Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2016-03-28, recording 1 (started 17:00)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2016-03-28/

[0:00:00] the Pledge of Allegiance. For those of you who wish me to join us, please rise.
[0:00:03] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
[0:00:19] I would confirm we do have a quorum of the City Council. All seven members are here this evening.
[0:00:29] Deputy City Manager Mitchell Humboldt, do we have any amendments to the agenda?
[0:00:34] We do not have any amendments for you tonight.
[0:00:38] We do have one proclamation, which I will read now, for Fair Housing Month.
[0:00:44] Whereas April 2016 marks the 48th anniversary of the passage of Title VIII of the Civil Rights
[0:00:50] Act of 1968, commonly known as the Federal Fair Housing Act, and whereas the Idaho Human
[0:00:56] Rights Commission Act has prohibited discrimination in housing since 1969, and whereas equal
[0:01:02] opportunity for all regardless of race, color, religion, sex, disability, familial status,
[0:01:09] or national origin is a fundamental goal of our nation, state, and city. And whereas equal
[0:01:15] access to housing is an important component of this goal, as fundamental as the right
[0:01:20] to equal education and employment, and whereas housing is a critical component of family and
[0:01:25] community health and stability, and whereas housing choice impacts our children's access
[0:01:31] to education, our ability to seek and retain employment options, the cultural benefits we
[0:01:36] enjoy, the extent of our exposure to crime and drugs, and the quality of health care we
[0:01:41] receive in emergencies.
[0:01:43] And whereas the laws of this nation and our state seek to ensure such equality of choice
[0:01:48] for all transactions involving housing, and whereas ongoing education, outreach, and monitoring
[0:01:54] are key to raising awareness of fair housing principles, practices, rights, and responsibilities,
[0:02:00] And whereas only through continued cooperation, commitment, and support of all Idahoans can
[0:02:05] barriers to fair housing be removed.
[0:02:08] Now therefore, I, Sean Berriger, Mayor of the City of Twin Falls, do hereby proclaim April
[0:02:13] 2016 to be Fair Housing Month in the City of Twin Falls, State of Idaho.
[0:02:19] And Mandy Thompson is listed for receiving this, but Mitch, would you like it?
[0:02:23] I don't see Mandy here.
[0:02:41] Next on the agenda is general public input.
[0:02:44] Is there anyone here from the public who would like to address the council on an issue that
[0:02:48] is not listed on tonight's agenda?
[0:02:53] Seeing no one scurrying forward, we'll move to the first item as the consent calendar.
[0:03:00] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:03:01] I move approval of the consent calendar as printed.
[0:03:04] Second.
[0:03:05] Motion by Suzanne Hawkins, seconded by Ruth Pierce to approve the consent calendar as printed.
[0:03:12] Is there any discussion?
[0:03:15] Seeing none, Sharon roll call vote please.
[0:03:17] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:03:18] Yes.
[0:03:19] Nikki Boyd.
[0:03:20] Yes.
[0:03:21] Sean Beriker.
[0:03:22] Yes.
[0:03:23] Chris Hockington.
[0:03:24] Yes.
[0:03:24] Greg Lanting.
[0:03:25] Yes.
[0:03:25] Don Hall.
[0:03:26] Yes.
[0:03:27] Ruth Pierce.
[0:03:28] Yes.
[0:03:29] Motion passes 7 to 0.
[0:03:32] Under items for consideration, the first
[0:03:34] is a presentation to recognize recently promoted firefighters
[0:03:37] Sean Burgess and Brian Rice to the rank of driver operator
[0:03:42] and to promote driver operator Tom Bloxham to the rank
[0:03:45] of Captain and we have Fire Chief Ron Clark.
[0:03:49] Welcome Chief.
[0:03:51] Thank you.
[0:03:53] Good evening Mayor and Council.
[0:03:55] Thank you for taking this opportunity
[0:03:56] to recognize some of our finest firefighters, Sean Burgess.
[0:04:00] And Brian Rice, we're recently promoted
[0:04:03] to driver operators in our department.
[0:04:05] We'd like to congratulate Sean and Brian
[0:04:08] on their accomplishment and wish them all the best
[0:04:10] in their new position.
[0:04:12] And we'd appreciate it if Mayor Barrieger would present
[0:04:15] the newly promoted Sean and Brian, their helmets.
[0:04:22] We thought we'd get these two together
[0:04:23] and then we have one other one.
[0:04:26] There you go, right up there.
[0:04:28] Where are we?
[0:04:29] That's not going to happen.
[0:04:31] Yay.
[0:04:34] I hope so.
[0:04:35] I hope so.
[0:04:35] You know what I'm talking about.
[0:05:07] You would also appreciate it if you'd help us recognize
[0:05:19] driver operator Tom Bloxham,
[0:05:21] who was recently promoted to the rank of captain.
[0:05:24] We'd like to congratulate Tom on his accomplishment,
[0:05:27] and we wish him all the best in his new position.
[0:05:30] And we would also ask that the mayor present his red helmet.
[0:06:07] Chief, we would expect an immediate 10% reduction
[0:06:10] in all fires with the advancement of these three fine gentlemen.
[0:06:15] That is part of our strategic plan.
[0:06:18] Thank you very much for taking the time to recognize our firemen.
[0:06:23] Thank you, Chief, and congratulations, gentlemen.
[0:06:29] And if you all want to sneak out, now you're more than welcome to.
[0:06:31] Yeah.
[0:06:32] We could mandate them to stay, I guess.
[0:06:46] The next item on the agenda is consideration of a request to award the contract for the
[0:06:51] 2016 Eastland Drive South Project to PMF Incorporated of Twin Falls, Idaho.
[0:06:57] And we have Deputy City Engineer, Troy B. Tech.
[0:07:00] Welcome, Troy.
[0:07:01] Thank you, Council.
[0:07:04] I am reading before you a request to award a contract to PMF construction for the Eastland
[0:07:11] Drive South project.
[0:07:12] So, over the past few years we have so deep been advancing that project as we started at
[0:07:18] the South end because it was the most deteriorated at the corner of Orchard in Eastland.
[0:07:23] We've been progressing northward, but there's been some concern about the corner of Rye
[0:07:29] and Eastland and there's some business owners that are really impacted by that and how deteriorated
[0:07:35] it is. So right now we're leapfrogging. Now we're going to go up to Kimberly Road and start working
[0:07:40] south and eventually we'll film the part in the middle. So we put out a bid. There was two bidders,
[0:07:45] Knife River and PMF. They're both good bids really tight together for the bid tab. You can see there
[0:07:52] and PMF was a low bidder. All their documentation was in line. They have their bid bond when we
[0:07:59] We enter into an agreement with them.
[0:08:01] We'll get their construction bond and everything else.
[0:08:06] The bid is currently at $736,735 for them.
[0:08:14] Previously I came before the council and asked for a little more money to the tune of $1.292
[0:08:21] million.
[0:08:22] That also includes services during construction.
[0:08:25] our guys to be on site engineering, a little bit of contingency, but our real goal here
[0:08:30] is to continue that project and with that fun that you previously allowed for, we would
[0:08:36] like to extend the job beyond the 736,000 that is listed in the bid and continue south
[0:08:42] for as much as we could actually afford.
[0:08:44] We'll work with the contractor and changer order it in appropriately, but tonight I'm
[0:08:49] come up before you to actually just ask for an award to PMF construction for the for the
[0:08:56] project on East Lintreis. Do you have any questions? Chris talking. Troy explain a
[0:09:01] little bit now that additional 452.4 thousand debt from reserves or where does that come
[0:09:08] from and I'm curious how you came up with this bid because the inferences that you'll just
[0:09:14] give PMF the go ahead to continue a paving or whatever it is until they say that's all the money that the bid.
[0:09:23] And it's not a project specific meets and bounds then.
[0:09:28] The plans were said, so we designed the whole project and what they bid was a specific area.
[0:09:34] So if they increased their paving a little bit, we have associated dollars with that.
[0:09:41] So it's very easy for us to say, we'll pay an extra so many dollars per foot that you add on,
[0:09:46] and we can continue to add that until all those monies are expended.
[0:09:51] And where did that extra 452K come from?
[0:09:54] This, so the original engineers estimate was based on two years ago,
[0:09:59] when we actually bid the project, and we figured the prices would increase,
[0:10:05] as they always have in the past, they actually stayed the same and there was no increase.
[0:10:10] So there was some savings realized there for the most part.
[0:10:13] And then there's also contingency and other costs in there.
[0:10:17] But we estimate another $340,000 that
[0:10:21] can be used towards this roadway that we would like to continue
[0:10:24] to go southward with it.
[0:10:27] But the dollars are from street reserves.
[0:10:29] It is from street reserves, that is correct.
[0:10:33] Any other questions for Troy?
[0:10:36] Chris talking to you.
[0:10:37] Well, I'll move that in approval a little bit to PMF
[0:10:40] the amount of a million to 92 for 416 motion by Kristokington seconded by Nikki
[0:10:48] Boyd to award the contract as presented Greg Lanting. I'm just happy not often that
[0:10:56] I get on the East and South but I have to be on their Sunday and I can see their
[0:11:01] concerns it's it really is deteriorating quite a bit the winners been tough on it
[0:11:06] I'm sure they're going to be very glad to get this reded for them.
[0:11:10] Any other comments from Council? Seeing none, Sharon?
[0:11:16] Roll call vote, please.
[0:11:22] Nikki Boyd? Yes.
[0:11:24] Sean Beriker? Yes.
[0:11:25] Chris Hockington? Yes.
[0:11:27] Greg Lamting? Yes.
[0:11:28] Don Hall? Yes.
[0:11:29] Ruth Pierce? Yes.
[0:11:31] Suzanne Hocken? Yes.
[0:11:33] Motion passes 7-0.
[0:11:35] Thank you, Troy.
[0:11:37] Next, we have consideration of a request to adopt the latitude 42C1
[0:11:42] PUD agreement between the City of Twin Falls and James and Anna McCormick, Gary Nelson,
[0:11:48] Blass Inc., Gary Sleddy, Gerald Martins, Evan Robertson, Dirk Gibson, Daniel Conan, Stephen
[0:11:55] George and Kirby Dahl in care of Gerald Martins EHM engineers. We have Renee Caribouy Johnson.
[0:12:02] Yes, good afternoon. Thank you. Tonight, I am presenting to you a planned unit development
[0:12:10] agreement that has been in the process for several years, and what a PUD is is a zoning
[0:12:19] action on a piece of property. In this case, this property is located. Let me show you.
[0:12:50] This PUD consists of this property right here. It's approximately 29 acres. This is Pole
[0:12:56] Line Road West, Twin Falls Reform Church.
[0:13:00] This is a W.S. and B.P.U.D. agreement, and this is a residential subdivision called Field
[0:13:05] Stone.
[0:13:06] This property actually came through the process for zoning action back in 2005.
[0:13:12] The property was originally annexed and zoned under the R2 designation, and in 2009, the property
[0:13:20] was rezoned to a straight C1, which was in compliance with the comprehensive plan.
[0:13:27] And then in January 2011, there was a request to actually zone it under a planned unit development,
[0:13:38] and a planned unit development means that the entire parcel needs to be planned out with
[0:13:43] what the intent is for development on the site.
[0:13:47] This is the master development plan as presented.
[0:13:51] Again, the property, this is basically in a plat format, so they're showing subdivision
[0:13:58] of this property into different lots under commercial development.
[0:14:03] In your packets, you have the planned unit development agreement that was approved through the zoning
[0:14:10] action process under review with the engineer that processed this application and these clients.
[0:14:19] We feel that PUD agreement accurately reflects the PUD as approved.
[0:14:24] There were conditions that were approved by the Council in January.
[0:14:28] They're in your packet.
[0:14:29] There were four conditions.
[0:14:31] One is subject to site plan review, engineering building, and zoning compliance.
[0:14:39] Number two was subject to arterial and collector streets adjacent within the property being brought
[0:14:43] up to code.
[0:14:44] Those are both relatively standard conditions placed on development of property.
[0:14:50] Number three was subject to complete, to complete the design approval of Chaney Drive West being
[0:14:56] constructed to half width and per city standards.
[0:14:59] As of today, there is an agreement with all of the parties, but Washington Street is over
[0:15:11] here.
[0:15:12] Chaney Drive is down here, and there's an agreement right now in development underway
[0:15:18] to bring Chaney from Washington, clear over to Creekside Way.
[0:15:23] So that this.
[0:15:25] From Grandview.
[0:15:27] Oh, Grandview, sorry.
[0:15:29] You know.
[0:15:30] You know.
[0:15:31] You know.
[0:15:32] You know.
[0:15:33] It's only a mile.
[0:15:34] Over here.
[0:15:35] Sorry.
[0:15:36] Clear over to creek side way.
[0:15:37] So that is a process that's under development right now in order to encourage this property to
[0:15:43] be developed and is part of the agreement.
[0:15:46] So number three we feel is not completed but in compliance.
[0:15:51] And number four is subject to an approved and recorded PUD agreement to include a master development plan prior to approval and
[0:15:58] recordation of a final plan.
[0:16:01] So the PUD again reflects as the zoning action came through.
[0:16:06] We are asking for your approval of that agreement this evening so that the property may be developed as agreed upon.
[0:16:13] And I would just like to clarify for you tonight there was an item on the consent calendar that was a final
[0:16:21] of this property that is bringing this through.
[0:16:33] Yes, just one phase in it.
[0:16:41] This is a phase one of a final plot of this property,
[0:16:45] and this is the lot that's coming through
[0:16:48] and asking for final approval
[0:16:50] so that they can develop that lot,
[0:16:53] which occurred on the consent calendar.
[0:16:56] The rest of this property will need to come through
[0:16:59] planning and will be developed in other phases.
[0:17:02] So, do you have any questions for me?
[0:17:08] Chris talking to me.
[0:17:09] Renee, the only concern I have in work were dealing with existing zoning, but putting a
[0:17:15] C1 next to the R2 in the southeast corner does not always end for good land use planning.
[0:17:25] That will be conditions put upon the C1 as the partner coming in after the established R2 is always there to protect the viability of the R1 in that corner, R2 in that corner.
[0:17:40] You're talking about this property? No.
[0:17:42] You're talking about this property? No.
[0:17:44] The R2 as on the map. Right here.
[0:17:47] the field stone subdivision.
[0:17:51] Actually this is not a true reflection at this time.
[0:17:53] This property was rezoned to a professional office overlay
[0:17:58] and there will be professional offices
[0:18:00] along that corridor that just, this is a little bit
[0:18:03] over the map.
[0:18:04] So there was consideration of that at the time.
[0:18:11] I was, I was gonna ask, great landing.
[0:18:16] Do we know what's going into that corner, Gerald?
[0:18:18] I'm asking Gerald, or Renee, if you know,
[0:18:20] you can tell me. I was like you Gerald up here just to. Yeah,
[0:18:26] why is law not waste? He's time for being here.
[0:18:30] Jail for the record will you introduce yourself?
[0:18:31] Yes, for the record. My name is Gerald Martin. So one of the
[0:18:35] engineer and one of the owners of the property in that corner is
[0:18:39] an extended nursing care facility, a high level nursing facility of
[0:18:46] about 30,000 square feet and it is ready once the plant is recorded the
[0:18:54] plans are ready for cement for construction in this year the roadway
[0:18:59] and all of the utilities are currently under construction in the street to
[0:19:03] front set property.
[0:19:05] Sleddy just came in can we find a question we're going to do.
[0:19:09] Renee perhaps you can clarify for me so in this in the PUD there are some
[0:19:17] of separations of different uses within the PUD, correct,
[0:19:21] but at this 150 foot line.
[0:19:22] There is a 150 foot border for land uses.
[0:19:27] And that's from the southern border?
[0:19:29] Yes.
[0:19:29] So, yeah, from south up 150 feet,
[0:19:33] there's a limited types of uses.
[0:19:36] Again, being aware of the R6 property to the zone.
[0:19:41] So providing some transition to the more commercial use.
[0:19:45] Correct.
[0:19:46] Thank you.
[0:19:46] I am.
[0:19:48] I would move approval of the request to adopt the latter 242C1PUD agreement between the City
[0:19:57] of Twin Falls and James and Anna McCormick, Gary Nelson, Blas Inc., Gary Sledy, Gerald
[0:20:03] Martins, Evan Robertson, Dirk Gibson, Daniel Conan, Stephen George, Kirby Doll, C.O., Gerald
[0:20:13] Martin's EHM Engineers, Inc. with the four conditions listed.
[0:20:17] Second.
[0:20:19] Motion by Don Hall, seconded by Greg Lanting to approve the request with the attached conditions.
[0:20:25] Is there any discussion from the Council on it?
[0:20:29] Seeing none.
[0:20:30] Sharing roll call vote please.
[0:20:34] Sean Bericher?
[0:20:35] Yes.
[0:20:36] Chris Hockington?
[0:20:37] Yes.
[0:20:38] Greg Lanting?
[0:20:39] Yes.
[0:20:40] Don Hall?
[0:20:41] Yes.
[0:20:42] Yes, Nikki boy. Yes motion passes 7 to 0. Thank you
[0:20:57] There's a couple out there
[0:20:59] The next item on the agenda is discussion on direction for options on the PSI contract and we have bill Baxter
[0:21:07] from our, my name's Mr. Parr,
[0:21:10] and City Council.
[0:21:12] It is a pleasure to come before you again,
[0:21:15] try to review with you the parameters
[0:21:18] that we should be considering as we look at this PSI contract.
[0:21:23] I thought in the process,
[0:21:26] I would just go back and quickly review the comments
[0:21:28] we have heard on May 2014,
[0:21:33] or 2015, September 14 meeting,
[0:21:36] as we move toward negotiations with BSI.
[0:21:41] First of all, to expand the opportunity for the 35-gallon
[0:21:46] limited service trash cans has always been a priority item
[0:21:51] we've heard from Council.
[0:21:52] To push the recycling increases and lower the pricing
[0:21:55] of those carts over the garbage carts, again,
[0:21:57] as an incentive is one of the other things we've heard.
[0:22:02] Commercial and multi-unit recycling options.
[0:22:06] Commercial locations choose their own provider, which is not always PSI, but we have those numbers if people call the utility service's office.
[0:22:15] We are happy to share that information with them.
[0:22:18] Expanded options to deal with yard waste volumes, and what scenarios may be available for
[0:22:24] developing for that type of disposal are of interest, cost of recycling, and
[0:22:30] reprocessing this waste is anticipated to be no less than that of throwing it away.
[0:22:34] an investment in a facility would be substantial, but I understand that Southern Idaho Solid
[0:22:39] Waste is looking at a process that may work going forward. Recycling at City Parks is currently
[0:22:47] in the testing stage, but is a part of any contract we consider managing the hours of
[0:22:53] collection for commercial trash next to residential areas. This is an issue that came up because
[0:22:58] of some residential customers concerned with the noise early in the morning, PSI works to
[0:23:04] make sure that while they're maintaining their safety margins, they try to reschedule those
[0:23:10] visits to commercial properties as they can.
[0:23:14] Overall citizen educational materials and PSAs, etc. in partnership with the city as part of
[0:23:20] the contract.
[0:23:21] Again, pushing the recycling to increase that volume, move it away from the landfill as well
[0:23:29] as to correct any issues that are with trash collection.
[0:23:34] Options that have entered the discussions on service as we've proceeded to have these conversations,
[0:23:40] some of the parameters we understood Council to be concerned with let us down a road where
[0:23:46] we started to look at things like extra volume charges.
[0:23:52] This would be intended to push the idea of recycling through the economic incentive and
[0:23:56] to facilitate expansion, if we can, of the 35 and or 65 gallon cart size to lower trash
[0:24:04] where it's going to the landfill.
[0:24:07] Addressing the landfill charges, which is currently out of our effective control, as has been a
[0:24:12] discussion item, in reducing the Twin Falls volume through our recycling, becomes a fixed
[0:24:20] cost consideration of the southwest, or the southern Idaho solid waste operation, and
[0:24:27] every time we move to less tonnage, the rate seems to go up again addressing that fixed cost.
[0:24:34] One possible option for that would be for PSI in this contract to take on that fee, but
[0:24:41] it involves other factors that we'd have to consider.
[0:24:47] A paper volume type of management of trash collection
[0:24:50] so it counts with more trash to be collected
[0:24:52] above an estimated allowance.
[0:24:55] One can, three to five bags, something like that.
[0:24:58] Could be instigated to help control the volume of trash.
[0:25:02] But again, that moves away from
[0:25:05] cities unlimited trash process that we currently use.
[0:25:11] A warning notice for improper use of the recycling.
[0:25:14] We do have customers that don't understand
[0:25:17] with that recycled card is for.
[0:25:19] I visited with a lady in the last three weeks
[0:25:21] who was putting out her trash
[0:25:23] and she had called the complaint and she called PSI,
[0:25:26] and she didn't understand that the orange lid is recycled.
[0:25:31] The blue is the garbage.
[0:25:33] So the PSI truck was driving by
[0:25:36] because it was a recycled card out on the curb.
[0:25:40] So we do face these kinds of issues.
[0:25:44] A review of the parameters and cost considerations.
[0:25:47] One of the things under our current pricing is that we have a fixed cost of about $147,000
[0:25:54] a month for the service provided to the city.
[0:25:57] We have 69 one can customers and that item will be addressed later in this presentation.
[0:26:07] And if we are to expand the number of 35 gallon carts, move away from the 95, we still have
[0:26:14] to cover that $147,000.
[0:26:17] So as you increase a 35 gallon cart rate, the price of those will rise as the customers using the 95 gallon can
[0:26:24] props just in order to match that fixed cost we have each month.
[0:26:29] Oh, we have a comment from Ruth Pierce.
[0:26:31] Yes.
[0:26:31] I just have a question.
[0:26:32] The newly guarded person.
[0:26:34] Please.
[0:26:35] Okay.
[0:26:35] So I have the normal blue normal 95.
[0:26:39] Is that a 95?
[0:26:40] Yes.
[0:26:41] And then the 35 is that smaller than one.
[0:26:43] The smaller than one.
[0:26:44] And then you mentioned 65 with statutes.
[0:26:47] That is an option that PSI can present if we should want to move that away.
[0:26:52] So somewhere in between.
[0:26:53] Right.
[0:26:54] Thank you.
[0:26:55] Thank you for the question.
[0:26:58] And so if we were to look at the extreme of this, we have 14,412 account customers who have sanitation service with us.
[0:27:08] If everybody went to a 35-gallon cart, you'd be paying about the 1022 to 1019 that the 95-gallon customers currently pay.
[0:27:17] And it removes, we'd have to address the recycled issue because that one can rate.
[0:27:25] Currently, you fill up the 35-gallon cart, that's all you get, no extra bags, no recycled cart.
[0:27:31] That's just all there is.
[0:27:33] Again, I would mention we have discussed the potential elimination of the unlimited garbage.
[0:27:44] And in order to give you a concept of what that looks like in the city, some of the concerns
[0:27:52] PSI wrestles with.
[0:27:53] I'll show you that piece.
[0:27:58] I brought a few photographs courtesy of Les Reed's of PSI and Sean Stanley.
[0:28:06] This first one is simply an issue that comes up with the 35-gallon carts.
[0:28:13] You have to be able to maybe not close the lid, but it's got to get in the truck.
[0:28:18] And so the reason we have requirements for bundles of sticks and bushes and limbs is so
[0:28:26] the driver doesn't have to figure out how he's going to load that.
[0:28:29] Usually they will tag the bucket and say you'll have to cut this down and get it in the
[0:28:36] a cart or a garbage can. We would take a 35-gallon can that the driver could then empty
[0:28:41] into the cart, but you'd have to saw those off. And so then we'd just get into what a limited
[0:28:46] looks like. And then if you don't mind just kind of flashing through those. It's amazing
[0:28:53] to me. I'm the four or five extra bags of grass on a really big lawn day to see what people
[0:29:03] think PSI will pick up and this is unlimited.
[0:29:08] This is what the driver will be dealing with.
[0:29:12] Sometimes it takes an extra truck and an extra driver or
[0:29:15] two to come out just to handle it all.
[0:29:19] But I will, well, Mitch Flashes, oh, this is one of our
[0:29:22] favorites.
[0:29:23] We don't know where this guy got those, how he fit him in
[0:29:26] his house.
[0:29:28] But PSI got a call one day, eight or nine churches.
[0:29:32] I'm confused.
[0:29:33] Church views.
[0:29:34] Church views.
[0:29:35] And it, the piece I didn't show you is that cost us $31.24 at the transfer station, just
[0:29:45] because of the weight.
[0:29:48] So we would love some clarification on how far you want them limited to go, because right
[0:29:54] now the contract just says unlimited, no parameters, which meets the purpose of keeping the community
[0:30:01] clean, but it does sort of shift the burden to the citizens to cover the cost for some of this.
[0:30:10] Don Hall.
[0:30:11] I guess I never envisioned church pews as part of unlimited or large bundles of mattresses.
[0:30:19] We do have a large item pick up which falls under that and it's just a different schedule.
[0:30:26] What I generally do when I get to that kind of the stage, I take it to the transfer station
[0:30:31] myself because I would never burp the driver with that so is this a single
[0:30:36] residence yes it was a cleanup there's like five there's five bins there though
[0:30:44] so that's what extra bins five a bank repel you know a little hoarding sent
[0:30:51] somebody into cleanup this is spring cleaning I'm just sweating make sure
[0:30:58] and one of these isn't like that.
[0:31:00] We checked.
[0:31:02] The blue cart is actually behind that pile of bags.
[0:31:04] I was the first thing I said is, where's the blue cart?
[0:31:08] Because the driver depends on that, on the side load drug.
[0:31:12] This was interesting.
[0:31:13] This actually ended up being somebody whose roommate
[0:31:16] had moved him out.
[0:31:20] It was perfect.
[0:31:21] It looks like this, but the next day, last night, yeah.
[0:31:24] And it had been tarfed and taped.
[0:31:27] That's the other side of it.
[0:31:29] But yeah, the couch, everything all stacked up.
[0:31:31] So are we picking those up now?
[0:31:34] That kind of a load?
[0:31:35] Yeah.
[0:31:36] It's what you got to follow on now.
[0:31:38] If the couch and the construction materials weren't
[0:31:41] such a big part of that, that probably
[0:31:43] would have been unlimited.
[0:31:46] I've never envisioned this as being unlimited.
[0:31:48] So maybe we need some clarification.
[0:31:51] If we're going to continue with unlimited,
[0:31:53] Maybe we need a different clarification.
[0:31:56] Yeah, parameters.
[0:31:57] And maybe it shouldn't say unlimited.
[0:31:58] I like the idea of the conceptually unlimited
[0:32:02] in the sense that folks need to be able to clean up
[0:32:05] when they need to clean up.
[0:32:06] We want to keep our neighborhoods clean.
[0:32:07] But I never envisioned that.
[0:32:11] We have a couple of other comments up here at Greg
[0:32:13] Leenten.
[0:32:14] Once we actually turned our light on and waited until exactly.
[0:32:18] Mine was already on.
[0:32:19] I was looking for it.
[0:32:21] I never said I was done.
[0:32:25] I actually live in a condo that has a separate PSI contract, not through the city because condos are allowed to do that.
[0:32:34] Units, and we actually operate already in our agreement with PSI that whatever we have has to be in the can.
[0:32:42] We can't just pile crap along the cans and that kind of actually got in trouble for that to the day because there were some.
[0:32:49] So I can see along with Don, I mean, if I can be, I could be see a point where you unlimited doesn't make it.
[0:32:59] I owned a home in Queen Valley, Arizona, and again had a private contract and the city didn't provide the service.
[0:33:06] And it had to be in the can with the lid closed, shut.
[0:33:10] Or they didn't, they wouldn't pick it up. If it was all inside the can, they just picked the can up and went on.
[0:33:16] Most places do deal with that.
[0:33:20] I also understand the spring cleanup, the lawn,
[0:33:23] clippings, several things that are a little tough
[0:33:26] to get inside at different times,
[0:33:28] and so I'm trying to find that happy medium,
[0:33:31] but I don't think that we need to say that is acceptable
[0:33:35] without having an additional charge,
[0:33:37] and I don't know how we structure that
[0:33:41] so that that person is paying that additional charge
[0:33:45] without them just taking it over and dumping it in an empty water.
[0:33:48] I don't want to see that either, so you kind of think,
[0:33:51] but I think we do need to put some sort of limit on it,
[0:33:54] on the actual volume and bring our costs down that way.
[0:33:57] And so then maybe we can look at some of these other cost savings
[0:34:05] to allow, let's say, senior citizens with a senior can
[0:34:09] or something like that.
[0:34:09] And then like Chris has convinced me it's somewhere along the line
[0:34:14] and that those smaller cans have been subsidizing everybody else to a certain degree, a little
[0:34:20] bit.
[0:34:21] Yeah.
[0:34:22] So I agree with we need to work on something long as well.
[0:34:27] I hope you have a grand plan ready for us to look at.
[0:34:31] Well, we're working on this as part of the conversation, and I'll just state this real
[0:34:36] quickly.
[0:34:37] has grown to the point where we at least wanted you to have the advantage of seeing some of what PSI gets to pick up, some of what Sean has to deal with.
[0:34:49] But to remove that, some of the conversations have been that the exchange of this kind of information with PSI on their routes would not translate well into our software.
[0:35:03] As we approached that topic, it would mean a shift in the billing responsibility in order to make it work.
[0:35:12] But we weren't going there without coming before you to kind of show you what the task for clarification on some of the contracts that were created.
[0:35:26] Nicky Boyd.
[0:35:27] So, two pictures ago, there was a blue can with the lid closed, and quite a few hefty
[0:35:36] garbage bags.
[0:35:38] That one.
[0:35:40] That guy did a nice job.
[0:35:41] So.
[0:35:42] So.
[0:35:43] Stacked really nicely.
[0:35:44] There's also a pile behind there.
[0:35:45] It was all gone when I went home this time.
[0:35:48] And so, you know, you were looking at all these different pictures and I'm thinking everybody's
[0:35:53] throwing out or getting rid of a lot of stuff.
[0:35:57] But obviously, this seems like their understanding is, there's unlimited, it's spring cleaning.
[0:36:06] And I don't know how heavy any of those bags were, but it looks like one at a time you
[0:36:11] could have them in.
[0:36:12] That seems once a year, somewhat.
[0:36:17] Okay.
[0:36:19] If you clean up your yard and you don't cut it all up and put it real tidy, and I don't
[0:36:24] know what is that, 20 bags.
[0:36:26] And you could put it in a pick up and take it to the transfer station.
[0:36:30] If you don't have a truck, who do you call to bring a dumpster?
[0:36:35] Do you call PSI?
[0:36:39] And is this an odd, I'm kind of asking dumb questions, but do people go through this little
[0:36:45] process in their head of this is a lot to put out?
[0:36:51] That's reasonable to me, but all that big stuff and all the stuff that was literally
[0:36:55] just thrown and could have nails in it and that's just a safety issue.
[0:37:04] So how do you find that?
[0:37:07] And then the other part of my question is if we come up with a rule that says your can
[0:37:14] can be full but the lid has to be down is our goal to basically be teaching people how
[0:37:23] to separate recycling and sort of force the practice upon them is that?
[0:37:30] As much as we can.
[0:37:32] Just to answer your question about the bags, those 30 gallon trash bags, roughly 30 gallon,
[0:37:38] 35 pounds is the limit of weight.
[0:37:42] So they do have parameters.
[0:37:44] If it's in a 35 gallon or 30 gallon trash can, that can be 50.
[0:37:50] to the most, I'm guessing, a number of the trucks PSI now uses are a side load, so the
[0:37:57] driver has to be able to empty those bags into that blue cart once it's been dumped, so that
[0:38:02] it can lift it up its eight or so feed off the ground and dump it into the truck.
[0:38:08] So the side load truck is not where, like in the days where they jumped off the big truck
[0:38:14] and just...
[0:38:15] That's for the pews.
[0:38:16] That was used for the use of the rear load compression thing.
[0:38:22] Apparently it made a great noise.
[0:38:25] But then they have larger trucks they bring for the large refrigerator stove, large television
[0:38:31] sets.
[0:38:32] We can call them a PSI will schedule to combine and pick it up.
[0:38:35] It has to be on the curb.
[0:38:37] They've picked up living room sets, but they don't go on with the property anymore, partly
[0:38:42] because as with that photograph with this stuff all neatly
[0:38:45] stacked, Les called me and said, what are we going to do with this?
[0:38:49] And I said, well, so Sean went over and looked at it.
[0:38:54] And then the next day, Les drove by, and apparently it was
[0:38:58] somebody being moved out by their roommate.
[0:39:00] And they'd set it next to the curb, which technically his PSI
[0:39:03] picks it up.
[0:39:04] But it was all tart and duct taped up.
[0:39:07] So we were really glad we didn't throw that away.
[0:39:10] Somebody would've been looking for.
[0:39:12] What you doing with my stuff?
[0:39:15] But we're trying to push the recycling.
[0:39:19] These extreme cases are mostly just how much of that
[0:39:23] are we going to pay for under our contract with BSI,
[0:39:28] and how much are we going to expect citizens to realize
[0:39:31] this is time to get a dumpster.
[0:39:33] BSI certainly is one of the providers,
[0:39:35] but there are other providers in the town.
[0:39:38] They could call them, get a price quote,
[0:39:41] have another dumpster delivered. I don't mean to push against our PSI, but we do have five
[0:39:48] licensed garbage collectors in the city.
[0:39:51] And did you state the number of households that have one blue can issued?
[0:39:56] Is 69, and I need to review that with council here in a little while.
[0:40:01] Those are actually the small 35-gallon.
[0:40:04] Okay, thank you.
[0:40:08] is limited to just what fits in the car. Chris talking. Garbage is about my
[0:40:17] favorite side bickers so I'm really empathetic the PSI facing that intense
[0:40:24] labor problem that we've seen. They have to get off and manually load
[0:40:29] those things and I don't care if the little plastic bags are neatly stacked
[0:40:33] or not. I bet that take five seven minutes to do. That slows down their whole work
[0:40:38] schedule. The cheapest solution and best one is to meter the trash in over several weeks to get
[0:40:45] another big blue. You can do it seasonal, I would guess. There are solutions that would probably take
[0:40:52] care of the majority. I'm betting 80 or 90 percent of this. Church pews, I don't know what you can do
[0:40:57] except get a helicopter and get that crap out. But I want to remind the new city council in particular
[0:41:03] that are discussions with the county that controls Southwest waste, they offer us zero
[0:41:11] so far as tonnage reduction.
[0:41:15] It's in their mission plan, I think they even use the word recycling, and yet for all
[0:41:20] the recycling, we've been able to accomplish through the PSI, we've affected no net benefit
[0:41:26] to the taxpayer.
[0:41:28] And so that's something that, you know, we need to address in stronger terms.
[0:41:33] Hopefully we have new commissioners come November, but I would like to say that the most of the
[0:41:43] waste that I've seen going into recycling, I understand, is costing PSI net dollars because
[0:41:51] as our explanation talked about this evening, it's costing them $35 or $45 this summer.
[0:41:59] per ton, if I'm correct, to handle that. The carbon imprint of them transporting that garbage
[0:42:08] by rail, by truck, or by dirigible for what I care, to port them or whatever they recycle it,
[0:42:16] and net nothing in return, we have to ask what we're doing because we're costing pollution otherwise.
[0:42:25] I'm totally in favor of us getting really serious on stepping up for conservation measures,
[0:42:31] but I'm also empathetic that there is no return on recycling for the foreseeable future.
[0:42:37] Am I incorrect on that?
[0:42:41] No aluminum might be the only high value that you have and that's not much of one.
[0:42:47] But I'll shut up for now.
[0:42:51] Thank you.
[0:42:54] Thank you, sir.
[0:42:56] Good evening, Mr. Mayor, and members of the Council on Jeff
[0:42:59] Brewster on the District Manager for PSI.
[0:43:02] I may as well join in instead of shouting from the back of the
[0:43:05] room.
[0:43:06] Yeah, as far as right now, our commodities prices are pretty
[0:43:10] low, and that's really because of, I don't know if any of
[0:43:13] you have heard of the longshoreman strike they had late last
[0:43:15] year, but they actually put a lot of commodities at our
[0:43:19] shores that ship out overseas is where a lot of our recycling
[0:43:22] goes, and because of that, there's a surplus.
[0:43:24] So that really drove the cost of those commodities down.
[0:43:27] So that's part of the problem.
[0:43:28] And then the other part of the problem
[0:43:30] is recycling in town with people contaminating those molds.
[0:43:34] It degrades the product that's in there, obviously,
[0:43:37] cost of this more to give in as well.
[0:43:39] So like I said, right now we aren't $50 a ton to give it
[0:43:43] in cost.
[0:43:44] We just give it money for it.
[0:43:46] Look there.
[0:43:47] Well, it sounds to me like it's truly a public awareness
[0:43:51] campaign.
[0:43:52] I mean, I don't know about anybody else,
[0:43:54] but I do not read the little flyers that come in my pills.
[0:43:58] So it's going to have to be, you know,
[0:44:01] but I don't know, social media is not necessarily it,
[0:44:04] but our website, the city website, you know,
[0:44:09] messages out to the community, television, PSAs,
[0:44:16] whatever, but I think that is absolutely ridiculous.
[0:44:20] I've got to tell you.
[0:44:21] Now I've had an extra bag or two
[0:44:23] because it's Christmas and you've got some wrapping paper,
[0:44:26] whatever, but I would never think
[0:44:29] that unlimited garbage would include all that stuff.
[0:44:33] And I think it needs to be enforced,
[0:44:36] and I'm not putting any fault on anybody,
[0:44:39] but I think we need to tighten the parameters
[0:44:41] and just say, okay, you're allowed,
[0:44:45] I even think that 20 bags stacked up was a little ridiculous.
[0:44:49] I mean, drive to the transfer station,
[0:44:52] It's not that far out of town.
[0:44:55] And you can find somebody or somewhere to take that stuff.
[0:44:59] And I even saw an IRS agent put it in a dumpster at a 7-11 one.
[0:45:05] So you know, you could have it.
[0:45:08] That's probably not what we want to encourage.
[0:45:11] No, but I mean, no, not at all.
[0:45:13] And I was just saying that I was kind of shocked,
[0:45:15] because I thought everybody put their garbage
[0:45:17] in front of their house.
[0:45:19] But he's retired, so you know, yeah, it's all good.
[0:45:25] But I mean, it's happened in our dumpster at our office.
[0:45:29] We get this random stuff that somebody's come in,
[0:45:32] and it's absolutely ridiculous.
[0:45:34] And we get charged or, you know, there's more emptying.
[0:45:38] But I think it's tight in the parameters big time.
[0:45:41] I just think enough is enough personally.
[0:45:45] Absolutely correct.
[0:45:46] Right now, the high volume users are really
[0:45:49] take an invention so everybody's paying the same amount where that doesn't seem fair to.
[0:45:55] But I think everybody in the room, obviously if you have money you should pay for that.
[0:46:00] Obviously we're going to call it.
[0:46:04] Nicky Boyd?
[0:46:05] Do we have a community that we've looked at that is instigated?
[0:46:09] I don't know how you find somebody, but you get a warning and then you get a fine?
[0:46:14] Is that something that can be done?
[0:46:16] You know, general contractors do not have dumpsters on their sites and they haven't for years
[0:46:21] because we paid for everybody's refrigerator, broken stove, and mattresses to be hauled.
[0:46:26] So now we have people that just come in and clean the site and leave, and we only pay for what we generate.
[0:46:33] So, you know, dumpsters are a good idea, only if you fill it and make sure it's emptied.
[0:46:39] So, can we impose fines?
[0:46:42] there's ways to do it, obviously, in a partnership between the
[0:46:45] Holler and the City.
[0:46:46] Obviously, it would be working very closely with Sean.
[0:46:49] Obviously, he's out on the streets with us and taking those
[0:46:53] customers that are abusing the service and the program that
[0:46:56] we have in place.
[0:46:56] But yeah, there are certainly ways that you can obviously
[0:47:00] charge the hard-high volume users.
[0:47:01] And in one way, come up with a parameter.
[0:47:04] Maybe it is only one extra bag, and that's what will take
[0:47:07] anything over and beyond that.
[0:47:08] Maybe we assess an extra fee for that.
[0:47:11] We still take it, obviously we don't have stuff laying on the street because we want to avoid having clutter in the alleys or stuff going down our streets.
[0:47:19] That's what we want to avoid. There's got to be a way to, as Bill mentioned earlier, maybe difficult in our program.
[0:47:26] Our building software to speak with your building software, there are other ways that we can make sure that those customers get charged.
[0:47:33] we'd certainly like to accomplish, I think, for our point of view and as far as the citizens
[0:47:39] of Twin Falls that are abusing the program, so to speak.
[0:47:43] I think you do, do you have anything else there?
[0:47:47] No, I'm just thinking the other, the public service idea.
[0:47:52] What came to mind is back in the 60s and 70s when they decided that no smoking, they told
[0:47:59] all the grade school children and we went home and educated our parents and all their friends
[0:48:04] and pressured them and embarrassed them and did everything we could, you know, and I'm thinking,
[0:48:09] these kids are smart.
[0:48:10] They can turn the bottle over and see what number is in the little triangle and rinse it
[0:48:14] out and put it in the trash.
[0:48:16] You know, maybe the schools are an idea.
[0:48:18] I don't know.
[0:48:20] And just to answer schools or the question, or the question, or the question, there's actually
[0:48:24] a couple of items that are acceptable that I don't top the lid so they can look at that
[0:48:28] and see exactly what they can go in there.
[0:48:30] And then there is other outreach programs as well.
[0:48:34] That's an easy one every up, but he has to open that lid to put it in there.
[0:48:38] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:48:39] Thank you.
[0:48:41] So I'd like to caution us to take more of a middle of the road approach.
[0:48:47] I think that our unlimited pickup service has been a real value add to this community.
[0:48:53] I have kids that live in other communities that don't have that service.
[0:48:56] And I've seen the trash get stacked and stacked and stacked because the people don't have the money to pay to get.
[0:49:01] get rid of it. So, you know, I think we do need to tighten it up. Of course, what we
[0:49:06] thought there tonight was just not acceptable, but I don't want to see us
[0:49:10] tighten it down so much that people are not using the service. I don't want to
[0:49:16] see the city getting behind on that side of it. I appreciate the need for the
[0:49:20] recycling, but again, we're recycling costing as much as the trash, the
[0:49:24] education's great, and we want to help the environment as much as we can, but I
[0:49:29] I don't know that we're fixing any problems by doing that.
[0:49:31] Whether it's recycling or trash, we have the same amount of volume,
[0:49:35] and whichever way we choose to get rid of it,
[0:49:37] we still need to be reasonable with that.
[0:49:41] I know personally, I have two recycled cans
[0:49:44] and only one garbage can.
[0:49:46] And the recycling's picked up every other week,
[0:49:49] and my garbage is picked up every week,
[0:49:50] but my recycling's full before my garbage.
[0:49:53] And so maybe we need to look at that.
[0:49:54] Maybe we could start picking up recycling weekly
[0:49:57] instead of bi-weekly and maybe that would encourage people because my recycling fills
[0:50:01] up before I can get rid of it.
[0:50:03] So maybe that's another option to look at.
[0:50:05] I just want to ask you, unless you're trash, rather than an in-lawing price of recycling
[0:50:17] carts, maybe it's a dollar a month for an extra recycled cart, maybe it's five dollars a month
[0:50:21] for an extra trash can, just to encourage additional recycling and find that volume.
[0:50:26] I think that's great, but again, maybe we need to look at how often we're picking it up.
[0:50:30] In some cities they have changed it to where trash goes every other week and recycling as we can.
[0:50:35] I know I'm not probably the normal, but that would work great for me.
[0:50:39] It would be difficult and not obviously so.
[0:50:42] Because it is a newer program essentially if you consider the west coast has been recycling for 30 years and we're just getting in the game in the last decade.
[0:50:50] Not for most of the states. We fit behind, but it's doable.
[0:50:56] So Bill, can I ask how much more of your sort of presentation do you have, because we just keep getting lights and suggestions up here.
[0:51:03] And I want to make sure we actually get through the content of what you want it to discuss.
[0:51:08] Is everyone okay that's on up here to hold off until we get through?
[0:51:13] I need to have one assurance from PSI.
[0:51:16] You know what it could get.
[0:51:17] Okay, we're not done with them yet.
[0:51:19] I want to just want to build to get through the rest of what it discusses.
[0:51:21] But if you're dealing with through PSI, you're very quick.
[0:51:24] I periodically get calls and claims that the recycling is dumped into the general trash.
[0:51:31] Please assure me you're not doing that.
[0:51:34] That's not your policy at least.
[0:51:36] Absolutely not.
[0:51:37] If one was contaminated, one of our drivers calls our dispatch says, hey, this load is trash,
[0:51:43] and then we come by and pick it up.
[0:51:45] Thank you.
[0:51:46] I would just add on to that.
[0:51:48] I received the same claims and I was going to ask the same thing.
[0:51:52] We just need to make sure, because that's a bad PR piece.
[0:51:56] And people are adamant that they've seen the garbage truck.
[0:51:59] Come pick up their garbage, and then they're recycling
[0:52:02] from the same truck.
[0:52:04] We have two different trucks going down the same streets,
[0:52:07] but the only time we've actually put a recycled cart
[0:52:10] into our trash truck is when it does have
[0:52:12] a contaminated load of the trash trash.
[0:52:18] Thank you.
[0:52:20] Sean's going to step up here in a minute as our code enforcement
[0:52:22] But the letter to the editor two weeks ago, I did a little Google and checking out, found
[0:52:31] out where that address was called PSI and said, Will you please tell me what went on
[0:52:36] here?
[0:52:37] And that individual I know in the letter said it was all recycling, but the recycled
[0:52:43] driver had looked in the car, it was contaminated, and so when the trash, and he comes by first
[0:52:49] on my route anyway.
[0:52:50] And so when he got to the trash driver got to that address, he emptied both carts because
[0:52:55] of the contamination of the recycling.
[0:52:59] Sometimes PSI will take pictures of that if the resident insists, but they are very careful
[0:53:04] about dumping those recycled carts.
[0:53:07] They will not dump it into the blue cart, and then that would be a real challenge for
[0:53:11] one guy, but they will pick up the recycle and dump it in the trash.
[0:53:17] I just wanted to clarify a little bit about Unlimited.
[0:53:21] In the cold enforcement world, that's a pretty good deal.
[0:53:25] We need to clean up pretty quick.
[0:53:27] But we also realize that there's a fine line there
[0:53:30] that we have to draw.
[0:53:31] And between Les and his team here the last two or three years,
[0:53:36] Les has reached out and made a phone call and said,
[0:53:38] hey, come and take a look at this and tell us
[0:53:41] if this is beyond what we're responsible for.
[0:53:44] So we've been taking care of it anyway.
[0:53:48] We'll educate the citizen.
[0:53:50] In this case, it was a foreclosure.
[0:53:54] We paid PSI to pick it up and then build the property.
[0:53:58] So the city did get reimbursed for stuff like this.
[0:54:01] So I just wanted to clarify that.
[0:54:04] Thank you, Sean.
[0:54:06] So, points of clarification, finally there.
[0:54:11] The unlimited, you know, I knew that was going to be exciting.
[0:54:13] I just didn't know quite out.
[0:54:16] We need to clarify that we are pursuing a ten-year contract with BSI that involves
[0:54:22] the timing because of their investment in new trucks, cards, any opportunity to develop new methods of encouraging
[0:54:30] recycling and or adjusting card sizes as we determine to be necessary.
[0:54:37] Level of service, I believe this was a
[0:54:40] comment that we heard from council level of service is the primary consideration for our citizens.
[0:54:45] Rather than limiting the conversation to the length of the contract, we have an interest
[0:54:51] in finding the areas where we can increase existing service and identify options that
[0:54:55] may work better and that is what is being sought in this process.
[0:55:01] Unlimited garbage collection inside items was mostly to help us to find that terminology
[0:55:07] in the contract.
[0:55:08] If we are going to limit it, we don't want it to be extremely restrictive but we'd like
[0:55:14] a clearer line for Sean and PSI to use. Again, discretion will always be present because these
[0:55:22] gentlemen are really intelligent about how they go about their job. I just take the phone
[0:55:26] calls from the customers that complain about the trash nut. We picked up and go right back
[0:55:31] to those two. So anything you can do to help us clarify what we're reaching for, the unlimited
[0:55:39] service if we are going to move toward us so much per bag,
[0:55:45] multiple types of carts, it would help us if we could explore
[0:55:50] the opportunity for PSI to engage, to do the billing,
[0:55:55] because their drivers, their software,
[0:55:57] tracks how those loads at each address go on the truck.
[0:56:01] We don't really have a way to incorporate that into our system.
[0:56:05] I will leave that then and I have some comments about the one can, which would be fairly quick.
[0:56:13] Yeah, I think Bill, if you could address the one can since we've had quite a bit of discussion
[0:56:19] about that in the past.
[0:56:20] We, with Lessa's help, he has checked addresses.
[0:56:25] We do have 69 accounts listed on the books.
[0:56:30] We have 41 qualified addresses which means they were in service before October 1st of 2005.
[0:56:41] And they have a mix of different carts.
[0:56:44] There are a number of reasons for that, but they are paying the one can rate whether they
[0:56:48] have one can, a 95 can and a recycle, a 95 and a recycle, no 35.
[0:56:55] The carts move around.
[0:56:57] They disappear, but we have 41 qualified addresses
[0:57:02] for that one can rate.
[0:57:04] They just don't all have 135 gallon can.
[0:57:08] We have 28 unqualified addresses,
[0:57:11] which also have a mix of cans.
[0:57:14] Some will have a 35 gallon and a recycle.
[0:57:17] Some will have a 35, a couple of blues, and a recycle.
[0:57:23] But we are in the process of correcting our billing system.
[0:57:27] We are going to send letters to the unqualified addresses and say congratulations.
[0:57:32] You have been the beneficiary of a software problem, but we found it and we're going to fix it.
[0:57:38] The issue is, just so you'll know, that our billing system tracks the service rate by an
[0:57:46] address, not by the customer.
[0:57:49] And when this question was asked and I ran the first report and just about fell out of
[0:57:53] my chair.
[0:57:54] We explored why that was the case, and the service rate is attached to the address itself.
[0:58:01] So we now are putting alerts on all those remaining qualified addresses that when a new
[0:58:06] customer comes in to register for that account, the one can rate goes away.
[0:58:13] But it is a problem, has been a problem, PSI has been providing excellent service, we
[0:58:18] just haven't been charging enough to roughly 28 or so of these customers.
[0:58:22] we're going to confirm with those qualified residents that they want their 95 and or their
[0:58:28] recycled card or they want to go back to just the 35 and clean that part up as well.
[0:58:34] So is there anyone who has only the 35 gallon can is there anyone who's actually using the
[0:58:41] service as it's designed in the contract?
[0:58:43] Eight people.
[0:58:44] Eight people.
[0:58:45] Now the way the cards get delivered when the contractor that delivers like the recycle
[0:58:52] carts, they have not paid very good attention to PSI's list. They pull up in front of a bunch
[0:58:58] of addresses and unload carts. So that's probably exactly how the, I think they're 20 of those
[0:59:06] accounts or no, 10 with a 35 gallon and a recycle cart. That's probably how that happened.
[0:59:13] So we have some glitches and it's interesting to dive around and try to spot where these
[0:59:18] cans are. We have five addresses that are qualified addresses, but neither less nor
[0:59:24] I know what kind of carts they have. We've been by on garbage day, recycle day,
[0:59:29] nothing's out, the garage door is closed. So we're working on it.
[0:59:37] Well, Chris, I have some of those little friends that literally, if they fill up
[0:59:42] one of these little plastic bags, one of these little dinky five-gallon ones in
[0:59:46] a week. Sometimes that's all they have and they have to remember to feed the cat and not
[0:59:52] put the garbage out. They may go several weeks without putting garbage out. I mean, these
[0:59:56] people are frugal. It's not surprising to me that you may not see them week after week
[1:00:02] putting them. Well, I told me five and that's since we do have some snowbird offs which means
[1:00:08] all the services off while the people are out of town. Yeah. But I guess since a program
[1:00:14] that was instituted 11 years ago, it's not surprising, and yet it is really what you found
[1:00:21] out.
[1:00:22] I think all of us are a little bit amazed at the combination that you have now, but if the
[1:00:28] council were interested in expanding the program under some sort of a means testing, either
[1:00:36] age or volume or income or whatever, the council has been concerned in the past that we have
[1:00:43] to make our volume business by charging so much we're going to get behind and we can't
[1:00:52] be making too difficult a program.
[1:00:57] Is it not possible for us to just simply have a little software fix that institutes a credit
[1:01:03] against a normal charge for a person that's unidentified as a reduced user?
[1:01:10] I would imagine we could do that.
[1:01:12] The tough part would be auditing that.
[1:01:14] So it's just done on a computer desk instead of having
[1:01:17] to do anything else.
[1:01:19] It would probably, if I had to guess, Mr. Talkington,
[1:01:23] because of the way our software functions and the support
[1:01:27] that we currently have available for it,
[1:01:30] there is a cost to customizing.
[1:01:32] We might have to develop a rate that is, in fact,
[1:01:37] negative rate, and apply that to these addresses.
[1:01:43] The first thing we'd have to do is figure out
[1:01:45] how would the system for reporting work without someone from
[1:01:49] PSI sending us an Excel file, and then having one of our personnel
[1:01:54] work their way down through that and apply that monthly,
[1:01:58] because PSI, again, their drivers have the ability to track
[1:02:03] what's being loaded at any address.
[1:02:05] And if we instigated a program and said, okay, there's 1,500 of these people, and we start out the first month with a credit,
[1:02:13] we get a couple months down the road, and if we aren't auditing them every month,
[1:02:17] we'll probably find ourselves back in a one-can rate where we have a lot of things.
[1:02:22] Well, by an auditing, you can see what we have right here by exposure.
[1:02:26] Nonetheless, and I'll get off my soapbox.
[1:02:28] I just want to ask the Council to give consideration, and we could form a program with new parameters,
[1:02:35] either age or income or something like that, that I think would just give credence to the fact
[1:02:41] that people that have been paying taxes are now on fixed income, living alone, whatever combinations
[1:02:47] really are not contributing much to our waste stream, and we should give them some sort of consideration
[1:02:54] or their lack of trashing up the yard, the city, and the dump, and I would hope that this
[1:03:02] makes sense that we can reward people for being tight with the garbage.
[1:03:10] I don't know how they'll put it.
[1:03:12] We've seen the other extreme here, and by the way, Ruth, I've known some business people
[1:03:16] live outside the city limits that bring their trash into the dumpsters.
[1:03:20] of them was caught only because he had his names on his envelopes and he put them in the
[1:03:25] library dumpster and those things do happen. Anyway, thank you for their research.
[1:03:32] Ruth Pierce. Just one quick question. In your information
[1:03:35] you addressed that you were checking to see if there was anybody getting garbage service
[1:03:40] that wasn't paying. Did you find anybody? Oh, I'm perfect timing.
[1:03:46] timing.
[1:03:47] Good to sign.
[1:03:48] The question.
[1:03:49] So they'll actually have a question about the smaller cans, maybe before we go on it,
[1:03:54] maybe a question for PSI.
[1:03:56] So much the same as what the Solid Waste District has, there are fixed costs to doing something.
[1:04:04] So we have a fixed cost of the trucks still got to drive to the house, the trucks still
[1:04:08] got to pick up the can and dump it in the truck.
[1:04:11] Is there any piece of that fixed cost of pickup, any real number, that is reduced by 60 gallons
[1:04:23] less of trash in a can?
[1:04:25] There is, but it only comes in the form of a disposal fee, obviously.
[1:04:30] And when you pencil out a 35 versus a 95 in 69 cans, as opposed to 14,000 or even if
[1:04:38] if it's 1,500.
[1:04:41] Is that Penis that it saves or?
[1:04:43] Yeah, it costs us exactly the same to drive by that home,
[1:04:46] stop at that home, make the motion with the truck
[1:04:49] to dump that container, whether it's a 35 or a 95-gallon.
[1:04:52] The only difference in cost is truly
[1:04:54] the volume of the weight of the trash.
[1:04:57] And then obviously it's a little bit less purchase
[1:04:59] of 35-gallon container than 95.
[1:05:01] So there's a little bit of savings there.
[1:05:03] And truthfully, today, if someone's only generating
[1:05:07] a small amount of trash but happens to have the 95 gallon bin.
[1:05:12] The volume is likely not changing.
[1:05:15] It's now like if we implemented this can that suddenly people
[1:05:18] would produce less trash.
[1:05:19] There may be some incentive to do that.
[1:05:20] But likely those costs are already there.
[1:05:24] Generally, the people that would go to those containers
[1:05:26] would be folks that do want to recycle more
[1:05:28] and they get larger or two larger recycled containers
[1:05:33] and then go to that smaller trash container.
[1:05:35] and then there should be a discount for that,
[1:05:37] just to encourage that.
[1:05:38] It wouldn't necessarily save untrue expenses,
[1:05:42] but it encourages that behavior, so.
[1:05:43] But there is a huge fixed cost difference
[1:05:46] to the landfill to the Southwest
[1:05:49] who has less trash to bury.
[1:05:51] They run fewer tractor hours, fewer man hours,
[1:05:55] less gas consumption.
[1:05:56] You're basically feeling the same,
[1:05:58] you're just spreading your costs around a little bit different.
[1:06:01] But this is the Southwest garbage shed people
[1:06:04] that are affecting a real savings,
[1:06:06] and we're not getting the benefit for it.
[1:06:08] The true changes in costs are those folks
[1:06:10] that do have the 10 extra bags
[1:06:12] next to the trash container.
[1:06:13] Our driver is there for five minutes or three minutes,
[1:06:16] whatever the case may be,
[1:06:17] where is it with just a container,
[1:06:19] we're picking up and we're gone.
[1:06:20] So there is extra cost with larger volumes, obviously.
[1:06:24] Yes, far as Chris talked to me was mentioning,
[1:06:27] yes, the landfill shouldn't raise their age
[1:06:29] just because you reduce their volume,
[1:06:31] but they tend to do that, so they get it.
[1:06:34] Thank you.
[1:06:35] The number that I have from talking with Jeff about the cost of the carts, as I understand,
[1:06:44] $55 for a $95 gallon cart, $45 for a $35 gallon cart.
[1:06:49] If you amortize that over the five years that they're allocated warranty for those carts,
[1:06:55] it's $0.17 a month difference, just I'm going to count them.
[1:07:02] I thought it might come in, Andy.
[1:07:05] So the question about city services being provided to citizens,
[1:07:10] residents who are not paying.
[1:07:13] I believe this surfaced most recently with the Canyon Gate
[1:07:17] Place subdivision.
[1:07:19] Subdivision 20, and I believe the mid-90s.
[1:07:22] And we have one customer out of, I believe, 11, who
[1:07:26] is paying for that service.
[1:07:28] We did not have an out-of-city services agreement
[1:07:31] place for that subdivision. Fritz has just finished editing one. We are in
[1:07:37] conversations about where else are these things. I do have a letter to send out
[1:07:44] again to the Canyon Gate Place residents saying here's your agreement that will
[1:07:48] need you to sign please review this call with questions come in and sign up for
[1:07:53] an account. It will be $20.44 a month for the flat rate sewer because we aren't
[1:08:00] measuring water, they're all unwells, we can only charge the flat rate for the sewer.
[1:08:05] And that would be the charge and for some of those homes we've been 18-20 years without
[1:08:12] collecting that monthly fee.
[1:08:14] Others more recent, probably in the early 2000s, they were constructed.
[1:08:20] Most of the people that have contacted me are just happy to participate, but the sewer
[1:08:24] taps were put in and then there was a disconnect between engineering and utility services and
[1:08:30] We didn't get the bills out.
[1:08:32] Without the agreement, I'm not sure.
[1:08:34] This would be a question for Mitch and Fritz and Orshane.
[1:08:38] What do you do without those Los Lagos?
[1:08:41] We do bill for their water.
[1:08:43] But as far as I know, we don't have an agreement.
[1:08:46] They are not annexed into the city,
[1:08:48] although the city is pretty much wrapped around them.
[1:08:51] So there are a number of those kinds of things out there.
[1:08:54] Some we have sewer and sanitation only customers.
[1:08:59] We have sanitation only customers, still on wells, still on septic.
[1:09:03] We don't have a stick like our water.
[1:09:06] Every Wednesday is just a thrill here if you want to come down sometime and just watch.
[1:09:10] People that haven't paid their bill, we shut them off and we get their attention.
[1:09:15] We don't have that tool with sewer or sewer and sanitation only customers.
[1:09:20] So there are a number of those people out there who are just not quite sure how to deal with them.
[1:09:25] Great landing.
[1:09:26] So I'm assuming you were talking about on the ones you were,
[1:09:29] the Canyon ones you were talking about,
[1:09:30] the sewer's gonna be 2044,
[1:09:33] now we're also gonna be charging for their garbage pickups
[1:09:36] as well, or do they pick up garbage?
[1:09:37] No, they do not have garbage.
[1:09:39] They don't have garbage pickups.
[1:09:40] Just sewer service on the boats.
[1:09:42] They're outside the city limits on the north side of...
[1:09:45] Settlers Ridge.
[1:09:47] Canyon Rim Road.
[1:09:48] Yeah.
[1:09:49] Just sticks out there, nice area.
[1:09:51] And I don't believe these people were doing this on purpose,
[1:09:54] But when you're a contractor hooks you up,
[1:09:57] you walk in and you flush your toilet and it goes away?
[1:10:00] Well, yes.
[1:10:01] I happen to know the people that were,
[1:10:04] the ones who were paying, that were the one.
[1:10:07] And they would argue that the others knew.
[1:10:12] Well, they weren't paying.
[1:10:13] And I've heard that argument you've already
[1:10:15] don't know that I'll say that publicly.
[1:10:18] Yeah, we probably don't want to get the neighborhood
[1:10:19] in the argument, right?
[1:10:21] Don't know.
[1:10:22] Are there any other locations like that?
[1:10:24] Because I'm aware of at least one that I've heard.
[1:10:26] That is the marvel of this whole process.
[1:10:29] It's there out there somewhere.
[1:10:32] We're a little bit afraid we don't know where they all are.
[1:10:35] How do we find out?
[1:10:37] What's the investigative tools to find out?
[1:10:40] We stumbled over this, and Mitch was the one that helped me.
[1:10:44] So I've asked our water department
[1:10:47] to take a look at it, because they
[1:10:48] know where all the lines aren't.
[1:10:50] Then theory, they've got to go maintain all these lines.
[1:10:52] And I've asked them to compare where they got lines
[1:10:55] versus city limits.
[1:10:57] And that'll at least give us a place to start.
[1:10:59] And once we can identify all those places that have services
[1:11:02] outside the city limits, then we can start going,
[1:11:05] it'll be kind of addressed by address
[1:11:08] to see if there's an account set up.
[1:11:09] And it's been a time consuming process.
[1:11:13] We don't do this much anymore.
[1:11:15] In fact, we haven't done it since 1996 or 1998,
[1:11:18] something like that.
[1:11:19] In fact, I'll probably tie it to the switch-in city engineer.
[1:11:24] When Gary left and Jackie came on,
[1:11:26] Gary used to do these out-of-city services agreements,
[1:11:29] and since Jackie's been here,
[1:11:30] we just haven't done it, at least in the last 10 years.
[1:11:32] So if you wanna get city services,
[1:11:34] you annex into the city.
[1:11:36] For the, that's just how it's been for the last 10 years.
[1:11:39] So there aren't more of these things coming on.
[1:11:43] That's getting caught up with those ones.
[1:11:44] It's figuring out which ones we used to do it for,
[1:11:47] which ones of those lines did get extended
[1:11:49] into that neighborhood.
[1:11:50] And did we actually set up those accounts or not?
[1:11:53] A lot of them we did, a few we haven't.
[1:11:56] So yeah, it's just a time consuming process going through
[1:12:00] and checking them all and finding them all.
[1:12:01] But we're underway.
[1:12:03] There's a process to be able to find out
[1:12:05] who has wells within this area,
[1:12:07] and then finding out who has to or gives us.
[1:12:11] So we know where all of our infrastructure is, right?
[1:12:13] We know where our sewer lines are.
[1:12:14] We know where our water lines are.
[1:12:17] We don't offer trash services out of city limits, period.
[1:12:20] So we're not doing any of the sanitation costs,
[1:12:23] but we know water, we know sewer.
[1:12:25] And that's a good place to start.
[1:12:26] We also know where city limits are.
[1:12:28] So we can do this, but it's really not a simple, easy,
[1:12:33] run this report kind of thing.
[1:12:34] It's going out to look into every single one of them.
[1:12:37] And so they're working on it.
[1:12:38] And we're going to identify them.
[1:12:40] And then when we do, like Los Lagos is the one
[1:12:43] that came up more recently, did we have
[1:12:46] this out-of-city services agreement there and and I don't think we did and so we're
[1:12:51] gonna probably approach those guys about signing one of these agreements now
[1:12:54] you're pretty soon too and we haven't had a problem with them paying their bill
[1:12:58] it goes to the homeowners association but I guess the agreement not being the
[1:13:03] attorney is pretty important thank you thank Lansing well I would caution us and
[1:13:08] I'm glad to hear that we're no longer allowing that outside the city limits
[1:13:15] because I'll reference, and if I get something wrong on this, Suzanne,
[1:13:20] remind me, because we've heard about this quite a bit of ASE.
[1:13:24] There's an area southwest of Boise of about over 20,000 residents,
[1:13:31] which would make it like the 10th largest city in Idaho or something,
[1:13:36] that are on city water and sewer and are not in the city limits of Boise,
[1:13:42] And Boise has an agreement with them that they need to be annexed to become part of the city of Boise.
[1:13:49] And now they're trying to find legislative solutions that say they know they don't have to be part of the city, Boise, because they don't want to put Boise taxes.
[1:13:56] And of course Boise is saying, well, we just won't provide services to you.
[1:14:00] If that's the case, I don't want us to get us in that type of a situation where we have a large group of outside the city limits that are on city services and yet are fighting us to be annexed.
[1:14:11] Because behind my solution on the county park would just be the annex them
[1:14:15] I think we have the the state law would allow us to do so
[1:14:20] Because they are now contiguous to us. They are getting city services
[1:14:24] You know we would have to figure out how to do what we could actually we have water lines
[1:14:28] I guess we could do water if they wanted water, so
[1:14:32] I'm just I'm glad to hear we're no longer doing that and that takes care of the problem
[1:14:37] And what's the name of that subdivision that's here? Okay?
[1:14:41] over 20,000 residents.
[1:14:43] So that's pretty good size town, you know.
[1:14:47] Really I think it's like 10th or 11th largest city
[1:14:49] and I know and they're using city services
[1:14:53] but aren't paying for it.
[1:14:54] So whether paying fees but not taxes
[1:14:59] like the rest of our residents do, they help us out, good?
[1:15:06] Chris Stockington.
[1:15:07] Well, thanks Bill.
[1:15:08] I know you've put a lot of work in on this
[1:15:10] and I hope that the council will
[1:15:13] Reinforce what we've been doing with conservation is one of the best things the previous council
[1:15:19] tip my head to all the time was initiate the conservation program. I did hear a comment
[1:15:25] from one of our council people that conservation is not necessary. It doesn't say resources and
[1:15:32] my work with the energy sector is anywhere between 25 and 80 to 90 percent energy reduction
[1:15:40] when you use some recycled materials.
[1:15:43] So conservation is viable in a defensible program.
[1:15:48] The fact that we are not earning any money currently,
[1:15:53] I think we have to look a little bit longer term.
[1:15:55] But besides the single can rate that I hope we can reinvent
[1:16:01] and maybe provide to some of our elderly people
[1:16:05] on a greatly reduced volume, I would just like to think
[1:16:10] that most of the people could use that public education program review.
[1:16:14] And Nicky talked about they don't have to put all the trash out in one week.
[1:16:19] They can get a blue and extra blue can, and most of that can be handled without having those
[1:16:25] grotesque sites we've seen out there.
[1:16:28] And I wouldn't expect that our insurance carrier would be very happy if we had that much work put
[1:16:36] but upon either city staff or contractors looking to look into a dumpster.
[1:16:42] There's things we can do, and I think we just need to go to the city manager and get some sort
[1:16:47] of an idea of what our goal is and structure some workshops and within ourselves come up
[1:16:54] with some solutions.
[1:16:56] The time of free garbage is over.
[1:17:01] So Bill do you feel like you got any direction from the council discussion tonight or did you
[1:17:06] You just get a laundry list of other things to try to discuss.
[1:17:08] Well, I think we're right on track.
[1:17:09] We've got the same things.
[1:17:10] I would like just a point of clarification
[1:17:13] on a couple of things.
[1:17:13] 10-year contract is acceptable to the council.
[1:17:17] And if we were to come back with options for charging
[1:17:23] for the amount of trash, certain amount of unlimited,
[1:17:28] but then above that charging extra, wow,
[1:17:33] what is the council's appetite for a shift
[1:17:35] in the billing responsibility without loss of control
[1:17:41] over the amount annually for the increases,
[1:17:44] but it would redirect charges to people
[1:17:48] with exceptional unlimited trash.
[1:17:51] They want it all the way PSI would pick it up
[1:17:53] and bill those people specifically
[1:17:56] because they would have a ranking mechanism.
[1:17:59] This is just for presentation purposes.
[1:18:01] We don't want to go down that road
[1:18:03] if it's not an option, but.
[1:18:05] We should talk about this.
[1:18:07] So my input on that is that it sounds to me
[1:18:13] as if PSI is better equipped to actually do that kind of billing.
[1:18:17] So that would make sense.
[1:18:20] The area I would have concern is to ensure
[1:18:23] that the customer service and the presentation of information
[1:18:29] and the collection process and all of that
[1:18:32] would happen in a like way that the city would
[1:18:35] address that. And I think sometimes that's a challenge for a private business to try to
[1:18:42] function like a public service as a city is and finding that happy medium would be an area
[1:18:50] that I would want to be make sure is happening appropriately.
[1:18:55] Don Hall.
[1:18:56] I would just get rid of the term unlimited. That's the first place I would start because
[1:19:00] unlimited, you can't have parameters around unlimited. Unlimited is unlimited. So we need
[1:19:05] You'd have the parameters first and certainly, I guess that's really what I want to say.
[1:19:13] Get rid of unlimited, give us some parameters and let's go from there.
[1:19:16] I guess I would view it similar to my cell phone bill with my children that use a lot
[1:19:22] of data.
[1:19:23] It's this much a month for this much data and then you start paying for the overage.
[1:19:30] So maybe the trash needs to be looked at as overage.
[1:19:33] Yeah, and and some not unlimited some way of charging to that. John is a very happy man right now
[1:19:41] He would like that, but again, I think finding out what that what that
[1:19:47] reasonable amount of of waste is I think is the fine line because I mean so for example last week
[1:19:54] I mean I had a ton of stuff out in front of my house because I did a lot of yard work last week
[1:19:58] Did you get a picture of it? We could use that as I was afraid it was gonna show up
[1:20:02] Because my trash day was the windy day last week.
[1:20:07] So, you know, but I would hate to be at the point where, you know, my trash bill started
[1:20:16] fluctuating, you know, 20, 30, 40, 50 bucks a month.
[1:20:21] Because I'm not big for one day of a lot of trash or something.
[1:20:24] Well, I think it would involve some education as well.
[1:20:28] We don't have many offenders, but they do pop up on a regular basis.
[1:20:33] This is for Lester, whoever.
[1:20:36] Is there a calendar I can look at to find out?
[1:20:39] Because I end up seemingly putting out my girlfriend's garbage all the way.
[1:20:43] I live clearing the other side of town on Sunday nights.
[1:20:46] And I never know when, which is her recycle day and which it was or isn't.
[1:20:51] It sounds like a personal problem.
[1:20:53] It's on the city's website.
[1:20:55] I went to PSI's website and I was a little confused.
[1:20:58] website beautifully color coded and there's a map that'll tell you where you are.
[1:21:02] I will send you a copy.
[1:21:04] I appreciate that.
[1:21:05] I just missed on the city's website however Google it I've heard from a lot of people that
[1:21:10] if you Google it you get 2014's or 2015's calendar 2016 is on the city website.
[1:21:16] Okay that was probably Google in it you're probably right.
[1:21:19] Yeah.
[1:21:20] Well Josh explained to me that you can't take that stuff down after it's out there because
[1:21:25] the search terms will just grab it but I will mail you.
[1:21:28] as well as the maps of the city so unless you want to email me
[1:21:32] and send me up the addresses.
[1:21:33] The Oregon Trail Subdivision.
[1:21:35] Okay.
[1:21:36] So I'm worried about.
[1:21:37] Get that to you.
[1:21:38] Because we don't get to recycle at our place, but my place in Cancando.
[1:21:41] So.
[1:21:42] Thank you very much.
[1:21:43] All right, Bill.
[1:21:44] Thank you.
[1:21:45] Thank you very much.
[1:21:46] Jeff, thanks to you and your team.
[1:21:47] All right.
[1:21:49] Next on the agenda, consideration of a request to authorize the city manager to sign an executed lease agreement for the property located at 103 Main Avenue.
[1:21:58] Avenue, when it falls out of home, we have Deputy City Manager, Brian Pike, I corrected
[1:22:04] the agenda there on the fly because it says Main Street.
[1:22:08] Thank you, Mayor, members of the Council. What you have before you is a lease agreement negotiated
[1:22:13] by some of our finest, Mr. Rothweiler and our CFO, Lori Race. I want to get that plug in.
[1:22:22] But before we move forward, I just would like to kind of go back a little bit and lay a little
[1:22:27] bit of the background and how we got to this point. I think Travis brought it up several
[1:22:32] weeks ago when he was talking about how we were looking at phases and really one of the
[1:22:38] things I've realized, and I know this is a new process for us, but the construction manager
[1:22:42] general contractor, the CMGC process is really to our benefit. And when we sat down with
[1:22:50] Michael and Jason from Star Corporation early on, so sitting down at the public safety team
[1:22:55] and looking at how do we move forward
[1:22:58] and what kind of phasing options would we have?
[1:23:00] And would we close a quarter of the building
[1:23:03] and then open a quarter of the building?
[1:23:05] And it was really, really challenging.
[1:23:09] And they were instrumental in helping us find a way
[1:23:11] and giving us some ideas about creating some,
[1:23:15] maybe some little bit of different thinking, right?
[1:23:19] About how we approach this versus how we would have done
[1:23:22] traditionally and really helping us find
[1:23:24] and efficiencies and hopefully some cost savings as we move forward.
[1:23:29] So with that in mind, really what we came up with, and we looked at several options of
[1:23:32] phasing, but ideally we think the most efficient way for us to move forward is to go ahead and
[1:23:38] vacate the current city hall building.
[1:23:40] So city hall staff vacates the building and STAR Corporation can begin the process of the
[1:23:47] remodel of that city hall building to the new police administration and records building.
[1:23:53] They can do this at the same time that they start the construction work on the banner building.
[1:23:58] And instead of being tied to the banner, the public safety complex can move forward on the independent schedule.
[1:24:05] And what we're hoping is as we move forward and we get into a bid environment, that it'll be because of the synergy between the two projects.
[1:24:13] We're hoping for more, we're hoping for a favorable bid environment.
[1:24:16] I can't guarantee that.
[1:24:18] Because a contractor can come in and can bid on both,
[1:24:21] can bid on work at the banner and at the public safety complex
[1:24:24] at the same time.
[1:24:25] And we've created a system for that to happen.
[1:24:27] We think it'll work into our favor.
[1:24:30] So given all that, Mitch led us all over to one falls,
[1:24:34] looking for a site, literally, and the old key bank building
[1:24:41] at 103 Main Street.
[1:24:43] We looked at that early on, and we
[1:24:45] thought that had real potential.
[1:24:46] But we wanted to do our due diligence.
[1:24:48] We wanted to make sure, was there another building out there
[1:24:51] that could serve in this purpose?
[1:24:52] Was there a way that we could do this more efficiently?
[1:24:54] And we did.
[1:24:55] We went all over it, honestly, at the end of the day.
[1:24:58] We could not find buildings that would cost us less,
[1:25:01] but we couldn't accommodate our staff.
[1:25:04] And they wouldn't accommodate our citizens.
[1:25:06] And some were split level.
[1:25:08] We looked at one building that was a split level,
[1:25:09] which would have been, I think, very difficult
[1:25:11] for the public tax access on a regular basis.
[1:25:15] So with all that in mind, we've kind of focused
[1:25:18] with those parameters we focused on the Okebe building at 103 Main Street.
[1:25:23] The building contains approximately 14,000 square feet.
[1:25:27] We believe it has the access that our community expects.
[1:25:30] It's, I think, perfect for our staff.
[1:25:33] We have just about the same square footage right now in our current configuration.
[1:25:40] So it's a good fit.
[1:25:41] We're not planning to do anything, any kind of remodel to the building.
[1:25:45] to use some partitions and we'll make that space workforce.
[1:25:49] And the other thing that we like about is it puts us downtown
[1:25:52] right during the remodel of downtown.
[1:25:54] So it puts us really as a stakeholder right in that process
[1:25:58] and we think that's important.
[1:26:00] So with that, I would stand for any questions.
[1:26:03] On Hall.
[1:26:04] So does this mean the Hanson folks will be going there as well?
[1:26:08] Hanson will stay where they're at.
[1:26:09] Hanson will stay where they're at right now.
[1:26:12] So we're really basically looking to relocate
[1:26:14] just the staff at the current city hall.
[1:26:17] Chris, talking.
[1:26:18] Yeah, it looks like the right move for us to make, Ryan,
[1:26:20] but there is one particular that I'm sure is not accurate.
[1:26:26] It's including six additional parking spots.
[1:26:30] I would assume this is an addition to their requirement
[1:26:33] for their square footage.
[1:26:35] At six, it's not going to serve the public.
[1:26:40] So additional means on top of what is required
[1:26:43] for a building of that zoning nature
[1:26:47] by the required parking attached to its usage.
[1:26:51] Yeah, that's a great question,
[1:26:53] one that I anticipated.
[1:26:55] So the key, as you can see here,
[1:26:58] the KeyBank building has, it's basically a private lot
[1:27:01] and we will have access to what we call the purple lot.
[1:27:06] So approximately 43 parking spaces
[1:27:09] that are adjacent to that.
[1:27:11] There you go.
[1:27:12] with six additional spaces out of that private lot that will be dedicated to
[1:27:20] or basically to our customers. That will allow that for community access.
[1:27:24] So that'd be 49 parking spots all together. That's correct. And we don't
[1:27:31] envision allowing all city staff to park either on the lot or ride adjacent to
[1:27:36] the building either. I don't think that's one time we talked about having the mark
[1:27:40] move away, maybe on the other side of Main Street, one of the second lots.
[1:27:46] Those are some details that we need to work out.
[1:27:48] And one thing that we try to do now in our current configuration is to allow, we don't
[1:27:52] park up front and we allow our customers to have access to City Hall.
[1:27:57] We carry that same philosophy forward so that when our community members come in and
[1:28:01] utilize the services that we offer that they don't have to park three blocks away because
[1:28:06] we're up front.
[1:28:08] Just one other question.
[1:28:09] I don't even know.
[1:28:10] Is there a back street access right off of that parking lot into the key building or do they
[1:28:14] have to go around front or outside?
[1:28:16] Yeah.
[1:28:17] Are they doing that in front?
[1:28:20] I don't know.
[1:28:22] I still like the idea of keeping the drive up open, but Travis was resistant to that.
[1:28:27] I will say that I was resistant to this idea of actually leasing another building because
[1:28:33] It's additional cost of the cities to the city and just go one building at a time.
[1:28:40] But I've been fairly well converted by Travis to think that the synergy,
[1:28:44] as you say, both buildings at the same time really makes sense.
[1:28:49] I'm still, I'm a convert, but not a real strong one yet.
[1:28:53] One of the things that really convinced me was just the conversation with our CMGC,
[1:28:58] Star Corporation, when they started talking about the additional costs that would really,
[1:29:02] Also, yes, we will pay for the lease, but at the end of the day, I think it actually will save us money because of their concern and the additional time that really we can shave six months off the projects.
[1:29:14] I'm hoping that we recoup those cost savings. I can't guarantee that, but that's our hope.
[1:29:20] You're getting me closer.
[1:29:23] So the only comment I would make is perhaps a little nitpicky, but the lease agreement does refer to it as 103 Main Street,
[1:29:31] And that is actually 103 main avenue east east, okay.
[1:29:36] And so I realize it has a legal description of the property as well, and
[1:29:41] it's not like we don't know what property it is, but it is main avenue.
[1:29:48] Don't know.
[1:29:49] One last question, generally the mayor signs official documents.
[1:29:54] Is this a codified thing that's, I asked you, I don't know if Mitch knows or
[1:30:00] our esteemed attorney with us is this something different because it's a lease
[1:30:06] issue I'm just curious so there there are agents of the city that can
[1:30:13] obligate the city to spend money and and we've defined those in our code
[1:30:17] actually it's essentially the senior staff city manager so this is not all
[1:30:23] that different from us going and buying goods and services to get the store so
[1:30:29] So we're obligating the city to spend money on the lease, and Travis can do that, or the
[1:30:33] mayor can do that, or Brian or I can do that, or Lori can do that, there's several that can
[1:30:38] do that.
[1:30:39] And so I'm not sure why this was drafted with Travis' signature instead of the mayor's signature,
[1:30:44] but either way, either can obligate that.
[1:30:48] Okay.
[1:30:49] Makes sense.
[1:30:50] Just curious.
[1:30:51] But we do want to get the council's consent before we move forward either way.
[1:30:56] Just talking.
[1:30:57] So if we do execute the lease tonight, how soon might we start moving out of Bull City
[1:31:03] Hall to in there?
[1:31:04] I think what we're looking at is the lease is effective first in April and we're probably
[1:31:09] looking at the mid-month move.
[1:31:11] We would like to be in place no later than the first of May so that work can begin in
[1:31:16] City Hall.
[1:31:17] So we're thinking about mid-April.
[1:31:19] Given that, I would move to authorize the execution, signing an execution of the lease agreement
[1:31:24] of a property located one of three main street east.
[1:31:27] So the second, the described terms.
[1:31:30] Motion by Chris Togington, seconded by Greg Lanting
[1:31:33] to authorize the lease.
[1:31:36] Don Hall?
[1:31:37] I see that we have a motion on the floor,
[1:31:39] but and I know this isn't a public hearing,
[1:31:42] but we do have at least one member of the public
[1:31:44] that would like to address council on this.
[1:31:46] If you'd like to come forward, sir,
[1:31:47] you're more than welcome to give us your comments.
[1:31:59] [Muted for privacy: street address]
[1:32:00] [Muted for privacy: street address]
[1:32:06] [Muted for privacy: street address]
[1:32:10] to say would cost.
[1:32:12] According to what was in the paper, something like $8,000
[1:32:18] a month, and going from April this year until September
[1:32:24] next year, which is my Twin Falls school
[1:32:29] Figuring is 17 months and since Miss Pierce is a
[1:32:36] account she probably already got a figure here. Yeah, but to my rough figures, that's 136 thousand dollars and
[1:32:47] They said there's no remodeling but I guarantee you there would be some additional money for remodeling
[1:32:53] the moving expenses and
[1:32:56] and etc. And I think I bet we're looking at close to $200,000. By the time it's
[1:33:05] said I might be wrong, I hope I am, but you're going to be looking probably close
[1:33:11] to $200,000 to move into that bank. What was the price of the bank that we could
[1:33:17] have bought a year ago and been in it and going? And now we're going to demolish
[1:33:24] the building that who knows what's in there. I don't care what kind of engineers you've got,
[1:33:31] but it gives me just a few people. But there's gonna be things in that old building
[1:33:37] that's too late now that they're gonna find things that's gonna cost more
[1:33:42] by the time you get that building remodeled than if they were to buy that bank building to begin with.
[1:33:48] Anyway, that's all why can't I just with Mr. Hall on this that why can't the
[1:33:57] police stay in the building they're in they've been in it for 15 years what's
[1:34:02] another six eight months gonna do and I'm gonna save us over $200,000 and if
[1:34:08] they're gonna it's gonna cost us additional $200,000 to remodel that
[1:34:14] building. I don't know. But anyway, that's a senior citizen, taxpayers, president of the city. That's my
[1:34:26] idea and I'd encourage you to start thinking about that before you say, yeah, here, go do it. I think
[1:34:33] we had to really think about it before you do it. Thank you so much. Thanks, sir. Chris talking to
[1:34:40] Pete, I really appreciate your input with what we need to hear from the people other feet on the
[1:34:45] ground and we're accused of being stargazers at time, but we have spent about the last
[1:34:51] six to eight months of the most economical way to make this transition that we're talking
[1:34:56] about. And it's some big dollars, there's no doubt about it. A year's lease at $8,096,000,
[1:35:03] but we're thinking we can save that money over doing a piecemeal and moving back and
[1:35:08] forth. And if we're wrong, I'll be the first to admit it and buy a cup of coffee in apology.
[1:35:14] I would not agree to this lease if I didn't think we're not going to be money ahead.
[1:35:19] I know you've got something to do with that.
[1:35:23] Okay.
[1:35:24] That's my, you know.
[1:35:26] Thank you.
[1:35:27] Let me appreciate it.
[1:35:28] Thank you.
[1:35:34] Maybe just a little follow-up, you know, the lease is $8,000 a month, that includes utilities.
[1:35:40] And believe it or not, that's actually a blow market negotiation, that building lease for
[1:35:44] more than that.
[1:35:48] And it is a lot of money and I would just reiterate, we've looked at this, we believe
[1:35:53] at the end of the day, there's actually some cost savings.
[1:35:56] I know it's hard to kind of see that sometimes when we're talking about spending this kind
[1:36:00] of money.
[1:36:01] But we're working with our CMGC, Star Corporation and Hommel, we think this is the right way
[1:36:07] for it.
[1:36:08] Thank you, Brian.
[1:36:10] Suzanne Hawkins.
[1:36:11] Thank you.
[1:36:12] Brian, maybe you can confirm or deny my thoughts on this.
[1:36:15] I believe when we started this process and worked on our budget for the entire project,
[1:36:20] we did include the money for a lease in case we went that direction so this money was already
[1:36:25] included in the overall picture, is that correct?
[1:36:27] That's correct.
[1:36:28] That's correct.
[1:36:29] We had money for relocation.
[1:36:32] Thank you.
[1:36:33] But also in all fairness, when we were looking at numbers, we did step back from it and say,
[1:36:38] okay, maybe, you know, and we looked at it and thought, well, maybe there's, maybe we
[1:36:43] We could save some money, but at the end of the day, what we're finding out is that we
[1:36:48] extending that time by six months and not having the opportunity to utilize multiple bids and
[1:36:55] contracts could actually cost us.
[1:36:58] Don Hall?
[1:36:59] Could you, Pete, mention that he believes there could be some remodeling costs that we will
[1:37:05] have to extend for that building?
[1:37:07] Is that correct?
[1:37:09] We're not looking at any remodeling costs.
[1:37:10] We have some costs associated with some dividers,
[1:37:14] just so that we can divide spaces for work.
[1:37:18] We're trying to find the best price
[1:37:20] that we can't actually humble,
[1:37:21] and Boise's been working with a business up there.
[1:37:23] We think we have a good price.
[1:37:25] There'll be some additional costs,
[1:37:26] but no remodeling of that building.
[1:37:28] There will be some moving expenses,
[1:37:29] I'm not sure what that looks like,
[1:37:31] but we're mindful of those as we move forward.
[1:37:34] There's gonna be some fiber moved in that direction,
[1:37:37] but that sounds like that's something we need to do anyway.
[1:37:40] Right, that's part of the bigger picture of downtown.
[1:37:44] And again, I had the same concerns, Pete.
[1:37:47] The other concern that I had as well is that we're,
[1:37:50] the public is now going to City Hall,
[1:37:52] now they're going to go to a temporary City Hall,
[1:37:54] and then to another City Hall,
[1:37:55] and there's gonna be some transition there,
[1:37:57] but I believe that we can overcome that
[1:37:59] with community education,
[1:38:01] and our PIO can do a good job in that respect.
[1:38:03] Again, I was, I'm a recent convert.
[1:38:06] It took me a while, Pete, to get there,
[1:38:09] But I have assurance that we'll probably end up being money ahead doing this.
[1:38:13] Any other discussion from the council?
[1:38:16] Seeing none, Sharon, roll call vote please.
[1:38:20] Chris Talkington?
[1:38:23] Aye.
[1:38:24] Greg Lanting?
[1:38:25] Yes.
[1:38:26] Don Hall? Yes.
[1:38:27] Ruth Pierce? Yes.
[1:38:28] Suzanne Hawkins? Yes.
[1:38:30] Nicky Boyd? Yes.
[1:38:32] John Barricker? Yes.
[1:38:34] Motion passes 7-2-0.
[1:38:37] The next item on the agenda is public input, is there anyone from the public who would like to address the council on any other issues this evening?
[1:38:49] Seeing none, any items from the Deputy City Managers?
[1:38:56] Hi, I think we're good.
[1:38:59] City Council, done well.
[1:39:02] I just want to mention Bill, the shortest discussion item on our agenda was the longest discussion item on our agenda, so good job.
[1:39:10] And it was a lot of garbage going on.
[1:39:13] It was a ton of garbage.
[1:39:15] Good one, Chris.
[1:39:17] Greg Lanting.
[1:39:19] I know that we received information from our city manager that we, as was the idea I presented
[1:39:25] last year to allow city council members to opt into our insurance program and pay for it themselves.
[1:39:33] I'm not asking that the city pay for the insurance that they're going to be still checking with
[1:39:41] the underwriters with our insurance to see whether or not it would increase our premium for the
[1:39:47] city.
[1:39:48] Certainly, I don't want to do that.
[1:39:49] Chris asked that we find out what other cities in the state do that are of similar size and
[1:39:58] so I took it upon myself to contact.
[1:40:00] I didn't contact Boise because I figured they were so much bigger and that's it really wouldn't
[1:40:03] matter, but I contacted everyone else anywhere close to our size and with the
[1:40:08] exception of Lewiston, all of the other cities actually provide insurance for their
[1:40:14] council members and the response I got most often was well at what level and they
[1:40:20] say whatever employees of the city get. So another if the employees of the city
[1:40:25] get individual and a portion of the family that's what they provide if the
[1:40:31] If the city provides full family, which is what court lane does
[1:40:35] That's what they provide. So that was the one found with exception of
[1:40:41] Lewiston, which is one of our sister cities as a city manager former government
[1:40:46] They do not provide it as of right now
[1:40:48] But since they have already started their budget discussions
[1:40:52] It's actually on the docket to actually for them to provide for their
[1:40:57] their council members in this coming budget and as
[1:41:01] in their discussion whether they'll get that far.
[1:41:04] So that was the information I found.
[1:41:06] So it all changes anyone's mind.
[1:41:09] They get the same as full-time employees.
[1:41:12] On every city I contacted.
[1:41:15] And so including like Puerto Aime, I said,
[1:41:17] they get full family medical, dental, and vision
[1:41:21] for their council members.
[1:41:23] And almost all of them, I didn't check salaries on all of them.
[1:41:27] Most of the salary actually were comparable
[1:41:30] for us ever some more, some less, so it's pretty pretty pretty common. Again, I'm making sure no one's
[1:41:36] thinking I'm not asking that council members be covered. That's not all I'm asking for. I'm asking
[1:41:41] that council members have the option if they choose to pay for themselves and join the city's
[1:41:49] group health care plan. And I don't think I probably have changed anybody's mind including my
[1:41:55] my gentleman to my left.
[1:41:57] I have not, but Chris had asked for the information,
[1:42:00] so I decided I would find out.
[1:42:04] Susan Hawkins.
[1:42:05] Thank you.
[1:42:06] So I haven't had a meeting with youth council since last week,
[1:42:10] but I did contact AIC in the cost for youth
[1:42:13] to attend the conference's $295 per student.
[1:42:18] And I would still assume that probably four or five
[1:42:21] would be my plus housing.
[1:42:24] No, that's everything.
[1:42:25] it includes everything. That's the work. And I do have a chaperone lined up forum
[1:42:29] and we do have transportation costs already covered.
[1:42:32] It's not a bad deal then for all the meals and feeding teenagers.
[1:42:40] They put them up in Boise State don't they?
[1:42:43] And you said you had transportation lined up through that? Yes.
[1:42:47] So is there a looming deadline for those registrations? Oh, we have two months.
[1:42:52] Okay. Just getting things moving. All right. Thank you.
[1:42:56] Well, you know, I, I could speak. I've been involved, have been involved in the past and
[1:43:02] the American Legion or a historical contest for boys and girls state. And we found over a number
[1:43:08] of years that some sort of internal competition are often working work better than having a
[1:43:15] particular year, a number of businesses supporting the, an unlimited number is better to have a
[1:43:21] a more predictable number. And if you say it's four or five, I'm more
[1:43:26] comfortable than I got the idea at the time that I might be it does. I
[1:43:30] can't support that. But if we if we want to send three, four or five
[1:43:35] people that are either office holders or going to demonstrate some ability to
[1:43:40] show us what they learn, I'd like to ask some feedback on what we're going to
[1:43:44] invest. It doesn't sound bad.
[1:43:46] I think that half makes it limits the number pretty effectively.
[1:43:52] We just have a pay in half to limit the number just on its own.
[1:43:59] Okay. Any other items from the council?
[1:44:06] Sean. Mayor. Don't I have a back.
[1:44:09] Could you hold the meeting?
[1:44:13] I got four minutes to stop.
[1:44:17] I just reminded that I do have some information to share with the council and hopefully the
[1:44:23] viewing public at large. The city is going to be closed on Wednesday. We're going to
[1:44:28] have some citywide training going on and so I just want to get that out there and we're
[1:44:33] going to issue some press releases to kind of let the public know we've already talked
[1:44:36] to our press partners and so they know what's going on and hopefully they're going to help
[1:44:40] get the word out as well. So we'll have essential services up and going. But for the most part,
[1:44:48] I think we have 253 employees signed up for this training. So out of a 270 something currently
[1:44:58] filled slots of employees, that's a pretty good turnout. So we're excited about it, but
[1:45:02] we are going to be not available for regular everyday kind of duties.
[1:45:08] Thank you.
[1:45:09] Seeing no other items, the meeting is adjourned.
