Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2016-01-25, recording 1 (started 17:00)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2016-01-25/

[0:00:00] If anybody would like to join us, please rise and we will start with the Pledge of Allegiance.
[0:00:04] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
[0:00:20] Thank you and again welcome tonight.
[0:00:29] First of all, I would like to confirm that we do have a quorum of the council.
[0:00:33] We have two members that were unable to be here tonight, but with five we're good to keep going on, so we will.
[0:00:38] So we will.
[0:00:40] Travis, do we have any amendments to the agenda for tonight?
[0:00:44] Madam Vice Mayor, members of the council,
[0:00:46] there are no amendments to tonight's agenda.
[0:00:49] Thank you.
[0:00:53] We have no proclamations.
[0:00:54] So we are going to move on to general public input.
[0:00:58] Is there anybody from the public that has any business
[0:01:01] that's not on our agenda tonight
[0:01:02] that you would like to bring to our attention?
[0:01:08] All right.
[0:01:08] See none, we will move on.
[0:01:10] And we are to the consent calendar.
[0:01:12] I would take Council wishes.
[0:01:17] Greg Lanting.
[0:01:21] Second.
[0:01:23] We have a motion from Greg Lanting,
[0:01:25] seconded by Ruth Pierce.
[0:01:27] Is there any discussion on that?
[0:01:30] Sharon, roll call vote.
[0:01:33] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:01:34] Yes.
[0:01:35] Nikki Boyd.
[0:01:36] Yes.
[0:01:37] Chris Hockington.
[0:01:38] Yes.
[0:01:38] Greg Lanting.
[0:01:40] Ruth Pierce.
[0:01:41] Yes.
[0:01:42] Motion passes five to zero.
[0:01:45] And now we will move on to items for consideration.
[0:01:48] And the first item on our agenda tonight is the swearing-in ceremony for
[0:01:52] returning to and falls police department officer, Steven Gasser.
[0:01:56] And with that, welcome to our new chief, Chief Kingsbury, thank you.
[0:02:01] Thank you, Madam Vice Mayor and members of the council.
[0:02:06] It is my honor tonight to be standing before you for
[0:02:09] my first time as the Chief of Police in this fine city to swear in an officer.
[0:02:16] This is in our profession, a very big deal when an author takes an oath of office.
[0:02:24] It is something that not every profession does.
[0:02:29] When I was sworn in here just a little over a month ago, I spoke about how in this profession
[0:02:37] with this uniform that we wear, we represent three different things.
[0:02:42] And just to go over that briefly.
[0:02:45] The first item that we represent in our uniform is the City of Twin Falls with the patch that
[0:02:52] we wear on both of our shoulders.
[0:02:55] We also represent our family name with the name tag that we wear above our right breast.
[0:03:03] And then finally, we represent the profession with the shield and the shield that here just
[0:03:09] momentarily I will be pinning on Officer Steven Gasser.
[0:03:14] Now some of you may remember Officer Gassert, because he's coming back for more.
[0:03:21] Stephen Gassert was initially hired by the Twin Falls Police Department on March 24, 2008.
[0:03:26] He was born here in Twin Falls and graduated from Twin Falls High School.
[0:03:30] Stephen went on to attend the CSI law enforcement program and graduated in 2006 with his technical
[0:03:36] certificate.
[0:03:38] Stephen began to pursue his law enforcement career in 2002 when he joined the Twin Falls
[0:03:43] Police Department Explorer program. He participated in the program for six
[0:03:47] years logging in over 10,000 right along in volunteer hours prior to being hired
[0:03:52] full-time in 2008. During his tenure with the Twin Falls Police Department Steven
[0:03:57] served as a patrol officer and a school resource officer assigned to the
[0:04:01] juvenile crime unit. Steven had an active involvement in bully prevention
[0:04:05] education and programs in the schools. Steven has always had an interest in
[0:04:09] mentoring juveniles that have a drug problem in assisting them in getting off
[0:04:12] and staying off of drugs. In his off time, Stephen enjoys volunteering at Camp Rainbow
[0:04:18] Gold, a program for Idaho youth diagnosed with cancer, and he served as one of their
[0:04:24] camp directors. In June of 2015, he was given a full-time job opportunity to work with Rainbow
[0:04:30] Gold as a program director. Stephen accepted the position. After six months of employment,
[0:04:37] Stephen found that he missed his law enforcement career here at the Twin Falls Police Department,
[0:04:41] And he returned to the department in a full-time capacity on January 11th of this year.
[0:04:47] Stephen was awarded his basic certificate from the Agri-Stig Peace Officer Standards and Training
[0:04:51] Council on April 8, 2009 as Intermediate Certificate on April 10th, 2014.
[0:04:59] Officer Gasser, if I could have you rise, and before we get to this part, would you introduce
[0:05:05] your family members that you have here with you?
[0:05:08] I have my father and my gasser, my mother.
[0:05:13] Thank you. As we all know, in this profession, having your family behind you is very, very
[0:05:19] important. So I'd like to thank you for attending this very important.
[0:05:24] Only swear.
[0:06:02] Only swear.
[0:06:03] The support of the United States of America.
[0:06:07] Also the support of the Constitution of the United States of America.
[0:06:10] And the Constitution and laws of the State of Idaho.
[0:06:13] The Constitution and the laws of the State of Idaho.
[0:06:16] And the laws and ordinances of the State of Idaho.
[0:06:20] law is in accordance into the City of Twin Falls.
[0:06:22] And the rules and regulations of the Twin Falls City Police Department.
[0:06:26] And the rules and regulations of the Twin Falls City Police Department.
[0:06:30] And that I will properly and faithfully discharge.
[0:06:34] I will properly and faithfully discharge.
[0:06:36] The duties of the office of police officers.
[0:06:40] The duties of the office of police officers.
[0:06:42] Twin Falls Police Department.
[0:06:43] Twin Falls Police Department.
[0:06:45] To which I have been appointed.
[0:06:46] To which I have been appointed.
[0:06:48] According to the law, it's the best of my ability.
[0:06:51] According to the law and the best of my ability.
[0:06:53] Okay, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you.
[0:07:02] Congratulations.
[0:07:04] I think we still have four, five, eight,
[0:07:11] and so you can please.
[0:07:39] Well, in case everybody didn't here, welcome back.
[0:07:41] We're excited to have you as back part of the team.
[0:07:43] At this time, we're gonna take about a 60 second break
[0:07:46] in case anybody involved in this ceremony
[0:07:48] would like to leave you or not require
[0:07:50] to stay from the rest of the council meeting.
[0:07:52] You are welcome to stay.
[0:07:53] We don't have to.
[0:07:55] You've got to stay in Lanny.
[0:07:56] It's less fun.
[0:07:57] I think we need to get some extra.
[0:08:00] We need a corner.
[0:08:01] That way maybe they'll stick around.
[0:08:03] Nancy, you just lost half your audience.
[0:08:14] We're all here to listen.
[0:08:16] But they had your cookies first.
[0:08:18] So they're good.
[0:08:19] Yeah.
[0:08:23] Okay.
[0:08:24] Thank you to everyone who's staying with us for the night.
[0:08:26] So the next item on for consideration is a presentation of an update on the
[0:08:31] on the Rodgerson Hotel Recovery Project, and we have Nancy Taylor with our historic preservation
[0:08:37] committee. Welcome, Nancy.
[0:08:40] Thank you, Vice Mayor and Council. I'm happy to be here. I am Nancy Taylor. I'm Chair of
[0:08:46] the City's Historic Preservation Commission, and this presentation will be a light-hearted
[0:08:50] look at what our team has accomplished in the Rodgerson.
[0:08:53] Do you want to introduce some of your team?
[0:08:56] Oh, yes, I'm sorry.
[0:08:58] Oh, Julia Oxerengo Ingram, as part of our team
[0:09:03] and Michelle Matthews, of course, of the county HPC.
[0:09:09] Just as a brief background, in August of last year,
[0:09:13] I approached Melinda Anderson, who, as you know,
[0:09:16] was executive director of the RA for permission
[0:09:19] for a team of qualified historians, salvage experts,
[0:09:23] and a contractor to salvage historic items and recycle
[0:09:26] material from the building.
[0:09:29] This team was not, they were volunteers,
[0:09:32] but they are professional in their field
[0:09:34] and they volunteered for this work.
[0:09:36] With the support and encouragement of then Mayor Don Hall,
[0:09:40] Council Member Jim Munn, I should say,
[0:09:42] then Council Member Jim Munn, City Manager Travis
[0:09:46] and Melinda, we began work in September.
[0:09:51] The team rescued many historical items
[0:09:53] and salvaged important materials for reuse
[0:09:56] and other historic buildings in and around Magic Valley
[0:09:59] and possibly the state.
[0:10:02] Work was completed in December
[0:10:04] and rescued salvage items are being stored
[0:10:07] in the warehouse district of Twin Falls.
[0:10:13] Our rules to buy buy is the historic items,
[0:10:18] the city and county HPCs will determine and document
[0:10:22] and donate these to the county museum
[0:10:24] occurring crossing, which Michelle is a board member of.
[0:10:30] Historic items not chosen by the county
[0:10:33] will remain with our city's HPC for future use
[0:10:36] and or educational purposes if we ever design a museum here
[0:10:42] or we want to use them at schools and whatnot.
[0:10:46] The rest of the material, not of historic value,
[0:10:49] will remain in a repository under the umbrella
[0:10:52] of a 501c3 and that is to be determined
[0:10:56] and we're looking at several organizations
[0:11:00] that may want to umbrella us under there,
[0:11:04] and a board of directors to be determined
[0:11:07] for future use in the restoration of historic properties.
[0:11:10] The city will be notified when the appropriate groups are formed.
[0:11:14] We will let you know under what umbrella that is
[0:11:17] and who the board of directors will be.
[0:11:22] Now for the fun stuff.
[0:11:25] We did, later in my presentation, I made this statement,
[0:11:32] But I'm going to say it now that for historians,
[0:11:34] this is like Christmas morning.
[0:11:37] We found so many wonderful things.
[0:11:39] You can see on the left the fine dining room,
[0:11:42] which was Ty very fancy for Twin Falls.
[0:11:49] And if you see the columns in the middle of the room,
[0:11:53] but facing the wall, you can see we uncovered
[0:11:58] those particular columns that were there
[0:12:01] and covered up by recent modifications.
[0:12:07] Obviously, we couldn't save the column itself,
[0:12:09] but we did take down some of the best relief plaster
[0:12:14] that was part of the columns, and we do have that in storage.
[0:12:19] You can see that wonderful piano in the middle of the room.
[0:12:26] We also rescued a fire hose in the original casing.
[0:12:30] The inspection tag reads 1946.
[0:12:34] This was encased on the second floor, and for those of you interested, in 1965,
[0:12:41] a raging fire destroyed the third floor of the hotel, which was removed, obviously.
[0:12:48] And we obviously know this fire hose wasn't used in the rescue
[0:12:54] because it still reads 1946.
[0:12:57] And I have a feeling it was pretty rangy to attend with, and I don't know
[0:13:02] if it would have helped the fire at all.
[0:13:04] But we do have that in storage and we have cattle like that.
[0:13:10] The pine room, the infamous pine room in the basement
[0:13:14] was thought to be the site of many illicit poker games
[0:13:17] and drinking during prohibition.
[0:13:21] The knotty pine panels and the door have been recovered.
[0:13:25] The panels, the knotty pine panels are,
[0:13:28] they're not the panels that your father
[0:13:30] tacked up over the weekend in the basement.
[0:13:33] They're beautiful panels, and we hope to reuse those
[0:13:36] in another historic property somewhere.
[0:13:39] The pine room door has been saved with its original sign,
[0:13:44] and it was a real experience.
[0:13:47] We did a paranormal investigation of the hotel,
[0:13:49] which I don't have the tapes yet,
[0:13:51] but that room was a site of a lot of activity.
[0:13:54] And had I not been there, I would not have believed
[0:13:57] what happened, but there's some men living there.
[0:14:02] Their energy is there, let's say.
[0:14:04] And they evidently had a great time.
[0:14:10] The Rogerson Coffee Shop menu and some of the waitress tickets
[0:14:16] that we recovered.
[0:14:18] And I am going to now come, may I approach the bench?
[0:14:21] You begin.
[0:14:24] Here are some of the covered piece, hand, and light.
[0:14:31] So how old do you think they are, Nancy?
[0:14:38] They're all from a waitress named Gloria,
[0:14:40] we think who hid them for some reason but you'll notice some of the prices
[0:14:45] coffee ten cents sandwich dollar twenty five but we do have though obviously
[0:14:53] those in our possession this right in the fall but it was four bucks yeah some
[0:15:00] high rollers there at the restaurant here's the original interior with the
[0:15:07] skylight as you can see and due to all the remodels you can see on the right how
[0:15:12] it looked when we went into the building the banister has been salvaged but you
[0:15:18] can see the skylight has been kind of dissipated the stairwell is there you can
[0:15:25] see the stairs on the left excuse me going up that came up from that banister
[0:15:31] on the right the the frames around the doors and windows you see are not
[0:15:37] original to the hotel, but they were actually quite nice and they were salvaged
[0:15:42] too because they had some wonderful detail to them. This is our team. Like I said, we
[0:15:53] had professionals and I need to tell you that they worked very, very hard. The
[0:15:58] physical work alone was astounding. We had some volunteers from the LDS Church,
[0:16:05] some young bucks that came in and helped us carry out a lot of the heavy
[0:16:08] material and the left-hand photo is Carolyn Gaines. She was our general contractor under
[0:16:16] the umbrella of her insurance. Brett Simple, who is the owner of the historic building where
[0:16:23] the salvage material is located now. Myself, Julia, whom you just met, is Executive Director
[0:16:31] of the Southern Idaho Rural Economic Development. And Tom Gilbertson, I think you all know Tom,
[0:16:38] He was our historian and photographer, and Michelle Matthews, as you know, is our history
[0:16:44] expert and will help us decide what goes to the museum and what stays with us.
[0:16:51] So I want to thank them very much for their help.
[0:16:53] They were just, we just had a wonderful team, and they're very tired.
[0:17:01] Just briefly, I want to thank the city for allowing our team this opportunity to save a
[0:17:06] small part of our heritage and there's a picture of the
[0:17:10] Rogerson judging by the cars what do you think that's probably in
[0:17:13] the 20s or 30s for historians like I said this was like
[0:17:17] Christmas morning we just had a ball we hope this sets a precedent
[0:17:22] for future recovery product projects that we can help you
[0:17:26] within the city I need to tell you we're passionate about what we
[0:17:30] do and we stand ready to help with any other especially with
[0:17:34] downtown redevelopment coming on board, there may be some buildings we would like to get in
[0:17:39] and save what we can. I also, from the original Roderson Cafe, made the original Roderson restaurant
[0:17:56] oatmeal cookies. And I have the recipe right here, if anybody wants it, if they were a project,
[0:18:02] let me tell you. But I will leave these here for anyone who would like one. I will leave
[0:18:07] the recipe also and once again we thank you very much the City of Twin Falls for
[0:18:13] your support in this project. Nancy that's not the original meal though I hope.
[0:18:18] Oh it's not.
[0:18:21] Oh it's not.
[0:18:23] Well, we'll lock in there. Mitch won't eat one. Travis ate one.
[0:18:27] Sure they are. Any questions I can answer? Chris talking to? At two points number one
[0:18:35] and I had invited one of the restaurants co-managing,
[0:18:41] when I was saying it was owned by the Hoops family,
[0:18:43] the building, but Ted Smith and Ben modern,
[0:18:47] ran the restaurant and the hotel for,
[0:18:49] I have no idea how many decades.
[0:18:50] We had photos of them based on time,
[0:18:52] I couldn't show you everything we saw.
[0:18:54] Ed Smith and I went through high school together
[0:18:56] and I invited him to take a last tour
[0:18:58] through the building before it was demoed.
[0:19:01] And he says, you know, I spent a lot of time
[0:19:03] that basement running errands for my family and I was always scared as could be of that
[0:19:08] place. It was spooky and I told him about your inference about the energy down there is energy
[0:19:16] down there and I told you had I not been there I would and Michelle was there during the
[0:19:21] investigation. Anyway he wanted nothing to do with the last walk through the building. The
[0:19:24] other thing my grandmother was cashier and concierge there for probably 20 or 30 years
[0:19:30] and her job was to take the receipts for the day and drop them off the bank.
[0:19:37] And it was sometime in the 70s before it came back to the military.
[0:19:41] She was actually held up in Main Street, a little old 70-year-old lady tottering around
[0:19:45] with the day's receipts.
[0:19:48] And when she was asked what she said, she said, oh my, I didn't think anything else to say.
[0:19:53] Oh my.
[0:19:54] You know, in the basement, there's still what they called the vault room, which was where
[0:19:59] There are valuables and money was obviously held and it still has the heavy, heavy steel
[0:20:08] casing of the door and everything.
[0:20:10] I don't think we got that out.
[0:20:14] Yeah, but it was just too much to try to get out.
[0:20:22] Yes, as I said, the paranormal investigation, you can believe or you can't believe, but there's
[0:20:30] a lot of energy in that old building.
[0:20:34] Thank you, Chris.
[0:20:35] Ruth Pierce?
[0:20:36] I just wanted to say Nancy and I have a pleasure serving with Nancy on the historic preservation
[0:20:42] commission and she really pushed this project and she worked very hard.
[0:20:47] And I don't believe that the Times News gave her enough credit for as much hard work as
[0:20:52] she did.
[0:20:54] I have a friend who actually had a shop in the Rogerson and she said absolutely there's
[0:21:01] energy there.
[0:21:02] Yeah, but I wanted to thank you and your committee for all your hard work
[0:21:06] We're wondering when the building comes down where where is this energy gonna go?
[0:21:10] They'll probably come down to my building. Yeah, I'm not really excited about that
[0:21:15] Like they cross the street at the city hall
[0:21:23] Anyway, it was a it was a fun project and we look forward to doing more with with the city and doing what we can to help our
[0:21:30] save our heritage here thanks for all your hard work thank you thank you Greg
[0:21:35] Lantee yeah Nancy again thank you for for doing this and I've been thank you for
[0:21:42] your service on this first presentation then I have one Erin for you would you
[0:21:46] give this check to Julie I promised her a check for the Rogers in school project
[0:21:50] a long time ago and I first time I've had an opportunity to give it to her
[0:21:54] And she is also involved in the buildings at the
[0:21:57] building.
[0:21:58] Can I interrupt you to have you come to the microphone?
[0:22:10] I'm sorry.
[0:22:11] We're aired live and it's recorded.
[0:22:13] Thank you.
[0:22:14] Sorry.
[0:22:15] So we are working on the historic Rogersons school in the
[0:22:19] community of Rogersons and the same people were part of
[0:22:23] establishing that community.
[0:22:25] community. So we thought this was a great tie-in. That's kind of what started the
[0:22:29] whole ball rolling. And so we hope to use some more glass from the building and some
[0:22:34] other things to get all of the windows replaced in that building. And then some
[0:22:39] of the flooring that we got out of there and hopefully a few other things too.
[0:22:42] So thank you. And would you tell them what you're doing? What's they're gonna try to
[0:22:46] do with that building when you're done at a rutting? They would like it to be a
[0:22:50] community center again and there are a number of things. They don't really have a
[0:22:54] a place to have meetings for more than five or six people at a time there.
[0:22:59] They used to have dances there every weekend in the school, and so they'd like to start
[0:23:04] doing that again, get musicians out there and have events.
[0:23:09] By the way, if you haven't been out for their prime rib dinner on Friday nights, it's worth
[0:23:14] the trip out there on every Friday night.
[0:23:18] So they're starting to try to attract a little bit more attention there and have a place
[0:23:23] where they can do community business, have receptions, sell things occasionally, and also
[0:23:31] have a bit of a museum there telling the history of the community which was really substantial.
[0:23:36] I had no idea everything that was out there before.
[0:23:38] These have a Cadillac dealership that was right off the railroad, and I guess it was the
[0:23:45] largest place in the area where sheep would go out on the railroad track, so they would
[0:23:50] come from Nevada and all over the place there. So I'm learning a lot about the history of
[0:23:55] this area too and I feel like this projects like this are going to help us to renovate
[0:24:01] buildings like that. It could take them years to replace all the windows and if we can get
[0:24:06] the materials we may get it done in a year. So that's substantial.
[0:24:12] And my connection is my father went through a grade school at the Rogers School. So that's
[0:24:17] That's how I got Julia told me about it.
[0:24:20] So I give her a check for it to help out.
[0:24:25] Thank you very much.
[0:24:26] And just a few, Michelle Matthews is with the,
[0:24:30] obviously, you know, with the County Museum,
[0:24:32] and their museum will be the receptacle
[0:24:36] for a lot of the historic items we've got.
[0:24:40] And I do thank you very much for one of this opportunity
[0:24:44] to talk to you, but one thing I wanted to stress is,
[0:24:48] You know, the importance of these historic items and the ability
[0:24:53] that the county museum can hold this stuff,
[0:24:55] the county commissioners just gave us extra room down
[0:25:01] in the county west now.
[0:25:03] That's been our biggest struggle is limited space.
[0:25:07] And so now we have a whole bunch of good space for,
[0:25:12] especially for very delicate items and stuff.
[0:25:14] So we're very encouraged about that.
[0:25:16] One thing that, you know, people kind of have a, maybe have a hard time figuring out the salvage part of this.
[0:25:24] And for example, one place that something could have been used was a few years back, we had a large flood at the museum.
[0:25:33] And we are on the National Register of Historic Places, the building was built in 1914, and a bunch of the fine, you know,
[0:25:43] the hardwood floor was destroyed in this flood.
[0:25:46] And we, they very quickly came in and fixed it,
[0:25:50] but they fixed it with new materials,
[0:25:52] and it's not, you know, they did a great job,
[0:25:55] but it still looks like that.
[0:25:58] Had we had something like the hardwood floor
[0:26:03] that was salvaged from the Rogerson,
[0:26:06] we could have put that in there,
[0:26:07] and it would seamlessly, you know,
[0:26:10] still have the same appearance.
[0:26:13] So not that it did anything to the value
[0:26:17] of the building, but it still would have been very cool.
[0:26:19] So this is very nice that you're really setting a precedent
[0:26:24] here for future work.
[0:26:28] We, you know, there are many historic groups around.
[0:26:35] In prior years, prior to this project, a lot of the work,
[0:26:39] a lot of the groups operated not in, not so much in competition,
[0:26:45] but certainly isolated from each other.
[0:26:48] This truly is a new beginning for these groups where they can partner up and see the value
[0:26:55] of working together.
[0:26:56] We're all on the same page and we have the same goals and I hope this project is really
[0:27:01] going to push that point.
[0:27:03] So come see the museum.
[0:27:05] I'll give you a tour.
[0:27:08] Thank you.
[0:27:10] Thank you all three for coming and sharing with us tonight.
[0:27:12] We appreciate the update.
[0:27:14] Good luck and keep us in the loop as you continue on.
[0:27:20] So the next item on our list for consideration is a consideration of a request to amend Twin
[0:27:25] Falls City Code 6-2-3 Disorderly Conduct Houses.
[0:27:32] And I believe we have Lieutenant John Wilson with us this evening, welcome.
[0:27:37] Thank you Vice Mayor and City Council members.
[0:27:40] Just want to make sure you guys are reminding when we're done talking that I grab a couple
[0:27:44] of cookies before I, I already ate a couple.
[0:27:48] Somebody bring me back some milk.
[0:27:50] Hey, we're really good.
[0:27:55] Over the past several months, the Twin Falls Police Department staff has worked with our
[0:27:59] city attorney to help draft an amended city ordinance regarding disorderly conduct.
[0:28:05] This amended ordinance specifically addresses both public intoxication and public urination
[0:28:11] in addition to fighting in public and keeping a disorderly house.
[0:28:17] I'm assuming you've had an opportunity now to look at the proposed amendment and I guess
[0:28:23] that I'm here as well as for its wonderlet to answer any questions or address any concerns
[0:28:30] that you might have about that.
[0:28:33] I do want to point out that a number of our officers were active in proposing that we come
[0:28:42] up with this amendment amended ordinance because it fits so well in basically solving
[0:28:51] problems that we have in our community that we face on a fairly regular basis.
[0:28:57] Thank you. We have lights on, so we'll start with Chris talking to.
[0:29:01] Thank you. Appreciate the time. I do have one specific question. I can see the justifications
[0:29:08] we update 623D public urination.
[0:29:14] Does this refer only to public property
[0:29:18] or would it extend to private property
[0:29:21] where for instance, a urination act was witnessed
[0:29:25] by a neighbor?
[0:29:26] Certainly I imagine what we might come across here
[0:29:30] as people urinating in parking lots
[0:29:33] that are privately owned or maybe another person's yard.
[0:29:35] The way I read this, and for it can correct me if I'm wrong,
[0:29:38] is yeah, this would give us the ability
[0:29:41] to address that and charge this crime.
[0:29:43] But what about a person using their own property?
[0:29:47] And doing it in view of the public?
[0:29:50] Not knowingly, but let's say that I think the bigger question
[0:29:54] of person on their own property is still
[0:29:56] chargeable under violation of those ordinance.
[0:30:00] If it were witnessed or a complaint were made.
[0:30:04] where I read that, it looks like that could apply.
[0:30:08] Let me put it another way.
[0:30:09] As a guy in the middle of the summer
[0:30:11] on a beautiful moonlit night, I've been known to go out
[0:30:15] and look at the stars.
[0:30:16] OK.
[0:30:18] Wow.
[0:30:19] TMI.
[0:30:20] It's a guy thing.
[0:30:25] It must be.
[0:30:26] It's probably easier for guys, I understand,
[0:30:28] like you said there.
[0:30:31] We are free tonight.
[0:30:32] I guess it's that if you're on your own property,
[0:30:37] but people can see it as they walk or drive down the street
[0:30:42] that that could apply.
[0:30:46] Yes.
[0:30:47] I guess I should say thank you.
[0:30:51] That's what fences and bushes are for.
[0:30:53] My wife, thanks you.
[0:30:56] I'm afraid to go on with this, but great land teams.
[0:31:00] No, please.
[0:31:01] What about the golf course?
[0:31:03] Well, I'm a golfer, so I understand completely what you're saying, I just would say be careful
[0:31:13] because I think if somebody saw you and complained at the golf course that you could
[0:31:16] be subject to this ordinance, that's why I always golf with at least three other guys
[0:31:22] so they can make a circle around you.
[0:31:26] Okay, I'm going to change the line of questions in a moment, how's that?
[0:31:32] Okay.
[0:31:33] So as you know, Greg and I are involved closely with the Association of Idaho Cities, and one
[0:31:37] of the issues we've been watching and working with our state legislators is changing some
[0:31:42] of the penalties to lessen the court costs for the county as far as the different levels
[0:31:50] of charges.
[0:31:51] And I'm sorry, I'm not as up to speed as I probably should be.
[0:31:55] And so with the misdemeanor, this would be one that would not require a public defender or would it.
[0:32:03] What are we doing, I think Fritz knows where I'm going.
[0:32:06] Thank you.
[0:32:07] This is not an infraction.
[0:32:09] It's a misdemeanor and I'll tell you it's because the police department needs a tool to deal with people.
[0:32:17] And generally they're intoxicated but they engage in different kinds of conduct.
[0:32:21] And unless we have a, the primary purpose of this is unless we, under the existing ordinance,
[0:32:28] you have to have somebody say, my piece is disturbed, so we have a big fight and we know
[0:32:33] it's at three in the morning and it's an apartment complex, but we don't go out and search for
[0:32:39] somebody who said it really bothered me that there was a big fight out in the parking lot,
[0:32:42] but we received calls to dispatch about the fight and all that.
[0:32:46] So the primary purpose of this is to get away from the requirement that we bring in to
[0:32:50] court a person who says yes my piece was disturbed by this so the rest of this is
[0:32:57] a tool that our police department feels like it needs in order to when people
[0:33:02] it's almost always when people have had too much to drink it's a way to get him
[0:33:07] off the street and in the jail and tell the morning when they've sobered up
[0:33:11] because they know they don't have a tool like this that they're gonna be
[0:33:15] running into them another time later in the morning. Got it? Thank you. So we
[0:33:20] We could have done an infraction, but that's not going to help them because they just cite
[0:33:24] release and then they continue to have potentially the problem.
[0:33:28] I understand.
[0:33:29] Thank you very much.
[0:33:32] Any other comments?
[0:33:33] Okay.
[0:33:34] Before we go on real quick, Sharon, do you have an ordinance number in case we go forward
[0:33:38] with this tonight?
[0:33:40] Ordinance number 1956.
[0:33:42] Thank you very much.
[0:33:44] And Chris talking to you.
[0:33:45] I would move place ordinance 1956 on third and final by Kyle Hulumbic under suspension
[0:33:50] rules.
[0:33:51] All right, second that.
[0:33:54] All right, we have a motion by Chris Tockington,
[0:33:56] seconded by Ruth Pierce, to put ordinance number, I'm sorry,
[0:34:02] in 1956 onto third and final by title only.
[0:34:06] Is there any other discussion?
[0:34:09] Sharon Roll call vote please.
[0:34:13] Nicky Boyd?
[0:34:14] Yes.
[0:34:15] Chris Tockington?
[0:34:16] Yes.
[0:34:17] Greg Lanting?
[0:34:18] Yes.
[0:34:19] Ruth Pierce?
[0:34:20] Yes.
[0:34:21] And Suzanne Hopkins?
[0:34:22] Yes.
[0:34:23] Sharon, can you please read the title?
[0:34:29] Ordinance number 1956, an ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho,
[0:34:36] amending Twin Falls City Code 6-2-3 by the addition of other conduct constituting disorderly
[0:34:46] conduct.
[0:34:47] Be it ordained by the Mayor and the Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho, that's Twin
[0:34:53] in file city code 6-2-3 is amended as follows.
[0:35:00] Thank you.
[0:35:02] Greg Lanting.
[0:35:03] Move approval of ordinance 1956.
[0:35:09] Do we have a second?
[0:35:11] Second.
[0:35:13] Thank you.
[0:35:14] We have a motion by Greg Lanting, seconded by Nikki Boyd, to confirm the ordinance 1956.
[0:35:23] Is there any other discussion?
[0:35:26] Sharon, we'll call vote please.
[0:35:31] Yes.
[0:35:32] Yes.
[0:35:33] Greg Lanting.
[0:35:34] Yes.
[0:35:35] Ruth Pierce.
[0:35:36] Yes.
[0:35:37] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:35:38] Yes.
[0:35:39] Nikki Boyd.
[0:35:40] Yes.
[0:35:41] Both motions pass by zero.
[0:35:42] I'm sorry.
[0:35:43] I forgot to clarify that on the earlier motion.
[0:35:46] Thank you very much for your time.
[0:35:48] Thank you.
[0:35:49] Keep moving forward.
[0:35:55] The fourth item for consideration tonight is a request to
[0:35:58] approve changing the advisory function of the senior citizen advisory commission from the
[0:36:04] City Council to the office of the City Manager and I believe we have Brian Pike
[0:36:09] our Deputy City Manager leading on this one tonight. Thank you Madam Vice Mayor
[0:36:22] and members of the Council. Lieutenant Wilson is going to be a hard act to follow.
[0:36:27] Only from these two.
[0:36:30] I think Shane mentioned to me that maybe the energy from that building has already
[0:36:33] been released.
[0:36:35] I'm asking the city council to consider modifying the senior citizens advisory commission from
[0:36:42] a city council advisory group to a city manager advisory group.
[0:36:47] Before I get started, I think it's really important to understand the value of the group
[0:36:51] and the potential that exists in providing an opportunity and a mechanism for our senior
[0:36:56] citizens to engage their local governments and to continue to help shape the community that
[0:37:02] they really spent most of their lives in developing.
[0:37:06] To give you a little bit of history of how we got to this point,
[0:37:11] the senior citizens advisory commission was formed October 20, 2014
[0:37:17] by the creation of, actually created by Resolution 1934.
[0:37:22] And I believe there was an attachment in the resolution went out.
[0:37:26] And if you would take a look at this, some of the things that stood out
[0:37:31] as part of the structure that actually some of the things
[0:37:36] that we're dealing with, right, is it talks a little bit
[0:37:38] about the membership.
[0:37:40] So resolution 1934 says in order to be a member of the
[0:37:45] commission, you have to be 65 years or older, that you can't
[0:37:49] be employed by an organization providing services
[0:37:51] education or recreation to seniors, and then you can
[0:37:54] apply for membership.
[0:37:57] The officers of the commissioner elected from that
[0:38:00] and the resolution spells out how that takes place.
[0:38:03] My secret ballot and a number of other things.
[0:38:06] The meetings, because this is an advisory group to the City Council,
[0:38:10] have to comply with Idaho Public meetings law,
[0:38:12] which means that all of our meetings usually take place right here in the Council chambers.
[0:38:17] And if you've attended one of those meetings, you will see that it's really not conducive
[0:38:23] to the type of meeting that we're trying to conduct.
[0:38:25] Members, we have to be live.
[0:38:28] We have to be live, we have to record, the membership that does attend, they have to come forward speaking to the mic, and it has not worked very well for us, and really to date, I'm not really aware of any official membership.
[0:38:42] We have seniors that have attended on a regular basis and have tremendous ideas and really want to add value to the process, but really we haven't been able to in this kind of formal structure.
[0:38:55] structure. We haven't been able to move this commission forward. I think allowing the
[0:38:59] group to function as an advisory group to the city manager really allows for greater
[0:39:03] flexibility on part of the commission. This could mean that we could go to other locations
[0:39:08] in Twin Falls and have meetings that we could seek input out. We could go out and I think
[0:39:13] you know local government works best when we are actually engaged with the community
[0:39:17] that we represent. And I think this, if we change the role in kind of the structure of
[0:39:22] the commission, I think it gives us that greater flexibility.
[0:39:25] I believe it's a positive step forward, and I would ask the council to consider making
[0:39:29] the change.
[0:39:30] Chris, talking to.
[0:39:35] I'm supportive of this.
[0:39:37] I've been extremely disappointed with our efforts to represent one of the foundational
[0:39:45] demographics of our community, and we haven't been successful.
[0:39:49] This is the most difficult group I've ever worked with in the city.
[0:39:55] I can tell you from my days at cable and banking that there are many people in that 65 or above
[0:40:03] group in town that are not covered by senior citizen center, Neil on wheels, regular visits.
[0:40:13] There are many of them that are isolated, live alone.
[0:40:16] The city overcharges them for their garbage.
[0:40:19] They don't feel safe.
[0:40:21] The police don't have a registry of where some of them may need help, medical assistance.
[0:40:27] There's a lot more we can do and should be doing.
[0:40:30] We haven't been successful in the current status or framework.
[0:40:35] I don't know what the city manager can do, but I think we can't be less than successful
[0:40:41] than we have been, and as long as we understand that it's advisory or recommendations coming
[0:40:46] to the Council on any expenditures is still works
[0:40:49] through this regular city council process.
[0:40:52] But we have to do more for the important demographic
[0:40:56] that's underrepresented by our other coverage.
[0:40:59] So I'm all in favor of it.
[0:41:01] Thank you, Chris.
[0:41:02] I have other lights, but before I go on, I was going to see,
[0:41:05] I know we have Dave Moore in the audience
[0:41:07] and he has attended some of these meetings.
[0:41:08] And I was just going to put him on the spot for a minute
[0:41:11] and see if he'd come up and share his thoughts on it with us.
[0:41:15] Thank you, Dave.
[0:41:19] Thank you, ladies and gentlemen, as Suzanne indicated,
[0:41:22] I have attended a majority of the meetings.
[0:41:26] I believe that there is a great need for the seniors
[0:41:29] in this community to have an opportunity
[0:41:31] to provide input to the council,
[0:41:33] because you folks make the decisions
[0:41:35] that impact their day-to-day life.
[0:41:39] My frustration has been that we meet here,
[0:41:42] unfortunately, majority of the people that have shown up
[0:41:45] have been providers and not seniors.
[0:41:49] And I think that if we had the freedom,
[0:41:52] the liberty to move around the community,
[0:41:56] to go where the seniors are and solicit input from them,
[0:42:00] that we could then come back with viable information
[0:42:04] that could be presented to the council
[0:42:07] through proper channels, not doing anything in secret,
[0:42:10] not making any decisions, not doing anything
[0:42:13] that would violate the Sunshine Lost,
[0:42:16] but just giving the seniors a voice
[0:42:18] and an input into the city.
[0:42:20] I personally, as a senior, I'm closer to 70 than 65.
[0:42:27] I'm still quite mobile.
[0:42:29] I get around, well, I still drive, cook at home,
[0:42:34] wife and I are active in our community,
[0:42:36] and our church, for me, it's not an issue
[0:42:39] of needing the help, but the day is coming
[0:42:42] because my mother and my father lived in this town,
[0:42:45] and they had issues and they needed help.
[0:42:47] And when family couldn't provide it, it wasn't there.
[0:42:50] And there was no outlet for them to make their needs known
[0:42:57] for services that the city could provide.
[0:43:00] I'm strongly in favor of opening this up
[0:43:03] to a broader audience through changing it
[0:43:06] from a council commission to an advisory committee
[0:43:10] that would work with the city manager
[0:43:13] to bring our issues forward.
[0:43:15] Thank you.
[0:43:16] Thank you very much.
[0:43:17] Great, Lansing.
[0:43:18] I had my light on what Dave said everything I was going to say,
[0:43:20] so.
[0:43:21] There you go.
[0:43:22] I am going to take a moment and pass on a message
[0:43:25] from Councilman Hall.
[0:43:27] He was mayor when this group was formed,
[0:43:29] and he has been attending the meetings.
[0:43:31] And he just asked me to please share
[0:43:34] that he is very in support of changing this committee
[0:43:38] and giving the seniors the freedom they need to be successful with this.
[0:43:43] And so he wanted to make sure it went on record that he is supportive as well.
[0:43:48] Right.
[0:43:49] You know, one of the things I'd like to add is that I believe that we can get to a point
[0:43:52] where we can reach the point where the commission would make sense in its current structure.
[0:43:59] But I think that has to be directed and led by the seniors of our community.
[0:44:04] And I think we can get there, but I think what we need to do is we need to go back and
[0:44:08] the restructure just a little bit and has some flexibility to engage that group.
[0:44:13] Thank you.
[0:44:14] Great, Lanting?
[0:44:14] Do we need a different resolution or how are we handling it?
[0:44:20] I believe what we need to do is make a motion to resolve the resolution that is, and
[0:44:26] then a motion to turn it over to a manager's committee.
[0:44:30] We'll break back a written resolution for you, repealing this.
[0:44:33] We just need to find out if we make sure you guys want it more.
[0:44:38] So no motion needed tonight.
[0:44:43] We'll bring back the necessary paperwork for you.
[0:44:46] Hopefully next week.
[0:44:48] Thank you very much.
[0:44:49] Appreciate your time.
[0:44:51] Any other comments before we move on?
[0:44:55] All right, so the next item on our agenda tonight
[0:44:58] is a consideration of a request to approve
[0:45:01] the questions included in the National Citizen Survey.
[0:45:04] And we have our city manager, Travis Ruffweiler.
[0:46:14] So members of the city council, sorry
[0:46:16] for the technical difficulties.
[0:46:19] We're trying to continue to again illustrate the needs for new facilities.
[0:46:24] Doing a fine job.
[0:46:27] Thank you.
[0:46:28] I would promise that we won't experience those when we move into our new city hall facility.
[0:46:35] My luck tells me don't promise things that I can control.
[0:46:39] So we will certainly do our best to avoid those in the future.
[0:46:42] But tonight really is a conversation about launching our citizen survey and moving that forward.
[0:46:47] We want to spend a little bit of time communicating and talking about our citizen survey and how
[0:46:52] it's different, how our citizen survey is different, and how it's been different since
[0:46:56] we started the National Citizen Survey as part of our process.
[0:47:00] We also begin to use this as the beginning of our media announcement of ensuring that
[0:47:08] citizens recognize that beyond the lookout.
[0:47:12] It's once again that time of year to start looking at our survey.
[0:47:16] So the City of Twin Falls now uses the National Research Center and the National Citizen Survey
[0:47:23] to perform our Citizen Survey.
[0:47:25] And it is the fourth year in which we've utilized the survey vehicle and it is the only survey
[0:47:31] vehicle that is supported by the International City Managers Association.
[0:47:36] It is a survey vehicle that is done by an independent third party and through that process
[0:47:42] It really does help grasp a lot of different information about the community that we wouldn't
[0:47:50] be able to reach internally if we were doing this on our own.
[0:47:54] In fact, in the past when we've done surveys, we've often used voter registration lists and
[0:48:02] those who actually took the time to vote in the city election, and that's how we found
[0:48:07] our pool for people that we would move forward and ask, how are we doing as I said.
[0:48:14] And one of the things that we have found is that if you ask people who are normally engaged
[0:48:20] in what you are doing, you tend to have a very, very high, maybe overly inflated approval rating.
[0:48:29] And case in point, as like we like to pick on former Chief Pike and now Chief Kingsbury,
[0:48:37] There was a point in time where our police department had an approval rating in the community of
[0:48:41] 96 percent and that is generally unheard of.
[0:48:48] They were just that good.
[0:48:53] What this survey vehicle does is it goes forward and it actually ties census information to
[0:49:00] the respondents and it elevates the weights and so that you have a good understanding of
[0:49:07] how each demographic of your community feels about the particular questions that we are
[0:49:12] going to ask in this process.
[0:49:18] So by using the National Citizen Survey and using it as the fourth year, we have a better
[0:49:23] understanding of our customer's expectations.
[0:49:26] We have a better understanding of building improvements to our city's strategic planning
[0:49:31] vehicle.
[0:49:32] It has the ability to help us to find those outcomes, it has the ability to help us shape
[0:49:37] and understand what are those budgetary needs of our community, and then it also gives us
[0:49:42] the opportunity to go out and communicate those results as we kind of move forward throughout
[0:49:47] this entire process.
[0:49:49] What is really advantageous about this model is that we get a lot of information in a lot
[0:49:56] of different formats and types.
[0:49:59] So one of the things that we do is we divide the city up into different quadrants as reflected
[0:50:04] here on the map.
[0:50:06] What we want to know is what is your view and sentiment
[0:50:10] in the individual quadrants that you are living.
[0:50:13] It is important for us to know that if someone,
[0:50:16] as you'll notice on one of the questions,
[0:50:18] how do you rate your neighborhood as a safe place?
[0:50:21] The responses, as we have found, are very, very different
[0:50:24] or could be very different in the different quadrants.
[0:50:28] And so we can also utilize the information
[0:50:31] that we capture to help shape service delivery methods
[0:50:35] and tools and techniques.
[0:50:37] It also gives us the opportunity to take a look
[0:50:39] at how well our programs and services are doing
[0:50:43] in the different areas.
[0:50:44] And so when they talk about parks and open space
[0:50:47] and their sentiments and feelings towards that,
[0:50:49] we can really compare that to the geographic area
[0:50:53] that they live.
[0:50:55] The survey vehicle, they try to randomly sample
[0:50:59] an equal number of participants
[0:51:01] in each of the different geographic areas
[0:51:03] to try to complete that full sample.
[0:51:09] And so in those different forms,
[0:51:11] this is some of the information that we received
[0:51:13] in the 2014 survey where you'll see
[0:51:16] Twin Falls as a place to live,
[0:51:18] where the northwest side of our community
[0:51:20] rated it as 90% as good or excellent.
[0:51:24] The overall was 84.
[0:51:26] The southern part of our community
[0:51:27] had it at 81 and the south,
[0:51:30] excuse me, the northeast had it at 82.
[0:51:33] So you can really then begin to take a look at how are the different segments of our community
[0:51:39] evaluating our levels of services we move forward.
[0:51:46] The next way to do it is by demographic comparisons.
[0:51:49] And so by looking at the demographics, we also have the ability to determine how are
[0:51:54] our products and services amongst the different age groups and genders and socioeconomic classes
[0:52:01] within our community as well as how long people have lived here.
[0:52:05] And so when you really begin to take a look at the levels and types of services, you can
[0:52:10] see that for people who have lived in, put Twin Falls as a place to live, people who lived
[0:52:15] here more than 20 years rated at good to excellent at 87%, while those who had been here less
[0:52:21] than five years had rated it at 82%.
[0:52:24] And so you start asking yourself why is, why are those differences occurring?
[0:52:29] And then you can also take a look at the men, and if you own a home, if you rent a home,
[0:52:36] and the age group in which you fall in, so you'll notice that individuals between the ages
[0:52:41] of 18 and 34 were not as satisfied with Twin Falls as a community as compared to those who
[0:52:48] were 55 years and older.
[0:52:49] And you can see a bit of a spread there.
[0:52:53] You can also take a look at the male and female by gender by looking at that exact same question.
[0:52:59] What it does is it helps, you can see that one question.
[0:53:02] Now we've taken a look at geographic responses.
[0:53:06] Now we've also taken a look at the demographic responses.
[0:53:09] How it provides really good information all around.
[0:53:14] But this survey and the real value of this survey
[0:53:17] doesn't stop there.
[0:53:19] It allows us to compare ourselves to other jurisdictions
[0:53:23] of equal size.
[0:53:24] And so it really kind of helps us get a report card of where we
[0:53:28] rank by comparison. So you can see that the average rating of the overall quality of life
[0:53:33] in the City of Twin Falls during this survey was rated as a 65. We are ranked 244th. That
[0:53:40] may not mean anything, but you can see that out of 415 responses, and you can see that
[0:53:45] a 65 response was very similar to the benchmark that was received in other areas. Quality of
[0:53:51] neighborhood is a place to live, you can see it was a 66. That, unfortunately, was below
[0:53:57] in some of those categories, and so it's important to ask why are we below, what are we doing,
[0:54:05] or what are other places doing that we might try to emulate here to improve some of these
[0:54:10] responses.
[0:54:15] So inside your packet, we had a sample of what the 2014 National Citizen Survey is.
[0:54:24] The next survey that will go out will be identical, and the reason it's important to use the exact
[0:54:29] same survey vehicle is because you can mark progress.
[0:54:33] You can illustrate that as we were taking a look at the question as Twin Falls is a place
[0:54:38] to live, since this will be the fourth year that we've used as survey, we can determine
[0:54:42] are we advancing?
[0:54:44] Are we improving?
[0:54:45] Have we fallen off?
[0:54:47] What are some of the things that we could do differently to help enhance those ratings
[0:54:52] in comparison to where we were.
[0:54:55] In the last piece is the timeline that has been included in your packet.
[0:55:01] And I apologize for the smallness of the font, but what's important, I guess there's some pretty
[0:55:07] critical deadlines, is we're going to start the process of sending information out to our
[0:55:13] community and our residents are initially going to start receiving postcards from the city that
[0:55:17] says please be on the lookout for these.
[0:55:21] Then from that place we'll begin to generate household responses with the hopes of having
[0:55:26] first draft reports to us by the middle of April.
[0:55:31] And then we'll take about a month to kind of go through those processes to really understand
[0:55:35] the data.
[0:55:36] We'll make a series of presentations to the council in time, about the exact same time that
[0:55:41] you'll be receiving the information from the long-term planning committee and both of those
[0:55:46] pieces will be used to get gone for annual budgeting process.
[0:55:50] So with that, I'm happy to answer any questions.
[0:55:53] Chris, talking to.
[0:55:54] I think you said this will be our fourth,
[0:55:57] or we've had fourth.
[0:55:58] This will be our fourth.
[0:55:59] I think the point needs to reemphasizing
[0:56:01] you brought it up at the end.
[0:56:04] If our questions are pretty valid,
[0:56:05] which I think we've done a fine job
[0:56:07] of setting the specifics to the question,
[0:56:10] the real value is doing the comparative analysis
[0:56:13] of two-year intervals to see if you're increasing,
[0:56:17] decreasing. It's an old statistical track that, or legitimacy, that I think adds the
[0:56:24] real viability to it. And as such, I would hesitate to tinker with it very much because
[0:56:31] we want to see the comparative analysis coming up. Saying that, now I'll make a suggestion.
[0:56:38] Question 11 has always bothered me. If this was rating the quality of services by each
[0:56:43] of the following and we list the City of Twin Falls and then the Federal Government.
[0:56:49] The City of Twin Falls probably would be a legitimate one to kind of bring a cap, caps
[0:56:55] allied a summary statement that I can find no justification for a Federal Government question
[0:57:03] because what are you speaking of?
[0:57:04] Going to War, Congress, EPA, my suggestion is totally irrelevant unless and until we might
[0:57:12] I have the state as a third component or delete the Fed to begin with Travis the
[0:57:17] states on there. No it is. City of Twin Falls and the federal government but I
[0:57:23] just find the federal government sitting out there as just a total crapshoot. So I
[0:57:32] think that your stats at the state so I think that Councilman talking to him
[0:57:36] brings up a really good point and we'll talk to the NCS about that. In the past
[0:57:41] They had always asked about all levels of government, and so they would ask about the city, they asked about the county, they asked about the state, and they asked about the federal government.
[0:57:51] And I recall, because in the last citizen survey, we improved in 11 categories, and we fell in 9 categories, I believe.
[0:58:06] And three of those categories that we fell were actually in question 11 and they weren't ours if you understand.
[0:58:19] So we will talk to the NCS, I think that it's really important and we'll make sure that if they are going to ask that question of the federal government that they also include Twin Falls County as well as the state of Idaho.
[0:58:34] And I hesitate to throw them at all, except you're dealing with people who are more activated
[0:58:43] to vote, be involved in their community and know the issues, but I just think it needs
[0:58:48] to have a little bit more specificity to it than just saying the federal government without
[0:58:53] those other entities.
[0:58:54] So thank you for consideration.
[0:58:56] Thank you.
[0:58:57] Any other comments?
[0:58:58] Travis, did you need a motion to accept this, or can you just go ahead with it?
[0:59:04] We'll just go forward with it.
[0:59:06] One of the things, again, we're going to continue to use Josh and to make sure that people are
[0:59:12] aware of what this looks like, make sure that people are responding to this.
[0:59:17] They guarantee that our response will be statistically valid, but the more responses that we can receive
[0:59:22] on the front end, the sooner we can begin to receive those results as part of the process.
[0:59:26] Thank you for your time.
[0:59:27] Thank you very much.
[0:59:28] All right.
[0:59:30] We're doing good on time.
[0:59:31] It looks like we do have a public hearing coming up in a few moments.
[0:59:35] before we go on to that, we at this time generally take public input if there's anybody in the
[0:59:41] audience that has an idea or a concern they'd like to share with the council, now's your
[0:59:47] opportunity. And seeing no one moving forward, we will go on. Are there any items from the
[0:59:54] city manager's office?
[0:59:59] Madam Vice Mayor, members of the council, as you know, we try to script out council meetings
[1:00:05] over a very long period of time to ensure that our evening schedule is humane.
[1:00:12] And one of the things we want to avoid are those marathon meetings.
[1:00:17] Sometimes we can't help that.
[1:00:19] We had a couple of items that were originally scheduled for next Monday evening that I have
[1:00:26] had to poll as a result of a lack of complete information and we are moving those until
[1:00:32] February 8th.
[1:00:34] They were fairly large items and so because of that it is looking like a very sparse agenda
[1:00:41] for next week.
[1:00:44] It accounts for accounts payable and a park in blue dedication are the two items right
[1:00:51] now.
[1:00:53] Both would typically be consent calendar items and so I'm giving the count that we can come
[1:00:58] in and do that, or we could delay action on those items until February 8th, whatever the
[1:01:09] Council's prerogative is. February 8th will be a longer meeting than what we may have had
[1:01:19] so far this year simply because the items that we had budgeted for that timeframe will
[1:01:25] will be shifted to the eighth.
[1:01:29] Great, 19.
[1:01:30] I would say if there's no reason for us to be here that we're just wasting staff's time
[1:01:34] and everyone else's time went by being here so I would suggest that we choose not to have
[1:01:40] the meeting next week and publicize it.
[1:01:44] Any other thoughts?
[1:01:45] Yeah.
[1:01:46] I agree with that.
[1:01:47] I would have to have some motion.
[1:01:48] I second it.
[1:01:49] I don't think we need a motion on that.
[1:01:51] We can just have discussion.
[1:01:52] Chris talking to.
[1:01:53] It's too easy to say yes.
[1:01:57] Every time we delete one of those meetings, we end up with a ton of things on the following
[1:02:02] meeting.
[1:02:03] I cannot tell you how many times we thought we would just not do with one meeting and roll
[1:02:08] the simple little agendas in.
[1:02:11] I also say that because I will not be available in the meeting of the 8th.
[1:02:16] I would guess between now and next Monday you'll have things come up.
[1:02:22] So I don't particularly go for that.
[1:02:25] experience I've seen shows that we end up having a marathon meeting when we start deleting these.
[1:02:33] Thank you Chris. Great landing. So I was going to ask Travis for a bit what is the
[1:02:38] what's the deadline for information to be put on the next meeting? Isn't it by like Wednesday?
[1:02:44] It's Wednesday afternoon. So what we're looking at just so that the council is aware
[1:02:53] We were going to have a conversation about the Headworks Building, which was part of the
[1:03:01] Re-Bid process.
[1:03:05] Lori Race has been on vacation.
[1:03:07] She will not be back in the office until Wednesday.
[1:03:12] Many of us will be in Boise beginning this evening for the balance of the week and so
[1:03:16] there won't be the opportunity to connect, to talk about the availability of funds and
[1:03:20] the advancement of that project.
[1:03:23] Because the funding available for the project is bond proceeds, I want to make sure that before
[1:03:29] we present this bid to the Council for consideration that we can actually pay for the project.
[1:03:39] So that is the biggest piece that is kind of hanging out there.
[1:03:46] So that's kind of, that's the issue that has had to move.
[1:03:56] That'd be the meeting of February 1st.
[1:03:58] That would be the meeting of February 1st.
[1:04:00] That is the item that, yep.
[1:04:04] But once you can't get ready, if you don't have the time to get ready, there's not going
[1:04:07] to be anything on the agenda.
[1:04:08] And we'll just show up to say we showed up.
[1:04:11] You'll do a consent calendar and a request for a fee in lieu of dedication request in any
[1:04:17] issues that may emerge.
[1:04:19] They would be non-agendized issues that may emerge.
[1:04:22] consent item. I don't say any of the reasons. We know that there's not like
[1:04:29] anything else to get placed because the most of our leadership team is going to be in Boise all week.
[1:04:33] So, nothing else is going to be coming forth to be put on.
[1:04:39] I guess you wanted to take a roll call vote and the vote will be for no meeting next week.
[1:04:47] If you're in favor of not coming next week, your vote would be to the positive.
[1:04:51] to the point of the motion and the positive.
[1:04:56] I move that we suspend and not have a meeting on February 1st.
[1:05:00] Second.
[1:05:02] We have a motion on the floor by Greg Lanting, seconded by Ruth Pierce, to suspend the meeting
[1:05:07] for next Monday, February 1st.
[1:05:10] And Sharon, we will take a roll call vote.
[1:05:15] Chris Hockington.
[1:05:16] No.
[1:05:18] Greg Lanting.
[1:05:19] Yes.
[1:05:20] Ruth Pierce.
[1:05:21] Yes.
[1:05:22] Suzanne Hawkins.
[1:05:23] Yes.
[1:05:24] Yes, watch out the meeting passes forward to one. I think I think we were all well advised before the vote though
[1:05:34] But the 8th is going to be a long night. So we are aware
[1:05:37] Is there any other items of input from the City Council? All right
[1:05:51] It is after six o'clock so we can move to the public hearing and tonight we have Jonathan spin love
[1:05:57] of presenting a consideration of a request to approve
[1:06:02] a zoning title amendment and to adopt an ordinance
[1:06:05] for an amendment to Title 10, Chapter 7, Section 14,
[1:06:10] by redefining the area prohibited for outside storage
[1:06:14] or display of merchandise and defining the term
[1:06:18] primary business building for the city of Twin Falls.
[1:06:22] Welcome, Jonathan.
[1:06:24] Thank you, Vice Mayor.
[1:06:25] Tonight, I'm going to get this up on there, talking about the zoning code 1014, a little
[1:06:38] bit of history, this title, 1981 is when we had the last big addition or amendment to this
[1:06:44] title, and this specific section was amended recently that added an avenue for people to
[1:06:50] display merchandise.
[1:06:52] This request specifically tonight was to clarify the identified code section, specifically the
[1:06:59] manner in which the code is applied to commercial areas where commercial businesses may wish to
[1:07:03] place outside storage or display merchandise. The amendment removes a slight ambiguity within
[1:07:08] the code in regards to the adjacent sidewalk of a primary business. The amendment further
[1:07:12] defines what the definition of a primary business includes. If approved, this code amendment
[1:07:26] would further clarify the intent does not remove the ability for businesses to display merchandise
[1:07:31] as written. It will clarify where the merchandise is limited to a specific area.
[1:07:36] However, there are other avenues to displaying merchandise beyond the new
[1:07:39] limits defined in the amendment. Businesses may apply for a parking lot sale permit
[1:07:44] which allows for merchandise to be displayed in the parking areas during
[1:07:46] special events and promotions. The additions are in blue, the emissions are in
[1:07:51] red, just to further clarify where people will be able to show their items in front
[1:07:57] of their store or in certain spots on the property.
[1:08:00] Staff feels this amendment to the City Code
[1:08:04] would clarify and more accurately define the intent
[1:08:06] of section 10-7-14 outside storage and display.
[1:08:10] On December 8th, 2015, the commission held a public hearing
[1:08:14] on this request.
[1:08:15] No one spoke for or against this request.
[1:08:17] Upon conclusion of the public hearing
[1:08:20] and commission deliberations, Commissioner Boyd
[1:08:22] made a motion to approve the zoning title amendment
[1:08:24] as presented and Commissioner Tatum seconded the motion.
[1:08:27] All members present voted in favor of the motion.
[1:08:30] conclusion staff concurs with the planning and zoning commission's recommendation that is asking for the City Council to approve the amendment as presented.
[1:08:38] In the event the Council shall approve the amendment as presented staff requests adoption of the attached ordinance upon the passage and
[1:08:45] publication of the ordinance such amendments shall thereafter be a part of the title.
[1:08:51] Thank you, Jonathan. We have a question from Greg Lanting.
[1:08:55] Well, the one I'm just a little under make sure I understand, say it correctly here.
[1:09:02] A long-time tradition of downtown Twin Falls was to have what was called the crazy day sales that they would pull a few racks up in front of the store and
[1:09:11] They would have a sale is that would that prohibit this or would that be under the could they get a permit under the parking lot sale or
[1:09:19] I don't know they'd still do that anymore, but that used to be a I mean I was a kid
[1:09:24] I remember going to the crazy day sales
[1:09:26] I think it actually started linwood shopping center, which is public private property
[1:09:30] so it wouldn't matter, but it kind of spread it down to him.
[1:09:37] So downtown sidewalk sale wouldn't be a problem.
[1:09:43] Just so you understand what this is about,
[1:09:45] we prosecuted a case two years ago, I think.
[1:09:51] And it was a premises that had kind of an ongoing yard sale.
[1:09:58] We prosecuted the case.
[1:09:59] The person was found guilty.
[1:10:01] It was appealed.
[1:10:02] And on appeal, the judge thought that the existing language was ambiguous.
[1:10:08] The sidewalk being, does that mean it's extreme or where?
[1:10:14] The idea of this is to continue to avoid the problem.
[1:10:17] I don't know if you remember, in the old days we used to have some of the home-approop
[1:10:25] of places with big piles of merchandise all throughout their parking lot.
[1:10:30] So, the purpose of this is to avoid that,
[1:10:33] still allows the, in the spring, the sale of plants,
[1:10:37] and it still allows Christmas trees, seasonal goods.
[1:10:42] But the idea isn't to change really anything,
[1:10:45] it's just to do what we thought we were doing all along,
[1:10:47] but what one judge didn't think was clear enough.
[1:10:52] Great, did you have a follow-up?
[1:10:53] I did, but then one that has,
[1:10:57] I've had concern with is the,
[1:11:00] One of the downtown versions that has those old crates
[1:11:03] out in front of their building most of every day,
[1:11:07] would that still be allowed or would that be outlawed?
[1:11:10] So in the downtown, so this sidewalk is still the walkway
[1:11:15] in between the building and the street.
[1:11:17] So this would not directly prohibit it.
[1:11:20] Okay, all right, thank you.
[1:11:23] Thank you, Chris Talkington.
[1:11:24] Looking ahead to the time where we have the plaza
[1:11:27] where the Rogerson is now,
[1:11:30] A lot of that area is going to be widely used for commercial and other type of activities.
[1:11:38] But the very small point I'm questioning is are we painting ourselves into the corner
[1:11:43] by the addition of the language talking about paved pedestrian area?
[1:11:47] I mean, there will be type of adobe brick in there, but it's not technically a paving.
[1:11:55] Is that too specific of a definition?
[1:11:57] I think we'd still call that paved.
[1:12:01] As long as it gives inclusive of everything other than gravel.
[1:12:07] Yes.
[1:12:08] No.
[1:12:09] This was never directed at the downtown.
[1:12:10] I don't think it's probably anything downtown.
[1:12:13] It's out on the strips where the stores want to display their goods way out front in their
[1:12:20] parking lot where their car is.
[1:12:22] Oh, even if it's out there, though, and they put bricks in, then we consider that paving.
[1:12:27] Yeah.
[1:12:31] If there's no other questions, I'm going to go ahead and open up the public portion of
[1:12:35] this hearing.
[1:12:36] So we will open for public comment and see no one.
[1:12:43] We will close the public hearing.
[1:12:47] And I guess there's really no rebuttal at this time.
[1:12:51] So I just wanted to point out we have a problem with our sequence of ordinance numbers.
[1:12:59] Do you have it now?
[1:13:00] Okay.
[1:13:01] The previous number was wrong that we adopted a little while ago.
[1:13:04] So, Sharon has the right numbers, okay.
[1:13:08] Okay, so what is the ordinance number for this item,
[1:13:10] then Sharon?
[1:13:12] 31.
[1:13:15] 13.
[1:13:16] 31, 13.
[1:13:21] So do we need to go back and re-approve the previous one?
[1:13:26] No, don't worry about that.
[1:13:27] You did everything right.
[1:13:29] The fact that you named a number that is nonexistent
[1:13:31] doesn't make it clear.
[1:13:34] Thank you.
[1:13:35] Chris Talkington.
[1:13:36] Moved as suspend rules, place ordinance 31, 13,
[1:13:39] and final title on my thank you we have a motion we have a motion by chris
[1:13:46] talkington seconded by great landing to suspend the rules and put this ordinance
[1:13:51] on third and final by title only is there any other discussion k Sharon will
[1:13:57] call but please Greg landing yes repairs yes Suzanne Hawkins yes Nicky boy yes
[1:14:07] Yes, Chris talking.
[1:14:08] Yes.
[1:14:09] Motion passes 5-0.
[1:14:11] Sharon, can you please read the title of the ordinance?
[1:14:22] Ordinance number 31-13.
[1:14:24] An ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho amending Twin Falls City
[1:14:30] Code 10-7-14 by redefining the area prohibited for the outside storage or display of merchandise.
[1:14:42] Thank you, I'll stand for a motion.
[1:14:45] Move approval of ordinance 31.13.
[1:14:49] Second.
[1:14:50] We have a motion by Greg Lanting,
[1:14:53] so I can add by Ruth Pierce to approve ordinance 31.13.
[1:14:58] Is there any discussion?
[1:15:01] Sharon, roll call vote please.
[1:15:03] Great.
[1:15:04] Yes.
[1:15:05] Suzanne Hawkins.
[1:15:06] Yes.
[1:15:07] Nikki Boyd.
[1:15:08] Yes.
[1:15:09] Chris talking to Greg Lanting.
[1:15:11] Yes.
[1:15:12] motion passes 5 to 0 and if there is no further business this meeting is
[1:15:18] adjourned again if your machine is not updated
