Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2014-10-20, recording 1 (started 17:00)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2014-10-20/

[0:01:35] I'd like to call the meaning of the Twin Falls City Council to order.
[0:01:39] It's October 13th.
[0:01:41] It's just past five o'clock and I'm going to turn it over to Suzanne because she has an
[0:01:45] introduction to make just prior to us doing the Pledge of Allegiance.
[0:01:49] Thank you.
[0:01:50] Tonight we have the honor of having our Twin Falls City Youth Council members join us.
[0:01:55] We had our elections last month and our new president this year is Jonah Ruff and Jonah
[0:02:00] is going to bring up his team and lead us in the pledge and then introduce the Youth
[0:02:04] So I guess if you want to stand and join us in the Pledge of Allegiance, now's the time.
[0:02:09] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
[0:02:27] John, sounds like you're on.
[0:02:33] Yes. I am the President. This is Jesse Stroupe, a cousin. She is a Secretary.
[0:02:39] Harley-Jolothan, she is Vice President,
[0:02:42] and a bar, and Caitlin Morris, and also Ben Walling,
[0:02:47] and our treasurer and public relations are not here right now.
[0:02:54] What are you guys working on this year?
[0:02:56] We are deciding whether we should start a suicide prevention campaign
[0:03:01] we've possibly, we'll try to take this schools,
[0:03:04] and we're also doing a couple of community projects
[0:03:07] like in the Canyon Trail.
[0:03:09] Very good.
[0:03:10] Well welcome to all of you and thank you for your service. What about what schools we represent?
[0:03:18] I'm no bins not homeschooled bin bins from filer
[0:03:25] So filer and
[0:03:27] Can you reach?
[0:03:31] Yeah, we gave out 50 applications last month
[0:03:35] So hopefully well, thank you all again. Thank you for your service. Thank you
[0:03:40] I do want to confirm that we have a quorum of the City Council.
[0:03:44] Five members are here this evening,
[0:03:46] both Sean and Rebecca were not able to attend.
[0:03:50] We also, our city manager is not available tonight,
[0:03:53] so acting city manager Mitchell Humboldt,
[0:03:56] and we turn it over to him for any considerations of an amendment to the agenda.
[0:04:01] I don't think this will require motion or anything.
[0:04:03] I'd just like to flip up the order of items 2,
[0:04:05] 2, and 2, 3, discuss them in opposite order.
[0:04:10] So do three first and then two, correct?
[0:04:12] Okay, we can certainly do that, thank you, Mitch.
[0:04:15] With that, we have no proclamations tonight
[0:04:18] and this is an opportunity for anyone in the public
[0:04:20] that would like to come and stay anything
[0:04:23] to the council this evening.
[0:04:24] Generally we stay off of what is on the agenda
[0:04:27] because we'll have time to discuss that later
[0:04:28] but is there anyone from the general public
[0:04:31] that would like to come forward?
[0:04:34] [Muted for privacy: street address]
[0:04:37] [Muted for privacy: street address]
[0:04:38] [Muted for privacy: street address]
[0:04:39] I'm here on behalf of the Y because I want to thank the City Council and the Parks and
[0:04:44] Rec Department with Dennis and Kevin and Matt down there for the awesome landscaping job
[0:04:49] they did at the City Pool.
[0:04:50] That's really lightened up that facility a lot and I just, well, I think thanks her
[0:04:55] in order for how good of a job they did, so that's why it came tonight.
[0:04:58] I mean, they did a great job.
[0:05:01] We would like to have more folks come forward and say thank you to our city staff.
[0:05:04] I mean, thank you, John, for the service industry like I am,
[0:05:07] and it's nice to be complimented.
[0:05:09] I agree, because I just, around the tree,
[0:05:11] or was there other landscaping done?
[0:05:14] Just in the front of the facility, to the curb,
[0:05:17] and then all the way down to the south side of the pool deck.
[0:05:22] So it looks really great.
[0:05:23] Thanks, John, and Mitch, if you can make sure
[0:05:25] that you share that with Dennis, so you can tell those folks,
[0:05:29] really appreciate you coming and sharing that, John.
[0:05:31] Excellent.
[0:05:33] All right, next item on the agenda is the consent calendar, Jim Munn.
[0:05:37] Move approval.
[0:05:38] Second.
[0:05:39] Have a motion on the floor by Jim Munn.
[0:05:41] Seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to approve the consent calendar as noted.
[0:05:48] Anything further on that motion council?
[0:05:52] Leila, roll call vote please.
[0:05:53] Suzanne Hawkins?
[0:05:54] Yes.
[0:05:55] Jim Munn?
[0:05:56] Yes.
[0:05:57] Chris Tawkington?
[0:05:57] Yes.
[0:05:58] Greg Lansing?
[0:05:59] Yes.
[0:06:00] Don Hall?
[0:06:00] Yes, motion passes.
[0:06:02] five to zero. So we'll move to the next item under item for consideration and that's a consideration
[0:06:09] of a request to approve a senior advisory committee and we have Bob and Daphne Mallory. Welcome
[0:06:15] Bob Daphne. The floor is yours.
[0:06:24] Thank you Mr. Mayor and council members. We're here to give you a progress report and we think
[0:06:32] We're ready to move forward to the next step in formation of a senior advisory committee
[0:06:37] to the City Council upon approval.
[0:06:40] We've had some meetings and some discussions and come up with more of a framework which you
[0:06:46] should have your notes in front of you for what the Council make up would look like.
[0:06:52] Some of the decisions that have been made, first of all for membership is an age range
[0:06:58] which would be 65 and up.
[0:07:01] The reasoning behind that being that the City of Twin Falls
[0:07:05] recognizes that age as senior system age.
[0:07:08] I know everybody from restaurants to different organizations
[0:07:12] or different government bodies pick a different age,
[0:07:15] but that's the age that Twin Falls is our understanding,
[0:07:19] recognizes as a senior citizen.
[0:07:21] So in terms of an advisory committee,
[0:07:24] it seems to make sense for consistency sake
[0:07:27] to keep it at 65 and up for membership.
[0:07:31] Additional things that we're recommending
[0:07:35] in terms of membership of the committee
[0:07:39] to keep that open, no maximum cap for the number of people
[0:07:43] who want to participate in it.
[0:07:46] However, once it's formed, once the body begins gathering,
[0:07:51] it will elect its own officers and then
[0:07:53] again drafting bylaws with the assistance of the city and kind of move forward from there.
[0:08:02] We think we're at that point now where we need to start incorporating seniors into that
[0:08:07] process and moving forward.
[0:08:09] And so that's what we're here to visit with you about tonight.
[0:08:12] Excellent.
[0:08:13] Chris Stockety has a question.
[0:08:15] Well, I know you're both smart and not that you thought this through, but if you ask people
[0:08:19] to join, they usually want to know why, what's your mission, what's your vision, have you gotten
[0:08:24] something you can get a handle on for us, instead of just being old people, as many of us are,
[0:08:31] what do you see the direction you're moving or the needed services now provided something
[0:08:38] on the phone?
[0:08:41] So some of the pressing issues revolve around transportation as well as meal services, but
[0:08:47] We do want to emphasize again that this is not a programs or services committee, but rather
[0:08:52] a committee that could provide recommendation as part of the strategic plan that the City
[0:08:57] already has in place as well as addressing future needs in the community.
[0:09:02] Okay.
[0:09:03] Thank you.
[0:09:04] And just as another example yesterday, I went to the VFW meeting Veterans of Foreign Wars,
[0:09:11] which is primarily a senior citizen group
[0:09:15] and presented the information to them.
[0:09:17] They wanted to know more about it.
[0:09:19] Of course, our veterans are some of our more service minded
[0:09:23] citizens and groups like that are asking us to come
[0:09:27] and tell them more about the idea for the committee
[0:09:29] at this point.
[0:09:30] So we're doing some of that outreach, personally as well,
[0:09:33] going and talking about the idea with different groups
[0:09:36] in the community.
[0:09:39] Might still want to say it.
[0:09:43] I have a couple of questions for Fred's.
[0:09:46] Fred's, could you come forward?
[0:09:51] This may sound like a silly question,
[0:09:52] but I just want to make sure that we have our ducks
[0:09:56] in a row here.
[0:09:57] The 65 and older, that's not gonna be any kind of a
[0:10:01] discrimination for someone that's 55
[0:10:03] that wants to join or anything.
[0:10:05] Is there some precedents?
[0:10:07] There's discrimination against people over a certain age,
[0:10:10] is that not?
[0:10:11] Nothing under, okay, so there's no issue there.
[0:10:14] And if we choose to move ahead, and I don't know exactly
[0:10:17] what council wishes are going to be tonight,
[0:10:20] you and I had a quick discussion regarding codifying this
[0:10:24] or not, and trying to put some structure around it.
[0:10:28] Maybe you could share our conversation.
[0:10:30] Yeah, so I guess it depends on how much control
[0:10:34] you want over this committee.
[0:10:36] It sounds like to me from the presentation,
[0:10:38] they don't necessarily want you to have that much control
[0:10:41] They want an open group that may periodically come to the council with recommendation.
[0:10:49] So it might look something more like the Youth Council that's self-regulating, self-governing.
[0:10:55] You may recall when you created that, you did it by resolution rather than by ordinance,
[0:11:02] so it doesn't appear in the code, but they do have bylaws, so they can refer to the bylaws.
[0:11:07] And I don't know how much control you want to have with the bylaws for that matter either, right?
[0:11:11] I guess the council probably needs to provide direction about how much control you want to have over this or
[0:11:18] whether you want to allow them to be self-governing and if they have something to present to you, they come back to you if they wish to.
[0:11:26] Yeah, I think this is a discussion that we probably should have.
[0:11:29] You know, I think about our transparency resolution and how that would dovetail or fit in with this.
[0:11:35] The other thing that I think about is that many times our senior populations are those
[0:11:39] that people try to victimize.
[0:11:41] There's predators out there, and if something were to take place within this advisory committee
[0:11:47] and we had no knowledge of what they were doing and ends up being some sort of victimization,
[0:11:53] I think that might be very, very, what would be concerning to me that we were not involved
[0:12:00] in that.
[0:12:01] I don't know if we just like to throw that out and see what council feels about that.
[0:12:06] Mr. Mayor, isn't it typical though with advisory committees that there is a council liaison that goes to the meetings and offers a little guidance or participation as well?
[0:12:16] That is true, there is a standard.
[0:12:19] Okay.
[0:12:20] Not with every committee but with most, yes.
[0:12:25] Okay.
[0:12:26] Suzanne Hunt.
[0:12:28] Thank you.
[0:12:29] As we've been going through some of the brainstorming together, we have discussed the youth council
[0:12:34] as a role model in all of our discussions to the fact that even we've looked at the youth
[0:12:40] council bylaws to see how some of that might apply.
[0:12:44] And I think this group is looking for a place just to have really their thoughts and opinions
[0:12:51] heard and considered.
[0:12:53] It's not that they're looking for anything in particular.
[0:12:57] It's kind of a tough one, but I kind of looked at it more as the committees that have helped
[0:13:02] with the wastewater treatment and now downtown and space needs for us, that it's open to the
[0:13:08] citizens to come and just kind of have a place to brainstorm together and present solutions
[0:13:14] to us and not problems for things they're facing.
[0:13:18] And so I think it should be maintained.
[0:13:21] We've definitely discussed meeting here and keeping it recorded.
[0:13:27] It would definitely have minutes taken and be open and noticed to the public so it's not
[0:13:32] anything that's private or hidden.
[0:13:34] So I think that would put it in line with our transparency guidelines.
[0:13:39] And just really a chance for maybe some solutions to some problems where we're not even aware
[0:13:44] of this.
[0:13:45] Jim.
[0:13:46] Thank you, Mayor.
[0:13:47] First of all, I have a question.
[0:13:50] The Youth Council, is it codified?
[0:13:52] Resolution only.
[0:13:53] With the resolution only.
[0:13:54] Okay.
[0:13:55] One of the advantages I see of us developing this group is older people like consistency.
[0:14:02] And if there is a time and a place, monthly, bi-monthly, where they know where one of us
[0:14:09] or a group of facilitators are going to be, every month just to talk through issues, I
[0:14:15] think that's really good.
[0:14:17] I think the resolution matter with resolution idea is probably the most efficient.
[0:14:23] So I really don't see a disadvantage to this.
[0:14:25] I do also see Dawn's concern about victimization,
[0:14:30] so forth to this group.
[0:14:31] I may also have an opportunity to work with our older people
[0:14:36] on fraud prevention and other things
[0:14:38] that transpire in our community.
[0:14:39] So I support this in a resolution environment.
[0:14:45] Chris, talking to you.
[0:14:46] It's not often I get to agree and disagree
[0:14:48] with all three of my previous speakers,
[0:14:50] But yeah, I think the resolution is the way to handle it.
[0:14:53] I certainly would think, though, that we want to hear more
[0:14:59] about problems and solutions.
[0:15:01] There can't just be a glad-handed group.
[0:15:03] There may be some issues pertaining to city ordinances
[0:15:06] or the victimization of seniors don as you alluded to
[0:15:09] through scamming, online, or phone solicitation, probably,
[0:15:15] that could be very helpful.
[0:15:17] As long as by resolution, it's very clear that the senior group is not an ad hoc one season
[0:15:23] like your wastewater and where you have a beginning and ending.
[0:15:26] I think you want it to continue, don't you?
[0:15:29] As long as it's not implied and heard or any way alluded to that this committee is representing
[0:15:35] the official position, the city of Twin Falls, I see that with the resolution you have a good
[0:15:42] mandate to collect as many of the ideas, both problems and solutions and present some advisory
[0:15:50] recommendations to the council. Happy to work through the code and know what's really on
[0:15:56] the books. And I certainly would be happy to work with them in any way.
[0:16:01] Thank you, Chris. So, Jim, I just real quickly, are we going to, is the idea to meet here
[0:16:09] or maybe meet at the senior center, or what's the,
[0:16:12] if we develop any a plan of attack in that regard?
[0:16:16] The idea is to meet here, I think,
[0:16:18] for to cover the transparency issue.
[0:16:21] Right.
[0:16:22] And just to ensure a consistent location.
[0:16:25] There may be some other issues with the mobility
[0:16:29] and other things that need to be ironed out,
[0:16:31] but until we kind of see the interest level
[0:16:34] and who's coming and what the needs are in terms of that.
[0:16:38] Okay, but so here we have a great answer at this point, but yes here for four meetings.
[0:16:44] I'm cool with that.
[0:16:45] Thank you.
[0:16:46] I'm wondering we discussed early on that it would be more of a floating so we could go
[0:16:50] to the seniors where the seniors were.
[0:16:53] I'm wondering whatever we do with this resolution and it sounds like council's leaning towards
[0:16:57] resolution that we leave it a little bit open so we can do that if we wish.
[0:17:01] But again, I agree with Jim that seniors do like consistency and if it's generally here
[0:17:08] that that'll help.
[0:17:09] Prigland?
[0:17:10] Well, I just want to, you know,
[0:17:11] throw my support of one of the ones with one of Suzanne
[0:17:15] that met with, been meeting with Mallory's
[0:17:17] and about coming up with a plan for this
[0:17:22] and I certainly give me a perspective on some ideas
[0:17:27] of things that they might be able to not only help with
[0:17:31] but also bring ideas in problems to us
[0:17:35] that we may be unaware of.
[0:17:37] and I like the idea of it meeting here so that we can at least begin with so we can gauge the
[0:17:44] interest and then on occasion if they want to venture out I think I agree I think the resolution
[0:17:49] should be stated as kind of like the other with with announcement they can say we will meet at
[0:17:56] and like just right now all of our commissions have that ability we're pretty tight on them but
[0:18:01] like the golf course occasionally meets at the golf commission occasionally meets at the golf
[0:18:06] Of course, because there's a specific thing
[0:18:08] what they want to look at.
[0:18:09] So, yeah, I would think that this would be something thing.
[0:18:12] I would like to think that we should have Fritz
[0:18:15] write it up for us and vote on it in a separate week, though.
[0:18:20] Yeah, so if we could get some direction,
[0:18:23] you shouldn't be enacting a resolution tonight.
[0:18:25] You should be either directing us or a deaf knee to,
[0:18:30] I would suggest that maybe because we've got a framework
[0:18:33] from the Youth Council resolution in my laws, either have them look at it or have the direct
[0:18:39] us to look at it and come back with a form for you?
[0:18:43] I think that's a good idea.
[0:18:45] And with the staff report here, there are some nuggets in there that could be utilized
[0:18:50] for it as well, so does that sound good to the two of you?
[0:18:55] We've got other lights on, so we're not going, we're not done with this agenda item yet.
[0:18:58] I apologize, I'm not well versed in the process, but is there a way to make this finalize tonight pending the legalese afterwards or no?
[0:19:11] I'm not comfortable with voting on a resolution that's not in front of me.
[0:19:16] You have to have a resolution in front of you drafted that we have to vote on.
[0:19:22] So I think if I could just get consensus, I think we're all wanting to do this, and I'm
[0:19:28] fairly confident with the other two members that are here this evening.
[0:19:31] They are as well, but I think that we just need to get it a little more structure to
[0:19:36] it.
[0:19:37] Okay.
[0:19:38] So, I mentioned you have something completely unrelated, but we've got some reports coming
[0:19:43] in through Josh that there's folks watching online that can't hear very good.
[0:19:46] So if we could all make sure we talk into our microphones.
[0:19:49] Very good.
[0:19:50] Okay, closer.
[0:19:51] Can we give a timeline, though, when we might have the resolution, or Fred's commit, we've done with him for a time?
[0:19:58] I was going to do a teach-on.
[0:20:01] Jim, I would move that we direct staff, namely the city attorney, to prepare a city resolution for the development of a senior council, advisory council for the city of Twin Falls,
[0:20:16] to be drafted in the same, I guess, manifestation as a youth council and bring that back to council
[0:20:25] within the next two weeks if possible.
[0:20:30] For our review.
[0:20:31] We have a motion on board by Jim Munn, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:20:35] The only thing that I would add is I would really like to see at least the articles or what we say, not just the resolution,
[0:20:47] resolution but the bylaws thank you bylaws being drafted by the seniors themselves
[0:20:53] okay so I can the one we did for the youth council both created these council
[0:20:58] and set forth the bylaws so I can share what we did for the council with Bob
[0:21:04] and Mallory and then they can provide any changes like that they might want or
[0:21:09] thought we were suggesting yeah yeah I would just like to see the seniors
[0:21:14] involved in the bylaws and I'm assuming do we have a group of seniors that you've
[0:21:19] been meeting with that are interested in this because I don't see any of them here
[0:21:24] I would love to have seen a few seniors here to maybe share their perspective as
[0:21:28] well. Well we certainly don't want to I guess we didn't feel that that would be
[0:21:33] appropriate that we would start recruiting seniors that we would that
[0:21:38] this process take place and then have it open to the entire public for the reason
[0:21:43] why we've not done that.
[0:21:45] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:21:47] In our meetings, we did discuss the bylaws a number of times.
[0:21:50] And we agreed that if we could get the resolution
[0:21:53] and get the group organized and then
[0:21:55] get some founding members of that group,
[0:21:57] then let them kind of work with Fritz on the bylaws
[0:22:00] and how they see running their organization.
[0:22:03] But at the same time, having a general outline for bylaws
[0:22:07] that we look at now and then when they do form,
[0:22:09] they can make adjustments to their bylaws
[0:22:12] if it needs to be also.
[0:22:14] It's not like it's a one-time shot.
[0:22:16] I agree.
[0:22:17] For instance, that sound logical to you.
[0:22:22] I think it makes the most sense to start out
[0:22:24] with the set of bylaws they can work from.
[0:22:26] And then when they're organized and have time to meet about them
[0:22:30] and talk and work with them for a while,
[0:22:33] youth council came back and we modified those bylaws.
[0:22:36] We can certainly do that here.
[0:22:37] But it'll give them a framework to at least operate short term.
[0:22:41] I did not hear in your motion, Jim,
[0:22:43] that bylaws were attached to.
[0:22:44] I would like to include bylaws in this motion.
[0:22:47] Second.
[0:22:48] I agree.
[0:22:49] All right, we have a motion on the floor by Jim Munn,
[0:22:52] seconded by Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:22:53] Anything further on that motion council?
[0:22:56] Lee Island, roll call vote, please.
[0:22:58] Jim Munn.
[0:22:58] Yes.
[0:23:00] Chris Tawkins.
[0:23:00] Yes.
[0:23:01] Greg Lanting.
[0:23:02] Yes.
[0:23:03] Don Hall.
[0:23:03] Yes.
[0:23:04] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:23:05] Yes.
[0:23:06] Motion passes.
[0:23:07] Aye.
[0:23:07] To zero.
[0:23:08] Thank you both for all your work that you're doing on this.
[0:23:10] We really appreciate it.
[0:23:11] Thank you all.
[0:23:13] Okay, next item on the agenda, we're flip-flopping three for two, so we're going to three.
[0:23:18] It is a presentation discussion regarding a public information pamphlet about the causes
[0:23:23] of sewer backups and possible measures residents can use to prevent sewer backups in their homes.
[0:23:31] Mitch Humble and Josh Palmer, welcome Mitch.
[0:23:33] I'll go ahead and start talking whenever we get to the pamphlet thing on that Josh kind
[0:23:40] to pipe in if he fills the need to.
[0:23:45] So I guess back in August we had a minor rain event,
[0:23:49] ended up in something like a 300 year flood for us.
[0:23:52] I don't know if anybody remembers that or not,
[0:23:54] but it was kind of a big deal.
[0:23:57] And since then we've talked about a lot of different things
[0:23:59] the city could do maybe better up front.
[0:24:03] One of the negative things that happened in that event
[0:24:09] was that we had several of our residence homes
[0:24:12] where the sewers filled up with rainwater
[0:24:15] and discharged into the lowest point,
[0:24:18] being people's basements.
[0:24:20] So there was at least 14 that actually submitted claims
[0:24:25] to the city, and there may have been several more
[0:24:26] that didn't submit claims.
[0:24:29] And if we fast forward to today,
[0:24:32] and today's building codes and the plumbing codes,
[0:24:35] that kind of thing shouldn't be happening.
[0:24:38] If there's a situation where there's a drain that's kind of lower than the outside manhole
[0:24:43] in those situations, a backwater valve is required to be installed, but that's in the history
[0:24:49] of Twin Falls.
[0:24:50] It's a relatively new requirement, and so we may have a lot of older homes that don't
[0:24:55] have these backwater valves installed.
[0:24:57] A backwater valve essentially just prevents sewage from flowing out of the pipe and into
[0:25:02] a home, which is sort of the reverse way of where it should be flowing, right, out of the
[0:25:07] home and into the pipe.
[0:25:08] And so we thought we'd put together some informational packet
[0:25:12] that just says, hey, here's the situation.
[0:25:15] Sewer backups happen.
[0:25:17] And it doesn't just come from a rain event.
[0:25:19] It could come from any number of sources.
[0:25:20] And so the sources of sewer backups are discussed in here.
[0:25:27] And one possible solution to maybe fixing that would be
[0:25:30] insulation of a backwater valve, or fixing the one that's there
[0:25:32] that's broken because it was installed 20 years ago,
[0:25:35] and hasn't been maintained or whatever, right?
[0:25:38] So the information brochure is this is out there,
[0:25:42] there's an opportunity that maybe if we get ahead of it
[0:25:45] next time, we can prevent the next backup
[0:25:47] from negatively impacting you.
[0:25:51] And so it's just like the word out
[0:25:53] that this is available and this is out there.
[0:25:55] We wanted to bring this to the council to talk about it,
[0:25:58] again, because internet and visibility,
[0:26:00] we do want to get the word out.
[0:26:02] That these are available.
[0:26:04] And so, you know, we've got the brochure.
[0:26:08] It's all in your packet, but I brought one in like the trifold method, right?
[0:26:12] So when you print them out, we can have these kind of in, you know, holders on the counters
[0:26:17] and we can post on the internet and do whatever we need to do to get it out.
[0:26:27] Well, it's pretty sophisticated as a template from someplace else that you just kind of cut and paste.
[0:26:33] I mean, a sewer problem is a sewer problem.
[0:26:35] No, this was a fun project to work with because the pictures I was sent, so I tossed the pictures.
[0:26:42] No, we created this one from Scratch, and as it emphasized it as a draft, I want it to be as easily understandable by our average member of the public as possible.
[0:26:53] So, I'm still looking for any feedback on, and you can send me emails at a later time if you'd like,
[0:26:59] but if there's something that would make it easier for our citizens to understand,
[0:27:02] you know, please let me know and we'll run it by other staff
[0:27:04] members as well.
[0:27:07] So you guys have all had the opportunity
[0:27:10] to read some of my writing before.
[0:27:13] I put together a bunch of information,
[0:27:15] and I said, this is me talking to you know, you Josh,
[0:27:18] can you maybe put this in a form that actually
[0:27:21] the public might be better at reading.
[0:27:24] And we talked about whether we should include pictures of sewer
[0:27:26] backups, but we decided not to.
[0:27:29] Yeah.
[0:27:30] Wise move.
[0:27:33] Right?
[0:27:34] So anyway, like I said, we wanted to get the word out.
[0:27:38] On the back page of this, there's some phone numbers
[0:27:39] where somebody could call and maybe get some help,
[0:27:42] some assistance from either our sewer department,
[0:27:45] maybe the building department is a plumber
[0:27:48] on staff, a plumbing inspector on staff.
[0:27:50] And so, like I said, that's kind of the purpose
[0:27:54] of this was just to kind of talk about it.
[0:27:56] If you do have feedback, let us know.
[0:27:58] We'll tweak it a little bit.
[0:27:59] This this is still in someone of a draft form.
[0:28:04] And I guess that's about it.
[0:28:07] I would suggest we list the mayor's number for calling when they have what are
[0:28:11] from us. That's the first time Chris is really something nice to me.
[0:28:16] So I really appreciate that Chris call 24 hours 24.
[0:28:20] 24 7 call me 24 7.
[0:28:23] You know, I'm wondering in here somewhere or is it logical to or maybe it says
[0:28:29] that I read through it, but I don't remember.
[0:28:31] Does it say anything about your existing ones?
[0:28:34] If I have one, I'm sure,
[0:28:36] because my house was built in the 70s.
[0:28:38] Maybe I don't.
[0:28:39] I don't know what year it was that these were implemented.
[0:28:42] So to that point, before we jump off it real quick,
[0:28:44] we were able to go backwards.
[0:28:46] And the city's only been enforcing the plumbing code
[0:28:48] since 2007.
[0:28:50] So before that, the state was enforcing the plumbing code.
[0:28:52] And so we kind of did a little bit of digging back
[0:28:54] into state plumbing code history.
[0:28:56] We got to the 1990 plumbing code,
[0:28:59] and they were required at that point.
[0:29:01] Back further than that, we had a hard time really finding
[0:29:05] whether it was there or not.
[0:29:06] So in the 70s, maybe, maybe not.
[0:29:08] Maybe not, right?
[0:29:09] Yeah.
[0:29:10] But also, it would only be required in certain circumstances.
[0:29:13] Not every home has to have one.
[0:29:14] For example, my home doesn't have one.
[0:29:16] My lowest drain is higher than the next elevation manhole
[0:29:22] in the road out there.
[0:29:23] And so for me, it's not really an issue.
[0:29:27] You have to have an inspection, which
[0:29:28] the next item. Right and so in theory it was a code requirement and the home was
[0:29:33] built it should have met the code at the time and nowadays that is the case.
[0:29:39] Older homes that's that's the question so we're given a little bit information here
[0:29:44] and you can call us if you have questions. The next item we do want to talk about
[0:29:47] another option that the city can maybe provide a service to help people with
[0:29:52] that exact question. How do I know if I have one or if it's 40 years old because
[0:29:57] because it was installed in 72, this is still work, right?
[0:30:02] Or was it installed properly, or was it broken, or whatever?
[0:30:05] And so, yeah.
[0:30:06] So, can that be in this, should that be in the brochure?
[0:30:09] I do think that it should be, if we go to the next item and we're deciding that we want
[0:30:14] to proceed with that, then yeah, we will tweak this to say, call this number for this particular
[0:30:20] service, and that should actually be part of it, but that kind of depends on what happens
[0:30:26] next to.
[0:30:27] I just want to say, I think this is a good step forward.
[0:30:32] If we're not learning from these issues that come our way,
[0:30:36] which we'll have another one next year, something else,
[0:30:39] we're not learning from them, and trying to make life better
[0:30:42] for our citizens, then we're not doing our due diligence.
[0:30:45] So I appreciate both of your effort and the other folks
[0:30:47] that have been involved in this as well.
[0:30:50] Chris, talking to you.
[0:30:51] Well, yeah, nothing but compliments.
[0:30:53] It's vastly improved over the nothing
[0:30:56] as we have before. I don't believe in the city inventing anything if we can learn from
[0:31:01] other locales and I'm just wondering if we can take a little time if you haven't already
[0:31:06] do a check of other similar pamphlets just to make sure there's nothing we have overlooked.
[0:31:14] So when I was putting the information together I did a bunch of like web searching and things
[0:31:19] like that and I wasn't coming up with a lot of information from cities where I got a lot
[0:31:23] of the information I got was actually from folks that built and sell back water valves.
[0:31:27] No.
[0:31:28] That's where a lot of it came from.
[0:31:32] But granted, I wasn't specifically searching cities.
[0:31:36] Or just on the cutting edge, then, really, that's fine.
[0:31:38] Potentially.
[0:31:39] There may be out there, and I just was searching maybe just a different kind of search area.
[0:31:45] We can certainly look, though.
[0:31:47] More than a pressure station.
[0:31:48] Greg Lenny.
[0:31:49] Well thank you appreciate the efforts. I have a feeling that this is going to get
[0:31:54] copied by a lot of other cities. That's what I have a feeling and which is a
[0:31:59] kudos to Jostri, your expertise in putting this together and then everybody
[0:32:04] for that helped you out. One thing I'll just close with really quickly, if you
[0:32:11] open it up or you don't have muffle it up, but I think it's I don't know where it
[0:32:17] shows up on the first page or second page. It's in the dark great box that it
[0:32:21] runs down the full length of it.
[0:32:22] There's like causes of sewer backups.
[0:32:24] And part of this presentation really
[0:32:29] needs to be to tell people to know, flush, or put down
[0:32:33] your sink, oils, and fats and greases, really.
[0:32:36] That is one of the more common causes of a sewer backup.
[0:32:40] And for us in Twin Falls, that is one of the more common things
[0:32:44] that our sewer department is out there cleaning up.
[0:32:47] It's oils and fats and greases that people wash down the sink.
[0:32:51] or whatever, and that's really something we shouldn't be doing.
[0:32:55] So that also is part of the message that needs to get out,
[0:32:58] is look for it, find other ways to dispose of that stuff.
[0:33:02] Good point.
[0:33:03] Well again, thank you both, and that sounds good.
[0:33:07] Next item on the agenda is consideration of a request to act on a proposal
[0:33:12] to create a new inspection application for existing installation inspection request.
[0:33:18] Mitch.
[0:33:19] So, as I was going through this exercise for the sewer backup brochure pamphlet thing, I'm
[0:33:29] also having another conversation really at the same time that talked about, you know,
[0:33:35] maybe we could be a bit more proactive with customers in the building department regarding
[0:33:41] kind of existing buildings and how do we move forward with existing buildings and things
[0:33:45] like that.
[0:33:46] These two kind of came together at a real nice time.
[0:33:51] So this opportunity for, we have a plumbing inspector.
[0:33:55] He's willing to do these things.
[0:33:57] Very few people know to call, to ask.
[0:34:01] And when they do call to ask, what exactly
[0:34:04] would they be asking for?
[0:34:07] So what we also want to do tonight was get the word out
[0:34:10] again on this particular request.
[0:34:14] we have in our fee structure, and it's
[0:34:17] been there for at least 20-something years.
[0:34:20] I want to go back to the 1994 adoption of codes,
[0:34:25] and I can trace this back to that point,
[0:34:28] where we have a fee structure established
[0:34:30] for an existing installation inspection.
[0:34:33] Basically, if you have something in your home or in your business
[0:34:37] that was installed some time ago, and you're curious if it's
[0:34:41] working or was installed properly,
[0:34:42] you can call and request one of these kinds of inspections
[0:34:45] and we'll go out and take a look at it for you.
[0:34:47] This is a kind of inspection that doesn't come about
[0:34:51] because of a proposed construction standard or a project.
[0:34:56] Right, most of our other permits are directly tied to,
[0:34:58] I want to do this project and I need a permit to do it.
[0:35:02] This isn't that.
[0:35:03] This is somebody else did the work awhile ago
[0:35:05] and we want to double check it.
[0:35:07] That's why it's not, I think, why it's not really commonly
[0:35:10] thought of as a service the building department does.
[0:35:13] But it is, it's out there.
[0:35:21] So we have this opportunity, and we
[0:35:22] have a fee that's been established for 20-something years.
[0:35:24] I don't think it's changed since it was first adopted either.
[0:35:31] But it's really an opportunity that we
[0:35:33] can get the plumbing inspector out to your home
[0:35:35] to answer the question that Jim asked just a few minutes ago.
[0:35:38] How do I know if I have one of these?
[0:35:40] A lot of people may not know if they're curious about it,
[0:35:43] and they want to call up.
[0:35:44] We can get Steve out there to take a look.
[0:35:47] And you can look at the situation, and you can tell you, yep, that banola is up here,
[0:35:50] and that drain is down here, and guess what happens when it backs up?
[0:35:54] It comes out the lowest point.
[0:35:56] That's you.
[0:35:57] And there's not one here.
[0:35:59] And we can do it and provide that service to the community.
[0:36:03] A person, a homeowner, could just easily call a plumber and ask them to come out and do
[0:36:07] it.
[0:36:08] And in fact, the installation, if it does lead to an installation, needs to happen by a plumber
[0:36:13] with a permit.
[0:36:15] Our guy isn't going to do that for somebody.
[0:36:17] He can just help you understand if you need it or not.
[0:36:19] And if you do, he'll tell you, yeah, you need one.
[0:36:22] You need to go get a permit.
[0:36:23] And by the way, that's only $10 peramic.
[0:36:25] That's a small job.
[0:36:26] And we'll treat him that way too.
[0:36:28] So Mitch, is the testing to see if it's
[0:36:30] working properly done by a private plumber or by our folks?
[0:36:33] So what we can also do is look at if there is one there,
[0:36:36] we can look at the existing installation.
[0:36:38] Was it done properly and probably actually take a crack?
[0:36:42] Is it broken or not?
[0:36:44] If he can't, then he'll say it's much, right?
[0:36:48] But most of the time he'll be able to tell.
[0:36:51] And he should be able to see just by walking onto the site.
[0:36:55] Yes, you have one.
[0:36:56] Now I want to be clear also, this doesn't just apply to the back what about it.
[0:37:00] Is there anything in any existing installation that a business or at home?
[0:37:05] Christong didn't ask for us.
[0:37:07] What's the rationale where we would charge residential inspection at the half hour rate
[0:37:12] where commercials will be paying a full hour.
[0:37:15] Is it just the usual time on hand, the complexity?
[0:37:18] So you're jumping ahead of me a little bit?
[0:37:20] So that was a recommendation from the building
[0:37:23] and advisory board.
[0:37:24] Yeah, I think that's exactly where they're at.
[0:37:26] You know, if you're going to go look at a small installation
[0:37:29] at home, you're not going to be there very long.
[0:37:31] But you can't do anything in a commercial application
[0:37:34] in under an hour.
[0:37:35] That was their thought.
[0:37:38] Now, having said that, the fee structure
[0:37:41] already about it and it is what it is unless we go through a process to amend that. They
[0:37:47] just were making a statement that you're going to go to a commercial inspection and it's going
[0:37:52] to be an hour. So the half hour minimum thing is kind of a move point for a commercial. Okay,
[0:38:01] so that answer your question, okay? Yes, thank you. I'm going to back up a little bit then.
[0:38:07] So this whole backwater valve thing was kind of on my mind as I was going through another
[0:38:13] series of conversations.
[0:38:15] And this one really is a completely different scenario, but the same real solution I think
[0:38:20] is a good solution for this other scenario too.
[0:38:24] Well, at times the building department will be asked to come look at an existing installation
[0:38:30] for various reasons.
[0:38:33] One in particular I can think of was the building in town that's an older building that's been
[0:38:36] around for a while, is having a switch out of a tenant.
[0:38:41] And an electrician who was in a bid on that job,
[0:38:44] he didn't have the job yet, had asked Rob,
[0:38:48] our electrical inspector, to come take a look
[0:38:49] at the existing scenario to kind of help him maybe
[0:38:54] prepare a better bid.
[0:38:56] Rob had been to this building before for other permits
[0:38:58] and was aware of some potential problems
[0:39:02] and was very nervous to go in to this building,
[0:39:06] not invited by the building owner, and then tell the guy,
[0:39:10] you need all this work being done.
[0:39:13] What right did he have to be there for that
[0:39:14] when the building owner wasn't signing off on it?
[0:39:18] That was a bit of a concern for us, and rightly so.
[0:39:20] We shouldn't just be walking in the buildings around town
[0:39:23] and saying, you gotta fix that, and fix that, right?
[0:39:25] And so, the application process would be an application
[0:39:31] from the building owner, basically asking us to come in.
[0:39:34] that way we have the right to come in and do this inspection.
[0:39:37] Because that's one of them.
[0:39:38] Another one might be downtown.
[0:39:41] This happens more often than the other scenario I just described.
[0:39:45] But maybe downtown, you have a change of use.
[0:39:47] And there's a mechanical system that was put in place
[0:39:50] for an office, and now they're going to put in a restaurant.
[0:39:53] Is that mechanical system appropriate for a restaurant
[0:39:56] occupant load versus an office occupant load?
[0:39:59] You might need to have Jared come in or Vern come in
[0:40:01] and take a look at that and say, you know, yes or no,
[0:40:06] it's not or it isn't.
[0:40:08] And that's a bit complicated of an inspection.
[0:40:12] So this would give them the opportunity to go in there
[0:40:14] and do those kinds of inspections as well.
[0:40:18] Again, this is something we've been able to do for years,
[0:40:20] but we just haven't had very many requests
[0:40:23] for the actual inspection with this fee structure.
[0:40:28] It's always been kind of a weird,
[0:40:30] should we do it, should we not do it?
[0:40:34] And so the thought was formalize the process,
[0:40:37] put it down in place, come here to talk about it,
[0:40:39] go to the advisory board to talk about it.
[0:40:41] The advisory board is made up of the building community members.
[0:40:45] There's nine members of that board, and eight of them
[0:40:49] are actively working in the building trades.
[0:40:53] If they're support behind it, they can help us get the word out.
[0:40:56] And so we did that.
[0:40:57] We took it to the advisory board.
[0:40:59] They were very supportive of the concept,
[0:41:02] and basically wanted us to get after it right away.
[0:41:05] So that's what we're doing here, I guess.
[0:41:11] We think we can use these things.
[0:41:14] Everything's really in place to do it.
[0:41:17] That is unless we want to do something with the fee.
[0:41:21] And so I guess I would maybe just leave it at that, really.
[0:41:27] We created a formal application that's attached,
[0:41:29] not that that is super important,
[0:41:31] and they all kind of look the same to me really.
[0:41:34] Is it a new building or is it an insistent insulation?
[0:41:37] It's just a form that gets us to the point
[0:41:39] where we can get it into the system,
[0:41:42] track it properly, get the recorded notes back
[0:41:45] into the system, get the conversations happening,
[0:41:48] the results are getting back out to the people, request it.
[0:41:53] You know, I think it's a good way of getting this all done.
[0:41:56] It's a potentially a really good way of helping our public understand what risk they may have
[0:42:04] with sewer backups or whatever other problems they might have in their homes.
[0:42:08] And so that's really the bulk of it there.
[0:42:15] So to clarify tonight, this isn't an action item unless we want to change the fee structure.
[0:42:21] Right. So the fee structure is in place and I promise to talk a little bit about that.
[0:42:24] That's a $42 an hour fee with a minimum of a half hour charge.
[0:42:31] And so the minimum is going to be $21.
[0:42:33] The maximum will be whatever that ends up being if you're out there for eight hours looking
[0:42:38] and this is the installation that could be pricey but that fee structure is in place.
[0:42:45] Somebody could call today and ask for one of these.
[0:42:47] We just don't have a formalized process really to do it.
[0:42:50] So then that's just a process question that the building official can kind of create a process.
[0:42:56] So really this was more about let's get this out in the open, let's have hopefully people
[0:43:01] are watching, they'll see this and they'll call us to come and take a look at their basement
[0:43:05] backing up.
[0:43:07] So if we're okay with that moving forward then I think we're good, I don't think we necessarily
[0:43:12] need an action.
[0:43:14] There was some comment about the fee structure though.
[0:43:18] Maybe we don't want to charge $21 to the resident.
[0:43:21] Maybe we do.
[0:43:22] Maybe we want to fix it at $21.
[0:43:26] And even if it takes 45 minutes or an hour,
[0:43:29] the residential request is still a $21 request.
[0:43:31] And that's the kind of thing that I
[0:43:34] don't have the authority to do or Jared doesn't
[0:43:36] have the authority to do because the fee structure has
[0:43:40] been in place and adopted by the council.
[0:43:42] So if we want to do something different with the fees,
[0:43:44] then, yeah, we need some direction, some action
[0:43:47] by the council, if we're okay with the way all this right now,
[0:43:50] then we can move forward, but it would still be nice
[0:43:52] to have the council understand what we're doing
[0:43:56] and be supportive of what we're doing.
[0:44:00] Thanks, Mitch, Chris, talking to me.
[0:44:02] Mitch, a couple of questions pertaining to
[0:44:05] besides a wastewater issue,
[0:44:07] what, I'm having trouble figuring what a non-commercial
[0:44:12] request might be besides that.
[0:44:15] they wouldn't call you in for high VAC or anything like that, would they?
[0:44:19] That's my first question.
[0:44:22] What's high VAC?
[0:44:23] HJC, is that what we're talking about?
[0:44:25] Heating ventilation air conditioning, right?
[0:44:28] HVAC.
[0:44:29] You know, I could see maybe someone wanting us to come out and look at an NHPC system to
[0:44:38] make sure it was maybe appropriately sized for the home.
[0:44:42] I'm not sure that we would get very many of those.
[0:44:47] But that's a potential application, right?
[0:44:50] So somebody builds a very big home,
[0:44:52] and yet it's always really hot upstairs,
[0:44:56] because the heat goes upstairs.
[0:44:58] Do we need to do something different?
[0:44:59] We could go look at an existing HVC system
[0:45:02] and say, you know, with this volume of air,
[0:45:04] you really should have this size of system,
[0:45:06] and you have something smaller than that.
[0:45:09] Isn't that more the purview of the private contractor though?
[0:45:13] Right, there are some minimum code requirements that we could speak to you. If it's just a preference issue, then yeah.
[0:45:20] My second point is then what that information that's
[0:45:23] collated by the inspector on the site, would that go somehow into home plans attached to that address in the city files or
[0:45:31] what would be the end application of that?
[0:45:33] So in the case of like a backwater valve installation
[0:45:39] If the home was built in 46 and it didn't have one,
[0:45:44] we wouldn't necessarily go into the home and say,
[0:45:46] now you're out of compliance with code,
[0:45:49] you have to come in and apply for this permit to put one in.
[0:45:53] It's kind of a grandfather situation right now,
[0:45:55] so we wouldn't do that.
[0:45:57] But we could know that we did the inspection on that address,
[0:46:03] and then a future permit that does come in would show up
[0:46:07] Our tracking system is, yes, we did an existing installation inspection at this address, now
[0:46:13] you're asking for the plumbing permit and it'll go to the same address and we'd have the
[0:46:17] history there and it would all kind of come together at that point.
[0:46:21] Which would be more, I think, vital for us on the commercial side of things, particularly
[0:46:26] with a frontlight consultation kind of a visit like the HVAC restaurant question asked.
[0:46:32] Well, thank you.
[0:46:33] And I think the third point I'd just like to, as files says, I think that 42 bucks is
[0:46:38] a little high, especially, I think of maybe seniors living predominantly maybe in a little
[0:46:44] bit older homes that may have some of these issues, let's say a wastewater, 42 bucks is
[0:46:50] high, even though it's been on the books for a long time.
[0:46:53] I would be supportive of a lower one that's arbitrary, but 25 or something.
[0:46:58] So 42 for residents, but 42 not for commercial.
[0:47:02] 42 for non-commercial.
[0:47:04] Okay, very good.
[0:47:05] Thank you.
[0:47:06] I'm going to suggest in 25 range.
[0:47:07] Sure.
[0:47:09] Thank you, Mayor.
[0:47:10] Yeah, I really can't make the call on the $42,
[0:47:14] because I don't know what the soft,
[0:47:17] the fully burdened cost per hour of a community service
[0:47:21] and a community development employee would be.
[0:47:23] So I certainly want to make sure
[0:47:26] that we can cover our costs there.
[0:47:29] Keeping in mind that I do recognize that some elderly people
[0:47:32] or some lower income people may not be able to do that.
[0:47:35] I'm happy with test writing this idea for a period of time.
[0:47:41] I think it's very well thought out.
[0:47:43] And I think that you have done a very good job,
[0:47:45] particularly in the development of the application process.
[0:47:48] So in terms of my analysis,
[0:47:50] I think that it's good to go.
[0:47:52] So great job.
[0:47:54] Thanks Jim.
[0:47:55] Greg Lanning.
[0:47:56] Well, look at the fee thing.
[0:47:57] I guess maybe I looked at it a little differently and maybe I read it a little differently.
[0:48:00] To me, it was like, after what Mitch had said, that usually a half hour is going to be enough
[0:48:07] on a residential installation.
[0:48:09] So maybe the fee is actually closer to 21, but I can see putting them, you know, I am,
[0:48:16] but I might, like Jim, I mean, how much do we have tied up in that employee, plus I'm
[0:48:21] I'm sure we're not charging them for the drive out there
[0:48:23] and the drive back as well.
[0:48:25] The way that the fee structure is currently adopted,
[0:48:28] it does include travel.
[0:48:30] That does it, okay.
[0:48:32] So it's a $42 fee, an hour with a half hour minimum.
[0:48:37] So if someone were to come in and ask me for one of these,
[0:48:41] we typically pay for the inspections up front, right?
[0:48:46] So someone will fill out the application,
[0:48:48] It is set it down and here's the check.
[0:48:52] Well, at that point we haven't done the inspection yet,
[0:48:54] so we really don't know exactly how long it's going to take.
[0:48:58] So we would really make a judgment call.
[0:49:02] We'd probably then charged the $21 and then go do the inspection.
[0:49:06] If we came back and it was three hours later,
[0:49:09] we might send them a bill for the rest or something
[0:49:12] to that thing.
[0:49:14] For residents, I would assume the up front chart
[0:49:18] would be the 21 because we don't think it'll take much longer
[0:49:20] than the half hour anyway in getting where in town
[0:49:23] in 10 minutes.
[0:49:24] And then if you're just looking at the one piece of equipment,
[0:49:27] it's not unreasonable to think you could knock that out
[0:49:30] in 10 minutes as well.
[0:49:33] You know, I'm kind of torn on this
[0:49:34] because I don't want to see us do something different
[0:49:38] with residential than commercial because, you know,
[0:49:40] trying to do the fair thing.
[0:49:42] But at the same time, I'm thinking there's folks that will not call us to come out if there's going to be, you know, 42 or $21 fee associated, and I guess, is this a public safety issue potentially it could be when you get public health issues?
[0:49:57] Yeah, public health, that's what I mean, public health, which is public safety to me.
[0:50:02] And do we want to encourage our citizens to have these inspections to see if, so I guess I'm just torn.
[0:50:10] I don't want to.
[0:50:11] So to your point, I'm going to try to be another situation, we have a fee for what's called
[0:50:17] a small job and it's a $10 per month fee, never will that $10 fee cover our cost for performing
[0:50:23] that installation or performing that inspection.
[0:50:25] It just never does.
[0:50:27] So we lose money every time we do one of those $10 fees.
[0:50:33] But we do them for a reason.
[0:50:34] we do them to more important than the money
[0:50:38] is the increased compliance with the code.
[0:50:41] So for example, we talked just earlier in the spring,
[0:50:44] this year, about the backflow prevention,
[0:50:47] where you have a sprinkler system that's using
[0:50:49] potable water and the potential for some of that other nasty
[0:50:52] stuff to go backwards into the city's water lane.
[0:50:56] Those inspections are a small job inspection.
[0:50:59] It's more important for us to go out
[0:51:00] and make sure they're working and working properly
[0:51:03] installed properly than it is to collect the 40 bucks or whatever that it really
[0:51:08] does cost and so that's a small job. There are a lot of a lot of well hot
[0:51:13] water heaters a residential hot water heater that has potentially really
[0:51:17] dangerous side effects it was done wrong I think I'll blow your house up it's so
[0:51:25] easy to put one of those in without getting a permit and we know that and I'm
[0:51:30] I'm sure there are a lot that have been put in with our permits.
[0:51:34] So to help increase the compliance with the permits so we can get in there and make sure
[0:51:39] it's not venting carbon dioxide into the home or that it's not going to explode in a
[0:51:44] bunch of hole in your roof, we do that with a $10 fee.
[0:51:48] Just so that we can get in the home.
[0:51:50] And sometimes that part of it is more important than the money that goes.
[0:51:55] So if we take action tonight to make it a $10 fee for residential, you just need a motion
[0:52:00] regarding that. Yeah, we just can't increase it right without a hearing. I will tell I will tell the council I am very
[0:52:09] supportive of a
[0:52:11] $10 fee Jim. Thank you mayor. Well as I was looking through the resolution
[0:52:20] 1905
[0:52:21] It indicates that there is just a $5 small work permit for those things that are most generally going to occur in a residential application
[0:52:27] application, water heaters, bath fans, air ducts, water softeners, all the stuff that
[0:52:33] could pose a health and safety issue if they're installed wrong. You're
[0:52:36] scenario the improper venting. So I'm okay with that $10. I wouldn't support
[0:52:41] reducing the other residential stuff down to $10 because I would anticipate
[0:52:48] those things being a bit more complex, requiring a little bit more staff time.
[0:52:53] I would submit that most of the things you're going to do
[0:52:55] residentially would be these things attached on bullets under small work permit.
[0:53:00] Is that accurate?
[0:53:01] I mean in terms of what we usually go out on residential.
[0:53:04] So in the case where there's a home that's built and they're going to come ask us for
[0:53:10] a permit to do some things, a lot of them are those things on the bullet point list.
[0:53:15] But some of them are also remodels, you know, I'm going to add on a room or a garage or whatever.
[0:53:20] Okay.
[0:53:21] Okay.
[0:53:22] Those ones were going to charge the cost of the permit.
[0:53:23] but it could go down to 21 if it's only a half hour.
[0:53:26] There's a missing up the fee structure is a little bit.
[0:53:29] The 42 and the half 21 is for the existing installation inspection.
[0:53:34] They're not tied to, I'm gonna build this and I need you to come look at it for me.
[0:53:37] Different situation, okay, got it, yep, thank you.
[0:53:40] But I think where the mayor was going was that $10 fee might be appropriate for
[0:53:45] the residential existing installation inspection as well.
[0:53:49] That's where I'm going to go with that.
[0:53:50] Normally we would probably end up with a $21 fee for that one if we use the structure that's again
[0:53:56] I just look for compliance and to try to help some folks out to for public safety great landing. I would like move that we
[0:54:04] Act a ten dollar fee for
[0:54:07] Residential what was the last part of that existing installation existing installation inspections
[0:54:13] second that a motion on for by Greg Lanning seconded by Chris talking to
[0:54:18] for the $10 fee anything further on this motion Council. Leila roll call vote
[0:54:25] please. Yes. Greg Lanth yes. Don Hall yes. Suzanne Hawkins yes. Jim
[0:54:32] I'm gonna vote yes. I think I had a great I think I had a wonderful compelling
[0:54:38] are you but well let me finish four yeses and one bear barely yes I said yes by
[0:54:47] five to zero I can take out you know I'll change my mind very good thank you
[0:54:51] John okay next item on the agenda is public input and or items from city
[0:54:55] manager city council one thing I just want to throw out before we go on to
[0:55:01] public input is is maybe the council can be thinking about as far as the
[0:55:07] senior center advisory board advisory committee if we should have a staff assigned to that.
[0:55:15] Certainly we should have a council liaison but should we have staff assigned to that as
[0:55:23] well to help with minutes or are they going to be self-supporting.
[0:55:27] So anyway, just a thought about that.
[0:55:30] Suzanne, did you want to add?
[0:55:32] But we did discuss that and we actually, between our brainstorming came up with two possible places that could fit in the city structure.
[0:55:40] And so I think we'll wait and see how that plays out, but I know Greg and I did give them two ideas that we thought would be fitting to have staff involved, yes.
[0:55:48] And I apologize, I actually had a note here to ask that question while it was on up and on, but do we have anyone from the public that would like to address the council at this point?
[0:56:00] I heard a little peep from you, Shorty, next item, City Manager, anything from our City Manager?
[0:56:10] I mean, just as a reminder, last week Travis came here and talked about his plan to do the downtown facilities kind of a walk through thing.
[0:56:22] We're scheduled for next Monday for the Council to be the first group, I think, to do that.
[0:56:30] And we were talking about maybe starting early so that we could do it before 5 o'clock meeting, and I just guess-
[0:56:35] Go downtown and walk through the building that we're speaking of at 4 o'clock.
[0:56:39] Is that what you're thinking?
[0:56:40] Yeah, we might start here and call the meeting order and do those kinds of things.
[0:56:44] Would 4 o'clock be early enough?
[0:56:46] And I guess that's the conversation I wanted to have is 4 o'clock, okay, it's 3.30, okay, it's-
[0:56:52] Yeah, we'll just do it.
[0:56:54] Four o'clock, sounds good to everyone.
[0:56:56] We can call a meeting to order and boogie over there
[0:56:58] and get back by, hopefully by fine.
[0:57:00] So we'll post early meetings.
[0:57:03] Thank you.
[0:57:04] Anything else, Mitch?
[0:57:06] That was all I had.
[0:57:07] Thanks.
[0:57:08] Greg Lanning?
[0:57:09] I actually mind I'm going to ask Josh to come up and do mine
[0:57:11] to make sure I don't make any mistakes on it.
[0:57:14] Well, then that would be his.
[0:57:17] Well, let's make it his, then.
[0:57:19] Josh, I tried to delegate this to you, Greg.
[0:57:21] It doesn't work that we still get yearly, don't just wait.
[0:57:25] So on the 16th of this week, I just wanted to remind council, anybody who's here, anybody
[0:57:29] who's watching, that we have the next, the follow-up of the attack and the urban-related
[0:57:34] seat.
[0:57:35] And what this does is we got a little bit of a taste of it today, but bringing together
[0:57:38] some of the ideas that have come being formed from the feedback we received from citizens
[0:57:46] and stakeholders in the downtown area.
[0:57:48] And I will say it's actually pretty exciting.
[0:57:50] They are still pretty open and they are still really asking for any information and feedback
[0:57:56] they can get from anybody out there.
[0:57:59] But you can kind of start to see it come together.
[0:58:02] So I think on top of that, they are set up down in the Rogerson building and so people
[0:58:07] don't necessarily have to show up on the 16th at 6 o'clock at 6 p.m. at the ballroom.
[0:58:12] They can go down to the Rogerson building and they are set up there and you can actually
[0:58:15] see some of their, what other downtowns have done.
[0:58:19] do some kind of a space diagram on what you can fit on our streets type thing, which is
[0:58:24] pretty informative, and speak with some of the OTAC people. And then also on our website,
[0:58:30] as always there's a link at the top that says the main, it's the main avenue, it's the main
[0:58:37] avenue revitalization or main avenue investment, and that'll take you to the OTAC website and
[0:58:43] you can provide input there. But either way I guess we're kind of getting at is, we still
[0:58:47] need a lot of feedback, they still need a lot of input. It's pretty exciting right now.
[0:58:52] And then if anybody can make it at 6 p.m. on the 16th to the historic ballroom in downtown,
[0:58:58] we'll have a follow-up and kind of talk a little bit about what attack and different
[0:59:02] inter-legency have put together.
[0:59:04] So you're asking, as many council members in it, so are we going to, do we need to,
[0:59:11] you know, I was pitching this more out for the people who may be watching as well as anybody
[0:59:15] might be the audience. But you're just asking more the audience, the general, but not council.
[0:59:22] Yeah, I don't know, typically how we handle if we want to have a council member there
[0:59:26] or a couple and then just post it. Okay, so. Okay, very good. I don't think we need to post it unless we're, I mean, if five
[0:59:36] show up, as long as we're not discussing it or making decisions, remind us, Fritz.
[0:59:42] So if we know that we'll have a quorum of the council you're receiving information
[0:59:47] I don't know if you'll be asked to decide anything about that sometime in the future
[0:59:51] But the same thing we always do is we go ahead and notice it up
[0:59:55] And post it
[0:59:57] But we don't treat it like a meeting because you don't
[1:00:02] Call a quorum and all that stuff. You just happen to be there
[1:00:05] We're just giving the the public notice the city council or a quorum the city council will be here. Okay
[1:00:12] And honestly, public notice is perhaps a good thing
[1:00:16] because we want lots of public to come to this.
[1:00:19] Why don't we, does it hurt if only three show up?
[1:00:22] Okay, why don't we publicly notice that?
[1:00:24] Does that sound right in the council?
[1:00:26] And hopefully more show up.
[1:00:28] I know that a few of us showed up the other night
[1:00:30] for the bike route conversation.
[1:00:35] And we sat in the back and just listened
[1:00:37] to what the citizens were saying.
[1:00:39] So, great landing.
[1:00:41] Well, just by the way, Josh, much better job than I would have done, so I wasn't going to say that.
[1:00:48] But they also, they talked about a couple things that I might just bring up briefly.
[1:00:52] Obviously they're doing a parking survey at the same time, and they gave a little bit of a preliminary thing about that,
[1:01:00] including some possible things that might be able to do seconds and stuff like that.
[1:01:04] That was all very interesting.
[1:01:05] And also at the early part of the Urban & No Meeting,
[1:01:08] they're looking at refunding, I guess is the term,
[1:01:13] in a public nature, rather than refinancing
[1:01:16] their existing loans of like $5.8 million,
[1:01:19] and they can actually half their interest rate,
[1:01:22] which just gives them more money to use on these projects
[1:01:25] that they're discussing right now.
[1:01:27] That's awesome.
[1:01:28] So they're looking at refunding that at the same time,
[1:01:32] Because as always, if we play less entry phases in the city, we're always jumping on that.
[1:01:39] Refunding or refunding?
[1:01:40] Refunding, right.
[1:01:42] Which is different than, it's the same as refinancing, but public is called refunding.
[1:01:47] So, all right.
[1:01:48] That's all right.
[1:01:49] I've never heard of such a thing, good, very good.
[1:01:52] Anything else from the council?
[1:01:54] All right.
[1:01:55] Meaning is adjourned.
[1:01:56] Yeah, they can get late.
