Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2018-04-16, recording 1 (started 17:00)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2018-04-16/

[0:00:00] The first item of the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance, those of you wishing to join us, please rise.
[0:00:05] I pledge to the
[0:00:41] all of them last week. The next on the agenda is the opportunity for general public input.
[0:00:47] If there's anyone who wishes to address the council on an item that is not on the agenda
[0:00:51] this evening, now is your opportunity to please come forward. G8s, would please state your
[0:01:04] name and whether you are a resident or property owner in the City of Twin Falls for the record,
[0:01:09] please. Thank you, Sean. My name is Ron Yates. I am a property owner of Twin Falls. I live
[0:01:14] but 441 Elm Street are Twin Falls.
[0:01:18] And three things to say in regard to this building,
[0:01:25] thank you for making wise use of resources.
[0:01:28] It's tremendous, it's really beautiful.
[0:01:32] Secondly, on the second level,
[0:01:35] once I ran a banner that read One City Honesty,
[0:01:41] we are genuine and transparent.
[0:01:43] Trust decisions of others are accountable for our actions.
[0:01:48] What we say, be by example, has always been true
[0:01:54] when I've spoken with city staff every single time,
[0:01:59] many, many years that I've been a resident of Twin Falls.
[0:02:03] I'm very happy that that's always been a pleasant
[0:02:06] and helpful beneficial exchange.
[0:02:11] Number three, today I made a public comment
[0:02:16] at the City of Twin Falls,
[0:02:18] but the Historic Preservation Commission
[0:02:21] three suggestions to make. My time was at the end of the hour and I'd like you to
[0:02:30] please review my time in regard to the historic preservation mission. I wrote a
[0:02:35] letter once several months ago about the only other time that I had an
[0:02:39] interaction with Ms. Taylor. I had no response. It's happened again. I'd like
[0:02:45] you to take some action. I'd like to have a response. It includes my thank yous and my
[0:03:29] very specific they mentioned temple detour. This is not a reflection on for
[0:03:35] against any particular religion or business but all the people I did not
[0:03:39] remember that we provide detour directions for any profit or non-profit
[0:03:46] spoken with Travis a little bit and he says that's not quite the point but
[0:03:51] perhaps I could ask Travis to give a clarification on city policy or somebody
[0:03:57] I also have even more relevant knowledge on that.
[0:04:00] I'll take this one.
[0:04:01] Thank you, Troy.
[0:04:02] So there's a few projects throughout town.
[0:04:04] It's not, it actually is fairly common for us.
[0:04:08] If we impact the business and intermittently, especially with access, it's confusing at all.
[0:04:14] We actually put into our budget some traffic, site each identifies where the business is located.
[0:04:20] It tries to help them still succeed in making that business ago.
[0:04:26] of sinning now is really business, but it's our effort to identify signage to people if
[0:04:39] a business is in and we know about it and we can make the project proceed a little better.
[0:04:43] Traffic signage is on it several times on the SunDrive, the least nursery, Kmart, some
[0:04:56] of those we recently done.
[0:04:57] Are you using taxpayers dollars to assess profit and non-profit or highway need to earn?
[0:05:07] It's an identification of where they are, so I would put that into traffic control type stuff because when people are driving in an narrow roadway, some sign that if they miss a business or something, it really ends up being so weak.
[0:05:37] I was fairly common too with the Blue Lakes Project. The state did several years ago. There were all of the various
[0:05:43] accesses that were closed up between false and holy. If we can, if we really can plan it, well.
[0:05:50] We're quite glad not to have a deed to resign and drag your people to my house.
[0:06:00] All right, so we will move to the next item on the agenda, which is the consent calendar buttons push Nikki Boy.
[0:06:15] motion by Nikki Boyd seconded by Chris Reed to approve the consent calendar is
[0:06:27] there any discussion here I'll call please John Berger yes Nikki Boyd yes
[0:06:38] the van Hawkins yes great landing yes yes yes Christopher Reed yes
[0:06:47] talking yes motion passes seven to zero so last week we had someone who said
[0:06:53] to the entire meeting awaiting their consent calendar items, so just to quickly review here,
[0:06:59] if you are here for any of the agreements related to the Z-Country Estates subdivision,
[0:07:06] or the changing of the street name from Moonlight Loop to Twilight Loop,
[0:07:12] we're done with those, so you don't have to stick around unless you want to. You're more than welcome
[0:07:16] to stay. Next on the agenda, under items of consideration, the first is a request to hold
[0:07:22] the Shoshun Falls Light Event on May 17th, 18th, and 19th 2018 in Shoshun Falls Park.
[0:07:28] We have Sergeant Justin Diamond from the Twin Falls Police Department. Welcome, sir.
[0:07:33] Good evening, Mayor, Members Council. We have received a special event application to hold the
[0:07:38] Twin Falls, excuse me, the Shoshun Falls Light Event as the Shoshun Falls Park on the dates
[0:07:43] that were listed May 17th, 18th, and 19th. I've actually asked it's a request that was given to us
[0:07:50] by Southern Idaho Tourism, it's speaking to them was a various and a representative to
[0:07:56] kind of explain the event and explain kind of the unique nature of the event. I know it's normally
[0:08:03] our practice to put most of the events on the consent calendar, but this is the first event of
[0:08:08] this kind to ever be proposed as Sean Falls Park to include the falls. So we've asked Mr.
[0:08:16] Mr. Dan Olmsted is here to represent Southern Idaho Tourism.
[0:08:20] He's going to explain the event, answer any questions you might have and then have any
[0:08:25] for me.
[0:08:28] Thank you.
[0:08:30] Thank you Mr. Mayor and Council.
[0:08:31] I'm Dan Olmsted.
[0:08:32] My day job is with Idaho Power Company.
[0:08:34] Business address is 243.
[0:08:35] Little Lakes, Boulevard, South, Twin Falls, Idaho, 3301.
[0:08:36] As was mentioned, I'm here tonight.
[0:08:37] Lulex Boulevard, South Twin Falls, Idaho, 3301.
[0:08:42] As was mentioned, I'm here tonight,
[0:08:45] ending in from Melissa Berry,
[0:08:46] who's the Executive Director of Center of Iotourism.
[0:08:50] I'm currently the Chair, Board of Center of Iotourism.
[0:08:55] Unique event, I'm gonna read a little teaser for you,
[0:09:01] points of experience with the thundering power
[0:09:08] of 212-foot Shoshone Falls,
[0:09:11] rained by lights and lasers.
[0:09:15] Twin Falls Idaho right now, there's a spectacular show happening in southern Idaho at Shoshone Falls, known as the Niagara of the West.
[0:09:24] People can see and hear the thundering power of the waterfall as the snake river flows at approximately 15,000 cubic feet per second, or right over the falls.
[0:09:35] Joe Shawn Falls is 45 feet higher than Niagara Falls and attracts locals and visitors from all over the world.
[0:09:43] Light and a laser show at Joe Shawn Falls is a three day event.
[0:09:47] After the park's normal hours would be the first time in its thundering falls were eliminated.
[0:09:55] We aim to create a unique family-friendly event to celebrate Juan Vida's most iconic attractions in one of the most exciting ways possible.
[0:10:04] This is a major fundraising effort for Southern Idaho Tourism.
[0:10:09] As was mentioned, A17 through 19th will be the event.
[0:10:13] It will begin after dusk and we are requesting after hours access to Shoshoom Falls Park.
[0:10:20] Evening families activities and food vendors with 20 to 25 minute laser light show will show on the falls.
[0:10:30] General admission tickets will be sold for $10 to $15 with an option to upgrade to platform viewing.
[0:10:37] keeping the numbers limited on the platform.
[0:10:42] Attendings will park at River Christian Fellowship and be bused to the endings will also be given wristbands.
[0:10:50] Those that wish to walk into the park would be allowed to do so with the wristband.
[0:10:56] No outside containers of food will be allowed.
[0:10:59] Some on-site parking will be allowed for vendors and handy compact parking.
[0:11:04] We asked the city to sweep the parking lot per normal closing procedure
[0:11:08] and ask the park to our cars to exit the park.
[0:11:12] On-site tickets will be sold, so they are welcome.
[0:11:15] Re-enter the park with the ticket purchase.
[0:11:18] We will be requesting the park security stay for an additional couple of hours
[0:11:22] to help with the event so that I don't have to resume pay for those hours.
[0:11:26] We will have appropriate lost child booth and an EMT station.
[0:11:31] We do expect about a thousand people to not know those are just some of the talking points that Melissa left me.
[0:11:41] I would answer any questions if there's any questions for Dan.
[0:11:52] You're in teen good weather and water over the falls, I'm not so sure.
[0:11:55] You're in the conditions right now, we should have water over the falls.
[0:12:01] Weather in May is...
[0:12:03] It's for Dan.
[0:12:09] I might also make a statement that years ago, I know power company did eliminate some
[0:12:19] high floodlight type and power and floodlight lights, we discontinued that a number of years
[0:12:25] I was really excited when I read this, but I'm going to Stone Mountain to see the laser
[0:12:43] show in two weeks and I thought, draft, I spent all that money to go down there and I could
[0:12:47] have stayed home having known earlier.
[0:12:49] But you can give us a good report on how it turns out over there.
[0:12:53] I think it's a great idea and I'm glad you guys are putting the effort into it.
[0:12:57] We'll say I think this is an outstanding opportunity to help to showcase tourism in our region,
[0:13:05] certainly celebrating one of our most iconic natural features that we have,
[0:13:08] but doing it in such a way that can draw some more visitors to town and help to see the slender down there.
[0:13:14] No, Melissa had contemplated this during the winter months when we knew we were having a lot of flow down there,
[0:13:22] but access is a little more treacherous in the winter months with the mist down there,
[0:13:27] there's some happy to see that Dan decided to leave the water on for us for a little while.
[0:13:32] He can give it a try at me. Great planting.
[0:13:35] Dan, the brings the questions that are going to be outside advertising,
[0:13:39] like Boise area, Pocatello, I don't fall as that type of thing, you're just local.
[0:13:45] I'm assuming there will be some outside advertising, although that's not going to be talking points.
[0:13:49] Okay.
[0:13:50] So I can't answer that at this point.
[0:13:52] Okay.
[0:13:53] We'll be promoting that as much as we possibly can, and hopefully draw visitors from outside.
[0:13:58] that likely there will be a lot of folks as you know that come from
[0:14:01] not in communities anyway this will be just in there.
[0:14:06] Chris Tockington.
[0:14:10] Oh I would move to approve the Chisholm Falls Lighting Event May 1718 at 19 as well as
[0:14:16] 20, no 1718 the 19th Chisholm Falls Park per the discussion by us Chairman.
[0:14:23] Second.
[0:14:25] Motion by Chris Tockington second by Ruth appears to approve the event as requested.
[0:14:29] Ruth did you have an additional comment?
[0:14:32] There any discussion on the motion?
[0:14:36] Virgin Diamond, do you have anything else to add?
[0:14:41] Here, I'll call vote please.
[0:14:47] Hey, boy, yes.
[0:14:51] Rec landing.
[0:14:51] Yes.
[0:14:52] Repairs.
[0:14:53] Yes.
[0:14:54] Christopher Reed.
[0:14:55] Yes.
[0:14:56] Chris Talkington.
[0:14:57] Yes.
[0:14:58] Non-baricar.
[0:14:59] Yes.
[0:15:00] Motion passes 7-0.
[0:15:02] Thank you.
[0:15:03] Thank you.
[0:15:07] Thank you.
[0:15:08] Next on the agenda is a presentation of the Twin Falls Police Department's 2017 annual report
[0:15:13] to the city council and we have our chief of police,
[0:15:15] Craig Kingsbury, welcome chief.
[0:15:18] Thank you mayor and council.
[0:15:19] Jews were a little more conducive
[0:15:21] to the steps there today than they were on Saturday.
[0:15:24] Yes, sir, they were, and I will tell you,
[0:15:27] if you haven't walked up or down stairs in high eels,
[0:15:30] it is not easy.
[0:15:31] You ladies that do that on a regular basis,
[0:15:33] kudos to you, my right foot still hurts,
[0:15:36] but it was a great event.
[0:15:38] Mayor and council and members of our community,
[0:15:41] I'm here to go over our 2017 annual report from the Twin Falls Police Department.
[0:15:47] I believe all of you received at least an email version and we have some hard copies.
[0:15:51] Did we leave some of the dias?
[0:15:54] We can get, we have some, so I'll throw it down, I'll have some track, okay, craveless will make
[0:15:59] sure you get one.
[0:16:00] Now I'm going to hit some of the highlights of things that happened this past year for
[0:16:06] your police department.
[0:16:07] I want to say that as your Chief of Police, I feel very honored to be able to represent
[0:16:14] these fine men and women that go out each and every day to protect and serve our community.
[0:16:19] So running through the list of highlights, first and foremost, would be the new slash remodel
[0:16:25] facilities.
[0:16:26] I know that all of you have had a chance to come and tour them and take a look at them,
[0:16:30] but I can tell you and ensure the community, the men and women that work at the Twin Falls
[0:16:36] Police Department, they're working in just such a better environment, the physical location,
[0:16:44] the cleanliness and the tools that we now have in those buildings, you know, with the
[0:16:50] old city hall and the police operations building.
[0:16:54] The new facilities, the number one highlight and accomplishment, I believe, for our community
[0:16:59] for your police department.
[0:17:01] Number two is the formation of the Special Investigations Unit.
[0:17:04] You have heard me talk before about the partnership with Sheriff Carter and the Twin Falls County Sheriff's Office and the formation of our
[0:17:13] Special investigations unit which consist of members both of the Twin Falls Police Department as well as the Twin Falls County Sheriff's Office
[0:17:20] So they really you know we started forming this a little over a year ago
[0:17:24] They really kicked off in November. I can assure you that they are very busy within the state limits of Twin Falls and in Twin Falls County
[0:17:32] their primary goal right now is to be a very overt group of law enforcement
[0:17:39] officers targeting violent offenders and those that continually break the law
[0:17:44] within our county specifically like I said violent offenders and people
[0:17:48] committing violations of gun laws. Next in September we deployed we became fully
[0:17:57] deployed with our police cars with a drug called Narcan or Knoxoline. And Knoxoline is an antidote
[0:18:05] for opioid drugs. We started this process again about a year ago working through Dr. Larson
[0:18:14] at St. Luke's Medical Center, an ER doctor out there. And with our staff, we now have Narcan
[0:18:21] available in all of our police cars. We have had five saves from Narcan in 2017. In fact,
[0:18:31] we had one just two weeks ago where a young lady had overdosed on heroin and Narcan was
[0:18:37] administered. We'll also tell you that one of my, another reason we saw we were able to
[0:18:44] protect our public with that, but there have also been instances in this country of law
[0:18:49] officers through the processing and handling of some of the narcotics having
[0:18:55] reactions to these opioid narcotics and Narcan saving the lives of peace officers
[0:19:01] and other first responders. For example, we also have Narcan available in our
[0:19:06] crime lab in case our three ladies that process the evidence would ever get
[0:19:10] accidentally exposed to fentanyl and other dangerous opioid narcotics. So Narcan
[0:19:16] deployment is going very well. As I mentioned, we have five saves from the use of Narcan.
[0:19:22] The next thing is phlebotomy. When I first got here, one of my goals a couple of years
[0:19:28] ago was to increase our efforts in the areas of driving under the influence enforcement.
[0:19:34] We know that there's some things that we can do in police work that truly can prevent death
[0:19:40] and by getting the word out and preventing driving under the influence and then arresting
[0:19:45] those who do that. That makes our roadways safer. And we know that we have a
[0:19:50] driving and an influence, not like when I first got into policing 28 years ago,
[0:19:55] it was generally alcohol related DUIs. But now we see more and more DUIs that are
[0:20:01] narcotics related to others, prescription medication or other type of medication
[0:20:06] or even marijuana. So we have added five officers that have been trained in
[0:20:12] phlebotomy, so yes they they draw blood and if somebody were to refuse the required
[0:20:20] breath test when they're getting arrested for DUI, then those officers will work
[0:20:24] with the prosecutor's office and a judge to obtain a warrant and that warrant will
[0:20:29] then grant the officer permission to draw blood from those individuals and
[0:20:33] that blood is in use for evidentiary purposes in the processing of that
[0:20:38] criminal charge. So we have had success with that. We have so far census programs, but
[0:20:44] in effect we've done approximately 20 different blood draws on DUI cases. With that we are
[0:20:53] also working to increase our drug recognition expert ability within the police department
[0:20:59] at DREs. These are officers that are specifically trained to recognize the effects of narcotics
[0:21:06] other than alcohol, and they can testify as to that, for example, in DUI cases as well.
[0:21:12] We put together, I know you had a presentation about 10 or 11 months ago on a computer program
[0:21:18] that we purchased called IAPRO and BLUTEA, it's two programs, but they're combined.
[0:21:25] And if you'll notice in the report on the back page, talks about the Office of Professional
[0:21:31] Standards.
[0:21:32] And this was one of the areas when I got here that we really worked to try to streamline
[0:21:39] a little bit better.
[0:21:40] And these two computer programs have really helped us to do that and track what our police
[0:21:46] officers are doing.
[0:21:48] For example, in 2017, there were 47 uses of force by Twin Falls Police Department.
[0:21:56] Now a use of force can be something as simple as an officer maybe using an arm bar and taking
[0:22:01] a subject down to the ground, but it could be something like certain linear restraints.
[0:22:07] It could also include maybe pointing a firearm at another person to effect an arrest.
[0:22:13] And if we had a discharge of a firearm, that would as well.
[0:22:16] You can see the breakdown that we've had on our use as a force.
[0:22:20] We've got 47 incidents in 2017.
[0:22:23] Now we'll tell you that out of 2,427 physical arrests and 58,000 calls for service, that's
[0:22:31] that's a pretty low amount of use of force among your Twin Falls police officers.
[0:22:37] Another thing on Citizens' Complaints we tracked those as well. In 2017 the Office of
[0:22:43] Professional Standards received an investigative 39 complaints against members of the Twin Falls
[0:22:49] Police Department. We have assigned liaison officers to work with different communities
[0:22:56] within our community. Some of our communities we feel are underserved by law enforcement.
[0:23:01] For example, we have the liaison officers assigned to work with Special Olympics.
[0:23:06] We all know that this year we have Special Olympics at State Games coming for the third
[0:23:11] year in a row to Twin Falls, but we also have some great teams and law enforcement has a
[0:23:16] real special place with Special Olympics as a guardians of the flame.
[0:23:20] So we have two officers assigned to be our liaisons with that particular organization.
[0:23:25] We have two officers assigned to be our liaisons with our hotel and motel proprietors to work
[0:23:31] with them and educate them on areas where they should be alert for and to
[0:23:36] answer any questions that they have and to improve our service to our hotel and
[0:23:40] motels within the city. You also may remember just a few months ago when there
[0:23:47] was a shooting in Texas at a church and the Twin Falls Police Department put
[0:23:51] together a worship safety seminar. We have also assigned officers to be liaisons
[0:23:57] to those different places of worship, to make sure that they have any questions or safety issues that come up.
[0:24:03] With our LGBTQ community as well, we have Sergeant Applewhite working with that community, the Hispanic community, as well as the refugee community.
[0:24:15] So if officers are assigned to work with these different communities that may feel underserved by law enforcement,
[0:24:21] and also sometimes may have apprehensions to reach out to law enforcement and report criminal acts.
[0:24:26] In 2017, we launched our aerial fleet, if you will.
[0:24:32] Now, no, we don't have helicopters, maybe in the 20-21 budget or so,
[0:24:37] but we do have some unmanned aerial vehicles, aka drones.
[0:24:42] We use these UAVs to help in situations like large crowds situations,
[0:24:48] And I would take you just back a few months to December when we had the wonderful ceremony
[0:24:53] out here with the parade and the tree lighting.
[0:24:56] We were able to utilize one of our UAVs to watch for traffic issues on May and also
[0:25:03] crowd control issues as well.
[0:25:07] We did put together our workplace violence and our worship safety seminars that were taught
[0:25:12] by Captain Hicks and Staff Sergeant, right?
[0:25:15] In 2017, they did 26 different presentations and reached 851 people during those presentations.
[0:25:23] And the last thing I want to touch on, one of the conversations that we have had since
[0:25:29] I've been your police chief is retaining our police officers, retention, retention, retention.
[0:25:35] And thanks to the hard work of the employee committee within the police department,
[0:25:41] City Manager's Office, Gretchen and Human Resources, Gretchen Scott and with the support of the City Council in
[0:25:49] February of last year
[0:25:51] we were able to put forth a new salary table for the Police Department that
[0:25:57] Saw has become much more competitive with our neighbors to the West
[0:26:01] and I think that has and will continue to assist us in not only recruiting but also retraining or retaining some of these fine
[0:26:09] I spoke to the new Rotary Club last week and I use the analogy no longer are we going to be a AAA farm club for Meridian Police Department and the Police Department.
[0:26:26] We're in the big leagues now and we're going to maintain those fine men and women and a lot of that has to do with thanks to the city council and support that you gave to our fine organization.
[0:26:38] So, ladies and gentlemen, I hope you've had a chance to go through this.
[0:26:41] I will say, people out here in the audience, there were some of these that were laid out at the tables
[0:26:46] when you come in. If you'd like one, you can get one. If you didn't get one, Officer O'Donnell has a few extra, I believe.
[0:26:51] You can also get access to this on our website at TFID.org and go to the Police Department tab.
[0:26:58] With that, Mayor, Council, I would stand for any questions.
[0:27:01] Chief, I'd just like to thank the Department for his 24-7
[0:27:07] professionally. We're up against departments higher than others, more people.
[0:27:13] I'm just extremely impressed with your leadership, all of our uniforms.
[0:27:19] Going to your crime status with one that sticks out in my mind.
[0:27:22] Maybe you could take a couple seconds to explain.
[0:27:25] The case reports for felonies actually shows quite impressive.
[0:27:29] I guess 16 to 17 get to go down here rest for felonies shows it's 27% of what isn't understood
[0:27:42] about that.
[0:27:43] You know, I'll show Donald and I were just talking about that probably two hours ago looking
[0:27:49] at that number.
[0:27:50] And I think that what we see, so there's a lot of information on this with, on this page,
[0:27:58] On this page with these numbers, there's a lot of information and ways that you could interpret these numbers.
[0:28:03] What I would tell you that in my opinion are felonies, although they are down 9% from 2016.
[0:28:11] If you go across to 2017, it's just a little bit of an increase.
[0:28:16] So 2016 versus 17, for some reason, it seems that there's a little bit of a spike in 2016 that seems to potentially be an anomaly.
[0:28:26] One thing about our crime statistics, we report everything through the
[0:28:29] auto-state police to the Federal Bureau of Investigation.
[0:28:32] Those final crime stats will be out and published by the
[0:28:35] auto-state police in June and I do plan on coming back and having a
[0:28:39] discussion about those actual final numbers and we'll get right into all of
[0:28:43] the different group A offenses when those get printed.
[0:28:46] I don't have a great answer as to why that is.
[0:28:49] I do think though that with us being fully staffed
[0:28:53] and having a more proactive investigations division
[0:28:58] and with a little bit of help from SIU
[0:29:00] that's been in place since November.
[0:29:02] A lot of narcotics arrests and gun arrest are felony cases
[0:29:06] when they make those types of arrests.
[0:29:08] So when you look at the actual arrest,
[0:29:10] I think we're clearing a higher percentage
[0:29:12] of those felony investigations that come through.
[0:29:14] We're having a little bit more time to work on those.
[0:29:19] Any other questions or comments for the chief, Nikki Boyd?
[0:29:24] I'd like to say thank you very much to you.
[0:29:33] You're very welcome and it is our honor.
[0:29:36] Ms. Reed, again, thank you, as I'm sure all the council members
[0:29:40] feel the same way, thank you for everything that you do.
[0:29:42] Real quick on top calls for service in 2017,
[0:29:46] the top one was accidents at 2,108.
[0:29:49] Do we know how many of those are individuals
[0:29:52] who live within the city or those who are outside
[0:29:55] of the city limits?
[0:29:56] Do we have that information?
[0:29:57] That is a great question.
[0:30:00] I can tell you that historically, when we look at that data,
[0:30:03] about 48% of all of our contacts are with people
[0:30:08] who do not live within the city limits of Twin Falls.
[0:30:12] Whether that's a traffic crash
[0:30:13] that they're investigating, issuing a traffic citation
[0:30:17] or whatever, about 48%.
[0:30:19] And that's been very consistent long before I got here.
[0:30:22] You know, Captain Hicks runs those numbers every year.
[0:30:25] Travis has asked for them every year.
[0:30:28] which is I don't captain captain if you see is that still consistent. Yeah, so that's about 48% of our contacts with people who do not live within the city. One last thing I guess in closing last week we had the city of Twin Falls hosted the Idaho Highway Traffic Safety Summit and we received an award.
[0:30:50] the Twin Falls Police Department received an award as the most innovative agency in the state.
[0:30:56] And that is a program, we received that award because of a program that we worked with the
[0:31:03] Office of Highway Safety, the Out of Transportation Department, on increasing our seat belt use.
[0:31:08] Now what I will tell you is unfortunately we actually saw a decline in our seat belt usage.
[0:31:14] So our numbers aren't trending the right direction that I'd like to see them trending.
[0:31:19] We do know that seat belt save lives and seat belts lower
[0:31:21] and injury rates and crashes.
[0:31:23] But we received that award from highway safety
[0:31:28] as a police department.
[0:31:29] But I want to tell you that it truly was a city award.
[0:31:33] John Keaton is public works crew who helped
[0:31:36] with the signage, our communication center, Tammy
[0:31:40] and her crew to help with when we had extra officers
[0:31:43] out working seat belt enforcement emphasis.
[0:31:46] So even though the Black says Twin Falls Police Department,
[0:31:50] when we talk one city and we talk about not working as silos,
[0:31:53] it's such a great example of how the city came together
[0:31:58] to help us as a community to try to get the word out
[0:32:02] about CPA usage.
[0:32:04] Now we'll use this moment to let everybody know that
[0:32:06] we're starting round three of that CPA
[0:32:09] and emphasis just this coming week.
[0:32:12] So you're going to see police officers
[0:32:14] working overtime she shifts with the sole purpose of writing citations that
[0:32:19] keep in mind seat belt is what's called a secondary offense in Idaho so an
[0:32:23] officer must have another reason to pull somebody over maybe speeding or not
[0:32:28] stopping at a stop sign etc but we are going to go out and continue to enforce
[0:32:33] the seat belt laws as state laws is written and I would ask our listeners our
[0:32:39] community members remind everybody please buckle up seat belts do save lives and
[0:32:44] on those nice signs that our great city sign department put together I'd like to
[0:32:48] see an increase in the next quarter when we do our next you see the survey
[0:32:52] the other questions sir I don't see any others thank you chief thank you very
[0:32:57] much next on the agenda is a presentation of the Twin Falls Fire
[0:33:05] Department's 2017 annual report to the city council and we have our fire chief
[0:33:10] less than worthy welcome chief mr. Mayor council members unity I'm equally
[0:33:19] is honored to be here tonight present. Let me cue this up here a little bit on this
[0:33:29] part without glasses. We'll see how I do. So I did not bring handouts but it is on
[0:33:43] our website so you can see our annual report on the website. Same with the
[0:33:47] public here we do have that on our website as well. So you can see that
[0:33:52] online and get more detailed. So just to start with just where I'm gonna take
[0:33:56] you tonight a little bit is our annual report obviously and just looking at
[0:34:01] When I first started here, a few weeks back, even before I started here, we went through
[0:34:06] the 2030 strategic plan.
[0:34:08] And so I just kind of wanted to look at our last year and see how we tied in with that.
[0:34:13] And I think for the most part, we did that.
[0:34:15] I think as we focus forward from this point, we'll continue to do more of that.
[0:34:20] But what I'm going to go through tonight is our administration, operations with falls under
[0:34:25] our focus area one, the health community, focus area two, the learning community, which we'll
[0:34:30] talk about some fire prevention and education, and also some community relations, and then
[0:34:36] under focus area three is the secure community, which again is training and some more operational
[0:34:42] things that we do in the fire department.
[0:34:50] So just as you know, in 2017 we had a fire chief resignation, and we were a little short
[0:34:59] on leadership towards at least the end of the year.
[0:35:02] But I would like to just point out and say thank you
[0:35:05] to Assistant City Manager Brian Pike, who stood in
[0:35:09] and did a really good job, I think, all in all,
[0:35:12] to keep the firemen running and working
[0:35:14] and being productive along with our command staff
[0:35:17] to three battalion chiefs.
[0:35:19] Thank you, Brian.
[0:35:20] Appreciate that.
[0:35:25] As far as our personnel in 2017, we had a retirement
[0:35:28] of Captain Mark Petrizelli, hopefully I'm saying that correctly, he was a Captain from
[0:35:35] 1992 to 2017 so he had 25 years of service here. I just like to recognize his years of
[0:35:42] service. And then our newer firefighter Cody Lewin, who as you can see we don't even have
[0:35:48] a picture for him yet in uniform, but Cody's our new ironies in the process. Under the administration
[0:36:01] area we've been working on as you all know the fire station master plan and as
[0:36:09] matter of fact we have a meeting tomorrow where the steering committee and the
[0:36:14] programmatic committee are going to be meeting and kind of getting together and
[0:36:18] and talking about where we're at with the plan along with Pivot North or our
[0:36:24] consultant that we've hired as well so that will will continue program program
[0:36:31] programmatic planning and move forward with how we're going to move forward
[0:36:36] that project as the mayor spoke about. You spoke about it in the state of the city
[0:36:40] address last week. Apparatus replacements and additions. We had a new command vehicle
[0:36:47] that was put in service in 2017 as well as a new rescue truck as you can see on
[0:36:55] the far right. The new rescue truck carries mostly technical rescue rope type
[0:37:00] equipment that's made a great improvement in what we can do out there and for the community.
[0:37:07] We've also purchased a new brush truck that you can see at the bottom there that was totally
[0:37:14] funded by the outside group there with Fire Districts, thank you.
[0:37:27] So that's in service and that's working well as well.
[0:37:32] operations. I just want to talk just for a second of
[0:37:35] EMS enhancements. This group or this this council and this
[0:37:40] community and city management made a made a choice to get into
[0:37:45] the EMS business. As somebody who came from one of the biggest
[0:37:50] EMS capitals in the world, I think that was a good decision.
[0:37:54] And I think it was the right decision. I think in 2017, where
[0:37:59] we had the full year of service, we've increased our response times and ultimately giving better
[0:38:08] service for the community. And so as we move forward with that, we still have some challenges,
[0:38:13] but we're working towards looking at those and figuring out how we can come up with solutions.
[0:38:20] We didn't have any, I'm aware of any significant fires in 2017 to speak up, as far as the rescues
[0:38:27] we did have some canyon rescues with our technical rescue program. When we
[0:38:34] talk about technical rescue there's four different disciplines as we call
[0:38:40] confined space, rope, high angle, low angle, and trench and heavy rescued water
[0:38:47] which we really aren't involved yet, involved with yet, although the other
[0:38:52] disciplines we're heavily involved in. Under special operations we provide
[0:38:58] as it was materials not only in the city of Twin but we also provide some of that
[0:39:02] outside of our jurisdiction. And obviously we have wildland firefighting and urban
[0:39:08] interface that's always a concern as well. So just to break down our call
[0:39:14] volume in 2017 I got this chart here pie chart and it kind of breaks it down
[0:39:19] into structure, fire, service calls and all the different types of calls. As you
[0:39:24] You can see our biggest increase was EMS fire rescue, excuse me, rescue calls at 30-29.
[0:39:36] The calls are broken up into, we have a map into the zones and within the city zone 2-1-3
[0:39:41] and the different stations that accompany each one of those and the numbers are broken
[0:39:47] down there as well.
[0:39:48] As you can see in 2016 we had a call volume of 2700 calls.
[0:39:52] In 2017 we were at 5413, a significant increase.
[0:39:56] And as you can imagine, we've had some impacts because of that.
[0:39:59] Under the community relations banner, we've reached 1,714 students.
[0:40:12] We've had station tours with the Touch 2,160 community members with 77 events.
[0:40:21] And then the street fairs, as you're all aware, we've had several of those in the city.
[0:40:27] We've reached over 20,000 people there.
[0:40:34] And Fire extinguisher and demonstrations is another part of what we do.
[0:40:37] And again, we've got a large number of people that we have worked with to teach fire extinguishers
[0:40:44] and how to extinguish fire fire prevention and education, code enforcement, and a lot
[0:40:51] of our fire marshal has inspected over 300 buildings and done several reviews to include
[0:40:58] plan reviews and also actual inspections and that continues on.
[0:41:03] As you can imagine, with each increase of growth and the challenges with that, he's
[0:41:09] a busy fire marshal. One of the highlights that both Tim and one of the officers from
[0:41:17] our police department, Mr. Rodriguez, were able to do is go back to the National Fire Academy
[0:41:23] and learn about the fires that are programmed with juveniles. That's a week program. And
[0:41:31] just so in 2018, we were really trying to kick that off as a matter of fact. Tonight, I
[0:41:38] I think we had a student that Tim was meeting with to work through this program.
[0:41:43] It's a great program to reduce its early getting into someplace they shouldn't be.
[0:41:48] So that's continuing on this good work.
[0:41:50] We've had 29 fire investigations in 2016.
[0:42:00] An average fire investigation takes 10 hours.
[0:42:03] So if you add that up, we're looking at about 7 hours or 7 weeks of work worth for Tim
[0:42:08] when he does that.
[0:42:09] A lot of work goes into that.
[0:42:13] Under the training banner, Fire and EMS, obviously we do that on a continual basis.
[0:42:19] We have a driver's academy that we started last year and got into full gear and is working well.
[0:42:25] It's been a real improvement.
[0:42:27] A skill level for our Fire apparatus drivers.
[0:42:32] And then live aircraft training.
[0:42:36] We go to Salt Lake City every year.
[0:42:39] We send a certain number of members out there.
[0:42:42] Again, continues to be a good process, although I'm hearing that that's going to be closing
[0:42:48] soon.
[0:42:49] We're going to have to look at another option for that.
[0:42:52] Under technical rescue, again, we train on that quite often with a canyon.
[0:42:57] I think we had four different events in 2016.
[0:43:02] Again, we're being duly noted all over the state and even outside of our state for that
[0:43:10] work.
[0:43:11] So that'll continue as well.
[0:43:12] pictures up on the top there from the college where firefighters were practicing
[0:43:17] a confined space drill in one of the wind vades and so the answer was really good
[0:43:23] training with that opportunity. Hazardous materials again the hazardous materials unit
[0:43:33] that we used to have like from what I understand in the county was is no
[0:43:38] longer in effect and so the City of Twin is going to take that on as our own and so
[0:43:43] were continuing to increase our training there, which includes sending some of our people to
[0:43:48] Amazon, Alabama, which is a week-long program, and I believe they're getting ready to do
[0:43:54] that again in the next couple of weeks.
[0:43:57] We also did some BLM co-training scenarios in 2016 to picture there on the right of the
[0:44:06] mock tabletop that they did was very successful, successful as well.
[0:44:12] That is a quick dirty recap of 2016, which obviously I wasn't here, but as we go forward,
[0:44:22] I can see some areas where I think we can do some work on some reporting and use a little
[0:44:28] more detail about things.
[0:44:30] With that, I'll open it up for any questions you might have.
[0:44:33] Thank you, Chief.
[0:44:35] Chris talking to Chief, I'm going to report for you.
[0:44:38] I'm pressing here on your learning curve very well.
[0:44:40] Well, it's what to pay you from first-gen environment
[0:44:47] responding to accidents.
[0:44:49] I think as policy that's still in continuance
[0:44:52] about that we respond to all local vehicle accidents
[0:44:56] are only those that have a fuel spill
[0:44:58] and what's what's been your observation
[0:45:02] on the effectiveness of that.
[0:45:05] Well, to be honest with that, one of the things I guess
[0:45:08] I'm noticing is there's, we haven't had necessarily
[0:45:11] a lot of consistency and part of that
[0:45:14] is making sure that the communication between fire
[0:45:19] and our communication center is the same
[0:45:23] and it's across all shifts the same
[0:45:30] and dispatchers for that matter.
[0:45:32] And so we have some work to do there.
[0:45:34] What I would say is we are still responding to spills
[0:45:38] and that sort of thing or non-injury accidents.
[0:45:40] I've noticed that a lot.
[0:45:41] I think that some of the areas that we can look at
[0:45:44] as far as maybe reducing some of our numbers.
[0:45:48] And we're looking at that now,
[0:45:49] and we're doing some other work with our dispatch,
[0:45:51] just in general, not only for traffic accidents,
[0:45:54] but also our EMS calls.
[0:46:00] It is.
[0:46:02] We'll do.
[0:46:04] We're looking into that.
[0:46:08] Comments or questions?
[0:46:09] Pooh chief, I'm here.
[0:46:13] So thank you for the report,
[0:46:15] and we'll look forward to continued updates
[0:46:18] on various activities of the department.
[0:46:20] Thank you.
[0:46:23] Thanks again.
[0:46:24] Thank you.
[0:46:27] And next on the agenda is a request
[0:46:30] to amend Twin Falls City Codes 9-7-3 and 9-7-6-C,
[0:46:37] eliminating the requirement for parking passes
[0:46:39] within downtown public lots.
[0:46:41] And we have our economic development director.
[0:46:44] Hey, Mary.
[0:46:45] Okay, thank you.
[0:46:47] Thank you, Mayor and Council.
[0:46:48] So one of the complaints that when I hear it about
[0:46:51] downtown is always kind of music to my ears,
[0:46:53] is parking and about that that we need for it.
[0:46:58] And from time to time, we do want to recess
[0:47:04] kind of adjust the way we're going to access our businesses.
[0:47:09] So as we spoke with the business community,
[0:47:12] they reached out to us.
[0:47:17] Concerns wanted to address most,
[0:47:18] was just getting more turnover
[0:47:20] within the parking lots that we have.
[0:47:22] And so working with parking enforcement
[0:47:24] and meeting with some of those businesses,
[0:47:26] we decided to re-stripe, re-stall,
[0:47:32] kelson and lots as they're being used.
[0:47:35] And so in order to do that,
[0:47:37] we need to adjust the language in our code
[0:47:39] to reflect those changes.
[0:47:41] So we'll be eliminating for the type being the paid parking passes as we would just fill
[0:47:50] in the code going forward for now.
[0:47:54] We'd like to just have these try out having a certain number of three hour stalls in each
[0:48:00] lot and then bank stalls for all day.
[0:48:04] Those won't be by striping, re-signing and then also allocating the appropriate number
[0:48:14] of ADA stalls in each lot where in sum we actually are sufficient and some we may have
[0:48:18] a future many.
[0:48:19] So, we're structuring that and we asked the council to adjust the language to, uh, so I have a question name.
[0:48:32] So, is the, is the intent that there would still be a, a pass and all they pass so that you would be able to write?
[0:48:41] So, so if you park and install it, it's, it's going to be signed appropriately, but then,
[0:48:46] there'll be certain number stalls in each lot that are just dedicated for, uh, 12 hour.
[0:48:51] Other ones which are enforced through three hours. Most of the lots put that three hours going up a little bit.
[0:49:00] And the lots, I think if you look on your map, probably in the green lot and the black lot,
[0:49:07] stalls will be based on the employments in those areas and merchants actually encouraging their employees to park.
[0:49:17] And a further way of walking into their businesses to allow stalls closer to where most of the shops are to the three hours.
[0:49:24] specific to the new lot that the agency did on second-band hooding.
[0:49:36] So this is just the city lot's here in downtown of which there's seven.
[0:49:40] We're finding that the urban renewal lot that is over there on second-gooding is largely
[0:49:47] had been for the employers that are there in Poison Park.
[0:49:56] That's still going to be open all day for us.
[0:50:03] Nate, I think it's a great idea that you're moving some of those old-
[0:50:08] All day spots to a little bit out of the edge because it is pretty common.
[0:50:14] I remember the second avenue north where we had the little where everybody was trying
[0:50:20] to park as close to their business as possible and that's really not good business.
[0:50:25] And I think it's really positive that you'll be re-stripping and rebumpering and making
[0:50:32] it much more clear because it is a little bit confusing right now.
[0:50:36] It's all good work
[0:51:07] and trying to encourage their employees to parking.
[0:51:10] This doesn't mean that as you've provided
[0:51:12] our areas for their customers and those that don't
[0:51:16] get tickets and they understand that,
[0:51:18] one of the exact numbers, but as we stepped up our enforcement
[0:51:24] since February, what is it, a ticket,
[0:51:28] and they're expectation.
[0:51:35] How come?
[0:51:40] We understand that we're going to take out the parking blocks.
[0:51:43] That, yes.
[0:51:45] And how are we marking the stalls then?
[0:51:47] So, I mean, is it going to be paint color?
[0:51:50] We have paint color and signage and we are doing that so we can sweep and close lots during
[0:51:58] the winter.
[0:52:05] How is this working with the budget?
[0:52:06] Because we will be taking a loss of income since we are not selling parking passes.
[0:52:11] The enforcement do we have.
[0:52:17] Numbers broken down there.
[0:52:18] I haven't seen anything specific.
[0:52:19] So I know that when we sold about $9,000 worth of passes the last year we did it.
[0:52:25] don't believe the costs for maintaining and forcing them either.
[0:52:32] So using 9,000 revenue.
[0:52:35] I can help answer that question.
[0:52:44] So inside of the budget, we had about $38,000 that was budgeted.
[0:52:48] We made the decision to suspend the parking pass program
[0:52:53] because of all the construction activity that was going forward.
[0:52:56] And so for the year, we've collected about $2,500.
[0:53:00] And the entire overall parking piece
[0:53:03] This has kind of gone through that transformation reorganization like we shared with the council
[0:53:07] that Sean stand the overseas, not only that aspect of code enforcement, but we've also
[0:53:12] given him animal control.
[0:53:14] We've also given him the responsibilities for water and water enforcement and conservation
[0:53:19] messaging as well.
[0:53:21] And so when you take a look at budget to actual, there is a deficit to be able to cover
[0:53:27] that moving forward.
[0:53:28] We've been running a deficit and it's been supported by general fund tax dollars since
[0:53:34] we removed parking meters.
[0:53:35] Once we removed the parking meters, the parking program was no longer self-sufficient and
[0:53:41] even towards the end of it, it wasn't either.
[0:53:46] So for this year, those costs by the decision to remove the lease program have been absorbed
[0:53:52] by the general fund and in the upcoming FY19 staff's proposal will also be absorbed by
[0:53:57] general fund as well. Mickey Boyden?
[0:54:02] He's servicing and striping and parking places by putting things in it.
[0:54:10] Is there any creativity going in there?
[0:54:14] You know we can look at that. I don't think we have our exact layout yet, and we're still going to work with our streets department on that.
[0:54:21] We want to get a number of EAS dolls correct and get the right kind of access and appropriate businesses.
[0:54:29] The principles that you're having.
[0:54:32] not just like to make the meters
[0:54:39] this opening up the city downtown area to public parking
[0:54:43] started with us doing away with those
[0:54:45] and as I recall we tried to get away
[0:54:47] the parking meters to other cities
[0:54:49] and none of them took
[0:54:51] and we sold them for mementos
[0:54:53] and they're a few around the town
[0:54:55] but it's just a logical extension
[0:54:57] doing away with parking meters
[0:54:59] and doing away with restricted parking
[0:55:01] that is a disencouragement for people to shop downtown
[0:55:05] for people to shop downtown, so I'm totally supportive.
[0:55:13] From us is direction to bring us an ordinance, correct?
[0:55:18] Organists to actually amend the code.
[0:55:20] They send a couple of things, just a reminder to public
[0:55:39] the parking on Main Street is one-hour parking, is that correct?
[0:55:43] Yes. What about the side streets like Hanson? I always come with the council.
[0:55:47] I think it's two hours on the street.
[0:55:49] It's two hours on Main and all the side streets.
[0:55:52] I'd like to sort of enhance and remain the same and then
[0:55:56] very good to think of having really paid attention
[0:56:00] because I know where I'm going to try to park each other.
[0:56:03] I remember Claire back in Lance's cloud was suggesting that we come up with more signage
[0:56:07] for people that shows the like three are free parking on the streets,
[0:56:13] directing people into the parking areas.
[0:56:16] Do we have any plans to do things like that?
[0:56:18] So people realize how much parking there really is there.
[0:56:21] So there is in our strategic plan right now language that talks about reading
[0:56:27] out of a comprehensive downtown traffic part way finding would definitely be a
[0:56:35] component of that just kind of the marketing and messaging been there's at
[0:56:41] some future point where we're bringing certain pay lots back as our downtown
[0:56:45] density that necessitate that need some time yes we get a lot more input
[0:57:00] Boy since I've been a counselor, it's always been this concern about parking downtown. I remember coming to unfalls as a kid
[0:57:12] For most of every Friday night it seemed like as a storage roll up into Friday. Now is a big deal. We used to park
[0:57:19] Plurver past the old city hall and things because that's just where he parked because there wasn't a parking handler
[0:57:24] 10 times the parking downtown now there was then when
[0:57:28] Main street was pro it was more vibrant. Although it's getting more vibrant was more vibrant than now
[0:57:33] We have to walk, it's still all skewed, for if you want to be downtown, you know, go to the mall at Christmas and you have to park there and you know, set the restaurants and everything in the hat.
[0:57:47] So, thank you very much.
[0:57:50] Thank you for your presentation, one quick question for me, what's the timetable?
[0:57:55] What are we looking at if this amendment does happen?
[0:57:58] Restartments, surfacing, what types of impact will it have on businesses, those types of things?
[0:58:05] Well, that is a good question that we haven't addressed.
[0:58:08] I'd actually have my own short bet any discussions with on that side of it.
[0:58:16] So I've spoken to the street department and they're ready to go.
[0:58:19] We actually wanted to start this a couple of weeks ago with cleaning up our parking lots and get that going so that part of it can start
[0:58:27] Right away. I think they're gonna do all seven at one time. I think in their off time
[0:58:33] No, they'll do one this week and then Chris talking to me
[0:58:44] I'd like to
[0:58:50] amend the city code at Twin Falls
[0:58:52] Section 973 at 976 C
[0:59:35] Yes, I will note for the folks in the audience who are here for the public hearing on Chickens.
[0:59:48] That was scheduled no earlier than six, so we do have a couple more items that we need
[0:59:52] to finish up on the regular agenda, and then we'll be getting to that.
[0:59:57] And the Chickens and Roosters both still both wait.
[1:00:02] Next on the agenda is a request to adopt an ordinance for a zoning district change and
[1:00:07] zoning map amendment from R4 to M2 for property consisting of 10 plus or minus
[1:00:13] acres located on the south side of the 400 block of undeveloped diamond
[1:00:17] Avenue West undeveloped row in care of Gary's study on behalf of great cast
[1:00:22] percent and we have Renee Carrey Way Johnson the heart zoning and development
[1:00:27] manager
[1:00:29] Council history on how this how this process began and why I'm here on
[1:00:36] On January 23rd of 2018, the Planning and Zoning Commission held a public hearing on this request.
[1:00:42] There was no public comment and upon conclusion of the public hearing and commission discussion,
[1:00:47] Commissioner Higgly made a motion to recommend approval of the request to the City Council as presented.
[1:00:53] Commissioner Gray seconded the motion and all members present voted in favor.
[1:00:58] On February 20th of this year, the City Council held a public hearing on this request.
[1:01:03] Again, there was no public comment, and upon conclusion of the public hearing and City Council discussion,
[1:01:09] Council Member Talkington made a motion to approve the request as presented.
[1:01:14] Council Member Reed seconded the motion and roll call vote showed all members present voted in favor of the motion.
[1:01:20] Motion was approved 7-0.
[1:01:23] So as directed by the Council, there is an ordinance in your packet this evening for your review.
[1:01:28] There's also an area map, which I think helps kind of identify where the property was located.
[1:01:34] Staff is asking that the council adopt the ordinance, so it can be codified and the property will be officially resolved.
[1:01:43] I'm sure you have an ordinance in number.
[1:01:47] Ordinance number 2018-10.
[1:01:50] Don't soul with Nicky Boy.
[1:01:57] That we suspend the rules in place ordinance number 2018-10 on third and final reading by title.
[1:02:08] Oh, second.
[1:02:09] Motion by Nicky Boy.
[1:02:11] Seconded by Greg Lanting.
[1:02:13] Two place ordinance 2018-10 on third and final reading by title.
[1:02:17] All landers suspension of the rules is there any discussion?
[1:02:21] Nicky, did you have another comment?
[1:02:24] That's okay.
[1:02:26] Yes.
[1:02:27] Greg Lanting.
[1:02:28] Yes.
[1:02:29] Ruth Pierce.
[1:02:30] Yes.
[1:02:31] Christopher Reed.
[1:02:32] Yes.
[1:02:33] Chris Daukington.
[1:02:34] Yes.
[1:02:35] Don Bericher.
[1:02:36] Yes.
[1:02:37] Nicky Boyd.
[1:02:38] Yes.
[1:02:39] Suzanne Hawkins.
[1:02:40] Yes.
[1:02:41] Motion passes.
[1:02:42] It's 7 to 0.
[1:02:43] Sharon, would you read the title please?
[1:02:46] Ordinance number 2018-10.
[1:02:52] And ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho.
[1:02:57] to hope, rezoning certain rail property below described, providing the zoning classification
[1:03:04] therefore and ordering the necessary area of impact in zoning district map amendment.
[1:03:12] Thank you.
[1:03:13] Suzanne Hopkins.
[1:03:14] Ready to make a motion?
[1:03:16] I move that we approve or adopt ordinance 2018-10.
[1:03:20] Second.
[1:03:22] Motion by Suzanne Hopkins.
[1:03:24] second about Ruth Pierce to adopt
[1:03:26] ordinance 2018-10 is there any discussion
[1:03:29] here in roll call vote please
[1:03:34] Ruth Pierce? Yes
[1:03:40] Christopher Reed? Yes
[1:03:42] Chris Tockington? Yes
[1:03:44] Sean Beriker? Yes
[1:03:45] Nikki Boyd? Yes
[1:03:47] Suzanne Hawkins? Yes
[1:03:49] I should pass this in 7-0
[1:03:51] I didn't get a chance to vote
[1:03:55] I would vote yes, you did never come with
[1:03:57] I voted on her too
[1:03:59] I voted on her too
[1:04:00] Next on the agenda is a request to adopt an ordinance for a zoning district change and zoning map amendment 4-1 plus or minus acres from C1 to M2 for property located at 12-11 Addison Avenue West within the area of impact and again we have Renee Caraway Johnson our zoning and development.
[1:04:22] Yes you do.
[1:04:23] Again a little bit of history on how we got here today.
[1:04:27] January 9th of 2018, the Planning and Zoning Commission held a public hearing.
[1:04:32] There was no comment on this request and upon conclusion of the public hearing, the Commission
[1:04:38] and the Commission discussion commissioner Gray made a motion to recommend approval of
[1:04:42] the request of the city council as presented.
[1:04:46] Commissioner Wood seconded the motion and all members present voted in favor.
[1:04:50] On February 5th of 2018, City Council held a public hearing on this request.
[1:04:55] was no again no public comment and upon conclusion of the public hearing and
[1:04:59] council discussion council member talking to made a motion to approve the
[1:05:03] request as presented council member hockens seconded the motion and roll call
[1:05:08] vote showed all members present voted in favor of the motion motion was approved
[1:05:12] to six to zero as directed by council you do have an ordinance in your packet
[1:05:18] again there's an area not been there for your refreshing memory of where the
[1:05:23] properties located. Staff is asking that you adopt the ordinance so it can be
[1:05:27] codified and the property be legally rezoned. Thank you and thank you so wishes on
[1:05:34] ordinance 2018-11. Give a shot. I move that we suspend the rules of place ordinance
[1:05:47] 2018-11 on third and final by title only. Seconded by Mr. Fareed to suspend the
[1:05:59] rules of place ordinance 2018 and 11 on third and final reading by title only.
[1:06:03] Thank you.
[1:06:04] Thank you.
[1:06:06] Thank you.
[1:06:07] Thank you.
[1:06:08] Thank you.
[1:06:11] Thank you.
[1:06:12] Thank you.
[1:06:15] Thank you.
[1:06:16] Thank you.
[1:06:17] Thank you.
[1:06:18] Thank you.
[1:06:19] Thank you.
[1:06:20] Thank you.
[1:06:21] Thank you.
[1:06:22] Thank you.
[1:06:23] Thank you.
[1:06:24] Thank you.
[1:06:25] Thank you.
[1:06:26] Thank you.
[1:06:27] Thank you.
[1:06:30] Thank you.
[1:06:31] Thank you.
[1:06:32] Thank you.
[1:06:33] Thank you.
[1:06:35] Thank you.
[1:06:36] Thank you.
[1:06:37] Thank you.
[1:06:38] Thank you.
[1:06:39] Thank you.
[1:06:40] to help rezoning certain real property below describe providing the zoning classification
[1:06:48] therefore and ordering the necessary area of impact and zoning districts map amendment.
[1:06:56] Thank you, Christopher Reed.
[1:06:57] I'd like to make a motion if that's right.
[1:06:59] Yes, please.
[1:07:00] I move that we adopt ordinance 2018-11.
[1:07:02] Thank you, boy.
[1:07:03] Second.
[1:07:04] Christopher Reed, seconded by Nicki Boyd to adopt ordinance 2018-11.
[1:07:08] Is there any discussion?
[1:07:11] Great landing.
[1:07:13] Just one comment.
[1:07:16] I was looking at the site map.
[1:07:18] There's a street on there.
[1:07:19] I didn't realize that.
[1:07:21] Gulch Creek Road.
[1:07:22] You may have heard that one before.
[1:07:24] Does that exist?
[1:07:25] Does that exist or is that just potential?
[1:07:31] It does exist.
[1:07:33] Our house is out there.
[1:07:35] Okay, thank you.
[1:07:38] Any further discussion?
[1:07:43] Chris Stockington?
[1:07:47] Yes.
[1:07:48] John Beriker?
[1:07:49] Yes.
[1:07:50] Nicky Boyd? Yes.
[1:07:51] Is Ann Hawkins? Yes.
[1:07:53] Greg Lanting? Yes.
[1:07:54] Ruth Beers? Yes.
[1:07:55] Christopher Reed? Yes.
[1:07:57] Motion passes.
[1:07:58] Seven to zero.
[1:07:59] Renee?
[1:08:00] One more presentation. I just wanted to take a moment. I know you all are aware that this
[1:08:09] is my last week of employment with the city. I just wanted to take just this brief time
[1:08:16] to publicly thank this council and past councils for all of your cooperation and your support
[1:08:23] of the planning and zoning department and the development services departments in general.
[1:08:29] of you I've known from the beginning of my tenure. Some of you I've had on the
[1:08:34] Planning and Zoning Commission that worked with you in that capacity, some
[1:08:38] just for counsel, but again it's been a true pleasure. I just wanted to thank you.
[1:08:47] Thank you Renee. You've amazing for the team here. You've done a tremendous
[1:08:52] number. You've accomplished so much in the department. I certainly appreciate
[1:08:57] not only the work that you've done for the citizens but the friendship that I
[1:09:01] I think we've been able to develop, but I think you have that with a lot of us on the
[1:09:04] council and other members of the staff, so we wish you all the best in retirement, and
[1:09:09] we promise not to screw up your city for you.
[1:09:12] The little hidden messages I've heard about being a thorn in someone's side isn't true.
[1:09:18] Okay, I just needed to hear that.
[1:09:20] Thank you.
[1:09:21] Have a good weekend.
[1:09:22] Thank you.
[1:09:23] Thank you.
[1:09:24] Thank you.
[1:09:28] And next on the agenda is an opportunity for general public input, so there's anyone here
[1:09:33] which is to address the council on an item that is not on the agenda, so not chickens and roosters.
[1:09:38] Now is your chance to please come forward. Seeing no one, Travis, do we have any items from the City
[1:09:47] Manager's office? Well, Mr. Mayor, members of the council, we're going to have an opportunity this
[1:09:52] Thursday at 3.30 to celebrate, for these 27 years as a member of our team, and so we would invite
[1:10:01] Obviously you in the community, 330, this Thursday over in the overflow room, we're going to take some time to really celebrate Renee's tenure with the city.
[1:10:14] We're sorry to see her go. You see this file under her face is probably not exactly the same, but we'll take our time to celebrate her.
[1:10:24] Thank you to have us any items from the Council of the Advisory Board reports here.
[1:10:35] Yes, Chris talking.
[1:10:40] I guess we have somewhat of an impending decision to make on three traffic safety commission
[1:10:54] members who are at the end of their tenure.
[1:10:56] Can that wait or do we need to move for reappointment of the two of the three that are requested?
[1:11:03] So I spoke to Kathy in the Police Department today and she was working I believe with Captain Hicks
[1:11:11] on getting the detail together on potentially getting those reappointments done sooner than
[1:11:17] later since those terms did expire the first and then we have another one that the person
[1:11:23] is in here has now responded to reappointment and we actually have another opening that
[1:11:28] is in an email about today from the chamber seat appointee the person who's been in that
[1:11:34] seat is no longer on the chamber board and so the we have someone coming forward so we'll
[1:11:41] We'll do our best to keep that one moving along.
[1:11:43] It took us a fair amount of time to get them a point
[1:11:46] at the last go round, so we'll try to keep that moving.
[1:11:49] Traffic safety commission.
[1:11:53] With that, we will move on to our public hearing
[1:11:57] that is scheduled.
[1:11:58] This is a request to amend City Code 6-3-1
[1:12:03] and 6-3-4 regarding the banning of rooster chickens
[1:12:08] within the corporate limits of the city
[1:12:10] and allowing up to four hymn chickens
[1:12:12] without an approved animal permit.
[1:12:15] We have Sean Stanley, our Code Enforcement Coordinator,
[1:12:18] who will kick off the festivities.
[1:12:23] Thank you, Mayor of City Council.
[1:12:25] So a couple weeks ago, you heard from Citizen Lindsey Jacobson.
[1:12:30] She did a outstanding presentation.
[1:12:33] She brings up some good points about the consistency
[1:12:39] of our animal permit code.
[1:12:41] And now we allow four dogs.
[1:12:43] We allow four cats and up to three rabbits.
[1:12:46] Without an out of one chicken, Ms. Jacobson has a lot of followers inside the city of
[1:12:59] Twin Falls that feel the same way.
[1:13:02] I do want to go back to 2011, there were some minutes that were brought up, that's the last
[1:13:09] time this code was amended, and that had to do with applicant going, and then 75% of those
[1:13:24] had to agree, we had some applicants that wanted a rooster chicken, and they began on
[1:13:32] the outside of the 300 feet, closer to their property.
[1:13:38] When they got to that 75%, they just quit notifying.
[1:13:42] So that was the reason for that amendment.
[1:13:49] If you want to create a neighborhood dispute,
[1:13:51] let somebody have a rooster chicken.
[1:13:54] We don't get a lot of complaints,
[1:13:56] but if there is a rooster inside the city limits,
[1:13:58] we do hear about it.
[1:14:00] So we're looking to amend 631 to change the wording
[1:14:07] from it used to say pigs and hogs.
[1:14:12] Now 631 is prohibited to animals that includes pigs, hogs, and rooster chickens.
[1:14:19] And then a men's city code 634 to allow up to four hen chickens without an animal permit.
[1:14:27] And we feel that would just be a lot more consistent with our current city code.
[1:14:37] Approximately 10% of our animal permits are for four hen chickens or less.
[1:14:42] There's either one to see something that I would answer any questions.
[1:14:53] Any questions for Sean before we don't see any?
[1:15:05] Hey Josh, could you bring me that sign up sheet please?
[1:15:10] So I do believe we have several folks who have signed up here, so we will open this up for public input
[1:15:37] and I would ask everyone to please state your name whether you are a property owner or resident in the city of Twin Falls
[1:15:45] And then if you would please limit your input to, we'll say no longer than three minutes.
[1:15:56] Now that I'm saying that, oh I guess we have the timer on the computer, right?
[1:16:00] So I've been at the whole clock door.
[1:16:02] And please try not to be repetitive with the other folks who testify.
[1:16:08] So start off at Lindsey Jacobson.
[1:16:14] opposition behind me and stuff that I'd be happy to.
[1:16:44] Is that my fault?
[1:16:45] It has a green line. I have to say that all again.
[1:16:55] I've kind of said everything I think that I had to say, depending on what opposition may or may not be brought up,
[1:17:02] I'd be prepared to speak about problems or concerns of any other citizens that haven't been addressed already,
[1:17:10] so I'm just kind of here to make sure it all follows through, I guess.
[1:17:14] Next, I have Sandy Hacking.
[1:17:37] My name is Sandy Hacking.
[1:17:38] I am a property owner and resident of the City of Twin Falls.
[1:17:45] I believe in rules and regulations.
[1:17:46] I think that they're here to protect those of us
[1:17:50] who have property.
[1:17:52] However, the subdivisions within Twin Falls city limits
[1:17:56] over the past 40 some years have rules in place
[1:17:59] and regulations addressing these types of issues.
[1:18:06] The restrictive covenants are established to protect homeowners so that they are able
[1:18:11] to enjoy their property within the guidelines, stipulated in the CC&Rs, the protective covenants.
[1:18:20] In the restrictive covenants that are in my subdivision, it's very clear, and here are
[1:18:28] some copies if you would like to see specifically what my CC&Rs state.
[1:18:35] Each 3, item 16, addresses livestock poultry.
[1:18:39] No animals, livestock, or poultry of any kind shall be raised, bred, or kept on any lot,
[1:18:46] except that dogs, cats, or other household pets be kept provided they are not kept,
[1:18:52] bred or maintained for commercial purposes.
[1:18:55] I grew up with livestock, I grew up with chickens.
[1:18:59] I moved to the city because I don't want to live next to chickens.
[1:19:04] I know what goes on with chickens, the hins stop laying and outcomes the axe, outcomes
[1:19:11] the burn barrel, outcomes the boiling water, and they hang them on my swing set.
[1:19:16] I'm not willing to live next to all of that for the remainder of my life.
[1:19:25] Just like architectural committee, um, covenants within our CC and ours, they're there to protect
[1:19:33] property owner. You don't want a lime greenhouse with purple trim in your
[1:19:40] subdivision and so we do have rules in place. I think we should follow those
[1:19:45] rules and regulations. I think we need to allow the property owners to work
[1:19:51] within these guidelines of their subdivision and if we need an ordinance
[1:19:56] to areas within the city limits that do not have CCNRs then maybe we need to
[1:20:03] have an ordinance but I think ordinances rules and regulations are in place we
[1:20:08] need to follow those rules and regulations. Thank you. Next I have Bill Hacking signed
[1:20:29] up. Jennifer Pierce. Good evening. Thank you Council for letting me speak tonight.
[1:20:48] As a past chicken keeper I have found chickens to bring joy and peace,
[1:20:55] education and beauty, entertainment and food. A small flock and an urban lot is
[1:21:02] what I had in Buell. I just moved to Twin Falls about three weeks ago and I
[1:21:09] found that keeping four hens in my backyard was just the perfect amount and
[1:21:17] I did not have to seek permission from my neighbors and I found that they were
[1:21:22] all incredibly happy with my hens and they were glad to provide scraps of food for them
[1:21:30] as well as come and enjoy them in my yard. Keeping four hens or less without a permit
[1:21:41] is a great way to give the residents a chance to try on if keeping urban chickens is for
[1:21:47] them and their neighbors before seeking that permit. Next to happen, Dennis Crawford.
[1:21:57] It's Crawford, I have a city for the last 45 years in the council.
[1:22:16] I've been following this kinds of livestock.
[1:22:28] I actually enjoy hearing a rooster in the morning.
[1:22:31] It doesn't bother me at all. I have a neighbor that has roosters and chickens.
[1:22:37] Unfortunately, it all says a peacock that occasionally waters in the neighborhood though,
[1:22:42] so I wonder about that.
[1:22:44] I guess my feeling is that we'd probably have enough rules if there's objections, then that's probably something that the neighbors who have objection I think could complain to the city address that.
[1:23:08] To have more rules, I guess that's all.
[1:23:15] I'm Heather Evans.
[1:23:22] I'm Heather Evans and I'm a resident and a property owner here in Twin Falls.
[1:23:36] And I'm in favor of this code change because, I mean, a couple of months, I feel like the
[1:23:42] rules are already in place that you could have foreheads.
[1:23:45] It's just more time consuming to get that approval.
[1:23:49] So I feel like the rules allow for this.
[1:23:52] It's just making it easier.
[1:23:54] And if somebody doesn't want to live in a community that has lots of chickens,
[1:23:58] then you would decide to live in a neighborhood that does have those CCNRs,
[1:24:02] that have those restrictions, and that's your choice as a resident.
[1:24:06] But I feel like this is very acceptable considering the benefits
[1:24:10] of chickens compared to dogs and cats
[1:24:14] and just making that available and easy for people to have that benefit
[1:24:18] that they have in their notes.
[1:24:26] So I just think that there's so many more benefits out
[1:24:29] outweigh the cons and the noise and dealing with waste. So I'm in favor of this
[1:24:35] code. Thank you. And last I have the court Johnson. I also wanted to share a
[1:24:56] personal experience. I lived in Oklahoma City and at the time I actually had eight
[1:25:01] chickens lived on 5,000 square feet and had 40 rabbits. And that sounds
[1:25:05] excessive. Until one day about nine months after we lived there I invited my
[1:25:09] neighbor over to four of our BQ and he said I had no idea he had all these
[1:25:13] animals back here and part of the reason why I'm very much in favor of changing the code
[1:25:18] is because I think that the 300 foot restriction is a bit of a obnoxious and the reason why
[1:25:27] I say that is because I went through the permit process in Oklahoma City and later had a neighbor
[1:25:33] come and get rid of them for me even on me so I find that to be a bit of a bit of a cruisive
[1:25:40] when you have to get permission when they don't even realize that you have them and I also
[1:25:45] I just thought a question about the changing of six, three, four, if that would include increasing
[1:25:50] rabbits.
[1:25:51] I know right now it's three, but that includes increasing them to four.
[1:25:57] And then the other thing I had was pest control.
[1:25:59] When we had chickens, it completely eliminated our black flies, and that was a really big concern
[1:26:04] for our family because we had the chickens and they got rid of all of the flies that we
[1:26:08] were getting in our garden.
[1:26:09] It made us so we could actually grow a much better garden by putting a perimeter around
[1:26:13] the garden for the chickens to stay in close and they weren't allowed to leave them there
[1:26:17] so.
[1:26:22] Because, uh, although I had signed up to speak, is there anyone else who wishes to speak on this item who did not sign up?
[1:26:29] We know when we will pose the public input portion of this and turn it over to Council for some questions here, Chris talking to.
[1:26:44] On a clarification for our attorney, a restrictive covenant that is more restrictive, the city ordinance would take precedence, would it not?
[1:26:54] So restrictive covenants are the restrictions on property and they're only enforceable by
[1:27:03] the owners within subdivision to which they apply.
[1:27:06] The city does not have a standing to take any enforcement action for CCNR violations.
[1:27:13] We frequently have this very same issue in like rezone issues, CCNRs limit the minimum
[1:27:24] size of lots, for example, and those are often different than our minimum sizes established
[1:27:32] by Arizona Ordinance, so with our regulations, we completely disregard the existence or the
[1:27:40] contents of any CCNR because we have no standing to enforce it.
[1:27:46] But that said, if a CCNR restricted livestock and another person in that subdivision wish
[1:27:52] to take that person.
[1:27:54] Inforceable, they could enforceable by persons
[1:27:57] to live within that same subdivision subject to those CCNRs.
[1:28:03] But non-inforceable bias, right?
[1:28:05] That must have been the correct.
[1:28:08] Because all the lights went off Suzanne Hawkins.
[1:28:13] I was going to go there, but I also have another question.
[1:28:17] So right now, if somebody has four dogs,
[1:28:21] the dogs are supposed to be licensed within the city,
[1:28:23] not permitted, but licensed.
[1:28:24] Is that correct?
[1:28:25] To run.
[1:28:26] But we have nothing in place like that with cats or do we?
[1:28:31] No.
[1:28:32] So they're just allowed for?
[1:28:33] They're just allowed.
[1:28:34] So with the chickens though, even if they were allowed and a neighbor had a problem, they
[1:28:39] could still call code enforcement and you would still go out and if there's a limitation
[1:28:44] on how close they could be to a neighbor's fence.
[1:28:46] Is that correct?
[1:28:47] Well, to a dwelling.
[1:28:48] To a dwelling.
[1:28:49] They still have to be cooped.
[1:28:51] the ability to be cooped up 40 feet away from a neighboring door. So if a neighbor was
[1:28:59] pestered by odor or noise they could still call you and that would be, how would that be enforced
[1:29:06] or what would happen in that case if you went out? We have other sections of this same code
[1:29:11] on conditions of animal premise is 637, I believe, and all animals fit into that. And this is off
[1:29:21] the subject, I know, but do we allow goats? We do with a permit. There's
[1:29:27] different guidelines for bigger animals, like a gold horse, a cow, an
[1:29:35] hater of 10,000 square feet of real property designated to that. And they have
[1:29:44] to go within 300 feet, all the signatures. Okay, so with this ordinance
[1:29:50] change though, again, if the CC&Rs prohibit poultry, homeowners would still
[1:29:58] have the right to enforce that in their HOA's and the city would not supersede their rules
[1:30:05] in any shape or form and if there are problems they can still call code enforcement to get
[1:30:10] compliance issues. Yeah, but not as far CCRs, right? Right, not CCRs, but noise or stanch
[1:30:18] or whatever the problem might be. Yes. Thank you. Chris Stockington. So I have another question.
[1:30:27] So, just to clarify, maybe for people to understand that the change that these two
[1:30:34] code changes would make, one would prohibit roosters, and two, it would not require applying
[1:30:43] for a permit for forehands or less, but the other restrictions on having animals on your
[1:30:51] property would still be, in effect, no changes.
[1:30:56] the only changes are the number of n chickens and making roosters illegal inside the city
[1:31:04] limits. Okay, Chris talking to me. Well, that said, I would move to place ordinance 2018 dash 12 on third and final
[1:31:14] like title only.
[1:31:16] This is spending rules. Is that what we're doing? I would so move to a math city code 631 634 regarding
[1:31:30] We have a new ordinance, sure it has a new ordinance number for you, although we're amending
[1:31:38] the code.
[1:31:39] It's a new ordinance.
[1:31:40] That's 2018-12.
[1:31:41] So your original motion was correct, so we have a motion by Chris Docuetin, seconded
[1:31:47] by Ruth Pierce to place ordinance number 2018-12 on the third and final reading by title, only
[1:31:54] under suspension of the rules is their discussion
[1:32:02] Chris talking to be seen and Sharon will call the police
[1:32:08] Chris talking to yes non-baraker yes Nikki Boyd yes
[1:32:14] Suzanne Hawkins yes Reg planting yes
[1:32:18] Ruth Pierce yes Christopher Reed yes motion passes
[1:32:22] seven to zero Sharon would you read the title please
[1:32:27] Ordinance number 2018-12, an ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho,
[1:32:34] amending Twin Falls City Code 6-3-1 to prohibit rooster chickens and amending Twin Falls City
[1:32:43] Code 6-3-4 to allow the keeping of four or fewer hen chickens without a permit,
[1:32:52] Be it ordained by the Mayor and City Council of the City of Twin Falls, I'd help.
[1:32:58] Thank you, Sharon.
[1:32:59] Council wishes.
[1:33:01] Kibweid, seconded by Greg Lanting to adopt ordinance 2018-12.
[1:33:17] Is there any discussion?
[1:33:19] John Bericher?
[1:33:30] Yes.
[1:33:30] Nicki Boyd?
[1:33:32] Yes.
[1:33:32] Zann Hawkins?
[1:33:33] Yes.
[1:33:34] Greg Lanting?
[1:33:35] Yes.
[1:33:35] Ruth Pierce?
[1:33:36] Yes.
[1:33:37] Christopher Reed?
[1:33:38] Yes.
[1:33:39] Chris Talkington?
[1:33:40] Yes, she crude.
[1:33:43] Motion passes.
[1:33:44] Seven to zero. That's it. That's it. That's going to do the agenda.
[1:33:55] Meeting is adjourned.
