a look at the tax rate.
[0:48:48] And so right now the median home inside the city of Twin Falls pays about $1,043 in city
[0:48:55] property taxes.
[0:48:57] So a couple of notes.
[0:48:58] Number one, a lot of people will be taking a look at the property tax bill and they say
[0:49:01] but I pay more and we will say yes, yes, but this is just that city portion.
[0:49:07] It's the portion that we can control.
[0:49:09] We don't have control over the tax rates that are imposed by the other taxing entities including
[0:49:15] the College of Southern Idaho, the Twin Falls School District and Twin Falls County.
[0:49:22] This is our effort.
[0:49:24] This is our tax rate.
[0:49:25] And this is how we compare to those other cities.
[0:49:28] And you can see that we are among the lowest in the state.
[0:49:33] And you'll also notice that there are some cities that are missing.
[0:49:38] Why do we exclude Meridian?
[0:49:39] Why do we exclude Boise?
[0:49:41] And why have we begun to exclude NAPA?
[0:49:45] So for Meridian and for Boise, both of them,
[0:49:51] their highway systems, their roadway systems
[0:49:53] are covered under the Ada Highway County Highway District.
[0:49:58] And that is responsible for all of the roads.
[0:50:01] And so the cost of road maintenance and construction
[0:50:04] is not included in any of those city's budgets.
[0:50:06] It's an independent entity.
[0:50:08] And then recently, the city of Napa
[0:50:11] chose to work out a relationship with the Napa Rural Fire
[0:50:15] District in which now fire services are offered by the Napa
[0:50:19] Rural Fire District and no longer by the city of Napa.
[0:50:22] So those are why they're excluded because we want to try to create as close to an apples-to-apples comparison as we could.
[0:50:29] What I can tell you is that you are if you were comparing apples to oranges here,
[0:50:33] what you would see is that those tax rates would be more than the city of Twin Falls is right.
[0:50:41] We want to take a look at the budget in two major parts.
[0:50:49] One is going to be the property tax funds or the government funds.
[0:50:53] funds, there's going to be the enterprise funds, then we also break that down. The five broad
[0:50:57] categories, personnel operations, capital debt service and transfers. You'll notice that personnel
[0:51:03] is by far the single largest cost that we have and it makes sense. The services that we offer
[0:51:10] are offered by members of our talented team and while we continue to look at AI and we try to look
[0:51:16] at efficiencies and how can technology benefit us. The services that we offer are still offered
[0:51:23] by the talents of human hands and human ingenuity and we have 328 employees inside of this budget.
[0:51:31] You can see the individual positions that we've increased but also in the spirit of one city.
[0:51:36] We've removed a position and that was a building inspector position and we spent some time talking
[0:51:42] about that. The cost of operation and maintenance continues to increase as we have all experienced
[0:51:49] higher electrical cost, higher fuel cost, higher cost for travel and training to make
[0:51:56] sure that members of our team have the ability to learn new processes and to adapt to an ever
[0:52:03] changing environment. In fact, it's the power and increases that really are driving
[0:52:10] portion of the sewer and water fund increases that we're experiencing this year.
[0:52:15] And then you'll notice that we're spending about $30 million in capital.
[0:52:20] And we had a great conversation this year about that spend in capital and there's a lot
[0:52:27] of one-time money that is placed into this budget.
[0:52:31] $8.5 million nearly of care is funding.
[0:52:35] This placed into the budget.
[0:52:37] The only piece that's not placed for entirety is the park, but the engineering is in there.
[0:52:44] And in the coming weeks, you're going to see a presentation from all of the recipients.
[0:52:50] There's money for the transit system, there's money for airport projects, there's increases
[0:52:55] associated with water and fire projects.
[0:52:59] So all of that collectively one-time money translates into a $30.223 million capital buy.
[0:53:09] So I'm going to briefly go through the elements of the strategic plan, I thought that the members
[0:53:13] of the team covered this brilliantly. Unfortunately, I don't have cool videos. I don't have people
[0:53:23] going to walk out in amazing parts of their presentation, and so my piece is relatively
[0:53:30] boring, so we'll kind of go through this a bit quickly. You can see the different pieces
[0:53:36] that we're moving forward in a healthy community. The healthy community is really reflective
[0:53:42] of our park system and all of the amenities that we offer to try to create
[0:53:47] environments where individuals can recreate and participate in all the great
[0:53:52] things our community has. You can see we're going to make $500,000 of park
[0:53:57] improvements at City Park using CDBG funds. We're going to continue to make
[0:54:02] sure that our inventory of parking spaces is maintained and approved in
[0:54:06] partnership with the Street Fund. Those parking lots are selected and that
[0:54:11] they're part of their programming.
[0:54:14] We talked about the need and the importance
[0:54:16] of the pool circulation system and the deck resurfacing
[0:54:19] and the importance of buying the rotary mowers.
[0:54:24] Tara did a great job in presenting the library
[0:54:27] and the team, how they're expanding their collections
[0:54:30] and the library projects this year total $118,000
[0:54:34] and that was presented to you.
[0:54:38] Part of this is part of that advanced fund
[0:54:40] in the four police vehicles in moving forward.
[0:54:45] And you might say, well, why is it different?
[0:54:47] And remember, we're buying the vehicle,
[0:54:49] not all the stuff that we have to put into the vehicles.
[0:54:52] I'm looking at Gretchen to make sure that's accurate.
[0:54:57] And so by placing the order early,
[0:55:00] we're going to be able to move forward.
[0:55:02] But this is really part of the public safety, secure community
[0:55:07] acquisition that we're going to move forward.
[0:55:09] You'll notice that the first lease payment for fire station number two is to come do.
[0:55:16] And that that is part of the certificate of participation that was approved.
[0:55:20] And that we're using fire impact fees to cover those costs.
[0:55:28] Members of the public works and engineering teams spent quite a bit of time going
[0:55:33] through the capital list as it relates to an accessible community and bill and the members
[0:55:40] of his team, illustrated the projects that, for their more cost, $3.35 million, providing
[0:56:00] water and wastewater services is one of those things that sometimes we take for granted.
[0:56:08] That is part of where the magic happens on a daily basis, and you can see that we're able
[0:56:13] to move forward with pump number five, which is a price of about $3 million.
[0:56:17] We're going to continue to do mainline replacement.
[0:56:21] There are a series of drainage projects, meter replacement system improvements that are really
[0:56:27] designed to help us meet the needs of a growing community, but also to replace parts of our
[0:56:32] system that have aged beyond its useful life, which is similar into the wastewater where
[0:56:38] we're asking for one and a half million dollars for primary and secondary clarifier rehabilitation,
[0:56:45] line improvements, the sledge bed expansion, a sledge truck replacement, and then you notice
[0:56:51] that $4 million of that is our partnership with Jacobs Engineering.
[0:56:55] Jacobs has been operating our facility for nearly 40 years, and they bring a collection
[0:57:01] of expertise to the table that allows for the successful operations of the wastewater treatment
[0:57:08] plant.
[0:57:12] We talked about the importance of our prosperous community and over the course of the last several
[0:57:18] meetings. In the past, we've talked about revenue guarantees and how Bill and members
[0:57:23] of his team and Sean Barrigar really were able to connect with Delta and to bring a second
[0:57:30] flight. And while we're aware of one possible guarantee to assist, we believe the days of
[0:57:37] revenue guarantees after that one are going to be gone and that we're going to need the
[0:57:42] community in Twin Falls to really fly local to take advantage of the dual-class
[0:57:48] jets that are going to be flying out of Twin Falls and recently had the
[0:57:54] opportunity to purchase flights and I was pleasantly surprised and happy I'm
[0:58:00] happy to report that flying out of Twin Falls for where I was going at the time
[0:58:05] in which I was going was cheaper than flying out of either Boise or out of
[0:58:08] salt lake. So we would encourage individuals to look and fly local and to
[0:58:14] recognize that there are more flights and they are convenient times positioned in
[0:58:19] the morning in the afternoon as well as in the evening. We talked about being a
[0:58:25] responsible community where we do participate in a annual citizen survey
[0:58:31] that we are seeking new ways to expand talent inside of our organization which
[0:58:37] we'll talk about under Focus Area 8 and our priority budgeting process.
[0:58:41] This is also where we talk about the $770,000 of Council-Directed Capital, and then we'll
[0:58:47] go through that list in a second.
[0:58:50] And then in terms of our employees and making sure that we are able to attract and to retain
[0:58:57] individuals, we are seeking a 4% performance adjustment, a 5% table move, and it's important
[0:59:03] remember on our pay structure that does not necessarily equal 9 when you move the table
[0:59:08] that does not necessarily mean that individual salaries slide with that.
[0:59:13] We're creating a new VIBA program in which will allocate $900 to every employee.
[0:59:19] We're continuing our retention program.
[0:59:21] We're funding the health insurance increase of 7.4% and the practice of providing $1,000
[0:59:28] to every employee's HSA account.
[0:59:30] As we transitioned, we now only offer one health insurance
[0:59:35] plan to our employees, and that's been a couple of years now.
[0:59:38] But in the past, we had dual programs.
[0:59:41] Now we have one.
[0:59:42] And then obviously, making sure that we have the right equipment
[0:59:47] and providing the right environment for them
[0:59:49] to be successful.
[0:59:52] Really wanted to just take a minute and talk about the labor
[0:59:55] because a lot of individuals say,
[0:59:58] when is that going to end?
[0:59:59] When do we believe that we're going to see people emerge?
[1:00:02] And what we've learned is that people retired,
[1:00:07] maybe in advance of where they were projected to.
[1:00:10] And so this battle for talent is going to be ongoing.
[1:00:16] And we need to make sure that we continue to remain nimble
[1:00:20] and that our employees are part of that focus area
[1:00:25] focus area and part of our focus because it's the talent that we have that allows us to accomplish
[1:00:32] the many good things that they presented to you over the course of the last month.
[1:00:40] Here is one of the rising costs of health insurance.
[1:00:42] We always want to make sure that we're reflecting, we're looking, we're really no different than
[1:00:48] many other employees when it comes to the cost of health insurance and our commitment is
[1:00:55] to continue to shop to investigate and once again over the course of this next fiscal year,
[1:01:01] we will look at going partially self-insured to see if that's an option for us financially.
[1:01:10] So when it comes to Council Capital, over the course of the last several weeks, members
[1:01:17] of our team have been placing these items onto your list for consideration.
[1:01:25] a one little note that I want to make and if you take a look at bullet number two
[1:01:30] and three they are essentially for the restroom or model at city pool that we
[1:01:36] had talked about and we are showing the total cost of those items in the bottom
[1:01:43] but in actuality the total cost if you elect to do only the design and full
[1:01:49] remodel for the restroom shower and office area at the pool that's a hundred
[1:01:53] $146,000 in the design and construction of one family-style restroom at the
[1:02:00] Well, it's 232,000. So if you elected to do a design in a larger potential improvement that was discussed
[1:02:08] It would be a hundred forty six thousand dollars this year and it does not include the construction costs that we would look
[1:02:15] Investigate and then bring back at an appropriate time if that was the option
[1:02:20] you the total
[1:02:22] prices right around $760,000. If you were not to do the larger improvement or
[1:02:31] design at the pool and you were to include the design and the construction
[1:02:36] of just the single family restroom that would be the $232,000 and the total
[1:02:43] price tag would be right around $847,000. That variance from the $770 or funds that
[1:02:51] that we could find in other places of the budget.
[1:02:58] And namely, we would set that inside of the contingency.
[1:03:05] So tonight is also not only is it
[1:03:10] the end of the cool presentations,
[1:03:11] but it's the beginning of your first formal action.
[1:03:17] And your first formal action this evening
[1:03:20] is to set the maximum spending cap
[1:03:24] by establishing the preliminary budget
[1:03:27] for the City of Twin Falls.
[1:03:28] And that dollar value has been provided in your packets.
[1:03:34] And then also, formally establishing the public hearing date
[1:03:39] for the 21st of August, 2023,
[1:03:45] to occur no sooner than 6 p.m.
[1:03:52] And with that, I'm happy to stand for any questions.
[1:03:56] And if they're really hard,
[1:03:57] you'll notice that we have lots of people here,
[1:04:01] lots of great members of the team that have been champions
[1:04:04] throughout this entire effort,
[1:04:06] that I would be more than happy to defer to,
[1:04:09] as they're probably going to have better information.
[1:04:11] Hey, questions for Travis?
[1:04:16] Answer, do you have some?
[1:04:17] Yes, thanks, Mayor.
[1:04:18] Just about the council directed spending.
[1:04:20] So is the process that if we stick with the budget
[1:04:24] at 770,000 that after we adopt the budget,
[1:04:28] then we, as a council, discuss which projects would make the final list.
[1:04:33] Typically, we've preferred to have that done prior to the adoption of the budget.
[1:04:39] So, when you come in on the 21st, the members of the community
[1:04:43] have full understanding of the complete allocation of the budget, not after.
[1:04:48] When are you asking us to have that discussion? It won't be tonight, but...
[1:04:55] Next week would be great.
[1:04:57] And if there are specific questions that you would like to have, if you could send those
[1:05:07] to me, what I want to do is I want to make sure that we can have the appropriate staff
[1:05:12] person here to be able to answer that question directly because as you saw, there were probably
[1:05:17] 60 participants and there may have been something that one of them shared and we would like to
[1:05:23] have them come in and share their expertise with you again if needed.
[1:05:28] So it does say more ideas to come but this is the list right?
[1:05:32] Unless the members of the community have other ideas or members of the council say
[1:05:38] you forgot we like to add and so we don't believe that this is a complete and
[1:05:43] exhaustive list we believe that these are just mere suggestions for you to
[1:05:47] consider. Any questions for Travis comments? I'd entertain a motion then.
[1:06:02] Mr. Reed, I move that we establish the 2023-2024 fiscal year preliminary budget for the city of
[1:06:10] Twin Falls in the amount of 94,270,338 dollars and setting the public hearing for August 21st,
[1:06:19] 2023, no sooner than 6 p.m. followed by citizen input. I'll second that.
[1:06:26] Thank you motion by Christopher Reed seconded by Jason Brown to adopt a
[1:06:35] preliminary budget for fiscal year 2324 and set the public hearing for August
[1:06:41] 21st 2023 no earlier than 6 p.m. Any further discussion from the council?
[1:06:49] Amy Roll Call vote please.
[1:06:52] Spencer Cutler.
[1:06:54] Yes.
[1:06:55] Ruth Pierce.
[1:06:56] Yes.
[1:06:57] Chris Reed.
[1:06:58] Yes.
[1:06:59] Keep Boyd.
[1:07:00] Yes.
[1:07:01] Greg Hawkins.
[1:07:02] Yes.
[1:07:04] Thank you.
[1:07:05] Motion passes six to zero.
[1:07:07] So that is the end of our items of consideration.
[1:07:11] The next item on the agenda is general public input.
[1:07:14] And again, I'm going to break this into two different subject matters.
[1:07:20] the first is if there's anybody in the public that wishes to comment on the
[1:07:25] budget that we just heard please come down state your name and you will have
[1:07:33] two minutes and Amy would you please time I just wanted to echo what Mr.
[1:07:41] Rothweiler said regarding that's seven hundred seventy thousand dollar city
[1:07:46] council public budget with public input citizens, I think you guys should consider doing something
[1:07:53] for the dog park, maybe a shelter or some benches and make it simple, you know, so that's it.
[1:08:00] Thanks.
[1:08:01] Thank you.
[1:08:03] Okay, anybody else that wishes to comment on the budget?
[1:08:08] Okay, seeing no one then, now it's time for general public input on any other matter
[1:08:15] that is not on today's agenda.
[1:08:20] And again, please state your name.
[1:08:23] My name is Arnelle.
[1:08:25] My name is Arnelle, and I'm here today
[1:08:28] to ask City Council for an action item
[1:08:32] for the termination of.
[1:08:33] Okay, okay, go ahead.
[1:08:37] Okay, well, we do not have personnel discussions
[1:08:58] and during public input, okay.
[1:09:03] We do not have personnel discussions,
[1:09:14] do you have any comments?
[1:09:15] Madam Mayor, I think that by virtue of the Idaho code,
[1:09:22] it says that personnel actions shall not be discussed.
[1:09:29] There are very specific limitations
[1:09:32] when it comes to what can be discussed
[1:09:34] as a result of personnel and personnel actions.
[1:09:38] Historically, what has happened is
[1:09:40] if an individual has a concern about the conduct
[1:09:43] or the behaviors of an employee,
[1:09:49] they have engaged directly with the supervisor of that employee
[1:09:53] where there is a level of potential privacy,
[1:09:57] but also litigation that we need to make sure
[1:10:00] that we're sensitive of.
[1:10:02] OK.
[1:10:08] So again, this is not the venue to have that discussion.
[1:10:15] We are not going to discuss any kind of personnel issues
[1:10:19] in City Council.
[1:10:21] you just heard Travis.
[1:10:25] Again, we are not going to discuss any personnel issues
[1:10:30] at City Council.
[1:10:31] If you have a specific request,
[1:10:37] I understand exactly what I'm doing.
[1:10:40] I am saying that we do not discuss personnel
[1:10:44] at a City Council meeting.
[1:10:46] If you have a specific request, put it in writing,
[1:10:50] put it in writing to the supervisor,
[1:10:54] And that would be to me.
[1:10:56] So you're asking for what kind of committee?
[1:11:37] Didn't we go through this once before
[1:11:39] and you were asking for a committee?
[1:11:41] What kind of committee are you asking for?
[1:11:51] Again, this is a personnel issue.
[1:11:58] Okay, R&L?
[1:12:00] Okay, anybody on city council interested in forming
[1:12:03] a committee on this particular issue?
[1:12:06] No.
[1:12:07] No.
[1:12:07] Okay, thank you.
[1:12:10] Okay. Anybody else here that wishes to address Council?
[1:12:14] Yes ma'am. Please state your name and remember you have two minutes.
[1:12:24] All right. Thank you. I wanted to thank Travis for helping me last time.
[1:12:27] I didn't know when to input. Thank you, Travis.
[1:12:30] And also my name is Maria Hernandez and I am from Twin Falls, Idaho.
[1:12:36] Originally, I'm a Native American part Latina and I'm a survivor of PTSD.
[1:12:42] You guys heard that last time.
[1:12:43] I'm also a follower of the Ponca Indian Tribe of Chief Standing Bear and Congressman Civil
[1:12:49] Rights Leader John Lewis, a follower of the Tribe of Judah in Imagine Dragons and Neil
[1:12:54] Rold-Ponakin.
[1:12:58] I'm asking for an action item to have the request I made to Mayor Pierce in private on
[1:13:03] 8-323 to possibly reconsider, that's all I'm going to say.
[1:13:07] Also for the sake of transparency and keeping accountability, I'm here to publicly report
[1:13:13] back to council and city manager that Mayor Pierce met with me last week on 8-3-23 to
[1:13:20] hear my grievances regarding the situation. I am documenting my meeting with this letter,
[1:13:27] Mayor, would like to give it to the Mayor publicly and request her response to me in
[1:13:32] writing if possible, but I know you're busy with two jobs. Before I forget, I would like
[1:13:38] to thank Officer Bailey Kemp, badge 420, and Sergeant Gasser for their help during the
[1:13:46] time of my case hearings and wanted to thank them publicly, as Bailey Kemp did an extensive
[1:13:57] job in the body cam footage.
[1:14:02] Mr. Noops not here but I would publicly would like to,
[1:14:06] or my healing would like to forgive him for his actions.
[1:14:10] Okay, again we don't.
[1:14:11] Thank you, thank you.
[1:14:13] And I know that you're signed up there at five seconds,
[1:14:19] says one city, well a city divided will fall.
[1:14:23] So for me I'm here to bring unity and not division
[1:14:27] because division doesn't help.
[1:14:30] But forgiveness does, and that's what I'm walking.
[1:14:33] time is up. Thank you. Thank you so much. Oh, here's who would you
[1:14:38] leave that with Travis? Thank you. Okay, anybody else from the public that wishes
[1:14:45] to address City Council on an item not on today's agenda? Seeing no one, any
[1:14:57] other council reports? Anybody? Anything from the City Manager's office? I just
[1:15:09] I just want to congratulate the Council on, I think, a very nicely done state of the city
[1:15:16] address.
[1:15:17] I've heard lots of different compliments on that.
[1:15:20] Thank you to the Chamber for their partnership with us on that, and obviously to Lisa and David
[1:15:26] Second Street Market.
[1:15:27] That was a great event, it was well attended, and thank you to the Council for sharing your
[1:15:33] thoughts on that process.
[1:15:35] Thank you to Maxine Duran and Andy Thompson for the ribbon cutting that we had, and also
[1:15:42] the police department and having the night out that we had last week as well as a busy
[1:15:49] week.
[1:15:51] And those are all examples of members of our team really going outside and above and beyond
[1:15:58] that typical defined work day or going out and doing different things.
[1:16:03] So a great job to them and I just want to publicly thank them.
[1:16:06] Next week we'll have a presentation on the budget much more abbreviated and it will be really
[1:16:13] the council's opportunity to really work through more parts of that budget.
[1:16:17] Again, we'd make ourselves available for any conversations that you would like to have.
[1:16:25] And then on the 21st, again, we would invite the public to participate in the public hearing
[1:16:31] process and if members of our community who are listening now have questions about the
[1:16:35] budget they don't have to wait till a council meeting they can reach out to I know any member
[1:16:40] of the council but also they can also reach out to any member of the city's team to help
[1:16:44] clarify expenses and responses. Perfect okay so next on the agenda is the public hearing
[1:16:55] are you all ready to go ahead you want to need to break no you're good okay so we'll move
[1:17:01] into the public hearing and it's an action item. It's a public hearing on fee and rate increases
[1:17:08] for the City of Twin Falls and we have Brianna Howard, our CFO. Welcome Brianna.
[1:17:15] Good evening, Mayor and Council. So I am here because we're so into Idaho Code Section
[1:17:23] 63, Chapter 13, we are required to establish new fees and increase certain fees by more than 5%
[1:17:29] by having a public hearing and publishing in the newspaper.
[1:17:34] So in your packet, there is a list.
[1:17:37] There's a list of fee proposed changes.
[1:17:41] There's an entire list of the master fee schedule
[1:17:44] in addition to the footnotes
[1:17:46] and then the resolutions I would like to request
[1:17:51] that gets approved.
[1:17:53] In this fee change list, we have categories.
[1:17:57] So it was quite extensive this time.
[1:17:59] So I wanted to break it down just a little bit piece by piece
[1:18:02] and maybe invite any questions on each piece
[1:18:05] and then we can move forward as that goes along.
[1:18:08] So the first category I wanted to talk about was the airport.
[1:18:12] In 2004, as it means to provide adjustments
[1:18:14] to Hanger ground and terminal facility leases,
[1:18:16] the airport instituted an annual CPI-based escalation clause
[1:18:21] in lease agreements.
[1:18:22] This escalation clause was developed
[1:18:23] through the collaboration of members of the airport board
[1:18:26] and several private Hanger tenants from that time.
[1:18:29] He was agreed that utilizing the year-over-year annual average CPI would be a good way to maintain
[1:18:34] reasonable yet consistent increases to leases over time.
[1:18:39] So I provided an excerpt from the airport lease inside of the staff report that shows
[1:18:43] the rate escalation based on 2022 versus 2021 as around 8% increased to the pending October
[1:18:51] 1st, 2023 leases.
[1:18:55] the high inflation period we saw in 22 and 21, the escalation clause yield to change of
[1:18:59] 8% to be applied to the lease as annual billing period starting October 1st. This is the first
[1:19:05] time since we instituted the CPI escalation clause, the annual rental increases has ever
[1:19:10] exceeded that 5%. Requiring it to be listed as a public hearing notice. So with that, we've
[1:19:18] got Bill Carberry here to answer any questions if you had any on the airport fee section
[1:19:23] and the increases therein.
[1:19:27] Looks like we're good.
[1:19:30] OK.
[1:19:31] The next couple is from the City Manager team.
[1:19:35] The fees proposed by the City Manager's Office
[1:19:37] are specific to ride TFT.
[1:19:40] These fees are for advertising.
[1:19:41] The first fee is for a 12 or 24 month contact,
[1:19:44] for wrapping the TFT vans with the vinyl design that covers
[1:19:48] either part of or entire van.
[1:19:50] This mobile billboards are often used as advertisements
[1:19:53] to promote special or increased brand awareness
[1:19:55] and will be offered to businesses and organizations in Twin Falls.
[1:19:58] The 12-month contract is 2,000 per month, or 24,000 for the year plus the cost of the
[1:20:03] wrap.
[1:20:04] The 24-month contract offers a 20% discount which equates to 1,600 per month, or 38,400
[1:20:11] for two years plus the cost of the wrap.
[1:20:13] These fees were based on the same fees in place of Idaho Falls, and the second fee is
[1:20:17] for in-car advertising which will be mounted in the vans.
[1:20:21] This is a $300 month with a minimum commitment of one quarter.
[1:20:24] These fees will be integral for the city in meeting the federal matching requirements.
[1:20:28] Once the ITD grant has been expended and the city takes on the financial obligation of operating
[1:20:32] the system.
[1:20:33] While we will be eligible for federal funds, there will be a local match, which Maxine talked
[1:20:38] about tonight.
[1:20:39] And these advertising fees will assist in meeting those that match the threshold.
[1:20:44] Any questions on the TFT advertising fees?
[1:20:49] No.
[1:20:50] Okay.
[1:20:51] The next one is engineering. The water meter fees are increased to accommodate the increase in supplies and parts passed through from our suppliers.
[1:20:59] The water main connection fees are increased to account for the increase in material costs to connect the taps.
[1:21:05] The increased cost is an average of the cost of each size of connection and a number of times we can reshape and
[1:21:10] resharpen the bits and reuse them. The cost is a large diameter.
[1:21:14] shell cutter style bits have gone up considerably and shell cutters may last
[1:21:18] up to one tap or three to four taps the cost calculation is better made on the
[1:21:22] average. Any question on the engineering? So I don't see anybody so that's okay.
[1:21:34] I'm not rolled over to the three. Yeah okay Jason I got Jason first. So that
[1:21:41] that cost is directly related to the cost that we have seen by our suppliers is
[1:21:47] Is that correct?
[1:21:48] Yes, so we're not relying on the citizens to pay for that.
[1:21:53] This is just a direct, almost a pass.
[1:21:55] Yeah, there's no profit.
[1:21:56] Yeah, there's no profit motive here.
[1:21:58] It's the direct fees that we pass through.
[1:22:01] And we typically see a slight increase,
[1:22:03] a small increase for Indian parts.
[1:22:06] A little bit more of this here, though.
[1:22:08] Thank you.
[1:22:09] Yes, has this been communicated to?
[1:22:13] It's been published twice.
[1:22:14] It's been the, I don't.
[1:22:16] I saw it in the paper, yep.
[1:22:20] He says yes.
[1:22:21] Don't stop, yeah, right.
[1:22:23] It's the engineering territory, BTEC,
[1:22:24] so it has been communicated.
[1:22:26] Wonderful.
[1:22:27] Actually, I forgot to mention to the airport fees too,
[1:22:30] as well, have been communicated to the airport advisory board
[1:22:33] as well.
[1:22:36] Perfect.
[1:22:37] OK.
[1:22:40] OK, so the next few sections, I'll lump those together.
[1:22:43] We've got general fees, parks fees, rec fees,
[1:22:48] and Shoshone Falls and Durkey fees.
[1:22:50] If you remember in 2021, we compiled a list of all the fees
[1:22:55] across all the departments in the city
[1:22:57] to make everything more transparent,
[1:22:59] to make it more efficient for us to look at,
[1:23:01] and we've actually published on our city website as well.
[1:23:05] In effort to standardize and make these with state code,
[1:23:07] we reviewed the general fees in the master city-wide fee schedule
[1:23:10] in detail, finding some that needed updated and reworded
[1:23:13] to accurately portray each fee with an additional explanation.
[1:23:16] The alcohol, beer, and liquor license fees descriptions
[1:23:19] were updated to reference dictated by state or city code,
[1:23:22] and the code section was referenced.
[1:23:24] Beer licenses as dictated by city code were also added
[1:23:27] to the schedule to include the distinction of on
[1:23:29] or off the premise, and liquor license fees
[1:23:32] were included inside it as well.
[1:23:34] We've also changed, we've returned payment fee
[1:23:39] from utility billing into a general fee
[1:23:41] because it's something that we potentially could use
[1:23:43] across another departments,
[1:23:45] although we currently only use it
[1:23:46] as a utility billing fee right now.
[1:23:52] A few fees were deleted and reiterated in the alcohol, beer and liquor license fees described above for the clarification and accuracy.
[1:23:59] The parks, wrecks, so-and-falls and derkeys, that one's a little bit different.
[1:24:03] Our citywide fee schedule that you have had in the last few years has a few fees that reference the fees after sales tax.
[1:24:11] To reflect more accurately what the City of Twin Falls is actually charging, sales tax has been imputed and the fees have been reduced commensurate with the computation.
[1:24:20] And that is the case for all of the parks, the rec that she shown falls in the Durkeys one.
[1:24:27] We do have a few new fees in parks though, as it relates to the downtown commons.
[1:24:33] We retained the city of Twin Falls, received the property.
[1:24:39] When the urban renewal agency conveyed it, conveyed the downtown city commons to us,
[1:24:44] and the proposed fees are for the private rental of the commons area to cover the cost of the labor to claim
[1:24:49] and a power supply to outlets.
[1:24:51] The fees proposed rent conjunction with fees already assessed
[1:24:54] for other city park areas available for private use.
[1:24:57] And it was actually brought before the Parks and Recs Commission
[1:25:00] as well.
[1:25:02] Any questions on any of those fees that were either imputed,
[1:25:06] changed for sales tax, descriptions changed,
[1:25:08] or city code related?
[1:25:10] Any questions?
[1:25:13] Looks good.
[1:25:14] OK, so I'm going to skip and do utility billing,
[1:25:17] because that one's easy, because the pool is huge.
[1:25:19] utility billing has what you would expect a 2.5% increase in all the utility billing ones
[1:25:25] as you can see have a 2.5% increase. Any questions on utility billing? All right, pool. That's
[1:25:31] a fun one. Inside the packet, I've included John Pauli and Wendy have actually gone before
[1:25:39] the Parks and Rec and they've published this. They've talked to each one of them. They've
[1:25:43] got approval from the Parks and Rec Commission. In tandem with the other fees where we saw that
[1:25:50] sales tax was included, this was the same for the pool except that they have taken a different
[1:25:54] approach on some of those fees where there's been some much needed increases. And so they've
[1:25:58] increased quite a few of those fees by 6%. You can see a bulk of those by that increase
[1:26:04] of 6%. There's a few, there's a couple new fees, silver and fit and silver sneakers. These
[1:26:11] programs are Medicare backed and allow seniors 16 older to use the pool at no cost. The City
[1:26:16] Twin Falls would be reimbursed for the number of visits up to $30 or silver and fit, and
[1:26:21] $21 for silver sneakers, which is within the range of the senior rate of 24 per city
[1:26:25] residence and 29 for non-residents.
[1:26:28] Providing these programs will lead to increased use of the pool during the school day when
[1:26:32] usage is lower.
[1:26:34] Youth and teen passes have changed daily admissions and punch passes are set up to offer
[1:26:38] a wide variety of different age groups that monthly and annual passes do not have.
[1:26:43] creates a youth and teen category to align. All the city pool admission options the same
[1:26:48] standard. Teens would be included with seniors because their daily admission and punch past
[1:26:52] prices are the same. Swim meet rentals. There were two. We had a lower price of $650 in the
[1:26:59] winter and a summer meet is $1000 and we are proposing to increase that to the $1000 so
[1:27:05] have a standard same rate for swim meet rentals. These allow for fees to be the same regardless
[1:27:11] of the season. The staffing expenses to host meets in the winter have increased due to higher
[1:27:15] wages and more staff needed during meets so the additional fees are needed to cover costs.
[1:27:20] The city has needed to use additional staffing for lifeguard coverage, cleaning and general
[1:27:24] supervision of spectators. Birthday party, the proposed increase will allow the city to better
[1:27:30] cover an increase in the number of lifeguards for proper coverage when there are birthday
[1:27:34] parties. Community water safety, sorry there's a lot. It's quite a bit this time. Community
[1:27:40] Any water safety lessons per day, the proposed increase will give the city an option to set
[1:27:45] up many swim lessons during sessions during winter or spring break by charging less because
[1:27:49] there are fewer days available during these times.
[1:27:52] Along with the water aerobics, there's a proposed drop-in annual and 30-day cost.
[1:27:58] Red Cross Safety Certification classes, the proposed fee increase covers additional staff
[1:28:03] hours that are required to reach the programs and when the original fee was created.
[1:28:08] It also helps cover additional fees that come with courses such as equipment and red cross
[1:28:12] certification fees.
[1:28:13] Private swim lessons, they have been historically difficult to track, staff have created a new
[1:28:18] system that allows for them to be requested online and then assigned and scheduled in
[1:28:23] the proposed fees assessed to cover the time associated with assigning and scheduling.
[1:28:28] The proposed fees would additionally cover the time before and after a 30 minute lesson
[1:28:32] allowing for a more accurate cost recovery of 45 minutes.
[1:28:36] And then at a rescheduling fee for the time it takes to reschedule.
[1:28:42] So in a nutshell, that's the pool.
[1:28:44] There's some significant increases.
[1:28:45] There's quite a bit of 6% increases.
[1:28:48] All of this is brought before the Parks and Rec Commission.
[1:28:50] I know Wendy is here as well if there's any questions on any of the pool fee increases.
[1:29:00] Any questions?
[1:29:01] Chris Reed.
[1:29:02] Um, the, I find it the swim meet rental.
[1:29:07] Are the schools being charged that?
[1:29:13] Which ones are they?
[1:29:15] I can help with that.
[1:29:18] So the schools that we have a partnership agreement
[1:29:23] with the Twin Falls schools.
[1:29:26] So Twin Falls High School, Cambridge High School,
[1:29:28] they are not charged that fee.
[1:29:31] The other schools are, they are assessed a slight fee
[1:29:36] associated with.
[1:29:37] OK, perfect.
[1:29:39] All I want to know is with that increase,
[1:29:43] making sure that they are notified of that type of an increase.
[1:29:47] I don't know if the winter, they were being charged a winter one,
[1:29:50] or because if it's going from 650 to 1,000,
[1:29:55] if they were being charged over the winter, a winter fee,
[1:29:58] because it does go into October, just worried
[1:30:02] about those organizations, because they do use the pool
[1:30:06] if they were notified.
[1:30:07] But if we have agreements with them separate
[1:30:10] than this, that's different.
[1:30:25] Well, if we have separate agreements,
[1:30:28] that's different than this, but Wendy can talk about who was notified in that process
[1:30:34] or maybe that's a John Polly question we can find out as to the notification and the assessment
[1:30:41] of that increase fee.
[1:30:43] John's on vacation, I apologize, I'm semi-prepared, but I don't know if any notifications have
[1:30:50] been made yet.
[1:30:51] The agreement with the school district is we pay hard costs for the use of their facilities
[1:30:59] they pay hard costs for the use of ours. So in other words, we pay for staff and their
[1:31:04] facilities, they pay for staff in our facility. I can't imagine that he would propose this
[1:31:13] kind of an increase without having a conversation and notifying. Again, I could text him real
[1:31:23] quick and say I know a lot about this. Unfortunately, I spend many, many hours at the pool and understand
[1:31:29] the schedule just came out and there's a lot of non-twin fall schools that use our pool,
[1:31:36] wanting them to know that it potentially could be much more expensive for them.
[1:31:41] And I think it really depends on who hosts it.
[1:31:44] That's exactly right.
[1:31:45] And I know that several of the surrounding schools are now using the jackpot pool.
[1:31:50] Well, at least the schedule I got from them.
[1:31:52] So, that's my understanding too, is that some of them are not even using ours at the moment,
[1:31:56] so.
[1:31:57] But I can text him real quick and ask him if he's...
[1:31:59] That's okay. We don't need to go there
[1:32:05] Jason Brown
[1:32:07] Yeah, so you know looking at looking through this it appears that a lot of these newer fees are really to
[1:32:14] Account for some of the activities at the pool. John's really gone through and said these are
[1:32:19] The costs associated with the operation of the pool is that is that a fair assessment?
[1:32:24] Yeah, it's in for the city to
[1:32:28] Sizing too, so they've gotten rid of some of the past
[1:32:30] options that are necessary anymore adjusting some fees to include passes that
[1:32:38] sort of a population that weren't included before and unfortunately and I
[1:32:45] don't know how far down this rabbit hole to go because I don't totally
[1:32:47] understand this but like in recreation they have the ability to assess fees in a
[1:32:55] self-supporting budget thing the pool does not have that so any time they try any
[1:33:00] any new program, we have to set a fee for it, which is partly what you're seeing here.
[1:33:06] So you're just, yeah, and I think it's fine. I just try to understand that really we're
[1:33:11] looking at trying to make the pool, you know, if you're using the pool, you're paying to
[1:33:16] use the pool in that regard. Correct. And looking at some of the different categories it looks
[1:33:21] like we're trying to pinpoint who may be using it for specific. Right. And trying to make
[1:33:27] the whole new water aerobics program and trying to make that more user-friendly with better
[1:33:33] options for participating in that. And then, you know, some of these it's talking about
[1:33:39] lost revenue too. So when you close the entire facility down for a swim meet, that's a lost
[1:33:45] opportunity.
[1:33:46] Okay, thank you. Hey, that looks like questions. Do you have any more info for us?
[1:33:56] Nope, that's it. That's it. It takes a more than 50% vote to pass the entire fee resolution.
[1:34:04] So next is to open it up for public input. So I'm going to open up the public hearing. Anybody here
[1:34:12] who wishes to come down and comment on the proposed fee increases? Again, please come down the podium
[1:34:20] state your name and whether you're a citizen of Twin Falls and then you have two minutes to make
[1:34:25] your comments. Yes sir, welcome. Would you turn on your mic, just push that. Is that okay?
[1:34:38] That's better. Good evening. I appreciate the time. My name is Jeff Freeman with Reader Flying
[1:34:43] Service out of the airport and we received the fee schedule. The change of the fee schedule
[1:34:47] this past week and 8% increase at any time is tough to swallow but we understand with real estate
[1:34:54] the way it is. I just was here really to show support for the airport management and the airport
[1:35:00] in general and what they provide us is tenants and it's fantastic. So it's really
[1:35:05] just more of a support for what they're doing and what your guys are helping us.
[1:35:09] Thank you. That's nice to hear. Thank you. Okay anybody else in the public out
[1:35:17] there that wishes to comment on our fee increase? Okay seeing no one I'm gonna
[1:35:25] close the public hearing. Is there any further discussion with City Council?
[1:35:30] So do we have a resolution we need to pass is that
[1:35:35] The direction I didn't I think I'll update that for next time. It's resolution number 2023 dash 0 1 0
[1:35:50] resolution 10
[1:35:53] Yep
[1:35:55] It's to propose new fees and amendment and mending the city's master fee schedule is it in the
[1:36:09] Attachments yes resolution, okay. Thank you
[1:36:14] So is there any further discussion from Council?
[1:36:18] Thank you Jason, go for it.
[1:36:25] Okay, I'll at least I'll attempt it.
[1:36:27] I'd like to approve resolution 2023-010, a resolution of the city of Twin Falls, Idaho proposing new fees and amending the city's master fee schedule.
[1:36:45] Thank you.
[1:36:46] Do I have a second?
[1:36:47] second. Thank you motion by Jason Brown seconded by Greg Hawkins to approve
[1:36:55] resolution number 2023-010. Any further discussion? Amy Roll call vote please.
[1:37:03] Ruth Pierce. Yes. Chris Reed. Yes. Thank you Boyd. Yes. Greg Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown.
[1:37:11] Yes. Spencer Cutler. Yes. Thank you motion passes six to zero. Okay. Thank you
[1:37:18] So that is it for our City Council meeting tonight.
[1:37:23] There's nothing else on the agenda. So meeting's adjourned. Thank you.
