{
 "built": "2026-11-21",
 "jurisdictions": [
  {
   "slug": "twin-falls-id",
   "name": "City of Twin Falls",
   "place": "Twin Falls, Idaho",
   "level": "City"
  }
 ],
 "findings": [
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "E-01",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/findings/e-01/",
   "title": "Mayor's letter lifted the vacation sell-back cap for the City Manager; no Council vote located",
   "area": "City Manager pay & leave",
   "topic": "executive-pay",
   "category": "Policy; contract; possible open-meeting; possible I.C. 18-1359(1)(a); City Code 1-2-1, 1-2-3",
   "grade_raw": "A",
   "grade": "documented",
   "grade_label": "Documented",
   "scopes": [
    "Local policy",
    "State law"
   ],
   "shows": "The Mayor's letter of Dec 8, 2022 lifts the vacation sell-back limit for the City Manager (\"Based on the direction of the performance review committee I am directing the Human Resources staff...\"). The Mayor signed it alone, and it has no end date. HR then wrote: \"Per Mayor's letter, we will process the full 100 requested\" (Dec 12, 2022). Payroll shows 100-hour sales on 12/23/2022, 12/22/2023, 1/3/2025 and 11/21/2025: 240 hours ($27,161.83) above the 40-hour cap. No motion appears in the Dec 5 or Dec 12, 2022 minutes, or in any Council record from 2014 to 2026 that we indexed.\nThe cap is Council-approved policy, not a staff rule. The FY2023 audited financial report (ACFR p30) says the new sick and vacation policies were adopted \"After management made some modifications and the City Council approved them.\" The record of that approval has not yet been located.\nThe letter's stated reason: it lifts the limit \"so that you may realize the benefit of vacation time that you have been unable to take.\" In the 12 months before the letter he used 96 hours of vacation and 40 hours of executive leave (136 hours). That is more vacation than in the same 12-month window of any year from 2016 to 2021 (the highest before was 67 hours, in 2019). He also used 36 hours of vacation in the pay period of the 100-hour sale (Dec 18-31, 2022). [Deduction] The City could argue that a balance built up in the 12 months ending Dec 2020, when he used 21.75 vacation hours; the register shows hours used, not balances.\nFor context (EX-A21, checks dated 10/1/2020 to 9/11/2026), vacation sell-back pay totals: City Manager $63,058.19; Deputy City Manager Humble $19,598.21; Deputy City Manager Scott $15,698.91; CFO, HR Director and Economic Development Director $0.\nThe City's sell-back form tells Payroll to confirm each request: \"Did they sell back in the current Fiscal Year?\" and \"Have they used the required vacation in the last 365 days? Look for pay code V - Vacation\" (EX-A30, from Sept 2022). No sell-back form for any City Manager sale has been released (P-77).\nThe letter is addressed to the City Manager but gives the order to his staff: \"I am directing the Human Resources staff to make the following compensation adjustments.\" Human Resources staff work for the City Manager. City Code 1-2-3 bars any Council member from giving orders to the City Manager's subordinates, and City Code 1-2-1 gives the mayor no administrative powers. The Sept 2025 letter uses the same words (EX-A09).\nThe letter rests on \"the direction of the performance review committee.\" The only evaluation committee the Council ever created in public was formed by a 7-0 vote on Sept 2, 2014, for \"the annual performance evaluation\" of the City Manager and City Attorney, with Mayor Don Hall, Vice Mayor Suzanne Hawkins and Council Member Chris Talkington as members (EX-B01; E-06). None of the three was on the Council when the Dec 2022 letter was signed. Don Hall is last listed on the Council in the Minutes 2017-01-09 p1, and Christopher Reid holds the seat by the Minutes 2017-01-17 p1. Chris Talkington's last roll call is in the Minutes 2020-01-06 p1; he is not on the Council in the Minutes 2020-02-03 p1. Suzanne Hawkins's last roll call, as Mayor, is in the Minutes 2022-01-03 p1; Ruth Pierce presides as Mayor from the Minutes 2022-01-10 p1. The Council at the Dec 5 and Dec 12, 2022 meetings was Mayor Ruth Pierce, Vice Mayor Christopher Reid and Council Members Craig Hawkins, Jason Brown, Spencer Cutler, Nikki Boyd and Alexandra Caval (EX-B09, EX-B10). At the Sept 8, 2025 meeting, the date of the second letter, it was Mayor Ruth Pierce, Vice Mayor Jason Brown and Council Members Craig Hawkins, Christopher Reid, Spencer Cutler, Cherie Vollmer and Grayson Stone (EX-B21). Council Member Craig Hawkins is not the Suzanne Hawkins named in 2014. No minutes from 2015 to 2026 re-form the committee or name new members.",
   "rule": "Handbook sell-back cap 40 hrs/FY (all versions 2018-2026). 2024 CM Agreement sec. 8 applies personnel rules unless the agreement alters them; sec. 2 requires amendments in writing signed by the parties. I.C. 74-206(3) bars final action in executive session. I.C. 18-1359(1)(a): no public servant may, without specific authorization of the governmental entity, use public funds to obtain a pecuniary benefit for himself. City Code 1-2-3 (Ord. 3106, 2015): the Council and its members deal with the City's administrative services \"only through the city manager, except for the purpose of inquiry, and neither the city council nor any member thereof shall give orders to any subordinates of the city manager.\" City Code 1-2-1: the mayor performs \"such other duties consistent with his office as may be imposed by the council,\" and signing contracts or legal instruments by title \"shall not be construed as conferring upon him/her administrative powers or functions\" (the same rule as I.C. 50-810).",
   "why": "The employee handbook caps vacation sell-back at 40 hours a year. The Mayor lifted that cap for the City Manager with a letter signed by the Mayor alone, crediting a \"performance review committee\" whose only publicly named members had all left the Council by January 2022, no Council vote appears in any minutes we indexed from 2014 to 2026, and the City then paid for 240 hours above the cap ($27,161.83) across four sales from 2022 to 2025. The letter says the exception was needed because he had been unable to take vacation, but the payroll register shows he took more vacation in the year before the letter than in any comparable year since 2016.",
   "checked": "We searched machine transcripts of 529 City-posted Council recordings (2013 to November 2026) for any discussion of vacation sell-back for the City Manager and found none. Machine transcripts miss words, so this is a search result, not proof.",
   "matters": "Taxpayers paid $27,161.83 for vacation hours above a cap the Council approved, on the strength of a single signature instead of a public vote. A limit that can be lifted privately for the City's top executive is not a limit on public spending. The accounting manual the City posts with its Financial Policies describes a working control system as one where \"you don't get different rules because you are the mayor or a councilmember\" (p78). The Legislature's 2026 audit of Kamiah found the same weak spot: vacation payouts beyond the city's limits, with no documented approval.",
   "would_change": "The Mayor's letter rests on \"the direction of the performance review committee.\" This finding would change if a record from the time shows the Council gave that committee, or the Mayor, authority to lift the sell-back limit, or approved the exception itself in an open meeting. The committee would also have to exist in December 2022. The only one the Council created, in 2014, had three members, and all three had left the Council by January 2022. So a record would have to show the Council re-formed the committee or named its current members, and gave it that authority. Such records would be Council minutes or a resolution from before December 2022. None appears in the Council records from 2014 to 2026, and none was produced in answer to request #4869, which asked for exceptions to the handbook.",
   "level_shown": "City policy",
   "level_possible": "Ethics law",
   "harms": [
    {
     "label": "Public money",
     "slug": "public-money",
     "def": "Money paid outside the rules, or spent without the approvals the rules require. It comes out of the same budget as police, streets, parks and water."
    },
    {
     "label": "Unequal treatment",
     "slug": "unequal-treatment",
     "def": "Rules applied to some people and not others: employees held to limits their bosses ignore, or requesters treated differently depending on what they ask for. Rules that depend on rank or favor stop being rules."
    },
    {
     "label": "Hidden decisions",
     "slug": "hidden-decisions",
     "def": "Decisions made without a public vote, a proper notice or minutes. The public can't question, challenge or reverse what it never saw."
    }
   ],
   "sources": "PRR #4869 HR production: Travis 2022-2023 Compensation Letter (p1; emails pp2-5). PRR #4814 payroll register (Rothweiler) pp61,70,78,86. Minutes 2022-12-05, 2022-12-12. Handbooks (see Law sheet). EX-A21. 2023 Financial Statements (ACFR) p30 [City website, saved 2026-11-07]. Our count of every vacation line in the register (EX-A03 pp53-60 for the 12 months before the letter; p62 for Dec 18-31, 2022).; EX-A30 (sell-back form and payroll instructions).; City Code 1-2-1, 1-2-3 (online code, current through Ord. 2026-007).; EX-B01 (2014 committee); Minutes 2017-01-09, 2017-01-17, 2020-01-06, 2020-02-03, 2022-01-03 and 2022-01-10 (roll calls); EX-B09, EX-B10, EX-B21 (roll calls); E-06.",
   "exhibits": [
    "EX-A01",
    "EX-A02",
    "EX-A03",
    "EX-A09",
    "EX-A12",
    "EX-A21",
    "EX-A30",
    "EX-B01",
    "EX-B09",
    "EX-B10",
    "EX-B21"
   ],
   "requests": [
    {
     "j": "twin-falls-id",
     "request": "#4729",
     "subject": "ELT compensation records FY21-FY26",
     "filed": "2026-08 (approx.)",
     "outcome": "Produced HR documents",
     "findings": [
      "E-01",
      "E-02",
      "E-03",
      "E-04",
      "E-05",
      "E-06",
      "E-07",
      "E-08",
      "E-09"
     ],
     "how": ""
    }
   ],
   "level_label": "City code, policy or contract; possibly state ethics law",
   "level_score": 3,
   "level_keys": "city ethics",
   "outstanding": 4,
   "complete_rank": 488
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "E-02",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/findings/e-02/",
   "title": "Over-cap sell-backs 2016-2021, made before the required regular vacation was used, with no authority located",
   "area": "City Manager pay & leave",
   "topic": "executive-pay",
   "category": "Policy (Council Resolution No. 1897; 2018 and 2021 handbooks); possible I.C. 18-1359(1)(a)",
   "grade_raw": "A (payments) / B (no authority)",
   "grade": "documented",
   "grade_label": "Documented",
   "scopes": [
    "Local policy",
    "State law"
   ],
   "shows": "The City Manager's payroll register (EX-A03) shows these vacation sales: 80 hours on 10/21/2016 (p10), 10/20/2017 (p18), 11/2/2018 (p26) and 11/1/2019 (p35); 40 hours on 4/27/2020 (p39); and 100 hours on 1/8/2021 (p45) and 11/29/2021 (p52). The rules allowed 40 hours, once per fiscal year. Hours over the 40-hour limit: 40 in each of fiscal years 2017, 2018, 2019 and 2020 (the November 2019 sale) and 60 in each of fiscal 2021 and 2022, a total of 280 hours worth $22,925.48 at each sale's hourly rate. The April 2020 sale was 40 hours, within the limit, and is not counted here. No authorization for any of these sales appears in Council minutes from 2014 to 2021, and none has been released.\nVacation used in the 365 days before each sale (the register's \"Vacation\" pay lines, including the older \"Vacation (Inactive)\" code): 76.75 hours (Oct 2016), 49.25 (Oct 2017), 46.5 (Nov 2018), 76.0 (Nov 2019), 12.0 (Jan 2021) and 31.25 (Nov 2021). In calendar 2020, the year before both 2021 sales, he used 21.75 hours. So the Jan 2021 and Nov 2021 sales fail every version of the vacation-used test: 80 hours (the 2018 rule) or 40 hours (the City's 2020-2021 form and later handbooks), counted over 365 days or over the calendar year. The 2016-2019 sales fall short of the 80-hour rule in force then, but would meet a 40-hour test.\nFor scale: from Oct 2015 to Nov 2025 the City Manager sold 1,000 hours of vacation in 12 sales, $93,314.89 in all. Counting the 2022-2025 sales (E-01), 520 of those hours were above the 40-hour limit ($50,087.31).",
   "rule": "Resolution No. 1897 (Employee Resolution text in the Oct 29, 2018 packet p.35) and the Oct 2018 handbook (packet p.79): 80 hours accrued at the time of the request; 80 hours of vacation taken in the preceding 12 months; once per fiscal year; 40 hours maximum. The City's own sell-back form in 2020 and 2021 (EX-A30) printed: at least 80 hours accrued; \"at least one week of vacation during the preceding calendar year\" (40 hours); \"Vacation may only be sold back once during any fiscal year\"; and a sale \"to avoid a 'use it or lose it' situation must be approved by the City Manager.\" Later handbooks (2025 handbook sec. 5.2.1, released under PRR #3946): 40 hours taken \"in the preceding 12-month period,\" once per fiscal year, 40 hours maximum. The City Manager Service Agreements (2020; 2024) apply the Employee Handbook to his vacation.",
   "why": "",
   "checked": "Every pay line in the City Manager's payroll register, Oct 2015 to May 2026 (EX-A03, 299 checks), sorted by pay code. Each regular paycheck adds up to 80 hours (two have extra holiday hours), so no vacation line is missing from the counts above. Council minutes 2014-2021 for any sell-back authorization. The ten Deputy City Manager sell-back requests (EX-A30) for the rules the City printed on its own form.",
   "matters": "$22,925.48 in public money was paid for vacation hours above the City's own limit, with no record of anyone authorizing it. With the 2022-2025 sales (E-01), the total above the limit is $50,087.31. Rules on public spending only protect taxpayers if they apply at the top. The Legislature's 2026 audit of Kamiah found the same weak spot: vacation payouts beyond the city's limits, with no documented approval.",
   "would_change": "This finding would change if a written approval from the time allowed each sale above the 40-hour limit, signed by someone with authority to grant an exception for the City Manager. Such approvals would be filed with the sale requests in the City's payroll records. The City has released sell-back request forms for two deputies (EX-A30), but none for the City Manager.",
   "level_shown": "City policy",
   "level_possible": "Ethics law",
   "harms": [
    {
     "label": "Public money",
     "slug": "public-money",
     "def": "Money paid outside the rules, or spent without the approvals the rules require. It comes out of the same budget as police, streets, parks and water."
    },
    {
     "label": "Unequal treatment",
     "slug": "unequal-treatment",
     "def": "Rules applied to some people and not others: employees held to limits their bosses ignore, or requesters treated differently depending on what they ask for. Rules that depend on rank or favor stop being rules."
    }
   ],
   "sources": "Payroll register (Rothweiler), EX-A03 pp10, 18, 26, 35, 39, 45, 52 (sales) and every vacation line in the 12 months before each sale; EX-A02; Deputy City Manager sell-back requests 2020-2025, EX-A30 (rules printed on the form; payroll instructions); City Council Oct 29, 2018 packet pp35, 79, 102 (EX-B06); 2025 Employee Handbook sec. 5.2.1 (PRR #3946); City Manager Service Agreements Apr 2020 and 2024 (EX-A11, EX-A12).; City Code 1-5-8 (online code, current through Ord. 2026-007).",
   "exhibits": [
    "EX-A02",
    "EX-A03",
    "EX-A05",
    "EX-A11",
    "EX-A12",
    "EX-A30",
    "EX-B05",
    "EX-B06"
   ],
   "requests": [
    {
     "j": "twin-falls-id",
     "request": "#4729",
     "subject": "ELT compensation records FY21-FY26",
     "filed": "2026-08 (approx.)",
     "outcome": "Produced HR documents",
     "findings": [
      "E-01",
      "E-02",
      "E-03",
      "E-04",
      "E-05",
      "E-06",
      "E-07",
      "E-08",
      "E-09"
     ],
     "how": ""
    }
   ],
   "level_label": "City code, policy or contract; possibly state ethics law",
   "level_score": 3,
   "level_keys": "city ethics",
   "outstanding": 7,
   "complete_rank": 791
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "E-03",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/findings/e-03/",
   "title": "City Manager raises 2016-2025: all but one set outside any located open-session vote",
   "area": "City Manager pay & leave",
   "topic": "executive-pay",
   "category": "Possible open-meeting (I.C. 74-203, 74-206(3)); contract; City Code 1-2-1, 1-2-3",
   "grade_raw": "A (method 2020-25) / B (no vote)",
   "grade": "documented",
   "grade_label": "Documented",
   "scopes": [
    "Local policy",
    "State law"
   ],
   "shows": "Only three public Council actions on the City Manager's pay or agreement were located for 2014-2026: Feb 2, 2015 (Service Agreement approved 7-0); Apr 20, 2020 (agreement update; the staff memo says \"The rate of compensation is not changed by this agreement\" and states current pay as $169,124); and Dec 9, 2024 (amendment, 7-0). The Dec 2024 amendment set his pay at \"an annual base salary of $239,560 and $22,600 into an IRS qualified deferred compensation plan\" (EX-A12), and the Mayor read both figures aloud before the vote (Meeting 2024-12-09 at 0:08:38). His January 2025 rate of $115.17 an hour (about $239,554 a year) matches it, so the January 2025 raise is the one raise from 2016 to 2025 that the Council approved in open session. The Feb 2015 agreement was also discussed and approved as its own agenda item. None of these three actions was placed on the consent calendar, and no consent calendar from 2016 to 2024 lists payroll. Every other change has no located motion: Oct 2016 ($145,002), Oct 2017 ($158,002), Oct 2018 ($164,996), Oct 2019 ($169,125), Jan 2021 ($185,000), Oct 2021 ($193,336 + 5% deferred), Dec 2022 ($226,000 + $2,000), Dec 2023 (10% deferred = $22,600 + $1,500) and Sept 2025 ($272,650 total). The 2020-2025 changes were directed by Mayor and Vice Mayor emails and letters.\nCitywide raises in each adopted budget: FY2018 3.5% + 5% table (FY2018 budget p57); FY2019 3% across the board + 1% table (FY2019 budget p55); FY2020 3% + 3% table (FY19-20 budget p20); FY2021 2% + 2% table (FY2021 budget p21); FY2022 4.5% + $2,000 one-time (FY2022 budget p24); FY2023 5% + 2% table + $2,000 one-time (FY2023 budget pp25-26).\nCity Manager base increases: Oct 2017 +8.97%; Oct 2018 +4.43%; Oct 2019 +2.50%; Jan 2021 +9.39% (mid-year); Oct 2021 +4.51%; Dec 2022 +16.90% (base only; the separate $2,000 equals the citywide one-time payment). The Oct 2019 raise was below the citywide raise and the Oct 2021 raise equaled it, so those two were not above the citywide rate. [Deduction] Compounding the citywide raises for FY2018-FY2023 gives about +23%; the City Manager's base rose about +56% from Oct 2016 to Dec 2022.\nContext: under the agreement approved 7-0 on Dec 9, 2024, severance for termination without cause is twelve months of the \"total compensation package, which is defined as the Employee's rate of pay, deferred compensation package, other compensable pay or benefits extended the Employer, and Employer offered insurances.\" The April 2020 agreement based it on \"the Employee's then existing rate of pay\" (EX-A11, EX-A12). [Deduction] Each later pay adjustment therefore also raises the severance amount.",
   "rule": "I.C. 74-203(1) (deliberations and decisions in open meeting); 74-202(1) (\"decision\"); 74-206(3) (no final action in executive session); CM Agreement sec. 3 and sec. 8.; Financial Policies (eff. 10-1-13) pp11-12, repeated in each budget's policy appendix. City Code 1-2-3 (Ord. 3106, 2015): the Council and its members deal with the City's administrative services \"only through the city manager, except for the purpose of inquiry, and neither the city council nor any member thereof shall give orders to any subordinates of the city manager.\" City Code 1-2-1: the mayor performs \"such other duties consistent with his office as may be imposed by the council,\" and signing contracts or legal instruments by title \"shall not be construed as conferring upon him/her administrative powers or functions\" (the same rule as I.C. 50-810). The Dec 2022 and Sept 2025 letters say \"I am directing the Human Resources staff\" (EX-A07, EX-A09).",
   "why": "The City Manager's pay was raised seven times from 2016 to 2022, and again in 2023 and September 2025, with no Council vote located in any open meeting. The one raise approved in open session was January 2025's, set by the December 2024 contract amendment. The City's adopted budgets never state his salary, so adopting a budget did not approve it, and the City's own Financial Policies require base-budget increases to be approved at a Council meeting.",
   "checked": "We searched every set of Council minutes from 2006 to 2026 for a motion on the City Manager's pay. Before 2015 the only open actions on the position are his appointment (Nov 15, 2010, effective April 1, 2011) and the 2014 evaluation committee. So setting the City Manager's raises without an open vote did not start in 2016; the records show it as the long-standing practice.",
   "matters": "The City Manager's pay is one of the largest personnel decisions the Council makes, and residents are entitled to see it made. Raises set outside an open vote leave no way to know who decided, or why.",
   "would_change": "This finding would change if records from the time show the Council approved each raise in an open meeting, or adopted a formula that produced these amounts. Those would be Council minutes, a resolution, or the 2015 City Manager agreement, which the City has not produced (E-11). A budget line naming the City Manager's salary would also count; the budgets the City posts show department totals only, and its fiscal 2024 budget is not posted.",
   "level_shown": "City policy",
   "level_possible": "State law",
   "harms": [
    {
     "label": "Hidden decisions",
     "slug": "hidden-decisions",
     "def": "Decisions made without a public vote, a proper notice or minutes. The public can't question, challenge or reverse what it never saw."
    },
    {
     "label": "Public money",
     "slug": "public-money",
     "def": "Money paid outside the rules, or spent without the approvals the rules require. It comes out of the same budget as police, streets, parks and water."
    }
   ],
   "sources": "Minutes 2015-02-02 p8; 2020-04-20 packet pp74-77; 2024-12-09 minutes pp1-2; HR production #4869; payroll register. Adopted budgets FY2017-FY2023 and FY2025-FY2026 (FY2024 not posted) compensation sections (pages above); Financial Policies pp11-12 [City website, saved 2026-11-07].; City Code 1-2-1, 1-2-3 (online code, current through Ord. 2026-007).; EX-A12 sec. 3; Meeting 2024-12-09 at 0:08:38 (recording).",
   "exhibits": [
    "EX-A03",
    "EX-A04",
    "EX-A05",
    "EX-A06",
    "EX-A07",
    "EX-A08",
    "EX-A09",
    "EX-A10",
    "EX-A11",
    "EX-A12",
    "EX-A13",
    "EX-A21",
    "EX-A26",
    "EX-B02",
    "EX-B07",
    "EX-B08"
   ],
   "requests": [
    {
     "j": "twin-falls-id",
     "request": "#4729",
     "subject": "ELT compensation records FY21-FY26",
     "filed": "2026-08 (approx.)",
     "outcome": "Produced HR documents",
     "findings": [
      "E-01",
      "E-02",
      "E-03",
      "E-04",
      "E-05",
      "E-06",
      "E-07",
      "E-08",
      "E-09"
     ],
     "how": ""
    }
   ],
   "level_label": "City code, policy or contract; possibly state law",
   "level_score": 5,
   "level_keys": "city state",
   "outstanding": 3,
   "complete_rank": 383
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "E-04",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/findings/e-04/",
   "title": "Employer retirement and deferred compensation paid before it appears in any Council-approved document",
   "area": "City Manager pay & leave",
   "topic": "executive-pay",
   "category": "Contract; possible I.C. 18-1359(1)(a); federal tax-limit question",
   "grade_raw": "A",
   "grade": "documented",
   "grade_label": "Documented",
   "scopes": [
    "Local policy",
    "State law",
    "Federal"
   ],
   "shows": "CORRECTED 2026-11-08: Oct 19, 2021 email (EX-A06): \"The intent was 5% of the existing salary of $185K = $9250 for PERSI.\" The City's deduction report shows $9,302.00 total paid to \"Persi Choice City Manager\" from Oct 2020 to Sept 2026 (EX-A14), i.e. a one-time contribution, not an ongoing 5%. Dec 6, 2023 email (EX-A08): \"The base salary is $226,000 with a 10% deferred comp payment of $22,600,\" paid monthly per the Mayor; the City's expense report shows $61,280.73 paid under code A8 over 69 checks through Sept 2026 (EX-A15). Deferred compensation first appears in a Council-approved document in the Dec 2024 agreement (EX-A12, EX-B08). No posted adopted budget (FY2017-FY2023, FY2025-FY2026), nor the FY2027 recommended budget, mentions City Manager deferred compensation. The City has not posted its fiscal 2024 adopted budget, which covers the December 2023 change, or any fiscal 2024 quarterly report except December 2023 (E-31).",
   "rule": "2020 Agreement: base salary only. CM Agreement secs. 2, 3, 8.; Financial Policies p12 (base-budget increases need Council approval documented at a Council meeting).",
   "why": "The City Manager's 2020 contract provides a base salary only. A one-time employer retirement contribution of about $9,300 (2021-22) and ongoing deferred compensation of $22,600 a year (from December 2023) were set by email, but neither appears in any Council-approved document until the December 2024 amendment.",
   "checked": "",
   "matters": "Deferred compensation is pay. Adding it by email, up to $22,600 a year, years before any Council-approved document provided for it, means public money was paid that elected officials never approved.",
   "would_change": "This finding would change if records from the time show the Council approved the retirement contribution (October 2021) and the deferred compensation (December 2023) before they were paid: minutes, a resolution, or an adopted budget that names them. The fiscal 2024 adopted budget, which would cover the December 2023 change, is not posted on the City's website.",
   "level_shown": "City policy",
   "level_possible": "Ethics law",
   "harms": [
    {
     "label": "Public money",
     "slug": "public-money",
     "def": "Money paid outside the rules, or spent without the approvals the rules require. It comes out of the same budget as police, streets, parks and water."
    },
    {
     "label": "Hidden decisions",
     "slug": "hidden-decisions",
     "def": "Decisions made without a public vote, a proper notice or minutes. The public can't question, challenge or reverse what it never saw."
    }
   ],
   "sources": "Travis Rothweiler Deferred Compensation 1 & 2; 2020-2021 and 2023-2024 compensation emails; Amendment to the Agreement. Financial Policies p12; adopted budgets FY2017-FY2023 and FY2025-FY2026 (FY2024 not posted) [City website, saved 2026-11-07].",
   "exhibits": [
    "EX-A03",
    "EX-A06",
    "EX-A08",
    "EX-A11",
    "EX-A12",
    "EX-A14",
    "EX-A15",
    "EX-B08"
   ],
   "requests": [
    {
     "j": "twin-falls-id",
     "request": "#4729",
     "subject": "ELT compensation records FY21-FY26",
     "filed": "2026-08 (approx.)",
     "outcome": "Produced HR documents",
     "findings": [
      "E-01",
      "E-02",
      "E-03",
      "E-04",
      "E-05",
      "E-06",
      "E-07",
      "E-08",
      "E-09"
     ],
     "how": ""
    }
   ],
   "level_label": "City code, policy or contract; possibly state ethics law",
   "level_score": 3,
   "level_keys": "city ethics",
   "outstanding": 2,
   "complete_rank": 291
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "E-05",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/findings/e-05/",
   "title": "Pay directions follow \"evaluation\" executive sessions (2018-2025)",
   "area": "Open meetings",
   "topic": "open-meetings",
   "category": "Possible open-meeting (I.C. 74-206(1)(b), (2), (3))",
   "grade_raw": "B",
   "grade": "indicated",
   "grade_label": "Indicated",
   "scopes": [
    "State law"
   ],
   "shows": "Direction documents fall 0-3 days after a 74-206(1)(b) session in Dec 2020, Oct 2021, Dec 2022, Dec 2023 and Sept 2025. The pattern reaches back to 2018: the Oct 2018 raise and the Nov 2, 2018 sell-back fall between (b) sessions on Oct 29, Nov 5 and Dec 3, 2018; the Oct 2019 raise and the Nov 1, 2019 sell-back fall between (b) sessions on Sept 16, Oct 7 and Oct 28, 2019. No open-session motion follows any of them.\nThe direction emails describe a Council decision that no open-session minutes record. Dec 14, 2020, Mayor to HR: \"Is there some official way of taking care of this?\" HR: \"If the council approved the message from my attached email I don't think that I need anything other than your approval to move forward.\" Dec 17, 2020, HR: \"I'm just reaching out to confirm that the council approved the compensation plan for Travis.\" Mayor: \"Yes. The Council is unanimous.\" Dec 6, 2023, Mayor (after HR asked \"What is the council's direction\" on the $1,500 payment): \"Yes - TR gets the $1500 - he doesn't want to include himself but we decided he should also receive.\" (EX-A05, EX-A08)\nThe pattern also covers 2017: (b) sessions on Aug 7, Aug 28, Sept 5 and Sept 18, 2017 precede the October 2017 raise, with no open-session action on his pay in the minutes. One raise does not fit: before the October 2016 raise, the last (b) session in the minutes we have was April 11, 2016 (several mid-2016 minutes are not on the City's portal).\nAcross all minutes 2008-2026, (b) sessions in the minutes we have ran 1 to 7 a year until 2020, then 15 in 2021 and 13 in 2022. [Deduction] (b) sessions also cover other employees, so the count alone shows nothing about any one person.\nFrom the City's own recordings (machine transcripts; each reference plays that moment): before these sessions the chair states that no decisions will be made in them (Meeting 2018-10-29 at 0:43:01; Meeting 2019-09-16 at 0:47:28; Meeting 2019-10-28 at 0:36:26; Meeting 2021-10-18 at 1:03:20; Meeting 2022-12-12 at 1:06:35). On December 9, 2024, presenting the amended agreement for a public vote, the Mayor said its terms had been agreed with the City Manager during his evaluation (Meeting 2024-12-09 at 0:08:25).",
   "rule": "74-206(1)(b) permits an executive session \"to consider the evaluation, dismissal or disciplining of\" an employee; 74-206(2) requires the exceptions to be construed narrowly; 74-206(3): no executive session may be held \"for the purpose of taking any final action or making any final decision.\" AG Open Meeting Law Manual p.18: no executive sessions on general personnel matters, only the enumerated ones; do not \"shoehorn\" an issue into an exception. Neither the statute nor the manual says directly whether setting pay is \"evaluation\" [Deduction: the narrow-construction rule weighs against it].",
   "why": "",
   "checked": "",
   "matters": "Closed sessions can't be used to make decisions. When pay directions follow them within days, year after year, it suggests decisions are being made where the public can't see them.",
   "would_change": "What is said in a closed session isn't recorded, so the minutes can't show what happened inside one. This finding would change if records from the time show these pay decisions were made somewhere else: in an open meeting, or by someone the Council had authorized in writing to make them. No such record appears in the minutes or has been released.",
   "level_shown": "",
   "level_possible": "State law",
   "harms": [
    {
     "label": "Hidden decisions",
     "slug": "hidden-decisions",
     "def": "Decisions made without a public vote, a proper notice or minutes. The public can't question, challenge or reverse what it never saw."
    }
   ],
   "sources": "Council_Meeting_Index.xlsx > Exec Sessions; minutes 2018-10-29, 2018-11-05, 2018-12-03, 2019-09-16, 2019-10-07, 2019-10-28. EX-A05, EX-A08. Minutes 2017-08-07, 2017-08-28, 2017-09-05, 2017-09-18; minutes 2016-04-11.",
   "exhibits": [
    "EX-A05",
    "EX-A08",
    "EX-B09",
    "EX-B10",
    "EX-B11",
    "EX-B12",
    "EX-B13",
    "EX-B14",
    "EX-B15",
    "EX-B16",
    "EX-B17",
    "EX-B18",
    "EX-B19",
    "EX-B20",
    "EX-B21"
   ],
   "requests": [
    {
     "j": "twin-falls-id",
     "request": "#4729",
     "subject": "ELT compensation records FY21-FY26",
     "filed": "2026-08 (approx.)",
     "outcome": "Produced HR documents",
     "findings": [
      "E-01",
      "E-02",
      "E-03",
      "E-04",
      "E-05",
      "E-06",
      "E-07",
      "E-08",
      "E-09"
     ],
     "how": ""
    },
    {
     "j": "twin-falls-id",
     "request": "#5293",
     "subject": "Council committee for City Manager / City Attorney evaluations: membership, rules on committees, notices and minutes, compensation recommendations, minutes of 14 executive sessions (2014-present)",
     "filed": "2026-11-17",
     "outcome": "Denied Nov 20 (within 3 working days), one page: \"not in possession of a report or record of that nature\" and \"denied under Idaho Code 74-102(4\" (cut off). No item-by-item answer; no statute tied to any item; nothing was asked of the requester first. The City's delivery folder held only the denial and its own copy of the request.",
     "findings": [
      "E-06",
      "E-22",
      "E-05"
     ],
     "how": ""
    }
   ],
   "level_label": "Possibly state law",
   "level_score": 5,
   "level_keys": "state",
   "outstanding": 3,
   "complete_rank": 10384
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "E-06",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/findings/e-06/",
   "title": "The \"performance review committee\" was publicly created once (2014) and never again",
   "area": "Open meetings",
   "topic": "open-meetings",
   "category": "Possible open-meeting (subagency) / authority",
   "grade_raw": "B",
   "grade": "indicated",
   "grade_label": "Indicated",
   "scopes": [
    "State law"
   ],
   "shows": "On Sept 2, 2014, the Council voted 7-0 to let Mayor Hall form a committee (Hall, Vice Mayor Hawkins, Councilmember Talkington) \"to complete the annual performance evaluation of the City Manager and City Attorney.\" No later motion naming a committee or members was found in any minutes 2015-2026. The 2022-2025 pay letters rely on \"the performance review committee.\" The wording changed between the two letters. Dec 8, 2022: \"The Twin Falls City Council designates an evaluation committee to conduct performance reviews and to discuss compensation increases.\" Sept 8, 2025: \"The Twin Falls City Council conducts performance reviews and discusses compensation increases.\" Both letters then say the pay direction is \"Based on the direction of the performance review committee\" (EX-A01, EX-A09).\nFrom the City's own recordings (machine transcripts; each reference plays that moment): at the 2014 vote the Mayor says that forming such a committee has to come before the Council under the City's transparency resolution (Meeting 2014-09-02 at 4:12:48).\nWho was on it: none of the three 2014 members was on the Council when the pay letters were signed. Don Hall is last listed on the Council in the Minutes 2017-01-09 p1, Chris Talkington's last roll call is in the Minutes 2020-01-06 p1, and Suzanne Hawkins's last roll call, as Mayor, is in the Minutes 2022-01-03 p1. The Council on Dec 5, 2022 was Mayor Ruth Pierce, Vice Mayor Christopher Reid and Council Members Craig Hawkins, Jason Brown, Spencer Cutler, Nikki Boyd and Alexandra Caval (EX-B09); on Sept 8, 2025 it was Mayor Ruth Pierce, Vice Mayor Jason Brown and Council Members Craig Hawkins, Christopher Reid, Spencer Cutler, Cherie Vollmer and Grayson Stone (EX-B21). Council Member Craig Hawkins is not the Suzanne Hawkins named in 2014.",
   "rule": "AG Open Meeting Law Manual p.4, Questions 3-4: a subagency created by or pursuant to a legislative act with authority to make decisions or recommendations is a governing body subject to notice, open-meeting and minutes rules.",
   "why": "",
   "checked": "Re-checked on Nov 9, 2026 across all minutes, agendas and packets from Sept 2014 to Nov 2026: no other mention of a committee to evaluate the City Manager.\nWe searched machine transcripts of 529 City-posted Council recordings (2013 to November 2026) for an evaluation, review or compensation committee for the City Manager. Only the September 2, 2014 meeting mentions one. Machine transcripts miss words, so this is a search result, not proof.",
   "matters": "A committee that decides an executive's pay is doing public business. If it meets without notice, open meetings or minutes, the public can't tell who decided or on what basis.",
   "would_change": "This finding would change if a Council motion or resolution after 2014 created a standing evaluation committee or named its members. It would be in the minutes. None appears in any minutes from 2015 to 2026, and all three members named in 2014 had left the Council by January 2022.",
   "level_shown": "",
   "level_possible": "State law",
   "harms": [
    {
     "label": "Hidden decisions",
     "slug": "hidden-decisions",
     "def": "Decisions made without a public vote, a proper notice or minutes. The public can't question, challenge or reverse what it never saw."
    }
   ],
   "sources": "Minutes 2014-09-02 pp14-15 (Item II.10). EX-A01 (Dec 8, 2022 letter); EX-A09 (Sept 8, 2025 letter).; Minutes 2017-01-09, 2020-01-06, 2022-01-03 (roll calls); EX-B09, EX-B21 (roll calls).",
   "exhibits": [
    "EX-A01",
    "EX-A09",
    "EX-B01",
    "EX-B09",
    "EX-B21",
    "EX-C15-1",
    "EX-C15-2",
    "EX-C15-3"
   ],
   "requests": [
    {
     "j": "twin-falls-id",
     "request": "#4729",
     "subject": "ELT compensation records FY21-FY26",
     "filed": "2026-08 (approx.)",
     "outcome": "Produced HR documents",
     "findings": [
      "E-01",
      "E-02",
      "E-03",
      "E-04",
      "E-05",
      "E-06",
      "E-07",
      "E-08",
      "E-09"
     ],
     "how": ""
    },
    {
     "j": "twin-falls-id",
     "request": "#5293",
     "subject": "Council committee for City Manager / City Attorney evaluations: membership, rules on committees, notices and minutes, compensation recommendations, minutes of 14 executive sessions (2014-present)",
     "filed": "2026-11-17",
     "outcome": "Denied Nov 20 (within 3 working days), one page: \"not in possession of a report or record of that nature\" and \"denied under Idaho Code 74-102(4\" (cut off). No item-by-item answer; no statute tied to any item; nothing was asked of the requester first. The City's delivery folder held only the denial and its own copy of the request.",
     "findings": [
      "E-06",
      "E-22",
      "E-05"
     ],
     "how": ""
    }
   ],
   "level_label": "Possibly state law",
   "level_score": 5,
   "level_keys": "state",
   "outstanding": 2,
   "complete_rank": 10291
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "E-07",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/findings/e-07/",
   "title": "Pay changes made by letters signed by one person, not the signed amendment the agreement requires",
   "area": "City Manager pay & leave",
   "topic": "executive-pay",
   "category": "Contract; City Code 1-2-1, 1-2-3",
   "grade_raw": "A",
   "grade": "documented",
   "grade_label": "Documented",
   "scopes": [
    "Local policy"
   ],
   "shows": "Dec 2022 and Sept 2025 letters signed by the Mayor alone; Sept 2025 letter quotes sec. 3 without \"during the budget process.\" The Sept 2025 letter also sets one total, $272,650, and says: \"The salary includes a deferred compensation component. The amount allocated to deferred compensation is based on your preference.\" The agreement the Council approved on Dec 9, 2024 fixes the two amounts separately: $239,560 salary and $22,600 deferred compensation (EX-A09, EX-A12).",
   "rule": "2024 Agreement sec. 2 (written, signed by the parties), sec. 3, sec. 8. City Code 1-2-3 (Ord. 3106, 2015): the Council and its members deal with the City's administrative services \"only through the city manager, except for the purpose of inquiry, and neither the city council nor any member thereof shall give orders to any subordinates of the city manager.\" City Code 1-2-1: the mayor performs \"such other duties consistent with his office as may be imposed by the council,\" and signing contracts or legal instruments by title \"shall not be construed as conferring upon him/her administrative powers or functions\" (the same rule as I.C. 50-810).",
   "why": "",
   "checked": "",
   "matters": "A contract spells out how it can be changed to protect the City. Changing pay by one-signature letters bypasses that protection, and the Council's role with it.",
   "would_change": "This finding would change if the Council, in an open meeting, authorized the Mayor to change the City Manager's pay by a letter signed alone. That authorization would be in the minutes. None has been located.",
   "level_shown": "City policy",
   "level_possible": "City code",
   "harms": [
    {
     "label": "Hidden decisions",
     "slug": "hidden-decisions",
     "def": "Decisions made without a public vote, a proper notice or minutes. The public can't question, challenge or reverse what it never saw."
    },
    {
     "label": "Public money",
     "slug": "public-money",
     "def": "Money paid outside the rules, or spent without the approvals the rules require. It comes out of the same budget as police, streets, parks and water."
    }
   ],
   "sources": "Travis 2022-2023 Compensation Letter; Travis 2025 Compensation Letter; 2024 CM Contract signed.; City Code 1-2-1, 1-2-3 (online code, current through Ord. 2026-007).",
   "exhibits": [
    "EX-A01",
    "EX-A09",
    "EX-A12",
    "EX-A13"
   ],
   "requests": [
    {
     "j": "twin-falls-id",
     "request": "#4729",
     "subject": "ELT compensation records FY21-FY26",
     "filed": "2026-08 (approx.)",
     "outcome": "Produced HR documents",
     "findings": [
      "E-01",
      "E-02",
      "E-03",
      "E-04",
      "E-05",
      "E-06",
      "E-07",
      "E-08",
      "E-09"
     ],
     "how": ""
    }
   ],
   "level_label": "City code, policy or contract",
   "level_score": 2,
   "level_keys": "city city",
   "outstanding": 1,
   "complete_rank": 195
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "E-08",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/findings/e-08/",
   "title": "$2,500 Deputy City Manager stipend described as Council-authorized; no vote located",
   "area": "Staff pay",
   "topic": "executive-pay",
   "category": "Possible open-meeting; authority",
   "grade_raw": "A / B",
   "grade": "documented",
   "grade_label": "Documented",
   "scopes": [
    "State law"
   ],
   "shows": "City Manager email Apr 17, 2026, copied to the Mayor and Vice Mayor: \"As a part of Gretchen's evaluation and overall efforts this past year, the City Council has authorized me to provide a $2,500 stipend to Gretchen. TO my knowledge, this is the first time that it has been done\" (EX-A18). Paid 4/24/2026 as \"DTI Incentive Pay\" (EX-A19). The City's executive pay summary for Oct 2020 to Sept 2026 lists that pay code for no other executive; the $3,500 and $5,500 \"ECP\" amounts the executives share are the citywide one-time payouts (EX-A21). No vote or (b) session on it appears in the Mar-Apr 2026 minutes before Apr 17. The Employee Handbook's only one-time payments are employee referral awards and retention payments; its pay-adjustment clause covers salaries (\"salaries may be adjusted on an annual basis, in October, or in such other manner as deemed to be equitable by the City Manager\"), and no provision covers a payment tied to an evaluation (EX-C01-8 pp37, 47).",
   "rule": "74-203, 74-206(3). If the stipend continues into later years, Financial Policies p12 also applies: actions that raise a department's base budget for later years need Council approval \"documented at a City Council meeting.\"",
   "why": "A City Manager email said the Council had authorized a $2,500 stipend for a Deputy City Manager, and it was paid a week later. No Council vote, and no executive session on it, appears in the minutes before that email.",
   "checked": "In the City-posted recordings of 2026 Council meetings (37 recordings through November 2), no stipend for a Deputy City Manager is discussed. Machine transcripts miss words, so this is a search result, not proof.",
   "matters": "Saying the Council authorized a payment it never voted on makes a private decision look like a public one, and undermines the record residents rely on.",
   "would_change": "This finding would change if a record from the time shows the Council approved the stipend in an open meeting before April 17, 2026. If instead the City Manager granted it under his own authority in the Employee Handbook, a written special arrangement dated before the payment would show that, though his email would then be wrong about who authorized it.",
   "level_shown": "City policy",
   "level_possible": "State law",
   "harms": [
    {
     "label": "Hidden decisions",
     "slug": "hidden-decisions",
     "def": "Decisions made without a public vote, a proper notice or minutes. The public can't question, challenge or reverse what it never saw."
    },
    {
     "label": "Public money",
     "slug": "public-money",
     "def": "Money paid outside the rules, or spent without the approvals the rules require. It comes out of the same budget as police, streets, parks and water."
    }
   ],
   "sources": "EX-A18 (Apr 17, 2026 email and form); EX-A19 (payroll register, check 4/24/2026); EX-A21 (executive pay codes, Oct 2020 - Sept 2026); EX-C01-8 pp2, 37, 47 (Employee Handbook); minutes Mar 9 - Apr 27, 2026; City Code 1-2-3.",
   "exhibits": [
    "EX-A18",
    "EX-A19",
    "EX-A20",
    "EX-A21",
    "EX-B22",
    "EX-B23",
    "EX-B24",
    "EX-B25",
    "EX-B26",
    "EX-C01-8"
   ],
   "requests": [
    {
     "j": "twin-falls-id",
     "request": "#4729",
     "subject": "ELT compensation records FY21-FY26",
     "filed": "2026-08 (approx.)",
     "outcome": "Produced HR documents",
     "findings": [
      "E-01",
      "E-02",
      "E-03",
      "E-04",
      "E-05",
      "E-06",
      "E-07",
      "E-08",
      "E-09"
     ],
     "how": ""
    }
   ],
   "level_label": "City code, policy or contract; possibly state law",
   "level_score": 5,
   "level_keys": "city state",
   "outstanding": 1,
   "complete_rank": 189
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "E-09",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/findings/e-09/",
   "title": "The City Manager took part in the Council-approved Employee Retention Program and the citywide one-time payouts, as his agreement extends employee benefits to him (context)",
   "area": "Staff pay",
   "topic": "executive-pay",
   "category": "Context / compensation package",
   "grade_raw": "A (context)",
   "grade": "documented",
   "grade_label": "Documented",
   "scopes": [],
   "shows": "Oct 22, 2018: the Council voted 7-0 to \"ratify the City Manager and Human Resource Director's proposal to create a retention compensation program,\" presented by HR Director Scott; two citizens spoke against it. The HR production shows retention program agreements and payouts for the City Manager ($2,000 payout; $5,000 prepaid retention on Dec 15, 2023, under an agreement he submitted himself on 11/8/2023) and for Scott, Howard, Kohntopp and Humble.\nThe program itself was public. The 2019, 2020 and 2021 ACFRs say the Council \"took unprecedented action and began offering a retention pay program in December 2018,\" and every budget from FY2020 on continues it (FY2020 budget p20: \"$216,000 if all eligible employees elect to participate\"). The 2022 ACFR p27 says the \"City Council elected to pay a onetime compensation pay-out in November of both 2020 and 2021.\" So the finding does not rest on the program being hidden. It rests on two points: the City Manager co-proposed a program he then joined, and it is not shown whether the ratified program covered the Council's own employee.",
   "rule": "74-404 (disclose conflict before official action/recommendation); 18-1359(1)(a) (specific authorization). CM Agreement sec. 8 (Council fixes other terms).",
   "why": "",
   "checked": "",
   "matters": "These payments were made under programs open to employees, so they are not a finding on their own. They are part of the full picture of the City Manager's pay: his agreements give him the benefits employees receive (retention pay, one-time payouts, holidays, longevity and vacation sell-back), while the employee limits that go with those benefits, such as the 40-hour sell-back cap, were set aside for him (E-01, E-02).",
   "would_change": "",
   "level_shown": "Context",
   "level_possible": "",
   "harms": [],
   "sources": "Minutes 2018-10-22 p3; ERP agreements and payouts in #4729/#4869 HR production. ACFR 2019 p26, 2020 p27, 2021 p27, 2022 p27; FY19-20 budget p20 [City website, saved 2026-11-07].",
   "exhibits": [
    "EX-A03",
    "EX-A16",
    "EX-A17",
    "EX-A20",
    "EX-A21",
    "EX-A22",
    "EX-A23",
    "EX-B04"
   ],
   "requests": [
    {
     "j": "twin-falls-id",
     "request": "#4729",
     "subject": "ELT compensation records FY21-FY26",
     "filed": "2026-08 (approx.)",
     "outcome": "Produced HR documents",
     "findings": [
      "E-01",
      "E-02",
      "E-03",
      "E-04",
      "E-05",
      "E-06",
      "E-07",
      "E-08",
      "E-09"
     ],
     "how": ""
    }
   ],
   "level_label": "Context",
   "level_score": 0,
   "level_keys": "context",
   "outstanding": 1,
   "complete_rank": 191
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "E-10",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/findings/e-10/",
   "title": "Handbook changes were delegated to the City Manager in 2018 (explains the 160->200 hr cap change)",
   "area": "Policy",
   "topic": "executive-pay",
   "category": "Context / exculpatory",
   "grade_raw": "A",
   "grade": "documented",
   "grade_label": "Documented",
   "scopes": [
    "Local policy"
   ],
   "shows": "Resolution No. 2018-012 (Oct 29, 2018, vote 5-0) repealed Resolution 1897 and \"authorized the City Manager to implement an employee handbook\"; the handbook reserves the City's right to modify terms. Since 2021 every handbook states no one other than the City Manager may make special arrangements on terms of employment.",
   "rule": "Res. 2018-012; handbook \"About this handbook.\"",
   "why": "",
   "checked": "",
   "matters": "Moving the rules for pay, leave and complaints out of Council resolutions and into a handbook issued by one appointed official took those decisions out of public votes, and left that same official as the only person who can grant exceptions, including for himself.",
   "would_change": "",
   "level_shown": "Context",
   "level_possible": "",
   "harms": [
    {
     "label": "Hidden decisions",
     "slug": "hidden-decisions",
     "def": "Decisions made without a public vote, a proper notice or minutes. The public can't question, challenge or reverse what it never saw."
    }
   ],
   "sources": "Minutes 2018-10-29 p2; City Council 20181029 Packet pp11-12, 102; handbooks 2021-2026.",
   "exhibits": [
    "EX-B05",
    "EX-B06"
   ],
   "requests": [],
   "level_label": "Context",
   "level_score": 0,
   "level_keys": "context",
   "outstanding": 0,
   "complete_rank": 97
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "E-11",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/findings/e-11/",
   "title": "2015 City Manager Service Agreement exists but was not produced to PRR #4869",
   "area": "Public records",
   "topic": "public-records",
   "category": "Public Records Act (I.C. 74-102 search; 74-103(4)-(5) denial notice)",
   "grade_raw": "A",
   "grade": "documented",
   "grade_label": "Documented",
   "scopes": [
    "State law"
   ],
   "shows": "Minutes Feb 2, 2015 record approval of \"the City Manager Service Agreement\" (7-0). PRR #4869 asked for every version \"all years\"; production contained only the Apr 2020 agreement, 2024 agreement and amendment. No denial notice for the omitted version. The City's own staff report for the Dec 9, 2024 agreement amendment says \"The initial agreement took effect on October 1, 2014\" (2024-12-09 packet p39), and the Mayor said the same to the Council (Meeting 2024-12-09 at 0:08:03). So an agreement from October 2014, as well as the one approved in February 2015, was left out of the answer.",
   "rule": "74-102(1); 74-103(4)-(5).",
   "why": "",
   "checked": "",
   "matters": "A response that leaves out a record without saying so tells the public something doesn't exist when it does. The right to records only works if responses are complete.",
   "would_change": "If the City still holds the 2015 agreement, it can release it now; it should have been part of the answer to request #4869. If the agreement was destroyed, the City's records-destruction approval would show when, and under which retention rule.",
   "level_shown": "State law",
   "level_possible": "",
   "harms": [
    {
     "label": "Records access",
     "slug": "records-access",
     "def": "Delays, gaps and denials that keep public records from the public. They don't just frustrate one requester; they keep information from everyone."
    }
   ],
   "sources": "Minutes 2015-02-02 p8; PRR #4869 production list.; 2024-12-09 agenda packet p39 (staff report); City recording of 2024-12-09 at 0:08:03.",
   "exhibits": [
    "EX-B02",
    "EX-C05-1",
    "EX-C05-2",
    "EX-C05-3"
   ],
   "requests": [
    {
     "j": "twin-falls-id",
     "request": "#4869",
     "subject": "CM contract versions + handbook exceptions",
     "filed": "2026-09",
     "outcome": "Produced 2020/2024 agreements, letters; no 2015 agreement; no Council exception directives",
     "findings": [
      "E-11"
     ],
     "how": ""
    }
   ],
   "level_label": "State law",
   "level_score": 6,
   "level_keys": "state",
   "outstanding": 1,
   "complete_rank": 195
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "E-12",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/findings/e-12/",
   "title": "PRR #3946: 109 of 117 items withheld as vendor \"proprietary\"; the notice omitted the attorney-review statement",
   "area": "Public records",
   "topic": "public-records",
   "category": "Public Records Act (74-103(4)-(5); 74-107(1); 74-112)",
   "grade_raw": "A",
   "grade": "documented",
   "grade_label": "Documented",
   "scopes": [],
   "shows": "Filed 5/31/2026; extension notice; records released 7/1/2026 (31 days after filing). The City says the delay came from waiting for the requester to agree to an attorney-review fee. The completion notice gave appeal rights but did not say anything was withheld, cite a statute, or state whether an attorney reviewed the request. On 7/13/2026 a Deputy Clerk wrote that the City Attorney \"agreed that proprietary information is excluded from the public records act,\" that staff \"didn't know enough about the project to differentiate\" HUB's material from the City's, that Human Resources \"worked with our agent from HUB,\" and that 109 of 117 entries were \"statutorily excluded from release by Idaho Code Section 74-107(1).\"",
   "rule": "74-103(4)-(5): a denial or partial denial must be in writing, \"shall state\" that the agency's attorney reviewed the request or that the agency had the chance to consult one and chose not to, and must indicate the statutory authority and the right to appeal. 74-107(1): a trade secret must both derive independent economic value from not being generally known and be the subject of reasonable efforts to keep it secret; the statute has no general exemption for material a vendor calls proprietary. 74-112: separate exempt from nonexempt material and release the rest. Timing not counted: no residency declaration was filed, so the non-resident limit (35 days) may apply, and 74-102(12) allows advance payment of fees.",
   "why": "",
   "checked": "",
   "matters": "Withholding nearly everything as a vendor's 'proprietary' material, without the explanations the law requires, makes the records law easy to defeat. It hides how decisions about public pay were made.",
   "would_change": "",
   "level_shown": "State law",
   "level_possible": "",
   "harms": [
    {
     "label": "Records access",
     "slug": "records-access",
     "def": "Delays, gaps and denials that keep public records from the public. They don't just frustrate one requester; they keep information from everyone."
    },
    {
     "label": "Hidden decisions",
     "slug": "hidden-decisions",
     "def": "Decisions made without a public vote, a proper notice or minutes. The public can't question, challenge or reverse what it never saw."
    }
   ],
   "sources": "PRR #3946: Completion Notice; Notice of Cost/Payment; Attorney Response and Reasons (Deputy Clerk email 7/13/2026).",
   "exhibits": [
    "EX-C01-1",
    "EX-C01-2",
    "EX-C01-3",
    "EX-C01-4",
    "EX-C01-5",
    "EX-C01-6",
    "EX-C01-7",
    "EX-C01-8",
    "EX-C01-9",
    "EX-C01-10"
   ],
   "requests": [
    {
     "j": "twin-falls-id",
     "request": "#3946",
     "subject": "Market Analysis keyword, 5 custodians",
     "filed": "2026-05-31",
     "outcome": "Partial; late; 109/117 withheld as \"proprietary\"",
     "findings": [
      "E-12"
     ],
     "how": ""
    }
   ],
   "level_label": "State law",
   "level_score": 6,
   "level_keys": "state",
   "outstanding": 3,
   "complete_rank": 389
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "E-13",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/findings/e-13/",
   "title": "City twice said it does not hold copies of records requests, then produced 1,183 of them three days later",
   "area": "Public records",
   "topic": "public-records",
   "category": "Public Records Act (74-101(13), 74-102(1))",
   "grade_raw": "A",
   "grade": "documented",
   "grade_label": "Documented",
   "scopes": [],
   "shows": "Request #5061 was denied on Nov 2, 2026: \"not a record that is held.\" A second request was denied on Nov 3. Yet every City response returns the requester's own \"Initial Request\" PDF from the City's system, and request numbers exceed 5,000.\nOn Nov 5, 2026 at 7:17 a.m., City staff answered a third request for the same records: \"that is not a record that we will be able to fill,\" because redacting each request \"would take our IT department days to fill\" and \"there would be a large charge.\" At 7:45 a.m. staff wrote that IT \"is going to run a report ... and that is what you are going to receive.\" At 10:14 a.m. the same day the City delivered the records as request #5162: 1,183 request forms, with no fee. On Nov 6 the City sent an extension notice for #5162, after it had already closed the request.",
   "rule": "74-101(13) public record = any writing prepared, owned, used or retained; requests submitted through the City's online form are retained electronically.",
   "why": "",
   "checked": "",
   "matters": "Claiming not to hold the City's own request files blocks the public from seeing how requests are handled, including whether requesters are treated alike.",
   "would_change": "",
   "level_shown": "State law",
   "level_possible": "",
   "harms": [
    {
     "label": "Records access",
     "slug": "records-access",
     "def": "Delays, gaps and denials that keep public records from the public. They don't just frustrate one requester; they keep information from everyone."
    },
    {
     "label": "Unequal treatment",
     "slug": "unequal-treatment",
     "def": "Rules applied to some people and not others: employees held to limits their bosses ignore, or requesters treated differently depending on what they ask for. Rules that depend on rank or favor stop being rules."
    }
   ],
   "sources": "EX-C11-3 (request #5061 response, Nov 2, 2026); EX-C12-2 (second request and denial, Nov 3, 2026); EX-C13-2 (third request; City staff email of Nov 4, 2026); EX-C13-3 (request #5162 correspondence, Nov 5-6, 2026).",
   "exhibits": [
    "EX-C11-1",
    "EX-C11-2",
    "EX-C11-3",
    "EX-C11-4",
    "EX-C12-1",
    "EX-C12-2",
    "EX-C13-1",
    "EX-C13-2",
    "EX-C13-3"
   ],
   "requests": [
    {
     "j": "twin-falls-id",
     "request": "#5061",
     "subject": "Copies of all PRRs Jun-Oct 2026",
     "filed": "2026-10-20",
     "outcome": "Denied: \"not a record held\" (Nov 2); second request denied Nov 3; third request filled as #5162",
     "findings": [
      "E-13"
     ],
     "how": ""
    },
    {
     "j": "twin-falls-id",
     "request": "#5162",
     "subject": "Copies of records requests (third attempt)",
     "filed": "2026-11-03",
     "outcome": "Filled Nov 5, 2026: 1,183 request forms, no fee; extension notice sent Nov 6 after closure",
     "findings": [
      "E-13"
     ],
     "how": ""
    }
   ],
   "level_label": "State law",
   "level_score": 6,
   "level_keys": "state",
   "outstanding": 2,
   "complete_rank": 290
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "E-14",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/findings/e-14/",
   "title": "PRR #4814/#4940: Finance request answered with HR payroll registers; AP reimbursements not produced",
   "area": "Public records",
   "topic": "public-records",
   "category": "Public Records Act (74-102 search)",
   "grade_raw": "B",
   "grade": "indicated",
   "grade_label": "Indicated",
   "scopes": [],
   "shows": "City response acknowledged travel reimbursements are paid through Accounts Payable and \"will therefore appear on separate reports\"; no AP report is in the production. The follow-up request #4940 (filed Oct 5, 2026) got a 10-working-day extension notice on Oct 6 and no answer since, despite follow-ups on Oct 22, Oct 28 and Nov 2; under I.C. 74-103(3) a request not answered in time is deemed denied.",
   "rule": "74-102(1); 74-106(1) makes \"vouchered and unvouchered expenses for which reimbursement was paid\" public. Financial Policy III-e and I.C. 50-1017: every claim against the City, including expense reimbursements, is approved by the Council before payment, so a record of each reimbursement exists in the accounts payable approvals.",
   "why": "",
   "checked": "",
   "matters": "Expense reimbursements are public by law so taxpayers can see how officials spend public money. Leaving them out of a response keeps that spending out of view.",
   "would_change": "",
   "level_shown": "State law",
   "level_possible": "",
   "harms": [
    {
     "label": "Financial transparency",
     "slug": "financial-transparency",
     "def": "Payment lists, card statements, budgets and financial reports kept out of public view. Residents can see that money was approved, but not what it bought or who spent it."
    },
    {
     "label": "Public money",
     "slug": "public-money",
     "def": "Money paid outside the rules, or spent without the approvals the rules require. It comes out of the same budget as police, streets, parks and water."
    },
    {
     "label": "Records access",
     "slug": "records-access",
     "def": "Delays, gaps and denials that keep public records from the public. They don't just frustrate one requester; they keep information from everyone."
    }
   ],
   "sources": "PRR #4814 Unavailable Information; #4940 request.",
   "exhibits": [
    "EX-C04-1",
    "EX-C04-2",
    "EX-C04-3",
    "EX-C04-4",
    "EX-C06-1",
    "EX-C06-2",
    "EX-C16-1",
    "EX-C16-2",
    "EX-C17-1",
    "EX-C17-2",
    "EX-C17-3",
    "EX-C17-4"
   ],
   "requests": [
    {
     "j": "twin-falls-id",
     "request": "#4814",
     "subject": "Finance payment summaries FY16-present",
     "filed": "2026-09",
     "outcome": "Payroll registers; \"no FY subtotal\"; AP to come separately",
     "findings": [
      "E-14"
     ],
     "how": ""
    },
    {
     "j": "twin-falls-id",
     "request": "#4940",
     "subject": "Follow-up/deficiency memo to #4814/#4729",
     "filed": "2026-10-05",
     "outcome": "No response after 26 working days as of Nov 10 (deemed denied Oct 20); five follow-ups unanswered",
     "findings": [
      "E-14"
     ],
     "how": ""
    },
    {
     "j": "twin-falls-id",
     "request": "#5254",
     "subject": "Accounts payable payment register and Council AP reports, fiscal year 2026 (Oct 1, 2025 to Sep 30, 2026)",
     "filed": "2026-11-15",
     "outcome": "Produced Nov 17, 2026, inside the 3 working days, with no fee: the FY2026 Invoice Distribution Report (.xlsx, and the same report as a 292-page PDF) and weekly check-run, payroll-remittance and prepaid proof lists (PDF). No invoices. A 10-working-day extension notice followed at 10:06 PM the same day, after delivery.",
     "findings": [
      "E-31",
      "E-14"
     ],
     "how": ""
    },
    {
     "j": "twin-falls-id",
     "request": "#5299",
     "subject": "Accounts payable register, fiscal years 2020-2025 (follow-up to #5254)",
     "filed": "2026-11-17",
     "outcome": "Nov 18: aggregated with #5254 under I.C. 74-102(11), 12 hours / $567.48 advance payment (Budget Coordinator $47.29/hr), though the City says it is 'not suggesting' fee avoidance. Requester narrowed to the Excel report only. Nov 19: 1.5 hours / $70.94 ('report generation and legal review'), billed at the Budget Coordinator rate. Nov 20, 3:24 AM: requester asked the City to reconsider (aggregation needs a reasonable belief of fee avoidance; Resolution 1912 Section 5) or confirm in writing. Nov 20, 9:19 PM: 10-day extension notice (ends Dec 3).",
     "findings": [
      "E-31",
      "E-14"
     ],
     "how": ""
    }
   ],
   "level_label": "State law",
   "level_score": 6,
   "level_keys": "state",
   "outstanding": 3,
   "complete_rank": 10387
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "E-15",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/findings/e-15/",
   "title": "PRR #4953 denial turned on requester identity/residency (legally mixed)",
   "area": "Public records",
   "topic": "public-records",
   "category": "Public Records Act (74-102(4), (5)(a); 74-103(5))",
   "grade_raw": "B",
   "grade": "indicated",
   "grade_label": "Indicated",
   "scopes": [],
   "shows": "#4953 denied for \"non-compliance with 74-102(4)\" (requester listed a New Mexico address).",
   "rule": "Since the 2025 amendment (2025 ch. 298), 74-102(4) says a request \"shall also provide\" name, mailing address, email, phone and a written declaration under oath stating whether the requester is an Idaho resident; 74-102(5)(a) allows identity inquiries only \"in accordance with section 74-113\" (records about the requester). Nonresidents still have a right of access (21/35-day timelines).",
   "why": "",
   "checked": "",
   "matters": "The law asks every requester for the same information. Enforcing it against some requesters and not others turns a neutral rule into a way to choose who gets public records.",
   "would_change": "",
   "level_shown": "",
   "level_possible": "State law",
   "harms": [
    {
     "label": "Unequal treatment",
     "slug": "unequal-treatment",
     "def": "Rules applied to some people and not others: employees held to limits their bosses ignore, or requesters treated differently depending on what they ask for. Rules that depend on rank or favor stop being rules."
    },
    {
     "label": "Records access",
     "slug": "records-access",
     "def": "Delays, gaps and denials that keep public records from the public. They don't just frustrate one requester; they keep information from everyone."
    }
   ],
   "sources": "PRR #4953 Response.",
   "exhibits": [
    "EX-C07-1",
    "EX-C07-2",
    "EX-C07-3",
    "EX-C07-4"
   ],
   "requests": [
    {
     "j": "twin-falls-id",
     "request": "#4953",
     "subject": "All executive exceptions to handbook",
     "filed": "2026-10",
     "outcome": "Denied: non-compliance with 74-102(4)",
     "findings": [
      "E-15"
     ],
     "how": ""
    }
   ],
   "level_label": "Possibly state law",
   "level_score": 5,
   "level_keys": "state",
   "outstanding": 2,
   "complete_rank": 10295
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "E-17",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/findings/e-17/",
   "title": "Closed sessions added to the agenda after the meeting began, at the City Manager's request, with no reason recorded (three times in 2017)",
   "area": "Open meetings",
   "topic": "open-meetings",
   "category": "Possible open-meeting (74-204(4))",
   "grade_raw": "B",
   "grade": "indicated",
   "grade_label": "Indicated",
   "scopes": [
    "State law"
   ],
   "shows": "Aug 7, 2017, under \"Consideration of amendments to agenda\" just after the meeting was called to order: \"City Manager asked that an additional Executive Session 74-206(1)(b) ... be added to the agenda.\" The motion to add it passed 5-0. The posted agenda listed only a 74-206(1)(c) real-property session.\nDec 18, 2017, under the same agenda item: \"City Manager Rothweiler asked that 74-206(1)(b) be added to the Executive Session.\" The motion passed 5-0. The posted agenda listed only a 74-206(1)(f) legal-counsel session.\nNeither set of minutes records a reason for the amendment or a reason the item was left off the posted agenda.\nNov 13, 2017, under the same agenda item: \"City Manager Rothweiler asked that Executive Session 74-206 1(F) be added to the agenda item 10 (a).\" The motion passed 6-0. The posted agenda listed only a 74-206(1)(c) real-property session, and no reason is recorded.\nOn July 2, 2018, the City Manager told the Council that \"the State code has changed as of July 1, 2018 and amendment can only be made when there is a demonstrated emergency.\"",
   "rule": "74-204(4)(c), as in force in 2017 (section added 2015, ch. 140) and today: once a meeting has begun, an agenda may be amended only \"upon a motion that states the reason for the amendment and states the good faith reason the agenda item was not included in the original agenda posting.\"",
   "why": "",
   "checked": "We read both posted agendas: neither lists a 74-206(1)(b) session. We read the statute as it stood in 2017: the requirement to state the reasons in the motion was already in force. We read the full minutes of both meetings for any stated reason; none is recorded.",
   "matters": "Agendas tell residents in advance what will be discussed. Twice in 2017 a closed session about an employee's evaluation was added at the start of the meeting at the City Manager's request, with no reason recorded, so it never appeared on the public agenda.",
   "would_change": "",
   "level_shown": "",
   "level_possible": "State law",
   "harms": [
    {
     "label": "Hidden decisions",
     "slug": "hidden-decisions",
     "def": "Decisions made without a public vote, a proper notice or minutes. The public can't question, challenge or reverse what it never saw."
    }
   ],
   "sources": "Minutes 2017-08-07 p1 (amendment) and p5 (adjournment to the (c) and (b) sessions); agenda 2017-08-07 p2. Minutes 2017-12-18 p1 and p4 (EX-B03); agenda 2017-12-18 p2. Statute as of 2017: Idaho Code 74-204 (2017 edition). Minutes 2017-11-13 p1 and p5; agenda 2017-11-13. Minutes 2018-07-02 p1.",
   "exhibits": [
    "EX-B03"
   ],
   "requests": [],
   "level_label": "Possibly state law",
   "level_score": 5,
   "level_keys": "state",
   "outstanding": 1,
   "complete_rank": 10198
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "E-18",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/findings/e-18/",
   "title": "The City budgeted $65,000 for a compensation study and told the Council it would keep pay market competitive. Results existed by March 2026 and were shared with executives as confidential; none appears in any Council record",
   "area": "Procurement",
   "topic": "contracts-ethics",
   "category": "Possible procurement / authority question",
   "grade_raw": "A (budget; what the Council was told; that results exist) / C (what the study found and what became of it)",
   "grade": "documented",
   "grade_label": "Documented",
   "scopes": [],
   "shows": "The fiscal year 2026 adopted budget lists \"Compensation Study (HR) - $65,000\" (p63). From the City's own recordings (machine transcripts; each reference plays that moment): in the budget presentations, the Council was told the study is done about every five years to keep City pay market competitive (Meeting 2025-07-07 at 1:06:20), that the City had chosen Hub International as its consultant after a request for qualifications, and that pay would be based on market comparisons (Meeting 2025-07-14 at 0:48:36).\nWe searched the 53 City-posted Council recordings from July 15, 2025 to November 2, 2026, and the posted agendas, packets and minutes for the same period. None mentions the study's results or any decision about it. Records the City released for request #3946 show that results existed by early 2026: the consultant sent an invitation on February 27, 2026 for a March 3 meeting titled \"City of Twin Falls - Market Analysis Results\" (EX-C01-10), and on April 15, 2026 the Human Resources lead shared a file named \"Market Analysis Results\" with the executive leadership team with the note \"This information is confidential and is only authorized for review by members of the ELT. It may not be shared or distributed\" (EX-C01-5, EX-C01-6). The same release includes the consultant's May 2026 invoice email for $350 (EX-C01-11). The City withheld 109 of the 117 items it found (E-12).\nThe City's quarterly expense report for October to December 2025 shows $65,025 spent from the Human Resources capital line, against a $65,000 budget. The adopted budget's only Human Resources capital item for fiscal 2026 is the Compensation Study (FY2026 adopted budget p66). The line stays at $65,025 in the March and June 2026 reports.",
   "rule": "Second Amended Resolution 1912 (openness of the City's legislative and administrative process). Employees' classification, pay grade and salary are public (I.C. 74-106(1)); exempt and non-exempt material must be separated (I.C. 74-112).",
   "why": "Residents paid for a study of whether City pay matches the market and were told what it was for. More than a year later, no public record says what it found or what the City did with it.",
   "checked": "Machine transcripts of the 53 City-posted Council recordings from July 15, 2025 to November 2, 2026; agendas, packets and minutes for the same period. Machine transcripts miss words, so this is a search result, not proof. The City's posted quarterly expense reports for fiscal 2026 (Human Resources, Capital Expenditures).",
   "matters": "Pay is the City's largest cost. A study of it, paid for by residents, should not disappear from view.",
   "would_change": "This finding would change if records show the study's results were reported to the Council, or that the study is unfinished or still under review. Those would be Council packets or minutes, or the consultant's deliverables and correspondence, much of which the City withheld from request #3946.",
   "level_shown": "Question",
   "level_possible": "",
   "harms": [
    {
     "label": "Records access",
     "slug": "records-access",
     "def": "Delays, gaps and denials that keep public records from the public. They don't just frustrate one requester; they keep information from everyone."
    },
    {
     "label": "Public money",
     "slug": "public-money",
     "def": "Money paid outside the rules, or spent without the approvals the rules require. It comes out of the same budget as police, streets, parks and water."
    },
    {
     "label": "Financial transparency",
     "slug": "financial-transparency",
     "def": "Payment lists, card statements, budgets and financial reports kept out of public view. Residents can see that money was approved, but not what it bought or who spent it."
    }
   ],
   "sources": "FY2026 adopted budget p63 [City website, saved 2026-11-07]; City recordings of July 7 and July 14, 2025; EX-C01-5, EX-C01-6, EX-C01-10, EX-C01-11 (released for request #3946); EX-C01-4 (Deputy Clerk's explanation of the withholding).; Quarterly expense reports, fiscal 2026 first, second and third quarters, Human Resources (City website, Archive Center, saved 2026-11-08); FY2026 adopted budget p66 (capital list).",
   "exhibits": [
    "EX-C01-4",
    "EX-C01-5",
    "EX-C01-6",
    "EX-C01-10",
    "EX-C01-11"
   ],
   "requests": [
    {
     "j": "twin-falls-id",
     "request": "Market Analysis Cost",
     "subject": "Payments to HUB / study cost",
     "filed": "2026-09",
     "outcome": "Denied (response not in folder)",
     "findings": [
      "E-18"
     ],
     "how": ""
    }
   ],
   "level_label": "Open question",
   "level_score": 0,
   "level_keys": "question",
   "outstanding": 2,
   "complete_rank": 294
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "E-19",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/findings/e-19/",
   "title": "Deferred compensation amount vs. IRS annual limits (question only)",
   "area": "Federal question",
   "topic": "federal",
   "category": "Federal tax (26 U.S.C. 457(b)/402(g)/415(c)) - question",
   "grade_raw": "C",
   "grade": "open",
   "grade_label": "Open question",
   "scopes": [
    "Federal"
   ],
   "shows": "$22,600 a year in employer deferred compensation from Dec 2023. The payroll codes do not show the plan type (457(b) or PERSI Choice 401(k)). A Dec 5, 2023 HR email says: \"I will begin working with payroll to determine the 457 vehicle that TR wants to use.\" [Deduction] This points to a 457(b) plan. A 457(b) annual limit counts employee and employer deferrals together, so the $22,600 employer amount should be checked against each year's limit together with any of his own deferrals. (EX-A08)",
   "rule": "IRS annual limits depend on plan type and on his own deferrals.",
   "why": "",
   "checked": "",
   "matters": "This is an open question. If contributions exceeded federal limits, correcting them can cost both the City and the employee.",
   "would_change": "This is a question, not a finding of a violation. It would be settled by the plan documents showing which kind of plan receives the $22,600, and the payroll records of his own contributions for each year.",
   "level_shown": "Question",
   "level_possible": "",
   "harms": [
    {
     "label": "Public money",
     "slug": "public-money",
     "def": "Money paid outside the rules, or spent without the approvals the rules require. It comes out of the same budget as police, streets, parks and water."
    }
   ],
   "sources": "Deferred Compensation 1 & 2. EX-A08.",
   "exhibits": [
    "EX-A08",
    "EX-A14",
    "EX-A15"
   ],
   "requests": [],
   "level_label": "Open question",
   "level_score": 0,
   "level_keys": "question",
   "outstanding": 1,
   "complete_rank": 20196
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "E-20",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/findings/e-20/",
   "title": "Request #4940 unanswered for more than 20 working days - deemed denied by law",
   "area": "Public records",
   "topic": "public-records",
   "category": "Public Records Act (I.C. 74-103(2)-(3))",
   "grade_raw": "A",
   "grade": "documented",
   "grade_label": "Documented",
   "scopes": [
    "State law"
   ],
   "shows": "Filed Oct 5, 2026; City extension notice Oct 6; requester follow-ups Oct 22, Oct 28, Nov 2, Nov 3 and Nov 5 received no reply. As of Nov 5 no records, denial or explanation had been issued - more than 20 working days after filing; the 10-working-day limit ran out on or about Oct 19-20.",
   "rule": "74-103(2): an Idaho resident's request must be granted or denied within 3 working days, or records provided within 10 working days after a written extension (non-residents: 21 days / 35 days); 74-103(3): failure to respond within the time allotted means the request \"shall be deemed to be denied.\" Appeal: petition to district court within 180 days (74-115).",
   "why": "",
   "checked": "",
   "matters": "When a city simply doesn't answer, the requester's only remedy is to go to court. Silence shifts the cost of enforcing the law onto the public.",
   "would_change": "",
   "level_shown": "State law",
   "level_possible": "",
   "harms": [
    {
     "label": "Records access",
     "slug": "records-access",
     "def": "Delays, gaps and denials that keep public records from the public. They don't just frustrate one requester; they keep information from everyone."
    },
    {
     "label": "Wasted time",
     "slug": "wasted-time",
     "def": "Hours spent chasing deadlines, appealing denials and refiling requests: residents' time, and the staff time taxpayers pay for."
    }
   ],
   "sources": "Records request #4940 correspondence (all messages); PRR_Correspondence_Log.xlsx.",
   "exhibits": [
    "EX-C06-1",
    "EX-C06-2"
   ],
   "requests": [],
   "level_label": "State law",
   "level_score": 6,
   "level_keys": "state",
   "outstanding": 1,
   "complete_rank": 197
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "E-21",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/findings/e-21/",
   "title": "Three requests for leave and sell-back records denied within 16 to 69 minutes, with an instruction to stop asking",
   "area": "Public records",
   "topic": "public-records",
   "category": "Public Records Act (74-103(5), 74-106(1), 74-112)",
   "grade_raw": "B",
   "grade": "indicated",
   "grade_label": "Indicated",
   "scopes": [],
   "shows": "Requests filed Oct 14 and twice Oct 16, 2026; denials Oct 15, Oct 16 (16 minutes after filing) and Oct 16 (69 minutes). Each cites only 74-106(1); the third adds \"Per our City Attorney, please stop requesting the same information.\" Attempts 2 and 3 also asked for records used to determine vacation sell-back eligibility. None of the three notices says whether an attorney reviewed the request or gives the right to appeal.",
   "rule": "74-103(5): a denial notice \"shall state\" attorney review (or that the agency chose not to consult an attorney), indicate the statutory authority, and \"indicate clearly\" the right to appeal and the time limit. 74-106(1) makes public gross salary and salary history, \"including bonuses, severance packages, other compensation\"; leave usage and hours worked are not on that list, so the denials themselves have a plausible basis. Sell-back payments appear in the payroll registers released under #4814. 74-112 requires release of any nonexempt portion.",
   "why": "",
   "checked": "",
   "matters": "A denial has to tell the requester whether a lawyer reviewed it and how to appeal. Notices that leave out both, followed by an instruction to stop asking, leave a requester without what the law guarantees for challenging a denial.",
   "would_change": "",
   "level_shown": "State law",
   "level_possible": "",
   "harms": [
    {
     "label": "Records access",
     "slug": "records-access",
     "def": "Delays, gaps and denials that keep public records from the public. They don't just frustrate one requester; they keep information from everyone."
    }
   ],
   "sources": "Records request correspondence: three leave-records requests filed Oct 14 and Oct 16, 2026, each denied.",
   "exhibits": [
    "EX-C08-1",
    "EX-C08-2",
    "EX-C09-1",
    "EX-C09-2",
    "EX-C10-1",
    "EX-C10-2"
   ],
   "requests": [
    {
     "j": "twin-falls-id",
     "request": "PTO x3",
     "subject": "Hours worked and leave usage, ELT",
     "filed": "2026-10",
     "outcome": "Denied three times",
     "findings": [
      "E-21"
     ],
     "how": ""
    }
   ],
   "level_label": "State law",
   "level_score": 6,
   "level_keys": "state",
   "outstanding": 2,
   "complete_rank": 10293
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "E-22",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/findings/e-22/",
   "title": "The City enforces the requester-information rule on some requests and not others",
   "area": "Public records",
   "topic": "public-records",
   "category": "Public Records Act (74-102(1), (4)); even application",
   "grade_raw": "B",
   "grade": "indicated",
   "grade_label": "Indicated",
   "scopes": [],
   "shows": "The City processed request #3946 from May 31 to Sept 16, 2026, including months of correspondence with the requester, without questioning identity. After the requester pressed for the withheld records (Sept 3 and Sept 18), the City denied that requester's next request on Sept 24 for \"failure to comply with Idaho Code 74-102(4). Idaho statute requiring a requestor to state the requestor's name and address\" (EX-C02-2). That request was filed on the City's form, which requires a name and street address, and gave a name, mailing address, email and phone; the City's saved copy shows the address field blank (EX-C02-1). It did not include a residency declaration, and the denial did not mention one. On #4953 (all handbook exceptions for executives) the City Attorney wrote that \"the City does not believe you are who you represent yourself to be\" and offered to resolve it on proof of identity. Requests #4729, #4814 and #4869, also filed without a sworn residency declaration, were processed without identity questions.\nThe City's public records page states: \"All public records requests, whether sent physically or electronically, must include this form, pursuant to City policy.\" 74-102(4) lets an agency require a written request and says a request may be made by email; it does not mention an agency form. The page does not mention the residency declaration, and it cites \"Idaho Code § 74-104-111\" (a garbled citation). The City's online form requires the requester's name, street address, city, state, ZIP code, phone number and email, and has no field for the residency declaration. Request #3946 was submitted on that form with every required item, street address and phone included, and without a residency declaration (the requester's copy of the submitted form, EX-C01-12). The copies of submitted forms the City saved and released leave out the street address and phone on every request, under every requester name: the fields are blank (for example EX-C02-1), or on #3946 missing altogether (EX-C01-1), although the requester's copy of the same submission, made the same minute, shows both filled in (EX-C01-12). Those copies do not show what a requester entered.\n[Requester account] Every request in this comparison gave a name, mailing address, email address and phone number on the City's form or in the request; none included the sworn residency declaration. The City's stated reasons were the name and address (Sept 24) and, on #4953, that \"the City does not believe you have provided your actual name, address, or phone number\" (EX-C07-4). Neither of those two denials cited the missing declaration.",
   "rule": "74-102(4): a request \"shall also provide\" the requester's name, mailing address, email address, telephone number and a written declaration under oath of whether the requester is a resident. The duty is the requester's; the statute names no exceptions and does not say what an agency must do with an incomplete request. 74-102(5): the custodian \"shall make no inquiry\" of a requester except as listed. The City's online form does not ask for the residency declaration.",
   "why": "",
   "checked": "",
   "matters": "The law asks every requester for the same information. Enforcing it against some requests and not others turns a neutral rule into a way to choose who gets public records. If the City means to insist on every item the law lists, its own form should ask for all of them and refuse an incomplete request, rather than accepting it and denying it later.",
   "would_change": "This finding would change if the City's records show it applied 74-102(4) the same way to other requests in the same period, or recorded a specific reason for these denials at the time.",
   "level_shown": "",
   "level_possible": "State law",
   "harms": [
    {
     "label": "Unequal treatment",
     "slug": "unequal-treatment",
     "def": "Rules applied to some people and not others: employees held to limits their bosses ignore, or requesters treated differently depending on what they ask for. Rules that depend on rank or favor stop being rules."
    },
    {
     "label": "Records access",
     "slug": "records-access",
     "def": "Delays, gaps and denials that keep public records from the public. They don't just frustrate one requester; they keep information from everyone."
    }
   ],
   "sources": "Records request #3946 correspondence; records request correspondence on the market analysis cost (denied); records request #4953 correspondence (denied). City website, Make a Public Records Request page (saved 2026-11-07).; EX-C01-1 and EX-C02-1 (the City's saved copies of the submitted forms); EX-C01-12 (the requester's copy of the #3946 submission).",
   "exhibits": [
    "EX-C01-1",
    "EX-C01-2",
    "EX-C01-3",
    "EX-C01-4",
    "EX-C01-5",
    "EX-C01-6",
    "EX-C01-7",
    "EX-C01-8",
    "EX-C01-9",
    "EX-C01-12",
    "EX-C02-1",
    "EX-C02-2",
    "EX-C03-1",
    "EX-C03-2",
    "EX-C03-3",
    "EX-C07-1",
    "EX-C07-2",
    "EX-C07-3",
    "EX-C07-4",
    "EX-C15-1",
    "EX-C15-2",
    "EX-C15-3",
    "EX-C15-4"
   ],
   "requests": [
    {
     "j": "twin-falls-id",
     "request": "#5293",
     "subject": "Council committee for City Manager / City Attorney evaluations: membership, rules on committees, notices and minutes, compensation recommendations, minutes of 14 executive sessions (2014-present)",
     "filed": "2026-11-17",
     "outcome": "Denied Nov 20 (within 3 working days), one page: \"not in possession of a report or record of that nature\" and \"denied under Idaho Code 74-102(4\" (cut off). No item-by-item answer; no statute tied to any item; nothing was asked of the requester first. The City's delivery folder held only the denial and its own copy of the request.",
     "findings": [
      "E-06",
      "E-22",
      "E-05"
     ],
     "how": ""
    }
   ],
   "level_label": "Possibly state law",
   "level_score": 5,
   "level_keys": "state",
   "outstanding": 3,
   "complete_rank": 10376
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "E-23",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/findings/e-23/",
   "title": "Deputy City Manager sold vacation twice in fiscal year 2024",
   "area": "Executive pay & leave",
   "topic": "executive-pay",
   "category": "Policy (handbook sec. 5.2.1)",
   "grade_raw": "A (payments and request dates) / C (any written exception)",
   "grade": "documented",
   "grade_label": "Documented",
   "scopes": [
    "Local policy"
   ],
   "shows": "Payroll (Scott register): 40-hour sales on checks dated 10/13/2023 (p67) and 9/27/2024 (p75), both inside fiscal year 2024 (Oct 1, 2023 - Sep 30, 2024): 80 hours in one fiscal year, 40 over the cap, $3,210.00 at that rate. Her other sales (9/30/2021, 12/9/2022, 10/10/2025) are one per fiscal year at 40 hours, and each passes the 40-hour vacation-taken test.\nHer requests are dated 10/9/2023 and 9/20/2024 (EX-A30), so both were made inside fiscal year 2024, and Payroll approved both. From September 2022 the form tells Payroll to check: \"Did they sell back in the current Fiscal Year? (October 1st to Sept 30th).\"\nThe same requests show vacation balances above 200 hours, the maximum in the current handbook, when Deputy City Manager Scott applied (269 hours in Sept 2021, 236 in Oct 2023, 226 in Sept 2024, 215 in Oct 2025) and when Deputy City Manager Humble applied (223 in Oct 2023, 252 in Oct 2024). A balance may pass the maximum during the year; the excess expires on the employee's anniversary date unless the City Manager grants a grace period. None of the ten requests checks the form's \"use it or lose it\" box, which the form says needs City Manager approval, and no City Manager step appears in their approval histories.",
   "rule": "Every handbook 2021-2026: vacation may be sold only once during any fiscal year; maximum 40 hours per fiscal year for general employees. 2025 Employee Handbook sec. 5.2 (PRR #3946): \"The maximum accrual of vacation shall be 200-hours\"; balances over the maximum \"shall expire on the employee's anniversary date\"; the City Manager may grant a grace period on a director's written explanation. The sell-back form (EX-A30): \"Vacation may only be sold back once during any fiscal year.\"",
   "why": "",
   "checked": "",
   "matters": "The cap exists to control what the City pays out for unused leave. Exceeding it for a senior official spends public money outside the City's own limits, with no public decision.",
   "would_change": "This finding would change if a written exception from the time allowed the second sale in fiscal 2024, or a grace period for the balances above 200 hours. Under the handbook these would be signed approvals filed with the requests. None was included with the released forms (EX-A30).",
   "level_shown": "City policy",
   "level_possible": "",
   "harms": [
    {
     "label": "Public money",
     "slug": "public-money",
     "def": "Money paid outside the rules, or spent without the approvals the rules require. It comes out of the same budget as police, streets, parks and water."
    },
    {
     "label": "Unequal treatment",
     "slug": "unequal-treatment",
     "def": "Rules applied to some people and not others: employees held to limits their bosses ignore, or requesters treated differently depending on what they ask for. Rules that depend on rank or favor stop being rules."
    }
   ],
   "sources": "Payroll register (Scott) pp67, 75.; EX-A30 (requests dated 10/9/2023 and 9/20/2024; balances on all ten requests); 2025 Employee Handbook sec. 5.2 (PRR #3946).",
   "exhibits": [
    "EX-A20",
    "EX-A30"
   ],
   "requests": [],
   "level_label": "City code, policy or contract",
   "level_score": 2,
   "level_keys": "city",
   "outstanding": 2,
   "complete_rank": 297
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "E-24",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/findings/e-24/",
   "title": "Executive leave: a paid-leave benefit for the leadership team that appears in individual agreements but in no Employee Handbook",
   "area": "Executive pay & leave",
   "topic": "executive-pay",
   "category": "Policy / equal treatment; handbook \"special arrangement\" clause",
   "grade_raw": "A (benefit exists) / B (scope and use unknown)",
   "grade": "documented",
   "grade_label": "Documented",
   "scopes": [
    "Local policy"
   ],
   "shows": "City Manager Service Agreement (Apr 2020) and 2024 agreement: \"an additional forty hours (40) of personal leave, also known as executive leave\" each January 1, in a separate bank, \"no compensatory value,\" not affecting other leave accruals, forfeited Dec 31. Economic Development Director offer letter (2022): \"As a member of the Executive Leadership team of the city you will be provided with an annual award of executive leave\"; it is \"use it or lose it\" and \"may not be sold or converted to any other accrual.\" The same letter and the CFO's 2020 offer also credit 120 hours of vacation at hire. Payroll registers show \"Executive Vacation\" (code EX) of about 40 hours a year for both the City Manager and the Deputy City Manager. None of the Employee Handbooks we hold (2021 draft through 2026-2027) mentions executive leave.\nThe City Attorney Service Agreement the Council approved 6-0 on Sept 28, 2026, which makes the City Attorney a City employee from Oct 1, 2026, grants \"an additional twenty hours (20) of personal leave, also known as executive leave\" each January 1, with \"no compensatory value\" and forfeited on December 31 (Council packet Sept 28, 2026, pp68, 71; minutes p2). That grant was made in open session, as the City Manager's was.",
   "rule": "Every handbook since 2021: no one other than the City Manager may \"provide any special arrangement concerning terms or conditions of employment in an individual case or generally and any such modification must be in writing.\" The City Manager's own executive leave is in Council-approved agreements (2020, 2024).",
   "why": "",
   "checked": "",
   "matters": "A paid-leave benefit that exists only for the leadership team, outside the published rules, is a cost to taxpayers that residents can't see in any policy or vote.",
   "would_change": "The City Manager's executive leave is in his Council-approved agreements. For other members of the leadership team, this finding would change if written approvals from the time grant it to each person: an offer letter, a written special arrangement under the handbook, or a policy. Only some have been released.",
   "level_shown": "",
   "level_possible": "City policy",
   "harms": [
    {
     "label": "Unequal treatment",
     "slug": "unequal-treatment",
     "def": "Rules applied to some people and not others: employees held to limits their bosses ignore, or requesters treated differently depending on what they ask for. Rules that depend on rank or favor stop being rules."
    },
    {
     "label": "Hidden decisions",
     "slug": "hidden-decisions",
     "def": "Decisions made without a public vote, a proper notice or minutes. The public can't question, challenge or reverse what it never saw."
    }
   ],
   "sources": "PRR #4869: CITY MANAGER SERVICE AGREEMENT APR 2020; 2024 CM Contract signed. PRR #4729: Barigar - Offer Letter; Howard, Breanna Final Offer MAR 2020. PRR #4814: payroll registers (code EX). Handbooks 2021-2027 (searched; no executive leave provision).; Council packet 2026-09-28 pp67-72 (City Attorney Service Agreement); minutes 2026-09-28 p2.",
   "exhibits": [
    "EX-A03",
    "EX-A11",
    "EX-A12",
    "EX-A20",
    "EX-A24"
   ],
   "requests": [],
   "level_label": "Possibly City code, policy or contract",
   "level_score": 1,
   "level_keys": "city",
   "outstanding": 1,
   "complete_rank": 194
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "E-25",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/findings/e-25/",
   "title": "Mayor (later Council Member) Pierce acted on seven Suburban Construction items after stating on the record that she does accounting for the firm; no later recusal or disclosure is recorded",
   "area": "Ethics / contracts",
   "topic": "contracts-ethics",
   "category": "Ethics in Government Act (I.C. 74-403(3)-(4), 74-404(4), 74-406); federal CDBG conflict rules (2 CFR 200.318(c)(1), 24 CFR 570.611)",
   "grade_raw": "A (statement, votes, CDBG budget label) / B (federal conflict rule applies to the restroom contract) / C (Idaho legal conflict)",
   "grade": "documented",
   "grade_label": "Documented",
   "scopes": [
    "Local policy",
    "State law",
    "Federal"
   ],
   "shows": "Oct 7, 2024 minutes, item 5a (request to negotiate with Suburban Construction Management for CM/GC services on the Public Works Site, $1.2M from water and wastewater reserves): \"Mayor Pierce recused herself as she does accounting for Suburban Construction Management. Vice Mayor Brown proceeded.\" Vote 6-0 with 1 abstention. Later items naming the firm (\"SuburbanCM,\" \"Suburban CM,\" \"Suburban Construction Management\" or \"Suburban Construction\"), each with Pierce listed present and no recusal, abstention or disclosure recorded: (1) Feb 18, 2025 - rank CM/GC candidates for the City Park Restroom and negotiate with top-ranked SuburbanCM (6 present, 6-0). (2) Mar 17, 2025 - up to $1,600,000 of water and wastewater reserves for the Public Works Site project and authority to sign the CM/GC contract with Suburban Construction Management (6 present, 6-0). (3) Mar 17, 2025 - contract with Suburban CM as CM/GC for the City Park Restroom (6-0; Mayor Pierce asked about the timeline). (4) Nov 17, 2025 - $2,980,000 of water reserves for Well #5 and a $2,395,826 construction contract to Suburban Construction (6 present, 6-0). (5) Aug 17, 2026 - negotiations with Suburban Construction Management for CM/GC services at the Elizabeth Blvd / Hankins Rd park (6 present, 6-0); the same minutes record another member recusing on a different item. (6) Oct 5, 2026 - re-authorize $486,013 of park impact fees and approve a Suburban Construction CM/GC contract for that park; Council Member Pierce seconded (6-0). (7) Oct 19, 2026 - $900,000 of water reserves for a change order with Suburban Construction (Pheasant pressure reduction valve); Council Member Pierce made the motion (6-0). [Deduction] With six members present and a 6-0 vote recorded, Pierce voted on each item. \nMinutes searched: 193 minutes files for 2022-2026 in our council set; one (Jun 3, 2024) has no text layer and was not searched. \nFederal funds: The City has been a HUD CDBG Entitlement Community since September 2019 (FY2021 budget p21). The FY2025 adopted budget p60 lists \"City Park Restroom (CDBG) - $950,000.\" Two of the Suburban items are that project: Feb 18, 2025, Council approved the ranking of CM/GC candidates for the City Park Restroom and authorized negotiation with the top-ranked firm, SuburbanCM (EX-B29); Mar 17, 2025, Council approved \"a contract with Suburban CM to serve as the City's construction manager/general contractor (CM/GC) for the demo and reconstruction of the City Park Restroom\" (EX-B30). The minutes record Mayor Pierce present at both meetings (she spoke on other items Feb 18 and asked the project timeline Mar 17), and both votes were \"all members present ... 6 to 0.\" On a federally supported contract, 2 CFR 200.318(c)(1) bars anyone with a \"real or apparent\" conflict from taking part in selection or award, and 24 CFR 570.611 applies to CDBG. [Deduction] Her own Oct 2024 statement that she does accounting for the firm is at least an apparent conflict under the federal standard, which is broader than Idaho's. Open: whether the CM/GC contract itself was paid with CDBG funds, and whether HUD granted any 570.611(d) exception.\nFor comparison, the minutes record council members stepping aside for business relationships many times, including Pierce herself: July 13, 2020, \"Vice Mayor Pierce recused herself from Public Hearing b) stating she has a business relationship with the applicant... she consulted with the City Attorney on this matter\"; Aug 24, 2020; Oct 7, 2024 (the Suburban item); June 16, 2025. Other members recused over clients, e.g. June 25, 2018: \"Extreme Excavation, Inc is one of her clients.\"\nFrom the City's own recordings (machine transcripts; each reference plays that moment): her recusal on the first item (Meeting 2024-10-07 at 0:13:32) and her recorded yes votes on later items (Meeting 2025-11-17 at 0:27:57; Meeting 2026-08-17 at 0:09:44; Meeting 2026-10-05 at 0:35:22; Meeting 2026-10-19 (recording 2) at 0:08:45).",
   "rule": "I.C. 74-403(4): a conflict of interest is an official action whose effect would be to the private pecuniary benefit of the official, a household member, or \"a business with which the person ... is associated.\" 74-403(3): \"associated\" means director, officer, owner, partner, employee or holder of stock worth $5,000 or more. 74-404(4): an elected municipal official \"shall disclose the nature of a potential conflict of interest prior to acting on a matter\"; disclosure does not bar voting. 74-406: intentional failure to disclose is a civil offense (fine up to $500).; 2 CFR 200.318(c)(1); 24 CFR 570.611 (CDBG).",
   "why": "",
   "checked": "",
   "matters": "Officials must disclose a business connection before acting on that business's contracts. Without disclosure, residents can't judge whether public contracts are awarded on the merits.",
   "would_change": "This finding would change if records from the time show Council Member Pierce disclosed the relationship at these meetings (the City's recordings would show a spoken disclosure the minutes left out), a written disclosure or legal opinion under Idaho Code 74-404, or that her work for the firm had ended before February 2025. Business filings showing that the differently named firms are separate businesses would also change it.",
   "level_shown": "",
   "level_possible": "Federal law",
   "harms": [
    {
     "label": "Conflict of interest",
     "slug": "conflict-of-interest",
     "def": "An official acting on matters that affect their own business or finances without disclosing it, so residents can't tell whether the decision was made on the merits."
    },
    {
     "label": "Public money",
     "slug": "public-money",
     "def": "Money paid outside the rules, or spent without the approvals the rules require. It comes out of the same budget as police, streets, parks and water."
    }
   ],
   "sources": "Minutes 2024-10-07 p1 (EX-B28); 2025-02-18 p2 (EX-B29); 2025-03-17 pp2-3 (EX-B30); 2025-11-17 pp1-2 (EX-B31); 2026-08-17 p2 (EX-B32); 2026-10-05 p2 (EX-B33); 2026-10-19 p1 (EX-B34). Statute: EX-D06. FY2025 adopted budget p60; FY2021 budget p21 [City website documents saved 2026-11-07]. Minutes 2020-07-13 p5; 2020-08-24 p2; 2025-06-16 p2; 2018-06-25 p2.",
   "exhibits": [
    "EX-B28",
    "EX-B29",
    "EX-B30",
    "EX-B31",
    "EX-B32",
    "EX-B33",
    "EX-B34",
    "EX-D06"
   ],
   "requests": [],
   "level_label": "Possibly federal law",
   "level_score": 7,
   "level_keys": "federal",
   "outstanding": 4,
   "complete_rank": 491
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "E-26",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/findings/e-26/",
   "title": "A Deputy City Manager submitted and then approved, as both \"City Manager\" and HR, pay changes for an employee she supervises",
   "area": "Executive pay & HR process",
   "topic": "workplace",
   "category": "Policy / internal control (handbook special-arrangement clause; approval steps)",
   "grade_raw": "A (form approval history) / C (whether the City Manager delegated the step)",
   "grade": "documented",
   "grade_label": "Documented",
   "scopes": [
    "Local policy"
   ],
   "shows": "Employee Status Change records for the HR Director (supervisor listed: Deputy City Manager Scott). Oct 2, 2023 (promotion to Acting HR Director, grade 11 to 17, $54.60/hr): \"Submit by Gretchen Scott\" 9:42:54 AM; \"City Manager Approves by Gretchen Scott\" 9:43:35 AM; \"HR Approves by Gretchen Scott\" 9:44:11 AM (77 seconds in all). Oct 31, 2025 (raise to $73.00/hr, \"105% of market in grade 17 for completing 7 years\"): submit 10:00:44 AM, City Manager approval 10:05:41 AM, HR approval 10:06:16 AM, all by Gretchen Scott. By contrast, the City Manager himself approved the City Manager step on Scott's own promotion (Dec 14, 2021) and on the HR Director's Dec 2023 promotion, and a different HR employee approved the HR step on two of the Economic Development Director's 2023 forms (Feb and Apr 2023). Hourly-rate history: $37.74 (Oct 13, 2023), $54.60 (Oct 27, 2023), $65.51 (Dec 22, 2023) - [Deduction] a 73.6% increase in about ten weeks, through two promotions.",
   "rule": "Every handbook since 2021: no one other than the City Manager may provide special arrangements on terms of employment, and they must be in writing. The status-change form has a separate City Manager approval step (\"City Manager Approves\" in its action history). [Deduction] When the submitter completes the City Manager and HR steps herself, the form loses the independent review those steps exist to provide. The City's written Financial Policies apply the same principle elsewhere: utility staff may not \"open, close or enter any activity to their own account(s)\" (Policy VII-c), cash handling requires \"Segregation of duties - authorization, recordation, custodian functions, and reconciliation\" (Policy III-c), and each senior staff member is responsible for seeing that internal control procedures are followed in their department (Policy I-c). [Our reading] A pay form approved at every step by the person who submitted it falls short of the separation the City requires of its clerks. The accounting manual the City posts with those policies: \"One person should not be able to authorize a transaction, record the transaction in accounting records and maintain custody of the assets resulting from the transaction\" (p82).",
   "why": "",
   "checked": "",
   "matters": "Separation of duties means the person asking for a pay change isn't the person approving it. When one person signs as requester, City Manager and HR, there is no check at all.",
   "would_change": "The October 2023 pay itself matches a City Manager letter (EX-A28). This finding would change if the City Manager had delegated his approval step to the Deputy City Manager in writing before October 2023.",
   "level_shown": "",
   "level_possible": "City policy",
   "harms": [
    {
     "label": "Hidden decisions",
     "slug": "hidden-decisions",
     "def": "Decisions made without a public vote, a proper notice or minutes. The public can't question, challenge or reverse what it never saw."
    },
    {
     "label": "Public money",
     "slug": "public-money",
     "def": "Money paid outside the rules, or spent without the approvals the rules require. It comes out of the same budget as police, streets, parks and water."
    }
   ],
   "sources": "EX-A24 pp29-44 (status-change records and action histories); EX-A28; EX-A29; EX-B39; EX-A26 (hourly rates).; City Financial Policies I-c, III-c, VII-c (City website, saved 2026-11-07).; ICCTFOA Accounting Manual p82 (posted with the Financial Policies, City website).",
   "exhibits": [
    "EX-A24",
    "EX-A26",
    "EX-A28",
    "EX-A29",
    "EX-B39"
   ],
   "requests": [],
   "level_label": "Possibly City code, policy or contract",
   "level_score": 1,
   "level_keys": "city",
   "outstanding": 1,
   "complete_rank": 194
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "E-27",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/findings/e-27/",
   "title": "In Dec 2021 the City Manager set the Deputy City Manager salaries as a percentage \"variance\" from his own pay; his later raises did not carry that link forward (context)",
   "area": "Executive pay & HR process",
   "topic": "workplace",
   "category": "Context / compensation method",
   "grade_raw": "A (records) / C (significance)",
   "grade": "documented",
   "grade_label": "Documented",
   "scopes": [],
   "shows": "Dec 10, 2021 email, City Manager to Scott, subject \"Salaries\": \"Mitch 160,500.90 [20% variance w/ CM] / Gretchen 152,858.00 [26%] / Will you do the forms for me?\" Scott submitted Humble's form Dec 13, 2021 and her own promotion form Dec 14, 2021 at 3:25 PM; the City Manager approved hers at 3:34 PM. The Council confirmed her appointment as Deputy City Manager 5-0 on Dec 13, 2021 (the minutes state no pay). New rates first appear on Jan 7, 2022 checks (Humble $72.80 to $77.16; Scott $69.33 to $73.49). Her promotion letter is dated Feb 7, 2022, states an effective date of Dec 13, 2021 (the form says Dec 20, 2021) and is signed by an HR staff member who reported to her. [Deduction] The rates on the forms ($73.4875 and $77.1625 an hour) come to $152,854 and $160,498 a year at 2,080 hours, within a few dollars of the email figures.\nWhat happened next (EX-A26, hourly rates by check date): each October since 2022 both deputies have received the same percentage raise as the Chief Financial Officer: 5% (Oct 2022), 4% (Oct 2023), 6% (Oct 2024) and 4% (Oct 2025). The City Manager's base pay changed at other times: Dec 2022 (+16.9%), Jan 2025 (+6.0%) and Oct 2025 (+4.4%). [Deduction] Measured as the City Manager's hourly rate above each deputy's, the gap was 20% (Humble) and 26% (Scott) in Jan 2022, matching the email; 15% and 20% after the Oct 2022 raises; 34% and 41% after the City Manager's Dec 2022 raise; 22% and 28% in Oct 2024; and 29% and 36% from Oct 2025. The two deputies' rates have stayed exactly 5% apart since Oct 2020. The registers end in May 2026, so raises from Oct 2026 are not covered.",
   "rule": "The City Manager appoints department heads with Council confirmation and sets staff pay under the handbook. No rule violation is shown.",
   "why": "",
   "checked": "Every hourly rate the City released for the City Manager, both deputies and the other executives from Oct 2020 to Oct 2025 (EX-A26), compared at each change.",
   "matters": "In 2021 the City Manager set his deputies' pay by reference to his own, including the pay of the deputy who processes his pay changes. Pay set that way gives the deputies a stake in the City Manager's pay. The payroll since then shows no continuing link: his larger raises were not passed on to them, so this is not an ongoing conflict. It is recorded because it shows how the salaries were first set.",
   "would_change": "A record after 2021 that sets deputy pay as a fixed percentage of the City Manager's, or later deputy raises that follow his.",
   "level_shown": "Context",
   "level_possible": "",
   "harms": [
    {
     "label": "Conflict of interest",
     "slug": "conflict-of-interest",
     "def": "An official acting on matters that affect their own business or finances without disclosing it, so residents can't tell whether the decision was made on the merits."
    }
   ],
   "sources": "EX-A27; EX-A24 pp4-12; EX-B35; EX-A26.",
   "exhibits": [
    "EX-A24",
    "EX-A26",
    "EX-A27",
    "EX-B35"
   ],
   "requests": [],
   "level_label": "Context",
   "level_score": 0,
   "level_keys": "context",
   "outstanding": 0,
   "complete_rank": 95
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "E-28",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/findings/e-28/",
   "title": "A former council member's hire as Economic Development Director was handled in public; his HR records list a 2012 hire date",
   "area": "Executive pay & HR process",
   "topic": "workplace",
   "category": "Context / equal treatment question",
   "grade_raw": "A (records) / C (effect unknown)",
   "grade": "documented",
   "grade_label": "Documented",
   "scopes": [],
   "shows": "Jul 18, 2022: on the City's request, the Council passed Ordinance 2022-013, adding the Economic Development Director to the department heads listed in City Code 1-2-4. The staff memo says this makes the City Manager's appointment to the post subject to Council confirmation, that the post \"is currently vacant,\" and that recruitment would start \"right away\" (EX-B50). Council Member Barigar \"recused himself from the vote and stepped down from the dais\"; the ordinance passed 5-0 with one abstention (EX-B51). One week later, on Jul 25, 2022, Council Member Barigar read his resignation, effective that night, saying he intended to apply for the Economic Development Director posting and that, \"after consulting with the City Attorney,\" an active application would be a conflict of interest; he said he had served \"more than 14 years.\" Accepted 5-0 on Aug 1, 2022. Offer letter of Sept 19, 2022: $138,000, plus 3.5% after six months, $2,000 sign-on bonus, 120 hours of vacation and 40 hours of sick leave credited, and executive leave. Council confirmed the appointment 7-0 on Oct 10, 2022. His Oct 6, 2023 status-change record lists \"Date of Hire 1/1/2012.\" [Deduction] 1/1/2012 matches neither his Oct 11, 2022 start nor a council tenure of more than 14 years.",
   "rule": "Handbook special-arrangement clause (the City Manager may grant written special arrangements). Front-loaded leave also appears in other executive offers (CFO, 2020: 120 hours of vacation and 120 of sick leave). City Code 1-2-4 (amended by Ord. 2022-013, Jul 18, 2022): the Economic Development Director is a department head. The City Manager appoints department heads and the Council confirms them (EX-B50; I.C. 50-808).",
   "why": "",
   "checked": "",
   "matters": "Context. Moving from the Council to a City job can be done properly in the open, and this move was handled publicly. The hire date in his records matters only if it raised benefits tied to years of service.",
   "would_change": "This would change if the City's records show what the 2012 hire date is based on, for example his years on the Council carried over in the payroll system, and that it has not affected his leave, longevity or retention pay.",
   "level_shown": "Context",
   "level_possible": "",
   "harms": [],
   "sources": "EX-B36; EX-B37; EX-B38; EX-A24 pp20-28; EX-A21; EX-A26.; EX-B50; EX-B51; City Code 1-2-4.",
   "exhibits": [
    "EX-A21",
    "EX-A24",
    "EX-A26",
    "EX-B36",
    "EX-B37",
    "EX-B38",
    "EX-B50",
    "EX-B51"
   ],
   "requests": [],
   "level_label": "Context",
   "level_score": 0,
   "level_keys": "context",
   "outstanding": 1,
   "complete_rank": 191
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "E-31",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/findings/e-31/",
   "title": "The Council promised in 2013-2014 to post accounts payable, monthly financial reports and a financial dashboard on the City website. None is posted, and no record shows the promise was withdrawn.",
   "area": "Financial transparency",
   "topic": "financial-transparency",
   "category": "City policy (Second Amended Resolution 1912, Section 5); records retention (I.C. 50-907) as a lead",
   "grade_raw": "A (promise; current website) / B (never withdrawn)",
   "grade": "documented",
   "grade_label": "Documented",
   "scopes": [
    "Local policy",
    "State law"
   ],
   "shows": "Resolution 1912, adopted Dec 2, 2013 (6-1), amended Apr 7, 2014 (4-3) and re-adopted as Second Amended Resolution 1912 on Apr 21, 2014 (7-0), says in Section 5 that the City \"will provide access to the annual budget, monthly financial reports, accounts payable, financial dashboard ... on the City's website.\" A staff memo of Apr 13, 2015 cites the City's \"January 2015, Financial Dashboard.\" Council minutes stated each week's accounts payable total until Aug 3, 2015 ($1,102,058); from Aug 10, 2015 they give only the date range. On Apr 4, 2016 the Council authorized destruction of Finance \"Check Registers 2007-2015\" (Res. 2016-02, 7-0). In 2019 the City still cited \"Second Amended Resolution 1912\" in the code text for the Public Art Commission (Ord. 2019-009). The City Code, as supplemented through June 22, 2026, still says that commission's meetings follow \"Second Amended Resolution 1912\" (City Code 2-13-10). On Nov 10, 2026 the City website's site map listed no accounts payable, check register, monthly financial report or financial dashboard.\nFrom the City's own recordings (machine transcripts; each reference plays that moment): the financial dashboard was described to the Council as available online in 2013 and 2014 (Meeting 2013-05-06 at 2:26:35; Meeting 2014-04-21 at 2:04:06). Council members asked about individual payments from a paged accounts payable list (Meeting 2014-01-21 at 0:05:36; Meeting 2014-02-24 at 0:07:35). City staff were still describing the transparency resolution as something the City must comply with in 2017 and as something it was complying with in 2022 (Meeting 2017-02-06 at 1:17:45; Meeting 2022-04-25 at 0:07:57).\nThe City's Archive Center posts quarterly revenue and expense reports, not monthly ones, and the set has gaps. As saved on Nov 8, 2026: fiscal 2021 has only the first quarter; fiscal 2023 has the first three; fiscal 2024 has only a December report, posted under a fourth-quarter 2023 label; fiscal 2025 starts at the second quarter; and the link labeled as the fiscal 2026 fourth-quarter expense report serves the revenue report. Every posted report includes the line \"Citizens are invited to inspect the detailed supporting records of the above financial statements.\"\nThe City's budget page links adopted budgets for fiscal 2017 to 2023 and 2025 to 2026. The link labeled \"Budget 2024\" opens the fiscal 2024-2025 budget; no fiscal 2023-2024 adopted budget is posted on the budget page or the older budget archive page (checked Nov 11, 2026).",
   "rule": "Second Amended Resolution 1912, Section 5: \"The City will provide access to the annual budget, monthly financial reports, accounts payable, financial dashboard ... on the City's website (www.tfid.org).\" Its stated purpose: \"to promote accountability, to enhance dissemination of public information, and to encourage citizen participation.\" The City's own Financial Policy I-a commits it to \"Prepare and publish periodic financial and operating reports to facilitate management, policy, and appropriation decisions.\" State law requires each quarterly statement to be published in the official newspaper with the sentence \"Citizens are invited to inspect the detailed supporting records of the above financial statements\" (I.C. 50-1011), and requires the Council to examine the accounts quarterly by reviewing a treasurer's report (I.C. 50-708). Section 4 of the same resolution promises video, agendas, staff reports and minutes of Council meetings online (see E-34).",
   "why": "The Council decided, in its own resolution, that the law's minimum was not enough and that residents should be able to see the City's payments online without asking. That promise is still on the books, and the payments are not online.",
   "checked": "Every mention of Resolution 1912, \"Transparency Resolution\" and the Section 5 wording in 1,995 Council agendas, packets and minutes (2005-2026); the last mention in a Council document is Sept 23, 2019, and no amending or repealing action appears. The current City Code (through Ord. 2026-007, June 22, 2026) still cites it (City Code 2-13-10). Every accounts payable consent item from 2006 to 2026 (totals stop after Aug 3, 2015). Records-destruction resolutions mentioning check registers or claims. The City's site map and budget page (Nov 10, 2026). The Council hears quarterly finance presentations in open session, including for fiscal 2024, the year with no posted budget or quarterly reports (Meeting 2024-05-06 at 0:37:32; Meeting 2024-08-19 at 0:12:02; Meeting 2024-11-25 at 0:27:22). They summarize funds by category and do not list payments.",
   "matters": "The Council approves a list of payments at nearly every meeting, but the public never sees the list: since August 2015 not even the total appears in the minutes. Posting accounts payable, as promised, would show residents who the City pays and how much.",
   "would_change": "This finding would change if the Council amended or repealed Section 5 of Resolution 1912 in a later resolution or in minutes, or if these reports were posted on the City's website for a time (archived copies of the website would show that). We found no such resolution in Council records from 2005 to 2026.",
   "level_shown": "City policy",
   "level_possible": "",
   "harms": [
    {
     "label": "Financial transparency",
     "slug": "financial-transparency",
     "def": "Payment lists, card statements, budgets and financial reports kept out of public view. Residents can see that money was approved, but not what it bought or who spent it."
    },
    {
     "label": "Records access",
     "slug": "records-access",
     "def": "Delays, gaps and denials that keep public records from the public. They don't just frustrate one requester; they keep information from everyone."
    },
    {
     "label": "Hidden decisions",
     "slug": "hidden-decisions",
     "def": "Decisions made without a public vote, a proper notice or minutes. The public can't question, challenge or reverse what it never saw."
    },
    {
     "label": "Public money",
     "slug": "public-money",
     "def": "Money paid outside the rules, or spent without the approvals the rules require. It comes out of the same budget as police, streets, parks and water."
    }
   ],
   "sources": "EX-B40 (minutes 2013-12-02 pp3-5); Agenda 2013-12-02 pp19-27; Packet 2014-04-07 p119; Minutes 2014-04-07 pp6-7; EX-B41 (agenda 2014-04-21 pp73-76, Section 5); EX-B42 (minutes 2014-04-21 p5); Agenda 2015-04-13 p46; Minutes 2015-07-20 p2; EX-B43 (minutes 2015-08-03 p2); EX-B44 (minutes 2015-08-10 p1); EX-B45 (agenda 2016-04-04 pp39-41); EX-B46 (minutes 2016-04-04 p5); EX-B49 (special meeting packet 2019-09-23 p6); Minutes 2019-09-23 p1. City website: tfid.org/SiteMap and tfid.org/161/City-Budget (checked 2026-11-10).; Quarterly revenue and expense reports, fiscal 2020-2026 (City website, Archive Center, saved 2026-11-08).; City website budget page tfid.org/161/City-Budget and budget archive page tfid.org/528/City-Manager (checked 2026-11-11); Financial Policy I-a; I.C. 50-708, 50-1011.; City Code 2-13-10 (online code, current through Ord. 2026-007).",
   "exhibits": [
    "EX-B40",
    "EX-B41",
    "EX-B42",
    "EX-B43",
    "EX-B44",
    "EX-B45",
    "EX-B46",
    "EX-B49",
    "EX-C16-1",
    "EX-C16-2",
    "EX-C17-1",
    "EX-C17-2",
    "EX-C17-3",
    "EX-C17-4"
   ],
   "requests": [
    {
     "j": "twin-falls-id",
     "request": "#5254",
     "subject": "Accounts payable payment register and Council AP reports, fiscal year 2026 (Oct 1, 2025 to Sep 30, 2026)",
     "filed": "2026-11-15",
     "outcome": "Produced Nov 17, 2026, inside the 3 working days, with no fee: the FY2026 Invoice Distribution Report (.xlsx, and the same report as a 292-page PDF) and weekly check-run, payroll-remittance and prepaid proof lists (PDF). No invoices. A 10-working-day extension notice followed at 10:06 PM the same day, after delivery.",
     "findings": [
      "E-31",
      "E-14"
     ],
     "how": ""
    },
    {
     "j": "twin-falls-id",
     "request": "#5299",
     "subject": "Accounts payable register, fiscal years 2020-2025 (follow-up to #5254)",
     "filed": "2026-11-17",
     "outcome": "Nov 18: aggregated with #5254 under I.C. 74-102(11), 12 hours / $567.48 advance payment (Budget Coordinator $47.29/hr), though the City says it is 'not suggesting' fee avoidance. Requester narrowed to the Excel report only. Nov 19: 1.5 hours / $70.94 ('report generation and legal review'), billed at the Budget Coordinator rate. Nov 20, 3:24 AM: requester asked the City to reconsider (aggregation needs a reasonable belief of fee avoidance; Resolution 1912 Section 5) or confirm in writing. Nov 20, 9:19 PM: 10-day extension notice (ends Dec 3).",
     "findings": [
      "E-31",
      "E-14"
     ],
     "how": ""
    }
   ],
   "level_label": "City code, policy or contract",
   "level_score": 2,
   "level_keys": "city",
   "outstanding": 6,
   "complete_rank": 685
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "E-32",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/findings/e-32/",
   "title": "The Council approves the City's credit card spending every month, but the report it approves is not in the public meeting packet.",
   "area": "Financial transparency",
   "topic": "financial-transparency",
   "category": "Transparency (Second Amended Res. 1912, Sec. 5); City Financial Policies III-e and III-f; I.C. 50-1017",
   "grade_raw": "A (consent items; packets) / C (what the reports contain)",
   "grade": "documented",
   "grade_label": "Documented",
   "scopes": [
    "State law"
   ],
   "shows": "On June 23, 2014 the Council took up \"a request to change the City of Twin Falls current credit card process.\" The Chief Finance Officer said the existing process \"is not the best tool to control usage or costs,\" and a Wells Fargo representative said \"The payment of the credit card bill is an automatic debit eliminating late fees.\" The Council approved the new process 5-0, with staff to \"provide to Council a six month update\" (EX-B47). On January 26, 2015 the Chief Finance Officer reported that the new process, in place since October 1, 2014, gave \"stronger controls over these cards.\"\nThe City's Financial Policies (section III-f, \"Use of City Issued Credit Card Policy/Procedure,\" revised Oct 1, 2014) say each card is \"linked to a specific cost center and individual employee,\" and that the card statement \"will reflect the transaction date, posting date, supplier/merchant name and the total amount of the purchase.\"\nStarting Mar 18, 2019 (for January 2019), the Council's consent calendar carries a monthly item to approve the \"Wells Fargo Commercial Card\" or \"Wells Fargo Credit Card Summary\" (EX-B48). The most recent is Oct 19, 2026, for September 2026 (EX-B34). In the agendas and packets posted from 2019 to 2026 we found no page containing the card report itself. Before March 2019 no separate card item appears on the consent calendar.\nFrom the City's own recordings (machine transcripts; each reference plays that moment): the June 2014 discussion and motion (Meeting 2014-06-23 at 0:40:03) and the six-month report (Meeting 2015-01-26 at 0:18:39).",
   "rule": "Second Amended Resolution 1912, Sec. 5: the City \"will provide access to ... accounts payable ... on the City's website.\" Financial Policies III-e: \"all payment of vendor claims will be approved by the City Council\"; III-f: \"The Accounts Payable Department is responsible for paying the Program invoice(s) each month.\" I.C. 50-1017 (Council approval of claims). The same policy sets the approval chain: the cardholder marks the statement reviewed, \"an email will be issued to the appropriate manager for approval,\" and receipts go \"first to the manager (account approver) and on to Accounts Payable\"; \"card records will be audited from time to time.\" The accounting manual the City posts with its Financial Policies says: \"When the p-card statement comes in, somebody other than the cardholder should approve it\" (ICCTFOA Accounting Manual, 2003, p86).",
   "why": "Residents can see that the Council approved the month's card spending, but not what was bought, by whom, or for how much.",
   "checked": "Every mention of the card program in Council minutes from 2014 to 2026 (71 mentions), and every agenda and packet page that mentions it, looking for a page of card transactions; none was found. Some large packets were only partly machine-read.",
   "matters": "The monthly vote is the public's only view of City card spending, and all it shows is one line on an agenda.",
   "would_change": "This finding would change if the reports the Council approves each month are kept with the official meeting record even though they are left out of the posted packet. The City could then release them on request.",
   "level_shown": "City policy",
   "level_possible": "",
   "harms": [
    {
     "label": "Financial transparency",
     "slug": "financial-transparency",
     "def": "Payment lists, card statements, budgets and financial reports kept out of public view. Residents can see that money was approved, but not what it bought or who spent it."
    },
    {
     "label": "Records access",
     "slug": "records-access",
     "def": "Delays, gaps and denials that keep public records from the public. They don't just frustrate one requester; they keep information from everyone."
    },
    {
     "label": "Public money",
     "slug": "public-money",
     "def": "Money paid outside the rules, or spent without the approvals the rules require. It comes out of the same budget as police, streets, parks and water."
    }
   ],
   "sources": "EX-B47 (minutes 2014-06-23 pp3-4); Minutes 2015-01-26 p3; Financial Policies pp21-25 [City website, saved 2026-11-07]; EX-B48 (minutes 2019-03-18 p2); EX-B34 (minutes 2026-10-19 p1); EX-B41 (Second Amended Resolution 1912, Sec. 5); Council agendas and packets 2019-2026.; Financial Policies III-e, III-f pp21-25; ICCTFOA Accounting Manual p86 (posted with the Financial Policies, City website).",
   "exhibits": [
    "EX-B34",
    "EX-B41",
    "EX-B47",
    "EX-B48"
   ],
   "requests": [],
   "level_label": "City code, policy or contract",
   "level_score": 2,
   "level_keys": "city",
   "outstanding": 1,
   "complete_rank": 195
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "E-35",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/findings/e-35/",
   "title": "A Veterans Day holiday was paid on top of a full 80 hours of regular pay for the City Manager in November 2024; no reversal appears in his payroll register through May 2026",
   "area": "City Manager pay & leave",
   "topic": "executive-pay",
   "category": "Payroll accuracy; City Financial Policies (internal control)",
   "grade_raw": "A (payment) / C (whether it was corrected another way)",
   "grade": "documented",
   "grade_label": "Documented",
   "scopes": [],
   "shows": "The City Manager's check of Nov 22, 2024 (period Nov 3-16, 2024) paid 80.00 hours of regular pay and 9.00 hours of holiday pay at $108.6538 an hour, 89 hours in all, $9,711.72 gross (EX-A03 p78). In every other pay period with a holiday, regular hours are reduced by the holiday hours so the total is 80 (for example Dec 6, 2024: 18 holiday + 62 regular; Jul 3, 2025: 9 holiday + 63 regular + 8 vacation) (EX-A03 pp78, 83). The extra 9 hours came to $977.88. No negative or correcting line for it appears in the register through May 22, 2026. A similar overpayment was corrected: the Jun 6, 2025 check paid 98 hours (80 regular + 9 holiday + 9 vacation), and the Jun 20, 2025 check took back 18 hours ($2,073.12) as \"Additional Straight Time Pay\" (EX-A03 pp82-83). The Deputy City Manager's check for the same Veterans Day period (Nov 22, 2024) was paid correctly: 9 holiday + 62 regular + 9 vacation = 80 hours (EX-A20 p76). Her June 6, 2025 check had the same Memorial Day error (89 hours) and it was also reversed on June 20, 2025 (EX-A20 p81).",
   "rule": "City Financial Policies, Financial and Internal Control (eff. 10-1-13): internal controls are to ensure \"all financial transactions are executed in accordance with management's authorization and recorded properly and accurately.\" His salary is set by his Service Agreement and the Council (CM Agreement sec. 3).",
   "why": "In November 2024 the City Manager was paid for 89 hours in an 80-hour pay period: a full 80 hours of regular pay plus 9 hours of Veterans Day holiday pay. Everywhere else in his payroll records, holiday hours replace regular hours. A similar overpayment in June 2025 was taken back two weeks later; this one was not.",
   "checked": "We compared the hours on each of 299 checks in the register (Oct 2015 to May 2026) with each check's printed totals. Three periods exceed 80 hours. One (Aug 2021) is an unpaid holiday-leave entry at $0.00. One (Jun 2025) was reversed in the next check. The November 2024 check is the only one left uncorrected. We ran the same check on the Deputy City Manager's register (Oct 2015 to May 2026): her only period over 80 hours (June 2025) was reversed.",
   "matters": "The amount is small. But payroll errors that favor the official whose pay is administered by people who report to him are exactly what internal controls exist to catch, and the City caught and reversed a similar error in 2025.",
   "would_change": "This finding would change if a written rule pays holiday premium pay to the City Manager for working on a holiday and a record shows he worked Veterans Day 2024, or if a later deduction or repayment recovered the $977.88.",
   "level_shown": "City policy",
   "level_possible": "",
   "harms": [
    {
     "label": "Public money",
     "slug": "public-money",
     "def": "Money paid outside the rules, or spent without the approvals the rules require. It comes out of the same budget as police, streets, parks and water."
    }
   ],
   "sources": "EX-A03 pp78, 82-83 (City Manager payroll register); EX-A20 pp76, 81 (Deputy City Manager payroll register). PRR productions.",
   "exhibits": [
    "EX-A03",
    "EX-A20"
   ],
   "requests": [],
   "level_label": "City code, policy or contract",
   "level_score": 2,
   "level_keys": "city",
   "outstanding": 1,
   "complete_rank": 197
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "E-36",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/findings/e-36/",
   "title": "Departments spent more than the Council appropriated in each of fiscal years 2022 to 2025, including the Council's own budget three years running; the audit note that used to disclose this stopped appearing in 2022",
   "area": "Budget & finance",
   "topic": "executive-pay",
   "category": "State law (I.C. 50-1006); City Financial Policies (budgetary control)",
   "grade_raw": "A (audited figures) / C (level at which appropriations bind; materiality)",
   "grade": "documented",
   "grade_label": "Documented",
   "scopes": [
    "State law"
   ],
   "shows": "Each year's audited General Fund budgetary comparison schedule (final budget vs actual, budgetary basis) shows activities over their final budget: FY2022 Janitorial $175,012 vs $127,295 (+$47,717), Fire +$19,558, Animal Control +$10,454 (2022 Financial Statements p79); FY2023 Council $155,696 vs $149,508 (+$6,188), Janitorial +$16,928, Economic Development +$16,387, Animal Control +$9,668 (2023 Financial Statements p81); FY2024 Council $154,059 vs $148,877 (+$5,182), Fire +$40,451, Parks +$33,684, Planning and Zoning +$25,036 (2024 Financial Statement p81); FY2025 Council $158,313 vs $154,496 (+$3,817), Recreation +$23,585, Public Transportation +$16,853 (2025 Annual Comprehensive Financial Report p86). In each year the General Fund as a whole spent less than its final budget. The notes to each audit say \"Expenditures may not legally exceed budgeted appropriations at the activity level.\" The 2019, 2020 and 2021 audits follow that with an \"Excess of Expenditures over Appropriations\" paragraph (2020: Pool Fund $60,234, Historic Preservation $2,000, Fireworks $5,839; 2021: Impact Fees Fund $25,050). The 2022 to 2025 audits keep the first sentence but have no such paragraph.",
   "rule": "I.C. 50-1006: city expenditures in a year may not exceed the annual appropriation, except in a declared emergency. City Financial Policies, Budgetary Control (eff. 10-1-13): \"In no case may total expenditures of a particular department or fund exceed that which is appropriated by the City Council without a specific recommendation from the City Manager.\" The audits' own note: no spending over appropriations \"at the activity level.\"",
   "why": "The City's own audits say spending may not legally exceed what the Council appropriates for each activity. Yet every year from 2022 to 2025 the audited budget schedules show several activities over their final budget, including the City Council's own line three years in a row, and the note that disclosed such overspending in earlier audits is gone.",
   "checked": "We read the budget-to-actual schedule and the stewardship note in each audit from fiscal 2019 to 2025, and the City's Financial Policies. Only governmental activities are listed; enterprise-fund depreciation, which is not budgeted, is left out. We have not yet found budget amendments covering these amounts; the audits say only that \"some supplementary appropriations were necessary.\"",
   "matters": "Spending limits only mean something if they hold. When even the Council's own budget runs over, and the disclosure that would tell residents about it disappears from the audit, the public loses one of the few independent checks on how its money is spent.",
   "would_change": "This finding would change if the appropriation ordinances set the legal limit at the fund level only, or if a budget amendment, supplementary appropriation or written City Manager recommendation covered each overrun at the time.",
   "level_shown": "City policy",
   "level_possible": "State law",
   "harms": [
    {
     "label": "Public money",
     "slug": "public-money",
     "def": "Money paid outside the rules, or spent without the approvals the rules require. It comes out of the same budget as police, streets, parks and water."
    },
    {
     "label": "Financial transparency",
     "slug": "financial-transparency",
     "def": "Payment lists, card statements, budgets and financial reports kept out of public view. Residents can see that money was approved, but not what it bought or who spent it."
    }
   ],
   "sources": "City audits posted on tfid.org (Audits and ACFR): 2019 Financial Statements p53; 2020 p53; 2021 p53; 2022 pp53, 79; 2023 pp55, 81; 2024 pp55, 81; 2025 Annual Comprehensive Financial Report pp58, 86. Financial Policies (eff. 10-1-13) pp11-12. [City website, saved 2026-11-08]",
   "exhibits": [],
   "requests": [],
   "level_label": "City code, policy or contract; possibly state law",
   "level_score": 5,
   "level_keys": "city state",
   "outstanding": 1,
   "complete_rank": 199
  }
 ],
 "exhibits": [
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-A01",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-a01/",
   "group": "A",
   "description": "2022-12-08 Mayor letter lifting City Manager sell-back limit, with HR emails",
   "date": "2022-12-08",
   "source": "PRR #4869",
   "findings": [
    "E-01",
    "E-07"
   ],
   "pages": "all (5)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "d51b2904364358d03e1240dc9bc14ef34534cfa3562e425ff28c2c38075f710e",
   "orig_sha": "5ed35e4f13acd69243418a6c9cae4ad53b5a4ee5b96d57abe7f2fb253db8f501",
   "orig_shas": [
    "5ed35e4f13acd69243418a6c9cae4ad53b5a4ee5b96d57abe7f2fb253db8f501"
   ],
   "size": 1767770,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-A01.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-A01 - 2022-12-08 Mayor letter lifting City Manager sell-back limit, with HR emails.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 5,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4869",
    "subject": "CM contract versions + handbook exceptions",
    "filed": "2026-09",
    "outcome": "Produced 2020/2024 agreements, letters; no 2015 agreement; no Council exception directives",
    "findings": [
     "E-11"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4869"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-A02",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-a02/",
   "group": "A",
   "description": "City Manager payroll register - vacation sell-back pages (excerpt)",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #4814",
   "findings": [
    "E-01",
    "E-02"
   ],
   "pages": "pp 1,10,18,26,35,39,45,52,61,70,78,86",
   "notes": "Excerpt: page 1 and register pages 10, 18, 26, 35, 39, 45, 52, 61, 70, 78, 86 (sell-back lines, code VS). Vacation-used lines for each 12-month look-back are in the full register (A03).",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "753377f0f052b053c9b3659c823bdfdbdacaadd4302970031d96320f1d2d5690",
   "orig_sha": "6c44741c0f2193d74ff118d0c1d76afa8b3dbeaf6ed36037443b0493ec9226ba",
   "orig_shas": [
    "6c44741c0f2193d74ff118d0c1d76afa8b3dbeaf6ed36037443b0493ec9226ba"
   ],
   "size": 5946136,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-A02.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-A02 - City Manager payroll register - vacation sell-back pages (excerpt).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Pages extracted: pp 1,10,18,26,35,39,45,52,61,70,78,86",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 12,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4814",
    "subject": "Finance payment summaries FY16-present",
    "filed": "2026-09",
    "outcome": "Payroll registers; \"no FY subtotal\"; AP to come separately",
    "findings": [
     "E-14"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4814"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-A03",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-a03/",
   "group": "A",
   "description": "City Manager payroll register detail, Oct 2015 - May 2026 (full)",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #4814",
   "findings": [
    "E-01",
    "E-02",
    "E-03",
    "E-04",
    "E-09",
    "E-24"
   ],
   "pages": "all (91)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "e8725657031ec34c4518894f2a7beaf61419187ab0089b0a95e12b5c55b5886c",
   "orig_sha": "6c44741c0f2193d74ff118d0c1d76afa8b3dbeaf6ed36037443b0493ec9226ba",
   "orig_shas": [
    "6c44741c0f2193d74ff118d0c1d76afa8b3dbeaf6ed36037443b0493ec9226ba"
   ],
   "size": 44355645,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-A03.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-A03 - City Manager payroll register detail, Oct 2015 - May 2026 (full).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "too_big": true,
   "parts": [
    {
     "name": "EX-A03-part1.pdf",
     "pages": "1-49",
     "size": 23897245,
     "sha": "43583b65063c739c38aed6546b3696a6b96dad35736cc62cd6ca51f70b6cc974",
     "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-A03-part1.pdf",
     "download_name": "EX-A03 - City Manager payroll register detail, Oct 2015 - May 2026 (full) (part 1 of 2).pdf"
    },
    {
     "name": "EX-A03-part2.pdf",
     "pages": "50-91",
     "size": 20461685,
     "sha": "eba9ece50fec1dcdb6b1ff8ea24411eac172dd92518f94b3617adcb79b4d1591",
     "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-A03-part2.pdf",
     "download_name": "EX-A03 - City Manager payroll register detail, Oct 2015 - May 2026 (full) (part 2 of 2).pdf"
    }
   ],
   "page_count": 91,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4814",
    "subject": "Finance payment summaries FY16-present",
    "filed": "2026-09",
    "outcome": "Payroll registers; \"no FY subtotal\"; AP to come separately",
    "findings": [
     "E-14"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4814"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-A04",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-a04/",
   "group": "A",
   "description": "City Manager compensation documents (HR compilation)",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #4869",
   "findings": [
    "E-03"
   ],
   "pages": "all (3)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "1051db1ea510a1dc983cb35694c63de3f1cbff42ca95566d931cb74b0ebdb0bd",
   "orig_sha": "f3dc9b1e35dc24c44a8511c5f74c38ce44746b2b1e0191be34c4092341ed25b7",
   "orig_shas": [
    "f3dc9b1e35dc24c44a8511c5f74c38ce44746b2b1e0191be34c4092341ed25b7"
   ],
   "size": 817128,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-A04.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-A04 - City Manager compensation documents (HR compilation).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 3,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4869",
    "subject": "CM contract versions + handbook exceptions",
    "filed": "2026-09",
    "outcome": "Produced 2020/2024 agreements, letters; no 2015 agreement; no Council exception directives",
    "findings": [
     "E-11"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4869"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-A05",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-a05/",
   "group": "A",
   "description": "2020-12 Compensation email (Mayor/HR) for 2021 raise",
   "date": "2020-12",
   "source": "PRR #4869",
   "findings": [
    "E-02",
    "E-03",
    "E-05"
   ],
   "pages": "all (2)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "87538b5c4748cb400fed92d3cac585e5207db4c76f7f0176629f1de44ef2d222",
   "orig_sha": "d960490ce0a2fd4974aaf8fb52fdd3bab1bd03b9a3efa0c9b749bc1e7610aaf9",
   "orig_shas": [
    "d960490ce0a2fd4974aaf8fb52fdd3bab1bd03b9a3efa0c9b749bc1e7610aaf9"
   ],
   "size": 523815,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-A05.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-A05 - 2020-12 Compensation email (Mayor-HR) for 2021 raise.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay",
    "open-meetings"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 2,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4869",
    "subject": "CM contract versions + handbook exceptions",
    "filed": "2026-09",
    "outcome": "Produced 2020/2024 agreements, letters; no 2015 agreement; no Council exception directives",
    "findings": [
     "E-11"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4869"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-A06",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-a06/",
   "group": "A",
   "description": "2021 City Manager compensation (Oct 2021 raise and one-time 5% PERSI contribution)",
   "date": "2021-10",
   "source": "PRR #4869",
   "findings": [
    "E-03",
    "E-04"
   ],
   "pages": "all (2)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "3359c25df4fc3afd44847d1a6067a1b854373404267ba52de9ea17d91e62f762",
   "orig_sha": "808a663febccdc62910c05d61f3c7703b17df4c6a7a0124de2a4e8ed064c373a",
   "orig_shas": [
    "808a663febccdc62910c05d61f3c7703b17df4c6a7a0124de2a4e8ed064c373a"
   ],
   "size": 584368,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-A06.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-A06 - 2021 City Manager compensation (Oct 2021 raise and 5% deferred comp).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 2,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4869",
    "subject": "CM contract versions + handbook exceptions",
    "filed": "2026-09",
    "outcome": "Produced 2020/2024 agreements, letters; no 2015 agreement; no Council exception directives",
    "findings": [
     "E-11"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4869"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-A07",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-a07/",
   "group": "A",
   "description": "Compensation memo, fiscal year 2023",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #4869",
   "findings": [
    "E-03"
   ],
   "pages": "all (1)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "1c794ac70b03721ad647f27d9101633ee0adbdfad4b4a44067af1ac42fdcb64b",
   "orig_sha": "d5f5d354a811d8422904b8ad3935283fb7c73b4e1180c7359f47103bb17867a1",
   "orig_shas": [
    "d5f5d354a811d8422904b8ad3935283fb7c73b4e1180c7359f47103bb17867a1"
   ],
   "size": 470531,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-A07.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-A07 - Compensation memo, fiscal year 2023.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 1,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4869",
    "subject": "CM contract versions + handbook exceptions",
    "filed": "2026-09",
    "outcome": "Produced 2020/2024 agreements, letters; no 2015 agreement; no Council exception directives",
    "findings": [
     "E-11"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4869"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-A08",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-a08/",
   "group": "A",
   "description": "2023-2024 compensation direction (10% deferred comp)",
   "date": "2023-12",
   "source": "PRR #4869",
   "findings": [
    "E-03",
    "E-04",
    "E-05",
    "E-19"
   ],
   "pages": "all (2)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "36c328fa7aa53b93ac7eeb885256c4936667c5176858f73f3ff2be045e414a62",
   "orig_sha": "d92f6636190d14fa96a7e3e1bc74b7df5c53d2d87667156dd14f2db2c7579c55",
   "orig_shas": [
    "d92f6636190d14fa96a7e3e1bc74b7df5c53d2d87667156dd14f2db2c7579c55"
   ],
   "size": 802047,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-A08.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-A08 - 2023-2024 compensation direction (10% deferred comp).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay",
    "federal",
    "open-meetings"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "391b8b72b77d7406908cb6f681d0abdd041fad902a87137a3bfd69ba155e8aa6",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Personal email addresses, phone numbers and home or mailing addresses redacted (page 2); names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 2,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4869",
    "subject": "CM contract versions + handbook exceptions",
    "filed": "2026-09",
    "outcome": "Produced 2020/2024 agreements, letters; no 2015 agreement; no Council exception directives",
    "findings": [
     "E-11"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4869"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-A09",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-a09/",
   "group": "A",
   "description": "2025 compensation letter signed by the Mayor",
   "date": "2025-09",
   "source": "PRR #4869",
   "findings": [
    "E-03",
    "E-07"
   ],
   "pages": "all (1)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "a9a8bc62f096f62b87dea53266addff341e4d624a436baeb5ab11c6b799e3057",
   "orig_sha": "61339827edc0842e1eafeb8b775c51f3715272333df11fc372956c7f9e128ec9",
   "orig_shas": [
    "61339827edc0842e1eafeb8b775c51f3715272333df11fc372956c7f9e128ec9"
   ],
   "size": 428462,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-A09.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-A09 - 2025 compensation letter signed by the Mayor.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 1,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4869",
    "subject": "CM contract versions + handbook exceptions",
    "filed": "2026-09",
    "outcome": "Produced 2020/2024 agreements, letters; no 2015 agreement; no Council exception directives",
    "findings": [
     "E-11"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4869"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-A10",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-a10/",
   "group": "A",
   "description": "FY 2025-26 salary adjustment",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #4869",
   "findings": [
    "E-03"
   ],
   "pages": "all (1)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "039385f10bdbc08b6b3190be713523540f723f50cb558b5dca7e1aa3c0208204",
   "orig_sha": "3b0da6ccd49dd7d3f930de395851d06ee96470133e82238a5c341a79813e5b19",
   "orig_shas": [
    "3b0da6ccd49dd7d3f930de395851d06ee96470133e82238a5c341a79813e5b19"
   ],
   "size": 429081,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-A10.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-A10 - FY 2025-26 salary adjustment.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 1,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4869",
    "subject": "CM contract versions + handbook exceptions",
    "filed": "2026-09",
    "outcome": "Produced 2020/2024 agreements, letters; no 2015 agreement; no Council exception directives",
    "findings": [
     "E-11"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4869"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-A11",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-a11/",
   "group": "A",
   "description": "City Manager Service Agreement, April 2020",
   "date": "2020-04-20",
   "source": "PRR #4869",
   "findings": [
    "E-03",
    "E-04",
    "E-24"
   ],
   "pages": "all (5)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "6848c939be165d9fb1b8e51212558e0c488b3af48ba086487c3724996780475c",
   "orig_sha": "c283f712d999820613810c2b26602a7f09d1eeacfe6ddcdbc2109153b5cf5478",
   "orig_shas": [
    "c283f712d999820613810c2b26602a7f09d1eeacfe6ddcdbc2109153b5cf5478"
   ],
   "size": 3170415,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-A11.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-A11 - City Manager Service Agreement, April 2020.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 5,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4869",
    "subject": "CM contract versions + handbook exceptions",
    "filed": "2026-09",
    "outcome": "Produced 2020/2024 agreements, letters; no 2015 agreement; no Council exception directives",
    "findings": [
     "E-11"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4869"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-A12",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-a12/",
   "group": "A",
   "description": "City Manager Service Agreement, 2024 (signed)",
   "date": "2024-12-09",
   "source": "PRR #4869",
   "findings": [
    "E-01",
    "E-07",
    "E-24"
   ],
   "pages": "all (5)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "a0b0bebf3e4357357afa1b7743a54e0e6baae8dd462d6d369fd6f3f45b8a2b20",
   "orig_sha": "f58298350dfb1af12b94470cd9c3f635954b93b755197ac6d384402f593062dc",
   "orig_shas": [
    "f58298350dfb1af12b94470cd9c3f635954b93b755197ac6d384402f593062dc"
   ],
   "size": 3333543,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-A12.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-A12 - City Manager Service Agreement, 2024 (signed).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 5,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4869",
    "subject": "CM contract versions + handbook exceptions",
    "filed": "2026-09",
    "outcome": "Produced 2020/2024 agreements, letters; no 2015 agreement; no Council exception directives",
    "findings": [
     "E-11"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4869"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-A13",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-a13/",
   "group": "A",
   "description": "Amendment to the Agreement with the City Manager",
   "date": "2020-04-20",
   "source": "PRR #4869",
   "findings": [
    "E-03",
    "E-07"
   ],
   "pages": "all (2)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "3d2db560814c5521e7490b767df000c740c3d243819853b31aba5251e0142c02",
   "orig_sha": "cbf6bc4027003613387626994ad361e304023f552e5359c4e3f78eab10b3edd5",
   "orig_shas": [
    "cbf6bc4027003613387626994ad361e304023f552e5359c4e3f78eab10b3edd5"
   ],
   "size": 954429,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-A13.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-A13 - Amendment to the Agreement with the City Manager.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 2,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4869",
    "subject": "CM contract versions + handbook exceptions",
    "filed": "2026-09",
    "outcome": "Produced 2020/2024 agreements, letters; no 2015 agreement; no Council exception directives",
    "findings": [
     "E-11"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4869"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-A14",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-a14/",
   "group": "A",
   "description": "City Manager deferred compensation report 1",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #4869",
   "findings": [
    "E-04",
    "E-19"
   ],
   "pages": "all (1)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "2e1ecf3891e3e781dbec4eee90014dc84d06bea47e2fcb72b52cc9339cdb9585",
   "orig_sha": "545ccf41f3204dfcf38a1504b8f77a3a3b3666e0f1af0f585622c5955754b562",
   "orig_shas": [
    "545ccf41f3204dfcf38a1504b8f77a3a3b3666e0f1af0f585622c5955754b562"
   ],
   "size": 270094,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-A14.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-A14 - City Manager deferred compensation report 1.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay",
    "federal"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 1,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4869",
    "subject": "CM contract versions + handbook exceptions",
    "filed": "2026-09",
    "outcome": "Produced 2020/2024 agreements, letters; no 2015 agreement; no Council exception directives",
    "findings": [
     "E-11"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4869"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-A15",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-a15/",
   "group": "A",
   "description": "City Manager deferred compensation report 2",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #4869",
   "findings": [
    "E-04",
    "E-19"
   ],
   "pages": "all (1)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "fb18c8ce0a0efd55e4bd0505b4022f29bbd71929f203d4dfa1f9df2245e331ed",
   "orig_sha": "8ff844d45d88b5566c848bfc7157580bfe7d313c7d46abcf150cab77c17cfbad",
   "orig_shas": [
    "8ff844d45d88b5566c848bfc7157580bfe7d313c7d46abcf150cab77c17cfbad"
   ],
   "size": 217495,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-A15.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-A15 - City Manager deferred compensation report 2.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay",
    "federal"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 1,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4869",
    "subject": "CM contract versions + handbook exceptions",
    "filed": "2026-09",
    "outcome": "Produced 2020/2024 agreements, letters; no 2015 agreement; no Council exception directives",
    "findings": [
     "E-11"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4869"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-A16",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-a16/",
   "group": "A",
   "description": "City Manager Employee Retention Program agreement",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #4869",
   "findings": [
    "E-09"
   ],
   "pages": "all (3)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "6b74398e8503ae2da3884fbe57a3e386d12832850ac2c82c195c384cc752ac27",
   "orig_sha": "ea2396a9b75e1d1ea88cf7e1f3254bb19eacb9758032420a44a203ab5ddb4a35",
   "orig_shas": [
    "ea2396a9b75e1d1ea88cf7e1f3254bb19eacb9758032420a44a203ab5ddb4a35"
   ],
   "size": 915651,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-A16.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-A16 - City Manager Employee Retention Program agreement.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 3,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4869",
    "subject": "CM contract versions + handbook exceptions",
    "filed": "2026-09",
    "outcome": "Produced 2020/2024 agreements, letters; no 2015 agreement; no Council exception directives",
    "findings": [
     "E-11"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4869"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-A17",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-a17/",
   "group": "A",
   "description": "City Manager 2021 retention payout",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #4869",
   "findings": [
    "E-09"
   ],
   "pages": "all (1)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "1b99889c1b733df64bf2355b2486af05969246b726674bdd4a02119a0a7b8284",
   "orig_sha": "16b3f09ec26dcced537f513d78faf544755553f9f0c1719ea16e6924374a5849",
   "orig_shas": [
    "16b3f09ec26dcced537f513d78faf544755553f9f0c1719ea16e6924374a5849"
   ],
   "size": 305355,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-A17.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-A17 - City Manager 2021 retention payout.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 1,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4869",
    "subject": "CM contract versions + handbook exceptions",
    "filed": "2026-09",
    "outcome": "Produced 2020/2024 agreements, letters; no 2015 agreement; no Council exception directives",
    "findings": [
     "E-11"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4869"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-A18",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-a18/",
   "group": "A",
   "description": "Deputy City Manager $2,500 stipend (Apr 2026 email and form)",
   "date": "2026-04-17",
   "source": "PRR #4729",
   "findings": [
    "E-08"
   ],
   "pages": "all (1)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "ac4b4cabe6cc9578106fae64e811ead4a0c13232a868d2dfd76c5c8e1e98a7aa",
   "orig_sha": "1e9313c5341d16f6118fc6db030ce9485959d322c4dcc0891af2aeb23397feb1",
   "orig_shas": [
    "1e9313c5341d16f6118fc6db030ce9485959d322c4dcc0891af2aeb23397feb1"
   ],
   "size": 446865,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-A18.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-A18 - Deputy City Manager $2,500 stipend (Apr 2026 email and form).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 1,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4729",
    "subject": "ELT compensation records FY21-FY26",
    "filed": "2026-08 (approx.)",
    "outcome": "Produced HR documents",
    "findings": [
     "E-01",
     "E-02",
     "E-03",
     "E-04",
     "E-05",
     "E-06",
     "E-07",
     "E-08",
     "E-09"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4729"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-A19",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-a19/",
   "group": "A",
   "description": "Deputy City Manager payroll register - stipend page (excerpt)",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #4814",
   "findings": [
    "E-08"
   ],
   "pages": "pp 1,88",
   "notes": "Excerpt: page 1 and page 88. Full register is A20.",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "e47d035d66ee1d2979f18ada1ebe6036f1bfc61724eb86c2cba28197a8fdbfd2",
   "orig_sha": "fbcdd4f314148c9588b001d05d1786eaa6b6416602b33f49d450d45c5a2107ba",
   "orig_shas": [
    "fbcdd4f314148c9588b001d05d1786eaa6b6416602b33f49d450d45c5a2107ba"
   ],
   "size": 988993,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-A19.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-A19 - Deputy City Manager payroll register - stipend page (excerpt).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Pages extracted: pp 1,88",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 2,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4814",
    "subject": "Finance payment summaries FY16-present",
    "filed": "2026-09",
    "outcome": "Payroll registers; \"no FY subtotal\"; AP to come separately",
    "findings": [
     "E-14"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4814"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-A20",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-a20/",
   "group": "A",
   "description": "Deputy City Manager (Scott) payroll register detail, Oct 2015 - May 2026 (full)",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #4814",
   "findings": [
    "E-08",
    "E-09",
    "E-23",
    "E-24"
   ],
   "pages": "all (89)",
   "notes": "Sell-backs on pp50, 60, 67, 75, 84; two in fiscal year 2024 (pp67, 75).",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "385276483b1e22990badde5ab1c24cd70ad22a4529a6e47c6693c0d6936d144f",
   "orig_sha": "fbcdd4f314148c9588b001d05d1786eaa6b6416602b33f49d450d45c5a2107ba",
   "orig_shas": [
    "fbcdd4f314148c9588b001d05d1786eaa6b6416602b33f49d450d45c5a2107ba"
   ],
   "size": 43555031,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-A20.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-A20 - Deputy City Manager (Scott) payroll register detail, Oct 2015 - May 2026 (full).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "too_big": true,
   "parts": [
    {
     "name": "EX-A20-part1.pdf",
     "pages": "1-49",
     "size": 23935067,
     "sha": "df6dd880ffde9b6fc97eee5fdc0747a58f03d9bda18ef0775bc044de96336a5e",
     "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-A20-part1.pdf",
     "download_name": "EX-A20 - Deputy City Manager (Scott) payroll register detail, Oct 2015 - May 2026 (full) (part 1 of 2).pdf"
    },
    {
     "name": "EX-A20-part2.pdf",
     "pages": "50-89",
     "size": 19623181,
     "sha": "0dd7ea6406a783b27993068143826ab853418d36fcfedf37f1cc80c446b514a9",
     "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-A20-part2.pdf",
     "download_name": "EX-A20 - Deputy City Manager (Scott) payroll register detail, Oct 2015 - May 2026 (full) (part 2 of 2).pdf"
    }
   ],
   "page_count": 89,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4814",
    "subject": "Finance payment summaries FY16-present",
    "filed": "2026-09",
    "outcome": "Payroll registers; \"no FY subtotal\"; AP to come separately",
    "findings": [
     "E-14"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4814"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-A21",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-a21/",
   "group": "A",
   "description": "Executive base and additional pay summary",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #4729",
   "findings": [
    "E-03",
    "E-09",
    "E-01",
    "E-28"
   ],
   "pages": "all (1)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "49bd4457a49e1bc0ff2f7dd5d0aec0a9490647b0e827e1fd364755d920edcb2c",
   "orig_sha": "99535b16700563b36ae8fdc94ce857f4310473296bea420ebffb31c88b4003bd",
   "orig_shas": [
    "99535b16700563b36ae8fdc94ce857f4310473296bea420ebffb31c88b4003bd"
   ],
   "size": 353119,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-A21.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-A21 - Executive base and additional pay summary.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay",
    "workplace"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 1,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4729",
    "subject": "ELT compensation records FY21-FY26",
    "filed": "2026-08 (approx.)",
    "outcome": "Produced HR documents",
    "findings": [
     "E-01",
     "E-02",
     "E-03",
     "E-04",
     "E-05",
     "E-06",
     "E-07",
     "E-08",
     "E-09"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4729"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-A22",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-a22/",
   "group": "A",
   "description": "Executive retention agreements - Deputy City Managers, CFO, HR Director",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #4729",
   "findings": [
    "E-09"
   ],
   "pages": "all (2); all (3); all (2); all (3)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "a50c3503bdcefa438a94a94c46203e8dc54682e94f7527e8acb07cc053deb03b",
   "orig_sha": "29969d9bc041efe6ba74509fd96da8428f3e4d4bcfc4f09728dfb69b5fa25f00\n126c51138898390cf3f6e86097a42b11a9da844b8207bcd2f2549e2cce52ff34\na6be9c12193c81b4ab30c8c6445a8d70d1fd3294b9df00aeb33e4cfa65796654\n8dc8714055a926636e79272e7750d5666548c680ac6c9bff1b4292546ee5c4d4",
   "orig_shas": [
    "29969d9bc041efe6ba74509fd96da8428f3e4d4bcfc4f09728dfb69b5fa25f00",
    "126c51138898390cf3f6e86097a42b11a9da844b8207bcd2f2549e2cce52ff34",
    "a6be9c12193c81b4ab30c8c6445a8d70d1fd3294b9df00aeb33e4cfa65796654",
    "8dc8714055a926636e79272e7750d5666548c680ac6c9bff1b4292546ee5c4d4"
   ],
   "size": 3482746,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-A22.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-A22 - Executive retention agreements - Deputy City Managers, CFO, HR Director.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Combined from 4 files as released",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 10,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4729",
    "subject": "ELT compensation records FY21-FY26",
    "filed": "2026-08 (approx.)",
    "outcome": "Produced HR documents",
    "findings": [
     "E-01",
     "E-02",
     "E-03",
     "E-04",
     "E-05",
     "E-06",
     "E-07",
     "E-08",
     "E-09"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4729"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-A23",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-a23/",
   "group": "A",
   "description": "Executive retention payouts 2021-2022",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #4729",
   "findings": [
    "E-09"
   ],
   "pages": "all (1); all (1); all (1); all (1); all (1); all (1); all (1); all (1); all (1)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "c420f6b6e708827fa2173227cfebc066ab7fee46a81217986b57a8fe11aa1cd3",
   "orig_sha": "fbaeacb340de3c402593b49312a80730d006c0557c4daf258674ac1ee0b02a8d\n790fafa6cf8138a96c7baead1457d25439bbb6f498c02ba6cb82e0ad0543c58a\nf55eec6cef2c681b2047a16c935ca1aeeb65a57b92f49dc6f1b6511a4ddd9a87\n2d30e2eca433abe87b8cf03df9af1d41c2c5cac17ae533cf6bd0d7e904e7f8a4\n66de504468f3ca4983aafd1fd47a24987c5e90d2207b7a7a9fc8a354efb21cb3\n5a3a9abd66ea1f16b58c8431fea8029c330b151844362951aca2a5eaeed3f50c\ncaf07f8f5a28959fedea92dda97eaba8d25aaa3e8b4bbc10f1ca37aa758aa1fa\nc45ce03461e1e24ba24b199b963d4c565bebf17b5f1fc8474f96b79a408d10fc\n479bdd66509a98793455bcaf940937ce78123f882fbfea5000a441a30c0957d0",
   "orig_shas": [
    "fbaeacb340de3c402593b49312a80730d006c0557c4daf258674ac1ee0b02a8d",
    "790fafa6cf8138a96c7baead1457d25439bbb6f498c02ba6cb82e0ad0543c58a",
    "f55eec6cef2c681b2047a16c935ca1aeeb65a57b92f49dc6f1b6511a4ddd9a87",
    "2d30e2eca433abe87b8cf03df9af1d41c2c5cac17ae533cf6bd0d7e904e7f8a4",
    "66de504468f3ca4983aafd1fd47a24987c5e90d2207b7a7a9fc8a354efb21cb3",
    "5a3a9abd66ea1f16b58c8431fea8029c330b151844362951aca2a5eaeed3f50c",
    "caf07f8f5a28959fedea92dda97eaba8d25aaa3e8b4bbc10f1ca37aa758aa1fa",
    "c45ce03461e1e24ba24b199b963d4c565bebf17b5f1fc8474f96b79a408d10fc",
    "479bdd66509a98793455bcaf940937ce78123f882fbfea5000a441a30c0957d0"
   ],
   "size": 2745194,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-A23.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-A23 - Executive retention payouts 2021-2022.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Combined from 9 files as released",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 9,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4729",
    "subject": "ELT compensation records FY21-FY26",
    "filed": "2026-08 (approx.)",
    "outcome": "Produced HR documents",
    "findings": [
     "E-01",
     "E-02",
     "E-03",
     "E-04",
     "E-05",
     "E-06",
     "E-07",
     "E-08",
     "E-09"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4729"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-A24",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-a24/",
   "group": "A",
   "description": "Executive status changes and offer letters 2020-2025",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #4729",
   "findings": [
    "E-24",
    "E-26",
    "E-27",
    "E-28"
   ],
   "pages": "all (2); all (1); all (8); all (1); all (7); all (2); all (7); all (9); all (7)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "51e515b2c7e7ebf265627bced20f7e93c97f04bfdb6d810ce60cd87dc1ceca4a",
   "orig_sha": "93173a04b5d6b3a0475cf3c381930b37be9a74328288df0f9c299b7f071b8ccc\n429fc07608601643bcf0ae2ad17cbc7082e4e7820522f263761a3d8dde70a573\nc4dc420cb38da1f94c84c500309e905643c4ff6e90f2a96e3d84d227d6f62cfc\nf49982b14089731a267f47e7d0bb9b4852fefdd24bfc79f96ab2d5a3bbf561a8\ndccfb8c0ad2f9e9fed72deafd16722131716ec6c4d33c4361e1616e1ebec6f4e\n9c0690284ab83d8368f7d7c8d5994ddddd8bdd5ec3156d6f453a9b7f6b94d849\n08e8d305f55c3ba98cbfcfdf4c29cbd30959ce68334ec7c208c39d742ce91d76\nfad9106a26af79d2f5defcbc8db2f98186f2938735faa92ba9a0c15cc17777ba\n5af3877e0ac9fab44bc4888cf87e7d756e9e842caa89c1cc5a6a885912a8167d",
   "orig_shas": [
    "93173a04b5d6b3a0475cf3c381930b37be9a74328288df0f9c299b7f071b8ccc",
    "429fc07608601643bcf0ae2ad17cbc7082e4e7820522f263761a3d8dde70a573",
    "c4dc420cb38da1f94c84c500309e905643c4ff6e90f2a96e3d84d227d6f62cfc",
    "f49982b14089731a267f47e7d0bb9b4852fefdd24bfc79f96ab2d5a3bbf561a8",
    "dccfb8c0ad2f9e9fed72deafd16722131716ec6c4d33c4361e1616e1ebec6f4e",
    "9c0690284ab83d8368f7d7c8d5994ddddd8bdd5ec3156d6f453a9b7f6b94d849",
    "08e8d305f55c3ba98cbfcfdf4c29cbd30959ce68334ec7c208c39d742ce91d76",
    "fad9106a26af79d2f5defcbc8db2f98186f2938735faa92ba9a0c15cc17777ba",
    "5af3877e0ac9fab44bc4888cf87e7d756e9e842caa89c1cc5a6a885912a8167d"
   ],
   "size": 17487789,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-A24.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-A24 - Executive status changes and offer letters 2020-2025.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay",
    "workplace"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "e1935bb4475e4cb7f306e711306db2bb7f0043a6f899221c39cdca1ed3e99d9d",
   "changes": [
    "Combined from 9 files as released",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Personal email addresses, phone numbers and home or mailing addresses redacted (pages 1, 12, 20); names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 44,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4729",
    "subject": "ELT compensation records FY21-FY26",
    "filed": "2026-08 (approx.)",
    "outcome": "Produced HR documents",
    "findings": [
     "E-01",
     "E-02",
     "E-03",
     "E-04",
     "E-05",
     "E-06",
     "E-07",
     "E-08",
     "E-09"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4729"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-A25",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-a25/",
   "group": "A",
   "description": "Year-to-date earnings report, Jun 1 - Sep 11, 2026",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #4814",
   "findings": [],
   "pages": "all (3)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "e130c41d90817a1fd9a2a824de82f9028a31d301815f7100940e327cc6c05b98",
   "orig_sha": "fba8b1100a116825ceaaed8fa5ee078c07a03221af0fe9cd60c321b4434a99ac",
   "orig_shas": [
    "fba8b1100a116825ceaaed8fa5ee078c07a03221af0fe9cd60c321b4434a99ac"
   ],
   "size": 1423486,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-A25.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-A25 - Year-to-date earnings report, Jun 1 - Sep 11, 2026.pdf",
   "topics": [],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 3,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4814",
    "subject": "Finance payment summaries FY16-present",
    "filed": "2026-09",
    "outcome": "Payroll registers; \"no FY subtotal\"; AP to come separately",
    "findings": [
     "E-14"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4814"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-A26",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-a26/",
   "group": "A",
   "description": "History of hourly rates (spreadsheet)",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #4729",
   "findings": [
    "E-03",
    "E-26",
    "E-27",
    "E-28"
   ],
   "pages": "all",
   "notes": "Spreadsheet; workbook author properties cleared.",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "a42f8fd5a507e51d444f693981fb59960ced13e482aa2b5f9957b11209e7988d",
   "orig_sha": "1ec1c6cac77371fbc4615b6c6da13bb378f21616c4ec191bfc5531595b471bce",
   "orig_shas": [
    "1ec1c6cac77371fbc4615b6c6da13bb378f21616c4ec191bfc5531595b471bce"
   ],
   "size": 6614,
   "ext": ".xlsx",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-A26.xlsx",
   "download_name": "EX-A26 - History of hourly rates (spreadsheet).xlsx",
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay",
    "workplace"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4729",
    "subject": "ELT compensation records FY21-FY26",
    "filed": "2026-08 (approx.)",
    "outcome": "Produced HR documents",
    "findings": [
     "E-01",
     "E-02",
     "E-03",
     "E-04",
     "E-05",
     "E-06",
     "E-07",
     "E-08",
     "E-09"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4729"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-A27",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-a27/",
   "group": "A",
   "description": "2021-12-10 City Manager email setting Deputy City Manager salaries as variance from CM pay",
   "date": "2021-12-10",
   "source": "PRR #4729",
   "findings": [
    "E-27"
   ],
   "pages": "all (1)",
   "notes": "Attachment to Humble status-change record (effective 12/20/2021).",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "e0458a78a08817921535351d629bbf037300e047d4852643e2dc7e4e0396e650",
   "orig_sha": "413ae1e0362c65cd7d1288dd2621060b9946a5673a718a5ac4129b5370323875",
   "orig_shas": [
    "413ae1e0362c65cd7d1288dd2621060b9946a5673a718a5ac4129b5370323875"
   ],
   "size": 296813,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-A27.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-A27 - 2021-12-10 City Manager email setting Deputy City Manager salaries as variance from CM pay.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "workplace"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 1,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4729",
    "subject": "ELT compensation records FY21-FY26",
    "filed": "2026-08 (approx.)",
    "outcome": "Produced HR documents",
    "findings": [
     "E-01",
     "E-02",
     "E-03",
     "E-04",
     "E-05",
     "E-06",
     "E-07",
     "E-08",
     "E-09"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4729"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-A28",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-a28/",
   "group": "A",
   "description": "2023-10-02 City Manager letter installing Acting HR Director (grade 17, $4,368 biweekly)",
   "date": "2023-10-02",
   "source": "PRR #4729",
   "findings": [
    "E-26"
   ],
   "pages": "all (1)",
   "notes": "Attachment to the 10/8/2023 status change; matches the pay on EX-A24 pp29-37.",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "fe5c552709c94d451ff18a2cd4098b65877844db77aa2c4204cbdbf8ed987782",
   "orig_sha": "68b1de31c7cb431838dd3667785d6ebeb0390a43bc102cb8dc81bb86f4e15c25",
   "orig_shas": [
    "68b1de31c7cb431838dd3667785d6ebeb0390a43bc102cb8dc81bb86f4e15c25"
   ],
   "size": 605814,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-A28.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-A28 - 2023-10-02 City Manager letter installing Acting HR Director (grade 17, $4,368 biweekly).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "workplace"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 1,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4729",
    "subject": "ELT compensation records FY21-FY26",
    "filed": "2026-08 (approx.)",
    "outcome": "Produced HR documents",
    "findings": [
     "E-01",
     "E-02",
     "E-03",
     "E-04",
     "E-05",
     "E-06",
     "E-07",
     "E-08",
     "E-09"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4729"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-A29",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-a29/",
   "group": "A",
   "description": "2023-12-01 City Manager promotional letter - HR Director (five years of service credited)",
   "date": "2023-12-01",
   "source": "PRR #4729",
   "findings": [
    "E-26"
   ],
   "pages": "all (1)",
   "notes": "States Council confirmation scheduled Dec 4, 2023 (see EX-B39).",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "a3258d1d549ec69b7285aaaa2e83e9f1cf8a9f3134cdb9438e429045ef26bd26",
   "orig_sha": "07dddce06542f78751404b898dad05fdc178d75cf559e6a5dacf6eaf75b50162",
   "orig_shas": [
    "07dddce06542f78751404b898dad05fdc178d75cf559e6a5dacf6eaf75b50162"
   ],
   "size": 575263,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-A29.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-A29 - 2023-12-01 City Manager promotional letter - HR Director (five years of service credited).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "workplace"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 1,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4729",
    "subject": "ELT compensation records FY21-FY26",
    "filed": "2026-08 (approx.)",
    "outcome": "Produced HR documents",
    "findings": [
     "E-01",
     "E-02",
     "E-03",
     "E-04",
     "E-05",
     "E-06",
     "E-07",
     "E-08",
     "E-09"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4729"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-A30",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-a30/",
   "group": "A",
   "description": "Deputy City Manager vacation sell-back requests 2020-2025 (Humble, Scott)",
   "date": "2020-10-30 to 2025-10-06",
   "source": "PRR #4729",
   "findings": [
    "E-01",
    "E-02",
    "E-23"
   ],
   "pages": "all (40)",
   "notes": "Ten requests in date order, 4 pages each: action history, rules printed on the form, application, finance approval. Shows balances, hours taken the previous year, the 'use it or lose it' box (unchecked on all ten) and who approved each. From Sept 2022 the form tells Payroll to check for a sale in the current fiscal year and for vacation (pay code V) used in the last 365 days.",
   "redaction": "Employee numbers, phone numbers and signatures covered; pages rebuilt as images with no text layer",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "0e2120849a0accd8b1b4ae4f025cbd31372f4ce309a0bb9068b95e177567aa9b",
   "orig_sha": "9910bc8771d2ffdf0e930529c7ef5727f0b9ac8993c8f20447bad1ddb9e813df\n9bc8f2f4a9cfac772d5a44bbef086aed24b4376b30d5a544aeb5d59e56598f86\n365f3e1fe8e5835fa5792398a8248ae5b4f1a1a9c745cb51c36cfa257c8fca27\n507558d0bf54b8323f70f0b96d6d8eee98856fa24ceb3f4d8dd056e39a41ebcd\n248a10fb6f5af514bd03429daa30137183a6bfeea9415804084dad474c784fa2\n522d8d2362b9322091ad816b7241a5d7dc9894ee1cf7e7e68ba95b73b5510e9d\n56305e5918dda166735c566c2cfcd7bbfb7210413e7e0f29db1f119cd14e014d\na6a456ecf6e289f7231e7fb336d27835b227fae359bbe264193a24c5de66d457\n186f0a6811f3fb1f5830fb62d19f9a0508f52fa56dd81a991d4701d9065ad5a2\n9c4c39ff6183a3a926d6e687c9856266db546d729577d157ad91eb7c24448cf4",
   "orig_shas": [
    "9910bc8771d2ffdf0e930529c7ef5727f0b9ac8993c8f20447bad1ddb9e813df",
    "9bc8f2f4a9cfac772d5a44bbef086aed24b4376b30d5a544aeb5d59e56598f86",
    "365f3e1fe8e5835fa5792398a8248ae5b4f1a1a9c745cb51c36cfa257c8fca27",
    "507558d0bf54b8323f70f0b96d6d8eee98856fa24ceb3f4d8dd056e39a41ebcd",
    "248a10fb6f5af514bd03429daa30137183a6bfeea9415804084dad474c784fa2",
    "522d8d2362b9322091ad816b7241a5d7dc9894ee1cf7e7e68ba95b73b5510e9d",
    "56305e5918dda166735c566c2cfcd7bbfb7210413e7e0f29db1f119cd14e014d",
    "a6a456ecf6e289f7231e7fb336d27835b227fae359bbe264193a24c5de66d457",
    "186f0a6811f3fb1f5830fb62d19f9a0508f52fa56dd81a991d4701d9065ad5a2",
    "9c4c39ff6183a3a926d6e687c9856266db546d729577d157ad91eb7c24448cf4"
   ],
   "size": 2935776,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-A30.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-A30 - Deputy City Manager vacation sell-back requests 2020-2025 (Humble, Scott).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Combined from 10 files as released",
    "Redacted: Employee numbers, phone numbers and signatures covered; pages rebuilt as images with no text layer",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 40,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4729",
    "subject": "ELT compensation records FY21-FY26",
    "filed": "2026-08 (approx.)",
    "outcome": "Produced HR documents",
    "findings": [
     "E-01",
     "E-02",
     "E-03",
     "E-04",
     "E-05",
     "E-06",
     "E-07",
     "E-08",
     "E-09"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4729"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B01",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b01/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2014-09-02 minutes - Council creates City Manager evaluation committee (excerpt)",
   "date": "2014-09-02",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-06"
   ],
   "pages": "pp 1,14,15",
   "notes": "Excerpt: pages 1, 14-15 (Item II.10).",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "31efd29ba1adf8e9e3f728946a8c0ea542accd9caf09ede36918623467774fb9",
   "orig_sha": "927510a3dd8b766a7b607101aebf3fa51585fbb7c3583fe0a362ea470730348d",
   "orig_shas": [
    "927510a3dd8b766a7b607101aebf3fa51585fbb7c3583fe0a362ea470730348d"
   ],
   "size": 149238,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B01.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B01 - 2014-09-02 minutes - Council creates City Manager evaluation committee (excerpt).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "open-meetings"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Pages extracted: pp 1,14,15",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 3,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B02",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b02/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2015-02-02 minutes - City Manager Service Agreement approved 7-0",
   "date": "2015-02-02",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-03",
    "E-11"
   ],
   "pages": "all (9)",
   "notes": "Approval on page 8.",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "470fc2042e4c1eac6c14ea646270d0ffa2c3bc982e5ae19d5c5e8dad4051e96e",
   "orig_sha": "f0d9874505f80f477b209ba332bdafe977dcfeb875c279287f571b1f3a75e7e0",
   "orig_shas": [
    "f0d9874505f80f477b209ba332bdafe977dcfeb875c279287f571b1f3a75e7e0"
   ],
   "size": 226236,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B02.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B02 - 2015-02-02 minutes - City Manager Service Agreement approved 7-0.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay",
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 9,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B03",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b03/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2017-12-18 minutes - evaluation item added to executive session at City Manager request",
   "date": "2017-12-18",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-17"
   ],
   "pages": "all (4)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "793b8e558440a936a97d931ba09fe8908108ce67d65fc3e595cd98f7d2f7599b",
   "orig_sha": "efcd435648db845d5b61d042558315b094fcf5a7683ba9f08b03da88b1635105",
   "orig_shas": [
    "efcd435648db845d5b61d042558315b094fcf5a7683ba9f08b03da88b1635105"
   ],
   "size": 82781,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B03.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B03 - 2017-12-18 minutes - evaluation item added to executive session at City Manager request.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "open-meetings"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 4,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B04",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b04/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2018-10-22 minutes - retention program ratified",
   "date": "2018-10-22",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-09"
   ],
   "pages": "all (3)",
   "notes": "Page 3.",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "2535e9fe917296f66b526b48a8c79ee812a5b11a230025b10fdfa9d2d806c082",
   "orig_sha": "9bae38163192d08ce2e7a9cea5a1c82e6ed454b18a9acc07d3cc6194d40bd220",
   "orig_shas": [
    "9bae38163192d08ce2e7a9cea5a1c82e6ed454b18a9acc07d3cc6194d40bd220"
   ],
   "size": 105212,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B04.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B04 - 2018-10-22 minutes - retention program ratified.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 3,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B05",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b05/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2018-10-29 minutes - Resolution 2018-012 (handbook delegated to City Manager)",
   "date": "2018-10-29",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-02",
    "E-10"
   ],
   "pages": "all (3)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "27b8c6d93acf198bb03eda0b6bd22cafa4ac200d8a042128ba9a4cd47a319106",
   "orig_sha": "484af1322439b93750c2d473c57bb10e48bc53f9823e4caea1754774b98c51f8",
   "orig_shas": [
    "484af1322439b93750c2d473c57bb10e48bc53f9823e4caea1754774b98c51f8"
   ],
   "size": 105171,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B05.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B05 - 2018-10-29 minutes - Resolution 2018-012 (handbook delegated to City Manager).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 3,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B06",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b06/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2018-10-29 packet - Resolution 1897 sell-back rules and Resolution 2018-012 (excerpt)",
   "date": "2018-10-29",
   "source": "Council packet",
   "findings": [
    "E-02",
    "E-10"
   ],
   "pages": "pp 1,11,12,35,79,102",
   "notes": "Excerpt: packet pages 1, 11-12 (staff memo), 35 (Resolution 1897 sell-back text), 79 (2018 handbook sell-back text), 102 (Resolution 2018-012).",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "39ef03ab52dfab97627da9b93d514f6b5c789770f7541f17706c88cd248d1e28",
   "orig_sha": "41e38ed9ae85fc036cd148ade57ef06ed74384af7abb8a28057c2ab7ed554ce1",
   "orig_shas": [
    "41e38ed9ae85fc036cd148ade57ef06ed74384af7abb8a28057c2ab7ed554ce1"
   ],
   "size": 1145320,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B06.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B06 - 2018-10-29 packet - Resolution 1897 sell-back rules and Resolution 2018-012 (excerpt).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Pages extracted: pp 1,11,12,35,79,102",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 6,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B07",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b07/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2020-04-20 packet - City Manager agreement update (excerpt)",
   "date": "2020-04-20",
   "source": "Council packet",
   "findings": [
    "E-03"
   ],
   "pages": "pp 1,74,75,76,77,78,79,80,81",
   "notes": "Excerpt: pages 1, 74-81.",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "694c7cfafaf0b228324b72d5d0a9562393665dc1e75ebf0c807da3a17700fb2a",
   "orig_sha": "249009647a326883ddd377298eefd9379350e0df7300288c52b96ef48f714c41",
   "orig_shas": [
    "249009647a326883ddd377298eefd9379350e0df7300288c52b96ef48f714c41"
   ],
   "size": 1149126,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B07.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B07 - 2020-04-20 packet - City Manager agreement update (excerpt).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Pages extracted: pp 1,74,75,76,77,78,79,80,81",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 9,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B08",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b08/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2024-12-09 minutes - City Manager agreement amendment approved",
   "date": "2024-12-09",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-03",
    "E-04"
   ],
   "pages": "all (3)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "e27843ac2b758708a2aa8960b257662984ef810d07420a87487902883a7e609a",
   "orig_sha": "50498e2ecf3b96b322440b6d2d05658b049691217ed7d37409eb003505d4a9a0",
   "orig_shas": [
    "50498e2ecf3b96b322440b6d2d05658b049691217ed7d37409eb003505d4a9a0"
   ],
   "size": 89187,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B08.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B08 - 2024-12-09 minutes - City Manager agreement amendment approved.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 3,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B09",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b09/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2022-12-05 minutes - evaluation session, no motion on City Manager pay",
   "date": "2022-12-05",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-01",
    "E-05"
   ],
   "pages": "all (4)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "3a005bb03def9acf880c25832a9d5a8013d09b64832b16403a8b6dcd0eb404dc",
   "orig_sha": "774b4e9ecfa34840c3f7d4247cc6aca1b28769dba4493a0e819fc40430302777",
   "orig_shas": [
    "774b4e9ecfa34840c3f7d4247cc6aca1b28769dba4493a0e819fc40430302777"
   ],
   "size": 119720,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B09.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B09 - 2022-12-05 minutes - evaluation session, no motion on City Manager pay.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay",
    "open-meetings"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 4,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B10",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b10/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2022-12-12 minutes - no motion on City Manager pay or sell-back",
   "date": "2022-12-12",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-01",
    "E-05"
   ],
   "pages": "all (3)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "05a2200dd7b4820ded095a1cc3aab6a7a20d63257e81826f62287402b215cc18",
   "orig_sha": "fb9d4e2a8d48feba578e29e7be3bbdef54988b6dbcbfebecbb1ab57229aade54",
   "orig_shas": [
    "fb9d4e2a8d48feba578e29e7be3bbdef54988b6dbcbfebecbb1ab57229aade54"
   ],
   "size": 77244,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B10.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B10 - 2022-12-12 minutes - no motion on City Manager pay or sell-back.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay",
    "open-meetings"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 3,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B11",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b11/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2018-11-05 minutes - executive session under 74-206(1)(b)",
   "date": "2018-11-05",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-05"
   ],
   "pages": "all (4)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "50c818ff6a4cd283f90edf1df6f7e702cf34cc31411b52b1c29ea5976f2c34e0",
   "orig_sha": "eda1836b80b7cde5c6dcb3eb6f011e5e286acd16b0bfe28584769e84e2d713a0",
   "orig_shas": [
    "eda1836b80b7cde5c6dcb3eb6f011e5e286acd16b0bfe28584769e84e2d713a0"
   ],
   "size": 109342,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B11.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B11 - 2018-11-05 minutes - executive session under 74-206(1)(b).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "open-meetings"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 4,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B12",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b12/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2018-12-03 minutes - executive session under 74-206(1)(b)",
   "date": "2018-12-03",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-05"
   ],
   "pages": "all (5)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "7bc16440afc988ac676689c79ee6aade4185444afb486226470ee33372d101aa",
   "orig_sha": "9d9882ad38a00f9b1cadf3f714747cbd504a4f52c9d3542b8d27a505c0baf7d8",
   "orig_shas": [
    "9d9882ad38a00f9b1cadf3f714747cbd504a4f52c9d3542b8d27a505c0baf7d8"
   ],
   "size": 116818,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B12.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B12 - 2018-12-03 minutes - executive session under 74-206(1)(b).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "open-meetings"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 5,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B13",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b13/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2019-09-16 minutes - executive session under 74-206(1)(b)",
   "date": "2019-09-16",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-05"
   ],
   "pages": "all (3)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "8db06eb16ad1ddc52ac688b5772c0421d694555b4c55fb218df21970634fb3a0",
   "orig_sha": "94f3d6e1bc4c3c9bd4e8e793f2b78e3ff2ce4c041a79660871171e82f4a2347c",
   "orig_shas": [
    "94f3d6e1bc4c3c9bd4e8e793f2b78e3ff2ce4c041a79660871171e82f4a2347c"
   ],
   "size": 97070,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B13.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B13 - 2019-09-16 minutes - executive session under 74-206(1)(b).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "open-meetings"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 3,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B14",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b14/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2019-10-07 minutes - executive session under 74-206(1)(b)",
   "date": "2019-10-07",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-05"
   ],
   "pages": "all (4)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "546e54d9199b91bb8466d689dae55cc4cb50eb64c0ca5b72f1e73938407ea0e4",
   "orig_sha": "130e38e8cb2ed964d2fbe32e4c7133b7b9ffda18610e221f5cfa8d66c1690764",
   "orig_shas": [
    "130e38e8cb2ed964d2fbe32e4c7133b7b9ffda18610e221f5cfa8d66c1690764"
   ],
   "size": 129831,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B14.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B14 - 2019-10-07 minutes - executive session under 74-206(1)(b).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "open-meetings"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 4,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B15",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b15/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2019-10-28 minutes - executive session under 74-206(1)(b)",
   "date": "2019-10-28",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-05"
   ],
   "pages": "all (3)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "9b487e04b5a4be5b81a45eba1b6fbf591020a1190aceb600384db16b62f70290",
   "orig_sha": "caec487b91be0f88f267b0c2f1baa8a15c25fb4afafc82f2713c4659e465efd4",
   "orig_shas": [
    "caec487b91be0f88f267b0c2f1baa8a15c25fb4afafc82f2713c4659e465efd4"
   ],
   "size": 81653,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B15.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B15 - 2019-10-28 minutes - executive session under 74-206(1)(b).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "open-meetings"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 3,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B16",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b16/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2020-12-07 minutes - executive session under 74-206(1)(b)",
   "date": "2020-12-07",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-05"
   ],
   "pages": "all (4)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "999c09940b2c6214cb95a36980e76fa7fac18a00cadca037e0779fe436b12aa3",
   "orig_sha": "a24c16c918e62bc2c01a888586c57f86b277c9e1015453a0de337417ccf722df",
   "orig_shas": [
    "a24c16c918e62bc2c01a888586c57f86b277c9e1015453a0de337417ccf722df"
   ],
   "size": 90778,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B16.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B16 - 2020-12-07 minutes - executive session under 74-206(1)(b).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "open-meetings"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 4,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B17",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b17/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2020-12-14 minutes - executive session under 74-206(1)(b)",
   "date": "2020-12-14",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-05"
   ],
   "pages": "all (5)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "eda2d2fc28f180974ab009f585c3725eff67041d82918bacdf71962b21f5dde0",
   "orig_sha": "111a44e69079393fa8a102fd625351902956e0973ebc0407c473bf2fbb782cb8",
   "orig_shas": [
    "111a44e69079393fa8a102fd625351902956e0973ebc0407c473bf2fbb782cb8"
   ],
   "size": 87677,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B17.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B17 - 2020-12-14 minutes - executive session under 74-206(1)(b).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "open-meetings"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 5,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B18",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b18/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2020-12-21 minutes - executive session under 74-206(1)(b)",
   "date": "2020-12-21",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-05"
   ],
   "pages": "all (3)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "81b1521beab2935bcaff12cb3f2d3a947b45827dc456b57fb2368496ace21416",
   "orig_sha": "4420b2d89923eb6c209fbeb6ad685f244cdb640e97adaf2f6a9a876d3b209e36",
   "orig_shas": [
    "4420b2d89923eb6c209fbeb6ad685f244cdb640e97adaf2f6a9a876d3b209e36"
   ],
   "size": 81170,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B18.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B18 - 2020-12-21 minutes - executive session under 74-206(1)(b).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "open-meetings"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 3,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B19",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b19/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2021-10-18 minutes - executive session under 74-206(1)(b)",
   "date": "2021-10-18",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-05"
   ],
   "pages": "all (3)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "0c51a6dde2e797b1bf1f0b1bdae150ed16095c8924b14c9e17bba76e3cf4e4d0",
   "orig_sha": "089eda45a0ded209860cd9669bcd461c507345143dea8974ff8b59adf7d8fcda",
   "orig_shas": [
    "089eda45a0ded209860cd9669bcd461c507345143dea8974ff8b59adf7d8fcda"
   ],
   "size": 101795,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B19.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B19 - 2021-10-18 minutes - executive session under 74-206(1)(b).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "open-meetings"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 3,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B20",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b20/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2023-12-04 minutes - executive session under 74-206(1)(b)",
   "date": "2023-12-04",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-05"
   ],
   "pages": "all (2)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "0a372992fcf651cf4ce9ea4c04babe8f6afc8d2a9b07138dc44064c0a28a367b",
   "orig_sha": "a8fa2296544d84863e5fbaf749ae3650495e1c44fc82d031903c0951c012fd18",
   "orig_shas": [
    "a8fa2296544d84863e5fbaf749ae3650495e1c44fc82d031903c0951c012fd18"
   ],
   "size": 78322,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B20.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B20 - 2023-12-04 minutes - executive session under 74-206(1)(b).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "open-meetings"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 2,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B21",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b21/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2025-09-08 minutes - executive session under 74-206(1)(b)",
   "date": "2025-09-08",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-05"
   ],
   "pages": "all (3)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "ec7e09dc9fbdc19f3e94d171e4efa68bfacb4eb3dfbeb5543cee775e4850127d",
   "orig_sha": "f35435436f198d550cdf1b2788e5f994c625b3b7aad6c4226703ca1e7657a77b",
   "orig_shas": [
    "f35435436f198d550cdf1b2788e5f994c625b3b7aad6c4226703ca1e7657a77b"
   ],
   "size": 83081,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B21.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B21 - 2025-09-08 minutes - executive session under 74-206(1)(b).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "open-meetings"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 3,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B22",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b22/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2026-03-09 minutes - no stipend authorization recorded",
   "date": "2026-03-09",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-08"
   ],
   "pages": "all (3)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "7b2e44132c48f8385a622cd18a7cb9f8dfffc7b75592943c5a4b08b8c4eeb2d2",
   "orig_sha": "215d7123def0f5cb7a33a5cd19603d830bee08b7b5cf067d480b46614abef51c",
   "orig_shas": [
    "215d7123def0f5cb7a33a5cd19603d830bee08b7b5cf067d480b46614abef51c"
   ],
   "size": 80799,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B22.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B22 - 2026-03-09 minutes - no stipend authorization recorded.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 3,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B23",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b23/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2026-04-06 minutes - no stipend authorization recorded",
   "date": "2026-04-06",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-08"
   ],
   "pages": "all (2)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "a948949be594ed59a424c688d01797b6ad082393aced27881710b3080b1bfd6f",
   "orig_sha": "3a2927da31c129a5590b5bf6df0edb24d3d3706180968d4376d4d20e78363ab8",
   "orig_shas": [
    "3a2927da31c129a5590b5bf6df0edb24d3d3706180968d4376d4d20e78363ab8"
   ],
   "size": 105642,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B23.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B23 - 2026-04-06 minutes - no stipend authorization recorded.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 2,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B24",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b24/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2026-04-13 minutes - no stipend authorization recorded",
   "date": "2026-04-13",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-08"
   ],
   "pages": "all (3)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "54f9bd983200aaf8d4bcf77f39584cac6e6d9952a9baf75da617ae2c54ae8f41",
   "orig_sha": "413a757b1539cfdc00f58c13b0328808dcf5ba29c4a9abc6444e55dfed342855",
   "orig_shas": [
    "413a757b1539cfdc00f58c13b0328808dcf5ba29c4a9abc6444e55dfed342855"
   ],
   "size": 113051,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B24.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B24 - 2026-04-13 minutes - no stipend authorization recorded.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 3,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B25",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b25/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2026-04-20 minutes - no stipend authorization recorded",
   "date": "2026-04-20",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-08"
   ],
   "pages": "all (3)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "3b782726ab78b34c5a457fc47fd4138c14b0ae5757af3f2f6252c84d56fed4f7",
   "orig_sha": "ea6b92ab139f799a91e9e410a14d0f023511e3768b2167aaca09abf9ce5e8fba",
   "orig_shas": [
    "ea6b92ab139f799a91e9e410a14d0f023511e3768b2167aaca09abf9ce5e8fba"
   ],
   "size": 79491,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B25.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B25 - 2026-04-20 minutes - no stipend authorization recorded.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 3,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B26",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b26/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2026-04-27 minutes - no stipend authorization recorded",
   "date": "2026-04-27",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-08"
   ],
   "pages": "all (5)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "3853c85a9fe4e676bfec9255b6e5307509884eaece0fe0db61838873578f0549",
   "orig_sha": "11b0924bbfba343e0c75483a937347c4991e2d289ae639cef0b3417df31dae0e",
   "orig_shas": [
    "11b0924bbfba343e0c75483a937347c4991e2d289ae639cef0b3417df31dae0e"
   ],
   "size": 85301,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B26.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B26 - 2026-04-27 minutes - no stipend authorization recorded.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 5,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B27",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b27/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2022-01-18 notice - regular meeting cancelled (a recording of that date exists)",
   "date": "2022-01-18",
   "source": "Council notice",
   "findings": [],
   "pages": "all (2)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "ba1bce378ece14576269f2abf32ca770705980aac88448a6dd921ba7ad6f218e",
   "orig_sha": "fa6959b57d9a645cb3d8bba171c969b7906d78e285acc6552fb5c80d50e02da4",
   "orig_shas": [
    "fa6959b57d9a645cb3d8bba171c969b7906d78e285acc6552fb5c80d50e02da4"
   ],
   "size": 126401,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B27.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B27 - 2022-01-18 notice - regular meeting cancelled (a recording of that date exists).pdf",
   "topics": [],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 2,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B28",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b28/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2024-10-07 minutes - Mayor recuses: does accounting for Suburban Construction Management",
   "date": "2024-10-07",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-25"
   ],
   "pages": "all (3)",
   "notes": "Item 5a, page 1.",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "0f25a64e3caeaa049e72f1909a2d2c1624e795eab0229fd81c8d332e7c468f4d",
   "orig_sha": "f5a2a0725c729238df3a26780b5d100b502573ee96b5aaea4464f06b531e2793",
   "orig_shas": [
    "f5a2a0725c729238df3a26780b5d100b502573ee96b5aaea4464f06b531e2793"
   ],
   "size": 96812,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B28.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B28 - 2024-10-07 minutes - Mayor recuses does accounting for Suburban Construction Management.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "contracts-ethics"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 3,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B29",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b29/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2025-02-18 minutes - SuburbanCM ranked for City Park Restroom; 6 present, 6-0",
   "date": "2025-02-18",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-25"
   ],
   "pages": "all (2)",
   "notes": "Item 5c, page 2. No recusal recorded.",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "8618d1bcff2ffd707d95237aef1b7dd8d8a87fc0f0f9ad37415c0151879d0b2f",
   "orig_sha": "6e03dd5cb5e371d3b2f62c451b28aac1f4441aa04b10c044ca596cbbb6dcf8d5",
   "orig_shas": [
    "6e03dd5cb5e371d3b2f62c451b28aac1f4441aa04b10c044ca596cbbb6dcf8d5"
   ],
   "size": 78688,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B29.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B29 - 2025-02-18 minutes - SuburbanCM ranked for City Park Restroom; 6 present, 6-0.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "contracts-ethics"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 2,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B30",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b30/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2025-03-17 minutes - $1.6M reserves and Suburban CM/GC contracts; 6 present, 6-0",
   "date": "2025-03-17",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-25"
   ],
   "pages": "all (4)",
   "notes": "Items 5d and 5h, pages 2-3. No recusal recorded.",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "b5d10d5e70f2b519c492248415f52e80b0791567a6dd4a59aabe32df9ca46c57",
   "orig_sha": "95a18083a782312a469f8fa20238a5ec5798f7fd0ca70f8070664b43083d3dcf",
   "orig_shas": [
    "95a18083a782312a469f8fa20238a5ec5798f7fd0ca70f8070664b43083d3dcf"
   ],
   "size": 96123,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B30.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B30 - 2025-03-17 minutes - $1.6M reserves and Suburban CM-GC contracts; 6 present, 6-0.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "contracts-ethics"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 4,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B31",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b31/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2025-11-17 minutes - Well #5 contract to Suburban Construction ($2,395,826); 6 present, 6-0",
   "date": "2025-11-17",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-25"
   ],
   "pages": "all (3)",
   "notes": "Item 5b, pages 1-2. No recusal recorded.",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "d9623e0a67caefb45b8a7ebe0a51b5aec11842b9bb37c285cb38af5627f8e5a4",
   "orig_sha": "f48dcca7b2f0beba0358157b8fdf70256019a9618d9ad0bc5401e9954bae8e52",
   "orig_shas": [
    "f48dcca7b2f0beba0358157b8fdf70256019a9618d9ad0bc5401e9954bae8e52"
   ],
   "size": 103222,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B31.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B31 - 2025-11-17 minutes - Well #5 contract to Suburban Construction ($2,395,826); 6 present, 6-0.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "contracts-ethics"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 3,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B32",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b32/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2026-08-17 minutes - negotiations with Suburban Construction Management; 6 present, 6-0",
   "date": "2026-08-17",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-25"
   ],
   "pages": "all (4)",
   "notes": "Item 5b. Another member's recusal on a different item is recorded in the same minutes.",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "fa363e9db1bc823dfb1ff1c424bb14e36e7a51af8fcbc1568b8d99f4b3c7f84f",
   "orig_sha": "57878bef18b58fa1397a820e8476023257ddad3102edf724ed258ccc31b011bb",
   "orig_shas": [
    "57878bef18b58fa1397a820e8476023257ddad3102edf724ed258ccc31b011bb"
   ],
   "size": 105974,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B32.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B32 - 2026-08-17 minutes - negotiations with Suburban Construction Management; 6 present, 6-0.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "contracts-ethics"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 4,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B33",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b33/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2026-10-05 minutes - $486,013 Suburban Construction contract; Pierce seconds; 6-0",
   "date": "2026-10-05",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-25"
   ],
   "pages": "all (2)",
   "notes": "Item 5c. No recusal recorded.",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "5344e729187e2bc4af79912bc05c3078836d52b7b0edc03dacebf18ac46e2cfe",
   "orig_sha": "d730a02705112727d40c4876315bc67c16623c5fc7dfd3b8611c147bccc2ab06",
   "orig_shas": [
    "d730a02705112727d40c4876315bc67c16623c5fc7dfd3b8611c147bccc2ab06"
   ],
   "size": 90329,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B33.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B33 - 2026-10-05 minutes - $486,013 Suburban Construction contract; Pierce seconds; 6-0.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "contracts-ethics"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 2,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B34",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b34/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2026-10-19 minutes - $900,000 Suburban Construction change order; Pierce moves; 6-0",
   "date": "2026-10-19",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-25",
    "E-32"
   ],
   "pages": "all (3)",
   "notes": "Item 5a. No recusal recorded. Consent calendar item c: September 2026 Wells Fargo Credit Card Summary.",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "9af077f3390a82ff6dd1d3dee77853777369aaf643b1b5eb8b7c99f630ac48cb",
   "orig_sha": "d112689bf29e8e6eac18e6406016e0c2d0aa046bab9d001853eb59cf5abf423b",
   "orig_shas": [
    "d112689bf29e8e6eac18e6406016e0c2d0aa046bab9d001853eb59cf5abf423b"
   ],
   "size": 93011,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B34.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B34 - 2026-10-19 minutes - $900,000 Suburban Construction change order; Pierce moves; 6-0.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "contracts-ethics",
    "financial-transparency"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 3,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B35",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b35/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2021-12-13 minutes - Council confirms Deputy City Manager appointment 5-0",
   "date": "2021-12-13",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-27"
   ],
   "pages": "all (3)",
   "notes": "Item 5a. Exculpatory context.",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "f7eb879802a0ff027555ebd9a99174a90dfd7036c43446c6975c3845d1494401",
   "orig_sha": "a20aa8db900e6f2afb0120cdb5bfa387901e446d2b8e3c6b7d1de9b92051fe57",
   "orig_shas": [
    "a20aa8db900e6f2afb0120cdb5bfa387901e446d2b8e3c6b7d1de9b92051fe57"
   ],
   "size": 79589,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B35.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B35 - 2021-12-13 minutes - Council confirms Deputy City Manager appointment 5-0.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "workplace"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 3,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B36",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b36/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2022-07-25 minutes - Council Member Barigar resignation statement (conflict, intends to apply)",
   "date": "2022-07-25",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-28"
   ],
   "pages": "all (4)",
   "notes": "Item 8. Exculpatory context.",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "a6cf4afc0c8853b728a466a6ec031ba4a89db27d32354348192d7cf6a87ef325",
   "orig_sha": "d635b2a8a4be82b4a8072a972b5b9cba899f1805ef24cf94a1866be08cda8e84",
   "orig_shas": [
    "d635b2a8a4be82b4a8072a972b5b9cba899f1805ef24cf94a1866be08cda8e84"
   ],
   "size": 90173,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B36.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B36 - 2022-07-25 minutes - Council Member Barigar resignation statement (conflict, intends to apply).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "workplace"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 4,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B37",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b37/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2022-08-01 minutes - resignation accepted 5-0",
   "date": "2022-08-01",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-28"
   ],
   "pages": "all (5)",
   "notes": "Item e.",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "cbe1c9b97ff73c51283cf6bf396821a83e81797d022a64cd4df71cb9138a6d3d",
   "orig_sha": "27e0e90ec7a07f233b4f263e7fab36803b7ba6d391a31732f662a5589cbcc00f",
   "orig_shas": [
    "27e0e90ec7a07f233b4f263e7fab36803b7ba6d391a31732f662a5589cbcc00f"
   ],
   "size": 92510,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B37.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B37 - 2022-08-01 minutes - resignation accepted 5-0.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "workplace"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 5,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B38",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b38/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2022-10-10 minutes - Council confirms Economic Development Director appointment 7-0",
   "date": "2022-10-10",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-28"
   ],
   "pages": "all (3)",
   "notes": "Item b. Exculpatory context.",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "d5951f4110a63f660a1deeecfd885f95945c7acc1db17475578229504b3499c3",
   "orig_sha": "23f4b1fc2b345b9756b1b670b43ca0e77ac030a44fdb6de1ec770e05b2a3655f",
   "orig_shas": [
    "23f4b1fc2b345b9756b1b670b43ca0e77ac030a44fdb6de1ec770e05b2a3655f"
   ],
   "size": 78223,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B38.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B38 - 2022-10-10 minutes - Council confirms Economic Development Director appointment 7-0.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "workplace"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 3,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B39",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b39/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2023-12-04 minutes - Council confirms HR Director appointment 7-0",
   "date": "2023-12-04",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-26"
   ],
   "pages": "all (2)",
   "notes": "Item 5a. Exculpatory context.",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "8ab0bbaf0149c1b399295904a79fe5cc1e783c95e13c227ccf37a6ad90a85aa1",
   "orig_sha": "a8fa2296544d84863e5fbaf749ae3650495e1c44fc82d031903c0951c012fd18",
   "orig_shas": [
    "a8fa2296544d84863e5fbaf749ae3650495e1c44fc82d031903c0951c012fd18"
   ],
   "size": 77919,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B39.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B39 - 2023-12-04 minutes - Council confirms HR Director appointment 7-0.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "workplace"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 2,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B40",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b40/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2013-12-02 minutes - Resolution 1912 (Transparency in City Government) adopted 6-1",
   "date": "2013-12-02",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-31"
   ],
   "pages": "all (5)",
   "notes": "Item II.3, pp 3-5.",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "9face4d8aeabad172a57e8b4ad2f8decb718e422109e3deb9fb4252e56ac62c5",
   "orig_sha": "80a4daa4ce62d58a33ce5a2aff747342a4039ae3360804fc2aba7d33e346a876",
   "orig_shas": [
    "80a4daa4ce62d58a33ce5a2aff747342a4039ae3360804fc2aba7d33e346a876"
   ],
   "size": 45860,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B40.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B40 - 2013-12-02 minutes - Resolution 1912 (Transparency in City Government) adopted 6-1.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "financial-transparency"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 5,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B41",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b41/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2014-04-21 agenda - Second Amended Resolution 1912, Section 5 website commitments (excerpt)",
   "date": "2014-04-21",
   "source": "Council agenda and packet",
   "findings": [
    "E-31",
    "E-32"
   ],
   "pages": "pp 1,73,74,75,76",
   "notes": "Excerpt: page 1 and pages 73-76 (the resolution). Section 5 is on page 75 of the original, page 4 of this excerpt.",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "f408370ec381864bc73e41468302153043d557d635188538bb0554fb74aec3f2",
   "orig_sha": "c1aaca38b17b7e73669cdfe9889eeac2211ebfc63297849143d4f6fc09c9ec8a",
   "orig_shas": [
    "c1aaca38b17b7e73669cdfe9889eeac2211ebfc63297849143d4f6fc09c9ec8a"
   ],
   "size": 46711,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B41.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B41 - 2014-04-21 agenda - Second Amended Resolution 1912, Section 5 website commitments (excerpt).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "financial-transparency"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Pages extracted: pp 1,73,74,75,76",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 5,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B42",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b42/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2014-04-21 minutes - Second Amended Resolution 1912 adopted 7-0",
   "date": "2014-04-21",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-31"
   ],
   "pages": "all (6)",
   "notes": "Item II.5, p 5.",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "55e21bf9e1a9a086c1098b30a1d4c0c0eaa2e1098f53771e7eb7ddceb089edcf",
   "orig_sha": "0a1d9d80c86b751162ba0253bf1c6b8c3ddd079bfcccf9fd57d0b83be35d5175",
   "orig_shas": [
    "0a1d9d80c86b751162ba0253bf1c6b8c3ddd079bfcccf9fd57d0b83be35d5175"
   ],
   "size": 206306,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B42.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B42 - 2014-04-21 minutes - Second Amended Resolution 1912 adopted 7-0.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "financial-transparency"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 6,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B43",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b43/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2015-08-03 minutes - last minutes stating the accounts payable total",
   "date": "2015-08-03",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-31"
   ],
   "pages": "all (6)",
   "notes": "Consent calendar item 1, p 2: total $1,102,058.",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "6100392a145a9e254cd2ecf13471c6a977cdd8dca4b91105f45fcc6b73d14a29",
   "orig_sha": "8d2a7d44e0124d05afab61509946339c85986723ab76d02ebbfe9dd1d976106c",
   "orig_shas": [
    "8d2a7d44e0124d05afab61509946339c85986723ab76d02ebbfe9dd1d976106c"
   ],
   "size": 59238,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B43.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B43 - 2015-08-03 minutes - last minutes stating the accounts payable total.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "financial-transparency"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 6,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B44",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b44/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2015-08-10 minutes - accounts payable approved, no total stated (excerpt)",
   "date": "2015-08-10",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-31"
   ],
   "pages": "pp 1,2",
   "notes": "Excerpt: pages 1-2. Consent calendar item 1 gives only the date range.",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "29bf2f8341841e54155d654a77513108ad773f1ac50c694944733910e0671d62",
   "orig_sha": "676ce99ed7c89ea17f7330471f0d324e29548b93caa2dc0434c35dacf92db64b",
   "orig_shas": [
    "676ce99ed7c89ea17f7330471f0d324e29548b93caa2dc0434c35dacf92db64b"
   ],
   "size": 1367410,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B44.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B44 - 2015-08-10 minutes - accounts payable approved, no total stated (excerpt).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "financial-transparency"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Pages extracted: pp 1,2",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 2,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B45",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b45/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2016-04-04 agenda - Resolution 2016-02 records destruction list, Check Registers 2007-2015 (excerpt)",
   "date": "2016-04-04",
   "source": "Council agenda and packet",
   "findings": [
    "E-31"
   ],
   "pages": "pp 1,39,40,41",
   "notes": "Excerpt: page 1 and pages 39-41 (staff memo and resolution). 'Check Registers 2007-2015' is on page 40 of the original, page 3 of this excerpt.",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "099bad70e9ddae9d36f9b7c53c604c999e658e8826d0af1c0620043f524ddff3",
   "orig_sha": "dae02e41ce032a0b2fea007a2c42632a6dc0a7635ca2a63785d46f7842818c27",
   "orig_shas": [
    "dae02e41ce032a0b2fea007a2c42632a6dc0a7635ca2a63785d46f7842818c27"
   ],
   "size": 356152,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B45.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B45 - 2016-04-04 agenda - Resolution 2016-02 records destruction list, Check Registers 2007-2015 (excerpt).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "financial-transparency"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Pages extracted: pp 1,39,40,41",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 4,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B46",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b46/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2016-04-04 minutes - Resolution 2016-02 adopted 7-0 (excerpt)",
   "date": "2016-04-04",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-31"
   ],
   "pages": "pp 1,5",
   "notes": "Excerpt: pages 1 and 5.",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "1e146e205639ce320290cbfabcfb143f33662b5fff06f4e08794f6a7d0a1db48",
   "orig_sha": "7982d2978691b0802f5d9130b395f9d4b4331566dbfe9e2ee24b852ccfb2dbaa",
   "orig_shas": [
    "7982d2978691b0802f5d9130b395f9d4b4331566dbfe9e2ee24b852ccfb2dbaa"
   ],
   "size": 1381796,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B46.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B46 - 2016-04-04 minutes - Resolution 2016-02 adopted 7-0 (excerpt).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "financial-transparency"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Pages extracted: pp 1,5",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 2,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B47",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b47/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2014-06-23 minutes - Council approves new City credit card process 5-0, six-month update promised",
   "date": "2014-06-23",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-32"
   ],
   "pages": "all (5)",
   "notes": "Item II.4, pp 3-4.",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "2e8c6f979cc689e13fff76b4f229ab98c9a20074203bf952f8f61e6e696c97c8",
   "orig_sha": "f554ecbf6934d3c7818084ae628efbc8e75b024dc47785d3ec37d3f085024836",
   "orig_shas": [
    "f554ecbf6934d3c7818084ae628efbc8e75b024dc47785d3ec37d3f085024836"
   ],
   "size": 160051,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B47.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B47 - 2014-06-23 minutes - Council approves new City credit card process 5-0, six-month update promised.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "financial-transparency"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 5,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B48",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b48/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2019-03-18 minutes - first monthly Wells Fargo Commercial Card approval on the consent calendar",
   "date": "2019-03-18",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-32"
   ],
   "pages": "all (4)",
   "notes": "Consent calendar item b, p 2.",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "d5911e060a03f8606f7aade33bae0f17b3aaf3eccdf73e2650a1af2abc24f716",
   "orig_sha": "702efccbe2cf8d530b8699f7242cd764f1dfc1338d069715b5a567c3a7cb16be",
   "orig_shas": [
    "702efccbe2cf8d530b8699f7242cd764f1dfc1338d069715b5a567c3a7cb16be"
   ],
   "size": 138166,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B48.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B48 - 2019-03-18 minutes - first monthly Wells Fargo Commercial Card approval on the consent calendar.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "financial-transparency"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 4,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B49",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b49/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2019-09-23 packet - Ordinance 2019-009 code text cites Second Amended Resolution 1912 (excerpt)",
   "date": "2019-09-23",
   "source": "Council packet",
   "findings": [
    "E-31"
   ],
   "pages": "pp 1,6",
   "notes": "Excerpt: pages 1 and 6. City Code 2-13 text, meetings 'in accordance with Second Amended Resolution 1912'.",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "0dd3a025926885342bf707954e40c12d1ba530ef87605ceb23af443be51df417",
   "orig_sha": "dd9e2e687b289c23f20401e230f2128941ca9b8992d784aadac85573043e5e86",
   "orig_shas": [
    "dd9e2e687b289c23f20401e230f2128941ca9b8992d784aadac85573043e5e86"
   ],
   "size": 1178803,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B49.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B49 - 2019-09-23 packet - Ordinance 2019-009 code text cites Second Amended Resolution 1912 (excerpt).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "financial-transparency"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Pages extracted: pp 1,6",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 2,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B50",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b50/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2022-07-18 packet - staff memo and Ord. 2022-013 making the vacant Economic Development Director post a department head (excerpt)",
   "date": "2022-07-18",
   "source": "Council packet",
   "findings": [
    "E-28"
   ],
   "pages": "pp 1-2, 20-22",
   "notes": "Excerpt: agenda pp1-2; staff memo pp20-21 (post vacant; appointment becomes subject to Council confirmation); ordinance p22.",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "893c94b40945fd189e7966432a28ab5fd76dc70b1bc614c7c46735a041d84629",
   "orig_sha": "af2e96eab750c249b75221e7070ab36bc3a317ac309665e50f7cff7770a24b9c",
   "orig_shas": [
    "af2e96eab750c249b75221e7070ab36bc3a317ac309665e50f7cff7770a24b9c"
   ],
   "size": 299022,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B50.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B50 - 2022-07-18 packet - staff memo and Ord. 2022-013 making the vacant Economic Development Director post a department head (excerpt).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "workplace"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Pages extracted: pp 1-2, 20-22",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 5,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-B51",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-b51/",
   "group": "B",
   "description": "2022-07-18 minutes (approved 2022-07-25) - Council Member Barigar recuses; Ord. 2022-013 passes 5-0 (excerpt)",
   "date": "2022-07-18",
   "source": "Council minutes",
   "findings": [
    "E-28"
   ],
   "pages": "pp 4-5",
   "notes": "Excerpt: the July 18, 2022 minutes as printed for approval in the July 25, 2022 special meeting packet (pp4-5), item 5b. The City's posted '2022-07-18 City Council Minutes' file holds the July 11 minutes instead.",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "245e6b6f0b442bcbf8c8f08e0aa34b92826aaa15d4d50e3bd214d72e7b752809",
   "orig_sha": "ae0c0c61424cef7760959ed7c121670875621268fe5734af18454217102df92a",
   "orig_shas": [
    "ae0c0c61424cef7760959ed7c121670875621268fe5734af18454217102df92a"
   ],
   "size": 84910,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-B51.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-B51 - 2022-07-18 minutes (approved 2022-07-25) - Council Member Barigar recuses; Ord. 2022-013 passes 5-0 (excerpt).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "workplace"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Pages extracted: pp 4-5",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 2,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C01-1",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c01-1/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Request form",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #3946",
   "findings": [
    "E-12",
    "E-22"
   ],
   "pages": "all (1)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "1 area(s) redacted",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "866e81099f5040797e00791e5a9f0d72aa816957222c7cba05ea63b029a24b7f",
   "orig_sha": "503a8fff88089f24b411c4c6291004946f5c96392af59353b720c5ba7210f743",
   "orig_shas": [
    "503a8fff88089f24b411c4c6291004946f5c96392af59353b720c5ba7210f743"
   ],
   "size": 844499,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C01-1.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C01-1 - Request form.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "53eb6f6cb66b2ccd844e5152e5c9a4131d97e7f852f1fab4a09d118eb1659e1f",
   "changes": [
    "Redacted: 1 area(s) redacted",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (page 1); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 1,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#3946",
    "subject": "Market Analysis keyword, 5 custodians",
    "filed": "2026-05-31",
    "outcome": "Partial; late; 109/117 withheld as \"proprietary\"",
    "findings": [
     "E-12"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #3946"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C01-2",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c01-2/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Notice of cost and payment",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #3946",
   "findings": [
    "E-12",
    "E-22"
   ],
   "pages": "all (2)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "65ad65e519478f6bad6746d2abdb9838e28030daf8f2d5603929e7f9ed89e306",
   "orig_sha": "68bd7d97c89c3baf3830df9700520039c8f96105934a495a6931327a11714ce7",
   "orig_shas": [
    "68bd7d97c89c3baf3830df9700520039c8f96105934a495a6931327a11714ce7"
   ],
   "size": 401023,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C01-2.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C01-2 - Notice of cost and payment.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "2ec5dd55e264a0c32111b8688475cff0d8cc667979aa32ed0bea340f789b2680",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (pages 1, 2); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 2,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#3946",
    "subject": "Market Analysis keyword, 5 custodians",
    "filed": "2026-05-31",
    "outcome": "Partial; late; 109/117 withheld as \"proprietary\"",
    "findings": [
     "E-12"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #3946"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C01-3",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c01-3/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Completion notice",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #3946",
   "findings": [
    "E-12",
    "E-22"
   ],
   "pages": "all (1)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "5e8d86bcc9d675d72ef4bd18c4978e387eb2bdf51d82a36a509794a0989d0a44",
   "orig_sha": "369f4c7dfa2e7200474e563de61f362c773f684a70a13111486d1348d19cac3b",
   "orig_shas": [
    "369f4c7dfa2e7200474e563de61f362c773f684a70a13111486d1348d19cac3b"
   ],
   "size": 333497,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C01-3.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C01-3 - Completion notice.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "4d4a9e8c5d30c8afaf866934e3fa80d7fe3ca5aeb2f8743093de655250eed25e",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (page 1); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 1,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#3946",
    "subject": "Market Analysis keyword, 5 custodians",
    "filed": "2026-05-31",
    "outcome": "Partial; late; 109/117 withheld as \"proprietary\"",
    "findings": [
     "E-12"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #3946"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C01-4",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c01-4/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Deputy Clerk explanation of withheld records (Jul 13, 2026)",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #3946",
   "findings": [
    "E-12",
    "E-22"
   ],
   "pages": "all (5)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "b0ea4ebdae6bec4561fd54cb04d6b944d5a8948d6a8ca7be592ceb44c0a3e6f4",
   "orig_sha": "aba3212c945c93c8635ec912b258e8fb103cadee3500a5b9eaf44e745180ce0d",
   "orig_shas": [
    "aba3212c945c93c8635ec912b258e8fb103cadee3500a5b9eaf44e745180ce0d"
   ],
   "size": 250286,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C01-4.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C01-4 - Deputy Clerk explanation of withheld records (Jul 13, 2026).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "99ef985453dc99b999729019fe05a6d6e01c49565146a3274118bca25a61d783",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (pages 1, 3, 4, 5); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 5,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#3946",
    "subject": "Market Analysis keyword, 5 custodians",
    "filed": "2026-05-31",
    "outcome": "Partial; late; 109/117 withheld as \"proprietary\"",
    "findings": [
     "E-12"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #3946"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C01-5",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c01-5/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Released - April 2026 email sharing Market Analysis Results",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #3946",
   "findings": [
    "E-12",
    "E-22",
    "E-18"
   ],
   "pages": "all (1)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "b3d6acfa033c71777fa583af645ab7318e6398a19e43620219ce99d313155883",
   "orig_sha": "e1406c8cfe781fbf360fdcebebd2490e38dc9d5016a2d8acdaf6dce99ee805c7",
   "orig_shas": [
    "e1406c8cfe781fbf360fdcebebd2490e38dc9d5016a2d8acdaf6dce99ee805c7"
   ],
   "size": 42683,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C01-5.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C01-5 - Released - April 2026 email sharing Market Analysis Results.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "contracts-ethics",
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 1,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#3946",
    "subject": "Market Analysis keyword, 5 custodians",
    "filed": "2026-05-31",
    "outcome": "Partial; late; 109/117 withheld as \"proprietary\"",
    "findings": [
     "E-12"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #3946"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C01-6",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c01-6/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Released - forward of Market Analysis Results to ELT",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #3946",
   "findings": [
    "E-12",
    "E-22",
    "E-18"
   ],
   "pages": "all (1)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "1e98d7765c7ce37f0cec7119e095e7478a05e391ed750c6f5ecb1b1f014053b7",
   "orig_sha": "b2afcf1de0faca85537f217f49119749ea5d2e6e3c54366f2d6ded84107b23fa",
   "orig_shas": [
    "b2afcf1de0faca85537f217f49119749ea5d2e6e3c54366f2d6ded84107b23fa"
   ],
   "size": 1202,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C01-6.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C01-6 - Released - forward of Market Analysis Results to ELT.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "contracts-ethics",
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 1,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#3946",
    "subject": "Market Analysis keyword, 5 custodians",
    "filed": "2026-05-31",
    "outcome": "Partial; late; 109/117 withheld as \"proprietary\"",
    "findings": [
     "E-12"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #3946"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C01-7",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c01-7/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Released - 2025 Employee Handbook midyear update draft",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #3946",
   "findings": [
    "E-12",
    "E-22"
   ],
   "pages": "all (91)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "00a43e5e5327a72c7621485d0ffea9a0abe580be5a3c7ac0446b7f99c770c8f5",
   "orig_sha": "904f1e79804053a46a799c41e8162bb0d17a4fb2011155c6c4d3c8522c25fb58",
   "orig_shas": [
    "904f1e79804053a46a799c41e8162bb0d17a4fb2011155c6c4d3c8522c25fb58"
   ],
   "size": 135175,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C01-7.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C01-7 - Released - 2025 Employee Handbook midyear update draft.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 91,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#3946",
    "subject": "Market Analysis keyword, 5 custodians",
    "filed": "2026-05-31",
    "outcome": "Partial; late; 109/117 withheld as \"proprietary\"",
    "findings": [
     "E-12"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #3946"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C01-8",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c01-8/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Released - 2025-2026 Employee Handbook updates effective May 31, 2026",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #3946",
   "findings": [
    "E-12",
    "E-22"
   ],
   "pages": "all (90)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "e3dd660b34cf86e784ec7fd8df8f378bf58689296cecb96212acb7df2c4ac2cf",
   "orig_sha": "fa3d3d63f871f8e6d802b54c44badcf85bcff3ff3786d14157ed173db854dd70",
   "orig_shas": [
    "fa3d3d63f871f8e6d802b54c44badcf85bcff3ff3786d14157ed173db854dd70"
   ],
   "size": 135376,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C01-8.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C01-8 - Released - 2025-2026 Employee Handbook updates effective May 31, 2026.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 90,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#3946",
    "subject": "Market Analysis keyword, 5 custodians",
    "filed": "2026-05-31",
    "outcome": "Partial; late; 109/117 withheld as \"proprietary\"",
    "findings": [
     "E-12"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #3946"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C01-9",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c01-9/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Correspondence with the City, compiled in date order (with City attachments)",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #3946",
   "findings": [
    "E-12",
    "E-22"
   ],
   "pages": "all (2); all (1); all (1); all (2); all (1); all (2); all (1); all (1); all (2); all (2); all (4); all (3); all (3); all (3); all (4)",
   "notes": "Each email rendered to PDF from the received message; bookmarks give date/sender/subject. Requester signature images omitted.",
   "redaction": "3 area(s) redacted",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "bde06480fda50f4be83d430c9c3d855fd8c687bea8e1275dd992c2bdcd137e5c",
   "orig_sha": "dd69f44a6dd6e76a93b0a5f6c3acee53a53b75f6ce3041b7c0a2e9d22543bff5\nc216af04f67fba2fdaa8d32ca3884cf775aa884d75e0f60a426c482265d75a4b\n637ed20f185ed06916ac3da3d584332f75c88e7b04faa1170fbcc5cda729b37b\n0aef53b42802a873d8687af4e69a7ac3c954a9143e062d26f419905a942f5218\n591fff0c46a715f5b12019e648c723c06ed32aceb50b646bee964ef3b912d530\n0aef53b42802a873d8687af4e69a7ac3c954a9143e062d26f419905a942f5218\n0775a0b5b2f2abc1911b28e43f2184b78e2cdd61189c2121812cfdf1cc56c28c\n0b477f0252d9c6c7a5cb110672b141069343f666dbe8057488218b73c734b205\n69938c61f7f824b723848765320b5ca0cd78552477609311c04230dd50d5080e\n0aef53b42802a873d8687af4e69a7ac3c954a9143e062d26f419905a942f5218\n19dfd2f5df7f48c896d5e1c21636c4353fd190ca8c9d175906a93a5b37e0b020\n833cad21fef18a667614885e527e1b61da5d0b0a76b70307bb8a486d36edee8d\n2aa4a39736afd92ad05eb393d3261fd398dcc3910b1a919a23875e60e4e75fcf\n1fb951bf74e018f35c3474d44d2d802e4e232c2a43ab5d89a7b32252f5eb8052\ne2e9d9a8d6a73250f52d7826cdb80a108940bf66e74e09c954fc0c4bfd001e32",
   "orig_shas": [
    "dd69f44a6dd6e76a93b0a5f6c3acee53a53b75f6ce3041b7c0a2e9d22543bff5",
    "c216af04f67fba2fdaa8d32ca3884cf775aa884d75e0f60a426c482265d75a4b",
    "637ed20f185ed06916ac3da3d584332f75c88e7b04faa1170fbcc5cda729b37b",
    "0aef53b42802a873d8687af4e69a7ac3c954a9143e062d26f419905a942f5218",
    "591fff0c46a715f5b12019e648c723c06ed32aceb50b646bee964ef3b912d530",
    "0aef53b42802a873d8687af4e69a7ac3c954a9143e062d26f419905a942f5218",
    "0775a0b5b2f2abc1911b28e43f2184b78e2cdd61189c2121812cfdf1cc56c28c",
    "0b477f0252d9c6c7a5cb110672b141069343f666dbe8057488218b73c734b205",
    "69938c61f7f824b723848765320b5ca0cd78552477609311c04230dd50d5080e",
    "0aef53b42802a873d8687af4e69a7ac3c954a9143e062d26f419905a942f5218",
    "19dfd2f5df7f48c896d5e1c21636c4353fd190ca8c9d175906a93a5b37e0b020",
    "833cad21fef18a667614885e527e1b61da5d0b0a76b70307bb8a486d36edee8d",
    "2aa4a39736afd92ad05eb393d3261fd398dcc3910b1a919a23875e60e4e75fcf",
    "1fb951bf74e018f35c3474d44d2d802e4e232c2a43ab5d89a7b32252f5eb8052",
    "e2e9d9a8d6a73250f52d7826cdb80a108940bf66e74e09c954fc0c4bfd001e32"
   ],
   "size": 4260928,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C01-9.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C01-9 - Correspondence with the City, compiled in date order (with City attachments).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "da0e65a105b7e00c2ae10b0f611fb0add7dafa50b1bbba3f1fd393f46d50e644",
   "changes": [
    "Combined from 15 files as released",
    "Redacted: 3 area(s) redacted",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (pages 1, 3, 4, 5, 7, 8, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 16, 17, 18, 20, 21, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 32); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 32,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#3946",
    "subject": "Market Analysis keyword, 5 custodians",
    "filed": "2026-05-31",
    "outcome": "Partial; late; 109/117 withheld as \"proprietary\"",
    "findings": [
     "E-12"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #3946"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C01-10",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c01-10/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Released - consultant meeting invitation, Market Analysis Results (for Mar 3, 2026)",
   "date": "2026-02-27",
   "source": "PRR #3946",
   "findings": [
    "E-18",
    "E-12"
   ],
   "pages": "all (2)",
   "notes": "Invitation from the consultant, sent Feb 27, 2026, for a Mar 3, 2026 meeting titled 'City of Twin Falls - Market Analysis Results'.",
   "redaction": "None by Oversight Archive. The City's own black box (over the online meeting link and passcode) is kept. Pages are images of the City's pages: the City's file kept a hidden text layer under its own box, which is not carried over.",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "bd869a28e5f1efaf1762e331f37bb7e8db32633a2d86d2d5d27902b8545e4740",
   "orig_sha": "b5a3852c4328d55ceead88878626d77262496b473b7d7b84dc6bca0cc91f7ab7",
   "orig_shas": [
    "b5a3852c4328d55ceead88878626d77262496b473b7d7b84dc6bca0cc91f7ab7"
   ],
   "size": 230011,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C01-10.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C01-10 - Released - consultant meeting invitation, Market Analysis Results (for Mar 3, 2026).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "contracts-ethics",
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "8dcc23e922cac2ea1012e4b78cd2d1f0115033e7fd0f39ef8fcc612b8923d8d6",
   "changes": [
    "Redacted: None by Oversight Archive. The City's own black box (over the online meeting link and passcode) is kept. Pages are images of the City's pages: the City's file kept a hidden text layer under its own box, which is not carried over.",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester email addresses redacted (page 1); City and other government addresses left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 2,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#3946",
    "subject": "Market Analysis keyword, 5 custodians",
    "filed": "2026-05-31",
    "outcome": "Partial; late; 109/117 withheld as \"proprietary\"",
    "findings": [
     "E-12"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #3946"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C01-11",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c01-11/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Released - consultant invoice email, May 2026 ($350)",
   "date": "2026-05-27",
   "source": "PRR #3946",
   "findings": [
    "E-18"
   ],
   "pages": "all (1)",
   "notes": "Email from the consultant's billing office to the HR Director, May 27, 2026, about invoice 4640996 for $350.",
   "redaction": "None by Oversight Archive. Pages are images of the City's pages.",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "8eb27fa81ff2b5ac45cb3731ef7f570f6345d587e433ec1abc30e27c5c10ccc8",
   "orig_sha": "5e2836a73453bbf24b94d09f0ed992541f47b0506649561963252dfae75fc3bb",
   "orig_shas": [
    "5e2836a73453bbf24b94d09f0ed992541f47b0506649561963252dfae75fc3bb"
   ],
   "size": 215576,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C01-11.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C01-11 - Released - consultant invoice email, May 2026 ($350).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "contracts-ethics"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "692527ac685ba185ee8cece6f25cdb11b9ed1241b6a5156d771c5a168bebdc14",
   "changes": [
    "Redacted: None by Oversight Archive. Pages are images of the City's pages.",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Personal email addresses, phone numbers and home or mailing addresses redacted (page 1); names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 1,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#3946",
    "subject": "Market Analysis keyword, 5 custodians",
    "filed": "2026-05-31",
    "outcome": "Partial; late; 109/117 withheld as \"proprietary\"",
    "findings": [
     "E-12"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #3946"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C01-12",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c01-12/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Requester's copy of the submitted request form (May 31, 2026)",
   "date": "2026-05-31",
   "source": "PRR #3946 (requester's copy)",
   "findings": [
    "E-22"
   ],
   "pages": "all (2)",
   "notes": "The PDF of the form as submitted, created May 31, 2026 at 4:43 PM MDT (the City's saved copy, EX-C01-1, is time-stamped 4:42:37 PM). Address 1 and Phone Number are filled in here; the City's saved copy has no address or phone fields. Document properties removed; the original's creation date is recorded in this note.",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "32bd5e2efd3920ea92c255958a78e990e1abafa4515f791af95f65cb5807454d",
   "orig_sha": "dd69f44a6dd6e76a93b0a5f6c3acee53a53b75f6ce3041b7c0a2e9d22543bff5",
   "orig_shas": [
    "dd69f44a6dd6e76a93b0a5f6c3acee53a53b75f6ce3041b7c0a2e9d22543bff5"
   ],
   "size": 3493017,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C01-12.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C01-12 - Requester's copy of the submitted request form (May 31, 2026).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "b6f43ce57e5ffa0d8f5993223127808579b36631fbc8b85a0bc29d52f79c0b38",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (pages 1, 2); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 2,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#3946",
    "subject": "Market Analysis keyword, 5 custodians",
    "filed": "2026-05-31",
    "outcome": "Partial; late; 109/117 withheld as \"proprietary\"",
    "findings": [
     "E-12"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "The requester's own copy of the request as submitted for public records request #3946, saved at the time of submission. It is not a record the City released"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C02-1",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c02-1/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Request form",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR (Market analysis cost (denied))",
   "findings": [
    "E-22"
   ],
   "pages": "all (3)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "3 area(s) redacted",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "e6d7390d56998497e83d187e11e92163a2f3d2b2d8971590ab12dc83f14021c6",
   "orig_sha": "765c77512a89abb78ba7d20b47592d80260c5e62a17d92d901b693b36f9ee54d",
   "orig_shas": [
    "765c77512a89abb78ba7d20b47592d80260c5e62a17d92d901b693b36f9ee54d"
   ],
   "size": 3513779,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C02-1.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C02-1 - Request form.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "840d70c1b8c54dabadaf02d866aacd999757f1c482991717fd06b405f35ef480",
   "changes": [
    "Redacted: 3 area(s) redacted",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (page 1); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 3,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "From the City of Twin Falls' response to a public records request"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C02-2",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c02-2/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Correspondence with the City, compiled in date order (with City attachments)",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR (Market analysis cost (denied))",
   "findings": [
    "E-22"
   ],
   "pages": "all (1); all (2); all (2); all (2)",
   "notes": "Each email rendered to PDF from the received message; bookmarks give date/sender/subject. Requester signature images omitted.",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "f0516dbda78715874286dde73ab38a83ca7883c6c074eb3292b8794783d06b70",
   "orig_sha": "c30a492d0c85ecb4f8e60e2d88681e499afdf27aaf80c996d239f22fe94e3025\n6be502455effa3374a2c4c96611cc6d8148ee8f05300dfb748f708f1e3a5d354\n0a6f66bb6cbfa66b8bbdc86a99362372ebfeeb32314c034ec5429084f8de8609\n3c5f8b38270e8802f7b3edc5aabbaec8e3ac8a3ce2e17ff490cc042c45367bad",
   "orig_shas": [
    "c30a492d0c85ecb4f8e60e2d88681e499afdf27aaf80c996d239f22fe94e3025",
    "6be502455effa3374a2c4c96611cc6d8148ee8f05300dfb748f708f1e3a5d354",
    "0a6f66bb6cbfa66b8bbdc86a99362372ebfeeb32314c034ec5429084f8de8609",
    "3c5f8b38270e8802f7b3edc5aabbaec8e3ac8a3ce2e17ff490cc042c45367bad"
   ],
   "size": 156848,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C02-2.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C02-2 - Correspondence with the City, compiled in date order (with City attachments).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "655afad50b11a3492b6154d75237090e567f045023eb89d67b1c9388873b7cb4",
   "changes": [
    "Combined from 4 files as released",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (pages 1, 2, 4, 5, 6, 7); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 7,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "From the City of Twin Falls' response to a public records request"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C03-1",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c03-1/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Request letter",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #4729",
   "findings": [
    "E-22"
   ],
   "pages": "all (5)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "8342fc36316c12d9ee119e460d68311bfc85f368f1f1cae4416904cc7290779c",
   "orig_sha": "9c158cbb9db42842ff8689e3fc87dabe6d54e2ea6b6df3e010fbb14cf2c1a6e8",
   "orig_shas": [
    "9c158cbb9db42842ff8689e3fc87dabe6d54e2ea6b6df3e010fbb14cf2c1a6e8"
   ],
   "size": 48179,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C03-1.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C03-1 - Request letter.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 5,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4729",
    "subject": "ELT compensation records FY21-FY26",
    "filed": "2026-08 (approx.)",
    "outcome": "Produced HR documents",
    "findings": [
     "E-01",
     "E-02",
     "E-03",
     "E-04",
     "E-05",
     "E-06",
     "E-07",
     "E-08",
     "E-09"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4729"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C03-2",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c03-2/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Request form as filed",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #4729",
   "findings": [
    "E-22"
   ],
   "pages": "all (3)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "1 area(s) redacted",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "4b0d809c7d1f2d4645e426b1eb3de211a7f3144a5353b77dfff42e0f18769003",
   "orig_sha": "3d0a6707c528b1c76a6ccc21a70ebd222c21da5791038f7048ffb368e276ce8d",
   "orig_shas": [
    "3d0a6707c528b1c76a6ccc21a70ebd222c21da5791038f7048ffb368e276ce8d"
   ],
   "size": 3374015,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C03-2.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C03-2 - Request form as filed.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "0734eaa25cb0361cb039b55293a8482cdb33b3e05b9452e88bd2f6e95f74f0e8",
   "changes": [
    "Redacted: 1 area(s) redacted",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (pages 1, 3); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 3,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4729",
    "subject": "ELT compensation records FY21-FY26",
    "filed": "2026-08 (approx.)",
    "outcome": "Produced HR documents",
    "findings": [
     "E-01",
     "E-02",
     "E-03",
     "E-04",
     "E-05",
     "E-06",
     "E-07",
     "E-08",
     "E-09"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4729"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C03-3",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c03-3/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Correspondence with the City, compiled in date order (with City attachments)",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #4729",
   "findings": [
    "E-22"
   ],
   "pages": "all (4); all (1); all (1); all (1); all (1); all (1)",
   "notes": "Each email rendered to PDF from the received message; bookmarks give date/sender/subject. Requester signature images omitted.",
   "redaction": "3 area(s) redacted",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "1a797a0ff30ed53aa0d406ef0ab666ab23e5ac14878184fb565a335ee4696b14",
   "orig_sha": "316d60bbeab4280b053f68308848ca585feb8c10bc71d84e4945c8e2cdd12d14\n3e69b9ad0c9fef88bbd3aeb71b0e68077df96f7da2a5f12a4abc8f4ae3ec9cbf\n8736464202ab57d952dcf1a42ef0d72d74e11f99567bfa571dbd01472323fc07\nf911b3ff39d8743245230a5d7c90b6f9ca77d153c5edd53dd52d6e57810ef02b\nd3de6742efb71b5b451bafcb1a516dc2ec9077bc2c2990569a5b21ff1237ca81\ndaeab25a870148cafa400ada588df2701d4d0fbba7a6e9aae40f512b4d9c687e",
   "orig_shas": [
    "316d60bbeab4280b053f68308848ca585feb8c10bc71d84e4945c8e2cdd12d14",
    "3e69b9ad0c9fef88bbd3aeb71b0e68077df96f7da2a5f12a4abc8f4ae3ec9cbf",
    "8736464202ab57d952dcf1a42ef0d72d74e11f99567bfa571dbd01472323fc07",
    "f911b3ff39d8743245230a5d7c90b6f9ca77d153c5edd53dd52d6e57810ef02b",
    "d3de6742efb71b5b451bafcb1a516dc2ec9077bc2c2990569a5b21ff1237ca81",
    "daeab25a870148cafa400ada588df2701d4d0fbba7a6e9aae40f512b4d9c687e"
   ],
   "size": 3634703,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C03-3.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C03-3 - Correspondence with the City, compiled in date order (with City attachments).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "92c444bd2ad9c700c4563a2e2943595fec5a4ea3a17a954e75e591cbaaeec4d1",
   "changes": [
    "Combined from 6 files as released",
    "Redacted: 3 area(s) redacted",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (pages 1, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 9,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4729",
    "subject": "ELT compensation records FY21-FY26",
    "filed": "2026-08 (approx.)",
    "outcome": "Produced HR documents",
    "findings": [
     "E-01",
     "E-02",
     "E-03",
     "E-04",
     "E-05",
     "E-06",
     "E-07",
     "E-08",
     "E-09"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4729"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C04-1",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c04-1/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Request form",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #4814",
   "findings": [
    "E-14"
   ],
   "pages": "all (3)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "3 area(s) redacted",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "da233905b6ac0f339f37030d1bfc063ae6e9c45a2ae540161ae911bedcbc5d29",
   "orig_sha": "e0a08c0ff6082f31107c828ce73628509f1120604b10673c752722d470fbf7e5",
   "orig_shas": [
    "e0a08c0ff6082f31107c828ce73628509f1120604b10673c752722d470fbf7e5"
   ],
   "size": 3517445,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C04-1.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C04-1 - Request form.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "0ce24cca8461f3229d0f5681009661c75d99e7c7e5ef715c87ce77db6545e857",
   "changes": [
    "Redacted: 3 area(s) redacted",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (page 1); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 3,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4814",
    "subject": "Finance payment summaries FY16-present",
    "filed": "2026-09",
    "outcome": "Payroll registers; \"no FY subtotal\"; AP to come separately",
    "findings": [
     "E-14"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4814"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C04-2",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c04-2/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Request form as filed",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #4814",
   "findings": [
    "E-14"
   ],
   "pages": "all (3)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "1 area(s) redacted",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "d95fc0f5faf45946d2e936ad7d220ed1531dabfd1c9b0521ddbc9b82cec75e9e",
   "orig_sha": "27bd4518a7d0e70f68e8416dd69e6eaaf0e9014d9bee782d19a3c0f729b83b4e",
   "orig_shas": [
    "27bd4518a7d0e70f68e8416dd69e6eaaf0e9014d9bee782d19a3c0f729b83b4e"
   ],
   "size": 1599526,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C04-2.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C04-2 - Request form as filed.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "6628d57c9d81bb3df351f861e47ec47f5127c88c0b29ddb77cfb2015c49468bc",
   "changes": [
    "Redacted: 1 area(s) redacted",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (pages 1, 3); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 3,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4814",
    "subject": "Finance payment summaries FY16-present",
    "filed": "2026-09",
    "outcome": "Payroll registers; \"no FY subtotal\"; AP to come separately",
    "findings": [
     "E-14"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4814"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C04-3",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c04-3/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "City response - unavailable information",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #4814",
   "findings": [
    "E-14"
   ],
   "pages": "all (1)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "dc34efee5640d8cfb1ff4133ddfa759462a7eb4e553a1ec94cd878cf2c9392c4",
   "orig_sha": "53ed9269a129fea4093d1e64e254f59b53e2cba86ea5aa28c6760aea99969003",
   "orig_shas": [
    "53ed9269a129fea4093d1e64e254f59b53e2cba86ea5aa28c6760aea99969003"
   ],
   "size": 582121,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C04-3.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C04-3 - City response - unavailable information.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 1,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4814",
    "subject": "Finance payment summaries FY16-present",
    "filed": "2026-09",
    "outcome": "Payroll registers; \"no FY subtotal\"; AP to come separately",
    "findings": [
     "E-14"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4814"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C04-4",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c04-4/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Correspondence with the City, compiled in date order (with City attachments)",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #4814",
   "findings": [
    "E-14"
   ],
   "pages": "all (1); all (1); all (1); all (1)",
   "notes": "Each email rendered to PDF from the received message; bookmarks give date/sender/subject. Requester signature images omitted.",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "9886dbc0527415474fef7fb776906a841548fffbbd12de6732e7cd1a986ac838",
   "orig_sha": "5df2474b5f20e318de499565ae7a3e08f9ff56bea5fcb4ee4d4f9f2a38979e71\n29aca0d1ab922831fcd5fa7a4463cb1a2ebdd3f73fd3dae19959536da60eb7ca\n8d73ded1a445523b9e58fc4588f904b54747a8a0cc0497c96de318e655898ea0\n98e4599ef040826089db326ac69be93a4fd7a95fe8cbde6b229e558555308546",
   "orig_shas": [
    "5df2474b5f20e318de499565ae7a3e08f9ff56bea5fcb4ee4d4f9f2a38979e71",
    "29aca0d1ab922831fcd5fa7a4463cb1a2ebdd3f73fd3dae19959536da60eb7ca",
    "8d73ded1a445523b9e58fc4588f904b54747a8a0cc0497c96de318e655898ea0",
    "98e4599ef040826089db326ac69be93a4fd7a95fe8cbde6b229e558555308546"
   ],
   "size": 85512,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C04-4.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C04-4 - Correspondence with the City, compiled in date order (with City attachments).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "5aa4fa88d1d1a02ae91094f5cc69f21c0d57805be5688bdea6f187c2e1fa6cef",
   "changes": [
    "Combined from 4 files as released",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester email addresses redacted (pages 1, 2, 3, 4); City and other government addresses left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 4,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4814",
    "subject": "Finance payment summaries FY16-present",
    "filed": "2026-09",
    "outcome": "Payroll registers; \"no FY subtotal\"; AP to come separately",
    "findings": [
     "E-14"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4814"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C05-1",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c05-1/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Request form",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #4869",
   "findings": [
    "E-11"
   ],
   "pages": "all (3)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "3 area(s) redacted",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "c86dd84c6c0e0851b01e672ffefb03c6e2185356e0460127c6ddbf6fd56b8820",
   "orig_sha": "c4e2dc774639e3a95fcd90bfe5fd7080b072700aacd96f47f71e3dc681b7aab5",
   "orig_shas": [
    "c4e2dc774639e3a95fcd90bfe5fd7080b072700aacd96f47f71e3dc681b7aab5"
   ],
   "size": 3480756,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C05-1.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C05-1 - Request form.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "5fe9deaf0965a2266049a67828197878a9f21196cfb46d89ecc591a5d62e6dc7",
   "changes": [
    "Redacted: 3 area(s) redacted",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (page 1); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 3,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4869",
    "subject": "CM contract versions + handbook exceptions",
    "filed": "2026-09",
    "outcome": "Produced 2020/2024 agreements, letters; no 2015 agreement; no Council exception directives",
    "findings": [
     "E-11"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4869"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C05-2",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c05-2/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Request form as filed",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #4869",
   "findings": [
    "E-11"
   ],
   "pages": "all (2)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "1 area(s) redacted",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "51f52fe031d2f4cda77381cd0ffb13e2847082826da109a4992d32c655ac79ca",
   "orig_sha": "4c17870d510b0bf2ffc8eb6f1e51e11586bc90e1c2987736b7c5656e1caa343f",
   "orig_shas": [
    "4c17870d510b0bf2ffc8eb6f1e51e11586bc90e1c2987736b7c5656e1caa343f"
   ],
   "size": 1888234,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C05-2.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C05-2 - Request form as filed.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "259fee64982ca465f392c2d9a31f16cc20ded816a1c77221e56d78c962885bda",
   "changes": [
    "Redacted: 1 area(s) redacted",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (pages 1, 2); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 2,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4869",
    "subject": "CM contract versions + handbook exceptions",
    "filed": "2026-09",
    "outcome": "Produced 2020/2024 agreements, letters; no 2015 agreement; no Council exception directives",
    "findings": [
     "E-11"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4869"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C05-3",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c05-3/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Correspondence with the City, compiled in date order (with City attachments)",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #4869",
   "findings": [
    "E-11"
   ],
   "pages": "all (3); all (1); all (1); all (1); all (1); all (1)",
   "notes": "Each email rendered to PDF from the received message; bookmarks give date/sender/subject. Requester signature images omitted.",
   "redaction": "3 area(s) redacted",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "76304d711a9f1abf83dc1bf545c5bd51b7cb0c0187d6b229a34c599a307d3cfd",
   "orig_sha": "c4e2dc774639e3a95fcd90bfe5fd7080b072700aacd96f47f71e3dc681b7aab5\n4a96fd59a595f000b1c36160ec03ceb7dae599d3ca4ad4a527bc38a2aa0c7bf1\ne2d6c41a2748db61f053475246d4e323ff67ff3acb049c5f40e68684086407c9\ncc2093645f8fe0c3efe445f0ed89a6a5efa91215b09ff549f3a5df988835881e\n76e713727b960d036236d47c765428d4ad31aa5931abddfb9ed429790219814c\n20eac93c95544e2d5b913489ee0106dedf5b188d4685e19f888dd0462b8faf2a",
   "orig_shas": [
    "c4e2dc774639e3a95fcd90bfe5fd7080b072700aacd96f47f71e3dc681b7aab5",
    "4a96fd59a595f000b1c36160ec03ceb7dae599d3ca4ad4a527bc38a2aa0c7bf1",
    "e2d6c41a2748db61f053475246d4e323ff67ff3acb049c5f40e68684086407c9",
    "cc2093645f8fe0c3efe445f0ed89a6a5efa91215b09ff549f3a5df988835881e",
    "76e713727b960d036236d47c765428d4ad31aa5931abddfb9ed429790219814c",
    "20eac93c95544e2d5b913489ee0106dedf5b188d4685e19f888dd0462b8faf2a"
   ],
   "size": 3590131,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C05-3.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C05-3 - Correspondence with the City, compiled in date order (with City attachments).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "7e61007e3bb32f1241967d02e249743506e6d5b611581bbbc103952fc0b0a938",
   "changes": [
    "Combined from 6 files as released",
    "Redacted: 3 area(s) redacted",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (pages 1, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 8,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4869",
    "subject": "CM contract versions + handbook exceptions",
    "filed": "2026-09",
    "outcome": "Produced 2020/2024 agreements, letters; no 2015 agreement; no Council exception directives",
    "findings": [
     "E-11"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4869"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C06-1",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c06-1/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Request form",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #4940",
   "findings": [
    "E-14",
    "E-20"
   ],
   "pages": "all (6)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "3 area(s) redacted",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "a666d0bca0575d21cddc5e94e8d591ea7726cf0cf425ee9044076580baba12cb",
   "orig_sha": "087e289cdf586d0ee0cdecf5e9715ffb79255da186ae68bdb21272a46521d264",
   "orig_shas": [
    "087e289cdf586d0ee0cdecf5e9715ffb79255da186ae68bdb21272a46521d264"
   ],
   "size": 3502105,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C06-1.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C06-1 - Request form.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "8ae904237bdb9a26da0c0d21b9048d304d2952d386fac3e789aa51e6b39aac7e",
   "changes": [
    "Redacted: 3 area(s) redacted",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (page 1); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 6,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4940",
    "subject": "Follow-up/deficiency memo to #4814/#4729",
    "filed": "2026-10-05",
    "outcome": "No response after 26 working days as of Nov 10 (deemed denied Oct 20); five follow-ups unanswered",
    "findings": [
     "E-14"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4940"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C06-2",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c06-2/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Correspondence with the City, compiled in date order (with City attachments)",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #4940",
   "findings": [
    "E-14",
    "E-20"
   ],
   "pages": "all (6); all (1); all (1); all (1); all (1); all (1); all (2); all (2); all (2)",
   "notes": "Each email rendered to PDF from the received message; bookmarks give date/sender/subject. Requester signature images omitted.",
   "redaction": "3 area(s) redacted",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "eedc6841665fef2f50db10b0d729252c4667a9211c44c18f52482e0188613ade",
   "orig_sha": "087e289cdf586d0ee0cdecf5e9715ffb79255da186ae68bdb21272a46521d264\n0f7154adb7cacd16af03cb5be6e8d9fd079697c5b149691776cc09d3738be863\nf9128760a760d1e11d0127421005e5e8ed34d6b616465b992b2d85044a87b57d\n011a9968a863cb90d313d7d7739cf0e27659d92c15bbfbeca014dbc0306a528c\ne88f0fe6a4052a3f7441a14d388dd5a04c1238a99a3546a4326ceaaf728b2a21\n91398c0ea43ae0cedc4da8eb9e3bffd7f3f2da76e1774b1cc9f22ba0618f7ef6\n8d1aaa71549f6c94850af13e0a2a218dee708d43da34ac9e49501c437662e755\n4dad93744eae82f3e172ef925dc41ecb5a8c573948888cf162023bc1f4a33d87\n1c1802f6e5b5c2a8522a5f5ce4fa5db458501d42202505d0b8892e34902595b6",
   "orig_shas": [
    "087e289cdf586d0ee0cdecf5e9715ffb79255da186ae68bdb21272a46521d264",
    "0f7154adb7cacd16af03cb5be6e8d9fd079697c5b149691776cc09d3738be863",
    "f9128760a760d1e11d0127421005e5e8ed34d6b616465b992b2d85044a87b57d",
    "011a9968a863cb90d313d7d7739cf0e27659d92c15bbfbeca014dbc0306a528c",
    "e88f0fe6a4052a3f7441a14d388dd5a04c1238a99a3546a4326ceaaf728b2a21",
    "91398c0ea43ae0cedc4da8eb9e3bffd7f3f2da76e1774b1cc9f22ba0618f7ef6",
    "8d1aaa71549f6c94850af13e0a2a218dee708d43da34ac9e49501c437662e755",
    "4dad93744eae82f3e172ef925dc41ecb5a8c573948888cf162023bc1f4a33d87",
    "1c1802f6e5b5c2a8522a5f5ce4fa5db458501d42202505d0b8892e34902595b6"
   ],
   "size": 3649724,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C06-2.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C06-2 - Correspondence with the City, compiled in date order (with City attachments).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "24b81a0f040dfc98900db7e27714ebba3224055111fd276c69cc042472ca810f",
   "changes": [
    "Combined from 9 files as released",
    "Redacted: 3 area(s) redacted",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (pages 1, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 14, 15, 16, 17); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 17,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4940",
    "subject": "Follow-up/deficiency memo to #4814/#4729",
    "filed": "2026-10-05",
    "outcome": "No response after 26 working days as of Nov 10 (deemed denied Oct 20); five follow-ups unanswered",
    "findings": [
     "E-14"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4940"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C07-1",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c07-1/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Request form",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #4953",
   "findings": [
    "E-15",
    "E-22"
   ],
   "pages": "all (3)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "3 area(s) redacted",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "b9bb89d72838c11f432631cae0b15c8f085d89345b3f04e0a5320c12c415b13a",
   "orig_sha": "c98c87d9d1f079d1376891ad660034aee1817df2a8e9c0c7773bfd57358a0904",
   "orig_shas": [
    "c98c87d9d1f079d1376891ad660034aee1817df2a8e9c0c7773bfd57358a0904"
   ],
   "size": 3488125,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C07-1.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C07-1 - Request form.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "a59e01fcab93e787a827a359bdfb22ff2f71e404c18644bbbb9193a90ec9de93",
   "changes": [
    "Redacted: 3 area(s) redacted",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (page 1); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 3,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4953",
    "subject": "All executive exceptions to handbook",
    "filed": "2026-10",
    "outcome": "Denied: non-compliance with 74-102(4)",
    "findings": [
     "E-15"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4953"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C07-2",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c07-2/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Request form as filed",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #4953",
   "findings": [
    "E-15",
    "E-22"
   ],
   "pages": "all (3)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "1 area(s) redacted",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "cac1f994e61acc99cbd7d00af258bc1f03f7ea0476c4d11c32b9c9bcf816b40f",
   "orig_sha": "5efcbfced2e76623c411563d4640d1b53293cd229d024009ea9f3c6eda36a93d",
   "orig_shas": [
    "5efcbfced2e76623c411563d4640d1b53293cd229d024009ea9f3c6eda36a93d"
   ],
   "size": 1982550,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C07-2.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C07-2 - Request form as filed.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "1fc3fe2658cbac1a19b597d58faf10786bd093e8335b38787ec33978ada7cf80",
   "changes": [
    "Redacted: 1 area(s) redacted",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (pages 1, 3); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 3,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4953",
    "subject": "All executive exceptions to handbook",
    "filed": "2026-10",
    "outcome": "Denied: non-compliance with 74-102(4)",
    "findings": [
     "E-15"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4953"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C07-3",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c07-3/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "City response - unavailable information",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #4953",
   "findings": [
    "E-15",
    "E-22"
   ],
   "pages": "all (1)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "5dc5212165af9e6afdae747d296d93d5ec5bfa52ac97bb1bed58bb58f4551ec6",
   "orig_sha": "16a8a50da7a0d2db05d96b8d4568211f7fd080fc107b81b7a7434da23ca2a172",
   "orig_shas": [
    "16a8a50da7a0d2db05d96b8d4568211f7fd080fc107b81b7a7434da23ca2a172"
   ],
   "size": 310017,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C07-3.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C07-3 - City response - unavailable information.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 1,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4953",
    "subject": "All executive exceptions to handbook",
    "filed": "2026-10",
    "outcome": "Denied: non-compliance with 74-102(4)",
    "findings": [
     "E-15"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4953"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C07-4",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c07-4/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Correspondence with the City, compiled in date order (with City attachments)",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #4953",
   "findings": [
    "E-15",
    "E-22"
   ],
   "pages": "all (3); all (1); all (1); all (1); all (1); all (1); all (3); all (2); all (1); all (2); all (3); all (3); all (3); all (4); all (4); all (6); all (8); all (8); all (14); all (16)",
   "notes": "Each email rendered to PDF from the received message; bookmarks give date/sender/subject. Requester signature images omitted.",
   "redaction": "7 area(s) redacted",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "d4a2487250cb99fe3885ecf01110db6a6507615941c3fa6cf06142951f2d25b8",
   "orig_sha": "c98c87d9d1f079d1376891ad660034aee1817df2a8e9c0c7773bfd57358a0904\nfffa898532a350704057f56ccf840c409c69b40e5c09845d9d3d9c06ba364d69\ned21bf31d1dc5374187c70ab9f87aca3bdd576f39e413622899504140bbcdbb6\nbcfc6e42850fee31ee81bd130954a671c0efa977f48fc90b1b791f16aabcc349\n09e8ceaa7105d283f4cecf35d1cfe0a16137e069bae48f9f3b6cd322048cd900\n7a27e77afbb839a7ae7f9b76837309473954d8b5335dfb40d961917da304d65a\n5efcbfced2e76623c411563d4640d1b53293cd229d024009ea9f3c6eda36a93d\n43bea86b27491e06cfcc365e3a1d09b9f72ac3cd6a6997925e135b9773f1ab76\n5bcb505310d4c654032ed7c69faf9ffb8583346b675cca02375baf1912f50549\n223502539dde85c53c7c3994cc65fb90c34a09547a51ef459e588e98c24ce835\nc98c87d9d1f079d1376891ad660034aee1817df2a8e9c0c7773bfd57358a0904\ncc8768cf3103aac5eaf45190d9ad303ab47fd4b24643a5ba9a99ee8413819974\nd29184628b296fc48db4d8c3d2144be099c6ec0de69497200799c6fec5b19832\n8b26d375f4ce0ccabb9d6c6988e51c2ee6a726460be54a195f758e417d702174\n005beb3bb0fb8a99fbc75388b65c1525e6757080a1758296fffb4922ed579347\n0491d220bb7325637aa6ebfb370a67ac6c6a784546b1c815d07e98c3b202900f\n740f95413a76ac8c78ee402cb792492b485b73de72b33f5a2eec5256d5569305\n455ae973684692dc7b6a46f895a786170a41440a385b5c124bca4d109f530b1e\n0d2fcfe53b7eb38d031bbc25ec5a8107b7674e0c11216f93e1b73fb4ae47259d\n741983278337e4a8f41e8defe94daaa89fffe468506f36583a9e907d8c158cdf",
   "orig_shas": [
    "c98c87d9d1f079d1376891ad660034aee1817df2a8e9c0c7773bfd57358a0904",
    "fffa898532a350704057f56ccf840c409c69b40e5c09845d9d3d9c06ba364d69",
    "ed21bf31d1dc5374187c70ab9f87aca3bdd576f39e413622899504140bbcdbb6",
    "bcfc6e42850fee31ee81bd130954a671c0efa977f48fc90b1b791f16aabcc349",
    "09e8ceaa7105d283f4cecf35d1cfe0a16137e069bae48f9f3b6cd322048cd900",
    "7a27e77afbb839a7ae7f9b76837309473954d8b5335dfb40d961917da304d65a",
    "5efcbfced2e76623c411563d4640d1b53293cd229d024009ea9f3c6eda36a93d",
    "43bea86b27491e06cfcc365e3a1d09b9f72ac3cd6a6997925e135b9773f1ab76",
    "5bcb505310d4c654032ed7c69faf9ffb8583346b675cca02375baf1912f50549",
    "223502539dde85c53c7c3994cc65fb90c34a09547a51ef459e588e98c24ce835",
    "c98c87d9d1f079d1376891ad660034aee1817df2a8e9c0c7773bfd57358a0904",
    "cc8768cf3103aac5eaf45190d9ad303ab47fd4b24643a5ba9a99ee8413819974",
    "d29184628b296fc48db4d8c3d2144be099c6ec0de69497200799c6fec5b19832",
    "8b26d375f4ce0ccabb9d6c6988e51c2ee6a726460be54a195f758e417d702174",
    "005beb3bb0fb8a99fbc75388b65c1525e6757080a1758296fffb4922ed579347",
    "0491d220bb7325637aa6ebfb370a67ac6c6a784546b1c815d07e98c3b202900f",
    "740f95413a76ac8c78ee402cb792492b485b73de72b33f5a2eec5256d5569305",
    "455ae973684692dc7b6a46f895a786170a41440a385b5c124bca4d109f530b1e",
    "0d2fcfe53b7eb38d031bbc25ec5a8107b7674e0c11216f93e1b73fb4ae47259d",
    "741983278337e4a8f41e8defe94daaa89fffe468506f36583a9e907d8c158cdf"
   ],
   "size": 6041563,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C07-4.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C07-4 - Correspondence with the City, compiled in date order (with City attachments).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "376e312c877e293827aee8ebe33bdd4d3a22a8dce06520a64af9de9101ce057a",
   "changes": [
    "Combined from 20 files as released",
    "Redacted: 7 area(s) redacted",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (pages 1, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 11, 12, 14, 15, 16, 17, 20, 21, 23, 24, 26, 27, 28, 30, 31, 32, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 40, 41, 42, 43, 44, 45, 48, 49, 50, 51, 52, 53, 56, 57, 58, 60, 61, 65, 70, 71, 72, 73, 75, 76, 77, 81, 82); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 85,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#4953",
    "subject": "All executive exceptions to handbook",
    "filed": "2026-10",
    "outcome": "Denied: non-compliance with 74-102(4)",
    "findings": [
     "E-15"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4953"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C08-1",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c08-1/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Request form",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR (Leave records attempt 1 (denied))",
   "findings": [
    "E-21"
   ],
   "pages": "all (4)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "3 area(s) redacted",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "996073ee5869323273de61b0e2070d1f03cf021714362de035df6106c8ca3f2e",
   "orig_sha": "768f0b3cf5dcdeba8374d9719100192bacf4743341fb7a7ddf20281576f6186e",
   "orig_shas": [
    "768f0b3cf5dcdeba8374d9719100192bacf4743341fb7a7ddf20281576f6186e"
   ],
   "size": 3480817,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C08-1.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C08-1 - Request form.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "e2860e24f6670143f79e283fa9084c406fe4c39783f551046bef0f3bdf5bbdc9",
   "changes": [
    "Redacted: 3 area(s) redacted",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (page 1); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 4,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "From the City of Twin Falls' response to a public records request"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C08-2",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c08-2/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Correspondence with the City, compiled in date order (with City attachments)",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR (Leave records attempt 1 (denied))",
   "findings": [
    "E-21"
   ],
   "pages": "all (4); all (1); all (1)",
   "notes": "Each email rendered to PDF from the received message; bookmarks give date/sender/subject. Requester signature images omitted.",
   "redaction": "3 area(s) redacted",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "6f0c7b10177fe925f64757f6ff5d783e5c1e7cdd05a653f251e9ac05554052bb",
   "orig_sha": "768f0b3cf5dcdeba8374d9719100192bacf4743341fb7a7ddf20281576f6186e\nd7b0c96337e18863e73545819ea8f57502a5abeb948a20751a41f6d81f5e6805\n3189be5f09a2f37f482d1e9fa8a2ac1372762fbc1915986da940bc7773675044",
   "orig_shas": [
    "768f0b3cf5dcdeba8374d9719100192bacf4743341fb7a7ddf20281576f6186e",
    "d7b0c96337e18863e73545819ea8f57502a5abeb948a20751a41f6d81f5e6805",
    "3189be5f09a2f37f482d1e9fa8a2ac1372762fbc1915986da940bc7773675044"
   ],
   "size": 3542996,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C08-2.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C08-2 - Correspondence with the City, compiled in date order (with City attachments).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "20cfcfff58b37caa7734e5843933292eed4b3d42bd552e6e0c0114c69d562b53",
   "changes": [
    "Combined from 3 files as released",
    "Redacted: 3 area(s) redacted",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (pages 1, 5, 6); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 6,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "From the City of Twin Falls' response to a public records request"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C09-1",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c09-1/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Request form",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR (Leave records attempt 2 (denied))",
   "findings": [
    "E-21"
   ],
   "pages": "all (3)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "3 area(s) redacted",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "fbe3f41770341bf9fcc79e6676ac8845a41cfa12ce3b982474f8b914135a6327",
   "orig_sha": "151164ad969c462f0bbf1b87cf65ca11ea0e6d8a712cf047b97fb0f9e99c6e14",
   "orig_shas": [
    "151164ad969c462f0bbf1b87cf65ca11ea0e6d8a712cf047b97fb0f9e99c6e14"
   ],
   "size": 3487104,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C09-1.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C09-1 - Request form.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "b8e5dcf699e2c76c6b97ae15cbb55b1204947e6ccb72ae00056dfcd80b486af0",
   "changes": [
    "Redacted: 3 area(s) redacted",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (page 1); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 3,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "From the City of Twin Falls' response to a public records request"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C09-2",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c09-2/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Correspondence with the City, compiled in date order (with City attachments)",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR (Leave records attempt 2 (denied))",
   "findings": [
    "E-21"
   ],
   "pages": "all (3); all (1); all (1)",
   "notes": "Each email rendered to PDF from the received message; bookmarks give date/sender/subject. Requester signature images omitted.",
   "redaction": "3 area(s) redacted",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "e0bb3e6015fa973b838b41a454a6eb86f20be32a56edeb0cdbe97eb991aad62b",
   "orig_sha": "151164ad969c462f0bbf1b87cf65ca11ea0e6d8a712cf047b97fb0f9e99c6e14\n9203d3fddd7979987100b24cbf38b52160056c64b8b934d0ed4846003b578603\n38fd3881f93c7fc7f8add8891bdba5a8a90470a0d44fb001fa5f902bf049867d",
   "orig_shas": [
    "151164ad969c462f0bbf1b87cf65ca11ea0e6d8a712cf047b97fb0f9e99c6e14",
    "9203d3fddd7979987100b24cbf38b52160056c64b8b934d0ed4846003b578603",
    "38fd3881f93c7fc7f8add8891bdba5a8a90470a0d44fb001fa5f902bf049867d"
   ],
   "size": 3548849,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C09-2.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C09-2 - Correspondence with the City, compiled in date order (with City attachments).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "5fd7e8a51c64fbc6a0442f6c17af141942732b9b9dfbbb705340c1005a2f58a0",
   "changes": [
    "Combined from 3 files as released",
    "Redacted: 3 area(s) redacted",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (pages 1, 4, 5); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 5,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "From the City of Twin Falls' response to a public records request"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C10-1",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c10-1/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Request form",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR (Leave records attempt 3 (denied))",
   "findings": [
    "E-21"
   ],
   "pages": "all (4)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "3 area(s) redacted",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "933c63f29f9fd8c7c0f9374f5146fb5e1095cc88b4e754668bce0ee74013a996",
   "orig_sha": "94a075d2ca5553fada0d89ca9010fb24cc6a7eb86cc7d2216fc5015b3e14d165",
   "orig_shas": [
    "94a075d2ca5553fada0d89ca9010fb24cc6a7eb86cc7d2216fc5015b3e14d165"
   ],
   "size": 3501026,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C10-1.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C10-1 - Request form.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "e85b73c81edb603c14fe10dd79133ea62a574432f7320c95768c2ba09722c780",
   "changes": [
    "Redacted: 3 area(s) redacted",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (page 1); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 4,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "From the City of Twin Falls' response to a public records request"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C10-2",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c10-2/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Correspondence with the City, compiled in date order (with City attachments)",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR (Leave records attempt 3 (denied))",
   "findings": [
    "E-21"
   ],
   "pages": "all (4); all (1); all (1)",
   "notes": "Each email rendered to PDF from the received message; bookmarks give date/sender/subject. Requester signature images omitted.",
   "redaction": "3 area(s) redacted",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "5488e971fb2390922c2a63f754c9b8a8fe6e551d61afa784c30f9e9aa65bb600",
   "orig_sha": "94a075d2ca5553fada0d89ca9010fb24cc6a7eb86cc7d2216fc5015b3e14d165\nb5359fb7100d987c8da13cdf0097eaec08702c9e47ac8ec9c8d5a74463939be1\n35f599e54ee960f2ee4814cfb7010deb232951e5d2eaa996f76cc9b89d0763d2",
   "orig_shas": [
    "94a075d2ca5553fada0d89ca9010fb24cc6a7eb86cc7d2216fc5015b3e14d165",
    "b5359fb7100d987c8da13cdf0097eaec08702c9e47ac8ec9c8d5a74463939be1",
    "35f599e54ee960f2ee4814cfb7010deb232951e5d2eaa996f76cc9b89d0763d2"
   ],
   "size": 3562949,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C10-2.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C10-2 - Correspondence with the City, compiled in date order (with City attachments).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "24e7e3bf2d57e13611f59c5b680355e60c639dd750a524c3c67009b46aad0e99",
   "changes": [
    "Combined from 3 files as released",
    "Redacted: 3 area(s) redacted",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (pages 1, 5, 6); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 6,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "From the City of Twin Falls' response to a public records request"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C11-1",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c11-1/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Request form",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #5061",
   "findings": [
    "E-13"
   ],
   "pages": "all (2)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "4 area(s) redacted",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "e5544383945702fd48b1c46075535a7634fb318893d735c1f204e911806540bf",
   "orig_sha": "c715c47c7d9f9c5f3266c18b03a644b6b554267964bb78db4fd2417ee27b0e06",
   "orig_shas": [
    "c715c47c7d9f9c5f3266c18b03a644b6b554267964bb78db4fd2417ee27b0e06"
   ],
   "size": 3447768,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C11-1.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C11-1 - Request form.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "2f792d24f62a8026d21c853c58daac112dc6ac0a1b32b0a90b7d097d4336ad14",
   "changes": [
    "Redacted: 4 area(s) redacted",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (page 1); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 2,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#5061",
    "subject": "Copies of all PRRs Jun-Oct 2026",
    "filed": "2026-10-20",
    "outcome": "Denied: \"not a record held\" (Nov 2); second request denied Nov 3; third request filled as #5162",
    "findings": [
     "E-13"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #5061"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C11-2",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c11-2/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Request form as filed",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #5061",
   "findings": [
    "E-13"
   ],
   "pages": "all (1)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "1 area(s) redacted",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "2143805dc3d48e5f426e5b9fa03d1019ac5f37b3fa7e8c558bd2fe4e6e4c94d9",
   "orig_sha": "d5ad1e815cd665c0beb9e4d5793476c6089d3521c1ecf000eded51fb90be4c20",
   "orig_shas": [
    "d5ad1e815cd665c0beb9e4d5793476c6089d3521c1ecf000eded51fb90be4c20"
   ],
   "size": 788866,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C11-2.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C11-2 - Request form as filed.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "8d13bd7adcefff9755a09afa6a7a4f1538ce7eb3e1425b4ece44736ca07f645d",
   "changes": [
    "Redacted: 1 area(s) redacted",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (page 1); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 1,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#5061",
    "subject": "Copies of all PRRs Jun-Oct 2026",
    "filed": "2026-10-20",
    "outcome": "Denied: \"not a record held\" (Nov 2); second request denied Nov 3; third request filled as #5162",
    "findings": [
     "E-13"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #5061"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C11-3",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c11-3/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "City response - unavailable information",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #5061",
   "findings": [
    "E-13"
   ],
   "pages": "all (1)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "a5ec8791e3bfb507ff12cf91a1b366d082f99dd2028f5d69ac26854dd43b8865",
   "orig_sha": "222e6e7f3f8f53cac2811a3c88f2dbfed554578843b5c111da6183f13b82f05d",
   "orig_shas": [
    "222e6e7f3f8f53cac2811a3c88f2dbfed554578843b5c111da6183f13b82f05d"
   ],
   "size": 352570,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C11-3.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C11-3 - City response - unavailable information.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 1,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#5061",
    "subject": "Copies of all PRRs Jun-Oct 2026",
    "filed": "2026-10-20",
    "outcome": "Denied: \"not a record held\" (Nov 2); second request denied Nov 3; third request filled as #5162",
    "findings": [
     "E-13"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #5061"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C11-4",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c11-4/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Correspondence with the City, compiled in date order (with City attachments)",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR #5061",
   "findings": [
    "E-13"
   ],
   "pages": "all (2); all (1); all (1); all (1); all (1); all (1)",
   "notes": "Each email rendered to PDF from the received message; bookmarks give date/sender/subject. Requester signature images omitted.",
   "redaction": "4 area(s) redacted",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "25261f076e8d37d92d2c433fcf42b1c39d47d83a749321c66eae567cc36aef6c",
   "orig_sha": "c715c47c7d9f9c5f3266c18b03a644b6b554267964bb78db4fd2417ee27b0e06\nc0dde464b0a6ab4f360528801823618283289c8ccb73d98000d2a85335939f27\n35852113523a1b5282fd12163ee5925bd75c8c9039d7c3d117ed28590d6d90ba\n9470cff37d2088b032e1e31e8f42f71a1678dd1a94129c6059ea61ea0e713899\ne35ca7c007cd994676f75ef71cca4d4bf89bb65ccf827f309db9c8883f4c20ec\n523c5d772fdd95d9021e8af187c90f8aaaf8d5d2f835baa1501660671d65d781",
   "orig_shas": [
    "c715c47c7d9f9c5f3266c18b03a644b6b554267964bb78db4fd2417ee27b0e06",
    "c0dde464b0a6ab4f360528801823618283289c8ccb73d98000d2a85335939f27",
    "35852113523a1b5282fd12163ee5925bd75c8c9039d7c3d117ed28590d6d90ba",
    "9470cff37d2088b032e1e31e8f42f71a1678dd1a94129c6059ea61ea0e713899",
    "e35ca7c007cd994676f75ef71cca4d4bf89bb65ccf827f309db9c8883f4c20ec",
    "523c5d772fdd95d9021e8af187c90f8aaaf8d5d2f835baa1501660671d65d781"
   ],
   "size": 3557055,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C11-4.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C11-4 - Correspondence with the City, compiled in date order (with City attachments).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "25de1d7ce6eadc4ff06ec284ac1f0d48dbba0c71cdd38a2d1d83ce9223748ca0",
   "changes": [
    "Combined from 6 files as released",
    "Redacted: 4 area(s) redacted",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (pages 1, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 7,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#5061",
    "subject": "Copies of all PRRs Jun-Oct 2026",
    "filed": "2026-10-20",
    "outcome": "Denied: \"not a record held\" (Nov 2); second request denied Nov 3; third request filled as #5162",
    "findings": [
     "E-13"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #5061"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C12-1",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c12-1/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Request form",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR (Copies of records requests - second request)",
   "findings": [
    "E-13"
   ],
   "pages": "all (2)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "4 area(s) redacted",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "b43d1be94d3769661bfd2573b397186e07db07def0a5e40fdc1748bd2b604adf",
   "orig_sha": "552217759916e6bfb6e7ce2e79d9578f5764bff262179f2a8789a60b126247d7",
   "orig_shas": [
    "552217759916e6bfb6e7ce2e79d9578f5764bff262179f2a8789a60b126247d7"
   ],
   "size": 3448286,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C12-1.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C12-1 - Request form.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "d347df649f66e3f70c46c0bd91fe349c85f22d9e4f5378d2f0b340c6abab5af4",
   "changes": [
    "Redacted: 4 area(s) redacted",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (page 1); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 2,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "From the City of Twin Falls' response to a public records request"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C12-2",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c12-2/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Correspondence with the City, compiled in date order (with City attachments)",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR (Copies of records requests - second request)",
   "findings": [
    "E-13"
   ],
   "pages": "all (2); all (1); all (1)",
   "notes": "Each email rendered to PDF from the received message; bookmarks give date/sender/subject. Requester signature images omitted.",
   "redaction": "4 area(s) redacted",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "4b07bc6fcc2c6bf434b65ca276fa751c8366d6200a0b3c6b1c813afd4038d862",
   "orig_sha": "552217759916e6bfb6e7ce2e79d9578f5764bff262179f2a8789a60b126247d7\n5e1242c4c0c404072b1f01453a2eda3125fe3a652e06a96bab6c3c6b200372ac\nc4a641f49bdaa7d5fe8f5397bfa041343408c391d051c54dca9cb7da2bdfa2bd",
   "orig_shas": [
    "552217759916e6bfb6e7ce2e79d9578f5764bff262179f2a8789a60b126247d7",
    "5e1242c4c0c404072b1f01453a2eda3125fe3a652e06a96bab6c3c6b200372ac",
    "c4a641f49bdaa7d5fe8f5397bfa041343408c391d051c54dca9cb7da2bdfa2bd"
   ],
   "size": 3510530,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C12-2.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C12-2 - Correspondence with the City, compiled in date order (with City attachments).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "f395490e88c81640f7453c365b9b08a83b89131315415da80aac63f4fe38ef14",
   "changes": [
    "Combined from 3 files as released",
    "Redacted: 4 area(s) redacted",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (pages 1, 3, 4); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 4,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "From the City of Twin Falls' response to a public records request"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C13-1",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c13-1/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Request form",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR (Copies of records requests - third request)",
   "findings": [
    "E-13"
   ],
   "pages": "all (2)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "4 area(s) redacted",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "50655b8f7f10a53bd0783bf5d878c623be3aad237cc98bd34b533437be1d777f",
   "orig_sha": "2e869b431b1b656408d5633db321b87e62988c9f75b96bd39038a9ccc9f9e48e",
   "orig_shas": [
    "2e869b431b1b656408d5633db321b87e62988c9f75b96bd39038a9ccc9f9e48e"
   ],
   "size": 3460136,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C13-1.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C13-1 - Request form.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "ff8a1e992662d870e9500471506a6ad3ecbecd87853a9698983ee9d781b4a36b",
   "changes": [
    "Redacted: 4 area(s) redacted",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (pages 1, 2); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 2,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "From the City of Twin Falls' response to a public records request"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C13-2",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c13-2/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Correspondence with the City, compiled in date order (with City attachments)",
   "date": "",
   "source": "PRR (Copies of records requests - third request)",
   "findings": [
    "E-13"
   ],
   "pages": "all (2); all (1); all (1); all (2)",
   "notes": "Each email rendered to PDF from the received message; bookmarks give date/sender/subject. Requester signature images omitted.",
   "redaction": "4 area(s) redacted",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "af4506f09e8be16ce464ed1a2390fef811ee9b73b1f388b491eff2e099d26712",
   "orig_sha": "2e869b431b1b656408d5633db321b87e62988c9f75b96bd39038a9ccc9f9e48e\nc164eb42bfb943745f5b4c0314a1f341a8929235b8daff6c41e9e08ef0cab037\nc0681b704bd8edf329faaee736caaebf5ac943b7512994b3952f7331eede1872\n891f713150df29e005dd5f7057a2e693982850c0fa08a98b1eae84c3ba661a49",
   "orig_shas": [
    "2e869b431b1b656408d5633db321b87e62988c9f75b96bd39038a9ccc9f9e48e",
    "c164eb42bfb943745f5b4c0314a1f341a8929235b8daff6c41e9e08ef0cab037",
    "c0681b704bd8edf329faaee736caaebf5ac943b7512994b3952f7331eede1872",
    "891f713150df29e005dd5f7057a2e693982850c0fa08a98b1eae84c3ba661a49"
   ],
   "size": 3632553,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C13-2.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C13-2 - Correspondence with the City, compiled in date order (with City attachments).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "a529ccba9c3e905a27280e4231cbcecb47aaab92fce26e4518e3dab0c7746c28",
   "changes": [
    "Combined from 4 files as released",
    "Redacted: 4 area(s) redacted",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (pages 1, 2, 3, 4, 5); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 6,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "From the City of Twin Falls' response to a public records request"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C13-3",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c13-3/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Correspondence with the City, Nov 5-6 2026 - request filled as #5162",
   "date": "2026-11-05",
   "source": "PRR #5162",
   "findings": [
    "E-13"
   ],
   "pages": "all; all; all; all; all; all",
   "notes": "Six emails rendered to PDF from the received messages; bookmarks give date, sender and subject. The original hashes are of the rendered emails on file; each page also prints the hash of the received .eml.",
   "redaction": "Requester name and email removed; link to the delivered records removed",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "573f374d995f8ab3cc14c8e990e30d852ba8bdf4518e3fed70a7ea4c41b007f3",
   "orig_sha": "bc49b9c9e390b7dc00557a7138f711d177b01991a5c820658e91b72d95b0d0b2\n48edec93a22121ffe1433180968aca515d73d6b7d6fcfb3ea458dc3b55475d3e\n8d1becaf91d584e36e7325547e4da2dec9d689b4b16c736c708bd4811fe4eef9\nee2b92074505b89929592840348c82b52d7f756ce1f857963f7c41d5b4de9860\n9e8a48604b28311415b150f2866f4cb2f3529f791afc9eb4fe796f296b81455c\nee2584c70006b1983950a0b6f3e6de273b8a122cd8d3b0c618977c5dbbc2f472",
   "orig_shas": [
    "bc49b9c9e390b7dc00557a7138f711d177b01991a5c820658e91b72d95b0d0b2",
    "48edec93a22121ffe1433180968aca515d73d6b7d6fcfb3ea458dc3b55475d3e",
    "8d1becaf91d584e36e7325547e4da2dec9d689b4b16c736c708bd4811fe4eef9",
    "ee2b92074505b89929592840348c82b52d7f756ce1f857963f7c41d5b4de9860",
    "9e8a48604b28311415b150f2866f4cb2f3529f791afc9eb4fe796f296b81455c",
    "ee2584c70006b1983950a0b6f3e6de273b8a122cd8d3b0c618977c5dbbc2f472"
   ],
   "size": 62780,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C13-3.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C13-3 - Correspondence with the City, Nov 5-6 2026 - request filled as #5162.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Combined from 6 files as released",
    "Redacted: Requester name and email removed; link to the delivered records removed",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 8,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#5162",
    "subject": "Copies of records requests (third attempt)",
    "filed": "2026-11-03",
    "outcome": "Filled Nov 5, 2026: 1,183 request forms, no fee; extension notice sent Nov 6 after closure",
    "findings": [
     "E-13"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #5162"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C14-1",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c14-1/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Requester's copy of the submitted request form (Nov 18, 2026)",
   "date": "2026-11-18",
   "source": "PRR #5290 (requester's copy)",
   "findings": [],
   "pages": "all (2)",
   "notes": "The PDF of the form as submitted, created Nov 18, 2026 at 12:30 AM MST. Asks for electronic copies by email; the City's form states \"Requested records will be provided electronically.\" Document properties removed; the original's creation date is recorded in this note.",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "9926276f736bc5c9313f676d319390654ddb1f4e447cb193233fa92eb22e143a",
   "orig_sha": "dfaa54e17b4104f1653c10d3cf4c46775e115e579607731abea8b9ea5b054534",
   "orig_shas": [
    "dfaa54e17b4104f1653c10d3cf4c46775e115e579607731abea8b9ea5b054534"
   ],
   "size": 3473210,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C14-1.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C14-1 - Requester's copy of the submitted request form (Nov 18, 2026).pdf",
   "topics": [],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "0ce5d722a08beb0bde523d2283f11dfd32adbfa4a3eaebebfb2fabad3e56886a",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (pages 1, 2); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 2,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#5290",
    "subject": "City Manager employment agreements and written amendments since Oct 2014; City Attorney agreement",
    "filed": "2026-11-18",
    "outcome": "Nov 18: City Attorney reviewed, access granted, but records offered only by in-person pickup at City Hall \"due to the substantial volume of records requested\"; no date. Nov 19, 8:11 AM, after the requester asked for email delivery: \"Per our City attorney\" a signed residency declaration under penalty of perjury, with printed name and home address, is required \"before we can move forward.\" No statute cited; the delivery question not answered.",
    "findings": [],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "The requester's own copy of the request as submitted for public records request #5290, saved at the time of submission. It is not a record the City released"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C14-2",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c14-2/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Correspondence with the City, Nov 18-19 2026 - pickup only, then a sworn declaration",
   "date": "2026-11-18",
   "source": "PRR #5290",
   "findings": [],
   "pages": "all (7)",
   "notes": "Four emails rendered to PDF from the messages; bookmarks give date, sender and subject; each page prints the hash of the .eml. Nov 18: request being processed; the City Attorney reviewed it and access is granted, but records are offered only by in-person pickup \"due to the substantial volume of records requested,\" with no date. Nov 19, 5:12 AM: the requester asks for email delivery as requested, citing the City's form (\"Requested records will be provided electronically\") and I.C. 74-102(4), and asks for any refusal in writing with the statute and appeal rights (I.C. 74-103(4)). Nov 19, 8:11 AM: \"Per our City attorney\" the City requires a signed declaration, under penalty of perjury, with the requester's printed name and home address and an Idaho-residency choice, before it will move forward. The City's reply does not answer the delivery question or cite a statute.",
   "redaction": "Requester email and home city replaced; requester name redacted by the redaction run; signature logos omitted",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "7c1ce7a2474217a8335653683de4851dd032e8a881003fc1f2b0ae16c785d1b7",
   "orig_sha": "79475647605133b2843e3032f7165e6633ee256895f79c5323f6e4410a7ae584\nc1c8e68c901a1d67146ea4910d210efd5fb2565a3789363630dd35fc5b8e8fbd\nc9896e1b4619682ab7a60aa24a5066bbf366098719740241d0c355433fc363c5\nb05d6f9cdd01529a0a03e39dbece38c87c089d78dc89951543bac85eef551685",
   "orig_shas": [
    "79475647605133b2843e3032f7165e6633ee256895f79c5323f6e4410a7ae584",
    "c1c8e68c901a1d67146ea4910d210efd5fb2565a3789363630dd35fc5b8e8fbd",
    "c9896e1b4619682ab7a60aa24a5066bbf366098719740241d0c355433fc363c5",
    "b05d6f9cdd01529a0a03e39dbece38c87c089d78dc89951543bac85eef551685"
   ],
   "size": 56803,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C14-2.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C14-2 - Correspondence with the City, Nov 18-19 2026 - pickup only, then a sworn declaration.pdf",
   "topics": [],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "4d8267027ac553d1f88fb2d59ef34a9c4fff16f1605c954ec64f4b053465a218",
   "changes": [
    "Combined from 4 files as released",
    "Redacted: Requester email and home city replaced; requester name redacted by the redaction run; signature logos omitted",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (pages 3, 5, 6); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 7,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#5290",
    "subject": "City Manager employment agreements and written amendments since Oct 2014; City Attorney agreement",
    "filed": "2026-11-18",
    "outcome": "Nov 18: City Attorney reviewed, access granted, but records offered only by in-person pickup at City Hall \"due to the substantial volume of records requested\"; no date. Nov 19, 8:11 AM, after the requester asked for email delivery: \"Per our City attorney\" a signed residency declaration under penalty of perjury, with printed name and home address, is required \"before we can move forward.\" No statute cited; the delivery question not answered.",
    "findings": [],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #5290"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-D01",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-d01/",
   "group": "D",
   "description": "Idaho AG Public Records Law Manual",
   "date": "",
   "source": "Public (Idaho AG)",
   "findings": [],
   "pages": "all (78)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "bd4c94c9ab7a19edd40990530b01e8baac0adfaa0774c62abe339921725ee044",
   "orig_sha": "8dafeb5759583141a66d5c0adc6560c56ad1cccc7fe186b756df3e53754997aa",
   "orig_shas": [
    "8dafeb5759583141a66d5c0adc6560c56ad1cccc7fe186b756df3e53754997aa"
   ],
   "size": 802157,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-D01.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-D01 - Idaho AG Public Records Law Manual.pdf",
   "topics": [],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "1d2a2ae1070a3493094579d2ed4c71421acfb36ec0ef218d5a415ef57f159aab",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester email addresses redacted (pages 74, 75, 77, 78); City and other government addresses left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 78,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Published by the Idaho Attorney General at ag.idaho.gov"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-D02",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-d02/",
   "group": "D",
   "description": "Idaho AG Open Meeting Law Manual",
   "date": "",
   "source": "Public (Idaho AG)",
   "findings": [],
   "pages": "all (44)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "6bf4bbb42dc1dd102bf359e5d243de8304aec2df18f904edf3aadc7ff39fd27a",
   "orig_sha": "d41729e7eb2725151e7f50a4c02eeec86a398ba3abb7a9e20da3ac8cf9cfe046",
   "orig_shas": [
    "d41729e7eb2725151e7f50a4c02eeec86a398ba3abb7a9e20da3ac8cf9cfe046"
   ],
   "size": 996155,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-D02.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-D02 - Idaho AG Open Meeting Law Manual.pdf",
   "topics": [],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 44,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Published by the Idaho Attorney General at ag.idaho.gov"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-D03",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-d03/",
   "group": "D",
   "description": "Idaho AG Ethics in Government Manual",
   "date": "",
   "source": "Public (Idaho AG)",
   "findings": [],
   "pages": "all (53)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "2d4e0ce49284d86bc842d40afa608c63f601b4c85a5e207152e5468eb8141401",
   "orig_sha": "1d3f6f14512a2f66dea94d609160d0645bbc0ad3c4f651b3b88f225bd27bf052",
   "orig_shas": [
    "1d3f6f14512a2f66dea94d609160d0645bbc0ad3c4f651b3b88f225bd27bf052"
   ],
   "size": 531291,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-D03.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-D03 - Idaho AG Ethics in Government Manual.pdf",
   "topics": [],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 53,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Published by the Idaho Attorney General at ag.idaho.gov"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-D04",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-d04/",
   "group": "D",
   "description": "Idaho Code Title 74 Chapter 1 - Public Records Act",
   "date": "",
   "source": "Public (Idaho Legislature)",
   "findings": [],
   "pages": "all (33)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "08c0e571cf1018dd59d8cd760d3ddaa11c9073ae36039b822383fbad31bde767",
   "orig_sha": "4d80102571988d01e55ac62c666358f617c216ffda2df7b43a99ab9ff40e7c20",
   "orig_shas": [
    "4d80102571988d01e55ac62c666358f617c216ffda2df7b43a99ab9ff40e7c20"
   ],
   "size": 235709,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-D04.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-D04 - Idaho Code Title 74 Chapter 1 - Public Records Act.pdf",
   "topics": [],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 33,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": {
    "url": "https://legislature.idaho.gov/wp-content/uploads/statutesrules/idstat/Title74/T74CH1.pdf",
    "when": "2026-11-08",
    "via": "",
    "captured": ""
   },
   "provenance": "Downloaded from https://legislature.idaho.gov/wp-content/uploads/statutesrules/idstat/Title74/T74CH1.pdf on 2026-11-08"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-D05",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-d05/",
   "group": "D",
   "description": "Idaho Code Title 74 Chapter 2 - Open Meetings Law",
   "date": "",
   "source": "Public (Idaho Legislature)",
   "findings": [],
   "pages": "all (7)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "8da958c340b5364486719eac84dba55f755fa4b611f93db9a6e899f87ebdceb7",
   "orig_sha": "4ebd041d3f3b6d61718c3e0a771c802ff4c3d546ea7facd69a9a823c9631a87e",
   "orig_shas": [
    "4ebd041d3f3b6d61718c3e0a771c802ff4c3d546ea7facd69a9a823c9631a87e"
   ],
   "size": 68126,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-D05.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-D05 - Idaho Code Title 74 Chapter 2 - Open Meetings Law.pdf",
   "topics": [],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 7,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": {
    "url": "https://legislature.idaho.gov/wp-content/uploads/statutesrules/idstat/Title74/T74CH2.pdf",
    "when": "2026-11-08",
    "via": "",
    "captured": ""
   },
   "provenance": "Downloaded from https://legislature.idaho.gov/wp-content/uploads/statutesrules/idstat/Title74/T74CH2.pdf on 2026-11-08"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-D06",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-d06/",
   "group": "D",
   "description": "Idaho Code Title 74 Chapter 4 - Ethics in Government",
   "date": "",
   "source": "Public (Idaho Legislature)",
   "findings": [
    "E-25"
   ],
   "pages": "all (5)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "e03511901a58854a75217674ac00f4458a9d416d19efefdbbe2a6436ea21fe87",
   "orig_sha": "bea241f13acc1cbbbd13275c90f5ee488202be06272da79dfcf32a150bd95440",
   "orig_shas": [
    "bea241f13acc1cbbbd13275c90f5ee488202be06272da79dfcf32a150bd95440"
   ],
   "size": 50457,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-D06.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-D06 - Idaho Code Title 74 Chapter 4 - Ethics in Government.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "contracts-ethics"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 5,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": {
    "url": "https://legislature.idaho.gov/wp-content/uploads/statutesrules/idstat/Title74/T74CH4.pdf",
    "when": "2026-11-08",
    "via": "",
    "captured": ""
   },
   "provenance": "Downloaded from https://legislature.idaho.gov/wp-content/uploads/statutesrules/idstat/Title74/T74CH4.pdf on 2026-11-08"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-D07",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-d07/",
   "group": "D",
   "description": "Idaho Code Title 74 Chapter 5 - Prohibitions Against Contracts With Officers",
   "date": "",
   "source": "Public (Idaho Legislature)",
   "findings": [],
   "pages": "all (3)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "cba3e7420deac3cf6008b2d9b0ab8b7aaed21ac2b963224c4916049e22622daf",
   "orig_sha": "da206e3e96a702f7adc60edca55ac71932bea69296a61da91732f7e0bf2f229f",
   "orig_shas": [
    "da206e3e96a702f7adc60edca55ac71932bea69296a61da91732f7e0bf2f229f"
   ],
   "size": 41176,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-D07.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-D07 - Idaho Code Title 74 Chapter 5 - Prohibitions Against Contracts With Officers.pdf",
   "topics": [],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 3,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": {
    "url": "https://legislature.idaho.gov/wp-content/uploads/statutesrules/idstat/Title74/T74CH5.pdf",
    "when": "2026-11-08",
    "via": "",
    "captured": ""
   },
   "provenance": "Downloaded from https://legislature.idaho.gov/wp-content/uploads/statutesrules/idstat/Title74/T74CH5.pdf on 2026-11-08"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-D08",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-d08/",
   "group": "D",
   "description": "Idaho Code Title 74 Chapter 6 - Public Integrity in Elections Act",
   "date": "",
   "source": "Public (Idaho Legislature)",
   "findings": [],
   "pages": "all (4)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "dc720c2528852fb4e422fa0c7b47303c01669cbe709194ba2d1befb348db0087",
   "orig_sha": "a8e2803b0914d5aa802bfe0b74d0b27f8cf4a2191ba1e2d4861eeb595122bb58",
   "orig_shas": [
    "a8e2803b0914d5aa802bfe0b74d0b27f8cf4a2191ba1e2d4861eeb595122bb58"
   ],
   "size": 45252,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-D08.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-D08 - Idaho Code Title 74 Chapter 6 - Public Integrity in Elections Act.pdf",
   "topics": [],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 4,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": {
    "url": "https://legislature.idaho.gov/wp-content/uploads/statutesrules/idstat/Title74/T74CH6.pdf",
    "when": "2026-11-08",
    "via": "",
    "captured": ""
   },
   "provenance": "Downloaded from https://legislature.idaho.gov/wp-content/uploads/statutesrules/idstat/Title74/T74CH6.pdf on 2026-11-08"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-D09",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-d09/",
   "group": "D",
   "description": "Idaho Code Title 74 Chapter 7 - Lobbying Disclosure",
   "date": "",
   "source": "Public (Idaho Legislature)",
   "findings": [],
   "pages": "all (9)",
   "notes": "",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "c77780703664aef2f72eea11a1ff652892fca9213d87f073eb19509462d9d241",
   "orig_sha": "451832fdfcf9c88868af0763bc61f58bb3bf686d00b7bff81f3da220978e38ce",
   "orig_shas": [
    "451832fdfcf9c88868af0763bc61f58bb3bf686d00b7bff81f3da220978e38ce"
   ],
   "size": 80240,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-D09.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-D09 - Idaho Code Title 74 Chapter 7 - Lobbying Disclosure.pdf",
   "topics": [],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 9,
   "request": null,
   "retrieved": {
    "url": "https://legislature.idaho.gov/wp-content/uploads/statutesrules/idstat/Title74/T74CH7.pdf",
    "when": "2026-11-08",
    "via": "",
    "captured": ""
   },
   "provenance": "Downloaded from https://legislature.idaho.gov/wp-content/uploads/statutesrules/idstat/Title74/T74CH7.pdf on 2026-11-08"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C15-1",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c15-1/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Requester's copy of the submitted request form (Nov 17, 2026)",
   "date": "2026-11-17",
   "source": "PRR #5293 (requester's copy)",
   "findings": [
    "E-06",
    "E-22"
   ],
   "pages": "all (2)",
   "notes": "The PDF of the form as submitted Nov 17, 2026 at 11:47 PM MST (the City's emailed copy of the form is the same file). Five numbered items: committee membership records for City Manager and City Attorney evaluations since 2014; any Council rule or code on how committees are created; that committee's notices, agendas and minutes; its written recommendations on compensation; and the minutes of 14 listed executive sessions. Every required field was filled in. Document properties removed.",
   "redaction": "Requester name, address, city, state, ZIP, phone, email and signature redacted by the redaction run",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "fc0de7ce241f2e19292815bfacf85b86725ec00df844135526b20d324c49117c",
   "orig_sha": "2320522a7187e2a45b2445700e0eb20cd35eb6cbd0eeda425b648c07ddffe3f8",
   "orig_shas": [
    "2320522a7187e2a45b2445700e0eb20cd35eb6cbd0eeda425b648c07ddffe3f8"
   ],
   "size": 3469460,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C15-1.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C15-1 - Requester's copy of the submitted request form (Nov 17, 2026).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "open-meetings",
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "babb6c59646b1943865841eda94500afee2d9abcbd8c0e4ccd79c6c2589875fe",
   "changes": [
    "Redacted: Requester name, address, city, state, ZIP, phone, email and signature redacted by the redaction run",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (pages 1, 2); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 2,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#5293",
    "subject": "Council committee for City Manager / City Attorney evaluations: membership, rules on committees, notices and minutes, compensation recommendations, minutes of 14 executive sessions (2014-present)",
    "filed": "2026-11-17",
    "outcome": "Denied Nov 20 (within 3 working days), one page: \"not in possession of a report or record of that nature\" and \"denied under Idaho Code 74-102(4\" (cut off). No item-by-item answer; no statute tied to any item; nothing was asked of the requester first. The City's delivery folder held only the denial and its own copy of the request.",
    "findings": [
     "E-06",
     "E-22",
     "E-05"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "The requester's own copy of the request as submitted for public records request #5293, saved at the time of submission. It is not a record the City released"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C15-2",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c15-2/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "City notices, Nov 17-20 2026 - received, processing, final review, result",
   "date": "2026-11-17",
   "source": "PRR #5293",
   "findings": [
    "E-06",
    "E-22"
   ],
   "pages": "all (4)",
   "notes": "Four automated City emails rendered to PDF; bookmarks give date and subject; each page prints the hash of the .eml. Received Nov 17 11:47 PM; processing Nov 18 1:16 PM; final review Nov 18 4:50 PM; result Nov 20 9:09 AM (\"Fulfilled Request ... This request is now concluded\"), linking to the City's delivery folder, which held EX-C15-3 and EX-C15-4.",
   "redaction": "Requester email replaced; the City's expiring delivery link removed",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "0c7a1cb55a0d0d1ac6c708620bdaff30e05162c37104ff78ceb1dba501e9418c",
   "orig_sha": "48ca68c77cfbf74cacadb2bc393d90c322be9de68fd5ce48565ebd206d8969bd\nef609708eff38a4fe5855279e1bab13dcd5c09ad7e6b46a7ab24a05e73c19012\ne46842afaf3ca855553588c127b418d776886bb058de6e15be26ad6d83a75f2e\nc547a8cad009491f562175cee1b690c63f13e4d0c243b20283c5578d2c8d5a47",
   "orig_shas": [
    "48ca68c77cfbf74cacadb2bc393d90c322be9de68fd5ce48565ebd206d8969bd",
    "ef609708eff38a4fe5855279e1bab13dcd5c09ad7e6b46a7ab24a05e73c19012",
    "e46842afaf3ca855553588c127b418d776886bb058de6e15be26ad6d83a75f2e",
    "c547a8cad009491f562175cee1b690c63f13e4d0c243b20283c5578d2c8d5a47"
   ],
   "size": 46805,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C15-2.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C15-2 - City notices, Nov 17-20 2026 - received, processing, final review, result.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "open-meetings",
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Combined from 4 files as released",
    "Redacted: Requester email replaced; the City's expiring delivery link removed",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 4,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#5293",
    "subject": "Council committee for City Manager / City Attorney evaluations: membership, rules on committees, notices and minutes, compensation recommendations, minutes of 14 executive sessions (2014-present)",
    "filed": "2026-11-17",
    "outcome": "Denied Nov 20 (within 3 working days), one page: \"not in possession of a report or record of that nature\" and \"denied under Idaho Code 74-102(4\" (cut off). No item-by-item answer; no statute tied to any item; nothing was asked of the requester first. The City's delivery folder held only the denial and its own copy of the request.",
    "findings": [
     "E-06",
     "E-22",
     "E-05"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #5293"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C15-3",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c15-3/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "City response, Nov 20 2026 - not in possession, denied under I.C. 74-102(4)",
   "date": "2026-11-20",
   "source": "PRR #5293",
   "findings": [
    "E-06",
    "E-22"
   ],
   "pages": "all (1)",
   "notes": "The City's whole answer, one page: \"we are not in possession of a report or record of that nature,\" a suggestion to narrow the request or call the department, and \"Your request is denied under Idaho Code 74-102(4\" (the citation is cut off in the City's letter). It does not answer the five items separately or say which item the statute applies to. I.C. 74-102(4) is the requester-information and residency subsection; the City did not ask this requester for anything before denying. Not in the City's answer: Resolution 1912 (Council committees, Section 3) is in the City's own Council packets, and the 2014 committee appointment is in the City's own minutes (EX-B01).",
   "redaction": "",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "f34c6e067c7a97ba1a34be87717861bf65baa6b304cb59a18f59adb5d6e0fdce",
   "orig_sha": "e5ec4d10241f38b6293c9c63097c0421fb40354c052b6571e447ecff22034a98",
   "orig_shas": [
    "e5ec4d10241f38b6293c9c63097c0421fb40354c052b6571e447ecff22034a98"
   ],
   "size": 312624,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C15-3.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C15-3 - City response, Nov 20 2026 - not in possession, denied under I.C. 74-102(4).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "open-meetings",
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 1,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#5293",
    "subject": "Council committee for City Manager / City Attorney evaluations: membership, rules on committees, notices and minutes, compensation recommendations, minutes of 14 executive sessions (2014-present)",
    "filed": "2026-11-17",
    "outcome": "Denied Nov 20 (within 3 working days), one page: \"not in possession of a report or record of that nature\" and \"denied under Idaho Code 74-102(4\" (cut off). No item-by-item answer; no statute tied to any item; nothing was asked of the requester first. The City's delivery folder held only the denial and its own copy of the request.",
    "findings": [
     "E-06",
     "E-22",
     "E-05"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #5293"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C15-4",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c15-4/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "City's copy of the request as received, delivered with the response (Nov 20, 2026)",
   "date": "2026-11-17",
   "source": "PRR #5293",
   "findings": [
    "E-22"
   ],
   "pages": "all (2)",
   "notes": "The City's own record of the request, delivered in the same folder as the denial: timestamp 11/17/2026 23:47:04, type Personal, department Admin. This copy shows no address, phone or email fields. The City's file name carried the requester's name and was replaced.",
   "redaction": "Requester name and signature redacted by the redaction run",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "5a00437839e8ba0a4525d693f0393469b6b1eda8a42454d75913dc21dbd68efc",
   "orig_sha": "9ddf1ca4d636014a475c8ea4bd0d1c8cf69c9736045c4c6b85f80f848bf064bb",
   "orig_shas": [
    "9ddf1ca4d636014a475c8ea4bd0d1c8cf69c9736045c4c6b85f80f848bf064bb"
   ],
   "size": 1664921,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C15-4.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C15-4 - City's copy of the request as received, delivered with the response (Nov 20, 2026).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "e1171f141b81fb10c59ce81752f3c9c9467ac06fe0951ab1bd2aff1a4bcd5bad",
   "changes": [
    "Redacted: Requester name and signature redacted by the redaction run",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (pages 1, 2); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 2,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#5293",
    "subject": "Council committee for City Manager / City Attorney evaluations: membership, rules on committees, notices and minutes, compensation recommendations, minutes of 14 executive sessions (2014-present)",
    "filed": "2026-11-17",
    "outcome": "Denied Nov 20 (within 3 working days), one page: \"not in possession of a report or record of that nature\" and \"denied under Idaho Code 74-102(4\" (cut off). No item-by-item answer; no statute tied to any item; nothing was asked of the requester first. The City's delivery folder held only the denial and its own copy of the request.",
    "findings": [
     "E-06",
     "E-22",
     "E-05"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #5293"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C16-1",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c16-1/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Requester's copy of the submitted request form (Nov 15, 2026)",
   "date": "2026-11-15",
   "source": "PRR #5254 (requester's copy)",
   "findings": [
    "E-31",
    "E-14"
   ],
   "pages": "all (2)",
   "notes": "The PDF of the form as submitted Nov 15, 2026 at 12:06 AM MST. Asks for (1) the fiscal 2026 accounts payable payment register as a standard report or export and (2) the accounts payable reports presented to the Council for approval. States Idaho residency and lists an attached residency declaration (the declaration itself is not part of this record). Document properties removed.",
   "redaction": "Requester name, address, city, state, ZIP, phone, email and signature redacted by the redaction run",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "5dd82940aeec3840fc592b9886d1b0ae648bf729add3517fc2af478eb089a672",
   "orig_sha": "9ae552ea1d3804033ca74656f40440b8f3bb680cc5f5941c21da1e29ea7e9404",
   "orig_shas": [
    "9ae552ea1d3804033ca74656f40440b8f3bb680cc5f5941c21da1e29ea7e9404"
   ],
   "size": 3475273,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C16-1.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C16-1 - Requester's copy of the submitted request form (Nov 15, 2026).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "financial-transparency",
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "eebdc72f414fbe6ef79a16c4f482d19c96aa68a3aae8323aa4f2bcdb29ad5b78",
   "changes": [
    "Redacted: Requester name, address, city, state, ZIP, phone, email and signature redacted by the redaction run",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (pages 1, 2); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 2,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#5254",
    "subject": "Accounts payable payment register and Council AP reports, fiscal year 2026 (Oct 1, 2025 to Sep 30, 2026)",
    "filed": "2026-11-15",
    "outcome": "Produced Nov 17, 2026, inside the 3 working days, with no fee: the FY2026 Invoice Distribution Report (.xlsx, and the same report as a 292-page PDF) and weekly check-run, payroll-remittance and prepaid proof lists (PDF). No invoices. A 10-working-day extension notice followed at 10:06 PM the same day, after delivery.",
    "findings": [
     "E-31",
     "E-14"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "The requester's own copy of the request as submitted for public records request #5254, saved at the time of submission. It is not a record the City released"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C16-2",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c16-2/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "City notices, Nov 15-17 2026 - received, processing, final review, result, extension",
   "date": "2026-11-15",
   "source": "PRR #5254",
   "findings": [
    "E-31",
    "E-14"
   ],
   "pages": "all (5)",
   "notes": "Five automated City emails rendered to PDF; bookmarks give date and subject; each page prints the hash of the .eml. Received Nov 15 12:06 AM; processing Nov 16 7:36 AM; final review Nov 16 5:55 PM; result Nov 17 10:35 AM (\"Fulfilled Request ... This request is now concluded\"); then a 10-working-day extension notice at 10:06 PM on Nov 17, after the records had been delivered.",
   "redaction": "Requester email replaced; the City's expiring delivery link removed",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "6462469a7846c03ad9d6be7aaefb101de43b1e3986040158cf272ae27b8f461e",
   "orig_sha": "b473d1f9ca47863f8194b51e95fcd86fe5a59d8ce69d90daaf700500a24f10c5\n1204e6333e4b6bdd992516615d9c235cb72d04e2f7e7357e783dd87933d83cf1\n1cf0379e1e726d51da6102d7f55eae0a539a935384df0edc7d8f146851cd8e93\n54532e4d3c728a38dedef8fcf57cf1000fd558d61ae65340d63573a4e834dd75\n8385b6fc50390b645cc4eb05164444c1e9518649523d705458f963464528a902",
   "orig_shas": [
    "b473d1f9ca47863f8194b51e95fcd86fe5a59d8ce69d90daaf700500a24f10c5",
    "1204e6333e4b6bdd992516615d9c235cb72d04e2f7e7357e783dd87933d83cf1",
    "1cf0379e1e726d51da6102d7f55eae0a539a935384df0edc7d8f146851cd8e93",
    "54532e4d3c728a38dedef8fcf57cf1000fd558d61ae65340d63573a4e834dd75",
    "8385b6fc50390b645cc4eb05164444c1e9518649523d705458f963464528a902"
   ],
   "size": 50532,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C16-2.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C16-2 - City notices, Nov 15-17 2026 - received, processing, final review, result, extension.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "financial-transparency",
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Combined from 5 files as released",
    "Redacted: Requester email replaced; the City's expiring delivery link removed",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "page_count": 5,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#5254",
    "subject": "Accounts payable payment register and Council AP reports, fiscal year 2026 (Oct 1, 2025 to Sep 30, 2026)",
    "filed": "2026-11-15",
    "outcome": "Produced Nov 17, 2026, inside the 3 working days, with no fee: the FY2026 Invoice Distribution Report (.xlsx, and the same report as a 292-page PDF) and weekly check-run, payroll-remittance and prepaid proof lists (PDF). No invoices. A 10-working-day extension notice followed at 10:06 PM the same day, after delivery.",
    "findings": [
     "E-31",
     "E-14"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #5254"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C17-1",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c17-1/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Requester's copy of the submitted request form (Nov 17, 2026)",
   "date": "2026-11-17",
   "source": "PRR #5299 (requester's copy)",
   "findings": [
    "E-31",
    "E-14"
   ],
   "pages": "all (2)",
   "notes": "The PDF of the form as submitted Nov 17, 2026 at 11:19 PM MST. Asks for the accounts payable payment register for fiscal years 2020-2025 (one file per year preferred) and the Council AP reports if they are a different record. Asks that, if all six years would exceed the free allowance, the City produce the most recent years first, one year at a time, and send an itemized estimate for the rest. States Idaho residency. Document properties removed.",
   "redaction": "Requester name, address, city, state, ZIP, phone, email and signature redacted by the redaction run",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "ef7a36cf1cd3cc049032a4002bdaed92ecd7befa7d4f3f4aabf97c21cc54e23e",
   "orig_sha": "d90d776815b85201b979fe56a3ad1ab67057616d531e9cc62078a4c6cb721874",
   "orig_shas": [
    "d90d776815b85201b979fe56a3ad1ab67057616d531e9cc62078a4c6cb721874"
   ],
   "size": 3472408,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C17-1.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C17-1 - Requester's copy of the submitted request form (Nov 17, 2026).pdf",
   "topics": [
    "financial-transparency",
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "81686acb43217295add7c610097200f54fe217935fdb6e0493ae1e876a614fe1",
   "changes": [
    "Redacted: Requester name, address, city, state, ZIP, phone, email and signature redacted by the redaction run",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (pages 1, 2); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 2,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#5299",
    "subject": "Accounts payable register, fiscal years 2020-2025 (follow-up to #5254)",
    "filed": "2026-11-17",
    "outcome": "Nov 18: aggregated with #5254 under I.C. 74-102(11), 12 hours / $567.48 advance payment (Budget Coordinator $47.29/hr), though the City says it is 'not suggesting' fee avoidance. Requester narrowed to the Excel report only. Nov 19: 1.5 hours / $70.94 ('report generation and legal review'), billed at the Budget Coordinator rate. Nov 20, 3:24 AM: requester asked the City to reconsider (aggregation needs a reasonable belief of fee avoidance; Resolution 1912 Section 5) or confirm in writing. Nov 20, 9:19 PM: 10-day extension notice (ends Dec 3).",
    "findings": [
     "E-31",
     "E-14"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "The requester's own copy of the request as submitted for public records request #5299, saved at the time of submission. It is not a record the City released"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C17-2",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c17-2/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "Correspondence with the City, Nov 17-20 2026 - requests aggregated, advance payment, reconsideration",
   "date": "2026-11-17",
   "source": "PRR #5299",
   "findings": [
    "E-31",
    "E-14"
   ],
   "pages": "all (12)",
   "notes": "Seven emails rendered to PDF; bookmarks give date, sender and subject; each page prints the hash of the .eml. Nov 18: the Assistant to the City Manager writes that #5299 'appears to be an expansion' of #5254, cites I.C. 74-102(11), says the City 'is not suggesting that your requests were intentionally submitted to avoid fees,' treats the two as related, and asks for advance payment (EX-C17-3). Same day the requester narrows the request to the Excel report alone. Nov 19: the City keeps the pre-payment for 1.5 hours ('report generation and legal review'), because the two free hours were 'used' on #5254 (EX-C17-4). Nov 20: the requester asks the City to reconsider, citing the 74-102(11) test and Resolution 1912 Section 5, or to confirm the fee and the basis for aggregation in writing. Nov 20, 9:19 PM: 10-working-day extension notice.",
   "redaction": "Requester email replaced; requester name redacted by the redaction run",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "6de3b873cbd3b7a155c039281a245e905ee095d8e90e1deda1532de980c38286",
   "orig_sha": "5151684ca811c6f190d99eade15cd240ef3bad394445b7aa012b35ecd1346cd8\n0caa39aab7de03c1c9b92b41f12ae15d306b45dd8ac03b737d0c61d8e2b9ac00\n88c61ace235f72384e01294b782c2e1dbe252c011fa0a664e6a32a691abe62e5\nbc747330abda5bb4523c61e99ceeb786a88adde189e4e319703e4ca004e607b7\n9624e6cf67dd6ffff5794fff2a91a9ae0851dd6303dd8c862caf753d48022a83\n71d2a2d0e230b34b6e908212ce229b84a8a311f8be4339adf7caa09981c9b892\nf0c2d834c9e0552df52c61740e5acf79c5e0d9a4518dd24c1fabb520c0440e62",
   "orig_shas": [
    "5151684ca811c6f190d99eade15cd240ef3bad394445b7aa012b35ecd1346cd8",
    "0caa39aab7de03c1c9b92b41f12ae15d306b45dd8ac03b737d0c61d8e2b9ac00",
    "88c61ace235f72384e01294b782c2e1dbe252c011fa0a664e6a32a691abe62e5",
    "bc747330abda5bb4523c61e99ceeb786a88adde189e4e319703e4ca004e607b7",
    "9624e6cf67dd6ffff5794fff2a91a9ae0851dd6303dd8c862caf753d48022a83",
    "71d2a2d0e230b34b6e908212ce229b84a8a311f8be4339adf7caa09981c9b892",
    "f0c2d834c9e0552df52c61740e5acf79c5e0d9a4518dd24c1fabb520c0440e62"
   ],
   "size": null,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C17-2.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C17-2 - Correspondence with the City, Nov 17-20 2026 - requests aggregated, advance payment, reconsideration.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "financial-transparency",
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "changes": [
    "Combined from 7 files as released",
    "Redacted: Requester email replaced; requester name redacted by the redaction run",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed"
   ],
   "missing": true,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#5299",
    "subject": "Accounts payable register, fiscal years 2020-2025 (follow-up to #5254)",
    "filed": "2026-11-17",
    "outcome": "Nov 18: aggregated with #5254 under I.C. 74-102(11), 12 hours / $567.48 advance payment (Budget Coordinator $47.29/hr), though the City says it is 'not suggesting' fee avoidance. Requester narrowed to the Excel report only. Nov 19: 1.5 hours / $70.94 ('report generation and legal review'), billed at the Budget Coordinator rate. Nov 20, 3:24 AM: requester asked the City to reconsider (aggregation needs a reasonable belief of fee avoidance; Resolution 1912 Section 5) or confirm in writing. Nov 20, 9:19 PM: 10-day extension notice (ends Dec 3).",
    "findings": [
     "E-31",
     "E-14"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #5299"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C17-3",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c17-3/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "City advance payment notice, Nov 18 2026 - 12 hours, $567.48",
   "date": "2026-11-18",
   "source": "PRR #5299",
   "findings": [
    "E-31",
    "E-14"
   ],
   "pages": "all (2)",
   "notes": "The City Attorney's office letter attached to the Nov 18 email. Estimates 12 hours ('roughly 2 hours per fiscal year requested'), at the Budget Coordinator rate of $47.29 an hour, $567.48, payable before work begins; quotes I.C. 74-102(10) and (11). Document properties removed.",
   "redaction": "Requester name and email redacted by the redaction run",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "38df93e1c59b3cd67dfe18fd74b86f93140e84980cb2dab076bb3da919c1452d",
   "orig_sha": "04200672de569dbcf522a226742a677d88432643c4278b9d3f73247f5c467a8a",
   "orig_shas": [
    "04200672de569dbcf522a226742a677d88432643c4278b9d3f73247f5c467a8a"
   ],
   "size": 309571,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C17-3.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C17-3 - City advance payment notice, Nov 18 2026 - 12 hours, $567.48.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "financial-transparency",
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "fc144763c26fec2b1adac3ea0a1050c8c1c82576a648792b4c792e2189735990",
   "changes": [
    "Redacted: Requester name and email redacted by the redaction run",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (page 1); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 2,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#5299",
    "subject": "Accounts payable register, fiscal years 2020-2025 (follow-up to #5254)",
    "filed": "2026-11-17",
    "outcome": "Nov 18: aggregated with #5254 under I.C. 74-102(11), 12 hours / $567.48 advance payment (Budget Coordinator $47.29/hr), though the City says it is 'not suggesting' fee avoidance. Requester narrowed to the Excel report only. Nov 19: 1.5 hours / $70.94 ('report generation and legal review'), billed at the Budget Coordinator rate. Nov 20, 3:24 AM: requester asked the City to reconsider (aggregation needs a reasonable belief of fee avoidance; Resolution 1912 Section 5) or confirm in writing. Nov 20, 9:19 PM: 10-day extension notice (ends Dec 3).",
    "findings": [
     "E-31",
     "E-14"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #5299"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "id": "EX-C17-4",
   "url": "/twin-falls-id/records/ex-c17-4/",
   "group": "C",
   "description": "City revised advance payment notice, Nov 19 2026 - 1.5 hours, $70.94",
   "date": "2026-11-19",
   "source": "PRR #5299",
   "findings": [
    "E-31",
    "E-14"
   ],
   "pages": "all (2)",
   "notes": "Revised letter attached to the Nov 19 email after the request was narrowed to the Excel report: 1.5 hours ('report generation and legal review') at $47.29 an hour, $70.94, payable before work begins. Document properties removed.",
   "redaction": "Requester name and email redacted by the redaction run",
   "names_ok": false,
   "sha": "88984d0c8206817cf516310cabcebd9e928f0ecb45450f175adc9e783a1f09e5",
   "orig_sha": "3e8ab9c0a9607e2cb9ff4a961342fdb9311c66d7814b33f18b2b0ae4f8c00242",
   "orig_shas": [
    "3e8ab9c0a9607e2cb9ff4a961342fdb9311c66d7814b33f18b2b0ae4f8c00242"
   ],
   "size": 341410,
   "ext": ".pdf",
   "href": "/files/twin-falls-id/EX-C17-4.pdf",
   "download_name": "EX-C17-4 - City revised advance payment notice, Nov 19 2026 - 1.5 hours, $70.94.pdf",
   "topics": [
    "financial-transparency",
    "public-records"
   ],
   "mirror": "",
   "exhibit_sha": "e5daa85345749763d7b243b2b49f6695cb86affbc6fcd238f3243ba2469e1488",
   "changes": [
    "Redacted: Requester name and email redacted by the redaction run",
    "Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed",
    "Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (page 1); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable"
   ],
   "page_count": 2,
   "request": {
    "j": "twin-falls-id",
    "request": "#5299",
    "subject": "Accounts payable register, fiscal years 2020-2025 (follow-up to #5254)",
    "filed": "2026-11-17",
    "outcome": "Nov 18: aggregated with #5254 under I.C. 74-102(11), 12 hours / $567.48 advance payment (Budget Coordinator $47.29/hr), though the City says it is 'not suggesting' fee avoidance. Requester narrowed to the Excel report only. Nov 19: 1.5 hours / $70.94 ('report generation and legal review'), billed at the Budget Coordinator rate. Nov 20, 3:24 AM: requester asked the City to reconsider (aggregation needs a reasonable belief of fee avoidance; Resolution 1912 Section 5) or confirm in writing. Nov 20, 9:19 PM: 10-day extension notice (ends Dec 3).",
    "findings": [
     "E-31",
     "E-14"
    ],
    "how": ""
   },
   "retrieved": null,
   "provenance": "Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #5299"
  }
 ],
 "timeline": [
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2012-12-10",
   "event": "Council passes Resolution 1897, the employee rules, including the vacation sell-back limits",
   "basis": "Public",
   "source": "Res. 1897 text in 2018-10-29 packet",
   "links": "EX-B06; E-02",
   "why": "Sets the rule at the center of the sell-back findings: no more than 40 hours of vacation sold a year, once a fiscal year, and only after taking 80 hours of vacation in the prior 12 months. The City's 2020-2021 sell-back form and later handbooks lowered the vacation-taken test to 40 hours; the 40-hour yearly limit stayed the same.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-01",
    "E-02"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2012-12-10"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2013-12-02",
   "event": "Council adopts Resolution 1912, \"Transparency in City Government,\" 6-1. Section 5 says the City \"will provide access to the annual budget, monthly financial reports, accounts payable, financial dashboard ... on the City's website.\"",
   "basis": "Public",
   "source": "Agenda 2013-12-02 pp19-27 (resolution as presented, Section 5 on p23); Minutes 2013-12-02 pp3-5 (vote 6-1)",
   "links": "EX-B40; MTG 2013-12-02; E-31",
   "why": "The Council's own written promise to post every payment the City makes.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-31"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "financial-transparency"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2013-12-02"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2014-04-07",
   "event": "Council amends Resolution 1912's rules on committees, 4-3. The accounts payable promise in Section 5 stays.",
   "basis": "Public",
   "source": "Packet 2014-04-07 p119 (Section 5 text); Minutes 2014-04-07 pp6-7 (vote 4-3)",
   "links": "E-31",
   "why": "The promise survived the first rewrite.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-31"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "financial-transparency"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2014-04-07"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2014-04-21",
   "event": "Council adopts Second Amended Resolution 1912, 7-0. Section 5 still promises accounts payable, monthly financial reports and a financial dashboard on the City website.",
   "basis": "Public",
   "source": "Agenda 2014-04-21 pp73-76 (Section 5 on p75); Minutes 2014-04-21 p5 (vote 7-0)",
   "links": "EX-B41; EX-B42; MTG 2014-04-21; E-31",
   "why": "The version in force. We found no later Council action changing or repealing it.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-31"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "financial-transparency"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2014-04-21"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2014-06-23",
   "event": "Council approves a new City credit card process 5-0, with a six-month update promised; a bank representative says the card bill is paid by automatic debit",
   "basis": "Public",
   "source": "Minutes 2014-06-23 pp3-4 (Item 4)",
   "links": "EX-B47; MTG 2014-06-23; E-32",
   "why": "The start of the Wells Fargo commercial card program the Council now approves monthly.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-32"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "financial-transparency"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2014-06-23"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2014-09-02",
   "event": "Council votes 7-0 to let the Mayor form a committee (Hall, Hawkins, Talkington) to evaluate the City Manager and City Attorney",
   "basis": "Public",
   "source": "Minutes 2014-09-02 pp14-15",
   "links": "EX-B01; E-06",
   "why": "The only public record creating an evaluation committee. Later pay letters cite \"the performance review committee\" as their authority, but no later motion creates one or names its members.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-06"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "open-meetings"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2014-09-02"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2015-02-02",
   "event": "Council approves the City Manager's service agreement, 7-0",
   "basis": "Public",
   "source": "Minutes 2015-02-02 p8",
   "links": "EX-B02; E-07",
   "why": "The agreement the Council approved in public. It requires changes in writing signed by both parties, the standard every later pay letter is measured against.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-07",
    "E-03"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2015-02-02"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2015-04-13",
   "event": "A City staff memo cites \"the City's January 2015, Financial Dashboard.\"",
   "basis": "Public",
   "source": "Agenda 2015-04-13 p46",
   "links": "E-31",
   "why": "Shows the City did keep a financial dashboard at the time. None is on the website today.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-31"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "financial-transparency"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2015-04-13"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2015-08-03",
   "event": "Last Council minutes that state the weekly accounts payable total ($1,102,058 for July 28 to August 3, 2015). From August 10, 2015 on, the minutes give only the date range of the payments approved.",
   "basis": "Public",
   "source": "Minutes 2015-07-20 p2 and 2015-08-03 p2 (totals); Minutes 2015-08-10 p1 and later (date range only)",
   "links": "EX-B43; EX-B44; MTG 2015-08-03; E-31",
   "why": "Instead of putting the payments online, the public record began showing less: not even the total.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-31"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "financial-transparency"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2015-08-03"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2015-10-05",
   "event": "Council re-enacts Title 1 of the City Code (Ordinance 3106). City Code 1-2-1 says the mayor has no administrative powers; City Code 1-2-3 says Council members deal with administration only through the City Manager and may not give orders to his staff.",
   "basis": "Public",
   "source": "City Code 1-2-1, 1-2-3 (history notes: Ord. 3106, 10-5-2015)",
   "links": "E-01; E-03; E-07",
   "why": "The City's own code rules that the Mayor's later pay letters run up against.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-01",
    "E-03",
    "E-07"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2015-10-05"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2015-10-12",
   "event": "Council holds a closed evaluation session under 74-206(1)(b)",
   "basis": "Public",
   "source": "Minutes 2015-10-12",
   "links": "MTG 2015-10-12; E-05",
   "why": "An evaluation session. Closed sessions may discuss evaluations but may not be used to make final decisions (I.C. 74-206).",
   "followed": "Eleven days later, the October 23 check raised the City Manager's hourly rate 3.0% (TL 2015-10-23). The minutes we have record no open vote on it.",
   "findings": [
    "E-05"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "open-meetings"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2015-10-12"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2015-10-23",
   "event": "City Manager's hourly rate rises 3.0%, from $60.66 to $62.49 (about $129,974 a year), on the October 23 check; the same check sells 40 hours of vacation",
   "basis": "PRR payroll",
   "source": "Payroll p1",
   "links": "EX-A03 p1; E-03",
   "why": "The first change in his pay after the October 12 evaluation session. No open-session vote on it was located. We could not compare it with the citywide raise because the City does not post its FY2016 budget. The 40-hour sale is within the yearly limit; the register does not reach back far enough to test the vacation taken before it.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-03"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2015-10-23"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2016-04-04",
   "event": "Council adopts Resolution 2016-02, 7-0, authorizing destruction of Finance Department records including \"Check Registers 2007-2015.\"",
   "basis": "Public",
   "source": "Agenda 2016-04-04 p40 (list); Minutes 2016-04-04 p5 (vote 7-0)",
   "links": "EX-B45; EX-B46; E-31",
   "why": "Check registers are the payment lists Resolution 1912 promised to post. Whether electronic copies were kept is not stated.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-31"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "financial-transparency"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2016-04-04"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2016-10",
   "event": "City Manager's base pay raised to $145,002; no vote found",
   "basis": "PRR payroll",
   "source": "Payroll register",
   "links": "EX-A03; E-03",
   "why": "A raise paid with no open-session vote found in the minutes.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-03"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2016-10"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2016-10-21",
   "event": "City Manager sells 80 hours of vacation: twice the 40-hour cap, after taking 76.75 hours of vacation when 80 were required",
   "basis": "PRR payroll",
   "source": "Payroll p10",
   "links": "EX-A03 p10; E-02",
   "why": "Twice the 40-hour cap. He had used 76.75 hours of vacation in the prior 12 months; Resolution 1897, in force then, required 80. (He would have met the later 40-hour test.)",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-02"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2016-10-21"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2017-08-07",
   "event": "At the City Manager's request, the Council adds an evaluation session at the start of the meeting, 5-0",
   "basis": "Public",
   "source": "Minutes 2017-08-07 p1",
   "links": "MTG 2017-08-07; E-17",
   "why": "The City Manager asked that an evaluation session be added; the posted agenda listed only a real-property session.",
   "followed": "Further evaluation sessions on Aug 28, Sept 5 and Sept 18. Then the October 20 check raised the City Manager's base pay 8.97%, to $158,002 (TL 2017-10), and sold 80 hours of his vacation (TL 2017-10-20). No open-session vote on either was located.",
   "findings": [
    "E-17"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "open-meetings"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2017-08-07"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2017-10",
   "event": "City Manager's base pay raised to $158,002; no open-session vote found",
   "basis": "PRR payroll",
   "source": "Payroll register",
   "links": "EX-A03; E-03",
   "why": "A raise paid with no open-session vote found. The Apr 24 to Dec 4, 2017 minutes record no action on the City Manager's pay.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-03"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2017-10"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2017-10-20",
   "event": "City Manager sells 80 hours of vacation, twice the 40-hour cap, after taking 49.25 hours of vacation when 80 were required",
   "basis": "PRR payroll",
   "source": "Payroll p18",
   "links": "EX-A03 p18; E-02",
   "why": "Twice the 40-hour cap, after 49.25 hours of vacation in the prior 12 months when Resolution 1897 required 80. (He would have met the later 40-hour test.)",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-02"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2017-10-20"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2017-11-13",
   "event": "At the City Manager's request, the Council adds a legal-counsel session at the start of the meeting, 6-0",
   "basis": "Public",
   "source": "Minutes 2017-11-13 p1",
   "links": "MTG 2017-11-13; E-17",
   "why": "The posted agenda listed only a real-property session; no reason for the addition is recorded.",
   "followed": "The minutes do not say what the legal matter was, and no related action appears in them.",
   "findings": [
    "E-17"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "open-meetings"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2017-11-13"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2017-12-18",
   "event": "At the City Manager's request, the Council adds an evaluation session at the start of the meeting, 5-0",
   "basis": "Public",
   "source": "Minutes 2017-12-18 p1",
   "links": "EX-B03; MTG 2017-12-18; E-17",
   "why": "The evaluation session was added mid-meeting at the City Manager's own request, so it never appeared on the public agenda.",
   "followed": "The payroll register shows no change in the City Manager's pay after this session; his next raise came in October 2018 (TL 2018-10). Evaluation sessions can also concern other employees.",
   "findings": [
    "E-17"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "open-meetings"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2017-12-18"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2018-10",
   "event": "City Manager's base pay raised to $164,996; closed evaluation sessions follow on Oct 29, Nov 5 and Dec 3",
   "basis": "PRR payroll / Public",
   "source": "Payroll; minutes",
   "links": "EX-A03; EX-B05; EX-B11; EX-B12; E-03; E-05",
   "why": "A raise paid with no open-session vote, alongside a run of closed evaluation sessions.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-03",
    "E-05"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay",
    "open-meetings"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2018-10"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2018-10-22",
   "event": "Council approves the retention pay program proposed by the City Manager and the HR Director, 7-0",
   "basis": "Public",
   "source": "Minutes 2018-10-22 p3",
   "links": "EX-B04; E-09",
   "why": "Context: the retention program was approved in public and open to eligible employees; the City Manager later took part in it (E-09).",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-09"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2018-10-22"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2018-10-29",
   "event": "Resolution 2018-012 hands the employee handbook to the City Manager, 5-0; a closed evaluation session follows the same night",
   "basis": "Public",
   "source": "Minutes 2018-10-29 p2",
   "links": "EX-B05; EX-B06; E-10",
   "why": "The Council stopped adopting employee rules itself and let the City Manager issue the handbook. From then on he wrote the rules and was the only one who could grant exceptions to them.",
   "followed": "Four days later, the November 2 check sold 80 hours of the City Manager's vacation (TL 2018-11-02). His October raise had already been paid from the October 19 check (TL 2018-10). More evaluation sessions followed on Nov 5 and Dec 3.",
   "findings": [
    "E-10"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2018-10-29"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2018-11-02",
   "event": "City Manager sells 80 hours of vacation after taking 46.5 hours when 80 were required",
   "basis": "PRR payroll",
   "source": "Payroll p26",
   "links": "EX-A03 p26; E-02",
   "why": "Twice the cap, after 46.5 hours of vacation in the prior 12 months when the October 2018 handbook required 80. (He would have met the later 40-hour test.)",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-02"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2018-11-02"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2019-03-18",
   "event": "First monthly \"Wells Fargo Commercial Card\" approval appears on the Council's consent calendar (for January 2019)",
   "basis": "Public",
   "source": "Minutes 2019-03-18 p2",
   "links": "EX-B48; E-32",
   "why": "From here on the Council approves card spending monthly; the report itself is not in the posted packets.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-32"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "financial-transparency"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2019-03-18"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2019-09-16 to 10-28",
   "event": "Closed evaluation sessions on Sept 16, Oct 7 and Oct 28",
   "basis": "Public",
   "source": "Minutes",
   "links": "EX-B13; EX-B14; EX-B15; E-05",
   "why": "Closed evaluation sessions, followed that fall by a raise with no open vote.",
   "followed": "The October 18 check, between the Oct 7 and Oct 28 sessions, raised the City Manager's base pay 2.5%, to $169,125 (TL 2019-10), and the November 1 check sold 80 hours of his vacation (TL 2019-11-01). No open-session vote on either was located.",
   "findings": [
    "E-05"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "open-meetings"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2019-09-16-to-10-28"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2019-09-23",
   "event": "Council passes Ordinance 2019-009 creating the Public Art Commission. The code text presented requires its meetings to follow \"Second Amended Resolution 1912.\"",
   "basis": "Public",
   "source": "Special meeting packet 2019-09-23 p6 (code section 2-13-10); Minutes 2019-09-23 p1 (ordinance passed)",
   "links": "EX-B49; E-31",
   "why": "Five years later, the City was still writing Resolution 1912 into its own code.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-31"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "financial-transparency"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2019-09-23"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2019-10",
   "event": "City Manager's base pay raised to $169,125",
   "basis": "PRR payroll",
   "source": "Payroll register",
   "links": "EX-A03; E-03",
   "why": "A raise with no open-session vote found. At 2.5% it was below the citywide raise that year.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-03"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2019-10"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2019-11-01",
   "event": "City Manager sells 80 hours of vacation after taking 76 hours when 80 were required",
   "basis": "PRR payroll",
   "source": "Payroll p35",
   "links": "EX-A03 p35; E-02",
   "why": "Twice the cap, after 76 hours of vacation in the prior 12 months when the handbook required 80. (He would have met the later 40-hour test.)",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-02"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2019-11-01"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2020-04-06",
   "event": "Council adopts Ordinance 2020-007 giving the City Manager emergency powers, including authority to waive internal rules to protect employees' health during a declared public health emergency (City Code 1-5-8).",
   "basis": "Public",
   "source": "City Code Title 1, Chapter 5 (history notes: Ord. 2020-007, 4-6-2020)",
   "links": "E-02; P-84",
   "why": "Context: a possible basis for exceptions to leave rules in 2020-2021, if an emergency order and a written waiver exist.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-02"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2020-04-06"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2020-04-20",
   "event": "Council approves an updated City Manager agreement, 7-0; the staff memo says his pay is not changed",
   "basis": "Public",
   "source": "Apr 20, 2020 packet pp74-77",
   "links": "EX-B07; EX-A13; E-07",
   "why": "The Council wrote the City Manager's then-current $169,124 salary into his agreement. Every raise after this, until December 2024, was paid above that approved figure without another open vote.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-03",
    "E-07"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2020-04-20"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2020-12-07 to 12-21",
   "event": "Closed evaluation sessions on Dec 7, 14 and 21; the Mayor emails HR that \"the Council is unanimous\" on the City Manager's pay",
   "basis": "Public / PRR",
   "source": "Minutes; #4869",
   "links": "EX-B16; EX-B17; EX-B18; EX-A05; E-05",
   "why": "The Mayor wrote \"The Council is unanimous\" about a raise that appears in no open-meeting minutes. Closed sessions may not be used to make final decisions.",
   "followed": "The January 8, 2021 check paid the raise to $185,000 with $4,274.09 in back pay to October, and sold 100 hours of the City Manager's vacation (TL 2021-01-08).",
   "findings": [
    "E-05",
    "E-03"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "open-meetings",
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2020-12-07-to-12-21"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2021-01-08",
   "event": "City Manager's raise to $185,000 is paid back to October; the same check sells 100 hours of vacation after 12 hours of vacation taken in the prior 12 months",
   "basis": "PRR payroll",
   "source": "Payroll p45",
   "links": "EX-A03 p45; E-03; E-02",
   "why": "The raise was paid back to October with no open vote, and the same check sold 100 hours, two and a half times the 40-hour cap. He had used 12 hours of vacation in the prior 12 months (21.75 in calendar 2020). That fails the 80-hour test in the 2018 handbook and also the 40-hour standard printed on the City's own 2020-2021 sell-back form (EX-A30).",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-03",
    "E-02"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2021-01-08"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2021-10-18",
   "event": "Closed evaluation session; the next day the Vice Mayor emails a 4.5% raise and a 5% retirement contribution for the City Manager",
   "basis": "Public / PRR",
   "source": "Minutes; #4869",
   "links": "EX-B19; EX-A06; E-05; E-04",
   "why": "The day after a closed session, the Vice Mayor's email set a raise and a one-time retirement contribution. Neither went to an open vote.",
   "followed": "The raise was paid as back pay on the November 29 and December 23, 2021 checks and at the new rate ($92.95 an hour) from January 7, 2022 (EX-A03 pp52-53). The November 29 check also sold 100 hours of his vacation (TL 2021-11-29).",
   "findings": [
    "E-05",
    "E-04"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "open-meetings",
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2021-10-18"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2021-11-29",
   "event": "City Manager sells 100 hours of vacation after taking 31.25 hours when 40 were required",
   "basis": "PRR payroll",
   "source": "Payroll p52",
   "links": "EX-A03 p52; EX-A30; E-02",
   "why": "100 hours sold, two and a half times the 40-hour cap. He had used 31.25 hours of vacation in the prior 12 months. The City's own sell-back form then in use required 40 hours in the preceding calendar year (he used 21.75 in 2020), and later handbooks require 40 in the preceding 12 months, so the sale falls short either way (EX-A30).",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-02"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2021-11-29"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2021-12-10",
   "event": "City Manager emails his two deputies' new salaries, set as a percentage below his own: \"Will you do the forms for me?\"",
   "basis": "PRR",
   "source": "EX-A27",
   "links": "EX-A27; E-27",
   "why": "The City Manager set his deputies' pay as a percentage of his own and asked the HR Director, one of the two, to process it. (Their later raises matched other executives' raises, not his.)",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-27"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "workplace"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2021-12-10"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2021-12-13",
   "event": "Council confirms Gretchen Scott as Deputy City Manager, 5-0",
   "basis": "Public",
   "source": "Minutes 2021-12-13",
   "links": "EX-B35; E-27",
   "why": "The Council confirmed the appointment in public; the minutes state no salary.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-27"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "workplace"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2021-12-13"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2022-07-18",
   "event": "At the City's request, the Council makes the vacant Economic Development Director post a department head (Ordinance 2022-013), so the appointment needs Council confirmation. Council Member Barigar recuses and leaves the dais; 5-0.",
   "basis": "Public",
   "source": "Packet 2022-07-18 pp20-22; Minutes 2022-07-18 (approved in the 2022-07-25 packet, pp4-5); City Code 1-2-4",
   "links": "EX-B50; EX-B51; E-28",
   "why": "Context. One week before he resigned to apply for the post.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-28"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "workplace"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2022-07-18"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2022-07-25",
   "event": "Council Member Barigar resigns to apply for the Economic Development Director job (accepted Aug 1, 5-0)",
   "basis": "Public",
   "source": "Minutes 2022-07-25, 2022-08-01",
   "links": "EX-B36; EX-B37; E-28",
   "why": "Context. A council member resigned, saying he intended to apply for a City job. It was handled in public.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-28"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "workplace"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2022-07-25"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2022-09-30",
   "event": "Fiscal 2022 ends: the audited schedule later shows Janitorial, Fire and Animal Control over their final budgets; the audit's \"excess over appropriations\" note no longer appears",
   "basis": "Public",
   "source": "2022 Financial Statements pp53, 79",
   "links": "E-36",
   "why": "First year the audit stops disclosing overspending that its own schedules show.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-36"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2022-09-30"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2022-10-10",
   "event": "Council confirms the Economic Development Director appointment, 7-0",
   "basis": "Public",
   "source": "Minutes 2022-10-10",
   "links": "EX-B38; E-28",
   "why": "Context: the appointment was confirmed in public.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-28"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "workplace"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2022-10-10"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2022-12-05 / 12-12",
   "event": "Closed evaluation sessions on Dec 5 and 12; the Mayor's Dec 8 letter sets the City Manager's base pay at $226,000, gives him the $2,000 citywide one-time payment, and lifts his sell-back limit",
   "basis": "Public / PRR",
   "source": "Minutes; #4869",
   "links": "EX-B09; EX-B10; EX-A01; E-01; E-05",
   "why": "The letter lifts the sell-back cap so the City Manager \"may realize the benefit of vacation time that you have been unable to take.\" The payroll register says otherwise: in the 12 months before the letter he used 96 hours of vacation plus 40 of executive leave, more than in the same period of any year since 2016, and he had already sold 80 or 100 hours at a time six times since 2016. Neither meeting recorded a vote.",
   "followed": "The December 23, 2022 check paid the new rate ($108.65 an hour) with $6,281.54 in back pay, the $2,000 payment, and a 100-hour vacation sale (TL 2022-12-23).",
   "findings": [
    "E-01",
    "E-05",
    "E-03"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay",
    "open-meetings"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2022-12-05-12-12"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2022-12-23",
   "event": "City Manager sells 100 hours of vacation",
   "basis": "PRR payroll",
   "source": "Payroll p61",
   "links": "EX-A03 p61; E-01",
   "why": "100 hours sold, two and a half times the 40-hour cap, in the same pay period he used 36 hours of vacation.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-01"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2022-12-23"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2023-10-02",
   "event": "Deputy City Manager Scott files and approves, as both \"City Manager\" and HR, an employee's promotion to Acting HR Director in 77 seconds; the City Manager's letter that day sets the pay",
   "basis": "PRR",
   "source": "EX-A24 p29; EX-A28",
   "links": "EX-A24 p29; EX-A28; E-26",
   "why": "One person filled all three approval roles (requester, \"City Manager\" and HR) in 77 seconds, for an employee she supervises.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-26"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "workplace"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2023-10-02"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2023-12-04",
   "event": "Closed evaluation session; the Mayor's Dec 6 email gives the City Manager 10% deferred compensation and a $1,500 payment",
   "basis": "Public / PRR",
   "source": "Minutes; #4869",
   "links": "EX-B20; EX-A08; E-05; E-04",
   "why": "Two days after a closed session, the Mayor's email set $22,600 a year in deferred compensation and a $1,500 payment. The Council first approved deferred compensation in public a year later.",
   "followed": "The December 15 check paid the $1,500 and a $5,000 retention payment (TL 2023-12-15); the December 22 check sold 100 hours of his vacation (TL 2023-12-22).",
   "findings": [
    "E-05",
    "E-04"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "open-meetings",
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2023-12-04"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2023-12-04",
   "event": "Council confirms the HR Director appointment, 7-0",
   "basis": "Public",
   "source": "Minutes 2023-12-04",
   "links": "EX-B39; E-26",
   "why": "Context: the appointment was confirmed in public, two months after the acting appointment above.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-26"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "workplace"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2023-12-04-2"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2023-12-15",
   "event": "City Manager receives a $5,000 prepaid retention payment under the citywide retention program",
   "basis": "PRR",
   "source": "ERP agreement",
   "links": "EX-A16; E-09",
   "why": "Context: retention pay was open to eligible employees, and his agreement extends employee benefits to him (E-09).",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-09"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2023-12-15"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2023-12-22",
   "event": "City Manager sells 100 hours of vacation",
   "basis": "PRR payroll",
   "source": "Payroll p70",
   "links": "EX-A03 p70; E-01",
   "why": "100 hours sold, two and a half times the 40-hour cap.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-01"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2023-12-22"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2024-10-07",
   "event": "Mayor Pierce steps aside on a Suburban Construction Management item, saying \"she does accounting for\" the firm",
   "basis": "Public",
   "source": "Minutes 2024-10-07 p1",
   "links": "EX-B28; E-25",
   "why": "The Mayor said she does accounting for the firm and stepped aside. On later votes involving the same firm, the minutes record no recusal.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-25"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "contracts-ethics"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2024-10-07"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2024-11-22",
   "event": "City Manager paid 89 hours in an 80-hour pay period (80 regular + 9 Veterans Day holiday), $977.88 over salary",
   "basis": "PRR payroll",
   "source": "Payroll p78",
   "links": "EX-A03 p78; E-35",
   "why": "Holiday hours elsewhere replace regular hours; no reversal appears through May 2026.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-35"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2024-11-22"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2024-12-09",
   "event": "Council approves an amendment to the City Manager's agreement, 7-0",
   "basis": "Public",
   "source": "Minutes 2024-12-09",
   "links": "EX-B08; EX-A12; E-04; E-07",
   "why": "The first public vote on the City Manager's pay since 2020: $239,560 base plus $22,600 a year in deferred compensation, which had already been paid for a year.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-04",
    "E-07"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2024-12-09"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2025-01-03",
   "event": "City Manager sells 100 hours of vacation",
   "basis": "PRR payroll",
   "source": "Payroll p78",
   "links": "EX-A03 p78; E-01",
   "why": "100 hours sold, two and a half times the 40-hour cap.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-01"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2025-01-03"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2025-02-18",
   "event": "SuburbanCM ranked first for the City Park Restroom project; Mayor Pierce present, 6-0, no recusal recorded",
   "basis": "Public",
   "source": "Minutes 2025-02-18 p2",
   "links": "EX-B29; E-25",
   "why": "The City Park Restroom is a federally funded (CDBG) project. The Mayor was present for the vote ranking the firm she had said she does accounting for; no recusal is recorded.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-25"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "contracts-ethics"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2025-02-18"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2025-03-17",
   "event": "$1.6 million in reserves and a construction contract with Suburban CM, plus the City Park Restroom contract; Mayor Pierce present, 6-0, no recusal recorded",
   "basis": "Public",
   "source": "Minutes 2025-03-17 pp2-3",
   "links": "EX-B30; E-25",
   "why": "The contract with the same firm was approved with the Mayor present and voting; no recusal is recorded.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-25"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "contracts-ethics"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2025-03-17"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2025-06-20",
   "event": "Payroll takes back an 18-hour overpayment from the June 6 check",
   "basis": "PRR payroll",
   "source": "Payroll pp82-83",
   "links": "EX-A03 pp82-83; E-35",
   "why": "Context: the City reverses payroll errors it catches; the November 2024 one was not reversed.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-35"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2025-06-20"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2025-09-08",
   "event": "Closed evaluation session; the Mayor's letter the same day sets the City Manager's pay at $272,650 in total",
   "basis": "Public / PRR",
   "source": "Minutes; #4869",
   "links": "EX-B21; EX-A09; EX-A10; E-05; E-03",
   "why": "A closed session and a pay letter on the same day: $272,650, described as \"a market-based adjustment.\" That is $10,490 a year above the pay the Council approved in December 2024, with no open vote.",
   "followed": "The new rate ($120.22 an hour) appears from the October 10, 2025 check (EX-A03 p85), and the November 21 check sold 100 hours of his vacation (TL 2025-11-21).",
   "findings": [
    "E-05",
    "E-03"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "open-meetings",
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2025-09-08"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2025-09-30",
   "event": "Fiscal 2025 ends: the audited schedule later shows the Council's own budget over for a third straight year, with Recreation and Public Transportation",
   "basis": "Public",
   "source": "2025 Annual Comprehensive Financial Report p86",
   "links": "E-36",
   "why": "The overruns continue, still without the disclosure earlier audits carried.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-36"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2025-09-30"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2025-10-31",
   "event": "Deputy City Manager Scott files and approves, as both \"City Manager\" and HR, the HR Director's raise to $73.00 an hour",
   "basis": "PRR",
   "source": "EX-A24 p38",
   "links": "EX-A24 p38; E-26",
   "why": "The same one-person approval pattern, for a raise to the employee she supervises.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-26"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "workplace"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2025-10-31"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2025-11-17",
   "event": "$2,395,826 Well #5 contract to Suburban Construction; Mayor Pierce present, 6-0, no recusal recorded",
   "basis": "Public",
   "source": "Minutes 2025-11-17",
   "links": "EX-B31; E-25",
   "why": "A $2.4 million contract to the firm, approved with the Mayor present; no recusal is recorded.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-25"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "contracts-ethics"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2025-11-17"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2025-11-21",
   "event": "City Manager sells 100 hours of vacation",
   "basis": "PRR payroll",
   "source": "Payroll p86",
   "links": "EX-A03 p86; E-01",
   "why": "100 hours sold, two and a half times the 40-hour cap.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-01"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2025-11-21"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2026-04-17",
   "event": "City Manager emails that the Council \"authorized\" a $2,500 stipend for the Deputy City Manager; paid Apr 24",
   "basis": "PRR",
   "source": "Stipend - Gretchen Scott",
   "links": "EX-A18; EX-A19; EX-B22; EX-B23; EX-B24; EX-B25; EX-B26; E-08",
   "why": "The email says the Council \"authorized\" the payment, but none of the Council's meetings that spring record a vote on it.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-08"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "executive-pay"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2026-04-17"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2026-05-31",
   "event": "Request #3946 filed for the City's market analysis",
   "basis": "PRR",
   "source": "Completion notice",
   "links": "EX-C01-1; REQ #3946; E-12",
   "why": "A request for the consultant's market analysis, the data behind executive pay.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-12"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2026-05-31"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2026-06-22",
   "event": "The City Code, as supplemented through Ordinance 2026-007, still requires Public Art Commission meetings to follow \"Second Amended Resolution 1912\" (City Code 2-13-10).",
   "basis": "Public",
   "source": "City Code 2-13-10 (online code, current through Ord. 2026-007, passed 6-22-2026)",
   "links": "E-31",
   "why": "The resolution that promised online accounts payable is still cited in the City's current code.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-31"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "financial-transparency"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2026-06-22"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2026-07-01",
   "event": "Request #3946 answered with a few items; most of the rest were later said to be withheld",
   "basis": "PRR",
   "source": "#3946 response",
   "links": "EX-C01-3; EX-C01-4; REQ #3946; E-12",
   "why": "Nearly everything was withheld as the vendor's \"proprietary\" material, without the explanation the law requires.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-12"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2026-07-01"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2026-07-13",
   "event": "Request #3946: Deputy Clerk says 109 of 117 entries were withheld as \"statutorily excluded\"",
   "basis": "Request",
   "source": "PRR #3946 correspondence (7/13/2026)",
   "links": "EX-C01-4; REQ #3946; E-12",
   "why": "The completion notice gave no statutory reason for each withheld item.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-12"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2026-07-13"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2026-08-17",
   "event": "Council approves negotiations with Suburban Construction Management for a park project; Pierce present, 6-0, no recusal recorded",
   "basis": "Public",
   "source": "Minutes 2026-08-17 p2",
   "links": "EX-B32; E-25",
   "why": "Another vote on the same firm's work with no recusal recorded.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-25"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "contracts-ethics"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2026-08-17"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2026-09-24",
   "event": "Request about the cost of the market analysis denied for \"failure to comply with 74-102(4)\"",
   "basis": "Request",
   "source": "Denial notice (9/24/2026)",
   "links": "EX-C02-2; E-22; E-18",
   "why": "The same requester had corresponded with the City for months without an identity question, until pressing for the withheld records.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-22",
    "E-18"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "public-records",
    "contracts-ethics"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2026-09-24"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2026-10-05",
   "event": "$486,013 contract with Suburban Construction; Council Member Pierce seconds the motion, 6-0",
   "basis": "Public",
   "source": "Minutes 2026-10-05 p2",
   "links": "EX-B33; E-25",
   "why": "The motion was seconded by the Council member who had said she does accounting for the firm; no recusal is recorded.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-25"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "contracts-ethics"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2026-10-05"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2026-10-05",
   "event": "Request #4869 answered: no 2015 City Manager agreement produced",
   "basis": "Request",
   "source": "PRR #4869 production",
   "links": "EX-C05-3; REQ #4869; E-11",
   "why": "The Council approved a 2015 agreement in public, but the production skipped it with no denial notice.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-11"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2026-10-05-2"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2026-10-05",
   "event": "Request #4814 answered with HR payroll registers; accounts payable reports not produced",
   "basis": "Request",
   "source": "PRR #4814 response",
   "links": "EX-C04-3; REQ #4814; E-14",
   "why": "The City said reimbursements \"will therefore appear on separate reports\"; none came.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-14"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2026-10-05-3"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2026-10-16",
   "event": "Three requests for leave and sell-back records denied, two of them within 16 and 69 minutes: \"please stop requesting\"",
   "basis": "Request",
   "source": "Denial notices (10/15 and 10/16/2026)",
   "links": "EX-C08-2; EX-C09-2; EX-C10-2; E-21",
   "why": "Each denial cited only the personnel-records exemption (74-106(1)); the third added \"Per our City Attorney, please stop requesting the same information.\"",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-21"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2026-10-16"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2026-10-19",
   "event": "$900,000 change order with Suburban Construction; Council Member Pierce makes the motion, 6-0",
   "basis": "Public",
   "source": "Minutes 2026-10-19 p1",
   "links": "EX-B34; E-25",
   "why": "The change order was moved by the Council member who had said she does accounting for the firm; no recusal is recorded.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-25"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "contracts-ethics"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2026-10-19"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2026-10-20",
   "event": "Request #4940 passes 10 working days with no response: deemed denied by law",
   "basis": "Request",
   "source": "PRR #4940 correspondence",
   "links": "EX-C06-2; REQ #4940; E-20",
   "why": "Five follow-ups through Nov 5 went unanswered.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-20"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2026-10-20"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2026-10-20",
   "event": "Request #4953 denied for \"non-compliance with 74-102(4)\"; City Attorney questions the requester's identity",
   "basis": "Request",
   "source": "PRR #4953 response and correspondence",
   "links": "EX-C07-3; EX-C07-4; REQ #4953; E-15; E-22",
   "why": "The request asked for every handbook exception granted to executives.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-15",
    "E-22"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2026-10-20-2"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2026-11-02",
   "event": "Request #5061 for copies of records requests denied: \"not a record that is held\"",
   "basis": "Request",
   "source": "PRR #5061 response",
   "links": "EX-C11-3; REQ #5061; E-13",
   "why": "Every City response attaches the requester's own request form, and request numbers pass 5,000.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-13"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2026-11-02"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2026-11-05",
   "event": "Three days after denying it holds copies of records requests, the City delivers 1,183 of them (#5162), three hours after writing that it would take IT \"days\" and \"a large charge\"",
   "basis": "Request",
   "source": "Records request #5162 correspondence (Nov 5-6, 2026)",
   "links": "EX-C13-3; REQ #5162; E-13",
   "why": "The first two requests for the same records were denied on Nov 2 and Nov 3.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-13"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "public-records"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2026-11-05"
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "date": "2026-11-10",
   "event": "The City website's site map lists no accounts payable, check register, monthly financial report or financial dashboard. Its Finance links are the City Budget, the Master Fee Schedule and building permit fees.",
   "basis": "Public",
   "source": "tfid.org/SiteMap and tfid.org/161/City-Budget (checked 2026-11-10)",
   "links": "E-31",
   "why": "What Resolution 1912 promised is not there.",
   "followed": "",
   "findings": [
    "E-31"
   ],
   "topics": [
    "financial-transparency"
   ],
   "anchor": "tl-2026-11-10"
  }
 ],
 "requests": [
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "request": "#3946",
   "subject": "Market Analysis keyword, 5 custodians",
   "filed": "2026-05-31",
   "outcome": "Partial; late; 109/117 withheld as \"proprietary\"",
   "findings": [
    "E-12"
   ],
   "how": ""
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "request": "#4729",
   "subject": "ELT compensation records FY21-FY26",
   "filed": "2026-08 (approx.)",
   "outcome": "Produced HR documents",
   "findings": [
    "E-01",
    "E-02",
    "E-03",
    "E-04",
    "E-05",
    "E-06",
    "E-07",
    "E-08",
    "E-09"
   ],
   "how": ""
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "request": "#4814",
   "subject": "Finance payment summaries FY16-present",
   "filed": "2026-09",
   "outcome": "Payroll registers; \"no FY subtotal\"; AP to come separately",
   "findings": [
    "E-14"
   ],
   "how": ""
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "request": "#4869",
   "subject": "CM contract versions + handbook exceptions",
   "filed": "2026-09",
   "outcome": "Produced 2020/2024 agreements, letters; no 2015 agreement; no Council exception directives",
   "findings": [
    "E-11"
   ],
   "how": ""
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "request": "#4940",
   "subject": "Follow-up/deficiency memo to #4814/#4729",
   "filed": "2026-10-05",
   "outcome": "No response after 26 working days as of Nov 10 (deemed denied Oct 20); five follow-ups unanswered",
   "findings": [
    "E-14"
   ],
   "how": ""
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "request": "#4953",
   "subject": "All executive exceptions to handbook",
   "filed": "2026-10",
   "outcome": "Denied: non-compliance with 74-102(4)",
   "findings": [
    "E-15"
   ],
   "how": ""
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "request": "PTO x3",
   "subject": "Hours worked and leave usage, ELT",
   "filed": "2026-10",
   "outcome": "Denied three times",
   "findings": [
    "E-21"
   ],
   "how": ""
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "request": "Market Analysis Cost",
   "subject": "Payments to HUB / study cost",
   "filed": "2026-09",
   "outcome": "Denied (response not in folder)",
   "findings": [
    "E-18"
   ],
   "how": ""
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "request": "#5061",
   "subject": "Copies of all PRRs Jun-Oct 2026",
   "filed": "2026-10-20",
   "outcome": "Denied: \"not a record held\" (Nov 2); second request denied Nov 3; third request filled as #5162",
   "findings": [
    "E-13"
   ],
   "how": ""
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "request": "#5162",
   "subject": "Copies of records requests (third attempt)",
   "filed": "2026-11-03",
   "outcome": "Filled Nov 5, 2026: 1,183 request forms, no fee; extension notice sent Nov 6 after closure",
   "findings": [
    "E-13"
   ],
   "how": ""
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "request": "#5254",
   "subject": "Accounts payable payment register and Council AP reports, fiscal year 2026 (Oct 1, 2025 to Sep 30, 2026)",
   "filed": "2026-11-15",
   "outcome": "Produced Nov 17, 2026, inside the 3 working days, with no fee: the FY2026 Invoice Distribution Report (.xlsx, and the same report as a 292-page PDF) and weekly check-run, payroll-remittance and prepaid proof lists (PDF). No invoices. A 10-working-day extension notice followed at 10:06 PM the same day, after delivery.",
   "findings": [
    "E-31",
    "E-14"
   ],
   "how": ""
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "request": "#5290",
   "subject": "City Manager employment agreements and written amendments since Oct 2014; City Attorney agreement",
   "filed": "2026-11-18",
   "outcome": "Nov 18: City Attorney reviewed, access granted, but records offered only by in-person pickup at City Hall \"due to the substantial volume of records requested\"; no date. Nov 19, 8:11 AM, after the requester asked for email delivery: \"Per our City attorney\" a signed residency declaration under penalty of perjury, with printed name and home address, is required \"before we can move forward.\" No statute cited; the delivery question not answered.",
   "findings": [],
   "how": ""
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "request": "#5293",
   "subject": "Council committee for City Manager / City Attorney evaluations: membership, rules on committees, notices and minutes, compensation recommendations, minutes of 14 executive sessions (2014-present)",
   "filed": "2026-11-17",
   "outcome": "Denied Nov 20 (within 3 working days), one page: \"not in possession of a report or record of that nature\" and \"denied under Idaho Code 74-102(4\" (cut off). No item-by-item answer; no statute tied to any item; nothing was asked of the requester first. The City's delivery folder held only the denial and its own copy of the request.",
   "findings": [
    "E-06",
    "E-22",
    "E-05"
   ],
   "how": ""
  },
  {
   "j": "twin-falls-id",
   "request": "#5299",
   "subject": "Accounts payable register, fiscal years 2020-2025 (follow-up to #5254)",
   "filed": "2026-11-17",
   "outcome": "Nov 18: aggregated with #5254 under I.C. 74-102(11), 12 hours / $567.48 advance payment (Budget Coordinator $47.29/hr), though the City says it is 'not suggesting' fee avoidance. Requester narrowed to the Excel report only. Nov 19: 1.5 hours / $70.94 ('report generation and legal review'), billed at the Budget Coordinator rate. Nov 20, 3:24 AM: requester asked the City to reconsider (aggregation needs a reasonable belief of fee avoidance; Resolution 1912 Section 5) or confirm in writing. Nov 20, 9:19 PM: 10-day extension notice (ends Dec 3).",
   "findings": [
    "E-31",
    "E-14"
   ],
   "how": ""
  }
 ]
}