Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2022-12-12, recording 1 (started 16:58)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2022-12-12/

[0:01:31] Good evening ladies and gentlemen and welcome to our December 12, 2022 City Council meeting. I want to confirm we have a quorum. We have all seven members here in chambers.
[0:01:43] First I'm on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. If you wish to join me please rise.
[0:01:49] I have states of America, and she can be probably before we just stay.
[0:02:00] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
[0:02:09] Thank you.
[0:02:10] Next, we have no proclamations tonight, so next on the agenda is the consent calendar.
[0:02:18] Big Hawkins.
[0:02:19] Mayor would like to make a motion to approve the consent calendar as written.
[0:02:23] Thank you.
[0:02:24] Do I have a second?
[0:02:25] Second.
[0:02:26] Thank you, Nikki.
[0:02:27] Emotion by Craig Hawkins.
[0:02:28] Second.
[0:02:29] I would like to approve the consent calendar as written.
[0:02:32] Amy Roll call vote please.
[0:02:36] Ruth Pierce?
[0:02:36] Yes.
[0:02:37] Chris Reed?
[0:02:38] Yes.
[0:02:38] Nikki Boyd?
[0:02:39] Yes.
[0:02:39] Ray Cawkins?
[0:02:40] Yes.
[0:02:41] Mason Brown?
[0:02:41] Yes.
[0:02:42] Spencer Cutler?
[0:02:43] Yes.
[0:02:44] And Alex Cabot?
[0:02:45] Yes.
[0:02:46] Thank you.
[0:02:46] Motion passes 70-0.
[0:02:49] Next item under items of consideration is an action item.
[0:02:55] A request to confirm the mayoral appointment
[0:02:57] Sherry Vollmer to the historic preservation commission and we have Lisa Strickland our city plan. Hello
[0:03:04] That was an awful city planner. Good evening, Mayor Pierce Council
[0:03:09] This is a request to confirm an appointment of Sherry Vollmer to the historic preservation commission
[0:03:15] The commission has had three vacancies to fill over the past few months
[0:03:19] So the city published a request for volunteers during the month of September and we had three applicants which were
[0:03:25] were submitted for the open seats.
[0:03:28] The city council liaison, Cutler, Chairman Doug Baldwin,
[0:03:32] and City Planner, myself, we interviewed the applicants
[0:03:37] and the interview team found all three candidates
[0:03:40] to be very qualified and committed to furthering
[0:03:44] the goals of the end objectives
[0:03:46] of this sort of preservation commission.
[0:03:48] The interview team forwarded this information
[0:03:50] to the mayor and we would like to propose
[0:03:52] that Sherry Wilmer be confirmed as a new member
[0:03:54] on the historic preservation commission.
[0:03:56] And should she be appointed,
[0:03:58] she will be completing a partial term
[0:04:01] that will expire June 30th of 2024.
[0:04:05] So basically a simple majority of the city councils
[0:04:08] needed to approve the request
[0:04:10] and approval of this request will fill our third vacancy
[0:04:13] on the historic preservation.
[0:04:15] We recommend confirmation.
[0:04:17] Thank you.
[0:04:18] Jason Brown.
[0:04:20] If there's no discussion, I'll make a motion.
[0:04:24] Perfect.
[0:04:25] I move to approve Sherry Volmer to the Historical Preservation Commission.
[0:04:30] Thank you.
[0:04:31] Do I have a second?
[0:04:32] Second.
[0:04:33] Thank you.
[0:04:34] Motion by Jason Brown.
[0:04:35] Seconded by Spencer Cutler to confirm the mayoral appointment of Sherry Volmer to the Historic Preservation Commission.
[0:04:42] Amy Rokow, please.
[0:04:44] Chris Reed.
[0:04:46] Yes.
[0:04:47] Thank you.
[0:04:48] Boyd.
[0:04:49] Yes.
[0:04:50] Jason Brown.
[0:04:51] Yes.
[0:04:52] Alex Koval.
[0:04:53] Yes.
[0:04:54] Spencer Cutler.
[0:04:55] Thank you. Motion passes 7-0. So we have two options, Sherri. You can get up and speak if you'd like or you don't have to.
[0:05:03] It's about 50-50 on who doesn't, who doesn't. So push your little button, the green or...
[0:05:12] There we go. Okay. Thank you very much for this and I look forward to helping the city and helping the committee.
[0:05:20] Thank you, Sherri. Welcome.
[0:05:24] Okay, next item on the agenda is a presentation. It's the water facility plan and pressurized irrigation plan presentations
[0:05:32] And we have Lee Gleismann staff engineer. Welcome Lee
[0:05:37] Good evening mayor council. I've got two parts to this presentation tonight first part is gonna be the water facility plan
[0:05:45] Which I Gary Hatterley with JUB will will be presenting and then I'll follow that up with the master PI plan
[0:05:52] And then we'll talk about budget perfect. Thank you
[0:05:56] Perfect.
[0:06:22] All right.
[0:06:23] Good evening, Mayor.
[0:06:25] Councilwoman and Van, it's a pleasure to be here tonight.
[0:06:29] I'm Gary Hatterley with JUB and Mark Holson, who I'm sure many of you know, is in the audience
[0:06:35] with us as well, but we have many other staff including Timothy Kill and others listed there
[0:06:41] who have helped us with this.
[0:06:44] So we've prepared a water facilities plan based on many meetings and input from your dedicated
[0:06:53] staff primarily in your engineering and public works department but also with
[0:06:57] city administration with finance with legal utilities apartment we've had a
[0:07:04] lot of discussions across a broad swath of the city and based on all that input
[0:07:10] we've prepared updated a water model that analyzes the water system for the
[0:07:16] whole city we've put in inputs for every single parcel within the city that could
[0:07:22] build to have something on that. And so we're excited to be able to share some of that with
[0:07:28] you tonight. To start out, I wanted to talk a little bit about water planning and master
[0:07:39] planning, if you will. So what is master planning? What should this do for you? This is a high-level
[0:07:46] planning process for your water system that we're trying to align the goals of your strategic
[0:07:51] plan and your comprehensive plan and to make improvements and look at what needs
[0:07:57] to happen to stay in alignment with that focus that you have as a city. It allows
[0:08:02] you to understand and tackle big picture items as well as big risk items. It allows
[0:08:08] you to define how you want the city to grow and prosper and finally it helps
[0:08:14] us understand the capital improvement priorities the infrastructure needs that
[0:08:19] that will have an estimated cost to implement them.
[0:08:24] That will then help you as you come up this next year
[0:08:26] with your budgeting for your water system.
[0:08:28] So that's kind of the big picture items.
[0:08:31] And so what do we even talk about tonight then?
[0:08:34] First, we'll talk a little bit about the existing system.
[0:08:37] Make sure you have familiarity with that.
[0:08:39] And we'll talk about water supply and demand
[0:08:42] and the evaluation of the system.
[0:08:44] And then finally, we'll talk about some of the improvements
[0:08:47] that we've come up with.
[0:08:50] So, before we get going too much more though,
[0:08:54] what are some of the successes that the city has had
[0:08:57] over the last 10 years or so?
[0:08:59] I think it's important to point out some of this.
[0:09:01] Sometimes we forget all of the things that have happened.
[0:09:04] And so, prior to this master plan,
[0:09:07] we began previously some planning processes
[0:09:09] almost 10 years ago,
[0:09:11] and you can see quite a long list,
[0:09:13] it's not even a comprehensive list,
[0:09:15] but a long list of a number of things.
[0:09:17] I just wanted to go over just a couple of those things.
[0:09:20] First of all, as many of you are aware, the Harrison Storage Tank has been undersized
[0:09:24] for many years.
[0:09:25] In order to build that tank, we've had a choir land.
[0:09:28] The city was able to do that in 2017.
[0:09:31] It's such a big deal.
[0:09:33] As you may also know, for many, many years, the Will's Wooster Pump Station was not doing
[0:09:39] well, and that was able to be replaced here in the last few years.
[0:09:44] Many other successes here, but this kind of success comes out of master planning and
[0:09:48] thinking through your goals, and you can just see what, you know, pat yourselves in the back,
[0:09:54] a lot of good stuff has been done there.
[0:09:56] Alright, so kind of jumping back into more of the master planning process then.
[0:10:01] In case you're not familiar with the water system, we just wanted to review it briefly.
[0:10:05] Up on the very north end of the city, we have four wells, the blue lakes wells, as they're
[0:10:10] called.
[0:10:11] Those provide the majority of the water for the city, and those provide the, or that provides
[0:10:17] the water that meets all the water quality, constituent, their concerns, the EPA has, so
[0:10:26] that's our best water and our most water.
[0:10:29] Down in the south, we also have several south wells that provide the most efficient water
[0:10:33] for the city and that blends with the blue lakes of the well water.
[0:10:38] The yellow lines, let's see, is this mouse, it's not pointing, however you can see those
[0:10:45] Those yellow lines are some of the major pipelines that supply the water throughout
[0:10:49] the city to several pump stations.
[0:10:51] And on the right there, you can see just a few statistics about the water system over
[0:10:56] 300 miles of pipe.
[0:11:03] As I continue on here, I'm anticipating that we may be able to take some questions at the
[0:11:07] end, if you will.
[0:11:08] But if you feel like there's a question as I'm going here, feel free to jump in, I don't
[0:11:12] mind.
[0:11:15] So next, let's talk a little bit about water supply.
[0:11:23] What kind of water supply does the city have and what's going to be needed?
[0:11:27] We asked Brockway engineers to help with the groundwater modeling
[0:11:31] to prepare some of these graphs that have done that for us for many years before the city.
[0:11:35] So typically for capital improvements, the things that you're going to need to build a budget for now,
[0:11:41] we want to look at the next around 10 to 20 years, and that's what we put in our plan.
[0:11:46] When we start talking about water supply and water rights,
[0:11:50] The state of Idaho allows us to look out to 50 years or longer because that's such a critical
[0:11:56] item that you acquire those water rights. The state's guidance isn't exacting, but again,
[0:12:04] it allows us cities to be able to prepare for that. So, as you can see on this graph here on the bottom
[0:12:12] graph is the Blue Lakes Wells. On the top graph is the South Wells. There's been some decline in both
[0:12:17] these for many years. If you see in the Blue Lakes Wells, you can see that the
[0:12:22] jagged up and down has gone up the last couple years. This is in part due to
[0:12:27] some recharge efforts and also outside of the last year or two where you know
[0:12:31] we've had a drought that wasn't quite the case prior to that and so the water
[0:12:35] had come up. Because of the time frame of the recharge versus somebody's
[0:12:41] other metrics is such a short time frame, Rockway didn't feel entirely confident
[0:12:46] that recharged was the entire reason it has come up and so they've tried to
[0:12:51] conservatively estimate for the city what that water supply trend will continue
[0:12:56] to be going forward and as you can see there's a forecast that it will continue
[0:13:01] to have some declines even though there's always been some ups and downs in that
[0:13:04] water period. Again our focus for immediate needs is the next 20 years but
[0:13:10] I think it's important to point out for the city that all of the water rights that
[0:13:14] you currently have will not be enough even in the future. And so when you consider acquiring
[0:13:22] additional water rights or making negotiations with that, just please bear that in mind.
[0:13:27] When the city continues to fill out to the comprehensive plan area, all of the water
[0:13:34] that you have is currently needed as some. Now on the current capital improvement plan,
[0:13:41] we don't have to tackle all of that right now. But water rights has been constantly an ongoing
[0:13:46] discussion that we've had with many entities in the city, and it's something that you should
[0:13:50] need to keep at the forefront of your mind. So, on this graph again, I just want to make
[0:13:58] sure that you're clear. The Blue Lakes graph you can see there is a combination of not
[0:14:02] only the city's water, but several other entities that procure water from Blue Lakes, and those
[0:14:09] combined water rights are represented on this graph. The city is a portion of those, and
[0:14:16] Again, you can see that that is going down.
[0:14:19] Talk a little more about that in a minute here.
[0:14:22] So what kind, going to the next slide here,
[0:14:25] what kind of demand for water does the city have
[0:14:29] and how has this changed?
[0:14:32] So first of all, we wanted to just look
[0:14:33] at how has this changed over time.
[0:14:35] Back in 2003, the city was using over 30 million gallons
[0:14:39] a day of water, that's that blue lined up top.
[0:14:46] And you can see that it's actually gone down
[0:14:49] any M.G.D. over the last 20 years. It was kind of a quandary in 2008-19 when we were doing
[0:14:56] the last Master Plan update. We weren't entirely sure why this was, but that's right when the
[0:15:01] recession had hit. So it was a little difficult to peace out with confidence that was an economic
[0:15:06] attrition or other reasons. But you can see that on this graph, the very biggest reason
[0:15:12] for the decline has been the pressure irrigation stations that have gone in. And that blue line
[0:15:17] represents peak demand in the summer time use. The red line down at the bottom is
[0:15:23] winter time demand and you can see it's going up a little bit or almost flat but
[0:15:29] as the city has continued to grow there has been some demand but due to back
[0:15:33] several decades ago an energy policy act that was enacted the amount of water used
[0:15:38] per house continues to go down so even though growth has gone up individual
[0:15:42] household water has gone down and the net effect of that has been in general as
[0:15:46] you can see kind of a declining of water over this time period.
[0:15:50] Now, the city has caught up on most of the pressure
[0:15:52] irrigation at this point.
[0:15:54] We don't expect that trend to continue.
[0:15:56] And so when we start looking at future,
[0:15:59] we have to analyze what kind of growth rate might
[0:16:01] you be looking at.
[0:16:02] We looked at several different growth rates.
[0:16:04] But in short, over the next 20 years,
[0:16:07] they're not substantially different.
[0:16:09] The longer time period they are, for this plan,
[0:16:11] we looked at 1.8% growth rate.
[0:16:13] That was what was selected, I should say, by city staff.
[0:16:21] Okay, so now we wanted to look at based on that 1.8%
[0:16:25] as well as some possibilities for industrial
[0:16:28] or level large growth.
[0:16:29] What would the demand be in the future?
[0:16:31] And you can see that we're expecting to go
[0:16:33] from this 23 or 24 million gallons a day back up
[0:16:36] to at least 28 and a half million gallons a day
[0:16:40] over the next 20 years.
[0:16:42] Interestingly, you can see that's a little bit less,
[0:16:44] has been used historically.
[0:16:48] But with better city meters and a better handle on all of this,
[0:16:51] we feel much more confident about where the city's headed.
[0:16:55] This projection of going up continues to account
[0:16:58] for some declining in household use with the Energy Act.
[0:17:02] Okay, on the top right of that graph,
[0:17:04] can you guys see that brown line going down?
[0:17:08] That represents the city's water supply
[0:17:12] during the low groundwater aquifer time of year,
[0:17:15] which is typically around May or June, April, May, June.
[0:17:18] So in May or June, the demand is coming up because of irrigation and also the supply is going down and so that biggest supply or biggest demand to low supply happens right in the major time period.
[0:17:31] And you can see over the next 20 years, those get right close to one another.
[0:17:36] And so we become very uncomfortable, if you will, from planning to hit up a line just like that.
[0:17:42] But in short, you can see with additional industrial use, as well as all the typical
[0:17:50] development we have, we expect things to go up in water supply or water demand, I should
[0:17:57] say.
[0:17:58] Alright, so continuing on.
[0:18:16] So based on that water demand, water supply numbers, we've evaluated all those many different
[0:18:22] infrastructure components.
[0:18:23] This is included the supply wells, the storage tank and booster pump stations.
[0:18:28] of the major items if you will and you can see we've noted several different colors here.
[0:18:34] The green in general means you're good.
[0:18:38] The yellow means there's a caution.
[0:18:40] We would recommend some changes there and the red are things that we think are things
[0:18:46] that more immediately need to be looked at either now or in the future.
[0:18:50] In the south you can see we've noted that as a red.
[0:18:53] Currently the south doesn't have any redundant pumps if you will for those wells down there
[0:18:59] And all the water we can pump out of the south is more cheap.
[0:19:02] We, you know, provide it to the city and this more resilient water source, if you will.
[0:19:08] You can see, as I mentioned earlier, the Harrison storage tank on the middle there has been undersized
[0:19:14] for many, many years.
[0:19:15] You might ask, well, how are we working in?
[0:19:18] How's the city running?
[0:19:21] What happens is the supply that we're supposed to be saving, if you will, for fire-flowed emergency,
[0:19:27] We're basically just, so it kind of puts the city
[0:19:30] in kind of a precarious situation, if you will.
[0:19:32] You know, when the city had less people,
[0:19:35] perhaps that was less, less, or concerned,
[0:19:37] but the more industries and the more people
[0:19:40] who really rely upon a water source,
[0:19:42] it becomes a bigger and bigger risk not to address that.
[0:19:46] Looking over at the booster pumps station,
[0:19:49] you can see that on the top station there,
[0:19:52] the canyon springs booster station,
[0:19:53] this is what pumps the water,
[0:19:54] the blue lakes water out of the canyon.
[0:19:57] this pump station was put in in the 60s and those pumps are just pumping but we
[0:20:04] don't typically expect pump stations to last that long so we are very concerned
[0:20:08] about that pump station and put that down as a yellow just we absolutely
[0:20:13] think we've got to keep track of that. The wheels visitor station we just put it
[0:20:18] in but with new development that will need another pump the Hankins pump station
[0:20:22] as well. There's a few generators that could be needed there we had some incidents
[0:20:29] on that this last summertime.
[0:20:31] Okay, we just wanted to give you one graph
[0:20:33] on some of the evaluation here.
[0:20:34] This is the Harrison Storage Tank.
[0:20:36] The blue bars there is the capacity of the tank
[0:20:40] and the green, red, and purple together
[0:20:42] represent how much volume is actually needed there each summer.
[0:20:47] So you can see we're actually well over the amount we,
[0:20:50] we are supposed to be there.
[0:20:57] This is a real detailed graph, so I apologize,
[0:20:59] it in short. This graph shows pressures throughout the system and where you see red pressure means
[0:21:06] that the city doesn't really have the right pressure there. It's either too low or too
[0:21:12] high. It's technically an orange color in the south there, but it's a little bit hard
[0:21:18] to see that. You guys are familiar with the Hankets pressures on projects we're doing
[0:21:22] right now. That's to address a great deal of those orange low pressures, but you can
[0:21:26] see up north there's also some on the west side some red high pressures that
[0:21:31] eventually will need to be addressed and there's also some additional pressure
[0:21:34] zones that we need to be made in the south eventually. If I can ask a question real
[0:21:40] quick I think it's probably go ahead go ahead and help clarify that. So just
[0:21:44] just so we everybody has a clarification what would be a good
[0:21:48] pressure rating that we would want? Thank you. So as you can see the green is
[0:21:56] is what's most of the city that's at 55 to 85 psi pressure that's what we're
[0:22:02] basically going for is a good pressure historically we've tried to be around 60
[0:22:06] psi if you get over 80 psi you can start up problems a little bit with your
[0:22:12] household PRVs and plumbing so that's kind of middle ground the state
[0:22:16] regulated pressures are 40 to 100 psi so even those pressures we are in
[0:22:22] violation of any, definitely try to tackle that. This shows what the low pressures are, or it's
[0:22:28] focused more on the low pressures. The high pressures are more evident under low demand,
[0:22:33] which is winter time. So you can see a lot more red up north in the winter time. The only way to
[0:22:43] address that is to make new pressure zone boundaries. And again, we're working on that down the southeast,
[0:22:48] we're not currently working on that up in the north, and in fact we're, this graph here just shows
[0:22:59] some fire flow requirements throughout the city and deficiencies and short where
[0:23:03] there's red or fire flow deficiencies so you can see those are scattered all
[0:23:06] throughout. Okay finally so based on all that evaluation what are some
[0:23:14] specific improvements that need to be done? We divided the improvements into
[0:23:18] existing capacity issues so not even a growth related items but things that are
[0:23:23] just problems right now and you can see at the very top of the list again is that
[0:23:27] Harrison storage tank we think it's probably about the most critical thing
[0:23:30] for the city to complete. Down in the distribution or the pipe systems within the city, you can
[0:23:37] see a number of projects that are listed there, including that Hinkins pressure zone split.
[0:23:44] Those other projects continue to dress primarily fire flow and just hold their pipe. You can
[0:23:51] see we divide this up in the time frame of zero to ten years and ten to twenty years.
[0:23:55] We realize that it's a process for you to budget and get through that. Just at a high
[0:23:59] level effort we wanted to show that timeframe. Now Lee in a minute is going to
[0:24:05] show some more specific budgeting and we looked at some of that and he'll show
[0:24:09] you that but looking at different percentages of rate increases or revenue
[0:24:13] bonds or private partnerships or just other revenue sources. This next slide goes
[0:24:21] into some kind of more redundancy resiliency items. You can see the big
[0:24:26] thing on there again is the Canyon Springs pump station. Probably our biggest
[0:24:30] concern for a state of condition, if you will, at just the age. But also on the
[0:24:38] same list, you can see that Southwell and even looking out into the future,
[0:24:43] we're going to need another South tank. The South tank can't be built, of course,
[0:24:48] unless we have land from the South tank, so we can put that down as well. I want to
[0:25:00] jump over this too fast. Any questions on this list? I think we're good. Okay. And I'm
[0:25:08] just going and looking into the future a little bit and with growth, we've
[0:25:12] We've identified a few different improvements that will be needed again, the wheels mister station, some upgrades there, the new Hankins pump station will be needed with all the growth on the east side of the city.
[0:25:23] Eventually we'll need new supply or additional supply of Hankins tank that could happen with this pipeline as long as we have water rights.
[0:25:33] So those are kind of again the main improvements that we've looked at, we spent, you know, so much effort and time with the city,
[0:25:43] Travis in particular asked us to make sure we're looking at the financing and budgeting, and going through that to look at options for the city.
[0:25:50] Again, Lee will talk about that a little bit more in a snapshot.
[0:25:55] And I know it's not so fast as I've talked here, but that is a lot of us.
[0:26:01] Any questions? Any questions for Gary?
[0:26:06] Yes, Alex.
[0:26:08] How short are we on the water rights in your opinion or growth in the next 20 years?
[0:26:15] In the next 20 years, you're okay.
[0:26:18] Okay.
[0:26:19] So you're projecting out 50 years?
[0:26:21] Is that what you were doing?
[0:26:22] Yeah, but when we look at water rights, we're looking out at, you know, with the boundary,
[0:26:26] the comprehensive plan, as we showed that earlier on the slides, in order to fill in those boundaries
[0:26:32] for water rights, we're going to need, no, I won't say too much about water rights here,
[0:26:39] water rights here, but all the water rights that you currently have access to or potentially
[0:26:44] have access to is not enough, includes all the south, as well as everything that's north
[0:26:52] of the Snake River that you currently should have or do have access to. In our opinion,
[0:27:01] that is something that discussions will continue to be had, the cities having those, but eventually
[0:27:08] we will need to look at even other sources of water rights.
[0:27:11] Go in terms of like, because I think we were at like what, 30, or current usages what, 30-something?
[0:27:23] Around 23,000 gallons of, it's 30 at one point.
[0:27:28] Yeah, in about 50 years, where do you estimate that to be?
[0:27:32] No, I don't have that exact number on me right now, but you can see that trend line that
[0:27:41] We just showed 20 years, if you will, we expect a similar trend to continue.
[0:27:46] So we're showing around about 5 million gallons a day, if you will, for the next 20 years.
[0:27:52] Don't come and give you a sense of that.
[0:27:54] Thank you.
[0:27:56] Any other questions for Gary?
[0:28:00] Thank you.
[0:28:01] Thank you.
[0:28:24] Thank you, Gary.
[0:28:25] I'd like to point out before I start that JEP has done an awful lot of work on these plans.
[0:28:30] On the Master PI plan, it's only about 200 pages, but there's about 450 pages of technical memorandums
[0:28:37] of all the evaluations they've done and everything that they've looked at.
[0:28:40] So, you know, try to cover 650 pages of information here in just a few minutes.
[0:28:45] It just really doesn't do it justice.
[0:28:48] And if there's any of you want to go a little deeper dive later on,
[0:28:53] we can meet with you one-on-one or something like that.
[0:28:56] So I'm sure we're going to miss a few of the things that are in the plan that we'll try to go over further quickly here.
[0:29:05] Back in 1999, due to diminishing potable water supplies and drought, the city passed more than restricting the use of potable water for irrigation and new developments.
[0:29:15] At the time, it looked like we were going to be running out of water, literally by now.
[0:29:21] So instead of using potable water, we started using canal company water in our subdivisions.
[0:29:28] Basically, when you have a field that is being developed, we have water rights that used to
[0:29:35] irrigate the field, irrigating the landscape in the new developments.
[0:29:40] And before I forget, pressurized irrigation, I'll use the term PI a lot.
[0:29:45] So that's what I'm saying when I say PI.
[0:29:49] This is the existing pressurized irrigation system along with pump stations and the areas
[0:30:04] that they serve.
[0:30:05] We have about 26 irrigation stations, 70 miles of pipe, and we serve about 2,000 acres.
[0:30:20] This is a heat map that we created.
[0:30:22] It uses about 500,000 water meter readings over the course of a couple of years.
[0:30:28] We compared the water usage in the middle of the winter compared to the middle of the summer,
[0:30:34] And so each dot represents the amount of potable water being used, or the additional amount of
[0:30:40] water being used in the summer compared to the winter.
[0:30:42] You can see in areas where we have pressurized irrigation, they're virtually black.
[0:30:51] They use basically the same amount of water during the summers they do in the winter.
[0:30:56] And you can see in various subdivisions, some of them use a little more water than others.
[0:31:00] are each one of these represents a water meter. Typically we see patterns where
[0:31:06] larger lots use more water, smaller lots use less water. You see a lot of
[0:31:12] these really super bright dots. A lot of those the top users that we when we're
[0:31:18] looking through the day of the top users are typically schools, churches, parks,
[0:31:24] sisters living facilities, apartment complexes, mobile home parks, landscape
[0:31:29] centers or nurseries, landscapes, drips, and office complexes.
[0:31:34] So a lot of these thoughts, if you look at them,
[0:31:38] you'll recognize that they may be one of those categories.
[0:31:55] So when we start out with plan, we also
[0:31:57] started looking at the difference in water consumption
[0:32:00] between PI areas and non-PI areas.
[0:32:04] We tried to pick out several neighborhoods around the city
[0:32:06] where they were built around at the same time,
[0:32:10] this location that I'm showing here.
[0:32:12] This is North Point Ranch.
[0:32:13] This is an earlier phase that was on potable water
[0:32:16] and in a laser phase that's on PI.
[0:32:20] What we found is that the PI areas use
[0:32:23] about 550 gallons per acre per day,
[0:32:26] and the non-PI areas use between 300 and 300, 900 gallons
[0:32:30] per day per acre.
[0:32:33] So in July and August when our water uses
[0:32:36] at the highest PI, neighborhoods use about 3000 gallons
[0:32:41] per day, less potable water than the PI neighborhoods.
[0:32:45] Well, when you, these are real rough numbers,
[0:32:47] but if you say you have 2,000 acres on PI,
[0:32:50] that's about 6 million gallons of potable water a day,
[0:32:54] that would have probably otherwise been used
[0:32:57] if we had not implemented the PI.
[0:33:08] It's a map of the Twin Falls Canal Company system,
[0:33:10] at least in the city of Twin Falls.
[0:33:13] Twin Falls Canal Company serves about 200,000 acres.
[0:33:18] And as over a hundred years old now, the original system, it was designed using gravity, the
[0:33:25] water flows, down canals, and bitches to get to all the various users, the canal company,
[0:33:32] has gates that deliver the water to the individual properties, and this is a 24-7 operation.
[0:33:40] Any water that enters the system, like in this case, it's the low line canal right
[0:33:44] here towards the bottom, water flowing down to the low line canal. They open
[0:33:49] gates over at Mertal Lake, and once they open those gates, that water has to either
[0:33:54] be used or it's going to go to Rock Creek or it's going to go to the Snake River Canyon.
[0:33:58] So the system, I say it's not something you can just turn on and turn off like
[0:34:03] we're used to with our potable water supply. It's a typical pressurized
[0:34:14] irrigation station. You have a supply ditch and then you have a gate. The gate
[0:34:20] supplies the water over to the usually their PI stations are composed of the
[0:34:25] pumps and storage so the water fills the storage and the pumps when they turn on
[0:34:30] they draw off that water any water that's not used has to waste down a ditch it's
[0:34:42] the same spot looking the other direction you can see the water just wasting
[0:34:45] downstream so this is just a little screen grab of the pressurized irrigation
[0:34:54] that the water department has online for any of any customers to look at you
[0:34:59] look at your individual pressurized irrigation stations, this one here is a morning sun.
[0:35:03] This was actually a couple years ago, but I took this shot because I thought it was kind
[0:35:07] of interesting.
[0:35:08] You can see that during the night, most people water, you see it really ramping at 8 p.m.
[0:35:15] and peeking over night and then it drops off at 9 a.m.
[0:35:18] In the middle of the day, we don't use nearly as much water.
[0:35:24] And this is a little bit of a problem because the canal company system is a constant flow
[0:35:28] system source supply is 24 hours a day. So when you see this dish shape right here, that's
[0:35:36] actually wasted water. That's water that's running down the ditch that we're not using.
[0:35:40] And in this case, if the water supply is up here around a thousand gallons per minute,
[0:35:46] go across here. If we don't have storage and we try to pump too much, you start seeing
[0:35:51] situations like this on the right, the wet wells for the pumps start to draw down and
[0:35:59] to prevent the pumps from damage, the pumps will actually shut off for about 15 minutes
[0:36:04] and then they will come back on and in this case it looks like three times that they
[0:36:10] kicked on, kicked off, kicked on, kicked off and with the water users if they weren't observing
[0:36:16] that their sprinklers weren't running they would just say oh my grass is just getting
[0:36:19] a little bit dry, and so just increase the amount of time that they're running their
[0:36:24] sprinklers, and that'll actually exacerbate snowball of the situation.
[0:36:29] We have tried to get users to use water in the middle of the day.
[0:36:34] We've put out advertisements.
[0:36:36] We haven't had much success.
[0:36:38] One time when we did an advertisement or public service announcement, a reporter talked
[0:36:43] to the University of Idaho about water and grass in the middle of the day and says,
[0:36:47] oh no, that's not a good idea.
[0:36:49] So it's very difficult to get people to water in the middle of the day when they're at PI
[0:36:54] and trying to convince them that it's actually a better way to use the water when you're
[0:36:57] on the irrigation system.
[0:37:00] So one of the ways that we can, well, there's a couple things, the other thing that's going
[0:37:05] on is this wasted water, it goes down ditches that it really wasn't intended to carry, you
[0:37:10] know, the system is 100 years old.
[0:37:12] And so it causes fluctuations in the delivery system, it causes problems for the Twin Falls
[0:37:16] canal company, because it's just a management issue, and there's also potential for needing
[0:37:23] to modify ditches or improve ditches to be able to handle these kinds of flows. Also, increasing
[0:37:32] storage will help this situation a little bit, too, so if we were able to instead delivering
[0:37:36] a thousand gallons per minute this example, we were delivering more like 800 gallons per
[0:37:40] minute but during this period right here if we were filling a pond and during this period
[0:37:47] right here we could be drawing off that pond and so that will help reduce the amount of
[0:37:51] water that's being wasted and then also reduce those fluctuations. So that's kind of the way
[0:38:00] the system is operating. So that gets us to capital improvements. So we have existing pump
[0:38:13] pump stations, right now the system works. What we have going on right now we have the pumping
[0:38:18] capacity for what our current situation. But as we grow some of these pump stations will
[0:38:25] need to have improvements to increase their capacity to be able to cover larger areas.
[0:38:31] Also we're looking into increasing pump station storage to reduce that waste until less of the
[0:38:36] impacts of the water fluctuation of the canal company system. We also need to evaluate and
[0:38:42] improve upstream downstream ditches to increase the supplies needed for growth and to better
[0:38:46] accommodate the water fluctuations.
[0:38:49] We also need to evaluate future development areas to determine future PI station locations.
[0:38:55] What we've been doing for years is when a development comes in and we don't have a capacity and
[0:39:00] existing pump station, that's when we have been putting in the pump stations.
[0:39:05] Usually we're getting the land from that current developer and it's not necessarily the absolute
[0:39:10] optimum location for those pump stations.
[0:39:13] So what we want to do is we want to start looking out into the future development areas,
[0:39:18] look at those to see where those better locations are for those pump stations and plan to put
[0:39:25] those stations to those places.
[0:39:26] And we would acquire land for those future PI stations.
[0:39:30] And we also need to expand some of the existing, say this is the purchase land for like storage.
[0:39:38] and also construct new PI stations as needed for growth.
[0:39:42] One of the things that we're contemplating bringing forward
[0:39:45] is we may be better for us to run new neighborhoods
[0:39:52] off of potable water for a while as the development goes out
[0:39:57] further to the country to where those pump stations are
[0:40:00] going to be.
[0:40:01] But we're going to put those pump stations right
[0:40:03] on the edge of Tamil.
[0:40:04] They'll be out of town.
[0:40:05] We won't wait until town gets to them
[0:40:07] before we bring them online.
[0:40:09] And so, like I said, there may be some time there
[0:40:12] that they'll have the PI piping,
[0:40:13] but they'll actually,
[0:40:14] that PI piping will actually carry hot water.
[0:40:17] Then also, we just have other general improvements.
[0:40:20] There's a lot of miscellaneous with the system.
[0:40:22] And finally, funding.
[0:40:25] We need to evaluate and establish fees
[0:40:26] for new developments.
[0:40:27] We typically expect development to pay for itself.
[0:40:31] So any land that we'd be purchasing
[0:40:33] or things like that,
[0:40:35] those future PI stations we would expect the funding for that to come from
[0:40:39] development. Questions? Honey, talk about budget here a little bit. This, I put
[0:40:51] together a spreadsheet, actually JUB, all the base work on this. We've got our
[0:40:57] revenue expenses and also our reserves. If you look at our revenue, we include a
[0:41:05] 1.5% estimated growth every year and that's just as we get more and more people connected
[0:41:13] that will just and they pay their water bills will get a little bit of extra money every
[0:41:18] year from that.
[0:41:19] So there is a little bit of increased revenue over time just from new connections to the
[0:41:24] water system.
[0:41:25] And you can see 1.5% comes to about 189,000, maybe 200,000 in that area.
[0:41:32] We have our expenses.
[0:41:33] You have your basic expenses, your personnel, M&O, that transfers and that's this line right
[0:41:39] here.
[0:41:40] Got most of this information from finance and then we have our capital expenditures.
[0:41:46] That's the capital improvements for water supply, water distribution and PI and they're
[0:41:51] all summarized right here.
[0:41:54] One thing that's not or two things that are not included in here are the Canyon Springs
[0:41:59] pump station and the Harrison tank improvements.
[0:42:01] I'll bring those in later, but I just kind of want to show you that if we don't do those two things
[0:42:06] How things play out?
[0:42:08] So when you take your reserves we start out about this 12 million and then we start doing expenditures over time
[0:42:15] some of this stuff that's in here is like the
[0:42:18] Precious-owned improvements and things like that, but as you go out to the end or we don't have enough money. So
[0:42:29] This is a graphical representation of the previous spreadsheet
[0:42:34] You can see your revenue line right here is in black, and the red line are our expenditures.
[0:42:43] And this blue line is what's happening with our reserves.
[0:42:49] And you see the get out there that we don't quite make it.
[0:42:54] So I've included this slide just as an FYI because we don't actually know how much the PI fee is going to be.
[0:43:03] I took a swag at it. I assumed that we would have a $270,000 a year revenue from this PIV.
[0:43:14] I just took the last 20 years of residential building permits. They averaged it as $278
[0:43:22] a year through $1000 each and came up with $270,000. Right now JUB is working on trying to come up
[0:43:30] methodology for what that fee would be and eventually what the actual dollar
[0:43:36] amount would be. But using this number, you can see that the reserves over time
[0:43:43] are a little better instead of having nothing. We have about $300,000. I just
[0:43:50] wanted to show that in here. I'm going to pull that out in the future slides but
[0:43:53] just to keep that back in your mind that this is something that there is going
[0:43:56] be a little bit of revenue in there, we don't quite know what that is.
[0:44:04] So if we do a 2% rate increase every year, it works.
[0:44:09] We have, we maintain our reserves, we can cover all of our expenditures, you know, larger
[0:44:19] rate increases up front and maybe smaller increases later on, but you know some, there are going
[0:44:24] to need to be some rate increases to be able to do the capital improvements that we need
[0:44:31] to do. We do the Canyon Springs pump station in the Harrison tank in 25-26. We immediately
[0:44:43] run out of money and we're upside down. We're in the red pretty deep path. We were to do
[0:44:50] a $30 million bond. It works. Well, we don't want to try to do a $30 million bond. Maybe
[0:45:01] we want to split these up. You can either do the Harrison tank first or the Canyon Springs
[0:45:05] pump station. I've chosen to show the Harrison tank first and the Canyon Springs pump station.
[0:45:10] just the Hankins tank by itself, you can see that 2526 we still have a problem and of course
[0:45:17] it gets worse as we go out. Now if we were able to come up with a $10 million bond or maybe
[0:45:24] a grant or some other money, then that will give us some time. But once again, we get out
[0:45:32] to the Canyon Springs pump station,
[0:45:35] we need to do something.
[0:45:39] So, you know, this is an option,
[0:45:43] bond earlier and a bond later.
[0:45:46] You can see maybe do it one way or another.
[0:45:49] We're gonna probably have to do a bond
[0:45:51] to be able to pay for water.
[0:45:53] But you can see that we do need to have some rate increases.
[0:45:57] And that's, I'd say there's multiple scenarios.
[0:46:00] I think we can get through this,
[0:46:02] but we will be revisiting you annually, at least,
[0:46:07] to talk about what we think we can do over the next 10
[0:46:10] years.
[0:46:13] With that, questions?
[0:46:16] Lee is it possible that you could send us
[0:46:19] this PDF presentation in the email if you would do that?
[0:46:23] It's a pretty big file size.
[0:46:25] I can borrow it.
[0:46:26] We can upload it to our site.
[0:46:28] I can get it to you.
[0:46:29] Yeah.
[0:46:29] OK.
[0:46:31] Yeah, put it on teams.
[0:46:32] Any questions for Lee at this point?
[0:46:37] A lot of information, thank you.
[0:46:38] It is, I'd say it's still quite a bit
[0:46:41] that I'm sure I missed, but.
[0:46:46] Thank you very much.
[0:46:47] It doesn't look like there's any other questions.
[0:46:50] Thank you.
[0:46:53] So that is it under items of consideration.
[0:46:57] Next on the agenda is the time for general public input.
[0:47:01] There's anybody in the audience that wishes
[0:47:03] to come down and address council.
[0:47:06] Now is the time.
[0:47:08] I ask that when you come down, you state your name
[0:47:11] and whether you're a resident
[0:47:12] or a property owner of Twin Falls.
[0:47:15] And then tonight we'll limit input to three minutes.
[0:47:22] When you do, please state your name in full
[0:47:24] so we can get it for the record.
[0:47:26] So first, go ahead.
[0:47:33] Thank you, Mayor, Mayor Pierce and Council people.
[0:47:36] I appreciate the opportunity to speak to you.
[0:47:39] I am not a resident of Twin Falls.
[0:47:42] I live in the impact zone at 1467 Falls, Avenue West.
[0:47:49] My name is Sarah Harris and I am here for myself and I'm also representing five other
[0:47:58] neighbors.
[0:47:59] Earlier today, we sent you an email expressing our concerns about a decision made by the
[0:48:10] the Twin Falls Planning and Zoning Commission meeting on November 29th.
[0:48:15] On that night, the Commission considered and approved in a 43-vote, a special use permit
[0:48:24] filed by OASIS Stop and Go, LLC, to construct an eight-pump gas station with convenience
[0:48:32] store and drive through at the corner of Falls Avenue West and Grandview Drive North. The
[0:48:41] gas station will be constructed amidst residents, mostly that aren't there yet. In a neighborhood
[0:48:51] commercial overlay zone that had been previously approved for small-scale commercial develop,
[0:48:58] not to include gas stations or drive-thrues, but a region designed to provide services
[0:49:06] to the surrounding neighborhood.
[0:49:08] An eight-pump gas station is not a small-scale operation.
[0:49:13] It does not make our neighborhood more walkable or bikeable.
[0:49:18] It presents health risks, will increase noise, traffic, litter, possibly crime, and will
[0:49:27] reduce the value of homes in the area. We, as residents in that neighborhood, are opposed
[0:49:34] to the project. We believe that a gas station located in any residential area violates the
[0:49:42] Twin Falls Planning and Zoning Commission's decision-making standards of operations, specifically
[0:49:48] number three, number four, and number seven, enumerated in the special use code 10-13-2-2,
[0:49:58] and violates the stated intent of the 2016 Twin Falls Comprehensive Plan to promote developments
[0:50:06] that are in harmony with neighborhoods.
[0:50:09] We respectfully request that the Twin Falls City Council use its authority defined under
[0:50:15] Section 10-17-2 of the Twin Falls Code to review and overturn the decision made by the
[0:50:23] Planning and Zoning Commission in improving this special use permit.
[0:50:28] Thank you.
[0:50:29] Thank you.
[0:50:30] Do you have any questions?
[0:50:32] We'll have some discussion.
[0:50:34] Thank you.
[0:50:36] Thank you.
[0:50:37] Anybody else here that wishes to come down and address Council before we close the public
[0:50:43] input?
[0:50:44] Go on down.
[0:50:48] Thank you, Mayor Piers.
[0:50:52] Members of the City Council, my name is David Tebow, and I do reside in the City of Twin Falls at 503 Stone-Hageway.
[0:50:59] And I'm just here representing Oasis Stop and Go.
[0:51:04] Our firm made application for the special use permit on behalf of Oasis Stop and Go for this application.
[0:51:10] Ran through the formal processes, received a proving vote from the political subdivision body that has authority to do so.
[0:51:19] And we noted that there was not a formal appeal filed, and in a timely manner, and the due process has been served in this matter.
[0:51:29] This plan for neighborhood commercial overlays have been in existence for many, many years.
[0:51:34] The entire east side of Grandview Drive is built out in homes.
[0:51:40] The south west side has had its first couple phases of homes constructed within the middle west subdivision.
[0:51:48] and the residential users are established within the area for this proposed field station.
[0:51:54] So we would hope that this city council would not take the next step in an unusual manner
[0:52:02] to appeal it unto yourselves a matter that's been formally held and due process upheld
[0:52:09] with regard to the special use of issuance. Thank you. Thank you. Is there anybody else
[0:52:18] close the public input section Travis do you have some guidance for us on this
[0:52:28] issue so I do and I also have Jonathan Spentlove the planning director here to
[0:52:36] make sure that I get this right he's been trying to coach me all day slow
[0:52:41] learner and we'll see if he's a good teacher and I'm a okay student and so
[0:52:48] So the process tonight is really for you to determine whether or not you want to hold
[0:52:56] a special meeting to determine whether or not you would consider appealing the planning
[0:53:04] and zoning decision.
[0:53:06] No per our city code.
[0:53:08] There is a 15 day limitation on when appeals can be timely.
[0:53:14] That appeal expires this Wednesday.
[0:53:19] This was not agentized, so you cannot take up the issue of moving forward with an appeal
[0:53:26] tonight.
[0:53:27] All you can do is say you want to have a special meeting.
[0:53:31] There's enough window to be able to have a special meeting, and that special meeting
[0:53:35] time would be on Wednesday evening of this week to honor the special meeting requirements
[0:53:41] as described in Idaho Code, as well as to be within the 15-day appeal guidelines as described in City Code.
[0:53:54] There is nothing stating, so as I understand it, the appeal process is still open,
[0:54:02] and that the citizens still have an opportunity to file their appeal, should they choose to move forward with it.
[0:54:14] So, you may or may not elect to move forward with an appeal that would be your decision.
[0:54:22] You would need to decide that at a separate meeting, again, because it's not agentized.
[0:54:27] The citizens who have expressed their thoughts and the concerns with the development, their
[0:54:33] window to appeal the decision is still open and also does not close until Wednesday.
[0:54:39] Two head shakes.
[0:54:44] So just to be clear, prior appeals that we've heard P&Z appeals have been filed by citizens,
[0:54:55] is that correct?
[0:54:56] Yes, I am not.
[0:55:01] While the city code does say the council has the right to review and consider and even change
[0:55:11] an appeal, a decision made by the Planning and Zoning Commission or any one of its advisory
[0:55:19] commissions on a myriad of issues.
[0:55:23] I have never in my tenure seen the council formally appeal the decision.
[0:55:32] There was one point in time in which the council made a decision and the council was asked
[0:55:38] to reconsider its action, but I have not seen a council in my 10 year take a step to over
[0:55:53] PO or to appeal a decision made by the Planning and Zoning Commission.
[0:55:58] Just because it hasn't happened doesn't mean you can't do it, I just haven't seen it.
[0:56:05] Okay, given that, maybe if anybody wants to have some discussion let's start with Spencer.
[0:56:11] I didn't have a question just about process.
[0:56:14] The email the council received last night, there was some concern from residents about cost to appeal.
[0:56:20] So, do I understand right?
[0:56:23] They still have a window that they could appeal.
[0:56:25] There's some cost to them.
[0:56:27] Otherwise the council could call or post an agenda for special meeting, and that would mean the residents don't bear that cost.
[0:56:35] We're invoking the appeal more or less.
[0:56:37] Yes, so whoever moves forward with appeal would be the one that would be responsible for the costs the costs are
[0:56:46] So there is for the appeal it'd be very similar to the cost that we would assess for a special use permit, which is five hundred dollars
[0:56:55] there is the cost of
[0:56:59] Renting the sign that are needed to be posted or
[0:57:03] or an individual could go through the cost and they could create their own sign using city code.
[0:57:10] And then there is a, that's about $53 if you were to go to the firm that rents them.
[0:57:16] I can't speak to what the cost would be if you were to make them.
[0:57:20] And then if you would go $42 for the cost of the newspaper, there is a $200 deposit
[0:57:29] that is placed at the time in which you rent it, and then my understanding is if those signs are returned
[0:57:35] in the manner in which they were rented, they are that $200 fee is returned.
[0:57:41] So the net cost based upon staff estimate is $595.
[0:57:46] That's the best, I mean, that's using the 70 names that were on the initial list at 60
[0:57:54] cents per mailing, $53 net cost of the rent of the signs, and the $500 associated with
[0:58:03] the cost of staff time and newspaper publication and the like.
[0:58:09] The $500 is not a fee that we would assess ourselves, but we would still have costs associated
[0:58:16] associated with the publication, and you'd have the cost associated with the staff time.
[0:58:23] All the other costs would be hard cost borne by the city.
[0:58:27] That answer your question, okay?
[0:58:33] What are your wishes?
[0:58:44] I guess I just share my thoughts.
[0:58:49] Whether or not we agree with the initial vote is one thing.
[0:58:52] The other thing is do we disagree strong enough to, I guess, override the planning and zoning.
[0:58:59] So that's where mine's kind of at.
[0:59:01] How would I have voted initially, but is it so egregious that we think that we need to override the planning and zoning so?
[0:59:09] Well, and just to be clear, this is not we're not making a decision tonight. It's strictly whether
[0:59:15] We are going to be the ones appealing versus citizens appealing and again
[0:59:20] They have the same window we have and have had up now 13 days
[0:59:26] I guess everybody's had 13 days to appeal that and so we're down to the deadline and that's why we have to
[0:59:33] If we choose if we choose to appeal it we have to have a meeting on Wednesday
[0:59:40] Discuss it
[0:59:44] So I mean ultimately the question that keeps coming to my mind is what would we be appealing?
[0:59:50] Would we be be appealing if it if it fits in the area or if it fits in line with what was
[0:59:58] Zoned? I guess those would be the questions that I have that come to my mind at least initially,
[1:00:04] as if we went forward with the appeals process. What would we be gaining or what would we be overriding?
[1:00:13] So under the section that was cited in the letter and by the citizens, it would be a significant adverse impact
[1:00:21] Based on the fact that a special use permit was granted in this situation it'd be
[1:00:27] Subjective to this property and you would be undoing or questioning whether or not a special use permit should be granted
[1:00:33] in the
[1:00:35] As the burden there is
[1:00:39] Was pointed out does this council believe it's this
[1:00:43] financial adverse impact
[1:00:45] Thank you, you know tip
[1:00:51] Typically we don't step in and override something unless it's appealed
[1:00:56] I don't know that that's necessarily our place.
[1:01:01] I don't know how everybody else feels.
[1:01:03] I would agree with you, Mayor.
[1:01:05] I think that this is we have a process in place.
[1:01:07] I understand that there is a neighborhood that's frustrated and that's not for us to decide.
[1:01:13] I know that there's been many when I was on P&Z being here.
[1:01:16] There's been areas that are frustrated.
[1:01:18] The process needs to be followed without in my opinion,
[1:01:22] without the city council coming in and stepping in and saying,
[1:01:26] you know, we're going to do this or we're not going to do this.
[1:01:29] Once the process has come, then we'll make a decision.
[1:01:32] It will come here.
[1:01:33] I know that there's a cost associated with it.
[1:01:36] That's not always fun to pay, but you need to have those things
[1:01:39] and follow the process.
[1:01:41] Um, not only for this one, but for future situations like this,
[1:01:46] if we are always stepping in, then we're pretty much pushing the process out
[1:01:51] and saying, no, just come to us and we'll take care of it.
[1:01:54] I think we need to follow the process.
[1:01:56] Thank you.
[1:01:57] Any other thoughts?
[1:02:02] Madam Mayor, I would agree with those comments.
[1:02:04] And my other concern would be, if we
[1:02:06] are the ones initiating the appeal,
[1:02:08] then at some point when we actually
[1:02:10] have to sit and hear the appeal, one side
[1:02:13] is going to argue that we are already biased by initiating
[1:02:16] Senate.
[1:02:17] And I would like to avoid that appearance
[1:02:19] as much as possible.
[1:02:22] Even though I don't think it's an outright conflict to do that,
[1:02:26] but it's enough of an appearance that I would like to avoid it if we can.
[1:02:31] The window for an appeal has not closed.
[1:02:34] Applicants still have the ability to initiate it.
[1:02:38] And so for that, I would strongly urge us to decline the invitation
[1:02:45] to step in and initiate those.
[1:02:48] Thank you.
[1:02:49] So this is not necessarily a vote.
[1:02:51] So head nod, we don't choose to have a meeting.
[1:02:58] So that's our first option,
[1:02:59] or we choose to appeal it and have a meeting on Wednesday.
[1:03:03] So what is heads to nod?
[1:03:07] No, we don't want to appeal it.
[1:03:09] I'm not a favorite of appealing.
[1:03:11] Okay, looks like it's unanimous.
[1:03:15] Almost so.
[1:03:16] Okay, thank you.
[1:03:18] Next on the agenda is advisory board reports.
[1:03:25] Before we do that, I just want to thank Chief Kingsbury and his guys at the parade.
[1:03:31] Actually, I want to thank all departments for the parade on Friday.
[1:03:35] It was a fabulous parade, and though it was super cold.
[1:03:39] The coordination between all the departments, fire, police,
[1:03:44] I know Roberke had helped just streets, parks and rec, the city manager's office, and then
[1:03:51] of course, Chief saved the day with his microphone, so we were able to light the tree, but it
[1:03:56] was just a great evening.
[1:03:59] Allieck, very cold, and I just shout out to all the apartments.
[1:04:06] So anybody else have any advisory board reports?
[1:04:10] Madam Mayor, I do the Public Arts Commission at last Wednesday and I am happy to report that they have finalized their application for public arts and I think it's going to go live if it has a public website.
[1:04:25] So, should be able to start accepting applications for the public.
[1:04:30] That's been.
[1:04:31] Wow.
[1:04:32] Yes.
[1:04:33] Thank you.
[1:04:34] Anybody else?
[1:04:35] Okay.
[1:04:37] City Manager's Office.
[1:04:39] Yeah, just a quick public announcement that tomorrow,
[1:04:43] the general operational aspects of our organization
[1:04:46] are going to be closed for the day as the city goes
[1:04:48] to a TANU organizational meeting.
[1:04:51] Emergency services and emergency groups
[1:04:53] will continue to respond and they'll
[1:04:55] be business as usual and normal with the exception of deploying
[1:05:00] maybe from offsite locations.
[1:05:02] But really, it's a great opportunity for the city council
[1:05:05] or to engage with employees, employees to come together.
[1:05:09] I really talk about the successes of the year
[1:05:11] and to focus forward on what the future looks like.
[1:05:14] So again, tomorrow from eight to five organization,
[1:05:19] we will not be out open for normal business for Zoom.
[1:05:24] Normal business on Wednesday morning,
[1:05:29] 19th the city council will host its last meeting
[1:05:33] of the calendar year 2022.
[1:05:37] Okay, with that, the last item on the agenda is an action item to move into executive session
[1:05:52] under 74-206-1B to consider the evaluation, dismissal, or disciplining of or to hear complaints
[1:06:00] or charges brought against the public officer employee, staff member or individual agent
[1:06:06] or public school student.
[1:06:09] So moved.
[1:06:10] Thank you, Jason, do I have a second?
[1:06:12] OK.
[1:06:13] Thank you.
[1:06:14] Motion by Jason Brown, second by Alex Kaval.
[1:06:17] To move into executive session under 74-206-1B.
[1:06:22] Amy Rolkov, please.
[1:06:25] Ninky Boyd.
[1:06:26] Yes.
[1:06:26] Frank Hawkins.
[1:06:27] Yes.
[1:06:28] Jason Brown.
[1:06:28] Yes.
[1:06:29] Alex Kaval.
[1:06:30] Yes.
[1:06:30] Spencer Cutler.
[1:06:31] Yes.
[1:06:32] Ruth Pierce.
[1:06:32] Yes.
[1:06:33] And Chris Reed.
[1:06:34] Yes.
[1:06:35] Thank you. Motion passes 7-0. We will not be adjourning back and we will not be making
[1:06:40] any decisions. So we're adjourned. Thank you.
