Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2015-05-26, recording 1 (started 17:00)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2015-05-26/

[0:04:31] I'd like to call the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council to order it is May 26th, it's 5 p.m.
[0:04:40] And as always we start our agenda with the Pledge of Allegiance.
[0:04:45] So those of you wishing to join us please rise.
[0:04:48] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
[0:05:05] The first item on the agenda that's actually not on the agenda, but I'm going to put it
[0:05:10] on there anyway, is Rebecca Mills, Soya, and Casey, Soya, had their baby.
[0:05:18] On the 23rd, I should know that because that's my anniversary, too.
[0:05:23] They had a little boy, eight pounds, two ounces, 20 inches long, and is doing well at this point.
[0:05:31] So congratulations to Casey and to Rebecca on their birth of their very first child.
[0:05:36] So we can give them a hand.
[0:05:37] Move over to the tax payer of ten.
[0:05:39] Yeah, another tax payer.
[0:05:42] Eventually, President.
[0:05:43] All right, moving on to, we do have a quorum of the City Council.
[0:05:50] Six members are here this evening.
[0:05:52] Rebecca is not for obvious reasons.
[0:05:55] Do we have any amendments to our agenda, Mr. City Manager?
[0:06:00] Mr. Mayor, members of the council,
[0:06:01] there are no amendments this evening.
[0:06:03] We have no proclamation, so the very first item
[0:06:06] that we open up to the community is a public input section,
[0:06:10] and I know there's at least one person
[0:06:11] that would like to come forward.
[0:06:13] We'll give you a couple minutes.
[0:06:14] It has to be something that's not on the agenda this evening.
[0:06:16] So at this time, if you'd come forward,
[0:06:18] if you had any public input,
[0:06:19] you wanna address the council.
[0:06:22] If you'd state your name, your address,
[0:06:24] and then the floor is yours, sir.
[0:06:27] My name is Mike Stradley.
[0:06:28] I live with two 10 camera all the way here in Twin Falls.
[0:06:31] Thank you, Mayor Hall and members of the council.
[0:06:34] Today, I am here representing a large number
[0:06:38] of the members of our community about Disc Golf.
[0:06:42] I think it's really exciting to see
[0:06:44] in all the growth happening in Twin Falls business-wise
[0:06:47] and especially recreationally,
[0:06:49] the new park that was put in
[0:06:51] to talk about a community center,
[0:06:52] the expansions of the trails,
[0:06:54] but Disc Golf has slipped through the cracks
[0:06:56] and it is one of the fastest growing sports
[0:06:58] in the world right now for various reasons
[0:07:01] such as being low cost, available to the masses, so on and so forth.
[0:07:07] So I'm not here to propose anything today.
[0:07:10] I'm here just to put it on your guys' radar.
[0:07:13] I know you guys are very, very busy right now with other things
[0:07:15] such as downtown, but you will be seeing me here in the near future.
[0:07:20] We're working closely with Dennis Boyer and the members of the park
[0:07:23] and rack to come up with some master plans that we can propose to you guys.
[0:07:26] but why you guys are discussing the future budgets
[0:07:30] and recreation and whatnot,
[0:07:31] I wanted to make sure that Disc Golf
[0:07:33] was at least on your guys' radar.
[0:07:35] So I've got a little back sheet here
[0:07:37] that I'd like to hand out to each one of you guys,
[0:07:40] and you guys as well.
[0:07:42] So you guys can look at that at your convenience,
[0:07:44] and then I will be seeing you again.
[0:07:48] I thought I saw some folks going through what they're like.
[0:07:51] Great planning.
[0:07:52] I know we have a long agenda this recently,
[0:07:54] but I'll ask a quick question.
[0:07:56] I know of two disc golf in the area.
[0:07:58] Do we have more than one falls right now?
[0:08:00] There are two 18-fold courses, one at CSI.
[0:08:03] It's privately owned by them, obviously,
[0:08:05] and one at Rock Creek, which is county property, not city,
[0:08:07] and that was put in completely by us as disc golfers
[0:08:10] out of our own pocket.
[0:08:12] The reason I say we need more is the city,
[0:08:14] we know it's going to double in size
[0:08:16] over the next few years, and with two courses,
[0:08:18] that is not going to be enough to accommodate the masses.
[0:08:21] When it's not enough to accommodate the masses,
[0:08:23] that's when issues occur where you have a hard time teeing off, getting onto the course.
[0:08:29] You might get hit with the Frisbee and these things are not your typical traditional beach
[0:08:34] frisbees.
[0:08:35] These are beveled, sharp edged discs that can actually hurt you.
[0:08:38] So we are going to need to disperse that public into other areas that we can all share the
[0:08:44] enjoyment of this sport that grows from ages 5 to 105 for as little as $6 to have a blast
[0:08:51] all day long. And with the two courses, we're going to overgrow those very shortly. Plus,
[0:08:58] another thing that I'm really shooting for is I would love to be able to hold a national
[0:09:03] tour, a major or even a world championship here, but we mean a minimum of four 18-hole
[0:09:08] championship level courses in order to do that. But at other events where they've held
[0:09:14] these, it's drawn in thousands of athletes and it's brought in millions of dollars into
[0:09:19] the community. So this is something I think that would be great all the way around. I mean,
[0:09:22] my kids got the invite last year to the amateur worlds and we couldn't go because it's been
[0:09:28] on the East Coast for the past 10 years. I would love to be able to put the bid in, get
[0:09:33] it accepted by the Professional Disc Golf Association and host it here in Twin Falls. We have a
[0:09:38] lot to offer and I think it would be very beneficial for both the sport of disc golf and
[0:09:43] the community as well. Plus then I wouldn't have to try to get my kids to Madison Wisconsin
[0:09:48] next year. Which we're going either way. Thank you very much. Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:09:55] Thank you. Oh, I know we took the course out at Thompson Park because of complaints
[0:10:00] from the neighbors, but I thought we also had one at O'Leary Junior. Yeah, whole
[0:10:04] course and same with Thompson. So that's great for, you know, providing
[0:10:08] recreational, but it's not something that we can host an actual professional
[0:10:12] disc golf level tournament there. And Thompson is actually a prime example of
[0:10:18] what the issues we're going to run into at disc golf if we don't address this in the near future.
[0:10:22] When you try to cram something as popular as disc golf into a small park of nine holes,
[0:10:27] these are the issues that happen.
[0:10:29] There's overcrowding, you know, people throwing over the fence, jumping the fence,
[0:10:33] you know, there's not signage that indicates etiquette, things like this.
[0:10:37] And so we really need our own space.
[0:10:39] Ideally, I'd love to have a Twin Falls municipal disc golf course.
[0:10:42] Now, that's a far-fetched dream that's very, very expensive,
[0:10:46] even though you can put a disc golf course in for as little as $5,000,
[0:10:50] something on that scale is obviously much, much more money.
[0:10:54] But we are going to need our own space, because Thompson was a prime example of just cramming us into
[0:11:00] somewhere why it doesn't work. And though a municipal disc golf course is a little far fetched,
[0:11:05] I'd still love to see a course that actually had bathrooms.
[0:11:09] So when my wife and kids are out there playing, they have a facility that they can go use.
[0:11:14] And like I said, more championship level courses, not just the nine holes that you're referring to so that we can host some of these big events.
[0:11:22] Thank you.
[0:11:23] I know we drive out to like, Walcott is where my family loves to go play.
[0:11:27] So yes.
[0:11:28] All right.
[0:11:29] Thank you.
[0:11:30] Appreciate you coming in front of us.
[0:11:31] I might debate you a little bit later on the inexpensive part of disc golf.
[0:11:35] My son played it for a little while and the prank Cooley ate a lot of discs.
[0:11:41] The other reason we need another course that maybe doesn't have so many water hazards because it is evil.
[0:11:46] All right.
[0:11:47] Very evil.
[0:11:48] Well Mike, thank you for bringing that to our attention.
[0:11:49] You're working with the right people and it's on our radar now.
[0:11:52] Thank you.
[0:11:53] Thank you.
[0:11:54] Is there anyone else that would like to come forward?
[0:11:57] All right.
[0:11:58] Well, we're going to move on to the consent calendar.
[0:12:00] I'll turn that over to Council for their direction.
[0:12:02] Chris talking to us.
[0:12:03] Approval is printed.
[0:12:04] Second.
[0:12:05] Motion on the floor by Chris Daukenden, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to approve the consent calendar
[0:12:10] as published and printed.
[0:12:11] and printed. Anything further on that motion council?
[0:12:16] Lee Eiloh, you're messing me up because I've got so used to saying Sharon now.
[0:12:19] Lee Eiloh, no call vote case.
[0:12:22] Suzanne Hawkins. Yes. Jim Mann. Yes. Sean Berriger. Yes. Chris Talkington. Yes. Greg
[0:12:29] Lanthine. Yes. Don Hall. Yes. Motion passes six to zero. Moving now to items for
[0:12:35] consideration. And I know that this is a misprint on the agenda. The first item
[0:12:41] consideration is presentation to introduce Tara Bartley, Bartley, as the new
[0:12:53] Twin Falls Public Library Director and we have Debbie Dane as the chairperson of
[0:12:58] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[0:13:07] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[0:13:12] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[0:13:18] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[0:13:23] She grew up in Hagerman and graduated from Hagerman High School. She attended Eastern Washington University
[0:13:29] where she, excuse me, Eastern Oregon University, where she earned her bachelor's in business administration.
[0:13:36] While she was at Eastern Oregon, she worked in the library as a student.
[0:13:41] and fell in love. And she fell in love twice at Eastern Oregon. She married her
[0:13:49] husband Joe there as well. She continued to work after graduation on a library
[0:13:55] initiative. In 2002 she and Joe moved to Pennsylvania and they've experienced a
[0:14:03] different part of the country and during that time she received her Masters of
[0:14:08] of Library Science at Clerian University in Pennsylvania.
[0:14:14] And shortly after that, she began working
[0:14:16] as the children's librarian at Benson Memorial Library.
[0:14:20] It was Joe and Tara's plan to stay just for a little while,
[0:14:24] but 11 years later, they're in the process
[0:14:28] of completing their move to Twin Falls.
[0:14:31] She is thrilled to be back here, and we're thrilled to have her.
[0:14:36] She has roots in the Valley and she really during our interview process impressed all
[0:14:42] of the Board of Trustees with her passion for libraries as well as her desire for the job
[0:14:50] and to come back and do the best possible job for the Twin Falls Public Library.
[0:14:55] She and Joe have two children, Lainey, who is age eight and Nathan, who is age six.
[0:15:03] And also, Joe will begin teaching social studies at a Larry Middle School this fall.
[0:15:08] So it is my pleasure to introduce to you, Tara Bartley, who is the Director of the Public Library here in Twin Falls.
[0:15:16] Thank you, Teddy.
[0:15:22] I'm under fire.
[0:15:25] Welcome, Tara.
[0:15:25] Thank you.
[0:15:26] Thank you.
[0:15:27] It's nice to be here.
[0:15:28] Anything that you would like to start off with or?
[0:15:32] No.
[0:15:33] I'm pleased to be at the library.
[0:15:35] It is a wonderful place.
[0:15:36] when I interviewed and then now that I'm here, I realize that Twin is very progressive
[0:15:43] in what they're offering in library services and I will continue to just keep offering those
[0:15:49] services and see what we can add as Twin grows.
[0:15:53] Excellent.
[0:15:54] Chris Tawington.
[0:15:55] Couple points, an author to a newcomer to town but in our community survey, the library
[0:16:01] continues to be just among the most highest rated public services. So you have big shoes to fill
[0:16:08] and you and I will get along if you don't burn books. Okay. Nice to have you here. Thank you.
[0:16:15] Thank you Chris. Well from the council's perspective welcome to our community or welcome back and if
[0:16:22] there's anything we can do to make your time here productive and happy let us know we're here for you.
[0:16:29] We have a great partnership with the library.
[0:16:31] Great. Thank you. I appreciate that.
[0:16:32] Thank you.
[0:16:33] Thank you for your time.
[0:16:35] Moving to the item number two, it's presentation of service plaques to Kevin Dane and Ryan
[0:16:39] Horsley in recognition of their service on the Parks and Recreation Commission.
[0:16:44] We have our Parks and Recreation Director, Dennis Boyer.
[0:16:47] Yes.
[0:16:49] Thank you, Mayor and Council.
[0:16:50] It is a pleasure to be here tonight to honor a couple of our members from the Parks and
[0:16:53] Recreation Commission.
[0:16:55] First, I'd like to kind of introduce Kevin Dane a little bit.
[0:16:59] not better half, not better half. The other half about that.
[0:17:02] The other half.
[0:17:03] I would definitely not say better half.
[0:17:05] Sorry, that's why I made, you know.
[0:17:07] Sorry.
[0:17:08] The other half, okay, how about that?
[0:17:11] I'm turning red now.
[0:17:13] I think I'll go over one or two.
[0:17:16] It's not like that at all.
[0:17:17] Anyway, Kevin served on our commission since April 2009.
[0:17:21] He had served his two full three-year terms.
[0:17:24] And even the past five years, he has served as chairman
[0:17:28] of the commission and he led us through some great ideas
[0:17:31] in what we had on the commission.
[0:17:32] And he has been already surely missed anyway
[0:17:36] on the commission.
[0:17:37] So I would like to have the mayor and our council liaison,
[0:17:41] Sean Berger, come down.
[0:17:43] And also then I'll just go and talk about
[0:17:45] a little bit about Ryan Horsey too,
[0:17:46] because then we'll get our photo op with Mitch.
[0:17:49] We'll do that.
[0:17:50] Ryan also started on the commission back in April of 2009 and served his two four-year terms.
[0:17:57] Ryan was always great to provide a great input into the commission on no matter what the issue
[0:18:01] was.
[0:18:02] He had some good thoughts and ideas about that.
[0:18:04] And also, he will be missed by the commission and staff as well.
[0:18:07] So could I have Kevin and Ryan come up please?
[0:18:20] So on behalf of the Parks and Recreation Commission and staff and on the council, we'd like to
[0:18:28] just to honor Kevin and Ryan for their six years of service and yes then.
[0:18:32] Well, I'm going to go in between us right now.
[0:18:37] I'm going to go in between us right now.
[0:18:40] I'm going to go in between us right now.
[0:18:43] I'm going to go in between us right now.
[0:19:04] I'm going to go in between us right now.
[0:19:05] Oh, yeah.
[0:19:06] Don't get Ryan started.
[0:19:07] If you'd like to say a few words tonight, I won't say anything.
[0:19:13] Okay.
[0:19:14] Both of us have said too much over the years.
[0:19:17] Well, just on behalf of the council as well, thank you so much for your service.
[0:19:22] We say this all the time.
[0:19:23] We truly appreciate those that serve on these committees and commissions to the council because
[0:19:29] we can't make these decisions.
[0:19:31] We can't spend the time on all these issues by ourselves.
[0:19:36] We need the public our commissions to give us that input.
[0:19:40] So thank you both very much for your service.
[0:19:43] Next item on the agenda is presentations of service plaques to Dusty Becker, Richard
[0:19:48] Burrell, Helen Brown, Jack Jardine, and Tina Thompson in recognition of their service on
[0:19:54] the Golf Advisory Commission and we have Dennis Boyer again.
[0:19:57] Thank you again.
[0:19:58] As you know last month the City Council did assign the duties of the Golf Commission to
[0:20:02] the Parks and Recreation Commission.
[0:20:03] Because the last several years of the Golf Commission, you know, it found out really their
[0:20:08] duties of the Commission just was kind of narrowed it down to one to run the Friends of
[0:20:12] of Muni Golf Tournament.
[0:20:14] So we thought it'd be best to go ahead
[0:20:16] and disband the Golf Advisory Commission.
[0:20:18] We did, to let you know, remember,
[0:20:20] we did appoint someone from the Golf Advisory Commission
[0:20:23] to the Parks and Recreation Commission,
[0:20:24] kind of serve at that lathe on a little bit.
[0:20:26] And just a reminder, the Prince of Muni Golf Tournament
[0:20:29] is Saturday to like 25th, right?
[0:20:31] Great, yeah, okay, for sure it is.
[0:20:33] Yeah.
[0:20:34] But I would like to give out some awards
[0:20:38] to these five individuals that has committed some time
[0:20:42] effort into serving on the Golf Advisory Commission. First, Ducky, Dusty. Dusty? Boy, I'm having a
[0:20:48] hard time tonight, aren't I? There you go. Dusty Becker, how about that? Okay. She only served on
[0:20:55] one year on the commission, but she was a valuable input. She could not see her in the audience, but
[0:21:02] we'll go ahead and recognize her. Next is Richard Braille. Even though he did have served on the Golf
[0:21:07] Advisory Commission, now he's on the Parks and Recreation Commission. He has served since May
[0:21:12] of 2011 served a partial term and then kind of served another full three-year term and
[0:21:17] he was really active on the commission and also especially our friends of Muni tournament.
[0:21:21] Helen Brown, she served on the commission since March of 2012 and just finished her
[0:21:26] first three-year term.
[0:21:29] She was a liaison from the Women's Golf Association to the commission and also she really brought
[0:21:34] some good insight to help with the friends of Muni tournament.
[0:21:38] Back charting, he served since just a little bit over a year since March of 2013.
[0:21:43] Even though he really, Jack wasn't a golfer, you might say, but I tell you, on the friends
[0:21:48] immunity, golf tournament, he was a go-getter on getting prizes and donations, and without
[0:21:53] him, you know, I know our tournament would have suffered some without him, so he was a
[0:21:57] great, great person to have on the golf advisory.
[0:22:00] And then also, I have Tina Thompson, she only served a little bit over a year.
[0:22:04] She could not make it tonight, because I know I think her and her sister are coaching at one
[0:22:08] of our youth softball teams were, so I still got her involved out there anyway.
[0:22:11] So I'd like to eat these three individuals come up please and could I add Greg and Don
[0:22:18] down here representing the city?
[0:22:20] You're not a gusty.
[0:22:45] No!
[0:22:46] No!
[0:22:47] No!
[0:22:54] No!
[0:22:56] No!
[0:23:02] No!
[0:23:21] No!
[0:23:22] No!
[0:23:23] No!
[0:23:24] No!
[0:23:25] No!
[0:23:26] No!
[0:23:27] No!
[0:23:28] No!
[0:23:29] No!
[0:23:30] No!
[0:23:31] We have a chance to entertain a lot of people
[0:23:33] when they come to town.
[0:23:34] It's a great thrill to drive them by the golf course.
[0:23:36] It is a very nice thing to show.
[0:23:40] So, and it's well run.
[0:23:41] Thank you.
[0:23:42] Thank you, Jack.
[0:23:43] And again, thank you to the three of you
[0:23:45] for your service.
[0:23:46] Really appreciate it.
[0:23:48] Moving on to the next item on the agenda.
[0:23:50] It's consideration of request to adopt an ordinance
[0:23:53] vacating a portion of a cladded utility,
[0:23:56] vehicle access and drainage easement
[0:23:58] on property located at 170,
[0:24:01] Let's say one, seven, seven, seven, and 1821 Canyon Crest Drive
[0:24:07] for West Park Partners.
[0:24:09] And we have Renee Caraway-Johnson.
[0:24:12] Welcome Renee.
[0:24:13] Yes, good afternoon Mayor Hall and City Council.
[0:24:16] This area map is showing you the location
[0:24:19] of where this vacation took place.
[0:24:22] This is pole lying down on the Southside Canyon Crest Drive.
[0:24:27] These two lots were the lots that were under discussion.
[0:24:30] They're not developed at this time.
[0:24:36] This yellow portion along the west boundary is an easement
[0:24:41] that was included in the recording of the plat.
[0:24:45] That easement was dedicated for utility to be placed in there.
[0:24:50] It's owned by the property owner, but dedicated for easement.
[0:25:01] Again, this is Canyon Crest.
[0:25:03] Pole line is down below here.
[0:25:06] If you recall in the previous map I showed you,
[0:25:08] The easements go all the way up and along the Western boundary.
[0:25:14] With this request, there was only a request to vacate portion of this,
[0:25:19] and that is what we're here tonight with an ordinance for your adoption.
[0:25:25] Just a little bit of background or history.
[0:25:27] On March 31st, the Planning and Zoning Commission did hold a public hearing,
[0:25:32] whereby there was no public comment on this request.
[0:25:35] After discussion, Commissioner Gray made a motion
[0:25:37] to recommend approval of the request to the City Council
[0:25:42] with staff recommendations.
[0:25:43] Commissioner Munoz seconded the motion
[0:25:45] in all members present, voted in favor of that motion
[0:25:49] to bring to you a positive recommendation.
[0:25:51] Those two conditions are subject to all applicable
[0:25:55] utility letters being submitted to the City Council
[0:25:58] prior to publication of the vacation ordinance
[0:26:01] and the second condition was subject to all conditions
[0:26:03] of approval by the applicable utility companies
[0:26:06] being met prior to publication of the vacation ordinance.
[0:26:13] On April 27th, this request came to the city council.
[0:26:18] You did hold a public hearing,
[0:26:19] there again was no public comment.
[0:26:21] And the council, councilman Munn,
[0:26:25] made a motion to vacate the portion of
[0:26:27] climate utility easement as presented,
[0:26:30] subject to the two conditions.
[0:26:32] And it was seconded by Councilman Burger by a vote of 5, 4, and 0 against.
[0:26:40] So all conditions at this point in time have been met on this request and we are asking for
[0:26:47] your adoption of an ordinance to codify this vacation.
[0:26:51] What would the ordinance number be if we so decide?
[0:26:54] 3095.
[0:26:55] 3095, thank you, Hannah.
[0:26:58] Turn it over.
[0:26:59] Council for questions and or direction.
[0:27:01] Great language.
[0:27:02] There hall I move that we place ordinance 30-25-3095 on 3rd and final by title only by suspending the rules.
[0:27:11] Second.
[0:27:13] We have motion on the floor by Greg Lanting, seconded by Sean Berrigger.
[0:27:17] I think further on that motion council.
[0:27:21] We have a recoupled, please.
[0:27:23] Yes.
[0:27:24] Yes.
[0:27:26] Chris Talkington.
[0:27:28] Yes.
[0:27:29] Greg Lanting.
[0:27:30] Yes.
[0:27:31] Don Hall.
[0:27:32] Yes.
[0:27:33] Motion passes six to zero if you agree with the ordinance.
[0:27:38] In ordinance of the mayor and the city council
[0:27:40] of the city of Twin Falls, Idaho,
[0:27:42] vacating the rail property described below
[0:27:44] and providing for vesting a title to the property
[0:27:47] so vacating.
[0:27:48] Thank you, the aye la.
[0:27:50] Chris Dauchke.
[0:27:50] I would move passage of ordinance 3095 subject
[0:27:53] to the attachment of the two conditions
[0:27:56] mentioned in the narrative.
[0:27:59] Second.
[0:28:00] Motion on four by Chris Dauchke.
[0:28:02] seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to adopt ordinance 3095 as stated anything
[0:28:07] further on that motion council Lee other roll call vote please Sean Baragurd yes
[0:28:13] Chris talking ten yes Greg Lanting yes Don Hall yes Suzanne Hawkins yes Jim
[0:28:19] Munn yes motion passes six to zero thank you Renee moving on to the next
[0:28:25] item on the agenda is a general discussion about city councils fiscal
[0:28:30] year, 2016 budget priorities and philosophies followed by citizen input.
[0:28:36] We have our city manager, Travis Swethaw.
[0:28:38] Mr. Mayor, members of the council, good evening tonight is the second of several conversations
[0:28:44] and dialogues that we will have about the upcoming budget.
[0:28:50] Two weeks ago, we had an opportunity to really begin that process of asking and engaging
[0:28:56] the members of the City Council about what would some of your priorities be over the course
[0:29:01] of the next fiscal year. Prior to that, you had received a presentation from the City's
[0:29:08] long-term planning group. The City's long-term planning group takes a look at not only the
[0:29:12] city's needs in fiscal year 2016 that will begin on October 1st, but also begins to prioritize
[0:29:20] capital operational and positional means for the organization in a five-year window of time.
[0:29:28] All of it being directly connected to the city's strategic plan that has the eight vision areas.
[0:29:35] And in those eight vision areas, it hopes and the areas that we hope to realize or have
[0:29:40] to have false achieved to realize the community we want to become.
[0:29:45] In your packet this evening, we took a summary of the different input that was provided by
[0:29:51] the members of the City Council, and what we thought we would do is run through those
[0:29:55] really quickly and then build and expand upon those as we continue to move forward.
[0:30:02] From this list, later this week, members of all of the City's departments are going
[0:30:07] to come together, and we are going to have a meeting to talk about the priorities that
[0:30:14] that were expressed by the long-term planning committee,
[0:30:17] the priorities that were expressed by the city council,
[0:30:20] and then also the individual department priorities
[0:30:22] that have been put forth by the department leaders
[0:30:24] and really come to a reconciliation
[0:30:26] of what that looks like.
[0:30:28] From those steps, then we will come back
[0:30:30] and report to the council a very early
[0:30:34] preliminary draft budget at the second meeting in June,
[0:30:39] saying this is what we heard.
[0:30:40] We are preparing to build the final budget
[0:30:44] that we will present on July 2nd,
[0:30:46] just to kind of check in to make sure
[0:30:47] that we haven't left anything significant
[0:30:50] off in that process.
[0:30:51] From July 2nd until the 24th of August,
[0:30:55] we will have a conversation at every council meeting
[0:30:59] about a different component of the budget
[0:31:02] as is connected to the city's strategic plan.
[0:31:05] Tonight, again, it's the second of 12 total opportunities
[0:31:09] that we ask for public engagement.
[0:31:11] We have a public vetting of our budget process.
[0:31:28] So what we tried to do was break this
[0:31:30] into very defined areas as it relates
[0:31:35] to the budget and upcoming budget.
[0:31:38] You'll notice that we had some general goals.
[0:31:41] And one of the general goals that was stated
[0:31:42] was we wanted a direct connection
[0:31:44] to the city's strategic plan, which is important
[0:31:47] because we said that the strategic plan
[0:31:49] is going to be the driving document
[0:31:51] for organizations going to shape our fiscal policies,
[0:31:54] our operational policies, our personnel decisions,
[0:31:57] and help us to realize those visions as we move forward.
[0:32:01] We also wanted to make sure that we were hitting
[0:32:03] those desired target levels of our citizens.
[0:32:06] Are we meeting their expectations?
[0:32:08] Are there areas that we can improve our service delivery
[0:32:11] to honor our citizens by performing at their expectations?
[0:32:18] We wanted to make sure under the revenues category
[0:32:20] that we are taking conservative approaches in times of looking at tax rates as well as
[0:32:25] utility rates and we wanted to make sure that the new tax gas tax revenues that are coming
[0:32:32] as a result of the legislative action were applied directly to the street department and
[0:32:37] it didn't cause a tax shift moving to other areas.
[0:32:41] We wanted to make sure that we continue to follow the zone maintenance program.
[0:32:45] We wanted to make sure that we are finding opportunities to enhance the city's trail system
[0:32:50] throughout the community.
[0:32:52] We wanted to develop more water storage.
[0:32:55] We wanted to continue to work through the Canyon Springs Road Grade Project, identify solutions,
[0:33:02] and then develop a funding strategy moving forward.
[0:33:05] We also wanted to take a look at improving recreational facilities and diversifying what
[0:33:10] that looks like.
[0:33:11] We wanted to make sure that we didn't forget about the rec center conversation that has been
[0:33:15] occurring in our community.
[0:33:17] We wanted to take a look and diversify our park standards, and we wanted to make sure that
[0:33:21] we are creating more unique spaces.
[0:33:26] When it came to personnel, it was a strong commitment of the Council two years ago to ensure that
[0:33:32] we made the necessary improvements to ensure that we were competing against our market.
[0:33:39] And the steps that we have taken over the course of the last two years have really allowed
[0:33:43] us to strengthen our position, which we have seen in the ability to retain as well as attract
[0:33:48] to quality employees into our organization.
[0:33:51] We said we didn't want to lose ground.
[0:33:53] So making sure that not only the salary table,
[0:33:55] but the benefits of total compensation remain competitive.
[0:34:00] We also wanted to make sure that we are adding staff
[0:34:05] in those areas where we need it to maintain levels of service.
[0:34:09] And one of the conversations that we've been having internally
[0:34:13] is we want to make sure that we're adding staff
[0:34:15] as a last resort.
[0:34:17] We want to make sure that we've examined processes.
[0:34:19] We want to make sure that we have determined to find ways
[0:34:23] to become more efficient with the human talent that we have
[0:34:26] as opposed to falling back on the easy answer
[0:34:29] and always adding staff because that seems to be convenient.
[0:34:32] We believe that there are always ways to improve how we offer
[0:34:37] and how we work within our business groups
[0:34:39] and we're going to continue to strive moving forward.
[0:34:42] Programs and services.
[0:34:45] We really wanted to make sure
[0:34:46] that water conservation continues to move forward. We've started that effort this year, but we
[0:34:51] also want to make sure that there is funding for those types of issues as well as having
[0:34:57] recycling programs. We wanted to find a program and a process that allowed us to do something
[0:35:06] different with sidewalks, that we recognize that the city code says that the sidewalks
[0:35:11] shall be the property owner's responsibility.
[0:35:15] But we're also finding that side blocks have become
[0:35:18] one of the more neglected components of public infrastructure.
[0:35:22] And there may need to be a solution that involves
[0:35:25] a public process moving forward, and members of our team
[0:35:27] are currently researching ways to develop
[0:35:30] a public-private partnership on fixing
[0:35:33] many of the side blocks in our area.
[0:35:36] We don't have a program, and we don't have a cost,
[0:35:39] but it at least is something that we can start investigating now,
[0:35:43] and then possibly allocating dollars moving forward.
[0:35:47] We wanted to make sure that we continue to examine all of our codes
[0:35:50] as they relate to building, planning and zoning,
[0:35:55] code compliance to ensure that we're creating best practices,
[0:35:59] to ensure that it is in compliance with our strategic plan,
[0:36:02] and more importantly, in compliance with our land use comprehensive plan.
[0:36:07] We wanted to make sure that we are taking a look at business retention, recognizing
[0:36:12] that recruitment is that nice, shiny, new prize, but business retention is really the
[0:36:20] key of good, strong economic development efforts.
[0:36:23] It's working closely with those companies that help create the very foundation of the
[0:36:28] Twin Falls Local Economy that makes us strong today.
[0:36:32] We wanted to make sure that we develop communications on it, and we are in the final process of
[0:36:37] of developing a welcome packet, but we want to make sure that we have the resources to be able to move that forward.
[0:36:42] The only citizen comment that we had last time was really in conjunction with the presentation that was made by Mandy Thompson,
[0:36:49] and that was to ensure that we are committing the resources that we need to take advantage of public transportation opportunities
[0:36:59] as they become required for us in the year 2020.
[0:37:04] That really does kind of talk about the broad goals that were initially stated by the City Council.
[0:37:11] As we did a quick glance, we found in those a direct tie to the city's strategic plan in moving forward whether it be from an accessible community, an environmental community,
[0:37:26] a responsible community, really making sure that all of those did make that time.
[0:37:31] So with that staff would stand for questions,
[0:37:35] would also seek any input that you have to offer the seat.
[0:37:39] So what we're going to do first council is just maybe
[0:37:41] have some comments from the council.
[0:37:44] And then of course, as always, we open it up
[0:37:47] to the community for any comment that they might have
[0:37:49] regarding the budget.
[0:37:50] We do that each and every time we talk about the budget.
[0:37:54] Greg Lanning.
[0:37:55] I would like to hone in, and this is probably going off
[0:37:58] script just a little bit, but I'd
[0:37:59] like to hone in on the under capital, the Canyon Springs
[0:38:04] grade design and improvement strategy, which, of course,
[0:38:07] is going to need some funding as well.
[0:38:10] And my conversations with our leadership at the IC,
[0:38:16] I believe there will be, at some point,
[0:38:19] if it's not this next session, it
[0:38:20] will be the following session.
[0:38:21] There will be a salt pond forgo, in other words,
[0:38:24] to eliminate forgo, and say, well, if you didn't need it,
[0:38:28] you don't need it now. And so I would like to at least have a discussion with
[0:38:34] Council and staff about utilizing and maybe as much as $1 million of our
[0:38:40] foreground amount for getting ready for that cost of implementing that design
[0:38:49] and if we went to your open house that the public works department had and
[0:38:58] and then talking to those people, there's obviously the building there, the Chief of the
[0:39:04] Street Department, talked dramatically, talked quickly about when I asked them where would
[0:39:09] you like to rebuild, and they quickly said, Eastland South, the site of our flood, here
[0:39:16] recently in the last couple of days as well, but they spent a lot of crew time, a lot of
[0:39:22] maintenance time on that section of the road, and it's time to rebuild it. So if we didn't
[0:39:27] use it on the canis print grade. We could certainly use it on rebuilding these
[0:39:31] ones south. Travis, maybe before I go on to the next council person talk to us a
[0:39:36] little bit about the Canyon Springs grade and what money we have dedicated
[0:39:40] and where we are with that. And then also maybe expand upon what is for gone
[0:39:45] balance because as we start using technical terms with us it's probably
[0:39:49] important for us to share what that means. I think it was better that you
[0:39:54] explain that instead of me I think that's good advice. And that's why we have our
[0:39:58] CFO here. I'm always ready to correct me when I get this wrong. So the as you're
[0:40:05] aware the City Council had allocated six hundred thousand dollars this year for
[0:40:09] the purposes of building a comprehensive engineering study to find the right
[0:40:12] solutions which is also going to include a community engagement piece. We engage
[0:40:18] the council about the level of community involvement and what that looks
[0:40:21] like, and we're creating the scope with a consultant and help right now in that piece.
[0:40:30] And we will bring that forward shortly.
[0:40:34] After we go through the public process and we define what the project looks like is about
[0:40:39] the time in which we're going to be able to really define what those costs are.
[0:40:43] And what we want to do in the process is not only share what the different possible solutions
[0:40:48] defined by the public are, but we also want to share what those costs would be as well as
[0:40:53] methodologies to pay for them. In Idaho, we're fairly restricted in when it comes to revenues
[0:40:59] that we have coming into our system. On an annual basis, cities can take 3% more revenue
[0:41:05] than they did the prior year by statutory allowance. The cities have the ability to take
[0:41:13] a bond to be able to cover the cost of the project depending upon the type of bond, or the type
[0:41:21] of fund will determine the type of bond. In this case, we'd be using property tax dollars or a fund
[0:41:27] that is fueled by property tax dollars. So any bond measure would require the super majority of
[0:41:33] 66 and 2 thirds percent approval as opposed to enterprise funds that are fee driven. Those are
[0:41:40] of the simple majority.
[0:41:42] The other is to save for it.
[0:41:45] And to save for that project means
[0:41:47] that you are going to be able to cover your immediate needs
[0:41:51] as a community and an organization,
[0:41:53] and you're able to put additional monies away
[0:41:56] over a period of time.
[0:41:59] Depending upon the option that is selected,
[0:42:01] we believe that the Canyon Springs Great Project could
[0:42:04] exceed seven, be as high as possibly $10 million,
[0:42:08] depending upon what that looks like moving forward.
[0:42:11] $10 million constitutes about 55, 60%
[0:42:17] of the total tax collections inside the City of Twin Falls.
[0:42:24] And we're guessing we really don't have a number
[0:42:26] because we haven't defined a solution
[0:42:28] because we're really much of that infancy.
[0:42:33] But as we look forward, the engineering piece
[0:42:37] that we've funded in budget is going to help unlock
[0:42:41] a whole series of possibilities which the council
[0:42:43] will be asked to make a series of possible suggestions
[0:42:47] and alternatives to fund it or to move it forward.
[0:42:51] And I think that as we look at Canyon Springs grade,
[0:42:54] I think the first and foremost thing that we look at
[0:42:56] is creating a safe roadway.
[0:42:59] And then we build after that being the first objective
[0:43:03] as has been stated by the council.
[0:43:05] This last legislative session, there was a, I believe a bill, it actually made it to bill form,
[0:43:15] where the foregone opportunity was to be eliminated by the members of the legislature.
[0:43:23] And the foregone balance is a simple term to say that every year the city has the ability to take 3% more revenue than it did the prior year.
[0:43:33] that statutory allowance. And any year that we don't, that money is placed over into this
[0:43:40] fictitious account. Now, it's monies that are never collected. But the Idaho Code says that
[0:43:47] the council reserves the right to go and collect monies that they could have in the past and
[0:43:55] elected not to. Our foregone balance is approaching $2 million. And that means that on an annual
[0:44:06] basis, the city of Twin Falls could increase property tax collections by about $1.8 to
[0:44:14] $2 million. Now it's not without an impact because in Idaho, the property tax rate is determined
[0:44:22] by total government spending divided by total taxable value of a community.
[0:44:28] We're in Idaho, we don't assess mills.
[0:44:30] We actually determine and spread those costs uniformly across all properties.
[0:44:35] And so if you significantly increase spending without significantly increasing the tax base,
[0:44:42] you will drive the tax rate.
[0:44:45] The foregone balance that we have created
[0:44:49] has equaled a property tax savings in excess of 10%
[0:44:55] on an annual basis.
[0:44:57] And so that means that through our processes that we use
[0:45:01] and the evaluations, taxes inside the city of Twin Falls
[0:45:06] are at least 10% less than what they otherwise would have been
[0:45:11] had the council always taken that 3% increase
[0:45:15] by just doing it.
[0:45:18] The City of Twin Falls is one of the few cities in Idaho
[0:45:21] that actually has a robust conversation
[0:45:24] about government spending and does not assume
[0:45:28] that we will automatically take the 3% into our revenue stream.
[0:45:32] Staff, as we're constructing this budget,
[0:45:34] is doing the same thing.
[0:45:37] Thank you, Travis.
[0:45:39] Chris, talking.
[0:45:41] Several comments, I'd like to acknowledge
[0:45:44] The many viable strategic options that our long-range planning group has presented, we're starting
[0:45:53] to take it for granted, but I'll hop back to the old days where Council will get together
[0:45:59] around a breakfast or two with very little city input until it came time to public hearings,
[0:46:06] often making decisions that did not address the internal needs, hence the service capability,
[0:46:13] the delivery capability of the city. We're in a tardly hair-printed, much healthier scenario
[0:46:20] and want to laud all of our department heads, led by Travis, for taking this, I think, really
[0:46:27] to a leadership position in this city. I would also like to take a little side comment. I just
[0:46:34] came back from a weekend, a week visit, a cousin in Central California, around Visalia, around
[0:46:41] the orange orchards in the foothills of the sequoias.
[0:46:47] Water is the longest, the biggest long-term threat to our viability, I firmly believe,
[0:46:54] and it was borne out by a newspaper article and a little paper that the greater water
[0:47:04] jurisdictional district that includes vice-allia, but other areas, has called for an immediate
[0:47:09] 32% reduction in that city's water, not to be phased in over a period of time, but starting
[0:47:16] yesterday and severe fines. City fines for anything in excess of what they're allowed to do either
[0:47:26] as individuals or collectively as a city. So our city is really on the cutting edge, I think,
[0:47:32] by going to our pressurized irrigation system of our, I think it's around 40% reduction from our
[0:47:38] high time of potable water, but I'm not thinking that we're serious enough on it yet the city
[0:47:44] needs to continue to be the leader through its advertising and promotion of and consideration
[0:47:53] of revamping the zoning ordinances that call for much less grass to be planted to be watered
[0:47:59] by any type of water. That's one of my priorities, not necessarily the lead one. I would guess
[0:48:06] personally, just into the comment column Travis, I would say that this next year, our
[0:48:13] capital projects, I want to see them be brought in on time and on or under budget.
[0:48:18] And that's going to take your full-time diligence and your reports to the Council have been extremely
[0:48:24] helpful so far on that.
[0:48:26] In addition, I think even though the foregone taxes are a temptation, Greg, they still will
[0:48:35] result in up to 10% increase in the taxes levied if we take the full amount if I understand your
[0:48:43] discussion correctly. I am much more concerned that we're just about at the maximum sustainable
[0:48:51] increase for property taxes for a substantial part of our community and I'm hopeful that our new
[0:48:59] growth is starting to come on is going to pay for some of our new projects but I will be very
[0:49:04] questionable about raising property taxes and or use of foregone.
[0:49:11] And the strategic plan, I think that that goes without saying we all about into it and
[0:49:15] hope that we see it complied with and the timetable kept with and to put our dollars in support
[0:49:24] of that strategic plan.
[0:49:27] Thank you.
[0:49:28] Thank you, Chris.
[0:49:30] I see no further lies, but I would like to weigh in.
[0:49:32] I think our list up here is fairly comprehensive, but maybe if I could reiterate a few areas,
[0:49:39] again, compensation, Travis, we need to stay on top of that.
[0:49:42] We don't want to slide backwards again.
[0:49:44] The most important thing that we have as a city is our people.
[0:49:50] Equipment is second.
[0:49:51] Our people are the ones that run the equipment, they're the ones that work with our community,
[0:49:55] so we need to be able to attract the brightest and the best.
[0:50:00] We've read a lean machine here and I want to see us continue that, but we need to treat
[0:50:04] our people fairly.
[0:50:05] So I'm glad that's on our list.
[0:50:08] Infrastructure stay on top of that.
[0:50:10] You highlighted some areas, but again, on my soapbox about water storage, I think that
[0:50:16] we're making some good inroads there, but we're not done.
[0:50:19] I think we need to continue with the water storage transportation corridors and specifically
[0:50:26] trails.
[0:50:27] the opportunity of going to Boise this weekend for my
[0:50:32] anniversary with my wife and I and we hit the green belt.
[0:50:35] I think the thing that hit me the most when I hit the green belt and we wrote that is how
[0:50:40] connected that is and how you can get all over town
[0:50:44] through a bunch of different corridors which I think we're sort of lacking here.
[0:50:48] I'd like to see an emphasis to continue on trying to
[0:50:52] bring these non-motorized corridors together
[0:50:58] because as we know that our community is changing,
[0:51:01] more people ride bikes, walk, those kind of things,
[0:51:04] and we need to embrace that for the future.
[0:51:09] Canyon Springs Road goes without saying, need some help.
[0:51:13] I actually went down yesterday to Canyon Springs Road
[0:51:16] and down the road and saw some damage
[0:51:19] from the recent storm that we had.
[0:51:24] Maybe you could highlight what,
[0:51:25] because I saw that we had an announcement
[0:51:27] that we closed the road for a little bit today, tomorrow?
[0:51:31] Is that going to be for tomorrow?
[0:51:33] Maybe you could highlight what that's all about,
[0:51:36] but I went down there to go kayaking,
[0:51:38] and it was, I couldn't believe how many people
[0:51:41] were traveling down that road, walking, riding,
[0:51:44] driving, it was packed down there.
[0:51:46] Of course, it was a holiday weekend,
[0:51:47] but we need to stay on top of that.
[0:51:50] I'm not, I appreciate what Greg said
[0:51:53] about the foregone balance,
[0:51:54] But I'm not ready to do anything with that until we know what the plan is.
[0:51:59] If the plan is that we have to do whatever it is and we need the money,
[0:52:04] then I certainly as a councilman person would look at that foregone balance to help solve that puzzle.
[0:52:10] That is an incredibly important roadway to not only the city infrastructure,
[0:52:16] but recreation and to the community at large.
[0:52:19] There's a lot of people that use that road.
[0:52:21] that road. I think that's all I wanted to say. Again, a great
[0:52:26] list and look forward to hearing from Sean Behringer.
[0:52:31] So Travis, this is maybe more of a question. In the long term
[0:52:37] planning committee's presentation, one of the one of the
[0:52:42] capital items that was discussed was the master
[0:52:44] transportation plan. So I know currently we have a little bit
[0:52:50] effort going on with the public transportation planning, kind of getting underway, got a
[0:52:58] lot of discussion about this multimodal transportation, trails, pedestrian friendly, non-motorized
[0:53:05] vehicle stuff. If the master transportation plan were to be funded and move forward, could
[0:53:12] it include these other components? For example, multimodal transportation for pedestrian and
[0:53:21] and bicycle friendly corridors, would that plan include that or would that be separate
[0:53:27] stuff?
[0:53:28] So that's going to fall under our city engineer, Jackie's not only request but also a level
[0:53:34] of expertise, so I'll have her addressed from the multi-modal, but when you're looking at
[0:53:40] the actual creation of what we're doing on the public transportation piece, that's going
[0:53:45] to be slightly different than outside of what I believe Jack's request is
[0:53:50] self-optimistic. Jacky Fields, our city engineer, welcome Jacky. Thank you. So if
[0:53:57] there's a component of the transit grant that should be incorporated into the
[0:54:02] transportation master plan, then it will be in the same manner that the
[0:54:07] comprehensive planning component that talks about fire station location. There's
[0:54:11] There's some recommendations from that piece of the study that applied directly to the Transportation
[0:54:20] Master Plan for being incorporated in there.
[0:54:23] Dennis is also working on parks and trails that have an impact on streets.
[0:54:29] The piece of what the budget that was developed for the Transportation Master Plan was intended
[0:54:36] to address collectors, materials, road balance sections,
[0:54:42] bicycles, previously requested in pedestrian buildings.
[0:54:50] So yes, it would include those things.
[0:54:52] Yeah.
[0:54:52] It can.
[0:54:54] Because my only, but all of these things are important.
[0:54:58] I mean, I've been looking back at some of our plans
[0:55:00] as we're getting ready to have our discussion that's
[0:55:02] going to be happening tonight at 6.
[0:55:03] And some of these plans are pretty dated.
[0:55:06] and the transportation plans of 2008 plan
[0:55:09] that touches on bicycles and let's make everybody
[0:55:15] get along in the same right of way,
[0:55:16] but not a lot of specifics related to it.
[0:55:19] So if we're gonna be moving forward in that direction,
[0:55:22] I think we should have a good solid plan,
[0:55:24] and I would hate to do a plan for pedestrian
[0:55:27] and bicycle connectivity, and then a year later,
[0:55:29] do the transportation plan and have it not jibe with that, so.
[0:55:34] I'll take it for what it's like.
[0:55:39] Thank you, Sean.
[0:55:41] Any other comments from council before I turn it over to the public?
[0:55:45] All right, ladies and gentlemen, we're going to give you about two minutes apiece.
[0:55:49] We'll give you a 30 second sign, but this is in respect to, I know a lot of folks just
[0:55:55] came in, I'm assuming some of you are here for the back-end parking.
[0:56:00] That's not yet.
[0:56:01] We're talking about the budget at this point, so we are going to open it up for public comment
[0:56:07] on the budget. There's anyone that would like to come forward. Seeing no one rush for the podium.
[0:56:18] If we said something about back-end parking and the budget, would you come forward? Really
[0:56:24] contrary, make the controversy. Back-end of the budget. Yeah, I can't do the budget.
[0:56:29] So, Mr. Mayor, members of the council and for the members of the audience, tonight is not
[0:56:35] the last time to have a conversation about the budget. We will have 10 additional conversations
[0:56:40] as we continue to move forward. We will have a two for sure one public hearing, official
[0:56:47] public hearing with the budget and possibly a second should there be any requested rate
[0:56:53] adjustments in excess of 5%, which we're not seeing or envisioning at this point, but in
[0:56:58] the event that those would come up, those do require a public hearing before the council
[0:57:03] prior to being implemented.
[0:57:08] Thank you, Travis.
[0:57:09] Just wanted to say for folks watching home and folks
[0:57:12] in the audience, again, as Travis said,
[0:57:14] where there's plenty of opportunity for you
[0:57:16] to engage us regarding the budget.
[0:57:18] This is, dare say, the most important thing
[0:57:21] that we do up here is set priorities for your money.
[0:57:25] So please don't be shy.
[0:57:27] You can keep track of what we're doing online
[0:57:29] and come to these meetings, but we really, truly
[0:57:33] do treasure your input.
[0:57:35] Don't just leave it to the seven of us.
[0:57:36] We want to hear from you, so don't be shy.
[0:57:39] Moving on to the next item.
[0:57:41] We do have two public hearings this evening
[0:57:44] that won't start before six.
[0:57:45] We're going to be successful there, because we're almost six.
[0:57:48] So the next item is public input.
[0:57:50] Again, this is for something that's not on the agenda.
[0:57:53] Is there anyone that would like to address the council
[0:57:55] on another item that's not on the agenda this evening?
[0:58:01] I will go to our city manager,
[0:58:02] anything further from our City Manager this evening. City Council sees that in Hawkins.
[0:58:08] Thank you. So I'm bringing forward a request on behalf of the City's Youth Council. In
[0:58:16] years past, we've had Youth Council members go to the AIC conference and we have paid
[0:58:23] half their registration fee if they match the other half. And we have three, possibly four
[0:58:29] students who would like to attend this year. And they would like us, I guess, I need our
[0:58:35] blessing on doing that as well. We also have two chaperones this year because we do have
[0:58:39] boys and girls both going. And I was going to see how you felt about paying half of their
[0:58:45] registration and how you felt about mileage for the chaperones going to boys seem back.
[0:58:50] And I will turn it over to council.
[0:58:51] Chris, talk.
[0:58:52] Yes, Susan, I don't know about the agenda for the AIC. Are there specific youth programs
[0:58:57] or are they going to be observing?
[0:58:59] You know, there is a whole conference just for them and they do join with us on parts of it.
[0:59:05] We had Hannah Bello, one of our past presidents, go two years ago and she said she learned more
[0:59:09] about preparing for college in those two and a half short days than anywhere else and it was
[0:59:13] really a good experience.
[0:59:16] I think I kind of like the way and I like the idea of sharing the cost of registration for
[0:59:22] the youth because I think that really builds some skills and some ownership and some skin
[0:59:28] in the game, if you will.
[0:59:29] So I would be supportive of that.
[0:59:32] Is there a registration for the chaperones?
[0:59:34] Yes.
[0:59:35] Okay.
[0:59:36] Full registration.
[0:59:37] I would be more supportive of paying the chaperones registration because they are taking
[0:59:42] time out of their life.
[0:59:44] They are taking time off work.
[0:59:46] So that would be my inclination.
[0:59:49] And chaperones are mandatory.
[0:59:51] Yeah.
[0:59:52] And they should be yes.
[0:59:54] Sean Bearer.
[0:59:55] So what would be the cost of all that?
[0:59:58] Students registration our half would be a hundred and forty seven fifty per child
[1:00:03] then depending a
[1:00:05] Chaperone's registrations two hundred and ninety dollars each and I believe mileage is around a hundred and forty five dollars
[1:00:11] And it would be one vehicle because they would go up together
[1:00:14] So you said a couple of chaperones two chaperones two chaperones, but they were right up in the same vehicle male and a female
[1:00:24] Yes, it's a mom and a dad going up. Yes any further direction council Greg lining. I move that we
[1:00:34] provide half of the registration fee for the youth council delegates, the four of them, and all of the
[1:00:41] registration fee for the chaperones and then pay whatever the city typically pays for mileage for
[1:00:51] a city employee, they would be the same for the mileage.
[1:00:55] Second.
[1:00:56] Motion on the floor by Greg Lanthine, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins.
[1:01:00] Chris talking.
[1:01:01] So, what you're going to calculate around and tell us what that comes to?
[1:01:04] I don't think we want to have six people going out and charging
[1:01:07] mileage to the city.
[1:01:08] Well, I will make it as part of my motion.
[1:01:12] She said there's only going to be one vehicle.
[1:01:14] OK.
[1:01:15] But four kids.
[1:01:17] There's three for sure.
[1:01:18] There's possibly a fourth.
[1:01:19] I don't know on the fourth one yet.
[1:01:24] Yeah.
[1:01:25] We have a motion on the floor and seconded anything further
[1:01:27] on the motion council.
[1:01:29] The aisle will call vote, please.
[1:01:31] Chris Tawkington.
[1:01:32] Yes.
[1:01:34] Greg Lantine.
[1:01:35] Yes.
[1:01:35] Don Hall.
[1:01:36] Yes.
[1:01:37] Susan Hawkins. Yes Jim on yes. John Berger. Yes. Motion passes six to zero. Thank you
[1:01:43] Suzanne. On behalf of the students. Thank you. I think you're making a wise investment.
[1:01:49] We are. So a question is that an item that's in our city council budget on an
[1:01:56] annual basis or does the youth council have its own area of budget. I'm looking at Travis as a
[1:02:02] question. So typically what we do is we take that out of the council's training
[1:02:08] line item however many years the council does a series of fundraisers that helps
[1:02:15] offset some of those costs. So youth council? Yes. Well quick the youth council
[1:02:21] does have many in their account but this year they have spent most of their
[1:02:25] funds on their selfie with the police officer campaign and they did buy a
[1:02:29] a billboard and some advertising so they do not have enough money in their account to cover
[1:02:34] this.
[1:02:36] So my only suggestion would be that for next year that we plan to budget this somewhere,
[1:02:43] either that it's just budgeted as part of our training or that the youth cancel be aware
[1:02:49] that if they are doing fundraisers with the projects that perhaps keeping a piece of the
[1:02:54] back or something like this might be a good way of teaching some budgeting there as well.
[1:02:59] suggestion Sean thank you counsel again I'm going to ask how we we talked last week regarding
[1:03:06] western days and potentially riding on the fire engine the ladder truck I'm assuming but
[1:03:11] Suzanne you said there might be a different option what did you find out it is just a single
[1:03:15] vehicle and not room for us we can walk we could certainly do that I could certainly use do
[1:03:23] to be on the fire trucks.
[1:03:26] So how many of us are three of us?
[1:03:29] I just don't know.
[1:03:30] Don't know yet.
[1:03:31] Don't rise possibly.
[1:03:32] Thank you.
[1:03:33] Okay.
[1:03:34] Very good.
[1:03:35] Council, I see nothing further on public input or city manager, city council.
[1:03:41] So I think it is time at six o'clock to move into our public hearings.
[1:03:47] So the first item, by the way, folks, if you're here to testify on the public hearing, there
[1:03:52] There is a sign up sheet in the back if you'd sign up, put which item that you would like
[1:03:56] to speak on, either item number one or two in the public hearing section.
[1:04:02] That would be great, I'd be grateful to that, it helps us get you up here in an orderly fashion.
[1:04:07] So the first item on our public hearings is a consideration of a request for a zoning
[1:04:12] title amendment, amending Title 10, Chapter 12, Section 2.5B regarding the timing for required
[1:04:20] improvements for conveyance, plats to be as determined by City Council and I
[1:04:26] believe we have Jonathan spend love are you on first or Brad wills it's Brad
[1:04:31] wills welcome mr. wills good evening I was thinking Jonathan was going first and
[1:04:50] by the time he got done so in planning zoning after Jonathan did his presentation
[1:04:58] And Fritz got up and talked a little bit
[1:05:01] that there was nothing left for me to do on that one.
[1:05:03] So I'll give you that same spiel on this one.
[1:05:06] So what's before you is a situation
[1:05:10] occurred when we were doing all these entitlements
[1:05:12] with the school district on the use of conveyance plats
[1:05:17] and the way that the current code is written.
[1:05:20] What originally conveyance plats typically dealt with
[1:05:24] is if we had like a 40 acre parcel on the corner
[1:05:28] and the farmhouse was right on the corner, and so the developer would get the 39 acres
[1:05:34] around the house, and he would develop that, and we end up with a little house in the corner
[1:05:38] with no development, no improvements.
[1:05:41] And so the way that the text was written, that if one or either of the two parcels in
[1:05:51] a conveyance plant that was split into two parcels, if one of those parcels went forward
[1:05:56] development, the other one had a development at the same time.
[1:06:01] So 15 years ago, maybe 10 years ago, over on the SACOT farm on Hankins, where the school
[1:06:09] property is, we separated out a two-acre parcel for the city for a Reshwaist irrigation station
[1:06:20] to go there.
[1:06:21] Technically, when we start doing our development, if we had never replanted, the city would
[1:06:28] be obligated to do their improvements once we started doing our improvements, the way that
[1:06:32] the code was written, and there was no way for the city council to waive that.
[1:06:39] So what the language before you is giving the city council the ability to make that a
[1:06:48] a requirement or maybe not make a requirement.
[1:06:50] So we just did a bunch of splitting of parcels
[1:06:54] so that we could sell off our excess parcel
[1:06:57] and build the school on the remaining parcel.
[1:07:02] But it makes no sense to go forward developing
[1:07:05] the secondary one.
[1:07:09] So, I have a hard time.
[1:07:15] I think we'll have some clarification questions.
[1:07:18] I was really prepared for Jonathan to come out here.
[1:07:22] Well, you can find that for work, so.
[1:07:25] And I'm going to stand for any questions.
[1:07:27] Do we have any questions for Mr. Wells?
[1:07:32] It doesn't look like we have any lights on right now, Brad.
[1:07:35] But there might be some questions for you.
[1:07:36] So we're going to go ahead and turn it over
[1:07:38] to Jonathan Spendlove for the staff report regarding this item.
[1:07:41] Welcome, Jonathan.
[1:07:43] I think Mr. Mayor, members of the Council,
[1:07:45] someone up with Brad, the staff report's pretty detailed
[1:07:48] as far as history and some more we're here for.
[1:07:50] This is the language that we have
[1:07:52] on the bread supplied for us.
[1:07:55] It's out of Code Section 1012, 2-500 conveyance plots.
[1:08:00] Line up portion will be deleted,
[1:08:02] underline portion is being requested to be added.
[1:08:06] In the end, what you have left with is a council's
[1:08:08] discretion to require abutting streets and utilities
[1:08:12] to be installed and accepted by the city
[1:08:14] at the time the building permitting
[1:08:15] for development stage.
[1:08:17] If either partial develops or is built on,
[1:08:19] City Council may require construction of street
[1:08:22] and utility improvements on both parcels.
[1:08:25] It becomes an action by the City Council
[1:08:26] to require if it deems necessary.
[1:08:29] It's no longer a shall.
[1:08:31] Really that sums up what we're dealing with.
[1:08:33] When you get into the conveyance plats,
[1:08:36] each one's gonna be different for each situation
[1:08:38] as far as where they're at,
[1:08:41] the roads that are located on.
[1:08:42] So this removes the requirement and has it
[1:08:45] be decision by the body, which they do.
[1:08:48] So, on April 28th, the Planning and Zoning Commission held the public hearing on the request.
[1:08:55] The public hearing had no public comment.
[1:08:56] During the deliberations, there was some concerns with removing the limitations for development
[1:09:03] under Convene's plan and the vagueness of the amendment upon conclusion of deliberations.
[1:09:08] There was a motion to recommend in all members present, voted in favor of the motion.
[1:09:13] If it is approved, it could affect properties within the area of impact, therefore this
[1:09:17] request will require a public hearing before the Board of County Commissioners.
[1:09:22] So conclusion if the Council feels the zoning entitlement does present it as appropriate
[1:09:26] staff recommends approval.
[1:09:28] That's all.
[1:09:29] Do we have any questions for either Jonathan or Brad?
[1:09:32] Chris talking to.
[1:09:33] I'm interested in that last conveyance item four.
[1:09:39] So the Council would retain the ability because of particular situations to require the development.
[1:09:47] Correct on both parcels great. We have that that option. Yes, so we have the flexibility
[1:09:55] We did not have before that's great
[1:09:58] Great lining Jonathan just so I have it's clear in my mind that the situation I'm thinking of is
[1:10:05] Actually one about south of town, but I will say any different places that
[1:10:10] Like Brad described you get a 40 acre possible and develop 39 acres of typically the houses in the corner of a 40
[1:10:16] or a corner of a 160, whatever the case may be.
[1:10:20] And so you end up with a situation
[1:10:21] where the whole development occurs,
[1:10:23] but we don't end up getting the intersection
[1:10:26] taking care of like we needed
[1:10:27] because 39 acres just got developed.
[1:10:29] So that was the reason for the rule originally.
[1:10:32] This would still give us the ability
[1:10:34] to require that corner to be done,
[1:10:36] but it also gives us the ability to say,
[1:10:38] no, we don't need it right now,
[1:10:40] or maybe it's not in the corner,
[1:10:42] it's somewhere else in the way.
[1:10:43] I just don't wanna get in a situation
[1:10:45] where we leave out sections and then we have sidewalks to nowhere because they go and then
[1:10:54] there's a 300 feet of no sidewalk and then you have a sidewalk again or streets that are
[1:10:59] widened. The example to me, you know, not this particular, this conveyance didn't cause
[1:11:05] this, but you come around a really beautiful Eastland road headed north that turns into
[1:11:09] pole wind and then also they get real narrow for a ways because one you got just houses
[1:11:14] here and then the other side hasn't developed yet so there's not any really
[1:11:17] way to take care of it. I just want to stay away from those but this in your
[1:11:21] opinion does this still give us the ability to take care of the first
[1:11:25] example I made where you get the corner this that needs to be improved but you
[1:11:28] can't because it's one of the one acre. This would this would allow you to be
[1:11:33] developed in the corner. Thank you. Jonathan you say because this has to do
[1:11:39] with the area of impact it will need to go in front of the board of County
[1:11:43] If they choose not to approve this, then it's done.
[1:11:48] So I'm going to look towards Frist and either who comes up or I give you the answer.
[1:11:53] Yeah, so we have areas within the city that this will potentially affect.
[1:12:01] So we would go ahead and adopt the ordinance, whether it would apply in the area of impact or not,
[1:12:07] would depend on whether or not the county commissioners would also approve it.
[1:12:10] Okay, so we would be covered on the city.
[1:12:14] In the city of the district.
[1:12:15] Very good. Thank you.
[1:12:16] Do we have any further questions, council, before I open it up to the public for their input?
[1:12:22] Suzanne Hopkins.
[1:12:23] Thank you.
[1:12:24] So how many times would you estimate the last 10 years?
[1:12:28] This has been an issue or do you foresee others coming up in the near future or kind of give me a feel for how many times this is going to come into play?
[1:12:39] I can give you the last three years.
[1:12:41] Okay, I'll take it.
[1:12:43] Okay, I'll take it.
[1:12:44] Okay, I'll take it.
[1:12:45] Okay, I'll take it.
[1:12:46] Okay, I'll take it.
[1:12:48] Okay, I'll take it.
[1:12:49] Okay, I'll take it.
[1:12:50] Okay, I'll take it.
[1:12:51] Okay, I'll take it.
[1:12:52] Okay, I'll take it.
[1:12:53] Okay, I'll take it.
[1:12:54] Okay, I'll take it.
[1:12:55] Okay, I'll take it.
[1:12:56] Okay, I'll take it.
[1:12:57] Okay, I'll take it.
[1:12:58] Okay, I'll take it.
[1:12:59] Okay, I'll take it.
[1:13:00] Okay, I'll take it.
[1:13:01] Okay, I'll take it.
[1:13:02] Okay, I'll take it.
[1:13:03] Okay, I'll take it.
[1:13:04] Okay, I'll take it.
[1:13:05] Okay, I'll take it.
[1:13:06] Okay, I'll take it.
[1:13:07] and they just want to sell it and get out of it.
[1:13:12] I don't believe it will prolong the process for them.
[1:13:15] It would be a decision by this body, but it will save some time.
[1:13:20] It will also give the flexibility that the City Council's
[1:13:22] looking for and some of the applicants are looking for.
[1:13:25] So as far as a tenure outlook, I don't know how it goes.
[1:13:29] No way.
[1:13:32] Guess.
[1:13:33] OK.
[1:13:33] Thank you.
[1:13:35] Shumbehr.
[1:13:36] Mitch is going to guess.
[1:13:37] No, I'm sorry.
[1:13:40] And so this code in a minute for conveyance plots came up in 2007, because we haven't
[1:13:44] been living with it yet for 10 years, but almost.
[1:13:48] In that time we've had probably a dozen or so conveyance plots come through.
[1:13:51] They haven't been real widely used, but they have been.
[1:13:55] And I would say about half and half are just a rough guess.
[1:13:59] About half and half are probably half of them fall into the reason why we adopted the
[1:14:04] code and are probably appropriate the way they were approved.
[1:14:08] And the other maybe half really are a little different than that and probably do benefit
[1:14:17] from something like this and on two or three of those, the city is probably a party and another
[1:14:27] two or three made the school district as a party.
[1:14:29] So this really benefits I think some of those public property owners.
[1:14:35] And then, but the reason that we came up with the amendment,
[1:14:39] it still applies for half the time we see these come through.
[1:14:45] Sean Darrow.
[1:14:47] So I'm going to walk through what if out in the area of impact.
[1:14:51] So there's 40 acres just outside the city limits.
[1:14:57] It's got a house on the corner.
[1:14:59] That owner goes through some process
[1:15:04] to keep their five acres around their house
[1:15:07] and sell the balance, and the developer buys the balance,
[1:15:12] and X's goes in for development.
[1:15:15] How do you deal with the five acres on the corner?
[1:15:23] So I think the way the wording that this happened,
[1:15:27] that is exactly the scenario why the wording
[1:15:31] was written the way it is in the first place.
[1:15:32] So in that case, we would probably
[1:15:34] bring a plat before the council with some conditions on it.
[1:15:38] The conditions in this case might be
[1:15:40] when the larger property develops,
[1:15:42] going to do the improvements on the smaller property as well. That is the exact reason
[1:15:46] for doing it. When the plaque comes through, we're going to have the right-of-way dedicated
[1:15:50] for those whitening of the arterial that's adjacent to the hypothetical scenario you described.
[1:15:56] And so we'll have the right-of-way done, and then when the larger property develops,
[1:16:05] you would place a condition on the approval that says that development is going to do
[1:16:08] those improvements across the little guy that's left over. Now, the contrast to that would
[1:16:13] be kind of exactly what the school district is doing right now on the property that falls
[1:16:19] in Sunway where the Sunway Soccer Complex is, that was a conveyance plant that split 90,
[1:16:25] 89 acres into 240-ish acre parcels. Either one of those parcels is plenty big enough to do
[1:16:33] their own improvements, but it might be a bit much to ask one to do the other parcels,
[1:16:39] shaker improvements and so that might be a perfect example where you would say
[1:16:44] maybe you don't and each when each develops they do their own thing as a
[1:16:49] as a contrast and in my hypothetical that would all come through our building
[1:16:56] department our planning and zoning commission our council right although
[1:17:01] may have to still go to the commissioners if it weren't annexed so in a it would
[1:17:06] run through our planning and zoning and engineering departments for review and
[1:17:09] then it would come straight to the council for approval because it's a
[1:17:11] conveyance plan we don't we don't go to the P&Z first with those now in an area
[1:17:15] of impact the council would make a recommendation to the county commissioners
[1:17:19] for approval wherein the city limits the council's decision would be final
[1:17:23] okay thank you any further questions for either Mr. Mills or Mr. Spindlop
[1:17:32] council all right at this point I am going to go ahead and open up the public
[1:17:37] testimony portion of this evening's hearing and ask for city staff to go back
[1:17:42] and take a look see if there's anyone on the list that would like to testify
[1:17:49] regarding item number one. Show of hands anybody here for item number one? Brad
[1:18:00] you've already taught. You're you're item number one?
[1:18:03] It's you gets more time after you do yes. Do you it's public testimony so go
[1:18:17] ahead and we can ask him the question afterwards, Leah. If you'd say your name and your address.
[1:18:22] I have a client to 50 Camarillo way. I have a question for Mr. Will's or maybe for Mitch.
[1:18:29] In regards to in Lou fees, I was trying to understand the effects of splitting properties.
[1:18:36] Does that affect the formula for in the fees or how would that?
[1:18:42] So Leah is asking about our park dedication requirement. This is what everybody kind of
[1:18:46] is aware and oftentimes with the park dedication
[1:18:48] will take fees in lieu of dedication.
[1:18:51] Convenience Platt does not require a dedication nor an in-lue
[1:18:57] that comes along the time when the final Platt comes through,
[1:19:00] which is later in the process.
[1:19:02] So this actually has no impact on that.
[1:19:04] Okay, thank you.
[1:19:06] Thank you, Leah.
[1:19:07] Oh, and Leah would know about that,
[1:19:08] she's a member of our Parks and Recreation Commission.
[1:19:11] Sure, sure, very good.
[1:19:12] Is there anyone here to testify on item number one?
[1:19:18] I'm going to go ahead and close the public testimony portion of the hearing and keep the
[1:19:23] public hearing open and allow our applicant to come forward again if he has some final comments.
[1:19:31] So just the high points, this is conveyance plats are not for development purposes, they're
[1:19:35] mainly just a split of property.
[1:19:38] I think the important part is all public right-of-ways and easement shall be dedicated.
[1:19:42] So when we do a conveyance plant, we do dedicate the right-aways at that time.
[1:19:46] And that's usually where we've gotten in trouble before, is we haven't handled right-aways.
[1:19:51] We've got the 25-foot, so I think that's the main point.
[1:19:54] But this is mainly improving an existing ordinance or code that we have.
[1:20:01] This just gives the council the ability to be a little more flexible and to stay in compliance.
[1:20:08] So that's all I have to say.
[1:20:10] Thank you.
[1:20:11] Thank you, Mr. Wills.
[1:20:14] Does council have any further questions of either staff or applicant or our public?
[1:20:22] Before I close the public hearing, which means that we go into deliberation, I know we had
[1:20:27] some conversation about this last time.
[1:20:28] Once we go into deliberation, we cannot ask any further question of the applicant or staff
[1:20:35] only to our city attorney for clarification of legal unless I reopen the public hearing
[1:20:41] again. Are there any questions council? Public hearing is now closed turn it over to council
[1:20:50] for their deliberation.
[1:20:52] We don't have an ordinance prepared tonight so if there's an approval we'll prepare one
[1:21:00] and bring it back in a future meeting.
[1:21:03] Chris talking to.
[1:21:04] I would move approval of the zoning title amendment for title 10 chapter 12 section 2.5b
[1:21:12] Regarding timing for required improvements for conveyance plats as determined by City Council and bring back the ordinance to City Council Roger
[1:21:19] Then I have a motion on floor by Christotan and seconded by Greg Lanting as stated anything further on that motion council
[1:21:28] The island roll call go puts great glancing. Yes, John Hall. Yes, Suzanne Hawkins
[1:21:34] Yes, Jim Mundt. Yes, Sean Berriger. Yes, he's talking yes motion passes six to zero ladies and gentlemen
[1:21:41] We have another public hearing, but I traditionally will
[1:21:45] Take a break at an hour and a half
[1:21:48] Something tells me that this next public hearing is gonna go a little longer than our last one so I am going to
[1:21:54] Ask for a break for seven minutes for the council and the public to take a little bit of a break
[1:22:00] So we will come back at six twenty five
[1:22:03] I'd like to reconvene the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council.
[1:31:15] It is May 26th, about 628.
[1:31:20] So the next item on the agenda is a public hearing regarding parking configurations on
[1:31:25] main avenue for main avenue redesign project.
[1:31:29] And we have Melinda Anderson going to lead the conversation.
[1:31:32] And then we are going to give time for the public to give us input on this.
[1:31:37] So we'll turn it over to Melinda.
[1:31:40] Thank you, Mayor. Good evening, Mayor and Council, thank you for this opportunity to have this
[1:31:45] public input into a pretty important part of the design process regarding main avenue. I'm
[1:31:50] going to do a reasonably short introduction and then ask Mandy Roberts from OTAC to make
[1:31:57] the rest of the presentation. Her presentation will include some new things that we just learned,
[1:32:04] just sent out to you today. But also she's gonna go over some of the some of that
[1:32:10] material that she's gone over before because there's so many new people here
[1:32:13] in the audience that may not have heard some of this information that she's going
[1:32:17] to provide to you tonight. So I just want to start out with a really brief history
[1:32:21] of why we're here tonight. As you know about a year ago as the Urban Renewal
[1:32:26] Agency in the city we're looking at doing a small downtown you know
[1:32:31] infrastructure project, a group of downtown business owners came to both the Council and
[1:32:36] the Urban Renewal Agency and asked that we slow down, look at what Maine Avenue and downtown
[1:32:44] really needs and think about the next 50 years rather than just tomorrow or next year.
[1:32:49] They wanted us to do that which was really, in my opinion, great advice and we actually
[1:32:54] heated that and so that's how the Urban Renewal Agency ended up hiring OTAC was because we wanted
[1:33:01] to go through a pretty extensive design process, along with public input.
[1:33:06] We know that public input is really important in this process,
[1:33:09] because downtown belongs to all of us.
[1:33:15] A couple of other things.
[1:33:17] One of the things that Mandy talked about, has talked about in the past,
[1:33:21] that she's probably going to reiterate tonight, but I just want to also talk
[1:33:23] about is that early on in the process, which started last fall with OTAC,
[1:33:29] was that we got some consensus from the community on some of their values regarding downtown.
[1:33:35] One is people really wanted to beautify Maynavity since that's the project we're working on.
[1:33:41] People really are interested in making it pedestrian, bicycle, and vehicle friendly, basically
[1:33:46] available for everyone to use.
[1:33:49] We wanted to create a great new open space, and we wanted downtown and Maynavity would
[1:33:54] be a place that people want to be.
[1:33:56] So those are some of the overall values that we heard from the public through a lot of different
[1:34:03] types of venues.
[1:34:07] As I mentioned earlier, Mandy has created a new matrix that is new from the one that we
[1:34:14] sent you with the board, or what's, excuse me, with the council packet.
[1:34:17] This new one will actually is an expansion of option number two.
[1:34:22] So there will be a 2A and a 2B that Mandy will show you.
[1:34:26] And the reason it came up is we determined that if we change the angle of the parking configuration,
[1:34:33] it could actually create more spaces.
[1:34:35] So option two right now is looking at front and angle parking on both sides of the street
[1:34:40] along the five blocks of main avenue.
[1:34:44] We found that if we did a little bit changing of the angle, we could actually, it would reduce
[1:34:50] a little bit of the parking spaces but might increase a little bit of the sidewalk space.
[1:34:55] me and he's going to go into more detail on that. But I wanted to tell you why this recently came up.
[1:35:02] So I also wanted to tell you know as you know the council requested and staff developed a parking
[1:35:07] demonstration area along main avenue. It was basically in front of the Zahn main avenue south,
[1:35:14] several spaces both in front of the 11th bank as well as St. Vincent de Paul's store.
[1:35:21] It was, and we had it up, it'll be up until tomorrow morning, I believe the
[1:35:26] department will be taking it down. So we had it up for two weeks. We had, it was
[1:35:32] probably, I don't know if I'm going to call a successor failure, we just were, there were people that came in and tried it.
[1:35:38] There were some people that decided they didn't want to try it, so they parked front end. So you probably, if you had traveled down Main Avenue, you may have seen people parked both ways in those particular parking areas.
[1:35:49] because they may not have understood that this was a test
[1:35:52] and may not have understood that we were trying to back in.
[1:35:55] So you probably saw some of both.
[1:35:58] We did ask people who did try the demonstration,
[1:36:02] or excuse me, the parking demonstration.
[1:36:05] The parking demonstration with a fill out a survey online
[1:36:11] that was on the city's website.
[1:36:14] There were actually 78 people who actually took that survey.
[1:36:18] Of those 78 responses, 67 said they actually tried the parking and 11 said they did not
[1:36:28] try the parking.
[1:36:29] They didn't actually go through the demonstration.
[1:36:31] They just decided they wanted their views known, so they decided to answer the survey.
[1:36:40] So if you were to look at the 67 who did actually try the demonstration area, 42 of
[1:36:47] them thought it was a really poor or just poor idea.
[1:36:52] Five folks said they weren't sure or they were neutral on it.
[1:36:55] And 20 people said this is good and very good or good to excellent.
[1:37:00] So there was still, as you can tell from the survey, and
[1:37:03] I gave you copies of the whole survey with all of the responses.
[1:37:09] Because it wasn't just yes or no or a rating.
[1:37:11] There were also a lot of them that actually we had a space where people could actually
[1:37:15] write comments and there were a lot of comments on these. So, you know, as far as the survey
[1:37:23] concerned, if you look at the numbers, definitely people who answered the survey said, you know,
[1:37:30] we're not too excited about it. So that was what the survey said. So at this point, I'm
[1:37:35] going to sit down and ask me and Edna come up and go through the presentation with you.
[1:37:40] Thank you very much.
[1:37:41] Thank you, Melinda. Welcome, Mandy.
[1:37:43] Thank you, Melinda and Mayor, Council.
[1:37:47] Thanks for listening to the background again on the project.
[1:37:52] And as Melinda said, I have some new information to share.
[1:37:56] We also wanted to share some information that we shared in the May 11 meeting
[1:38:02] just because we knew we'd have new people here tonight to just hear the background.
[1:38:06] So I'm going to just talk a little bit about our approach in designing main avenue
[1:38:12] and this 50-year vision that we're working towards touch on the past and current conditions
[1:38:19] on the main avenue corridor.
[1:38:22] And then I will go through the cross-section options that are in the matrix that you have
[1:38:26] before you.
[1:38:27] And really the trade-offs, the characteristics of each option in detail, and then I'll just
[1:38:34] close with a few considerations in the decision-making process.
[1:38:40] So it's interesting, you know, this is really, it's certainly a once-in-a-lifetime project
[1:38:46] for me as a designer, and it's really only something that we do, you know, something like
[1:38:53] this of this scale every 40 or 50 years or so in a community.
[1:38:58] And so when we think about that as designers, we're not only trying to balance what's out
[1:39:03] there today, how people are using Main Avenue today, but we're also thinking ahead, you know,
[1:39:08] How are people going to be using this corridor in the future?
[1:39:12] And so, you know, some of the demographics that we've been studying and trends that we're
[1:39:18] seeing is that we can expect in the future as land use has changed downtown and we have
[1:39:25] more of a mixed use environment with more housing, we can expect to see aging baby boomers, of
[1:39:33] which I am one, so that generation of folks
[1:39:36] is really showing a strong interest in downsizing,
[1:39:40] relocating to urban areas, and that demographic
[1:39:44] is also a really active older adult demographic.
[1:39:48] Those folks wanna live somewhere where they can walk,
[1:39:50] where they can bicycle, whereas they think about
[1:39:54] living out their lifetime, they have access
[1:39:57] to everything they need within a short distance.
[1:40:00] We're also seeing the millennial generation who are coming of age, starting to rent and
[1:40:07] buy properties.
[1:40:09] They're showing a really strong interest in downtown areas.
[1:40:12] And this is happening all throughout the country and particularly in the West.
[1:40:16] There's a lot of research and studies that are showing this.
[1:40:19] And again, this generation is really interested in very walkable neighborhoods, urban settings
[1:40:25] where they can go get an ice cream cone with their family, go out to dinner, sit inside
[1:40:30] what cafes and that kind of thing.
[1:40:32] So as we design a place like this, we're thinking not only about what's happening now, but what's
[1:40:38] going to happen in the future and who are the future customers that will be downtown and
[1:40:44] what will Twin Falls as a community be like in 40 or 50 years from now.
[1:40:49] So I think all of us need to kind of put that future hat on as we think about the solutions
[1:40:54] that we're going to talk about in a few minutes.
[1:40:56] As far as past and current conditions on Main Avenue,
[1:41:00] they're over the generations.
[1:41:02] There have been a lot of changes.
[1:41:04] You know, we look at this example from the 1940s,
[1:41:07] and it was a very busy, active place.
[1:41:09] We're maximizing the parking,
[1:41:11] and we've got a lot of people on the sidewalks.
[1:41:14] We don't have a lot of trees.
[1:41:15] We don't have a lot of areas for landscape or sidewalk cafes.
[1:41:19] So just a rural, different era.
[1:41:22] And then when we, oops, sorry.
[1:41:23] Then when we look at, you know, the improvement that took place in the late 1960s, there was
[1:41:31] a lot of thought and care given to changing that dynamic and really creating more spaces
[1:41:36] for pedestrians, less parking areas, and a lot more furnishings and streetscape elements in
[1:41:44] the design.
[1:41:46] So we have, we don't have cross-section information from the 1940s version, but we do have a survey
[1:41:53] that tells us exactly what the dimensions are for this piece that was built in the three
[1:41:58] block area from Gooding to Idaho.
[1:42:03] And so with that, one thing that we learned when our survey information came in is that
[1:42:11] interestingly enough that the parking areas and the travel lanes are less dimension than
[1:42:18] the current code and engineering standards would dictate for today.
[1:42:23] So you see on this example, we've got existing today about 10 and a half foot travel lanes
[1:42:29] and we have about 16 feet for the parking bays themselves and then really important,
[1:42:37] the 14 and a half foot sidewalks on each side which really feel nice today and there's
[1:42:42] a lot of space for sidewalk cafes and people to put storefront displays and things like
[1:42:47] that out so that 14 and a half feet is a good measurement if we think about
[1:42:52] what's out there today and what we want for the future for the sidewalk space.
[1:42:56] Mandy could I stop you? Yes. Could you go back? Oh sure of course. You said that
[1:43:03] what we have today doesn't match the engineering best practices essentially
[1:43:08] right or code are there codes saying that roads have to be wider than this
[1:43:13] that's that's the question that I've heard from folks on a couple different
[1:43:16] Are there truly codes or is it just engineering best practices?
[1:43:21] There is a parking design code, and we've been looking at that in terms of the space for the stall widths and the aisle width.
[1:43:31] And that is a city, it's adopted as part of city code for parking design.
[1:43:37] And I don't know if Jackie, if you want to speak to the engineering standards, because I know there is some flexibility and we have been working on that as well.
[1:43:45] not as well because that's one of the questions that keeps we keep hearing and
[1:43:49] we want we want clarification is this codified or is it just engineering best
[1:43:54] practices Jackie Fields our city engineer
[1:43:59] good evening stall dimensions are in the code in the 1970s the road lane with by
[1:44:14] policy and perhaps transportation master plan would have been about 11 feet so
[1:44:21] So they certainly were 11 feet 20 years ago.
[1:44:27] So the parking area is codified.
[1:44:30] The road width is not.
[1:44:32] Is that what I just heard you said?
[1:44:34] The road width is not.
[1:44:36] And there is some standard of care considerations.
[1:44:44] For instance, it's very difficult to have your road at less than 9 feet.
[1:44:50] That is a very narrow road.
[1:44:53] We have tried to provide roads with a 12 foot driving lane because that provides you some room to accommodate other uses, wider loads.
[1:45:07] I think Jim Munn has another question.
[1:45:10] I was going to ask if one was going to conceptually take Main Street as it is now with 14.5 foot sidewalks, 10.5 foot driving lanes.
[1:45:25] Rebuild this exactly like it is now in a new and improved way. Could we do it legally legally?
[1:45:34] Do it front and angle parking
[1:45:38] Roads the same rebuild the sidewalks make it is it legal to do that?
[1:45:47] Well, I mean that would be helpful. It would be I got to make the call here. So yeah, whatever the answer is yes, okay
[1:45:54] Okay, ladies and gentlemen, I'm going to ask you please not to do that because we're in the middle of gathering information.
[1:46:06] We're going to be asking questions back and forth on different issues, different sides of this equation.
[1:46:13] And so when we get that, that's not helpful to us.
[1:46:17] We're going to give you an opportunity to come forward here in a few minutes to give us your input and your testimony.
[1:46:23] And we're looking forward to that as well.
[1:46:25] So the plotting on one side or the other of this equation is not helpful to us, I appreciate it.
[1:46:33] Thank you, Jack.
[1:46:34] So I have a brief follow-up to that.
[1:46:36] So as a brief follow-up to Jim's question.
[1:46:38] So while it could be built that way today to meet the requirements of our code,
[1:46:44] it would have the same level of functionality that it has today as well.
[1:46:48] Meaning it gets cars from one end of the street to the other and allows parking.
[1:46:53] that's accurate as long as you don't have a substantial increase in pedestrians and driving traffic.
[1:47:01] Because this is much more designed for vehicle traffic, not necessarily multi-modal transportation
[1:47:14] of pedestrians and bicycles and vehicles.
[1:47:17] That's also accurate.
[1:47:19] Thank you.
[1:47:20] planning.
[1:47:21] And again, follow up to Jim's resort for trying to gather all the information we can here.
[1:47:26] One of the other things we've heard in other, the many meetings I've been to on this about
[1:47:32] the legality of our parking as far as crossing the center line to back out and sure if you
[1:47:38] have a small car, you can probably back up and you've got a 22 foot pickup, maybe not.
[1:47:44] So, is it possible to have a real listing to have to have a type of lanes and still be able to back out and not cross the tunnel?
[1:47:54] I mean, you probably get it done, but is it real listing?
[1:47:57] Not for all vehicles, and certainly not for many drivers.
[1:48:01] Okay, thank you.
[1:48:02] All right, that's all the questions we have at this point.
[1:48:06] Mandy, you're back up. Thank you, Jackie.
[1:48:11] Okay.
[1:48:14] So I guess just to get at some of those questions and try to show them graphically, what we've observed down along Maine on several occasions is a lot of times we'll see extra big trucks and longbed pickups and vans and even work trucks that are parked and they're extending out over the valley getter.
[1:48:37] And sometimes even into the lane of travel.
[1:48:42] And so in working with engineering staff, first of all the biggest concern is the visibility.
[1:48:50] As you're backing out, you just don't, you're backing out blindly and you just don't have that view of oncoming traffic.
[1:48:57] And so then secondly, as we all just talked about some folks in order to give themselves extra room around these longer vehicles
[1:49:06] are backing out over the center line, which is a concern.
[1:49:11] So just to recap what's happening today, out there
[1:49:15] in our five block zone, and remember our project is really
[1:49:18] focused from Fairfield to Jerome, we have 186 parking spaces
[1:49:23] out there today.
[1:49:25] And we have 14 and a half foot sidewalk, amenity zone space.
[1:49:29] We do not have formal bicycle facilities.
[1:49:31] And by that, I mean, we have no striping or anything
[1:49:34] that indicates that there's a bicycle way.
[1:49:38] And for that reason, today it's not really a complete street
[1:49:42] as we would define complete streets.
[1:49:46] So we've been working under the premise
[1:49:48] or understanding that we've got a 90 foot right of way
[1:49:52] to work with.
[1:49:53] We're certainly not going to be going
[1:49:54] beyond that 90 feet downtown.
[1:49:57] And so we have to really budget our space.
[1:49:59] And how do we do that if, in fact, we do need wider lanes
[1:50:04] and longer parking stalls, that starts to really cut into the space for bicyclists, you know,
[1:50:14] depending on if we have sherros or bicycle lanes, of course, the amenities, the trees,
[1:50:20] light poles for machines, aspects like that that are part of the streetscape, as well as probably the last
[1:50:28] but not least and probably the most important for creating a really vibrant downtown,
[1:50:32] having sufficient sidewalk and pedestrian space.
[1:50:37] So to us, balancing all of these priorities and values
[1:50:42] has been a challenge, you know,
[1:50:44] because we have a limited amount of space.
[1:50:47] We can't do everything to a best practice standard.
[1:50:50] So what are the trade offs
[1:50:52] and where do we start to look to share space
[1:50:55] and still achieve these priorities,
[1:50:58] which we've heard through a number
[1:51:01] of public meetings, stakeholder meetings.
[1:51:03] We've met with groups that are really interesting.
[1:51:06] Having main avenue B, a bicycling route
[1:51:09] to take them to the favorite restaurant
[1:51:12] and what not downtown.
[1:51:13] So that's really why we started to look at the different cross
[1:51:17] section options initially.
[1:51:20] And the first option being back and angled parking
[1:51:24] on both sides.
[1:51:25] And we had a lot of discussion with our project advisory group
[1:51:29] about that because it really seemed to achieve a lot of the objectives that we were trying
[1:51:35] to achieve and it just kind of became low-hanging fruit and as a matter of fact we had a project
[1:51:41] advisory committee meeting in April where there were about 14 people in attendance, a
[1:51:46] few people were not in attendance but of the 14, 12 in an informal straw poll, but 12 voted
[1:51:54] that we should proceed with, you know,
[1:51:57] back and angled parking as the design.
[1:52:00] So, you know, we had been kind of working down that route,
[1:52:04] but then hearing that concerns were mounting in the community,
[1:52:08] we started to look at other options
[1:52:10] and really look at the trade-offs on space.
[1:52:12] So, tonight, I'm gonna show you five different options.
[1:52:16] Option one, which is the back and angled parking
[1:52:18] on both sides, and then we now have two variations
[1:52:23] of head and angle parking on both sides.
[1:52:25] And then we also have two options that look at parallel
[1:52:29] on one side with either back end or front end angled.
[1:52:34] So with back and angle on both sides
[1:52:36] and using the dimensions that we'd worked the staff on
[1:52:39] previously, we're able to retain a sidewalk amenity space
[1:52:44] of about 13 and a half feet.
[1:52:47] Everyone felt really comfortable with that.
[1:52:49] And then also, we're able to stripe sheros in the travel lanes.
[1:52:57] That's what sheros look like.
[1:52:58] I know you guys have them around town, but basically it's a signal to both drivers or motorists
[1:53:04] and bicyclists that they're sharing that space and they should operate that way.
[1:53:09] So the other benefit that, you know, back in angle parking related to what I presented earlier
[1:53:16] is after you're backed into the space,
[1:53:20] when you're ready to pull out,
[1:53:21] you have a direct oncoming view of cars,
[1:53:26] as well as, whoops, sorry, let's go do that again, pardon me.
[1:53:33] The wrong one.
[1:53:34] Yeah, here we go, okay.
[1:53:37] You have a direct oncoming view of cars,
[1:53:40] as well as bicyclists,
[1:53:43] and because of that orientation
[1:53:46] versus head and angle and that visibility and safety aspect,
[1:53:51] then the city feels comfortable striping
[1:53:55] sheriffs in the travel lanes with back and angle parking.
[1:53:59] And so that's the other thing is you can just pull right out
[1:54:02] into the lane of travel without that whole maneuverability
[1:54:08] issue that I showed you earlier of backing out over the center
[1:54:12] line with some drivers.
[1:54:15] So the statistics on the back and angled parking option one is we're able to get 198 parking
[1:54:22] spaces within the five blocks, which is an increase of 12 spaces over what's there today.
[1:54:29] We're able to retain sidewalk space of 13 and a half feet.
[1:54:33] We can get bicycle facilities in in the way of Sherro's and then therefore we have a
[1:54:38] complete street.
[1:54:41] So a lot of folks have said, and we're listening to this and feeling that it needs to be addressed,
[1:54:50] we've heard from some merchants that there's a real concern if their customers are not able
[1:54:57] to do back-and-angle parking, you know, what's going to happen or are they just going to leave,
[1:55:01] take their business elsewhere, do we make it that much harder for people to come downtown?
[1:55:06] And so I just wanted, since we are going to be talking about parking quantities a lot tonight,
[1:55:10] I thought it would be helpful to put this back up as a graphic.
[1:55:14] We did an inventory of the public, basically the areas that are open for public parking
[1:55:20] around the five, excuse me, the five block zone of our project.
[1:55:25] And so just to kind of again reiterate some of the numbers, there are 96 spaces today
[1:55:32] on the three blocks from Gooding to Idaho.
[1:55:35] As I mentioned, there's 186 spaces with all five blocks.
[1:55:39] This is a piece of the total 997 public parking spaces in the five block area.
[1:55:48] So there's a lot of other spaces and we've talked about that before, you know, behind
[1:55:52] main avenue and on the cross streets where people can park if they don't feel comfortable
[1:56:00] with back end for example or with parallel for that matter.
[1:56:03] This doesn't include some of the additional private spaces that are scattered throughout
[1:56:08] downtown.
[1:56:09] I do want to mention though that one block of big concern, we've had a lot of talk and
[1:56:16] a lot of comments about this, is the Gooding to Shoshone block.
[1:56:19] It happens to be the block that has the highest demand for parking, and that's where the
[1:56:23] Orpheum is located, and the least amount of capacity because it's busy, but also because
[1:56:30] because it doesn't have as much surrounding parking as some of the other blocks.
[1:56:35] So that is a concern.
[1:56:37] So with options one and two, just to mention this, we are actually, we would be increasing
[1:56:45] the level of parking on Main Avenue.
[1:56:47] Options three and four don't do that.
[1:56:49] They actually decrease the parking.
[1:56:53] So let's look at option two.
[1:56:55] The first thing we looked at because this is really what's out there today in the three
[1:56:59] block improvement area is a 60 degree angle parking and we thought we would just carry
[1:57:04] that forward.
[1:57:05] People are used to that and so as as shown here the concern there with the longer spaces
[1:57:14] and the travel lanes for maneuverability is that that would eat up a lot of sidewalk
[1:57:19] space on each side of the street and I'm sorry I got this way so statistics for that
[1:57:26] was although we were going to get 208 parking spaces total in the five blocks, we were concerned
[1:57:33] about the sidewalk amenities being reduced in size.
[1:57:39] The other concern is that we really wouldn't have any ability to stripe bicycle facilities
[1:57:46] or have formal bicycle facilities.
[1:57:47] There's just not enough space with this design.
[1:57:53] One thing that happened also concurrently with the demonstration project is we started
[1:57:58] looking at what an 11 and a half foot sidewalk would look like, how it would function.
[1:58:06] This is in front of the bank, D11's bank.
[1:58:11] In this particular area, it's not so much of a concern because it's mostly through traffic,
[1:58:16] pedestrian traffic.
[1:58:18] In a lot of areas where we have sidewalk cafes, trees, light poles, landscaping, that 11 and
[1:58:24] a half feet just was starting to be really a concern to us.
[1:58:29] So we thought, well, okay, if we're really going to be looking at these options, we need
[1:58:36] to look at what would happen if we introduced a 45-degree angle and actually from gooding
[1:58:42] to Fairfield is strived at 45 degrees today.
[1:58:46] So we do have a precedent, there are also other streets downtown that have 45 degree striping.
[1:58:52] And that actually allows us to recapture more sidewalk space on each side.
[1:58:57] We can get back up to 13 foot sidewalks on each side.
[1:59:04] 45 degree parking is not as efficient as 60 degree parking.
[1:59:07] So instead of 208, we're back down to 198 spaces with that, but it's still 12 spaces more than
[1:59:16] what's out there today. Oh and I guess the other the other difficulty is we still
[1:59:22] just wouldn't be able to have enough space for striping sherros or having
[1:59:27] bike lanes so bicycling is a question with this option. So quickly because I know we
[1:59:34] want to get to the public testimony I just want to cover the other options real
[1:59:39] quickly so we did look at back and angle parking on one side parallel parking on
[1:59:44] one side. What that does is you can see from the dementia series, it really increases the
[1:59:51] sidewalk width. And we can treat that sidewalk width as flexible space so we can either take
[2:00:02] some of that and widen lanes to provide sheroes for bicycling or we can also look at the possibly
[2:00:08] of raised bicycle lanes. I'll go through that in more detail. So this option does give
[2:00:13] us bicycle facilities and it does give us a complete street. We also looked at head and
[2:00:19] angle parking on one side, parallel on the other side, dimensions are slightly different.
[2:00:27] But with both of these, we have less parking spaces than what's out there today, just because
[2:00:34] parallel parking is less efficient than the angled parking that's out there today. And
[2:00:40] And so I wanted to just show you how these dimensions work, because I realize it may not
[2:00:44] be completely clear.
[2:00:46] Mandy, before you do that.
[2:00:48] Oh, yes.
[2:00:49] Okay.
[2:00:50] Okay.
[2:00:51] So with either head in or back in angle parking on one side in parallel on the other side, we're
[2:00:55] looking at that sidewalk space, amenities on space as flexible space.
[2:01:01] And so we can take dimension out of that space to increase travel lanes to add Sherrios in
[2:01:10] the lanes and still have adequate sidewalk width, similar to what's out there today.
[2:01:18] Another idea that's come up is the idea of looking at potentially a raised bike lane,
[2:01:24] bike lanes on either side of the street.
[2:01:27] The reason why that works really well with front and angled parking is it puts the bicycle
[2:01:32] movement above the curve on the sidewalk in front of the vehicle rather than behind if
[2:01:38] if you're trying to fit a lane in behind a vehicle,
[2:01:41] to the park vehicles, it doesn't work as well.
[2:01:44] So just to show you what that would look like,
[2:01:47] we'd be taking space out of the sidewalk community zone
[2:01:50] to create bike lanes, raised bike lanes,
[2:01:55] some folks also call these cycle tracks.
[2:01:58] And I think I showed this picture when I was here
[2:02:01] a couple of weeks ago, this is Higgins Avenue in Missoula,
[2:02:04] just to give you one example of,
[2:02:06] So it's becoming a trend to do this type of design downtowns,
[2:02:10] but here's the bike lane that's raised on the sidewalk.
[2:02:15] It really, if we went down that route,
[2:02:18] we'd really need to study it a little bit more
[2:02:20] and really understand the implications
[2:02:22] to the sidewalk width.
[2:02:26] I did wanna point out that there are a few selected locations
[2:02:29] where we're considering having festival streets,
[2:02:32] raised streets where we would not have parking on one side
[2:02:37] and the parking on the other side would be designed according to whichever option we choose.
[2:02:43] One of those as an example is within the Gooding to Shoshone block where we've been meeting
[2:02:49] with the stakeholders on that block and there's a strong interest in having no parking on
[2:02:54] the northerly side where O'Dunkins and Slice and Sandwich Company because that really provides
[2:03:05] a lot of space for sidewalk cafes and we don't have parking oriented next to those areas.
[2:03:10] So it's a really, it's a great way of orienting parking and also providing space for extra space
[2:03:18] on the sidewalk for displays and cafes. And so speaking of that, if you look at some of
[2:03:24] the places that are out there today, we have in front of the Euroshop, we have a sidewalk
[2:03:29] a cafe space that can fit in four feet.
[2:03:32] We also have in front of ground around a larger table
[2:03:36] and chairs assembly that fits in eight feet.
[2:03:40] So it's really important to know that we're
[2:03:41] going to be adapting this design, whichever design we
[2:03:45] choose, to accommodate these spaces along main avenue.
[2:03:51] For example, today where that sidewalk cafe
[2:03:55] is in front of ground around, that happens
[2:03:56] to be an area that's a bowl-bout mid-block crossing.
[2:04:00] So we can do the same thing in the future design
[2:04:03] to make sure that that space is accommodated.
[2:04:05] And I think there was a question last time about,
[2:04:08] okay, that's great for the sidewalk cafes
[2:04:10] that are here today.
[2:04:11] How do we deal with future?
[2:04:14] So there's a lot of different ways that communities
[2:04:16] are dealing with that.
[2:04:18] This example from Portland,
[2:04:21] you can see that this is kind of the normal sidewalk area
[2:04:25] here, and then this is actually the parking lane that's temporarily taken up by
[2:04:32] planter space and sidewalk cafe space. This is another example from Colorado,
[2:04:40] which is a little bit more easy to visualize, so this is a deck platform that
[2:04:47] folks put out only in the summer and with the railing around it, and then that
[2:04:51] becomes extra cafes space during the summer in front of the restaurant over a
[2:04:57] couple of different parking spaces there. So there's a lot of different ways to
[2:05:03] create parklets or portable cafes spaces and even in the rain people find
[2:05:10] usefulness of these areas so I think it's something you know that we could
[2:05:15] really consider for the future to adapt the main avenue designed to fit future
[2:05:19] needs. So lastly, I just want to wrap up by saying that, you know, there's a lot of considerations
[2:05:27] here that Council is going to be weighing, obviously, should main avenue be designed for
[2:05:33] all modes, pedestrian, bicycle and vehicle. Our wider sidewalks and amenity area is important.
[2:05:41] Does the city want to keep main avenue as a bicycling route with striping, whether it's
[2:05:45] Sherrows or bike lanes, is more parking or less parking important.
[2:05:51] And then again, how can the design balance the current concerns with future trends and
[2:05:56] our aspirations to really create a Deere vision?
[2:06:02] So I think there'll be a lot of input tonight and of course we've gotten the questionnaires
[2:06:07] and a lot of comments on those and considering those values as part of your decision making
[2:06:13] criteria would be advised.
[2:06:15] Thank you very much.
[2:06:16] Mandy, we have some questions, but before we do that, just remind the audience if you're
[2:06:20] wanting to testify this evening, if you wouldn't mind going back and signing in so we can bring
[2:06:24] you up here orderly, that would be greatly appreciated.
[2:06:27] Sean Berger.
[2:06:28] So, Mandy, back on option 2B, and you may not be able to answer this, so I know that this
[2:06:39] particular design doesn't support bicycle facilities. I understand the space
[2:06:48] constraints of a dedicated bike lane, but considering that the traffic speeds in
[2:06:57] this five-block section are relatively low, I mean you're hard-pressed to go 20 down
[2:07:04] mean avenue? Could they not be striped or still be painted with
[2:07:11] sheroes as hay cars, there are bicycles, hay bikes, there are cars, and still
[2:07:19] accommodate that? Yeah, so we did a little research to look at what sort of
[2:07:26] the minimum lane dimension of sheroes is because it varies, but as a best
[2:07:32] practice we were seeing no narrow where the 13 feet also saw a lot of 14s and 15s out there
[2:07:41] including Moscow Idaho as an example and that was closer to 15 feet so you could
[2:07:49] adapt this design you would have to find another foot in the sidewalk area or the
[2:07:56] parking lane and maybe this is a question for staff so complete streets
[2:08:04] isn't this is what a complete street is go follow the instructions complete
[2:08:10] street is safe transportation for multiple modes of transportation bicycles
[2:08:17] pedestrians vehicles and there's some flexibility in design and maybe concept
[2:08:26] that then would lead to policy.
[2:08:30] So we don't necessarily have policy currently.
[2:08:35] I'm looking at both Travis and Jackie.
[2:08:38] We don't have written policy that says,
[2:08:40] if you're going to have a street that has bikes and cars,
[2:08:43] it needs to be X-feet.
[2:08:49] We do not have a policy that says that.
[2:08:53] But we do have some shared vision
[2:08:57] that we want to accommodate multiple modes
[2:08:59] of transportation, how do we do that safely?
[2:09:02] Yes.
[2:09:03] We have a strategic plan that says that we should look.
[2:09:07] We have a standard street section in our residential street
[2:09:11] plan that provides for some accommodation
[2:09:14] that is substantially wider than that.
[2:09:19] So directly, we do not set policy on where we feel comfortable.
[2:09:24] So our residential street width is what?
[2:09:29] from curb to curb and that's and that's with on-street parking as well
[2:09:42] parallel parking right right parallel parking thank you we have several lights
[2:09:49] but before we do that Melinda would you mind coming up and talk to I asked you
[2:09:53] if you wouldn't mind today to research the accident rate on that that section of
[2:10:00] Main Street because currently right now we have 10 and a half foot roadways
[2:10:04] We have people backing out of these spots
[2:10:08] Currently and and it's been my experience that they back completely over into the other lane
[2:10:14] So I'm just curious maybe the council that might help us to know what the extra rate has been for the last couple years
[2:10:22] Thank you mayor. Yes. I
[2:10:24] I talked with Barbara Handy in the records department at the police department for information
[2:10:30] on traffic accidents from May 15, 2013 to this past May 15 last week, so two years basically.
[2:10:39] She said they had 33 calls for service reference accidents on May in between Idaho Street and
[2:10:47] Fairfield Street.
[2:10:48] So that five block period area, they had 33 calls.
[2:10:52] However, only 13 of those 33 calls resulted in actual report on an accident.
[2:10:59] And those 13 resulted in three where we're in related.
[2:11:03] One was loss of control, five were turning slash angle events.
[2:11:08] One was a backing event, one was head-on, one was side swipe, and one was an unknown hit
[2:11:13] and run resulting in damage.
[2:11:15] So those were the 13 reports that were filed.
[2:11:18] But there are actually 33 calls made to PD, the police department regarding accidents on May Avenue.
[2:11:25] This past two years.
[2:11:27] Thank you, Melinda.
[2:11:29] I believe I have Suzanne Hawkins next.
[2:11:32] Thank you.
[2:11:33] Okay, I have a couple, so I'll try to go quick.
[2:11:36] On option four on the back, head in, back out one side parallel.
[2:11:41] Is that 45 or 60 degree angle?
[2:11:44] Right now it's shown at 60 degree.
[2:11:46] So we could pick up a couple of feet if we went to 45 with that.
[2:11:52] OK, so that is possible.
[2:11:53] It's about one and a half feet on each side.
[2:11:56] OK.
[2:11:56] Should be precise.
[2:11:58] And then that would also give us more parking spaces as well.
[2:12:03] No?
[2:12:04] Oh, 60, 45.
[2:12:05] 45's fewer.
[2:12:06] OK.
[2:12:06] Yes, that's a straight.
[2:12:08] OK.
[2:12:10] And then is it a possibility?
[2:12:13] And this is probably more for staff.
[2:12:15] What if we had some kind of parking regulation on compact vehicles on Main Street or, you
[2:12:23] know, no extra truck length, can we do, I mean, does that an option for us?
[2:12:30] So that we don't have these big vehicles blocking or can we have a section where?
[2:12:38] So the council, I mean, just like tonight, you're having a conversation about what to
[2:12:43] do with the type of style of parking. You could also go through a process that says that you're
[2:12:48] going to restrict the type of the size of vehicle downtown as well. I would bet that that would
[2:12:58] probably not be a real popular option based upon some of the comments that we've heard previously.
[2:13:04] Just looking for options and legally we could even though we have like option two A and two B
[2:13:11] at 12 feet, we could take those down to 11 feet
[2:13:15] and gain a foot of sidewalk on each side legally.
[2:13:18] Yes, Jackie says yes.
[2:13:20] And that would still be wider than what we have today.
[2:13:23] Yes.
[2:13:23] I'm going to keep you as clear
[2:13:24] from what you're saying, is it?
[2:13:26] I know that you're going to go back to that.
[2:13:27] Over here.
[2:13:28] On number 2B, I'm just clarifying the question.
[2:13:30] Please.
[2:13:31] Never next up, anyway.
[2:13:32] Well, on number 2B, your idea or an eye option
[2:13:37] would be to increase the sidewalks to 14 feet,
[2:13:41] reduce the traffic lanes to 11 feet each.
[2:13:44] Just asking if we can legally do that, yes.
[2:13:46] Yeah, we can legally do it.
[2:13:47] Okay, so.
[2:13:48] Okay.
[2:13:50] Okay.
[2:13:51] Thank you.
[2:13:52] Is that it?
[2:13:54] Chris, talking to me a little historical perspective.
[2:13:59] I'm wondering if our main street is 90 feet, front door to front door.
[2:14:05] Is that the norm or do we have a narrower whites main street than those that you work
[2:14:12] It's actually really common that right of way that I showed you for Higgins Avenue
[2:14:16] and Zula's 90 feet and Moscow's Main Street is 90 feet and and I would say
[2:14:23] too that that's really the minimum in some places you know where where the
[2:14:29] bank is for example on on the good to Shoshan block building set back so that
[2:14:36] gives us a little bit more space to work with in certain areas as well. The
[2:14:41] The only time I've ever heard Twin Falls called Normal, Ben, there's a lot of men.
[2:14:46] Common, maybe.
[2:14:47] Common, maybe.
[2:14:48] Okay.
[2:14:49] Greg Lanning.
[2:14:50] Uh, Mandy, the, I think about downtown and the sidewalk off the cafes, and Duncan's
[2:14:58] being on a corner, oh, Duncan, excuse me, kind of has two sidewalks.
[2:15:04] What is the width of the sidewalk on the shoshone side, just for some comparison in
[2:15:09] my mind?
[2:15:10] You have the two-site, two-seater tables on that side of their status, is that 10 feet?
[2:15:19] Is that 12 feet?
[2:15:20] No, I'm just going from memory here, it's certainly more than 10 feet.
[2:15:23] I want to say it's between 12 and 14.
[2:15:26] Okay, so it still is a pretty good size.
[2:15:28] Okay, I'm just trying to...
[2:15:29] My mind is...
[2:15:30] I'm talking about later on.
[2:15:33] I ride my bike down at all time, but I'm terrible.
[2:15:36] I ride illegally on the sidewalk, is where I ride my bike.
[2:15:39] that seem narrower than the main street that so.
[2:15:43] Did you say illegally?
[2:15:44] Yeah, it's illegal.
[2:15:45] I know it's illegal, but I don't want to be in the street.
[2:15:47] It's on record.
[2:15:49] I don't want to be on the street with people backing out,
[2:15:51] so as if they can't see me.
[2:15:54] I don't know if this is for you, Mandy, or for staff.
[2:15:56] But let me ask this question.
[2:15:58] If we went with any of these designs
[2:16:00] where it's front and angle parking,
[2:16:03] and I know the one that I'm kind of leaning towards,
[2:16:06] at least at this point until I hear public input,
[2:16:09] Can it be changed later?
[2:16:10] Can we design this in such a way that we do front end parking
[2:16:14] now where maybe we're not ready for the back end parking
[2:16:16] yet for as a community?
[2:16:18] And later on, we adopt a different way
[2:16:24] with the bulb outs and everything.
[2:16:25] Or is it going to be designed in such a way
[2:16:28] that it would be cost prohibitive
[2:16:30] to change the parking direction later?
[2:16:34] You know, we had always intended to design,
[2:16:39] I can describe this, let me show you a picture.
[2:16:43] Let's see here, hold on.
[2:16:47] So the parking bays themselves will have a right angle
[2:16:54] return here, and so this is just white paint
[2:16:59] between the two perpendicular curve lines.
[2:17:04] So you could change that in the future.
[2:17:08] Yeah, if we went with front and now
[2:17:10] and change it to back in the future could be done.
[2:17:13] That was my concern there because we are talking 20 to 50 years.
[2:17:17] I always like to look at that.
[2:17:18] But we also have to live in now as well.
[2:17:22] And I just like the idea of flexibility for the future
[2:17:25] because we don't know what the needs are going to be in the future.
[2:17:27] Jim, I'm not so yield to you.
[2:17:29] So I have a direct follow up to that question.
[2:17:32] So while you certainly could change the direction,
[2:17:35] you're not going to pick up any space
[2:17:37] in any one of these zones without reconstruction.
[2:17:42] Right.
[2:17:42] Because you can't just, you're gonna have to build
[2:17:45] two feet of sidewalk or move the valley getter
[2:17:49] or whatever to make that change.
[2:17:52] So you're not, so the four feet,
[2:17:55] because it's two feet, about two feet difference
[2:17:58] between the front and the back end stall length.
[2:18:01] You're not just gonna change the paint.
[2:18:03] Right, that would be if you wanted to live
[2:18:06] the sidewalk width that you achieved with a front end angle design which as we
[2:18:12] looked at just a minute ago could be about 13 feet and then in the future
[2:18:16] changed it to back end angle. If we went with back end angle initially because it
[2:18:22] needs less space we could you know have wider sidewalks of about 14 and a half
[2:18:27] feet on each side. But you can't go the other way. You can't go back in first
[2:18:33] and then switch it to front and left.
[2:18:35] Because that won't work.
[2:18:36] Because they don't have the same problem that we have now, which is hanging out in the street.
[2:18:39] Very good point.
[2:18:40] Yes, very good point.
[2:18:43] No, I think that's a valid question.
[2:18:45] I had another one that followed up, but I lost it.
[2:18:48] Jim, I just threw a quick go and go back to the traffic accident analysis that Melinda did on Main Street.
[2:18:53] And during the course of your analysis of traffic accidents during those two-year period in those 13 accidents,
[2:19:01] did any of them involve bicycles?
[2:19:03] I understood from PD that these were vehicle-to-vehicle accidents.
[2:19:10] So no reported bicycle accidents, this analysis?
[2:19:14] That I'm aware of.
[2:19:15] Well, we know it's common knowledge that they ride their bikes on the sidewalk and on the
[2:19:20] street, on Main Street.
[2:19:21] I mean, if you go down there.
[2:19:23] I will say, my follow-up really was, if we did change it to back-end parking, it does
[2:19:31] allow more safety for the Sherros because that's the main to me that's the main emphasis
[2:19:40] for back in parking anyway is to be able to share that lane better with the industry and
[2:19:46] bicycles.
[2:19:47] That's right.
[2:19:48] I wanted to clarify if there's a lot of numbers floating around.
[2:19:50] So if we used a 60 degree angle on the back in parking option one that actually shows 13
[2:20:00] and a half foot sidewalks on each side.
[2:20:02] And if that changed to 45 degrees,
[2:20:05] that would be 15 feet on each side, just so you know.
[2:20:08] So.
[2:20:09] Thank you.
[2:20:11] All right, any further questions from council?
[2:20:14] We are going to go to the public testimony portion this evening.
[2:20:17] Now this isn't a true public hearing,
[2:20:19] but I'm trying to treat it as closely as possible
[2:20:22] so that we can stay orderly.
[2:20:24] So all of you that are just wanting to get up here,
[2:20:27] I'm gonna ask staff to go back and grab the signup sheet.
[2:20:30] That doesn't mean that if later on, you didn't sign up and you want to come up for it, I'm going to give you that opportunity, but it's just easier to do it this way.
[2:20:37] So, Linda's bringing that up forward, so we are going to open up the public testimony portion of this evening.
[2:20:45] I'm going to try to limit you to about two minutes. There's so many of us tonight, so try to keep it concise.
[2:20:51] Suzanne to my right here will be showing a 30 second mark for you, so you know, don't forget when you see 30 seconds.
[2:21:01] you still have 30 seconds.
[2:21:02] And so we are going to get started.
[2:21:04] We will start with, I think he talked about this call,
[2:21:10] Anne Moise, husband of this call too.
[2:21:22] Diane Stevens, welcome Diane.
[2:21:31] Thank you city council members.
[2:21:35] I have been a Twin Falls resident since I was 12,
[2:21:38] but the exception of about six years in the Midwest.
[2:21:41] I did live in four other states at that time.
[2:21:46] And I'm going to be commenting solely as a customer visitor to the downtown area.
[2:21:52] I see a lot of traffic that you're talking about, a lot of pedestrian, a lot of bicycle,
[2:22:03] during events.
[2:22:05] And during events, we have cars blocked off out of that area anyway.
[2:22:13] And then, but my main concern is we live in a climate that six to eight months out of
[2:22:20] the year, it's cold.
[2:22:22] And people idle their cars to stay warm or keep their cars warm when sometimes they lock
[2:22:29] their cars, we're still running while they run in, etc.
[2:22:33] If they're backed up, I can just picture me lined up for a movie down at the Orpheum and
[2:22:40] cars, gas coming, choking us to death, and also shop doors opening, sucking in exhaust into
[2:22:52] the stores. And that would just be not good. And see, should that happen? I envisioned it
[2:23:04] leading to the necessity of monitoring and ticketing those who idle their cars, resulting
[2:23:09] in more in-mentee between the store owners and the customers and the traffic monitors.
[2:23:16] And the other thought I had is, do we want to encourage the bicycle traffic? Do we want
[2:23:27] to encourage people to come and shop on bicycles and park in front of the stores? I don't think
[2:23:32] we want to do that. Why can't we just identify Main Street as a place where maybe it's not
[2:23:40] the best place to ride a bike and provide traffic for allow for bicycle traffic on the
[2:23:48] side streets and provide bicycle rats on the corners of the side streets so that they go
[2:23:53] to those bicycle wrecks and then walk down and not park right in front of the stores anyway.
[2:24:00] And that's all I have.
[2:24:01] So I think I've met your time limit.
[2:24:03] You did.
[2:24:04] You did well.
[2:24:05] Thank you, Diane.
[2:24:06] Tom Ashenbrenner.
[2:24:13] Mr. Mayor and Council members, thank you for the opportunity.
[2:24:17] A couple points.
[2:24:18] The first one is I think we all share in the entire room
[2:24:21] is that we're going through a process
[2:24:23] where we're trying to redesign downtown
[2:24:27] from the perspective of not the business owners,
[2:24:30] but the community that we live in and that we serve.
[2:24:33] And I think that's very important to keep in mind.
[2:24:35] And secondly, it's not really even just the community
[2:24:38] as we stand here today, but over the next 20, 30, 50 years.
[2:24:42] So that's another consideration as we go forward.
[2:24:46] With that said, I'm becoming more convinced
[2:24:48] that our community is not in favor of back-in parking.
[2:24:52] The reasons maybe don't matter as much anymore.
[2:24:54] Certainly made a lot of sense in a lot of ways.
[2:24:57] But in my mind, I think we're passed up
[2:24:59] from what I can see in here.
[2:25:01] I applaud the city and OTAC for doing the proper run.
[2:25:05] And I think in the future as we keep planning this,
[2:25:09] we need to keep trying to objectively gauge
[2:25:11] what the community wants in their downtown.
[2:25:14] My guess is they want a place to come socialized
[2:25:16] to see and be seen to safely have daytime and evening events
[2:25:21] to also park, go in, get the description, and leave.
[2:25:26] So it's a mix, as Diane was saying.
[2:25:29] And we're at the park now where it's like making sausage
[2:25:33] and it's messy.
[2:25:34] When we change price hard work to Rudy,
[2:25:36] then we stripped everything and had to say,
[2:25:37] okay, we have 25 feet, we wish we had 40, but we didn't.
[2:25:41] what are we going to do?
[2:25:42] What good things can't stay there?
[2:25:44] And I think that's where we're at.
[2:25:48] So we need to compromise.
[2:25:51] We need to look at the options from the perspective
[2:25:54] of the customers and look at other options
[2:25:56] that may not even be here, one of which is a request
[2:25:58] for the city and urban renewal to work together
[2:26:01] to analyze possible off-site parking,
[2:26:05] which provides employee parking, which opens up more space
[2:26:08] for customer parking, which might let other compromises work,
[2:26:12] parallel parking on one side and angled in on the opposite. So we still have adequate parking.
[2:26:18] Thank you for your consideration. Thank you, John. Susan, I think it's Hill or Hall?
[2:26:27] Hall? Is it Hall? Lucky for you. I'm Susan Hall. I own Susan's Antiques on Main Street.
[2:26:36] It was quite entertaining watching the parking. It was basically a free for all.
[2:26:40] What I noticed is a lot of complete non-compliance that people would rather cross the street and
[2:26:47] park illegally than to park back in.
[2:26:52] I get the gist of the back in parking.
[2:26:54] I just don't think we're ready for it yet.
[2:26:55] There's nothing but negative comments.
[2:26:57] I can't repeat any of them in here.
[2:27:01] The one thing that I wonder, well first up there are only about three or four bicycles
[2:27:06] a day for the most part and they're on maybe in the evening there might be more but during
[2:27:10] the day, they're very, very little bicycle traffic. They are on the sidewalk. And it's
[2:27:17] just something I can't wrap my head around. How does it say a 20 foot long vehicle take
[2:27:22] up more room pulling in forward than it does backing up? And that's just more of a design
[2:27:28] question that I just don't quite, I can't wrap my head around. Oh, it makes the sidewalk
[2:27:32] smaller. If you head in as opposed to backing up, if you back up and you're in a big vehicle,
[2:27:38] going to hang over the sidewalk. So essentially, that makes it smaller. But that's just more
[2:27:43] of a mathematically, I don't get it. But it was the whole, it was quite a show. We were
[2:27:48] going to have scorecards that I can't get printed up. And thank you for the engagement.
[2:27:53] It was wonderful. I'm glad you didn't see me do it because you might have given me a
[2:27:58] point all. Stephanie Johnson. Welcome Stephanie. Good evening. My family purchased the Orpheum
[2:28:11] recently, and I am also on the advisory committee for a downtown
[2:28:15] for main avenue redesign.
[2:28:18] I agree with Diane.
[2:28:19] I agree with Susan.
[2:28:20] I agree with Tom.
[2:28:21] I think that people don't want it.
[2:28:24] People don't want it.
[2:28:24] And it's a business owner.
[2:28:26] That's all I really care about.
[2:28:28] It could be the most wonderful thing ever.
[2:28:30] Since sliced bread, it can make the most logical sense
[2:28:33] of anything ever.
[2:28:34] If people don't want it, I'm sunk.
[2:28:37] And so is everybody else downtown.
[2:28:39] And whether it's logical or reasonable or not,
[2:28:41] for them to say, I'm not doing that.
[2:28:42] That's their prerogative, and they are not obligated
[2:28:45] to come downtown and patronize our businesses.
[2:28:48] I think that we have to listen to what they have to say.
[2:28:54] And also, at this point, I have a hard time
[2:28:58] seeing the reward.
[2:28:59] I understand all of the logical, you know,
[2:29:03] the numbers and everything.
[2:29:04] And on paper, it all looks very reasonable and sensible.
[2:29:08] But in the end, I did try the back up parking.
[2:29:12] And to me, I'm envisioning trying
[2:29:14] to back in between two big trucks.
[2:29:16] Now, I was in my husband's deal, which makes that a lot easier.
[2:29:19] But in my SUV, I'm not sure I could do it
[2:29:22] without pulling over the center line, to be honest with you,
[2:29:25] if I had to pull that off.
[2:29:27] And I think that something in practice very often
[2:29:32] does not turn out the way that it looks on paper and in planning.
[2:29:35] Finally, I also, I think that it's important for the people to understand that what a complete
[2:29:45] street is.
[2:29:46] Who defines a complete street?
[2:29:47] Because my understanding is that there are federal guidelines that actually mandate what
[2:29:51] a complete street is.
[2:29:53] These are just my, what I've taken from what I've learned about the process, and also how
[2:30:00] much of this project is tied to federal funding, and what are we required to do federal or state
[2:30:06] funding and what are we required to do to take advantage of that and I think that
[2:30:10] people need to know that. Bicycles, I'm not sure that we can accommodate
[2:30:16] everybody with 90 feet from building to building and I think we really need to
[2:30:19] pay attention to who is going to come downtown and patronize our downtown
[2:30:24] merchants. So thank you. Thank you. I think federal funding I don't think there's
[2:30:30] any federal funding on this job. Is there a crevice? There's no federal funding
[2:30:33] attached to the project.
[2:30:35] Thank you. Larry, or excuse me, Jared? No, no, no. Jared Johnson. Well, I want to give
[2:30:53] you the chance, sir. Welcome.
[2:30:57] Oh, I guess. Oh, yeah, thank you for reminding me that. When you come forward, make sure you
[2:31:03] state your name and your address. It's here, but just for a record.
[2:31:07] is a sad dress or personal?
[2:31:10] Either.
[2:31:10] Jared Michael Johnson, 439 Vitter Brush, Twin Falls.
[2:31:15] My question is, Justin, a follow-up then
[2:31:17] to what my lovely mother had brought up.
[2:31:22] In the event that this is not federal funding, not state
[2:31:27] funding, is this all already coming out of the redesign
[2:31:31] funding?
[2:31:32] What is the funding?
[2:31:32] I got a very interesting email today
[2:31:35] saying it was the itinerary for today,
[2:31:37] said as far as back in parking goes that this has no impact on the city budget
[2:31:42] whatsoever which means that the funding has to be coming from somewhere now I
[2:31:45] don't know if that was an official city document or not but that's what I had
[2:31:49] received as a part of the greater downtown area why don't we go ahead and
[2:31:51] answer that question real quick for you so Mr. Mayor thank you for that question
[2:31:57] right now the funding is coming from the Twin Falls Urban Renewal Agency which
[2:32:04] which most folks know is separate from the city of Twin Falls.
[2:32:08] So it's coming from urban renewal agency.
[2:32:10] It's coming from folks who pay property taxes within the downtown urban renewal district.
[2:32:19] And I'll go ahead and send another nail on the coffin of the biceless bicycle thing.
[2:32:24] As someone who faces Main Street for, I would say probably about eight hours a day,
[2:32:30] looking directly across at my lovely neighbors at Vergudys.
[2:32:35] I don't know where all the talk of needing a bicycle, anything, is coming from.
[2:32:43] Three or four a day at that.
[2:32:47] I realize it would be great to make everyone happy, but when we're looking at all of this,
[2:32:52] not necessarily something that makes a whole lot of sense to me, especially since I'm quite
[2:32:58] literally staring at the main street unless someone is buying tickets from me at the Orpheum
[2:33:03] Theater.
[2:33:04] outside of that. I'd really like to echo what Miss Stevenson said about the
[2:33:11] backing in. As far as the restaurants, I love to head over to Slice. I love to head
[2:33:17] over to the Sam's Company. I'd like to sit outside. O'Dunken doesn't necessarily
[2:33:22] have this problem to go and have a burrow at O'Dunken's. You don't have to deal
[2:33:26] with the back-end parking and you don't have to deal with say a large diesel
[2:33:29] engine there idling spewing fumes at you I can only imagine the victory hall that
[2:33:37] would come from a situation like that so that being said thank you thank you
[2:33:41] Jared and I think that's the first time I've ever heard anybody refer to Tom as
[2:33:45] lovely he's talking about the store oh the store
[2:33:53] Larry Johnson, welcome Larry, good sir.
[2:34:03] Larry Johnson and my address is in Filer but I'll say 146 Main Avenue North, that's the
[2:34:08] Orpheum Theatre. As my wife said, we bought the Orpheum Theatre a couple of months ago and
[2:34:13] I could reiterate everything that she said but I think another perspective on it is in
[2:34:17] the business that we do at the Orpheum, we listen to what people are telling us all the
[2:34:22] time. We try to figure out what we're going to put in the Orpheum this weekend. What will
[2:34:25] people come to do at the orchium. And we tried some things that have been a big success, and
[2:34:30] we tried other things that nobody came to at all. And we thought, oh my goodness, we
[2:34:33] really thought people would come out to see this. I wish we would have known beforehand
[2:34:38] that no one wanted to come and see this. We wouldn't have put this on. So we learn by
[2:34:43] what people actually do, not necessarily even people will say, yeah, I'm really going
[2:34:49] to come out. And then they don't show up. Here we have a situation where everybody I'm talking
[2:34:53] was saying, I'm not coming downtown if they have back-and-angle parking. And as a person
[2:34:58] who just bought the Orpheum, that scares the daylight side of me. So I hope you don't do
[2:35:03] it. And I'll probably scream in the island, jump up and down a lot. Whatever else I can
[2:35:09] think of if you decide to. So, thanks.
[2:35:12] Thank you, Larry. Dan Guthrie. Welcome, Dan.
[2:35:21] Dan Guthrie, 2076 Maple in Twin Falls. You guys have a lot of great points. I'm having
[2:35:28] good time tonight. So I've been on the downtown citizens advisory board since last year. We've
[2:35:34] got some exciting ideas about creating a brand new downtown that is focused, family activities,
[2:35:40] excitement and commerce, so a lightning rod for every citizen and windfalls to come down.
[2:35:46] I personally like the idea of backup parking. I voted for it in the committee. It seemed
[2:35:52] like a great idea, but you guys were making great points too, which I appreciate. But you
[2:35:56] I've never heard of it before, but it started making sense.
[2:35:59] So in the committee, we wanted to utilize as much space as possible.
[2:36:03] More parking, more sidewalks, more bike lanes.
[2:36:05] You guys heard everything there.
[2:36:06] So what we wanted to do was focus on that.
[2:36:10] So we also wanted to say for a more convenient for the additional pedestrians, bikes, and
[2:36:15] children visiting downtown.
[2:36:16] When you see a whole plan, it's going to be family focus.
[2:36:20] There's going to be a lot more kids downtown.
[2:36:22] There's going to be a lot more bikes downtown.
[2:36:24] It's going to be a place where you want to take your bike.
[2:36:26] Right now, you don't want to, but you will.
[2:36:29] When these things all come into place,
[2:36:31] it's going to be the family spot to be a real lightning rod.
[2:36:33] So, and also during the construction,
[2:36:38] they'll be revamping the alleys first.
[2:36:39] Am I right about that, Phil?
[2:36:41] So they'll revamping the alleys first.
[2:36:43] So during that time, they're also
[2:36:45] going to be beautifying the rear entrances.
[2:36:47] So it'll be a four-sided experience
[2:36:51] who come downtown as some of the businesses.
[2:36:53] not everyone. I don't know. I can't speak for anyone. So if front row parking is
[2:36:58] important to you, you'll have more opportunities because the access to the
[2:37:03] rear parking lots will, you know, be more accessible. Valleys will be brand new.
[2:37:07] The entrances in the rear will be just as beautiful and amazing as the ones in
[2:37:12] the front. And I'm actually looking forward to that. Either way, however we do the
[2:37:16] parking. So, what else is going on? So, you know, this project will preserve our
[2:37:21] Our classic elements of downtown with the new additions that will attract everybody.
[2:37:25] It's going to be the place to be again, just like when I moved here in 1989 with real protein
[2:37:29] beans and everything else.
[2:37:30] So the parking will be secondary.
[2:37:32] This will be remembered, you know, any way we decide to do the parking, I'm never going
[2:37:37] to stop coming downtown.
[2:37:38] So I hope everyone else has the same idea.
[2:37:41] So that's my piece.
[2:37:42] Thank you.
[2:37:43] Thank you, Dan.
[2:37:44] Sheen Cook.
[2:37:45] Thank you, Shane.
[2:37:50] Coverdory points are ready, thanks, Dave.
[2:37:53] I'm having a tough time with the name, but last name Smith, Leon, is that Leon?
[2:38:00] Leon, were you an attorney at one time?
[2:38:03] My name is Leon Smith, and I am the Chairman of the Urban and Ooh Board, and I want to say
[2:38:24] that we have better this thing publicly for so long and with so many meetings that I'm
[2:38:30] worn out with meetings. But some of the main things that were considered here, we got very
[2:38:37] narrow main streets. By 91 feet between buildings, we have a lot of amenities on the sidewalk.
[2:38:46] We have people putting their goods out there. We have cafes out there. We have planters.
[2:38:50] We have trees. And all of these hearings, they still want these things. And they want
[2:38:57] bicycle access and I don't remember how many parking places that we had along
[2:39:03] Main Street but the direction to us was to keep the same number or more. Okay so
[2:39:11] that's where back-end parking entered the scene and in order to get or keep that
[2:39:19] kind of parking along Main Street this was a consideration that we felt needed
[2:39:25] to be considered and put it in some place.
[2:39:28] We haven't got this design done.
[2:39:30] Man, you still got this thing in the mill.
[2:39:33] But without back in parking, there are going to be
[2:39:36] substantially less parking places.
[2:39:38] And I think that was something that people really wanted.
[2:39:42] OK, so you and Greg told me.
[2:39:45] He said, we want your recommendation
[2:39:47] so that we can act on it.
[2:39:48] OK, you've had the recommendation of the special select
[2:39:53] committed. They've met many, many times. And they had a vote with only one dissent, said
[2:40:00] consider back in parking as part of this formula. So that came to the Urban New Board. And we
[2:40:07] passed that on to you and say we need to consider back in parking if we're going to keep these
[2:40:11] parking places and have what people want downtown. Okay, then we've got Otak and their planners
[2:40:21] and their engineers and Mandy, they all say, you need to keep back in parking as part of
[2:40:26] the formula.
[2:40:27] Okay, so that's the background for this thing.
[2:40:32] Now I've been in politics long enough to know that we've kind of gone out of the good engineering
[2:40:37] practices now and we're in politics and most of these folks back here are in politics and
[2:40:42] they're speaking politics and you are the political party.
[2:40:45] So you're going to make a decision and it will probably be political.
[2:40:50] But just make a decision.
[2:40:53] This is the important thing.
[2:40:55] This part, whether you go front or back, is such a small part of this whole scheme.
[2:41:01] We got millions of dollars on this thing.
[2:41:03] We delayed this whole thing, the whole planning for a month.
[2:41:07] While we have an example down half a week back in, and while you have a hearing, a public
[2:41:11] hearing, and while all of this stuff is meshing, this is just a little part of this thing.
[2:41:17] But we needed to go forward.
[2:41:20] So all I'm asking you tonight, as the Chairman of the Urban
[2:41:25] and the Middle Board, and I think I would have an animal
[2:41:27] support, is to make a decision.
[2:41:30] Tell us what you want.
[2:41:32] If you don't want us to consider back in parking,
[2:41:35] then tell us, so that we can go forward
[2:41:37] and don't lose another month.
[2:41:40] That's my pitch, and I'll be happy to answer any questions.
[2:41:44] Thank you, Leon.
[2:41:46] Bob Richards.
[2:41:48] just covered all my points basically the last
[2:41:50] cause I want to stay in.
[2:41:53] Thank you, thank you Bob.
[2:41:56] Ken fits Gerald.
[2:41:59] Can I say that right?
[2:42:01] Don't look so excited.
[2:42:03] Hi Ken Fitzgerald, property owner down here 124
[2:42:09] through 136 Maine Avenue North.
[2:42:14] I want to thank you Mr. Mayor and the City Council here.
[2:42:18] I think all of you obviously have listened to the public.
[2:42:22] public, you've listened to Mandy and everybody else involved and you asked some very good
[2:42:28] questions this evening and I want to really thank you for that. I think have these questions
[2:42:34] not been asked. A lot of these people might still have a lot of these questions but afraid
[2:42:39] to ask them or not want to come up here. I think, Mr. Mayor, you hit it on the head
[2:42:44] when you kind of were looking at the long-term plan and you asked the question could we go
[2:42:50] back and change it in 20 years, I firmly believe that yes, having bicycle paths and everything
[2:42:57] downtown down Main Street would be a great thing to have. Right now, unless you can make
[2:43:01] big loops around downtown, going back and forth on Main Street is not going to attract bicyclists
[2:43:06] down here. Families are not going to drive their car, put all the bikes in the car, come
[2:43:10] down to Main Street and go back and forth on Main Street. So in 10 years, 15, 20 years,
[2:43:15] when I know the master plan is to get a bike loop going around the city, and if we can re-in
[2:43:21] reintroduced possibly back in parking at that time on main then it starts making
[2:43:26] sense to worry about back in parking. We're not worried about that. We're worried
[2:43:30] about people not coming downtown after spending hundreds and hundreds of thousands
[2:43:34] of dollars doing what we've done the last few years. So I just wanted to say I
[2:43:38] appreciate you asking that questions. I appreciate Mandy you've done a lot of
[2:43:41] work to try and give you all the different options planned you know to a to be. I know
[2:43:47] It's been a lot of work and everybody's throwing stuff at you, you know, like crazy.
[2:43:51] I just want to say I appreciate it and hopefully that's the direction we go and worry about this at another time.
[2:43:58] I think the design, like she was saying at the right angles coming in, it can be flipped back and forth.
[2:44:04] The angle, the forward versus back end, those could all be changed later on.
[2:44:10] And as you ask the questions earlier about, is it a legal thing that we have to change this?
[2:44:17] or can we keep it, you know, status quo on the size of the drive lanes and parking spaces?
[2:44:24] Those are very good questions. Thank you.
[2:44:26] Thank you.
[2:44:27] Thank you, kid. Welcome, Peggy.
[2:44:35] I'm a air-fired council. I downtown mainly as a person who does business downtown and a shopper.
[2:44:43] For one, back in parking, I can't. If you look at the back of my car, I've got bumps on its brakes on it.
[2:44:49] I just can't back up anywhere.
[2:44:52] So I tried it and I can't do it.
[2:44:55] So, and I know I'm only one of 40,000 people
[2:44:58] that live in the city, but a couple things were brought up.
[2:45:02] What's gonna happen when public transportation
[2:45:04] comes into play?
[2:45:06] What are you guys gonna do?
[2:45:07] You said that has to happen in 2020.
[2:45:10] You guys need to figure that out also.
[2:45:13] It's not gonna work if you have back in parking.
[2:45:16] The big trucks that back in down there,
[2:45:18] You can't tell them not to come downtown.
[2:45:20] Those guys spend a lot of money at the restaurants.
[2:45:22] They drink a lot of beer.
[2:45:23] They keep a lot of people happy.
[2:45:25] So, I mean, I seriously, I be toyed.
[2:45:29] I'm sorry for all your hard work,
[2:45:30] but there are a couple of plans that you guys had up there
[2:45:33] that will probably work.
[2:45:34] And there's also farther down, advantage archery down that way.
[2:45:38] There's parking spots down there
[2:45:40] that people don't use and they can walk down that way.
[2:45:43] So, thank you, have a good day.
[2:45:45] Thank you, Peggy.
[2:45:48] Oh, I'm sorry again, remember when you come up here,
[2:45:51] state your name and your address, I keep forgetting,
[2:45:54] thank you, great.
[2:45:56] David Woodhead.
[2:46:06] How did he get to do it?
[2:46:08] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[2:46:09] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[2:46:15] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[2:46:20] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[2:46:22] and so every few days I get an email from the mask
[2:46:26] me when I want to do my survey. I'm going to have to deal with that sooner or later.
[2:46:34] Okay, so your little experiment on Maine in front of D11's really opened my eyes. I
[2:46:40] now realize how dangerous I've been driving all these many years because you know you really
[2:46:50] can't see anything when you back out. I've just taken it for granted. I mean that's just
[2:46:55] the way you did it. All these years. But I tried it in a boat, by the way, because I'm
[2:47:01] driving at Crown Victoria at the moment. And guess what? It's not. It's just like backing
[2:47:09] out except backing in. But here's the deal. Once you're in, you can see the road. So there's
[2:47:16] no guesswork. There's no holding your breath, hoping that nobody is going to plow into
[2:47:21] you when you back out. So, since then I've become a dedicated backer in or I back in
[2:47:28] wherever I can, three times today. I always was the sort that would, you know, in the
[2:47:34] grocery stores where you have head-on parking, I would go completely through so I don't
[2:47:39] have to back up. But now, if there's no such opportunity, I'll just plain back in because
[2:47:44] it's the way to go. It's just plain, it's like buttered bread. So thank you, City Council.
[2:47:51] I'm a safer driver now because of you.
[2:47:55] I know there's a lot of big blowback about this,
[2:47:57] and I know people complain that they are afraid.
[2:48:00] They don't have the skill to do this,
[2:48:02] which is a strange argument if you think about it,
[2:48:04] because if a primary driving maneuver is beyond your scope,
[2:48:10] yeah, I wouldn't think you'd want to throw
[2:48:12] everyone's attention to it.
[2:48:14] So, and also, I would like to say,
[2:48:16] if you're afraid of backing in,
[2:48:18] what makes you so brave about backing out?
[2:48:20] because that's way more dangerous.
[2:48:22] I mean, it's impossible.
[2:48:25] Please City Council ignore the naysayers.
[2:48:29] Don't let backward thinking scuttle back in parking.
[2:48:35] Perfect timing.
[2:48:37] Thank you.
[2:48:38] Desk in the waters?
[2:48:40] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[2:48:53] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[2:48:57] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[2:49:01] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[2:49:05] with my little 13 foot Honda Fit,
[2:49:09] and another six times with my extended cab,
[2:49:13] long bed, three-core time pickup.
[2:49:17] I had no trouble lining up the strikes with either vehicle.
[2:49:23] The distance between the rear tires and the bumper
[2:49:26] of my pickup is a full three feet,
[2:49:29] and I did not come close to a tree or a lap poster.
[2:49:33] Any other extras.
[2:49:36] I should say that it's all sitting height,
[2:49:39] and I'm used to backing up using my side of the mirrors.
[2:49:45] Piece of cake.
[2:49:46] I tried to screw it up and I couldn't.
[2:49:48] I would like to say a second something that Mr. Smith said,
[2:49:53] we've spent a full month on this one issue.
[2:50:01] I think it's time to get a consensus and move on.
[2:50:05] Thank you.
[2:50:06] Thank you, sir.
[2:50:08] Sergio Larios, welcome, Sergio.
[2:50:26] Good evening city council.
[2:50:27] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[2:50:28] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[2:50:35] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[2:50:38] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[2:50:43] of parking downtown.
[2:50:45] The handicap designated spaces don't allow
[2:50:50] for my passenger side, Rampton, Fold.
[2:50:53] So I do have the park in this manner.
[2:50:55] Every time I am downtown, there was a Times News video that was recently posted that showed a driver having difficulty putting the idea of back-in parking into action,
[2:51:07] and they failed miserably where the driver's vehicle came hazardously close to another vehicle that was situated there.
[2:51:14] It wasn't a good example of back-in parking at all.
[2:51:18] I believe that a capable driver would have no trouble safely completing the maneuver and
[2:51:23] contrary to popular belief, there is no need to cross the center line at all to do so.
[2:51:30] My big thing is safety.
[2:51:32] I believe that although it takes slightly longer to complete the maneuver, I think it's better
[2:51:40] to back up while in a non-traffic situation than to back up into an unknown one.
[2:51:46] It allows better visibility for cyclists, motor and bicycle, and I think that the number
[2:51:56] of bicyclists in the downtown area was understated by the other people that spoke previously.
[2:52:03] Maybe it's because I'm on wheels, I see a lot of the other people on wheels traveling downtown,
[2:52:11] and I just would like to see more, I think that's great.
[2:52:15] My final point is, unless you have suicide doors on your vehicle, parking, using the back
[2:52:22] end manner does not allow for immediate access to the traffic through way for children exiting
[2:52:27] the rear section of the vehicle for those customers that show up with families.
[2:52:31] That was the deal maker for me only because I see it happening with drivers that have
[2:52:38] families of small children and even pets that like to jump out of the cars into the roadway.
[2:52:44] And I like the mandate or they gather information regarding the accidents that occur.
[2:52:52] But if you were to take into account and I know there's no way to quantify the near misses
[2:52:59] that occur, I'm downtown between Fairfield and Goody and there's an event center right
[2:53:04] there and at night there's a lot of honking that goes on and just near accidents that
[2:53:13] would probably be reduced with back in parking. That's my two cents. Thank you for
[2:53:18] allowing me the chance to speak and thank you for allowing me. Thank you.
[2:53:23] Tim Stasney. I've messed your last name up again. I'm sorry. Probably won't do so good if you try to
[2:53:31] spell it. Tim Stasney 132 Main Avenue North Island Slice Restaurant. I just
[2:53:37] quickly want to reiterate what everyone else is saying as a guy that's put some
[2:53:41] money into his restaurant and believes in the downtown. I have a folder here full of hundreds
[2:53:48] and hundreds of negative comments from my customers, from online surveys that it's no. And so as
[2:53:56] a business owner, I have to follow sentiments of the Johnson's. It's consistent. We just
[2:54:04] won't come. There's other places to go, AP. It's at granted we do have a cool downtown
[2:54:08] and the vibe is nice.
[2:54:10] But when you're fighting with the chain restaurants,
[2:54:14] like we all do that are down there,
[2:54:16] if we're giving people another reason
[2:54:18] under the misconception that there's no parking right now,
[2:54:21] and now we're talking about educating an entire community,
[2:54:23] not just Twin Falls, but to Wells, Nevada.
[2:54:26] I mean, I have people every day from all over
[2:54:29] that come into this restaurant.
[2:54:32] And so if we're giving them another,
[2:54:34] just it's all about perception.
[2:54:36] And if there's a way to get this done and alter that perception over time, like even
[2:54:41] if you start the back in on another block, don't do it on all streets.
[2:54:45] Let's try it.
[2:54:46] You try to, you know, you tried this here, yeah, think miserably, but keep trying it.
[2:54:52] And you know, you had some people that did like it, maybe over a course of time, that
[2:54:56] will grow in 10, 15 years.
[2:54:59] We can do that.
[2:55:00] It's a lot easier to repaint some stripes to add it
[2:55:05] Versus trying to get people to come back down. We live in a you know people make up their minds. They're pretty stuck to it in this area
[2:55:11] I mean they're they're stubborn people. I'm stubborn
[2:55:15] So I tried to back in park and I couldn't do it took a couple of tries, you know
[2:55:21] But I just really feel you really have to listen to these people. I have a lot of money
[2:55:26] I, all of my, people on my block have spent a lot of money all the same.
[2:55:31] We start losing one, two, three customers that are going to go out to the canyon and
[2:55:35] sit down out there and eat.
[2:55:37] There's a lot of new restaurants coming out there where there is no back-end parking.
[2:55:40] I mean, those people that will go to Costco, they'll sit there and walk a half a mile to
[2:55:46] get into Costco.
[2:55:47] They won't do that downtown.
[2:55:48] They won't.
[2:55:49] They'll drive around the block 58 times to park in one of those spots out front.
[2:55:53] Will they do that if they have to back in?
[2:55:55] I don't know.
[2:55:56] well so please take into consideration all of those things. Thank you. Thank you.
[2:56:00] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[2:56:12] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[2:56:18] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[2:56:23] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[2:56:28] I don't want my customer to have to try to do anything to get downtown.
[2:56:33] I want them to be easy and convenient.
[2:56:36] I think we're trying to get our downtown to be nicer and more convenient,
[2:56:40] not add another item to the con side of the list of coming to downtown and the public's eye.
[2:56:45] Parking is one of the biggest problems facing downtown.
[2:56:48] However, it is the amount of spaces or lack thereof,
[2:56:52] and the confusion of where and when to park,
[2:56:54] not necessarily parking forward or coming back out.
[2:56:59] Let's focus on these concerns and these problems.
[2:57:02] As the gentlemen say, we need to put this to rest.
[2:57:04] It's been a long time.
[2:57:07] So please help to continue to make our downtown grow and flourish.
[2:57:11] Please don't allow back in parking,
[2:57:13] which will just be another inconvenience
[2:57:16] in the public and community's eyes.
[2:57:18] So thank you.
[2:57:19] Thank you, Kimmy.
[2:57:20] Ben Rasmussen.
[2:57:28] Thank you, Mayor, Council.
[2:57:30] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[2:57:31] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[2:57:35] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[2:57:40] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[2:57:44] So I've been downtown at the RPM for that long.
[2:57:48] I've seen it grow tremendously as the population changed.
[2:57:52] I used to be able to go out there and lay
[2:57:54] in the middle of the road during lunch hour.
[2:57:56] I can't do that anymore.
[2:57:58] There's so many more people down there.
[2:58:00] I think having people back in, it's
[2:58:03] going to change the way people perceive the downtown.
[2:58:09] I drive every type of vehicle from a four-door truck
[2:58:13] to a regular cab pickup to a car, also a motorcycle.
[2:58:18] Backing up a motorcycle, no problem.
[2:58:20] Wives car, no problem.
[2:58:23] SUV. Yeah, I can do it. Truck, same thing. Pulling out, no problem. My wife, absolutely not. Even
[2:58:33] pulling out, as I'm pulling my truck out into, I can see perfectly, but to get past that vehicle
[2:58:41] next to me, I still have to cross into the other lane of traffic. I think a one way considered
[2:58:48] is a good idea.
[2:58:50] Me personally, you could leave the amount of space,
[2:58:54] each lane being 10 feet, that's 20 feet,
[2:58:58] and pull in frontwards.
[2:59:01] It was curious why I didn't see anything about a one way.
[2:59:05] I heard things about the fire department.
[2:59:07] If fire truck can't fit down 20 feet of main road,
[2:59:11] I don't know what to do.
[2:59:14] I think you guys have a tough decision in front of you.
[2:59:18] Something I learned in dealing with the public for many years in maintenance for interstate amusement is keep it simple, stupid.
[2:59:27] You don't take a fire exit and make them run around a wall and through a hallway and down and out an exit door.
[2:59:34] No. Get them in, get them out, keep it simple.
[2:59:39] Backing in is going to take so much longer.
[2:59:42] There's 75 80 year old people who come downtown now.
[2:59:46] To get them to back in it's going to take twice as long backing track traffic up further
[2:59:52] Thank you for your time. Thank you Ben
[2:59:56] Last on the list, but certainly will allow others to add is Sid Vanderpool
[3:00:02] Said did you do that on purpose? You could do that
[3:00:09] [Muted for privacy: street address]
[3:00:11] [Muted for privacy: street address]
[3:00:14] In March I want a vacation to the UK.
[3:00:16] I drove down very narrow roads.
[3:00:19] I shared those narrow roads with many bicycles.
[3:00:22] Everybody knows everybody rides a bike in the UK.
[3:00:25] It's not rocket science.
[3:00:26] You can share a regular road, very thin road with bicycles and do it safely.
[3:00:34] In regards to the 10 foot, was it 10 foot, the rows, lanes or 11 foot, that's what the
[3:00:43] are today?
[3:00:44] Today they're 10 and a half.
[3:00:46] There's an article that was in Boise State's, where the City Council President requested
[3:00:52] the commissioners to change their lanes in their downtown area to 10 foot lanes.
[3:00:59] She said she cited national standards that allow for lane widths to be narrow as 10 feet
[3:01:04] on similar streets and highway district staffs believe that 10 feet is accessible with for
[3:01:11] cars following capital boulevard's 25 by an hour limit. And that came off of from October
[3:01:18] of last year. So if it's the width of the road that gives us problems, that might be
[3:01:25] something to look at. In regards to the sidewalk width, if you ever go to the mall, I know that's
[3:01:34] bad word for downtown people but if you ever go to the mall and they have a
[3:01:36] sidewalk sale with the mall from storefront to storefront you're looking
[3:01:41] at only probably 25 feet between the storefronts and they managed to have all
[3:01:46] sorts of shopping opportunities when they have their sidewalk sales there so
[3:01:52] do you really need to have 14 feet for your sidewalks? I'm against I've tried the
[3:01:58] vacuum parking three times I'm not an idiot when it comes to driving and I
[3:02:03] I mess it up every time, so that's all I have to say.
[3:02:06] Thank you, sir.
[3:02:08] Is there anyone else that would like to come forward?
[3:02:11] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[3:02:21] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[3:02:27] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[3:02:32] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[3:02:36] We have Guppies Hot Rock Grill.
[3:02:39] We are wanting to, of course, have an outside seating area too.
[3:02:43] We've started that, look forward to it growing
[3:02:46] and accepting the changes that they're gonna make downtown.
[3:02:51] But I think there was a couple of really good points.
[3:02:54] As far as the bicycles, I too have been downtown a lot
[3:02:58] and not seen a bicycle track.
[3:03:00] I mean, a lot of people riding bikes.
[3:03:04] But I love the idea that came up about bike tracks
[3:03:07] around the whole program.
[3:03:09] and parking just half a block from the event.
[3:03:13] So I thought that was a good idea,
[3:03:15] but I'd like to talk about what Tim said.
[3:03:18] We are attracting more people than just even our own area.
[3:03:24] We get critical acclaim of our places on Yelp,
[3:03:30] on TripAdvisor, and these are people
[3:03:32] that are gonna pull into our town,
[3:03:34] and they're gonna put down,
[3:03:35] they're gonna come to our area,
[3:03:37] And when they get down, they're going to see foreign parking
[3:03:39] to them, because this back in parking
[3:03:42] is not prevalent all over the nation.
[3:03:45] So I thought that that was something I really need to reiterate on.
[3:03:49] It's an important fact to me.
[3:03:51] Thank you.
[3:03:52] Thank you, sir.
[3:03:53] Yeah.
[3:03:54] Is there anyone else?
[3:03:56] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[3:04:01] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[3:04:03] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[3:04:05] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[3:04:08] I think that after listening to everything that's going on,
[3:04:12] I think what we have to really always consider,
[3:04:15] whether it's today or whatever it might be,
[3:04:17] is what's the future going to be,
[3:04:19] and build toward the future,
[3:04:20] not necessarily about what's happening right now
[3:04:22] in front of our own stores or our own front doors.
[3:04:25] I think that some of the ideas of the potential
[3:04:28] of having front end parking,
[3:04:29] which could be accommodated back end parking
[3:04:31] in a later time, is a great idea.
[3:04:33] I think that the opportunity of having more bike traffic
[3:04:38] is great, but I think again, it needs to be accessed so that bikes can come down there.
[3:04:42] And I think that's a future plan.
[3:04:44] So I think in the near term, front end parking makes a lot of sense.
[3:04:48] Back end parking may make better sense as we go down the road.
[3:04:52] The other thing I'd like to see is we're talking about parking or two other things.
[3:04:55] One is the parking lots that we do have now, there are some small restricted parking lots
[3:05:00] with way too many lease spaces in those, and way too many people who are business owners
[3:05:05] the park in those and then complain that their customers don't have places to go.
[3:05:11] I think that those two things are related.
[3:05:13] One is we need to get rid of all of the lease parking that is near Main Avenue, push those
[3:05:18] out in some fashion whether it be finding other opportunities to buy parking that's away from
[3:05:24] that.
[3:05:25] But the real piece of all of the parking, regardless of whether it's Main Avenue or whether it's
[3:05:30] on any of the side streets or the parking lots is we have to look forward and it goes
[3:05:34] to the budget discussion which is we have to provide enforcement to take care of those
[3:05:38] issues so that they don't become problems so that if there are issues with parking whether
[3:05:43] people want to cross the street, go over the center line, park in, lease spots, whatever
[3:05:47] it might be, there is some enforcement behind that that we take care of now.
[3:05:52] Thank you Tony.
[3:05:53] Is there anyone else?
[3:05:56] Leah.
[3:06:02] Thank you Council.
[3:06:03] I also wanted to wait being that we- Leah, where do you live?
[3:06:07] A 250 camera away.
[3:06:09] Thank you.
[3:06:10] redesign committee with Tony and so it was good to sit back and just get feedback that
[3:06:15] compliments I guess the information that we do have. Mandy did forget to mention a
[3:06:24] sixth option I think moving the buildings. That is another option. I want to really
[3:06:31] acknowledge that Mandy did a really nice job I think and if anyone's here on
[3:06:36] that's also on that committee would agree on educating.
[3:06:41] She's taken an impossible task,
[3:06:44] which is getting people in this community
[3:06:46] to see not only outside of a box,
[3:06:48] but beyond that box, which is the 10, 20, 40 years
[3:06:54] for this town and how to enjoy downtown
[3:06:57] and all the variety.
[3:06:59] It's hard to change behavior, but it's not impossible.
[3:07:02] There's been a lot of change already
[3:07:03] within that downtown space, even going from horses to cars, I'm sure. Space does dictate
[3:07:10] behavior, whether it's encouraging or discouraging that behavior or lifestyle. So of course there's
[3:07:17] going to be less bike scene right now because it's not very encouraging, it's not very accessible,
[3:07:22] it's not safe. And it's easy to get emotional about an unknown change. People get very emotional
[3:07:30] about change as it is, even with information, but it's very easy to get emotional about
[3:07:37] unknown change, about a type of parking that you have not had exposure to.
[3:07:42] So with that aside, I think that being a little bit more logical and really seeing the safety
[3:07:49] and comparing the different designs, I'm for the back-end parking, I see the advantages
[3:07:57] of it, for many reasons, not only to accommodate safety for cyclists and kids and people that
[3:08:04] are walking downtown, but also the number one problem that since I've been downtown that's
[3:08:09] been reoccurring and I think we even brought it up before the council here in the petition,
[3:08:13] which is people aren't using the back lot. Well, if people are discouraged to back-end park
[3:08:19] in the front, they naturally will use the back parts of the parking and which is what
[3:08:25] but we've been trying to encourage them to do anyways.
[3:08:29] I do imagine a downtown that is healthy,
[3:08:32] 24th century accessible, not just a cyclist,
[3:08:36] but to all people.
[3:08:37] And we do have customers, I have customers,
[3:08:40] that come down moms, that come down on bikes,
[3:08:42] CSI students that don't have vehicles
[3:08:44] that come down to shop with us.
[3:08:46] And in the near future, I'm sure the cars will park themselves,
[3:08:49] but until then we do have to share the roads.
[3:08:52] And not only with bikes, but with buses, pedestrians, wheelchair, accessible, people that need wheelchair access.
[3:09:01] And as a mother, my instinct and rationale also tells me that back-end parking is safe for me and my children.
[3:09:07] So not just as a business owner, but as a consumer, as a downtown consumer, I do see the advantages of it.
[3:09:13] So I want to encourage the council to be logical and not just think about the emotional aspect of this decision
[3:09:21] and think about the downtown that we're investing the millions and millions and
[3:09:25] millions of dollars in building it for the future and for all people to enjoy.
[3:09:30] Thank you.
[3:09:31] Thank you, Leah.
[3:09:32] Is there anyone else?
[3:09:36] You'd come forward, sir?
[3:09:47] Thank you.
[3:09:48] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[3:09:49] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[3:09:52] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[3:09:57] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[3:10:01] people are forward thinking or backward thinking.
[3:10:04] It doesn't really matter to me.
[3:10:06] What matters to me is what my customers think.
[3:10:10] And I've had numerous people tell me that if they do back
[3:10:16] in parking, they just won't come downtown anymore.
[3:10:20] Now, I'm in an area downtown where the parking is pretty open,
[3:10:24] a back lot, and we have a back entrance.
[3:10:27] So that works for us pretty good.
[3:10:29] Now, they talked about having families down town
[3:10:33] and children and families.
[3:10:36] You know, we see more skateboarders at our place
[3:10:40] than we see bicycles.
[3:10:42] They're flying off that fountain all day long in the summer.
[3:10:47] Now, I know that's going to be gone, so that might change.
[3:10:50] But what, again, matters to me is what my customers think.
[3:10:55] Now, call them backward thinking.
[3:10:57] But if they're convinced that it's going to be way beyond their ability or their desire
[3:11:03] to back in park, then they probably won't come downtown.
[3:11:08] So I would encourage you to not put back in parking at this stage anyway, only because
[3:11:16] of what everybody that I've talked to has told me.
[3:11:21] Thank you.
[3:11:22] Thank you, Mr. Brown.
[3:11:23] Is there anyone else?
[3:11:24] All right.
[3:11:27] At this point, I'm going to go ahead and close the public testimony portion of this
[3:11:31] evening's agenda item and I will be turning this over to Council for questions
[3:11:38] and deliberation. We're going to be a little looser about the deliberation piece.
[3:11:42] But what I would encourage, I think we heard it from several individuals tonight,
[3:11:47] is that we make a decision. I think it's very important. Chris talking.
[3:11:52] Well, I would concur. I think the decision we can can and should make tonight
[3:11:56] and Council will drive some of our subsequent ones
[3:12:00] and the parking is something everybody at the last
[3:12:03] side is such a trivial issue, but I can't remember
[3:12:07] a city budget of 58 million ever drawing as many people
[3:12:11] as how to park, so we know that the priorities
[3:12:14] are something that people can grab a hold of
[3:12:17] and have evidence of whether government works
[3:12:20] for them or not.
[3:12:22] A couple of points, yes, I did angle park, back in angle parking, my SUV and had no trouble,
[3:12:31] and I wanted to work.
[3:12:33] I don't think it's going to work, and I'll tell you why, and it's this picture right
[3:12:37] here.
[3:12:38] Three of the four template designs show either trucks or SUVs in one little vehicle.
[3:12:46] In my SUV, I had to adjust my mirrors to get a good reflection or angle for back-end parking.
[3:12:56] So with my small SUV and taking the time to adjust the mirrors on the weekend evening, comparing
[3:13:05] that to a busy time with a one-ton pickup whose mirrors are high and wide or a mom with four
[3:13:14] five kids in a SUV, I think we're asking for a high spike potentially in vehicle vehicular
[3:13:25] type of accidents. My decision is from the start been driven by maximizing the sidewalk
[3:13:34] availability for downtown and more parking. And as such, I clearly come down on the side
[3:13:41] of 2B which is the current front end parking. I do appreciate very much the 21 or so people
[3:13:50] that have shown the stripes tonight and taken an active part in Twin Falls but I will stick
[3:13:58] with front end parking even if it is back end parking and get a ticket just to show
[3:14:04] them to stick with it. No, actually I'll go to the back lots or I hope more people do
[3:14:09] ago so that's let's make a decision you're right on thank you Chris Jim I thank
[3:14:15] you mayor I too agree that number two B is the best course of action for us to
[3:14:22] proceed with this evening with some with just a small caveat if you notice on
[3:14:26] number two B I don't know if you bring it bigger because you can't see the numbers
[3:14:29] very well but on number two B it shows that the sidewalk is 13 feet could we
[3:14:34] expand that or blow that up a little bit to be while he's talking.
[3:14:39] Yeah, the sidewalks are 13 feet.
[3:14:42] The angle parking at 45 degrees is 16 feet.
[3:14:46] The traffic lanes are 12.
[3:14:47] I would propose that we increase the sidewalks to 14,
[3:14:52] reduce the traffic lanes to 11, and proceed with number 2B.
[3:14:57] It'll provide 45 degree angle.
[3:14:59] It'll provide us 12 more parking spots downtown.
[3:15:02] We can put Sherro's in there, there's no, whereas best practices may say that's not in best practice,
[3:15:10] but we could put them there if we want to, if we believe that's okay.
[3:15:14] There was no indication of traffic accidents there, but I think that's a fair compromise,
[3:15:19] and it will also provide a parking configuration that in 20 years we can rethink it and maybe proceed
[3:15:27] with the back end parking in the future.
[3:15:29] So, 2B14 foot and sidewalks, 11 foot traffic lanes, 198 parking spots.
[3:15:35] Is that a motion?
[3:15:36] I don't think so, are we going to do it?
[3:15:40] Yeah.
[3:15:41] I would put that in the form of a motion, but I would like to hear from the other council
[3:15:44] to be.
[3:15:45] Do we have a second?
[3:15:46] I'll second it.
[3:15:47] We have a motion on the floor by Jim Munn, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins regarding recommending
[3:15:53] or approving 2B with 14 foot sidewalks, where the only change is 14 foot sidewalks and
[3:16:00] 11 foot lanes. Suzanne Hawkins. First of all, I think Jim was looking at my notes.
[3:16:04] I just want to go on the record and say that.
[3:16:07] Oh, sorry. I had to give you a brief on that.
[3:16:12] So, you know, the back-end angled parking makes sense for a certain group of the society,
[3:16:21] but I think, you know, as a council, we've decided to take public comment.
[3:16:24] We've decided to go out of our way to hear what the citizens wanted, and it's been
[3:16:29] and overwhelmingly negative towards back in parking.
[3:16:33] So we're elected to look out for the best interest of our city.
[3:16:38] And in this, I think our citizens have spoken,
[3:16:40] whether it's the time for it or not.
[3:16:43] I think we need to listen to what we've been told.
[3:16:46] And I agree with the motion Jim made and I would support the sidewalk change and the lane change.
[3:16:51] Greg Lanning.
[3:16:54] Well, first off, I want to say obviously like Chris said,
[3:16:57] I appreciate the people coming out and contacting me.
[3:17:02] I've been talking to people nonstop for about a month,
[3:17:06] like Leon said.
[3:17:07] You need information.
[3:17:08] I was at some of the earlier you were a meeting
[3:17:11] where this was being discussed.
[3:17:12] I'm a huge Daptan fan.
[3:17:14] The two years I was mayor, I made it a conscious effort
[3:17:18] to only eat at restaurants that were locally owned.
[3:17:22] In other words, I wouldn't go to a chain,
[3:17:23] I wouldn't go to a drive in unless I at least
[3:17:26] knew the first person who had the franchise.
[3:17:30] And so I've spent a lot of time in the restaurants downtown.
[3:17:33] I think everyone who is an owner of a restaurant downtown
[3:17:36] has seen me eat at those restaurants.
[3:17:37] Often I just try to take turns.
[3:17:39] I started one in and work the other in.
[3:17:41] I'd go back because there's five, four, five
[3:17:44] that you can hit, so you can give yourself
[3:17:45] a lot of variety that way.
[3:17:48] I tried the back end parking, and I was actually
[3:17:50] one of the ones that actually brought it in.
[3:17:52] I tried the back end parking here, and I'll
[3:17:54] Boycey, Boycey is a little more of a realistic view because there are any cars there. They have one section there in
[3:18:00] Bodo that is loosely back in parking and I'm pretty sure it's so they could put a bicycle link down the other side and make it safer for people to ride a bicycle.
[3:18:09] Chris I have the advantage by car actually whenever you put it in reverse the mirrors automatically tilt down a little bit so that made it very easy.
[3:18:19] cover up the backing camera which is going to be required by all vehicles like 2017 and that doesn't
[3:18:24] leave only 10 years or 20 years or 30 years of vehicles. I don't have it so that would make it
[3:18:30] easier. I tried it with the with the back it was really easy that way a little harder with the
[3:18:37] mirrors but I can still get it done. So I didn't really have a problem with it. I do know that it's
[3:18:44] safer because you're pulling out you can see the traffic and to be honest with you I most often park
[3:18:49] in the back parking lots because of that, because I don't like backing out into the lanes.
[3:18:54] So I'm one of the ones that use the back-end parking, or use the back-lot parking on purpose.
[3:19:01] But I know that I'm not the majority of, I've seen people wander around the block trying
[3:19:05] to find the parks.
[3:19:06] But I had to do that on the back-end.
[3:19:07] Boy, see, I had to go on the block like ten times to give a chance to back-end because
[3:19:10] they were all full.
[3:19:12] But anyway, and I know that back-end parking is probably going to be better for the future.
[3:19:17] I'm kind of leaning in the direction with the group as I expect it will
[3:19:22] votes to do Freddie and parking that we do design it in a manner that down the
[3:19:27] road as attitudes change and more cities start to have it and it becomes more
[3:19:32] an acceptable practice that we could change. I would like to see that. I
[3:19:36] certainly understand the investment arguments. There's a need out. At this
[3:19:41] particular time I want to give Tony a prop here on his. He took care of that
[3:19:46] problem with employees by going out and buying his own parking lot to put his
[3:19:49] employees in. I think he needs to be received credit for that for doing so
[3:19:53] because that took care of that problem for his employees. He tells them where to park
[3:19:58] because he provided them a place to park and I think if we could have more
[3:20:01] business to be able to do that I think that would also help our down to
[3:20:05] parking. But I just don't think we're ready and I'm I don't know if I know which
[3:20:11] one of these, I would specifically say to be there, but I do think we're going to have
[3:20:17] to at some point address the bicycles because that is going to become more and more the option
[3:20:23] for people to utilize to get downtown. I agree though we don't have a way for them to get
[3:20:28] there now and so just having a three block area with a with a share on down it isn't going
[3:20:33] to solve the problem. But anyway that's that's I will be voting for front end at this time,
[3:20:39] And I certainly would like to see us as it becomes more of a common thing to do to have
[3:20:45] backhand parking that we designed it so that we can move to backhand parking should be
[3:20:51] choose to.
[3:20:52] Thank you.
[3:20:53] Sean Berger.
[3:20:54] Thank you, Mayor.
[3:20:56] So I want to address just a few of the things that we're said to hear by the group because
[3:21:02] I do think that, and I think Leon may have made this point, taking the step back to
[3:21:08] to what this is actually about downtown
[3:21:12] is probably the more important perspective
[3:21:14] to be approaching this about.
[3:21:16] I appreciate that not a whole lot of people
[3:21:18] ride bikes to your restaurants today, they will.
[3:21:22] And in 15 years, when you're saying,
[3:21:24] why don't we have any bike lanes?
[3:21:25] There's no way for bicycles to get to my business.
[3:21:28] You're gonna be in here screaming
[3:21:29] about us building bike paths.
[3:21:31] So I'm just gonna address that now
[3:21:33] that bicycling, I'm looking through
[3:21:36] City's Strategic Plan is in no fewer than like seven initiatives of our City's Strategic Plan is
[3:21:43] about bicycle and pedestrian and vehicle harmony. So the question about why are we even dealing with
[3:21:52] bicycles is because it's our initiative as a community to create better connectivity.
[3:22:00] Does that mean you can get from point A to point B right now? No. I rode my bike from my house on the
[3:22:06] the east side of town to downtown several times last summer. Not on just event days. You
[3:22:11] find your way around. It was not comfortable riding on main avenue because people back
[3:22:17] up and can't see you. So I just want to address that issue about bicycles that this is about
[3:22:23] creating what's called a complete street which is defined as streets that are designed and
[3:22:33] operated to enable safe access for all users, including pedestrians, bicyclists, motorists,
[3:22:40] and transit riders of all ages and abilities.
[3:22:42] So the goal is to create a space that everybody can function in the way that they're most
[3:22:47] comfortable functioning.
[3:22:49] It was asked about public transit.
[3:22:51] We talked about that a couple of weeks ago that public buses would likely not be on
[3:22:56] Main Street in a public transit plan.
[3:22:58] They'd be on the second avenue.
[3:23:00] It addresses it.
[3:23:02] concept of let's allow bicycles to come downtown but park on the corner so they
[3:23:06] only have to walk a half block that's a neat idea I would make that same argument
[3:23:11] with every public parking lot we have downtown now there is no public parking
[3:23:16] lot that isn't that's further than a half block from every business why aren't
[3:23:20] vehicles parking in the public lots and walking the half block so again there are
[3:23:26] lots of issues downtown and I get it Liam was also right this is a political
[3:23:31] decision not about logic anymore. Logic flew out the window right about the time
[3:23:36] that everybody started ranting on KMBT's Facebook page about how we're all
[3:23:40] idiots and aren't listening to anyone. So I appreciate all of you who came
[3:23:45] tonight and gave constructive input on this. Random rants online is not public
[3:23:53] input. It's just not. I know some of you in this audience were some of those who
[3:23:58] we're making those pants.
[3:24:00] So again, I appreciate you coming here tonight
[3:24:03] and giving some constructive input.
[3:24:05] But I mean, even some of these printed comments
[3:24:08] we've received, I mean, I would have been embarrassed
[3:24:12] to turn this into the city as having come from your customers.
[3:24:17] Some of this commentary is just unprofessional
[3:24:21] and really out of line.
[3:24:23] So I'm gonna get off my soapbox now.
[3:24:27] I will certainly support a concept that allows us
[3:24:32] to protect your investments because that's important,
[3:24:36] but also makes it accessible not only to your customers today,
[3:24:40] but for the customers for the next 50 years downtown.
[3:24:44] I do think that the backup parking proposal provides a greater
[3:24:48] level of safety across the board.
[3:24:50] I think Dave Woodhead hit it on the head.
[3:24:53] do it, it's way, way safer to function. I sat downtown on Thursday for the demo. It was
[3:25:03] not people screwing up back in parking, that was what was concerning to me. It was every
[3:25:08] person who came down and flipped a ui and parked on the other side or just parallel parked
[3:25:14] across three diagonal spaces and dropped their wife off to run into the store or literally
[3:25:19] We pulled up on the sidewalk in front of businesses while we're all standing there.
[3:25:25] This isn't about, oh, back in parking is going to ruin downtown.
[3:25:28] People are just lousy drivers.
[3:25:31] And I know that all of this commentary was people can't back up, well, you know what?
[3:25:35] If you can't back up, turn your license in, because you have to back up sometimes and drive
[3:25:43] better downtown, because it just was an embarrassment to even watch people.
[3:25:48] So, like I said, I will certainly support making a decision so this can move forward.
[3:25:55] I do think we should preserve the option to allow us to make that change.
[3:26:01] The other comment too that I would make, and then I'll be quiet, you know, there is a perception
[3:26:08] that this is going to happen next week.
[3:26:10] We're just going to come downtown and re-stripe everything and move on with your day.
[3:26:16] So we have a year of construction on the alleys, and then we have about a year of construction
[3:26:23] that there is going to be no parking on Main Street, or at least in sections of Main Street,
[3:26:29] for a period of time all this reconstruction happens.
[3:26:31] My feeling would be when you give people a two-year lead, maybe they can figure out how
[3:26:37] to do it, or as Chris said, when you start forcing people to park in the, what was the
[3:26:44] 997 spaces downtown 997 space that's almost a thousand parking spaces in five
[3:26:52] blocks maybe they'll continue to use those so again all support but the
[3:26:59] council wants to to go with but I did want to get a little bit so boxy because
[3:27:04] I appreciate we put ourselves in these positions as public servants some of
[3:27:10] comments have been downright nasty and really undeserved.
[3:27:14] Thank you, Sean.
[3:27:16] I'm going to go ahead and weigh in.
[3:27:18] I'll try to keep my comments very, very short, but I went into this with safety being paramount
[3:27:27] to me and a full analysis of the different parking configurations led me to believe and
[3:27:36] experienced it that back-end parking is the safest way to for main street. While
[3:27:45] I was practicing my back-end parking, I saw a vehicle across the street in the
[3:27:51] front-end parking, pull out, pull completely across both lanes and
[3:27:58] then head out. And I saw a similar sized vehicle leaving the back-end parking
[3:28:04] stain within the one lane. So that told me enough right there that it was safer route to go.
[3:28:11] Now with that being said, there certainly doesn't seem to be the public support for that now.
[3:28:17] That's why I asked the question, can we change it later? Whatever configuration that we come
[3:28:21] up with tonight, can we change it later? And we can't. So I am in full support of Tooby.
[3:28:29] I wish the motion would have been with the existing lane widths, though.
[3:28:34] I think that for future the 12-foot lane for what we want to do, especially when we start
[3:28:39] talking about Sherrows and back in parking and all those dynamics made more sense.
[3:28:45] It's on a safety measure and that one extra foot on your sidewalk, on your side, doesn't
[3:28:52] negate the safety of the 12-foot lane for me for the future, but politics is all about
[3:28:59] compromise and this is compromised for me so I guess in the long run I would be
[3:29:04] supportive of this but I again wish it would have stayed at the 12-foot lane
[3:29:08] because maneuvering your vehicles to me is more important than one foot of sidewalk
[3:29:14] just out of the safety aspect. Suzanne Hawkins. Thank you. I just my thought on
[3:29:19] the lane going down to 11 foot is I see in in the future is going to the back in
[3:29:27] parking, and then we can make the parking area shorter and gain that back when we put
[3:29:35] the share hose in for the bike lane at that time.
[3:29:38] So that's why I thought if we do the extra sidewalk now, because adding the sidewalk later
[3:29:42] was going to be the difficult cost.
[3:29:45] So that was my thinking on that.
[3:29:47] I don't know if that's accurate or not.
[3:29:48] Maybe Mandy can correct me if I'm wrong.
[3:29:50] That's your thinking.
[3:29:51] It's just our opinion.
[3:29:52] So Sean Bearer.
[3:29:54] So actually, on that, isn't the Valley Gutter a concrete structure that's built, so really
[3:30:02] it can't move either.
[3:30:04] You can't add a foot and just scooch it down the road.
[3:30:09] So I would actually make an amendment to the motion to go back to the widths that are depicted
[3:30:17] on 2B with sidewalks at 13,
[3:30:22] angle parking at whatever that number is,
[3:30:25] 8 is 18 feet and 12 foot travel lanes.
[3:30:29] I'd second that motion.
[3:30:31] We have a motion on the floor by Sean Barrigar,
[3:30:33] seconded by Chris Talkington to amend
[3:30:36] the main motion to go back to
[3:30:37] the original 2B for 13 foot sidewalks and 12 foot lanes.
[3:30:43] Jim, I'm on.
[3:30:44] Okay, well, let's let's talk about this just for a minute
[3:30:47] If we reduce the track if we the valley gutters are
[3:30:53] Three feet the math isn't adding up for me. Okay. We have a as it exists now. We have 16 foot parking
[3:31:03] Three feet got three foot valley gutters
[3:31:06] 18 foot parking no on existing no on existing 16 foot parking three foot valley gutters
[3:31:13] 10.5 foot traffic lanes and then you know the same on the other side of the street.
[3:31:20] You go to 12B and my motion is to bring that to 14 feet, 16 feet, decrease the travel lane
[3:31:31] to 11, 11.
[3:31:35] What's the big deal?
[3:31:36] A crowded feeling of water driving, two feet I think is going to give a much more crowded
[3:31:42] feel.
[3:31:43] I won't support the amendment, because I think that we need to capture as much sidewalk spaces
[3:31:50] we can for our merchants down down there.
[3:31:54] So I think part of the discussion of leaving it at 12-foot lanes is that should there be
[3:32:01] a time in the future that the parking reverses and you go back in parking, 12-foot lanes
[3:32:09] will give greater comfort to bicycles sharing that and you can't once we build it
[3:32:19] if you reverse the parking you still don't you don't get to change any of the widths of the zones
[3:32:24] because everything is set the sidewalk is going to stay because you're either going to have to go build
[3:32:31] but you just can't do it you can't build a foot a sidewalk and then move the
[3:32:34] move the valley gutter afoot and do all those things and so
[3:32:38] Any further on the amendment to the main motion?
[3:32:44] Lee Island, roll call vote, please.
[3:32:49] Don Hall?
[3:32:50] Yes.
[3:32:52] Suzanne Hawkins?
[3:32:53] No.
[3:32:55] Jim Mun?
[3:32:56] No.
[3:32:57] Sean Berrigger?
[3:32:58] Yes.
[3:32:59] Chris Tockington?
[3:33:00] Yes.
[3:33:01] Great glancing.
[3:33:02] Yes.
[3:33:03] Motion passes forward to moving on to the main motion.
[3:33:07] Lee Island, roll call vote.
[3:33:08] Suzanne Hawkins?
[3:33:09] Yes.
[3:33:10] Jim Mun?
[3:33:11] Yes.
[3:33:12] Sean Berriger. Yes. Chris talking. Yes. Great glancing. Yes. Don. Yes. Motion passes six to zero. Ladies and gentlemen, I do want to thank you for coming out this evening, sharing your opinions. It makes a big difference to us to hear from you. And thank you for being
[3:33:30] Professional this evening as well Curtis did you want to say something before we end?
[3:33:34] Just speaking on behalf of the people who are here today. I want to thank you very much for answering that historic question
[3:33:48] to be or not to be I
[3:33:52] Want to state that that was Curtis Eaton
[3:33:58] Ladies and gentlemen, thank you
