Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2018-07-02, recording 1 (started 17:00)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2018-07-02/

[0:00:17] July 2nd for the City of Twin Falls City Council.
[0:00:20] At a vice mayor, there are no amendments to the agenda, and as Mr. Humble shared with you
[0:01:09] last week, I understand that Idaho Code has changed, and in which an agenda can be urgency
[0:01:30] is to show, look at that section.
[0:01:45] That said, Idaho Code also does have another requirement that five members are present any
[0:01:50] time in which the City Council is going to go into executive session.
[0:01:54] And since there are only four of you here this evening, you will not be able to get into executive session.
[0:02:01] It's not necessarily an amendment to the agenda. You just simply do not have the nurse present tonight at adjournment to witness somebody.
[0:04:10] Second.
[0:04:27] Where's Piers? Yes.
[0:04:28] Mr. Fareed? Yes.
[0:04:30] Where's talking to? Yes.
[0:04:41] Consideration.
[0:06:12] I'm not serving alcom, not expect 500 orville, but I still have four veterans.
[0:07:32] City staff, what are their fees are associated with this?
[0:07:48] So thank you.
[0:07:49] We wish that staff had a push to talk button as well,
[0:07:52] because there are a thing that, first thing we'd like to say
[0:07:55] is the staff is entirely supportive
[0:07:57] of the requests in the event.
[0:07:59] The fee resolution that was created
[0:08:01] doesn't allow for the city staff to waive the fee.
[0:08:04] It says that this is the fee that will be assessed.
[0:08:07] It was approved by the city council,
[0:08:08] so city staff doesn't have capacity to waive here
[0:08:15] this evening, okay, yes,
[0:08:20] because she's going to have to exceed Tammy's expectations
[0:08:33] and have that the core system is going to city staff.
[0:08:47] It's an application fee that we are processed.
[0:08:52] Aside from that, you might have some incidental trash collections
[0:08:55] that we don't see.
[0:09:48] Ruth Pierce?
[0:09:49] Yes.
[0:10:21] Appreciate you guys' time tonight.
[0:10:23] I think for the most part, tourism has been doing fantastic,
[0:10:26] but I'd like to give an annual update so that you guys have
[0:10:30] all the details and the numbers behind it as well.
[0:10:32] So, for our region, we are the fifth largest industry.
[0:10:35] It is the third largest in the state,
[0:10:36] so it is a big industry.
[0:10:38] We do not have any regional collections as of January.
[0:10:42] However, we will get our new collections
[0:10:44] and those numbers in July,
[0:10:46] so hopefully the next couple of weeks.
[0:10:48] But at this point, all I can report is that we are up 7%.
[0:10:52] With that said, we did have a low snow year,
[0:10:54] so for the most part, those months
[0:10:56] within the winter time,
[0:10:58] we're probably a little bit more down
[0:11:00] than what we would normally see,
[0:11:01] So we're probably going to be more towards the 10% and 12% increase, which is fantastic,
[0:11:06] and something that we've been kind of tracking on for the past couple of years.
[0:11:09] So for the past three years, we've been about 10 plus percent, and so I hate to interrupt you now.
[0:11:15] Yes, sir, anyway, it's fabulous information. I feel like our audience, actually, do you guys like to see it?
[0:11:40] I appreciate that because I know there's a lot of numbers and statistics to be able to see it.
[0:12:06] So, for the fiscal year 2017, we had about 45.9 million in sales for our region, so when
[0:12:15] you break that down and you go a little bit deeper to just Twin Falls County, because
[0:12:18] that's where they regionally break down to, is by county, you look at county year 2017
[0:12:24] and Twin Falls County is sitting at about $31.3 million, so definitely good numbers
[0:12:30] on that end.
[0:12:31] the comparison between that and the previous year, it's 26.9 million, so we've had a pretty
[0:12:38] significant growth that's reflected in the regional collections as well. I think Twin Falls County
[0:12:43] sits a little bit higher than some of our other counties. It does reflect the bigger portion of
[0:12:48] what our collections are. Twin Falls is the hub of our region. It's seven counties. I don't know if
[0:12:54] you guys are familiar with those, but essentially the Magic Valley without Wood River. I know sometimes
[0:12:59] people in Cliff Price, that you were actually a little bit lower than that, so
[0:13:36] these numbers are probably what they should be. Typically, it's about an
[0:13:40] $86 fee, but Twin Falls, the ADR has gone up significantly, and we're seeing
[0:13:46] somewhere around the lines up too. When you take that in, we look at about
[0:13:56] 313,000 visitors and overnight stays. Roger Brooks, who we had come and do a
[0:14:02] presentation, has a formula that kind of takes into consideration all the
[0:14:06] the different spending habits.
[0:14:08] So for their example, these are people who come in,
[0:14:12] spend the night, and then they shop in.
[0:14:14] All of our retail stores, things along those lines,
[0:14:17] as well as gas stations and other places.
[0:14:20] And on average, they spend about $231 per overnight stay.
[0:14:24] So when you take the 313,000 people
[0:14:27] and you take that $231, we're looking at about $72 million
[0:14:31] that are being spent in our communities.
[0:14:34] So there's a really big impact out of that.
[0:14:37] And while sometimes people don't think necessarily
[0:14:40] that tourism affects them, it is paying
[0:14:42] some other person's wage, and it will affect
[0:14:45] the trickle down, and it's nice to have
[0:14:46] that outside investment.
[0:14:48] It does take resources from the city,
[0:14:51] so we very much appreciate your guys' dedication
[0:14:54] to tourism.
[0:14:55] The city of Twin Falls and Shoshan Falls
[0:14:58] are a really great example of that good synergy.
[0:15:01] The city takes fantastic care about park,
[0:15:04] and it's our number one tourism draw,
[0:15:06] so we wouldn't be able to do that without their help,
[0:15:08] so we very much appreciate that.
[0:15:11] To kind of give you an update on some of the campaigns
[0:15:14] that we've been pushing, we did do a brand refresh,
[0:15:17] excuse me, so we took all of our website collateral
[0:15:21] and magazines, ads, things along those lines,
[0:15:24] and refresh them, brought in new imagery
[0:15:26] that really reflected what we had to offer here.
[0:15:28] A lot of the things that we had before
[0:15:29] were a little bit dated,
[0:15:30] and this really kind of gives us a fresh new outlook.
[0:15:33] And we also recategorize our website so that way people can go and actually find the activities
[0:15:38] that they're looking for based on the type or time of year so it's not as hard to get through.
[0:15:45] And by doing that it allowed us to collect more information about them as they come and
[0:15:50] search our website.
[0:15:51] So if they click through on, for example, the first three are top four different categories.
[0:15:56] We have national parks, events, hot springs, and water sports.
[0:16:02] So we can actually gauge how much time they spend on each page, which ones they click through
[0:16:06] to.
[0:16:07] And we have a lot of really good in-depth information on all the different people that visit our website,
[0:16:12] so that way we have a better idea of who our target audience is.
[0:16:15] And so we can best use that information to hopefully bring more people here as we kind of
[0:16:20] grow our tourism outlook.
[0:16:23] With that, we did two main focuses before we kind of had a broad spectrum, as you may know
[0:16:29] or probably know.
[0:16:30] So the Idaho has a lot to offer.
[0:16:32] It's very diverse in its recreation, and we tend to focus on that leisure traveler.
[0:16:37] But we really wanted to make sure that we took the top two and put those things forth,
[0:16:42] and then drew them in with the additional add-on type of things.
[0:16:46] So those two are national park properties.
[0:16:49] So City of Rocks, Hagerman Fossil Beds, Minidoka National Historic Site, and Creators of the
[0:16:54] Moon.
[0:16:55] Creators is partially in our region, so we don't focus on them as much, but they are a huge
[0:16:59] draw and bring in a lot of international tourism.
[0:17:02] as well as waterfalls and waterways.
[0:17:06] So kind of the heart of our area is based on the Snake River.
[0:17:09] We have many, many different waterfalls
[0:17:11] and it brings in a lot of travelers
[0:17:13] that are looking to mark these different water for lists.
[0:17:16] And it's a great picturesque look.
[0:17:20] So we get a lot of the Instagrammers and the influencers
[0:17:23] that are really interested in these things.
[0:17:24] So it's important to promote those.
[0:17:26] So then they kind of help promote building effect.
[0:17:34] With the placements that we've had,
[0:17:35] we did purchase the cover of the AAA magazine.
[0:17:38] That was a big placement in something
[0:17:40] that the state helped co-op for us.
[0:17:42] We're in many different advertisements
[0:17:44] with a couple that I'll call out or trip up,
[0:17:46] or excuse me, Alaska Air.
[0:17:47] We co-op that with CEDU and actually did a joint advertisement
[0:17:52] that allowed us to look at not only tourism,
[0:17:54] but also what it would mean to attract talent.
[0:17:57] That was the first advertorial that we had experienced
[0:18:00] before, and I believe on CEDU's part as well.
[0:18:03] Alaska Air provides a very captive audience.
[0:18:06] They can't go very many places,
[0:18:08] and their readership is pretty robust.
[0:18:10] So we felt like that was a good IN plus it provided co-op on the states level as well.
[0:18:15] So you can read through the rest of those there.
[0:18:17] We obviously as a marketing organization, we place a lot of ads.
[0:18:20] So that's our primary purpose.
[0:18:23] We did hire a new social media manager.
[0:18:25] I absolutely recommend going out and taking a look at our Facebook pages and Instagram.
[0:18:30] She has done an amazing job and has just increased engagement.
[0:18:34] We picked up a lot of interest off of the lights and lasers.
[0:18:37] Excuse me. And from there, she's just built on that momentum and kept it going, so we're
[0:18:42] very, very happy with that. For the fiscal year 17 grant, these are some of the projects
[0:18:48] that we've been working on. We did finish up a brand USA video. Those will be completed
[0:18:53] probably in September, and we essentially watched some people jump off the prime bridge.
[0:18:58] We did some kayaking. It's really targeted toward the international market, so they're
[0:19:02] going to be translating this itinerary into multiple languages and brand USA will you
[0:19:07] be using that in an international market to help bring people to our area.
[0:19:11] So another great co-op, we split it with several different regions on the state, and then Brand
[0:19:15] USA takes that message so we get all those assets, but then they get to use it to essentially
[0:19:20] promote us because that helps promote USA as well.
[0:19:23] So it was a fantastic partnership.
[0:19:25] We've brought in about 12 national journalists so far where this is a brand new thing for
[0:19:30] some kind of tourism.
[0:19:31] We did several during the winter months.
[0:19:33] It was kind of a juggling act with the snow levels because we had some back country scheduled
[0:19:38] and we had to kind of move things around.
[0:19:40] Luckily, we have good partners at Sun Valley and then Boise and so we'll see lots of good
[0:19:45] presses off of that as well with just, you know, people continuously coming here and talking
[0:19:49] about it.
[0:19:50] We are working on an influencer trip, which is the Instagrammer zone.
[0:19:53] That's kind of the new trend of people taking information from these almost celebrities
[0:19:59] that are on Instagram.
[0:20:00] So that will be coming up in September.
[0:20:02] Then I wanted to talk about, oh, next one, Sunset Magazine, we did submit for kayaking under the bridge, and it was a finalist. They'll be announced in July, so that's going to be great.
[0:20:13] Regardless whether we win or not, we will still be featured in their magazine as one of those top locations.
[0:20:19] Sunset has a great following and is very well respected within the travel world.
[0:20:25] Lights and Lasers, that was a first time event for us. We felt like it went pretty well.
[0:20:30] The first evening was a little rough, I will say that, you know,
[0:20:33] without knowing where certain things fit and how all of the logistics were going to work out.
[0:20:37] It wasn't to my expectations, so that was hard, but for the most part I think, you know,
[0:20:42] we had a fantastic show. I do know that if we continue on next year, the show itself will
[0:20:48] probably change pretty significantly. Without ever doing it again, you know, we didn't really
[0:20:52] know what to expect, so I'd like to see a little more depth, some storyline to it, maybe more
[0:20:57] lights rather than just lasers. So there's lots of tweaks that will be made, but for the
[0:21:02] most part, you know, it brought a lot of attention to show some falls into our area.
[0:21:07] Most of the conversations were positive. There were a few complaints because of things that
[0:21:10] were, you know, not capable of making better at that certain point. But we definitely did
[0:21:15] our best to make sure that everyone was taken care of. But for the most part, we brought it
[0:21:20] in 4,500 people. Sold out the last two nights, you know, it was a fantastic community event
[0:21:26] as well as a tourism event. We had lots of people locally as well as from many
[0:21:30] different parts of the area. Filled many of the hotels, they got involved, gave away
[0:21:35] tickets, did different things on those lines, which you'll see with lots of
[0:21:39] different events that we have that happen in our valley. But for the most part, and
[0:21:43] I would be happy to answer any questions about it as well, because the city was a
[0:21:46] huge partner in making that happen. And I owe a lot to the police department and to
[0:21:51] fire and Parks and Rec when he was especially helpful. So we will evaluate in August and let
[0:21:58] you know for sure, but most likely it'll be the same weekend if we end up doing it again,
[0:22:02] because hopefully water flows will be in efforts with the city. However, we can support that
[0:22:16] as obviously our priority. The things as I did attach a study that we did late last year
[0:22:25] about business travel. I'll let you guys go through that. It's important to know that
[0:22:28] business travel is a rising trend. As we see more businesses come here, you know, the need
[0:22:34] for meeting rooms and conference space will be increasingly important. So hopefully those
[0:22:39] conversations can continue. You'll see through that report that there's some significant
[0:22:46] employers that were part of that that see their growth being exponential, which is pretty fantastic.
[0:22:51] It also means a lot of great things for the airport too. And then the last one we brought
[0:22:55] in the far west ag conference back to Twin Falls, which is a big one that will happen
[0:22:59] in January and the hotel years are very pleased about that.
[0:23:02] So that just shows you the power of conferences.
[0:23:05] They're not necessarily weather based, so it's a lot better to have that cyclical event
[0:23:09] to plan on.
[0:23:10] You know, when we have a bad winter, you know, it's kind of hard for the hotels to
[0:23:16] plan on their sales being as good as they were in previous years.
[0:23:20] Finally, in the fiscal year 18 grant, which is next year, some of the things that we're
[0:23:25] kind of planning on our event seating. So we would like to see as you guys can kind of
[0:23:30] tell with the criterion and some music festivals that are happening and even with stretch front
[0:23:35] falls, the lights and lasers event, it brings in a lot of people and it has a lot of buzz
[0:23:39] around it. So what we'd like to see is not necessarily supporting previous events, we'll
[0:23:45] still do that of course, but we want to really try and help bring more events that will put
[0:23:49] a lot of our sponsorship funds into new things. So for those events that maybe couldn't find
[0:23:54] first-year sponsors, hopefully we'd be able to kind of fulfill that gap and really
[0:23:59] get them off the ground and then continue them on with resources and a
[0:24:02] committee to help them figure out how to move on. They will have certain criteria
[0:24:06] that have to be met, that it has to bring in tourism, so on and so forth, but we would
[0:24:10] like to see more things happen. I actually feel like Twin Falls County
[0:24:13] especially has a lot of room for growth there, so I think the criteria is a great
[0:24:18] place that we're feeling that momentum and it's just going to continue to grow
[0:24:21] off of that too. And then we're gonna look at a lot more athletic events and my
[0:24:27] hope this next year is we've been pretty broad about our marketing. We hit many
[0:24:32] different targets and granted they're all performing extremely well. We make sure
[0:24:36] that they're you know have good ROI. However I think that the price per
[0:24:41] conversion to get them to actually spend the night in twin files would be a lot
[0:24:45] easier and a lot lower price level if we were to target just Boise and just
[0:24:49] all like because we have a high conversion rate there already. It's just a quick drive
[0:24:54] time so we're going to spend the most of our money in those markets and build our tax
[0:25:00] base, you know, the 2% lodging collections and grants, even that much higher and then
[0:25:05] redistribute those back out so that we've got, if we're continuously growing and that's actually
[0:25:10] what McCall did several years ago and they've been overrun by tourists so we don't want to
[0:25:15] go that far but certainly in that level that I think those are kind of my biggest
[0:25:21] updates I will say that the grant continues to grow I mentioned that we've
[0:25:25] gone upwards of 10% each year so we're at this point we're at 353,000 that's
[0:25:31] purely spent on marketing so for you know operational costs match costs things
[0:25:35] like that we rely on the city's help and then chambers of commerce and several
[0:25:40] other private partners including our hospitality partners you're welcome to
[0:25:43] see through our board members. We have several from Twin Falls. Dan Homestead is our chair and
[0:25:49] he's obviously in Twin Falls but he represents a pretty wide area as well and I just again want
[0:25:55] to say thank you for everything the city has done. You guys have been wonderful to me and to the
[0:26:00] organization so with that I will stand for questions. How many dots? I know that you know as far as
[0:26:55] being part of that conversation we are very much a part of that and want to make sure that tourism
[0:27:00] as considered as influencer in those directions, especially when we're looking at talent attraction
[0:27:07] and things along those lines.
[0:27:09] I guess I'm not quite sure if we've looked specifically at what kind of socioeconomic investment
[0:27:16] that brings to our communities is something I would be more than happy to look at.
[0:27:19] I can't imagine that it would be something a slide, but I do know from the Twin Falls
[0:27:27] side as people become more aware of the area and have these tourism possibilities. The likelihood
[0:27:35] that they'll come here to live is a lot higher. A lot of times a person's first introduction
[0:27:40] to the community they're going to live in is their first tourism experience. So I guess
[0:27:45] it's just a matter of picking out those correct audiences, which is what we try to do to figure
[0:27:50] out how to bring those people that have the same type of recreational. We focus a lot
[0:27:56] of recreation, but also the socioeconomic placements that, you know, if we need somebody
[0:28:01] that's going to, for example, be employed by St. Luke's, you know, hopefully they have
[0:28:06] all of that correct interest that that way they want to stay here.
[0:28:10] Appreciate it. Thank you again.
[0:29:01] Well, thank you, Madam Vice-Counsel. It's always tough to follow a good presentation, you know.
[0:29:07] It's like, as you mentioned, this is a little follow-up of a conversation that we had.
[0:29:13] I wanted to say several weeks ago, but the truth is it was probably over a month ago.
[0:29:17] And I have right a whole team with me.
[0:29:19] I've got Courtney Cunningham, who will be
[0:29:22] number control officer, will be helping with the presentation.
[0:29:25] She'll kind of walk you through that process
[0:29:26] and show you what she deals with on a regular basis.
[0:29:29] I've shown and of course Shane on the legal side of it.
[0:29:32] So I'm hoping that if you, I'm hoping to answer your questions.
[0:29:36] I've also had conversations with Debbie Blackwood
[0:29:39] over at Petz talking very interesting.
[0:29:45] And maybe before I get started to kind of walk you through
[0:29:48] on how I got here with these numbers.
[0:29:51] It's just as easy as presenting you with a bunch of numbers.
[0:29:55] But it's not that easy.
[0:29:56] It's never that easy, isn't it?
[0:29:57] It's kind of like the citizenship.
[0:29:59] As you mentioned, the citizenship program,
[0:30:01] I was thinking one time, one day,
[0:30:02] I was having a conversation with Robin about this.
[0:30:05] And I googled the test for citizenship.
[0:30:08] If you haven't done that, Google that test
[0:30:09] and take the sample test and see how you do.
[0:30:13] I learned a lot about American history,
[0:30:14] but it's never, exactly.
[0:30:17] It's never as simple as you think it is.
[0:30:19] So I asked Candy Reynolds over the police department
[0:30:21] to run the numbers and to look for,
[0:30:23] But I was looking for mainly is all types that we've reported as vicious dogs, dogs at large and animal bite.
[0:30:34] I mean she did that and I asked her to go back for the last three years and provide me with some information.
[0:30:41] And then friends and I did a little date of my and what we found out is I'll give you a for instance.
[0:30:47] So to date when she generated that report, we had one is a 16 called types in 2018 that would fit into that range.
[0:30:56] But when you really looked at the call type, so this is the portion that the officers actually
[0:31:02] dictating what happened, but really had two situations out of the 16th, so it looked like
[0:31:07] what was much higher than what it really was.
[0:31:10] So, French and I talked a little bit about how we could present this to you in a way that
[0:31:14] would make sense.
[0:31:15] And so, what I want to try a little bit is maybe just to start tonight talking about the
[0:31:20] issue.
[0:31:21] I want to talk a little bit about some definitions.
[0:31:23] And then I'm going to have Courtney walk you through the process that she deals with.
[0:31:27] I know it's a daily basis, but before we get started, I just, a couple things I want to ask you,
[0:31:35] when you hear the term Vicious Dog, and the conversation that I want to have with you deals with numbers,
[0:31:40] and when we're dealing with statistics like anything else,
[0:31:43] statistics in this business are people. So I am not trying to, through any one's situation,
[0:31:53] I don't have any situation, but when you hear the term Vicious Dog, I want you to think, you know,
[0:32:06] what image comes to your mind. And I'm going to come back to that in a little bit,
[0:32:11] Because looking at the data, I think you'll be surprised
[0:32:13] if that vicious dog looks like.
[0:32:16] The other thing I'd like to do is maybe just walk you
[0:32:19] through some codes just so that you have an understanding
[0:32:21] that we have a city ordinance and we have state codes
[0:32:24] that apply here.
[0:32:26] So I want to talk a little bit about the city code
[0:32:27] and vicious dogs.
[0:32:29] And on our code, what it means is a vicious dog is this.
[0:32:35] By definition, a dog that has a bitten, clawed,
[0:32:38] or otherwise armed, or constitutes a physical threat.
[0:32:42] or a dog who's temperament or habits in danger or a menace any person or any other animal without provocation by such person or animal.
[0:32:51] This term shall not include a dog that bites, attacks or a menace is a person or other animal that has tormented or injured the dog.
[0:33:00] So that's our city code on Fishes that would be how we would define a vicious dog.
[0:33:05] The state code is a little different in that it breaks down.
[0:33:10] If I get this wrong, I'll leave them help if I get out of it.
[0:33:17] Staycode uses two terms.
[0:33:19] An at-risk dog, and it defines an at-risk dog, is any dog that without justification.
[0:33:25] A revocation bites a person without causing serious injury.
[0:33:31] It's defined as an at-risk dog.
[0:33:34] So if the staycode, if the dog has been someone, and it hasn't been provoked, it's considered
[0:33:41] at-risk.
[0:33:42] The state further defines a dangerous dog as a dog that without a provocation is inflicted
[0:33:49] serious injury on a person or has been previously found to be at risk or at risk and therefore
[0:33:56] bites are physically attacks in person without justification.
[0:34:02] The justified provocation really means to perform and act that a reasonable person
[0:34:09] knowledge a dog behavior will conclude as likely to precipitate a dog.
[0:34:15] If you're torturing, if you're menacing a dog,
[0:34:18] if you catch it at a certain point,
[0:34:20] and your actions are threatening to that dog,
[0:34:22] and it bites you, the state code allows for that to happen.
[0:34:25] In other words, if you threaten a dog,
[0:34:27] defend itself, or its owner.
[0:34:33] And then serious injury, I think these definitions
[0:34:35] are important because you hear vicious dog,
[0:34:37] what does it really mean?
[0:34:38] A serious injury by state code would mean this.
[0:34:41] An injury to a person characterized by piercing
[0:34:44] of the hypodermis, or tearing of the muscles, veins,
[0:34:47] or disfiguring lacerations that would cause a reasonable prudent person to seek treatment
[0:34:54] from a medical professional without regard to whether the person actually sought medical
[0:34:59] treatment.
[0:35:00] So fairly significant by, I think when Courtney gets up and explains her process, she'll
[0:35:04] talk a little bit about what guides her decision to take certain courses of action.
[0:35:09] Now I say all that, and also going back to if you've bitten by a dog and it doesn't pierce
[0:35:16] this skin, right?
[0:35:17] A dermis.
[0:35:19] A dejibid dog is his computer.
[0:35:25] It really goes back to what I asked you earlier.
[0:35:28] What do you, what do you, what do you talk about Vicious Dog?
[0:35:30] What comes to your mind?
[0:35:31] So I wanted to bring him tonight and he's really disappointed that he's not here.
[0:35:34] But I have a, I have a 94 pound gold retriever named Hudson.
[0:35:37] And he's a great dog.
[0:35:38] I love the dog.
[0:35:40] He's a great companion to me and my family.
[0:35:43] And when you think of Vicious Dog, you probably didn't think of Hudson.
[0:35:52] Dog is out there, I mean the streets, but it probably wasn't a 94 pound.
[0:35:57] but what Frisson and I started through the information, here's what we discovered.
[0:36:02] We discovered that the majority of dog bites that occur
[0:36:06] and take place in our city. The large percentage of those dog bites are just that.
[0:36:11] They're the Hudson's out there. They've never displayed any aggressive tendencies.
[0:36:17] The dog owners, when this happens, a dog owner would say something like,
[0:36:21] I had no idea that my dog was capable of this.
[0:36:24] It's a total surprise to me. And for whatever reason,
[0:36:27] reason whether the dog was cornered, felt threatened, sometimes the animals just respond and react,
[0:36:36] but they've never displayed any aggressive tendencies. In these cases, generally, a high percentage of
[0:36:42] these cases, probably 80% of these cases. The owner had no one aggressive, and that would probably fit,
[0:36:51] my understanding of Hudson, I would not believe for one minute that Hudson could be aggressive.
[0:36:56] Could he be aggressive? He's an annery defensive, if you need. But what we found,
[0:37:05] And now, Fritz and I have found going through the cases we found, and a number of those cases were just that.
[0:37:09] So there has been conversations with the dog bites someone, should the dog be destroyed?
[0:37:13] What you'd find out in 80% of those cases is the dog that has actually been someone has never displayed any kind of violent or aggressive behavior in the past.
[0:37:24] And so when Fritz talks about how these cases are moving forward in the court system, and how troubling they are,
[0:37:31] They are.
[0:37:32] When you have a jury, those are the issues that he was trying to explain to you are so
[0:37:36] difficult to prosecute with the public defender, as juries are sympathetic to a lot of causes.
[0:37:44] But what he has found over the history of prosecuting these cases is they're really sympathetic
[0:37:49] to the Hudson's.
[0:37:50] Dogs that have been displayed in aggressive activity for whatever reason, right?
[0:37:56] All the stars aligned or something happened with that animal and they've been similar.
[0:38:01] Now these aren't all the cases.
[0:38:02] In the cases of Hudson, we're not sure why this occurs, but we also saw in a very small percentage that we do have some animals that have a tendency to be aggressive.
[0:38:15] We had Norvicious, and they've displayed this.
[0:38:19] Actually, it's very rare for Fred to have to deal with an animal more than one time.
[0:38:25] He's dealt with owners multiple. He's dealt with the same owner of multiple dogs.
[0:38:31] So I don't know if that says that maybe the conversation with how that animal is raised or what's happening there.
[0:38:38] But rarely does he encounter an animal that is dead he has that comes back a second time.
[0:38:44] It does happen. It is out there. And when that happens, as Courtney will show you, they take a different approach with how they treat that animal.
[0:38:51] We'll also find that animals, these aggressive animals that we run into, don't always include a human perpets.
[0:39:05] I've shared with me is that if you have two or three dogs and they get out together, dogs have a tendency to speed on the energy
[0:39:11] and they can't be very problematic when they start running together. If something happens with another dog, tendency there for them.
[0:39:26] So I know that's a lot of information, but that's really what I can give you in numbers, but the numbers are deceiving in that.
[0:39:33] What we're really seeing is just what I describe to you probably 80% of what we're dealing with are the Hudson's, that for some reason have taken an aggressive moment.
[0:39:43] I'm not saying that Cordy has more experience in this area than I do, and then of course
[0:39:50] the 20% we would consider to be dangerous just dogs.
[0:39:55] So with that I'm going to turn it over to Cordy and kind of walk you through the process
[0:39:59] of what she deals with.
[0:40:00] First of all thank you Madam my name is Cordy Cunningham, sir with the City of Twin Falls.
[0:40:13] Like Brian said I'm here to talk to you kind of about our process.
[0:40:16] If you'll look to the screen or your handouts I'll kind of go through piece by piece on
[0:40:20] what I do responding to an incident.
[0:40:24] much of us in law enforcement, we kind of have reasons for our existence, right? The first is
[0:40:29] enforcing the law and the second is protecting the people and the animals in our city. That
[0:40:34] being said, my first priority responding to one of these incidents is to make sure that the threat
[0:40:39] is taken care of, if the dog has not already been contained to do so. Second is to assess
[0:40:46] the victim. Do they need medical attention? Have they gotten it? Etc. Once that's concluded,
[0:40:51] we begin the investigation of the attack. I'll kind of take it to the orange box here on the screen.
[0:40:57] First by saying that every situation is different, every dog is different, every owner, every officer,
[0:41:02] so they're treated as such. This is kind of a basic guideline on what we do. The first one I'll take you
[0:41:09] through is on the right here, which is generally a minor bite and where we ruled the dog is not
[0:41:14] at fault. Some of these examples are if I were to break into a person's home or backyard and get
[0:41:19] that's my fault, that's not the dog's fault.
[0:41:22] If I were to reach my hand over a fence and get bit,
[0:41:25] again, my, in these types of cases, well, sorry,
[0:41:29] let me step back, I would pull a case number
[0:41:31] on any of these situations before you.
[0:41:33] So like Mr. Pike was saying, generally, you know,
[0:41:37] the 40 cases that we may have in a year of dog bites
[0:41:40] are not all the vicious attacks.
[0:41:42] I would pull one in a case as the dog not being in fault,
[0:41:46] just to kind of clarify the number there.
[0:41:49] In this case, we would make contact with the owner.
[0:41:51] We would let them know what happened.
[0:41:52] We would tell them that it was not the fault of their dogs.
[0:41:55] They generally would not receive any citations.
[0:41:57] We would still check if they were current
[0:41:58] on their rabies vaccination as that is required.
[0:42:02] If it is not current, we would have them generally
[0:42:04] quarantine the dog at their home for 10 days.
[0:42:06] We would follow up after that time,
[0:42:08] ensure the dog is healthy,
[0:42:09] and release the dog from quarantine.
[0:42:11] If the dog is current, then essentially that would be
[0:42:14] the end of it.
[0:42:15] We would talk to the victim on dog next time.
[0:42:20] our dog bite cases are in this middle column here,
[0:42:23] like the Hudson's.
[0:42:24] They're generally minor bites,
[0:42:27] and what we would call is defensive bites.
[0:42:29] Again, like he said, most of the time,
[0:42:31] none of them have shown aggression before,
[0:42:33] we don't know them, they're not in our system,
[0:42:35] that kind of thing.
[0:42:36] I would say in the majority of these cases,
[0:42:38] the dog somehow gets out.
[0:42:40] It's generally in its front yard,
[0:42:42] and the alley behind its backyard,
[0:42:43] sitting on its front step, you know,
[0:42:45] they generally want back inside.
[0:42:47] When these bites occur, generally the person is walking down the street, the dogs are already nervous, right?
[0:42:54] The dog thinks that the person is in their area and they go out and they generally bite one time.
[0:42:59] That is what I kind of define as a defensive bite, is generally one single bite that is not, it can vary in severity.
[0:43:07] But generally one bite is a defensive warning protective bite of the dog's property or the dog's owner.
[0:43:13] For example, if you're walking your dog and another person gets too close and the dog bites,
[0:43:18] we would call that a defensive bite, just as they would think that they were getting too close.
[0:43:22] In these situations, if we are not able to get a hold of the owner, we would contain the dog
[0:43:26] and we would take it to the shelter for a quarantine.
[0:43:29] If the owner is able to come home, talk to us, contain the dog, let us see the dog.
[0:43:33] Most of the time, they are very friendly. Once they're back in their yard,
[0:43:36] once they are with their owner in their home, the dog is very friendly.
[0:43:39] The owner is not having to hold it back. It's not trying to attack us.
[0:43:42] And that is kind of the distinction between the two types of dogs that we might deal with.
[0:43:46] Again, in these cases, it's certainly not acceptable that the dog was loose and that the dog was
[0:43:51] on, so they would generally get a dog at large and a vicious dog's citation.
[0:43:56] Again, depending on the rabies vaccination, we could quarantine at home or at the shelter,
[0:44:01] or if we have proof of rabies, we wouldn't necessarily need to quarantine.
[0:44:04] Please, if you have any questions, stop me as I'm going here.
[0:44:10] The next one, and thankfully the most rare dog bite.
[0:44:13] So if a bite breaks the skin at all, we look for a rabies vaccination, whether it's the dog's fault or not.
[0:44:52] So if the person walks by and sticks their hand over the fence, we might not cite them for having a vicious dog or a dog at large
[0:44:59] because the dog was contained on its own property, but we would still need the rabies vaccination information because it did bite and break the skin.
[0:45:05] Last and least common scenario are the major dog bites and the offensive dog bites.
[0:45:14] dog bites. Like I said, defensive, generally one by one minor bite. Offensive or where the dog
[0:45:21] is loose and it will attack anyone on the street or it attacks and it keeps attacking. The owner
[0:45:27] can't pull it off, the person cannot get away. So they're generally very clear if this is the
[0:45:32] kind of attack or not. In this kind of situation, whether or not there is a rabies vaccination
[0:45:37] generally does not matter. In the dogs that we determine are a danger to officers, to animals,
[0:45:44] to people, we will quarantine them at the shelter and we will notify the prosecution team of this
[0:45:49] animal and they will determine whether or not a motion to destroy a file, depending on whether it
[0:45:57] is filed or not, we go back into the current rabies vaccination as far as if the dog is really
[0:46:01] back to the owner or not. Also in all of these bites, we very heavily rely on what the victim wants.
[0:46:10] The majority of them, actually, the owner, excuse me,
[0:46:14] the victim does not want the owner to get in trouble.
[0:46:15] They don't want the dog to be taken.
[0:46:17] They don't want the dog to be put down.
[0:46:19] A lot of them recognize that the whites are their fault
[0:46:23] when they are, and we will rely on that.
[0:46:26] That being said, we don't always 100% go with the victims.
[0:46:30] When I get dispatched to a call on a certain street,
[0:46:33] a certain block number, dog description,
[0:46:35] I probably already know the owner's name.
[0:46:37] I probably know the dog's name.
[0:46:39] And those kind of cases, whether the victim wants them to get in trouble or not, is not always, say, as Mr. Pike said, if we're familiar with them, they're previous animals, they're current animals.
[0:46:50] It's generally an owner problem that needs to be dealt with. Any questions? Sorry.
[0:46:59] It's reserved for that.
[0:47:13] It would never be specific.
[0:47:20] There is. So, there is a main corridor at the shelter for animals up for adoption. There is then a separate area for the animals that we bring in where they're waiting for an owner to come.
[0:47:30] And then there's a separate quarantine room, which is saved for dog bites.
[0:47:36] They are in a complete separate room away from the public.
[0:47:38] They generally have a lock on the kennel.
[0:47:40] There are solid walls between each kennel, so they can't cause problems with the dogs.
[0:47:43] Courtney isn't there a leash lock in the city?
[0:48:02] Yes.
[0:48:03] So, for a dog to get out of its yard, it's also broken that leash lock, correct?
[0:48:10] Correct.
[0:48:11] Yes, and that is the they would generally get a dog at large citation for breaking that containment law as well as a vicious dog citation
[0:48:18] Okay, thanks
[0:48:22] That's actually really good point. One of the things that Sean and his team are working on right now is
[0:48:28] Educating the community and I've seen this and you've probably seen it too
[0:48:32] You know there seems to be more animals around than there than I remember
[0:48:36] It seems like everyone has a dog and that's great
[0:48:39] And we're glad that they have them and they bring them out.
[0:48:42] But when they do, and Sean and his team
[0:48:46] are going to be about this, if you're going to access the trail,
[0:48:51] they want all of our citizens to do so.
[0:48:53] It's a beautiful trail.
[0:48:55] But if you take your dog along, it needs to be on a leash.
[0:49:04] It's not OK, dog needs to be in.
[0:49:09] Which actually makes a lot of sense
[0:49:10] when you look at some of the data that we talked about tonight
[0:49:15] for the citizens out there.
[0:49:25] So that he or she's not in place in those situations
[0:49:28] where for whatever reason, they're
[0:49:31] fearful or they feel like they have to protect and describe the defense. Those are some of the things that we're working on. I don't know if you have any other questions for us if there's anything that we can do. This is something that we take seriously. And as more people come out, utilize the amenities of Twin Falls. And they do so with their pets. We're going to have a great team here tonight.
[0:50:29] So I'm not sure who this question is for, maybe Cormand again.
[0:51:06] So I'm seeing more and more snakes around people's necks in City Park, not talking about
[0:51:14] little tiny snakes.
[0:51:15] We're talking about big non-snakes, the least lost for snakes or something.
[0:51:24] I don't know, you know, it scares a lot of people.
[0:51:29] I'm talking about snakes, but you know,
[0:51:36] there's a lot of children in City Park.
[0:51:39] I mean, last time I was there
[0:51:42] where there were half a dozen, easy snakes
[0:51:46] around people's necks.
[0:51:53] Parks, you know, if a sir come up and say,
[0:51:59] take that home, please.
[0:52:02] It's similar to other things that have come up
[0:52:05] with regard to animals, it is personal property.
[0:52:29] Actually, I was having a conversation with Shane.
[0:52:32] We'll look at, and I'll talk to Fritz, too,
[0:52:34] if there's advantage for our team
[0:52:36] citing under state code,
[0:52:38] and it gives the advantage to the victim
[0:52:40] for restitution or for other action.
[0:52:43] That's something that I would...
[0:53:04] Oh, sir, yes.
[0:53:28] I'm gonna be Sheriff for 17,
[0:53:30] and also work for the City of Filer
[0:53:33] for those years as a part-time officer.
[0:53:37] Just within the past four years,
[0:53:40] this has changed from a misdemeanor
[0:53:43] to an infraction in city. Fraction is no more than a dog down the street. There's
[0:53:56] separate that was up there as all well and fine, except for the victim. Until you've
[0:54:03] been bitten by a door started with Twin Falls County Sheriff's Department. This dog might
[0:54:19] last month for the first time I ever got bitten by a dog. It came out of the yard right at
[0:54:24] me. Across the street from me, the yard has no fence around me. All the people have
[0:54:30] to do is let that dog out the door as I'm walking up the street. And I could get bent
[0:54:35] The city tells them not to do that, but an infraction doesn't give the victim any option.
[0:54:44] Anything except to go to civil court costs that they incur from the right $107 costs that
[0:54:53] I turn into the officer.
[0:54:54] I have the only way I can collect that is to go to court on civil case, which is like
[0:54:59] time pass as a misdemeanor the victim could go to court.
[0:55:04] The victim could submit their cost and the judge would determine of a person they had
[0:55:10] person they had to pay that cost along with paying to find if he was found you know it looks well and
[0:55:22] find up there except for the victim and the victim is the one the city and the police department should
[0:55:29] be taken care of they're the citizens that walk around this community and expect dogs to be under
[0:55:35] control and offensive so you can't always guarantee that that person you talk to that have dog that
[0:55:43] just bit somebody is not going to turn that dog lives and I said my house and watch that next door
[0:55:49] neighbor turn that dog loose every night to run it in the yard to go to the bathroom.
[0:55:53] Unless I take a picture of it, they're not going to sit us if I cannot sign a citation
[0:56:03] and take the dog loose dog and saw it.
[0:56:09] That used to not happen before either.
[0:56:12] The Constitution says we have to write as citizens to make a citizen's arrest in a police department
[0:56:49] aggressively attack wise and aggressively attack for five separate times.
[0:57:05] I'm just saying these laws are great until the year you're stuck with for the civil case
[0:57:13] after the guy goes in and pays him.
[0:57:18] They didn't just sighted and impounded several dogs.
[0:57:27] They impounded several dogs when I worked over the fire.
[0:57:38] I just want you guys to consider that some of those things
[0:57:42] I wish it was back up there.
[0:57:44] A minor attack is a major attack.
[0:57:47] The person gets attacked whether they fight or rather
[0:57:51] they can skin on me off of her because she has a dark in hand
[0:58:13] and I ask you why he has shrugged his shoulders and walked off him.
[0:58:20] Well, is this dog hit somebody else, and does our city even know, even check to find out if the dog that went was in Boise, has a previous record of a cell when a dog gets his teeth.
[0:58:34] But there's a lot of dogs running loose over in my area, and he's talked to us, wanted to say my piece, that's why I came here in the first place.
[0:59:08] And the fact that the officer can take a final discretion of whether to sign to me, violates my civil rights as a citizen, to sign a citation.
[0:59:20] I'll fight somebody to sight him.
[0:59:26] Get to sight.
[0:59:34] Very sad that the...
[1:04:50] ...share your story as hard as it was.
[1:04:58] To sight out, I'll come out of his yard.
[1:05:41] He chases me.
[1:05:42] It's quite a bit away from his yard.
[1:05:44] Twice I've been hit.
[1:05:47] The next time, I'm gonna make holy hell.
[1:05:49] I'm gonna stand my ground.
[1:05:51] I'm gonna mace the dog.
[1:05:53] I'm gonna do everything I can to make that dog miserable.
[1:05:55] And tell the owner, you can't tell me this is the first time.
[1:05:59] time. It was been in Florida, behind me said the dog came out chasing him. I was
[1:06:06] been in fuel and the guy says, oh we just let him, we just came away to him for one
[1:06:11] time. I no longer take people's word because they've left themselves out I think.
[1:06:15] This is a normal thing. Through the shock, I'll go to the counseling and the law force
[1:06:22] will say if I'm going to radical, they're standing in my ground and beating up a dog,
[1:06:26] But I'm not going to be the victim anymore. I look at the Moravian's dog. These are defensive
[1:06:34] bites because I have to be riding along the street, which is what I'm right to do.
[1:06:38] They're dogs off the leash, and they don't chase with me until I get out of his territory.
[1:06:45] So thank you very much.
[1:06:46] I'm a Mad Vice Mayor, members of the Council. We have several announcements. The first would
[1:07:14] be obviously on Independence Day July, our work celebration, day the sixth, and that's the sixth
[1:07:58] that four o'clock in that grace. You're going to see events throughout the entire day. We're really
[1:08:15] fortunate to have both male and female professional athletes who are going to become
[1:08:20] in cycling were placed at the version of the cycling events.
[1:08:32] Forbes, on 6.37 o'clock in life conversations about it.
[1:09:10] This is pretty exciting because we've been waiting for this since last fall,
[1:09:15] and our Christmas parade and the lights on, and so this is really it.
[1:09:21] As it was just month of July, everybody knows that that's going on.
[1:09:35] With all of the fireworks stands that we see as we drag around,
[1:09:38] there are certain laws associated with in the city of Twin Falls for fireworks.
[1:09:44] They are different than county laws. So if you do not know, please have a safe Fourth of July. Don't be safe
