Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2014-01-21, recording 1 (started 17:00)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2014-01-21/

[0:02:31] We have Chris come up for your own.
[0:02:33] I'd like to call the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council to order.
[0:02:52] It's January 21, 2014, 5 o'clock in the afternoon.
[0:02:56] Welcome everyone in the audience.
[0:02:58] And as we always do, we start with the Pledge of Allegiance.
[0:03:01] So if you wish to, please join us.
[0:03:04] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
[0:03:16] We have all seven members here with us this evening.
[0:03:19] Our city manager, Traverse-Rothweiler, do we have any amendments to our agenda, sir?
[0:03:26] Mr. Mayor, members of the council, there are no amendments to tonight's agenda, just maybe one correction,
[0:03:33] under the items for consideration on item number seven,
[0:03:37] our agenda sir. Mr. Mayor members of the Council there are no amendments to
[0:03:41] tonight's agenda just maybe one correction under the items for consideration on
[0:03:45] item number seven it says that Chief Brian Pike will be discussing public
[0:03:49] safety tonight that will be done by Captain Anthony Barnhart Chief Pike is
[0:03:54] ill this evening. I'm sorry to hear that but are you sure that Anthony's going to
[0:03:58] do that looks like he skipped out. Okay maybe you'll be doing it tonight.
[0:04:06] We have kind of changed around how we run City Council meetings on the public input side of things.
[0:04:13] We have items for consideration, items of consent on our calendar, and we will discuss those as we go.
[0:04:20] But we're trying to kind of turn things around a little bit to make sure that we engage our public.
[0:04:25] And if there's anyone in the audience that would like to come up and visit with Council a little bit before we get on the agenda,
[0:04:34] be on one of the agenda items because we'll have time to speak about those later.
[0:04:39] We wanted to open the floor for anyone in the community.
[0:04:42] Is there anyone that would like to come up?
[0:04:45] No one's rushing the pulpit there.
[0:04:48] So we'll move on to the consent calendar and turn that over to the council wishes.
[0:04:56] Chris Daukington?
[0:04:57] I've moved a proof of the consent calendar, but I would also like, uh, uh, has to make
[0:05:02] a special awareness that, uh, in the payables this time is almost a million point two and
[0:05:08] construction costs I think is evidence that how proactive our community is in
[0:05:13] expanding looking out for tomorrow and wisely using public funds. Thank you Chris
[0:05:19] we're back in milsoka. I have a question on the counts fable. Could we get a second
[0:05:24] and then we'll go to questions? Second. Sean Barrigar seconds if so Chris
[0:05:29] talked and made the motion and then Sean Barrigar seconded it so we'll turn
[0:05:35] Thank you, Mayor. Just a quick question. On page five of the accounts payable, there's a CH
[0:05:42] Schwam Hill bill for $14,740. It's for odor control northeast sewer engineering and design.
[0:05:49] Travis, can you tell us more about that and what the cost is associated with?
[0:05:54] Yeah, so, and Troy Vitek is here, and so I'm going to ask him to also assist and fill in
[0:06:00] if there's any additional details.
[0:06:03] One of the things that we started to do is there is
[0:06:06] odor control and design, and then often we've been most
[0:06:09] recently having a conversation about the odor control at the
[0:06:12] UASB, and know that the two projects are related in their
[0:06:16] treatment of odor, but the CH2M Hill piece under design is
[0:06:21] not necessarily associated with the UASB component, but it's
[0:06:25] designed to install odor control units along the collection line from the northeast sewer
[0:06:34] line and going all the way to the wastewater treatment plant.
[0:06:39] Because of the length of the flow, the oxygen in the solids goes away and that is what causes
[0:06:49] the odor.
[0:06:50] What we're doing is developing a series of odors scrubbing units along the collection
[0:06:55] to get rid of the odors.
[0:06:57] Two, did you just do this?
[0:07:06] But we are looking at two locations.
[0:07:08] One is at the corner of Pauline in Eastland from one odors control unit and the other is
[0:07:12] down in the canyon.
[0:07:14] This is just preliminary design.
[0:07:15] You're going through those efforts.
[0:07:16] Once we get done with that, then we'll possibly construction contract.
[0:07:21] This is all part of the facility dollars and part of the tenant they have to get in
[0:07:29] It is being paid for with tax increment financing and part of the TIFF project that we've rolled
[0:07:36] forward in the larger Jibani piece.
[0:07:40] The second thing that I would add is we are entertaining a current scope right now for the
[0:07:45] odor control at the wastewater pretreatment facility and the responsibility of who ends
[0:07:53] up bearing that cost at the end will be the responsible party and we've done some really
[0:07:58] good investigations in terms of the water chemistry and the design of the UASB and we'll continue
[0:08:04] those conversations. But collectively we're all agreeing to share in that scope so that
[0:08:09] we can mitigate the issue faster and sooner than later.
[0:08:14] Okay. Because we heard about some of those odor complaints and so I was wondering what
[0:08:18] they were, what these costs were associated with.
[0:08:22] Yeah, we they see as to male actually anticipated odor being part of this project
[0:08:26] And so we are pre-acting starting the design before the making bed for next summer
[0:08:33] temperature goes up the central go up and so they
[0:08:38] Did some recommendations to us on how to alleviate that and essentially what Travis said?
[0:08:42] It's a big vacuum unit that takes the odors
[0:08:44] It's some through some sort of media and biologically removes the odors from the air and then exhausts in the air
[0:08:51] So are there odor problems other than the ones associated out on the corner of Hinkins and
[0:08:57] out by the UASB?
[0:08:58] Is there odor in other areas?
[0:09:01] We're concerned that there will be when the flows move forward and that's why, like Troy
[0:09:06] just said, we're proactively addressing the odor along the collection line.
[0:09:13] There have been days in the summer last year where there would be intermittent moments
[0:09:19] of order in some of the neighborhoods
[0:09:21] where the trunk line went through.
[0:09:23] We also had, I believe, a couple of complaints near
[0:09:28] and around the Gary Store section of that property earlier
[0:09:35] this year as well.
[0:09:36] And so part of that is as Chibani's flows go up,
[0:09:40] you're going to see more need
[0:09:43] for these odor control items in place.
[0:09:47] Okay, so it does originate from the Chobani flow,
[0:09:50] the order situation.
[0:09:52] It originates from the line.
[0:09:54] We don't want to credit the problem and the issues necessarily
[0:09:57] with Chobani because there could be a series of mixings
[0:10:01] of different flows along the way that could be causing a flow
[0:10:06] imbalance in terms of the chemistry.
[0:10:10] But the idea is is to make sure that the odor units are
[0:10:14] effectively removing the odor regardless of the chemistry
[0:10:16] that's flowing in the drug lines.
[0:10:19] Okay.
[0:10:20] I just want to make sure that as you're talking about the responsible party pays for it and
[0:10:26] that that's not the general rate payers of Twin Falls.
[0:10:30] So in this $14,700, is that coming from the general rate payers or?
[0:10:36] No, this is part of the tax increment financing bond that was sold as part of the overall urban
[0:10:43] renewal chibani tax increment package.
[0:10:46] Okay.
[0:10:46] Good question.
[0:10:47] Greg Lang.
[0:10:48] And again, I'm just a just a little bit, if I remember when we went on the tour of the
[0:10:55] facilities in John Teake, he took us down to the water pumping place down in the canyon.
[0:11:02] I'm sorry.
[0:11:03] He actually, there was somebody was getting into the sewer trunk line right then and so
[0:11:09] after he dropped us, he went back to see who that may be and that was actually siege to
[0:11:13] him, he'll employees.
[0:11:14] Because that has also been well before Chibani, occasionally an odor-producing spot
[0:11:20] They're on our trunk line and so he they were they were actually testing the odor at that particular day to see what the level was
[0:11:27] So I think this has been an ongoing problem
[0:11:29] that
[0:11:30] On occasion problem especially summertime
[0:11:34] Thank you, Greg. Chris talking to just that field of the fire at Troy, please correct me if I'm wrong
[0:11:39] but proper aeration from the time the wastewater flow and
[0:11:43] enters the stream anywhere in the city to it's ultra-multreatment is always a
[0:11:48] matter of balancing the oxygen to demand the aeration. This is not something that's
[0:11:53] caused solely by Chabani. It comes from every residence, every commercial user,
[0:11:59] and sometimes the lines degrade or they get into situations where you start
[0:12:04] reducing the amount of oxygen and the other overcoo and multiply. I'm not Charlie
[0:12:10] off-based on that I don't think I'm it is and this truck line also has Kimberly
[0:12:14] attributed to a two-footage area so it's chirping experience it elsewhere throughout
[0:12:19] the city and there's some areas of other concern. In Kimberly's not the source of
[0:12:25] the odors either. Okay so we don't want Larry Hall the city administrator is
[0:12:31] joining us this evening we we certainly don't want you know to start casting stones that are
[0:12:36] good neighbors to the east. Welcome to Twin Falls. I'm looking out at John right now John.
[0:12:44] Any other questions regarding this council? That was a good question. They were good questions.
[0:12:49] Thank you. Leila, roll call vote please. Sean Berger. Yes. Chris Tockington. Yes. Greg Lanting. Yes.
[0:12:56] Don Hall. Yes. Rebecca Milseika. Yes. Suzanne Hawkins. Yes. Jim. Yes. Motion passes seven to zero.
[0:13:03] Before we move on to items consideration, I do want to introduce a couple folks in our audience
[0:13:08] this evening. They're our neighbors from our east, Kimberly. We have a City Councilwoman Nancy Duncan,
[0:13:14] as well as City Administrator Larry Hall from Kimberly. So welcome tonight, folks. Moving under
[0:13:20] items for consideration number one is a presentation by the Twin Falls futures
[0:13:25] unlimited group regarding the future development and growth up Twin Falls is
[0:13:30] the presentation no action necessary but Brad Willes welcome it Mr. Mayor members
[0:13:38] the council maybe if I could just maybe set the tone of Brad's presentation forum
[0:13:43] so as we've been very successful in our economic development efforts one of the
[0:13:49] things that became very apparent to us as we began navigating through the Cliffbar project
[0:13:56] was the fact that we were running out of developed ground for the next industrial company
[0:14:03] or large commercial company that may want to come to our community.
[0:14:08] And it was also about that same time where the City of Twin Falls had completed its strategic
[0:14:15] plan where it talks about and Brad's going to share this, talks about exploring and creating
[0:14:19] new areas for opportunity and growth.
[0:14:22] And we had sold the city's wastewater treatment plant bond that really opened up opportunities
[0:14:27] for growth and expansion.
[0:14:29] And so it really began a conversation about what can we do in a public-private partnership
[0:14:37] and from asking the question, which is really the only role that the city has had in this,
[0:14:43] is what can we be doing to ensure that when those future
[0:14:47] opportunities present themselves, that we are in a position
[0:14:51] to be able to take advantage of them.
[0:14:54] Brad and a series of individuals that
[0:14:57] are called the futures group that Brad will probably
[0:14:59] share in his presentation have been meeting.
[0:15:03] I want to describe as regularly.
[0:15:05] I don't attend their meetings, but I
[0:15:07] think saying regularly is probably appropriate.
[0:15:11] trying to come up with a series of concepts for you to explore, investigate, and possibly
[0:15:19] move forward so that we are in a position to take advantage of future opportunities as they
[0:15:24] may present themselves.
[0:15:26] And so with that, I just wanted to maybe have a good understanding or prove that, provide
[0:15:30] to the council how the conversation came to be.
[0:15:33] And with that.
[0:15:34] Thank you, Travis, and again, welcome, Brad.
[0:15:38] Thank you.
[0:15:39] So, my name is Brad Wills, address and all that, okay, so.
[0:15:44] So, like Travis said, back in the summer time when the talk was
[0:15:56] that we had somebody that could possibly be taking the last
[0:15:59] of the industrial land, didn't know who that was,
[0:16:03] and you know, you guys all keep good secrets,
[0:16:05] so I never did know who it was until they announced it.
[0:16:09] So in September, Travis had reached out to a few
[0:16:15] developers just to have them look at the town in general.
[0:16:19] So we decided that we'd do an organized effort to do that.
[0:16:22] So we met for the first time in September.
[0:16:26] There's 12 of us, Gerald Martins and Fran Florence,
[0:16:34] Rich Divers, Todd Blass, Ken Stutzman, Gary Nelson, Gary Wollerton, James Ray, and myself.
[0:16:49] So we've been meeting, we've been about 10 or 11 times since that time.
[0:16:54] And at first we're trying to figure out what we were going to do as a group.
[0:16:59] And so our goal here was to work like Travis is on a private, public partnership here, that
[0:17:08] we were not going to have the hats on as developers, we're going to have the hats on as community
[0:17:14] leaders knowing this is our specialty is development, trying to foresee where development is going
[0:17:21] and knowing the consequences is we have to run a sewer line, that kind of stuff.
[0:17:27] So in doing that, Evan Robertson said, you know, you ought to look back because there
[0:17:32] was a group of guys.
[0:17:34] So back in the 1960s, 63, 64, there was a group of 31 businessmen that were all downtown people
[0:17:45] and that was when the Blue Lake Small, I think, was just there and the city was, the downtown
[0:17:49] district was looking kind of bleak.
[0:17:53] So a bunch of these names you'd recognize, you've got Rudy, Ash and Brenner, Don Jensen,
[0:18:03] Howard Allen, Earl Faulkner, John Roper, Hudson, Curtis, senior.
[0:18:10] So what they did is they started buying up parking lots and to do that they started a
[0:18:15] corporation called Twin Falls Futures Unlimited Incorporated and they bought up a lot of the
[0:18:21] parking lots that were downtown behind there. And to do an urban renewal back then, the city
[0:18:28] had to contribute 25% of the funds to do it and the federal government would give the 75%.
[0:18:34] So all that mixed together, the businessmen gave the land to the city as their contribution.
[0:18:42] So at that point in 1970, there was a three-day celebration and we had the new mall.
[0:18:48] Let me ask you a real quick question that gives me history to those parking lots
[0:18:52] So the parking lots were prior to that owned by the businesses
[0:18:57] Great different individuals and stuff pieces of the parking lots. Yeah, and so we give some context to yeah the discussion about
[0:19:05] Yeah, so so when we were looking for some type of group name
[0:19:11] We decided that that was appropriate because you know, we've had business plus but now we've got another group of
[0:19:16] local people that want to look into what can we do for the City of Twin Falls. So that's our story.
[0:19:23] So when we wanted to do this, we've been working as developers and it was good to go back and look at your strategic plan and actually read it and see how we applied to it.
[0:19:38] So it was a little easier to get started than we kind of worked backwards into it.
[0:19:45] But our goal was, so the first objective is to explore
[0:19:55] Sustainable.
[0:19:59] Amazing.
[0:20:01] It's, gosh, that really is hard to read.
[0:20:06] Employee sustainable.
[0:20:07] So it says the city will employ sustainable land use policies.
[0:20:13] It's initiative E is an echo, C is in Charlie 1.2.
[0:20:18] I will assist Brad.
[0:20:20] Okay, he's got it in front of him now.
[0:20:24] So the city wants to, would like to employ sustainable land use practices.
[0:20:29] So one of those is not to leapfrog and we've kind of done that pretty well with development.
[0:20:33] We try to, you know, to infuse grows on to itself and stuff.
[0:20:38] So we're doing a pretty good job on that.
[0:20:40] The other one is, encourages the maintenance of agricultural production on lands as we phase
[0:20:45] them.
[0:20:46] And we've actually been doing a lot of that.
[0:20:48] The tax law helps us also to do that, because it's
[0:20:52] advantage to keep that under ag.
[0:20:54] So we may do developments, but as we phase it, we'll keep
[0:20:57] farming that land as long as we can.
[0:21:01] And then the last thing is update the development codes.
[0:21:04] And that's going to be one of the things we're going to do
[0:21:07] in the future here next month.
[0:21:08] We're going to have another developers meeting like we've
[0:21:11] done in the past with city staff and the developers to start
[0:21:14] going through our codes, looking at areas that we can maybe do it better or save money
[0:21:22] or you know when we were really busy we did a lot of changes but now that we've slowed
[0:21:28] down we've got a little time to look at it we're going to go ahead and do that.
[0:21:36] So this one of our other things that in your list was to expand utilities to support economic
[0:21:43] development around the airport.
[0:21:46] So we'll go ahead and look at that.
[0:21:48] We haven't looked very deep in that, that wasn't a very high priority, but that is something
[0:21:54] to look at down the road if we have an industrial park, you see around the airport.
[0:21:59] We have some pretty major infrastructure issues to get there if you talk to Jackie, Chris talking
[0:22:04] to.
[0:22:05] Greg, I think you and I talked about a little bit, and I think that we need to get a gas
[0:22:09] line out there.
[0:22:10] The question is, do the utilities drive the growth, or does the growth request become available
[0:22:18] if the utilities are extended to the airport,
[0:22:21] and I'm speaking of wastewater and water, too.
[0:22:25] Well, you can extend an urban renewal area out there.
[0:22:30] Actually, you can back up.
[0:22:31] You could annex the airport.
[0:22:33] It's legal to annex your airport property,
[0:22:36] even if it's not attached to your city
[0:22:39] and create an urban renewal area.
[0:22:40] But those questions need to be asked.
[0:22:44] So that's the whole purpose of our group, is to start.
[0:22:47] Well, let's ask it, let's do the next thing and start moving along.
[0:22:51] I apologize for calling it Greg.
[0:22:53] No, Greg, an honest mistake.
[0:22:57] So your next goal was to expand opportunities for business.
[0:23:01] And one of those is develop and maintain an inventory of industrial buildings and sites.
[0:23:07] The buildings we can't do a lot with, but we can do the sites.
[0:23:10] And that's kind of where we set our sites, in fact, is where are the next areas
[0:23:15] that Twin is going to grow.
[0:23:16] and I'll follow up with that.
[0:23:19] And then the last one was that the city will serve
[0:23:23] as the focal point for economic development.
[0:23:25] Can you pass forward a little bit, bro?
[0:23:27] Thank you.
[0:23:30] So you guys are the leaders.
[0:23:33] You've done a really good job.
[0:23:35] It's not broken, doesn't it be fixed?
[0:23:37] All we can do is come alongside and do that partnership
[0:23:42] to pursue those objectives.
[0:23:44] And so our objectives are economic development,
[0:23:47] making those things possible.
[0:23:52] So when we did this, we started with industrial,
[0:23:55] but we actually looked at the whole site,
[0:23:58] and we looked at residential first.
[0:24:00] So I did my own little chart here with Excel,
[0:24:06] doing a population study, your strategic plan goes to 2030.
[0:24:14] So I just took the population of what we had,
[0:24:16] and if you look back, the growth rate for twin
[0:24:19] between 1975 and 2005 average 2.5.
[0:24:24] In the earlier part of the 70s and early 80s,
[0:24:27] we were growing at almost 2.9%.
[0:24:30] Then we went to 2.5 and then we kind of tapered off
[0:24:33] at the end there.
[0:24:35] But in the last 10 years, from 2000 to 2010,
[0:24:38] we've been growing at about an average of 2%.
[0:24:41] So 2% I think is conservative, giving the opportunity
[0:24:46] that we're seeing.
[0:24:48] But if you take these numbers, another number that really came up that kind of shocked me
[0:24:56] is the home owner rate in Twin Falls.
[0:25:00] So that's the rate of, I guess, single family homes is 60% in Twin Falls.
[0:25:07] The state average is 70.
[0:25:10] Multi-family housing is 25% in Twin Falls and 15 in Idaho.
[0:25:17] So, if you look at the population, the average household has 2.6 people, you divide that by
[0:25:28] the population, times the 60 that tells you how many homes you should be doing.
[0:25:33] So, according to my chart, we should be doing about 217 homes, 217 homes here.
[0:25:40] We did 192 this year.
[0:25:42] We kind of faltered in December.
[0:25:44] I was hoping we'd make it over 200, but the numbers that we used to see were we had permits
[0:25:50] that were 660 and 550, that ain't going to happen again in twin.
[0:25:56] I don't see that ever really happening.
[0:25:59] I think that got actually pushed into several years because we went down under 100 permits
[0:26:04] here two years ago.
[0:26:07] If you have a, if we actually grow at two and a half percent, that goes from, by that
[0:26:13] time, of 4300 homes to 5700 homes, and if we're able to get the 70 percent, which is the average
[0:26:21] homeowner rate, you know, that, so we have some pretty good opportunity.
[0:26:25] But the interesting thing is I was sharing this with Travis, that number right there, and
[0:26:31] so you had a, you know, falls as well with an S, but.
[0:26:37] So as that goes up there, your projection on your strategic plan, all the information
[0:26:44] you had was 66,470 and I was 65, eight, so we were within 600.
[0:26:55] So I think these numbers are pretty accurate, but the other part that kind of is a head scratcher
[0:27:00] is if we're 25% multifamily, that means we should be doing 90 apartment units a year to
[0:27:10] be keeping up with our growth to feed these employees that are coming and stuff.
[0:27:17] I know we're not doing that.
[0:27:19] It's hard to look back because you don't keep numbers on multifamily in such a way that we
[0:27:25] we could look back over many years to see where we are.
[0:27:28] But, you know, next year we've got Idaho Housing Planning
[0:27:32] a 60 unit over on the northwest side of town.
[0:27:35] But if you look at all around the city,
[0:27:39] we're just not building entry level,
[0:27:41] we're not building every family.
[0:27:47] Great.
[0:27:47] Brad would like, I think of some multi-family going in
[0:27:53] on park where they're building all those four plexes,
[0:27:56] that be considered of the numbers?
[0:27:58] And even a duplex would be.
[0:28:01] Because aren't they putting it, he's putting them like six right there.
[0:28:04] Yeah, TKO is doing that.
[0:28:05] And then there's some other ones, but you know, we're not even.
[0:28:08] But still wouldn't be, we're 90.
[0:28:10] OK.
[0:28:10] All right.
[0:28:11] Thank you.
[0:28:16] It's kind of interesting on that.
[0:28:17] Stay with that percentage of homeowner rate.
[0:28:22] So I took kind of a survey of a lot of different cities around the state.
[0:28:28] Here's Idaho's average is 70 right here.
[0:28:32] Of the cities that I looked at,
[0:28:34] 60, quarter lanes less than we are.
[0:28:37] But everybody else is kind of a little bit higher.
[0:28:41] Kimberly is about 90%.
[0:28:45] There isn't just looking at the number of households
[0:28:47] that are in the city with that population.
[0:28:50] It works up there.
[0:28:51] And then I've just guessed in 5% on the multifamily
[0:28:54] because there was just really no way to figure that.
[0:28:57] You look at EGLE's bedroom community, 82.
[0:29:02] I've always felt like Caldwell and Napper
[0:29:05] are kind of similar cities.
[0:29:07] And so, you know, we're all a little bit lower than we should.
[0:29:12] Part of that, I think, is our wages are a little lower.
[0:29:17] People can't afford the homes they rent.
[0:29:20] And then the other part of that right now
[0:29:22] is we're not seeing the single family entry level
[0:29:25] south of town like we were.
[0:29:28] Sean Berger.
[0:29:29] Brad, does that take into consideration
[0:29:34] homes that are not within a city limits?
[0:29:37] So for example, we have a lot of development
[0:29:40] east of town in the county.
[0:29:43] We have a lot of development out in the curry area
[0:29:46] in the county.
[0:29:47] Would that have some impact on these numbers?
[0:29:51] I mean, it doesn't have the impact on these numbers.
[0:29:53] I appreciate that.
[0:29:54] But if you have a city that has most of their development
[0:29:58] within a city limits and very little outside compared to us or even Kimberley.
[0:30:04] I mean, there's a lot of development around Kimberley that isn't in Kimberley.
[0:30:09] Is there a way to get to those numbers or is it irrelevant?
[0:30:11] Well, I don't know.
[0:30:19] I got those from the census and some Travis is going to help me.
[0:30:24] Travis?
[0:30:25] So I was just going to share the same thing.
[0:30:26] So those numbers shouldn't surprise us because those were the exact same numbers that we had
[0:30:30] conversation about during our strategic plan and they came from the Census data. It also
[0:30:36] was reflected in our community survey. Really, the only way would be to probably do more of
[0:30:43] a hand count and produce some sort of documentation or report on your own because the Census is
[0:30:52] just going to look at specific geographic area and it's only going to include the city.
[0:30:59] So for us to probably build an area of influence, if you will,
[0:31:03] of single-family homes, you're probably going to be doing
[0:31:05] a lot of hand-counting and probably spending a lot of time
[0:31:08] in the assessor's office and the recorder's office
[0:31:10] looking at plats.
[0:31:18] So Twin Falls right now is set to grow in five areas,
[0:31:23] we believe.
[0:31:25] We've been looking at the south part.
[0:31:27] We have two basins.
[0:31:28] We have a southeast base and southwest base.
[0:31:30] And we've been working on this basin
[0:31:32] for eight to 10 years with multiple developers.
[0:31:35] There's a lot of infrastructure issues
[0:31:38] that are related to that out there.
[0:31:43] There's land that's purchased in the Southwest.
[0:31:46] There's really only a couple subdivisions,
[0:31:49] Fez-a-Mettos and then the Magic Valley Ranch
[0:31:52] that were on this side,
[0:31:53] but there's a lot of other land that's purchased there.
[0:31:56] Someday we see the Hancans barrier break in some way
[0:32:01] in some way that twin will grow that direction,
[0:32:05] but for right now that's not,
[0:32:08] in the near future we're not seeing that yet.
[0:32:11] You know, the Northwest has really been,
[0:32:13] and the West right here have been
[0:32:16] probably the busiest this year.
[0:32:19] You know, there's a group of subdivisions out here,
[0:32:22] and then there's room to do here.
[0:32:23] So what I did is I did a study,
[0:32:26] it's a little hard to see,
[0:32:27] but taking the land that is either final plated, preliminary plated, or a drawing in
[0:32:37] one of our engineers offices, there's almost 4,500 lots that are planned on the land that's
[0:32:48] ready to be developed.
[0:32:51] There's about 700 lots still in that little area that's north of the hospital with those
[0:32:57] series of five subdivisions in there. There's a group of subdivisions, you know,
[0:33:02] prime point, broad more. A whole bunch of subdivisions, there's almost a thousand
[0:33:10] lots that are designed in there. The southeast basins about 1,800 lots and then
[0:33:17] there's a smaller area here that's Wilson Grove area that has about 5,000
[0:33:22] lots and 500 lots. There's some more growth on the east side here, about 200
[0:33:28] lots and then there's maybe 100 lots scattered. So if you go back to this number in 2030 based
[0:33:38] on 2% growth with our 60% that's 4,300 homes. So if you go forward we've got enough homes,
[0:33:48] probably enough land under design to take care of our residential needs to 2030. So other
[0:34:00] than the will serve issue, we're pretty well in pretty good shape. Will serve is probably
[0:34:10] the biggest issue is this area. We are out of Will serve south of town. There's enough
[0:34:16] major infrastructure issues to go in there that's kind of been keeping that from probably
[0:34:23] expanding much. There are about 120 lots still left south of town and at the rate we're going
[0:34:30] south of town that that lasts us a long time because we're just not seeing the
[0:34:34] growth that direction. Well I got your audience here a couple issues so I talked
[0:34:43] to Travis a little about this. You're in the process of working on impact fees and
[0:34:50] I did a study in the state and I took all the cities that are 5,000
[0:34:56] population are above and of those 32 cities about half of them have impact fee
[0:35:03] and the average fee is $2,000.
[0:35:05] Our fees are roughly 17.
[0:35:06] So our impact fees are pretty much in line.
[0:35:09] But when we get into the entry level housing on the south part,
[0:35:14] town even $2,000 is a lot of money to, for somebody to buy it.
[0:35:19] The other part that you're working on a facility plans
[0:35:22] with your sewer and my other, the reason I did that study was
[0:35:26] connection fees, a fee that's paid for water and sewer
[0:35:29] to hook into the system, not to lay a meter out there
[0:35:33] with a back hole, but just to hook into your equity
[0:35:36] buy into your system.
[0:35:38] And the average, OK, Twin Falls is around 1,300
[0:35:44] for both of those.
[0:35:46] The average is 6,000 in the state.
[0:35:49] Hayden, City of Hayden is the highest at 15,000.
[0:35:53] But what that does is that just knocks off that entry level,
[0:35:56] and especially in a community like ours
[0:35:57] that we don't have the incomes.
[0:36:00] And so people are barely getting into that issue.
[0:36:05] One of the legislative issues, the Homer exemption,
[0:36:10] if we didn't have the occupancy tax, which
[0:36:14] is allowed when a house is occupied mid-year,
[0:36:20] if a home is occupied mid-year, you
[0:36:23] have to wait until the following year to apply for your Homer
[0:36:25] exemption if the home didn't have one already.
[0:36:28] but on new homes, you can apply for it.
[0:36:30] But the difference in entry levels, like $130 a much,
[0:36:35] which will kick a lot of people out of being able to buy a home.
[0:36:38] So long story to a short point, we're concerned that when you do your facility plans
[0:36:46] that we don't knock those fees up too high, because we will stop residential housing.
[0:36:52] The other part, south of town, we need $25,000, $30,000 lots.
[0:36:58] and lands south of towns only worth $10,000, $15,000 an acre.
[0:37:03] Even at that price to do all the development,
[0:37:05] we can't hardly pencil out a $25,000 law anymore.
[0:37:10] There's enough infrastructure issues
[0:37:13] between the sewer, water, that those issues,
[0:37:19] we're gonna push those costs probably up
[0:37:21] another $4,000 a lot.
[0:37:23] So those are things we'd like to work with the city
[0:37:25] defined solutions to Jackie and Travis and have been working really hard on it for five
[0:37:32] years.
[0:37:33] So it's not something that's new, but we are concerned that when you do connection fees
[0:37:38] that we don't try to reach to the 6,000, you know, that we keep as low as we can.
[0:37:46] So all this to lead us to what we started with, and that's the commercial industrial.
[0:37:57] Shabani is in this area here and so we looked around at where we thought commercial could
[0:38:03] go and where we think should stay residential.
[0:38:07] One area is the airport, industrial park, the city owns land to the north of the airport
[0:38:16] but we do have the sewer line to get out there and there's just a lot of infrastructure.
[0:38:24] Power is not really an issue anywhere in our valley.
[0:38:28] I talked to him with Dan Olmsted in every of the areas that we've talked about.
[0:38:33] I-O-Powers, one ahead of us, and so the gas company says they can get anywhere.
[0:38:40] If there's somebody to buy it, they'll get there.
[0:38:44] So we looked at, this is the corridor with Polline Road that we are seeing some industrial
[0:38:53] uses in other parts and business parks that are buildings that look really good, but actually
[0:38:59] they're manufacturing inside. And so that may be a little bit of the future if you get some company
[0:39:06] that like Chibani, but it can fit in a nice commercial looking building and have a nice parking lot
[0:39:14] and stuff like that, but still it's a use that typically it's just an industrial area. So I'm
[0:39:23] I'm going to back up.
[0:39:25] So when we looked at this, we were looking at traffic,
[0:39:31] trying to keep the traffic from going through twin.
[0:39:34] We looked at the access to sewer and water.
[0:39:37] And so right here is our main access to sewer and water.
[0:39:41] It's down in the canyon.
[0:39:42] And so we're bringing water up and mixing it
[0:39:45] in the water tanks.
[0:39:47] We're solving some of the water on this side
[0:39:49] with your cliff bars planned for the water tank.
[0:39:52] But whatever we do, we've got to get the sewer there.
[0:39:56] There's a lot of land south of town,
[0:40:00] but it doesn't get us to the freeway very easily,
[0:40:04] unless you're going south.
[0:40:07] And we've got to put it through a bunch of already heavy users,
[0:40:11] con agra and stuff.
[0:40:12] And we've got a pump station there
[0:40:15] that would have to be upgraded.
[0:40:18] There's just a lot.
[0:40:18] So we don't think that the south part of town,
[0:40:22] you come across Washington offers much potential. For the short term, three to five years, one
[0:40:31] area that we considered as a group was this area. Here's Chibani, and here's Cliff bars.
[0:40:43] There's about 100 acres right here that could be zoned commercially. It's already, part of
[0:40:50] It's already commercial in the in the con plan, but that's one area that we were thinking for a business park
[0:40:57] You've got this corridor here. So this is this is assumed commercial anyway, but maybe work on that area a little bit
[0:41:04] the other one is
[0:41:06] I mean I talked to Larry back in October about
[0:41:10] whether
[0:41:11] Kimberly
[0:41:12] Could service this area in the near future or if it would made more sense and it would be beneficial for both cities
[0:41:19] for to move the area of impact boundary about a half a mile and open up about 300 acres in here.
[0:41:26] So I talked to Larry in October, again in December. We did we did visit with the land owners here
[0:41:36] just to see we didn't even want to talk about unless they had they didn't just tell us no right
[0:41:42] off the bat. So we have talked to these people but this is an idea that would take care of I
[0:41:50] I talked to Jan Rogers today, and she's just saying,
[0:41:54] we got to find someplace, because we're
[0:41:56] going to get called here.
[0:41:57] We're going to see things doing a national campaign.
[0:42:01] They've got a company in New York working on that.
[0:42:03] We're going to tell our national story on maybe Wall Street
[0:42:06] Journal and stuff.
[0:42:06] So we may be getting those calls, but we don't have anywhere
[0:42:11] to put them.
[0:42:11] We have some 40 and 50 acre parcels that are around there,
[0:42:15] but we don't have any 100 acre, 200 acre.
[0:42:20] So that was just an idea, but it would take working with the city of Kimberly and working
[0:42:27] through those issues.
[0:42:28] So that was one issue.
[0:42:33] Really what we think is the best solution in the long term for Twin Falls Industrial.
[0:42:40] So this is the Pulline Bridge.
[0:42:44] This is the old hospital.
[0:42:46] You've got your sewer down here that falls in down to the treatment plant there.
[0:42:52] We've got water here, here, here, here, and this is rock creek and so your
[0:42:59] Area of impact stops at rock creek right here. So this is this is land that doesn't have any
[0:43:07] It's not filers. It's not anybody's and this is pulling right here
[0:43:12] So we think there's three areas here to look at
[0:43:17] There's there's going to be a commercial corridor that's naturally blending out of Twin Falls going this way with 93
[0:43:25] going down and with being there for freeway access this way. The hospital is
[0:43:33] right here, the gravel pits here. This is a kind of a natural place. The only problem is
[0:43:37] it can't get sewer there very easily. And then this area is also a good area,
[0:43:43] because it's got the railroad that goes through it here. We're seeing with
[0:43:49] climp bars, they carried where they were. And when you drive out Addison, you know,
[0:43:54] You're going past the gravel pit by the CCC,
[0:43:58] by the, as my son used to call it, the car cemeteries.
[0:44:05] And if we could somehow sewer this area,
[0:44:11] you were on the city council years ago,
[0:44:15] I don't know how long ago, five years ago,
[0:44:18] had some foresight to ask the highway district
[0:44:21] to design a sewer and water line across the line.
[0:44:24] and that was really, really had some foresight.
[0:44:29] Great planning.
[0:44:30] We'll give credit to Jackie for that one.
[0:44:32] Okay.
[0:44:33] Jackie brought that to us.
[0:44:34] We'll give Jackie.
[0:44:35] And that wasn't cheap.
[0:44:36] No, it wasn't.
[0:44:37] We had to pay some money to have a number.
[0:44:38] It was Jackie's idea.
[0:44:39] It didn't come from up here.
[0:44:40] Yeah.
[0:44:43] So we've got a sewer line here.
[0:44:46] Jackie hates pump stations.
[0:44:47] So wherever we can gravity.
[0:44:49] So fortunately, everything falls towards the canyon.
[0:44:52] So this area here, this is the hospital here.
[0:44:56] So there's a big area here, but we see that as residential.
[0:45:00] Just naturally, we think that'll grow that way.
[0:45:05] But if a person was to put a Chibani line that he just put in
[0:45:11] through this property across the bridge,
[0:45:14] that would open up this area and open up this area.
[0:45:17] This area could actually gravity all the way there,
[0:45:21] according to Google Earth.
[0:45:22] I'm not an engineer, but according to Google.
[0:45:26] This area offers a little bit harder area because you'd have to get across the state highway.
[0:45:35] Problem with this area a little bit is you don't have the railroad, you know, you can
[0:45:38] pence spurs in and stuff.
[0:45:41] So these were just, we think as a group that this is the place to aim in 5 to 15 years.
[0:45:52] And to do that we need to start aiming now, figure out what infrastructure would take to
[0:45:57] get there, how to pay for it. You know, a Chobani right here or just somewhere over here,
[0:46:05] you know, I don't know how far you went on that sewer line, but I think it was six miles.
[0:46:09] It's three miles. It'd be a three and a half mile to get in this area here. We have some
[0:46:18] residential areas to be sensitive about and stuff, so we would, you know, there's a lot
[0:46:23] more works that would need to be done.
[0:46:37] One last thing that we, one of our members brought up, which is a good part, is what happened
[0:46:41] to the bridge. There was a third bridge that was going to go over. I looked back at how
[0:46:48] that happened. That was Governor Kim Thorpe's connecting Idaho. We almost got on the planning
[0:46:56] stage. It was in his budget that budget went to the legislature and they ended up cutting
[0:47:05] the budget right down on February. He was asking for $218 million. They dropped it to $200 million
[0:47:14] and doing that only five projects got dropped and our bridge got dropped. I think this is
[0:47:22] something that we should never forget about. It won't get back on anybody's radar unless
[0:47:28] we keep kind of putting it back up there so that was I think that's a good idea.
[0:47:35] So just a recap in the last thing we were wondering if we could jump the canyon. We have a site
[0:47:41] plan. May or can. I'm not laughing. Just gonna jump the little canyon, right? So just a recap.
[0:47:55] We may have areas that we want you to push the water boundary just a little bit, maybe
[0:48:03] just that an area is growing a little more than another area, but generally speaking we're
[0:48:08] in pretty good shape there.
[0:48:12] I had a formal housing or workforce housing meeting with like three lenders, some realtors
[0:48:18] in the three builders in town and we met and were going to meet again next month to figure
[0:48:25] out how to get that entry-level or workforce housing on the single family, but we really
[0:48:30] need to figure out where we can get the multifamily. We manage rentals and we just don't, aren't
[0:48:39] able in twin to get enough rent to justify building anything new and penciling out unless
[0:48:45] you have some subsidy in the rent. We're going to have to expand the water service boundary
[0:48:53] for industrial and so that that's kind of been a pretty hard solid line and you guys are probably
[0:48:59] the only ones that could break that line because you know the staffs was told you know let's figure
[0:49:05] out and not go beyond that but to draw we're going to have to go beyond that a little bit.
[0:49:11] You know the short term industrial is really important but we're really limited and so
[0:49:16] you know I I invited Larry and the city council from Kimberly to come over.
[0:49:21] there was the perception that you guys were talking about wanting to see take
[0:49:30] that land on to yourselves and so I clarified that last night that that was
[0:49:36] me asking that was none of you guys and so you guys would would be talking
[0:49:43] amongst each other rather than anything darkroom backroom so and the last thing
[0:49:52] is to start down our long-term industrial, you know, if that's where we're going to grow,
[0:49:56] let's figure out what it's going to take to get there. And so that's the end of my presentation.
[0:50:02] We'll probably have some questions. Lights are already popping up, so we'll start with
[0:50:06] Greg and I. Brad, thank you very much for your efforts on this and your group as well. I
[0:50:11] will understand the time it took for you, all of you, to put this gun slip together and
[0:50:16] just the meetings themselves. We appreciate that. Thank you.
[0:50:20] We're not done either. Well, I know that yeah, do we need to get started on you know the expansion of the
[0:50:29] or bound not to not
[0:50:32] Obviously some of the boundaries, but I'm talking about the area of impact boundaries, especially to the west
[0:50:37] Do we need to get started on that now so we do have a?
[0:50:42] Opportunity come along we would be ready for it. Should they like those other areas better?
[0:50:47] I mean obviously the one if we were to go to the east we would have to be working with Kimberly on that
[0:50:51] that one, but is it time to begin that process now with the
[0:50:57] county commissioners?
[0:50:59] You know, I think next year, you were planning on addressing
[0:51:04] your comp plan, redoing your comp plan, I would update your
[0:51:10] comp plan. I think and I think we should be working sooner than
[0:51:15] that. There's a process you have to go through for that. But if
[0:51:20] we identified areas, we could do a comp plan amendment application and go through that process
[0:51:26] to expand outside your area of impact.
[0:51:30] So I think that needs to be talked about some more.
[0:51:36] Identify where we think we want to grow and then we've got landowners, we've got farmland,
[0:51:41] we've got issues that way too that we have to be real sensitive to.
[0:51:46] And we looked at those places we were trying to stay away from residential as best we can
[0:51:51] because some people would invest a lot of money.
[0:51:54] Thank you, Brad.
[0:51:55] Yeah.
[0:51:56] Chris, talking to him.
[0:51:57] Yeah, excellent job, Brad.
[0:51:59] I hope we get a written plan of that.
[0:52:01] As your group taken it to the next step and actually formulated some action items, a short
[0:52:08] medium long term.
[0:52:09] And you mentioned the conflend, that's absolutely essential for us to get dovetailed with the expansion.
[0:52:17] And then the last thing, if we are fortunate to develop some of this industrial area, that
[0:52:23] in turn will grow the demand for a residential growth, so you're going to be out of balance
[0:52:30] with what you see at 2030, but that's the type of problem, I guess, you want the amount
[0:52:35] of drilling.
[0:52:37] So we have plenty of residential land to grow into.
[0:52:43] I guess you're dealing with the plot at lots of that.
[0:52:45] I'm giving you what land was specifically purchased with intent to develop and that a plan has actually been drawn up on those.
[0:52:52] So that's when I did that I knew the name of every subdivision that I put in there, even though it's not a plenary plat that's approved by the city.
[0:53:00] So I guess actually back to an action plan might be the next step for us.
[0:53:04] So short answers no, because we wanted to come to the city council,
[0:53:11] what we're thinking, what we're doing, and see what your input is before we go any farther with this.
[0:53:17] So that was the purpose of working up to this point, meeting with you guys, getting your inputs,
[0:53:25] and then go off again.
[0:53:29] We see a lot of opportunity, and we're not all altruistic here.
[0:53:36] I mean, this will help the title businesses,
[0:53:40] it'll help the development business.
[0:53:41] I mean, we will all benefit as developers,
[0:53:45] but we really worked hard to take that hat off.
[0:53:49] And if we find landowners that want to let us help them
[0:53:54] change their use on their land,
[0:53:56] we're gonna offer that service,
[0:53:58] not to purchase a land from them,
[0:54:00] not to take any control,
[0:54:01] but if we see some things happening,
[0:54:04] get proactive there and maybe help them do some zoning change and stuff.
[0:54:09] Rebecca Milsoka.
[0:54:10] Thank you, Mayor.
[0:54:11] Just a couple of thoughts.
[0:54:16] I like your comment in bringing up the third bridge.
[0:54:18] I think that's something that's been long forgotten and maybe we should be pressing forward
[0:54:23] and more vocal about it.
[0:54:26] One thought, you mentioned some aspects of the strategic plan that you were focusing
[0:54:32] on and a huge part of the strategic plan is also to encourage urban infill and to discourage
[0:54:39] sprawl.
[0:54:40] And so that's the only advice or comment that I would have on the plan is that the south and
[0:54:46] west, you know, as you mentioned there are some obstacles there, but overall our community
[0:54:51] has seen less new development in those areas and that tends to feed into the degradation
[0:55:01] or so on, of the communities and the areas, the roads, everything gets less attention.
[0:55:07] And so, I mean, what better areas to work in than the areas that actually need to see
[0:55:13] some new development?
[0:55:14] You mentioned, you know, just some of the appearance or something of that west side of
[0:55:18] Addison, but I think what better place to redevelop and to invest in our community?
[0:55:25] I personally would like to see more implementation of urban infill and discouraging that urban
[0:55:32] sprawl because it's costly to the citizens, it's costly to everyone.
[0:55:36] When we sprawl out further towards Kimberley or further towards the north and the development
[0:55:42] in the east and the north areas has been positive and it looks great and it's added to the quality
[0:55:51] of life in those areas but I would hate for us to forget the south part of town and the
[0:55:56] west part of town which you know really that makes us a better city and a more robust city
[0:56:01] and the citizens in those areas I think would be much appreciative for us to turn our attention
[0:56:07] there and as you mentioned you know it will be the city council that determines where the
[0:56:11] future growth is and so I just would hope that we would focus on areas that need new development
[0:56:18] and need some urban infill to kind of revive those into towns.
[0:56:22] Otherwise, in the future, you're going to be dealing with social problems
[0:56:25] and infrastructure problems and other issues in entire neighborhoods of a city.
[0:56:30] And we definitely don't want that.
[0:56:32] We don't want to create slums or low-income areas where our city is not beautiful.
[0:56:37] The areas where, you know, we're not going to take economic development suitors.
[0:56:41] You know, we're not going to show them those areas.
[0:56:43] My suggestion would to just be proactive and not allow those areas to develop because we're
[0:56:50] paying attention to them and we're allowing new development to come and obviously it's
[0:56:55] going to take someone who's invested in this community and who's brave, you know, much like
[0:57:00] St. Luke's downtown.
[0:57:01] They were the first to invest, but they've seen much success in people following them and
[0:57:07] And so I would just encourage us to also incorporate that aspect of the strategic plan.
[0:57:13] So fortunately for Twin, the way infrastructure works, we do kind of grow out and we don't
[0:57:21] reach out too far because that infrastructure costs us so large.
[0:57:27] And the other part of this is we're going back and replacing lines that 30 years ago
[0:57:34] would be nice if we upgraded at that point.
[0:57:37] So that's the other thought here, whatever we're doing here we want to make sure that
[0:57:41] we're putting the bigger lines in.
[0:57:43] I didn't mention one thing south of town that would really help and all you residents of
[0:57:48] this area hope you vote for the school bond, but the thought is to put a middle school south
[0:57:54] of town and I think that would really help that area.
[0:57:58] So.
[0:58:00] Brad I just want to tell you in your group, thank you for the work that you're doing.
[0:58:04] It's absolutely appreciated.
[0:58:07] The more I know about economic development, the more I know that government has a place,
[0:58:12] but private folks.
[0:58:13] Private industry has a bigger seat at the table to help drive that.
[0:58:18] And we need your input.
[0:58:19] We need your vision.
[0:58:20] And just like our forefathers there, the Faulkner's and all those folks that came for
[0:58:26] us and had that vision and helped lead us, and that's what we need to hear.
[0:58:32] So I just want to thank you for that.
[0:58:35] I've got two more lights. Travis, Sean Berger.
[0:58:39] Brad, I do want to thank you and your group for the work you've done on this.
[0:58:43] One, can we get copies of this presentation sent to us?
[0:58:47] We can have that information.
[0:58:49] Second, I know you're wanting some feedback and some input from us.
[0:58:53] Truthfully, I think if I tried to offer that right now,
[0:58:56] I would talk about how all of this makes sense,
[0:58:59] but I think you want more direction than that.
[0:59:02] So I need a little bit of time to think through this
[0:59:06] and kind of understand some of the consequences
[0:59:09] and impacts that you've talked about,
[0:59:11] but would like to get back on that soon.
[0:59:13] Because I agree with you,
[0:59:14] I don't think we can wait around for another year
[0:59:16] to start thinking about starting a plan
[0:59:19] to address something,
[0:59:20] because we'll be three years down the road then
[0:59:22] and still with nothing.
[0:59:24] So again, thanks for the information
[0:59:26] and I'm looking at the cops that, I think it'd be helpful.
[0:59:30] Thank you, Brad, I appreciate all the information.
[0:59:34] I've thought a lot about economic development and what directions the city to go and you
[0:59:39] guys brought up some good points that I hadn't considered like access to the interstate and
[0:59:44] some of those transportation needs.
[0:59:47] So it gives me something to think about because I was always in favor of moving towards the
[0:59:50] airport but I can understand how that could be even more difficult with some of the roads
[0:59:55] let alone the underground infrastructure.
[0:59:58] And as Sean said, I too would like to take a look at this
[1:00:02] in more detail and see where you're going.
[1:00:04] But I'm very supportive of all your efforts.
[1:00:06] And if there's anything I can do to lend support to your group,
[1:00:10] I'd be very interested in doing so.
[1:00:14] Thank you, Suzanne and Travis.
[1:00:16] So one thought would be to have the city staff begin
[1:00:21] to actually work with this group,
[1:00:24] where we could develop maybe a series of action plans
[1:00:26] that later collectively both the Twin Falls Futures Group
[1:00:30] and the city staff could present in more of a unison approach.
[1:00:34] As we look at what is it going to take to expand water service
[1:00:38] and sewer boundaries?
[1:00:40] What is the steps taken to adjust the area of city impact?
[1:00:45] What are those intricate steps that need to?
[1:00:47] So maybe we could spend some time with this group
[1:00:50] and then we could bring back a series of proposals
[1:00:53] and processes that need would need to take place
[1:00:56] for your ultimate consideration as we move forward.
[1:00:59] Thanks, Travis. Rebecca.
[1:01:01] Thank you, Mayor. A couple of comments just regarding that idea.
[1:01:06] I would hope that the process would still maintain its objectivity
[1:01:12] as an interested group coming forward and presenting
[1:01:16] so that we would give fair consideration for the citizens
[1:01:19] want to comment or participate in that, that would be my one comment on having staff and
[1:01:28] this group because I appreciate that you're wearing your different hat and you're thinking
[1:01:33] of the future of the community but they're also a conflict of interest because of financial
[1:01:37] interest.
[1:01:39] So I would think it would be a good idea to keep it a little bit more objective.
[1:01:44] A second unrelated issue, I just wanted to ask a question of Bill Carberry from the airport as we're talking about growth possibly out at the airport.
[1:01:53] I have a question regarding that.
[1:01:59] Ladies and gentlemen, just while Bill's walking up here, I just want to let you know we have a public hearing scheduled for six o'clock.
[1:02:06] What that means is it won't start any earlier than six o'clock.
[1:02:09] We are on item number one of seven items before that.
[1:02:13] However, I'm going to pull the audience here in a few minutes because there's a couple items on here that are really centered around public input.
[1:02:21] So I want to get the public in and out of here as soon as possible so you don't have to sit through all the rest of the stuff that we go through.
[1:02:29] Unless you really want to.
[1:02:30] We'll give you that option.
[1:02:32] So, Bill?
[1:02:32] Thank you.
[1:02:35] Thank you.
[1:02:35] So my question is about the growth and development around an airport.
[1:02:40] that there have been communities in the past where once residential and other things spring
[1:02:44] up, they've actually had that hinder their airport and their ability to increase their
[1:02:51] airport.
[1:02:52] So my question is, do you see any issues or will you be thinking about and preventing
[1:02:57] any possible conflicts for the develop if we decide to go towards the airport and develop
[1:03:04] towards the airport?
[1:03:05] for the question is an excellent question.
[1:03:08] Compatible land surrounding land uses with airports are critical.
[1:03:14] And the airport has been in a position
[1:03:16] where we've got a very favorable surrounding land use.
[1:03:19] It's agricultural, residential, and extension
[1:03:22] of utility boundaries past the low line canal
[1:03:26] has sort of been the line in the sand.
[1:03:28] I think there's been concerns with recharging aquifers
[1:03:31] and things like that.
[1:03:32] So yes, I think the airport and the airport community
[1:03:34] and the city and county should be very mindful
[1:03:37] of any encroaching incompatible uses now.
[1:03:40] Could be arguable whether we define residential that way.
[1:03:44] But I think it's something we certainly want to be mindful of.
[1:03:47] Okay, thank you.
[1:03:48] Thank you, Bill.
[1:03:49] And again, thank you.
[1:03:51] We're going to move on to the next item
[1:03:52] and actually do a good direction.
[1:03:55] Oh, do you, okay.
[1:03:58] Sean Berg.
[1:04:00] So I heard Travis sort of make a request of us
[1:04:03] and then we didn't want to give them direction on that.
[1:04:06] So I would agree with his comment
[1:04:10] that I think it would be very valuable for city staff
[1:04:12] to participate, to offer guidance and direction
[1:04:17] on what it might take to do some of these bits and pieces.
[1:04:22] The same as individual staff works
[1:04:23] with an individual developer now,
[1:04:25] as they're looking at a specific development.
[1:04:29] And gather that information with more data for us
[1:04:34] And bring that back to a public forum for us to to review that and and take a look at that
[1:04:39] And maybe even take some public input at that point
[1:04:42] But I think for for this group to say we think it would be X Y and Z to do a sewer line out here
[1:04:49] And then have city staff turn around in the back end and say that's never gonna happen
[1:04:52] That's you know sort of defeats the purpose of that group going ahead. So I would recommend that we
[1:04:58] Direct staff to participate in that discussion and bring that back to us. Yeah, I think that's
[1:05:04] the first part of the action plan I was alluding to.
[1:05:06] Let's see what the concepts are and attach some
[1:05:10] rough numbers to it as well and how they might or might not be
[1:05:14] financed.
[1:05:15] But that would sure be a first step and make sense.
[1:05:19] That makes sense to me.
[1:05:20] The rest of the council, if I can get a kind of a head nod.
[1:05:23] All right.
[1:05:24] Give you direction?
[1:05:26] Council?
[1:05:26] Very good.
[1:05:28] Pulling the audience here, how many are here
[1:05:30] to discuss the faculty media jumping the canyon issue.
[1:05:36] How many are here for the mobile food concession
[1:05:42] public hearing?
[1:05:45] I'm thinking that we're gonna move right into
[1:05:47] the public hearing portion of the consideration.
[1:05:52] So we're going to move down to item number four
[1:05:56] under public hearing.
[1:05:58] It's consideration of a request to adopt ordinance 3059
[1:06:02] amending city code 3-18 regarding city issued permits for mobile food concessions.
[1:06:10] And I have Mitch Humbold's name next to this and so Travis I need some guidance.
[1:06:15] Mitch is another cache of the an illness that took place so I'm going to ask Mr.
[1:06:23] Wonderlick who has been working very closely with Mitch Humbold on this to maybe provide
[1:06:31] thought and comment. One of the things that I will state just so that the Council is aware
[1:06:36] at any point in this conversation after the public hearing and after that process that you
[1:06:42] want to adopt an ordinance. We do need to have the ordinance read three times, have the rule
[1:06:48] suspended and have it moved to third and final reading. Even though we've had the conversation
[1:06:53] three different times, we've never had those official readings to declare it. And so it's
[1:07:00] is something that if you choose to enact an ordinance this evening those rules of engagement
[1:07:06] need to be followed. And that's all I can really offer on this one. I'm going to turn over to
[1:07:11] Fritz now.
[1:07:12] Turn over to our city attorney Fritz Wonderlet. Ladies and gentlemen those of the just came
[1:07:18] in. We are moving ahead in the agenda a bit. We're going to the public hearing which states
[1:07:23] that it starts at six or beyond. And if you are interested in speaking at the public hearing
[1:07:30] I would ask that you would sign up in the back of the room so that we can do this in an orderly
[1:07:35] fashion.
[1:07:36] So, turn it over to...
[1:07:37] Correct.
[1:07:38] Yeah.
[1:07:39] So, you've discussed this.
[1:07:44] I'm going to call it a food track ordinance twice before.
[1:07:48] I think the version that you have before you now is also the one that you saw last time.
[1:07:52] It contains the changes that you asked for during the first meeting of the month.
[1:07:58] So you have before you now the proposed ordinance.
[1:08:02] I think you've, I think this was advertised for public hearing.
[1:08:06] You've got people here before you.
[1:08:07] So I think at this point, take your public hearing.
[1:08:11] And then if there are additional changes to be made to the ordinance, we can talk about
[1:08:16] those.
[1:08:17] If not, as Travis has said, for actual adoption of this, the best way to clean this all up
[1:08:25] is to if you're going to adopt tonight is placed on third and final white
[1:08:30] title only by suspension.
[1:08:33] Thank you, Chris.
[1:08:35] Travis, did you have something you wanted to add to that before I open it up?
[1:08:38] Just Mr. Mayor, members of the council, we did not have a sign of sheet at the
[1:08:41] back of the table.
[1:08:42] And so what we would ask is that if individuals would maybe come orderly
[1:08:46] and sign their name for the record and that often is part offered as part of
[1:08:50] the record, we'd appreciate it.
[1:08:51] So you want them to sign as they speak, please.
[1:08:53] Okay.
[1:08:54] So this is how we're going to handle it.
[1:08:56] I'm going to open up the public testimony portion of the hearing.
[1:08:59] That's a time that you come up.
[1:09:01] You ask questions.
[1:09:02] You give us input.
[1:09:04] We generally don't respond right to you right then.
[1:09:07] We take notes.
[1:09:08] We try to keep track of your questions.
[1:09:10] And then at the end we'll respond to your questions because you'll have two minutes to testify to this evening.
[1:09:16] And this is with us.
[1:09:18] And Suzanne Hawkins, our vice mayor to my right will have a little 32nd card that she'll hold up.
[1:09:23] Don't freak out when you say that it's 30 seconds and we don't throw rocks at you if you go over a little bit, okay?
[1:09:29] So be patient with us. So we are going to now open up the public testimony portion of our hearing and
[1:09:38] Ask folks in the audience that would like to come forward to bleed please do so now come on
[1:09:46] I saw some hands come up before so don't nobody wants to be first. Yeah, don't leave me hanging
[1:09:50] So we're gonna give you just a second
[1:09:52] You can go ahead and write your name and your address.
[1:09:54] And then if you'd repeat that for the record,
[1:09:56] that's when we'll start the time, sir.
[1:10:18] Travis, why don't we take that sign up sheet
[1:10:20] and actually put it in the back of the room,
[1:10:22] and then they can be signing it up
[1:10:23] as this fine gentleman speaks to us.
[1:10:26] So.
[1:10:27] [Muted for privacy: street address]
[1:10:29] [Muted for privacy: street address]
[1:10:33] [Muted for privacy: street address]
[1:10:36] from planning and zoning last week,
[1:10:39] Everything in my eyes looked pretty good.
[1:10:43] The only thing I had a question on was the mobile
[1:10:49] and motorized food concessions on private property,
[1:10:52] section C number four.
[1:10:55] It says the application must include site plan
[1:10:57] and written permission from the property owner
[1:10:59] to allow the operation of the concession.
[1:11:03] All site plans shall be reviewed
[1:11:04] by the planning and zoning department.
[1:11:07] My question to that is, would this be in a mobile setup?
[1:11:11] We don't always know where we're going to be,
[1:11:13] because it's just, if something's going on
[1:11:15] and I can get permission for a Saturday morning,
[1:11:18] then I'm going to go set up there.
[1:11:21] Do I need to get with planning and zoning?
[1:11:24] You know, it could be on a weekly basis,
[1:11:27] is my thought.
[1:11:28] I just, you know, it depends on what's going on in the area.
[1:11:31] There's times that we have more stuff happening
[1:11:34] on a weekend on the south end of town,
[1:11:36] which is more of an industrial area, versus the shopping and whatnot on the north end of town,
[1:11:41] bringing a lot of outside residents or outside people into the area.
[1:11:48] So, and I can submit a list of a bunch of different places, but I can't guarantee where I'll be.
[1:11:58] Very good. So, what we will do is we'll answer that question in just a few minutes.
[1:12:03] If you keep track of that, Travis, anything else further this evening, sir?
[1:12:07] I believe that's all I have. Like I said, everything else looked pretty good. I'm impressed with it.
[1:12:13] Perfect. Thank you, sir. Thank you very much.
[1:12:16] Next person that would be interested. Just here to listen. Just here to listen.
[1:12:30] What else? Okay. So what I'm going to do, go ahead. I think you still have some time, Justin.
[1:12:41] Oh, it starts over.
[1:12:44] Good luck with that. Do I need to repeat my name?
[1:12:47] Okay, with the $100 annual permit, what, I guess what I'm getting at is it's not really stopping.
[1:13:03] This goes back to the revenue discussion from a couple weeks back.
[1:13:09] If it's local citizens with food trucks in their community, they are supporting the community.
[1:13:17] If a food truck from Boise decides, you know what?
[1:13:19] I'm going to twin for a day or a weekend or a week.
[1:13:23] They take that money that they made in our community back.
[1:13:27] They're still making the same, paying the same $100 comment,
[1:13:31] but nothing is staying in the community.
[1:13:35] Is there option for maybe regulating them a little bit
[1:13:40] in this permit?
[1:13:41] Charging them more, you're asking.
[1:13:43] Yes.
[1:13:44] Make it a little more difficult.
[1:13:45] I haven't personally checked in to say me going to Boise,
[1:13:49] but I would expect it to be a little different than the locals
[1:13:53] because I'm taking money I make from there
[1:13:55] and bringing it back here.
[1:13:57] So.
[1:13:57] It's a good question.
[1:13:58] That's all.
[1:13:59] I promise.
[1:14:00] Thank you.
[1:14:00] Yeah.
[1:14:01] I'll hold you to that.
[1:14:04] Again, the public testimony portion of the hearing
[1:14:06] is still open.
[1:14:07] So if there's anyone interested.
[1:14:11] Sam, you're raised your hand.
[1:14:12] Don't you want to come up?
[1:14:17] He guilt of you, didn't he, Sam?
[1:14:24] I'm Sam Sides.
[1:14:25] No, just in reading it, I was very impressed.
[1:14:28] I thought that the City Council did a very good job.
[1:14:31] And there was really nothing there that I thought was unreasonable.
[1:14:36] Or I think this gentleman brought up
[1:14:38] some phenomenal points as well.
[1:14:42] I did look at some other cities kind of just kind of compared.
[1:14:47] This would be adding.
[1:14:48] The only thing I thought that could maybe ensure a little more
[1:14:50] safety, a lot of cities require first aid kits, not only fire extinguishers, but first
[1:14:59] aid kits and why not on their food service vehicles, you know, just for safety benefit.
[1:15:07] You never know somebody could be harmed and I'm not saying they're taking the liability
[1:15:11] for that, but there is liability, but you know, a simple first aid kit could address
[1:15:14] safety and just visibility, so also they're visible, so to avoid any accidents, but that
[1:15:21] only thing I saw that maybe was missing from a Twin Falls City standpoint but my
[1:15:26] compliments to the City Council on drafting a well-fied document. Thank you
[1:15:32] Sam and we don't want to take all the credit for that we helped but it was city
[1:15:38] staff and public input that did that. Anyone else in the audience? Come forward
[1:15:45] Matt and we're gonna go back to signing up while you're here I guess.
[1:15:52] Actually, why don't you introduce yourself, state your name, and then maybe sit down and
[1:15:57] sign and take someone else's answer.
[1:15:59] [Muted for privacy: street address]
[1:16:00] [Muted for privacy: street address]
[1:16:06] [Muted for privacy: street address]
[1:16:15] It talks about the hours being between 7 a.m. and 10 p.m.
[1:16:20] With extended operation being approved with a special use permit.
[1:16:25] Would that special use permit be a one-time only permit?
[1:16:30] Or would it be for the annual term of the concessionaires permit?
[1:16:38] We'll answer that question in just a few minutes.
[1:16:41] Okay. Anything else?
[1:16:42] along the lines of like the food safety if if there's any consideration for
[1:16:48] operators having food handler certification to verify they know
[1:16:52] food safety rules that might be something to consider as well. Thank you very much
[1:16:57] for your book. Anyone else from the audience? I'm going to close the public
[1:17:06] testimony portion of this hearing and turn it over to council for questions and
[1:17:12] or answers and any clarification that may be said to staff what to make.
[1:17:17] For instance, if you could help us with those questions first.
[1:17:21] I'll try.
[1:17:23] I'm Mr. Abramowski's first question about if he's going from place to place.
[1:17:28] I think we could probably establish some sort of procedure,
[1:17:32] maybe even by email where he could provide that information to Sharon
[1:17:36] and we could move that through.
[1:17:38] I know it might be difficult if he goes somewhere different
[1:17:41] every single week. I guess we're not sure how to deal with that.
[1:17:46] Whether we can charge more for out-of-city versus in-city,
[1:17:54] we can only charge a fee that is related to the cost of administering the program.
[1:18:02] So that's by law.
[1:18:04] Yeah. There is a possibility if you wanted to charge more for those on public
[1:18:12] property versus private property if you wanted to look at that as sort of rent or or lease of the city's property you could charge more
[1:18:20] for that part of it, but the
[1:18:24] The license fee by itself you cannot
[1:18:28] The special use permit if you get a special use permit for a certain location
[1:18:35] That's last forever. It's not just a single line
[1:18:39] So you get a location, but it's always going to be a particular location.
[1:18:44] In some places, seven to ten, or beyond seven to ten,
[1:18:49] won't matter because it might be completely in a commercial area.
[1:18:52] Another one might be right next to or surrounded by a residential
[1:18:57] in a way that neighbors probably would not like that continued activity after 10 p.m.
[1:19:04] So we can't tell them they will get the special use credit.
[1:19:07] It would be available.
[1:19:08] So that's a consideration that would be part of the decision-making that once it's open,
[1:19:13] it's always open.
[1:19:14] Yep.
[1:19:15] Okay.
[1:19:16] And I'll let you guys address first aid kits and food handler safety certificates.
[1:19:21] Okay.
[1:19:22] Well, I do have a question about food handler safety.
[1:19:24] Obviously, they have to get a certificate from health district.
[1:19:27] Yeah, I assume that comes with the health district.
[1:19:32] Sharon is shaking her head, yes, if they do.
[1:19:36] So, again, I think you turn over to us the first date.
[1:19:42] Yeah, thanks Fritz.
[1:19:43] So then did you have a question?
[1:19:45] Okay.
[1:19:47] Oh, I'm sorry, Chris, you're like, what's the question?
[1:19:48] Yeah, look, I was following up with your input, Fritz,
[1:19:52] so emailing when they move around.
[1:19:55] If a vendor had a regular route, let's say it does
[1:19:58] in the round town, but he does not sure at the time,
[1:20:01] why not just apply that list?
[1:20:03] And if there's anything added to it,
[1:20:05] Yeah, they could do that what I'm suggesting is it's simply
[1:20:09] Amendment to their existing permit, and they're just saying okay. I want to add another place to my list of places that I visit
[1:20:17] Here's the address here said a PDF of that
[1:20:22] the permission by the property owner and then
[1:20:25] Once that's approved they're good to go good
[1:20:28] Just for the audience say you know that we're in the middle of still asking questions we can ask folks from
[1:20:35] that testified or anyone in the community
[1:20:37] are in the area here to come up and ask questions.
[1:20:40] In a few minutes, I'll be closing all of that.
[1:20:42] It'll be just deliberation.
[1:20:43] We can't take any more input from the public and or staff.
[1:20:48] Other than clarification questions
[1:20:50] from our legal councils.
[1:20:51] Jim.
[1:20:52] Thank you, Mayor.
[1:20:53] And the only thing I was really, you know,
[1:20:55] when I was talking the other day about bureaucratic insanity,
[1:20:58] one of the issues was this building side deal,
[1:21:00] this building plan or the site plan.
[1:21:02] And so if I'm if I have a food truck and it's Friday at 5 and a private property owner
[1:21:09] says Jim come down here tomorrow morning at Saturday morning at 8, how am I going to do
[1:21:15] that legally?
[1:21:16] See, that's just ridiculous.
[1:21:20] In my opinion.
[1:21:21] I'm sorry.
[1:21:22] I think there's got to be some that the site plant things really got me bugged.
[1:21:25] Isn't there something in the code or in this ordinance without me looking it up?
[1:21:30] says they have to stay by the setbacks and all that. That's already in there. So who
[1:21:34] cares where they park on the lot as long as they don't violate the setbacks
[1:21:37] or deal? If I were parking the back a lot, I'm trying to get my head around that. Are
[1:21:41] we worried about mud or are we worried about what are we worried about? I think part of
[1:21:46] it is making sure that we have a copy of the private property owners permission
[1:21:50] for them to be there. That's the hint. The site plan is mildly interesting but the
[1:21:55] private property right and we just want to show up you're probably going to have
[1:21:59] the cops called on if you show up on somebody for the next day.
[1:22:02] In my experience.
[1:22:03] There's one to look at.
[1:22:05] And many times it's probably not a problem at all,
[1:22:08] but I can imagine some people proposing to set up on a lot.
[1:22:12] And it's going to create a terrible problem
[1:22:15] for getting in and out of the lot, because they didn't
[1:22:17] think it through before they set up their food track.
[1:22:21] So the ordinances for the unreasonable person.
[1:22:25] Yeah.
[1:22:26] Well, it's all regulations.
[1:22:28] I did. Okay. Well, I just think we need to have I need to bet this out a bit. So thank you
[1:22:35] I got some involved in Jim's question. I'm not sure. I remember what mine was
[1:22:41] I'm an afterweight I forgot I've lost it. Sorry Rebecca Mills like
[1:22:46] Thank you mayor. I would agree with councilman. Munn. You know the site plan for me isn't really a deal breaker and it does seem a little bit
[1:22:55] cumbersome
[1:22:56] and maybe
[1:22:58] slightly beneficial, but I'm not sure the benefit outweighs the bureaucracy of it.
[1:23:05] Similarly, I still question the value of requirement M, I think it's on page four.
[1:23:13] The motorized or mobile food concessions vehicles, seating, trash cans, and all of their items
[1:23:17] and equipment associated with the food concession shall be removed from the site at the end of
[1:23:21] each day.
[1:23:23] I guess my question is I don't understand the value of that.
[1:23:26] I mean, I don't know if it proves anything to have the vehicle move or not.
[1:23:31] My other question is who's going to regulate it, who's going to enforce it.
[1:23:34] Our code enforcers, I'm under the impression work during the day.
[1:23:39] I'd really hate to see them.
[1:23:41] Have to work overtime just to regulate whether a vehicle moves or doesn't move after 10 PM.
[1:23:49] And I'm not sure there's a real value to the business owner or the community.
[1:23:53] I mean, I don't think moving actually proves anything,
[1:23:57] nor do I think that a mobile truck sitting there
[1:24:00] for so many days in a row makes it a building.
[1:24:03] You know, that's really not my interpretation of the code.
[1:24:05] I don't think that just because it doesn't physically move
[1:24:08] every night, it doesn't make it a building.
[1:24:10] And the code doesn't read that, you know,
[1:24:13] food, mobile food trucks become buildings
[1:24:15] and are automatically subject to Title X improvements.
[1:24:20] Anyway, it just seems a little bit cumbersome
[1:24:22] And I'm not sure that that's the goal here.
[1:24:25] So I actually do have a question of, I know Mrs. Dingwall
[1:24:29] has commented on this in the past.
[1:24:33] And Mrs. Dingwall, you can say no.
[1:24:35] But I do have a question.
[1:24:37] Is it still your concern not having
[1:24:40] to move the truck every evening?
[1:24:44] Or are you now in support of this?
[1:24:47] Ms. Dingwall, could you come forward?
[1:24:51] I think we have your address from last time, so you're OK.
[1:25:00] Rosalie, Dean Wall, I am concerned about having to move
[1:25:05] every single night, although I will tell you the person that
[1:25:07] was going to rent this and has wasted six months of his money
[1:25:12] has backed out because he cannot sit and play with this game.
[1:25:16] But I think it's, as you say, kind of a cumbersome situation
[1:25:21] to be messing around with every single night to shift this thing
[1:25:25] And the pick up, if the property owner says it's okay to leave that garbage can there,
[1:25:31] if it's okay to leave this thing here, if it's okay to park there for the week,
[1:25:36] maybe he would move once a week or something.
[1:25:39] I don't know, but I really do think it's off the camera for someone to do it every single night.
[1:25:46] Thank you.
[1:25:46] Thank you.
[1:25:47] And Rebecca, did you have another question?
[1:25:48] I thought you had a question at the beginning.
[1:25:51] I just made a comment to, you know, concur with Councilman Munn
[1:25:55] on his issue with the site plan.
[1:25:56] I'm not convinced that's necessary, but.
[1:25:59] Very good, thank you.
[1:26:01] Greg Lani.
[1:26:02] This will be a question for Sharon.
[1:26:05] I mean, we're, maybe, Fritz, what was our fee previously?
[1:26:10] We're going to a $100 a year fee now.
[1:26:13] What was it previously?
[1:26:14] $25 a quarter.
[1:26:15] Right, because somebody did call me and asked me about that,
[1:26:17] say why is it going to $100?
[1:26:19] I said, well, I think it's actually staying the same.
[1:26:21] It's just one fee for the year or other $25 quarter, all right.
[1:26:24] Thank you.
[1:26:26] Sean Barrow here.
[1:26:29] So the ordinance we have only speaks about the items that
[1:26:32] are being amended in this particular section of code, correct?
[1:26:35] There's other stuff in the code.
[1:26:37] So as I look at section 318-5, we have
[1:26:45] a process for non-mobile food concession
[1:26:48] stands, a permit process for non-mobile food concession
[1:26:52] stands.
[1:26:53] So to Rebecca's point of why does the thing have to move
[1:26:58] every night because if it doesn't move every night,
[1:27:00] it's not mobile in my mind, in my definition.
[1:27:05] So if it's not gonna move all the time,
[1:27:07] then it's a non-mobile food concession stand.
[1:27:12] And we have a different process
[1:27:15] for that review, correct Fritz.
[1:27:19] Fritz is looking at it right now.
[1:27:21] If he's trying to get on the internet, I can't.
[1:27:23] So I've been trying to look that same one up myself.
[1:27:26] Maybe you suck them all the way.
[1:27:28] I had to go off the Wi-Fi.
[1:27:30] OK.
[1:27:31] Well, 3G.
[1:27:32] Yeah.
[1:27:32] That's a good thought.
[1:27:33] We'll take that down there.
[1:27:46] Mayor, can I respond really quickly?
[1:27:48] Well, Rebecca, we have a few in front of you,
[1:27:51] so we're going to let them go first.
[1:27:52] That's only on public property?
[1:27:55] OK.
[1:27:56] I was just going to say I don't think they're
[1:27:57] allowed non-mobile by our code.
[1:28:08] So we don't have a provision for it non-mobile food stand
[1:28:12] on private property.
[1:28:14] Unless it's a function of that business or the fruit stand in front of the place that sells
[1:28:23] the fruit inside or something like that.
[1:28:26] Okay.
[1:28:28] Jim, Mom?
[1:28:30] Well, I mean, the 800-pound gorilla in the room is this, there are these mobile food, or
[1:28:36] these trucks that sit in a parking lot forever and never move.
[1:28:42] That's the 800-pound gorilla in the room.
[1:28:44] They're not mobile, I mean, they're a car or a motorized vehicle, but they never move.
[1:28:50] And the rub becomes really, as you talk to restaurant tours in this regard, is that these
[1:28:55] people are bifur, they're skirting all the rules and regulations that am I required to
[1:29:01] do to have a restaurant.
[1:29:04] That's the deal.
[1:29:05] They're going around the law because they never move.
[1:29:11] And now I'm talking like a bureaucrat, but I'm just saying that you really can't have it both
[1:29:18] ways. You either have a restaurant, you have a car that's a restaurant. It's like having
[1:29:24] a train box car in a parking lot. It's a vehicle. So, to Mrs. Dingwald, I mean, you just can't
[1:29:35] have it both ways here. It's either a mobile food truck or it's a restaurant. It's just
[1:29:41] got to move. So that's why I'm struggling with this. And I just, I don't think, I just don't
[1:29:46] think you'd have it both ways.
[1:29:48] Great lining again. Well, when this goes back to, I'm glad Sean looked that one up. One of
[1:29:56] the other, one of the person actually was talking in both directions on this to me that
[1:30:00] called me, and they were asking about the fee, the same person asked about the fee. They're
[1:30:05] They're also a grocery store owner who has owned a lot that they allow food truck to
[1:30:11] set up on who's been there about a decade.
[1:30:15] But they send them, why am I not getting protection from the fruit stand next to the
[1:30:21] first, I don't know, farmers national bank on polling that sets up and sells fruit every
[1:30:29] year in competition to me and that they they wanted the same rules to apply across the board if they're going to
[1:30:36] play and their person had to move they wanted the the mobile food concession non-mobile food concession stand which is
[1:30:45] the thing and is that covered in another spot in our code because that that's obviously not public property that's
[1:30:51] obviously private so wrestling between frets and Travis answering this question yeah we do have an exception
[1:30:58] for agricultural products that are sold by the grower, I think that reads, that's an
[1:31:09] exception, it's actually an exception from the transit vendors. So the transit vendors
[1:31:14] are like the pottery people that used to set up in the payless lot, all those that you
[1:31:18] don't see anymore, you will still see periodically in various places agricultural products and
[1:31:25] That's because you allow that in your code.
[1:31:27] Okay.
[1:31:28] That was a nice bill to call in back and explain that to you.
[1:31:31] That there is an exception for agricultural products
[1:31:34] by the owner.
[1:31:35] I'm just wondering if the one that used to set up
[1:31:37] in front of Fred Meyer, which is actually,
[1:31:41] I don't think that was by the owner.
[1:31:43] Travis is reminding me that we do that
[1:31:45] because it falls under the right to Farm Act,
[1:31:48] which you have nothing to say.
[1:31:49] Oh, okay.
[1:31:51] That's what you wanted to say.
[1:31:52] So we have no authority.
[1:31:56] So is it a taco, an agricultural product?
[1:32:01] Did he grow all the products?
[1:32:02] That's a good answer though.
[1:32:05] Thank you.
[1:32:05] Appreciate the answer.
[1:32:06] That is the distinction I can call back and tell them
[1:32:08] the sticks.
[1:32:09] Dave, do you have anything?
[1:32:10] No, I'm sorry.
[1:32:11] You know, I just want to weigh in.
[1:32:12] It sounds like most of the rest of the council weighed in.
[1:32:14] And I certainly don't want to be a bureaucrat either.
[1:32:17] But I'm trying to look at this fairly.
[1:32:20] And first of all, I want to apologize to this steam wall because this has taken so long.
[1:32:25] And we shouldn't take this long on these issues.
[1:32:29] We should be more responsive to our public, if it all possible.
[1:32:32] And I'm sorry that you lost the business regarding that.
[1:32:38] I believe that mobile food truck means mobile, that it needs to move.
[1:32:43] Maybe I'm not so hung up about moving the garbage cans and I do see that place behind, you're
[1:32:50] talking about Swinsons.
[1:32:52] Behind Swinsons with the cover,
[1:32:55] so people have a play in the picnic table,
[1:32:57] have a place to sit in the shade out of the weather,
[1:33:01] I get all that.
[1:33:01] So maybe I'm not so concerned about that portion of it,
[1:33:05] but I think over and all,
[1:33:07] this is a good direction that these folks need to move
[1:33:12] and not skirt, whatever people have to do, I get that.
[1:33:17] that. So I think this has been well drafted and in support overall.
[1:33:23] What's your zap?
[1:33:25] It just brought back to mind when this all started a few weeks ago, we discussed possibly
[1:33:29] having restroom facilities and stuff and we decided not to do that because the people
[1:33:34] that stop at these mobile food vendors get their food and leave. So to me, that means
[1:33:40] the seating, the cover, I think it's nice. But if the idea is mobile and people are going
[1:33:45] to you and you're not going to provide a restroom and a place to wash your hands and
[1:33:48] all the other facilities. I think the tables and the cover should go to. Sorry.
[1:33:55] Well that's okay. We have a differing view of that. Chris talking to me. I'm going to change
[1:34:00] direction of questioning just a little bit. I think we're so eager to find an
[1:34:06] accommodation that we're violating some of our own city internal city work
[1:34:11] standards. I'm still concerned about dropping a 20-day permit process down to 10 business
[1:34:17] days. Why don't we drop it down to 10 for every business with a permit like this? Or why
[1:34:25] don't we make it two days? Because 10 days are certainly bureaucratic. I see no rationale
[1:34:30] going from 20 to 10, unless you apply it across the board for like type of operations. And
[1:34:37] it's really without consideration of the city work staff who would get the idea to sit
[1:34:41] around for 19 of the 20 days and do nothing and then hurry it through the last day.
[1:34:46] I just can't buy into the rationale for that.
[1:34:51] That's my only comment just to throw us off there.
[1:34:53] But I would really argue that a taco is an agricultural product as opposed to pottery.
[1:34:59] Okay?
[1:35:00] It's a restaurant.
[1:35:01] They were the agricultural, they had to have grown it themselves.
[1:35:05] Chris?
[1:35:06] So there'd be no farm letting, no people that were hard to work in.
[1:35:13] There was only a family that was able to operate the farm then.
[1:35:16] They couldn't have a hard hand then.
[1:35:18] I don't buy that.
[1:35:20] But you got off target there.
[1:35:23] For what I would have further you don't like still.
[1:35:26] You like still answer.
[1:35:28] I'm glad I have a light and beyond that for this discussion.
[1:35:33] So I saw some folks in the audience that wanted to come up.
[1:35:36] The public testimony portion is not.
[1:35:39] If we wanted, we gave you plenty of room.
[1:35:42] So I sure appreciate that you'd like to,
[1:35:45] but at this stage, I'm about to close the public hearing
[1:35:50] and turn it over to Council for deliberations
[1:35:53] unless Council has any other questions
[1:35:54] that they might want to ask.
[1:35:56] And the audience members are city staff,
[1:35:58] and then I will remind city council
[1:36:00] that if we do want to adopt this tonight,
[1:36:03] that we have to go to third and final.
[1:36:06] Clarify that again, Travis.
[1:36:07] We haven't done any readings.
[1:36:09] We have to read three times from this point on,
[1:36:12] if we don't go to third and final.
[1:36:14] You've had a first reading.
[1:36:18] But I think it's important that you follow the step.
[1:36:21] Our process has always been as an organization
[1:36:24] that we would receive an ordinance,
[1:36:26] we would go through a process
[1:36:27] and we would suspend the rules.
[1:36:29] Because of that, we never had an official reading of the ordinance by the title.
[1:36:34] And so because of that fact, what we need to do is we need to treat it as though we're seeing it for the first time.
[1:36:43] And follow that process that we typically do.
[1:36:46] And this is the second reading tonight.
[1:36:49] We technically have not hearing tonight.
[1:36:53] Yeah, this is the fourth, I believe, evening that we've had the conversation.
[1:36:57] And I don't believe that a official declaration of reading has taken place at any of those.
[1:37:04] Certainly been vetted, certainly been well discussed, but we just failed to read the title of the bill.
[1:37:12] Thank you very much.
[1:37:15] Rebecca Mills, sorry.
[1:37:16] Thank you, Mayor.
[1:37:17] So the public testimony part is still open if we had a question.
[1:37:21] No, the public testimony is gone.
[1:37:23] The asking the public is absolutely still open.
[1:37:26] Okay, because I did see someone who wanted to speak and since I had asked someone else if they wanted to speak out with the gentleman in the blue shirt, I was interested in what he had to say.
[1:37:36] Please come up.
[1:37:37] That's a, I'm going to go ahead and open up the public test moment portion of the hearing again because that's what we're doing then.
[1:37:44] So it's reopened.
[1:37:46] Sir.
[1:37:47] Thank you.
[1:37:48] Thank you.
[1:37:49] the resident of those temples.
[1:37:52] And a quick question about Section 2B,
[1:37:58] just trying to clarify that if it applies to my business.
[1:38:04] I recently started selling ice cream on the street.
[1:38:11] And on Section 2B, it says that I
[1:38:16] I have to get consent from the business where I would run it.
[1:38:23] If someone calls me, do I need to get consent from them to park and
[1:38:29] attend my customers?
[1:38:32] That's one question.
[1:38:34] On section 3A, it's unclear to me if it is going to be $100 for
[1:38:44] each quarter or annual.
[1:38:46] So that's...
[1:38:49] Good question.
[1:38:50] Thank you.
[1:38:51] Thank you.
[1:38:52] Thank you.
[1:38:54] Justin, would you like to
[1:38:55] pour it again?
[1:38:56] You told me you were done.
[1:38:59] Sorry.
[1:39:00] I don't
[1:39:02] currently know how this works.
[1:39:05] I don't have more.
[1:39:06] I don't really have a question.
[1:39:08] I just statement.
[1:39:09] And I'd like to propose a solution to the
[1:39:13] the notifying of location that we're going to be going because if I get a phone call at
[1:39:19] six o'clock on a Friday night from a business on it and says you know what I'm having a
[1:39:25] grand opening deal tomorrow for my ski shop I'd like you to be there at eight o'clock in the morning
[1:39:31] and where we can't get a hold of anybody what about getting a written permission slip from
[1:39:39] the property owner and having that on file. Even if the city says okay August 1st and December 15th,
[1:39:50] these are due and then you know where we're at. That way if an inspector whoever manages this
[1:39:58] throughout the city they show up and say you know I heard that you were over here. Yeah I have a permit
[1:40:03] I have the permission slip right here.
[1:40:06] I don't know that it's 100%,
[1:40:08] but it definitely saves the city staff from overtime
[1:40:12] and trying to chase a mobile truck.
[1:40:18] Another thing, you know, I go down on Main Street
[1:40:22] on Wednesday nights throughout the summer,
[1:40:24] the 24th of tonight.
[1:40:26] My parents own the Mr. Burger in town on South Blue things.
[1:40:31] If I leave there and go park my trailer at their restaurant,
[1:40:37] their private property back out of the way,
[1:40:39] because I'm gonna be there the next afternoon
[1:40:43] to set up and sell, it's not parking,
[1:40:49] I don't know, it's more just using the parking than anything.
[1:40:53] I'm not saying go leave it and set up
[1:40:57] and just everybody says, hey, I'm parking that there,
[1:41:00] don't take deal for mobile's mobile.
[1:41:03] If I'm dragging it from one place,
[1:41:05] I can drag it to the next.
[1:41:07] Good questions.
[1:41:09] I think that's all I have.
[1:41:10] And you were out of time.
[1:41:12] Again, Travis, do you want to address those?
[1:41:16] Mr. Mayor, members of council, on the first question
[1:41:19] in terms of does he have to get specific ownership
[1:41:24] or permission for the different dates and time?
[1:41:27] I think that we're looking at that as more annual
[1:41:30] Because if you read that he's going to have an annual process, he's going to have an annual permit.
[1:41:34] So if I were to read, he's going to have an annual permission slip.
[1:41:37] You know, so he's going to go to a place and he's going to have that and he is allowed to be there.
[1:41:43] It is certainly not our expectation that if he's going to be there, you know, on the 21st of January and the 26th.
[1:41:52] I mean, we have a lot better things to do as staff than, you know, kind of track that.
[1:41:57] But I think what we want to do is we want to make sure that the person and
[1:42:02] it isn't just setting up without the permission of the landowner.
[1:42:06] And like I think Fritz shared and I think that Councilman Munn concurred
[1:42:11] most of the time we're writing the ordinance for those very few who just
[1:42:15] don't want to comply.
[1:42:20] Did we answer the other question?
[1:42:22] I'm going to have you come up next, ma'am.
[1:42:25] I've lost control of this public hearing.
[1:42:29] But he might have to come in again and explain the ice cream truck.
[1:42:34] That provision that you have there has always existed in a different place.
[1:42:37] It's re-cautified in this place.
[1:42:39] It was originally intended for the downtown area where they didn't want people setting
[1:42:45] up on the sidewalk in front of another restaurant because the restaurants were not very happy
[1:42:49] about that.
[1:42:51] So if we could have to come back up, sir, and maybe clarify, do you have an ice cream truck,
[1:42:58] Car what do we speak? Yes, it's a nice cream truck. Yes. I like the ones that you see around you know the anything
[1:43:06] Yeah
[1:43:07] though in in in the reason why I asked is to I did have a
[1:43:14] Comment to me made to me by a business owner
[1:43:19] He he actually called the police the police game and of course they saw my permit and everything was you know, okay
[1:43:26] But people call me, you know, to the place, and I was just selling the ice cream on the
[1:43:39] street.
[1:43:41] And I want to know if he has the right to, you know, call the police on me or just say,
[1:43:52] you know, you can't be parked on the street.
[1:43:54] On the street or in his private street?
[1:43:56] No, on the street.
[1:43:57] On the street.
[1:43:58] We'll get that answer.
[1:43:59] And it is $100 a year.
[1:44:01] A year.
[1:44:02] Okay.
[1:44:03] Prince, could you answer that question?
[1:44:08] So, if he sets up in a parking place in front of an ice cream store, I guarantee you guys
[1:44:14] are going to hear from the ice cream store that this guy has set up in front of my business.
[1:44:19] He didn't even ask for permission.
[1:44:21] So he does need permission from adjoining property orders to set up in that way.
[1:44:26] If he's just driving around, the ones we know about that play the music and drive around,
[1:44:32] it's not going to be a problem, but if he sets up on a street and stops, then he's got to get to get to the room.
[1:44:38] Does that make sense to you, other room?
[1:44:42] For me, it's different setting up.
[1:44:47] Setting up would require me to get my stuff out of the truck, you know, setting up.
[1:44:52] If I'm dealing from inside the truck, I'm still inside my truck.
[1:44:58] Do you kind of understand the mentality though?
[1:45:00] If you pulled up in front of my ice cream shop and started selling there, you see it's
[1:45:05] in conflict.
[1:45:06] Yeah, yeah, of course.
[1:45:07] Yeah.
[1:45:08] But if it is a Franklin supply or whatever, you know, I don't see a competition.
[1:45:15] Yeah, of course, I want my permit and I want everybody to do business.
[1:45:19] I wouldn't just go to an ice cream track and try to do a competition.
[1:45:26] I get your question.
[1:45:28] Yeah.
[1:45:29] Perfect.
[1:45:30] Thank you.
[1:45:31] Ma'am, did you want to come forward?
[1:45:39] And I was just how to question about the shed.
[1:45:43] The shed in the sitting area, people when I'm serving or when I'm making it, it takes about
[1:45:48] ten minutes for your order to be ready.
[1:45:50] So people like to sit in the shade and not in the sun and then also like in the winter
[1:45:55] too or if it's raining.
[1:45:56] That was just my concern.
[1:45:58] And about bathrooms, most people don't sit there very long,
[1:46:02] so they just sit and eat and leave.
[1:46:05] But the bathrooms, there's a gas station right across the street,
[1:46:08] and people don't really mind.
[1:46:10] And also, I can also have the hand sanitizers.
[1:46:15] That makes sense to me about it.
[1:46:17] We took the restaurant part.
[1:46:18] The restaurant part has been taken out.
[1:46:19] And about the sinks, too.
[1:46:22] Thank you.
[1:46:25] Is there any more public testimony this evening regarding
[1:46:29] this issue. I'm closing the public testimony hearing portion again.
[1:46:33] Jim. Thank you. Just to clarify now, Fritz, if I have a mobile ice cream truck and I park
[1:46:39] it on the city street anywhere, if I park it, I have to have permission of a joining business
[1:46:46] owners right now according to code. Okay. Well, that's going to cover. Okay. Okay. Absolutely.
[1:46:53] I get it. Bring my. Well, I guess that brings up the whole as Mr. I'm like, I'm trying to
[1:46:58] pronounce it. I was actually talking about the person that has the big fatties, which I've
[1:47:05] had to just barbecue in its excellent, by the way. Once you deny concerts, when they
[1:47:13] have two blocks worth of food vendors set up, are they going to now have to have permission
[1:47:20] from all the store owners on Main Street? That's the question that Prince is about to
[1:47:26] answer.
[1:47:28] You guys give them permission on the Wednesday night live. What do they call that?
[1:47:36] Yeah, you've given them permission already with good thoughts tonight. Okay, by the fact that they apply for especially you
[1:47:42] Special just like you do in the city part. Okay. All right. Thank you. Just one of those is that what you want? Okay, all right good
[1:47:50] Greg you like so sorry
[1:47:54] Are folks that testify tonight and or staff
[1:47:59] deliberations. I'm closing the public hearing and what's over to deliberations and Chris talking to you.
[1:48:07] Well, as I said before, this is going to be an ordinance that makes no one really happy.
[1:48:11] It's still an improvement over clarification of the differences and I really think we need to move it through
[1:48:17] and put it on third and final and try it for six months and tweak it three months for six months from now.
[1:48:23] now. I don't think we're going to be able to
[1:48:26] deliberate enough to ever get the thing resolved
[1:48:29] between the seven of us, let us, at least of all of the
[1:48:32] various competing business interests. So with that, I'm
[1:48:37] going to move to suspend the rules and place 3059 on
[1:48:42] third and final by title only.
[1:48:44] Second, we have the motion on the floor by Chris talking
[1:48:47] seconded by Sean Burger to place ordinance 3059 by title only suspending the rules
[1:48:57] third and final yeah you got dollars certainly not right or
[1:49:02] you know anything further on that motion council yes yes yes
[1:49:15] Yes, Suzanne Hawkins. Yes. Yes, John Baraker. Yes
[1:49:23] Council Council Bill will confuse their
[1:49:24] moment now Liana would you read the ordinance? In ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho
[1:49:31] amending chapter 18 of title three of the Twin Falls City code relating
[1:49:36] regulating mobile and motorized food concessionaires by re-organizing the chapter the chapter by making technical corrections
[1:49:44] by increasing the annual permit fee to $100.
[1:49:47] And by adding more detailed requirements for mobile
[1:49:51] and motorized food conditionnaires operating on private property.
[1:49:57] Motion by Council, Sean Barrier.
[1:49:59] I would move approval of Ordinance 3059.
[1:50:02] Second.
[1:50:03] Suzanne Hopkins.
[1:50:04] So we have a motion on the floor by Sean Barrier,
[1:50:07] seconded by Suzanne Hopkins to approve Ordinance 3059.
[1:50:11] Anything further on that motion?
[1:50:13] Council, we're back in Millside.
[1:50:15] Thank you, Mayor.
[1:50:17] I'd just like to propose an amendment, maybe,
[1:50:19] in the spirit of compromise on section, or requirement M,
[1:50:23] of section four.
[1:50:24] Perhaps we can change the wording of the motorized or mobile
[1:50:30] food concession vehicles, seating, trash cans,
[1:50:32] and all other items and equipment associated with the food
[1:50:35] concession be removed from the site at the end of each week,
[1:50:39] instead of day.
[1:50:41] And that would be my amendment to change day to week.
[1:50:46] Motion on the floor, do we have a second council?
[1:50:54] Motion fails due to lack of second.
[1:50:57] Anything further on this motion council?
[1:51:00] The aye, the roll call vote raised.
[1:51:05] Great glanting.
[1:51:06] Yes.
[1:51:06] Don Hall.
[1:51:07] Yes.
[1:51:08] Rebecca Milsoica.
[1:51:09] No.
[1:51:10] Suzanne Hawkins.
[1:51:12] Yes.
[1:51:12] Jim Munn.
[1:51:13] No.
[1:51:14] Sean Berriger.
[1:51:15] Yes.
[1:51:16] Chris Tockney, thank you.
[1:51:18] Motion passes 5-2-2.
[1:51:21] And before we break, we're going to take a real quick
[1:51:25] five minute break. I wanted to say thank you. Nobody, we didn't make everyone happy obviously, but
[1:51:31] thank you for your input. This has been a eventful ordinance to go through and really do appreciate
[1:51:38] the public coming out. So with that, we're going to take a five minute break meeting the meeting of
[1:58:37] City Council and the fall City Council. But thank you January 21st. It's about four minutes to seven
[1:58:43] seven in the evening. We're going to ship some things around Council. Please be patient with me
[1:58:49] at some request. We are going to move the number five as our next agenda item. That is
[1:58:56] consideration of a request to authorize the mayor to sign the recreation trail program grant
[1:59:02] application and we have Dennis Boyer and Mandy Thompson making his presentation. Welcome, Dennis
[1:59:08] And Mandy.
[1:59:12] Thank you, Mayor and Council.
[1:59:14] Yeah, I'll just give a real quick brief thing,
[1:59:16] and then I'll turn it over to Mandy.
[1:59:19] As you all remember, last October,
[1:59:21] the working with the Magic Rail Enance Committee,
[1:59:24] and we made that presentation to the City Council,
[1:59:27] what their project was going to be their plan of attack
[1:59:30] on the money we have in the budget.
[1:59:31] And one was, if we talked about,
[1:59:33] is applying for a grant through the
[1:59:34] out of the Department of Parks and Recreation
[1:59:36] for the Silver Falls section of the trail.
[1:59:39] So the grand is due with the 31st of January,
[1:59:43] and I kind of threw a rough draft on it,
[1:59:45] I turned it over to Mandy so she could make it look pretty,
[1:59:48] make my writing look prettier than it is,
[1:59:50] which not doesn't say much, but.
[1:59:52] Ha ha ha ha, I'm writing it in a step.
[1:59:55] But the grand is for the pillar fall section,
[1:59:58] and right now I'll just go ahead
[1:59:59] and turn it over to Mandy Thompson,
[2:00:01] or perhaps right, so we should, you know.
[2:00:03] Well, welcome again, Mandy.
[2:00:04] Thank you.
[2:00:06] Good evening.
[2:00:07] I promise I would keep it short.
[2:00:09] So I will stick to that promise.
[2:00:13] So the recreational trials program is actually,
[2:00:15] it's a federally funded grant program,
[2:00:17] it's what you refer to as a pass-through grant.
[2:00:19] So it's federal funds that are passed through a state agency.
[2:00:22] So as a city government, we're able to apply
[2:00:25] to the Idaho Department of Parks and Recreation
[2:00:28] for this money.
[2:00:30] There's approximately $1.5 million
[2:00:32] available annually in Idaho for this program.
[2:00:35] 30% of that money is reserved for non-motorized recreation,
[2:00:39] another 30% for motorized recreation,
[2:00:41] and then the remaining 40% is for mixed use.
[2:00:45] We obviously would be are going to be applying
[2:00:47] for the 30% of non-motorized recreation.
[2:00:52] This is just a picture of the proposed pillar falls trail.
[2:00:57] As you can see, it passes along, I guess that would be the,
[2:01:03] what is that, the southwest side of a private
[2:01:07] land owners property.
[2:01:09] Then it will go ahead and follow along the Canyon Trail and then it will go directly south and it will stop at
[2:01:16] Pole Line Road
[2:01:18] Just right there at the curve. So that is the
[2:01:22] the section that we're going to be
[2:01:26] Finishing it's approximately 2100 square or 2100 or excuse me 2100 feet and
[2:01:33] Cost estimates for the trail itself are
[2:01:37] $63,690 and then another $18,625 for the fencing for a combined total of $82,315 for this entire
[2:01:48] section of the trail. This is slightly higher than we had originally estimated because if
[2:01:52] you remember approximately three years ago there was actually plans for development of
[2:01:57] that property and as Perksi Code the developer was going to actually finish this section of
[2:02:04] the trail. That development has stopped and so the city is going to take on this section.
[2:02:10] Unfortunately, the initial base work for the trail was not put in the proper location. It
[2:02:16] was put too close to that private landowner's home. And so he spoke with Dennis and they
[2:02:22] came to the conclusion that they were going to have to move that section of the trail in
[2:02:27] in order to satisfy the landowners, you know,
[2:02:32] obviously desire for privacy.
[2:02:36] So the cost was not a whole lot more,
[2:02:39] but a little bit more than we had originally intended.
[2:02:42] The requirements for the grant itself is a 20% match,
[2:02:47] but the city is putting forth a application
[2:02:49] with a 44.56% match, fully acknowledging that
[2:02:54] by putting more matching funds into a grant application,
[2:02:58] you can and very often do garner more points in the process.
[2:03:03] So the match combination will be $20,000 of city funds,
[2:03:07] which we would pull from the recreation trail budget.
[2:03:11] 10,000 from the Twin Falls Community Foundation
[2:03:13] and 7,500 from the Magic Valley Trail Enhancement Committee.
[2:03:18] In addition, I'm in the process of putting forth
[2:03:21] a letter of interest to a private foundation
[2:03:24] called People for Bikes.
[2:03:26] This is a private foundation out of Boulder, Colorado, that will grant funds to communities
[2:03:35] and private groups and nonprofits for projects that promote biking in a community and in
[2:03:43] actually NAMPA, the city of NAMPA, actually received a grant from this foundation last
[2:03:48] year to help connect their path system within the city of NAMPA.
[2:03:53] So if that comes to fruition, we won't find out about that until May, but that would lessen
[2:04:00] the city's cost by $10,000.
[2:04:02] So it would potentially only have an impact of $10,000 on the city's budget.
[2:04:07] So what you have within your packet was a copy of the draft application.
[2:04:13] And at this point, I think that is, you know, that's everything that we put forth in the
[2:04:24] application.
[2:04:25] Now we just ask for your agreement to sign the application so we can get it submitted.
[2:04:33] Thank you, man.
[2:04:34] Just a real quick question.
[2:04:35] Remind me, Travis, since this is being taken care of potentially through the grants and
[2:04:41] these funds.
[2:04:42] When the developer does develop that property, is it just a freebie or do they have to participate?
[2:04:50] Can we have them participate in another way?
[2:04:56] So this is, as we shared during the budgeting process
[2:05:00] and we shared in the conversations,
[2:05:02] this is a responsibility of the developer
[2:05:05] at the time of the development.
[2:05:06] But that responsibility goes away
[2:05:09] if the project is completed.
[2:05:12] We've had and tried to reach out numerous times
[2:05:15] with the current property owner to see
[2:05:17] if we could have something in the selling price
[2:05:22] or the disposition of the property to recognize the contribution of public funds to construct
[2:05:29] the trail in advance. And unfortunately, we have not been able to have or make any progress
[2:05:37] in that conversation with the property owner. So if the council does proceed, it's recognition
[2:05:43] that the advancement of the trail and the use of city funds for this will be done at
[2:05:50] our expense with no expectation of a return in cost and benefit.
[2:05:56] Thank you for that clarification, Greg Lanning.
[2:05:58] I've got a quick comment on that.
[2:06:00] And it goes back to the park and lua fees.
[2:06:03] Let's say that that property had came in.
[2:06:06] And it was a planned originally.
[2:06:07] It had a portion of it that was residential.
[2:06:10] And a portion of it was commercial and office and the whole thing.
[2:06:15] Do we typically waive that park and lua fee
[2:06:18] if they have to put trail in or they have to do both,
[2:06:23] if it is of being residential.
[2:06:26] There's a formula that sets aside about,
[2:06:28] they still have to do a park's end to look,
[2:06:30] but they do get a reduction in that
[2:06:32] if they provide a trail.
[2:06:34] Right, so we could actually recoup some of this
[2:06:36] through the park and lieu of funds at that time
[2:06:39] if some of it ends up being residential,
[2:06:41] which I'm sure some of it will be,
[2:06:43] so we can get some of it back at that point.
[2:06:46] Thanks, Mike.
[2:06:47] Thank you.
[2:06:48] Sean Berriger.
[2:06:48] I was actually going to make a motion.
[2:06:50] Well, we have another light, so if you could be patient,
[2:06:52] I'll come back to you.
[2:06:53] Rebecca Melsoika.
[2:06:55] Thank you, Mayor.
[2:06:56] Two questions.
[2:06:57] One is a follow-up on a question about recouping the cost.
[2:07:02] If the city were to create a trail impact fee
[2:07:06] in the course of the time before this land develops,
[2:07:08] would money then be able to go towards future trail
[2:07:13] money through a park's recreation type of impact fee?
[2:07:18] Yes. So if you, if it's not necessarily creating an impact fee specifically for trails, but what it would be is it would be including trails in the master capital improvements list that is currently being vetted and discussed when it comes to impact fees.
[2:07:37] And when that, if that project is funded, then it will receive funding and you'll have additional funding to advance the trail work.
[2:07:46] with dollars that are paid for by the development community.
[2:07:52] Okay, and that might be a roundabout way to do it, but it might be something to consider.
[2:07:58] My other question was regarding the private property,
[2:08:02] could you explain in more detail maybe why the trail has to be moved?
[2:08:05] Is it an issue of code violation that it's too close or
[2:08:09] is it just a preference on the property owners?
[2:08:12] Part of the agreement when this development happened that this is residents of Todd Blass.
[2:08:18] Part of the agreement that he had with the development too was there was a buffer between
[2:08:23] his property and the trail.
[2:08:25] If I remember right correctly, it's a 20 foot buffer, landscaping buffer.
[2:08:30] And I spoke with Todd Blass a couple of weeks ago.
[2:08:33] And when I personally walked this about three weeks ago just to get more familiar with the
[2:08:38] property.
[2:08:39] That seemed like really close to his property, and it is.
[2:08:42] It's probably within 10 feet of his property line.
[2:08:47] So this section of trail would just
[2:08:49] have to be pushed back a little bit south.
[2:08:52] The base work anyway, because that's
[2:08:53] what the developer already did.
[2:08:54] So by the agreement that Todd last had
[2:08:58] with this development here, and we require, if I remember,
[2:09:01] we own this section here, and I think
[2:09:03] this was some of the easement you remember
[2:09:05] for it's on this, just section below that part.
[2:09:13] I know when this, you know, we received this property here
[2:09:17] from the bank, right, that, and this property was more of a,
[2:09:20] was that a, was that a, was it, give you a name?
[2:09:24] Was it a pre-existing pre-existing?
[2:09:26] Okay, all right, but part of it is there's,
[2:09:30] wanna be good neighbors, I wanna to make sure this agreement
[2:09:34] Todd had with the developers that we kind of follow that and we are either away from his property than what the trail
[2:09:40] If we build it on the existing path, so we just have to move this path, you know
[2:09:45] 10 feet 15 feet further south
[2:09:49] And how much will that cost? Actually, it was up. It was approximately
[2:09:54] $15,000 extra
[2:09:57] I think that's about this recovery.
[2:09:59] My question is that the developer that he had the agreement with is no longer a party.
[2:10:08] I wouldn't mind that landscape buffer, but if the new owner doesn't build anything in
[2:10:13] between, what uses that land if we move the trail?
[2:10:18] Obviously, the use of the land, well, I guess would be no high use if we don't want to put
[2:10:26] screening there between the private property and the the trail itself. So it's
[2:10:32] just the but there's no landscaping you might say just did space out there but I
[2:10:36] think we want to because we have tried to I guess responsible property or
[2:10:44] I guess responsible neighbors when we build Kenyan trails you know along
[2:10:48] commercial property or there so a lot of times we have worked with the developers
[2:10:53] about what type of landscaping we have out there,
[2:10:55] because this is just 20 feet of wasted space.
[2:11:01] It's gonna get weeds, so we're just spraying weed
[2:11:03] killer out there, so it would be best to landscape it,
[2:11:07] so it is kind of beautify the area to enhance the trail.
[2:11:13] Yeah, and that's my only concern is just who pays for that,
[2:11:17] and the added expense, I don't know if that's the,
[2:11:22] the citizens' responsibility. Obviously, there's a developer no longer involved, and so that
[2:11:27] falls on the grants or trail money or whatever.
[2:11:31] I do not propose to do the landscaping when I talk to Mr. Blass there. He fully expects
[2:11:36] whoever developed this to do the landscaping in there, but he just want to make sure the
[2:11:41] buffer remains the same as originally was planned. But I do not plan on putting any
[2:11:49] any landscaping in that buffer area?
[2:11:52] Yeah, I'm just concerned about the additional cost in moving it.
[2:11:56] I don't know if that's necessary.
[2:11:58] So before Sean makes the motion in between now and when it develops, it's just going to be weeds?
[2:12:07] Well, we'll keep it sprayed down.
[2:12:09] Okay.
[2:12:10] We'll definitely do that. We'll keep the weeds down.
[2:12:12] Okay.
[2:12:13] Okay.
[2:12:14] Sean Burger.
[2:12:15] So I would move that the Council authorize the mayor to sign the recreational trails program grant application as presented.
[2:12:24] Second.
[2:12:25] We have a motion on the floor by John Berger, seconded by Chris Tockington to authorize the mayor to sign the recreational trail program grant application anything further on that motion council.
[2:12:37] I see no lights.
[2:12:39] Lehigh, the roll call vote please.
[2:12:40] John Hall.
[2:12:41] Yes.
[2:12:42] Rebecca Mesoica.
[2:12:43] Yes.
[2:12:44] Susan Hawkins. Yes Jim. Yes. John Burger. Yes. Yes. Greg Lance. Yes. Motion passes seven to zero.
[2:12:55] Moving back up to item number two under items of consideration. Thank you both very much. Update on
[2:13:01] the wastewater treatment plant upgrades, waiting in the wings, very patiently Troy Vitek.
[2:13:15] He was raised a little bit about an hour and a half ago.
[2:13:22] Thank you for your patience tonight, Troy.
[2:13:24] Good evening, council members.
[2:13:25] My name is Troy Vitte, the assistant city engineer.
[2:13:28] Tonight, I'm just going to give you a brief outline of what we've been working on.
[2:13:32] The council has asked us to come forward every so often with what progress we've made on the wastewater treatment plan upgrade.
[2:13:38] So this is my attempt to do that.
[2:13:40] From tonight, I'll gauge how you guys respond and what I need to bring next time.
[2:13:45] The wastewater treatment plant, just to give you a little kind of reference here, north is this way to the left.
[2:13:52] You would enter the wastewater treatment plant here. This is a new I-FAST, integrated fixed, activated slide, sorry.
[2:14:03] This is the primary system that gives us the most capacity.
[2:14:07] In that, we are doing some renovation to these existing aeration basins,
[2:14:12] and we're going to be installing a new clarifiers part of this project,
[2:14:15] as well as updating some of our UV facilities over here.
[2:14:18] It was previously designed to have capacity,
[2:14:21] we're just adding the extra bangs,
[2:14:22] so they had some fourth thought and planning there.
[2:14:27] Right now, the designer CH2 male is at 60% design.
[2:14:32] So we are not near completion,
[2:14:34] but we're kind of getting to the point
[2:14:35] where we have to make some decisions
[2:14:39] on how to maintain the budget that Travis previously
[2:14:43] beats me with, and we're getting to a point where it's really kind of starting to cool
[2:14:50] less and come together. The project is going to be broken into two packages. One is a construction
[2:14:58] for the earthwork and the other is a general construction package. The reason for that
[2:15:03] is because of our time frame we're trying to just get through this as fast as possible
[2:15:07] to meet the deadline of 2015.
[2:15:10] And in those packages, there's going
[2:15:13] to be five procurement packages, of which
[2:15:18] is one for the IFAS system, another for the blower buildings.
[2:15:22] They blow bubbles into this to make them the system work.
[2:15:27] The clarifier mechanism out here, which
[2:15:28] is just an arm that screeds off all the waste,
[2:15:32] the gates inside this system, and then
[2:15:33] it's a large diameter piping throughout that.
[2:15:36] It takes a lot of time for the manufacturers.
[2:15:38] So I'll become for you multiple times
[2:15:40] asking for awards of those as we go through the bidding process.
[2:15:44] There's a couple of ways you can bid projects.
[2:15:46] You can go through a standard bidding process.
[2:15:48] You design the package, you send it out there.
[2:15:51] Everybody's able to bid on it.
[2:15:54] In a couple of these, we've looked
[2:15:57] to do a pre-qualifications based.
[2:15:59] We're asking the contractors to meet certain requirements
[2:16:03] and we're doing this so that we get certain types of systems
[2:16:05] that our engineering people are seeing better, such as the blowers,
[2:16:13] that are going to be coming through.
[2:16:14] We have blowers in this existing building,
[2:16:16] but they're not very economical, efficient there.
[2:16:24] So the blowers that are going to go on this new proposed building,
[2:16:28] we're looking at turbo high speed fan blowers.
[2:16:31] What that allows us to do is look at aisle power incentives
[2:16:33] for the cost of that.
[2:16:35] And I think they estimated it would be three years,
[2:16:37] who would pay off the additional costs in the blower.
[2:16:41] So while I'll be a more upfront capital costs,
[2:16:45] but there's only several companies
[2:16:46] that they feel comfortable and have a reputable
[2:16:50] in delivering those blowers.
[2:16:52] So we're gonna go out and pre-qualify them.
[2:16:54] So you have to meet these things
[2:16:56] so that not everybody can't bid on this project.
[2:17:00] So just a couple of things we're trying to jump through.
[2:17:05] We're trying to manage all the risks,
[2:17:08] associated with this. Some of it is the schedule. As you know, there's multiple people working
[2:17:14] on the site and contractor one, contractor two and a dewatering contractor all can be
[2:17:19] on the site the same time. When contractors get together, sometimes they don't mingle
[2:17:23] well and we're trying to minimize that as much as possible. But there are just going
[2:17:27] to be some overlap of that. We hope that one contractor gets both packages, or if not
[2:17:32] all three. And then idle power, they're putting in some upgrades to the facility and now idle
[2:17:38] power is fantastic with it, but met all our previous construction requirements, but we
[2:17:44] don't control them, we have no say in how they actually do it, so we think, anyway, the
[2:17:50] construction packages are cut out like here, the construction package one has come in before
[2:17:54] you hear priests, and we're going to advertise next month, and we'd like to have that all
[2:18:00] wrapped up by mid-April and the completion by the fall of the year, and then we'll start
[2:18:06] with construction package 2, which is really the big package.
[2:18:11] This one kind of gets the whole ready for this guy
[2:18:14] and then construction package 2.
[2:18:16] He installs everything.
[2:18:17] And that'll be a large one.
[2:18:19] And he'll have to mid-June 2015.
[2:18:22] Now you see several milestones here.
[2:18:24] This June 2015 has to get to the 13MJD required.
[2:18:28] The December 2015 is for the total 16MJD,
[2:18:31] which is second to me.
[2:18:33] and other capacity needs at the time.
[2:18:39] And then by the time you wrap up all the paperwork,
[2:18:41] do all the closeout, get all the warranties
[2:18:43] of B March 2016.
[2:18:46] Couple of issues, and we would like
[2:18:48] to come back in the future and talk about this.
[2:18:51] Two that we see is, actually, I'll jump to this.
[2:18:58] This is the budget so far.
[2:19:02] This number here is kind of what I'd like you to focus on.
[2:19:05] But this is somewhat over budget,
[2:19:07] But this is an uncommon first 60% design.
[2:19:12] It's up and down and all around.
[2:19:13] As they get closer to 90%, we'll get closer there.
[2:19:17] This budget does include two items here.
[2:19:19] We call these bid alternatives.
[2:19:21] These are things we can put in or take out a little bit.
[2:19:26] And here's the items that are included in that total $1.8 million.
[2:19:30] These items we can put in, in which we do feel that a lot of these are good ideas,
[2:19:37] but it's not necessary.
[2:19:38] So we can take these out of the bid to meet that $34 million.
[2:19:42] But if we get a really good bid, contractors
[2:19:45] happen to be hungry or something like that,
[2:19:47] we want the ability to put money back in there easily
[2:19:50] without having to go back and re-bid it.
[2:19:51] And this is a good way to do that.
[2:19:53] We can do that all in front before we ever
[2:19:55] win the contract, right?
[2:20:03] The $940,000 one.
[2:20:05] We have four aeration basins we're doing out there.
[2:20:07] They are aerated all the time.
[2:20:09] If you shut down the aeration on them,
[2:20:11] without them being empty, these little disks get full of luck.
[2:20:14] And what this does, this $940,000,
[2:20:18] it puts a different head on that.
[2:20:19] So the water can't go back in, kind of,
[2:20:22] so you're able to shut down portions of aeration,
[2:20:25] aeration, by doing that, you save air costs,
[2:20:28] you save on those inefficient blowers.
[2:20:31] This pays back within three years, this $940,000.
[2:20:35] So it doesn't meet the budget at this time,
[2:20:37] but it may be an option that might invest in,
[2:20:40] and I'll let you guys talk about that
[2:20:42] when we get the actual numbers,
[2:20:44] when we go with the total construction packages.
[2:20:48] The other one, and we always do this on projects,
[2:20:54] so we try to do that.
[2:20:55] We try to do a contract change order
[2:20:57] we deserve of 2.0, and this is just under 10%
[2:21:01] of the construction package.
[2:21:03] What we do there is, we always know
[2:21:05] there's going to be changes in your documents,
[2:21:07] especially as fast-paced schedules as a system.
[2:21:09] Somebody's going to hit something underneath there,
[2:21:10] and they're going to be extra rocker.
[2:21:14] We can see an opportunity where we can change something
[2:21:16] real quick.
[2:21:17] So we try to keep a little reserve in that.
[2:21:19] This I'm sure will get a lot less as we near the 90%
[2:21:24] and the more we know.
[2:21:25] But that's always an option that we would like to have
[2:21:28] that change order reserve to be part of that.
[2:21:31] Of course, there's permitting and some other things.
[2:21:33] The other part of this was Belft-Prest III,
[2:21:36] which was it, I'm entirely realized,
[2:21:38] till we started this project.
[2:21:41] The judicial confirmation paid for two of the Belft-Prests
[2:21:45] To meet the capacity requirements,
[2:21:47] we have to install a third.
[2:21:49] Unfortunately, there was a method
[2:21:51] in that judicial confirmation.
[2:21:52] So this project will be picking up
[2:21:54] that additional cost there.
[2:22:04] This is the one I wanted to talk about.
[2:22:06] As we start construction,
[2:22:12] there was several ways we can get rid of material.
[2:22:15] We can take it out of the canyon,
[2:22:16] which is a cost to us, the contractor,
[2:22:19] would give if we had a site to do it.
[2:22:21] So, it was determined that there's, since it's just need of material down there,
[2:22:25] sand most late rocks, there's plenty of space of agar falls.
[2:22:29] So agar falls was kind of an opportunity.
[2:22:30] We said we have a property here, we have a disposal site, it's a clean material,
[2:22:34] and our inspectors will be sure to validate that.
[2:22:39] But, so we said take it to agar falls because it's a lease haul, short, but at its peak,
[2:22:45] there are going to be 33 trucks a day, all in the back and forth.
[2:22:51] These aren't small trucks, these are Volvo-sized trucks.
[2:22:54] So some of our risk and concerns are how does that impact the public,
[2:22:58] especially the public that wants to be down there?
[2:23:00] And I don't know the answer yet.
[2:23:02] I don't think we've come to a conclusion.
[2:23:04] I don't know if there's just really signage and safety concerns
[2:23:07] that we just need to address so the public can be down there.
[2:23:10] Or if we want to restrict hours to say, contract, do you have it between 9 and 5?
[2:23:14] The public is it from 5 on and weekends.
[2:23:18] I don't know, but also no.
[2:23:20] I would like to eventually come before you can talk about that as when you're final completion.
[2:23:24] The other one is the C-Man Trucks.
[2:23:26] The C-Man has to be brought down and construct this.
[2:23:29] That peaks at a different time than you can see here's 24 trucks a day at certain times
[2:23:33] that goes down at others.
[2:23:36] That's going down that grade, that's a large load going down that grade, that's going to
[2:23:39] affect that roadway.
[2:23:40] And in coming months I'll come to you again and talk about C-Man Trucks.
[2:23:46] not sure it's gonna last effect or pretty sure it might be affected on the corners
[2:23:51] well we can put that in the contractors cost right now to to look at it fix it
[2:23:57] but we'll pay for it now or we can see how it's impacted the roadway for later
[2:24:02] I don't know what you guys want to do there and again I'll look for that in the
[2:24:06] future but we I would like to get with the cine engineer a little bit more as we
[2:24:10] year, final design, and kind of come up with the plan to present it to you. See what we want
[2:24:16] to do there. This also is, it's access on the public, especially Canyon Falls, or King
[2:24:23] and Screech grade, throughout most of the year they're praying and walking once. If you have
[2:24:30] a con, create truck coming down the roadway, and people are forebressed, that's scary.
[2:24:36] So the traffic control plan may include possible one way
[2:24:40] for portions of it or flaggers,
[2:24:43] possibly again won't come with more recommendations
[2:24:47] at that time.
[2:24:50] I guess that's all I had.
[2:24:51] If you guys have questions, be happy to talk about them.
[2:24:54] Well, thank you.
[2:24:55] The only thing I was going to say, well, a couple things.
[2:24:58] I had never even thought about the construction,
[2:25:01] the concrete trucks going up and down that road.
[2:25:03] That's really a good point.
[2:25:05] And I look forward to some solutions and some mitigation issues that we're going to be talking
[2:25:11] about.
[2:25:13] And also just the truck hauling the material back into the overfalls area, I'm sure that
[2:25:21] we're going to have a plan to make sure that we do that properly and re-vegetate or whatever
[2:25:25] we're going to do to make sure that that's a, because that is a popular place now, that
[2:25:31] roadways are a popular place.
[2:25:32] The other thing I was just going to mention just off-handedly is that I never dreamed
[2:25:36] in a million years I'd ever say this, but I'm pretty excited about what we're doing with
[2:25:40] our wastewater treatment plant.
[2:25:42] And I haven't taken a tour of that facility since I first came on council eight years
[2:25:47] ago.
[2:25:48] So I haven't seen, when I took the tour, it was when they had, I called it the pallet pallets
[2:25:53] where they had that look like pallets in the middle and it was kind of falling in on itself.
[2:25:57] I haven't been there since then.
[2:25:59] So I'll wait until this, I'll get out of the way of the concrete trucks.
[2:26:06] Chris talking to you.
[2:26:07] It looks like the obvious place to put some of that evacuation in rock or in the old Idaho
[2:26:12] frozen ponds that were excavated.
[2:26:15] Isn't that a doable thing or are those?
[2:26:18] Actually, there happens to be, and I talked with Lee, who happens to know quite a bit
[2:26:22] about artifacts.
[2:26:23] He has a premium spot parked picked out that's kind of green and some loops of the happen
[2:26:27] the juice to use two trucks and it's kind of away from the riverfront where most of
[2:26:31] people are kind of focusing on it's back up against the towels slope a little bit.
[2:26:35] Okay. So you're getting some stuff and the other thing on the concrete trucks frankly
[2:26:40] I'd be more worried about the vibrations that sets up. That's an unstable wall.
[2:26:45] I exercise on that and I don't see four people are brass but I see two
[2:26:51] two abreast, let me reword that, two mothers pushing baby buggies, two abreast, and not paying
[2:26:59] attention, but I've also seen rocks fall off and hit right in front of people. Is there
[2:27:05] a consideration for some sort of a holding screen to go up the least temporarily?
[2:27:11] I think we'll look at that in our analysis. I don't really think that vibration would be
[2:27:15] as much of a risk as anything.
[2:27:18] Unfortunately we don't own the wall there.
[2:27:22] Yeah.
[2:27:24] We know who does.
[2:27:27] We're back in mail, sweet.
[2:27:29] Thank you, Mayor.
[2:27:30] Just a question about the truck traffic.
[2:27:33] What is the time frame for that?
[2:27:35] Is this start April 2014 and go all the way through June of 2015?
[2:27:40] Is it the whole time or is it certain portion?
[2:27:43] It goes 33 through the months of May, July, then it falls off August, September.
[2:27:51] These are the haul trucks.
[2:27:53] Those aren't very good colors.
[2:27:54] It's kind of a light blue and a purple.
[2:27:56] This is the ones that go down the auger falls.
[2:28:00] The concrete trucks that kind of start here in September 2014 through November, January
[2:28:08] there all the way through January there coming down the grade.
[2:28:11] So it's icy.
[2:28:12] It's cold.
[2:28:13] So this is a year and a half basically.
[2:28:15] Yeah, this will finish till the end of 25th.
[2:28:17] Okay, thank you.
[2:28:19] Great, Lana.
[2:28:20] Troy and this is probably, maybe I already know the answer, but I guess I want confirmation.
[2:28:24] Would this have been a lot easier and a lot quicker design if we'd just been building something scratch rather than trying to put all this together with what we already had or is it just take that long?
[2:28:37] There's not what I wondered is there a cookie cutter went out there some place
[2:28:41] We use it all pull that one off the shelf and the bill or yeah, unfortunately
[2:28:48] I know when they looked at places
[2:28:57] The cheapest we get for the most capacity
[2:29:00] Thank you
[2:29:01] Any other questions council try. Thank you for the update. We look forward to the future updates as well. Thank you
[2:29:10] Moving on to the next item as consideration of your request
[2:29:12] to adopt Ordinance 3060 authorizing the signing
[2:29:16] of the loan agreement with the Idaho Bond Bank
[2:29:19] and presentation on the bonding process
[2:29:22] for the $38 million of improvements
[2:29:27] at the wastewater treatment plant.
[2:29:29] And we have our city finance director, Lori Ress.
[2:29:33] Welcome, Lori.
[2:29:34] Good evening, and how appropriate that the money piece
[2:29:36] follows the project piece.
[2:29:39] How weird.
[2:29:40] So tonight I just want to provide you with a brief update where we're at in the
[2:29:44] bond process of obtaining that $38 million approved by our voters to make these
[2:29:50] improvements Troj just shared. So the Idaho Bond Bank adopted their bond
[2:29:55] resolution and notice of sale at their January 13th meeting. So formal reaction
[2:30:02] or a formal action that's required so that we can sell bonds. The city is in the
[2:30:08] final stages of securing a commitment from assured guarantee municipal.
[2:30:15] So what they're doing is they're providing a surety bond policy for the city so we don't
[2:30:20] have to have a debt reserve fund.
[2:30:22] That frees up about $3.5 million that we don't have to hang on to until the bonds are paid
[2:30:28] for.
[2:30:30] And an important point to note here is that this company approved our policy based on
[2:30:36] on the strength of our financial information.
[2:30:39] We didn't have to go through the process
[2:30:41] or the cost of being rated.
[2:30:44] Cameron Ariel was, Zion shared that
[2:30:47] this is the first time Zion's has seen this
[2:30:49] from a bond issuer in their shop.
[2:30:52] And he thinks that you need to, Idaho.
[2:30:55] The gentleman with AGM told Cameron we just couldn't not do it.
[2:31:00] And so Cameron was very complimentary
[2:31:03] and told both Travis and myself that
[2:31:05] really speaks to the city and the quality of our system. The actual bond sale will
[2:31:11] take place on February 12th and it's going to be done competitively and what
[2:31:17] this means is that bond buyers will be bidding for our bonds and that typically
[2:31:23] results in the best rates for us. The entire transaction will become final on
[2:31:31] February 26th and that's when the funds become available. Now when Troy was
[2:31:37] talking, he talked about the project and focusing on the $34.7 million number and
[2:31:45] that's a little bit over from where we anticipated it being but there's the
[2:31:49] opportunity or the possibility that our bonds could be issued at a premium which
[2:31:53] means we'll actually get a little bit more and we also have about $3.3
[2:31:59] million of capacity fees, excuse me, on hand that we could use to help pay for
[2:32:05] this. Does anybody have any questions about any of that? Any questions so far? I will.
[2:32:12] Okay. Well, so part of the process on our end is the signing of the bond ordinance. This
[2:32:20] document authorizes the issuance of the bonds to the bond bank authority and
[2:32:24] authorizes the signing of the loan agreement with the bond bank. It provides
[2:32:29] conditions of the loan and provides for a reserve fund, but in our case insurance so
[2:32:34] we don't have to have that reserve fund. So tonight, I would just ask that they may
[2:32:39] or be able to approve the bond ordinance and allow us to move forward.
[2:32:43] Thank you, Lori. I think we're gonna have questions. Chris talking to. First of all,
[2:32:50] that's incredibly good news. I think to paraphrase what you're saying, in part
[2:32:54] because of our bond rating and the state's bond rating, I guess overall, we are able
[2:33:00] to defer, delay or ignore the requirement for a $3 million surety.
[2:33:09] So $3.5 million debt reserve fund?
[2:33:12] Debt reserve fund.
[2:33:13] So we're able to buy a policy, a surety bond policy, to cover that.
[2:33:20] And the company that sells that bond based on the information that we provided felt very
[2:33:25] comfortable.
[2:33:26] We did not have to go through a rating process, the city of Twin Falls did not have to go
[2:33:30] through a rating process.
[2:33:32] Well, that's incredible.
[2:33:33] But does this impact the $38 million bond itself?
[2:33:38] Is that is $3.5 million added onto that $38 or subtract it?
[2:33:42] Or is it a well situation?
[2:33:44] No, so Chris, if we had to put money in a debt reserve fund,
[2:33:49] we would have to come up with $3.5 million.
[2:33:51] So potentially that would have to come out of the $38 million.
[2:33:55] Well, that's incredible.
[2:33:56] Next step now, we can prepay.
[2:34:00] But I'm not sure that terms how long before prepayment is allowed.
[2:34:05] And we collected 125% of our requirements, and I'm wanting to know that 25% is held in escrow by the bond bank, I think.
[2:34:20] Okay.
[2:34:21] Well, I'm asking.
[2:34:22] So what you're saying is spot on for what we've done in the water department, but in the sewer fund,
[2:34:28] We're not necessarily collecting 125% of the debt payment.
[2:34:33] We're going to have to have a, so we go through a calculation and
[2:34:38] come up with what's called net reserves of the system.
[2:34:41] So our revenues minus the things that we get to subtract and
[2:34:45] that resulting number has to be 125% of our debt payment.
[2:34:51] So it doesn't necessarily mean we're collecting 125%
[2:34:55] So how does that influence our ability to prepay?
[2:35:00] So we can certainly set up a rate stabilization account.
[2:35:06] And as we do collect more dollars from whatever source those would be,
[2:35:11] we can put those dollars in a rate stabilization account.
[2:35:14] But this would be from activity that isn't currently in the equation.
[2:35:17] New business coming in or expansion.
[2:35:19] Could definitely be.
[2:35:21] be. Okay. And so what I'm concerned is that any additional revenues that are
[2:35:30] accruable because of an uptick in business for whatever reason are escrowed
[2:35:38] in the bonds names that they cannot be grabbed by future councils and used to
[2:35:42] pay off the the arsenic bonding. So I would like to have travel he's about I
[2:35:52] I mean, usually it's one finger, it's all fingers now.
[2:35:55] So I can, would you allow him to answer that question?
[2:35:58] Travis?
[2:36:00] Well, I don't want this to be missed in Lori's presentation
[2:36:04] because I think that she was incredibly humble.
[2:36:07] The fact that we were able to get the Assurity Bond
[2:36:11] had everything to do with Mrs. Race and her team
[2:36:15] and how she manages our system and nothing to do
[2:36:17] with the state of Idaho's credit rating.
[2:36:20] That was not taking into account.
[2:36:22] He was taking into the job that our team does.
[2:36:26] And I think that Lori undersold that a bit.
[2:36:31] Really, that's a testament to Lori and her team.
[2:36:35] One of the things that you're going to have to balance
[2:36:37] in answering your question is you heard Brad Will's earlier
[2:36:39] talk about how capacity fees and connection fees
[2:36:44] in our area are about $1,300 for sewer and water
[2:36:48] and the statewide average is 6,000.
[2:36:50] I think he said Hayden was like 15,000.
[2:36:54] Our intent, and we are required to take those
[2:36:57] connection fees and capacity fees.
[2:36:59] They're one and the same, connection fee for residential,
[2:37:02] capacity fee for industrial, and place those into an escrow
[2:37:06] like account so we can buy off the back years of the debt.
[2:37:10] That was our intent.
[2:37:13] And it will allow us to shorten the life on the note
[2:37:18] a note by having people pay the equity position that they owe for coming into the system.
[2:37:24] Brad and I shared this conversation and had a few philosophical differences on it, but that's
[2:37:29] how you pay that off early, is by continuing to assess a capacity fee and or a connection
[2:37:35] fee that makes good reasonable sense for our area.
[2:37:37] But there can't be tampered with and used for something other than that purpose.
[2:37:42] Thank you.
[2:37:44] Do you have further?
[2:37:47] Well, we have some questions, Greg Lenny.
[2:37:50] Just one or a quick comment on that one.
[2:37:52] The one that you said, Chris, I may be bristled
[2:37:56] as a poor term, but I brought my attention to my attention
[2:37:58] is we couldn't use sewer fees money for arsenic
[2:38:03] at any point, could we, Travis?
[2:38:07] No, so when you connect collect fees
[2:38:09] for a particular system, they must be applied
[2:38:12] to that system in which they're assessed?
[2:38:14] Good, good, good point.
[2:38:16] All right, council, if you have,
[2:38:19] I don't want to, did you have further?
[2:38:20] No, all right.
[2:38:21] I just want to tell you how proud I am of you and your team.
[2:38:25] I remember years ago, you were in the exact position
[2:38:29] you are now, and I'm just really proud
[2:38:30] that you're there.
[2:38:31] Thank you.
[2:38:32] Does my heart seem good, so.
[2:38:34] Council, this is an ordinance,
[2:38:36] so if we are going to pass it and needs to go to third
[2:38:38] and final, if we're going to do that tonight.
[2:38:40] Chris, talking to you.
[2:38:41] Nope, passage of ordinance 3060 by placing on third and final
[2:38:45] by title on my second motion on the floor by Chris talking then seconded by
[2:38:50] Rebecca Mills so I can to suspend the rules I think I think he said that to
[2:38:56] suspend the rules and place it on third and final yes any anything further on
[2:39:02] that motion council I see no lights Lee on the roll call vote please yes yes
[2:39:15] Yes, motion passes seven to zero if you could read the ordinance.
[2:39:20] Yeah, please.
[2:39:22] And ordinance of the city of Twin Falls, Twin Falls County, Idaho, authorizing and
[2:39:27] providing for the issuance of a parity link.
[2:39:29] So we're revenue bond series, 2013 and a principal amount, not to exceed $38 million
[2:39:36] to provide funds for the acquisition.
[2:39:39] I see 38 million.
[2:39:41] Yes.
[2:39:43] Okay.
[2:39:44] It's late.
[2:39:48] To provide funds for the acquisition and construction of certain wastewater facilities, establishing funds, providing for the form, execution, registration, maturity, and payment of the bonds, providing covenants relating to the bonds and to the tax exempt status of the interest on the bonds,
[2:40:04] approving a form of loan agreement between the city and the Idaho Bond Bank Authority, providing for related matters, approving a summary of this ordinance for publication.
[2:40:13] application and providing an effective date
[2:40:17] Council wishes
[2:40:19] Move approval
[2:40:21] ordinance
[2:40:23] 36
[2:40:24] 36
[2:40:26] 36 second most on the floor by great landing seconded by Sean Barreger to approval to approve
[2:40:33] ordinance 3060
[2:40:35] Anything further on that motion council the a roll call vote, please
[2:40:41] Yes
[2:40:43] Sean Berger yes Chris talking yes, great one team. Yes, don Hall. Yes, Rebecca
[2:40:50] Yes, motion passes seven to zero. Thank you. All right. We're moving down to item number four
[2:40:56] Bill, thank you for your patience consideration of the airport for its recommendation to select
[2:41:02] CS HQA as the architecture
[2:41:06] Firm for the airport terminal modification
[2:41:09] project, we have our airport manager built.
[2:41:12] Herberry and welcome Bill.
[2:41:13] Thank you, Mayor.
[2:41:14] Good evening, Council members.
[2:41:16] Dialing back a couple of years ago, in late 2012,
[2:41:20] we finished the airport's master plan update.
[2:41:23] And one of the development concepts that came out
[2:41:27] was that we needed to do something
[2:41:28] with our airport terminal building.
[2:41:30] You know, looking back to the formation of the TSA,
[2:41:33] the check bag, the screening function.
[2:41:36] Those were things that weren't designed
[2:41:38] into the building when it was constructed in the mid-90s.
[2:41:41] So just to touch on a couple of these overall goals
[2:41:45] with this thermal re-modification project,
[2:41:48] we're looking at adding additional sterile hold room area.
[2:41:51] The hold room has constraints to it.
[2:41:54] I think that was amplified with the previous period
[2:41:57] that Allegiant was here.
[2:41:59] We had issues with serving that with the size of the room.
[2:42:02] There's no restrooms in there.
[2:42:03] That's probably our number one complaint.
[2:42:06] We're looking to move the explosive trace detection equipment that you see in the lobby
[2:42:12] now back behind the wall.
[2:42:15] We really need to get that out of the lobby open up circulation as well.
[2:42:18] So really we need to do some basic evolutionary changes to the airport terminal building.
[2:42:26] So with that, we set out with our capital improvement plan now that we've got a lot
[2:42:30] of pavement rehabilitation work done this last year to set out on selecting an architect.
[2:42:36] And the way we do that is through a qualification-based selection process through an RFQ.
[2:42:41] So we let an RFQ out, we advertised for that, that got out in the trade papers, and we received
[2:42:47] a three-statement of qualifications, all from excellent firms.
[2:42:52] We heard back from inside architects out of Boise who teamed with JVH and the Denver Aviation
[2:42:57] Firm, and they're most recently working on the Idaho Falls Terminal.
[2:43:02] Rental Smith and Hill, RS&H, their Denver firm,
[2:43:06] an aviation firm does a lot of terminal work
[2:43:10] all around the country.
[2:43:12] And we also heard from CSH, QA from Boise,
[2:43:15] who does quite a bit of airport work
[2:43:18] as well as other work around the country.
[2:43:21] Most notably in town, you may know that the Glantbier
[2:43:24] building was designed by CSHQA as well in our community.
[2:43:29] Before I go any further, I just as a way
[2:43:30] about just a brief shout out here introduction.
[2:43:34] That's Martin Hale, the principal architect of CHQA,
[2:43:38] and he's team with Rita Sel engineering
[2:43:40] with his firm as well.
[2:43:44] Went to the airport board and said,
[2:43:46] hey, we've got some interviews to do.
[2:43:47] We've got three really good firms.
[2:43:49] How would you like me to handle this?
[2:43:50] Would you like to set up a subcommittee,
[2:43:52] do public interviews,
[2:43:53] or would you like me to handle this on a staff level?
[2:43:56] They were uncomfortable with public interviews,
[2:43:58] So they asked me to handle the interviews on a staff level.
[2:44:01] Doing that, I assembled what I thought was a good team.
[2:44:04] We had Dwayne Thompson as our building official.
[2:44:09] Patty Gleiman from our finance department was part of that
[2:44:13] interview team.
[2:44:14] Terry Moreto, the SkyWest station manager,
[2:44:17] direct stakeholder there, was part of that team,
[2:44:20] as well as Steve's story of a retired
[2:44:23] air traffic manager.
[2:44:24] They assisted me on these interviews.
[2:44:27] We held the interviews on January 6th.
[2:44:31] The group felt that, once again, they were all excellent firms,
[2:44:34] but CSHQA was the firm that rise to the top in their view.
[2:44:41] So with that, I brought this interview committee's
[2:44:44] recommendation to the airport board meeting the following day
[2:44:46] on January 7th.
[2:44:48] Discussed the strengths of the firms, the recommendation
[2:44:52] from the interview committee, and the airport board
[2:44:55] voted unanimously with their concurrence and asked me to bring forward the recommendation
[2:45:01] for CSHQA.
[2:45:04] Looking at the budget impact where we are now, we're looking at a selection.
[2:45:07] That's the action tonight.
[2:45:09] Concurrence are not with this selection.
[2:45:11] And then from that, we'll be moving into scoping the work and moving into negotiating
[2:45:18] a contract.
[2:45:19] And so I'll be back before you with a contract proposal in the future.
[2:45:23] right now, we're looking to get going on the work, scoping, and moving ahead with a firm.
[2:45:32] From a regulatory impact perspective, we follow the FAA procedures. The FAA will be a big player
[2:45:38] in this as we look at funding mechanisms. We'll be looking at our airport improvement
[2:45:43] funding program as well as our passenger facility charges. Part of the initial scope of work
[2:45:49] that we'll be doing with CSHQA,
[2:45:51] we'll be taking a look at how this project could be funded.
[2:45:56] So we'll be looking at funding integration,
[2:45:57] funding sources, and how we'll go ahead with that.
[2:46:00] So you'll be hearing after this phase one,
[2:46:02] after we have a contract, and I'll remind you again,
[2:46:04] as we get closer to a contract.
[2:46:07] There'll be initial phase one that's really gonna look at,
[2:46:09] what are we looking at, what are we looking to build?
[2:46:12] Here's maybe option A, option B,
[2:46:14] option C, here are some potential ways to fund this.
[2:46:17] So I'll be bringing back those things for discussion in the future.
[2:46:22] So with that, I look for your concurrence with the airport board's recommendation to move
[2:46:27] ahead with the scoping and the contract negotiations with CSHQA.
[2:46:32] Any questions, Council?
[2:46:35] Rebecca Mills-Soyka.
[2:46:37] Thank you, Mayor.
[2:46:38] Thank you, Mr. Carberry, for your presentation.
[2:46:41] In reviewing the applications, I would concur that the resume or the package that CSHQA presented,
[2:46:50] their work has been varied throughout the United States and even in Idaho.
[2:46:56] I noticed that the focus on lead certified projects, is there any opportunity, are you
[2:47:04] looking for the opportunity to incorporate any lead aspects of this building project,
[2:47:09] or is that any part of your decision making process?
[2:47:13] I think it's still yet to be determined.
[2:47:15] I know there are various levels.
[2:47:17] With the recent storm over the equipment building,
[2:47:19] we didn't get LEED certification with that,
[2:47:22] but we did look certainly for energy efficiency
[2:47:24] and some sustainability.
[2:47:26] I think Martin brings an area of expertise with that,
[2:47:29] so I think we'll have a robust discussion about that
[2:47:33] and then the cost benefits and the sustainability issues
[2:47:36] when it comes to our systems in there.
[2:47:38] Certainly, and I would certainly encourage that.
[2:47:41] And I'd like to comment that Martin actually looks good for the past 176 years.
[2:47:49] He's been working on all aspects of the terminal design.
[2:47:51] So he looks very good for his age.
[2:47:53] It's typing, probably, with something like that.
[2:47:57] No, in all seriousness, no, I just looked at that and it made me go.
[2:48:01] But in all seriousness, the resume is quite impressive and I guess I'll wait for a motion.
[2:48:09] or I'll make a motion.
[2:48:12] I'll make a motion that the city council concurs
[2:48:15] with the airport board's recommendation
[2:48:17] to select CSHQA as the architecture firm
[2:48:20] for the airport terminal modification project.
[2:48:25] Second.
[2:48:26] We have a motion on the floor by Rebecca Milsoyka,
[2:48:28] seconded by Suzanne Hawkins.
[2:48:30] Do we have anything further on that motion, Rebecca?
[2:48:33] Your light's still on, did you have further on your motion?
[2:48:36] Bill, I do have a question for you after this.
[2:48:38] So if you could just hang loose for a second,
[2:48:40] Any questions, Council?
[2:48:43] Please call the roll call vote.
[2:48:45] Jim Munn.
[2:48:46] Yes.
[2:48:47] Sean Berriger.
[2:48:48] Yes.
[2:48:49] Chris Talkington.
[2:48:50] Yes.
[2:48:50] Greg Lanting.
[2:48:51] Yes.
[2:48:52] Don Hall.
[2:48:52] Yes.
[2:48:53] Rebecca Milsoyka.
[2:48:54] Yes.
[2:48:55] Suzanne Hawkins.
[2:48:56] Yes.
[2:48:57] Motion passes seven to zero.
[2:48:58] You had a quizzical look on your face
[2:49:00] at the end of that motion.
[2:49:01] Did we, what's that?
[2:49:08] That tells me I didn't, and we'll discuss it later.
[2:49:10] Okay. Bill, just a real quick question. Years ago, when Allegiance came here, we put money
[2:49:19] out towards this new ramp, stairway. What are we doing with that? Is that useful in the
[2:49:28] aircraft that we have now? Are we storing that somewhere safe to keep it nice? If I recall,
[2:49:33] it was fairly pricey.
[2:49:35] Yeah, we utilized the state grant. We were fortunate to have some state grant.
[2:49:39] to work with, so I think it was a good application for that. I think it was somewhere around $30,000.
[2:49:45] We have used it and it enables us when we get large general aviation charters when it would
[2:49:50] be a diplomat from Italy that's coming to the Allen Convention in July. We do from time
[2:49:56] to time have larger aircraft and we also get larger aircraft diverting in if there's fog
[2:50:02] in Salt Lake, we may get a 757 that comes in those types of things.
[2:50:06] So we allow all comers to use it, whether it be Sky West,
[2:50:11] readers, so it's a public instrument that we allow them to do.
[2:50:16] So, yeah, on occasion we absolutely do use it.
[2:50:18] Can you probably have told us that before?
[2:50:20] I just did.
[2:50:20] No, it's a good question, Azim.
[2:50:22] OK.
[2:50:22] Follow up to that.
[2:50:23] So it is a very helpful tool.
[2:50:24] OK.
[2:50:25] Very safe.
[2:50:26] Well, thank you and thank you again for your presentation.
[2:50:29] Thank you.
[2:50:29] Thank you, gentlemen.
[2:50:31] Moving beyond number five, because I did that earlier,
[2:50:35] we were moving to number six,
[2:50:36] discussion of the draft, of draft three,
[2:50:39] of the agreement with Beckley, not Buckley,
[2:50:42] Beckley, media to use the Twin Falls City property
[2:50:45] in his effort to jump the Snake River Canyon.
[2:50:47] This will not be an action item.
[2:50:50] Travis Rothweiler is going to do this portion.
[2:50:53] Mr. Mayor, members and council will make this fairly brief
[2:50:56] because there aren't any significant changes
[2:50:59] to this agreement.
[2:51:00] I will just state that time is running near in terms of the deadlines that we have set.
[2:51:09] We continue to have additional conversations moving forward with this.
[2:51:12] I want to highlight four or five quick changes that we have spent in this agreement so far.
[2:51:19] And then I want to draw your attention to a couple of spots.
[2:51:23] Number one, in section four of the agreement, we added the additional individuals who have
[2:51:29] the ability to jump or to complete the jump.
[2:51:35] And we're also working through
[2:51:37] under what those emergency circumstances look like.
[2:51:40] And so know that what is here,
[2:51:42] I believe we can stay still very much in draft form,
[2:51:45] but it is getting the concept across.
[2:51:49] Number two, we wanted it known very, very clearly
[2:51:52] because there might have been some,
[2:51:57] I won't call it this communication,
[2:51:59] because I think that we've been incredibly clear,
[2:52:01] that we really do not want alcohol associated at the jump site.
[2:52:05] I think that that has been very clear.
[2:52:07] I think that ECLI media has also stated
[2:52:12] that they were not necessarily inclined to having alcohol being
[2:52:17] served, and so we've talked about that.
[2:52:21] One of the things, and this is actually the third change
[2:52:25] that we have is found on page two,
[2:52:28] which is on paragraph two, section two, subsection A,
[2:52:33] subsection one, where we state that they need to have approval
[2:52:39] from Twin Falls County.
[2:52:40] One of the things that we've had conversations about in terms
[2:52:43] of the prosecution services, the potential impacts on the courts
[2:52:47] and the impacts on the jail was how do we navigate through that?
[2:52:51] And the prosecutor had suggested that in a conversation
[2:52:57] that he had with our legal counsel that maybe it's best
[2:53:01] if they work independently with Beckley through this process
[2:53:05] and what they share with us is that we have an agreement
[2:53:09] and this is what the agreement says,
[2:53:11] but there really kind of does take the city
[2:53:14] out of that intermediary role
[2:53:16] and allows them to work collectively
[2:53:19] on finding that solution.
[2:53:20] We think that both Grant and Prince,
[2:53:23] I think was pretty happy with that too
[2:53:25] because we really struggled to try to figure out
[2:53:28] what that looked like.
[2:53:31] The, one of the things that I think
[2:53:33] Beckley Media had a conversation about,
[2:53:36] and I think that Captain Barnhart is going to highlight
[2:53:40] this a bit to talk about this,
[2:53:42] but it's on page 15 of the agreement in section 12C
[2:53:50] where you have the ancillary events.
[2:53:52] So you'll remember that to represent
[2:53:55] from Black Bekley Media were talking about how they did not want to be responsible for
[2:54:01] those fees that were being or be responsible for fees or expenses that were being generated
[2:54:07] by events outside of the ones that they were producing.
[2:54:11] And so we have Paragraph C inserted in there to cover that and then the additional was
[2:54:16] recovering of staff time in this process, that expenditure.
[2:54:19] And one of the things that we're looking for is that once this agreement is outlined, we will go forward and we will submit our first bill, if you will, of the accounting of those hours.
[2:54:29] And we will do so in 30 to 60 day increments as we move forward.
[2:54:34] We've also, as I think John Simmons and shared last time, we agree to have a conversation about those fees.
[2:54:40] Staff's responsibility is to make sure we're documenting and accounting for our time appropriately and in the manner that's available.
[2:54:47] So, that's what we're doing.
[2:54:49] Those really do constitute the hidden significant changes.
[2:54:54] It shouldn't be any real big surprises in this
[2:54:56] in comparison to what we've seen.
[2:54:58] The one thing that, I guess, seeking your guidance in Prince
[2:55:02] and I talked a little bit about this,
[2:55:04] there are still some blanks in this agreement that talk
[2:55:07] about milestones and dates.
[2:55:09] One of them, they begin to appear on page three.
[2:55:14] They appear on page 5, and they also appear on page 6,
[2:55:19] and the blanks are really the timelines
[2:55:22] in which they have to complete the phases.
[2:55:24] And so staff can put in those dates and times
[2:55:29] as an initial conversation internally,
[2:55:31] and present those next week for your review.
[2:55:34] And more you can, over the course of the next few days,
[2:55:38] if you want to look at that and think about that,
[2:55:41] submit those dates to us, and we will incorporate that
[2:55:44] into our decision-making process.
[2:55:50] Greg Lanning.
[2:55:52] Travis, you know, following up on an article
[2:55:55] in the newspaper either today or yesterday.
[2:55:58] I read them in the middle of the night,
[2:55:59] so I can't remember which day I read them,
[2:56:01] because I read them online.
[2:56:04] And there apparently is going to be another jump,
[2:56:07] possibly a week or so, prior to this one
[2:56:10] that we have no control over yet could provide us
[2:56:14] some of the exact same issues as Mr. Beckley's.
[2:56:18] And so my concern there is like,
[2:56:21] have they dealt with the county?
[2:56:23] If it's like, if I'm gonna require
[2:56:25] Mr. Beckley to have prosecutor costs,
[2:56:28] does the other group gonna have to have it?
[2:56:31] Are they not allowing alcohol?
[2:56:33] Like Mr. Beckley is not which could actually provide us
[2:56:35] with more issues.
[2:56:37] It's kinda like the second one
[2:56:39] is kinda reminds me of the one back in 74
[2:56:43] when the city had no control of what we were just
[2:56:45] party in it whereas this one we seem to we because we own the land we've been able
[2:56:51] to have some control and some input on what how things occur the second one to
[2:56:56] be caught on so as you opens up a whole can of worms for the second one I kind of
[2:57:00] look up on the one is JV and the the big one using our side is varsity but
[2:57:05] you know to use a sports analogy like you still like to do but it's still
[2:57:12] because some of the same issues and we don't have any, at this point, you know, I'm kind
[2:57:19] of lost on where are we at as far as some of our expenses that may occur from that one
[2:57:23] and we have no control over it.
[2:57:26] You know, I think that's a really good question, so I think that there could be some indirect
[2:57:31] costs or some direct costs however we want to look at it with an event that is going
[2:57:37] to take place a week before the event that we've been working and coordinating through.
[2:57:42] And so if so for the people maybe that are watching or streaming that did not have a chance
[2:57:48] to read the Times News today, there was a story that shared that there is a another group that
[2:57:57] intends to make a similar jump just going the opposite direction close to the Hanson Bridge.
[2:58:07] And I believe their targeted jump date is sometime about the first of September.
[2:58:16] When I was contacted yesterday by the Times News, it was really was news to me.
[2:58:24] And I think that it was probably news to all of us.
[2:58:26] I know that Commissioner Morley is here.
[2:58:29] I believe Commissioner Morley had shared with this group at a previous meeting that no
[2:58:37] permits had been necessarily issued. I think in the newspaper story today he had shared that
[2:58:43] he was confused with linking the events in terms of what that had looked like. We have
[2:58:51] not had any conversation with the other group that is looking at making those jumps. It is
[2:58:58] is really outside of our jurisdiction.
[2:59:00] I was surprised personally that with the level of conversation
[2:59:09] and engagement that we've had from the prosecutor's office,
[2:59:12] that this event kind of did not perceive,
[2:59:16] or at least to my knowledge, that same level of process
[2:59:20] and questioning.
[2:59:21] And so I don't know where Twin Falls County is at in the review
[2:59:25] of this process.
[2:59:26] If they've reviewed this process,
[2:59:28] We have not been included in those conversations.
[2:59:31] And we didn't even know that the jump was moving forward
[2:59:38] until I think some of us until yesterday
[2:59:40] when we were interviewed or today when we read the paper.
[2:59:47] I think that the group that is the group has got record
[2:59:52] and Scott Truax and I think that you'll recall
[2:59:55] And when they made their presentation at the middle school,
[3:00:00] they had actually shared that it wasn't their intent
[3:00:03] to recuse themselves from the process that we had set forward
[3:00:07] and they were going to go out and go their own direction.
[3:00:09] That was really the last that we had heard
[3:00:14] as an organization, at least the last that I'm aware
[3:00:16] that we heard from an organization of what their intent was.
[3:00:19] I wasn't, I was surprised to find that they were as far along
[3:00:23] in their process as what they appear to be.
[3:00:26] Thank you, Travis.
[3:00:28] Chris, talking to you.
[3:00:29] Answer your first question earlier on.
[3:00:31] I wouldn't know how to set any dates on pages 3, 5, and 6.
[3:00:35] I'd rather you come to the council with the dates
[3:00:39] and rationalize or justify those dates.
[3:00:42] Second thing, since the council has allowed somebody other
[3:00:45] than Beckley to jump if he gets a sort of wonder
[3:00:48] if the Beckley group has supplied the names yet
[3:00:51] of the older nuts.
[3:00:52] They did that night, Chris.
[3:00:54] They helped.
[3:00:56] Well, they verbalized.
[3:00:57] I don't think there's anything in writing.
[3:00:59] I thought they sent their resume in emails.
[3:01:02] Their resume.
[3:01:03] Did you get that?
[3:01:04] OK.
[3:01:05] All right.
[3:01:05] Want to make sure that they're firm.
[3:01:06] Yeah, those two individuals.
[3:01:08] They are listed on page six, Gene Sullivan and or Bubba
[3:01:18] Blackwell.
[3:01:19] I guess I thought those were tentative, but not the ones
[3:01:22] they've affirmed my understanding is that they've already started the training with
[3:01:26] them. Mr. Backley said is that is my understanding is that they are the the
[3:01:33] alternates that have so they will be in the the ultimate contract. That is my
[3:01:38] understanding and and they we as you recall asked the opportunity to to meet
[3:01:46] them and and we will continue to work with Mr. Simmons to arrange that.
[3:01:50] So, a couple of items that I made note of prior to tonight's discussion.
[3:02:01] In the lease, it talks about if it's terminated that they have to return the site to the natural
[3:02:06] contour and vegetation.
[3:02:08] And I was actually concerned that if they actually had started some work that might be
[3:02:11] beneficial to us, to not require them to put that back.
[3:02:16] So I don't know if there needs to be some wiggle room language.
[3:02:18] I mean, if they go in and make the site work to do the ramp and then never do it, we probably
[3:02:26] don't want them to put the rocks and humps back in.
[3:02:31] On the dates, perhaps plugging in the same dates that are in the state lease that coincide
[3:02:37] to some of those might make sense.
[3:02:39] I'm a little bit with Chris.
[3:02:40] I don't know how you kind of just pick dates.
[3:02:44] So maybe if you guys pick dates, then we can go from their back timing to an event.
[3:02:52] On the county approval piece, so I actually had the opportunity to speak to Commissioner
[3:02:57] Mills today and ask a very similar question to what you just speculated about is there
[3:03:04] seemed to be a whole lot of interest in this process, but this other one just sort of happened
[3:03:08] and Twin Falls County's response was, you don't need our permission, so enjoy.
[3:03:14] And I questioned why that was, and his indication to me was, well, they're not doing anything
[3:03:21] really on this side of the property with public access, so we don't think it's going to have
[3:03:26] an impact.
[3:03:27] I think maybe this is a question for the police, is how do we ensure that we're engaging in
[3:03:33] those same conversations with whatever these events are going on, because they do think we
[3:03:37] all have some piece of the pie, no matter which event it is.
[3:03:42] So I'll just throw that one out there, kind of arbitrarily now.
[3:03:45] And when we talk about county approval, and this goes a bit to that, who are we talking
[3:03:52] about approval from?
[3:03:53] Is that commissioner approval?
[3:03:55] Is that the prosecutor's approval?
[3:03:57] Is that the sheriff's approval?
[3:03:59] Because my concern is the prosecutor's office and the sheriff's office seem to be very engaged
[3:04:04] in this process, and I don't feel that the commissioners are necessarily.
[3:04:08] We left it as county, the people that we were meeting with included the court administrator,
[3:04:16] grant loads, the jail, representatives of the jail.
[3:04:21] Okay.
[3:04:22] Now, it seems maybe like they're not talking to their commissioners.
[3:04:26] I don't know.
[3:04:27] And that might be something maybe we just want to clarify because if we just say county approval
[3:04:33] and Beckley media goes and gets a letter from the commissioners that says enjoy your event,
[3:04:39] And then we've got two or three or four other departments at the county that we've been in discussion with.
[3:04:44] I think that might be a little muddy, and one more thing for the one.
[3:04:53] Two more quick things.
[3:04:54] The media partnership language that we talked about last week, John indicated that there was maybe some
[3:05:02] some way we could include that, and I didn't see that.
[3:05:06] I didn't read it in great detail.
[3:05:08] But, and then I still have some concern
[3:05:13] with a two year window approval on the front end
[3:05:18] because things will change over the next two years
[3:05:22] in that neighborhood.
[3:05:23] And I would hate to give approval now that says
[3:05:26] you have a window open for two years.
[3:05:28] And then next year the neighboring subdivision develops.
[3:05:32] And we actually don't have a two year window in this one.
[3:05:40] If you look on the very first page, there's a start date and an end date, and those are
[3:05:45] two of those blanks that we were asking for, but my idea was this starts from the day that
[3:05:51] you approve it and it ends two weeks or a month after.
[3:05:55] At some point this fall.
[3:05:58] And maybe that would be some direction I would try to give on the date because I do think
[3:06:02] that without coming back with some revision or re-presentation of the plan, I think it's
[3:06:09] It's difficult to predict what the landscape is going to look like two years now.
[3:06:13] And I think that the way to assure if there is going to be a secondary event is to evaluate
[3:06:23] the first event.
[3:06:25] And I think that before I recognize and appreciate the fact that Mr. Beckley has a two-year lease
[3:06:34] for the state lands, but I think that Fritz is absolutely right.
[3:06:37] could be a host of monumental changes in our area that occur, especially with that subdivision.
[3:06:44] The event may go off famously, there is absolutely no issue, and we may do everything that we
[3:06:49] can to encourage that to occur again and again and again, or it may not be as successful as
[3:06:57] we all hope that it will be, and we will say that we'd really never to do that again.
[3:07:04] And I think that tying your hands on the front end of the agreement is probably not one of
[3:07:12] the best moves that we could make.
[3:07:15] There's certainly no problem with extending it and if that was something to be considered
[3:07:25] from an extension of the release, I think that you could probably build that in here.
[3:07:30] I think, like I said, doing it on the front end makes staff incredibly
[3:07:33] nervous.
[3:07:37] Rebecca Melsoyka?
[3:07:39] I would support maybe building in some language for potential extension, as you're saying.
[3:07:46] And I agree that we wouldn't want to approve anything before the first event has happened
[3:07:52] and we could evaluate it.
[3:07:55] But I wouldn't be opposed to adding language that would allow them to extend their lease
[3:07:59] should they choose and should the city approve?
[3:08:06] I'll weigh in, I'm kind of in the same boat and also on the date piece.
[3:08:10] I'd really like to hear back from staff and give some suggestions that give some guidance.
[3:08:14] And on the other jump issue, Commissioner Morley.
[3:08:21] I just wanted to say, I felt like we were a little bit taken to task about communication.
[3:08:27] And so we've really worked diligently on that.
[3:08:31] And reciprocal would be greatly appreciated.
[3:08:34] Because I had heard a rumor that there was a potential
[3:08:38] of a permit, and that's why I asked you that night.
[3:08:40] There has been a permit.
[3:08:42] But being a permit that does not mean they're going to jump.
[3:08:46] And I can't understand why they would ask me a question
[3:08:51] about our plans when they're not firmed up yet.
[3:08:53] We haven't firmed up anymore.
[3:08:55] And now we've formed a lot of things up since the last time we talked to you.
[3:08:58] But I really had, these guys went like they dropped out of sight after that first meeting.
[3:09:06] And everybody said, well they're going to join Ed's team, they're going to join this
[3:09:09] team, they're going to cross over to this team.
[3:09:12] And so I was under the impression and I'm not kidding, it was the only jumper I was.
[3:09:18] And we had not discussed, we had issued a permit because I mean anybody with 150 bucks can
[3:09:24] get a permit and say, OK, yeah, I can do all this stuff.
[3:09:28] And so we did issue that permit.
[3:09:31] I was quite taken back by the article today myself.
[3:09:35] That's why I'm here.
[3:09:37] I wanted to honestly give you all an apology for what I said.
[3:09:43] It was honestly not meant in any kind of a way that would
[3:09:51] throw us off our task off our scope.
[3:09:55] And now that I know we do have a jump that's going, and you have a jump that's going, then
[3:09:59] that's going to tax our infrastructure of both cities even more.
[3:10:03] But like I say, when they can have one issue up from it, that's all it is.
[3:10:09] They don't have to jump.
[3:10:10] And so we had lineups, we had several events, we had lined up, and they weren't done yet.
[3:10:16] So I wasn't sure if we were good or not, so I'm sorry.
[3:10:20] You know, Roger, the way I look at this is we're all kind of hooked at the hip here.
[3:10:25] what takes place over in Jerome, Twin Falls, Buell,
[3:10:29] it affects each of us and we need to work together
[3:10:32] and I take your word at your word.
[3:10:34] I do, regarding that, but let's work together.
[3:10:38] Let's make sure that if there is this other jump,
[3:10:41] which we have absolutely no control of,
[3:10:45] we just need to have some indication
[3:10:48] what's going to happen so we can prepare
[3:10:50] because you're exactly right.
[3:10:52] We're already probably going to stretch
[3:10:54] resources as thin as we can for the time that we have our jump and to throw
[3:10:59] another one on top of it. I'm gravely concerned. Don't you'll have to understand
[3:11:03] that the only reason I was here at the first meeting was because I heard about
[3:11:07] your jump on the television. Right. You hadn't contacted us. Right. So I mean
[3:11:12] turn about is exactly fair play and if you want to be joined at the hip or mind
[3:11:16] yourself don't concern one person as JV and the other one as far as city. Yeah
[3:11:22] And I agree with that too, sir.
[3:11:24] And I'm not looking for a tip for TAT here.
[3:11:28] That's not why I asked.
[3:11:29] I just wanted to make sure that we continue this communication.
[3:11:32] From this point on, we're all on the same page.
[3:11:34] I mean, even me, I don't know how I got off track on this deal.
[3:11:39] But people were like, say, dropping out and changing teams.
[3:11:43] And so I thought it was the only guy.
[3:11:46] In fact, when we went to see his rocket last week,
[3:11:49] Ed went with Scott.
[3:11:51] Well, I just have seen some great communication and again, I always joke about that canyon being deep and white sometimes.
[3:12:01] I saw it starting to close in and I don't want to see it go back out.
[3:12:05] No, and we don't either. The world's getting too small. I agree with that, sir.
[3:12:09] I'd like to throw a little water in of the mud or mud into the water because I continue to hear rumors of a potential third one. Okay.
[3:12:16] That's it commissioner. Morley do you have any knowledge of a third job?
[3:12:22] Because I do not have any
[3:12:24] No, I'm not bringing that up. I think if there's a third one we're gonna have to redo our budget
[3:12:29] I think I'm saying is that this is a largely out of our control
[3:12:33] The parties doing what they want and we are
[3:12:36] Join at the hip and we are communicating
[3:12:38] But you know there's been any oversight on our part then we throw you an apology
[3:12:43] But it and and my as well to you. I honestly before I saw that on the news
[3:12:48] I honestly believed in my heart that there would never ever be another jump over this canyon ever again to the last time
[3:12:57] There still may not be there still may not be and it's that's
[3:13:02] I
[3:13:03] Just put all those things together and it did honestly shock you guys. It said yes after what happened last time
[3:13:09] And so that's why I was here and
[3:13:11] Well we have not said yes to anything. No, I'm standing here. We're still we're still working through it. Greg landing. Well, well, what I want to apologize in my mind, I was thinking maybe that's how Beckley looks at it. Is this one is a smaller event?
[3:13:27] His is actually a motorcycle. This is back to a rocket because I start thinking about how we have drones flying over the world at this point. And at this point, you could strap a man underneath the drone, have him take off of the airport and land over to your airport and land.
[3:13:40] to your airport and land.
[3:13:41] And so a rocket type thing really doesn't have the same feel
[3:13:45] as the motorcycles.
[3:13:46] My apologies, I really wasn't looking at that,
[3:13:49] plus the fact that they were listing a much smaller event
[3:13:52] than Mr. Beckley's listing is a little,
[3:13:54] kind of felt like the AV at Barstown.
[3:13:55] Certainly wasn't the meaning just
[3:13:57] because it started on your side.
[3:13:59] I was talking about the jump itself,
[3:14:00] but it's still gonna have just like Don said
[3:14:03] and I said earlier.
[3:14:04] This could have a major effect upon us
[3:14:06] and this one feels like the last one
[3:14:08] because we don't have any control over it.
[3:14:11] Well, we're all having a hard time getting a handle on it.
[3:14:14] This one we feel like we have control.
[3:14:16] It kind of like morphs as you try to work with it.
[3:14:19] Well, welcome to our world.
[3:14:21] Yeah.
[3:14:22] Well, I honestly did not know that segment was going,
[3:14:25] and I wanted to apologize.
[3:14:27] And I wasn't looking forward to apology.
[3:14:28] I just wanted to make sure that we maintain the communication.
[3:14:31] I want to be a good leader of my community,
[3:14:32] and I do love Jerome, and I would not have misled anybody
[3:14:36] or to light to anybody for any amount of money or reason or anything else that's
[3:14:42] just not the reason I'm here. Thank you sir I appreciate your time. Moving on to
[3:14:48] unless there's other issues or questions regarding this moving on to the next
[3:14:51] item on the agenda is the general update on the public safety and possible
[3:14:57] compensation and it's going to be shared with both Travis Rathweiler and our
[3:15:01] Captain Barn who is used to graveyard so there's no big deal you being here at
[3:15:05] So we have no update on the compensation piece.
[3:15:09] It remains in the same format manner that was previously.
[3:15:13] Captain Barnhart, welcome.
[3:15:17] Good evening, Mr. Mayor and members of the Council.
[3:15:19] I really don't have a lot to update you on from last week.
[3:15:23] I would say that the time that I spent with Jim Molzak
[3:15:27] last week, I thought was productive. He knows exactly where we stand
[3:15:31] and where we want to go. And at this point in time, we're really
[3:15:35] just waiting to see his public safety plan and then we'll know better how we're
[3:15:40] going to augment that. The one thing that I would like to bring before the council
[3:15:44] this evening and ask for your consideration would be to not allow any
[3:15:49] other special events during this this particular event and that would be and I
[3:15:54] would ask for one week on each side of the event date. So beginning February I'm
[3:16:00] I'm sorry, August 29th, that would be a Friday through Sunday, September 14th is the time
[3:16:07] frame that I'm asking for.
[3:16:09] One of the most obvious reasons is that our resources will be stretched thin as it is.
[3:16:14] And if there is this second jump that weekend before, we'll have to be prepared to handle
[3:16:21] any events within the city's going to hold.
[3:16:23] Make that move for May occur.
[3:16:25] Thank you, sir.
[3:16:27] We have a couple of lights and we're starting off with Greg Land.
[3:16:31] Well, uh, Captain Barnard, the only concern I have on that particular request is that, uh,
[3:16:39] my concern is having things for people to do who are here and maybe coming in days ahead
[3:16:45] and days afterwards, and my thought would be, and obviously you disagree, but my thought
[3:16:50] would be to give them something to do but only allow those that had the wherewithal and
[3:16:56] on our approval to provide their own private security and abundance.
[3:17:01] So in other words, they were taking care of their issues with that event because I'm not
[3:17:06] sure if the numbers that are being credit carded so we can't sleep all the ones that are either
[3:17:14] abandoned is talking about.
[3:17:16] There's not enough room.
[3:17:17] Do we want them just wandering around or would we really have events that they could go to
[3:17:22] which would in their nature would allow for more of the dollars to stay right here in the
[3:17:29] or charitable organizations running like rotary or they could go for the downtown park or other
[3:17:35] different things. I'm just saying if they had the weather with all to have their own security
[3:17:39] and not put it by us but that may not be the case. That was just my thought. I'm obviously not
[3:17:44] married to it but it was one of those things that the city park is empty during that days.
[3:17:49] I don't know if that makes sense if that the day before would say so.
[3:17:53] And like us, I can only imagine private security is going to be stretched extremely thin during this time period as well.
[3:18:00] Okay. Good point. Chris, talking.
[3:18:05] Well, I applaud your idea of providing that umbrella.
[3:18:09] I think that to do otherwise is putting cash registers over public safety.
[3:18:14] And if we're expecting 70,000, not 40,000, 70,000 as they said before,
[3:18:21] They're going to be arriving early and staying late.
[3:18:24] I don't think that necessarily 10 days or two weeks is an absolute number, but I sure see
[3:18:29] the need if you view it from a public safety perspective to provide some exclusivity and
[3:18:36] some safety cushion as you will.
[3:18:41] Do the other party know that there's this February date looming where they haven't provided a
[3:18:47] safety plan to you yet?
[3:18:49] I believe that they are aware of a date and are they taking a serious they are moving forward with the plan?
[3:18:55] Yes, if I don't get it. I'm voting against it
[3:19:00] Do you anticipate we'll have it my next Monday? I would think so Councilor
[3:19:06] Jim on
[3:19:07] Thank you. I was just kind of waiting on what?
[3:19:11] Councilman
[3:19:12] Landing said if you know my experience tells me that if you do allow certain special events to occur
[3:19:19] within the umbrella, for example, if you have something at City Park, a band concert, or some sort of event, and you allow private security,
[3:19:30] I know that a lot of times that doesn't work very well because they don't have the authority to provide public safety properly.
[3:19:39] They don't have the power to arrest like a police officer and so forth.
[3:19:42] So I'm leaning towards buying into your process here.
[3:19:47] I just don't think that private security is going to be adequate for
[3:19:51] some big events that may occur adjacent to or in other areas.
[3:19:57] So I think you guys have thought this thing through pretty well.
[3:20:00] So I'm with you.
[3:20:02] I would also add to that that private security is always going to have to be augmented with police.
[3:20:07] And there are, I think, even some requirements when alcohol is served at these events,
[3:20:13] that the things are mandated to be at these events as well.
[3:20:16] So.
[3:20:17] Yeah, you have to have the police there if you're going to have alcohol served,
[3:20:19] because you're going to have trouble, by the western days issues and so forth.
[3:20:25] Rebecca Mel Suica.
[3:20:27] Thank you, Mayor.
[3:20:30] Wow, I just don't know if I can commit right now to supporting that length of time.
[3:20:36] One week on either side does seem a bit extreme.
[3:20:40] My caution in approving that is just for the sake
[3:20:45] of other citizens that live in the city and it's their city
[3:20:49] and it's their town and they may have already had
[3:20:53] something planned or they have a certain event.
[3:20:57] I can understand definitely the day of the event
[3:21:00] in a few days before and after because I think you
[3:21:05] I think you made good points about the safety, maybe the difficulties with private security,
[3:21:12] but I just would hate to let one event, one outside event, you know, really take precedence
[3:21:18] over citizens who live here and take precedence over the rest of the community.
[3:21:24] Maybe we need to get more public input on that aspect.
[3:21:28] I would like to see some well-organized events, you know, if it can be controlled, if it's,
[3:21:35] and maybe one of your options is to not allow alcohol.
[3:21:38] I mean, maybe that cuts down on some of the security and the safety issues.
[3:21:44] But I just, I'm not sure if I can support that time frame right now.
[3:21:49] Suzanne, huh?
[3:21:50] Oh, I'm sorry.
[3:21:51] I'm, no, go ahead.
[3:21:52] I'm just...
[3:21:53] I'm going to add one thing for you to consider while you're thinking about this is the number of people that will take to work these events.
[3:22:02] And we only have so many, so that means we're going to be working these men and women of the police department maybe two weeks straight in a row.
[3:22:12] So that would be something to consider as well.
[3:22:15] Sure.
[3:22:16] Suzanne Hawkins, thank you.
[3:22:17] I don't know if this is thinking too far out,
[3:22:20] but going back to the event now that could possibly happen
[3:22:23] the week before, that would be the same weekend
[3:22:25] as the Twin Falls County Fair weekend.
[3:22:28] Do we as the city support the displease offer anything?
[3:22:32] Do we provide help with that?
[3:22:35] Is that going to stretch us another direction?
[3:22:38] We do, Council, it's very minimal.
[3:22:40] Our traffic unit will go over in a system
[3:22:43] with some traffic control issues over in the city of Filer
[3:22:47] or around the county over there.
[3:22:50] They do ask and they do pay our officers
[3:22:52] when they go over to work,
[3:22:54] but typically we don't send a whole lot of officers
[3:22:56] in the fair to work that with the county.
[3:22:58] I know it's out of our hands, but maybe
[3:23:02] we can make sure that others are aware
[3:23:04] that that weekend is already pretty overloaded
[3:23:08] in the county if they're gonna try
[3:23:10] to jump the same weekend as that.
[3:23:11] To me that would be, I mean, I know we don't have control,
[3:23:15] But food for thought, I guess.
[3:23:19] You know, I've been thinking about this for a time,
[3:23:22] and especially knowing now there's going to be a jump before.
[3:23:24] And thank you for sharing that it's
[3:23:27] going to be fair weekend, too.
[3:23:28] I wasn't aware of that.
[3:23:30] I certainly would support the week before.
[3:23:34] Maybe I just need a little more information, Captain.
[3:23:37] And maybe we need to look at this case by case,
[3:23:40] because some events won't need security
[3:23:44] because of the type of event.
[3:23:46] You know, I sat at a table the other night at an event with a gentleman and his fiance
[3:23:51] that are getting married that same day and they're very concerned because already the
[3:23:57] hotel prices are sky high and their guests coming in and also, well, their joke was they
[3:24:03] didn't want the crowd screaming as he makes the jump right as they're doing their vows
[3:24:09] and we shared with him, that might be really cool for your vows, but that just illustrates,
[3:24:13] I just hear that story because that just illustrates that life goes on, even though this is happening,
[3:24:18] and we need to be somewhat sensitive about that.
[3:24:21] But, Anthony, I understand exactly what you're saying.
[3:24:24] We're stretching our people, and especially with this other event.
[3:24:27] So, I just want us to be sensitive.
[3:24:29] Well, the one thing that we've primarily been talking about this evening are events, and that
[3:24:34] we cannot remember that we still are going to have to maintain some level of service to
[3:24:40] our citizens and the visitors to our community as well.
[3:24:43] that's what I'm really thinking about. You know, we might get away with one or two officers at
[3:24:48] one of these side events, but how many calls for service are we going to be able to handle
[3:24:54] during that same time frame? You might have to call Jim Lund back into duty.
[3:25:02] The bad guys might be counting on that too then.
[3:25:05] Yeah.
[3:25:07] Yeah.
[3:25:08] All of a sudden.
[3:25:09] Back to public safety.
[3:25:10] Great landing.
[3:25:11] I just wanted to expand on mine.
[3:25:13] I was certainly the one I think I was talking about events that would bring even more people
[3:25:19] to town.
[3:25:20] I was just trying to serve the people who were already here like a soccer tournament or something
[3:25:23] like that.
[3:25:24] Obviously, I wouldn't be voting for that that would actually try to bring even more people
[3:25:29] here.
[3:25:30] That's what I was just talking about, the people who are already here and possibly give
[3:25:34] them something to do.
[3:25:35] And I obviously wouldn't be allowing any alcohol at any of those in my mind anyway.
[3:25:42] Sean Barrier.
[3:25:44] Would it be possible to get a list of past special events that have typically occurred
[3:25:50] in that time frame?
[3:25:51] So I know of a couple community events that have happened for many, many years that fall
[3:25:57] within these dates.
[3:26:00] And there, I think, needs to be some sensitivity to that as well, about saying, sorry, you can't
[3:26:07] do your event because we're doing this other thing.
[3:26:10] So if we could maybe get that list from your Sergeant Paulen to take that into consideration,
[3:26:18] again, I think, someone on a case-by-case look, if you're doing a, you know, kids' fun run
[3:26:26] on some trail that's not even in town that weekend,
[3:26:31] that's gonna, that maybe still has to have our permission
[3:26:34] because it starts at the visitor center.
[3:26:36] For example, and goes down to agra falls,
[3:26:38] that we have some consideration for that.
[3:26:41] So if we could get that list,
[3:26:42] that would certainly help me be a little more thoughtful
[3:26:45] as opposed to just saying,
[3:26:47] I mean, are you gonna cancel Labor Day
[3:26:49] because it have falls during that timeframe?
[3:26:52] It kind of gets to that point where it's like, you know?
[3:26:55] I just hope that your birthday doesn't fall during that.
[3:26:57] No, I'm a couple months or.
[3:26:59] We can bring that list to you.
[3:27:01] And I think that we already have some applications for that same time period as well.
[3:27:05] We'll bring what we're.
[3:27:06] Thank you.
[3:27:07] We're back from El Surica.
[3:27:08] Thank you, Mayor.
[3:27:09] I concur with Councilman Burger, I think it's a good idea.
[3:27:13] But just to clarify, and not to state the obvious, but the first jump if it happens is
[3:27:19] in the city of Hanson, correct, or somewhere out in the county.
[3:27:24] And it's not in the city of Hanson, but it's it's it's in the
[3:27:28] Yeah, so it's it's in the unincorporated areas of both Jerome County and Twin Falls County in close proximity to the Hanson Bridge
[3:27:39] Correct so when we're talking about using our resources during this time
[3:27:43] We're just talking about any possible crime or activities that maybe come from obviously
[3:27:50] we're not going to be responding out in that area of Eden, as well beyond our jurisdiction.
[3:27:57] But we're talking about possible incidents that may be related to persons coming from
[3:28:04] this other jump event, or I'm confused about why we're concerned about the other jump.
[3:28:09] I think the primary concern would be the increase in our population from that event as well.
[3:28:14] So our population increases, our calls for service increase, and we really need more men
[3:28:19] and women on the on the streets to handle those calls for service so we would
[3:28:24] definitely increase the number of police officers working during that time frame
[3:28:29] okay potentially and it's not unheard of for us to go help our
[3:28:36] neighboring communities if they have a true there I know that Chief Deputy
[3:28:41] Newman knew that this second jump was a possibility but I haven't spoken since
[3:28:46] the article this morning, I can only imagine that he may be asking for for some assistance.
[3:28:52] Great, man. Well, it just looked like you said, like Travis just said, it was from an
[3:29:00] unincorporated area of drum to an unincorporated area of Twin Falls County. That sounds like 1974.
[3:29:07] It was from an unincorporated part of Twin Falls County to an unincorporated part of
[3:29:11] of grown county, and we still have the issues.
[3:29:14] That's why I have the concern.
[3:29:16] We have some control over the one,
[3:29:19] and we can require them to do certain things,
[3:29:22] but we don't have control of this other one,
[3:29:24] and all those people, if they're here,
[3:29:26] we gotta deal with them, so I agree.
[3:29:27] You're gonna have to have more people on duty
[3:29:31] without it out, and the county's gonna be in trouble
[3:29:33] both times, I would think.
[3:29:35] The county, Sheriff's Department,
[3:29:37] and plus the fair at the same time,
[3:29:39] which you've ever been to the fair
[3:29:41] and see the presence they have at the fair.
[3:29:44] They probably have what,
[3:29:46] five to 10 officers on duty all the time at the fair.
[3:29:49] Something along that line.
[3:29:51] They maintain a very good staff.
[3:29:52] Yeah.
[3:29:53] So thank you.
[3:29:56] I see no further lights.
[3:29:57] Captain, do you have anything further you'd like to share?
[3:29:59] I do not.
[3:30:00] Thank you for coming tonight.
[3:30:03] Last item on the agenda council is number eight,
[3:30:05] public input and or items from city manager, city council.
[3:30:08] Is anyone from the public?
[3:30:10] Shorty, you ready to talk?
[3:30:13] Okay, you didn't talk some point, or were you?
[3:30:18] Moving on to our city manager, Mr. Rothwell,
[3:30:21] do you have anything?
[3:30:22] I just have a couple of quick items
[3:30:24] to kind of outline the future jump meetings
[3:30:27] in terms of what they look like.
[3:30:28] Next week, we do hope to have a completed draft agreement.
[3:30:31] It is our goal and it's something that we're working towards.
[3:30:34] Obviously, it's going to take considerable work
[3:30:39] with our partners in Beckley Media to make that happen,
[3:30:41] and we'll do our best to ensure that that agreement
[3:30:44] is complete, but when you look at it.
[3:30:46] On February 3rd, we'd like for you to get together
[3:30:49] at four o'clock if it works within your schedules.
[3:30:51] We'd like to have you take a tour of the jump site
[3:30:54] as a collective group, and then on the evening,
[3:30:57] February 6th, staff is proposing that we would hold
[3:31:00] a 6 p.m. start to the conversations associated
[3:31:04] with the jump and treat it like a public hearing,
[3:31:07] so that we would do what we can from a staff perspective
[3:31:11] to ensure that the public has the opportunity
[3:31:14] to once again provide their thoughts and comments
[3:31:16] on the agreement.
[3:31:17] So if that schedule works for you,
[3:31:18] we'll put that schedule in motion.
[3:31:22] What was the second day?
[3:31:24] February 3rd.
[3:31:25] 3rd is the first, and then you just
[3:31:26] can mention a different day.
[3:31:28] No, the same night.
[3:31:29] Oh, the same night, and then so we do the tour
[3:31:31] at the third at four o'clock.
[3:31:33] Four o'clock, and then come back here at six.
[3:31:36] Yeah, we would have a normal business meeting
[3:31:38] from five to six if it's possible.
[3:31:43] We really have cleared the agenda for February 3rd
[3:31:47] to focus predominantly on the jump.
[3:31:49] It is the only items that are there.
[3:31:52] Makes sense to me.
[3:31:55] Chris talking to me.
[3:31:56] Travis, I like that idea.
[3:31:58] The agreement with all of the cities and inclusions,
[3:32:01] would you make sure that they're highlighted or clearly
[3:32:05] deparentated so we know that what is our language?
[3:32:10] What is our language for the country?
[3:32:14] We'll give you only our language.
[3:32:16] Okay.
[3:32:17] Yeah.
[3:32:17] Okay.
[3:32:18] That's the title.
[3:32:19] Highlighted.
[3:32:20] Jim, huh?
[3:32:21] This is just kind of a side bar.
[3:32:25] Our special events are approved by the police chief, who by the city council.
[3:32:33] Suzanne Hawkins.
[3:32:34] Just a reminder, I understand Chief Pike is sick tonight, but if we could get a little
[3:32:38] more update on the I Let's Price increase coming up.
[3:32:43] He's going to do that.
[3:32:44] In fact, we're looking at, in fact, he had planned,
[3:32:48] as we had shared, to have that conversation this evening,
[3:32:51] we will probably have him send out an email
[3:32:54] and then make a official report probably on February 10th.
[3:32:58] Perfect.
[3:32:59] You know, I apologize.
[3:33:00] I did not hear what the subject matter was.
[3:33:03] The Islet's Board has agreed to raise the fees for that
[3:33:08] and so I've just kind of won an update.
[3:33:10] I'm not going to tell you what I heard.
[3:33:11] It was not Islet's.
[3:33:12] Greg Laddick.
[3:33:14] My apologies in Travis.
[3:33:16] I'll ask if you got one.
[3:33:18] I cannot find the email right now.
[3:33:21] One of the person in charge of the conservation service
[3:33:25] in Jerome County had sent me an email about a meeting
[3:33:29] that he has put together.
[3:33:31] I believe this Thursday, maybe Mr. Morley knows about it.
[3:33:34] Mr. Morley, could you come up and help me on this?
[3:33:36] I apologize.
[3:33:41] Jeromeconservation.com?
[3:33:42] Is it the one?
[3:33:43] Yes.
[3:33:44] Here it is right here.
[3:33:45] Yeah, Terry Halbert, and RCS.
[3:33:46] Friday, January 24th, from 9 to noon,
[3:33:50] is there concerns about the Columbia River Treaty
[3:33:53] and how it might affect irrigation in the Magic Valley?
[3:33:56] Yes, yes, it is.
[3:33:57] Okay, I just want to bring that one to everyone's attention
[3:34:00] in case they want it.
[3:34:01] Thank you, Mr. Marley.
[3:34:02] I appreciate it.
[3:34:04] All right, Travis.
[3:34:05] Oh, I'm sorry, Travis.
[3:34:06] Go ahead.
[3:34:09] The last item I had was we've done a poll
[3:34:11] And it appears that we will not have a quorum on March 24th for spring break.
[3:34:20] We have three members gone, one member that is unsure, and I will also be gone.
[3:34:26] So we're asking in advance now to cancel the meeting scheduled for March 24th.
[3:34:33] Right now, it appears that you highly likely you will not have a quorum.
[3:34:39] in the event that you did, you would have four members.
[3:34:42] I'm good with that.
[3:34:44] If Council's good with that, we might have to separate you
[3:34:48] after this evening.
[3:34:49] That is correct, Chief Martin.
[3:34:54] I Chris, you OK with that?
[3:34:56] With what, with the Council?
[3:34:58] I'm here.
[3:34:59] It's just a month from now.
[3:35:00] I won't go a month after that.
[3:35:01] But no, I mean, I won't meet if there's a quorum.
[3:35:05] But I would say, Council.
[3:35:07] Yeah, it makes sense to me.
[3:35:09] All right, anything further from Council, City Manager, meeting adjourned.
[3:35:14] I'll put that with me so I remember to go over.
