Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2019-08-05, recording 1 (started 17:00)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2019-08-05/

[0:00:00] I am putting my phone on mute.
[0:00:01] I am connected on my tablet so I can click on there to tell you what I want to speak, Sean.
[0:00:06] Okay, great.
[0:00:07] Thanks, Suzanne.
[0:00:08] Thank you.
[0:00:20] Good evening.
[0:00:21] I would like to call to order the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council for Monday, August
[0:00:26] 5th, and confirm that we do have a quorum of the council here, all seven members.
[0:00:30] Our presence this evening, six of us are here in person and Councilwoman Suzanne Hawkins
[0:00:34] is attending by telephone.
[0:00:38] For the next item on the agenda, I would like to ask everyone to please join us in a moment
[0:00:43] of silence to remember these shooting victims, you know, pass on and date, whether we can
[0:00:47] out for those of you wishing to join us please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance.
[0:01:31] We have no proclamations this evening, so the next item on the agenda will be general
[0:01:36] public input and we do have a full house here tonight, so I'm just going to go over a couple
[0:01:40] of logistical issues that we have going on.
[0:01:43] So when we built this new Fabulous City Hall, one of the things we planned for was the crowds
[0:01:48] on occasion.
[0:01:49] So we have a room up top that is called the Council Overflow Room.
[0:01:53] So folks in there are able to engage in the meeting.
[0:01:56] They can hear us and see us.
[0:01:58] However, there is a slight video and audio delay to what you all are seeing.
[0:02:04] So we're going to go a little bit slowly here to make sure that they're keeping up with the
[0:02:07] conversation that's happening right here in front of us now.
[0:02:12] I also have several people who signed up on the sign-in sheet out front for an opportunity
[0:02:17] to speak, so I'm just going to clarify the way the speaking goes here.
[0:02:21] So the public input session that we will have here momentarily is for items that are not
[0:02:27] on the agenda this evening.
[0:02:29] If you signed up to speak to the special event application at Amazing Grace, we are going
[0:02:35] to pull that separate on the consent calendar and have an opportunity for people to speak
[0:02:39] to that item.
[0:02:40] So, this would not be the time you would come up for that.
[0:02:43] We'll invite you up to speak when we get to that item on the agenda.
[0:02:47] If you signed up on the signup sheet to speak to the first item on the agenda, which is Pastor
[0:02:54] Paul Thompson's presentation to the council, we will not be accepting public input on that
[0:02:59] topic this evening.
[0:03:00] We will only be hearing the presentation from Pastor Thompson and having a conversation
[0:03:05] amongst the council.
[0:03:06] So again, I appreciate your attendance, but know that at this point in that process, we will not be taking public input on it.
[0:03:13] So with that, I would invite anyone who wishes to address the Council on an item that is not on the agenda this evening to please come forward.
[0:03:22] If you would please state your name and whether you are a property owner or resident of the City of Twin Falls.
[0:03:36] And also, John, if you would push the button.
[0:03:39] There it is.
[0:03:40] Okay.
[0:03:41] Mayor and Council, I'm John Capillares, so one, two, three, one, son, burst.
[0:03:44] I am a property owner and resident.
[0:03:49] I would like to speak in favor of limiting what is put into our recycling bin.
[0:03:54] I was disappointed with the wording but forth in the proposal of continued, discontinue
[0:04:00] or limit.
[0:04:02] Continuing leads one to believe that the City and PSI are doing a great job recycling.
[0:04:07] Why would we stop doing that?
[0:04:09] But this council knows that the status quo is unsustainable, so diversion has not worked.
[0:04:17] Discontinuing will load up the landfill and the people of Twin Falls are not quitters.
[0:04:24] I don't think that's a good option.
[0:04:27] Limiting is the best option because we will truly be recycling that and making money
[0:04:33] for the city, MPSI, but the use of the words in the proposal of higher value commodities
[0:04:42] implies that there are lower value commodities that can be recycled, but we don't care about
[0:04:49] those because we're in this to make a buck.
[0:04:52] But that's not the case.
[0:04:55] There are items that can be recycled and items that cannot.
[0:04:59] If we limit what is put into the recycling bin to things that are actually recyclable,
[0:05:04] we will decrease sorting costs, increase revenue, and maintain our quality of life.
[0:05:09] This is why Limit is the best option.
[0:05:12] Please act soon.
[0:05:13] Vote Team Limit for the Common Good.
[0:05:17] Thank you, Mr. Cappellaris.
[0:05:18] Travis, could you address that item, please?
[0:05:21] We can't.
[0:05:22] So, next week, the City Council is going to be hosting a public hearing in which Public
[0:05:27] The second put is going to be used to help drive the conversation, I think that Mr.
[0:05:31] Campillares is following the same path that we are, there are three proposals that staff
[0:05:36] is prepared to outline.
[0:05:38] One is to maintain the current program.
[0:05:41] The second is to get rid of the program.
[0:05:43] And the third is obviously a balance of somewhere in between looking at those commodities that
[0:05:49] are truly being recycled as opposed to those commodities that we believe are being recycled,
[0:05:53] we're placing them in a recycling bin, but they're making their way in a landfill
[0:05:57] either in Ada County or somewhere in the east coast.
[0:06:00] So again, next week at six o'clock,
[0:06:02] we'll be hosting that conversation.
[0:06:04] And that's part of the information
[0:06:06] that we've been sending out on various media
[0:06:10] and social media sites.
[0:06:11] We would encourage the citizens to engage
[0:06:14] in that conversation as to help guide the direction
[0:06:18] that we're going for.
[0:06:19] Thank you, Travis.
[0:06:21] If there anyone else who wishes to address the council
[0:06:23] on an item that is not on the agenda this evening,
[0:06:29] Mitch, is there anyone up there too?
[0:06:31] No, okay, thank you.
[0:06:33] Yes, and if you can please state your name
[0:06:35] and whether you're a property owner
[0:06:36] or a resident of the City of Twin Falls.
[0:06:37] Hi, my name is Holly Pexch, I'm a property owner in Twin Falls.
[0:06:40] Thank you, Mr. Talking to your service.
[0:06:44] I'm fully aware that you might just miss me,
[0:06:46] but I like to get my first sentence out.
[0:06:48] I am here to ask you to enforce a law that's on the books
[0:06:52] and in this Roe versus Wade.
[0:06:55] Roe versus Wade.
[0:06:56] And ma'am, this item is on the agenda to be addressed
[0:07:00] and we are not accepting public input on this.
[0:07:02] When will you be accepting public comment?
[0:07:03] That will be following our discussion today.
[0:07:06] We will lay out the path forward of whether we will continue
[0:07:09] to pursue the proposal that Mr. Thompson and Patrick Thompson
[0:07:13] is bringing to us.
[0:07:15] So thank you.
[0:07:16] OK.
[0:07:16] Is there anyone else who wishes to address the council
[0:07:18] on an item that's not on the agenda this evening?
[0:07:24] All right.
[0:07:24] Seeing no one, we will move to Mr. John Caden,
[0:07:28] public works director I'd like to invite him up because shockingly none of
[0:07:32] you are here to talk about road construction this evening although I'm
[0:07:36] sure so we have our public works director John Caden here to speak to a
[0:07:42] little bit of the activity around road construction we understand it's a
[0:07:46] significant topic today so welcome John. Thank you mayor good evening counsel again
[0:07:51] I'm John Caden the public works director and we do have a lot of road
[0:07:56] projects going on right now so I just want to take a minute and talk about it
[0:08:01] we've seen I've just gotten a stack of citations that were issued today whether
[0:08:07] they were accidents or just citations I don't know I haven't been through them
[0:08:10] yet but there's been lots of folks frustrated with the with the construction
[0:08:16] and I'll touch on that at the end but but just to just to let the public know we
[0:08:23] have a lot going on right now. I recognize that it is inconvenient and we've got
[0:08:29] more in fact I've been with the City 12 years. I have never had two milling
[0:08:34] machines in town performing projects at the same time in my career and we've got
[0:08:38] two in town in a very close proximity that was in a half mile quarter mile
[0:08:43] or a mile so and we're in zone seven as you all know we have a zone maintenance
[0:08:48] program so we concentrate a good portion of our maintenance anyway and we sequence it so
[0:08:54] it doesn't as least as little impact as possible. What's really happening is the perfect storm
[0:09:00] we've got three contracts going on right now which doesn't sound that bad however the
[0:09:05] first contract has six projects in it so really a guy could say there are eight projects going
[0:09:10] on right now there's six reconstruct milling jobs, paved jobs and then there's Eastlin and
[0:09:17] falls which is a reconstruct and then we have our annual slurry seal. So again
[0:09:23] there's a ton going on and I just wanted to give a couple comments. We don't try
[0:09:28] to concentrate construction so it it conveniences the public the most although
[0:09:33] it feels out of way right now especially. When we do this we we let
[0:09:39] projects we allow some flexibility to the contractor and we package projects
[0:09:44] together because we get the best price historically we get a good price if we
[0:09:48] tell a contractor you can build it from this window to this window you can't go
[0:09:52] past x-day because school starts there's some clear milestones that we tried
[0:09:57] try to to avoid but when you have flexibility and construction scheduling
[0:10:04] is probably one of the most challenging components to construction is just
[0:10:08] simply getting the schedules to work out and right now I should point out
[0:10:12] the milling and paving jobs which placed 6,000 tons.
[0:10:16] About 6,000 tons and we're on schedule.
[0:10:18] So, out of those six projects, Shoshone is done,
[0:10:23] Addison is done, Locust is two-thirds paved out,
[0:10:26] it should be finished in the morning.
[0:10:28] Stadium will be finished by Thursday, correct?
[0:10:32] I'm looking at Josh Barrett, he's our project engineer,
[0:10:34] he's got all the specifics.
[0:10:37] Sunrise will also be finished by Thursday.
[0:10:39] The Slurry Seal will be done this week,
[0:10:42] So this week is, excuse me, but it's held week for construction.
[0:10:46] And again, we don't try to concentrate that.
[0:10:50] It's kind of how it played out this way.
[0:10:52] If I could build in a week, if I could have built in a week
[0:10:54] separation, it probably would have made a big difference.
[0:10:58] But again, sometimes it's a preference
[0:11:02] that some people want it all to happen at one time.
[0:11:05] And other folks would rather string out.
[0:11:07] So it is tough to anticipate what the complaints
[0:11:11] going to be contractors have been working weekends I saw them milling
[0:11:16] both Saturday and Sunday and the last thing I'd like to say is construction
[0:11:22] safety is really important and I recognize people are frustrated when
[0:11:26] they're coming out of construction cells and I haven't been through all the
[0:11:28] data yet but I know that there's been the chief explained to me that there's
[0:11:31] been several citations issued for 15 miles an hour over the speed limit so in
[0:11:37] some places we're talking in excess of 50 miles an hour I've personally seen
[0:11:41] I've personally seen that, and some of our flighters have also seen traffic trying to
[0:11:47] beat the light.
[0:11:48] There was an accident today at Locust and Filer, that's what happened.
[0:11:52] Someone tried to beat the light, and no amount of traffic control can prevent that, but we
[0:11:58] do have a lot going on right now.
[0:12:00] And with Eastland and Falls closed, there's 25,000 cars per day.
[0:12:04] Go through that intersection.
[0:12:05] So they're not there.
[0:12:06] They're everywhere else.
[0:12:07] And I know we can see that on Blue Lakes, especially.
[0:12:10] So I don't want to go on.
[0:12:12] I don't want to go on.
[0:12:13] I don't want to go on.
[0:12:14] I don't want to go on.
[0:12:15] I don't want to go on.
[0:12:16] I don't want to go on.
[0:12:17] I don't want to go on.
[0:12:18] I don't want to go on.
[0:12:19] I don't want to go on.
[0:12:20] I don't want to go on.
[0:12:21] I don't want to go on.
[0:12:22] I don't want to go on.
[0:12:23] I don't want to go on.
[0:12:24] I don't want to go on.
[0:12:25] I don't want to go on.
[0:12:26] I don't want to go on.
[0:12:27] I don't want to go on.
[0:12:28] I don't want to go on.
[0:12:29] I don't want to go on.
[0:12:30] I don't want to go on.
[0:12:31] I don't want to go on.
[0:12:32] I don't want to go on.
[0:12:33] few places that have some of this additional construction going on that
[0:12:36] as you mentioned we'll be wrapping up by the end of this week so I would encourage
[0:12:41] people to be safe first and foremost at being five minutes late for your meeting
[0:12:47] or whatever you're trying to get to is not worth the safety impacts that it has
[0:12:52] particularly with a lot of these detours that are going through neighborhoods I
[0:12:57] think people just need to slow down take a deep breath I will go on be there a
[0:13:02] a few minutes late, so I just would encourage people to do that.
[0:13:05] I would like to make a comment.
[0:13:07] It was like the pavement fairy showed up.
[0:13:10] I was not expecting Addison to just be done like that,
[0:13:14] so you did it during the night.
[0:13:18] Because, yeah, I came down and it was just all beautiful
[0:13:22] and done, and that was the easiest road construction
[0:13:25] I ever survived.
[0:13:27] It was very nice.
[0:13:28] So the contractor had a home adheres and construction.
[0:13:31] They were the ones that requested, and we authorized them
[0:13:33] to do night paving for both Shoshone Street and Addison,
[0:13:37] and mainly because they were business quarters
[0:13:38] and the residents nearby.
[0:13:40] So we were thankful I think it was helpful for everybody.
[0:13:45] We're just talking to them.
[0:13:47] Well, I have to say if all the business that comes
[0:13:50] to support the city council, John,
[0:13:52] this poll on your not polling falls
[0:13:55] in Eastland intersection has given me more unfavorable impact
[0:14:00] than just about any of the other project.
[0:14:03] It seems to be centered around a matter of timing of the project.
[0:14:07] I was not able to answer to people why we chose the time as most opportune for school
[0:14:13] busing the peak, the end of the tourist season at all, if you chose something out on it,
[0:14:22] it appears that the construction schedule has been based upon the convenience of the
[0:14:28] contractors rather than the traffic flows.
[0:14:32] I'm not sure that statement, but you're welcome to read.
[0:14:37] The last couple of years we've had significant construction seasons.
[0:14:47] We spent $4.4 million, not last summer, but the summer prior.
[0:14:51] And we've always had falls in Eastland on the radar.
[0:14:55] And construction sequencing, we knew we couldn't do falls in Eastland.
[0:14:59] In fact, we had the money.
[0:15:00] We could have done it at that time.
[0:15:02] But there was just never, the sequence wouldn't work out.
[0:15:06] So we pushed it out as far as we could.
[0:15:08] And so when you say in all fairness, why did we pick that?
[0:15:13] It's in failure mode.
[0:15:15] It was the intersection is completely failing.
[0:15:19] The basis failed, the payments failed.
[0:15:21] And if we didn't reconstruct it, which was an option,
[0:15:24] we would be repairing it this winter,
[0:15:26] and there'd be other inconveniences.
[0:15:29] So I guess in all fairness to see that we picked the timing,
[0:15:32] it kind of picked us.
[0:15:35] And plus with the eight total projects,
[0:15:39] it's unusual amount of activity,
[0:15:41] limit the number of contractors.
[0:15:44] You keep in the audience,
[0:15:45] you don't have my home phone number anymore, I hope.
[0:15:49] And we'll do the best we can,
[0:15:50] but it will be an extremely inconvenient time,
[0:15:53] especially in the northeast,
[0:15:56] but then any significant bleeder streets
[0:15:58] to feed the traffic.
[0:16:00] So bear with us, public.
[0:16:02] We just echo the comments that I made a couple of times,
[0:16:04] though it's it's anticipated to be four weeks plus four weeks not 16 the original
[0:16:11] plan and the road's gonna get built sometime so as John said earlier some
[0:16:20] people like it quick and dirty and get it out of the way some people just want it
[0:16:24] to be happening all the time and smaller doses I do if I could mayor do you
[0:16:29] want to acknowledge that I recognize it is extremely inconvenient and difficult
[0:16:33] challenging and this isn't exactly how I would have picked it if I could control
[0:16:38] every aspect this isn't the ideal situation but it's what we're up against.
[0:16:43] But we do have that $3,000 penalty. It'll kick in that'll provide some incentive for the contractors to stay up to speak.
[0:16:51] That is correct. You make it five.
[0:16:57] They've already signed. Thank you John. Thank you Josh.
[0:17:02] Next on the agenda is the consent calendar and I am going to request that item, item H,
[0:17:18] we address that one first and separate of the balance of the consent calendar. So this is a request
[0:17:32] that was submitted as a special event application by amazing grace fellowship church for an outdoor
[0:17:38] service and picnic. And we have Sergeant Diamond here, although I'm happy to just read through the
[0:17:46] the request if that works for you, Sergeant, or you're welcome to come down to.
[0:17:52] Okay.
[0:17:53] Maybe if you don't mind just explaining the application that's coming in, isn't it,
[0:18:01] Mike?
[0:18:02] It is, thank you.
[0:18:03] Like you said, Mayor, we received an application from amazing Grace Fellowship requesting to
[0:18:08] hold their outdoor church service.
[0:18:10] This is an annual event that's been going on a number of years.
[0:18:13] After we submitted that and they met all the requirements for the committee, we recommended
[0:18:18] that it be placed on the consent calendar
[0:18:20] to be approved by the council.
[0:18:22] Following that, I received some information
[0:18:25] that maybe some of our patrons here in Twin Falls
[0:18:27] would like to have some input on some concerns
[0:18:30] that they have about mainly noise concerns
[0:18:35] with that outdoor church service.
[0:18:36] We do require the permit because there is amplified sound,
[0:18:41] but there were some complaints about maybe
[0:18:44] what the sound level was and how long it takes.
[0:18:47] And with the council's permission,
[0:18:49] we have one of the patrons here that would like to express
[0:18:52] some of the concerns that they have.
[0:18:54] Great, thank you, Sergeant.
[0:18:56] So I do have Debbie Dane here, who I know
[0:18:59] wanted to address this.
[0:19:00] And I believe there may be a couple of others
[0:19:02] who signed on here, but if you would please state your name,
[0:19:05] and whether you are a resident or property owner
[0:19:07] in the city of Twin Falls.
[0:19:09] My name is Debbie Dane, and we are property owners
[0:19:11] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[0:19:14] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[0:19:21] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[0:19:33] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[0:19:40] and actually we had to call the police who the gentleman came into our home and was halfway
[0:19:47] to the back door and said, oh yes, it's too loud.
[0:19:50] And so then the next day, if this request mirrors what happened last year, it's supposed
[0:19:58] to be from 10.30 to 2.
[0:20:00] The music started at just after 9 a.m. and went straight through.
[0:20:08] I walked over to see because we've had situations with this organization where the noise is a
[0:20:17] little bit much to take and have had to call on enforcement.
[0:20:21] So I walked over and to my surprise it is a commercial-sized sound stage that is on the
[0:20:29] northern edge of their property which backs up to our backyards.
[0:20:34] And you cannot go into any room in our home, up or down without that noise just being like
[0:20:41] this.
[0:20:42] What we're asking for is some either to permit it without the amplified sound or to put some
[0:20:50] sideboards on it.
[0:20:52] As Sergeant Diamond explained to me, we don't have a noise ordinance if I understand that
[0:20:57] correctly.
[0:20:58] So it's basically disturbing the peace or something else.
[0:21:03] But if we would ask for the consideration of the church,
[0:21:07] as well as the council, to possibly look at the impact
[0:21:12] to the neighborhoods during this event, thank you.
[0:21:17] Thank you.
[0:21:21] So I have two other people who have signed up
[0:21:24] on the sign-in sheet that say special event app.
[0:21:27] When is Rob Heidemann?
[0:21:29] Council members, I appreciate your time.
[0:21:40] I'm from Amazing Grace Fellowship, I represent that church.
[0:21:45] And Ms. Dan, I apologize for the inconvenience
[0:21:47] and for the sound problems that we've had in the past.
[0:21:50] I'm willing to do what we can to help with those sound problems.
[0:21:55] I will say one of the things that was last year that will not
[0:21:58] be this year as we had a professional sound company come in.
[0:22:02] We will be still using professional sound system
[0:22:05] and a professional sound stage.
[0:22:07] but we will be doing the sound ourselves,
[0:22:09] and why that might make a difference
[0:22:11] is we have written down in our own policy
[0:22:14] a sound, a decimal, maximum, and that's 92 decibels
[0:22:18] on any given Sunday morning inside our building,
[0:22:21] and we would abide by that as well outside.
[0:22:23] So we have a decibel meter that we use to control that
[0:22:27] and make sure that it doesn't peak any higher
[0:22:29] than 92 decibels.
[0:22:31] So I don't know if that makes any sense to you
[0:22:32] what 92 decibels is, but the average lawn mower
[0:22:36] is around 90 decibels, so it still is volume, but it wouldn't be much more than a lawnmower
[0:22:44] that's taking place outside.
[0:22:47] I believe that the sound, the sideboards that Ms. Dane talked about is something that we
[0:22:52] can try to do, I don't know exactly what that means right now, we have a couple more
[0:22:57] weeks to look into that, so I'm happy to look into that.
[0:23:00] One other thing that I just want to make known to you and to the public is that our intent
[0:23:05] obviously is not to disturb the public. Our intent is to have an environment that is welcoming
[0:23:11] and inviting to the public as well. So one of the things that we will be doing is we will be inviting
[0:23:16] our neighbors, which, Ms. Stane, is very welcome to come as well. I know you may not, but that's okay.
[0:23:22] Welcome to come and we will be probably three or four days ahead of time going and handing out.
[0:23:27] I don't know if you want to see these or not. These are much larger than what they're going to look
[0:23:32] but invites to the neighborhood inviting them to the free lunch as well as to the
[0:23:36] service and we just want to be something that's inviting the public as well so
[0:23:41] it's not just our congregation but to our neighbors that we would like to
[0:23:44] have come as well. Great. Thank you. Great, please. I need decibels. It's a nice handle, but it is also a reflective
[0:23:59] from the sound source. So 90 decibels from the emission of your music is far different
[0:24:08] than what may be received by a neighbor. Do you have something more specific to address
[0:24:13] that 90 dB?
[0:24:15] So the 90 decibels will be approximately for about a 30 minute time period during the service
[0:24:21] and there will be a sound check as well. So that will be limited when that amount of decibels
[0:24:27] will actually be going to the public beyond that.
[0:24:31] So that'll be during music, in other words,
[0:24:33] beyond that time frame, it'll be talking,
[0:24:35] and it will be amplified talking,
[0:24:37] but it won't be talking at that amount of decibels.
[0:24:40] So again, last year, the amount of decibels that we had,
[0:24:44] it was loud, and I absolutely admit to that.
[0:24:47] And we had a sound company that came in and ran sound for us,
[0:24:50] and it sounded phenomenal, but it was too loud.
[0:24:52] So we're gonna fix that this year
[0:24:54] by being in charge of that,
[0:24:56] making sure that we are the ones controlling that sound.
[0:24:59] I appreciate your comment, but you didn't address the issue of 90 decibels at what distance.
[0:25:04] Okay, so 90 decibels, that's a good question.
[0:25:08] I'm going to guess right about 50 feet to 35 feet.
[0:25:13] I'm trying to just ballpark it from the stage to where the soundboard is.
[0:25:18] That's where they would be controlling the soundator.
[0:25:22] So Ms. Dane's house is, if I can say it this way, is on the north side of our property.
[0:25:28] We have a stage that faces towards the south and we do that intentionally to make sure that
[0:25:33] we're affecting the least amount of neighbors.
[0:25:36] And I understand that bumped up right against Ms. Dane's home that she is probably going to
[0:25:41] be the one that hears it the most.
[0:25:43] But the decibels will be going in the opposite direction of her home.
[0:25:46] Did that answer your question, Mr. Titan?
[0:25:54] I also have a run of Myers who signed up for, okay, so thank you for that input and for your
[0:26:06] conversation about the event.
[0:26:07] So questions would be for Sergeant Diamond probably.
[0:26:12] So the current application says the event's from 10.30am to 2pm and we have some assurance
[0:26:21] that's when the amplified sound is occurring,
[0:26:24] that the musical portion of that is maybe an even more
[0:26:28] limited time, and then the provision of the approval
[0:26:31] is that at any given time,
[0:26:33] the on-duty supervisor has given the authority
[0:26:35] to order the event organizers to mitigate
[0:26:38] the sound of amplified amplified music.
[0:26:40] They become habitual, they can turn that off.
[0:26:44] So my question is, would approval of this still fit
[0:26:47] within the context of what's been shared here?
[0:26:50] and I'm hearing that the church is willing to go visit with the neighbors and maybe work on some mitigation in the interim.
[0:26:58] Yeah, my opinion would be that yes, I think we can find a way to still make it happen and talk to our on-duty supervisor that will be working that day and make sure that he's monitoring the situation as well.
[0:27:10] And if it needs to be turned down, we can address that.
[0:27:16] Input from the council that they might like to see further restrictions or considerations.
[0:27:23] a question. What is the difference between two decibels in a building with audience at
[0:27:40] outside? Does that sound louder outside or does it just spread farther? I'm not a sound
[0:27:49] person so I'm just wondering what that does.
[0:27:52] I don't have any technical knowledge of that. I don't know that I can answer that question.
[0:27:57] I would say though, with other special events that we approve regularly at City Park, we
[0:28:22] don't require decibel measurement either it's very subjective to whoever's hearing it and
[0:28:28] then limiting the time of day and those types of things. Also not based on writing, I don't
[0:28:35] think pretty close behind the library Chris Reed.
[0:28:44] After listening to Amazing Grace I think they want to be good neighbors. I think a communication
[0:28:51] between amazing grace and the fellows and the neighbors at that point in time.
[0:28:55] I don't have a problem with this in the sense that if it's too loud and the neighbors reach out and say hey, it's really loud,
[0:29:02] especially during the sound check, they can work on that together because they know that if it's too loud,
[0:29:08] they're going to call the police and the police are going to come in and say please turn it off.
[0:29:12] And so with that communication, it seems like we have neighbors who are willing to work with one another.
[0:29:17] I don't see an issue with it.
[0:29:23] So it sounds as if the general consensus here would be that the application, as presented, is
[0:29:30] fine for approval with the encouragement from the council that the
[0:29:36] the church reach out to the neighbors over the next time frame before the event to
[0:29:41] make sure that's mitigated. Do we want to still vote on separately since we pulled it off?
[0:29:47] We can. I pulled it off. I pulled it off.
[0:29:51] I would move that we approve item 5H separately from the rest and so I'll vote on that issue.
[0:30:03] Now so I'm making that motion.
[0:30:05] Second.
[0:30:06] Motion by Greg Lanting, seconded by Chris Reed to approve these special event application
[0:30:11] for amazing Grace Fellowship.
[0:30:13] Church is their discussion.
[0:30:15] Amy, roll call vote please.
[0:30:19] Suzanne Hawkins?
[0:30:22] Yeah.
[0:30:23] Nicky Boyd? Yes. Chris Tockington? Yes. John Vericard? Yes. Greg Lanting? Yes. Christopher Reed? Yes.
[0:30:36] And Bruce Pierce? Yes. Ocean passes 7 to 0. I guess subsequent motion if you're ready.
[0:30:43] Sure. I'm there. I moved. We we approved the rest of the consent calendar as published. Second.
[0:30:50] Motion by Greg Lanting, seconded by Ruth Pierce to approve the balance of the consent calendar items is their discussion. Amy, roll call vote, please.
[0:31:02] Mickey Boy, yes. Chris Tockington. Yes. John Berger. Yes. Greg Lanting. Yes. Christopher Reed. Yes. Yes.
[0:31:11] Yes.
[0:31:12] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:31:13] Yeah.
[0:31:14] Motion passes seven to zero.
[0:31:15] So I'm just going to run through quickly what all of those items just were.
[0:31:20] So that was the trust agreement for West Park commercial subdivision.
[0:31:24] The improvement agreement for West Park commercial subdivision.
[0:31:30] The final plan for the field would professional subdivision.
[0:31:33] The special event application for the Joshua Way block party.
[0:31:38] as well as the special event application for the Twin Falls County Democrats annual picnic.
[0:31:44] Next-center items of consideration. The first is action item. This is a request from Paul Thompson
[0:31:56] to amend City Code Title VI Chapter II to prohibit abortions within the City of Twin Falls.
[0:32:03] And we have Pastor Paul Thompson.
[0:32:05] Thank you, Mr. Mayor and members of the City Council. I am a happy resident of the City of Twin Falls
[0:32:17] Twin Falls and a property owner. Thank you for your time. So I'm here
[0:32:29] before you today as a man under authority, under authority by my God,
[0:32:35] under the authority of the good people of East Side Babs Church and under the
[0:32:40] authority of the good city of Twin Falls, Idaho. So I'm just simply here today to
[0:32:45] request your consideration of introducing Section 20 to that Title 6, which is public
[0:32:53] safety, and then primarily concerning general offenses, and to introduce this matter of
[0:33:00] abortion.
[0:33:04] Where the Bible declares that all human life is created in the image of God, and therefore
[0:33:12] where every person is valuable to our Creator. We see this throughout the Bible. And then
[0:33:19] whereas the preamble of the Idaho Constitution acknowledges that this God is the one who
[0:33:29] our state looks to whenever we first adopted our Constitution when it says, and I quote,
[0:33:37] the people of the state of Idaho grateful to Almighty God for our freedom to secure its
[0:33:44] blessings and to promote our common welfare to establish this Constitution.
[0:33:52] Whereas the Bible proclaims that the unborn child is a person bearing the image of the
[0:33:59] triune God from the moment of conception, whereas Idaho Code, Title 32, Chapter 1, agrees with
[0:34:09] the Bible on this matter, and it says that the unborn child conceived, but not yet born, is
[0:34:16] to be deemed an existing person.
[0:34:19] So far as it may be necessary for its interest in the event of the subsequent birth from the
[0:34:24] moment of fertilization.
[0:34:27] Idaho Code Title 18, Chapter 40, is also in agreement with the Bible and the authority
[0:34:34] of Almighty God when it says, and I quote,
[0:34:37] It defines human being, including but not limited to the human embryo and the fetus.
[0:34:45] Whereas the citizens of the Magic Valley of South Central Idaho, we are pleased to live
[0:34:53] among each other even when at times we disagree with each other and to do so with respect of
[0:34:59] each other and respect to our God.
[0:35:02] Whereas many women who seek abortions, they know exactly what they're doing.
[0:35:11] It is also true that some women in their distress are being lied to while in that hard moment
[0:35:19] of life.
[0:35:21] Whereas Idaho Health and Welfare defines induced abortions and I quote, as an intentional action
[0:35:30] to stop live birth, whereas there were 258 abortion procedures reported to intentionally
[0:35:40] terminate pregnancies without a live birth on innocent, unborn persons, neighbors in
[0:35:49] the city of Twin Falls in 2017.
[0:35:54] Whereas, since 2008, over 2000 human babies have been aborted in the city of Twin Falls.
[0:36:04] That is the equivalent to the combined populations of the cities of Hanson, Eden, and Castle
[0:36:12] Fort.
[0:36:15] Whereas, again, according to the Bible, all persons, including myself, have an unrighteous
[0:36:23] nature and are spiritually bankrupt of being righteous and in need of a sufficient redeemer
[0:36:31] in order to live righteously in our neighborhoods.
[0:36:36] So therefore, according to the Bible, Jesus is the only sufficient redeemer by which persons
[0:36:44] can be saved from the judgment of God.
[0:36:50] Further resolved that we, the God-faring citizens of the Magic Valley, that we repent
[0:36:56] of our collective silence before God, and man of this heinous act against humanity that
[0:37:03] has been allowed to happen in our city, but further resolved that we, the citizens of the
[0:37:09] Magic Valley, appeal to you, the City Council of Twin Falls, Idaho, to hear our voice as
[0:37:16] we interpose for the human population that has no opportunity to stand before you and
[0:37:24] appeal to your conscience to enact this fair and just code that forbids any person or organization
[0:37:32] to ever again from this day forward perform induced abortions upon another fellow neighbor
[0:37:39] in our city.
[0:37:41] Further resolved that we mourn the recent lack of action by our state legislators and local
[0:37:49] representation of our constitutional republic who ignored our appeal of a just and a fair
[0:37:56] bill presented before them, this last legislative session to abolish abortion in the state of
[0:38:02] Idaho altogether known as the Idaho Abortion Human Rights Act, further resolved that we
[0:38:11] make our homes available as suitable sanctuaries, safe and nurturing homes for every abandoned
[0:38:19] woman or unwanted child found in distress and not sure what to do in this unwanted pregnancy
[0:38:28] or with this unwanted child.
[0:38:32] Essentially I'm saying if we have empty chairs at our dinner tables, we will gladly
[0:38:38] fill them with women and children who are in distress and when we run out of room at
[0:38:45] our tables, we will build bigger tables.
[0:38:52] are resolved that we are here today to proclaim the human baby in the womb as a
[0:38:59] precious, miraculous, marvelous, valuable, and welcome neighbor in the city of Twin
[0:39:07] Falls, Idaho. A final argument before I present the code that I'm asking you to
[0:39:15] let me just state three other proclamations from Idaho code 18-601
[0:39:25] Where it declares, and I quote, the Supreme Court of the United States, having held in
[0:39:31] the case of Planned Parenthood versus Casey, that the states have a profound interest in
[0:39:36] preserving the life of pre-born children.
[0:39:40] Idaho hereby expresses the fundamental importance, that profound interest, and it is hereby declared
[0:39:49] to be the public policy of the state of Idaho, that all states statutes, rules, and constitutional
[0:39:59] provisions shall be interpreted to prefer by all legal means live childbirth over abortion."
[0:40:11] Idaho Constitution, Article 7, Section 2 of the Idaho Constitution states, and I quote,
[0:40:19] any county or incorporated city or town may make and enforce within its limits all such
[0:40:28] local police, sanitary, and other regulations as are not in conflict with its charter or
[0:40:36] with the general laws.
[0:40:38] And so a declaration before we look at the code is the considering of the foregoing of
[0:40:45] what I've presented to you.
[0:40:47] It is appropriate that the city of Twin Falls would recognize the inalienable rights of man
[0:40:55] to defend life and that abortion is the taking or the termination of life of an unborn human
[0:41:05] being. Accordingly, the act of abortion is contrary to the inalienable rights of man set
[0:41:14] forth in the Idaho Constitution, and the City of Twin Falls does have the authority to prohibit
[0:41:21] the act of abortion within its limits. These are the reasons that I submit to you the
[0:41:28] following for consideration to be entered as legal code for the City of Twin Falls, Idaho.
[0:41:34] This ordinance shall be enforced and in effect and enforceable from and after its approval
[0:41:41] and passage and publication in accordance with Idaho law.
[0:41:50] So an ordinance of the City of Twin Falls of the State of Idaho declaring that abortion
[0:41:56] is to be contrary to the inalienable rights of man, prohibiting the act of abortion within
[0:42:03] the limits of the city of Twin Falls and providing for enforcement and the said prohibition.
[0:42:12] So I present to you the for consideration Title 6 Public Safety Chapter 2 General Offences
[0:42:22] Section 20 that you see before you.
[0:42:27] An abortion, every person or organization using any means to intentionally terminate the clinically
[0:42:35] diagnosable, viable pregnancy of a woman with knowledge that the termination by those means
[0:42:42] will with reasonable likelihood cause the death of the unborn human being will be guilty of
[0:42:49] inflicting inhumane actions upon another causing death before the otherwise live birth.
[0:42:58] A.
[0:42:59] Definitions.
[0:43:00] For the purpose of this section, the following words shall have the following meanings.
[0:43:06] Unborn human being.
[0:43:08] The offspring of human beings from the moment of conception until either live birth or natural
[0:43:14] death, including the human conceptus, the zygote, marula, blastocyst, embryo, and fetus, were
[0:43:23] the conceived and or located inside or outside the body of the human female.
[0:43:31] Conception will be identified or defined as this, the fertilization of the ovum of the female
[0:43:38] by the sperm of the male, and that abortion should be defined as the use or prescription
[0:43:45] of any instrument, medicine, drug, or any other substance or device to intentionally heal an
[0:43:53] unborn human being, and be violations, notwithstanding any other law. It shall be unlawful for a person
[0:44:04] to knowingly and intentionally perform, procure, or attempt to perform an abortion.
[0:44:13] See construction. It is the intention of the City of Twin Falls that the provision of
[0:44:19] this section be construed, enforced, and interpreted in such a manner as to absolutely defend the
[0:44:26] right of life as enumerated in Section 1, Article 1 of the Idaho Constitution, that the City
[0:44:34] of Twin Falls shall enforce this section regardless of any contrary or conflicting federal or state
[0:44:42] statutes, regulations, executive orders, or court decisions, and then finally D, and I'll
[0:44:52] just preface this. I do not mean any offense to any unborn baby that will be murdered in
[0:44:59] the womb to belittle the actions as a misdemeanor, but it is all that the law will allow. The
[0:45:08] violation of the provisions of this section is a misdemeanor, punishable by a fine of up
[0:45:14] to $1,000 and or six months in jail or both, until Christ returns, or my death, or justice
[0:45:27] is made for the unborn. I stand ready for clarification or questions. May the name of
[0:45:34] the Almighty God be revered."
[0:45:51] I don't have any questions for Pastor Thompson.
[0:45:56] I guess I do have one under your interpretation or addition of this chapter two.
[0:46:03] What a miscarriage fall under the provisions of an abortion.
[0:46:09] So a miscarriage is simply inside of the scientific world and inside of a law a natural
[0:46:17] death of a child.
[0:46:21] So it is not an induced abortion, it is not a forced to end the life of the child before
[0:46:29] life-birth could happen, so miscarriage is not an abortion.
[0:46:37] Thank you, Chris Reed.
[0:46:39] Master, where would we be incest and the health of the mother fall under this code?
[0:46:47] With all due respect and all sincerity on this matter, because of what Idaho Code identifies,
[0:46:55] At the moment where the sperm of the male meets the ovum of the female, Idaho Code identifies
[0:47:01] that life has begun and indeed rape and incest are tragic occasions.
[0:47:09] But the life of the child is nonetheless still a human being.
[0:47:15] So that's where we as a church and we as a community commit to you that we will stand
[0:47:19] inside any woman, in any child, in any moment of distress, and just wanting to have a discussion.
[0:47:30] Again, health of the mother, if there's a situation where carrying that child to turn.
[0:47:36] Absolutely, you know, in her life.
[0:47:40] Yeah, I think in lots of conversations I've had with a lot of people on this matter, that
[0:47:46] this indeed is a complicated matter.
[0:47:50] It does appear that we have advanced by the grace of God scientifically, that those typically
[0:47:57] called endopic pregnancies, where the baby cannot grow to full birth, to full size, we're
[0:48:05] learning now that that child can actually be moved into the womb.
[0:48:11] Those rare occasions when that does happen, the law would not bring prosecution upon in
[0:48:16] the medical necessity of a matter in the attempt to save the life of the mother or of the child.
[0:48:25] Thank you.
[0:48:28] Questions for Dr. Thompson?
[0:48:32] Is Anne Hawkins?
[0:48:33] Thank you.
[0:48:34] I'll take you forward.
[0:48:36] Thank you for leaving on this.
[0:48:38] You never need to talk to me.
[0:48:44] Take a vote.
[0:48:50] If I would like to talk with you about her.
[0:48:52] She was saying that she was saying she agreed with Dr. Thompson and felt that we worked in a position to make a decision
[0:49:18] decision this evening and requested that we consider bringing a back of weeks for other consideration by the council.
[0:49:34] Further, chins from the council? Thank you, Paul. I do have a question for our legal council, so...
[0:49:43] May I just finish the same thank you for your time? I come all the time and I know this is a very busy time for you.
[0:49:51] I'm very grateful for your time tonight. Thank you. Shane, I have a question.
[0:49:57] And so, Pastor Thompson referenced a couple of different areas of state code there, one
[0:50:03] of which was that municipalities and counties have authority to make laws and ordinances that
[0:50:10] aren't in conflict with, or I guess, the powers that are granted to municipalities and counties
[0:50:16] by the state to do that.
[0:50:18] So, clarify for me, abortion is legal in the state of Idaho, correct?
[0:50:23] And it's legal in the United States.
[0:50:27] And to me, this seems somewhat out of our wheelhouse as a city council.
[0:50:38] Even in looking through the other 19 items under Title VI, Chapter II,
[0:50:46] it deals with the handful of items that are kind of outside of the scope of state government.
[0:50:52] state government, so what kind of traps you can set when you're dealing with wild animals
[0:50:58] in your neighborhood.
[0:50:59] And frankly, I think a few of them are probably, they're from the 1958 code of the city that
[0:51:05] I suspect are now outright illegal actionable.
[0:51:09] Houses of prostitution, for example, was one of them I suspect that's against the law in
[0:51:14] the whole state.
[0:51:15] seems to me an item that would not necessarily be simply passed and enforced, in your opinion,
[0:51:27] city.
[0:51:28] So I guess the question really is about power, jurisdiction.
[0:51:36] So it's very commonly known that a city doesn't have any more power than a state because
[0:51:41] a city is formed by the state of Idaho.
[0:51:44] So we can't possibly have any additional power than the state of Idaho has to enact laws or
[0:51:51] otherwise.
[0:51:52] Further definitions we have in our state code that don't match or meet what has been interpreted
[0:52:00] by the Supreme Court of the United States would not be upheld as constitutional.
[0:52:04] So, for example, in 1973, Roe v. Wade, I agree with the pastor that science has changed some
[0:52:11] things and definitions of some of the terms that maybe they didn't have then, but it doesn't
[0:52:17] change the fact that in that analysis, the Supreme Court of the United States said that
[0:52:23] there was a legal right of privacy found in the Constitution that applies in this case.
[0:52:30] In that particular case, they set up trimesters and talked about how, in certain trimesters,
[0:52:37] the state might have a larger interest in protecting the health of the child and also the
[0:52:42] health of the mother. After that case, there were a list of cases going forward, including
[0:52:50] Planned Parenthood versus Casey, which our state legislature in passing our abortion
[0:52:55] law, which was quoted by the pastor, indicates that our law should all be as liberally as
[0:53:02] construed as possible, but housed within the framework of Planned Parenthood v. Casey.
[0:53:09] So I took that wholeheartedly as I was reviewing, the pastor just met with me previous to this.
[0:53:15] He shared copies of this with me and I took that very literally that I need to find any
[0:53:22] way possible that this is legal or constitutional.
[0:53:27] And unfortunately, as Mr. Pastor's mindset, my mindset of trying to follow the law of Idaho
[0:53:36] which says liberally construed as much as possible, the law, as presented, in my opinion, would
[0:53:45] be found unconstitutional, her, the Supreme Court of the United States, meaning should
[0:53:51] we go forward, I would anticipate very real costs to the City of Twin Falls to try to promote
[0:54:01] an ordinance that I do believe that the Supreme Court of the United States would find unconstitutional.
[0:54:07] Thanks, Shane. Great landing.
[0:54:10] Well, follow that same vein, and I've got conversations with that a week.
[0:54:16] Our city attorney, I checked with the AIC attorney at concerning this, and I think we would probably follow it
[0:54:27] if you realize it isn't that long ago that the legislature tried to send a limit of 20 weeks
[0:54:33] and lost, and where it gets expensive is, they had to end up having to pay my
[0:54:39] impairments, legal fees of $121,000 of the constitutional defense fund. We don't
[0:54:46] have a constitutional defense fund. We don't have $150,000 laying around to
[0:54:52] just give to an organization because they showed us that what we're doing. I
[0:54:56] don't believe we have the power to do this. I don't believe that we have the
[0:55:01] power to circumvent those. If you look at Article 6 of the U.S. Constitution, the Supreme Law
[0:55:10] of the Land, which usually comes to either Congress or from the Supreme Court, who are
[0:55:15] at the bottom of his pile, was concerned with his public officials. We're given everything
[0:55:21] we can do to us from a state legislature and a state legislature is not willing to react
[0:55:27] on it. We have no recourse to react on it either so I am not in favor of us moving forward
[0:55:33] and jeopardizing citizen tax money on something that it's obvious we're going to lose on. Now
[0:55:41] we can lay ourselves down in front of the bus so to speak, a principal but it still doesn't
[0:55:48] pay the bills. And we're in the middle of budget season right now and I'm not willing
[0:55:54] to risk hundreds of thousands of dollars on something I know by reasoning and by reading
[0:56:04] and looking at previous court cases to know that we are not in position to have the authority
[0:56:10] to pass this law or that this law would come anywhere near standing up to those Supreme
[0:56:17] Court's decisions.
[0:56:18] And yes, that row vase is weighed may be overturned, but until it has, it is the law of the land.
[0:56:25] And so I will be voting. If we decide to take a vote, I will be voting.
[0:56:30] Then we know this does not advance further, because it doesn't have any legal standing to move forward.
[0:56:37] We don't have the authority as the telephone city council to pass this particular ordinance.
[0:56:43] and that I'm now what you know this is opposite of my personal views but I know
[0:56:49] that that's what the law will say and that's what the courts say and so and then every attorney
[0:56:54] I've checked with to give us advice and said to me the same thing. Thank you. What else from the
[0:57:05] council? Take some time to digest this. Chris Reed, I would agree with this with what Suzanne said
[0:57:23] Chris because I understand what Greg is saying completely. The legal ramifications of saying
[0:57:33] yes to this because my personal opinion I'm against abortion but I want something that
[0:57:42] actually does something besides just cause more contention but actually helps whether
[0:57:49] it's encouraging the state, helping them making an impact. I definitely want to do that.
[0:57:58] I think that this started the dialogue, but I do think this is something maybe we need to digest and see what we can really do,
[0:58:05] to make sure that this moves forward and this isn't just a standstill.
[0:58:13] Is there some council action someone would like to propose?
[0:58:27] Yes.
[0:58:34] It is indeed my appeal to you to give longer consideration to this.
[0:58:43] I know you're aware of all global atrocities that have happened on humanity throughout the ages.
[0:58:51] We will never forget the images and the stories that were told that came out of Nazi Germany.
[0:58:59] We should never forget about the genocides of Rwanda.
[0:59:05] We should never forget the killing fields of Cambodia, our own nation, 61 million babies
[0:59:15] later.
[0:59:16] American soil, will God give us men and women who have the right and have the authority
[0:59:28] to act on their behalf?
[0:59:31] will God give us that people from you.
[0:59:37] Nowhere in all of history
[0:59:40] does anyone think rightly of Nazi Germany?
[0:59:44] No one thinks rightly
[0:59:46] of those who committed the atrocities in Russia.
[0:59:50] Cambodia, Rwanda, you know what's,
[0:59:53] there's one thing different here.
[0:59:55] What's happened on American soil
[0:59:57] and happening in the city of Twin Falls.
[1:00:00] God raise up men and women
[1:00:03] who will take a risk and stand against
[1:00:07] heinous act against humanity. I've come to appeal to you, to be that man, to be that woman,
[1:00:17] have come today to appeal to you. The difference of all of the atrocities across all of the globe
[1:00:24] and this atrocity, these babies in the womb have no ability to run from their enemies. Will someone
[1:00:33] 1. Stand up and stand in the way. Will you not interpose on their behalf? City of Twin
[1:00:45] Falls, City Council, I'm appealing to your conscience. Our state and our nation needs
[1:00:55] bold men.
[1:01:15] Again, this is listed as an action item, but it would not be an action on the potential
[1:01:22] action of what the Council would like to traverse. That is correct, so part of our
[1:01:30] That's the opportunity to engage the council as he did this evening and engage in that conversation
[1:01:37] in that dialogue.
[1:01:39] Staff would need a understanding of what those future steps would be from the council.
[1:01:47] What I did here is that there are some members of the council who would like to have our legal
[1:01:53] team and others evaluate polls before us and bring back that legal
[1:02:01] finding if I heard that correctly.
[1:02:03] I just wanted to thank everyone for coming and supporting us.
[1:02:15] I really appreciate it.
[1:02:16] I know one day evenings are sometimes difficult but we're not only full here in the city council
[1:02:21] chambers but in the overflow so thank you very much for coming and supporting us.
[1:02:25] Suzanne Hawkins.
[1:02:26] Thank you, Suzanne.
[1:02:27] You're just as much difficult to hear on your phone, but I'm going to see if I can summarize
[1:03:45] the motion that I heard you make there, which was to schedule a future meeting to continue
[1:03:52] dialogue, to have a legal review of the proposed ordinance, and to include Pastor Thompson in
[1:04:02] that ongoing conversation, did I miss anything in your motion?
[1:04:09] No, that's for rethinking.
[1:04:11] Thank you.
[1:04:12] Second.
[1:04:16] Motion by Susan Hocken, seconded by Christopher Reed to legal team, our internal legal team,
[1:04:25] as well as potentially other legal experts to review the viability of the ordinance and
[1:04:33] also to continue the dialogue to be scheduled at a future council meeting, and to include
[1:04:38] Pastor Thompson in those conversations.
[1:04:40] I'm concerned on this, this is, I don't have a problem with this talking about it more, I think we've already had a legal opinion on it and the girl, we know how to read, and we know this is out of our wheelhouse just like you said, and that we're giving these people hope for the fact that in six weeks or two weeks we're going to move it down the road, and we're going to just be saying no we can't do this, so I give them hope why not just let them know now that we, this is not something this city has been false.
[1:05:17] into legally by every step of the way.
[1:05:22] We are the bottom level of government,
[1:05:26] and we get our power from others.
[1:05:29] We don't have any anywhere
[1:05:30] what's called a Delano state or a general rule state
[1:05:33] that says we get all our power from legislature.
[1:05:36] We're not like some other states that say
[1:05:38] there is some inherent power.
[1:05:40] To be honest with you,
[1:05:41] they're going to take this anywhere
[1:05:43] that we would think they would take it to the county
[1:05:46] Because the county does have some inherent powers that we don't have
[1:05:50] So that would be my that will be the reason I would vote no against the motion
[1:05:56] I don't want to get people hope that it's down the road. We're gonna decide to
[1:06:00] Take this court case on and
[1:06:03] spectacularly lose a
[1:06:08] $100,000 to do so
[1:06:09] Thank you Nicky boy
[1:06:38] Is this something we can really do and make a difference?
[1:06:44] I don't know.
[1:06:45] I think what you're looking for, Councilwoman Boyd,
[1:06:51] I haven't found anyone and I've reached out
[1:06:54] to a lot of counterparts in other cities.
[1:06:56] In fact, the Attorney General's office
[1:06:58] was on the phone with one of their deputies today
[1:07:00] about this.
[1:07:01] They didn't know of any other Idaho cities.
[1:07:04] There is a city in Texas that has done this
[1:07:07] And they are going through the blows of a lawsuit.
[1:07:11] And that's to be explained.
[1:07:13] The answer to that question is we can pass ordinances.
[1:07:21] And in the past, we have that have been found unconstitutional.
[1:07:26] And then they just get stricken by the court.
[1:07:29] And as has been pointed out, a lot of these courts look at,
[1:07:34] did you have a true argument?
[1:07:38] Did you have a true basis to move this forward?
[1:07:41] My big is concerned, the legal side of things is with the status of the law nationally.
[1:07:48] I don't know how I can formulate a legal argument that would counteract any of that until,
[1:07:56] or unless Roe v. Wade is overturned, nor the powers that reverts back to the states as some are arguing for.
[1:08:06] And in that in that case, I think we could, legal, again, that's one way to answer it.
[1:08:15] We could act, but my legal opinion is that we would act and it would be found unconstitutional.
[1:08:20] And if we continued to act, we would spend a lot of time and money that ultimately, in
[1:08:28] my opinion, it would be found unconstitutional, as written.
[1:08:35] Again, I'll just reiterate, I think that, you know, there is national debate and discussion
[1:08:40] of this issue from a legal perspective.
[1:08:42] If changes occur to that, that is something that occurs at the state level to Councilman
[1:08:51] Lanting's point of the authority with limited authority.
[1:08:56] We actually have as city government in the people is vested in state government at the
[1:09:04] legislative level.
[1:09:06] I just think that this is an exercise in futility.
[1:09:10] There's no public input on this item tonight.
[1:09:20] further discussion from the council?
[1:09:22] Well, I wanted to give them more time.
[1:09:25] I'd like to kind of adjust the pros and cons of this.
[1:09:30] Are we set council person hawkers trying to ramrod
[1:09:33] through a motion?
[1:09:35] As such, I will oppose it.
[1:09:37] A roll versus wait.
[1:09:39] I don't know.
[1:09:40] Rules.
[1:09:41] No clear idea what we would do.
[1:09:44] I'll play up to it.
[1:09:46] If this were passed, having to hire a portion of the police squad to enforce it, it is ludicrous.
[1:09:56] It's a conflict between the objects, so I will oppose it.
[1:10:03] And it is clarified that the motion that Councilwoman Hawkins made is to continue to dialogue, schedule this for a further discussion on the future agenda.
[1:10:12] Have our legal team review it and do include Pastor Thompson in that so that there's no action in
[1:10:18] concluding something tonight it was to
[1:10:21] Forward but for the discussion roll call vote
[1:10:31] Greg Lanting no Ruth Pierce
[1:10:39] Christopher Reed. Yes Chris Tockington. No, not burger
[1:10:45] And Suzanne Hawkins
[1:10:48] Yeah.
[1:10:49] Motion fails.
[1:10:52] Let me do four, but thank you all for your presentation and for your participation where
[1:11:04] you're going to go ahead and go into recess for ten minutes.
[1:11:21] We received bids from Kodiak, Incorporated, Wassaw, Oshkosh, I have to cheat, MB, is that
[1:11:42] four?
[1:11:43] Yes.
[1:11:44] Okay, thank you.
[1:11:47] And unfortunately, there were irregularities in the bid.
[1:11:52] The first two low-bitters out of the four, they were missing information in the bids,
[1:11:58] and therefore, GUB recommended that we reject all bids.
[1:12:02] And next year, we'll look to do something differently with the FAA and go back out to
[1:12:07] bid for snow equipment.
[1:12:09] So with that, those irregularities, especially with two bidders, it makes it kind of a difficult
[1:12:16] to work with moving forward.
[1:12:18] So with that, staff would recommend rejecting all four bids
[1:12:22] for the snow, snow broom.
[1:12:24] Happy to answer any questions you might have.
[1:12:26] Thank you Bill, Chris Reed.
[1:12:28] I was going to make a motion unless somebody else says it.
[1:12:30] Chris Stockington, did you have any questions?
[1:12:32] I move that we reject all bids.
[1:12:36] We received four in the airport runway, snow broom.
[1:12:39] I'm sure that Chris Reed's second up by Chris Stockington
[1:12:43] to approve the request to reject all bids.
[1:12:47] Is there a discussion?
[1:12:50] Any of your own public, please?
[1:12:54] Christopher Reed?
[1:12:55] Yes.
[1:12:55] Chris Dockington?
[1:12:56] Yes.
[1:12:57] Sean Berriger?
[1:12:57] Yes.
[1:12:58] Nicky Boyd?
[1:12:59] Yes.
[1:12:59] Suzanne Hawkins?
[1:13:00] Yes.
[1:13:01] Greg Lanting?
[1:13:02] Yes.
[1:13:03] Norees Pierce?
[1:13:04] Yes.
[1:13:05] I should pass this up in the zero.
[1:13:06] Thank you, Mayor.
[1:13:07] There you go.
[1:13:09] Next is an action item.
[1:13:10] This is a request to accept a bid for the construction
[1:13:13] of a storage shed at the Twin Falls Club
[1:13:16] and dedicate cash reserves to complete the project.
[1:13:19] Wendy Davis, our Parks and Recreation Director.
[1:13:21] Welcome, Wendy.
[1:13:22] Thank you. Good evening, Mayor and Council. If you recall, I was here about a month ago with a request to use cash reserves to complete the construction project of the – so that we could take it back to bed of the golf course storage shed.
[1:13:42] And the discussion ensued and we decided to dedicate the funds so that I could put it back to bid and then you wanted me to come back with the bid once we had them.
[1:13:55] And I'm pleased to tell you that they did, well two of them came back about where we expected and one came back considerably lower.
[1:14:05] So, I would like to request that you will accept that bid and then dedicate some funds
[1:14:13] to finish the project and when I say some funds, we have a bid for $109,846 to construct
[1:14:22] the storage shed.
[1:14:23] The site work at $11,200 has already been done and then we need about $17,000 to do the
[1:14:30] electrical on the building.
[1:14:32] I didn't include when I wrote the staff report some 5% contingency, so if you wanted to cap
[1:14:38] it 20,000 above what we already have budgeted, which is 120,000, should absolutely be sufficient
[1:14:45] to complete the project.
[1:14:49] So, you're saying I'm not so...
[1:14:51] I'm not saying this is calling out his...
[1:14:52] I'm not like hitting 140,000.
[1:14:53] Yeah, so we have $120,000 budgeted, and what I'm saying is I think an additional 20,000
[1:15:02] cover the rest of the project and give us a little bit of a buffer in case we find something
[1:15:07] we're not expecting. I move we accept the bid for the construction of the storage shed and awarded
[1:15:20] to Clary construction for the Twin Falls Golf Club Storage Shed and dedicate 20,000 of cash reserves
[1:15:29] to complete the project. Most of my every is pierced, seconded by a great planting to award the bid as
[1:15:36] presented to Clary Building Corp in the amount of $109,846, an additional $20,000 from
[1:15:44] reserves to complete the project. Is there a discussion? Amy Earle, call vote please.
[1:15:52] Chris Tockington? Yes.
[1:16:04] Not Berrigger? Yes.
[1:16:05] Nicky Boyd? Yes.
[1:16:06] Suzanne Hawkins? Yes.
[1:16:08] Dan Hawkins? Yes.
[1:16:09] Great. Lanting? Yes.
[1:16:11] Ruth Pears? Yes.
[1:16:12] And Christopher Wrigger? Yes.
[1:16:14] Motion passes 7-0. Thank you.
[1:16:16] So, in the interest of time, we do have a public hearing scheduled for this evening that was
[1:16:22] to be end over earlier than 6 p.m.
[1:16:25] I'm going to rearrange the agenda a little bit.
[1:16:28] We will hold off on our budget presentation.
[1:16:30] We will go ahead and advance to the public hearing, which is an action item.
[1:16:35] Where I apologize, would I?
[1:16:39] You've got to sneak out of a prior gauge when I need to head to the holostricity and somebody.
[1:16:45] Thank you.
[1:16:59] All right, so this is a public hearing for an action item.
[1:17:04] This is a request, actually, first of all,
[1:17:06] let me run through the rules of a public hearing
[1:17:08] for a land use item.
[1:17:11] So what we will have here, this will be the city staff
[1:17:14] will present the request analysis.
[1:17:16] The applicant will then present their request.
[1:17:19] The council can then ask questions of the applicant
[1:17:21] or the staff.
[1:17:23] After those questions have been asked,
[1:17:24] we will open a public hearing for public input
[1:17:27] on the item.
[1:17:28] In that time, anyone in attendance is given the opportunity to comment or ask questions
[1:17:32] about the request being considered.
[1:17:34] When giving testimony, please step up to the podium, state your name, and address the presenter
[1:17:39] comments or concerns.
[1:17:40] After giving testimony, please be sure that you sign the public sign-in sheet, look at
[1:17:45] it in the lobby with your name and address for the record.
[1:17:48] After public comments are concluded, the applicant will be invited to answer any questions
[1:17:52] and make a closing statement.
[1:17:54] The staff will then answer or clarify any comments as needed.
[1:17:57] After those closing statements, the public hearing will be closed, no further testimony,
[1:18:02] or comments from the applicant where the audience will be allowed, and the council will then
[1:18:05] have an open discussion and take action on the request.
[1:18:10] So this is an action item, this is a request to approve an amendment to the Perrine Point
[1:18:14] PUD number 251 to allow multifamily units, amend landscaping requirements, and update the pressure
[1:18:21] irrigation agreement on property located at the northwest corner of Falls Avenue West in
[1:18:26] Grandview Drive, North and Caribbean Jam engineers.
[1:18:30] On behalf of Tree Screen goes LLC
[1:18:33] and the approval of the prime point pressure
[1:18:35] your Asian development agreement.
[1:18:40] With that we have Steve O'Connor, City Planner
[1:18:42] to present the report on behalf of the staff.
[1:18:45] Thank you Mr. Mayor, Council members.
[1:18:47] What we have for you is a request to amend the PUD
[1:18:51] for the prime point.
[1:18:53] It is located at the northwest corner of Grandview Drive
[1:18:57] Falls Avenue. There are several parts to this PUD. I'll try to lay them out as
[1:19:04] concisely as possible and then also update you as to what happened on the
[1:19:10] July 9th Planning and Zoning Commission and then the follow-up discussions that
[1:19:14] happened after that. So the main changes to the PUD, there are three parts,
[1:19:20] multiple attached units and buildings within the area identified as the R6B
[1:19:24] zone, which is, oh, no, I just closed it, nope, here we go, so this is, this outlined
[1:19:35] area is the original PUD area, this is what's described as the R6 zone, this area B here,
[1:19:45] with the highlighted black buildings, so this is the area that we're discussing right now,
[1:19:50] they're requesting multiple attached buildings within that R6 B zone on the, to be amended
[1:19:55] as shown on the master development plan,
[1:19:58] remove the perimeter landscaping requirement
[1:20:00] for all zones and revert any landscaping requirements
[1:20:03] to the underlying zoning district,
[1:20:05] so that would apply to the entire PUD,
[1:20:08] and then amend the pressure irrigation development agreement
[1:20:10] by relocating PI infrastructure
[1:20:12] from the southeastern portion in this general area
[1:20:16] that I'm circling, and then moving it
[1:20:20] to the northwestern area above this area,
[1:20:24] and we will discuss that in a little bit of detail.
[1:20:29] There have been also five or a few other changes
[1:20:34] that were requested during the PUD amendment.
[1:20:37] One was to allow for a five foot wide,
[1:20:40] attached rolled curbside walks
[1:20:43] for all internal pedestrian circulation
[1:20:46] within the R6B zone.
[1:20:47] So again, we're going back to that zone
[1:20:49] that we have identified here.
[1:20:53] And then also the PUD currently prohibits chain link
[1:20:56] fencing within the boundaries of the PUD,
[1:20:58] this would take that off,
[1:21:01] and then it would revert to an agreement
[1:21:03] between the property owners,
[1:21:05] and then also the developers at the time.
[1:21:08] And then it would also allow for,
[1:21:14] it would be through a written agreement,
[1:21:16] I'm sorry, written agreement
[1:21:17] that the chain link offensive would be allowed.
[1:21:19] And then per the city engineering department,
[1:21:22] there was a requirement,
[1:21:24] or there is currently a requirement of the PUD
[1:21:25] to require a traffic signal to be constructed
[1:21:29] at the intersection of falls and Grandview.
[1:21:31] City Engineering Department has requested
[1:21:33] that we remove that from the PUD
[1:21:36] as we currently excise impact fees
[1:21:39] for that specific reason.
[1:21:41] And it's a cleaner system to do so,
[1:21:43] rather than putting the entirety of that
[1:21:46] on this one developer.
[1:21:50] Oh, see here.
[1:21:54] We have worked extensively with the applicant
[1:21:56] and the representatives to get the language
[1:21:58] the proposed amendments to meet city code and policies,
[1:22:00] while also allowing the applicant to develop
[1:22:02] the property as a desire.
[1:22:04] And so on July 9th, 2019, the Planning and Zoning Commission
[1:22:08] did hear this item and they did recommend approval
[1:22:11] to the city council on this.
[1:22:13] However, during that hearing,
[1:22:15] there was a discussion on the parking requirement,
[1:22:19] and we felt after that, after that hearing,
[1:22:22] that the amendment number three was not very clear.
[1:22:25] And with follow-on discussions with the applicant,
[1:22:27] We have proposed a new amendment number three
[1:22:31] to make that the parking requirement a little more clear.
[1:22:35] And so you see that updated in the current
[1:22:38] in your staff report.
[1:22:40] A little bit of history, not much other than that.
[1:22:42] Both the plat and the PED were recorded in May of 2008.
[1:22:47] The request is in compliance with a comprehensive plan
[1:22:50] as this area is designated as a town neighborhood
[1:22:53] and neighborhood commercial.
[1:22:55] So you still have the somewhat commercial corridor here
[1:22:58] on the east edge of the development and then residential,
[1:23:02] which is very in line with our comprehensive plan.
[1:23:09] So there's gonna be two actions on this particular item.
[1:23:15] There's gonna be one action on the amendment to the PUD,
[1:23:20] and then also an action to accept
[1:23:23] the new pressure irrigation development agreement.
[1:23:27] And if you have any questions on that,
[1:23:29] we have some city engineers in the audience tonight
[1:23:31] to clarify any questions that you may have on that.
[1:23:35] So in conclusion, should the Council approve this request,
[1:23:39] staff recommends the following conditions.
[1:23:41] One, subject to continue compliance
[1:23:43] with all local, state, and federal causes requirements
[1:23:46] and requirements and other standards as applicable.
[1:23:49] And two, subject to the approval of changes
[1:23:51] to amendment number three of the proposed draft PUD
[1:23:53] amendment.
[1:23:55] And I will be available for questions
[1:23:56] once the applicant has had their time.
[1:23:59] Thank you. Thank you Steve. Now present their request.
[1:24:08] Thank you. You have a good evening, Mayor and members of the Council.
[1:24:13] I do appreciate you juggling the schedule for us.
[1:24:16] Like Charlie is here. Also, he's done most of the exhibits
[1:24:21] and in detail designed for the future owner of
[1:24:25] the R6B zone that you are looking at
[1:24:29] and like lifts from out of town so I know he appreciates the juggle as well.
[1:24:34] Um, Steve's comments are exactly correct.
[1:24:40] We have worked extensively on this.
[1:24:44] You saw this probably two or three months ago when we vacated the original internal portion
[1:24:50] that this apartment development complex is sitting in.
[1:24:55] This would have been a much simpler PAD amendment.
[1:24:58] Originally, we were only looking at dealing with the R6B zone, but we found through negotiations
[1:25:07] and conversations with the city that there were other things within the development that
[1:25:12] needed cleaned up as well.
[1:25:14] One of them being specifically the pressure oration requirements, so that is part of the
[1:25:21] detailed agreement you see within your packet.
[1:25:26] I believe it has some sort of both the developer and city staff and as far as everything else
[1:25:34] it is a quality development and it's going to be a great addition to the neighbors.
[1:25:38] So I would not be labor my time.
[1:25:42] I would stand for you or at work blank if you need any questions answered for the immediate development itself.
[1:25:51] Thank you.
[1:25:54] I see Chris Reed has a question or comment in this comments or questions towards Steve
[1:26:00] I remember this area coming before planning and zoning four or five years ago
[1:26:05] and we had a public hearing and that light was discussed on Grand Human Falls
[1:26:11] that was the main topic so can you just it's as far as the payment for that
[1:26:18] that light is that you've taken off the applicant being paid for by impact fees, is that what you're telling us?
[1:26:25] That's correct, yeah, it's a cleaner system like I said, and it would allow for as the development happens, and then as the impact to the intersection happens, then it would develop organically rather than boom, there's a traffic light, but there will be a traffic light.
[1:26:43] When it's worn.
[1:26:45] When it's worn.
[1:26:46] Yeah, when it's worn, thank you.
[1:26:47] Or councilman Reed.
[1:26:48] Steve, correct me if I'm wrong.
[1:26:50] I don't believe the impact fees existed at that original approval time.
[1:26:54] That's the change.
[1:26:55] Right.
[1:27:00] And it's for staff or the applicants.
[1:27:05] Not seeing it.
[1:27:06] Thank you.
[1:27:11] Open it up for public input.
[1:27:13] If you would like to speak to this issue,
[1:27:15] now is your opportunity to please come forward in the public hearing.
[1:27:18] I'll close the public hearing.
[1:27:23] And Tim, I'm guessing you're okay to not to have to rebut anything there.
[1:27:26] I'll turn it over to the Council for discussion, Chris, talking to him to approve the amendment.
[1:27:36] My multi-family units, men, landscaper, and requirements, and update the pressure irrigation agreement on the property located at the northwest corner of Folsam, New West Grandview Drive, North.
[1:27:52] So we have to trace the Lagos, the trace gringos, L, L, C.
[1:27:58] I have approval of the prime point pressure irrigation development agreement, plus the
[1:28:03] described city of additional wrinkle.
[1:28:07] So it's going to be split up into two actions.
[1:28:10] So we're going to take two actions, one will be for the PUD, and the second will be for the
[1:28:14] irrigation development zone.
[1:28:16] We'll take that as your motion and repair second.
[1:28:19] Motion by Chris Doggman, second by Ruth Pierce to
[1:28:23] Approve the PUD amendment as presented and with the conditions as presented
[1:28:39] Burger
[1:28:58] I move that we approve the prime point pressure irrigation development agreement as well.
[1:29:08] I move that we approve the prime point pressure irrigation development agreement as shown.
[1:29:14] Wait a second.
[1:29:21] I approve the prime point pressure irrigation development agreement discussion.
[1:29:28] Nicky Boyd?
[1:29:35] Yes.
[1:29:36] Yes.
[1:29:37] Yes.
[1:29:39] Ruth Pears. Yes. Christopher Reed. Yes. Chris Tockington. Yes. Yes. And Sean Berger. Yes.
[1:29:46] Motion passes 6-0. Thank you. Alright, so we will jump up, back up under items of consideration.
[1:30:02] The presentation of these city managers recommended budget for fiscal year 2020 followed by citizen input.
[1:30:08] Presentation will focus on the internal organization focus area 8 of the strategic plan.
[1:30:13] And I have Gretchen Scott, our Human Resource Director.
[1:30:16] Come, Gretchen.
[1:30:19] He's the one listed on the agenda, so I don't know if I'm gonna let you speak.
[1:30:35] How short is it?
[1:30:38] We're tag teaming.
[1:30:39] We have our city manager, Travis Rothweiler, here to present, all of my good part of the
[1:30:48] show from Gretchen Scott.
[1:30:49] That's exactly right.
[1:30:50] So we're going to talk about Focus Area 8, and that's why we're hired good people, so
[1:31:55] So they know exactly what buttons to help the City Manager push when it comes to having
[1:32:01] all of the display moving forward.
[1:32:03] So tonight we just want to have a quick conversation about the budget and where we're at.
[1:32:07] And just as the other members of the City Management Team have provided is just a quick overview
[1:32:13] of the topic of the conversation this evening.
[1:32:17] This is the last conversation that we will have about a particular focus area.
[1:32:23] And over the course of the last several weeks, we've engaged and we've done a deep dive in
[1:32:29] all of the various focus areas, and we've saved the heart of our focus areas for this evening's
[1:32:37] presentation.
[1:32:38] Tonight we're going to be talking about focus at area 8, which is our internal organization,
[1:32:44] and it really is the intersection of where public services are delivered to the citizens
[1:32:51] that is it that live and do business in our fair city.
[1:32:59] As we have done for the last several years
[1:33:02] and also for the last several weeks,
[1:33:05] we like to share the end of the story first
[1:33:09] because that becomes one of the most important parts
[1:33:11] and citizens in our community
[1:33:13] want to know what is it going to cost me.
[1:33:15] And so this evening we handed out an updated staff report
[1:33:19] that reflect all of these numbers.
[1:33:21] In addition to that, the numbers here are updated.
[1:33:26] Mitch last week had these numbers illustrated and read
[1:33:28] as a point of trying to illustrate what those look like.
[1:33:32] But really at the end of the day,
[1:33:34] we are looking at having a monthly increase
[1:33:36] to live inside of the city of Twin Falls
[1:33:38] of $7.78.
[1:33:41] If this budget is unaltered and the plan moving forward,
[1:33:47] the tax rate is not something that we have the opportunity
[1:33:50] to directly set. We set the tax rate based upon our focus on how much money, property
[1:33:56] tax dollars in particular. Are we going to be spending in this year's budget? We do
[1:34:02] not have control over the assessed or praised value. That is the responsibility of the
[1:34:08] account and the assessor. And for us, the tax rate is not a mill rate. We don't assign
[1:34:15] Our tax rate is actually a mathematical formula, where we take our total proposed level of spending and we divide that by the total taxable value.
[1:34:24] And you get a tax rate that is applied uniformly to all properties that reside within the city of Twin Falls' corporate boundary.
[1:34:32] And we're projecting that that tax rate is going to decrease by 29 cents per $1000 of tax value based upon the best information that we have.
[1:34:40] last year was $7.50, we're projecting a tax rate of $7.21.
[1:34:47] In addition to that, you can see the projected increases that we're talking about for water
[1:34:53] and for sewer and for sanitation.
[1:34:56] Just a note on the sanitation rate that's reflected there, that assumes that we make
[1:35:01] no changes to the current plan.
[1:35:04] And in some of our conversations, and as we shared earlier this evening, next week we
[1:35:09] will engage in the conversation about recycling and so that number may change
[1:35:14] depending upon the direction that we receive from the City Council going forward
[1:35:19] in particular about recycling. So you can see that the City of Twin Falls as an
[1:35:25] entity has a taxable value of $3,184 million that is an increase from $2,895
[1:35:36] million dollars from the prior year. You can see that we're looking at spending in all
[1:35:41] tax-supported funds, $43 million in non-tax-supported funds, which is water,
[1:35:46] plantation, sewer, those things in which we receive a service. We're looking at total
[1:35:53] spending of about $24 million. When you take a total look at the city's total
[1:35:58] taxable value, include the urban rental agency, that value grows to about $3.75
[1:36:04] $2.5 billion to put that in comparison in 2012, the value was $2.3 billion.
[1:36:13] So we've seen some impressive growth, but that growth is not without its challenges and some
[1:36:19] of those challenges.
[1:36:20] Our Public Works Director John Caden had described to you earlier this evening, trying to keep
[1:36:25] up with those items that we deferred in the past, but also trying to make sure that we
[1:36:30] can leave this place a little bit better in which we have found it today.
[1:36:35] What we'd like to illustrate is the tax rate over a period of time and you can see this tax
[1:36:40] rate is the lowest tax rate that we are projecting over the course of the last eight fiscal years.
[1:36:49] And that has really a product of how we've seen the median home value increase in our community.
[1:36:57] At the bottom of the recession, the median home inside of the City of Twin Falls was
[1:37:01] $116,000. Today that same home in that market unchanged is estimated to have a total value
[1:37:10] of $205,000 and a good conversation with some of my friends who are in the real estate business.
[1:37:18] And one of the things they said is you won't find a house in Twin Falls for $205,000 even
[1:37:23] if that is the median. And that's why at the bottom you'll see that the median listed
[1:37:28] price of homes in Twin Falls is 245. We are projecting that houses will continue to increase
[1:37:36] over the course of the next calendar year. That ranges anywhere between 8 and a half to
[1:37:41] 10 percent total value. So we like to compare ourselves to other full service cities inside of
[1:37:49] the state of Idaho and you'll notice that the city of Twin Falls appears in green. All of the other
[1:37:58] cities appear in either blue or a version of red and we want to make that distinction
[1:38:06] because if you just take a look at the cities as independent entities and you take their
[1:38:11] tax rate and you apply it to that same median home in their communities in blue that is
[1:38:18] an apples to apples comparison to Twin Falls because all the cities in blue operate a street
[1:38:25] department and therefore a significant portion of their dollars go to fund
[1:38:29] streets. Aida County is a bit different. Aida County has a county wide highway
[1:38:33] district and if you were to add the total value of the taxes assessed by the
[1:38:39] Aida County Highway District to both Meridian and to Boise you see where they
[1:38:44] shoot up in that and so the city of Twin Falls as an entity has the lowest taxes
[1:38:52] on a median home inside of the state of Idaho, but not only that, one of the things that we found
[1:38:57] we get access to a lot of information, and we have learned that we are the lowest median
[1:39:05] house price of any metropolitan statistical area west of the Mississippi River. Our housing index
[1:39:15] is rated at a 7800 is the national average and that continues to, while we watch houses
[1:39:27] in our area significantly increase in value and we reflected that in that chart, they're
[1:39:31] not growing at the same rate in the same pace that we see in many places including the Treasure
[1:39:36] Valley where the median house in Twin Falls is about $100,000 less than that same median
[1:39:42] house inside the city of Boise and the cities of Arrudian really quickly this
[1:39:51] budget goes for the statutory three percent which will generate six hundred
[1:39:58] sixty one thousand dollars in tax revenue it uses the growth formula which is the
[1:40:03] growth that we've seen come on to our tax rolls of nearly 75 million which is
[1:40:08] the largest that we have on on our record and that will create about another
[1:40:15] of $559,000, the $74 million of new construction value is $20 million greater than the prior
[1:40:25] fiscal year.
[1:40:26] I think that that really kind of reflects the amount of growth.
[1:40:32] Total property tax collections are projected to be $23.26 million.
[1:40:39] We've had conversations about the foregone balance, and that foregone balance is that
[1:40:44] money that the council has elected not to take as related to the statutory balance over a period of time.
[1:40:49] This does not incorporate any portion of the foregone balance for our budgets moving forward.
[1:40:57] And the total increases projected are 1% for water, 1% for sewer, and again 4.9% for sanitation should you keep that unchanged.
[1:41:09] changed. The municipal cost index that we use is 1.9%. And so we are doing business at
[1:41:17] a better rate than the municipal cost index. Tonight we're going to talk about the internal
[1:41:22] organization. When we first created this strategic plan in 2012, we had all eight of those focus
[1:41:29] areas saying that they're of equal weight and equal value. And then through a series of
[1:41:33] conversations and the update that occurred in 2018 we recognized we've
[1:41:41] long recognized the value of our employees we demonstrated that as we
[1:41:46] recreated the visual that describes our strategic plan you cannot be an
[1:41:53] accessible community you cannot be a safe community you cannot do the things
[1:41:57] that we're doing if it's not for the 312 dedicated men and women public service
[1:42:04] professionals that work as a part of our organization.
[1:42:07] They are the boots on the ground.
[1:42:08] They are the ones that come to us at our worst times
[1:42:14] and our greatest needs.
[1:42:15] They are there to provide us with some of the greatest
[1:42:18] moments of memory through recreation services.
[1:42:20] It is absolutely amazing the things and the members
[1:42:24] of what our team move forward with.
[1:42:28] Helping us drive that is not only every single member
[1:42:32] of our leadership team, and those who have custodial
[1:42:37] responsibilities and overall of our employees,
[1:42:40] but most importantly, our HR team.
[1:42:42] And so Gretchen, Scott, and member of her team
[1:42:44] are going to talk about some of the amazing things
[1:42:48] that they're doing to help further focus area eight.
[1:42:51] You will say that all the other presentations
[1:42:53] have been absolutely wonderful.
[1:42:54] They've been dynamite.
[1:42:55] They've been visuals.
[1:42:58] We don't need a lot of glitz and glitter
[1:43:02] when we're talking about our employees.
[1:43:05] We think that they sell themselves,
[1:43:06] so we don't need any fancy videos
[1:43:07] and Josh Palmer expertise.
[1:43:10] We got our own secret weapon over with HR,
[1:43:12] so with that, I'm turning over to Gretchen.
[1:43:22] Congression.
[1:43:24] Thank you.
[1:43:25] Okay, so we didn't have the talents of Josh Palmer
[1:43:30] to help us tonight, but we do have talents of members
[1:43:34] of the HR team, members of the finance team,
[1:43:37] and we expect to be able to give you a great insight
[1:43:40] what's going on within your organization.
[1:43:43] I apologize that we're two hours into the meeting.
[1:43:46] A lot of stuff to tell you.
[1:43:51] We'll try to keep it brief.
[1:43:54] So I won't go through and read the actual focus area
[1:43:58] highlights.
[1:44:00] It lays out the strategic objective vision
[1:44:02] for where we're heading.
[1:44:04] It is sort of our point that we head towards
[1:44:08] as we are crafting and working internally on all
[1:44:11] of the different pieces that we're responsible for.
[1:44:16] So we're gonna talk to you tonight
[1:44:17] about three specific things,
[1:44:19] well, three main topics,
[1:44:21] and underneath those, what those pieces all involve.
[1:44:24] The first one in play, Wellness, K2Shay,
[1:44:26] our Wellness and Safety Coordinator is gonna touch on,
[1:44:29] and I'll follow up,
[1:44:30] organizational objectives,
[1:44:32] Janie Higgins from the finance team.
[1:44:35] We'll be talking to you a little bit
[1:44:36] about what we've been doing there,
[1:44:38] and relative to employer of choice,
[1:44:41] Kristin was going to talk but she's fallen ill, she hasn't fell up to it.
[1:44:45] We have her on backup though in case we need to pull her in so that's what we're going to
[1:44:50] be fizzing with you about tonight.
[1:44:52] Okay so with that is Katie.
[1:44:55] Good evening everyone, it's good to be here.
[1:45:01] I have all these notes and Gretchen told me to keep it short.
[1:45:04] So I've highlighted the highlights.
[1:45:07] Our wellness program has been going for a few years, and we, so the city's motto is people
[1:45:16] serving people, and I like to think of HR as the department that serves the people who
[1:45:21] serve the people.
[1:45:22] We get to deal with all departments, which is our fortune.
[1:45:26] It's kind of challenging sometimes to get everybody on board.
[1:45:29] In fact, I don't think we've ever gotten everyone on board, but we're trying.
[1:45:33] So just a few things about our wellness program.
[1:45:36] We had our second annual health fair in May.
[1:45:40] We had about 80 employees and their spouses come.
[1:45:42] And I don't remember if any council people came or not.
[1:45:45] I'm sorry.
[1:45:46] But it was just a way to present things from St. Luke's,
[1:45:50] from Select Health, from our other providers,
[1:45:53] dental, just to get people to come and see
[1:45:56] what we have available and what we can help them do
[1:45:59] to help themselves be healthy.
[1:46:01] That was kind of fun.
[1:46:03] Next year, we're hoping to get the big inflatable colon,
[1:46:05] but it was a really windy day, and they said the commons
[1:46:08] was not a good place for the big inflatable colon,
[1:46:11] so I'll keep you posted on that.
[1:46:13] We also work with our employees to see who's interested
[1:46:17] in buying a corporate membership to Air St. Luke's.
[1:46:20] And for us to do it, it's $45, it's for your family,
[1:46:24] your dependents, there's some specifics
[1:46:26] on who can be in your program, but it's a great deal.
[1:46:29] And I can tell you we've had one employee
[1:46:33] who was an Air St. Luke's member, who had to use it twice.
[1:46:37] And the savings, you can't really count the savings.
[1:46:42] It was very good.
[1:46:43] So we also had a lot more people join up this year.
[1:46:46] And I think it was probably because with that in mind,
[1:46:48] it's like, why not?
[1:46:49] $45 for a year, it's a good deal.
[1:46:52] And you're all welcome to participate as well.
[1:46:55] Our Wellness Reimbursement Program is really popular.
[1:46:58] We have budgeted $150 per city employee.
[1:47:02] They can put in a request for reimbursement for something
[1:47:05] that they're passionate about.
[1:47:07] We've had people who, by hunting and fishing licenses,
[1:47:11] they go to campgrounds and they have to pay a campground fee.
[1:47:14] They go to professional baseball games.
[1:47:17] These are things where we want people to do something
[1:47:19] that they enjoy that's not work related.
[1:47:22] And we, like I said, we budget 150 per person.
[1:47:26] Some people have claimed the entire amount.
[1:47:29] Some people will do it bits and pieces, fund runs.
[1:47:33] Jim memberships, you name it.
[1:47:36] I haven't turned anybody down this year.
[1:47:38] So all requests have been granted this year.
[1:47:40] So we found out from, this is the second year we've done,
[1:47:44] and it's very popular.
[1:47:45] So we're going to do it again next year.
[1:47:48] We have managed in the last year 35 workers' compensation
[1:47:52] claims.
[1:47:53] So it may not sound like we're wellness people,
[1:47:56] but that's what we do in the department.
[1:47:59] It's been a bad year for ankles.
[1:48:01] I don't know how many ankle injuries we had through the year.
[1:48:04] So we follow up with those claims.
[1:48:06] We file paperwork along with paper.
[1:48:09] So that's really important for employees.
[1:48:12] Same with FMLA leave, FMLA benefits, sorry.
[1:48:16] We've had people who have asked for that,
[1:48:19] and they're having new babies.
[1:48:21] They want to stay home for a while with their babies.
[1:48:22] That's a good thing.
[1:48:23] Sometimes it's for their own personal illnesses.
[1:48:26] Sometimes it's for family members who need some help,
[1:48:29] so we follow FMLA as well,
[1:48:31] and that's a lot of paperwork,
[1:48:34] but it's very worthwhile.
[1:48:36] As far as wellness alone, we do monthly challenges,
[1:48:40] we do it through the newsletter,
[1:48:42] we do it through Tuesday tips,
[1:48:44] just to try to keep people engaged,
[1:48:46] and they're not just go out and run a mile.
[1:48:49] They're read a book on a particular topic.
[1:48:52] So we try to bring in all aspects of wellness, same with our luncheon learns, we're doing
[1:48:58] that as well, which brings me to this week we actually have a luncheon learn and I hope
[1:49:05] you saw it in your email, maybe you didn't, but we have Megan Johnson from the Treasure
[1:49:10] Valley YMCA who's going to be down here on Thursday giving a presentation on the Diabetes
[1:49:15] to Prevention program.
[1:49:18] We found out when we got our Healthy Values report from St. Luke's, where we are lacking
[1:49:27] as an organization and just to kind of briefly summarize, we have a lot of employees and I
[1:49:40] am putting myself right in that category who are overweight or under tall, however you
[1:49:46] you want to say it? And there are other factors that lead to type 2 diabetes. And I know from
[1:49:52] personal experience in my family how devastating that can be. So we are having Megan come down,
[1:49:58] she's going to talk about this diabetes 2 prevention program that we're going to offer
[1:50:03] at the city starting in the fall. It can be as long as a 26 week program that you commit
[1:50:13] to, but really only have to do 22 weeks of that and so when she comes down she's
[1:50:17] going to tell everybody who comes this is what the program is, this is what it
[1:50:21] offers you, these are the things you need to do to qualify and it's really a great
[1:50:27] program. I actually did it a couple years ago, was very successful, then it had kind
[1:50:32] of a family issue come up and it's like I am depressed, I'm just going to go eat
[1:50:36] and I'm going to watch Netflix and that's only going to do. So I'm looking forward to
[1:50:40] doing the program as well.
[1:50:41] In fact, I was trained as a lifestyle coach, something
[1:50:45] I never thought I would be.
[1:50:47] But I will be helping to facilitate these meetings.
[1:50:50] I'll actually be doing the meetings,
[1:50:52] although the Y is going to provide all the material
[1:50:54] and actually set up the schedule.
[1:50:57] So all you have to do to be successful in this program
[1:51:02] is three things.
[1:51:05] You weigh at the beginning of the program,
[1:51:07] And then what they're hoping is through the end of the program,
[1:51:11] you will have lost 7% of whatever your body weight is.
[1:51:16] Now I did my own math on this, and it's not that bad.
[1:51:20] It's not that bad.
[1:51:21] And it's based on you yourself.
[1:51:23] It's not like the program says everybody goes out and loses 20 pounds.
[1:51:26] It's to you.
[1:51:27] It's specific to yourself.
[1:51:29] You also commit to 150 minutes of exercise a week.
[1:51:34] It can be walking, running, biking, jumping, anything.
[1:51:39] And you can break it up into 10 minute increments,
[1:51:41] 30 minutes, however you want to do it.
[1:51:42] So there's the weight loss, there's the exercise,
[1:51:45] and the last one is actually the hardest,
[1:51:47] and it's tracking every day what you eat and drink.
[1:51:52] And I know from when I did it the first time,
[1:51:54] it was a pain in the neck, but when I quit doing it,
[1:51:58] that's when I started sliding,
[1:52:00] that scale started sliding back up.
[1:52:02] So it is a great program, we're gonna offer that
[1:52:04] to our city employees, there's a cost involved,
[1:52:07] but insurance will cover it as long as you commit
[1:52:11] to the program and fulfill at least,
[1:52:13] and I can't remember right now what the number
[1:52:15] is, how many classes you go to.
[1:52:17] But it is a very good program, and we, you know,
[1:52:20] from looking at this report, we know that
[1:52:24] Type II Diabetes unchecked leads to
[1:52:28] much, much worse things, and we don't want any
[1:52:31] of our employees to go through that,
[1:52:33] So we're going to do what we can.
[1:52:34] We're going to lead them to the water.
[1:52:37] We're going to lead them.
[1:52:38] And then we can't put their head under water.
[1:52:41] And we know that.
[1:52:42] But we're offering what we can to help our employees.
[1:52:46] And so anything, if you guys have any questions about any
[1:52:48] of these, I'm more than happy to answer questions.
[1:52:51] And if you want to sit out by Thursday at lunchtime,
[1:52:53] it'll be up in the overflow room.
[1:52:56] Come on and see what it's all about.
[1:52:59] I think that's all I have.
[1:53:02] Thank you.
[1:53:03] Thank you, Katie.
[1:53:04] I was just going to show you in the Healthy Values Report.
[1:53:07] So this is an aggregate report over the past since 2014,
[1:53:11] so the past four years of our data by our employees.
[1:53:17] And it goes through and it shows the areas in which we
[1:53:21] measure how our employees are doing.
[1:53:24] So we do each year a Body Mass Index at BMI.
[1:53:30] And according to this, only 19% of our employees
[1:53:34] are within the normal body mass index.
[1:53:38] It can go forward, only 58% have a normal waste circumference.
[1:53:43] 87% have a normal blood pressure,
[1:53:46] or exit within an area that is considered controlled.
[1:53:51] The reason why the diabetes type two prevention class
[1:53:54] becomes such an important initiative
[1:53:57] of the Human Resources Department
[1:53:59] is when you get down here to this bottom
[1:54:01] courses of our employees who has two or more risk factors and has an increased risk for
[1:54:07] metabolic syndrome and heart disease.
[1:54:10] We have 127 of our employees are in that category and that's a really scary figure.
[1:54:19] So when we talk about health insurance as an organization, it's a really expensive
[1:54:25] outlay by the city. So anything that we can do that's going to prevent the
[1:54:31] declining health, that's going to improve our employees ability to stay
[1:54:35] productive, stay efficient, stay at work, increase their quality of life is a
[1:54:41] program we believe is worth pursuing.
[1:54:45] Bikati's involvement in the Prevent Type 2 Diabetes class, she came to me she said
[1:54:51] why it has asked me if I'd be willing to do this. And I said, heck yeah, we're gonna do it.
[1:54:55] This is a great idea. And so she moved forward with that. This is an aggregate chart of everything
[1:55:02] that we measure and how those have changed over time. 2018 is out here. I'm gonna scroll in just
[1:55:09] a little bit for you. You're welcome. And you can see where some of those things have changed.
[1:55:14] Some of the areas that are concerning to us is that uncontrolled diabetics seem to be
[1:55:22] flipping back and forth.
[1:55:23] So sometimes they're testing well and other times they're not.
[1:55:27] Another area of concern for us is the increasing in overweight and increasing in obese categories.
[1:55:33] So to us that's a messaging, a continued effort to talk about health, to talk about wellness,
[1:55:40] encourage people to make healthy and good choices as they move forward.
[1:55:46] We have so much good stuff to share with you, so sorry.
[1:55:51] This category is all good things over here, on the year-over-year regressions.
[1:55:56] Those are negatives, 120% regression and uncontrolled diabetes.
[1:56:01] That's where it flip-flought from year to year.
[1:56:05] It's important that I just sort of want to make sure that everybody understands.
[1:56:09] know who people are, we don't get, this is just the aggregate report we get. So we've
[1:56:13] been doing health screens since I started here. We don't know who's in these
[1:56:18] categories, we just get this kind of report that tells us where our focus
[1:56:21] should be. So the last thing that they share with us is what they see as identified
[1:56:29] opportunities that we should be moving forward with. One of these that's really
[1:56:33] important that I want to talk about is under two ND, Explore Innovative
[1:56:37] trends with technology such as wearables and apps to add gamification or healthy
[1:56:44] behaviors and related weight management. We're going to talk a little bit more
[1:56:48] about that later but I wanted to point that out. So then so as we've talked about
[1:57:01] health insurance our lowest level of copay has always been based on whether
[1:57:09] or not you into the annual health screening as we move forward in the next
[1:57:13] 12 months in gear up for October of 2020, we are trying to build in some additional things
[1:57:20] that mean participating and what it means for employees to start engaging in their health.
[1:57:25] And we're doing that specifically in partnership with Select Health and State Lukes.
[1:57:31] And we have some things we're going to be bringing to the employees this year.
[1:57:34] I'm not going to go into all those because it's been two hours and 10 minutes now.
[1:57:38] But I did want to show you what one of those looks like.
[1:57:49] So in partnership with Select Health, we will be rolling out, not to over, to all of our employees,
[1:57:55] this healthy living platform.
[1:57:57] We did this a couple of years ago.
[1:57:59] We stopped because we couldn't get employee engagement.
[1:58:03] We had about one-third of the organization and consistently the same third always involved.
[1:58:09] And we have to try to get them more and deeper within the organization and their spouses involved
[1:58:15] in things like this in order to change our wellness curve.
[1:58:23] So this is just kind of a high-level overview from Healthy Living.
[1:58:28] Our team, Katie, will be running essentially the lead on getting our employees involved
[1:58:35] in this.
[1:58:36] We have a team as Select Health and the Healthy Living product itself that will be working
[1:58:41] with us.
[1:58:43] You can see that they will go on, they will do digital coaching programs.
[1:58:47] It's based on their health assessment that they go on electronically and filled out, and
[1:58:52] then it will tell them, are you having trouble with your sleep?
[1:58:54] Are you having trouble with stress?
[1:58:55] Are you having trouble with nutrition?
[1:58:57] What are some areas that we can help you on?
[1:58:58] And then it provides the helping steps that they can take to move forward with their health
[1:59:02] in a better area.
[1:59:06] In addition to that, there are challenges that will happen as an organization where we'll
[1:59:11] do and they sync with people's electronic gadgets or phones, but it's activities, it's
[1:59:18] things they can do that are healthy habits.
[1:59:24] Back here, really great.
[1:59:26] Are you liking our special effects?
[1:59:31] So these are the challenges that will come up.
[1:59:33] This is what they look like.
[1:59:35] When you're on the program and you're logging in and you're logging your steps, you're logging
[1:59:39] your activity, and let's say you're doing the US National Parks Challenge, you started
[1:59:44] a certain location and you walk your way across the United States to different
[1:59:47] parks, you get to go to different areas and when you hover over the map it'll pop up
[1:59:52] information about those things. When we were doing this program originally, Travis
[1:59:58] cheated. He became a triathlete. He pretty much finished all of them in like
[2:00:04] the first week so we kicked him off all the teams because he was totally ruining
[2:00:08] the average. But there are a lot of there a lot of fun and they gave us great
[2:00:12] information. In addition to the activity challenges, the other things that are
[2:00:17] part of wellness, healthy eating, building relationships and connections,
[2:00:22] contributing to my community, reducing stress. These are the kinds of things that
[2:00:28] are also part of our wellness reimbursement that Katie was just talking
[2:00:31] about, but these are other challenges that are designed to help people in the
[2:00:35] other areas of wellness beyond just my physical health, which we believe builds are
[2:00:41] well-rounded and balanced employee. We had to connect with a lot of our employees this
[2:00:54] last year because our health insurance renewal came in. I think they said that we
[2:00:59] technically earned about a 29% increase. What they ended up giving us in terms of
[2:01:06] our renewal rate was much lower than that, but even so at an unsustainable amount.
[2:01:11] So we've worked with department leaders, we asked them to connect with their
[2:01:16] teams to talk to them about what they really valued in terms of our health insurance, what
[2:01:20] benefit they really cared about in terms of what those plans offered to them, and then we
[2:01:25] made plan changes to our health insurance as a result of that feedback. It isn't something
[2:01:30] we could have done alone. It isn't something we could have had buy-in across the organization
[2:01:35] without employee's input, and without us valuing that input and saying, your thoughts, your value
[2:01:43] sets mattered and how we went about this and so those are some of the big changes
[2:01:47] that we've made in health insurance. Next I want to talk about some of the
[2:01:53] accomplishments for organizational objectives that we're working on. Time
[2:01:57] clock plus is a digital timekeeping system that accurately accounts for
[2:02:03] hours worked and automatically feeds into our financial software system and this
[2:02:08] is a project that was entered into about 12 or 18 months ago started by the
[2:02:13] finance team, and then started incorporating payroll and human resources.
[2:02:18] And Janie is going to join us over here, and she's going to give us some input.
[2:02:22] Thank you, Katie.
[2:02:23] And she's going to take you on a digital tour.
[2:02:33] One thing I want to talk about after, or as she's visiting about this, is we had no idea how far
[2:02:40] astray the actual practices within the field of how employees and supervisors were
[2:02:46] hand recording on paper, their time cards, in comparison to Fairly Were Standards Act and
[2:02:51] what our own policy said. So we ended up getting a whole 12 month, last 12 months crash course
[2:02:59] through all of our policy reviews. It's been exhausting. We've had just the ones that I've
[2:03:05] been invited to, 78 meetings, over 100 hours of time and meetings to talk about how we
[2:03:10] ourselves have some of the problems that we've had. Those are just the ones that I was involved
[2:03:13] and not what the whole finance team has been involved in.
[2:03:16] So, Jeannie.
[2:03:20] Good evening.
[2:03:22] So, I'm going to show you what the managers see when they log into this system.
[2:03:40] And some of the tools this will provide, as managers are trying to keep track of overtime,
[2:03:45] we have a widget that allows them to see anybody who's clocked in who's approaching overtime,
[2:03:50] provides them with a widget of overtime that has already been earned that needs to be approved.
[2:03:55] It also lets them know when employees have requested time off.
[2:03:58] There are some other alerts if somebody forgot to punch in or approval that are required.
[2:04:07] We're hoping it will be a useful tool, not just in actually improving time, which they
[2:04:11] can do on a daily basis if they choose to, rather than waiting for the end of the time
[2:04:15] card when somebody has in a paper time card, and they're trying to look through and approve
[2:04:19] time that's happened two weeks ago.
[2:04:21] They can actually go in and they can view hours that are being clocked on a regular
[2:04:25] basis.
[2:04:35] Time is easy.
[2:04:36] It's just clicking the little button.
[2:04:39] have the ability to add notes to time segments, the supervisors can then read,
[2:04:42] supervisors can add notes as well, and it just gives them an overall view or
[2:04:47] picture of everything that's happening within the system. There are also some
[2:04:51] reporting features, I'm not going to go into that. I think it's not long. I'll try
[2:04:56] to keep it as brief as I can. So that is the supervisors are seeing. They also
[2:05:03] have an opportunity to go and look and see who's clocked in, who isn't, and we're
[2:05:07] also working on a demand scheduler piece that hasn't been rolled out yet, then we
[2:05:11] hope is going to be of great benefit to supervisors and our two employees. Employees
[2:05:29] are able to record their time one of three ways. They can use a physical time
[2:05:32] clock that's mounted to the wall. There is a mobile app and there is the web clock.
[2:05:36] This is the web clock. This dashboard is brand new. We just rolled that out on
[2:05:40] Friday. There is a section for messages. Right now we're using this as a reminder
[2:05:46] for open enrollment for health insurance. Probably also use it for as a reminder
[2:05:50] for health screenings. We've added a link here to take you to Laserfish, which is how
[2:05:55] you fill out your open enrollments. We're trying to keep it all in one place. And see
[2:05:59] your hours here and make those adjustments. I'm sorry, make those approvals. You can see
[2:06:04] the leave request that you've submitted and what's pending or approved or denied. One
[2:06:09] of the biggest benefits I think is you can look and see your accruals at any time. Take
[2:06:15] out your last paste of, you can just log in hours. Police Department is using that for
[2:06:39] So over time notes, public works is using that for some call outs that happen after hours.
[2:06:44] And so we have some good response and positive feedback on that.
[2:06:48] If you want to request time, pretty easy, positive response on it.
[2:07:03] Now it is just as easy as clock in.
[2:07:05] Read your messages if you have any or what you're clocking into.
[2:07:11] And the same for clock in my office.
[2:07:28] It would be absolutely remiss if I did not acknowledge and thank Janie for her efforts.
[2:07:46] She has been the lead on this project.
[2:07:49] She has taken tremendous amount of time in terms of testing,
[2:07:54] rolling out the program, making sure that it is accurate,
[2:07:58] working on weekends, late on days off,
[2:08:02] trying to make sure that the desires of the departments
[2:08:06] and their individual practices are incorporated in a system
[2:08:10] that was not designed for the level of complexity
[2:08:12] of what we are running in this operation.
[2:08:16] she's remarkable. I will tell you that last year the city of Nampa, and actually the chief
[2:08:22] of police told me this, so the city of Nampa rolled out an electronic digital timekeeping
[2:08:27] system and their CFO and HR director were terminated because of the multiple problems,
[2:08:35] the cost, and the ultimate dissatisfaction with the product. So I credit with Janie was
[2:08:42] saving my job and I'm glad it was a finance project. I'm throwing the orient to the bus.
[2:08:51] So I did mention the FLSA compliance and historical practices have been somewhat different. We
[2:08:58] are trying to bring those as close together as we can. We've had to put out a lot of training.
[2:09:04] We've had to put out a lot of refreshers for supervisors. It's been a pretty major undertaking
[2:09:11] for the organization, and it's been well received.
[2:09:16] It's a huge change, and any change is uncomfortable.
[2:09:21] So I want to talk tonight a little bit
[2:09:22] about being the employer of choice.
[2:09:24] So this is the last header of the three topics.
[2:09:32] We know that as an organization
[2:09:34] we want to be the employer of choice.
[2:09:36] We want this to be a destination site
[2:09:38] where our community looks to us to lead
[2:09:41] in employment practices, where we're able
[2:09:43] to recruit excellent talent, where we're able
[2:09:46] to fill positions with the best that we absolutely can to serve the organization in our community.
[2:09:54] I want to talk and highlight one of the real difficulties that we're having because I think
[2:09:58] it speaks to some of the stuff that we're trying to still get passed.
[2:10:05] In 2018, the legislature, legislation that just slates her, pass a new stricter requirements
[2:10:17] for emergency communication officers, both in terms of the selection, the certification,
[2:10:22] and the training for those positions.
[2:10:26] When we look at that, staffing in order to be compliant with those has become a huge operational
[2:10:33] concern.
[2:10:34] It's become the most difficult position for us to recruit for.
[2:10:38] Since we reopened the dispatch center in 2003, and I'm not exaggerating, I've been here since
[2:10:45] then.
[2:10:46] We have been fully staffed on two occasions.
[2:10:51] It has gotten even worse in the last year.
[2:10:56] Since December 1st, we've had 230 applicants for the open positions in the dispatch center.
[2:11:04] From those, we were able to hire five as qualified.
[2:11:08] Any application that comes in, we move forward.
[2:11:11] We don't turn them down because we don't like their application.
[2:11:14] that comes in the door starts in our process. Of 230, we were able to hire five. Of the five
[2:11:21] that we've hired since December 1st, one remains. We have lost all of the others in the training
[2:11:29] phases. We have four vacant positions now in dispatch. Of those people that are there
[2:11:40] that have been there for at least a year, the seven of those people have averaged 230
[2:11:46] hours of overtime in 10 months. As a center, the total number of overtime hours equal
[2:11:56] 50% of patrol uniform in just gross hours. I'm not exactly sure, but I'd be willing to
[2:12:04] say there are 40 people working patrol that have twice as much overtime as seven people
[2:12:11] in dispatch. That's a staggering number. When I was talking to Deputy City Manager Pike
[2:12:19] earlier today, he said to me, it's become a sweatshop.
[2:12:28] And I didn't think about that phrase until he said that.
[2:12:32] But it's no longer fun for those people
[2:12:35] that are trying to cover such a huge workload
[2:12:37] and such a heavy burden and cover all of the hours
[2:12:42] for people that we can't hire.
[2:12:46] In result of change to the 2018 status change
[2:12:51] to emergency communications officer,
[2:12:53] we increased them from a grade seven to a grade nine,
[2:12:56] which was a significant financial move.
[2:12:58] We felt it was necessary, it was very competitive,
[2:13:02] and we still are having trouble.
[2:13:05] It is absolutely the biggest organizational challenge
[2:13:10] that we have for HR.
[2:13:15] We have had people that have worked in their in-light duty.
[2:13:18] Those people have helped significantly.
[2:13:20] They're rotating back out.
[2:13:22] We are trying and looking at all sorts of different options
[2:13:26] of ways that we can try to staff the center.
[2:13:28] But I want to bring it to your attention
[2:13:30] because the people that are working in the center now
[2:13:34] are working in some pretty rough conditions.
[2:13:41] In order to help with that recruitment effort,
[2:13:43] Kristin, the awesome recruitment coordinator,
[2:13:48] has been working and trying to figure out
[2:13:49] how are we going to shake the tree?
[2:13:51] How do we get different people?
[2:13:52] Same tactics won't work.
[2:13:53] How do we move forward?
[2:13:55] Oh, this has sound.
[2:14:02] No, Josh Palmer needed.
[2:14:20] So that is going to be it before the movies starts this month.
[2:14:24] So we're hoping to target a whole new group of applicants
[2:14:29] who maybe had not thought about that and are lost.
[2:14:54] So organizationally, our recruitment efforts,
[2:14:57] we talked last year about the investment
[2:15:00] that you have made both in terms of the salary table
[2:15:03] and compensation, health insurance increases facilities
[2:15:07] that you have improved and continue to build on.
[2:15:12] We've seen great results as an outcome
[2:15:15] of those investments that you've made.
[2:15:17] Our organizational recruitment for this past fiscal year,
[2:15:21] just the last 10 months, we've had 1,051 applications
[2:15:25] for 24 different processes,
[2:15:28] fired an onboarded 32 new regular employees,
[2:15:31] 65 part-time or full-time seasonal positions,
[2:15:35] that's in parks, Durkeys Lake, the pool, I should make that lastly, these are the
[2:15:57] current recruitment processes that are either going right now or set to go
[2:16:02] within the next 30 to 45 days. So in addition to everything else we've already
[2:16:06] done, this is what's currently on the plate. The fire captain testing is running
[2:16:14] this week. We have to post the hazardous device unit which is the bomb squad for
[2:16:19] patrol or for police. It's a really big workload. Each applicant that comes into the
[2:16:31] department and the organization comes to laser-fishing. It's an electronic process
[2:16:35] now, but all of them require a response. We believe in providing customer service
[2:16:41] and Kristen works tremendously hard to make sure that she is reaching out and
[2:16:45] not losing talent that's interested in coming here because they're in process
[2:16:50] and sometimes particularly for our public safety teams,
[2:16:53] hiring takes a while.
[2:16:55] There's a lot of steps people can get frustrated
[2:16:58] and it's easier to go someplace else
[2:17:00] where they can get hired faster.
[2:17:01] So it's a constant priority that we have to work towards.
[2:17:08] Okay, this is the last slide for me.
[2:17:12] One of the things that is also part of being employer of choice
[2:17:16] is making sure that employees feel valued, respected,
[2:17:20] and are safe in our workplaces, our work sites.
[2:17:24] We will be conducting a respectful workplace training
[2:17:28] on August 20th and 21st.
[2:17:30] I sent to you all an email inviting you to participate
[2:17:33] both in that and in the open insurance meetings.
[2:17:36] If you're welcome, you're welcome to attend any of those
[2:17:38] if you'd like to.
[2:17:39] We're happy to have you participate in that.
[2:17:45] We believe part of the respectful workplace training
[2:17:47] is making sure that our supervisors
[2:17:49] in our employees understand that it's beyond just their legal obligations, that we have
[2:17:57] a higher mission and value that we place towards making sure that we are including everyone
[2:18:03] within the organization and treating them fairly.
[2:18:07] So that will be part of the way that Respectful Replays Training.
[2:18:10] It's with legal and compliance, but it is also, there's a higher standard, and we want to make
[2:18:15] sure that all of our employees understand that.
[2:18:19] In addition to the compensation recruitment, the health, we also need to make sure that
[2:18:25] we have up-to-date policies that reflect current practices and that reach out to our employees
[2:18:31] in their current needs in the year 2020.
[2:18:36] One of the things that we developed this last year was the Compassionate Leave Bank.
[2:18:39] The leadership team of the organization worked on this for quite a while, and this is designed
[2:18:46] places like when people do not have any leave available, and how they can be
[2:18:52] supported, how we can support them as an organization as they transition through
[2:18:56] some very significant crisis. The last thing that I just want to talk about is
[2:19:06] what we haven't accomplished. And I bring this up because if you go through
[2:19:15] the budget and you look at the HR narrative, you'll see some things that
[2:19:19] We're on their last year that are kind of repeated.
[2:19:21] And I wanted to explain why is a department of let you down.
[2:19:29] So we don't put in the budget process, trucks, equipment
[2:19:37] typically.
[2:19:39] What we typically use are man hours.
[2:19:43] And just like other departments within the organization,
[2:19:47] we've requested a position for the last couple of years.
[2:19:50] that has not been funded.
[2:19:53] This year, for the first time, we're
[2:19:56] starting to contract our work.
[2:19:59] We're doing that because the day-to-day functions of the things
[2:20:03] that we're doing are big and time-consuming.
[2:20:08] And it's taking away the opportunity
[2:20:10] to work on major city objectives and things
[2:20:15] that we need to do in order to move forward
[2:20:17] on the strategic plan.
[2:20:20] So, it was a difficult decision to make,
[2:20:24] resourcing and hiring company to do all of the
[2:20:28] supervisor training, to do all of the
[2:20:33] respectful workplace training, was a big decision.
[2:20:37] And it costly one.
[2:20:39] Some of the things that I think are important
[2:20:41] for us to be focusing on that we have yet to tackle,
[2:20:45] essentially come under knowledge and competencies
[2:20:48] will be communicated and opportunities will be created
[2:20:50] to help prepare and mentor employees.
[2:20:54] Growing our leaders from within
[2:20:57] is a critical strategic objective
[2:20:59] in order to maintain leadership, maintain values,
[2:21:03] keep the trajectory of our organization
[2:21:05] moving up and forward.
[2:21:08] And what we don't have is right now
[2:21:11] on many levels by organizational leaders,
[2:21:14] time to mentor, time to really work with our employees.
[2:21:18] What are your deficiencies
[2:21:19] how can we move you forward? What do you want to do? You hate planning? Great, let's get you into HVAR, it's awesome.
[2:21:26] Anyway, there's just little things like that that is a challenge for all of our department leaders.
[2:21:34] It's one of the objectives that we have yet to tackle, but I want to share that with you because I think one of the things that we get frustrated by
[2:21:41] is when our own talent isn't ready to assume positions when they come forward.
[2:21:45] And that's a real frustration that all of us share.
[2:21:48] It's also one of the biggest goals to try to move forward with and frequently interrupted
[2:21:56] by the fires that we put out daily.
[2:21:59] So the one piece that is in Focus Area 8 for internal organization and capital requests
[2:22:08] is some equipment for the employee exercise room.
[2:22:11] It continues to make improvements all the time.
[2:22:14] This is for updated weights, for updated temporary storage lockers.
[2:22:19] This is for new benches for people to sit on while they're kind of rotating through the
[2:22:25] weight stations.
[2:22:26] This is not a facility remodel.
[2:22:27] This is simply to upgrade equipment.
[2:22:33] These are some other pieces that are within Folks Area 8 internal organization and capital
[2:22:38] requests.
[2:22:39] Some of these we've already talked about and I believe that's my last slide.
[2:22:45] Thank you very much.
[2:22:46] So we're resorting these things but these are really the parts and pieces that help our
[2:23:03] employees be successful.
[2:23:05] Several of these items have been communicated throughout the entire part of the budget,
[2:23:09] and the most significant being the $1.5 million project for the CAD system that we intend to use
[2:23:15] cash reserves to build, move forward.
[2:23:17] So a lot of these things, and now Kathy Marcus is here, she could share on any of these items,
[2:23:22] but really what it is, is it's designed to make sure that our folks have the tools and
[2:23:26] the technology needed to be able to work smarter, as opposed to not always working harder.
[2:23:36] So again, we share that end of the story for where this budget stands.
[2:23:42] We believe that this is a sustainable budget throughout the entire conversation.
[2:23:48] You have seen significant lists of capital items that were not funded.
[2:23:52] You saw significant positions that were passed, Gretchen talked about what does that look
[2:23:57] like?
[2:23:58] And while our economy continues to remain robust and while we're continuing to advance one
[2:24:08] One of the most important things when we start looking at this budget is can we carry that
[2:24:14] forward into an unknown future?
[2:24:17] And so, admittedly, we do take a conservative approach, but what we want to do is we want
[2:24:21] to make sure that the decisions that we make today don't create benefits rollercoaster
[2:24:26] for our employees, or we hire employees and we're not able to maintain that employment
[2:24:32] because they're of an down turn economy.
[2:24:34] So, we have staff judiciously.
[2:24:37] We look at capital very conservatively and we require all of the members of our team to
[2:24:44] go through a series of process review we're adding employees is that last choice because
[2:24:51] that employee that we add, well it's important to be part of the member of our team, it is
[2:24:56] the one thing that is ongoing and permanent.
[2:25:00] We think about the City of Twin Falls and you think about how large is our employee.
[2:25:04] of the base, again we have 312 full-time positions inside of the city. What's
[2:25:10] important about that number is that it's population we serve every single day is
[2:25:16] far greater than 50,000. Every single day our community grows to somewhere
[2:25:21] between 85 and 90,000 people and then when you throw in an event it can exceed
[2:25:26] 100,000 people. There are 312 people that serve that entire population 24 hours a
[2:25:33] seven days a week, and when you take a look at our employee counts and comparison to other
[2:25:39] organizations, we are incredibly lean, and sometimes being too lean can cause its own
[2:25:46] collection of inefficiencies, some of which Gretchen had discussed. We're also kind of going
[2:25:53] through a time in which we are making sure that our compensation packages are incredibly
[2:25:59] competitive in this budget you'll notice that there's a 3%
[2:26:02] compensation adjustment for our employees and we're also doing what we
[2:26:07] can to maintain health insurance but health insurance in our organization has
[2:26:13] gone up threefold just in a period of time where I think it's like 2000 and it
[2:26:24] has gone up for a family threefold we budget full insurance for our employees
[2:26:31] is for their families and at one point in time in our organization we said that
[2:26:36] cost would be roughly a third in some cases today the benefit package are 50%
[2:26:42] and it is part of the world that we're moving forward on that's why we're so
[2:26:49] focused on employee wellness making sure that our experience rate which drives
[2:26:54] our health insurance costs is something that remains the great
[2:27:04] and we don't always have all of the resources that we need to be successful, our times in
[2:27:22] which we're not able to accomplish all of the goals that we play forward, but every single
[2:27:28] year we become a little bit more one city and we try to drive to create an organization
[2:27:36] that wants to be that player choice that tracks people to us.
[2:27:41] So really, this is the last conversation that we will have with the budget that is largely
[2:27:52] employee-driven.
[2:27:55] We have shared every aspect of this budget, and now we turn this over to you for your thoughtful
[2:28:01] conversation and discussion for the next three weeks.
[2:28:07] Next week, we are going to ask you to adopt the preliminary budget.
[2:28:12] And just as a matter of refresher, that preliminary budget is the maximum
[2:28:18] spending cap that you will set. And sometimes in the past the council has said
[2:28:26] there may be projects we want to continue to have a conversation about, so we're
[2:28:30] going to include the entire foregone balance into this budget. In the event that
[2:28:36] you choose to do that, we do have to have a special public hearing date now
[2:28:41] recognized by code and staff will be prepared to have that foregone resolution
[2:28:47] public hearing ready to be published. Should that be the direction that you
[2:28:50] choose to go? If not, we will have just one public hearing in which we will set
[2:28:56] that for August, evening of August 26th in which we'll move forward and adopt the
[2:29:01] budget, but really the next three meetings are really driven by you to
[2:29:06] to help answer any questions that you have
[2:29:10] to continue to build your comfort level with the budget.
[2:29:14] One thing that would help staff to make sure
[2:29:16] that we have the right member in the audience
[2:29:19] is that give us an indication of what your questions
[2:29:22] will be in advance of that
[2:29:24] so that we can have the right staff member here
[2:29:26] to be able to engage you and thoughtfully
[2:29:28] answer the question to make the best consumer time.
[2:29:32] So with that, we would certainly stand for any questions
[2:29:34] that you have tonight.
[2:29:35] and not we look forward to continuing conversations
[2:29:39] for the balance of the month.
[2:29:41] Could you have us any questions?
[2:29:43] Who's talking to me?
[2:29:44] Very general one.
[2:29:52] Construction or changes to the property
[2:29:54] with an area of impact, of course,
[2:29:56] or directed guided by our zoning rules in that particular area.
[2:30:02] But until the area's actually brought into the,
[2:30:04] to the corporate boundaries,
[2:30:07] there are no property taxes levied on areas of impact.
[2:30:12] There are no city, that's correct.
[2:30:14] Yeah, the city taxable value is only within our specific corporate boundary.
[2:30:21] I put that out for the public to hear, I write the queries and I just want to get the word out.
[2:30:26] Yes.
[2:30:27] Actually, property is not being used for.
[2:30:30] That's right.
[2:30:33] I don't see any more questions, right?
[2:30:41] From the public who wishes to, I haven't done the budget.
[2:30:48] The opportunity of both who says non-city employees citizens.
[2:31:02] All right, seeing no one, we uh, agenda again to bring teams in the presentation night.
[2:31:16] All right, so where are we here in the agenda?
[2:31:19] The bad part of moving things around.
[2:31:21] So one more opportunity for general public input if anyone would like to visit with the council,
[2:31:27] let an item not on the agenda tonight.
[2:31:29] Move on to advisory report reports from the council.
[2:31:36] Grab us anything from the city manager's office.
[2:31:45] Just in an effort to continue uh, communicating um, with the citizens who may be watching.
[2:31:51] Next week we will, part of our conversation, engaging in the topic of recycling.
[2:31:56] Understand the will of the council and to receive input from the citizens that will be starting around six o'clock on the 12th and then on the 19th.
[2:32:10] Staff and citizens community will come back and present a series of possible options to continue the discussion about fire stations and the result of the opportunities moving forward.
[2:32:31] It's National Night Out this week is our Night Chief Kingsbury's here in the audience and he can
[2:32:39] share all the festivities. Make this council meeting go a little bit longer. Thank you Mayor
[2:32:52] Councilor. Yes, tomorrow evening National Night Out a great opportunity for members of the community
[2:32:58] to come down to City Park and interact with law enforcement first responders. A brother at the
[2:33:03] fire department will be there and we'll have all our toys, bells and whistles and probably most
[2:33:08] Importantly hot dogs who will have hot dogs? So come on down. Good time to start 36 o'clock
[2:33:21] Alright, something else we do have a request for a chair run tonight to executive session under Idaho Code 74206 1b
[2:33:31] Instead of the evaluation dismissal or disciplining of or to your complaints
[2:33:35] Or charges brought against a public officer
[2:33:38] Please staff member or individual agent or public school a student Ruth Pierce
[2:33:44] Yes, I move we move into executive session under Code Section 74-2061B.
[2:33:51] I'm Nikki Boyd, motion by repair, seconded by Nikki Boyd to adjourn to executive session as presented.
[2:33:59] Is there any discussion?
[2:34:01] Need me a roll call vote please.
[2:34:05] Nikki Boyd?
[2:34:07] Yes.
[2:34:08] Suzanne Hawkins?
[2:34:09] Yeah.
[2:34:10] Greg Lane?
[2:34:11] Sorry.
[2:34:12] Ruth Pierce?
[2:34:13] Yes.
[2:34:14] Christopher Reed?
[2:34:15] Yes.
[2:34:16] Chris Tockington?
[2:34:17] Yes.
[2:34:18] Motion passes 6-0.
[2:34:20] Just let everyone know we will not be reconvening following the Executive Session.
[2:34:25] Or will we be making any decisions in the Executive Session?
[2:34:29] And with that the meeting is adjourned.
