Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2023-07-03, recording 1 (started 16:59)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2023-07-03/

[0:00:45] Good evening, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the July 3rd, 2023 City Council meeting.
[0:00:52] I want to confirm we have a quorum.
[0:00:54] We have five members here in chambers.
[0:00:57] Nikki Boyd is on the phone and Craig Hawkins is excused.
[0:01:04] So the first item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance.
[0:01:06] If you wish to join me, please rise.
[0:01:26] Thank you.
[0:01:27] We have no proclamations tonight, so we'll move on to the consent calendar.
[0:01:33] Wishes move to approve the consent calendar. Thank you to have a second. Thank you. Motion
[0:01:43] by Christopher Reed seconded by Jason Brown to approve the consent calendar is written.
[0:01:49] Amy roll call vote please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Thank you Boyd. Thank you. Yes. I can't hear
[0:02:11] you guys very good. Jason Brown. Yes. Spencer Cutler. Yes. And Alex Cabal. Yes. Thank you
[0:02:19] motion passes six to zero. First item on the item under items the only item under
[0:02:26] items of consideration is a presentation of the city manager's
[0:02:30] recommended budget for fiscal year 23 24 followed by citizen input and we
[0:02:36] have Travis Roth while our city manager. So Madam Mayor members of the council
[0:02:41] thanks for the opportunity to present the recommended budget to you for the
[0:02:46] 23, 24 fiscal year. The budget is available. It is online. It is also available through
[0:02:54] the city manager's office should individuals like to have an email to copy of it. But I thought
[0:03:00] I'd do tonight is start at page one and read through page 217 just to make sure that you knew
[0:03:06] it entirely front and back. I'm sure done in an hour we're good. So I'll put on my auction
[0:03:12] to be able to make that happen.
[0:03:15] No, tonight is designed to be a high-level overview
[0:03:20] of the entirety of the budget.
[0:03:24] It is a work that started for our team shortly
[0:03:29] after the first of the year.
[0:03:31] And while it has the city manager's recommended budget,
[0:03:33] it is certainly one that is built by many hands.
[0:03:36] It is built by a team.
[0:03:37] And we believe that it is a complete proposal
[0:03:40] for your review. So with that, I'll begin. And what I'll do is I'll begin by celebrating
[0:03:50] the work of the team across our entirety of our organization. So the City of Twin Falls
[0:03:58] is one of two cities that has received the GFOA award for the distinguished budget and for
[0:04:04] a comprehensive annual financial report or CAFRA. As a result, and we're received it for 11 consecutive
[0:04:13] years, which is the most out of any Idaho City.
[0:04:17] And what I will share with you is it represents a collection of best practices that we follow
[0:04:24] in the establishment of our budget.
[0:04:26] We don't work for the award.
[0:04:30] We work to make sure that we have a document that is easily understood by the layperson
[0:04:39] in our community because we believe that there is no better way to honor our fiduciary
[0:04:43] responsibility than to follow best practices.
[0:04:48] And so inside of our budget, if a citizen were to take a look at it, it starts with words,
[0:04:53] it has pictures, it has numbers.
[0:04:57] We want to make sure that it's not a collection of line items, and if someone is interested
[0:05:01] in the line items, we can give them to you.
[0:05:04] But line items onto themselves and expenses don't tell the story.
[0:05:09] And it also talks about how our budget is directly connected to our organization's goals and objectives
[0:05:17] and the things that we hope to accomplish.
[0:05:20] In addition to following best practices, it follows an entire collection of codes that
[0:05:26] are sprinkled throughout.
[0:05:28] It follows Title 50, which is Municipal Corporations.
[0:05:31] And I think it's important for us to think very similar to those of the private side of
[0:05:38] of how they work through processes
[0:05:41] and how in those processes they have shareholders.
[0:05:45] Our shareholders are our voters.
[0:05:47] Our voters and our property owners
[0:05:51] provide the resources for us to turn dollars
[0:05:55] into tangible goods and services for our community.
[0:05:58] And so honoring our fiduciary responsibility
[0:06:01] is something that we hold very near to what we do.
[0:06:07] Oftentimes, people want to get to the last page of the book first.
[0:06:12] They want to know how the story ends.
[0:06:14] And so in our effort to kind of share how the story ends,
[0:06:18] we tell you that next year it is going to cost the averages
[0:06:22] and $5.70 more for the same level of municipal services
[0:06:28] at the least than what it cost last year.
[0:06:32] That doesn't mean that individuals
[0:06:34] are going to be paying more in property taxes.
[0:06:37] Because what we do is we take that average person,
[0:06:40] and we take the median home value
[0:06:42] at very specific points in time.
[0:06:44] What was the median home value in the City of Twin Falls
[0:06:48] on January 1st of 23 in comparison to 22?
[0:06:51] And you can see that median home value
[0:06:53] has increased by about $9,000.
[0:06:58] The tax rate is functionally the same.
[0:07:01] It is the same tax rate at $4.78
[0:07:04] based upon the information that we have this year
[0:07:06] compared to last year.
[0:07:07] And we are asking for slight increases in water and sewer
[0:07:10] at 2.5% that we haven't done previously.
[0:07:14] That collectively, if there is a median person,
[0:07:19] would pay $5.70 more in city related services
[0:07:23] this year than last.
[0:07:25] But what is important is when we talk about property taxes,
[0:07:28] the Idaho legislature has made some changes.
[0:07:31] And so we do believe that there'll be some level
[0:07:33] of property tax relief for all citizens
[0:07:35] and businesses within our community.
[0:07:39] There's a lot of work that goes into the document,
[0:07:42] and one of the things that's at the front of the budget
[0:07:44] talks about the economic indicators
[0:07:47] and Brianna spent considerable time this year
[0:07:52] looking at different economic reports
[0:07:56] and compiling a list of economic indicators
[0:08:01] that we follow closely,
[0:08:04] and those indicators that we wanted to use into our budget.
[0:08:07] So here's a snapshot of the city of Twin Falls.
[0:08:11] So we're growing.
[0:08:13] And everyone talks about how we're growing.
[0:08:17] But when you start looking at estimated numbers
[0:08:19] in comparison to census, you can see that we've grown
[0:08:23] at 8.32% over the course of the last three years,
[0:08:28] where our population has gone from just above 51,000
[0:08:33] to just over 56,000 from July 1st of 2020
[0:08:40] to July 1st of 2022.
[0:08:45] And that's going to continue
[0:08:47] where we know that the daytime population of the city
[0:08:50] of Twin Falls routinely exceeds 100,000
[0:08:55] and that 41,000 individuals cross the prime bridge
[0:08:59] based upon a recent I.T.D. study.
[0:09:03] We know that per capita retail sales
[0:09:05] inside of the City of Twin Falls are greater than per capita income.
[0:09:09] And we see that in the amount of commerce that takes place on many of our corridors within
[0:09:18] our community.
[0:09:19] We've seen an increase in the household median income, as well as an increase in the proper
[0:09:26] median value of a home.
[0:09:28] In fact, it's gone up 63% since 2020.
[0:09:34] have not kept at that same pace. And while our homes have gone up slightly, the median
[0:09:41] home in the state of Idaho has fallen by an average of 5.1% from its high of $484,000.
[0:09:50] That's largely attributed to the reductions in property values that they see mainly in
[0:09:55] the treasure valley. Our unemployment rate inside the city of Tuanfalsas is considered
[0:10:00] to be at full employment.
[0:10:03] Anything between that three and four or lower mark, most
[0:10:08] economists will tell you that everyone who should have a job
[0:10:13] is working within the system.
[0:10:15] Unemployment rate in Idaho is 2.6% and the national rate
[0:10:19] is at 3.6%.
[0:10:23] So I was like, this illustrates the median home value
[0:10:29] according to Zillow of homes in Boise.
[0:10:33] Idaho and Twin Falls, and what's particularly interesting is if you follow the value of that
[0:10:40] home, which is represented in the bullets of January of each year.
[0:10:46] And then you'll notice that there's one high of July.
[0:10:50] So you can see that, yes, own values have come down from their high of July of 22.
[0:10:57] But the time in which they were assessed for property tax purposes, they were $9,000 higher
[0:11:05] than what they were the prior year.
[0:11:07] Idaho Code says the county assessor shall assess on or about January 1st at the beginning of
[0:11:16] each calendar year.
[0:11:18] And it needs to be closely tied to a market value.
[0:11:22] If it's not, the State Tax Commission has the authority to come in and make that change.
[0:11:28] So what has happened to Twin Falls values?
[0:11:31] You can see that over that period of time it's about a 4% decrease, Idaho is about a 7% and
[0:11:37] national average has gone up too.
[0:11:39] So when you look at those different windows based upon January to January timeframe, it
[0:11:45] is important to see that we're still above the national average.
[0:11:50] last year was the first time that we became our median home value was higher
[0:11:55] than the national average. It's also exciting to see that the municipal cost
[0:12:03] index curve is beginning to flatten, where it was up 0.62% or 1.9 points in May.
[0:12:12] What was also important to recognize is the steep curve to where we've gotten,
[0:12:19] where we had to endure first, and that's where cost had increased 13.15% over two
[0:12:25] year period of time. The CPI, which is important for us to follow as we look at
[0:12:30] engaging our employees ability to buy consumable goods and to buy services, how
[0:12:38] much more are they paying this year than last? And you can see that it is
[0:12:43] still much higher than the Fed's target of 2%. We believe the consumer price index
[0:12:48] will begin to continue to moderate just as we have seen in the municipal cost
[0:12:53] index, but if anything has proven to be true over the course of the last five years of budgeting,
[0:13:03] there is nothing certain about what we're going to see and that it is important for us to remain
[0:13:10] incredibly nimble.
[0:13:12] We shared this slide with you previously about how difficult it is to attract employees into
[0:13:20] our organization and how across the country there were about 1.5 million more individuals
[0:13:26] who elected to retire what I'd describe as prematurely or earlier than what was anticipated
[0:13:33] by most economists and as a result of that we struggled to continue to find competent
[0:13:40] individuals in our organization. We're going to spend a lot of time talking about the value
[0:13:46] that each member of our team brings to the community
[0:13:49] and Focus Area 8, and it is the centerpiece of our budget,
[0:13:55] where we are a human organization
[0:13:57] and we deliver services through the talented hands
[0:14:00] of the men and women that work with us.
[0:14:03] And this budget works to care for them because I believe
[0:14:07] that the best recruitment tool that we have is
[0:14:12] to have a retention tool that causes individuals
[0:14:16] not to look in the first place. This is a snapshot of the different unemployment
[0:14:25] rates, whether it be inside the city of Twin Falls, the Twin Falls metropolitan
[0:14:30] statistical area, the state of Idaho, or the national rate. At the beginning of
[0:14:37] our process, I have a conversation with the members of our long-term planning
[0:14:42] team. Our long-term planning team is really the group that should take the
[0:14:47] credit for the great proposal that they put forward.
[0:14:52] It is a cross collection of individuals, cross-start organization at different levels, and they put
[0:15:00] together a recommendation for the core leadership team to review, to consider, and then collectively
[0:15:07] we balance that, trying to follow these different budgetary strategies.
[0:15:11] You'll see a green check, but you're one of those, because I believe the budget that we
[0:15:17] presented to you through this process.
[0:15:21] Meet every single one of the milestones that we've achieved.
[0:15:26] So let's talk about the budget.
[0:15:28] The City of Twin Falls total taxable value is increased.
[0:15:33] You can see that the net expenses are up
[0:15:35] by about $10 million and we'll talk about
[0:15:38] what those look like.
[0:15:39] Remember, the council has awarded $8.5 million
[0:15:42] of CARES money.
[0:15:43] We have bond payments associated
[0:15:46] or season up on payments.
[0:15:47] We have certificates of participation payments
[0:15:50] that are included in these dollars.
[0:15:52] And so you can see that there's about $5 million
[0:15:58] or slightly less in the tax-supported funds.
[0:16:00] And there's another $5 million in the non-tax-supported
[0:16:06] or the enterprise funds.
[0:16:08] The budget utilizes a 3% increase in property tax revenue,
[0:16:12] 90% of the new construction and the taxation
[0:16:14] roll values, 80% of the projected value of the urban renewal areas, 4-1 and 4, and it uses
[0:16:25] 1% of the foregone revenue as we continue to drive that number towards zero.
[0:16:33] It asks for a 2.5% increase associated with water, a 2.5% increase associated with sewer,
[0:16:41] And it will be a nominal increase that is going to be associated with sanitation.
[0:16:46] We are still in negotiations with PSI, and we haven't got that number yet, but we'll bring
[0:16:49] that to you as soon as we do.
[0:16:53] So here's the value of the City of Twin Falls as we continue to grow.
[0:16:57] You can see that the value has gone up by half a million dollars or just slightly less than.
[0:17:04] And more importantly, the City of Twin Falls' value has grown by more than 51% in the last
[0:17:13] fiscal years. So the value of the growth of the City of Twin Falls is almost
[0:17:21] equal to the total value of the City of Twin Falls in 2013 and that excludes all
[0:17:29] of the properties that are included into an urban or rural area. They've often
[0:17:34] said that one of the greatest indicators of an overall economic health of an
[0:17:39] organization of a community is how its total value, or the value of the community is growing,
[0:17:47] and we're seeing that here, arguably, and as Brianna has shared in past presentations,
[0:17:58] the largest place of growth and the largest place that has absorbed more of that property tax burden
[0:18:05] is largely placed upon the residential property owners'
[0:18:09] shoulders, as the valuations for residential properties have
[0:18:15] increased significantly by comparison to all other sectors.
[0:18:19] They are having to consume more of that pie,
[0:18:25] and we believe that there are two strategies, and we will continue to talk
[0:18:28] about these two strategies. Number one, we believe that indexing
[0:18:32] of properties should be restored, the legislature removed that.
[0:18:37] And then the second thing we believe is that a local option sales tax to take advantage of
[0:18:42] all those additional resale sales inside the City of Twin Falls should be a legislative
[0:18:47] priority for our community as we continue to move forward.
[0:18:52] The citizens of the City of Twin Falls, all nearly 56,000 strong, are supplying the services
[0:19:00] to a daytime population, in some cases, that is double.
[0:19:06] And that is the clearest form of subsidy that I know.
[0:19:11] So you can see that the tax rate we're projecting to be
[0:19:14] similar in this upcoming year.
[0:19:16] As we kind of move forward, you'll notice that the fiscal year 24 is noted in green,
[0:19:23] and the prior year is noted in blue.
[0:19:26] And you can see that we've been working the property tax rate downward over the course of the last several years.
[0:19:36] And this tax rate is among the lowest.
[0:19:40] And I will also say that it is still early.
[0:19:43] There is still considerable fluctuations that could occur in this tax rate just because it is a relatively complex math formula.
[0:19:54] And in that mathematical formula, there are some significant inputs that have not been fully defined yet, namely the value of the Urban Renewal Agency upon its closure and how it will flow back in.
[0:20:07] We continue to work with the Assessors Office.
[0:20:09] The Assessor continues to work with the Tax Commission Office.
[0:20:12] We believe that we have a very close tax rate for your and changes will be insignificant, but you can see that we go up for the tax.
[0:20:23] that we go up pretty far in the decimal points and then we do expect some slight
[0:20:29] changes to that as we move forward. You can also see that there are two numbers
[0:20:37] here this first one, 116.9 million dollars which should be shaded in green
[0:20:43] and then 170 million dollars both of them are considered to be new construction
[0:20:48] numbers this year by the way Idaho code is structured after House Bill
[0:20:54] The $116.9 million as associated with all of the new buildings and structures and taxable
[0:21:01] values that came onto the tax world in the prior year.
[0:21:05] The city has the ability to take 90% of that value and incorporate it into its property
[0:21:12] tax calculations.
[0:21:14] The closure of an urban or renewal agency, the city and all other taxing entities have
[0:21:21] the ability to take 80% of that value.
[0:21:24] And so that equals to $170.7 million.
[0:21:29] That number is the number that is in question.
[0:21:32] And that's the best number that we have right now.
[0:21:36] Because of a series of law changes that have occurred
[0:21:39] since our urban renewal was created.
[0:21:44] Prior to 2006, every local government entity
[0:21:48] had the ability to capture the value of new construction that
[0:21:52] occurred in an urban renewal area.
[0:21:55] And the city did take some portion of that value.
[0:21:59] And so the 170 represents the net value,
[0:22:03] where the value that the city did not
[0:22:05] take as a result of the law change in 2006,
[0:22:08] from 2006 through present year.
[0:22:13] So we do expect some slight changes.
[0:22:15] And we say slight changes.
[0:22:17] We're talking in the hundreds of thousands of dollars in value, which would constitute
[0:22:23] very slight changes in the total overall tax rate.
[0:22:33] Another thing that we're closely watching is building permit revenue, and you can see
[0:22:37] that building permit revenue in fiscal year 21 exceeded all of our expectations, and that
[0:22:45] in fiscal year 22, and in fiscal year 23, it had softened.
[0:22:50] And to the point where in this upcoming fiscal year 24,
[0:22:54] we've made calculated reductions in what total building permits
[0:22:58] would be.
[0:23:00] And I think that the first is that you're looking,
[0:23:05] there were some supply chain issues,
[0:23:08] and then there were some labor issues.
[0:23:10] And now there are some mortgage rate issues.
[0:23:14] The good thing for us as an organization
[0:23:16] is we've been relatively consistent
[0:23:19] in the amount of money that we've budgeted moving forward.
[0:23:23] So where you see the spike of nearly $1.7 million
[0:23:27] in just building permit revenues,
[0:23:28] that does not include the mechanical, electrical,
[0:23:31] and plumbing.
[0:23:32] This is just the physical structure of the building permit.
[0:23:35] We have not fallen for the trap of believing
[0:23:40] that those building permit revenues
[0:23:43] at record pace levels were always going to continue.
[0:23:46] And the result of that is that we're not having to make wholesale changes, holdbacks, or reductions
[0:23:54] in levels of service.
[0:23:57] So we're looking at this year, and we believe that we're going to be really close to hitting
[0:24:04] fiscal year 23.
[0:24:08] We may be $100,000 off in revenue, but we believe that with the position holdbacks that
[0:24:15] we've made will be able to cover the revenues that we don't realize, as well as we have other
[0:24:24] revenues that are outperforming, such as electrical franchise fees and Brianna spent a considerable
[0:24:32] time talking about that with you at her last finance report.
[0:24:36] So, we're being conservative and just as when we introduce category B, should revenues outpace
[0:24:47] what we're projecting, we will approach the council in the middle of fiscal year 24, and
[0:24:53] we will present to you a slate of possible projects that you would be able to spend those
[0:24:57] unanticipated revenues on, none of which would change the tax rate, but it would allow us
[0:25:03] to accomplish things that we weren't able to include in this year's budget.
[0:25:07] Any questions so far?
[0:25:13] Hey Travis, a quick question on the recently closed revenue allocation areas.
[0:25:17] So my assumption was that the 80% value that we can utilize, that's for the first fiscal
[0:25:25] year and then the next fiscal year that just goes on to the overall basket of taxable value,
[0:25:33] is that correct?
[0:25:34] Yeah, so the total taxable value of the revenue allocation area is in the denominator.
[0:25:44] The revenue portion of it is in the numerator.
[0:25:49] And so the denominator will be the full value.
[0:25:53] Our ability to claim the revenue is that 80% and then moving forward it turns into the
[0:26:00] the base and then the council has the ability to take 3% more property tax revenue the following
[0:26:07] year than they did the prior year. So that loss of 20% is a lost opportunity into perpetuity.
[0:26:17] Thank you. No, because this is for us. In an urban rural area, you're absolutely right.
[0:26:28] It's just like an investment or an annuity. You invest, but when it comes back to a city
[0:26:34] and they have those mandatory reductions, it is lost forever.
[0:26:41] So one of the things that we're often asked is,
[0:26:43] how does the City of Twin Falls compare
[0:26:45] to all of the other cities?
[0:26:48] And this is just a focus on city taxes.
[0:26:53] We do not have the ability to control
[0:26:55] what other taxable or taxing entities inside
[0:27:00] of the City of Twin Falls charge.
[0:27:04] And we only have the ability to reflect on what we do.
[0:27:09] And so this is a rear looking approach.
[0:27:12] This is how our budget for fiscal year 23,
[0:27:17] calendar year 22 and 23,
[0:27:23] how that compared to other communities.
[0:27:25] And you can see that it cost less than $3,
[0:27:30] dollars or in Twin Falls than it did in Caldwell and both the City of Twin Falls
[0:27:37] and the City of Caldwell were among the lowest when you take a look at their
[0:27:42] tax rate which is applied to us by looking at the associated taxpayers of
[0:27:48] Idaho Levy book and then the value of property as determined by Zillow. I know
[0:27:54] people love Zillow or they hate Zillow but it is the most consistent source that
[0:27:59] that we have to be able to utilize,
[0:28:01] and then you can see what that looks like moving forward.
[0:28:06] As people on the council who have gone through this for years,
[0:28:09] you'll notice that the city of Nampa
[0:28:12] is now another one of those cities that has been excluded,
[0:28:19] where we exclude and have excluded both Meridian and Boise
[0:28:25] because of their connection with the Ada County Highway
[0:28:28] district and how the tax rate for the cities of Boise and Meridian do not include funding
[0:28:34] a street operation.
[0:28:37] Some new developments occurred in the city of Napa in which the city of Napa turned over
[0:28:41] its fire department to the Napa Rural Fire Protection and we know as you look at our budget,
[0:28:49] the amount of resources that are spent on fire departments is significant.
[0:28:53] And so because it's not a true apples to apples comparison with the city of Napa anymore,
[0:28:59] we have now excluded them from that process as well.
[0:29:03] So you can see that the City of Twin Falls
[0:29:06] remains incredibly competitive when
[0:29:09] it takes a look at the total cost of the level of services
[0:29:15] that we provide for our citizens.
[0:29:18] So this is a look at the totality of the budget,
[0:29:23] whether it be in the government funds,
[0:29:27] or the non-tax supported funds, and the tax supported funds,
[0:29:32] as well as personnel costs, operations, capital, debt
[0:29:36] service transfers.
[0:29:43] So the city of Twin Falls continues
[0:29:45] to be a lean organization.
[0:29:49] We are adding 2.5 or adding a net of 2.5 budget,
[0:29:55] or F2 full-time equivalents into this budget.
[0:29:57] Those positions are listed there.
[0:30:00] But we're also removing one.
[0:30:01] So you can see that there's three and a half positions
[0:30:05] that we're adding and we're removing one from the budget,
[0:30:08] that one decision that we're moving
[0:30:09] is the building inspector position
[0:30:12] and credit to Matthew Long.
[0:30:15] Matthew came forward into the budget process
[0:30:18] and as you saw what building premier revenues look like,
[0:30:21] it was the position that we have on hold for this year.
[0:30:24] Matthew in forecasting forward,
[0:30:27] having great conversations with members
[0:30:29] of the building community,
[0:30:30] believed that was a position that he could give up
[0:30:34] in his department and that those resources
[0:30:36] could be dedicated to another department
[0:30:39] to be able to meet those needs.
[0:30:41] And so when we talk about One City,
[0:30:42] we talk about our organization working collaboratively.
[0:30:45] That is a great example of that.
[0:30:48] You can see that our operation and maintenance costs
[0:30:50] are continuing to increase.
[0:30:52] Some of the largest pieces of that
[0:30:55] are going to be the increases that we're seeing
[0:30:58] in electrical costs and the increases that we have seen
[0:31:01] over the course of the last year for fuel costs.
[0:31:04] Electrical is on a step series of step increases
[0:31:07] where over a period of time of less than 18 months,
[0:31:12] I believe it's a 25% increase.
[0:31:16] When you think about the size of our pumps
[0:31:18] and how mechanized our water and waste water systems are,
[0:31:26] you can begin to see that a lot of those costs
[0:31:28] are going to be attributed to rated and the need.
[0:31:33] And those increases in cost are one of the primary factors in what's driving the need
[0:31:39] to raise our sewer and water rates to make sure that we have the resources to be able
[0:31:44] to cover those costs that we can't help.
[0:31:49] You can also see that this is one of the largest capital funding thing, our capital budgets
[0:31:57] that we have.
[0:31:58] What we're going to do is we're going to spend a lot of time going through the capital on a
[0:32:04] piece-by-piece process, but what I wanted to do tonight is I will provide a high-level approach.
[0:32:10] This is our strategic plan.
[0:32:12] This really becomes the guidepost of our organization and the thing that we try to fund moving forward.
[0:32:19] We will begin the process of updating our strategic plan later this fiscal year.
[0:32:23] in members of the team have started that process now where they're evaluating the current conditions.
[0:32:30] And so if you're familiar with our strategic plan, you'll talk about the conditions in 2012,
[0:32:35] the conditions of the city in 2018 in each of the focus areas in Gretchen right now is going through that process.
[0:32:41] Talking about the conditions, the operating environment, the emerging trends and issues that we're seeing in 23 as we prep for that change to our fiscal year.
[0:32:52] But again, the heart of our organization are the employees of our organization because
[0:32:59] they're the ones that are delivering the services and that's why they are in the center to help
[0:33:03] us realize the vision.
[0:33:06] So Focus Area 1.
[0:33:08] Focus Area 1 describes the vision that we're hoping to fund, hoping to realize.
[0:33:16] The way to look at the vision is in 2030 if we were to move forward with that time machine
[0:33:25] and find our flux capacitor.
[0:33:28] We would be able to hopefully see this is that community
[0:33:34] that we have been striving to reach,
[0:33:38] where it has a broad commitment to the overall health
[0:33:41] of our community and our visitors.
[0:33:44] Then we put into connection a series of goals,
[0:33:48] key intended outcomes, and then we move forward
[0:33:51] on how we're going to find those.
[0:33:52] And so some of the highlights this year,
[0:33:54] You can see that we're going to make upgrades to City Park with using CDBG funds to prove
[0:34:00] that project.
[0:34:01] Those funds have been allocated and estimated cost of about $500,000.
[0:34:06] With parking lots across our organization and in particular around OpenSpace, and so we're
[0:34:10] continuing to maintain those parking lots and Wendy does so in partnership with our street
[0:34:16] team.
[0:34:19] We have some pool circulation concerns.
[0:34:23] So John, Paulie, and members of the team
[0:34:25] are taking a look at some fixes to the pool circulation,
[0:34:28] to the pumps, as well as making sure
[0:34:30] that the surface is safe.
[0:34:31] And so they're looking at some anti-slip surfing
[0:34:35] and then maintaining the parks requires equipment.
[0:34:38] And so we have a lawnmower.
[0:34:41] It's certainly much more expensive
[0:34:43] than the lawnmowers that you and I would buy.
[0:34:46] But I would also argue that none of us
[0:34:48] trying to push a lawnmower through 12 acres of Sunnways soccer field.
[0:34:58] Vision number two is really about a learning community is where we focus on the library.
[0:35:05] And so Tara will be in to share with her library report like she does on an annual basis as
[0:35:11] well as share what their plans are moving forward.
[0:35:16] You can see public safety is a cornerstone of this budget, especially with the level expenditures.
[0:35:25] Police, fire, building safety, communications are all part of that secure community initiative
[0:35:34] where the community feels safe and what does it take for us to ensure not only that feeling
[0:35:40] of safety, but also being able to deliver services in which they are truly safe.
[0:35:49] The next is going to be an accessible community, it's going to talk not only about roadways,
[0:35:55] but it's also going to talk about our airport, it's going to talk about trails, it's going
[0:36:00] to talk about multimodal transportation, and you can see that a large piece of this project
[0:36:06] is really to deal with the asphalt that we have within our community, to maintain the
[0:36:12] road miles, members of the street team and members of the airport team will be in to
[0:36:20] talk about their projects as we move forward.
[0:36:26] I think what makes Twin Falls great is it's unparalleled natural scenic beauty.
[0:36:31] There was a great piece in the Times News about culture and land and that's part of that
[0:36:38] environmental stewardship is to make sure that we have the ability to continue to
[0:36:45] grow, to continue to remote, and to continue to ensure that the environment in
[0:36:51] which we play and direct rate and live continues to be well cared for. And so
[0:36:57] you can see that there's four million dollars going to Jacobs Engineering to
[0:37:01] operate the wastewater treatment facility. There's $1.5 million to ensure that the
[0:37:06] clarifiers are functioning properly so that as those waters are returned back into the
[0:37:12] snake that they are cleaner than the water that is going by, you can see their improvements
[0:37:18] to wells.
[0:37:19] We're going to continue to invest in our wells to ensure that the water supply system is there
[0:37:25] and we're going to continue to do mainline replacement.
[0:37:28] That mainline replacement number is one of the largest mainline replacement numbers that
[0:37:33] we've ever put forward and we're able to do that because of the way in which the council
[0:37:42] allowed us to restructure the bond payment and to be able to turn that into a large capital
[0:37:50] operating fund.
[0:37:51] A prosperous community is really talking about securing the airport and last week Bill was
[0:38:03] able to share the revenue guarantee bays out and how delta we've shared earlier in the month
[0:38:11] is going to be offering dual class.
[0:38:13] And there's going to be a slight startup cost associated with that, but we're really excited
[0:38:17] about offering now two dual class flights out of the City of Twin Falls and returning.
[0:38:24] And then also talks about the establishment of an additional revenue allocation area in
[0:38:28] the downtown, old town area, where we want to use the urban renewal platform, which is
[0:38:34] truly one of the only platforms that localities have to assist in fueling economic development.
[0:38:42] Being a responsible community means being and promoting engagement, and we want to make
[0:38:47] sure that we're also reviewing performance and finding new ways in which we can offer
[0:38:52] higher levels of services in an era of uncertainty and reduced costs.
[0:38:56] And so it allocates $17,000 to the citizen survey.
[0:39:00] We have time and talent dedicated to process review.
[0:39:03] We refer to it as Q2.
[0:39:05] It is not actual dollars that we're allocating, but it is time that we're intentionally going
[0:39:11] to spend thinking about our organization and finding ways to drive it forward.
[0:39:17] And then priority based budgeting and performance measurement is a process that we're currently
[0:39:23] continuing to undertake.
[0:39:25] The other piece of that is the $770,000, which is the Council directed capital.
[0:39:31] Over the course of the next several weeks, you're going to have members of our team share
[0:39:37] with you items that did not make the cut into this budget.
[0:39:42] You're also hopefully going to hear from citizens who are going to engage, and they're also going
[0:39:47] to be able to share with you their ideas and thoughts on how these dollars can be expended.
[0:39:53] and the Council will have choices to make on the 770 and know that every week will kind of
[0:39:59] build a list and that we hope that right around the first meeting in August when you've received
[0:40:06] all the presentations on all the focus areas, we'll be able to begin that process of assigning
[0:40:12] those dollars to projects.
[0:40:15] The good news is you don't have to have it done until the 21st, largely because the revenues
[0:40:22] on the front end and the revenue on the receiving end
[0:40:25] and the expenditure end have balanced out.
[0:40:27] So they just have 770 directed capital,
[0:40:30] 770 directed capital on the expenditure side,
[0:40:33] and you'll be able to move that forward.
[0:40:36] In our terminal organization, we talk about everything
[0:40:39] that we believe is important to move forward,
[0:40:41] not only in terms of compensation,
[0:40:44] but also in terms of capital.
[0:40:45] And that list is here, and we'll dedicate an entire evening
[0:40:49] where IDEA members of the HR team in Gretchen will talk to you about the great things that
[0:40:56] we're doing in the area of One City Boot Camp Training as well as the compensation models
[0:41:01] and moving forward.
[0:41:04] And we always share with you that we look at compensation and complete compensation.
[0:41:08] We don't look at compensation in just the salary dollars, but it is what is that net take home
[0:41:13] and health insurance continues to be important.
[0:41:16] It also continues to be one of those things that is a considerable cost and this shows
[0:41:22] how those costs have increased.
[0:41:25] It also shows on this chart changes that we've intentionally tried to bend that cost curve.
[0:41:32] We continue to work with Select Health.
[0:41:33] We've continued to look at being partially self-insured.
[0:41:37] We look and have conversations with other carriers while we're not planning on making
[0:41:43] any changes this year at this point in time for this fiscal year know that we are very
[0:41:49] conscious of where these dollars are being spent because it means that it is an opportunity
[0:41:56] that we're not able to capture somewhere else for our employees.
[0:42:01] So that's a very high overview of the budget under an hour even.
[0:42:11] And we recognize that there's a lot that's thrown at you in this process.
[0:42:19] That's why we want to make ourselves available to answer any questions.
[0:42:23] So you'll see that there are members of the City's Executive Leadership Team that are
[0:42:28] here and that we will have members of our team present in each one of these focus areas.
[0:42:34] And while we may not have the exact answer to your questions in those evenings, we will
[0:42:40] commit to reporting to you at the following council meeting with those ideas.
[0:42:48] So we'll continue through the exploration of the focus areas.
[0:42:51] On August 7th, we'll ask you to adopt what's referred to as the preliminary budget.
[0:42:55] The preliminary budget sets the maximum spending gap.
[0:42:59] It can go downward.
[0:43:00] It cannot exceed that number that you set.
[0:43:03] And then we'll host a public hearing on the 21st with anticipation of also adopting the
[0:43:08] budget that night.
[0:43:09] And then you can see the staff deadlines to move forward in accordance with Idaho Code
[0:43:15] during the month of September.
[0:43:17] of that. Any questions? Any questions for Travis at this point? Is that a great
[0:43:28] president? Thank you. Okay, that's the only item of consideration tonight. So next
[0:43:40] item on the agenda is the time for general public input. There's anybody in
[0:43:45] the public that wishes to come down and address City Council? You're welcome to?
[0:43:52] Seeing no one advisory board reports.
[0:43:58] Anything from council on advisory boards?
[0:44:02] Just a couple of notes.
[0:44:03] Tomorrow night is back the blue at City Park,
[0:44:07] or Wednesday night, I'm sorry.
[0:44:09] Tomorrow night is the fireworks at CSI.
[0:44:14] We have no public here,
[0:44:15] anything from city manager's office.
[0:44:18] We have no public hearings tonight.
[0:44:20] Next item on the agenda is executive session,
[0:44:24] an action item to communicate with legal counsel for the public agency to discuss the
[0:44:29] legal ramifications of and legal options for pending litigation or controversies not yet
[0:44:36] being litigated, but imminently likely to be litigated.
[0:44:40] The mere presence of legal counsel in an executive session does not satisfy this requirement.
[0:44:45] Thank you.
[0:44:48] Do I have a second?
[0:44:49] Second.
[0:44:50] Thank you.
[0:44:51] Motion by Chris Reed.
[0:44:52] second by Alex to go ball to move into executive session under nine a F. Amy
[0:45:02] roll call vote please. Chris Reed. Yes. Nikki Boyd. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. Spencer
[0:45:12] Cutler. Yes. Alex Koval. Yes. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes six to zero. I just
[0:45:20] want to remind everybody we will not be making any decisions and we will not be
[0:45:25] reconvening in chambers so meeting this adjourned thank you
