Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2022-08-15, recording 1 (started 16:28)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2022-08-15/

[0:02:03] say good afternoon ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the
[0:02:06] August 15, 2022 City Council meeting. I want to confirm we have a quorum. We have five members present and chambers.
[0:02:17] So, that's our color. We'll be here at about five o'clock. So, the first item on the agenda is executive session.
[0:02:28] Executive Session 24-2061-F to communicate with legal counsel for the public agency to
[0:02:37] discuss the legal ramifications of and legal options for pending litigation or controversies
[0:02:44] not yet being litigated but imminently likely to be litigated near the presence of legal
[0:02:51] Council is in and out an executive session does not satisfy this requirement
[0:02:55] Council wishes to approve the executive session
[0:03:05] second motion by Chris for read second by Craig Hawkins to move into
[0:03:12] executive session under 2074 dash two of six one F real call please
[0:03:20] Mayor Pierce yes vice-read yes
[0:03:26] Thank you, Boyd Craig clockins Jason Brown. Yes
[0:03:30] Thank you motion passes 5 to 0 just let everybody know we're gonna be in executive session till just a little bit before 5 o'clock
[0:03:39] And we'll be back here in chambers. We're not going to make any decisions just an information session
[0:03:46] So we'll see you five good evening ladies and gentlemen and welcome back to
[0:04:31] or welcome to our City Council meeting. We met this morning or this afternoon at 4 30 moved into executive session and now we're back out. I want to confirm we have a quorum. We have six members present in chambers.
[0:04:47] So first item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. If you wish to join me please rise. Next item on the agenda. I would mention there's no proclamations tonight. So our next item is the consent calendar.
[0:05:23] Calendar Council wishes Jason Brown
[0:05:32] Thank you. Do I have a second motion by Jason Brown seconded by Craig Hawkins to approve the consent calendar
[0:05:42] Aaron roll call vote, please
[0:05:45] Mayor Pierce yes, Vice-Mary yes Nikki Boyd. Yes Craig Hawkins. Yes Jason Brown. Yes, I'm sure cutler. Yes
[0:05:55] Thank you motion passes
[0:05:58] 6 to 0
[0:06:01] items on the agenda under items of consideration, we have an action item,
[0:06:06] consideration of an agreement with JUBE Engineers, engineers in the amount of
[0:06:12] $268,713 for engineering services associated with FAA Airport Improvement
[0:06:22] Project, AIP, 54 construction of an aircraft parking ramp, and we have Bill
[0:06:28] Carberry or your part manager welcome Bill. Thank you very good evening Council. So just a step back and sort of refresh our audience about the
[0:06:38] improvement program on the airport works very closely with the FAA with the
[0:06:43] FAA project managers as these projects unfold and look for their concurrence for
[0:06:49] the scopes of work we do the contracts that we let those types of things so
[0:06:53] backing up a little bit the airport master plans and through master planning
[0:06:58] We're able to look at forecast demand,
[0:07:00] come up with ideas to platform capital projects
[0:07:04] that will assist us throughout the planning period.
[0:07:06] So, project that I have tonight,
[0:07:09] I'll show you a quick overhead aerial.
[0:07:19] Excuse me, Bill, would you roll us forward?
[0:07:21] What are we waiting for?
[0:07:25] I know, but we don't have that up on our screen.
[0:07:36] Little delayed on the train there.
[0:07:37] Sorry, but yeah, here's just a quick sort of Google Earth.
[0:07:42] and the ramp expansion is highlighted on the right side of the screen.
[0:07:47] There's about two acres. It's right now. It's just some grass and things of that nature.
[0:07:52] So we've had this on our our capital program for some time.
[0:07:56] With the bike part infrastructure legislation, we were able to free up some dollars
[0:08:01] to take advantage of moving ahead with this project.
[0:08:04] So we're looking to do design and vid it, perhaps this fall, winter and construction.
[0:08:10] constructed in this construction season, but tonight I'd like to talk a little bit about the JUV engineering contract for design meeting and construction of this ramp.
[0:08:20] The contract is decided, that's funded by AIP dollars as is the construction project with the required local match of six and a quarter percent.
[0:08:31] The project we're estimating to be about $950,000, and when you have engineering contracts that are expected to exceed $100,000 for services, the FAA asks sponsors airports to go out for independent fee estimates.
[0:08:48] It's really kind of unique, you know, probably here at much with highway contracts and other things, but it's a way for airports to sort of gauge scopes of work and the tasks and the efforts associated with the contracts they're developing with their customers.
[0:09:01] developing with their consultants. So we enlisted the help of Century West Engineering
[0:09:06] at Vandoor again. You said before, there's a few engineering firms that I use. So with
[0:09:13] an approved scope of work by the FAA project manager, we enlisted a short task order with
[0:09:20] them to take a look at the man hours of scope of work and it provides sort of an independent
[0:09:24] the estimate of what they would charge to perform the services that JV has scoped with
[0:09:31] the airport for their services. So with that we got with them and they provided us
[0:09:37] with an independent fee estimate. So bottom line numbers what we're looking at at Century
[0:09:43] West Engineering was $373,460. A UB Engineering was $268,168,768. That's a good idea. It's not
[0:09:54] there's a fairly wide gap there about 28% so you ask yourself why and looking
[0:10:01] into the independent fee estimate compared to the contract really a couple
[0:10:05] things stood out that was travel costs and expenses and also subconsult costs
[0:10:11] JUB has the surveying the environmental work in house and those would be subconsulted
[0:10:18] system with the independent fee estimate we have and then the travel which you
[0:10:22] You can imagine from Ben Doregan would be considerable.
[0:10:25] So what I tried to do to try to get more of an apples to apples has comparison is remove travel costs from the independent fee estimate from the proposals from JUB.
[0:10:36] And things started to line up and become a little bit more capable.
[0:10:39] And JUB was 8% lower, not rather than 28% lower, so it started to make a little bit of sense there.
[0:10:53] But with that we did get concurrence from the FAA with a proposed contract that you're reviewing tonight.
[0:10:59] And I'd be happy to answer any questions you have in conclusion.
[0:11:04] Our staff recommends the City Council approve the agreement for engineering services with JUB Engineering.
[0:11:10] The sum of $268,713.
[0:11:13] And authorize the Mayor to sign the agreement.
[0:11:18] Any discussion? Any questions for Bill?
[0:11:20] Councillor.
[0:11:30] There's $4,268,713 and authorize the mayor to sign the agreement.
[0:11:42] Thank you, Craig Hawkins.
[0:11:44] Second.
[0:11:45] Thank you, Emotion by Spencer Cutler and seconded by Craig Hawkins to approve the agreement
[0:11:52] with J.E.B.
[0:11:53] Engineers for the amount of $268,713 and authorize the mayor to sign.
[0:12:00] Aaron Rolkelvo, please.
[0:12:05] Vice Mayor Reed.
[0:12:06] Yes.
[0:12:07] Thank you, Boyd. Yes. Great. Cawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. Spencer Cutler. Yes. Mayor Pierce. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes six to zero. Thank you. Thank you.
[0:12:19] A, next item on the agenda is the budget. Presentation. Discussion of the physical year 2022-23.
[0:12:29] Tenanted to budget for the City of Twin Falls. You have Travis, Rosweller, our City Manager. Welcome, Travis.
[0:12:36] Thank you, Madam Mayor, members of the City Council.
[0:12:41] So tonight we'll have a conversation about the tentative budget that you approved last week.
[0:12:48] We've been having the conversation about the budget over the course of the last several weeks starting with the first week in July when we started making initial budget presentations, but as you're aware, as we've shared repeatedly throughout this conversation, really our work began shortly after the first of the year.
[0:13:07] And we're getting here the conclusion of our conversation.
[0:13:11] So tonight is going to be just a quick overview of the budget and make sure that we are able
[0:13:16] to answer any questions that you have because next week we're going to ask that you host
[0:13:21] the public hearing, which you said.
[0:13:23] And we're also going to ask you to adopt the appropriation ordinance next week that really
[0:13:29] defines the budget that we've been having the conversation about.
[0:13:33] The budget that we've created will begin on October 1st of this year and it will be fiscal year aligned with the federal calendar.
[0:13:44] It is in alignment with the provisions of the Idaho Code as well as the best practices of the Government Finance Officers Association.
[0:13:54] We've shared repeatedly and we went through the budget probably in painstaking detail at some point in time of how our expenditures align with the City's Strategic Plan.
[0:14:06] as we've shared with you, we had to go through a revision of the City Strategic Plan that is one of the items that we're asking you to fund.
[0:14:15] We went last through 17, so this marks the fifth year that we've been looking at the budget.
[0:14:25] And while we don't know if the broad focus areas will change,
[0:14:29] we do know that the environment that we constructed the budget has, as well as the strategic plan,
[0:14:34] and we want to make sure that it is relevant for the organization.
[0:14:38] We've shared this over the course of the last several weeks and the highlights that we've
[0:14:45] pointed out is the city's total taxable value which is a measurement of the overall health
[0:14:51] of the community has grown by nearly $1.6 million.
[0:14:54] We've also reflected that the tax rate is going to decrease significantly about 23.4%
[0:15:00] this year compared to last year.
[0:15:03] We've also shared that a tax rate does not necessarily mean that individuals are going
[0:15:07] to be paying lower in taxes, an tax rate in Idaho is simply the multiplier, and an individual's
[0:15:13] tax burden. Pay is going to be real taxable value of the properties of the health in comparison
[0:15:23] to the tax rate that we've shown that the growth at the inside of the city of Twin Falls
[0:15:31] is by far the single largest year that we've ever experienced at $1.6 billion and that the
[0:15:38] 5.56 billion of total taxable value of the city excludes $115 million of urban or local properties are also up nearly $200 this fiscal year.
[0:15:57] So the budget that you have before you is about 13.19% larger than the budget that we're currently operating under this budget is $78.6 million.
[0:16:08] The current budget that we're operating in right now is about $69.5 million.
[0:16:15] We illustrate the places that it's going.
[0:16:19] First, in the tax-supported funds, those are those funds that receive some portion of their funding from property taxes.
[0:16:27] And then you have the enterprise funds, which are those funds that really reflect those business-like funds that we have.
[0:16:38] That we assess a fee to have their operations.
[0:16:41] Inside of the budget, if you were to look through all of the narratives, we break the budget down into these five categories,
[0:16:47] but notice that personnel is the largest source of our budget, and as we've shared, and many department teams have come and illustrated,
[0:16:55] we deliver services through the hands and efforts of many talented people in our organization.
[0:17:02] We've shared that the tax rate is decreasing, and you can see that it is the lowest tax rate that we have issued in the last decade,
[0:17:10] and we will lowest those ever been issued by the City of Twin Falls.
[0:17:15] One of the things that we like to do is to compare the City of Twin Falls city property taxes paid by what we would describe as our competing cities.
[0:17:27] You'll notice that property taxes paid inside the City of Twin Falls are lower than what a property taxpayer would pay in city taxes in many of those other cities.
[0:17:40] We've shared why we exclude both Boise and Meridian, and that's because of the
[0:17:45] Eda County Highway District influence. The City of Toronto falls in all of the
[0:17:49] cities up on this list are responsible for roads and road maintenance, and we
[0:17:55] pay for roads and road maintenance on property tax dollars, where the cities of
[0:18:00] Boise and Meridian and those that are part of the Eda County Highway District do not
[0:18:04] have the same responsibilities for road and roadways. We spend some time
[0:18:09] I'm talking about the different positions that we're adding and the size of the city staff.
[0:18:14] You can see that we're adding employees in these categories here.
[0:18:20] Each members of our team have kind of really described the need for those different positions.
[0:18:24] And you'll also note that some of these positions, five of the positions that we're asking for,
[0:18:29] have were included in the prior year.
[0:18:32] There are four new positions that are being asking for you to consider for the first time
[0:18:37] as part of this budget.
[0:18:38] And then you'll also say, well, if there's four police officers and a planning person and
[0:18:44] four other people, that equals nine positions.
[0:18:47] And you've been talking about eight positions.
[0:18:49] It's because internally we made a reduction.
[0:18:52] We reduced a position to pay for the planning and zoning technicians.
[0:18:56] And we treated that.
[0:18:59] We described the maintenance and operation costs in all the funds.
[0:19:02] And this is an area that I think that we were celebrating for the city.
[0:19:07] We see that it's an increase of 7.46%, which is significantly lower than the municipal
[0:19:13] cost index of nearly 12.5% when we construct the budget.
[0:19:17] They can reflect the efforts that the department leaders took to make sure that their budgets
[0:19:23] were in line.
[0:19:24] The other piece that we highlighted was the significant investment that we continue to
[0:19:29] make in the city's infrastructure across all of the different service lines that we
[0:19:34] offer.
[0:19:35] $18.2 million in this budget, and that excludes the $18 million that we're investing in fire
[0:19:40] stations, and so in total, it's about $36 million in total infrastructure that we'll spend in
[0:19:47] this year and next year.
[0:19:50] And then last week, the Council took all of that information that you've been hearing
[0:19:54] for the last several weeks, and you applied that to the Council-Directed Capital Projects
[0:20:00] of $770,000 in this, we believe equals the totality of the list, and then in addition
[0:20:07] to that you'll remember that Jonathan and his team came up with the idea to use CDBG dollars
[0:20:13] to assist with the additional hands-in street work, and so it's the $770,000 plus an additional
[0:20:21] $271,000 that will be used as CDBG, and again, it really continues the city's commitment
[0:20:29] to creating a truly accessible community,
[0:20:32] as you focus in on sidewalks and the transportation.
[0:20:40] So at the end of the day,
[0:20:42] this is what citizens can expect.
[0:20:45] If they lived in a median home,
[0:20:46] and they use a median amount of water,
[0:20:49] and they've fallen to that better average.
[0:20:53] You'll notice that we're not asking for any increases
[0:20:55] for water, for sewer, or for sanitation.
[0:20:59] and that homes have increased,
[0:21:07] straight has decreased.
[0:21:08] And so, citizens on the average can expect
[0:21:11] to pay a little bit more property taxes this year,
[0:21:14] even though we're offering the single largest,
[0:21:17] or single smallest property tax rate
[0:21:20] that we ever have.
[0:21:23] I know that was quick.
[0:21:26] Reality, this conversation and over,
[0:21:32] and we thought it would be better for
[0:21:34] than us just talking at you for the next hour
[0:21:38] to quickly go through, summarize where we've been,
[0:21:41] but then take time to answer questions
[0:21:43] that you might have in preparation
[0:21:45] of next week's adoption of the budget.
[0:21:48] So with that, first of our team who have joined us tonight,
[0:21:54] I will be happy to answer any questions
[0:21:56] that you might have or that have come up during this process.
[0:21:58] And again, next week we'll be hosting the public hearing,
[0:22:01] and which we'll be able to answer those questions as well.
[0:22:04] Thank you, Travis.
[0:22:06] Anybody have any questions for Travis or members of his team?
[0:22:12] Contemplating next week Chris free. I just want to say thank you to everyone
[0:22:18] I know this this has been something that everybody's worked on really hard
[0:22:22] Something that a lot of time and energy has gone into it
[0:22:25] I know that in the past and I'm sure it's the same way this time that there's some things that departments needed that didn't get on this this budget
[0:22:33] And so we appreciate everybody working together
[0:22:36] Really, this is a
[0:22:38] Entire city coming together to make sure that this process goes goes well. So thank you for that
[0:22:43] I can speak for myself, we've gone over the three months, three and a half months.
[0:22:49] This has been going on maybe even a little bit longer.
[0:22:52] I appreciate it.
[0:22:54] I understand the process.
[0:22:56] I understand what's going on if somebody was to come in and ask me a question about
[0:23:00] the budget.
[0:23:02] Because of the process that we've gone through, I am confident in what we're passing.
[0:23:07] So I appreciate that.
[0:23:08] I appreciate the time and energy that's gone into it.
[0:23:10] So thank you.
[0:23:11] Yeah, I believe that from my public perspective, this is either the 13th or 14th conversation
[0:23:18] that we've had, it starts with a long-term planning process shortly after the first of
[0:23:25] the year where many members across our organization work as a cross-functional team, across all
[0:23:30] different levels inside our organization, really preparing the moment of the budget,
[0:23:36] it goes through a budget balancing process, we submit to you a balanced budget, and conversations
[0:23:44] as well as with members of the community about our logic behind projects and programs that we have.
[0:23:53] Thank you, Chris. Anyone else? Would you just say something?
[0:23:57] We shade all the time. Thank you.
[0:24:02] So the next item on the agenda is time for general public input.
[0:24:07] This would be someone in the audience who wishes to discuss something that is not on the agenda today.
[0:24:15] Although if you had a comment on the budget, that's welcome.
[0:24:18] We do have a public hearing at 6 p.m.
[0:24:22] So if anybody wishing to comment on that item, we'll need to wait until 6 o'clock.
[0:24:28] So is there anybody today that wishes to come down and speak on other inputs?
[0:24:34] Seeing no one advisory board reports.
[0:24:39] Anybody have vice report?
[0:24:44] So the greater Twin Falls transportation met last week, the good roundtable discussion.
[0:24:55] Again, the topic of the third bridge came up.
[0:24:59] There is a meeting on Wednesday this week.
[0:25:02] We're going for that.
[0:25:04] We'll address a little bit more probably.
[0:25:16] So I would mention that we do have our state of the city tomorrow morning in the comments.
[0:25:22] It's a breakfast.
[0:25:23] You haven't got your tickets.
[0:25:25] I don't, still, it's too late, okay.
[0:25:28] You can come and listen, just can't eat breakfast, I guess.
[0:25:31] So that starts at seven o'clock.
[0:25:33] I think our program will start about seven-thirty.
[0:25:36] Anything from the City Manager's office?
[0:25:38] Just a couple of other additional items.
[0:25:42] Next week, it really is.
[0:25:44] The focus is on the items that we'll cover later.
[0:25:50] Start the normal.
[0:25:52] Cannot start the budget conversation until six.
[0:25:56] We don't believe we have significant items.
[0:26:02] start the preparation of a six o'clock public hearing and then just a reminder
[0:26:11] that as many might die as there is a vacancy the city council has been accepting
[0:26:18] in the city as a city council person individuals who are qualified on
[0:26:31] lecturers as defined by Idaho code for the city of Twin Falls are welcome to
[0:26:34] submit their applications until noon Wednesday and noon Wednesday is the cut
[0:26:40] of period of time that would have created two full weeks
[0:26:43] in which the process has been open.
[0:26:46] We will take all of the names which we have received.
[0:26:49] We will collect those names.
[0:26:59] Hopefully we have them all back hope is that next meeting
[0:27:05] will present the names of the individuals
[0:27:07] that have submitted their credential night.
[0:27:11] The City Council has set that time aside.
[0:27:25] Okay, so we do have a public hearing at six o'clock.
[0:27:28] I think we could move into our executive session
[0:27:32] for the next 30 minutes, so we don't have to just hang out.
[0:27:35] Wait till six, so an action item executive session
[0:27:40] to 742061B to consider the evaluation dismissal
[0:27:46] is planning over to hear complaints or charges brought
[0:27:49] against the public officer, employee, staff member,
[0:27:51] individual, agent, or public school students
[0:27:56] who have a motion, motion by Jason Brown,
[0:28:03] Second invite Nikki Boyd to move into executive session
[0:28:07] under 74-2061 B. Aaron Rokal vote please.
[0:28:12] Nikki Boyd, Craig Hawkins, Jason Brown,
[0:28:17] Spencer Cutler, Mayor Pierce, Vice-Mayor Reid.
[0:28:21] Yes, thank you.
[0:28:22] Motion passes six to zero.
[0:28:25] So we'll be back here at six o'clock
[0:28:28] for the public hearing relating to the residential historic
[0:28:33] district.
[0:28:33] Thank you.
[0:28:57] Okay, good evening ladies and gentlemen.
[0:29:00] Thank you for your patience.
[0:29:02] Sorry, we're a little late.
[0:29:05] Our next item on the agenda is our public hearing.
[0:29:10] Today, we will be discussing,
[0:29:13] it'll be a public hearing with Council
[0:29:15] to receive input on creating a residential
[0:29:18] historic district, PZ22-039.
[0:29:23] And today we have Jonathan's been loved.
[0:29:26] are planning a zoning director to start us off?
[0:29:33] I remember as a council, this item
[0:29:35] has been before you previously.
[0:29:39] And I'll give the caveat, I'm not gonna read the slides,
[0:29:42] I have a lot of words on them.
[0:29:44] I'm the council had this ahead of time,
[0:29:45] people have had this ahead of time.
[0:29:47] I'm so gonna read everything,
[0:29:48] but I'm gonna go through a little bit of short history
[0:29:51] and then we'll get down to the item,
[0:29:52] the information that you need and the discussion
[0:29:54] you can have after the public.
[0:29:57] And the background on the request
[0:30:01] is in the spring of 2022, we are approached by neighborhood group called the Friends of
[0:30:05] the Avenues and the petition city staff to work on creating a new historic district that
[0:30:11] they call the Avenues Historic District. It contains approximately 300 properties and is
[0:30:16] outlined in red there. This is City Park. This is the library courthouse. Sixth Avenue
[0:30:23] is that kind of came down around the library. Do the nature of the request. There's a smaller
[0:30:31] area than the original National Historic designation, including an outdated investigation. We basically
[0:30:40] discuss this with the avenues folks and encourage them to go through basically the City Council to
[0:30:46] get the money to have an updated investigation. It's also something that our planning staff
[0:30:53] does not have the expertise in. I'm not an architect or historian or anything like that.
[0:30:57] I can read and look at pictures, but I'm not that knowledgeable about historic architecture.
[0:31:04] So somebody similar to Miss Giro who did the original nomination of the area would be somebody that would be more appropriate.
[0:31:11] So we put people put them on a pass to talk with the sort of preservation commission to get a recommendation to come to council for it to be budgeted.
[0:31:21] The City Council is the only entity that can essentially spend taxpayer money for things,
[0:31:28] and so that was the route that we took.
[0:31:34] March 7th is when they went to the commission.
[0:31:36] April 4th, it came to the City Council with some preliminary budgets.
[0:31:39] On May 22nd, we had a meeting with the avenues to discuss consultants.
[0:31:43] We came back to Council on the 23rd to present the amounts.
[0:31:48] If you remember, there's between 40 and 125 for the consultation,
[0:31:52] And then creating this new district would create an additional staff load.
[0:31:57] So we believe there'd be another planner that would be needed.
[0:32:00] That's around 80,000 plus for a year over year cost to manage the program.
[0:32:06] In that timeframe, June, we were asked to hold a public information meeting.
[0:32:12] We did that on June 23rd.
[0:32:15] Sorry, July 13th.
[0:32:18] And then this is the information we presented.
[0:32:20] We presented information on Idaho Statutes
[0:32:23] pertaining to zoning codes and the current zoning districts
[0:32:25] and development standards.
[0:32:27] Set back height land uses in that area
[0:32:30] of the avenues proposal.
[0:32:32] We had a brief history on the old clinic property.
[0:32:34] We also included information on Idaho Statutes
[0:32:37] pertaining to historic districts and historic properties.
[0:32:39] Those are two distinct things in state statute.
[0:32:42] And then the background info on the nationally recognized
[0:32:44] or registered original town site residential district
[0:32:48] will briefly go through some of these things
[0:32:50] presentation tonight for anybody that missed that one. There's a legislative
[0:32:54] defined purpose for the local land use planning act. This is dealing with the
[0:32:58] zoning districts separate from the storm preservation districts. I don't
[0:33:03] statute 67-65-02. Purpose of the act shall be to promote the health safety and
[0:33:09] general welfare of the people of the state of Idaho. I paraphrased it. It
[0:33:14] goes through private property rights, public facilities, talks about airports,
[0:33:18] talk about avoiding overcrowding, natural resources, etc. The zoning districts that are enacted across
[0:33:25] this state have to meet this general purpose statement when they want to regulate people's
[0:33:30] properties in their property rights. Local governments shall exercise the powers of the local landings
[0:33:37] planning act. Cities and counties don't have a choice in Idaho, they have to have zoning districts
[0:33:43] to meet these things and they shall and force them.
[0:33:49] So, this is a general overview of the area.
[0:33:52] The outline in red is the avenues proposal.
[0:33:56] It's color coded.
[0:33:57] We have the regulation type, which is buildings
[0:34:00] and setbacks from rear building height.
[0:34:02] And then the types of some land uses that are permitted.
[0:34:05] Orange is called R4.
[0:34:07] That's what's in the orange over here.
[0:34:09] Then there's a pier, a purple pinkish, R6.
[0:34:14] The R4 district has buildings, setbacks up 20 in the front,
[0:34:17] 20 in the back, 5 on the sides, and no building can be taller than 35 feet.
[0:34:22] It can only have single family, homes, detached, and duplexes.
[0:34:28] Triplex or footplex would require a public hearing.
[0:34:31] That would be a notification to anybody within 500 feet and a public hearing
[0:34:35] with the Planning and Zoning Commission.
[0:34:37] An apartment building, or what we would call 5 or more, is not permitted in that orange area.
[0:34:42] Again, this is the City Park. This is the courthouse, the library.
[0:34:47] the old clinic building is here on just showing in sixth. The parking lot, it was converted
[0:34:53] to an apartment building is here and here. More specifically, that property was zoned
[0:35:00] R6 in 1989. It just was used as a parking lot. Someone purchased it and exercised the right
[0:35:07] to build five or more units on the property encompassing both of those parking lots. They
[0:35:14] at the R6 standard. Additionally, properties along 6th, which would be on the northeast side of 6th,
[0:35:20] are also zoned R6. These properties could have these types of uses. There's other factors that go
[0:35:28] into play in terms of parking requirements, land area, if they have enough land area to build those
[0:35:34] types of things. That's the area where a 4plex or an apartment structure could be built,
[0:35:41] and what we call a by-right development, which is just go for building permit and meet the code.
[0:35:46] That kind of truncates the zoning items that we discussed in July.
[0:35:51] A pause for questions on zoning items here. There are any. Anybody have any questions for Jonathan so far?
[0:36:06] After that on July 13 we went through the local historic districts legislature talks about
[0:36:13] authorizing local governments to engage in comprehensive program of historic preservation.
[0:36:17] This is their purpose statement. I didn't summarize that one, but I'm not going to read all of it either.
[0:36:24] They also have a very clear process to create and historic districts.
[0:36:30] Legislature allows local governments to establish a local district.
[0:36:35] I paraphrase one through five. It's not listed the same way in state statute, but essentially you conduct an investigation
[0:36:42] For the historic area, architectural, archaeological, and cultural significance go through reporting the findings to the local planning board for their consideration.
[0:36:51] Historic Preservation Commission holds a public hearing after noticing those inside the property boundaries or inside the boundary.
[0:36:58] That commission also submits a final report and a draft proposal to council and then the council acts on the ordinance.
[0:37:04] That's the process to create a local historic district.
[0:37:07] When you do that, you can see these sections of state code on come right after the other,
[0:37:16] so 4607-4608.
[0:37:17] Once that's done and you have the designation of a historic district,
[0:37:21] the certificate of appropriateness clause or requirement comes in.
[0:37:24] It talks about no exterior change of standing building, and then it lists numbers of things.
[0:37:29] No changes are permitted until after approval of a certificate of appropriateness
[0:37:34] by the sort of preservation commission.
[0:37:36] This approved.
[0:37:39] It also goes further and shall be required, whether or not a building permit is required,
[0:37:43] shall include review of and then at lists, architectural style, general design, or general
[0:37:48] arrangement of the exterior buildings, including color, kind, and texture of the building material
[0:37:53] and type and style of all windows, doors, light fixtures, signs, other pertinent fixtures,
[0:37:58] and natural features such as trees and shrubbery.
[0:38:01] That's from the state statute.
[0:38:03] So once you create an historic district, then this clause for a certificate of appropriateness
[0:38:07] comes in.
[0:38:08] Now there is a leeway in speaking with the attorney, there's leeway as to what degree
[0:38:14] you look at if this were enacted, which is it could be that as you go through the process
[0:38:19] to create what they call guidelines, the council on the sort of preservation commission could
[0:38:24] say in this area the shrubbery and the trees were not of historic significance to the one
[0:38:31] two.
[0:38:33] I'm just kind of going if you put that in your ordinance, it would need to kick in.
[0:38:39] There's an automatic approval of a certificate of appropriateness.
[0:38:42] What we can't do is not require someone to basically declare what they've done or what
[0:38:47] they're going to do.
[0:38:48] We have to issue a certificate of appropriateness, either way.
[0:38:51] The statute's clear on it.
[0:38:52] You shall have that step of issuing a certificate of appropriateness.
[0:38:58] It could be an automatic issuance if they tell you what you're doing and it meets these
[0:39:01] minimums.
[0:39:02] If someone's going to tear a building down, build a new one that might be something that
[0:39:07] the degree of regulation is you need to go through the Historic Preservation Commission
[0:39:11] to get approval.
[0:39:12] So there's everywhere from.
[0:39:14] We don't mind you re-painting the picket fence from white to brown.
[0:39:18] Just tell us what you're doing so it's documented, registered.
[0:39:22] And then there's the full leg where we're going to tear a building down and go through
[0:39:25] this public process.
[0:39:26] The degree can change, but what we've determined is you still have, there would be some semblance
[0:39:33] of telling the cities and truly registering the changes
[0:39:37] with somebody so that we can keep any questions
[0:39:42] on this particular, could it be someone
[0:39:49] in a pocket?
[0:39:52] Any questions for John?
[0:39:55] So, to be clear, the zoning, whether it's, looks like yellow
[0:40:02] to me, you called it orange, or pink, if a historic,
[0:40:07] and the section that falls within the triangle is
[0:40:11] declared a historic district, what does that do
[0:40:14] to the existing zoning. The zoning separate regulation of the zoning is for land uses,
[0:40:21] heights, things like that. Is it different type of different area in the state statute
[0:40:25] that you shall follow? We have to set up our process for the items that we're looking
[0:40:30] at. So a adoption of a historic district would not have changed the masquerade apartments
[0:40:41] ability to build their complex.
[0:40:45] It would have changed potentially would have looked like if this were in place before.
[0:40:49] The land use as an apartment building was permitted back in 1989
[0:40:53] and you wouldn't be able to take that away without some sort of a taking of private property rights.
[0:40:57] So there may be some exterior changes
[0:41:01] based on the historic district
[0:41:05] but the building itself could have still been built.
[0:41:09] A building apartment building, I haven't been able to be built yet. These are the items that would be reviewed.
[0:41:15] The style might have changed. The general design arrangement of the exterior of the building.
[0:41:21] And that's not necessarily on an existing structure. It can be on a new structure as well.
[0:41:26] Yes.
[0:41:27] So if houses torn down and somebody wants to build a house in the historic district, they have to follow these guidelines.
[0:41:34] If this were in place.
[0:41:35] Okay. Thank you. Chris Reed.
[0:41:37] What about those businesses, especially on Shoshone, that are not historic, that have been built recently, what would happen to those, whether it turned out something new built there, or if they wanted to change the facade on their buildings?
[0:41:51] Any buildings, I mean that's downtown, they have the downtown historic district, they're all businesses primarily, I think almost all of them are down here to the design guidelines that get created.
[0:42:03] That's what makes us want to be complicated.
[0:42:05] We have some businesses long to show that have been there a long time.
[0:42:07] We also have historic homes.
[0:42:09] The architectural features of the homes, domestic translated businesses,
[0:42:13] that's something that would have to be accomplished in the future.
[0:42:17] They might meet different design guidelines.
[0:42:19] Yet they would still fall under this unless they were specifically excluded out of the district that were created.
[0:42:32] Also contained in the state statute, it's somewhat the number's difference.
[0:42:36] So 67, 46, 14 it comes sometime later after the historic district piece.
[0:42:41] not only bring it up because it's in statute,
[0:42:42] it talks about something different for historic properties
[0:42:45] that is allowed by ordinance to the council.
[0:42:49] And so it's essentially written to be used,
[0:42:52] potentially for city councils
[0:42:53] to basically designate individual properties,
[0:42:56] or properties that may not be consolidated one area,
[0:42:59] but are a store in nature
[0:43:00] that the council would want to protect individually.
[0:43:02] The process for that is very similar to the other.
[0:43:06] Investigation of a hearing from the property,
[0:43:10] passage of an ordinance and then it creates essentially a demolition ordinance
[0:43:14] so you have to wait 180 days or if they're going to change that property you wait 180 days
[0:43:19] I'm basically going to kind of talk with the sort of preservation commission
[0:43:23] it just allows that time period of like a cool down period type of discussion
[0:43:27] there are exceptions to 180 days of like safety and maintenance repairs this is
[0:43:33] a distinct and separate type of protection it is not the same as a
[0:43:37] district. It doesn't have like a historic guideline type of thing. It's just an
[0:43:42] ordinance for each individual property, although it is distinct and separate. So
[0:43:45] I think it's a tool you have available if you so wish to use it. I'm going to go
[0:43:55] through real quickly this background info on the original town site. What you see
[0:43:58] is kind of this brown orange whatever this is, different color than the rest of it.
[0:44:03] It encompasses a large portion of downtown or the original town site which
[0:44:08] which is the one mile block. That is the original boundary of the town site at Central District.
[0:44:15] That's what was nominated in 2000 for the National Register of Historic Places, an area
[0:44:22] that encompasses 950 properties. The area that the avenues is proposed is this corner piece
[0:44:28] over here. It's 300-ish properties in this area, but it's part of the original district.
[0:44:36] The federal guidelines have being on the National Register does not limit private property owners using the property.
[0:44:41] That was a question someone posted to me, so I thought I'd put it on here.
[0:44:44] That does create a protection of private property from the federal level.
[0:44:49] So if a federal project is going to be contemplated in these boundaries, there's federal guidelines you have to go through in order to do the project in that area using federal dollars, and that's where our State Historic Preservation Office gets involved.
[0:45:03] There's a step from federal, basically a federal checklist to go through consulting,
[0:45:09] SHPO, and consulting the local area for the disturbance of these properties when it's
[0:45:16] a federal project.
[0:45:17] Does that include opportunity zone?
[0:45:19] I don't know if the opportunity zone comes into it.
[0:45:24] What I do know comes into it is federal transportation dollars and anything from the EPA in terms
[0:45:31] review like either stormwater or something like that.
[0:45:36] But that's part of the original project.
[0:45:43] So now I'm going to the area, Ms. Giro, also created design guidelines that are applicable to that nominated area.
[0:45:49] They contain a collection of exhibits and drawings depicting materials, things like that, that were unique to that area
[0:45:55] on the original town site.
[0:45:57] They can be used for education, they can also be used for exactly what we're talking about tonight, a local district
[0:46:02] district to say, if you're going to change things, follow the guidelines, go to the
[0:46:07] Historic Preservation Commission, they make a determination on whether you
[0:46:09] meet the guidelines or not. This is an excerpt from one of the pages. I picked
[0:46:14] the fence one because people asked me about fences in the area. This is an
[0:46:19] excerpt from her guidelines. It talks about from yard fencing and planting
[0:46:24] patterns. He's actually one like two, three, four, five. What he essentially
[0:46:30] create would be the guideline, just to maintain the traditional planting in front yards.
[0:46:34] The talk is about owners might want to investigate water-wise landscaping, but the use of grass
[0:46:40] front yard reinforces visual continuity and hard surfaces in the front yard should not
[0:46:44] be allowed.
[0:46:45] The talk is about fencing material that complements historic character of the district.
[0:46:49] In the early 1900s, the hairpin wire fencing for wood pickets and lattice, a chain link
[0:46:55] was intended for industrial and is inappropriate in front yards.
[0:46:59] So if you create the guidelines to create a district, and if you have these as the guidelines,
[0:47:03] someone bringing a fence change to, let's say just a wood seeder that precluded vision
[0:47:08] in the front yard, the historic preservation commission would have to review it, review
[0:47:13] it against these guidelines and make a determination whether or not it meant the guidelines approve
[0:47:17] the change or not approve the change.
[0:47:19] It's just a scenario that's possible if these are the guidelines used.
[0:47:23] So, if you create it, the local district, they'll be created a system, the property will need
[0:47:32] to seek approval for changes to their homes that have previously been now right permitted.
[0:47:36] Right now, we do not have any needing for approval to repeat the house, the fence, anything
[0:47:42] in the front door, anything like that in that area.
[0:47:46] So the amount of regulation that will be decided upon by the Council through a public hearing
[0:47:51] process and an ordinance.
[0:47:52] But what we know is there would need to be something.
[0:47:57] Where are we in the process?
[0:47:58] So we've started spring.
[0:48:02] This is the code on what's required to create a district.
[0:48:07] We're here on August 15th, and we are at step 0.5.
[0:48:10] That's what I put in there.
[0:48:11] We don't have an investigation that's updated.
[0:48:14] So you're tasked with making a decision,
[0:48:17] writing staff to move forward with the creation of a district.
[0:48:21] And these are the amounts that are from the previous items.
[0:48:26] That's the information I have, truncating,
[0:48:29] multiple hearings and multiple things down to this.
[0:48:33] I have no more to present if you have any questions for me.
[0:48:36] Any questions for Jonathan?
[0:48:43] Did a very good job of explaining that.
[0:48:46] So I would guess our next would be to open it up
[0:48:49] for the public.
[0:48:50] We did encourage people to write down.
[0:48:52] So I would have the list to go first.
[0:48:54] Oh, perfect.
[0:48:55] Would you like a map or anything up while people speak?
[0:48:57] Or would you like the timer up?
[0:49:00] Can we do both?
[0:49:16] And there's no, this isn't a land use public hearing.
[0:49:18] So this is.
[0:49:19] So the rules related to public input when you come up to the podium.
[0:49:29] I will call your name off this list and then we'll leave it open for anybody that didn't happen to sign the list.
[0:49:36] As soon as I call your name, please come up to the podium, state your full name,
[0:49:41] and whether you're a resident or property owner in the City of Twin Falls,
[0:49:45] and then proceed with your input tonight.
[0:49:48] put tonight. Typically I only do two minutes. Tonight I'm gonna allow three minutes.
[0:49:53] One thing I would ask is, well, several things. Number one is if someone has
[0:50:00] spoken and said the exact same thing that you have said, please help us so we
[0:50:05] don't have to be there here all night. Secondly, I would hope that everyone was
[0:50:10] respectful. All of us have worked very hard getting up here and we're very
[0:50:16] serious about this discussion and so we really are taking everything you say
[0:50:22] to heart so please also be respectful and let's have fun okay so a first name on
[0:50:32] the list is Kathy learn Kathy would come up please make a suggestion that we
[0:50:49] just leave that mic on nobody wish the button that says push when you're done
[0:50:53] [Muted for privacy: street address]
[0:51:00] [Muted for privacy: street address]
[0:51:06] [Muted for privacy: street address]
[0:51:12] I am against the historic district.
[0:51:18] Yes, we are a story of city. Yes, we are awesome.
[0:51:22] But I do not feel, and I am speaking on four houses in my block.
[0:51:30] We do not feel that it is someone's right to tell me whether I can paint my house pink with purple hot polka dots.
[0:51:40] If I want to put a chain-link fence out front, it's my home.
[0:51:45] I don't care who built it. I appreciate the built it.
[0:51:51] I don't care who lived in it. I care who lives in it now. And that's me. And with that, you know, this is something
[0:52:01] It's great to have historic districts. It's great to be able to go and see a Lincoln's home
[0:52:06] That I agree
[0:52:08] If someone wants to have their home and have it so that you know people can know that
[0:52:16] So-and-so live there or build it, you know, I mean that's fine
[0:52:21] might do that. But don't put restrictions on the rest of us. And even though I've been
[0:52:31] told by a bunch of people that no, if the taxes won't go up, they're going to go up
[0:52:36] into a coast or a district. Yeah, well, but when that happens, then when you go to sell,
[0:52:42] you make more money. It's an unlimited income. I don't have the extra funds to pay more property
[0:52:51] for funds to pay more property taxes because people decided that I lived in the
[0:52:59] historic district. I just I hope you listen to all of us pro and con and I hope
[0:53:08] you really decide to vote against it. Thank you Kathy. Okay next person is
[0:53:19] is Courtney's buck. Am I saying that right? Courtney, please come down.
[0:53:26] The extra 45 seconds. No you don't. I should do that also. You can't take it. You can't give your time to anybody else.
[0:53:44] My name is Courtney Stalk and I am a property owner and a resident of Twin Falls.
[0:53:50] So I don't necessarily have anything special to say and I'm just going to throw my hat into, yes I would like to have something put in place.
[0:53:59] place so that if somebody decides to buy the property next to me that I'm not
[0:54:07] living next to if I want to live in a newer area I would I would live in a
[0:54:12] newer area and I respect those who do want it I respect those who don't want
[0:54:18] anything to be done however in for all purposes I'm already doing
[0:54:26] everything because I actually like the area, I would already do everything that would be
[0:54:33] in the booklet.
[0:54:34] And if I have to run a paint color by somebody, it does chafe me to have to do so, to be honest
[0:54:42] with you.
[0:54:43] That's why I say I respect both sides.
[0:54:45] But that's the least of my worries when it comes to having the ability to live in an
[0:54:54] that I appreciate and that has value.
[0:54:58] I hope that when people live in a place where they live, they find that it has value.
[0:55:04] And if they don't, that they can find a place, that they want to live, that they find value where they live.
[0:55:11] I could live someplace else, I don't live someplace else, and I would be doing everything.
[0:55:19] I'm not necessarily wild about having to run something by somebody else.
[0:55:24] I would want it to be done in a timely manner. There should be stipulations that way as well.
[0:55:29] However, I don't want somebody, even though, as has been said by planning and zoning,
[0:55:36] that somebody could come in, and regardless of it being a single family home before they move in,
[0:55:44] maybe they want to make it a duplex or a triplex, because where I am, it's zoned for that.
[0:55:49] I would still like it for it to be to look appropriate and that's all that I
[0:55:56] typically care about is that it looks appropriate what has been built the
[0:56:01] masquerade loss yes it's zoned for that and there's nothing I can do about it
[0:56:06] but it doesn't look appropriate and that that would just be come the norm if
[0:56:11] somebody won't come in here by it a lot they decide I have this amount of square
[0:56:17] footage and this is what I'm allotted to do just please make it look appropriate
[0:56:22] and that's all I have to say thank you guys for your time. Thank you Kourtney.
[0:56:25] Next is K Lopez. I guess that's okay.
[0:56:36] I'm Nyeworth. You Madam Chairman and Council members my name is Tom Nyeworth
[0:56:57] Twin Falls City resident former resident of 8th Avenue East but no longer
[0:57:04] living in the proposed district.
[0:57:07] I just wanted to speak to a couple of things that have been said.
[0:57:17] I want to reinforce the zoning and the historic district
[0:57:23] are really two different animals, anything
[0:57:27] that you're allowed to do with your property the way it's zoned.
[0:57:32] Now you'd still be able to do either as a permitted use
[0:57:36] especially use. The only thing that the historic district is really trying to do is preserve
[0:57:45] the feel of the neighborhood. If it's a commercial building like Farmer's Bank, for example,
[0:57:51] I don't think anybody wants to tell them that if they add on it's going to look like a ginger
[0:57:56] burnt house or something, it's just talking about scale and materials that would be consistent
[0:58:03] with what they've already done, it's still consistent with the scale of the neighborhood.
[0:58:07] So it's not, I don't think we're trying to create a colony of Williamsburg or take everything
[0:58:13] back to a particular period in architectural history.
[0:58:17] It's about respecting what's already there and doing future projects or modifications
[0:58:24] to existing buildings that are consistent with the feel of the neighborhood.
[0:58:31] The other thing I wanted to talk about just a second is the, uh, I read the, read the, uh,
[0:58:38] Twin Phyllis Historic Preservation Plan, the City Historic Preservation Plan, uh, it does
[0:58:43] speak to, uh, as a, as a goal of the city to establish a residential district, uh, within
[0:58:50] the city, uh, it did put set of goals and kind of a time frame for doing that. We're
[0:58:58] kind of at the tail end of the timeframe for doing that now.
[0:59:01] The reason I bring that up is just to emphasize that this isn't something that really just came out of the blue.
[0:59:07] It's something that city residents have given input in when the historic preservation plan was created.
[0:59:15] It's something that the city has had input in also.
[0:59:19] So it is creating this would be consistent with the city's goals that they've stated in their historic preservation plan.
[0:59:27] Thank you, Tom. Next is Shannon Cream. Is that right?
[0:59:36] Madam Chair, members of the Council, my name is Shannon Cream, and you north within the proposed historic district.
[0:59:52] Winston Churchill said, we shape our buildings thereafter they shape us.
[1:00:01] And I think that speaks tremendously to what we're addressing here, which is the legacy
[1:00:11] that our city is leaving to those that are going to follow us.
[1:00:17] I moved here from Tacoma, Washington, which is a city that's right now undergoing a radical
[1:00:23] transformation from an old city into one that's being reimagined by Galena Properties,
[1:00:29] who are obviously familiar with our city and I don't, at type of cookie cutter appearance
[1:00:39] in the town that I've moved to and I don't think many people we've managed to and I say
[1:00:46] we, I'm a member of the historical as petitioned here and the number of signatures collected
[1:00:57] from people living in the neighborhood is in the hundreds.
[1:01:01] This isn't, and certainly there's, you know, I'm not arguing that we have a mandate or there aren't people in opposition.
[1:01:09] I certainly respect that people who own property don't want to see the government pushing them around and telling them that their front door can't be green with pink polka dots.
[1:01:20] But I think, conversely, I don't think those people recognize that when Galena properties
[1:01:27] buys a piece of land that abuts their house, they can build a building that can open their
[1:01:33] garden.
[1:01:34] I don't think that was what they planned when they moved into a historic district.
[1:01:39] So in my opinion, I think this is something that we're arguing should be creative to the
[1:01:48] value that it brings to our community. Not just the value it brings to our individual properties,
[1:01:54] I think it's something that we need to develop a sense of pride in this city and not feel awkward
[1:02:02] as though we're a bunch of heaks that need to look like Los Angeles or Portland or any of the
[1:02:09] other places that these property development companies have successfully moved into and created
[1:02:14] places that look exactly the same one after the other. Thank you so much for you.
[1:02:23] Thank you Shannon. So next is um if we could hold applause today that would be nice so we don't um hold
[1:02:34] this up. Next on the list is Days Ever Heart. How close was I? Dan. Ah that does look like a white note. I know. Okay I've been bothered about it by
[1:02:52] for Nina. Go ahead. Madam Mayor, members of the council, my name is Dan Everhart. I work for the State
[1:03:01] Historic Preservation Office as our outreach historian. That means I'm not a resident of Twin Falls,
[1:03:06] but I'm happy to be here tonight as I've been in previous public meetings and been involved in these
[1:03:12] conversations both with city staff and neighbors now for quite some time, well before making up the
[1:03:19] Just briefly, the State Historic Preservation Office is a department of division within the Idaho State Historical Society, which is a state agency with the Governor appointed board, who makes historic places around the State of Idaho in concert with a whole series of local partners at the city and county level.
[1:03:40] level. We have 40 such certified local governments, Twin Falls being one of them, across the
[1:03:49] state to understand, designate, sometimes protect historic places. Co-State Historic Preservation
[1:04:00] Office, which we abbreviate as SHPO, SHPO, we call ourselves, has had a long and productive
[1:04:07] relationship and partnership with the City of Twin Falls, which established its historic
[1:04:12] program in 1998. So over the past 24 years our office has been happy to award the City of
[1:04:20] Twin Falls, 21 grants, totally over $110,000. We value this partnership, we apply the city's
[1:04:29] efforts to identify and protect historic places. Through this particular issue, of course we
[1:04:37] We appreciate the time and the energy invested in your consideration of the local residential
[1:04:43] historic district.
[1:04:44] These local districts are experiencing our understanding working state-wide, statewide,
[1:04:50] are the most effective way to ensure the preservation of historic places, and they've been used
[1:04:56] to help twin falls, protect its historic downtown, commercial, and warehouse neighborhoods for
[1:05:03] years.
[1:05:04] We also understand that there are many considerations which you must weigh before making the decision
[1:05:10] and we're happy to help if we can.
[1:05:13] We're happy to help answer questions, ensure that you have a full understanding of the opportunities
[1:05:19] and yes the obligations that a new local historic district would bring.
[1:05:24] Not only is ours to have prepared to work with the city but our grant program which
[1:05:28] you have access to as a certified local government could possibly find additional studies, documentation,
[1:05:34] design guidelines are discussed with whichever route you go. So, this conversation is important.
[1:05:44] It's a decision left to you and we won't interfere in that.
[1:05:51] Thank you very much.
[1:05:53] Up next is Rest remain.
[1:05:56] Twin Falls, Paul Smith, who is not able to be here, who is with the State Historical Society.
[1:06:20] As forty years as a professional historian in public history and preservation, I've been
[1:06:29] here in Twin Falls for a long time.
[1:06:31] I'm a native of Twin Falls of the southern Idaho I live in the area, our community, and
[1:06:41] for me and for y'all.
[1:06:44] The study by Elizabeth Shiro is not out of date.
[1:06:47] With all due respect to Jonathan, I told him this at the meeting prior.
[1:06:52] I don't think we want to take Jonathan's word over Dr. Gentry or Dr. Tremaine.
[1:07:00] The columns were of the study I was there when that study was conducted.
[1:07:08] And I thought for 20 years we had a warehouse district, the park, the business district,
[1:07:15] and a residential district.
[1:07:18] I just discovered recently that the city has not recognized the historic residential
[1:07:24] district, and it needs to do it urgently.
[1:07:29] This is not step one in the process.
[1:07:33] Paul Smith and I have worked on this for 20 years, Madam Mayor and City Council, but
[1:07:38] we were there when this was produced.
[1:07:40] There were 600 homes.
[1:07:41] We're down to 300.
[1:07:43] A little intervention I would like to look at the map again.
[1:07:49] We don't have time into the old pre-be house to create a parking lot.
[1:07:57] Judge Smith represented the parking lot at that time.
[1:08:00] And I'd like to go to Jonathan's slide on how the state encourages cities to create historic
[1:08:08] districts and to pursue historical preservation.
[1:08:12] I was with Dan just a week ago at Milachro, one of the most unique farm sites in the western
[1:08:20] United States.
[1:08:22] We live in a historic district that deals with some life and continuity that was decimated
[1:08:29] in the 1960s and 70s when people were indifferent to history and historical preservation.
[1:08:37] I was here when we celebrated the 100th anniversary and it needs to be celebrated daily.
[1:08:46] This residential area needs to be saved.
[1:08:50] No one's losing private property rights.
[1:08:53] It has to be approved by the Historical Preservation Commission.
[1:08:57] It has to be approved by you all.
[1:09:00] You can tell the preservation people to go jump in the river, there's nothing that we
[1:09:05] can do.
[1:09:06] We're here to advise, to consult, to encourage the preservation of our most valuable history
[1:09:15] in the state, in the western United States.
[1:09:17] Thank you, Madam.
[1:09:18] May I have a few in time?
[1:09:19] Thank you, Russ.
[1:09:21] Okay.
[1:09:22] Next is Jan Rogers.
[1:09:23] Rogers.
[1:09:24] Actually, I was curious.
[1:09:36] I didn't know whether I'd speak to you.
[1:09:45] I was curious, I didn't know whether I'd speak tonight, and I was curious as to how this plan was going to be laid out, and what I've heard are really two different things.
[1:09:54] We have the homes, the single family homes, which are the boundaries of the district, that really differences the residential.
[1:10:29] It's now great. If I had to go back and think about it, so at the end of the day, I accomplished what we've been trying to last 100 years.
[1:11:12] I lived in Idaho Falls, one street away from the historic
[1:11:16] district, both inside and out, inside and around.
[1:11:32] He's just very restricted on to replace the windows
[1:11:39] if I had to replace them with a ring.
[1:11:43] So next is Alicia Cochran.
[1:12:14] My name is Alicia Cochran.
[1:12:15] I'm a property owner and resident of Twin Falls.
[1:12:18] I am one of the few residents, the Long Show Shelms.
[1:12:22] I have a home on Show Shell.
[1:12:24] I see the pros and cons on both sides.
[1:12:26] a lot of what I was going to say has already been said.
[1:12:28] My one concern I have is the impact this could have
[1:12:31] on just deferred maintenance of people's homes.
[1:12:34] Would they be able to afford some aid issues
[1:12:38] not to apply to change the pain to their house
[1:12:39] or update their house?
[1:12:40] I'm already can't afford to,
[1:12:42] but I just wonder what impact it could have
[1:12:44] on people being able to do maintenance
[1:12:47] or interventions on their home.
[1:12:52] So that is everybody who's signed up,
[1:12:54] but I do want to give an opportunity
[1:12:56] to anybody in the audience who didn't sign up that wishes to speak for anybody.
[1:13:02] Thank you Madam Mayor and City Council for this opportunity. My name is Michael already.
[1:13:18] I am a resident of Twin Falls and I do live, I do have a home that I currently live in.
[1:13:25] That's within the historic district. I am adamantly against what the historic preservation committee
[1:13:33] trying to do what they are trying to do to our properties for multiple reasons. One really,
[1:13:44] really hate HOA's and what the state law and I have read the state law over and over and
[1:13:52] actually look at the state law and there's a reason why the state excludes its properties
[1:13:56] from the guidelines and the structure of the historic conditions. They are very burdensome,
[1:14:02] they are very expensive.
[1:14:04] And frankly, they are for more repressive than any HOA.
[1:14:09] Now, they can come in and say, we're really, really modest.
[1:14:13] You know, tell me a federal regulatory agency that has limited their power and their authority.
[1:14:20] You always come in on an easy dime to make it more acceptable.
[1:14:24] I have found they have actually been dishonest with the community, not, you know, not,
[1:14:29] I've not explained to people what it actually means to be an historic district.
[1:14:34] If you tell people that they need to ask permission to switch out their light fixtures,
[1:14:38] find a lot of them are adamantly, you know, quickly change their opinion on their property,
[1:14:45] being under these guidelines and these building codes.
[1:14:48] Building codes for the city are meant to protect the city, protect the well-being, the safety of the city.
[1:14:55] This is putting the burden on the people within a certain geographic area
[1:15:02] I have worked on these homes much of my life and I can tell you they are very very expensive
[1:15:07] Close message you see in the picture. They are not cheap those windows the wood
[1:15:13] Deciding is very very expensive. They are not going to be paying that difference a hundred thousand dollar bond
[1:15:22] That is pen gonna give everyone a thousand dollars
[1:15:26] $2,000 to fix their home. I can spend over $100,000 at my home alone. In fact, I spend many
[1:15:33] thousand dollars because I love restoring these homes. I love all the homes. People move into
[1:15:39] old neighborhoods because they love old homes. Now, this is a tax. This is a tax on the whole
[1:15:47] city. They said that this was not going to cost the city anything. I'm having to pay somebody
[1:15:53] to go through and redo the survey to find out where the homes are at and is and then have another
[1:15:59] full-time employee I think we should actually take those dollars if we are
[1:16:02] gonna have another employee let's hire another firefighter let's hire another
[1:16:05] policeman let's not take away property rights of the individual citizen it's
[1:16:10] my property I'm the deed holder I know what's best for not an outside
[1:16:16] committee thank you so anybody else who wishes to speak I'll get you Kate my
[1:16:30] My name is Patti and I am...
[1:16:32] How do you hear last name please?
[1:16:33] Cameron.
[1:16:34] Thank you.
[1:16:35] And I am a friend post-residence.
[1:16:37] And I do not live in this area.
[1:16:40] But I would not want anyone coming to my area in telling you what to do with my home.
[1:16:47] So I am supportive of these people that have come down to speak what they want to do with their own.
[1:17:02] Anybody else who didn't sign up?
[1:17:04] Yes sir.
[1:17:05] My name is Philip Alenta, I'm a resident of Twin Falls.
[1:17:23] I've been jotting down some notes here and I will skip the ones that have been stated already.
[1:17:30] I would like to remind people of what was said earlier that the apartment building could have been built anyway.
[1:17:42] I would also like to state that as a homeowner, the creation of a historical district would
[1:17:56] impact who may enter into a contract with me to purchase my home in a future time.
[1:18:05] In my opinion, the creation of a historical district is not the way to prevent department
[1:18:10] buildings from being built into in-false.
[1:18:14] It is not the way to deal with upset over what deals are made with certain property developers.
[1:18:22] The additional scrutiny on everything from plants to property use that a historical district
[1:18:28] would create for the homeowner sounds quite onerous, if you ask me.
[1:18:35] It's also interesting the use of the word historical before Twin Falls existed.
[1:18:41] The vegetation was sagebrush.
[1:18:43] So we would be sort of moving target this idea of history.
[1:18:50] So what vegetation is really of historical significance to this area?
[1:18:58] Is it a black locus tree?
[1:19:00] Is it sagebrush?
[1:19:02] What is that vegetation?
[1:19:05] In addition to these things, I believe that issue here is a difference in values.
[1:19:11] And I do not believe that a blanket application of those values, in spite of an individual homeowner's
[1:19:18] objection, is appropriate.
[1:19:23] I welcome homeowners in this area to make a case for their own homes, but if they want
[1:19:32] their own homes to be historical homes and to be protected in that way, then I believe
[1:19:38] that they and their neighbors should get together and do that.
[1:19:42] I am opposed to the historical district.
[1:19:45] I do not want my home designated as part of an area as such.
[1:19:50] And I'll finish with another reason why.
[1:19:55] There is a housing crunch in Twin Falls.
[1:20:00] They're putting our new Americans, our refugees in hotels.
[1:20:05] They cannot house them.
[1:20:07] There are people who are coming to Twin Falls for work who cannot find housing and have to
[1:20:11] turn jobs down. How are we going to handle the growth that is happening here in Twin
[1:20:17] Falls without more justification? Thank you. Thank you. Are anyone else? Okay, Kate.
[1:20:27] I appreciate hearing the dissent. Actually, some of the topics are of concern. However,
[1:20:56] one of them I think that's misunderstood is that the residents of the members of the
[1:21:04] friends of the avenues have no intention of making anything retroactive.
[1:21:09] Any of the homes that are in the district or in the proposed district now,
[1:21:14] this would only be going forward, would have nothing to do with the interior buildings.
[1:21:19] It would only have to do with the exterior, and there have been no design guidelines prepared.
[1:21:25] Hopefully, it's the intent of the committee that the members in that proposed,
[1:21:30] the residents of that proposed district could get together with the historic
[1:21:34] Preservation Commission and council members and create those guidelines to
[1:21:39] not have them onerous. That's not the intent at all. The intent is to keep an
[1:21:44] area that's beautiful the way it is now to welcome visitors to town. This area
[1:21:52] that's proposed is the gateway to twin and it identifies the historic area of
[1:21:58] downtown, these are the initial homes that the founders lived in, and it's one more thing
[1:22:03] that we can celebrate as a city, because our city is becoming Walmart and Target and every
[1:22:09] other homogenous business in the world, where it's not like that, it's downtown.
[1:22:16] That's the field we want to maintain, and that's what we want to do by adding the last
[1:22:21] part of the puzzle that your comprehensive plan and your historic master plan has said
[1:22:28] is a goal and that's the residential component. Now I know that there have been COVID funds
[1:22:35] that have been awarded to the city and I'm not proposing that they be used for this, but
[1:22:41] I am asking you to consider that because there are additional funds that the city will have
[1:22:47] that it might free up regular dollars in the budget
[1:22:53] to continue to look at the historic district
[1:22:57] and allocate some funds for the creation of historic districts
[1:23:00] so that we can be proud and advertise the very assets
[1:23:05] that make us who we are.
[1:23:12] OK, is there anybody else that wishes to speak at this time?
[1:23:18] OK, seeing no one that closes the public input section
[1:23:23] of this meeting, this public hearing.
[1:23:25] Yes, Jonathan.
[1:23:26] Just wanted to clarify.
[1:23:27] We did receive letters.
[1:23:28] Yes.
[1:23:29] Letters that were received were put in the packet.
[1:23:30] Those that were received after, I think, Thursday, two around two o'clock today were emailed to you.
[1:23:37] We have a copy if you want to put the discussion.
[1:23:55] Can I just read the application from Jonathan?
[1:23:59] Yes.
[1:24:00] Can you address why you feel the study is outdated of your guidelines on why that is?
[1:24:13] Yes, so what we believe needs to be updated during the pictures associated with the investigation.
[1:24:19] 20 years has passed, people have done a lot of things to homes over 20 years.
[1:24:23] You've heard a couple of them, so we wouldn't need this case saying if you create the regulation today,
[1:24:29] we would go from today forward, but we would have a 20-year gap of what has happened since 2000, the 2022.
[1:24:38] And so if we're going to hold somebody to something that has occurred, we don't want them to be held to something that happened before the regulation was in place.
[1:24:44] So we would need new photos of each property in the area.
[1:24:47] Some of them would be contributing, that's a term for, there's still a historic and nature value.
[1:24:53] Some of them may not be anymore, we need to keep track of that going forward because the regulation would be more stringent on those that are contributing.
[1:25:01] In terms of they need to keep them that way and those that want to add on to a non-contributive building have different types of regulations to look at.
[1:25:08] They get separated into different piles.
[1:25:10] That's our cover.
[1:25:19] You don't need to stay in the hot stand.
[1:25:21] Thank you.
[1:25:22] So, I'm sure other council members
[1:25:24] go on a chance to weigh in tonight,
[1:25:26] and so I have somewhat of a proposal,
[1:25:30] but not ready to make a motion on it,
[1:25:31] but something to think about.
[1:25:33] So, a lot of this really comes down to the devils are,
[1:25:36] and the devil is in the details.
[1:25:40] I'm still hearing a lot of misunderstanding
[1:25:41] about what historic district is.
[1:25:44] Now, if you're using that term historic district,
[1:25:47] that is defined in state statute,
[1:25:49] And there's a very prescriptive way about going about it.
[1:25:53] There is some room for interpretation.
[1:25:56] As I've looked into two other historic districts
[1:26:00] that exist in the state, they seem to have interpreted
[1:26:03] pretty loosely and they haven't been challenged legally.
[1:26:06] So this is a new territory really for Idaho,
[1:26:09] where a young state, but what I'm getting at
[1:26:13] is a lot of people, especially in the written comments,
[1:26:17] I said, I don't want to tell my neighbor
[1:26:19] They can't meet their house or they can't do that.
[1:26:21] I just want to protect this.
[1:26:23] Well, depending on the guidelines and depending
[1:26:25] on your interpretation of state statute,
[1:26:29] your neighbor would have to go through the process
[1:26:31] of submitting to get a certificate of appropriateness,
[1:26:35] going to the commission, and then hitting approval
[1:26:38] to paint their house or say a light fixture.
[1:26:41] So the bad side is, it could be a Saturday
[1:26:44] and you think, oh, I actually have a good free time today.
[1:26:47] I'm gonna run down to Home Depot
[1:26:48] and replace that fixture that's been broken on my front porch.
[1:26:51] No, stop.
[1:26:52] You need to plan ahead of time.
[1:26:54] So that's a scenario that I think a lot of people
[1:26:57] are aware of and think that would be terrible.
[1:26:59] They don't want that burden put on them.
[1:27:03] It's possible that we write the guidelines such that you
[1:27:07] don't have to apply for a certificate of appropriateness
[1:27:10] to do a task like that.
[1:27:12] So really, as the devil is in the details,
[1:27:15] I think that it might be appropriate to actually spend
[1:27:18] money to write the guidelines and then when people are speaking
[1:27:23] hearing against this they have a clearer idea of what to expect for the property.
[1:27:29] I personally have bought a home outside the district because I saw
[1:27:35] as a chance to fix up make money and my wife and I would like to sell our home
[1:27:39] and move to this neighborhood and I would love to live in historic district.
[1:27:44] That's my personal bias and I'm saying it here because I wanted to make a public record
[1:27:47] a public record rather than inadvertently mention this in a conversation outside of here and
[1:27:52] you know, get in trouble that way. That being said, I couldn't look an existing homeowner in the eye
[1:27:58] and say I understand that you do not want this, but I'm voting against you. So I'm in a tough spot.
[1:28:05] I think if we spent the money to write the guidelines it might alleviate a lot of the misunderstanding and
[1:28:13] Disagreement.
[1:28:14] Yeah, it's down there.
[1:28:23] Questions, thoughts?
[1:28:26] Craycottons.
[1:28:29] This was, of course, uh, decided a situation to try to decide on.
[1:28:40] He dies, uh, right, so private property.
[1:28:42] All that we received.
[1:28:50] This, he basically said, make a historic preservation.
[1:28:56] But we don't need all the rules and regulations.
[1:28:58] We just want the next nation.
[1:29:00] Peace that I don't know.
[1:29:07] It's historical.
[1:29:11] history like that is really the answer to that. Jonathan may be a question for you. You talked about historic properties.
[1:29:22] Obviously those that are very strongly in favor of this and there's those that aren't.
[1:29:28] Could you have expound on that just a little bit? Could a person determine their home to be historic property?
[1:29:36] Neighbors and so forth wanted to get that expanded into a district eventually.
[1:29:44] So the property is statute separate and distinct. It's in the same chapter as it's a different section
[1:29:51] Clearly to me meant to be just a different the way it works is you have an investigation
[1:29:58] I'm into the property
[1:30:00] And then you have a hearing notifying the property owner and the council just an accident ordinance saying this is this property is a stored property
[1:30:07] The council were to see a number of those
[1:30:12] Either the property owner themselves as you're saying the property owner says I want my house their neighbor also agrees
[1:30:19] and they could chain those together on a street, and if you had enough of them together, indication
[1:30:26] to meet at the council, if they all put their properties on it, because it does restrict
[1:30:31] their property in terms of, you have to wait 180 days, part of that statute also requires
[1:30:38] the commission to notify the assessor, and for him to take into account on their property
[1:30:44] taxes, good or bad, I don't know what you're just says to inform the assessor of it, in
[1:30:50] theory what you're talking about is possible to say we've got ten of these in
[1:30:53] a row now all ten of us have decided we want to do this that could be an
[1:30:58] indication of council to say here's the street one in the historic district
[1:31:01] that way and it is just an ordinance of public hearing and ordinance do ordinances
[1:31:07] all the time yeah I mean if you have an ordinance done by the council the only
[1:31:16] way to remove the ordinance would be for the council to say they want to vote
[1:31:20] majority vote to remove there's nothing I guess nothing in government unless
[1:31:28] The deed restriction is necessarily permanent even zoning codes.
[1:31:32] They take a process to do.
[1:31:34] The process of them be reversed or done the same as they were good.
[1:31:37] As I was going through every sort of two-and-one seems to be more try to do as places to live.
[1:32:12] It was more about an unstill try.
[1:32:37] Here in this country, and if you, a piece of the structure on it or not, it is zoned something.
[1:32:54] And these are the things just by right of only that.
[1:33:00] So is there anything, have we addressed anywhere in
[1:33:04] if Sony houses, so outside of six, they would be our six
[1:33:15] for so the biggest they could get is?
[1:33:20] The duplex would be a by right, which is get a building permit.
[1:33:26] And then follow the code, the fourplex would be a public hearing
[1:33:29] item with the planning and zoning commission.
[1:33:31] So anything more than a duplex to go through a process
[1:33:37] where those neighbors would be put in?
[1:33:40] Yeah, and to add to that, I know this wasn't the question,
[1:33:43] but sometimes it came to my mind.
[1:33:46] During those public hearings when you have,
[1:33:48] if they were to go that far, the Planning and Zoning Commission
[1:33:51] has within their power granted by the state to dictate
[1:33:54] the look of buildings.
[1:33:56] That is one of those items when you have a special use permit.
[1:33:59] There's a list, and one of them, a few of you
[1:34:01] are on the Planning and Zoning Commission.
[1:34:04] There's a list of items, and being harmonious
[1:34:06] is one of the questions you'd have to find.
[1:34:08] So a Foreplex would go through the process
[1:34:11] of a public hearing commission would then either have to make a decision on whether it's
[1:34:16] harmonious or not, or they can put conditions on approval to say you shall. They could be
[1:34:23] as specific as 25% brick, 15% stucco, 30% siding. They can get that specific if they find that
[1:34:34] it would be in harmonious to not do it for the specific location. So, there's avenues
[1:34:42] to get at what we would call design elements of the building, not through that, but through
[1:34:48] the public hearing process with the special use permits, it's just, I want to don't want
[1:34:52] to complicate the zoning side, but it may have just done that, but it is something that you
[1:34:56] can't do.
[1:34:57] I know, but I also know, I've sent the outright owns a lot that they want to build something
[1:35:00] on, and then, and commission of some kind puts a list of things that they have to have,
[1:35:06] it has to be a certain way, out of expense historically.
[1:35:17] would only be for triplexes and four plexes and what was yellow or orange area the majority of this area
[1:35:26] this is a this is a tough topic for me I appreciate what councilman keller had said I guess the thing that keeps coming to my mind
[1:36:10] or that my concern is once you know if we were to pass the historical district I don't think it's the intent of anybody in this
[1:36:18] this room to regulate somebody else.
[1:36:21] But there are some levers that once you pull,
[1:36:24] you can't take that back.
[1:36:26] My concern is what happens with the next group of people
[1:36:29] that come in to the area and want to make it
[1:36:31] a little bit more strict or stringent.
[1:36:34] They weren't part of this initial conversation.
[1:36:36] There were conversations that I was not a part of
[1:36:39] during the masquerade apartment complex.
[1:36:43] I don't really understand some of the core values
[1:36:46] or issues around that.
[1:36:48] My concern is, once we create the district,
[1:36:53] it becomes very difficult to put that back in,
[1:36:56] back in the barn, to say it that way.
[1:37:01] The other part, I think, is what Councilman Hawkins said,
[1:37:04] is if there's a way to maybe do a more of a grassroot
[1:37:07] after getting individual homeowners to work together,
[1:37:11] to create a subset of that district,
[1:37:14] and we can see what that looks like
[1:37:17] from a individual property understand point.
[1:37:20] I think that is a benefit, but also go back to what Councilman
[1:37:24] Cutler said, it would be nice to see what those design criteria may be.
[1:37:32] But again, if somebody wants to change something,
[1:37:35] it takes 180 days for that change to go through.
[1:37:38] There's requirements that we aren't able to get around.
[1:37:43] So, again, my concern is once we go down this road,
[1:37:49] we may not be able to have that room,
[1:37:53] so that's what I'm trouble.
[1:37:58] So we have all sorts of options here.
[1:38:04] We've had this discussion for several months now.
[1:38:08] We can direct staff to do something different.
[1:38:13] I see, Chris, are you still on your Nikki?
[1:38:17] What are you?
[1:38:18] Okay, so Chris, are you doing some thoughts?
[1:38:22] Yeah, I'll share my opinion.
[1:38:26] First, I think tonight we do value Europe,
[1:38:31] appreciate the input.
[1:38:33] As someone who does not live in this district, this area,
[1:38:38] I do appreciate historic preservation.
[1:38:42] This is a fascinating discussion,
[1:38:44] because two really important good things,
[1:38:47] personal property rights and historic preservation.
[1:38:51] I think everybody, maybe not everybody,
[1:38:55] I'm speaking for everybody,
[1:38:57] But everybody possibly finds that important, okay?
[1:39:01] But right now we're discussing
[1:39:04] potentially a conflict.
[1:39:06] The hard thing I'm struggling with right now
[1:39:08] is it seems that it's a moving target.
[1:39:11] Because the letters that we got,
[1:39:13] we had some, let's count some and talk and talk about it,
[1:39:16] is I don't want to limit somebody's ability
[1:39:20] to change a light fixture,
[1:39:23] but I want to protect this area.
[1:39:27] So how do we go about doing that?
[1:39:29] Because state statute brings it down as, yep, that's absolutely what can happen.
[1:39:36] And so having this discussion without something concrete is very challenging to say, yay or nay,
[1:39:43] because the study does make those specifications.
[1:39:52] It was somebody who, last time, those that were here, now I voted against this,
[1:40:00] I'm struggling right now because it isn't specific what we're actually asking for.
[1:40:05] The second part is to be able to do that. We want to go back and update this study whatever that my pictures
[1:40:15] but then you're asking for
[1:40:20] Individual taxpayers who do not live in this area to pay for that I struggle with that and then the ongoing cost
[1:40:29] Potentially, but we're not even there yet. We're talking about the study to be able to dictate
[1:40:35] Hey
[1:40:36] You can this is the fencing that we're okay with
[1:40:41] According to the study, we might not want that, but that's where I'm struggling right
[1:40:48] now is, this is kind of just the, hey do we want this, but we don't know what we really
[1:40:55] want and we have one side of, don't you dare tell me what to do, which I appreciate, and
[1:41:02] then on the other side, I don't know what the other side is, but I do know people in this
[1:41:12] district are not happy with, potentially changing the environment of it from these historical
[1:41:19] homes which I appreciate, hey I grew up in Chicago, I love the old homes, I love that,
[1:41:25] alright, I went to school in Freeport, Illinois which Abraham Lincoln was in homes, I love that,
[1:41:32] but at the same time we're making everybody in the community potentially pay for that.
[1:41:40] So, my thought, and this, the next step, if we wanted to take a next step, would be similar to almost what Matt Tech did, if the individuals in this district wanted to carry this forward, get a group together and update this, then at that point in time, we all know what the target is.
[1:42:07] I don't know because I've had some people say don't tell me what to pay my
[1:42:11] house and some people say we don't really want to tell you what to pay your
[1:42:15] house we just don't want an apartment complex I don't know what to do but I
[1:42:21] would be willing to look at an actual target an actual study with this is this
[1:42:25] is what we want but again I'm not willing to say everybody in Twin Falls
[1:42:33] gets to pay for this similar to if you know MavTech came in they wanted trails
[1:42:37] they raised funds, they got those funds, they built trails. And then having that
[1:42:43] conversation, we have a gentleman from the State Historic Office. Maybe that's
[1:42:50] something that they can work with him. So there's a target. I don't know what to
[1:42:54] do right now without a target. That's my thoughts. Spencer?
[1:43:00] Thanks, Vice Mayor. So I think that actually the guidelines are more of the
[1:43:08] target that maybe you're referring to. I hope I'm not misunderstanding. But before we do the effort of the study, capturing the existing condition is writing the guidelines.
[1:43:18] Because those would really dictate how strict or how onerous the process is to make changes to your property. I think it's pretty clear, and if Jonathan wants to shake his head at me, I'd give you a chance.
[1:43:31] I think it's pretty clear that state statute does not
[1:43:34] require us to address interior improvements.
[1:43:37] It's just the exterior things that you see.
[1:43:41] And it's possible the guidelines could
[1:43:43] be written that a lot of changes or updates
[1:43:45] or regular maintenance is just outright permitted,
[1:43:48] just as we're not going to address this particular, you know,
[1:43:52] small details that we don't have to worry about.
[1:43:55] It's also possible that there's some exterior improvements
[1:43:58] that could simply be done as long as it complies.
[1:44:01] So they don't have to actually go before the Historic Preservation Commission to get approval.
[1:44:07] So it might be that replacing something on the exterior, whatever, is just permitted per the guidelines if you do it this way.
[1:44:16] So it's not an extra step or extra government regulation that a homeowner or property owner has to go through.
[1:44:22] Now, exactly where those things are, I don't know, that's not the expertise I have.
[1:44:29] I also, my personal belief is that this hasn't really been tested too much and I know, I just, to my knowledge, there haven't been a lot of big disputes, so there could be gray area that we get surprised by.
[1:44:41] But I would be willing to make a motion if no one else has, I guess, comment about actually directing city staff to work on the guidelines because I think that would address at least 80% of the points that we have heard.
[1:44:58] before we spent the time and money on guidelines, before we spent time and money on any other steps.
[1:45:05] Maybe it's putting... I don't think that is putting the card before the horse, I think that's the logical thing to do.
[1:45:11] I'd also add there was guidelines that were, I guess, suggested or offered 20 years ago.
[1:45:18] Maybe what we want or not, but that's what we could work on.
[1:45:25] And also just thank you for everybody for your comments.
[1:45:27] I'm pleasantly surprised how respectful it has been.
[1:45:31] We're talking about people's homes.
[1:45:33] If you want to really strike as someone's heart and emotion,
[1:45:36] you start messing with their homes.
[1:45:38] So thank you so much for your respectful comments.
[1:45:42] Jonathan?
[1:45:46] So our direction on who's going to decide
[1:45:54] what's in the guideline and not,
[1:45:56] because I have a separate, very clear and separate
[1:46:00] don't touch anything and do this.
[1:46:03] I don't know what that process looks like.
[1:46:07] be struggling to know who would make the actual determination as to who writes
[1:46:10] that and what gets put into it and what doesn't. I'm not sure that's going to
[1:46:13] solve anything for y'all but it certainly did. That's part of the issue
[1:46:17] that I think when other municipalities do this the council makes a determination
[1:46:23] to do a district so that you have at least a determination they're gonna do
[1:46:27] it and then you create them. That's where they've all done. Dan and I've talked
[1:46:33] about that like usually that's kind of how they roll because the council you
[1:46:37] I don't know if I'd ever get consensus on a document, is where I'm really coming after.
[1:46:43] I know where you're coming from.
[1:46:45] I don't know where the consensus is with the group of people we've heard from tonight.
[1:46:49] If we're going to get that with 300 people in the district that's being proposed.
[1:46:53] That's from a staff level, I'm not sure I could get that.
[1:46:56] I don't know what I'd put in the document other than create one to be voted on by a body of some sort.
[1:47:02] Well, the other question is the time it takes.
[1:47:06] Yeah, I don't know how I'm going to do that.
[1:47:08] Yeah, from what I understand, things are running pretty tight as it is right now with the staff you have.
[1:47:14] Nicky Boyd.
[1:47:17] That's what I was going to say is asking staff to draft something.
[1:47:25] It's huge, the historical agreements.
[1:47:51] Years.
[1:47:52] Three years.
[1:47:53] Yeah, three years to get through the downtown district with a hundred business owners.
[1:47:58] And so we have something to follow, and so if somebody comes and says, I want to do this kind of sign, we don't have to go through all this stuff.
[1:48:07] This is what signs, lots of ways to do them, but this is the basic document, this is what you can or can't do for years.
[1:48:17] So it's having staff do something is what you're saying,
[1:48:31] and I think what you're saying is,
[1:48:37] and this maybe is going back to the grassroots portion
[1:48:41] of this key, those who really want,
[1:48:50] I'm also with that Chris, other staff person
[1:48:58] in $80,000 a year, that just, when I first learned that,
[1:49:02] that's what just totally blew my mind,
[1:49:04] is I was totally, I was one of the two that was really
[1:49:07] for this and voted yes, but when you see what the state
[1:49:11] state and government telling them how it has to be done and who has to pay for what?
[1:49:48] So I guess my concern is how we pay for it.
[1:49:53] We just passed a budget that says tight as possible and I guess I'm concerned where we
[1:49:58] come up with the funds to do the update, the study and then how we fund time position along
[1:50:09] with the other issues, the personal property rights issue.
[1:50:13] Travis do you have any comment or not at all?
[1:50:17] Thank you so much. You're a big help. Yeah, very wise.
[1:50:22] So, statehood, does the state historic preservation organization have a pretty good, I guess, template that could be more or less handed over?
[1:50:43] I think we're speaking to Dana. Is it Dana? Please, Dan.
[1:50:51] There it looks like there's an A on the end now. You got me all flustered. Dan.
[1:50:57] Yeah, he did. Sorry, Mayor. It's not a complicated name, but I'm sorry. I've been here since 2.30, so
[1:51:13] I remember color. I
[1:51:16] Are there existing templates for design guidelines?
[1:51:20] Absolutely. I
[1:51:22] Wouldn't tell you that our office
[1:51:25] Has them per se, but you do have them in
[1:51:29] in sister cities and communities around the state.
[1:51:33] There are about a dozen Idaho towns and counties
[1:51:37] which regulate historic properties through historic districts
[1:51:41] through local historic districts. So, are you inventing the wheel?
[1:51:46] I don't think so. I think there's a lot that could be taken from
[1:51:50] some of your sister communities if you choose.
[1:51:55] I think it does. I mean, for example, I've seen what voice he's done. There's some things
[1:52:03] that they do that when I read the state statute, I wonder if they're actually technically doing
[1:52:08] it properly, but no one's complained that I've heard about. Thank you for giving your
[1:52:15] best advice without being in a attorney.
[1:52:17] Dan, let me ask you one other question while you're up there. Are there state funds through
[1:52:22] Chippo available for us to hire a consultant to grant or something that would allow us not
[1:52:30] to take it out of our city budget but allow us to hire a consultant to do these guidelines.
[1:52:36] Madam Mayor, yes there are.
[1:52:38] I'm just going to give you a little bit of parameters around that.
[1:52:42] We routinely grant for studies, guidelines, a resurvey, that is our burden, but we do that
[1:52:51] all the time.
[1:52:52] We do require a 50% match, usually the city meets that through their staff time, we don't require a cash match, so I don't want to mislead you to tell you that there is no cost to the city.
[1:53:07] The commissioners on your preservation commission, their volunteer time counts as matched towards our grants, as does any work that the city staff does in their normal work for preservation.
[1:53:19] So these grants do require a match.
[1:53:22] I just want to be clear about that.
[1:53:24] And I would like to just clarify this as well.
[1:53:26] And I don't want to torpedo anything that's being discussed.
[1:53:30] But it is unlikely that impossible, but unlikely,
[1:53:34] that our office would fund the creation
[1:53:37] of historic district guidelines, or a district that does not
[1:53:43] yet exist with the distinct possibility
[1:53:46] that our very precious grant dollars would then not be used in their effectiveness.
[1:53:53] They'd simply be used to create design guidelines.
[1:53:56] Would we fund an additional re-survey of the neighborhood?
[1:54:01] Absolutely, we do that all the time.
[1:54:03] That does not, I'm going to use a phrase of waste or money.
[1:54:08] We would be concerned, I think, about a potential grant application for design guidelines.
[1:54:16] Without an assurance that you wouldn't just say thank you very much. We're not approving this district
[1:54:23] Your $20,000
[1:54:25] Does that's the same hole true for the update?
[1:54:30] Again, we would we would absolutely pay to fund a
[1:54:36] Relook at the district new photographs new mapping new documents
[1:54:40] We do that routinely, so we would pay for that, that adds information from frankly to the state's records, and we'd be happy to have that with your assistance.
[1:54:51] Okay, with a match, 50% that's right. Okay, thank you. I'm sorry we've closed public input, but thank you though, Russ, you have a match.
[1:55:08] We just ask that if you're going to recognize the speaker that he should approach the podium,
[1:55:21] we are broadcasting and it is difficult if impossible to hear from shouting from the gallery.
[1:55:26] I was hoping to get two cents worth in there because I was here at present act creation
[1:55:32] when we did the study before, and a preservation commission helped raise money.
[1:55:36] I'm here representing preservation to involves and the neighborhood, I'm sorry, I forgot
[1:55:41] to mention my late already saying.
[1:55:44] The preservation to end falls will put up this match or a non-profit and we're in the business
[1:55:50] this target that we're looking for is saving history and so we're more than willing to put up
[1:55:56] the sponsor of the match to work with the state, with the preservation commission to do whatever
[1:56:02] the city needs for the study of the guidelines. Thank you. But with all that information,
[1:56:14] But do you have any thoughts, wants to make a motion, any general discussion?
[1:56:22] Answer I can tell. You're going to click the button right here.
[1:56:28] My button, yeah. So if we don't do anything tonight's status quo, nothing's changed.
[1:56:34] I'll go ahead and make a motion.
[1:56:37] At least we know if that's a yes or no on one item.
[1:56:42] And if it's a no, then we would look for another strategy.
[1:56:45] So I would move that we direct city staff to get us, I wasn't planning to do this tonight.
[1:56:53] So I didn't really think about this option.
[1:56:59] Then we direct city staff to bring us a plan to develop the guidelines.
[1:57:10] So that would be, if it's in-house, I'm afraid.
[1:57:17] So that would be, if it's in-house, time frame, I understand they have a staffing shortage
[1:57:24] and it's also busy time for development, they're busy.
[1:57:27] So it would be a plan, which would be time frame, perhaps hours or maybe the plan involves seeking outside help such as a consultant.
[1:57:36] I'm struggling to work this properly, I apologize, but I'd like to make a motion somehow to move forward in this way
[1:57:43] So we could vote yes or no and then do something.
[1:57:50] I might be able to help out the council.
[1:57:54] Please.
[1:57:59] The councilman would like for the city staff to investigate time of the
[1:58:03] creation of design and present that plan.
[1:58:13] Can I sound like what you were trying to say?
[1:58:15] Yes.
[1:58:16] Thank you very much.
[1:58:19] Okay, so there's been a motion. Is there a second?
[1:58:23] Can I change? Can I add something or go add this and have to add this second?
[1:58:34] You can amend the motion.
[1:58:36] I think what I heard a little bit and correct me if I'm wrong is
[1:58:42] I think we should go after the state grant or an update of pictures
[1:58:48] and have that as a starting point for us to update that
[1:58:52] in a projection of going into a design. But if I
[1:58:57] that weren't didn't the night.
[1:59:03] That's a hard horse thing.
[1:59:04] So we have a motion on the floor that hasn't been seconded.
[1:59:09] We have a proposed amendment.
[1:59:12] Where's legal counsel?
[1:59:13] What am I supposed to do here?
[1:59:16] Vote on, they get a second on the amendment.
[1:59:20] The first thing to remember is that we have nothing.
[1:59:24] So relax a little bit there.
[1:59:27] But I think that there are two separate items at this point.
[1:59:30] One is the study and updating the study.
[1:59:32] The other is actually the guidelines.
[1:59:34] So, I think that's an amendment to the motion that's here,
[1:59:40] and I think that it means either have a second or a dice.
[1:59:42] Okay, got it.
[1:59:44] So, the motion on the floor is to direct staff
[1:59:48] to bring back to us design guidelines,
[1:59:56] timeline and costs.
[2:00:00] I think the way City Manager Vergig was
[2:00:06] formally present to us an outline
[2:00:09] in the process of developing guidelines.
[2:00:13] Do I have a second on that motion?
[2:00:20] Okay, that motion dies for lack of a second.
[2:00:24] Any other motions?
[2:00:26] These are brown.
[2:00:29] It would move to have staff investigate opportunity
[2:00:36] through the state historical chip-out
[2:00:43] and consider the match with the Twin Falls preservatement.
[2:00:48] What was that group? Preservation Twin Falls.
[2:00:55] Hey, do I have a second for that?
[2:00:58] Second.
[2:01:01] Motion by Jason Brown, second by Craig Hawkins
[2:01:05] to ask staff to pursue the
[2:01:09] updated study through
[2:01:16] SHIPO with the match coming from Preservation Twin Falls.
[2:01:20] Christopher Reed.
[2:01:23] I appreciate the motion.
[2:01:25] Understanding that staff needs to come in at some point in time, and the car before the horse type of thing.
[2:01:34] I don't want staff to have anything to do with this at this moment.
[2:01:37] I need historic preservation.
[2:01:39] The individuals that are part of this group, we don't have time, energy to work on that.
[2:01:45] So at this point in time, I'll be voting no.
[2:01:48] But I, outside individuals, if they want to continue to come back with that target, I would be more than happy at that point in time.
[2:01:57] just don't have time or energy. Anybody else who wish to comment on the motion before we vote?
[2:02:06] Yes.
[2:02:07] John, if I'm fine?
[2:02:08] Correctly. We've applied for those grants before when I was on historic preservation.
[2:02:13] That's something we look at every year, isn't it?
[2:02:17] We look at grants.
[2:02:18] And there's a time frame?
[2:02:20] Yes.
[2:02:21] You have to submit. Yes.
[2:02:22] And so forth.
[2:02:23] In the city is the certified local government. We would then be responsible to manage the grant with the state as they grant it to cities.
[2:02:30] granted to cities they don't grant it necessarily to other individuals so
[2:02:34] there's still there's a time management of that
[2:02:37] then could speak more as to the amounts that are
[2:02:40] grutually granted to entities this amount would be so we'd have to work on that
[2:02:46] but it was like a $2,200 that we had those were because we asked for that
[2:02:52] amount I'm sure there's amounts that have been granted I believe in the past
[2:02:56] around 10 to 15,000 a much more than that I am unaware of city receiving much
[2:03:02] more than around that amount. I have no idea what investigation such update to
[2:03:07] the properties would be that was not the only item that we investigated
[2:03:11] previously but we would still have to manage that grant to the staff with the
[2:03:14] state or through the state. So Jonathan before you sit down I mean this this kind
[2:03:23] of seems like a conflict because we're asking you're asking for the group to
[2:03:30] manage this and you're saying that they can't the state because the state
[2:03:34] will only grant us. My guess is, and that's as a CLG grant, is sort of a local
[2:03:40] government grant. Okay. The state funds would come to the city. That's how we manage
[2:03:46] those. They wouldn't go to a third party, we would have to manage the contract of
[2:03:50] whoever's doing the work. Could certainly use an house identity, potentially as a
[2:03:54] match. I'm looking, I think we can do that. Volunteer time. It's either volunteer time.
[2:04:01] It's usually covered by volunteer time from those that are working on it, like
[2:04:05] the historic preservation commission and city staff for the CLG grants.
[2:04:10] So just investigating the possibility, how much time do you think that would take, sitting
[2:04:16] down with the parties, and is that a three-month process, is that a, something, I mean, we all
[2:04:25] recognize you have plenty on your plate, and staffing shortages.
[2:04:29] In terms of what we're looking at is getting the update of that area,
[2:04:34] SHIPO puts out a list of people that are qualified to do some of that work.
[2:04:39] Previously we ended up just contacting everybody in Idaho.
[2:04:43] He said here's kind of the idea of what we're doing, but it included
[2:04:47] all of these items. It was basically to stand up the district.
[2:04:50] Okay.
[2:04:51] Personally, this is how we'd have to go back to the group of people in the email
[2:04:55] and kind of give them the scope the issue is, if people don't have a really good scope
[2:05:00] asking then the prices can be all over if it's a this is what we need you to do
[2:05:05] specifically and this is the end of the item they can give us a better number
[2:05:11] so I need to like this is what we're going to ask for an update to the pictures
[2:05:18] and information on whether they are contributing or not and if that's the
[2:05:24] extent for these 300 some properties then I believe we could get a pretty good
[2:05:28] dollar amount taking that to get people it's phone calls a few days hours yeah
[2:05:36] it's in the hour to tell people call you back right okay so we do have a motion
[2:05:44] on the floor any further discussion before we vote on that let's make sure
[2:05:53] we understand what this motion is can you read that back to us you have it
[2:05:57] typed up yet uh-huh I would echo what was said that the motion would be for
[2:06:07] updating the pictures and the contributing or non-contributing factors.
[2:06:16] Thank you for the clarification as far as the city's involvement.
[2:06:22] Appreciate that.
[2:06:28] On the second.
[2:06:29] This is better.
[2:06:30] Do you have any further discussion?
[2:06:31] I would just say if that motion is seconded, I would be voting now just because I feel
[2:06:36] like it will consume time and it doesn't, in my opinion, get us any closer to actually
[2:06:42] voting yes or no on creating the district and so I would be voting no if it is seconded.
[2:06:50] No, it was seconded.
[2:06:53] Okay, so there's motion on the floor to authorize staff to look into the cost of pictures and
[2:07:02] compliant contributing buildings versus not in that historic triangle.
[2:07:09] Aaron Rolkovo please.
[2:07:13] Hair pairs?
[2:07:15] No.
[2:07:17] No.
[2:07:19] Nicky Boyd.
[2:07:20] No.
[2:07:21] Craig Hawkins.
[2:07:22] Yes.
[2:07:23] Jason Brown.
[2:07:24] Yes.
[2:07:25] That's your cutler.
[2:07:26] No.
[2:07:28] Motion fails.
[2:07:30] Ort.
[2:07:31] Thank you.
[2:07:34] Okay.
[2:07:36] So that being said, what's our next thought here?
[2:07:40] You have to make some sort of decision.
[2:07:57] So bad members of the city council like you have those motions in advance to a vote or the
[2:08:11] So what's everybody's pleasure here?
[2:08:57] Yes, okay.
[2:09:09] Where's the struggling group of citizens?
[2:09:15] They use your moving target, Chris, of listening to everything.
[2:09:31] The conversation goes on.
[2:09:33] There isn't anything super specific at this time.
[2:09:42] I really don't.
[2:09:46] I, how we pay for it, how it's formed, how staff is going to get all things and things that,
[2:09:59] that, that's the cart before the horse.
[2:10:02] But yeah, we can't move forward without that.
[2:10:05] And so I think I'm starting to feel like their journey, their journey, and has more of a this is what you know
[2:10:35] Instead of here pain sir fix stuff. It has to get more
[2:10:47] It has to have a bigger group. This is it. This is what we want
[2:10:53] And I think that's what we're waiting for afraid to vote or something. We're just not we don't have something we can really vote for
[2:11:04] That makes sense
[2:11:11] They are, several weeks ago, we had a group come in for public hearing and the specific
[2:11:24] was to increase the height as you move farther away from the canyon.
[2:11:30] We knew what to do with that because we knew specifically it was based off of height.
[2:11:36] This one, and I understand that, Carl, before the horse, all these issues, but we've had
[2:11:42] such a variety of concerns, I don't want to say, we're going to create a historic, a
[2:11:50] Presidential Historic District make these changes. I don't know what the changes are and it might just be
[2:11:57] We don't want apartment complexes because that's a lot of letters. We had is we don't want apartment complexes
[2:12:04] That that's different
[2:12:06] Then I don't want you to do polka dots on your house
[2:12:10] I don't know if anybody in this house in this room wants polka dots, but that's a pretty big difference
[2:12:16] I don't know
[2:12:19] Which one is good which one's bad according to the folks that live in that area and what I would be comfortable with details came
[2:12:36] We can debate the details. We can discuss the details
[2:12:41] That's where I'm at. I'm just wondering how we pursue this but the historic properties
[2:12:52] I guess there's those people that are really adamant about it. They're very positive about it
[2:12:59] Is that an avenue really that we can pursue?
[2:13:02] What that does is also
[2:13:06] Those that are against it because they're not really a part of that property
[2:13:10] Yeah, having a good go through that, that is simply a request that comes through staff
[2:13:19] essentially.
[2:13:20] I read that section as well.
[2:13:24] If I thought of it, that were the possibility we would use the, if it were a one-on-one basis,
[2:13:29] or maybe there's 10 or 15 or 20 at the beginning, we can schedule like an inspection scene.
[2:13:34] We can go take a picture of the house every two or three weeks and say,
[2:13:38] okay, here's this.
[2:13:39] This is the ordinance part.
[2:13:42] That's something that's pursuing what we could use in National Register Information and an updated picture
[2:13:46] just as an ordinance from a local thing from you.
[2:13:49] I think that's a possibility.
[2:13:50] That would be the... essentially you're following the statute for what's possible for that.
[2:13:54] It's a local decision of an ordinance and we can provide an updated photo of that property as it's the owner that's requesting it.
[2:14:02] Well, that could eventually proceed into making the historic residential.
[2:14:08] I think that's an avenue you could use
[2:14:10] to say the direction of council is.
[2:14:13] We would like to do the properties.
[2:14:15] We would like to look at these ordinances
[2:14:16] as they come in one-on-one from property owners.
[2:14:19] That could be the,
[2:14:20] I think you could make a motion
[2:14:21] or you could do something like that
[2:14:22] as a clear direction to people in the area
[2:14:24] of what you want to do now.
[2:14:27] Knowing that if there's enough of them in an area,
[2:14:30] it would be clear evidence
[2:14:31] as you've already adopted ordinances
[2:14:33] as to protecting the properties individually
[2:14:35] to then create a district.
[2:14:37] I don't think that could work.
[2:14:39] And that would be them coming to us.
[2:14:41] You could make that as your motion
[2:14:44] to say we'd like to do that.
[2:14:45] I think the statute allows others to do it.
[2:14:47] But if you, you're kind of, this is an act,
[2:14:50] an action item for you to give us directional
[2:14:52] what you'd like us to do.
[2:14:53] If the direction is a clear indication
[2:14:55] of to the public and staff,
[2:14:57] we would like to see that avenue used.
[2:15:00] I believe that it's an indication to the public
[2:15:02] that way as well as our time being spent
[2:15:04] to get these things together when they come in.
[2:15:06] So that's the 67-46-14?
[2:15:11] Yeah, that's the statute that it reads, like I paraphrase that one because it's kind of long but it essentially just goes to those steps.
[2:15:20] It's an ordinance.
[2:15:21] So what it says is the following steps investigate and report on the historic architectural archeology, archeological and cultural significance.
[2:15:34] So that would be why this is...
[2:15:37] and then hold a public hearing on, after giving written notice, property owners and occupants, so that's the property, that property, passage of an ordinance, a waiting period of 180 is required for demolition material,
[2:15:55] authorization, remodel relocation, or change of use, and exemptions to the 180-day
[2:16:02] waiting period would include maintenance, repairs, or public safety. So for example,
[2:16:08] if somebody wanted to change the color of the paint outside their house, the statute
[2:16:14] doesn't apply for that necessarily. So they could still do that.
[2:16:18] Yeah, the maintenance is different.
[2:16:20] It's a little bit different.
[2:16:25] Which is changing use relocation, demolition, material,
[2:16:29] and outreach.
[2:16:30] It talks about those things.
[2:16:32] We can look at it more clearly, but what it does do is it makes it so it's only the one property.
[2:16:38] It's not a regulation on others or whoever you put whichever property is listed in the ordinance.
[2:16:43] So, quite frankly, if you have like four properties that came together in one ordinance, you can do all four on one night.
[2:16:49] If for property owners wanted to go together
[2:16:51] Mr. E, I'd love to do some more research on this
[2:16:59] I don't know if I'm a decision on this specific
[2:17:03] not not wanting to kick the can down the road
[2:17:06] for properties
[2:17:12] and the guidelines around that and what that means
[2:17:14] a fair decision tonight
[2:17:22] direction is we would be interested in learning more about this
[2:17:25] I'm comfortable with that and I think that that's the direction
[2:17:28] That makes sense to me
[2:17:39] so what I'm basically hearing from him
[2:17:42] let's everybody let me know if you concur is asking staff to look more
[2:17:50] specifically into this legislative section 67-416 and report back to us
[2:17:58] what's a good time frame for you I mean let's wait till after budget let's wait till
[2:18:04] after council you're into September with the council thing on the 29th I can't do
[2:18:09] by Monday and then Labor Day is the next week so either the 12 have a meeting
[2:18:14] so 12 through the 19th or what nothing else 12 yes so you'd be looking I mean
[2:18:19] the way you have a council agenda stacked up looking at the 19th of
[2:18:26] September within reason I mean if you're planning trip to Europe please still go
[2:18:39] but I don't think you are right okay okay well I'm comfortable with that you
[2:18:46] I know my biggest concern is the elephant in the room is this apartment complex that seems to be the theme on these letters that would have still happened regardless, maybe not the outside exterior, but it would have happened regardless of a historic district being put into place.
[2:19:07] So, and that's the zoning issue, not a historic issue.
[2:19:12] So, I'm comfortable with that direction.
[2:19:15] If everybody else is comfortable,
[2:19:18] then we hear back from staff on the 19th.
[2:19:35] And also the reservation,
[2:19:44] because there's a lot of work that's been done,
[2:19:46] and if some of it is,
[2:19:49] we just have to update it a little bit,
[2:19:51] and all these things,
[2:19:52] that's where the work gets done,
[2:19:54] is the people who want this.
[2:19:57] In this chain and I have talked, there's nothing that precludes an outside entity proposing an historic district.
[2:20:03] The presentation I talked about was when using city funds is kind of the status down this path if you have an entity that proposes.
[2:20:12] Here's the finished product to the historic preservation commission or to us we then take it through steps one through five.
[2:20:19] The statute doesn't say that it has to be initiated by the city, it can be initiated by our understanding.
[2:20:27] I mean, doesn't have to be a nonprofit, doesn't have to be a submission.
[2:20:32] Kind of anybody, and then we just take it through steps one through five.
[2:20:35] Okay, perfect.
[2:20:38] Hey.
[2:20:39] We're moving forward on all levels and both desks can keep going.
[2:20:52] Well, thank you, everybody. That ends our public hearing.
[2:20:55] Have a good evening.
