Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2018-05-21, recording 1 (started 17:00)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2018-05-21/

[0:00:11] Good evening. I'd like to call the order of the meeting on the Twin Falls City Council for Monday, May 21st and confirm we do have a quorum of the council. All seven members are here this evening.
[0:00:21] The next item on the agenda is the, excuse me, the Pledge of Allegiance. For those of you wishing to join us, please rise.
[0:00:27] I pledge allegiance to the Mr. Rothweiler. Do we have any amendments to our agenda this evening? Mr. Members, the council, there are no amendments. Thank you.
[0:00:54] We also have no proclamations this evening, so next would be an opportunity for general public input.
[0:01:00] There's anyone here from the public who wishes to address the council on item that is not on the agenda this evening.
[0:01:05] How is your opportunity to please come forward?
[0:01:11] Seeing no one, Greg Lanting.
[0:01:21] Approval to consent calendar as published.
[0:01:26] Nicky Boyd. Motion by Greg Lanting, seconded by Nicky Boyd to approve the consent calendar.
[0:01:32] Is there any discussion?
[0:01:34] It's actually not for the building. It is I believe that's going to be for the Plaza and as you'll remember the Urban Renewal Agency
[0:01:52] contracted with the city and so they're running all those expenses through the city. We build the agency completion of those
[0:02:02] invoices. I knew you'd have the answer.
[0:02:04] Brother, discussion.
[0:02:25] Suzanne Hawkins. Yes.
[0:02:27] Greg Lanting. Yes.
[0:02:29] Ruth Pierce. Yes.
[0:02:31] Christopher Reed. Yes.
[0:02:33] and Chris talking to. Yes, we should pass that seven to zero. Next on the agenda is a request to confirm the mayor's appointment of Tom Frank to the airport advisory board.
[0:02:48] So earlier this year the city advertised for applicants interested in becoming a city representative on the airport board due to the departure of Abi Michelle who needed to resign due to his new career as a charter pilot.
[0:03:10] A staff worked with the City Public Information Officer and issued two separate press releases.
[0:03:14] List of the opening on the city's webpage for over a six-week period.
[0:03:18] In an interview committee composed of myself, County Airport Liaison and County Commissioner
[0:03:23] Don Hall, Airport Board Chairman Mike March and Airport Manager Bill Carberry.
[0:03:29] We interviewed six candidates earlier this month.
[0:03:32] The committee was impressed with Tom Frank and unanimously agreed to recommend him.
[0:03:36] Mr. Frank has a background in community volunteer work. He served on a couple of our city commissions
[0:03:42] I mean good understanding of current airport operations and development goals lives within the city limits and works at a local television station
[0:03:50] So the city code states that the airport board appointments are recommended by the mayor and confirmed by the city council
[0:03:56] so I would ask for the councils
[0:04:01] concurrence with the appointment of Tom Frank for the
[0:04:04] seat on the airport advisory
[0:04:07] Susan Hawkins that he's a good loyal member to be greatly to that request to
[0:04:20] Ruth Pierce second motion by Susan Hawkins seconded by Ruth Pierce to
[0:04:29] approve the appointment of Tom Frank to the airport advisory board is there
[0:04:33] any other discussion Nicky Boyd is Anne Hawkins yes great
[0:04:55] glanting yes Ruth Pierce yes Christopher Reed yes Chris
[0:05:01] talking to and Sean Berninger. Yes, Ocean Pass is 7-0. Thank you, I saw you
[0:05:08] sneaking in. It's such a vast audience, I can't pick you out from out there. Thank
[0:05:14] you for agreeing to serve and I would look forward to your service on the board.
[0:05:18] Next on the agenda is a request to approve a cash contribution in lieu of
[0:05:25] parkland dedication for morning sun number 10 subdivision we have Jonathan
[0:05:29] It's been love.
[0:05:33] But yeah, I'm not windy that's who was put on it.
[0:05:35] I think that was my hair of who was by and who was from.
[0:05:39] This is the beginning of a different type of process.
[0:05:43] We're going to use going, planning and zoning staff.
[0:05:46] We'll be preparing staff reports for Parks and Lewis,
[0:05:50] Parks and Lewis part of the preliminary plan process.
[0:05:53] So we take care of the applications
[0:05:57] as it comes through the engineering department,
[0:05:59] planning and zoning reviews of those plans.
[0:06:00] We take it to the Parks and Rec Commission, and then we will be bringing those to the City Council.
[0:06:05] All of this is done in conjunction with the Parks Director.
[0:06:08] So Wendy's here for any questions.
[0:06:10] For after, generally, we do a very brief, it's the same presentation we gave to the Parks
[0:06:16] and Rec Commission.
[0:06:17] This is a property, morning sun 10, is on Hank and the Road Stadium.
[0:06:22] It's the southeast corner of that intersection, minus the property that is already built
[0:06:27] on. It comes as approximately 95 buildable lots for residential homes. The staff report
[0:06:35] gives you the acreage, it gives the contribution calculation which is in city code.
[0:06:41] This one is a little bit unconventional. Most of the time these will come under a consent item.
[0:06:46] This case there is a request from the applicant for a type of credit, quote unquote credit.
[0:06:53] The total contributions calculated $58,000, I'm not going to do the $100, I think I'm going to stick with the thousands of dollars, and the credit proposes about $35,000, almost $36,000 for a total cash contribution of $22,000, almost $23,000.
[0:07:10] credit it has to do with a shelter that was built across Hank and
[0:07:16] Droad with Morning Sun Park and that's the exact name. There was a shelter that was
[0:07:22] built in lieu of the cash contribution for the Morning Sun number eight and
[0:07:26] number nine subdivisions. This amount, $36,000 is what it costs to build the
[0:07:33] shelter so it carried over to Morning Sun number ten as well. So the cash
[0:07:37] contribution that the applicant is requesting is that $23,000.
[0:07:41] In the end, there's the park land dedication.
[0:07:49] However, they can ask for a new contribution.
[0:07:53] If we went with the park land dedication,
[0:07:56] we would get approximately, it's almost an acre,
[0:07:59] a plan that this subdivision would be required to dedicate.
[0:08:02] It's not large enough to meet our requirement
[0:08:05] for a neighborhood park.
[0:08:06] It could meet our requirement for a mini park.
[0:08:09] So since it doesn't meet that minimum threshold three acres
[0:08:12] for a neighborhood park, it can go for this
[0:08:14] into contribution, April 27th,
[0:08:19] or in conclusion, April 27th,
[0:08:20] the Parks and Recommission Herd is request.
[0:08:23] There was much debate and discussion amongst the members.
[0:08:25] They forwarded a positive recommendation
[0:08:27] to accept cash contributions
[0:08:29] into the parkland dedication by a vote of five to two councils
[0:08:34] tasked with deciding on whether to accept
[0:08:36] the parks and the contributions
[0:08:37] for the morning sun number 10 subdivision.
[0:08:47] was the original shelter construction, not an in-lue for her, and is something I was not
[0:08:57] involved in the original approval of it, but I believe it was, built the shelter for eight,
[0:09:02] and I answered that question. That is who I went direct to.
[0:09:09] That is what I'm trying to figure out, so I understand that concept of,
[0:09:16] built the shelter, can you count that toward my in-lue, but my question is,
[0:09:19] did that not already get counted as in-lue for mornings and eight and mornings and nine?
[0:09:24] It did. So the cash contribution that would have been the in the contribution for eight and nine was applied to the shelter.
[0:09:32] Was it the shelter in its entirety? Because they're now requesting additional credits.
[0:09:39] So the budget or the the shelter of mount exceeded the eight and nine. So it carried over a little bit and so he's asking for credit.
[0:09:50] different with the difference exactly yes I was getting there great planting yes
[0:10:02] y'all I was making the assumption that at this point time we're not looking at a
[0:10:07] park on that side of Hankins especially in this particular neighborhood since
[0:10:14] schools are in real life this parks and we think about the case anymore as we
[0:10:22] watch the news but so that the thought very being there's not really need for
[0:10:26] park there because they have the school they'll let you suppose right there as
[0:10:29] So maybe I can back it up just a tiny bit, too, so Morning Sun 10 in concept for the end
[0:10:38] of the contribution went to the Parks and Rec Commission last, it was last year or some
[0:10:43] time, and it changed because then there was a request for some credit, and so we took it
[0:10:51] back to the commission and we never brought it to the council because we didn't have the
[0:10:56] amount and the completed documents for ten yet. And then when the documents came in, there was a
[0:11:02] request for credits. We took it back, asked for the credit piece, and brought it forward. So,
[0:11:08] because it crosses an arterial, that's one of the reasons why it needs to be discussed.
[0:11:14] Because of the because of the elementary school, it made sense to go ahead and apply those funds
[0:11:21] at Morning Sun Park, which is nearby, but across Hinkins.
[0:11:25] All right, thank you.
[0:11:26] Susan Hawkins.
[0:11:29] So Wendy, would we collect the park in Lua Funds?
[0:11:32] Isn't it typical that we collect shelter?
[0:11:37] So was this different or we understand how the need of a man?
[0:11:42] So this time, we had the checks.
[0:11:48] I think the checks came in and we held the checks.
[0:11:52] But the expectation was that he could take care of the shelter,
[0:11:58] probably cheaper than if we bid it out and did it ourselves. So he asked to do it and offered to do it as part
[0:12:05] as part of the project and then it just applied the funds and then gave us the shelter.
[0:12:10] And so we gave the money back. We gave him the
[0:12:14] in-lou checks back. Is that going to be something we're doing or are we trying to avoid this and this?
[0:12:20] So it's hard to like it really. Right. So part of what happened here is
[0:12:25] is, by cleaning up the process and putting it on the front end, which is where it needs
[0:12:34] to be, and having, planning and zoning involving us in a conversation that would be part of
[0:12:40] the preliminary plat, is where we'll have the conversation about what we're going to
[0:12:46] do.
[0:12:47] And then we'll be able to document it and move it forward.
[0:12:50] Some of these things have happened in that developers come and say, this is what I
[0:12:55] want to do and we say okay this way we'll have the conversation in the front end
[0:12:59] we'll determine whether we want parks and lu whether it's a park and have
[0:13:04] those conversations on the front end and it would probably that process will
[0:13:08] eliminate something like this happening later because it would be documented all
[0:13:12] along and the conversations would happen this one wasn't this was a little
[0:13:17] looser and so we wound up here but in the future it'll be a better process is
[0:13:23] That's what we expect.
[0:13:25] Thank you.
[0:13:34] Chris, talking to Chris, talking to seconded by Greg Lansing to cash contribution in the park land dedication has presented.
[0:13:56] Further discussion?
[0:14:20] Suzanne.
[0:14:23] Yes.
[0:14:24] Yes.
[0:14:25] Yes.
[0:14:26] Yes.
[0:14:27] Yes.
[0:14:28] Yes.
[0:14:29] Yes.
[0:14:30] Very good.
[0:14:31] Yes.
[0:14:33] Nicky Boyd passes.
[0:14:44] Next is a request to adopt an ordinance creating city code 8-2-15 regarding outdoor seating
[0:14:51] on public sidewalks.
[0:14:53] We have Nathan Murray, our economic development director.
[0:15:01] And Council, to what this ordinance is intending to do is to create a set of, kind of uniform set of standards
[0:15:07] by which we can govern outdoor seating on public sidewalks.
[0:15:12] Something that's been done for a number of years, but there's no theme in our code that kind of standards are,
[0:15:20] trying to get some guidelines to ensure that there's continued access for pedestrians or continuing ADA standards is required.
[0:15:30] This has come about a new nice wide sidewalk in our downtown for use, and we were encouraging of that.
[0:15:41] I sort of researched the demonstrates that cities that allow the juices of a loved group and see central business district.
[0:15:49] So in general, what for is areas where a narrow sidewalk less than 15 feet that at least 5 feet of your clear could walk through this trance.
[0:16:03] The end of your scene has to be set back at least 5 feet for any specified hours of operation, clear to the close of business day.
[0:16:21] And remains in a few areas and disorders also of some provisions that outline the approval wheels where the scene will be entered into business.
[0:16:42] Insurance for any damages to provisions of those codes.
[0:16:49] I have a fair number of downtown business folks here as well, so I am going to offer an opportunity
[0:17:06] if you'd like to share some comments after we have a little bit of discussion here, many
[0:17:20] clarifying questions that Council may have.
[0:17:28] Chris Reed.
[0:17:35] and share some comments after we have a little bit of discussion here.
[0:17:38] If any clarifying questions the council may have.
[0:17:41] Chris, what exactly are you looking for areas in which tables are?
[0:17:51] Are you looking specific to one this area, table in this area, table in this area?
[0:17:57] Yeah, we want a scale drawing that identifies where those seats will be in relation to business,
[0:18:04] so it has to be in front of the business that it serves.
[0:18:07] You have to maintain that corridor for pleasure, the smallest parallel in front of business with the street.
[0:18:11] So I'm going to identify an error of seeing.
[0:18:16] The second question is if you walk me through the process of a restaurant getting this permit.
[0:18:22] It would provide a drawing to our planning and zoning staff.
[0:18:28] I just think you would number other types of permits that would be reviewed against the code.
[0:18:33] Verify that they have their insurance in place.
[0:18:36] Business that allows them to stop the sidewalk.
[0:18:48] Right of way or costs associated with this.
[0:19:06] Establish.
[0:19:07] He parked our seating on the public sidewalks as a king sitting.
[0:19:30] I just spent three weeks in the scanning and successful.
[0:19:35] Businesses were often up to receding.
[0:19:42] Likewise, he certainly didn't have this assuming it was for successful citrus.
[0:19:52] Jason, retails to a sidewalk seating.
[0:20:02] Just that. So I looked at Boise's ordinance and I saw a number of cities.
[0:20:09] It is pretty clear that in aired downtowns that allow this some of that
[0:20:15] outdoor scene is the prime scene for a restaurant or other days like a number of
[0:20:21] proceeds from that restaurant are going to be.
[0:20:29] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:20:30] Thank you.
[0:20:31] So Nate, are the permits that we're issuing issued to the actual business owner or the business name?
[0:20:38] So like if the business is sold and things change, how will that process work?
[0:20:42] It would be to the business owner.
[0:20:44] We didn't specify but it might be months at a time.
[0:20:57] That was my next question. Is there a time frame on these permits? And I think it would
[0:21:15] be considered a cost for the permits because there's definitely a cost to city staff time
[0:21:22] to prepare it and go through these. Though I would be making sure we're clarified who
[0:21:31] the permit is with, whether it's the business name or the owner's name. So, so Susanna,
[0:21:45] we will bet how this works out. You'll see at the end of this that these are not considered permanent permits
[0:21:58] and they can be revoked. Consider these like especially as permit that you gain rights in.
[0:22:06] These are permission to temporarily in public sidewalks for very successful and bigger cities.
[0:22:17] Are they cities actually charged someday with gates in us in ways that we didn't,
[0:22:53] it says sort of a temporal works out.
[0:23:00] So we can't expect a follow-up on this maybe at the end of the summer.
[0:23:41] They just looked so you have a better idea in our mind.
[0:23:44] Let's say we have some guppies here.
[0:23:48] So how wide is the sidewalk there at guppies?
[0:23:52] It's 20 feet.
[0:23:53] 20 feet so they would need to maintain 10 feet of access for the district's face,
[0:23:59] but they could use 10 feet as proceeding.
[0:24:04] Also, I noticed since I've noticed several of the people of the Catholic people and Boise pretty well, they have a slightly different ordinance where they have some of theirs have
[0:24:16] various, you know, that are behind like a small, broader, and fancier such thing, and I think they have that there in my mind as soon as they talk to them, that's the area is if they want to serve alcohol, they have to be behind those
[0:24:31] type of a situation that we consider that type of thing or like you said this is an ongoing process.
[0:24:38] The minor status of that code is that might be specific to the city of Boise or state.
[0:24:47] It requires alcohol to be served inside the confines of a business.
[0:24:51] There's nothing that I'm aware of in 2012's ordinances that allows you to consume alcohol on the sidewalk
[0:24:58] It prevents you from alcohol served and then tear it with a biggie boy.
[0:25:18] My life's not going on. Just one quick clarification, Nate.
[0:25:58] Is this strictly limited to Main Street at this point?
[0:26:03] Yeah, this is for CB.
[0:26:05] Yeah, I saw CB and OT, but that means Main Street.
[0:26:10] Yeah. Okay.
[0:26:11] Well, thank you.
[0:26:14] Okay. Because we have a business on Second Avenue
[0:26:17] that actually has umbrellas and tables out as well,
[0:26:21] and then one on Shoshone Street.
[0:26:24] And so I was curious as to how far out that was going to.
[0:26:28] If they're in our zone, they would fall under these codes.
[0:26:30] There's one additional provision for them located.
[0:26:43] So that would cover the one on Shoshone Street.
[0:26:46] Because that's a state highway.
[0:26:58] So I would like to give the opportunity for folks who came this evening.
[0:27:02] If anybody wants to give any additional input on this before we move forward with any further discussion or decision for the council, so
[0:27:10] Come on down and if you would please
[0:27:13] state your name and
[0:27:16] property owner in the city of Twin Falls
[0:27:20] My name is Jay Waters III
[0:27:22] I'm in Twin Falls, Idaho. I came down here, Twin Falls County lead for 3%
[0:27:33] Basically stand up and just rights are being heard. Something like this. It's me too
[0:27:45] Speak on my mind that I just sleep. Do we already have specific fire code firing certain amount of space?
[0:28:16] Also, because I'm not sure that making more regulation is going to go what I would personally like to see because
[0:28:28] It has public property. I don't know if you can lease out
[0:28:35] Basically fans or something you're taking that public property that I also believe restaurants down town
[0:28:54] You can get the sun now, fight and seeding.
[0:29:04] That's going to bring a lot more activity.
[0:29:16] If you have a fee and a business is struggling.
[0:29:19] Why are they going to pay the fee to have two tables outside?
[0:29:23] You're really putting a damper on letting someone take their freedom and the best.
[0:29:30] either restaurant on Main Street or Best Business on Blue Lakes, you know, you're really taking
[0:29:35] the personal initiative away from business owners if you require them able outside.
[0:29:42] If you'd like to see any legislation created, I think the table should be clearly marked if they're privately owned.
[0:29:54] I would fix a lot of the screw-ups, you know, and a lot of the fuss that's going on.
[0:30:01] There's a lot of tables down there that look the same.
[0:30:03] You know, if they're from business, I need to buy food from them to use it.
[0:30:11] It's so clear that click uppies hot rock grill have
[0:30:24] I'm gonna sit here and think that with some of the struggles down there. Also, I think
[0:30:34] So say you so say you come in
[0:30:38] You get to permit to have his
[0:30:42] tables and chairs in a certain location
[0:30:44] You guys approve it the permits granted. He has his chairs there. We have a great thing
[0:30:51] You know the concert series that are happening down Main Street
[0:30:56] It's getting summer, a lot of people are wanting to go down and congregate and assemble
[0:31:01] during the Constitution that we have that right to assemble on public properties zones
[0:31:09] and say this public property is for Twin Falls Sound Company
[0:31:13] and this private property is for companies, eye rights,
[0:31:20] copulation, and required business owners that are already doing what they need to do
[0:31:36] to be in, don't think we need a reception on Facebook, Google, all those
[0:31:47] all these companies get reviews every day.
[0:31:52] People are able to go and see where the business stands.
[0:31:56] It's not saying they can have people sit outside
[0:32:04] in a certain designated spot.
[0:32:06] Also, on Greg's statement about the fence,
[0:32:11] if you look into that, I would probably say that's probably located on the business's private property.
[0:32:19] It's probably not in the council to don't think business is doing great.
[0:32:41] It looks like downtown's boom and it looks like you know people are coming here and I I personally
[0:32:48] Think it should remain public if a business wants to allow seats seating
[0:32:55] You know and as long as if it is under to date
[0:33:02] They went else who wishes to address the council on this issue
[0:33:13] It was meant for you 11 17 21 Maplewood drive here in Twin Falls
[0:33:22] My personally think the outside seating is a fantastic idea. We've
[0:33:25] you've used it in Boise when we've walked downtown. There's a lot of great places to visit. I just had a couple of points that I've
[0:33:34] that, uh, wait, first of all, we have issues with people crossing streets that are intoxicated, people that are intoxicated along the public sidewalk. So, the
[0:33:50] serving of alcohol out onto the patios and stuff like that might lead to an issue where you have intoxicated people that you're actually serving out on the sidewalks, mixing with the people who are
[0:33:59] I drove downtown today and took some photographs of most all the tables with the exception of the ones over on 2nd Avenue in front of scooters, which I think those tables there might be outside of what the ordinances here, because of the way they're positioned.
[0:34:25] What I see is most all the tables are pushed out towards the street, the on main street.
[0:34:31] Most of those are probably, I won't say most of those.
[0:34:34] I can't say that, but there are a lot of them within that five foot range.
[0:34:38] And one thing that I see up there says away from the street,
[0:34:45] you know, five feet away from the street and stuff like that.
[0:34:47] You also need to add parking spaces into that as well because you can be five feet back from the street.
[0:34:52] But with the two feet of the curb near a parking space, you're going to limit people's friend park and get it out of their vehicles.
[0:34:57] vehicles. Also one of the businesses I did see downtown that is located on one of the corners.
[0:35:04] Their tables and chairs are actually away from the curb, but in the walk line of somebody
[0:35:10] who might be handicapped blind or such that might provide a entrance to them. The things
[0:35:22] I see in the code, you talked about the sidewalk in front of Guppies being 20 feet. So if you're
[0:35:28] allowing for 10 feet of obstructed walk space. I'm assuming that's from the building to the first table at 20 feet. You would only have 5 feet to put the
[0:35:39] 5 feet away from the from the street. It's actually good out of the 10 feet in the middle. And that's fine. But like I said, it looks like everybody has pushed their tables out closer to the street versus keeping them closer to the middle of the 6th when you look down there. So like I said, but like I said, when you're talking at 21st sidewalk, if you have to have 5 feet from the sidewalk,
[0:35:58] Our government, excuse me, from the street, and you give them 10 feet, then it limits you down to 5 feet for the actual tables on that 25th section.
[0:36:06] So, but I honestly think it's a great idea. I think there's something to be said for. I think one of the things like Jay talked about is ownership of the tables.
[0:36:17] If I'm downtown with my 75-year-old father and his girlfriend is going in and out of the shops and a lot of those shops don't have tables assigned to them.
[0:36:28] restaurant and my dad decides to set down at one of those tables to rest while his
[0:36:33] girlfriend is going in out of the shops is he gonna have a business owner come
[0:36:37] out and it cost him for sitting in down and resting for five ten minutes while
[0:36:41] she's in a shop and he doesn't want to go anywhere else.
[0:36:55] I can't see this all the faster than you were doing.
[0:37:05] I've sat in a lot of these meetings and I sat in businesses and so it helps
[0:38:06] just much more times would be in the same though there should be a little bit of
[0:39:08] So, I'm Dan Brzee, and I live with 285, my long, 7 second Avenue. I'm also a chairman of, so, first of all, we should all be really proud of what has been created.
[0:39:32] Look, I'm concerned about the 5 foot setback, and the reason I'm concerned about the 5 foot setback is because I think that's something that you 5 feet.
[0:40:30] I spent a lot of time on being twice a day, right?
[0:40:37] There was seven vendors who had tables, a lot of different places, and there's a lot of different challenges with each place in front of the coffee shop.
[0:40:54] We've got planters out there because the way that was designed, and those are all with all those chairs within five feet.
[0:41:02] We're going to have to have some leniency, and I think when people apply for permit, they give us a picture, have access.
[0:41:18] It is, as somebody mentioned, the community space.
[0:41:21] I mean, it's no different than a park,
[0:41:24] because that's its public space.
[0:41:27] What he mentioned was the buildings,
[0:41:32] and the property line is the front of the buildings.
[0:41:36] That's it.
[0:41:38] So this has to morph.
[0:41:40] This has to change.
[0:41:43] The primary reason I came today is because there was talk
[0:41:46] on the paper today about fences.
[0:41:48] I mean, those taking takes away.
[0:42:12] Yes, sir.
[0:42:26] At the restaurant for three and a half years, we suffered through the road construction.
[0:42:32] I think everybody on Main Street, not our finished product.
[0:42:38] I think that I've heard a couple of people touch on the fact of what we've ended up with
[0:42:43] is a great thing, but hasn't come out around.
[0:42:47] Is it here yet?
[0:42:48] I think we're on our way, but we've still got a lot of following in what, as far as putting
[0:43:02] Our tables closer to our table are building with offense.
[0:43:07] You've just eliminated us 10 customers.
[0:43:11] Does it create an entryway into our place that's inviting?
[0:43:15] Because we're going to have to walk through those two
[0:43:17] barriers on each side?
[0:43:19] Believe so.
[0:43:26] Yeah, there's more to have to be done,
[0:43:28] but then do you make exceptions for this guy and this guy,
[0:43:31] but not this guy.
[0:43:33] And I don't know how you're going to make it fair for us all.
[0:43:36] Yes, we have 20 feet in front of us, 10 foot of us.
[0:43:40] Is that clear, big walk?
[0:43:41] Wait, we've developed that.
[0:43:42] It's there.
[0:43:43] I feel good about it.
[0:43:45] When I look down and conforming it,
[0:43:50] I see that the whole road, as its way is in appearance too.
[0:43:56] So I think the tables do too.
[0:43:58] And it looks inviting, but as far as our center of our tables,
[0:44:05] we are probably within eight feet of the road,
[0:44:10] that even the benches are within that five.
[0:44:14] I think that what I see everybody downtown, I'm just like the folks went down there today
[0:44:20] just to make sure I think it's a clean environment, tables are organized.
[0:44:26] The rules for the people, is it time to do it for business?
[0:44:50] That's about all I got to say.
[0:45:14] Edward's, first of all, I think this is way ahead of where it should be.
[0:45:22] I don't think it was well prepared.
[0:45:24] There's a lot of things that haven't been addressed that was brought forth by the presenters.
[0:45:31] Questions that couldn't be answered and it's going to morph and it's going to change.
[0:45:34] And I understand all that.
[0:45:36] When you put an ordinance in place, how do you enforce an ordinance if you're going to morph and change it?
[0:45:41] The other thing is that sidewalk that's been developed now at taxpayers expense is private right away.
[0:45:50] It's not private property.
[0:45:52] It is property, but it's private right away.
[0:45:54] So what it sounds like to me is that the business owners can go ahead and take that area in front of their business, second
[0:46:03] coordinate off and that's their seating area. What happens if as a citizen I take my folding chair and put out there in that area?
[0:46:11] Do I get fined for being in that area using utilizing that area because I bought a sandwich from business down the road?
[0:46:18] How are you going to enforce that?
[0:46:20] I know common sense plays into this,
[0:46:23] but that is private right away.
[0:46:25] And you're public right away.
[0:46:27] Well, public right away, yeah, public right away.
[0:46:30] You're giving folks an advantage.
[0:46:33] So it's kind of like a redistribution of wealth in a way.
[0:46:37] You're giving those people extra access
[0:46:41] to property that they don't own,
[0:46:43] and excluding other people from that.
[0:46:46] So I don't know how you can justify that.
[0:46:48] I think that's illegal.
[0:46:50] I think you're compensating a business,
[0:46:53] privately owned business, with taxpayer dollars
[0:46:56] and ordinances that restrict people from using that.
[0:47:00] So if I set in front of X number of business
[0:47:04] and I was on the wrong one,
[0:47:07] wasn't supposed to be there,
[0:47:09] who's gonna find me and whose responsibility
[0:47:12] is that city ordinance?
[0:47:13] Is the city code enforcement guy gonna come out there
[0:47:16] tell me to move the police department guy come up and tell me to move if I go
[0:47:20] there and I sit there and I say I'm not moving and they say well I'm gonna film
[0:47:24] you and I'm gonna turn you into the police department what's my option says
[0:47:28] citizen do I just tell them to go pose themselves or do I say okay I'll go move
[0:47:35] to another bench or I just won't do business in front of your city
[0:47:40] subsidized right away. That's my concern. Anyone else comments, folks who spoke the question
[0:48:08] whether the my foot setback is too much. Actually let me take one setback. Now
[0:48:18] sidewalk seeding downtown is not the new thing that only happens suddenly because
[0:48:22] we did the new dysfunction relatively well. Having some boards on that use is
[0:48:36] maybe a good way of looking at this. Making sure we're maintaining safe access for pedestrians.
[0:48:42] to proceed, I'd show fencing up, does exactly the opposite of what the entire town project
[0:48:52] was designed to do with a sense of openness, had a slightly different design on the current
[0:49:00] restaurant stand town, I might agree that that fencing would work, and it doesn't function
[0:49:05] like Boise does. Buildings just aren't designed that way. The other thing, too, that I think
[0:49:10] we need to think about is it's not only about the seven restaurants downtown that we have
[0:49:16] Today I see this Wells Fargo building is for sale that could be all kinds of buildings downtown that I'd have some formality to.
[0:49:29] Truthfully I don't feel this ordinance tonight until the setback is one that I would fall setback.
[0:49:48] Also I notice in the ordinance a couple of places it references the cement pavement.
[0:49:54] There are some areas that are actually pavers, not cement so pears, but I don't.
[0:50:13] success of this ordinance requires not on the heavy handedness of government and self-policing
[0:50:22] of business owners. There is an issue with tables in front of their place that's on the business owner
[0:50:33] to have some foresight to go out and say hey you know these are for our customers only or put
[0:50:40] some signage on that that says this is for our customers only neighbors that's happened with
[0:50:53] the sidewalk seating or that's just an incense and courtesy unfortunately we don't have some of
[0:51:12] and that sometimes we have to make our ancestors, but sit back, I'm not sure I understand the full
[0:51:27] purpose of that one, especially with the bitches or they are and that kind of thing. I think
[0:51:34] that we've already had a population between the businesses. I've went down there with my
[0:51:39] girlfriend before and she wanted to eat a slice and I wanted to eat a sandwich company
[0:51:42] or guppies and we both went and got what we wanted and we sat at one or the other and
[0:51:47] I think the business owners have already cooperated on that, it's kind of like, to me, it's when you go to the fair, I mean, that hardly ever do you both want the same booze, and so you buy from one or the other, and you just said that I think we can work that out as well.
[0:52:08] Well, I didn't want anybody to think I wanted fences.
[0:52:11] I must have kept crossing the side of that.
[0:52:13] I was just questioning that because I know that's the norm and Boise.
[0:52:16] And whether that had to do with alcohol, and I don't know what those are,
[0:52:20] I'm pretty certain that those test off areas are on public right away.
[0:52:26] That they probably pay a fee is what I'm betting kind of like that was mentioned.
[0:52:31] They pay a fee to have that that area to the city that they utilize to utilize that public
[0:52:37] I must, with Sean, I think I'm willing to wait a week or two, let us tweak this a little bit, and uh, let's see whether we come back. I would definitely be in favor of pulling out the 5 foot, sit back. I'm not quite sure I understand why, if you've got 20 feet, you have to have 10.
[0:52:54] I guess that makes sense because you have more room, so you need to provide more public right way, but if we only need 5, I like the look of only these examples of the way I shouldn't.
[0:53:10] because I might mess up on the business name down there, but I like the fact that they have some
[0:53:14] couple of tables over close to their building and they have a table that's not closer to the street and they have a pathway between
[0:53:20] I think that provides the welcoming feel of the area and so I would hope that we don't put something in like that five foot that might
[0:53:32] preclude that from occurring and I must try to understand why that would be. So I would be willing to finish this
[0:53:40] To table this, if that's the mood of the tear-counsel, if not, I'm willing to vote for it with minus the five feet.
[0:53:47] Great, Chris, talkin' to suggest tableing, because the concept is undeniable, is in the sidewalks, and I see other peeps speak, so I won't move.
[0:54:39] As I said for a council vote tonight, so we just need some direction. I hope you'll give us some more comments.
[0:54:57] These restaurants have been serving outside all this time.
[0:55:00] Is there a problem a complaint or something we're trying to address with this?
[0:55:05] Are we trying to be proactive? Are we fixing something?
[0:55:08] If it's been working, there are reasons why we're meddling in it, I guess.
[0:55:26] It gets to me in a form of 7 different formations of chairs for the 7 kind of me.
[0:55:41] It's not as easy because you see them.
[0:55:43] There's a kind of a transition with sidewalk narrows.
[0:55:46] There's some difficulty in there about what is this person appropriate?
[0:55:49] for restaurant spaces on these corners.
[0:55:55] If the scene was up next to their walk,
[0:56:01] we're just on the access that this required.
[0:56:04] So we wanted to get something that could address
[0:56:06] just be a little more versatile.
[0:56:08] From needs of some of those restaurants,
[0:56:13] Council person Lanting, I think that's a safe environment,
[0:56:21] trying to say that and can nice if we could just picture.
[0:56:41] Is there some, there was some enforcement activity
[0:56:44] on the Saturday at one point in the chairs
[0:56:48] and we're gonna block it.
[0:56:53] We could just meet the business owners
[0:56:57] and say, hey, you can walk space through here
[0:57:00] with the official ordinance or rule.
[0:57:03] Could we try that before we turn through this?
[0:57:06] Uh, I don't know which I can show you some pictures.
[0:57:09] Like there was a time the other day when I was walking down.
[0:57:11] This is perfect.
[0:57:12] It was almost like this.
[0:57:13] I think it would be a task.
[0:57:23] Someone maybe is not responsible or you start to see
[0:57:27] some investments in these blocks further down,
[0:57:29] establish what is our regulation.
[0:57:38] This is all stemming from because.
[0:57:49] So I think that I remember this was probably several months ago.
[0:57:53] We had an incident on the Saturday.
[0:57:55] where one of the business owners took the liberty of kind of fencing the area from front of their restaurant
[0:58:01] and so the real question is what will be allowed?
[0:58:05] and I agree with a lot of the comments, you know, this is something that could be businesses
[0:58:10] but I think this was an attempt to set some parameters on
[0:58:14] Grisbee, and then they also want me right now
[0:58:23] I'm sure they don't want this to allow them to be on the sidewalk anyway, right?
[0:58:27] Does that one come in?
[0:58:30] You just set up a lawn chair and sit in there
[0:58:32] So, I'll get with you in just a minute,
[0:58:37] as we're having our discussion up here.
[0:58:43] I was a little derri of this, to be honest, at first.
[0:58:47] Through this, really is basic things, a good business,
[0:58:56] good neighbors, all things that I would like to see
[0:58:59] reworked if that's all right, A2 and A3.
[0:59:03] Those are the setbacks, the areas, just looking at that
[0:59:07] after some of the discussion.
[0:59:09] Also, putting in there, this is, I'm
[0:59:17] and Boise because of defenses and the sidewalk significantly.
[0:59:24] It could be something.
[0:59:25] Okay, so I walked down the two blocks section of where the restaurants are, and frankly,
[0:59:48] I only saw a couple that I thought should be tweaked.
[0:59:52] Everybody else seemed like they were easy to get around and through.
[1:00:00] Keep in mind there have been a couple restaurants added, and so maybe it worked out fine a couple
[1:00:07] three years ago, because last year we weren't doing it because of the construction, but I
[1:00:15] think we just sit down with some of these places and just say, okay, you know, look how close
[1:00:23] you are to the sidewalk, look that you don't have a ten foot span in between two sets of
[1:00:32] tables to rows of tables and see if we can't work it out without maybe getting
[1:00:40] crazy about adopting an ordinance and if we do adopt an ordinance I think we do
[1:00:47] have a fee just for the the labor related to doing it it's gonna require
[1:00:55] something to do that but it's not gonna be $10,000 you know it's gonna be a real
[1:01:02] reasonable E in my mind just like you paid for your driver's license. I'm here
[1:01:09] or she's also paying this day but you're paying to have something renewed and it
[1:01:14] seems to me that it's the same kind of thing if this were adopted.
[1:01:48] and hold your whole family.
[1:01:53] Adding, oh, how are you going to enforce?
[1:01:55] Can people use only a certain size of tables?
[1:01:58] Can they only hold so many people at a certain table
[1:02:02] like Terry brought up?
[1:02:03] If I sit in the wrong spot, is the cop
[1:02:05] going to come and give me a trespassing ticket
[1:02:07] for being on public property?
[1:02:09] All of these things, I understand,
[1:02:13] these guys have a job to do.
[1:02:15] I'm a fee because they're tables two foot off the line
[1:02:22] that you say they're supposed to.
[1:02:25] It takes away a business owner's ability to actually go out and bring the public in.
[1:02:32] I would just say you can't make the best one on the to decide the way the seating is allowing that seating for your input.
[1:02:58] Alright, so we will, uh, but we do have a public hearing that's scheduled, um, no sooner than six or after six, but we're still early on in our main agenda.
[1:03:16] So if you're here for the public hearing, stick around.
[1:03:20] Next on the agenda is an update on fire stations and remodels.
[1:03:24] Our programming committee is going to give us an update on the status of new fire station
[1:03:28] and remodel projects.
[1:03:29] We have Cory B on the agenda.
[1:03:32] Aaron Council, welcome.
[1:03:36] We appreciate the opportunity to give you guys an update on the work we've been doing
[1:03:41] since we last presented to you.
[1:03:45] Computer going here.
[1:04:27] Since the last time I heard a present, we started by looking at the needs that we felt
[1:04:33] for a fire station room by room.
[1:04:35] I would say emphasizing facilities that accommodate our current and future projections for staffing
[1:04:43] and equipment needs.
[1:04:45] So we have some examples of room diagrams to show you some of that work that we did.
[1:04:51] This was a look at Station 1 Bay.
[1:04:55] Now you'll notice in a lot of these pictures that there's things that we don't have and
[1:04:59] things that we currently don't do but we're trying to project what we might need
[1:05:03] 30 years from now so we're not trying to set policy you notice there's an ambulance
[1:05:07] in this one that's just a spot for that kind of a vehicle that may be an eight car
[1:05:11] maybe it's a partnership with Magic God Medics we're not dictating any of that
[1:05:16] we're just trying to foresee things that could happen in the future so a vehicle
[1:05:20] that's as this example that would be used for EMS purposes there's a diagram of a
[1:05:28] Station 2, at Bredis Bay, and again there's a zodiac and different things that we're just trying to foresee the things that might happen in the future.
[1:05:35] Station 3 Bay, and then a bedroom, so designed for sleeping space in the desk, and then some lockers outside.
[1:05:48] Restrooms that are gender-friendly currently we have, which you might call locker room-style restrooms,
[1:05:55] which aren't good if we were to hire a female employee, which will certainly happen.
[1:06:03] example of a kitchen and the sizes of the kitchens in the dining rooms and a lot of the station
[1:06:07] size things are dictated by how many bedrooms there are and what apparatus are for seeing
[1:06:12] to be in that station. So this is an example of a kitchen in stations 2, 3, and 5 which
[1:06:18] would be smaller than the station one kitchen where there's more personnel there. The dining
[1:06:22] room stations 2, 3, and 5, and then here's an example of an office space probably downtown
[1:06:31] for a battalion chief or deputy chief computer work space area which also is adjacent to the lobby
[1:06:43] here's a look at a lobby training room at station one other stations would have training
[1:06:50] rooms as well they'd just be scaled down in size bunker storage the isolated room currently we
[1:06:57] store our bunker gear in the same room as the apparatus which isn't a preferred way to do it
[1:07:02] just because of diesel costs and things and this gives our equipment a better space and we can
[1:07:07] kind of isolate that possible contaminant there and also keep it separate from other contaminants.
[1:07:13] And then just some examples, some other storage rooms. That's not all of the different rooms that we
[1:07:19] just wanted to give you an example of some of the things we looked at. As we mentioned before,
[1:07:24] all the components are designed with an emphasis on firefighter-shifting health
[1:07:27] against separating those clean and dirty areas of the station. So that after we got done with the
[1:07:33] room by room, the design team took all those boxes and put them together in a preliminary design.
[1:07:39] They also evaluated our current stations, they evaluated structural components, HVAC systems,
[1:07:48] electrical, plumbing, that kind of thing, and then they gave us a grade for each station
[1:07:53] for as it currently sits.
[1:07:55] The scale was one to five, five mean unsatisfactory, and I'm sorry, one being unsatisfactory and
[1:08:02] five being excellent.
[1:08:03] So then we took those scores and these boxes in a preliminary design and kind of evaluated
[1:08:09] through all the stations where we felt was best for our current facilities if we
[1:08:14] could remodel or if we would need to rebuild on the current site or possibly
[1:08:18] build on a different site so we'll go through those stations one by one here.
[1:08:21] So the station one current site the score on the current facility was 3.3
[1:08:28] which is they would call fair and we felt it was possible to use the current
[1:08:34] site although not optimal. We did have conversations in our group about
[1:08:39] possible other uses for the station one site because it is adjacent to the
[1:08:43] police public safety campus the possibility of them using that building
[1:08:48] and the possibility of us building elsewhere but we do have a design that
[1:08:54] would work on this current site and that's what's shown here would be a can be
[1:09:00] built of that station that's the first floor that would be the second floor of
[1:09:04] that station so we could possibly set that on the site but there's other
[1:09:08] other conversations that are ongoing in the city to see what the best option would be.
[1:09:16] Station 2, the current station 2, the score was 2.5, which was considered poor. The current
[1:09:22] facility and location are not adequate for any future growth and the building is over
[1:09:28] 40 years old and it's starting to show its age. So as you know, there's a site at Washington,
[1:09:35] I'm sorry, Chaney in Washington, and this is a diagram of how the new station would fit
[1:09:44] on that site.
[1:09:45] And again, you'll see things on these pictures that aren't necessarily going to happen.
[1:09:49] We're just trying to design those areas that we can foresee future things like you can see
[1:09:54] on this one.
[1:09:55] There's a training and education building.
[1:09:56] That's a possibility.
[1:09:58] We just wanted to make sure that these sites have room to put the things that we could possibly
[1:10:03] do in the future.
[1:10:05] It's going on to station three.
[1:10:06] The current evaluation for that station is 2.8,
[1:10:09] which again is considered poor.
[1:10:12] The current facility isn't adequate for any future growth.
[1:10:16] The site location was able to be used as it is.
[1:10:20] This picture here shows how they could
[1:10:24] rebuild a new station on this site
[1:10:26] and leave the current station in use
[1:10:28] while we do the building station four,
[1:10:34] which is at the airport.
[1:10:34] I don't have a slide on that one.
[1:10:36] The score was 4.1, which is considered
[1:10:38] good. That current facility we felt was adequate for our current needs and could meet future
[1:10:44] needs with minor addition and a remodel of that station. The projected station 5, but
[1:10:51] that site location is at Bylern-Hankins, so we looked at the ground that is there and
[1:10:58] whether or not the size of station that we thought we would fit in it does. It's a
[1:11:05] good example of that. Other things that have happened since then, we've had opportunities
[1:11:10] for our whole department to come in and weigh in on the process and where we're at, we looked at
[1:11:14] some station design things for aesthetics to see what the firefighters feel as a group would be
[1:11:21] desirable for architectural looks. We've also had conversations on standalone training facilities
[1:11:30] somewhere in the city. There's talks of land that might be available for that and we've talked about
[1:11:37] what kind of facilities we would possibly have. We kind of felt that was outside of the current
[1:11:41] scope of this programming, because that would probably need a whole team on its own, because
[1:11:45] that would be such a big project.
[1:11:47] So, we have started those conversations though.
[1:11:51] We did talk about partnerships with other agencies in the area, other fire departments
[1:11:56] in the area, especially with the training facilities, whether or not that would be some
[1:11:59] sort of regional facility.
[1:12:00] But again, these are very preliminary, just trying to understand if there's interest in
[1:12:05] some of the community for something like that that would be shared.
[1:12:09] And we also had a meeting that included call volume data from 2017 that was reflective
[1:12:16] of our EMS response that we've taken on, just to make sure that these locations that we're
[1:12:22] looking at would be appropriate for the station.
[1:12:24] So we're scheduled to meet in early June again with our CITEC team and the plan is that they're
[1:12:32] going to give us concept design and then some preliminary financial estimates that could
[1:12:37] be used for budgeting purposes.
[1:12:38] So the next time we come to you, we anticipate actually having heart numbers that we could
[1:12:43] actually talk about numbers and we're going to go from there.
[1:12:47] So that's what I had, so I've had any questions if you had any.
[1:13:18] Is necessary.
[1:13:23] I also am on Saturday and a sort of is expected of them in the facility to be used by, like
[1:13:57] you say, lots of entities that would make a percent chance of surviving a car instead
[1:14:06] of 17% chance.
[1:14:07] I kind of like that.
[1:14:08] I don't want to be in a car crash.
[1:14:10] My ads have gotten better because people are better trained.
[1:14:13] I thought that was kind of cool because they still know but it's what somebody their responsibilities
[1:14:23] are and how widely spread they are in a given situation where all the money is broken.
[1:14:31] It's impressive and this is really important.
[1:14:40] Also we did look at adding components at each of the sites for on-site training for the
[1:14:45] stations but that's very limited what you can do at a single station.
[1:14:50] We are trying to find ways to train any station, but the ultimate goal is to have a training facility where you can do more in depth things.
[1:14:56] Just to make sure I'm clear, if the one do, you showed us the drive for station number two.
[1:15:15] Is it thought to keep it and the one out by Jenkins or I should be out by, uh, uh, uh, watching to a chain year or one or the other?
[1:15:23] We wanted the other.
[1:15:24] Okay.
[1:15:25] Yeah, our, our talk was to not use station two anymore and build a new station two at a different site.
[1:15:33] Part of the advantage of that is that in Station Duke and State Functional, while the new Station Duke is being built,
[1:15:40] I don't, we didn't talk about what the use of that property would be in the future if we weren't too built.
[1:15:48] Well the, you know, you showed us a design of what it might look like if you tried to utilize Station 1 where it is right now.
[1:15:57] Do you have thoughts of where Station 1 would be if we had chosen to move into a different location?
[1:16:03] talk about some other city property, but again, I think that would be considered preliminary
[1:16:08] because, you know, we know that there's property out there, but that doesn't mean that we can
[1:16:12] just say the fire department wants it and we get it. So we talked about that. I believe
[1:16:16] that there's other locations available. I think the city management team would speak
[1:16:21] on that better than I would unless one would look for did you have something to add?
[1:16:41] I do just to kind of add on to what Captain Dean was already said and maybe talk a little
[1:16:45] bit about what the next step looks like. But I wanted to say, honestly, it's been a
[1:16:49] privilege the programming team. It's just been a privilege working with this team.
[1:16:52] They've done a really good job and I think you've seen some of the concepts
[1:16:56] that they've put together. They're serious about it and they're serious about their
[1:17:00] space, their programming needs specific to fire and to the technical side of it.
[1:17:05] But as we move forward now part of what Captain Bean shared with you two is
[1:17:10] there's a lot of unknowns and so it's always been our intent to provide a
[1:17:14] community fire asset that would last for 34 years and we believe that given the
[1:17:19] scope of this potential project because it has a huge impact on our community that we
[1:17:25] should make every effort to involve community while respecting firefighters technical needs
[1:17:32] and programming needs. So at this point, our first step has really been just meeting with
[1:17:36] that fire programming team and asking them, you know, what do you need to do your job
[1:17:39] and what does that look like? And as we move forward now in the concept of putting these
[1:17:43] stations into play, what they look like, it's probably worthwhile to have a conversation
[1:17:53] with you at the next step.
[1:17:55] Really with that, that comes to me to ask
[1:17:59] for your general improvement process
[1:18:01] of forming a citizen advisory committee.
[1:18:04] And this is something that we've talked about.
[1:18:06] This is a process that we've used over the years.
[1:18:08] It's been a very successful process
[1:18:10] in blending the technical and programming needs
[1:18:12] of our professionals with community's responsibility.
[1:18:16] I mean, these are community projects.
[1:18:19] And these are community assets
[1:18:21] that the committee would,
[1:18:25] as a lot of our communities in the past,
[1:18:28] have done would really evaluate that we would use it to validate the programming needs to
[1:18:32] really take a look at it, to provide additional feedback on site selection and help evaluate
[1:18:37] our current properties specific to those programming needs.
[1:18:41] Help us address the current and future training needs as Captain Beam talked about.
[1:18:45] There's a lot of unknowns and there's a lot of questions.
[1:18:48] We'll approach what not be a regional approach.
[1:18:50] How does this work out?
[1:18:51] How can we get our community involved in this?
[1:18:53] And then also help us and guide us in the funding of this project.
[1:18:58] This is an expensive project and as we move forward we really feel like it's important to have some community.
[1:19:03] So we would recommend, like we've done in the past, the composition of the community that would be represented by Council.
[1:19:12] In this particular case we would probably recommend a member of the fire district because they are a true partner and we do provide service to them.
[1:19:19] And then we would like to see seven community members falls sitting on.
[1:19:28] So I'm not asking for formal action tonight, but I am just looking for your general direction.
[1:19:37] It has real potential for specific programming needs.
[1:19:42] These techniques ask that, I mean, the goal has always been to put something in play.
[1:19:53] So with that, I would stand for any additional questions.
[1:19:58] Before you said, you'd have been one of Chinavas, my direction is all in the process.
[1:20:15] I think it's something we can put together.
[1:20:22] The agenda isn't update on the current state of the recycling program and market in a discussion
[1:20:37] at the next stage of the small cart pilot program.
[1:20:42] Bill Baxter?
[1:20:43] Good and Council.
[1:20:44] I appreciate the chance to come before you again.
[1:20:49] So the first thing I'm going to kick off with because it's very brief is we are going to
[1:20:53] start what is the second step in our pilot program is to see how it goes in another piece
[1:21:02] the city before going to select the area between North College and the
[1:21:11] northern boundary of the city limits and Blue Lakes and the Western
[1:21:15] boundary. That's going to be in the neighborhood of 2000 or so homes I believe
[1:21:21] the North 35 opens people's selection process so they can't decide if they're
[1:21:39] not going to need the full 95 gallon cart size for garbage. They can go with a
[1:21:44] 65, about two thirds the size, or a 35-gallon cart, a caveat that comes with that is you don't
[1:21:51] get extras except three times a year, so designated huge success in the area, we've been 68 people
[1:22:06] into the 65-gallon cart, and I think we have including the grandfather, one can, folks, we
[1:22:14] have about 113 or 41 person, select the 35, extras out, find out, they didn't get picked
[1:22:31] up and call in and ask why, and it's like, oh, gotta be clear, that isn't available except
[1:22:37] three times a year.
[1:22:38] It's a process we want to continue opening that up a little less cost in the garden.
[1:22:51] So as I go into the recycle garden, unless there are other questions, the recycling process,
[1:23:00] a slideshow I was going to just because this gives you combination.
[1:23:15] This is the biggest issue across the country, has probably led us into the issue with China
[1:23:20] refusing to take recycling products from the United States and not to bore you, this is fairly short but it'll roll around it.
[1:23:29] The same kind of things these photographs were taken over a period of about a week, barriers by PSI drivers.
[1:23:39] So for April, we collected 155.47 tons of recycling material, which all, because of the cost-sharing arrangement,
[1:23:54] The continued pricing pressure is happening because volume stockpiles are increasing, and
[1:24:01] even some communities which have stockpiled hoping for a change have decided, okay, now
[1:24:07] we're going to throw it away, plan it stockpiled, the cost factor for April was still at $164
[1:24:20] with Western recycling in Boise.
[1:24:23] That is projected to hump up again over 170 waste management at their facility in Washington.
[1:24:32] is adding $7.50 per ton contamination, sorting that's going on in a very good direction right now,
[1:24:46] but that is the site where most of Boise's volume, including ours, ends up going,
[1:24:51] being a price impact to us as well. Change in the market conditions still,
[1:25:02] the story is it will require some time. There are some end users are going to need to invest in equipment
[1:25:08] and to process the material into a usable product.
[1:25:12] There is a company in Arlington, Texas as an example that takes the difficult to recycle
[1:25:18] plastic scrap and they're making street signs, art benches, and other usable products from
[1:25:24] that.
[1:25:25] It's costly.
[1:25:26] Recyclers are also going to need to modify and upgrade their sorting equipment.
[1:25:35] In a moment here I'll put up something from Penn Waste.
[1:25:38] They did a $3.5 million retrofit on a 96,000 square foot recycling facility for a sorting
[1:25:47] facility where they have also modified their paper mix, and they are finding success selling
[1:25:54] about 80% of that to India.
[1:25:57] People are making changes in the market, it just will take a while before those become
[1:26:02] ones, especially for communities in areas like we are to reach out quite a ways to find
[1:26:11] processing facility.
[1:26:14] increase in use of technology is being pushed primarily to control contamination. Sensors
[1:26:20] on dumpsters, how all this works but to sense what's in it, how it fills up when it's full
[1:26:27] of trips required, also to help with draining the facility of recycling efforts. But this
[1:26:42] truck sensor is also a monitor, so they can fine and or educate people at the sites where
[1:26:50] truck is unloading, reduce, reuse and recycle is a mantra that's been around for a while.
[1:26:59] This is the question. Right now, to say, recycling, which has been the most popular, feel-good
[1:27:07] opportunity, is not where we should start. Be start with reducing amount of recyclable
[1:27:17] materials that are involved in our use of products. Fags contain washing outcomes before
[1:27:27] you just throw them away, and then recycle should be the last. Let waste today in the
[1:27:46] quotation. Frickle as while recycling makes companies and consumers feel good, the thought
[1:27:51] of reducing waste often invokes something akin to a fear response from the public, as people
[1:27:57] feel they have a right to consume with their discretion. The problem with that is, this
[1:28:02] approach is no longer reasonable or sustainable as we're seeing from the efforts at the present
[1:28:10] formation, utilizing the good information that's been in the Times News and online for
[1:28:20] other locations about recycling non-signal stream items, contamination reduction, these
[1:28:28] photos are probably the best example of by this education. One of the issues you know
[1:28:45] is that it's complicated, executive director of Recycling Cross America, which says you
[1:28:53] can't educate more because whenever we go out in public or even at home the rules are
[1:28:58] different. The way the information presented is completely different and truthfully it's
[1:29:02] presented in such a bad way that it's hard for people to get too serious, shorten the message, clean it up, it's hard to reach people.
[1:29:17] Other people are thinking we need to move away from the single street.
[1:29:20] This is where some of the problem has come.
[1:29:22] With containers, it is hard to separate the paper.
[1:29:27] Even if it's not contaminated from single streams, it's been around for many years, it's fairly simple and easy.
[1:29:39] It also introduces the market, pressure is still there.
[1:29:48] Our message to Arting Things I know for the question this is,
[1:29:54] Why are we even doing this and prices will come down, but again, it could process before
[1:30:08] we will finally be in this piece of it, never go away, so without it would stand for any questions.
[1:30:31] The piece I put in front of you is from Penn Waste.
[1:30:34] I found it interesting, I think it's at aluminum, we throw away within one month would redo
[1:30:40] the whole state says that recycling is important and there's some other facts in there just seem
[1:30:50] brilliant. I was mostly thankful. I didn't recognize my recycling in a few minutes. Next on the agenda
[1:31:05] is a request to authorize the purchase of approximately 1.7 acres of real property located on the east
[1:31:11] side of Hankins Road. 325 feet north of Phoenix. A few minutes ago we had a report from Captain
[1:31:26] being talking about the progress of our fire station planning effort. You notice
[1:31:33] that at some point in there he said future fire station number five fits on
[1:31:37] the site here. What they analyzed was the proposed site here. So up on the screen
[1:31:43] you have a map. It shows that we own just about two acres. It's in the blue
[1:31:49] box. We already currently own that. There's a there's a PI station at that
[1:31:54] location right now, that PI station needs some room to expand that station serves the entire
[1:32:01] morning sun, yes, or the disc morning sun, but into the sub-dramatic area station. In addition to that,
[1:32:18] the water that's going into that PI station is really, really dirty water, probably some of the
[1:32:26] dirtiest water in town, and it clogs that station up very regularly, and so we need to do something,
[1:32:33] most likely some kind of unsettling pond to settle that.
[1:32:42] And so that's going to need and demand some space at this location.
[1:32:47] So when you look at the PI station needs that are there,
[1:32:52] the rest of that site, property is not suitable for future fire station.
[1:32:57] Our fire station location now assessed about two years ago.
[1:33:02] Some of you might remember going through that process and then
[1:33:05] identified this location as a pretty good future location for this fire station.
[1:33:10] station and so we started talking to Jason property hunter to figure out if
[1:33:14] that opportunity was there to purchase what is in the box in red with the little star
[1:33:21] on it and so they're willing to sell it to your fire station when I say future I
[1:33:35] don't know when the future is for the fire station it's it's out a little ways
[1:33:39] probably but are also early conversation about morning Sun number 10 in developing
[1:33:50] that right now if we don't get it now we will have the opportunity and so that's
[1:33:56] why we're approaching you now price for $64,000
[1:34:01] inches in the report in the site of $64,239 to purchase 1.7 acres of this
[1:34:07] location it is for future fire station the fire station serves future growth
[1:34:13] and so it's eligible to use impact fees fire impact fees for this acquisition
[1:34:20] We have over $1.9 million in fire station and pipe fees in the bank, so we've certainly got the money to cover it.
[1:34:28] So tonight we just want to ask if Council would be agreeable to us, but losing out of this purchase with the $64,000 in $39,000 for this property.
[1:34:49] So we'd have to do a couple of different things to speak here, but I guess the decision would be what do we do with it?
[1:35:17] sell it if we do we would refund or reimburse the the fund if we used it for
[1:35:23] some other purpose that the fire fees are not eligible for we would have to
[1:35:27] reimburse the fire fund for those fees those fees are only for fire and so if we
[1:35:34] did the worst been in the fees. Well I was actually a good question for
[1:36:18] me to PI station go forward this the season with expanded fire to PI station
[1:36:28] there we don't have anything in the current years budget to do anything out
[1:36:34] with it. My understanding is that our water supply crew is kind of what the best solution is.
[1:36:42] There's a number of different solutions, so it happened in the works just yet. We just know it's
[1:36:46] something is needed. I don't know as far as how much land, which 1.7 was probably a little more than
[1:36:57] maybe the fire station on the 1.7 you leave some of that bottom for for PI station fixes. I think 1.7 is enough.
[1:37:10] to comment, since I get next to the ex-stationals on a daily basis, on the next to the four green at the golf course, that water's been really dirty this year, and I didn't know there was a this year problem, more a continual problem there without the water this year in the, in that, in that settling pond for the golf course has been amazing, the dirty, dirty that I remember at any other time, but that'd be bad, I didn't know it was a, a bad day.
[1:37:48] I don't know about that one out there, but here you can see in the picture where the
[1:38:00] PI station is right below the sea and we're in city.
[1:38:05] You notice there's no pond there right now.
[1:38:07] This is one of our PI stations that's built with basically a box.
[1:38:10] It kind of flows into the box and gets sucked out and what doesn't get sucked down.
[1:38:15] It goes down the pipe pretty quickly.
[1:38:17] It doesn't sit there very long.
[1:38:19] It's not settling out in them. It wasn't designed for them.
[1:38:23] If you look upstream to the east, you can see the canal that's going right into it.
[1:38:29] You can run south a little bit of the east off-site, and if you know this area, you know that that canal is coming across several large farms.
[1:38:41] It's a base farm, too, which is a run-off.
[1:38:44] It's going to be a first-dender run-off, almost a big rock.
[1:38:47] And so all that rough is going into this canal and then it's ending up right in that station.
[1:38:53] That's why this one is particularly dirty.
[1:38:58] I'd like to make motion if I mean Chris was interested so I'll second it though go ahead Chris.
[1:39:08] What the third floor was expenditure of $64,239 from the Firey Unpack fee.
[1:39:16] The purchase is approximately 1.7 acres of real property located on the east side of the
[1:39:21] Hankins Road, 325 feet north of Father Avenue.
[1:39:25] Second.
[1:39:26] Motion to the second to authorize the purchase as presented as there any further discussion.
[1:39:44] Greg Lanting.
[1:39:45] Yes.
[1:39:46] Ruth Piers.
[1:39:47] Yes.
[1:39:48] Christopher Reed.
[1:39:49] Yes.
[1:39:50] Chris Tawkington.
[1:39:51] Yes.
[1:39:52] John Berger.
[1:39:53] Yes.
[1:39:54] Nicky Boyd.
[1:39:56] Yes.
[1:39:57] passes 7-0.
[1:39:59] motion passes 7-0 now next on the agenda we have a request to adopt an ordinance
[1:40:08] for a zoning district change zoning map amendment from R2 to R2 pro for property
[1:40:15] located at 104 Lincoln Street Jonathan Spentlow thank you mayor the council the
[1:40:22] background on March 27th public hearing was held by the planning and zoning
[1:40:25] commission here a few comments by residents and that vote was in 9-0 on
[1:40:30] April 23rd, the City Council heard the same request.
[1:40:36] There was no public input regarding the item
[1:40:38] and there was some discussion after the,
[1:40:41] after some discussion, the Council proved that vote
[1:40:44] by about a six to zero.
[1:40:46] As a result, the staff has prepared an ordinance
[1:40:49] as directed and the Council wishes to pass it this evening.
[1:40:55] This has been the rules placed at Hunter and final
[1:40:57] and the simple majority.
[1:41:11] 2018, zero, one.
[1:41:42] Thank you by second by great landing to suspend the rules and place coordinates 2018 dash
[1:41:47] further discussion.
[1:42:03] Raised pairs.
[1:42:04] Yes.
[1:42:05] Christopher Reed.
[1:42:06] Yes.
[1:42:07] Chris Talkington.
[1:42:08] Yes.
[1:42:09] John Berger.
[1:42:10] Yes.
[1:42:11] Nicky Boyd.
[1:42:12] Yes.
[1:42:13] Suzanne Hawkins.
[1:42:15] Yes.
[1:42:19] He's working on it.
[1:42:20] Motion passes.
[1:42:21] Seven to zero.
[1:42:22] Ordinance number 2018-015 and ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho
[1:42:46] Resort zoning a certain real property
[1:42:49] Hello described providing the zoning clarification therefore in ordering the necessary area of impact in zoning districts map
[1:44:17] Sharon Bryan stand up please.
[1:44:25] So tonight since staff is going to request that we do not meet next Tuesday is Sharon's
[1:44:36] last official city council meeting as an employee of the City of Twin Falls.
[1:44:42] Sharon has been with our city and served 42 years as the longest ten year to we'd like
[1:44:56] I'd like to thank Darren tonight for her years of service,
[1:45:03] also knowing that on May 31st, from two to four o'clock,
[1:45:07] we're gonna be hosting a celebration in Sharon's honor,
[1:45:09] but if we could give Sharon a round of applause
[1:45:12] for 42 years of service.
[1:45:26] I'm sure Chris has a mill on council water.
[1:45:29] I say Sharon, that's why we may have such an easy night
[1:45:33] for him, I would know.
[1:45:34] And thank you, my Sharon, for all that you've done
[1:45:38] the city and all that you've done for us as the council and I'm sorry that we
[1:45:42] didn't have cake tonight but we can't have food in this room.
[1:45:47] And then Mr. Member of the Council, you'll also notice a new face in the writing co-pilot
[1:45:55] with Sharon this evening and we'd like to welcome Amy Luna to our organization.
[1:46:00] She will now be serving in this role and she will be meeting for us.
[1:46:08] Anything else from the City Manager's Office?
[1:46:15] Travis?
[1:46:16] Yes sir.
[1:46:17] Excellent.
[1:46:18] As so we will move to our public hearings now we have one scheduled for this evening.
[1:46:23] This is a request to amend Cedar Park PUD number 210 to allow a planned residential fourplex
[1:46:30] development on one log within the C1 zone as a dated area as shown on the master development
[1:46:37] plan.
[1:46:38] at the northwest corner of Meadow View Lane, extended in Addison Avenue East, and we have
[1:46:44] Dave Tebow with EHM engineers on behalf of Summit Development this evening. Welcome, Dave.
[1:46:50] Thanks for sticking around. Good evening, Mr. Mayor and members of the City Council. My name
[1:46:54] is Dave Tebow with EHM engineers located at 621 North College Road. This evening, we're
[1:47:00] looking at a piece of property that's situated north about us in Avenue East and Carageway
[1:47:05] North. It's a piece of property that's included within the Cedar Park PUD. We've requested that
[1:47:13] allow to amend the construction of four plex units within the C1 commercial. PUD is a permitted use.
[1:47:24] The C1 zoning ordinance identifies that multiple household dwelling units are appropriate.
[1:47:31] Parenthesis it does define that that is five units or more. And so our request is to that we
[1:47:39] We'd be allowed to build four plexus.
[1:47:42] We have submitted a master plan.
[1:47:46] Switch over to that.
[1:47:49] But this is in advance of our preparation
[1:47:51] to create a one-law subdivision
[1:47:53] so that some of development
[1:47:54] it'll be able to move forward with their project
[1:47:58] down to construction, Harrison, Streetman Falls here,
[1:48:06] with us and the city so much
[1:48:07] that they've identified a second site
[1:48:09] and like to proceed with their project
[1:48:14] at a second site on the east side of town.
[1:48:16] When a nutshell, we've reviewed the staff recommendations
[1:48:19] and the report that's been prepared this evening.
[1:48:23] no objection to those conditions being a part of the approval but we're here
[1:48:27] seeking approval this evening would be able to stand for any questions that you
[1:48:31] might not see any so we'll turn it over to Jonathan for the staff report he
[1:48:48] also says it's kind of the older format we've got to a different reports the
[1:48:54] cedar part pud that comes about 132 acres it happened in the late 90s
[1:48:59] this eventually recorded in early 2000s 2004 and there was a preliminary
[1:49:04] presentation with the Planning and Zoning Commission there was a
[1:49:07] We are really only talking about changing that allows for four plexus, that's four dwelling units in one building, every in a C1 zone, or it says multiple household, five units or more.
[1:49:29] We only change that requesting on this BUD amendment, there's nothing else.
[1:49:38] We do have a master building, it shows buildings with four plexus.
[1:49:43] Similarly, there's something approved previously for the location.
[1:49:48] The West, so it's not unprecedented for Plexus to be in this area.
[1:49:55] The Addison Springs Complexus is here, and they did a similar...
[1:50:00] They requested to go through the ZDA process to get the same thing as opposed to just a minute.
[1:50:05] This one truly is for talking about...
[1:50:08] Onings only commission had that meeting, and there was a unanimous vote to recommend approval.
[1:50:16] Council may approve their request, and neither request or table the request for additional information.
[1:50:22] Council concludes to approve this request as presented. Staff has fine recommendations.
[1:50:28] The public decide plan amendments as required by building engineering for its own officials to ensure compliance with applicable codes.
[1:50:34] Standards number two subject to approval by all property owners prior to recordation. Number three subject to assign PUD.
[1:50:40] Address the council on this issue and has your opportunity to close the public hearing.
[1:51:16] to council and the cedar park pud number two ten to allow a planned residential
[1:51:41] for plexas listed motion by susan hockon seconded by chris reed to pre-quest as
[1:51:58] presented for the discussion chris talked experience this is not normally a
[1:52:05] the zoning request changer or is it a housing that they're meant to stand for
[1:53:04] in order to have some christopher reed yes was talking to yes
[1:53:21] On Burger? Yes.
[1:53:23] Mickey Boyd? Yes.
[1:53:24] Suzanne Hawkins? Yes.
[1:53:26] Frank Lanting? Yes.
[1:53:27] And Rose Pierce? Yes.
[1:53:29] Bunch of passes, 7-0.
[1:53:38] No other business that meeting has adjourned?
