Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2013-04-08, recording 1 (started 17:00)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2013-04-08/

[0:02:42] Convene the April 8 meeting
[0:02:45] 2013 April 8th
[0:02:48] Council to order our first item of businesses pledge all those wishing to Joyce please write join us please write
[0:02:56] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
[0:03:14] Number one, I would like to confirm we do have a forum.
[0:03:17] All seven members are here in attendance tonight.
[0:03:20] There's actually a staff, this briefly city manager, Robert Walthweiler, City Attorney
[0:03:26] Prince Wunderlick, Deputy City Clerk, Corrine Secretary of the other Sancias and one.
[0:03:32] the other city staff are in the items tonight as well.
[0:03:39] It's the duration of being just brought by the amendments
[0:03:41] to the agenda tonight.
[0:03:43] Mr. Mayor, members of the council staff would ask
[0:03:45] that the council consider adding one item
[0:03:47] to the consent calendar for business this evening.
[0:03:49] The item is handed out to you prior to the meeting
[0:03:52] and it is for an approval and alcohol license
[0:03:54] to the Twin Falls number 612 loyal order of moose,
[0:04:00] located at 835 Falls Avenue.
[0:04:02] I don't have a little trouble hearing you as your mic on.
[0:04:05] It is.
[0:04:05] OK.
[0:04:06] All right.
[0:04:07] So, Council wishes to come about all?
[0:04:14] I make that motion.
[0:04:15] Mayor.
[0:04:16] Second.
[0:04:17] Then moved by Don Hall and seconded by Rebecca Milsuk.
[0:04:20] And then we add an alcohol license for the Moose Hall
[0:04:26] to the consent calendar in the discussion.
[0:04:30] Seeing none, the other roll call vote.
[0:04:32] Chris Talkington.
[0:04:33] Yes.
[0:04:34] Sean Berriger.
[0:04:35] Yes.
[0:04:35] Don Hall.
[0:04:36] Yes.
[0:04:36] Susan Hawkins.
[0:04:37] Yes.
[0:04:38] Yes. Jim Mon? Yes. Rebecca Miller? Yes. Motion passes 7-0 to further amendment.
[0:04:47] Yeah, we did amend it. All right. I don't know. We need the amended consent calendar.
[0:04:55] Has any lost a letter from the committee? Your stomach. Wish you a second.
[0:05:02] I do have a question on item three on the consent calendar.
[0:05:12] If we can remove that please.
[0:05:14] We'll remove item three on the consent calendar and vote on it separately.
[0:05:18] I would move for the approval of the consent calendar minus item number three.
[0:05:24] I've been moved by Sean Burger and
[0:05:28] Segermuckers-Tockington to approve the consent calendar as amended minus item three.
[0:05:35] Rebecca, did you want to talk to him now?
[0:05:37] All right.
[0:05:38] Okay.
[0:05:39] Go ahead and vote on that, Madam.
[0:05:42] Sean Burger.
[0:05:43] Yes.
[0:05:44] Don Hall.
[0:05:45] Yes.
[0:05:45] Susan Hawkins.
[0:05:46] Yes.
[0:05:47] Greg Lantine.
[0:05:47] Yes.
[0:05:48] Jim Mon.
[0:05:48] Yes.
[0:05:49] Rebecca Milsica.
[0:05:50] Yes.
[0:05:51] Chris Chockington.
[0:05:51] Yes.
[0:05:52] Motion passes seven to zero.
[0:05:54] Rebecca, your concerns about number three?
[0:05:56] Okay, I just have a question.
[0:05:58] This is the improvement agreement
[0:06:00] for Canyon Park amended subdivision.
[0:06:03] And on page eight, item number seven,
[0:06:08] it goes through landscaping and sidewalk placement.
[0:06:11] And it says the landscaping will be maintained by the city
[0:06:14] and funded through a fee added to the water bill
[0:06:16] of each account within the development.
[0:06:21] And so my question is, is this something
[0:06:23] that we typically do or what land is it all of the landscaping within the development?
[0:06:31] So typically what we do is that's referred to as a common area maintenance and then through
[0:06:35] those common area maintenance as we offer and issue contracts with private vendors to
[0:06:39] go out and make sure that those areas that are considered within rights of ways or other
[0:06:44] areas that are within easements are properly and well maintained. And so what happens is
[0:06:50] As part of that billing process does occur on the water bill, but we are responsible
[0:06:54] as a city for the execution of contracts, and so where it says that we are responsible for
[0:06:58] that work, it just means that we're responsible for the performance and the execution and we
[0:07:03] do that through contract.
[0:07:04] Okay, so that would be separate from their regular landscaping that they would go to
[0:07:10] like a private company to have landscaped.
[0:07:14] Yeah, we use that as a common area maintenance approach, and so those areas that again would
[0:07:19] fall within the rights of ways or within the prescribed easements.
[0:07:22] Right, so is that, is there somewhere in here where that's specified or am I missing that?
[0:07:28] It just seems kind of general to say that the landscaping will be maintained by the city.
[0:07:35] I think it's referring to the landscaping that's spelled out in that item.
[0:07:39] The landscaping and sidewalk placement required adjacent to arterial and collector streets.
[0:07:44] Okay.
[0:07:45] In the city right away.
[0:07:47] Oh my.
[0:07:48] Correct.
[0:07:51] I took that to just be referring to that landscaping that's delineated in that.
[0:08:00] Travis, do we have any of the others of these or do you want to expound for it?
[0:08:03] Well, Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, if you take a look on page seven,
[0:08:06] it would fall under the general heading of public ways.
[0:08:10] And so under that, it would refer to those areas, not that are large in the entire project,
[0:08:17] but just under the heading of public rights of ways.
[0:08:19] If there were ever a question about the development agreement,
[0:08:22] we would simply refer to that section for the interpretation.
[0:08:25] Okay, thank you for that clarification.
[0:08:27] Mayor, if I could just follow on,
[0:08:29] then a comparable might be the improvements made
[0:08:31] to Washington Street with the center median,
[0:08:34] the city picks up the water bill for those improvements.
[0:08:38] Yeah, so there's lots of different areas
[0:08:42] that we do in the community.
[0:08:44] We have areas that we hire under contract,
[0:08:47] Pole Line would be one, Washington Street would be one,
[0:08:50] And then there are also areas within a subdivisions,
[0:08:54] specific subdivisions, for example,
[0:08:57] the subdivision off of Eastland and Falls Avenue
[0:09:01] where the stone brick wall is.
[0:09:04] There is a turf or a grass strip,
[0:09:06] and that is also subject to a common area of maintenance as well.
[0:09:11] Thank you.
[0:09:12] Thank you, Travis.
[0:09:13] Wishes on item number three as a consent calendar
[0:09:16] for Rebecca Millisley.
[0:09:17] Move approval item three.
[0:09:20] Second.
[0:09:21] Then moved by Rebecca Melsoika and seconded by Jim Munn to approve item number three of
[0:09:26] the consent calendar.
[0:09:27] Seeing the lights.
[0:09:28] The other roll call vote.
[0:09:31] Don Hall.
[0:09:32] Yes.
[0:09:33] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:09:34] Yes.
[0:09:35] Big Latin.
[0:09:36] Yes.
[0:09:37] Jim Munn.
[0:09:38] Yes.
[0:09:39] Rebecca Melsoika.
[0:09:40] Yes.
[0:09:41] Chris Tawkington.
[0:09:42] Yes.
[0:09:43] John Verigar.
[0:09:44] Yes.
[0:09:45] Motion passes seven to zero.
[0:09:46] Moving on to item number one under items consideration.
[0:09:47] I don't know why I'm farming, but that's the first place to first.
[0:09:50] Thank you.
[0:09:51] I'll skip those every week.
[0:09:53] We have several micromations.
[0:09:55] I will read the first ones and the next one of the council members to read the others.
[0:09:59] First one is the making the designated the month of May is better hearing month.
[0:10:04] Off the mayor's city, Twin Falls Proclamation, better hearing month.
[0:10:08] Whereas audiologists in Twin Falls item and nationwide observe and celebrate better hearing month each year,
[0:10:13] during the month of May and whereas the City of the City, Twin Falls City Council recognizes
[0:10:20] and values the efforts of all those who work to eliminate or minimize the isolated effects
[0:10:25] of communication disorders in one in five families affected by them and whereas more than
[0:10:31] half of the people with hearing loss are younger than age 65 and whereas hearing loss is the
[0:10:37] third most common health problem in the United States and whereas our citizens who have overcome
[0:10:42] communications disabilities through the services of audiologists are now able to lead independent,
[0:10:48] productive, and fulfilling lives, and whereas audiologists have attained the highest level
[0:10:53] of education for hearing and balanced disorders, and whereas Twin Falls is proud and honored
[0:11:00] to have audiologists offering quality education and healthcare services to its citizens, therefore
[0:11:06] be it resolved that I, Greg Landing, Mayor of Twin Falls Idaho hereby proclaim May as
[0:11:11] the better hearing month and encourage all citizens to recognize the achievements of
[0:11:16] audiologists improving the quality of life for people with communication disorders signed
[0:11:22] by me on April 8th, 2013.
[0:11:27] Do we have someone here that is going to be receiving this?
[0:11:30] Come forward and I'll hand this to you and then you can say a few words if you'd like.
[0:11:46] Well, Mr. Barron and members of the Council on behalf of the hearing healthcare industry
[0:11:55] here in the Twin Falls area were grateful and appreciative for your recognition of hearing
[0:12:02] as an item that needs to be addressed and that there are many people within our community
[0:12:09] and surrounding area that do have hearing difficulties. We would hope by this proclamation not only
[0:12:16] only would those with hearing difficulty take an opportunity to do something about their
[0:12:23] hearing, but we would also hope that it would draw to the attention of the community in general
[0:12:29] the need to protect and preserve the hearing that we do have.
[0:12:34] Oftentimes, particularly as we're younger, we feel pretty invincible as it relates to our
[0:12:40] health in general hearing being one of those things and there's much that we can
[0:12:45] do on a preventative basis to to preserve our hearing and maintain a better quality
[0:12:52] of life by doing so thank you very much. Thank you. The next one will be read by
[0:12:57] Kelcelyn Berger, Child Abuse Prevention Month. Thank you Mayor. Whereas child
[0:13:04] abuse is a serious and growing problem affecting more than 3.2 million of our
[0:13:09] nation's children annually, and thousands of children locally, and whereas this societal
[0:13:14] malignancy called child abuse respects no racial, religious, class, or geographic boundaries,
[0:13:20] and in fact has been declared a national emergency, and whereas CSI head start, early head start
[0:13:27] through its support of parent aid programs, parenting classes, educational programs, and
[0:13:32] community service activities is making significant progress in stopping this crime against families
[0:13:37] and children.
[0:13:38] Now, therefore, Gregory Lanting, Mayor of the City of Twin Falls, does hereby proclaim
[0:13:42] the month of April, 2013, as Child Abuse Prevention Month, and encourage the citizens of Twin
[0:13:48] Falls to use this time to better understand, recognize, and respond to this grievous problem.
[0:13:54] We'd like to congratulate CSI Head Start, Early Head Start for their continued success
[0:13:59] in helping families break the cycle of child abuse, signed by the mayor.
[0:14:03] We have someone here.
[0:14:14] Yeah.
[0:14:16] Please.
[0:14:29] Thank you so much for joining us again in our campaign for preventing child abuse.
[0:14:35] Hopefully as you travel throughout the community, you will see pinwheel bases in agencies and also pinwheels planted at partnering programs.
[0:14:45] We're working with the schools this year and a lot of other programs.
[0:14:49] So thank you so much, and we'd like to invite anyone
[0:14:52] that would like to attend this Thursday at 4.30,
[0:14:55] Roger Sherman will be coming from the O'Chillness Trust Fund
[0:14:59] and presenting the strengthening families curriculum.
[0:15:02] It'll be at the Head Start Center at 296 Falls Avenue West,
[0:15:06] 4.30.
[0:15:07] Thank you.
[0:15:08] Thank you.
[0:15:09] Thank you.
[0:15:11] The next one is for National Service Redition Day,
[0:15:14] and I'm Chris Councilman Chris Tockeman.
[0:15:16] Thank you, Mayor.
[0:15:18] On behalf of National Service Recognition Day, whereas service to others is a hallmark
[0:15:23] to the American character and central to how we meet our challenges, and whereas AmeriCorps
[0:15:28] and Senior Corps help address some of the challenges facing cities and our nation from educating
[0:15:33] students for the jobs of the 21st century, to supporting veterans and military families
[0:15:38] to preserve in the environment and for helping communities recover from natural disasters.
[0:15:44] And whereas National Service expands economic opportunity by creating more sustainable, resilient
[0:15:50] communities and providing education, career skills and leadership abilities for those who
[0:15:55] serve.
[0:15:56] And whereas National Service participants serve in more than 70,000 locations across the country,
[0:16:01] bolstering the civic, neighborhood and faith-based organizations so vital to our economic and
[0:16:06] social well-being.
[0:16:08] And whereas National Service participants increase the impact of the organizations they serve with
[0:16:13] well through their direct service and by recruiting and managing millions of additional volunteers.
[0:16:19] And whereas National Service represents a unique public-private partnership that invests in
[0:16:24] community solutions and leverages non-federal resources to strengthen community input and
[0:16:30] increase or return on taxpayer dollars, and whereas the AmeriCorps and Service Corps volunteers
[0:16:36] demonstrate commitment, dedication, and patriotism by making an intensive commitment to service
[0:16:42] a commitment that remains with them and their future endeavors, and whereas the Corporation
[0:16:47] for National and Community Service shares a priority with mayors nationwide to engage
[0:16:51] citizens, improve lives and strengthen communities, and is joining with mayors across the country
[0:16:57] to support the Mayors Day of Recognition for National Service April 9, 2013.
[0:17:03] And whereas throughout the office, CSI office on aging, three senior core volunteer programs
[0:17:10] help hundreds of volunteers and citizens annually in South Central Idaho through the Foster Grand
[0:17:16] Parents Program, the retired and senior volunteers program, and the senior core program.
[0:17:22] Now therefore, of it resolved that Greg Lanning, Mayor of Twin Falls, does hereby proclaim
[0:17:26] April 9, 2013 as National Service Recognition Day, and encourage residents to recognize the
[0:17:33] positive impact of national service in our city and to thank those who serve and find ways
[0:17:39] to give a back to our communities.
[0:17:41] Mayor I know Jim Fields, a fellow Hawaiian veteran, and had to see us all in the office
[0:17:46] of aging would probably accept this.
[0:17:49] Mr. Mayor and members of the council, first of all I'd like to tell you that I give thanks
[0:18:10] and I'm very proud to be a member of a community where service to others, volunteering, helping
[0:18:19] people whether one is recognized usually or not is a standard and I'm glad to have grown
[0:18:28] up in this community and I look at the seven of you who are good examples of people who
[0:18:34] give all of your, you give of yourself all the time.
[0:18:38] Thank you.
[0:18:39] to be used to be able to do that.
[0:18:44] You know, on item number one,
[0:18:45] find up for consideration.
[0:18:46] Sorry for the jumping there.
[0:18:50] Presentation by Lindsey,
[0:18:51] you're right heart from compassion.
[0:18:53] I know.
[0:18:54] Welcome, Lindsey.
[0:18:55] Thank you, Mr. Mayor.
[0:18:57] Greetings, City Council.
[0:18:58] I appreciate your time.
[0:19:00] We really are very grateful that you've given us the opportunity
[0:19:03] to come defend the patients in your region and allow us to educate
[0:19:08] you on why we think that banning marijuana from your city would
[0:19:12] not be a good idea.
[0:19:13] But we do really appreciate the opportunity to educate you and to explain why we feel that
[0:19:19] the patients of Idaho need to have medical marijuana in our communities and have safe legal access
[0:19:24] to it.
[0:19:25] I did prepare a presentation and you have accompanying literature but I don't expect you to be able
[0:19:32] to read along with all of it because I tried to give you as much as I could.
[0:19:47] One of the things that we really talk about a lot in Idaho and we're discussing a debate
[0:19:51] on medical marijuana or marijuana in general is what's the truth and what's not.
[0:19:56] And so a lot of the time you get information that is very conflicting depending on the
[0:20:01] website you go to.
[0:20:04] A lot of the time that can be very confusing so we always encourage everybody to do their
[0:20:08] own research.
[0:20:09] Basically, whenever you're looking for medical, you want to look at journals of medicine.
[0:20:14] We want to look at things that have been done studies from colleges, universities, other countries,
[0:20:20] places that aren't as effective as prohibition has made it to kind of limit how much research
[0:20:26] can be done on the plant.
[0:20:27] And so that's why it's easier to rely on other countries or universities for their data, because
[0:20:32] we don't often get unslanded data from the federal government.
[0:20:37] One of the things that we're going to talk about with the myths and facts before we jump
[0:20:42] into that is that there's experts that have weighed in on this.
[0:20:46] Instead of just small drug reform agencies,
[0:20:48] Compassion and Idaho is a grassroots organization
[0:20:51] that seeks to protect patients from arrest,
[0:20:53] forfeiture, and prosecution.
[0:20:55] We'd like to offer that for seriously ill
[0:20:57] and terminally ill patients, as well as their caregivers.
[0:21:00] There is broad support from surgeon generals,
[0:21:03] judges, et cetera.
[0:21:04] So one of the first pages I gave you,
[0:21:07] if you look at the Institute of Medicine,
[0:21:08] it says, nasha, appetite, loss, pain, and anxiety
[0:21:11] are all afflictions of wasting and can be mitigated by marijuana.
[0:21:15] Another one is from Francis Young, which we also cited in our petition.
[0:21:18] Quote, to marijuana, its natural form is one of the safest therapeutically active substances
[0:21:23] known.
[0:21:24] The evidence in this record clearly shows that marijuana has been acceptable and capable
[0:21:27] of relieving the distress of great numbers of very ill people, and doing so with the safety
[0:21:32] under medical supervision.
[0:21:34] It would be unreasonable, arbitrary, and capricious for the DEA to continue to stand between those
[0:21:38] seppers and the benefits of the substance. Now that was the DEA chief administrative law
[0:21:44] judge ruling on rescheduling marijuana ends September 6 of 1988. Another one that is
[0:21:50] on here that we wanted to look at was the police foundation from UK. It says, quote,
[0:21:56] by any other major territory of harm, mortality, morbidity, toxicity, edictiveness, a relationship
[0:22:03] with crime, cannabis is less harmful than any of the major illicit drugs other than
[0:22:07] and alcohol or tobacco.
[0:22:09] And this time I'd also like to inform you
[0:22:12] that there is an organization in our country called
[0:22:14] law enforcement against prohibition,
[0:22:16] who strongly disagrees with the word on cannabis
[0:22:19] and the stance that it puts patients
[0:22:21] in where it makes patients criminals
[0:22:24] instead of allowing a safe access point for us.
[0:22:27] And Nancy Pelosi had stated in June 15th of 2005,
[0:22:32] quote, we must not make criminals a seriously ill people.
[0:22:34] It is not a crime to be ill
[0:22:36] to have access to pain relief.
[0:22:38] People who seek this therapy should be able to receive it.
[0:22:40] It is long past time for us to base our policies
[0:22:43] on science and not misguided politics.
[0:22:45] I'd like to take this time to express
[0:22:47] that compassion is not political.
[0:22:50] When you are weighing in on this decision,
[0:22:51] please weigh in with compassion and not politics.
[0:22:54] I know that it all affects you differently.
[0:22:57] I know that it changes different political stances,
[0:23:00] but when you're looking at a medical need for patience,
[0:23:04] I would ask that you please remove the politics out of it
[0:23:07] and look at it with compassion.
[0:23:10] Wukimi and Limfoma Society supports legislation
[0:23:13] to remove criminal and civil sanctions
[0:23:14] for the doctor-advised medical use of marijuana
[0:23:16] by patients with seriously physical conditions.
[0:23:19] And that's from the Wukimi and Limfoma Society.
[0:23:22] Another thing that I wanted to touch on
[0:23:24] before we jump into this is that we have
[0:23:28] the therapeutic role of marijuana
[0:23:30] and it's from the American College of Physicians
[0:23:33] And they petitioned to have medical marijuana rescheduled,
[0:23:37] well, marijuana rescheduled and toe-scheduled too,
[0:23:40] so that it would be allowed to be used for the patients.
[0:23:44] And then I wanted to go ahead and touch
[0:23:45] on the disadvantage of an oral method called marinol.
[0:23:49] You may have heard that there's a prescribed form
[0:23:52] of cannabis that can be used.
[0:23:54] And marinol, and this is coming
[0:23:57] from the American College of Physicians.
[0:24:00] It says, quote, while useful for some,
[0:24:02] These drugs have serious limitations.
[0:24:04] The oral root of administration
[0:24:05] hampers the effectiveness of THC
[0:24:07] because of the slow absorption.
[0:24:08] In addition for patients with severe nausea and vomiting,
[0:24:11] for whom oral THC is indicated,
[0:24:13] soloing a pill may not be feasible.
[0:24:16] The oral synthetic THC has low
[0:24:18] and variable bioavailability.
[0:24:20] Oral THC is slow in onset of action,
[0:24:23] but produces more pronounced and often unfavorable psychoactive
[0:24:27] effects that last much longer
[0:24:28] than those experienced with smoking.
[0:24:30] On the other hand, smoke THC is quickly absorbed into the blood and affects expressed, experienced
[0:24:35] immediately.
[0:24:36] Studies have found that patients prefer the immediate effect on symptoms that occurs after
[0:24:40] smoking marijuana.
[0:24:41] I'd also like to touch on the gateway theory, where they have also stated that marijuana
[0:24:48] has not been proven to cause or even the most serious predictor of serious drug abuse.
[0:24:52] It is also important to note that the data on marijuana's role in illicit drug use progression
[0:24:57] only pertains to its non-medical use.
[0:24:59] Again, that's from the American College of Physicians.
[0:25:02] Now, if we want to go ahead and get into, sorry,
[0:25:05] I'm trying to learn how to do this.
[0:25:16] There's some of our tech people, Tammy, can you talk?
[0:25:19] There you go.
[0:25:20] Come in very well.
[0:25:27] Tammy, there's an IT department.
[0:25:41] We can go ahead and go over some of this information
[0:25:43] while they're trying to work that out.
[0:25:44] So there's the myths that marijuana has no accepted
[0:25:47] medical use in saying that it's not safe or effective.
[0:25:52] Controlled clinical studies have confirmed
[0:25:53] marijuana's therapeutic benefit in relieving and array of symptoms for people living with
[0:25:58] cancer, HIV, AIDS, MS, Alzheimer's, hepatitis, arthritis, and chronic pain among many other
[0:26:03] conditions.
[0:26:05] Our next myth is that the national, is that marijuana is addictive.
[0:26:11] In fact, the National Academy of Sciences noted in a 1990 report that millions of Americans
[0:26:17] have tried marijuana, but most are not regular uses, and few marijuana users become dependent
[0:26:21] on it.
[0:26:22] I concluded that although some marijuana users develop dependence, they appear to be less likely to do so than those of other drugs.
[0:26:29] Myth numbers 3 says research has not shown marijuana-smoked-contreat pain.
[0:26:34] I can tell you right now, if you look at a video of multiple sclerosis patients that is in extreme pain and shaking because of muscle spasticity,
[0:26:41] and you watch them inhale cannabis either in the form of smoke or a vaporizer,
[0:26:46] their muscle spasms stop almost immediately within just a few seconds. It
[0:26:51] provides relief. Another one that we have on here again is about marinol. Again it's
[0:26:58] talking about the synthetic copy of THC. So again it is a synthetic which we've
[0:27:04] all agreed or we don't want synthetics so it kind of makes more sense to stick to
[0:27:09] that. There's more than 100 no-can manoids found in marijuana. Marinol is
[0:27:13] expensive, it doesn't work for everybody, it has inconsistent results, creates more
[0:27:17] adverse side effects, does not relieve symptoms as quickly or effectively as
[0:27:21] whole plant therapies. The Institute on Medicine reports it is well recognized
[0:27:24] that Marinernell's oral root of administration hampers and
[0:27:27] suspectiveness because of slow absorption and patients desire for more control over
[0:27:31] the dosing. I would also like you to note that Marinernell was only prescribed
[0:27:35] for nausea and lack of appetite. It is not prescribed for pain. It is also not
[0:27:41] not allowed by many insurance companies to be covered for anything other than cancer.
[0:27:46] We've gone over some different things that we want to make a point that we're not the
[0:27:52] only ones that are standing up for medical marijuana.
[0:27:55] Organizations that support safe access are cited in our petition as well, but American
[0:27:59] Medical Association, Institute of Medicine, American College of Physicians, American Academy
[0:28:04] of Family Physicians, American Public Health Association, American Nurses Association, Leukemia
[0:28:10] and women's homeless society, American Academy of Psychiatry, American Academy of HIV Medicine,
[0:28:16] and National Women's Health Network.
[0:28:18] I would like you all to seriously consider why all of those different networks would be endorsing medical marijuana for treatment.
[0:28:24] Marijuana does not cause cancer.
[0:28:28] We had a Dr. Toschkin, Donald Toschkin, who worked for our government for 25 years.
[0:28:33] His hypothesis was that if you smoked five cigarettes, it would equate one joint of marijuana.
[0:28:39] saying that a marijuana cigarette would cause the same cancer risk as five cigarettes.
[0:28:45] Now, Dr. Tashkin worked for 25 years to prove that hypothesis to our government.
[0:28:52] And what he found after 25 years was that not only did it not cause cancer
[0:28:58] as he had previously hypothesized and put that information out in the 1980s,
[0:29:03] but that it shrunk cancer and reduced cancer significantly so much that he came out
[0:29:09] for legalizing it for medical marijuana in 2003.
[0:29:13] He reversed this dance completely.
[0:29:16] Another argument that you'll hear is that today's marijuana
[0:29:18] has higher levels than it did in the past.
[0:29:21] We have a government that has a marijuana potency monitoring
[0:29:24] project, and it's saying that only 8.52% of that is THC.
[0:29:30] The test from the 60s and 70s earns as reliable as a test
[0:29:33] now, so it's very hard to predict if it's stronger or not.
[0:29:36] if it is, it's climbing by inches.
[0:29:39] And again, the Institute of Medicine also found no conclusive evidence
[0:29:43] that linking marijuana with a subsequent abuse of other illicit uses of drugs
[0:29:49] is the effect of prohibition and the interaction with drug dealers
[0:29:52] that provide patients with easy access to more other potent and harmful drugs.
[0:29:57] And let me tell you right now, those drug dealers do offer patients more potent drugs,
[0:30:01] and they do on the guys that will provide different relief for their pain.
[0:30:05] and I'm telling you right now that those are lies.
[0:30:08] Drug dealers do not check ID.
[0:30:10] They do not help patients,
[0:30:12] the way patients need to be helped.
[0:30:13] Patients need safe access to cannabis right now.
[0:30:18] Moving on from there,
[0:30:21] one of the other facts or fictions
[0:30:22] is that we have abuses of medical cannabis laws.
[0:30:26] Now, in different states that are more liberal
[0:30:29] than ours perhaps, you can kind of see how that might happen.
[0:30:32] A doctor over recommending
[0:30:35] or maybe somebody trying to manipulate the system.
[0:30:37] But after looking at California,
[0:30:40] where we had a lot of people saying
[0:30:42] that there's young able bodied males
[0:30:45] that can work, they don't need medical cannabis.
[0:30:49] They found that there were out of California's 37 million
[0:30:52] people, there's a patient population of 400,000.
[0:30:56] So that's only one to two percent
[0:30:58] of the general population,
[0:31:00] and every state that medical marijuana
[0:31:01] has been legalized in there is an oversight committee
[0:31:04] to look at the doctor's prescribing practices
[0:31:07] or recommending practices for that matter.
[0:31:10] Another part of this that nobody ever talks about
[0:31:12] is the fact that our government owns the patent
[0:31:16] on medical cannabis while simultaneously listing it
[0:31:19] as a Schedule 1 drug with no medicinal value.
[0:31:22] I have handed out a slide with the US patent 6630 507
[0:31:27] 663-05-07, titled, Canobanoids as Antioxidants and Neuro-Protectants, which is assigned to the
[0:31:36] United States of America as represented by the Department of Health and Human Services.
[0:31:41] The patent claims that canobanoids have been found to have antioxidant properties unrelated
[0:31:45] to MDA receptor and antagonism.
[0:31:48] The best way to explain this is that the plant cannabis has over 100 things called canobanoids,
[0:31:55] And those cannabinoids all provide different benefits within the plant.
[0:31:58] Most people are familiar with THC, there's one that's extremely helpful that you've been
[0:32:03] heading to a graph on called CBD, which is cannabis dial, which is an investigation.
[0:32:08] I could really use that.
[0:32:10] It is a neuro-protectant and my disease attacks my myelon sheath, which is the part that protects
[0:32:14] your nerves.
[0:32:15] So to have a neuro-protectant, the patent is owned by our federal government.
[0:32:20] If they're not allowing access to our medicine, when the federal government is telling this
[0:32:25] there's no medical value while simultaneously holding the patent on the medical value, that
[0:32:31] has to be given serious consideration on which is right.
[0:32:37] And if you're looking at it being a Schedule I and you look at the national effort to overturn
[0:32:42] that to a Schedule II or III, you find that it is almost always turned down in court.
[0:32:47] However, our government does own the patent.
[0:32:50] The article that comes after that in your packet is actually where that information came from.
[0:32:55] And after that, a simple Google search led me to this website.
[0:33:00] And it is the Cannabis International and it's patents related to dietary and medicinal study
[0:33:05] and use of cannabis.
[0:33:06] Again the same patent that we talked about is cited as well as one, two, three, four, five,
[0:33:11] six, seven more that our government currently holds on medical marijuana.
[0:33:17] I think you can go down a little bit.
[0:33:20] This is teen use.
[0:33:21] Let's actually talk about this while this slide is up.
[0:33:23] So for teen use, the year that states legalized for medical marijuana alone, it gives you a
[0:33:30] good starting point of where those states were at.
[0:33:33] It then follows it over the course of the next seven years.
[0:33:37] Now if you look at Alaska, a teen use was at 10.40 before a medical marijuana law.
[0:33:45] One years later, it's at an 8.2%, so that's down 2.1.4%.
[0:33:51] In California, where there's by far the most liberal medical marijuana laws, you have 7.7
[0:33:58] percent of teens using in 99, and 6.51 percent in 2006, so again, that's down.
[0:34:06] The biggest jump that we saw was in Colorado for 2000.
[0:34:10] They started out at 10.3, and they end up at 7.44 in a seven-year slot.
[0:34:17] That's 2.8% percent down.
[0:34:20] The only state that saw an increase was Maine, and that's just out of those ones.
[0:34:25] We now have 18 states plus the District of Columbia that have medical marijuana in their
[0:34:32] states.
[0:34:33] We also have 27 states with marijuana, pro marijuana legislation in their state houses as we speak.
[0:34:42] So we need to keep in mind that while we all want to think about the children, I am a mother,
[0:34:47] I do have two children, I think about them often, and I also think about my quality of
[0:34:52] life and being able to take care of my children.
[0:34:55] And I know that when I am on morphine, I am not a good parent, and I don't take it anymore.
[0:35:04] There's different ways to administer cannabis that people don't talk about.
[0:35:07] Everybody knows about smoking.
[0:35:08] One thing that I touched based on briefly was vaporizing.
[0:35:11] There is a way to inhale just the vapor.
[0:35:14] It heats below a burning unit, so below the point of combustion, and it allows people
[0:35:18] to inhale that substance safely without, you know, putting smoke in your lungs.
[0:35:24] That being said, if you think about typical breathing treatments that you would receive
[0:35:29] in the hospital such as albuterol or other chemicals that you would inhale into your lungs, it
[0:35:33] would make sense of the natural plant-based matter going
[0:35:36] into a vaporizer would be less harmful.
[0:35:38] Another way the patients prefer to eat,
[0:35:40] in fact, 60% prefer to eat their cannabis.
[0:35:43] It has a longer lasting effect.
[0:35:46] It tends to take the pain down more
[0:35:49] than just a smoked version,
[0:35:50] and typically you have to consume much less.
[0:35:53] And so a lot of patients are much more comfortable
[0:35:55] with that.
[0:35:56] The only problem is sometimes they get a little overzealous
[0:35:58] in the beginning, so we recommend that patients
[0:36:00] if they're going to use medibles,
[0:36:02] especially when they're starting out,
[0:36:03] to use very small doses until they know
[0:36:06] what their body is prepared to handle
[0:36:08] and then they can move on.
[0:36:09] Your body is very good at telling you
[0:36:12] what it can and cannot handle.
[0:36:13] There should always trust your body.
[0:36:15] Some people who prefer to drink a tea,
[0:36:18] a lot of patients prefer a tincture.
[0:36:21] A tincture is an alcohol based,
[0:36:24] basically it's meant to break down the plant
[0:36:26] so that you can get the basic plant material.
[0:36:28] Again, if I go back to MS, a MS patient would use
[0:36:32] T-shirt to really muscle spassist the V.
[0:36:34] Again, it works almost instantly.
[0:36:36] A PTSD patient would use this to relieve an anxiety attack,
[0:36:41] or if they were having more than that,
[0:36:43] like a flashback to a war, or something
[0:36:46] that is very hard for our veterans to handle.
[0:36:49] Topical treatments are lotions, salves, creams,
[0:36:52] different ways to handle, arthritis,
[0:36:54] different ways to handle pain from muscle spasms
[0:36:58] and then it talks about marinol again and the reason I put in there again is because I'd
[0:37:04] like to put on the point that it does have the potential for overdose. It's a pill. Pills
[0:37:09] have the chance for overdose. Now, it's been said that you would have to consume 1,500
[0:37:13] pounds of marijuana in 15 minutes to induce an overdose that is lethal. Now, if you consume
[0:37:19] too much cannabis, you will probably go to sleep. You'll probably wake up hungry. We're
[0:37:23] going to have dry eyes, you may have more appetite, you may have less appetite, you may feel confused
[0:37:29] or disoriented, but you are certainly not going to be dead.
[0:37:34] And another slide that we have, I don't know if you can get to this one, wait let's go back.
[0:37:42] That's the first slide to it actually.
[0:37:44] So in here when you look at, the main organ systems under human anatomy, it was hard to
[0:37:51] find a website that actually included what I'm going to educate you on and it's because
[0:37:57] There's not very many people that know about it,
[0:37:58] and it's also a relatively new finding.
[0:38:01] So these are going to list the different systems
[0:38:03] in your body.
[0:38:04] You know about these systems.
[0:38:05] Go ahead and scroll down one, please.
[0:38:07] To the next slide.
[0:38:09] Number four is called your endocannabinoid system.
[0:38:12] Your endocannabinoid system is a system
[0:38:14] that there's little discussion about.
[0:38:16] It is all over your body.
[0:38:18] There is one receptor in the part that controls your heart
[0:38:22] and your lungs.
[0:38:23] That is why you do not die if you consume too much cannabis.
[0:38:26] The rest of those endocannabinoids are located throughout your brain, throughout your body.
[0:38:33] They're actually everywhere.
[0:38:36] And the endocannabinoid system, as it says, it controls physiological process, thrust,
[0:38:41] hunger, mood, pings, sensation, extra psychological processes come under the system.
[0:38:47] And if you want to go to the next slide, Sarah, one more.
[0:38:51] That's just to show all the different systems in your body, go one more.
[0:38:55] All of the places on this chart are the places, if you look where they're all lit up blue all over in the diagram of the human body,
[0:39:03] those are where you have cannabinoid receptors throughout your entire body.
[0:39:08] Now, there's a way for your body to actually secrete cannabis, which is why sometimes you hear people say,
[0:39:14] I've never consumed cannabis before in my life, how did I test positive for it?
[0:39:18] Well, if you've got a lab test, they automatically allow for a certain amount of cannabinoids to
[0:39:24] be present in your blood.
[0:39:26] Once you serve past that level is when they deem that you are positive for cannabis.
[0:39:31] So it automatically allows for these cannabinoids to be secreted from your body because you
[0:39:36] have a whole system meant to do so.
[0:39:40] And that is why there is on there.
[0:39:41] So it says on there, I know it's really little print and I didn't include it because it's
[0:39:45] even smaller on paper, but it says because chemical compounds in marijuana fit like
[0:39:50] keys into receptors on cells all over the human body, those receptors control processes
[0:39:54] ranging from vein and thought to inflammation in the immune system. The receptors are there
[0:40:00] because they serve as keyholes to chemicals produced within the human body. Now, throughout
[0:40:06] your human body, when you're looking at ways to treat pain, when you're looking at ways
[0:40:11] to help other disorders, it's clear to see that there's different ways to target those
[0:40:16] areas.
[0:40:17] Now, the next chart, please.
[0:40:23] This is part of your endocannabinoids.
[0:40:27] So their plant has over 100 cannabinoids that are being studied right now.
[0:40:32] Now, that big blue one, the CBD, is called Canaba Dial, and that's the neuro-protectant
[0:40:37] that our government holds the federal patent on.
[0:40:40] And if you look at all of the things that that can help with anywhere from neuro-protectant
[0:40:45] antispasmatic, what else do we have here, anti-diabetic,
[0:40:50] anesthetic, bone stimulant, anti-inflammatory, immunosuppressants.
[0:40:56] And then if you look at the other cannabinoids
[0:40:58] that are also being more heavily studied right now,
[0:41:01] that green one is THCA.
[0:41:04] And that is the raw plant matter.
[0:41:06] Now, if a patient is allowed to consume the plant raw,
[0:41:09] there's no psychoactive effect at all.
[0:41:11] In fact, patients that have juiced the entire plant,
[0:41:15] have had some very high success rates
[0:41:17] in decreasing their symptoms, getting rid of illnesses,
[0:41:20] and regenerating cell growth and helping cancer,
[0:41:24] as well as MS.
[0:41:25] And that is the only way to consume THDA as if it's raw.
[0:41:29] So again, not everybody that wants to use medical marijuana
[0:41:33] is looking to get a euphoric effect,
[0:41:35] although that is a side effect.
[0:41:38] Not every patient is looking to get that side effect,
[0:41:40] In fact, many aren't.
[0:41:42] And that's why teachers and topicals and stuff like that
[0:41:44] are very preferred among people that have to deal
[0:41:48] with a lot of medications.
[0:41:50] And so when you look at something like this
[0:41:52] where it actually shows all of the different things
[0:41:55] that it can help, just by the system in your body
[0:41:58] that's meant to receive cannabinoids,
[0:42:00] it really has to be the question of why is this not
[0:42:03] available for your patients?
[0:42:04] Why is this not available to your residents?
[0:42:07] Why do we not have a safe alternative to morphine?
[0:42:10] I've been on morphine a lot of it.
[0:42:13] I have MS.
[0:42:14] I was on 180 milligrams of morphine a day,
[0:42:18] plus eight, 10, 325, North Pole,
[0:42:22] to get through my last MS attack.
[0:42:24] I was in that much pain.
[0:42:26] I was also prescribed 5,000 milligrams of Narontan.
[0:42:29] Narontan just, Pfizer just lost the lawsuit.
[0:42:32] Narontan's not supposed to be prescribed over 1,800 milligrams,
[0:42:35] and it's not supposed to be prescribed for anything other than epilepsy.
[0:42:38] Yet they find it appropriate to put 5,000 milligrams of Narontin in my body as an MS patient
[0:42:42] and tell me that that's okay.
[0:42:44] And I'm telling you right now, if I had cannabis, Narontin is to treat nerve pain.
[0:42:50] That's what they prescribe it to me for.
[0:42:52] If I had a tincture, if I had access to something that wasn't Narontin, morphine,
[0:42:59] and biketin, I would be a much healthier person.
[0:43:02] Your residents, kidneys, and livers are begging you to please not ban marijuana.
[0:43:07] I am also asking you to please not ban marijuana.
[0:43:10] This is much safer than the pill epidemic that our state is facing right now.
[0:43:14] And when you have a chronic pain patient, where you have somebody like me,
[0:43:17] or a cancer patient, our doctors write prescriptions at us all day long.
[0:43:23] Their drug reps are sitting in that lobby room while we are two.
[0:43:27] And oftentimes they get close to the meeting before we do.
[0:43:30] and we're told to take x, x, x, x, it's the practice of medicine.
[0:43:36] They practice which drugs work on you.
[0:43:38] And when you've got a safe alternative that isn't practice,
[0:43:42] it's time to pay attention.
[0:43:44] When we've got doctors that are causing a pill epidemic,
[0:43:47] we've got a problem.
[0:43:48] Idaho doctors are usually pretty conservative,
[0:43:51] which is why we don't think there will be
[0:43:53] an over-recommendation of cannabis,
[0:43:54] especially with the stigma that goes along with it.
[0:43:57] But when we've got doctors that don't have the stigma
[0:43:59] of the pills or just don't mind if their patients get too far out of control.
[0:44:03] I'm not saying that there aren't good doctors that will curtail that and win people back down.
[0:44:08] I am saying that those drugs are extremely addictive and that there are far too many patients
[0:44:13] that have to go through rehab to get off of those medications and then are left with no
[0:44:18] recourse because if they were addicted to those medications, how are they supposed to
[0:44:22] go back on them if they are addicted to them?
[0:44:25] And so if you're trying to not be an addict, it doesn't make any sense to go back on the
[0:44:30] pain pill that you were formerly addicted to.
[0:44:33] I am lucky that I am not in that situation, even after being on all of those drugs.
[0:44:38] I am lucky enough that I have enough willpower to step away from that.
[0:44:42] I know 20 other people that aren't.
[0:44:44] We have people dying, overdosing constantly, and it is a problem in this state and around
[0:44:50] the country.
[0:44:51] Our country consumes more viketin than the rest of the world combined.
[0:44:55] We have to start looking at what's a safer alternative.
[0:44:59] Patients and family members are faced with hard decisions that no one should ever have to make
[0:45:03] because cannabis is illegal in our state.
[0:45:05] We don't need to ban it city by city.
[0:45:07] We already had the SCR-112 trying to ban it from our state and it was a statement piece.
[0:45:12] We don't need to ban it city by city.
[0:45:13] We need help.
[0:45:14] We need help to save access.
[0:45:17] We need help for the patients and caregivers using Merriam wanted to not be breaking the law.
[0:45:22] We have options but they're not desirable.
[0:45:24] The first one, again, is marinol.
[0:45:26] We talked about that.
[0:45:27] The second one is medical marijuana,
[0:45:29] and to continue using it without it,
[0:45:32] and be in pain, not have a good quality of life,
[0:45:35] not be able to function.
[0:45:38] When you look at costs, we have the cost thing.
[0:45:43] If you look at costs of treating patients
[0:45:46] that have to deal with these diseases,
[0:45:51] it gets expensive.
[0:45:53] There it was, one more, go, go, go, go, go, go, way, way, way.
[0:45:57] That's tincture from the 1800s, by the way.
[0:45:59] So that's MS therapy.
[0:46:01] My first MS therapy was $4,500.
[0:46:04] One of the MS therapies I received,
[0:46:05] I had to go to the hospital and get
[0:46:07] infused over a two-hour period once a month.
[0:46:09] It also has a high death rate.
[0:46:11] It costs $7,000 a month paid for by Medicare.
[0:46:15] Hemotherapy is $4,000 to $7,000 per round,
[0:46:19] And hospice care is $151 per day,
[0:46:23] and that's typically 87 days
[0:46:25] when somebody is completely lost to dementia.
[0:46:28] We also have, I'm not sure, did it go to the next slide, sir?
[0:46:31] This is really important.
[0:46:32] Our PTSD counseling and medication
[0:46:34] for the average veteran from Iran study
[0:46:37] says it is between $6,000 and $20,000 per year
[0:46:41] to help take care of our veterans.
[0:46:43] We have an extremely high veteran population,
[0:46:47] And I hear from them every single day pleading with me
[0:46:53] to please help them get medical marijuana.
[0:46:56] So in this petition that we drafted,
[0:46:58] we went ahead and included it,
[0:47:00] even though it is highly debated,
[0:47:02] because when you have that many veterans
[0:47:04] that are fought for our country come and tell you
[0:47:08] that they have found relief in something,
[0:47:10] it's time to listen.
[0:47:12] And so we listened to our veterans
[0:47:14] because we think they're more grateful for their service.
[0:47:17] And Crohn's disease is $13,000 per year,
[0:47:20] plus the average Crohn's patient has to have
[0:47:22] about five feet of their lower intestine removed.
[0:47:25] I'm sure that surgery is quite expensive as well.
[0:47:30] We can use a loophole, an organ program,
[0:47:33] and go there and get medicine,
[0:47:35] and risk being a criminal for crossing
[0:47:36] into Idaho with the medicine.
[0:47:38] Then we have trafficking charges,
[0:47:40] and we have other problems that we're looking at.
[0:47:43] really turning patients into criminals by encouraging that behavior because if the black market
[0:47:48] isn't working, that's what's going to happen. Plus, it's a safe access point. People are
[0:47:52] more than happy to go into Oregon, get their card, and be able to go to a dispensary and
[0:47:56] not have to go to the local drug dealer. But then again, it comes with the risk.
[0:48:02] And the last option, well, one of the options is the black market. When people turn to that
[0:48:06] medicine, for that for their medicine, you don't have a treatment testing facility. A testing
[0:48:11] Pesticiding facility is really important because patients need medicine, not a recreational
[0:48:15] drug.
[0:48:16] So we set up testing facilities and they test for mold, pesticides, bugs, and other contaminants.
[0:48:21] A drug dealer is not going to do that for you.
[0:48:25] Patients don't know if they're medicine is safe on the black market at all.
[0:48:28] You don't know if it's been sprayed with a chemical to keep bugs away.
[0:48:30] You don't know if somebody let it get moldy.
[0:48:32] You have absolutely no clue what you're getting except for that you're trying to get relief.
[0:48:39] We're putting the patients and caregivers at risk whenever we have to go to the black market.
[0:48:43] So again, safe access is really key.
[0:48:46] And if we grow our own medicine, then we get targeted with manufacturing and up to five
[0:48:50] years in prison.
[0:48:51] I would really like to touch on that because you're going to hear that in Idaho, three
[0:48:56] ounces and under of cannabis is not a felony.
[0:48:59] And I am here to tell you that that is not true.
[0:49:02] If you get caught with cannabis, if you get caught with it, let's say that you're a patient
[0:49:07] and you have a strain to help you with your fatigue,
[0:49:10] and you have a strain to help you with your pain,
[0:49:12] and you have a strain to help you with your nausea.
[0:49:15] Now you are in a possession of three different types
[0:49:17] of cannabis.
[0:49:18] If an officer comes to your door and you have cannabis,
[0:49:22] put into different separate baggies,
[0:49:24] you will be charged with distribution,
[0:49:26] or at least intent to distribute,
[0:49:28] and that doesn't do well for the patients at all.
[0:49:34] We also want to make sure that people aren't leaving.
[0:49:37] We don't want to leave cities.
[0:49:38] We don't want to leave our state.
[0:49:40] It puts patients and their caregivers
[0:49:42] in a position to have to want to leave.
[0:49:45] And cannabis from your city forces your residents
[0:49:47] to move from your city.
[0:49:48] They're seriously ill and terminally ill,
[0:49:50] as well as their caregivers.
[0:49:52] Please don't use politics in your decision.
[0:49:53] Instead, use the knowledge and compassion that I know you have.
[0:49:57] It would be what you would want if you were seriously ill
[0:50:00] or terminally ill and not a ban on you.
[0:50:03] We don't want to have patients leaving Idaho.
[0:50:06] And when we have a war on medical cannabis,
[0:50:09] it is a war on the seriously ill and terminal people.
[0:50:13] And we do not want to wage war on our seriously ill
[0:50:17] and terminally ill people.
[0:50:18] It is not an appropriate action to take.
[0:50:21] And for that, I urge you to please not ban marijuana
[0:50:24] for emergency.
[0:50:26] And I stand for any questions that you may have.
[0:50:28] Have any questions for Lindsey?
[0:50:30] We're going to allow some short time for others
[0:50:32] to speak on the issue.
[0:50:35] We didn't last time, but we were, this time,
[0:50:37] and hopefully we'll get both sides from this.
[0:50:39] Rebecca, no second.
[0:50:41] Thank you, Mayor.
[0:50:42] Thank you for your presentation.
[0:50:44] Thank you for coming.
[0:50:46] I just had two quick questions.
[0:50:47] The one, you showed us some statistics on Team marijuana use.
[0:50:51] And I was just wondering what the source of those statistics
[0:50:54] were and who collected that data.
[0:50:57] That came from procon.org.
[0:51:01] And so it is a, it's basically exactly what it sounds like.
[0:51:05] So you get the pros and the cons of introducing
[0:51:09] like a socioeconomic impact into the lives of the community.
[0:51:13] You also hear from procon.org on what's a pro
[0:51:17] in treating with cannabis, what's a negative
[0:51:19] in treating with cannabis.
[0:51:20] So typically you can get the kind of information
[0:51:23] that I'm providing or even that peruse
[0:51:25] say like the Idaho office of drug control policy
[0:51:27] would provide, they all come from that same site
[0:51:30] or dealing with pro-con, not work.
[0:51:31] And so you can go through it pretty easily.
[0:51:33] So you don't know who collected the statistics, though?
[0:51:36] Who did the study in producing the statistics?
[0:51:40] It's all cited.
[0:51:42] Go up one chart, please.
[0:51:44] Go up one more.
[0:51:45] OK.
[0:51:46] So it looks like on there it says the substance abuse
[0:51:51] and mental health services administration
[0:51:53] and the National Household Surveys on Drug Abuse
[0:51:56] in 1996 through 2006.
[0:51:58] Thank you.
[0:51:59] Thank you.
[0:52:01] My second question is you were talking about advising patients
[0:52:04] on how to ingest cannabis or how to use it.
[0:52:09] Is that something your organization does?
[0:52:11] No.
[0:52:13] Not until we have a legal form of cannabis.
[0:52:17] We're not going to be telling anybody to break our laws.
[0:52:20] What we are saying is when a cannabis patient is first
[0:52:24] introduced to using cannabis, sometimes
[0:52:28] It's because of prohibition, being able to study cannabis,
[0:52:33] like I stated before, is very hard to do.
[0:52:36] So a lot of times people have to rely on their bodies
[0:52:39] and their doctors and other patient experience.
[0:52:42] So when somebody first experiments with eating cannabis
[0:52:45] for the first time, the point that you usually go to
[0:52:50] is that you want to eat the whole edible
[0:52:51] because you're trying to get out of pain.
[0:52:54] And all I'm suggesting is once it's legal in her state
[0:52:58] to educate the patients that perhaps instead of eating the entire medical,
[0:53:02] they'd want to start with a smaller dose until they know what their body can tolerate.
[0:53:06] Okay, so this isn't something you're currently doing, because your organization is called Compassion, Idaho,
[0:53:11] so I was just curious about what your organization does. Do you currently work with patients?
[0:53:17] We work with patients outreaching into the community as a grassroots organization,
[0:53:21] so we're trying to seek protection for our patients and their caregivers
[0:53:26] just from arrest, prosecution, portraiture, and anything that can go along with that.
[0:53:32] So for now, what we're trying to do is to seek protection, legal protection for those
[0:53:38] patients.
[0:53:39] We want to set up safe access centers, we've got in our petition, provided copy of, we have
[0:53:44] production facilities, we have safety testing compliance facilities, and we have safe access
[0:53:49] It's called the Srinceries.
[0:53:51] Cannabis is illegal in our state.
[0:53:53] So until we have it legal in our state,
[0:53:56] it's a grassroots organization, there's nothing
[0:53:59] that we can do beyond representing our patients'
[0:54:02] voices to our state.
[0:54:04] Thank you.
[0:54:07] Sean Berg.
[0:54:08] Yeah, Lindsey, I just wanted to thank you for your time
[0:54:10] as well in your presentation in presenting us
[0:54:13] some additional information related to experiences
[0:54:18] from other states and certainly some of the medical journals.
[0:54:21] So I thank you for the time that you've taken to come speak to us.
[0:54:25] Thank you for hearing us.
[0:54:26] I appreciate it very much.
[0:54:27] Sure. And just for a little clarification, I'm not seeing, you know,
[0:54:30] lights before we allow others to speak.
[0:54:33] What we had been considering when we had the,
[0:54:37] the other side of the issue presented to us was a resolution asking
[0:54:41] that the federal government continued to enforce the federal laws.
[0:54:46] we didn't ever actually have the word band in our resolution,
[0:54:50] as I recall.
[0:54:51] So just a little clarification there.
[0:54:53] Well, thank you.
[0:54:54] And I appreciate that.
[0:54:56] And you're aware that with the SCR,
[0:55:00] that it was to enforce the marijuana ban
[0:55:03] that that did not go through in the state house, correct?
[0:55:08] It did not go through?
[0:55:09] It did not go through.
[0:55:11] The one that went through was our state's legislature
[0:55:14] making a statement piece saying that they do not support legalization of marijuana in
[0:55:18] any form. The one that got voted down was the one urging our federal government to enforce
[0:55:24] its current law of banning marijuana.
[0:55:26] Okay, thank you for that information. If you would stand by we may have additional questions.
[0:55:32] We're going to allow some others from the public to speak if they would like to. Vice
[0:55:36] Mayor Hall will do doing the timing of two minutes and we'll do a thirty second notice
[0:55:43] when they're here, but if you'll stay close by and we'd appreciate it.
[0:55:46] Thank you and thank you for having us, we really appreciate it.
[0:55:50] Thank you. Anyone else like to, we don't have a sign up sheet for this, but if you
[0:55:55] would raise your hand and say you would like to speak, and we've got a couple here,
[0:55:59] we'll go this one here and I saw her hand first and then you'll be next.
[0:56:02] All right. If you identify yourself and your address, it's, we do, these
[0:56:07] public meetings are publicly recorded and actually we are being streamed live
[0:56:12] I live on the web as well,
[0:56:14] the help people at all, who they're listening to.
[0:56:19] Excuse me, my name is Gary DeBort.
[0:56:22] I live in Twin Falls on Worschine Avenue.
[0:56:26] And I am here to ask you not to pass this ban.
[0:56:30] I live in Twin Falls.
[0:56:32] This is my home.
[0:56:33] My children have gone to school here.
[0:56:35] They were raised here.
[0:56:37] My husband was raised here.
[0:56:40] A few years ago, I was in really nasty car accident.
[0:56:42] I had to have half of my neck replaced.
[0:56:45] They now have it held together with some metal
[0:56:47] and some screws.
[0:56:49] The drugs that my doctor can prescribe me
[0:56:52] are highly dangerous, oxy-cotton morphine,
[0:56:57] and they will only work until my body is no longer
[0:57:03] immune to them, once it's immune.
[0:57:05] When the morphine's gone, the morphine's gone.
[0:57:07] There is nothing else.
[0:57:11] And that I'm only a 35-year-old woman.
[0:57:13] This is the rest of my life.
[0:57:15] And I've had to go through these medications.
[0:57:19] My pharmacy bill was $1,000 a month
[0:57:22] for the nerve medication, because I've permanent nerve damage.
[0:57:25] And the tummy medications that they have to give you,
[0:57:29] and then this medicine will give you this side effect.
[0:57:34] So you have to have another medication to treat that.
[0:57:37] I was taking over 30 pills a day a year ago.
[0:57:40] I'll prescribe for my doctor, I'll completely illegal,
[0:57:43] I picked him up at the pharmacy,
[0:57:45] and I've never in my life been so messed up.
[0:57:50] I was in a fog, I didn't get out of bed.
[0:57:52] It was horrible.
[0:57:54] And the reason I stand here before you
[0:57:57] is because our government patented medical marijuana
[0:58:03] for the exact use that I could use it for.
[0:58:07] But in order for me to access that,
[0:58:09] I have to move from my home.
[0:58:11] I have to load up my children and my husband and coach, another state.
[0:58:15] And I would like to stay here.
[0:58:19] Thank you.
[0:58:20] Any questions?
[0:58:21] These are the questions after everyone's speech.
[0:58:23] So thank you.
[0:58:24] Uh, of you were next.
[0:58:26] Hello, Mr. Mayor, members of the council.
[0:58:31] My name is Alicia Figueroa.
[0:58:33] I'm the administrator of the Idaho Office of Drug Policy and I'm at 944 North Caledonia
[0:58:37] in Eagle, Idaho.
[0:58:39] And I just wanted to share a few things with you.
[0:58:42] I presented you with some packets as well.
[0:58:45] And what we've heard a lot about tonight is compassion.
[0:58:48] And I want you to know that we are all compassionate.
[0:58:51] We all have family members that suffer
[0:58:53] from chronic and terminal illnesses.
[0:58:55] We all probably have family members and friends
[0:58:58] that have passed away from cancer
[0:59:00] or that have suffered from MS.
[0:59:01] This is not a question of compassion.
[0:59:04] This is a question of compassion at what cost.
[0:59:07] What we know is that we have a scientific process
[0:59:12] in this country to approve our medications for a reason.
[0:59:15] We want to make sure that patients get the dosage,
[0:59:18] the medication that they need,
[0:59:21] that they're advised by a physician,
[0:59:24] that they know what side effects to watch out for,
[0:59:26] and that there's some recourse for them
[0:59:28] if they have a problem.
[0:59:30] That is not happening with medical marijuana.
[0:59:32] It has not gone through that FDA process
[0:59:34] other than marinol.
[0:59:36] We are supportive of if there are components
[0:59:39] of the marijuana plant that can be helpful to patients,
[0:59:43] take those through the proper scientific process
[0:59:46] to ensure that patients can use that
[0:59:49] and not have other detrimental effects to their health.
[0:59:52] What we know is that the current research,
[0:59:54] and we've heard a lot about research,
[0:59:55] and what I noticed is there were a lot of dates
[0:59:57] in the 80s and the 90s that were presented to you.
[0:59:59] What we know from the current research
[1:00:01] is that it is linked to many physical ailments,
[1:00:04] many mental illnesses.
[1:00:06] There are links to testicular cancer,
[1:00:08] a study that came out this fall of 2012.
[1:00:12] You asked about the youth usage.
[1:00:14] This study that was cited from SAMHSA was 1999 to 2006.
[1:00:18] In 2011, they released another report
[1:00:20] showing that medical marijuana states
[1:00:21] had significantly increased youth usage.
[1:00:24] What I want to also show you very quickly
[1:00:28] in my last 30 seconds is we passed out these pictures of,
[1:00:33] and I think that this shows when you speak to fraud,
[1:00:36] the true state of the medical marijuana systems in the states.
[1:00:40] It shows, and I did pass those out,
[1:00:44] but it shows flyers from medical marijuana dispensaries
[1:00:47] as well as a picture of a medical marijuana
[1:00:48] dispensary in California.
[1:00:50] And it is very clear who they're marketing toward.
[1:00:52] They're marketing toward that average California patient
[1:00:54] that's a 32-year-old white male with a past drug history
[1:00:57] and no history of chronic or terminal illness.
[1:01:01] They are not marketing to your sick grandmother
[1:01:04] with cancer. That is just not what is happening. And one last quote, Reverend Scott Imler, who
[1:01:10] helped write California's medical marijuana initiative said this. We created Prop 215 so
[1:01:17] that patients would not have to deal with the black market profiteers, but today it is all
[1:01:21] about the money. Most of the dispensaries operating in California are little more than dope dealers
[1:01:26] with storefronts. I will also add that the petition that is currently being taken around
[1:01:32] in Idaho, but allow for 2.5 ounces of marijuana.
[1:01:36] That's two and a half times the amount allowed
[1:01:39] in Washington or Colorado, and equates
[1:01:41] to about 140 joints a day.
[1:01:44] I will stand on your questions, you might have.
[1:01:46] We usually wait for it well, at the end.
[1:01:48] I don't know if we get someone to go along,
[1:01:49] we'll certainly pass them on up.
[1:01:51] Thank you.
[1:01:52] Anyone else would like to speak?
[1:01:58] Come up and view the idea.
[1:01:59] Find yourself in your address.
[1:02:01] We'd appreciate it.
[1:02:05] Hi there.
[1:02:05] I'm Craig Manning.
[1:02:07] I live in Twin Falls.
[1:02:08] I just had a couple of questions and she may have answered this earlier or in some of the information that you have been given.
[1:02:14] But I didn't know what the cannabis legend status was and depending on that, I had some other questions in regards to what the state's position currently is regarding cannabis.
[1:02:27] And the legend status is traditionally governed by the FDA and I didn't know that city councils could go ahead and change any of those.
[1:02:37] I'm pretty sure we can't.
[1:02:40] Pretty sure we can just do some things that...
[1:02:43] We have a grant load right there, or our city attorney might be best to answer those questions.
[1:02:49] I didn't know if it was in the materials that she had given to you.
[1:02:53] We just got to move to the night and haven't had a chance to really prove them closely.
[1:02:57] At least I haven't.
[1:02:58] Okay.
[1:02:59] Things.
[1:03:00] Traditionally, in Idaho, physicians generally
[1:03:04] dispense or have a major say in nutraceuticals or pharmaceuticals,
[1:03:09] and they're either governed by those physicians,
[1:03:10] or the pharmaceutical board for the state.
[1:03:13] And just want to see if those questions
[1:03:16] could get answered sometime tonight.
[1:03:18] I did appreciate the presentation.
[1:03:22] I am a licensed physician, and she is right on many points
[1:03:27] that likely cannabis is very helpful in those situations
[1:03:33] that she had talked about, however,
[1:03:36] I am not a fan of a number of the side effects,
[1:03:39] and I have a question, a number of the stats as well,
[1:03:42] that they are brought up from non-typical sources,
[1:03:47] and there are more reliable sources than that
[1:03:49] than what was presented tonight, thank you.
[1:03:52] All right, thank you, sir.
[1:03:54] Mr. Loeb's. I didn't necessarily intend to speak today. I just wanted to hear the debate.
[1:04:03] A couple of things I think that it's important for the Council to know. It is a misdemeanor
[1:04:10] to possess under three ounces. It is not prosecuted as a felony because you happen to have baggies.
[1:04:16] Now if the prosecutor can prove that it is your intent to take the marijuana that you
[1:04:21] have whatever amount that is and distribute it and sell it and manufacture it and we can
[1:04:26] prove that, then that is felony conduct to distribute and manufacture and be a marijuana
[1:04:32] dealer in the state of Idaho, but it is not a felony to be in possession of three ounces
[1:04:38] or under.
[1:04:40] And with regard to that, it's important for the Commission or the Council to know that
[1:04:47] People who are found in possession of a joint of marijuana in Twin Falls are not thrown
[1:04:53] away into jail and punished and given months of jail terms to serve.
[1:05:01] The typical process of that, although they may be arrested initially, and that's often
[1:05:07] up to the police on the beat to do that.
[1:05:10] come in they're allowed to bond out immediately and usually we're looking at a
[1:05:16] hundred dollar fine. Now your attorney is here and his office
[1:05:20] prosecutes most of the misdemeanors for marijuana in this county because they're
[1:05:24] mostly in the city but the the county fine is usually hundred dollars if my
[1:05:29] office does it and that's pretty much it. It is not regarded as a heinous crime
[1:05:36] time to possess a small amount of marijuana for personal use.
[1:05:40] And I think there's been a lot of discussion throughout our whole criminal justice system
[1:05:44] in the past year about how we're taking these people who are using drugs and throwing them
[1:05:50] into prison and that's what our prison population is made of and that's simply not true.
[1:05:55] I'll also yield to your council about whether or not this council has the ability to overturn
[1:06:04] federal law, you know, there may be something technicality that I'm not aware of, but I would
[1:06:10] tell my county commissioners that they don't.
[1:06:12] First, would you like to talk about the prosecution in the city of Tofol?
[1:06:22] Well, so I think the first thing I would say is I don't really think that there is any action
[1:06:29] you can take here that will legalize marijuana. I know you've seen it around other places.
[1:06:37] It's still federal violation of possess marijuana. It's not been made legal. I know that's created
[1:06:43] problems in other states that have legalized it. I guess we've seen that in California
[1:06:48] where the federal government is prosecuting and the state government is regulating the
[1:06:55] stores and you just need to remember you have the authority to enact city laws that the state
[1:07:10] is not already regulated. You're preempted by state, you're preempted by the federal government.
[1:07:15] And honestly, I don't know what action legally you could take with regard to marijuana. I think
[1:07:21] we're waiting for our state legislature or the federal government to do something different.
[1:07:27] something different is done.
[1:07:30] What about how is it prosecuted?
[1:07:32] What does it define?
[1:07:33] I think that somebody's gotten the city to unfold.
[1:07:35] Grand Tried.
[1:07:36] It's generally fine.
[1:07:37] It's generally not jail time.
[1:07:40] There is generally probation.
[1:07:41] They might be required to drink in terms of probation
[1:07:45] to take a periodic urine test to see
[1:07:49] that they're staying off marijuana.
[1:07:51] But at Grand Tried, it's not perceived to be a huge crime.
[1:07:58] I mean, we know it's in the community,
[1:08:02] and the police do their best to try to keep it in check,
[1:08:05] but they can only do what they can do.
[1:08:10] I might ask the same.
[1:08:10] We have the chief here.
[1:08:12] I might ask him the same thoughts on how his officers proceed.
[1:08:23] You know, I'm not a chemist.
[1:08:26] I'm not a medical expert.
[1:08:28] And sometimes I get caught with all the statistics,
[1:08:31] and what they say about statistics
[1:08:32] to their numbers looking for an argument.
[1:08:35] But here's what I can say after almost 20 years
[1:08:38] of being in this business.
[1:08:40] And that is regardless of the substance,
[1:08:42] we're talking about substance abuse.
[1:08:45] And I think all substances have a tendency to be abused.
[1:08:49] Whether it's alcohol, alcohol by far would be our
[1:08:51] number one substance that we struggle with.
[1:08:54] If you ask me what the drug was that was our primary concern
[1:08:58] in Twin Falls, I would say alcohol by far.
[1:09:00] we deal with more alcohol-related incidents than anything else.
[1:09:04] That said, we do enforce state laws and local laws.
[1:09:11] Our people are active.
[1:09:12] It is not a main focus for us, but we are out.
[1:09:16] And if we encounter someone with amounts of marijuana, they will be arrested for that.
[1:09:21] It doesn't mean that they'll go to jail that night, but they will definitely receive a
[1:09:25] citation.
[1:09:26] Some will end up being arrested on the misdemeanor charge.
[1:09:30] So this is something that we've struggled with.
[1:09:32] I think there's a lot of debate that will take place in this country as we move forward.
[1:09:37] I will say that there are a lot of us that are watching Colorado and Washington to see
[1:09:41] what happens in those states.
[1:09:43] And we will say that from the states surrounding us, we're surrounded by states with medical
[1:09:47] marijuana.
[1:09:49] And I don't know that we've seen marijuana being treated really as a medicine, hence
[1:09:54] the dispensaries and everything that you've been presented with here.
[1:09:58] This is not how you can't go to a dispensary and get some hydrocodone.
[1:10:03] There's a process for it.
[1:10:04] You're going to seek your guidance from your doctor.
[1:10:10] Can people become addicted to those substances?
[1:10:12] Absolutely.
[1:10:13] So I think the real challenge is to idahoans, for all idahoans, to make a smart, intelligent
[1:10:18] decision on what's best for our state and what's best for our community.
[1:10:22] What I've seen over the years is that any substance could lead to some form of addiction.
[1:10:31] So.
[1:10:33] Thank you.
[1:10:34] Chief.
[1:10:36] Don Hall.
[1:10:37] You know, I don't have any questions, Mayor.
[1:10:38] I just wanted to reiterate, tonight's we weren't, as far as I was concerned, talking about banning
[1:10:44] marijuana.
[1:10:45] There's already laws on the books to deal with that.
[1:10:49] We weren't, I had not heard any of us talking about legalizing marijuana.
[1:10:53] I don't think any of us even have the pretense that we can do that.
[1:10:57] We don't have that authority.
[1:10:59] So I just wanted to reiterate those points.
[1:11:00] I heard that throughout this evening that we might be banning or whatever with marijuana.
[1:11:07] Sure.
[1:11:08] Thank you, John.
[1:11:10] Thank you, Mayor.
[1:11:11] Yeah, just a clarified group, Councilman Hall, that the original issue that came to us was
[1:11:18] a resolution that supported the continued ban, the continued federal ban on marijuana
[1:11:25] And specifically it was against legalizing medical marijuana.
[1:11:30] But we had some people who were for it who wanted to speak,
[1:11:35] just to present the opposite side.
[1:11:38] So yeah, we weren't intending to take any action
[1:11:43] because that is not within our jurisdiction,
[1:11:46] and that's not something that we can do,
[1:11:49] and we were very aware of that.
[1:11:51] We just had a request from the citizen group
[1:11:54] to speak to this issue, and I think it's important that we all are educated on the topic, and
[1:12:02] my degree is not in biology.
[1:12:04] I have not gone to medical school and to address the good questions brought up by Dr. Manning.
[1:12:12] I think that we do need to trust, you know, we have to trust the doctors, the researchers,
[1:12:20] the ones who are truly educated in this field to inform us.
[1:12:23] And even if we might have some speculations or some questions
[1:12:30] as to their integrity of research or whether they have an agenda,
[1:12:36] that's not something I can address as a counsel person,
[1:12:40] because I'm not a doctor.
[1:12:42] I didn't even major in biology like my sister.
[1:12:45] I'm a sociology major.
[1:12:46] So, you know, I can talk about social issues,
[1:12:50] and it's a good idea to talk about people's needs
[1:12:53] and their concerns, and so I appreciate you sharing,
[1:12:56] all of you sharing your perspectives,
[1:12:58] and thank you to the prosecutor, Grant Loebz,
[1:13:00] for sharing that information with us,
[1:13:02] because I think it is important that we have the conversation
[1:13:05] and that we all get the correct information.
[1:13:09] Just don't you?
[1:13:10] Well, I'd like to know if anybody else
[1:13:11] wanna give input, and then if not,
[1:13:13] I have two bits I'd like to throw in.
[1:13:15] Okay.
[1:13:16] Well, did anyone else that would like from the audience would like to speak on this issue?
[1:13:20] It's not a true public hearing, but we're allowing people to comment.
[1:13:25] Seeing none, Chris.
[1:13:27] Thanks.
[1:13:28] First of all, thanks, Lindsey, to you for presenting information and data.
[1:13:35] Likewise, the state representative, too little is known factually.
[1:13:39] I would doubt some of your database and I would doubt some of your database, but we're coming
[1:13:43] a lot closer to dealing with facts than my ancient age would belie.
[1:13:50] I am reminded when I was in the Air Force in Puerto Rico in the late 60s, anybody who
[1:13:57] smoked the marijuana sicker was categorically called thereafter a communist.
[1:14:04] We come a long ways.
[1:14:05] There aren't many communists among us, but I think there are a lot more pot smokers.
[1:14:10] I'd like to make my comments in reference to about the 13 years I spent in juvenile adjudication,
[1:14:16] both with the Idaho Youth Branch and then as a Twin Falls County adjudicator or administrator
[1:14:22] for adjudication.
[1:14:25] And it's two points.
[1:14:27] Number one, we were really interested, the kids that we took into detention and were placed
[1:14:33] on probation, their habits, where they got them and where it was leading them.
[1:14:39] And in a non-threatening environment, a non-mandatory voluntary survey, we discovered that most of
[1:14:47] the juveniles, the majority of the juveniles, excuse me, that we were seeing come before
[1:14:52] the courts, the juvenile courts, were more prone to smoke marijuana than tobacco.
[1:14:58] And that was a real head scratcher.
[1:15:00] And until we started digging into some of the probabilities, well, you see a lot of advertising
[1:15:08] about the harms of tobacco. Kids were scared of tobacco and the lung cancer where actually
[1:15:14] nothing was known, advertised or presented about the potential harm or the potential good
[1:15:22] of THC. Kids were doing what they thought was less harmful to them and I cannot give you
[1:15:30] statistics. It's been that long ago. I left a juvenile business in 2007. But I can tell
[1:15:37] I'd be highly surprised now if more kids today are still not starting by smoking marijuana
[1:15:43] than tobacco.
[1:15:45] The second point, reviewing the hundreds of cases from the time I entered in 1994 to the
[1:15:54] time I left in 2007, very few cases of kids getting into trouble did not begin with original
[1:16:07] of experimentation with marijuana, THC.
[1:16:11] I cannot say that with the same certainty with alcohol.
[1:16:14] I would hesitate to call it a gateway drug,
[1:16:17] but I'm lacking for any other substantive label to put on it.
[1:16:22] THC today for either lack of advertising with pros and cons
[1:16:28] or because of the social peer dynamics, kids who are in trouble
[1:16:34] today and graduate to the adult system by and large, have their start smoking marijuana.
[1:16:41] Thank you.
[1:16:42] Don Hall.
[1:16:44] I guess before I make too many comments, I want to give you my biases as well so you
[1:16:50] understand.
[1:16:51] First of all, I'm a child of the 70s so I saw a lot of pot growing up just as I share
[1:16:55] a volume of how many folks used it.
[1:16:58] I've spent 12 years of my life being a police officer, four of which I was a dare officer
[1:17:03] so I educated against drugs.
[1:17:06] Eight years as a boys and girls club director working with youth and troubled youth numerous
[1:17:11] times.
[1:17:12] In the last few years I've been the director of the law enforcement program at the CSI training
[1:17:18] new officers to come out into the field.
[1:17:20] So I'm probably the worst nightmare for legalization of marijuana that there is.
[1:17:26] I truly believe that it is a gateway drug.
[1:17:29] I've seen it be a gateway drug.
[1:17:31] And just so you understand, I have absolute compassion for folks that need medication for
[1:17:36] their ailments.
[1:17:40] If I was you in the legalization of marijuana, medical marijuana, I would probably be pushing
[1:17:46] more for figuring out some way of getting the derivatives that might be helpful for you in
[1:17:54] your medical situation legalized in a healthier form than smoking.
[1:18:00] I'm just here to tell you, smoking marijuana is bad for you.
[1:18:05] It has carcinogens and we can play with the stats all we want,
[1:18:09] but I know it has carcinogens in it.
[1:18:11] And I've seen family members and I've seen friends go
[1:18:14] on a downward spiral because of it.
[1:18:17] And I've seen people in the public and I've seen it lead
[1:18:20] to other drugs.
[1:18:21] So, you know, you're not going to convince me of anything
[1:18:25] but that because I've seen it.
[1:18:28] And again, I will tell you that when I was elected City Council, I've always said that
[1:18:33] I wanted to look 30 to 50 years out on all decisions that we make up here.
[1:18:40] And to legalize marijuana, I think is going to be detrimental to our community, to our
[1:18:45] state, to our families in 30 to 50 years.
[1:18:49] And I think we're seeing some of those stats now in some of these other locations.
[1:18:53] I think there's a group of folks that say that they want medical marijuana, but what
[1:18:59] they truly want is legalization of marijuana, just like Colorado and Washington did recently
[1:19:06] legalizing recreational marijuana, so they can get hot.
[1:19:11] I'm sure there's folks that believe in the medical side of it as well, but I think that
[1:19:16] there are a lot of folks that are taking this up as a cause because they want to get high,
[1:19:21] they want to be able to use it recreationally.
[1:19:24] And I don't think that our society, in the shape that we're in today and all the troubles
[1:19:29] that we have, need to inject any further intoxicants because marijuana is an intoxicant.
[1:19:36] THC is an intoxicant to your body and it changes your behavior.
[1:19:41] And I just don't see the healthy benefits of those intoxicants being injected into our
[1:19:47] communities and into our kids.
[1:19:49] And I think it sends a horrible message to our youth, that when we say we're going to
[1:19:54] legalize it for medical or recreation or whatever purpose, then they think it's okay.
[1:20:00] And I think that again starts the downward spiral.
[1:20:02] Do I think that everyone that uses marijuana is going to be a heroin addict?
[1:20:06] No.
[1:20:07] But I've never met a heroin addict that did not start or use marijuana along the way.
[1:20:14] So that's where I'm at, I absolutely have compassion to any kind of medical issue.
[1:20:20] And again, if I was in your shoes and you saw the benefits of some of the derivatives
[1:20:26] from marijuana to help you with your ailments, that's the direction I would go.
[1:20:30] Trying to figure out how we can get more support of getting these derivatives in this
[1:20:35] marinol or some other form that can help you with your ailments in a prescribed manner
[1:20:41] by a physician instead of some of these clinics that are just, you know, it's a joke in the
[1:20:49] world that if you have a hang nail, you can go get a prescription to get high. I mean,
[1:20:56] that's happening. And when I hear statistics that in some of these states where they legalize
[1:21:02] medical marijuana, there's more dispensaries than there are Starbucks, that tells me something.
[1:21:08] I'm going to try to be a little bit original, but Councilman Hall did say some of the comments
[1:21:17] I was thinking.
[1:21:18] My first thought is sometimes compassion is saying no and not yes, and I say that very
[1:21:26] heavily as a mother and a community leader that there's a lot of things that it seems
[1:21:32] like it would be compassionate to tell people if it feels good, do it, what, you know, no
[1:21:37] matter what it's okay and that's not reality. Reality is sometimes because I love my children,
[1:21:44] I have to tell them no, that's not good, it's not in your best interest. So I wanted to start
[1:21:50] with that. I also wanted to say along with what Don was just saying, I would be more comfortable
[1:21:56] with it if it was in a pharmacy handled like all the other prescriptions we have and not
[1:22:02] in its own dispensary. I don't think that's the right direction to go when somebody's
[1:22:07] is looking for medical help and pain relief.
[1:22:10] And thirdly, I have family members in California
[1:22:14] who have been prescribed the medical marijuana,
[1:22:16] and I see how it has destroyed their families.
[1:22:19] I've seen what it has done to people that were close to me,
[1:22:23] who I used to have a relationship with,
[1:22:25] that now I don't, and it's really sad to me.
[1:22:30] And so on that side, I'm sorry I understand being in pain.
[1:22:34] I have family members that are sick,
[1:22:37] but I don't think it's the right answer,
[1:22:38] and I don't think it's something I could support.
[1:22:49] You know, decisions about marijuana use
[1:22:53] and legalization are going to come to Idaho at some point.
[1:22:57] They're gonna be here probably sooner than later
[1:23:00] considering some of the comments we've heard tonight
[1:23:02] were surrounded by states that have taken some actions.
[1:23:06] Half the states in the country have some laws
[1:23:09] on the books or in process.
[1:23:10] So it is going to be before us.
[1:23:14] And when I say us, I don't mean the city council.
[1:23:18] I absolutely agree with Grant's comment.
[1:23:20] This is way above our pay grade to be making these decisions
[1:23:23] tonight.
[1:23:26] But I do think that Idahoans need
[1:23:29] to make the best decisions for what works in Idaho.
[1:23:32] And that process is underway.
[1:23:35] When this initial issue came up before us,
[1:23:37] it was that the invitation of a council person
[1:23:40] to the governor's office on drug policy,
[1:23:42] to come talk to us about some activities
[1:23:45] and education that they were doing
[1:23:47] that led immediately to the suggestion
[1:23:50] that we should sign on to a resolution
[1:23:52] that was being considered by many other municipalities
[1:23:55] in the state and through the legislature to do two things.
[1:23:58] One, to urge the federal government
[1:24:00] to enforce the laws around the books.
[1:24:02] And two, to stand up saying,
[1:24:04] we don't support efforts to legalize
[1:24:07] medical marijuana use of the state.
[1:24:10] And again, I will say, way above our pay green,
[1:24:13] there are processes in place that allow Idahoans to engage
[1:24:17] in that process.
[1:24:18] And for us to sit here in Twin Falls and say,
[1:24:21] we don't think that citizens ought to be able to bring
[1:24:24] an initiative process forward to have this conversation,
[1:24:27] I can't support that no matter what the issue is about,
[1:24:30] whether I support the issue or not.
[1:24:32] I'm not going to stand in the way of that.
[1:24:34] So again, I think it's important to clarify
[1:24:37] what it is, how we got to the point of talking about this tonight, and I think it's been a
[1:24:41] good opportunity to get a lot of information. I agree with Councilman Talkington. I think
[1:24:46] that there are probably holes in both sides of the conversations that we've had here. But
[1:24:52] again, more information and more opportunities for Idahoans to get involved in this is going
[1:24:58] to make a good decision at some point for what is best for Idaho.
[1:25:02] See no other lights. I would like to thank all those who testified before us tonight
[1:25:10] And we appreciate your your bringing the information is we have a very long agenda ahead of us still
[1:25:17] even after this agenda we spent an hour and
[1:25:20] 15 minutes or so on this particular one so I
[1:25:24] Thank you, and we'll be moving forward to
[1:25:28] Another item. I'm also because we do have such a long agenda item. I'm gonna state that we probably should done all
[1:25:35] Well, I know you're going to go to a break, but I also wanted to say thank you.
[1:25:38] I think we all thank you for coming in this evening and sharing your perspectives as well,
[1:25:44] personal level. Thank you.
[1:25:45] Thank you. We do have a long agenda ahead of us, so we're going to take some staggered breaks through
[1:25:51] the evening here to make sure we get through it in some sort of a fashion where we understand what
[1:25:56] we're still seeing. So we're going to take a 10-minute break and we'll be back with item two.
[1:26:14] Okay.
[1:26:15] All right.
[1:26:16] All right.
[1:26:17] All right.
[1:26:18] All right.
[1:26:19] All right.
[1:26:20] All right.
[1:26:21] All right.
[1:26:22] All right.
[1:26:25] All right.
[1:26:27] All right.
[1:26:28] All right.
[1:26:29] All right.
[1:26:30] All right.
[1:26:31] All right.
[1:26:32] All right.
[1:26:35] All right.
[1:26:36] All right.
[1:26:37] All right.
[1:26:38] All right.
[1:26:39] All right.
[1:26:40] All right.
[1:26:41] All right.
[1:26:42] All right.
[1:26:43] All right.
[1:26:44] All right.
[1:26:45] All right.
[1:26:46] All right.
[1:26:47] All right.
[1:36:52] We have a staff meeting here tonight.
[1:37:00] So, in the middle of the area, we have a staff meeting here.
[1:40:29] Yes, sir.
[1:40:30] Moving on to item number two, this presentation by the football
[1:40:33] department, juvenile crime unit, regarding school safety in Twin Falls, and Captain Hicks' list.
[1:40:40] He's already there.
[1:40:41] He's listed as a professional.
[1:40:43] Procter's possible.
[1:40:45] He's already done.
[1:40:46] I promise to get you out of here before 9 o'clock.
[1:40:48] Don't promise.
[1:40:52] Like the previous presentation, we're not asking for any action tonight from the Council, but
[1:40:57] a little bit differently.
[1:41:00] You do have a direct role to play in how the Twin Falls Police Department provides enhanced
[1:41:05] school safety in Twin Falls.
[1:41:07] It's important for us to even know exactly what our juvenile crime unit is doing, how you
[1:41:13] support that unit, what resources are available to us before any of you were ever considered
[1:41:18] proposing any changes to that.
[1:41:20] And we know that in the aftermath of the Sandy Hook School
[1:41:23] shooting, virtually every single one of you
[1:41:25] is approached by your constituents,
[1:41:27] where they express their concern, they express their ideas.
[1:41:31] And that got you thinking about what
[1:41:32] is your role in impacting the school's safety
[1:41:35] here in Twin Falls?
[1:41:36] And I'm here to tell you that you do
[1:41:37] have an important role to play in already providing school
[1:41:40] safety here in Twin Falls.
[1:41:41] We all have an interest in this.
[1:41:42] I look around the counts, and I see each one of you
[1:41:44] has a direct interest in this, not only
[1:41:46] because you have either children attending or did
[1:41:48] have children attending local schools.
[1:41:51] You either taught in a school environment,
[1:41:54] or you, as a city council person, directly control
[1:41:59] how we provide that level of service.
[1:42:02] So we want to quickly, tonight, as quickly as we can,
[1:42:06] go over what our school resource officer program does.
[1:42:08] We have all five of our school resource officers here tonight,
[1:42:12] as well as Dr. Dobbs and his operations director, Carl Voig here.
[1:42:16] They have to leave here momentarily for a board meeting,
[1:42:19] but there will be on hand for a short time to answer
[1:42:20] any questions if you can get to it.
[1:42:23] Right now, I want to introduce Dennis Paulin.
[1:42:24] Dennis Paulin has been with our organization for 24 years,
[1:42:28] and for much of that time, he has spent dedicated towards
[1:42:31] providing school safety here in Twin Falls.
[1:42:34] He either worked as a school resource officer,
[1:42:36] or supervising that unit, in a matter of fact,
[1:42:38] proposing the creation of the unit.
[1:42:40] And we couldn't possibly have a more qualified person
[1:42:43] leading our school resource officer program,
[1:42:45] So with that, I can hear your steps.
[1:42:49] Welcome, Staff Sergeant Bullock.
[1:42:51] Thank you, Mayor Nining, Council members.
[1:42:54] I'll be quick, very brief, and I just
[1:42:56] want to go over a quick history of our program,
[1:42:59] a little bit about what we do.
[1:43:01] We were just speaking in the back with Dr. Dobbs
[1:43:04] when our SRO program actually started.
[1:43:07] It's been around since 1976.
[1:43:11] We had a detective that actually worked at the Twin Falls
[1:43:13] High School for several years.
[1:43:17] During that time, after he had left,
[1:43:20] we still just had one SRO there.
[1:43:22] That was kind of the time frame.
[1:43:23] When we started the DARE program,
[1:43:26] we had the great program and a few other programs
[1:43:28] that our school resource officer kind of focused on,
[1:43:31] reaching out to other schools as well.
[1:43:35] Shortly after that, time frame I became a school resource
[1:43:38] officer at the Twin Falls High School,
[1:43:39] and it was quite an eye-opening experience for me.
[1:43:43] At the end of this day, working in the schools
[1:43:44] and working with kids has probably been
[1:43:46] one of the most pleasurable things that I've done
[1:43:48] within the department over the years, the 24 years that I've been there.
[1:43:52] Shortly after that time we were able to get an
[1:43:56] SRO to cover both, at that time Junior High is in other middle
[1:44:00] schools. Robert Stewart, Junior High and Ellery, Junior High,
[1:44:04] we were then able to get an additional school resource office for bringing that up to three
[1:44:08] SRO's covering the two junior high's in the high school.
[1:44:12] During this timeframe we started under programs
[1:44:16] I'm working with schools, I'm trying to reach out to students,
[1:44:19] working closely with staff members in the school
[1:44:21] and the school administration.
[1:44:23] I'm trying to get more involved in the community.
[1:44:25] We started providing more preventative programs.
[1:44:27] And around 1998, we started the every 15 minute program.
[1:44:31] I know a lot of you are probably aware of that.
[1:44:33] It's now called preventative program.
[1:44:35] We're actually getting that again this year.
[1:44:36] This will be the 15th straight year
[1:44:38] that we put that program on within the Twin Falls School
[1:44:41] District.
[1:44:42] We've also been able to have our SROs reach out
[1:44:45] to other schools, districts, I'm in the Valley,
[1:44:48] assisting with that program and other programs
[1:44:50] as they have come up.
[1:44:52] I know I'll have to try and I'll introduce him here shortly.
[1:44:54] He's after this mentor's first seniors
[1:44:56] with senior projects this year,
[1:44:58] doing every 15-minute program and helping with them.
[1:45:01] So we continue to reach out to other members
[1:45:03] in the community and the Valley.
[1:45:06] Around 2004, I had moved back to the patrol division.
[1:45:11] And during that time, after my working
[1:45:13] school resource, our school resource officer, I kind of felt, you know, we need to have,
[1:45:18] we need to kind of bring this program together, have a more, more of an individual unit and
[1:45:23] have a supervisor that has some knowledge working in the schools and we put a proposal.
[1:45:28] I said we put a proposal together at that time, SROs and myself, and submitted that
[1:45:34] naturally and we created what we refer to now as our JCUR juvenile crime unit.
[1:45:39] Then in 2009, 2010 school year, we added another high school within Twin Falls, and hence we were able to provide another school resource officer.
[1:45:51] So we actually have four school resource officers, one at Twin Falls High School, one at Canyon Ridge, one at Robert Stewart, as well as Olery Junior or Olery Middle School.
[1:46:01] These school resource officers also reach out. They have other assigned schools within the district, the elementary schools.
[1:46:08] With this, once Canyon Ridge came into play,
[1:46:14] we realized, I guess we realized at the time,
[1:46:17] we actually have 13 schools under the twin fall school districts
[1:46:21] that we work out of four of them.
[1:46:23] Obviously, there are primary schools.
[1:46:26] So, our officers, our work, the assigned elementary schools,
[1:46:29] one of them might have two or three schools,
[1:46:31] so they kind of bounce around as well.
[1:46:33] When they're in the elementary schools, they do the same thing.
[1:46:35] They try to provide education, try to be a mentor to the younger students
[1:46:38] students, act as a role model, and just be there for the students in general.
[1:46:46] This program, with this program, we work very closely with the Twin Falls School District.
[1:46:52] It's quite amazing the partnership that we have.
[1:46:55] They all work very well with our SROs.
[1:46:59] Because of this, the school district has agreed over this last several years to pay a portion
[1:47:04] of the cost for the school resource officers.
[1:47:06] With this time, the Twin Falls School District pays up to a total of $95,000 a year towards
[1:47:13] wages and such for our four school resource officers being in the school.
[1:47:21] They threaten me if they have to get up and talk, so in case you don't know, I'm all just having to stand.
[1:47:26] We have Officer Matt Triner. He's actually been our school resource officer,
[1:47:30] as long as he has ten years of experience in the schools.
[1:47:33] He started here in 2001 with the police department, so he spent a lot of time in the schools.
[1:47:40] He's actually our school resource officer at Canyon Bridge High School at this time.
[1:47:43] He kind of steps in and oversees things, very knowledgeable.
[1:47:48] Officer Cynthia Lebens, Cynthia started with our department in 2005.
[1:47:55] I know Officer Kleiner and I both knew her.
[1:47:57] She actually worked at the Twin Falls High School when I was a resource officer out there.
[1:48:01] She came on board with our department.
[1:48:04] She's been a school resource officer for the past seven years,
[1:48:07] and she's actually working at a Lurie Middle School
[1:48:09] at this time.
[1:48:11] Officer Preston Stevenson.
[1:48:14] Preston came to work for us in 2006 and for the last,
[1:48:18] and I wasn't sure on this, two or three.
[1:48:20] This is your third year, per second year.
[1:48:22] This is his third year school resource
[1:48:24] officer for the Twin Falls High School.
[1:48:26] Preston also helped coach the varsity football team
[1:48:29] a couple of years ago.
[1:48:31] Just one of the other things that our SROs
[1:48:32] is going to try to get more involved with the kids.
[1:48:35] Officer Gasser, probably our busiest SRO, by far,
[1:48:40] is our newest SRO.
[1:48:42] Steven came to work for us in 2008.
[1:48:45] This is his first full year as a school resource officer.
[1:48:47] He's a resource officer at Robert Stewart Middle School.
[1:48:53] And that's pretty much the history of our J.C.U.
[1:48:58] at this time.
[1:49:00] Do you have one?
[1:49:01] Thank you.
[1:49:02] Thank you, Sergeant Pullen.
[1:49:05] I wanted to thank councilman talking to him for asking for this presentation.
[1:49:08] We're really proud of the juvenile crime unit from all the work they do.
[1:49:12] But obviously the reason why we're talking about this tonight is because of the school
[1:49:17] shooting in Connecticut and a lot of the attention that's drawn.
[1:49:20] I'm sure that you've been approached as well as most of us from concerned parents and
[1:49:25] citizens asking themselves could this happen here?
[1:49:30] So I think that in our roles as public servants we have to analyze the systems
[1:49:34] on place, try to mitigate that as much as possible.
[1:49:39] We have learned a few things since, especially in 1999 at Columbine, about these incense that
[1:49:47] are current schools.
[1:49:48] And I just really want to briefly talk about those.
[1:49:50] I think it's important to talk about what the research has shown and what it's actually
[1:49:55] disproving some cases before we start talking about enhancing any current systems that are
[1:50:01] in place.
[1:50:02] It's kind of a study that we recently took note of that the NYPD conducted.
[1:50:08] They summarized over 200 shootings that have occurred in America, many of which occurred
[1:50:14] in schools.
[1:50:17] The one thing that they actually were able to find is that not all school shooters are
[1:50:21] alike.
[1:50:22] There's actually no sound profile for a school shooter.
[1:50:27] Many of them were identified.
[1:50:29] shooters is having social difficulties, but not always. They were not always the
[1:50:34] loner type. Matter of fact, in a couple of notable instances, they were actually
[1:50:39] very popular students. It's a very common factor, but revenge is not solely the
[1:50:45] motivation behind these school shootings. Most attackers had previously used guns
[1:50:51] and had access to them, but the access to the weapon is probably not the most
[1:50:54] significant factor involved in those shootings.
[1:50:58] Unusual behavior or interests are not always the hallmark,
[1:51:02] but they're usually present in most of the instances
[1:51:04] where school shootings have occurred.
[1:51:07] Instances of targeted violence in schools
[1:51:09] are rarely impulsive, but they're usually
[1:51:11] planned in great detail in advance.
[1:51:15] Prior to most of the incidents involved,
[1:51:17] the attacker told somebody about his or her idea.
[1:51:21] In a number of cases, bullying played a role
[1:51:24] and could possibly have been a predictor in the attack.
[1:51:28] And prior to the incident, most, but again, not all,
[1:51:32] exhibited some sort of behavior that caused concern
[1:51:35] that was either overlooked or undervalued.
[1:51:40] So in analyzing our systems currently in place,
[1:51:42] and just to let you know, this happens on a continual basis
[1:51:44] and obviously happening in great detail since last December,
[1:51:49] we have found that working on what F scenarios really
[1:51:53] doesn't work in drafting a plan.
[1:51:55] We always like to examine things from the worst possible
[1:51:57] scenario.
[1:51:59] But in this instance, try to develop a plan around every
[1:52:02] possible incident that could happen at a school.
[1:52:05] It doesn't lend to a very practical plan.
[1:52:08] The plans that we do have in place, and they've been in
[1:52:10] place for some time, and much of the credit of the
[1:52:12] Twin Falls school district, they actually are very
[1:52:17] comfortable with where we're sitting right now, even a
[1:52:19] live in Sandy Hook.
[1:52:21] They are based mostly around what type of plan will be in
[1:52:25] place under stress, so they try to keep it as basic and as realistic and as vital as possible.
[1:52:30] But it does revolve around what we refer to as three different tiers, and the first here
[1:52:36] to that, the most important is early detection.
[1:52:38] Our officers along with the employees of the school district really excel in recognizing
[1:52:43] early behavior that's troubling to them.
[1:52:46] They have intervention systems in place where school counselors, teachers, and parents can
[1:52:51] get involved in law enforcement if necessary to try to address any troubling issues they
[1:52:56] see in students to try to mitigate those as quickly as possible.
[1:53:01] The second tier, which is also something that we've improved quite a bit in the last 15
[1:53:05] years, is constant preparation and training for these type of events.
[1:53:09] The Twin Falls School District is committed to having regular lockdown drills with their
[1:53:14] schools so that their employees and their students know the procedures that are in place and
[1:53:19] to become second nature because we all know in times of stress they're going to fall back
[1:53:23] to what they have trained to do and if there's no plan in place panic won't sue.
[1:53:28] Our department also has taken great strides in the last several years to train every single
[1:53:33] officer and obviously these four officers would be at the very forefront of one of those
[1:53:38] incidents but train every single officer and emergency response to those instances as well
[1:53:42] as properly equipping them and finally the last year would probably be the emergency response
[1:53:47] We recognize that these five officers cannot be the bulk of a new response of every officer,
[1:53:56] not only with a Twin Falls Police Department, but countywide, would have a role in that response
[1:54:00] as well.
[1:54:01] We've recently recognized, especially after the Hampton Inn shooting, that if we have
[1:54:07] an incident like that, a Twin Falls, we're going to have officers from multiple agencies
[1:54:10] responding with a desire to help, but that can also create some sort of confusion.
[1:54:16] So actually, the suggestion of the Sheriff's Office,
[1:54:19] we are now working with their school resource officer program
[1:54:22] and developing a county-wide school response plan
[1:54:25] to try to make that as uniform as possible
[1:54:28] with any school in Twin Falls County,
[1:54:30] knowing that if we had a school shooting in fuel,
[1:54:32] our officers should probably respond and likewise.
[1:54:35] So we'll be working in the future
[1:54:36] to try to develop that plan.
[1:54:38] And obviously, we won't.
[1:54:39] Captain Hicks, I want to thank Dr. Dobbs
[1:54:42] for the cooperation that we feel
[1:54:44] with the schools on these type of programs.
[1:54:46] We know that we are partly responsible with that or majorly responsible, and we do thank you.
[1:54:57] As Dennis said earlier, we have many partnerships with the community.
[1:55:03] The fewer are as strong as the one we have with the Twin Falls School District.
[1:55:07] The length of time we've been in partnership with them and the open discussions we have expressed
[1:55:11] against us back and forth, we're very prideful of that relationship.
[1:55:17] Our general philosophy with planning for these incidents is event mitigation.
[1:55:24] Obviously, we want to try to prepare and identify problems as early as possible.
[1:55:29] But without going into a lot of detail, we try to plan in the event of one of these instances
[1:55:34] by trying to minimize the amount of damage and pain that these events can occur.
[1:55:41] So I know that you're pressed for time.
[1:55:45] So in closing, I just wanted to make the presentation to you
[1:55:49] that these systems are in place.
[1:55:50] The school resource officer program is very functional.
[1:55:55] We're very engaged in developing and constantly
[1:55:57] modifying the response plan that we have in the city.
[1:56:02] We're available to answer any questions that you may have
[1:56:04] or to deal with any questions that you may have.
[1:56:07] A couple of lights on.
[1:56:08] Are there any Chris talking to?
[1:56:10] Captain, first of all, I was going to ask you what else
[1:56:12] do you need, but then I realized that we don't end up
[1:56:15] to having in the school resource officer in every school.
[1:56:18] And we have budget limitations.
[1:56:20] Let me ask you your impression from the national press
[1:56:24] and some of the crazy ideas that have come out of the stratosphere.
[1:56:28] How feasible are a couple in particular metal detectors
[1:56:32] at the entrance of schools and more consultation with counselors.
[1:56:42] I realize there's the confidentiality factor,
[1:56:45] but it would appear that counselors sometimes have
[1:56:48] indication of polling going on that
[1:56:51] doesn't come up to change the commander down.
[1:56:53] But what do you think of those two ideas?
[1:56:56] I will say in general, I assume that we had not heard
[1:57:00] any proposals that you heard,
[1:57:02] and I would describe them as a broad range
[1:57:05] of proposals all the way to arming teachers
[1:57:08] to providing...
[1:57:10] That was the only one I didn't want to bring up.
[1:57:12] security checkpoints and not to get in a gun control debate,
[1:57:17] but we've heard a number of those.
[1:57:20] I think it's important to remember that we do have
[1:57:23] a lot of resources.
[1:57:24] Let me just give you a little bit more background.
[1:57:26] The Twin Falls School District has 13 schools
[1:57:28] here in Twin Falls, but that does not
[1:57:30] make up for the entirety of the schools within Twin Falls.
[1:57:33] There's actually 22 in the schools that are either
[1:57:36] charter schools or private schools,
[1:57:37] and I'm including the college in that number.
[1:57:40] There's approximately 8,300 students that go to the Twin Falls schools, district schools,
[1:57:45] and at least a thousand to the private charter schools, not including the 10,000 and 10 CSI.
[1:57:53] So that's a number of the schools we don't currently provide direct service to.
[1:58:01] So to staff every single school with the school resource officer would be fantastic,
[1:58:06] but those are the numbers that you're looking at.
[1:58:08] And while I'm sure there are service
[1:58:10] delivery would improve at each one of those schools,
[1:58:13] I'm not sure that having even one officer in the school
[1:58:15] would guarantee absolute security during one of these events.
[1:58:21] Another point that Councilman Talkinger just mentioned,
[1:58:26] having a security checkpoint
[1:58:27] would maybe a metal detector at the school.
[1:58:30] Sounds fantastic, and I know in some degree
[1:58:33] they've had a modified portion of that
[1:58:34] within the last 20 years.
[1:58:38] But I think until you actually walk around one of these schools
[1:58:41] and see all the different access points,
[1:58:44] would you have an idea about how many different checkpoints
[1:58:46] you actually have to have in place
[1:58:48] in order to have the school function properly?
[1:58:50] Without giving the exact number of just
[1:58:52] a Twin Falls High School loan, it's dozens and dozens
[1:58:55] of entrance points at that school every day.
[1:58:58] So I think that it's important to examine different proposals,
[1:59:02] and we're not afraid to discuss anything.
[1:59:04] I do think that we have to balance that
[1:59:06] with what resources are available to us.
[1:59:08] And mostly try to direct it towards that
[1:59:10] here response point I mentioned before.
[1:59:12] I do think we need to closely examine ramping up
[1:59:16] early detection within the schools.
[1:59:18] I think that they do an excellent job
[1:59:19] with the resources that they have available.
[1:59:21] But that obviously is the first line of defense.
[1:59:24] And I think that we can probably make some improvements there.
[1:59:28] But as I said before, we don't want to try
[1:59:31] a way for any conversation.
[1:59:32] We'll take a look at any idea.
[1:59:34] Jim Munn.
[1:59:35] Thank you, Mayor.
[1:59:36] Captain Hicks, thank you, sir.
[1:59:38] In regards to the three-tier plan that the TFPD uses response to these in partnership with
[1:59:44] the school district, I really encourage you and the department to, because we're just entering
[1:59:50] the budget process right now, and in regards to early detection, practical routine, procedures
[1:59:57] and so forth and emergency responses, if you need things in the budget from an operation
[2:00:03] or a capital perspective, get them in there, I think at least myself, and I would submit
[2:00:07] other members of the council would look at that very, very closely to help you get what
[2:00:11] you need to keep our schools safe with your expertise.
[2:00:14] Okay?
[2:00:15] I appreciate that, sir.
[2:00:16] And as I said before, you're going to be commended for the support you're currently giving.
[2:00:20] And I don't want to undermine that at all.
[2:00:22] You, the existence of the School Resource Office of Program is the work of your council
[2:00:27] and previous councils.
[2:00:29] We have started those preliminary discussions that would be hard considering the possible
[2:00:33] way of asking for additional positions.
[2:00:35] We will want that to be well thought out, well justified, and we make sure we want to, if we ask for that, give you the right perception about what we think that that person can do.
[2:00:46] Great, thank you, sir.
[2:00:47] Rebecca, I will second.
[2:00:49] Thank you, Captain Hicks.
[2:00:51] It sounds like your plan is well thought out and appreciate the time that you've taken in your team to really study and quote that report from the New York PD.
[2:01:04] I appreciate that.
[2:01:06] I have a question about the placement of the officers.
[2:01:10] So you have five officers, one at each high school,
[2:01:15] Canyon Ridge Twin Fills High School.
[2:01:17] What about Magic Valley High School, the alternative school?
[2:01:22] In our preliminary discussions, that's actually been identified
[2:01:25] as probably the school.
[2:01:26] If we work at another officer, we would most likely think
[2:01:29] about having them work out of that high school.
[2:01:33] again, this very preliminary.
[2:01:35] But we recognize that the four officers primarily,
[2:01:38] and Dennis is a very, very busy man.
[2:01:40] I know he does a supervise issue,
[2:01:41] but you see him on a weekly basis
[2:01:43] with a number of other issues.
[2:01:46] That their primary schools will take them all sort of time,
[2:01:49] but each one of them has assigned
[2:01:50] a number of schools in addition to that,
[2:01:52] as well as Magic, Belly High School.
[2:01:55] Obviously one of the areas that we would
[2:01:57] leave him to think about addressing in the future.
[2:01:59] Right, and I would encourage us to look
[2:02:02] our placement based on, in some part, based on incidents or issues at the schools.
[2:02:08] I know we have certain schools even on the elementary level that obviously have more issues
[2:02:16] or incidents, occurrences of whatever police or crime related, I don't know how much crime,
[2:02:27] so to speak, is at the elementary level.
[2:02:29] But I would encourage us to look at kind of the makeup of a school.
[2:02:35] Whether there is more at risk, low income students, and
[2:02:40] whatever other factors tend to play into occurrences of violence or
[2:02:46] a need for the presence of an officer.
[2:02:49] And maybe use that maybe as a stronger indicator of where we place our officers.
[2:02:57] Thank you, Donald.
[2:02:59] I was just going to wait till the end. 24 years Dennis. Congratulations. Little Gray up here,
[2:03:06] huh? Congratulations, sir. Well, thank you Captain Texan. Thank you to the resource officers
[2:03:12] for your, your fine work. I spent a lot of years in schools and never in a middle school,
[2:03:18] especially I never had the luxury of a resource officer, but I would gladly welcome one on many,
[2:03:23] many occasions, so we appreciate your efforts to help keep our community and our school safe.
[2:03:30] And thank you.
[2:03:32] Keep up good work.
[2:03:33] Thank you for the information.
[2:03:34] It's always nice to know how things are working within our community.
[2:03:38] Thank you.
[2:03:40] I have number three, a consideration request for adopt resolutions that approve, participate
[2:03:46] in three state local agreements to design and construct projects in the local highway
[2:03:51] safety improvement program and authorized the mayor to sign the agreements.
[2:03:56] Now we have Jackie Fields, our city engineer who had the honor of writing up to Boise with
[2:04:03] today and for the city and the engineering groups that worked with the city to receive
[2:04:08] two awards for the engineering excellence of both the Northeast sewer project and also
[2:04:16] of the Arshte compliance program and we were, I think we were the only city they got too,
[2:04:23] weren't we?
[2:04:24] We did pretty well.
[2:04:25] Yeah, it was by the, you have to tell what it is, a group of engineers, obviously, they
[2:04:32] were, I said they were going to do a lot, so.
[2:04:35] It was ACEC, so that's American Council Engineering Company, and they helped set standards, and
[2:04:46] They will get projects technically.
[2:04:48] So it was a wonderful work for us to receive
[2:04:52] on technical merit for achieving the schools too.
[2:04:57] So tonight I'm here to talk to you about three projects
[2:05:01] that we discussed briefly in June.
[2:05:04] We had an opportunity to participate in a new program
[2:05:08] that ITD has its local highway safety improvement program
[2:05:12] and it provides local jurisdictions
[2:05:14] and funding to make safety improvements.
[2:05:17] And there's a variety of rules that we need to conform to,
[2:05:20] and there is a match that's required at 7.34%.
[2:05:25] And the three projects were actually placed
[2:05:28] into that stage program.
[2:05:32] Used to be called a step, and I haven't moved along
[2:05:34] with the times, so I don't know what it is now,
[2:05:36] but it's the stage program for the projects.
[2:05:38] The first is placement of new stop signs
[2:05:41] and larger stop signs on the corridor falls
[2:05:44] between Washington and Blue Lakes.
[2:05:47] The second project is to illuminate the corner,
[2:05:51] around the corner of Eastland and Pullon.
[2:05:54] There had been run off the road accidents
[2:05:57] through that vicinity and before we decided
[2:05:59] to put median barrier up without the should try
[2:06:02] illumination, because it's rather dark
[2:06:05] and it would be a bummer to hang up on the median barrier.
[2:06:10] And I think that illumination may solve the problem.
[2:06:13] It'll be good for the area in any case.
[2:06:16] If we do end up needing to put a barrier on because we
[2:06:18] continue to have problems, we'll only delineate it.
[2:06:21] And the last project is to place a signal at Carrage and
[2:06:24] Addison.
[2:06:25] So the matches were estimated in September.
[2:06:29] And the contracts before you are close to those numbers.
[2:06:36] They're round fingers.
[2:06:38] I gave you something down to the buck, which we know won't
[2:06:42] ever happen.
[2:06:43] And so for the purposes of agreement, they're a rounder number.
[2:06:46] So it's $1,000 for the Stop Sign Project, $16,000
[2:06:51] for the illumination at Poland and Eastland, and $31,000
[2:06:55] for the signal at Cara Genatison.
[2:06:57] So when the state enters into an agreement
[2:06:59] with a local entity, that agreement takes the form
[2:07:02] of a state of agreement for project development.
[2:07:05] And the way that the state acknowledges
[2:07:07] that the Council wants to do the work
[2:07:10] is that the Council adopts a resolution
[2:07:13] that authorizes the merits signed contract.
[2:07:15] So the mayor isn't doing something in a vacuum
[2:07:17] that perhaps the rest of the council
[2:07:19] does not want the mayor to do.
[2:07:21] So later when the products go to construction,
[2:07:24] if they happen to be that type of project,
[2:07:26] then there will be another agreement for construction.
[2:07:31] So for this point in time, the recommendation is that
[2:07:35] the council adopt the resolutions.
[2:07:39] There are three independent resolutions
[2:07:42] and then that authorized the marriage to sign these contracts.
[2:07:45] Okay, we have to have a like, Chris, like.
[2:07:48] Can we just whip them out all at once?
[2:07:51] Or do we have to read the resolutions?
[2:07:58] I'll just go with two questions, and Jackie,
[2:08:00] that illumination on Pull Line and Easton,
[2:08:03] will that be the overhead LEDs
[2:08:05] like you have installed on the Filer West?
[2:08:09] I would like them to be the overhead LEDs
[2:08:12] like we have on Filer West.
[2:08:13] Yeah, yeah.
[2:08:14] I think for illumination is a little bit false, sorry.
[2:08:17] I just followed right along with what you're saying,
[2:08:19] but I think you were talking about it.
[2:08:22] The difference in the two areas has
[2:08:24] to do with the goals that were mine.
[2:08:26] Falls Avenue West intended to illuminate to the back
[2:08:29] of the sidewalk because there's a large number of kids
[2:08:32] that walk along that roadway to get to school
[2:08:34] at the darker parts of the year.
[2:08:36] So where I said the recommendation
[2:08:39] be somewhat negotiable and available for input
[2:08:42] on whether or not we just illuminate to the back of the curb at this point in time because
[2:08:48] I cannot imagine that we'll have a ton of kids on an arterial road right next to the roadway.
[2:08:55] When those properties develop they should be offset sidewalks and the safety consideration
[2:08:59] will be a little bit different.
[2:09:02] The next question is I thought that the warrant for the light up carriage and Addison was going
[2:09:13] to be able to utilize impact fees, but you say not.
[2:09:16] It wasn't because it was warranted at the time that that capital improvement plan was developed.
[2:09:24] So that meant it was 100% preceding additional development in the area.
[2:09:30] I say thank you.
[2:09:32] So do we have the three resolutions?
[2:09:36] 1902, 1903, 1904.
[2:09:38] I'm sorry I couldn't hear you.
[2:09:40] You know, two, three, and four.
[2:09:42] Okay, 1902, you know, three, 1904, and the first one would be four.
[2:09:50] Falls Avenue.
[2:09:52] Falls Avenue.
[2:09:53] Okay.
[2:09:55] And then the second one is the Eastland and Pole Line.
[2:09:58] Yes.
[2:10:00] And then the third one would be four, three.
[2:10:02] Signalizing Carogenes.
[2:10:03] Carogenes.
[2:10:04] We're going to talk to you.
[2:10:08] Thank you, Bear.
[2:10:09] I just had two quick questions.
[2:10:12] The first is about the falls, and I think you might have addressed it on why falls was
[2:10:19] chosen between Washington and Blue Lakes, so that's because of maybe school traffic, pedestrian
[2:10:26] traffic, or why was that one chosen?
[2:10:29] So the data that's projected from data that's been gathered by the state, and they look at
[2:10:36] accidents that have been in the section on falls between Washington and Blue Lakes, it
[2:10:41] It appears that the accidents that are occurring
[2:10:43] are not on that road are failure to yield off of site streets.
[2:10:47] And so the hope is that with a more prominent stop sign
[2:10:51] that makes the retroreflectivity standards soundly,
[2:10:56] that it will become, and with stop bars installed,
[2:10:59] it will be easier for people to detect the roadway
[2:11:02] and not have a failure to yield situation.
[2:11:06] Jim, thank you.
[2:11:07] Oh, I had one more.
[2:11:08] Yes, she's a two-player.
[2:11:10] Yes, she's two-player.
[2:11:10] Thank you.
[2:11:11] It's very quick.
[2:11:13] The question is about the illumination on Poline in Eastland.
[2:11:17] One, what is the accident history of that area?
[2:11:20] Do we have any kind of numbers about the frequency
[2:11:23] of accidents there?
[2:11:24] And when that road is improved in the future
[2:11:31] during a state project or a rebuilding or whatever road
[2:11:35] maintenance will this illumination be affected?
[2:11:37] Are we going to place it so that we'll not
[2:11:39] have to be moved if the road is improved.
[2:11:45] In the area of the project, I believe
[2:11:47] we have adequate red weight to place luminaires on the backside
[2:11:54] of the curb.
[2:11:55] So they wouldn't necessarily be behind the sidewalk
[2:11:59] at the back of the future right away.
[2:12:01] But in some of those areas, they certainly
[2:12:02] could be able to have to figure out
[2:12:04] something that's truly logical in there.
[2:12:06] I don't think they'll have to be moved in the future
[2:12:08] because the section of roadway that we're talking about
[2:12:10] is already improved.
[2:12:12] Okay, so the other piece of the question was.
[2:12:16] Oh, just the occurrences of accidents
[2:12:19] on that section of road?
[2:12:21] The occurrences of accidents on that section of road
[2:12:24] aren't numerous, they're deadly.
[2:12:29] So, and that's how it showed up
[2:12:31] on the data map is black dots,
[2:12:33] so there were fatalities there.
[2:12:36] So when you air, it's a little bit disastrous,
[2:12:40] you slip across the road
[2:12:41] and it looks like a head-on or you fall all the way off the road
[2:12:44] instead of the road.
[2:12:46] Great.
[2:12:46] Thank you for that information.
[2:12:48] Yeah, you bet.
[2:12:48] Jim, I'll show you that.
[2:12:50] If there's no other questions, I'll make a motion.
[2:12:52] Certainly.
[2:12:53] For the adoption of resolution number 1902,
[2:12:57] which calls for the improvements to the for construction
[2:13:03] of Falls Avenue West intersection improvements.
[2:13:05] That's right.
[2:13:08] Second.
[2:13:09] Can we have a second?
[2:13:10] Yep.
[2:13:11] Can I get something done here, man?
[2:13:13] Good move by Jim on the second of my Chris talking.
[2:13:17] That will be approved at resolution 1902.
[2:13:20] Seeing no additional lights, we'll have a roll call vote.
[2:13:23] Susan Hawkins.
[2:13:23] Yes.
[2:13:24] Greg Lanting.
[2:13:25] Yes.
[2:13:25] Jim Mundt.
[2:13:26] Yes.
[2:13:27] Rebecca Milsoica.
[2:13:28] Yes.
[2:13:28] Chris Talkington.
[2:13:29] Yes.
[2:13:30] Sean Beriver.
[2:13:31] Yes.
[2:13:31] Don Hall.
[2:13:32] Yes.
[2:13:33] Motion passes 7-0.
[2:13:35] Do I hear a motion for resolution 1903?
[2:13:37] So moved.
[2:13:38] Second.
[2:13:40] Then moved by Chris Talkington and second by Jim Mundt
[2:13:42] that we approve resolution 1903, which covers the lighting,
[2:13:46] eliminating the corner of Eastland and Pole line.
[2:13:50] So you know dish lights.
[2:13:52] Laila Rojalvo.
[2:13:53] Greg Lanting.
[2:13:54] Yes.
[2:13:55] Jim Mann.
[2:13:56] Yes.
[2:13:57] Rebecca Milsoica.
[2:13:58] Yes.
[2:13:58] Chris Tofington.
[2:13:59] Yes.
[2:14:00] Sean Berreber.
[2:14:01] Yes.
[2:14:02] Don Hall.
[2:14:03] Yes.
[2:14:04] Suzanne Hawkins.
[2:14:05] Yes.
[2:14:06] About 1904.
[2:14:07] Hi.
[2:14:08] I would love to move approval of that one.
[2:14:09] All right.
[2:14:10] I'm ready to drive through that intersection every morning.
[2:14:11] And seconded by Susan Hawkins that we approve resolution 1904, which is the establishment
[2:14:21] of a light at the corner of Kerry, Jen Addison, see no additional light, so the other roll
[2:14:26] call vote.
[2:14:27] Jim Munn.
[2:14:28] Yes.
[2:14:29] Rebecca Milsoica.
[2:14:30] Yes.
[2:14:31] Miss Tocqueville.
[2:14:32] Yes.
[2:14:33] Sean Berger.
[2:14:34] Yes.
[2:14:35] Yes.
[2:14:36] Yes.
[2:14:37] Yes.
[2:14:38] Motion passes 7-0.
[2:14:39] Thank you, Jackie.
[2:14:40] So quick question Jackie, so I'm assuming that these projects get built by us or contractors
[2:14:46] that we sign up with, not the state, yes, no, the state builds them, okay?
[2:14:54] It's has the look and feel of federal aid job, so we submit a PSN package so that the signs
[2:15:03] will be a little bit different.
[2:15:07] We'll procure the signs, our forces will install it lastly,
[2:15:11] we can figure the job.
[2:15:13] And we'll provide the posts and things like that.
[2:15:17] So that's a documentation challenge.
[2:15:20] The other jobs will bid according to the state rules
[2:15:23] through activity.
[2:15:24] And is the intent that those would be this spring summer?
[2:15:30] Not this one.
[2:15:32] So our design money is this year, and our construction money
[2:15:35] is next year.
[2:15:37] All right.
[2:15:38] You're just arguing it.
[2:15:39] I'd just like to point out the council what a good deal this is for the city.
[2:15:43] If you do the numbers, it's a 13 times leverage for the dollars we put in to what we get out
[2:15:49] of it, plus the considerable improvement in safety on that Kerry Jaddison in particular.
[2:15:56] It's a heck of a good deal for us.
[2:15:58] Thank you, Chris, and I see Dean back there, and I want to thank you for your efforts.
[2:16:03] I got very few complaints this winter, and that's a good thing.
[2:16:07] So, appreciate it.
[2:16:09] Dean Luller, our streets superintendent.
[2:16:13] Moving on to item number four, consideration of a request
[2:16:16] to amend the public right-of-way easement agreement
[2:16:18] for Canyon Park Development, Jackie Fields.
[2:16:25] The council addressed a public right-of-way easement agreement
[2:16:29] where we and Canyon Park developers agreed
[2:16:34] to allow Fillmore Street between, I'm sorry, Golden Corral,
[2:16:42] And we like some Canyon Springs.
[2:16:45] We like some Canyon Springs.
[2:16:47] We like some Canyon Springs.
[2:16:48] I'm sorry, I couldn't remember the name of the street.
[2:16:51] So we like some Canyon Springs.
[2:16:54] So we entered a new agreement where that road,
[2:16:58] that alignment could be moved and it could be made
[2:17:00] into a private roadway with the public right way
[2:17:03] he's been on it.
[2:17:04] When we entered into that agreement,
[2:17:07] the developer found out just about immediately thereafter
[2:17:12] that there was an instrument by a separate agreement
[2:17:14] to address the stormwater on the roadway that's going away.
[2:17:18] And so the request this evening is to allow
[2:17:22] that stormwater easement to go away
[2:17:25] when the old roadway alignment goes away.
[2:17:29] And then the question that we have is what happens
[2:17:31] to the stormwater on the new?
[2:17:35] Well, the new roadway is required by our subdivision
[2:17:38] planning rules to have its water addressed
[2:17:42] by the adjacent property owners, and it's a private road,
[2:17:46] so they have to take care of it and pass through, you know,
[2:17:49] whatever 100-year water there is.
[2:17:52] And so the storm water needs will be addressed
[2:17:57] for the new Canyon Park development.
[2:17:59] So this is housekeeping as a floor.
[2:18:04] So the request is to have Council consider approving the
[2:18:10] amendment and authorizing the mayor to sign the First Amendment, which doesn't
[2:18:17] actually vacate the stormwater easement until the agreement is exercised.
[2:18:24] Thank you Mayor. Do we know if there are any other utility or city lines in that
[2:18:33] old easement? Are those all being moved if there are any?
[2:18:45] A abandonment of the roadway does not include an abandonment of utilities.
[2:18:50] Okay, so there's a utility easement that stays put until those utilities are moved.
[2:18:58] So at this point in time, I did not understand that the utilities were moving.
[2:19:04] So there's an easement still there for them.
[2:19:07] But is the plan to move them? Are they being moved?
[2:19:11] I don't think so I
[2:19:13] That's not my understanding. I may be a little bit behind on that actual subdivision review plan set
[2:19:20] But I can certainly find out the answer for you and give you that feedback
[2:19:25] Sure, there is no way that we're gonna relinquish a road right away with a water line in it without keeping an easement on our line
[2:19:32] Right, and do we know what will be built on top of that is that will be a parking lot or a building no buildings on top of city
[2:19:41] public. Correct. But if it's it's a parking lot, then the city water you know and utilities
[2:19:48] will run under that parking lot. If we need to work on it would have to be taken up.
[2:19:54] It's similar to the private road. Okay. Is that the cost of the city or the landowner?
[2:20:03] Yes. So how would that compare to whether it's under is it better for it to be under
[2:20:16] a road or is it just the same if it's under landscaping or parking lot?
[2:20:25] It can be better to be through a parking lot because you can close
[2:20:34] aisles of a parking lot and if you kill off a tree you can play a new tree and you don't
[2:20:39] have to deal with traffic control.
[2:20:41] Okay, thank you.
[2:20:44] Just talking to them.
[2:20:45] I'll make a motion unless somebody has questions, all right.
[2:20:50] to authorize a amendment for the public right-of-way easement in the canyon park
[2:20:55] development and authorized mayor to sign that amendment. Second. Then moved by
[2:21:01] Chris Tockington and seconded by Don Hall to be approved the request for the amendment.
[2:21:06] First amendment I think is called. First amendment and we'd be able to sign it. Any
[2:21:12] other discussion? Seeing none they have a roll call vote. Rebecca Mills-Sleika.
[2:21:16] Yes, Chris talking to yes Sean Burger. Yes. Don Hall. Yes. Yes, Greg Lansing. Yes, Jim Mundt. Yes
[2:21:25] Motion passes seven to zero
[2:21:32] The next time which is public input is there anyone the audience it would
[2:21:40] You're hopeful thinking
[2:21:47] I have.
[2:21:48] I'm sure they'll write them.
[2:21:49] One more.
[2:21:50] I want to report this thing because I was just wishful thinking.
[2:21:54] Good try though.
[2:21:55] All right, John Keaton is going to talk to us about the update on the Booliex Generator
[2:22:00] Project and share with City Council the new infrastructure zone maintenance program that
[2:22:05] will be implemented this year.
[2:22:09] Thank you.
[2:22:10] Good evening.
[2:22:11] I'll be with you.
[2:22:12] John.
[2:22:13] Just an update.
[2:22:14] There's no action tonight.
[2:22:15] I just wanted to give you some information on the maintenance program we're implementing
[2:22:19] and I'll start with the Blue Exgenerator project.
[2:22:22] It took a lot of effort and a lot of agency approvals and reviews to get this project going.
[2:22:30] Within the next two weeks, I tend to be breaking ground on the project and once we get going,
[2:22:35] once we start, it should go very quickly.
[2:22:39] Right now we're in a redesign on the slab.
[2:22:42] We're going to add a retaining wall to it so we can tuck it in a little tighter and get it a little tightier on site.
[2:22:49] And I would think that project would be a 10-to-15-day project once we get one here.
[2:22:57] So any questions before we move on?
[2:23:02] You might mention for the audience, hopefully watching the sense we're up Cassie to them.
[2:23:09] What agencies did you have to get approval through?
[2:23:12] beginning with our own to get approval that we can spend those funds, you know,
[2:23:18] they're coming out of reserves, it was a fun budget, you know, it was a unscheduled maintenance activity.
[2:23:22] And after that, we had to go through Jerome County, because this is actually in Jerome County planning and zoning.
[2:23:29] There was DEQ,
[2:23:36] DEQ needed to review and approve the plan set, and I know I'm forgetting somebody.
[2:23:41] Oh yeah, who likes to introduce the owner of this property?
[2:23:44] Yeah.
[2:23:45] All right.
[2:23:46] Thank you, John.
[2:23:47] I'm going to lead on to the road.
[2:23:53] Okay.
[2:23:54] So, this old maintenance program really started when, you know, when it's based and was developed
[2:24:03] from a street's perspective.
[2:24:04] When we started talking about street maintenance, it's kind of where it started from.
[2:24:10] And the big driver in this was our organized street superintendent, Dean Lentler, he's really been, he's very organized and he brought, really, the way we're approaching this, it just brings a sense of order to how we do a lot of our things.
[2:24:27] So I'll start with how we used to do things.
[2:24:30] In the past, when you think about maintenance and infrastructure in the whole city, it's a lot to digest.
[2:24:36] I give you some approximate numbers.
[2:24:38] We have 625 lane miles paved in the city.
[2:24:42] We have over 230 miles of wastewater, of sewer line.
[2:24:48] We have over 200 miles of water line.
[2:24:50] And when you sit and think about all the things
[2:24:53] that need fixed on there, it can be intimidating.
[2:24:56] And then you have to prioritize what you're doing.
[2:24:58] And in the past, when we looked at road maintenance,
[2:25:01] we'd look at the streets that have the greatest need.
[2:25:06] And when you go on the map and you start highlighting the roads that need the greatest need and you take a step back, it's spread everywhere throughout the whole city.
[2:25:14] And over time, you know, the city's grown and we're doing more maintenance and it's starting to become inefficient, cumbersome, it's confusing, it's not very manageable.
[2:25:27] And then, so Dean along of course with engineering really started to look at, okay, so how can
[2:25:35] we make this a little bit more predictable and so that we can all collaborate here.
[2:25:40] And we started with the zone map here.
[2:25:44] So when you think of streets, we try to divide the city into eight similarly sized zones and
[2:25:53] they're similar in size because of the amount of pavement that's in each.
[2:25:56] You'll see some of them are larger again, land area, but the pavement is approximately
[2:26:01] 520,000 square yards, which really comes out to be about 75 lane miles, paved lane miles per zone.
[2:26:12] This is zone one here, of course, north, at the top of the page. And zone two is here,
[2:26:23] and the time works in a clockwise direction. So this year is the first year that we're implementing
[2:26:30] the program. And what it does is it really helps us plan, first of all, plan, budget,
[2:26:39] engineer, and then implement. So I'll just give you an example where we're at today. In zone
[2:26:48] four, public works is out looking at our infrastructure, providing engineering some feedback on what we
[2:26:57] see as some low hanging fruit or some opportunities for some maintenance. Zone three, engineering
[2:27:05] is in design. So they're designing the projects that we're suggesting. And in zone two, public
[2:27:14] works as either constructing them or engineering is supervising the reconstruction of those
[2:27:20] project. And then in zone, excuse me, in zone one, we're actually doing the seal coat. The
[2:27:25] The whole goal here is to, you know, we've all seen it, you have a new road, and then
[2:27:31] two weeks later you have a water main break underneath it, you know.
[2:27:34] This program, I mean, isn't going to completely eliminate that, but it's going to minimize
[2:27:39] that.
[2:27:40] We're going to be able to coordinate our efforts.
[2:27:41] It's very predictable, as you can see, all of Public Works is aware of the zone program.
[2:27:47] They know that if they're in zone one, they're good.
[2:27:55] They can do some maintenance.
[2:27:57] And they know where they're going to be the next year.
[2:28:00] The other thing it does is it helps us forecast what our budgets are going to be.
[2:28:05] And because these are similarly sized, it allows us to be fairly stable.
[2:28:12] I should mention that not all of our roads are pavement, some of them are concrete
[2:28:17] And so they'll require different kinds of maintenance.
[2:28:20] And not all of our maintenance will always occur in that zone.
[2:28:24] It'll be our priority.
[2:28:25] It'll be our focus.
[2:28:26] But obviously, there'll be unscheduled maintenance
[2:28:28] that'll occur other places.
[2:28:29] And we'll have to deal with that as it comes.
[2:28:32] There's been good because it brings a sense of order
[2:28:37] to a lot of things that we do.
[2:28:41] Like I said, when you think about trying
[2:28:42] to take care of that whole city, it really helps out
[2:28:46] when you focus on the zone, you can really wrap your head around it, you can really dig
[2:28:51] in and make some progress.
[2:28:53] I miss anything, Dave.
[2:29:01] You know, he and Jackie, there's been a lot of people collaborating and putting this together
[2:29:06] and we've had a lot of discussions and there's so many things that really makes us more efficient
[2:29:14] and predictable.
[2:29:15] and I'm excited about it, it'll be a good thing.
[2:29:18] And I won't go on and on, but if you have any questions.
[2:29:21] We do have some lights on, Don Hall.
[2:29:24] John, it makes sense to me, but I also believe we've talked about in the past that we're also trying to communicate with folks like the cable and the power and other folks that might tear up some of our roads to do some repairs or some updating to make sure that we don't pay a brand new road,
[2:29:42] and then they come through and tear up our brand new pavement.
[2:29:45] The citizens really get concerned about that, including myself.
[2:29:48] Can you elaborate on it?
[2:29:50] Sure.
[2:29:50] You know, we try to do that now when we have major projects going through.
[2:29:52] We try to coordinate with the utilities, the council, and try to make sure that everybody's
[2:29:56] had an opportunity to evaluate their own utilities.
[2:29:59] But you know, it's hard for anybody to react in a short period of time.
[2:30:04] And like I said, we're just implementing this now.
[2:30:06] But one of these days when we've had a few trial runs here, and this works well, it'll
[2:30:12] be an opportunity for other utility companies to, again, will be more predictable for them,
[2:30:17] so they can start doing some capital maintenance ahead of us.
[2:30:22] I'm very commendable, John.
[2:30:24] I like the systemic approach, but let me be the devil's advocate.
[2:30:29] If you tell Dean to spend a preponderance of his budget or his time in picking his own
[2:30:36] Zone four, is that the tan one?
[2:30:40] Yeah, zone four.
[2:30:44] Is that necessarily population problem
[2:30:49] or infrastructure need driven by its boundaries?
[2:30:56] I guess what I'm asking is over a period of time, is it possible
[2:31:00] that we're going to see areas of most concern,
[2:31:04] not necessarily receiving the budgetary focus that it should.
[2:31:11] How are you assuring that you're not neglecting any section,
[2:31:16] but maybe not diddling your money away in some area that has cobwebs growing on it?
[2:31:21] You know, that's something that Dean and I are going to have to just really pay attention to every year.
[2:31:26] And like I said, you know, the goal is to stay in the zone so that utilities can predict where they're going to be,
[2:31:34] But there's going to be anomalies and there's going to be newer parts of town that are going to require less
[2:31:41] costly and less
[2:31:42] Surface repairs and in those years if we want to go outside of the zone we can certainly do that
[2:31:47] I rely heavily on dean to evaluate the condition
[2:31:51] I mean he drives this and I should mention actually that it worked out this year's budget will seal coat
[2:31:58] 90% of one of course. Yeah, it's market driven, but right now we're looking at that
[2:32:11] So it's a fair question, obviously we're going to spend the dollars as wisely as we can.
[2:32:19] It's got to be an improvement over the system you have now though.
[2:32:22] Do you think, Chris?
[2:32:26] Oh, that's good.
[2:32:27] No, no, I've just been getting people off tonight.
[2:32:30] It seemed like something.
[2:32:31] I was trying not to anymore.
[2:32:33] We're making months like it.
[2:32:34] Thank you, Mayor.
[2:32:35] Just a comment.
[2:32:36] I just want to say thank you for this response.
[2:32:40] I know in the past couple of years we've had a lot of citizen comment on requests for the
[2:32:48] city to be more orderly and plan ahead for maintenance and road work.
[2:32:55] And I think that this plan does a very good job of addressing all of their complaints.
[2:33:00] I mean, some of the complaints are don't have the whole city torn up at once.
[2:33:05] And so I think this is actually a very good way to address it.
[2:33:10] And like you said, it's not going to prevent any, you know,
[2:33:13] all situations where there are emergencies.
[2:33:16] But it certainly is a great response to citizen input.
[2:33:20] So I really appreciate that.
[2:33:22] And I, too, am very excited about it.
[2:33:26] Susan Hawkins.
[2:33:28] Just a thought.
[2:33:29] With our strategic planning meeting on Thursday night,
[2:33:32] I know there's going to be different bits of information
[2:33:34] around. Is it possible you could have this map set up somewhere and maybe be
[2:33:38] available to address it if citizens would like to see what we're talking about?
[2:33:42] Absolutely. Thank you. Good ideas Suzanne. I have no other lights John so if you have
[2:33:49] a wrap-up or if you're just done we'd like to thank you and Dean Dean you know
[2:33:53] it's good thing you have that mustaches because when you have your hat off
[2:33:56] sometimes I don't recognize you. I'll have that black hat up there. But thank you
[2:34:01] John and we'll look forward to seeing how this works.
[2:34:06] Yeah, I'll keep you posted.
[2:34:07] Thank you.
[2:34:08] Thank you.
[2:34:13] Thank you.
[2:34:14] Finally, item six.
[2:34:15] Got there.
[2:34:16] We have one in the audience that would like to provide public input.
[2:34:19] One item was a warrant on the agenda tonight.
[2:34:24] Seeing none, how about City Major?
[2:34:27] Mr. Mayor, members of the council, just two quick reminders.
[2:34:30] The first was mentioned on Thursday evening at 6 o'clock PM in this room.
[2:34:35] We are going to have our public open house for the strategic planning session.
[2:34:39] We are going to set up various stations regarding the eight different strategic planning elements.
[2:34:46] It is designed to be an open house.
[2:34:49] We are going to begin a presentation of the strategic plan.
[2:34:53] If you've seen it, you've seen it.
[2:34:55] It's pretty much the same roadshow.
[2:34:57] But we're going to begin that somewhere between 6.20 and 6.30, it takes about a half hour.
[2:35:01] and then continue to allow people to walk through and provide their thoughts in their
[2:35:08] comments. Later on this month, we intend to place it in the form of a resolution and
[2:35:13] have it in a final format to be adopted by the City Council so that we can use that in
[2:35:18] the creation of our fiscal year 2014 budgeting process.
[2:35:22] The second item is on April 29th, that is a fifth Monday. It is one of those meetings
[2:35:28] that we typically do not use unless needed.
[2:35:32] And I'm asking possibly if you could come in on that Monday,
[2:35:36] we would like to begin the budgeting process on that evening
[2:35:40] by beginning a review of the strategic plan and the items
[2:35:45] to begin or what that you would like to see funded.
[2:35:49] We would continue that conversation again on the sixth.
[2:35:52] The special meeting on the 29th with the a single purpose item
[2:35:57] would be for this purpose and so it's the only topic that we would discuss that evening
[2:36:02] and then we would continue that conversation on the 6th so that we can begin the staff budget
[2:36:07] hearings later on towards the end of May and kick off our FY 2014 budgeting process.
[2:36:17] Thank you Travis, also you want to talk about tomorrow?
[2:36:21] I thought one of you would but tomorrow is the state of the city address, it is at noon
[2:36:26] at the fine art auditorium over in the,
[2:36:29] that's not what it is, I can't remember the exact,
[2:36:32] the arts.
[2:36:34] That's where it is, in the same building
[2:36:36] that the elevation 486 restaurant is in,
[2:36:40] the format is slightly different this year
[2:36:43] than in past years, the mayor is going to open a,
[2:36:47] with a few brief remarks after a meal,
[2:36:50] and then I guess all members of the council
[2:36:53] will be standing for questions as they
[2:36:56] are ball lead from those interested participants.
[2:36:59] And every member of staff who's there
[2:37:00] could be called upon to help us answer.
[2:37:04] Staff is having lunch at D.C.
[2:37:07] I may not be there, so I would hope
[2:37:10] Jack could answer any greater transportation issues, right?
[2:37:15] Or library issues, whoever wants to speak.
[2:37:18] OK.
[2:37:20] Don, your hand says it's been pleased for quite some time.
[2:37:22] Come away.
[2:37:23] I'm not even nervous.
[2:37:25] Rebecca Mills, I can beat you in this, apparently.
[2:37:27] You did?
[2:37:28] Oh, sorry, I didn't mean for that happy use.
[2:37:30] No, it wasn't a race.
[2:37:31] I'll be quick about this idea.
[2:37:35] I received an email that I had, I look forward to the council.
[2:37:40] And it was a request from a citizen about connecting trails.
[2:37:44] But it was really a budget request, is what it was.
[2:37:47] And so it got me thinking about our process
[2:37:50] and how we have our state statute appointed budget hearing,
[2:37:55] which is typically at the end of the budget process.
[2:37:57] And I thought it might be good or helpful for us
[2:38:01] since Travis usually comes to us
[2:38:04] at the beginning of the process and says,
[2:38:06] what are your priorities?
[2:38:07] What are the priorities of the community?
[2:38:08] And I think that I would like to have,
[2:38:11] and so I wanna throw this out to council
[2:38:13] and see what your thoughts are on this
[2:38:15] on having a pre-budget kind of public hearing
[2:38:18] and really emphasizing that, because in my experience,
[2:38:21] when people come speak at the very end,
[2:38:23] we're about to adopt the budget.
[2:38:25] They have all these ideas or complaints,
[2:38:27] and we say, yes, great, thank you,
[2:38:29] and then we adopt the budget and move on,
[2:38:32] and I don't think that that process really encourages them.
[2:38:37] First of all, to come to public hearings,
[2:38:38] I don't know if it makes them feel heard
[2:38:41] or makes them feel like they're part of the process.
[2:38:44] And so I would like to have maybe on that beginning meeting
[2:38:49] or when Travis is asking us what the community priorities are,
[2:38:53] I think it would be appropriate to have input
[2:38:56] from the community and those people who want a dog park
[2:38:59] or want a community garden or have a trail system in mind
[2:39:03] or whatever those priorities are,
[2:39:06] I would like to hear it at that time
[2:39:08] and I think it might be more beneficial for us
[2:39:12] and for them to be on the front end of the process.
[2:39:17] We take the 29th, possibly.
[2:39:20] It could be as early as that.
[2:39:22] I don't know what the, I would leave it up to staff
[2:39:25] and city manager to kind of just put it on
[2:39:29] one of the beginning agendas.
[2:39:31] And that way also that we could really promote that
[2:39:35] even bigger than we do, you know,
[2:39:37] of course we have our legal notices
[2:39:38] that we do for the state statute, public hearing.
[2:39:43] But to really promote that public hearing as,
[2:39:47] this is really your time because as the dog park proponents
[2:39:52] and people come in and we say, well,
[2:39:54] we're kind of in the middle of a budget.
[2:39:55] We can't give you any money.
[2:39:57] We don't feel good about giving you money right now.
[2:40:01] I think it would be a good time for them to come.
[2:40:04] But we could just have staff schedule it
[2:40:07] into the budget schedule as far as.
[2:40:10] I mean, problem that or?
[2:40:13] I might I really know myself as well.
[2:40:16] I might be as early as the 29th.
[2:40:19] What were your thoughts were exact?
[2:40:21] So staff would like guidance from the council
[2:40:23] on when you want it.
[2:40:25] Because our tendencies may not be to have it when you would.
[2:40:30] So if I were to place it somewhere in all honesty,
[2:40:36] I would place it some place within the first couple of weeks of July.
[2:40:40] At that point in time, we have a budget that has gone through those more formalized processes.
[2:40:46] So we hope that we've had lots of good community input associated with our strategic plan.
[2:40:52] The purpose of our budget is to fund the strategic plan and fund those priorities.
[2:40:59] Move then forward to, we go through several internal processes in June.
[2:41:05] We're going to come back to you just as we do, and we will say, did we hear you right?
[2:41:11] This is the box that we would like to fund.
[2:41:13] That might be an appropriate opportunity.
[2:41:16] Another appropriate opportunity might be after we have a preliminary budget that we are presenting
[2:41:22] to you to wrestle with and add to, subtract from whatever that looks like.
[2:41:28] So, those would be the processes.
[2:41:31] If you want to do it on the 20th night, that's a slightly different process, but we could work
[2:41:37] that in.
[2:41:40] Our idea was that you would share with us the strategic planning objectives that you wanted
[2:41:45] to move forward with to really begin to create those sideboards.
[2:41:49] If that's the appropriate time, we'll make that allowance at that time.
[2:41:55] I think both of those ideas are good ideas as far as either the preliminary budget or...
[2:42:00] I think I'm kind of leaning toward your trade
[2:42:07] tribes that one for the first one is alive because then people we can publicize that
[2:42:12] and they kind of have the meat of what we're talking about then they can be in a
[2:42:15] disagree or disagree well before the end because like Rebecca says at the end
[2:42:20] sometimes we're kind of walked in I mean we may change we may change it based on
[2:42:24] public comment but it's a little tougher at the end and it is right there at that
[2:42:27] at the primary budget stage, so.
[2:42:30] What if, and I'm just kind of flying with just ideas,
[2:42:35] what if we, when we come back to you in June,
[2:42:42] which is typically going to be the second week of June,
[2:42:45] is when we come back?
[2:42:47] What if during that meeting we share with you
[2:42:52] what the general outline looks like,
[2:42:55] and then there's an opportunity if public comments
[2:42:58] want to be thrown in there, you can instruct items to be included or not.
[2:43:07] Typically, what we've done in the past is we've asked what number one projects do you
[2:43:12] want to be funded?
[2:43:13] That's one.
[2:43:14] And number two, what is your tolerance for adjustment in tax rates as well as user rates?
[2:43:21] Because there's a direct correlation between revenues received and services being able to
[2:43:27] be provided.
[2:43:28] So that's where that rubber meets the road conversation, and so maybe it's appropriate
[2:43:34] also to have that in that second meeting in June, with a recap in July of this is what
[2:43:40] we heard and this is what we're doing as we roll through that process.
[2:43:44] In all honesty, you could open up all of those conversations at the discretion of the mayor
[2:43:51] and with the support of the council, any one of the budget hearings that we have throughout
[2:43:56] the process.
[2:43:57] However you want to engage to include the public is really your discretion.
[2:44:04] What will be the first time we will have a handle on tax revenue?
[2:44:17] We believe right now that we will see a continued decline in the value of residential homes in our community.
[2:44:33] We believe that that's going to continue probably this year, certainly.
[2:44:38] If I were guessing not as significant as what we've seen in the prior year.
[2:44:43] Remember there is, we went through the exercise last year sharing that there is,
[2:44:49] not necessarily a correlation from a higher tax rate causing higher taxes.
[2:44:54] In fact, as we illustrated last year, the higher tax rate even caused
[2:44:59] most residential property owners to have a lower tax bill than what they had the prior year.
[2:45:06] We, $0.16, but I don't think we get to the point by July, we're not going to have even a tentative on the revenues available.
[2:45:14] We will, we will.
[2:45:15] Yeah, I'm trying to think we will have, we are, I am required by statute to present to you a balanced budget.
[2:45:22] I will present to you a balanced budget the first week in July.
[2:45:27] I can't tell you how much sooner than that, it will be done.
[2:45:31] That's where I'm kind of hedging my bet.
[2:45:34] Is July 29th too far away?
[2:45:36] Because that's also a fifth Monday.
[2:45:38] That might be a time to do a community.
[2:45:42] We are going to ask the council, and this
[2:45:47] is one of those statutory processes.
[2:45:49] We will ask the council to adopt what's
[2:45:51] called the tentative budget.
[2:45:53] That maximum spending budget, the first week
[2:45:58] in August, whatever that first Monday is, is that,
[2:46:03] and so maybe that fifth Monday might be pushing it
[2:46:05] from the time frame as well.
[2:46:07] I actually like the second week of June.
[2:46:09] I think that's really good time.
[2:46:10] I like the June time frame as well.
[2:46:12] I do too, because we do want it far enough away
[2:46:14] from the actual state required public hearing,
[2:46:18] I mean, because you want it on the front end,
[2:46:20] but they will have something to respond to,
[2:46:22] and you'll have kind of a rough idea, a rough presentation
[2:46:27] of here's what we are thinking of funding, is that correct?
[2:46:32] I think it's going to be challenging for us
[2:46:33] to try to set a broad framework at the front end
[2:46:38] of May with citizens in here with their pet projects
[2:46:45] to be perfectly blunt.
[2:46:46] I think it's going to be difficult for us to say,
[2:46:49] here's the big picture of what we're
[2:46:50] after for the community based on the strategic plan.
[2:46:53] While we're listening to, won't you build my dog park?
[2:46:56] I need my community garden.
[2:46:58] And not that those things are important,
[2:46:59] but I think they need to be in that framework.
[2:47:01] And if we don't build the framework first.
[2:47:03] It's gonna be tough even in June to do that though.
[2:47:05] It is, it's gonna be difficult whenever it happens.
[2:47:08] But I think if it happens,
[2:47:10] when we have nothing sitting in front of us,
[2:47:13] it's gonna be hard to figure out how it fits in that.
[2:47:16] So I think that June-ish timeframe
[2:47:18] as that preliminary budget stuff is coming out,
[2:47:20] might be a good time to do that.
[2:47:22] I would agree.
[2:47:23] I agree.
[2:47:25] Does that give me enough direction?
[2:47:28] All right, thank you, Don Hall.
[2:47:29] Couple things I wanted to bring to Council's attention.
[2:47:33] We had a urban renewal agency meeting today,
[2:47:36] and one of the agenda items was the potential expansion
[2:47:41] of a revenue allocation area downtown.
[2:47:47] I think what we found is that there's some projects
[2:47:50] or some things that the urban renewal agency
[2:47:55] would like to be involved in enhancement of downtown,
[2:47:59] but they're not able to do it,
[2:48:00] because it's outside of the revenue allocation area.
[2:48:04] And so they would like to have an open house meeting
[2:48:08] with the public regarding the expansion of that area,
[2:48:12] and they can expand it up to 10%.
[2:48:14] Is that right, Mitch?
[2:48:17] And so there's some preliminary ideas
[2:48:20] of what that could look like,
[2:48:21] but they wanna have again this open house with the public.
[2:48:24] It looks like on April 24th, still being determined
[2:48:27] whether it's going to be here or maybe the ballroom
[2:48:29] because we had the folks from the ballroom,
[2:48:32] make mention of that.
[2:48:33] But as soon as we know that we'll bring that to the council's
[2:48:35] attention, of course, publicize that.
[2:48:38] Second issue that I just wanted to bring to the council.
[2:48:40] Tonight's the first night that I've actually jumped
[2:48:43] on our website, the city's website,
[2:48:46] and looked at the live streaming.
[2:48:49] A little scary, the guy right in the middle right here
[2:48:51] to look at, but the rest of you are fine to look at.
[2:48:53] But yeah, I'm sorry, I was talking about me.
[2:48:59] But I do want to compliment Josh.
[2:49:02] I know that you were really involved in this.
[2:49:04] And thank you.
[2:49:05] It's actually very, you can see it very well.
[2:49:11] It's running about 30 seconds behind.
[2:49:13] If you've not done this before, not taking a look at,
[2:49:16] which is a little weird to watching them.
[2:49:18] So you do this and then 30 seconds later happens.
[2:49:20] And alongside the, it actually has our agenda items that are there.
[2:49:25] So I think that's very user friendly for the public to be able to see.
[2:49:29] And somehow magically, when we're on a subject, it actually says current item.
[2:49:35] And I'm assuming you're doing that, Leyla.
[2:49:37] And I'm assuming the person that would be sitting in that position for
[2:49:42] all the commissions and committees that meet here can do the same thing.
[2:49:45] So anyway, I just think kudos to you and everyone
[2:49:49] that helps you bring this.
[2:49:51] And it's just again opening City Council meetings
[2:49:54] up to more folks.
[2:49:57] Ditto, I'm just gonna say almost the exact same thing,
[2:49:59] Gus, in the IT department.
[2:50:00] They've, Tammy's left, but to congratulate them as well.
[2:50:04] Chris Tignon.
[2:50:05] Actually, I'd like to follow on Don's first item.
[2:50:08] That was my thought.
[2:50:10] I'm actually very disappointed in the city of Twin Falls
[2:50:13] and the urban renewal for being so amateurish
[2:50:16] on this plan development of the downtown area.
[2:50:19] I remember we spent most of an afternoon with urban renewal
[2:50:23] with grandiose plans of how they were going
[2:50:25] to put money improving the water lines, the sidewalks,
[2:50:30] the planings, streets and everything.
[2:50:33] And we were all probably in use
[2:50:36] and more than we've been in any time I can remember.
[2:50:38] And for us to make, and I put the blame on myself
[2:50:41] for making such an amateurish oversight to not recognize
[2:50:45] that that was not in one of the revenue allocation area is allowed.
[2:50:49] I don't know how the heck it happened, but I'm not very happy
[2:50:52] because we have now put that project off for another complete fiscal cycle.
[2:50:58] And I think we've all left down the public on this.
[2:51:02] And if this public hearing of the urban renewals goes somewhere,
[2:51:07] Don, more power to it.
[2:51:09] But I was assured with all their technical competence we had
[2:51:13] that this was a matter of only a matter of when we get our act together and start doing
[2:51:20] something jointly. I think we've done a disservice to the taxpayers and to the downtown area by
[2:51:27] not being more on the ball. So I'll take my 40 glasses.
[2:51:31] Fred, did any of this kind of surprise to you that I'm just puzzled with the right questions
[2:51:39] I know when it came to me, and it was like I don't always know where different monies are coming from to fun things, but when the question comes to me, can we spend tax increment funds outside the area, the answer is obvious, you can't do that.
[2:51:55] Why didn't we know that long ago?
[2:51:57] We didn't know that. I don't know what the source of the funds was when we were talking about that.
[2:52:05] The important part to me is that we're moving in the
[2:52:12] part of including what most people consider downtown
[2:52:16] and that rather than allocation area better late than never I guess.
[2:52:20] We'll put it to the chamber.
[2:52:24] I just wanted to mention that last week the Parks and Rec Department
[2:52:28] held two community meetings related to the
[2:52:32] off-leash dog proposal that we directed
[2:52:36] them to get some input on Parks and Rec Commission is actually going to hear a
[2:52:39] report from Dennis tomorrow at noon which none of us will be attending since
[2:52:44] we'll be at City City but I want to let you know that the Commission is going to
[2:52:48] hear that information and I'm anticipating that'll be on the agenda
[2:52:52] next week with some recommendation back to the Council but there are pretty well
[2:52:57] attended meetings a lot of good input and truthfully I'm glad the Commission is
[2:53:02] going to have the debate tomorrow to come up with the recommendation because I
[2:53:04] I think it would be difficult for us to do it without that input.
[2:53:08] Suzanne Hockett.
[2:53:10] Couple updates from Youth Council.
[2:53:12] They're getting ready for their kite day on April 20th and 21st.
[2:53:16] And they are still looking for judges.
[2:53:19] So if anybody is available on that Saturday or Sunday to help judge some of those events
[2:53:24] would be really appreciated. And I just wanted to make mention that the Youth Council is also putting
[2:53:30] and putting recycling bins in City Park this summer.
[2:53:34] So they are gonna take on that responsibility
[2:53:37] and see how it goes over this summer
[2:53:39] and decide how to go forth in the future.
[2:53:42] I thought that was great.
[2:53:46] Seeing the weather lights on,
[2:53:48] we do have one more item on the agenda
[2:53:51] and that is an executive session
[2:53:53] to conduct deliberations,
[2:53:54] considering labor negotiations
[2:53:56] or require an interest in real property,
[2:53:58] which is not owned by a public in, excuse me, public agency,
[2:54:02] 67-234-5C, Sean Berger.
[2:54:08] And move that be going to executive session as you just stated.
[2:54:13] Second.
[2:54:14] And move by Sean Berger and seconded by Susanne Hawkins
[2:54:18] that we move into executive session for 67-235-C.
[2:54:23] Seeing no lights in the other overall vote.
[2:54:25] Chris Tockington.
[2:54:27] Sean Burger yes, Don Hall yes Suzanne Hawkins yes great 19. Yes, Jim. I'm yes, but I'm also yes
[2:54:35] Pass seven zero we will not this will be conclude the public portion of the meeting will not be coming out of executive session
[2:54:42] I'm making any decisions
[2:54:44] We're adjourned to executive session
