Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2017-01-30, recording 1 (started 17:00)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2017-01-30/

[0:08:09] I'd like to call the order of the Twin Falls City Council meeting for Monday January 30th 2017
[0:08:15] Before we get started with the agenda, I'd like to give a little bit of time to vice mayor Suzanne Hawkins. Thank you
[0:08:22] I'm gonna ask everybody in the audience in just a moment to join me for in a moment of silence
[0:08:27] Friday one of our fellow council members from Wilder was killed in a car accident
[0:08:32] Is Mal Fernandez was more than a council member?
[0:08:34] He's one of the youngest people in Idaho ever elected to an official office.
[0:08:40] He worked as a page at the State House.
[0:08:44] He campaigned door to door with his grandma because his dad was killed when he was six
[0:08:47] months old and his grandma raised him.
[0:08:50] Last year in June at the Association of Idaho City's annual conference, he worked with
[0:08:56] a lot of our youth and the kids that were there trying to make a difference not only
[0:09:00] locally in his community but throughout the state and he just really showed what true
[0:09:06] servant leadership was all about.
[0:09:08] I've gotten to know him a little bit.
[0:09:10] He was a wonderful young man.
[0:09:12] He had big aspirations for his future and I know he's being sorely missed by those that
[0:09:17] he worked with daily but I would just ask you all now to join me in a moment of silence
[0:09:21] for the loss that our state has suffered.
[0:09:31] Thank you.
[0:09:32] Thank you, Suzanne.
[0:09:34] And next on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance.
[0:09:36] We do have a voice out here this evening who I'd like to ask to come forward and lead
[0:09:39] us.
[0:09:40] Those of you who wish to join us, please rise.
[0:09:42] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
[0:10:04] If you wouldn't mind just stepping up to the podium here, please, and you're super
[0:10:09] nervous.
[0:10:10] If you could just tell us your name and which troop you're with and what badge you're
[0:10:14] working on this evening. My name is Grant Valed from Troops 73 of Twin Falls and I
[0:10:23] am working on the citizenship in the community and communication. Excellent.
[0:10:27] All of your punishment is complete now. You can sit down and enjoy the rest of the meeting.
[0:10:32] Thank you. Yes, Chris Stockington. I'd just like to pay homage to mentor
[0:10:42] mine in the audience. We were both much younger back in 1976 and 77. When I came
[0:10:48] on the council and Paul Austin was mayor. I want to remind everyone that that was in
[0:10:53] 1976, not 1877, but it was still last century and last millennium. Welcome, Mayor.
[0:11:01] Thank you, Chris. Welcome. I would confirm we do have a quorum of the council. All seven
[0:11:05] members are here this evening. Mr. Rockweller, do we have any amendments to the agenda?
[0:11:10] Mr. Mayor, members of the council, we would ask that you postpone the consideration of
[0:11:14] of item number three on the agenda this evening.
[0:11:17] We have not had an opportunity to review all the materials
[0:11:20] from ITD and we hope to put that on the agenda next week.
[0:11:24] We will do so, do we need formal action for that?
[0:11:28] All right, thank you.
[0:11:30] Next is proclinations of which we have none this evening.
[0:11:33] So next will be general public input.
[0:11:35] If there's anyone here from the public wishing
[0:11:37] to address the council on an item
[0:11:39] not on the agenda this evening,
[0:11:40] now is your chance to please come forward
[0:11:42] and address the council.
[0:11:51] Welcome, Mayor Austin.
[0:11:53] Honorable Mayor, I'm a respected council people.
[0:11:55] My name is Paul Austin.
[0:11:57] I'm a resident of the city at Twin Falls.
[0:12:01] I've been trying to get down here for the last four or five
[0:12:04] weeks and for some reason or other,
[0:12:07] and I'm not blaming it on the snow,
[0:12:08] but that's one of the reasons I haven't been able to get here.
[0:12:12] But it's nice to come down,
[0:12:15] nice to see my friend Chris and Greg still chopping away here.
[0:12:22] Really, I just got a couple three comments that I'd like to make tonight and share with you my feelings
[0:12:28] The first one is that I want to compliment the council and
[0:12:33] anybody else who had anything to do with the
[0:12:37] entry at bluelights and show shown to the horse I
[0:12:41] Think it's a beautiful thing
[0:12:44] It represents our community it
[0:12:46] It represents our area, and it's something that should have been done as far as I'm concerned
[0:12:54] a long time ago, back in 18 seconds.
[0:12:58] Anyway, just a comment along that same line, years ago, I remember that the City Council
[0:13:08] back in the days when we had what was called a little bit of revenue sharing.
[0:13:14] I remember, Chris might remember this, we put a little money in the, in the, the coffee
[0:13:22] and the, the budget to improve the entryway from fire along the, the old hospital in there.
[0:13:33] For some reason or another, that money never got used for that, probably for a far more
[0:13:39] important item.
[0:13:41] But that's one thing I would like to encourage anybody who has input to maybe improve our
[0:13:50] entryway into Twin Falls from Filer.
[0:13:54] We have a nice little spot right there before you get to the creek that would just be beautifully
[0:14:01] if we could just put it good anyway, food for thought.
[0:14:04] And then the last comment I want to make, I see in the paper that you're considering a
[0:14:10] possibility of increased money for the police department and or possibly the
[0:14:17] fire department. I certainly would like to encourage you to do that. If you have
[0:14:22] any monies at all in the budget that can't be expended, I can't think of
[0:14:27] anything that it would be better spent for. I've had an occasion in the last two
[0:14:33] months, three occasions supposedly, and they're not speeding tickets, so they were not ticketed.
[0:14:40] But to see our police department in work, and I was not only pleased with the mannerisms
[0:14:51] of the officers that took part in it, but I was pleased.
[0:14:56] And I think everybody would be very pleased to see these men in action.
[0:15:03] If you've got some money, throw it their way.
[0:15:07] If not, let's get some and keep these good men in our town.
[0:15:13] Thank you.
[0:15:14] Thank you, sir.
[0:15:17] Is there anyone else wishing to address the council this evening?
[0:15:23] Seeing none, we'll move on to the consent calendar.
[0:15:26] Council wishes.
[0:15:27] Susan Hawkins.
[0:15:28] I move approval.
[0:15:29] Second.
[0:15:32] Motion by Suzanne Hawkins, seconded by Christopher Reed to approve the consent calendar as present.
[0:15:40] Is there any discussion?
[0:15:44] Seeing none.
[0:15:45] Chair and roll call vote please.
[0:15:46] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:15:47] Yes.
[0:15:48] Nicky Boyd.
[0:15:49] Yes.
[0:15:50] John Bericke.
[0:15:51] Yes.
[0:15:52] Chris Hockington.
[0:15:53] Yes.
[0:15:54] Greg Lanting.
[0:15:55] Yes.
[0:15:56] Christopher Reed.
[0:15:57] Yes.
[0:15:58] Yes.
[0:15:59] Motion passes.
[0:16:00] And our items for consideration, the first is a presentation regarding the Idaho Department
[0:16:04] of Corrections Community Mentor Program.
[0:16:06] We have Jeff Kirkman, the program manager.
[0:16:10] Jeff, welcome.
[0:16:11] Well, Mayor, City Council members, thank you.
[0:16:17] I appreciate the time that you've allowed me to scan here before you and talk just a
[0:16:21] little bit about what this program is from the Idaho Department of Corrections.
[0:16:24] My way of introduction, my name is Jeff Kirkman and I'm a program manager with IDOC.
[0:16:30] I live in NAMBA and I just wanted to comment on the horse.
[0:16:32] I did notice that when I came into town today, and it's a plow, I think it's a plow that the horse
[0:16:37] is pulling, so I did notice that and I thought it was very, very cool.
[0:16:41] So the Department of Corrections, we recognize from all over the state, we release offenders
[0:16:46] from our institutions into communities around Idaho, that's obviously no secret.
[0:16:51] One of the things that we are very, very concerned with is protecting the public and
[0:16:54] how we go about doing that.
[0:16:56] One of the things that we've decided, that we've recognized is that we really need community
[0:17:00] involvement because 98% of our offenders that are getting out of prisons are coming back
[0:17:06] into communities across the state.
[0:17:09] And we don't want them coming back.
[0:17:10] I am literally trying to work myself out of a job here.
[0:17:13] We want them to come back.
[0:17:14] We want them to be connected to the community.
[0:17:17] We feel that they have connected to the community in a very positive way and they don't go back
[0:17:21] to those old habits or the old associates that led them to where they are now.
[0:17:27] We feel that that's one way that we can really protect communities around Idaho.
[0:17:32] One of the things we figured out we could do is it's not a new idea, but it is certainly
[0:17:36] new to the Department of Corrections.
[0:17:38] For about the last year or so, we've been developing this Free to Succeed program, and
[0:17:43] I think you have some couple of materials in front of you.
[0:17:47] But what this Free to Succeed program is for is the name implies one that when the offender
[0:17:53] is freed from incarceration and it could be either from an institution, a state institution.
[0:17:59] We also have lots and lots of offenders of our housing community and county facilities also.
[0:18:05] That that offender is then free to be successful.
[0:18:08] We want the community to step in and help that person be successful in their respective communities.
[0:18:14] Also it frees the community.
[0:18:16] For so long we wanted the community to help, but we've been very resistant about letting
[0:18:21] them into our inner circle, if you will, at the Department of Corrections.
[0:18:25] We've changed that.
[0:18:27] We want them to mentor these individuals when they come out in the community, more so than
[0:18:32] what our POs, our Probation and Pro Officers, can do.
[0:18:35] They're very limited at what they can do for the offenders on their caseload, and they
[0:18:39] may have 80 to 100 offenders on their caseload.
[0:18:43] And so what a mentor can provide is one-on-one accountability to that individual.
[0:18:48] They can take them to church if that's something that that individual wants to do.
[0:18:52] They can introduce them to their network of pro-social people.
[0:18:55] They can find resources that maybe we don't know about in the community.
[0:18:59] They can find other support services for them.
[0:19:02] It's all volunteer.
[0:19:04] The individual that's incarcerated, the offender requests a mentor, and it kind of spells it
[0:19:08] out in this thing that I sent out.
[0:19:10] So it's not a very involved or confusing way to get a mentor.
[0:19:15] It's very simple.
[0:19:16] simple. We've very simplified the process. We release about 3,200 offenders from our
[0:19:23] institutions and communities throughout Idaho. There's about 400 or so that we release on
[0:19:29] an annual basis in the district five area which Twin Falls, Burley this area down here. It
[0:19:34] is really incumbent upon us as a department to find ways to provide opportunities for those
[0:19:39] offenders to change their behavior. We don't want them back and you know there's a time,
[0:19:45] There's a money issue, there's a human factor involved, families are reunited.
[0:19:50] It really is a good program that we're really pushing.
[0:19:53] And so I want to just come before you and just let you know, it's just an FYI, I'm not
[0:19:57] here to ask for any money or anything like that.
[0:20:00] But just to let you know that this program is available to those who are on supervision
[0:20:04] in this community, whether they're coming out of a county jail or whether they're coming
[0:20:09] out of a state prison.
[0:20:11] So in a nutshell, that's really what it is, it's free to succeed.
[0:20:14] I don't want to take a whole lot of time.
[0:20:16] But I will stand for questions if you have any questions too.
[0:20:20] Thank you, Jeff.
[0:20:21] Chris talking to me.
[0:20:22] Jeff, good job.
[0:20:23] And we know you'll succeed.
[0:20:25] We have to succeed in this.
[0:20:27] I'm assuming part of your efforts would be to coordinate
[0:20:30] with the courts and local law enforcement
[0:20:33] as a transition halfway or something
[0:20:37] so that not only the service and civic organizations
[0:20:42] that we need to get involved, but there have to be some follow-up checks and mentoring if
[0:20:51] you will, people that get the release a little bit of affirmation that they're on the right
[0:20:58] track, if you know where I'm going on.
[0:21:00] Yes. We provide some training, and we just start, we just schedule some training here
[0:21:04] in Twin Falls with Cornerstone Baptist Church, they're going to host our first training for
[0:21:08] us. So reaching out to the community and ways like that, but we do provide training, and
[0:21:12] We focus on the manipulation part, the boundaries.
[0:21:16] This is a difficult population to work with,
[0:21:18] and so we want to mitigate as much as possible
[0:21:21] any of those issues that might arise.
[0:21:23] Again, the goal is to keep the community safe,
[0:21:25] and that includes the mentors who step in and help, too.
[0:21:28] But our probation and parole office, district office,
[0:21:30] and this community is on board with this.
[0:21:32] We have a lot of people that are excited about it,
[0:21:34] and so it's a great thing.
[0:21:36] It's really, you're gonna see a lot more of this.
[0:21:40] Last week, I think I did it.
[0:21:41] I was down here, I did interview with KMTV and there was an article in the paper about it and that's just sparked a whole lot of interest in this area.
[0:21:48] Good.
[0:21:49] Thank you, Council.
[0:21:50] Thank you.
[0:21:51] Thank you.
[0:21:52] Well, Jeff, thank you for taking the time to share this with us and would certainly encourage folks who want to learn more on the mentoring opportunities.
[0:21:58] They can visit your website, the Department of Corrections IDOC.idaho.gov and has the details on there.
[0:22:03] Thank you, Mayor.
[0:22:04] I appreciate it.
[0:22:05] Thank you, Council.
[0:22:06] Thank you.
[0:22:09] Next on the agenda is a request to approve an amendment
[0:22:12] to the memorandum of understanding
[0:22:14] between the City of Twin Falls,
[0:22:15] the Twin Falls Community Foundation
[0:22:17] and Gary and Connie Storrer,
[0:22:18] regarding the acquisition of property
[0:22:20] and the construction of a Canyon Rim Trail extension,
[0:22:23] Mitch Humboldt.
[0:22:25] So back in April last year,
[0:22:27] I'm sure all of you will remember what we entered
[0:22:29] into an agreement with the Community Foundation
[0:22:32] and the stores about the acquisition development
[0:22:36] of a trail across Storrer's property.
[0:22:38] Since we're a party to that agreement,
[0:22:40] there's now being proposed a quick minor amendment
[0:22:43] to that agreement that we need to sign off on.
[0:22:46] And so that's what we're here for,
[0:22:47] just actually approval to authorize the mayor
[0:22:49] to sign off on that on behalf of the city.
[0:22:52] Just briefly, in my take on this,
[0:22:55] the amendment really deals with the foundation and store,
[0:22:59] and doesn't really affect us too much,
[0:23:01] but we're a party of the agreement,
[0:23:02] we're gonna sign off in anyway.
[0:23:04] It changes the closing date up a couple of weeks,
[0:23:08] So we're ready to get moving on that.
[0:23:10] And it adds a provision for those guys
[0:23:12] to have, I'm going to get the board wrong here,
[0:23:16] but a promissory note for up to $100,000 for that.
[0:23:22] So again, I don't believe it really affects our piece
[0:23:25] of the deal too much.
[0:23:26] We're still responsible to build a trail
[0:23:28] and put on the fence and all those other kind of things
[0:23:31] that the agreement requires us to do.
[0:23:33] So here, we're just sort of supporting the other two
[0:23:37] parties in the deal and making it happen. So with that, I would stand for any
[0:23:41] questions that you might have. I also know there's a whole row of MavTech folks
[0:23:44] here. And if one of you guys want to come say anything more than what I've said, you
[0:23:51] might ask them some questions too. They might have if you have any. So anyway, Mitch,
[0:23:57] we do have a couple of lights here. Chris talked. Just wanted to affirm that upon
[0:24:04] And then receipt of the payment, the full payment, the warranty date will be in Twin Falls City's
[0:24:11] name.
[0:24:12] Will it for the right-of-way?
[0:24:13] Right.
[0:24:14] So we're going to receive the property on the 20th is when the closing date is scheduled
[0:24:17] for that and that's right, the 20th date.
[0:24:19] Okay, so it's got a little-
[0:24:20] It's coming to the city.
[0:24:21] It'll be free and clear.
[0:24:23] Yep.
[0:24:24] That will there be attachments for its usage or timelines or completion project?
[0:24:34] So we still will be governed by the agreement on what we are to be doing with the property
[0:24:40] and that is to build a trail on it.
[0:24:43] And it's pretty specific and we're going to build a trail.
[0:24:46] It's going to be in this location and we're going to have a fence that looks like this.
[0:24:50] And all that stuff is pretty well spelled out in the agreement and we're going to be
[0:24:53] subject to that agreement.
[0:24:54] Is there a timeline?
[0:24:56] I don't believe there's a timeline in that original agreement.
[0:24:59] Yeah.
[0:25:00] We just got to get going with it.
[0:25:02] there's no like deadline for us to finish that.
[0:25:08] I just want to get after it.
[0:25:09] So I just want to be clear.
[0:25:11] So my understanding is we were, you were raising 600,000
[0:25:15] and you're not quite there.
[0:25:17] Is that correct?
[0:25:20] Excellent.
[0:25:21] So 537 since she was not standing right by a mic.
[0:25:25] Right.
[0:25:26] So that additional 63,000 will be raised hopefully
[0:25:29] between now and that March deadline.
[0:25:38] So, the new date is the 15th February for the closing
[0:25:41] and also the promissory note allows another,
[0:25:46] what was it, check the timing again,
[0:25:49] I want to say six months, a year, another year for them
[0:25:53] to make that final payment up to $100,000.
[0:25:55] It's not 160,000.
[0:25:59] Right, okay.
[0:25:59] So they'll have a year to pay that,
[0:26:01] it probably won't take a year to get that.
[0:26:03] Correct, okay, thank you.
[0:26:04] Suzanne, let me have Travis jump in here because I think you may have a little bit of detail.
[0:26:11] So just maybe in relationship to the timeline that we've been working forward,
[0:26:17] and so we've been kind of penciling a timeline that we certainly have not been able to cast in stone,
[0:26:24] but in having conversations with MAFTAC about next appropriate steps.
[0:26:31] We believe it is entirely possible to go through the bidding process and
[0:26:36] to be in a position to be constructing the trail late spring early summer.
[0:26:42] With a completion date prior to the conclusion of the construction season.
[0:26:50] So we're looking more of a fallish at the latest completion of that trail.
[0:26:58] that trail. We have all of the funds that have been appropriated for our
[0:27:02] responsibility inside of the budget and all those estimates are proving to be
[0:27:06] true at this point and so we're we're anxious and looking forward to moving
[0:27:10] forward. Thank you, Travis, Suzanne Hawkins. Mitch, I was just wondering if maybe
[0:27:15] somebody from MavTech would want to give us an update of how they reach this goal
[0:27:19] and who some of the community partners are that helped us get there and and maybe
[0:27:24] give a plug for the option that's coming up just real quick so it goes on the
[0:27:27] record. Jamie, thank you. So Jamie can I think speak to some of the upcoming fundraising I do
[0:27:39] know that there has been some effort to plan a sort of a groundbreaking kickoff to use that as
[0:27:45] the opportunity to celebrate some of the donors who have been a part of this but certainly future
[0:27:51] opportunities I think Jamie could speak to now. That's very true. Thank you Sean. Absolutely we do
[0:27:57] We have many community partners who are involved in this process.
[0:28:01] However, at this time, I'm not going to speak about who those partners are at this time.
[0:28:07] Like Sean mentioned, we will do that at the groundbreaking when everything is set in stone.
[0:28:14] I hate to just announce things that are not 100% on docket yet.
[0:28:21] So we currently are close to our goal of 600,000 of everything goes as planned as we're working
[0:28:29] on with the timeline and some term agreements through some of the partners that we're working
[0:28:34] with right now.
[0:28:36] Once that is complete, hopefully, within the next couple of weeks with that deadline of
[0:28:42] February 15th, we should know for sure where we stand and where we're at.
[0:28:47] We are working closely with Travis and other city partners on that timeline to make sure
[0:28:53] that we're at where you guys are at and that we are coordinating really well together.
[0:28:59] Thank you.
[0:29:00] The auction can I speak towards that really quick.
[0:29:03] Thank you to Title 1, which Jason Vickery has put forth announcement that they would like
[0:29:11] to.
[0:29:12] One that he mentioned is we can't give you a hundred thousand but we can give you our
[0:29:18] time and our energy, which I love and they're going to be sponsoring a dinner auction for
[0:29:22] us on March 16th.
[0:29:25] That is a Thursday evening and that dinner auction will be how the elevation and elevation
[0:29:32] is sponsoring the space where Title 1 is sponsoring the dinner and with MathTech's help all of
[0:29:39] the crew where we're working on some auction items so if you have any
[0:29:43] auction items you would like to put up to help us get to this finish line please
[0:29:49] don't hesitate to contact me. Thank you Jamie. Thank you. Greg Lanting. Jamie, before you leave
[0:29:57] I believe I've already made a donation but I would certainly like to go to the
[0:30:01] auction and things. How does one get tickets for that? Great question, please
[0:30:05] contact Jason Vickery through Title 1. They have the tickets and and all the
[0:30:12] information that you can attend. Okay. I'd love to have you. Thank you.
[0:30:16] The statements are $200 or for $1,000 you didn't have a table for an 8-10.
[0:30:24] Okay. Chris talking to you. I'm just looking ahead a little bit under the most
[0:30:29] optimistic scenario of the closure and the city working. One do you think we
[0:30:34] might get this trail completed and linking up the two dead ends. Travis can speak to that.
[0:30:43] Yes, so we hope to have the trail going through the bid process this late spring early summer,
[0:30:48] and we hope to have it completed in time for the conclusion of the fall 2017 construction cycle.
[0:30:56] Wonderful. It's going to make a world-class final destination site. That's great.
[0:31:05] Great Lansing.
[0:31:06] I think as soon as we get this connected,
[0:31:08] we should partner with some of the groups,
[0:31:10] and there needs to be a run that starts somewhere
[0:31:12] and uses the light of lies all the way.
[0:31:15] I am sure that Matt has plans for that.
[0:31:19] I don't even know where it's.
[0:31:21] Because I've seen our good council further,
[0:31:26] the city or attorney, right, he's pike up this.
[0:31:29] So I know it's possible.
[0:31:31] I think it'd be pretty, it looked hard,
[0:31:33] as soon as possible.
[0:31:34] I move that we grant the request to approve an amendment to the memorandum of understanding
[0:31:45] between the City of Twin Falls, the Twin Falls Community Foundation and Gary and Connie Store
[0:31:51] regarding the acquisition of property and the construction of a canyon rim trail extension.
[0:31:57] Question by Nikki Boyd, seconded by Ruth Pierce to approve the amendment has
[0:32:03] presented. Is there any discussion from the council? Sharon Rolkov, please.
[0:32:10] Nikki Boyd? Yes. Sean Berriger? Yes. Chris Hockington? Yes. Greg Lanting? Yes. Christopher
[0:32:18] Reid? Yes. Ruth Pierce? Yes. Suzanne Hawkins? Yes.
[0:32:23] Motion passes, seven to zero.
[0:32:26] Chris Stockington.
[0:32:27] I'd just like to make one more comment.
[0:32:28] Mayor Austin's gone, but the whole trail system
[0:32:31] actually started last century in the 1970s or 80s.
[0:32:37] I think it might have been under Paul Austin
[0:32:39] where we initiated the trail in the Rock Creek Canyon.
[0:32:42] Isn't that correct?
[0:32:44] Look how far we've come, that's amazing.
[0:32:48] And thank you to MavTech and all of your community partners
[0:32:50] for your diligence and community support for this project.
[0:32:53] it would not have been possible without your efforts.
[0:32:55] So kudos to you and thank you.
[0:32:58] And I'll get that signed real soon.
[0:33:08] Next on the agenda is a request to consider
[0:33:10] providing mid-year compensation adjustments
[0:33:12] to sworn police officers and firefighters.
[0:33:15] Effective February 5th 2017,
[0:33:17] we have our city manager Travis Rothweiler.
[0:33:19] So Mr. Mayor and members of the council,
[0:33:21] before I begin, I want to apologize at any point in time
[0:33:25] should this become completely disjointed?
[0:33:30] There is some question a little earlier today,
[0:33:32] it's whether or not I would be here,
[0:33:34] and I am propped up on cold medicine and anti-flu stuff,
[0:33:38] so I would say stay away, I might be,
[0:33:41] but we'll get through this together.
[0:33:44] So I asked for a little bit of patience
[0:33:45] and indulge your grace as we kind of work through this together.
[0:33:53] So tonight I come before you to present
[0:33:55] these recommended mid-year adjustments for sworn police officers and for our firefighters.
[0:34:05] And in doing so, I kind of want to take a step back in time to kind of help you understand
[0:34:13] how we arrived here tonight.
[0:34:21] This is a illustration of the city's strategic plan.
[0:34:26] And it is something that we will refer to throughout tonight's presentation.
[0:34:33] In the last fiscal year, you'll notice that we made a change that prior to this illustration,
[0:34:42] all of the eight focus areas pointed towards the vision.
[0:34:47] And then we started having a conversation about the value and the importance of the employees
[0:34:51] inside of the City of Twin Falls.
[0:34:54] And it was quickly recognized by all that the most important link to quality public services
[0:35:01] is having a quality public team.
[0:35:06] And our team is among some of the best, and I would be happy to compare them to any other
[0:35:12] team inside of our state and nation.
[0:35:17] So we made the shift, and we made the shift recognizing that it was the internal organization
[0:35:23] at the end of the day that is going to help us drive home this strategic plan.
[0:35:31] And if you take a look at the time from October 1st 2015 to October 31st 2016, you'll notice
[0:35:40] that we have moved our table more steps than at any other point in our history.
[0:35:48] We moved our table a total of 9.73%, it was half a percent in October 1st, last June we
[0:35:58] did a mid-year adjustment of 4%, followed up with a 5% adjustment on October 1st of this
[0:36:07] year at the beginning of the fiscal year.
[0:36:10] In addition to that we provided compensation adjustments that total 8.15%, 3% in 2015 and
[0:36:18] 5% at the beginning of this fiscal year 2016.
[0:36:26] In addition to that, we've had many of our employees be able to benefit from compression
[0:36:31] ratio adjustments.
[0:36:33] Those are those steps in our time in which employees reach certain 10 years and they're
[0:36:38] able to advance.
[0:36:41] And we move them along the salary table.
[0:36:45] If they are not at the appropriate place on our salary table based upon tenure, we slide
[0:36:51] them forward.
[0:36:52] And recent changes have allowed fewer of those adjustments to occur, but they still do occur
[0:36:57] from time to time in our employees have benefited from them.
[0:37:01] And I want you to know, and I say that, because I know that at certain points of this conversation
[0:37:09] tonight, you may become discouraged, and I'm hoping that you will hold on to the fact that
[0:37:13] the work that you've done to this point in most places of our organization has been absolutely
[0:37:20] spot on and have been the steps that we've needed to take.
[0:37:25] In fact, one of that testaments is the fact that most of our departments are fully staffed
[0:37:30] today.
[0:37:31] And if you look back just a few months, 18 months ago, you would notice some of our departments
[0:37:38] were not.
[0:37:39] In fact, some of those departments maybe were down 40%.
[0:37:45] Two people out of a building department of five individuals constitute 40% reduction
[0:37:51] in their team, which means that they're not able to service our citizens and their customers
[0:37:57] in a manner that we have set out in our strategic plan.
[0:38:02] So the steps that you have taken have been aggressive and the steps that you have taken
[0:38:05] have worked because the building department today is fully staffed.
[0:38:09] The public works team is doing great works, they're fully staffed.
[0:38:14] And the retirements are the only reasons why we've had certain vacancies that have come
[0:38:19] and sprung up.
[0:38:22] However, if that were the end of the story for all parts of our organization, this conversation
[0:38:28] wouldn't be needed tonight.
[0:38:32] And so tonight, I want to address a couple of areas that we need to focus upon.
[0:38:41] And that is our sworn police officers and our firefighters.
[0:38:45] I would invite conversations throughout this entire presentation so that I can answer your
[0:38:50] questions as they arise.
[0:38:52] I'm hoping that this can be more of a free-flowing conversation as opposed to one that is just me
[0:38:59] speaking and then having you trying to remember your questions at the end of the presentation.
[0:39:06] Certainly we'll make opportunity for that.
[0:39:12] One of the things that I enjoy doing is having the opportunity to connect with all members
[0:39:21] of our team on an annual basis.
[0:39:25] And while I admit that going out annually may not be enough, I am proud of the fact that
[0:39:31] we've held annual conversations throughout our organization every year for the last five
[0:39:37] years.
[0:39:39] And when I first started those conversations, we felt like I was the only one talking.
[0:39:47] And there wasn't a lot of response.
[0:39:50] And over time, there has been more response than this year.
[0:39:53] You could say that it reached a crescendo in some areas.
[0:39:58] And one of the primary reasons was this fact on this screen right here, is that when we
[0:40:04] looked at a salary survey that was presented to me in October, that had been produced by
[0:40:12] the city of Meridian. It reflected some pretty staggering news. And while I think that we
[0:40:18] at the leadership team knew that we were not competitive or as competitive with the Treasure
[0:40:25] Valley law enforcement agencies that have routinely taken our people, I think that we
[0:40:32] we were, I know I was shocked to see it had grown to this level.
[0:40:38] I was proud of the fact that we had moved the table 5%, but Meridian, our competition,
[0:40:43] moved at 5 and a quarter percent, according to their chief.
[0:40:47] And when you start out significantly above 5 and a quarter percent actually increases
[0:40:56] the divide between what we're paying, our law enforcement professionals, and what other
[0:41:01] communities were paying theirs. So after we received the survey, we took an opportunity
[0:41:07] to kind of condense it into this sheet. And we worked on this, recognizing that not all
[0:41:16] things are going to be in alignment, especially when you start looking at positions like staff
[0:41:22] sergeants. I'm going to look at Gretchen and Brian occasionally because I don't believe
[0:41:26] that a lot of organizations have the position of staff sergeants in local law enforcement.
[0:41:33] So when we have the position of staff sergeant, it's a bit of a hybrid that we have to tweak
[0:41:38] into that system.
[0:41:41] But if you take a look, you'll notice that if you have an officer with three years of experience,
[0:41:47] with a basic certification from post, the difference is 19.89%.
[0:41:59] That continues to look at an officer with five years that grows to 32%.
[0:42:05] an officer with 10 years of experience that grows 25% and so on and so forth.
[0:42:21] I think the challenge is the absolute size of the problem and where I think that I have
[0:42:29] failed is the fact that we have tried to take incremental steps to try to alleviate the problem
[0:42:37] in looking out and trying to compete with those law enforcement agencies.
[0:42:41] our incremental steps have not allowed us to complete or to patch this whole.
[0:42:53] When you begin to look at individuals who have left our department since 2011, this is
[0:43:01] information that was compiled by TFPD, you can see that 49 of our now 56 sworn police
[0:43:11] officers have left our organization since 2011. That represents a 64.5 turnover rate in
[0:43:21] a five-year period of time. And the reasons why they have left are illustrated on the
[0:43:29] table above. But it shows that 15 of the 49 have left to find other employment at other
[0:43:39] law enforcement agencies in the state.
[0:43:43] Four of them resigned in lieu of termination, 12 resigned in general, 12 retired, five were
[0:43:50] terminated, and one was promoted to the position of Deputy City Manager.
[0:43:57] There's our 49 positions.
[0:44:00] And of those 15, you can see that seven of them had occurred in 2015 and 2016.
[0:44:14] But in addition to that, we also started to hear rumblings of additional individuals testing,
[0:44:22] looking at other opportunities.
[0:44:24] Questioning whether or not they wanted to remain inside of the City of Twin Falls, questioning
[0:44:30] whether or not the organization was honestly living up to its strategic planning objectives
[0:44:34] of treating them fairly, providing them with a market-based compensation and moving forward.
[0:44:43] So why did we pick the Treasure Valley?
[0:44:45] Why look at the Treasure Valley?
[0:44:47] I think the Treasure Valley is not only taking our talent,
[0:44:56] and that is everything from the Attorney General's office
[0:44:58] to law enforcement agencies throughout that valley,
[0:45:03] but they really are similar in size.
[0:45:06] So I want you for a moment not to think of the city
[0:45:10] of Twin Falls as a community shy of 50,000 people,
[0:45:14] Because our police department and our fire department
[0:45:16] and on an annual basis do not service a community
[0:45:19] of just shy of 50,000 people.
[0:45:22] We are a regional hub.
[0:45:24] And if our estimates are correct,
[0:45:25] we're a community of roughly 75 to 80,000
[0:45:32] when you look at total service population.
[0:45:35] And when you're a community of 75,000 people
[0:45:41] and you begin to look at the number
[0:45:44] of law enforcement officers that we have,
[0:45:47] who are truly dedicated to our community.
[0:45:50] One of the things that we will tell you
[0:45:51] is the calls for service with the TFPD are no less here
[0:45:55] than anywhere else.
[0:45:56] In fact, one of the things that I have been told
[0:46:00] is that if you look at our call volumes,
[0:46:04] our individual officer call volumes are significantly higher
[0:46:08] than what their peers will experience in other communities.
[0:46:12] In fact, it has been shared a couple of times,
[0:46:15] whether it is true or by urban legend.
[0:46:18] The worst place to find a parking place in Boise
[0:46:22] is on the street when there are 15 cop cars
[0:46:25] that respond to a simple automobile accident on State Street.
[0:46:31] There are a lot more officers in these communities,
[0:46:34] and when you look at a community of about 45 to 48,000,
[0:46:38] and if you believe in ratios, they're appropriate.
[0:46:42] But if you begin also to look at the number of community,
[0:46:46] members that we're serving,
[0:46:47] the number of officers that we have is also something
[0:46:50] that we need to continue to address as we advance
[0:46:55] and move forward.
[0:46:57] The challenge that we have is retaining the quality talent
[0:47:01] that we have today.
[0:47:04] Travis, I want to make sure that we're correct.
[0:47:08] When we look at the Treasure Valley,
[0:47:09] we're excluding City of Boise though.
[0:47:11] Yes, that is correct.
[0:47:12] So when we're looking at the Treasure Valley,
[0:47:14] we're looking at all of those cities except for Boise.
[0:47:17] Yes.
[0:47:18] And that is reflected on this sheet that reflects 32% less.
[0:47:25] Those are all of the Treasure Valley,
[0:47:28] based upon the salary survey that I had received,
[0:47:30] and it does exclude the city of Boise's
[0:47:35] compensation's good.
[0:47:36] Would the assumption be that the city of Boise's
[0:47:38] face scale exceeds that average?
[0:47:44] Yeah, we don't need to assume that we know
[0:47:46] that the City of Boise's compensation scale
[0:47:48] makes that look even worse.
[0:47:51] Travis, just a comment I would make
[0:47:53] when you were talking about this slide previously,
[0:47:57] addressing this new information that really shows quite a chasm
[0:48:06] in some of these pay ratios, but also commenting
[0:48:10] that the council and the city staff and our budgeting efforts
[0:48:14] really have been trying to address this organization-wide for the last few years, this, to me, this
[0:48:22] is an example of forces outside of our control that are influencing the creation of the problem,
[0:48:30] but that we have the opportunity now to help address the problem.
[0:48:33] It's not for lack of trying to address some of these things, I think, is maybe the summary
[0:48:38] of that.
[0:48:39] I don't think that any of this is a dereliction of duty.
[0:48:42] In fact, what I do believe is, well, very candidly,
[0:48:47] I think that if you go back and look,
[0:48:50] I think that this information has always been available.
[0:48:53] I think it's a question on how we looked at data.
[0:48:56] And I think that looking at data and taking data
[0:49:01] and applying it to measures to ensure
[0:49:04] that it truly reflects the entities
[0:49:07] that you're competing with has been an important learning lesson
[0:49:11] for me in this process, that you really can't just look at that bottom line to see what it's
[0:49:17] telling you. Because really, and we mean no disrespect, but there are several agencies
[0:49:24] that we sample and pull their data that aren't true competition, that really aren't a part
[0:49:32] of that process. And when you remove those from that picture, and you begin to look at
[0:49:38] how and where our compensation levels lie.
[0:49:43] It's easy to go back in hindsight being 2020 to say,
[0:49:47] now I see the fact.
[0:49:52] And I wish, is there anything more on that piece?
[0:49:57] And please, I don't see anything.
[0:49:59] Because I wish that's where the story ended,
[0:50:01] but we also experienced those same compensation issues
[0:50:07] inside of our fire department,
[0:50:09] but inside of our fire department
[0:50:10] were also compounded, if you will,
[0:50:14] with another unique feature that is associated
[0:50:18] with our collective bargaining agreement that we have.
[0:50:23] So right now, we have what I would believe
[0:50:25] to be an internal pay equity issue
[0:50:28] inside of our fire department ranks.
[0:50:31] And that is partially caused,
[0:50:34] well, it's caused by a whole series of factors,
[0:50:36] but one of the primary drivers, in my opinion,
[0:50:40] is there are mandated adjustments that occur
[0:50:43] as an individual promotes from fire fighter to driver,
[0:50:48] and they will promote at a mandatory 7%.
[0:50:51] And when you go from driver to captain,
[0:50:54] it's an adjustment of 10%.
[0:50:58] And what happens is when we have officers
[0:51:04] with more tenure in the department
[0:51:11] take longer to promote up.
[0:51:14] When they do promote up, there are times
[0:51:17] in which they will be less tenured in their current role
[0:51:21] as a driver or as a captain, but are making significantly more
[0:51:26] than other drivers or other captains
[0:51:28] who had been serving in those roles for, in some cases,
[0:51:32] many years.
[0:51:34] And when we ran into that situation in other departments,
[0:51:38] We've had the ability to make those adjustments and movements.
[0:51:42] We've done that routinely with sergeants.
[0:51:45] We've done that in the engineering department.
[0:51:47] We've done these in many, many other places.
[0:51:50] And you would say, why do you not do that for the fire department?
[0:51:54] And the reason we didn't do that for the fire department
[0:51:56] was because we have a collective bargaining agreement that states,
[0:51:59] this is how we're going to work and operate.
[0:52:02] So what's different?
[0:52:05] Scott said, we're through is a captain and also president.
[0:52:08] is here this evening. We spent some time not only with him, but also members of the Executive
[0:52:14] Board. And we were able to, Chief Sol was able to sign into a memorandum of understanding
[0:52:22] that really was a product of the past conversation of the collective bargaining agreement. And
[0:52:26] when we presented that to you, I had shared that we wanted to make some surgical fixes
[0:52:31] to help us fix equity issues inside of the fire department. This proposal fixes some
[0:52:37] of those equity issues that we have to prevent that leapfrogging, if you will, that's what
[0:52:44] I refer to it as in moving forward.
[0:52:50] And in having a conversation with the members of our local, they believed, and I would just
[0:52:59] ask them to nod or if I just verify this is true, that the equity issues were the primary
[0:53:05] a concern that we needed to address today, with a commitment to continue to close that gap
[0:53:11] on the compensation and market piece in the subsequent steps.
[0:53:18] Okay.
[0:53:19] I see nods.
[0:53:20] That's good, right?
[0:53:21] Because if the word, I would be like, this whole presentation just got blown up.
[0:53:30] So I want to just take a minute and talk about the connection to the strategic plan.
[0:53:34] So hopefully that presents the problem.
[0:53:39] And I think that this goes to the commitment that this council and immediate past councils
[0:53:46] have had when it comes to ensuring and creating a quality work environment for our employees,
[0:53:52] especially as it relates to compensation.
[0:53:55] In 2012, the City of Twin Falls adopted a strategic plan through a process that involved
[0:54:01] the community and we're going to go back through that process.
[0:54:04] And when we created that strategic plan, it was the very first strategic plan that included
[0:54:08] any recognition of the efforts of our employees.
[0:54:14] And from that point in time, we move forward.
[0:54:18] Here is the preamble, if you will, to focus area number eight,
[0:54:25] where it talks that the City of Twin Falls
[0:54:27] strives to carry out its mission with unquestioned integrity
[0:54:31] and the highest ethical standards,
[0:54:34] that we have a shared obligation to create a quality community,
[0:54:38] community, to take advantage of opportunities, to be transparent in our decision-making practices,
[0:54:45] that we are going to work in close partnership with professionals and our partners, and that
[0:54:50] we can do this if we have a high level of competency that is provided by a lean, properly
[0:55:02] compensated employee court.
[0:55:10] Tonight's effort is really to continue on that path
[0:55:14] in police, sworn police officer, and firefighter to continue
[0:55:20] to honor the strategic planning processes just as we have tried
[0:55:24] to do in all the other departments.
[0:55:27] The two primary areas of the strategic plan are reflected
[0:55:30] up here, goal number, internal organization one,
[0:55:33] provide an effective professional high quality services
[0:55:36] to our residents, businesses, industries, and visitors.
[0:55:38] And how are we going to do that?
[0:55:41] The very first objective is to attract,
[0:55:43] recruit, retain the most qualified employees.
[0:55:48] The second is to treat our employees fairly.
[0:55:54] And that we are going to do that by having a strong,
[0:55:58] informed, committed workforce through fair compensation,
[0:56:01] good treatment, and professional development programs.
[0:56:04] And that we are going to, under the first objective,
[0:56:07] create and maintain a market competitive compensation model
[0:56:10] and a corresponding benefits program.
[0:56:19] So when we go forward tonight,
[0:56:20] I think that you need to recognize
[0:56:22] that this isn't where it ends.
[0:56:25] This is a multiple step process,
[0:56:29] and that's really no different
[0:56:31] than the multiple step process that we've been in.
[0:56:34] We are in an environment that is highly competitive.
[0:56:37] If you talk to many of our private sector employees,
[0:56:41] they say that workforce talent development,
[0:56:45] employees is one of the primary driving factors of their decision-making processes.
[0:56:51] Please note that it is no different for us.
[0:56:54] That we, every single day, are competing for the right to capture the absolute best talent.
[0:57:00] And if we're going to do that, then we need to continue to make sure that we're vigilant
[0:57:04] in the areas of compensation, not just tonight, but as we move forward, and I'll talk about
[0:57:08] that, possible future steps that we will be moving forward with for your consideration
[0:57:13] as we continue to develop those.
[0:57:16] But tonight we really need to focus on sworn police
[0:57:21] and firefighters, and I want you to look at this
[0:57:24] as a stop gap.
[0:57:27] This is a stop gap.
[0:57:30] Please do not look at this as a final solution.
[0:57:39] So the proposal that I have calls for an average
[0:57:42] of 7% adjustment for sworn police officers,
[0:57:49] but it's not a blanket adjustment.
[0:57:53] In fact, the lowest is zero.
[0:57:56] There are employees that are associated with this plan
[0:57:59] that will not receive a compensation increase
[0:58:02] as a result of this proposal.
[0:58:05] And the question is why?
[0:58:07] Well, because we believe and look at the market,
[0:58:11] that is not needed.
[0:58:13] But you also see that there are individuals
[0:58:16] that are receiving compensation adjustments
[0:58:18] as high as 22% in the same logic applies.
[0:58:24] because it's warranted, because it's needed.
[0:58:27] And the cost for the balance of this fiscal year
[0:58:29] is $258,000 with an annual cost of $369,000.
[0:58:37] So how did we come up with this?
[0:58:40] So what we did was we took a look at our competition
[0:58:44] and I asked Regent to take our officers
[0:58:49] with their current certification levels,
[0:58:53] educational attainments, whatever was called for
[0:58:57] in this organization's survey, or their compensation model,
[0:59:01] and I said, what would it take for us to get here?
[0:59:06] And remember, Twin Falls is unique with some of our positions,
[0:59:09] so we kind of worked through that process.
[0:59:12] And placing them into our organization
[0:59:16] would cost roughly $800,000 today.
[0:59:19] You can see that this makes up about half of that ground
[0:59:24] in its annual cost.
[0:59:26] And this is really what it looks like.
[0:59:28] Caratos, before you move on, can you clarify
[0:59:31] whether it's 396 or $376,000?
[0:59:35] It's $396,000 in FY18.
[0:59:42] I only ask is the documents in the packet have 376.
[0:59:52] Let's go on 396.
[0:59:53] Let's go on 396.
[0:59:55] To be honest, I mean $20,000 in the vaccine, this isn't.
[0:59:58] That number came from Lori today.
[1:00:01] And so I'm going to trust the 396.
[1:00:04] Her and Gretchen can argue over the $20,000
[1:00:07] later on terms of which one is right.
[1:00:15] But then we took that a step further.
[1:00:16] And you can see when I say it's not a blanket adjustment,
[1:00:19] you can see what occurs.
[1:00:21] That it's actually much more pinpointed in those areas
[1:00:28] that we're seeing the greatest loss
[1:00:30] in attrition of our individuals and the greatest level
[1:00:33] of market disparity.
[1:00:36] So you will see that, in some cases,
[1:00:39] an introductory police officer will receive 0.12% of a race,
[1:00:47] where an individual who we will call a PO3 will receive 10.59%.
[1:00:56] And that's just the average for those who we would call a PO3.
[1:01:01] And I know that I apologize that you can't see this,
[1:01:04] but this actually represents every single sworn police
[1:01:07] officer within our department and the percent of wage that they will receive.
[1:01:12] And you can see that there are many individuals who are in these various police officer categories
[1:01:19] that will receive raises well in excess of 10 and 12 percent.
[1:01:26] That is in addition to the five and five move that it occurred earlier this year.
[1:01:34] The idea is to take that first really big bite, and I believe this gets us to about 91 percent.
[1:01:44] This gets us to about 91 percent of the Treasure Valley markets that we had surveyed and sampled.
[1:01:54] So it really does a good job in closing that gap, and that's why I think that you need
[1:01:58] to view that as that stop-gap measure, it's not all the way through.
[1:02:06] We'll talk about subsequent steps.
[1:02:08] Is there any other questions about the police adjustment process?
[1:02:18] So in firefighter equity, there's an annual cost of about $177,000 and the balance of
[1:02:26] this fiscal year is $118,000 and by coincidence, it's a 7% adjustment because we want the
[1:02:33] through that exact same wage and process for the firefighters.
[1:02:40] And that ranges between 0 and 22.4%
[1:02:45] in terms of their individual compensation levels.
[1:02:49] And really, it's about that same process that we used.
[1:02:54] We took these individuals, we took their certifications,
[1:02:57] we took their experiences, and then we
[1:02:59] placed them into a better hierarchy in moving forward.
[1:03:04] It recognizes length in 10 year of the role
[1:03:08] in which they are serving.
[1:03:10] And so this represents what you will see inside the percentage
[1:03:16] of increases very similar to the fire department.
[1:03:19] And you will see that some of the ranges vary between role.
[1:03:26] And because this is about 10 year in the position,
[1:03:30] when you add another chart and graph,
[1:03:32] you can see that the individual who is a driver that's
[1:03:37] getting at a 2% raise, this individual's
[1:03:41] been in the role for a year, so you
[1:03:43] can see how that corresponds as that kind of moves up.
[1:03:50] Again, the emphasis is making sure
[1:03:53] that we are creating the foundations of a immediate stop
[1:03:58] gap to prevent the hemorrhage.
[1:04:04] The total cost again is $376,000, or $300,000.
[1:04:13] OK, so that's the.
[1:04:15] So our CFO is going to explain to me how $376,000 equals $396,000.
[1:04:22] So when you go back to the last slide where you asked that,
[1:04:26] that's the total cost for the police department.
[1:04:29] There's a portion for an annual cost of $396.
[1:04:33] There's a portion that we'll have to come up with in 17 and a portion in 18.
[1:04:40] And then there's a total cost for fire and the amount that we need to come up for
[1:04:45] in this year added to the police is the three seventy six.
[1:04:50] Thank you.
[1:04:51] So it's the two fifty eight plus one seventy seven.
[1:04:56] One eighty eight.
[1:04:59] Yeah, one eighteen.
[1:05:00] Right.
[1:05:01] Thank you.
[1:05:05] So one of the questions is exactly how are we going to pay for this?
[1:05:11] And what we've been able to do is we've been able to look at our current existing budgets
[1:05:16] and we've been able to go through a process that will move funds to help offset some of these new liabilities that we're causing.
[1:05:28] As a result of our effort, we've been able to directly earmark $210,000 of the amount needed to move that forward.
[1:05:37] That does not take into account any of the position vacancies that we anticipate that will occur.
[1:05:43] In fact, over a five-year period, on the average, Lori had shared with me in a bet we routinely have in excess of a million dollars a year in salary savings
[1:05:56] savings as a result of not being able to fully staff our organization.
[1:06:02] And while I think that some level of salary savings is appropriate, it's interesting that
[1:06:07] when you see that 52% of it comes from the police department alone.
[1:06:13] And that grows to 71% when you incorporate the fire department.
[1:06:18] Travis Chris has it coming.
[1:06:19] I think that's really an important point.
[1:06:21] I'd like you to reiterate that if I could capitalize at what you're saying,
[1:06:25] Our ability to fully staff in both departments I guess, primarily police, has left already
[1:06:35] tax authorized and collected funds that are sitting in reserves because they are not being
[1:06:40] expended for those sworn officers.
[1:06:44] They're not in reserves, but they're just in our line items that will transfer to reserves
[1:06:49] should they not get spent this year, that's correct.
[1:06:52] they are not new tax dollars that we have to acquire.
[1:06:56] None of this, so you can't, at this point in time in this junction,
[1:07:01] we are not asking you for any new tax dollars for the mid-year adjustment.
[1:07:05] Thank you.
[1:07:06] Yep.
[1:07:07] We'll talk about future strategies.
[1:07:10] So there's like a three-step dance card here tonight.
[1:07:13] I'm still on step one.
[1:07:16] Step one is the most complicated.
[1:07:21] But I also want you to think about what that means from a workload perspective.
[1:07:32] I don't know, I'm sure you know this, but my work is never done.
[1:07:39] I never leave my office with the opportunity to have a clean slate the following day.
[1:07:47] I will always have some number of emails that I didn't respond to.
[1:07:51] I will have some number of larger projects that we'll be working out there.
[1:07:56] I will have something that I just ran out of time, and it moves and shifts to a priority,
[1:08:02] and if you ask L'Ila, sometimes getting a meeting with me is worse than getting a meeting
[1:08:07] with my kids' pediatrician.
[1:08:10] Sometimes it's pretty hard, and I'm really grateful that we have two deputy city managers
[1:08:14] to absorb that workload, and they would probably share the exact same thing.
[1:08:19] When you look around, there's a lot of things going on in Twin Falls.
[1:08:22] Now, I want you to think about you as a police officer.
[1:08:30] You don't have the opportunity not to respond to that call.
[1:08:37] You can't just push that off to tomorrow.
[1:08:43] Their work doesn't stop when they're short staffed.
[1:08:47] In fact, it gets more complex because they can't not do the job.
[1:08:54] So what do we do?
[1:08:56] We have to pull in other segments.
[1:09:00] We have to place a stronger emphasis on patrol and less emphasis on narcotics, on traffic,
[1:09:07] on many other valuable important parts of our organization.
[1:09:14] And so this is as much about public safety as anything that we've ever done.
[1:09:21] And what I want you to remember is having a quality community hinges upon a community's
[1:09:31] to provide safety and security for its citizens.
[1:09:37] It is a fundamental driver of local economies.
[1:09:42] This is just as important about economic development
[1:09:45] as what we're doing on Main Street.
[1:09:47] In fact, I will argue that if people don't feel safe
[1:09:49] going on Main Street, then there's a question of whether
[1:09:54] or not we can do the project or should do that project.
[1:09:59] We believe that this is going to be something
[1:10:02] that can be addressed in the first fiscal year,
[1:10:06] but it requires a second step.
[1:10:08] Here's the second piece to the dance.
[1:10:10] And that is the development of a new compensation model.
[1:10:17] I believe, and it's taken me a while to mature to this place,
[1:10:25] that maybe not one size fits all.
[1:10:30] And maybe we do need to look at different structures
[1:10:33] across our organization that are more predictable.
[1:10:37] Structures that allow members of our team to see the city's commitment to them in future
[1:10:48] years and have a knowledge of the investments that they need to make in themselves to be
[1:10:55] able to achieve those different roles or those different levels and rates of compensation.
[1:11:02] One that is understandable and one that is predictable.
[1:11:06] that all of our competition has. And while I might be able to look at our salary table
[1:11:12] and I might be able to decipher it and share and move and advance it, that doesn't matter
[1:11:22] if the young officer or firefighter can't look at the compensation model and understand
[1:11:30] how they can grow with it. So the second step of this process would be to develop a compensation
[1:11:39] model that allows us to transform the existing process that we have to build a new model that
[1:11:47] would be in time for your consideration and adoption for the fiscal year 18 budget, which
[1:11:52] means that I've shared with Gretchen, we need to have that probably by May, so that we can
[1:12:00] incorporate those expenditures and a pathway forward to be able to continue to move our salary
[1:12:06] table in the right direction.
[1:12:12] The third step.
[1:12:14] The third step then provides a general thought across the organization.
[1:12:20] And right now, based upon early information, we believe that we need to make every reasonable
[1:12:27] approach and step to provide a 3.5% adjustment to all of our employees and look at moving
[1:12:37] the existing table, although it may be new across the organization, the equivalence of
[1:12:42] about 5%. That does not mean our employees are going to receive an 8.5% raise that moves
[1:12:48] the, that you move the table and then compensation also occurs, but that does, again, that doesn't
[1:12:54] mean that someone is going to receive that 8.5%. We need to do that because again, at the
[1:13:02] beginning of this conversation, we've taken great strides. We've done great things and
[1:13:08] We don't want to cause this issue to grow and hamper other departments abilities to continue forward with their workload.
[1:13:19] So right now we're looking at a three and a half percent adjustment.
[1:13:21] That total cost is about a million, three thousand dollars.
[1:13:33] After this budget, actually in conjunction with this budget,
[1:13:38] I'm not certain that ending at fiscal year 18 in the area of compensation is
[1:13:45] that end either. And so as we continue to work through these processes, and as we build
[1:13:51] a new compensation model, I would like to plant the seed now beginning to consider adopting
[1:13:57] a resolution that calls for minimum increases in compensation over a much longer period
[1:14:06] of time so that we can incorporate those into our long term planning. Now, there would be
[1:14:12] be some fallout measures because sometimes our crystal balls don't allow us to predict
[1:14:17] when the great recessions are going to occur and that we have to make decisions that cause
[1:14:22] us to veer off of our path. But I think by laying out a good foundation, just as we do
[1:14:28] in capital, just as we do in the acquisition of new talent to our organization, only makes
[1:14:34] sense as a retention tool for our existing employees, to the degrees in which we can.
[1:14:40] The point of clarification of the million three thousand dollars would be not new costs,
[1:14:47] but it would be total cost for all personnel within the city under the plan to be laid
[1:14:52] out.
[1:14:53] The million three would be an additional cost to be considered in conjunction with our
[1:15:01] conversations of the FY18 budget.
[1:15:04] What I didn't want to do tonight was to come with a solution that didn't completely spell
[1:15:10] out how are we going to avoid this in the future.
[1:15:13] So that's no cost.
[1:15:15] Yes.
[1:15:16] The action tonight is only about the mid-year adjustments and commissioning us to move forward.
[1:15:31] It's probably appropriate to jump to this slide.
[1:15:34] So as we look forward, we're conservatively estimating that we will collect anywhere between
[1:15:39] 888,000 and $1,140,000 in new property tax revenue just by following the statutory requirements.
[1:15:50] That's the what is allowed for us and that's based upon, you can see the largest indicator
[1:15:56] of there is determining what is that market value going to be.
[1:16:01] The 888,000 is a result of where we were at for fiscal year 18 for new construction.
[1:16:07] You can see that we grew to $67 million for fiscal year 2017, and that creates the $1.14
[1:16:16] million.
[1:16:17] What's important to remember when we look at the new construction number, when we receive
[1:16:22] it in June, it is typically about six months from old.
[1:16:33] So it starts the calendar year of the prior year.
[1:16:38] And so as you look at fiscal year 17, we received it in June of 16.
[1:16:44] That was for the construction season, that was 2015.
[1:16:48] So when we receive the new construction value for fiscal year 18, that will be for the construction
[1:16:54] value that's 2016.
[1:16:58] And when we look at building permits, it all depends upon when it falls onto the tax
[1:17:04] But we do believe, I believe, that we lean closer to the 1.14 million than we do the 888,000.
[1:17:17] But that doesn't also talk about the other sources of revenue that come into the city's accounts.
[1:17:25] So if you ever looked at Lori's budgeting spreadsheet, there are 300 plus individual revenue sources
[1:17:34] that we track on an annual basis to create a balanced budget.
[1:17:39] And you will remember that Lori and her financial presentation last week highlighted the largest,
[1:17:46] but the balance equals $6 million, and that's considerable money.
[1:17:50] When we take a look at the opportunities for additional investment income,
[1:17:55] we look at state-shared revenues, we look at building permits,
[1:17:58] we look at taking all available property taxes,
[1:18:01] It is easy to cover this liability.
[1:18:07] Then we could also reduce spending.
[1:18:10] There are areas, in fact, we're talking about different
[1:18:13] capital strategies where we create a capital budget A and a
[1:18:17] capital budget B that we'll be able to unveil to you that
[1:18:22] really kind of creates a pay-as-you-go system that allows
[1:18:26] us to maximize opportunities each fiscal year of the dollars
[1:18:31] and the resources that we have.
[1:18:33] And so as our budgeting gets much more sophisticated and our planning gets much more sophisticated,
[1:18:37] we have the ability hopefully to take the steps to create a sustainable course of action,
[1:18:44] not in single year increments, but in multiple year increments.
[1:18:49] Both Lori and Gretchen have reviewed this plan, and I just ask them to nod.
[1:18:54] They believe that this plan that we're proposing today is sustainable, is a sustainable path
[1:19:01] path for us to move forward. I thought this was a great quote. One way to
[1:19:12] attract and retain top employees and to keep them motivated is to determine what
[1:19:17] your competitors are paying and pay them as much or more. I stood at this podium
[1:19:26] at the beginning of this fiscal year and talked about the importance of building
[1:19:30] a multi-year compensation plan and being competitive. I think that this is just
[1:19:36] another iteration of that conversation.
[1:19:40] We've had this conversation, but I wanted to talk about the importance of what we're doing
[1:19:44] tonight.
[1:19:45] It really goes to retention, our ability to attract and retain individuals into our organization,
[1:19:51] our ability to create a quality work product and workforce, our ability to meet the needs
[1:19:57] of our citizens moving forward.
[1:20:00] And I will be the first to tell you that I don't believe that compensation, it's the magical
[1:20:04] So a lecture that's going to prevent all turnover from occurring.
[1:20:08] There will be reasons why people continue to leave.
[1:20:11] We might be the cause of why people leave.
[1:20:14] We may encourage individuals to no longer be a part of our organization based upon their actions.
[1:20:20] But we as an organization should never get to a place where compensation is the defining reason why they're leaving.
[1:20:30] And unfortunately I think that is the spot that we find ourselves today.
[1:20:37] Some of the more than compensation issues
[1:20:40] that I believe are important,
[1:20:41] that I believe are important by conversations
[1:20:44] I've had with the council are one,
[1:20:45] is our one city initiative.
[1:20:47] All of the work that we're doing in the areas
[1:20:50] of our structures, creating a new public safety building,
[1:20:53] creating a new police operation center,
[1:20:57] master planning some opportunities
[1:20:59] for the fire department.
[1:21:00] Chief Sol is going to be coming in
[1:21:02] and sharing his vision of the fire department
[1:21:05] in which we're going to be able to be
[1:21:06] having conversations about what the fire department looks like.
[1:21:09] Being able to make improvements to those structures
[1:21:12] and continuing to invest in our teammates
[1:21:15] are some of the things that we need to do
[1:21:17] to create quality organization and be the employer of choice.
[1:21:24] So tonight, I'm asking you to adopt
[1:21:28] the mid-year compensation adjustments
[1:21:30] at a price tag of $176,000 for this fiscal year,
[1:21:35] $1,000 for this fiscal year, recognizing that that is an ongoing financial commitment of the
[1:21:43] organization and that you commission the staff to begin the processes of building a new compensation
[1:21:51] model that can be introduced in time for the fiscal year 2018 budget.
[1:21:57] Thank you, Travis.
[1:22:02] Chris, talk.
[1:22:04] I don't have a question.
[1:22:05] I just want to make wrap up comments
[1:22:07] after you're done.
[1:22:09] You're done.
[1:22:10] This is big dollars, especially for the newer council
[1:22:13] that have joined us.
[1:22:15] And it's not often we have this magnitude of an issue
[1:22:20] presented before us, especially mid-budget year.
[1:22:25] I'd like to put it perspective for a couple things
[1:22:28] that I'm familiar with.
[1:22:30] When I was hired as the juvenile adjudication chief of the county, it was because of the
[1:22:37] high turnover we were losing probation officers, safety related staff and detention.
[1:22:44] I don't know what our turnover rate is, but any organization, and here we speak, the city
[1:22:50] of Twin Falls, it has a 64 and a half percent, five-year turnover rate is bordering on dysfunctional
[1:22:58] and not operative, discussing with Brian and Travis, they inform me that probably already
[1:23:06] not that when we hire a new uniform, it's one year of mentored work before that officer
[1:23:16] is able to have a car by themselves.
[1:23:18] I think that's roughly correct.
[1:23:20] Yeah, so we have two examples of two phenomenal young,
[1:23:27] talented individuals that we hired to join our team.
[1:23:32] And because of a series of circumstances,
[1:23:37] they were not able to get into post right away.
[1:23:40] Post is offering fewer classes than what they've offered historically,
[1:23:44] and so we have individuals who are enrolled
[1:23:47] at the College of Southern Idaho.
[1:23:50] I believe they'll be able to take their test in about May or June.
[1:23:55] Is that right? May?
[1:23:57] And then upon successful completion, they'll enter into a FTO program.
[1:24:03] And when you map that out on a calendar, it's about a year for those two individuals from the time in which they were employed,
[1:24:12] gainfully employed by the City of Twin Falls to the point in time in which they will be in right alone status in that police car.
[1:24:19] This just points to the investment we put into our officers and our firemen, 64% turnover
[1:24:28] is not perhaps going to be immediately reduced significantly, it's going to take time for people
[1:24:35] to realize the city is committed to keeping and retaining that effort of recruiting those
[1:24:42] highly qualified officers.
[1:24:44] I'd also like to point out that our police hiring stats are roughly about one and a half
[1:24:52] officers per thousand persons, I believe, in the community.
[1:24:57] And that's based on the community of around 45,000, if in fact, during some of the peak times
[1:25:04] and the weekends, our community goes up to 75,000 to 90,000, that officer ratio can drop
[1:25:12] almost in half.
[1:25:14] This is a significant safety issue.
[1:25:18] I am increasingly concerned that the combined resources of the county and the city, state
[1:25:25] police and others, are not keeping up with the war on drugs.
[1:25:30] I only threw unofficial sources.
[1:25:33] It is not an optimistic outlook we have.
[1:25:36] The least we can do is to keep our police in twin falls as long as possible to make them
[1:25:42] productive and protecting the citizenry. I have seldom encountered such a
[1:25:49] untastily bite to encounter mid-budget year but one more vital to protecting the
[1:25:57] safety of Twin Falls. I'm in favor of this. Thank you Chris. Greg Lanting. Thank you
[1:26:04] Travis for a great presentation. I believe you informed us with a lot of
[1:26:09] information that I think we were suspecting a lot of it, but we didn't have a verifiable
[1:26:15] data to show us where we're at.
[1:26:18] I'm really tired of training people for other agencies.
[1:26:22] That's what we're doing.
[1:26:23] We're training, even if we can find the best and brightest with our salary schedule.
[1:26:30] Once we train them up and spend a year and a half or two years making them a quality officer,
[1:26:36] and somebody else hires them away,
[1:26:38] we've just wasted all that training.
[1:26:40] We have to find the best of them brightest
[1:26:42] and we have to keep them
[1:26:43] because we don't want to be the Ferguson's
[1:26:45] and those other places of the world where
[1:26:48] I believe any experienced officers
[1:26:50] are what caused me some of those problems.
[1:26:52] And not as highly trained as they need to be.
[1:26:55] And so I hold heartily for this plan.
[1:27:00] I want to let the rest of the employees know the city
[1:27:02] that we're not forgetting about you.
[1:27:05] If we didn't do this, it isn't a changer.
[1:27:07] hour at all we're going to make sure to take care of you at the appropriate time
[1:27:11] at the end of the year because I know we're just there's going to be times we're
[1:27:15] going to have to do the same thing in the engineering department or someplace in
[1:27:17] public works we're going to have to make close a gap to make sure we're
[1:27:22] keeping our employees here and I would like to apologize to the city employees
[1:27:28] that I would been on the council for 11 years and that I allowed part of this
[1:27:32] to happen without my voting frugal budgets that didn't take into account the amount of
[1:27:38] money we needed to be spending and we may not have been in this situation had we not
[1:27:45] been stingy in the past and I'll put it that way so I apologize for that fact and moving
[1:27:52] forward I will be voting each and every time if you can bring me data like this I will
[1:27:58] I guarantee you, Travis, you will always have my vote for doing what we need to do to get our employees where we need them.
[1:28:05] Mr. Mayor, maybe two comments.
[1:28:06] So, I don't believe the Council should look at this as your responsibility.
[1:28:15] I am looking at you for the solution.
[1:28:20] I am not aware of a single time in which you have substantially amended or
[1:28:27] changed any one of my budgets.
[1:28:29] I'm going to be completely honest.
[1:28:32] We've had good conversation.
[1:28:33] We've had good vetting.
[1:28:36] We may not have always agreed on the exact path moving forward,
[1:28:39] but I do not recall a time in which you substantially
[1:28:43] changed any of the directions that, well, my name
[1:28:47] on that budget recommended.
[1:28:51] And I think that had we presented this information,
[1:28:55] had I been in tune with this process,
[1:28:59] and the issues to the degree in which they are,
[1:29:02] I believe you would have taken those appropriate steps.
[1:29:05] And so it's really me who has placed you
[1:29:07] into a fairly awkward position of having to do
[1:29:10] mid-year adjustments and advancing.
[1:29:13] And I had already apologized to Councilman Reed.
[1:29:18] He said, welcome aboard.
[1:29:20] I'm gonna have this really tough issue
[1:29:24] just a few weeks into your term.
[1:29:26] And I believe it is appropriate for the staff to take me in particular, to take responsibility
[1:29:34] for this and we can debate that after the meeting, but I want to go on the record to share that
[1:29:39] it is our job, it is our duty to provide you with the absolute best information to help you
[1:29:46] make a decision and in this regard I had failed you.
[1:29:50] Thank you, Travis.
[1:29:54] Chris Reed.
[1:29:55] So, again, thank you for all this information.
[1:29:57] I think this was very enlightening, kind of eye opening,
[1:30:02] but also going forward.
[1:30:03] So, something like this doesn't happen.
[1:30:05] When are these reports generated?
[1:30:07] How can we get this data from, I know the Treasure Valley's pushing this out,
[1:30:13] but I don't want this to happen on the other side and all of a sudden everybody's going
[1:30:17] to Idaho Falls or however this is going on.
[1:30:19] How do we get this information to make sure that we're competitive?
[1:30:24] I think that's a really fair question.
[1:30:27] One of the things that we're looking at is the data that
[1:30:30] has been coming in, I believe, has been entirely accurate,
[1:30:34] although it lacks.
[1:30:36] So the challenge that we have is we will receive all of the
[1:30:40] information of what all the cities did in the past budget
[1:30:44] about four or five months after that fact.
[1:30:48] And one of the steps, if you take a look in June,
[1:30:50] were reactive.
[1:30:52] I think what we need to do is we need to be able to build a plan that really begins to
[1:30:57] look at their data.
[1:30:58] So we know that several of the organizations that we looked at have guaranteed raises that
[1:31:04] have been plugged into the collective bargaining agreements.
[1:31:08] Those raises, for example, the city of Napa calls for a one and a quarter percent adjustment.
[1:31:14] I would be surprised if that adjustment were to change for fiscal year 18, but it is entirely
[1:31:19] possible.
[1:31:21] By doing a three and a half percent it allows us to continue to make up ground on those communities.
[1:31:27] And so what we need to do is make sure that we're doing the absolute level best research
[1:31:33] that we can on what our competition is doing.
[1:31:38] That's one.
[1:31:39] Number two, it has to be sustainable.
[1:31:42] So we have to be able to build a plan that allows us to continue to advance forward.
[1:31:47] And it's going to be a balance between going toe to toe with our competition and being able
[1:31:52] to develop a plan that is financially viable in the outgoing years because if you build
[1:32:00] a step in great system, you are building a system that is going to increase your liability
[1:32:05] as individuals gain experience and they gain tenure.
[1:32:10] So it is that balancing act and we want to make sure that all of those factors are taken
[1:32:16] into place. Finally, I think we would encourage the council as we continue to look forward
[1:32:24] to consider looking at multi-year processes and paths when it comes to the area of compensation
[1:32:37] and creating no less statements. We will do no less than blank which will help us to continue
[1:32:44] to make up that ground over a defined window of time.
[1:32:50] Susanne Hawkins.
[1:32:51] Thank you.
[1:32:54] Travis, I know that health care costs and everything
[1:32:57] have been increasing greatly as well.
[1:32:59] How do we compare to like market and what we're offering
[1:33:04] for health care and benefits that way?
[1:33:06] Can you just real quick touch that or?
[1:33:08] So I'm going to look at Gretchen and she's either
[1:33:11] going to stand up and walk up and say you didn't get it right.
[1:33:14] or she already started to walk in on it.
[1:33:19] So when it comes to health care the last time,
[1:33:21] so we look at compensation as a full package.
[1:33:26] And we look at what we do for dependent care.
[1:33:29] We look at what our competition does for dependent care.
[1:33:31] We look at the price of our deductibles
[1:33:34] and the copays and the prescription meds.
[1:33:36] And we put all that into a calculation.
[1:33:39] We know that we're not the best.
[1:33:42] We also know that we're not the worst.
[1:33:44] I would describe our plan as something in the middle.
[1:33:48] I think that it is reasonably competitive.
[1:33:52] My concern is if what we have is sustainable.
[1:34:00] Last year we experienced a 15% adjustment.
[1:34:04] I believe that we could be experiencing potentially
[1:34:09] other adjustments of a similar nature in future years.
[1:34:14] And it really has to do with our experience level.
[1:34:17] The amount of claims that we place onto our organization,
[1:34:20] and that's why we're having a significant focus
[1:34:24] on the topic of wellness.
[1:34:26] Well, we don't believe any wellness program
[1:34:29] will allow us to reduce the cost of health insurance.
[1:34:33] We believe that it will help us to starve off
[1:34:36] some of the increases in adjustments,
[1:34:39] meaning that we've seen over time.
[1:34:42] Our wellness program has not quite matured yet, and we hope to bring that to the Council
[1:34:52] yet this fiscal year.
[1:34:55] The Council has appropriated funds to advance wellness inside of our organization, will pitch
[1:35:01] that proposal, and then have that also be an ongoing conversation.
[1:35:04] But, Travis, I want to take the opportunity to thank you and Gretchen and Laurie and all
[1:35:10] the others on your team for working through this, I don't want to say it was an absolute
[1:35:17] surprise because I know that we've dealt with challenges of compensation over the past few
[1:35:23] years, but this was a pretty acute problem that needed to be addressed and I commend you
[1:35:29] all for bringing it to us.
[1:35:31] To me I think it really affirms not only a commitment to law enforcement and firefighters
[1:35:38] in this particular state but I think again addresses the overall employee base of the
[1:35:45] city and I know the last couple of years in particular working through the budget we've
[1:35:49] really tried to focus on compensation and being fair and ensuring that we have quality
[1:35:57] employees and I like your strategy of figuring out a way to look ahead beyond just budget
[1:36:05] year by budget year. So I'll look forward to hearing back about that as we
[1:36:09] enter into the new budget. But again, this is a significant amount of money,
[1:36:15] but to me it's an investment, not an expense. So I look forward to being able
[1:36:20] to vote in favor of it. Chris talking. One more clarification then with the
[1:36:26] budget year approximately a third done.
[1:36:29] We have enough money, it's 176 or 166,000,
[1:36:34] and money that we have not been able to fully hire departments
[1:36:39] out that we would use for some portion of this mid-year adjustment.
[1:36:44] Yeah, we believe over the course of the year,
[1:36:47] we believe that we will have all the resources,
[1:36:51] plus additional resources to be able to offset all these costs,
[1:36:55] And I think that we are based on that being not only on the financial information that
[1:37:00] Laurie had presented to you, but also really Laurie and her team have reflected backward
[1:37:07] of how history has played and how we've operated as an organization and how we've added money
[1:37:14] into cash reserves at the conclusion of each fiscal year.
[1:37:17] And so we believe that this plan is financially sound.
[1:37:23] And with that, I'd move to authorize mid-year compensation adjustments to sworn police officers and firefighters effective February 5th, 2017, and the program outlined by the City Manager.
[1:37:38] Second.
[1:37:39] Motion by Chris Dockington, seconded by Greg Lanting, just barely since.
[1:37:43] I'm sitting closer.
[1:37:45] I have a scratchy throat.
[1:37:47] Okay.
[1:37:48] Sorry.
[1:37:49] And would you like that to include direct and staff
[1:37:51] to develop the new compensation model?
[1:37:53] That would be good, but our firefighters actually
[1:37:56] are paid monthly, and so we need their part
[1:37:59] to be effective February 1.
[1:38:03] I'd stand.
[1:38:04] The second is fine with that.
[1:38:07] All right, so motion by Chris talking
[1:38:09] and seconded by Greg Lansing to approve
[1:38:11] the requested mid-year compensation adjustments
[1:38:16] as presented by the city manager.
[1:38:18] Is there any further discussion from the council?
[1:38:23] I'm sure you'll go vote, please.
[1:38:25] Sean Berriger.
[1:38:26] Yes.
[1:38:27] Chris Hockington.
[1:38:28] Yes.
[1:38:29] Reg Lanting.
[1:38:30] Yes.
[1:38:31] Christopher Reed.
[1:38:32] Yes.
[1:38:33] Ruth Pierce.
[1:38:34] Yes.
[1:38:35] Suzanne Hawkins.
[1:38:36] Yes.
[1:38:37] Nicki Boy.
[1:38:39] Yes.
[1:38:40] Motion passes.
[1:38:42] Seven to zero.
[1:38:43] Thank you, Travis.
[1:38:46] And next on the agenda is another opportunity for public input.
[1:38:49] If there is anyone here wishing to address the Council on any issues as your chance.
[1:38:58] No one items from the city manager, Mr. Rothwiler.
[1:39:02] Just a quick reminder next week, we're going to meet early.
[1:39:05] We're going to be meeting at 3.30 here, and then we will begin to take a series of tours.
[1:39:11] We're going to meet and go through the current construction phase of the public safety building.
[1:39:19] We'll walk over and you can see the work that is being done at City Hall, and then we will
[1:39:24] come back for our regular scheduled meeting at that meeting.
[1:39:27] We'll be providing a complete update on all of those projects and activities.
[1:39:33] Where your closed toed shoes, places not all your falls to work.
[1:39:42] Anything from members of council.
[1:39:47] All right, seeing none with that, meeting is adjourned.
