Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2014-03-17, recording 1 (started 17:00)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2014-03-17/

[0:00:02] Quinlan and Booth and I'm nothing.
[0:00:06] You're very important, young man.
[0:00:10] Scout, you're a scout. Yes, thank you.
[0:00:14] I am K. Chisholm and I'm probably part of Eagle Patrol.
[0:00:22] Thank you. Last but certainly not least.
[0:00:26] I'm Blake Coleman and I'm just a scout.
[0:00:29] Very good. Not just a scout, you are a scout.
[0:00:32] Thank you young men for coming up and we did not miss any scouts that came in late did we
[0:00:37] Know that they would have missed that right now
[0:00:39] I
[0:00:41] Do want to confirm that we do have quorum the city council this evening we have all seven members here
[0:00:46] And I'd like to ask our city manager if we have any amendments to our agenda
[0:00:52] Mr. Mayor members of the council
[0:00:54] Earlier we sent out some corrected minutes that we would ask for you to substitute in your agenda packets
[0:01:00] and they should have been distributed,
[0:01:02] that would be the only correction to tonight's agenda.
[0:01:05] Thank you, Travis.
[0:01:06] So we don't need to make a motion to that.
[0:01:08] Just a note.
[0:01:10] Very good, thank you, Travis.
[0:01:12] I want, before we move into the general public input,
[0:01:14] one to state to our audiences here and folks
[0:01:17] that are listening at home.
[0:01:19] Recently, well, several of us have had some inquiries
[0:01:23] regarding one of our council members
[0:01:25] appeared at another council recently over in Filer,
[0:01:30] regarding an issue that they've been dealing with.
[0:01:33] They asked me, is this our stance?
[0:01:37] And so I called the mayor and filer,
[0:01:41] and I found out that it was Rebecca Milsoica that appeared,
[0:01:44] and she stated unequivocally that she was speaking
[0:01:48] on her own, and it wasn't regarding a philosophy
[0:01:52] or a direction that the city of Twin Falls
[0:01:55] was taking on their endeavor.
[0:01:57] And all seven of us are individuals,
[0:02:00] and we have that right to be able to do that.
[0:02:02] But several of us have received inquiries on that.
[0:02:05] So I just wanna make sure that I made that clearer
[0:02:07] to the public that one of us can't speak for all seven of us.
[0:02:11] The only time that we can really speak as a group
[0:02:14] is when we vote, and that vote is a quorum
[0:02:18] or a majority of the council.
[0:02:20] So I just wanna make sure I made that clear.
[0:02:22] Jim?
[0:02:23] Thank you, Mayor.
[0:02:24] I think you indicated this happened,
[0:02:26] but just I would like to include for the record,
[0:02:29] this is the issue of the dog shooting event over in Filer,
[0:02:34] just so there was any inquiries
[0:02:36] just exactly what this matter was about.
[0:02:39] Thank you.
[0:02:40] Very good, sir, thank you.
[0:02:41] At this point, we always open it up
[0:02:42] at the beginning of our council meeting
[0:02:44] for those that would like to come
[0:02:45] and make any general input to the council.
[0:02:49] Not according to what we have on our agenda
[0:02:53] or anything that we're going to be talking about tonight
[0:02:55] because there will be an opportunity for that later.
[0:02:57] But is there anyone in our audience that would like to come forward and address the council
[0:03:02] this evening?
[0:03:04] I see no one rushing up forward, so we are going to move it now to the next item, which
[0:03:09] is the consent calendar.
[0:03:10] Chris talking to.
[0:03:11] I would like to, prior to making the motion, advise everyone whether they know it or not
[0:03:17] everyone, everybody is Irish today.
[0:03:21] And God bless Ireland, Erin Galdurro.
[0:03:23] I move to approve the consent calendar as amended.
[0:03:28] Second.
[0:03:28] I have a motion on the floor by Chris Tawington,
[0:03:31] seconded by Sean Berger, to approve the consent calendar
[0:03:34] as amended.
[0:03:36] Anything further on that motion council?
[0:03:39] I see no lights.
[0:03:40] So Leila, could you roll call vote please?
[0:03:44] Susan Hawkins?
[0:03:45] Yes.
[0:03:46] Sean Berger?
[0:03:47] Yes.
[0:03:48] Jim Mundt?
[0:03:49] Yes.
[0:03:50] Greg Lanting?
[0:03:51] Yes.
[0:03:51] Don Hall?
[0:03:52] Yes.
[0:03:53] Chris Tawington?
[0:03:54] Yes.
[0:03:55] back in my second. Yes.
[0:03:57] Can you get everyone Jim?
[0:04:00] Okay.
[0:04:01] For some reason I just did a different order.
[0:04:03] Okay.
[0:04:04] Yeah.
[0:04:05] Turn me off.
[0:04:06] So motion passes seven to zero.
[0:04:08] We will be moving on to items for consideration.
[0:04:10] Those of you there here may be following along under two items for
[0:04:14] consideration.
[0:04:15] The first item is presentation of a service plaque to Gail Clankoff,
[0:04:19] a name known to our city council, of course.
[0:04:22] He served with distinction and was a mayor at one time as well.
[0:04:27] In recognition of his service on the Golf Advisory Commission, we have our parks superintendent, Dennis Boyer.
[0:04:34] Yes, thank you, Mayor and Council.
[0:04:35] Yes, it is a privilege tonight to honor Gail, kind of sad to that he's leaving off the Golf Advisory Commission.
[0:04:43] But I think Gail got on the commission about the same time when the golf course was kind of put under Parks and Recreation.
[0:04:48] Some of you, I think Chris, you remember, and some of you may remember, you know, the golf course was kind of satin on it, stood on its own for a while.
[0:04:55] Finally, back in 2006, it was kind of put on the Parks and Recreation, so I had really got the privilege to serve with Gail Klein-Clough on the Golf Advisor Commission.
[0:05:04] He was first appointed to the Golf Advisory back in October of 2006.
[0:05:09] He served a partial term, then he was eligible to serve two more three-year full terms, which he did.
[0:05:16] So February was just his last meeting on the Golf Advisory Commission.
[0:05:20] He was chairperson for the last two years, and as I mentioned, my staff report,
[0:05:25] his leadership will be really missed by our Golf Advisory Commission.
[0:05:28] We know he will still support the golf course and its endeavors,
[0:05:32] and I sure hope he's still golf with me on our golf tournament, right?
[0:05:35] We don't do very well, but we have a good time.
[0:05:38] But again, I like to hopefully the council will wish Gell the best
[0:05:44] and also thank him for his years of service on the Golf Advisory Commission.
[0:05:48] I do have a plaque, so I would like to have the mayor come down,
[0:05:50] and our new golf lays on Greg Lanting to give this back to Gail.
[0:05:56] First of all, everybody is joking to get there.
[0:06:18] So if I could, again, this is a certificate of appreciation to Gail.
[0:06:28] Gail has served with distinction not only on the Golf Advisory Committee,
[0:06:31] but many years on city council and in many other aspects of our city government and it's
[0:06:38] just an honor for me to be able to present you on grade this plaque for your service scale.
[0:06:44] So thank you very much.
[0:06:54] The council, it's been a privilege for me to work with the commission on the golf advisory
[0:07:25] Commission that I've really enjoyed that for a while.
[0:07:29] It's been kind of fun.
[0:07:31] As you are probably aware, at least most of you
[0:07:34] are, the major responsibility of the Commission today
[0:07:39] is to operate and sponsor a golf tournament
[0:07:44] to raise funds to do capital improvements to the golf course.
[0:07:48] Over the past five years, we've raised somewhere between $8,000
[0:07:51] and $10,000 per year to go into improvements in the golf course.
[0:07:56] And if those of you that play out there obviously are aware of how nice that has been, there's been tea boxes put in, there's been trees planted, there's been concrete poured, there's been a number of things that have made to play at the golf course a lot better.
[0:08:12] And I am privileged to be part of that because I think that will continue and there's a lot of passion in the commission remaining to do that golf tournament.
[0:08:22] I think you should be aware that that's our real asset to the city. Hey, in lieu of salary,
[0:08:28] this is pretty nice.
[0:08:30] Yeah, well, if you would stay, we have plenty of lights on here that we'd like to say a few
[0:08:34] words to you. I'm going to start off with Quigland.
[0:08:36] All right, yeah. Well, thank you very much for your service. I can remember back when I
[0:08:41] was on the Golf Advisory Board, well, before I was on the council and you were the mayor
[0:08:46] at the time and spearheading the movement to get the new sprinkler system that time put
[0:08:50] in and appreciate all the efforts you've had and I think we've missed another one.
[0:08:55] He's been a long time member of the Library Foundation Board as well so it certainly serves
[0:09:00] your community well and a lot of different hats and we appreciate it.
[0:09:03] Thanks, Gil.
[0:09:04] Thank you, Greg.
[0:09:05] Jim Moon.
[0:09:06] Thank you, Mayor.
[0:09:08] I have absolutely nothing to say about the golf thing but there's a lot of police officers
[0:09:15] out here that may not know who you are.
[0:09:18] Now I remember in the late 1990s, Chief Devore and myself presented a proposal to the city
[0:09:26] and you were the mayor and we were proposing in the middle of a budget year the hiring of
[0:09:31] six police officers.
[0:09:32] Do you remember this?
[0:09:33] I imagine you do.
[0:09:34] And I think our argument was sound and you led that council in the decision to go ahead
[0:09:42] and allow us to hire six police officers and all the equipment and all the stuff necessary.
[0:09:49] And it was controversial, but you showed real true leadership then.
[0:09:53] And I just wanted the troops out here in the audience to recognize that you were the mayor
[0:09:57] at that time when he approved these positions for us in the middle of the budget, which is
[0:10:01] unprecedented.
[0:10:02] So, I never had a chance to publicly thank you for that, but there you have it.
[0:10:06] Thank you, Mayor.
[0:10:07] Jim.
[0:10:08] Thank you, Jim.
[0:10:09] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:10:10] Wow, so as a new City Council person learning what to do, I was assigned to come work with
[0:10:17] the Golf Commission, which if you don't know, I'm not a golfer.
[0:10:21] And Gil was so gracious in not only teaching me about golf and what was going on at the
[0:10:26] golf course, but as a new Council member kind of mentoring me on how to go and what to do.
[0:10:33] And I just want to say thank you so much.
[0:10:35] You've invested in me and I hope it's making me a better servant for our community.
[0:10:40] And I really appreciate all you've done not only for the city but for me personally.
[0:10:44] So thank you very much.
[0:10:46] Thank you.
[0:10:47] Well, Gary, I think it's been said, but thank you.
[0:10:50] And if we could all give him a hand, those are kind of fun to do.
[0:11:05] Next item on the agenda is swearing in ceremony for, I'm sorry.
[0:11:09] We would like to move to item number three.
[0:11:12] Item number two, we're still waiting for some guests to appear.
[0:11:15] that we'd like to move to item number three
[0:11:17] and possibly item number four
[0:11:20] prior to the swearing-in this evening.
[0:11:21] So will you give me the high sign when I go?
[0:11:23] A chief bike will.
[0:11:24] So I'll watch for you Brian, thank you.
[0:11:27] So we thank you very much Travis.
[0:11:29] We're gonna go ahead and move to item number three then.
[0:11:33] Consideration of a request to rename Canyon Crest Drive
[0:11:36] as plotted in Grandview Estate Subdivision
[0:11:40] to Canyon Crest Drive West.
[0:11:42] We have Jackie Fields, our city engineer
[0:11:44] And if you're trying to stall for time, I think your report said that you're going to take like 30 seconds or something on this one, so I'll start you down.
[0:11:55] So, every once in a while when we're plating, we, every time when we go through a plating process, we review all the plans, all of the details, every once in a while we miss them.
[0:12:09] So, in this particular case, we allowed a plot to be recorded with the road name of Canyoncrest drive.
[0:12:18] The problem with that is that this is Grand V.S. states right here. This road right over here is Canyoncrest West.
[0:12:30] So, we can't have that. So, the request tonight is that, you know, West is supposed to be West of everything that's not West, right?
[0:12:40] right? So we are now requesting that we change Canyon Crest Drive to Canyon Crest
[0:12:47] Drive West in the Grand United States final plan. In order to do that code
[0:12:53] requires that we bring the item to council for approval and then it's
[0:12:57] recorded with the city clerk and that is absolutely as long as I can possibly.
[0:13:03] You did well so I have a question so basically in the nutshell what you're
[0:13:07] saying is all those other roads on that side of the street heading to the west are west.
[0:13:12] This one just got missed.
[0:13:14] Well, and the piece of Canyon Crest West where people live that you can see right here, they're
[0:13:22] on west.
[0:13:23] Right.
[0:13:24] So the people that are west of them need to also be on west.
[0:13:27] Makes perfect sense.
[0:13:30] Thank you.
[0:13:31] You know, usually we catch that when it never comes up publicly, but you know, we were a little
[0:13:36] busy when this was planning this is when we have many, many subdivisions on and
[0:13:40] we missed it. Well I think when we see that we've made a mistake or we need to do a
[0:13:46] correction we need to do that so thank you for bringing that. Sean Berger. I'm
[0:13:50] ready for a motion if you're ready for a motion. I am ready sir. I would move to
[0:13:54] approve the request to rename Canyon Crest Drive as plotted in Grandview estate
[0:13:58] subdivision to Canyon Crest Drive West. I'll tell you the motion I'm for by Sean Berger
[0:14:04] seconded by Greg Lanting any discussion on this item council I see none we have
[0:14:12] the roll call vote yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes motion passes
[0:14:25] seven to zero thank you very much thank you it's extraordinary that we
[0:14:29] We actually get a change in the recipe for someone who lives there.
[0:14:32] So, this is Sylvanas.
[0:14:34] Absolutely.
[0:14:35] Thank you.
[0:14:36] Thank you.
[0:14:37] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:14:38] I would just like to say it's really nice to see Parkway going towards the canyon being
[0:14:44] finished and widened out.
[0:14:45] That's really a happy thing.
[0:14:47] Thank you.
[0:14:49] Okay.
[0:14:50] It looks like we are now ready for item number two, which is the swearing-in ceremony for
[0:14:55] the Twin Falls Police Department's newest police officer.
[0:14:58] William Janssen is requested that the mayor
[0:15:02] administered the oath of office.
[0:15:03] What I've asked our chief to do, just prior to doing this,
[0:15:07] if he wouldn't mind just spending a minute
[0:15:09] and maybe updating us on the half means of today
[0:15:12] because it was a big day,
[0:15:14] especially when it comes to public services,
[0:15:16] public safety, streets, trees, all those kinds of things.
[0:15:20] We were full service today, all across the board.
[0:15:24] And as you mentioned, it was a blistery day.
[0:15:26] And it really was.
[0:15:28] The summary like this really probably won't do justice to the work that our men and women
[0:15:32] did today to make sure that the roads were safe and clear.
[0:15:37] But you know today we experienced really sustained winds between 35 and 45 miles an hour and the
[0:15:43] wind always blows here but not like it was blowing today.
[0:15:46] With gusts up to 60 miles an hour, we had a number of calls, actually 13 calls for down
[0:15:51] trees in the area.
[0:15:52] The majority of those handled by our street department.
[0:15:56] Hanson Bridge had a number of, I actually had two accidents out there, two semi-trucks that
[0:16:01] were overturned because of the wind, and on the prime bridge almost simultaneously on
[0:16:05] both north and southbound, we had semi-trucks turn over on the bridge.
[0:16:10] So for a period of time, the only way out of Twin Falls was either to continue east to
[0:16:16] burly or to head to fuel and cross over that way.
[0:16:19] So really a busy day and I really want to just thank the men and women of the street department,
[0:16:24] the fire department, the police department.
[0:16:25] The street department was a huge help.
[0:16:27] We had the opportunity to go out today,
[0:16:29] out to the bridge and get sandblasted.
[0:16:32] Literally.
[0:16:33] It was amazing to see the work that would take
[0:16:36] to get that traffic diverted.
[0:16:37] And everyone did a tremendous job.
[0:16:39] And of course, unfortunately, Councilman talked,
[0:16:42] we had to stop the St. Patrick's Day parade today
[0:16:45] because it went so.
[0:16:47] But a really busy day.
[0:16:48] So.
[0:16:49] The wrath of God will hit us again.
[0:16:51] Yeah.
[0:16:52] Probably will.
[0:16:54] Thank you, Chief, I appreciate that.
[0:16:56] You know, tonight we have the honor, as you mentioned,
[0:16:58] is swearing in one of our newest members, William Janssen.
[0:17:01] I'd ask Bill if you'd step forward.
[0:17:02] Now, Bill, I kind of hate to put you on the hot seat
[0:17:05] for a little while, but you know, as, as,
[0:17:08] because I told him I was going to address the council
[0:17:10] for a little bit and then also get personal
[0:17:12] between Officer Janssen and myself,
[0:17:15] but as your Chief, over the last three years,
[0:17:18] I have sworn in 19 new police officers.
[0:17:20] And as I was preparing for the ceremony,
[0:17:22] I really couldn't help but to reflect back on our process and the length that we go to make
[0:17:27] sure that we have the right individuals and how important it is.
[0:17:31] And I also wondered that maybe due to the structure of the ceremony, whether I had conveyed to you
[0:17:36] and to our community the real challenges facing the men and women in law enforcement and why
[0:17:41] it's so important that we do hire the right individuals.
[0:17:45] With 20 years of police service behind me, and I hate to admit this, I find myself taking
[0:17:50] for granted the skill set associated with this profession, the discipline that's required
[0:17:55] to handle difficult and dynamic situations, the courage it takes to face adversity, to
[0:18:02] go to the fight, to stand in the gap, the sympathy and compassion that gets extended to families
[0:18:10] facing some of their greatest fears, the clarity of thought associated with the life and death
[0:18:14] decision, and I know those moments are few and far in between, but this same thought process
[0:18:20] is carried out daily in the application of force, judgment, and discernment, all of which we
[0:18:27] know has the potential to create significant liability for our city and for our community.
[0:18:32] And sadly, I admit that there are times when I just assume that our men and women will do
[0:18:37] the right thing, because for the most part, they do the right thing day in and day out.
[0:18:44] And Bill, the expectation for you will be no different.
[0:18:48] We believe that you have the background, the temperament, the education, and the life experience
[0:18:53] to serve our community in this role.
[0:18:55] So Council, let me introduce you to your newest officer.
[0:18:58] William Jansen was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department December 2, 2013 as a full-time
[0:19:03] police officer.
[0:19:05] He was born and raised in Jerome Idaho and graduated from Jerome High School in 2002.
[0:19:10] He went on to further his education at the College of the Idaho, where he earned two associates
[0:19:14] of applied science degrees in drafting, technology, and cabinetry and woodworking.
[0:19:19] William is a sergeant in the Idaho Army National Guard with over 11 years of service, including
[0:19:24] two combat deployments in Iraq.
[0:19:26] He's completed the Warriors Leader Course, Electronic Warfare Specialist Certification,
[0:19:30] and was recognized as the Distinguished Honor Graduate in the Support System Specialist
[0:19:35] Course.
[0:19:36] He's married to his lovely bride, Miranda Brown.
[0:19:39] William completed and the Post Academy actually successfully completed it last Friday, March
[0:19:45] 14th, where he graduated, and we're glad to have him with us.
[0:19:49] So Bill tonight, the ceremony really consists of two parts, the pinning of the police badge
[0:19:54] and then Alaska and Mayor Hall to administer the year-of-the-office.
[0:19:58] The oath that you are about to take tonight represents the heart of everything that we
[0:20:01] do in law enforcement.
[0:20:03] These are more than words repeated and the paper signed.
[0:20:06] The badge that you'll receive tonight represents that commitment.
[0:20:09] It's the symbol of your office and the trust the community has placed in you in the performance
[0:20:13] of your job.
[0:20:14] By raising your hand and affirming your commitment to provide public safety to our community, you'll
[0:20:19] be empowered to perform the functions of your job.
[0:20:22] So my charge to you is to be always mindful of the community's trust and ever diligent
[0:20:27] in your duties.
[0:20:28] Mayor Hall, I'd like to ask you to come down and why I present.
[0:20:32] Please raise your right hand, repeat your hand.
[0:20:50] I state your name.
[0:20:51] I believe, Chancellor, do solemnly swear,
[0:20:54] do solemnly swear that I will support the Constitution,
[0:20:57] that I will support the Constitution of the United States
[0:21:00] of America, of the United States of America,
[0:21:02] and the Constitution, and the laws of the state of Idaho,
[0:21:06] and the laws of the state, and the laws of ordinances,
[0:21:10] the laws of ordinances of the city of Twin Falls,
[0:21:13] of the city of Twin Falls, and the rules and regulations,
[0:21:16] and regulations of the Twin Falls Police Department,
[0:21:21] so the Twin Falls Police Department.
[0:21:23] And that I will, well and faithfully,
[0:21:28] discharge the duties of the office of police officers,
[0:21:31] discharge the duties of the office of police officers.
[0:21:34] Twin Falls Police Department,
[0:21:36] and the Falls Police Department,
[0:21:37] to which I have been appointed,
[0:21:39] to which I have been appointed,
[0:21:40] according to law, according to law,
[0:21:43] and to be the best of my ability
[0:21:45] and to be the best of my ability.
[0:21:47] If you're not going to assign him to clear those bridges already,
[0:22:18] I hope they're clear.
[0:22:22] If I could say just a couple things. First of all,
[0:22:38] it's an absolute honor to be the mayor and minister this old to a new officer.
[0:22:43] And if you could have seen your wife's face and the pride and the honor that
[0:22:49] she's feeling for your new position, don't let her down.
[0:22:54] Don't let us down, you're going to do a great job,
[0:22:57] and I appreciate you standing,
[0:23:00] taking a step forward and serving our community.
[0:23:02] I really appreciate that.
[0:23:04] Rebecca.
[0:23:05] Thank you, Mayor.
[0:23:06] I just want to say thank you for your service
[0:23:07] to our country as well.
[0:23:09] There is a volunteer organization,
[0:23:11] the ESDR, employer support of the Garden Reserve,
[0:23:14] and I just want to say thank you to City staff
[0:23:17] for really leading the way.
[0:23:18] This is, this volunteer organization's
[0:23:20] encourages employers to hire our guard members,
[0:23:24] and hire the people who are serving our country.
[0:23:26] And it just, it makes me very proud that the city
[0:23:29] is really leading the way in setting an example
[0:23:32] for other businesses, other organizations in our community
[0:23:36] to hire our guardsmen.
[0:23:38] So thank you for your service.
[0:23:40] Here here, thank you.
[0:23:41] We're back in for sharing that.
[0:23:43] Well, what we generally do is go to the next agenda item,
[0:23:46] but we're going to give it just a moment
[0:23:47] because generally half the audience
[0:23:50] clears out after these.
[0:23:51] So we're just going to give it a minute.
[0:24:07] Quiet, too.
[0:24:09] Okay, I think I'm going to go ahead and move on to the next agenda item, what a great night.
[0:24:15] Consideration of a request to hear concerns regarding the list of certified backflow device testers being developed by the city's water department staff.
[0:24:26] And we have Travis Rothweiler, and it looks like followed by Dave Wright from Kimberly Nursery possibly.
[0:24:31] So our city manager, Travis Rothweiler.
[0:24:33] Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, just to kind of give you a quick reminder and also
[0:24:39] for the people listening on how we got to this point to kind of set the stage for the
[0:24:44] comments and concerns that will probably be expressed by Mr. Wright in a few minutes.
[0:24:51] As you will recall, at our February 24th meeting, we had a presentation by Rob Bowling, our
[0:24:57] water superintendent who is ill tonight and not able to be with us.
[0:25:02] John Caten as well as representatives from DEQ, talking about the importance of the back
[0:25:06] flow device testing process, not only for commercial properties but also for those residential properties.
[0:25:12] And during that conversation we shared with you that we've always maintained compliance and
[0:25:16] we always did a really good job on that commercial side.
[0:25:20] The residential side, we had a bit of a different approach in DEQ, shared with us that in order
[0:25:25] to be fully in compliance with IDAPA policies, we also had to have a policy that regulated
[0:25:31] and had an enforcement mechanism associated
[0:25:34] with the residential backflow device processes as well.
[0:25:37] During that meeting we shared with you the possible impacts
[0:25:41] of not modifying our process which involved not having access
[0:25:46] to SRF loans, should we need them at some point in time,
[0:25:50] possibly in some extreme examples
[0:25:52] where the water superintendent could lose his licensure,
[0:25:55] having licensure over our system is critically important
[0:25:59] And then also, in a very extreme possibility,
[0:26:01] would be the condemnation of our entire water system,
[0:26:05] which would make it difficult for lawns and growth
[0:26:08] and expansion.
[0:26:09] So when we took a look at moving forward,
[0:26:11] we looked and saw those opportunities,
[0:26:15] and we really wanted to make sure
[0:26:16] that we were falling into compliance.
[0:26:18] And so at that point in time, we shared,
[0:26:19] we outlined a strategy that really put education
[0:26:23] at the first and foremost part of our overall effort,
[0:26:27] where a water department is going to go forward
[0:26:29] in a series of public open house type sessions
[0:26:33] in sharing and communicating the importance
[0:26:36] that we're going to be doing,
[0:26:37] water bill inserts and in sharing information
[0:26:40] about why we have to do this and then also.
[0:26:43] And then which really gets at the heart
[0:26:45] of the conversation this evening,
[0:26:47] providing a list of individuals that we're willing to
[0:26:51] or offer this service at a level of $35 or less.
[0:26:55] And as you'll recall, that recommendation came from City staff as we looked at this opportunity
[0:27:01] and we shared that recommendation based upon how we currently operate with tow truck dividers
[0:27:07] in our community.
[0:27:08] We say that we don't put a fee for service or a maximum fee for service, but we say that
[0:27:13] if you want to be on our list, you commit to be able to offer it at a certain price.
[0:27:19] We recognize the importance of capitalism, we recognize the importance of the free market
[0:27:24] approach, but we also said that we want to make sure that our citizens have an understanding
[0:27:30] of where they're able to get this service for a reasonable price.
[0:27:34] And we were in that process of defining the term reasonableness.
[0:27:39] Mr. Wright approached City staff and he also approached me and he really did outlay I think
[0:27:45] some pretty honest concerns about that approach and how putting a value in a price tag might
[0:27:53] not be something that the City Council should be doing in his opinion. So, as you know last
[0:27:59] week I shared that he had this concern to see if you would be willing to put this on
[0:28:03] the Council agenda for review and public comment and Mr. Wright is here and I believe that he
[0:28:10] would like to say a few words to express his thoughts and opinions. From there at the conclusion
[0:28:15] we're looking for whether you want to think about this for a period of time or to come
[0:28:22] amount and provide a recommendation to city staff.
[0:28:26] We know that we have not created those lists yet.
[0:28:28] We have not published those lists, and so they're still should the council choose an opportunity
[0:28:33] to reconsider the action that was taken on the evening of February 24th at the recommendation
[0:28:40] of city staff.
[0:28:41] With that, I'm happy to stand for any questions.
[0:28:42] If not, I'll turn it over the rest of my time to Mr. Wright.
[0:28:47] Thank you, Travis.
[0:28:48] I see no lines, but I wouldn't be surprised that we're going to ask you some questions.
[0:28:51] So, Mr. Wright, welcome.
[0:28:53] I can't believe everybody didn't want to stick around for this, but it is an important
[0:29:02] issue.
[0:29:03] Travis brings up and he mentioned quite a few of my points that I would like to mention,
[0:29:08] so I thank you for your time.
[0:29:10] But my name is Dave Wright.
[0:29:12] I'm president of Kimberly Nurseries Incorporated, we're the oldest landscape company in Idaho
[0:29:17] and in our 107th year in business, right here in Twin Falls.
[0:29:21] But I'm here today to provide an understanding on my input for about this decision that Council
[0:29:27] made concerning this list of certified backflow testers and to the general public that owned
[0:29:34] these devices from which I understand has been mandated to be tested annually by the DEQs.
[0:29:43] We were told in a phone call from the City Water Department that to be included on this
[0:29:47] list, fourth going that we could charge no more than $35 per customer.
[0:29:55] And although I understand the desire and intent of the council to look at after the best interests
[0:30:01] of the citizens of Twin Falls regarding this mandate, I'm here to raise awareness of this
[0:30:06] action, whether purposeful or not, artificially fixes the price for this service.
[0:30:12] And if I could, I just want to share with you a few of the costs associated with having
[0:30:16] legitimate backflow testing service. First of all, the test itself takes about an hour,
[0:30:22] almost an hour to complete. A backflow testing kit costs an average of $850. The test kit must
[0:30:30] be sent every year to Tetonia to be recertified at a cost of $48 plus the shipping. A state
[0:30:37] license for the tester has to be gathered and that costs $35 per person per year. A certified
[0:30:44] My tester also has to go through a recertification class every two years, which costs $185, and
[0:30:53] often has to include travel to Boise, Pocatella, or Idaho Falls.
[0:30:58] And it takes an entire day for the tester to be away from work.
[0:31:05] Not to mention the day-to-day costs of vehicles, taxes, and insurance, and overhead to bring
[0:31:10] a license certified backflow tester to your doorstep.
[0:31:15] If you call a legitimate licensed plumber or electrician to your house, it's going to cost
[0:31:20] you upwards of $85 to $100 or even more per hour for their services.
[0:31:24] And although nobody likes to pay that kind of money for the services, those are just
[0:31:29] simply the economics of having a legitimate business enterprise this day and age.
[0:31:35] And unfortunately, many of these backflow testers that are doing this charge for $35 now can
[0:31:42] hardly be called legitimate professional businesses.
[0:31:46] So my suggestion is this, if the Council wants to produce a list of these testers, they neither
[0:31:51] include everyone that is certified and forget about trying to list the charges that they
[0:31:55] charge for it, because those can become outdated anyway, as someone sees they need to raise
[0:32:00] their prices.
[0:32:01] Or else forget doing the list altogether.
[0:32:04] But scrutinizing list artificially sets the price, and that oversteps the bounds of free
[0:32:10] enterprise. And I don't believe that that the municipality or any government
[0:32:15] entity should be setting prices because the free enterprise system governs itself
[0:32:22] and takes care of that and its own. So I would strongly ask that the council
[0:32:27] reconsider their stance on setting this price on these issues. And I thank you for
[0:32:32] your time. Dave you might have some questions. So if you if you want to have
[0:32:37] a seat. Okay. Certainly do that. Great landing. I have a couple of questions first. The to
[0:32:46] be on the list, they have to be certified, correct? Travis? Dave, I would probably sit
[0:32:50] up here because that way you don't have to run back and forth. I'm assuming we'll have
[0:32:54] some questions for you, sir. I'm sorry Travis, go ahead. Yes. So they have to be certified?
[0:32:58] Yes. Okay. And I know we're in the infancy of this, but have we had people who have been
[0:33:06] willing to state they would do it for 35 and ready to be on the list at this
[0:33:11] point or we still work too early for that to know. Did I say that so it made sense?
[0:33:20] Give me sense to me. We are bringing the entire team to answer your questions tonight.
[0:33:32] I've never done this before so. Wally, if you could introduce yourself, tell us
[0:33:40] your job. My name is Wally Kindred. I work for City, Twin Falls, Water Department,
[0:33:45] around the backflow program among other things.
[0:33:50] So what I did is I compiled a list of the licensed backflow testers
[0:33:57] and took the local ones just to get an average price.
[0:34:02] I contacted BET, which is in Titonia.
[0:34:08] They're a backflow service testing business.
[0:34:13] According to her, the average price nationwide for a residential backflow test was about
[0:34:22] $45.
[0:34:24] So taking the local testers, which I thought was more reasonable than trying to call somebody
[0:34:32] from say Boise or whatever, the 11 that I picked, the highest being $95, the lowest
[0:34:41] being $25, just miraculously averaged $45.
[0:34:47] And that's the list that I think Travis presented when we met last on this issue.
[0:34:54] So then I contacted the people on the list and we sent out the letters.
[0:34:58] When I sent the letters out, the test is due every year on the back of that
[0:35:05] test letter as a list of licensed backflow testers.
[0:35:11] And a lot of them call that they want to be on that list,
[0:35:14] which is basically free advertising.
[0:35:17] That means they don't have to look to the phone book
[0:35:20] because to my knowledge that there is no
[0:35:23] in the yellow pages, backflow tester section.
[0:35:27] It's under sprinklers, guys, landscape outfits,
[0:35:32] um, numerous.
[0:35:35] So probably half that I contacted declined.
[0:35:41] to do that because of what Dave Wright just said.
[0:35:45] You know, you've got your overhead, you've got workman's comp,
[0:35:50] you've got this, you've got that.
[0:35:53] But so I have probably about half the degree to test
[0:35:58] this residential for 35 or less.
[0:36:03] That's to be analyst.
[0:36:06] That doesn't mean that they can charge whatever they want to.
[0:36:10] that just means they agree to be on the list at that price.
[0:36:16] That price or less?
[0:36:18] Or less?
[0:36:18] Yes.
[0:36:19] Thank you.
[0:36:20] All right.
[0:36:21] That answers my question.
[0:36:24] Council, do we have any other questions?
[0:36:27] Jim not?
[0:36:27] I'm pretty sure.
[0:36:29] It was round about answer.
[0:36:31] Thank you.
[0:36:35] I'm kind of starting to lean towards the idea
[0:36:39] that Mr. Wright's analysis of government intermedaling
[0:36:45] in the free enterprise system is generally a bad thing.
[0:36:50] My question is, can we list backflow certified backflow
[0:36:57] people and stay out of the pricing matter?
[0:37:00] Certainly.
[0:37:01] OK.
[0:37:01] Then the second question is, if some people opt to do we,
[0:37:05] what kind of staff time would be involved in?
[0:37:10] Ensuring that the people who are on the list wanted to be on the list or their new business
[0:37:19] is coming in that didn't have an opportunity to get on the list, then we're kind of in this,
[0:37:24] would we be in a business of having to go out and capture or advertise to backflow people
[0:37:30] saying here's your chance to get on our list now.
[0:37:33] I'm just wondering if we want maybe, I see why we're doing it in that it does provide
[0:37:39] an opportunity for people to see names where they wouldn't know where to go in the phone
[0:37:42] book.
[0:37:44] But what happens if we just say you have to get a certified backflow person to do this
[0:37:49] and we walk away from it?
[0:37:51] There is absolutely no harm in doing that.
[0:37:54] Okay.
[0:37:55] I'm just wondering if it might be.
[0:37:56] So in some of the things that we've talked about internally, the other alternative would
[0:38:00] be if people are looking for options and opportunity, I believe the state is the one that provides
[0:38:08] an entire list. We can publish that entire list or link on our city's website and individuals
[0:38:16] could go and go there. Because what I think is happening here is in our effort to provide
[0:38:24] good public service and an opportunity for the community to find these people, we may
[0:38:30] be getting the exact opposite result in that we're inflaming our commercial businesses.
[0:38:36] Yeah, so there certainly could be some unintended consequences.
[0:38:39] And like I shared with Dave, I thought that we had a very good conversation on the phone.
[0:38:45] It was never the council's intent to get into a place of price setting, but
[0:38:51] really getting into a place that we recognize that we have what we would classify
[0:38:57] possibly as an unfunded mandate.
[0:38:59] A mandate that we have to now assess an additional fee moving forward.
[0:39:04] And that we wanted to make sure in having to move forward with that that our citizens had at least some level of relief.
[0:39:11] And there could be some unintended consequences as you described.
[0:39:19] Thank you, sir.
[0:39:20] I look at it this way.
[0:39:21] When we began this conversation, I started thinking about, okay,
[0:39:26] there's another unfunded mandate or you can say it's a tax.
[0:39:31] because there's a service that needs to be provided,
[0:39:34] and the government is saying you have to do this.
[0:39:37] So it's almost a tax to me.
[0:39:40] And we're very sensitive to raising taxes,
[0:39:45] as you can see us go through our budgeting process every year.
[0:39:49] And I always try to think of that single person
[0:39:57] on a fixed income, and then we're
[0:40:00] going to throw more taxes at them.
[0:40:02] And so I think our intent, as you said, Travis,
[0:40:05] was to try to provide some relief.
[0:40:08] Here's a new issue that you have to deal with in our city.
[0:40:12] You have to get your sprinkler system tested.
[0:40:17] And here's some ideas of maybe doing that as most effectively
[0:40:23] and efficiently and cost-effective as possible.
[0:40:27] But I certainly appreciate it.
[0:40:28] I'm really glad that, Dave, Mr. Wright,
[0:40:30] came and gave us this perspective because it is absolutely true.
[0:40:34] So now we're meddling on the other side too.
[0:40:36] So I'll be honest with you, I'm a little torn.
[0:40:39] Rebecca Milsoyka.
[0:40:40] Thank you, Mayor.
[0:40:41] Thank you, Mr. Wright, for your comments.
[0:40:43] I will certainly consider those and just to provide you with kind of a perspective, I think,
[0:40:47] from the Council in taking this action.
[0:40:49] We were really looking for compliance and, of course, if the service is affordable or more
[0:40:55] reasonable, I believe that more people will be compliant in testing their back flow devices
[0:41:00] And so we certainly didn't mean to meddle in the free market or certainly take control of that.
[0:41:08] I feel like the list itself is important just for convenience for people to, well basically
[0:41:16] they're not going to do it if it's not available and convenient.
[0:41:20] They're also not going to do it if it's not affordable.
[0:41:22] And I think our concern with setting an average price or a maximum price was that the market
[0:41:31] can also inflate those prices.
[0:41:34] Because it's a service that citizens have to get by code and we're enforcing this, we
[0:41:43] didn't really want the prices to be so inflated that people couldn't afford it or that they
[0:41:48] wouldn't have the testing done.
[0:41:50] But you know with that said that was just our perspective or it was my perspective, I certainly
[0:41:56] don't want to speak for the council.
[0:41:58] I think the list is important, I think you bring up some good points but I'm so comfortable
[0:42:06] with the idea of setting a price that is affordable and is attainable because really what we want
[0:42:12] is to have safe drinking water, we want people to follow this part of the code for the betterment
[0:42:20] of the community, but we'll take your comments
[0:42:25] into consideration, thank you.
[0:42:26] Thank you, Rebecca.
[0:42:27] Chris Dockington.
[0:42:28] Well, I don't personally have any problem
[0:42:30] with moving that 35 suggested limit off.
[0:42:34] I was my question related as how did we get to that figure?
[0:42:38] And I think we all might be a little hazy on that.
[0:42:42] However, I would only support that if we put language
[0:42:45] in the prices may vary.
[0:42:47] Mr. Wright, the other side of your comment
[0:42:49] about meddling in private enterprise as appropriate.
[0:42:53] We're also providing private business free advertising.
[0:42:56] And I think it's a good trade off to make sure people
[0:42:59] see this list and don't say we're approving these companies.
[0:43:04] No, they have met certification then or list,
[0:43:07] but by prices very won't encourage people
[0:43:10] to sharpen their pencil.
[0:43:12] That's the only way I could support it,
[0:43:14] but it makes sense to take that 35 cap on.
[0:43:17] Thank you, Chris, Greg Lining.
[0:43:19] Well, when we were deciding to do this, obviously we were dealing somewhat with sticker shock
[0:43:27] and realizing that we were going to, like Don said, we were going to require basically a tax
[0:43:32] on every citizen and we were doing our best efforts to make that tax as low as possible.
[0:43:38] And obviously we always had options.
[0:43:43] One of them was we could just say we're going to expand the size of our seasonal employees
[0:43:50] with the water department and do it ourselves and charge and find an amount that we could
[0:43:54] pay for that at and take the private enterprise out of it totally and make it a govern entity.
[0:43:58] I don't think he even wanted to do that.
[0:44:00] But it was certainly an option that we could have looked at.
[0:44:04] The water department perspective definitely got his head to the moment back and forth.
[0:44:07] While he was shaking no please.
[0:44:10] But, you know, one of the things I think I would like to, I would actually be in favor
[0:44:14] of something that's in between here, because I think the list is important.
[0:44:18] I really do believe that we need to have people a way to find out one, that they have to do
[0:44:24] it, and again, because we are fighting exactly that.
[0:44:29] If we have to have compliance by our mandate on our water system, if we don't find a
[0:44:35] way to make it as least expensive as possible, we're going to have an awful lot of people
[0:44:40] not going to comply. They're just not going to pay $65, $85, $85, whatever the amount is, they're just
[0:44:45] going to say, no, I'm not going to do it. And when we're in, then we're going to be in an enforcement
[0:44:50] mode, and we don't want to be there either. So my, but a possible other way to do it is because
[0:44:56] I would vote to leave the $35 on there, even though it maybe seems like, because of what
[0:45:00] one we found out, maybe a little bit too low, I would say anybody that is certified and would
[0:45:07] would like to list that this free advertising. They have the opportunity to put their rate
[0:45:12] behind it. And if they don't want to put their rate behind it, they don't have to. But if they
[0:45:16] want to, they can. That gives them the option to say, here's what I charge. And if you would
[0:45:22] like me to do your service, then we aren't setting an artificial limit every individual
[0:45:30] that would say, I'm willing to do it for this price for the citizens. It's been false. It doesn't
[0:45:34] they have to do it for somebody out in the county. This says for the system falls, they're listing
[0:45:38] by getting this for advertising, they're willing to list their rate. If they aren't willing to list
[0:45:43] their rate, then that's fine too because people are still going to call them because they're on the list
[0:45:47] and well-known names like some in town. People are going to call them even though they don't list
[0:45:54] or rate-mind it, just to find out what they charge possibly if nothing else. But I think the list is
[0:45:59] important is everybody said so people know who they can call the list of the
[0:46:04] name and the phone number and if they're willing to put the right behind it I
[0:46:08] think that's great so thank you Sean Barrier so that the certification comes
[0:46:15] from the state so is there a list that they have that says here's everybody who
[0:46:20] certified yes and and we took that just to kind of pick the ones and twin when
[0:46:26] you made the calls, Wally.
[0:46:28] Wally, if you can come, sorry.
[0:46:31] This is televised in folks who are listening at home.
[0:46:34] Okay.
[0:46:35] Not to make you nervous.
[0:46:38] Not a problem.
[0:46:40] Yeah.
[0:46:41] Everybody that I talked to, they're all licensed.
[0:46:45] Okay.
[0:46:46] It's a license.
[0:46:47] It used to be a certification.
[0:46:49] It's a license.
[0:46:50] The state, we have to take a state test where before we would
[0:46:55] We have a class that's basically close to week long.
[0:47:00] We do a practical on three of the backflow assemblies
[0:47:05] to show that we could actually do the test
[0:47:08] and take a written test and pass
[0:47:11] and then we got our certification.
[0:47:13] The state ticket over, we still have to go through
[0:47:16] just jump through the sand hoops,
[0:47:18] but now we take a state test also,
[0:47:21] which is actually quite a bit harder.
[0:47:25] involved took me a long time pass it.
[0:47:27] So from that list of licensed folks,
[0:47:30] that's where you got these 11 that were presented to us
[0:47:34] in February.
[0:47:36] Yeah, and see, I just took, there's substantially more people
[0:47:42] on the back of those letters I send out on that,
[0:47:47] or ones to choose from, okay,
[0:47:51] than the ones that I just randomly picked.
[0:47:54] I just like, like I said, I picked the local ones to get a local figure.
[0:48:00] Right.
[0:48:01] That was reasonable.
[0:48:02] One thing to keep in mind is that, you know, the market adjusts itself.
[0:48:09] And so you might get a guy, a company that goes down, say, Parkview, and he talks to some
[0:48:18] people and he'll say, I'll do this whole block for so much a pop.
[0:48:24] which will actually lower the rate.
[0:48:28] That's pretty conceivable.
[0:48:32] But I don't know if that's answering your whole question.
[0:48:36] It answers the first part of my question.
[0:48:38] Now I'm going to go someplace with it.
[0:48:40] So just a random Google here, while we were talking,
[0:48:44] I pulled up City Jerome, City of Boise, City of Meridian,
[0:48:50] and it runs the gamut.
[0:48:52] Some just say, here's the link to the state list.
[0:48:55] Some say, here's the list of everybody in town and their phone numbers.
[0:48:59] Meridian actually does what you were talking about, Greg.
[0:49:01] They list the company, the price, and the phone number.
[0:49:06] And then it has the caveat at the bottom.
[0:49:08] Prices are affected as of January 1, 2014, or subject to change without notice.
[0:49:12] Customer is responsible to verify pricing, part of testing.
[0:49:16] And then they add a link to their home page of the backflow information.
[0:49:21] and they vary from 22.50 to call for a quote.
[0:49:27] So when I'm kind of reading into that
[0:49:30] as they probably ask the company,
[0:49:32] you can either provide a surprise
[0:49:35] or you can say call for a quote.
[0:49:39] And these vary from 22.50 up to 85
[0:49:43] and they have a couple that say like $30 and up for example.
[0:49:47] I think this is a combination of commercial
[0:49:51] and residential on this list, too.
[0:49:54] But my sense is I can appreciate your comments, Dave,
[0:49:59] that it does perhaps artificially regulate price.
[0:50:05] So I think the way around that is put everybody's price
[0:50:08] or put nobody's price.
[0:50:10] And I would favor putting everybody's price
[0:50:12] because I do think, one, we have some responsibility
[0:50:16] to provide that list because like you say,
[0:50:18] you can't go to the Yellow Pages and say,
[0:50:20] backflow device checkers, or they're going to call the chamber, and we're going to go,
[0:50:25] I don't know the foggiest idea, because it runs the gamut of a bunch of different kind
[0:50:30] of industry sectors.
[0:50:33] So if we provide that list and contact information, I think we should provide the price at some
[0:50:38] point in time as well.
[0:50:41] I agree with you too.
[0:50:42] I think at some point, if somebody's in a neighborhood and they're walking down the street
[0:50:47] knocking on doors, they're going to owe other price.
[0:50:50] Well, you know, I don't like the government to be involved myself in business.
[0:50:56] I think business should be business, and the less government is involved in business, the better.
[0:51:04] I understand, you know, getting a lower price to get them to comply.
[0:51:11] I agree with that.
[0:51:13] on these backflows, they vary in size. Some people charge, some companies charge by the
[0:51:18] inch. Some go up to commercial, up to 12 inch. Some are really hard to get to, some are really
[0:51:28] easy to get to. But just, you know, you say you do 35 bucks for this, or might be a piece
[0:51:35] a cape, but it might also take you an hour to do it, as opposed to maybe 50 and 20 minutes.
[0:51:44] So it's a real variable thing.
[0:51:47] It's just not like sitting out there and it's really simple to do somewhere, somewhere.
[0:51:55] But I would like to see myself, the list, on the website, I think that if we could have
[0:52:02] a link to that that would be more helpful because a good lot of calls saying okay
[0:52:09] word who do I call well it's on the back letter but I can't tell who's the cheapest
[0:52:16] blood I can't tell you right right yeah I think I think we have to keep in mind
[0:52:21] that it compliances what we're after to protect the water system and so I think
[0:52:26] the easier we can make it for people to comply but more likely they are going
[0:52:30] to.
[0:52:31] Right.
[0:52:32] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:52:33] I'm in favor of having no prices on the list personally.
[0:52:40] I think if we give the citizens a list of names and phone numbers and let them call and do
[0:52:44] their own homework on it, that's probably in the best interest.
[0:52:48] I don't think it's our job to set prices, tell businesses how to do it.
[0:52:53] I think the businesses will now be aware that some companies are less than it might make
[0:52:57] them relook at how they're charging in their structure.
[0:53:01] But I would be very comfortable with just giving the citizens the information of here's
[0:53:05] some ideas of people you can contact that are licensed and responsible and leave it at that
[0:53:10] personally.
[0:53:11] You know, I've heard the gamut here.
[0:53:15] No, no, Liz, no, no, you know, I'm probably, I'm personally comfortable with either saying
[0:53:24] call for quotes.
[0:53:25] Here's the folks call for their quotes.
[0:53:28] If we did that, I would want it to say the average price in our areas 45 to give folks
[0:53:35] some guidance or the actual list and their prices like Meridian does.
[0:53:41] I'm glad you did that, Sean, because that shows another municipality stepping forward
[0:53:45] and giving their citizens some opportunity.
[0:53:47] Again, if it was anything else, if it wasn't a government-directed thing that we're telling
[0:53:52] people they have to do this, I would probably not want to be involved at all.
[0:53:57] that's private industry, that's private a capitalistic society that we live in.
[0:54:03] But we as a government are telling folks that they have to do this.
[0:54:07] So I'd like to give them some options.
[0:54:09] So Greg Lannick.
[0:54:11] I'd like to move that we alter our decision from previous weeks
[0:54:17] that we will provide a list of all certified backflow specialists
[0:54:25] to would like to have their name on our list
[0:54:30] and that they either provide a price that says this much
[0:54:33] and up or call for quote.
[0:54:39] I have a motion on floor by Greg Lontine,
[0:54:41] seconded by Jim Mon.
[0:54:43] Just to clarify your motion, is it for this area,
[0:54:48] for the whole state?
[0:54:50] I'm in this area.
[0:54:52] Okay, that's what my thought process was.
[0:54:55] Here you go.
[0:54:56] So can you define what this area is?
[0:54:58] Thank you.
[0:55:00] I was in my mind, I was thinking the Magic Valley,
[0:55:04] but I don't know the exact dimensions of the Magic Valley.
[0:55:07] Is that close enough?
[0:55:08] If we said Magic Valley, do you want to?
[0:55:12] So when you say Magic Valley,
[0:55:15] and you start thinking about the eight county region
[0:55:18] and the number of possible backflow device people in there
[0:55:21] that we will have to call to get a price for a quote,
[0:55:24] I think that is a... I think we put the onus on them to call us to get on the list.
[0:55:31] We have a motion on the floor, seconded, and we're in the middle of deliberation here.
[0:55:38] Not use it not functional, Travis?
[0:55:50] I think that if we're going to create a list, we need to be the responsible ones
[0:55:55] creating the list and moving forward.
[0:55:58] You never know on who watches the streaming video of this event or watches or reads about
[0:56:06] something in the newspaper and we would hate to hear if we only had knowledge.
[0:56:11] We would have included or been on that list.
[0:56:15] I think that if we're going to create a list with pricing, I think that that's really probably
[0:56:19] like Meridian.
[0:56:20] I bet you the city of Meridian created that list and I'm going to bet that they probably
[0:56:24] kept it to a defined geographic area, maybe to individuals within their service boundary.
[0:56:32] And so I think that you look at backflow device testers within the city of Twin Falls as a
[0:56:43] good place to start.
[0:56:44] I mean, because at some point in time, my concerns were do you draw the line?
[0:56:49] If I include the folks in Jerome County, why not Gooding County, do I include the folks
[0:56:54] over in Kaja, if not, if Kaja, then why not in the Doka?
[0:56:58] And so you start getting this expansive geographic area in a very big list.
[0:57:02] Right. So with the, with my second, we'll agree, I will change it to Twin Falls County.
[0:57:09] I agree with that. Okay. We have, we have changed to Twin Falls County. We have a motion on the floor
[0:57:13] and lots of lights. Jim Munk. Just a matter of protocol. Is this where I could make an amendment
[0:57:20] to the main motion, are we there then?
[0:57:22] Okay, the only thing I would add is that,
[0:57:26] pursuant to this motion, the main motion,
[0:57:31] that the city update that list every January of every year.
[0:57:39] In other words, ensure that every January,
[0:57:43] the water department or whoever would be charged
[0:57:45] with this would update this list and pricing
[0:57:50] to less complicated.
[0:57:52] Are you okay with that, Jim?
[0:57:54] Are you okay with being wonderful?
[0:57:56] Yeah, but it's in the main motion.
[0:57:57] Yeah, well, there's others that have the motion.
[0:58:00] Thanks. All right.
[0:58:02] We have Tom Berger.
[0:58:05] We'll come back to you.
[0:58:10] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:58:11] I don't know if I want to make this as an amendment
[0:58:14] to the main motion or if I can just,
[0:58:15] can I address Councilman Lanting on this real quick?
[0:58:18] Sure. Can we add on to that?
[0:58:20] That we would include the website to the state.
[0:58:23] So if people wanted to look outside the City of Twin Falls,
[0:58:25] they would have that address to go to the state list
[0:58:27] for certified providers as well.
[0:58:31] And then if somebody wanted to do their own homework,
[0:58:33] they would know what that web address is.
[0:58:35] Yeah, as long as they're talking about a separate button
[0:58:38] from what we're doing here, you know,
[0:58:40] there's a button that shows people.
[0:58:42] Maybe the last one on the list after all the 11 providers
[0:58:45] would have the web address to the state list.
[0:58:47] I'm fine with that.
[0:58:48] Are you okay with that, Jim?
[0:58:49] Okay, well, it's fine.
[0:58:51] So, I'm trying to envision my mind what this would look like.
[0:58:55] We're going to have a list on the city website with all Twin Falls County certified backflow
[0:59:01] fixtures.
[0:59:02] And their prices.
[0:59:04] And their prices.
[0:59:05] To be updated every January.
[0:59:07] Or to call for quotes.
[0:59:09] Or to call for quotes.
[0:59:10] That's where I got you.
[0:59:11] I'm with you.
[0:59:13] Secondly, there will be a subsequent hyperlink below that with the state list, correct?
[0:59:19] Just to the state list.
[0:59:21] to the state list of all the backflow fixers certified backflow people is
[0:59:25] getting testers in the state of Idaho. That is my understanding. Okay. I'm
[0:59:28] fine with that. I'll buy that. Rebecca, did you turn your light up? Yes. Okay.
[0:59:34] Chris talking to our rhetorical question. Why we would exclude Jerome? It is closer
[0:59:40] to Twin Falls than some places in Biel doesn't make sense doesn't. What's magic
[0:59:47] about Twin Falls County? Would you like to make an amendment to the motion? No, it's
[0:59:52] rhetorical question. I was just trying to make it a service area that I was actually going to start
[1:00:01] with. I was going to change it to Twin Falls and Jerome and then Travis said, well if you do
[1:00:04] Jerome, why don't you do a link in a pretty quick house back to the whole Magic Valley.
[1:00:07] Don't you think those prices are going to mod regulate themselves? Nobody could drive from
[1:00:11] gooding to Twin Falls and do this for $35. But somebody from that's groups at Twin Falls
[1:00:19] as a whole sector own rather, could come into
[1:00:22] when falls and somebody would be well-good.
[1:00:25] I'm just trying to break down those regional barriers.
[1:00:28] All right, thank you.
[1:00:31] May I respond to?
[1:00:34] Well, depends on the parliamentarian,
[1:00:36] I'm just asked a rhetorical question.
[1:00:40] We'll get to you in a minute.
[1:00:41] Sean remembers his question.
[1:00:44] So I'm struggling with this geographic area a bit as well.
[1:00:51] You know, I could make the argument that you've dropped a 35-mile circle around Twin Falls and make that the area.
[1:00:57] My issue is I don't necessarily want 70 people on this list because I don't think that necessarily serves the citizens need.
[1:01:09] But I don't want it to be so narrow that they don't have any choice.
[1:01:13] So, Wally, the 11 that you provided us back in February, was that everybody in
[1:01:21] Twitter was that sort of an area that you threw a net at as well?
[1:01:25] That included out of town people too.
[1:01:33] A drone, some drone, maybe a fire field.
[1:01:39] I mean just looking around town when you see landscape companies doing stuff,
[1:01:44] I mean, they're coming from Kimberly, coming from Biler, or some from Jerome.
[1:01:50] I think it's a commercial, and the commercial end of it, you got people from all over the
[1:01:54] state that would come to Twin to see some like corporate, like Target, corporate entities,
[1:02:05] they have people every year, it seems like that they have to do their all their stores
[1:02:09] throughout the country.
[1:02:10] through a license in every state, as far as residential.
[1:02:15] I've got a lot of calls from people wanting to know
[1:02:19] that the city of Twin is going to pass to make it mandatory.
[1:02:23] And so they would love to, if they work at your own,
[1:02:28] they'd love to be able to get on a list here in Twin
[1:02:32] because they figured if they get enough clientele,
[1:02:35] they could make money and say they would come here
[1:02:39] not just to test one, they would come here to test four or 50 or whatever. So to limit it just to
[1:02:50] save the Magic Valley, I don't know what to say as far as residential, you're not probably going
[1:03:00] to have people travel farther than the Magic Valley, the test residential. Commercial is a whole
[1:03:07] different story. Right. So I'm wondering, just let me throw this out, that we say Twin Falls County,
[1:03:12] But we have a line down there says for other prices of other counties, please go to their websites because it sounds like Jerome has
[1:03:19] Well, they're based the city. I mean truthfully, I'm struggling a bit with Twin Falls County
[1:03:23] Because we're the city of Twin Falls
[1:03:29] That was my thought process for linking to the state's list of people
[1:03:33] Is Ann Hawkins sorry if people wanted to go look everything is listed there
[1:03:38] They can go look at Jerome everybody is on that state list
[1:03:41] So, we're giving our citizens the information on where to find it without having to make such a cumbersome list for our staff that they're continually having to keep up with it.
[1:03:50] The information's available already.
[1:03:52] There's a perfectly legitimate list to go to, and we're giving them the website to go find that information.
[1:04:00] Which would include Jerome, Buell, and Fylur.
[1:04:04] Jim Mann.
[1:04:05] I second the motion because I think we need to get to sound the floor for a vote, but I think what we're discovering through this debate that we're having right now is that
[1:04:12] Clearly, it is the most efficient thing for us to do, is simply put the state hyperlink
[1:04:20] on our city council or on our city website and walk away from this and let the market
[1:04:26] take care of itself.
[1:04:27] Now we're talking about Jerome, now we're talking about Buell, let's go to Lincoln County,
[1:04:31] let's go here, put the state link there, let the market and people do it and let's get
[1:04:37] out of this thing.
[1:04:38] to be here all night to site in which where we want to go with it. So I'm going to vote no, but
[1:04:46] it was important for me to at least get to sound the floor. Thank you, Jim. Anything further on this
[1:04:51] motion council? We have a real call vote, please. Let's have a restatement of the motion, please.
[1:04:58] Would you like to make a statement motion? Certainly, that we place on both our water bills as well as
[1:05:05] the website, a listing of those certified backflow testers from Twin Falls County, and that they
[1:05:16] have the opportunity to list their price, or please call for a quote and also their phone
[1:05:24] numbers. And at the bottom of that list, that will be a hyperlink to the state list. And
[1:05:32] And then we will be updating this list every January 1.
[1:05:39] Clerk, Clerk, John Berriger, do you think further on the motion council?
[1:05:46] The aye.
[1:05:47] The roll call vote.
[1:05:48] Please.
[1:05:50] No.
[1:05:51] Great.
[1:05:52] Thank you.
[1:05:53] Yes.
[1:05:55] Don Hall?
[1:05:56] Yes.
[1:05:57] Chris Talkington?
[1:05:58] No.
[1:06:00] Rebecca Milasueca?
[1:06:01] Yes.
[1:06:02] See Dan Hawkins?
[1:06:05] Yes.
[1:06:06] John Berriger.
[1:06:10] Yes.
[1:06:12] First of all, I want to thank Council for making an easy math equation tonight.
[1:06:17] The motion passes 5 to 2.
[1:06:23] Moving on to the next item on the agenda is a presentation of the 2014 updated community
[1:06:31] strategic plan which includes city staff and council progress on strategic plan goals
[1:06:37] and initiative, our city manager at Traverse-Westwater.
[1:06:42] That's all it took to clear the boys' test.
[1:06:48] We made too much sauce, he's there to do it.
[1:06:52] Thank you, gentlemen, for coming.
[1:06:55] I think the maupers, for bringing them as well.
[1:06:57] Yes, absolutely.
[1:06:59] Thank you, ma'am.
[1:07:06] Don't take it to your ego.
[1:07:09] They're not the first person to walk out when I start speaking.
[1:07:12] Happens at home often.
[1:07:14] So Mr. Mayor, members of the council tonight
[1:07:16] is really a really good night.
[1:07:19] In fact, this is the very first strategic planning update
[1:07:23] that the staff has been able to provide to the council.
[1:07:27] And it feels like it's a long time in the coming,
[1:07:30] but I really want to share that it's important
[1:07:33] to recognize that from the time that we started the process
[1:07:36] to the time on October 1st, when it became operational,
[1:07:40] really that was more of our preparatory time.
[1:07:42] This strategic plan that we've been operating under
[1:07:45] has been functional since October 1st of 2013.
[1:07:49] And this is really our first opportunity to share
[1:07:51] and showcase and talk about some of the things
[1:07:54] that we've been able to do.
[1:07:56] You'll notice that the entire update to the strategic plan
[1:08:00] is included in your packet.
[1:08:02] And for your benefit and for the benefit of those
[1:08:06] that we'll be watching this currently or later,
[1:08:10] what we did was we took the elements
[1:08:13] that were budgeted for, the elements that were described
[1:08:17] in the 2014 budget.
[1:08:19] And we placed them into the strategic plan in the format that was very familiar with our
[1:08:25] strategic plan because one of the things that we said was that the budget is going to fund
[1:08:31] the initiatives.
[1:08:32] And so we wanted to make sure that we were capturing all of those elements that we were
[1:08:37] funding in our budget and we included them in there.
[1:08:40] That is why this plan became operational for the first time on October 1st of 2013.
[1:08:47] And since that time, you'll notice as you read through the 75 pages of update that our
[1:08:53] city staff has been working hard to accomplish many of these items.
[1:09:00] The updates really provide, I think, a good place of the progress that we've made and we
[1:09:05] will continue to come in and share and showcase and highlight all of the items.
[1:09:11] So we thought that what we would do is we would start on page one and we would roll all the
[1:09:16] way through page 75 just teasing right you should the grimace that just occurred
[1:09:21] from and you're gonna read it all right I was just getting ready no happy no in
[1:09:29] all honesty what we've done is we've we've we've taken the opportunity to really
[1:09:35] showcase and highlight some of those things that we thought were really cool
[1:09:38] some of those things that we've that we've completed all the entire update will
[1:09:44] will be placed onto the city's website.
[1:09:46] Individuals can review that.
[1:09:48] They can call us, they can contact.
[1:09:50] Members of the Council who want more information
[1:09:52] can certainly approach us.
[1:09:53] And we can come in and make a special presentation
[1:09:56] on those items that you found to be cool and innovative
[1:10:00] and really driving our community forward.
[1:10:04] Tonight, and know that this is a process
[1:10:07] that may or may not work for you.
[1:10:10] So this is the first time that we've prevented an update
[1:10:12] to the strategic plan that I can recall as an organization
[1:10:15] in a public setting to a city council.
[1:10:18] And so just as this is new for us,
[1:10:21] we may tweak this from time to time
[1:10:22] so that it fits better communication opportunities
[1:10:26] that we have normally with you, but also with our citizens.
[1:10:29] So we would encourage your input, critique us,
[1:10:31] share with us how we could do things a bit better.
[1:10:34] So we highlighted those four items
[1:10:36] and those four items are going to be presented
[1:10:38] by the individuals that are with us tonight.
[1:10:41] We're going to be talking about the background checks
[1:10:45] that we started in the ID checks,
[1:10:47] which we think is really, really important
[1:10:49] in the area of public safety.
[1:10:50] I'm going to touch briefly on the long-term plan,
[1:10:53] kind of like a teaser for what's going to be occurring
[1:10:55] at our 31st meeting when we unveil the entire plan
[1:10:59] to the members of the city council
[1:11:00] for the review as we kick off that budgeting process.
[1:11:04] We're gonna talk about the bicycle steps that we've taken
[1:11:07] in developing and creating those bicycle
[1:11:11] lanes and community forms that we had Dennis is going to provide that update and
[1:11:15] then John Caton I believe is going to be providing the update on some of the
[1:11:20] innovative work that we're doing with the sewer upgrades without trenching which is
[1:11:24] saving at both cost time and money. So the long-term plan the long-term plan
[1:11:30] was really designed to when it was first created to take a look at all the
[1:11:36] planning documents that we had within the City of Twin Falls and try to
[1:11:40] a fixed price deal. Try to determine how much is it going to cost us to accomplish all of
[1:11:45] those planning documents. It really didn't include the strategic plan as we know it because
[1:11:50] the strategic plan in the past was very different than this one. The long-term plan that will
[1:11:56] be unveiled to you on the 31st actually takes all of the priority ones and assigns them fiscal
[1:12:04] years and then moves forward.
[1:12:07] And it really illustrates maybe a couple of things that we might want to spend some time
[1:12:13] focusing on.
[1:12:14] This group, it is a cross-section of multiple group-I employees at all different levels of
[1:12:20] cross-start organization that have taken the time to really understand revenue forecasting,
[1:12:27] to really try to develop what the long-term priorities and needs and opportunities are
[1:12:33] as they relate to accomplishing the strategic plan,
[1:12:37] not only those priority one initiatives,
[1:12:39] but also those ongoing things that the citizens
[1:12:42] have come to expect from us from a level of service.
[1:12:46] The long-term planning group will be here next week,
[1:12:49] or not next week, next week, we don't have a meeting.
[1:12:52] They will be here on the 31st,
[1:12:54] and they are going to be able to highlight and share
[1:12:57] how we will take and mobilize the strategic plan
[1:13:02] over the course of the next five years.
[1:13:06] It is important to recognize that the long-term plan is a plan.
[1:13:09] It's not a balanced budget for a period of five years,
[1:13:12] but really what it does, it says if we were to fund these things,
[1:13:16] this is kind of what that financial outlook looks like.
[1:13:19] And along that way, as we've presented past long-term plans,
[1:13:24] there might be some deficits in there.
[1:13:26] But it is important to recognize that those deficits do not really
[1:13:30] represent where we're at financially because we are constitutionally required to have a balanced
[1:13:34] budget. And what we're trying to do is we're trying to determine the financial feasibility
[1:13:39] of the strategic plan as we've stated and prioritized. I believe this council has shared last time the
[1:13:45] concerns that they have are we trying to bite off more in the first five years than what
[1:13:51] we had anticipated. And a brief preview in terms of the long-term plan that will be presented,
[1:13:57] We believe that it for the upcoming year, we're in good shape and we will continue to work
[1:14:03] on the subsequent years to ensure that we're able to have the financial means and the resources
[1:14:08] to ensure that we're delivering the strategic planning commitments and that we described moving
[1:14:15] forward.
[1:14:16] The out years will continue to focus on and we're going to have the long term planning
[1:14:21] group start their work much earlier than they did this year.
[1:14:25] that their delay and their start was actually, you can point the finger at me, we really wanted
[1:14:30] to spend some time understanding what that group would be doing moving forward.
[1:14:35] In subsequent years they'll probably start as early as October and they'll be able to
[1:14:39] move forward very, very thoughtfully for the upcoming year, they've really stepped forward
[1:14:44] and prevent and provided I think a really good insight into this upcoming fiscal year.
[1:14:50] That will kick off our budgets.
[1:14:52] that we'll begin that budgeting season on March 31st,
[1:14:57] that is probably starting much earlier
[1:14:59] than any other entity that I'm aware of.
[1:15:02] With that, I'm going to turn it over to Dennis.
[1:15:05] Dennis is going to talk about some of the things
[1:15:08] that occurred in Parks and Recreation.
[1:15:14] OK, first part of it, I'm going to talk about our background
[1:15:16] checks.
[1:15:17] We have been doing background checks.
[1:15:19] I was trying to remember, and I could not figure out
[1:15:21] exact year we implemented that.
[1:15:23] It was probably seven to eight years ago
[1:15:25] that we implemented background checks
[1:15:26] on our volunteer coaches.
[1:15:30] And we'll add to all the police departments left,
[1:15:32] but really have to thank them.
[1:15:33] They've run all the background checks for us.
[1:15:35] We just, they come in our office, they'll out the form.
[1:15:37] We get a copy of their driver's license,
[1:15:39] make sure they are who they say they are,
[1:15:41] and ship it over to PD and so thank you to the police department.
[1:15:45] Because we have, we're looking at our youth programs.
[1:15:48] We have between our baseball, softball, soccer,
[1:15:51] two seasons, you know, basketball.
[1:15:53] We have probably anywhere between 300 and 320 head coaches
[1:15:58] that we have background checks for a light on.
[1:16:00] We do know that some of these coaches
[1:16:02] are the same people that coach their kids, you know,
[1:16:04] I was trying to think back and realize myself
[1:16:06] and my two boys were growing up in our programs.
[1:16:08] I thought, oh, wow, I coached both their baseball programs
[1:16:11] in December, both their soccer teams spring and fall
[1:16:15] and their basketball team.
[1:16:16] So instead of eight background checks on one team,
[1:16:19] you know, they just would have to do one background check on me.
[1:16:22] So somewhere, I mean, there's close to 300 background checks.
[1:16:25] We are looking at to also implement even the assistant coaches
[1:16:29] also on our background checks.
[1:16:32] We could have anywhere, sometimes a head coach,
[1:16:33] that's all there is, is a head coach.
[1:16:35] Other times you could have one assistant coach,
[1:16:37] two assistant coach, and I know Suzanne,
[1:16:39] you have coached for us many, many years, you know,
[1:16:41] so as you know that there's sometimes
[1:16:43] you could have one assistant coach,
[1:16:44] or sometimes it seems like you have
[1:16:46] every parent is an assistant coach,
[1:16:47] but we won't go that far.
[1:16:49] But we estimate that we'll probably
[1:16:51] have on the average two assistant head coaches
[1:16:53] that will be background.
[1:16:54] So we'll have up in the neighborhood of 900 and 950
[1:16:58] backgrounds a year.
[1:17:00] And with these background checks are good for one year only.
[1:17:04] So if you coach in the spring soccer program
[1:17:07] and you're good for a couple of other programs,
[1:17:09] come around again the following spring program,
[1:17:11] you have to go through the background check again.
[1:17:15] But also this year what we want to do,
[1:17:17] We want to implement this for our baseball softball program
[1:17:20] that starts practicing, starts in May, games in June.
[1:17:24] We want to be able to have to prove that to our staff
[1:17:28] that we have supervisors out there and our officials out there
[1:17:31] to prove that this coach has gone through the background check
[1:17:33] and is the right person out there that is kind of a do an ID card.
[1:17:37] We're looking at some type of an ID card with the land
[1:17:39] that coaches wear that.
[1:17:40] So our supervisor or officials know that person
[1:17:43] because we did have an incident in our soccer program this year
[1:17:46] where the head coaches didn't show up,
[1:17:48] somebody volunteered to coach,
[1:17:49] and we found out that person
[1:17:50] would not have passed our background checked,
[1:17:53] but just volunteered to help out.
[1:17:54] So we didn't want that situation to come up again.
[1:17:57] So we want to make sure all our coaches,
[1:17:59] head coaches and assistant coaches,
[1:18:01] do have the background checks,
[1:18:03] and do have those ID cards to that.
[1:18:05] So we're looking at trying to,
[1:18:07] look at an ID card system,
[1:18:09] produce an ID card,
[1:18:12] produce it right then and there,
[1:18:13] after their background checks,
[1:18:15] Okay, issue that ID card to that coach
[1:18:18] and make a mandatory for the coaches
[1:18:20] to provide that at the games for our staff there.
[1:18:25] So, just a new system, we know it's gonna take
[1:18:28] a little longer, because with the police department,
[1:18:31] because now we're also maybe doubling, tripling,
[1:18:35] their background checks that they do right now.
[1:18:38] We know it's gonna be sent a little more staff time,
[1:18:40] but we figure that this is really the right way
[1:18:44] direction to go to make sure all our coaches are qualified to coach.
[1:18:48] Rebecca has a question, but I have a question for you. What's the benchmark?
[1:18:52] I mean, what tells you they can't be a coach because we all...
[1:18:56] There is some things that we list on, have you ever been convicted or whatever.
[1:19:02] Any questions, they all go to our, uh,
[1:19:06] attorney for each one of the key decides that they qualify or not.
[1:19:10] And if they do not, I'll put a pressure on them.
[1:19:12] Could you give us some kind of guidance what you're looking for for us and you have a list of criteria like convictions for DUI within a certain number of years?
[1:19:21] possession of controlled substances delivery controlled substances
[1:19:26] Sex abuses
[1:19:28] injury children right so there's this
[1:19:32] That's right very good. Yeah, and they're all listed right on the application perfect. Thank you. That was my question. Thank you mayor
[1:19:38] No, I was just wondering what disqualified someone so that they would the public would know, you know, of course, we always, you know, all of us have a past and I hope downtown parking citations don't disqualify you.
[1:19:51] That was my question.
[1:19:53] And if our attorney ever does disqualify that letter is sent to that coach or what's the coach anyways sent to my first one where they can staff ourself. We do not know, you know, if there's some question, we don't know why they were disqualified.
[1:20:07] qualified so we don't know it's just our attorney sends that letter out to that
[1:20:12] person. Thank you. Thank you Rebecca. Chris talking. Dennis I think you cover
[1:20:17] this but this is an NCIC check it's not a Twin Falls County check. If I remember
[1:20:23] correctly, can you help me on that question? It's both NCIC and and city and if we
[1:20:30] have reports they send those over for me to review too. Greg Mack and I know it's
[1:20:37] hard to know how many chose not to coach because they saw the list and realized
[1:20:43] that they would be disqualified but how many do you have actually come back that
[1:20:47] are disqualified do we have a number I would say probably have you know ten to
[1:20:54] ten to twelve a year back I don't see them again once they've qualified I
[1:21:01] don't I don't see them again so when once they're on the list they don't send
[1:21:06] to back to back check. We want every year we go through background check. Okay, all right.
[1:21:15] Well, I just want to go ahead and finish with a statement. I appreciate this dentist. I know
[1:21:20] when I came on the mare I instituted that we would ask to do background checks on those appointed
[1:21:26] party committees and commissions just for the fact that we have to have people feel like they're
[1:21:33] safe and the coaches are one of the first places that occurs and and with the
[1:21:39] embarrassment of having somebody who's listed as coast of all year and then you
[1:21:43] find out later that they are a sexual predator and certainly not something that
[1:21:46] one the embarrassment city but two we've subjected kids to a potential problem
[1:21:53] and so I appreciate your endeavor on this.
[1:21:56] Chris is this the same I know that we did Institute a few years ago that we were
[1:22:01] we're doing these kind of background checks
[1:22:03] for commissions and committees.
[1:22:05] So is it the same benchmarks that we're looking there?
[1:22:08] You know, I haven't been seeing any on the commissions.
[1:22:13] I don't know.
[1:22:14] Maybe we have all with no records.
[1:22:17] OK.
[1:22:19] We're still doing that, aren't we, Travis?
[1:22:25] Yeah, I was under the understanding
[1:22:26] that we were, and we'll get you an update on that.
[1:22:28] OK, thank you.
[1:22:30] I think I know that we did that, because you used about this time
[1:22:33] years when the new appointments happen to on the commissions, you know, reappointments
[1:22:38] we haven't had to go through the background checks, but new appointments, I know last year
[1:22:43] a couple of new appointments, we sent those names over to the police department. I don't
[1:22:48] remember, I don't think the commissioners filled out a form like we do for our coaches,
[1:22:53] but I know the commission's names went over the release department.
[1:22:57] Well, you just brought up a point, Chris, I know you're next, I'm sorry, but should we
[1:23:01] be doing this for reappointments as well. If we're doing it every year for coaches when
[1:23:07] it comes time for us to reappoint someone on a commission or a committee, I'm wondering
[1:23:12] if we should probably look at that. Chris, talking to me.
[1:23:15] Well, I personally would draw the line that they're working with youth, absolutely. I don't
[1:23:23] know about somebody in the library board, but anyway, I think it just should be noted that
[1:23:27] the numbers that we process and those that are rejected it shows about a 97%
[1:23:34] approval rate which speaks well of our population. There's 3% you can find
[1:23:39] guilty or wrong doing for anything. Rebecca Mills-Zuica? Oh I would just agree with
[1:23:46] Councilman Talkington I think that if there's you know if there's a
[1:23:50] purpose in the background check you know that something would disqualify
[1:23:53] someone from you know working with youth I think protecting children is important.
[1:23:57] And the other commissions, I really don't know how you would set which items disqualify
[1:24:03] someone or which items don't.
[1:24:05] So I'm probably less concerned about commissions unless they're working with children.
[1:24:14] Thank you, Dan.
[1:24:15] You want me to go on my next one?
[1:24:17] All right, switch gears a little bit.
[1:24:20] Okay, this one kind of talks about developing partners to advocate for our bike trails and
[1:24:25] support bike programs.
[1:24:26] So I think some of you were at the meeting back we Travis hosted,
[1:24:31] might say, back in October by Black Form.
[1:24:33] And you saw the great response we had show up there
[1:24:36] that people are interested in making this community a more
[1:24:39] biking-friendly community.
[1:24:42] So what we have done is we have taken those maps
[1:24:44] that they produced at that evening,
[1:24:47] where they kind of go from point A to point B home to work
[1:24:51] or to schools or to the library or to the different parks.
[1:24:55] And also, earlier that Bob and Robin Seastrum and Art Oak
[1:25:00] kind of develop a map of what they thought was the,
[1:25:03] maybe the better routes to and falls for bikes to go on,
[1:25:06] some of the routes that you want to stay away from,
[1:25:09] completely like the lakes.
[1:25:12] But, so staff is now kind of working on these areas.
[1:25:16] If you took everybody's suggestion,
[1:25:18] almost every street would be a bike friendly route
[1:25:20] type of deal.
[1:25:21] Well, we know that's not gonna happen.
[1:25:22] So we kind of sitting down myself, Jackie Fields, and also Josh Baird with the engineering department
[1:25:30] kind of sat down and looked at all these maps and tried to come up with some type of consensus
[1:25:34] of where we can put these bike routes on.
[1:25:39] And also we looked at our master plan that was the street master plan, but one component
[1:25:43] of that was our bicycle master plan.
[1:25:45] A lot of the future bicycle trails that we have on the master plan were part of this
[1:25:52] group of bicyclists that wanted to go to different areas of town.
[1:25:57] So I still have to get together with Jackie and Josh kind of finalizing, okay, here's our
[1:26:04] proposed bike.
[1:26:05] I don't know, we haven't really come up with what we want to call these routes, I've been
[1:26:09] calling them bike-friendly routes, you know.
[1:26:13] After we can kind of come to consensus staff-wise about where we can place these out, you know,
[1:26:18] depends sometimes on the road construction or what's going to happen there can part of
[1:26:22] it is, you know, one of the big things is how do we cross the lake safely, you know?
[1:26:26] So we look at where the intersections may be with stoplights at.
[1:26:30] But what we want to do and is get it out to the public one more time, see what their thoughts
[1:26:35] are about where we are, have these proposed at.
[1:26:39] One thought we had was have it on our website, maybe host another open forum.
[1:26:45] And I believe Jackie said that our Robin with the handles our GIS that we could put something
[1:26:51] on the website where they could kind of click on the links or the trails they would like
[1:26:55] to see and that might we could kind of get totals on that.
[1:27:00] So we kind of make sure we have the right areas that we want to make sure that the bike-friendly
[1:27:05] routes that we pick out are the routes that the cyclists around town will use.
[1:27:12] And the next step we want to, these are the right step, is, okay, how are we going to sign
[1:27:17] them?
[1:27:18] How are we going to stripe them?
[1:27:19] How are we going to tell people, you know, besides just our citizens of Twin Falls, but
[1:27:23] also our tourists in Twin Falls?
[1:27:24] How are we going to notify them?
[1:27:25] You know, so we're looking at, okay, some striping maybe on the roads there, some signage
[1:27:29] on there, also producing maps so we can have them at the hotels, at the visitor centers,
[1:27:35] so people, when they come into town, they can go, okay, we're going to ride my bike.
[1:27:39] you got the Kenyonham Trail, but also if you want to go, if you're staying on a hotel on Blue Lakes,
[1:27:44] this is how you want to get to downtown for the Wednesday night concerts that have, what's the best
[1:27:49] way to get down there. So internally staff has to do a little bit more work on it, and I think we're
[1:27:54] ready to kind of get those proposed, like friendly routes out to the community, let them kind of mold
[1:28:00] over one more time, and then look at because it's something, if we do some striking on the roads,
[1:28:05] that's going to cost more money to maintain that striping.
[1:28:08] I believe that Dean with the Street Department right now,
[1:28:10] I think he gave a little update to our,
[1:28:13] the department head staffers,
[1:28:15] how many, 580 some bike logos out on the streets,
[1:28:21] or how many were there, Jack, do you remember?
[1:28:23] Okay, yeah, he had, there's hundreds and hundreds,
[1:28:27] and how many miles of striping he has right now,
[1:28:30] we only have three designated bike routes in Twin Falls right now.
[1:28:34] So, we need to know that's cost because that does cost the city money to maintain those areas, put up the signs.
[1:28:42] We do have some money in the budget this year to kind of get it implemented, but also we need to know what the long-term maintenance of that program will be.
[1:28:50] And also producing maps, you know, is that something that we'll probably have to update every two or three years as we might add more areas?
[1:28:57] Or we may have to reroute one area because of something anyway.
[1:29:01] So that's kind of the process we're looking at,
[1:29:03] we're hoping that we could have something out there,
[1:29:06] you know, for the public to get some more comments
[1:29:10] from them in the near future.
[1:29:12] I'm available for questions on that part.
[1:29:15] Any questions?
[1:29:16] Rebecca, may I second?
[1:29:17] Thank you, Mayor.
[1:29:18] Thank you, Dennis.
[1:29:19] So you touched on one of my questions
[1:29:20] about the Trails Master Plan
[1:29:22] and kind of taking the input from the community
[1:29:25] and applying it to that Trails Master Plan.
[1:29:27] So are we maybe going to see an update
[1:29:30] of that master plan for those bike routes since that's what determines, you know,
[1:29:36] this objective is about having the right zoning requirements in place.
[1:29:41] And so that plan actually indicates to planning a zoning, okay, you need to build.
[1:29:48] Sorry, am I talking about the right trails master plan, bike-friendly route sort of a thing?
[1:29:53] Is this separate?
[1:29:55] Because from what I understood of the trails master plan, it kind of tells the subdivision,
[1:29:59] We need to plan a bike-friendly or pedestrian-friendly trail here.
[1:30:04] Is the input, I guess my question, is the input from the community,
[1:30:06] can that be applied to the trail's master plan for an update?
[1:30:10] If I could answer that question all the way.
[1:30:16] I think the input that we're getting from the citizens anyway is,
[1:30:21] I don't think that would help with the master plan for planning and zoning to say,
[1:30:27] okay, they want a trail in this area.
[1:30:30] We are looking at where people are going right now and implementing on the existing trails.
[1:30:35] We have not really, I mean back up, we have looked at some areas where someday we know
[1:30:41] that this road will extend further.
[1:30:44] For example, I'll give you a good example.
[1:30:47] The bike route we have on Falls Avenue, you know, starts at and over there by the, by
[1:30:51] the front right in front of the tennis courts there on stadium goes west on stadium, goes
[1:30:56] North Amadrona and west on Falls Avenue all the way to 3300 and heads north and to the
[1:31:01] top of the canyon rim there.
[1:31:04] What we want to do someday is take it off the Falls Avenue, okay.
[1:31:08] That was a federally funded program so where do we put it?
[1:31:11] We looked at right now you could continue going west on stadium all the way to Hankins
[1:31:17] right now and then take it up to Falls Avenue so we can take it part of way off and eventually
[1:31:22] They have Hankins that development further west of Hankins,
[1:31:27] excuse me, further east.
[1:31:28] I'm sorry, got the direction wrong way.
[1:31:31] Further direction east, that there will be some day,
[1:31:33] you might say, development that we could make sure we have
[1:31:36] a bike route going all the way east to 3,300.
[1:31:39] Then you take it off the major arterial street
[1:31:42] and put it on a little lesser side street.
[1:31:45] So some of these plans could affect,
[1:31:47] you might say, planning and zoning.
[1:31:49] But I think right now I was looking
[1:31:51] at just more of a bike-friendly routes areas around town that may or may not affect, you
[1:31:58] know, subdivision, future subdivisions?
[1:32:00] Okay, right.
[1:32:01] And maybe I was combining the two, and there's actually those two separate parts.
[1:32:04] So I think my input would be, and maybe this is more for planning and zoning, but I guess
[1:32:08] I'm looking at the objective HC-1B, and that's about requiring certain paths or trails to
[1:32:16] be developed as part of new development.
[1:32:18] So sorry if I let that mesh into your bike trails,
[1:32:21] but I guess of my input on that in general to staff
[1:32:25] would be to maybe use this bike committee
[1:32:28] as kind of public input to affect
[1:32:31] and update our trail's master plan,
[1:32:33] because I know recently we had a subdivision come in
[1:32:38] on the canyon rim, you know,
[1:32:39] and it wasn't designated on the trail's master plan
[1:32:43] to continue that trail,
[1:32:45] but I know that a lot of the maps
[1:32:47] that people drew on at that night, you know,
[1:32:50] they kind of drew areas where they would like
[1:32:52] to see future connections, or so on and so forth.
[1:32:55] So, sorry to divert you a bit,
[1:32:57] but maybe we can use that input on that committee
[1:33:00] to perhaps feed into our future plans for the update.
[1:33:05] I think that we can blend those.
[1:33:09] So I think that you have Dennis's master trail plan,
[1:33:11] and then we have a collection of individuals,
[1:33:14] primarily bicyclists in this case.
[1:33:17] that have stated where they currently reside
[1:33:21] and where they would like to go.
[1:33:22] And there's probably a lot of commonality
[1:33:24] between those two.
[1:33:25] So we're going to be able to take the community's input
[1:33:29] on where they would like to see those trail systems
[1:33:32] built and developed and we're going to be able
[1:33:33] to possibly compare that with our existing trail system
[1:33:37] and we're going to be able to maybe take a blended approach.
[1:33:40] But I think it's a good idea to make sure
[1:33:42] that the master trail plan is a continual evolving
[1:33:47] document that as we continue to grow there's going to be additional places that we'd like
[1:33:51] to access and so that plan needs to reflect that and I think that we can, I think that's
[1:33:56] what Dennis and we'll go and certainly make sure that's one of our priorities.
[1:34:00] That's wonderful, thank you.
[1:34:01] Any other questions for Dennis?
[1:34:03] Good job.
[1:34:06] Thank you, Dennis.
[1:34:07] Who's next?
[1:34:08] Travis?
[1:34:14] Welcome, Mr. Caten.
[1:34:15] Good evening.
[1:34:17] Mayor, Councilor.
[1:34:18] Good evening, Mayor, Councilman, Jesus, eye level, microphone.
[1:34:26] I wonder what happened there.
[1:34:30] I thought Bill was orange.
[1:34:35] Okay, I'm here tonight to talk about trenchless pipe replacement.
[1:34:44] And it's pretty self-explanatory. I wanted to just show you some projects that we're doing.
[1:34:52] Like I said, we're doing.
[1:34:54] First of all, we talked in our plan about this being like a pilot test, and I just want
[1:34:59] to be clear that this trenchless concept has not new.
[1:35:02] It's been around since the 70s, but it didn't become real common until the 90s.
[1:35:06] There's three different types of trenchless pipe replacement, or repair that I'm aware
[1:35:11] of.
[1:35:13] Pipe bursting, which is basically taking a cutting head and pulling it through a pipe.
[1:35:19] cuts the pipe and as it turns through it, almost like a bullet in her rifle, it splits the pipe and pulls a new replacement pipe behind it.
[1:35:29] You can split any kind of pipe, ductal iron, plastic, concrete, anything.
[1:35:34] The cool thing about pipe bursting is you can burst size on, same size, or else you can go up in size.
[1:35:43] So there's advantages for each of the different types of trenchless.
[1:35:48] In the past, the City of Twin Falls has done quite a bit of pipe bursting.
[1:35:52] In the last couple of years, we haven't done as much of it.
[1:35:56] The opportunities haven't come up as often.
[1:35:59] And then the second time is a slip line, and that is just pulling a new pipe into an existing
[1:36:08] pipe.
[1:36:09] You obviously lose pipe capacity because you've got a pipe on the inside of the old one.
[1:36:16] And then the one I wanted to talk about tonight I think is the most interesting and
[1:36:21] very innovative.
[1:36:22] It's been around since the 70s as well and it's called CIPP.
[1:36:26] It's cured in place piping and we did one this year.
[1:36:32] These pictures are not from the project this year.
[1:36:36] They're from two years ago.
[1:36:37] Back to my new men three years ago now.
[1:36:41] But the pictures are good and it represents what's going on here.
[1:36:44] So I want to point a couple things out in this picture.
[1:36:48] Carodin Place pipe is laying in the back of this truck.
[1:36:53] And what it is, it's basically a fiber.
[1:37:00] It's like a sock, flexible sock, injected with resin.
[1:37:03] You can see the blue resin, so it's just not in there.
[1:37:10] You can also see that it's stored in a condition environment.
[1:37:13] There's ice bags in there.
[1:37:15] So here in place pipe has a shelf life, and you have to use it, and it's expensive to store, as you can see.
[1:37:23] And so there's a closer view of what the fabric looks like.
[1:37:34] Here's the crew setting up on a manhole.
[1:37:39] They basically pull the sock through that manhole to the next manhole, and seal it off, fill it with steam,
[1:37:50] and it pressurizes, and it cooks it, and in about an hour,
[1:37:54] it's cured, and this is what it's like.
[1:37:58] Good, great.
[1:37:59] So the reason I think it's so cool is because it's fast,
[1:38:03] and it has the integrity of PVC pipes.
[1:38:07] So not only do you replace the pipe,
[1:38:13] but it also has the strength of a new pipe.
[1:38:16] So obviously you're adding some wall thickness,
[1:38:19] and one of the questions I had was,
[1:38:21] Okay, are we losing capacity?
[1:38:22] And the manufacturer has explained that
[1:38:24] because of the, and I'm getting to the engineering stuff,
[1:38:27] but because the walls are smoother,
[1:38:29] you actually, it's a net gain and loss on capacity.
[1:38:32] So in most scenarios, you don't even lose capacity.
[1:38:35] I'm just going way too far.
[1:38:37] You're entering someone else's realm.
[1:38:41] I think it's cool.
[1:38:42] So the other thing that's cool is,
[1:38:44] and I'll show the pressure we did this year,
[1:38:47] is it works well in gravity,
[1:38:49] when there's other ladders that connect sewer in between
[1:38:52] manholes, they'll send a remote down and they'll,
[1:38:56] they can visually see and they can cut,
[1:38:58] they can cut other ladders in so you don't even have
[1:39:00] to send a man in there to do that.
[1:39:01] Or if there's service connections,
[1:39:03] you can cut it to service connection.
[1:39:04] It's really cool.
[1:39:08] So the project we did this year is.
[1:39:14] Can I ask you some questions real quick?
[1:39:16] So this is for mainly sewer?
[1:39:18] Yeah.
[1:39:19] Can it be used for water?
[1:39:20] You know, I've been told that there are technologies for water for pressure line.
[1:39:27] I have not seen it.
[1:39:28] I'm not aware of what I've seen.
[1:39:29] This is mainly gravity sort.
[1:39:32] How many times can you do it?
[1:39:34] I mean, I know when you re-rerupt your house, you can do so many layers on top of your shingles,
[1:39:38] right?
[1:39:39] How many times can you do this?
[1:39:40] I've never even been asked to ever thought about it, but the life of the PVC, I mean,
[1:39:47] The existing pipe is there and you're replacing it for a reason, but there's still some length
[1:39:52] on the existing pipe and you're adding a whole new PVC pipe.
[1:39:55] So I mean 90 years and you're probably going to have a capacity problem before you have
[1:40:00] a maintenance problem again.
[1:40:02] John, your experiment was with an 8-inch how large a diameter can you go to?
[1:40:06] They'll go up to 60-inch.
[1:40:08] Wow.
[1:40:09] Yeah.
[1:40:10] You can go down as much as 6-inch, but 6-inch, they don't love doing 6-inch.
[1:40:15] and how about the length of your pole?
[1:40:18] Pretty much as long as the manhole is long as you have.
[1:40:22] It's really revolutionary.
[1:40:24] It's neat.
[1:40:25] We're fascinated. There's lights coming on.
[1:40:27] Great land.
[1:40:28] What kind of pipe are you replacing or basically putting a new sleeve on the inside?
[1:40:33] What kind of pipe is it replacing?
[1:40:35] You know, gravity pipe in town. We have clay.
[1:40:38] We have concrete. We have asbestos concrete. You could do PVC.
[1:40:42] You can virtually any pipe type.
[1:40:44] So any of those first several that you mentioned, that's reason to you. There's probably almost a net gain in
[1:40:50] capacity because this would be smoother than those. Yeah, so it's kind of like we replaced, we put a plastic liner in the one
[1:40:58] the one that goes down grand view as I recall at some point early in our 10-year-old
[1:41:03] that we put a plastic pipe in and we actually gained ground because it was smoother than the concrete pipe that was there.
[1:41:09] We put plastic inside the concrete pipe, but I'll restate that and so all right. I think you've entered Jackie Fields round
[1:41:18] No, I just left a note for it. Just left a note
[1:41:23] Reminded me to talk about when when we wouldn't use it. There's definitely applications where it's just it's not it's not perfect
[1:41:29] There's there's places you use it in places you wouldn't Chris talking
[1:41:33] Yeah, what about the cost savings you mentioned that roughly where you're gonna start just gonna get that
[1:41:38] I think it really depends on the project, so when I was first getting familiar with it,
[1:41:46] I was thinking, okay, this is going to be half the cost.
[1:41:49] It's not always half the cost.
[1:41:51] Sometimes I gave it a range of 20 to 50%.
[1:41:58] That's just kind of a rule of thumb.
[1:42:01] This project that we did this year is potentially more than 50% savings.
[1:42:07] The sewer manuals are here to here, and so we replaced this sewer line across Washington.
[1:42:18] So if we had to change Washington, you can imagine the traffic control costs and the
[1:42:26] reconstruction plus that state right away, we would have to meet their standard.
[1:42:34] Suzanne Hawkins.
[1:42:36] Is this technology going to be usable as we're moving forward with downtown redevelopment
[1:42:41] and the sewer line replacement we need down there?
[1:42:43] It could be.
[1:42:44] There is six inch pipe downtown and that's not preferred
[1:42:51] but there is eight inch so where there's eight inch you could use it.
[1:42:54] So let me talk about that just for a minute.
[1:42:56] Okay. So CIPP is great if the host pipe is compromised
[1:43:05] but you cannot have real big sags in the pipe.
[1:43:10] can have huge offset joints and unfortunately in a lot of downtown you have that not everywhere
[1:43:16] but in some places. So it'll bridge gaps, it'll bridge holes and things like that but
[1:43:23] if there's an offset joint it has, you can't do that.
[1:43:28] Would you use the pipe bursting downtown then instead or are you think is it going to have
[1:43:32] to be trenched? Do you have pipe bursting has similar limitations in that if there's
[1:43:37] a huge sag it's going to follow the path of the original pipe. So if you have large
[1:43:41] sags you know you probably need to trench. My challenge was pipe bursting
[1:43:48] just thinking is EPA okay with that? Oh yes. Okay because you're bursting a pipe
[1:43:54] and letting the substance go into the ground. Well you're not you're not yet
[1:43:58] well you'll actually bypass the line it won't be in service at that point so I
[1:44:03] saw it's all clean out first and then you do that. Thank you.
[1:44:09] But I just can't imagine with, you know, Greg landing.
[1:44:13] Well, John, I'm on the pipe burst.
[1:44:14] You know, what about the, you know, you see, you know,
[1:44:18] my experience is pretty limited.
[1:44:19] You know, we've grown up on a farm and you got drain fields
[1:44:22] and you always laid the right materials
[1:44:24] around the drain field so that it didn't, you know,
[1:44:27] get busted and things.
[1:44:30] So what about the shards of what you've just busted?
[1:44:32] Does that not cause problems for the new pipe?
[1:44:36] So you're thinking about pipe bursting.
[1:44:39] Right.
[1:44:40] OK.
[1:44:41] In that case, the head cuts ahead of the new pipe.
[1:44:48] And it's slightly larger than the piping pulled in.
[1:44:52] So it consolidates the soil.
[1:44:56] And it's generally not an issue on this one.
[1:45:00] OK, all right.
[1:45:04] Keep going.
[1:45:05] Obviously be on my scope of knowledge here.
[1:45:07] I just need to say this, Dennis, I didn't think that
[1:45:10] pipe bursting and trenching would trump the bicycle,
[1:45:13] but I think he's beating you tonight.
[1:45:15] I knew this was the main one.
[1:45:17] I knew this was the main one.
[1:45:18] Um, another challenge with this technology is,
[1:45:25] it takes specialized equipment and training.
[1:45:28] It's not, it's not, I don't know of a local contractor.
[1:45:32] So usually you have to come in from the region.
[1:45:35] Filer recently did a ton of this a couple of years ago.
[1:45:38] There are contractors in Boise.
[1:45:40] So how can we do more of this?
[1:45:43] I think we do, you know, we have to be careful
[1:45:47] with the application and not just go CIPP everything, right?
[1:45:50] We don't want to be doing that.
[1:45:52] So we have to be careful in our selection,
[1:45:54] which means we have to have a good inspection list
[1:45:58] or an inspection program.
[1:45:59] And I think in my opinion, the best thing to do
[1:46:02] was to start to build a list of CIPP candidates so that every couple of years we have a backlog
[1:46:09] of as much pipe that we can do at one time so you can price leverage.
[1:46:15] So the reason we only did one here is because the contractor had a product that was going
[1:46:22] to expire and he contacted us and said, hey, give me a good price.
[1:46:26] This project was $12,000 for just under 400 feet of pipe.
[1:46:33] I'm thinking that traffic control probably would have been more than $12,000.
[1:46:37] Just the traffic control?
[1:46:38] Probably.
[1:46:39] I think your program?
[1:46:40] So it was a good opportunity for us and we'll continue to do that.
[1:46:46] We told them, hey, if you have single projects for us, we're always interested and in the
[1:46:52] anytime we'll develop a big project lesson hopefully do this in a couple years.
[1:47:01] This is a fun thing. Anything else? Good report. Thank you. Thank you, John.
[1:47:06] Thank you. Travis. Beat that. I can't. And who knew that we can have such a good
[1:47:18] conversation about paper stand right? So you admit when you saw that on the
[1:47:21] agenda you thought well how is that and why is that going to be cool? I felt the
[1:47:26] same thing until Jim was assigned. So what's important about tonight, what's
[1:47:32] important about tonight is hopefully it illustrates not only these quick little
[1:47:37] presentations but the other 75 pages that we've outlined really talks about the
[1:47:42] focus that we have in the organization, that focus being one of a strategic focus
[1:47:46] that is driving our fiscal priorities and defining our choices as we move
[1:47:51] forward. The strategic plan helps us answer how we're going to allocate our
[1:47:56] resources. It also helps answer how we're going to allocate our time and our talent. And hopefully
[1:48:02] the illustrations that we've provided to you this evening provides you a good idea of what
[1:48:08] some of the members of our team have been working on since this plan was adopted and became
[1:48:14] implementation or implemented. As we continue to drive forward, it's important to recognize
[1:48:19] that this strategic plan will help decide and define those two goals.
[1:48:25] What I would like is, as we started in the last few years, we've had departments come
[1:48:31] to you and they would share what's going on in their department as a matter of interest
[1:48:35] to you.
[1:48:36] We would like these updates to drive those conversations.
[1:48:40] We would like to highlight and showcase those items that you would like to have more information
[1:48:45] about.
[1:48:46] is to do very similar tonight. Until the next update, which should be every three to four months,
[1:48:54] we will present a new update, a new circumstance of where we're at. And it's important that also,
[1:48:59] as we're moving forward in the budgeting process, we're talking a lot about the strategic plan,
[1:49:03] so it's not like we have an update and it sits on the shelf. But in the month of April, we would
[1:49:09] like to do two more presentations to you, selecting two more areas that we felt were
[1:49:15] great and we would like your ideas and your suggestions. So if you could just email those
[1:49:20] to me and share with me some of the things that you would like to have additional information
[1:49:24] about, we will compile that and then we will get that before you and we will make subsequent
[1:49:29] presentations as we continue to move forward. And if your item may not make the majority list
[1:49:35] or the time that we haven't allowed,
[1:49:38] we'll still make sure that the individual
[1:49:40] who is the champion of that spends time with you
[1:49:43] to answer those questions and showcases
[1:49:45] and shares the directions that we're going.
[1:49:47] So if that will stand for any additional questions
[1:49:49] or comments that you might have?
[1:49:52] Chris, Tom?
[1:49:53] Oh, I think that's a, is that spot onto what I see
[1:49:57] of the application for our time
[1:49:59] and all the time we put in to have it drive council meetings
[1:50:03] with updates that are maybe not so much the busy work
[1:50:07] but the more significant issues
[1:50:09] that I just can't compliment them enough.
[1:50:13] I do have one update that I think we need to address
[1:50:16] from the council and all Ashan to do that.
[1:50:19] Further back in our plan as mentioned
[1:50:22] about our regional airport and I think
[1:50:24] that it's important that council knows the latest
[1:50:27] on his trip and the results.
[1:50:32] Well, thank you.
[1:50:34] Sean Berger.
[1:50:36] So last week, Bill Carberry and I and Dan Olmsted,
[1:50:43] as a member of the airport advisory board,
[1:50:45] and Jake Rogers with Southern Edo economic development,
[1:50:48] had an opportunity to go down and visit with the team
[1:50:52] at SkyWest.
[1:50:55] We did a similar trip two years ago,
[1:50:59] and really just a chance to kind of check
[1:51:01] and see what's happening within their industry.
[1:51:03] As you know, we have this current small community grant, air service grant through the Federal
[1:51:10] Department of Transportation that's about halfway through that continues until June.
[1:51:17] And through the winter months in particular, about $200,000 of those grant funds were used
[1:51:26] to subsidize service.
[1:51:29] And when you try to come up with the exact answer of why that is, it's a formula about
[1:51:35] this long.
[1:51:36] So it's costs of providing the service, it's fairs, it's boardings, and all of those were
[1:51:47] in various levels of flux.
[1:51:50] One thing I'll point out, winter weather had a significant impact on that number.
[1:51:55] So the cost of operation of the service is calculated from the time the door closes on
[1:51:59] the airplane until the time the door opens on the airplane when you get to your destination.
[1:52:04] So if you're eighth in line to get de-iced in Salt Lake City, you're paying for that time
[1:52:10] while you sit there on the runway and not coming here.
[1:52:13] So anyhow, there are still funds remaining in that grant service.
[1:52:18] It will continue with the four flights, the four brazilia flights per day that we have now,
[1:52:25] which is about 120 seats a day.
[1:52:27] And in June, the plan is to replace that service
[1:52:31] with jet service here in Twin Falls, 50 seat jets.
[1:52:35] So it'll be 100 seats per day instead of the current 120.
[1:52:40] And actually the current 120 is really only 115-ish,
[1:52:47] depending on how much everyone weighs
[1:52:50] and their luggage on the small plane.
[1:52:53] But in talking to SkyWest, the data suggests that 100 seats per day will meet the current
[1:53:01] demand of use of the service here.
[1:53:03] And those flights will connect to large banks of outgoing flights in Salt Lake in a more
[1:53:11] timely fashion than they do currently.
[1:53:13] So for example, if you're on the early flight out now, chances are you will sit on a layover
[1:53:22] Salt Lake for up to three hours to connect to the next bank of flights out of Salt Lake and
[1:53:27] the
[1:53:29] Matching of the schedules according to Sky West will match more closely with the outgoing bank on both early morning flight and the afternoon flight
[1:53:37] But we'll be going out
[1:53:39] You know, it's it's a good news bad news
[1:53:43] conversation the good news is
[1:53:46] Jet service for those who don't enjoy flying on the small planes
[1:53:53] The conversation is that it's a little better connections
[1:53:56] to the flights to get you to other places.
[1:53:59] The bad news is it's two flights now instead of four,
[1:54:03] but it's still service.
[1:54:04] It's like I tell my wife when she points out
[1:54:07] that my hairline is receding.
[1:54:09] I say, or that my hair is getting gray,
[1:54:11] I say I don't really care what color it is
[1:54:13] as long as it's still hair.
[1:54:15] So I do think that it is a little bit of good news,
[1:54:18] bad news.
[1:54:20] Sky West was very.
[1:54:21] I will say that this visit this year, as opposed to two years ago, I think SkyWest was much
[1:54:33] more aware of our concerns, much more accommodating of trying to meet community needs as best they
[1:54:41] could within their business model.
[1:54:45] And we will go from there.
[1:54:46] Now, as I said, this change doesn't occur until June, so the current service will continue.
[1:54:53] We did request that they take a look at perhaps a midday flight turnaround, perhaps subsidized
[1:55:02] by the grant funds, but so the grant contract agreement with SkyWest will be renegotiated
[1:55:08] come June.
[1:55:09] So, I think Bill is probably in that process of beginning those discussions based upon what
[1:55:14] Department of Transportation may say. Does that answer your question?
[1:55:21] Yeah, Ben, I saw Bill back here earlier and I thought he was going to speak to it and he
[1:55:26] laughed, so I thought that you'd be the one to address it.
[1:55:28] Good answer. Good answer. Yeah, absolutely.
[1:55:30] John, I guess I know the answer to this.
[1:55:35] If the jet traffic actually grows the number of people utilizing it because there are a lot of people
[1:55:42] don't like the turboprops and I had the opportunity to ride one of the flights
[1:55:47] that I flew both out and in on this last summer was on the one of the regional
[1:55:52] jets and they're much nicer than those Brazilians. I assume that the grows that
[1:55:58] they start being full at least parts of the year that we might be able to pick up
[1:56:02] that third flight like you're talking about is that what they're the thought
[1:56:04] process or at the risk of speaking for Sky West I will say that they are
[1:56:12] very attentive to our market and and
[1:56:17] Appreciate the business that they get from this market. So we're we're we're a well-performing market for them. I
[1:56:25] Can't I can't say that if the demand is filling the planes up
[1:56:31] X percent of the time that they'll look at adding a jet and that's just a that's just a business decision
[1:56:37] They have to make it was still have to match up with their bank down there to for to make it
[1:56:41] And it has to balance with the rest of the markets that they serve, too, and that was
[1:56:48] a little bit of a concern that we discussed with them is, you know, going from four flights
[1:56:53] to three flights a day with 30 seat planes is only a change in 30 seats.
[1:56:59] Going up to a third flight a day when you're at 50 seat jets is a big leap.
[1:57:04] So it's not like you can say, oh, we're at 110 demand for 100 seats.
[1:57:11] we're going to add an airplane and then have it have 40 seats not full, so I mean that's
[1:57:17] just kind of general economics, so. But again they were very open, they were very inviting
[1:57:23] for the conversation, encouraged us to come back every couple of years and check in and
[1:57:26] visit. One thing they were especially appreciative of was us sharing with them what's happening
[1:57:33] in the region from an economic perspective because they look at data of who gets on airplanes.
[1:57:40] I mean, that's their focus of the area, so it was a good meeting.
[1:57:45] It was encouraging news to tell them, too, that 10 of our 11 communities in the region passed
[1:57:51] school bonds the night before to the tune of $109 million, so they thought that was pretty
[1:57:57] telling of the positive economic climate here.
[1:58:00] Before we move on to anything else on the agenda, I did want to say on the Strategic Planning
[1:58:07] Update, thank you for bringing that.
[1:58:09] Thank you for your staff coming up and making these updates to us.
[1:58:14] It really drives it home.
[1:58:16] All the good work we did on that strategic plan, I say we collectively.
[1:58:21] And I do want to do just appreciate Chris talking to him and he's kind of inspired me
[1:58:28] to keep my focus.
[1:58:29] I think most of our focus is on this plan, but he's a little more insistent on that than
[1:58:35] most of us.
[1:58:36] So I appreciate your leadership on that, Chris.
[1:58:37] I was coming in case you had any questions.
[1:58:40] I had no questions.
[1:58:41] I was just going to compliment you and your team.
[1:58:43] Thank you.
[1:58:44] All right.
[1:58:45] Moving on.
[1:58:46] April, April, then, we can expect the next.
[1:58:47] We will.
[1:58:48] So once a month, what we would like to do is because it is so large.
[1:58:53] Once a month, we will focus on what that's going to be.
[1:58:57] Right now, if I'm thinking about what that agenda looks like, it would probably actually be coming
[1:59:03] Right now, if I'm thinking about what that agenda looks like,
[1:59:06] it would probably actually be coming out sooner than later,
[1:59:09] and probably be the April 7th meeting,
[1:59:13] because on the 14th and the 21st of April is when we're going
[1:59:17] to begin our conversations about the budget.
[1:59:20] And the long-term planning conversation will be on the 31st,
[1:59:24] the 7th makes a really, probably a good opportunity
[1:59:27] to again provide a couple of additional updates on the 7th.
[1:59:30] The 14th and the 21st will be rolling into the conversations about the budget, getting the
[1:59:36] council's thoughts.
[1:59:37] And it was also at those times where we invite the public to come in early to that process
[1:59:43] to share their thoughts also with the council during those meetings.
[1:59:47] So if we could get ideas and thoughts by the 7th, that would be, well, before the 7th, because
[1:59:54] we've got to be here on the 7th, right?
[1:59:56] That would be very, very helpful.
[1:59:59] Thank you.
[2:00:00] Thank you, Travis.
[2:00:01] All right.
[2:00:02] We will move to the next item, which is public input and or items from city manager and city
[2:00:06] council.
[2:00:07] Is there anyone from the public that would like to come forward and address the council?
[2:00:11] I see no one city manager?
[2:00:15] I think I just provided my update.
[2:00:17] You did a fine job.
[2:00:19] Thank you.
[2:00:20] Oh, and turn it over to city council before we get too far.
[2:00:23] I did send an email out.
[2:00:25] I tried to send it last night.
[2:00:26] I ended up sending it this morning, glitches.
[2:00:29] But I wanted to have just a quick conversation, or as long as the conversation council would
[2:00:35] like to have, about the upcoming state of the city.
[2:00:39] And so I just threw some ideas out there because I had a meeting with Travis and with
[2:00:43] Sean regarding this because it's going to be the next state of the city address will
[2:00:48] be held at the Stone House on April 9th at 12 PM.
[2:00:54] Tickets can be purchased at the Twin Falls Chamber of Commerce.
[2:00:58] folks out in the audience at $15.
[2:01:01] But really I wanted to have the conversation
[2:01:03] because we've had several different kind of forums,
[2:01:07] if you will, for the state of the city in the past.
[2:01:10] We've had, where each council member stood up
[2:01:13] and talked about their liaison positions
[2:01:15] and what was going on.
[2:01:18] Of course, we've diminished some of those
[2:01:20] liaison positions this last year,
[2:01:21] but we've also had more of the mayors or the city manager
[2:01:26] city manager really mayor generally stand up and and do a speech about where we are
[2:01:31] and start a process and then the council stands individually for for questions of
[2:01:38] the audience so really what I'm asking from the council what do you want to do this
[2:01:42] year Greg Lanning I'm no longer mayor I think the mayor should do a nice long
[2:01:48] change somehow I knew that was coming from you anyone else in the audience Rebecca
[2:01:54] Thank you Mayor. I've actually enjoyed the years, I think two out of the three
[2:02:00] years that we've done it. It's been kind of based on questions or comments from
[2:02:05] the audience. I really especially liked the year when we had a moderator so to
[2:02:10] speak and of Jill and Kelly hosted it one year and it kind of kept the topics
[2:02:14] going. It kind of provided some structure. But then the questions and the issues
[2:02:20] were really geared towards what was popular among the community, and so, especially as opposed
[2:02:29] to having us all give updates on our liaison positions, I would recommend some sort of structure
[2:02:34] in that way, but that really highlights audience input and community input.
[2:02:41] I really like the question and answer format so that their interest kind of drives what we
[2:02:46] we talk about that way. I think it's more lively and better attended.
[2:02:53] Any other input from council? We've had a couple. Mine was basically the same as Rebecca's.
[2:03:02] I liked that format. I was just wanted to make sure we had a mayor speech at the beginning.
[2:03:07] Sure, yeah. Okay. So is that?
[2:03:12] This is kind of new to me, so who attends this, how do we let the community know?
[2:03:19] Is it just open or how does that work?
[2:03:24] So this is actually part of the Chambers Twin Falls Today luncheon series for the year, so
[2:03:29] it is that event.
[2:03:30] Got it.
[2:03:31] Held in April, it is much more widely attended than our typical Twin Falls Today luncheon,
[2:03:39] that it includes, I would say the majority of the folks there are business people.
[2:03:46] So last year, this is the one that was out at like the background behind elevation.
[2:03:51] Okay, I do remember now.
[2:03:54] Yes.
[2:03:55] Okay.
[2:03:56] And we've done it down at the bottom of the past.
[2:03:58] It is publicized to the general public, so the general public certainly is welcome.
[2:04:03] But it does tend to be a bit of the kind of that audience that we get for our chamber.
[2:04:08] Thank you.
[2:04:09] Any other input on forum, if you will.
[2:04:14] So what I'm hearing is maybe a brief speech at the beginning and then brief.
[2:04:21] I believe I was a brief.
[2:04:24] Okay.
[2:04:25] Thank you.
[2:04:26] And then, you know, and maybe some of the issues, a strategic planning update and how we're going to utilize that for budgeting and our dashboard review.
[2:04:37] some ideas here but really probably the thing that's going to drive more than
[2:04:40] anything else is the update on strategic plan and how we're going to utilize that
[2:04:43] because by that time we will be talking about the budgeting more and more get
[2:04:47] closer to the budgeting so that works yeah and then jump into some Q&A and then
[2:04:53] we'll research some ideas about maybe a moderator we'll see where we'll go with
[2:04:57] there so I think these good suggestions. Chris you have any suggestions?
[2:05:04] Okay, very good. Okay. Yeah, I'll get more air traffic.
[2:05:12] Excellent, sir. Anything else from council? All right. The next item on the agenda is
[2:05:21] adjournment to executive session. I'll read these 67-2345-1c to conduct deliberations
[2:05:30] concerning labor negotiations or to acquire an interest in real property, which is not
[2:05:35] owned by a public agency and executive session 6347-2345-1E, to consider preliminary negotiations
[2:05:43] involving matters of trade or commerce in which the governing body is in competition with
[2:05:48] governing bodies in other states and or nations, Jim, let's go move second, I have a motion on
[2:05:55] by Jim seconded by Chris talking them move into executive session as listed anything
[2:06:01] further from council the island will call both place yes yes yes motion passes
[2:06:18] seven to zero just one dimension we're going into executive session we will
[2:06:23] not be making any decisions within that executive session nor will we be coming
[2:06:28] out and reconvening this evening so with that we will adjourn into executive session.
